Hell's Terror

Christopher Love

N.B. The following text was freely provided by Updated Works. Their updated books and audios are superb in every way.

"Some of the most important ideas in history are locked away in old books that modern readers struggle to understand. Archaic language, unfamiliar phrasing, and outdated conventions create unnecessary barriers to timeless wisdom.
"Updated Works exists to change that. We take significant older texts and translate them into clear, contemporary English while faithfully preserving the author's original meaning and voice. Our goal is simple: make important books readable again.
"Archaic spelling, obsolete words, and tangled sentence structure are rendered into clear, contemporary English--always preserving the author's meaning, voice, and line of argument. We modernize the language, never the message."

Please visit their website to purchase select hardcopy books and audio books: Updated Works.

 

Publisher’s Introduction

Hell’s Terror is a series of seven sermons on Matthew 10:28, preached by Christopher Love at St Lawrence Jewry in London as the deliberate companion to his ten sermons on heaven. Love, a Presbyterian minister of the Civil War years who was executed on Tower Hill for his part in a plot to restore the king, told his hearers that a minister with a mixed people must mix his doctrine, comfort for some and terror for others, and this series is the terror. He sets out who is able to destroy both body and soul in hell, what the torments of the damned are, and why the fear of God rather than the fear of men should govern a life, and he offers the whole as a preservative against the security of a careless conscience.

 

CHAPTER 1

FEAR HIM WHO CAN DESTROY THE SOUL

But rather fear him who is able to destroy both Body and Soul in Hell. (Matt 10:28)

Beloved, you may remember that I have preached ten sermons on the glorified condition of the saints in heaven. I now intend to speak of the tormented condition of the damned in hell, so that if those earlier sermons about glory did not gain your affections, this sermon on hell might startle your consciences. Ministers, having a mixed congregation, must mix their doctrine, sometimes with comfort and sometimes with terror. You have heard ten sermons on the former text; you may hear as many more on this one.

Before I give you the sense of the text, I must give you the scope of the chapter. Jesus Christ had called his twelve disciples together and commissioned them to preach the gospel throughout the regions of Judea, and, to confirm their doctrine, to work all manner of miracles, cure all manner of diseases, and cast out devils. Yet he knew, as he tells them in Matthew 10:16, that they must go as silly sheep among ravenous wolves, and that they would meet persecution and opposition in carrying on the great work of the gospel. So Christ labors in this chapter to prop up the hearts of his people with four arguments.

The first argument comes in Matthew 10:19–20: "They shall bring you before Governors for my name’s sake; but take no thought what you shall say, for it shall be given you in the same hour." It is as if Christ said: you will be called before courts of judicature for my name’s sake, for preaching my gospel, but do not worry about what you will plead for yourselves, for my Spirit will tell you what to say. In Luke 21:15 you find the same idea: "They should have a mouth, and wisdom given them" to make their defense and vindicate the gospel in their hands.

2. The second argument he brings is this: though they will meet troubles in the flesh, Christ will save their souls (Matt 10:22). If they suffer in their bodies, their soul will be saved, "for he that endures to the end shall be saved."

3. The third is that before they had preached in every city, Christ promised to come in the blessing of his Spirit and make their preaching effective for the conversion of souls (Matt 16:28). Some say this refers to the destruction of Jerusalem, but Calvin understands it as the giving of the Spirit (Matt 10:23).

4. The fourth argument comforts them with the fact that Jesus Christ was their partner in suffering. They must not expect to be above Christ, above their master (Matt 10:24): "The disciple is not above his master, nor the servant above his Lord, it is enough to be as he is." As if he said: do not be discouraged. I, your Lord and master, suffered and must suffer more, even death. So do not be discouraged, for the disciple is not above his Lord.

5. And a fifth argument stands in my text: do not be afraid, because the power of your enemies is limited. All your enemies can do reaches only the body and can never hurt your souls. Fear not him who can kill the body but not the soul. Christ tells them here whom they should, and should not, fear: "But fear him who is able to cast both body and soul into hell." Having brought you to the words, I will now give you their sense.

"But rather fear him." The word translated "rather" is not to be taken comparatively, as though you may fear men but must fear God more. It is an adversative: you are not to fear men at all, but God alone.

"But rather fear him that can kill both body and soul." "Kill" here does not mean the annihilation or destruction of the body, but the continual tormenting of body and soul under the wrath of God for all eternity. Luke explains it this way in Luke 12:5: "Who is able to cast both body and soul into hell," that is, to destroy both soul and body. It would be well for the damned if soul and body were destroyed in the sense of being annihilated. Both body and soul are mentioned because the body has been partner with the soul in sin, and so will share with it in punishment.

"Fear him that can destroy both soul and body in hell." Hell in Scripture carries four different meanings.

1. It is taken for the grave, as in Psalm 16:10: "Thou wilt not leave my soul in hell, nor suffer thy Holy One to see corruption"; that is, Christ would not lie and rot in the grave, but would rise again. The apostle Peter refers to this prophecy, that he would not see corruption nor be left in the grave (Acts 2:31–32), speaking of Christ’s resurrection from the dead.

2. Hell in Scripture is taken for the belly of the whale into which Jonah was cast. So Jonah 2:2 reads: "Out of the belly of hell I cried unto the Lord, and he heard me." Jonah was never in hell itself, but the belly of the whale was called hell because it was a dark place, as hell is. But that is not the sense meant here either.

3. Hell in Scripture is taken for the devil himself, or his malignant spirits. So (Jas 3:6): "The tongue of man is set on fire by hell," meaning not the place but the devil in hell. The devil in hell kindles the fire of an enraged and passionate spirit; the tongue is set on fire by the devil of hell.

4. Hell is taken in Scripture for the place of the damned, where God tortures and torments the souls and bodies of all the reprobate for all eternity. This sense is frequent in Scripture, as in Matthew 5:29, Luke 12:5, and Luke 16:23, and it is the sense meant here: "Fear him that can cast both body and soul into hell," that is, into that place of torment which the Lord reserves eternally for the punishment of all ungodly men and women. That is the meaning of the phrase "into hell."

The word rendered "hell" here comes from the Hebrew word gehinnom, meaning the valley of Hinnom. It was a valley near Jerusalem possessed by Hinnom or his son (Josh 15:8; Neh 11:30). Hell is named in Scripture after this place because the idolatrous Jews set up an idol there called Molech, made of brass in the form of a man, hollow within, in which they kindled a fire. Children were placed within the arms of the idol and burned. The Jews believed that a father who gave one of his children to the idol would receive a blessing on all his other children.

From this the Greek word for hell derives its meaning, carrying an allusion to that place: as there was a continual fire in that idol, along with continual shrieking and crying of children (so much so that bells were rung and instruments sounded to drown out the children’s cries), so it will be in the fiery torments of hell. The story is told at length in 2 Chronicles 33:6, 2 Kings 16:3, 2 Chronicles 28:3, Jeremiah 7:31, Jeremiah 32:35, and Leviticus 18:21. Good king Josiah destroyed this place (2 Kgs 23:10).

Having laid open the words, nothing remains but to give you the observations the text will bear. There are two observations I will draw from these words.

First, from the context, "but rather fear him," observe this:

Doctrine 1: The fear of God fences the heart against the fear of man. The more you fear God, the less you will fear men. As Isaiah 8:13 says, "Fear not their fear but sanctify the Lord in your hearts; let him be your fear, and let him be your dread." But I will pass over this point, since my only intention in handling this subject is to set before you the torments of the damned in hell.

That thought will awaken some drowsy consciences, and I trust it will deepen the joy of believers who have been delivered from these hellish torments. The observation that sums up the whole substance of this text is this:

Doctrine 2: That the consideration of this, that God has an absolute power over men and women, to cast their bodies and souls into hell, should work an awful fear of God in the hearts of his own people. This is the point, and it carries a great deal of dread and terror with it. Before I take up the doctrine directly, I must first lay down reasons why I preach on so terrible a subject, and then answer some objections that may be raised against preaching so dreadful a doctrine.

I confess this is a terrible doctrine, given the atrocity of the torments it describes.

First, the reasons why I take up this subject are four.

First, I handle it now because I have already spoken at length about the glory of the elect in heaven, for the comfort of the godly. Now I will speak of the torments of hell, for the punishment of the wicked, so that if the glory of the elect has not won your affections, hearing of the torment of the damned might startle your consciences and wake you from your security.

Second, I handle it so that none of you grow secure and presumptuous, nourishing ungrounded hopes of glory and expecting to be in glory with Jesus Christ on the strength of the previous sermons alone. To keep you from that vain hope, I thought it right to pair this subject with those sermons, so that you might be equally guarded against presumption on the one hand and despair on the other.

Third, because this is a doctrine so little preached and so little written about in our day. I know of only one English book written on this subject, by Mr. Bolton, and very few in Latin. It is a useful subject, useful for the wicked and useful for the godly, yet so little handled, and nowadays much cried down and argued against. This reason too moved me to take it up.

Fourth, I handle this doctrine because I am persuaded that if many people knew the torments of hell distinctly, they would never walk in the way of sin that leads there as they do. I believe that if this doctrine of hell were well studied and better known among the people, they would take far more care to avoid hell and gain glory than they do now.

If people knew that those who live and die unrepentant, burning in their lusts, will one day burn in fire; if they knew that those who drink bowls of wine to excess will one day drink draughts of brimstone in hell; if they knew that those who grind their teeth in hatred and indignation against the godly here will one day gnash their teeth in hell hereafter; if they knew that those who persecute and imprison God’s people now will one day be dragged into an everlasting prison and hauled by devils into hell, and that those who could not endure the company of saints on earth will be with devils and damned spirits in hell, then they would not be as profane and wicked as they now are. The lack of study of this point opens a wide gate to the world’s profaneness, and for these reasons I resolved to treat this subject.

There are two objections against preaching on a subject like this. First, some will say this is legal preaching, casting flashes of hellfire about the congregation, which is not preaching the Gospel but the law. To answer this, I will say four things.

1. Jesus Christ was surely no legal preacher, yet he preached this very doctrine, for these are Christ’s own words. Preaching of hell and its torments cannot rightly be called legal preaching, since Jesus Christ, the minister of the new covenant, preached about hell more than anyone. It is worth noting that neither the apostles nor the evangelists preached as much about hell as Jesus Christ did. Christ has seven specific texts on hell and the torments of the damned that the apostles never had. So this is not legal preaching, since it is the doctrine of Jesus Christ himself.

2. It is a great strategy of the devil to lull people into security in their sins by branding all soul-searching preaching, all sin-reproving preaching, all conscience-awakening and duty-pressing preaching as "legal preaching." It is the devil’s great strategy to attach so bad a name to so good a work.

3. If preaching of terror is legal preaching, then the law was preached more in the New Testament than it ever was under the Old. I will show this. There are more terrible and dreadful doctrines scattered through the New Testament than the Old. Chrysostom notes that the word "damnation" is never used in the entire Old Testament, but appears thirteen times in the New. It is further worth noting that in the Old Testament, though the word "hell" is often used, it most commonly refers to the grave rather than the place of the damned. In the New Testament, except in two places, "hell" is taken entirely as the place of the damned (Acts 2:27, 31). So it is plain to every eye that the Gospel is backed with more terror, and more doctrine of hell and damnation, than the law ever was. The preaching of the law has only "anathema," but the Gospel has "maranatha" too.

So all who hold the Antinomian error, crying down the pressing of duty as legal preaching, deceive themselves badly, for Christ himself, the apostles, and the evangelists all preached more of terror than any of the prophets ever did.

4. As for the claim that preaching of terror is legal preaching, I say this: sermons of terror have done more good on unconverted souls than sermons of comfort ever have. Sermons of hell have kept many people out of hell. I have read often of Mr. Throgmorton, who was converted by a sermon of terror on the text, "How shall you escape the damnation to come?" I have heard of another famous divine who tells us he was converted by the text on Christ preaching to the spirits in prison. I have heard of Mr. Greenham, a famous minister, whose conversion and first calling came from hearing a sermon on the last judgment and the torments of the damned. I have read of other ancient authors. Jerome tells us of himself, "Whether I eat or drink," he says, "I hear a voice sounding in my ears: arise, arise, you dead, and come to judgment." That very sound converted him, and many others besides.

Beloved, God has sanctified doctrines of terror for the conversion of souls more than any other doctrine in the world. It is worth noting that John the Baptist, the forerunner of Christ who prepared his way, preached as his very first sermon one of terror and coming wrath: "You generation of vipers, who has warned you to flee from the wrath to come?" And the second sermon Christ ever preached was likewise a terrible sermon about hell. As Gregory says in his Morals, we must not flee sermons about hell if we wish to flee hell itself.

Second, some may object that while preaching of hell is lawful, preaching of Christ’s love and free grace makes for more winning subjects, doctrines better suited to build upon, and better able to refresh and cheer God’s people, winning more of people’s hearts than such terrible doctrines do. To this objection I ask you to consider five things in answer.

1. It is true that if all our hearers were converted, doctrines of grace, love, and comfort might best serve their edification. But since we deal with a mixed congregation, our doctrines must be mixed as well, or we will never do them good.

2. It is true that if all people’s natures were alike, all of a soft and tender disposition, all troubled in mind and under a sense of God’s wrath, we should preach only love and only grace to lift up their hearts, for a person’s character is better guided than dragged. But Scripture tells us that people’s tempers differ: some are of a soft disposition, others of a knotty and rough spirit; some will be won by mercy, others only by judgment. Since Scripture tells us that people’s tempers vary, our doctrines must vary too, sometimes of mercy, sometimes of judgment, so that as sermons of love win over soft hearts, doctrines of terror serve for hardened spirits. "On some have compassion, making a difference; and others save with fear, pulling them out of the fire; hating the garment spotted with the flesh" (Jude 1:22–23).

Some, the apostle says, you must treat with compassion, preaching love and kindness to them; but others you must save with fire, that is, by showing them hellfire and terrifying them with the fear of God’s wrath. Some people are more yielding and tender, and these must be dealt with gently. Others, who are more stubborn and hardened sinners, must be saved with fear, pulled out of the fire of hell. That is my second answer: some people’s natures are better led than dragged, while others are so stubborn and hardened that nothing but flashes of hellfire will startle their consciences.

3. To those who argue so much for doctrines of free grace and comforting truths, insisting that such points of terror should not be preached to them, I answer that human nature is more prone to abuse doctrines of free grace, though these must be preached in their season, than to abuse doctrines of terror and coming wrath. Jude tells us this: "They turn the grace of God into wantonness" (Jude 1:4). And the apostle Paul raised the objection, "Shall we sin because grace abounds? God forbid," implying that some men made it their practice to abound in sin precisely because grace abounds.

4. How can a minister discharge his conscience before God, claiming to have preached the whole counsel of God to his people, if he runs only on strains of free grace, Christ’s love, and doctrines of comfort throughout his ministry? Doctrines of terror are also the will of God, and must be preached as much as doctrines of comfort.

5. Those who have cried so loudly for preaching only on love and free grace have, as some manage the matter, hardened more souls than they have ever converted by such sermons. For my part, beloved, I know of no one converted by these new teachers who claim more light than their brethren and claim to present Christ more clearly than their brethren. I do not see holiness shining in their lives above others. Meanwhile, I am certain that those who preached mixed doctrines, sometimes fear and sometimes love, sometimes wrath and sometimes grace, worked most powerfully on the consciences of their hearers. I have read of Mr. Hildersham, a minister at Ashby-de-la-Zouch, a most forceful preacher; it is said God gave his ministry more success in converting souls than to all the other ministers in the region combined. And when Paul preached a sermon of judgment to come, it made the heart of Felix tremble, even that great man’s heart trembled to hear of judgment.

Scripture shows that just as God had his Barnabases, sons of consolation, so he had his Boanergeses, sons of thunder, to make the stout hearts of people tremble. So, lest any misled heart should be carried away thinking all this legalistic, I judged it right to offer this defense before entering the subject. Remember the doctrine: the consideration that God has absolute power over men and women, to cast both into hell, should work in God’s own children an awful fear of God. In handling this dismal subject, I have fifteen questions to work through: first, whether there is a hell or not; second, why there must be a hell to receive the souls and bodies of wicked men; third, what this hell is; fourth, whether there are degrees of torment in hell, and so on.

Question 1: Whether there is a hell or not. To answer this, I will show it first from the confession of heathens, who had only the glimmerings of nature and never saw the Bible, and second from the testimony of Scripture.

1.) From the confession of heathens: though they could not know clearly, never having been acquainted with the word, yet by the glimmering light of nature they had some notions and impressions of this place of the damned. Virgil tells us, "The descent to Avernus is easy" (Virgil, Aeneid 6).

So they had a figure called Pluto, the chief ruler of hell, who especially tormented the most wicked. They had their Charon’s boat, a fancy that a man with a boat ferried wicked persons into hell, and they had their Etna, their burning mountain, which they imagined to be hell. They pictured hell as a continual rolling of stones upon dead bodies, along with many other fancies. Pluto himself carried many footsteps of the idea of hell. As one said, if a man suffers no punishment after death, he will still carry some sense of guilt within him, enough to torture and torment him. All these were merely human impressions of hell. But I will pass over these.

2.) Just as you have testimony from the heathen, you have this truth clearly from Scripture as well. Let me name a few texts. "I will kindle a fire in mine anger, and it shall burn to the lowest hell" (Deut 32:22). "The wicked shall be turned into hell, and all the people that forget God" (Ps 9:17). "Upon the wicked he shall rain snares, fire and brimstone, and a horrible tempest" (Ps 11:6). "Ye serpents and generation of vipers, how can you escape the damnation of hell?" (Matt 23:33). "He cast them down to hell. They are locked up in chains of darkness to be reserved unto judgment" (2 Pet 2:4). "They are reserved in everlasting chains of darkness to the judgment of the great day" (Jude 6). All of this plainly proves that there is a hell.

Question 2: Why must there be a hell? This appears from the following demonstrations.

1.) Because of the filthy nature of sin. Sin is committed against an infinite God, and since the offense is infinite, the punishment must be infinite as well. But the punishment cannot be infinite on earth, because we remain here only a short while and our bodies rot in the grave. There must therefore necessarily be a hell to keep the bodies and souls of the wicked, so that they may receive punishment proportionate to the sins they committed on earth.

2.) Because otherwise the justice of God could never be satisfied for the sins wicked men committed on earth. The reasoning runs this way.

a) Christ would not satisfy and suffer God’s wrath on behalf of wicked men, so they must bear it themselves.

b) On earth they cannot satisfy God’s wrath, because sin, being an infinite offense, can only be punished finitely and temporarily here. So all their sufferings on earth cannot satisfy the wrath due for their sins. There must therefore necessarily be a hell to keep men through all eternity, so that by their everlasting torments God’s justice might be satisfied, which it could not otherwise be (2 Thess 1:5). As one has put it: divine justice requires that the wicked pay the penalties owed for their sins; and since this does not happen in this life, it will most certainly happen in the next.

3.) It appears there must be a hell from the horrors and terrors of conscience found in wicked men when they are dying. Many a man in good health will scoff at hell, scorn its fire, and mock its flames. Many a man in health never thinks of hell; he can drink one day, swear the next, commit adultery the third, and sin every day, and the thought of hell never troubles him. But bring this man to his sickbed, and what horrors and fears seize his soul! I would appeal from a healthy drunkard to that same man when dying, just as one appealed from King Philip drunk to King Philip sober, who then repealed his unjust act and gave the wronged man justice. You who by your sinning have spent your strength and wealth in drink, and never think of hell while drunk, I would appeal to you as a dying man and ask, what would you say then?

What would you then give for Christ? What would you then give for a pardon, that you might not be damned? The very horrors and wounds of conscience at your dying day demonstrate that a time of torment awaits you. How else could conscience become such a terrible torment to the souls of men at that hour, if no such thing as hell were prepared for them? What made the Roman emperors afraid of death, running under their beds in fear when it thundered? Only this: the very workings of conscience showed them that something awaited after this life. The very terrors of conscience declare there is a hell, a place of torment prepared for wicked men.

