Wonders of the Invisible World
Cotton Mather
N.B. The following text was freely provided by Updated Works. Their updated books and audios are superb in every way.
"Some of the most important ideas in history are locked away in old books that modern readers struggle to understand. Archaic language, unfamiliar phrasing, and outdated conventions create unnecessary barriers to timeless wisdom.
"Updated Works exists to change that. We take significant older texts and translate them into clear, contemporary English while faithfully preserving the author's original meaning and voice. Our goal is simple: make important books readable again.
"Archaic spelling, obsolete words, and tangled sentence structure are rendered into clear, contemporary English--always preserving the author's meaning, voice, and line of argument. We modernize the language, never the message."Please visit their website to purchase select hardcopy books and audio books: Updated Works.
CONTENTS
1. Why This Book Was Written: The Author's Defense
2. The Devil in New England: An Account of the Afflictions
3. A Guide to Discovering Witches (From the Work of Mr. Perkins)
4. The Invisible War: A Sermon on the Devil's Final Assault
5. An Urgent Address to a Nation Under Siege by the Devil
6. A Ghostly Warning: The Apparition of a Murdered Brother
7. An English Precedent: A Witch Trial Before Judge Matthew Hale
8. The Trial of George Burroughs
9. The Trial of Bridget Bishop
10. The Trial of Susanna Martin
11. The Trial of Elizabeth How
12. The Trial of Martha Carrier, the "Queen of Hell"
13. Remarkable Curiosities: Invisibility, Apparitions, and Diabolical Imitations
14. Further Accounts and Eyewitness Testimonies
15. A Crisis of Conscience: Can We Trust the Evidence of Spectres?
16. Postscript: Final Reflections on the Trials
CHAPTER 1
WHY THIS BOOK WAS WRITTEN: THE AUTHOR'S DEFENSE
As I recall, the learned Scribonius reports that one of his acquaintances, while devoutly praying for a person tormented by evil spirits, received a terrible blow to the face from those spirits. I myself might expect some attacks from evil spirits for the efforts I am about to make against them. I am well aware that during this extraordinary time of the devil coming down on us with great wrath, many tongues and hearts are "set on fire of hell" (James 3:6). The various opinions about the recent witchcraft troubles are held by some with such intense fury, as if they could only be adequately expressed in the ink witches use to write their covenants. Anyone who becomes an author at such a time needs to be "fenced with iron, and the staff of a spear" (2 Sam. 23:7). The unexplainable stubbornness, harshness, unreasonableness, and inconsistency of many people every day visibly illustrates the passage, "An evil spirit from the Lord came upon Saul" (1 Sam. 16:14), and the story, "There met him two possessed with devils, exceeding fierce, so that no man might pass by that way" (Matt. 8:28). Sending out a book to such readers would be unwise if a person didn't have good reasons for doing so, as I do. Briefly, I hope it cannot be said, "They are all so." No, I hope the majority of this people are still able to thoughtfully make a right use of the astonishing and extraordinary events happening among us. Because I was concerned when I saw that no more capable person was writing essays to engage the minds of this people in the holy, pious, and fruitful improvements that God wants us to make from His amazing works now upon us, I have done what is done. Only "the Father, who sees in secret" (Matt. 6:6), knows the heart-breaking struggles I have faced while composing what is now going to be shared, lest I fail in any way to serve His glory and His people. But I am now somewhat comforted by His favorable acceptance, and "I will not fear; what can a Satan do unto me!"
Having done some of what God requires by trying to match His words to His works happening today among us, and also addressing a topic that has sometimes been considered worthy of a king's attention, it will be clear that some secondary goals have been considered in these efforts.
I have indeed set myself to counteract the entire plot of the devil against New England, in every aspect of it, as far as someone of my limited understanding can grasp such a work of darkness. I may add that I have also aimed to inform and satisfy good people in another country, a thousand leagues away, where I may have more, or at least more significant, friends than in my own. I do what I can to maintain the best relations with that country, now and always. But while I am doing these things, I have been compelled to do something for myself as well; I mean, by addressing the false reports and harsh criticisms about my opinion on these matters, the challenges my pursuit of peace has brought me among the critics. My consistent thoughts are published here, and I believe they will be supported by most of the ministers of God in these colonies; nor can adequate amends be made for the wrong done to me by other kinds of representations.
In short, for the doctrinal part of my discourse, I need no defense; for the historical part, I have a very strong one. The Lieutenant-Governor of New England, after reviewing it, has honored me by providing a shield, under whose protection I now confidently venture out.
Reverend and Dear Sir,
You greatly pleased me and showed respect when you gave me your detailed and timely work titled "The Wonders of the Invisible World." After reading such a fruitful and well-timed composition on this subject, especially considering my role in the Court of Oyer and Terminer, which is still working on the trials of those accused and convicted of witchcraft, I feel more deeply and personally involved than just an ordinary reader. I must express my gratitude and appreciation for your hard work. I feel obligated, in my current public role, to declare my strong approval of it. Your purpose is clearly expressed throughout; your zeal for God, your opposition to Satan and his kingdom, your faithfulness and compassion for these poor people; the vigor yet great restraint of your spirit; your instruction and counsel, your care for truth, your wisdom and skill in calming and moderating what needs it among us; your clear understanding of divine providences and the periods now quickly moving towards their glorious outcomes in the world; and finally, your good news of "The Shortness of the Devil's Time," make it so that all good people must desire to see your work made public. They will greatly rejoice that the "Spirit of the Lord" has enabled you to "lift up a standard" against the infernal enemy that has been "coming in like a flood upon us" (Isa. 59:19). Therefore, I earnestly request that you commit this work to the press as soon as possible. I am,
Your assured friend,
William Stoughton.
I live among neighbors who compel me to write these undeserved lines. But now, just as when Mr. Wilson, observing a large gathering of soldiers, was told by a gentleman present, "Sir, I'll tell you a great thing: Here is a mighty body of people; and there is not seven of them all, but what loves Mr. Wilson." That gracious man promptly and pleasantly replied, "Sir, I'll tell you as good a thing as that; here is a mighty body of people, and there is not so much as one among them all, but Mr. Wilson loves him." Similarly, it's possible that among this group of people, there may be few who love the writer of this book; but allow me to boast this much, there is not one among all this group of people whom this Mather would not strive to serve, as well as to love. With such a spirit of love, is the book now before us written: I appeal to all this world; and if this world will deny me the right of acknowledging so much, I appeal to the other, that it is not written with an evil spirit: for this reason, I shall not be surprised if evil spirits are angered by what is written, just as the Sadducees were likely upset by what was spoken in the days of our Savior. I only ask for the justice that others read it with the same spirit with which I wrote it.
CHAPTER 2
THE DEVIL IN NEW ENGLAND: AN ACCOUNT OF THE AFFLICTIONS
FROM A PURITAN UTOPIA TO A LAND OF TROUBLES
In 1637, a faithful minister of the Church of England named Mr. Edward Symons, in a sermon later printed, expressed himself like this: "At New England now the Sun of Comfort begins to appear, and the glorious Day-Star to show itself; there will come times in after ages, when the clouds will overshadow and darken the sky there." Many now promise themselves nothing but ongoing happiness there, which for a time through God's mercy they may enjoy; and I pray God, they may for a long time; but in this world, there is no perpetual happiness. An observation, or almost an inspiration, now sadly verified upon us! It has been stated by some who best knew New England that the world would do New England a great injustice if it did not acknowledge a measure of religion, loyalty, honesty, and industry in the people there, beyond what is found with any other people for their number.
When I published a book a few years ago mentioning some memorable witchcrafts committed in this country, the excellent Baxter graced the second edition of that book with a kind preface, where he saw fit to say, "If any are scandalized, that New England, a place of as serious piety as any I can hear of, under Heaven, should be troubled so much with witches; I think, 'tis no wonder: Where will the Devil show most malice, but where he is hated, and hateth most." And I hope the country will still deserve and answer the charity so expressed by that reverend man of God. Whoever travels over this wilderness will see it richly adorned with evangelical churches, whose pastors are holy, capable, and diligent overseers of their flocks, lively preachers, and virtuous livers; and such as in their several neighborly associations, have had their meetings where ecclesiastical matters of common concernment are considered.
Churches, whose communicants have been seriously examined about their experiences of regeneration, as well as about their knowledge, belief, and blameless conversation before their admission to the sacred communion; although others of lesser but hopeful attainments in Christianity are not ordinarily denied baptism for themselves and theirs. Churches, which are cautious of using anything in the worship of God for which they cannot see a warrant from God; but with whom yet the names of Congregational, Presbyterian, Episcopalian, or Antipaedobaptist, are swallowed up in that of Christian; persons of all those persuasions being taken into our fellowship when visible godliness has recommended them. Churches, which usually manage their own discipline within themselves, under the guidance of their elders; but yet call in the help of synods upon emergencies or grievances. Churches, lastly, wherein multitudes are growing ripe for heaven every day; and as fast as these are taken off, others are daily rising up. And by the presence and power of the divine institutions thus maintained in the country, we are still so happy that I suppose there is no land in the universe more free from the debauching and debasing vices of ungodliness. The body of the people are so disposed that swearing, Sabbath-breaking, whoring, drunkenness, and the like, do not make a gentleman, but a monster, or a goblin, in the common estimation. All this notwithstanding, we must humbly confess to our God that we are miserably degenerated from the first love of our predecessors; however, we boast a little when men would go to trample upon us, and we venture to say, "Wherein soever any is bold (we speak foolishly) we are bold also."
The first planters of these colonies were a chosen generation of men, who were first so pure as to disrelish many things they thought needed reformation elsewhere; and yet withal so peaceable that they embraced a voluntary exile in a squalid, horrid American desert, rather than live in contentions with their brethren. Those good men imagined they would leave their posterity in a place where they would never see the inroads of profanity or superstition. A famous person returning from here could, in a sermon before the Parliament, profess, "I have now been seven years in a country where I never saw one man drunk, or heard one oath sworn, or beheld one beggar in the streets all the while." Such great persons as Budæus and others, who mistook Sir Thomas More's Utopia for a country really existent, and stirred up some divines charitably to undertake a voyage there, might now have certainly found a truth in their mistake; New England was a true Utopia. But, alas, the children and servants of those old planters must inevitably produce many degenerate plants, and there is now a number of people risen up, otherwise inclined than our Joshuas and the elders that outlived them.
Those two things, our holy progenitors and our happy advantages, make omissions of duty and such spiritual disorders as the whole world abroad is overwhelmed with, to be as provoking in us as the most flagitious wickednesses committed in other places; and the ministers of God are accordingly severe in their testimonies. But in short, those interests of the Gospel, which were the errand of our fathers into these ends of the earth, have been too much neglected and postponed, and the attainments of a decent education have been too much undervalued by multitudes that have not fallen into excesses of wickedness; and some, especially of our young ones, when they have gotten abroad from under the restraints here laid upon them, have become extravagantly and abominably vicious. Hence, the happiness of New England has been but for a time, as it was foretold, and not for a long time, as has been desired for us. A variety of calamity has long followed this plantation; and we have every reason imaginable to ascribe it to the rebuke of Heaven upon us for our manifold apostasies; we make no right use of our disasters if we do not "Remember whence we are fallen, and repent, and do the first works" (Rev. 2:5). But yet our afflictions may come under further consideration with us: there is a further cause of our afflictions, whose due must be given him.
THE DEVIL'S WAR ON NEW ENGLAND
The New Englanders are a people of God settled in what were once the Devil's territories. It's easy to imagine that the Devil was very upset when he saw such a people fulfilling the promise made to our Blessed Jesus, "That He should have the utmost parts of the Earth for his possession" (Psalm 2:8). There wasn't a greater uproar among the Ephesians when the Gospel was first brought to them than there was among the "Powers of the Air" (Eph. 2:2) when the "Silver Trumpets" of the Gospel made the "Joyful Sound" here. The Devil, irritated, immediately tried all sorts of methods to overturn this poor plantation. The church, which had fled into this wilderness, immediately found, "The Serpent cast out of his mouth a flood for the carrying of it away" (Rev. 12:15). I believe that never were more Satanic devices used to unsettle any people under the sun than what have been employed for the destruction of the vine which God has planted here, "Casting out the heathen, and preparing a room before it, and causing it to take deep root, and fill the land, so that it sent its boughs unto the Atlantic Sea eastward, and its branches unto the Connecticut River westward, and the hills were covered with the shadow thereof" (Psalm 80:8-10). But all those attempts of Hell have been unsuccessful. Many an Ebenezer has been erected to the praise of God by His poor people here, and "Having obtained help from God, we continue to this day" (Acts 26:22). Therefore, the Devil is now making one more attempt on us; an attempt more difficult, more surprising, and more tangled with unintelligible circumstances than any we have encountered before. It's an attempt so critical that if we get through it well, we shall soon enjoy peaceful days with all the vultures of Hell "trodden under our feet" (Rom. 16:20). He has lacked his incarnate legions to persecute us, as the people of God have been persecuted in the other hemisphere. He has therefore drawn forth his more spiritual ones to attack us. We have been advised by some credible Christians still alive that a criminal, accused of witchcraft as well as murder and executed here more than forty years ago, gave notice of "An horrible plot against the country by witchcraft, and a foundation of witchcraft then laid, which if it were not seasonally discovered, would probably blow up, and pull down all the churches in the country." And we have now with horror seen the discovery of such witchcraft! An army of devils has horribly broken in upon the place which is the center, and in a way, the first-born of our English settlements. The houses of the good people there are filled with the doleful shrieks of their children and servants, tormented by invisible hands with tortures altogether unnatural.
After the mischiefs there attempted, and since partly conquered, the terrible plague of evil angels has spread to other places, where other people have been similarly diabolically handled. These poor afflicted neighbors, soon after becoming infected and infested with these demons, gain the ability to discern what they believe are the shapes of their tormentors. Despite the great and just suspicion that the demons might impose the shapes of innocent people in their spectral exhibitions upon the sufferers (which may prove to be a significant part of the witch-plot in the end), many of the people thus represented, when examined, have been convicted of very damnable witchcraft. Yes, more than twenty have confessed that they have signed a book the Devil showed them and engaged in his hellish design of bewitching and ruining our land. We do not know, or at least I do not know, how far the delusions of Satan may be interwoven into some circumstances of the confessions. But one would think all the rules of understanding human affairs are at an end if, after so many voluntary harmonious confessions made by intelligent people of all ages, in various towns, at different times, we must not believe the main points where those confessions all agree. Especially when we have a thousand unnatural things every day before our eyes, in which the confessors acknowledge their involvement and demonstrate their involvement. If the devils can now strike the minds of men with any poisons of such fine composition and operation that scores of innocent people shall unite in confessions of a crime, which we see actually committed, it is a thing prodigious, beyond the wonders of former ages, and it threatens no less than a sort of dissolution upon the world.
Now, by these confessions, it's agreed that the Devil has made a dreadful knot of witches in the country, and by the help of witches has dreadfully increased that knot. These witches have driven a trade of commissioning their confederate spirits to do all sorts of mischiefs to the neighbors, resulting in such harmful consequences upon the bodies and estates of the neighborhood as could not otherwise be explained. Yes, at prodigious witch-meetings, the wretches have proceeded so far as to plan and consult the methods of rooting out the Christian religion from this country and setting up instead of it, perhaps a more gross diabolesm than the world has ever seen before. And yet it will be a thing little short of a miracle if, in such a widespread business as this, the Devil should not get in some of his tricks to confuse the discovery of all the rest.
WHY SO MANY ACCUSED? THE QUESTION OF INNOCENCE
Many people will likely be scandalized by the number of individuals accused or suspected of witchcraft in New England. However, it's easy to provide explanations that could lessen this scandal. If God allows the devils to lure a few wicked individuals into witchcraft and then use them to spread their harmful influence among ignorant, envious, and discontented people, leading them into sudden acts that trap them in the snares of hell, what country wouldn't have numerous witches?
The kingdoms of Sweden, Denmark, Scotland, and even England, as well as New England, have all experienced outbreaks of witchcraft that caused significant devastation. I hope these will be the last. It's not hard to imagine that God has not revealed all the witchcrafts in other lands with the same swift, dreadful, and destructive jealousy as He has here, in a land of righteousness. Here, transgressors may more quickly face the vengeance of Him "who has eyes like a flame of fire" and "who walks in the midst of the golden candlesticks" (Rev. 1:14, 1:13). Furthermore, if other parts of the world mock the people of God here, they should remember the story from Loim in the Duchy of Gulic. There, a Catholic curate, after failing to use charms to expel a devil from a possessed girl, angrily told the devil to come out of her and into himself. The devil replied, "What need I meddle with one whom I am sure to have, and hold at the Last-day as my own forever!"
But besides all this, let me add, we hope that among the people represented by the spectres that now trouble our neighbors, there will be some who never explicitly made a pact with evil angels. The witches have not only hinted but some have admitted that they have plotted to represent innocent people to cover and protect themselves in their witchcrafts. Now, although our good God has generally protected us from the abuse intended by the devils, who among us can precisely determine how far God may allow the devil to proceed in such abuse for our chastisement? It was the conclusion of a recent discussion among some very pious and learned ministers that the devils may sometimes be allowed to represent an innocent person as tormenting those under diabolical attacks.
However, such occurrences are rare and extraordinary, especially when these matters come before civil courts. This opinion, expressed with caution and judgment, seems to be the prevailing view of many others who are notably cautious and judicious, and they have both argument and history to support them. It is rare and extraordinary for an honest Naboth to have his life sworn away by two children of Belial, yet this does not infringe on the righteous rule of our eternal sovereign, whose judgments are a great deep, and who gives no account of His matters (Job 33:13). Thus, although the appearance of innocent people in spectral exhibitions afflicting the neighborhood is rare and extraordinary, who can be sure that the great Belial of Hell must always be restrained from this mischief? The best man who ever lived has been called a witch, so why might not this too common and unfortunate symptom of a witch, even a spectral representation, happen to a person who is not among the worst? Is it not possible? The Laplanders will tell us it's possible for people to be unknowingly attended by helpful demons, bequeathed to them and imposed upon them by relatives who were witches. Query, also, whether at a time when the devil and his witches are engaged in a war upon a people, some of our actions in such a war may not lead to us appearing in certain ways among them in the visions of our afflicted forlorn ones! And who can certainly say what other degrees or methods of sinning, besides that of a diabolical pact, may give the devils the advantage to act in the shape of those who have erred? Besides what may happen for a while to test the patience of the virtuous. May not some who have been quick to uncharitably judge and reproach others on weak grounds be punished for it by spectres exposing them to judgment and reproach for a while?
Furthermore, I pray that it may be considered whether a world of magical tricks often used in the world may not unknowingly oblige devils to attend the superstitious users of them. A witty writer against Sadducism has observed that people who never made any express contract with apostate spirits may still act strangely with diabolical aids, which they obtain by using those wicked forms and arts that the devil first imparted to his allies. He adds, "We know not but the laws of the dark kingdom may enjoin a particular attendance upon all those that practice their mysteries, whether they know them to be theirs or not." Some of those accused of employing evil spirits to harm our land have been known to be bloody fortune-tellers, and some have confessed that when they told fortunes, they would pretend to use the rules of chiromancy and other ignorant sciences, but indeed they had no rule, they said, but this: "The things were then darted into their minds." Darted! By whom, I ask? Surely by none but the devils, who, though perhaps they did not exactly foreknow all the predicted contingencies, yet having once foretold them, they stood bound in honor to use their influence, which, alas, in this world, is very great, for the fulfillment of their own predictions. There are others who have used wicked sorceries to satisfy their unlawful curiosities or to prevent inconveniences in man and beast; sorceries which I will not name, lest by naming, I teach them.
Now, some devil is always invited into the service of the person who practices these witchcrafts, and if they have continued impenitently in these communions with any devil, the devil may perhaps become a familiar to them, and so assume their livery, that they cannot shake him off in any way but that one, which I would most heartily prescribe to them, namely, that of deep and long repentance. Should these impieties have been committed in a place like New England, for my part, I would not be surprised if, when devils are exposing the grosser witches among us, God permits them to bring in these lesser ones with the rest for their perpetual humiliation. In the end, may it not be found that New England is not as filled with rattlesnakes as was imagined?
A PLOT TO SOW DIVISION AND CHAOS
But I don't believe that the spread of witchcraft among us is the only plan the Devil is working on with the witchcraft happening now. It's thought that the Devil caused the storm mentioned in Matthew 8 to try to overturn the little boat where the disciples of our Lord were with Him. We might fear that in the horrible storm we are facing now, the Devil's plan is to disrupt the happy government settlement that Almighty God has graciously inclined Their Majesties to grant us. We are blessed with a Governor who is more than willing to serve Their Majesties and this province. He is constantly risking everything to do so, and if the interests of his Prince weren't dearer to him than his own, he would soon tire of the helm he holds. We have a Lieutenant Governor who is not only admirably accomplished with both natural and acquired talents, fitting him for Their Majesties' service, but also applies himself with unblemished loyalty. Our counselors are some of our most eminent people, loyal subjects to the Crown, and true lovers of their country. Our constitution also comes with unique privileges, all of which the Devil greatly envies. The Devil will surely use this opportunity to raise complaints and clamor that could harm some part of our current settlement if he can impose so far. But what most threatens us now is the misunderstanding and animosity that the raging witchcraft has enchanted us into. The turmoil of our spirits and then our affairs is clearly a significant part of the hellish plot that now troubles us.
The Devil has made us like a troubled sea, and the mire and mud are beginning to rise quickly. Even good and wise men let themselves fall into their fits, and the shake the Devil is giving us brings up the dirt that lay still at the bottom of our sinful hearts. If we let the mad dogs of Hell poison us by biting us, we'll imagine we see nothing but such things around us and attack everything we see. If it weren't for what's in us, I wouldn't fear a thousand legions of devils. It's our quarrels that ruin our prayers, and if our humble, zealous, and united prayers are hindered, alas, the Philistines of Hell have cut our locks; they will blind us, mock us, ruin us. I can't entirely blame people for being a little carried away when they think all their secular interests and those of their families are at stake.
Yet, seeing these heartburnings, I can't help but exclaim like the sweet-spirited Augustine in his peace-making letter to Jerome about the contest with Ruffin, O truly miserable condition! But what can be done to cure these distractions? It's wonderfully necessary that some healing attempts be made now, and I must confess (if I may speak so much) like a Nazianzen, I am so eager to be part of them that if being thrown overboard were needed to calm the storm, I would consider dying a small price for such a great blessing.
A PLEA FOR CHARITY AND UNITY
I would urgently ask everyone to maintain a holy suspicion over their soul at this time and consider: Could the Devil use me, even unknowingly and unwillingly, as an instrument to do something he wants done? Personally, I admit my suspicion that some form of enchantment may have affected more people and spirits among us than we realize. However, let's generally agree to maintain a kind opinion of one another. That charity, without which even giving our bodies to be burned would profit nothing, follows this rule: it is kind, it is not easily provoked, it thinks no evil, it believes all things, hopes all things (1 Cor. 13:3-7). If we ignore this rule of charity, we will indeed give our political body to be burned. I've heard it said that during the recent great flood in Connecticut, creatures that would normally quarrel stood by each other agreeably. We would be worse than animals if we turn against each other when the floods of evil make us afraid. On one side, there are very worthy men who, having been called by God when and where this witchcraft first appeared, are eager to get to the bottom of it. And I ask, which of us, living under the constant pressure of the tortures, outcries, and havoc caused by devils, confessedly commissioned by witches among their distressed neighbors, wouldn't have a bias in that direction? People inclined this way have been men known for wisdom and virtue, driven by a noble sense of conscience. Had conscience (duty to God) not prevailed over other considerations, they wouldn't have involved themselves in this thorny business for all they are worth in the world. Have there been disputed methods used in uncovering the works of darkness? Perhaps none but those with great precedents in other parts of the world, which may not fully justify but can alleviate a mistake in us if any such mistake is found in such a dark matter.
They have acted with repeated prayers to God for guidance and are aware of how much they have exposed themselves in what they have done. They would gladly find a way to spare the shedding of blood by recovering witches not beyond the reach of pardon. They invite all good men, saying, "Being amazed at the number and quality of those accused of late, we do not know but Satan by his wiles may have enwrapped some innocent persons; and therefore should earnestly and humbly desire the most critical enquiry upon the place, to find out the fallacy; that there may be none of the servants of the Lord, with the worshippers of Baal." I may also add that if a witch confesses among us, no more spectres appear in their shapes to trouble the neighborhood. If any guilty individuals confess their crime to a minister of God and escape the Devil's snare, no minister will reveal such a conscientious confession, and I believe no authority will press him to reveal it, but rejoice in a soul saved from death. On the other side, there are very worthy men who are not satisfied with the proceedings in prosecuting this witchcraft. Why? Not because they want to defend such abominable things from impartial justice. No, those reverend persons who advised the honorable council that presumptions leading to commitment and convictions leading to condemnation for witchcraft should be more substantial than just the accused being represented by a spectre to the afflicted, nor should changes in the sufferers by a look or touch of the accused be considered infallible evidence of guilt, as they are often subject to the Devil's tricks. Those same men of God conscientiously added this to their advice: "Nevertheless we cannot but humbly recommend unto the government, the speedy and vigorous prosecution of such as have rendered themselves obnoxious; according to the best directions given in the laws of God, and the wholesome statutes of the English nation for the detection of witchcraft." It is commendable caution in those gracious men to be wary lest the Devil infiltrates our faith, making us believe lies for the sake of many truths he tells us, leading to a desolation of names and other harmful consequences. They are cautious lest any principles are adopted that, when practiced, would cause the righteous to perish with the wicked or lead to the bloodshed of any persons, like the Gibeonites, whom some learned men believe were exterminated by Saul under a false notion of witches (Josh. 9:3-27).
They want all the necessary steps taken to eliminate witches, but they want to be sure those steps are effective. It's not from anything but genuine and sincere goodness that these people are reluctant to suspect others of wrongdoing until there is solid evidence. As for the honorable judges who have been part of the commission so far, they are beyond my judgment. Therefore, I will only say this much: those of them whom I have the honor of knowing personally are people of excellent character. Initially, they approached the task they were commissioned for with great reluctance, and they have continually been deeply concerned about how they might best serve both God and humanity in this matter. In conclusion, if there have been mistakes on any side, surely they have been, at worst, the mistakes of well-meaning ignorance. So, on every side, why shouldn't we strive to help each other out of the traps the Devil wants to ensnare us in, through friendly cooperation? Trying to argue the Devil out of the country will truly be a new experiment. Alas, we are not aware of the Devil if we don't realize that he aims to turn us against one another. Shall we allow ourselves to be controlled by the Devil, or through any lack of wisdom, contribute to widening our divisions?
In short, there is a published and credible account that claims very recently in a part of England, where some neighbors were arguing, a raven from the top of a tree very clearly and inexplicably cried out, "Read the Third of Colossians and the Fifteenth!" If I were to choose what sort of bird I would be transformed into, I would say, "O that I had wings like a dove!" However, I will for once take on the role that, it seems, Heaven sent that raven to do; to ask, "That the peace of God may rule in our hearts."
ON THE PROPER METHOD OF INVESTIGATION AND THE USE OF SPECTRAL EVIDENCE
It's necessary that we unite in everything, but there are especially two things where our unity must guide us. We need to unite in our efforts to help our distressed neighbors, who are being horribly harassed and tormented by a dreadful witchcraft. We should avoid anything that might hinder or obstruct a proper investigation of this witchcraft with holy fear. Their Majesties' good subjects must not be torn apart by horrid witches every day, and those bloody criminals must not be left unpunished. Witchcraft is a matter that won't be ignored without bringing us severe and lasting troubles. But we must also unite in methods for this deliverance that are unquestionably safe, lest "the latter end be worse than the beginning." What can I say here? I will venture to say this much: we are safe when we use advice from the invisible world as much as God intends for us to. It is a safe principle that when God Almighty allows any spirits from the unseen regions to visit us with surprising information, there is something to investigate; we should then ask one another what the cause for such things might be. God's unique governance over the unbodied intelligences is a sufficient foundation for this principle. When a murder has been committed, an apparition of the slain party accusing someone, although such apparitions have often spoken true rather than false, is not enough to convict the person of that murder.
However, it is a sufficient reason for magistrates to make a particular inquiry into whether the accused person has given any reason for such an accusation. Similarly, a specter that exactly resembles a certain person, when the neighborhood is tormented by such specters, may reasonably prompt magistrates to investigate whether the person represented has done or said anything that suggests their alliance with evil spirits, even if it may not be enough for conviction. This is especially true at a time when it's possible that some overly powerful conjurer might have learned how to exhibit the shapes of all sorts of people, with the intention of stopping the prosecution of the wretches whom proper inquiries, thus provoked, might have made liable to justice.
Whether, if God wants us to go beyond just inquiry based on reports from the spiritual world against someone, He will also provide us with clear and tangible evidence to consider someone a criminal. I will say this further: it is wise to protect both the names and lives of our neighbors until it is clear through human observation that the peace of mankind is disturbed. We are human beings, and it is safe to assert that witnesses must also be human, having only human assistance in their act of seeing or hearing, which qualifies them as witnesses when laws are to be enforced. Additionally, a wise and just magistrate may choose to hold back from acting on their own strong beliefs about what may be considered proof of a crime if the nature of the crime is so complex and unclear that it causes much debate. While they should not neglect their duties, they may choose not to act on something they otherwise could when public safety demands it.
A SUMMARY OF RULES FROM THE EXPERTS
I was about to make one more attempt; that is, to offer some safe rules for identifying the witches who are currently our cursed troublemakers. However, this would be too presumptuous and risky for me to attempt. I leave that to those excellent and wise individuals with whom I am not worthy to be counted. All I will do is present to my readers a brief summary of what has been written on this subject by a group of three eminent individuals who have ever addressed it. I will begin with,
CHAPTER 3
A GUIDE TO DISCOVERING WITCHES (FROM THE WORK OF MR. PERKINS)
MR. PERKINS'S METHOD: GROUNDS FOR SUSPICION (BUT NOT CONVICTION)
1. There are presumptions, which at least probably and conjecturally suggest someone to be a witch. These give reason to examine, yet they are not sufficient causes for conviction.
2. If any man or woman is notoriously accused of being a witch, this creates a strong suspicion. Yet the judge should carefully ensure that the report is made by people of honesty and credit.
3. If a fellow witch or magician gives testimony that someone is a witch, this alone is not enough for condemnation; however, it is a reasonable presumption to warrant a thorough examination.
4. If after cursing there follows death, or at least some mischief, for witches are known to practice their harmful acts by cursing and banning, this is also a sufficient matter for examination, though not for conviction.
5. If after enmity, quarreling, or threatening, a present mischief follows, that is also a strong presumption.
6. If the person suspected is the son or daughter, the man-servant or maid-servant, the familiar friend, near neighbor, or old companion of a known and convicted witch, this can also be a presumption. Witchcraft is an art that can be learned and passed from person to person.
MR. PERKINS'S METHOD: UNRELIABLE TESTS AND INSUFFICIENT PROOFS
7. Some add this as evidence: If the person suspected is found to have the Devil's mark, it is commonly believed that when the Devil makes his covenant with them, he always leaves his mark on them, so he knows they belong to him—a mark for which no clear natural explanation can be given.
8. Lastly, if the person being questioned is inconsistent or contradicts themselves in their deliberate answers, it suggests a guilty conscience, which hinders their ability to speak freely. However, there are reasons for astonishment that can affect both the good and the bad.
9. But then there is a conviction, discovering the witch, which must proceed from just and sufficient proofs, and not from mere presumptions.
10. Scratching the suspected person and their recovery afterward, along with several other weak proofs, such as the floating of the suspected person when thrown on water, are far from being sufficient. In fact, some of these are, in a way, practices of witchcraft themselves.
11. The testimony of a wizard, even if they claim to show the witch's face in a glass, may be a good reason to conduct a thorough examination, but it cannot be considered sufficient proof for conviction. If the devil tells the grand jury that the person in question is a witch and offers to confirm it with an oath, should the jury accept the devil's oath or accusation to condemn the person? Certainly not. And yet, that is equivalent to the testimony of another wizard, who only reveals the witch with the devil's help.
12. If a man, being dangerously sick and likely to die, upon suspicion, claims on his deathbed that a certain person has bewitched him, it is an allegation of the same nature that may prompt the judge to examine the accused party, but it holds no weight for conviction.
MR. PERKINS'S METHOD: SUFFICIENT PROOFS FOR CONVICTION
13. Among the sufficient means of conviction, the first is the free and voluntary confession of the crime made by the party suspected and accused, after examination. I am not saying that a mere confession is sufficient, but a confession after due examination, taken upon strong presumptions. What more witness or further inquiry is needed now?
14. There is a second sufficient conviction, by the testimony of two witnesses, of good and honest reputation, affirming before the magistrate, based on their own knowledge, these two things: either that the accused party has made a pact with the Devil, or has engaged in some known practice of witchcraft. And all arguments that necessarily prove either of these, when brought by two sufficient witnesses, are strong enough to fully convince regarding the party suspected.
15. If it can be proved that the person suspected has called upon the Devil or desired his help, this is strong evidence of a previous agreement made between them.
16. If it can be proved that the person has entertained a familiar spirit and had a conversation with it in the form of some visible creatures, here is evidence of witchcraft.
17. If the witnesses swear under oath that the suspected person has done any action or work that necessarily implies a covenant made, such as using enchantments, predicting things before they happen with certainty, raising storms, or causing the form of a dead person to appear, it sufficiently proves that he or she is a witch. This is the essence of Mr. Perkins.
MR. GAULE'S JUDGMENT: DISTINGUISHING BETWEEN SUPERSTITION AND EVIDENCE
Take next the summary of Mr. Gaule's judgment about detecting witches:
1. Some signs for identifying witches are completely unwarranted. These include the old pagan sign of witches having "long eyes," the belief that witches cannot cry, and the practice of throwing a witch into water with thumbs and toes tied across. Many more such marks exist, and if these are used to identify a witch, then the user of them is the real witch.
2. There are some signs for identifying witches that are more probable, yet not certain enough to provide conviction. These include strong and long suspicion, suspected ancestors, some appearance of fact, the corpse bleeding upon the witch's touch, the testimony of the bewitched person, the supposed witch's unusual bodily marks, and the witch's usual cursing and immoral lifestyle.
3. Some signs of a witch are more certain and infallible. Firstly, declining judgment or giving faulty, inconsistent, and contradictory answers upon judicial and deliberate examination. Secondly, when upon due inquiry into a person's faith and manners, all or most of the causes that produce witchcraft are found, namely, God forsaking, Satan invading, particular sins disposing, and lastly, a compact completing all. Thirdly, the witch's free confession, together with full evidence of the fact. Confession without fact may be a mere delusion, and fact without confession may be a mere accident. Fourthly, the similar gestures and actions of suspected witches, with comparable expressions of affections, which in all witches have been observed and found very much alike. Fifthly, the testimony of the bewitched person, whether pining or dying, together with the joint oaths of sufficient persons who have seen certain prodigious pranks or feats performed by the accused party.
4. Among the most unfortunate circumstances to convict a witch is maligning and opposing the Word, Work, and Worship of God, and by any extraordinary sign seeking to seduce anyone from it. See Deuteronomy 13:1-2, Matthew 24:24, Acts 13:8-10, 2 Timothy 3:8. Mark these places well, and for this very property of opposing and perverting, they are all concluded to be absolute witches.
5. It is not necessary for such palpable evidence of conviction to be present as in other more sensible matters; it's enough if there is but so much circumstantial proof or evidence as the substance, matter, and nature of such an abstruse mystery of iniquity will well admit. [I suppose he means that whereas in other crimes we look for more direct proofs, in this there is a greater use of consequential ones.] But I could heartily wish that the juries were composed of the most eminent physicians, lawyers, and divines that a country could afford. In the meantime, it’s not to be called a toleration if witches escape where conviction is lacking. To this purpose, our Gaule.
BERNARD OF BATCOMB'S GUIDE: SIGNS OF A WITCH IN LEAGUE WITH THE DEVIL
In his "Guide to Grand Jurymen," the insightful Bernard of Batcomb, after mentioning several things that are strong suspicions of a witch, moves on to things that are the convictions of such a person. He says, "A witch in league with the Devil is convicted by these evidences:
1. By a witch's mark, which is found on the lower sort of witches; and this, by the Devil either sucking or touching them. Tertullian says, 'It is the Devil's custom to mark his.' Note that this mark is insensible, and when pricked, it will not bleed. Sometimes, it's like a teat; sometimes just a bluish spot; sometimes a red one; and sometimes the flesh is sunk: but witches sometimes cover them.
2. By the witch's words. As when they have been heard calling on, speaking to, or talking of their familiars; or when they have been heard telling of harm they have done to man or beast; or when they have been heard threatening such harm; or if they have been heard relating their transportations.
3. By the witch's deeds. As when they have been seen with their spirits, or seen secretly feeding any of their imps. Or, when their pictures, poppets, and other hellish compositions can be found.
4. By the witch's ecstasies: with the delight of which, witches are so taken that they will hardly conceal it; or, however, at some time or other, they may be found in them.
5. By one or more fellow-witches confessing their own witchcraft and bearing witness against others; if they can prove the truth of their witness and give sufficient proof of it. As, that they have seen them with their spirits or that they have received spirits from them; or that they can tell when they used witchery tricks to do harm; or that they told them what harm they had done; or that they can show the mark upon them; or that they have been together in their meetings; and such like.
6. By some witness of God Himself, happening upon the execrable curses of witches upon themselves, praying to God to show some token if they are guilty.
7. By the witch's own confession of giving their souls to the Devil. It is not a rare thing for witches to confess.
They are important things, which I have recited; and yet it must be with open eyes, kept upon open rules, that we are to follow these things.
8. But juries are not the only instruments to be employed in such a work; all Christians should be involved with daily and fervent prayers to support it. In the days of Athanasius, the devils were found unable to stand before that prayer, even though it might have been used with too much ceremony: "Let God arise, let His enemies be scattered: let them also that hate Him flee before Him" (Ps. 68:1).
Oh, that instead of letting our hearts rise against one another, our prayers might rise to a high level of urgency for such a rising of the Lord! Especially, let those who are suffering from witchcraft be sure to stay and pray, and beseech the Lord three times, as much as they can, before they accuse any neighbor of afflicting them. Let those who are accused of witchcraft also set themselves to fast and pray, and shake off the demons that would cling to them like vipers; and make the waters of jealousy beneficial to them.
And now, O Hope of New England, and its Savior in times of trouble, please look mercifully down upon us and rescue us from the trouble that threatens to overwhelm us. Let Satan soon be crushed under our feet, and let the covenanted servants of Satan, who have treacherously brought him upon us, be gloriously conquered by your powerful and gracious presence among us. Do not reject us, O God, but cleanse us, heal us, and save us for the sake of your glory, which is tied to our salvation. By your Spirit, raise a standard against our infernal enemies. Let us soon find you making us glad, according to the days we have been afflicted. Accept all our efforts to glorify you in the trials we face; and among them, let these my humble and weak attempts, composed with tears, cares, and prayers that only you know, not lack the acceptance of the Lord.
CHAPTER 4
THE INVISIBLE WAR: A SERMON ON THE DEVIL'S FINAL ASSAULT
A Discourse on the Wonders of The Invisible World. Uttered (in part) on Aug. 4, 1692
Ecclesiastical history tells us that a renowned martyr at the stake, seeing the Book of Revelation thrown by his equally profane and bloody persecutors to be burned in the same fire with himself, cried out, "O Beata Apocalypsis; quam bene mecum agitur, qui tecum Comburar!" Blessed Revelation! he said, "How blessed am I in this fire, while I have you to bear me company." As for ourselves today, we are in a fire of severe affliction and confusion; but it is a significant advantage to us that we have the company of this glorious and sacred Book of Revelation to assist us in our trials. From that book, there is one text I would like to highlight for you at this time.
