Charity and its FruitsJonathan Edwards
N.B. The following text was freely provided by Updated Works. Their updated books and audios are superb in every way.
"Some of the most important ideas in history are locked away in old books that modern readers struggle to understand. Archaic language, unfamiliar phrasing, and outdated conventions create unnecessary barriers to timeless wisdom.
"Updated Works exists to change that. We take significant older texts and translate them into clear, contemporary English while faithfully preserving the author's original meaning and voice. Our goal is simple: make important books readable again.
"Archaic spelling, obsolete words, and tangled sentence structure are rendered into clear, contemporary English--always preserving the author's meaning, voice, and line of argument. We modernize the language, never the message."Please visit their website to purchase select hardcopy books and audio books: Updated Works.
CONTENTS
1. Lecture 1. Charity: The Sum of All Virtue
2. Lecture 2. Love Is Greater Than the Extraordinary Gifts of the Spirit
3. Lecture 3. The Greatest Achievements or Sufferings Are Worthless Without Love
4. Lecture 4. Love Is Patient and Kind
5. Lecture 5. Love Is Not Inconsistent with Truly Seeking Our Own Happiness
6. Lecture 6. Love Is Incompatible with Envy
7. Lecture 7. The Spirit of Love Is a Humble Spirit
8. Lecture 8. The Spirit of Love Stands Against Selfishness
9. Lecture 9. The Spirit of Love Is the Opposite of an Angry Spirit
10. Lecture 10. The Spirit of Love Is the Opposite of a Judgmental Spirit
11. Lecture 11. All True Grace in the Heart Leads to Holy Practice in Life
12. Lecture 12. Love Seeks the Good of Others
13. Lecture 13. Love Bears, Believes, Hopes, and Endures All Things
14. Lecture 14. True Grace Cannot Be Overthrown by Opposition
15. Lecture 15. The Holy Spirit Will Forever Be Given to the Saints in the Grace of Divine Love
16. Lecture 16. Heaven Is a World of Love
CHAPTER 1
LECTURE 1. CHARITY: THE SUM OF ALL VIRTUE
"Though I speak with the tongues of men and of angels, and have not charity, I am become as sounding brass, or a tinkling cymbal. And though I have the gift of prophecy, and understand all mysteries, and all knowledge; and though I have all faith, so that I could remove mountains, and have not charity, I am nothing. And though I bestow all my goods to feed the poor, and though I give my body to be burned, and have not charity, it profiteth me nothing." (1 Cor 13:1-3)
In these words we observe, first, that the apostle singles out something of special importance, something he regards as uniquely essential in the life of a Christian, and calls it CHARITY. This charity, we find, is emphasized throughout the New Testament by Christ and His apostles more consistently and more urgently than any other virtue.
But the word "charity," as used in the New Testament, carries a far broader meaning than it does in everyday conversation. When people use the word "charity" in ordinary speech, they typically mean a tendency to think well of others and interpret their words and actions generously; sometimes the word simply refers to giving money or goods to the poor. Yet these are only particular branches, or fruits, of that great virtue the New Testament insists on so consistently. The word properly means love, or that disposition by which one person holds another dear; and the original Greek (?????), translated here as "charity," would more accurately be rendered "love," since that is its true English equivalent. In the New Testament, then, "charity" means precisely the same thing as Christian love. While it most often refers to love toward other people, it sometimes encompasses love toward God as well. This is clearly how the apostle uses it in this letter, as he explains in chapter 8: "Knowledge puffs up, but charity builds up" (1 Cor 8:1). The comparison here is between knowledge and charity, with charity given the higher place because knowledge inflates pride while charity builds others up. The following two verses then explain more specifically how knowledge tends to produce pride and why charity builds up, so that what is called charity in the first verse is called loving God in the third, since both verses are plainly speaking of the same thing. There is no doubt that the apostle means the same thing by "charity" in this thirteenth chapter as he does in the eighth, since he is comparing the same two things in both places: knowledge and charity. "Though I have all knowledge, and have not charity, I am nothing" (1 Cor 13:2); and again, "charity never fails, but knowledge will vanish away" (1 Cor 13:8). By charity, then, we should understand Christian love in its fullest sense, whether it is directed toward God or toward our fellow human beings.
And here, charity is presented in a distinctly emphatic way as the great and essential thing. This becomes clearer when we consider, Secondly, what things are described as worthless without it: namely, the most excellent things that natural men can ever possess, both the most excellent privileges and the most excellent performances. First, the most excellent privileges: speaking in tongues, the gift of prophecy, understanding all mysteries, faith to move mountains, and so on. Second, the most excellent performances: giving everything one owns to feed the poor, and surrendering one's body to be burned, and so on. No natural man has ever possessed or accomplished anything greater than these, and they represent precisely the kind of things in which people are most tempted to place their trust. And yet the apostle declares that if we have all of them and do not have charity, we are nothing. The doctrine being taught, then, is this: THAT ALL THE VIRTUE THAT IS SAVING, AND THAT DISTINGUISHES TRUE CHRISTIANS FROM OTHERS, IS SUMMED UP IN CHRISTIAN LOVE. This follows clearly from the text, because so many other things are listed that natural men may possess, and the things listed are of the highest kind they could possibly have, in both privilege and performance, and yet it is said that none of them count for anything without charity. If any of them were saving in themselves, they would count for something without it.
By listing so many things of such high order and then declaring that all of them profit nothing without charity, the apostle gives us every reason to conclude that nothing whatsoever counts for anything without it. Whatever a man may have, whatever he may do, it means nothing without charity. This surely implies that charity is the great thing, that everything lacking charity in some way contained or implied within it is empty, and that charity is the life and soul of all religion, without which everything that bears the name of virtue is hollow and vain.
In addressing this doctrine, I want to begin by examining the nature of this divine love, and then demonstrate the truth of the doctrine concerning it. And I. I want to speak about the nature of a truly Christian love. Here I would observe, 1. That all true Christian love is one and the same in its principle. It may take many forms and have many objects, and may be directed either toward God or toward other people, but it is the same principle in the heart that underlies every expression of a truly Christian love, whatever its object may be. The holy love in a Christian's heart is fundamentally different from the love found in other people. In others, love toward different objects may arise from different principles and motives, with different intentions; but a truly Christian love is different from this. It is unified in its principle, regardless of the object toward which it is directed. It flows from the same source or fountain in the heart, even though it may run out through different channels and in different directions, and it is therefore fitting that it all falls under the single name of charity, as in the text. That this Christian love is one, whatever the objects toward which it may flow, is evident from the following considerations:
First, all Christian love flows from the same Spirit working in the heart. Both love for God and love for other people arise from the same Spirit breathing life into the soul. The Spirit of God is a Spirit of love, and when He enters the soul, love enters with Him. God is love, and whoever has God dwelling in him through His Spirit will have love dwelling in him as well. The very nature of the Holy Spirit is love, and it is by communicating Himself, in His own nature, to the saints that their hearts are filled with divine charity. This is why we find that the saints are partakers of the divine nature, and why Christian love is called the "love of the Spirit" (Rom 15:30) and "love in the Spirit" (Col 1:8). Even the deep affections of love and mercy seem to point to the same reality as the fellowship of the Spirit (Phil 2:1). It is this same Spirit who pours love for God into our hearts (Rom 5:5), and it is through His indwelling that the soul remains in love toward both God and other people (1 John 3:23-24; 4:12-13). Second, Christian love, both toward God and toward others, is produced in the heart by the same work of the Spirit. There are not two separate works of the Spirit, one to instill love for God and another to instill love for people. In producing one, He produces the other as well. In the work of conversion, the Holy Spirit renews the heart by giving it a divine character (Eph 4:23), and it is that one divine character, worked into the heart, that flows outward in love both to God and to others. Third, when God and other people are loved with a truly Christian love, they are both loved from the same motives. When God is loved rightly, He is loved for His excellence and the beauty of His nature, especially the holiness of His nature, and it is from that same motive that the saints are loved: for the sake of holiness. Everything that is loved with a truly holy love is loved out of the same regard for God. Love for God is the foundation of gracious love for others, and people are loved either because they resemble God in some way, sharing His nature and spiritual image, or because of the relationship they stand in to Him as His children or creatures, as those who are blessed by Him, or to whom His mercy is offered, or in some other way that traces back to regard for Him. I should note that while Christian love is one in its principle, it is distinguished and described in different ways according to its objects and the kinds of expression it takes, including its varying degrees, and so on. I now move on to the second point.
II. To demonstrate the truth of the doctrine that all saving virtue, the kind that distinguishes true Christians, is summed up in Christian love. And 1. We can argue this from what reason itself teaches us about the nature of love. When we consider that nature carefully, two things become clear:
First, that love will dispose us toward all proper acts of respect for both God and man. This is clear, because genuine respect for either God or man is rooted in love. If a person sincerely loves God, that love will naturally move him to show God every form of respect that is due Him; and people need no greater motivation to honor one another than love itself. Love for God will move a person to honor Him, to worship and adore Him, and to wholeheartedly acknowledge His greatness, His glory, and His sovereign dominion. In the same way, love will move us toward every act of obedience to God; for the servant who loves his master, and the citizen who loves his ruler, will naturally incline toward proper submission and obedience. Love will dispose the Christian to relate to God as a child relates to a father: in times of difficulty, turning to Him for help and placing all his trust in Him, just as it is natural for us, in moments of need or suffering, to seek out someone we love for comfort and aid. Love will also lead us to take God at His word and to place our confidence in Him, since we are not inclined to doubt the honesty of those we hold in genuine affection. It will move us to praise God for the mercies we receive from Him, just as we feel gratitude for any kindness shown to us by those we love among our fellow human beings. Love, furthermore, will incline our hearts toward submission to God's will, because we are far more willing to see the wishes of those we love carried out than the wishes of others. We naturally want those we love to be pleased, and we want to be agreeable to them; and true love for God will incline the heart to recognize His right to govern, and to acknowledge that He is worthy of that authority, and so will draw us toward willing submission. Love for God will also move us to walk humbly before Him, because the person who truly loves God will be ready to acknowledge the vast distance between God and himself. Such a person finds it fitting to exalt God, to lift Him high above all things, and to bow low in His presence. A true Christian delights in seeing God exalted even at the cost of his own diminishment, because he loves Him. He is glad to confess that God is worthy of all honor, and it is with genuine joy that he casts himself in the dust before the Most High, drawn there by his sincere love for Him.
A proper understanding of love's nature reveals that it naturally inclines us toward every duty we owe our neighbors. When we genuinely love our neighbors, that love will move us toward justice in all our dealings with them, because real love and friendship always dispose us to give others what they deserve and never to wrong them: "Love works no ill to his neighbor" (Rom 13:10). That same love will also incline us toward honesty, working against every form of lying, fraud, and deception. We simply aren't disposed to cheat or betray those we love, because such treatment is how we treat enemies, and love destroys enmity. This is precisely why the apostle appeals to the unity that should exist among Christians as a reason for truthfulness between people (Eph 4:25). Love will also incline us to walk humbly among others, because genuine love naturally produces high regard for those around us and leads us to think of them as better than ourselves. It moves us to honor one another, since we naturally think well of those we love and want to lift them up, fulfilling the commands to "honor all men" (1 Pet 2:17) and to "let nothing be done through strife or vain-glory, but in lowliness of mind let each esteem others better than themselves" (Phil 2:3). Love will incline us toward contentment in the place God has set us, free from coveting what our neighbors have or envying them for any good they enjoy. It will shape our manner toward others into one of meekness and gentleness, moving us away from passion, harshness, and hot-tempered reactions and toward moderation, calm, and kindness. It will hold in check every trace of bitterness, because love contains no bitterness at all; it is a gentle and sweet disposition of the soul. And it will prevent quarrels and conflict, inclining us instead toward peace and a readiness to forgive those who have wronged us, just as Proverbs says: "Hatred stirs up strife, but love covers all sins" (Prov 10:12).
Love disposes people toward every act of mercy when their neighbors are suffering or in distress, since we naturally feel compassion for those we care about. It moves people to give to the poor, to carry one another's burdens, and to weep with those who weep, just as readily as to celebrate with those who rejoice. It inclines people toward the duties they owe one another within their various roles and relationships. It disposes a community toward all the obligations they owe their rulers, giving them the honor and deference that is rightly theirs. And it disposes rulers to govern the people entrusted to them with justice, seriousness, and faithfulness, seeking the genuine good of those they lead rather than pursuing their own private interests. It moves a congregation toward all proper duty to their ministers: listening to their counsel and instruction, submitting to their guidance within the house of God, supporting them, sympathizing with them, and praying for them as those who keep watch over their souls. And it moves ministers to seek the good of their people's souls with faithfulness and tireless devotion, watching over them as those who will one day give account. Love shapes the way people of different stations treat one another: it moves children to honor their parents, and servants to obey their masters not merely when someone is watching, but with genuine sincerity of heart. And it moves masters to treat their servants with kindness and goodness.
In this way, love disposes people toward every duty, both toward God and toward other human beings. And if it truly inclines us toward all duties in this manner, it follows that love is the root, the source, and, in a real sense, the sum of every virtue. It is a principle that, once planted in the heart, is sufficient on its own to produce every form of right conduct. Every proper disposition toward God and toward others is gathered up in love and flows from it, just as fruit comes from the tree, or a stream from its fountain.
Second, reason teaches that whatever actions or apparent virtues exist without love are hollow and hypocritical. If there is no love in what people do, then there is no genuine respect for God or others in their conduct, and without that, there can be no sincerity. Religion is nothing without a proper regard for God. The very concept of religion, as humanity has always understood it, is that it represents the creature's exercise and expression of respect toward the Creator. But if there is no true respect or love, then everything called religion is merely an outward performance with no real substance; it is hollow and empty. Consider a man whose faith contains no genuine regard for God: reason tells us that such faith must be worthless, because without love for God, there can be no true respect for Him. From this it becomes clear that love is always present in a true and living faith, and that it is faith's proper life and soul. Without love, faith is as lifeless as a body without its soul, and it is love that most clearly distinguishes a living faith from every counterfeit. Without love for God, there can be no genuine honor given to Him. A person is never wholehearted in the honor he appears to show someone he doesn't love, which means that all the apparent honor or worship ever offered without love is simply hypocrisy. Reason teaches the same about obedience performed without love: if there is no love, nothing done can be spontaneous or free; everything is forced. Without love, there can be no heartfelt submission to God's will, and there can be no real, genuine trust and confidence in Him. The person who does not love God will not trust Him. Such a person will never, with true peace of soul, cast himself into the hands of God or into the arms of His mercy.
And so, whatever good behavior a person may show toward their neighbors, reason tells us it is all worthless and empty if there is no genuine regard for those neighbors in the heart, if the outward conduct is not driven by inward love. Taking these two things together, then: that love is the kind of thing that naturally produces all virtues and inclines us toward every duty to God and to other people, and that without it there can be no sincere virtue and no duty properly carried out at all. From this, the truth of the doctrine follows clearly: all true and distinctively Christian virtue and grace can be summed up in love.
2. The Scriptures teach us that love is the sum of everything contained in God's law and of all the duties His word requires. This is what the Scriptures teach about the law in general, and about each of its two tables in particular.
First, the Scriptures teach this of the law and word of God in general. In Scripture, the word "law" carries several meanings. Sometimes it refers to the entire written word of God, as in "Is it not written in your law, I said, Ye are gods?" (John 10:34). Sometimes it refers specifically to the five books of Moses, as in Acts 24:14, where it is distinguished from "the prophets." And sometimes it refers to the Ten Commandments, understood as the complete summary of universal and permanent human obligation. But whether we take "the law" to mean only the Ten Commandments or the entire written word of God, Scripture consistently teaches that love is the sum of everything it requires. When the law refers to the Ten Commandments, Rom 13:8 states, "He that loveth another hath fulfilled the law," and after several commandments are listed, verse 10 adds that "love" (which moves us to obey them all) "is the fulfilling of the law." Now, unless love were the sum of what the law requires, the law could not be wholly fulfilled through love, since a law is only fulfilled by obeying the whole of what it contains and commands. The same apostle declares again in 1 Tim 1:5, "Now the end of the commandment is charity out of a pure heart, and of a good conscience, and of faith unfeigned," and so on. And if we take the law in its broadest sense, as the entire written word of God, Scripture still teaches that love is the sum of all it requires. In Matt 22:40, Christ teaches that all the law and the prophets, that is, the entire written word of God then in existence, hang on the two commands to love God with all the heart and to love one's neighbor as oneself. Second, the Scriptures teach the same thing about each table of the law individually. The command "Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart" is declared by Christ in Matt 22:38 to be the sum of the first table of the law, the first great commandment; and in the following verse, loving one's neighbor as oneself is declared to be the sum of the second table. This is confirmed in Rom 13:9, where the specific precepts of the second table are listed, followed by the statement: "And if there be any other commandment, it is briefly comprehended in this saying, namely, Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself." Similarly, Gal 5:14 states, "For all the law is fulfilled in one word, even in this, Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself." The same point appears in Jas 2:8: "If ye fulfil the royal law, according to the Scripture, Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself, ye do well." Love, then, is clearly the sum of all the virtue and duty God requires of us, and it must therefore be the most essential thing, the core of all the virtue that is real and distinctive in genuine Christianity. Whatever stands as the sum of all duty must also stand as the sum of all true virtue.