And thus, having finished these questions, the use I will make of them will be for condemnation and astonishment.

1. This is for condemnation, a condemnation of all who hold that there is no such thing as hell. The Photinians hold that there is no hell, and that what we call hell is merely the annihilation of the body, that man is reduced to nothing and no more. One author writes of fifteen sorts of heretics who deny a hell. Among them was one called Empecta, a view held by Barba, wife of the emperor Sigismund, who paid her followers money to hold this opinion, so that their consciences might be seared over in sensuality and lustful pleasure. As the saying goes, "Scarcely do children believe there are ghosts and underground kingdoms." This truth condemns all who have seared their consciences so as to deny that there is a hell.

2. This is for astonishment. To whom? To all of you who add sin to sin, drunkenness to greed, and one provocation to another, as if there were neither a heaven for the godly nor a hell for you. You who are like Sardanapalus and say, "Eat, drink, play, for after death there is no pleasure," meaning eat, drink, and be merry, for after death there is no pleasure and therefore no pain, and so while men live they should live as pleasurably and joyously as possible (Isa 28:19). O beloved, tremble, for if all these texts I have cited prove such a place exists, how should it astonish your soul that all the actions of your life have been but a race toward these chambers of death! All your life’s actions have been but a laying up of treasure in this place of torment. How should this astonish you, whose whole course leads only to this doleful dungeon of hell?

3. Though this is a terrible and dreadful doctrine, you who are the elect people of God may draw consolation from it. It is true there is a hell, and wicked men will unavoidably come to it, as John says: "You serpents and generation of vipers, how shall you escape the damnation of hell!" But all of you who are the elect of God are not only forewarned, you are also forearmed, and need not fear this place of hell. First, you need not fear the devil, that is, the torments of hell, because God shall bruise Satan under your feet shortly. Though he now goes about like a roaring lion seeking his prey to devour, he shall soon be in chains and go abroad no more. Second, you need not fear the torments the damned undergo in hell.

Though there is a worm that never dies, a fire that never goes out, though there is weeping, wailing, and gnashing of teeth, though the damned lie under the wrath of an incensed God, you may lift up your heads with joy, elect of God, for Jesus Christ is your redemption and your life. "He hath destroyed him that had the power of death, that is, the devil" (Heb 2:14). Because of this, you are delivered by Jesus Christ from the wrath to come (1 Thess 1:10). Here, then, is matter for joy: though there is a hell, and the wicked are tormented night and day, you are delivered by Jesus Christ from this wrath to come.

CHAPTER 2

THE FEARFUL TORMENTS OF HELL

 

But rather fear him who is able to destroy both Body and Soul in Hell. (Matt 10:28)

In beginning these words, I gave you both their scope and their sense. The main observation I drew from them was this.

Doctrine: The truth that God has absolute power over men and women to cast their souls and bodies into hell should work in the hearts of his own people an awful fear of him.

In pursuing this, I have already finished two questions. I now proceed to a third.

Question 3: What is this hell, in which the bodies and souls of wicked men will be tormented? Before I give you the description, I should first lay before you the various terms and expressions in Scripture that describe hell, this place of the damned. Among these there are sixteen or seventeen notable expressions, and knowing them will make plain what hell is.

1. Hell, where the bodies and souls of wicked men are tormented, is sometimes described in Scripture by the term unquenchable fire: "He will burn up the chaff with unquenchable fire" (Luke 3:17). It is unquenchable in both an active and a passive sense. That is, it will never be quenched itself, and the bodies within it will never be consumed away.

2. It is called a furnace of fire: "Then they were cast into a furnace of fire" (Matt 13:42), meaning hell. This alludes to the fiery furnace of Nebuchadnezzar (Dan 3:21–22), which was a type of hell. So Christ, in the New Testament, takes up the Old Testament image and calls hell a furnace of fire. The resemblance holds in two ways. First, just as that fire could not burn the three children, the fire of hell will not burn a single godly man. Second, just as that fire was so far from prevailing over those godly men that it burned the ones who threw them in, hell fire will be so far from prevailing over the godly that the wicked who wish the godly into hell will themselves be thrown in.

3. It is called a lake of fire: "They shall be cast into a lake of fire and brimstone" (Rev 19:20). It is called this to signal the abundance of torments in hell. Just as rivers and lakes hold plentiful water, hell will hold plentiful torments for those cast into that dreadful place. As Anselm says, it is called a lake because, just as a stone sinks in the sea, so souls are plunged there.

4. Eternal fire: so Jude writes that the ungodly "suffered the vengeance of eternal fire," meaning the torments of hell (Jude 7).

5. Utter darkness. This is Christ’s word about the man without a wedding garment: "Bind him hand and foot, and cast him into utter darkness" (Matt 22:13), meaning hell. It is called this because the damned are deprived of the light of God’s face, which is true light, and the lack of it is what makes hell dark.

6. Hell in Scripture is called the blackness of darkness: "They are reserved unto the blackness of darkness for ever" (Jude 1:13). It is called this because darkness is terrifying, and people fear more readily in the dark than in the light. Hell is described in this fearsome way, not merely as darkness but as the blackness of darkness, to make the hearts of men tremble.

7. Chains of darkness: "They are reserved in chains of darkness to the judgment of the great day" (2 Pet 2:4). It is called this to show that once a man is in hell, he will be as unable to escape as a man bound in chains and living in darkness is unable to free himself or find his way out.

8. Damnation: "How shall you escape the damnation of hell?" (Matt 23:33).

9. It is called a place of torment. So Dives, in hell, says, "Send to my brethren upon earth that they may not come into this place of torment" (Luke 16:28), a terrible and dreadful expression describing this tormenting place (Rev 14:10).

10. Hell in Scripture is called wrath to come: "He hath delivered us from wrath to come" (1 Thess 1:10), meaning from hell. Hell is called wrath to come because it is the wrath of God that makes hell what it is. If it were possible for a man to have God’s favor in hell, hell would be a heaven to him. It is the lack of God’s favor that makes hell hell.

11. Hell is called a prison: "Christ went and preached to the spirits in prison" (1 Pet 3:19), that is, in hell. You may object that if this refers to hell, then Christ himself went into hell, and so you hold with the Papists. But mark the words closely, and the true sense is this: by his Spirit, Christ preached through the ministry of Noah for one hundred and twenty years to the people of the old world, those who, at the time this epistle was written, were now in hell, but who were living on earth when they were preached to. So this passage does not support the idea of Christ’s descent into hell. This is simply another expression for hell, and you may guess what a comfortable place a prison is.

12. Tophet: "Tophet is prepared of old, for the king it is prepared, the pile thereof is fire, and much wood. The breath of the Lord, like a river of brimstone shall kindle it" (Isa 30:33). By Tophet is meant hell. It is so called because idolatrous Jews once cast their children into fire there as an offering to the idol Molech, a place where nothing but shrieking and howling was heard night and day. The Holy Spirit, alluding to that, calls hell by this name, Tophet, and tells us it was prepared for kings, to show, as Mr. Greenham says, that the greatness of kings, if they are wicked, cannot keep them from hell. Just as fire burned continually in the valley called Tophet near Jerusalem, so there will be continual burning and torment in hell.

13. Hell is called a bottomless pit (Rev 9:1), out of which you will never come. If it were a pit with a bottom, you might hope to escape, but this pit is bottomless. Once you are cast in, you will never escape.

14. The second death: "He that overcometh shall not be hurt of the second death" (Rev 2:11).

15. Destruction: "Wide is the gate, and broad is the way that leadeth to destruction" (Matt 7:14), that is, to hell.

16. It is called everlasting punishment: "They shall go away into everlasting punishment" (Matt 25:46).

Lastly, hell is called corruption: "They that walk after the flesh, of the flesh shall reap corruption" (Gal 6:8), meaning hell. This is plain, since the same verse continues, "they that walk after the Spirit shall of the Spirit reap life," which is glory. So, beloved, you have seventeen expressions by which Scripture represents hell. I mention these so that when you come across them scattered through Scripture, you will know what place is meant: that place of torment to which the reprobate will be condemned forever.

Having laid these expressions out, I will now give you the general description of hell. Hell is a place of torment, ordained by God for devils and reprobate sinners, in which by his justice he confines them to everlasting punishment, tormenting them both in body and soul. They are deprived of God’s favor, made objects of his wrath, and must lie under it for all eternity. This is hell, as Scripture warrants it.

Question 4: Having shown you that there is a hell, why there is a hell, and what this hell is, the fourth question is this: are there degrees of torment in hell, or not? The answer must be yes. Scripture teaches that just as there are degrees of glory in heaven for the godly, there are degrees of torment in hell for the damned and wicked. The Jerinianists and the Stoics held that all sins were alike, and so all punishments were alike. It is true that torments are alike in three respects. First, in respect of duration, the torments of all will be eternal. Second, in respect of what they are deprived of, all alike are deprived of God, Christ, and heaven. Third, in respect of expectation, none has more hope of escape than another.

Yet it is certain that one will endure more pain and torment than another, and I will show this from Scripture and reason. Some will suffer greater torments, some less, yet all enough to make them miserable.

To confirm this from Scripture, consider (Matt 10:15): "Whosoever shall not receive you, nor hear your words, when ye depart from that house and city, shake off the dust of your feet; for I say unto you, it shall be more tolerable for the land of Sodom and Gomorrah at the day of judgment than for that city." Mark this: Scripture tells us that Sodom and Gomorrah suffered the vengeance of eternal fire, and though they are in hell, it will be more tolerable for them than for those who live in the days of the gospel unrepenting and leading profane lives.

So too (Matt 11:22): "I say unto you it shall be more tolerable for Tyre and Sidon at the day of judgment than for you." Christ speaks here of Chorazin, a city that enjoyed the gospel and witnessed Christ’s miracles, yet did not become a repenting and reformed people despite all this. So Christ says it will be more tolerable for Tyre and Sidon, two heathen cities, at the day of judgment than for Chorazin.

So too (Luke 12:47–48): "He that knows his master’s will, and does it not, he shall be beaten with many stripes, but he that knows it not shall be beaten with few."

So too (Matt 23:14–15), where Christ says that those who make long prayers under pretense "shall receive greater damnation." This implies that although everyone who has lived wickedly and died unrepentant will receive damnation, hypocrites will receive greater damnation than others.

Now if you ask me the reasons why there are degrees of torment in hell, some greater and some lesser, though all are enough, I answer:

1. Some people commit greater sins on earth than others. It is only just for God to give each person what their deeds deserve, so those who have committed worse transgressions will be tormented more severely in damnation. Christ tells us, (John 19:11), "No man could have power to take my life from me, if it were not given him of my Father; therefore he that delivered me up to you, hath the greater sin." God’s justice strikes so directly at sin that those with the most sins will suffer the greatest torments. (John 15:22), "If I had not come and spoken to them, they had not had sin; but now they have no cloke for their sins." Some people’s sins are small as motes, others as great as beams (Matt 7:4); some sins are as small as gnats, others as great as camels (Matt 23:24).

2. There are also degrees of glory in heaven. Just as those most eminent in grace will have the greatest degrees of glory in heaven, so those most vile in sin will have the most torment and punishment in hell. Yet, as I said before, though there are degrees of glory in heaven, all will have enough. Perkins illustrates it this way: put two vessels into the sea, one larger and one smaller. Both will be full, though the small vessel will not hold as much as the great one. So it is with the glorified saints in heaven: some are capable of greater glory, some of less, yet all are full. And so it will be with the damned. Some, having been vile sinners, will have greater torments; others will have less; yet all will have enough, as much as creatures are able to bear.

I could cite the church fathers here too: the punishment of each will be greater in proportion to how greatly each one sinned (Augustine, on 2 Corinthians 5:10).

For application, then: tremble, all you who rush into the vilest sins and transgressions, who give yourselves over to lewdness to work uncleanness with greediness. You will endure the greatest torments in hell. "How much she hath glorified herself, and lived deliciously, so much torment and sorrow give unto her." Though even the least measure of the torments of the damned is enough to make a soul miserable, woe to you who store up the greatest measure of God’s wrath.

But let me move on to a fifth question.

Question 5: It is good to hear a sermon on hell, so that you may never feel hell, and so that you may avoid the sin that leads there. So mark this fifth point: since there are degrees of torment for the damned in hell, how might we know which people Scripture points to as those who will suffer the greatest torments in hell? This is a dreadful subject, yet Scripture speaks fully of it. I must tell you, my very flesh trembles in speaking this doctrine to you, and I wish to God that your hearts and mine might tremble in hearing it, so that we might not be numbered among that black roll of the damned who will be plunged into the lowest hell. Everything I say on this I will gather under seven points. Scripture points to seven sorts of people who, if they live and die unrepentant of these seven sins, will have a greater portion of hell’s torments than other damned persons.

Who are they?

1. Those who will neither live a holy life themselves nor allow others, so far as it lies in their power, to live holily. Whoever they are, they will receive greater damnation than other people (Matt 23:14–15). "Woe unto you," says Christ, "for you will neither go to heaven yourselves, nor suffer others to go thither; but what in you lies, you hinder them; verily," says Christ, "you shall receive great condemnation." So, beloved, let this word startle you. All you parents who will not be holy yourselves, and cannot bear that your children should be. All you heads of households who will not be holy yourselves, and cannot endure that your servants should pursue godliness. All you husbands who will not be holy yourselves, and cannot bear that your wives should profess godliness: take heed. If you live and die in this state, you will receive greater condemnation.

I wish to God this word might startle those who do all they can to act as blocks and bars in others’ way to heaven. You read in Romans 16:10–11 of two heathens, Aristobulus and Narcissus. Paul says of them that they had godly people in their household: "Salute the household of Narcissus." I told you, in expounding that passage, that these heathens were honest enough, not so vilely wicked, that though they were not godly themselves, though they were heathens, they still allowed godly people to live in their houses. But such is the great height of wickedness people have grown to in our age that they are not only unholy themselves, they are worse than Aristobulus, a heathen, for they cannot bear to have a godly person under their roof. I beg you to take this to heart, for truly, if you do not repent, you will receive greater damnation than other people.

2. Those who live long under the enjoyment of glorious ordinances without any improvement or amendment of life. Whoever they are, they will have a deeper portion of hellfire than other people (Matt 11:22–23). "It shall be more tolerable for Tyre and Sidon at the day of judgment, than for you. And thou, Capernaum, that art exalted to heaven, shalt be cast down to hell." Capernaum and Chorazin, the two cities Christ speaks of here, were places where Jesus and his disciples preached in person and worked many great and wonderful miracles. This is plain from verse 23: "Then he began to upbraid the cities wherein most of his mighty works were done, because they repented not." Christ worked mighty miracles there. In fact, the very first time Christ spoke publicly in the world was in Capernaum. Christ and his apostles preached there, mighty miracles were done there, yet the people did not repent.

So what does Christ say to them? "It shall be more tolerable for Tyre and Sidon at the day of judgment than for you." You will have the greater portion in hell’s torments than those poor heathens who lived in Tyre and Sidon (Luke 10:12–15).

Let me press this home. Though heathens will be damned for not believing in Jesus Christ, you who hear of Christ and yet do not believe will go to hell with a vengeance far worse. The Indians will be punished in hell for not receiving Christ, but England will be punished ten thousand times more than they. Sodom will fare better than London, and heathens will be less punished than Christians who live under the gospel unreformed. You who live under the enjoyment of ordinances, I say to you, it would have been better for you to have been in Sodom when fire fell from heaven and burned it to ashes, than to be in England if you do not profit by the gospel. In Sodom, though people were burned by fire, some perhaps saved their souls; but if you live under the enjoyment of glorious ordinances and do not profit by them, your soul will not be saved.

It would be better for you, beloved, who live under these ordinances, that you had never been born, that you had never come within London’s walls, that you had never heard so many powerful sermons as you have heard with your own ears, if none of it turns you to amend your lives. All the profession you make will only be an aggravation of your damnation.

Let me speak plainly here, to you who profess without practicing, who hear the word but do not do it, who write sermons in your notebooks but have not written one word of it on your hearts. Let me say this grim thing: the very pens you now write with will become spears to wound you. The very paper you now write on will become fuel to burn you. The very ink you now write with will only deepen the blackness of hell’s darkness around you. And every line you write now will stand as a line of indictment against your own soul at the last day.

So I urge you, take this to heart. If you live under the enjoyment of ordinances yet remain ignorant, profane, and loose, the Lord have mercy on you, for this is your doom: you will receive greater damnation than other people. There is a well-known passage that confirms this, (Rom 2:9), where you find this phrase: "Tribulation, anguish and wrath shall be to every soul that works evil, but to the Jew first, and then to the gentile," that is, to the Jew chiefly, to the Jew especially, and then to the gentile. Why does Scripture say this?

Because the Jews had the ordinances of God (Rom 9:3–4). "I could wish myself accursed from Christ, for my brethren, my kinsmen, according to the flesh; who are Israelites to whom pertaineth the adoption, and the glory, and the covenant, and the giving of the law, and the service of God, and the promises." The Jews enjoyed glorious ordinances, had the service of God, were God’s people by outward covenant, and Christ came from their lineage. So if a Jew is wicked, if a Jew rejects Christ and remains ignorant of the knowledge of Christ, tribulation and anguish will come to the Jew first, says Christ.

So I may say, and God will say, that tribulation, anguish, and wrath will come to the profane heathen, but to a professing believer first, to a Christian first, to a resident of London first, above all people in the world. So I urge you, all who live under the gospel without amendment of life, take this to heart: your doom is to receive greater condemnation from your God. Again,

3. Those who make the greatest profession of religion and have the most knowledge, yet practice least and sin most against knowledge and conscience, will receive greater damnation than other men. Christ speaks of two sorts of people in Luke 12:47–48. Some knew their master’s will and did not prepare themselves to do it. "That servant that knew his Lord’s will, and prepared not himself, nor did according to his will, he should be beaten with many stripes; but he that knew it not, shall be beaten with few stripes." Ignorance does not excuse sin, though, as theologians say, it lessens the punishment without removing it entirely. Ignorance reduces the degree of torment but does not cancel it altogether. Those who do not know, Christ says, will receive few stripes; they will still be punished.

But the one who knew his Lord’s will and did not prepare himself, who did not act accordingly even though he knew, sinned against knowledge and against conscience, and that man will be beaten with many stripes. Let this be a sobering word to all of you who have long professed faith and attained great knowledge. For all your knowledge, you may still be like that heathen woman who said, "I see the best things, yet I follow the worst" (Video meliora proboque, deteriora sequor). If this describes you, you know what God is, you know sin is sin and hell is hell, you know how evil it is to sin against God, and yet you knowingly risk sin against your own conscience. Consider this: if the Lord does not bring you to timely repentance, you will receive more stripes than others. Ignorant men who never knew Christ will be punished, but you will be punished more than they.

4. Those that have by the evil of their lives given other people example or provocation to live wickedly, and to go to hell as well as themselves, will be tormented more dreadfully than other men, for they will be damned not only for their own sins but for the sins of others too. Read Luke 16:27–28. When the rich man was in hell, the text tells us, he begged Abraham to send someone from the dead to warn the people still living what kind of place hell was. Abraham answered, "they have Moses and the prophets, let them hear them." God will not work miracles now; people must listen to the ministry and preaching of the Gospel. If they will not hear that, they will never be saved. But the rich man pressed further: "for I have five brethren upon earth, let him go to them, lest they come to this place of torment." Why did the rich man want his five brothers kept from hell?

Not because he loved their souls, for there is no love of souls in hell; those who are there wish the whole world to join them. Rather, he knew that while alive he had led his brothers into sin by his own bad example, and he understood that their arrival in hell would only add to his own torment. Every commentator agrees this was self-love speaking, not love for his brothers. Let this word settle among you. Have many of you not given bad examples to others? Have your children not learned to stammer out oaths from hearing you, their fathers, swear in front of them? Have your children not learned indecent and vulgar talk from hearing it come from you? Have they not learned to be unclean from watching such uncleanness practiced by you? Have they not learned godlessness from watching you live godlessly?

