Anne Dutton's 
    Letters on Spiritual Subjects
 
    
    My Dear Brother in the Lord,
    The account you gave me of the Lord's work upon your soul refreshes my 
    spirit, and that He was pleased to make my printed account of His gracious 
    dealings with me a comfort unto you, as you found so great a part of it to 
    answer to your own experience, for which I rejoice, and bless the Lord. And 
    in answer to your request, "to give you my thoughts if the work of God upon 
    your soul be really a work of grace or not?" 
    I can with gladness assure you that I am fully satisfied that it is, and it 
    appears clear to me from the following particulars, in that—
    1. The Lord has hedged up your way with thorns, and 
    weaned you from all sinful delights. 
    2. In that you have been convinced of your lost and 
    perishing condition as a sinner, both by nature and practice. 
    3. Of the spirituality of the law as in force against 
    you, and that flaming justice barred up mercy from you that way. 
    4. In that you have been brought off from dependence upon 
    the perishing sands of your own duties. 
    5. In that God has revealed His Son in you, as your only 
    and all-sufficient help—in the glory of His perfect righteousness and 
    all-atoning blood, and in the glory of His infinite fullness—to save you to 
    the uttermost, and to satisfy all your desires through time and to eternity.
    
    6. In that hence, seeing Jesus to be such a suitable 
    Savior to your case as a lost sinner, you have embraced Him as your Savior, 
    and fled unto Him for refuge as the only, the glorious hope set before you 
    in the gospel. Wherever these things are experienced, my brother, the work 
    of God on that soul is saving—a special work of supernatural grace—by which 
    the man is brought out of darkness into God's marvelous light, or made a new 
    creature in Christ Jesus. As a believer in the Son of God, that soul is 
    passed from death unto life, and shall not come into condemnation.
    As to what you further mention, of your being drawn of 
    late closer unto blessed Jesus than ever; that He is now become your 
    spiritual rock, whence all your consolation flows; that as you said (which 
    was sweet to me), "Take away Christ, and you take away all the comfort of my 
    soul"; that if you had all the treasures that this world can afford, you 
    would count all but loss and rubbish for the excellency of the knowledge of 
    Christ Jesus, your Lord; that you desire so to be with Christ, which is far 
    better, that if you had heaven for your portion, and all the joy and 
    happiness it could afford, yet, if you had not the presence of precious 
    Jesus there the desires of your soul would never be satisfied; that your 
    desire not to be saved, not just barely for happiness' sake, but that God 
    and the Lamb might be thereby glorified; and that now, all the delight you 
    have on earth is in the delightful service of blessed Jesus, so that it 
    would be a hell to you to go back to your natural state, and your desire is 
    to praise free grace, victorious grace, in life and death, and to reign in 
    its triumphant praises to all eternity. These things, my brother, are 
    further evidences that the work of God upon your soul is saving. But I take 
    these to belong rather to some good degree of growth in grace than to the 
    truth, or first being of it in your heart.
    I would next attempt a short answer to those objections 
    which arise in your mind and make you fear that the Lord's work on your soul 
    is not saving, or whether it be any more than the fruit of a religious 
    education.
    But before I consider your objections in particular, let 
    me say, a religious education is a great privilege, as a means to 
    restrain from vice and immorality, and to train up youth in a doctrinal 
    knowledge of the truths of the gospel; and is often blessed for conviction, 
    and may be for conversion. But the most religious education that ever any 
    person was favored with, as in and of itself, never did nor can give such a 
    spiritual conviction of sin, of heart-sin, as to make the soul cry out in 
    the views of the uncleanness of its nature, in the light of the law's 
    spirituality, and of its own inability to help or save itself, Woe is me, 
    for I am undone! Nor yet did the most religious education, as in and of 
    itself, ever make Christ precious as the only and all-sufficient Savior unto 
    any one soul. 
    No! these are, as I may say, the two main hinges upon 
    which the soul turns from a state of nature to a state of grace. They are 
    the two great characters whereby a new creature, a man that is in Christ, 
    may be known, and the undeniable evidences of a real spiritual gracious 
    change upon the heart, or of the soul's being brought out of nature's 
    darkness into God's marvelous light. Such a man is new-made, has true, 
    precious faith, the faith of God's elect, wrought in his heart, unto which 
    the everlasting salvation of the soul is annexed. And the power that 
    produced it was not the natural force of a religious education, but the 
    supernatural power and almighty energy of the Holy Spirit in regeneration.
    