3. The truth of the doctrine, as shown by the Scriptures, appears in the apostle's teaching (Gal 5:6) that "faith works by love." A truly Christian faith is one that produces good works, and all the good works it produces flow from love. Two things relevant to our purpose are clear from this.
First, that genuine love is an essential ingredient in true and living faith, and is in fact what is most vital and distinctive about it. Love plays no part in a merely speculative faith, but it is the life and soul of a practical faith. A truly practical or saving faith combines light and heat, or rather light and love, while a merely speculative faith is light without heat; and because it lacks spiritual warmth and divine love, it is empty and worthless. A speculative faith consists only in the assent of the understanding, but a saving faith also involves the consent of the heart. Faith that goes no further than intellectual assent is no better than the faith of demons, who believe as far as belief can exist without love, believing even as they tremble. Now, the true spiritual consent of the heart cannot be separated from the love of the heart. Whoever's heart consents to Christ as Savior genuinely loves Him as such. For the heart to sincerely consent to the way of salvation through Christ cannot be distinguished from loving that way of salvation and resting in it. True saving faith involves an act of choice, by which the soul chooses Christ as its Savior and portion and accepts and embraces Him as such. But as noted earlier, a choice that selects God and Christ in this way is an act of love: the love of a soul embracing Him as its dearest friend and portion. Faith is a duty God requires of everyone. We are commanded to believe, and unbelief is a sin God forbids. Faith is a duty required in the first table of the law, and in the first commandment of that table. It follows, then, that faith is included in the great commandment, "You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart," and so it follows that love is the most essential element in true faith. That love is the very life and spirit of genuine faith is especially clear when we compare the apostle's statement that "faith works by love" (Gal 5:6) with the closing verse of James 2, which declares that "as the body without the spirit is dead, so faith without works is dead also." The active, working nature of anything is what gives it life; what leads us to call something alive is precisely that we observe an active nature in it. In a person, this active and working nature is the spirit within. And just as the body without that spirit is dead, so faith without works is dead as well. If we want to know what the active, working element in true faith actually is, the apostle tells us in Gal 5:6: "Faith works by love." Love, then, is the active and working spirit within all true faith. It is faith's very soul, without which faith is dead, as the apostle also says in another form in the text itself, declaring that faith without love is nothing, even if it reaches the degree that can move mountains. And when he says in the seventh verse of that context that love "believes all things and hopes all things," he is most likely referring to the great virtues of believing and hoping in the truth and grace of God, virtues he compares to love elsewhere in the chapter, and particularly in the final verse: "Now abides faith, hope, love." In that seventh verse, he gives love priority over faith and hope precisely because love includes them; he says that "love believes all things and hopes all things." This appears to be his meaning, rather than the more popular reading that love simply thinks the best of our neighbors. That a justifying faith, as one of Christianity's most distinctive marks, is included within the great commandment to love God is also made very plain by what Christ says to the Jews (John 5:40-43).
Second, the apostle's declaration that "faith works by love" makes something else equally clear: all the Christian exercises of the heart, and all the works of the Christian life, flow from love. The New Testament teaches us abundantly that all Christian holiness begins with faith in Jesus Christ. All Christian obedience is, in Scripture, called the obedience of faith, as in Rom 16:26, where the gospel is said to be "made known to all nations for the obedience of faith." The obedience Paul refers to there is undoubtedly the same obedience he describes in the preceding chapter's eighteenth verse, where he speaks of making "the Gentiles obedient by word and deed." In Gal 2:20, he tells us, "the life which I now live in the flesh, I live by the faith of the Son of God"; and we are told repeatedly that Christians, insofar as they are truly Christians, "live by faith." This is another way of saying that all gracious and holy exercises, all the virtues of the spiritual life, are produced by faith. But how does faith produce these things? In this passage in Galatians, Paul states explicitly that faith works whatever it does work by love. From this, the truth of the doctrine follows directly: everything that is saving and distinctive in Christianity is rooted in love and, at its core, can be summed up by love.
In applying this subject, we can use it for self-examination, instruction, and encouragement. And, 1. In light of this, let us examine ourselves and ask whether we have the spirit it calls for. Love for God gives rise to love for others, as the apostle writes: "Whosoever believeth that Jesus is the Christ is born of God: and every one that loveth him that begat, loveth him also that is begotten of him" (1 John 5:1). Do we have this love for all who are God's children? This love also leads those who possess it to rejoice in God, to worship Him, and to magnify His name. Heaven is filled with people like this: "And I saw as it were a sea of glass mingled with fire; and them that had gotten the victory over the beast, and over his image, and over his mark, and over the number of his name, stand on the sea of glass, having the harps of God. And they sing the song of Moses the servant of God, and the song of the Lamb, saying, Great and marvellous are thy works, Lord God Almighty; just and true are thy ways, thou King of saints. Who shall not fear thee, O Lord, and glorify thy name? for thou only art holy: for all nations shall come and worship before thee; for thy judgments are made manifest" (Rev 15:2-4).
Do we truly delight in God, rejoice in His worship, and take pleasure in magnifying His holy name? This love also leads those who possess it to sincerely desire and earnestly work to do good to their fellow human beings: "By this we know love, that he laid down his life for us, and we ought to lay down our lives for the brothers. But if anyone has the world's goods and sees his brother in need, yet closes his heart against him, how does God's love abide in him? Little children, let us not love in word or talk but in deed and in truth. By this we shall know that we are of the truth and reassure our heart before him" (1 John 3:16-19). Is this spirit, the spirit that lived in Jesus Christ, the spirit that reigns in our hearts and shows itself in our daily lives?
This subject may also be useful 2. In the way of instruction. And first, this doctrine shows us what the right Christian spirit looks like. When the disciples, on their way to Jerusalem, asked Christ to call down fire from heaven to consume the Samaritans who refused to receive Him, He rebuked them, saying, "You do not know what kind of spirit you are of" (Luke 9:55). This doesn't mean they were unaware of their own hearts in a general sense, but rather that they hadn't truly grasped what kind of spirit was fitting for people who claimed to follow Him, and what kind of spirit was consistent with the new order He had come to establish. It may well have been true, and almost certainly was, that in many respects they didn't fully know their own hearts. But what Christ was pointing to here wasn't a lack of self-knowledge in general; it was the particular spirit they had shown in asking Him to call down fire. That request revealed not so much that they were ignorant of their own dispositions, but that they didn't seem to understand what kind of spirit and character belonged to the Christian way of life He was establishing, and to the Christian example they were called to set. They revealed their misunderstanding of the true nature of Christ's kingdom: that it was to be a kingdom of love and peace. They apparently didn't realize that a vengeful spirit was entirely out of place for His disciples, and it was precisely for this reason that He rebuked them.
There are many people today who deserve serious correction on this point: despite spending so long in the school of Christ and under the teaching of the gospel, they still fundamentally misunderstand what a truly Christian spirit looks like and what kind of spirit is fitting for followers of Christ and the age in which they live. But if we pay close attention to the text and its teaching, we will learn what this spirit actually is: in its very essence and character, it is the spirit of divine and Christian love. This can rightly be called, above all others, the Christian spirit, because the New Testament emphasizes it more than any other aspect of our duty or moral condition. When Christ taught people how to live and gave His counsel and commands to His disciples and others, He devoted a great deal of His words to the precepts of love. Because everything that came from His mouth was so saturated with this sweet, divine virtue, He commends it to us in the most unmistakable way. After His ascension, the apostles were filled with the same spirit, and their letters are full of calls to love, peace, gentleness, goodness, compassion, and kindness. They directed believers to express their love to God and to Christ, as well as to their fellow human beings, and especially to all who follow Him. This spirit of love is the one toward which the gospel offers greater motivation than toward anything else. The work of redemption that the gospel reveals provides, above all else, the most compelling reasons to love, because that work was the most glorious and extraordinary display of love the world has ever seen or heard of. Love is the central theme the gospel returns to when it speaks of God and of Christ. It brings to light the love that has existed eternally between the Father and the Son, and it shows how that love has been expressed in countless ways: how Christ is God's beloved Son, in whom He is always well pleased; how He loved Him so deeply that He raised Him to the throne of the mediatorial kingdom, appointed Him to be the judge of the world, and ordained that all humanity would stand before Him in judgment. The gospel also reveals the love that Christ has for the Father, and the remarkable fruits of that love, seen especially in the great things He accomplished and the great suffering He endured in obedience to the Father's will, and for the honor of His justice, His law, and His authority as the supreme moral governor. There we learn how the Father and the Son are united in love, so that we might be drawn, in the same spirit, into unity with them and with one another, in keeping with Christ's prayer: "That they all may be one; as thou, Father, art in me, and I in thee, that they also may be one in us: that the world may believe that thou hast sent me. And the glory which thou gavest me I have given them; that they may be one, even as we are one: I in them, and thou in me, that they may be made perfect in one; and that the world may know that thou hast sent me, and hast loved them, as thou hast loved me" (John 17:21-23). The gospel also declares that God's love is eternal, reminding us that He loved those redeemed by Christ before the foundation of the world, that He gave them to the Son, and that the Son loved them as His own. It further reveals the extraordinary love of both the Father and the Son for the saints now in glory, showing that Christ not only loved them while they were in the world but loved them to the very end. And all of this love was poured out on us while we were wanderers, outcasts, worthless, guilty, and even enemies. This is a love unlike anything ever known or imagined elsewhere: "Greater love hath no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends" (John 15:13); "Scarcely for a righteous man will one die... But God commendeth his love toward us, in that, while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us;... when we were enemies" (Rom 5:7-10).
In the gospel revelation, God and Christ appear clothed in love, seated as it were on a throne of mercy and grace, a seat of love surrounded by the warm radiance of love itself. Love is the light and glory encircling the throne on which God sits. This seems to be precisely what the apostle John, that loving and beloved disciple, witnessed in his vision of God on the isle of Patmos: "And there was a rainbow round about the throne, in sight like unto an emerald" (Rev 4:3), meaning the rainbow encircled the very throne on which God was seated. God appeared to John, enthroned in majesty, encompassed by a circle of extraordinarily sweet and pleasant light, like the beautiful colors of the rainbow, like an emerald, which is a precious stone of remarkably lovely and vivid color. This imagery represents the truth that the light and glory surrounding God in the gospel is, above all else, the glory of His love and covenant grace, for the rainbow was given to Noah as a sign of both. It is clear, then, that the spirit the gospel revelation most powerfully calls us toward is a spirit of love, and that this spirit of love is, in the most essential and elevated sense, the Christian spirit: the true spirit of the gospel.
Second, if everything that is truly saving and distinctive in a genuine Christian is summed up in love, then this truth offers a test for those who profess Christianity: are their spiritual experiences real, or not? If they are real, then love is their core and substance. When people receive the true light of heaven into their souls, that light does not come without warmth. Divine knowledge and divine love always travel together. A spiritual vision of divine things will always stir love in the soul, drawing the heart outward toward every fitting object. True insight into God's character moves us to love Him as the highest good; it binds the heart in love to Christ; it inclines the soul to pour itself out in love toward God's people and toward all of humanity. This is precisely what happens when someone genuinely discovers the excellence and sufficiency of Christ. When they come to a true belief in the gospel, that belief is inseparable from love. They love the One they have come to believe is the Christ, the Son of the living God.
When the truth of the gospel's glorious doctrines and promises becomes clear to someone, those doctrines and promises act like cords that take hold of the heart and draw it outward in love toward God and Christ. When people experience genuine trust and reliance on Christ, they lean on Him with love, and so they do it with delight and a deep, quiet rest of soul. The bride in the Song of Songs sat under Christ's shadow with great delight and rested peacefully under his protection, because she loved him (Song 2:2). When people experience true comfort and spiritual joy, their joy is the joy of faith and love. They are not rejoicing in themselves; God is their exceeding joy.
Third, this truth reveals how beautiful a truly Christian spirit is. A spirit of love is a beautiful spirit. It is the spirit of Jesus Christ; it is the spirit of heaven.
Fourth, This doctrine reveals the pleasantness of a Christian life. A life of love is a pleasant life. Both reason and Scripture teach us that "happy is the man who finds wisdom," and that "her ways are ways of pleasantness, and all her paths are peace" (Prov 3:13, 17).
Fifth, From this we can understand why contention does so much damage to religion. Scripture tells us plainly that it has this tendency: "Where envying and strife is, there is confusion and every evil work" (Jas 3:16). And experience confirms it. When contention enters a community, it seems to block every good thing. If religion had been flourishing before, contention quickly chills and deadens it, while everything harmful begins to thrive. In light of our doctrine, the reason for this is clear: contention strikes directly against the very heart of what is essential and distinctive in true Christianity, which is a spirit of love and peace. No wonder, then, that Christianity cannot flourish during times of strife and contention among its own people. No wonder that religion and contention simply cannot coexist.
Sixth, this means that Christians must keep a vigilant watch against envy, malice, and every form of bitterness toward their neighbors. These things are the direct opposite of what Christianity is at its core. Christians who don't want their daily conduct to flatly contradict their stated beliefs must take this seriously. They should suppress the first stirrings of ill-will, bitterness, and envy; guard carefully against the situations that breed such a spirit; fight with everything they have against any disposition that tends in that direction; and avoid, as much as possible, every temptation that might lead there. A Christian should at all times maintain a strong defense against anything that tends to overthrow, corrupt, or quietly erode a spirit of love. Whatever hinders love for other people will also hinder love for God, because, as noted earlier, the principle underlying genuine Christian love is a single, unified thing. If love is the sum of Christianity, then surely the things that destroy love are deeply unbecoming in a Christian. An envious Christian, a malicious Christian, a cold and hard-hearted Christian: these are the greatest absurdities and contradictions imaginable. It's like speaking of dark brightness, or a false truth.
Seventh, it's no wonder that Christianity so strongly requires us to love our enemies, even the worst of them (as in Matt 5:44), for love is the very character and spirit of a Christian; it is the sum of Christianity. And when we consider what powerful incentives the Gospel gives us to love our enemies, by revealing the love of God and Christ toward those who were their enemies, we can hardly be surprised that we are called to love our enemies, to bless them, to do good to them, and to pray for them, "that we may be the children of our Father which is in heaven, who maketh his sun to rise on the evil and on the good, and sendeth rain on the just and on the unjust."
3. Our subject calls us to pursue a spirit of love, to grow in it, and to let that growth overflow into concrete acts of love. If love is so central to Christianity, so essential and defining, and indeed the very heart of all Christian virtue, then those who call themselves Christians should live in love and pour themselves into works of love, because no works are more fitting. If you claim to be a Christian, where are your works of love? Have you been generous with them? Are you generous with them now? If this holy principle truly lives and reigns in you, won't it show up in your daily life through acts of love? Think carefully: what deeds of love have you actually done? Do you love God? What have you done for Him, for His glory, for the growth of His kingdom in the world? How much have you denied yourself to advance the Redeemer's cause among people? Do you love your fellow human beings? What have you done for them? Reflect on where you have fallen short in these areas, and consider how fitting it would be for you, as a Christian, to abound more richly in deeds of love going forward. Don't excuse yourself by saying you have no opportunities to do anything for God's glory, for the Redeemer's kingdom, or for the spiritual good of your neighbors. If your heart is truly full of love, it will find a way out. You will find, or create, enough avenues to express that love in action. When a spring is full of water, it sends out streams. Remember that just as love is the central principle in the heart of a genuine Christian, the labor of love is the central business of the Christian life. Let every Christian take these things to heart; and may the Lord give you understanding in all things, make you aware of what kind of spirit you should have, and move you toward the excellent, winsome, and generous life that such a spirit produces, so that you may not love only "in word and tongue, but in deed and in truth."
