Return of PrayersThomas Goodwin
N.B. The following text was freely provided by Updated Works. Their updated books and audios are superb in every way.
"Some of the most important ideas in history are locked away in old books that modern readers struggle to understand. Archaic language, unfamiliar phrasing, and outdated conventions create unnecessary barriers to timeless wisdom.
"Updated Works exists to change that. We take significant older texts and translate them into clear, contemporary English while faithfully preserving the author's original meaning and voice. Our goal is simple: make important books readable again.
"Archaic spelling, obsolete words, and tangled sentence structure are rendered into clear, contemporary English--always preserving the author's meaning, voice, and line of argument. We modernize the language, never the message."Please visit their website to purchase select hardcopy books and audio books: Updated Works.
CONTENTS
Preface
The Foundation: Expecting God's Reply to Prayer
1. The Duty and Reasons for Attending to the Answers of Our Prayers
2. Concerning Prayers for the Church and for Blessings in Future Ages
3. Concerning Prayers Made for Others and How They Are Answered
4. Discerning Our Own Prayers' Influence When Joined with Others
5. General Directions: Observing God's Promptings Before and During Prayer
6. Further Observations: The Heart's Disposition After Prayer, While Awaiting an Answer
7. Discerning Answers When the Specific Thing Prayed For Occurs
8. Further Marks of Answered Prayer: The Effects of Mercy Fulfilled Upon the Heart
9. Considerations for Recognizing God's Answer When the Specific Request is Not Fulfilled
10. Application: A Correction for Neglecting to Look for the Return of Prayers, and the Reasons for Such Neglect
PREFACE
To the much honored knight, Sir Nathaniel Rich.
Sir,
God, who from all eternity has had an infinite amount of grace and glory ready to give to His Church, has accordingly provided a treasury and storehouse sufficient to hold it all, the Bosom of His Son, in whom are hidden riches so unsearchable that they cannot be counted, much less exhausted, for all eternity.
He has generously poured out His Holy Spirit on us so that we, who could never have known about anything given to us, nor what to pray for as we should, might fully know from Him all that God has given us. Through Him, we can lay claim to it, as He makes intercession for us, providing us with a secret key to all that treasure, which is otherwise locked away from the rest of the world.
Through this Spirit of prayer and supplications poured out, believers are immediately anointed to share in and carry out the three glorious offices of Christ, their head. Not only 1. as priests, by offering up their prayers as spiritual sacrifices acceptable to God through Jesus Christ, but also 2. as kings, to rule with God (Hos. 11:12). By this, they become part of the Privy Council to the King of kings, so that their plans and desires expressed in their petitions are said to be fulfilled, and their decrees in their prayers are made, ratified, and established. Furthermore, through this privilege, they are elevated to such a height of favor that by their strength in prayer alone, they have power with God himself; and not only with him, but also over him; and in their struggles, they prevail. Yes, they can command: He himself has said it; "Thus saith the Lord, the Holy One of Israel and his Maker, Ask of me, of things to come, concerning my sons, and concerning the work of my hands, command ye me" (Isa. 45:11). This extraordinary privilege of power is also, by the express words of this great charter, universally extended to all transactions in this lower part of his dominions; whether ecclesiastical, which concern his sons, that is, his Church, or whatever other, the more ordinary works of his hands, that pertain to common providence.
Since these important matters of His Kingdom, which are future and yet to come, are entrusted to their prayers as their most appropriate subject, they are to ask about things to come. In this way, they become like prophets, not by predicting the future, but by speaking about future events in their prayers. To show this, God, who created and sustains the world and everything in it by His powerful word, also rules and governs it according to the principles and rules of His will. He dispenses rewards and punishments to people based on His promises and warnings, as recorded in past events, though with such variety that His ways remain mysterious and beyond understanding. Just as He set the sun, moon, and stars to govern day and night and the seasons, He has also spread His word and law over the rational world of angels and humans. He established His statutes and judgments so that by the light of His precepts and their effects in rewards and punishments, they might guide and direct His creatures and their actions, and determine their outcomes. Since His saints are people whose hearts hold His law and who delight in meditating on it day and night, they constantly observe and consider the various influences of His countless precepts, promises, and warnings that affect themselves and others, nations or individuals. By forming judgments from this, they strive to shape their prayers according to God's will. As a result, their prayers often align with the outcomes that later occur. Just as the earth sometimes aligns directly with the sun and moon during their conjunctions, their desires and prayers sometimes align directly with God's secret purposes and a revealed promise, working together to produce certain effects. The Spirit also helps their weaknesses, sometimes guiding and directing them through a gracious instinct, even without their knowledge, to focus their requests on specific things that God has fully intended to bring about, thus becoming like a spirit of prophecy to them, to some extent.
In this way, the great King uses his closest servants as his officers and sheriffs to deliver his orders and carry out judgments on his enemies, fulfilling the judgment written in his threats (Ps. 149:9) and also bringing about his mercies by acting on all the promises. They are like midwives, as Hezekiah's reference suggests when he sent a message to the Prophet Isaiah for his support, to help and assist in bringing forth his promises and decrees when they are ready to deliver mercies and deliverance, but there is no strength to bring them to completion.
In all of this, they will have the honor of being considered co-workers with God in His greatest works of wonder. And on the last day, when the final version of all God's works, and ours too, is complete and revealed to the world, they will see their names included with His own. God will acknowledge that these works are as much the result of their hearts and prayers as they are the work of His hands and power. Such honor is given to all His saints.
And if all the works of God are so incredibly great, and His thoughts in them so very deep (Psalm 92:5), that every tiny detail deserves our deepest study and attention; and they require a special skill and wisdom to understand, which is unique to the saints (Psalm 92:6), then we must also diligently search and carefully observe to discover His meaning in them. We should have a special inclination and delight to engage with them, as "The works of the Lord are great, sought out of all them that have pleasure therein" (Psalm 111:2). And if, among all His works, those that show His mercy deserve our utmost attention—where His heart and delights are most focused, and where His wisdom has crafted the richest designs of His love—then surely that special collection of mercies given in response to our prayers should be studied and read by us more than anything else. In these, God reveals Himself and opens His heart to us more sweetly and familiarly; they are directed and almost dedicated particularly to us alone. Many of them are written with His own hand, in a more direct way, and all of them come sealed with the mark of everlasting love, filled with the most precious signs of His special favor. "Whoso is wise, and will observe these things, even they shall understand the lovingkindness of the Lord" (Psalm 107:43).
These blessings not only have more mercy in the things themselves given to us, but they also become more special to us because they are made our own personal blessings, with a unique claim to them. This makes the kindness in them twice as meaningful. We have the royal freedom to choose and shape our own situation, with all the promises given to us, allowing us to write our names on whichever ones we desire; this is the greatest freedom. Along with this, we have His Spirit quietly guiding and aligning our desires with His great plans for us, which is the truest freedom. Being made the main instruments, under Him, of our own greatest happiness is a privilege, and there's no greater royalty that a creature can have. Yet, when our greatest love, corrected in this way, opens its mouth the widest and stretches our desires in prayer to their fullest extent, God's infinite love will not only fill them but do for us more than we can ask or even think; abundantly more, as far above as His thoughts are above our thoughts, which is much more than the heavens are higher than the earth (Eph. 3:20, Isa. 55:9).
When you consider all of this together, it should encourage us to gather up all the precious time, thoughts, and intentions we waste on trivial things and invest the best of them in the rewarding practice of communicating with God. The benefits of this are better than the trade of silver, and the profit is greater than fine gold. A praying Christian is the only one who truly uses the riches of God's promises, which we often leave unused like dead stock. Meanwhile, he, like a wise and diligent merchant, looks at all the affairs of Jesus Christ happening in this world and gets involved in them all. He is watchful to find every opportunity and, with a holy eagerness, engages in every activity that can bring glory to God, benefit to the Church, and grace and comfort to his own soul. And how incredibly rich must that person become who invests even God's riches, gaining ten talents for one, or even a hundredfold!
Properly valuing this would motivate us to diligently investigate what happens to all those noble efforts, the prayers we make; to pay attention to what destination they reach, how, and when, and with what results they come back.
In this important duty, which is a crucial quality for all true merchants, many of the best and most significant traders, who are diligent enough in praying, still fall short and lack in this area. They miss no profitable opportunity for investment but are careless and unobservant of their returns.
Some people, perhaps out of ignorance that this is a duty or of any importance, focus only on saying enough prayers, not expecting to see any results until the final day when everyone returns with joy, bringing their rewards with them. Others, even though many of their prayers are answered after a short time and with great blessings, fail to recognize these blessings because they don't know how to interpret the signs God often gives in subtle ways, so they overlook them. Many, when their prayers take a long time to be answered (though ultimately to their greater benefit when they finally are), become discouraged and assume everything is lost, like ships at sea we haven't heard from. Most people often complain that their efforts in prayer fail, and that little or nothing comes from all their prayers. And everyone tends to neglect keeping track of their spiritual accounts, balancing their gains and losses. By doing so, they miss out on the main comfort God provides for us to live on—the benefits of their prayers. Additionally, God is not only deprived of the glory that should come from answered prayers, but is also wrongly seen as owing them answers to prayers that He has already fulfilled long ago.
I have tried in this small treatise to convince believers of the great importance of this duty, which is so rewarding. I also aim to reveal the reasons for neglecting it and to remove the temptations and discouragements that cause this neglect. I have briefly addressed common issues that arise in practicing it. My main goal was to provide some experiments and observations to help guide those who are less experienced. While they may not fully understand, they can begin to recognize, especially from the impressions in their own hearts, what God means in His answers. I've included some scattered examples of incomplete prayers, which, although they don't form complete and perfect tables, can serve as instances and examples for beginners. These examples can guide them in the practice of this valuable skill and wisdom—how to compare and balance their prayers with the responses they receive.
I have decided to send this small and imperfect work out into the world, and I wanted to first offer it to you and express my gratitude by mentioning your name. Your worth deserves a more elaborate and lasting tribute. If you were to use your abilities in learning, eloquence, and wisdom in human affairs, you could create a memorial that would reflect your great worth when you are no longer with us. What encouraged me to do this was the connection between these meditations and your private thoughts that you share only with God and your own soul. You have long been dedicated to spending time with God in private, and those who know you are aware of your commitment to those moments you've set aside for communion with Him. Above all, it was the personal obligation I felt due to a great favor you showed me long ago that led me to dedicate my first efforts to your service. It was a relief to me, considering the challenges of appearing publicly, that this gave me the opportunity to fulfill my vows openly before everyone. Having done this, I pray that God, who is rich in mercy to all who call upon Him, fills you with all grace and grants all your requests; so prays.
I am obliged to love and serve you, Tho: Goodwin.
THE FOUNDATION: EXPECTING GOD'S REPLY TO PRAYER
I will hear what God the Lord will speak: for he will speak peace unto his people, and to his saints: but let them not turn again to folly. - Psalm 85:8
This Psalm was written for the comfort of the entire Jewish church, both as a prophecy and a prayer for their return from Babylonian captivity. It speaks of the restoration of their ancient glory, peace, justice, freedom to practice God's ordinances, and prosperity, which they had enjoyed before but had lost for seventy years. The Psalm begins with a prayer, from the first verse to the one we are discussing, reminding the Lord of His gracious actions in the past for His Church. The Psalmist says this isn't the first time the Church has been in captivity and that God has brought them back before (like from Egypt), so they hope He will do it again: "You have been favorable to your land," and so on. After finishing his prayer, he stands and listens, like when you wait for an echo, to see what response will come from Heaven, where his prayer has already reached. "I will hear what the Lord will speak," or as some read it, "I hear what the Lord does speak," because sometimes there's an immediate echo, a quick answer to a person's heart, even before the prayer is finished, like with Daniel (Dan. 9:20-21). In short, the answer is that the Lord will speak peace to His people. This response is found at the end of the petition, but with a warning for the future: "But let them not return again to folly," which is a good reminder to make use of such a gracious answer.
CHAPTER 1
THE DUTY AND REASONS FOR ATTENDING TO THE ANSWERS OF OUR PRAYERS
The main observation and subject of this discussion is that God's people should carefully pay attention to the answers to their prayers. Here are the reasons for it.
These words are specifically spoken in relation to God's answer to his prayer, so I primarily intend to address them in that context.
The observation is this: When someone has prayed to God, they should be confident that God will mercifully answer their prayers. They should also listen carefully and pay attention to how their prayers are answered.
Both aspects are important here. "I will hear what God will speak," meaning how He will fulfill them, and at the same time, he confidently expresses assurance that God will speak peace. This is what the Church does in Micah 7:7-9: "I will look to the Lord; I will wait for the God of my salvation; my God will hear me. Rejoice not over me, O my enemy; when I fall, I shall rise; when I sit in darkness, the Lord will be a light to me. I will bear the indignation of the Lord because I have sinned against him, until he pleads my cause and executes judgment for me." Similarly, Habakkuk, after praying against the tyranny of Nebuchadnezzar in the first chapter, begins the second chapter by saying, "I will take my stand at my watchpost and station myself on the tower, and look out to see what he will say to me, and what I will answer concerning my complaint" (Hab. 2:1). Eventually, an answer comes in verse 2. Just as he waited for a vision (since sometimes their prophecies were answers to their prayers), we should also wait for an answer to ours.