    The most religious education is a tree of too low a 
    nature to bear such high and precious fruits as a sight of a sin-ruined, 
    law-pursuing, and perishing state, and a flight unto Christ for refuge, as 
    beheld Mighty to save and altogether lovely. It is impossible it should be 
    found on any soul before it is engrafted into Christ and partakes of the 
    spirit of grace from Him, or of His fullness as the root of grace and 
    fatness, as the glorious olive-tree to His Church.
    But I must come to your objections. And you fear the work 
    of God upon your soul is not saving, and say:
    Objection 1. Because I have not felt those terrors of 
    conscience for sin that others have.
    
    Answer. The same degree of terror is not necessary to 
    be felt by every soul that is truly convinced of sin; nor is it usual for 
    those who have had a pious education, and been restrained from outward 
    immoralities, to feel the same degree of terror as those who have run great 
    lengths in wicked courses. If a moralized person, who has been religiously 
    educated, has had so much terror for sin, for his heart and life-sin, that 
    he dare not trust in himself or in his own doings for life, but being warned 
    of God by His holy law of the wrath which is to come, and by His gospel of 
    fleeing unto Christ as the only hiding place from it, and being moved with 
    fear (of being found out of Christ) runs unto Him for safety—it is 
    sufficient to prove a saving conviction of sin. And as great a display of 
    the power of the Holy Spirit in His work of convincing of sin is this, where 
    the soul has less terror, as where the same work in other souls, that have 
    been openly immoral, is attended with great terrors. I humbly think that the 
    display of power in the former is the greatest. But, however, the glories of 
    Omnipotence in various rays shine in both. The soul that has passed under 
    the greatest terrors, which have been over-ruled to bring him to Christ, has 
    cause to bless God forever for His kind dealings with him, in that, though 
    He led him by a rough way, He brought him to such a glorious place of rest 
    and safety. And the soul that has had less terror, that is not left to rest 
    short of Christ, is equally safe with the other, and has reason in a 
    particular manner to bless God that He gave him such an easy passage from 
    his soul-pursuers into Christ, the city of refuge, and brought him through 
    the straits of the new-birth without those pangs and throes which some souls 
    feel. Which way however the Lord deals with us in conviction of sin, He 
    leads us by a right way, that is and shall be most for His glory and our joy 
    if we are brought thereby unto Christ, that city of habitation. But again, 
    you fear the reality of the work, and say,
    Objection 2. Because I have not experienced those 
    overflowing joys in believing which other saints have.
    