CHAPTER 2
LECTURE 2. LOVE IS GREATER THAN THE EXTRAORDINARY GIFTS OF THE SPIRIT
"Though I speak with the tongues of men and of angels, and have not charity, I am become as sounding brass, or a tinkling cymbal. And though I have the gift of prophecy, and understand all mysteries, and all knowledge; and though I have all faith, so that I could remove mountains, and have not charity, I am nothing." (1 Cor 13:1-2)
In the previous lecture, I argued that all the virtue found in the saints that is both distinctive and saving can be summed up in Christian love. Now I want to examine what Paul places alongside love in this passage, and which of the two he considers greater.
The things being compared in this text fall into two categories. On one side, there are the extraordinary and miraculous gifts of the Spirit, such as the gift of tongues and the gift of prophecy, which were common in that era and especially prominent in the church at Corinth. On the other side, there is the fruit of the Spirit's ordinary work in the lives of true Christians, namely charity, or divine love.
That was an age of miracles. In the old days among the Jews, only two or three people, or at most a very small number in the entire nation, had the gift of prophecy. But now it seemed as though Moses's wish, recorded in Num 11:29, had been largely fulfilled: "Would to God all the Lord's people were prophets!" Not only a select few of great standing were endowed with such gifts; they were common to all kinds of people, old and young, men and women alike, just as the prophet Joel had foretold when he preached about those days: "And it shall come to pass in the last days (saith God), I will pour out of my Spirit upon all flesh: and your sons and your daughters shall prophesy, and your young men shall see visions, and your old men shall dream dreams: and on my servants, and on my handmaidens, I will pour out in those days of my Spirit; and they shall prophesy." The church at Corinth was especially remarkable for such gifts. As this epistle makes clear, every kind of miraculous gift was bestowed on that church, and the number of people who enjoyed them was not small. "To one," the apostle writes, "is given by the Spirit the word of wisdom; to another the word of knowledge by the same Spirit; to another faith by the same Spirit; to another the gifts of healing by the same Spirit; to another the working of miracles; to another prophecy; . . . but all these worketh that one and the self-same Spirit, dividing to every man severally as he will." So some had one gift, and some had another. "But," the apostle continues, "covet earnestly the best gifts; and yet shew I unto you a more excellent way," that is, something more excellent than all these gifts combined, something so vital that all these gifts without it amount to nothing. For "though I speak with the tongues of men," as they did on the day of Pentecost, yes, "and of angels" too, "and have not charity, I am become" an empty and worthless thing, "as sounding brass, or a tinkling cymbal. And though I have" not just one but all the extraordinary gifts of the Spirit, and can not only speak with tongues but have "the gift of prophecy, and understand all mysteries, and all knowledge," seeing into the deepest things of God by immediate inspiration; "and though I have all faith" to work every kind of miracle, even "so that I could remove mountains, and have not charity, I am nothing." Charity, then, which is the fruit of the Spirit's ordinary sanctifying work, is held up as more excellent than any, indeed than all, of the Spirit's extraordinary gifts. It is Christian love, which, as we have seen, is the sum of all saving grace. So completely is it preferred that all the extraordinary gifts of the Spirit, without it, are nothing and can profit nothing. The doctrine being taught, then, is this: THE ORDINARY INFLUENCE OF THE SPIRIT OF GOD, WORKING THE GRACE OF CHARITY IN THE HEART, IS A MORE EXCELLENT BLESSING THAN ANY OF THE EXTRAORDINARY GIFTS OF THE SPIRIT. In what follows, I will attempt to show, first, what is meant by the ordinary and extraordinary gifts of the Spirit; secondly, that the extraordinary gifts of the Spirit are indeed great privileges; and yet, thirdly, that the ordinary influence of the Spirit, working the grace of charity or love in the heart, is a more excellent blessing still.
I. I would briefly explain what is meant by the ordinary and extraordinary gifts of the Spirit; for theologians have traditionally distinguished the gifts and operations of the Holy Spirit into two pairs of categories: common and saving, and ordinary and extraordinary.
1. The gifts and operations of the Holy Spirit are distinguished into those that are common and those that are saving. Common gifts of the Spirit are those shared by both the godly and the ungodly alike. The Spirit of God influences the minds of unregenerate people in certain ways, just as He influences the minds of believers. For example, there are common convictions of sin, that is, convictions that ungodly people can experience just as much as the godly can. Similarly, there are common illuminations or enlightenments that belong to both groups. There are also common religious affections, common gratitude, common sorrow, and the like. But other gifts of the Spirit belong exclusively to the godly: saving faith, love, and all the other saving graces that the Spirit imparts.
2. Ordinary and extraordinary: The extraordinary gifts of the Spirit, such as the gift of tongues, miracles, and prophecy, are called extraordinary precisely because they are not granted in every age. By contrast, the ordinary gifts are those the Spirit gives in conviction and conversion, along with those that belong to building up the saints in holiness and comfort.
It's worth noting, then, that the distinction between ordinary and extraordinary gifts of the Spirit is quite different from the distinction between common and special gifts. Some ordinary gifts, such as faith, hope, and charity, are not common gifts. They are gifts that God ordinarily bestows on His Church in every age, but they are not shared by the godly and the ungodly alike; they belong exclusively to the godly. Extraordinary gifts of the Spirit, on the other hand, are common gifts. The gifts of tongues, miracles, prophecy, and so on are not ordinarily given to the Christian Church, but only on exceptional occasions; yet they are not exclusive to the godly, since many ungodly people have possessed these gifts: "Many will say to me in that day, Lord, have we not prophesied in thy name? and in thy name cast out devils? and in thy name done many wonderful works? and then will I profess unto them, I never knew you: depart from me, ye that work iniquity" (Matt 7:22-23). Having clarified these terms, I will now go on to show:
II. That the extraordinary gifts of the Spirit of God are indeed great privileges.; When God endows someone with a spirit of prophecy, favors him with direct inspiration, or grants him power to work miracles, heal the sick, cast out demons, and the like, the privilege is immense. In fact, this ranks among the highest privileges God ever bestows on human beings, second only to saving grace. It is a great privilege to live within reach of the outward means of grace and to belong to the visible Church, but to be a prophet and a worker of miracles within that Church is a far greater privilege still. It is a great privilege to hear the word spoken by prophets and inspired persons, but a far greater one to be a prophet yourself, to preach the word, to be moved by God to make His mind and will known to others. Consider what God bestowed on Moses when He called him to be a prophet and used him as the instrument through whom the law was revealed to the children of Israel, delivering to the Church so large a portion of the written word of God, including the very first written revelation ever given to it. God also used Moses as the instrument of so many wonders in Egypt, at the Red Sea, and in the wilderness. The privilege God gave David was equally remarkable, inspiring him and making him the author of so great and excellent a portion of Scripture, a gift that has served the Church in every age since. Great, too, was the privilege God gave to Elijah and Elisha, enabling them to perform such miraculous and extraordinary works. And the privilege given to the prophet Daniel was extraordinary in its own right, as God granted him so much of the Spirit's extraordinary gifts, particularly his remarkable understanding of divine visions. This brought Daniel great honor even among pagans, and even within the court of the king of Babylon. Nebuchadnezzar, that great, mighty, and proud monarch, so admired Daniel for these gifts that he was once on the verge of worshiping him as a god. He fell on his face before him and commanded that an offering and sweet incense be presented to him (Dan 2:46). As a result of these extraordinary gifts, Daniel was elevated above all the wise men, magicians, astrologers, and fortune-tellers of Babylon. Consider how the queen describes him to Belshazzar: "There is a man in your kingdom in whom is the spirit of the holy gods; and in the days of your father, light and understanding and wisdom like the wisdom of the gods was found in him; whom the king Nebuchadnezzar your father, the king, I say, your father, made master of the magicians, astrologers, Chaldeans, and soothsayers; because an excellent spirit, and knowledge, and understanding, interpreting of dreams, and explaining of hard sentences, and dissolving of doubts, were found in the same Daniel" (Dan 5:11-12). This same privilege also secured Daniel's honor in the Persian court: "It pleased Darius to set over the kingdom one hundred and twenty princes, who should be over the whole kingdom; and over these three presidents, of whom Daniel was first; that the princes might give accounts to them, and the king should have no damage. Then this Daniel was preferred above the presidents and princes, because an excellent spirit was in him; and the king thought to set him over the whole realm" (Dan 6:1-3). By this "excellent spirit," the text doubtless means, among other things, the spirit of prophecy and divine inspiration, for which Daniel had already been so honored by the princes of Babylon.
It was a remarkable privilege that Christ bestowed on the apostles by filling them with the extraordinary gifts of the Holy Spirit, inspiring them to teach all nations, and placing them as it were just below Himself, as the twelve precious stones considered the twelve foundations of the Church: "And the wall of the city had twelve foundations, and in them the names of the twelve apostles of the Lamb" (Rev 21:14).
"Built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Jesus Christ himself being the chief corner-stone" (Eph 2:20). And how greatly was the apostle John favored, when he was "in the Spirit on the Lord's day" and received those extraordinary visions representing the great events of God's providence toward the Church across every age, all the way to the end of the world.
Scripture consistently treats these extraordinary gifts of the Spirit as immense privileges. The same was true of the privilege God gave Moses in speaking to him through miraculous revelation, as it were "face to face." The same was true of the outpouring of the Spirit in His extraordinary gifts on the day of Pentecost, which the prophet Joel foretold and described as a great privilege in those well-known words: "And it shall come to pass afterward, that I will pour out my Spirit on all flesh" (Joel 2:28-29). And Christ Himself speaks of the gifts of miracles and tongues as great privileges He would grant to those who believe in Him (Matt 16:17-18).
Such extraordinary gifts of the Spirit have long been regarded as marks of exceptional honor. Moses and Aaron were envied in the camp precisely because of the special honor God placed on them (Ps 106:16). Similarly, Joshua was ready to envy Eldad and Medad simply because they prophesied in the camp (Num 11:27). And when angels themselves were sent to do the work of prophets, to reveal things to come, it placed them in a remarkably honorable light. Even the apostle John, in his astonishment, was on two separate occasions ready to fall down and worship the angel Christ had sent to reveal the future events of the Church to him; but the angel stopped him, acknowledging that the privilege of the spirit of prophecy he carried was not his own, but something he had received from Jesus Christ (Rev 19:10; 22:8-9). The pagans of Lystra were so stunned by the power that Barnabas and Paul had to work miracles that they were on the verge of offering sacrifices to them as gods (Acts 14:11-13). And Simon the sorcerer desperately craved the gift the apostles possessed of conferring the Holy Spirit through the laying on of hands, going so far as to offer them money for it.
These extraordinary gifts are a remarkable privilege, in that they reflect a conformity to Christ in His prophetical office. The greatness of this privilege is further evident in the fact that, while such gifts have occasionally been given to unregenerate men, this has been exceedingly rare. As a rule, those who received them were saints, and often the most eminent saints at that. This was true on the day of Pentecost, and it was true in earlier ages as well: "Holy men of God spoke as they were moved by the Holy Spirit" (2 Pet 1:21). These gifts were typically bestowed as tokens of God's extraordinary favor and love, as was the case with Daniel. He was a man greatly beloved, and it was precisely for this reason that he was granted the remarkable privilege of receiving divine revelations (Dan 9:23; 10:11-19). Similarly, the apostle John, as the disciple whom Jesus loved, was chosen above all the other apostles to receive the great prophetic visions recorded in the book of Revelation. I come now to the third point: III. To show that, though these are great privileges, the ordinary work of the Spirit of God producing the grace of charity in the heart is a far more excellent privilege than any of them: a greater blessing than the Spirit of prophecy, or the gift of tongues, or of miracles, even to the removing of mountains; a greater blessing than all the miraculous gifts with which Moses, Elijah, David, and the twelve apostles were endowed. This will become clear when we consider the following. 1. This blessing of saving grace is a quality inherent in the very nature of the one who possesses it. The gift of the Spirit working a truly Christian character in the soul, and stirring up gracious exercises there, confers a blessing that has its seat in the heart itself, a blessing that makes a person's inner nature excellent. Indeed, that excellence consists precisely in this grace. The extraordinary gifts of the Spirit, by contrast, do not work this way. They are excellent things, but they are not properly the excellency of a person's nature, because they do not reside within the nature itself. Consider, for example, the gift of working miracles: this power is not anything inherent in the person who exercises it. It is not, properly speaking, a quality of the heart and nature of the man, the way that true grace and holiness are. And though those who have possessed the extraordinary gifts of prophecy, speaking in tongues, and working miracles have most commonly been holy persons, their holiness did not consist in the possession of those gifts. These extraordinary gifts are not properly inherent in the person at all. They are something added from outside. They are excellent things, but they are not excellencies of the person's own nature. They are like a beautiful garment, which does nothing to alter the nature of the one who wears it, or like precious jewels that adorn the body. True grace, by contrast, is that by which the very soul itself becomes, as it were, a precious jewel.
2. The Spirit of God communicates Himself far more fully in bestowing saving grace than in bestowing extraordinary gifts. In the extraordinary gifts of the Spirit, the Holy Spirit does produce effects in people, or through people, but not in a way that properly communicates Himself, in His own nature, to them. A person may receive an extraordinary impulse from the Spirit of God, through which some future event is revealed; or he may be given an extraordinary vision representing something yet to come. And yet, through either of these, the Spirit may not impart Himself at all in His holy nature. The Spirit of God can produce effects in things without communicating Himself to us through them. Consider how the Spirit of God moved over the face of the waters (Gen 1:2), yet did not impart Himself to the water in doing so. But when the Spirit, through His ordinary influences, bestows saving grace, He imparts Himself to the soul in His own holy nature, that nature on account of which He is so often called in Scripture the Holy Ghost, or the Holy Spirit. By producing this effect, the Spirit becomes an indwelling, life-giving principle within the soul, and the person becomes spiritual, being defined as such by the Spirit of God who dwells in him and whose nature he now shares. Grace is, in a real sense, the holy nature of the Spirit imparted to the soul. The extraordinary gifts of the Spirit, however, such as foreknowledge of future events or the power to work miracles, carry no such implication. This is not to say that God, when He grants extraordinary gifts, doesn't also typically grant the Spirit's sanctifying influences alongside them; but neither one necessarily implies the other. If God grants only extraordinary gifts, such as prophecy or miracles, those gifts alone will never make their recipient a true partaker of the Spirit, in the sense of becoming genuinely spiritual in his own nature.
3. That grace or holiness, which is the effect of the ordinary influence of the Spirit of God in the hearts of the saints, is that wherein the spiritual image of God consists; and not in these extraordinary gifts of the Spirit.; The spiritual image of God does not consist in the power to work miracles or foretell future events. It consists in being holy as God is holy: in having a holy and divine principle rooted in the heart, one that shapes us toward holy and heavenly lives. There is, admittedly, a kind of likeness to Christ in possessing the power to work miracles, since Christ held such power and performed miracles in abundance: "The works that I do shall he do also" (John 14:12). But the moral image and likeness of Christ consists far more in having the same mind in us which was in Christ; in sharing the same Spirit He possessed; in being meek and lowly of heart; in carrying a spirit of Christian love and walking as Christ walked. All of this makes a person more like Christ than any number of miracles ever could.
4. That grace which results from the Spirit's ordinary work is a privilege God reserves only for His own beloved children, while the extraordinary gifts of the Spirit are not restricted in this way. It has already been noted that while God has most often chosen saints, and even eminent saints, as the recipients of the Spirit's extraordinary gifts, He has not always done so. These gifts have sometimes been given to others and have appeared among both the godly and the ungodly alike. Balaam is condemned in Scripture as a wicked man (2 Pet 2:15; Jude 11; Rev 2:14), and yet he possessed the extraordinary gifts of the Spirit for a time. Saul was a wicked man, and yet we read more than once of his being among the prophets. Judas was one of those whom Christ sent out to preach and perform miracles, numbered among the twelve disciples of whom it is written: "And when he had called his twelve disciples to him, he gave them authority over unclean spirits, to cast them out, and to heal every kind of sickness and every kind of disease" (Matt 10:1). The following verses name each of them, and "Judas Iscariot, who also betrayed him" appears among the rest. Then in verse 8, Christ says to them, "Heal the sick, cleanse the lepers, raise the dead, cast out demons." The grace of God in the heart is a gift of the Holy Spirit that belongs exclusively to the saints; it is a blessing God reserves only for those who are the objects of His special and particular love. The extraordinary gifts of the Spirit, by contrast, are sometimes given to those whom God does not love but hates, and this is a sure sign that the one is infinitely more precious and excellent than the other. The most precious gift is the one that most clearly evidences God's love. But the extraordinary gifts of the Spirit, in the age of inspiration and miracles, were no reliable sign of God's love at all. The prophets did not typically ground their confidence in God's favor on the fact that they were prophets who received revelations; they grounded it on the fact that they were sincere saints. This was true of David (see Pss 15:1-5; 17:1-3; 119 throughout), and indeed the entire book of Psalms bears witness to this pattern. Similarly, the apostle Paul, though he was so richly privileged with the extraordinary gifts of the Spirit, was so far from treating those gifts as evidence of his standing before God that he explicitly declares that without love, all such gifts amount to nothing.