"Woe to the inhabitants of the earth and of the sea, for the devil has come down to you, having great wrath, because he knows that he has but a short time." - Rev. 12:12
The text is like the cloudy and fiery pillar given to Israel in the wilderness of old. There is a very dark side to it in the message that "the devil is come down having great wrath," but it also has a bright side when it assures us that "he has but a short time." I invite you today to contemplate both.
We have in our hands a letter from our ascended Lord in Heaven, to inform us that he is still alive and intends to visit us soon, where we shall see our living Redeemer stand on the Earth in the latter days. It's the last message we've received from Heaven for the past sixteen hundred years, and its purpose is to show how the Lord Jesus Christ, having started to establish his Kingdom in the world through the preaching of the Gospel, will continually destroy all powers that oppose it until "the kingdoms of this world are become the kingdoms of our Lord, and of his Christ, and he shall reign for ever and ever" (Rev. 11:15). It's a commentary on what Daniel wrote about the "fourth monarchy," with some insights into the "fifth," where "the greatness of the kingdom under the whole heaven shall be given to the people of the saints of the most High" (Dan. 7:27). And although it has, as one of the ancients expressed, "tot sacramenta quot verba," a mystery in every syllable, it should not be neglected with such despair as to say, "I cannot read, for the book is sealed" (Isa. 29:11). It is a revelation, and a special and notable blessing is pronounced upon those who humbly study it.
The Divine Scriptures have, with remarkable skill and care, drawn an exact timeline from the first Sabbath at the creation of the world to the great Sabbath at the restoration of all things, as the very pious Beverley has thoroughly demonstrated. In that famous timeline, from the decree to restore Jerusalem after the Babylonian captivity, there seem to be about 2,300 years remaining until the New Jerusalem, to which the Church is to be elevated when the mystical Babylon has fallen. At the resurrection of our Lord, there were still seventeen or eighteen hundred of those years left to reach "the rest which remains for the people of God" (Heb. 4:9). This remaining part of the timeline is variously highlighted, adorned, and marked with distinguishing events in our Apocalypse. If we pay attention to them, they will help us avoid the criticism, "Can ye not discern the signs of the times?"
The Apostle John, for the view of these things, had a book laid before him, as I understand it, with leaves or folds. This volume was written both on the backside and on the inside, and rolled up in a cylindrical form, under seven labels, fastened with so many seals. The first seal being opened, and the first label removed, under the first label the Apostle saw what he saw of a first rider portrayed, and so on, until the last seal was broken. Each of the images was enlarged with suitable visions and voices to illustrate it. The book being now unrolled, there were trumpets, with wonderful accompanying events, shown successively on the expanding backside of it. Whereupon the book was eaten, as if to be hidden from interpretations; until later, in the inside of it, the kingdom of Antichrist was exposed. Thus, the judgments of God on the Roman Empire, first leading to the downfall of paganism, and then to the downfall of popery, which is just revived paganism, are in these displays, made clear to us with vivid colors and features.
In the twelfth chapter of this book, we have an important introduction to the description of that terrible kingdom, which our Lord Christ refused, but Antichrist accepted from the devil's hands. This kingdom was to be a continuous oppression on the people of God and opposition to His interests for 1,260 years, until the arrival of that glorious day when "The kingdom shall be the Lord's, and he shall be governor among the nations." The chapter is, as an excellent person calls it, an "extravasated account" of the circumstances that befell the primitive church during the first four or five hundred years of Christianity. It shows us the state of the church, first in heathen Rome and then in converted Rome, before the "man of sin" had yet come to maturity. Our text contains the praises made upon the most glorious revolution that ever happened in the Roman Empire; namely, when the struggling church brought forth a Christian emperor. This was a most significant victory over the devil and a resemblance of the state in which the world will soon see "The kingdom of our God, and the power of his Christ." It is noted here,
First, as a matter of triumph. It's said, "Rejoice, you heavens, and you that dwell in them." The saints in both worlds took comfort in this change. The devout ones who survived the recent persecutions were filled with overwhelming joy when they saw Christianity become the imperial religion and when they saw good people come to govern the rest of humanity. The deceased ones, whose blood had been sacrificed in the ten persecutions, undoubtedly filled the heavenly regions with "Hallelujahs" to God when they received the news of the progress now given to the Christian religion, for which they had suffered martyrdom.
Secondly, as a matter of horror. It's said, "Woe to the inhabitants of the earth and of the sea." The "earth" typically means the "false church," and the "sea" means the "wide world," in prophetic language. There was still a large group of people who were enemies of the true Christian religion, a large group left for the devil to influence. To these, a "woe" is announced; and why is that? It's added, "For the devil is come down unto you, having great wrath, because he knows that he has but a short time" (Rev. 12:12). These people were, it seems, to face some desperate and unique attacks from the devil. In the meantime, we can accept this as our doctrine.
Great woe comes from the great wrath, with which the devil, towards the end of his time, will descend upon a miserable world.
THE NATURE OF THE ENEMY
I have now published a most serious and solemn warning for ourselves today, which includes four propositions.
Proposition 1: That there is a Devil is a thing doubted by none but those under the influences of the Devil. To deny the existence of a Devil must come from ignorance or wickedness worse than diabolical. A Devil—what is that? We have a definition of the creature in Ephesians 6:12: a "spiritual wickedness," that is, a wicked spirit. A Devil is a fallen angel, an angel fallen from the fear and love of God, and from all heavenly glories, but fallen to all kinds of wretchedness and cursedness. He was once in that order of heavenly creatures, which God in the beginning made ministering spirits for His own service and honor, in the management of the universe; but we may now write this epitaph upon him: "How art thou fallen from heaven! Thou hast said in thine heart, I will exalt my throne above the stars of God; but thou art brought down to hell!" A Devil is a spiritual and rational being, by his apostasy from God, inclined to all that is wicked, and for that apostasy confined to the atmosphere of this Earth, "in chains under darkness, unto the judgment of the great day" (Jude 1:6). This is a Devil; and the experience of mankind, as well as the testimony of Scripture, abundantly proves the existence of such a Devil.
About this Devil, there are many things we can reasonably and profitably inquire about; I mean things that are revealed to us in our Bibles. If we speak on such a dark subject without referring to these revelations, but instead rely on our own uncertain and perhaps whimsical guesses, "There is no light in us." I will take you with me to one paragraph of the Bible to learn about three things related to the Devil; it's the story of the Gadarene demoniac in the fifth chapter of Mark (Mark 5).
First, it's to be acknowledged that the devils are so numerous that thousands can sometimes focus on tormenting one person. In Mark 5:15, it is said, "He that was possessed with the devil had the Legion." It's dreadful to say! A Legion consisted of twelve thousand five hundred people, and we see that so many devils can be assigned to one or two people as a garrison. As the prophet cried out, "Multitudes, multitudes, in the valley of decision!" (Joel 3:14), I say, "There are multitudes, multitudes, in the valley of destruction, where the devils are!" When we speak of "the devil," it's a name of multitude; it doesn't mean one individual devil, so powerful and knowledgeable as perhaps a Manichee would imagine, but it means a kind to which a multitude belongs. Alas, the devils swarm around us like the frogs of Egypt, even in the most private of our rooms. Are we at our tables? There will be devils to tempt us into sensuality. Are we in our beds? There will be devils to tempt us into carnality. Are we in our shops? There will be devils to tempt us into dishonesty. Yes, even if we enter the church of God, there will be devils to haunt us in the very temple itself and tempt us to various misbehaviors. I am truly convinced that there are very few human affairs into which some devils do not insinuate themselves; there is not even a journey planned without Satan having a hand in hindering or furthering it.
Secondly, it's to be supposed that there is a kind of arbitrary, even military government among the devils. This is suggested when in Mark 5:9, the unclean spirit said, "My name is Legion." They have a discipline similar to what legions use. Hence, we read about "the prince of the power of the air" (Eph. 2:2). Our air has a power, or an army of devils in the high places of it, and these devils have a prince over them, who is "king over the children of pride" (Job 41:34). It's probable that the devil, who was the ringleader of that mutinous and rebellious crew that first rejected the authority of God, is now the general of those hellish armies. Our Lord, who conquered him, has told us his name; it's Beelzebub. He is the devil, and the rest are his angels or his soldiers. Think of vast regiments of cruel and bloody French dragoons, with an intendant over them, overrunning a pillaged neighborhood, and you will have a small idea of what the organization among the devils is like.
Thirdly, it's to be supposed that some devils are specifically assigned, and perhaps equipped, for certain countries, while others are for different ones. This is suggested in Mark 5:10, where the devils begged our Lord not to send them away out of the country. Why was that? Probably because these devils were more capable of doing the works of the devil in that country than in another. It's unlikely that every devil knows every language or that every devil can do every mischief. It's possible that the experience, or if I may call it so, the education of all devils is not the same, and there may be some differences in their abilities. If one might infer from what the devils do to what they are, one cannot help but imagine that there are degrees of devils. Who can believe that such trivial demons, like those of Mascon, or those that once troubled our Newberry, are as grand as those demons whose games involve mighty kingdoms? Indeed, it's certain that not all devils have the same status in the invisible world. Nor does it seem fitting that the demons who were the familiars of a man like the old Apollonius differ not from those lesser goblins that choose to nest in the filthy and loathsome rags of a beastly sorceress. Accordingly, why may not some devils be more suited for what is to be done in certain places, while others must be assigned to other territories? Each devil, as he sees his advantage, cries out, "Let me be in this country, rather than another."
But enough, if not too much, of these things.
Proposition 2: There is a devilish wrath against mankind, with which the Devil is inspired for God's sake. The Devil himself is suffering under the unbearable and endless wrath of God; and a fiery wrath at God is what inflames the Devil for that reason. I imagine the Devils in Isaiah 8:21, "They fret themselves, and curse their God, and look upward." The first and main wrath of the Devil is directed at Almighty God himself; he knows, "The God that made him, will not have mercy on him, and the God that formed him, will show him no favor;" and so he can have no kindness for that God, who has no mercy or favor for him. This is why he cannot stand the name of God being acknowledged in the world: every acknowledgment paid to God is like a fresh drop of burning brimstone falling upon the Devil; he makes his insolent, though impotent, attacks even upon the throne of God himself and foolishly desires to be exalted to that glorious high throne by all people, as he sometimes is by execrable witches. This horrible dragon not only strikes at the stars of God with his tail but also at God himself, who made the stars, wanting to outshine them all. God and the Devil are sworn enemies to each other; the terms between them are those in Zechariah 11:8, "My soul loathed them, and their soul also abhorred me." From this furious wrath, or displeasure and prejudice at God, comes the Devil's wrath at us, the poor children of men. Our doing the service of God is one thing that exposes us to the wrath of the Devil. We are the high priests of the world; when all creatures are called upon, "Praise ye the Lord," they bring to us those demanded praises of God, saying, "do you offer them for us." This is why the Devil has a quarrel with us, as he had with the high priest in the vision of old. Our bearing the image of God is another thing that brings the wrath of the Devil upon us. Like a tiger, through his hatred of man, will tear the very picture of him if it comes in his way; such a tiger the Devil is; because God said of old, "Let us make man in our image," the Devil is always saying, "Let us pull this man to pieces." But the envious pride of the Devil is one more thing that sharpens his furious wrath against us. The Apostle has hinted that pride was the condemnation of the Devil. It's not unlikely that the Devil's desire to be above the condition he might learn that mankind was to be preferred to might have been the reason for his rebellion against the immortal King. However, the Devil now sees man lying in the bosom of God, but himself damned in the bottom of Hell; and this enrages him exceedingly; "Oh," he says, "I cannot bear it, that man should not be as miserable as myself."
Proposition 3: The Devil, in carrying out his wrath upon people, often gets permission to attack humans. When the Devil harms us, he "comes down" to us; for the gathering place of the infernal forces is in the higher parts of our air. But as it's said, "A sparrow of the air does not fall down without the will of God," so I may say, "Not a Devil in the air can come down without God's permission." We have a famous example in the Arabian Prince, whom the Devil could not touch until God allowed him to "go down." The Devil stands ready with all the instruments of death, aiming at us, and asking the Lord, like the King asked about the blindfolded Syrians of old, "Shall I smite them, shall I smite them?" He cannot strike until the Lord says, "Go down and smite," but sometimes he gets permission from the high possessor of Heaven and Earth to do it. The Devil sometimes causes great havoc among us, but we can still say to him, as our Lord said to a great servant of his, "You could have no power against me, except it were given you from above." The Devil is called in 1 Peter 5:8, "Your Adversary." This is a legal term, meaning "An Adversary at Law." The Devil cannot come at us except in some sense according to law; but sometimes he causes sad things to happen according to the law of the eternal King upon us. The Devil first "goes up" as an accuser against us. He is therefore called "The Accuser," and it is for this reason that his proper name belongs to him. There is a court somewhere, a court of spirits, where the Devil files all sorts of complaints against us; he charges us with many sins against the Lord our God: there he burdens us with heavy accusations of hypocrisy, iniquity, disobedience; whereupon he urges, "Lord, let them now have the death, which is their wages, paid to them!" If our advocate in the heavens does not now dismiss his charges, the Devil, with God's permission, "comes down" as a destroyer upon us. Having first been an attorney to request that the judgments of Heaven may be ordered for us, he then also pleads to be the executioner of those judgments; and the God of Heaven sometimes, in a way, signs a warrant for this destroying angel to do what has been requested for the destruction of men. But such permission from God for the Devil to "come down" and attack mankind often must be accompanied by a commission from some wicked people themselves. Every person is, as hinted in Gen. 4:9, "His brother's keeper." We are to keep one another from the Devil's attacks by wishing prosperity for each other. When ungodly people give their consent in witchcrafts, diabolically performed, for the Devil to harm their neighbors, he finds a breach in the hedge around us, through which he rushes in with severe troubles. Yes, when impious people, who have never seen the Devil, utter curses against their neighbors, those are like watchwords, prompting the hounds of Hell to attack us. This is how the Devil gets permission to trouble us.
Proposition 4: Most horrible woes come to be inflicted upon mankind when the Devil, in great wrath, makes a descent upon them. The Devil is a doer of evil and is completely focused on causing harm. When our Lord once was going to restrain him, so he couldn't harm others, he cried out, "Art thou come to torment me?" It seems he is tormented himself if he is merely restrained from tormenting humans. If upon the sounding of the three last apocalyptic angels, there was an outcry made in heaven, "Wo, wo, wo, to the inhabitants of the Earth by reason of the voice of the Trumpet," (Rev. 8:13) I am sure a descent made by the angel of death would give cause for a similar exclamation: "Wo to the world, by reason of the wrath of the Devil!" What a woeful state mankind would be brought into by the descent of the Devil can be gathered from the woeful pains, wounds, and hideous desolations that the Devil brings upon those with whom he has made a bodily possession. You can read many direful accounts in both sacred and secular history of the woes that those possessed by the Devil undergo. From there, you can conclude, "What must the children of men hope from such a Devil!" Moreover, the tyrannical ceremonies to which the Devil subjects such woeful nations or groups of people that are more entirely under his control declare what woeful work the Devil would make where he comes. The very devotions of those forlorn pagans, to whom the Devil is a leader, are most bloody penances. What woes indeed must we expect from such a Devil of a Moloch, who relishes no sacrifices like those of human heart-blood, and for whom there is no music like the bitter, dying, doleful groans, ejaculated by the roasting children of men.
Furthermore, the miserable, lowly, and needy conditions in which the Devil keeps his slaves, those under his more obvious control, show us how miserable the Devil would make all our lives. We live in a region that provides everything necessary or comfortable for us, but it was once filled with large groups of natives who never saw even a knife, a nail, a board, or a grain of salt in their entire lives. The Devil would have the world similarly deprived. We, or anyone else, would not have a single convenient thing around us and would be as poor as our most ragged witches usually are, if the Devil's malice were not controlled by a compassionate God, who "preserves man and beast" (Ps. 36:6). Because of this, the Devil, like a dragon guarding treasures that would refresh a weary world, has prevented humanity for many ages from discovering useful inventions that were so obvious and easy that everyone wonders why they weren't discovered sooner. The confused world had to continue for thousands of years without knowing about the lodestone until a Neapolitan discovered it about three hundred years ago. The world couldn't be blessed with the matchless engine of learning and virtue, printing, until about the middle of the fifteenth century. And no old man anywhere on Earth could benefit from something as small yet necessary as a pair of spectacles until a Dutchman provided them a little while ago.
Indeed, as the Devil begrudges us all kinds of good, he also troubles us with all kinds of woes whenever he can. Let's mention some of the specific woes with which the Devil usually infests the world. Briefly, plagues are some of those woes with which the Devil troubles us. It is said of the Israelites in 1 Corinthians 10:10, "They were destroyed by the destroyer." This means they had the plague among them. The "Destroyer," or the Devil, spreads plagues around the world. Pestilential and contagious diseases are often brought upon us by the Devil. It's not difficult for the Devil to fill the air around us with harmful substances that, when they meet with our body's natural elements, cause a reaction that can destroy our vital connections, much like a strong acid corrodes what it touches. When the Devil releases these poisonous fumes, which become deadly arrows, he can easily inject these harmful miasms into the bodies of people, inflaming them with a deadly fever. This is how plagues occur, like the one that swept away many people from an English city in one outbreak. Infectious fevers are just disguised plagues among us, causing widespread devastation. Again, wars are also some of those woes with which the Devil causes our trouble. It is said in Revelation 12:17, "The dragon was enraged and went to make war." In truth, there is hardly any war that isn't started by the Dragon. The Devil is like Vulcan, from whose forge come the instruments of our wars, and he finds us uses for those instruments. We read about demoniacs, or people possessed by the Devil, that they would harm themselves; similarly, when the Devil is in people, he drives them to treat each other barbarically. Wars often provide him with thousands of souls in one morning from one piece of land, and for such feasts, he will incite as many wars as he can.
Once more, why can't storms be considered among the troubles with which the Devil disturbs us? It's not unlikely that natural storms in the world are often caused by the Devil. We are told in Job 1:11-12, 19 that the Devil created a storm that destroyed Job's house, killing those who were feasting inside. Paracelsus could have informed the Devil, if he hadn't already known, that if much aluminous matter is mixed with unprepared saltpeter, it will send up a cloud of smoke that will come down as rain. But undoubtedly, the Devil knows as well how to create a tempest as to change the winds at the request of a Laplander. This might be why thunders are often observed to strike churches more than any other buildings. Moreover, many a man, ship, or town has been lost when the Devil has been allowed from above to create a horrible tempest. However, that the Devil has raised many metaphorical storms upon the Church is something more notorious than anything else. It was said to believers in Revelation 2:10, "The Devil shall cast some of you into prison." The Devil was the one who first set Cain upon Abel to murder him, as the Apostle seems to suggest, for his faith in God as a rewarder. And in how many persecutions, as well as heresies, has the Devil been engaging all the children of Cain ever since! That serpent, the Devil, has driven his cursed seed in tireless efforts to have those "of whom the world is not worthy" treated as those who are "not worthy to live in the world." By the Devil's impulse, first the old heathens, then the mad Arians, became thorns to the true servants of God. The Papists that came after them have outdone them all in slaughtering those who have been "accounted as the sheep for the slaughter." The recent French persecution is perhaps the most horrible that ever was in the world. And as the Devil of Mascon seems to have previously hinted in his cries about "the miseries preparing for the poor Huguenots!" Thus, it has all been acted out by a singular fury of the old dragon inspiring his emissaries.
But in reality, spiritual woes are the main woes among all those that the Devil would use to destroy us. Sins are the worst of woes, and the Devil seeks nothing more than to plunge us into sins. When people commit a crime for which they are to be indicted, they are usually moved by the instigation of the Devil. The Devil will push bad people to become worse. Wasn't it he who said in (1 Kings 22:22), "I will go forth, and be a lying spirit in the mouth of all the prophets?" In the same way, the Devil becomes an unclean spirit, a drinking spirit, a swearing spirit, a worldly spirit, a passionate spirit, a revengeful spirit, and the like in the hearts of those who are already too much of such a spirit; and thus they become improved in sinfulness. Yes, the Devil will push good people to do wrong. Thus we read in (1 Chronicles 21:1), "Satan provoked David to number Israel." And so the Devil provokes people who are eminent in holiness to do things that may become eminently pernicious; he provokes them especially to pride and to many unsuitable emulations. There are also most lamentable impressions that the Devil makes upon the souls of people as a punishment for their sins. It is thus when an offended God puts the souls of people into the hands of that officer who has the power of death, that is, the Devil. It is the woeful misery of unbelievers in (2 Corinthians 4:4), "The god of this world has blinded their minds." And thus it may be said of those woeful wretches whom the Devil is a god to, the Devil so blinds them that they cannot see the things of their peace. And the Devil so hardens them that nothing will awaken their cares about their souls. How do so many become seared in their sins? It is the Devil who, with a red-hot iron fetched from his hell, does cauterize them. Thus it is, until perhaps at last they come to have a wounded conscience in them, and the Devil often has a share in their torturing and confounding anguishes. The Devil who terrified Cain, Saul, and Judas into desperation still becomes a king of terrors to many sinners and frightens them from laying hold on the mercy of God in the Lord Jesus Christ. In these regards, woe to us when the Devil comes down upon us.
Proposition 5: Toward the end of his time, the descent of the Devil in wrath upon the world will produce more woeful effects than what have been in former ages. The dying dragon will bite more cruelly and sting more bloodily than ever before. The death-pangs of the Devil will make him more of a devil than ever he was, and the furnace of this Nebuchadnezzar will be heated seven times hotter, just before it goes out.
First, we need to understand that God has set a specific time for the Devil to have control over our sinful and therefore miserable world. The Devil once cried out in Matthew 8:29, "Jesus, thou Son of God, art thou come hither to torment us before our time?" It's clear that until the second coming of our Lord, the Devil will have a period to trouble the world, which he feared would have ended at Jesus' first coming. The Devil is, by God's wrath, the prince of this world, and his reign will continue until the time when our Lord himself will take his great power and reign. At that time, the Devil will hear the Son of God declaring with loud thunders against him, "Thy time shall now be no more!" Then the Devil and his angels will receive their judgment, which will be, "Depart into the everlasting fire prepared for you."
We should understand that, in the meantime, the Devil can make a pretty good guess when he is nearing the end of his time. When he saw Christianity taking hold among the Romans, it is mentioned in Revelation 12:12, "He knows he hath but a short time." And how does he know it? Well, reason will make the Devil understand that God won't allow him to have everlasting dominion, and that once God starts rescuing the world from his grasp, He will continue until "the captives of the mighty shall be taken away and the prey of the terrible shall be delivered." But the Devil will also have Scripture to make him aware that when his Antichristian representative, the seven-headed beast on the seven-hilled city, has completed his appointed years, he and his representative must inevitably go down into the bottomless pit. It's not unlikely that the Devil often hears Scripture being explained in our congregations; indeed, we never gather without a Satan among us. Some theologians even speculate, with some uncertainty, based on a passage in the Epistle to the Ephesians, that angels sometimes come into our churches to gain some benefit from our ministry. But certainly, our clear interpretations can repeatedly remind the Devil, "That his time is almost out;" and just as the preacher says to the young man, "Know thou, that God will bring thee into judgment!" so too can our sermons tell the old wretch, "Know thou, that thy judgment is at hand."
In these times, we must understand that the troubles of the world will become greater than ever before. The Apostle warns us in 2 Timothy 3:1, "This know also, that in the last days perilous times shall come." When the Devil realizes he is in his final days, he will create perilous times for us. The world will be filled with more devils and therefore more dangers than ever before. If we want to know the reason for this, it's not only because the Devil becomes more capable and eager to torment the world, but also because the world is more deserving of such torment than ever before. The sins of people in this generation will be greater than those of previous ages; people will become more skilled and refined in the art of sinning. Moreover, the sins of all previous ages will also weigh upon the sinners of this generation. Why do the powers of darkness prevail more in our days than in the past? It's because by repeating the sins of former days, people share in all those unfruitful works of darkness. As stated in Matthew 23:36, "Verily I say unto you, All these things shall come upon this generation," so the people of the last generation will find themselves caught in the consequences of all that came before them. It is said of sinners, "They heap up wrath," and the sinners of the last generations not only add to the pile of sin that has been accumulating since the Fall of man, but they also involve themselves in every sin of that enormous heap. There has been a cry from all former ages going up to God, "That the Devil may come down!" and the sinners of the last generations intensify that cry until it comes to pass, as destructively as it is irreparable. As a result, the Thrice Holy God, with His Holy Angels, will now, in a way, abandon the world more than in previous ages. The roaring impieties of the old world eventually caused such a distaste in the heart of the Just God that He said, "It repents me that I have made them." Although it may be just a clever idea from a recent learned writer that the Earth before the Flood was closer to the Sun than it is today, and that God's moving the Earth further from the Sun caused the Flood, we can say that people perished by a rejection from the God of Heaven. Thus, the increased impieties of our world will provoke God's displeasure to such an extent that He will cast us off more than before, until finally, with more than ordinary indignation, He says, "Go Devils; do you take them, and make them beyond all former measures miserable!"
If, lastly, we are curious about examples of the severe woes with which the Devil will attack us towards the end of his time, remember that all the extreme events foretold by the Trumpets and Vials in the apocalyptic visions of these things, meant to come upon the world, were the woes to come from the wrath of the Devil, upon the shortening of his time. The terrible devastations that have come upon humanity by the invasions of the old Barbarians upon the Roman world, and then of the Saracens, and later, of the Turks, were such woes as people had never seen before. The unspeakable blindness and vileness that then came upon humanity, and the monstrous Crusades that consequently led the Roman world by millions to slaughter, were also such woes as had never yet had a parallel. And yet these were some of the things intended here, when it was said, "Woe! For the Devil is come down in great wrath, having but a short time."
But besides all these things, and besides the increase of plagues, wars, storms, and internal maladies in our days, there are especially two most extraordinary woes that one would fear will become very common. One woe that may be expected is a frequent repetition of earthquakes, perhaps caused by the devil's energy in the earth. The devil will be confined as a prisoner in or near the bowels of the earth when the conflagration is completed, which will create "the new earth wherein dwelleth righteousness" (2 Pet. 3:13); and that conflagration will likely be much promoted by the subterranean fires, which are a cause of the earthquakes in our days. Accordingly, we read of "great earthquakes in divers places" (Matt. 24:7), listed among the signs of the time approaching when the devil shall have no longer time. I suspect that we will now experience more frequent and more fatal earthquakes than our ancestors did, as the fires that are shortly to "burn unto the lowest hell, and set on fire the foundations of the mountains" (Deut. 32:22), will now gain more strength than they used to; and it is not impossible that the devil, who is soon to be punished in those fires, may beforehand increase his desert of it by having a hand in using some of those fires for our detriment. Learned men have made no hesitation to blame the devil for it; "Deo permittente, Terræ motus causat." The devil surely was involved in the earthquake whereby the vengeance of God, in one black night, sunk twelve significant cities of Asia in the reign of Tiberius. But there will be more such catastrophes in our days; Italy has lately been shaking until its earthquakes have brought ruins upon more than thirty towns at once; but it will soon shake again and shake until the fire of God has made an entire Etna of it. And behold, this very morning, when I was intending to speak to you about such things, we are cast into a heartquake by news of an earthquake that has recently happened in Jamaica: a horrible earthquake, whereby the Tyrus of English America was at once pulled into the jaws of the gaping and groaning earth, and many hundreds of the inhabitants buried alive. The Lord sanctify so dismal a dispensation of his providence unto all the American plantations! But be assured, my neighbors, the earthquakes are not over yet! We have not yet seen the last. And then, another woe that may be expected is the devil being now let loose in preternatural operations more than before; and perhaps in possessions and obsessions that shall be very marvelous. You are not ignorant that just before our Lord's first coming, there were most observable outrages committed by the devil upon the children of men: and I am suspicious that there will again be an unusual range of the devil among us, a little before the second coming of our Lord, which will be to give the last stroke in destroying the works of the devil. The evening wolves will be much abroad when we are near the evening of the world. The devil is going to be dislodged from the air, where his present quarters are; God will, with flashes of hot lightning upon him, cause him to "fall as lightning" (Luke 10:18) from his ancient habitations: and the raised saints will there have a new heaven, which we expect according to the promise of God. Now a little before this thing, you are likely to see the devil more sensibly and visibly busy upon earth perhaps than ever he was before. You shall more often hear about apparitions of the devil, and about poor people strangely bewitched, possessed, and obsessed by infernal fiends. When our Lord is going to set up His kingdom in the most sensible and visible manner that ever was, and in a manner answering the transfiguration in the mount, it is very likely that the devil will in various parts of the world attempt the same for himself, with a most apish imitation: and men, at least in some corners of the world, and perhaps in such as God may have some special designs upon, will to their cost be more familiarized with the world of spirits than they had been formerly.
So, in conclusion, if just before the end, when the times of the Jews were to be finished, a man went around everywhere, crying, "Woe to the nation! Woe to the city! Woe to the temple! Woe! Woe! Woe!" then much more should the descent of the Devil, just before his end, when the times of the Gentiles will also be finished, cause us to cry out, "Woe! Woe! Woe! because of the dark things that threaten us!"
But it is now time to make use of what has been said. First, we shall consider a few conclusions drawn from what has been asserted.
CONCLUSION 1: THANKSGIVING FOR OUR PRESERVATION
What reason do we have to thank God for protecting us from the Devil's wrath in what can reasonably be called the Devil's World! While we are in this present evil world, we are constantly surrounded by swarms of those devils who make this world so evil. What a wonder of mercy it is that no devil has ever been able to capture us! We can't step anywhere without being in the midst of hellish rattlesnakes; and one of those rattlesnakes once, through the mouth of a man it had seized, hissed out a truth like this: "If God would let me loose upon you, I would find enough in the best of you all to make you all mine." What can I say? The wilderness we are passing through to the Promised Land is filled with fiery flying serpents. But, blessed be God, none of them have fastened upon us to destroy us completely! Our path to Heaven lies by the dens of lions and the mounts of leopards; there are incredible droves of devils in our way. But have we safely made it this far? Oh, let us be thankful to our eternal preserver for it. It is said in Psalm 76:10, "Surely the wrath of man shall praise thee, and the remainder of wrath shalt thou restrain." But surely it is right for us to praise God that we have not suffered more damage from the wrath of the Devil and that He has restrained that overwhelming wrath. We are poor travelers in a world that is both the Devil's field and the Devil's jail; a world where the Devil is camped in every corner with bands of robbers to trouble all who are looking toward Zion. And are we still preserved from the Devil's traps? It is, "Thou, O keeper of Israel, that hast hitherto been our keeper!" And therefore, "Bless the Lord, O my soul, bless his holy name, who has redeemed thy life from the destroyer!"
We can see the rise of those multiplied, magnified, and uniquely painful afflictions that often come to aged or dying saints, making their death difficult and their old age bitter. When the saints of God are about to leave the world, it usually becomes a more stormy world for them than ever before; they find more vanity and vexation in the world than they ever did before. It is true, "many are the afflictions of the righteous" (Ps. 34:19); but just before they say goodbye to all those many afflictions, they often face greater, harder, and more severe burdens than they have yet endured. It is true, "through much tribulation we must enter the kingdom of God" (Acts 14:22); but just before our entrance into it, our tribulation may have sharper sorrows than ever before. And what is the cause of this? It is indeed the faithfulness of our God to us, that we should find the earth more full of thorns and briars than ever, just before He takes us from earth to heaven; so that we may leave more willingly, more easily, and with less struggle when He calls for us. Oh, there are ugly ties that bind us to this world; but God will tear those ties apart with thorns and briars. But, is not the hand of Joab here? Surely, there is the wrath of the devil in it as well. Just before we step into heaven, the devil thinks to himself, "My time to abuse that saint is now but short; whatever mischief I am to do to that saint must be done quickly, if at all; they will shortly be out of my reach forever." And for this reason, he will now attack us with the fiercest efforts and furies of his wrath. It was allowed to the serpent, in Genesis 3:15, "to bruise the heel." Why, at the heel, or at the close, of our lives, the serpent will be biting more than ever before in our lives: and it is because now he has but a short time. He knows that we shall very shortly be "where the wicked cease from troubling, and where the weary are at rest" (Job 3:17); therefore, that wicked one will now trouble us more than ever, and we shall have so much unrest that will make us more weary than ever of things here below.
CONCLUSION 2: A LESSON FROM THE DEVIL'S URGENCY
Isn't it reasonable that those whose time is short should make the most of it? Let's learn something good even from the wicked one himself. It has been advised, "Be wise as serpents" (Matt. 10:16); there's a piece of wisdom where even the old serpent, the Devil himself, can be our guide. When the Devil realizes his time is short, it makes him very angry. But how should it be with us when we realize our time is short? It should motivate us to work hard. The reason that makes the Devil full of wrath should make us full of warmth, watchfulness, and diligence to make our calling and election sure. Our pace on our journey to Heaven must be quickened if our time for that journey is shortened, just as Israel traveled further in the last two years of their journey to Canaan than they did in the 38 years before. The Apostle uses this as a motivation for the devotions of Christians in 1 Corinthians 7:29, "This I say, brethren, the time is short." So, I say this: some things I lay before you, which I only think or guess, but here is something I say with all the freedom imaginable. You have now a time to get good, a time to make sure of grace and glory, and every good thing, by true repentance: But, "This I say, the time is but short." You have now time to do good, to serve your generation, as by the will, so for the praise of God; but, "This I say, the time is but short." And what I say to all people, I say to old people with a special urgency: Sirs, it cannot be long before your time is out; there are only a few sands left in the hourglass of your time: And it is the saddest thing for a man to say, "My time is done, but my work undone!" O then, work as fast as you can; and of soul-work and church-work, accomplish as much as you can. Say to all hindrances, as the gracious Jeremiah Burrows would sometimes to visitors: "You'll excuse me if I ask you to be short with me, for my work is great, and my time is but short." Every time we hear a clock or see a watch, we have a reminder that our time is flying, and it will all be gone soon. I remember reading about a famous man who had a clock-watch long lying unused in his trunk, and it unaccountably struck eleven just before he died. Many of you, I am to do that office today: I am to tell you, "You are come to your eleventh hour;" there is no more than a twelfth part at most of your life left. But if we neglect our business until our short time is reduced to none, then woe to us, for the great wrath of God will send us down from where there is no redemption.
CONCLUSION 3: THE WELCOME RELEASE OF A GODLY DEATH
How welcome should a "Death in the Lord" be to those who belong not to the Devil, but to the Lord! While we are living in this world, we are in what could be called "The Devil's Country" for many reasons: we are where the Devil may come upon us with "great wrath" continually. The day when God takes us out of this world will be "the day when the Lord will deliver us from the hand of all our enemies, and from the hand of Satan." On such a day, why shouldn't our song be that of the Psalmist, "Blessed be my Rock, and let the God of my Salvation be exalted!" While we are here, we are in "the valley of the shadow of death"; and what makes it so? It's because the "wild Beasts of Hell" are lurking on every side of us, ready to attack us at any moment. But our "Death" will take us out of that "Valley," and carry us where we shall be "forever with the Lord." We are now under the daily "Buffetings" of the Devil, and he troubles us with such "Fiery Darts," that we even cry out, "I am weary of my Life." Yes, but are we as "willing to die" as we are "weary of Life"? Our Death will soon place us where we cannot be reached by the "Fist of Wickedness"; and where the "Perfect cannot be shot at." It is said in (Rev. 14:13), "Blessed are the Dead which die in the Lord, they rest from their labors." But we may say, "Blessed are the Dead in the Lord, inasmuch as they rest from the Devils!" Our "dying" will be just our "taking wing": When attended by a convoy of winged Angels, we shall be carried into that Heaven, from which the Devil, having been thrown out, shall never come after us. What if God should now say to us, as to Moses, "Go up and die!" As long as we "go up" when we "die," let us receive the message with a joyful soul; we shall soon be there, where the Devil can't "come down" upon us. If the "God of our Life" should now send that order to us, which he gave to Hezekiah, "Set your house in order, for you shall die, and not live" (2 Kings 20:1); we need not be thrown into such deadly agonies as Hezekiah was: We are just going to that "House," the Golden Doors of which cannot be entered by the Devil who used to persecute us here. I imagine I see the departed "Spirit" of a believer, triumphantly carried through the Devil's "Territories," in such a stately and Fiery Chariot as the "Spiritualizing Body of Elijah" had; I imagine I see the Devil, with whole flocks of "Harpies," grinning at this Child of God, but unable to grip him with their talons: And then, on the edge of our "Atmosphere," I imagine I overhear the holy soul, with a heavenly courage, mocking the defeated Fiend, and saying, "Ah! Satan! Return to your dungeons again; I am going where you can never come!" Oh, it's a brave thing to die like that! and especially to die like that, "in our time." For, though when we remember, "That the Devil's time is now but short," it may almost make us wish to "live" until the "end" of it; and to say with the Psalmist, "Because the Lord will shortly appear in his Glory, to build up Zion. O my God! Take me not away in the midst of my days" (Ps. 102:16, 24). Yet when we remember, "that the Devil's Wrath is now most great," it would make one willing to be "out of the way." Since now is the time for the doing of those things in the prospect of which Balaam long ago cried out, "Who shall live when such things are done!" (Num. 24:23) We should not be overly reluctant to "die" at such a time. In short, the "Times" are so "bad," that we may well consider it as "good" a "time" to die in as we have ever seen.
CONCLUSION 4: GOOD NEWS FOR NEW ENGLAND
Good news for the Israel of God, and especially for His New-English Israel. If the Devil's time was declared short over a thousand years ago, what should we think of it now in our time? Surely, we are not a thousand years away from those happy thousand years of rest, peace, and, even better, holiness reserved for God's people in the latter days. If we are not a thousand years short of that Golden Age, there is reason to believe we are not even a hundred years away. It is clear that the blessed thousand years have not yet begun because we do not see the Devil bound. No, the Devil has never been more unleashed than in our days, and it's surprising that anyone would think otherwise. But the same evidence that shows the thousand years of prosperity for the Church of God under the whole Heaven have not yet begun also shows that it is not very far off. This is the extraordinary wrath with which the Devil persecutes and even devastates the world in our days. Let us look almost anywhere, and we will see the Devil dominating at a rate that can justly astonish us. It is questionable whether iniquity has ever been so rampant or calamity so severe as in this lamentable time. We may truly say, "It's the hour and the power of darkness." But, although the wrath is so great, the time is short. When we are troubled by the Devil's wrath, God's word to us at the same time is in Romans 16:20: "The God of peace shall bruise Satan under your feet shortly." Shortly, did you say, dearest Lord! O joyful word! Amen, even so, come Lord! Lord Jesus, come quickly! We will never be rid of this troublesome Devil until you come to chain him up!
But because the people of God would willingly be informed about where we stand concerning the wrath and the time of the devil, please allow me to humbly present a few conjectures to you.