    Answer. The Holy Spirit, as the Comforter of 
    believers, is a Sovereign, and divides unto every new-born soul individually 
    as He will. The least comfort, the least beam of infinite favor, upon 
    fleeing unto Christ for refuge, is an unspeakable blessing, a ray of light 
    that is the dawn of eternal day. What though as to some souls who have been 
    covered with the thick darkness of amazing terror, the light of God's 
    salvation unto ravishing joy has arisen upon their spirits, and presently 
    made day, yes, high noon, as it were, at once with them; perhaps they may be 
    called hereafter to walk by faith in darkness, and as seeing no light, to 
    trust in the name of the Lord, and to stay themselves upon their God. 
    And you, whose night has not been so dark, and upon whom 
    the light has gradually arisen, may shortly have the clear shine of the Sun 
    of righteousness, and walk in the light of God's countenance all the day 
    long. Those earnest desires which are wrought in your soul, after the clear 
    witness of the Spirit and the full sealing of the Holy Spirit, foretell a 
    morning of joy unspeakable and full of glory at hand. Wait awhile, and you 
    shall have joy enough to fill every corner of your soul to the brimful. The 
    joy of faith, the joy of spiritual sense, the joy of the Holy Spirit in His 
    witness to your interest in the three-one God, your exceeding joy, shall 
    enter into you here; and hereafter you shall enter into joy, into your 
    Master's joy, and be immersed in pleasures for evermore, while as a vessel 
    of mercy you are cast into Him, the ocean of joy and glory, to take your 
    fill of God in Christ unto bliss unknown, to the days of eternity. But 
    further, you fear the work of God upon your soul is not saving, and say,
    Objection 3. Because I have not those inward troubles 
    and temptations from Satan which other Christians have.
    
    Answer. You may have much of these hereafter; and let 
    your present freedom be esteemed by you as your great privilege, and be the 
    matter of your thanksgiving. It was well you said that you "have not been 
    wholly free from inward temptations," for among the rest, I must tell you 
    that this is an inward temptation, in that you are put upon questioning the 
    work of grace on your soul because you have no more inward troubles. Oh, my 
    brother, do not covet temptations, but go on to pray that you may not be led 
    into temptation, but delivered from evil. Once more, you fear, and say,
    Objection 4. Because the work of God has been so 
    gradual upon my soul.
    