1. The reason is that if you don't believe in the power of prayer, you're taking one of God's ordinances in vain, which is like taking God's name in vain because you're dealing with Him in that ordinance. It's a sign that you think your prayer isn't an effective way to achieve its intended purpose. You might secretly think, like those in Job 21:15, "What profit have we, if we pray to him?" If you use any means and don't expect the result, it shows you think the means are useless for achieving that result. However, every sincere prayer is ordained by God to be a means to obtain what we desire and pray for, and it won't be in vain but will receive an answer. As stated in 1 John 5:14-15, "This is the confidence that we have in Him, that if we ask anything according to His will, He hears us." It's true that God hears even an enemy, but the hearing meant here is with favor. We use this in ordinary speech, like saying a favorite has the King's ear, or if someone ignores advice, we say they wouldn't hear, even if they listened. So, to hear is a word of gracious inclination to do what's requested, and God's ears are said to be open to their prayers. It follows that if He hears us, whatever we ask, we know we have the petitions we desired of Him. As soon as we pray, we are said to have our petitions, meaning they are granted, and we can be confident God agrees, even if the outward fulfillment hasn't happened yet. It's like when a petitioner is said to have his request when the King's word is given, even if it isn't officially signed for a while. Similarly, when a wicked person sins, as soon as the act is done, God's sentence goes forth against them, but the execution might not happen for some time, as Solomon says, "Sentence against an evil doer is not presently executed." It's sentenced immediately, but not executed right away. In the same way, when a godly person prays, as soon as the prayer reaches Heaven (which happens instantly), the petition is granted (as in Daniel 9, where the command came at the start of his prayer, verse 23, though the angel with the answer arrived later in the evening, verse 21), but the actual fulfillment might be delayed. So, no prayer is in vain regarding an answer. Where God gives a heart to speak, He has an ear to hear and love to respond. Ignoring this is like taking an ordinance in vain, which is God's name.
2. Secondly, it's not just about using God's name in a formal way, but also about taking His attributes lightly. When you pray, if you think that God either can't hear you, can't help you, or doesn't care, you're taking away one of His most important titles: a God who hears prayers. In 1 Kings 8:59, it says that prayers are close to the Lord day and night; they are always before Him, like letters from friends that we keep in sight to remind us to respond. God keeps the prayers of His people in His view until He sends an answer, which is like Him speaking through His actions and words. But when you neglect this, you make Him like an idol, like the false gods of the heathens who have ears but don't hear, eyes but don't see your needs. It's like when Elijah mocked, saying you must shout because the god might be on a journey. You make the God of heaven and earth seem like this when you don't trust Him or value your prayers to Him any more than the heathens valued their sacrifices to their gods. Petitioners not only make requests but also wait at the doors of great men, listening for a response, which honors those men. We should do the same with God, acknowledging His greatness and our dependence on Him. As servants look to their master's hand, so we look to God until He shows us mercy. In Psalm 130, after praying in verse 2, it says he waited more eagerly than those who watch for the morning, like people with important tasks waiting for daylight. Similarly, in Psalm 5:3, it says, "In the morning, I will direct my prayer to you and look," meaning he looks for an answer.
3. If God gives you an answer and you don't pay attention, you're letting God speak to you in vain when you don't listen to what He answers. If two people are walking together and one speaks but doesn't listen to the other's response, it's very disrespectful. Just as not responding is considered contempt, so is not listening to what someone says. Our prayers to God and His answers to us, along with studying His actions by comparing our prayers and His responses, are like dialogues between us and Him and are a big part of our relationship with God. It's said of Samuel's prophecy that not a word of it fell to the ground, and the same should be true of our prayers and God's answers—not a word should be ignored. This happens if you don't observe and listen to them, like Benhadad's servants are said to have done with Ahab's words, by not understanding and observing them. For the same reason you observe the fulfillment of God's promises, you should observe your prayers too. In 1 Kings 8:56, it says not one word failed of all He promised. Solomon had carefully noted everything God had spoken and done for them and found no promise unfulfilled. The same reasoning applies to answers to prayers, since prayers are like putting promises into action, and we should observe them. Solomon mentions this to strengthen their faith that no prayer based on a promise would fail, encouraging others and himself to be diligent in this, and also as a reason for God to hear him. In verse 59, he says, "Let my words be near you," because God always fulfills His good word to His people.
4. Yes, you might provoke the Lord not to answer at all. He might choose not to respond because he sees it would be pointless. When someone is talking to a person who isn't listening, they will stop answering and speaking, and God might do the same. Just like the Apostle says about faith, that it's not enough to believe, but after doing God's will, you need patience to complete your faith so you can receive the promises (Heb. 10:36), the same is true for praying: it's not enough to just pray. After you have prayed, you need to listen for an answer so you can receive what you prayed for; otherwise, God won't fulfill them. As someone said, the sermon isn't finished when the preacher stops speaking because it's not complete until it's practiced. Similarly, our prayers aren't finished when we say them; you must also wait for and pay attention to their fulfillment.
5. If you don't pay attention to His answers, how can you bless God and thank Him for hearing your prayers? Psalm 116:1-2 says, "I love the Lord, because He hath heard my voice and my supplications." The psalmist goes on to thank Him throughout the whole Psalm. You are supposed to watch over your prayers with thanksgiving. Just as you watch, observe, and remember your own needs, which you are to pray for, so you have things to request, you should also observe God's answers for things to be thankful for. Many people fill their minds with things to ask for, but when it comes to thanksgiving, they don't pay attention or prepare for it when they pray. If any study will help you in this way, it is studying God's answers to your prayers. The reason you pray so much and give thanks so little is that you don't pay attention to God's answers; you don't study them. When we offer a sincere prayer, God becomes our debtor by promise, and we need to notice His response and acknowledge receiving it, or else He loses some of His glory.
6. Just as God loses out, you also miss the experience you could gain from this. 1. You miss the experience of God and His faithfulness, which would build hope and confidence in you for the future when you see Him answering your prayers repeatedly. A holy person once said, after God fulfilled a significant request, that since God had never denied him any request, he would now trust Him completely. If hearing about God answering someone else's prayers encourages us to pray (as in Psalm 32:6), how much more should we be encouraged when we see our own prayers answered? That's why David says in Psalm 116:1-2, "I love the Lord, because He has heard my voice and my supplications. Because He has inclined His ear to me, therefore I will call upon Him as long as I live." It's as if he said, "Now that God has heard me, I know what to do: this experience alone is enough to encourage me to pray to God forever. I've learned to call upon Him as long as I live." Also, 2. by observing God's answers to your prayers, you will gain insight into your own hearts, ways, and prayers, and learn how to judge them. In Psalm 66:18-19, David's assurance that he did not regard iniquity in his heart was strengthened by God hearing his prayers. He reasons, "If I regard iniquity in my heart, the Lord will not hear me. But certainly God has heard me; He has attended to the voice of my prayer." For 1. if God does not grant your petitions, it will make you study why He is dealing with you this way, leading you to examine your prayers and the state of your heart to see if you prayed wrongly, as in James 4:3, "You ask and do not receive, because you ask amiss." If you send a message to a friend who is usually prompt in replying and you receive no answer, you would suspect something is wrong. Similarly, when a petition is denied, you will question yourself and investigate what went wrong, learning from it for next time. Or 2. if your prayers are answered, since God often responds in proportion to your prayers (as you might notice if you observe His dealings with you), you would gain insight into God's acceptance and opinion of your ways. You would see that His dealings with you and yours with Him are very parallel and correspond to each other. In Psalm 18:6, "In my distress I called upon the Lord, and cried out to my God; He heard my voice from His temple, and my cry came before Him, even to His ears." Then in verses 7, 8, and so on, he describes his deliverance, which was the result of those prayers. Then in verses 20, 21, and so on, he adds his observation on both, "The Lord rewarded me according to my righteousness; according to the cleanness of my hands He has recompensed me," and "With the pure You will show Yourself pure."
7. You will lose a lot of your comfort: there's no greater joy than seeing prayers answered or seeing people come to faith through us. In John 16:24, it says, "Ask and you shall receive, that your joy may be full." Receiving answers makes joy overflow. Even when we pray for others, if our prayers are answered for them, our joy is very great; even more so when it's for ourselves. In even the smallest things a Christian enjoys, their comfort is greater because they have them through prayers and promises. They know how they received them. If "stolen waters are sweet, and bread eaten in secret" (as Solomon says) to wicked people, then begged food is much sweeter to godly people. Even in praying for outward blessings, there's more sweetness than in enjoying them. Just as it's a joy to a good heart to see someone converted, it's much more joyful for the one who helped make it happen. "I have no greater joy," says St. John, "than to hear that my children walk in truth" (3 John 1:4). So, seeing God do good for His Church and hearing others' prayers is comforting, but it's much more comforting to see Him do it because of one's own prayers. Therefore, when God restores comfort to a sad soul, He is said in Isaiah 57 to restore comfort also to those who prayed and mourned for that soul, as it's a comfort to them to see their prayers answered. Comfort comes in many ways: [1] Hearing from God is like hearing from a friend; even if it's just a few words about a small matter, if it's signed "Your loving Father" or "Your assured friend," it satisfies greatly. [2] Knowing that God is mindful of us, accepts our works, and fulfills His promises. [3] It brings joy to find someone who shares our views in a disagreement, but for God and us to be of one mind and desire the same things is even more joyful. Not just two people on earth agreeing, but God in heaven agreeing with us brings great joy. This is what happens when a person sees their prayer answered. So, you lose a lot of comfort in blessings when you don't notice the answers to your prayers.
CHAPTER 2
CONCERNING PRAYERS FOR THE CHURCH AND FOR BLESSINGS IN FUTURE AGES
Now, as for rules and helps to figure out God's meaning towards you in your prayers, and to recognize answers, and how to know when God does something in response to your prayers, this is the next thing to discuss. First, I will answer some cases and questions that may arise in different types of prayers about the answering of them.
Concerning prayers offered for the Church, for the fulfillment of things that will happen in future ages.
Concerning prayers made for other people, like your friends, relatives, etc.
Concerning those prayers, whether for yourselves or others, where others join with you.
First, there may be some prayers that you must be content to never see answered in this world; their fulfillment may not happen in your lifetime. These include prayers for the calling of the Jews, the downfall of God's enemies, the flourishing of the Gospel, the full purity and freedom of God's ordinances, and the well-being of the society and place you live in. All of you with sincere hearts store up many such prayers and sow much of this precious seed, which you must be content for the Church to reap in future ages. These prayers are not lost but will be answered. Just as God is eternal and Christ's righteousness is everlasting and therefore eternally effective (Dan. 9:24), being offered by the eternal Spirit (Heb. 9:14), so are prayers, which are the work of the eternal Spirit of Christ, made to God in His name. They are eternally accepted and have eternal power, and therefore may be fulfilled in future ages. For example, the prayer that Stephen made for his persecutors was fulfilled in Saul after Stephen was dead. David's prayer against Judas (Ps. 109:8-9) took effect over a thousand years later, as seen in Acts 1:20. The prayers of the Church for three hundred years during the early times, that kings might come to the knowledge of the truth and lead peaceful and quiet lives in all godliness and honesty (which Paul encouraged during Nero's time, 1 Tim. 2:2), were not fulfilled until Constantine's time when the Church brought forth a man-child. In Isaiah 58, after he exhorted and gave directions for fasting and prayer in the right manner, he added this promise: "You shall raise up the foundation of many generations; you shall be called the repairer of the breach," because his fasting and prayers might influence many future ages in fulfilling what was prayed for. What Christ says about the Apostles reaping the fruit of John the Baptist's ministry and the seed he had sown is similarly verified here: "One sows and another reaps" (John 4:37). In this sense, what the Papists say is true: there is a common treasury of the Church, not of their merits, but of their prayers. There are bottles of tears being filled, vials being filled to be poured out for the destruction of God's enemies. What a collection of prayers has there been over these many ages toward this? This may be one reason why God will do such great things toward the end of the world, because there has been such a great stock of prayers over many ages, which is now to be fulfilled. This is similar to how it was with the prophets of old, whose prophecies signified the sufferings of Christ and the glory that would follow. It was revealed to them that they were not serving themselves, but us, with the things now revealed. This is also true in the spirit of prayer, which takes the place of the spirit of prophecy, for we pray through the guidance of the Spirit (who teaches us what to ask) for many things that come to pass in future ages.
Right now, it might be that during prayer, you feel a secret impression on your spirit that these things will happen, which strengthens your faith in them. This also serves as evidence that God will fulfill them partly because of your prayers. Your prayers contribute to the overall outcome. During such prayers, God often shows that He accepts you and reveals Himself to you, confirming that you belong to Him, just like He did with Moses. God never showed His love to Moses more than when Moses prayed the most for God's people. Perhaps you see this as one of the best signs of your sincere heart—that you can pray for the Church's well-being, even for a future you may never witness with your own eyes, just as David did and found joy in it.
And when everything is fulfilled, and you are in heaven, your joy will be even greater because of these prayers of yours: both at the conversion of those you prayed for and at the downfall of the Church's enemies, whom you prayed against. For if there is joy in heaven at the conversion of a sinner (like the birth of a new prince and heir of heaven), then perhaps the one who prayed the most for it will rejoice the most, having a special part in it. Just like your other works, your prayers will follow you, and so will their results, as Jeremiah mentions. And no matter what, on the day of judgment, you will rejoice, just like those who benefited from your prayers during their lives, since you planted the seeds of their happiness. Both the one who sows and the one who reaps will rejoice together, as Christ says in John 4:36.