5. From the fruit and consequence of these two different things, we can see that the one is infinitely more excellent than the other. Eternal life is, by the promises of the gospel, consistently connected with the graces of the Spirit and never with the extraordinary gifts alone. Salvation is promised to those who possess the Spirit's graces, not to those who merely possess His extraordinary gifts. Many may have the latter and still go to hell. Judas Iscariot had them and is in hell. Christ tells us that many who possessed such gifts will, on the last day, be told to depart as workers of iniquity (Matt 7:22-23). And so, when He promised His disciples these extraordinary gifts, He told them to rejoice not because the demons were subject to them, but because their names were written in heaven, making clear that the one could be true without the other (Luke 10:17ff.). This demonstrates that the graces of the Spirit constitute an infinitely greater blessing than the extraordinary gifts, because those graces carry eternal life within them. Eternal life is of infinite worth and value, and any blessing that is inseparably connected to it must be excellent indeed, far surpassing any privilege a person might possess while still, in the end, going to hell.
6. Happiness itself is far more directly and essentially rooted in Christian grace, produced by the Spirit's ordinary work, than in any extraordinary gifts. A person's deepest happiness consists in holiness, because it is through holiness that a rational creature is united to God, the source of all good. Happiness is so fundamentally bound up with knowing, loving, and serving God, and with possessing a holy and Christlike disposition of soul along with its active expression in daily life, that these things alone can make a person genuinely happy; but no other pleasures or privileges, however great, can produce true happiness without them.
7. This divine disposition of soul, which is the fruit of the Spirit's ordinary sanctifying work, is the ultimate goal of all His extraordinary gifts. The gifts of prophecy, miracles, tongues, and the like were given by God for a specific purpose: to advance the spread and establishment of the gospel throughout the world. And the goal of the gospel itself is to turn people from darkness to light, and from the power of sin and Satan to the service of the living God, that is, to make people holy. The goal of all the Spirit's extraordinary gifts is the conversion of sinners and the building up of believers in that holiness which flows from His ordinary influences. For this reason, the Holy Spirit was poured out on the apostles after Christ's ascension, enabling them to speak in tongues, perform miracles, and more. For this same reason, many others in that era were given extraordinary gifts of the Holy Spirit. As Paul writes, "And he gave some, apostles; and some, prophets; and some, evangelists" (Eph 4:11). Here the extraordinary gifts of the Spirit are in view, and their purpose is stated in the very next words: "For the perfecting of the saints, for the work of the ministry, for the edifying of the body of Christ." What kind of edifying this is becomes clear in verse 16: "Maketh increase of the body unto the edifying of itself in love," that is, in charity, the same virtue spoken of in our text, since the original word is identical and the meaning is the same. This aligns perfectly with 1 Cor 8:1: "charity edifieth."
But the end is always more excellent than the means. This is a universally accepted principle, since means have no goodness in themselves except insofar as they serve the end. The end, therefore, must be regarded as superior in excellence to the means.
8. The extraordinary gifts of the Spirit will do nothing to help those who lack the saving grace that comes from the Spirit's ordinary work; in fact, those gifts will only deepen the condemnation of those who possess them. There is no question that Judas's condemnation was made far worse by the extraordinary privileges he had enjoyed. Some who received such gifts went on to commit the sin against the Holy Spirit, and their very privileges were what made that sin unforgivable, as we see in Heb 6:4-6: "For it is impossible for those who were once enlightened, and have tasted of the heavenly gift, and were made partakers of the Holy Ghost, and have tasted the good word of God, and the powers of the world to come, if they shall fall away, to renew them again unto repentance: seeing they crucify to themselves the Son of God afresh, and put him to an open shame." Those who fell away were people who had publicly professed Christianity and then abandoned it entirely, having already received the extraordinary gifts of the Holy Spirit, as most Christians did in that era. They had been thoroughly instructed in the faith, and through the Spirit's common influence they had received the word with joy, like those described in Matt 13:20. On top of that, they had received the Spirit's extraordinary gifts as well: they were "made partakers of the Holy Ghost, tasted of the heavenly gift, and the powers of the world to come." They spoke in tongues, prophesied in Christ's name, and cast out demons in His name. And yet, after all of this, they openly renounced Christianity, joined in calling Christ an impostor just as His murderers had done, and so "crucified to themselves the Son of God afresh, and put him to an open shame." It is of these people that the apostle says, "It is impossible to renew them again to repentance." In renouncing Christianity, such apostates were forced to attribute the miraculous powers they had personally exercised to the devil. Their case therefore became hopeless, and their condemnation was made incomparably worse. From this it is clear that saving grace is of infinitely greater worth and excellence than any extraordinary gift of the Spirit. And finally, 9. Another reason why the saving grace that flows from the Spirit's ordinary work is superior to the extraordinary gifts is simply this: one will pass away, and the other will not. This is precisely the argument the apostle uses in the surrounding passage to show that divine love surpasses the extraordinary gifts of the Spirit (v. 8): "Charity never faileth: but whether there be prophecies, they shall fail; whether there be tongues, they shall cease; whether there be knowledge, it shall vanish away." Divine love will endure throughout all eternity, while the extraordinary gifts of the Spirit will eventually come to an end. They are by nature only means to an end, and once that end is achieved, they will cease; but divine love will remain forever. In drawing out the implications of this subject, I offer the following observations: (1.) If saving grace is a greater blessing than the extraordinary gifts of the Spirit, we can reasonably conclude from this that it is the greatest privilege and blessing God ever bestows on any person in this life. The extraordinary gifts of the Holy Spirit, such as the gifts of tongues, miracles, and prophecy, represent the highest order of privileges God ever grants to natural men, and they have been given to such people only rarely in any period of history, the apostolic age being the one notable exception.
If you take seriously what has been said, one conclusion becomes impossible to avoid: the saving grace of God working in the human heart, shaping the soul into a holy and Christlike character, is the greatest blessing any person can receive in this life. It surpasses every natural gift, every remarkable inborn ability, every skill and knowledge acquired through years of effort, and every form of worldly learning. It exceeds all outward wealth and status, all political power, all royal dignity. It is greater than being lifted from a shepherd's field, as David was, and crowned king over all Israel. And all the riches, splendor, and magnificence of Solomon in the height of his glory cannot begin to compare with it.
God granted the blessed Virgin Mary an extraordinary privilege: that the Son of God would be born from her. Consider what this meant. The one conceived in her womb and nursed at her breasts was infinitely more honorable than the angels, the Creator and King of heaven and earth, the great Sovereign of the world. To be His mother surpassed even the privilege of bearing the child of the greatest earthly king who ever lived. And yet, remarkable as that honor was, it did not equal the privilege of having the grace of God in the heart, of having Christ born in the soul. Jesus Himself teaches this plainly: "And it came to pass, as he spake these things, a certain woman of the company lifted up her voice, and said unto him, Blessed is the womb that bare thee, and the paps which thou hast sucked. But he said, Yea, rather blessed are they that hear the word of God, and keep it" (Luke 11:27-28). On another occasion, when someone told Him that His mother and brothers were waiting outside and wanted to speak with Him, He used the moment to make a deeper point: that there is a more blessed way of being connected to Him than a merely physical family bond. "Who is my mother?" He asked, "and who are my brethren? And he stretched forth his hand toward his disciples, and said, Behold my mother and my brethren! For whosoever shall do the will of my Father which is in heaven, the same is my brother, and sister, and mother" (Matt 12:46-50).
(2.) Hence, these two kinds of privileges must not be confused by mistaking things that merely resemble extraordinary miraculous gifts of the Spirit for certain signs of grace. If someone at some point experiences an unusual impression on their mind, which they believe is God revealing something about the future, this, if genuine, would indicate an extraordinary gift of the Holy Spirit, namely the gift of prophecy. But based on what has already been said, it would clearly not be a reliable sign of grace or of anything spiritually saving, even if it were genuine. In fact, we have no good reason to regard such claims, when made in our own day, as anything other than delusion. Nor does it change the situation when such impressions come through a Bible verse suddenly surfacing in the mind, because a verse coming to mind proves no more than simply reading that verse would prove. If reading a passage of Scripture at any given moment does not establish a particular conclusion, then that same passage coming suddenly to mind does not establish it either, since Scripture says the same thing at one time as it does at another. The words carry the same meaning when read in the normal course of reading as they do when they flash unexpectedly into thought. Anyone who draws further conclusions from the manner in which the words arrived is proceeding without any warrant, because the sudden arrival of a verse does not give it a new meaning it never had before. So if someone concludes that he is in a good spiritual condition because a particular verse came suddenly to his mind, but that verse would not have proven such a thing had he simply read it in the ordinary course of reading, then the mere fact of its coming to mind gives him no real evidence of his spiritual standing. Similarly, if something appears to a person as though he has seen a visible form or heard a voice, such experiences should not be taken as signs of grace. Even if they are real and from God, they are not themselves grace, because the extraordinary work of the Spirit producing visions and dreams, such as the ancient prophets experienced, is no reliable sign of saving grace. All the fruits of the Spirit that we should treat as genuine evidence of grace are summed up in charity, or Christian love, because love is the sum of all grace. The only way, therefore, that anyone can know their true spiritual condition is by recognizing the activity of this divine love within their own heart, because without love, whatever gifts a person may possess, they amount to nothing.
(3.) If saving grace is more excellent than the extraordinary gifts of the Spirit, then we cannot conclude, from what Scripture says about the glory of the latter times of the Church, that the extraordinary gifts of the Spirit will be granted to people in those times. Many have been quick to assume that during those glorious days of the Church that will follow the calling of the Jews and the fall of Antichrist, many people will be inspired and given the power to work miracles. But what Scripture says about the glory of those times proves no such thing, nor does it make it particularly likely. It has already been shown that the pouring out of God's Spirit in His ordinary, saving work, filling human hearts with a Christian and holy character and drawing people into the practice of the divine life, is the most glorious way the Spirit can be poured out. It is more glorious, far more glorious, than any outpouring of miraculous gifts. The glory of those future days in the Church, therefore, doesn't require anything like those extraordinary gifts. Those times may be the most glorious the Church has ever known without them. The absence of prophecy, tongues, healing, and similar gifts from the apostolic age won't prevent those days from surpassing even that era in glory, provided the Spirit is poured out in greater measure through His sanctifying work. As the apostle explicitly states, this is a more excellent way (1 Cor 12:31). This kind of glory is the greatest glory the Church of Christ possesses, and the greatest glory Christ's Church will ever enjoy in any period of history. It is what will make the Church more like the Church in heaven, where love reigns perfectly, than any number or degree of extraordinary spiritual gifts ever could. We have no reason, then, to expect that the extraordinary gifts of the Spirit will be poured out in those glorious days still to come. No new arrangement is being introduced in those times, and no new Bible will be given. Nor do we have any reason to expect that our present Scriptures will be added to or expanded. If anything, the closing words of the sacred writings we now have seem to suggest that no addition will be made until Christ returns (Rev 22:18-21).
4. What cause have they to bless God, and to live to His glory, who have received such a privilege as is implied in the influence of the Holy Spirit working saving grace in the heart.; If we take seriously the condition of the godly, those who have experienced this extraordinary blessing, we cannot help but stand in awe of the grace poured out on them. And the more carefully we consider it, the more astonishing and beyond words it becomes. When we read in Scripture about the great privileges given to the Virgin Mary, or to the apostle Paul when he was caught up into the third heaven, we naturally marvel at such gifts. But remarkable as those privileges were, they are nothing compared to the privilege of being made like Christ and having His love dwelling in the heart. Those who hope they have received this blessing should reflect, more deeply than they ever have before, on how extraordinary a gift God has given them, and on how greatly they are obligated to glorify Him for the work He has done within them, to glorify Christ who purchased this blessing with His own blood, and to glorify the Holy Spirit who has sealed it to their souls. What kind of people should those who have received such grace be, in all their conduct and devotion to God? Consider, you who hope in God's mercy, how greatly He has lifted you up; will you not then be diligent to live for Him? Will you dishonor Christ by giving Him so little of your heart, chasing after the world instead, neglecting Him, His service, and His glory? Will you not stand guard against your own corrupt, worldly, and proud tendencies, which would draw you away from the God who has been so gracious to you and from the Savior who purchased such blessings at the cost of His own suffering and death? Will you not make it your daily, earnest question: "What shall I render to the Lord for all His benefits toward me?" (Ps 116:12). What more could God possibly have done for you? What greater privilege could He have given, one more worthy of drawing your heart into gratitude? And consider honestly how you are living: how little you have done for Him, how much you do for yourself, how little this divine love has actually moved your heart toward living for God and Christ and the advance of His kingdom. Those who have received such high privileges should make them visible through the active exercise of love: love toward God expressed in obedience, submission, reverence, joy, and hope; and love toward your neighbor expressed in gentleness, sympathy, humility, generosity, and doing good to all as you have the opportunity.
Finally, (5.) The subject calls all those who have not yet been renewed, those who are strangers to this grace, to seek this most excellent blessing for themselves. Consider how miserable your present condition is while you remain entirely without this love, far from righteousness, captivated by the vanities of the world, and full of hostility toward God. How will you endure when He deals with you according to what you truly are, coming against you in anger as your enemy and pouring out His fierce wrath upon you? Consider also that you are capable of receiving this love; Christ is both able and willing to give it, and countless people have received it and been transformed by it. God is actively seeking your love, and you are under an immeasurable obligation to give it. The Spirit of God has been poured out in remarkable ways here. Multitudes have been converted. Scarcely a family has been passed over. In nearly every household, some have been made nobles, kings, and priests to God, sons and daughters of the Lord Almighty. What kind of people, then, should all of us be: how holy, serious, just, humble, generous, devoted in God's service, and faithful to our fellow human beings! God has richly blessed us both as individuals and as a people, and it is fitting that we should be, in both capacities, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, a people set apart, showing forth the praises of Him who has called us out of darkness into His marvelous light. "Now consider this, you who forget God, lest I tear you in pieces, and there be none to deliver. Whoever offers praise glorifies me, and to him who orders his conduct rightly I will show the salvation of God" (Ps 50:22-23).
CHAPTER 3
LECTURE 3. THE GREATEST ACHIEVEMENTS OR SUFFERINGS ARE WORTHLESS WITHOUT LOVE
"Though I bestow all my goods to feed the poor, and though I give my body to be burned, and have not charity, it profiteth me nothing." (1 Cor 13:3)
In the previous verses of this chapter, we have seen how the necessity and excellence of charity are established by placing it above the greatest spiritual privileges, and by showing how utterly worthless those privileges become without it. The privileges mentioned there are the extraordinary gifts of the Holy Spirit. In this verse, Paul turns to something different: the moral dimension of the Christian life. He declares that even our greatest moral achievements count for nothing without charity. Specifically, consider first that our performances are worthless without it. The example Paul chooses is one of the highest forms of external religious action: giving away everything we own to feed the poor. Generosity toward the poor is one of the most consistently emphasized duties in Scripture, and especially so under the Christian faith. In the early days of the church, circumstances sometimes called believers to give up literally everything they had. This was partly because of the desperate needs of those who were being persecuted and driven into poverty, and partly because following Christ and doing the work of the gospel demanded that disciples free themselves from the weight of worldly possessions, going out, as it were, without money in their pockets, without a travel bag, or even a spare coat. The apostle Paul tells us that he had suffered the loss of everything for Christ's sake, and the early Christians in Jerusalem sold all they had, pooled the proceeds into a common fund, and "none said that aught that he had was his own" (Acts 4:32). The duty of giving to the poor was especially pressing for the Corinthian Christians at this particular moment, not only because of the widespread troubles of the era, but also because of a severe famine that was causing acute suffering among the believers in Judea. In response to that crisis, Paul had already urged the Corinthians to send relief, addressing the matter directly in this very letter (1 Cor 16) and again at length in his second letter to the same church (2 Cor 8-9). And yet, for all the energy he pours into motivating them toward generosity in both letters, he is equally careful to make clear that no matter how far they go in giving, even if they were to give away every last possession to feed the poor, it would profit them nothing if they did not have charity.
