Improvement of the Mind
Isaac Watts
N.B. The following text was freely provided by Updated Works. Their updated books and audios are superb in every way.
"Some of the most important ideas in history are locked away in old books that modern readers struggle to understand. Archaic language, unfamiliar phrasing, and outdated conventions create unnecessary barriers to timeless wisdom.
"Updated Works exists to change that. We take significant older texts and translate them into clear, contemporary English while faithfully preserving the author's original meaning and voice. Our goal is simple: make important books readable again.
"Archaic spelling, obsolete words, and tangled sentence structure are rendered into clear, contemporary English--always preserving the author's meaning, voice, and line of argument. We modernize the language, never the message."Please visit their website to purchase select hardcopy books and audio books: Updated Works.
CONTENTS
Publisher’s Introduction
Foreword by Dr. Doddridge and Rev. Jennings
I. The Duty of Self-Improvement
1. Essential Rules for Mental Growth
2. The Five Methods of Learning Compared
3. How to Learn Through Observation
4. Strategies for Effective Reading
5. How to Evaluate Books Critically
6. Learning from Teachers and Lectures
7. Mastering New Languages
8. Interpreting Texts and Speech Accurately
9. Learning Through Conversation
10. Handling Disagreements and Debates
11. The Socratic Method
12. Formal and Legal Debates
13. Academic Debate
14. The Art of Deep Study and Meditation
15. Mastering Focus and Attention
16. Expanding Your Mental Capacity
17. Techniques for Improving Memory
18. How to Analyze and Settle Questions
19. Investigating Causes and Effects
20. The Sciences and Professional Development
II. How to Communicate Knowledge
21. Effective Teaching Methods
22. Developing a Clear Teaching Style
23. Persuasion and Correcting Errors
24. The Proper Use and Abuse of Authority
25. Managing and Overcoming Prejudice
26. Effective Public Speaking and Preaching
27. Writing for Publication
28. Handling Controversial Topics
Foreword by Dr. Doddridge and Rev. Jennings
This book, if it deserves to be called that, consists of various observations and guidelines for improving the mind in useful knowledge. I gathered it from reflections on my own studies and from watching the attitudes, opinions, temperaments, and behavior of others as they pursued learning or dealt with everyday life. It has also benefited considerably from notes I collected while reading many authors on different topics. I admit that I'm responsible for most of the weaknesses and shortcomings you'll find in these pages, since I can't point to other writers as the source for more than a small fraction of the content.
I wrote this work at different times and in stages. Occasionally it grew rapidly, like a plant in April, expanding by seven or eight pages in a week. At other times it lay dormant like a plant in winter, barely growing half that much over an entire year.
As these ideas came to me through reading, reflection, or observing how things work among people, I organized them under headings that now form the chapter titles. Gradually I arranged them into something resembling a coherent structure, as far as the subject allowed.
Given these considerations, you shouldn't expect this book to follow the precise organizational structure you'd find in a systematic treatise planned out from the beginning. When a book takes twenty years to write, you have to allow for some variation in style and approach, though I trust you won't find any major contradictions in the ideas themselves. Where I learned better in later years than what I'd first written, I've made corrections with a few edits and revisions. If you're willing to let what's incomplete in one section be filled in by material from another, I believe you'll find that apparent inconsistencies resolve themselves satisfactorily.
The language and tone of these thoughts reflect whatever frame of mind I was in at the time, whether serious or lighthearted, stern or good-natured. If anything comes across as too harsh, I suspect it will be directed at those mocking or audacious writers of our age who attack religion and Christianity, and who seem to have abandoned reason, decency, or both in some of their work.
The same excuse about the many years it took me to write this book also explains why you may find the same ideas repeated in different places without my intending it. In other cases, though, the repetition was deliberate: I wanted the most essential rules for training the mind to appear in several different contexts so they would impress themselves on the reader more frequently and more powerfully. I'll be satisfied if my readers will approach these pages with patience and generosity, viewing them as collections of incomplete sketches. I drew them quickly, in a thousand spare moments, intending someday to gather them into fuller landscapes offering glimpses of the world of learning and everyday life. I meant to point out the most promising and fertile areas, as well as the rocks, wastelands, and barren swamps of the territory. But I feel age creeping up on me, and my health won't allow me to complete what I had planned: to expand and develop these observations, to refine and strengthen these rules, and to enrich the various sections with a wider and more compelling range of examples. The subject is nearly inexhaustible, and new writers in this age and those to come will continue to find plenty of foolishness, weakness, and danger among humanity to describe in ways that protect young people from falling into the same traps.
These suggestions, modest as they are, might prove useful to younger readers who take the time to read them and who want to develop their minds early in life. Perhaps they'll find something here that awakens a hidden talent and guides a willing student's efforts. Perhaps they'll help a student identify the most worthwhile areas to focus on and speed up his progress in the most important questions. Perhaps a bright young person will find something here to protect or warn him against errors, and keep him away from pursuits that are likely to prove fruitless and disappointing.
I should also note that in our time, many women pursue learning successfully, and others want to improve their reasoning in everyday life just as men do. Yet the examples I occasionally describe here are almost always written with masculine pronouns. But if any woman finds a description that fits her, she can easily adjust the wording to apply it to herself and accept whatever instruction, warning, or praise it offers.
RECOMMENDATIONS
The author's name on the cover makes any recommendation from us unnecessary. Anyone familiar with Dr. Watts's other writings will immediately recognize this as his genuine work: his clear style and elegant expression appear on every page. We consider it an honor that this truly great man chose to entrust us with the manuscripts he intended to publish, naming us in his final will. However, he lived long enough to publish several of these himself after making his will, so not many remain for us to handle. Some manuscripts do remain that he originally meant to publish, but his declining health prevented him from finishing them. These are too incomplete to ever see print. Among these is the longer work on psalmody that he announced in the preface to the second edition of his Hymns, when he removed the shorter essay on that subject from the first edition. His papers also include some writings on a theological controversy he had been involved in, but the public seems to have lost interest in that debate. Most likely, then, this Second Part of The Improvement of the Mind, along with the Discourse on Education and some additions to the Reliquiae Juveniles, will be the only posthumous works of Dr. Watts ever printed.
Regarding this particular work, the Doctor himself corrected a substantial portion of it for publication. As for the rest, he didn't consider it so unfinished that it should discourage publication. He left this note with the manuscript: "Although this book (the second volume of The Improvement of the Mind) isn't as polished as I would like, I'm including it among the books ready for publication. Any person with intelligence and knowledge can easily finish it and publish it in a form that will be useful to the world." The corrections we've made are relatively few and minor. When we occasionally needed to add a line or two to clarify a passage, we've generally placed it as a footnote at the bottom of the page.
You might expect us to apologize for the long delay in publishing this book after the author's death, especially since it has been so eagerly anticipated. This is evident from several letters we found in the Doctor's study, written by distinguished individuals and learned societies. Various factors contributed to the delay, which the public doesn't need to know about. However, the considerable distance between our homes and the heavy workload each of us regularly handles are circumstances that are fairly well known, and we hope these will excuse part of the delay. The booksellers must answer for the rest. Still, we're not overly concerned about apologizing for the delayed publication, since we're confident the book will be welcomed now that it's here. Those who read the first volume and eagerly awaited the second will not be disappointed when they read it.
We can only add our heartfelt wishes and prayers that a book so perfectly designed to improve people's minds (especially those of the younger generation) and to promote universal goodness may receive a blessing from above.
D. Jennings. P. Doddridge, June 26, 1751.
PART ONE
THE DUTY OF SELF-IMPROVEMENT
No one is required to learn and know everything: this can be neither expected nor demanded, because it's completely impossible. Yet everyone has some obligation to develop their own understanding. Otherwise it becomes a barren wasteland or a forest choked with weeds and thorns. Total ignorance or endless errors will take over any mind that's completely neglected and left without cultivation.
Mastery of the sciences is the business and profession of only a small portion of humanity. But many others occupy such elevated positions in the world that they have plenty of leisure time and ample opportunities to develop their reasoning abilities and to enrich their minds with various knowledge. Even people of lower social standing have particular jobs in life where they need to acquire a proper level of skill, and this can't be done well without thinking and reasoning about what they do.
The common duties and benefits of society (which apply to everyone alive, since we are social creatures), and even our natural and necessary relationships to family, neighborhood, or government, require all people to use their reasoning powers on countless occasions. Every hour of life demands some disciplined exercise of our judgment regarding time and circumstances, people and actions. Without prudent and careful decisions about the matters before us, we'll be thrown into constant errors in our conduct. Now whatever must always be practiced must at some point be learned.
Every descendant of Adam has a vital stake in the affairs of the life to come, which makes it absolutely essential for everyone to understand, judge, and reason correctly about religious matters. It's pointless for anyone to claim they don't have time for this. The daily breaks from necessary work, combined with one day of rest each week in the Christian world, provide more than enough time if people would just apply themselves with even half the energy and commitment they give to life's trivial pursuits and entertainments. The return on investment would be infinitely greater.
This makes it clear that every person has both a duty and a personal interest in improving their understanding, informing their judgment, storing up useful knowledge, and developing the skill of sound reasoning, to whatever extent their position, ability, and circumstances provide the means to do so. Our errors in judgment can plunge us into considerable foolishness and guilt in practice. When we act without thought or reason, we dishonor the God who made us rational beings, we often harm our neighbors, relatives, or friends, and we bring sin and misery on ourselves. We remain accountable to God, our judge, for every part of our misguided and mistaken behavior, especially when He has given us sufficient opportunities to guard against those mistakes.
CHAPTER 1
ESSENTIAL RULES FOR MENTAL GROWTH
I. Develop a deep conviction about how crucial good judgment is and how valuable the ability to reason correctly truly is. Look back at your own mistakes in life. Think seriously about how many foolish choices and painful experiences you could have avoided, how much guilt and suffering you could have prevented, if you had simply learned from an early age to judge people, timing, and situations correctly. This realization will energize you to work on improving your reasoning abilities and to seize every opportunity that can help you do so.
II. Recognize the weaknesses, limitations, and errors that are part of human nature itself, which come from the very fact that a soul is joined to a physical body and faces many disadvantages because of it. Consider the many additional weaknesses, mistakes, and limitations that come from our original rebellion and fall from innocence: how much more our ability to understand has been darkened, weakened, and deceived by our senses, our imaginations, and our uncontrolled passions. Consider how deep and difficult many truths are, and how attractive false ideas can appear, which creates countless dangers that threaten our ability to judge things correctly. Read eagerly those authors who write about prejudices, preconceptions, and the sources of error, so that your mind stays alert on all fronts and avoids being deceived by any of them as much as possible.
III. A quick glance at such important matters isn't enough. You need to develop and practice specific methods to become aware of your own ignorance and to impress on your mind a deep and uncomfortable sense of how limited and incomplete your current knowledge is. This will motivate you to work actively toward greater understanding. Among other approaches, you may find methods like these helpful.
1. Every so often, take a broad look at the vast, unlimited territories of human knowledge. Let your mind wander through the names of all the different fields of study, with their countless branches and endless specific topics. Then consider how few of them you actually know to any reasonable degree. Even the most learned people will never need to repeat what legend says about Alexander the Great: that after conquering what was known as the eastern world, he wept because there were no more worlds left to conquer. The worlds of knowledge are immense and without end.
2. Consider the countless questions and difficulties that belong even to the particular field where you've made the most progress, and how few of them you've resolved with final, absolute certainty. The only exceptions are questions in pure mathematics, where theorems can be proven and leave almost no room for doubt. Yet even in pursuing some of these, people have become strangely confused.
3. Take some time now and then to wrestle with puzzling questions about vacuums and atoms, or the mathematical concepts of infinites, indivisibles, and incommensurables in geometry, where truly unsolvable problems exist. Do this deliberately to get a visceral sense of how limited your understanding is and how incomplete your knowledge remains. This will show you how foolish it is to imagine you know everything, and it will teach you to think modestly about what you've actually achieved when every speck of dust and every inch of empty space exceeds your comprehension and defeats your arrogance. Arithmo had worked with numbers his entire life and considered himself a complete master of mathematics. But when someone pressed him hard to find the square root of 2, he attempted it and labored endlessly with thousandths of decimal places until he finally admitted the calculation never ends. Yet he gained enough humility from this frustrating problem that he hesitated to declare it impossible. It represents real progress when we become afraid to be dogmatic.
4. Read about the vast stores of knowledge that some people who have died once possessed, and that some living scholars possess today. Read these accounts and be amazed at the almost unbelievable advances that have been made in science. Get to know some highly educated people so that through conversation with them and comparing yourself to them, you can develop a humble view of your own achievements. Let this motivate you with fresh energy to match them as much as possible, or even surpass them. In this way, let your effort be sharpened by a noble and praiseworthy sense of competition. If Vanillus had never encountered Scitorio and Palydes, he would never have realized he was merely a beginner in philosophy, and he would never have started studying in earnest.
Remember this: if you start to value yourself too highly based on a few superficial accomplishments, if you let yourself swell with pride as though you were already learned, you're building an insurmountable barrier against all improvement. You'll settle into idleness and rest content in the midst of deep and shameful ignorance. Many would have reached knowledge if they hadn't assumed they'd already arrived (Multi ad scientiam pervenissent si se illuc pervenisse non putassent).
IV. Don't presume too much on a bright mind, a quick wit, and natural talent, for these qualities alone, without hard work and study, will never make you knowledgeable and wise. This has been a dangerous temptation for people with vigorous and lively imaginations: they come to despise learning and study. They've been praised for shining in social gatherings and sparkling in conversations about common topics, and from this they get it into their heads to abandon reading and hard work, growing old in ignorance. But when they lose the vivacity of youth and animal energy, they become dull and foolish to the point of contempt and ridicule. Lucidus and Scintillo are young men of this type. They shine in conversation. They display their native gifts before the ignorant. They take pride in their own lively imaginative powers and think themselves wise and learned. But they'd better avoid the company of the truly skilled and the test of real reasoning. I would advise them to think ahead once a day and consider what a contemptible figure they'll cut in old age.
The witty sometimes have enough sense to recognize their own weakness. Therefore they cleverly avoid argumentative challenges, or they boldly pretend to despise and reject them, because they're conscious of their own ignorance and inwardly admit their lack of skill in reasoning.
V. Just as you shouldn't think yourself learned simply because you're blessed with a ready wit, neither should you imagine that extensive and laborious reading combined with a strong memory can truly make you wise.
What that brilliant critic determined when he decided whether wit or study makes the best poet applies equally well to every kind of learning:
. . . . . Ego nec studium sine divite venâ, Nec rude quid prosit, video, ingenium: alterius sic Altera poscit opem res, et conjurat amicè. Hor. de Art. Poet. Translated into English:
Concerning poets there has been contest, Whether they're made by art, or nature best; But if I may presume in this affair, Among the rest my judgment to declare, No art without a genius will avail, And parts without the help of art will fail: But both ingredients jointly must unite, Or verse will never shine with a transcendent light. Oldham.
Meditation and careful thought, the exercise of your own reason and judgment on everything you read: these are what give good sense even to the finest natural ability, and provide your understanding with its truest improvement. A boy with a strong memory might recite an entire book of Euclid yet still be no mathematician, for he may not be able to prove a single theorem. Memorino has learned half the Bible by heart and become a living concordance, a walking index to theological volumes, yet he understands little of theology.
A well-stocked library and a capacious memory are certainly valuable for improving the mind. But if all your learning amounts to nothing more than a collection of what others have written, without genuine insight into the meaning and without judicious selection and formation of your own views, I don't see what claim your head has to true learning beyond what sits on your shelves. You may have read philosophy and theology, ethics and metaphysics in abundance, along with every other art and science, but if your memory is the only faculty you've exercised while neglecting your reasoning powers, you can justly claim no higher title than that of a good historian of the sciences.
Here's something worth noting: many of the suggestions I've given apply especially to those who think too highly of their abilities and are quick to develop an inflated opinion of themselves. But if you're a modest, humble young person with genuine talent, don't let any of these warnings discourage you. They're meant only to push you toward hard work and to protect you against vanity and pride.
VI. Don't be foolish enough to think that a life of learning is a life of laziness and comfort. Don't commit yourself to any of the learned professions unless you're prepared to work hard at your studies and can make that work your delight and the joy of your life, following the motto of our late Lord Chancellor King:
Labor ipse voluptas (work itself is pleasure).
Being a true scholar is no easy thing. Someone who is devoted to luxury and pleasure, recreation and entertainment, should never claim to dedicate himself entirely to the sciences unless his character has been so reformed and refined that he can find all these pleasures in an even better form in his study, among his books and papers. Sobrino is a temperate man and a philosopher, and he feasts on partridge and pheasant, venison and fine dishes, and every delicacy through his growing understanding and his serene and healthy soul, even though he actually dines on a dish of sprouts or turnips. Languinos loved his comfort, and so he chose to become a scholar. He had a lazy temperament, and because he never cared for real study, he falls under universal contempt in his profession. He has nothing but the gown and the title.
VII. Let the hope of new discoveries, along with the satisfaction and pleasure of known truths, fuel your daily work. Don't assume that learning in general has reached its peak, or that knowledge of any particular subject in any science can't be improved, simply because it has remained unchanged for five hundred or a thousand years. Our present age, by God's blessing on human ingenuity and hard work, has brought to light such truths in natural philosophy, and such discoveries in the heavens and the earth, as once seemed beyond human reach. But why shouldn't there be Isaac Newtons in every science? You should never despair of discovering what has never yet been found, unless you see something in its nature that makes it unsearchable and beyond the reach of our abilities.
A theology student shouldn't assume that our generation has achieved complete understanding of everything the Scriptures can teach us. Every era since the Reformation has shed new light on difficult biblical texts and passages that were obscured for centuries by the early rise of the antichrist. Many difficulties and obscurities still surround certain Christian truths today, and several of these involve crucial doctrines: the origin of sin, Adam's fall, the person of Christ, the Trinity, God's decrees, and others. These issues continue to trouble honest, searching readers and fuel heated controversies. Clearly, the Bible still contains things we don't fully understand or haven't adequately explained. Just as clearly, there must be ways to resolve these difficulties and reconcile these apparent contradictions. Why couldn't a sincere truth seeker in our own time, through hard work, careful study, and prayer, combined with the best use of reason, discover the right solutions to these knots and puzzles that have remained unsolved and have provided fuel for bitter disputes? Blessed is anyone whom Heaven favors to help usher in that coming age of light and love.
VIII. Don't always skim the surface of things or settle for mere appearances. Dig into the depth of matters as far as your time and circumstances allow, especially in areas related to your own profession. Don't let yourself judge things by a quick glance or a shallow examination, because this will fill your mind with errors and prejudices. It will give you a distorted perspective and bad thinking habits, and you'll spend a lot of time later having to correct yourself. Subito gets carried away by title pages: he'll confidently pronounce judgment on a thick octavo volume immediately and recommend it enthusiastically after reading half the preface. He dismissed another equally large volume of controversies at once because it claimed to discuss the Trinity, yet he couldn't find the words "essence" or "subsistencies" in the first twelve pages. But Subito changes his opinions about people, books, and ideas so often that nobody takes him seriously.
As for those sciences or branches of knowledge that your profession, your available time, your interests, or your limitations prevent you from pursuing seriously or investigating deeply, you must be content with a general and surface-level knowledge of them. Don't pretend to form your own judgments on subjects you understand only imperfectly.
IX. Once a day, especially in your early years of learning, take stock of what you've gained: what new ideas or truths you've discovered, what further evidence you've found for things you already knew, and what progress you've made in any area of knowledge. If possible, don't let a single day pass without some intellectual growth. If you stick to this practice, you can't help but advance in useful knowledge. The learned have a wise proverb, borrowed from the words and habits of a famous painter: Nulla dies sine lineâ (let no day pass without at least one line). The Pythagoreans had a sacred rule: every evening, they would review the day's actions and affairs three times, examining their conduct, what they had done, and what they had left undone. They promised their students that this method would lead to remarkable progress in virtue.
???' ????? ?????????? ??' ?????? ???????????? ???? ??? ???????? ????? ???? ??????? ????????. ?? ???????; ?? ?' ?????; ?? ??? ???? ???' ????????; ????? ?? ??? ????? ?????? ??? ????? ?????.
Nor let soft slumber close your eyes, Before you've recollected thrice The train of action through the day: Where have my feet chose out their way? What have I learnt, where-e'er I've been, From all I've heard, from all I've seen? What know I more that's worth the knowing? What have I done that's worth the doing? What have I sought that I should shun? What duty have I left undone? Or into what new follies run? These self-inquiries are the road That leads to virtue, and to God.
I wish I could find young Christians in our nation who would seriously practice what this pagan writer teaches.
X. Stay constantly on guard against a dogmatic spirit. Don't lock yourself into any position with firm, unshakable conviction until you have firm, unshakable grounds for it and have reached clear, solid evidence. Turn the proposition over from every angle and search the matter thoroughly so you can't be mistaken. Even when you think you have complete grounds for certainty, don't be too quick or too frequent in expressing that certainty in overly forceful and absolute terms. Remember that human nature is always prone to error in this corrupt and weak state. A dogmatic spirit brings many problems with it: 1. It closes your ears to any further reasoning on that subject and shuts your mind off from any further growth in knowledge. If you've stubbornly fixed your opinion, even on too slight and insufficient grounds, you will determinedly reject the strongest reasons brought for the contrary opinion and grow obstinate against the force of the clearest argument. Positivo is a man of this character. He has often declared his certainty about the Cartesian vortexes. Last year some further light broke in on his understanding with uncontrollable force when he read something on mathematical philosophy. Yet having asserted his former opinions in the most confident manner, he is now tempted to close his eyes a little to the truth, or to speak evasively on that subject, lest by admitting he was wrong, he should expose himself to the necessity of confessing his former foolishness and mistake. He doesn't have enough humility for that. 2. A dogmatic spirit naturally leads us to arrogance of mind and gives a man certain airs in conversation that are too haughty and presumptuous. Audens is a man of learning and very good company, but his infallible certainty makes his manner sometimes unbearable.
A dogmatic spirit makes a person judgmental toward others. Each of his own opinions seems to him as clear as daylight, and he gets angry when his neighbor doesn't see it the same way. He's tempted to look down on those who disagree with him, viewing them as people with limited and clouded understanding simply because they won't believe what he does. Furio takes this wild path even further: he accuses those who reject his ideas of deliberate stubbornness and shameful hypocrisy. He tells them bluntly that they're resisting the truth and sinning against their own consciences.
These are the people who, when they engage in controversy, take pleasure in insults. They freely throw around accusations of absurdity and stupidity among their fellow believers. They generously heap charges of heresy and nonsense on their opponents. And in matters of sacred importance, they distribute their condemnations liberally upon Christians better than themselves. They pronounce damnation on their neighbors without either justice or mercy. And when they declare sentences of divine wrath against supposed heretics, they add their own human rage and fury to it. A dogmatist in religion isn't far from being a bigot, and he's in serious danger of becoming a violent persecutor.
XI. While being cautious and slow to form judgments will protect you from making frequent mistakes and having to backtrack, you should develop enough humility and courage to take back any error and admit when you're wrong. Constantly changing your mind signals that you were careless in your initial thinking. Still, you should never be too proud to change your opinion or frightened by being called inconsistent. Learn to dismiss those common fears that keep foolish people locked into their old mistakes just because they're afraid of being accused of flip-flopping. I admit it's better not to judge at all than to judge incorrectly. It's wiser to hold back your agreement until you see complete evidence. But if we've agreed too quickly (as even the wisest person sometimes does), if we've stated something we later discover to be false, we should never be ashamed or afraid to renounce that mistake. There's an excellent essay among the occasional papers called "To Encourage the World to Repractise Retractions," and I would recommend it to every scholar and every Christian.
XII. Anyone who wants to develop judgment beyond the ordinary level and learn to form sound opinions about people and things must guard against a whimsical temperament and erratic behavior. Whimsy and moodiness, if indulged early and constantly, will lead to an old age overrun with foolishness.
A whimsical person is someone who becomes extremely pleased or extremely upset over trivial matters, who sets his heart on things of very little importance, whose decisions are swayed daily by trifles, whose actions are rarely guided by reason and the true nature of things, and whose emotions are frequently stirred up by inconsequential matters. When this behavior is allowed to continue, it will gradually distort your judgment until you start calling small things important and convince yourself to give them great weight. In short, this temperament will lead you to assign the wrong value to almost everything you encounter, and every step you take down this path moves you further away from wisdom.
XIII. For the same reason, be careful not to trivialize things that are important and weighty, or to joke about things that are solemn and sacred. Don't give in to a spirit of ridicule, as some witty people do on every occasion and with every subject. This will bias your judgment just as badly in the opposite direction, leading you to undervalue the most precious things. Whatever bad habit we allow in our behavior will gradually gain power over our thinking and lead us into many errors. Jocander is always ready with his jokes to respond to everything he hears. He reads books in the same playful mood and has mastered the art of turning every thought and sentence into a laugh. How many clumsy and distorted judgments does this man make about serious subjects, even when he tries to be solemn and sincere? His mirth and joking attitude has become a fixed habit and temperament, and it leads his thinking shamefully off course. You'll see him chasing after a bright, fluttering feather, and he's drawn by a kind of false light (ignis fatuus) into swamps and mud almost every day of his life.
XIV. Always maintain a virtuous and godly frame of mind, because indulging vicious tendencies debases your thinking and corrupts your judgment. Sexual immorality and wine, and new wine, take away a person's heart and soul and reason. Sensuality ruins the higher faculties of the mind. Indulging appetite and passion weakens the powers of reason. It makes judgment feeble and susceptible to every falsehood, especially to those errors that tend toward gratifying our animal nature. And it twists the soul strangely away from that steadfast honesty and integrity that necessarily belongs to the pursuit of truth. It is the virtuous person who is on the right path to wisdom. "God gives to those that are good in His sight wisdom, and knowledge, and joy" (Eccl 2:26).
Devotion to God, along with self-control and virtue, are necessary qualities for becoming truly wise and discerning. Anyone who abandons religion must act in such contradiction to his own conscience and best judgment that he damages and corrupts his reasoning faculty itself. This happens both by the nature of things and by God's righteous judgment: even the supposed sages among the pagans, who refused to acknowledge God, were given over to a reprobate mind (eis noun adokimon), an undiscerning or injudicious mind, so that they reasoned inconsistently and practiced sheer absurdities (ta me anekonta) (Rom 1:28).
And this is the character of those enslaved to the antichrist (2 Thess 2:10 and following): those who reject the love of truth were exposed to the power of diabolical deceptions and lying wonders. When divine revelation shines and blazes in people's faces with glorious evidence, and they close their eyes against it, the god of this world is allowed to blind them, even to the most obvious, common, and sensible things. The great God of Heaven, for this very reason, sends them strong delusions so they will believe a lie. The nonsense of transubstantiation in the Catholic world is a glaring fulfillment of this prophecy, beyond even what could have been imagined among creatures who claim to reason.
XV. Guard against pride in your own reasoning and a vain conceit of your own intellectual powers, which leads to neglecting divine help and blessing. Don't presume you can achieve great knowledge through your own self-sufficiency: those who trust entirely in their own understanding are called fools in the word of God. The wisest of men gives them this label: "He who trusts in his own heart is a fool" (Prov 28:26). And the same divine writer advises us to "trust in the Lord with all our heart, and not to lean on our understanding, nor to be wise in our own eyes" (Prov 3:5, 7).
Those who neglect religion and dependence on God, relying instead on pure reason to investigate every aspect of divine truth, have been allowed to fall into wild foolishness and bizarre extremes of opinion. Anyone who pursues this empty path, refusing to ask for God's guidance in studying religion, has good reason to fear that God will abandon him and leave him vulnerable to countless prejudices. He should worry that he'll be handed over to the foolishness of his own heart, pursuing his own destruction in both this life and the next. And even in ordinary studies, we should use humility and dependence to bring the God of truth to our side.
XVI. Therefore, offer up your daily requests to God the father of lights, asking Him to bless all your efforts in reading, study, and conversation. Consider how easily and subtly, with one shift of thought, He can lead you into a vast field of useful ideas. He can teach you to grasp a thread that will guide your thoughts safely and easily through all the difficulties of a complex subject. Think how easily the Author of your being can direct your actions through His providence, so that a glance, a word striking your ear, or a sudden turn of imagination can lead you to a series of valuable insights. Through His secret and supreme way of governing, He can draw you to read a particular book or talk with a particular person who may give you more understanding of some difficult subject in an hour than you could gain through a month of working alone.
Consider how easily the God of spirits can plant a useful idea in your mind and give a fortunate direction to your own thoughts or the thoughts of those you talk with. From this you may gain incredible insight and clarity about a problem that has confused and frustrated you for a long time. He can show you a path that no one else has seen and lead you through some unknown door out of a wilderness and maze of difficulties where you've been lost for ages.
Constantly ask for His divine grace to direct your interests toward the right studies and to fix your heart on them. He can keep temptations away from you on every side, both through the events of His providence and through the secret, imperceptible promptings of His Spirit. He can protect your mind from every harmful influence of error and keep you safe from the danger of bad books and people who might otherwise have a devastating effect and lead you into destructive mistakes.
Nor should this kind of advice be dismissed by the godless and profane as mere bigotry or fanaticism drawn from faith and the Bible: the reasons I've given to support this pious practice of asking for God's blessing on our studies come from natural reason as well as revelation. He who made our souls and is the Father of spirits, shouldn't we suppose He has the most friendly influence toward instructing and governing them? The Author of our rational powers can plunge them into darkness whenever He pleases, through a sudden illness; or He can abandon them to wander into dark and foolish opinions when they're filled with vain pride in their own understanding. He expects to be acknowledged in the ordinary affairs of life, and He certainly expects it in the higher operations of the mind, in the search for knowledge and truth. Even the Greek pagans, by the light of reason, were taught to say, "We begin from Zeus" (Ek Dios archometha), and the Latins, "From Jove the beginning, O Muses" (A Jove Principium Musae). In works of learning they thought it necessary to begin with God. Even the poets called upon the muse as a goddess to help them in their compositions.
The opening lines of Homer's Iliad and Odyssey, the first line of Musaeus in his song of Hero and Leander, the beginning of Hesiod's poem Works and Days, and several other works give us plenty of examples of this practice. Even Ovid includes this devotional element when he begins his Metamorphoses. Christianity makes this even more binding on us through Scripture's commands to seek the true God's help in all our mental work, whether for our own growth or for helping others. Bishop Saunderson said that study without prayer is atheism, just as prayer without study is presumption. We have even stronger encouragement from those who have testified from their own experience that sincere prayer never hindered their studies. They sometimes gained more knowledge on their knees than through laboring over a variety of authors. They left this observation for those who came after: Bene orâsse est bene studuisse (praying is the best studying).
To wrap up, combine hard work with devotion, and you won't need to doubt the happy outcome. "Incline your ear to wisdom; apply your heart to understanding: cry after knowledge, and lift up your voice: seek her as silver, and search for her as for hidden treasures; then you will understand the fear of the Lord, which is the beginning of wisdom" (Prov 2:2). It is "the Lord who gives wisdom even to the simple, and out of his mouth comes knowledge and understanding."
CHAPTER 2
THE FIVE METHODS OF LEARNING COMPARED
There are five important ways the mind improves its knowledge of things: observation, reading, instruction by lectures, conversation, and meditation (which in a particularly special way is called study).
Let's look at the general definitions or descriptions of all five.
Observation means noticing everything that happens in human life, whether we perceive it through our senses or our minds, whether it involves people or things, ourselves or others. From infancy onward, observation supplies us with a rich variety of ideas and statements, words and phrases. Through observation we learn that fire burns, that the sun gives light, that a horse eats grass, that an acorn produces an oak, that humans can reason and speak, that our judgment is weak, that we make many mistakes, that we experience great sorrows, that our bodies die and are buried, and that one generation follows another. Everything we see, hear, or feel, everything we perceive through our senses or inner awareness, everything we know directly without much reflection or reasoning, falls under the general category of observation.
When observation relates to something that directly concerns us and that we're conscious of, we can call it experience. For instance, I'm said to know or experience that I have within myself the ability to think, fear, love, and so on, that I have appetites and passions working in me, and that many personal events have happened to me in this life.
Observation therefore includes everything that Mr. Locke means by sensation and reflection.
When we're investigating the nature or properties of something by trying various methods, or when we apply certain forces or set certain causes in motion to see what effects they produce, this kind of observation is called experiment. For example, when I throw a bullet into water, I find it sinks. When I throw the same bullet into quicksilver, I see it floats. But if I beat out this bullet into a thin, hollow shape like a dish, then it will float in water too. Similarly, when I strike two flints together, I find they produce fire. When I throw a seed into the earth, it grows into a plant.
All these belong to the first method of knowledge, which I'll call observation.
II. Reading is the means or method of knowledge by which we learn what other people have written or published to the world in their writings. These arts of reading and writing offer infinite advantages: through them we can share in the thoughts, observations, reasoning, and discoveries of all the learned world, across the most distant nations and throughout former ages, almost from the beginning of humanity.
III. Public or private lectures are verbal instructions given by a teacher while the students listen in silence. This is how we learn religion from the pulpit, or philosophy or theology from the professor's chair, or mathematics when a teacher shows us various theorems or problems (that is, speculations or practices) through demonstration and operation, using all the instruments of art necessary for those operations.
IV. Conversation is another method of improving our minds. Through mutual discussion and inquiry, we learn what others think while also sharing our own thoughts with them in the same way. Sometimes, even though both parties take turns speaking, only one side benefits, as when a teacher and a student meet and talk together. But often the profit is mutual. Under this heading of conversation we can also include disputes of various kinds.
V. Meditation or study includes all the mental exercises that make the previous methods useful for growing in true knowledge and wisdom. Through meditation, we strengthen our memory of things that pass through our minds in daily life, in our own experiences, and in the observations we make. Through meditation, we draw various conclusions and establish general principles of knowledge in our minds. Through meditation, we compare the various ideas we get from our senses or from the operations of our souls, and join them into propositions. Through meditation, we fix in our memory whatever we learn and form our own judgment about the truth or falsehood, the strength or weakness, of what others say or write. It is meditation or study that draws out long chains of argument and searches out and finds deep and difficult truths that previously lay hidden in darkness.
It would be pointless to prove that our own private meditations, together with the few observations that most people are capable of making, are not enough by themselves to lead us to any considerable amount of knowledge, at least in an age as advanced as ours, without the help of conversation and reading and other proper instruction available in our day. Yet each of these five methods has its particular advantages, by which they help each other, and its particular defects, which need to be supplied by the others' assistance. Let us trace over some of the particular advantages of each.
I. One method of improving the mind is observation, and its advantages are these: 1. Observation is what furnishes our minds with the first simple and complex ideas. It lays the groundwork and foundation of all knowledge, making us capable of using any other method for improving the mind. If we didn't acquire a variety of sensible and intellectual ideas through the sensations of outward objects, through the consciousness of our own appetites and passions, pleasures and pains, and through inward experience of our own spirits' actions, it would be impossible for either people or books to teach us anything. Observation must give us our first ideas of things, since it includes both sense and consciousness.
2. All our knowledge derived from observation, whether of single ideas or of propositions, is knowledge gotten firsthand. Through this we see and know things as they are, or as they appear to us. We take the impressions of them on our minds from the original objects themselves, which gives a clearer and stronger conception of things. These ideas are more lively, and the propositions (at least in many cases) are much more evident. In contrast, what knowledge we derive from lectures, reading, and conversation is only the copy of other people's ideas: the picture of a picture, one step further removed from the original.
3. Another advantage of observation is that we can gain knowledge all day long, and every moment of our lives. Every moment of our existence we can be adding something to our intellectual treasures this way, except only while we're asleep, and even then the memory of our dreaming will teach us some truths and lay a foundation for a better understanding of human nature, both in its powers and in its frailties.
II. The next way of improving the mind is by reading, and its advantages are these:
1. Reading lets us engage with the affairs, actions, and thoughts of people across the globe and throughout history, both living and dead, as easily as if they were our neighbors today. Through books, we can learn from humanity everywhere. In contrast, observation teaches us only what we experience directly. Conversation limits us to the few people nearby, our neighbors and contemporaries. And if we rely solely on our own thinking without much observation or reading, our growth becomes even more restricted: we can only advance through our internal reasoning and reflection.
2. Reading doesn't just expose us to the actions and ideas of different nations and eras; it gives us access to the knowledge and insights of the most learned people, the wisest and best minds humanity has produced, regardless of when or where they lived. True, many books have been written by weak and foolish authors, but most books that have earned lasting reputations are the work of great and wise individuals from their respective times and places. Conversation, by contrast, limits us to whoever happens to live within reach of our home or social circle, wise or not. Sometimes that narrow sphere doesn't include anyone particularly distinguished in wisdom or learning, unless we're fortunate enough to have such an instructor. And even when we reach respectable levels of learning through our own study and reflection, the potential for further growth through those means alone remains far more limited than what we can gain from reading.
3. When we read good authors, we encounter the best and most refined thinking of wise and learned people. These writers have studied hard and put their most mature thoughts on paper: the results of long study and experience. In contrast, when we learn through conversation or attend lectures, we often get only the immediate thoughts of our teachers or friends. These ideas may be bright and useful, but they're often spontaneous and undigested: mere hints that haven't yet matured.
4. Reading offers another advantage: we can review what we've read. We can return to the page again and again, meditating on it at different times during our quietest and most private hours, with the book always within reach. But what we gain from conversation and lectures often disappears as soon as the gathering ends, or at least by the end of the day, unless we happen to have a good memory or quickly retreat to write down the remarkable things we heard in those discussions. For the same reason, and because they failed to withdraw and write things down, many learned people have lost several of their own useful insights and could never recall them again.
III. The advantage of verbal instruction through public or private lectures are these.
1. There's something more lively, more delightful and entertaining in the living discourse of a wise, learned, and well-qualified teacher than in the silent and sedentary practice of reading. The very tone of voice, the good pronunciation, and the polished and alluring manner that some teachers have mastered will capture attention, keep the mind focused, and convey the ideas of things in a more lively and forceful way than simply reading books in the silence and privacy of one's study.
2. When a tutor or instructor paraphrases and explains other authors, he can pinpoint exactly where the difficulty or controversy lies and clarify it for you. He can show you which paragraphs matter most and which are less important. He can tell his students which authors, or which parts of an author, are most worth reading on any particular subject, saving his students considerable time and effort by shortening the work they need to do in private study. He can give you a summary of what the ancient writers taught, something that might otherwise require extensive labor and reading through many books to discover. He can tell you about new ideas or theories emerging in the world before they become public knowledge, and he can share his own private thoughts, experiments, and observations that have never been published and perhaps never will be, yet may prove extremely valuable and useful.
3. A living instructor can appeal to our senses when conveying the ideas he wants to teach us, particularly when he's teaching natural philosophy or most branches of mathematics. He can perform experiments right in front of us. He can draw figures and diagrams, point to specific lines and angles, and work through demonstrations in a much clearer way using tangible methods that can't be replicated as well through mere reading, even when we have the same figures in a book before our eyes. A living teacher is therefore an essential aid in these fields of study.
I should also add that even when the subject is moral, logical, or rhetorical (topics that don't directly involve our senses), a tutor can explain his ideas using familiar examples and simple comparisons that rarely appear in books and written works.
4. When an instructor presents difficult material in a lecture, or phrases something in a way that seems unclear, and you don't fully grasp what he's saying, you have the chance (at least when the lecture ends, or at other appropriate times) to ask how a particular statement should be understood, or how a particular difficulty can be clarified and resolved.
If the tutor allows open discussion, either during the lecture or (better yet) at the end, about any questions or difficulties that come up for listeners, this brings the experience very close to actual conversation or dialogue.
IV. Conversation is the next method of improvement, and it offers the following advantages:
1. When we talk informally with a learned friend, we have his immediate help to clarify every word and idea that seems unclear in what he's saying, and to explain his full meaning. This makes us much less likely to misunderstand him. With books, however, whatever is genuinely obscure may remain obscure forever without any solution, since the author isn't available for us to ask what he meant.
If we misunderstand our friend in conversation, we're quickly corrected. But when reading, we often continue in the same misunderstanding without any way to correct ourselves. This is why we see so many debates throughout history about what ancient authors meant, especially the sacred writers. How fortunate we would be if we could actually converse with Moses, Isaiah, and St. Paul, and consult the prophets and apostles when we encounter a difficult passage. But that glorious conversation is reserved for the ages of future blessedness.
2. When we're discussing any topic with a friend, we can raise our doubts and objections to his views and have them answered on the spot. The difficulties that come up in our minds can be cleared away by a single illuminating word from our conversation partner, whereas when reading, if a difficulty or question arises that the author hasn't addressed, we have to live without an immediate answer or solution. Books can't talk back.
3. Not only can the doubts that arise in our minds on any subject be easily raised and resolved in conversation, but even the difficulties we encounter in books and in our private studies can find relief through friendly discussion. We might puzzle over a thorny problem in solitary meditation for months without a solution, perhaps because we've started down the wrong path of thinking. Our effort (while we're chasing a false lead) is not only useless and unsuccessful, but it may lead us into a long chain of error simply because we weren't corrected at the first step. But if we write down this difficulty when we encounter it, we can bring it up to a thoughtful friend when we see him. We might be relieved in a moment and watch the difficulty vanish: he perhaps sees the matter from a different angle, presents it to us in an entirely new light, leads us straight to clarity and truth, and does so with delightful surprise.
4. Conversation brings into the light what has been stored in all the hidden corners and secret chambers of the soul: through casual hints and incidents it brings old useful ideas back to mind. It unfolds and displays the hidden treasures of knowledge that reading, observation, and study had previously stocked in the mind. Through mutual discussion, the soul is awakened and drawn out to share its stores of knowledge, and it learns how to make them most useful to humanity. A person of vast reading without conversation is like a miser who lives only for himself.
5. In free and friendly conversation, our intellectual powers come alive, and our minds work with unusual energy as we search for unknown truths. There's a sharpness and insight that comes with conversation that we simply don't find when we're alone reading and thinking in private. Our minds may be calm in solitude, but they don't sparkle, even when we're reading the works of brilliant writers. It often happens in open discussion that new thoughts suddenly emerge, and the seeds of truth flash and ignite throughout the group in ways they never would during quiet, solitary reading. Conversation gives and receives this benefit: like flints striking against each other in motion, producing living fire on both sides, which would never arise from the same hard materials sitting still.
6. In stimulating conversation among intelligent and learned people, we gain a great advantage by proposing our private opinions and putting our own ideas to the test. We learn in a faster and safer way what the world will think of them, how people will receive them, what objections might be raised against them, what flaws exist in our thinking, and how to correct our own mistakes. These advantages aren't as easy to obtain through private meditation alone. The pleasure we take in our own ideas, along with self-love and our limited perspective, tempts us to judge our own thinking too favorably. But the variety of minds among our different companions will give us valuable insight into how our opinions will stand up in the eyes of humanity.
7. Conversation also offers another major benefit: it teaches the student about people and how life actually works, just as reading gives him knowledge from books. Someone who spends all his time with books may accumulate a huge store of ideas, but they risk becoming nothing more than a scholar (a rather pathetic figure in the real world). A hermit locked away in his college cell develops a kind of mildew and corrosion on his soul, and all his mannerisms carry a certain clumsiness. But these clumsy habits gradually wear away in company: the corrosion and mildew get filed and brushed off through polite conversation. The scholar now becomes a citizen or a gentleman, a neighbor and a friend. He learns not only how to present his ideas in the strongest light, but also how to dress them in the most attractive colors. This way he brings out his ideas with honor, puts them to actual use in the world, and refines theory through practice.
But before we go too far in perfecting this impressive character through conversation, we need to recognize that something else is necessary beyond familiarity with people and books. So I add this: lectures, reading, and conversation alone, without thinking, cannot make someone truly knowledgeable and wise. Our own thought and reflection, study and meditation, must accompany all these other methods of improvement and bring them to completion. This approach carries several advantages:
1. While observation and instruction, reading and conversation can supply us with many ideas about people and things, it's our own meditation and mental work that must shape our judgment. Our own thinking must connect or separate these ideas into propositions: it's our own mind that must judge whether ideas agree or disagree, and form true propositions from them. Reading and conversation can introduce us to many truths and many arguments supporting them, but it's our own study and reasoning that must determine whether these propositions are actually true and whether these arguments are sound and solid.
Admittedly, there are countless things our eyes have never seen, things that will never come within reach of our personal, direct knowledge and observation because of the distance in time and place: we must learn about these by consulting other people, either through their writings or their conversations. But after all this, let's establish one fixed principle: it's our own reflection and judgment that must determine how far we should accept what books or people tell us, and how far they deserve our trust and belief.
2. Meditation and study are what transform other people's ideas and insights into our own. When we judge these ideas for ourselves and commit them to memory, they become our property. This process digests our intellectual food and makes it part of us, much like how we can call our limbs and flesh our own regardless of whether we got the raw materials from beef or mutton, from lark or lobster, from grain or milk, from fruit trees or from herbs and roots in the ground. All of it becomes one substance with us, and we control those muscles and limbs for our own purposes, even though they were once part of other animals or plants. The very substance that was grazing in a field or swimming in the ocean last week, sitting in a milk pail or growing in a garden, has now become part of the person.
3. Through study and meditation, we develop the insights we've gained from observation, conversation, and reading. We spend more time thinking, and through mental effort we dig deeper into subjects and sometimes push our thoughts much further than anything we've encountered in books or heard in discussions. It's our own reasoning that draws one truth from another and builds an entire system or science from a few borrowed hints.
Looking at these observations, we can draw a clear conclusion: someone who spends all their time attending lectures or buried in books, without observing the world, thinking deeply, or talking with others, will only acquire a superficial historical knowledge. They'll be able to recite what others have known or said, but nothing more. Someone who lets all their time slip away in conversation, without proper observation, reading, or study, will gain only shallow and fleeting knowledge that risks evaporating the moment the speaker stops talking. And someone who confines himself entirely to his study and his own limited observations, learning only from his solitary thoughts without instruction from lectures, reading, or genuine conversation, risks developing a narrow mind, an inflated opinion of himself, and an unreasonable contempt for others. In the end, he'll obtain only a restricted and incomplete understanding of things, and he'll rarely learn how to make that knowledge useful.
These five methods of improvement should be pursued together, working in tandem, whenever our circumstances are fortunate enough to provide the opportunity and means to enjoy them all. However, I must say that two of them (reading and meditation) should take up far more of our time than public lectures or conversation and discussion. As for observation, we can always be acquiring knowledge that way, whether we're alone or in company.
But we'll make even more progress if we examine all five of these methods for obtaining knowledge more carefully and thoroughly, and see what specific advances in useful knowledge we can draw from each of them.
CHAPTER 3
HOW TO LEARN THROUGH OBSERVATION
Though observation, in the strict sense of the word (as distinct from meditation and study), is the first means of improvement, and in its strictest sense doesn't include any reasoning about the things we observe or inferences drawn from them, the mind moves so incredibly fast that it's almost impossible for a thinking person to gain experiences or observations without making some quick, unconscious reflections on them. Therefore, in offering a few directions about this method of improvement, I won't confine myself narrowly to the first mere impression of objects on the mind through observation. I'll also include some hints that relate to the first, easiest, and most obvious reflections or reasoning that arise from them.
1. Make the expansion of your knowledge a constant goal in life, since there is no time or place, no transaction, occurrence, or engagement in life that excludes us from this method of improving the mind. When we're alone, even in darkness and silence, we can converse with our own hearts, observe the working of our own spirits, and reflect on the inner movements of our own passions in some of the recent occurrences in life. We can acquaint ourselves with the powers and properties, the tendencies and inclinations of both body and spirit, and gain a more intimate knowledge of ourselves. When we're in company, we can discover something more of human nature, of human passions and follies, and of human affairs, vices, and virtues by conversing with others and observing their conduct. And there is nothing more valuable than the knowledge of ourselves and the knowledge of other people, except the knowledge of God who made us and our relationship to Him as our Governor.
When we're inside a house or city, everywhere we look we see what humans have made. When we're out in the countryside, we see far more of what God has made. The sky and ground above and below us, along with the animal and plant life all around us, can fill our observations with countless varieties.
Try to draw some instruction or mental improvement from everything you see or hear, from everything that happens in human life, from everything inside or outside yourself.
Pull down some knowledge from the clouds, the stars, the sun, the moon, and the movements of all the planets. Dig up and draw out some valuable thoughts from the depths of the earth, and search through the vast oceans. Extract some intellectual insights from the minerals and metals, from the wonders of nature among the plants, herbs, trees, and flowers. Learn some lessons from the birds and animals, even from the smallest insect. Read God's wisdom and His remarkable design in all of them. Read His almighty power, His rich and varied goodness, in all the works of His hands.
From day and night, from the hours and the fleeting minutes, learn to use time wisely and stay alert to seize every opportunity to grow in knowledge.
From the changes and upheavals of nations and families, and from the various events of the world, learn how unstable mortal affairs are, how uncertain life is, how certain death is. From a coffin and a funeral, learn to think about your own departure.
From other people's vices and foolishness, notice what's hateful in them. Consider how such behavior looks in another person, and remember that it looks just as bad or worse in yourself. From other people's virtue, learn something worth imitating.
When you see the deformity, distress, or calamity of others, let it teach you to be thankful to God. Offer grateful praise to your Creator, Governor, and Benefactor, who has formed you in a better mold and protected you from those evils. Learn also the sacred lesson of contentment in your own circumstances, and compassion toward your neighbor in his miseries.
From your natural powers (sensations, judgment, memory, hands, feet, and so on), draw this conclusion: they weren't given to you for nothing, but for some useful work that honors your Maker and serves the good of your fellow creatures, as well as your own best interest and final happiness.
From the sorrows, pains, sicknesses, and sufferings that come your way, learn about the evil of sin and the imperfection of your present state. From your own sins and foolish mistakes, learn about God's patience toward you, and practice humility toward both God and other people.