    Answer. The gradation of the work is no argument 
    against the truth of it, but is rather an evidence of the same. The kingdom 
    of God, or the work of grace in the souls of His people, is progressive. The 
    word of the gospel, as a living seed, being cast into the heart, and 
    received by faith of the operation of God in its blessed effects upon the 
    soul, springs up, first in a small, tender blade, then advances to the ear, 
    and last of all, to the full ripe corn in the ear, as grace ripens for and 
    hastens apace unto glory. This is true concerning the good work of God, 
    begun in the souls of all the saints. But yet it must be confessed that in 
    some the first work, as well as its after-progress, is much more speedy than 
    in others. The Lord acts herein, as I hinted under another head, as a 
    Sovereign; and in His various dealings with all His children abounds towards 
    them according to the exceeding riches of His grace and the infinity of His 
    wisdom. And as far greater display of the glory of divine grace is it to 
    that there is such a vast variety in the particular experiences of 
    particular souls, while the same blessed work in the general is carried on 
    in all, than if every one in particular did particularly experience the same 
    thing at the same time and in the same degree. 
    Our God is a great Being! Great in His love, grace, and 
    mercy, great in His wisdom and power, and in all His immense perfections; 
    and He delights to act like Himself, to cast abroad His infinite glory in a 
    thousand various rays, in a thousand various ways of working, upon the 
    vessels of mercy, in His time—preparing them for glory, for that glory He 
    ordained them to and prepared for them before time began, which shall be to 
    His exalted praise in a thousand various notes among the saved of the Lord, 
    while they all join the song, "Salvation unto God and to the Lamb!" unto 
    ages without end.
    As to these objections, my brother, which arise in your 
    mind, and many more of a like nature which at times perplex the hearts of 
    God's people, there is no just ground for them, inasmuch as the things 
    objected as lacking in some particular souls, which are to be found in 
    others truly gracious, belong not to the essentials of a state of grace, but 
    to the 'circumstantials' which with much difference in different persons 
    attend gracious souls. If we would judge of our state of grace by comparing 
    our experience with that of others whom we look upon to be truly gracious, 
    let us do it in those generals wherein all agree, and not in particulars, in 
    which there is so much difference. See the two I mentioned before I came 
    particularly to answer your objections.
    It appears to me, my brother, that you were a regenerate 
    soul when what the world calls innocent diversions became so 
    disagreeable to you, that what was your former chief delight became your 
    greatest burden. The cause, as I conceive, was this, the new nature was 
    wrought in your soul, a holy, spiritual appetite, that could find no delight 
    in natural sinful pleasures, but still sought pleasures of a higher kind, of 
    a heavenly extraction, agreeable to itself and its heavenly descent and 
    taste, with which alone it could be satisfied. This is evidenced to me by 
    that pleasure which you then found in heart-mourning for sin; by that fear 
    which you then had lest convictions should wear off without any saving 
    effect; by your desire after deeper convictions of sin; and by your earnest 
    prayer for grace to live a holy life here, even if you might never enjoy 
    happiness hereafter. These things, together with what you have experienced 
    since, make the work of God upon your soul appear to me very clear and full, 
    that it is, indeed, a real supernatural work of divine grace, which is 
    wrought in none but those who are prepared for glory, or "made meet to be 
    partakers of the inheritance of the saints in light."
    But oh, rest not in present experiences. You are to see 
    greater things than these. Follow hard after the sealing of the Spirit. He 
    can open such clear, satisfying, soul-ravishing views of your interest in 
    Christ to you in a moment as will far transcend all that the creatures by 
    discourse or argument can give you in an age. Oh, when the Holy Spirit comes 
    in; the great power of God to seal upon your heart your eternal interest in 
    Jesus, unbelieving fears and carnal reasonings shall fly before Him as the 
    shades of night or glooms of day before the rising morn, the out-breaking 
    sun, in his clear meridian-shine. And immediately, in full assurance of 
    faith and raptures of joyful spiritual sense, you will cry out with Thomas, 
    "My Lord, and my God."
    Oh, my brother, is this the joy you long for? This is the 
    joy that is reserved for you. This is the joy with which you shall be 
    satisfied. Your Beloved is yours, and you are His, and you shall know it. 
    Enfolded in His arms, and leaning on His bosom, your love-sick soul with 
    love shall be solaced, feasted, filled. Your Beloved shall bring you 
    into His banqueting house, and His banner over you shall be love. He will 
    bid you eat, as His friend, that heavenly bread, that bread of life. His 
    body broken for you, for you in particular; and call you to drink, give you 
    to drink as His beloved of the wine of His love that flowed in His blood, 
    shed for you, for you as distinctly as if it was poured out for never 
    another in the world. "Drink," He will say, "O! beloved, O infinitely 
    beloved soul! Come, open your thirsty mouth, open it wide, I will fill 
    it—take your fill, you can never drink my love dry. Drink, yes, drink 
    abundantly, be inebriated with my love, with all my immense glories as yours 
    in love! View Me, handle Me, possess Me as your own, for I Myself, in whom 
    all the fullness of the Godhead dwells, and yours in love—to satisfy and 
    solace you with bliss ineffable, with pleasures new to surround you, to 
    ravish you through time and to eternity's abounded space." 
    Thus familiar, my dear brother, will your lovely, loving 
    a Lord be with you; thus gracious will He be to you in whom His soul 
    delights. Your Maker is your husband, and as a bridegroom rejoices over his 
    bride, so will your God rejoice over you in renewed displays of His old, 
    everlasting love, that knows neither bound, change, nor end! Oh happy, 
    thrice happy are you! Jesus is yours forever! Drawn then by His love-cords, 
    do you likewise be His, and give up yourself to His service in love, to 
    glorify Him both now and for evermore.
    The times look dark, the heavens are black with clouds, 
    the Church, like a ship in a tremendous sea, may be tossed with the waves; 
    but, since our Lord is with us in the ship, we shall not sink, we shall have 
    blessed company in trouble, safely out-ride the storm, and be brought at 
    last to our desired haven. Jesus being at the helm, the Church need not 
    fear; well He will steer her through danger, and bring her soon into her 
    promised rest and glory.
    Grace be with you. In the arms of Christ I leave you.