Secondly, the apostle teaches that not only our actions, but also our sufferings count for nothing without charity. People are quick to take pride in what they do, but even quicker to take pride in what they endure. They tend to think it a great thing when they inconvenience themselves, spend lavishly, or suffer for their faith. Here the apostle points to suffering of the most extreme kind: suffering unto death, and one of the most terrible forms of death imaginable, and he says that even this amounts to nothing without charity. When a man has given away everything he owns, he has nothing left to offer but himself. And the apostle teaches that when a man has surrendered all his possessions and then goes further, giving his own body to be utterly consumed in flames, it will profit him nothing if it does not flow from sincere love in the heart. When Paul wrote to the Corinthians, Christians were frequently called to surrender not only their property but their very lives for Christ's sake, since the church was broadly under persecution, and multitudes were then, or soon after, put to death in the cruelest ways for the sake of the gospel. Yet even if they suffered throughout their lives or endured the most agonizing death, it would all be in vain without charity. What this charity actually means has already been explained in the earlier lectures on these verses, where it was shown that charity is the sum of everything that is distinctive about true religion of the heart. The doctrine I draw from these words, then, is this: THAT ALL A MAN CAN DO, AND ALL HE CAN SUFFER, CAN NEVER COMPENSATE FOR THE ABSENCE OF SINCERE CHRISTIAN LOVE IN THE HEART.
I. There may be great performances, and so there may be great sufferings, without sincere Christian love in the heart. And, 1. There may be great performances without it. In the third chapter of his letter to the Philippians, the apostle Paul describes what he accomplished before his conversion, while he was still a Pharisee. In verse 4, he says, "If any other man thinks he has reason to trust in his own achievements, I have more." Many of the Pharisees did impressive things and were prolific in their religious observances. The Pharisee mentioned in Luke 18:11-12 boasted about everything he had done, both toward God and toward other people, and thanked God that he surpassed other men in his conduct. Many people among the pagans were also notable for their achievements: some for their integrity or their sense of justice, others for great deeds done for the public good. Many men, with no genuine love in their hearts, have been extraordinarily generous in their gifts to religious and charitable causes, earning themselves great fame and securing a glorious place in the historical record. Many have done great things out of fear of hell, hoping to appease God and make up for their sins, and many have done great things out of pride and a desire for reputation and honor. And while these motivations don't typically drive people toward a consistent and comprehensive obedience to God's commands, or sustain a life of Christian practice and faithful duty toward God and others, it's difficult to say just how far such natural impulses can carry a person in specific acts of devotion. And so, 2. There may be great sufferings endured for religion, and yet no genuine love in the heart. People may undergo tremendous hardship in life, just as some of the Pharisees subjected themselves to severe austerities, penances, and self-inflicted pain. Many have undertaken exhausting pilgrimages, cut themselves off from the comforts and pleasures of human society, or spent their lives in deserts and solitudes. Some have even suffered death, though we have no reason to think they had any sincere love for God in their hearts. Countless Catholics have voluntarily gone to war, risking their lives in bloody conflicts, hoping to earn heaven by doing so. In the wars fought against the Turks and Saracens, known as the Holy Wars or Crusades, thousands willingly faced every danger of battle in the hope of securing the forgiveness of their sins and the rewards of glory in the life to come. Many thousands, even millions, lost their lives in this way, draining the population of large parts of Europe to a considerable degree. Many of the Turks, for their part, were so inflamed by this that they threw themselves recklessly at the very swords of their enemies, because Muhammad had promised that all who die in war defending the Muslim faith would go immediately to Paradise. History also tells us of some who chose death out of sheer stubbornness and defiance rather than yield to the demands of others, even when they could have saved their lives without any loss of honor. Many among the pagans died for their country, and many died as martyrs for a false faith, though not nearly in the same numbers or in the same manner as those who died as martyrs for the true religion. In all these cases, many doubtless endured their sufferings or faced death without any sincere love for God in their hearts.
But, II. Whatever men may do or suffer, they cannot, by all their performances and sufferings, make up for the absence of sincere love in the heart. A person may pour himself into religious activity and be deeply engaged in acts of justice, kindness, and devotion. His prayers and fasts may multiply without end. He may spend his days and nights in the forms of religious worship, denying himself sleep so that he can be more diligent in spiritual exercises. His deeds may earn him a name throughout the world and make him famous to every future generation. Yet all of it would be worthless without sincere love for God in the heart. And if a man were to give most generously to religious or charitable causes, and if, possessing the wealth of an entire kingdom, he were to give it all away, reducing himself from the splendor of an earthly prince to the level of a beggar, and if he were not to stop there but, having done all this, were to yield himself to the most brutal suffering, surrendering not only all his possessions but also his body to be clothed in rags, mangled, burned, and tormented to the furthest limits of human cruelty, all of it, even all of this, would not compensate for the absence of sincere love for God in the heart. And it is clear that it would not, for the following reasons:
1. It is not the external work done, or the suffering endured, that is, in itself, worth anything in the sight of God. The physical movements of the body, or anything the body might do, considered apart from the heart, the inward core of a person, carries no more weight before God than the movements of a lifeless machine. If something is offered or given, whether silver or gold, cattle on a thousand hills, a thousand rams, or ten thousand rivers of oil, none of it has any value as a mere external thing in God's sight. If God actually needed these things, they might hold some value to Him considered on their own terms, apart from the motives of the heart that prompted the offering. We often need external goods ourselves, and so things offered or given to us can carry real value simply by virtue of what they are. But God needs nothing. He is entirely self-sufficient. He is not fed by animal sacrifices, nor made richer by gifts of silver, gold, or pearls: "Every beast of the forest is mine, and the cattle on a thousand hills. If I were hungry, I would not tell you, for the world is mine, and everything in it" (Ps 50:10, 12). "All things come from you, and of your own we have given you. O Lord our God, all this abundance that we have provided for building you a house for your holy name comes from your hand and is all your own" (1 Chr 29:14, 16). And just as none of our service or performance profits God in any way, nothing we do externally can be acceptable in His sight without sincere love in the heart, "for the Lord does not see as people see; people look at the outward appearance, but God looks at the heart." The heart lies just as open and exposed before Him as our outward actions do. He therefore sees everything we do, all our conduct, not merely as the mechanical motions of a machine, but as the actions of rational, intelligent creatures who choose freely, and so in His estimation nothing we do can possess any excellence or beauty if the heart behind it is not right with Him.
God takes no pleasure in our suffering for its own sake. He gains nothing from human torment, and He takes no delight in watching people inflict hardship on themselves, unless that suffering flows from a worthy motive or serves a genuine purpose. There are times when we need our fellow human beings, our friends and neighbors, to suffer on our behalf, to help carry our burdens and put themselves out for our sake. But God has no such need of us. Our sufferings, considered simply as sufferings, are not acceptable to Him; they carry no weight apart from the motive behind them. Whatever a person may do or endure, neither actions nor afflictions can compensate for the absence of love for God in the soul. They profit God nothing, and they hold no beauty in His sight on their own terms. They can never substitute for that love toward God and love toward others which is the sum of everything God requires from His moral creatures.
2. Whatever is done or suffered, yet if the heart is withheld from God, there is nothing really given to him.; In everything a person does or endures, their action is understood not as the output of a lifeless machine, but as the act of a thinking, willing, morally responsible being. A machine, after all, cannot truly give anything. If some mechanism driven by springs or counterweights places an object before us, we wouldn't say it gave us anything. Harps, cymbals, and other musical instruments were used in ancient times to praise God in the temple and elsewhere. But those lifeless instruments could not be said to offer praise to God, because they had no thought, no understanding, no will, no heart to give meaning to their pleasant sounds. In the same way, even though a person possesses a heart, a mind, and a will, if he gives something to God without engaging his heart in the act, then no more has truly been given to God than what a musical instrument gives.
He who lacks sincerity in his heart has no genuine regard for God in anything he appears to give, in any of his religious performances, or in any suffering he endures. God is therefore not his ultimate purpose in what he does or gives. A gift goes to whoever the giver has made his ultimate end. If that end is only himself, then the gift is given only to himself and not to God. If his aim is his own honor, his own comfort, or worldly gain, then the offering is simply devoted to those things. A gift is an offering to whoever holds the giver's heart and for whom he truly intends it. It is the sincere aim of the heart that makes a gift real, and if that aim is not directed toward God, then nothing has truly been given to Him, regardless of what is performed or endured. It would therefore be deeply absurd to suppose that anything offered or given to God could compensate for the absence of love toward Him in the heart, because without that love, nothing is genuinely given at all. What appears to be a gift is nothing more than a mockery of the Most High. This becomes even clearer in a third consideration.
3. From the fact that this love or charity is the sum of everything God requires of us. It is absurd to think that anything could compensate for the absence of what constitutes the whole of what God requires. Charity, or love, is something rooted in the heart, and as we have seen, it is the very essence of everything that is saving and distinctive in Christian character. This is the love our Savior identifies as the summary of all that the two tables of the law demand, and which the apostle declares is the fulfilling of the law. How, then, can we compensate for its absence? By withholding it, we are in effect withholding the entire sum of what God requires. It would already be absurd to suppose we could make up for one required thing by offering another required thing, as if we could settle one debt by paying a different one. But it is even more absurd to suppose we can compensate for the whole debt without paying anything at all, while continuing to withhold everything that is owed. As for outward acts performed without the heart, God speaks of them as not being what He actually requires (Isa 1:12), and He insists that the heart itself must be given to Him before any outward offering can be accepted.
4. If we make a great show of respect and love to God in our outward actions while there is no sincerity in the heart, it is nothing but hypocrisy and practical lying to the Holy One. To pretend to such respect and love when it isn't genuinely felt is to act as though we believe we can deceive God. It is to do what Israel did in the desert after their deliverance from Egypt, when they are said to have "lied unto God with their mouth, and flattered him with their tongues" (Ps 78:36). But it is just as absurd to think we can compensate for the absence of sincere respect with flattery and guile as it is to think we can compensate for the absence of truth with falsehood and lies.
5. Whatever may be done or endured, if there is no sincerity in the heart, it is nothing more than an offering to some idol.
As noted earlier, nothing in the scenario described is truly offered to God, and it follows that whatever is offered goes to some other being, object, or end. Whatever that may be, Scripture calls it an idol. In all such offerings, something is effectively being worshipped, and whatever that something is, whether self, other people, or the world, it is allowed to usurp the place that belongs to God and to receive the devotion that should be His. How absurd, then, to imagine that we can make up for withholding from God what is rightfully His by offering something to our idol instead. It is as absurd as supposing that a wife can compensate for her lack of love toward her husband by giving the affection owed to him to a stranger, or that she can make up for her unfaithfulness by committing adultery.
In applying this subject, we should use it in three ways, the first being self-examination. If it is truly the case that everything we do or endure counts for nothing without sincere love for God in our hearts, then we must search ourselves honestly to determine whether that love is genuinely there. Many people profess religion and make a show of it, and some carry out many of its outward requirements, perhaps even believing they have done and suffered a great deal for God and His service. But the real question is whether the heart has been sincere throughout, and whether everything was done or endured out of genuine regard for God's glory. If we examine ourselves honestly, we will almost certainly find much hypocrisy. But is there any sincerity at all? God despises even the greatest acts when they lack sincerity, yet He accepts and delights in even small things when they flow from genuine love for Him. A cup of cold water given to a disciple in sincere love is worth more in God's sight than all one's possessions given to feed the poor, more than the wealth of an entire kingdom given away, or a body offered up in flames, all without love. And God accepts even a small measure of sincere love. Though there may be much imperfection, if there is any true sincerity in our love, that little will not be rejected simply because some hypocrisy is mixed in with it. It is worth noting here that sincerity has four essential qualities: truth, freedom, integrity, and purity.
The first is truth. This means that what appears in outward action must genuinely exist in the heart. Where there is real respect for God, the love that honors Him will be felt inwardly to the same degree that it is expressed outwardly in words and actions. This is what the fifty-first psalm means: "Behold, thou desirest truth in the inward parts" (Ps 51:6). In this sense, sincerity is presented throughout Scripture as the opposite of hypocrisy, and a sincere Christian is described as someone who truly is what he appears to be, "without guile" (John 1:47). Examine yourself on this point. If your outward actions carry the appearance of respect for God, ask whether that respect is only external or whether it is genuinely felt in your heart, because without real love you are nothing.
The second quality in the nature of sincerity is freedom. This is precisely why Christian obedience is called filial, the obedience of children: because it is willing and generous, not legal, slavish, or compelled, but performed from love and with genuine delight. God is chosen for His own sake, and holiness for its own sake and for God's sake. Christ is chosen and followed because He is loved, and religion is embraced because it is loved, and the soul rejoices in it, finding in its duties the highest happiness and delight. Examine yourself honestly on this point, asking whether this spirit is truly yours.
The third quality belonging to sincerity is integrity. The word itself implies wholeness, suggesting that where sincerity exists, God is sought and religion is chosen and embraced with the whole heart, and held to with the whole soul. Holiness is chosen without reservation. Every duty is embraced wholeheartedly, whether it concerns God or neighbor, whether it is easy or difficult, whether it involves small matters or great ones. There is a completeness and proportion to the character. The whole person is renewed. Body, soul, and spirit are sanctified entirely. Every part of the self is brought into obedience to Christ. All the seeds of holy dispositions are planted in the soul, and they will increasingly bear fruit in the performance of duty and for the glory of God.
The fourth quality belonging to sincerity is purity. The word "sincere" frequently carries the meaning of "pure," as in "As newborn babes, desire the sincere milk of the word, that ye may grow thereby" (1 Pet 2:2), meaning pure, unmixed, unadulterated. This quality shows itself in the contrast between virtue and sin. Sin is described as defilement, impurity, and uncleanness, while virtue is described as freedom from those things. The apostle compares sin to a corpse, which is among the most polluting things imaginable, while holiness is described as purity, holy pleasures as pure pleasures, and the saints in heaven as without spot before the throne of God. Ask yourself, then, whether this purity is yours, and whether in possessing it you find evidence that you sincerely love God.
2. This subject should also convince those who remain in an unregenerate state of how lost they truly are. If it is indeed the case that nothing you do or endure can compensate for the absence of a holy, sincere principle of love in your heart, then it follows that you remain in a ruined condition until God's regenerating grace renews a right spirit within you. Whatever you do, whatever you undergo and suffer, you cannot be freed from your wickedness without the converting grace of God. No matter how many prayers you offer, they will not make your condition any less miserable unless God, by His mighty power, sees fit to give you a new heart. No matter how much effort you put into religion, how much you deny yourself, or how much you do or endure, none of it will be enough without this. Therefore, whatever you have done, even if you can look back on countless prayers offered and long hours spent in reading and meditation, you have no reason to think that any of it has made atonement for your sins, or made your situation any less desperate, or left you as anything other than a wretched, lost, miserable, guilty, and ruined soul.
Unregenerate men would love nothing more than to find a substitute for genuine love and real grace in their hearts. Many pursue grand achievements to fill that void, while others are willing to endure great suffering. But none of it matters. Whatever they do or endure, it doesn't change who they are at their core; and if they build their hopes on such things, they are only deceiving themselves, chasing after wind. If this describes you, consider how miserable your life will be while you live without hope in the only true source of hope, and how miserable your death will be, when the face of death itself will expose the emptiness of everything you've accomplished. Consider how miserable you will be when you see Christ coming in judgment on the clouds of heaven. In that moment, you will be willing to do and suffer anything to be accepted by Him. But no amount of doing or suffering will help. Nothing you've done will atone for your sins, earn God's favor, or shield you from the overwhelming force of His wrath. Rest, then, on nothing you have done or suffered, nothing you can do or suffer; rest on Christ alone. Let your heart be filled with sincere love for Him, and then, on that final day, He will acknowledge you as His follower and His friend. The subject, 3. Exhorts all, earnestly to cherish sincere Christian love in their hearts. If this love is so absolutely necessary, then let it be the one great thing you pursue. Seek it with diligence and prayer, and seek it from God rather than from yourself. He alone can give it. It is something far beyond what human nature can produce on its own; for however impressive one's achievements or however great one's suffering, without sincere love they count for nothing. Such deeds and sufferings may indeed be required of us as followers of Christ, as part of faithful obedience; but we must not rest in them or imagine they carry any merit of their own. At best, they are outward evidence of a right spirit within, the overflow of a heart that has already been transformed. Be urged, then, to pursue this above all else: cherish sincere love, Christian charity, in your heart. You must have it, and nothing else will help your condition without it. Everything else will, in some measure, only deepen your condemnation and drive you to lower depths in a world of despair.