Conjecture 1
The Devil's "eldest son" seems to be nearing the end of his last "half-time," and if that's the case, the Devil's "whole time" must be very close to its end. It's quite embarrassing that any Protestant would be confused about where to find the Antichrist. However, we have enough assurance that the duration of the Antichrist is to be for a "time," "times," and "half a time," which means twelve hundred and sixty years. Indeed, those twelve hundred and sixty years were the exact period left for the Devil, as mentioned when it says, "he has but a short time." Now, I would have an easy time if I never had a harder task than to present evidence making it extremely probable that Antichrist entered his last "half-time," or the last one hundred and eighty years of his reign, at or soon after the celebrated Reformation that began in 1517 in the previous century. It's quite fitting to see how Antichrist then lost half of his empire and how that half, which became reformed, has in many ways been only half-reformed. But with this calculation, we must be very close to a significant downfall for the See of Rome, so that Antichrist, who has recently been establishing what proves to be no more lasting than a "tabernacle in the glorious holy mountain between the seas," must soon "come to his end, and none shall help him" (Dan. 11:45). So then, in a very short time, we shall see the Devil stripped of the grand, indeed the last, vehicle in which he can abuse our world. The fires with which "that beast" is to be consumed will singe the Devil's wings too, so he can no longer set the affairs of this world on fire. Yes, they shall both go into the same fire, to be "tormented forever and ever" (Rev. 20:10).
Conjecture 2
That which is, perhaps, the greatest effect of the Devil's wrath seems to be almost at an end, and this gives hope that the Devil's time cannot be far from its end. It is in persecution that the Devil's wrath usually breaks out with its greatest fury. Now, there are signs that the last persecution intended for the Church of God, before the coming of our Lord, has happened. When we see the second woe passing away, it signals to us that the last slaughter of our Lord's witnesses is over; and then what follows quickly? The next thing is, "The kingdoms of this world are become the kingdoms of our Lord, and of His Christ," and then down goes the kingdom of the Devil, so that he can no longer come down upon us. Now, the irreversible and irretrievable humiliations that have recently befallen the Turkish power are declarations of the second woe passing away. The dealings of God with the European parts of the world today further strengthen this expectation. We see, at this hour, a great earthquake all over Europe, and we shall see that this great earthquake and these great commotions will contribute to the advancement of our Lord's previously depressed interests. It is also noteworthy that a tendency to recognize the empire of God over the conscience of man now prevails more in the world than before; and God from on high more touches the hearts of princes and rulers with an aversion to persecution. It is particularly the unspeakable happiness of the English nation to be under the influence of that excellent Queen, who could say, "Inasmuch as a man cannot make himself believe what he will, why should we persecute men for not believing as we do? I wish I could see all good men of one mind; but in the meantime, I pray, let them however love one another." Words worthy to be written in letters of gold! And by us, the more to be considered, because to one of ours did that royal person express herself so excellently, so obligingly. When the late King James published his declaration for liberty of conscience, a worthy divine in the Church of England, then studying the Revelation, saw cause upon revelational grounds to declare himself in such words as these, "Whatsoever others may intend or design by this liberty of conscience, I cannot believe that it will ever be recalled in England, as long as the world stands." And you know how miraculously the earthquake which then immediately came upon the kingdom has established that liberty! But what exceeds all the tendencies this way is the dispensation of God today towards the blessed Vaudois. Those renowned Waldenses, who were a sort of root to all Protestant churches, were never dissipated by all the persecutions of many ages until within these few years, when the French King and the Duke of Savoy joined forces for their dissipation. But just three years and a half after the scattering of that holy people, to the surprise of all the world, a spirit of life from God has come into them; and having with a thousand miracles repossessed themselves of their ancient seats, their hot persecutor has become their great protector. Whereupon the reflection of the worthy person who writes the story is, "The churches of Piemont, being the root of the Protestant churches, they have been the first established; the churches of other places, being but the branches, shall be established in due time. God will deliver them speedily; He has already delivered the mother, and He will not long leave the daughter behind: He will finish what He has gloriously begun!"
Conjecture 3
There is little room for hope that the great wrath of the Devil will not lead to the complete ruin of our poor New England in particular. I believe there has never been a poor settlement more pursued by the wrath of the Devil than our poor New England. What makes our condition even more deplorable is that the wrath of the great God Himself is also pressing hard upon us at the same time. It was a significant alarm to the Devil when a large group of English Protestants and Puritans came to establish Evangelical Churches in a part of the world where he had reigned without any control for many ages. It is a vexing sight to the Devil that our Lord Christ should be known, acknowledged, and preached in this howling wilderness. Therefore, he has left no stone unturned in his efforts to undermine this settlement and force us out of our country.
First, the Indian shamans used all their magic to trouble the first settlers here, but God said to them, "Touch them not!" Then, deceiving spirits came to take root in this vineyard, but God drove them away, so they haven't succeeded much beyond the edges of our land. After this, we've had a constant blight on some of our main crops, annually reducing a large part of our usual food supply. Along with this, wasting sicknesses, especially burning and deadly fevers, have sent the arrows of death into our homes. Next, we've had many adversaries who speak our language, continually trying to take away the English liberties that these territories were settled to encourage. As if this wasn't enough, the native people among whom we settled have watered our soil with the blood of many hundreds of our inhabitants. Destructive fires have also many times turned the main treasures of the whole province into ashes. As for losses by sea, they have been multiplied upon us: and particularly in the present French War, the whole English nation has observed that no part of the nation has had as many vessels taken as our poor New England. Besides all this, now at last the devils are, if I may say so, personally come down upon us with such wrath, which is justly much, and will quickly be more, the astonishment of the world. Alas, I may sigh over this wilderness, as Moses did over his, in Psalm 90:7, 9, "For we are consumed by thine anger, and by thy wrath are we troubled. For all our days are passed away in thy wrath: we spend our years as a tale that is told." And I may add this to it, "The wrath of the devil too has been troubling and spending us, all our days."
But what will happen to this poor New England in the end? Will we sink, expire, or perish before the devil's "short time" is finished? I must admit that when I think about the lamentable unfruitfulness of people among us, even under the most powerful and clear teachings of the Gospel in the world, and when I consider the declining state of the power of godliness in our churches, along with the most horrible unwillingness to recover from this decline, I can't help but fear that this might be our fate, and that an Asiatic removal of candlesticks might come upon us. However, for some other reasons, I would like to hope otherwise; and I will give you the chance to see what conclusions can be drawn from these probable predictions.
I say, first, that surely America's fate must eventually include New England's in it. What was God's purpose in bringing over so many Europeans here in recent years? What role or state will America have when the Kingdom of God comes? If it must all belong to the Devil, while the saved nations of the other hemisphere will be walking in the light of the New Jerusalem, then our New England has likely accomplished all it was established for. But if God intends to make this a place for any of those glorious things spoken of you, O City of God, then even you, O New England, are very close to better days than you have ever seen.
I say, secondly, that even though there are very threatening signs in America, there are also some hopeful ones. I admit, when one considers the terrible acts with which most of the Europeans who settled this New World became its rulers, it seems ominous. When one also considers how much the way of living in many parts of America is utterly inconsistent with the very essentials of Christianity; yes, how much harm and violence is done to humanity itself; it is enough to dampen the hopes of even the most optimistic person. And the frown of Heaven, which has so far been upon attempts to better spread the Gospel in the colonies, when considered, will only increase the discouragement. Nevertheless, on the other hand, what can be said of all the promises, that "our Lord Jesus Christ shall have the uttermost parts of the Earth for his possession" (Ps. 2:8)? And of all the prophecies, that "all the ends of the Earth shall remember and turn unto the Lord" (Ps. 22:27)? Or does it seem fitting that such a rich part of the world, equal in some regards to all the rest, should never be out of the Devil's hands, from its first inhabitation to its final dissolution? No, surely not; why can't the last be the first? And the Sun of Righteousness come to shine brightest in climates where it rose latest upon!
I say, thirdly, that as it goes with Old England, it will most likely go with New England. For this reason, there may be more of God's favor in our current dependence on England than we realize. It's very certain that if things go poorly with our mother country, her poor American daughter here must feel it; nor could our previous happy settlement have prevented us from sharing in that unhappiness. But if things go well in the Three Kingdoms, as long as God blesses the English nation with rulers who encourage piety, honesty, and industry in their subjects, and who support the interests of our glorious Gospel both abroad and at home, New England will at least stay afloat. And even more so, because of our comfortable settlement in the form we are now in. Unless there should be any unique, devastating, local plagues, by which an offended God would finally make us rise; but, alas, O Lord, what other place have you provided for us!
I say, fourthly, that England will certainly and quickly be visited with the ancient loving kindness of God. When one sees how strangely the curse of our Joshua has fallen upon the people and houses of those who have tried to rebuild the old Romish Jericho, which has been so far demolished, they cannot help but say that the Reformation there will not only be maintained but also pursued, advanced, and perfected; and that God will soon have a New Jerusalem there. Or, let a person think about the series of amazing providences towards the English nation over the last thirty years: let them reflect on how many plots for the ruin of the nation have been strangely discovered. Yes, how very unaccountably those very people, and I may also say, those very methods which were intended for the tools of that ruin, have become the instruments or occasions of deliverances. A person cannot help but say upon these reflections, as the wife of Manoah once wisely expressed herself, "If the Lord were pleased to have destroyed us, He would not have shown us all these things" (Judg. 13:23). Indeed, it is not unlikely that the enemies of the English nation may yet provoke such a shake unto it, as may perhaps exceed any that has been experienced so far: may the Lord prevent the schemes of his adversaries! But that shake will lead to the most glorious times that ever arose upon the English horizon. As for the French cloud which hangs over England, though it is likely to rain showers of blood upon a nation where the blood of the blessed Jesus has been too much treated as an unholy thing, yet I believe God will soon scatter it; and my belief is grounded upon a foundation that will support it. If that overgrown French Leviathan should accomplish anything like a conquest of England, what could stop him from the universal empire of the West? But the visions of the Western world, in the views of both Daniel and John, assure us that whatever monarch, while the Papacy continues, attempts to swallow up the ten kings who received their power upon the fall of the Western Empire, he must fail in the attempt. The French Phaeton's epitaph seems written in that "sure word of prophecy" (2 Pet. 1:19).
Since making this guess, we have received news of a victory by the English over the French, which further confirms our guess. This causes us to sing, "Pharaoh's chariots and his hosts has the Lord cast down into the sea; Your right hand has dashed in pieces the enemy!"
Now, in the salvation of England, the plantations cannot help but rejoice, and New England will also be glad.
But enough about our conclusions, I quickly move on to the main topic intended for your interest.
CHAPTER 5
AN URGENT ADDRESS TO A NATION UNDER SIEGE BY THE DEVIL
An Urgent and Necessary Address, To a Country Now Extraordinarily Alarmed By the Wrath of the Devil
Let us now make a good and proper use of the extraordinary attack that the Devil, in great anger, is making on our land today. Upon the death of a great man once, an orator called the town together, crying out, "Come together, neighbors, your town walls are fallen down!" But such is the Devil's attack on us today that I can truly tell you, "The walls of the whole world are broken down!" The usual walls of defense around humanity have such a gap in them that the very devils have broken in upon us, to seduce souls, torment bodies, tarnish reputations, and consume the estates of our neighbors, with effects both as real and as furious as if the Invisible World were becoming incarnate, specifically to trouble us. And what use should we now make of such a tremendous situation? We are engaged in a fast today; but shall we try to get nourishment from the eater, and make the lion provide some honey for our souls?
The Devil has come down to us with great anger, and we can see and feel it, and we lament it. For many years, the Devil has been trying to destroy the Kingdom of our Lord Jesus here. New England can complain like in Psalm 129:1-2, "Many times have they afflicted me from my youth, yet they have not prevailed against me." But now, there is an extraordinary affliction from the Devil that is unmatched. The confessions of witches and the sufferings of others together show the extent of our affliction. The Devil, often appearing as a small black man, has lured a group of proud, stubborn, ignorant, envious, and malicious people into his service by having them sign their names in a book he offers them. These witches, over twenty of whom have confessed and shown their deeds, and some are now tormented by the Devils for confessing, have met in hellish gatherings. The confessors say they have had diabolical sacraments, imitating the baptism and the supper of our Lord.
In these meetings, these monsters have joined forces to destroy the Kingdom of our Lord Jesus Christ in this part of the world. To achieve this, they each have their spectres, or devils, representing them and acting as instruments of their malice. These wicked spectres torment people across the country with various and bloody torments, and some have died from these clearly unnatural torments. They have bewitched some to the point of self-destruction, and others in many towns are suffering under their evil hands. The afflicted people are miserably scratched and bitten, with marks visible to all, but the causes are invisible. These invisible forces also stick pins into the bodies of the afflicted, distort and disjoint their members, and inflict countless other plagues beyond any natural diseases. They sometimes drag people out of their rooms and carry them over trees and hills for miles. Many of those tortured by these spectres are horribly tempted by them, sometimes with promises, sometimes with threats, but always with suffering, to sign the Devil's laws in a spectral book. Two or three of these sufferers, worn down by their suffering, have done so and were immediately released from their miseries, then appeared as spectres to torture those who were once their fellow sufferers. The witches, by their covenant with the Devil, have become owners of spectres and are often forced by their own spectres to allow the torment of some they did not wish to harm. Cruel attacks are then made on the neighborhood. In these witchcrafts, among countless other strange things, the spectres have a peculiar ability to make the most solid and physical instruments of torture invisible, while the wounds they cause are very real. Sufferers attacked with unseen iron instruments have managed to grab them from the spectres, and everyone has then seen and handled an iron instrument taken by a Devil from a neighbor.
These wicked spectres have even stolen money from various people, some of which has been seen falling from the air into the hands of the sufferers while the spectres urged them to sign their covenant with death. In such extreme ways, these wretches have tried to drag as many as they can into their group and destroy others with lingering, spreading, deadly diseases until our country becomes unbearable for us. Among the terrifying examples of the success these bloody witches have had, we have seen even some of their own children dedicated to the Devil, with imps sucking them in infancy and making them venomous. We have also seen the Devil's first attacks on the town where the first church of our Lord in this colony was established, causing distractions that nearly ruined the town. We have also seen the plague spreading to other towns, where the houses of good men are filled with terrible vexations from the Devil!
This is the attack that the Devil seems to have launched on us now. What makes this attack more frightening is the number and type of people accused of being involved in this witchcraft, through the power of the spectres that take their name and shape. This causes many good and wise people to fear that many innocent, and even some virtuous people, are being wrongly accused by the Devils. It is believed that the Devils have gained the power to take on the likeness of harmless people and, in that likeness, afflict others, being manipulated by deceitful demons so that upon their look or touch, the afflicted are strangely affected. Arguments from the providence of God on one side, and from our charity towards man on the other, have turned this into a highly debated controversy among us. There is a struggle in the minds of people, fearing that the Devil might deceive us with tricks perhaps more cunning than ever before. The whole situation has become so tangled, and the resolution of the question one way or another so dreadful, that our honorable judges find themselves in a position similar to Jehoshaphat's exclamation, "We know not what to do!" (2 Chron. 20:12).
They have used, as judges have done in the past, spectral evidence to guide their further investigations into the lives of the accused; and through the wonderful providence of God, they have been strengthened with other evidence, leading to the fair execution of some of the witch gang. But what should be done about those against whom the evidence is primarily based in the dark world? Here, they solemnly request our prayers to the Father of Lights on their behalf. Meanwhile, the Devil uses the darkness of this affair to push us into a blind man's bluff, and we are almost ready to sinfully, even heatedly and madly, attack one another in the dark.
The consequence of these things makes every thoughtful person tremble; and even more so because the frequent deceptions of passion and rumor lead so many to act hastily. I wish I could say that most people were thoughtful.
But what makes our trials so terrifying, to the point that they could be called "a wrath unto the uttermost," is this: It is not without the wrath of Almighty God himself that the Devil is allowed to come down upon us in wrath. As it says in Isaiah 9:19, "Through the wrath of the Lord of Hosts, the land is darkened." Our land is indeed darkened, since the powers of darkness have turned upon us. It's a dark time, truly a black night, now that the hounds of the Pit are among us. But it is through the wrath of the Lord of Hosts! Since the very firebrands of Hell itself are used to scorch us, we have every reason to cry out, "What means the heat of this anger?" Blessed Lord! Are all other instruments of your vengeance too good for punishing transgressors like us? Must the very Devils be sent out of their own place to trouble us? Must we be lashed with scorpions fetched from the place of torment? Must this wilderness become a home for the dragons of the wilderness? If a place like Lapland harbored many who could bewitch others with looks or words, sell winds to sailors, have familiar spirits passed to their children, and learn things from a thousand leagues away with enchanted kettle-drums, or if a place like Swedeland had a village where scores of witches met with familiar spirits and dragged children from their beds to spoil them, it wouldn't be so surprising! But that New England should be harassed this way! They are not Chaldeans, that "bitter and hasty nation," but bitter and burning devils; they are not swarthy Indians, but sooty devils that are unleashed upon us. Ah, poor New England! Must the plague of Old Egypt come upon you? As we read in Psalm 78:49, "He cast upon them the fierceness of his anger, wrath, and indignation, and trouble, by sending evil angels among them." What, oh what must we expect next? Must what is mentioned next be what we face? "He spared not their soul from death, but gave their life over to the pestilence." For my part, when I consider what Melancthon says in one of his letters, "That these diabolical spectacles are often prodigies," and when I think about how often people have been called upon by spectres just before their deaths, I am truly afraid that some devastating mortality may be among the things this plague is a forerunner of. I pray God prevents it!
But now, what shall we do?
1. Let the devils coming down in great wrath upon us cause us to come down in great grief before the Lord. We can truly and sadly say, "We are brought very low!" Low indeed, when the serpents of the dust are crawling and coiling around us, insulting us. May we not say, "We are in the very belly of Hell," when Hell itself is feeding upon us? But how low is that! O let us then most penitently lay ourselves very low before the God of Heaven, who has thus humbled us. When a cruel Nero, a devil of a man, was unleashed upon the world, it was said, "Humble yourselves under the mighty hand of God" (1 Pet. 5:6). How much more now ought we to humble ourselves under that mighty hand of God, who indeed has the devil in a chain, but has horribly lengthened out the chain! When the old people of God heard any blasphemies tearing His ever-blessed name to pieces, they were to rend their clothes at what they heard. I am sure that we have cause to rend our hearts this day when we see what high treason has been committed against the most high God by the witchcrafts in our neighborhood. We may say, and shall we not be humbled when we say it? "We have seen a horrible thing done in our land!" O, it's a most humbling thing to think that there should ever be such an abomination among us, as for a group of humans to renounce their Maker and unite with the devil for the troubling of mankind, and for people to be, as some confess, baptized by a fiend using this form upon them, "Thou art mine, and I have a full power over thee!" afterwards communicating in a hellish bread and wine, administered to them by that fiend. It was said, "There shall not be found among you an enchanter, or a witch, or a charmer, or a consulter with familiar spirits, or a wizard, or a necromancer; for all that do these things are an abomination to the Lord, and because of these abominations, the Lord your God does drive them out before you" (Deut. 18:10-12). That New England now should have these abominations in it, yes, that some of no mean profession should be found guilty of them: Alas, what humiliations are we all hereby obliged to? O, it's a defiled land in which we live; let us be humbled for these defiling abominations, lest we be driven out of our land. It's a very humbling thing to think what reproaches will be cast upon us for this matter among the daughters of the Philistines.
Indeed, enough might easily be said for the vindication of this country from the singularity of this matter by revealing what has been discovered in others. Great Britain alone, and this also in our days of greatest light, has had that in it which may divert the calumnies of an ill-natured world from centering here. They are words of the devout Bishop Hall, "Satan's prevalency in this age is most clear in the marvellous number of witches, abounding in all places. Now hundreds are discovered in one shire; and, if fame deceives us not, in a village of fourteen houses in the north, are found so many of this damned brood. Yes, and those of both sexes, who have professed much knowledge, holiness, and devotion, are drawn into this damnable practice." I suppose the doctor in the first of those passages may refer to what happened in the year 1645, when so many vassals of the devil were detected that there were thirty tried at one time, whereas about fourteen were hanged, and a hundred more detained in the prisons of Suffolk and Essex. Among other things which many of these acknowledged, one was that they were to undergo certain punishments if they did not perform such and such hurts as were appointed them. And among the rest that were then executed, there was an old parson called Lowis, who confessed that he had a couple of imps, one of which was always urging him to do mischief; once particularly, that imp, calling for his consent to do so, went immediately and sank a ship then under sail. I pray, let not New England become of an unsavory and sulfurous resentment in the opinion of the world abroad for the doleful things which are now fallen out among us, while there are such histories of other places abroad in the world. Nevertheless, I am sure that we, the people of New England, have cause enough to humble ourselves under our most humbling circumstances. We must no more be haughty because of the Lord's holy mountain among us; no, it becomes us rather to be humble because we have been such a habitation of unholy devils!
2. Since the Devil has come down in great anger upon us, let's not, in our own great anger against each other, give him a place to stay. It was a very wise warning in (Eph. 4:26-27), "Let not the sun go down upon your wrath: Neither give place to the Devil." The Devil has come down to see what kind of welcome he will find among us. If his arrival fills us with anger against each other, and if we take extreme sides between the cause of the sufferers on one hand and the cause of the suspected on the other, the Devil will be pleased to find such a convenient place to stay as we provide him. It may be that the anger we have had against each other has contributed to the Devil's wrath that now astonishes us. Haven't many of us acted like devils to one another with slander, backbiting, and animosity?
For this reason, among others, perhaps God has allowed the devils to trouble us as they now do. But it is high time to stop all devilish behavior when the Devil himself is attacking us. It is no time for us to be judging and insulting each other with a devilish wrath when the Devil's wrath is troubling us. The way for us to outsmart the Devil in the tricks with which he now bothers us would be for us to unite in our prayers to God for guidance and resolution in this difficult matter. But if we do not lift up our hands to Heaven without wrath, we cannot do it without doubt of success. I am ashamed when I read French authors describing Englishmen as "They hate one another, and are always quarreling with one another." I would be much more ashamed if this became the character of New Englanders, which is indeed what the Devil would want. Satan would have us harm each other by breaking the peace among us, but let us disappoint him. We read of something that sometimes happens to the Devil when he is foaming with his wrath, in (Matt. 12:43), "The unclean spirit seeks rest, and finds none." But we give rest to the Devil by being angry with one another. If we would put aside all fierceness and harshness in the disputes the Devil has raised among us, and if we would use only soft answers, which turn away wrath, I would hope we might find such counsel that would quickly get us out of our difficulties. But the old troublemaker of the world has come from Hell with sparks of Hell-Fire flashing on every side of him, and we make ourselves tinder to the sparks. When Emperor Henry III kept the Feast of Pentecost at the city of Mentz, a disagreement arose among some people there, which escalated from words to blows, and eventually led to bloodshed. After the tumult was over, when they came to the part of their devotions that said, "Thou hast made this day Glorious," the Devil, to the unexpressible terror of that vast assembly, made the temple ring with the outcry, "But I have made this day quarrelsome!" We have truly come into a day that, if well managed, might be very glorious for eliminating those cursed things that have hindered our prosperity. But if we make this day quarrelsome through any raging confidences, alas, O Lord, "my flesh trembles for fear of thee, and I am afraid of thy judgments."
Erasmus, among other historians, tells us that at a town in Germany, a witch or devil appeared on top of a chimney, threatening to set the town on fire. Eventually, scattering a pot of ashes abroad, the town was quickly and horribly burned to the ground. I think I see the spectres from the top of the chimneys to the northward, threatening to scatter fire about the country. But let us quench that fire by the most friendly interactions, lest, as the spectres have, they say, already literally burned some of our dwellings, a further fire from the brambles of Hell may more terribly devour us. Let us not be like a troubled house, although we are so much haunted by the devils. Let our long-suffering be a well-placed piece of armor against the fiery darts of the wicked ones. History informs us that as long ago as the year 858, a certain pestilent and malignant sort of demon molested Caumont in Germany with all sorts of methods to stir up strife among the citizens. He uttered prophecies, detected villainies, and branded people with all kinds of infamies. He incited the neighborhood against one man in particular as the cause of all the mischiefs, who yet proved himself innocent. He threw stones at the inhabitants and eventually burned their homes until the demon's commission could go no further. I say, let us be well aware lest such demons come here also.
3. Since the Devil has come down with great wrath, we need to work with all the care and speed we can to prevent the great wrath of Heaven from coming upon us at the same time. The God of Heaven has been calling us with long and loud warnings to reform our provoking evils as the only way to avoid His wrath, which not only threatens but consumes us. It's because we have been deaf to those calls that we are now, by a provoked God, exposed to the wrath of the Devil himself. It is said in Proverbs 16:7, "When a man's ways please the Lord, he maketh even his enemies to be at peace with him." The Devil is our grand enemy; and though we would not be at peace with him, we would like to be at peace from him, meaning we want him unable to disturb our peace. But since the wrath we endure from this enemy allows us no peace, we can be sure our ways have not pleased the Lord. It is because we have broken the hedge of God's precepts that the hedge of God's providence is not as complete as it used to be around us, and serpents are biting us.
O let us then set ourselves to make our peace with our God, whom we have displeased by our iniquities, and let us not imagine that we can face the wrath of the Devil while there is the wrath of God Almighty to set that mastiff upon us. REFORMATION! REFORMATION! has been the repeated cry of all the judgments that have been upon us so far; because we have been like deaf adders to it, the adders of the infernal pit are now hissing around us. At last, as it was said of old in Luke 16:30, "If one went unto them from the dead, they will repent," even so, there are some who have come to us from the damned. The great God has loosened the bars of the pit, so that many damned spirits have come among us to make us repent of our misdemeanors. The means which the Lord had formerly employed for our awakening were such that He might well have said, "What could I have done more?" and yet after all, He has done more, in some regards, than was ever done for the awakening of any people in the world. The things now done to awaken our inquiries after our provoking evils and our efforts to reform those evils are most extraordinary things; for this reason, I would freely say it, if we now do not do some extraordinary things in returning to God, we are the most incurable, and I wish it not quickly said, the most miserable people under the sun.
Believe me, it's a time for all people to do something extraordinary in searching and trying their ways and in turning to the Lord. It is at an extraordinary rate of circumspection and spiritual-mindedness that we should all now maintain a walk with God. At such a time as this, magistrates ought to do something extraordinary in promoting what is laudable and in restraining and chastising evildoers. At such a time as this, ministers ought to do something extraordinary in pulling the souls of men out of the snares of the Devil, not only by public preaching but by personal visits and counsels, from house to house. At such a time as this, churches ought to do something extraordinary in renewing their covenants and in remembering and reviving the obligations of what they have renewed. Some admirable designs about the reformation of manners have recently been on foot in the English nation, in pursuit of the most excellent admonitions given for it by the letters of Their Majesties. Besides the vigorous agreements of the justices here and there in the kingdom, assisted by godly gentlemen and informers, to execute the laws upon profane offenders, there has been a proposal for the well-affected people in every parish to enter into orderly societies, where every member shall bind himself not only to avoid profanity in himself but also, according to their place, to do their utmost in first reproving; and, if it must be so, then exposing, and so punishing, as the law directs, for others that shall be guilty.
It has been observed that the English nation has had some of its greatest successes upon some special and signal actions this way; and a discouragement given under legal proceedings of this kind must be very trying to the wise who observe these things. But, O why should not New England be the most forward part of the English nation in such reformations? I think I hear the Lord from Heaven saying over us, "O that my people had hearkened unto me; then I should soon have subdued the devils, as well as their other enemies!" There have been some feeble attempts towards reformation of late in our churches; but, I pray, what comes of them? Do we wait until the storm of His wrath is over? No, let us be doing what we can, as fast as we can, to divert the storm. The devils having broken in upon our world, there is great asking, "Who is it that has brought them in?" And many do by spectral exhibitions come to be cried out upon. I hope in God's time it will be found that among those who are thus cried out upon, there are persons yet clear from the great transgression; but indeed, all the unreformed among us may justly be cried out upon as having too much of a hand in letting the devils into our borders; it's our worldliness, our formality, our sensuality, and our iniquity that has helped this letting of the devils in. O let us then at last consider our ways.
It's a strange passage recorded by Mr. Clark in the life of his father, that the people of his parish, refusing to be reclaimed from their Sabbath breaking by all the zealous testimonies which that good man bore against it; at last, on a night after the people had retired home from a reveling profanation of the Lord's Day, there was heard a great noise, with rattling of chains up and down the town, and a horrid scent of brimstone filled the neighborhood. Upon which the guilty consciences of the wretches told them the Devil was come to fetch them away; and it so terrified them that an eminent reformation followed the sermons which that man of God preached thereupon. Behold, sinners, behold and wonder, lest you perish: the very devils are walking about our streets with lengthened chains, making a dreadful noise in our ears, and brimstone even without a metaphor is making a hellish and horrid stench in our nostrils. I pray, leave off all those things whereof your guilty consciences may now accuse you, lest these devils do yet more direfully fall upon you. Reformation is at this time our only preservation.
4. When the Devil comes down in great anger, let every major sin that might make us vulnerable to that anger be discredited among us. It's generally agreed by everyone who hasn't become too unreasonable for common conversation that the presence of witchcraft is what has brought the Devil among us. So, not only should all witchcraft be strongly condemned by us, but we should also be vigilant against all the steps leading to it. There are smaller sorceries that are said to be too common in our land. As it was said in 2 Kings 17:9, "The children of Israel did secretly those things that were not right, against the Lord their God." Similarly, it's feared that the children of New England have secretly done many things pleasing to the Devil. It's said that in some towns, people commonly cure injuries with spells or use detestable conjurations with sieves, keys, peas, nails, and horseshoes, among other things, to learn forbidden and impious knowledge. These things are done in the Devil's name, and in God's name, I charge them today as vile impieties. By these actions, people play with the hole of the asp until that venomous asp pulls many of them into the deep hole of witchcraft itself. Some who have fallen deeply into this horrible pit have admitted they started with these little witchcrafts. It's a pity the laws of the English nation, which make the repeated incorrigible practice of these tricks a felony, aren't strictly enforced. From similar sinful curiosity, the predictions of judicial astrology are foolishly regarded by many among us.
Although the juggling astrologers rarely get things right, except in obvious predictions like many old men will die in a year, some will experience losses at sea, and there will be much lying and cheating in the world, their foolish admirers still believe the innocent stars are involved in these events. It's a disgrace to the English nation that the pamphlets of such idle, trivial stargazers are so highly regarded, and the attention given to a study where everything is done by impulse, if anything is done at all, is dangerous to the souls of men. It's not a science, but a juggle, as the learned Hall well says, "It is presumptuous and unwarrantable, and cried ever down by councils and fathers, as unlawful, as that which lies in the mid-way between magic and imposture, and partakes not a little of both." People consult the aspects of planets, whose northern or southern motions are named after a celestial dragon, until the infernal dragon eventually insinuates into them with a poison of witchcraft that can't be cured. Has there not also been a world of discontent in our borders? It's no wonder the fiery serpents are stinging us; we have been a most murmuring generation. It's not irrational to partly attribute the recent astounding growth of witches among us to the bitter discontents caused by affliction and poverty. It's inconceivable what advantage the Devil gains over people through discontent. Moreover, the sin of unbelief may be considered perhaps the chief crime of our land. We are told, "God swears in wrath, against them that believe not" (Heb. 3:18-19); and what follows then but this, "That the Devil comes unto them in wrath?" Never were the offers of the Gospel more freely tendered or more basely despised among any people under the whole sky than in New England. Does it seem at all surprising to us that the Devil should gain such a foothold in our country? It's because the Savior has been slighted here, perhaps more than anywhere else. The blessed Lord Jesus Christ has been offering us grace, glory, and every good thing, and has been enticing us to accept Him with terms like, "Undone sinner, I am all; are you willing that I should be your all?" But, as proof of the contempt this unbelief has cast upon these offers, I would seriously ask the many hundreds above a thousand people within these walls: which of you, oh how few of you, can indeed say, "Christ is mine, and I am his, and he is the beloved of my soul?" I would only say this much: When the precious and glorious Jesus is entreating us to receive Him in all His offices with all His benefits, the Devil notices what respect we pay to that heavenly Lord. If we refuse Him who speaks from heaven, then he who comes from hell does with a sort of claim set in and cry out, "Lord, since this wretch is not willing that thou shouldst have him, I pray, let me have him." And thus, by the just vengeance of heaven, the Devil becomes a master, a prince, a god to the miserable unbelievers. But oh, what are many of them then hurried unto! All of these evil things, I now set before you, as branded with the mark of the Devil upon them.
5. With great regard and great pity, we should consider the condition of those who are afflicted by the great wrath of the Devil. There are many of our good neighbors, some particularly noted for their goodness and virtue, of whom we might say, "Lord, they are vexed with devils." Their tortures, primarily inflicted on their spirits, may make the effects on their bodies less durable, though more noticeable. They endure horrible things, and many have been murdered. Harsh judgments on these poor sufferers cannot be pleasing to our Lord, who, as He said about some who were killed by Pilate (Luke 13:2-3), "Think ye that these were sinners above others, because they suffered such things? I tell you, No, but except ye repent, ye shall all likewise perish." Similarly, He now says, "Think ye that they who now suffer by the Devil have been greater sinners than their neighbors?" No, repent of your own sins, lest the Devil come to attack you, as he has done to them. If this is true, how rash it would be if those sufferers who carry themselves with piety, seriousness, and humility under their suffering were unjustly judged or had their calamity blamed on them as a crime. It is easy for us to fall into the fault of adding affliction to the afflicted and of talking to the grief of those already wounded. Nor is it wise to ignore the dangers of such a fault. Meanwhile, we lack compassion if we do not sympathize with the distressed county of Essex, now crying to all these colonies, "Have pity on me, O ye my friends, have pity on me, for the hand of the Lord has touched me, and the wrath of the Devil has been turned upon me." Indeed, if heartfelt pity is due to anyone, the difficulties faced by our honorable judges demand a significant share of that pity.
What a difficult and arduous task those worthy individuals have on their hands! To wield the knife so precisely that, on one side, no innocent blood is shed by too blind a zeal for the children of Israel, and on the other side, no shelter is given to those diabolical works of darkness, without the removal of which we shall never have peace, or to those furies that have killed more people than would populate a village: "Hic labor, hoc opus est!" O how we need to be concerned that the sins of our Israel may not provoke the God of Heaven to leave His Davids to make a wrong step in such a consequential matter as is now before them! Our disingenuous, uncharitable, unchristian reproaching of such faithful men, after all the prayers and supplications, with strong crying and tears, with which we are daily pleading the throne of grace that they may be kept from what they fear, is not the way to prevent what we fear. Nor should our pity forget those accused ones who indeed call for our most compassionate pity until there is fuller evidence that they are less worthy of it. If Satan has maliciously brought onto the stage those who have had a just and good reputation for their just and good living among us; if the Evil One has obtained permission to appear in the figure of those we have reason to think have abstained even from the appearance of evil, it is truly an invasion upon mankind that should raise horror in us all.
But, O what compassions are due to those who may come under such misrepresentations of the Great Accuser! Who among us can say what may be shown in the glasses of the Great Lying Spirit? Although the usual providence of God [we praise Him!] keeps us from such a mishap, where do we have an absolute promise that we shall always be kept from it? As long as charity is bound to think no evil, it will not harm us private persons to refrain from judgment that does not belong to us. Let it rather be our wish: May the Lord help them to learn the lessons for which they are now put into such a hard school.
6. With great zeal, we should embrace the covenant of God to protect ourselves and our loved ones from the great wrath with which the Devil rages. Let us enter into the Covenant of Grace, so we won't be drawn into a covenant with the Devil, and we will have some armor against those in that covenant. The way to come under the saving influences of the New Covenant is to connect with the Lord Jesus Christ, who is the all-sufficient mediator of it. Let us do this by surrendering ourselves to the saving, teaching, and ruling hands of this blessed mediator. Then we shall be, as we read in Jude 1:1, "Preserved in Christ Jesus." Just as the destroying angel could not harm those marked by the blood of the Passover on their houses, the blood of the Lord Jesus Christ, sprinkled on our souls, will preserve us from the Devil. The birds of prey (and indeed the devils, most literally in the shape of great birds!) are flying about. Would we find shelter from these vultures? Let us then hear our Lord Jesus from heaven calling to us, "O that you would be gathered under my wings!" When this is done, let us acknowledge the covenant we have entered by joining a particular church, walking in the order of the Gospel. In doing so, according to that covenant of God, we give ourselves to the Lord and, in Him, to one another.
While others have their names entered in the Devil's book, let our names be found in the church book, and let us be written among the living in Jerusalem. By no means let church work diminish and fail among us; instead, let the tragic events happening now greatly energize that work. Many of the rising generation have utterly forgotten the mission of our fathers to build churches in this wilderness, and many of our homes are allowed to exist where they do not, and perhaps cannot, worship God with the churches of His people. This is likely to lead to the spread of witchcraft among us. But it is fitting for us, with similar passion, to bring our poor children with us when we come ourselves into the covenant of God. It would break a heart of stone to have seen what I have recently seen: even poor children of various ages, from seven to twenty, more or less, confessing their familiarity with devils, but at the same time, in sorrowful, bitter lamentations that made a little portrait of hell itself, accusing their wicked parents for devoting them to the Devil in their infancy, thus entailing devilishness upon them! Now, as the Psalmist could say, "My zeal hath consumed me, because mine enemies have forgotten thy words" (Ps. 119:139), let the wickedness of those who have explicitly dedicated their children to the Devil, even with devilish symbols of such a dedication, provoke our zeal to have our children sincerely, significantly, and openly consecrated to God, with an education afterward assuring and confirming that consecration.
7. Let our prayer go up with great faith, against the Devil, who comes down in great wrath. The Devil has such a dislike for our prayer that he cannot bear to stay long where there is a lot of it. Indeed, it is the "Devil's Scourge," as well as the "Remedy for Misery"; the Devil will soon be driven out of the Lord's Temple by a whip made and used with the effective fervent prayer of righteous people. When the Devil afflicts us and drives us to our prayers, he is "the fool making a whip for his own back." Our Lord said of the Devil in Matthew 17:21, "This kind goes not out, but by prayer and fasting." But prayer and fasting will soon make the Devil leave. Here are charms indeed! Sacred and blessed charms that the Devil cannot stand before. A promise of God, when well managed in the hands of those who spend much time on their knees, will resist the Devil so that he will flee from us. With every other weapon, the Devils will be too hard for us; the spiritual wickedness in high places has clearly the upper hand of us; that old serpent will be too old for us, too cunning, too subtle; they will soon outwit us if we think to encounter them with any wit of our own. But when we come to prayers, incessant and vehement prayers before the Lord, there we shall be too hard for them. When well-directed prayers, that great artillery of Heaven, are brought into the field, there, I think, I see, "There are these workers of iniquity fallen, all of them!" And who can tell how much the most obscure Christian among you all may do towards the deliverance of our land from the troubles the Devil is now giving us. I have read that on a day of prayer kept by some good people for and with a possessed person, the Devil at last flew out of the window, and referring to a devout, plain, mean woman then in the room, he cried out, "O the woman behind the door! 'Tis that woman that forces me away!" Thus, the Devil that now troubles us may be forced within a while to forsake us; and it shall be said, "He was driven away by the prayers of some obscure and retired souls, which the world has taken but little notice of!" The great God is about a great work at this day among us: Now, there is extreme hazard, lest the Devil, by compulsion, must submit to that great work, and may also, by permission, come to confound that work; both in the detections of some and in the confessions of others, whose ungodly deeds may be brought forth by a great work of God; there is great hazard lest the Devil intertwines some of his delusions. It's prayer, I say, it's prayer that must carry us well through the strange things that are now upon us. Only that prayer must then be the prayer of faith: O where is our faith in him, who "has spoiled these principalities and powers, on his cross, triumphing over them" (Col. 2:15)!