CHAPTER 3
CONCERNING PRAYERS MADE FOR OTHERS AND HOW THEY ARE ANSWERED
The second case is about getting answers to our prayers for others, like specific people such as friends and family, and also for physical or material blessings.
We must pray for others we know, like the elders of the church for those who are sick, as mentioned in James 5:15-16. "Pray one for another," says James. For example, if someone is struggling with a sin, they should tell a trusted friend about it. "Confess your sins one to another," so that when a person's own prayers aren't strong enough to overcome it, it can be done with the help of another's prayers combined with theirs. As it follows, "That ye may be healed," in verse 16. I understand healing in this sense in verse 16. Also, in 1 John 5:16, if someone sees their brother committing a sin that is not leading to death, meaning not against the Holy Spirit, they should ask for life for him, and God will give life to those who sin not unto death.
Regarding this situation, I offer these thoughts on how such prayers are answered.
Consideration #1: God often hears such prayers; why else would any such promises be made? For example, that they shall be healed in their bodies (James 5:15), healed of their lusts (James 5:16), and converted to life (1 John 5:16). God has made these promises to encourage us to pray and to show His abundant love for us; it overflows so much that He will hear us, not only for ourselves but for others too. This is a sign that we are in extraordinary favor. God hints at this concerning Abraham and Abimelech in (Gen. 20:7): "He is a Prophet, and he shall pray for thee, and thou shalt live." Just as Abraham was a prophet, we are priests; we pray to God our Father for ourselves and for others. This is a privilege we have through our connection with Christ's Priestly office, who has made us kings and priests, allowing us to intercede for others. It is a special sign of extraordinary love. For if God hears a person's prayers for others, He will certainly hear them for themselves. When Christ healed the man sick with palsy, it was, as stated, for the faith of those standing by (Matt. 9:2). He saw their faith and said, "Thy sins are forgiven thee." This doesn't mean He forgave the man's sins because of their faith, for "The just shall live by his own faith," but to encourage those who, out of faith, brought the sick man to Him. It encourages us all to bring others and their troubles to Him through prayer. He then took the opportunity to declare and pronounce forgiveness to that poor man, saying, "Thy sins are forgiven thee."
Consideration #2: Yet secondly, prayers for others may often also not obtain the particular thing prayed for them. So Samuel's prayer for Saul (1 Sam. 15:35). So David for his enemies (Ps. 7:13).
It's like this: when we use other methods and practices for the benefit of others, God makes similar promises to our prayers as He does to our efforts to convert people when we preach. Just as we preach to many, but only a few believe—"Who has believed our report?"—only those appointed to eternal life do. We try to reach everyone, but only some are won over. Similarly, we pray for many, not knowing who is destined for eternal life. While we don't know, we are still supposed to pray for them (1 Tim. 2:3-4). Just as when God has established preaching as a practice, it's more than likely He has some people to convert, and usually, the word reaches some, even if it's just a few. In the same way, when He stirs our hearts to pray for others, it's a sign that God will hear us for some of those we pray for, yet we may still be denied. God requires it as a duty on our part because it is an external means ordained by Him, which He sometimes uses to make things happen. However, it's not a certain and infallible means that He has universally committed to using to make things happen on His part.
And even though God's promise to hear and accept prayer is general and universal, the promise to grant the specific thing prayed for is only an indefinite promise. This is similar to other means of doing good, like our advice, corrections, and preaching. He makes such promises because sometimes He does hear and convert through them. For example, the promise in James 5:15 about healing the sick cannot be universal. If it were, it would imply that sick people might never die, even though it is appointed for all people to die once (Heb. 9:27). Elders could always come and pray during times of danger, but the meaning is that God has made a gracious promise to this ordinance because He often restores the sick through their prayers. Therefore, in each specific situation, we should rely on God to fulfill it, with an act of trust, though not with full assurance that we will obtain it, since the promise is not universal, but indefinite.
Promises about temporary and outward things, like when God promises long life to those who honor their parents or riches and honors to those who fear Him, are not guaranteed to be fulfilled absolutely, infallibly, and universally for everyone who meets the conditions of those promises. Scripture, examples, and common experience show the opposite. These promises are meant to be understood indefinitely. Whenever God gives such blessings, He does so by promise, as all His ways are truthful, fulfilling some promised truth. God has decided to give riches and honors to some who fear Him, though not to all, because not everything can happen the same way for everyone. Poverty and contempt can also come to those who fear God, just as they do to those who do not. Therefore, God has expressed His gracious intentions in an indefinite way, requiring a corresponding act of faith from us. This faith is suited to a promise, like a faculty is to its proper object. God did not intend these promises to be an absolute, infallible, universal obligation to perform them for everyone who fears Him. So, the faith a person should have towards this promise is not an absolute, infallible assurance that God will give these outward things to them because they have these qualities. Instead, it should be an indefinite act of trust and submission, relying on Him for the fulfillment of it, not knowing if He will make it happen in His outward plans, but submitting to His will if He decides otherwise.
It is true that the general belief, which faith must have in this promise as a general truth, should be a firm and certain belief that God has made this promise and that He will definitely fulfill it for some people according to His purpose stated in it. This general belief is the unwavering faith in the truth of the promise that James talks about in prayer (James 1:6). However, the specific act of applying this faith to myself, where I rely on it personally, doesn't require me to be absolutely sure that this specific promise will be fulfilled for me. The truth, purpose, and intent of the promise are not universal but indefinite. It's more like a "maybe" (as God expresses such promises elsewhere, like in Zephaniah 2:1-2). Because there is a possibility that God will fulfill it for me, my duty is to trust God and seek it, while submitting to His will for its fulfillment in my life. So, to the extent that the truth and intent of the promise are revealed to be infallible and certain, I am obligated to have a corresponding act of faith, a certain and infallible belief that God has made such a promise and will fulfill it according to His intent, which is for some people. But since the promise is indefinite, and it's not certainly revealed whether it will be fulfilled for me, God doesn't require me to have an absolute full belief that He will fulfill it for me in a specific way. Instead, I should have an act of dependence and trust, leaving it to His wise and righteous will for me.
And yet again, if God ever gives someone a special faith about a specific temporary blessing for themselves or another person, then they must believe it specifically. For example, when He gave the power to perform miracles to His Apostles, along with the authority to do so, they were required to believe that certain miracles would definitely be performed by them, like casting out demons. In this situation, Christ rebukes His disciples for not believing in these specific instances (Matt. 17:20). It's also true that if God gives such faith, He will definitely fulfill it. This is how we should understand His words in Matt. 21:22: "Whatsoever ye ask in faith believing, ye shall receive." He refers to the faith of miracles, as in verse 21, He said, "If ye believe and doubt not, ye shall say to this mountain, remove into the sea, and it shall be removed." So, when God gives such faith and calls us to it, we must believe with certainty that it will happen, and it will. However, God doesn't always call us to this kind of special faith in temporary promises for ourselves or others. If we ever truly believe without doubting, due to a special faith given by God, that He would move a mountain into the sea or grant any outward mercy, it would happen because the one who stirred up such faith would accomplish it. But God doesn't require believers to have this kind of unwavering belief about outward things, as the promises are not universal but indefinite. Therefore, a person is not absolutely required to believe that God will definitely give them a specific temporary blessing, even if they have the qualification, since the promise is not universal to all who are qualified, but indefinite to some who are. The same applies to believing promises made when praying for others, which is the topic at hand.
Consideration #3: When prayers are made out of a sense of duty for others, even if God does not intend to show mercy to them, those prayers come back to benefit us. Just like Paul said that his joy in others preaching, even if their efforts were wasted, would contribute to his own salvation (Phil. 1:18-19). Similarly, prayers for others, even if they don't help those we prayed for, still benefit us. In Psalm 35:12-13, when David's enemies were sick, he prayed and humbled himself, and he said, "my prayer returned into my own bosom." By praying in secret for his enemies, David showed the sincerity of his heart to God and his true forgiveness of them. It's common for God's children to pray for their greatest enemies. Even if the prayer doesn't help them, it benefits the one who prayed, bringing blessings to themselves. God delights in and rewards such a disposition because it resembles Christ and shows that God is our Father, and we have His compassion within us. God encourages this praying attitude in His children for their enemies, not always because He plans to answer those prayers, but because He wants to reward those holy dispositions, which are the noblest parts of His image in them and bring Him great delight. So, their prayers return to their own benefit, as if they had prayed for themselves all along. Similarly, when Moses prayed earnestly for the people of Israel, God offered to return his prayer to his own benefit, promising to make a great nation of him, doing as much for him as Moses had prayed for the people. Just like when preaching the Gospel, Christ told the disciples that if they preached peace in a house and there was no "son of peace" to receive it, their peace would return to them (Luke 10:6). The same applies if your prayers don't take effect.
Consideration #4: If we have prayed for a long time for those whom God does not intend to show mercy to, He will eventually remove them from our prayers and hearts, and He will take our focus off praying for them. What He did through a revelation from heaven to some prophets of old, like Samuel and Jeremiah, He now does through a less noticeable work; that is, by withdrawing the help to pray for such people, by taking away the spirit of supplication from a person for certain people and in certain matters. This is what He did with Samuel: "How long will you mourn for Saul?" (1 Sam. 16:1). And with Jeremiah: "Do not pray for this people" (Jer. 7:16). He does this because He is reluctant to hear His people pray without answering them, and He does not want such precious breath as prayer to be without its full and direct success or to be in vain. Therefore, when He does not intend to listen, He puts the key of prayer out of reach, so eager is He to answer every prayer. This situation of praying for another is similar to reproving another. For someone whom God does not intend good for, God will close a person's heart towards them, so they will not be able to reprove them, while for another, God will open their heart as much as possible, where He intends good. This is sometimes the case in praying for another; a person may not be able to pray for or reprove someone, even though their heart was set on doing both. It is like what God threatened concerning Ezekiel towards that people, making his tongue stick to the roof of his mouth.
Consideration #5: God will hear those prayers and answer them in others, in whom we will find as much comfort as in those we originally prayed for. This often happens. God, to show that He doesn't look or choose as humans do, allows our hearts to pray for the conversion or good of someone He doesn't intend to show mercy to; then He answers those prayers in someone else, whom He makes just as dear to us. When God rejected Saul, Samuel's heart still lingered after him, and he mourned for him. But God, at the same time, told him to stop mourning for Saul (1 Sam. 16). To show that He accepted Samuel's mourning, God said, "Go and anoint one of the sons of Jesse" (1 Sam. 16:1). Samuel wanted to see a good successor in that government, and since he had been their ruler, it was his special concern. Having anointed Saul, it deeply grieved him that Saul turned out so wicked. God saw and answered the core of his desires, and immediately after his prayers, sent him to anoint the best king that ever sat on that throne, who was the result and fulfillment of those prayers. Again, when Samuel came to anoint one of the sons of Jesse, he saw Eliab and said, "Surely the Lord's anointed is before me" (1 Sam. 16:6). If Samuel had been choosing, he would have chosen Eliab and prayed for him. But God doesn't see or choose as humans do (1 Sam. 16:7). In David, Samuel's prayer was fully heard and answered, and even better. Similarly, Abraham prayed for Ishmael, saying, "Oh let Ishmael live in your sight!" (Gen. 17:18). But God gave him Isaac instead. So perhaps you pray for one child more than another, out of natural affection, looking at their appearance and stature, as Samuel did with Eliab. Yet, if your prayers are sincere in their intent, desiring a child of promise, God answers you through another child, for whom your heart may not have been as stirred. When that child is converted, they become as great a comfort to you, and it is as if the one you prayed for most had been transformed.
CHAPTER 4
DISCERNING OUR OWN PRAYERS' INFLUENCE WHEN JOINED WITH OTHERS
The third situation to consider is when a person prays for something along with others, or when others also pray for the same thing with him, so that he is not praying alone. How can he know that his prayers contributed to obtaining it, just as much as theirs did? In such cases, Satan is likely to suggest that even though the request was granted, it wasn't because of your prayers, but because of the prayers of those others who joined in with you.
1. If your heart felt the same holy emotions as others while praying, then your voice definitely helped support it. Jesus said, "If two agree on earth" (Matt. 18:19). The word used means if they harmoniously agree to play the same tune. Prayers are like music to God's ears and are called a melody to God (Eph. 5:19). It's not just about agreeing on what is being prayed for, but about sharing the same emotions. It's these emotions that create harmony and melody. If God's Spirit touched and moved your heart in the same way as theirs, then you helped complete the harmony; without you, it would have been incomplete. In fact, without you, the prayer might not have been answered, as God sometimes requires a certain number of voices, and one voice can make the difference, like when He mentioned ten righteous people to save Sodom. So, when the same holy emotions moved you in your prayer as in theirs, it was the work of the same Spirit in both you and them, and God has heard you.
Especially if God stirred up the same secret instinct in you, to sympathize with another in praying for something unknown to each other, as sometimes happens; then surely your prayers are involved in it as well as his. You might notice sometimes a general instinct of the Spirit, placed into God's people's hearts, to pray for or against something, without prompting each other: just like Ezekiel by the river Chebar prophesied the same things Jeremiah did at home in Jerusalem. Similarly, when Christ the Messiah came in the flesh, there was a great expectation raised in the hearts of the godly people, to look and pray for him (Luke 2:27, 38).