If you live and die unrepentant of the sins of your bad example, and God brings you to hell, your torments will be greater than other men’s. Augustine, in one of his books, prays, "Lord deliver me from other men’s sins." He prays this because at the judgment he must answer not only for his own sins but for the sins of others that his example caused; he would be punished for their sins as well as his own.

5. Those who live and die unrepentant in the sin of adultery will be tormented above other men. You who now burn in your lusts will one day burn in hotter flames than others will. 2 Peter 2:9–10 says, "The Lord knows how to deliver the godly out of temptation, and to reserve the unjust to the day of judgment to be punished," but especially whom? "chiefly them that walk after the flesh in the lusts of uncleanness." The Lord will reserve all unjust men for punishment, but especially those who walk in the lusts of uncleanness. And so Hebrews 13:4 tells us, "whoremongers and adulterers God will judge." God will judge everyone, but these especially. If you are adulterers, he will judge you and give you a greater measure of torment than other men. So if any of you, man or woman, are guilty of this sin, repent now.

Believe this: if you do not repent, you will be punished more than others. Those who habitually give themselves to unclean lusts, if they live and die unrepentant of them, will have a deeper portion in hell than other men.

6. Those who are hypocrites, who take up the profession of religion merely as a cloak to cover grosser and more abominable sins in their lives, will receive the greatest damnation. (Mark 12:40) gives us a striking phrase: "Woe unto you Scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites, for under pretence you make long prayers" (making long prayers was not itself sinful, but doing so as a pretense toward an evil end made it sin) "that you might devour widow’s houses." That was their sin: they committed acts of violence in their courts and their outward dealings, and to avoid suspicion of being so vile and wicked, they put on a mask of holiness, devoting themselves to prayer and profession so they would not be suspected of such cruelty. And what does Christ say? "They that under pretence make long prayers, they shall receive great condemnation."

7. Those who continue in impenitence and hardness of heart against a patient, longsuffering God who has shown them abundant lovingkindness will suffer greater torments than other men. (Rom 2:5) asks, "Despisest thou the riches of God’s goodness and forbearance, not knowing that the goodness of God should lead thee to repentance? but after thy hardness, and heart that cannot repent, thou treasurest up to thyself wrath against the day of wrath." Every man lives under God’s mercy, but every man who lives unrepentant under that mercy, precisely because God is longsuffering, stores up wrath against the day of wrath. The reason is this: the more God’s patience is abused, the more wrath will be poured out to punish that abuse. Laesa patientia fit furor, wronged patience turns into fury. That is why we see that no men grow so fiercely angry as meek men once provoked.

Scripture tells us that Moses, a man gifted with patience, the meekest man on earth, became so enraged when the Israelites worshiped the molten calf that in his anger he broke the two tables of stone he had received from God’s own hand. God’s patience, wronged and slighted, will provoke him so that he may justly multiply and increase your torments. This far I have gone in this grim subject. May the Lord use it to bring you to heaven and free you from that place of torment, which will be the portion of all who do not fear God and do not walk in his ways.

CHAPTER 3

GOD’S POWER OVER BODY AND SOUL

 

But rather fear him who is able to destroy both Body and Soul in Hell. (Matt 10:28)

When I began on these words, the observation I drew was this:

Doctrine: The consideration that God has an absolute sovereignty over creatures, to cast their bodies and souls into hell, should work in the hearts of his own people an awful fear of God.

In pursuing this subject, I have gone over five questions, which I treat only to awaken drowsy sinners and to increase the joy of glorified saints as they hear of the eternal torments they have been freed from. I now come to the sixth question.

Question 6: Where is hell? There is a variety of opinions about this. I will give you the thoughts of several writers, then lay down what best agrees with the word of truth. All agree that there is such a place; even reason itself insists that everything finite must exist somewhere.

1. Some hold that this place of the damned is in the air. This was the opinion of Gregory of Nyssa and others after him, built on two passages. The first is Ephesians 2:2, which calls the devil the prince of the power of the air; therefore, they say, hell as a place must be in the air. The second is Ephesians 6:12, which says, "We wrestle against principalities and powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this world, and against spiritual wickedness in high places," meaning in the air, where they suppose the devils and hell to be.

To answer this: hell is not there. As for the first passage, (Eph 2:2), the devil is called the prince of the power of the air not to mark the location of hell or the damned, but to show that God has permitted the devil, on many occasions, power over the air to raise winds, storms, and tempests. God has given the devil that much power. So it happened in Job 1:19, when the devil raised an east wind and struck the four corners of the house where Job’s children were feasting. This phrase, then, only shows that God allows the devil to raise storms in the air, or to move about in it, and so he is called prince of the air. It has no bearing at all on the location of the damned.

As for the second passage, (Eph 6:12), we wrestle not against flesh and blood, but against principalities and powers and rulers of darkness, that is, the devils who rule in the dark minds of ignorant people. We wrestle, says the apostle, against spiritual wickedness in high places, meaning we wrestle against the devil, a spirit, and a spirit full of wickedness, who fights against us in high places. In the original Greek this phrase means not "in the air" but "in the heavenly places." When an adjective stands alone like this, the noun understood is usually "thing" or "things," as in Hebrews 8:5, where the same construction appears. So here it means "heavenly things," that is, our heavenly graces, for it is against these that the devil directs his malice, wrestling against our heavenly graces and against our going to heaven. That is why he is called a spirit of wickedness.

So this passage gives no support at all to the opinion that hell is in the air. It only shows that the devil’s chief malice is to oppose our going to heaven and the graces that lead us there (2 Cor 4:4).

2. Isidore says hell is beneath the globe of the earth. But this is not likely, because beneath the earth people live just as we do here.

3. A third opinion places hell in the valley of Jehoshaphat, drawn from Joel 3:12. But what I have already said in refuting the idea that Christ will come to judgment there applies equally against this opinion.

4. A fourth opinion, held by many learned men, places hell at the very center and core of the earth. They base this on hell being called in Scripture a pit, a lake, and a deep, and so conclude that all the damned are confined at the earth’s center. But this has no real foundation in the word of God, and so cannot be confirmed by it.

There is another opinion, which seems to carry some appearance of reason: that hell lies at the bottom of the sea. Keckermann and others hold this, building it on the passage in Matthew 8:29 and Luke 8:31, where the devils, once cast out, begged Christ to let them enter a herd of swine, and the swine ran into the sea and drowned. Since the devils went there, they argue, hell must be there too. My answer is that this cannot be the meaning of the passage, for it would then follow that the swine went to hell, which is against both reason and Scripture. Only reasonable creatures, men, women, and angels, are subject to hell; no creature incapable of sin goes there but these. Such are the many conceits people hold about this place.

Those who write most soberly about it say only, in general terms, that hell is a place beneath the earth, as Augustine says in his Retractions, book 2, chapter 2. The apostle who preached to the Gentiles called hell hades, a place underground appointed for punishment. Hesiod claims hell lies as far beneath the earth as heaven is above it. Let me now give you, in sober terms, what Scripture itself says on this matter.

Scripture does not reveal the exact location of hell. It gives us warrant to believe only two things in general.

1. That there is such a place as hell, distinct from heaven; it is not where heaven is, and this you may clearly believe.

2. You may clearly believe from Scripture likewise that this place, wherever it is, must lie below heaven, somewhere beneath it. So Proverbs 15:24 says, "The way of life is above to the wise, to preserve him from hell beneath." And in Luke 8:31, the devils begged Christ, "Lord, torment us not, and send us not into the deep." Hell lay in the deep, somewhere below both heaven and earth. That is why they said, "Lord, do not send us into the deep," meaning, do not torment us by sending us to the place of the damned.

But as to the exact location, Scripture is silent, and where Scripture has no tongue to speak, you should have no ear to listen. If anyone asks further, I can only say what Socrates said: I have never been there myself, nor spoken with anyone who has.

But what reason would move God to conceal the location of hell, and not reveal it to the world? There may be five reasons that lead God to do this.

1. God does this to prevent curiosity in many people. If men knew the exact place, some would grow so curious that they would never rest until they found it. So God conceals the place to prevent this curiosity.

2. God conceals it so that people would not fear the place itself more than the sin that leads to it. It is God’s will that you fear sin more than hell. As Anselm rightly says, if hell stood on one side and sin on the other, you should fear falling into sin more than falling into hell. If people could find this place and hear the shrieking of the damned, and see the torments prepared for sinners, they would fear the place itself more than the sin that leads there. So God prevents this too by concealing it.

3. God does this to keep faith active and in use, so that you are bound to believe he has provided such a place, even though we know neither exactly what it is nor where it is.

4. God does this to rouse people from complacency, making them fearful of sin in every place. Since God does not tell you where hell is, you might fall into it before you are aware. So God withholds this knowledge to stir you from your ease.

5. Last, God conceals it so that people would not look for extraordinary means and ways to convert them, but would commit themselves instead to the ordinary preaching and working of the word. I might give the same answer Abraham gave to Dives, when Dives asked for someone to go from hell and warn his brothers how he was tormented. No, said Abraham, God will work no miracles: "they have Moses and the prophets, let them believe them." Abraham checked Dives with the truth that God would work no miracles to convert men; they must commit themselves to the ordinary means of the word. If people could see the flames of hell flashing before their faces, this might startle their conscience and change their expression. But God is not pleased to show you the signs of hell, or the knowledge of where hell is, until you are in it, if you are not elect and do not belong to God.

Now let me draw this question to a close with a practical application.

1. It should be your wisdom to labor more to avoid hell than to try to discover where hell is. If you do not labor to avoid hell, be sure that wherever hell is, it will find you out and receive you into everlasting torment. Chrysostom draws this same lesson from the point: we should not ask where hell is, but how to escape it (Homily 31 on Romans, chapter 16). If a man’s house were on fire, he would not ask how it started, but how to put it out.

2. Though it is uncertain exactly where hell is, you can be certain that sin is the very high road to hell, the direct way there. You may not know the place for certain, but this much is certain: sin will lead you there. "Whosoever goes in to a whore, her house is the way to hell, going down to the chambers of death" (Prov 7:26–27). The more recklessly you sin, the faster you run toward the place of the damned.

3. Do you not know exactly where hell is? Then this should teach you to watch against sin in every place, for hell follows sin at its heels. If you sin against God, God knows how near you are to hell. There is a phrase in Genesis 4:7, God’s own words to Cain: "If thou dost ill, behold sin lies at thy door," meaning the punishment due to sin lies there. I say to you: if you walk in the ways of sin, if you get drunk in secret, or swear in secret, or cheat in secret, hell is at your door, and damnation is at your door. You do not know how near you are to hell when you sin against God. So take heed of sin in every place, since you do not know exactly where hell is.

4. Though we do not know where hell is, we can be sure of this: some people carry the resemblance of hell about with them wherever they go. A guilty, galled conscience joined with a profane, wicked life is the living picture of hell itself.

Question 7: What are the torments of the damned in hell? This, beloved, is a question that makes my own heart tremble as I speak to you of what Scripture says about it. Yet I must be faithful both to the text and to the truth in setting out this dismal subject, and I ask you to give me your attention a little as I speak of what the torments of the damned are. In answering it, I will cover everything I have to say under two headings.

The torments of the damned are twofold: either privative or positive, either the punishment of loss or the punishment of sense, as the scholastic theologians call it. Under these two headings, even a man with the tongues of men and angels could not fully unfold the extreme misery of a tormented soul. Let me borrow the philosopher’s manner of speech about hell: if all the land were paper, and all the water in the sea were ink, with as many pens as blades of grass on the ground and as many writers as grains of sand on the shore, it would still be too little to set forth the torments of hell. But let me speak what Scripture says, for it says enough about these torments, so that you may avoid the ways that lead to them.

1. The torments of the damned are privative; the damned lose something, and this punishment of loss makes their torment great. Their loss falls into five particulars, five things of which they are deprived.

1.) The wicked in hell suffer this loss: they are deprived of and banished from the favorable presence of God. Chrysostom says that if a thousand hells were named, none of them would compare to being cast out from the honor of that blessed glory, being hateful to Christ, and hearing him say, "I never knew you" (Homily 24 on Matthew). If there were a thousand worlds, the loss of the favor of the one God would matter more than all of them. It is the greatest torment of a damned man that he is without God. The presence of God is what makes heaven a heaven. The absence of God makes hell more hellish than it would otherwise be. "Depart from me, ye cursed": this is the great torment of the damned, that they must depart from God and Jesus Christ forever.

If Absalom counted it so great a misery that the text says he grew weary of his life because he could not see his father for a while, what weariness will it be for the damned, who will never see God as their Father, not for a while, but forever? The loss of God is the greatest loss possible, and this is your loss if you are cast into hell.

2.) The damned lose not only God and Christ but also the company of the saints and angels forever. Here on earth they may enjoy the company of God’s saints, but the time of their being in hell is the time of their separation (Matt 22:13; Matt 25:41): "Go from me, you cursed, with the devil and his angels." If they are cast with the devil and his angels, they must necessarily be separated from the saints.

3.) You lose heaven, the place of blessedness. "There is a deep gulph" (says Abraham) "between us and you, that you cannot come to us" (Luke 16:26); you are utterly lost. Cicero so lamented his banishment from Italy that every time he looked toward it he wept. Demosthenes took his banishment from Athens so heavily that every time he looked that way he wept. If this grieved them so deeply, how much more will the thought that you are banished from heaven grieve you, if it should ever be your dismal fate to be cast into hell?

4.) You lose not only God, Christ, and the angels, but also, and this is not the least of your misery, you lose all pity, from God, from Christ, and from all the saints of God. It is some comfort in misery to be pitied by a friend, but in hell you will lose even that kind of pity. God will not pity you; "he shall laugh at your destruction, and mock when your fear comes" (Prov 1:26). The godly will not pity you either; they will rejoice to see God’s power and God’s glory displayed in your damnation (Ps 52:8). Augustine says that neither creator nor creature will feel any sympathy toward the damned in all their torments. When you are scorching in your flames, when you are howling in your torments, God will laugh at your destruction, and the saints of God will sing and rejoice that you are a vessel of his justice, his power and wrath made known in you (Rev 14:10).

Here, if you are in misery, someone shows you pity; but in hell no one will pity you, and so your misery will be all the greater.

5.) Last, here is your loss: you lose all hope of recovery. We say that if it were not for hope, the heart would break. Here in this world, however wicked you have been, there is still some hope while you are among the living. But in hell there is no hope; you are past redemption. Once you are in hell, your heart may break with sorrow, because there is no hope of ever coming out.

So now you have a glimpse of what your loss in hell would be.

But second, and this may move your thoughts even more, consider the punishments of sense, what we call positive punishments, the torments that the bodies and souls of men endure in hell. Here I ask you to give me your attention a little longer as I speak in detail of these particulars.

There are eight considerations that make the torments of the damned very great and grievous: first, the variety of those torments; second, the universality of those torments; third, the extremity; fourth, the continuance; fifth, the society with whom you are tormented; sixth, the quality of the place where it is; seventh, the cruelty of those who torment you; and lastly, the eternity of all this. If you do not have hearts of stone, these eight considerations will make you tremble to think of them.

1. Consider the variety of these torments. There is not one way to torment you, but a hundred, a thousand, ten thousand ways. If you were sick here, you would likely have only one kind of disease at a time. Perhaps it is the stone, or the plague, or some other illness, but you do not have variety. If you had plague, stone, gout, and fever all afflicting your body at once, how miserable would you be? In hell there is not one kind of torment but every kind at once: unquenchable fire to burn you, a lake of brimstone to choke you, eternal chains to bind you, utter darkness to terrify you, and an everlasting worm of conscience to gnaw you. God has made a variety of torments to converge upon a single soul, and this makes the torments of hell dismal indeed.

2. There is not only variety but universality of torments. Not only many kinds of suffering, but these torments will afflict both body and soul entirely, all the parts of the body and all the powers of the soul. This makes the torments of hell more dreadful still. On earth you may suffer disease, yet even when some parts are afflicted, other parts remain free. If your body is ill, your head may still be well; if your head is ill, your vital organs may be spared; if your vital organs are ill, your arms and legs may be untouched. No earthly disease puts the whole body in pain at once. But in hell it is different: all the parts of your body and all the powers of your soul will be tormented, if you should ever go to that dismal place.

1.) Consider all the parts of the body. The eye will be tormented with the sight of devils. The ear will be tormented by the howling and hideous outcries of the damned in the flames. The nostrils will be choked with brimstone. The tongue will burn with flame. In short, the whole body will be tormented in fire; there is no part of the body, neither hand, foot, tongue, nor eye, that will escape those flames.

Nor is it only the body; the powers of the soul will be tormented as well. Your imagination will be tormented by the thought of your present pain. Your memory will be tormented by the thought of the heaven and happiness you have lost, the opportunities you had to be saved, that you lived under the gospel, that the ministers of Jesus Christ warned you again and again to repent, and that you would not be persuaded. Your mind will torment you with the thought of the time you wasted. In short, your understanding will torment you with thoughts of past pleasure, present pain, and future sorrow that will never end, and your conscience will gnaw at you continually. Not only the body but the soul will be tormented by these flames.

3. A third consideration that makes the torments of hell very grievous is their extremity. The fire of hell burns so violently that all the water of the sea could not quench it. Suppose a man suffered a disease throughout his whole body and was troubled in mind as well. If the pain were not extreme, it would be somewhat bearable. But if a man’s body were afflicted and his mind troubled, both to the highest possible extreme, death would be far better for him. Beloved, this is how it is in hell: the torments there reach the utmost extremity. The worst torments known on earth, the colic, the gout, the rack, burning at the stake, are mere flea bites compared to the extreme torments your body and soul must endure in hell. There you will bear as heavy a weight of God’s wrath as your nature can possibly hold.

There the fire will be a hundred times hotter than the fire of Nebuchadnezzar, which was itself seven times hotter than usual. This is pain at its utmost extremity. Who, beloved, can bear universality, and who can bear variety, and who can bear extremity of torment? Yet you must endure all these in hell, if that is your lot. If bearing the guilt of your sin for even an hour or two was so extreme for the Son of God that it made him sweat drops of blood, what will the extremity of your torments in hell make you do?

4. Consider the continuance of these torments. Even if the torments of hell were many, universal, and extreme, it would be some comfort if you had occasional relief. A man troubled with gout or the stone finds great refreshment in any relief from pain. But in hell this is your deplorable condition: there is no relief at all. When you have drained one draught of brimstone, you must drink another the next day. When you have lain a day under the fury of an angry God, you must be crushed under the weight of his wrath the next. There is never any rest. Revelation 20:10 says, "They shall have no rest night nor day." It is a comfort to a sick man, even if he cannot sleep at night, to know he may have relief in the morning. But in hell there is no rest night or day; torments never cease there. So too (Rev 14:11).

The reason for this continual torment is that the damned continually sin in hell and blaspheme God there, for cursing is the language of hell. If there is continual sinning in hell, there must be continual punishment in hell. Just as the damned have no forgiveness of sin, so they have no cessation of pain, no interruption of torment, no admission of comfort. As Jerome says, the sinning of the damned in hell is like oil, and God’s wrath is like fire. As long as oil is cast into the fire, it will never stop burning; so as long as you continue sinning in hell, the fire of God’s wrath will continue to scorch you. John 3:36 says, "The wrath of God shall abide upon you." This is why the torments of hell have no intermission.