8. Lastly, shake off, every soul, shake off the hard yoke of the Devil. Where it is said, "The whole world lies in wickedness," some of the Ancients have translated it as, "The whole world lies in the Devil." The Devil is a prince, yes, the Devil is a god to all the unregenerate; and alas, there is a whole world of them. Desolate sinners, consider what a horrid lord it is that you are enslaved to; and oh, shake off your slavery to such a lord. Instead of him, now make your choice of the Eternal God in Jesus Christ; choose him with a most unalterable resolution, and to him say, with Thomas, "My Lord and my God!" Say with the Church, "Lord, other lords have had dominion over us, but now you alone shall be our Lord forever." Then instead of perishing under the wrath of the Devils, God will bring you to a place among those that fill up the room of the Devils, left by their fall from the ethereal regions. It was a most awful speech made by the Devil, possessing a young woman, at a village in Germany, "By the command of God, I am come to torment the body of this young woman, though I cannot hurt her soul; and it is that I may warn men to take heed of sinning against God." "Indeed," said he, "it's very sore against my will that I do it; but the command of God forces me to declare what I do; however, I know that at the Last Day, I shall have more souls than God himself." So spoke that horrible Devil! But oh, that none of our souls may be found among the prizes of the Devil, in the Day of God! Oh, that what the Devil has been forced to declare, of his kingdom among us, may prejudice our hearts against him forever!
The text says, "The Devil has come down in great wrath, for he has but a short time." Yes, but if you do not quickly and thoroughly convert to God to escape the Devil's wrath, you will end up where the Devil is, suffering under his wrath not for a short time, but forever; not for a short time, but for infinite millions of ages. The smoke of your torment under that wrath will "ascend forever and ever!" Indeed, the Devil's time for his wrath upon you in this world can only be short, but his time for you to do his work, or, which is the same, to delay your turning to God, is a long time. When the Devil was about to be cast out of a man, he cried out, "Am I to be tormented before my time?" You will torment the Devil if you rescue your souls from his grasp through true repentance. If you start to look that way, he'll cry out, "Oh, this is before my time, I must have more time yet in the service of such a guilty soul." But, I urge you, let us join together to torment the Devil in a holy revenge for all the harm he has done to us; let us tell him, "Satan, your time with me is short, no, your time with me shall be no more; I am deeply sorry that it has been so much; depart from me, you evil-doer, who would have me be an evil-doer like yourself; I will now forever keep the commandments of that God, in whom I live and move and have my being!" The Devil has played a fine game for himself indeed if, by troubling our land, the souls of many people come to "think upon their ways, till even they turn their feet into the testimonies of the Lord." Now, that the Devil may be thus defeated by his own schemes is the desire of all who love the salvation of God among us, as well as of him who has thus addressed you. Amen.
With God's help, I will now share some remarkable and memorable examples of the wonders that this world has shown us. Although the main interest for my readers will be a true account of the witchcrafts that are currently persecuting us, I will begin by discussing these matters with a brief introduction.
CHAPTER 6
A GHOSTLY WARNING: THE APPARITION OF A MURDERED BROTHER
A Narrative of an Apparition which A gentleman in Boston had from his brother, Just Then Murdered in London
On the 2nd of May in the year 1687, a very intelligent, accomplished, and well-meaning gentleman named Mr. Joseph Beacon, around five o'clock in the morning, had a vision of his brother who was in London, even though he himself was in Boston, separated by a thousand leagues. Whether he was sleeping or awake, he couldn't say, but he believed he was awake. His brother appeared to him at five o'clock in the morning in Boston, wearing a Bengal gown, which he usually wore, with a napkin tied around his head. His face was very pale, ghastly, and deadly, with a bloody wound on one side of his forehead. "Brother!" said the frightened Joseph. "Brother!" answered the apparition. Joseph asked, "What's the matter, brother? How did you get here?" The apparition replied, "Brother, I have been most barbarously and injuriously butchered by a debauched drunken fellow, to whom I never did any wrong in my life." He then gave a detailed description of the murderer, adding, "Brother, this fellow, changing his name, is attempting to come over to New England, in Foy or Wild. I would pray you, on the first arrival of either of these, to get an order from the governor to seize the person I have now described; and then indict him for the murder of me, your brother. I'll stand by you and prove the indictment." And then he vanished. Mr. Beacon was extremely astonished at what he had seen and heard; and the people of the family not only noticed an extraordinary change in him for the following week, but have also given me a full written testimony that he then told them about this apparition.
During this time, Mr. Beacon had no idea that anything was wrong with his brother in England. However, around the end of June, he learned through common communication that back in April, his brother, while rushing at night to call a coach for a lady, encountered a drunk man with his girlfriend. Somehow, the man felt insulted by Beacon's hurried passage and immediately ran into a nearby tavern, where he grabbed a fire-fork and severely wounded Beacon in the skull, exactly where the apparition had shown his wound. Beacon suffered from this wound until he died on May 2nd, around five in the morning in London. The murderer, it seems, was trying to escape, as the apparition had said, but Beacon's friends caught him. They prosecuted him at law, but he had friends who helped him avoid the death penalty. Since then, nothing more has been heard about the matter.
I received this history from Mr. Joseph Beacon himself. Shortly before his own pious and hopeful death, which occurred not long after, he gave me the story written and signed with his own hand, and confirmed with the circumstances I have already mentioned.
But I will no longer keep my reader from the expected account of the trials of some of the criminals recently executed at Salem for the witchcrafts they were convicted of. I was not present at any of these trials, nor do I have any personal prejudice against the people brought to trial, much less against the surviving relatives of those individuals, for whom I would sincerely mourn as much as anyone in the world. May the Lord comfort them! However, having been commanded to do so, I can only briefly relate the main facts from the trials of some who were executed, based on an abridgment collected from the court papers given to me. You are to take the truth just as it was, and the truth will not harm any good person. There could have been more of these accounts if my book wouldn't have become too large, and if some other worthy individuals did not perhaps plan to add more to these collections. For this reason, I have only selected four or five cases to illustrate the typical dealings involved in witchcraft, and I report these matters not as an advocate, but as a historian.
They were some of the gracious words included in the advice, which many of the neighboring ministers, this summer, humbly presented to our honorable judges: "We cannot but with all thankfulness, acknowledge the success which the merciful God has given unto the diligent and persistent efforts of our honorable rulers, to detect the abominable witchcrafts which have been committed in the country; humbly praying, that the discovery of those mysterious and mischievous wickednesses, may be perfected." If, in the midst of the many dissatisfactions among us, the publication of these trials may promote such a pious thankfulness to God for justice being so far executed among us, I shall rejoice that God is glorified; and pray that no wrong steps of ours may ever tarnish any of His glorious works. But we will begin with…
CHAPTER 7
AN ENGLISH PRECEDENT: A WITCH TRIAL BEFORE JUDGE MATTHEW HALE
It may shed some light on the dark events now in America if we take a quick look at similar events that recently happened in Europe. We can see that the witchcraft here closely resembles the witchcraft there, and we can learn what kind of devils are troubling the world.
The venerable Baxter very truly says, "Judge Hale was a person than whom no man was more backward to condemn a witch without full evidence."
Now, one of the most recent printed accounts about a trial of witches is what was before him, and it went like this. [Printed in the year 1682.] It is mentioned here because it was a trial that was greatly considered by the judges of New England.
1. Rose Cullender and Amy Duny were each indicted for bewitching Elizabeth Durent, Ann Durent, Jane Bocking, Susan Chandler, William Durent, Elizabeth, and Deborah Pacy. The evidence on which they were convicted was based on various specific circumstances.
2. Ann Durent, Susan Chandler, and Elizabeth Pacy, when they came into the hall to provide instructions for drawing up the bills of indictments, fell into strange and violent fits, making them unable to give their depositions, not only then but also throughout the entire assizes. William Durent, being a child, had his mother swear that Amy Duny, while looking after her child one day in her absence, confessed upon her return that she had "given suck to the child" (even though she was an old woman). When Durent expressed her displeasure, Duny left with discontent and threats.
The night after, the child fell into strange and sad fits, which continued for several weeks. One doctor, Jacob, advised her to hang up the child's blanket in the chimney corner all day, and at night, when she went to put the child into it, if she found anything in it, to throw it without fear into the fire. Accordingly, at night, a great toad fell out of the blanket and ran around the hearth. A boy caught it and held it in the fire with tongs, where it made a horrible noise and flashed like gunpowder, with a report like that of a pistol. After that, the toad was no longer seen. The next day, a relative of Duny's told the witness that her aunt was severely scorched by the fire, and when the witness went to her house, she found her in such a condition. Duny told her she could thank her for it, but she would live to see some of her children dead and herself on crutches. However, after the burning of the toad, this child recovered.
This witness further testified that her daughter, Elizabeth, who was about ten years old, was afflicted in the same way as her first child. During her fits, she complained a lot about Amy Duny and said that Duny appeared to her and tormented her just like before. One day, she found Amy Duny in her house and pushed her out the door. Duny said, "You need not be so angry, your child won't live long." Within three days, the child died. The witness added that she herself was soon after struck with such lameness in both her legs that she was forced to use crutches, and she was now in court using them. It was remarkable that immediately after the jury found Duny guilty, Durent was restored to the use of her limbs and went home without her crutches.
3. As for Elizabeth and Deborah Pacy, one aged eleven years and the other nine, the elder was made completely senseless or at least speechless during the entire trial. By the judge's direction, Duny was privately brought to Elizabeth Pacy, and she touched her hand. Upon this, the child, without even seeing her, suddenly leaped up and attacked the prisoner. The younger child was too ill to be brought to the trial. However, Samuel Pacy, their father, testified that his daughter Deborah was suddenly struck with lameness. After Amy Duny grumbled about being denied something while the child was sitting there, Deborah experienced extreme stomach pain, like being pricked with pins, and shrieked in a dreadful manner, more like a puppy than a rational creature. The physicians could not determine the cause of the illness, but since Amy Duny was a woman of ill repute and the child, in her fits, cried out about Amy Duny frightening her with the apparition of her person, the father suspected her and had her put in the stocks. While there, she said in the hearing of two witnesses, "Mr. Pacy keeps a great stir about his child, but let him stay till he has done as much by his children as I have done by mine." When asked what she had done to her children, she answered, "She had been forced to open her child's mouth with a tap to give it food." The father added that within two days, his daughters' fits were so severe that they could not preserve either life or breath without the help of a tap. The children cried out about Amy Duny and Rose Cullender afflicting them with their apparitions.
4. The fits of the children were varied. Sometimes they would be lame on one side, sometimes on the other. Sometimes they were in a lot of pain; other times they would regain use of their limbs, only to be deaf, blind, or mute for a long time. When they recovered their speech, they would cough excessively and bring up crooked pins with a lot of phlegm, and once, even a two-penny nail with a very broad head. Usually, at the end of every fit, they would vomit a pin. When the children read, they couldn't pronounce the name "Lord," "Jesus," or "Christ" without falling into fits and would say, "Amy Duny says, I must not use that name." When they came to the name "Satan" or "Devil," they would clap their fingers on the book, crying out, "This bites, but it makes me speak right well!" During their fits, the children would often cry out, "There stands Amy Duny," or "Rose Cullender," and they would later say that these witches appeared before them, threatening that if they told what they saw or heard, they would torment them ten times more than ever before.
5. Margaret Arnold, the sister of Mr. Pacy, testified about similar sufferings happening to the children at her house, where her brother had moved them. Sometimes, only the children would see things like mice running around the house. One of them suddenly caught one with the tongs and threw it into the fire, where it screeched like a rat. At another time, something like a bee flew at the face of the younger child, causing the child to fall into a fit and eventually vomit up a two-penny nail with a broad head. The child claimed that the bee brought this nail and forced it into her mouth. Similarly, the child would be attacked by flies that brought crooked pins to her, making her swallow them first and then vomit them. One day, she caught an invisible mouse and threw it into the fire, where it flashed like gunpowder. No one besides the child saw the mouse, but everyone saw the flash. She also declared, when not in her fits, that during them, Amy Duny often tempted her to harm herself.
6. As for Ann Durent, her father testified that after a disagreement with Rose Cullender, his daughter became very ill with stomach pains and severe, sharp pains like the pricking of pins. She then experienced swooning fits, and upon recovering, she declared, "She had seen the apparition of Rose Cullender, threatening to torment her." She also vomited up several pins. The maid was present at court, but when Cullender looked at her, she fell into such fits that she was completely unable to say anything.
Ann Baldwin testified to the same.
7. Jane Bocking was too weak to attend the Assizes. But her mother testified that her daughter, who had previously suffered from fainting fits and recovered from them, was now experiencing severe stomach pain and new fainting fits. She ate little food but vomited crooked pins every day. During her initial fits, she would stretch out her arms and make gestures as if grabbing something, and when her clenched hands were forced open, they would find several pins bent in various ways, inexplicably lodged there. She would also have conversations with some invisible presence, often saying, "I will not have it!" but eventually saying, "Then I will have it!" and when her hand was opened shortly after, a lath nail was found in it. Her main complaints were about being visited by the shapes of Amy Duny and Rose Cullender.
8. As for Susan Chandler, her mother testified that during the examination of Rose Cullender, they found something like a teat, about an inch long, on her belly, which Rose claimed was due to a strain. But near her private parts, they found three more, smaller than the first. At the end of the long teat, there was a little hole that looked as if it had been recently sucked, and when they pressed it, a white milky substance came out. The mother further said that her daughter, being upset one day after Rose Cullender took her by the hand, became very sick and cried out at night that "Rose Cullender would come to bed with her." Her fits became violent, and during the intervals, she declared that she saw "Rose Cullender in them, and once having a great dog with her." She also vomited up crooked pins, and when she was brought into court, she fell into her fits. She recovered herself after some time and was asked by the court if she was in a condition to take an oath and give evidence. She said she could, but after being sworn in, she fell into her fits again, and "Burn her! Burn her!" were the only words she could manage to say. Her father also gave the same testimony as her mother, except for the examination part.
9. Here was the summary of the evidence: Mr. Sergeant Keeling thought it was not enough to convict the prisoners. He argued that even if the children were bewitched, it couldn't be attributed to the prisoners based solely on the imagination of the afflicted parties, as this would mean no one could be safe.
Dr. Brown, a very learned person who was present, gave his opinion that these people were bewitched. He added that in Denmark, there had recently been a significant discovery of witches who used the same method of afflicting people by inserting pins and nails into them. His opinion was that the Devil, through witchcraft, worked on the bodies of men and women based on a natural foundation, and that he extraordinarily afflicted them with illnesses to which their bodies were most susceptible.
10. The experiment about the usefulness, or even lawfulness, of which good men have sometimes debated, was conducted several times. It was observed that although the afflicted were completely deprived of all sense during their fits, upon the touch of the accused, they would scream and react in a way they did not with any other person. However, it was also discovered that once, upon the touch of an innocent person, the same effect occurred, which caused the whole court to pause. Eventually, a small reason was attempted to be given for it.
11. To further support the credibility of the evidence already presented against the prisoners, one John Soam testified that while bringing home his hay in three carts, one of the carts accidentally hit the window of Rose Cullender's house. She then came out with violent threats against him. The other two carts passed by twice, fully loaded, later that day without incident. However, the cart that touched Cullender's house overturned two or three times that day. After reloading it, as they brought it through the gate leading out of the field, the cart got stuck so firmly in the gate's head that they couldn't get it through. They had to cut down the gate post to make the cart pass through, even though they couldn't see that the cart touched the gate post on either side. They eventually managed to get it home to the yard with much difficulty, but they couldn't get the cart near the place where they needed to unload. They had to unload at a great distance, and when they were exhausted, the noses of those who came to help started bleeding. They had to stop until the next morning, and then they unloaded without any difficulty.
12. Robert Sherringham also testified that when the axle-tree of his cart accidentally broke part of Rose Cullender's house, she angrily threatened him, saying, "His horses should suffer for it." Shortly after, all four of his horses died, and he experienced many other losses with the sudden death of his cattle. He also became lame in his limbs and was plagued by an extraordinary number and size of lice, which no remedy could stop from swarming until he burned up two suits of clothing.
13. As for Amy Duny, it was testified by Richard Spencer that he heard her say, "The Devil would not let her rest until she was revenged on the wife of Cornelius Sandswel." Sandswel testified that his poultry died suddenly after Amy Duny threatened them, and that his chimney fell shortly after Duny spoke of such a disaster. Additionally, a firkin of fish could not be kept from falling into the water after Duny's suspicious words.
14. The judge told the jury that they needed to determine two things: first, whether these children were bewitched, and second, whether the prisoners at the bar were guilty of it. He had no doubt that witches existed, as the Scriptures confirmed it, and the wisdom of all nations had created laws against such people. He prayed to the God of Heaven to guide their hearts in the important matter they were dealing with, because "to condemn the innocent and let the guilty go free were both an abomination to the Lord" (Prov. 17:15).
The jury, in half an hour, found them guilty on their several indictments, which were nineteen in number.
The next morning, the children and their parents came to the lodgings of the Lord Chief Justice, and they were in as good health as ever in their lives; being restored within half an hour after the witches were convicted.
The witches were executed, and they confessed nothing. This won't be surprising to those who consider and accept the judgment of a wise writer, who stated that the unpardonable sin is most often committed by those who profess the Christian religion and fall into witchcraft.
We will now proceed to several similar trials among ourselves.
CHAPTER 8
THE TRIAL OF GEORGE BURROUGHS
Glad would I have been if I had never known the name of this man, or never had this occasion to mention even the first letters of his name. But since the government requires some account of his trial to be included in this book, it is my duty to obediently comply with the order.
1. This G.B. was indicted for witchcraft, and during the prosecution of the charge against him, he was accused by five or six of the bewitched as the cause of their miseries. He was accused by eight of the confessing witches as being a leading actor at some of their hellish gatherings and as someone who had the promise of being a king in Satan's kingdom, which was now being established. He was accused by nine people for extraordinary feats of strength, such as lifting, which could not be done without diabolical assistance. He was accused of other such things until about thirty testimonies were brought against him. These were not considered even half of what might have been used for his conviction. However, they were enough to label him as a witch according to the rules of reasoning directed by the judicious Gaule in such cases.
2. The court understood that the testimonies of the people who were bewitched often played a role among the suspicions or presumptions against someone accused of witchcraft. Several people who were clearly bewitched and tortured daily by invisible forces testified, accusing the specters of G. B. of being involved in their torment. During the examination of G. B., the bewitched individuals were severely harassed by supernatural forces, which could not possibly be faked, and they attributed these actions to G. B.'s attempts to kill them. During the trial, one of the bewitched individuals testified that during her agonies, a small black-haired man came to her, saying his name was B. He asked her to sign a book he showed her, boasting that he was a conjurer above the ordinary rank of witches. He often persecuted her with the offer of that book, saying, "She should be well, and need fear nobody, if she would but sign it." However, he inflicted cruel pain on her because she refused to do so. The testimonies of the other sufferers matched these accounts. Notably, biting was one of the methods witches used to torment the victims. When they cried out that G. B. was biting them, the teeth marks would appear on the complainants' flesh, matching G. B.'s teeth, which could be distinguished from others. Others testified that during their torments, G. B. tempted them to attend a sacrament, where they perceived him summoning other witches with the sound of a trumpet. After the sound, witches would quickly gather from all directions. One person, falling into a trance, claimed that G. B. had taken her to a very high mountain, where he showed her mighty and glorious kingdoms, saying, "He would give them all to her if she would write in his book." She replied, "They were none of his to give," and refused, enduring much suffering for her refusal.
The court faced a lot of trouble hearing the testimonies of the victims. When they were about to give their statements, they would often have fits that made them unable to speak. The chief judge asked the prisoner who he thought was preventing these witnesses from giving their testimonies. The prisoner answered, "He supposed it was the Devil." The honorable judge replied, "How comes the Devil then to be so loath to have any testimony borne against you?" This left the prisoner in great confusion.
3. It's often reported that people who are bewitched see apparitions of ghosts of murdered people at the same time that the specters of witches trouble them. These ghosts always frighten the observers more than any other spectral appearances. When they show up, they claim they were murdered by witchcraft or other violence from the people whose specters are present. It's also noted that once or twice, these apparitions have been seen by others at the same time as the bewitched people. These apparitions usually appear when something unusual or suspicious has surrounded the death of the person appearing. Some people accused by these apparitions, who had never heard of such individuals before, have confessed to the murders of those very people after a fair examination, even though they didn't know how the apparitions had accused them. Several bewitched individuals testified that they were troubled by the apparitions of two women who claimed to be G. B.'s two wives and said he was responsible for their deaths. They insisted that the magistrates must be informed, and if G. B. denied it during his trial, they might appear again in court. G. B. was notorious throughout the country for his cruel treatment of his two late wives. Additionally, it was testified that the specter of G. B. threatened the sufferers, claiming he had killed, among others, Mrs. Lawson and her daughter Ann. It was noted that these were the virtuous wife and daughter of someone G. B. might have disliked because that person was helpful in Salem Village, from where G. B. had been removed under bad terms some years before. When they died, which was long ago, there were some strange circumstances that made some of the attendants suspect witchcraft, although no one knew from where it might have originated.
Well, G. B. was now on trial, and one of the bewitched people was thrown into horror at the ghost of B's two deceased wives appearing before him and crying for vengeance against him. Following this, several of the bewitched people were called in one by one. Without knowing what the previous person had seen and said, they all agreed in their horror of the apparition, which they claimed he had before him. However, he, though very disturbed, completely denied seeing anything of it; nor was it any part of his conviction.
4. Knowledgeable writers have considered it significant evidence of witchcraft when individuals are accused by other well-known witches of being just as evil as themselves, especially if those individuals have been known for neglecting the worship of God. Now, there might have been enough evidence of G. B.'s aversion to prayer and other ordinances of God, even though he was particularly obligated to them by his profession. Additionally, there were testimonies against the prisoner from several people who confessed to being horrible witches themselves. Since their confessions, they had been terribly tortured by the devils and other witches, just like the other sufferers, and had endured the pains of many deaths for their confessions.
These witnesses testified that G. B. had been at witch meetings with them and that he was the person who had seduced and compelled them into the traps of witchcraft. They said he promised them fine clothes for doing it, brought them poppets and thorns to stick into those poppets to afflict other people, and encouraged them, along with the rest of the group, to bewitch all of Salem Village, but to make sure to do it gradually if they wanted to succeed in what they were doing.
When the Lancashire Witches were condemned, I don't remember there being any significant evidence beyond the testimony of the bewitched and some who confessed. We already see so much against G. B. But since this is not enough, there were other things to make what had already been presented believable.
5. A well-known theologian lists this among the signs of a witch: "The testimony of the person bewitched, whether suffering or dying, along with the joint oaths of credible people who have witnessed certain extraordinary acts performed by the accused." Now, God allowed this G. B. to trap himself with several examples of unnatural strength, which were now used against him. He was a very small man, yet he often did things beyond the strength of a giant. A gun with about a seven-foot barrel, so heavy that strong men could not hold it steadily with both hands; there were several credible and honorable witnesses who testified that he easily lifted such a gun by the lock with just one hand and held it out like a pistol at arm's length. G. B., in his defense, foolishly claimed, "an Indian was there, and held it out at the same time." However, none of the witnesses saw any such Indian; they suspected that the "Black Man" (as witches call the Devil, who they generally say resembles an Indian) might have helped him. There was also evidence that he effortlessly lifted whole barrels filled with molasses or cider in very awkward positions and carried them through the most difficult places from a canoe to the shore.
There were even two testimonies that G. B., by just putting the forefinger of his right hand into the muzzle of a heavy gun, a fowling-piece with a barrel about six or seven feet long, lifted the gun and held it out at arm's length. The gun was one that the witnesses believed strong men couldn't lift and hold out with both hands from the butt-end, as is usual. In fact, one of these witnesses was persuaded by some people to be absent during G. B.'s trial, but he later came back with regret for his absence and gave his testimony. Neither of these witnesses was used as evidence in the trial.
6. Several testimonies were presented regarding the domestic affairs of G. B., which painted him in a very negative light. These testimonies not only proved him to be a very bad man but also reinforced the belief in the reputation that had already been attributed to him.
It was testified that he kept his two successive wives in a strange kind of slavery. When he came home from being away, he would pretend to know the conversations they had with others. He brought them to the point of death with his harsh treatment and then made the people around him promise that if death occurred, they would say nothing about it. He used all means to make his wives write, sign, seal, and swear a covenant never to reveal any of his secrets. His wives privately complained to the neighbors about frightening apparitions of evil spirits that sometimes infested their house, and many such things were whispered among the neighborhood. There were also other testimonies related to the death of people, which convinced the consciences of an impartial jury that G. B. had bewitched the persons mentioned in the complaints. However, I am forced to omit several passages in this and all the succeeding trials because the scribes who noted them have not provided them to me.
7. One Mr. Ruck, brother-in-law to this G. B., testified that G. B., himself, and his sister, who was G. B.'s wife, went out for two or three miles to gather strawberries. Ruck and his sister, the wife of G. B., rode home very slowly, with G. B. walking on foot in their company. G. B. stepped aside a little into the bushes; whereupon they halted and called for him. He did not answer, so they went homewards at a quicker pace, not expecting to see him for a while. Yet, when they got near home, to their astonishment, they found him on foot with them, carrying a basket of strawberries. G. B. immediately began to scold his wife about what she had been saying to her brother about him on the road. When they wondered at this, he said, "He knew their thoughts." Ruck, being startled at that, made a reply, suggesting that even the Devil himself did not know so much; but G. B. answered, "My God makes known your thoughts unto me." The prisoner now at the bar had nothing to answer to what was witnessed against him that was worth considering. He only said, "Ruck and his wife left a man with him when they left him," which Ruck now affirmed to be false. When the court asked G. B. "What the man's name was?" his countenance changed significantly, and he could not say who it was. The court began to think that he stepped aside only to, with the assistance of the "Black Man," put on his "invisibility," and in that "fascinating mist," satisfy his own jealous curiosity to hear what they said about him. This trick of rendering themselves "invisible" is something our witches, in their confessions, claim they sometimes master. It is more credible because there is evidence that they often render many other things utterly "invisible."
8. Faltering, faulty, inconsistent, and contradictory answers during a judicial and deliberate examination are considered some unlucky signs of guilt in all crimes, especially in witchcraft. Now, there never was a prisoner more notable for these than G. B., both during his examination and at his trial. His evasions, contradictions, and falsehoods were very noticeable. He had little to say, except that he had heard some things he could not prove, which reflected on the reputation of some of the witnesses. He only submitted a paper to the jury, in which, although he had many times before admitted not only that there are witches but also that the current sufferings of the country are the effects of horrible witchcrafts, he now tried to prove that "there neither are, nor ever were witches, that having made a compact with the Devil, can send a devil to torment other people at a distance." This paper was transcribed from Ady, which the court immediately recognized as soon as they heard it. But he claimed he had not taken any of it from a book, for which his later excuse was that a gentleman gave him the discourse in a manuscript from which he transcribed it.
The jury found him guilty. However, when it was time for him to die, he completely denied the act for which he had been convicted.
CHAPTER 9
THE TRIAL OF BRIDGET BISHOP
The Trial of Bridget Bishop, Also Known As Oliver, at the court of oyer and terminer, Held at Salem, June 2, 1692
1. She was charged with bewitching several people in the neighborhood, with the indictment prepared in the usual manner for such cases. Pleading "Not Guilty," several people were brought in who had long suffered various kinds of miseries, which were unnaturally inflicted and generally attributed to horrible witchcraft. There was little need to prove the witchcraft, as it was evident and well-known to all who witnessed it. To connect the witchcraft to the prisoner at the bar, the first evidence used was the testimony of the bewitched. Several testified that the shape of the prisoner often grievously pinched them, choked them, bit them, and afflicted them, urging them to write their names in a book, which the specter called "Ours." One of them further testified that it was the shape of this prisoner, along with another, that one day took her from her spinning wheel and carried her to the riverside, threatening to drown her if she did not sign the mentioned book, which she refused. Others also testified that the shape threatened them, bragging that she had caused the death of several people she named and that she had "ridden" a man she also named. Another testified about the apparition of ghosts to the specter of Bishop, crying out, "You murdered us!" There was, unfortunately, too much suspicion about the truth of these matters of fact.
2. It was testified that during the examination of the prisoner before the magistrates, the bewitched individuals were extremely tortured. If she merely looked at them, they were immediately struck down, and this happened in such a way that there could be no deception involved. However, when she touched them with her hand while they were in their swoons, they would immediately revive, and this did not happen with the touch of anyone else. Moreover, with certain movements of her body, like shaking her head or turning her eyes, they would instantly and painfully fall into similar postures. Many similar incidents occurred while she was at the bar. One person at the same time testified that she said, "She could not be troubled to see the afflicted thus tormented."
3. There was also testimony presented that a man struck at the spot where a bewitched person claimed the "shape" of this bishop stood. The bewitched person cried out that he had torn her coat in the exact place she specified, and indeed, the woman's coat was found to be torn in that very spot.
4. One Deliverance Hobbs, who had confessed to being a witch, was now tormented by the specters because of her confession. She testified that this Bishop tempted her to sign the book again and to deny what she had confessed. She claimed that it was the shape of this prisoner that whipped her with iron rods to force her to do so. She also affirmed that this Bishop was at a general meeting of the witches in a field at Salem Village and participated in a diabolical sacrament of bread and wine administered there.
5. To make it even more certain that the prisoner at the bar was truly guilty of this witchcraft, many pieces of evidence of other witchcrafts committed by her were presented. For example, John Cook testified that about five or six years ago, one morning around sunrise, he was in his room when he was attacked by the shape of this prisoner. It looked at him, grinned, and hurt him with a blow to the side of his head. On the same day, around noon, the same shape appeared in the room where he was, and an apple mysteriously flew out of his hand into his mother's lap, six or eight feet away from him.
6. Samuel Gray testified that about fourteen years ago, he woke up one night and saw the room where he lay filled with light. He then clearly saw a woman between the cradle and the bedside, looking at him. He got up, and she vanished, even though he found all the doors securely closed. Looking out at the entry door, he saw the same woman in the same clothes again and said, "In God's name, what do you come for?" He went back to bed, and the same woman assaulted him again. The child in the cradle let out a loud scream, and the woman disappeared. It took a long time to calm the child, and although it was a very healthy and thriving child, from that time on, it wasted away and, after several months, died in a sad condition. He did not know Bishop or her name, but when he saw her after this, he recognized by her face, clothing, and all the circumstances that it was the apparition of this Bishop that had troubled him.
7. John Bly and his wife testified that he bought a sow from Edward Bishop, the husband of the accused. He was supposed to pay the agreed price to another person. The accused was angry because she was prevented from getting the money directly and argued with Bly. Soon after, the sow started having strange fits; it was jumping, leaping, and hitting its head against the fence. It seemed blind and deaf and would neither eat nor be suckled. A neighbor remarked that she believed the creature was "overlooked," and several other circumstances led the witnesses to believe that Bishop had bewitched it.
8. Richard Coman testified that eight years ago, while he was awake in his bed with a light burning in the room, he was troubled by the apparition of this bishop and two others who were strangers to him. They came and oppressed him so much that he couldn't move or wake anyone else. The next night, he was disturbed again in a similar manner, with the bishop grabbing him by the throat and almost pulling him out of bed. His relative offered to stay with him for this reason, and that night, as they were awake and talking, Coman was once more visited by the troublesome guests. His relative was struck speechless and unable to move. Coman had his sword by him, which the specters tried hard to take from him, but he held on too tightly for them. He then managed to call the people of his house, but although they heard him, they couldn't speak or move until finally, one of them cried out, "What's the matter?" and the specters all vanished.
9. In 1680, Samuel Shattock testified that Bridget Bishop often came to his house for trivial and foolish reasons, making them suspect she had harmful intentions. Soon after, his eldest child, who was as healthy and intelligent as any child of that age, began to become very ill. The more Bishop visited, the worse the child got. While standing at the door, the child would be thrown and bruised against the stones by an invisible force and would also hit his face against the sides of the house, causing severe bruising. Bishop would bring him things to dye, which seemed useless, and when she paid him money, the purse and money mysteriously disappeared from a locked box and were never seen again. The child then started having terrible fits, and his friends feared he would die. He mostly cried and slept for several months, and eventually, he lost his understanding completely. One sign of enchantment was that there was a board in the garden he would walk on, and no amount of persuasion could get him off it. About 17 or 18 years later, a stranger visited Shattock's house and, upon seeing the child, said, "This poor child is bewitched; and you have a neighbor living not far off, who is a witch." He added, "Your neighbor had a falling out with your wife and thought in her heart that your wife is a proud woman, and she would bring down her pride through this child." Shattock remembered that Bishop had parted from his wife with muttering and threatening words shortly before the child fell ill. The stranger insisted on taking the bewitched boy to Bishop's house under the pretense of buying a pot of cider. Bishop reacted furiously and attacked the boy, scratching his face until it bled, saying, "You rogue, why do you bring this fellow here to plague me?" It seems the man had said before he went that he would draw blood from her. After that, the boy continued to have severe fits, which doctors generally attributed to witchcraft, and he would be thrown into the fire or water if not constantly watched. It was firmly believed that Bishop was the cause of it.
10. John Louder testified that after a small argument with Bishop about her chickens, he went to bed and woke up in the night by moonlight. He clearly saw the likeness of this woman oppressing him severely, and he couldn't help himself until nearly morning. He told Bishop about this, but she denied it and threatened him a lot. Soon after, while at home on a Sunday with the doors shut, he saw a black pig approach him. When he tried to kick it, it vanished. Immediately after, as he sat down, he saw a black thing jump in through the window and stand before him. Its body was like a monkey's, its feet like a rooster's, but its face was much like a man's. He was so extremely frightened that he couldn't speak. This creature spoke to him, saying, "I am a messenger sent to you, for I understand that you are in some trouble of mind, and if you will follow my advice, you shall want for nothing in this world." He tried to grab it, but he felt no substance, and it jumped out of the window again. It immediately came in through the porch, even though the doors were shut, and said, "You had better take my counsel!" He struck at it with a stick, but only hit the ground, breaking the stick. The arm he used to strike was immediately disabled, and the creature vanished. He went out the back door and saw Bishop in her orchard, heading toward her house, but he couldn't move toward her. Returning inside, he was immediately confronted by the creature again, which was about to attack him. He cried out, "The whole armor of God be between me and you!" (Eph. 6:11). The creature sprang back, flew over the apple tree, and shook many apples off the tree as it flew over. As it leaped, it flung dirt with its feet against the man's stomach, which caused him to be struck dumb for three days. When this testimony was presented, Bishop denied knowing this witness, even though their orchards were next to each other and they had often had small quarrels for several years.
11. William Stacy testified that after receiving money from Bishop for work he did, he had only gone about three rods from her when he found the money had unaccountably disappeared. Some time later, Bishop asked him if her father would grind her grain for her. He asked why, and she replied, "Because folks count me a witch." He answered, "No question but he will grind it for you." Then, about six rods away from her with a small load in his cart, the off-wheel suddenly stumbled and sank into a hole on plain ground, forcing him to get help to recover the wheel. But when he stepped back to look for the hole that caused the disaster, there was none to be found. Some time later, he was awakened in the night, but it seemed as light as day, and he clearly saw the shape of Bishop in the room, troubling him. But when she left, it was dark again. He later accused Bishop of this, and she did not deny it but was very angry. Soon after, this deponent, having been threatened by Bishop, was suddenly lifted from the ground and thrown against a stone wall while going to the barn on a dark night. After that, he was hoisted up again and thrown down a bank at the end of his house. After this, when passing by Bishop, his horse with a small load tried to pull, but all the gears broke, and the cart fell. When he tried to lift a bag of corn weighing about two bushels, he couldn't move it with all his might.
Many other tricks of this bishop, this deponent was ready to testify. He also testified that he truly believed the said bishop was the instrument of his daughter Priscilla's death, for which he provided convincing reasons.
12. To top it all off, John Bly and William Bly testified that while they were hired by Bridget Bishop to help take down the cellar wall of the old house where she used to live, they found several poppets in holes of the old wall. These poppets were made of rags and hog bristles, with headless pins sticking outwards. She could not provide a reasonable or acceptable explanation for them to the court.
13. One thing that went against the prisoner was her being clearly caught in gross lying in the court several times while she was making her plea. Besides this, a jury of women found an unnatural teat on her body. However, upon a second search within 3 or 4 hours, there was no such thing to be seen. There was also an account of other people whom this woman had afflicted, and there could have been many more if they had been asked for, but there was no need for them.
14. There was one very strange thing more that the court was recently informed about. As this woman was under guard, passing by the large meeting-house of Salem, she glanced towards the building. Immediately, a demon invisibly entered the meeting-house and tore down a part of it. Even though no person was seen there, the people, upon hearing the noise and running in, found a board that had been strongly fastened with several nails moved to another part of the house.
CHAPTER 10
THE TRIAL OF SUSANNA MARTIN
The Trial of Susanna Martin, at the Court of Oyer and Terminer, Held by Adjournment At Salem, June 29, 1692.
1. Susanna Martin, pleading not guilty to the indictment of witchcraft brought against her, faced evidence from many people who were clearly and severely bewitched. They all accused the prisoner at the bar as the person they believed was causing their suffering. As in the other trials, there was an extraordinary effort through witchcraft, with cruel and frequent fits, to prevent the afflicted from giving their complaints. The court had to exercise much patience, waiting and watching to obtain their testimonies.
2. There was also an account given of what happened at her first examination before the magistrates. The way she looked at the afflicted people caused them to fall to the ground, whether they saw her look or not. There were these, among other exchanges, between the magistrates and the examinee.
Magistrate: Pray, what is wrong with these people?
Martin: I don't know.
Magistrate: But what do you think is wrong with them?
Martin: I don't want to give my opinion on it.
Magistrate: Don't you think they are bewitched?
Martin: No, I do not think they are.
Magistrate: Tell us your thoughts about them then.
Martin: No, my thoughts are my own when they are inside, but when they are out, they belong to someone else. Their master.
Magistrate: Their master? Who do you think is their master?
Martin: if they are involved in the Black Art, you can know just as well as I do.
Magistrate: Well, what have you done towards this?
Martin: Nothing at all.
Magistrate: Why, it's you or your appearance.
Martin: I can't help it.
Magistrate: Is it not your master? How does your appearance harm these people?
Martin: How do I know? He that appeared in the shape of Samuel, a glorified saint, may appear in anyone's shape.
It was also noted in her, as in others like her, that if the afflicted tried to approach her, they were thrown to the ground. When she was asked the reason for this, she said, "I cannot tell; it may be, the devil bears me more malice than another."
3. The Court felt alarmed by these events and decided to investigate further into the behavior of the prisoner to see if there was more evidence to support these accusations. John Allen of Salisbury testified that when he refused to cart some staves for Martin because his oxen were weak, she became displeased and said, "It had been as good that he had; for his oxen should never do him much more service." In response, the deponent said, "Dost thou threaten me, thou old witch? I'll throw thee into the brook." To avoid this, she flew over the bridge and escaped. However, as he was going home, one of his oxen got tired, forcing him to unyoke it to get it home. He then put his oxen, along with many others, on Salisbury Beach, where cattle usually gained weight. In a few days, all the oxen on the beach were found by their tracks to have run to the mouth of the Merrimack River and not returned; but the next day, they were found washed ashore on Plum Island. Those who searched for them used all imaginable gentleness, but the oxen continued to run away with a violence that seemed entirely diabolical until they reached the mouth of the Merrimack River, where they ran straight into the sea, swimming as far as they could be seen. One of them swam back with a speed that amazed the onlookers, who stood ready to receive him and help his tired body. But the beast ran furiously up into the island, then through the marshes, into Newbury Town, and into the woods, where it was eventually found near Amesbury. Out of fourteen good oxen, only this one was saved; the rest were found drowned, some in one place, some in another.