God usually and often shows a person that their prayers contributed and were among the others in achieving it; as,
1. By some circumstance: for example, sometimes God arranges it so that the person who prayed the most for something important is the first to hear about it when it happens. God does this because He knows it will be the most welcome news to that person. It's like what we do with a friend who is genuinely supportive and wishes well for a situation; we send them the first word about it because they were the most sincere and prayed the most about it. Good old Simeon had surely been earnest in seeking the Lord, just like the others in Jerusalem, to send the Messiah into the world to restore and uplift Israel. God revealed to him that he would see the Messiah before he died. To show His respect for Simeon's prayers, God led him into the Temple right when the Child was brought in to be presented to the Lord (Luke 2:27-28). Similarly, good Anna, who served God with fasting and prayer night and day, was also brought in at the same moment (Luke 2:38). Through such unique circumstances, God often shows a person that He has heard their prayers, even when prayed for in common with others.
2. By filling the heart with much joy when what someone prayed for is accomplished: this clearly shows that their prayers influenced the Lord to make it happen, just like the prayers of others. Just like the good old Simeon, who, seeing his prayers answered, was even ready to die from joy; he thought he couldn't die at a better time, "Lord, now lettest thou thy servant depart in peace" (Luke 2:29). When desires have been expressed and poured out, then when the answer comes, they share in the comfort of it: and as desires were abundant in praying, so will joy and comfort be in the fulfillment. It's like when a ship returns home, not only the main owners, but everyone who invested will get a share from the return, in proportion to their investment: so here, even if someone whom it mainly concerns has a special interest in the mercy obtained, you will receive joy from God that the prayer was granted. Paul had started a church in Thessalonica, but he couldn't stay to continue preaching, yet when he was away, he supported those he had taught with prayers, night and day (1 Thess. 3:10). "Night and day praying exceedingly for you," he says: and as his prayers were exceedingly abundant for them, so was his joy abundant when he heard they remained steadfast and didn't fall back; "For now we live, if ye stand fast in the Lord" (1 Thess. 3:8). "For what thanks can we render to God again for you, for all the joy wherewith we joy for your sakes before our God" (1 Thess. 3:9).
3. If God gives you a thankful heart for a blessing given to someone else, which you prayed for along with others, it is another sign that your prayers played a part in it. Paul didn't know how to thank God enough for answering his prayers, as mentioned before. Old Eli had only made one short prayer for Hannah that we know of, saying, "The Lord grant thy petition" (1 Sam. 1:17). When Hannah told him how God had answered her, he gave solemn thanks and worshipped the Lord there (1 Sam. 1:26-28).
And lastly, if the thing prayed for by others was about you, why shouldn't you think it was granted because of your own prayers, and not just theirs? God moved their hearts to pray for you and gave you the heart to pray for yourself. Plus, He gave you what you wanted, which shows you're loved and accepted just like they are. "I know that this shall turn to my salvation through your prayers," says Paul in (Phil. 1:19). Even though their prayers helped, if Paul hadn't been accepted himself, the prayers of everyone in the world wouldn't have done much good. God might listen to the prayers of godly people for wicked people when they don't pray themselves, in worldly matters; like He listened to Moses for Pharaoh and Abraham for Abimelech. He might also listen to godly people sooner because of others' prayers; like He listened to Aaron and Miriam sooner for Moses' sake (Num. 12:13). But if God moves your heart to pray for yourself, as well as others praying for you, then the God who gave you a heart to pray has heard your prayers too, and has paid more attention to them because it was about you, as a special mercy to you.
CHAPTER 5
GENERAL DIRECTIONS: OBSERVING GOD'S PROMPTINGS BEFORE AND DURING PRAYER
Having introduced these cases, I now move on to more general and common directions to help you understand and notice God's will and His answers to your prayers. All these directions can be helpful in all the previously mentioned cases and in all types of prayers. They are based on observations to be made about your prayers, both before, during, and after praying.
First, before praying, when God prompts a prayer, (if I may say so) that is, when God quietly speaks to the heart to pray a lot about something; I describe it like this according to David's words, "You said, 'Seek my face': and I said, 'Your face, Lord, will I seek'" (Ps. 27:8). Now, God speaks to the heart to pray when he not only urges the duty by telling the conscience, "This is what you should do," but God's prompting to pray is like his first words when he created the world, when he said, "Let there be light," and there was light. So he says, "Let there be a prayer," and there is a prayer. That is, he pours upon a person a spirit of grace and supplication, a praying disposition; he provides motives, suggests arguments and pleas to God; all of which you will find come naturally and spontaneously, and also with a lively warmth and expansion of feelings, and with a lingering, longing, and restless spirit to be alone, to pour out the soul to God, and to shape and form those thoughts and suggestions into a prayer, until you have gathered them together and made a prayer out of them. This is speaking to the heart: and notice such times when God does this, and do not neglect them; strike while the iron is hot; you have his ear then, it is a special opportunity for that matter, one that you may never have again. Petitioners at court observe the best times to ask, when they have kings in a good mood, which they will surely take advantage of; but especially if they find that the king himself begins to speak about the matter they want from him. This is how some understand the phrase in Psalm 10:17, that God prepares the heart and causes the ear to hear; that is, he shapes it and composes it into a praying frame. And surely it is a great sign that God intends to hear us when he himself inspires the petition.
Let me point out a difference between these promptings to the heart and those where Satan urges us to do duties at inconvenient times, like when we need to be working, eating, or sleeping. For example, Satan might push us to pray at these times to wear out new converts. The difference is that the devil comes forcefully upon the conscience but doesn't open the heart to the duty. However, whenever God calls us at such unusual times, He prepares the heart and fills the soul with holy thoughts as material for the duty. Whatever God calls us to do, He also gives us the ability to do it.
Usually, when God wants something significant to be done, He gets people to pray by giving them a kind of gracious pre-instinct. He stirs them up and touches the strings of their hearts through His Spirit. For example, before the return from captivity, He stirred up Daniel's heart (Dan. 9:1). Daniel, knowing from books that the time was almost up, was moved to seek God. Similarly, the person who wrote this Psalm was stirred up to pray and write this prayer for their return when salvation was near (verses 9-10). God had foretold this in Jeremiah 29:10-12. He promised, "I will cause you to return after seventy years." Then, in verse 12, He says, "You shall call upon me, and you shall go and pray to me, and I will listen to you." This wasn't just a command of what they should do, but also a prophecy of what they would do because He intended to stir their hearts, as shown in the examples mentioned. So, pay attention to the things God moves your heart to pray for at times, sometimes unexpectedly, when you might not have planned to pray about such things. He might stir you up most when you're walking or have spare time, drawing you into His presence and moving you in the way described.
Now secondly: Just as God speaks to the heart to encourage prayer, He also speaks during prayer; and His communication to the heart in prayer can be recognized by these specific aspects.
1. When God quiets, calms, and satisfies your heart in prayer, it's often because He has spoken something to your heart, even if you don't always recognize what it is. Imagine someone who was very anxious and eager when they went to speak with an important person, but after they come out, they are content, calm, and cheerful. You would think that something must have been said to them that gave them encouragement, satisfaction, and contentment. Similarly, when you go to God and are persistent in a request—like asking for Christ, saying, "Oh give me Christ, or else I die!"—and you leave with your mind calmed and satisfied, feeling the anxiety and worry about the matter lifted and gone, it's a good sign that God has heard your prayer and spoken something to your heart that has brought you peace. When Hannah was deeply troubled and had strong desires (which had grown more intense over time, making her heart very restless, because "hope deferred makes the heart sick" (Prov. 13:12)), she poured out her soul to the Lord (1 Sam. 1:16). After Eli the Priest prayed for her, saying, "The Lord grant thy petition," she found her heart so calmed that she was no longer sad, as the text says. She rose up quieted and calmed, and it was that prayer that filled Eli's mouth with prophecy and her heart with peace, accompanied by a secret word from God that calmed her worries. God then gave her a son, the son she desired. God does the same now by speaking something to the heart, like dropping a promise or consideration into it, saying, as Eli did from God to her, "The Lord grants thy petition." As with Paul, when he was earnestly asking God to remove his afflictions from Satan (whether they were a stirring of lust or temptations of blasphemy, I won't debate now), he said, "I besought God thrice" (meaning earnestly), that it might depart. In response, he received an answer that calmed him until it was taken away (2 Cor. 12:8-9). God said to him, "My grace is sufficient for thee, and my power is made perfect in weakness." This answer, this promise, came at the right time and calmed Paul's heart. Similarly, you might have been praying for a long time against poverty or some other distress, and God may drop a promise like, "I will never leave thee, nor forsake thee," into your heart, which calms and satisfies your mind. This is an answer, and you should pay attention to such answers because they are precious.
2. If while you are praying, God comes close to your soul and reveals Himself to you during a specific request. For example, if you mainly intended to ask for some temporary blessing or something significant for the good and prosperity of the Church (like Daniel did in Chapter 9 when he sought God for the return from captivity), and even before you ask or while asking, God shows favor to you, welcomes you, embraces you: This is a sign that He hears your prayer and accepts both you and your request. When you feel a strong sense of God's favor and presence during such a request, more than at other times or other parts of the same prayer, it is a sign that God hears you in that specific matter, and you should take note of this communication to your heart. When you come into His presence to seek Him, and He says, "Here I am," as promised in Isaiah 58:9, it is a sign He hears you. Therefore, in Psalm 69:17-18, David says, "Hear me quickly," and asks God to draw near to him as a sign of being heard. When God draws near to you, it is a sign He hears you. Daniel fasted and prayed for three weeks (Dan. 10:2-3), and then an angel came, and one of the three Persons told him he was greatly loved (Dan. 10:11, 19). Similarly, when God by His Spirit comes down, meets you, and tells your heart in secret that you are His beloved and He is yours, your prayers are certainly heard. If He accepts you, He will certainly accept your prayers (1 John 5:14-15). Unlike deceitful people who pretend to be kind when they intend to deny requests, God, who is truth and faithfulness itself, does not act this way. When He intends to answer a prayer, He sometimes reveals His free grace so that you may see and acknowledge the source of all blessings as His everlasting love, and thus receive the granted request as a fruit of it, becoming more abundantly thankful.
Let me add this caution, which might be very helpful to you. It's not always guaranteed that when God comes close to you in response to a specific request, that request will be granted exactly as you wanted. However, it is a sure sign that your prayer is heard, that what you're asking for is in line with His will, and that He approves of you and your request greatly. He will give you what you asked for or something even better. Sometimes, there can be a misunderstanding of God's intentions, thinking that the request will always be granted when God comes close to someone. Experience sometimes shows otherwise.
Question: But you might ask, why does God come so close if He doesn't intend to grant it?
Answer #1: He shows His approval of the thing being prayed for. Now, God approves many things that He does not decree. There is His approving will and His decreeing will. God may show His approving will for the thing you ask for (for example, if it's something important for the Church), which He does to encourage you. But it doesn't necessarily mean that His decreeing will is to make that specific thing happen.
Answer #2: God may accept the person and the prayer, even when He does not grant the thing prayed for; and by that drawing near, He shows His acceptance of you and your prayer. Yes,
Answer #3: Sometimes, God's revealing of Himself is the only answer He intends to give to a prayer, and it's enough to have the assurance of God's love instead of a specific blessing. For example, if you prayed against some trouble coming upon His Church, which He still plans to allow, He might have set your heart to pray against it to show your sincerity. Then, seeing your sincerity, He comes close to you and tells you that, no matter what happens, it will be well with you and that you are greatly loved by Him. You are sometimes meant to accept this as the only answer He intends to give. He does this to satisfy your heart and prepare you for a denial in the matter, because otherwise, the denial of something a Christian has been earnest about might lead to questioning and doubting God's love.
3. When God stirs up a specific faith in someone's heart about a particular matter, He sometimes does this and helps the person remain hopeful despite all discouragements. This happened to David in Psalm 27:3. David was in great danger because of Saul or Absalom, and these dangers were so frequent and severe that it seemed unlikely he would ever live peacefully in Jerusalem again and enjoy God's ordinances there. But David had prayed for this and made it the main request of his life (as everyone has one major request, just as they have a special grace or gift). Therefore, David says in verse 4, "One thing have I desired of the Lord, that will I seek after." God gave him a special faith in this matter above all others because it was his great request. "In this will I be confident" (Psalm 27:3). Even if an army surrounded him repeatedly, he said he would be confident that he would escape, see Jerusalem again, enjoy the ordinances, and live in peace. Although his faith sometimes faltered (as it did during Saul's persecution when he thought he would perish by Saul's hand), at other times, his faith was remarkably strong, and he was confident in this matter. He wasn't usually so confident in other requests, which is why he says, "In this," etc. Just as there is a witness of the Holy Spirit directly to the heart, confirming adoption to a person, there can also be a similar testimony for obtaining something significant we have asked for. This specific faith is somewhat like the faith of miracles in the past, where a person had a particular confidence that God would perform a miracle through them. Through prayer, there can be a particular strengthening and assurance in some matters that God will do something for a person. I admit this is rare and extraordinary, just like the immediate testimony concerning our personal adoption, which many who go to heaven do not experience. This other testimony about the fulfillment of special mercies is even rarer and only occurs in some situations. Some people may not be familiar with it, but it can exist in certain cases for some people's spirits, as it did for David in the matter mentioned.