5. Consider the society with whom you are tormented, which makes hell’s torments grievous and dreadful. Good company can greatly ease a sick man’s pain and help him forget his sorrow, but bad company torments him as much as his disease. In hell it would be some relief if you had good company, but the only company you will have there is devils and damned souls like yourself. Just as it torments a person here to see and feel what others suffer, so it will torment the damned in hell to see the torments and hear the shrieks of those around them. You would count it miserable to be forced to live in a hospital among the crippled, or in a prison among thieves and criminals, or in an asylum among the insane. Yet hospitals, prisons, and asylums all offer better company than the damned find in hell. That company alone will make your being there most miserable, and will only increase your torments.

As Bernard said, he would rather enter the hottest burning furnace than see the devil in his own form.

6. The quality of the place itself will make your torments more grievous. Beloved, if a man were put in a place with no good company but a pleasant setting, it would be tolerable. But to be banished from a pleasant place into a prison of darkness is truly miserable, and that is how it is in hell. You may have stately houses and pleasant gardens, fruitful vines and fine buildings on earth, but from these beautiful places you will be thrust into hell, a prison, a bottomless pit, a dungeon of darkness, a lake of fire and brimstone, a furnace that burns for eternity. Beloved, the very nature of that place will make hell grievous to you.

7. The cruelty of those God has appointed to be your tormentors in hell will make hell’s torments grievous. Who are they? Read Matthew 18:34. The devils are called your tormentors; they torment wicked men. The devils in hell are the great tormentors of souls.

It would somewhat lessen a man’s suffering, even if he were condemned to endure punishment, if the one appointed to execute it were merciful and would spare him what he could. If a man were to be burned in the hand, and the one doing the burning would spare him and hardly touch him, he would count it a great happiness. Your torments would be somewhat lessened if your tormentors in hell were merciful creatures. But who are your tormentors? Your tormentors are devils, in whom there is no pity, who will not spare you but will torment you as much as they are able to inflict and you are able to bear. Be sure your tormentors will show no mercy. They will load you with rivers of brimstone and mountains of fire to the utmost. This is what makes hell’s torments so grievous: your tormentors are full of cruelty.

A man condemned to die will find that the very sight of his executioner makes his heart tremble, especially if the executioner is cruel. In the same way, the sight of the devil, your tormentor, will afflict you exceedingly. I recall the words of Anselm: "I would rather endure all the torments that exist, or that nature can devise, than see the devil with my bodily eyes, than see him as he afflicts and torments the damned in hell." So, beloved, take heed of hell. For once you are there, your tormentors will show you no pity. They will not spare you, but will heap on whatever they can to increase your torments.

8. And then lastly, the eternity of all this, the thought of these torments never ending, makes them most grievous of all. When a man lies on a sickbed, here is his comfort: though he suffers grievous pain, is sorely afflicted, and cannot rest night or day, he still has hope that it will not last long. Either he will be cured or he will die, and so his pains will end. But this comfort cannot reach you in hell. You are there in pain, and you will be there in pain forever. Mr. Bolton says that this word ever should break the hard heart of a sinner. Your pains are many, your pains are universal, your pains are extreme, and they will be eternal. Eternity is what makes it all miserable.

Now let me draw this question to a close with a word of application. Is it true, beloved, that the torments of the damned are privative, that you lose God, lose Christ, lose heaven, lose glory, lose the saints, and lose all pity and all hope of recovery? If this is true, then it seems to me, first, that it exposes the madness and folly of those who will run the risk of losing God, Christ, heaven, and glory, and will risk undergoing the torments of hell, all for some fleeting pleasure or fleshly lust. Such is the madness of many in the world, that they would rather lose God than lose a lust, rather than leave their mistress, rather than give up the profit that comes from unjust gain.

I recall a story of Lysimachus, king of Macedonia. While leading his army in hot, dry weather, his whole army was ready to die of thirst, and he was forced to surrender himself, his army, and his kingdom into his enemy’s hand for a draught of water. Having drunk it, he cried out, "How short-lived is this pleasure, that for one draught of water I have lost a glorious kingdom!" Truly, you have more cause to complain than Lysimachus did. You may lose the kingdom of heaven for a draught of water, for a cup of wine. Because you will drink one glass too many, or gain one coin too many, you may lose heaven for it. Because you will swear one oath too many, you may lose God by it. And all this for so small a profit. This shows the reckless madness and headlong folly of which men are guilty.

2. Are these the torments of the damned, privative in losing God and positive in these eight considerations? If this is true, then all of you who are outside Jesus Christ should today be in Belshazzar’s state of mind, (Dan 5:5): "When he saw the hand writing upon the wall his joints trembled, and his knees smote one against another." Tremble, and be afraid, you who are appointed a vessel of eternal vengeance. How can you endure this variety of torments? How can you bear the weight of the wrath of an angry God? This thought alone should draw tears from your eyes, blood from your hearts, and above all, sin from your lives, when you consider how grievously the damned are tormented.

Is this the fate of the damned in hell? Then this should teach you that, grievous as hell’s torments are, sin is worse than hellish torments. Hell is not as bad as sin, because sin made hell. What made hell to be hell is worse than hell itself. Though you have heard of these hellish torments, I would not have you fear torment more than sin. Fear sin, the cause, more than hell, the effect, for sin is worse than hell. When you take an oath in your mouth, or drink to excess, think that you would be better off swallowing a draught of brimstone than committing that sin. So, beloved, do not let hearing of these torments cause you to think lightly of sin. Fear sin rather than fear hell.

I recall a saying of Chrysostom: "It is a more woeful thing to dishonor Jesus Christ than to be vexed with the torments of the damned." And I recall Mr. Bolton quoting Anselm on this subject: "If sin were on one hand and hell on the other, I would rather go into hell than run into sin." And there is a saying from Edmund, Anselm’s successor: "I would rather leap into a furnace of fire, or cast myself into a lake of brimstone, than knowingly commit one sin against God." Beloved, I mention these only so that you might not look upon hell as worse than sin, and might not think the torments of hell so terrible, for sin is ten thousand times worse. Hell is a created thing, but sin is not. God made hell, but the devil made sin. God created hell, but he never made sin.

God counted hell better than sin, or else he would never have made a hell to punish sin. So, though you have heard of all these hellish torments, still regard sin as worse than all of them.

4. And lastly, I urge you all: do not, for the pleasure of sin or the profits of sin, run the risk of entering these everlasting torments. Suppose your unjust gain increases your wealth, suppose you gain large revenues. If you lose God, what have you gained? If you lose your soul, what have you gained? If you lose Christ, what has it profited you? Do not run the risk of these eternal torments for the sake of enjoying sin’s pleasures for a season.

An author has said that the man who turns to theft is a great fool. He may spend less than an hour stealing the goods, yet may lie a whole year in jail for it, and be hanged when it is all done. But how much greater fools are those who, for an hour’s pleasure, or at most a lifetime’s unjust gain and sinful living, will lie in the jail and prison of hell, not for a year, but for all eternity? They are far greater fools. So I urge you, let these torments of hell take hold of your hearts. If you will think on hell’s torments while you live, it is the way to keep yourselves from those torments when you die. There is a fitting saying of Bernard: "Let us," he says, "go down to hell while we are alive, so that we may not go to hell when we are dead."

It is a very good saying, and I wish to God you would do the same, that you would go home today and consider what you have heard of the punishment of loss and the punishment of the senses. Perhaps these thoughts will so shape how you live that you may keep yourselves from hell when you die.

CHAPTER 4

THE ETERNITY OF HELL’S TORMENTS

 

But rather fear him who is able to destroy both Body and Soul in Hell. (Matt 10:28)

The observation to remember from these words is this:

Doctrine: The truth that God has absolute authority over men and women, to cast their souls into hell, should work in the hearts of his own people an awful fear of God.

In pursuing this, I have already gone over seven questions. I now proceed to the eighth in order, which is this:

Question 8: Are the torments of hell eternal or not? Will they last forever, or will they have an end? I will first answer this in general, then answer it more particularly.

1. In general, the torments of the damned are eternal torments. To show this, I will give you both Scripture and reason. For Scripture: in Matthew 18:8 the fire is called unquenchable fire. In Jude 1:7 it is called eternal fire, tormenting the wicked. In Matthew 25:46 they are called everlasting torments that will last forever. In 2 Thessalonians 1:9, "they shall be punished with everlasting destruction from the presence of the Lord." And in Daniel 12:2, "they shall be put into everlasting contempt." Put all these together, unquenchable fire, eternal fire, everlasting punishment, everlasting destruction, and everlasting contempt, and these Scriptures clearly show that the torments of the damned must be everlasting.

Now for reasons to show this, I will name a few.

1.) These torments must be eternal, because the justice of God, which the damned have wronged by their sins, can never be satisfied. Until God’s justice is satisfied, the wicked must be tormented. In Luke 12:59 the wicked remain in hell "till they have paid the utmost mite." If a sinner cannot pay God his due, and cannot make God amends for his sins, he must lie in hell that long. But it is impossible for a wicked man to pay that last mite, to satisfy God for the wrong he has done. This is why Jesus Christ, who is God as well as man, had to come down in the elect’s place, to make God amends for the wrong they did him in Adam and by their sins on earth. For this reason the torments of the damned must be eternal.

I have read a story of Tiberius Caesar. Being angry at an offender in his court, the offender petitioned the emperor that his punishment might be hastened, so he might know what to expect. The emperor answered, "O man, I am not yet friends." Beloved, God says the same. Wicked men wrong God’s justice, wrong God’s kindness, wrong God’s authority, and refuse to submit to his commands. They expect their torments to end soon. But God says no. He answers them as Tiberius answered his prisoner: "I have not yet restored you to favor. You and I are not yet friends. You have not made me amends for the wrong you have done me. So you must go on suffering."

2.) Wicked men will sin for all eternity, so their torments must be eternal. As long as sin remains in a man, the Lord will torment him, for sin and punishment cannot be separated. Sin is like oil, and God’s wrath like fire. As long as you keep pouring oil on fire, the fire cannot stop burning; as long as sin remains in a man’s nature, he cannot be free from suffering. In Revelation 14:11, "the smoke of their torments shall ascend for ever and ever." The wicked sin in hell forever, and so will be punished forever. Their cursings are their hymns, their howlings their tunes, their blasphemies their songs. There the wicked blaspheme the God who made them only to condemn them to hell eternally (Rev 16:9, 11, 21). "Being cursed of God, they curse God again." There they blaspheme his justice, because he judged them; his wrath, because they feel it.

There they condemn his mercy, because they never tasted it. And there they curse the blood of Christ, because that blood saved thousands, but did not save them. Hell is made up of nothing but blasphemies and sins. There they sin against God without end, and so without end they will be tormented by him.

3.) The godly will enjoy everlasting joy, so the wicked will endure eternal torments. Their conditions are exact opposites: the torments of one will last as long as the joys of the other. Just as one exists for the glory of God’s grace, the other exists for the glory of his justice. The wicked in hell sin against God continually, yet they never have a heart to repent of the sins they commit, so they must be punished forever. If men go on sinning and never repent, God must go on punishing; God will keep punishing as long as man keeps sinning impenitently. One author has said that the damned will always grieve, but only over their punishment. They will never be converted in a way that leads to pardon or grace. This is as far as I will go in general.

Now, more particularly, which will further illustrate and confirm the matter. Here I will show you that everything contributing in any way to the torments of the damned is itself eternal, and therefore the torments must be eternal. I ask you to give me your attention a little longer, as I go over every part of this sobering subject. I will cover it under eight heads.

1. The God who damns a wicked man is an eternal God, so the punishment must be eternal. As long as there is a God, so long there will be a hell, as Chrysostom said. In Isaiah 33:14, "Who can stand before the everlasting burnings?" God is called an everlasting God because he will burn and torment ungodly men to everlasting. Likewise Romans 16:26 speaks of "the commandments of the everlasting God." If the God who torments the wicked is an everlasting God, their torments must last as long as God does, and so be everlasting torments. Mr. Bolton, writing on this subject, offers this image: suppose all the mountains of the earth were mountains of sand, with still more mountains added, until they reached up to heaven; and suppose a little bird, once every thousand years, took away one grain of sand from this mountain.

An almost uncountable number of years would pass before that mass of sand was carried away entirely, and yet that span of time would still have an end. It would be a mercy for man if hell lasted no longer than that. But this is man’s misery in hell: after millions of years there, he will have no more hope of coming out than he did the moment he was first cast in, because his torments last to all eternity, without end, since the God who damns him is eternal.

2. The fire that torments wicked men is eternal fire. Jude 1:7 says "they suffered the vengeance of eternal fire," and so do (Isa 30:33 and Isa 66:24). If the fire is eternal, the torments must be eternal as well.

3. The prison that receives wicked men is an eternal prison. It is a prison that will never fall into ruin, never be broken through and dug into by thieves. It is a prison that shuts you in, from which you can never escape. Jude 1:6 calls hell everlasting chains of darkness. If you are in darkness, you do not know which way to go; if you are bound in chains of darkness, you have no hope of escape. This describes the condition of hell: once you are in, you cannot get out. That is why it is called a bottomless pit. Once a man begins sinking, he will not stop until he reaches the bottom; so it is in hell. Once you are shut in there, you will never come forth. As long as heaven remains heaven and hell remains hell, so long hell will torment the wicked, just as heaven blesses the saints.

4. The worm that gnaws the conscience of wicked men is an eternal worm. Isaiah 66:24 and Mark 9:44 say "there the worm shall never die." This worm is no natural worm, of the kind that gnaws on flesh in the grave, but the strivings and accusations of conscience. This is the worm that will forever gnaw and consume man’s peace. Even the heathen, though they had no Scripture, caught a glimpse of this by the light of nature. I have read in Virgil, a pagan poet, of one Tityus, whose liver was gnawed every day by a vulture, and repaired again each night, so the vulture could feed on it again the next day. In this they pictured hell, and the gnawing of conscience there. This vulture, your conscience, will devour your peace and torment you with thoughts of terror, and this you will have until time is no more.

Put all these together: the eternal God, the eternal prison, the eternal fire, and the eternal worm. The torments must be eternal as well.

5. The loss of God, and glory, and Jesus Christ, is an eternal loss. You know that when friends part, even for a while, the parting itself provokes tears. But if they part never to see each other again on earth, what floods of sorrow does that parting cause? When you are dying, you are departing not for a time, but forever. You bid an everlasting farewell to God and Christ, and to all the saints among whom you lived here in company. You bid them farewell, never to see them more, never to enjoy their company again. You will be cast into a dungeon of darkness, never to see the sun, into a bottomless pit, never to come out, into a society of devils, never again to be with Christ and his saints.

Your loss is an irrecoverable loss. "You shall see Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob in the kingdom of heaven, but you shall be shut out from it." Your loss will be an everlasting loss, and so your torments must be everlasting torments as well.

6. Sin, the cause of hell’s torments, is everlasting, so the torments must be eternal too. Put the cause in place, and the effect must follow; take the cause away, and the effect ceases. Since sin, the cause of hellish torments, lasts forever, wicked men will blaspheme God in hell to all eternity, blaspheme his justice, blaspheme his mercy, and blaspheme the blood of Jesus Christ. So hell’s torments, the effects of sin, must be eternal too.

7. The sentence passed against wicked men is an everlasting sentence: "Go from me ye cursed into everlasting fire." It is a sentence like that of the Medes and Persians, never to be revoked.

8. And lastly, the body and soul that are the subjects of these torments are eternal. The body is mortal here, subject to corruption; here it must die. But in hell, neither body nor soul will ever die. Your soul, subject to torments, is an eternal soul (Rev 9:6). No one will be able to put an end to himself, or to another. Now put all these together: your God is an eternal God, hell is an eternal prison, the fire is an everlasting fire, the worm is eternal, the soul and body are eternal, and sin, the cause of all, is eternal too. Then tell me if it can be denied that the torments of the damned must be eternal.

Application 1: Is this so, that the torments of the damned are eternal? Then consider the following.

1. This point refutes the ungrounded opinion of Origen, who held that although there is a hell, and although the wicked are tormented there (he grants that much), at the day of judgment there will be no such thing as hell any longer. He thought that everyone, not only the wicked on earth but even the devils, would be saved. This is a gross opinion. If these torments are eternal, and the wicked must be punished everlastingly, then Origen’s opinion, that all will be saved and hell destroyed, even the devils themselves saved, must be false. This plainly and clearly overturns that opinion.

2. Are the torments of hell eternal torments? This should teach those of you who live on earth to take heed that you do not risk enduring these eternal torments for temporary vanities. If you sin, you can sin only for a while. If you gain unjust wealth, you enjoy it only for a while. But if you are damned, you will be damned to all eternity. So take heed that you do not risk eternal torments for these things. Just as we say you can buy gold too dear, so you can buy these worldly vanities too dear. Demosthenes was tempted by the harlot Lais to uncleanness; she demanded ten thousand drachmas for one night’s pleasure. Demosthenes thought it over and answered her, "I do not love to buy pleasure at so dear a rate." If Demosthenes, a heathen, could answer a temptation this way, I would have you, who are Christians, answer it even more firmly. You are tempted by the devil to sin.

If you yield, you risk losing God, losing Christ, and undergoing these everlasting torments. So check your hearts and say: I do not intend to buy pleasure at so dear a rate. I will not lose God and lose Christ, and risk the sufferings of eternal torment forever, for the sake of a sin. Put off temptation with resolutions like these.

3. This gives grounds for condemning all desperate livers who wish themselves in hell before God would have them there. How many people cry out for God to damn them, to sink them, to confound them? Poor men! They do not know what they wish upon their souls. Some go beyond merely wishing themselves in hell; they would become self-murderers, sending themselves to hell before God would have them there. If a man truly knew what this place of torment is, he would never have such words in his mouth. Why? If you do not know, I will tell you.

When you wish for God to damn you, you wish only this: that God should take you from a pleasurable world, from your comforts and contentments, from a place of delight and pleasure, and send you instead to a place of darkness, a dungeon of darkness, a bottomless pit where you will never see light; that God should banish you from his presence, never to receive one kind look from him again; that God should cast you into unquenchable fire to burn you, into a lake of brimstone to choke you, and give you over to devils to torment you, where your torments will be ceaseless, endless, and beyond remedy. This is what it means to wish yourself in hell. So let the thought that hell’s torments are eternal give pause to all who cry for God to damn them. You are wishing upon yourself the greatest misery that can befall anyone, either in this life or in the world to come.

4. Learn from this, all of you redeemed by Jesus Christ, to patiently endure whatever temporary affliction God lays upon you in this world. However heavy the affliction God lays on you, whether a month’s pain from the stone, a year’s pain from gout, or a lifetime of sickness and weakness in your body, bless your God that you are delivered from the greatest pain of all. These are mere flea bites compared to the torments of the damned. So if God has freed you from the torments of hell, be patient, however much he afflicts you while you are in this world. The apostle draws this same lesson, comparing (1 Thess 1:6 and 1:10): "You received the word in much affliction, yet with joy." They were greatly afflicted, yet joyful.

On what ground? "Because you did wait for his Son from heaven, even Jesus that delivered us from wrath to come." This is the ground of their joy in affliction: because they were looking for Jesus. It is as if he said, blessed be God, who has delivered us from wrath to come, the greatest torment. So we may well rejoice and be patient under whatever affliction we meet in this world for Christ’s sake or for the profession of the gospel. We are freed from the greatest torments, and so we may well endure the lesser ones. All you redeemed of the Lord, let this doctrine of hell’s torments strengthen you greatly to bear any affliction here, because your afflictions are not eternal. God has freed you from eternal torments, far greater than any affliction you will ever undergo in this world.

5. Are the torments of the damned eternal torments? Then labor, while you live in this world, so that you do not come to ruin for all eternity, so that you do not plunge yourself into this infernal gulf from which there is no recovery. While you are here, there is hope, but afterward you are past hope. Labor now, while you live, so that you do not fall into an eternal state of misery. Zeuxis the painter was once asked why other men dashed off their work hastily and finished so much, while he took such pains and spent so much time to finish his work and make it complete. He answered, "Other men trade for profit, but I paint for eternity, to have my works seen to eternity, that future ages may behold them." Beloved, I would have you be like this painter. Other men sin, and swear, and gain unjust wealth, and care nothing for how.