4. John Atkinson testified that he traded a cow with Susanna Martin's son, and she muttered and was reluctant for him to have it. When he went to collect the cow, even though he hamstrung and haltered her, the cow, which was usually tame, became so wild that they could hardly manage her. She broke all the ropes tied to her, and even when fastened securely to a tree, she managed to escape, causing them so much trouble that they could only attribute it to witchcraft.
5. Bernard Peache testified that while he was in bed on a Sunday night, he heard a noise at the window. He then saw Susanna Martin come in and jump down onto the floor. She grabbed his feet and pulled his body into a heap, lying on him for nearly two hours. During this time, he couldn't speak or move. Eventually, when he was able to move, he grabbed her hand and bit three of her fingers, as he thought, down to the bone. After that, she left the room, went down the stairs, and out the door. Bernard then called out to the people in the house to tell them what had happened, and he followed her. The people didn't see her, but there was a bucket to the left of the door with a drop of blood on it, and several more drops of blood on the freshly fallen snow outside. There were also the prints of her two feet just outside the threshold, but no other footprints further away.
At another time, this witness was invited by the prisoner to come to a corn husking event at her house. She said, "If he did not come, it were better that he did!" He did not go, but the following night, Susanna Martin, as he believed, and another person came towards him. One of them said, "Here he is!" but he, having a quarterstaff, swung at them. The roof of the barn stopped his swing, but as he followed them to the window, he swung again and struck them down. Yet, they got up and left, and he saw no more of them.
About this time, there was a rumor around town that Martin had a broken head, but the deponent couldn't say anything about that.
The said Peache also testified about the bewitching of the cattle to death due to Martin's discontent.
6. Robert Downer testified that this prisoner, Susanna Martin, was prosecuted in court for being a witch some years ago. He told her that he believed she was a witch. She was unhappy with this and said, "Some she-devil will shortly fetch you away!" Others heard these words as well. The following night, as he lay in bed, a figure resembling a cat came in through the window, attacked him, grabbed his throat, and almost killed him. He then remembered what Susanna Martin had threatened the day before. With much effort, he cried out, "Avoid, thou she-devil! In the name of God the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost, avoid!" At that moment, the figure left him, jumped on the floor, and flew out the window.
There were also several testimonies that, even before Downer spoke a word about this incident, Susanna Martin and her family had already described how this Downer had been treated.
7. John Kembal testified that Susanna Martin, after being upset with him for no reason, threatened him about one of his cows, saying, "That she should never do him any more good." It happened just as she said, because soon after, the cow was found dead on dry ground with no visible illness. After this, more of his cattle died under strange circumstances, and he lost thirty pounds' worth of cattle in one spring. John Kembal had even more remarkable testimony to give against the prisoner.
Wanting to get a dog, he tried to buy one from Martin, who had a female dog with puppies at her house. But since she wouldn't let him choose, he said he would get one from Blezdel's instead. After picking a puppy he liked at Blezdel's, he ran into George Martin, the prisoner's husband, who asked him if he wanted one of his wife's puppies. He replied, "No." That same day, Edmond Eliot was at Martin's house and heard George Martin talk about where Kembal had been and what he had said. Susanna Martin then said, "If I live, I'll give him puppies enough!" A few days later, as Kembal was coming out of the woods, a small black cloud appeared in the northwest, and Kembal suddenly felt a force that made him unable to avoid running into tree stumps in front of him, even though he had a clear, wide path. Despite having an ax on his shoulder that could have hurt him in his falls, he couldn't stop himself from going off the path and stumbling over them. When he got near the meeting house, a small, dark-colored thing like a puppy appeared and darted back and forth between his legs. He bravely tried to cut it with his ax but couldn't hit it. The puppy jumped away from him and seemed to disappear into the ground. A little further on, a black puppy, slightly bigger than the first and as black as coal, appeared. It moved faster than his ax, lunging at his belly and then his throat, going over his shoulder one way and then the other. His heart began to fail him, and he thought the dog would tear his throat out. But he regained his composure, called upon God in his distress, and when he named the name of Jesus Christ, it vanished instantly. He didn't speak of these events to anyone, fearing it would frighten his wife. But the next morning, when Edmond Eliot went into Martin's house, the woman asked him where Kembal was. He replied, "At home, in bed, for all he knew." She said, "They say he was frightened last night." Eliot asked, "With what?" She answered, "With puppies." Eliot asked where she heard of it, as he hadn't heard anything. She replied, "Around the town," even though Kembal hadn't mentioned the matter to anyone.
8. William Brown testified that Heaven had blessed him with a very pious and wise wife. One day, his wife met Susanna Martin, but as she got close to her, Martin vanished, leaving her extremely frightened. After that, Martin often appeared to her, causing her a lot of trouble. When Martin appeared, birds would attack her, pecking and pricking her. Sometimes, a lump like a small egg would rise in her throat, almost choking her, until she cried out, "Witch, you shan't choke me!" While this good woman was in such distress, the church appointed a day of prayer for her. As a result, her troubles ceased; she no longer saw Martin as before, and the church gave thanks for her deliverance instead of fasting. However, a considerable time later, she was summoned to give evidence in court against Martin. Shortly after, Martin came up behind her while she was milking her cow and said, "For thy defaming her at court, I'll make thee the miserablest creature in the world." Soon after this, she fell into a strange illness, became horribly frantic, and was unable to perform any reasonable actions. The physicians declared that her illness was unnatural and that some devil had certainly bewitched her, and in that condition, she remains.
9. Sarah Atkinson testified that Susanna Martin came from Amesbury to their house in Newbury during a time when it was not suitable for anyone to travel. Martin claimed to Atkinson that she walked the entire long distance on foot. She boasted and showed how dry she was, and it couldn't be seen that even the soles of her shoes were wet. Atkinson was amazed by this and said that she herself would have been wet up to the knees if she had come that far. But Martin replied, "She scorned to be drabbled!" It was noted that this testimony during her trial caused her significant confusion.
10. John Pressy testified that one evening, he became inexplicably lost near a field belonging to Martin. He kept returning to the same spot as if under a spell. Eventually, he saw a strange light about the size of half a bushel, about two rods away from the path. He went up to it and struck it with a stick, hitting it with all his strength. He hit it nearly forty times and felt it was a solid object. But as he walked away, he was tripped and fell on his back, sliding as if into a pit. He managed to recover by grabbing onto a bush, although later he couldn't find any pit in that area. After he got back on his feet and walked five or six rods, he saw Susanna Martin standing on his left, just like the light had been before, but they didn't speak to each other. He had a hard time finding his way home, but eventually, he made it back, extremely frightened. The next day, it was discovered that Martin was in a terrible state, suffering from pains and injuries.
This witness also testified that after he had given some evidence against Susanna Martin many years ago, she spoke harshly to him about it and said, "He should never prosper more;" specifically, "That he should never have more than two cows; that though he was very likely to have more, yet he should never have them." And from that very day to this, for twenty years straight, he could never have more than that number; some strange thing or another always prevented him from having any more.
11. Jervis Ring testified that about seven years ago, he was often and severely oppressed at night, but he couldn't see who was troubling him. Eventually, while lying perfectly awake, he clearly saw Susanna Martin approach him. She came to him and forcefully bit him on the finger, and the mark of the bite can still be seen on him even now, so long after.
12. But besides all of these evidences, there was a most wonderful account of one Joseph Ring, produced on this occasion.
This man has been strangely taken by demons from one witch meeting to another for nearly two years; and for one quarter of this time, they made him and kept him mute, though he is now able to speak again. There was one T. H. who, it is believed, had a plan to trap this Joseph Ring in a snare of devilry, and managed to get Ring two shillings in debt to him.
Afterward, this poor man would be visited by unknown shapes, and this T. H. was sometimes among them. They would force him away to unknown places, where he saw meetings, feasts, and dances. After his return, during which they hurried him through the air, he showed the neighbors that he had indeed been transported. When he was brought to these hellish meetings, one of the first things they did to him was to give him a knock on the back, after which he felt as if he were bound with chains, unable to move from the place until they released him. He related that a man often came to him, presenting a book for him to sign, promising that he could have whatever he wanted. The man would show him all the delightful things, people, and places he could imagine. But when he refused to sign, the encounter would end with dreadful shapes, noises, and screeches that almost scared him out of his wits. Once, with the book, there was a pen offered to him and an ink-horn with liquid in it that seemed like blood, but he never touched it.
This man now claimed that he saw the prisoner at several of those hellish gatherings.
Note, this woman was one of the most shameless, vulgar, and wicked creatures in the world; and she showed herself to be such throughout her entire trial. Yet, when she was asked what she had to say for herself, her main defense was, "that she had led a most virtuous and holy life."
CHAPTER 11
THE TRIAL OF ELIZABETH HOW
Trial of Elizabeth How at the At Salem, June 30, 1692
1. Elizabeth How pleaded not guilty to the indictment of witchcraft charged against her. The court, following the usual proceedings of the courts in England for such cases, began by hearing the depositions of several afflicted people. These individuals were grievously tortured by clear and evident witchcraft and all complained that the prisoner was the cause of their trouble. It was also found that the sufferers could not bear her look, and in their deepest swoons, they could distinguish her touch from other people's, which would raise them out of their swoons.
There was also testimony from people who were troubled by the shape of this How nine or ten years ago.
2. It has been very common for the bewitched people, while the spectres representing the witches tormented them, to also see apparitions of ghosts claiming to have been murdered by the witches being represented. Sometimes, the confessions of the witches later admitted to those very murders that these apparitions accused them of, even though they had never heard what information had been provided by the victims.
There were reports of ghost apparitions testified by some of the current sufferers, and the ghosts claimed that this How had murdered them. These things were feared but not proven.
3. This How had made some attempts to join the church at Ipswich several years ago, but she was denied admission into that holy society, partly due to a suspicion of witchcraft that was then raised against her. Testimony now came in of supernatural mischiefs soon happening to some who had been instrumental in barring her from the communion she was trying to enter.
4. Joseph Stafford testified that his wife developed an intense dislike for How after hearing reports of her witchcraft. However, one day How took her by the hand and said, "I believe you are not ignorant of the great scandal that I lie under, by an evil report raised upon me." Immediately, and without reason, like someone enchanted, Stafford's wife began to support How. When How was later proposed for admission to the Lord's Table, some of the pious brethren were not satisfied with her. The elders arranged a meeting to discuss the objections against her, and no argument could stop Goodwife Stafford from attending the lecture. She promised with difficulty not to go to the church meeting, yet she couldn't resist going there too. How's situation was discussed, and she ended up appearing more guilty than cleared. Nevertheless, Goodwife Stafford couldn't help but take her by the hand and say, "Though you are condemned before men, you are justified before God." She was soon taken in a strange manner, ranting, raving, raging, and crying out, "Goody How must come into the church; she is a precious saint; and though she be condemned before men, she is justified before God." She continued like this for two or three hours and then fell into a trance. When she came to, she cried out, "Ha! I was mistaken," and repeated it again. When asked by someone nearby, "Wherein?" she replied, "I thought Goody How had been a precious saint of God, but now I see she is a witch: She has bewitched me and my child, and we shall never be well until there is a testimony for her, that she may be taken into the church." How later said she was very sorry to see Stafford at the church meeting mentioned. After this, Stafford declared herself afflicted by the shape of How and suffered many miseries from that shape.
5. John How, the brother of the prisoner's husband, testified that when he refused to accompany the prisoner to her examination, as she had requested, some of his cattle were immediately bewitched to death. The cattle were leaping three or four feet high, turning around, making noises, falling, and dying all at once. When he went to cut off an ear for a purpose that perhaps could have been avoided, the hand holding the knife became very numb and remained painful for several days, and it was still not well at the time of his testimony. He suspected the prisoner of causing this.
6. Nehemiah Abbot testified that unusual and harmful accidents would happen to his cattle whenever he had any disagreements with this prisoner. Once, in particular, she wished his ox would choke, and shortly after, that ox choked on a turnip in its throat. At another time, after he refused to lend his horse at the request of her daughter, the horse was abused in an unnatural manner. Several other strange incidents of that kind were also testified.
7. There was testimony that a woman named Goodwife Sherwin, after having some disagreement with How, was bewitched. She died, accusing How of being involved in her death. Additionally, other people experienced their barrels of drink being mysteriously damaged, spoiled, and spilled after they displeased her.
The events themselves were minor, but because there were so many of them, they were taken more seriously. Among others, Martha Wood gave her testimony, stating that shortly after her father had been involved in gathering information about How's behavior, they repeatedly lost large amounts of drink from their containers in a way that could only be attributed to witchcraft. Additionally, she mentioned that after How gave her some apples, she experienced a very strange kind of confusion, to the point where she didn't know what she was saying or doing.
8. There was also a group of statements that one Isaac Cummings, after refusing to lend his mare to the husband of this How, found the mare in a strange condition within a day or two. The animal seemed badly treated, as if she had been running over rocks, and had marks where the bridle went, as if burned with a red-hot bridle. Moreover, when someone used a pipe of tobacco to try to cure the beast, a blue flame came out of her, caught her hair, and not only spread and burned on her, but it also flew upwards towards the roof of the barn and almost set the barn on fire. The mare died very suddenly.
9. Timothy Pearley and his wife testified that not only did unexplainable misfortunes happen to their cattle after they had disagreements with this prisoner, but they also had a daughter who was destroyed by witchcraft. This daughter consistently accused How as the cause of her suffering. It was noted that she would be struck down whenever How was mentioned. She often seemed to be thrown into the fire and water during her strange fits. Even though her father punished her for accusing How of bewitching her, she insisted, as others also testified, that she was sure of it and would die standing by it. She accused How up until her death and said, "Though How could afflict and torment her body, yet she could not hurt her soul," and, "The truth of this matter would appear when she should be dead and gone."
10. Francis Lane testified that he was hired by the husband of this How to get him a batch of posts and rails. Lane then hired John Pearly to help him. This prisoner, How, told Lane that she believed the posts and rails wouldn't work because John Pearly helped him, but if he had done it alone without Pearly's help, they might have been fine. When James How came to receive his posts and rails from Lane, How picked them up by the ends, and even though they were good and sound, they inexplicably broke off. As a result, Lane had to get thirty or forty more. When the prisoner was informed of this, she said she had told him before that it would happen because Pearly helped with them.
11. Afterwards, there came the confessions of several other penitent witches, who affirmed that this How was one of those who, with them, had been baptized by the Devil in the river at Newbury Falls. Before this, he made them kneel down by the brink of the river and worship him.
CHAPTER 12
THE TRIAL OF MARTHA CARRIER, THE "QUEEN OF HELL"
The Trial of Martha Carrier At Salem, August 2, 1692
1. Martha Carrier was accused of bewitching certain people, according to the usual form in such cases. She pleaded "Not Guilty" to her indictment. First, a considerable number of the bewitched people were brought in. They not only made the court aware of a horrid witchcraft committed upon them but also testified that it was Martha Carrier, or her shape, that grievously tormented them by biting, pricking, pinching, and choking them. It was further testified that while Carrier was being examined before the magistrates, the poor people were so tortured that everyone expected them to die on the spot. However, when Carrier was bound, they were relieved. Moreover, Carrier's look laid the afflicted people for dead, and her touch, if her eye was not on them, raised them again. These things were also seen during her trial. It was testified that when someone mentioned having their necks twisted almost around by the shape of Carrier, she replied, "It's no matter though their necks had been twisted quite off."
2. Before the trial of this prisoner, several of her own children had openly and fully confessed, not only that they were witches themselves, but that their mother had made them so. They made this confession with great signs of repentance and with much demonstration of truth. They described the place, time, and occasion; they gave an account of journeys, meetings, and mischiefs they had performed, and were very believable in what they said. However, this evidence was not presented against the prisoner in court, as there was already enough other evidence to proceed with the trial.
3. Benjamin Abbot gave his testimony that in March of the previous year, Carrier was very angry with him about laying out some land near her husband's property. In her anger, she said, "That she would stick as close to Abbot as the bark stuck to the tree; and that he should repent of it before seven years came to an end, so as Doctor Prescot should never cure him." These words were heard by others besides Abbot himself, who also heard her say, "She would hold his nose as close to the grindstone as ever it was held since his name was Abbot." Shortly after this, he developed a swelling in his foot, then a pain in his side, and was exceedingly tormented. It turned into a sore, which was lanced by Doctor Prescot, and several gallons of pus came out of it. For six weeks, it remained very bad, and then another sore developed in the groin, which was also lanced by Doctor Prescot. Another sore then developed in his groin, which was likewise cut, causing him great misery. He was brought to death's door and remained so until Carrier was taken and carried away by the constable. From that very day, he began to improve, grew better every day, and has been well ever since.
Sarah Abbot, his wife, also testified that her husband was not only afflicted in his body during this time, but also that strange, extraordinary, and unexplainable calamities befell their cattle; their deaths were such that they could not guess any natural reason for them.
4. Allin Toothaker testified that Richard, the son of Martha Carrier, had a disagreement with him and pulled him down by the hair of his head. When he got back up, he intended to strike Richard Carrier, but he fell flat on his back to the ground and couldn't move his hands or feet until he told Carrier he surrendered. Then he saw the shape of Martha Carrier leave his chest.
This Toothaker had received a wound in the wars, and he now testified that Martha Carrier told him, "He should never be cured." Just before the apprehending of Carrier, he could thrust a knitting needle into his wound, four inches deep; but shortly after she was seized, he was thoroughly healed.
He further testified that when Carrier and he sometimes argued, she would clap her hands at him and say, "He should get nothing by it," after which he several times lost his cattle to strange deaths, for which no natural causes could be given.
5. John Rogger also testified that after the threatening words of this malicious carrier, his cattle would be strangely bewitched, as was more specifically described.
6. Samuel Preston testified that about two years ago, after having some disagreement with Martha Carrier, he lost a cow in a strange, unnatural, and unusual manner. About a month after this, Carrier had another disagreement with him and told him, "He had lately lost a cow, and it should not be long before he lost another," which indeed happened. He had a thriving and well-kept cow that, without any known cause, quickly fell down and died.
7. Phebe Chandler testified that about two weeks before Martha Carrier was arrested, on a Sunday while the psalm was being sung in the church, Carrier took her by the shoulder and shook her, asking her where she lived. Chandler didn't answer, even though Carrier, who lived next door to her father's house, should have known who she was. Soon after this, while crossing the fields at different times, Chandler heard a voice she believed to be Martha Carrier's, which seemed to come from above her. The voice told her she would be poisoned within two or three days. As predicted, within that short time, half of her right hand became very swollen and painful, as did part of her face, and she couldn't explain how it happened. It remained very bad for several days, and since then, she has often experienced severe pain in her chest and has been so affected in her legs that she could hardly walk. She added that recently, while going to church in good health, Richard, the son of Martha Carrier, looked at her intently, and immediately her hand, which had previously been poisoned, began to hurt greatly, and she felt a strange burning in her stomach. She was then struck deaf and couldn't hear any of the prayer or singing until the last two or three words of the psalm.
8. One Foster, who confessed her own involvement in the witchcraft for which the prisoner was accused, affirmed that she had seen the prisoner at some of their witch meetings and that it was this Carrier who persuaded her to become a witch. She confessed that the Devil carried them on a pole to a witch meeting, but the pole broke, and as she was hanging around Carrier's neck, they both fell down. She then received an injury from the fall, from which she had not yet recovered at that time.
9. One Lacy, who also confessed her involvement in this witchcraft, now testified that she and the prisoner were once physically present at a witch meeting in Salem Village. She stated that she knew the prisoner to be a witch and to have participated in a diabolical sacrament. Lacy claimed that the prisoner was responsible for her downfall and that of her children by luring them into the devil's trap.
10. Another Lacy, who also confessed her involvement in this witchcraft, now testified that the prisoner was at the witch meeting in Salem Village, where they had bread and wine administered to them.
11. During this prisoner's trial, Susanna Sheldon, in open court, had her hands inexplicably tied together with a wheel-band so tightly that it couldn't be loosened without cutting. It was done by a specter, and the sufferer claimed it was the prisoner's specter.
Memorandum. This rampant hag, Martha Carrier, was the person about whom the confessions of the witches, including her own children, agreed that the Devil had promised her she would be "Queen of Hell."
CHAPTER 13
REMARKABLE CURIOSITIES: INVISIBILITY, APPARITIONS, AND DIABOLICAL IMITATIONS
Having completed the task given to me so far, I will continue by sharing a few of the remarkable curiosities that the witchcraft currently affecting us has presented. I will report only what is well-documented and encourage all my readers to investigate while it is still fresh and new. If any mistakes are found, they will be as willingly retracted as they were unwillingly committed.
CURIOSITY 1: THE DEVIL'S BLASPHEMOUS IMITATION OF THE CHURCH
1. It's very remarkable to see the impious and shameless imitation of divine things, which the devil foolishly attempts in several matters, as informed by the confessions of our witches and the afflictions of our sufferers.
In a conversation with the Reverend and excellent person, Mr. John Higginson, he once invited me to reflect on how the Indians who traveled from afar to settle around Mexico were, in their journey to that settlement, under the guidance of the devil. This guidance strangely imitated what the blessed God provided to Israel in the wilderness.
Acosta is our author for it, that the Devil in their idol Vitzliputzli governed that mighty nation. "He commanded them to leave their country, promising to make them lords over all the provinces possessed by six other nations of Indians, and give them a land abounding with all precious things." They went forth, carrying their idol with them, in a coffer of reeds, supported by four of their principal priests; with whom he still discoursed in secret, revealing to them the successes and accidents of their way. He advised them when to march and where to stay, and without his commandment, they moved not. The first thing they did, wherever they came, was to erect a tabernacle for their false god, which they set always in the midst of their camp, and they placed the ark upon an altar. When they, tired with pains, talked of proceeding no further in their journey than a certain pleasant stage, where they had arrived, this Devil in one night horribly killed those who had started this talk by pulling out their hearts. And so they passed on till they came to Mexico.
The Devil, who back then imitated what was in the Church of the Old Testament, now among us tries to imitate the affairs of the Church in the New Testament. The witches say that they organize themselves much like Congregational churches, and that they have a baptism, a supper, and officers among them, horribly resembling those of our Lord.
But there are many more of these bloody imitations, if the confessions of the witches are to be received; which, I admit, ought to be with very much caution.
What is their striking down with a fierce look? What is their making the afflicted rise with a touch of their hand? What is their transportation through the air? What is their traveling in spirit while their body is in a trance? What is their causing cattle to run mad and perish? What is their entering their names in a book? What is their coming together from all parts at the sound of a trumpet? What is their appearing sometimes clothed with light or fire upon them? What is their covering themselves and their instruments with invisibility? It's a blasphemous imitation of certain things recorded about our Savior, His prophets, or the saints in the kingdom of God.
CURIOSITY 2: THE MYSTERY OF INVISIBILITY
In all the witchcraft that is currently troubling us, I don't know if anything is more puzzling than the trick witches have to make themselves and their tools invisible. Witchcraft seems to be the skill of using the world's creative spirit for unlawful purposes through an alliance with evil spirits. Yet, it's surprising how the evil spirits themselves can do certain things, especially making the most solid objects invisible. I can name an ancient author who claims to show the way a person can walk around invisible, and I can name another ancient author who claims to disprove that method. But I won't speak too clearly, lest I accidentally mislead some of my readers, as the pious Hemingius did with one of his students when he recited a spell, supposedly to cure fevers, just for fun. I will say this much: the idea of achieving invisibility through any natural means currently known is, I believe, mere nonsense. How far it can be achieved through a magical sacrament is best known to the dangerous tricksters who have tried it. But our witches do seem to have mastered the trick, and this is one of the reasons I think witchcraft won't be fully understood until the day when there isn't a single witch left in the world.
There are certain people who are very dogmatic about these matters, but I'll give them only these three bones to pick.
One of our bewitched people was cruelly attacked by a spectre that, she said, ran at her with a spindle, although no one else in the room could see either the spectre or the spindle. Eventually, in her distress, she managed to grab the spectre and pulled the spindle away. As soon as it was in her hand, the other people present saw that it was indeed a real, proper iron spindle, which they knew belonged to someone. Even though they locked it up very securely, it was nonetheless inexplicably stolen by demons to cause further harm.
Another of our bewitched people was tormented by a very abusive specter, which she said appeared to her with a sheet around it. After enduring a lot of trouble from the specter's annoyance, she violently grabbed at the sheet it was wearing and tore off a corner. This corner immediately became visible to a room full of spectators—a tangible corner of a sheet. Her father, who was holding her at the time, caught it to keep what his daughter had so strangely seized. The unseen specter almost pulled his hand off in an attempt to wrest it from him; however, he still held onto it, and I suppose he still has it to show. This incident happened just a few hours ago, at the beginning of this October, in the family of one Pitman, at Manchester.
A young man delayed getting testimonials for his parents, who were being held on suspicion of witchcraft and needed him to help them. He soon faced some strange troubles. One time, an officer went to brand the horns of some cows belonging to these people. Although he had seized the cows for some of their debts, he was willing to leave them with the family for their support. The young man helped hold the cows for branding. He managed to hold the first three cows without any issue, but when the hot brand was placed on the fourth cow, he flinched and shrank back so much that he couldn't hold the cow anymore. When questioned about it later, he confessed that at the exact moment the brand touched the cow's horn, he felt the same burning brand on his own thigh. He showed the lasting marks of it to those who asked to see them.
Solve these things, and you will be a great Apollo to me.
CURIOSITY 3: JUSTICE AFTER EXECUTION: THE STRANGE DELIVERANCE OF THE AFFLICTED
If a drop of innocent blood is shed in the prosecution of the witchcrafts among us, how unfortunate we are! For this reason, I cannot express myself better than in the words of a most worthy person who lives near the center of these events: "The mind of God in these matters is to be carefully looked into, with due circumspection, so that Satan does not deceive us with his devices, as he transforms himself into an angel of light and may pretend justice while intending mischief." But on the other hand, if the storm of justice now falls only on the heads of those guilty witches and wretches who have defiled our land, how happy!
The execution of some people who have recently died has been immediately followed by a strange deliverance of others who had been in a very sad condition for many years, under the influence of unknown evil forces. I am fully convinced that many of the suicides committed here have been the result of cruel and bloody witchcraft, unleashing demons upon the unfortunate victims. It has been astonishing to me to see how a devilish witchcraft, sending demons upon them, has driven many poor people to despair and tormented their minds with such whispers of atheism and blasphemy that it has made them nearly lose their minds with terror. Some who had been long oppressed by such a spirit of infirmity have been marvelously recovered upon the death of the witches.
One woman named Whetford, about ten years ago, accused Bridget Bishop (whose trial you have read about) of stealing a spoon. Bishop threatened her very severely. Shortly after this, Whetford was in bed at night when she was visited by Bishop and another woman named Parker. They made the room light upon entering and discussed various harms they intended to inflict on her. Eventually, they pulled her out of bed and took her to the seaside to drown her. However, when she called upon God, they left her, though they expressed their anger. From that time on, poor Whetford was completely ruined and became a tempted, irritable, and unstable woman, a burden to herself and everyone around her, behaving unreasonably in many ways. She remained in this state of distraction until those women were apprehended by the authorities. Then she began to improve, and upon their execution, she was immediately and completely recovered from the ten years of madness that had afflicted her.
CURIOSITY 4: THE GHOST OF A MURDERED MAN: THE CASE OF GILES CORY
It is a great shame that we let our eyes become so clouded with emotions that we miss seeing many wonderful things where the wisdom and justice of God would be glorified. Some of these things include the frequent appearances of ghosts, which bring many old murders among us to light. Among many examples of this, I will focus on one that involved a poor man who was recently pressed to death because he refused to plead for his life. I will share an excerpt from a letter written to my honorable friend, Samuel Sewall, Esq., by Mr. Putman, for this purpose:
Last night, my daughter Ann was severely tormented by witches, threatening that she would be pressed to death before Giles Cory. But through the goodness of a gracious God, she finally had a little respite. Then, she said, a man in a winding sheet appeared to her and told her that Giles Cory had murdered him by pressing him to death with his feet. However, the devil appeared to him and made a covenant, promising him, "He should not be hanged." The apparition said God hardened his heart so that he would not listen to the advice of the court and die an easy death, because, as it said, "It must be done to him as he has done to me." The apparition also said that Giles Cory was taken to court for this, and that the jury found the murder, and that her father knew the man, and the thing happened before she was born. Now, sir, this is quite strange to us; that nobody remembered these things while Giles Cory was in prison and so often before the court. For now, everyone remembers very well (and the records of the court also mention it) that about seventeen years ago, Giles Cory kept a man in his house who was almost a natural fool. This man died suddenly. A jury was assembled for him, among whom was Dr. Zorobbabel Endicot, who found the man bruised to death and having clots of blood around his heart. The jury, several of whom are still alive, declared the man murdered; but as if some enchantment had hindered the prosecution of the matter, the court did not proceed against Giles Cory, though it cost him a great deal of money to get off. Thus the story.
The Reverend and worthy author, at the direction of His Excellency the Governor, has obliged the public by providing an account of the sufferings brought upon the country by witchcraft and of the trials which have resulted in the execution of several individuals for the same:
Upon reviewing it, we find the facts and evidence accurately reported. A perspective is given on the methods of conviction used in the proceedings of the court at Salem.
Boston, October 11, 1692. William Stoughton, Samuel Sewall.
A SWEDISH PRECEDENT: THE WITCH-TRIAL AT MOHRA
But is New England the only Christian country that has faced such diabolical troubles? No, there are other good people who have been harassed in this way, but none in circumstances more similar to ours than the people of God in Sweden. The story is a very famous one, and it comes to us in English through the sharp writing of the excellent and renowned Dr. Horneck. I will only highlight a few of the more memorable events that occurred, and where it aligns with what happened among us, my reader will understand by my inserting a word of every such thing in bold letters.
1. In the years 1669 and 1670, in Mohra, Sweden, the devils, with the help of witches, committed a most horrible outrage. Among other instances of hellish tyranny exercised there, one was that hundreds of children were usually taken from their lodgings at night to a diabolical gathering at a place they called Blockula. There, the monsters who spirited them away tempted them in all sorts of ways to associate with them. The perilous growth of this witchcraft was so alarming that people of high status began sending their children to other countries to avoid it.
2. The inhabitants had earnestly sought God through prayer, and yet their affliction continued. As a result, judges had a special commission to find and root out the hellish crew, especially because another county in the kingdom, which had been similarly troubled, was delivered upon the execution of the witches.
3. The examination began with a day of humiliation, appointed by authority. The commissioners consulted on how they might resist such a dangerous flood. The suffering children were first examined, and even though they were questioned one by one apart, their declarations all agreed. The witches accused in these declarations were then examined. At first, they stubbornly denied the accusations, but eventually, many of them honestly confessed the truth of what the children had said. They admitted with tears that the devil, whom they called Locyta, had stopped their mouths. But now that he was gone from them, they could no longer conceal the matter. The things they acknowledged remarkably agreed with what other witches in other places had confessed.
4. They confessed that they used to call upon the Devil, who would then carry them away over the tops of houses to a green meadow, where they gave themselves to him. One of them said that sometimes the Devil only took away her strength, leaving her body on the ground; but at other times, she went in body too.
5. Their method was to enter people's rooms and take away their children on beasts provided by the Devil, promising fine clothes and other nice things to entice them. They said they never had the power to do this until recently, but now the Devil would plague and beat them if they didn't please him with this mischief. They claimed to use all sorts of instruments in their journeys—men, beasts, and posts. The men were usually put to sleep at the place where they were taken, and if the children mentioned the names of those who took them, they were severely whipped for it, sometimes to the point of death. The judges found the marks of the lashes on some of them, but the witches said, "They would quickly vanish." Moreover, the children would have strange fits after they were brought home from these transportations.
6. The first thing they said they had to do at Blockula was to give themselves to the Devil and vow to serve him. They would cut their fingers and write their names in his book with blood. He also had them baptized by priests he had in this horrid company. In some of them, the mark of the cut finger was found. They said that the Devil gave food and drink to them and to the children they brought with them. Afterwards, their custom was to dance before him and swear and curse most horribly. They said the Devil showed them a great, frightful, cruel dragon, telling them, "If they confessed anything," he would unleash that great Devil upon them. They added that the Devil had a church, and when the judges were coming, he told them, "He would kill them all"; and that some of them had attempted to murder the judges, but could not.
7. Some of the children talked a lot about a "White Angel" who would often forbid them from doing what the Devil had told them to do. This angel would assure them that these events would not last long and that what had happened was allowed because of the wickedness of the people. This "White Angel" would sometimes rescue the children from joining the witches.
8. The witches confessed to many harmful acts they committed, explaining the types of enchanted tools they used for their mischiefs. They particularly tried to kill the minister of Elfdale but were unsuccessful. However, some of them mentioned that those they wounded would recover before or by the time of their execution.
9. The judges wanted to see them perform some of their tricks, but they all declared together that since they had confessed, they found all their witchcraft gone. The devil then appeared very terrifying to them, threatening to thrust them into a burning pit with an iron fork if they continued with their confession.
10. There were discovered no less than seventy witches in one village, twenty-three of whom freely confessed their crimes and were condemned to die. The rest, one pretending she was with child, were sent to Fahluna, where most of them were later executed. Fifteen children, who confessed themselves engaged in this witchery, died like the rest. Thirty-six of them, between nine and sixteen years of age, who had been less guilty, were forced to run the gauntlet and be lashed on their hands once a week for a year; twenty more who had less inclination to these infernal enterprises were lashed with rods upon their hands for three Sundays in a row at the church door. The number of the seduced children was about three hundred. This course, together with prayers in all the churches throughout the kingdom, resulted in the deliverance of the country.
11. The highly accomplished Dr. Horneck includes a very wise caution in his preface to this narrative. He says, "There is no public calamity, but some ill people will serve themselves of the sad providence, and make use of it for their own ends; as thieves when a house or town is on fire, will steal what they can." He mentions a remarkable story of a young woman in Stockholm in the year 1676, who accused her own mother of being a witch and swore positively that her mother had carried her away in the night. The poor woman was burned for it, professing her innocence to the very end. But even though she had been a bad woman, it later proved that she was not a witch. Her daughter came to the judges with terrible lamentations, confessing that she had wronged her mother out of wicked spite against her. As a result, the judges ordered the daughter's execution as well.
But enough about these things. And now, Lord, make these labors of your servant profitable to your people.
A NOTE ON WHAT WAS OMITTED FROM THE TRIALS
Nineteen witches have been executed in New England. One of them was a minister, and two more ministers are accused. There are a hundred more witches in prison, some of whom have escaped, and about two hundred more are accused. Some men of great wealth in Boston have been accused of witchcraft. The hundred now in prison, accused of being witches, were committed by fifty of their own, some from Boston, but most from around Salem and the nearby towns. Mr. Increase Mather has published a book about witchcraft, prompted by the recent trials of witches, which will soon be printed in London by John Dunton.
UNDERSTANDING THE DEVIL'S DEVICES: AN ANALYSIS OF TEMPTATION
"We are not ignorant of his devices." - 2 Cor. 2:11
Our Blessed Savior has given us advice as wholesome and necessary as any that can be given, in Matthew 26:41: "Watch and pray, that you do not enter into temptation." Just as there is a tempting flesh and a tempting world that would lead us away from our obedience to the laws of God, there is also a busy devil, who is notably called "The Tempter," because he manages the temptations of the flesh and the world.
It is not just one devil that has the cunning or power to use the multitude of temptations that daily divert mankind from serving God. No, the high places of our air are swarming with those wicked spirits whose temptations trouble us. There are so many that it seems like no less than a legion, or more than twelve thousand, may be spared for the torment of one miserable person. But because these fallen angels are all united under one infernal monarch in their plans of mischief, they are spoken of in the singular. Now, the devil, whose malice and envy prompt him to do what he can to make us as unhappy as himself, usually uses more fraud than force in attacking us. He who attacked our first parents in a serpent will still act like a serpent, rather than a lion, in pursuing his wicked purposes upon us. Guarding against the wiles of the wicked one is one of the greatest responsibilities with which our God has charged us.
We are all subject to various temptations every day, which, if we let them lead us away from the straight paths of righteousness, cause us all sorts of harm. Regarding temptations, I might say, as the wise man said about mortality, "there is no discharge from that war." The devils attacked both Adams fiercely, and none of their descendants should expect to be exempt. Even the Son of God Himself had this dog of hell barking at Him; much more, then, should the children of men expect to be visited in this way. Indeed, there is hardly any temptation that is not common to man. When I was considering how to spend one hour in raising a most effective and profitable defense against the attacks of this enemy, I realized it could be done by a short answer to this.
CASE
What are those usual methods of temptation with which the powers of darkness assault the children of men?
The Corinthians, following the Apostle's guidance, excommunicated a member of their community who had married his mother-in-law, and it's believed this happened while his own father was still alive. The Apostle encourages them to welcome the man back after he showed deep and sincere repentance. He provides several reasons for suggesting this, one of which is "lest Satan should get advantage of us" (2 Cor. 2:11). If the man had faltered under the harshness of the continued sentence after his repentance, it's likely the church itself might have quickly fallen apart; certainly, the success of the Gospel would have been significantly hindered. The Apostle, on this occasion, suggests that Satan has his "devices," meaning tricks or schemes used to deceive those who are targeted by them. But what can we do to achieve this level of understanding like the Corinthians, so that "we are not ignorant of Satan's devices?"
The Devil truly has "a thousand ways to harm," and it would be impossible for us to cover all the strategies and tactics of our adversary. I will only make a few observations on the temptations of our Lord Jesus Christ, who was "tempted in all things like us, except in our sins." When we read about the temptations of our Lord Jesus Christ in the fourth chapter of Matthew, you will understand what was once considered so difficult: "the way of a serpent on a rock." There are certain ancient and well-known methods that the Devil often uses in his temptations. This is not due to any lack of creativity or laziness on the Devil's part, but because he has found these methods to be effective. How did the Devil attack the first Adam? It was with temptations drawn from pleasure, profit, and honor, which, as the Apostle notes in (1 John 2:16), are "all that is in the world." The Devil used the very same temptations on the second Adam as well. In these temptations, you will see the more common methods the Devil uses to ensnare us. I urge you to pay attention to the following warnings, as your soul's life depends on heeding them.
There were especially three remarkable assaults of temptations, which the Devil, it seems, visibly made upon our Lord; after he had been more invisibly tempting that Holy One for forty days together. We may make a few distinct remarks upon them all.
The first of our Lord's three temptations is described in (Matt. 4:3). He was hungry, and when the tempter came to him, he said, "If you are the Son of God, command that these stones be made bread."
From this, consider these remarks:
1. The Devil will usually use our circumstances as opportunities for his temptations. When our Lord was hungry, the temptation was all about "Bread! Bread!" The Devil tried to make Him take a wrong step to get bread. Every condition we face comes with some kind of hunger, and the Devil notices what we are hungry for. One person's situation might make them hunger for promotions or jobs, another for money, land, or business; someone else might hunger for fun or distractions. Every afflicted person hungers impatiently for relief. The Devil will tailor his temptations to match our circumstances. When he sees our situation working in his favor, he thinks, "I am sure this person will now listen to my proposals!" Therefore, if people are prosperous, the Devil will tempt them to forget God; if they are in adversity, he will tempt them to complain against God. Wise Agur was aware of this; in Proverbs 30:9, he says that if a person is full, they might be tempted "to deny God, and say, who is the Lord?" If a person is poor, they might be tempted "to steal, and take the name of God in vain." The Devil will speak accordingly; if you consider your circumstances, you can expect to be tempted in ways that match them.