In this way, from every appearance in nature and every occurrence in life, you can draw natural, moral, and religious observations to engage your mind, as well as rules of conduct for the affairs of this life and the one to come.
II. To furnish the mind with a rich variety of ideas, we should indulge and satisfy the laudable curiosity of young people rather than discourage it. It's a very hopeful sign in young people when they're curious in observing and eager to search into the deeper aspects of things they encounter. We shouldn't frown such an inquiring temperament into silence or restrain it harshly, but rather satisfy it by giving proper answers to all those questions.
When time and circumstances permit, young people should be taken out into society at appropriate times. They should visit the countryside to see fields, forests, and rivers, as well as buildings, towns, and cities far from home. They should have the chance to observe unusual birds, animals, fish, insects, plants, and all kinds of natural and artificial creations, whether from their own country or from abroad. And when Providence provides the opportunity, they should travel to different parts of the world under the guidance of a wise tutor or supervisor, so they can bring back valuable knowledge.
III. As you make these observations, write down whatever strikes you as most remarkable and unusual. Keep these notes stored away for the right occasions, and review them regularly. This practice will train you to think productively. It will prevent your mental energy from being wasted, and it will turn even your idle moments into something valuable, both now and in the future.
Whatever useful observations you've made should become at least part of your conversation with friends the next time you meet.
No matter what your circumstances or where life takes you, you should never neglect the growth that comes from careful observation. Whether you travel to the East or West Indies to fulfill military or commercial duties, whether you roam across land or sea for your own pleasure as a traveler, or whether you pursue your interests as a gentleman in whatever part of the world you choose, whether good fortune or bad calls you to the most distant corners of the globe: always continue developing your knowledge and improving your mind through thoughtful observation. In time, this practice will enable you to contribute something valuable to human society.
Theobaldino visited the forests of Norway in his younger years to work in the timber trade. Beyond his own observations about how trees grew on those northern mountains, he learned about a group of people called Finns who lived in the border regions near Sweden. These people made their homes in the woods. Later in life, he was able to give the Royal Society for the Improvement of Natural Knowledge a detailed account of them and some of their customs. Puteoli was captured and taken to Turkey as a young man, and he traveled with his master on their holy pilgrimage to Mecca. This experience gave him a deeper understanding of the forms, ceremonies, and absurdities of Islamic worship than perhaps any other Briton had before. Thanks to his manuscripts, we learned more in the last century about Turkish religious practices than anyone had previously told us.
IV. Let's keep our minds as free as possible from passions and prejudices, because these will distort our observations of both people and things.
A person with jaundice sees everything with a yellow tint. In the same way, a soul colored by any passion or prejudice spreads a false hue over the real appearance of things and disguises many of the ordinary events of life. It never sees things in their true light or allows them to appear as they really are. Therefore, whenever you want to make accurate observations, set aside self and all its influences as much as possible. Remove your own interests and concerns from the equation, and tell all friendships and hostilities to stand back and stay out of the way when you're making observations about people and things.
If we followed this rule carefully, we would be far better protected against the common mistakes people make when observing others: the false judgments that come from pride and envy. How easily envy creeps into our perceptions of other people! How often we're inclined to put the worst possible spin on our neighbors' actions, to view them from a negative angle and in the most unfavorable light? This leads us to form worse opinions of our neighbors than they deserve, while at the same time pride and self-deception tempt us to make unfair observations about ourselves in our own favor. Whenever we pass favorable judgments on ourselves, we should make some allowance for this bias.
V. When making your observations about people, be careful not to indulge that restless curiosity that constantly pries into private and domestic affairs, with an endless itch to learn the secret history of families. Such prying curiosity rarely achieves anything valuable. It often breeds suspicions, jealousies, and disturbances in households, and it frequently tempts people to slander their neighbors. Some people can't help repeating what they know: a busybody is most likely to become a gossip at every opportunity.
VI. Let your observation, even of people and their behavior, be designed primarily to lead you to a better understanding of things, particularly of human nature, and to inform you what to imitate and what to avoid, rather than to supply material for the evil passions of the mind or the pointless chatter and accusations of the tongue.
VII. While it's sometimes appropriate to discuss people as well as ideas in learned or useful conversations, any observations you make about specific individuals, especially critical ones, should usually stay private until some clear and legitimate occasion, some necessary circumstance, requires you to speak up.
If the character or behavior you've observed is seriously wrong, you should be even more reluctant to make it public. You can store up these observations about your neighbors' foolishness, impropriety, or vices as a constant warning against falling into the same traps yourself, without damaging your neighbor's reputation in the process. There's a good old principle that our conversations should focus on ideas rather than people, and this guideline should generally be followed unless we keep names anonymous when discussing human faults and follies.
The late Archbishop Tillotson wrote a short but excellent piece on slander, in which he brilliantly explains, qualifies, and applies that general apostolic command: "Speak evil of no man" (Titus 3:2).
VIII. Don't rush to construct sweeping theories from just a few specific observations, appearances, or experiments. Logicians call this a false induction. When general observations are drawn from enough specific cases to become certain and undeniable, they become jewels of knowledge, containing great treasure in a small space. But precisely because of this, they must be formed with extra care and caution, since errors at this level become widespread and far-reaching if we make mistakes in these general concepts.
Jumping to broad conclusions without carefully examining all the specific cases they might cover is a sure way to trap ourselves in error as we think through any subject. We'll often find ourselves captured by mistakes and falsehoods. Take Niveo, for example: in his youth he noticed that three Christmases in a row brought a good amount of snow, so he wrote in his almanac, as part of his supposedly wise weather observations, that it always snows at Christmas. Or consider Euron, a young man who observed ten times that there was a sharp frost when the wind came from the northeast. So in the middle of last July, he nearly expected freezing temperatures because the weathervanes showed a northeast wind. He was even more disappointed when the season turned out to be sweltering. This same rush to judgment has thrown entire nations into disrepute because of a few guilty individuals from those countries. Yet not all Frenchmen are lighthearted and frivolous, not all Italians are jealous and vengeful, and not all the English are consumed by melancholy.
CHAPTER 4
STRATEGIES FOR EFFECTIVE READING
The world is full of books, but many are so poorly written that they were never worth anyone's time. Thousands more might be good in their own way, yet become worthless once the month, year, or occasion they were written for has passed. Still others may be valuable for some special purpose or in some particular field, but aren't worth reading unless you're actually working in that field. What use is it for a minister, physician, or tradesman to wade through massive volumes of legal case reports? Or for a lawyer to learn Hebrew and study the rabbis? When you're trying to expand your knowledge and save time, one of the best advantages a young person can have is getting recommendations for the most appropriate books from a wise friend.
When you're dealing with important books of any kind, especially complete treatments of a subject, you should first read them in a more general, quick way to get a sense of what the work promises and what you can expect from the writer's approach and skill. To do this well, I'd always recommend reading the preface and looking over the table of contents (if there is one) before your first pass through the book. This way you'll not only be better prepared for that first reading, but you'll also be much better equipped for your second time through, which should be done with greater attention and care. You'll learn more easily and readily what the author is trying to teach. As you read, mark what's new or unknown to you, and review those chapters, pages, or paragraphs later. Unless a reader has an unusually strong memory, I can safely say that almost no book or chapter worth reading once fails to deserve a second look. At the very least, take time to carefully review all the lines or paragraphs you marked and recall the sections you thought were truly valuable.
There's another reason I prefer to take a quick, initial survey of a book before settling down to read it with serious attention: there may be several difficulties in it that we can't easily understand and overcome on the first reading, simply because we don't yet grasp the author's overall plan. In such works, we shouldn't stop and struggle with every difficulty during our first time through. Many of these problems will likely be solved as we continue further in the book, or they'll simply disappear on a second reading.
Whatever we can't grasp or penetrate at first should be noted down for later consideration and investigation, in case the pages that follow don't happen to shed complete light on those that came before.
III. If three or four people agree to read the same book, and each brings his own observations about it to regular meetings appointed for conversation, and they share their thoughts on the subject with each other and debate it in a friendly way, this practice will make reading any author far more beneficial to everyone involved.
IV. If several people engaged in the same study take up different works on one subject, and schedule a time to meet once a week, they can briefly inform each other about the meaning, ideas, and approach of those various authors. This way they promote each other's learning, either by recommending that their companions read the same book, or perhaps by answering their questions about it through conversation, without everyone having to read it.
V. Remember that when you read or engage in conversation, especially on topics related to natural science, ethics, or theology, your goal isn't simply to learn what the author or speaker thinks. That would be mere historical knowledge. Your main purpose is to evaluate whether their opinions are correct and to develop your own solid understanding through careful reflection on what they've written or said. Approach every author with a critical eye, and give your agreement only when the evidence and reasoning justify it.
I should clarify that I'm speaking here only about human authors, not about sacred and inspired Scripture. When we read the Bible, our task is to discover the true meaning of each passage and page. Once we're convinced that the writing is divine, our agreement must follow. Yet I should add that this divine origin itself provides sufficient grounds for our assent.
But when it comes to human writings, remember that you are just as human as the authors. It's not their reason but your own that should guide you once you've reached an age of mature judgment and discretion.
VI. Make this your regular practice, especially after you've completed an initial course of study in any academic subject: if a writer on that topic agrees with your views but fails to explain his ideas clearly or prove his points effectively, note the flaws or gaps. Then try to do better yourself, either in the margins of your book, in your own notes, or at least in your private thinking. For example:
When an author writes unclearly, clarify what he means. When his work is incomplete, fill in the gaps. When he's too brief and compressed, expand on his ideas a bit and present his thoughts more clearly. When he's wordy, mark those sections for cutting. When he wastes time on trivial matters, skip those passages or pages entirely. When he makes an argument, check whether his reasoning actually holds up. If his conclusion is correct but his argument is weak, try to strengthen it with better evidence. When he derives or draws conclusions in a murky or uncertain way, clarify how the inference works, and draw additional inferences or corollaries if they come to mind. When you think he's made an error, raise your objections and correct his thinking. Whatever he writes well enough to earn your approval (both as accurate and useful), store it in your memory and count it as part of your intellectual progress.
Note: many of these same guidelines I've just given can be applied to conversation as well as reading, to make it useful in the most extensive and lasting way.
VII. You can also apply other useful practices when reading authors. If a book's structure is disorganized, create your own brief outline or add notes in the margins. When topics that should be separated are jumbled together, distinguish and divide them carefully. If material on the same subject is scattered throughout the work, use cross-references to bring it all into one view. And if a book contains truly valuable content, consider reorganizing it into a better structure, reducing it to a more logical framework, or condensing it into a shorter form. All these practices will help you develop your logical and organizational skills, sharpen your overall judgment, and give you a more complete understanding of the particular subject. After you finish the work and all your observations on it, reflect on what real improvements you've gained from reading that author.
VIII. If a book lacks an index or a good table of contents, creating one as you read proves very useful. You don't need the precision required for publication, where you'd include the substance of every page and paragraph. For your own index, simply note the parts of the book that are new to you, or that you consider well written and worth remembering or reviewing later.
Let me be honest with my younger friends: these reading methods will take real effort in your first year of study, especially with the first books you work through in any field or on any particular topic. But the payoff will more than justify the work. And in the years that follow, once you've read a few valuable books on a specific subject this way, it will become much easier to read others of the same kind. You won't usually find much new material in them that you haven't already examined.
If the writer has any distinctive strengths or weaknesses in his style or approach, make careful observations about these as well. Whatever fine qualities you find there, or whatever flaws appear in the language or manner of the writer, you should note them thoughtfully. And remember this: one book read through in this manner, with all this demanding reflection, will do more to enrich your understanding than skimming the surface of twenty authors.
IX. By working through books in the way I've described, you will make all your reading serve not only to expand your store of knowledge, but also to sharpen your reasoning abilities.
Many people read consistently and diligently, yet make no real progress in knowledge. They enjoy the ideas they read or hear the way they would enjoy stories being told, but they don't weigh them carefully in their minds to determine whether they're true or false. They make no observations about them, draw no conclusions from them. Perhaps their eyes slide over the pages, or the words slide past their ears and vanish like an evening's worth of tales, or like the shadows of a cloud flying over a green field on a summer's day.
Or if they review their reading enough to remember it, they do so merely to retell the story later and show off their learning. They drift through their days in a constant cycle of reading without gaining anything real. Just as someone might eat all day but never feel nourished because they can't digest their food, these endless readers stuff themselves with intellectual material but never truly improve their minds because they fail to digest it through proper reflection.
X. Be diligent, therefore, in following these directions. Grasp the meaning and arguments of the authors you read. Examine all their proofs, then judge whether their opinions are true or false. This way you'll not only enrich your understanding through the truths the author teaches (when you see them well supported), but you'll also gradually develop the ability to judge wisely and reason well by imitating the good writers whose works you study.
This approach is laborious, I admit, and the mind resists the exhausting work of weighing every argument and tracing everything back to its source. It takes far less effort to accept everything on trust: believing is much easier than arguing. But once Studentio convinced himself to commit to this method I've described, he quickly gained remarkable skill in reading and evaluating what he read through daily practice. He made enormous progress in pursuing truth, while Plumbinus and Plumeo made less headway in knowledge despite having read through more volumes. Plumeo skimmed over the pages like a swallow gliding over flowery meadows in May. Plumbinus read every line and syllable but didn't bother to think about or judge what he was reading. Both could brag in company about their extensive reading, since they knew more titles and page numbers than Studentio, but they were far less familiar with actual knowledge.
I admit that people who read only to sound impressive in conversation, while actually knowing very little, might be satisfied skimming through books in this hasty, superficial way. They can tear through entire libraries like this and still end up as poor thinkers, lacking any solid wisdom or genuine learning. A traveler who walks carefully along the right path, checking every turn before taking it, will reach his destination sooner and more safely than someone who races down every side street he encounters, even if he gallops at full speed all day. Someone who reads extensively and has an excellent memory but never stops to think deeply might become what the world calls a knowledgeable person. If he spends enough time with ancient texts, he might even earn a reputation for being learned. But he lives far from true wisdom and sound judgment, and he possesses very little of the real wealth of the mind.
XI. Never start reading any human author with your mind already made up either for or against him, or with a fixed determination to believe or disbelieve, to support or oppose whatever he says. Instead, always read with the intention of keeping your mind open to truth and embracing it wherever you find it, just as you should reject every falsehood, no matter how attractive its disguise. How unfortunate are those people who rarely pick up a book without having already decided whether they will like or dislike it! They've formed some impression of the author's name, character, political affiliation, or principles through casual conversation, or perhaps by glancing at a few pages. With all their own opinions already settled beforehand, they read everything he writes with a bias either for or against him. How unfortunate are those who hunt for ammunition to support their side, scraping together from every author only those things that support their own beliefs, while they dismiss and ignore everything else!
XII. Yet take this caution. I don't want to be misunderstood here, as if I'm persuading someone to live without any settled principles at all for judging people, books, and ideas, or as if I want to keep someone perpetually doubting their foundations. What I'm mainly trying to accomplish with this advice comes down to three things:
1. After we've established our most necessary and important principles of science, prudence, and religion on good grounds (with regard to our present conduct and our future hopes), we should read with genuine freedom of thought all those books that treat subjects open to doubt and reasonable dispute. None of our opinions should be so firmly fixed, especially in our younger years, that we never listen to or tolerate opposition to them.
2. When we read authors who defend our own settled convictions, we shouldn't assume all their arguments are sound and solid. Instead, we should make a wise distinction between the wheat and the chaff, between solid reasoning and mere superficial appearances of it. We shouldn't readily swallow all their minor opinions just because we agree with them on the major ones.
3. When we read authors who oppose our most certain and established principles, we should be ready to receive any insights from them on other points, and not abandon everything they say at once, even though we're firmly opposed to their main argument.
Fas est ab hoste doceri. Virg. Seize upon truth wherever it's found, Among your friends, among your foes, On Christian or on heathen ground; The flower's divine wherever it grows, Neglect the prickles and assume the rose.
XIII. Everything I've said so far about books and reading applies mainly to the kind of books and study hours we devote to improving our minds with natural, moral, or divine knowledge. But when it comes to works written to guide our behavior or persuade us to act, there's one more essential step: once our consciences are convinced that these rules of wisdom or duty apply to us and demand our obedience, we need to hold ourselves accountable and ask seriously whether we've actually put them into practice. We should dwell on the arguments and press the motives and persuasive methods into our own hearts until we feel their force and power inclining us toward the practices they recommend.
If foolishness or vice is exposed in its obvious forms or its hidden disguises, let us search our hearts and review our lives to see how far we are guilty. We shouldn't consider ourselves finished with the book until we feel genuine sorrow for our past misconduct and aspire to victory over those vices, or until we find that a cure for those follies has begun to take effect in our souls.
In all our studies and pursuits of knowledge, let us remember that virtue and vice, sin and holiness, and the shaping of our hearts and lives according to the duties of true religion and morality matter far more than all the furnishings of our understanding and the richest treasures of purely theoretical knowledge. This is because they have a more immediate and powerful influence on our eternal happiness or eternal sorrow.
XIV. There's another category of books I should address while discussing this subject: history, poetry, travel writing, and books meant for entertainment. We can also include common pamphlets, newspapers, and similar materials. For many of these, I'll admit that reading them once may be enough, assuming you have a reasonably good memory.
Or when several people gather together and one person reads such material aloud to the rest, hearing it once may suffice, provided everyone pays attention and feels comfortable making spontaneous comments on whatever lines, sentences, periods, or paragraphs they think deserve it. Any paragraph or idea that strikes someone as new and unusual, noble and excellent in content, strong and convincing in argument, beautiful and elegant in language or style, or worthy of hearing again deserves such a comment. And if anyone in the group requests it, those paragraphs should be read aloud a second time.
Similarly, any parts of these writings that happen to be remarkably stupid or foolish, false or mistaken, should become subjects for spontaneous criticism from someone in the group. This can provide a reason to repeat those passages as well, either to confirm the negative judgment or simply for amusement and entertainment.
We should remember, though, that when a historical account matters significantly, or when the poetry, rhetoric, and so on display real excellence, reading it once isn't enough to satisfy anyone with genuine appreciation for this kind of writing. We can't get the most out of these works without returning to them properly, both in private and in conversation with others. Anyone who truly enjoys good writing wouldn't be content hearing the beautiful passages of Steele or Addison, the magnificent descriptions of Virgil or Milton, or some of the finest poems of Pope, Young, or Dryden read aloud just once and then set aside forever.
XV. We can rightly include among these latter writings the short miscellaneous essays on every conceivable subject: works like the Occasional Papers, the Tatlers, the Spectators, and other books compiled from weekly or daily publications. These contain countless brilliant insights, clever observations, and excellent commentary that have played a major role in making our current age more knowledgeable and refined.
I wish every piece in these collections could be both innocent and useful. I wish every crude idea and suggestive phrase had been removed, and every trivial page had been left out when they were bound into volumes. But in such an imperfect world, we can't expect every page of these mixed public papers to be entirely blameless and praiseworthy. Yet on the whole, we have to admit there's so much virtue, wisdom, cleverness, and goodness in them (especially in the eight volumes of the Spectator), there's such respect for sacred things, so many valuable observations for how we should live, that they're perfectly appropriate to keep in living rooms, garden houses, or wherever we usually spend time, to occupy our thoughts during any spare moments or free hours. They reveal so much about the follies, wickedness, and fashionable vices of humanity that we can learn a great deal about the moods and madness of our age and the wider world, all from the comfort of our own private retreat, without the danger of keeping bad company or catching a deadly infection.
XVI. Among other books that are proper and necessary for improving our knowledge in general, or our understanding of any particular field, we need to have vocabularies and dictionaries of various kinds: dictionaries of common words, idioms, and phrases to explain their meaning; dictionaries of technical terms to show how they're used in arts and sciences; dictionaries of names of people, countries, towns, rivers, and so on (what we call historical and geographical dictionaries), and others. These should be consulted and used whenever needed. Never let an unfamiliar word pass by in your reading without looking up its sense and meaning in one of these resources.
If you don't have access to these books, you'll need to make up for it by asking people who can help you. It's useful to write down your questions and uncertainties in a pocket notebook, then take the first chance you get to resolve them, either by talking to knowledgeable people or consulting books when you find them.
XVII. Don't settle for merely knowing about the best authors who write on a subject instead of thoroughly understanding the subject itself. Many young students love expanding their knowledge of books, but they satisfy themselves with just knowing the title page. That's the achievement of a bookseller, not a scholar. These people face a strong temptation to commit two foolish mistakes: (1) They pile up huge numbers of books at greater expense than most of them can afford, stocking their libraries far better than their minds. (2) Once they've gathered these supposed treasures of knowledge on their shelves, they imagine themselves learned and take pride in dropping the names of famous authors and the topics they cover, without actually improving their own minds in real knowledge or wisdom. At best, their learning goes no deeper than the indexes and tables of contents. They have no idea how to judge or reason about the actual content in those books.
The truth is, no matter how many volumes of learning someone owns, he remains desperately poor in understanding until he has made those various pieces of learning his own through reading and reasoning, through judging for himself, and through remembering what he has read.
CHAPTER 5
HOW TO EVALUATE BOOKS CRITICALLY
I. If you want to form an opinion about a book you haven't seen before, the first thing you'll notice is the title page, and sometimes you can guess a bit about the book's purpose and content from it. That said, titles are often misleading and promise more than the book actually delivers. If the author's name is well known, that might help you make a slightly better guess about what to expect and how the book will be written. Reading through the preface or introduction (which I recommended earlier) can further sharpen your judgment, and if there's a table of contents, it will give you even more insight.
If you don't have the time or desire to read through the entire book systematically, you can use the chapter titles to guide you toward specific chapters or sections, then check whether they contain anything valuable or important. This approach will show you whether the author explains ideas clearly, reasons convincingly, organizes material well, and writes with substance and polish. On the other hand, you'll also discover whether the author is unclear, weak, trivial, and disorganized. Finally, you might find that the content itself is solid and substantial even if the style and presentation are rough and unpleasant.
II. After surveying several chapters and sections this way, we can usually tell whether the book deserves a complete reading. But if this selective examination leaves us thoroughly disappointed, we should set the book aside. There's a strong likelihood that an author is mediocre at best if he offers only one worthwhile insight among many worthless ones (and perhaps some outright errors too). A work can hardly be valuable if, out of seven or eight chapters we examine, we find only a little truth, evidence, logical force, beauty, or clever thinking mixed with abundant error, ignorance, irrelevance, dullness, trite and ordinary thoughts, sloppiness, faulty reasoning, or harsh attacks. Life is too short, and time too precious, to read every new book cover to cover just to discover it wasn't worth reading.
III. People frequently make certain common mistakes when judging the books they read.
Here's one problem: when a book is reasonably well written, we're quick to judge it favorably and sometimes praise it far beyond what it deserves if it agrees with our own principles and supports the opinions of our side. On the other hand, if the author holds different views and defends opposing principles, we can find neither wit nor reason, good sense nor good language in it. Yet the reality is this: even if our opinions were certain and infallible truth, a foolish author might still take up his pen to defend them, and he might attack even gross errors with weak and ridiculous arguments. Truth in this world is not always attended and supported by the wisest and safest methods. And error, though it can never be maintained by sound reasoning, may still be cleverly disguised and defended. A skilled writer can make his own mistakes look excellent. Some Socinians who deny the Atonement of Christ have written well and with much appearance of argument for their own unbiblical views. And some writers defending the Trinity and Satisfaction of Christ have embarrassed themselves and the sacred doctrine by their weak and foolish manner of handling it. Books should never be judged merely by their subject or the opinion they represent, but by the soundness of their thinking, the beauty of their style, the force of their expression, or the strength of reason and the weight of proper argument that appears in them.
But this foolishness and weakness of joking instead of arguing doesn't fall only to Christian writers. There are some who have taken up the pen to support the Deistical or anti-Christian scheme of our day, who make grand claims to reason on all occasions but seem to have left it all behind when they're mocking the Bible and sneering at the books we call sacred.
Some of these works would hardly have been considered acceptable if they hadn't attacked the Christian faith, yet they've now earned a place among celebrated writings. I seriously doubt whether several of the rambling essays called the Characteristicks would have survived past the first edition if they hadn't shown such a strong streak of unbelief and occasionally thrown out a profane jab at our holy religion. I've sometimes found myself wondering how a book, on the whole so carelessly written, could ever attract so many intelligent readers. Surely they must realize as they read that sometimes an aristocrat can write as foolishly as a commoner, and waste time as much as an old academic, just in a different style. I'm forced to say there are few books I've ever read that claimed to show great genius from which I gained so little valuable knowledge as from these essays. There is, admittedly, a lively impudence among them, a show of learning, and much of what some people nowadays call sophistication; but it's unreasonable that we should be required to admire all this author's fantasies on pain of being considered unfashionable.
IV. Another mistake some people make is this: when they read a treatise on a subject they know little about, they find almost everything new and unfamiliar. Their minds are greatly entertained and improved by encountering many things previously unknown to them; they admire the treatise and praise the author immediately. However, if they had achieved a good level of skill in that field, they might discover that the author had written very poorly, that neither his reasoning nor his method was sound and appropriate, and that his discussions on that subject contained nothing but common or trivial material.
This explains why Cario and Faber, both raised as laborers with no education in the sciences, will marvel at some weekly paper or short pamphlet that discusses a scholarly or technical topic in a clever way. The material seems completely foreign and fascinating to them, so they heap praise on the writer. For the same reason, a young college student will obsess over a journal or political commentary that discusses trade and politics with an air of authority, and will gush about how brilliant the author is. Meanwhile, people who actually know these subjects well listen to this shallow chatter with justified contempt. They recognize how weak and clumsy many of these brief little pieces really are. Those very articles on science, politics, or trade that impressed the ignorant readers are often quite mediocre. That said, I should acknowledge that some of these papers do contain excellent essays, whether on science or trade.
V. But we can also make the opposite mistake when judging books. Once we've mastered a particular subject and examined it thoroughly from every angle, almost no writer on that topic entertains or satisfies us anymore. We find little or nothing new in their work. Yet if we judged fairly, we might recognize that their ideas are actually sound and appropriate, their explanations clear, their reasoning solid, and all parts of their argument well connected and presented effectively. But since we already knew most of this material, it doesn't impress us, and we risk undervaluing it.
So both the learned and the unlearned face their own distinct dangers and biases when judging what others write. What I've described here represents just a sample of these biases. The prejudices that distort our judgment away from truth are practically infinite and endless.
VI. Yet I can't help but point out a few more of these foolish habits, in hopes of correcting them or at least warning others against them.
Some people have a bold and lively temperament and love to meddle with anything that looks like knowledge. They'll pass judgment on a book the moment its title is mentioned, because they hate to seem ignorant of anything others know. This is especially true if they happen to have some superior status or worldly possessions: they think this gives them the right to speak freely about anything that comes up, even when they have no other qualification for such freedom. Divito is worth forty thousand pounds. Politulus is a fine young gentleman who sparkles with fashionable clothes and expensive accessories. Aulinus is a minor attendant to a government minister and shows up at court almost every day. These three happened to meet during a social visit where an excellent book of passionate and refined devotional writings lay in the window. "What dull rubbish is this!" said Divito. "I've never read so much nonsense on one page in my life. I wouldn't give a shilling for a thousand such books." Aulinus, though a courtier, wasn't usually rough in his speech, yet he refused to admit there was a single line of good sense in the book. He declared that the man who wrote it in his private retreat was a madman, and the one who published it after his death was a fool. Politulus had too many manners to disagree with men of such rank and status, so he sneered at the devout expressions as he heard them read and turned the divine work into an object of scorn and mockery. Yet it was well known that neither this fine gentleman, nor the courtier, nor the wealthy man had a grain of devotion in them beyond their horses waiting at the door with their gilded carriages. But this is how the world works: blind men will talk about the beauty of colors and the harmony or imbalance of figures in paintings; the deaf will chatter about discords in music; and those who have nothing to do with religion will condemn the best writings on divine subjects, even though they don't understand the very language of scripture or the common terms and phrases used in Christianity.
VII. I should mention another type of critic who will champion an author or condemn him as incompetent based entirely on the company they keep and the opinions they've heard from others like themselves, even though they have no real knowledge or appreciation of the subject. These people, armed with a smooth and fluent tongue, simply echo whatever praise or criticism they've heard from others. Sonillus happened to be in the room when the three gentlemen I just mentioned freely shared their thoughts on an excellent devotional book, and two days later he met with some of his friends where this same book came up in conversation and was being praised. Sonillus was amazed at their stupidity and repeated the jokes he'd heard mocking the author's supposed weakness. His entire knowledge of the book and his judgment of it came from hearsay, since he'd never even seen it. And even if he had read it cover to cover, he had no business judging anything about religion, having no more knowledge or appreciation of genuine piety than a hedgehog or a bear has of good manners.
After I wrote these observations, Probus, who knew all four gentlemen, wished they might have a chance to read their own character as I've portrayed it here. Unfortunately, Probus, I'm afraid it would do them very little good, though it may protect others from their foolishness: not one of them would recognize their own name in these descriptions if they read them, even though all their acquaintances would immediately recognize the features and see the people practically alive in the portrait.
VIII. There's another harmful tendency that affects how some people judge the writings of others: driven by vanity, pride, or envy, they dismiss a valuable book and heap scorn on it indiscriminately. If you ask them why they're so harsh, they'll tell you they found a mistake or two, or that a few ideas or phrases didn't suit their taste and preferences. Bavius condemns an excellent philosophy treatise and claims it promotes atheism because a few sentences seem to suggest that animals are merely machines. Under the same influence, Momus refuses to acknowledge Paradise Lost as a good poem because he's read some dull and clumsy lines in it, and he thinks Milton received too much praise. It's a petty attitude that leads someone to attack any human work simply because it isn't absolutely perfect. Horace would give us a better example:
Sunt delicta tamen quibus ignovisse velimus, Nam neque chorda sonum reddit quem vult manus et mens; Nec semper feriet quodcunque minabitur arcus: Verum ubi plura nitent in carmine, non ego paucis Offendar maculis, quas aut incuria fudit, Aut humana parum cavit natura. Hor. de Art. Poet.
Here's the English version:
Don't be too harshly critical: A string may produce the wrong note in the best master's hand, And the most skilled archer may miss his target: So in a poem elegantly written, I won't quarrel with a small mistake, The kind that our nature's frailty may excuse. Roscommon.
This distinguished translator of Horace, whom I'm quoting here, has a very high opinion of Homer overall. Yet he admits Homer deserves criticism for some glaring flaws and blemishes:
For who without disgust ever looked On holy garbage, though by Homer cooked; Whose railing heroes, and whose wounded gods, Make some suspect he snores as well as nods.
We need to make careful and fair distinctions when we judge human achievements, but envy doesn't bother with such nuance. It condemns everything indiscriminately. Envy is a poisonous thing: some trace of it takes root in almost everyone's nature, and it operates in subtle, nearly invisible ways, even in people who are otherwise wise and devout. They can't stand hearing praise for a talented writer, especially if he's still alive and works in their own field. So they'll search for any flaw in his work, no matter how small, just to have something to attack. They'll try to diminish the value of even the finest book written on a subject, working to make it seem worthless through their criticism rather than let their envy rest and allow the author's minor errors to pass unnoticed. Sometimes they'll praise the work in general terms, putting on a show of fairness, but then follow up with so many subtle, spiteful criticisms that they completely undermine their own lukewarm compliments.
IX. When someone notices this spiteful impulse stirring in himself, he can try to correct it by considering the following. He should think about how many excellent qualities such an author possesses compared to his flaws, and remember that it's far more honorable and generous to identify distinctive strengths than to hunt for weaknesses. Genuine, unfeigned fairness is a much more admirable and godly quality than fault-finding. He should also reflect on how easy it is to find mistakes in any human writer, since we're all necessarily fallible and imperfect.
I'll admit that when an author sets out to mock sacred writers and religious matters while acting like an absolute authority, praising the ancient pagans as if they were gods while pouring contempt on all modern writers (especially those who dare to acknowledge miracles and the gospel), his admirers need to understand something important: nature and these ancient writers are not the same thing, even though some authors always treat them as if they were. Reason and nature never made these ancient pagans the ultimate standard for art, genius, writing, or heroism. Sir Richard Steele, in his short essay called The Christian Hero, showed our Savior and St. Paul in a far more glorious and transcendent light than Virgil or Homer ever managed with their Achilles, Ulysses, or Aeneas. I'm convinced that if Moses and David hadn't been inspired writers, these same critics would have ranked them at least alongside Herodotus and Horace, if not above them.
But when an author has many strengths that align with virtue, piety, and truth, petty critics shouldn't puff themselves up and pour out their spite on him without any restraint or limit. Instead, they should stretch their own abilities until they write something better than what they're condemning. That's the noblest and most effective way to suppress what they criticize.
A little cleverness or a bit of education, combined with a good dose of vanity and spite, will enable someone to fill pages with criticism and attacks based on one real or imagined error by a great and worthy author. The same talents can dress this up and make it entertaining enough for a world that loves criticism and scandal. But if the critic would just once try to outshine the author by writing a better book on the same subject, he would quickly discover his own inadequacy. Perhaps he might even learn to judge other people's work more fairly and generously. A cobbler or shoemaker might find some small fault with the latchet of a shoe that Apelles had painted, and perhaps rightly so, even when the whole figure and portrait is something only Apelles could have painted. Every mediocre mind can quibble with what the richest and noblest intellect has accomplished. But when such quibbling becomes sufficient reason to condemn outright both a brilliant author and an entire valuable work, it reveals envy and malice added to a small and impoverished mind.
Another common mistake in judging books is spreading the same praise or criticism across an entire work and all its chapters when those comments really apply to only some parts. People judge in bulk, so to speak, without properly distinguishing between the different sections of the work. This easily misleads anyone who hears them talk. Florus greatly admires the late Archbishop of Cambray and enthusiastically praises everything he wrote, refusing to acknowledge any flaws. Yet that excellent man's writings aren't all of equal quality. Even his books that contain many beautiful and valuable ideas shouldn't be recommended wholesale or all at once without distinction. Take his demonstration of the existence and attributes of God, which has justly earned universal respect for bringing new and noble thoughts about the wisdom of creation down to the level of ordinary readers (thoughts that also deserve the attention of scholars), perhaps as far as the fiftieth section. But many of the sections that follow are very weakly written, and some are built on an enthusiastic and mistaken scheme similar to Father Malebranche's peculiar opinions. For instance, section 51 and 53 claim "we know the finite only by the ideas of the infinite." Sections 55 and 60 argue "the superior reason in man is God himself acting in him." Sections 61 and 62 state "the idea of unity cannot be taken from creatures, but from God only." Several of his sections from 65 to 68 on the doctrine of liberty seem inconsistent. Then, toward the end of his book, he spends more time and effort than necessary refuting the Epicurean notion of atoms moving eternally through infinite changes, which could be done effectively in a much shorter and better way.
In his posthumous essays and letters, you'll find many excellent thoughts on practical and experiential religion, along with beautiful and divine expressions of devotion. But sometimes, across long paragraphs or even entire chapters, he drifts into the clouds of mystical theology and never comes back down to where ordinary ideas or common sense can reach him.
Keep in mind, though, that few authors are like this great man, who can write so feebly at times yet in other places rise far above most other writers.
There are other examples of this sort, where people with generally good judgment set themselves up as critics, but they bring too many of their passions along with them. Like lovers, they go into raptures at the name of their beloved idol. They pour out all their praise at that shrine and can't stand the thought of admitting any flaw in their favorite.
You'll hear Altisono not only admire Casimir of Poland's lyrics as the ultimate purity and perfection of Latin poetry, but he won't allow anything in them to be extravagant or faulty, and he'll defend every line. I can't be too surprised, since I've heard him declare Lucan the best of the ancient Latin poets and idolize even his weaknesses and mistakes. I'll readily admit that Casimir's Odes have more spirit and force, more magnificence and fire, and in twenty places rise to greater dignity and beauty than I've ever found in any modern poet. Yet I'm hesitant to say that "Palla sutilis e luce" (a robe woven from light) has enough dignity for a garment made for the Almighty (Book 4, Ode 7, line 37), or that the virtuous man in Ode 3, line 44, "under the ruins of heaven and earth, will bear up the fragments of the falling world with a comely wound on his shoulders":
Late ruenti Subjiciens sua colla cælo Mundum decoro vulnere fulcie; Interque cæli fragmina.
I have to admit, though, that it's nearly impossible for a writer to reach the heights of poetry that Casimir achieved without occasionally falling into these kinds of excesses. Still, we shouldn't admire or defend such lapses if we want to judge even the greatest writers fairly.
Milton is a brilliant genius (everyone agrees on that), and his Paradise Lost is a magnificent achievement that stands alongside the most celebrated works of ancient literature. But you'd have to be heavily biased in his favor to think he maintains the same level of excellence throughout the entire work. The sublime ideas, the dignified verse, the powerful and beautiful language: none of these remain consistently strong, even in passages that demand grandeur, beauty, force, or harmony. I have to agree with Dryden's assessment, though I'll put it in my own words: for stretches of dozens of lines at a time, there's a coldness and flatness, an almost complete absence of that poetic spirit that breathes, lives, and burns in other sections.
XI. When you hear someone claiming to judge a book, ask yourself whether they're actually qualified to do so. Could they be operating under some unfortunate bias or prejudice, either for or against it? Have they investigated it thoroughly enough to form a sound opinion?
Even if someone has good sense generally, they can't judge a particular book accurately unless they know the subject matter well and understand the style in which it's written (whether verse or prose). They also need to have had enough time and opportunity to examine the work itself properly.
Again, even if someone is perfectly capable of judging a book based on their knowledge of the subject and the work itself, you still need to consider whether anything about the author (their style, language, opinions, or political leanings) might bias the reviewer's judgment. These factors can make someone think too well or too poorly of a work and lead them to praise or condemn it unfairly.
If you discover that a person is unfit to judge a book either because they lack knowledge or because they're prejudiced, their opinion should carry no weight. Take Philographo, for example: he's a good theologian, a helpful preacher, and a respected biblical commentator. But he's never had any appreciation for the refined literature of our time. He loved anything that looked pious, but all poetry was the same to him. Just last week, he told me about a wonderful book of poems on the three Christian virtues (faith, hope, and charity) and an elegant piece of rhetoric on the four last things (death, judgment, heaven, and hell). Do you really think I'm going to buy either of those books just because Philographo recommends them?
CHAPTER 6
LEARNING FROM TEACHERS AND LECTURES
I. Very few people have such sharp minds and sound judgment that they can learn the arts and sciences without help from teachers. Almost no field of study can be learned safely and quickly, even by the most brilliant mind using the best books, without a tutor. For most people, a teacher's help is absolutely necessary, and it's extremely useful for all beginners. Books are essentially mute instructors: they show you the path to learning, but if you're confused or mistaken about something, they can't answer your immediate questions or clear up your current doubts and difficulties. That's the proper role of a living teacher.
There are very few tutors who possess the kind of universal learning needed to teach across all subjects and fields. The sciences are numerous and often quite different from one another. It's best to learn from at least two or three tutors if you want to cover the full range of sciences (where this is possible). That way, each tutor can teach the few subjects assigned to them with greater skill. But when this advantage isn't available, one exceptional teacher must do the work of two or three ordinary instructors.
It's not enough for instructors to be reasonably skilled in the subjects they claim to teach. They also need to understand the art and method of teaching itself, and they need the patience to practice it well.
It's truly unfortunate when people become tutors through party politics, factional influence, personal interest, or simply by buying their position, despite having neither adequate knowledge of their subject nor skill in communicating it. And sadly, there are others who, despite their ignorance and incompetence, have enough self-admiration and boldness to set themselves up as teachers. The poor students suffer accordingly, and their minds grow thin and malnourished.
It's worth noting that some highly learned people know a great deal themselves but lack the ability to share what they know, or they're simply lazy and won't put in the effort. They might have a confused and unclear way of explaining things, or they show off their learning in useless ways, giving long-winded explanations of every word in the book they're teaching. Some can't bring themselves down to the level of beginners, while others jump straight into the advanced parts of a subject because they find it more enjoyable. Some get angry and impatient quickly, unable to tolerate a few irrelevant questions from a young, curious, and energetic student. Others merely skim over a subject in a shallow and superficial way, never taking their students into its depths.
IV. A good tutor should have qualities and characteristics completely different from all of these. He's someone who both can and will apply himself with diligence, care, and tireless patience to accomplish what he sets out to do: to teach his students and make sure they actually learn. He adapts his approach and methods as closely as possible to the different personalities and abilities of those he teaches, and he regularly checks in on their progress and improvement.
The teacher must carefully monitor his own temperament and behavior to ensure nothing about him sets a bad example. He should avoid anything that suggests arrogance or a petty, small-minded attitude. Nothing about him should make his students dislike or look down on him, or create prejudice against him and what he teaches. Ideally, he should combine natural warmth and kindness with his scholarly expertise in a way that makes knowledge flow into his students' minds with gentle ease and genuine pleasure. This approach should draw them toward the highest development of their reasoning abilities through an irresistible yet almost imperceptible influence. I'll have more to say on this topic when I discuss methods for communicating knowledge more directly.
V. The student should attend all of his tutor's instruction consistently and attentively. If he's unavoidably prevented from attending at any time, he must make up for the loss by working twice as hard going forward. He should always review and reflect on his lectures, read additional authors on the same subject, discuss it with his instructor or fellow students, and write down the clearest conclusions from his current thinking, reasoning, and investigation. He can then return to these notes later, either to reexamine and apply them properly or to develop them further for his own benefit.
VI. A student should never be satisfied with merely showing up to his tutor's lectures unless he clearly grasps what his teacher means and understands what's being taught. A young student should conduct himself well enough to earn his instructor's affection and attention, so that he can freely ask questions whenever needed, discuss his own thoughts, doubts, and difficulties, and humbly and respectfully request help in resolving them.
VII. Students should work to maintain a high opinion of their instructors and listen carefully to their teaching, recognizing that they're being guided by someone with more experience. While you're not obligated to agree with everything your teacher says, you should at least commit to carefully considering the matter and examining it thoroughly with an honest heart before you presume to disagree. And when you do disagree, it should be done with great modesty, with a humble suspicion that you might be wrong, and with a clear reluctance to differ from your teacher unless the force of argument and truth compels you to do so.
VIII. One of the most common and growing problems of our time is that cocky young students quickly imagine themselves wiser than those teaching them. At first glance, or with just a little thought, they think they can see how insignificant, weak, and mistaken their teacher's assertions are. Today's young people, with their early arrogance and supposed freedom of thought, dare to reject immediately (and with a kind of contempt) all those ideas and doctrines that their teachers have arrived at only after long and repeated consideration, after years of mature study, careful observation, and extensive practical experience.
IX. It's true that teachers and instructors aren't infallible, and they aren't always right. I have to admit, it's genuinely difficult for younger minds to maintain a proper and serious respect for the authority and advice of their parents and the instruction of their teachers while at the same time preserving a proper freedom in their own thinking. If we respect and love our teachers, we're sometimes too ready to absorb all their ideas without examination. On the other hand, if we take complete freedom to challenge their opinions, we're sometimes tempted to abandon the love and respect for them as people that God and nature require. Young people are always in danger of falling into one of these two extremes.
X. But I think I can safely conclude this: While a teacher's authority shouldn't absolutely determine what a student believes, young and inexperienced learners should show all proper respect for the instruction of their parents and teachers, stopping just short of absolute submission to their commands. Yet we must still maintain this principle: students should never accept any opinion into their minds, whether it agrees or disagrees with their tutor's view, without first receiving sufficient evidence that satisfies their own reasoning powers.
CHAPTER 7
MASTERING NEW LANGUAGES
The first thing you need when reading an author or listening to a tutor's lectures is a solid understanding of the language they're writing or speaking in. Living languages (those currently spoken as the native tongue of any nation) are more easily learned and taught through a few rules combined with much familiar conversation and reading appropriate authors. Dead languages are those no longer spoken by any nation. Even these are easier to teach (as far as possible) using the same method that works best for living languages: partly through rules, and partly through repetition and custom. It might be helpful here to mention a few directions for this purpose.
I. Start with the most necessary and general observations and rules that belong to that language, compiled in the form of a grammar. In most languages, these are relatively few. You should learn the regular declensions and variations of nouns and verbs early and thoroughly by heart, along with twenty or thirty of the plainest and most necessary rules of syntax.
Here's one thing to keep in mind: in almost every language, some of the most common nouns and verbs are highly irregular. Take the basic auxiliary verbs (to be, to have, to do, to be done, and so on). The same goes for comparatives and superlatives of words like good, bad, great, small, much, and little. These should be among the first rules and variations students learn, simply because they come up constantly.
As for less common words, don't burden young beginners with too many anomalies or irregularities when teaching the general rules. Save those for later. Advanced students can pick them up through notes on the rules, like you find in the Latin grammar called the Oxford Grammar or in Ruddiman's notes on his Rudiments. Or they can learn them through examples as they encounter them, or by working through a larger, more comprehensive grammar system that covers the finer points of speech. For instance, the heteroclite nouns of Latin (taught in the school book called Quae Genus) shouldn't be touched when students are first learning the basics of the language.
II. Whatever grammar you use to learn a language should be very short at first, and it must be written in a language you already know well and feel comfortable with. That's why I strongly prefer even the common English accidence (as it's called) over any grammar written in Latin for this purpose. The English accidence certainly has its flaws, but the editions printed after 1728, corrected by a learned professor, are the best available. Another excellent option is the English rudiments of the Latin tongue by that learned North Briton, Mr. Ruddiman. These are perhaps the most useful books of this kind I've come across, especially because I don't want to stray too far from the traditional and common methods of teaching. Several good grammarians have abandoned these methods, and it has seriously hurt students who later transferred to other schools.
The exhausting and illogical method of learning Latin through a grammar book with Latin rules would reveal itself as absurd and ridiculous even to the teachers who use it, if those same teachers tried to learn Chinese or Arabic from a grammar written entirely in Chinese or Arabic. Mr. Clarke of Hull said enough in a few pages of his preface to his new grammar (1723) to expose this practice as deeply irrational and inappropriate, though he said it in such a heated and angry way that it provoked Mr. Ruddiman to write against him and defend a practice that I believe is completely indefensible.
III. At the same time you begin learning the rules, start practicing immediately. For instance, when you decline musa, musae, read and translate some easy Latin author that same day, either with a tutor's help or using an English translation. Choose a book whose style is simple and whose subject matter is very plain, obvious, and easy to understand. Many small books have been written for exactly this purpose: Corderius's Colloquies, some of Erasmus's shorter writings, the sayings of the wise men of Greece, Cato's moral couplets, and the rest of the selections collected at the end of Mr. Ruddiman's English Grammar, or Castellio's Latin translation of the New Testament (which is considered the purest Latin), and so on. These are all very appropriate for this stage, along with the fables of Aesop and Phaedrus, short stories, and accounts of common daily household life written in Latin. But keep the more advanced poets, orators, historians, and other writers whose language is more elaborate and whose content is more removed from everyday life out of reach until you've made real progress in the language.
It's odd that teachers start children so early on Cicero's letters and speeches, or the poetry of Ovid and Virgil. The sense is often hard to grasp because of how drastically the words are rearranged, and even when students figure out the grammatical meaning, they get very little from it. They have almost no understanding of the ideas or purpose behind what the writer is saying, since it's so far removed from a child's knowledge. Simple everyday stories and dialogues, rules for how children should behave, and other straightforward subjects would do much more to help them remember the words, because they're already familiar with the concepts.
IV. It can also help to have the student memorize the most common and useful words: nouns and adjectives, pronouns and verbs, taken from a well-designed and thoughtful vocabulary list. This will give him names for the most familiar ideas.
V. As soon as the student is ready, the teacher should speak with him in the language being learned (if it's a living language), or in Latin, which serves as the living language of the scholarly world. This way he'll pick it up through repetition as well as through rules, and through active practice as well as through reading old texts. After all, if a two-year-old child can learn to speak his native language this way, I'm certain the same method will greatly help and speed up the learning of any other language for older students.
VI. In schools where students learn Latin (at least during the first year or more), the main lessons and exercises should focus on nouns, verbs, and basic syntax rules, along with simple translation from Latin texts into English. Teachers should examine students daily, having them trace words back to their root forms: the first case of nouns or the first tense of verbs. Students should explain how these words are formed and changed, and how they function within sentences (a process called parsing). This exercise is incredibly valuable for helping students truly understand what they're doing.
The teacher should carefully correct the English translations students produce. Then, for the next day's work, students should translate their corrected English back into Latin without looking at the original Latin text. However, they should be given the Latin words in their basic forms (first case and tense) rather than being left to hunt through a dictionary on their own. The closer a student's translation matches the original author's wording, the more praise he deserves. This method builds skill in both languages simultaneously. I believe Mr. Clarke has provided a real service to education by creating Latin translations designed for exactly this purpose.
But we should permanently abandon the foolish practice of making every mediocre student write themes, speeches, and verses on moral topics in a foreign language before he can even think clearly in his own.
VII. As students advance, they should learn the irregular words: the unusual declensions of nouns and verbs, the less common ways words connect in sentences, and the exceptions to standard grammar rules. But whenever possible, these exceptions should be traced back to the fundamental rules students learned earlier, showing how they relate to the proper categories where they belong.
VIII. While the student is doing this, he should also start reading authors who are a bit more challenging: historians, orators, poets, and so on. But his tutor needs to explain the Roman or Greek customs that come up in these texts. The student should then translate portions of them into his native language, or into another language he knows well, and then translate them back into the original language. However, he should translate verse into prose, since poetry isn't really part of grammar study.
IX. By this point he'll be ready to learn some of the special emphases of speech and the distinctive idioms of the language. He should also be taught the particular beauties and ornaments of the language. This can be done partly through books by authors who have collected such idioms and organized them in an accessible way, and partly through the thoughtful observations his instructor makes about the texts he's reading, whenever these peculiarities of speech or special elegances appear.