CHAPTER 4
LECTURE 4. LOVE IS PATIENT AND KIND
"Charity suffereth long, and is kind." (1 Cor 13:4)
In the verses leading up to this text, as we have already seen, the apostle lays out just how great and essential charity, or a spirit of Christian love, truly is within the Christian life: that it far surpasses any of the extraordinary gifts of the Spirit; that it exceeds all outward acts of devotion and sacrifice; and that it is, in short, the sum of everything that distinguishes genuine, saving Christianity. It is the very life and soul of all true religion, without which, even if we give everything we own to feed the poor and surrender our bodies to be burned, we amount to nothing. From there, the apostle moves naturally into his next concern: demonstrating the excellent nature of charity by describing its many beautiful and admirable fruits. In this text, two of those fruits are named: suffering long, which concerns the evil and injury we receive from others; and being kind, which concerns the good we are called to do for others. Focusing for now on the first of these, I want to show that CHARITY, OR A TRULY CHRISTIAN SPIRIT, WILL DISPOSE US TO BEAR MEEKLY THE EVIL WE RECEIVE FROM OTHERS, AND THE INJURIES THAT OTHERS MAY DO TO US.
Meekness is a central part of the Christian spirit. In that earnest and moving invitation recorded in the eleventh chapter of Matthew, where Christ calls all who are weary and burdened to come to Him for rest, He specifically mentions that He wants them to come and learn from Him, adding: "I am meek and lowly in heart." When meekness relates to injuries received from others, Scripture calls it long-suffering, and it appears repeatedly as an expression or fruit of the Christian spirit: "The fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, long-suffering" (Gal 5:22); "I therefore, the prisoner of the Lord, beseech you that you walk worthy of the calling to which you were called, with all lowliness and meekness, with long-suffering" (Eph 4:1-2); and "Put on therefore, as the elect of God, holy and beloved, hearts of mercy, kindness, humility, meekness, long-suffering; bearing with one another, and forgiving one another, if anyone has a complaint against another: even as Christ forgave you, so also do you" (Col 3:12-13).
In exploring this point more fully, I will: I. identify some of the various kinds of injuries we may receive from others; II. explain what it means to bear such injuries with meekness; and III. show how love, which is the heart of the Christian spirit, will incline us to do this. And, I. I will briefly identify some of the various kinds of injuries that we may or do receive from others. Some people harm others financially through unfairness and dishonesty in their dealings, whether by being fraudulent and deceitful, or at least by keeping others in the dark and exploiting their ignorance. Others cause harm by oppressing people, taking advantage of their desperate circumstances, or by proving faithless, failing to keep their promises and commitments. Some are careless and dismissive in work they've been hired to do by their neighbors, aiming at nothing more than the bare minimum their agreement requires, and making no real effort to use their time well in completing what they've taken on. Others cause harm by charging unreasonable prices, withholding what is rightfully owed, neglecting to pay their debts, or needlessly forcing their neighbors through trouble and difficulty just to collect what is due to them. Beyond all of these, there are countless other ways people wrong one another in their dealings, through a whole range of crooked and dishonest behavior that falls far short of treating others as they themselves would want to be treated, and by which they provoke, aggravate, and injure one another.
Some people harm others in their reputation by speaking ill of them behind their backs. No injury is more common, and no wrongdoing more frequent or contemptible, than this. Other forms of harm are widespread enough, but the damage done through this kind of malicious talk is simply incalculable. Some harm others by fabricating or spreading false reports, cruelly slandering them in the process. Others, without saying anything directly false, still manage to distort reality significantly, painting everything about their neighbors in the worst possible light, exaggerating their faults, and presenting them as far worse than they actually are, always speaking of them in an unfair and dishonest way. A great deal of harm is done among neighbors by this kind of uncharitable judgment, by placing the worst possible interpretation on one another's words and actions.
People can also cause serious harm to others simply through their thoughts, by harboring unjust contempt or a low opinion of them. Some people are deeply and persistently harmful to others through the contempt they carry for them in their hearts, and through their readiness to assume the worst. And because thoughts tend to find their way outward, a great deal of harm is done through words as well. The tongue is all too willing to serve as the instrument of the soul's worst thoughts and feelings, which is why Scripture calls it a scourge (Job 5:21) and compares it to the fangs of the most venomous serpents, whose bite is said to bring death (Ps 140:3).
Sometimes people harm others through the way they treat them and the harmful actions they take against them. Those who hold positions of authority sometimes treat the people under them in deeply damaging ways, behaving with arrogance, condescension, and outright tyranny. Conversely, those who are subject to authority sometimes harm those above them by withholding the respect and honor that their positions deserve. Some people harm others by indulging a profoundly selfish spirit, appearing to live entirely for themselves, with no apparent concern for their neighbor's welfare; all their scheming is directed toward advancing their own interests. Some carry themselves in ways that injure others through the expression of a haughty and proud spirit, as though they considered themselves superior to everyone around them and regarded no one else as worthy of notice. This attitude shows itself in their manner, their speech, their actions, and their generally presumptuous behavior, all of which leaves those around them feeling, quite rightly, that they have been wronged. Some people harm others through a deeply stubborn spirit, being so fiercely determined to have their own way that they will, whenever possible, bend everything to their own will, never adjusting course or yielding to anyone else's wishes. They close their eyes to whatever light or reasons others might offer, ignore everyone else's preferences entirely, and remain persistently and willfully self-directed. Some harm others through the approach they take in public affairs, acting not out of genuine concern for the common good but out of opposition to a particular faction or individual. The target of that opposition is thereby wronged and, more often than not, deeply provoked and embittered. Some injure others by nursing a malicious and wicked spirit toward them, whether or not any real grievance exists. It is far from uncommon for neighbors to dislike and even hate one another, harboring nothing resembling genuine affection in their hearts. Whether they admit it or not, they truly hate each other, taking no pleasure in one another's honor or success and, on the contrary, feeling a quiet satisfaction when the other suffers misfortune. They foolishly and wickedly imagine, perhaps, that another person's fall is somehow their own rise, which it never is. Some harm others through the envy they display toward them, nursing ill will for no reason other than the honor and prosperity that person enjoys.
Many people harm others out of a spirit of revenge, deliberately returning evil for real or imagined wrongs done to them. Some will carry a grudge in their hearts against a neighbor for their entire lives, and whenever the opportunity arises, they will act on it by causing harm out of sheer malice. There are countless other specific ways in which people injure one another, though these examples are sufficient for our present purpose. But, II. I would go on to show what it means to bear such injuries with meekness, and how they ought to be borne.; Here I will address, first, the nature of the duty itself, and then why it is called long-suffering, or suffering long. And, 1. I would show the nature of the duty of meekly bearing the injuries we suffer from others. And, First, it means that injuries should be borne without taking any action to avenge them. There are many ways in which a person acts revengefully, not only by directly causing suffering to the one who has wronged them, but also through anything said or done that reveals a bitter spirit toward that person. So if, after being offended or injured, we speak contemptuously to our neighbor, or about him to others, with the intention of diminishing or harming him in order to satisfy the bitterness we feel over what he has done to us, that is revenge. The person who exercises genuine Christian long-suffering toward a neighbor will bear the injuries received without retaliating, whether through harmful actions or bitter words. He will bear it without doing anything that reveals a spirit of resentment, without speaking to his neighbor or about him with vindictive words, and without harboring a vengeful spirit in his heart or expressing it in his behavior. He will receive everything with a calm, undisturbed manner and with a soul full of meekness, quietness, and goodness, and this will show in all his dealings with the one who has wronged him, whether face to face or behind his back. This is why Scripture commends this virtue under the name of gentleness, or as something always connected with it, as we see in "the wisdom from above is first pure, then peaceable, gentle" (Jas 3:17) and "the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, patience, kindness" (Gal 5:22). In the person who truly exercises the Christian spirit, there will be no passionate, rash, or hasty words, no bitter or hardened expression, no air of hostility in speech or conduct. On the contrary, the face, the words, and the whole manner will reflect the quality of peaceableness, calm, and gentleness. He may, of course, rebuke his neighbor. That may clearly be his duty. But if he does, it will be without rudeness and without the kind of harshness that only inflames the situation. Though his rebuke may carry the weight of sound reasoning and plain, direct appeal, it will still be free of angry accusations or contemptuous language. He may show that he disapproves of what has been done, but not with an air of high indignation. Rather, he will reprove the offender as someone who has sinned against God, not merely as someone who has wronged him personally. He will grieve over the offender's condition more than he resents the injury done to himself. He will seek the offender's good, not his harm, and will be more concerned with rescuing him from the error he has fallen into than with settling the score. The duty also implies, Secondly, that injuries be borne with love continuing in the heart, and without the inward emotions and passions that tend to disrupt and destroy it. Where we are called to suffer injuries, we should bear them not only without showing an evil or vengeful spirit in our words and actions, but also without harboring such a spirit within. We should not merely restrain our passions when wronged and hold back from outward retaliation; the injury should be borne without the spirit of revenge taking root in the heart at all. It is not enough to maintain a smooth outward manner; there must also be a sincere love accompanying it. We should not stop loving our neighbor simply because he has wronged us. We may pity him for what he has done, but we should not hate him for it. The duty also implies, Thirdly, that injuries be borne without our losing the quietness and peace of our own minds and hearts. They should be borne not only without rough behavior, but with a continuing inward calm and serenity of spirit. When the injuries we suffer are allowed to disturb our peace of mind and throw us into agitation and turmoil, we have ceased to bear them in the true spirit of long-suffering. If an injury is permitted to unsettle and disquiet us and break up our inner rest, we cannot enjoy our own lives and are not in a proper condition to carry out our various duties, especially our religious duties of prayer and meditation. Such a state of mind is the very opposite of the long-suffering and meek bearing of injuries that the text describes. Christians should keep the calm and serenity of their minds undisturbed, whatever injuries they may suffer. Their souls should be serene, not like the restless surface of water stirred by every passing wind. No matter what hardships they endure or what wrongs are done to them, they should continue to live by the principle expressed in the Savior's words to His disciples: "By your endurance you will gain your lives" (Luke 21:19). The duty we are describing also implies, once more, Fourthly, that in many cases when we are wronged, we should be willing to absorb considerable loss to our interests and feelings for the sake of peace, rather than do what we have the opportunity, and perhaps the right, to do in defending ourselves. When we suffer injuries from others, the situation is often such that a genuinely Christian spirit, if we exercised it as we should, would lead us to hold back from taking whatever advantage we might have to vindicate and defend ourselves. By doing otherwise, we may bring very serious harm on the one who has wronged us, and a tender concern for him should and ought to incline us toward considerable restraint, accepting some loss ourselves rather than inflicting so much suffering on him. Beyond that, pressing our advantage would likely shatter the peace and entrench a lasting hostility, whereas restraint may offer hope of winning our neighbor over and turning an enemy into a friend. All of this is clear from what the apostle says to the Corinthians about taking one another to court: "To have lawsuits at all with one another is already a defeat for you. Why not rather suffer wrong? Why not rather be defrauded?" (1 Cor 6:7). This does not mean that every effort a person makes to defend and vindicate himself when wronged is blameworthy, or that he should absorb every injury his enemies choose to inflict rather than use whatever means he has to protect himself, even if doing so costs the offender something. But in many cases, and probably in most, people should first suffer long in the spirit of the long-suffering charity the text describes. The situation may often be such that they are called to endure considerably, as both charity and prudence direct, for the sake of peace and out of sincere Christian love for the one who is wronging them, rather than seizing whatever opportunity they have to free themselves. Having shown what this virtue involves, I will now address briefly, 2. Why it is called long-suffering, or suffering long. It seems to be called this especially for two reasons:
First, because we should meekly bear not only minor offenses but also a considerable amount of mistreatment from others. We should remain calm and continue to love our neighbor without interruption, not only when he wrongs us a little, but when he wrongs us greatly. And we should bear not just a few such wrongs, but many of them, even when our neighbor persists in his mistreatment over a long period of time. When Scripture says that charity suffers long, we cannot conclude from this that we are to bear injuries patiently for a season and then stop. The meaning is not that we must endure for a while but may eventually give up; it is that we should continue bearing wrongs patiently even when they go on indefinitely, right to the very end. The spirit of long-suffering should never run out. And it is called long-suffering, Secondly, because in some cases we should be willing to endure harm to our own interests for a considerable time before we take steps to defend ourselves. Though we may ultimately defend ourselves when necessity truly demands it, we must not do so out of revenge or with any desire to harm the one who harmed us, but only out of genuine self-defense. And even that, in many cases, should be set aside for the sake of peace and out of a Christian spirit toward the one who wronged us, lest we end up doing him harm in return. Having shown in what ways we are often wronged by others, and what it means to bear those wrongs with meekness, I turn now to show, III. How that love, or charity, which is the heart of the Christian spirit, will incline us to bear such wrongs with meekness. This can be shown both with respect to love for God and love for our neighbors. And, 1. Love for God and the Lord Jesus Christ naturally inclines us toward this. For, First, love for God inclines us to imitate Him, and therefore inclines us toward the same long-suffering He displays. Long-suffering is frequently described as one of God's attributes. In "The Lord, God, merciful and gracious, long-suffering" (Exod 34:6), and in "Do you despise the riches of his goodness and forbearance and long-suffering?" (Rom 2:4), we see this quality on full display. God's long-suffering is most wonderfully evident in His bearing countless wrongs from humanity, wrongs that are both severe and unrelenting. If we consider the wickedness that fills the world, and then consider how God sustains the world rather than destroying it, showering it with countless mercies, the daily gifts of His providence and grace, causing His sun to rise on the evil and the good, sending rain on the just and the unjust alike, and offering His spiritual blessings ceaselessly to all, we begin to grasp how immense His patience toward us truly is. And if we consider His long-suffering toward some of the great and populous cities of the world, how the gifts of His goodness are constantly poured out on them and consumed by them, and then consider how great the wickedness of those very cities is, we see just how staggering His patience really is. The same long-suffering has been shown to countless individuals across every age of history. He is patient toward the sinners He spares, to whom He offers mercy even while they are in open rebellion against Him. And He is patient toward His own chosen people, many of whom lived long in sin, despising both His goodness and His warnings, yet He bore with them to the end, until they were brought to repentance and made, through His grace, vessels of mercy and glory. He showed this mercy to them even while they were enemies and rebels, as the apostle tells us was true of himself: "I thank Christ Jesus our Lord, who has strengthened me, because he judged me faithful, appointing me to his service, even though I was formerly a blasphemer, persecutor, and arrogant man. But I received mercy because I acted ignorantly in unbelief, and the grace of our Lord overflowed for me with the faith and love that are in Christ Jesus. This saying is trustworthy and deserving of full acceptance: Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners, of whom I am the worst. But I received mercy for this reason, so that in me, the worst of them, Christ Jesus might demonstrate his extraordinary patience as an example to those who would believe in him for eternal life" (1 Tim 1:12-16). Now, it is the nature of love, at least toward a superior, that it always inclines toward imitation. A child's love for his father inclines him to imitate his father, and especially does the love of God's children incline them to imitate their heavenly Father. As He is long-suffering, so they should be. And, Secondly, love for God will incline us to express our gratitude for the long-suffering He has shown toward us. Love not only inclines us to imitate; it also works through gratitude. Those who love God will be thankful to Him for the abundant patience He has shown them personally. Those who love God as they should will have such a deep sense of His extraordinary patience toward them, given all the ways they have wronged Him, that bearing with the wrongs done to them by their fellow human beings will seem a small thing by comparison. All the wrongs they have ever received from others, measured against the wrongs they have committed against God, will look like a few pennies compared to ten thousand talents. And as they gratefully receive and marvel at God's patience toward themselves, they cannot help but show their approval of it and their gratitude for it by extending, as far as they are able, the same patience to others. For if they refused to be patient toward those who have wronged them, they would in practice be rejecting God's patience toward themselves, since what we truly approve of and delight in, we will not practically refuse. And then gratitude for God's long-suffering will also incline us to obey Him in this particular matter, when He commands us to be patient toward others. And so, again, Thirdly, love for God tends toward humility, which is one of the deepest roots of a meek and patient spirit. Love for God, in lifting Him up, naturally produces a low estimate of ourselves and a deep