2. The Devil often uses our necessities to tempt us. He tempted our Lord by saying, "You need bread, and you'll starve if you don't get it my way." The Devil will show us something forbidden and argue that, like bread, "it must be had." *Necessity* has a powerful influence. You can see what *necessity* can do if you read in Deuteronomy 28:56: "the tender and delicate woman among you, her eye shall be evil towards the children that she shall bear, for she shall eat them for want of all things." The Devil will persuade us that there is a *necessity* for doing what he suggests; and then, even if God's *laws* were like stone *walls* around us, we would break through them all. The small inconvenience of having to beg for our *bread*—oh, what a terrifying picture the Devil paints of it! Once the Devil scares us into thinking a sinful thing *must be done*, we quickly come to believe *it may be done*. When the Devil convinces us that something is *needful*, he immediately engages all our soul's faculties to prove it may be *lawful*. The Devil told Esau, "You'll die if you don't sell your birthright"; the Devil told Aaron, "You'll have all the people against you if you don't support their superstitions"; and they complied immediately. Sometimes, if the Devil merely pretends there is a necessity, he wins people's hearts. He only pretended there was a need when he told Saul, "the cattle must be spared, and the sacrifice must be rushed," and he only pretends there is a need when he tells many people, "if you do no work on the Sabbath day, and if you don't rob God of his evening, you'll never survive in the world." All the denials of God in the world often come from this deception imposed on us. It can never be necessary for us to violate any negative commandment in God's law; where God says, "thou shalt not," we cannot reply, "I must." But the Devil will put a terrifying and astonishing face of necessity on many *abominable things, which are hateful to the soul of God*. He'll say nothing about the one thing needful, but he'll present the trivial and insignificant *need-nots* of this world with the most alarming colors of *necessity*. He will not say, "it's necessary for you to maintain the favor of your God, and secure the welfare of your soul"; but he'll say, "it's necessary for you to get along with your neighbors, and that you and yours may have a good living among them."
3. The Devil introduces his most terrible temptations under the guise of friendship and kindness. He seemed very concerned that our Lord should not lack anything comforting; but he was still a Devil! The Devil flatters our Mother Eve, as if he wanted to make her happier than her Creator did; but that flattery was from the Devil. To deceive under the name of a friend, to greet people with offers to do all kinds of service for them, and at the same time to stab them as Joab did to Abner long ago; this is just like the Devil, and the Devil truly has many children who imitate him in this. Some very affectionate things were once spoken to our Lord: "Lord, be it far from thee, that thou shouldest suffer any trouble!" But our Lord's answer was, "Get thee behind me, Satan" (Matt. 16:23). The Devil will say to a person, "I would have thee to consult thy own interest, and I would have trouble to be far from thee." He speaks these pleasant things through the mouths of our professed friends, just as he did through the tongue of a deceitful snake to our deluded parents at the beginning. But all the while, it is wisely advised: "When he speaks fair, believe him not, for there are seven abominations in his heart."
4. Things that are in themselves allowable and convenient can often become serious temptations by the Devil. He tempted our Lord to make bread; this very act was later performed by our Lord in the miracles of the loaves. Yet, at that moment, it was a suggestion from the Devil: "Pray, make yourself a little bread." The Devil often distracts us from doing a timely duty by urging us to do another duty, which may be very untimely at that moment. As it is said in Ecclesiastes 8:5, "A wise man's heart discerns both time and judgment." The poor timing of good things is one of the main strategies the Devil uses. The Devil himself will push us towards many duties, but why? Because at that time, a more appropriate and useful duty might be neglected. Thus, there are many things where we can say, even if only this much, "They are lawful ones," by which lawful things we all perish. Where do we find the Devil has set our most fatal traps? Truly, our traps are on the bed, where it is lawful for us to sleep; at the table, where it is lawful for us to sit; in the cup, where it is lawful to drink; and in the shops, where we have lawful business to do. The Devil will lure us to the very edge of the liberty that is lawful for us, and then one little push hurries us into a transgression against the Lord. By inviting us to a lawful thing at the wrong time, the Devil entangles us further in guilt before God. It is lawful for people to use recreations, but in the evening of the Lord's Day or the morning of any day, how ensnaring they are! The Devil often takes part in the sport. If promiscuous dancing were lawful, though almost all the Christian churches in the world have made a scandal of it, for people to go directly from a sermon to a dance is to do something that the Devil surely profits from.
5. To distrust God's providence and protection is one of the worst things the Devil tries to push us into through his temptations. He tried to make our Lord doubt God's care for Him, saying, "You may die from lack of bread if you don't take care of yourself better than God will." It's common for people to despair of God's fatherly care for them; they worry themselves with fears that they will be in need before they die. They even say with Jonah, "I am cast out of the sight of God; He won't look after me!" (Jonah 2:4). But it's the Devil who is the author of such melancholy thoughts in people's minds. Married people often worry when their responsibilities increase, thinking, "God will never be able to feed and clothe all my little ones in the way of my calling." Aged people are often tormented with the thought, "Though God has supplied me all my days, I shall face hardships before my journey ends." It's a malicious Devil that raises these evil suspicions in people's hearts. Sometimes, a physical illness provides a place for the Devil to launch cruel and fiery thoughts into many people's minds. The Devil chooses to persecute us with such thoughts because by questioning God's care, we forfeit it, until perhaps the Devil utterly drowns us in destruction. Our God says, "Trust in the Lord, and do good; so shalt thou dwell in the land, and verily thou shalt be fed" (Ps. 37:3). But the Devil says, "Don't trust in God; be afraid you won't be fed," and thus he hinders people from doing good.
6. When we face temptations from the Devil, it's common for him to make us doubt our adoption as God's children because of our afflictions. When our Lord was in need, the Devil said, "If you are the Son of God," turning it into a question. "What? The Son of God and can't even command a piece of bread?" Similarly, when we are in difficult situations, the Devil will suggest, "You are not a child of God." The Bible says in Hebrews 12:7, "If you endure chastening, God deals with you as with sons; for what son is there whom a father does not chasten?" Since the Devil can't take away our grace, he tries to take away our joy. After accusing us to God, he then accuses God to us. When Israel was weak and tired in the wilderness, Amalek attacked them; in the same way, the Devil attacks God's people when their losses, troubles, and challenges have weakened their souls. And what does the Devil say? The same thing whispered to the afflicted Job: "Is not this the uprightness of your ways? Remember, I pray you, who ever perished being innocent? If you were a child of God, He would never follow you with such signs of His displeasure." This is the Devil's logic, and it disrupts the patience and cheerfulness with which we should endure the will of God.
7. The Devil often tempts us to question the divine origin and authority of God's Word. God had just declared from Heaven to our Lord, "This is my Beloved Son," but now the Devil tries to create doubt by saying, "If you are the Son of God." The Devil isn't bold enough to openly say, like Pharaoh, "Who is the Lord, that I should obey his voice?" Instead, he whispers to us, just as he did to our mother Eve long ago, "It is not the Lord who has spoken what you call His Word." The Devil wants us to say to the Scripture what was said to the Prophet in (Jer. 43:2), "You speak falsely; the Lord our God has not sent you to speak what you say to us." He tries to plant secret and cursed doubts in our hearts that things aren't exactly as the Scripture represents them. The Devil would love to burn all the Bibles in the world, and he has millions of persecutors to help him suppress this miraculous book. It was the Devil, speaking through a Papist, who once cried out, "A plague on this Bible; this is what causes all our trouble." But since he can't suppress this book, he tries to disgrace it as much as possible. Even though the Scripture carries its own evidence and is so pure, great, true, and powerful that it could only come from God, the Devil wants to discredit it as if it were just a human invention. The Devil desires nothing more than for us not to consider Christ so precious, Heaven so glorious, Hell so dreadful, and sin so odious as the Scripture declares.
The second of our Lord's three temptations is described in this way in (Matt. 4:5-6): "Then the Devil took him to the Holy City and set him on the pinnacle of the temple. He said to him, 'If you are the Son of God, throw yourself down; for it is written, He will command his angels concerning you, and on their hands they will bear you up, so that you will not strike your foot against a stone.'"
From which take these remarks:
1. The places of the greatest holiness will not protect us from the temptations of the Devil, leading to the greatest wickedness. When our Lord was in the Holy City, the Devil attacked him there. Indeed, there is no specific holiness of places in our days; the signs and means of God's more special presence are not tied to any certain places under the Gospel. Nevertheless, there are places where we often experience much of God; and although God does not visit people for the sake of the places, he visits the places for the sake of the people. But, I must tell you that the Devil will visit those places and the best people there. No place, that I know of, has a spell on it that will always keep the Devil out. The meeting-house where we gather for the worship of God is filled with many holy people and many holy concerns continually; but if our eyes were as refined as the servant of the prophet had his of old, I suppose we would now see a throng of devils in this very place. The Apostle has suggested that angels come in among us; there are angels, it seems, that listen to how I preach and how you hear at this hour. And our own sad experience is enough to suggest that the devils are also gathering here. It is reported in Job 1:6, "Now there was a day when the sons of God came to present themselves before the Lord, and Satan came also among them." When we are in our church assemblies, oh, how many devils do you imagine crowd in among us! There is a devil that rocks one to sleep, there is a devil that makes another think of things he barely understands himself; and there is a devil that makes another indulge in wanton and wicked thoughts. It is also possible that we have our closets or our studies gloriously filled with devotions every day; but alas, can we shut the Devil out of them? No, wherever we go, we will still find a Devil near us. Only when we come to Heaven will we be out of his reach forever; "O thou foul Devil; we are going where thou canst not come!" He was driven out of Paradise and shall never enter it again. Yes, more than that, when the New Jerusalem comes down into the high places of our air, from which the Devil will then be banished, there shall be no Devil within the walls of that Holy City. "Amen, Even so Lord Jesus, Come quickly."
2. The Devil's temptations will allow any acknowledgment of the Lord Jesus Christ, as long as the true and complete acknowledgment of Him is prevented. Why did the Devil take Jesus to the top of the Temple? It wasn't just to find cliffs; any part of the wilderness would have had those. No, it was to have spectators. Why? Because the carnal Jews expected Elijah to fly from Heaven to the Temple, and the Devil seemed willing for Jesus to be seen as Elijah by the crowd, or anything else, no matter how significant, rather than being received as the Christ of God. The Devil will let his followers think highly of Jesus, but he doesn't want them to think of everything. We read in Colossians 1:19, "For it pleased the Father that in Him all the fullness should dwell." But the Devil wants us to deny some of the immense fullness in our Lord. The Devil would confess to Jesus, "Thou art the Holy One of God!" but then adds, "Thou art Jesus of Nazareth," which was to hide Jesus being from Bethlehem, and thus being the true Messiah. All the heresies and persecutions that have troubled the Church of God have aimed to attack some glory of our Lord Jesus Christ. A Christ fully acknowledged will save the souls of those who acknowledge Him; but, says the Devil, "Whatever happens, I must not allow that." It's said that the Devil makes witches unable to say the entire Lord's Prayer or some religious system without some corruption; similarly, the Devil will let us make a large confession of Jesus Christ, but he will have us corrupt it, at least in one important article. Some honor, some office, and some ordinance of the Lord Jesus Christ must always be left unacknowledged by those who follow the Devil's wishes.
3. High positions in the Church of God expose people to intense and unique temptations from the Devil. When our Lord was on the pinnacle, not the spire, but the battlements of the Temple, the Devil troubled Him with special challenges, intending to ensnare both the Jews and our Lord. Believe me, those who stand high cannot stand safely. The Devil is like Nimrod, a mighty hunter, and ordinary or small targets won't satisfy him. He is a Leviathan, of whom it is said, "He beholds all high things" (Job 41:34). People with high achievements and those with high roles in the Church of God must expect, like Peter, to be more sifted, and like Paul, to be more buffeted than others. "Lightning strikes the highest mountains." The Devil can raise a storm when God allows it, but for those who stand near Heaven, the Devil will attack them with his most severe storms of thunder and lightning. It was said, "Let him that standeth take heed," but we may say, "Those who stand most high have the most reason to be cautious." The Devil is like Goliath, and when he finds a champion, he will fiercely combat such a person. He aims to "kill many birds with one stone," knowing he can prevent much good and cause much harm if he can ensnare a person in a prominent position. This is why the ministers of God are more pursued by the Devil than others, especially those ministers who are in the highest sphere of service and, most of all, those who have spent many years in commendable efforts to be helpful. These ministers are the stars of Heaven, at which the tail of the Dragon will deliver the most sweeping and stinging blows; the Devil will find ways to make them walk cautiously all their days. These are the people who have troubled and vexed the Devil more than others, for which the Devil holds a long-standing grudge against them. Oh, neighbors, you may not realize the dark days of mourning, fasting, and praying before the Lord that a raging Devil brings into the lives of such men of God.
4. The Devil will deceitfully and unfaithfully use the Scriptures to make his temptations more powerful. When the Devil tempted our Lord to do something wrong, he quoted the 91st Psalm to Him, although he deceitfully left out a very important part of it. The Devil is most dangerous when he uses our own weapon against us. We have the weapon described in Ephesians 6:17, "The sword of the Spirit, which is the word of God," to defend ourselves. But when the Devil uses that very weapon against us, he causes great harm. When the Devil wants to poison people with false doctrines, he'll quote Scriptures for them; even a Quaker will often refer to the first chapter of John. When the Devil wants to persuade people to commit vile actions, he'll quote Scriptures for them; he'll encourage people to continue in sin by showing them where it says, "The Lord is ready to pardon." I say this: the story of David's fall in the Scripture has been used by the Devil as a tool for the damnation of many millions. The Devil will scare people away from doing things that are for their peace; but how? He'll turn a Scripture into a scarecrow for them. The Devil will frighten them away from constant prayer to God by quoting the Scripture, "The sacrifice of the wicked is an abomination to the Lord" (Prov. 15:8); the Devil will frighten them away from the Holy Supper of God by quoting the Scripture, "He that eats and drinks unworthily, eats and drinks damnation to himself" (1 Cor. 11:29). In this way, the Devil will use some misused Scripture to terrify the children of God; the Scripture is written, as we are told, "for our comfort" (Rom. 15:4); but it is quoted by the Devil, "for our terror." How many godly souls have been cast into sinful doubts and fears by the Devil's foolish interpretations of that Scripture, "He that doubts is damned" (Rom. 14:23); and that, "the fearful shall have their portion in the burning lake" (Rev. 21:8). The Devil sometimes plays the preacher, but I say, beware all foolish souls when such a fool is preaching.
5. Grievous and intense urges to commit self-murder are among the significant outrages the Devil inflicts upon us through his temptations. Why did the Devil say to our Lord, "Cast yourself down," if not in hopes that our Lord would have broken his bones in the fall? The Devil is an old murderer, and he loves to murder people, but no murder gives him as much satisfaction as when people, under his influence, commit it upon themselves. We see that those who are bewitched and possessed by the Devil quickly lay violent hands upon themselves if they are not watched continually. We also see that when people have begun the unnatural act of killing themselves, there is a preternatural, stupendous, and prodigious assistance given by the Devil. When people are about to harm themselves, we call upon them, like those who spoke to the jailer in Acts 16:28, "Do yourself no harm!" And we have this argument for it: "It is the Devil dragging you to this mischief; but will you believe, will you obey someone like the Devil?" What caused Judas to strangle himself? We read it was when the Devil was in him. I suppose there are few self-murderers who have not first fallen strangely into the Devil's hands; possibly, it's through some extraordinary discontent against God or backsliding from Him that the Devil first enters those disturbed souls. Indeed, some very great saints of God have sometimes had hideous turmoil raised by the Devil in their minds until they have cried out with Job, "I choose strangling rather than life" (Job 7:15). Sometimes, the ill humors or vapors in the bodies of such good people harbor the Devil, leading to the woeful motion every day: "You must kill yourself! You must! You must!" But it is rarely anyone other than a Saul, an Abimelek, an Achitophel, or a Judas; rarely anyone other than a very reprobate, whom the Devil can drive, while the person is compos mentis, to consummate such a villainy. Indeed, no child of God in their right senses can go so far in this impiety as to be left without time and room for true repentance of the crime; it's done by none but those who go to the Devil. A self-murder, committed by someone who is otherwise a reasonable person, is an attempt of revenge upon the God who made them, which only someone full of the Devil can be guilty of. If any of you are being dragged by the Devil to murder yourselves, my advice to you is: disclose it, reveal it, make it known immediately. One who cut his own throat among us expired crying out, "O that I had told! O that I had told." You may spoil the Devil if you tell what he is doing.
6. The Devil tries to tempt us into presumptuous and unwarranted trials of God. This is what the Devil attempted with our Lord, trying to make Him "tempt the Lord our God." God commands us in Deuteronomy 6:16, "You shall not tempt the Lord your God." However, the Devil tries to make us test God in sinful ways, questioning whether God is truly who He says He is. In the ways of obedience, God invites us to "prove Him" and see if He will be true to His word. But there are ways of presumption where the Devil wants us to test what kind of God we are dealing with. The Devil tempts us to test God's purpose for ourselves or others by consulting astrologers or fortune tellers, or even by randomly opening the Bible to see the first sentence we find. The Devil wants us to test God's mercy by recklessly putting ourselves in danger without any real reason. He wants us to test God's power by expecting good things without using the means to obtain them. He tempts us to test God's justice by sinning in secret, thinking God will never expose us. He wants us to test God's promises by limiting God to certain ways of revealing Himself, or else believing nothing at all. He tempts us to test God's threats by continuing in disobedience, for which "the wrath of God comes upon the children of disobedience" (Eph. 5:6). In these ways, the Devil wants us to challenge the majesty of Heaven every day.
7. The temptations of the Devil aim to puff us up with pride, perhaps more than any other sin. The Devil wanted our Lord to make a vain and glorious display of Himself to the world by flying in the air, something no mortal can do. The Devil wants us to soar high, not only to be above other people but also to know that we are. Pride is the Devil's own sin, and he especially wants to be the king over the children of pride. It's a warning in 1 Timothy 3:6: a pastor must not be a novice, "lest being lifted up with pride, he fall into the condemnation of the Devil" (1 Tim. 3:6). (Let us young ministers read this text with utmost reverence and piety!) Accordingly, the Devil wants us to be excessively taken with the excellencies God has given us. If our wealth increases, he wants our spirits to rise too. If we have been blessed with beauty, education, honor, success, attire, spiritual privileges, or praiseworthy achievements, the Devil says, "Think yourself better than other men." The Devil even wants us to claim excellencies we never actually had and boast of a false gift. He wants us to thirst for applause from others who see our excellencies and be impatient if we are not considered important. He also wants us to aspire to a status that God has not deemed fit for us and push ourselves into a high position that doesn't suit us. The Devil wants to elevate us into the air above our neighbors, and why? So that we may suffer such falls that make us cry out with David, "O my bones are broken with my falls!" The Devil can't stand to see people lying in the dust because there's no falling from there. Being a fallen spirit himself, he takes pleasure in seeing the falls of men.
The third of our Lord's three temptations is described in these terms (Matt. 4:8-9): "Again the devil took him up to an exceedingly high mountain and showed him all the kingdoms of the world and their glory. And he said to him, 'All these things I will give you if you will fall down and worship me.'" From this, consider these remarks.
1. The Devil in his temptations will present the pleasures of this world to us, but he'll put a fair and false varnish on those pleasures. He has some unknown methods, both for distorting the view and for magnifying the object, which allowed him to give our Lord a view of the entire Roman Empire at once. But what was it? It was the world and its glory; he doesn't mention the world and its troubles. No, certainly not; the Devil won't expose his hook so plainly to us. The Devil highlights the delights of sin that he offers us with exaggerated and elevated rhetoric, but he won't admit, "Even in laughter the heart may ache, and the end of joy may be grief" (Proverbs 14:13). There is only one lens in the spectacles with which the Devil wants us to read those passages in Ecclesiastes 11:9: "Rejoice, O young man, in your youth, and let your heart cheer you in the days of your youth, and walk in the ways of your heart, and in the sight of your eyes." This far, the Devil wants us to read, and he'll make many a fine comment on it; he'll tell us that if we follow the ways of the world, we will enjoy all its delights. But he doesn't want you to read the next words: "But know that for all these things God will bring you into judgment" (Eccles. 11:9). Oh, he's reluctant for us to be aware of the dreadful consequences and reckonings that our worldly delights will bring. He sets before us "the pleasures of sin," but he won't say, "These are but for a season" (Heb. 11:25). He sets before us "the sweet waters of stealth," but he won't say, "There is death in the pot" (2 Kings 4:40). He is a charlatan who will offer nothing but exaggerated praises for all that he tempts us with.
2. There are extremely hellish blasphemies often whispered by the temptations of the Devil into the minds of the best people alive. What a most horrible thing was presented to our Lord Himself: even to acknowledge the Devil as God! A thing that cannot be spoken without indescribable horror of soul. The best person on earth may have such fiery darts from Hell shot into their mind. Someone influenced by the Devil had the audacity to suggest this to a good man like Job, "Curse God." The Devil enjoys choosing the hearts of good people with his vile suggestions, "That there is no God," or, "That God is not a righteous God," and a thousand more such things, too devilish to mention. A good person is extremely grieved when they hear blasphemy from another person's mouth; as the Psalmist said in Psalm 44:15-16, "My confusion is continually before me, for the voice of him that blasphemes." But much more when a good person finds blasphemy in their own heart; it throws them into feverish agonies of soul. For this reason, a mischievous Devil will infest the heart of such a person with blasphemous thoughts, making them cry out, "Lord, I am even weary of my life." Yes, the Devil treats the person just as Joseph's mistress dealt with him; he pressures the person to think wickedly from day to day, and if the person refuses, he eventually cries out, "Behold, what wicked thoughts this person has lodging in them." Do you say so, Satan? No, they are your own traps; and they shall forever be laid at your door alone.
3. There is a type of witchcraft in the things that the Devil's temptations would lure us into. To worship the Devil is witchcraft, and our Lord was tempted to sin under that idea. We are told in 1 Samuel 15:23, "Rebellion is as the sin of witchcraft." When the Devil wants us to sin, he wants us to do the things that the lost witches do. Perhaps there are few people ever tempted by the Devil into an explicit covenant with him. If any among us are, my advice is that you drive the Devil away with words like the Psalmist had, "Be gone, depart from me, you evil doers, for I will keep the commandments of my God." But unfortunately, most people are led by the Devil to do things that are similar to the worst practices of witches. The Devil says to the sinner, "Despise your baptism, and all the bond of it, and all the good of it." The Devil says to the sinner, "Come, cast off the authority of God, and refuse the salvation of Christ forever." Yes, the Devil, who is called "the god of this world," would have us take him for our God, and rather hear him, trust him, and serve him than the God who formed us.
4. The temptations of the Devil are focused on getting the rulers of the world to pay homage to him. Our Lord has been promised by His Father that one day He will be the ruler of the nations. The Devil is extremely afraid of the coming of that glorious time when the Kingdom of God will come and His will be done on earth as it is in heaven (Matt. 6:10). Because of this, he wanted our Lord to accept the kingdom from him, which Antichrist later accepted, to establish devil-worship in the world. I can tell you, the Devil is very unwilling to have even one godly magistrate on the earth. The influence of government is such that the Devil will strongly interfere to have it on his side. What kind of rulers would the Devil want to command all mankind if he could choose? The kind described in Psalm 94:20: "The throne of iniquity, which frames mischief by a law"; rulers who promote vice through both tolerance and example, and who oppress all that is holy, just, and good. Therefore, everyone should be cautious about how the Devil might use them in matters of government. But rulers, in particular, should consider that the Lord Jesus from heaven calls upon them, saying, "Satan has desired that he might sift you and have you; O look to it, what side you take."
In the temptations of our Lord, you have seen the main strategies the Devil uses to trap our souls. But what can we do to protect ourselves against these strategies? Oh, how I wish we could be equipped with the whole armor of God! However, I believe there are certain aspects of our Lord's temptations that particularly suggest these few tips for our protection.
First, if you don't like temptation, don't seek out unnecessary or excessive isolation. Where did the Devil confront our Lord? It was when He was alone in the wilderness. We should all have times to be alone every day; and if the Devil tries to scare us out of our rooms with the threat that he'll appear to us, stay there despite his threats, stay to finish your prayers; he lies, he doesn't dare show himself. But on the other hand, by being too solitary, we might make ourselves too vulnerable to the Devil; you know who says, "Woe to him that is alone" (Eccl. 4:10).
Secondly, let a word from God be your defense against a temptation from Hell. How did our Lord silence the Devil? It was with, "It is written!" And all his three citations were from the Book of Deuteronomy. What a full armory we have, then, in all the sacred pages that lie before us! Whatever the words of the Devil are, drown them with the words of the Great God. Say, "It is written." The Belshazzar of Hell will tremble and withdraw if you show these writings of the Lord.
Lastly, since the Lord Jesus Christ has conquered all the temptations of the Devil, run to that Lord, cry to that Lord, that He would give you a share in His happy victory. It was for us that our Lord overcame the Devil: and when He simply said, "Satan, get thee hence," the tiger immediately fled. Does the Devil bother us? Then let us go to our Lord, who says, "I know how to succor the tempted." The Psalmist said, "Lead me to the rock that is higher than I" (Psalm 61:2). A woman in this land, being possessed by devils, had the devils within her audibly speak of various harms they would inflict upon her; but they always made this answer, "Ah! She runs to the rock! She runs to the rock!" and that stopped everything. Oh, this running to the rock; it's the best protection in the world; the vultures of hell cannot prey upon the doves in the clefts of that rock. May our God now lead us there.
CHAPTER 14
FURTHER ACCOUNTS AND EYEWITNESS TESTIMONIES
With the observations of a person who was on the scene for several days when the suspected witches were first brought in for examination.
To which is added,
Cases of Conscience Concerning Witchcrafts and Evil Spirits Personating Men.
Written at the request of the ministers of New England.
By Increase Mather, President of Harvard College.
A TRUE NARRATIVE OF SOME REMARKABLE EVENTS RELATING TO VARIOUS PEOPLE AFFLICTED BY WITCHCRAFT AT SALEM VILLAGE IN NEW ENGLAND, WHICH HAPPENED FROM MARCH 19 TO APRIL 5, 1692.
Collected by Deodat Lawson.
On the 19th of March, I went to Salem Village and stayed at Nathaniel Ingersol's place, which is near the minister Mr. P.'s house. Shortly after I arrived at my lodging, Captain Walcut's daughter, Mary, came to Lieutenant Ingersol's and spoke to me. But soon after, as she stood by the door, she was bitten and cried out about her wrist. When we looked at it with a candle, we clearly saw the marks of teeth, both upper and lower sets, on each side of her wrist.
In the beginning of the evening, I went to visit Mr. P. While I was there, his relative, Abigail Williams, who is about 12 years old, had a severe fit. She was first violently moved back and forth in the room, even though Mrs. Ingersol tried to hold her. Sometimes she acted as if she wanted to fly, stretching her arms as high as she could and repeatedly crying, "Whish, Whish, Whish." Shortly after, she said that Goodwife N. was there and asked, "Do you not see her? Why, there she stands!" She said Goodwife N. offered her the book, but she was determined not to take it, repeatedly saying, "I won't, I won't, I won't take it. I do not know what book it is. I am sure it is none of God's book; it is the Devil's book for all I know." After that, she ran to the fire and began to throw firebrands around the house and ran against the back as if she would run up the chimney. They said she had attempted to go into the fire during other fits.
On the Lord's Day, the 20th of March, several of the afflicted people were at the meeting, including Mrs. Pope, Goodwife Bibber, Abigail Williams, Mary Walcut, Mary Lewes, and Doctor Grigg's maid. Goodwife C. was also at the meeting (she was later examined on suspicion of being a witch). They had several severe fits during the time of public worship, which somewhat interrupted me during my first prayer, as it was so unusual. After the psalm was sung, Abigail Williams said to me, "Now stand up, and name your text!" And after it was read, she said, "It is a long text." At the beginning of the sermon, Mrs. Pope, an afflicted woman, said to me, "Now there is enough of that." And in the afternoon, Abigail Williams, upon my referring to my doctrine, said to me, "I know no doctrine you had. If you did name one, I have forgotten it."
In the middle of the sermon, when Goodwife C. was in the meeting-house, Ab. W. called out, "Look where Goodwife C. sits on the beam, feeding her yellow bird between her fingers!" Ann Putman, another afflicted girl, said, "There was a yellow bird sitting on my hat as it hung on the pin in the pulpit," but those nearby stopped her from speaking loudly about it.
On Monday, March 21st, the magistrates of Salem gathered to examine Goodwife C. Around noon, they went into the meeting-house, which was crowded with spectators. Mr. Noyes began with a very relevant and heartfelt prayer. When Goodwife C. was called to respond to the accusations against her, she asked to pray, which surprised the many hundreds present. The magistrates told her they would not allow it; they were there to examine her about the allegations, not to hear her pray. The honorable Mr. Hathorne asked her, "Why do you afflict these children?" She replied that she did not afflict them. He asked who did, then. She said, "I do not know; how should I know?" At that time, there were about ten afflicted persons: four married women—Mrs. Pope, Mrs. Putman, Goodwife Bibber, and an elderly woman named Goodall; three maids—Mary Walcut, Mercy Lewes at Thomas Putman's, and a maid at Dr. Griggs's; and three girls aged 9 to 12—Elizabeth Parris, Abigail Williams, and Ann Putman. Most of them were present at Goodwife C.'s examination and strongly accused her of afflicting them by biting, pinching, strangling, etc. They claimed that during their fits, they saw her likeness coming to them and bringing a book. She said she had no book. They insisted she had a yellow bird that used to suck between her fingers. When asked if she had any familiar spirit attending her, she said, "She had no familiarity with any such thing." She called herself a "Gospel Woman," but the afflicted persons told her, "Ah! she was a Gospel Witch." Ann Putman affirmed that one day, when Lieutenant Fuller was praying at her father's house, she saw the shape of Goodwife C. and thought Goodwife N. was praying at the same time to the Devil. She wasn't sure it was Goodwife N., but she was very sure she saw the shape of Goodwife C. The said C. claimed they were poor, distracted children and that no attention should be given to what they said. Mr. Hathorne and Mr. Noyes replied that everyone present believed they were bewitched, and only she, the accused, said they were distracted. It was observed several times that if she bit her under lip during the examination, the afflicted persons were bitten on their arms and wrists and showed the marks to the magistrates, ministers, and others. Being watched for that, if she pinched her fingers or grasped one hand hard in another, they were pinched and showed the marks to the magistrates and spectators. After that, it was noted that if she leaned her breast against the seat in the meeting-house (being the bar at which she stood), they were afflicted. Particularly, Mrs. Pope complained of severe torment in her bowels, as if they were being torn out. She vehemently accused C. as the cause and first threw her muff at her; when that didn't hit, she took off her shoe and hit Goodwife C. on the head with it. After these actions were watched, if C. moved her feet, they were afflicted in their feet and stamped fearfully. The afflicted persons asked her why she didn't go to the company of witches mustering before the meeting-house. Did she not hear the drum beat? They accused her of having familiarity with the Devil during the examination, in the shape of a black man whispering in her ear. They claimed her yellow bird sucked between her fingers in the assembly, and when ordered to see if there was any sign, the girl who saw it said it was too late now; she had removed a pin and put it on her head, which was found there sticking upright.
They told her that she had made a pact with the Devil for ten years, six of which had passed, leaving four more to go. The magistrates asked her to answer the question from the Catechism, "How many persons are there in the Godhead?" She answered it in an unusual way, but there was not much to be concluded from it. She denied all the charges against her and said, "They could not prove a witch." That afternoon, she was sent to Salem Prison, and after she was in custody, she did not appear to them or afflict them as she had before.
On Wednesday, March 23rd, I went to Thomas Putman's house to see his wife. I found her lying on the bed, having had a severe fit a little before. She spoke to me and said she was glad to see me. Her husband and she both asked me to pray with her while she was still aware, which I did, even though the apparition said, "I should not go to prayer." At first, she listened, but after a little while, she was taken with a fit; yet she remained silent and seemed to be asleep. When the prayer was done, her husband went to her and found her in a fit. He took her off the bed to set her on his knees, but at first, she was so stiff she couldn't be bent. However, she later sat down but quickly began to struggle violently with her arms and legs. She then started to complain about, and as if to converse personally with, Goodwife N., saying, "Goodwife N. Be gone! Be gone! Be gone! Are you not ashamed, a woman of your profession, to afflict a poor creature so? What harm did I ever do to you in my life? You have but two years to live, and then the Devil will torment your soul; for this, your name is blotted out of God's book, and it shall never be put in God's book again; be gone for shame, are you not afraid of what is coming upon you? I know, I know what will make you afraid; the wrath of an angry God, I am sure that will make you afraid; be gone, do not torment me, I know what you would have" (we thought she meant her soul) "but it is out of your reach; it is clothed with the white robes of Christ's righteousness." After this, she seemed to argue with the apparition about a specific text of Scripture. The apparition seemed to deny it (the woman's eyes being closed all this time). She said, "She was sure there was such a text," and she would tell it, and then the shape would be gone, for she said, "I am sure you cannot stand before that text!" Then she was sorely afflicted, her mouth drawn to one side, and her body strained for about a minute, and then said, "I will tell, I will tell; it is, it is, it is," three or four times, and then was afflicted to prevent her from telling. At last, she broke forth and said, "It is the third chapter of the Revelations." I was somewhat hesitant to read it and let my hesitation show, lest Satan should make anyone superstitiously misuse the Word of the Eternal God. However, though not experienced in these matters, I thought I might do it this once as an experiment. I began to read, and before I had nearly read through the first verse, she opened her eyes and was well. This fit lasted nearly half an hour. Her husband and the spectators told me she had often been relieved by reading texts that she named, something pertinent to her case, such as Isa. 40:1, Isa. 49:1, Isa. 50:1, and several others.
On Thursday, March 24th, which was the regular Lecture Day at the Village, Goodwife N. was brought before the Magistrates, Mr. Hathorne and Mr. Corwin, around ten in the morning to be examined in the Meeting House. The Reverend Mr. Hale began with prayer, and after the warrant was read, she was asked why she afflicted those people. She pleaded her innocence earnestly. Thomas Putnam's wife, Abigail Williams, and Thomas Putnam's daughter accused her of appearing to them and afflicting them during their fits. However, some others said they had seen her but didn't know if she had ever harmed them. Among these was Mary Walcut, who, right after she declared this, was bitten and cried out against her in the Meeting House, showing the marks of teeth on her wrist. I didn't have time to attend the entire examination, but both the Magistrates and Ministers told me that the accusations by the afflicted and her defenses were much like the previous cases. Her actions resulted in effects like biting, pinching, bruising, and tormenting at their breasts by her leaning, and when bent back, it felt as if their backs were broken. The afflicted persons said the Black Man whispered to her in the assembly, which is why she couldn't hear what the Magistrates said to her. They also said she rode by the Meeting House behind the Black Man. Thomas Putnam's wife had a severe fit during the examination, greatly weakening her to the point she could hardly move when carried out. Others were also severely afflicted, causing such a loud scream and noise (which I heard as I walked a little distance from the Meeting House) that it amazed me. Some inside told me the whole assembly was struck with fear, worried that those sitting next to them were under the influence of witchcraft. This woman was also committed to Salem Prison that day. The Magistrates and Ministers informed me that they apprehended a child of Sarah G. and examined it, being between 4 and 5 years old. They unanimously affirmed that when this child merely looked at the afflicted persons, they were tormented. Even when they held her head, anyone her eyes could fix upon was afflicted, which they observed carefully several times. The afflicted complained they had often been bitten by this child and showed marks of a small set of teeth accordingly. This child was also committed to Salem Prison. The child looked healthy, like other children. I saw her at Lieut. Ingersol's. After Goodwife N.'s commitment, Thomas Putnam's wife was much better and had no violent fits from March 24th to April 5th. Some others also said they hadn't seen her appear to them as frequently to harm them.
On the 25th of March (as Captain Stephen Sewal of Salem later informed me), Eliz. Paris had severe fits at his house, which greatly troubled him and his wife, to the point where he said they were almost discouraged. She said that the great Black Man came to her and told her that if she followed him, she would have whatever she desired and go to a Golden City. When she shared this with Mrs. Sewal, Mrs. Sewal told the child that it was the Devil, and he was a liar from the beginning (John 8:44), and instructed her to tell him so if he came again. The child did as instructed during her next fit.
On March 26th, Mr. Hathorne, Mr. Corwin, and Mr. Higison went to the prison-keeper's house to examine the child. The child told them it had a little snake that used to suck on the lowest joint of its forefinger. When they asked where, and pointed to other places, the child said, "Not there, but there," pointing to the lowest joint of the forefinger, where they noticed a deep red spot about the size of a flea bite. They asked who gave it that snake, whether it was the great black man. The child said no, its mother gave it.
On March 31, there was a public fast held in Salem because of these afflicted people. Abigail Williams said that the witches had a sacrament that day at a house in the village, and they had red bread and red drink. On April 1, Mercy Lewis, Thomas Putnam's maid, in her fit, said they ate red bread, like man's flesh, and tried to make her eat some, but she refused; she turned her head away, spat at them, and said, "I will not eat, I will not drink, it is blood, etc." She said, "That is not the bread of life; that is not the water of life; Christ gives the bread of life; I will have none of it!" On April 1, Mercy Lewis also saw in her fit a white man and was with him in a glorious place, which had no candles or sun, yet was full of light and brightness. There was a great multitude in white glittering robes, and they sang the song in Revelation 5:9, Psalm 110, and Psalm 149. She said to herself, "How long shall I stay here! Let me be along with you." She was reluctant to leave this place and was grieved that she could not stay longer. This white man has appeared several times to some of them and given them notice of how long it would be before they had another fit, which was sometimes a day, or a day and a half, or more or less, and it happened accordingly.
On April 3rd, which was a Sunday and Sacrament day at the village, when Mr. Parris announced his sermon text, "John 6:70, 'One of you is a devil,'" Goodwife C. immediately left the meeting house and slammed the door behind her, shocking the congregation. Later, some people in their fits claimed to see her and said, "Oh, Goodwife C., I did not expect to see you here!" While they were having their bread and drink, they said to her, "Is this the time to receive the Sacrament? You ran away on the Lord's Day and refused to receive it in the meeting house, and now you choose this time to receive it? I am surprised at you!" This is the summary of what I either witnessed myself or received information about from people of unquestionable reputation and credibility.
REMARKS ON THINGS MORE THAN ORDINARY ABOUT THE AFFLICTED PERSONS.
1. During their fits, they are tempted to become witches, shown a list of names of others, and tortured because they refuse to agree, get involved with, or touch the book. They are promised immediate relief if they would do it.
2. They would, in the assembly, mutually cure each other, even with a touch of their hand, when strangled and otherwise tortured; and would try to get to their afflicted to relieve them.
3. They also predicted when another person's fit was coming and would say, "Look to her! She will have a fit presently," which happened just as they said, as many can testify who heard and saw it.
4. At the same time when the accused person was present, the afflicted persons saw her likeness in other places of the meeting-house, feeding her familiar, sometimes in one place and posture, and sometimes in another.
5. Their movements during their fits are unnatural, both in the way they twist their bodies in strange ways that a healthy person couldn't achieve, and in the intensity, which is much stronger than the usual strength of the same person when they are in their right mind.
6. In their fits, some of them have their eyes tightly closed, and if you ask them a question, they can't answer. I believe they can't hear at that time, yet they clearly interact with the appearances as if they were talking with real people.
7. They are completely discouraged from having anyone pray with them, and the appearances tell them they should not go to prayer. For example, Thomas Putnam's wife was told, "I should not pray," but she insisted, "I should." After I finished praying, she reasoned with the appearance, saying, "Did not I say he should go to prayer?"
8. The aforementioned Mary W. was feeling a little better, and the afflicted persons said she had signed the book, which was the reason she was feeling better. This was told to me by Edward Putman.