X. Making students memorize every single lesson borrowed from poetical authors they're studying is an unfair and pointless burden. Still, the student must take the trouble to memorize the most essential rules of grammar (if not all the common ones), along with an example or two for each rule. He should also memorize some of the best and most useful sentences from the Latin or Greek authors he reads, along with some of the finest lessons from their poets. Sometimes entire episodes from epic poems, as well as complete odes from lyric poetry, may be worth this honor.
XI. Always make sure that students fully understand both the meaning and the language of any rules, lessons, or passages they're trying to memorize. The teacher should help them grasp the true sense of what they're learning, which makes the work easy and enjoyable. In contrast, forcing a child to memorize long strings of unfamiliar phrases or words without any understanding of what they mean is pointless cruelty, a harsh burden, and a practice better suited to a jackdaw or parrot than to any human being.
XII. This brings me to a question that often comes up in conversation: whether it's really appropriate in a Christian country to teach a classroom full of boys Latin through pagan poets like Ovid (with his Epistles and the foolish fables of his Metamorphoses), Horace, Juvenal, and Martial (with their indecent odes, satires, and epigrams), and so on.
XIII. (1.) I'll grant that the language and style of writers working in their native tongue must be more pure and refined in certain subtle elegances and distinctive features than modern writers from other nations who have imitated them. I'll also acknowledge that the beauty of their poetry may be superior. But boys can't be expected to gain or lose much from either quality at their age.
XIV. (2.) I'll also admit that modern poets in every living language have incorporated so many words, epithets, phrases, and metaphors from pagan myths and stories of their gods and heroes that understanding these modern writers requires some knowledge of those ancient follies. However, a good dictionary or a book like the Pantheon (or any history of those pagan deities) can provide schoolboys with enough information about those stories for practical purposes.
XV. (3.) I'll grant one more thing: students destined to become great scholars or theologians might, by reading these pagan poets, learn to better understand the writings of the early church fathers who argued against pagan religion. They can discover what ridiculous nonsense the Gentile nations believed as their articles of faith, what wretched and filthy idolatries they indulged in and practiced as religious duties, all because they lacked divine revelation. But students could probably learn this just as well from the Pantheon or some other collection while still in school. Or after they leave school, they can read whatever their own interests lead them to, including whatever material of this kind might actually prove useful.
XVI. But here's the real question: do all these supposed advantages actually make up for the long months and years wasted on incredible and trivial romances, on false and shameful stories about gods and goddesses and their love affairs, and on the lewd heroes and corrupt poets of the pagan world? Can these idle and ridiculous tales offer any real and solid benefit in human life? Don't they too often pollute the mind with empty, harmful, and impure ideas? Don't they linger in the imagination and leave a damaging influence on young people? Don't they stain the imagination with foolishness and vice from an early age, turning it away from everything good and holy?
XVII. After looking at the whole picture, I believe that for almost all boys learning Latin, it would be much safer to teach them Latin poetry (as soon and as far as they need it) from those excellent translations of David's Psalms by Buchanan in the various meters of Horace. And the younger students would do better reading Dr. Johnston's translation of these psalms, another elegant writer from Scotland, instead of Ovid's Epistles. He has turned the same psalms, perhaps with even greater elegance, into elegiac verse, and the learned W. Benson, Esq. has recently published a fine edition of them. I hear that these psalms are being used more and more in the schools of Holland and Scotland. A stanza or couplet from these writers would occasionally stick in the minds of young people and would give them infinitely better material for pious and moral thoughts, doing something toward making them good men and Christians.
XVIII. A small book collected from the psalms of both these translators, Buchanan and Johnston, along with a few other Christian poets, would be extremely useful for schools beginning their instruction in Latin poetry. And I'm convinced this would be more than sufficient for all those of lower rank who never intend to pursue a learned profession, yet custom has foolishly required them to learn that language.
I don't want to sound too harsh on Horace, Virgil, Ovid, and Juvenal by suggesting we ban them entirely from schools. So let me offer a compromise: what if we carefully selected just a few lyric odes, some satirical passages, a handful of heroic episodes, and perhaps a few of Martial's epigrams (all of them free from vice and impiety) that could inspire noble thoughts, ignite the imagination with vivid ideas, or teach moral and practical lessons? These selections could be gathered from the ancient Roman writers and published in one or two modest volumes. That would provide more than enough Roman poetry for the education of young students at that stage of life.
Even Juvenal himself would be embarrassed to defend teachers who assign his sixth satire to boys, along with many sections of his other works, especially when he himself warned us:
Nil dictu foedum, visuque, haec limina tangat Intra quae puer est. (Sat. 14)
Suffer no lewdness, nor indecent speech, Th' apartment of the tender youth to reach. (Dryden)
That's my answer to the question at hand.
But I'll step back here, because Mr. Clarke of Hull, in his treatise on education, and Mr. Philips, tutor to the Duke of Cumberland, have already given far better guidance on learning Latin.
When you've learned a language, and if it has any practical value, it would be a shame to let it slip away. You should take every reasonable opportunity to read something in that language regularly, whenever your other necessary and important studies allow time for it. Just as you kept dictionaries of words and phrases close at hand while learning the language, you should continue to keep them within reach if you want to remember what you've learned. Never settle for a vague guess about the meaning of any word you encounter. Instead, consult the dictionary for accurate information and protect yourself from error. It's pure laziness that makes us accept uncertain guesses, and this approach is neither safe nor useful for anyone who wants to learn a language or subject, or who wants to retain what they've already acquired.
When you've learned one or many languages, no matter how perfectly, be careful not to take too much pride in these accomplishments. They are merely collections of words, or tools for acquiring true and solid knowledge. Their main purpose is to lead us toward understanding things themselves, or to help us convey our ideas and knowledge to others more easily. Knowing various languages is nothing more than a remedy for the damage done at the Tower of Babel. Even if I mastered as many languages as were spoken at Babel, I would have little claim to real learning or knowledge if I didn't have clear and distinct ideas and useful concepts in my mind to go with the words my tongue could pronounce. Yet human nature is so flawed that this kind of knowledge of sounds and syllables tends to inflate the mind with vanity more than the most valuable and substantial improvements ever could. The pride of a grammarian or a critic generally exceeds that of a philosopher.
CHAPTER 8
INTERPRETING TEXTS AND SPEECH ACCURATELY
It's a real problem that words and phrases can be so ambiguous. The same sentence can mean different things to different people, which makes it hard for readers to figure out exactly what ideas the writer or speaker had in mind. Here are some of the best rules to help with this:
I. Get thoroughly familiar with the actual language the author is using. Learn not only what each word means, but also the sense those words take on when arranged in a particular order and context. Study the specific force and emphasis of different ways of speaking, and the various idioms of the language. You should also know the secondary meanings that custom has attached to many words, not just their primary definitions, if you want to understand any writer properly. (See Logic, Part I, Chapter 4, Section 3.)
II. Pay attention to what those words and phrases meant specifically in the same nation or around the same time period when that writer lived, and how authors from the same nation, opinion, sect, party, and so on used them.
For this reason, we can learn to interpret several phrases in the New Testament by looking at the Greek version of the Hebrew Bible called the Septuagint. Even though that translation is quite imperfect and flawed in many ways, it seems clear to me that the New Testament writers often used that version when they quoted passages from the Bible.
III. Compare the words and phrases in one passage with the same or similar words and phrases the author uses elsewhere. These are usually called parallel passages, and just as one expression can clarify a similar one, sometimes a contrasting expression will illuminate its opposite. Always remember that a writer is his own best interpreter. Since we believe the Holy Spirit is the ultimate author behind both the Old and New Testaments, He can best explain Himself. This is where the theological principle comes from: Scripture is the best interpreter of Scripture. That's why concordances, which show us parallel passages, are so valuable for interpretation.
IV. Consider the subject the author is discussing. By comparing other passages where he addresses the same topic, you can understand what he means in the passage you're reading, even if some of the terms he uses in those two places are quite different.
On the flip side, if the author uses the same words but is discussing a different subject, you can't determine his meaning by comparing those two passages, even though the words themselves might seem to match. Some authors use the same words in very different senses when treating entirely different subjects, as Paul does with the words faith, law, and righteousness.
V. Pay attention to the writer's scope and purpose. Figure out what he's trying to accomplish in that book, section, or paragraph, because this will help explain individual sentences. We can assume that a wise and thoughtful writer generally directs his words toward his intended goal.
VI. When an author mentions a subject in passing, interpret what he says by looking at passages where he discusses it thoroughly and deliberately. Where he uses mystical or metaphorical language, clarify it with passages where he addresses the same subject in plain, literal terms. Where he writes in a rhetorical, emotional, or persuasive style, explain it using passages where he covers the same topic in a doctrinal or instructive manner. Where the author speaks more precisely and specifically about a theme, use that to clarify his looser and more general statements. Where he writes at length, use that to explain his brief hints and short references. And wherever he writes obscurely, search for clearer passages by the same writer to determine what that unclear language means.
VII. Consider not only who is speaking, but also who is being addressed, the circumstances of time and place, the temperament and attitude of the speaker, and the temperament and attitude of the listeners. To interpret Scripture well, you need a solid understanding of Jewish customs, some knowledge of ancient Roman and Greek times and practices, which can sometimes shed surprising light on passages that were previously very obscure.
VIII. In specific propositions, you can sometimes determine an author's meaning by the conclusions he draws from them. You can rule out any interpretations that don't support those conclusions.
Note: This rule isn't always reliable when reading and interpreting human authors, because they can make mistakes in drawing their conclusions. But in explaining Scripture it's a dependable rule, because the sacred and inspired writers always draw valid conclusions from their own propositions. Yet even with them, we must be careful not to mistake an allusion for a conclusion, since the two are often introduced in nearly the same way.
IX. When dealing with controversial material, you can sometimes figure out what an author really means by looking at the objections raised against him. For instance, we can be certain that Paul argues against "justification before God through our own good works" in Romans 3, 4, and 5 because of the objection he addresses at the start of chapter 6: "What should we say then? Should we keep sinning so that grace may increase?" (Rom 6:1). This objection would never have come up if Paul had been arguing that we're justified by our own righteous deeds.
X. When you're reading disputed material, watch out for the tendency to twist the writer's meaning to fit your own views. This happens because of hidden biases: self-love and partisan loyalty. These prejudices have produced countless different interpretations of both Scripture and other texts, interpretations that would never have occurred to readers if they hadn't been working under such preconceptions.
XI. For the same reason, guard against the biases that come from passion, malice, envy, pride, or hostility toward an author. These emotions can easily tempt you to put a false and malicious spin on his words. Set aside a fault-finding attitude and read even an opponent with care and honesty, genuinely trying to understand what he means. Don't pounce on minor slips and apparent mistakes while ignoring his clearly stated intentions. And don't attribute any view or opinion to him that he explicitly denies holding, unless the most plain and direct language proves otherwise.
Finally, remember to treat every author, writer, or speaker the way you would want to be treated by others who are trying to understand what you write or say. Keep a deep awareness of God's presence, for He judges the heart and will punish those who, through dishonest and corrupt thinking, deliberately twist the meaning of Scripture or even ordinary authors because of their own culpable prejudices. For more on this, see Logic, part I, chapter 6, section 3, "Directions concerning the definitions of names."
CHAPTER 9
LEARNING THROUGH CONVERSATION
1. If we want to improve our minds through conversation, it's a great advantage to know people who are wiser than we are. It's useful advice, then, to seek out their conversation as often as circumstances allow. And if they happen to be somewhat reserved, use every courteous method to draw out what might increase your own knowledge.
2. Whatever company you find yourself in, don't waste time on trivial and pointless matters. If you spend a few hours with children, talk with them at their level. Notice the early signs of developing reason. Observe the different movements and distinct workings of both body and mind, as far as you can discern them. Pay attention to how gradually the little person grows into the use of his reasoning powers, and what early prejudices threaten to corrupt his understanding. This way you will learn how to speak to children for their benefit, and perhaps you may even discover some useful philosophical insights or theories for your own interest.
III. If you find yourself in the company of a merchant or sailor, a farmer or mechanic, a milkmaid or spinner, draw them into conversation about their own particular field or profession. Everyone knows, or should know, their own business best. In this sense, an ordinary mechanic is wiser than the philosopher. This way, you can learn something valuable from every person you meet.
IV. Don't limit yourself to just one type of company, or to people from the same party or opinion, whether in matters of learning, religion, or public life. If you were raised or educated with early misconceptions, sticking only to people who share those same views will simply confirm and strengthen those misconceptions. A free and wide-ranging conversation with people from various countries and different parties, opinions, and practices (as far as can be done safely) is extremely useful for correcting many wrong judgments we may have formed and leading us toward more accurate thinking. The story goes that when the King of Siam, near China, first met some European merchants who wanted permission to trade on his coast, he asked them about the common features of summer and winter in their country. When they told him about water growing so hard in their rivers that people, horses, and loaded carriages could cross over it, and that rain sometimes fell as white and light as feathers, and sometimes almost as hard as stones, he refused to believe a word they said. Ice, snow, and hail were names and things completely unknown to him and his subjects in that hot climate. He cut off all dealings with such shameful liars and wouldn't allow them to trade with his people. Here you see the natural effects of profound ignorance.
Talking with people from different backgrounds and places has a wonderful way of broadening our perspective and freeing us from the errors and crude prejudices we're prone to develop about them. Take Domicillus, who has never traveled five miles from his mother's house: he imagines all foreigners are Catholics who worship nothing but a cross. Or consider Tityrus the shepherd, who spent his entire life in the countryside and never saw Rome. He assumed it was just an oversized village, so he was utterly astonished when his first trip to the city revealed such palaces, such streets, such glittering treasures and dazzling splendor. In wonder, he admits his foolishness and mistake.
Virgil introduces us to a poor shepherd who says, Urbem quam dicunt Romam, Meliboe, putavi / Stultus ego huic nostrae similem, quo saepe solemus / Pastores ovium teneros depellere foetus (the city they call Rome, Meliboeus, I thought in my foolishness was like our own, where we shepherds often drive our tender lambs).
Here's the English version:
Fool that I was! I thought imperial Rome Like market-towns, where once a week we come, And thither drive our tender lambs from home.
Conversation would have given Tityrus a better understanding of Rome, even if he had never actually traveled there.
V. When you're in mixed company with both acquaintances and strangers, try to learn something from everyone. Be quick to listen, but careful with your words, or you'll reveal your ignorance and possibly offend someone present. Scripture harshly criticizes those who speak badly of things they don't understand. Make it a point, then, to occasionally spend time with people and groups far removed from your usual life and habits. This is how you can develop wiser judgments about people and ideas. "Prove all things, and hold fast that which is good" is a divine principle, coming from the Father of light and truth. Young people, however, should practice this with proper limits and under the guidance of their elders.
VI. Don't let opinions different from your own frighten or anger you. Some people are so convinced they're right that they refuse to listen to any ideas but their own: they carve out a tiny corner in the world of thought where they believe the light shines, and everything else is darkness. They never venture into the vast ocean of knowledge or explore the riches in other people's minds, which may be just as solid and useful, and perhaps even more valuable, than anything they've ever possessed. Don't assume that the only reliable truth exists in the fields you study or among the group you were born and raised in.
VII. Accept that you can learn something from people far below your level. We're all shortsighted creatures: our perspectives are narrow and limited. We often see only one side of an issue and don't look far or wide enough to grasp everything connected to what we're discussing. We see only in part and know only in part, so it's no surprise we don't always reach the right conclusions, because we never survey the whole of any subject or argument. Even the proudest person, most impressed with his own abilities, might find it useful to consult with others who have less capacity and insight. We get different views of the same thing (if I can put it that way) depending on how our minds are positioned toward it: a less capable person may sometimes stumble on ideas that escaped someone wiser, ideas that the wiser person could put to excellent use if he would humble himself enough to notice them.
VIII. When you're working through a difficult intellectual problem, it helps enormously to have a network of thoughtful correspondents you can turn to. Everyone brings a different perspective and way of thinking, which means the question you're wrestling with gets examined from every angle. You'll see it in all its forms, from every side, and that leads to better judgment.
IX. To make conversation more valuable and useful (whether during a planned visit or a chance encounter, and whether among people of the same sex or mixed company), try this: after you've finished the initial greetings and the flow of small talk starts to falter or run dry, have someone pick up a book that everyone would find interesting. With everyone's agreement, let that person read ten lines, a paragraph or two, or a few pages until some word or sentence sparks a thought in someone. Don't worry about interrupting the reader: conversation is the whole point. Someone might confirm what the author says, or build on it, expand it, correct it, argue against it, or ask a related question. Let everyone who wants to contribute add their thoughts and keep the discussion going. When the conversation dies down again or drifts into trivialities, the reader can pick up where they left off and continue with more paragraphs or pages until another word or sentence launches a new discussion, all with complete ease and freedom. This approach would keep a visit from being completely wasted. Even among scholars, it would rarely give anyone reason for that all too accurate and bitter complaint: "I've wasted my time in the company of the learned."
Young women can use this practice to spend their time honorably and pleasantly. While one reads aloud, the others can focus on their needlework, but everyone should contribute observations or questions as they occur. This approach protects much of that valuable time from fashionable gossip, trivial chatter, or malicious talk that might later cause painful regret.
Follow this general rule: whenever you have the chance to guide the conversation, steer it toward some useful topic of knowledge or practice, as far as good manners allow. Don't let the discussion and the hours drift aimlessly without purpose or direction. When someone raises a subject, don't jump hastily to another before you've brought the current topic to some reasonable conclusion, or everyone agrees to move on.
X. Listen with genuine attention while anyone in the group is expressing their view on the question at hand. Hear their argument patiently, even if it differs greatly from your own opinion, because you yourself want others to hear you patiently when you disagree with them. Don't spend the whole time actively searching for something to contradict or planning how to oppose the speaker, especially on matters that haven't been fully explored. This is a common and unfortunate habit. Instead, you should focus intently on grasping the speaker's mind and meaning, eager to recognize and affirm whatever is true in what they say. You shouldn't lack the courage to disagree when necessary, but let your modesty, patience, and friendly spirit be just as visible as your passion for truth.
XI. When someone speaks freely and naturally, expressing their views in straightforward, everyday language, don't assume you have nothing to learn from them. You'll sometimes encounter a person who, whether in conversation or writing, presents their thoughts in such a plain, effortless, and clear way that you understand and agree with everything as soon as you read or hear it. This can lead some listeners to jump to conclusions: "This person is only saying obvious things. I already knew all this, or I could have said it myself." This is a common error. Pellucido was a brilliant mind. When he spoke in the senate, he had a gift for conveying his ideas so simply and effectively that he instructed and persuaded every listener, carrying the entire distinguished assembly with him. He did this with such clarity that you might have wondered why everyone else hadn't said the same things. But Pellucido was the only one who could do it: the only speaker who had mastered this skill and earned this distinction. Horace would describe such a writer this way: "So that anyone might hope to do the same; but let him try, and he will sweat and labor in vain, though he dares to attempt it" (De Art. Poet.).
Your style should be smooth, plain, and natural, To reach both common folk and those in power. While others think this easy to achieve, Let them just try, and with their greatest effort They'll sweat and strain to imitate without success.
XII. If something in your companion's remarks seems unclear and you can't quite grasp what's being said, try to gain a better understanding by asking politely. Don't accuse the speaker of being obscure in either meaning or expression. Instead, ask for their help in overcoming your own difficulty in understanding, or request a clarifying word or two so you can fully grasp their meaning.
If you find yourself disagreeing with what someone has said, try framing your objection as something "some people might say" rather than presenting it as your own contradiction. This approach comes across as more modest and respectful than directly opposing the speaker.
XIII. When you must disagree with someone's position, start by highlighting where you do agree and show how much common ground you share. If possible, interpret their words in a way that lets you generally accept what they're saying. Or show how a small adjustment or addition to their view would bring you closer together. A fair-minded listener takes pleasure in demonstrating how reluctant they are to disagree. Let the speaker know that only your commitment to truth forces you to oppose them, and express that difference using as few words as possible, chosen carefully to give the least offense.
Always remember Solomon's advice and let the other person finish speaking before you respond: "He who answers a matter before he hears it, it is folly and shame to him" (Prov 18:13).
A little attention, care, and practice early in life will make all these habits easier and more natural to you until they become second nature.
XIV. Just as you should maintain a genuine awareness of your own ignorance, you shouldn't be afraid or embarrassed to admit it by asking questions whenever appropriate. Whether you need to understand the meaning of a word, the nature of something, the reason behind a claim, or the customs of a culture, never stay ignorant simply because you were too hesitant to ask.
Many people would have reached a much higher level of knowledge if they hadn't been so full of themselves, imagining they already knew enough, or if they hadn't been too embarrassed to admit their ignorance to others. Both God and other people are ready to teach those who are humble and willing to learn. But someone who thinks he already knows a subject well, or who won't risk asking a question about it, will never put himself in a position to improve through inquiry and effort. A fool may be "wiser in his own conceit than ten men who can render a reason," and such a person is likely to remain a fool forever. Perhaps it's a foolish sense of shame that makes his ignorance incurable.
The poet Horace wrote: foolish shame hides the wounds of fools, leaving them untreated (Stultorum incurata pudor malus ulcera celat, Epistle 16, Book 1).
In English:
If fools have ulcers, and their pride conceals them, They must have ulcers still, for none can heal them.
XV. Don't be too quick, especially when you're young, to settle any question in conversation with an absolute and final judgment. Don't speak with an arrogant attitude or in a tone that brooks no disagreement. A young man in the presence of his elders should listen carefully and weigh the arguments offered for or against any uncertain proposition. When it's your turn to speak, present your thoughts more as questions than as declarations. This approach will keep your mind in a better state to receive truth, and you'll be more willing to correct and refine your own ideas when you haven't been too dogmatic in stating them. But if you've pronounced your verdict like a judge, you'll find yourself secretly reluctant to back down, even when you feel an inner conviction that you were wrong.
XVI. I'll admit that sometimes a bold pretender to knowledge may adopt arrogant and dogmatic airs to assert and defend a gross and dangerous error, or to reject and attack some very important truth. If he has a popular talent for speaking, and no one challenges him, the company may be too easily tempted to accept the recklessness and supposed infallibility of this presumptuous person. They may imagine that a proposition so thoroughly attacked can never be true, and that a doctrine so boldly criticized and rejected can never be defended. Weak minds are too ready to convince themselves that a man would never speak with such confidence unless he were certainly right and could easily maintain and prove what he said. In this way, truth itself is in danger of being betrayed or lost if no one opposes such a pretentious talker.
In such a case, even a wise and modest person may adopt strong airs too, and repel insolence with its own weapons. There is a time, as Solomon, the wisest of men, teaches us, when a fool should be answered according to his folly, lest he become wise in his own eyes, and lest others too easily surrender their faith and reason to his imperious dictates. Courage and confidence are never more necessary than on such an occasion. But it's good to combine them with some argument of real and convincing force, and let it be strongly pronounced too.
When you push back like this, you'll find that some of these bold talkers will back down once their fierce but weak attacks on truth and reason meet with equal force and confidence. It's unfortunate that truth should ever need this kind of defense, but we know that a triumphant assurance has sometimes propped up complete falsehoods, and entire groups have been captured by error this way, until someone with equal assurance rescued them. It's a shame when any important point of doctrine falls under such attacks and requires this kind of defense: though if I happen to hear it, I shouldn't turn my back and slink away in silence, leaving the truth to lie defeated, bleeding, and dead. Yet I must admit, I'd be happy never to have occasion to fight anyone with these kinds of weapons, even if I were fortunate enough to silence his insolence and win a clear victory.
XVII. Don't be eager to debate everything from both sides, and don't indulge yourself by showing off your talent for attacking and defending. A logic that teaches nothing else is hardly worth anything. This attitude and practice will lead you away from knowledge and divert you from honestly seeking the truth that's being debated or investigated. In formal disputes, people often grab at every little straw to support their own position; everything that can be twisted in any way to give color to their argument gets advanced, often with vanity and showmanship. This puts the mind in the wrong position to seek and receive the truth.
XVIII. Don't bring heated partisan feelings into an open conversation meant for mutual growth in seeking truth. Be careful not to fall into that self-satisfied certainty that keeps your mind locked tight against any new ideas. Keep yourself ready to listen to fresh insights, always remembering that we're fallible and incomplete in our current understanding. Show your friends that it's not hard for you to learn and say those simple words, "I was mistaken," however difficult most people find them to say.
XIX. Sometimes you might ask questions to learn something yourself and draw out the knowledge, wisdom, and thoughtful ideas of your friends who might be too reserved or modest to share freely. At other times, if you notice someone struggling with a debate, you can use well-chosen questions in the Socratic style to guide them toward a clearer understanding of the topic. This way you become their teacher without appearing to set yourself above them.
XX. Be careful not to always try to outshine everyone else in a group or show off your intelligence or eloquence, as if you want everyone present to admire you. This rarely goes over well in polite company. Even worse would be using language that suggests the people you're talking with are ignorant or slow.
XXI. Even if you don't want to deliver long, elaborate speeches in conversation, you shouldn't rudely cut off or criticize someone who does speak that way. Instead, when they finish, try restating their main points more concisely. Don't act like you're correcting them; present it as if you're checking whether you understood them correctly. This approach can help bring a rambling discussion into sharper focus, resolve questions more quickly, and clear up confusion more easily.
XXII. Don't be so quick to accuse others of ignorance, bias, or error when you should be questioning yourself first. To prove you're truly free from prejudice, learn to handle disagreement calmly. Make it easy for yourself to hear your own views strongly challenged, especially on matters that are genuinely debatable among reasonable, thoughtful people. Listen patiently to arguments from all sides. Otherwise, you give everyone reason to suspect that you didn't arrive at your opinion through careful reasoning, but through lazy assumptions, cherished biases, or stubborn loyalty to a position you've held too long and don't want disturbed. If your beliefs rest on solid, sufficient evidence, why would you be afraid to let the truth stand up to scrutiny?
XXIII. Remove completely from all conversation, and especially from intellectual discussion, anything that stirs up anger or heats the blood. Don't allow sharp language, loud outbursts, sarcasm, or cutting jokes. Don't draw hostile conclusions from someone's opinions and then attack them personally. Don't deliberately twist another person's meaning. Don't pounce on a verbal slip to mock it, and don't misinterpret an innocent mistake. When a modest opponent begins to concede, don't let your words insult them. Don't gloat or celebrate victory, even when you've clearly won. All these behaviors destroy friendship and ruin open conversation. The unbiased search for truth requires complete calm and peace, along with self-control and fairness. No one can learn from each other in the middle of anger, pride, and shouting, unless we imagine that such a scene itself teaches a loud and clear lesson about the foolishness and shameful weaknesses of human nature.
XXIV. Therefore, whenever an unfortunate word arises in company that might reasonably offend you, suppress your rising anger, no matter how justified it may be. Command your mind and your tongue into silence, or you'll destroy any hope of learning for that hour and turn intellectual conversation into common insults and abuse. The person who first broke the peace in such a gathering will feel the shame and conviction of your silent rebuke, if he has any decency in him. If that isn't enough, let a serious warning, or a gentle touch of wit delivered pleasantly, give the heated debater a chance to stop his inappropriate fire, if not to take back the offense and put out the flame entirely.
XXV. Train yourself to be gracious and accommodating in all your conversations, and learn the art of engaging communication, whether you're teaching or learning, challenging or defending. This kind of social skill only comes through careful attention to guidelines like these and regular practice.
XXVI. If you want to know what kind of companions to choose for intellectual growth, here's the general rule: select people who can help you improve, whether through their sharp minds and dedication to study, their advanced learning, or their exceptional skill in any field, whether sacred or secular. Always pay attention to their moral character, though. Don't wander off in search of intellectual gain only to fall into the trap of irreligion and vice. No sensible person would walk into a plague-infected house just to see the finest art collection in Europe.
XXVII. Not every respectable person you know, and not even every brilliant or learned person, makes a good partner for serious intellectual discussion. No matter how impressive someone's abilities, they're not suitable for this purpose if they suffer from any of these problems.
1. If they're extremely reserved and either have no interest in discussion or lack the basic ability to express their thoughts clearly.
2. If they're arrogant about their knowledge, domineering in their manner, and always trying to force their opinions on everyone else.
3. If they're stubborn and dogmatic about their own views and will argue endlessly. If they'll resist the clearest evidence of truth rather than admit they're wrong, or refuse to accept even the most obvious and compelling reasoning.
4. If he's someone who always tries to outshine everyone else and loves to hear himself talk, delivering long speeches on every subject while everyone else has to sit quietly and listen.
5. If he has an unsteady, flighty mind and can't stick to the point of an argument, constantly wandering off topic and always anxious to say something, whether it's relevant or not. 6. If he's irritable and touchy, easily offended by everything: if he can't handle being contradicted, or tends to take things the wrong way; if he's quick to feel insulted or imagine he's been attacked, and then either explodes in anger or nurses a silent, bitter grudge.
7. If he tries to be clever all the time and fills every conversation with wordplay, puns, jokes, and witty comebacks: these things might make for an entertaining hour of fun, but they have no place in a serious search for truth.
8. If he always seems calculating, manipulative, and secretive, acting more like a spy than a friend. Watch out for someone who will twist your honest conversation against you and immediately accuse you of heresy when you happen to disagree with whatever beliefs authority or tradition has made standard.
In short, you should avoid anyone in these focused conversations who does anything inconsistent with being a sincere, free, and honest seeker of truth.
Now, even though you should fulfill all your social obligations toward people with these unfortunate traits and treat them with the decency and love that religion and basic humanity require, be careful not to enter into free-ranging debates about truth and falsehood in their presence, especially when it comes to religious principles. I'll admit that if someone with this kind of temperament happens to think and speak well on a subject, you can listen attentively and draw whatever benefit you can from what they say. But such a person should never be your first choice for an open discussion about matters of learning and knowledge.
XXVIII. While I'm urging you to be cautious around such people and avoid too much open conversation with them, it naturally follows that you should also watch for these same negative qualities emerging in yourself, if you happen to be infected with any of them. Learned and intelligent people will rightly avoid your company when they discover such an unfortunate and antisocial temperament dominating your personality.
XXIX. Finally, when you leave company and find yourself alone, take time to reflect and ask yourself what you've learned that might improve your understanding, correct your attitudes, increase your virtues, or better your conduct and behavior in any future situation. If you've observed some of your companions being open-minded, modest, and humble in their manner, wise and perceptive, just and devout in their views, polite and graceful as well as clear and forceful in their speech, and universally likable and admirable in their behavior, work to impress the image of all these qualities on your memory and store them up for your own imitation.
If the standards of reason, decency, and civility haven't been well maintained among your companions, take note of those failures for your own growth. From every instance like this, find something to either imitate or avoid in elegant, polite, and useful conversation. You may discover that some people present have genuinely annoyed the group by trying too hard and too obviously to please (that is, by indulging in servile flattery or indiscriminate praise), while others were just as quick to oppose and contradict everything that was said. Some have earned justified criticism for a sullen and affected silence, while others have been anxious and worried that their silence might be interpreted as a lack of intelligence, and so they've risked making speeches even though they had nothing worth hearing to say. You might observe that one person was clever in his thoughts and brilliant in his language, but he was so full of himself that he spilled it all over the company: he spoke well, certainly, but he spoke too long and didn't allow equal freedom or time to his companions. You'll notice that another was fully loaded and ready to let out his words before his friend had finished speaking, or impatient with the slightest opposition to anything he said. You'll remember that some people have talked at length, and with great confidence, about things they didn't understand, and others found everything tedious and intolerable that was spoken on subjects outside their sphere, and they would have preferred to confine the conversation entirely within the limits of their own narrow knowledge and study. The errors of conversation are almost infinite.
XXXI. By reviewing these kinds of mistakes, you can learn to avoid the foolish behaviors that ruin good conversation or make it less pleasant and useful. Gradually, you'll develop that delightful and natural way of speaking and acting in all worthwhile interactions, making your company desired and loved everywhere. At the same time, among your best companions, you can achieve the highest improvement in your own intellectual growth that conversation with mortal beings allows, despite all the disadvantages we face in this miserable mortal state. But a day is coming when we'll be taken from this lower class in the school of knowledge, where we struggle under so many dangers and darknesses, errors and burdens of flesh and blood, and our conversation will be with angels and more enlightened spirits in the upper regions of the universe.
CHAPTER 10
HANDLING DISAGREEMENTS AND DEBATES
1. Under the general topic of conversation for improving the mind, we should include the practice of disputing: when two or more people appear to hold different views and defend their own or oppose the other's opinion through back-and-forth argument.
II. These disputes often arise in earnest, where the two opponents genuinely believe the different positions they're defending. Sometimes they're arranged as mere tests of skill in academies or schools by students. Sometimes they're practiced, and with apparent passion, in courts of law by lawyers trying to earn fees from their different clients, even though both sides may actually hold the same view about the case being tried.
III. In everyday conversation, arguments often unfold without any formal structure or rules, and they lead to good or bad outcomes depending mainly on the attitudes of the people involved. Sometimes these exchanges successfully uncover truth, sometimes they effectively defend truth and persuade those who are mistaken. But other times, an argument becomes nothing more than a battle for victory and empty bragging rights.
IV. A few general rules should guide all debates if we want to use them to discover truth or show a friend where he's wrong, even when these discussions don't follow any formal debate structure. Since there are nearly as many opinions and judgments about things as there are people, when several people happen to meet and talk about any topic, they naturally share their different views and back them up with whatever reasoning they can muster. This is what we call debating or disputing, as I described above.
V. When people start a debate, they should always make sure they agree on some general principles or statements that relate to the question at hand, whether closely or distantly. Without this agreement, they have no foundation or hope of persuading each other. They need some common ground to stand on while they carry on the contest.
When people discover they agree on some foundational ideas, they should dig deeper and explore how closely their views align on other matters. Whatever points of agreement they find can serve as a foundation for the mutual hope of persuading one another. This approach will keep you from constantly retreating to distant first principles and axioms, a practice that both complicates and drags out any dispute. For example, if a Protestant and a Catholic were debating whether Purgatory exists, they should remember that they both agree on this point: Christ has made satisfaction or atonement for sin. Standing on this common ground, they can then investigate the disputed doctrine of Purgatory through discussion or debate.
VI. You need to strip the question of all unclear terms and unnecessary additions. Everything relevant to the question should be expressed in plain, understandable language. This is so essential that without it, people will find themselves in the kind of absurd arguments that once erupted between two uneducated debaters, Sartor and Sutor. They attacked and defended the doctrine of transubstantiation with tremendous passion and intensity. But when Latino happened upon them and asked what they were arguing about, he inquired what each of them actually meant by that long, difficult word "transubstantiation." Sutor quickly told him that he understood it to mean bowing at the name of Jesus. Sartor, however, insisted that he meant nothing more than bowing at the high altar. "No wonder you can't agree," Latino said, "when you don't understand each other or the word you're fighting about." I think the entire family of tailors and cobblers would be wiser if they avoided such debates until they better understood the terms. But unfortunately, even their wives carry on similar conversations. Just the other day, one was heard in the street explaining to her less educated neighbor the meaning of metaphysical science. She assured her that just as physics were medicines for the body, metaphysics were medicines for the soul. Based on this, they proceeded to argue about how far the theologian surpassed the doctor.
Auditum admissi risum teneatis, amici? Ridentem dicere verum quid vetat?
Can it be wrong to repeat A dialogue that walked the street? Or can my most serious friends hold back A laugh when they hear such disputes?
VII. When two people are debating, they need to do more than just agree on what the words in the question mean. They also need to pin down exactly what they're arguing about. The question under debate should be clearly limited to its specific scope, or explicitly stated to be taken in its broader sense. For example, if two people are arguing about whether civil government has divine authority or not, they need to clarify what they're actually asking. The question isn't whether God requires monarchy (rule by one person), or a republic (rule by the people), or an aristocracy (rule by a few elites). The question is whether civil government in general, in any form whatsoever, comes from God's will and design. Beyond that, the question needs even more narrowing. The real issue isn't whether government comes from God's will through divine revelation (everyone agrees on that). The issue is whether it also comes from God's will through natural reason. This kind of specification or limitation of the question keeps the debaters from drifting away from the exact point they're supposed to be discussing.
This annoying habit (or dishonest trick) of changing the question and wandering away from the original point of debate is what makes arguments drag on forever and leaves both sides dissatisfied when they finally quit. And here's the main reason it happens: when one of the fighters feels his position weakening and failing, when he's about to be proven wrong and demolished, he's tempted to sidestep the blow and shift to a different question. If his opponent doesn't catch on, he starts digging in at this new position and continues the fight with a whole new arsenal of ideas and arguments. The root of this problem is human pride and an unwillingness to give up our own opinions, even when truth itself is beating us down.
VIII. Keep this always in mind as an everlasting rule of conduct in your debates to find truth: a determined desire, or even a strong craving for victory, is the death of all real improvement and an effective barrier against admitting the truth you claim to seek. This works with a secret but powerful and harmful influence in every dispute, unless we stay very much on our guard. It appears in frequent conversation. Every age, every sex, and each party of mankind is so fond of being right that they don't know how to give up this unfortunate prejudice, this vain love of victory.
When truth with bright evidence is ready to break in on a debater and overcome his objections and mistakes, how swift and ready is the mind to engage wit and imagination, craft and subtlety, to cloud and perplex and puzzle the truth if possible! How eager he is to throw in some irrelevant question to divert from the main subject! How swift to seize on some passing word, thereby leading the discussion away from the point at hand! Human nature is so afraid of parting with its errors and being overcome by truth. Just as a hunted hare calls up all the tricks that nature has taught her: she treads back her mazes, crosses and confounds her former track, and uses every possible method to divert the scent when she is in danger of being seized and taken. Let the hare practice what nature teaches, but would anyone imagine that any rational being should take such pains to avoid truth and to escape the improvement of its understanding?
IX. When you enter a debate to discover the truth, don't assume you already possess it. Go into the discussion genuinely willing to accept reason, whichever side it supports. Don't use clever tricks to confuse and complicate the issue. Don't hide behind vague words and phrases. Don't resort to evasions and dodges to escape the force of an argument. Instead, take genuine pleasure in spotting the first glimmers of truth, even when they appear on your opponent's side. Work to clear away whatever small obscurities surround it, and allow it (even encourage it) to emerge into open and convincing light. That way, while your opponent may win the argument, you yourself will triumph over error: and I'm certain that's a far more valuable prize and victory.
X. In any debate, watch carefully to make sure your opponent doesn't trick you into accepting some principle or proposition that carries a fatal consequence, drawing you unknowingly into his position even though it strays far from the truth. One wrong step like this can plunge you into dangerous errors before you realize what's happening. In casual conversation, Polonides led Incauto to agree with him on this seemingly straightforward proposition: that God has too much justice to ever punish any being who is itself innocent. Incauto not only accepted this without thinking but asserted it in the most sweeping and unqualified terms. A little later, Polonides began praising the virtues, innocence, and piety of our blessed Savior, and from this he concluded that it was impossible for God to ever punish such a holy person who had never committed any crime. Then Incauto saw the trap and realized he had been robbed of the great doctrine of the atonement through Christ's death, on which he had placed his eternal hopes according to the gospel. This taught him what a dangerous concession he had made in such universal terms: that God would never punish any innocent being. He saw that he needed to take back his words, or at least explain them better, by adding this restriction or qualification: unless this innocent being were somehow involved in another's sin, or stood as a voluntary substitute for the guilty. With this qualification he protected the great and blessed doctrine of Christ's sacrifice for human sins, and learned to be more careful about what he conceded in the future.
Two months ago, Fatalio nearly convinced his friend Fidens to stop praying and to give up trusting in God's providence for everyday matters by getting him to make a similar concession. Fatalio argued: Isn't it obvious to reason that God's immense plan for the universe was designed and settled long before you and I were born? Can you really imagine, my dear Fidens, that the blessed God alters his original plans and constantly interrupts their course whenever you and I need his help to prevent or protect us from life's minor mishaps? Can you honestly believe that the great Creator of this world takes care to hold up a completely rotten bridge, keeping it standing just a few minutes longer until you've ridden across it? Or will he prop up a collapsing tower while the two of us are walking past it, just so insignificant creatures like you and me can escape the disaster?
But you say you prayed for his protection in the morning, and he certainly hears prayer. I grant that he knows about it: but are you so foolish and naive, Fatalio asked, as to think that the universal Lord of everything cared so much about a few words from your lips that he would alter his own eternal plan on that account? And there's no other way his providence could protect you in response to prayer except by creating constant interruptions and changes in his own conduct based on your daily behavior.
I admit, Fidens said, there's no other way to maintain the doctrine of divine providence in all these everyday matters. So I'm starting to doubt whether God actually does, or ever will, involve himself so specifically in our small concerns.
Be careful, Fidens, that you don't concede too much ground here. Watch out, or you'll have given Fatalio more than you should. Let me ask you this: couldn't the great God, who grasps and surveys all future and distant events in a single view, couldn't He have foreseen from the very beginning your morning prayer for His protection and arranged all secondary causes to work together to support that rickety bridge or keep that old tower standing firm until you had passed safely by?
Or couldn't He cause all the intermediate factors to work in such a way that the tower would fall before you came anywhere near it? Can't He arrange all His own transactions in the universe, and every event in the natural world, in a way that corresponds perfectly with His own foreknowledge of all the events, actions, and developments of the moral world in every part of it? Can't He direct everything in nature (which is merely His servant) to act in perfect agreement with His eternal foreknowledge of our sins or our piety? And in this way, all the glory of providence and our necessary dependence on it through faith and prayer are just as well secured as if He stepped in to alter His own plan every moment.
Let me ask again: didn't God in His own counsels or decrees appoint thunders and lightnings and earthquakes to burn up and destroy Sodom and Gomorrah, turning them into a dead sea, precisely when the wickedness of those cities reached its peak? Didn't He ordain the fountains of the deep to break open and overwhelming rains to fall from heaven exactly when a guilty world deserved to be drowned, while He took care to secure righteous Noah by means of an ark that would float on that very flood of waters? In this way He can punish the criminal when He pleases and reward the devout worshipper at the proper time through His original and eternal plans, just as effectively as if He intervened anew every moment. Be careful, Fidens, that you aren't tempted away by such sophisms from Fatalio to stop praying to God and to abandon your faith in His providence.
Remember this short and simple warning about the subtle errors of men. Let a snake thrust its head through even one small unguarded fold of your garment, and it will gradually and inevitably wind its whole body into your chest and deliver a deadly wound.
XI. On the other hand, when your opponent makes a concession that could help you defend the truth, be wise and alert enough to notice it, and use it to good effect. Rhapsodus has worked hard to undermine Christianity's reputation through subtle suggestions that the biblical writers constantly promote virtue and godliness through promises and threats. He argues that neither fear of future punishment nor hope of future reward can be called good motives, or the kind that produce genuinely good actions. He goes further, claiming that such fear or hope is actually incompatible with true virtue or goodness if it forms an essential part of any moral act or serves as a significant motive for any good deed. In this way, he wants Christians to feel embarrassed about the gospel of Christ because of its eternal promises and threats, which he sees as inconsistent with his concept of virtue. He believes virtue should be loved and practiced purely for its own beauty and appeal, and that any other motives based on rewards or punishments, fear or hope, diminish the very nature of virtue to the extent they influence us. According to him, only those good practices that arise from pure love of virtue itself, without any thought of punishment or reward, have real value.
But notice that just two pages later, he admits something important: this principle of fearing future punishment and hoping for future reward, however mercenary and servile it might seem, actually provides great advantage, security, and support to virtue in many situations, especially when violent rage or lust, or any other opposing passion, threatens to overpower the good inclinations of the mind.
Here's the problem: Christianity's rules and practices, especially when tied to eternal rewards and punishments, can be defended quite easily with this admission. Tell me, Rhapsodus, isn't it true that every person in this life can have their good impulses toward virtue controlled or overpowered by some violent opposing passion? Doesn't that mean eternal fears and hopes could provide a huge advantage, a security and support for virtue during such a dangerous journey as our passage through this world toward a better one? That's all the defense of Christianity really needs.
But let me push this further, my rhapsodist friend. If all you have to work with is the beauty, excellence, and loveliness of virtue to preach about and elaborate on before such pathetic and corrupt creatures as most of humanity, and you have no future rewards or punishments to appeal to their hopes and fears, how many of these vicious wretches will you actually reclaim from their endless varieties of profanity, excess, and madness? How many have you personally reclaimed using this smooth, soft method and these fine words? What have all that reasoning and rhetoric accomplished, all those displays by your predecessors the pagan moralists, going on about virtue's excellence and beauty? What has it actually done to reform a sinful world? Perhaps now and then someone with a better natural disposition has been somewhat refined, and perhaps here and there someone has been restrained or recovered from injustice or dishonesty, from drunkenness and sexual immorality and vile debauchery, by this attractive reasoning and philosophy. But have the passions of revenge and envy, of ambition and pride, and the inward secret vices of the mind been killed off merely by this philosophical language? Have any of these people been made into new creatures, people of genuine piety and love for God?
Go ahead and dress up all the virtues of human nature in the most beautiful language you can muster, and preach loudly about the praise of social virtue and the appealing qualities of goodness until your heart or your lungs give out. Do this among the more wayward crowds of humanity, and you will always discover, just as your pagan ancestors did before you, that the wild passions and appetites of people are too violent to be restrained by such mild and gentle words. You might as well build a fence of straw and feathers to stop a cannonball, or try to extinguish a flaming grenade with a splash of clean water, as hope to succeed in these attempts. But an eternal Heaven and an eternal Hell carry divine force and power with them: this teaching, delivered by Christian preachers, has begun the reformation of countless people; this gospel has rescued thousands among the nations from wickedness and death. They have been awakened by these terrifying realities to begin their religious life, and afterward their virtue has improved itself into higher and more refined principles and habits through divine grace, rising to high and outstanding levels, though not to a perfect state. The blessed God understands human nature far better than Rhapsodus does, and has throughout His Word appointed a more suitable and more effective method of reaching it through the emotions of hope and fear, through punishments and rewards.
If you read on four pages further in these writings, you will find the author makes another concession. He allows that the master of a family, using appropriate rewards and gentle punishments toward his children, teaches them goodness, and through this help instructs them in a virtue which they later practice on other grounds, and without thinking of a penalty or a bribe; and this, he says, is what we call a liberal education and a liberal service.
We can also use this new concession from that author to support Christianity quite effectively. What are even the best people like in this life? They're far from perfectly virtuous. We're all just children here in the great master's household, and He's pleased to teach us virtue through hopes and fears, through mercies and corrections, guiding us toward the higher and more perfect practice of it in the future world. There, perhaps (to use his own language), virtue will be performed without thinking of penalties or rewards. And since he's allowed that this approach can be called a liberal education and a liberal service, let's grant Christianity the same title of liberal education. It's perfectly suited for frail and sinful creatures like us while we're being trained toward the higher virtues of the heavenly state.
XII. When you're in a debate with someone whose principles differ greatly from yours, and you can't find an easy way to persuade him to accept the truth using principles you both freely acknowledge, you can fairly use his own principles to show him his mistake. This way you can convince or silence him using his own concessions.
If your opponent happens to be a Stoic philosopher or a Jew, you can defend a Christian doctrine or duty by using principles drawn from either Zeno or Moses. You don't need to investigate how many of Moses's laws have been abolished, or whether Zeno's philosophy was correct. If you can support your argument for the gospel of Christ using your opponent's own principles and concessions, this has always been considered a fair way to treat an adversary. This approach is called argumentum ad hominem, or ratio ex concessis. Paul sometimes uses this kind of argument when he talks with Jews or pagan philosophers, and he ultimately silences them, if not convinces them. This is sometimes necessary when dealing with an obstinate and loud adversary, so that proper honor can be given to truths he knew were divine, and so that the only true doctrine of salvation might be confirmed and spread among sinful and dying people.
XIII. Yet you must be very careful not to let your debates stir up your passions and draw them into the controversy. When your opponent presses hard and delivers serious, fatal blows to your own opinions, your passions are likely to feel the impact and rise up in resentment and defense. The self becomes so entangled with the views we've chosen, and feels so acutely any opposition to them, that personal quarrels are quick to step in as reinforcements, taking over and finishing what began as a dispute about ideas. Then noise, shouting, and foolishness appear in all their forms, driving reason and truth completely out of sight.
How miserable is the condition of weak and fallen humanity in this shadowy state of powerful emotions and dim reason? When our passions get involved in an argument, how quick we are to think about what nonsense and insults we can heap on our opponent rather than what reason and truth actually demand in the controversy itself? The consequences of this evil principle are disastrous, and humanity suffers from them far too often. This common and dangerous practice pulls the heart away from everything fair and honest in our search for truth or in spreading it throughout the world. One would wish with all one's soul that none of the Christian fathers had been guilty of such foolishness. But St. Jerome openly admits this evil principle in his apology to Pammachius, saying that in his controversy he had not focused so much on what should actually be said as on what would burden Jovinian with accusations. And I'm afraid this was the vile habit of many writers dealing with church matters in those times. But it will be doubly scandalous for us in our more enlightened age if we allow ourselves such criminal and dishonest conduct. Happy are those souls who maintain such sacred control over their lower and animal impulses, and over all the influences of pride and worldly interest, that these emotional upheavals or vicious influences never rise up to disturb the superior and better operations of the reasoning mind!
XIV. These general guidelines are necessary, or at least useful, in all debates whatsoever, whether they arise in casual conversation or are scheduled for a specific time and place, and whether they are conducted with or without any formal rules to govern them. But there are three kinds of disputation in which certain forms and procedures are observed, and which are distinguished by these three names: Socratic, Forensic, and Academic (that is, the disputes of the schools).
I should say a few words about each of these methods and offer some specific guidance and observations.
CHAPTER 11
THE SOCRATIC METHOD
1. This approach to debate takes its name from Socrates, who used it regularly, as did other philosophers of his time, long before Aristotle invented the specific forms of syllogism (organized by mood and figure) that are now used in academic debates.
2. The Socratic method works through questions and answers, something like this: If I wanted to convince someone that heaven and hell exist, or that there's a future state of rewards and punishments, I might start with this kind of inquiry, assuming the most obvious and straightforward answers.