sense of our unworthiness and our deserving of harm, because the one who loves God is keenly aware of how hateful and vile sin is when committed against the One he loves. Seeing so much of this in himself, he despises himself in his own eyes as unworthy of any good and deserving of every evil. Humility is always found alongside long-suffering, as the apostle says: "with all humility and gentleness, with patience, bearing with one another in love" (Eph 4:2). A humble spirit makes us reluctant to nurse resentment over wrongs done to us, because the person who thinks little of himself will not take an offense nearly as seriously as the person who thinks highly of himself. It is considered a far greater outrage to offend someone great and exalted than someone lowly and insignificant. Pride and self-importance are largely the foundation of bitter resentment and an unforgiving, vengeful spirit. Again, Fourthly, love for God inclines us to see God's hand in the wrongs we suffer, not only the hand of the person who wronged us, and to submit meekly to His will in the matter. Love for God inclines us to see His hand in everything, to acknowledge Him as the governor of the world and the director of providence, and to recognize His ordering in everything that happens. And the fact that God's hand is far more involved in everything that comes to us than any human action is, should lead us, in large measure, to stop thinking of things as coming merely from people, and instead to regard them chiefly as coming from God, ordered by His love and wisdom, even when their immediate cause may be the malice or carelessness of a fellow human being. And if we truly consider and feel that they come from God's hand, we will be inclined to receive them meekly and submit to them quietly, acknowledging that even the greatest wrongs received from others are justly and even kindly ordered by God, and so we will be far from any agitation or turmoil of mind on their account. It was with this perspective that David bore the curses of Shimei so meekly and quietly, when Shimei came out cursing and throwing stones at him (2 Sam 16:5, 10), saying that the Lord had told him to do it, and therefore forbidding his followers to take revenge. And once more, Fifthly, love for God inclines us to bear wrongs from others meekly, because it lifts us far above the reach of human injuries. It does so in two ways. First, it places us beyond the reach of real harm from others, because nothing can ever truly hurt those who are genuine friends of God. Their life is hidden with Christ in God, and He, as their protector and friend, will carry them on high as on eagles' wings. All things will work together for their good (Rom 8:28), and no one will be permitted to truly harm them while they follow what is good (1 Pet 3:13). And then, second, as love for God grows stronger, it lifts people above human injuries in this sense: the more they love God, the more they place all their happiness in Him. They look to God as their everything, seeking their happiness and fulfillment in His favor, and not merely in the circumstances of His providence. The more they love God, the less their hearts are set on worldly interests, which are all that their enemies can ever touch. People can only harm God's people with respect to earthly goods. But the more a person loves God, the less his heart is fixed on the things of this world, and the less he feels the wrongs his enemies may inflict, because those wrongs cannot reach beyond earthly things. And so it often happens that the friends of God barely consider the wrongs they receive from others worthy of the name, and the calm and quiet of their minds is scarcely disturbed by them. As long as they have the favor and friendship of God, they are not greatly troubled by the harmful actions of others. Love for God, and a sense of His favor, inclines them to say of the wrongs done by others, when those others would strip them of their worldly comforts, what Mephibosheth said when Ziba took the land: "Yes, let him take everything, since my lord the king has come home safely" (2 Sam 19:30). And as love for God will, in all these ways, incline us toward patience under wrongs from others, so, 2. Love for our neighbor will incline us toward the same. In this sense, charity suffers long: patience and forbearance are always the fruit of love. As the apostle suggests (Eph 4:1-2), it is part of walking worthily of the Christian calling that we walk "with all humility and gentleness, with patience, bearing with one another in love." Love will bear with a multitude of faults and offenses, and will incline us to "cover all sins" (Prov 10:12). We see this confirmed by abundant observation and experience. We always bear far more from those we have a deep and strong affection for than from those we dislike or feel indifferent toward. A parent will tolerate many things in his own child that he would strongly condemn in someone else's child, and a friend puts up with many things in his friend that he would not accept from a stranger. But there is no need to multiply words or reasons on this point, since it is perfectly plain to everyone. We all know that love is by its very nature directly opposed to both resentment and revenge, since these involve ill-will, which is the exact opposite of love and cannot coexist with it. Without dwelling further on this point, I turn, in conclusion, to draw some brief practical lessons from the subject. And, 1. This calls all of us to the duty of bearing meekly the wrongs we may receive from others. Let what has been said move us to put down all wrath, revenge, and bitterness of spirit toward those who have wronged us or who may wrong us at any time, whether they harm us in our property or our reputation, whether they abuse us with words or with actions, and whether those who wrong us are our superiors, inferiors, or equals. Let us not say in our hearts, "I will do to him as he has done to me." Let us not try, as people sometimes say, to "get even" through some form of retaliation, or even allow any hatred, bitterness, or vindictiveness to rise in our hearts. Let us strive, under all wrongs, to preserve the calm and quiet of our spirits, and be willing to suffer considerably in our legitimate rights rather than do anything that might lead us to stir up and live in strife and conflict. Toward this end, I offer the following considerations:
First, consider the example Christ set for us. He had a meek and quiet spirit, and his conduct was marked by extraordinary patience. Paul tells us about the meekness and gentleness of Christ (2 Cor 10:1). He bore countless and severe injuries from others with quiet endurance. He was the constant target of bitter contempt and scorn, dismissed and despised as someone of no importance. Though He was the Lord of glory, He was treated as worthless, rejected, and looked down upon by the very people He came to save. He endured the spite, malice, and bitter insults of those He had come to rescue. He bore the hostility of sinners directed against Him personally. He was called a glutton and a drunkard, and though He was holy, harmless, undefiled, and set apart from sinners, He was accused of being a friend of tax collectors and outcasts. He was called a deceiver of the people, and on several occasions (John 10:20; 7:20) He was said to be out of His mind and possessed by a demon. At other times they insulted Him (John 8:48) by calling Him a Samaritan and saying He had a devil; the first insult was considered by the Jews to be the deepest possible humiliation, and the second implied the most diabolical wickedness. He was sometimes accused (John 10:33) of being a wicked blasphemer who deserved death for it. At other times they charged Him with performing miracles through the power of Beelzebub, the prince of demons, and even called Him (Matt 10:25) a devil outright. Their hatred ran so deep that they had formally agreed (John 9:22) to excommunicate from the synagogue anyone who confessed that He was the Christ. They despised Him with a murderous hatred, wished Him dead, and made repeated attempts on His life, nearly always scheming to get His blood on their hands. His very existence was an offense to them, and they hated Him so intensely (Ps 41:5) that they could not stand the thought of Him living. We read repeatedly (as in John 5:16) of their efforts to kill Him. Many of them went to great lengths to monitor His words, hoping to find something they could use as an accusation and thus put Him to death with at least the appearance of legal justification. They frequently conspired together with exactly that goal in mind. On multiple occasions they actually picked up stones to stone Him, and once they led Him to the edge of a cliff intending to throw Him off and dash Him to pieces. And yet through all of this, Christ bore every injury without resentment or a single word of reproach, passing through it all with a heavenly calm. Finally, when He was treated most shamefully of all, when a close friend betrayed Him and His enemies seized Him and led Him away to be flogged and crucified, He went like a lamb to the slaughter, without opening His mouth. Not one bitter word escaped Him. His composure never broke under the weight of His suffering, and He harbored not the slightest desire for revenge. On the contrary, even as they were nailing Him to the cross, He prayed for His murderers and asked that they be forgiven, pleading on their behalf before His Father that they did not know what they were doing. The sufferings of His life and the agonies of His death never once interrupted His patience toward those who wronged Him.
Second, if we aren't inclined to bear injuries with meekness, we aren't fitted to live in this world, because this world is full of injuries we must expect to receive from others. We don't live in a world of purity, innocence, and love, but in one that is fallen, corrupt, miserable, and wicked, a world largely under the reign and dominion of sin. The principle of divine love that once lived in the human heart has been extinguished, and now it reigns in only a few people, and even in them only imperfectly. The principles that tend toward malice and harm are the very ones that hold most of the world in their grip. This world is a place where the devil, who is called the god of this world, wields influence and dominion, and where countless people are possessed by his spirit. As the apostle says, not everyone has faith (2 Thess 3:2), and indeed very few have that spirit of faith in their hearts that leads them to govern their lives by the rules of justice and kindness toward others. The face of this world looks far too much like what our Savior described when He sent out His disciples, saying, "Behold, I send you forth as sheep in the midst of wolves" (Matt 10:16). Those who lack a spirit of meekness, calm, patience, and composure for bearing injuries in such a world are truly miserable, and they're likely to be wretched at every step of their journey through life. If every injury we encounter, every reproach, every malicious and unjust act throws our minds and hearts into turmoil and disturbs the calm in which we might otherwise rest, then we can have no peace or enjoyment of spirit at all. We will instead be kept in a perpetual storm, like a small boat driven endlessly back and forth across a raging sea. People whose spirits flare up in bitter resentment when they are wronged act as though something extraordinary has happened to them, when in fact they are foolish to think so, because it is nothing extraordinary at all. It is precisely what anyone should expect in a world like this. Those who allow their spirits to be unsettled by the injuries they suffer are not acting wisely, because a wise person simply expects to encounter injury in this world, prepares for it, and in meekness of spirit, is ready to endure it.
Third, In this way we shall be most above injuries. A person who has cultivated the kind of spirit and disposition where the injuries others inflict no longer provoke or unsettle him lives, in a sense, above those injuries entirely, beyond their reach. He conquers them, rising over them as if in triumph, lifted above their power. Anyone who has grown enough in the Christian spirit to bear all injuries with genuine meekness dwells on high ground, where no enemy can touch him. History tells us that when the Persians besieged Babylon, the city walls were so extraordinarily high that the inhabitants would stand on top of them and laugh down at their enemies. In the same way, a person whose soul is fortified with Christian meekness and a calm readiness to bear all injuries can laugh at anyone who tries to harm him. When those who wish us ill attempt to wound us through slander or some other injury, they are gratified only if they can see that they've managed to disturb and upset us. But if they find that nothing they do can break the calm of our minds or shatter our inner peace, their aim is frustrated, and the arrows they meant to wound us with fall back harmlessly. On the other hand, in exactly the same proportion that we allow our minds to be disturbed and unsettled by an adversary's attacks, we surrender ourselves to his power.
Fourth, The spirit of Christian long-suffering, and of meekness in bearing injuries, is a mark of true greatness of soul. Maintaining calm in the face of injury and mistreatment reveals a genuinely noble character and true greatness of spirit. It is evidence of excellent temperament and deep inner strength. "He that is slow to anger is better than the mighty: and he that ruleth his spirit than he that taketh a city" (Prov 16:32), meaning that such a person displays a more noble and excellent nature, and more authentic greatness of spirit, than the greatest conquerors the world has ever seen. It is smallness of mind that causes the soul to be easily disturbed and unsettled by the reproaches and mistreatment of others; just as small streams are thrown into chaos by the minor obstacles and uneven ground they encounter, making a great deal of noise as they tumble over them, while great and mighty rivers pass over those same obstacles calmly and quietly, without so much as a ripple on the surface to betray any disturbance. The person who can hold himself together in such a way that, even when others harm and wrong him, he remains calm and genuinely warm toward them, pitying and forgiving them from the heart, demonstrates in this a godlike greatness of spirit. Such a meek, quiet, and patient spirit reveals true greatness of soul precisely because it reveals great and genuine wisdom, as the apostle James writes: "Who is a wise man and endued with knowledge among you? let him shew out of a good conversation his works with meekness of wisdom" (Jas 3:13). And the wise Solomon, who understood wisdom as well as anyone, returns to this theme repeatedly: declaring that "only by pride cometh contention; but with the well-advised is wisdom" (Prov 13:10), and again that "wise men turn away wrath" (Prov 29:8), and again that "the discretion of a man deferreth his anger" (Prov 19:11). Those who are quick to take offense at injuries, and who are easily consumed by anger and resentment, are described in Scripture as petty and foolish in spirit. "He that is slow to wrath is of great understanding; but he that is hasty of spirit exalteth folly" (Prov 14:29), and again, "The patient in spirit is better than the proud in spirit. Be not hasty in thy spirit to be angry; for anger resteth in the bosom of fools" (Eccl 7:8-9), and again, "The fool rageth and is confident. He that is soon angry dealeth foolishly, and a man of wicked devices is hated. The simple inherit folly" (Prov 14:16-18). And on the other hand, a meek spirit is explicitly described in Scripture as an honorable one: "It is an honour for a man to cease from strife" (Prov 20:3).
Fifth, the spirit of Christian long-suffering and meekness is commended to us by the example of the saints. The example of Christ alone might be, and is, sufficient, since it is the example of our head, our Lord and master, whose followers we claim to be and whose example we believe to be perfect. And yet some may be inclined to say, regarding the example of Christ, that He was sinless and had no corruption in His heart, and that we cannot be expected to do in all things as He did. Now, though this is no reasonable objection, the example of the saints, who were people of like passions with ourselves, is not without its special value, and may in some respects carry a particular weight. Many of the saints have set shining examples of this long-suffering that has been commended to us. With what meekness, for instance, did David bear the cruel treatment he received from Saul, when Saul hunted him like a partridge on the mountains and pursued him with the most unreasonable envy and malice, with murderous intent, even though David had always behaved dutifully toward him. When the opportunity was placed in David's hands to cut Saul down and at once free himself from his power, and when those around him were ready to consider such an act entirely lawful and even praiseworthy, David chose instead to commit himself and all his interests to God, to risk his own life, and to let his enemy live. And when, after this, he saw that his forbearance and goodness had not softened Saul, but that Saul still pursued him, and when again he had the chance to destroy him, he chose rather to go out as a wanderer and an outcast than to harm the one who would have destroyed him.
Another example is that of Stephen, of whom we read (Acts 7:59-60) that when his persecutors were stoning him to death, "he knelt down and cried out with a loud voice, 'Lord, do not hold this sin against them.'" This prayer is recorded as the last words he spoke, uttered after he had already asked the Lord Jesus to receive his spirit. Having prayed for the very men who were killing him, we are told that he fell asleep, forgiving them and commending them to God's blessing as the final act of his earthly life. Another example is the apostle Paul, who endured countless wrongs at the hands of wicked and unreasonable men. He describes both those injuries and his response to them in his own words: "Even to this present hour we both hunger and thirst, and are naked, and are beaten, and have no fixed home; and we labor, working with our own hands: when we are insulted, we bless; when we are persecuted, we endure it; when we are slandered, we respond gently: we have become like the filth of the world, the scum of all things, to this day" (1 Cor 4:11-13). In this way, Paul demonstrated a meek and patient spirit under every injury that was piled upon him. And it is not only the inspired writers who give us such records; secular and purely human histories also preserve remarkable accounts of the heroism and patient endurance of martyrs and other Christians under the most cruel and unjust treatment imaginable. All of these examples should draw us toward that same spirit of meekness and long-suffering.
Sixth, This is the way to be rewarded with the exercise of Divine long-suffering toward us. Scripture repeatedly tells us that God will deal with us according to how we deal with others. We read, for instance, that "with the merciful God will show himself merciful, and with the upright man, upright; that with the pure he will show himself pure, and with the froward he will show himself froward" (Ps 18:25-26). And again: "With what judgment you judge, you shall be judged; and with what measure you measure, it shall be measured to you again" (Matt 7:2). And once more: "For if you forgive men their trespasses, your heavenly Father will also forgive you; but if you forgive not men their trespasses, neither will your Father forgive your trespasses" (Matt 6:14-15). By trespasses here, the text means the injuries others do to us. So if we refuse to bear with the wrongs people commit against us, our heavenly Father will not bear with the wrongs we commit against Him; and if we don't practice long-suffering toward others, we have no grounds to expect God to practice it toward us. Consider, then, how desperately we need His long-suffering when it comes to our own offenses against Him. How often, and how seriously, do we wrong God? How poorly do we treat Him, day after day? If He did not bear with us, if He did not extend His remarkable patience toward us, what would become of us? The misery would be complete. Let this reality move each of us to pursue the kind of spirit we have been describing, and to resist and root out anything that runs contrary to it. If this spirit were to take hold, the effect on individuals, on families, and on all our shared institutions and public life would be profoundly good. It would cut off contention and strife at the root, and spread in their place gentleness, kindness, harmony, and love. It would clear away bitterness and disorder, and every kind of destructive behavior. Our affairs, both public and private, would be conducted without harshness, without cruelty, without a bitter edge to the spirit; without the cutting and contemptuous words we hurl at one another; and without the malicious gossip and scornful speech that circulate so freely among people, doing serious damage to the fabric of society and storing up a fearful account for the day of judgment.