I also want to add a caution about this, similar to the previous one. It doesn't always happen that when God gives a person a strong feeling or assurance about something they prayed for, it will definitely come to pass. These feelings, even if stirred by God, are often conditional and should be understood as such, not as absolute promises. We can't assume these are more absolute than some of the revelations God gave to the prophets, where He showed His intentions to bless or judge someone. Even those clear messages were often conditional, depending on whether people fulfilled certain conditions. For example, Jonah's warning about Nineveh's destruction was conditional, and the promise about Eli's house in 1 Samuel 2:30 was also conditional. God said, "I said indeed that your house and your father's house would walk before me forever, but now the Lord says, it shall not be so," because they broke the implied condition by despising God. Similarly, when God gives us a strong feeling through prayer that something will happen, it's under the condition of our obedience and fulfilling any vows we made to persuade God to grant our requests. If we fail to keep our promises or stop believing, things might turn out differently than we expected, and we might question if it was from God. It could have been truly from His Spirit, but not meant absolutely, only conditionally. In such important requests to God, there are often mutual agreements between God and us. We make promises in prayer, saying we'll do certain things if God grants our request, and we use this to persuade Him. God might then seal a covenant to grant the request and give us a strong assurance. But if, while waiting for the answer, we break our promise, even while depending on God, it shows we would have done so even more after receiving it. In this case, God might deny the request, even though the assurance was from Him. He might have said He would do something for you (like He told David, "I would have given you much more") because you promised to do something for Him. If you fail to keep your word, God might say, as He did to Eli, "Now it shall not be so," even though He had spoken it before, and it wasn't just from Satan or your own heart.
4. When God puts a persistent urgency into the heart, despite all discouragements. Like in Psalm 27:4, "One thing I have desired of the Lord, that will I seek after," meaning, as I have sought it, I will not stop seeking God for it. When God keeps this desire in the heart, it is a sign He hears and will answer. You know the parable where the unjust judge listened to her because of her persistence; so when God puts persistence into the heart, He intends to listen.
There is also something else to consider here: there are two types of persistence. One comes from an excessive desire for something, where the heart feels it cannot be without that blessing, and so it keeps asking, but asks in the wrong way and doesn't receive (James 4:3). But there is another type of persistence that is combined with submission to God's will. When this aligns with God's will, it means God has inspired it, and you can expect something to happen. Otherwise, you might be persistent, like those who seek God daily, yet God does not listen (Isa. 58:2).
CHAPTER 6
FURTHER OBSERVATIONS: THE HEART'S DISPOSITION AFTER PRAYER, WHILE AWAITING AN ANSWER
Next, after you have prayed, pay attention to what God does for you.
First, consider how God guides your actions and heart after praying: there's a lot to that. The Spirit of supplication that was in a person while praying remains as the spirit of obedience in their actions. This dependence on God for the mercy they seek becomes a special reason and means to keep them cautious of offending and diligent in their duties. They watch their paths to walk and behave appropriately as someone seeking favor, not just when they come to pray. David followed this principle, as seen in Psalm 66:18: "If I regard iniquity in my heart, the Lord will not hear me." This thought served as a restraint against sin. Without this, a person provokes God and sets themselves back, losing the progress made through prayer by sinning. Therefore, in Psalm 143:8-10, when David prayed as if his life depended on it (seeking deliverance from his enemies), he specifically asked God to guide and keep him from sinning, knowing that sin would weaken and ruin his prayers. He prayed not only for a quick response but also, "Cause me to know the way wherein I should walk; teach me to do thy will." He prioritized this over deliverance because he knew God wouldn't hear him otherwise. So, when you're asking God for any mercy, notice if God keeps you in a more obedient state after praying; it's a sign He intends to answer you. Similarly, when He prevents you from using wrong means, etc. When God intended to give David the kingdom, He kept him innocent and his heart tender, so much so that David felt guilty for just cutting off a piece of Saul's garment. He wasn't as tender afterward. Therefore, in Psalm 18, when he was delivered from all his enemies, he said God dealt with him according to his uprightness: "for I kept myself from mine iniquity." Also see Psalm 27:11.
Secondly, when God strengthens your heart to wait for mercy after you've prayed. In Psalm 27:14, David, after praying, tells himself, "Wait on the Lord, be of good courage, and He shall strengthen your heart." Honest people, when they give hope to someone who depends on them and waits patiently because of the hope they have, usually don't deny them. It would be dishonest to keep someone waiting and then disappoint them. Therefore, when God keeps your soul in a dependent state after praying, expect a good answer. Indeed, when someone has prayed for a long time, they start to wait rather than just pray (though they continue praying) because now they expect God to act. Before, they told the Lord they desired something, but now they can confidently say they are waiting and expecting it. The hope and expectation of a godly person would lead to shame if not answered, so in these cases, answers usually come.
Both of these last two are joined together in Psalm 37:34: "Wait on the Lord, and keep his ways, and he shall exalt thee."
CHAPTER 7
DISCERNING ANSWERS WHEN THE SPECIFIC THING PRAYED FOR OCCURS
When a man has waited and kept his way, then he should observe the outcome and conclusion of what he sought, how things are arranged by God. Now, necessarily, one of these two must happen: either the thing desired is accomplished, or it is not accomplished. In either case, he may come to see answers to his prayers, for prayer may be answered even if the thing is not done.
I plan to discuss each of these separately.
1. If the thing you prayed for happens, then why would you doubt if God heard you or not? You can see it with your own eyes: often, God grants what a person desires in their heart. Not only that, but He also fulfills their plans, as it says in Psalms 20:4. This means He fulfills not just the desire and aim of the prayer, but in the exact way and by the exact means that the person thought was best. The heart's desire might be satisfied when God gives something else, but the heart's plan is fulfilled when a person is answered in the specific way they thought was best. Planning is an act of understanding, thinking about ways to reach an end, and choosing a particular way to achieve it. As Eliphaz says to Job (Job 22:27-28), "You will make your prayer to God, and He will hear you; and you will decide on a matter, and it will be established for you." This means a person is guided to choose and pray for specific mercies that God grants. He says what he wants, and God performs it. This privilege, says Eliphaz, is yours if you turn to God, get to know Him, and receive His law. You won't make mistakes in praying; what you pray for will be granted to you. Such a person has the privilege of shaping their own blessings in a right sense, being their own chooser and creator of their own mercies. As Christ said, "Be it according to your faith," sometimes God says, "Be it according to your prayers." Eliphaz speaks of this as a special favor, that while other people's prayers are answered indirectly, yours will be answered directly, which is more comforting, like direct sunlight has more warmth than indirect light. If a person listens to God and obeys Him, God will listen to them. If a person is subject to Christ's kingly office, His prophetic office will guide them and prevent them from making mistakes in their requests. Through an unerring providence and instinct given by His Spirit, God will guide them to ask for exactly what He intends to give, even though they don't know what or how to ask on their own. David asked for long life, and God gave it to him (Psalm 21:2-4). God not only gave him his heart's desire but also the request of his lips (verse 2). Hannah asked for a son, and God answered her with exactly what she desired, so she named him Samuel (1 Sam. 1:20). She said, "I asked him of the Lord," and in verse 27, "For this child I prayed, and the Lord has given me my petition that I asked of Him." Similarly, in 1 Chronicles 4:10, Jabez called on God, and God granted him what he requested. This is often how God deals with His children. To this end, God has given us His Spirit and made Christ our wisdom, who knows what is good for us, even if we do not. He has also commanded us to identify mercies for ourselves and then come to Him for them. To this end, He has made specific promises of particular mercies that He wants us to focus on in our prayers, because often He intends to give us exactly what we ask for.
Even though we receive the very things we asked and desired, our hearts are often so doubtful and untrusting that we fail to recognize or admit that it was our prayers that brought them from God. Once we have them, we're likely to focus only on earthly things and the immediate causes, even though we earnestly sought them from God before. We might still question whether it was our prayers that led Him to grant them or if it was just common providence. Job, in his troubled state, said in Job 9:16, "Even if I had called and God had answered me, I would not believe that He listened to my voice," meaning he doubted God answered out of respect for his prayer because God was dealing harshly with him, "For he breaks me with a storm" (Job 9:17). Our doubtful hearts are often unsatisfied with the clearest signs of God's favor and tend to misinterpret and twist them. Even when God answers us when we call on Him, we refuse to believe He listened to our prayer. To help you better recognize when and how the things you prayed for come through prayer, I offer you these further directions.
Direction #1: When God does something in response to prayers, He often does it in such a way that His hand is seen more clearly than usual. There are few prayers where a person has earnestly sought God, but in the answers to those prayers, God reveals Himself greatly. He moves many significant events to fulfill them and shows His marvelous loving kindness (as David desires in Ps. 17:7). Indeed, when God answers prayers that have been made for a long time, He usually shows something almost miraculous in one way or another.
Now God shows His direct involvement in answering prayers in many ways.
1. When God carries something through many difficulties, when there are many obstacles in a situation you prayed for, and even the smallest of them could have stopped it from happening; when God seems to create a solution specifically to resolve it; when God plans and orchestrates all the steps in a situation you prayed for, and then completes it; this is a sign that it is a result of prayer, and that prayer has been working on that solution all along. Consider how God brought David to the kingdom, Joseph out of prison, Mordecai to honor, and similarly, Peter out of prison, which happened through the prayers of the Church (Acts 12). Peter was sleeping between two soldiers: if they had woken up, he would have been caught. He was in chains, but they fell off (Acts 12:6-7). The guards stood before the door, but they didn't notice him (Acts 12:6). After passing one watch, he quietly passed through another (Acts 12:10), and when both were passed, an iron gate opened on its own (Acts 12:10). Many situations have similar difficulties, yet in the end, they are resolved through prayer: iron chains fall off, iron gates and enemies' hearts open on their own, and although not in that miraculous manner by an angel, it is no less wonderful.
2. Or secondly, when God makes it easy for all the necessary steps to accomplish what was prayed for, so that everything seems to work together perfectly—like having the wind and tide in your favor, a clear day, and a smooth path ahead; or as David says, having your way made plain before you—and there is a great coming together of many circumstances to make it happen, where if even one had been missing, it might not have happened, then prayer has achieved it. For example, when God delivered the people of Israel out of Egypt, which was the fulfillment of their long-held desires and prayers (their cry came up, as the text says), everything was made easy! Those who held them captive actually came and begged them to leave, and were even urgent about it, as the text says; and that happened at midnight. They even paid them to leave with their earrings; and Pharaoh himself parted with them kindly and asked for their prayers, saying, "Bless me also." To show there was no resistance, the text says, not even a dog barked: the animals did not disturb them, even though it was midnight when animals are usually most noisy.
3. When God answers suddenly and fulfills what you have long prayed for before you even realize it: like the return from the Babylonian captivity, which was the result of many prayers and happened quickly. They felt like they were dreaming (Ps. 126:1). They could hardly believe it when it happened because they had planted many prayers that suddenly came to fruition (Ps. 126:5-6). Similarly, Peter was fast asleep and didn't even dream of being rescued. Joseph's release from prison and his rise to become the most important man in the kingdom also happened so quickly that it showed God remembered him and answered his prayers.
4. When God grants what we ask for and even more, adding many other blessings along with what we prayed for, this can also be a sign that God heard our prayers. When He truly listens, He often gives us more than we asked for or imagined, to touch our hearts even more. For example, David asked for a long life, and God gave him more than he asked for (Ps. 21:2-5). Solomon only asked for wisdom, but God gave him more than he asked for—peace, riches, and honor (1 Kings 3:12-13). Hannah asked for just one male child (1 Sam. 1:10), but God gave her three more sons and two daughters (1 Sam. 2:21). When prayers are answered, blessings usually come abundantly; the thing we prayed for doesn't come alone. Just as when sins are punished, miseries come like armies upon us, and temptations also come together, causing us to fall into many at once, as James mentions, blessings also come in abundance.
5. When something is granted through prayers, there is often a specific circumstance that happens alongside it, which serves as a sign for good and confirms to us that it is from God. This is something that a person notices themselves, and others notice too. David says, "Show me a token for good" (Ps. 86:17), so that others may see it and be ashamed. God often uses small circumstances as signs and tokens. Things that are small in themselves can be great signs and tokens. For example, Moses, Aaron, and the Israelites had prayed to God for the deliverance of His people and had offered many prayers. Their cry was heard, and when God delivered them, what signs were there of good, of God's hand in it, and of His answer to their prayers? The text notes that a dog did not bark when they were leaving (Exod. 11:7), which was a small circumstance but a great sign, intended by God. The text adds, "That you may know that God puts a difference between the Israelites and the Egyptians." This was a sign of God's hand, controlling the tongues of animals that usually react to unusual noises, especially at night. Similarly, when Isaac, Abraham, and his servant prayed for a wife for Isaac, see what sign God gave to show He had heard their prayers. Rebekah was the first to come out to the servant sent to find a wife for him. The servant said, if she is the woman appointed for Isaac, "Let her offer me drink, and my camels also." This was a small thing in appearance but a great sign of God's hand in it, and so the servant bowed and worshipped. The sign itself showed her good nature and kind, courteous disposition, which perhaps he chose as a sign of a suitable wife, something especially important in choosing a marriage partner.