Q. Doesn't God govern the world? A. Surely the one who made it governs it. Q. Isn't God both good and just as a governor? A. Both qualities certainly belong to Him. Q. What does it really mean to be a good and just governor? A. It means He punishes the wicked and rewards the good. Q. Are good people always rewarded in this life? A. Certainly not. Many virtuous people are miserable here and suffer greatly. Q. Are wicked people always punished in this life? A. Definitely not. Many of them live without sorrow, and some of the worst people often gain great wealth and honor. Q. How then does God show that He is good and just? A. I admit there's little evidence of it on earth.
Q. Won't there be a time when the tables turn and the situation reverses, since God governs humanity justly?
A. There must be an appropriate time when God will demonstrate that goodness and justice.
Q. If this doesn't happen before death, how can it be done?
A. I can't think of any other way except by assuming that people have some existence after this life.
Q. Aren't you convinced, then, that there must be a state of reward and punishment after death?
A. Absolutely. I now see clearly that God's goodness and righteousness as governor of the world necessarily require it.
III. The advantages of this method are substantial.
1. It takes the form of a dialogue or ordinary conversation, which is a much easier, more pleasant, and more lively way of teaching. It's better suited to capture the learner's attention and sharpen their thinking than solitary reading or silent listening to a lecture. Since we're social creatures by nature, we enjoy conversation more and learn better this way, provided it's done skillfully.
2. This method has something very appealing about it and comes across as humble and gracious, especially when the instructor seems to be the one asking questions and seeking information from the student.
3. It leads the learner to discover truth almost as if by their own invention, which is deeply satisfying to human nature. Through carefully and skillfully posed questions, it just as effectively draws them to recognize their own mistakes, which they're much more willing to abandon when they feel they've discovered the errors themselves.
4. It operates largely through the simplest form of reasoning, always building on something affirmed or established in the previous answer, then proceeding to explore something unknown in the next question, which in turn sets up the following answer. This kind of exercise is highly attractive and engaging to the mind, since its own reasoning powers are constantly at work, and without strain or difficulty, because the questioner identifies and presents all the connecting ideas or middle terms.
IV. There's a closely related method that has become quite popular lately: writing controversies using only questions, or confirming or refuting any position, or persuading people toward or away from any practice, by simply proposing queries. The answer to them is assumed to be so obvious and so inevitable that it doesn't need to be stated, because the query itself carries a convincing argument and seems to determine what the answer must be.
V. If Christian catechisms could be structured like a Socratic dialogue through question and answer, it would wonderfully enlighten children's minds and improve their intellectual and reasoning abilities while simultaneously teaching them about religion. This approach works particularly well for children's capacity in one respect: the questions can be fairly numerous, and the questioner doesn't need to rush toward the conclusion of his proposed point. This allows him to draw the learner on more easily, with clearer evidence and more certain success, to accept those principles step by step, from which the final conclusion will naturally emerge. The only drawback would be this: if children had to reason their way entirely through every part of their religion, it would expand ordinary catechisms into volumes too large for their available time, attention, or memory.
Yet those who explain catechisms to them can, with proper effort and planning, teach them in this manner.
CHAPTER 12
FORMAL AND LEGAL DEBATES
I. The forum was a public place in Rome where lawyers and orators delivered their speeches before the appropriate judge in matters of property or criminal cases, to accuse or excuse, to complain or defend. From this, all kinds of public debates in assemblies or courts of justice, where different people make their separate speeches for or against any person or thing whatsoever (but especially in civil matters), can fall under the name of forensic disputes.
II. This practice isn't limited to courtrooms, where a single judge evaluates the merits of a case and decides based on the weight of arguments from both sides. It's also used in political legislatures, church councils, and various other assemblies.
In these gatherings, one person is typically chosen as chairman or moderator, not to settle the dispute, but mainly to ensure that speakers follow proper rules of order and decorum. The final decision on any question comes from the majority of opinions or votes in the assembly, influenced (or at least ideally influenced) by the stronger reasoning presented in the various speeches.
III. The procedure usually follows a pattern like this. When the session begins, the first speaker presents the case, either briefly or in detail, and lays out the issue before the judge, chairman, or moderator of the assembly. He then gives his own reasons for his position on the matter at hand.
IV. This speaker is followed by one or more others who expand on the same topic and argue for the same side. They reinforce what the first speaker said and add new reasons to support the position. Then those who hold a different view stand up and deliver their speeches in turn, opposing the case that others have defended, presenting their reasons against it, and trying to refute the arguments the earlier speakers used to support it.
V. After this, various people rise to offer their rebuttals, either defending or attacking, supporting or refuting what has been said on each side of the question. Finally, according to the rules, procedures, or customs of the court or assembly, the matter is decided, either by a single judge or by the vote of the assembly.
VI. When a question or debate involves several parts, the first or second speaker usually lays out the whole issue. After that, the speakers who follow often divide up the work: each person takes one particular part of the debate, either by personal preference or by prior agreement, and focuses their arguments on that single point alone. This prevents the entire discussion from descending into confusion when multiple subjects are being handled by every speaker.
VII. Before the final decision is reached, it's customary to have all the reasons and arguments from both sides summarized and presented in a more condensed form. This is typically done by the appointed judge, the chairman, or some respected person in the assembly. The purpose is to ensure that the final judgment rests on the fullest possible view of the entire subject, so that, as far as humanly possible, nothing is decided contrary to truth or justice.
VIII. Since this is a practice that many gentlemen (not just those in the learned professions) may engage in, at least in their mature years, it would be very useful to introduce this custom into our academies. Specifically, tutors could propose cases and let students debate them in a forensic manner under supervision. The Roman youth practiced something similar in their schools to train themselves as orators, both in the forum and in the senate. Perhaps Juvenal hints at this when he says, "and I too gave counsel to Sulla, advising him as a private citizen to sleep soundly" (et nos consilium dedimus Syllæ, privatus ut altum dormiret, Satire 1). Or as the translation puts it: "Where with men-boys I strove to get renown, advising Sylla to a private gown, that he might sleep the sounder." Sometimes these were assigned to boys as single subjects for a theme or declamation. The same poet speaks sarcastically to Hannibal:
I demens, et sævas curre per Alpes, Ut pueris placeas et declamatio fias. Sat. 10. Go climb the rugged Alps, ambitious fool, To please the boys, and be a theme at school.
For more on this subject, see Kennet's Antiquities of Rome, in the second essay on Roman education.
CHAPTER 13
ACADEMIC DEBATE
The standard methods for managing debates in schools of learning are as follows:
I. The tutor assigns a question in one of the sciences to be debated among his students. One student agrees to affirm or deny the question and to defend his position, answering all objections raised against it. This student is called the respondent. The remaining students in the same class, or those studying the same subject, serve as opponents. Their job is to dispute the proposition or raise objections against it.
II. Each student takes a turn as the respondent or defender of the proposition, while the others oppose it, also taking their turns in succession.
III. The respondent must write a thesis in Latin (a short discourse on the assigned question). He either affirms or denies the question according to the tutor's opinion, which is assumed to represent the truth, and he reads this thesis at the start of the debate.
IV. In his discourse (which he writes as carefully as his abilities allow), he explains the terms of the question, removes any ambiguity, establishes their precise meaning, and clarifies the true intent of the question itself. He separates it from other questions that might be tangled up with it and distinguishes it from related questions that might be confused with it. Then he pronounces his affirmative or negative position on it.
V. Once this is done, the respondent moves to the second part of his presentation. Here he offers his strongest arguments to support the proposition he has laid down: in other words, to defend his position on the question. However, he typically does not go on to present objections against his own view or attempt to answer them, since it is the job of the other students to raise those objections during the debate.
VI. Note that in some schools, the respondent is allowed to speak at length about the question, adding elaborate flourishes and illustrations, citing impressive authorities from both ancient and modern writings to support his position, and liberally sprinkling Latin insults on anyone who disagrees. But this practice is not always permitted, nor should it ever be encouraged, since it teaches young people to attack rather than reason.
VII. After the respondent has read his thesis to the class, the most junior student raises an objection, formulating it as a proper syllogism. The respondent repeats the objection back, then either denies the major or minor premise outright, or he makes a distinction about some word or phrase in one of the premises. He shows in what sense the premise might be true, but explains that this sense does not apply to the question at hand. He then declares that in the sense that does apply to the present question, the premise is false, and therefore he denies it.
VIII. The opponent then proceeds with another syllogism to defend the premise that was denied. Again the respondent answers by either denying it or making a distinction.
The debate continues in this way, through a series of syllogisms and answers, until the objector is silenced and has nothing more to say.
IX. When he can go no further, the next student begins to present his objection, followed by the third and fourth, all the way up to the senior student, who is the final opponent.
X. During this time the tutor sits in the chair as president or moderator to ensure that both sides follow the rules of disputation and maintain proper decorum. He warns each disputant about any irregularities in their conduct. His job is also to clarify and explain the respondent's answer or distinction when it's unclear, to strengthen it when it's weak, and to correct it when it's wrong. When the respondent is pressed by a strong objection and can't find an answer, the moderator helps him by suggesting a response to the opponent's objection, defending the question according to his own opinion or judgment.
XI. In public disputes where the opponents and respondents choose their own side of the question, the moderator's job is not to favor either disputant. He simply presides to ensure that the laws of disputation are observed and proper decorum is maintained.
XII. Now the laws of disputation apply either to the opponent or to the respondent, or to both.
The laws binding the opponent are these: 1. He must directly contradict the respondent's proposition, and not merely attack any of the arguments the respondent has used to support that proposition. Refuting a single argument of the respondent is one thing; refuting the thesis itself is another.
2. (This is related to the first law) He must contradict or oppose the very sense and intention of the proposition as the respondent has stated it, and not merely oppose the words of the thesis in some other sense. This would only plunge the dispute into ambiguity and darkness, lead to talking beside the question, wrangling about words, and attacking a proposition different from what the respondent has actually defended (which is called ignoratio elenchi, or ignorance of the refutation).
3. He must present his arguments in a plain, short, and syllogistic form, according to the rules of logic, without resorting to fallacies or sophisms. As far as possible, he should use categorical syllogisms.
4. You can attack a respondent in two ways: by using something they've already conceded (called an argument from concession, or argumentum ex concessis), or by showing their position leads to an absurdity (called reduction to absurdity, or reductio ad absurdum). However, the cleanest, most useful, and best form of debate draws objections directly from the nature of the question itself.
5. When the respondent denies any proposition, the opponent must directly defend and confirm that proposition if he wants to continue. In other words, he must make that proposition the conclusion of his next syllogism.
6. When the respondent qualifies or distinguishes any proposition, the opponent must directly prove his own proposition in the specific sense and according to the particular part of the distinction that the respondent denied.
XIII. The laws that bind the respondent are these: 1. To repeat the opponent's argument in the exact same words it was presented before attempting to answer it.
2. If the syllogism is logically flawed in its form, he must identify the fault according to the rules of logic.
3. If the argument doesn't directly and effectively oppose his thesis, he must point out this mistake and show that his thesis remains secure even if the opponent's argument is accepted. Or at the very least, he must show that the argument only attacks his position indirectly or tangentially, rather than directly overthrowing it or proving it wrong.
4. When any part of the opponent's objection is flawed in substance, the respondent must grant what is true in it, deny what is false, and distinguish or qualify any proposition that is ambiguous or doubtful. Then, after granting the sense in which it is true, he must deny the sense in which it is false.
5. If a hypothetical proposition is false, the respondent must deny the consequence. If a disjunctive proposition is false, he must deny the disjunction. If a categorical or relative proposition is false, he must simply deny it.
6. Sometimes the respondent can use an indirect answer after giving a direct one, and he can also show how the opponent's argument could be turned back against him.
XIV. The rules that bind both disputants are these: 1. Sometimes it's necessary to mention certain general principles that both sides agree on regarding the question, so they don't waste time arguing about things that either are or should have been settled from the start.
2. Once the controversy is clearly understood, defined, and agreed upon, neither disputant should change it during the debate. The respondent especially needs to watch the opponent carefully on this point.
3. Neither party should intrude on the other's role. The respondent particularly should avoid becoming the opponent, except when turning an argument back on his adversary after giving a direct response, and even this is only allowed to illustrate or confirm his own answer.
4. Each person should wait patiently until the other finishes speaking. Interrupting someone while they're talking is rude.
However, while the disputants don't have this freedom, the moderator can interrupt when either disputant breaks the rules, and he can step in as much as necessary to maintain order.
XV. I should acknowledge that academic debate does offer real benefits. It energizes and sharpens the mind, breaking up the monotony of solitary study. It hones your wit and your ability to think creatively. It forces your thoughts into action, sending them in every direction to find arguments and responses for both attack and defense. It gives you the chance to examine a topic from multiple angles and to discover what problems, challenges, and objections surround particular viewpoints. It provides countless opportunities to generate ideas that would never have occurred to you otherwise. It makes a student more skilled at both dismantling errors and defending truths. It teaches you various ways to deflect objections and to identify and expose the clever tricks of sophists. It also develops fluency and ease in speaking, and it builds confidence in those who are naturally modest and hesitant.
XVI. But there are some serious drawbacks that can sometimes outweigh all these benefits. Many young students, through constant practice in debate, become arrogant and reckless, proud and contemptuous, chatty and insufferable. They make themselves unbearable through a stubborn insistence on defending whatever they've said, and through a spirit of contradiction that opposes nearly everything they hear. The debate itself often stirs up ambition, rivalry, and anger. It pulls the mind away from the calm and settled disposition that's so necessary for contemplating truth.
XVII. It's also clear that through repeated exercises of this kind, where true and false opinions are argued, defended, and attacked from both sides, the human mind gradually drifts toward uncertainty and instability. It risks falling into a skeptical mindset that never settles on any firm beliefs. Many people, through this process, become far more skilled at opposing whatever is presented in the search for truth. They barely wait to finish reading or hearing someone's position before their minds start racing to find arguments against it. They develop a natural sharpness for spotting difficulties, and by feeding this habit, they spend so much time dwelling on the dark and doubtful aspects of a subject that they nearly lose the ability to recognize solid evidence for a proposition or acknowledge clear truth. This approach tends to produce a nitpicking critic rather than a thoughtful, discerning person.
XVIII. I would add something more: in these debates, the respondent is usually assigned to defend the supposed truth (that is, the tutor's opinion). Meanwhile, all the opponents are busy and energetically engaged in finding arguments against the truth. Now if a clever young student happens to present his arguments so skillfully that he confuses and stumps the respondent, and perhaps even rattles the moderator a bit, he's quickly tempted to believe his argument is unbeatable and that the truth lies entirely on his side. The satisfaction he feels in having discovered a fallacy that sounds highly reasonable, and which he himself has wielded so successfully, can become a powerful bias. It draws his inner convictions toward his own argument and against the supposed truth.
XIX. Still, it might be possible to set up enough safeguards around academic debates to prevent most of these problems and the unfortunate outcomes that too often result. It would be a shame to completely abandon an exercise that offers real benefits, if we can protect young minds from its misuse. The following guidelines might help with that.
XX. General guidelines for academic debates:
1. Never debate trivial matters or things that are completely useless to know, just to claim you're sharpening your mind. You can get the same benefit from solid, useful topics, and that way you accomplish two worthwhile goals at once. And if these debates are always considered too risky when important matters are at stake, then abandon them entirely.
2. Don't make infinite or unknowable things the subject of debate, or propositions that are just empty words without real meaning. This leads young people into the terrible habit of talking without saying anything, and boldly making pronouncements about things that are barely within human capacity to understand.
3. Don't toss around obvious, well-known truths or clearly certain propositions in a debate just to test your skills. Anyone who argues against them this way risks developing a habit of opposing all evidence, acquiring a spirit of contradiction, and taking pride in their ability to resist the clearest light and fight against the strongest proofs. This gradually damages the mind and leads toward complete skepticism.
Given all this, the most appropriate topics for debate seem to be questions that fall somewhere in the middle: not the most critical and certain truths, nor trivial and insignificant matters, but rather the intermediate questions between these extremes. Fortunately, there are plenty of these in the sciences. However, I'm offering this merely as a suggestion, to be decided by those who are more learned and prudent than I am.
4. Ideally, every debate should be structured as a means of discovering truth, not winning a contest. Then each participant could approach the work without bias or prejudice, motivated by a desire for truth rather than ambition for glory and victory.
The debater's goal shouldn't be to cleverly dodge and escape the difficulties raised by the opponent, but to examine them thoroughly and resolve them fairly, if they can be resolved.
Similarly, the opponent should avoid trying to obscure and confuse the responses given to him with new complications. Instead, he should consider whether they genuinely answer the objection and be honestly willing to recognize and accept them, yielding when appropriate.
5. To achieve this, both the respondent and opponent should use the clearest, most precise, and most expressive language they can to convey their thoughts. Both sides should aim for brevity and clarity, avoiding long speeches, tedious roundabout explanations, and rhetorical embellishments.
If any doubt or obscurity arises on either side, neither party should ever refuse to provide a fair explanation of the words they're using.
6. Students shouldn't indulge in ridicule, whether of people or ideas, during their debates. They should avoid all mockery and jokes, laughter and levity. These things undermine the philosophical seriousness, composure, and calm temperament that should characterize every search for truth. While an argument on certain topics might occasionally benefit from a touch of wit, a joke or clever remark should never substitute for an argument, nor should it ever be allowed to pass as real and solid proof.
This is especially true when the subject is sacred or divine and contains nothing comical or ridiculous. In such cases, all humorous twists and joking or comic attitudes should be completely excluded, so that young minds don't become infected with a foolish and irreverent kind of ridicule, learning to joke and play around with the solemn realities of religion.
7. Similarly, sarcasm and insults, or arrogant language, should never appear among honest debaters. Don't shift from discussing ideas to attacking people. Leave all noisy fights, all shameless shouting, abusive language, and especially all personal slander and vulgarity to the lowest elements of society. Your manner should be all openness and kindness, patient and willing to listen, humbly eager to teach and be taught. You should be relaxed and pleasant in every response and behavior, more like well-mannered gentlemen in polite conversation than like loud and quarrelsome arguers.
8. If your opponent sees that victory is leaning his way, he should be satisfied to demonstrate the strength of his argument to the intelligent members of the audience, without demanding an answer too aggressively or petulantly, and without insulting his opponent or embarrassing the respondent. Similarly, the respondent shouldn't gloat over the opponent when he falls silent and stops replying. Whichever side wins, neither party should behave with such unpleasant and arrogant airs that they awaken destructive emotions like pride, anger, shame, or resentment, which drive the mind away from truth, make it stubborn in defending error, and prevent it from ever abandoning its old opinions.
In short, when truth clearly appears on either side, both parties should learn to yield to conviction. When either party reaches an impasse, they should admit the difficulty and ask for immediate help or more time to think about the matter in private, rather than straining their minds in the moment to invent little tricks for avoiding the force and evidence of truth.
9. Wouldn't it be a safer approach, if we want to achieve the best results from debate while avoiding some of its harmful effects, to sometimes have the opponent argue on the side of truth, presenting arguments against error? And what if the respondent were assigned to defend the error as well as he could, until he was forced to yield at least to those arguments from the opponent that appear genuinely sound, strong, and unanswerable?
In this approach, the respondent's thesis would simply be a fair statement of the question, along with some of the main objections against the truth being proposed, which he would then answer.
Perhaps this method wouldn't be as easily twisted and misused to cultivate a nitpicking, argumentative, and skeptical attitude in young minds.
I'll admit that in the method I'm proposing here, one student (the respondent) would always be defending a supposed error. But all the other students would be exercising their skills by arguing for the supposed truth. In contrast, with the standard methods of academic disputation, especially when there are many students, each individual student spends most of his time opposing the truth and defending error, except for the rare occasions when it's his turn to be the respondent.
10. All things considered, it seems necessary to learn these methods of disputation in school so that students can better defend truth and refute error, both in writing and in conversation, where the formal scholastic structures are completely ignored.
But in the end, the benefit that young people gain from disputations depends heavily on the tutor or moderator. He should manage things with such wisdom, both during the disputation and at its conclusion, that all the participants understand the exact point of controversy and what it consists of. He should expose the fallacies in sophistical objections and reinforce the solid arguments and answers. This could teach students how to make the art of disputation useful for discovering truth and defending it, rather than learning and practicing it merely as an art of arguing for its own sake. That kind of pointless wrangling dominated the schools for several hundred years and robbed the developing minds of young people of their best hopes and potential for growth.
CHAPTER 14
THE ART OF DEEP STUDY AND MEDITATION
1. Earlier chapters have established that no amount of personal observation, reading scholarly works, attending excellent lectures, or engaging in brilliant conversation can make someone truly knowledgeable and wise without using their own reasoning to examine, evaluate, and judge all subjects based on the best evidence available. Natural talent, sharp thinking, sound judgment, a strong memory, and plenty of opportunities to observe and converse will contribute significantly to developing the mind when properly utilized. But when someone combines the benefits of expert lectures, quality teaching, and carefully selected books with hard work and dedicated study, they have every human advantage working together to elevate them to an exceptional level of wisdom and knowledge.
The previous sections have already explained how our own thinking and reflection should examine, develop, and enhance all other methods and opportunities for enriching our understanding. What remains in this chapter is to offer some additional practical guidance on how to direct our own thoughts, what kinds of subjects we should think about, how we should organize our studies, and how we can sharpen our judgment to acquire useful knowledge in the most effective and efficient way possible. This applies to everyone according to their life circumstances, and especially to those pursuing learned professions.
II. The first instruction for young people is this: learn early to distinguish between words and things. Develop clear and concrete ideas about the subjects you're studying. Don't settle for mere words and labels, or your hard-earned progress will only pile up a collection of meaningless phrases, and you'll be feeding on husks instead of kernels. This principle proves invaluable in every field of study.
But the greatest and most common danger lies in the sacred science of theology, where established terms and phrases have been declared divine and orthodox despite being completely meaningless. Medieval scholastic theology provides countless examples of this foolishness. Yet for centuries, all truth and all heresy were determined by such senseless tests and by words without ideas. These shibboleths decided people's earthly fates: bishoprics or burning, mitres or the stake were handed out to different people depending on whether they pronounced these consecrated syllables or refused to do so. Defending them was considered the height of piety, pomp, and triumph. Despising, doubting, or denying them meant torture and death. We owe a thousand thank-offerings to Providence for delivering our age and our nation from these absurd iniquities! If only every trace and shadow of this madness could be banished from our schools and churches in every form!
III. Young students should not try to search out deep, dark, and difficult matters far beyond their reach, or waste their effort on specialized subjects for which they lack the necessary foundational learning, books, or observations. They should not rush to understand things beyond their current abilities, or plunge their inquiries immediately into the depths of knowledge, or begin studying any science in the middle of it. This will confuse rather than enlighten the understanding. Such practices may discourage and exhaust the mind by attempting something beyond its power. They may frustrate the understanding and create an aversion to future diligence, and perhaps through despair may prevent the pursuit of that subject forever afterward. Just as a limb overstrained by lifting too much weight may never recover its former agility and vigor (or if it does, the person may be too frightened to ever exert its strength again), so too can the mind be permanently damaged by premature intellectual strain.
IV. On the other hand, students shouldn't scare themselves at every turn with impossible obstacles or imagine that truth is wrapped up in darkness they can never penetrate. These are frightening illusions that the mind sometimes creates to justify its own laziness. Things that seem obscure and confusing when viewed from a distance can be approached through gentle, systematic steps, and they will then unfold and explain themselves clearly. The hardest problems in geometry and the most complex diagrams can be understood step by step: every great mathematician proves this point constantly.
V. When learning anything new, you should tackle as little as possible at once. Master that completely, then move on to the next unknown part. This approach is slow, but it's a safe and reliable way to gain knowledge. If you start with easier subjects and things closely related to what you already know, then gradually advance to more remote and difficult areas of knowledge, you'll be able to handle great difficulties and overcome them with amazing success.
Mathon happened to open a new geometry and measurement book to the last two chapters. As soon as he saw the complicated diagrams about the frustums of cones and pyramids and some advanced demonstrations involving conic sections, he shut the book in despair and imagined that only someone like Sir Isaac Newton could ever read it. But his tutor wisely persuaded him to start with the first pages about lines and angles. Within three weeks, he found such surprising pleasure in his daily victories that he eventually became one of the leading geometers of his time.
VI. Don't try to pursue too many unrelated subjects intensely at the same time. This will scatter your focus and prevent you from mastering any single area of study. You'll end up with superficial knowledge of several fields instead of deep, substantial understanding of any one, and you won't make real progress. While juggling two or three subjects at once can be useful (variety keeps your mind fresh and prevents mental exhaustion from one type of thinking), taking on too many will fragment your attention and weaken your ability to concentrate on any individual subject.
When you do work on two or three fields simultaneously, balance them strategically. If one is dry, abstract, and tedious (logic, metaphysics, law, or languages, for example), pair it with something more engaging and enjoyable. This protects your mind from burnout and keeps you from developing an aversion to study itself. Mix pleasure with work whenever possible: it makes the grind of difficult subjects more bearable. Poetry, practical mathematics, and history are generally considered enjoyable fields and work well for this purpose. By refreshing yourself during dull stretches with intellectually stimulating activities you actually enjoy, even your leisure time enriches your understanding. Your pleasure becomes productive.
VII. When pursuing any important subject, always keep your goal in sight and don't let every minor detail distract you along the way. Some people have such wandering minds that they chase after every tangential theme or stray idea until they've completely lost track of their original topic. These are the people who, in conversation, drag out their stories by dwelling on every little incident and stuff their narratives with endless digressions until they've forgotten what they set out to say. They're like someone sent to find a great treasure who stops to pick every flower he sees or pauses to dig up every shiny pebble he encounters, until the treasure is forgotten and never found.
VIII. Apply your care, skill, and effort to each subject and question in direct proportion to its importance, along with the danger and negative consequences of being ignorant or wrong about it. Many excellent benefits flow from this single principle:
1. This rule will teach you to be extremely careful when learning fundamental truths in philosophy, religion, and everyday life, because these truths matter most and easily lead our thinking into a thousand smaller, more specific conclusions. Take that great principle in natural philosophy: the doctrine of gravitation, or the mutual attraction of all bodies toward each other. Sir Isaac Newton established this so well, and from it he explained countless phenomena in the heavenly bodies as well as on earth.
Or consider that golden principle of morality which our blessed Lord gave us: Do to others what you think is just and reasonable for others to do to you. This principle is almost sufficient by itself to resolve all moral questions relating to our neighbor.
These are the foundational principles in religion: that a rational creature is accountable to his Maker for all his actions, that the human soul is immortal, that there is a future state of happiness and misery depending on our behavior in the present life. All our religious practices are built on or supported by these truths.
We should be extremely careful in examining any propositions that claim to be general principles. We shouldn't admit into this rank mere matters of common reputation or commonly accepted opinions without solid evidence. We shouldn't even accept the general conclusions of learned scholars or the established doctrines of any church or nation without scrutiny, because there are many learned presumptions, many synodical and national mistakes, and many established falsehoods, just as there are many popular errors. Throughout history, multitudes of people have followed one another almost blindly for entire ages. It's critically important for everyone to make sure these general principles are just and true, because one error can lead us into thousands more that will naturally follow once we admit a leading falsehood.
2. This rule will direct us to be more careful about practical matters than mere speculation, since practical matters are usually far more useful and important. Therefore, the speculations of algebra, the doctrine of infinities, and the quadrature of curves in mathematical learning, together with all the theorems in natural philosophy, should never encroach on our studies of morality and virtue. Even in theology itself, the most sublime speculations are not as valuable as the rules of duty toward God and toward other people.
3. When it comes to practical matters, we need to be extremely careful about setting the right goal and wisely determining what we're aiming for, because that goal will guide us in choosing and using all the means to reach it. If our goal is wrong, all our effort in pursuing it will be wasted, or perhaps even more harmful the better we get at achieving that mistaken end. If our chief aim is mere physical pleasure, human status, or wealth, we'll choose methods that contradict godliness and virtue, and we'll race toward real misery.
4. This principle will demand our best abilities and deepest focus when it comes to religion and matters relating to the next world: propositions that only affect this present life are relatively unimportant compared to those that influence our eternal destiny.
5. Even in religious matters, if we follow this rule, we'll work much harder investigating the necessary and fundamental truths of faith and practice than the minor details of Christianity. The great doctrines of repentance toward God, faith in our Lord Jesus Christ, along with love for others and complete holiness, will occupy our best and brightest hours and thoughts, while the mint, anise, and cumin (the gestures, vestments, and decorative elements of religion) will matter to us only insofar as they have a clear and obvious connection with faith and love, with holiness and peace.
6. This rule should make us careful not only to avoid errors that will spread throughout our own understanding and behavior, but also to avoid mistakes that would have an even wider and more harmful influence on others as well as ourselves: perhaps affecting many people or families, an entire church, a town, a country, or a kingdom. For this reason, people who are called to teach others, who are raised to any position of prominence in church or state, should be careful when establishing their principles in matters relating to civil, moral, or religious life. Otherwise, their mistakes could spread widespread harm, could lead to the most destructive consequences, and might even extend to future generations.
These are some of the benefits that come from the eighth rule: pursue every inquiry and study in proportion to its real value and importance.
IX. Be careful that some favorite idea or some beloved field of study doesn't dominate your mind so much that it colors all your other studies and distorts all your ideas, like a person with jaundice who sees everything through a yellow tint. I've known a man with exceptional skill in music, deeply devoted to that field, who found a great resemblance of the Athanasian doctrine of the Trinity in every single note, and he thought this carried some argumentative weight to prove that doctrine. I've read of another who matched the seven days of the first week of creation to seven musical notes, and thus the whole creation became harmonious.
Under this influence from mathematical studies, some people have been tempted to force all their logical, metaphysical, theological, and moral learning into the mathematician's method, bringing everything related to these abstract or practical sciences under theorems, problems, postulates, scholiums, corollaries, and so on. But the subject matter should always determine the method, because not all topics can be molded or forced into one form. Neither the rules for how we should think nor the doctrines and duties of religion and virtue can be naturally displayed in figures and diagrams. Things must be considered as they actually are: their natures are inflexible and their natural relationships unchangeable. Therefore, to understand them correctly, we must bring our minds to things as they are, not try to bend and twist things to fit our preferred patterns and forms.
X. Don't let any favorite study prejudice your mind so much in its favor that you despise all other learning. This is a fault of some narrow minds who have picked up a bit of astronomy, chemistry, metaphysics, history, or whatever else, and because they lack proper familiarity with other sciences, they mock them all in comparison to their favorite subject. Their understanding gets trapped in narrow boundaries, so they never look beyond their own province into other regions of the intellectual world, which might be more beautiful and more fruitful than their own. If they would explore other sciences a little, they might not only discover treasures of new knowledge but also find rich insights and powerful tools to cultivate the very field they've confined themselves to.
Here I would always make an exception for the sacred science of theology, which stands incomparably above all the rest because it teaches us the knowledge of God and the way to His eternal favor. This is that noble study which is every person's duty, and every one who can be called a rational creature is capable of it.
This is that science which would truly expand the minds of people, if it were studied with that freedom, that unbiased love of truth, and that sacred charity which it teaches. If only it were not made, contrary to its own nature, the occasion of strife, faction, malice, a narrow spirit, and unreasonable impositions on the mind and practice. Let this, therefore, always stand first.
XI. Let every particular study have its due and proper time assigned to it, and don't let a favorite science persuade you to spend hours on it that ought to be employed on the more necessary and more important affairs or studies of your profession. When you have, according to the best of your judgment and according to the circumstances of your life, fixed proper hours for particular studies, try to keep to those rules: not with superstitious exactness, but with some good degree of regular consistency. Order and method in a course of study saves much time and produces large improvements. Such a fixing of certain hours will have a happy influence to protect you from wasting away your minutes on trivial matters.
XII. Don't apply yourself to any one study at one time longer than the mind is capable of giving close attention to it without weariness or wandering. Don't over-fatigue the spirits at any time, or the mind will be seized with exhaustion and thereby be tempted to feel sick of and grow tired of a particular subject before you have finished it.
XIII. When you first tackle a new subject, don't get too frustrated by the difficulties you encounter, and don't be impatient for immediate answers to every question that comes up. A little more study, a bit more familiarity with the material, some time and experience: these will often solve those problems, untangle the knot, and clear up your doubts. This is especially true if you're working with a teacher. He can tell you when your questions are premature, when you haven't yet learned the foundational principles needed to resolve a particular difficulty.
XIV. Don't expect to reach absolute certainty in every subject you study. There are countless matters where we humans, in our limited and imperfect state, must settle for probability. Our best reasoning and clearest thinking can only take us so far. We must weigh the arguments as carefully as we can, and when we can't find enough weight on either side to tip the scales with complete confidence, we must often accept a slight tilt in one direction. This gives us a probable opinion, and these probabilities are sufficient for making thousands of daily decisions in human life, and often even in matters of religion.
A recent writer put it brilliantly: "When strong arguments are set before us, if we refuse to do what seems most appropriate until every minor objection is removed, we will never make a single wise decision as long as we live."
Let's say I had spent a long time honestly searching for the right religion, and I found that the arguments for Christianity didn't reach complete certainty but only gave me probable evidence of its truth. Even if many difficulties remained, I would still feel obligated to accept and practice that religion. The God of nature and reason requires us to believe and act according to the best evidence we have, even when it falls short of absolute certainty. Since He is our supreme judge, His abundant goodness and fairness will approve and acquit anyone whose conscience honestly seeks the best light available and obeys it as far as he can discover it.
But in matters of great importance in religion, combine diligent effort with earnest and humble prayer for divine help in your search. Use the kind of prayer and diligence that eternal concerns demand, the kind you could confidently present before the Judge of all.
XV. Try to apply every theoretical study to some practical use, as far as possible, so that both you and others benefit from it. Even inquiries into natural philosophy shouldn't be mere entertainment, and certainly not in religious matters. Research into the properties of natural bodies and their movements should lead people to invent helpful methods for making human life easier and more convenient. Or at the very least, such studies should move us to admire the wonderful wisdom and design of God our creator in all the works of nature.
If we pursue mathematical studies, they train us to focus closely on any subject, to seek and gain clear ideas, to distinguish truth from falsehood, to judge correctly, and to argue effectively. These studies also directly provide us with all the various rules for useful practical skills: measuring, building, sailing, and so on.
Even our investigations and debates about vacuum or space, about atoms, about incommensurable quantities, and the infinite divisibility of matter, and eternal duration (which seem to be purely theoretical) will teach us some valuable practical lessons. They will lead us to see the weakness of our nature, and they should teach us humility when we argue about divine subjects and matters of sacred revelation. This should guard us against rejecting any doctrine that is expressly and clearly revealed, even though we cannot fully understand it. It is good sometimes to lose and bewilder ourselves in such studies for this very reason: to attain this practical advantage, this growth in true modesty of spirit.
XVI. Though we should always be ready to change our views about things when we are justly convinced of their falsehood, there is not the same necessity of changing our accustomed methods of reading or study and practice, even though we may not have been led at first into the best method. Our thought may be true, though we may have hit upon an improper order of thinking. Truth does not always depend on the most convenient method. There may be a certain form and order in which we have long accustomed ourselves to arrange our ideas and notions, which may be best for us now, though it was not originally best in itself. The inconveniences of changing may be much greater than the conveniences we could obtain by a new method.
For example, if someone in their younger years organized all their theological thinking according to the structure of Ames's Medulla Theologiæ or Bishop Usher's Body of Divinity, it will be far more natural and easier for them to continue arranging all their future learning in the same order, even though neither of those works may be structured in the most perfect way. Similarly, once we've installed shelves in a library and arranged our books in a particular order (whether by language, subject, or alphabetically by author's name), we become completely familiar with that arrangement. We can locate any specific book we're looking for, or add a newly purchased book, much more easily than we could in a finer set of shelves where the books were arranged in any other way. Any different positioning of the volumes would feel new, strange, and troublesome to us, and the benefits wouldn't outweigh the inconvenience of making the change.
Likewise, if a forty-year-old man learned to hold his pen awkwardly in his youth but still writes well enough for all the purposes of his position, it's not worth teaching him the most precise methods of holding that instrument now. This would only create more trouble without equal benefit, and he might never write any better even after positioning his fingers perfectly with this new precision.
CHAPTER 15
MASTERING FOCUS AND ATTENTION
A student should work hard, using every proper method, to develop the ability to focus steadily. Attention is absolutely necessary for improving our minds. The evidence of truth doesn't always appear immediately or strike us at first sight. We arrive at evidence through long attention and careful examination, and we judge many things falsely because we lack it. We rush to make decisions based on a quick, superficial look. We confirm hunches that arise from a mere glance. We pass judgment while we have only a confused or unclear perception, and this plunges us into mistakes. This is like someone walking in a mist or standing at a great distance from a visible object (say, a tree, a man, a horse, or a church) who judges the figure, location, and colors of it very poorly and sometimes mistakes one thing for another. If he would just hold back his judgment until he came nearer to it, or wait until clearer light comes, and then fix his eyes on it longer, he would protect himself from those mistakes.
Now, to gain greater ease in paying attention, we can follow these rules:
I. Cultivate a genuine interest in whatever subject you want to study. You'll notice that it's not particularly hard to focus your mind on something you genuinely want to understand, especially when dealing with concrete matters or ideas that naturally capture your imagination. All you need is a sincere desire and commitment to explore and examine the various properties and aspects of such subjects, and your attention will naturally follow if there's any pleasure or interest in studying or thinking about them. This is why mathematical studies have such a remarkable power to fix the mind's attention and steady a wandering disposition: they work extensively with lines, figures, and numbers that appeal to and satisfy both the senses and the imagination. History has a similarly strong effect because it engages the mind through a variety of concrete events. Once you start reading, you can't put it down. You're driven by natural human curiosity to know how things turn out. Travel narratives and accounts of foreign countries and unusual phenomena serve the same purpose. This kind of study holds the mind's attention through the constant occurrence and anticipation of something new that can pleasantly strike the imagination.
II. Use concrete objects and physical images to illustrate abstract and intellectual concepts. Diagrams, for instance, greatly help the mind grasp astronomy and natural philosophy. Similarly, visual representations of virtues and vices can effectively teach children and make useful moral ideas stick in young minds in an engaging way. These same concepts might be much harder to convey through purely abstract moral discussions.
I admit that when we use pictures to represent moral subjects, we need to be careful. We risk drowning the mind in physical images to the point where it becomes unable to grasp abstract and intellectual ideas, or worse, it starts forming wrong ideas about immaterial things. This practice should really only be used at first to develop a solid habit of attention, and even then only in certain cases. It can never become our standard method for exploring all moral, abstract, and spiritual topics.
III. Focus on studies and authors who develop their subjects through a continuous chain of connected reasoning, where each part of the discussion flows naturally and easily from what came before. Several mathematical sciences (if not all of them) work wonderfully for this purpose. This will make the work of study delightful to a rational mind, and the sheer pleasure of it will hold your mental powers in strong attention to their proper operations. "The work itself is pleasure" (labor ipse voluptas) is a fortunate state of affairs wherever it can be achieved.
IV. Don't choose your regular study location based on beautiful views or the most varied and entertaining scenes of sensory things. Too much light, or a variety of objects that catch the eye or ear (especially when they're constantly moving or frequently changing), naturally and powerfully tend to pull the mind away too often from its steady pursuit of whatever subject we're contemplating. This causes the soul to develop a habit of silly curiosity and irrelevance, of superficiality and mental wandering. Vagario thought he had furnished himself with the best study space among the beauties, festivities, and diversions of Kensington or Hampton Court. But after seven years of claiming to pursue learning, he was still a complete novice.
V. Don't rush to settle a difficult or important question. Truth is worth waiting for. Don't commit to one side of an issue too quickly just because studying it takes a long time and feels hard. Better to remain uncertain for a while and stay in suspense until your focus, reflection, and careful work have uncovered enough evidence to decide. Some people are so eager to know everything at once, and they love to speak freely and confidently about things before they truly understand them, that they rarely give themselves enough time to investigate a matter thoroughly.
VI. Be careful not to indulge the more sensual passions and appetites of your physical nature: they are major enemies of focus. When a student sits down to search for truth or improve his understanding, his mind shouldn't be under the influence of any strong attraction to physical pleasures. A person controlled by love, fear, anger, intense pain, or deep grief has so little control over his soul that he can't keep it focused on the proper subject of his thinking. The passions constantly and insistently pull his thoughts toward whatever triggered them. If we regularly indulge the rising and wandering of our passions, we'll develop an unsteady and unfocused habit of mind.
Yet I must admit one exception: if we can be fortunate enough to engage one of the soul's passions on behalf of the particular subject we're studying, it can powerfully help fix our attention on it even more strongly.
VII. It helps tremendously to commit yourself to any field of study by thinking about the divine pleasures that come from truth and knowledge, by recognizing your duty to God, by taking delight in exercising your intellectual abilities, and by hoping that you'll one day serve your fellow human beings and gain glorious benefits for yourself in this world and the next. These thoughts may stir your emotions, but they do so in the right way: they will support and strengthen your focus rather than disturb or distract you from whatever you're currently studying and meditating on.
A soul filled with the deepest love of truth and the most fervent longing for genuine happiness and heavenly joy will keep all its powers focused on pursuing these things constantly. When this happens, passion becomes refined and dedicated to its highest purposes.
CHAPTER 16
EXPANDING YOUR MENTAL CAPACITY
Three things especially contribute to that breadth or capacity of mind which ranks among the noblest qualities of human understanding.
1. When the mind can easily take in great and sublime ideas without pain or difficulty.
2. When the mind can freely accept new and unfamiliar ideas, based on solid evidence, without excessive surprise or resistance.
3. When the mind can grasp or examine many ideas at once without getting confused, and can form sound judgments based on that comprehensive view.
Anyone who lacks any of these qualities can be said, in that respect, to have a narrow mind. Let's explore this subject a bit further.
I. A truly expansive mind can absorb vast and sublime ideas without strain or difficulty. People who have spent their lives dealing only with ordinary, small, everyday matters develop such a narrow mental habit that they can't stretch their thinking wide enough to accommodate large and noble thoughts. They instinctively use their domestic, daily, familiar experiences as the measure of everything that exists or could exist. Talk to them about the vast dimensions of the planetary worlds. Tell them that the star called Jupiter is a solid globe 220 times bigger than our earth. Explain that the sun is a vast globe of fire more than a thousand times bigger than Jupiter (that is, 220,000 times bigger than the earth). Mention that the distance from the earth to the sun is 81 million miles, and that a cannonball shot from the earth wouldn't reach the nearest of the fixed stars for hundreds of years. They simply can't accept it. They hear all these glorious achievements of astronomy as nothing more than idle fantasy.
Tell them about the amazing speed at which some of the smallest or largest bodies in nature move. Assure them, according to the best philosophy, that the planet Venus (our morning or evening star, which is nearly as big as our earth), though it appears to move from its place only a few yards in a month, actually flies 70,000 miles in an hour. Explain that rays of light shoot from the sun to our earth at the rate of 180,000 miles per second. They stand aghast at such talk and believe it no more than tales of giants fifty yards high or the rabbinical fables of Leviathan, who every day swallows a fish three miles long and is thus preparing himself to be the food and entertainment of the blessed at the feast of Paradise.
People with narrow minds react the same way to the wonders revealed by the microscope: the shapes, limbs, and movements of ten thousand tiny creatures whose combined size wouldn't equal a peppercorn. They're ready to dismiss all the ways we've enhanced our senses through various types of lenses, and they'll barely believe anything beyond what their naked eye can see without technological help.
If we want to address this limitation in a systematic way:
1. It helps to start with basic geometry principles and gradually guide them toward understanding incommensurable quantities (quantities that share no common measure, no matter how small). This will show them why we must accept that matter can be divided infinitely.
You can also prove this concept to their minds, and almost to their senses, through simpler arguments in a more straightforward way. Just opening and closing a pair of compasses clearly demonstrates that if you place the smallest imaginable piece of matter between the points, there will always be smaller and smaller distances along the legs as you move toward the pivot point. Therefore, there's no such thing as a smallest possible quantity. A basic understanding of real philosophy and mathematics would quickly teach them that space has no outer limits and matter has no smallest division. This would help them believe that bodies exist which are far larger or smaller than they can currently imagine.
2. Students should also learn about Earth's circumference. Simple principles of geometry, geography, and astronomy prove it to be roughly twenty-four thousand miles around, a measurement confirmed by sailors who have actually circumnavigated the globe. Once they grasp this, teach them that every twenty-four hours, either the sun and stars must all circle our planet, or Earth must rotate on its own axis. If Earth itself rotates, then every house or mountain near the equator moves at about a thousand miles per hour. But if (as most people assume) the sun and stars circle Earth, then their orbits must be vastly larger than our planet, meaning they would have to move far faster than a thousand miles per hour. This kind of thinking gradually expands their minds. Even if they accept the traditional view that the heavens revolve daily around Earth, they'll begin to comprehend the enormous scale of celestial bodies, their distances, and their movements.
3. Add to this the use of telescopes, which help them observe distant wonders in the sky, and microscopes, which reveal the tiniest parts of small creatures and expose some of nature's finest and most intricate workings. They should also become familiar with other remarkable inventions of modern science that greatly expand human understanding. I'll have more to say about these in the next section.
4. For the same purpose, encourage them to read those sections of Milton's magnificent poem, Paradise Lost, where he describes the armies and powers of angels, the wars and councils of devils, the creation of Earth, and his depictions of Heaven, Hell, and Paradise.
I'll grant that poetry often deals with these vast and sublime ideas. And even when the subject matter of a poem doesn't require such amazing and extensive thoughts, the tropes and figures (which are some of the main powers and beauties of poetry) gloriously elevate the material, giving a sublime imagination its proper satisfaction and delight.
For instance, when a boar is chased in hunting:
His nostrils flames expire, And his red eye-balls roll with living fire. - Dryden.
When Ulysses holds back and suppresses his resentment,
His wrath comprest, Recoiling, mutter'd thunder in his breast. - Pope.
But especially when the subject is grand, the poet never fails to represent it in all its grandeur.
So when the supremacy of God is described:
He sees, with equal eye, as God of all, A hero perish, or a sparrow fall; Atoms or systems into ruin hurl'd, And now a bubble burst, and now a world. - Pope.
These kinds of writing have a natural tendency to enlarge the capacity of the mind and make sublime ideas familiar to it. And instead of always turning to ancient pagan poetry for this purpose, we can gain equal (if not superior) advantage by spending time with some of the best of our modern poets, as well as with the writings of the prophets and the poetical parts of the Bible: the book of Job and the Psalms. In these sacred authors we will sometimes find more sublime ideas, more glorious descriptions, and more elevated language than the most devoted critics have ever found in any of the pagan poets of Greece or Rome. This is because Eastern writers use and allow much stronger figures and tropes than Western ones.
Now there are many great advantages to be gained from this kind of enlargement of the mind.
This will lead us to far more elevated ideas about the great God who created us than we've ever had before. It will fill our thoughts with holy wonder and amazement as we contemplate the Being who created these various works of surprising greatness and surprising smallness, who has displayed utterly inconceivable wisdom in designing all the parts, powers, and movements of these tiny animals invisible to the naked eye, who has shown a truly divine extent of knowledge, power, and greatness in forming, moving, and managing the massive bulk of the heavenly bodies, and in surveying and comprehending all those immeasurable spaces in which they move. Imagination, with all its images, grows exhausted and overwhelmed trying to follow the planetary worlds through such immense stages, such astonishing journeys as these, and gives way to pure intellect, which learns gradually to take in such ideas as these and to worship its Creator with new and sublime devotion.
And we're not only taught to form more accurate ideas of the great God by these methods, but this enlargement of the mind carries us on to nobler conceptions of His intelligent creatures. The mind that deals only in ordinary and common ideas is ready to imagine that the nature and powers of man come somewhat too close to God his maker, because we don't see or physically interact with any beings superior to ourselves. But when the soul has gained a greater breadth of thought, it won't immediately pronounce everything to be God which is above man. It then learns to suppose there may be as many various ranks of beings in the invisible world in a constant gradation superior to us, as we ourselves are superior to all the ranks of being beneath us in this visible world, even though we descend downward far below the ant and the worm, the snail and the oyster, to the smallest and dullest animated atoms that are discovered to us by microscopes.
By thinking this way, we can begin to imagine what incredible power and knowledge angels (whether good or evil) must possess to oversee the ancient kingdoms of Persia and Greece, or to superintend the affairs of Great Britain, France, Ireland, Germany, and other nations in our own time. Consider what power and speed would be necessary to destroy 185,000 armed men in a single night in the Assyrian camp of Sennacherib, and all the firstborn in the land of Egypt in another night: both of these acts are attributed to an angel.
Through these steps we can rise to form more accurate ideas of the knowledge and grandeur, the power and glory of the man Jesus Christ, who is intimately united to God and is one with Him. Without question, He is equipped with powers superior to all the angels in heaven, because He is employed in superior work and appointed to be the Sovereign Lord of all the visible and invisible worlds. It is His human nature (in which the Godhead dwells bodily) that is advanced to these honors and to this empire. Perhaps there is little or nothing in the government of the kingdoms of nature and grace that is not carried out by the man Jesus, inhabited by the divine power and wisdom, and employed as a medium or conscious instrument of this extensive governance.
II. I will now consider the next aspect of the mind's capacity or amplitude: the mind is free to receive new and unfamiliar ideas and propositions on solid evidence without great surprise or resistance. Those who confine themselves within the circle of their own inherited ideas and opinions, and who never allow themselves even to examine or believe anything beyond the teachings of their own family, sect, or party, are rightly accused of having a narrow soul. Let us look at some examples of this imperfection, and then I will offer guidance on how to cure it.
1. People who have spent their entire lives within the confines of their hometown or village are amazed by every new sight when they venture just a few miles away. The farmer gawks at the shops, the commerce, the throngs of people, the grand architecture, the splendor and wealth and pageantry of the court and capital city. He can hardly believe what others told him until he sees it with his own eyes. Meanwhile, the city dweller traveling to the countryside is equally astonished by the behavior of farm animals and birds in the fields, and by the everyday practices of rural life.