OBSERVATIONS ON THE BEHAVIOR OF THE ACCUSED
1. For the introduction to discovering those who afflicted them, it is reported that Mr. Parris's Indian man and woman made a cake of rye meal and the children's urine, baked it in the ashes, and gave it to a dog. Since then, they have discovered and seen specific individuals harming them.
2. In the time of examination, they seemed hardly affected, even though all the spectators were very upset to see it.
3. Natural actions performed by them caused preternatural actions in the afflicted, so that they are their own image without any poppets of wax or otherwise.
4. They are accused of having a group of about 23 or 24 people, and they supposedly gathered in arms, as it appeared to the afflicted persons.
5. Since they were confined, the persons have not been as afflicted with the apparitions biting or pinching them, etc.
6. The afflicted people report that they hold days of fasting, days of thanksgiving, and sacraments. Satan tries to transform himself into an "angel of light" and make his kingdom and actions resemble those of our Lord Jesus Christ.
7. Satan mainly targets the visible members of Christ's Kingdom and seemingly uses some of them to afflict others, so that Christ's Kingdom may be divided against itself and thus be weakened.
Several things used in England during the trial of witches, numbering 14 or 15, which usually serve as evidence or in conjunction with witnesses; at least 6 or 7 of them are found in these accused. See Keeble's Statutes.
Some of the most reliable afflicted persons affirm the same things about seeing the accused both out of their fits as well as in them.
10. The witches held a fast and told one of the afflicted girls that she must not eat because it was a fast day. She said she would eat anyway. They told her they would choke her if she did, and when she ate, they tried to do so.
A LETTER FROM SALEM: FURTHER STRANGE EVENTS
In Salem, on June 10, 1692, about 40 people were suffering from terrible torment by evil spirits. The afflicted accused 60 or 70 people of being witches because they had spectral appearances of them, even though the accused were absent when the torments occurred. When these witches were tried, several confessed to making a contract with the Devil by signing his book and expressed much sorrow for it. They also revealed their fellow witches and said the tempters pressured them to sign the Devil's book, tormenting them until they did. During the examinations, witnessed by hundreds, strange events occurred. Pins were taken from the clothes of the afflicted and thrust into their flesh, with many removed by the judges themselves. Thorns were also thrust into their flesh similarly. The accusers were sometimes struck dumb, deaf, or blind, and sometimes appeared dead for a while, all foreseen and declared by the afflicted just before it happened. Among the afflicted were two girls, about 12 or 13 years old, who saw everything and were called the Visionary Girls. They would say, "Now he, or she, or they, are going to bite or pinch the Indian," and everyone present in court saw the visible marks on the Indian's arms. They would also cry out, "Now look, look, they are going to bind such a one's legs," and everyone saw the person mentioned fall with her legs twisted in an extraordinary way. They would say, "Now we shall all fall," and immediately 7 or 8 of the afflicted fell down with terrible shrieks and outcries. When one of the witches was sentenced and tied with a cord, at the same time, the afflicted Indian servant, who was about 2 or 3 miles out of town going home, had both his wrists bound with a similar cord in the same manner as the sentenced witch. The cord entered his flesh with such violence that it couldn't be untied or easily cut. Many murders are suspected to have been committed in this way. The girls and others of the afflicted claimed to see coffins and bodies in shrouds rising up and looking at the accused, crying, "Vengeance, vengeance on the murderers." Many other strange things happened before the court during the examinations. Notably, one of the accused, while the rest were under examination, was drawn up by a rope to the roof of the house and would likely have been choked if the rope hadn't been cut immediately. The rope hung at the roof by some invisible tie, as there was no hole where it went up. After it was cut, the remainder of it was found in the chamber above, lying by the very place where it hung down.
In December 1692, the court met again at Salem in New England and cleared about 40 people suspected of being witches, while condemning three. The evidence against these three was the same as before, so the warrant for their execution was sent, and graves were dug for them and for about five more who had been condemned at Salem previously but were reprieved by the governor.
In the beginning of February 1693, the court sat at Charles-Town where the judge expressed himself to this effect.
Who it was that obstructed the execution of justice or hindered the good progress they had made, he did not know, but by doing so, the kingdom of Satan was advanced, and he prayed, "the Lord have mercy on this country." He then decided not to come to court anymore. In his absence, Mr. D---- sat as Chief Judge for 3 different days, during which time 5 or 6 were cleared by proclamation, and almost as many by trial, so that all were acquitted.
The most remarkable was an old woman named Dayton, of whom it was said, "If any in the world were a witch, she was one, and had been so accounted for 30 years." I had the curiosity to see her trial; she was a decrepit woman of about 80 years of age and did not use many words in her own defense. She was accused by about 30 witnesses, but the matters alleged against her needed little apology on her part. Not one passionate word, immoral action, or evil was objected against her for the past 20 years, only strange accidents occurring after some Christian admonition given by her, such as saying, "God would not prosper them if they wronged the widow." Overall, there was nothing proved against her worthy of reproof or just admonition, much less such a serious charge.
So, by the goodness of God, we are once more out of the present danger of this hobgoblin monster; the standing evidence used at Salem were called, but did not appear.
There were others also at Charlestown brought to their trials, who had previously confessed to being witches; but during their trials, they denied it and were all cleared. So, at present, there is no further prosecution of anyone.
CHAPTER 15
A CRISIS OF CONSCIENCE: CAN WE TRUST THE EVIDENCE OF SPECTRES?
All considered according to the Scriptures, history, experience, and the judgment of many learned men.
By Increase Mather, President of Harvard College at Cambridge, and Teacher of a Church at Boston in New England.
"That you might answer the words of truth, to those who send to you." - Proverbs 22:21
Printed at Boston, and re-printed at London, for John Dunton, at the Raven in the Poultrey. 1693.
CHRISTIAN READER
So odious and abominable is the name of a witch to the civilized, and even more to the religious part of humanity, that it often becomes a scandal for anyone to even suggest some cautious warnings against hastily suspecting or too quickly judging people on this account. But certainly, the more detestable the crime is, the more careful we must be in exposing the names, liberties, and lives of people (especially those with a godly life) to such accusations. The serious situation we face now, with God allowing evil angels to cause such horrid mischiefs and letting Hell's instruments do such fearful things, has led serious people to deeply ponder and carefully inquire what should be done to detect and defeat this tremendous plan of the grand adversary. And, although all who fear God agree that "no evil is to be done, that good may come of it," the Devil has succeeded somewhat in his plan by causing divisions among us about how to apply this rule.
That there are devils and witches, the Scripture asserts, and experience confirms. That they are common enemies of mankind and intent on causing harm is not to be doubted. That the devil can (by divine permission) and often does torment people in body and estate without the help of witches is undeniable. That he often has, and delights in having, the cooperation of witches and their consent in harming people aligns with his natural malice towards humanity and is sadly exemplified. When witches are detected and proven guilty, they ought to be exterminated and cut off, as we have God's warrant for this (Ex. 22:18). The same God who has said, "Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live," has also said, "At the mouth of two witnesses, or three witnesses shall he that is worthy of death, be put to death: but at the mouth of one witness, he shall not be put to death" (Deut. 17:6). Much debate arises about what constitutes sufficient conviction, and some have (in their zeal) supposed that less clear evidence should suffice in this case than in others, thinking it will otherwise be hard (if not impossible) to bring such to proper punishment due to the secret dealings between the devil and witches. But this is a very dangerous and unjustifiable belief. People serve God by doing their duty; He never intended that all guilty of capital crimes be discovered and punished by humans in this life, no matter how diligently they search for iniquity. It is therefore exceedingly necessary in times like these for people to be informed about what is evidence and what is not. This concerns people in terms of charity; for though the most shining professor may secretly be a most abominable sinner, until they are detected, our charity is bound to judge according to what appears. And although clear evidence must determine a case, presumptions must be weighed against presumptions, and charity should not be abandoned as long as it has the most weight on its side. It is equally necessary in terms of justice; not only are testimonies required by God, which are to be believed according to the rules given in His Word regarding witnesses, but there is also an evidence supposed to be in the testimony, which must be thoroughly weighed. If it does not infallibly prove the crime against the accused, it should not determine them guilty, for a righteous person may be condemned unjustly. In the case of witchcrafts, we know that the devil is the immediate agent in the mischief done; the consent or agreement of the witch is what needs to be demonstrated.
Among many arguments to prove this, the one most currently debated is about something commonly called "Spectre Evidence" and a certain type of ordeal or trial by sight and touch. The main argument to justify the convincing evidence in these cases is based on the wisdom and righteousness of God in governing the world. They believe this would fail if such things happened to an innocent person. However, it's certain that drawing too firm conclusions from this is a bold overreach on God's perfect sovereignty. Although some things, if allowed to be common, would disrupt this governance and ruin human society, God sometimes allows such things to happen so we can understand how much we owe Him for the restraint He places on the infernal spirits, who would otherwise turn the world into chaos. Resolving such cases is rightly the responsibility of Christ's servants in the ministry, and the timeliness of addressing it now is justified by the need for correct understanding of these matters and the danger of misinformation.
The reverend, learned, and wise author of the following cases is too well-known to need our praise. Our main concern is to express our wholehearted agreement with the substance of what is contained in the following discourse. We sincerely pray to God that He would reveal the depths of this hellish plan, guide the entire handling of this matter, prevent any wrong steps in this dark path, and especially bless these faithful efforts of His servant. We commend it and you to His divine blessing.
William Hubbard, Samuel Phillips, Charles Morton, James Allen, Michael Wigglesworth, Samuel Whiting Sr., Samuel Willard, John Baily, Jabez Fox, Joseph Gerrish, Samuel Angier, John Wise, Joseph Capen, Nehemiah Walter.
CASE 1: CAN THE DEVIL IMPERSONATE AN INNOCENT PERSON?
The first case I am asked to give my opinion on is this: Is it possible for the Devil to deceive the imaginations of people who are bewitched, making them believe that an innocent, even a pious person, is tormenting them when it is actually the Devil doing it? Or can Satan appear in the form of an innocent and pious person, just as he can in the form of a guilty and wicked person, to afflict those who suffer from diabolical attacks?
The answer to the question must be yes; let the following arguments be carefully considered in the balance of the sanctuary.
Argument #1: There are several scriptures from which we can infer the possibility of what is affirmed.
1. We find that the Devil, through the Witch at Endor, appeared looking like the Prophet Samuel. I'm aware that some have claimed, if proven, it would counter this argument, that it was the real Samuel and not a deceptive one that the Witch brought to talk with Saul. Some Jewish Rabbis, some Christian scholars, and many recent Catholic authors, including Cornelius a Lapide, have this view. But learned and Orthodox writers, especially Peter Martyr, Balduinus, Lavater, and our remarkable John Rainolde, have shown that it was a demon pretending to be Samuel. I won't go into detail here, especially since I've explained it elsewhere. I'll just add that the Witch said to Saul, "I see Elohim," meaning "a God" (since the whole context shows a single person is meant), "ascending out of the Earth" (1 Sam. 28:13). The Devil wants to be worshipped as a God, and now that Saul had become a necromancer, he must bow to him.
Moreover, if it had been the real Samuel from Heaven reprimanding Saul, it's reasonable to believe he would have also reproved him for his sin of not executing judgment on the Amalekites, as in verse 18. But especially for his wickedness in consulting with familiar spirits, which was a special reason for his death (1 Chron. 10:13). Since there's not a word against that abomination, we can conclude it wasn't the real Samuel that appeared to Saul. If it was the Devil in his likeness, the argument seems strong that if the Devil can appear as a saint in glory, he can more easily appear as the most pious and innocent saint on Earth. Some admit that a demon can appear as a godly person, but not while doing evil. However, the Devil in Samuel's likeness told a harmful lie when he said, "You have disquieted me." It wasn't in Saul's power, nor all the Devils in Hell, to disturb a soul in Heaven, where Samuel had been for two years before this apparition. Nor did the specter speak truthfully when he said, "You and your sons shall be with me." Though Saul himself went to be with the Devil at his death, his son Jonathan did not. Besides, which fits the matter at hand, the Devil in Samuel's shape confirmed necromancy and cursed witchcraft. If he can encourage witches to be familiar with Hell in the likeness of saints, he may possibly afflict a bewitched person in the likeness of a saint. But as we see from Scripture, Satan may be allowed to do this.
And it is argued that the Devil can appear as dead people, but not as those who are alive; the opposite is clear. There is no doubt that if Saul had asked the witch to bring him David, who was alive at the time, she could have shown living David just as easily as she showed dead Samuel. This is just as easily done as when that great conjurer mentioned by Wierus brought the appearance of Hector and Achilles, and later David, before Emperor Maximilian.
Evil angels have sometimes appeared looking like living people who are not present, and this is well-supported by history.
Austin tells us about a person who sought answers to complex questions from a philosopher but received no response. However, the philosopher appeared to him at night and resolved all his doubts. When asked why he couldn't answer during the day, the philosopher admitted he wasn't actually there at night but had only dreamed of the conversation while he was at home asleep. Paulus and Palladius both told Austin that someone resembling him had appeared to them in various places. Thyreus mentions several instances of living people appearing in different places at the same time, which he knew for certain. A person cannot be in two places at once, so such appearances are extraordinary and supernatural, likely involving diabolical activity. There has been debate among scholars about whether innocent people can be made to appear at witch gatherings through the devil's deception. Thyreus argues that the devil can and often does make innocent people appear at such gatherings, though he believes God's providence would prevent harm to the innocent. Delrio and Spineus agree with this view. However, Cumanus, in his book "Lucerna Inquisitorum," which I haven't seen, argues the opposite. Bins Fieldius, in his treatise on witches' confessions, leans towards the negative but acknowledges that by God's extraordinary permission, innocents can be represented in such ways. Claiming that God never allows the devil to deceive innocent people is more than one can prove. The story of Germanus discovering a similar diabolical illusion, where people seemed to be at a feast but were actually at home asleep, is noted by many authors. These examples support the idea that the devil can appear as innocent and pious people by divine permission. Furthermore, as stated in 2 Cor. 11:14, "For Satan himself is transformed into an angel of light." He pretends to be what he is not and makes others appear as they are not, portraying evil people as good and good people as evil. The angels of heaven, who are angels of light, love truth and righteousness, and the devil pretends to do the same. He sometimes presents good principles and encourages people to follow them, as he did with Theodore Maillit, to deceive more effectively. It's strange that he sometimes tells his devoted followers to avoid major sins and pray for divine protection to maintain contact with him. Boissardus shows how he transforms into an angel of light. He has often appeared to people as a good angel, as with Anatolius of old, and the well-known cases of Dr. Dee and Kellet. Many deluded enthusiasts, both past and present, have been deceived by Satan appearing as a good angel. Moreover, he transforms into an angel of light by appearing as holy men, who are children of light, even taking the form of eminent ministers of God. He appeared to Mr. Earl of Colchester as Mr. Liddal, a holy man, and to the Turkish Chaous baptized in London in 1658, pretending to be Mr. Dury, an excellent minister of Christ. He has often pretended to be the Apostle Paul, Peter, or other celebrated saints. Ecclesiastical histories are full of such instances. Sometimes, he even transforms into the form of Christ. It's reported that he appeared to St. Martin, gloriously arrayed as if he were Christ, and to Secundellus and another saint who, suspecting it was Satan, said, "If I may see Christ in Heaven it is enough, I desire not to see him in this World," causing the specter to vanish. It's said that after Luther had been fasting and praying, the devil appeared pretending to be Christ, but Luther dismissed him by saying, "away thou confounded Devil, I acknowledge no Christ but what is in my Bible," and nothing more was seen. Thus, the devil can, by divine permission, transform into any form or figure he chooses.
All things transform themselves into miracles.
A third scripture relevant to our discussion is found in Revelation 12:10, where the Devil is called the "Accuser of the Brethren." The Devil's malice and boldness lead him to accuse good people before God, not only of faults they are truly guilty of—like when he accused Joshua of his filthy garments because some of his family had sinned through unlawful marriages (Zech. 3:2-3; Ezra 10:18)—but also of crimes they are completely innocent of. He portrayed the early Christians as the worst of men, claiming they committed the most heinous acts at their meetings. It's not new for innocent, even notably pious people, to be accused of witchcraft due to the Devil's malice. The Lord allowed the great Athanasius to face such an affliction, but Divine Providence wonderfully cleared him of that and other false accusations. The Waldenses, whom the scriptures call "Saints" (Rev. 13:7), were maligned by Satan and the world as horrible witches, as have others in different places, simply because they achieved extraordinary things through prayer. Many authors have noted that a city in France was troubled by a diabolical specter called Hugon; near that place, Protestants gathered to worship God, leading Papists to nickname them "Hugonots," implying they were servants and worshippers of that demon named Hugon. I've often read in books by Jesuits that Luther was a wizard and confessed to having dealings with Satan—most impudent lies! These things shouldn't surprise us, as even the Holy Son of God was considered a magician and accused of having ties with the greatest of devils. The blaspheming Pharisees said, "He casts out the devils through the Prince of Devils" (Matt. 9:34). No saint on Earth, man or woman, can be sure the Devil won't cast such accusations upon them. "It is enough for the disciple that he be as his master, and the servant as his lord: if they have called the master of the house Beelzebub, how much more them of his household" (Matt. 10:25). It's not for humans to decide how far God may allow the wicked one to go in his accusations. The story of Job shows us that the Lord, whose ways are beyond understanding, allows Satan, for wise and holy reasons, to greatly afflict innocent people through direct action (and consequently through witchcraft), affecting their bodies, possessions, and reputations. I'll mention one more scripture to support this truth: Ecclesiastes 9:2-3, which says, "All things come alike to all, there is one event to the righteous and to the wicked, as is the good, so is the sinner; this is an evil among all things under the sun, that there is one event happeneth to all." And in Ecclesiastes 7:15, it says, "There is a just man that perisheth in his righteousness."
From this, we can infer that there is no outward affliction that cannot happen to a good person. Being represented by Satan as a tormentor of bewitched or possessed people is a severe affliction for a good person. To be tormented by Satan is a severe affliction, yet it is something that happened to Job and a daughter of Abraham, as we read in the Gospel (Luke 13:16). Being represented by Satan as tormenting others is an affliction similar to the former. The Lord may bring such extraordinary temptations on His own children to afflict and humble them for some sin they have been guilty of before Him. A very wicked person in St. Ives got a knife and went to a minister's house, intending to stab him, but was thwarted. Later, when his conscience was awakened, the devil appeared to this person in the shape of that minister, with a knife in his hand, urging him to commit self-murder. Wasn't this a punishment suitable to the sin that person had been guilty of? Perhaps some of those whom Satan has represented as committing witchcraft have been dabbling with some foolish and wicked sorceries, though not to the degree that is criminal and capital by the laws of both God and men. For this, Satan may be permitted to scourge them, or perhaps they have misrepresented and abused others, for which reason the Holy God may justly allow Satan to falsely represent them.
Have we not known some people who have harshly judged everyone accused by those claiming to be bewitched, insisting it was impossible for them to be innocent? Soon after, they or their close relatives have been accused in the same way and impersonated by the Devil, bringing lasting shame to their families! Such severe warnings to a few should make everyone cautious about joining with Satan in condemning the innocent.
Argument 2: Because it is possible for the Devil, in the shape of an innocent person, to do other mischiefs. For those who admit that Satan can impersonate a pious person but not to cause harm, their opinion has been disproved by several unfortunate instances. Mr. Clark speaks of a man who had been an atheist or a Sadducee, not believing in devils or any invisible world. This man was converted, but as a punishment for his disbelief, evil angels often appeared to him in the shape of his closest friends and sometimes led him into great inconveniences. It has been noted elsewhere that a demon in the shape of the excellent Mr. Dury appeared to the Turkish Chaos in 1658 to dissuade him from pursuing baptism in the name of Christ. Also, a demon appeared to Mr. Earle in the likeness of his friends to discourage him from doing lawful and good things. A multitude of Jews were once deceived by a person pretending to be Moses from heaven, claiming that if they followed him, they would pass safely through the sea, as their ancestors did through the Red Sea, resulting in many of them being deceived and perishing in the waters. Learned and judicious men have concluded that this "Moses Creensis" was a demon transforming himself into Moses. The Devil has frequently appeared in the shape of famous persons to seduce people into idolatry, a sin equal to witchcraft. Anyone who has investigated such matters cannot be ignorant of this. Many examples of this kind are collected by Mr. Bromhall in his "Treatise of Spectres," and by Mr. Bovet in his "Pandemonium." It is credibly reported that the Devil, in the likeness of a faithful minister (at St. Ives near Boston in Lincolnshire), came to someone troubled in mind, advising her to commit self-murder by telling her that the longer she lived, the worse it would be for her. An eminent person still living received this account from Mr. Cotton, the famous teacher of both Bostons. He was well acquainted with that minister, who related the whole story with all its circumstances. Mr. Cotton was so affected by the report that he traveled to the town where this happened to obtain a satisfactory account, which he did. Some authors say that a demon appeared in the form of Sylvanus (Hierom's friend) attempting a dishonest act, intending to ruin the reputation of a famous bishop. In another book, I mentioned a celebrated instance concerning an honest citizen in Zurich (the capital of Helvetia), in whose shape the Devil appeared, committing an abominable act early in the morning, witnessed by the city's prefect and his servant. They were amazed to see a man of good reputation committing such a vile act. However, when they went from the specter in the field to the citizen's house in town, they found him at home and in bed, having not been out that morning, which convinced them that what they saw was an illusion of the Devil. This passage is mentioned as a known and certain event by Lavater in his "Treatise of Spectres," who was a most learned and judicious preacher in that city. Our Juel says of him that he must honestly confess he never understood Solomon's Proverbs until Lavater explained them to him. That book of his "De Spectris" has been published in Latin, High and Low Dutch, French, and Italian. The learned Zanchy speaks highly of it, professing that he read it with both pleasure and profit. Voetius notes that passage from Lavater as a memorable event.
Some Catholic authors argue that the Devil cannot impersonate an innocent person as committing an act of witchcraft, because if he could, he might just as easily impersonate them committing theft, murder, and other crimes. If that were the case, life in the world would be impossible. But I use this argument against them: the Devil can (as proven by the mentioned instances) impersonate honest people committing other evils. There is no solid reason why he couldn't impersonate them as witches just as he could as thieves, murderers, and idolaters. As for the objection that life would be impossible, we will consider that in the next argument.
Argument 3: If Satan cannot represent someone who is not his covenant servant as afflicting those who are bewitched or possessed, then it must be because he either lacks the will or the power to do so, or because God will never allow him to do it. No one but a Sadducee doubts the ill will of devils; nothing pleases the malice of these wicked spirits more than seeing innocence wronged. The power of the enemy is such that, once he obtains divine permission to use his art, he can do this and much more. We know from Scripture that the sorcerers of Egypt caused many false and deceptive representations before Pharaoh and his servants (Ex. 7:11, 22; 8:7). We also read of Satan working with all power, signs, and lying wonders (2 Thess. 2:9). His understanding surpasses that of the wisest humans. He has perfect skill in optics and can make something visible to one person that is not visible to another, and make things appear differently than they are. He also has the art of painting in perfection and knows what can be done with colors. There is an unusual account I found in the Acta Eruditorum, printed in Leipzig, about thirty-two years ago, where a poor merchant in France was taught by a demon to use water of borax to color taffeta, making it glisten and look very bright. Satan investigates the nature, causes, and reasons of things, enabling him to produce amazing effects. So, if he does not form the shape of an innocent person as afflicting others, it is not due to a lack of will or power. Those who claim that God never did or will permit him to do so argue that it is inconsistent with God's righteousness and providence in governing human affairs to allow people to be deceived. It must be acknowledged that divine providence ensures that most of humanity is not left to unavoidable deception, always abused by the mischievous agents of hell in matters of plain sense. However, sinful and foolish mortals should not dictate rules to the Most High on how to govern the world or how far he may permit Satan to use his power. I am inclined to think that some among us, if they had lived in Job's time and seen the devil tormenting him, and heard him complaining of being scared by dreams and terrified by night visions, would have joined his uncharitable friends in judging him as a guilty person. But we should consider that the Most High God sometimes deals with people in a way of absolute sovereignty, performing what is appointed for them, and many such things are with him. If he destroys the perfect with the wicked and laughs at the trial of the innocent (Job 9:22-23), who can enter into his councils? Who has given him a charge over the earth? Or who has arranged the whole world? People cannot account for his ordinary works, much less his secret counsels and the dark dispensations of his providence. They only darken counsel with words without knowledge when they attempt it. If we cannot see how something aligns with the righteousness of the one who governs the world, shall we say that the Almighty will pervert judgment? Or that he who governs the earth hates right? Shall we condemn him who is most just? But when it is objected, "Where is providence? And how shall people live on earth if the devil may be permitted such power?" I ask, where was providence when Satan had the power to cause sons of Belial to lie and swear away the life of innocent Naboth, accusing him of crimes he never committed? And what an hour of darkness was it when the power of hell was allowed to prevail so far that Christ, the Son of God, was accused, condemned, and hanged for a crime he never committed? That was the strangest providence since the world began, yet ultimately the most glorious. We must therefore distinguish between what ordinarily happens by the providence of God and extraordinary events. It is not usual for a Naboth to lose his life due to false accusations or for an Athanasius or a Susanna to be charged and perhaps brought before courts for crimes of which they are completely innocent.
If we conclude that such things can never happen in the world, we would be wrong about the ways of the righteous. It's not common for devils to be allowed to reveal people's secret sins, but it has happened more than once or twice. Nor is it common for demons to steal money from people's pockets and purses, or wine and cider from their cellars. Yet, there have been instances of this among us. It's not usual for God to allow the devil to come from hell and set fire to the tops of houses, causing a whole town to burn to ashes. Admittedly, it would be impossible to live in the world if evil angels were allowed to do this whenever they wanted. However, credible authors tell us that this has sometimes happened. Both Erasmus and Cardanus write that the town of Schiltach in Germany was set on fire by a devil in April 1533 and burned to the ground in an hour. Sigibert, Aventinus, and others report that some cottages and barns in a town called Bingus were set on fire by a wicked spirit. This spiteful demon claimed it was for the sins of a man he named, and he was sent to trouble them. The poor man, to prove his innocence to his neighbors who were ready to stone him, carried a hot iron in his hand but was not harmed, so he was judged innocent. It's not common for a devil, upon the dying curse of a servant, to be given permission from Heaven to torment a cruel master, yet such a thing might happen. There is a frightening story in the account of the Buccaneers of America, where the author relates that a servant, who was kidnapped into America, fell into the hands of a tyrannical master. The servant ran away but was caught and brought back. The cruel master whipped him on his bare back until his body was covered in blood. To make the torment unbearable, he rubbed the wounds with lemon juice mixed with salt and pepper, ground together. With this torture, the miserable servant died, saying, "I beseech the Almighty God, Creator of Heaven and Earth, that he permit a wicked spirit to make you feel as many torments before your death as you have caused me to feel before mine." Barely four days after this horrible act, the Almighty Judge allowed the devil to possess the body of that cruel master and make him tear his own flesh until he died, likely surrendering his soul to the hands of the infernal spirit that tormented his body. But enough about this tragic story.
To continue, it is not common for people to appear to the living after their death. However, this does not mean that God will never allow it to happen. Throughout history, there have been examples of this occurring. Just last winter, there was much talk in London about a woman whose deceased son, along with another person she did not recognize, appeared to her. While I was in London, I wanted to find out the truth of these reports. On February 23, 1691, my brother (who is now a pastor in that city) and I spoke with the woman in question. She told us that her son, who had been a polite young man but more carefree than his serious mother liked, had died. She was worried about his condition in the afterlife. Two weeks after his death, he appeared to her and said, "Mother, you are worried about my spiritual well-being; don't trouble yourself anymore, for I am happy," and then he vanished. If there were constant interaction between the visible and invisible worlds, it would cause confusion. However, to conclude that God will never allow such things is incorrect. It is not common for devils to be allowed to violently carry people through the air, miles from their homes. Yet, this happened in Sweden about twenty years ago, due to a cursed group of witches there. A learned physician currently living has reported several children being stolen from their parents by diabolical means, with others left in their place. In two cases, a line was placed around their necks by invisible hands during the night, and they would have been strangled if not for the timely intervention of those nearby. (See Germ. Ephem. Anno 1689, pages 51, 516.)
Let me add further here: It has very rarely been known that Satan has impersonated innocent people doing something wrong, without Providence finding some way to clear their name. Either they have been able to prove they were in another place when the act was done, or something similar. So perhaps there has never been an instance of any innocent person condemned in any court on Earth solely because of Satan deceiving and manipulating people's imaginations, even when the witnesses, juries, and judges were all free from blame.
Argument 4: It is certain from both Scripture and history that magicians, through their enchantments and hellish conjurations, can create false representations of people and things. An enchanted eye can see things that others cannot. It is well-known that some people, by rubbing their eyes with bewitched water, have immediately seen things that others could not discern. There are people in the world who have a strange spectral sight. Mr. Glanvil speaks of a Dutchman who could see ghosts that others could not perceive. In Spain, there are people called Zahurs who can see into the earth and discover minerals and hidden treasures, but they have this extraordinary sight only on Tuesdays and Fridays. Delrio mentions that when he was in Madrid in 1575, he saw some of these strangely sighted people. Mr. George Sinclare, in his book "Satan's Invisible World Discovered," writes, "I am undoubtedly informed that men and women in the Highlands can discern fatality approaching others by seeing them in the waters or with winding sheets about them. And that others can lecture in a sheep's shoulder-bone a death within the parish seven or eight days before it comes. It is not improbable that such preternatural knowledge comes first by a compact with the Devil and is passed down to their descendants. Many such people, I suppose, are innocent and have this sight against their will and inclination." I agree with Mr. Sinclare's supposition that such knowledge originates from Satan and perhaps is the effect of some old enchantment. There are people today who, if they enter a house where someone will die within a fortnight, are offended by the smell of a dead corpse to such a degree that they cannot stay in that house. It is reported that near the Abbey of St. Maurice in Burgundy, there is a fishpond with fish corresponding to the number of monks there. If any monk falls sick, a fish is seen floating and swimming above water half-dead, and if the monk is to die, the fish dies a few days beforehand. In some parts of Wales, death-lights or corpse candles are seen at night going from the house where someone will soon die and passing into the churchyard. My honored and unforgettable friend Mr. Richard Baxter has given an account of this in his book about witchcrafts recently published. I do not know what to make of such things except that they might be the effects of some old enchantment. I also find it difficult to explain naturally the observation from the Imperial Academy for the year 1687, which states that in an orchard with choice Damascene plums, when the master of the family was sick with a quartan ague, four of his plum trees bore a vile sort of yellow plums instead of Damascenes. But when he recovered, the trees bore Damascenes again. However, when he later fell into a fatal dropsy, the trees bore a different sort of fruit. The same author gives instances of apple and pear trees whose fruit suddenly withered as if baked in an oven when their owners were mortally sick. It is also strange that in the illustrious electoral house of Brandenburg, feminine specters appeared before the death of a family member. Often in the houses of great men, voices and visions from the invisible world have been harbingers of death. When an heir in the worshipful family of the Breertons in Cheshire is near death, bodies of trees are seen swimming in a nearby pool for several days. Learned Cambden notes, "These and such like things are done either by the holy tutelar angels of men or else by the devils, who by God's permission mightily show their power in this inferior world." Regarding Mr. Sinclare's notion that some people may have a "second sight" and yet be innocent, I am convinced he is correct. This is common among the Laplanders, who are horribly addicted to magical incantations. They pass their demons to their children as a legacy, who are often assisted by them (like bewitched people) to see and do things beyond the power of nature. A credible historian relates that a certain Laplander gave him a true and detailed account of his journey to Lapland and further complained with tears about seeing things at a great distance and how much he wished to be delivered from that diabolical sight but could not. This was undoubtedly caused by some enchantment.
To continue with my point, the eyes of people, due to enchanting charms, may not only see what others do not but also be under such a power of fascination that things which are not real appear to them as real. The Apostle speaks of "bewitched eyes" (Gal. 3:1), and we know from Scripture that the imaginations of people have been imposed upon by enchantments. Histories abound with strange instances of this nature. The old witch Circe, by an enchanted cup, caused Ulysses' companions to imagine themselves turned into swine. Many witches have been so bewitched by the Devil that they truly believed they were transformed into wolves, dogs, or cats. It is reported of Simon Magus that by his sorceries, he could impose on people's imaginations so that they thought he had changed into another creature. Apollonius of Tyana could outdo Simon with his magic. The great Bohemian conjurer Zyto, through his enchantments, caused certain people he wanted to test his art on to imagine their hands were turned into the feet of an ox or the hooves of a horse, so they could not reach the dishes before them. He sold wisps of straw to a butcher who bought them as swine. Many such tricks were played by the unfortunate Faustus, as attested by Camerarius, Wyerus, Voetius, Lavater, and Lonicer.
There is a newly published book (mentioned in the Acta Eruditorum) where the author, Wiechard Valvassor, shares that a Venetian Jew taught him how to make a magical glass that could show any person or thing as desired. Although he didn't follow the instructions, if a magician can do this with an enchanted glass, then with the help of a demon, they could also create false images of people and things in the minds of those bewitched. The blood and spirits of someone bitten by a mad dog are so poisoned that strange impressions are made on their imagination. If brought into a room with a mirror, they might swear they see a dog, even if there isn't one within 20 miles. So, isn't it possible for the forces of hell to poison the imaginations of unfortunate people, making them believe and swear that certain people hurt them when they didn't? I've heard of an enchanted pin that led to the condemnation and death of many innocent people. There was a notorious witchfinder in Scotland who claimed he could infallibly identify witches by using a pin. If he pushed the pin an inch or two into the accused's body and no blood appeared or pain was felt, he declared them witches. My source tells me that no less than 300 people were condemned this way in that kingdom. This deceitful man, after his work in Scotland, came to the town of Berwick upon Tweed. An honest man now living in New England assured me he saw the witchfinder push a large brass pin two inches into someone's body to test for witchcraft. The accused felt nothing and was in danger of being punished for witchcraft. However, Colonel Fenwick, a respected gentleman who lived in New England, was the military governor there. He advised the mayor and magistrates to be cautious, suggesting the pin might be enchanted. The magistrates ordered the witchfinder to use a different pin, but he refused, revealing his deceit. There is a strange diabolical power in incantations. If Balak hadn't believed in this, he wouldn't have sent for Balaam to see if he could curse the children of Israel. The scripture suggests that incantations can keep a serpent from biting (Eccl. 10:11).
A witch in Sweden confessed that the devil gave her a wooden knife, and if she touched any living thing with it, it would die immediately. The devil's power with enchanted items is confirmed by the case of Major Weir, a Scottish man. He was a prodigy, a man of great intellect, considered a saint, yet secretly lived in sin with his sister for thirty-four years. After his crimes were discovered, he wasn't troubled by them, except for causing a woman to be whipped for reporting his bestiality, which was true but unprovable. This horrid man could pray and perform extraordinary acts if he had his enchanted staff, as detailed in the postscript to Mr. Sinclares' book. Without his enchanted rod, he couldn't disguise himself as an angel of light. From all this, we can conclude that it's possible a guilty conjurer might use magical arts and enchantments to make innocent people appear as if they are afflicting those whom the devil and the conjurer are actually tormenting.
Argument #5: The truth we affirm is so evident that many learned and judicious men have freely agreed to it.
The memorable story of the Devil taking the shape of an innocent citizen in Zurich is considered important by the great theologian Lud Lavater. He mentions it to caution judges in such cases, as the Devil often entangles innocent people and causes them great trouble. His words are, "Hanc Historiam ideo recito, ut Judices, in hujusmodi, Casibus cauti sint: Diabolus enim hac via sæpe innocentibus insidiatur." He supports his statement by recounting a story from Alertus Granzius, who writes that the Devil was seen in the shape of a nobleman coming out of the Empress's chamber. To prove her innocence, she walked blindfold over many glowing hot irons without touching any of them, according to the superstitious ordeals of that time. Voetius, in his Disputation of Spectres, raises the question of whether the Devil can falsely impersonate a godly person and answers affirmatively. He adds that it is a strong argument against the Papists, using their own histories, which include instances of Satan appearing as saints or even Christ himself. In his discourse on the Operations of Demons, he poses a similar question about whether the Devil can take the shape of a true believer, a real saint, whether dead or alive, and answers, "Quidni?" or "Why not?"
Although Popish casuists generally lean towards the negative on this question, the example of Germanus, who saw a group of honest people represented by the Devil as if they were feasting together while they were actually asleep in their beds, challenges them. They conclude, "That by an extraordinary Permission of God, innocent Persons may be represented by Satan in the Nocturnal Conventicles of Witches," and if so, much more in afflicting bewitched persons. Delrio gives an account of an innocent monk whose reputation was endangered by a demon appearing in his shape. He writes more like a theologian than Jesuits usually do when he says, "It is not absolutely to be denied, but that the Devils may exhibit the Forms of innocent Persons, if God permit it, who when he does permit it, usually by some Providence discovers the Fraud of the Devils, that so the Innocent may be vindicated, or if not, it is to bring them to repentance for some Sin, or to try their Patience." It is rare to see such words from a Jesuit.
As for Protestant writers, I cannot recall any of note who deny the possibility of the affirmative in this question. Dr. Henkelius recently published a learned and detailed discourse on the right method of curing those obsessed with demons, asserting that "Satan may possibly assume the Form of innocent and pious Persons, that so he might thereby destroy their Reputations, and expose them to undue Punishments." Regarding English theologians, few are greater casuists than Mr. Perkins, and I know of no one who has written on witchcraft with more judgment and clarity. He states, "If a Man being dangerously sick and like to die upon suspicion, will take it on his death, that such an one has bewitched him, it is an allegation which may move the Judge to examine the Party, but it is of no moment for Conviction." Similarly, Mr. Cooper and Mr. Bernard, once a famous minister at Batcomb in Somerset, wrote a book called "A Guide to Grand Jury-men in Cases of Witchcraft," a solid and wise treatise. His judgment on the current debate can be seen on pages 209 and 210, where he says, "An Apparation of the Party suspected, whom the Afflicted in their Fits seem to see, is a great suspicion; yet this is but a presumption, tho' a strong one, because these Apparitions are wrought by the Devil, who can represent to the Phansie such as the Parties use to fear, in which his representation he may well lye as in his other Witness: For if the Devil can represent to the Witch a seeming Samuel, saying, I see Gods ascending out of the Earth, to beguile Saul, may we not think he can represent a common ordinary Person, Man or Woman unregenerate, tho' no Witch to the Phansie of vain Persons, to deceive them and others that will give Credit to the Devil." Thus Mr. Bernard.
As for the judgment of the elders in New England, as far as I can learn, they generally agree with Mr. Perkins and Mr. Bernard. I know that at a meeting of ministers at Cambridge on August 1, 1692, where seven elders were present along with the president of the college, the question discussed was, "Whether the Devil may not sometimes have a permission to represent an innocent person as tormenting those under diabolical molestations?" The answer they all agreed on was, "That the Devil may sometimes have a permission to represent an innocent person as tormenting those under diabolical molestations; but that such things are rare and extraordinary, especially when such matters come before civil judiciaries." I am assured that some of the most eminent ministers in the land, who were not at that meeting, hold the same judgment. I am also sure that in cases of this nature, "the priest's lips should keep knowledge, and they should seek the law at his mouth" (Mal. 2:7).
Argument #6: Our own experience has confirmed the truth of what we affirm.
In another book, I have given an account about Elizabeth Knap of Groton, who claimed that a woman, known for her piety as much as anyone in that town, appeared to her and tormented her. However, she later realized that this person never harmed her and that it was the devil who deceived them both. About two years ago, a bewitched person in Chelmsford, during her fits, complained that a worthy good man, a close relative of hers, was afflicting her. She also made the same complaint about another person in that town who was known for integrity and piety.