Direction #2: Again, thinking about the timing when the things we have asked for are granted can really help us see if it's an answer to our prayers. God, who does everything with care and precision, shows His wisdom and love not just in giving us what we ask for, but also in the timing of it. God considers all the times in your life and always chooses the best and most suitable time to answer your prayers. "In an acceptable time have I heard thee" (Isa. 49:8). Just like David says he prayed in an acceptable time (Ps. 69:13). So, God answers at the best and most suitable time for us because He waits to be gracious, for He is a God of judgment (Isa. 30:18). This means He is a wise God who knows the best times and seasons to show kindness and give His blessings.
First, it might be that right at the time when you've been most persistent and sincere in prayer, even while you're praying or shortly after, the thing is done and accomplished. This is like what is said in Isaiah 65:24, that sometimes God hears before they call (showing great love to give blessings without being asked), and also while they are speaking, He will hear and grant the request, which shows no less love. He chooses that time on purpose so they can be sure it was in response to their prayer. To assure Hezekiah that his prayer was heard, God sent the prophet to him while he was praying and weeping, with his head turned towards the wall. Similarly, when Isaac went out to pray in the field, he met Rebekah coming; that blessing of a good wife was surely the great request he was discussing with God: Rebekah was the result of many prayers. When Peter was in prison, the church gathered to pray for him, and Peter came and knocked at the same hour (Acts 12:12-18). It often happens like with the ruler in the Gospel (John 4:52), who, upon inquiring, found that the same hour Christ said to him, "Your son lives," his son recovered, and so he believed, along with his whole household. Similarly, sometimes the thing is done, or the news of it comes the same hour or soon after a person was praying about it, especially when the heart was most stirred about it, more than at any other time. This is a sign it was an answer to prayers and can help strengthen a person's faith in it, just as it did for him.
Or secondly, when it is the most acceptable and best time to have the request granted. At that time, 1. when you need it the most, and 2. when your heart is most ready for it. When answering prayers, God focuses on two main things: 1. To show His mercy, so that a person might praise and lift it up; and 2. To have the heart satisfied and filled with joy and contentment in His answer, making the blessing truly sweet and a real mercy to the person; in short, so that His goodness might be enjoyed, and His mercy celebrated. For these two reasons, He chooses times when we need it most; and also when our hearts are most humble, and our desires are controlled. For then we are best able to appreciate His goodness alone, without being distracted by the worldly pleasure in the thing. The first is expressed in Isaiah 30:18, where it says He waits to be gracious to have His mercy exalted. The second is hinted at in James 4:3, where it says, "You ask and do not receive, because you ask with wrong motives, so that you may spend it on your pleasures." Such prayers, while the heart is in this state, the Lord denies, or delays in mercy until the heart is ready.
For the first of these: Suppose you prayed for a long time for assurance of salvation and joy in the Holy Spirit, and when you needed it the most, either when your spirit would have failed without it (Isa. 57:16), or against some great affliction coming, or some great challenge with the world for the Name of Christ, then God filled your heart with it, etc. That was the perfect time: now God has heard your prayer. Like when Peter was in prison and had been there for many days, as shown in Acts 12:4-5. God could have freed him at any time while the Church prayed for him (verse 5). But God kept him there on purpose until the very night before Herod planned to bring him out for execution the next morning, and then God delivered him at the prayers of the Church; that was the most fitting time. As the Psalmist says, the full time to have mercy on him had come. Receiving an answer then is a sign God did it out of special love, which love He wants you to exalt, as in Isa. 30:18.
If, secondly, when your heart was most ready for the mercy, it was granted, then you were also heard at an acceptable time. God does not withhold mercies from those who are His because of a lack of love, nor so much for what has happened in the past, but because of the current wrong disposition of their hearts, which makes them unfit to receive them. In this sense, it can also be understood that God prepares the heart and hears the prayer (Ps. 10:17).
First, when your heart is most detached from that temporary blessing (assuming it is such) granted to you after seeking it: So, when did David receive the kingdom? It was when he was like a weaned child, and had his high thoughts (which perhaps had initially arisen in his mind) cleansed out, as he says in Psalm 131:1-2, "My heart is not proud, Lord, my eyes are not haughty; I do not concern myself with great matters or things too wonderful for me. But I have calmed and quieted myself, I am like a weaned child with its mother; like a weaned child I am content." At that point, when your heart has let go of all worldly goals and has turned solely to God, finding your portion only in Him, then the thing you prayed for happens: this was the best time.
Objection: But you might say, having something when my heart is no longer interested in it, and I'm even content not to have it, makes it feel like it's not a blessing at all: because where there is no desire, there is no joy.
Answer: If your desire is no longer focused on the thing itself, then you will find more joy in God now. Even if the thing itself gives you less satisfaction, God will make up for it by giving you more joy through it. You will now appreciate His love and sweetness in it, which is better than life and certainly better than just enjoying that thing. In fact, the strong desire you had before would have made it less enjoyable because the thing alone wouldn't have satisfied that intense desire when it was an excessive craving. You would have been more frustrated than satisfied and found it more empty. But now that your desire is aligned with God, and your heart is calm and content with God in the thing, your heart will say, like she did, "I have enough." Also, you might have a hardship that you prayed to be relieved from, and it will be taken away when your heart is most willing to accept your punishment (as Moses puts it) and submit to God in it.
Direction #3: A third thing to notice about getting what you prayed for, which helps you see if it was granted because of your prayers, is when you notice God dealing with you in a way that matches how you prayed and sought Him, and how you lived while depending on Him for a certain blessing. Just like you can see a connection between sins and their punishments, where you can say a specific sin caused a particular trouble, you might also see a similar connection between your prayers, your relationship with God, and His responses to you. David noticed this in Psalm 18:24: "According to the cleanness of my hands hath he recompensed me." His words suggest a similarity or likeness. For example, the more selfish or worldly desires you had in your prayers, and the more you mixed these with your holy desires, and the less zeal and fervency you had, the more you might find bitterness mixed with the blessing when it is granted, and a lack of comfort in it. David also says in the same Psalm, verses 25-26, "With the pure thou wilt show thyself pure." Pure prayers bring pure blessings, and vice versa: "With the froward thou wilt show thyself froward." Similarly, if you sometimes became lazy and cold in praying, you might see the situation cool down and fall back, just like when Moses' hands were down, Amalek prevailed, but when they were lifted up, Israel had the advantage (Ex. 17:12). God showed him a connection, which indicated that his prayer was the reason for success. A person might find that their request sometimes gets stuck and doesn't progress as expected because they aren't as diligent in seeking God as they used to be. But when they were motivated to pray, things went well. This shows clearly that it was the prayer that God heard and responded to. Similarly, when someone sees ups and downs in a situation, with hopeful moments often dashed, and the thing eventually happening, they should look back at their prayers: didn't you deal with God in the same way? When you prayed earnestly and thought you had it, then messed it up by sinning, and did this repeatedly? God wants you to notice this connection, and it can help you understand how and when your prayers are answered and granted, because God deals with you in a way that matches your prayers.
CHAPTER 8
FURTHER MARKS OF ANSWERED PRAYER: THE EFFECTS OF MERCY FULFILLED UPON THE HEART
Direction #4: Fourthly, you can tell if they are in response to your prayers by the effects on your heart.
1. If the thing you receive after praying brings your heart closer to God, it's certain it was granted as an answer to your prayers. Things given through ordinary circumstances often increase our desires and become traps for us, like when Saul gave David his daughter Michal to be a trap for him. Their abundant tables become traps too. God gave the Israelites what they wanted, but also let them follow their desires (Ps. 106:15). He gave them what they asked for but sent leanness into their souls; the quails might have fattened some of their bodies that survived, yet their souls became lean. There was a curse on their spirits; this new fancy food made their bodies more lustful, and they ate, drank, and then played. But things obtained by prayer are made holy for us, because everything is made holy by prayer, so it won't trap or entangle our hearts. Something obtained by prayer, as it came from God, will be returned to God and used for His glory. Like Hannah, who obtained Samuel through prayer, she gave him back to God (1 Sam. 1:27-28): "For this child I prayed, and God gave me my petition, and therefore also I have lent him to the Lord as long as he liveth." If you find that His response to you motivates you to mourn for sin and restrains you from sin, it's a sign it was the result of prayer. This is how it worked with David (Ps. 6:8): "Away from me ye that work iniquity: God hath heard the voice of my weeping."
Also, if you rejoice in God more than in the thing you received: like how Hannah begins her song when she blesses God for her child; "My heart rejoices in the Lord," etc. (1 Sam. 2:1). She rejoices not so much in the gift as in the giver; and values His favor more because her prayer was answered than because of the thing she received. This is a sign of having received mercy through prayers when it is sanctified in this way to a person's spirit.
2. When your prayers are answered, it will make your heart more thankful, and this usually happens; self-love makes us more eager to pray than to give thanks, because our nature is all about wanting and taking. But where there is grace, any significant mercy gained through much effort will be remembered with gratitude for a long time, with much enthusiasm: and as prayers increase, so will thanksgiving. Hannah made a song (1 Sam. 2). Great blessings that are won with prayer are kept with thankfulness: such a person will not ask for new things without also giving thanks for the old ones. Thankfulness, of all duties, comes from pure grace, so if the Spirit moves you to it, it's a sign He inspired the prayer. "What thanks shall I render to God, for the joy I have in you," says St. Paul (1 Thess. 3:9-10). In all his other letters, he tells those he writes to that as he prays for them, he also gives thanks for them and for the graces he prayed for. And if answering prayers for others makes St. Paul so thankful, how much more when it's for himself? Prayer and thanks are like the double motion of the lungs; the air taken in by prayer is breathed out again by thanks. Is your heart newly opened, not only to mourn for past sins committed long ago but also to give thanks for past mercies won with long prayers, and this for a long time after? It is a sign that they were obtained by prayer.
3. If the mercy you've received encourages you to go to God again, to pray more confidently and fervently, it's a sign you received the previous mercy in that way. For the Holy Spirit, having once shown you this way of obtaining mercy, makes you ready to take the same approach next time. "Because he inclined his ear to me, therefore I will call on him as long as I live" (Psalm 116:2). He knows now what to do if he's in need—call upon God; and he encourages others to do the same.
4. When God hears your prayers after you've made solemn vows, and your heart is careful to fulfill those vows you made while asking God for mercy, this can be a sign that your prayer was heard. First, it shows that your heart secretly believes that God granted your request because of those vows, and you feel a duty to return everything to God in service, as part of the agreement you made with Him. It's like paying homage and acknowledging forever that such a mercy was obtained through prayer, and this helps you remember receiving that mercy. Vows are like a form of homage. Secondly, it's also evidence that the thing was obtained by prayer because God, through His Spirit in your heart, calls for those vows from you and encourages you to fulfill them. It suggests that in response to your answered prayers, He considers them as dues from you, and having granted your request, He now asks for what was promised to Him. Thirdly, when He accepts the fulfillment of your vows, it shows that those vows and prayers were heard. As Manoah said in another situation, "If He meant to have destroyed us, He would not have accepted a sacrifice" (Judg. 13:23). Similarly, if God hadn't heard your prayers, He wouldn't have accepted your vows after you prayed. This is like what David said in Psalm 66:13-14, "I will pay you my vows, which my lips have uttered, and my mouth has spoken, when I was in trouble," and the reason follows in verses 17 and 19, "because God has truly heard me when I cried to Him." Eliphaz in Job also connects these two, saying in Job 22:27, "You will make your prayer to Him, and He will hear you, and you will pay your vows." Paying vows is not only a duty but also a result that follows when prayers are heard. Eliphaz's aim is to encourage Job to turn to God, showing the benefits, including having his prayers heard and fulfilling his vows.
5. When you are able, through faith, to clearly see God's hand at work in bringing about that mercy, beyond the power of secondary causes, and acknowledge it for His glory: the truth is, one main reason our blind hearts often fail to recognize our prayers being answered, even when the thing is done, is that we focus on secondary causes and don't see God's hand in it. Therefore, when God enables you to see that He has done this kindness for you, and your mind is clear about it, this is a result of Him hearing your prayers. You will usually find that the amount of faith and dependence you had on God in prayer for obtaining a mercy will match the faith and acknowledgment you have when it is accomplished. This rule parallels another one given in a different context: in performing duties, the more the soul relies on God for strength to perform them, the more, when they are performed, the heart will acknowledge God's assistance and be humbled. This is a sign of prayer being heard because God's purpose in hearing prayers is for us to glorify Him. As it says in (Ps. 50:15), "Call upon me in the day of trouble, and I will deliver thee, and thou shalt glorify me." Therefore, when the heart has prayed much for a mercy, with dependence before obtaining it, and then is able to exalt God when it is obtained, it is a sign that God did it in response to those prayers. There is a connection between these, as between cause and effect: "I will hear thee, and thou shalt glorify me." David, when he was delivered from all his troubles (as when he made the 18th Psalm, as indicated by its title), in verse 6, he recounts how he prayed and was heard; and see how his heart was enlarged to acknowledge God alone for all of it in the rest of that Psalm, from verse 27 and also from verse 31. When we see angels from God, beyond the power of secondary causes, descending, it is a sign that prayers, like angels, first ascended and obtained that mercy. Similarly, in (Isa. 26), the Church, having obtained deliverances by prayer (verse 17), makes a song of thankfulness and ascribes all to God in verse 12: "Thou hast wrought all our works for us," and in verse 18: "Verily we have not wrought any deliverance in the earth."