If either of these people hears about the ordinary daily customs of foreign countries, they immediately dismiss them as improper and absurd. Their understanding is so limited, their thinking so restricted, that they can't accept as wise or appropriate anything beyond what they've been taught to do themselves.
This narrow-mindedness needs to be corrected by hearing and reading accounts of different parts of the world, and by studying the histories of past eras and of nations and countries far from our own, especially the more civilized societies. Nothing expands the mind in this regard as effectively as travel: visiting other towns, cities, or countries beyond where we were born and raised. And when our circumstances don't allow us this privilege, we must try to compensate for its absence through books.
The same narrow-mindedness explains why some people react with shock and disgust when they encounter doctrines and systems in human affairs or religion that differ from their own. Perhaps they were raised from childhood with one set of ideas, and their thinking has been confined to a single track in both civil and religious life, never hearing or learning what other opinions exist among humanity. Or at least they've only seen all other notions besides their own portrayed in a false and hostile light. As a result, they judge and condemn at once every belief except what their own party accepts, and they think it's an act of justice and truth to heap harsh criticism on the practices of every different sect in Christianity or politics. They've rooted themselves so deeply in their party's opinions that they can't hear an objection with patience, nor can they tolerate a defense, or even an apology, for any set of principles besides their own. Everything else is nonsense or heresy, foolishness or blasphemy.
This defect also needs to be remedied through open conversation with people who hold different views. This will teach us to patiently tolerate a defense of opinions contrary to our own. If we're scholars, we should also read the objections against our own beliefs and examine the principles of other parties as they're represented in their own authors, not merely in the quotations of those who would refute them. We should take an honest and unbiased survey of the strength of reasoning on all sides, and test everything against unprejudiced reasoning and divine revelation. Note, this shouldn't be done in a rash and self-confident manner, but with humble dependence on divine wisdom and grace, while we walk among snares and dangers.
By freely engaging with people from different religious groups (especially those who differ only in specific forms of Christianity but agree on its great and essential doctrines), we will discover that there are sensible and virtuous people, pious and worthy people, people of great openness and goodness, who belong to different parties and hold opposing views. This will soften the harshness of an unrefined soul, broaden the channels of our charity toward others, and make us more willing to receive them into all the degrees of unity and affection that God's word requires.
3. I could borrow further illustrations of both this freedom and this resistance to accepting new truths from modern astronomy and natural philosophy. How surprised the common people are when they hear about the daily and yearly revolutions of the earth! They have always been taught by their senses and their neighbors to imagine that the earth stands fixed at the center of the universe, and that the sun, along with all the planets and fixed stars, whirls around this little globe once every twenty-four hours. They don't consider that such a daily motion, given the distance of some of those heavenly bodies, would have to be almost infinitely faster and more inconceivable than any motion modern astronomers attribute to them. Tell these people that the sun is fixed at the center, that the earth and all the planets revolve around the sun in their various periods, and that the moon revolves around the earth in a smaller circle while being carried around the sun together with the earth. They can't accept a syllable of this new and strange doctrine, and they declare it utterly contrary to all sense and reason.
Tell them that four moons orbit the planet Jupiter constantly, traveling with it as it circles the sun, and that these little moons remained unknown until 1610, when Galileo discovered them through his telescope. Inform them that Saturn has five moons of the same kind attending it, and that the planet itself is surrounded by a broad, flat circular ring, positioned twenty-one thousand miles from the planet and twenty-one thousand miles wide. They will dismiss these things as tall tales and fantasies, insisting that the telescopes merely deceive your eyes with magnified images. Even when they look through these instruments themselves, their minds are so narrow that they will barely trust their own senses when those senses present such new and strange ideas.
If you go further and try to convince them that all these planetary worlds can support life, and that they are probably filled with intelligent beings living in physical bodies, they will mock the foolishness of anyone who suggests such things. They are determined to believe that no habitable worlds exist except this earth, and that no spirits dwell in bodies besides humanity. You can count yourself lucky if they don't brand as a heretic the person who is trying to free them from their long imprisonment and remove the chains from their souls.
Many other things related to mechanical experiments and to the properties of air, water, fire, iron, the lodestone, and other minerals and metals (as well as the study of sensible qualities like colors, sounds, tastes, and so on) remain beyond belief for this class of people simply because they lack sufficient breadth of mind.
The best way to convince them is by introducing them to various scientific experiments and proving through direct observation the diverse and remarkable effects of the air pump, the magnet, the chemistry lab, optical lenses, and mechanical devices. This approach will gradually expand their thinking, and once they've discovered that many new and strange things are clearly true, they won't be so quick to dismiss every novel idea in other sciences, or in matters of religion or everyday life.
III. Mental capacity includes another important quality: the ability to hold many ideas at once without getting confused. A broad mind can survey several objects in a single glance, keeping them all visible and present to the soul so they can be compared in their various relationships. It forms sound judgments and draws appropriate conclusions from these comparisons, even through long chains of reasoning and complex demonstrations.
The narrowness that characterizes human minds in general is a serious flaw that hinders both wisdom and happiness. Few people can think about or handle several things at once. Our abilities are quite limited, and while we focus intently on one aspect or feature of a subject, we catch only a fleeting glimpse of the rest, or we lose sight of it entirely. But it's a mark of a large and spacious mind if we can take in multiple objects with a single look, or at least when the mind can move between several objects with such rapid succession, and in such brief moments, that it achieves nearly the same results as if everything happened simultaneously.
This qualification is essential for developing real knowledge and sound judgment. Many aspects of human life, religion, and the sciences come with various circumstances, attachments, and relationships. Without examining all the ideas that connect to and relate to each other, we often risk making false judgments about whatever we're considering. This explains why we find so many controversies among both educated and uneducated people, in religious matters as well as in civil government affairs. Concepts like sin, duty to God and our fellow human beings, law, justice, authority, power, covenant, faith, justification, redemption, grace, church, bishop, presbyter, and ordination all contain such complex ideas that when we need to judge anything about them, it's difficult to see at once all the attendants or consequences that must and will be involved in deciding even a single question. Yet without paying proper attention to many or most of these factors, we risk deciding that question wrongly.
Our minds are limited, which means we face the same danger in matters of human duty and practical wisdom. In many of our actions, we shouldn't just consider the bare action itself, but also who is acting, toward whom they're acting, when, where, how, and for what purpose the action is done, along with the effects that must or may follow, and all other surrounding circumstances. We must take all these things into account to determine whether an action that is neutral in itself becomes lawful or unlawful, good or evil, wise or foolish, decent or indecent, proper or improper, depending on its circumstances.
Here's a straightforward example to illustrate this point. Mario kills a dog, which by itself seems like a neutral action: but the dog belonged to Timon, not to him, which makes it look wrong. However, Timon told him to do it, which makes it seem lawful again. It happened at church during worship: these added details give it a hint of irreligion. But the dog attacked Mario and threatened his life, which removes the apparent impiety of the action. Yet Mario could have escaped by running away, so the action still seems improper. But the dog was known to be rabid, and this further detail makes killing it almost necessary to prevent it from attacking the congregation and causing serious harm. Yet again, Mario killed it with a pistol he happened to have in his pocket from yesterday's journey: this terrified the entire congregation, disrupted the service, and forced it to stop. This carries an appearance of great indecency and impropriety. But after all, when we consider one more detail (that Mario, being violently attacked by a rabid dog, had no way to escape and no other weapon on him), it seems to remove all appearance of impropriety, indecency, or wrongdoing, and to confirm that preserving one or many lives justifies the act as wise and good. Now all these accompanying details of the action must be examined in order to judge it fairly and accurately.
There are countless human actions in private life, in domestic affairs, in business, in civil government, in courts of justice, in schools of learning, and so on, which involve so many complicated circumstances, aspects, and situations with regard to time and place, persons and things, that it's impossible for anyone to pass a right judgment concerning them without entering into most of these circumstances and surmounting the difficulties that attend them, surveying them extensively, and comparing and balancing them all properly.
This leads me to observe how many thousands there are who take it upon themselves to pass their judgments on the personal and domestic actions of others, who pronounce boldly on the affairs of the public, and determine the justice or madness, the wisdom or folly of national administrations, of peace and war, and so on, whom neither God nor men ever qualified for such a position of judgment! They weren't capable of entering into the numerous concurring springs of action, nor had they ever taken a survey of the twentieth part of the circumstances which were necessary for such judgments or censures.
It's the narrowness of our minds, as well as the vices of the will, that often prevents us from taking a full view of all the complicated and concurring details that belong to human actions: from this it comes to pass that there is so little right judgment, so little justice, prudence, or decency practiced among the bulk of mankind; from this arise infinite reproaches and censures, alike foolish and unrighteous. You see, therefore, how necessary and beneficial a thing it is to be possessed of some measure of this amplitude of soul, in order to make us very wise, or knowing, or just, or prudent, or happy.
I confess this sort of amplitude or capacity of mind is in a great measure the gift of nature, for some are born with much more capacious souls than others.
Some people have such limited mental capacity that they can barely grasp how two or three ideas connect, except when dealing with concrete, physical matters they've learned through direct experience. They're completely unsuited for theoretical studies. It's difficult for them to tell right from wrong when reasoning about abstract subjects. These individuals should never try to become scholars. Instead, they should pursue trades and professions that can be learned more gradually, through steady practice and hands-on experience.
Others have slightly more mental capacity and can follow the logic connecting a few ideas reasonably well. But if the chain of reasoning gets too long, they get stuck and confused. If people like this decide to pursue academic work, they need to make sure they have a strong, healthy body and be prepared for the exhausting effort that serious study demands. As King Solomon tells us, when the iron is dull, we must apply more strength.
But third, there are some people with such brilliant natural ability and such expansive minds that they can follow a long chain of reasoning, if not immediately, then very quickly, and judge accurately how the pieces fit together. They can examine a variety of complex ideas without getting tired or confused. When numerous truths present themselves almost simultaneously to their understanding, it doesn't overwhelm or confuse them. This is what makes a great thinker.
Now, while natural ability plays a significant role here, experience shows us that even a modest capacity for broad thinking can be strengthened through hard work and dedication, through regular practice, and by following rules like these.
I. Work hard to develop an attentive and patient mindset, the ability to focus and concentrate your thoughts on any given subject until you've examined it from every angle and in every context, and explored its various powers, parts, properties, and relationships, along with its effects and consequences. Anyone whose thoughts constantly flit and wander, unable to focus attentively on a few ideas in sequence, will never be able to examine many different subjects clearly at once. Instead, they'll inevitably be overwhelmed and confused by the sheer number of them. The rules for maintaining attention in the previous chapter are worth reviewing here.
II. Train yourself to think in clear and distinct ideas about everything. Don't settle for vague and confused concepts, especially when clearer ones are available. Even one vague or confused idea (particularly if it's central to the question at hand), mixed in with many clear ones and viewed from various angles in relation to them, risks spreading confusion across your entire mental landscape. This can seriously undermine your understanding and distort your judgment. A little black paint can ruin twenty bright colors.
Consider this further: if you frequently settle for words instead of real ideas, or for cloudy and confused notions of things, imagine how impenetrable the darkness will be, and how vast and endless the confusion, when many of these vague and confused ideas are presented to your mind all at once. How impossible it will be to form a clear and sound judgment about them.
III. Work hard to build up a large collection of ideas and concepts. Take every chance you get to add something new to your mental inventory, and through regular review, fix these ideas firmly in your memory. Nothing strengthens and expands memory more than frequently revisiting what it already holds. When your brain is well stocked with various impressions, patterns, and mental images, you'll have a rich reserve always ready to present itself when you turn your thoughts toward any particular subject. This will gradually give your mind the ability to survey many objects at once, much like a room richly decorated and hung with a great variety of pictures strikes the eye almost instantly with all that variety, especially if you've examined each picture carefully one by one at first. This makes it natural and easier for those who live there to take in many of those painted scenes with just a glance or two.
Note here that by building a rich collection of concepts, I don't mean only individual ideas, but also statements, observations, and experiences, along with reasoning and arguments on the various subjects that come up in natural and moral matters, everyday or sacred affairs. That way, when you're called to make a judgment about any question, you'll have some principles of truth, some useful guidelines and observations, always ready at hand to direct and assist your judgment.
IV. We need to organize our daily stream of new ideas in a systematic way, filing what we learn under appropriate categories: theology, law, medicine, mathematics, ethics, politics, business, home life, social conduct, and so on. We might also organize by concepts like cause and effect, substance and attribute, power and property, matter and spirit. We should train our minds to work methodically at all times. When we encounter fresh ideas, events, or observations, we should place them in their proper categories and see how they fit with what we already know about those subjects. Think of a librarian shelving a new book among related titles, or a postal clerk in London sorting each incoming letter into the box for its destination.
In any of these situations, if everything lies scattered in a heap, adding new material only makes the confusion worse. But a systematic approach lets you survey everything quickly and easily, with real satisfaction. Method is incredibly valuable for keeping your ideas from getting jumbled together and for keeping them ready whenever you need them. The science of ontology, which organizes all beings and all the properties of being (whether absolute or relative) into proper categories, does excellent work in keeping your intellectual acquisitions orderly enough that your mind can take them all in at once.
Since method is necessary for developing your mind and making your collection of ideas as useful as possible, you should also follow a regular, progressive method in all your further pursuits of truth and acquisition of rational knowledge. Start with the simplest, easiest, and most obvious ideas. Then gradually combine two, three, and more of them together. This way, as complicated ideas build up under your direct observation, they won't create the same mental confusion they would if they were all presented to your mind at once, without your seeing how they originated and formed. A perfect example of this appears in the study of arithmetic. If a student just entering school watches his teacher perform a division problem, his head immediately fills with confusion from the many comparisons between the numbers in the divisor and dividend, and from the multiplication of one and the subtraction of it from the other. But if he starts systematically with addition and then moves through subtraction and multiplication, within a few weeks he'll be able to understand all those division operations intelligently and perform them himself with ease and pleasure, even though each one seemed like nothing but complexity and confusion at first.
Here's an illustration from geometry, algebra, and other mathematical fields: consider how easily an expert geometrician can take in a complicated diagram at a single glance, one made up of many lines and circles, angles and arches. How quickly he can judge whether the demonstration it represents is true or false. He reached this level of understanding gradually. He started with a single line or a point, then joined two lines in an angle, then moved on to triangles and squares, polygons and circles. In this way, the powers of his understanding stretched and grew daily until, through diligence and practice, he acquired this extensive mental faculty.
But this advantage doesn't belong only to mathematical learning. If we start with clear and simple ideas in any field, and never rush ourselves on to the more complicated parts of knowledge until we thoroughly understand what came before, we can use the same method to expand the capacity of our minds with success in any of the sciences, or in the affairs of life and religion.
Starting with A, B, C, and building syllables from letters and words from syllables has been the foundation of all that glorious structure of arts and sciences that have enriched the minds and libraries of the learned world across the ages. These are the first steps by which the most capable and expansive minds among humanity have reached that remarkable extent of knowledge that makes them the wonder and glory of the nations where they live. Though Plato and Cicero, Descartes and Mr. Boyle, Mr. Locke and Sir Isaac Newton were certainly blessed by nature with genius of uncommon scope, yet in their early years and first attempts at science, this genius was limited and narrow compared to what they eventually achieved. But how vast and capable were those powers they later acquired through patient attention and careful observation, through the pursuit of clear ideas and a disciplined method of thinking!
VI. Another way to develop this breadth and capacity of mind is to work through difficult, tangled questions and their solutions in any field of study. Theoretical and case-based theology will give us many such problems and controversies. Some difficulties arise in reconciling different parts of Paul's letters when they discuss Jewish law and the Christian gospel. A successful solution requires such a comprehensive view of things, and reading these successful solutions will expand this ability in younger students. In ethics and political subjects, Puffendorf's Law of Nature and Nations, along with several of its conclusions, will promote the same breadth of mind. Attending public trials and arguments in civil courts will serve this purpose well. After someone has studied the general principles of natural law and English law in the proper books, reading the reports of decided cases (collected by men of great insight and judgment) will richly improve his mind toward acquiring this desirable breadth and range of thought, especially for people in that profession.
CHAPTER 17
TECHNIQUES FOR IMPROVING MEMORY
Memory is a distinct faculty of the human mind, very different from perception, judgment, reasoning, and its other powers. We remember something when the idea of it comes to mind along with the awareness that we've had this idea before. Our memory is our natural ability to retain what we learn and to recall it whenever needed. Therefore, we can never remember anything (whether ideas or statements, words or things, concepts or arguments) unless we've previously had some idea or perception of it, either through our senses or imagination, thought or reflection. But whatever we learn from observation, books, conversation, and so on must all be stored and preserved in memory if we want to make it truly useful.
Memory is such a vital and remarkable human capacity that every other mental ability depends on it for its value and effectiveness. Without memory, our other cognitive powers become nearly worthless. What good does it do to work hard at gaining knowledge and wisdom if we can't remember and apply what we've learned? Why bother with intellectual and spiritual growth if everything we gain disappears the moment we acquire it? Memory alone makes the mind rich by holding onto everything our effort and work gather each day. Put simply, knowledge, arts, and sciences cannot exist without memory. Neither can humanity improve in virtue, morals, or religious practice without this power supporting and shaping us. Without memory, the human soul would be nothing more than a pitiful, empty, bare thing, covered by an eternal blankness except for whatever fleeting thoughts pass through it right now.
Memory proves invaluable to speakers and learners alike. It helps the teacher and orator just as much as the student or listener. The best speeches and lessons lose nearly all their value if the audience forgets them immediately. And those called to speak in public gain far more acceptance and attention when they can deliver their message through natural talent and ready recall, rather than being forced to read everything they want to communicate. Reading is certainly a heavier way to convey our thoughts. Very few people who simply read aloud possess the gift of penetrating the soul and stirring the emotions of their audience with the grace and power of someone who seems to speak every word from the heart, pouring out the wealth of his own knowledge to those around him through free and abundant memory. This brings life and energy to everything spoken, and naturally tends to make a deeper impression on people's minds. It wakes up even the dullest listeners, causing them to receive a message with more warmth and pleasure, and adds remarkable grace and excellence to both the speaker and his speech.
Good judgment and good memory are very different abilities. A person may have a very strong, spacious, and retentive memory while his judgment remains poor and weak. Sometimes this happens in people who are barely above the level of an idiot, who have shown an amazing strength and reach of memory but have hardly been able to connect or separate two or three ideas in a wise and skillful way to form a solid, rational statement.
There have been cases of others who possessed only a moderately strong memory, yet whose judgment reached a much higher level: accurate and wise, solid and excellent.
Yet we must acknowledge that when someone has a strong memory, they've laid a solid foundation for wise and sound judgment, provided their natural intelligence has any sharpness and clarity to use it properly. Good judgment must always depend, at least to some degree, on surveying and comparing several things together in the mind, and determining the truth of some uncertain proposition through that survey and comparison. When the mind has, so to speak, placed before itself all the various objects necessary to form a true proposition or judgment about something, it then determines that certain ideas should be joined or separated, affirmed or denied. And it does this in a way that remains consistent and corresponds with all other ideas and propositions that relate or belong to the same subject. Now there can be no such comprehensive survey of many things without a reasonable degree of memory. We learn to judge the future by reviewing the past, and it sometimes happens that if one necessary or important object or idea is absent, the judgment about the thing in question will become false or mistaken.
You will then ask: How is it that some people appear in the business world, as well as in the academic world, to have good judgment and have earned a well-deserved reputation for prudence and wisdom, yet have neither a very sharp intelligence or quick thinking, nor a very strong memory, so that they cannot place before their minds at once a large array of ideas in order to make a judgment?
Penseroso can teach us something about this difficulty. You'll rarely find him quick to judge or decide on things people present to him. Instead, he always takes time, delays, holds back, and thinks things through carefully before forming his judgment. He practices slow meditation, chewing over the subject, and over the course of two or three days and nights, he deliberately calls up the various ideas he needs, one after another, to judge the matter correctly, reviewing them in sequence. He does this to compensate for both a lack of quick insight and a sluggish memory that doesn't recall things easily. This careful approach forms the foundation of his sound judgment and wise behavior. He examines thoroughly before he decides.
This leads me to offer one useful piece of advice to people of both high and low intelligence, and to those with both strong and weak memories: don't rush to conclusions about doubtful or uncertain matters when there's no urgent need for immediate action. A brilliant mind tends to move so quickly that it often falls into serious errors of judgment, speech, and behavior unless it constantly guards itself and restrains its tongue. Through this kind of delay and caution, many people with far less natural ability often surpass the most brilliant minds in wisdom and good sense.
You'll often find that brilliant people have terrible memories. When someone has a sharp mind and a vivid imagination, they tend to neglect their memory, and it never develops properly. An active imagination loves to jump from one thing to another, constantly entertaining itself with fleeting images. It races through countless new scenes or pages with pleasure but without real focus, rarely pausing long enough on any single item to make a deep impression or commit it to long-term memory. This explains why some exceptionally bright and energetic people have such limited powers of recall: when you're rich in your own ideas, you don't feel the need to borrow from others.
Just as a quick and varied imagination can interfere with attention and memory, a mind with strong retention that constantly stuffs itself with everything it learns and reads can actually stifle creativity. Take someone like Lectorides, whose memory is always ready to supply him with passages from other people's writings or conversations. His mind perpetually presents him with other people's thoughts, and as a result, this man (who was born with genuine creative ability) never allows himself to follow his own ideas. Some people blessed with natural insight and real talent have suppressed it by chaining themselves to the contents of every book they've read and every opinion those books contain.
When memory constantly gathers new information without good judgment to sort what's worth keeping from what's pointless, the mind fills up with a miserable jumble of words and ideas. The person may appear to possess a great deal, but they have no real wealth.
I once read a striking comparison in one of Milton's works about the writings of the Church Fathers. He said that whatever Old Time has dragged down to us through the centuries in his enormous net, whether shells or shellfish, jewels or pebbles, sticks or straws, seaweed or mud: these are the ancients, these are the fathers. Most people's memories work the same way. A few useful things get mixed up and buried under piles of trivia and junk, and this mess becomes their entire mental storehouse. It's a tremendous advantage, then, to distinguish what truly matters and store in memory only what has real value and deserves to be counted as treasure.
Whatever insights we gain through the careful use of our own reasoning, we can call our own products. Whatever we borrow from others, we can call our imported goods. Together, they make for a rich and fulfilled mind.
A wise and studious person develops countless excellent judgments and insights over the course of many years. Through both personal reflection and careful, diligent reading, he accumulates a wealth of admirable ideas throughout his life. Yet tragically, thousands of these thoughts vanish into thin air simply because memory isn't strong or reliable enough to hold them all. When a young lawyer once tried to debate a legal point with the great Serjeant Maynard (a leading attorney of the previous generation), Maynard reportedly replied, "Young man, I've forgotten more law than you've ever learned or read."
What incredible, almost inexpressible happiness it would bring to a thoughtful person pursuing knowledge if he could somehow stamp all his best ideas onto his memory in permanent form. Imagine if he could imprint every valuable passage and insight from the finest authors he's read onto his mind with the same ease and speed with which he read them in the first place. If a person with genuine talent and sharp perception could retain and review at once all the numerous, wise, and beautiful ideas that have ever passed through his mind on any single topic, he would be magnificently equipped to form sound judgments about everything he encounters in the present. What glorious pleasure and satisfaction would fill his spirit if he could grasp all these ideas in a single comprehensive view, the way a skilled painter's eye takes in an intricate historical scene painted by a Titian or a Raphael, seeing the entire composition at once and delighting in its full scope. But these are joys that don't belong to mortal life.
I've explored some scattered and disconnected thoughts about the different powers of wit, memory, and judgment. It was difficult to organize them into a regular structure without more space. Let me now treat memory alone in a more systematic way.
Although memory is a natural faculty of the human mind and belongs to spirits that aren't bound to flesh, it is greatly helped or hindered, and significantly shaped, by the brain or the physical nature to which the soul is joined in this present state. But which part of the brain stores the images of things is very hard for us to determine with certainty. Most likely, the very fibers, pores, or traces of the brain that assist at the first idea or perception of any object are the same ones that also assist when we recall it. If this is true, then memory has no special part of the brain devoted exclusively to its service. Instead, it uses all those parts in general that serve our sensation as well as our thinking and reasoning powers.
Just as memory grows and improves in young people from childhood and decays in old age, it can also be increased by skill, effort, and proper exercise, or it can be injured and completely ruined by laziness, disease, or a blow to the head. Some reasoning on this subject makes it clear that the quality of a memory depends to a great degree on the consistency and the condition of that part of the brain appointed to assist the exercise of all our sensory and intellectual faculties.
Consider children, for example. They notice and forget a hundred things in an hour. Their brains are so soft that they immediately receive every impression, like water or liquid mud, yet they hold onto almost none of it. All the traces, forms, or images drawn there are instantly erased or closed up again, as if you were writing with your finger on the surface of a river or on a vessel of oil.
In contrast, elderly people have very weak memories of recent events (that is, things from the same day, week, or year). The brain has grown so hard that present images or impressions make little or no mark, and therefore they immediately disappear. Prisco, at seventy-eight, will tell long stories about things that happened when he fought at the Battle of the Boyne almost fifty years ago, and when he studied at Oxford seven years before that. Those impressions were made when his brain was more receptive. They were deeply engraved at the right time, and so they remain. But words or actions from just recently are immediately forgotten, because the brain has now become more dry and solid in its consistency, receiving no more impression than if you wrote with your finger on a clay floor or a plastered wall.
But in the middle stage of life (perhaps from fifteen to fifty years of age), memory is generally at its best. The brain easily receives and long retains the images and traces impressed on it, and the natural spirits are more active in arranging these countless tiny unknown figures of things in their proper cells or cavities, preserving and recollecting them.
Whatever keeps the brain in its best condition and consistency can help preserve memory. But excessive wine or any kind of indulgence, as well as too much studying or overwork, can overwhelm memory by overstraining and weakening the brain's fibers, depleting mental energy, damaging the delicate structure of that tender organ, and scrambling the images stored there.
A good memory has several qualities. 1. It readily receives and absorbs, with great ease, the various ideas of both words and things that are learned or taught. 2. It is large and abundant enough to store these ideas in great number and variety. 3. It is strong and lasting enough to retain for a considerable time those words or thoughts committed to it. 4. It is reliable and active in suggesting and recalling, on every appropriate occasion, all those words or thoughts that have been entrusted to its care or stored within it.
Now in every one of these qualities a memory can be damaged or improved. Yet I won't dwell on these particulars separately, but will instead propose a few general rules or guidelines by which this noble faculty of memory, in all its aspects and qualities, can be preserved or strengthened, and show what practices both reason and experience have proven to be beneficial for this purpose.
One major principle applies to improving memory just as much as any other mental faculty: keep it in regular, appropriate exercise. Repeated actions gradually form habits, and through this process the ability itself grows stronger and more readily available when needed. We should train our memories from childhood, feeding them moderate amounts of knowledge early on, and they will develop into powerful tools for later use. Just as a limb grows stronger through proper, consistent exercise, the body's nerves are strengthened through use. Milo lifted a calf and carried it on his shoulders every day; as the calf grew, his strength grew with it, and eventually he developed joints firm enough to carry a full-grown bull.
Our memories will be largely shaped and formed, improved or damaged, according to how we exercise them. If we never use them, they will almost disappear. People who habitually discuss or read about only a few topics will retain only a few things in their memory. Those who are used to remembering things for just an hour, burdening their memories no longer than that, will retain them for only an hour before they fade. And remember words as well as facts, so that you can acquire a wealth of vocabulary (a copia verborum) as well as knowledge (a copia rerum), making yourself more ready to express your thoughts on any occasion.
Yet we need to add a caution in some cases: the memory of a child or any person with limited capacity should not be overburdened. A limb or joint can be overstrained by carrying too much weight, and its natural strength may never be recovered. Teachers should wisely assess the capacity and constitution of young people, and impose on them no more than they can bear with cheerfulness and genuine improvement.
Students need to be careful not to overwhelm the learner's memory with too many documents or ideas at once. This is the surest way to remember nothing: one idea simply erases another. Grabbing too greedily means you won't hold onto the largest handful. The key to improving memory is exercising it with proper moderation.
Here are the specific rules: 1. Paying close attention and working diligently to learn what you want to remember is absolutely essential. When your attention is strongly focused on a particular subject, everything said about it makes a deeper impression on your mind. Some people complain they can't remember the sermons or lectures they hear, but the truth is their thoughts wander half the time, or they listen with such coldness and indifference, with such a careless attitude, that it's no wonder the things they read or hear make only a slight impression on the brain. These ideas never get a firm foothold in memory, but quickly vanish and are lost.
Therefore, if we want to maintain a long memory of what we read or hear, we need to engage our delight and pleasure in those subjects. We should use the other methods I've already described for fixing our attention. Laziness, indifference, and idleness will no more bless the mind with intellectual riches than they will fill your hand with profit, your field with grain, or your purse with treasure.
We should also recognize that lazy and careless people aren't the only ones who fail to build up their knowledge properly. Even those with active, energetic minds can fall into the same trap if they're constantly skimming the surface of things with a restless temperament, never letting anything settle in their minds. Take someone like Vario, who spends entire mornings jumping from one random page to another, always chasing after whatever new words and ideas catch his attention in the moment. He flits from one subject to another across a thousand different topics in arts and science, yet he retains very little actual knowledge. Real learning requires the hard work of focused attention on specific subjects and questions. Only this kind of concentrated effort can imprint what we read or think about onto our memory.
2. If we want things to stick in our memory and stay there, we need to understand them clearly and precisely first. When we're trying to remember words or learn the names of people and things, we should fix them in our memory through clear and precise pronunciation, spelling, or writing. When we're trying to store ideas, concepts, propositions, arguments, and fields of knowledge, we should likewise grasp them clearly and precisely. Vague, dim, and muddled ideas will disappear like shapes glimpsed at dusk. Everything we learn should reach our understanding in the plainest possible language, without any ambiguity, so we don't confuse what we're trying to remember. This principle applies whether we're memorizing words or concepts, though I should acknowledge that memorizing mere sounds and words is much harder than learning actual things and concrete ideas.
Be careful, as I've often warned you, not to mistake words for actual understanding, or mere sounds for real ideas. Many students forget what they've been taught simply because they never truly understood it in the first place. They never clearly grasped the meaning behind the sounds and syllables they were required to memorize.
This explains why boys make such poor progress in learning Latin under teachers who use grammars and rules written entirely in Latin, as I've mentioned before. The same thing happens with children learning their catechisms at a young age. The language and concepts in those catechisms are far beyond what children that age can understand, and they have no real grasp of what the words mean. This makes the answers much harder to remember, and in reality they're learning nothing but words without ideas. Even if they can recite the words perfectly, they know nothing about theology.
For this reason, when teaching children the principles of religion, you must express them in very plain, easy, and familiar words. Bring the concepts down to their level as much as possible, adjusting for their different ages and abilities. This way they'll gain some useful knowledge when the words stick in their memory, because they'll be storing the divine ideas along with them.
3. Using method and regularity in what we memorize is necessary to make it take hold more effectively in the mind and stay there longer. Some vain and foolish critics of our age dismiss systematic learning, but it's clearly the best way to fill the mind with a wide range of knowledge.
Whatever you want to commit to memory should be organized in a logical system, connected coherently, and filed under distinct categories and subcategories, both general and specific. An apothecary's apprentice will learn all the medicines in his master's shop much faster when they're arranged in boxes or on shelves according to their different types: herbs, drugs, or minerals; leaves or roots; chemical or traditional preparations; simple or compound formulations. When they're placed in some order according to their nature, their fluidity, or their consistency, stored in vials, bottles, jars, cases, drawers, and so on, the learning becomes easier. Similarly, a family tree is more easily learned when you start with some great-grandfather as the root and distinguish the trunk, the large branches, the smaller branches, the twigs, and the buds, until you reach the present infants of the house. Indeed, all kinds of arts and sciences taught with a method something like this are more successfully committed to the mind and memory.
I could offer another simple comparison to confirm this truth. What horse or cart can pick up and carry away all the various rough and unwieldy trimmings of a branchy tree at once? But if they're divided further, so they can be laid close and bound up in a more uniform way into several bundles, perhaps those trimmings can all be carried in a single load.
The way things connect to each other helps us remember them both. When a discourse is organized in a logical method, it gives the reader or listener a huge advantage in remembering it. That's why you can remember a long series of mathematical proofs much better than a pile of disconnected sentences. The book of Proverbs, at least from chapter ten onward, is much harder to remember than the book of Psalms for exactly this reason. Some Christians have told me they remember what's written in Romans and Hebrews much better than many other New Testament letters because those two follow a more precise method and structure.
If you want to learn how to remember a sermon you hear, you should gradually familiarize yourself with the method the preacher uses to deliver its important parts. A huge number of preachers make the mistake of completely neglecting method in their sermons, or at least they refuse to make their method clear and obvious to their listeners. You'd be tempted to think they're afraid their audiences might remember too much and stop them from preaching the same sermon three or four times over. But I'm charitable enough to believe the real reason is that they think it's more fashionable to preach without numbered points. I'm certain it's also much more useless. It would benefit both speaker and listener greatly if sermons were organized into a plain and easy method, with reasons or conclusions arranged in proper order under the words "first," "second," and "third," no matter how unpolished or unfashionable those might seem now. Archbishop Tillotson didn't think so in his day.
4. Reviewing and carefully repeating what we want to learn, and condensing it into a compact form for this purpose, has a powerful effect on memory retention. This is why grammar teachers so often assign rules and useful examples of word variations and special phrases as lessons for students to repeat frequently. These materials are condensed into tables for regular review, so that what doesn't stick in the mind at first will be imprinted on the memory through constant examination and rehearsal.
Repetition is such a valuable practice that Mnemon, from his youth to his old age, never read a book without making small points, dashes, or hooks in the margin to mark which parts of the text deserved a second look. When he reached the end of a section or chapter, he always closed his book and recalled all the ideas or expressions he had marked, so that he could give a reasonable analysis and summary of every work he had read, right after finishing it. This is how he became so well equipped with a rich variety of knowledge.
Even when someone is listening to a sermon or lecture, they can allow their thoughts to step back occasionally and recall the main points from the beginning, two or three times before the sermon or lecture ends. Missing or losing a sentence or two among the elaborations is richly compensated by keeping the method and order of the whole discourse in mind, especially its most important parts.
If you want to remember the talks you hear or the speeches you plan to give, reduce them to brief summaries and review them often. Lawyers and ministers need this kind of help: they write down short notes or key points of what they want to memorize for preaching or arguing in court, because these summaries and outlines can be reviewed much faster, and the various supporting ideas or phrases will come back to you more easily in their proper places. Shorthand is incredibly useful for this, as well as for other purposes. I should point out that people who almost never pick up a pen to write brief notes or reminders of what they need to say or learn, who never try to organize things systematically or condense them for memorization, had better have twice the natural ability to retain and recall what they read, hear, or plan to say.
Don't throw yourself into other work or studies, entertainment or hobbies, right after you've received instruction, if you can possibly avoid it. Find time, if you can, to think over what you've heard, so it won't all get washed away from your mind by a flood of other events or commitments, or get lost in the chaos and noise of other urgent or demanding matters.
Discussing what you've read with your companions at the first good opportunity is one of the most useful ways to review and reinforce the material in your mind. Teach it to your younger friends: you'll strengthen your own understanding while passing it on to them. The physical act of speaking and hearing, combined with your mental faculties, will all work together to help your memory.
Hermetas studied intensely in a remote, isolated part of the country. Despite this solitude, he became highly learned. He rarely had the chance to enjoy suitable company at home, so he developed a habit of walking through the fields and woods in the evening, talking through what he had read during the day. He found this practice so beneficial that he recommended it to all his friends, having tested it successfully for seventeen years.
5. Pleasure and delight in the things we learn provide tremendous help in remembering them. Whatever you want a child to commit to memory, make it as pleasant to him as possible. Try to discover his natural abilities and temperament, and let him absorb the instructions you give him, or the lessons you assign him, in a way that suits his natural inclinations as much as possible. Fabellus would never learn any moral lessons until they were shaped into some fiction or fable like those of Aesop, or until they took on the appearance of a parable, like those in which our blessed Savior taught the ignorant world. Then he remembered well the symbolic instructions that were given him, and learned to practice the moral sense and meaning of them. Young Spectorius was taught virtue by setting before him a variety of examples of the various good qualities in human life, and he was assigned daily to repeat some story of this kind out of Valerius Maximus. The same boy was instructed early to avoid the common vices and follies of youth in the same manner. This is similar to the method by which the Lacedaemonians trained up their children to hate drunkenness and excess, namely by bringing a drunken man into their company and showing them what a beast he had made of himself. Such visible and concrete forms of instruction will make long and useful impressions on the memory.
Children can be taught to remember many things through games and play. Some young children have learned their letters and syllables, and the pronouncing and spelling of words, by having them pasted or written on many little flat tablets or dice. Some have been taught vocabularies of different languages, having a word in one tongue written on one side of these tablets, and the same word in another tongue on the other side of them.
There are also many clever ways to teach children geometry, geography, and astronomy through engaging, almost magical methods that would leave a lasting and delightful impression on their minds.
6. Memory can be greatly strengthened when useful information is put into verse. The rhythm, meter, and rhyme found in different languages have a powerful effect on people, making it easier to absorb new information and remember it longer. Think of how many everyday facts we learned as children through rhymes, facts that became fixed in our minds like nails driven into solid wood and reinforced through daily use!
For example, thousands of people remember the number of days in each month thanks to these four lines:
Thirty days hath September, June and April and November: February twenty-eight alone, And all the rest have thirty-one.
Young people have been taught thrift by calculating their own spending with these three lines:
Compute the pence but of one day's expense, So many pounds, and angels (ancient coins), groats, and pence, are spent in one whole year's circumference.
Since there are 365 days in a year, that same number of pence equals one pound, one angel, one groat, and one penny.
Health advice has been prescribed in verse in the book called Schola Salernitani, and many people have undoubtedly saved themselves from overeating at dinner (and the pain and illness that follow) by remembering these two lines:
Ex magna cœna stomacho fit maxima pœna: Ut sis nocte levis, sit tibi cœna brevis.
In English:
To be easy all night Let your supper be light; Or else you'll complain Of a stomach in pain.
Countless proverbs in various languages have been turned into rhyme or verse, which makes them stick in the memory of both young and old.
This principle explains why moral rules have been put into poetic form since ancient times. Think of the golden verses of the Pythagoreans in Greek, Cato's moral couplets (De Moribus) in Latin, Lilly's precepts for scholars called Qui Mihi, and many others. This approach has worked remarkably well. A line or two of this kind, coming back to mind, has often protected young people from temptation to vice and foolishness, while also reminding them of their present duty.
This same reason explains why the genders, declensions, and variations of nouns and verbs have been taught in verse by those who have followed the long-standing custom of teaching English children Latin through rules written in Latin itself. Truly, those rough piles of words and endings from an unknown language would never have been memorized so successfully by a hundred thousand boys without this smoothing technique. In fact, I don't know what else could reasonably be said to excuse or justify the obvious absurdities of this practice.
When you want to remember new things or words, try to link them with something you already know well, something firmly established in your memory. This association of ideas carries tremendous power and can prove remarkably useful in many areas of life. One familiar idea, when connected to something new and unfamiliar, will make that new concept much easier to recall. Maronides had memorized the first hundred lines of Virgil's Aeneid so thoroughly that he knew not only the order and position of every word but also each verse. Using this foundation, he could remember two or three hundred names of people or things by creating some logical or imaginative connection between a word in the verse and some letter, syllable, characteristic, or feature of the name or thing he wanted to remember, even if he had heard them only once or twice. Animato practiced much the same memory technique by memorizing the Latin names of twenty-two animals in alphabetical order: asinus, basiliscus, canis, draco, elephas, felis, gryphus, hircus, juvenis, leo, mulus, noctua, ovis, panthera, quadrupes, rhinoceros, simia, taurus, ursus, xiphias, hyaena or yaena, zibetta. He also divided most of these animals into four parts: head and body, feet, fins or wings, and tail. By creating some arbitrary or fanciful attachment between each of these parts and a word or thing he wanted to remember, he entrusted them to his memory with considerable success.
You can also use this association of ideas to better imprint new information on your memory by linking it with some circumstance of the time, place, or company where you first observed, heard, or learned it. When you're trying to recover a forgotten idea, it helps to recall those circumstances of time and place. You can often retrieve the substance by remembering the shadow: a person comes back to mind when you remember his clothing, his height, his job, and so on. An animal, bird, or fish might be recalled by its color, shape, or movement, or by the cage, courtyard, or tank where it was kept.
Related to this is the way we can remember names and things by recalling their similarity to other things we know, whether that resemblance involves the name, character, form, some incidental feature, or anything else connected to them. An idea or word that has been lost or forgotten can often be recovered by hitting on some other related word or idea that closely resembles it, whether in the letters, syllables, or sound of the name, or in the properties of the thing itself.
If you want to remember Hippocrates, Galen, or Paracelsus, think of a physician's name beginning with H, G, or P. If you want to remember Ovidius Naso, picture a man with a large nose. If Plato, think of someone with broad shoulders. If Crispus, imagine someone with curled hair. The same principle applies to other things.
Sometimes a new or unfamiliar idea can be fixed in memory by considering its contrary or opposite. So if you can't recall the word Goliath, remembering David may bring it back. Or you might recover the name of a Trojan by thinking of a Greek, and so on.
8. Whenever possible, develop a spatial memory for what you've read by remembering which side or page something appeared on: whether it was on the right or left, at the top, middle, or bottom, and whether it came at the beginning or end of a chapter or paragraph. For this reason, it helps to get used to books in the same edition. This practice has proven especially valuable for ministers and ordinary Christians who keep several Bibles of the same edition in different rooms. Whether they're in the bedroom, living room, or study, and whether they're young or old, they can always find chapters and verses in the same position on the page.
Printers would do well to follow this principle when producing new editions of grammars, psalms, Testaments, and similar books. By printing each chapter, paragraph, or verse in the same position as previous editions, they would greatly help young learners who benefit from (and can actually feel the advantage of) spatial memory.
9. Write down everything you want to remember clearly and distinctly, divided into sentences, with large letters at the beginning. This approach helps imprint both the content and the exact words on your mind, making them easier to recall at a glance when the writing looks visually striking. Sight conveys ideas to the imagination better than any other sense, and what we've seen stays with us longer than what we've merely heard. What Horace said about the mind and emotions applies equally well to memory:
Segnius irritant animos demissa per aurem, Quam quae sunt oculis subjecta fidelibus, et quae Ipse sibi tradit spectator.
In English:
Sounds that reach the ear are lost and die within an hour; but what strikes the eye lives long in the mind; faithful sight engraves knowledge with a beam of light.
To help weak memories, you can write the first letters or words of every sentence on each page in different colors: yellow, green, red, black, and so on. If you follow the same color sequence in the sentences that follow, it works even better. This creates a stronger impression and can significantly aid memory.
Along these lines, we should note how much memory benefits when we organize what we're learning into charts and tables. Mathematical and scientific concepts not only enter the understanding more easily but also stick in memory better when presented through figures and diagrams. You can learn the layout of different parts of the earth better by spending one day with a map or nautical chart than by reading geographical descriptions a hundred times. Similarly, the constellations and their positions in the sky are easier to remember when you have well-drawn star charts. Hanging these kinds of visual aids (figures, charts, and tables) around your study or wherever you spend time will greatly assist and improve your memory, as I explained thoroughly in the twentieth chapter on the practical use of sciences.
I should add here that writing something down once (while paying close attention to what you're writing) will fix it in your mind more firmly than reading it five times. In the same way, if you had a printed template showing just the bare lines of longitude and latitude projected on a meridian, you could advance much more quickly in geography by drawing all the world's regions on it yourself through imitation than by spending many days studying a printed world map. The same applies to the constellations: a student will learn better by drawing them on a blank projection of the celestial sphere onto the plane of the equator.
10. Some people have used a technique of imprinting names or sentences on their memory by taking the first letter of every word and creating a new word from them. For example, the name of the Maccabees comes from the first letters of the Hebrew words that form the sentence "Who is like you among the gods?" (Mi Camoka Bealim Jehovah), which was written on their banners. The early church fathers called Jesus Christ our Savior a fish, using the Greek word IX???, because these are the first letters of the Greek words for Jesus Christ, God's Son, the Savior. Similarly, the word ROYGBIV helps us remember the order of the seven original colors as they appear when sunbeams pass through a prism onto white paper, or as they form in a rainbow, according to the different refrangibility of the rays: violet, indigo, blue, green, yellow, orange, and red.
Hebrew grammarians use this same method to teach their students which letters change their natural pronunciation when marked with a dagesh. They gather these six letters (beth, gimel, daleth, caph, pe, and thau) into the word Begadchepat. To help students remember the letters called Quiescent (a, h, v, and i), they combine them into the word Ahevi. In logic, the universal and particular propositions are remembered through the words Barbara, Celarent, Darii, and so on.
I should mention a few other artificial memory aids here.
Dr. Grey, in his book called Memoria Technica, replaced the numbers 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 with consonants (b, d, t, f, l, y, p, k, n) and vowels (a, e, i, o, u) along with several diphthongs, creating words that represent numbers and are supposedly easier to remember. Mr. Lowe later refined this system in a short pamphlet called Mnemonics Delineated, where he managed to compress an almost infinite range of things (both scientific and everyday) into just seven pages, organizing them into a kind of meter similar to Latin verse. The resulting words, however, are quite awkward, since the mixture of vowels and consonants makes them sound harsh and unnatural.
That said, even the authors who write about these techniques admit that many of these artificial memory aids are so unwieldy that they don't suit everyone's temperament or abilities. They're useless for delivering a speech from memory and offer little help in learning the sciences. Still, they can occasionally be useful for remembering specific sentences, numbers, and names.
CHAPTER 18
HOW TO ANALYZE AND SETTLE QUESTIONS
I. WHEN a topic is presented for your consideration, first ask whether it can be known at all, and then whether it lies beyond the reach of your current inquiry and understanding. Remember that spending too much time on unsolvable questions is a serious waste of effort. The main value of studying such matters is to keep your mind humble by revealing your own ignorance and limitations.
Consider again whether the subject deserves your attention at all, and then how much it deserves your current effort and time based on your age, stage of life, position in society, abilities, profession, and main goals. Many things worth investigating for one person aren't worth it for another. And some things that deserve one person's study at one stage of life would be inappropriate or irrelevant at another. Reading books on the art of preaching or debates about church discipline makes sense for a theology student near the end of his academic training, but not at the beginning. Pursuing extensive mathematical studies might be useful for a philosophy professor, but not for a minister.
Consider whether your subject is easy or difficult, and whether you have enough foundational knowledge, skill, resources, and advantages to pursue it. It would be crazy for a young sculptor to try carving a Venus or Mercury right away, especially without proper tools. And it's equally foolish for someone to claim he can make great advances in natural philosophy without conducting proper experiments.
Consider whether the subject has any practical value before you commit to studying it. Often ask yourself: Cui bono? What's the point? What goal will it achieve? Does it serve God's glory, benefit humanity, advance your own interests, eliminate some natural or moral evil, or achieve some natural or moral good? Will the benefit justify the effort? The schools teach many subtle irrelevancies and many painstaking trivialities, even among mathematical theorems and problems. There are many difficiles nugae (laborious follies) of various kinds that have occupied some clever minds. Thinking carefully about these matters will redirect your mind from pointless diversions and save you considerable time.
V. Think about whether this question will make you wiser and better, not just more knowledgeable. Questions that lead to wisdom and practical judgment in dealing with people, as well as devotion to God, are clearly more important than inquiries that only expand your grasp of abstract theories.
VI. If the question seems worth your serious effort, and you have what you need to pursue it, then ask yourself whether it's buried under unnecessary words or tangled up with more complex ideas than required. If so, work to simplify and clarify it. This will make the entire investigation and argument easier and clearer.
VII. If the question is framed in an unclear, confusing, or awkward way, you can improve it by rewording it or rearranging its parts. But be careful to keep the central point of inquiry exactly the same when you restate it. Cheap sophistry tricks (slipping in or removing words that completely change the question) should be rejected by anyone who argues fairly and honestly seeks truth.
Stating a question clearly and fairly often gets you halfway to answering it. Most real knowledge comes from seeing clearly the distinctions between things that are actually different. Some people shed more light and understanding by simply stating a question with clarity and fairness than others do by talking about it in confused circles for hours. To state a question properly is to separate and untangle its parts from each other and from everything irrelevant, then arrange those untangled parts in logical order. Often, this alone resolves the doubt and shows the mind where the truth lies, without any need for further argument or debate.
VIII. When you're evaluating whether something qualifies as an axiom or first principle of truth, remember that a long chain of consequences may depend on it. For this reason, you shouldn't accept it hastily.
It's not enough to declare a proposition true (much less elevate it to the status of an axiom or first principle) simply because it has been believed for many centuries, accepted by many nations, almost universally acknowledged, or never denied. Nor is it enough that human laws have established it, or that people who reject it face legal penalties or social disgrace.
IX. Similarly, you shouldn't deny a proposition the title of axiom merely because some people have rejected it and others have doubted it. After all, some people are unreasonably gullible, while others are unreasonably skeptical. A proposition should be called an axiom, or a self-evident truth, only when you can pay moderate attention to the subject and predicate and see their connection in such plain and clear light that you need no third idea or middle term to prove they're connected.
X. While you're searching for truth in doubtful questions, or in matters you haven't yet thoroughly examined, maintain a careful neutrality toward both sides of the issue if you want to be led honestly to the truth. A desire or inclination leaning toward either side distorts your judgment remarkably. By contrast, when you care only about truth itself, you'll be motivated to examine the question fairly rather than jumping to conclusions, and you'll make sure your belief doesn't outrun your evidence.