I have personally known several people who I believe are now in Heaven, considering they lived good lives and were thought to be pious by those who knew them well. However, some of these people complained that their shapes appeared to them and threatened them. This can't be explained by saying we don't know if those people might have been witches. We are bound by the rule of charity to think otherwise. Those who judge others merely because they are falsely represented by Satan do not treat others as they would want to be treated. I thank the Lord that neither I nor any of my relatives have been abused in this way. But no one knows what may happen to them, since "there are just men unto whom it happeneth according to the work of the wicked" (Eccles. 8:14). What more needs to be said, since there is someone among us who no one who knows him can think is a wizard, yet some bewitched people complained that they are tormented by his shape. The devils have recently accused some prominent people.
It is a terrible thing that the Lord has done to convince some among us of their error. So, I declare and testify that taking away the life of anyone merely because a spectre or devil, in a bewitched or possessed person, accuses them will bring the guilt of innocent blood on the land where such a thing is done. May mercy prevent this from happening, and I trust that, as it has not happened yet, it never will in New England. What does such evidence amount to more than this: Either someone afflicted another person, or the devil did it in their likeness, or the person's eyes were bewitched.
CASE 2: IS THE "LOOK AND TOUCH" TEST INFALLIBLE PROOF?
The things that have been mentioned lead us to the second case, which we need to consider, namely,
If someone who is bewitched falls down at the look or gaze of another person, and then recovers after being touched by that same person, isn't this undeniable proof that the person suspected and accused is in league with the devil?
Answer: It must be acknowledged that witchcraft and witches have been discovered through such means more than once or twice. An ill reputation or other circumstances surrounding the suspected person may be grounds for examination, but this alone does not provide enough evidence for conviction. For example, specters or devils appearing in the shapes of murdered men, declaring they were murdered by certain people in specific places, may give the magistrate just cause to investigate. One prominent witch advocate admits that murders have been uncovered this way; yet, if other circumstances do not align, this alone would not, by God's law, justify taking a man's life. If my reader wishes, they can hear what old Mr. Bernard of Batcomb says about a similar case. His words are these: "The naming of the suspected in their fits, and also where they have been, and what they have done here or there, as Mr. Throgmorton's children could do, and that often and ever found true; this is a great presumption: yet is this but a presumption, because this is only the devil's testimony, who can lie, and that more often than speak truth. Christ would not allow his witness of him in a point most true; nor St. Paul in the due praises of him and Silas; his witness then may not be received as sufficient in case of one's life: He may accuse an innocent, as I showed before in Mr. Edmund's giving over his practice to find stolen goods; and Satan, we read, would accuse Job to God himself to be a hypocrite, and to be ready to be a blasphemer, and he is called the accuser of the brethren. Albeit, I cannot deny but this has very often proved true, yet seeing the devil is such an one as you heard, Christian men should not take his witness, to give in verdict upon oath, and so swear that the devil has therein spoken the truth; be it far from good men to confirm any word of the devil by oath, if it be not an evident truth without the devil's testimony, who in speaking the truth, has a lying intent, and speaks some truths of things done, which may be found to be so, that he may wrap with them some pernicious lie, which cannot be tried to be true, but must rest upon his own testimony to ensnare the blood of the innocent." Thus Mr. Bernard resolved the case over sixty years ago; and truly, in my opinion, like a wise and orthodox divine. What he says applies to both this and the former case. Dr. Cotta, a learned physician, in his book about "The Trial of Witchcraft, showing the true and right method of the discovery, with a confutation of erroneous ways" (which book he dedicates to the Right Honourable Sir Edward Cook, Lord Chief Justice of England), discusses the exploration of witches by the touch of the witch curing the touched bewitched, and shows the fallibility and vanity of that method of trial, even though he had often seen people bewitched in that way immediately delivered from the present fit or agony upon them. But he considers it a diabolical miracle. He argues thus: "No man can doubt but that the virtue wherewith this touch was endowed is supernatural: If it be so, how can man, to whom nothing is simply possible that is not natural, be justly reputed an agent therein? If he cannot be esteemed in himself any possible or true agent, then it remains that he can only be interested therein as an accessory in consent, or as a servant unto a superior power: If that superior power be the devil, the least reasonable doubt, whether the devil alone, or with the consent or contract of the suspected person has produced that wonderful effect; with what religion or reason can any man incline rather to credit the devil's mouth in the bewitched, than to pity the accused, and believe them against the subtlety of a deceitful devil: If the devil by divine permission may cause supernatural concomitances and consequences to attend the natural actions of men without their allowance, as is manifest in possessed persons, how is it reasonable and just that the impositions of the devil should be imputed unto any man: And (says he) God forbid that the devil's signs and wonders, nay his truths should become any legal allegations or evidences in law. We may therefore conclude it unjust, that the forenamed miraculous effect by the devil wrought and imputed by the bewitched, should be esteemed an infallible mark against any man, as therefore convinced for that the devil and the bewitched have so deciphered him!" Thus speaks that learned man. But regarding the case at hand, I have several things to offer.
1. It is possible that the people in question may be possessed by evil spirits: It is certain that people who are bewitched are often truly possessed by evil spirits. As Mr. Perkins notes, no one can prove that witchcraft wasn't the cause of many of the possessions mentioned in the Gospel. Histories and experiences show that devils have been sent into the bodies of unfortunate people by magicians and witches. Hierom tells of a virgin who was possessed by an evil spirit sent by a magician after she rejected a young man's advances. It's reported that Simon Magus, after performing a hellish sacrifice to get revenge on those who called him a great witch, caused infernal spirits to enter them. Many confessing witches have admitted to causing certain people to be possessed by evil angels, as noted by Thyræus and others. We should not trust what demons say through those they possess. Our Savior has shown us by example not to accept the devil's testimony in anything. The Papists are rightly condemned for using diabolical testimony to support their religious beliefs. Peter Cotton, the Jesuit, asked the devil in a possessed person what the clearest scripture was to prove purgatory. When Luther died, all the possessed people in the Netherlands were quiet; the devils in them said it was because Luther had been a great friend of theirs, and they wanted to attend his funeral in Germany. Another time, when discussing ministers of the Reformed Religion, the devils in the possessed laughed and said they were not afraid of them because the Calvinists and they were good friends. The Jesuits boast about these testimonies as if they were divine oracles, but the father of lies is never to be believed. He will tell twenty great truths to pave the way for one lie. He will accuse twenty witches if it helps bring one innocent person into trouble. He mixes truths with lies so that the truths lend credibility to the lies, leading people to believe both and be deceived. Some say the people in question are only bewitched and not possessed, but consider that possessed people are called Energumens Agitor: Those whose bodies are unnaturally agitated, to the point of being in danger of being thrown into fire or water, though they may be bewitched, are undoubtedly possessed by demons (Mark 9:22, 25). Learned men consider it a certain sign of possession when the afflicted person can see and hear things no one else can perceive, and when they can reveal secret things (Acts 16:16), past or future, like a possessed person in Germany who foretold the war that broke out in 1546. When the limbs of afflicted people are bent and disjointed in ways that would be impossible without dislocating joints, unless done by a supernatural force, and yet no harm is caused, that indicates possession. Also, when people are thrown into fits by the devil, during which they speak of things they later have no memory of, or if they are tortured by cruel devils causing horrendous cries, that's another sign of possession by evil spirits. If all these things are present in the people in question, we can conclude they are possessed by demons. If so, no juror can, with a clear conscience, consider the testimony of such people sufficient to take away a person's life.
2. Falling down by the cast of an eye comes not from a natural, but an arbitrary cause; not from any poison in the eye of the witch, but from the agency of some demon. The belief in fascination by the eye is an old fable, and (says Mr. Perkins) as foolish as it is old. Pliny speaks of a people that killed folks by looking at them; and he adds that they had two pupils in each eye. Tully writes of women who had two pupils in one eye that always caused harm with their mere looks; so Ovid says, "Pupula duplex fulminat." And Plutarch writes that some people have such poison in their eyes that their friends and familiars are fascinated by them; he even speaks of one who bewitched himself sick by looking at his own face in a mirror. Others write of fascination by merely speaking words; and for all I know, there may be as much witchery in the tongue as there is in the eye. Sennertus has exposed the superstition of these ideas; sight does not proceed from an emission of rays from the eye, but by a reception of the visible species; and if it is (as philosophers conclude) an innocent action and not an emission of optic spirits, so that sight as such receives something from the object and does not act upon it, the notion of fascination by the eye is unphilosophical. It is true that sore eyes will affect those who look at them, "Dum spectant oculi læsos, leduntur et ipsi," for which a natural reason is easily given; but if the witches' eyes are thus infected with a natural contagion, why is it that only bewitched persons are harmed by them? If the common error concerning the basilisk's killing with the look of its poisonous eye were true, whoever that serpent looked at would be poisoned. So if witches had a physical venom in their eyes, others as well as fascinated persons would be affected by it; there is as much truth in this idea of physical venom in the eye of a witch as there is in what Pliny and others say about the Thibians, namely, that they have two pupils in one eye and the image of a horse in the other eye; and that they are a people who cannot be drowned.
3. As for the matter concerning the bewitched persons being recovered from their agonies by the touch of the suspected party, it is varied and unreliable.
In some cases, the afflicted person becomes sick (instead of being healed) when touched by the accused. Sometimes, the power of imagination is so strong that the touch of an innocent person, who is not accused, can have the same effect. In the account of the trials of witches at Bury in Suffolk in 1664, during the trial, some experiments were conducted with the afflicted individuals by having the accused touch them. It was observed that with just the slightest touch from one of the supposed witches, those in their fits, who seemed to be completely deprived of all sense and understanding, would suddenly shriek and open their hands.
Mr. Sergeant Keeling did not think there was enough evidence to convict the prisoners. He said that even if the children were truly bewitched, it couldn't be attributed to the prisoners based solely on the imagination of the afflicted parties. If that were allowed, no one would be safe, as they might wrongly accuse an innocent person. To address this concern, the judge privately requested that some gentlemen in the court attend to one of the afflicted persons in another part of the hall while she was having her fits. They then brought one of the accused witches to her to see what would happen. They covered the afflicted maid's eyes with an apron, and then another person, not the witch, touched her, which caused the same reaction as when the witch touched her in court. The gentlemen returned unsatisfied with the results. Bodin relates that a witch tried at Nantes was ordered by the judges to touch a bewitched person, a practice often used by judges in Germany's Imperial Chamber. The witch was extremely reluctant, but when forced by the judges, she cried out, "I am undone," and as soon as she touched the afflicted person, the witch fell down dead, and the other recovered. The notorious witch of Salisbury, Ann Bodenham, who had been a servant to the infamous conjurer Dr. Lamb, couldn't bear the sight of someone bewitched by her. As soon as she saw the afflicted person, she ran around shrieking and crying, claiming the devil would tear her apart if that person came near her. While the witch was in torment, the bewitched person was at ease. These examples show that the laws and customs of the kingdom of darkness are not always the same everywhere.
It is good for people to involve themselves with them as little as possible.
I think there is weight in Dr. Cotta's argument, namely,
The gift of healing the sick and possessed was a special grace and favor from God, meant to confirm the truth of the Gospel. However, the idea that such a gift should be linked to the touch of wicked witches as an undeniable sign of their guilt is hard to believe. It is well known that if a person possessed by an evil spirit becomes very agitated while a good person is praying with and for the afflicted, and if the good person lays their hand on them, the evil spirit becomes calm. I hope this is not seen as evidence of any agreement or voluntary connection between the good person praying and the evil spirit; similarly, the situation we are discussing does not prove any such thing.
4. There are those who question the lawfulness of the experiment. If this healing power in the witch is not a divine but a diabolical gift, it may be dangerous to meddle too much with it. If the witch can be ordered to touch afflicted persons to heal or recover them from a sick fit, why can't the diseased person be ordered to touch the witch for the same reason? And if to touch them, why not to scratch them and draw blood, which is just a harsher kind of touch? Mr. Perkins does not hesitate to call this a practice of witchcraft. It is not safe to meddle with any of the devil's sacraments or institutions. For my part, I would be reluctant to tell a man, whom I knew or thought was a witch, to look at a person and see if they could bewitch them into a fit, or to take an afflicted person by the hand and see if they could bewitch them well again. If it is by virtue of some contract with the devil that witches have the power to do such things, it is hard to see how they can be asked to do them without being too involved in that hellish covenant. I believe it to be a solid principle, as the learned Sennertus insists, that those who force another to do something which they can only do by virtue of a compact with the devil have themselves implicitly entered into a diabolical covenant. The devil is pleased and honored when any of his institutions are used; this way of discovering witches is no better than putting the urine of the afflicted person into a bottle to torment and discover the witch. The vanity and superstition of this practice I have previously shown and testified against. There was a conjurer named Edward Drake who taught a man to use that experiment for the relief of his afflicted daughter, who found benefit thereby. But we should not practice witchcraft to discover witches, nor should we use a "white healing witch" to find out a "black and bloody one." And how did people first come to know that witches would be discovered in such ways as these? If Satan himself was the first discoverer (as there is reason to believe), the experiment must be deceitful. See Dr. Willet on Exodus 7, Question 9. Such experiments are more fitting for pagans or papists than for professors in New England. While it is argued that such things are practiced by the judges of the Imperial Chamber, I reply that those judges (as Bodin relates, Lib. 3. Dæmon. Cap. 6) have required suspected witches to pronounce over the afflicted persons, "I bless thee in the Name of the Father, &c.," upon which they have immediately recovered. But is the dark day upon us that such superstitions as these shall be practiced in New England? The Lord Jesus forbid it.
5. If the testimony of a bewitched or possessed person is valid regarding what they see happening to themselves, then it should be valid for others whom they see afflicted just as much as themselves. But what they say about others should not be taken as evidence. Where did they get this supernatural sight? It must be either from Heaven or from Hell. If from Heaven, like Elisha's servant and Balaam's donkey who could discern angels, let their testimony be accepted. But if they got this knowledge from Hell, even if there might be truth in what they say, they are not legal witnesses. For the law of God allows no revelation from any spirit but Himself (Isa. 8:19). It is a sin against God to use the devil's help to know what cannot be otherwise known, and I testify against it as a great transgression, which may justly provoke the Holy One of Israel to let loose devils on the whole land (Luke 4:35). See Mr. Bernard's Guide to Juries in Cases of Witchcraft, p. 136, 137, 138, and Brockmand, Theol. de Angelis, p. 227. Although the devil's accusations may be considered enough to cause an inquiry into the truth of things (Job 1:11-12; 2:5-6), they should not be used as evidence or grounds for conviction. The people in question see things through diabolical means, which makes their evidence not purely human testimony. If any part of it is diabolical, it should not be accepted as authentic, for the devil's testimony should not be received, neither in whole nor in part.
6. Some credible people have told me, and they say it's definitely true, that a bewitched person complained she was thrown into fits by the look of a dog. She couldn't bear the sight of that dog any more than she could bear the sight of the person she accused of bewitching her. As a result, the dog was shot to death. This dog wasn't a devil, because if it were, they wouldn't have been able to kill it. I don't think anyone would claim that dogs are witches. Therefore, being cast down by a look is not a certain sign of a witch.
7. It has always been said that finding witches is a difficult task. However, if simply seeing a person causing harm, or their look or touch, is considered undeniable proof of their guilt in witchcraft, then discovering them becomes the easiest thing in the world. This is because it is immediately apparent, and no further investigation is needed.
8. Let them say this is an infallible proof, produce any word from the Law of God which even slightly supports that assertion: The Word of God instructs jurors and judges to proceed based on clear human testimony (Deut. 19:15). But the Word nowhere gives us the slightest hint that everyone is a witch if a bewitched person falls into fits at their look; nor does it suggest that any other means should be used for discovering witches than those used for finding murderers, adulterers, and other criminals.
9. Sometimes natural aversions have strange and unexplainable effects. I've read about a man who would fall into fits at the sight of his own son, who was not a wizard. Some people find themselves naturally averse to certain individuals they've never met before, and they can't explain it any better than the person in Martial's writings about Sabidius.
"I do not love you, Sabidius, and I cannot say why."
Some people, when they see animals like cats or spiders, or even things like cheese, milk, or apples, will have fits. This is too well-known to be denied. Pensingius, in his learned discourse "De Pulvere Sympathetico," page 128, mentions someone in the city of Groning who couldn't stand the sight of a pig's head. He also knew another person who couldn't even look at a picture of it. Amatus Lusitanus talks about someone who would faint at the sight of a rose. This shows that having a fit at the sight of another person is not always a sign of witchcraft. It might come from nature and the power of imagination.
To conclude, wise theologians have determined that using methods to gain knowledge of something, which have no natural power or divine institution, is essentially turning to the devil for discovery. There is no natural power in a person's look or touch to bewitch another, nor is this a divinely instituted way to discover witchcraft. Therefore, it is an unjustifiable practice.
We now move on to the third case for consideration: If the things previously mentioned are not infallible proofs of guilt for the accused party, the question is then asked whether there are any discoveries of this crime that jurors and judges can safely use to convict and condemn the persons under suspicion?
Let me here begin with two things,
1. The evidence in this crime should be as clear as in any other crimes of a serious nature. The Word of God does not suggest anywhere that less clear evidence, or fewer or different witnesses, may be considered sufficient to convict a person of sorcery, which would not be enough to convict them if they were charged with another crime deserving of death (Num. 35:30). If we cannot accept the testimony of a disturbed person or a possessed person in a case of murder, theft, or any other felony, then we should not do so in the case of witchcraft.
2. Let me also say that there have been methods of testing witches used in many nations, especially during the dark times of paganism and Catholicism, which the righteous God never approved of. As the wise Mr. Perkins puts it in plain English, these methods were invented by the Devil so that innocent people might be condemned, and some notorious witches might escape. Many superstitious and magical experiments have been used to test witches. These include scratching the witch, boiling the urine of the bewitched person, or making a witch-cake with that urine. Other methods include putting their hands into scalding water to see if it will not hurt them, sticking an awl under the seat of the suspected person, and tying their hands and feet and casting them on the water to see whether they will sink or swim. I publicly expressed my opposition to this superstition in a book printed in Boston eight years ago.
I hear that recently some people in a neighboring colony have been experimenting with this diabolical invention. It is regrettable that in a land of righteousness like New England once was, a practice that Protestant writers generally condemn as sinful, and which even the more sober and learned men among Catholics have not only judged unlawful but, in their own words, consider to be no less than a mortal sin, should ever be heard of. If it weren't for the belief that the coming of Christ to judge the Earth is near, I would think that such practices are an unfortunate sign that the Devil and pagans might reclaim these dark territories. But so that I am not thought to have no reason for questioning the experiment in question, I have these additional points to argue against it.
1. It has been rejected long ago by Christian nations as something superstitious and diabolical. In Italy and Spain, it is completely unused; and in the Low Countries and in France, where the judges are men of learning. In some parts of Germany, old pagan customs are observed more than in other countries. Nevertheless, all the academies throughout Germany have disapproved of this method of purgation.
2. The Devil is involved in all superstition, and when hidden things or secret crimes are uncovered through superstitious practices, it is due to some agreement and connection with the Devil, as Augustine has rightly suggested. This is the case here; if a witch cannot be drowned, it must be due to some natural cause, which it is not, because it is against nature for human bodies, when hands and feet are tied, not to sink under water. Additionally, those who support this superstition claim that if witches are condemned for some other crime and not for witchcraft, they will not float like a cork above water. This shows that the cause of this floating is not physical. If it is not physical, then it must either be a divine miracle to save a witch from drowning, or it must be a diabolical wonder. This superstitious experiment is commonly known as "The Vulgar Probation" because it was never appointed by any lawful authority, but rather taken up by the suggestion of the Devil and the uneducated masses. Some learned men believe that the first person to test this (being a white witch) explicitly made a pact with the Devil to reveal hidden crimes in this way. It is by the power of that first contract that the Devil works to keep his servants from sinking when this ceremony is used. Moreover, we know that "Diabolus est Dei Simia," meaning the Devil seeks to imitate divine miracles. We read in church history that some martyrs, when ordered by persecutors to be drowned, proved to be unsinkable. The Devil tries to imitate this miracle by causing witches, who are his martyrs, not to sink when they are thrown into the water.
3. This method of purification is similar to the old ordeals of the pagans. If people were accused of a crime, to prove their innocence, they had to hold a hot iron in their hands or have scalding water poured down their throats, and if they were unharmed, they were acquitted. This was the Devil's invention, and many times (as the Devil would have it) those who underwent these trials suffered no harm. Nevertheless, it is astonishing to think about the innocent blood that has been shed in the world because of this Satanic device. Witches have often (as Sprenger observes) requested to be judged by this trial by hot iron and sometimes emerged unscathed. Indeed, this ordeal was used in other cases, not just in cases of witchcraft. Similarly, the common test of casting into water was practiced on people accused of other crimes as well as witchcraft. How it came to be restricted to witchcraft, I cannot say; it is as supernatural for a body with tied hands and feet to float above water as it is for their hands not to feel a red-hot iron. If one of these ordeals is lawful to use, then so is the other. But since the fiery ordeal is rejected and abandoned worldwide, the trial by water should be as well.
4. It is tempting God when people put the innocence of others to such tests; asking the Almighty to show a miracle to clear the innocent or convict the guilty is a very presumptuous way of tempting Him. Wasn't it a miracle when Peter was kept from sinking in the water by the power of Christ? As for Satan, we know that his ambition is to make his followers believe that his power is equal to God's, and therefore he can preserve whomever he pleases. I have read about certain magicians who were seen walking on water. If guilty people float on the water, either it is the Devil causing them to do so (as it no doubt is), and what business do people have setting the Devil to work; or it is a divine miracle, like when Peter didn't sink, or when the iron floated at Elisha's word (2 Kings 6:6). And should people test whether God will perform a miracle to reveal something? If a crime can only be discovered by a miracle, it is not for any earthly judge to take on the judgment that is reserved for the Divine Throne.
5. This supposed gift of not sinking that witches have is a very unreliable and misleading thing; many witches have actually sunk under the water. Godelmannus gives an account of six well-known and clearly convicted witches who, when subjected to the common test, sank under the water like other people. Althusius confirms the same about others. In the Bohemian history, it is mentioned that Uratslaus, the King of Bohemia, eradicated witches from his kingdom; some he executed by the axe, others he burned, and some he had drowned. If witches cannot sink, how did they die by drowning in Bohemia? Moreover, it has sometimes been observed that people who floated on the water when the executioner tested them have sunk like a stone when others tried the experiment.
6. The reasons commonly given for this superstition are not convincing. It's said that witches hate water, but there have been many times when they have asked to be thrown into water to prove their innocence. Some claim that because water is used in baptism, witches float. This is a weak idea; not all water in the world is holy water. Can't witches eat bread or drink wine, even though these elements are used in the Blessed Sacrament? Some say that devils make witches so light by sucking on them that they float on water, but some witches are twice as heavy as many innocent people. Well, if they are possessed by the devil, is the devil afraid that if they sink, he will drown with them? But then, why were the Gadarene pigs drowned when the devil was in them? (Matt. 8:32)
These things being stated, I answer the question affirmatively: "There are proofs for the conviction of witches which jurors may, with a clear conscience, proceed upon to find them guilty." The scripture that says, "Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live," clearly implies that some people in the world can be known and proven to be witches. Until they are proven to be witches, they may and must be allowed to live. Moreover, we find in scripture that some have been convicted and executed for being witches: "Saul cut off those that had familiar spirits, and the wizards out of the land" (1 Sam. 28:9).
It may be surprising that Saul, who acted like someone who said, "If I can't bend the heavens, I'll move the underworld," would order the execution of the wizards in the land. The Jewish rabbis say the reason was that those wizards predicted David would become king. Some learned Protestants, as Mr. Gaul notes, believe that Saul, in his zeal, went too far and that under the pretext of targeting witches, he killed the Gibeonites, which led to the judgment mentioned in 2 Samuel 21:1. Mr. Gaule also says, "Neither do we lack examples of God's judgments upon those who defamed, prosecuted, and executed people as witches who were not." However, we have an example in Scripture of a better man than Saul to encourage us to investigate wizards and witches for their conviction and execution. This was done by the greatest king who ever lived, Josiah, as recorded in 2 Kings 23:24. "The workers with familiar spirits and the wizards that were found in the land of Judah, Josiah put away, that he might perform the words of the law." It seems there were some who tried to hide these workers of iniquity, but that remarkable king found them out and rid the land and the world of them.
Question: But then the question is, what is sufficient proof?
Answer: This case has been wisely answered by several of our own theologians, particularly by Mr. Perkins and Mr. Bernard. Also, Mr. John Gaul, a respected minister at Staughton in the County of Huntington, has published a very insightful discourse called "Select Cases of Conscience Touching Witches and Witchcrafts," printed in London in 1646. In this work, he prudently and scripturally addresses this and other cases. I advise any jurors who can obtain these books to read them and seriously consider them in the fear of God. As long as they adhere to the law and testimony and speak according to that Word, accept the light they offer. However, since these books are now rare, let me express my agreement with them in these two points.
1. That a free and voluntary confession of the crime made by the person suspected and accused after examination is a sufficient ground for conviction.
If people are mentally disturbed or suffering from severe melancholy, that changes the situation. However, the jurors who examine them and their neighbors who know them can easily determine that situation. If a confession is forced, the evidence is not as clear and convincing. But if people, out of remorse of conscience or a touch from God in their spirits, confess and reveal their deeds, like the converted magicians in Ephesus did (Acts 19:18-19), nothing can be more clear. Suppose a man is suspected of murder, rape, or similar terrible wickedness. If he freely confesses to the accusation, that's enough ground to condemn him. The scripture approves of judging the wicked servant out of his own mouth (Luke 19:22). Some object that people in distress might falsely accuse themselves. I say, if they do so and it cannot be proven that they are false accusers of themselves, they ought to die for their wickedness, and their blood will be on their own heads; the jury, the judges, and the land are clear. I have read a very sad and amazing, yet true story related to this.
In the year 1649, in a town called Lauder in Scotland, a woman was accused and imprisoned on suspicion of witchcraft. When others in the same prison were convicted and their execution was scheduled for the following Monday, she asked to speak with a minister. She confessed to being guilty of witchcraft and admitted to many other crimes, expressing a desire to die with the others. She specifically mentioned that she had made a pact with the devil about twenty years earlier, that he had kissed her and given her a name, but had not acknowledged her since. Several ministers, suspecting that she was falsely accusing herself, warned her that she might be under a temptation from the devil to destroy her own body and soul. They urged her in the name of God to tell the truth. Despite this, she firmly stuck to her confession and was condemned and ordered to be executed on Monday. At the place of execution, she remained silent until the prayers were finished. Then, as she approached the stake where she was to be burned, she declared, "All you that see me this day! Know ye that I am to die as a witch, by my own confession! and I free all men, especially the ministers and magistrates, from the guilt of my blood. I take it wholly on myself, and as I must make answer to the God of Heaven, I declare I am as free from witchcraft as any child, but being accused by a malicious woman, and imprisoned under the name of a witch, my husband and friends disowned me. Seeing no hope of ever being in credit again, through the temptation of the devil, I made that confession to destroy my own life, being weary of it, and choosing rather to die than to live." Her sorrowful speech astonished all the spectators, and few could hold back tears. The truth of this account is certainly attested by a worthy divine now living, who was an eyewitness to the whole matter. But thus did that miserable creature suffer death, and this was a just execution. When the Amalekite confessed that he killed Saul, whom he had no legal authority to meddle with, although it's probable he lied, David ordered his execution and said to him, "Thy blood be upon thy head, for thy mouth hath testified against thee" (2 Sam. 1:16). However, the testimony of confessing witches against others is not as clear as against themselves. They are not such credible witnesses as is desired in a case of life and death. It is beyond dispute that the devil makes his witches dream strange things of themselves and others that are not true. There was, as reliable authors relate, an apparent sumptuous feast prepared, with wine and meat set forth in vessels of gold. A certain person whom an amorous young man had fallen in love with was represented and supposed to be really there. But Apollonius of Tyana discovered the witchery of the business, and in an instant, all vanished, leaving nothing but dirty coals. A similar case is mentioned in the Arausican Council. Certain women imagined they rode upon beasts at night, with Diana and Herodius in their company, along with a troop of other persons. The council gave this judgment: "Satan, who transforms himself into an angel of light, transforms himself into the likeness of various persons and deludes the souls he holds captive with dreams and fantasies." What credit can be given to those who say they can turn men into horses? If so, they could as well turn horses into men. But all the witches on earth, in conjunction with all the devils in hell, can never make or unmake a rational soul, and therefore they cannot transform a brute into a man, nor a man into a brute. This transmutation is fantastical. The devil may and often does deceive the imaginations of his witches and vassals, making them believe they are transformed into beasts and then back into men. As Nebuchadnezzar, while under the power of a demon, truly imagined himself to be an ox and would lie outdoors and eat grass. The devil has inflicted on many a man the disease called lycanthropy, causing them to lament being wolves. In short, there is no more reality in what many witches confess about strange things seen or done by them while Satan had them in his full power than there is in Lucian's ridiculous fable of being bewitched into an ass and the strange feats he then played. Therefore, what such persons relate concerning people and things at witch meetings should not be received with too much credulity.
I could mention terrible instances of innocent blood being shed because of the lies of some confessing witches. There is a very sad story mentioned in the preface to the relation of the witchcrafts in Sweden, about how in the year 1676, at Stockholm, a young woman accused her own mother (who had indeed been a very bad woman, but not guilty of witchcraft) and swore that she had taken her to the nocturnal meetings of witches, upon which the mother was burned to death. Soon after, the daughter came crying and howling before the judges in open court, declaring that to get revenge on her mother for an offense received, she had falsely accused her of a crime she was not guilty of; for which she also was justly executed. A most wicked man in France freely confessed himself to be a magician and accused many others, whose lives were taken from them; and a whole province was nearly ruined because of it, but the impostor was discovered. The confessing pretended wizard was burned at Paris in the year 1668. I will only further mention an awful example noted by A. B. Spotswood in his History of Scotland, page 449. His words are these: "This summer (Anno 1597) there was a great business for the trial of witches. Among others, one Margaret Atkin being apprehended on suspicion and threatened with torture, did confess herself guilty. Being examined about her associates in that trade, she named a few, and perceiving her accusations were believed, offered to detect all of that sort and to purge the country of them, so she might have her life granted. For the reason of her knowledge, she said, 'That they had a secret mark all of that sort in their eyes, whereby she could surely tell, as soon as she looked upon any, whether they were witches or not.' And in this, she was so readily believed that for the space of 3 or 4 months, she was carried from town to town to make discoveries of that kind. Many were brought into question by her accusations, especially at Glasgow, where several innocent women, through the credulity of the minister Mr. John Cowper, were condemned and put to death. In the end, she was found to be a mere deceiver and sent back to Fife, where she was first apprehended. At her trial, she affirmed all to be false that she had confessed of herself or others and persisted in this to her death, which made many regret their too great eagerness in that way and moved the king to recall his commission given out against such persons, discharging all proceedings against them, except in the case of a voluntary confession, until a solid order should be taken by the estates regarding the form that should be kept in their trial." Thus that famous historian.
2. If two credible people testify under oath that they have seen the accused person saying words or doing things that only those with familiarity with the devil could say or do, that's sufficient grounds for conviction.
Some people might argue that wizards aren't foolish enough to perform their acts in front of others, but it's certain that they have often been caught doing so. How often have they been seen by others using enchantments, conjuring storms, or heard calling upon their familiar spirits? They've been known to use spells and charms, show people in a glass or a show-stone who are absent, and reveal secrets that only the devil could uncover. Haven't people been seen doing things beyond human strength, things no one could do without diabolical help? Claudia was witnessed by many pulling a ship that no human strength could move. Tuccia, a Vestal Virgin, was seen carrying water in a sieve. The devil never helps people do supernatural things without being asked. Therefore, when such acts are testified against the accused by real men or women who can be trusted, and not by spectres, which are devils in the shape of living or dead people, it is enough proof that the accused has had dealings with the devil and should be removed from society. However, I will add this: it is better for ten suspected witches to escape than for one innocent person to be condemned. This is an old saying and true: "Prestat reum nocentem absolvi, quam ex prohibitis Indiciis & illegitima probatione condemnari." It is better for a guilty person to be absolved than to be condemned without sufficient evidence. I would rather judge a witch to be an honest woman than judge an honest woman as a witch. The Word of God instructs us not to execute even the most serious offenders until we have diligently searched and found the matter to be true and certain (Deut. 13:14-15).
A friend of mine in London, when describing New England, says that regarding their religion, the people there are like Mr. Perkins. It's no shame to us if that's true. I'm sorry that some among us are starting to dismiss such a great man, whom the most learned people in foreign lands speak of with admiration because of his refined and sharp judgment. He gives wise and good advice in his discussion on witchcrafts (Chapter 7, Section 2), which I will end with: "I would therefore wish and advise all jurors who give the verdict upon life and death in the court of assizes, to take good heed, that as they be diligent in zeal of God's glory, and the good of his Church, in detecting of witches, by all sufficient and lawful means, so likewise they would be careful what they do, and not to condemn any party suspected upon bare presumptions, without sound and sufficient proofs that they be not guilty through their own rashness of shedding innocent blood."
Boston, New England, October 3, 1692.
CHAPTER 16
POSTSCRIPT: FINAL REFLECTIONS ON THE TRIALS
The purpose of the previous dissertation is not to defend witchcraft or to act as an advocate for witches. I have therefore written another discourse, proving that there are indeed such horrible creatures as witches in the world, and that they should be removed and cut off from among the people of God. I plan to publish this in due time, and I am fully convinced that there have been, and still are, very cursed witches in the land. More than one or two of those now in prison have freely and credibly admitted their connection and familiarity with the spirits of darkness. They have also told me the time and occasion, along with the specific details of their evil commitments and abominations.
The intention here is not to criticize the honorable individuals involved in the recent proceedings at Salem. They are wise and good people who have acted faithfully according to their understanding, and have, out of caution, avoided doing some things they were personally convinced about. Given the challenging nature of the situation they faced, they deserve compassion and prayers rather than judgment. For this reason, I am pleased that my son has published a summary of the trials of some who were recently executed. I hope this will assure thoughtful people that there was more than just "spectral evidence" for convicting the condemned. I was not present at any of the trials except for one, specifically that of George Burroughs. Had I been one of his judges, I could not have acquitted him. Several people testified under oath that they saw him do things that no man without a devil as his companion could do. The judges assert that they have not convicted anyone solely based on what specters have said or what has been shown to the eyes or imaginations of the afflicted. If what is shared here can help prevent future occurrences, I will not regret my efforts in this undertaking. I have been compelled, as far as I can discern the truth in these complex cases, to share my thoughts and the arguments that hold weight with me, hoping that what is written may help uncover the "depths of Satan" and prevent innocent people from having their lives endangered or reputations ruined by being, through the cunning and power of devils, along with the ignorance and weakness of humans, wrongly implicated among the guilty. Those in my profession should be very cautious in matters of life and death and should imitate our Lord and Master, "who came not to destroy the lives of men, but to save them" (Luke 9:56).
I also intend, in what I have written, to give my testimony against these unjustifiable ways of discovering witchcrafts, which some among us have practiced. I hear that recently there was a "witch-cake" made with the urine of bewitched creatures as one ingredient by several people in a place that has suffered much from the attack of Hell upon it. I consider this not only wicked superstition but great folly. For though the Devil sometimes operates with these experiments, it is not always the case, especially if a "magical faith" is lacking. I will take this opportunity to share some passages from a letter I received from the eminent, pious, and learned man, Mr. Samuel Cradock, during my stay in London. The letter is dated February 26, 1690. Here it is in his own words: "We have at this present one in our next town, who has a son with strange fits, which they attribute to witchcraft. He came to consult with me about it, but before he came, he had used a means which I would never have directed him to, namely, he took the nails of his son's hands and feet, and some of his hair, and mixed them in rye paste with his water, and set it all by the fire until it was consumed. His son (as he says) was well after and free from his fits for a whole month, but then they came again. He tried that means a second time, and then it would not work. He moved his son into Cambridgeshire, the next county, and then he was well, but as soon as he brought him home, he was afflicted as before. The boy says he saw a thing like a mole following him, which once spoke to him and told him it came to do the office it was to do. I advised his father to make use of the medicine prescribed by our Saviour, namely, fasting and prayer (Matt. 17:21). Here have been others in this town who, though they were under 'ill-handling,' as they call it: one family had their milk so affected that they could not possibly make any cheese, but it swelled and was good for nothing. They are now rid of that trouble, but how they got rid of it, I do not know." Thus my letter. By which it is evident that towns in England, as well as New England, are troubled by demons. I only wish that the superstitions practiced in other places to get rid of such troublesome guests had never been known, much less used among us or them.
Some people, I hear, have gotten the idea that the book recently published by my son contradicts mine. It's strange that such thoughts would occur to people. I reviewed and approved that book before it was printed, and only my relationship to him stopped me from recommending it to the world. Both my son and I agreed with the humble advice that twelve ministers collectively presented to his Excellency and Council regarding the current difficulties. Let the world judge whether there is anything in it that disagrees with what either of us has stated.
It was in the following words:
The Response of Several Ministers Consulted by His Excellency and the Honorable Council Regarding the Current Witchcrafts in Salem Village.
Boston, June 15, 1692.
1. The troubled state of our poor neighbors, who are now suffering from attacks by the Invisible World, is so distressing that we believe their condition calls for the utmost help from everyone in their various roles.
2. We must gratefully acknowledge the success that the merciful God has granted to the diligent efforts of our honorable leaders in uncovering the terrible witchcrafts committed in the country. We humbly pray that the discovery of these mysterious and harmful wickednesses may be completed.
3. We believe that in the pursuit of these and all such witchcrafts, there is a need for very careful and precise caution. This is to prevent too much credulity in things received only on the Devil's authority, which could open the door to a long series of miserable consequences and allow Satan to gain an advantage over us, for we should not be ignorant of his schemes (2 Cor. 2:11).
4. As in complaints about witchcrafts, there may be matters of inquiry that do not amount to matters of presumption, and there may be matters of presumption that may not be considered matters of conviction; it is necessary that all proceedings be handled with great care towards those who may be accused, especially if they have previously had an unblemished reputation.
5. When the first inquiry is made into the circumstances of those who may be justly suspected of witchcrafts, we wish that as little noise, company, and openness as possible be allowed, which may too hastily expose those being examined. Nothing should be used as a test for the trial of the suspected if its lawfulness is doubted among the people of God. Instead, the directions given by knowledgeable writers like Perkins and Bernard should be consulted in such cases.
6. Presumptions upon which people may be committed, and even more so convictions upon which people may be condemned as guilty of witchcrafts, should certainly be more substantial than merely the accused person being represented by a specter to the afflicted. It is an undeniable and well-known fact that a demon may, by God's permission, appear for ill purposes in the shape of an innocent and virtuous person. We cannot consider changes in the sufferers caused by a look or touch of the accused to be infallible evidence of guilt, as they are often susceptible to being manipulated by the Devil's tricks.
7. We do not know whether some notable challenges given to the devils, by our disbelief in those testimonies whose entire force and strength come from them alone, might not put an end to the dreadful calamity that has begun upon us, in the accusation of so many people, some of whom we hope are still clear of the great transgression charged against them. 8. Nevertheless, we cannot but humbly recommend to the government the swift and vigorous prosecution of those who have made themselves liable, according to the direction given in the laws of God and the wholesome statutes of the English nation, for the detection of witchcrafts.