(To Mr. Macdonald. June 1855. Written by request, after a 
    long conversation.)
    Dear brother in the Lord, 
    You have set me a task in again requesting me to write the substance of our 
    conversation. You are surrounded with many deep streams in books and in 
    experienced servants of the Lord, and you have at hand "the well-spring of 
    wisdom, which is a flowing brook;" also you have within the well of living 
    water (John 4:14) springing up, and the anointing to teach; (1 John 2:27) 
    but as you have again expressed the desire, I must try, in humble dependence 
    upon the blessed Spirit, of whom our Lord said, "He shall teach you all 
    things, and shall bring all things to your remembrance, whatever I have said 
    unto you." 
    I think we first spoke of preaching to dead sinners—that 
    they should be told of their guilty, lost condition, and entire corruption, 
    their sin set before them; (Acts 2:23; and 3:13-15) also the only way of 
    escape, and that continuing in sin, they must perish. (Psalm 9:17) Their 
    responsibility must be appealed to, (Acts 17:28-31; 2 Cor. 5:10, 11) and 
    that not on the ground of their capability—but of God's rightful 
    sovereignty, He not having lost His right to command, though they have lost 
    all power to obey. Their complete helplessness must be stated, not leading 
    them to think there is any power in the creature, and yet showing how they 
    are responsible to the Divine law, and that because of transgression the 
    wrath of God comes upon the transgressor. We did not speak of the law—but 
    surely its holy requirements should be set forth in their spirituality, in 
    reaching to the thoughts and intents of the heart, in order to show out 
    transgression; (Rom. 3:20) not because any can meet its demands, yet all are 
    under it until released by the glad tidings of the gospel, coming by the 
    Spirit's power. The law is for "the disobedient," (1 Tim. 1:9) and what it 
    says is to them who are under it, to stop every mouth, and prove all guilty 
    before God. (Rom. 3:19) 
    Also it is needful to set forth what must be fulfilled 
    before any can be justified. Then comes in the great Law Fulfiller, who 
    could lay His hand on both parties, giving to the Lawgiver rich 
    satisfaction, and to the lawbreaker honorable salvation. Here is "a door of 
    hope," and "as Moses lifted up the serpent in the wilderness, even so must 
    the Son of man be lifted up," and when the Spirit opens the eyes, the 
    sin-bitten look and live! Thus while the law shows out man's utter 
    deformity, (Rom. 7:8, 13) it shows the Savior's beauty, for He was fully 
    conformed to its pattern. (Matt. 5:17; John 17:4) By faith in Him the soul 
    experiences full benefit of all He did and suffered, which is the only way 
    of salvation, (Acts 13:38, 39; John 3:36) and this faith is the gift of God. 
    (Eph. 2:8) 
    As to direct addresses to dead sinners, it has been said, 
    "You might as well stand in a churchyard and call to a corpse to come out of 
    the grave," which is most true as regards the state of a sinner, and the 
    power of a merely human call. But God told Ezekiel to prophesy to dead and 
    dry bones, (Ezek. 37:2-4) which was like preaching to dead sinners. The 
    Lord's ministers speak to all dead in sin, warning and teaching every man, 
    being at the same time quite sure that the word will only be used to gather 
    out those who are chosen, (Acts 13:48, and 15:14) and equally sure that this 
    can only be done by the power of the Spirit. They, feeling much for 
    perishing sinners, "preach the word," and warn with great earnestness, yet 
    place no dependence upon their feeling or their earnestness or their use of 
    the letter of Scripture—but entirely on the Spirit, without whose power 
    there will be no signs following, neither the quickening of the dead, nor 
    the comforting, reproving, and edifying of the living. Therefore, while 
    warning and teaching in season and out of season, as Col. 1:28, 2 Tim. 4:2, 
    they continually recognize that God must give the increase. (1 Cor. 3:6, 7; 
    2 Cor. 4:4-7) 
    We spoke of exhorting dead sinners to pray. Prov. 
    28:9, and Prov. 15:8, seem to be against this, the sacrifice of the wicked 
    being there said to be "an abomination to the Lord;" but it is evident that 
    Peter did so exhort Simon Magus, (Acts 8:22, 23) for he told him to repent 
    and pray for forgiveness, even while plainly perceiving that he was "in the 
    gall of bitterness, and in the bond of iniquity." Also, he exhorts the 
    Jerusalem sinners to repent, (Acts 3:19) yet not with any view to creature 
    power either in them or himself, for, in Acts 5:31, he clearly states that 
    repentance is the gift of Christ; but while he so exhorted them, the Lord 
    blessed the Word, for we read that many which heard it believed. (Acts 4:4)
    Ministers should so use the Word as the sower does the seed, knowing that 
    the Spirit alone can prepare the heart and give it entrance as well as cause 
    it to spring up. 