6. When the mercy comes with the assurance of God's love and a sign of His favor, when God sends not just a simple token but also a letter with it to show His love, in which the token is wrapped. I don't need to make that a sign, because when this comes with a mercy, it carries its own proof, and you will then know well enough that it is the result of prayer.
7. Lastly, it will be clear by the outcome; things obtained through prayer have few problems, the curse is removed, but what comes through ordinary means seems to come up on its own, like untended earth, full of thorns, briars, and many troubles. The reason is that what comes through prayer comes as a blessing, and no sorrow is added to it. Also, prayer removes those excessive desires, which cause the emptiness and trouble in the things we enjoy. But when God's blessing makes one rich, He adds no sorrow with it (Prov. 10:22). Things that are long delayed, but finally obtained through prayer, turn out to be very comforting and stable blessings. The trouble the heart experienced during the delay is compensated by the more constant and pure joy in enjoying it; prayer having long enriched it, and the thing being immersed in it, makes it extremely pleasant. So, "Hope deferred makes the heart sick, but when the desire comes, it is a tree of life," and it heals that sickness and greatly comforts the heart (Prov. 13:12). Isaac found Rebekah to be a great blessing and a comforting wife to him (Gen. 24:67). Isaac was also a comfort to Abraham (Gen. 17:18-19), a true son, a son of laughter, as his name means. Samuel was such a blessing to Hannah; she not only had a son but a good son, a blessed son, a prophet, and the judge of God's people. On the other hand, Jacob received the blessing without prayer, and it was bitter for him, even though it was a blessing in the end, because of twenty years of exile from his mother's house. When Israel set up a king, but not by God's will, as God says, what a punishment he was to them, given in wrath and taken away in anger (Hos. 13:11).
CHAPTER 9
CONSIDERATIONS FOR RECOGNIZING GOD'S ANSWER WHEN THE SPECIFIC REQUEST IS NOT FULFILLED
But now the next and more difficult question is, when the request is not granted, how can we still discern and know that God hears the prayer?
Before I address this, I need to clarify that it's true that sometimes the exact thing we ask for in prayer isn't granted, even though the prayer is heard. Christ prayed for the cup to pass from him, and while some interpret "passing" as the short duration of his suffering, meaning he was directly heard in what he asked for, if that's the case, why did he add the phrase "if it be possible"? This suggests his request was for a complete removal, yet he submitted to God's will because he knew a short removal wasn't a big impossibility. In fact, it was impossible for it not to pass (Acts 2:24). However, it's clear in the case of Moses about entering Canaan: "I besought the Lord," he says (Deut. 3:23), "and he was angry with me, and would not hear me" (Deut. 3:26). Before I resolve the issue, there's also an objection that needs to be addressed, which is,
Objection: If the Spirit of God makes every faithful prayer in us, as it says in Romans 8:26, where it mentions that we don't know what to pray for, but the Spirit helps our weaknesses, and He searches the deep things of God, as stated in 1 Corinthians 2:10, then you might think that since He knows God will not grant something, He wouldn't encourage us to pray for something God intends to deny. Instead, He should always guide our hearts correctly and not let us make mistakes in what we pray for. Here's a brief answer to that.
Answer #1: The Spirit doesn't always guide our prayers based on God's secret will and foreknowledge, but rather according to His revealed will to us, both in His word and through His providence, as things are presented to us and appear before us. This means our prayers may not always align with what God intends to do, but instead focus on what it is our duty to pray for the most. The Spirit helps us to pray just like He helps us in preaching or using other similar means and ordinances. Even though the Spirit knows whom God intends to convert and whom He does not, He often assists us ministers in preaching to those He does not intend to convert just as much as to those He does. He deals with us based on what is our duty, not according to His decree.
Answer #2: that phrase helps to answer this: when it is said that he helps our weaknesses, it means he doesn't shape our prayers based on his own vast knowledge. Instead, he adjusts his help to match our weak and limited understanding. He stirs up desires in us for things that, according to our knowledge, we are responsible to think about, and which, based on what we see revealed in his providence, we believe are most for our good and his glory. God accepts these desires as coming from us, but he acts for us according to the greatness of his own love.
And so now to address the issue presented, and to provide guidance on how to calm and direct the heart regarding those prayers where the requests are not granted.
1. First, how did you frame your prayer for the thing that was denied to you? Did you pray for it absolutely and insistently as if it was simply the best for you? If so, you shouldn't be surprised if such a prayer is denied, because you went beyond your authority. But if you prayed for it conditionally, with an "if," like Christ did—"if it be possible"—and said, "not my will, but your will be done," referring it to and trusting God's judgment instead of your own, just reminding Him of what seemed best for you, and then left it to Him to decide, then your prayer may be fully answered and heard, even if the thing is denied. You should interpret, and God understands, the meaning and intention revealed in the outcome in the best way, no matter how it turns out. Otherwise, Christ would not have been heard, yet the text says He was heard in all He feared (Heb. 5:7).
2. Notice if there wasn't a hidden purpose in that denial, for some greater and further blessing, where that denial was the foundation. Often, some great trouble is avoided by the denial of something we were eager for: if we had received many of our desires, we would have been ruined. It was a blessing to David that his child was taken away, for whom he was so earnest, as the child would have been a living reminder of his shame. It was also a blessing to David that Absalom was taken away (whom he surely prayed much for, as he loved him greatly), because if Absalom had lived, he might have caused the downfall of David and his house. Just as a wicked person's deliverance and the granting of their request lays a foundation for a worse judgment, the denial of a godly person's prayer is for their greater good and is the foundation of a greater blessing. Often, the very denial breaks a person's heart and brings them closer to God, prompting them to examine their ways and prayers to see what might be wrong, which is a great blessing in itself. It's better than the thing they asked for, as by losing that one thing, they learn how to pray better and obtain many better things afterward. Christ desired the cup might pass, but it did not; and that was the foundation of our salvation and the path to His glory, as He was to pass through that suffering into His glory. The woman with the issue of blood, though she tried many means, including prayers, and all in vain, found none effective; so that in the end, she might come to Christ and have both her body and soul healed at once.
3. Observe if there is a change or transformation of the thing desired into some other greater blessing of the same kind. God, whose ways are always mercy and truth to His people, uses and manages the valuable stock of their prayers for the best advantage, in ways that bring the greatest returns and gains. Just like old Jacob didn't place his hand of blessing where Joseph wanted, but instead placed his right hand on the younger son, whom Joseph had set on his left, God often removes His hand of blessing from the thing we prayed for and places it on something else that's better for us. When God gave Isaac the power to bless a son, Isaac intended it for Esau, but God unknowingly transferred it to Jacob, yet the blessing wasn't lost. This is how it works with our prayers for blessings for ourselves and others. There is often a transformation, but never a disappointment, which can truly be called an answer to the prayer. It's like if a merchant overseas, when the owner requests certain goods thinking they are more profitable, but the merchant, knowing the market and prices, sends back something else that will sell better and bring more profit. This can be said to answer his letters better than if he had sent the exact goods requested. Similarly, Abraham's prayers for Ishmael were turned to Isaac, and David's prayers for the child were turned to Solomon.
4. Notice if, in the end, God doesn't still answer you according to the main purpose of your prayer. That is, see if the holy purpose, intention, and feeling you had in prayer are not fully satisfied in the end, even if it's not in the exact thing you asked for. God answers according to the main point, like the hinge on which the prayer turns. It's similar to when a general is sent out with an army by a king or a state, who give him many specific instructions on how to conduct the war. Even if he deviates from some instructions due to unforeseen situations, as long as he sticks to the main purpose of their orders and does what's best for their goals, he can be said to follow his orders. Just as they say about the law, "Men's leg is est lex"—the mind of the law is the law, not just the words it's written in. Similarly, the meaning of the Spirit is the prayer (Rom. 8:27), not just the things we ask for. The meaning, intent, and main purpose of our prayers will still be answered. To explain this, the main purposes and meanings of our hearts in our requests are God's glory, the Church's good, and our own personal comfort and happiness. We can only desire comfort, and a person might identify a specific blessing they think will greatly serve God's glory and their happiness, yet that specific thing is denied. Still, God will answer according to the meaning of the prayers; His glory will certainly be advanced in some other way because of that prayer, and your comfort will be fulfilled, which is the common desire of all people. You can only have comfort, no matter what brings it to you, and God will ensure that the comfort your soul desired will come in one way or another. When it does, you cannot help but say your prayers are heard. Just as God fulfills His promises, He hears prayers; the same principle applies to both. God has promised that whoever leaves father and mother will receive a hundredfold—not necessarily in the same form, as we say, in kind. This cannot always be fulfilled literally, for one cannot have a hundred fathers. God fulfills it not always in the same form but in other things, which will be more than a hundred fathers would be.
Moses prayed to enter Canaan, but God responded to the reason behind his prayer, even though He didn't grant what Moses specifically asked for. This was both for Moses' comfort and God's glory. God took Moses to heaven, the true Canaan, which the earthly Canaan was just a symbol of. He appointed Joshua, a young man who was coming up in the world and whom Moses had taught and mentored, to lead the people (Num. 11:28). This brought more glory to God because Joshua was to be a symbol of Christ leading us to heaven, which the Law (represented by Moses) couldn't do because of its limitations. Joshua, being young, could do it better. It wasn't as much for God's glory for one man to do everything. Although Moses wanted the honor of leading the people, having his servant, who had learned everything from him, take on the role was almost as great an honor as if Moses had done it himself. Similarly, when David wanted to build the Temple, God denied his request for similar reasons. However, God honored David by allowing him to prepare the materials and design the plans, and by having his son, who was also a symbol of Christ as a Prince of Peace, build it. David, a man of war, was accepted by God as if he had built it himself, and God will reward him just as much.
5. Notice, if there's something you've prayed a lot about, and even if it's denied to you, yet if God seems to try to give you all the satisfaction possible, as if he's being careful about denying you, and therefore does a lot for the sake of your prayers, even if the outcome is different because of some other purpose he has for other reasons: Like when he denied Moses entry into the Land of Canaan, he did it with much respect to Moses. He allowed Moses to lead them up to the very borders, and he let him see that good land by taking him up a hill, and (as it is thought) by a miracle enabled him to see the whole land. The person chosen to complete this task was Moses' servant, which was a great honor to Moses; that someone he trained would succeed him. Similarly, when Abraham prayed for Ishmael, "Oh let Ishmael live in thy sight" (Gen. 17:18), God went as far as he could in granting the request. He said, "I have heard thee, and I have blessed him, and I will make him fruitful, and multiply him exceedingly, and he shall beget twelve princes; but my covenant I will establish with Isaac" (Gen. 17:20-21). Likewise, when in casting that thing, you sought at his hands, he shows an extraordinary hand in turning it; it is a sign he had respect for you, that he would choose to reveal his hand so much in it. Let the outcome be whatever it will, if God's hand is clearly seen in it, you can comfortably conclude that there is something significant in it, and that prayer worked that miracle in it, to arrange it so; and that there is a great reason why he denies you, and a great respect for your prayers, in that he is pleased to show such an extraordinary providence about it.
6. Lastly, consider the effect of that denial on your own heart, such as:
[1.] If your heart is open to recognize that God is holy and righteous in how He deals with you, and that your own unworthiness is the reason He denies you, then you are in a good place. We often see the saints expressing this in their prayers. Take Psalm 22, for example. Although it is typically about Christ, as it was written by David and may relate to his situation, it serves as an example. David says, "I cry in the daytime, but you do not hear." This could have made him doubt God, but he continues, "You are holy," and acknowledges that God is dealing with him in a holy and just way. Others have called on God and have been heard, but David feels denied because of his unworthiness. He humbly admits, "But I am a worm." While it might discourage someone to think others are heard but not them, it doesn't discourage David. Instead, it humbles him, "I am a worm," and he acknowledges, "You are holy" (Psalm 22:2-6).
[2.] If God fills your heart with a holy contentment in the denial; if He speaks to your heart, as He did to Moses when He denied him, "Let it suffice thee" (Deut. 3:26); if, like with St. Paul, when he was so eager about removing that buffeting, you receive an answer like "My grace is sufficient" (2 Cor. 12:9); or if some similar consideration is given that calms you: It was the result of David's seven days of fasting that he was able to bear the loss of the child so contentedly, which his servants thought would have overwhelmed him (2 Sam. 12:19-21). But a thought was given to him, which was the fruit of his prayer, that he would go to the child, not the child return here; and his mind was comforted by this, so much so that it is said in verse 24 that he comforted Bathsheba also.
[3.] If you can be thankful to God out of faith, believing that God has arranged everything for the best, even though He has denied you; and even if you see no reason why the thing you prayed for wouldn't have been for the best, yet you are thankful for the denial because you trust in God's judgment: Like David, in all those mentioned instances, "You are holy, enthroned on the praises of Israel"; he praises God for all this. Before David ate, after his seven days of fasting for the child, he got up and went first into the Temple and worshipped (2 Sam. 12:20). The kind of worship he offered is shown by his anointing himself and changing his clothes, which was a sign of rejoicing and thanksgiving. It turned out according to his faith, for soon after, Solomon was born (verse 24).