Why do they do this? Because they are working for profit, looking only after the world and its pleasures. But you are working for eternity, and so you ought to live in such a way that you might be happy to all eternity, and not plunge yourself into these infernal flames.

Question 9: Since the torments of the damned are eternal, can it be just for God to damn a person forever for sinning only for a time? Flesh and blood might well protest to their maker: "I died young, perhaps not even ten years old, and yet I am likely to be damned forever. Is this just of God?" Another might say, "I lived only so long, and yet I am as liable to as great a punishment as the oldest man alive. Is it justice for God to damn someone to eternity for sinning only a while?" So wicked men might plead against God. To answer this, I will affirm that it is indeed just for God to condemn someone to eternity even though they sinned only briefly in this world. I will lay out four or five points to establish this.

1. To vindicate the justice of God, I answer that punishment should not be measured by how long the offense took to commit, but should be proportioned to the nature of the offense itself. For instance, a man might break into a house in less than an hour, yet it is just for the magistrate to keep him in prison until the sessions come, far longer than the act itself took. A man in a fit of anger might deal another a deadly wound in the blink of an eye, yet he may spend the rest of his life in prison, if he is lucky enough to escape worse, though the act took only a minute. If human justice can punish a long time for a brief act, will you set limits on God when men themselves face no such limits?

If a man can be punished for life for an act that took only an hour, and human beings have that liberty, shall God not have it also?

2. Sin is an offense against an infinite God, and because it is committed against infinite majesty, it deserves infinite punishment. You know that in the same act, the punishment is increased or lessened depending on the person against whom the act is done. Strike an ordinary man, and it may amount to a minor lawsuit and a small fine. Strike a prince, and you may face the rack or life imprisonment, because the person offended is so eminent. If sin were against an ordinary person, it would not be just for God to inflict extraordinary punishment. But sin is against a God who is infinite and eternal, so it may be just for God to inflict infinite torment. Since wicked men sin against God, who is the highest good and an infinite person by divine right, the punishment for their evil may justly be inflicted on them for all eternity.

3. If man were to live forever, he would sin forever. Seeing this disposition in man, God may justly damn him forever even though he sins only for a time. Man sins throughout the whole span of life he is given, so God may punish him throughout eternity. Man sins as long as he is able, so God will punish him as long as he is able. If man would sin forever given the chance, it is just for God to give him a check and a curb, and to make him suffer forever.

4. Wicked men, though they can sin no longer on earth, carry their sins with them into hell after death. There they continue sinning still, and do not repent. There their blasphemies increase, and their provocations against God grow greater than they were on earth. Put all this together, and you cannot charge God’s justice with dealing too harshly with wicked men, nor fasten any cruelty or injustice upon your maker.

Lastly, wicked men, by sinning, have lost an infinite good and opposed an infinite good, so they must endure an infinite evil. Since the wicked despise the infinite grace and infinite mercy of God, the infinite merits of Christ, and the infinite offers of grace from God, they are justly given over to infinite punishment. You have received infinite kindness from God, kindness without number. If you sin against these infinite mercies, it is just for God to punish you with infinite torments, for the nature of your punishment should correspond to the nature of your offense.

As an ancient author put it, "If there were ten thousand hells, and ten thousand times more torments in those hells than there are, it would not be enough to make amends to the justice of God for man’s sins." Wicked men, even if they endured ten thousand times what they do, could not satisfy or make amends to God for the wrong they have done him by sinning. So it is no injustice at all to damn a man forever, even though he lived only a short time to sin here.

Is it true, then, that it stands well with God’s justice to damn man forever, though he lives only a short while in this world to sin against him? This should teach you the evil and abominable nature of sin. If sin were not an abominable evil, it would never carry such intolerable punishments. You can know the lion by its paw, and so you can know sin by its punishment. If sin brings such great guilt and deserves so heavy a load of wrath laid upon the sinner, then sin must be an extreme evil. So do not think lightly of sin. You would be better off running into hell than into sin, for sin is worse than hell, since sin is what made hell to be hell. If the torments are eternal, and it is just for God to damn men to those torments for even one year of sinning, then see how truly evil sin is.

When you see a man drawn on a cart to the gallows, you assume he is no ordinary thief or murderer, but some notorious traitor to the state. From the greatness of the punishment, you infer the greatness of the crime. In the same way, you may infer that sin is an extremely sinful and extremely evil act, because it carries so extreme and so intolerable a punishment. So I urge you to look upon sin with detestation, and to see sin in its full weight. We tend to look at sin through a diminishing glass, and so see it as smaller than it is. But you should look at sin through a magnifying glass, and see how it carries everlasting and eternal punishment, and so must be exceedingly evil.

2. Learn from this that little children and young infants, even if they live only a day, are in as great danger as men who live a hundred years. God will not judge you by how long you lived, but by the odious nature of sin itself. I draw this out to correct a mistaken and sentimental notion many people hold. They call children innocent, as though they were harmless, as though free of sin, and many women wish they were where that child now is, though that child may in fact be damned. Do not misunderstand me: I do not say all children are damned, for God has secret ways of working grace in them and saving them, just as he has open ways of saving others. But I do say that children, even if they live only a minute in this world, may justly be punished by God for the sin of their nature.

3. Is God just even though he punishes men forever for sinning only a while? Then, you young men and women here before God today, consider this: you have already lived long enough in sin to deserve eternal torment, however young you may be. Let this thought settle in your hearts: I have lived long enough already to be a fit subject for hell. So stop, and go no further in sin, lest you increase and aggravate your own torments.

Lastly, learn from this not to charge God with severity, as though he were hard-hearted, and not to charge him with injustice. In resolving this question, you have seen God’s justice fully cleared: he may justly damn you to eternal torments, even though you have sinned only a short time in this world.

CHAPTER 5

FEAR GOD RATHER THAN MEN

 

But rather fear him who is able to destroy both Body and Soul in Hell. (Matt 10:28)

The observation drawn from these words was this:

Doctrine: That the consideration of this, that God the Father has an absolute sovereignty over men and women, to cast soul and body into hell, should work in the hearts of his own people an awful fear of God.

In pursuing this, I have gone over nine questions. I now come to a tenth.

Question 10: Will most men and women be tormented in hell, or not? I will deal in the words of truth without flattery or partiality. Though this is one of the most dismal doctrines a minister can preach, Scripture is so full and plentiful on this matter that I cannot pass it over without being unfaithful to my text. I will answer it affirmatively: that most of the men and women God has made will have as their portion and misery to be tormented in hell forever. To confirm this, I will give five grounds.

1. Most men will be damned because most men and women in the world neither know Christ nor look after Christ, who alone can deliver them from hellish torments. Geographers say that if the whole world were divided into thirty-one parts, only five of the thirty-one know or profess Jesus Christ. Nineteen parts of the world are possessed at this very day by Turks and Jews, neither of whom acknowledge Jesus Christ. Seven parts are possessed merely by heathens, who know no Christ but worship idols of wood and stone, leaving only five parts possessed by Christians. So twenty-six parts of the world never look after the Christ who alone can free them from this place of torment. If men do not know or regard Jesus Christ, that is their doom; they must be tormented in hell forever, for it is impossible they could otherwise be saved. And of those five parts, many are Papists.

As Perkins says, "A Papist living and dying so, in a place where the Gospel is preached in an ordinary way, cannot be saved."

2. Even among those who do know and profess Jesus Christ, only a few will be saved. If that is so, you may guess that the greatest multitude of men will be damned: "Many are called, but few are chosen" (Matt 22:14). Many are called by the outward preaching of the Gospel to a profession, but few are chosen to salvation by election. Most of these are either profane in life or hypocrites at heart.

3. This will appear if you consider what wicked men in Scripture are compared to. Among many other things, wicked men in Scripture are compared to these seven things.

1.) Sometimes wicked men are compared to grasshoppers: "They are as the grasshoppers upon the earth innumerable" (Jer 46:23). We know that no insect on earth is as numerous as the grasshopper. Wicked men are compared to grasshoppers for their innumerableness, an innumerable company of wicked men there are. The Hebrew word for grasshopper signifies multitudes, and comparing wicked men to grasshoppers signifies that the greatest number of men are wicked, and therefore must be punished in this place of torment.

2.) Wicked men are compared to bees: "They came about me like bees on every side" (Ps 118:12). Bees, as you know, come together in great multitudes and swarms. Wicked men are likened to them in Scripture to show that there are swarms of wicked men in the world, ordained for hell, as bees are for the fire.

3.) Wicked men are compared to briars and thorns: "The light of Israel is a fire, and the Holy One of Israel as flames to devour and burn the thorns and briars" (Isa 10:17). This is spoken of Jesus Christ, the Holy One of God; he will be as fire to burn up wicked men. So also: The earth that brings forth briars and thorns is good for nothing but the fire (Heb 6:8). The godly are compared to lilies (Song 2:2). There are only a few lilies in a field, but every hedge has thorns and briars, showing that wicked men are as numerous as thorns and briars. You may find wicked men in every place, at every turn, as numerous as briars in a hedge, so many are ordained for everlasting wrath.

4.) Wicked men are compared in Scripture to mire and dirt: "He shall tread them down as mire in the street" (Isa 10:6); "They are like the sea, casting forth mire and dirt" (Isa 57:20). You will not find gold dust or silver dust everywhere, but you will find dirt and mire everywhere. Wicked men are called mire and dirt to show that they are everywhere. You can hardly take a step from your home without mire and dirt defiling you; you can hardly walk anywhere without meeting wicked men. This shows the multitude of those prepared for this place of torment.

5.) Wicked men are compared to stones (Matt 15:5). If you seek precious pearls, you can hardly find one, but you cannot leave your door without seeing stones in the street (Mal 3:17). Godly men are like rare jewels, but wicked men are like stones in the street, common and ordinary. They are called by these terms in Scripture to signify both the vileness and the numerousness of those who will perish, that they are the greatest number in the world.

6.) They are compared to worthless fish (Matt 13:48). It is notable that no living creature in the world increases as fish do; no creature on earth is so prolific, for one fish will bring forth a hundred, which no other creature can do. Wicked men are compared to fish to show that they are the greatest number of all people upon earth, ordained for this place of torment.

7.) Wicked men are compared to vessels of wood (2 Tim 2:20). If a man has two or three pieces of silver plate in his house, that is a great matter, for vessels of noble metal are few. But everyone may have wood and earthenware and vessels of baser metal, for these are common. God’s children are called vessels of honor, vessels of gold, and vessels of glory, showing there are few of them in the world, whereas wicked men are numerous and many. So, by these comparisons to which wicked men are likened, it appears that those ordained for eternal torment are the greatest number of people in the world.

4. A fourth reason is that the greatest part of men and women in the world live and die in the sins that lead to hell, this place of torment. If wicked men live and die without repentance, continuing in a course of sin, they must end in torments and arrive at hell. "The whole world," says John, "lies in wickedness" (1 John 5:19), meaning that the greatest number of people in the world live and die in their sins. "All men seek their own, but not the things of Jesus Christ" (Phil 2:21). That is, most men seek their profit, their pleasures, their lusts, but few or none seek after Jesus Christ. If Scripture tells us that all or most men in the world seek their lusts and themselves, and live and die in their sins, it must follow that most men are ordained for hell, this place of torment.

5. If you were to single out all persons in the world and look over every sort of man, what they are, what they do, and how they live, you would see that among every sort and rank of men, the fewest are saved. First, look at kings and nobles, the great and mighty of the earth. Scripture tells us, "Not many mighty, not many noble are called" (1 Cor 1:26). I remember that Buchanan, who was King James’s tutor (a Scotchman), when he lay dying, asked a nobleman then with him to render his allegiance to the king in England, and also to deliver this message: that his old master Buchanan was going to a place where few kings would come. I have read of another ancient author who said, "The pavement of hell is made up of the skulls of kings and the bones of noblemen."

His meaning is that the estates and honors of great and mighty men lead most of them so far into sin that they fall into this place of torment. This is why Christ himself tells us that it is as hard for a camel to go through a needle’s eye as for a rich man to enter heaven. Then look at learned men, and see how few of them attain salvation. "Where is the scribe? and where is the wise man? and where is the disputer of this world?" There were many of them, but what does the text say next? "The world by wisdom knew not God" (1 Cor 1:20). As if to say, there are many disputants, great scholars, and wise men in the world, yet the apostle says the world, by all its wisdom, did not know God.

That is, by all their scholarship and learning and natural wisdom, they fall short of knowing God in Jesus Christ, and so by consequence fall short of heaven. Chrysostom, preaching before a company of ministers, once said, "I do not know whether any clergyman is saved." His meaning was that the calling is so weighty, the temptations so many, and the lives of clergy often so bad. Elsewhere he said that religion is never in greater danger than among the most reverend. Look at every sort of man, and Scripture tells you that few of any sort will be saved. Look at all men in general.

If you were to single out the drunkard from the sober man, the adulterer from the chaste, the covetous man from the merciful, the hypocrite from the sincere, and the profane from the godly, and send the one group to heaven and the other to hell, how would the number of adulterers, drunkards, and other profane persons infinitely outstrip the number of sober, chaste, merciful, and godly people? I urge you, therefore, take heed and do not flatter yourselves, for the greatest number of men are ordained for hell, this place of torment.

6. This is clear from several express testimonies of Scripture. Consider first (Matt 7:14): "Wide is the gate, and broad is the way that leads unto hell, and many there be that go that way; but strait is the gate, and narrow is the way that leads unto life, and few there be that find it." There Scripture tells us that most go to hell, and only the fewest to heaven. So also in Luke 13:23, certain men asked Christ, "Lord are there few that shall be saved?" Christ answers in these very words: "Strive to enter in at the strait gate, for many shall seek to enter, and shall not be able." Some never seek heaven, and they will never come there. Many will seek and not find heaven. So from Christ’s answer you can judge that only a few will be saved, and most will perish.

So also (Luke 12:32): "Fear not little flock" (the word in the Greek is more emphatic, carrying two diminutives, "little, little flock," showing how very small the flock is that will be saved by Jesus Christ). So also (Rom 9:27): "Though the children of Israel be as the sand on the sea shore for multitude, yet but a remnant of them shall be saved." This saving does not refer to the time of Hezekiah, when all Judea was overrun by the Assyrians and only Jerusalem was spared, nor to their deliverance from the Babylonish captivity, as some explain it, though I grant that carries some resemblance, since though many were in captivity, only a few came out. Rather, it refers to their eternal salvation: though the number of the Jews be as the sand on the seashore, only a few of them will be saved.

You who are tradesmen know that if a remnant is left over from a great piece of cloth, you pass over it and think little of it, since the remnant is worth nothing compared to the whole piece. Though the Jews were numberless in number, only a remnant of them will be saved, and if so, you can guess where the multitude must go.

Objection 1: Some say, "What, most of the creatures God has made are damned and must endure the torments of hell? This cannot be believed. How can this be true, when Genesis 15:4 says that God came to Abraham and told him, ‘Look towards heaven, and tell the stars, if thou art able to number them; and he said to him, so shall thy seed be?’ God told Abraham his seed would be as the stars, an innumerable company. So how can God have promised this to Abraham, and yet most men be damned? How can this be?"

Answer 1: I answer that this promise in Genesis 15 does not refer to the eternal salvation of all Abraham’s seed. It is only a promise concerning an eternal mercy, that Abraham would have an innumerable seed with an everlasting admission into church privileges, counted by God as a church, not that all of them would be saved.

The apostle explains this meaning in Romans 9:6–8: "They are not all Israel which are of Israel;" that is, not all who descend from Abraham or Jacob will be saved. "Neither because they are the seed of Abraham, are they all children; but in Isaac shall thy seed be blessed;" that is, all the elect will be saved in Christ. "They which are his children in the flesh, these are not the children of God." It is as if he said: it is true Abraham had an innumerable seed by natural descent, but these numbers are not all children of God merely because they came from Abraham’s loins. Only those who come from Christ and have an interest in Christ will be saved by him, not all of Abraham’s seed.

2. I answer further that this cannot mean all Abraham’s seed will be saved, because that would contradict other Scriptures. Other passages say, "Though the number of the children of Israel be as the sand upon the sea shore, but few shall be saved" (Rom 9:27), and "all that are of Israel, are not Israel." All who descend from Abraham’s loins and are God’s people by an external covenant will not all be saved.

Objection 2: Yet we read in 1 Timothy 4:10, "God is the saviour of all men." If God is the savior of all men, how can it be true that most men will endure the torments of hell and suffer eternal fire?

To answer this, I must distinguish two senses of salvation. God may properly be called a savior in two ways.

1. By giving an outward and temporal salvation.

2. By giving an everlasting and eternal salvation. When it is said, "God is the saviour of all men," this does not mean he saves the souls of every man. That salvation is confined to the elect (Heb 9:28; Heb 5:9). Rather, it speaks only of an outward and bodily salvation: God saves the bodies of his people, and even the bodies of wicked men, from many dangers and deaths in this world. I show this is the meaning in three ways.

1.) From the context. "He is the saviour of all men" follows the statement, "We labour and suffer reproach." To encourage God’s people under outward sufferings and bodily reproaches, the apostle tells them God is the savior of all men. God delivers all men, sooner or later, from many dangers that threaten them.

2.) Because Scripture describes the saving of the elect in a different manner than his saving of all men. 1 Timothy 4:10 says, "He is the saviour of all men, especially of them that believe." It is as if he said: God saves all men from many dangers and diseases, but he saves the godly and elect who believe in another, special manner. This implies that the salvation spoken of here cannot mean the salvation of the soul.

3.) Because otherwise this Scripture would contradict other Scriptures, which say that all men will not be saved by Jesus Christ. It is a true rule in divinity that no passage of Scripture can be read in a sense that contradicts the meaning of another, since Scripture is written by one and the same Spirit and speaks with one voice everywhere. There is harmony between passage and passage, no clash or disagreement. Since other passages say God will not save all, but most will perish, you can take it as settled that this passage cannot mean that all will have eternal salvation through Jesus Christ.

From this truth I can draw eight distinct lessons.

Application 1: Is it the fate of most men to endure hellish torments? Learn from this to see the unsoundness of the opinion held by the Church of Rome, that universality marks the true Church. That cannot be, because the universal majority, most of mankind, are damned and perish. To make universality the badge of a true church is therefore an unsound and groundless opinion.

2. This condemns the opinion of Origen, who held that "all men would be saved, yes, even the devils." This opinion is unsound and without any basis, for far from saying all will be saved, Scripture says the most will be damned.

3. Learn from this that it is not safe to follow a multitude, or to make popularity the rule and guide of your actions, because numbers do not always have truth on their side. Often the multitude walks in the wrong way. So do not say you will follow a path because most people do, for then you walk the way that leads to hell, since most will go there.

4. Search and test your hearts to see whether you are among the many men and women who will perish. You may ask how to do this. I will give you a brief way to discover it: if you do as most do, you may be sure you will go where most go. Look over your ways. Most people have their tongues tipped with oaths; do you? Most have their mouths full of lies; do you? Most take no care for the Sabbath; do you? Most are profane, most follow their lusts; do you? If so, take this as a dreadful verdict: you will go where the most go, to a place of torment, to remain there forever. So I urge you, hold these tests up to your heart, to see whether you are among the great number appointed to perish, or not.

5. Learn from this not to be offended at how few believers there are. Though the saved are few and the damned are many, it is still better to be saved with a few than damned with the many. Agonaldus, a heathen prince taken prisoner by the emperor, once saw thirty-six poor men, few in number and poor in dress. He asked the emperor who they were, and the emperor answered, "They are the followers of Jesus Christ." "Are they so?" he said. "Has Christ such poor followers, and has Christ no more? Then surely I will never follow Jesus Christ." The poverty and fewness of Christ’s followers made him stumble at Christ, so that he refused to embrace Christianity. How many men stumble at this same thorn today? They see some ministers strict in life and preaching, and some people careful in their conduct.