    
    We spoke of the invitations of the gospel as being 
    given to character. Are not the hungry invited to the bread? the thirsty to 
    the waters? and the weary and heavy laden to Christ for rest? And while the 
    character is described, many poor and needy ones will find their token. But, 
    then, we saw they are not to rest in being the character—but seek relief and 
    rest alone in the Savior, as He says, "Look unto me and be saved;" and it is 
    written, "They looked unto Him and were lightened, and their faces were not 
    ashamed." The Spirit does not direct to His own work in them—but to the work 
    of Jesus, "He shall glorify me, for he shall receive of mine and shall show 
    it unto you." The Spirit says, "come," and the bride echoes His word "come;" 
    and why? "Come," because the fountain is so full and free—the blood so 
    life-giving and strengthening—the rest so refreshing! "Come," because the 
    blood is so efficacious to cleanse, the righteousness to justify. Come to 
    Jesus as sinners, His benefits are for sinners. This encourages 
    seekers who do not know their "election" of God, which is a glorious 
    truth—but not the first step on the ladder—they have to do with "calling," 
    and that is to sinners. (1 Tim. 1:15) The Spirit makes them feel that 
    they are sinners, and the Spirit directs them to the Savior as crucified for 
    sinners, and He often does both by the preaching of the word. And as the 
    soul is enabled to come to Jesus, and to look away from self to Jesus, the 
    Father is honored who gave Jesus, (2 Cor. 9:15) and draws sinners to Jesus, 
    (John 6:44) and accepts them in Him. (Eph. 1:6) The Spirit is honored who 
    testified of Jesus, (1 Pet. 1:11) and Jesus is honored in what He has done 
    and suffered. (1 Pet. 2:24) Thus the Triune Jehovah is glorified, and the 
    soul strengthened to "walk up and down in the name of the Lord." (Zech. 
    10:12) 
    We spoke a little of preaching personal experience. 
    Experience must not be put in the place of Christ, (2 Cor. 4:5) nor 
    encouragement from experience used instead of encouragement in the Lord our 
    God; (1 Sam. 30:6) yet to tell somewhat, at times, of personal deliverances 
    may more reach the case of tried and tempted souls, than only stating the 
    Lord's power and willingness to deliver. To describe the malady and tell the 
    skill of the physician may be the principal thing; yet for the minister to 
    mention occasionally some feature in his own case, and how the efficacy was 
    personally proved, may tell home on the heart of those who are in 
    soul-distress. 
    Paul did not scruple to tell what he had experienced when 
    cited before the rulers of his people, (Acts 22, 26) though this may not be 
    considered as an example of preaching. But may not 2 Cor. 1:4-6 bear 
    favorably upon some use of personal experience? You know we fully saw that 
    some of the Lord's ministers are more used for comforting and edifying His 
    people, and others for the calling of His dead—the Spirit working in each 
    individually as He will.
    On personal experience we remarked, that while it is good 
    to live in a constant sense of dependence, feeling that without divine power 
    we cannot think, speak, or do anything to the divine glory--yet that it is 
    making a wrong use of this, if therefrom we draw excuse for an inactive or 
    unexercised state of soul, which rather betokens unhealthiness than true 
    dependence. 
    The Lord having given us natural life, we look for Him to 
    give power for the exercise of that life (when we are in health) in eating, 
    drinking, walking, and working. And so being made spiritually alive in 
    Christ Jesus, it is our privilege to look for divine power to exercise the 
    spiritual faculties and the graces of the Spirit; not only to recognize that 
    we have life—but that we may be feeding on Christ, rooting in Him and 
    growing up into Him; so that while deeply feeling the truth of His words, 
    "Without me you can do nothing," we may also come to the experience of His 
    servant, who said, "I can do all things through Christ who strengthens me." 
    Not only acknowledging that "in Him all fullness dwells," but seeking, by 
    the Spirit's power, to have the exercise of faith thereupon, and be 
    receiving of that fullness grace for grace. By exercise, faith is 
    strengthened. 
    These were the points of our converse, and both our ideas 
    are embodied, though many fresh scriptures have flowed in writing. 
    You must be sure to send me word wherever you differ, as 
    it may tend to edification. Further search into truth is not labor in vain, 
    and most sweet is the promise, John 16:13. The Lord ever bless you and set 
    you apart for Himself by the Spirit's anointing. "Meditate upon these 
    things, give yourself wholly to them."
    Ever yours in Jesus,
    R. B.