[4.] If you can keep praying and don't give up, even when you're asking for blessings you don't receive; if when you receive blessings, you are most afraid, and when denied, you love the most and aren't discouraged, your prayers are heard (Psalm 80:4). Even though God seemed angry with their prayers, they kept praying, questioned Him, and didn't give up, because they made that Psalm a prayer, asking, "And how long will you be angry against the prayer of your people?" Similarly, in Psalm 44:17, even though they were surrounded by dragons, they hadn't been unfaithful to God's covenant. So you should say, I will keep praying, even if I never get an answer in this life. It moves sincere hearts to see people handle rejection and denial well, which proud people won't do; and it moves God too.
CHAPTER 10
APPLICATION: A CORRECTION FOR NEGLECTING TO LOOK FOR THE RETURN OF PRAYERS, AND THE REASONS FOR SUCH NEGLECT
The purpose of all this is to correct those who pray and are eager in asking, but don't follow up on their prayers once they're done, as if they hadn't prayed at all. They keep trying and have a lot of prayers going, but they don't check for the responses or benefits from their prayers. After praying, they sit down discouraged, not really believing they'll ever hear back about their prayers, as if their words were just thrown away, like beating the air or like bread cast upon the waters, which they think sinks or is carried away, never to be found again. In doing this, you disrespect God's ordinance and misunderstand the power of prayer, and you disrespect the Lord. But you might ask, as they did in the Prophet, "How do we disrespect Him?" If you asked someone a question and then turned your back on them, like Pilate mockingly asked Christ, "What is truth?" but didn't wait for an answer, wouldn't you be disrespecting them? Just as not answering a question is disrespectful, so is not caring about the answer when you've been earnest in asking. If you wrote letters to a close friend about important matters and earnestly asked for a reply, and they took care to send one in due time, if you didn't expect to hear back from them, wouldn't you be wronging them in your thoughts? Or if they did write back and you didn't bother to read their response, wouldn't that be disrespectful? It's the same here when you've been earnest with God for blessings and don't care about the answer. Because this is truly a fault among us, I will try to uncover the causes and discouragements that, even though they don't stop you from praying, keep you from having an earnest expectation and real belief that you'll hear answers to your prayers. My aim is not so much to show you the reasons why God denies many of your requests, but rather why you feel discouraged in your own hearts after praying, as if they won't be answered, even though God does answer them. These discouragements are partly temptations and partly sinful obstacles where we are more at fault.
1. Because your assurance that you are accepted by God is weak, your confidence that your prayers are heard is also weak. Just as God first accepts the person and then their prayers, believing that God accepts you is what gives you confidence that your prayers will be answered. You can find this in 1 John 5:13-15. In verse 13, it says, "These things have I written to you, that ye may know you have eternal life." With that assurance, the following happens in verses 14 and 15: "And this is the confidence that we have in him, that if we ask anything according to his will, he hears us. And if we know he hears us, we know we have the petitions we desired of him." Notice how these three are connected as effects and consequences of each other. 1. "These things I write unto you, that you may be assured, that life and heaven is yours," as in verses 12 and 13. And upon that, 2. this confidence will follow in your hearts, that God hears you, meaning that his ears are open to you and his heart is open towards you. Then, 3. if you are assured that God hears you, this will lead to assurance that you will receive anything you desire. He makes this one of the main and immediate effects of assurance of justification. Therefore, he says, "this is the confidence that we have in him," meaning this is the effect of this confidence. If they ask what benefit comes from this assurance, he says it is one of the great and main privileges of a Christian: assurance that God will hear them and grant all their prayers. When a person is assured that God has given them his Son, they will easily believe and expect, "How shall he not with him give me all things?" (Rom. 8:32). Once they see God as a Father, they will easily understand what Christ says: If fathers who are evil can give good things to their children, how much more will your Father give his Spirit and all good things to those who ask? And if he gave his Son when we did not pray to him, how much more will he give us all things we pray for? If someone approaches another person whose feelings towards them are unknown, they would have little hope or expectation of having their request granted, even if they ask repeatedly. But if they are assured they are in favor with that person, they will be confident of obtaining their request according to the degree of favor they believe they have.
2. Discouragement is the weakness of their prayers: even if a person believes they are accepted, they might think, "My prayers are so poor and weak, surely God will never pay attention to them."
[1.] To address this, let me first ask you this question: Do you pray with all your might? If so, even though your strength may seem weak in itself and in your own view, because it is all the strength you have and the grace within you, it will be accepted. For God accepts according to what a person has, not according to what they do not have (2 Cor. 8:12).
[2.] You should understand that God doesn't listen to you because of your prayers themselves, though He doesn't listen without them, but for His Name's sake and His Son's sake, and because you are His child. Just like a mother who hears and helps her child when it cries (even if it's a weak child), she doesn't care for it because it cries louder, but simply because it cries; and she feels more compassion the weaker it is.
[3.] Again, even if the prayer itself is weak, it can still be strong because a weak prayer can set the strong God to work. Just like faith, which might be weak when we act on it, still justifies because its object is Christ. Similarly, prayer prevails not because of the performance itself but because it is offered in Christ's name. Therefore, just as weak faith justifies, a weak prayer can prevail as well as a stronger one. Both work for the same reason: faith attributes everything to God, and so does prayer. Faith is about receiving grace, and prayer is about asking for grace. So, do you think your prayers are accepted despite their weakness? If they are accepted, then they must be accepted as prayers. If they are accepted as prayers, then they are effective in moving God to grant what you ask for. If He didn't accept them for their intended purpose, it would be as if He didn't accept them at all. Just as when He approves of someone's faith as true and sincere, He accepts it for its purpose, which is to save and justify, and He fully accepts the weakest act of faith as much as the strongest. The same goes for prayers, which are meant to obtain mercies from Him. If He accepts them at all, it is with the intention of fulfilling them, which is their purpose.
[4.] People often misunderstand the weakness of their prayers by focusing on their words and how well they perform them, or by how much emotion they show. However, the strength and power of prayer should be judged by the faith, sincerity, obedience, and desires expressed in it. Just like it's not the loudness of a preacher's voice, but the importance and holiness of the message and the preacher's spirit that moves a wise and intelligent listener, it's not the skills but the grace in prayers that move the Lord. The strength of prayer doesn't lie in words but in how well it is able to connect with God. One prayer isn't stronger than another unless it is framed in a way that has more or less power with God. As it is said about Jacob, he had power with God (Hos. 12:3-4). Prayers move God not like a speaker moves their audience, but like a child moves their father. Two words from a humble child crying at their father's feet will have more impact than written speeches. In Romans 8, it is the meaning of the spirit that God pays attention to more than the words, as the groans are described as unutterable. Hezekiah's words were so rough and broken that he says in Isaiah 38:14 that he just chattered, like a crane, yet God heard them.
A third discouragement is the lack of answers; I have prayed often and for a long time, and I have been seldom or never answered, so I don't think much of my prayers being heard. Others receive the results of their prayers, but I almost always miss out on what I ask for. Therefore, they say like those in Isaiah, "Why have we fasted, and you do not see it?" (Isa. 58:3).
To address this, consider:
[1.] You have more reason to wait because you have more answers to come. Just as wicked people store up wrath, godly people store up mercy, especially through their prayers. Therefore, mercies and answers often come in abundance, just as afflictions do.
[2.] Suppose you don't get many answers about the things you're praying for, whether for yourself or others, yet your reward is with the Lord. Praying is like preaching; a person might preach faithfully for many years without converting a soul, but they shouldn't stop waiting. Instead, they should observe after every sermon to see what good is done and whether God will grant people repentance (2 Tim. 2:25). And if no one is converted, still, as Isaiah 49:4 says, a person's reward is with the Lord. Everyone will receive their own reward according to their own labor (1 Cor. 3:8), not just based on the success of their work. It's the same with praying; even if you miss again and again and nothing you pray for seems to succeed, don't be discouraged, because your reward is with the Lord, and it will come one day.
[3.] God does it, not because He doesn't hear you, but to test you. For someone to say, like David does, "I love the Lord, because He has heard my voice and my pleas for mercy. Because He inclined His ear to me, therefore I will call on Him as long as I live" (Psalm 116:1-2), is not as significant as being able to say, "Well, I have prayed for a long time and for many things, and never succeeded, yet I will call upon Him while I live, even if I don't find an answer in this life." To find success in a business and still continue trading doesn't show as much faithfulness in a person's calling as when someone faces losses and setbacks but still continues to pursue it.
[4] 4. God usually waits so long that we stop expecting, as seen in Luke 18:8. The chosen ones cry day and night, but God waits so long (verse 7) that when He comes, He doesn't find faith; they have stopped expecting, have forgotten their prayers, and then He does things they weren't looking for.
There are other discouragements where we are more at fault, and these are our sins rather than just our temptations, which still weaken our expectation of having our prayers answered, such as:
1. Laziness in prayer happens when we don't put all our effort into praying. It's no wonder we don't just fail to receive what we ask for, but our own hearts doubt us, and we expect little success from such prayers. "He who asks coldly teaches the other to deny him." If someone approaches us weakly and carelessly, we aren't eager to deny them, but we think they can be easily turned away without much thought. Similarly, when we notice our own laziness in praying, praying as if we aren't really praying, it's no surprise that we don't expect success from such prayers, which we didn't take seriously. When we pray as if we are willing to be denied, knowing that the Scripture says only fervent prayer prevails, the kind that engages all our faculties (James 5:16), how can we expect God to grant us anything good? Although God doesn't sell us anything for our prayers but gives freely, He wants His gifts to be accepted. Without strong desires and longings, they wouldn't be accepted. And what is fervent prayer but the expression of such fervent desires? Jacob wrestled when he obtained; many seek to enter, says Christ, but you must strive. When we know these things and yet are lazy, how can we expect any answers at all? Won't our awareness of this laziness crush all our expectations? This is why God sometimes seems to act in proportion to our prayers. Because we seem to pray but not with purpose, God sometimes seems like He's asleep, then wakes up and makes offers to help, only to fall asleep again, because we were drowsy in our prayers. The prayers that awaken God must first awaken us. The prayers that stir God must first stir us to lay hold on God, as Isaiah speaks. Just as obedience strengthens faith and assurance, fervency in prayer creates confidence of being heard. In all other things, laziness discourages and weakens expectation. Does anyone expect riches when they do their work carelessly? It's the diligent hand that makes rich. Does anyone expect a crop and a harvest if they don't take the effort to plow and sow their corn? In the same way, if you don't take effort with your heart in prayer, can you expect an answer, or will you even expect one?
2. The second cause of sinful discouragement in prayer is viewing it only as a duty to be performed, like a task, rather than being driven by a genuine desire for the things we hope to receive or by faith that we will receive them. It's like a doctor prescribing medicine to a sick servant, and the servant takes it just because it's commanded by his master, seeing it as a duty rather than a remedy that will actually help him. As a result, he behaves as if he hasn't taken any medicine at all. Similarly, many people pray to God, treating prayer as just a prescription, not as a means to an end. They approach God daily as if He were just a master, not a father, and it's no surprise they expect little from their prayers. Our expectations never go beyond our intentions in any task. If I perform any religious practice just as a duty, I stop there and expect nothing more. For example, if someone preaches only for money, they do their duty and then expect payment, without looking for any other outcome from their sermons. Likewise, people won't look for answers to their prayers if they see them only as duties. To help with this, focus on two things in prayer: first, God's command, and second, God's promise. Consider prayer in two ways: first, as a duty in respect to the command, and second, as a means to obtain blessings from God in relation to His promise. Therefore, in prayer, you should exercise both obedience and faith, as it says, "ask in faith, nothing wavering" (James 1:6). Most people perform prayer as an act of obedience only, resting in the act itself, but if someone prays in faith, they will focus on the promises and see prayer as a means to receive mercy from God in the future. If so, they won't be satisfied until they receive an answer to their prayers and will wait, just as the Church says she would wait until God arises and pleads her cause.
3. A third sinful discouragement is going back to sins after praying. When someone has prayed for a blessing and feels confident that their prayers are heard, they walk with that confidence for a while. But if they fall into sin, that sin seems to shatter all their hopes and undo their prayers, as they think. It's like the sin meets with the answer, which is God's messenger, and sends it back to heaven. Often, when God is about to grant a request, and the decision is almost made, a sinful act interrupts, delaying and ruining both the prayer and the answer, leaving guilt in the mind that crushes our hopes. Then, we stop thinking about our prayers. This is especially true if, while sinning, a thought comes to mind (as it often does to stop us): "Aren't you relying on God for this blessing and have prayed for it? How dare you sin against Him?" When the heart continues in sin, it ruins the prayer and discourages a person. The conscience asks, "Will God hear sinners?" (John 9:31). It's true that sinning in this way interrupts and hinders our prayers from being answered. As we disrupt and betray our prayers, we find that obstacles and difficulties arise in obtaining what we prayed for. Just as we place obstacles in God's way of doing good for us, He places them in ours. Often, when things are going well and we think we will succeed, something happens that sets us back, because we dealt with God in the same way. After praying and feeling hopeful, some sin ruins everything and takes away our expectations. But remember, in the end, prayer usually overcomes sin in God's children, and God eventually overcomes difficulties and brings things to pass. Know that it's not so much past sins that hinder the prayers of God's people, but the current unfitness and lack of readiness in their hearts for mercy.