XI. Most people are born into their opinions and never question whether what their family, country, or political group believes is actually true. They dress their minds the way they dress their bodies: according to whatever style is currently popular. Not one person in a hundred ever examines their own principles. To even suggest that examination might be necessary is seen as a sign of weak commitment, and if you actually try to examine your beliefs, you'll be accused of heading toward betrayal. People get praised for assuming they're right, and as Mr. Locke said, anyone who thinks carefully and asks questions about why things are true gets labeled an enemy of orthodoxy, simply because he might end up disagreeing with some accepted doctrine. And so people (lazy and passive as they are) inherit what we might call local truths: the truths of whatever place they happen to live in. They get trained to agree without evidence.
This has a long and damaging effect. Once a person gets used to being dogmatic and aggressive about ideas he's never actually examined (especially on the most important matters), he'll naturally follow this quick and easy approach to forming judgments and beliefs about less important things too. He'll build all his opinions on shaky foundations.
XII. When you're trying to settle a question, especially one that's difficult and important, don't settle for a partial examination. Turn your thoughts in every direction to gather all the light you can toward solving it. Take your time and use every resource available before you make a final decision, except when immediate circumstances force you to decide quickly.
If you want to know what counts as a partial examination, here are some examples:
When you examine something through your senses, or investigate a matter of perception from too far away, or in an awkward position, or when your senses aren't working properly, or when anything obscures the medium, the organ, or the object itself, or when you rely on just one sense where you could use several, or when you examine something purely through sensation without engaging your understanding, judgment, and reason.
If the question requires reasoning and argument, your examination is partial when you view it from only one angle instead of turning it over completely: when you look at how it relates to one kind of object but not another; when you consider only its advantages and the reasons supporting it while neglecting the reasons against it and never surveying its drawbacks; when you decide hastily before giving yourself enough time to weigh all the circumstances.
Again, if it's a question of fact that depends on human testimony, your examination is partial when you ask only what one person or a few people say while avoiding the testimony of others; when you ask only those who weren't eyewitnesses or earwitnesses while neglecting those who actually saw and heard it; when you settle for vague and general talk without getting into specifics; or when many people deny the fact and you never bother with their reasons for denying it, but decide to believe only those who affirm it.
There's another fault in your partial examination of any question: when you decide to settle it by natural reason alone where you could be helped by supernatural revelation; or when you decide the point by some word or sentence, or by some part of revelation, without comparing it with other parts that might shed more light and better help you determine the meaning.
You're also guilty of bias if you examine some questionable vision or supposed revelation without using reason, or without comparing it to the revelation that's unquestionably and sufficiently proven to be divine. These are all examples of incomplete examination: we should never settle a question using only one or two sources of light when we could have the advantage of three or four.
XIII. Watch out that you don't turn some pet idea, favorite theory, beloved doctrine, or commonly accepted but unexamined opinion into the test for whether everything else on that subject is true or false. Don't dare build much on such an idea or doctrine until you've examined it thoroughly, assessed it carefully, and confirmed it adequately. Some people, by giving in to this practice, have been led into long chains of errors. They've found themselves trapped in a series of mistakes because they adopted some minor theory or principle (whether in philosophy, politics, or religion) on weak and insufficient grounds, then set it up as the test and rule for judging everything else.
Be careful not to make a hasty decision on any question when that decision will naturally affect how you judge related or parallel cases. Watch out for taking a wrong turn in your early thinking about things. Guard yourself as much as possible against any false bias that might influence your understanding, especially when you're young. Once you accept one silly opinion or believe one foolish story, your mind becomes vulnerable to many more. The ancient Romans were taught to believe that Romulus and Remus, the founders of their state and empire, were abandoned in the woods and nursed by a wolf. This story primed their minds to accept similar tales about other countries. Trojus Pompeius used the fable of Romulus and Remus to argue that one of the ancient kings of Spain was also nursed and suckled by a deer. Through the same influence, they learned to surrender their hopes and fears to omens and fortune-telling, once they were convinced that the greatness of their empire and the glory of their founder Romulus had been predicted by the favorable omen of twelve vultures appearing to him when he searched for where to build the city. They readily accepted all the subsequent legends of prodigies, auguries, and prophecies for many centuries afterward, which Livy filled his massive history with.
In the same way, a child who is once taught to believe that any occurrence is a good or evil omen, or that any day of the month or week is lucky or unlucky, has suffered a serious breach in the soundness of his understanding that will affect all his future judgments. He remains forever vulnerable to all the silly notions and idle tales of nurses, and he eagerly absorbs many foolish stories that he must unlearn later if he ever becomes acquainted with truth and wisdom.
XV. Be careful not to let your passionate religious zeal attach itself to matters that aren't sufficiently clear in themselves or that haven't been fully and thoroughly examined and proven. Once this zeal gets engaged (whether rightly or wrongly), it will powerfully influence you to lock yourself into doctrines that are actually doubtful, and it will shut down every avenue for receiving further light. This creates a kind of sacred fear of heresy in your soul, along with what feels like a divine obligation to defend whatever opinion you've adopted as divine truth, even though you may have adopted it without any real evidence and should actually reject it as false and harmful.
We should be zealous for the most important aspects of our faith and contend earnestly for the faith once delivered to the saints. But we shouldn't deploy this sacred intensity of spirit in service of any doctrine until we've seen it demonstrated with clear and strong conviction that it's a necessary or important point of faith or practice, and that it's either an obvious truth from natural reason or a certain article of revelation. Zeal must not rule over our understanding but obey it. God is the God of light and truth, a God of reason and order, and He never requires humanity to misuse their natural faculties to support His cause. Even the most mysterious and elevated doctrines of revelation shouldn't be believed without good reason. We shouldn't engage our pious emotions in defending them until we have clear and convincing proof that they are certainly revealed, even though we may never in this world achieve the kind of clear and distinct understanding of them that we desire.
XVI. We should never defend any revealed truth with passionate zeal until our reason is fully convinced of the revelation. By the same token, we should never use wit and mockery, jokes and ridicule, to oppose or attack any doctrines of professed revelation until reason has proven they aren't actually revealed. Even then, these methods should be used sparingly and with extreme caution and wisdom. Clever wit and humor were never designed to help us discover truth or settle rational debates. They can sometimes be useful for exposing inconsistent nonsense to contempt, but only after argument has thoroughly refuted it first. They serve merely to cover foolishness with shame once reason has already proven it to be complete nonsense.
Some of our deists have introduced a foolish and utterly unreasonable test for judging divine revelation: they try to see if it can withstand ridicule and laughter. They've been thoroughly defeated in all their battles using the weapons of rational people (that is, reason and argument). It wouldn't be unfair (though it's a bit rude) to say that they now want to attack our religion with the tactics of a base animal: making faces and sneering.
I don't believe that a jester or a monkey, a comedian or a puppet, can properly judge or settle controversies. Whatever dresses everything up in disguise is unlikely to lead us to any accurate understanding of things. You could throw a fool's costume on Plato or Socrates, Caesar or Alexander, and in that disguise, neither the wisdom of the philosophers nor the majesty of the rulers would protect them from mockery. This treatment would never tell us whether they were kings or slaves, fools or philosophers. The strongest reasoning, the best logic, and the most refined thoughts can all be made to look ridiculous by this mocking ability. The most obvious truths can be dressed up in foolish forms and wrapped in clever absurdities by this talent, but they remain truth, reason, and good sense nonetheless. Euclid, with all his proofs, could be so buried under mockery that a beginner in mathematics might start to doubt whether his theorems were true and wonder if they could ever be useful. In the same way, weaker minds could easily be turned against the noblest principles of truth and goodness, and young people could be driven away from believing the most serious, rational, and important points (even of natural religion) by the shameless jokes of an irreverent wit. The moral duties of civil life, as well as the doctrines of Christianity, can be painted over with the colors of foolishness and put on display in such a way that all social and personal virtue is destroyed among the carefree and thoughtless parts of society.
XVII. We should also note that these same people loudly condemn the use of harsh insults and abuse in debates, along with state penalties and persecution, as methods for convincing people's minds and consciences or settling questions of truth and error. I reject these punitive and painful methods of persuasion just as much as they do, yet I still think they are every bit as wise, just, and effective for this purpose as mockery and ridicule. Why should public mockery in print, or a clever joke on a stage, be a better test of truth than vicious sarcastic attacks and public persecution and punishment? Why should a song full of vulgar humor, or a witty ballad, shed more light on the understanding than a crude beating? When someone who professes a particular religion is held up for public laughter, I cannot see how this helps us judge the truth of his faith any better than if he were flogged. The jeers of a theater, the pillory, and the whipping post are all closely related. When the person or his opinion becomes the joke of the mob, or his back becomes the executioner's butcher block, I think there is no more real persuasion in one than in the other.
XVIII. Beyond this, even if we suppose it's merely possible that God might reveal His mind and will to people through miracles, visions, or inspiration, it's contemptuous and profanely insolent to treat any reasonable or rational appearance of such a revelation with jokes and mockery in order to test whether it's divine. Yet if this were a proper test of revelation, it could just as easily be applied to the true as to the false in order to distinguish between them. Imagine a royal proclamation sent to a distant part of the kingdom, and some of the subjects doubt whether it actually came from the king: could wit and ridicule ever settle the question? Would the prince ever consider himself justly honored to have his proclamation examined this way on a public stage, becoming the entertainment of jesters, just to determine whether it's the word of a king or not? Let such writers continue at their own grave peril, amusing themselves with their own deceptions. Let them mock the Bible and treat the sacred articles of Christianity with scorn and jokes if they will, but then they should abandon all their claims to reason as well as religion. And just as they expose themselves through such writings to the neglect and contempt of other people, so let them prepare to face the majesty and anger of God without timely repentance.
XIX. When you read philosophical, moral, or religious debates, never let your opinion of an idea rise simply because the author asserts it with confidence and passion, or because he praises it extravagantly. Likewise, don't let your opinion of an idea fall, or your opposition to it grow, just because some heated writer treats it with arrogant contempt or condemns it with an air of absolute authority. Let the strength of the argument alone determine whether you agree or disagree. Make sure your judgment isn't twisted or biased in either direction by flattering or abusive language, because every question imaginable has defenders and opponents who write this way. Ignore the writers who exploit their readers' weaknesses with this approach instead of offering real arguments. Let them celebrate their imagined possessions and victories: often enough, what they possess is just a pile of errors, and their boasted victories are nothing but loud noise and bluster meant to drown out the voice of truth.
In philosophy and religion, the fanatics on all sides are usually the most dogmatic, and they rely heavily on this kind of argument. Sometimes these tactics come from pride, because an arrogant person assumes all his opinions are infallible and imagines that contrary views are always ridiculous and beneath notice. Sometimes this way of talking is simply the weapon of ignorance: the people who use it know little about the opposing side of the question, so they celebrate their own empty claims to knowledge as if no sensible person could possibly disagree with them. They attack objections to their own views because they can't find any answer except attacks. And learned people, through excessive vanity, have sometimes fallen into the same insulting practice as the ignorant.
Yet we should also remember that some truths are so clear and obvious that opposing them seems strange, inexplicable, and almost absurd. When defending such truths, a sensible writer may sometimes be justified in using a degree of confidence and stating them forcefully, provided he backs them up with compelling reasons.
XX. Sometimes a question may be posed that is so broad and far-reaching, touching on so many different subjects, that it shouldn't be answered all at once with a single argument or response. For example, if someone were to ask me, Are you a professed follower of the Stoics or the Platonists? Do you accept the principles of Gassendi, Descartes, or Sir Isaac Newton? Have you chosen Tycho's hypothesis or Copernicus's? Have you committed yourself to the views of Arminius or Calvin? Are your beliefs episcopal, presbyterian, or independent, and so on? In such cases, I think it's entirely appropriate not to give a sweeping answer, but rather to go through the particulars and explain my own views. Perhaps there is no person or group on earth whose opinions I follow entirely. God has given me reason to judge for myself, and though I may find sufficient grounds to agree with most of one person's or party's opinions, it doesn't follow that I should accept them all. Truth doesn't always come in a package deal, nor does error necessarily contaminate every belief that a particular party holds.
Since every system of human knowledge comes with its own set of problems, I'm satisfied if I can lean toward the side with the fewest difficulties. As much as possible, I try to correct the mistakes or harsh language of one party by using gentler, more conciliatory methods: I reduce the extremes and borrow some of the best principles or expressions from another side. Cicero was one of the greatest men of antiquity, and he gives us an account of the various philosophical opinions in his age. But he himself belonged to the eclectic school and chose from each system whatever positions seemed, in his wisest judgment, to come closest to the truth.
XXI. When life or religion calls you to judge and decide on any question, to affirm or deny it, take a full survey of both the objections against it and the arguments for it, as far as your time and circumstances allow. Then see which side carries more weight. If either the objections against a proposition or the arguments defending it carry undeniable evidence and are clearly unanswerable, they will and should compel your agreement, even if there are many seemingly plausible points on the other side that at first glance might tempt your judgment to favor it. But when the reasons on both sides are nearly equal in weight, doubt or suspension of judgment is your duty, unless the case requires an immediate decision or action. In those situations, you must act according to whichever side seems to have slightly more weight at the moment.
XXII. When dealing with important matters, we should indeed search for certain and conclusive arguments (if they can be found) to settle a question. But when something is relatively unimportant, it's not worth spending much time pursuing certainty: probable reasons are good enough. And even in more important matters, especially where we need to act daily and can't find sufficient or certain grounds to decide either way, we must work with whatever probable arguments we can find. But we should observe this general rule: make sure your level of confidence rises no higher than the probable argument can support.
XXIII. There are many things in religion, philosophy, and everyday life that we believe with very different degrees of confidence. This is (or should be) always regulated by the different degrees of evidence we have. Perhaps there are a thousand gradations in how strongly we believe things, because there are thousands of circumstances relating to different questions that increase or diminish the evidence we have about them, both in matters of reason and revelation.
I believe there is a God, and that every rational creature owes Him obedience. I am completely certain of this because I have the strongest evidence: it is the clear teaching of both reason and revelation.
I believe in a future resurrection of the dead because Scripture tells us so in the clearest possible terms, even though reason alone says nothing about it. I also believe that the same matter of our bodies that died (at least in part) will rise again, but I'm not as fully convinced of this detail because the revelation isn't quite as clear and explicit. Going further, I believe that good people who knew each other on earth will recognize each other in heaven, but my conviction here isn't absolutely certain. Why? Because my belief rests only on circumstantial reasoning by people about what God has told us, and therefore my evidence isn't strong enough to rule out the possibility of error. This principle can't be repeated too often: our assent should always keep pace with our evidence. Our belief in any proposition should never rise higher than the proof or evidence we have to support it, and our faith shouldn't run faster than sound reason can encourage it.
XXIV. Perhaps someone will object here: Why then does our Savior, in the Gospel accounts, so highly commend a strong faith and extend both his miraculous benefits and his praise to those simple people with little reasoning ability who professed an assured belief in his authority and power to heal them?
I answer: the God of nature has given every person their own reason to judge evidence for themselves and to direct their own assent in all things they're called to judge. Even the matters of revelation are to be believed by us because our reason confirms the revelation to be true. Therefore, the great God will not (or cannot) in any instance require us to assent to anything without reasonable or sufficient evidence, nor to believe any proposition more strongly than what our evidence for it will support. We have, therefore, abundant ground to believe that those persons whom our Savior requires to have such strong faith, or whom he commends for their strong faith, had equally strong and certain evidence of his power and commission from the credible and incontestable reports they had heard of his miracles, which were performed on purpose to give evidence of his commission. Now in such a case, both this and the remarkable degree of their faith, as well as of their reasons, were also the gift of God. Strong faith and the open profession of it were very worthy of public encouragement and praise from our Savior, because of the great and public opposition which the magistrates, and the priests, and the doctors of the age made against Jesus the man of Nazareth when he appeared as the Messiah.
And besides all this, it may be reasonably supposed, with regard to some of those strong exercises of faith which are required and commended, that these believers had some further hints of inward evidence and immediate revelation from God himself. As when Peter confesses Christ to be the son of God (Matt 16:16-17), our blessed Savior commends him, saying, "Blessed are you, Simon Bar-Jonah," but he adds, "Flesh and blood has not revealed it to you, but my Father who is in heaven."
The same principle applies to the faith that produces miracles. The disciples and others were sometimes required to exercise this kind of faith, that is, when God assured them through inward and divine influences that certain miracles would happen. Their obedience to and cooperation with these divine revelations was expected and praised. This supernatural inspiration carried sufficient evidence for them, just as it did for the ancient prophets. We who have never experienced it are simply not as capable of judging and distinguishing it.
XXV. What I've said about truth and doctrine can also be confirmed when it comes to duties. The reasoning is the same for both: one concerns truths for our thinking, the other concerns truths for our practice. Duties that are explicitly required in the plain language of Scripture, or dictated by the most obvious reasoning from first principles, should bind our consciences more than those that are only doubtfully inferred from occasional occurrences, incidents, and circumstances. For instance, I am certain that I should pray to God. My conscience is bound to this because there are clear commands for it in Scripture, as well as arguments derived from reason. I also believe that I may pray to God either with a written form or without one, because neither reason nor revelation expressly requires either of these modes of prayer at all times or forbids the other. I cannot therefore bind my conscience to practice one so as to completely renounce the other. Instead, I would practice either of them as my reason and other circumstances direct me.
I believe Christians should remember Christ's death through the symbols of bread and wine. I also believe Christian churches should have pastors who are ordained or set apart in some way to lead worship and to bless and distribute the elements. However, this last practice isn't as explicitly commanded in Scripture as the first one is. Therefore, my conscience clearly requires me to remember Christ's death with some Christian community, even if their methods of ordaining pastors differ greatly from those of other churches or from my own views. It doesn't matter whether the person distributing these elements serves occasionally or permanently, since none of these details are clearly specified in Scripture. I must not neglect a direct command simply because some unnecessary details remain unclear. I trust I will receive approval from the God of nature and from Jesus, my judge on the last day, if I have tried to believe and practice everything in proportion to the evidence God has given me about it, or which He has enabled me to seek and obtain in the age and nation where I live.
Question: Will the stubborn deists and fatalists of Great Britain find adequate justification from this principle? I'll leave them to risk that terrifying experiment.
XXVI. We can follow these three rules when judging probabilities that must be determined by reason, whether they concern past or future events.
1. Whatever agrees most with the natural order of things carries the greatest probability, unless other circumstances counterbalance it. For example, if I release a greyhound within sight of a hare on a large plain, the greyhound will very likely catch her. Or consider a thousand sparrows: they will almost certainly fly away at the sight of a hawk among them.
2. What aligns most closely with consistent human observation or with frequently repeated experiments is most likely to be true. For example: winter in England will always bring some frost and snow; if you distribute large amounts of strong liquor to a crowd, many people will get drunk; a large gathering will hold different opinions on any uncertain matter; a thief will escape from prison if the doors are left unguarded at midnight.
3. When dealing with past or present facts where nature, observation, and custom provide no clear answer either way, we can derive probability from the testimony of wise and honest people, whether spoken or written, or from multiple witnesses who have seen and know what they report. In many cases, this testimony reaches the level of moral certainty. This is how we believe that tea grows in China, that the Turkish emperor lives in Constantinople, that Julius Caesar conquered France, and that Jesus our Savior lived and died in Judea. We believe that thousands converted to Christianity within a century of Christ's death, and that the books containing the Christian religion are genuine histories and letters written more than a thousand years ago. There are countless such statements that admit no reasonable doubt, even though they cannot be directly verified by our own senses or reasoning powers alone.
XXVII. Once you've thoroughly examined an issue and formed your judgment based on solid arguments in your mature years, after carefully weighing all sides of the question, it would be weak to keep wavering indefinitely. You should stand firm in such well-grounded principles and not be tempted to change your mind because of every difficulty or occasional objection. We shouldn't be blown about by every new teaching, like children tossed back and forth by the wind. It's good to have your heart established in grace, not in dietary rules: that is, in the great doctrines of the gospel of grace and in Jesus Christ, who is the same yesterday, today, and forever. But this firmness isn't as necessary in the smaller matters of religion, such as food and drink, forms and ceremonies, which are less important and for which Scripture hasn't given such explicit instructions. This is the advice of the great apostle (Eph 4:14; Heb 13:8, 9).
In short, those truths that serve as the foundation for daily practice should be settled as soon as possible, using the full exercise of our mature powers. But those things where we might possibly be mistaken should never be so absolutely and finally determined as if we were infallible. If the Catholics of Great Britain had maintained such stubborn certainty during the days of King Henry VIII or Queen Elizabeth, there would never have been a Reformation. Nor would any pagan have been converted, even under the ministry of St. Paul, if their obstinate commitment to their idolatries had kept their eyes shut against all further light. Yet this shouldn't prevent us from settling our most important principles of faith and practice where reason shines with its clearest evidence and the word of God plainly determines truth and duty.
XXVIII. But let's also remember this: while the Gospel is an infallible revelation, we're only fallible interpreters when we try to determine the meaning of even some important statements written there. Therefore, even if we feel firmly established in our belief about a particular interpretation of Scripture, and even if Providence clearly calls us to profess and subscribe to it, we still don't need to resolve or promise, subscribe or swear that we'll never change our minds. After all, it's entirely possible that in the natural course of things, we might encounter such a solid and substantial objection that it gives us a completely different view from what we once imagined, laying before us sufficient evidence for the opposite conclusion. We might discover a clearer light cast over the same Scriptures and see reason to change our views even on some important points. "This is what I believe, and this is what I will always believe" (or sic sentio, sic sentiam) is a lifelong prison for the soul and a barrier against all improvement of the mind. To impose such a profession on other people in matters that aren't absolutely necessary and aren't absolutely certain is a criminal usurpation and tyranny over faith and conscience, something that no one has the power to require except an infallible dictator.
CHAPTER 19
INVESTIGATING CAUSES AND EFFECTS
SOME effects are discovered by their causes, and some causes by their effects. Let's consider both of these. I. When we're investigating the causes of any particular effect or phenomenon, whether in the natural world or in the civil or moral affairs of people, we can follow this method:
1. Consider what effects or phenomena you've known of a similar nature, and what have been the certain and real causes of them. Like effects generally have like causes, especially when they're found in the same kinds of subjects.
2. Think about all the possible causes that might produce such an effect, then figure out from the circumstances how many of those possible causes can be ruled out in this specific case. From there, work your way through the probable causes until closer attention and inspection rule out some of those as well, gradually leading you to the real and certain cause.
3. Think about what things came before such an event or appearance that might have influenced it. While we can't determine the cause of something simply because it happened first, among the many things that came before, we can probably discover the true cause through further and more detailed investigation.
4. Think about whether one cause is enough to produce the effect, or whether it requires several causes working together. Then try as much as possible to determine how much influence each cause might have had in producing the effect, and what the proper role and contribution of each one was.
For example, in natural philosophy, if I want to find out what principles or causes produce that sensation we call heat when I stand near a fire, I'll find that several things must happen: the particles of fire must act on my skin, either directly or at least through the air between us; a particular kind of motion and stimulation must be impressed on my nerves; that motion must be transmitted to the brain; and my mind must pay attention to this motion. If any of these is missing, the sensation of heat won't be produced.
When I examine political upheavals in the same way, I might find that a revolution happened because of a ruler's tyranny or incompetence, or because his own people turned against him. This opposition could stem from religious persecution, violations of civil rights, invasion by a foreign army, or the emergence of someone (either at home or abroad) who claims the throne or champions the people's freedoms. Often several of these factors work together. We need to weigh each influence as carefully as we can, rather than attributing the entire outcome to just one cause.
II. When we investigate what effects a particular cause (or set of causes) will produce, we should follow this approach:
1. Examine each cause carefully on its own, and notice what effect each aspect or characteristic of it tends to create.
2. Look at the causes working together, considering their different natures and how they operate. Ask yourself how the properties of one might interfere with or strengthen the effects of another, and carefully weigh how much influence each one has.
3. Think about what the subject is that the cause will act on, because the same cause applied to different subjects often produces different results. The sun softens wax but hardens clay.
4. Make experiments frequently and carefully. Set in motion the causes whose effects you want to understand, and combine things in an organized way that seem most likely to produce useful results, based on the best assessment you can make of all the contributing causes and circumstances.
5. Pay close attention to everything that happens, whether through random chance bringing various causes together or through the deliberate work of knowledgeable people. When you see a positive result that occurs reliably and repeatedly, store it away in your mental collection of useful knowledge, along with whatever causes produced it.
6. Take a thorough look at all the circumstances surrounding how any cause (or combination of causes) produces a particular effect. Figure out, as much as you can, how each of those circumstances either helped, hindered, or altered the process, and therefore how much they influenced the final result.
Physicians practice and improve their skills in exactly this way. They study the known effects of specific herbs and drugs, thinking through what will happen when they combine them. Will one ingredient strengthen or weaken another? Will it counteract any harmful properties? Then they examine the patient's natural constitution and current condition, predicting how such a medicine will affect such a person. In unusual cases, they run careful experiments and closely track how particular compound medicines work on different constitutions and different diseases. Through this accumulation of sound observations, they develop an impressive level of skill in the art of healing. The preacher works similarly. He studies the doctrines and reasoning, the commands, the promises and warnings of God's word, considering their natural effects on the mind. He thinks about the natural tendency of a particular virtue or vice. He knows well that presenting certain truths may convince the understanding, while others may terrify the conscience, attract the lazy, or encourage the discouraged. He observes the temperament of his listeners, or of any individual who speaks with him about sacred matters, and he judges what effect each presentation will have on such people. He reviews and recalls what effects certain parts and methods of his ministry have produced. Through a careful survey of all these factors, he gains greater skill in his sacred work.
Note: In all these cases we must distinguish between causes and effects that are naturally and necessarily connected, and those that have only an accidental or contingent connection. Even when dealing with causes where the effect is merely contingent, we can sometimes reach a very high degree of probability. However, we cannot achieve the same certainty as when causes operate by evident and natural necessity, and effects necessarily follow from that operation. (See more on this subject in Logic, Part II, Chapter V, Section 7.)
CHAPTER 20
THE SCIENCES AND PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
I. THE best way to learn any science is to begin with a regular system, or a short and plain outline of that science, condensed into a manageable form, leaving out the deeper and more difficult parts, and doing so under the guidance and instruction of a skilled teacher. Systems are necessary to give a complete and comprehensive view of the various parts of any science, which may mutually influence each other toward explanation or proof. In contrast, if someone always and only reads essays and discussions on particular parts of a science, they will never obtain a distinct and accurate idea of the whole, and may perhaps omit some important part of it, even after seven years of reading such occasional pieces.
For this reason young students should focus on their systems much more than pamphlets. A person is never as qualified to judge particular subjects relating to any science if they have never surveyed the whole.
A clever writer once made this observation: imagine a primitive person who had never seen a palace or a ship examining their scattered, disconnected parts. Looking at the pillars, doors, windows, cornices, and turrets of the palace, or the prow and stern, the ribs and masts, the ropes and shrouds, the sails and tackle of the ship, he would form only a weak and confused idea of either of these excellent and useful inventions. In the same way, people who study only fragments or broken pieces of any field of knowledge, scattered across short, unconnected discussions, and who don't see how these pieces relate to each other or how they might fit together to create the beautiful symmetry of a complete system, can never grasp an entire body of truth. Instead, they will always see it as deformed and dismembered. Their ideas, which must remain forever unclear and often contradictory, will lie in the mind unsorted and thrown together without order or coherence: this is the knowledge of those who live on scraps of learning.
A talented young person with a lively imagination and an eager, ambitious spirit may construct in his own mind some attractive visions and appealing theories at the beginning of studying a subject, theories that are completely incompatible with some of the necessary and fundamental parts of that subject that appear in the middle or at the end. And if he never reads through and completes the whole course of study, he accepts and remains satisfied with his own hasty, appealing theories, storing these errors among his solid knowledge. Yet if he had continued his own labor and study further, he would have discovered his early mistakes and cured himself of his self-flattering delusions.
This explains why we have so many half-educated people today, and why some people's ideas are so confused and inconsistent. They spend all their study time on short essays and pamphlets, and they dismiss systematic works while claiming to be more sophisticated. The real reason they reject systematic learning, though, is simple laziness and poor judgment.
II. Once you've become familiar with a short, plainly written introduction to a subject, the next step (if you want thorough knowledge) is to read a full, comprehensive treatment of it. While you're reading this larger work, or after you finish it, you can then read specialized essays on particular aspects of the subject with real profit. These essays often contain significant corrections and improvements to what the introductions, or even the larger systematic works, have taught you (though they also contain some mistakes).
You should add these corrections or improvements as notes or commentary in the appropriate places, supplementing the main text you've read. A careful, thoughtful review of everything will then give you a solid grasp of the subject.
III. It's a great advantage to have a tutor, or friends and colleagues nearby, who can tell you which books on a subject (or on specific parts of it) are the best. Without this help, many people have wasted their time reading through entire volumes only to discover that those books weren't worth reading in the first place.
IV. Languages are best learned when you're young. At that age, your memory is mostly empty and ready to absorb new ideas constantly. We can see this in how children learn to speak their native language within just two years of being born.
V. The purely abstract sciences, which rely more on understanding and judgment and deal heavily in abstract ideas, shouldn't be forced on children too early. These include logic, metaphysics, ethics, politics, or the deeper complexities of grammar and literary criticism. That said, I should acknowledge that the basic elements of grammar are necessary (or at least very helpful) when a young person learns a new language. Similarly, some general, straightforward principles of morality and theology are needed to teach a child his duty to God and other people. But diving deep into abstract reasoning on these subjects goes beyond what children can handle.
VI. Several sciences will engage our younger years more naturally, and young boys can easily grasp the general parts of them. The basic principles and simpler practices of arithmetic, geometry, basic trigonometry, measuring heights, depths, lengths, distances, and so on: the fundamentals of geometry and astronomy, along with some mechanics, can be easily conveyed to sharp young people from nine or ten years old onward. These studies can be both entertaining and useful to young ladies as well as to gentlemen, and to everyone being educated for the learned professions. Young women can mix these studies with needlework and knowledge of household management. Boys can be taught to combine them with their basic grammar and their work in languages. And even those who never learn any language except their native tongue can be taught these sciences with lasting benefit in their early years.
That this can be done easily and effectively, consider these three reasons:
1. These subjects rely heavily on diagrams, numbers, images, lines, figures, and tangible objects. This means the imagination will significantly help the mind grasp them, making the learning process much easier.
2. These studies are so enjoyable that they make the tedious work of memorizing words, phrases, and languages more bearable for boys in Latin school through this delightful combination. Getting young people involved in these subjects will draw them away from many of the pointless games of childhood. They'll discover far more satisfying ways to spend their free time by exploring these appealing branches of knowledge.
3. Understanding these areas of science is both accessible and worth remembering for all children as they grow into adults, since they prove useful throughout every stage of human life. They help expand the mind early and provide exposure to valuable subjects from a young age. Surely it makes more sense, whenever possible, to teach children things they should never forget, rather than letting them waste years on trivial matters or difficult vocabulary that isn't worth remembering in the first place.
I can't help but wonder why any modern author would try to teach the outdated physics of Descartes, or even the brilliant discoveries of Sir Isaac Newton (his theories about celestial bodies and their movements, his work on light and color, and other parts of his natural philosophy), or attempt to explain the workings of the heavens, earth, and planets to children without using any illustrations or diagrams. How can you give a boy or a young woman clear, accurate understanding of these subjects without lines and figures to show them? Don't their minds need the help of visual imagery to form stronger and more precise ideas deep in their consciousness? Or do these authors really think that young people can grasp all these beautiful complexities of nature without the same tools that mature adults find essential? I'd rather not name specific books, since some of these writers are said to be gentlemen of considerable learning.
VII. After we've first learned and worked through any of those arts and sciences that require diagrams, figures, and charts (such as geometry, geography, astronomy, optics, mechanics, and so on), the best way to keep them fresh in memory is to hang those charts and figures on large sheets of paper where we'll always see them: in studies, living rooms, halls, bedrooms, entryways, staircases, and elsewhere. This way the learned images will constantly impress themselves on the brain and will keep the knowledge that depends on them alive and fresh in the mind throughout our growing years. The diagrams and figures alone will continually bring back to our thoughts those theorems, problems, and corollaries that were demonstrated through them.
It's remarkable how much geography you can learn this way using the two terrestrial hemispheres, along with specific maps and charts of the earth's coasts and countries cleverly arranged around us. You can also learn the constellations by hanging up accurate projections of the celestial sphere in the same manner. And I have to admit, for most people learning astronomy, I prefer the star projection that includes all the stars visible from our horizon, which extends to 38 1/2 degrees southern latitude even though its center is the north pole. This gives us a better view of the heavenly bodies as they appear to us each night, and with a little instruction, it can easily be used as a nocturnal to show the true hour of the night.
But remember, if these maps or projections have any coloring, it should be applied thinly enough not to obscure or hide any of the lines, figures, or letters. Instead, most of the time they're slathered so thick with bright and garish colors, and hung so high above eye level that anyone trying to examine and read them can't, as if their only purpose were to make a flashy display on the wall, and they're hanging there merely to cover the bare plaster or paneling.
You can organize sciences that work well in table format by hanging them on walls in convenient locations. This works for brief summaries of history, chronology, and similar subjects. In fact, you can break down the structure of any art or science into a kind of skeleton and display it on tables, showing how the various parts and subjects connect and depend on each other. Mr. Solomon Lowe has successfully converted the grammar of several languages into such tables. Reviewing these summaries and condensed versions frequently would help imprint them on your brain once you've learned them well. This practice would keep those learned pathways active and support a struggling memory. You could create a similar outline of Scripture history and use it to reinforce the ideas that daily reading provides.
VIII. Anyone who claims to be a scholar should develop at least a basic, surface-level understanding of most or all the sciences. Human knowledge contains certain connections across its various parts, so concepts borrowed from any one science can help you understand another, whether through explanation, illustration, or proof. That said, some sciences are much more closely related than others.
IX. When first studying any science (and when reviewing it later), focus mainly on the parts that most directly support your particular profession or your general calling as a Christian. Always pay attention to what you've personally found most necessary and useful throughout your life. Age and experience will teach you which sciences, and which parts of them, have proven most valuable. But in your younger years, you're not equipped to make these judgments well, so you should seek advice from people who are older.
X. We have three learned professions: theology, law, and medicine. While every scholar or gentleman should know enough about all the sciences to avoid looking completely lost when common topics come up, not everyone needs to master their complexities or reach the heights that specialists have achieved. A reasonable knowledge of these fields can benefit any profession, not only because all arts and sciences connect with each other, but because growing in knowledge brings genuine pleasure, earns respect, and makes you more welcome in any company.
But let's look more closely at several of these fields as they relate to the learned professions, starting with mathematics.
XI. Although I've often praised mathematical studies, particularly arithmetic and geometry, as ways to steady a wandering mind, develop focused attention, and strengthen reasoning ability, I don't mean to suggest that everyone should pursue these sciences to the extensive lengths that modern scholars have taken them. That's neither necessary nor appropriate for any students except the few who will make mathematics their main profession and life's work, or those gentlemen whose abilities and natural inclinations suit these studies and who have every advantage for advancing in them.
The basic principles of arithmetic, algebra, geometry, and trigonometry, along with geography, modern astronomy, mechanics, statics, and optics, all have valuable and excellent uses. They not only exercise and improve our mental faculties, but the subjects themselves are genuinely worth knowing at a moderate level. They often prove remarkably useful in everyday life. The material Dr. Wells provides in his three volumes titled The Young Gentleman's Mathematics is more than sufficient for most scholars or gentlemen, though there may be individual treatises on some of these subjects that are better written and more helpful to read than those by that learned author.
However, diving into the obscure difficulties and depths of modern algebra and fluxions, the various methods of quadratures, the measurement of all kinds of curves and their mutual transformation, and twenty other things that some modern mathematicians pursue, simply isn't worth the effort for those planning to enter any of the three learned professions: divinity, law, or medicine. This is the judgment of a notable figure, Dr. George Cheyne, who was himself highly skilled in these subjects and wrote extensively on them. He insists that they are barren and insubstantial studies for anyone to devote their life to entirely, and that indulging and reveling in these intensely captivating contemplations is only appropriate for public professors or for gentlemen of independent means who have a strong inclination in this direction and a talent suited to developing them.
But, as he admits, here's a painful truth: while these studies may sharpen our creativity, strengthen our imagination, improve our reasoning abilities, and prove useful in both essential and refined mechanical arts, they do nothing to correct our will, soften our temperament, or improve our character. In fact, they often leave weak minds rigid, dogmatic, and self-satisfied, which does far more harm to society and to the ultimate purpose of our existence than all their benefits can make up for. He goes further, warning that diving deep into these studies tends to breed a subtle and sophisticated pride, an arrogant and overbearing vanity that stands in complete opposition to the true spirit of the Gospel. This leads people to assume they know everything compared to their fellow human beings who haven't reached their level of understanding. These studies should only be trusted to those who have developed a humble heart, a modest spirit, and a sensible, teachable attitude. See Dr. Cheyne's preface to his Essay on Health and Long Life.
XII. Some practical aspects of geometry, astronomy, sundial construction, optics, statics, mechanics, and similar fields can provide pleasant entertainment and mental stimulation for students in any profession during their free time, assuming their circumstances allow them access to the necessary tools for this kind of learning. But they must be extremely careful not to let these pursuits encroach on more essential work, or they'll find themselves guilty of wasting time.
Yet I can't help observing that when students or young gentlemen master a variety of elegant mathematical problems in their early years, and learn the most accessible, refined, and engaging experiments in natural philosophy, along with some brief and appealing work in any of the other arts and sciences, they lay a foundation for earning the respect and affection of the people they meet, whether in higher or lower social circles. This knowledge often protects them from the temptation of idle pleasures, and it saves both their own time and their companions' time from being wasted on aimless wandering and trivial pursuits, and from countless foolish conversations. Gaming and drinking, along with many criminal and foolish scenes of talk and action, have been prevented by these innocent and enriching forms of knowledge.
XIII. History is an essential study, above all for gentlemen involved in politics. The governance of nations, and the distressing and devastating events that have in every age followed the mistakes of politicians, should always be present in their minds to warn them against similar conduct. Geography and chronology, which tell us precisely where and when such transactions or events occurred, are the eyes of history, and absolutely necessary to accompany it to some degree.
But history, insofar as it relates to the affairs of the Bible, is as necessary to ministers as to gentlemen of any profession. It helps us resolve many difficulties in Scripture and demonstrates divine Providence. Dr. Prideaux's Connexion of the Old and New Testament is an excellent work of this kind.
XIV. Among the shorter historical works, biography holds a high place in my estimation. The memoirs of great and good people deserve to be read by anyone who devotes themselves to the study of theology. In these accounts we often find our holy religion put into practice, with many aspects of Christianity shining with transcendent and exemplary light. We learn how deeply great and good people have felt the ruins of human nature caused by the first rebellion against God, and how they toiled and labored, turning themselves in every direction to seek recovery in vain, until they found the Gospel of Christ to be an all-sufficient relief. These biographies furnish us with effective and unanswerable evidence that the religion of Jesus, with all its self-denials, virtues, and devotions, is entirely practicable, since some wise and holy people have carried it to such a degree of honor. We are assured that the pleasures and satisfactions of the Christian life, in its present practice and future hopes, are not mere raptures of fantasy and enthusiasm, when some of the strictest advocates of reason have added the sanction of their testimony.
In short, the lives or memoirs of pious people, when well written, have been of infinite and unspeakable advantage to the disciples and professors of Christianity. They have given us admirable examples and rules for how to resist every temptation of a flattering or threatening world, how to practice important and difficult duties, how to love God above all and to love our neighbors as ourselves, to live by faith in the Son of God, and to die in the same faith, in sure and certain hope of a resurrection to eternal life.
XV. Remember that logic and metaphysics are essential disciplines, even though scholastic writers in earlier centuries badly misused them. Not just students preparing for theology, law, or medicine, but all educated people should at least gain a basic understanding of these subjects. The introduction of endless subtleties, hairsplitting distinctions, and meaningless technical terms without clear ideas has brought much of traditional academic logic and metaphysics into well-deserved contempt. Their logic has looked like nothing more than the art of arguing for argument's sake, and their metaphysics like the skill of splitting hairs, making distinctions without real differences, and slapping long, difficult names on ordinary things (and sometimes on confused jumbles of concepts that have no clear meaning at all).
Certainly, a massive pile of trivialities and irrelevancies has gotten mixed into these otherwise useful branches of learning. Because of this, many people in our sophisticated age have made it part of their social polish to mock these subjects. Being able to ridicule them skillfully has been considered a more valuable talent than actually understanding them.
But this goes to wild extremes, and we shouldn't abandon these areas of knowledge just because some earlier writers made fools of themselves with them. True logic teaches us to reason well and brings clarity to our understanding. True metaphysics (or ontology) illuminates everything we think about and study by organizing every kind of being with all its absolute and relative qualities, properties, modes, and characteristics into proper categories and classes. In doing so, it reveals how things relate to each other and what their general or specific differences are, which makes up a large part of human knowledge. This greatly helps us learn method, or how to arrange everything into its proper category and class of beings, attributes, or actions.
XVI. If I were to say anything about natural philosophy, I'd venture to put my thoughts this way:
I think it's extremely useful for a theologian to understand something about natural science. Simply knowing the natural history of birds, animals, and fish, of insects, trees, and plants, as well as weather phenomena like clouds, thunder, lightning, snow, hail, frost, and so on (in all their common or unusual forms) can be quite valuable to someone studying theology. It gives him broader and more delightful views of God's works and provides him with vivid and effective images and metaphors drawn from the vast book of nature to display and represent the things of God and religion in the most beautiful and moving ways.
And if simply knowing the history of these things proves useful for this purpose, it will surely be even more helpful to understand the reasons, causes, and effects behind these natural objects and phenomena, and to know the established laws of nature, matter, and motion by which God carries on His extensive works of providence from creation to this day.
I admit the old Aristotelian approach to this science teaches us very little worth knowing about these matters. However, the later writers who have explained nature and its operations in a more sensible and mathematical way are well worth the moderate study of a minister, especially those who have followed the principles of that wonder of our age and nation, Sir Isaac Newton. There is much pleasure and entertainment, as well as real profit, to be gained from those admirable improvements that have been advanced in natural philosophy in recent years through the assistance of mathematical learning, as well as from the multitude of experiments that have been conducted and are still being conducted on natural subjects.
XVII. This is a science that indeed belongs primarily to the physician: he ought to know all the parts of human nature, what the sound and healthy functions of an animal body are, and what the diseases and dangers are that threaten it. He should also possess extensive knowledge of plants and animals, and everything that makes up the materia medica (the ingredients from which medicines are made), and many other things in natural philosophy that serve his profession, as well as the related art of surgery.
XVIII. Questions about the powers and operations of nature may also sometimes fall within the lawyer's area of concern, especially those relating to assaults, wounds, murders, and so on. I remember reading about a trial of a man for murder by drowning, in which the judge on the bench heard several arguments concerning whether the lungs were filled or not filled with water, by inspiration or expiration, and so forth. He confessed himself so much a stranger to all of this that it did not bring him any great honor in public.
XIX. But I believe no minister who has the opportunity should be completely ignorant of this knowledge. With help from this study, he will be better equipped to observe the various monuments of creative wisdom in the heavens, the earth, and the seas with wonder and worship. And by using a moderate skill in this science, he may communicate so much of the astonishing works of God in forming and governing this visible world, and instruct many of his hearers in such a way that may help transfer the same ideas into their minds and raise them to the same delightful exercises of devotion. O Lord, how many are your works! In wisdom you have made them all! They are sought out by all who take pleasure in them.
Besides, every student of theology should notice that he ought to have some acquaintance with the principles of nature, so that he may judge a little how far they will go. That way he may not be tricked into taking every strange appearance in nature for a miracle, he may reason more clearly on this subject, he may better confirm the miracles of Moses and of Christ, and he won't surrender his faith to any claims of prodigy and wonder, which are either the occasional and uncommon operations of the elements, or the crafty tricks of men well skilled in philosophy and mechanical operations to deceive the simple.
XX. Understanding animal nature, the rational soul, and how these two aspects of our makeup affect each other is also worth a theologian's attention. People in this role need to assess how much our physical nature influences specific behaviors and practices. They should understand whether particular human appetites or passions originate in the body or the mind, how much we can moderate them, how much we should suppress them, and what methods work best for achieving these goals. This knowledge also helps us determine when these passions or appetites are acceptable and when they cross into sin. We can make this judgment by examining how much they fall under the will's control and how much we can change and correct them through vigilance, attention, and effort.
This profession should also be equipped to address questions about genuine inspiration or prophecy, wild enthusiasm, convulsive episodes, depression or madness, and similar phenomena. Theologians need to know what guidance to offer when these situations arise.
XXI. After studying natural phenomena and understanding human nature (which combines both body and soul), I believe natural religion deserves the next place in our attention. This field divides into two parts: first, the speculative or contemplative aspect, which involves knowing God in His various perfections and in His relationships to His rational creatures, as far as we can know Him through the light of nature. This used to be called the second part of metaphysics. Second, there's the practical or active dimension, which covers the various duties that arise from our relationship to God, our relationships to other people, and the proper conduct and governance of ourselves. This has traditionally been called ethics, or moral philosophy.
XXII. Every educated person should understand these subjects, not only because they help us develop more accurate views of revealed religion and Christianity (which are built on these foundations), but because every branch of natural religion and moral duty is contained and necessarily implied in all the revealed religions that God has ever given to the world. We should be suspicious of any religion claiming to come from God that rejects any part of natural duty.
Whether people lived under the system of the patriarchs, or of Moses, or the prophets, or of our Lord Jesus Christ, we are still required to know the one true God and to practice all the worship and reverence, all that love for Him, that faith in His perfections, along with that obedience and submission to His will, which natural religion demands. We are still required to exercise that justice, truth, and goodness toward our neighbors, that restraint and moderation of our own appetites and passions, and that proper behavior toward ourselves and all our fellow creatures around us, which moral philosophy teaches. No form of revealed religion will excuse us from these natural obligations: and a thorough familiarity with the various appetites, inclinations, and passions of human nature, along with the best methods to rule and restrain, to direct and govern them, are our constant business and should be our lifelong study.
Yet I would offer this caution, namely: Since students are instructed in the knowledge of the true God in their lectures on Christianity, and since among the Christian duties they are also taught all the moral principles of the light of nature, or a complete system of ethics, there is no absolute necessity of learning these two parts of natural religion as distinct sciences, separate and by themselves. But still it is of great importance for a tutor, while he is teaching his students these parts of the Christian religion, to point out how far the light of nature or mere reason will instruct us in these doctrines and duties, and how far we are dependent on divine revelation and Scripture for clearing up and establishing the firm foundations of the one, for giving us superior motives and powers to practice the other, for raising them to more elevated degrees, and building such a glorious superstructure on them.
XXIII. Studying natural religion (that is, what we can know about God and moral virtue through reason alone) serves an important purpose: it provides the most powerful proof for the truth of divine revelation and Scripture. However, once we've established the Bible's divine authority, Scripture itself becomes a sufficient source from which most people can learn theology and Christian doctrine for their daily faith, practice, and eternal salvation. In this sense, theology is essential for anyone who hopes to receive God's favor and enjoy the happiness of the world to come. It matters infinitely more than any of the arts and sciences connected to the learned professions of this earthly life.
XXIV. I should probably say something about studying civil law, or the law of nature and nations.
If we want to speak with precision and accuracy, civil law refers to the specific legal system of each state, country, or city. However, what we typically mean by civil law today is a collection of laws drawn from the best of Roman and Greek legal traditions, which was largely accepted and followed throughout the Roman territories for more than twelve hundred years. The Romans built the foundation of this law from what they called the twelve tables, which were summaries of the laws of Solon in Athens and of other Greek cities famous for their knowledge and wisdom. To these they added their own ancient customs from the city of Rome, along with the laws enacted there. These written laws were open to various interpretations, which led to daily disputes that were resolved by the judgments of learned scholars. These judicial decisions were what they first called Jus Civile. Over time, all of this grew into an enormous number of volumes. Eventually, the emperor Justinian ordered his chancellor Tribonian to consolidate them into a complete system, and this is what we call the body of civil law.
XXV. But what matters most for all educated people to understand is the law of nature, or the knowledge of right and wrong among human beings, whether it applies to individual persons or entire communities, as far as common reason and natural understanding can guide us. This is what Puffendorf calls the law of nature and nations, as you'll see if you look at section 3, chapter III of that invaluable volume he wrote on the subject. It deserves the careful study of every educated person, especially lawyers and theologians, along with other works on the same topic.
If a question concerns rights, property, or justice between people in any civilized country, it must be decided primarily according to that country's specific statutes and laws. However, knowledge of natural law will significantly help both lawyers and judges in reaching their decisions. This knowledge proves equally valuable to ministers, not only in resolving moral questions and answering difficult inquiries people bring to them, but also in their study of God's law, understanding obedience and disobedience, grasping the nature of duty and sin, and comprehending rewards and punishments.
XXVI. I mentioned languages earlier, but let me return to the subject here and offer a few thoughts about studies commonly called philological: history, languages, grammar, rhetoric, poetry, and criticism.
At minimum, familiarity with some of the learned languages is necessary for all three learned professions.
Even lawyers, who need foreign languages least, should understand Latin. For many centuries, lawyers wrote and conducted all important legal matters in that language, just as physicians wrote prescriptions in Latin and theologians cited Scripture in Latin. Prayers were also required to be said publicly and privately in the Roman tongue: the Lord's Prayer and Hail Marys made up half the devotions of those times. These cruel impositions on the people prevented them from reading in their own language what was being done to or for their souls, their bodies, or their property. I strongly suspect this all stemmed from the cunning and strategy of the priesthood and the Church of Rome, which tried to aggrandize itself and elevate its own profession into a sovereign tyranny, making mere slaves of the laity by keeping them in complete ignorance, darkness, and dependence. And they were willing to strike a deal with the physicians and lawyers, allowing them a small share in this tyranny over the common people, in order to maintain their own supreme dominion over everyone.