But most of their neighbors love good company, love to drink now and then, to be jovial and merry now and then, and so they reason that they may do as most of their neighbors do. This bolsters many in a course of wickedness and profaneness, and opens a wide road to hell.

6. Do most people perish? Then what cause for lament this gives to those who are delivered from those hellish torments, when they consider how many are to perish forever. Here I might call for floods of tears. All you who are delivered and redeemed from the wrath to come, all you who have escaped these torments through justification in Christ, come and lament over the multitude who must endure everlasting fire through all eternity. Xerxes, at the head of an army of a million men, climbed a high mountain to watch his army march by. Seeing such a vast number of men, he wept. His nobles asked why, and he said, "I weep for this, to think that within this hundred years there will not be one of all these gallant men alive."

If a heathen could mourn over that, how much more should you Christians mourn to see hundreds, thousands, millions in the world, knowing that most of them will, within a few years, be not only in their graves but in hell? Mourn and lament that the greatest number of people in the world are appointed to be cast into the torments of hell.

7. Let this rouse you from complacency. If most are damned, why should you not be among that number? If most are damned, how can you prove you belong to the smaller number who are saved? Chrysostom once asked this question in a public sermon: "How few are there in the city of Antioch who shall be saved?" His answer was this: "In this great city of Antioch, where there are a hundred thousand people and more, I can hardly, in all my observation, find a hundred who look after Jesus Christ. And of that hundred, I greatly doubt that many are sound toward God." Rouse up your complacent heart, you deluded sinner. You live in London, where perhaps many thousands profess Jesus Christ, but God knows how few of them will be saved by him. Let your conscience be awakened and your spirit fearful within you, lest you be found among the great number who will perish forever and endure the torments of the damned.

8. Learn from this not to harbor any ill thoughts against the mercy of God or the merits of Jesus Christ. There is no fault in Christ’s blood, no fault in his sufferings, no fault in God’s mercy, that most men perish. The fault lies in yourself and your sins. So do not blame God or Jesus Christ for it. This brings me to the next question, the eleventh, having proved that most people will endure the torments of hell.

Question 11: It may be asked: how can this stand with the mercy of God, that most of the men and women he made will be damned? This question has puzzled the Arminians and Origen. He could not conceive that God could be a merciful God and yet let so many perish, as Scripture teaches. Beloved, you see clearly from Scripture that it is true, beyond all contradiction. Yet as a minister it falls to me to say something to you in defense of my Lord and Master Jesus Christ, to show that though it is true that most men and women will be damned, this in no way impeaches the mercy of God or the merits of Jesus Christ. I will lay this out in five or six points.

1. To those who raise this objection, I would say what the apostle says: "Who art thou that dost cavil with thy Maker, or repliest against thy God?" (Rom 9:20). "Shall the potter say to him that fashioned it, why hast thou made me thus?" The apostle makes this comparison: if a potter makes a plain vessel of clay, will the pot say, "Why have you made me like this?" The potter would not take that treatment kindly from a piece of broken pottery. Now God has far greater power over man than the potter has over the clay. If the clay must not speak this way, you have no right to argue with God, asking why he has damned you or why you are not saved. This is the very reasoning the apostle rules out, that the Lord will not tolerate. You must not open your mouth against God on this account.

2. God damns no one without there being sin in that person deserving greater damnation than God actually inflicts. So you cannot charge God with any cruelty. "What if God willing to shew his wrath, and make his power known, endureth with much longsufferings vessels of wrath, fitted for destruction?" (Rom 9:22). God sends no one to hell before that person, through their own sin, has become fit for hell. Wicked people are damned because they are vessels of wrath fitted for destruction. Should God not send them to the place they are fit for? Those who sin on earth, dishonor God on earth, and make sin their pleasure, are not fit for heaven; heaven would be a hell to them. Those who do not love godly duties on earth will not love them in heaven.

How can you open your mouth against God when he tells you he has borne with you for many years, perhaps, before your damnation, and when he casts you there, he tells you that you are fitted for hell, if that turns out to be your sad portion? We cannot charge God with unmercifulness. God damns no one; it is sin in that person that fits them for hell and makes them a vessel of wrath fitted for destruction.

3. Whatever agrees with God’s decree also agrees with his mercy. It agrees with God’s decree that most people should perish, so this does not contradict his mercy. This is a certain rule: God’s decrees can never clash with any of his attributes, and since mercy is one of his attributes, the decree does not contradict it. Otherwise God would be warring against himself, which is unthinkable.

4. For God to damn most of mankind is so far from impeaching his mercy that it actually sets his mercy in greater relief. "What if God, willing to shew his wrath, and to make his power known, endured the vessels of wrath fitted for destruction; and that he might make known the riches of his grace unto the vessels of mercy which he hath prepared for glory?" (Rom 9:22–23). It is as if he were saying, does the damnation of souls impeach God’s mercy? No, it declares God’s mercy, because through it God shows the riches of his grace to all the vessels of mercy, to all his elect, so that though so many perish, they are saved.

5. God would show more mercy by saving even one person in the world than he would show extreme injustice by damning the whole world. If God saved only one person, that would still be great mercy, because that one deserves neither salvation nor deliverance from hellish torments. And if God damned the entire world, he would not thereby show extreme or rigorous injustice, because "all the world have sinned, and fallen short of the glory of God." All the world has fallen short of glory and heaven, so that even if God damned everyone, he would not be an unjust God. So for a person to object to the mercy of God, what is this but to set yourself above your Maker? What is this but to argue, like the papists, as though works could merit heaven and could obligate God to save rather than damn us?

Instead, you see: it is mercy in God if he saves even one; it would be just in God if he damned all. So whether God saves as many as he does, or only a few, or only one, it is mercy in every case, and the more he saves, the greater that mercy appears. God was bound to save none of his creatures. He would not have been unmerciful had he never poured out a single drop of his bounty, but kept his goodness within himself, as he did before creation. He is not obligated to share it with anyone.

1. How should this convict you, if you have harbored ill thoughts of God? You have resented God for laying bodily afflictions on you, yet you would not dare resent him for laying hell and the weight of his wrath on you, scorching your soul in fire and brimstone. So how should this check you? Perhaps you have suffered gout, or stone, or some other affliction in this world, and thought God a hard master, and blamed him foolishly for it. But if God cast you into hell, you would have no right to blame him at all. One author put it this way: "Lord, make me miserable on earth, and I will yet say you are a merciful God still. Cast me into hell, and I will acknowledge your mercy still. Cast me into the lowest pit of hell, and I will still say your mercy extends to me, for my sins have deserved more torment than hell itself could inflict."

Beloved, even if our natures could bear more torment than the devil can inflict, our sin deserves it. So God is merciful in inflicting no more upon you than he does.

2. If the damned have no cause to think ill of God’s mercy, how much more cause do you have to acknowledge and remember the greatness of the riches of his mercy, you who are freed from damnation, delivered from wrath, and called to obtain salvation by Jesus Christ (Eph 2:5–7)? You have greater cause to praise the mercy of God than the damned have, though even they have no cause to speak against it.

The twelfth question follows.

Question 12: Is there another place of torment after this life, besides hell, where the souls of men and women are tormented? I judged it right to take this question up because the papists, to turn people away from the thought of hell, hold that there is a purgatory. They describe it as a place of torment after death, underground, above hell, with fire nearly as terrible as hell’s fire, where, as in a prison, the souls of people must remain for a time so that those not fully purged in this life may be purged after it, and so made fit to enter heaven. They teach that the souls of good men do not go straight to heaven when they die, but into purgatory, where they are tormented, some for ten years, some twenty, some a hundred, and are purified there before entering glory. Bellarmine, the great champion of the papists, writes at length on this.

The opinion arose in the year 595 after Christ’s birth, first raised by Pope Gregory the First, who held that for certain small faults, or venial sins, souls must remain in fire before the day of judgment. To support the fire of purgatory, the papists gather up a great heap of flimsy, flashy arguments from Scripture.

The first Scripture, and the chief of all, on which they try to rest this doctrine, is (1 Cor 3:11–13, 15): "Other foundation could no man lay, than what is laid, Jesus Christ; and if any man build upon this foundation, gold, silver, and precious stones, wood, hay, stubble, every man’s work shall be manifest, because it shall be revealed by fire, and the fire shall try every man’s work, of what sort it is: if any man’s work be burned, he shall suffer loss, yet he himself shall be saved, yet so as by fire." Here the papists think they have found undeniable ground. "He shall be saved, yet so as by fire," they say, means he shall pass through purgatory fire, which will save him from hell fire, so that he comes to heaven a little while after.

Before I give you the true sense of the passage, let me set aside their argument and show that "fire" here does not mean the fire of purgatory, for these reasons:

1. If they take "fire" here literally, they must also take "wood, hay, stubble" literally. But these words cannot be literal; they must be metaphorical. So "fire" must be metaphorical too.

2. The passage says the fire shall burn the work and try the work: "every man’s work shall be burned," not the person. But purgatory fire burns the soul, not the work, so it cannot be meant here.

3. The passage says the fire will make every man’s work manifest, that is, visible. But what happens in purgatory fire is not manifest to us; we do not know what happens there. So this cannot be purgatory fire, since this fire reveals things, and must therefore be some other fire.

4. The passage says every man’s work shall be tried, but not every man will be in purgatory, for the martyrs will not go there.

5. Here the workman loses his work, but in purgatory, as the papists describe it, no work is lost.

Now let me give you the true scope and sense of these words. "If any man build on this foundation gold, silver, precious stones, wood, hay, stubble," and so on. The foundation is Jesus Christ. The builders are ministers, and ministers are of two sorts: some build with gold, silver, and precious stones; others with wood, hay, and stubble. That is, some ministers preach Jesus Christ and make him their foundation, yet mix in wood, hay, and stubble, meaning they preach corrupt and shallow doctrine on lesser matters. Others lay gold and precious stones, meaning they preach true and sound doctrine, holding fast to Jesus Christ as their foundation. The text says every man’s work shall be tried and burned, yet the man himself saved, and that by fire. The fire here means the fire of the word and the Spirit.

It is an image drawn from a refiner: as the refiner’s fire consumes the dross and separates it from the good metal, so the fire of the word consumes erroneous opinions and unsound doctrine (called here wood, hay, and stubble) and burns up these dull, corrupt views. When the fire of the word consumes these errors, the man who held them, reformed by the word, may have his soul saved, if through that reformation he abandons his error. This is the true sense of the passage.

It is not strange that the word of God is called fire; the Lord himself calls it so: "Is not my word even like fire, saith the Lord, and like a hammer that breaketh a stone?" (Jer 23:29). Jeremiah likewise tells us that the word within him was like fire in his breast. It is common in Scripture for God’s word to be called fire, and that is the sense required here. Just as fire separates dross from good metal, the fire of the word consumes unsound doctrine and separates error from sound teaching.

The papists cite many other passages to support their doctrine of purgatory, such as Matthew 12:32, where it is said, "That he that sinneth against the Holy Ghost, shall never be forgiven in this life, nor in the life to come." They claim "the life to come" means purgatory, so that a man who commits that sin will be forgiven neither in this life nor by the purifying fire of purgatory.

I answer that "the world to come" does not mean any time immediately after death, but refers to the day of judgment. The man who commits that sin will receive pardon neither here nor at the day of judgment. This is how "the world to come" is used elsewhere in Scripture: "The children of this world marry, and are given in marriage, but they that shall be counted worthy to obtain another world, and the resurrection from the dead, neither marry nor are given in marriage" (Luke 20:35).

Here Christ makes "the world to come" the beginning of that time when the dead shall rise, which is the day of judgment. So "the world to come" does not mean a time in which the souls of men lie in purgatory, but the time when Jesus Christ comes to judge the world. At that time, the one who sins against the Holy Spirit will not be pardoned, but will be condemned to hell for that sin. Again,

2. The world to come does not point to a purgatory. It is used in an exclusive sense: he shall not be forgiven in this world, nor in the world to come, meaning he shall never be forgiven. Mark explains the passage this way: "He that blasphemeth against the Holy Ghost, shall never have forgiveness, but is in danger of eternal damnation" (Mark 3:29). Mark shows this phrase means the same thing as "never to be forgiven," leaving the papists no footing to claim that "life to come" here supports their purgatory. So much for their objections.

I will now lay down reason and Scripture against this opinion, beginning with the reasons.

1. There can be no such place of torment as purgatory, because such a place would greatly diminish the merit and sufferings and blood of Jesus Christ. It would suggest that Christ’s blood cannot purge the soul from the guilt of all sin, and that the fire of purgatory must finish the work. But we are cleansed by his blood from all our sins (1 John 1:7). Christ’s blood is a Christian’s purgatory: "we are purged by his blood" (Heb 1:3). If purgatory were granted, it would undercut the power of Christ’s blood, as though it could not fully purge away the sins of man.

2. This would also diminish the satisfaction of Jesus Christ, as if he had not fully satisfied the wrath of his Father, and a man must still be purged further before he can enter heaven.

3. It charges God with cruelty, as though he would torment his children for sins already pardoned.

4. This would charge God with extreme injustice, demanding double satisfaction for one fault. Jesus Christ gave God the Father full satisfaction for all the sins the elect had committed against him. If God the Father then punished the elect in purgatory, he would be punishing a man for a sin for which Christ had already given ample satisfaction.

5. This would also create a trade in pardons, as we see practiced in the church of Rome. For these reasons, we cannot grant that there is a place of torment for the elect after this life ends.

Scripture likewise stands strongly against this view. Paul writes, "I desire to be dissolved, and to be with Christ" (Phil 1:23). The apostle tells us clearly that once he was dissolved, he would be with Christ at once. This is why the early Christians did not celebrate the day of their birth, but the day of their death. Likewise, "The body goes to the dust, and the spirit to God that gave it" (Eccl 12:7). The spirit did not go to purgatory but to heaven immediately. When the body of an elect person dies, it goes to the grave, and the spirit, the soul, goes to God who gave it. So too, after Lazarus died, he was carried by angels into Abraham’s bosom (Luke 16:23). And the thief on the cross was told, "This day shalt thou be with me in Paradise."

He did not go to purgatory but to Paradise, and Paradise here means heaven, as we see by comparing it with Paul’s words, I was wrapt up into Paradise, the third heaven (2 Cor 12:2–4), where Jesus Christ is in glory. See also (2 Cor 5:6, 8). Many more texts could be cited to overturn this baseless opinion. Besides, there will be many still living on earth at the day of judgment who will never pass through purgatory at all. Therefore no such place exists.

Is there no other place besides hell to torment persons in? Is there no purgatory fire to purge away the sins you have committed here? This truth serves a double purpose.

1. It brings comfort to you who are godly. Never fear torment when you come to die. I profess I would not be a papist for all the world, even if this were the only error in all their doctrine, that as I lay groaning on my deathbed under some lingering disease, I should have to consider that I must burn in fire for ten, twenty, a hundred years. Death would be a terror to me, to think I must enter a fire for a thousand years even after escaping hell. What comfortless doctrines these wicked papists preach, keeping the consciences of their hearers in horror! But you who are God’s elect, take comfort: when you lie on your deathbed, I would stake my soul on yours, you will never be tormented. The flame will never touch you. Instead you will go to God; you will enter into glory.

2. Let this astonish all of you who are wicked. As soon as you die, you will go not into purgatory but into hell, where a fire kindled by the breath of the Lord will burn you forever. No better place than this is prepared for you, when your soul and body are torn apart.

CHAPTER 6

CHRIST’S DESCENT INTO HELL

 

But rather fear him who is able to destroy both Body and Soul in Hell. (Matt 10:28)

The doctrine I drew from these words was this:

Doctrine: That the consideration of this, that God the Father has an absolute sovereignty over men and women, to cast soul and body into hell, should work in the hearts of his own people an awful fear of God.

In pursuing this, I resolve many questions. I now come to what remains to be said on this subject, and I turn to a thirteenth question, which is this.

Question 13: Did Jesus Christ personally descend into hell, that place of torment, or not? There are various opinions about this point. I will, as best I can, set down what seems most agreeable to truth and Scripture, and afterward set down the Scriptures that lead some men to think Christ did descend into hell, that place of the damned.

For answer, I will set down this assertion: that Jesus Christ did not descend into hell, that place of the damned. I will confirm this with three scriptural reasons.

1. Christ did not descend into hell, because Luke, the most exact historian among the evangelists, one who declared exactly to the end all things Christ either did or suffered, does not mention this action of his going personally into hell. Yet Luke tells us, (Luke 1:3), "I know all things that Jesus Christ did"; compare (Acts 1:1). If Christ had gone down into hell, the place of the damned, this being so significant an action, surely Luke and the other evangelists would never have left it out, since they recorded things far less significant that Jesus Christ did.

2. If Christ descended personally into hell, he must have descended either in body or in soul. His body could not have gone into hell, for it was laid in the grave that very night by Joseph of Arimathea, and the text says, (Matt 12:40), "As Jonas was three days and three nights in the whale’s belly, so shall the Son of Man be in the bowels of the earth." Nor could his soul have been in hell, for it is said, (Luke 23:24), that Christ said to the thief upon the cross, "This day shalt thou be with me in Paradise." How could Christ tell the thief he would be with him that day in heaven, unless his own soul went there? So since neither his body nor his soul was in hell, Christ was not there.

3. There was no purpose that Christ’s descent into hell would have served. Christ would never do anything without a good purpose behind it, and no such purpose appears here. If Christ had gone down into hell, it must have been for one of three reasons: either, as the papists hold, to bring souls out of hell; or to make further satisfaction for the sins of his people; or to vanquish and overcome the devil. None of these three could be the reason.

1.) It could not have been Christ’s purpose in going into hell to fetch souls from there, because it is a settled principle in divinity that souls once in hell never come out. As Abraham says in Luke 16:26, "There is a great gulph between us and you, that they that would come to us from you cannot." After death there is no redemption, no repentance, no hope of mercy once a person is in hell. This cannot have been Christ’s purpose, since no one who is once damned can be saved.

2.) Nor could the purpose have been to make further satisfaction for the sins of the elect, because Christ had already fully satisfied God’s wrath by dying on the cross. So we read in John 19:30 that when Christ took gall and vinegar to drink, he cried out, "It is finished." The work of your salvation was finished by Christ Jesus in his death, so Christ had no need to go into hell to do further work for your redemption.

3.) Christ had already fully vanquished the devil by dying on the cross. As Colossians 2:15 says, "He spoiled principalities and powers, and triumphed over them in the same cross." The apostle knew Christ had overcome the devil in dying, for otherwise he could not speak of triumphing over him in this way. So too Hebrews 2:14 says "Christ by dying destroyed him that had the power of death, that is, the devil." Christ therefore had no need to go to hell to destroy the devil, for he had already done it upon the cross. These reasons should confirm you in believing that Jesus Christ did not descend into hell, that place of the damned.

Now there are four objections or arguments that those who hold to Christ’s descent into hell raise against this. The first is this.

Will you hold that Christ did not go down into hell? Is this not an article of our creed? Does our creed not say that Christ was born, and descended into hell, and the third day rose again from the dead? And are the articles of our creed not true? To this I answer as follows.

It is true that what we call our creed does say this, that Christ descended into hell, but I do not know on what grounds it says so. It is both contrary to Scripture and to reason. I recall that the learned author Mr. Perkins, writing on that article of the creed in his expositions, said, "I have seen sixty creeds of the most ancient councils in various authors, and in those sixty creeds this clause was not present. But," he said, "how it came to be inserted, whether by carelessness, or by corruption of the times, or by the influence of the papists, I do not know. All I can say is this: Christ was buried and rose the third day, and no more." You may find this discussed at length if you read his book. Many learned church fathers likewise flatly reject this phrase, and the Council of Nicaea, along with other councils, condemned this clause as erroneous.