But thank God the world has grown somewhat wiser. In recent years the British Parliament has been pleased to grant relief from that bondage in legal matters as well, just as in the age of the Reformation we were delivered from saying our prayers in Latin, from being forced to read the word of God in a tongue unknown to the people, and from living in everlasting subjection to the clergy in matters of this life and the life to come.
But to return to the main point: there are still so many procedural forms in the legal system, and so many things called by Latin names in the practice of law, and so many strange words with Latin endings, that lawyers must understand this language. Some familiarity with old French is also necessary for the same people and professions, since Littleton's treatise on land tenure (which is something like a Bible to lawyers) was written in that language. This tongue has been woven into some forms of English law ever since the days of William the Conqueror, who came from Normandy in France.
XXVIII. Doctors should know Greek as well as Latin, because their great master Hippocrates wrote in that language, and his writings are still valuable and useful. A multitude of the names (both of body parts, diseases, and medicines) come from the Greek language. There are also many excellent books on medicine, both theoretical and practical, which are written in Latin, and the medical profession should not be ignorant of them.
XXIX. Those who intend to study theology should also be well acquainted with Latin, because it has been the language of academic institutions for many hundreds of years. Their debates are generally limited to that language, and many excellent books on theology would remain entirely hidden from students unless they are familiar with Latin authors.
Those preparing for ministry should make it their highest priority to become deeply familiar with their Bibles, both Old and New Testaments. This requires some knowledge of the original languages in which the Scriptures were written: Greek and Hebrew. Anyone who wants to pursue these studies with distinction should be able to read the Old Testament reasonably well in Hebrew, or at least know enough to determine the meaning of a passage with the help of a dictionary. But hardly anyone deserves to be called a solid theologian or a skilled teacher of the Gospel in our age of enlightenment and freedom unless he has a fairly strong grasp of Greek, since all the essential doctrines of Christianity come from the New Testament, which was originally written in that language.
30. As for Syriac and Arabic, if one theologian in thirty (or even one in three hundred) develops real expertise in these languages, that's sufficient. A handful of scholars skilled in these tongues can make enough observations to serve the entire Christian world, and their findings may occasionally prove useful to theologians who don't know these languages when they're reading the Bible. But the advantages of these languages aren't nearly as important as they've often been made out to be. My reader will agree with me when he considers that their main uses are these: Arabic is a language that shares some kinship and similarity with Hebrew, and we might occasionally be able to guess at the meaning of some rare and uncertain Hebrew word (one that appears only once or twice in the Bible) by looking at its supposed connection to Arabic. However, whatever guesses scholars might make about a Hebrew word's relationship to an Arabic root, there's no real certainty to be gained from it. Even words from the same language that clearly share the same root or origin give us only doubtful and inadequate information about the true meaning of related words that spring from the same source.
Let me give a couple of clear examples of this uncertainty. The word strages means slaughter; stratum is Latin for a bed; stramen means straw; and stragulum is a quilt or coverlet. All four derive from sterno, which means to throw down, to kill, or to spread out. I challenge any critic to tell me what definite meaning they could assign to any of these four words simply by looking at their relationship to each other or their common origin in one verb. Here's another example: who can tell me the exact meaning and precise idea of the word "honest" in English, and assure me that it signifies a man of integrity, justice, and moral uprightness, even though it clearly comes from honestus in Latin? Yet honestus carries a very different idea and refers to a man of some social standing, or a man of honor. Anyone can see, then, how little help toward explaining the Hebrew language can possibly come from all the languages of Arabia. Surely a great deal of the long scholarly exhaustion and tiresome travels of men through that region is almost pointless and useless for making the Hebrew Bible better understood.
As for the Syriac language, I'll grant there may be some small advantage in knowing it, because there's a very ancient translation of the New Testament in that tongue. Perhaps this can sometimes provide a proper and fitting meaning to a difficult and doubtful text, and offer a useful hint for recovering the true meaning of Scripture from the twisted interpretations of other writers. But there are several commentators and lexicographers who have been familiar with the Syriac language, and they've already given us the best of these hints in their writings on Scripture.
And after all, since none of these tools can give us sufficient proof of a true interpretation and provide a certain sense of a text, who would be convinced to waste any great number of his better hours in such dry studies, and in work of so little profit?
XXXI. The Chaldean language is much closer to Hebrew, and any theologian should have at least some familiarity with it, since several verses or chapters of Ezra and Daniel were written in that language. The old Jewish targums or commentaries, which were written in Chaldean, can sometimes shed light on difficult passages in the Old Testament.
That said, we must admit that knowledge of these Eastern languages doesn't deserve to be elevated as highly as some experts have insisted. They've pushed things beyond all reason and fairness, since hardly any of the most important topics in Christ's Gospel and the way of salvation can benefit from them.
XXXII. Now we come to the art of grammar. This is something distinct from simply knowing languages. After all, everyone learns to speak their native tongue from infancy through natural imitation of their mothers, nurses, and those around them, without any knowledge of grammar as an art or the various observations and rules that go with it. Grammar is really nothing more than rules and observations drawn from how people commonly speak in their various languages. It teaches us to speak and pronounce, spell and write with accuracy and correctness, according to the customs of those in every nation who are (or were) considered to speak and write their own language best. Now it's shameful for anyone who claims to be a scholar in any of the three learned professions not to be somewhat familiar with the proper use of those languages he ought to work with in his daily studies, especially those he may sometimes be called on to write as well as read.
XXXIII. After grammar, we move on to consider rhetoric.
Rhetoric in general is the art of persuasion, which can be divided into three parts: (1) conveying the speaker's meaning to the listeners' understanding in the clearest and most intelligible way, using the plainest expressions and the most vivid and striking representations, so that the mind becomes thoroughly convinced of the thing being proposed; (2) persuading the will effectively to choose or refuse the thing being suggested and represented; (3) raising the emotions in the most vivid and forceful manner, so as to set the entire soul and every power of human nature to work in pursuing or avoiding the thing under debate.
To achieve this goal, considerable skill is necessary not only in how matters are represented to the audience, but also in the arrangement or method of introducing these particular representations, along with the reasons that might convince and the various methods that might persuade and prevail on the listeners. There are certain moments when a violent torrent of speech, delivered in a disguised and concealed method, may prove more effective than all the precise forms of logic and reasoning. Questions and exclamations sometimes occupy a large place and produce a powerful effect in this sort of discourse, and no figure of speech should be absent here if the speaker has enough skill to introduce it successfully.
Teachers of rhetoric have laid down many observations and rules to help young talents develop the glorious abilities that gave Cicero and Demosthenes such tremendous influence and success in their own time and place, and such lasting fame across all nations and ages. These rules can certainly be studied with great benefit. But natural talent, a lively imagination, and strong passions, combined with solid knowledge of the subject being discussed and constant reading of the best orators' writings and listening to the best speakers, will do far more to create an orator than all the technical rules in the world could ever do without these natural gifts and careful imitation of the most accomplished and successful speakers.
XXXIV. You might immediately assume that lawyers arguing cases in court have great need of this art of rhetoric. But there's been legitimate debate about whether pleading in British courts of justice, before a skilled judge, should rely on rhetoric for anything beyond teaching how to present a case clearly and lay it out in the most transparent, complete, and unbiased way possible before the person who must decide. Since impartial justice is what we're after, no tricks should be used, no eloquence or powerful language employed to sway the will or manipulate the emotions, in case the judge's final decision gets tilted or twisted toward injustice. For this reason, John Locke wanted to ban all lawyers who work for fees from his proposed government of Carolina (you can find this in his posthumous works), though that great man was perhaps too harsh in condemning the entire profession so broadly.
XXXV. But the situation is completely different when it comes to ministers: the eloquence of the pulpit, without question, has a much wider scope.
Preachers aren't arguing a case of right and wrong before a wise and skilled judge. Instead, they're addressing every level of society: the high and low, the wise and foolish, the sober and corrupt. Their job is to persuade all these people to pursue and stick with virtue in their own lives, to practice justice and kindness toward their neighbors, and to show devotion to God. These matters carry eternal significance, and most of the people hearing these messages aren't wise and skilled judges at all. They're pulled in the opposite direction by their own sinful desires and passions, and they're bribed or swayed by the corrupt customs of the world around them.
Given the complexity and variety of human nature, we need more than just a clear and honest presentation of facts to convince people's reason and judgment. We also need every bit of skill and persuasive force we can muster, aimed directly at the will and the emotions. This is exactly what Cicero did when he addressed the entire Roman Senate, and what Demosthenes did when he spoke to the Athenian people. Both faced audiences with vastly different capacities and inclinations, which is why they deployed every tool at their disposal: the lightning and thunder of rhetoric, the full range of entreaties and warnings, all the smooth elegance and ornate beauty of language their training could provide. Ministers in the pulpit face much the same kind of listeners, and they should follow these ancient examples. Certainly, the mind should first be convinced through the clearest and strongest reasoning available. But once that foundation is laid, every powerful motive that legitimately influences human nature should be brought to bear. Every emotional chord should be struck to wake up the dull and careless, to pierce and soften the hardest hearts, to win over the reluctant, to stir the lazy, to bring back the stubborn, and to reform the corrupt. At the same time, these appeals should encourage those who are already humble and devout, supporting both their practice and their hope. Humanity has fallen into such a catastrophic state of corruption and such a terrible separation from God (and from everything holy and happy) that preachers should use every bit of eloquence they possess to rescue the world from its shameful ruin and misery through the Gospel of our blessed Savior. Their goal should be to restore humanity to virtue and devotion, to God and happiness, through the divine power of this Gospel. May such outstanding masters of sacred oratory never be lacking in the pulpits of Great Britain!
XXXVI. Should I now share my thoughts on poetry?
Anyone who claims to have a good education or any learning should read poetry, whether in classical or modern languages, during their leisure time. There are several good reasons for this.
1. Many couplets or stanzas contain a variety of moral lessons or practical rules that apply both to everyday wisdom and to religious matters. The poetic rhythm (and rhyme, if present) makes these much easier to remember.
Beyond that, poets offer many elegant and admirable insights or descriptions that are worth memorizing. The particular rhythms of verse help us recall these excellent passages, which can sometimes lift our conversation above trivial and mundane topics.
2. In heroic verse, and especially in the grander lyric poems, you sometimes find such noble heights of thought and feeling that they illuminate everything around us. They convey to the soul the most exalted and magnificent images and sublime ideas. These provide us with glorious resources to expand and enrich our thinking, to warm our souls, to awaken our better emotions, and to lift them to a divine level for devotional purposes. The lyric ode has shown the world some of the finest examples of this kind, and I have to say that this form of poetry has been my favorite above all others.
I've always believed that the great heroic poems (Greek, Latin, or English) that have won the highest fame in the world still lack something essential: they aren't sufficiently varied, elevated, or animated because they fail to intersperse an elegiac or lyric ode now and then. This could have been done with beautiful appropriateness whenever the poet introduces a song at a feast, the joys of a victory, soliloquies of divine satisfaction, or the pensive and despairing agonies of distressing sorrows. Why should what we call the most glorious form of poetry be bound down and confined to such a long and endless uniformity of meter, when it should kindle or melt the soul, swell or sink into all the various and transporting changes that human nature is capable of? Cowley, in his unfinished fragment of the Davideis, has shown the way to this improvement. Whatever flaws may be found in other parts of that heroic attempt, this beauty and glory of it deserves to be preserved for imitation. I'm convinced that if Homer and Virgil had happened to practice it, every critic would have renowned and glorified it. I'm greatly mistaken if this wise mixture of meters wouldn't represent a further reach of perfection than they ever attained without it. Remember: it isn't nature and strict reason, but a weak and fearful reverence for antiquity and the opinions of fallible men, that has established those Greek and Roman writings as absolute and complete models. In several ages there have been learned men who have very justly disputed this glory and have pointed to many of their mistakes.
3. But there's another purpose for reading poetry, and perhaps the most valuable benefit for most people: it gives us the richest and most refined variety of words and phrases for every situation in life or religion. Anyone who writes good verse will often need to search through every possible word that expresses a particular idea in the language, so they can match the meter or rhyme of their verse, or capture their own most beautiful and vivid sense of what they're describing. By reading a lot of this kind of writing, we'll gradually develop the habit and skill of expressing our ideas in the most appropriate and beautiful language, whether we're writing or speaking about God or everyday matters.
It's unfortunate that some of these talented writers have occasionally allowed something crude or impure to stain their pages and assault their readers' ears, or to violate the standards of the finest virtue and refinement. Still, among the writings of Mr. Dryden, Mr. Pope, and Dr. Young, as well as others, there's plenty to choose from in our own language that contains nothing indecent to offend the most modest speaker or listener.
Few writers in any country, and I would venture to say none in ours, have possessed a richer or more remarkable gift for bringing scenes to life, or have ever shown such vast and seemingly endless variety in their descriptions, as the celebrated Mr. Pope. If you read his translation of Homer's Iliad, you will find nearly every term or phrase in our language needed to express anything grand or magnificent. But if you read his Odyssey, which deals much more with everyday life, there is hardly any useful topic of conversation or thought, or any ordinary event, that he has not refined and presented in the most fitting language. And yet he has still elevated and enlivened even these humbler subjects with the most brilliant and pleasing touches.
I should also add that if this same author had more often turned his pen to religious themes, his short poem on the Messiah, along with parts of his letters between Abelard and Eloisa, and that ode on the dying Christian, give us ample proof that his pen would have honorably captured some of the tender scenes of repentant grief, as well as the loftier odes of the Hebrew Psalmist. Perhaps he would have revealed to us, better than any other translation has done, just how great a poet sat on the throne of Israel.
After everything I have said, there is yet another benefit to reading poetry: when the mind has grown tired from more demanding studies, or when it is somehow unfit for tackling more difficult subjects, it can be relaxed, so to speak, and rest for a while in the flowery meadows where the muses live. It is a genuine relief to the soul, when overtired, to entertain itself with the rhythms and beautiful sentiments of the poets. In a short time this pleasant diversion can restore weary spirits to energy and more important work.
XXXVII. These are my best observations about reading poetry. But what if someone asked me: Should a student with a bright mind never enjoy writing poetry? I would answer: Yes, but only when he absolutely cannot help it. A person of lesser talent, looking back in mature years, would sincerely wish he had spent far more time reading the best poets and far fewer hours trying to write verse himself. Yet I must admit (or at least suppose) that there may be times when a poetic soul can hardly restrain its imagination or cool its fire, when it's nearly impossible to hold back the overflowing rush of elevated thoughts and keep the mind from expressing itself in this kind of language. That is the only time, I believe, when this urge should be given free rein, especially for people who have committed themselves to entirely different professions. One reason is this: what they write in that inspired moment is more likely to carry something that rises above the ordinary, some genuine echo of the muse's voice.
XXXVIII. Beyond history, grammar, languages, rhetoric, and poetry, other subjects fall under what we call philological knowledge. These include familiarity with the beliefs, customs, manners, temperaments, and political systems of the world's various nations, or the distinct groups and tribes of humanity. This knowledge is essential for understanding history more deeply. Every lawyer or gentleman should acquire some acquaintance with these matters. Without them, he can never read history with real profit, nor can he maintain his position and character in life with honor and dignity.
XXXIX. Divinity students should develop a deeper understanding of Jewish laws, political structures, customs, and similar matters if they want to grasp many passages in both the Old and New Testaments and defend the biblical writers against attacks from skeptics. Familiarity with Roman and Greek history is equally important for interpreting various New Testament texts, helping honest seekers discover the true meaning of what the gospel writers and apostles intended, and protecting their writings from unreasonable criticism.
XL. Some people treat the art of criticism as a separate branch of language study, but it's really just a more precise and thorough mastery of the other components, combined with the ability to apply that knowledge whenever needed. This skill allows you to make sound judgments about these subjects, clarify obscure passages in the texts you read, fill in gaps, and correct errors in manuscripts or ancient copies. It helps you fix mistakes that authors and editors have made in understanding word meanings, resolve scholarly disputes, and ultimately spread more accurate knowledge among those who genuinely want to learn.
Anyone claiming to be part of the learned professions needs to either become a critic himself in matters of language and texts, or at least regularly consult the books that can help: dictionaries, paraphrases, commentaries, and works by other critics. These resources will resolve any difficulties you encounter and give you a more precise grasp of whatever field you're pursuing.
When someone reaches a level of expertise in these matters that qualifies him to practice criticism well, he needs to guard carefully against letting pride, vanity, contempt for others, or inner anger and arrogance creep into his observations and judgments. He should remember how frail all human beings are and how even the wisest people sometimes make mistakes. This will help him practice his craft with appropriate humility and fairness.
PART TWO
HOW TO COMMUNICATE KNOWLEDGE
The main purpose of the first part of this book is to guide us toward proper methods for improving our own knowledge. Now let's consider the best ways to improve other people's minds and share with them the knowledge we've gained. If we hoard and hide our mental treasures, they benefit no one except their owner. Even his own benefit from possessing them would be meager and limited compared to what those same treasures could yield, both to himself and to the world, through free sharing and distribution. Large amounts of knowledge acquired and kept by one person, like piles of gold and silver, would gather a kind of rust and become unattractive by sitting forever in secrecy and silence. But they shine and glitter when they circulate constantly among humanity.
The two main ways of conveying knowledge to others are through verbal instruction to our students, or by writing and publishing our thoughts to the world.
Here I will offer some observations about how to pass knowledge on to others, whether through formal lectures or casual conversation. I'll describe the main biases that students are likely to encounter, along with advice on how to avoid them. Then I'll mention some of the simplest and most effective ways to help people recognize their mistakes and to work with their minds when they're caught in the grip of prejudice. After that, I'll include as an appendix an essay I wrote many years ago on education, back when I was planning a more comprehensive work on the subject.
CHAPTER 21
EFFECTIVE TEACHING METHODS
Someone who has learned a subject thoroughly in a clear and systematic way, who has gained a sharp understanding and a comprehensive view of the whole topic, is usually best equipped to teach that same subject in a clear and accessible manner. Having developed a full and precise grasp of it himself, and having made it familiar through frequent reflection, reading, and occasional discussion, he can presumably see it from all angles, hold it (along with all its related elements and connections) in a single mental picture, and is better able to present it to the student from every perspective, with all its characteristics, relationships, and implications. He knows which angle or aspect of the subject to present first to his student, and how to introduce the part that's easiest to understand. He also knows how to frame it in a way that's most likely to attract the student's interest and support further exploration.
A great scholar doesn't always make the best teacher, even if he has a clear grasp of his subject and can survey its various branches methodically and comprehensively. He must also know how to use words as well as ideas, with enough variety that when his student doesn't grasp the concept in one form, he can rephrase it several different ways until he finally reaches the student's understanding and illuminates the truth clearly.
Beyond this, a tutor should have a pleasant and approachable temperament, with patience to tolerate slow comprehension or lack of insight in some students. He should also possess genuine generosity of spirit, offering gentle criticism of their foolishness, showing compassion for their mistakes, and using every kind and engaging method to instill knowledge in those who are willing and diligent in seeking truth, as well as correcting those who are straying into error. I've already discussed this somewhat in an earlier chapter, and I'll have occasion to say more about it shortly.
A particularly effective and useful way to guide someone toward a particular truth is through questions and answers, which is the Socratic method of discussion. I refer the reader to the chapter or section that covers this approach. For this reason, dialogues are used as an elegant and enjoyable way of introducing gentlemen and ladies to some of the sciences when they're not seeking the most rigorous and systematic form of learning.
However, the most useful and perhaps the most excellent way of instructing students in any of the sciences is by delivering lectures, as tutors in the academy do for their pupils.
Start by selecting a well-written book that provides a concise overview or summary of the subject. At the very least, it shouldn't be an overly lengthy and rambling work. If you can't find such a book already in print, you should create your own summary of the subject, covering its most essential and important elements, organized according to whatever method you think works best.
Have your student read a chapter or section of this book each day, and then expand on it in the following way: explain both the terminology and the concepts in greater detail. Pay special attention to anything unclear or difficult, clarifying and illustrating it through different ways of expressing the same idea and through relevant comparisons and examples. When the author's meaning is ambiguous, you need to pin it down and make it definite.
When the arguments are powerful and convincing, strengthen them through additional explanation, and make the logical connections crystal clear. When the arguments are weak or inadequate, either shore them up or discard them as unhelpful. Add new arguments if necessary to support the teaching.
Expand on anything the author treats too briefly. When several ideas are packed tightly together, separate them out and examine each one individually.
When you disagree with the author you're reading, gently identify and correct his errors.
When the book's structure and organization are sound and effective, follow them and point out their strengths. When they're flawed or disorganized, fix them.
Highlight the most essential, remarkable, and useful parts of the work or the subject for your students. Urge them to commit these to memory. At the same time, identify what's less necessary or excessive, so your student doesn't waste time on the less important aspects of the subject.
The teacher should explain the various purposes, applications, and practical uses of any science or branch of study, illustrating these points whenever he has the opportunity and resources to do so. This applies especially to mathematics and natural philosophy.
If the author's writing style has any particularly beautiful or flawed elements, the teacher should point these out appropriately.
While reading and explaining a specific work to his students, he can compare different editions of the same book or different authors writing on the same subject. He should tell them where other authors have treated the topic so they can read further, and in this way lead his students toward a deeper understanding, confirmation, or development of the subject he's teaching them.
Students also find it engaging and enjoyable when the teacher occasionally shares historical observations or useful stories he's encountered that relate to different aspects of the science being studied. However, he must not simply entertain his students with such stories while neglecting to give them solid, rational instruction on the actual subject at hand. Teachers should try as much as possible to combine profit with pleasure, mixing enjoyment into their instruction. At the same time, they must be careful not to merely amuse their students' ears and gratify their imagination without actually enriching their minds.
When delivering instructional lectures, the teacher should be deeply concerned that his students grasp his meaning. Therefore, he should frequently ask whether he's expressing himself clearly, whether they understand what he means, and whether they're absorbing all his ideas as he tries to convey them in his own words.
Anyone who teaches must use the clearest possible language to convey ideas easily to their audience. While teaching the sciences doesn't require the same conversational rules we follow in everyday speech (since technical terms and complex vocabulary are sometimes unavoidable), no one should use difficult language simply to show off their learning or adopt pompous phrasing without good reason. I'll return to this warning later.
I believe it's highly convenient and appropriate, if not absolutely necessary, for a tutor to review the previous lecture with students before moving on to the next one. By asking them questions, he can gauge their daily progress. Students might object: "Surely we're not schoolchildren who have to recite our lessons again. We came here to be taught, not to be quizzed and examined." But how can a teacher possibly continue if he doesn't know whether students are absorbing and retaining what they've learned?
Beyond that, I generally believe it's laziness or idleness, genuine ignorance, inability, or unreasonable pride that makes a student refuse to show his teacher how much he's gained from the last lesson. Without this regular assessment, young men have wasted years under the daily instruction of learned teachers. They've left the academy without mastering a single subject, and they've even shamefully lost the classical learning (that is, their knowledge of Greek and Latin) that they acquired in grammar school.
Teachers should always adapt to the natural abilities, temperament, and capacity of their students, using various prudent methods to attract, persuade, and help each one in their pursuit of knowledge.
When a student has less natural ability, the teacher should expand his explanations. He should investigate and discover exactly where the learner gets stuck, identify what's causing the difficulty, and then help the struggling mind work through it.
When a student shows a quick mind and lively curiosity through frequent questions, the teacher should reward such an inquisitive spirit by answering those questions as fully as is reasonable and practical. When these questions come at inappropriate times, he shouldn't shut down the young questioner with an authoritative rebuke, but should instead, with genuine warmth and gentleness, postpone those questions and redirect them to a better time.
Curiosity is a valuable source of knowledge: it should be encouraged in children and awakened through frequent, informal conversations with them. It should be nurtured in young people, though with sensible moderation. In those who have too much of it, curiosity should be limited by wise and gentle restraint or delay, so that by chasing after everything, they don't end up learning nothing thoroughly. In those who have too little, it should be stimulated, or else they'll become dull, narrow-minded, complacent, and never acquire a wealth of ideas or breadth of understanding.
The teacher shouldn't demand or expect overly complex and difficult things from the humble, modest, and timid student. When such a student gives a correct and thoughtful answer, even to straightforward and simple questions, the teacher should have words of praise and encouragement ready. He should nurture every spark of emerging understanding until it grows into clear insight and solid knowledge.
When he encounters a student who is cocky, dogmatic, and arrogant, the teacher should seize every appropriate opportunity to show him his error. He should display the absurdity in full view before him and prove his mistake through complete demonstration, until the student sees and feels it, and learns to be modest and humble.
A teacher needs to observe not just the different personalities and temperaments among students, but also watch how their reasoning develops and their understanding grows. He should work in his young classroom the way a skilled gardener works in his garden, applying thoughtful cultivation methods to every plant. Let him carefully and gently trim back irregular growth. Let him protect and encourage the tender beginnings of understanding until they bloom, and let him nurture the early fruits with care.
The tutor should seize every opportunity to teach his students and use every event in life to spark a profitable conversation. He should regularly ask his students questions that make them think, teaching them how to form inferences and draw one proposition from another.
Since reason is the mental faculty he's working with in his students, he should use every appropriate and accessible method to exercise it and expand its powers. He should frequently show them when an idea is clear or confused, when a proposition is obvious or doubtful, and when an argument is weak or strong. This way their minds will be so well trained that they'll readily accept whatever he presents with clear evidence and solid reasoning.
When any unusual events occur in the natural, moral, or political world, he should invite and teach them to make observations about it, and give them his own best reflections to improve their minds.
He should make it absolutely clear that he loves his students and that he wants nothing more than their growth in knowledge and their development in all valuable skills. This will win their affection for him personally and ensure they pay proper attention to his teaching.
And indeed there is little hope that a teacher will succeed in his instruction unless those who hear him have some good degree of esteem and respect for his person and character. And here I can't help but notice, by the way, that it is a matter of infinite and unspeakable injury to the people of any town or parish where the minister lies under contempt. If he has brought it on himself by his own conduct, he is doubly criminal because of the injury he does to the souls of those who hear him: but if this contempt and reproach are cast on him by the wicked, malicious, and unjust censures of men, they must bear all the ill consequences of receiving no good by his labors, and will be accountable hereafter to the great and divine Judge of all.
It would be very necessary to add in this place (if tutors weren't already well aware of it) that since learners are obliged to seek a divine blessing on their studies by fervent prayer to the God of all wisdom, their tutors should go before them in this pious practice and make daily address to Heaven for the success of their instruction.
CHAPTER 22
DEVELOPING A CLEAR TEACHING STYLE
The most necessary and most useful characteristic of a style fit for instruction is that it be plain, clear, and easy. And here I will first point out all those errors in a style which diminish or destroy the clarity of it, and then mention a few directions on how to obtain a clear and easy style.
The errors of style which must be avoided by teachers are these that follow.
1. The first problem is using too many foreign words that haven't really become part of our everyday language. Yes, when we're teaching academic subjects in English, we sometimes need to borrow terms from Greek and Latin because English simply doesn't have names for certain concepts. But when someone constantly throws in impressive-sounding words from ancient languages without any real need, or peppers their speech with French and other foreign expressions when plain English would work just as well, they're revealing a shallow and foolish mindset that's completely inappropriate for a teacher.
2. Stay away from a showy academic style that borrows terminology from various fields of study when your subject doesn't actually require it. Don't use technical jargon at every opportunity or try to display your education through elaborate vocabulary and obscure phrasing. That's what we properly call pedantry.
Young preachers fresh out of seminary often fall into the trap of stuffing their sermons with logical and metaphysical terminology when explaining their texts, feeding their congregations nothing but empty, impressive-sounding words. This academic language might satisfy their own ambition and create amazement at their learning among the wide-eyed crowd, but it does absolutely nothing to educate the uninformed or reform those living immoral or ungodly lives. These technical terms are simply the tools of a craftsman, meant to be used privately while the work is being done. The tools shouldn't be visible in the finished product.
Some people are so obsessed with geometry that they drag lines and circles, tangents and parabolas, theorems, problems, and postulates into every conversation. Others who have studied astronomy borrow their nouns and verbs from the stars and planets even in everyday speech. Instead of simply saying Jacob had twelve sons, they announce that Jacob had as many sons as there are signs in the zodiac. If they want to describe someone who can't make up his mind, they turn him into a planet and describe all his movements: direct, retrograde, and stationary. If a candle sits behind a screen, they call it eclipsed and spin elaborate tales about the orbit and revolutions, the radii and the circumference of a cart wheel.
Still others dress up their thoughts in chemical terminology. Extracts and oils, salts and essences enliven and strengthen their speech: a brilliant mind becomes sublimated spirit, and a fool is a dead residue (caput mortuum). One doctor, in his advertisement, puffs himself up when he tells the town that he has advised the counselors of several kings and princes, that he has mastered the knowledge of the green, black, and golden dragon, secrets known only to magicians and hermetic philosophers. If only the quacks had exclusive rights to this kind of language.
3. Some fancy, affected words are used only at court, and certain showy or grandiose phrases belong only to the theater. These should never appear in educational lectures. The language of poets contains too much metaphor to guide people toward clear and precise understanding. Poetry's purpose is to strike the soul with dazzling light and inflame the passions through spectacular imagery, powerful pictures, and an emotionally charged style. But teaching requires a different kind of speech, one better suited to leading the calm inquirer toward accurate understanding of things.
4. There's a crude, common style borrowed from the lower classes, the worst types of people, and the most trivial aspects of life: avoid this too. People with a good education presumably haven't grown up hearing such language and therefore won't understand it. Beyond that, it creates deeply unpleasant mental images when we borrow even comparisons from the kitchen, the manure pile, or the outhouse.
5. Avoid obscure, mysterious expression and murky language. Some people have been trained by their education, or misled by foolish prejudices, into a dark and incomprehensible way of thinking and speaking. This stays with them their entire lives, clouding and confusing their ideas. Perhaps some of these people were blessed with great and comprehensive intelligence, with remarkable natural abilities and a flood of ideas pouring into their minds. Yet because they lack clarity in how they form and express their thoughts, they sometimes drown their own subject and bury their argument in darkness and confusion. Preachers who have read extensively in the mystical theology of the Catholics and copied their manner of expression have often buried a fine mind under the obscurity of such a style.
6. Long, tedious writing is completely wrong for a teacher because it destroys clarity. Some learned writers never feel satisfied unless they pack every sentence with a huge number of ideas and thoughts. They inflate their propositions to monstrous sizes with explanations, exceptions, and precautions (all to avoid being misunderstood), and they cram everything into the same period. They obscure and muddy their writing with countless parentheses, and they stretch their sentences to exhausting lengths that go far beyond what ordinary readers can follow. Writers or speakers like this may possess deep knowledge, but they rarely know how to share it. Anyone who wants to develop a real gift for teaching others must learn to untangle and separate his thoughts when too many threaten to pile into one paragraph. He should speak three sentences clearly and distinctly, which the listener can absorb immediately with both ears and mind, rather than stuffing all his thoughts into one sentence that the listener forgets before he can even understand it.
But this brings me to the next topic I intended to address: some practical methods for achieving the kind of clarity in writing that good instruction requires.
1. Make a habit of reading authors who think and write with exceptional clarity and precision, authors who convey their ideas into your understanding as quickly as your eye or tongue can move across their sentences. This will create in your mind a habit of imitation. We naturally learn the style we encounter most often, and we practice it with ease and success.
2. Develop a clear and thorough knowledge of whatever subject you're writing about. Examine it from every angle and make yourself a complete master of it. Then you'll have all the relevant thoughts about it within your view and under your control, and your tongue will easily clothe those ideas with words once your mind has first made them so familiar and natural to itself.
Good sense is the source and foundation of good writing: when you know your subject well, the words will follow readily.
Horace, The Art of Poetry
Good teaching springs from good knowledge; words will hurry to follow things.
3. Master the language you speak. Learn all its idioms and special phrases that help you convey the ideas you need in the most varied and accessible ways to your listener's understanding. Being able to vary a phrase in several forms is incredibly useful for teaching: it's like turning all sides of a subject into view. If the learner doesn't grasp the ideas in one form of speech, another will probably succeed.
For this reason, I've always thought highly of a teaching method used in some Latin schools, which they call variation. Take a simple English sentence and turn it into many forms in Latin. For instance, A wolf let into the sheep-fold will devour the sheep: If you let a wolf into the fold the sheep will be devoured: The wolf will devour the sheep, if the sheep-fold is left open: If the fold isn't shut carefully, the wolf will devour the sheep: The sheep will be devoured by the wolf, if it finds the way into the fold open: There is no defense of the sheep from the wolf, unless it is kept out of the fold: A slaughter will be made among the sheep, if the wolf can get into the fold. By turning the active voice of verbs into the passive, and the nominative case of nouns into the accusative, and altering the connection of short sentences by different adverbs or conjunctions, and by ablative cases with a preposition brought instead of the nominative, or by particles sometimes put instead of the verbs, the negation of the contrary instead of the assertion of the thing first proposed, you create a great variety of forms of speech that express the same sense.
4. Build up a rich vocabulary of synonyms. Fill your memory with different words that express the same idea. This not only gives you the benefits of varied phrasing I mentioned earlier, but it also makes your writing more elegant by helping you avoid repetition. Using the same words too often can wear on your listener's patience.
5. Learn to break up long sentences into shorter ones. When other writers connect two or three ideas using relative pronouns (which, whereof, wherein, whereto, and so on) and frequently insert parentheses, you should split those ideas into separate sentences instead. If you absolutely must connect them, use simple conjunctions so they still feel like distinct thoughts rather than confusing your reader.
The best way to master this skill is to occasionally take a page from an author who writes in that long, tangled, parenthesis-heavy style and translate it into clearer English. Break the ideas apart, multiply the periods, and keep working until the language flows smoothly and makes sense on the first reading.
6. Practice explaining new subjects to young people or those unfamiliar with the topic, and keep checking whether they actually understand you. This will force you to rephrase and vary your expressions until you find the right way to reach them and get your ideas across clearly.
CHAPTER 23
PERSUASION AND CORRECTING ERRORS
When we arrive at a sound and rational opinion, whether it concerns religion or everyday life, we naturally want to bring everyone else around to our way of thinking. But this desire springs from the pride of wielding influence over others far more often than it comes from a sense of duty or a genuine love of truth: human nature is that corrupt. Still, there is such a thing as an honest, sincere delight in spreading truth, one that arises from a dutiful regard for our Maker's honor and a genuine love for humanity. If we want to succeed in convincing people of their errors and promoting truth, we need to strip away as much of that pride and self-importance as possible and cultivate a selfless love for others and a passion for truth that will naturally guide us toward the best methods for advancing it.
Here are some useful guidelines:
1. If you want to convince someone of his mistake, choose the right place, the right moment, and the best circumstances for the task. Don't approach him at an inconvenient time when he's busy with other matters, but when his mind is free and available to listen and pay attention. Don't bring up the subject when his emotions are stirred up or unsettled by life's events, and especially not when he has worked himself into a passion defending the opposite view. Instead, wait for a golden opportunity when something in life might cast a favorable light on the truth you want to convince him of, or when circumstances might reveal the dark and unfortunate consequences of the error you're trying to free him from. Life offers certain ideal moments (mollissima tempora fandi) for approaching someone, and if you handle them correctly, your efforts will be far more successful and his change of mind easier and more pleasant.
2. Show the person you're trying to teach, through everything you do, that you genuinely care about their wellbeing. Make it clear that your goal isn't to defeat their argument, expose their ignorance, or highlight their inability to defend their position. Let them see that you're not trying to boost your own reputation as a debater or set yourself up as some kind of teacher to the world. Instead, demonstrate that you care about them and want what's best for them. Don't just tell them this when you're starting an argument: let your entire relationship with them prove your real friendship. Truth and reasoning carry special weight when they come from someone we trust and love.
3. The gentlest, softest approach to someone who's mistaken is the best way to help them see their error. Sometimes you need to point out that they're actually close to the truth, and that you simply want to help them get a bit closer. Affirm and reinforce whatever they say that's accurate and true, just as our blessed Savior treated the young scribe who answered well about the two great commandments. "You are not far from the kingdom of heaven," our Lord told him (Mark 12:34). Follow the gentleness and example of Jesus himself.
Get as close to your opponent's position as you honestly can in all your statements, and concede as much as you're able to while still remaining consistent with truth and justice.
People who try to win others over to their side make a serious and damaging mistake when they emphasize how different their positions are. This approach repels anyone you're trying to convince. He will prefer to stick with his own beliefs if accepting yours means he has to reject everything he previously thought was true. You need to appeal to human nature as well as to reason, so your argument can actually reach his understanding instead of being pushed away. If you accuse someone of spouting nonsense and absurdities, of promoting heresy and contradicting himself, you're taking exactly the wrong approach to convince him.
Always remember that you can't uproot error from someone's mind through insults and attacks, through clever quips and biting jokes, through loud outbursts or sharp mockery. Long speeches and gloating over your neighbor's mistakes won't convince him either. These tactics signal either a weak position or a lack of arguments (or ability) to defend even a good one.
4. Therefore, constantly monitor yourself to make sure you don't get heated in an argument before you realize it. The passions never clarify understanding. Instead, they create darkness, clouds, and confusion in the soul. Human nature is like water with mud at the bottom: it can be clear while it stays calm and undisturbed, and ideas, like pebbles, appear bright at the bottom. But once passion stirs and moves it, the mud rises to the top and spreads confusion and darkness over all the ideas. You can't present things in a fair and clear light to your neighbor while your own thinking is clouded with heat and passion.
Beyond that, when you let yourself get worked up and your anger takes over, you naturally ignite the same fire in the person you're writing to. This prevents him from absorbing your ideas, no matter how clear they might be. His emotions suddenly kick in to defend his own mistakes, and they fight just as fiercely as yours do (which may happen to be fighting on the side of truth).
When you provoke someone you're trying to convince, you not only stir up his anger and turn it against your position, but you also direct his resentment at you personally, along with all your instructions and arguments. You need to treat an opponent like a friend if you want to persuade him to learn anything from you. This is one major reason why two debaters or controversial writers so rarely make progress: they're too quick to let their emotions get involved in the argument, which blocks the mutual understanding that could flow both ways. Ambition, indignation, and a self-proclaimed zeal dominate on both sides. Victory becomes the real goal, while truth is just the excuse. And truth often dies in the crossfire or simply walks away from the battlefield. The combatants end up exactly where they started, their minds still holding the same opinions, perhaps with this added problem: they're now a bit more stubborn and entrenched in those views without any new reasoning to support them. And they usually walk away having lost their temper and their charity.
5. Don't try to convince someone they're wrong by punishing them or treating them harshly. Fire, sword, and bloody persecution have never brought light to anyone's mind. By now, you'd think everyone (princes, priests, ordinary people, scholars, the uneducated, the powerful, and the lowly) would have learned how foolish and insane it is to try spreading truth through cruelty. We use blows to force an animal into a yoke because oxen and donkeys lack understanding, but you can't chain and compel human intellect that way. People can't believe whatever they want, nor can they change their religion and convictions at will. Harsh treatment only creates hypocrites who profess what they don't believe. You can force people to comply with external practices and ceremonies that violate their consciences, but this never pleases God or benefits anyone.
6. To convince someone, always choose arguments that fit their understanding, capacity, personality, temperament, and circumstances. If I wanted to persuade a farmer about the truth of some form of church government, I wouldn't quote Greek and Latin church fathers. Instead, I'd use God's word, natural reason, and common sense.
7. Arguments should always be presented in a way that helps the mind see truth in a clear and appealing light, not just forces agreement through logical power. In many cases, clear ideas are just as useful for convincing someone as a perfectly constructed, unanswerable syllogism.
8. Give the person you're trying to teach enough time to absorb your arguments. After you've presented your ideas as clearly as possible and backed them up with your strongest reasoning, don't expect your friend to be convinced right away and accept what you're saying. The habit of thinking in a certain way, like most other habits, becomes almost second nature. You can't expect to pull someone away from their familiar errors except gradually, and only with their cooperation. Ask them, then, not to make a snap judgment or reject your position immediately. Instead, request that they review your framework, consider your arguments as impartially as they can, and take time to think everything through carefully. At the very least, ask them to be willing to hear you say more on this topic without feeling annoyed or resistant.
Speak to him in a friendly way and say: I'm not foolish enough to think I've presented this subject in a way that will suddenly push you into a completely new way of thinking or make you immediately abandon your current opinions or plans. All I hope is that some hint I've given might be something you can develop into your own conviction, or perhaps it will lead you to a line of reasoning that, over time, brings about a change in your thinking. This point leads me to add the following.
9. Work as hard as you can to make the person you're trying to teach become his own instructor. Human nature can be drawn in by a secret pleasure and pride in its own reasoning, making it seem to discover for itself the very thing you want to teach. Some people have this natural bias toward self so deeply rooted in them that they can never be convinced of a mistake by even the clearest and strongest arguments to the contrary, no matter how obvious the proof is. But they might be persuaded, through gentle suggestions, to follow a line of thought you propose until they've worked themselves out of their own error and led themselves into your opinion, as long as you make it appear that they're following their own guidance rather than yours. Perhaps nothing shows more skill in communication than this subtle influence over other people's minds, which they don't even notice while they're following it.
10. If you can win the main point in the argument, don't worry too much about the exact wording used to express it. People are so vain that they hate admitting they learned something from someone else. Even when they can't come up with everything on their own, they at least want to appear as though they've added something of their own to what they've borrowed from others. So when you've presented your idea in the clearest possible light and proven it in the most effective way, your opponent will introduce some trivial and pointless distinction just to change how the question is worded. He'll acknowledge that he accepts your proposition when it's phrased a certain way and expressed in certain terms, but he can't accept it in your exact words and phrases. Vanillus will admit he's now convinced that a man who behaves well in society shouldn't be punished for his religion, but he still won't agree to allow universal toleration of all religions that don't harm the state (which is the proposition I had been proving). Well then, let Vanillus use his own language. I'm glad he's convinced of the truth. He can dress it up in his own way.
To these guidelines I'll add two remarks at the end of this chapter, which wouldn't fit properly under the previous instructions.
I. When you've worked hard to teach someone a controversial truth but they still hold onto their prejudice against it, refusing to accept your convincing arguments, you can sometimes succeed by having them read a weak author who argues against that truth. A young reader will take such pleasure in being able to refute the opponent's arguments that they'll drop their former prejudices against the truth and accept the power and evidence of your reasoning. I admit this looks like using one prejudice to overthrow another, but when prejudices can't be fairly removed through reason alone, even the wisest and best teachers will sometimes find it necessary to make way for reason and truth by contrasting prejudices against each other.
II. When we want to convince an entire family or community of people that they're mistaken and lead them toward truth, we should assume there are various dominant prejudices among them. Therefore, it's neither safe to attempt nor easy to accomplish by addressing the whole group at once. This approach has often been found to raise sudden alarm and produce violent opposition even to the most fair, godly, and useful proposals, so that the person who made the motion could never achieve their goal.
We must therefore first secure the most intelligent and learned people (or at least the most influential ones) among them by addressing them privately and prudently, offering proper reasons until they're convinced and committed to the side of truth. These people can then apply themselves more successfully to others in the same community. Yet the original proposer shouldn't neglect to make a distinct appeal to everyone else, as far as circumstances allow.
When a decision depends on multiple votes, you should work to secure a solid majority. Then make sure the right people present and argue the case publicly, or else it might get shot down at the first proposal simply because people have something against the person bringing it forward.
Our circumstances in this world are so unfortunate that even if truth, justice, and goodness could take human form and descend from heaven to propose the most divine and useful teachings, bringing with them the clearest evidence and announcing them all at once to a crowd already prejudiced against them, the proposal would fail completely. It would neither convince nor persuade anyone. This shows how necessary it is to combine skill and strategy with the force of reason if we want to convince people of the truth, unless we come equipped with miracles or divine power to create conviction.
CHAPTER 24
THE PROPER USE AND ABUSE OF AUTHORITY
The influence that other people have on our opinions is usually called authority. Its power is so great and far-reaching that hardly anyone in the world is entirely free from its effects, even after doing everything possible to avoid it. Our parents and teachers, even our childhood caregivers, determine countless beliefs we hold. Our friends, our neighbors, the customs of our country, and the established opinions of society all shape what we believe. The great, the wise, the devout, the learned, and the ancient, along with kings, priests, and philosophers, all carry tremendous power to persuade us to accept what they say. These can be sorted into different categories of prejudice, but they're all related and can be traced back to this single source: authority.
I've discussed these matters in detail in Logic, Part II, Chapter III, Section 4. However, a few additional observations turned up in my papers, and I thought it would be appropriate to include them here.
Cicero understood well how authority can mislead us, and he complained about it in his first book on the nature of the gods: "In disputes and controversies," he said, "it's not the authors or supporters of any opinion that should influence the mind, but the weight and force of the argument itself. The authority of teachers frequently hinders students because they completely neglect to exercise their own judgment, simply accepting whatever those they respect have decided for them. I can't approve of what we learn about the Pythagoreans: that if anything asserted in debate was questioned, they would answer, 'Ipse dixit' (He himself said so), meaning Pythagoras. Prejudice prevailed so far that authority without reason was enough to settle disputes and establish truth."
All human authority, no matter how ancient, no matter how universally dominant it has been over both the learned and the common world for thousands of years, has no certain and undoubted claim to truth. And it's no violation of good manners to respectfully challenge its supposed dominion. What has been more firmly established and universally accepted in all the sciences since the days of Aristotle (and perhaps for ages before he lived) than this: that all heavy bodies whatsoever tend toward the center of the earth? But Sir Isaac Newton discovered that those massive and weighty bodies (the earth and all the planets) actually tend toward the center of the sun. With that discovery, the authority of nearly three thousand years or more is not only called into question, but actually refuted and abandoned.
Consider this: Has anything ever been more universally accepted among poets and critics than the belief that Homer and Virgil wrote heroic poems that can't be matched? Anyone who dared to attack their writings or their reputation was either condemned as malicious or mocked as foolish. These ancient authors were thought to have special advantages for elevating their verses through pagan theology and the variety of ways they could portray their gods and weave them into human affairs. Yet in recent years, Sir Richard Blackmore (whose prefaces are universally considered superior to any of his poems) has dared to speak some important truths in his excellent preface to the poem Alfred. There he brilliantly demonstrates, beyond any possible objection, that both Virgil and Homer are often guilty of serious mistakes, indecencies, and shameful improprieties. He shows that far from gaining any advantage from the crowd of pagan gods, their theology almost inevitably exposed them to many of these errors. He argues that it's impossible to write a perfect epic poem based on pagan superstition, whereas the sacred religion of the Bible would provide a poem with far more appropriate and glorious scenes, and a nobler framework.
Mr. Dennis had also shown in his essays some years earlier that no images in even the greatest pagan writers were as sublime as those we find in the poetic parts of holy scripture. Rapin, the French critic, dared to express the same views, despite the fact that poets and critics had universally and unanimously elevated the pagan writers to supremacy for so many centuries. If we want to discover the truth in many cases, we must dare to deviate from the well-worn path and venture to think with genuine and unbiased freedom.
Though we need to guard against the harmful influence of authority and the prejudices it creates (because it has introduced countless errors and problems into the world), there are three important and notable cases where authority, or the opinions of other people, must or will determine how people think and act.
I. Parents are meant to make decisions for their children during their early years and teach them what to believe and how to behave in both civil and religious life. This is a natural principle, and it would have been true even in a state of innocence. Children simply cannot judge for themselves before their minds have accumulated enough ideas, before they've learned any principles and rules of sound judgment, and before their reasoning has matured and been properly exercised on such subjects.
I won't say that a child should believe nonsense and impossibilities just because his father tells him to. As far as the impossibility becomes clear, he can't believe it anyway. Nor will I say he should accept all his parents' false opinions or practice idolatry, murder, or other harmful acts at their command. Yet before a child can possibly judge for himself, he has no better way to discover what he should believe and how he should act than to turn to his parents and accept their views and guidance.
You might say this is terribly unfair: that the child of a pagan idolater or a brutal cannibal is placed under a kind of natural necessity to sin against the light of nature. I admit it is terribly unfair, but this is only because of our original fall and rebellion. The law of nature remains what it was in innocence: that a parent should make decisions for his child. But if the parent judges wrongly, the child is greatly endangered by it, through that universal disorder brought into the world by the sin of Adam, our common father. From the fairness and goodness of God, we can reasonably conclude that the great Judge of all will do what is right. He will weigh the ignorance and inability of the child against the criminal nature of the offense in these childish instances, and will not punish beyond what is justly deserved.
Besides, what could God, as Creator, do better for children in their early years than to entrust them to the care and instruction of parents? No one is supposed to be more concerned for the happiness of children than their parents are. Therefore, it is the safest path to happiness, according to the original law of creation, to follow their directions: their parents' reason acts for them before they have reason of their own in proper working order. Nor indeed is there any better general rule in our fallen state by which children can be governed, though in many particular cases it may lead them far astray from virtue and happiness.
If Providence places children under better instruction that contradicts their parents' mistaken beliefs, I can't say these children have a duty to follow error just because their father believes it, not when they can recognize it as error. What I said earlier applies only to those still under their parents' direct care and education, who haven't yet reached an age capable of examining these matters. I don't see how such children can avoid accepting their parents' authority in their earliest years, except through direct divine inspiration.
It's difficult to pinpoint the exact age when a child becomes free from parental authority in these matters. Perhaps it makes more sense to think of this authority as gradually diminishing as the child grows in understanding and capability, becoming more and more able to use his own mental powers, rather than trying to set a fixed age in months and years.
When childhood and youth have progressed far enough that a person's reasoning abilities have reached a reasonable level of maturity, he certainly ought to begin examining the reasons behind his own beliefs and practices in all areas of life and religion. But since reason doesn't reach this level of power and independence at any single moment, there's no single moment when a child should suddenly abandon all his former beliefs and practices. Instead, he should examine them gradually and one by one, as opportunity and circumstances allow, and either confirm them, question them, or change them, following the guidance of conscience and reason with all the information available to him.
When we reach adulthood, no person on earth, no group or organization of any kind, has been given power and authority by God, the creator and ruler of the world, to dictate absolutely to others what they should believe or how they should act in moral and religious matters. God has given every person the ability to reason and judge for themselves, in greater or lesser degrees. Where less is given, less will be required. But we are rightly accused of criminal laziness and wasting the talents our Creator has entrusted to us if we take everything at face value that others claim, and believe and practice everything they dictate without proper examination.
2. Another case where authority must govern our agreement is in many matters of fact. Here we can and should be determined by the declarations or narratives of other people, though I admit this is usually called testimony rather than authority. It is on this basis that every son or daughter among humanity is required to believe that certain persons are their parents, for they can never be informed of it except by what others tell them. It is by testimony that we are to believe the laws of our country, and to pay all proper respect to the ruler and to magistrates in subordinate degrees of authority, though we did not actually see them chosen, crowned, or invested with their title and position. It is by testimony that we are forced to believe there is such a city as Canterbury or York, though perhaps we have never been to either; that there are people such as Catholics at Paris and Rome, and that there are many foolish and cruel beliefs in their religion. It is by testimony that we believe Christianity and the books of the Bible have been faithfully passed down to us through many generations; that there was such a person as Christ our Savior, that He performed miracles and died on the cross, that He rose again and ascended to heaven.
When wise and honest people testify to something, particularly when they had full opportunity and ability to know the truth and are clearly not trying to deceive us, we should take their word seriously. This is especially true when many people agree on the same testimony and when numerous other circumstances raise what they're telling us to the level of moral certainty.
However, even in matters of fact and historical events, we shouldn't accept too readily everything that tradition hands down to us or every impressive claim backed by human testimony. We need to carefully examine all the factors that make testimony credible and establish a solid foundation for our belief. So many falsehoods have been forced on humanity with convincing claims of eyewitnesses and earwitnesses that we should be wisely cautious and justifiably suspicious of reports where the signs of truth don't clearly appear, especially when the matter is significantly important. The less probable the reported fact seems in itself, the stronger the evidence we can reasonably demand for the truthfulness of the testimony asking us to accept it.
III. The final case where authority must govern us is when we're called to believe what people under divine inspiration have told us. This isn't really human authority but God's authority itself. We're obligated to believe what that authority declares, even if our reason can't currently discover the certainty or evidence of the statement in any other way. It's enough if our reasoning faculty, working at its best, can recognize the divine authority that has presented it. When doctrines of divine revelation are clearly published along with sufficient proof of their revealed nature, all humanity is bound to accept them, even if we can't perfectly understand them, because we know that God is true and cannot speak falsehood.
But if these supposed divine instructions directly contradict the natural faculties of understanding and reason that God has given us, we can be confident these instructions were never revealed to us by God himself. When people are influenced by authority to believe supposed mysteries that plainly oppose reason, yet claim to have rational grounds for what they believe, this is nothing but empty self-deception.
No reasoning whatsoever can prove or establish any authority so firmly as to give it power to dictate beliefs that contradict all the principles of our reasonable nature. God himself has never given such revelations, and I think it can be said with reverence that He neither can nor will do so, unless He changes our faculties from what they currently are. To tell us we must believe a proposition that plainly contradicts reason is to tell us that we must believe two ideas are connected while (if we pay attention to reason) we clearly see and know them to be separate.
What else could have established the nonsense of transubstantiation in the world, if people had been firmly grounded in this great truth: that God gives no revelation contradictory to our own reason? Things may be above our reason (that is, reason may have only obscure ideas of them, or reason may not see the connection between those ideas, or may not know at present the certain and exact way of reconciling such propositions, either with one another or with other rational truths, as I have explained in some of my logical papers), but when they stand directly and plainly against all sense and reason, as transubstantiation does, no divine authority can be claimed to enforce their belief, and human authority is shameless to claim it. Yet this human authority, in Catholic countries, has prevailed over millions of souls, because they have abandoned their reason, they have given up the glory of human nature to be trampled on by deceivers, and so reduced themselves to the condition of animals.
According to one author, this manipulation of authority is how a horse learns to obey commands, a dog learns to fetch and carry, and a person learns to believe inconsistencies and impossibilities. Whips and dungeons, fire and the gallows, and the solemn terrors of eternal misery after death will persuade weak minds to believe against their senses and in direct contradiction to all their reasoning powers. A parrot can be taught to tell lies with much more ease and gentler treatment, but none of these creatures would serve their masters at the expense of their liberty if they had knowledge and the proper use of reason.
I've mentioned three categories in which people must or will be determined in their beliefs by authority: first, the case of children in their youth, regarding the commands of their parents; second, the case of all people, regarding universal, complete, and sufficient testimony of matters of fact; and third, the case of every person, regarding the authority of divine revelation and of divinely inspired individuals. Under each of these I've given the necessary limitations and cautions. I'll now mention some other cases in which we should pay great deference to the authority and opinions of others, though we aren't absolutely bound and determined by their views.
When we start making our own decisions about civil and religious matters as we come of age, we should give serious weight to our parents' views. After all, they were our natural guides in these areas during childhood. The same principle applies to learning: an inexperienced young person should respect his teachers' opinions. While it's reasonable to withhold judgment on what instructors teach until you see sufficient evidence, you shouldn't directly oppose either parents or teachers without compelling and obvious reasons that truly force your understanding or conscience to disagree.
Older people with extensive life experience deserve considerable respect from the young when they offer advice on practical or civil matters, especially from those who haven't yet seen much of the world. The odds simply favor the older person being right.
In matters of practical godliness, we should give significant weight to those who have long practiced virtue and piety. I'll admit that when it comes to specific religious forms and ceremonies, older people can be just as prone to bigotry and superstition as the young. But on questions of inner religion, pure devotion, and virtue, someone who has sincerely practiced these things for years almost certainly knows more than a young person still struggling with uncontrolled passions, appetites, and prejudices.
People working in their particular professions and trades, in which they've been trained and have spent their entire careers, naturally possess greater knowledge and skill than others. Their judgment in these areas deserves proper respect.
V. When we lack sufficient evidence to compel belief in matters of fact, we should still give appropriate weight to accounts from wise and sensible people, based on their honesty, expertise, and opportunity to know the facts firsthand.
I admit that in many cases where the question is purely theoretical and doesn't require any action from us, we can withhold judgment until better evidence emerges. But when the matter has practical implications and demands that we act one way or another, we should give considerable weight to authority and testimony, following probabilities when we can't have certainty. After all, this is the best guidance available to us. Surely it's better to follow this kind of direction, when nothing better exists, than to drift in complete uncertainty. It makes no sense to blow out our candle and sit in darkness just because we don't have sunlight.
CHAPTER 25
MANAGING AND OVERCOMING PREJUDICE
If we were dealing only with human reason, and if that reason were pure and uncorrupted, it wouldn't take much skill or effort to correct someone's common mistakes or persuade them to accept plain and obvious truths. But unfortunately, humanity is wrapped up in errors and entrenched in prejudices, and every opinion people hold is supported and guarded by something other than reason. A young, bright mind who has armed himself with various truths and strong arguments, but who hasn't yet experienced the world, goes out from the schools like a knight-errant, boldly expecting to vanquish human folly and spread light and truth among everyone he knows. But he encounters huge giants and enchanted castles: strong preconceptions, habits, customs, education, authority, self-interest, along with all the various passions of humanity, armed and stubborn in defense of their old opinions. He finds himself strangely disappointed in his generous attempts. He discovers now that he can't simply trust in the sharpness of his blade and the strength of his arm. Instead, he must wield the weapons of his reason with considerable dexterity and skill, with cleverness and tact, or he will never be able to overcome errors and convince humanity.
Where prejudices are strong, several methods must be practiced in order to convince people of their mistakes and make a way for truth to enter their minds.
I. You can avoid triggering someone's prejudice without attacking it head-on by taking slow, gentle, indirect approaches. Present your own views and supporting arguments gradually, leading the person step by step toward truths that their prejudices would reject if you laid them out all at once. Suppose your neighbor is caught up in superstition and narrow-mindedness through simple ignorance. Don't immediately charge at him with force and expose the absurdity or foolishness of his opinions, even if you could easily show how ridiculous they are. Instead, start from a distance and get him to agree with some familiar, easy points that tend to undermine his mistakes and support the truth. Then quietly watch how this affects him and proceed slowly as he's able to handle it. You may need to carry on this work across many separate conversations. A sensitive or damaged eye can't handle a flood of light all at once. We shouldn't judge our arguments purely by how strong we think they are and then expect others to be convinced immediately. We need to consider how the people we're talking with are likely to receive them, and manage our reasoning the way a nurse gives a child a drink in small amounts, so the infant won't choke or spit it all back up if it's poured in too quickly. No matter how good your wine is, and no matter how generous you are in offering it to your neighbor, if his bottle has a narrow opening and you try to pour freely, you'll knock the bottle over before you fill it with wine.
Excessive haste and intensity in arguing often stems from pride. It dulls the sharpness of your argument, weakens its force, and defeats your purpose. Suppose you wanted to convince someone that the doctrine of transubstantiation is false. If you picked up the consecrated bread in front of him and said, "You can see, taste, and feel that this is nothing but bread. Therefore, when you claim that God commands you to believe it isn't bread, you're wickedly accusing God of commanding you to lie," this kind of language would only provoke his anger instead of persuading him. He won't even consider the arguments you've presented. Instead, he'll rage at you as a profane wretch who elevates his own senses and reason above sacred authority. So even though what you're saying is obviously true, you lose the benefit of your entire argument through poor handling and badly timed delivery.
II. We can explicitly acknowledge and accommodate prejudices for a time when they seem to oppose the truth, and then work to introduce the truth gradually while those prejudices are still openly accepted. Eventually, as the truth advances, it may naturally erode the prejudice. God himself dealt with his own people, the Jews, this way after Christ's resurrection. Although the Jewish ceremonies became void and ineffective for any divine purpose from the day of Pentecost onward (when the Gospel was proclaimed and confirmed at Jerusalem), Jews who received Christ as the Messiah were still permitted to circumcise their children and practice many Levitical forms. This continued until that old covenant, which was already growing obsolete, would eventually disappear entirely.
When people's prejudices can't be overcome immediately, when they instinctively resist the evidence of truth, we need to make some allowances and accommodate them for now, as long as we can do so safely without actually harming the truth. If we want any success in convincing the world, we must practice this kind of flexibility for humanity's benefit.
Take a student who has deeply absorbed the principles of the Peripatetics and imagines certain immaterial beings called substantial forms inhabiting every herb, flower, mineral, metal, fire, water, and so on, serving as the source of all their properties and operations. Or take a Platonist who believes in an anima mundi, a universal soul of the world pervading all bodies, acting in and through them according to their nature, and actually giving them their nature and their special powers. It may be very difficult to convince these people through argument and force them to give up these ideas. Well then, let one believe in his universal soul, and let the other continue with his notion of substantial forms. At the same time, teach them how the various appearances in nature can be explained and the variety of effects produced through certain original laws of motion and the various sizes, shapes, and positions of the parts of matter (allowing for continued divine involvement in and with everything), according to the corpuscular philosophy improved by Descartes, Mr. Boyle, and Sir Isaac Newton. When they've gained some skill in this science, they'll see that these airy notions of theirs, these imaginary powers, are so useless and unnecessary that they'll drop them on their own. The Peripatetic forms will vanish from the mind like a dream, and the Platonic soul of the world will die out.
Let's say a young philosopher is firmly convinced that nothing exists without three dimensions: length, width, and thickness. He therefore believes that every finite being must have a figure or shape (since shape is simply the boundary and limit of dimension). Suppose this person, because of long-standing habits of sense perception and imagination, finds it hard to conceive of a spirit or thinking being without shape and dimensions. In that case, let him continue for now to imagine a spirit with dimensions. But he must be sure to retain in all his thinking the idea of thought, or the power of thinking, and then proceed to philosophize about the subject with this in mind. Perhaps after a little time he will discover that length, width, and shape play no role in any of the actions of a spirit. He may find that he can account for all the properties and relationships of such a being, along with all its operations of sensing, willing, and so on, just as well without this supposed shape or these dimensions. He may realize that all these operations and attributes can be ascribed to a spirit considered simply as a power of thinking. And when he further considers that God the infinite Spirit is an almighty, self-consistent, thinking power without shape and without dimensions of length, width, and depth, he may then suppose that the human spirit could be a lesser self-sustaining power of thought. He may be inclined to gradually drop the ideas of dimension and figure once he sees and becomes convinced that they contribute nothing to thinking, nor are they necessary to assist or explain the operations or properties of a spirit.
Here's another example of the same approach, this time dealing with someone who has an unhealthy attachment to specific words and phrases. Imagine a person who was taught to explain an important gospel doctrine using a particular expression, and through that phrase he has absorbed a completely wrong understanding of the doctrine. Yet he's so devoted to his way of saying it that he thinks if you drop those words, you've lost the doctrine itself. If I can't convince him to abandon his misleading terminology, I'll work with it for a while and try to explain it in a way that aligns with Scripture, rather than leave him stuck in his confusion.
Take Credonius, who believes that Christ descended into hell. I think the word "hell," as we commonly understand it today, is quite inappropriate here. But since most Christians, including Credonius, refuse to remove that word from their English creed, I'll explain "hell" to mean the realm of the dead, or the state where souls exist apart from their bodies. This way I can guide my friend toward a more accurate understanding of the truth: that Christ's soul existed for three days separated from His body, or was in the invisible world, which could legitimately be called "hell" in English just as it was called "hades" in Greek.
Then there's Anilla, who was raised Catholic her entire life. Though she doesn't know much about religion, she's determined never to abandon the Roman Catholic faith and stubbornly resists any change. I don't think it's wrong to teach her true Christian faith (that is, Protestant doctrine) from the Epistle to the Romans, and to show her that the same teaching appears in the Catholic Epistles of Peter, James, and Jude. This way she can live and die as a genuine Christian, believing the religion I teach her from the New Testament, while still thinking she's a Roman Catholic because she finds the doctrines I'm teaching her in the Catholic Epistles and in the one to the Romans.
I agree that different words should be applied to different ideas whenever possible, and this rule should never be broken if we were dealing only with human reason. But people's prejudices and their attachment to certain party phrases sometimes make it necessary to lead them into truth under the cover of their own favorite expressions, rather than let them live and die stubbornly unconvinced in some dangerous error. An attempt to take away their long-established words would create such an uproar in their minds that convincing them would become impossible.
III. Sometimes we can use a person's own prejudices to convince him of a particular truth, arguing with him based on his professed principles as if they were true. This is called Argumentum ad hominem (argument to the person), and it's another way of dealing with human prejudices.
Suppose a Jewish man is sick with a fever, and his doctor has forbidden him to eat meat. But when he hears that rabbits have been prepared for the family's dinner, he desperately wants to eat some. Suppose he becomes impatient because his doctor won't allow it, and he insists it couldn't possibly hurt him. Rather than let him persist in that fantasy and desire to the point of endangering his life, I would tell him that those animals were strangled, which makes them forbidden under Jewish law, even though I myself may believe that law no longer applies.
Tenerilla was persuaded in the same way to let her husband Damon prosecute a thief who broke into their house on a Sunday. At first she hated the idea and refused completely, because if the thief were convicted under English law he would be hanged. But (she argued) God's law in the writings of Moses doesn't prescribe death as punishment for such criminals. Instead, it tells us that a thief should be sold for his theft (Exod 22:3). When Damon couldn't convince her any other way that the thief should be prosecuted, he reminded her that the theft happened on Sunday morning. Now the same law of Moses requires that anyone who breaks the Sabbath must surely be put to death (Exod 31:15; Num 15:35). This argument won Tenerilla over, and she agreed to the prosecution.
Encrates used the same method of persuasion when he saw a Muslim drinking wine to excess and heard him defending the lawfulness and pleasure of drunkenness. Encrates reminded him that his own prophet Muhammad had completely forbidden all wine to his followers, and the good man restrained his sinful appetite through this religious conviction, since Encrates couldn't otherwise convince him that drunkenness was wrong or keep him from excess.
When we encounter someone stubbornly clinging to a mistake despite all reason, especially if the mistake is seriously harmful, and we know this person will listen to the opinion or authority of some favorite figure, it's sometimes necessary to invoke that favorite person's opinion and authority, since that's likely to carry far more weight than reason itself. I admit I'm almost embarrassed to talk about using authority's influence while I'm trying to teach the art of reasoning. But in some cases it's better for foolish, stubborn, contrary people to be persuaded to judge and act correctly through respect for others' opinions than to let them wander in destructive errors, remaining deaf to all arguments and blind to all evidence. They're just oversized children, and since they persist all their lives in their immaturity and reject all true reasoning, surely we can try to persuade them to do what's in their own interest by whatever childish reasons they'll actually listen to. We can scare them away from pursuing their own ruin with the threat of some solemn warning, or lure them toward their own happiness with a sweet reward.
But ultimately, we must conclude that wherever it's possible, it's best to remove and root out those prejudices that block truth from entering the mind, rather than to soothe, accommodate, or indulge them. And sometimes this must necessarily be done before you can make a person abandon some cherished error and lead him into better thinking.
Imagine you're trying to convince a gambler that gambling isn't a legitimate way to make a living, and you use this argument: 'Any activity that doesn't allow us to ask for God's blessing on our profits cannot be a lawful occupation. But we can't ask God's blessing on gambling, so it can't be lawful.' You prove the second point this way: 'We can't pray for our neighbor to lose money. That goes against the rule of seeking our neighbor's welfare and loving him as ourselves. That's wishing harm on our neighbor. But in gambling, we can only gain exactly what our neighbor loses. Therefore, in gambling we can't pray for God's blessing on our gains.'
The gambler might shrug and squirm, turning the argument over in his mind from every angle, but he can't honestly refute it. Still, he'll cobble together some answer to satisfy himself and will never accept the logic, because he feels too strongly the sweet pull of gambling, either feeding his greed or funding his lifestyle. He's deeply biased in favor of it and won't be easily convinced.
Your first task, then, is to gradually lead him to separate his personal financial interest from the argument itself. Show him that our immediate material concerns, our income, or our losses have nothing to do with settling this question when set against plain reason. He needs to see that he must set aside such considerations entirely if he wants to be honest and sincere in his search for truth or duty. He must be willing to listen to the voice of reason and truth, even when it runs counter to his financial interests. Once you've accomplished this, then an argument can carry some real weight toward convincing him.
In the same way, suppose the question is whether Matrissa should expose herself and her other children to poverty and misery just to support the extravagances of a favorite son. Perhaps the mother can't hear any argument against it. She feels no conviction even in the most powerful reasoning, because her fond prejudices cling so tightly to her heart. The first task here is to remove this prejudice. Ask her, therefore, whether it isn't a parent's duty to love all her children enough to provide for their welfare. Ask whether her duty to God and her family shouldn't regulate her love for a favorite. Ask whether her neighbor Floris did well in dressing up her daughters with expensive finery while neglecting the education of her son until she saw his ruin. Perhaps by this method she can be brought to see that peculiar fondness for one child should carry no weight or force in determining judgment when it opposes plain duty. She may then give herself up to conviction in her own case and to the evidence of truth, and thus correct her mistaken practice.
Suppose you want to convert Rominda from Catholicism, and you lay out all the errors, absurdities, and superstitions of that church before her in the clearest possible light. She still holds them fast and can't let them go, because she has a deep reverence for the faith and church of her ancestors and can't imagine they were wrong. Your first task, therefore, must be to convince her that our ancestors were fallible people; that we can leave their faith behind without dishonoring them; that everyone must choose their own religion; that we will answer for ourselves on the great day of judgment, not for our parents, nor they for us; that Christianity itself would never have been received by her ancestors in this nation if they had always stuck with their parents' religion, since they were all pagans. Once she has been persuaded through these lines of reasoning that she isn't bound to cling forever to her parents' religion, she may then find it easier to accept the errors of Rome.
But perhaps of all these different methods of curing prejudices, none can be practiced with greater pleasure to a wise and good person, or with greater success where success matters most, than trying to turn the attention of well-meaning people away from some point where prejudice dominates, toward something else of greater importance. By fixing their thoughts and hearts on some great truth they already accept, one that leads to conclusions contrary to some other notion they hold and maintain, you can help them forget their errors while they focus on the opposite truth. As their minds open and their temperaments grow more generous and virtuous, they may be led to give up those errors. Surely nothing can give a kind-hearted person more satisfaction than helping a neighbor grow in both knowledge and goodness at the same time.
CHAPTER 26
EFFECTIVE PUBLIC SPEAKING AND PREACHING
PRIORITIZING WISDOM OVER SHOWMANSHIP
Tyro is a young preacher fresh from his studies in logic and theology, now promoted to the pulpit. Back at the academy, he earned a reputation as a sharp student for breaking down propositions, and he's still brimming with technical terms and scholarly jargon. After reading his text and offering a brief introduction, he launches into an explanation of the multiple meanings of the key word: first how ancient Greek writers used it, then how it appears in the New Testament. He cites every chapter and verse with precision, trying to help you understand numerous other passages before he ever fully explains what his own text means.
He pulls all this material from the scholarly commentaries he's consulted, where such detailed work serves a necessary and valuable purpose, so he assumes it will enhance his sermon as well. Next, he gives you a learned survey of the various mistaken interpretations that theologians and commentators have offered for this passage, often including the reasoning behind each one. He then refutes these views with considerable enthusiasm and disdain. Having cleared away all these alternatives, he settles on the interpretation his judgment favors best and typically spends five or ten minutes presenting arguments to support it. He does this not only with obscure and difficult texts, but even when the meaning is so obvious that a child could hardly miss it.
Once he's finished this grammatical exercise, he moves on to his logic. The text gets divided and subdivided into many little pieces. He points out precisely where the subject and predicate are, introduces you to the agent and the object, shows you all the properties and accidents that attend it, and tries hard to make you understand the matter and form of it as well as he does himself. When he's done with all this, two-thirds of the hour is gone, and his hearers are completely exhausted. Then he begins to approach his doctrine or main theme, and after telling the audience with great formality and exactness how he plans to handle it, he names one or two particulars under the first general heading. By this time he realizes he needs to add, "I had intended to elaborate more fully on my subject, and I should have given you some reasons for the doctrine, but I'm sorry that I've run out of time. I also planned to bring this home to the conscience of every person here with a warm appeal, but since my time is gone I must cut things short." He rushes through a hint or two that should have been developed into exhortation or instruction, but all in great haste, and thus concludes his work. The obstinate and careless sinner leaves unawakened and unconvinced. The mourning soul departs uncomforted. The unbeliever is not led to faith in the gospel, nor is the immoral wretch brought to hate or forsake his sins. The hypocrite and the sincere believer both leave unedified, because the preacher didn't have time. In short, he has finished his work and accomplished nothing.
When I hear this man preach, it reminds me of a story I heard about the Czar of Russia during his army's first siege of a town in Livonia. He had just returned from his travels in Great Britain, where he and his ministers had learned mathematics from an old acquaintance of mine. The Czar took great care to begin the siege properly: he drew all the lines of circumvallation and contravallation according to the rules of military science. But he was so slow and so precise in these mathematical operations that the season ran out, and he was forced to abandon the siege and retreat without accomplishing anything against the town.
Ergates is a different kind of preacher, a workman who doesn't need to be ashamed. In his younger days he had few of these learned vanities, and age and experience have now worn them all away. He preaches like a man who watches over our souls, as someone who must give an account. He moves quickly past lesser matters and pursues his great purpose: to save himself and those who hear him (1 Tim 4:16). By following this advice of Paul, he successfully complies with that great and natural rule of Horace, always to hurry toward the most valuable goal: Semper ad eventum festinat (always hasten to the outcome). He never tries to choose a very obscure text, lest he waste too much of the hour explaining its literal meaning. He saves all those obscurities for when they come up naturally during his regular seasons of public exposition. He believes that preaching the gospel for the salvation of people carries a somewhat different purpose from a learned and critical exposition of difficult scripture passages.
He knows how to use logic in his writing, but he never calls any part of his argument by its technical name if there's a common word that works just as well. Reading and reflection have given him a broad understanding of his subject, and his own good sense has taught him to provide solid reasons for everything he claims. But he never offers a proof until one is actually needed. He's familiar with the mistaken interpretations of commentators, but he sees no reason to tell his listeners about them unless there's a real danger they might fall into the same error. He understands very well what his subject is not, as well as what it is. But when he explains it to you, he never starts with the negative approach unless some significant error is nearby that his listeners might easily stumble into without such a warning.
In this way, within five or ten minutes at most, he clears a path to the main point he intends to discuss. And being wise enough to know what to say and what to leave out, he balances every part of his message to fit his time. He expands a little on the subject by way of illustration until the truth becomes clear and understandable even to the weakest of his listeners. Then he confirms the point with a few convincing arguments where the matter requires it, and quickly moves to turn the doctrine into practical application. In this way the ignorant are taught, and growing Christians are strengthened and built up. The complacent sinner is loudly awakened, and the grieving soul receives comfort. The unbeliever is led to trust in Christ and his gospel, and the careless and immoral are convicted and softened, melted and reformed. The inner voice of the Holy Spirit joins with the voice of the minister. The good person and the hypocrite each receive what they deserve, and the Lord's work prospers in his hands.
This is his standard approach to preaching. Because this method feels natural, clear, and straightforward, he structures many of his sermons this way. But he refuses to be locked into any rigid system. Instead, he lets his topic and his congregation's needs determine how he'll organize each sermon, choosing whatever approach will best inform, convince, and move his listeners. Ergates understands that when a subject is inherently practical, he doesn't need to tack on formal "applications" and lengthy exhortations at the end. He knows that putting truth into practice is the whole point of doctrine, so he devotes most of his energy to this part of his work, weaving in emotional appeals throughout each section. Still, he pays close attention to the specific dangers facing his congregation and the errors prevalent in his era, and occasionally (though rarely) he finds it necessary to dedicate nearly an entire sermon to purely doctrinal matters. When such an occasion arises, he takes a bit more time during his hour to explain and defend his interpretation of the text, breaking it down so clearly that even a child could grasp it.
At other times, he may specifically aim to engage the few educated and cultured listeners in his audience. His goal here is strategic: by appealing to their refined sensibilities, he can win their attention and satisfy their intellectual curiosity in one part of the sermon, which then opens the door for the simpler, more essential, and more vital truths to reach their hearts. In these moments, he reaches for the sublime and delivers something that will satisfy even the most discriminating taste. Yet he almost never concludes his sermon without showing compassion for the less educated, always including an appeal that can reach their consciences with words of salvation.
I've watched him sometimes come down from the pulpit after a learned sermon looking ashamed and completely embarrassed. He has blushed and complained to his close friends, worried that people might think he was preaching about himself rather than Christ Jesus his Lord. He's been ready to wish he had spoken to the congregation in simpler terms and on a more ordinary topic, concerned that the servants, laborers, and tradesmen in attendance might gain nothing for their souls, and that the precious hour of worship might be wasted as far as their spiritual growth is concerned. He knows well, and keeps it close to his heart, that the middle and lower classes, people without formal education, make up most of the congregation. That's why he constantly works to adapt his thoughts and language, and the vast majority of all his preaching, to instruct and benefit people of ordinary status and ability. It's among these people that he hopes to find his triumph, his joy, and his crown on that final great day, for not many wise or noble are called.
His ordinary conversation has so much life and beauty that the intelligent men of his time seek it out and desire it. But he always carries with him a strict sense of godliness that tempers the pleasant quality of his talk, even in his brightest and most relaxed moments. Before he leaves a gathering (if possible), he will leave behind something of heaven's influence. In the living room he continues the work of the pulpit, but in such an elegant way that it delights the company and gives no reason for criticism.
His polite friends sometimes tease him for speaking so plainly in his sermons, for dumbing down his intelligence to such a basic level. But Ergates boldly tells even the most sophisticated among them, "Our public work, my friend, is mainly with the weak and the ignorant: that is, most people. The poor receive the gospel. The mechanics and day laborers, the women and children in my congregation, have souls to be saved. I will imitate my blessed Redeemer in 'preaching the gospel to the poor,' and learn from Paul to become all things to all people, so that I may win souls and lead many sinners to heaven through repentance, faith, and holiness."
THE DANGERS OF OVER-ANALYZING
I have always thought it a mistake for preachers to chop up their text or subject too finely with a huge number of subdivisions, because it creates tremendous confusion for uneducated listeners. When a preacher divides his material into more general, less general, special, and more particular headings, he sometimes has to say "firstly" or "secondly" two or three times in a row. The educated may follow this, but most of the audience, not understanding the structure, can't even grasp it, much less store it in their memories in a clear and orderly way. When you ask such listeners to summarize the sermon, they pile up the "thirdlies" and "secondlies" in heaps and make a complete mess of it, mixing up the general and specific points. In writing a long treatise this is more tolerable, but in preaching it is less helpful and more tangled and annoying.
It is equally pointless to string out a long series of points in the same sermon under any one heading, running the count up to eighteenth and twenty-seventh. People who enjoy this kind of thing will slice every idea into ribbons, and everything they can possibly say on any topic becomes a new point.
This kind of foolishness and misguided approach shows up every week in Polyramus's lectures, making all his talks thin and bland. It's hard to say whether this comes from simple poverty of thought and natural dullness of mind (meaning he can't vary his material or expand beyond the formal categories of analysis), or whether it stems from an affected way of speaking. But one thing is certain: most of his audience gains little and enjoys even less. When I sit under his preaching, I feel like I've been transported into the valley of Ezekiel's vision: it was full of bones, and there were very many in the valley, and they were very dry (Ezek 37:1-2).
It's the variety of expansion on a few appropriate topics that puts flesh on those dry bones and brings them to life with blood and energy. This is what gives color to a sermon, makes it warm and powerful, and renders divine truths bright and persuasive. This is what brings doctrine or duty down to the understanding or conscience of the entire audience, and enlists the natural emotions in the service of the gospel. In short, this is what (under the influence of the Holy Spirit) gives life and force, beauty and success to a sermon, and provides food for souls. A single rosebush or dwarf pear tree, with all its leaves, flowers, and fruit, has more beauty and vitality in itself and yields more food and pleasure to people than the countless branches, boughs, and twigs of a long thorn hedge. The fruit will feed the hungry, and the flower will refresh the faint, which is more than can be said of the thickest oak in Bashan when it has lost its vital sap. It may spread its limbs far and wide, but they are naked, withered, and lifeless.
THE RAMBLING SPEECH
Can't we avoid one extreme without falling into something worse? Isn't there a middle ground between a sermon chopped into sixty dry points and a long, rambling speech with no structure at all? Must the preacher divide his sermon by the ticks of a stopwatch, or let it flow without pause until the final word, like the steady stream of sand in an hourglass measuring out his theology? Fluvio certainly preaches as if he knows no middle way. Having been put off by one of Polyramus's lectures in the past, he decided his own sermons would have no distinct points whatsoever. His words flow smoothly in one long chain of sentences, gliding over the ear like a stream of oil across polished marble, and like that oil, they leave no trace behind. The listener's attention is held in a gentle pleasure, and (to put the best possible spin on it) the hearer is soothed into something resembling spiritual delight. But if a friend asks what pleased him, he can hardly give an account. He remembers a faint impression of sweetness but has forgotten the substance.
Tell me, Fluvio, is this really the most effective way to teach ignorant people the various articles of faith and the different duties of Christian life? Will such a long, uniform flow of language imprint all the distinct parts of Christian knowledge on the mind in their best form and order? Do you find such a gentle, gliding stream of words most powerful to wake up the souls of sinners from their dangerous or fatal lethargy? Will this lazy and motionless kind of speaking make a thoughtless person pay attention to matters of infinite importance? Can a long, purling sound awaken a sleepy conscience and give a dying sinner proper warning of his terrible danger? Can it fill his understanding and his memory with all the solemn and tremendous truths of our religion when it barely leaves any distinct impression of even one of them on his soul? Can you make the arrow wound where it won't stick? Where all the preaching vanishes from memory, can you really suppose the soul has been helped or enriched? When you brush over closed eyelids with a feather, have you ever found it gives light to the blind? Have any of your soft speeches, your continuous threads of silken eloquence, ever raised the dead? I suspect your whole goal is simply to talk for the appointed number of minutes on the subject, or to practice a little on the gentler emotions, without any real concern for how to give the understanding its proper improvement, or to fill the memory with any lasting treasure, or to create a knowledgeable and genuinely religious Christian.
Ask old Wheatfield, the wealthy farmer, or Plowdown, your neighbor, or any of his family who have sat under your ministry their entire lives what they actually know about the basic truths of religion or the specific doctrines of Christianity. Ask them to explain what the gospel is, or what salvation means. What are their duties toward God? What do they mean by religion? Who is Jesus Christ? What does His atonement mean, or redemption through His blood? Perhaps you'll admit to me yourself that you've rarely preached on these subjects. Fine, then ask them what heaven is. How does one get there? What hope do they have of living there? Ask them to explain how they've grown in holiness of heart and life, or in their readiness for death. Their clumsy answers will quickly reveal that they understood very little of all your elegant sermons, or those of your predecessor. They've gained almost nothing from forty years of church attendance. Perhaps they've occasionally enjoyed the music of your voice, like the sound of a pleasant instrument, and mistook that feeling for devotion. But their minds remain in darkness and their hearts stay earthly. They're essentially pagans with Christian names, knowing little more about God than their oxen do. In short, Polyramus's listeners have some confused knowledge, but Fluvio's congregation has hardly any knowledge at all.
But you'll tell me your sermons aren't all just flowery speeches. Sometimes your goal is to inform the mind through a series of well-connected arguments, with all your paragraphs in their lengthy sequence proving and supporting each other. And though you don't divide your sermon into distinct points, you've followed some invisible method throughout. Through some artful progression, you've brought your sermon down to its concluding sentence.
Sometimes this happens, I'll admit. But believe me, Fluvio, this artificial and invisible method brings darkness instead of light. It's not an effective way to teach ordinary people, who make up most of your audience. Their minds can't stretch wide enough to grasp the entire chain of your long, interconnected arguments. You talk reason and religion to them in vain if you don't make the argument short enough for them to grasp, giving their thoughts frequent rest. You must break the bread of life into pieces to feed children, and divide your sermons into distinct propositions to give the ignorant a clear outline of any doctrine, enabling them to understand and remember it.
Every day provides evidence confirming what I say, and it should encourage ministers to divide their sermons into several distinct points. Myrtilla, a little girl of nine years old, was at church twice yesterday. In the morning, the preacher entertained his audience with a flowing speech, and the child could give her parents no other account of it except that he talked smoothly and sweetly about virtue and heaven. It was Ergates' turn to lead the afternoon service. He's an excellent preacher, both for the wise and the simple. In the evening, Myrtilla very nicely entertained her mother by repeating the most important parts of the sermon. "Here," she said, "I can fix my thoughts on first, secondly, and thirdly: on the doctrine, the reasons, and the conclusions. I know what I need to try to remember, and I can repeat it when my friends ask me. But as for the morning sermon, I could do nothing but hear it, because I couldn't tell what I should memorize."
This loose, rambling style of speaking has damaged not only our pulpits but also many of today's essays and treatises, making them less effective at improving the reader's knowledge or enriching their memory. I'll readily admit that when a piece runs only a few pages, you don't need to formally outline all the parts before discussing each one separately, and you don't need such a rigid structure. An inexperienced reader with limited understanding can easily grasp the whole without the author pointing out each section. But when an essay stretches much longer, the reader gets confused at almost every page unless there's some framework or sequence of topics to guide the mind and help the memory.
Someone might object that these treatises and sermons aren't just random collections, since the author follows a proper method in composing them and arranges the subjects in logical order. But the reply is simple: this method is so hidden that an ordinary reader or listener can never find it. You'd have to assume that everyone reading such a book (and especially everyone listening to such a speech) already knows a good deal about logic before they can identify the various parts and sections, the connections and transitions. To an untrained eye or ear, it looks like nothing more than a pile of good material without any method, structure, or order. And if you tell your young students they should memorize and internalize it, they have no idea where to start.
If we ask why our modern clever writers favor this style, I can't think of a better reason than a mocking and willful contempt for the customs and preaching of our ancestors. A genuine disgust at some of their mistakes and poor conduct first tempted a vain generation into the opposite extreme nearly sixty years ago. Even today, it remains too much in fashion, so that the wise as well as the weak are ashamed to oppose it and get swept along with the current.
Our ancestors structured their sermons largely on the model of doctrine, reason, and application. Perhaps no other method is more universally useful or more easily adapted to most subjects, though it isn't necessary or appropriate for every sermon. But the very names "doctrine" and "application" have become such stale and old-fashioned things nowadays that a fashionable preacher is quite ashamed of them. A fashionable listener can't even bear the sound of those syllables. A direct and distinct address to the consciences of saints and sinners must not be named or mentioned, though these terms are scriptural, lest it should be hissed out of the church like the clothing of a Roundhead or a Puritan.
Some of our ancestors multiplied their points under one single heading of discourse and ran the count up to sixteen or seventeen. Culpable indeed, and far too many! But in opposition to this extreme, we are now almost ashamed to say "thirdly," and all "fourthlies" and "fifthlies" are very unfashionable words.
Our ancestors placed too much importance on the sciences of logic and metaphysics, and the formalities of definition and division, syllogism and method, when they brought them so often into the pulpit. But we hold those arts in such contempt and defiance that we would rather talk for a whole hour without order and without edification than be suspected of using logic or method in our sermons.
Our ancestors may have neglected politeness too much, indulging in coarse style and rough or awkward pronunciation. But we value elegance so highly, and our taste for what we call polite is so refined, that we won't spoil the rhythm of a sentence to quote a biblical text in it, nor disturb the harmony of our prose to number or name the points of our argument. For this reason, I've heard it suggested that the name of Christ has been banished from polite sermons because it's a monosyllable with too many consonants and too harsh a sound.
Yet for all their defects and weaknesses, our ancestors preached the gospel of Christ in ways that actually instructed entire parishes, converted sinners from their errors, and saved multitudes of souls. But as Dr. Edwards and other worthy sons of the established church have recently complained, too many pulpits today offer nothing but smooth speeches, while listeners who were ignorant of the gospel remain without knowledge, and profane sinners stay profane. May divine grace descend and reform what is wrong in all the sanctuaries of the nation!
CHAPTER 27
WRITING FOR PUBLICATION
When explaining and distinguishing between words and concepts through definition and description, when dividing things into their component parts, and when sorting things into their various categories, make sure you strike the right balance. We shouldn't always explain and distinguish, define, divide, and categorize, but we shouldn't always skip these steps either: sometimes they're useless and irrelevant, sometimes they're appropriate and necessary. Bringing too many or too few of these tools into our arguments and discussions creates confusion. One writer throws his reader into the middle of things without properly explaining them; another lumps together every idea that bears any resemblance to another without making distinctions; a third loves to explain every single word and invent distinctions between ideas that differ only slightly or not at all. But each of these approaches goes to extremes, because all these practices equally obstruct clear, accurate, and useful knowledge. No long list of rules can teach us when to explain, define, and divide, and when to leave it alone: only observation and good judgment can do that.
At the start of a treatise, it's sometimes appropriate and necessary to lay out some preliminary concepts (praecognita) or general principles that can introduce the subject and illuminate or strengthen what follows. But it's absurd to use these introductions or prefaces as an excuse to wander off into the most remote or distant topics that have no close or necessary connection to the matter at hand. This serves no purpose except to make a flashy display of learning. There was a divinity professor who began an analytical exposition of the Epistle to the Romans with preliminary concepts like these: first he demonstrated the excellence of man above other creatures, who alone could express the meaning of his mind through arbitrary signs; then he delivered a speech on the origin of language; after that he discussed the wonderful invention of writing and investigated who first created this art that taught us to paint sounds; when he had presented the various opinions of learned scholars on this point and classified writing into its several types and laid down definitions for them all, he finally got around to discussing epistolary writing and distinguished letters into familiar, private, public, recommendatory, credential, and so on. From there he moved on to discuss the salutation, the signature, and other such details, and several lectures had passed before he reached the first verse of Paul's epistle. The audience, half-starved and exhausted from waiting, drifted away one by one, so that the professor had scarcely any listeners left to attend the college or lectures he had promised on that portion of Scripture.
The principles Horace laid out in his Art of Poetry could teach many preachers and theology professors a great deal, if only they would pay attention. He tells us that a skilled author like Homer, when writing a poem about the Trojan War, wouldn't start with a long, convoluted backstory about Jupiter transforming into a swan to impregnate Leda with a double egg, from which Helen was hatched, who then married the Greek general Menelaus before being abducted by Paris, son of Priam, king of Troy, which sparked Greek fury against the Trojans:
Nec gemino bellum Trojanum orditur ab ovo (he doesn't begin the Trojan War from the double egg). Instead, the writer moves quickly toward the main events and doesn't drag things out by constantly veering off course and seizing on every incident to stretch his story, as if he lacked enough material to fill his tale:
Semper ad eventum festinat (he always hastens toward the outcome). Though I have to admit I don't think Homer always followed this rule in either of his two famous epic poems, but Horace isn't listening to my criticism. There's another related principle worth mentioning.
Just as a writer or speaker shouldn't stray from his subject to pull in irrelevant material from distant sources, neither should he pile up and drag in everything that could possibly be said, even about his chosen topic. Instead, he should consider what his main purpose is, what goal he has in mind, and then make every part of his presentation serve that purpose. If he keeps his primary objective always in view, he'll move quickly past those parts or side elements of his subject that have no clear connection to his purpose. Or he'll leave them out entirely and keep pressing toward his intended target, devoting his time, effort, and energy mainly to the aspects of his subject that are most essential for achieving his immediate and proper goal.
I could give you countless examples to prove this point, but an author who piled them up would risk becoming guilty of the very excess he's warning against.
Once you've finished any piece you plan to publish, it's always best (if circumstances allow) to set it aside for a while before releasing it. This gives you the chance to review it with the detachment of an outsider and subject the entire work to a fresh, impartial evaluation. No one can judge their own work fairly while the satisfaction of creating it is still fresh and their ego is too invested in what they've just completed.
If an author wants to publish something that will win the widest approval, he should consult people with very different perspectives, beliefs, and affiliations, and try to learn what they think of it. After all, these are exactly the kinds of readers it will encounter in the world. Show it first to various acquaintances who can examine the argument from all angles. One person may spot a problem that everyone else missed. And be sure to accept valid criticism and fair judgment wherever you find it. Don't let affection for your own writing blind you to your mistakes.
When writers ask a friend to review their work, they too often reject nearly every correction that a thoughtful friend makes. They defend this word and that phrase, justify this sentence and explain their reasoning for another paragraph, and almost never accept any changes. This completely discourages the honest feedback that a true friend would offer in pointing out our mistakes. Such writers, so wrapped up in themselves, can go ahead and admire their own flawed work, exposing both their writing and their foolishness to the world without sympathy.
Horace, in his Art of Poetry, addresses this subject brilliantly:
Quintilio si quid recitares, Corrige, sodes, Hoc, aiebat, et hoc: melius te posse negares, Bis terque expertum frustra, delere jubebat, Et malè tornatos incudi reddere versus. Si defendere delictum, quàm vertere, malles; Nullum ultrà verbum, aut operam insumebat inanem, Quin sine rivali teque et tua solus amares.
Let good Quintilius review all your lines, And he will freely say, Fix this, and this. Sir, I've tried often, and tried again, I'm sure I can't do better; it's pointless. Then delete every word, or try once more, And polish these poorly crafted verses over and over. But if you seem in love with your own ideas, More eager to defend than fix your mistakes, He says nothing more, but lets the fool continue, And without competition, admire his lovely work alone. Creech.
If you don't have friends who can review your writing, then review it yourself. As you read through, consider how different types of people will judge it. Think about what someone from your own camp would say, or how an opponent would react. Imagine the objections that a skeptical or hostile reader might raise, or what a nitpicking or jealous critic would point out. Consider what an ordinary reader versus a scholarly one would find fault with, whether in content, approach, or style. Most importantly, ask yourself what you would criticize in your own work if you held the opposite view or didn't know the author. This process will give you insights for correcting and improving your writing. It will help you defend against public criticism while making your work more useful to the audience you're primarily trying to reach.
CHAPTER 28
HANDLING CONTROVERSIAL TOPICS
WRITING ON CONTROVERSIAL SUBJECTS
When an intelligent person writes about a controversial topic, he will typically present the strongest arguments commonly used to support his position. Once he's done that, he will fairly and honestly represent the most powerful objections against it, giving them their full weight. Finally, he will offer whatever response he believes will dissolve and eliminate the force of those objections. In this way, the reader will usually find a complete view of the controversy, along with the main strength of the arguments on both sides.
When a good writer presents his opinion in full and defends it with the best and strongest evidence, he will inevitably be challenged by someone on the other side of the question. If his opponent is wise and capable, he will present the best reasons why the first writer's opinions cannot be true. In other words, he will lay out the objections against them in their fullest form, aiming to destroy what he believes is a mistaken opinion. Here we can reasonably assume that an opponent will present his objections against the supposed error more clearly and with stronger evidence than the first writer did when he originally proposed his contrary opinion.
If, in the third place, the first writer responds to his opponent with care and diligence, and defends his own position against the objections that were raised in the best possible way, the reader can then generally assume that in these three pieces he has a complete view of the controversy, together with the most solid and powerful arguments on both sides of the debate.
But when a fourth, fifth, and sixth volume appears in rejoinders and replies, we cannot reasonably expect any great amount of light to come from them, or that much further evidence for truth will be found in them. Daily experience makes it sufficiently clear that many problems attend this prolongation of controversies among learned people, which, for the most part, do injury to the truth, either by turning the reader's attention completely away from the original point to other matters, or by covering the truth with a multitude of incidental issues and complications that serve to confuse rather than guide a sincere inquirer.
Sometimes in these later volumes, the writers on both sides will fixate on minor words and casual expressions of their opponent in order to expose them, which have no necessary connection with the main point at issue and which have nothing to do with the truth being debated.
Sometimes writers will spend pages defending their own reputation or justifying some minor statement or casual remark against their opponent's criticism, even when these expressions have nothing to do with the actual truth being debated.
And sometimes you'll find even intelligent writers who, having expressed themselves poorly or indefensibly, get so caught up in self-love that they try to justify those expressions and defend their small mistakes rather than simply correcting them or retracting those inappropriate statements. If only we could set aside our pride, our arrogance, and our sense of infallibility when we enter into a debate about truth! But when a writer mixes these things into his main argument, the reader who has enough judgment to recognize them and ignore everything that doesn't belong to the original topic being discussed will be fortunate.
However, I should note one exception to this general observation: when the second writer attacks only a specific or side opinion that the first writer maintained, then the fourth piece of writing might contain a necessary part of the complete argument, just like the second and third, because the first piece only mentioned that idea in passing or as a side point, which the second then attacks and opposes. In such a case, the second piece should be considered the first real treatment of that particular controversy. It would take too much time to point out examples of this kind, which you could find in most controversial writers, and it might be unfair to get into specifics.
READING CONTROVERSIAL ARGUMENTS
When we pick up a book that argues for a particular doctrine or opinion, we too often decide beforehand whether it's right or wrong. If we agree with the writer, we're naturally inclined to accept his arguments as solid and substantial. This way, our existing beliefs get reinforced without any genuine search for truth.
If we disagree with the writer, we assume from the start that his arguments carry no weight. We give the book only a cursory glance and quickly dismiss it as mistaken, weak, and inadequate. Countless ordinary readers who have fallen into error, when advised to read something that would correct them, approach it with a disgust they've already formed. They skim lightly over the arguments, ignore or dismiss their force, and cling firmly to their own conclusions. In this way, they maintain their error even when surrounded by light, making themselves incapable of being convinced.
If we truly want to act like honest seekers of truth, we should examine every argument with a careful and unbiased mind, whether it agrees with our previous opinion or not. We should give every line of reasoning its full weight and consider it with our most sober judgment. The best way to test the strength of arguments brought against our own opinions is to sit down and try to give a solid answer, one by one, to every argument the author uses to support his doctrine. In this attempt, if we find some arguments we can't answer fairly to our own satisfaction, we should then start to ask ourselves whether we've been mistaken all along, and whether the person defending the opposite view might actually be right. A method like this will effectively prevent us from immediately dismissing doctrines and writers who contradict our beliefs. Instead, we'll work to find solid arguments to refute their positions before we fully commit ourselves to the opposite opinion.
Volatilis had thrown himself into the company of our age's free-thinkers on every topic. Charmed by the cleverness and apparent logic in some of our modern deists, he had abandoned the Christian faith too easily and joined the ranks of the infidels. Among other books recommended to bring him back to the gospel faith, someone placed Mr. John Reynolds's three Letters to a Deist in his hands. They especially urged him to read the third letter with extreme care, since it offered an irrefutable defense of Christianity's truth. He picked it up, and after a quick look through it, he told his friend he saw nothing but the usual arguments we all use to support whatever religion we were raised in. These arguments didn't convince him at all, and he still saw no good reason to believe that Christ's Gospel was anything more than religious fanaticism or outright fraud.
At this point, the friend who had recommended Mr. Reynolds's three letters, confident in the power of truth contained there, begged Volatilis to sit down seriously and try to write a response to Mr. Reynolds's third letter defending the gospel. He asked him to show, point by point, how each step in Christianity's spread could have been the natural result of fraud or fanaticism, and therefore why it deserves no trust from reasonable people.
Volatilis took on the project, but after he'd gotten a little way into it, he found himself completely lost. His arguments trying to prove the apostles were either fanatics or con artists became so muddled, so confused, and so unconvincing that after carefully reviewing this letter to the deists, he finally admitted he was fully convinced that the religion of Jesus was divine. That Christian author had made it clear that this doctrine could never have spread throughout the world through naivety or stupidity, through deception or lies. And so he gave his soul over to the gospel of the blessed Jesus.
I'm afraid there have been countless unbelievers like Volatilis. He himself has told me that even his most rational friends would be forced to accept the evidence for Christian doctrine if they would honestly try the same approach.
THE END.