So though it is part of our creed, if it is not according to Scripture, I wish it were removed. I grant that the creed compactly gathers together the articles of the faith, and that everything in it is true except this. Interpreters who try to excuse this phrase in the creed say that the word here does not mean hell, the place of the damned, but that Christ’s descent into hell means he was held captive under the power of death for three days. They soften the phrase this way in order to keep it in the creed. But, beloved, though scholars who know Greek understand that the Greek word for hell can also mean the grave, ordinary people, unaware of this, seeing the word "hell" there, take it to mean no other place than hell itself. This does a great deal of harm and further corrupts people’s judgment.

Or, second, when it is said that Christ descended into hell, most interpreters explain it this way: they say Christ did not go down into hell locally, but virtually. That is, Christ endured on the cross something equivalent to the torments of hell. He lay under the wrath of his Father, and lying under the wrath of an angry God is the chief part of hell’s torment. So on this view, Christ did not go down into hell in person, body and soul, but virtually, suffering something equivalent to its torments. But as I said before, in times such as these it would be wise for those entrusted with matters of reformation either to alter this word in the creed or else remove it.

1. A second objection, and a stronger one, is one the papists raise from 1 Peter 3:19–20: "By which he went and preached to the spirits in prison which sometime were disobedient; when the longsuffering of God waited for them in the days of Noah." From this the papists argue that the text plainly shows Christ went and preached to the spirits in prison, meaning that Christ went into hell and preached a sermon to the damned there, delivering many of them from it. You can easily imagine how badly this Scripture is abused. To give you its true sense, consider the context. The text says that "Christ being put to death in the flesh was quickened in the spirit," meaning that though put to death in the flesh, he was made alive by the spirit in his divine nature. By that spirit "he went and preached to the spirits in prison." By "prison" is meant hell, as in Revelation 20:7.

By "the spirits in prison" are meant the wicked men of the old world, called spirits because they were then in hell, having no bodies, only souls (compare Heb 12:23). Now note the phrase: "Christ went and preached to the spirits in prison, that were sometime disobedient." The meaning is this: Jesus Christ, by his spirit, in the ministry of Noah, preached to the people of the old world who were then living on the earth, but who were now, at the time Peter wrote this epistle, in hell. Compare (2 Pet 2:5 and 1 Pet 4:6). So this passage in no way suggests that Christ went and preached in hell to wicked men. It means only that Christ preached by his spirit in the days of Noah, through Noah’s ministry, to the old world who were then living but are now imprisoned, now in hell.

The words that follow confirm when this preaching occurred: "while the longsuffering of God waited in the days of Noah, while the Ark was preparing." This was the time of Christ’s preaching, when the Ark was being built. So it is a gross abuse of this text for the papists to place this interpretation upon it.

3. They have another argument from Acts 2:31 together with (Ps 16:11): "Thou shalt not leave my soul in hell, nor suffer thy holy one to see corruption." They say Scripture here tells us that Christ’s soul went into hell, and that God would not allow it to remain there, though it was there for some time. I answer as follows.

By "soul" here is meant the body of Christ. The word "soul" is often used this way in Scripture. In Genesis 46, "There went down into Egypt seventy souls" means seventy persons, seventy men. In Romans 13:1, "Let every soul (that is, let every man) be subject to the higher powers" uses the spiritual part of man to stand for the whole man. In 1 Corinthians 15, "The first man Adam was made a living soul," meaning a living man with a living body, the word "soul" must be taken for the body. Adam was made a living soul, that is, a living man. So this word is often used in Scripture for the body as well as the soul, and that it is used this way here appears from the words just before it: "This he spake of the resurrection."

Now only the body rose, since the soul never died, so the soul mentioned here must clearly refer to the rising of the body.

By "soul," then, is meant the body. But what is meant by "hell"? "Thou shalt not leave my soul in hell": hell does not always signify the place of the damned, though sometimes it does. Here it signifies the grave. So when the apostle says, "Thou shalt not leave my soul in hell," he means, "You shall not leave my body in the grave." The next words explain this: "Nor suffer thy holy one to see corruption." Other men lie in their graves and rot there, but Christ says his body will not be allowed to corrupt and rot in the grave, because it was to rise again on the third day. See Acts 13:35–36. Understood according to its true meaning and purpose, then, this text gives no support at all to the papist opinion of Christ’s descent into hell.

4. Another argument they urge comes from 1 Peter 4:7: "For this cause was the gospel preached also to them that are dead, that they might be judged according to men in the flesh, but might live according to God in the spirit." The papists say Scripture here tells us that the gospel was preached by Christ to dead men, to the damned in hell, so that they might live to God, that damned men might come out of hell and be saved. That is their reading of the passage.

To give you the true sense of the text: some understand "dead" here as those who are spiritually dead though naturally alive, meaning they lived a natural life but were dead in their sins and trespasses. Scripture does call living men "dead" when they are wicked, as in 1 Timothy 5:6, "She that liveth in pleasure is dead while she liveth," and (Rev 3:1), "They had a name that they lived, yet they are dead." On this reading, the gospel was preached to those who were dead, meaning it was preached to wicked men alive in a natural life but dead in their sins, and this gospel converted some of them, so that though they would be judged as men in the flesh, they would live to God. But I do not take this to be the true sense of the passage. I think Calvin and Piscator come closer to the meaning intended by the Holy Ghost.

They say that "dead" here means the same people mentioned in 1 Peter 3:19, namely those of the old world who were then dead. The gospel, through the ministry of Noah, was preached to the old world while they were living, but by the time Peter wrote this epistle they were dead. This gospel was preached to them "that they might be judged according to men in the flesh," meaning that some of the old world, though judged in the flesh (that is, destroyed by the flood in their bodies, as everyone knows), were nonetheless converted by Noah’s preaching and came to live to God. That is their reading. This has nothing to do with Christ going down into hell, for the text does not say Christ went down; it says the gospel was preached to them through Noah’s ministry, by which means some of the old world were saved and not all were damned.

I have spent this much time on the point because the papists bring forward so many passages of Scripture to support this opinion, and you can see how weak the texts are that they rest it on. From this I would give you this caution: be careful about accepting an opinion simply because, at first hearing, its defenders can point to Scripture. Beloved, if a papist argued with you about Christ’s going to hell and cited these texts, you might not be able to answer them on the spot. But that does not mean you must therefore agree with them. There is no man in error anywhere who does not use Scripture to justify his opinion. So be careful, I say, of believing any opinion just because its defenders can cite some Scripture, until you have carefully examined the opinion itself and tested it against Scripture. But I will move on from this.

Is it established, then, as truth that Christ did not descend into hell, the place of the damned, even though the creed states it this way?

Application 1: First, learn from this that even though Christ did not go down to hell, he suffered a great part of the pains and torments of hell on the cross for your sake, torments you would have had to endure in hell if he had not suffered them instead. So do not undervalue Christ’s love because he did not go into hell for you, for he endured a great part of hell’s suffering in bearing the weight of sin and his Father’s wrath for your sake.

Application 2: Though Christ did not go down to hell, he has suffered enough to free you from hell and keep you from it (Col 2:14–15; Heb 2:14).

Application 3: Take care how you understand that article of your creed concerning Christ’s descent into hell. If you understand it as Christ personally going into the place of the damned, that is untrue. But if you understand it as Christ’s virtual descent, in suffering something equivalent to the torments of hell, this may well be true. So much, then, for the thirteenth question: whether Christ did personally descend into hell.

A fourteenth question follows.

Question 14: Is there, properly speaking, fire in hell, or not? I judged this a necessary point to address, so that if love cannot turn you from your sins, the thought of fire might. On this question, I confess there is a variety of opinions. Most of those I have consulted give this answer, which I believe is most agreeable to the truth: that for the present, since we do not know where hell is, wherever it is, there is currently no fire in hell.

But at the day of judgment, when Christ comes to judge, he will come in flaming fire, and then that fire will burn the wicked for all eternity. Though there is no fire in hell now, Scripture gives hints that after the day of judgment there will be a substantial fire in which the wicked will burn forever. Gregory said, "If God, when he damns the wicked at the day of judgment, condemns them in fire, why would God not continue that fire to punish the ungodly forever?" He could see no reason why there should not be fire after the day of judgment. I know several divines hold that a fire is burning even now, but I believe that view can hardly be supported from Scripture. It is true that Scripture speaks of eternal and unquenchable fire, but these may be figurative expressions describing how the wicked will be scorched by the wrath of God, tormenting the soul as fire torments the body.

Others hold that when the body is in hell, just as there is a worm of conscience to torment the soul, there will be fire to burn the body. This is the note of a divine I have read: as we cannot now tell where the place of hell is, we cannot now tell whether there is fire in hell, but at the day of judgment we will know where hell is, and then we will better know whether fire is there. But in all likelihood, hell will be upon the earth. The godly will be taken up into heaven, and there on the earth the wicked will be tormented with fire. Where they have made the earth the place of their sin, there God will make it the place of their judgment; and when Christ comes to judgment, the world will be kindled by the breath of God to all eternity.

Objection: The fire cannot be physical, because it will afflict the soul, and whatever is physical works by touch. There can be no touch between the soul and a physical fire.

Reason 1: It may work by a supernatural power, though not by a natural one. Even though there is no touch of quantity, there may still be a touching in respect of essence and power.

2. Hell fire may be considered two ways: first, in itself, and second, in respect of the principal agent whose instrument it is. In this second sense it can work on the soul, just as heat has by nature a power of making things hot, but in the soul it has a power by which nourishment is turned into our substance. Augustine, in De Civitate Dei, book 21, chapter 10, doubts whether the present fire is physical fire, but he does not doubt that after the resurrection it will be physical.

But beloved, though there is fire in hell, I want you to note that this fire is very unlike the fire that burns in our chimneys. If you take these words too literally, then other words must also be taken literally, such as worms, brimstone, and the like. And hell’s fire is unlike ours in many respects.

First, our fire gives light as well as heat. But Gregory says that the fire of hell has heat enough to burn a man, yet it has no light. In the fire of hell there will be "blackness of darkness for ever" (Jude 1:13). The poets described such a thing as Cimmerian darkness, a region in Italy between Baiae and Cumae, where the Cimmerians lived, so enclosed by hills and overshadowed by such hanging cliffs that the sun never reached it. As one Latin phrase for it says: it has the power to burn but no light; it retains the force of burning but has lost the power of illuminating.

Again, whatever our fire takes hold of, it consumes and turns to ashes. But the fire of hell is not like that. You will be forever burning, yet never consumed. It would be a mercy for the damned if hell’s fire could burn them to ashes, but this is their misery: the fire of hell will forever burn your body, yet never consume it. You will be forever dying, yet never dead. Our fire consumes and uses up whatever is placed in it, but your body will not be consumed in hell.

3. Our fire is kindled by man, and can likewise be quenched by man. Whoever made the fire can put it out if he wishes. But hell fire is not kindled by man. As it is written, "The breath of the Lord like a river of brimstone shall kindle for ever" (Isa 30:33), and see also (Job 20:26). Nor can it be quenched by man, which is why Luke calls it unquenchable fire: "They shall be cast into unquenchable fire."

4. Our fire does not have the terrible power to torment that hell’s fire has. Our fire, as Polycarp says in the account of Sebastian’s life, "is but like fire painted upon a wall. You may see the picture of fire, but it will not burn you. The fire of hell, however, has a tormenting power, punishing the body with intolerable pains." Now let me draw this together in a brief application.

Is it so, that whether there is fire in hell now is disputable, though it is likely there will be at the last? Then let this be our use: make it your concern to avoid hell fire rather than to argue endlessly about it. Do not quarrel over the nature of hell fire; make it your business to avoid it instead. I remember a passage from Mr. Bolton on this subject: "Suppose there is no fire in hell. I assure you still, you will be scorched with fire, for the fire of God’s wrath will torment you more than any bodily fire could." So do not question hell fire in a way that fails to move you to keep away from it. I have read the story of a foolish man whose house was on fire.

He stood gazing about, wanting to know how the fire started, where it burned, what room and what things it consumed, but he took no care to put it out. That was his folly. In the same way, you who spend your time considering how fire exists in hell, how it is kindled, and how it continues, yet never make it your care to avoid it by a godly life, are more foolish than he was.

Application 2: Learn from this that though there is fire in hell, it should not terrify you if you are among God’s elect, who have your interest secured in Jesus Christ. Jesus Christ has quenched the violence of these flames. Though they scorch and burn the wicked, they will never touch you. I have told you before that Nebuchadnezzar’s fiery furnace was a type of hell, and that furnace did not singe a single hair on the heads of the three young men, though it burned the men who threw them in. So though wicked men wish you were in hell and would gladly have you there, you need not fear, for hell’s fire will not singe a hair on your head. You are delivered from the fire of hell through your interest in Jesus Christ, having a part in his blood. His blood will quench hell fire; it will not burn you.

Pliny writes in one of his works that nothing in the world so quickly quenches fire as salt and blood, and so in many countries where blood is plentiful, people use salt and blood rather than water to put out fires. Pour water on a fire and the fire will soon overcome it, but pour blood on it, and it dampens the flame in a moment. Beloved, I mention this only to make this point: though there is fire in hell, get Christ’s blood, and I can assure you, whatever other blood may do, the blood of Christ will quench the flames of hell so that none of them will scorch or consume you. So get a share in the blood of Christ.

Application 3: Is it so, that there will be fire in hell, even though it is now disputable whether there is fire there already? Then take heed of those fiery sins that will bring you to this place of fire. As Bernard says, fiery sins will beget fiery torments; they beget the fire of hell to torment you.

So take heed: if you burn with fire on earth, you will one day burn in fire in hell. And if you ask me what fire I mean, I answer: first, beware of burning in the fire of passion, anger, and wrath, like a furious man. Take heed that your passions, if inflamed, do not become fiery sins that bring fiery judgments. Second, beware of the fire of lust, for the fire of lust will bring you to hell fire one day. You know what Scripture tells us in 1 Corinthians 7 about those who burn with lust, that it is better to marry than to burn. Some men are on fire with lust, on fire after whores. If you burn in lust, take heed that those lusts do not one day make you burn in hell.

You recall what Solomon says in Proverbs of the adulterer, that whoever is hated of God shall go in to a whore, and elsewhere, that those who go in to a whore will not take hold of the path of life. Beloved, if you burn in lust, you are in great danger of burning in hell, unless God gives you a heart truly and soundly to repent of your sin. Let the thought of hell’s fiery torments work in your hearts a concern to avoid fiery and burning lusts.

I have read a story of a young virgin who, tempted by a lustful young man toward an act of uncleanness, was pressed earnestly by him to commit that foul act. She answered that if he would grant her one request, she would then satisfy his demand. He agreed. She then asked him to hold his finger for a whole hour in the flame of a candle. "That," he said, "is unreasonable to ask of me." "It is true," she said, "yet you ask of me something far more unreasonable: to satisfy you in a thing for which I would not merely burn an hour, but burn forever in the unquenchable fire of hell."

Beloved, I bring up this story to make this point: if God has sanctified thoughts of hell’s torments to you, then even if love of Christ and love of grace cannot yet move you to hate sin and obey him, the fear of hell may sometimes cause you to remember your sin and fear him. As Mr. Dod says, if the fire of hell will make a man look after Christ, then those thoughts of hell’s fire should be cherished and kept alive. I urge this only so that, if Christ’s kindness and grace and beauty cannot draw a hard and stubborn heart, then hearing of the torments of the damned might frighten it into turning.

So whenever you are tempted toward any lust, consider that to burn in hell fire would be intolerable, and let the thought of hell’s fire serve as a strong check against fiery lusts. I have read of a young man much given to uncleanness, who prayed often to God to mortify these burning lusts within him. He tells of himself that every time he felt lust beginning to rise, he would run to the fire and put his finger in the flame, scorching it, and then reason with himself: "Why, my soul and my body, if you cannot endure a minute with only your finger in the fire, how will you endure to all eternity, having not only your finger but your whole body forever in the flames?" By this means, he says, he gained great strength to mortify the burning lusts within him.

So, beloved, I urge you (knowing I speak to a mixed congregation, and perhaps to many who are burning in their lust) to let one fire put out another. Let the fire of hell consume the fire of sin, and let the fire of hell move you to avoid the fire of sin. To close with the words of Bernard, fiery sins will bring you into fiery torments.

4. Is it true, then, that there will be a fire in hell? See here the justice and judgment of God: he will punish your bodies, which have been instruments of sin, just as he punishes your souls. God will not only punish your souls with a worm of conscience, but will punish your bodies with fire as well. Your eyes, which have been eyes of uncleanness, will themselves be inflamed with fire. Your mouths, which have taken down drink in excess, will then take down shovels of brimstone in abundance. Your members, which have burned in lust and uncleanness, will one day burn in the fire of hell. This body of yours, which has been an instrument of sin, will by the just hand of God become a body burning in hell.

Now consider whether the pleasures of sin that come through the body can compare to the torments of that fire. In your body you may now burn with the lusts of uncleanness, but will these delightful indulgences match burning fire? You may now take down drink and wine in abundance, but will this cool the roof of your mouth when your whole body is on fire? Consider whether all these pleasurable sins you commit in the body now will outweigh the fiery torments you will meet on the last day.

I confess this has been a dismal subject to preach on. Yet perhaps God may bless it to some. Some are moved by love, others won by fear. God tells us in Scripture that people differ: some are Boanerges, sons of thunder; others are Barnabases, sons of consolation. Scripture tells us, "Some we must have compassion on, others we must save with fear." Scripture gives us warrant to preach dreadful doctrines, to make people afraid of sin and afraid of hell. I could wish to God that this doctrine might have its effect on the wicked and ungodly, who walk in the way that leads to hell, and do the things that lead there, and yet never think of it.

CHAPTER 7

WHAT GOD’S POWER SHOULD WORK IN US

 

But rather fear him who is able to destroy both Body and Soul in Hell. (Matt 10:28)

In taking up this subject, the doctrine I drew from it was this:

Doctrine: That the truth that God has absolute power over men and women, to cast their souls and bodies into hell, should work in the hearts of his own people an awful fear of God.

I have spent six sermons pursuing this doctrine. What remains of it I will finish now.

The fifteenth question I am to answer is this. Scripture clearly shows there is a hell, and that the wicked who have already died are in it. So when did God make hell? We read that (Gen 1:1), "in the beginning God made the heaven and the earth," and we read what his works were in the six days. But we are not told when God made hell. This is, I confess, a curious question, and those who take it up tend to pass over it briefly. Let me give you the thoughts of a few.

Lud. Mollina, an ancient author, offers his opinion that hell was made on the third day, though Scripture does not say so. His reason is that on the third day the earth was adorned with its beauty, and since hell lies at the center of the earth, hell must have been made when the earth was adorned. But this has no real ground, since it simply assumes that hell is at the center of the earth, a claim Scripture nowhere confirms.

Another author says hell was made before the six days, before either earth or heaven existed. His opinion arose from a question once put to an ancient author: what was God doing before he made the world? That learned author answered that God was preparing a hell for such curious questioners as the one asking, people who pry into secrets of God that do not concern them. I do not take this for the truth either, since God was surely delighting and satisfying himself in his own glory before the world was made. Hell was a created thing, and no creature existed before the world did, for Scripture tells us, "in the beginning the heaven and the earth was made."

Some of the rabbis say hell was made on the seventh day, so that although God rested from his labor on the seventh day, he still made hell, that wicked men should never rest even while God gave his own people rest. But this too runs against Scripture, for Scripture says God rested on the seventh day, and he could not have made hell on a day he rested.

Cornelius a Lapide holds the view most likely to be true: that hell was made on the first day, and for a reason that fits well, since the angels fell on the first day. When God made the heavens he made the angels in heaven, and God made heaven on the first day. The angels fell on the first day (as divines writing on this subject generally agree), and it is clear they fell before the sixth day, because by the sixth day there was already a devil to tempt Adam. Adam did not live even one day in innocence; the very day he was made, he sinned, and did not stay one night in honor (Ps 49:12). As soon as the angels fell, they were cast into hell. So the most probable account is that the angels’ fall and the making of hell happened together. Hell was made to receive them at the very moment of their falling. The angels fell on the first day, and hell was made then to receive the fallen angels.

The next question is this.

Question 16: What is meant by that part of the damned’s torment in hell described as an undying worm of conscience, gnawing at them forever (Mark 9:44; Luke 13:28)? This forms a great part of the torments of the damned, so it is worth asking what is meant by the wicked having a never-dying worm to gnaw them. I will not give you the fanciful notions of some authors, who imagine an actual physical worm gnawing the flesh of the body after the resurrection. Rather, by the worm that never dies is meant the gnawing horror of conscience that seizes a damned soul, because it lies under the wrath of a revengeful, incensed God forever.

Wicked men, though on earth they have seared and insensible consciences, so that sin never grieves them and conscience never troubles them here, will find in hell that conscience becomes a worm to them, endlessly gnawing, endlessly perplexing, laying them under disquiet and horror as they lie under the wrath of God forever, without hope of escape. Just as worms continually gnaw a carcass, so sin will gnaw the conscience. Even the heathen, by the dim light of nature, glimpsed something of this. I recall that Virgil, a heathen poet, speaks of one Tityus, on whose liver a vulture fed every day, the liver being restored each night so the vulture could feed on it again the next day. This is how the poets pictured hell and the worm of conscience, though without Scripture they could not speak of it clearly. Still, they made a shrewd guess at what Scripture calls the worm of conscience that never dies.

If this is so, how careful you should be, while you live here on earth, to keep a good conscience. Believe me, the more you defile your conscience and load it with guilt now, the more you will feel that worm gnawing in hell. So I urge you not to let guilt take root on your conscience. I recall Luther saying in his commentaries that the man who carries unrepented guilt on an awakened conscience carries a hell with him on earth. And you do little less, if your conscience is awakened, when you pile sin upon sin, lust upon lust, and deceit upon deceit onto it. Take heed, for conscience will become a gnawing worm one day. It will torment and gnaw you far more than it does now. Your conscience may be seared and asleep now, but this worm will never die. It will still be gnawing and tormenting you at the last day.

Again, second, what is meant by that part of the wicked’s torment described as gnashing of teeth in hell? Some imagine it arises from cold in hell, that though hell contains fire, some will also be frozen (I take this only as a fancy). I will give you three likely reasons why the torments of the damned are described by this phrase, gnashing of teeth.

1. Gnashing of teeth will come from the implacable enmity the damned carry in their hearts toward all who are saved. They will gnash their teeth out of envy that others are saved while they are damned. As Luke 13:28 says, "there shall be weeping, and wailing, and gnashing of teeth." Why? Because "they shall see Abraham, and Isaac, and Jacob in the kingdom of heaven, and themselves shut out." Just as men gnash their teeth with envy when they see the happiness of someone they hate, so the damned spirits gnash their teeth because they envy the salvation and glory of the elect.

2. The damned in hell gnash their teeth out of indignation toward Jesus Christ, that he would not save them as he saved others. Gnashing the teeth is the posture of a man enraged and tormented. The wicked are described this way to show that they carry an implacable anger against Jesus Christ, whose blood would not redeem them, and against God, whose mercy would not save them. They rage that they cannot be revenged on God and Christ, that they cannot, as it were, pull God out of heaven. This is the work of the damned: not only do they envy the glory of the saved, but they are enraged against God and Jesus Christ as well.

3. They gnash their teeth over this thought, that in their lifetime they had the opportunity to lay hold of heaven and salvation, yet neglected it. Just as men gnash their teeth when they have lost some opportunity that would have brought them great advantage, and its neglect has cost them dearly, so the damned do this when they consider that they lived under a godly ministry, had their sins exposed to them, were pressed toward a godly life, and yet stifled all these promptings and closed their ears to every reproof of the word. Christ was offered to them on easy terms, yet they would not receive him. This thought alone will greatly torment the damned: that they had many opportunities of grace in this world, and neglected every one of them.

And if this is so, that gnashing the teeth arises from envy of the saints’ happiness and indignation against Jesus Christ, and if this is the torment of the damned, then hear this, beloved. If you envy the happiness of godly men on earth, or carry any indignation against Jesus Christ, or any malice toward the salvation of godly men in heaven, you are doing the very work of hell. Hell’s work is to hate Jesus Christ and hate the conversion of souls. So if you envy the good of souls, you do the works of hell. The devils and the damned do exactly this: they gnash their teeth out of envy that other souls are glorified while they are condemned.

Having finished these sixteen questions, I will now bring everything together with a general and practical application of this whole doctrine. This doctrine of hell and its torments is a very useful doctrine, both to wicked and ungodly people.

1. This doctrine is useful concerning wicked people, and useful to them in two ways.

First, it is useful for the astonishment of wicked livers.

Second, it is useful to check sin in a wicked person’s life. In these two ways the doctrine of hell is a remarkably useful doctrine.

It is useful to astonish the spirits of secure and sensual sinners. To produce this astonishment, I will set out six astonishing considerations a wicked person may draw from this doctrine of hell.

1.) Consider that for most of the men and women God has made, it is their sad and dismal portion to be tormented in the flames of hell. This has already been addressed in answer to the tenth question, so I will only name it here.

2.) Consider that many now tormented in hell did more good than many of us still on earth who look to heaven. Look through Scripture: a humbled Ahab is in that place of torment (1 Kgs 21:29), though he humbled himself, yet it may be many of us have never had one humbled hour since we came into this world. A repenting Judas is now in hell (Matt 27:3): Judas repented himself and restored the money, yet Scripture says Judas is gone to his own place, that is, hell. It may be many of us have never had a relenting, repenting heart since we were born. A weeping Esau is now in hell (Heb 12:17): he sought the blessing with tears, but could not find it.

Many of us have never wept a tear either for our sins or our miseries since we came into the body; our faces are like rocks, from which water can burst forth as soon as tears can. A trembling Felix is now in hell (Acts 24:25). Many of us tremble no more at a sermon than the pews we sit in or the stones we walk on. A half-turned Agrippa is now in hell, who was half turned, half converted by the word, yet many of us have never found any change in our souls by the word since we were born. O beloved, how should this astonish a wicked person? A humbling Ahab, and you have never been humbled! A repenting Judas, and you have never been troubled! A trembling Felix, and you have never been startled in your conscience at hearing the word!

How dismal a thought this should be to you, that many now in this place of torment did more good in their lifetime than you have ever done.

3.) Consider that many now in hell have done less evil than many of us have done. Balaam has gone to that place of misery, yet Balaam said he would not curse God’s people if one gave him a house full of silver or gold (Num 24:13). Yet you, for a groat, or even for nothing, will swear and curse, and carry rage and hatred in your heart, caring nothing against whom. We read of the Pharisees, of whom Christ says that no one warned them to flee from the wrath to come, yet they were an undone people. Still, we read that they were no extortioners, no drunkards, no sabbath breakers, no profaners of the Lord’s Day (Luke 18:12, 14). In fact, they were so strict in observing the sabbath that they would not do necessary duties on the Lord’s Day for fear of profaning it.

They would not pull an apple from a tree, would not walk in the fields on the Lord’s Day lest their thoughts wander, would not put a plaster on a man’s wound lest it be counted bodily labor, would not rock a cradle or visit a patient. A midwife would not go help a woman in childbirth. If a thorn got into their foot, they would not pull it out on the sabbath. If their houses caught fire, they would not put the fire out. The Pharisees did a thousand times less evil than many of us have done, and should this not astonish you? A Pharisee now in hell was never a drunkard, though perhaps you are one. A Pharisee now in hell was never an adulterer, though perhaps you are one. Pharisees now in hell never profaned a sabbath, yet perhaps you have never kept a sabbath holy to your God since you were born. O how should this astonish you!

Surely, unless your conscience has become thoroughly seared, these considerations should greatly astonish you.

4.) Consider that many have taken more pains to go to hell, that place of the damned, than many of us have taken to go to heaven. I recall a striking story of an ancient church father who was invited to a great man’s house. Arriving about ten o’clock, he saw the mistress of the house grooming herself before a mirror, and from ten until one he watched her spend that time plaiting her hair, painting her face, and adorning herself. At one o’clock, when she came to dinner expecting nothing but merriment, this ancient father began weeping. Asked why, he turned to the mistress of the house and said, "I weep to see that you have spent three hours grooming yourself and performing all these acts of pride to damn yourself, and yet I have never spent so many hours to save my soul since I was born." Truly, beloved, you may take this as your own case.

When you see profane men, in the words of Habakkuk 2:14, "weary themselves in mere vanities," when you see men sit up whole nights at cards and dice and drink, when you see men tireless in the ways of sin, you may well weep and say, "This man has sat up longer, and spent more time going to hell, than I have ever spent going to God in prayer." This should astonish you: that many take more pains to go to hell than you take to go to heaven.

5.) Consider that there are many in the world who will endure the torments of hell, yet confidently hope and expect to have the joys and glory of heaven (Luke 13:25–27; Matt 25:11–12). There you read of some who will knock and say, "Lord, Lord, open unto us." Whoever knocks expects to be let in. Wicked people will be so confident of heaven that they will knock at heaven’s door, as it were, yet Christ will say, "I know you not." Then they will say, "Lord, we have eaten and drunk in thy presence, we have preached thy word, we have eaten at thy table." No, says Christ, "I know you not; go away, you cursed, into everlasting fire." So too in John 8:39–40, the Jews were confident of heaven, saying, "We have Abraham as our father." But Christ refutes this and tells them that if Abraham were their father, they would do the works of Abraham.

But since they do not do Abraham’s works, they are not Abraham’s children. In the next exchange they go further, claiming, "God is our father, and we are his children." No, says Christ (John 8:44), "you are of your father the devil, and his works you do." So you can see from all this that you may expect to be, and believe you are, a child of God, when you are actually a child of the devil, and that you may believe you are on the way to heaven when you are traveling the road to hell. Should this not greatly astonish you, that many will endure the torments of hell while truly expecting to enjoy the glory of heaven?

6.) The sentence passed on a damned sinner is both dismal and irrevocable. (Matt 25:41): "Go from me you cursed into everlasting fire, with the devil and his angels." That is your sentence. Consider carefully how dismal this sentence is. The punishment of a damned soul is first to depart from Jesus Christ ("Depart from me"), and of all punishments, the punishment of loss is the greatest torment a damned soul can bear. They might say, "If we must depart from you, Lord, let us at least go with a blessing." But Christ says no: "My curse be upon you. Depart from me, you cursed." They might say, "If we must depart, and depart with a curse, at least let us go to a place of ease." But Christ says, "Depart, you cursed, into fire." They might say, "Lord, if we must depart into fire, let it at least be for a while."

But Christ says it will be forever: "Go, you cursed, into everlasting fire." They might say, "Lord, if we must be cursed and go into everlasting fire, at least let us have good company, which might ease our sorrow and help us forget our misery." But Christ says no, their only companions will be devils and damned spirits: "Go, you cursed, into everlasting fire, with the devil and his angels." Those will be the best companions a damned soul will have. This is the dismal sentence passed on a wicked sinner, and once passed, it is irrevocable, never to be recalled. Put these six considerations together, and ask: who would go to hell for a sin? What man would damn his soul for a whore? Who would lie under this terrible sentence for the enjoyment of a lust?

Having spoken this far about this doctrine, I know many will think it will lead people to despair, that it is so uncomfortable it will keep a person from ever having a glad day in their life. To such I answer: indeed, if you are ungodly and walk in ways that lead to the gates of hell, this doctrine should plunge you into dismay. But godly and sincere hearts need not be troubled at all, for they are delivered by Jesus Christ from this wrath to come.

I know no doctrine in the whole Bible is as irksome to flesh and blood as doctrines of terror. The hearts and spirits of ungodly people rise against it. They are ready to say to us what the devil said to our Savior: "Have you come to torment us before the time?" I might compare many people to a story I read of a seminary priest in Lancashire. Having lost his glove, another man picked it up and ran after the priest to return it. The priest, carrying a guilty conscience, thought the man was chasing him to arrest him and have the law executed upon him, though the man meant him no harm. The priest ran from him, and to escape, drowned himself. Beloved, here is the use I make of this: in preaching these doctrines of terror, we ministers run after you and beg you to stop your course, not to run into hell, not to follow the paths that lead there.

But you run from us, as if this preaching would drag you to hell, when in truth we preach it so that you might avoid hell, not fall into it. We preach sermons on hell to your ears now, so that you may never see it or feel it in your bodies later. So do not fear us; ministers never wish you harm, though they sometimes dip their tongues in blood. May the Lord grant that you know more of hell now, so that you may feel less of it hereafter. I have read of a friend who gave a young gallant an ornate ring with a death’s head on it, on the condition that he look at it seriously once each day. By this means, in time, he turned from a profane rascal into a good Christian. Serious thoughts of hell would produce the same effect.

"Let us," says Bernard, "go down to hell while we are living, so that we are not cast down into hell when we are dead." That is a very good use to draw from this doctrine. Beloved, I am persuaded that whatever you may think of it, though a profane heart cannot bear to have its conscience rubbed raw, if you would take this doctrine to heart, it would be a great means of leading you toward a godly life and restraining you from a profane one.

2. This doctrine is also useful to wicked people by way of reproof. It checks and restrains many sins in the wicked. Scripture itself makes this use of the doctrine. Read 2 Peter 2:4, 6: "God spared not the angels that sinned, but cast them down into hell, and delivered them to be reserved in chains of darkness to the judgment of the great day." What use does Scripture draw from this? "These things he has made for examples to those that after shall live ungodly." The overthrow of Sodom, the destruction of the old world, the damnation of angels, all these the apostle turns into an example to warn all who live ungodly lives to take heed of sinning. Let me now speak more particularly about this matter. The doctrine of hell checks five sins especially.

1. It checks the sin of lust. (2 Pet 2): "The wicked are reserved in chains of darkness to be judged, especially they that walk in the lusts of uncleanness." There the apostle sets the thought of hell directly against the lusts of uncleanness. Beloved, nothing in the world checks the thoughts of lust more than the thought of the fire of hell: if you burn in your lusts on earth, you may burn in fire in hell.

2. It checks the sin of gluttony. Christ speaks of Dives, cast into hell, and calls him the rich glutton. (Luke 16:19): it is said of him, "he had good things in his life time, and he fared deliciously every day." So take heed of gluttony and pampering your flesh, for the more you pamper it, if you are wicked, the sweeter a morsel you make yourself for worms and devils alike. You who feed gluttonously now will one day perish for hunger; you who drink to excess will one day perish with thirst.

3. It checks the sin of pride. So Paul, speaking to Timothy, warns him to take heed of pride, lest he fall into the condemnation of the devil, that is, into the very sin for which the devil was condemned. The devils were cast into chains of darkness for the sin of pride alone. So take heed of pride; it may bring you to hell just as it did the angels. The angels, if I may put it this way, had far more grounds for pride than you do. They were more glorious creatures, more perfect in their natures. Yet though they truly had no cause for pride, pride still cast them into hell, and it may do the same to you.

4. It checks the sin of covetousness. James 5:13 says: "Go to now, you rich men, weep and howl, for your misery that shall come upon you, your riches are corrupt, your gold and silver cankereth, the rust of them shall be a witness against you, and shall eat your flesh as fire. You have heaped up treasures for the last days." You who have gained unjustly and grown wealthy dishonestly, may this text make you tremble. The rust of your gold and silver will testify against you on the last day.

Lastly, it checks the fear of other people, worldly fears, exactly as in my text. (Matt 10:28): "Fear not him that can kill the body, and can do no more, but fear him that can cast both soul and body into hell." Our Savior makes the doctrine of hell a defense against the fear of others. So much for its use to the wicked.

Application 2: This doctrine of hell is useful for you who are godly as well. First, it should quicken and stir up an awful fear of God in your hearts: "Fear him that can cast body and soul into hell." Little children, when they see their father angry and see him beat the servants, tremble. You are children too. You will not be beaten, but you will see the servants, wicked men, beaten in hell. Let this make you tremble. David tells us, "My flesh trembles at the thought of you, and your judgments make me afraid" (Ps 119:120). You should tremble far more at the thought of God’s judgments upon the damned.

2. This should work in you a fear of sin, since sin leads to hell. If hell is terrible, the sin that brings you there is worse.

3. This doctrine should increase your faithfulness and joy in Christ, that you have been delivered from such torments as these.

4. This should increase your love for Christ, that he endured on the cross the wrath of God (something equivalent to the torments of hell) to free you from hell. This should powerfully call for your love and increase your joy (1 Thess 1:6, 10, 15). This doctrine should also make you patient under all the outward, temporary afflictions you meet in this world. What though you are oppressed with gout, with kidney stones, or with any other terrible disease? God has given you freedom from hell, which is worse than if every disease imaginable struck one body at once. The worst diseases are mere flea bites compared to the torments of the damned. So be patient, whatever you undergo. God has freed you from the greatest torments, even if you must endure the lesser ones. And with that, I have finished the use of this doctrine for the godly.

The last use, with which I will end, is a use of examination. Remember the doctrine: that considering God’s sovereignty over men and women, his power to cast them into hell, should work in the hearts of God’s own people an awful fear of God. In this use I will put you to the test, to see whether this doctrine, and these seven sermons on the torments of hell, have worked a fear of God in your hearts. How happy you are if these teachings have made you fear sin more, or fear God more. Now you may ask, how can I know whether this has produced in my heart the fear of God? To answer this, I will lay down four marks.

1. This fear will drive out of your hearts all fear of men. "Fear not their fear, but sanctify the Lord God in your hearts, and let him be your fear, and let him be your dread" (Isa 8:13). Scripture tells us that those who make God their fear are not overtaken by the fear of wicked men. And so my text tells us, "Fear not him that can kill the body, but fear him that can cast body and soul into hell."

2. The person who has the fear of God in his heart carries greater respect for the commands of God than for the commands of men. Whoever truly fears God would rather displease man than God, and would rather obey God’s command than man’s. "The midwives feared God, and did not do the thing the king commanded" (Exod 1:17). A strange thing. What? Not obey the king’s command? No, these women would not obey the king in his sinful command, because they feared God. Royalists now think that whatever kings command must be done, but Scripture tells us that poor, weak women feared God and would not do what the king commanded. Take note of this, beloved: if the fear of God is in your hearts, then even if men command you to sin while God commands the opposite, you will not obey them. You will not sin because men command it, if God gives you a contrary command.

3. If the fear of God is planted in your hearts, you will be careful to guard your hearts against small and secret sins that the world never notices. "The fear of the Lord makes clean" (Ps 19:9). The fear of God in the heart works like a broom, sweeping the heart and inner self clean of all sin. There is a telling phrase: "You shall not curse the deaf, nor put a stumbling block before the blind, but shall fear your God" (Lev 19:14). Suppose someone cursed a deaf man. He could not hear the curse. Suppose you laid a stone in the path of a blind man. He could not see you lay it. But the fear of God would lead you to avoid even those sins that no one can hear or see.

Even if the people around you were as blind and deaf as could be, unable to see or hear your evils, the fear of God would still restrain you from them. So if the fear of God is not strong enough within you to make you refrain from sin, in private as well as in public, then you may rightly fear that you do not truly have the fear of God in you.

4. The true fear of God will give you high and reverent thoughts of God, and humble thoughts of yourselves. "Shall not his excellency make you afraid?" (Job 13:11); (Exod 3:6). So if you do not have high thoughts of God’s great majesty and excellence, if you are not aware of the infinite distance between you and him, it is because the true fear of God is lacking in your hearts. And with that, I have gone through ten sermons on the glory of the elect in heaven, and seven sermons on the torments of the damned in hell. My whole desire is that you would only ever hear of hell, so that you might never come there, and that these sermons might help keep you from the practice of sin, which will surely lead you to this place of torment.