But some readers may be inclined, in their hearts, to push back against the kind of meek and quiet endurance of injuries that has been described. It may be worth briefly addressing some of these objections and offering a response:
Objection 1. Some may be ready to say that the injuries they have suffered are simply unbearable; that the person who wronged them has been so unreasonable in word and deed, so unjust and indefensible, that it is more than any human being can endure; that they have been treated with such injustice that it would provoke even a stone; or that they have been so thoroughly despised and trampled on that they cannot help but push back. In response to this, I want to ask a few questions. First, do you honestly believe that the wrongs you have suffered at the hands of another person are greater than the wrongs you have committed against God? Has your enemy been more contemptible, more unreasonable, more ungrateful toward you than you have been toward the High and Holy One? Have his offenses been more serious, more aggravated, or more numerous than your own sins against your Creator, your Benefactor, and your Redeemer? Have they been more provoking than your own conduct has been toward the One who is the source of every mercy you have ever received, and to whom you owe the deepest obligation?
Second, do you not hope that just as God has borne with you until now, He will continue to do so, and that despite everything, He will still extend His infinite love and favor toward you? Do you not hope that God will have mercy on you, and that Christ will receive you in His dying love, even though you have been such an offensive and injurious enemy to Him, and that through His grace He will wipe away your sins and every wrong you have committed against Him, and make you eternally His child and an heir of His kingdom?
Third, When you consider such patience on God's part, don't you find it admirable? Don't you recognize it as not merely worthy, but genuinely glorious? And don't you approve of the fact that Christ died for you, and that God, through Him, offers you pardon and salvation? Or do you actually disapprove of this? Would you have preferred a God who never bore with you at all, but cut you off long ago in His wrath?
Fourth, If such patience is excellent and worthy of admiration in God, why isn't it equally so in you? Why shouldn't you imitate it? Is God being too generous in forgiving injuries? Is it somehow less serious to offend the Lord of heaven and earth than for someone to offend you? Is it right that you should receive forgiveness, that you should pray to God for pardon, and yet refuse to extend that same pardon to the people around you who have wronged you?
Fifth, Would you be willing, from this point forward, for God to stop bearing with the injuries you cause Him and the offenses you commit against Him? Are you prepared to go to God and ask Him to treat you in the future the same way you, in holding this objection, are proposing to treat the people who have wronged you?
Sixth, Did Christ retaliate against those who injured, insulted, and trampled on Him while He walked this earth? And wasn't He injured far more grievously than you have ever been? Haven't you yourself, in a far truer sense, trampled underfoot the Son of God, more than anyone has ever trampled on you? And is it really a greater offense for people to trample on and injure you, than for you to trample on and injure Christ? These questions should be more than enough to answer your objection.
Objection 2. But you might push further and say that those who have wronged you keep on doing it, showing no remorse and no sign of stopping. Yet what opportunity would there be to practice long-suffering if the injury weren't sustained over time? If wrongs continue, it may be precisely because providence is testing whether you will exercise patience, meekness, and the forbearance we've been discussing. Consider how God bore with you when you persisted in offending Him. When you were stubborn, self-willed, and relentless in your sins against Him, did He stop extending His patience toward you?
Objection 3. But perhaps you object that your enemies will only be encouraged to keep hurting you, reasoning that if you endure the injury quietly, you'll simply invite more of it. You don't actually know that, because you have no window into the future, nor into the hearts of other people. Beyond that, God will act on your behalf if you obey His commands, and He is far more capable of restraining human wrath than you are. He has said, "Vengeance is mine; I will repay, says the Lord" (Rom 12:19). He intervened in remarkable ways for David, as He has for countless others among His people, and if you simply obey Him, He will stand with you against everyone who rises up against you. Human observation and experience consistently show that a meek and patient spirit tends to bring injuries to an end, while a vengeful spirit only provokes more of them. Cultivate, then, a spirit of patience, meekness, and forbearance, and you will possess your soul in peace and contentment, and no one will be permitted to harm you beyond what God in His wisdom and kindness allows.
CHAPTER 5
LECTURE 5. LOVE IS NOT INCONSISTENT WITH TRULY SEEKING OUR OWN HAPPINESS
"Charity suffereth long, and is kind." (1 Cor 13:4)
In the previous lecture on this passage, we established that charity, or Christian love, is patient; that is, it moves us to bear the wrongs done to us with a quiet and humble spirit. Now we turn to the next quality: charity is kind. Put simply, A TRULY CHRISTIAN SPIRIT WILL MOVE US TO DO GOOD TO OTHERS FREELY AND WILLINGLY.
In exploring this point, I want to do two things: first, briefly explain what the duty of doing good to others actually involves; and second, show that a genuinely Christian spirit will naturally incline us toward it.
To understand this duty clearly, we need to consider three things: the act itself (doing good), the objects of that act (the people we should do good to), and the manner in which it should be done (freely and generously).
1. The act: what it means to do good to others. There are many ways a person can do good to others, and many ways in which we are genuinely obligated to do so whenever the opportunity arises. Consider, first, that we can do good to the souls of others, which is the highest and most excellent form of doing good. People can be, and often are, the instruments of spiritual and eternal benefit to those around them; and when that happens, they have done more for those people than if they had handed them all the wealth in the world. We can do good to the souls of others by taking the time to instruct those who are ignorant, guiding them toward a knowledge of the great truths of the faith. We can do good by offering counsel and warning, by stirring others to take their responsibilities seriously and to care wisely and thoroughly for the welfare of their souls. We can do good through honest, Christian correction of those who have wandered from the path of duty. And we can do good by setting a worthy example, which is perhaps the most necessary of all these means, and ordinarily the most effective. A good example must accompany every other effort to benefit the souls of others: the instructing, the counseling, the warning, the correcting. It gives those efforts their force and makes them far more likely to take root. Without it, all the other means will almost certainly come to nothing.
Believers can do good for the souls of sinful people by helping to draw them back from destructive habits, or for those who neglect worship by encouraging them to return to the house of God, or for those who are complacent and indifferent to their spiritual condition by reminding them of their misery and danger. In this way, believers can serve as instruments for awakening such people, bringing about their conversion, and drawing them home to Christ. They may thus be counted among those described as people who "turn many to righteousness," and who "shall shine as the stars for ever and ever" (Dan 12:3). Believers can also serve as instruments of comfort and stability for one another, strengthening each other in faith and obedience, stirring up and encouraging one another, building each other up in the faith, lifting one another out of spiritual dullness and deadness, helping each other through temptation, and pressing forward together in the life of God. They can guide one another through difficult and uncertain situations, offer encouragement to those walking through darkness or trial, and in general promote each other's spiritual joy and strength, serving as fellow travelers who help one another along the road to glory.
Second, people may do good to others in outward, material ways. They may help others through their external difficulties and hardships, because there are countless kinds of temporal suffering to which human beings are vulnerable, and in which they desperately need the help of their neighbors and friends. Many are hungry, or thirsty, or homeless, or without clothing, or sick, or imprisoned (Matt 25:35-36), or suffering in some other way; and to all such people we may offer assistance. We may do good to others by improving their material circumstances, by defending their reputation and thereby raising their standing among others, or by anything that genuinely adds to their comfort or happiness in this life, whether through a kind word or a thoughtful and generous act. By working to help others in these outward ways, we also gain a greater advantage in doing good to their souls; for when our instructions, counsel, warnings, and good examples are accompanied by such outward kindness, that kindness tends to open the door for our words to have greater effect, giving them their full force and leading people to receive our efforts more openly when we seek their spiritual good. We may contribute to the good of others in three ways: by giving to them what they need from what we possess; by doing for them, taking the trouble to help them and advance their welfare; and by suffering for them, helping them carry their burdens and doing everything in our power to make those burdens lighter. In each of these ways, Christianity calls us to do good to others. It calls us to give to others: "Give, and it will be given to you" (Luke 6:38). It calls us to do for others and to work on their behalf: "You remember, brothers, our labor and toil; working night and day, so that we would not be a burden to any of you, we proclaimed to you the gospel of God" (1 Thess 2:9); and "God is not unjust so as to overlook your work and the love that you have shown for His name" (Heb 6:10). And it calls us, when necessary, to suffer for others: "Bear one another's burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ" (Gal 6:2); and "By this we know love, that he laid down his life for us, and we ought to lay down our lives for the brothers" (1 John 3:16). In all these ways, then, Scripture calls us to do good to all. I turn now to speak,
2. Of the objects of this duty, or of those to whom we should do good. These are often described in Scripture by the word "neighbor," since the duty before us is implied in the command that we love our neighbor as ourselves. But here we may be tempted, like the young lawyer who came to Christ (Luke 10:29), to ask, "Who is my neighbor?" Just as Christ's answer showed him that the Samaritan was a neighbor to the Jew, even though Samaritans and Jews regarded each other with contempt and hostility, so we may learn who those are to whom we are to do good, in three respects:
First, we are to do good to both the good and the bad. We are called to do this if we want to imitate our heavenly Father, for "he makes his sun rise on the evil and on the good, and sends rain on the just and on the unjust" (Matt 5:43). The world contains all kinds of people, some good and some evil, and we should do good to all of them. We should, of course, especially "do good to those who are of the household of faith," or those we have good reason, in the exercise of charity, to regard as saints. But while we should be most generous toward them, our generosity must not stop there. We should do good to all people, as we have the opportunity. As long as we live in this world, we will inevitably encounter people with deeply troubling qualities and harmful habits. Some are proud, some immoral, some greedy, some profane, some unjust or cruel, and some openly contemptuous of God. But none of these faults, whether individually or together, should hold back our generosity or stop us from doing good to such people when the opportunity arises. In fact, for precisely this reason, we should be all the more eager to benefit them, so that we might win them to Christ. And we should be especially diligent to benefit them in spiritual things.
Second, we should do good to both friends and enemies. We are obliged to do good to our friends, not only because of the general duty we owe them as fellow human beings made in the image of God, but also because of the bonds of friendship, gratitude, and genuine affection. And we are equally obliged to do good to our enemies, for our Savior says, "But I say unto you, Love your enemies; bless them that curse you; do good to them that hate you; and pray for them that despitefully use you, and persecute you" (Matt 5:44). To do good to those who wrong us is the only form of retaliation that befits us as Christians. We are taught to "recompense to no man evil for evil," but instead to "overcome evil with good" (Rom 12:17, 21). Again, Scripture says, "See that none render evil for evil unto any man; but ever follow that which is good, both among yourselves, and to all men" (1 Thess 5:15). And once more: "Not rendering evil for evil, or railing for railing: but contrariwise blessing; knowing that ye are thereunto called, that ye should inherit a blessing" (1 Pet 3:9). Third, we should do good to both the thankful and the unthankful. The example of our heavenly Father compels us here, for He "is kind unto the unthankful and to the evil," and the command that follows is that we "be merciful, as he also is merciful" (Luke 6:35). Many people object to doing good to others by saying, "If I do, they will never thank me for it, and in return for my kindness they will give me abuse and injury." In this way they excuse themselves from practicing kindness, especially toward those who have already shown themselves ungrateful. But such people are not looking closely enough at Christ, and they reveal either their unfamiliarity with the principles of Christianity or their unwillingness to embrace its spirit. Having addressed the duty of doing good and the people to whom we owe it, I turn, as proposed, to consider 3. The manner in which we should do good to others. This is captured in a single word: "freely." The text itself implies as much, for to be kind is to have a disposition that gives freely. No matter what good a person does, there is no genuine kindness in it unless it is given freely. And this free giving involves three things:
First, that our doing good must not come from a mercenary spirit. We are not to do good in order to receive something in return from the person we're helping. The command is clear: "Do good, and lend, hoping for nothing again" (Luke 6:35). People often do good for others while expecting to receive just as much back, but we should do good to the poor and needy, those from whom we can expect nothing in return. Christ's command makes this even more explicit: "When you host a dinner or a supper, don't invite your friends, your brothers, your relatives, or your wealthy neighbors, in case they invite you back and you receive something in return. Instead, when you give a feast, invite the poor, the crippled, the lame, and the blind. You will be blessed, because they cannot repay you, and you will be repaid at the resurrection of the righteous" (Luke 14:12-14). For our doing good to be truly free and not mercenary, whatever we do must not be done for the sake of any earthly gain, or to advance our own interests, reputation, or profit, but must flow entirely from a spirit of love.
Second, that our doing good be truly free, it requires that we do it cheerfully and wholeheartedly, with genuine goodwill toward the person we want to help. What is done wholeheartedly is done from love, and what is done from love is done with delight, not grudgingly or with reluctance. "Use hospitality," says the apostle, "one to another, without grudging" (1 Pet 4:9), and Paul writes, "Every man, according as he purposes in his heart, so let him give; not grudgingly, or of necessity: for God loves a cheerful giver" (2 Cor 9:7). Scripture places great emphasis on this quality in our doing good. "He that gives," says the apostle, "let him do it with simplicity; he that rules, with diligence; he that shows mercy, with cheerfulness" (Rom 12:8). God also gives a clear command that we "shall not be grieved" in our heart when we give to our neighbor (Deut 15:10). In short, the very idea of giving acceptably is presented throughout the Bible as requiring a warm and cheerful spirit. Doing good freely also implies, Third, that we do it liberally and generously. We are not to be stingy or sparing in our gifts or efforts, but open-hearted and open-handed. We are to "abound to every good work, being enriched in everything to all bountifulness" (2 Cor 9:8, 11). So God requires that when we give to the poor, we should "open our hand wide to him" (Deut 15:8), and we are told that "the liberal soul shall be made fat" (Prov 11:25). The apostle urged the Corinthians to be generous in their contributions for the poor saints in Judea, assuring them that "he who sows sparingly shall reap also sparingly, and he who sows bountifully shall reap also bountifully" (2 Cor 9:6). Having explained the nature of this duty of freely doing good to others, I now move on to show, II. That a Christian spirit will dispose us to do good to others in this way. This becomes clear from two considerations:
1. The main thing in that love which is the sum of the Christian spirit, is benevolence, or good-will to others. We have already examined what Christian love is and how it takes on different names depending on its various objects and expressions. In particular, we have seen how, when it concerns the good enjoyed or to be enjoyed by the beloved, it is called the love of benevolence; and when it concerns the good enjoyed in the beloved, it is called the love of complacence. The love of benevolence is the disposition that leads us to desire or delight in another person's good. This is the heart of Christian love, its most essential quality, and the way in which our love most closely mirrors the eternal love and grace of God and the self-giving love of Christ, which consists in benevolence and good-will toward humanity, as the angels proclaimed at His birth (Luke 2:14). The core of Christian love, then, is good-will: a spirit that delights in and actively seeks the good of those we love.
2. The most conclusive evidence that such a principle is real and sincere is that it actually produces results. The proper and conclusive evidence of our wishing or willing good toward another is simply to do it. In every case, nothing is plainer than this: the will is proven by the act, and the act always follows the will when the power to act is present. The genuine evidence that a person sincerely desires another's good is that he pursues it in practice, because whatever we truly desire, we actively seek. Scripture therefore speaks of doing good as the proper and full evidence of love, and it frequently treats loving in deed and practice as the same thing as loving in truth and reality: "My little children, let us not love in word, neither in tongue; but in deed and in truth. Hereby we know that we are of the truth" (1 John 3:18-19), meaning we know that we are sincere. And again: "If a brother or sister be naked, and destitute of daily food, and one of you say unto them, Depart in peace, be ye warmed and filled; notwithstanding ye give them not those things which are needful to the body, what doth it profit?" (Jas 2:15-16). There is no profit to them, and so there is no evidence of sincerity on your part, no real proof that you desire they should be clothed and fed. Genuine desire leads not merely to words, but to the deeds of benevolence. In applying this subject, we may use it in two ways. 1. As a reproof. If a truly Christian spirit disposes people to freely do good to others, then all those who are of a contrary spirit and practice stand reproved by it. A malignant and malicious spirit is the direct opposite of the former, since it drives people to do harm rather than good. So too is a closed and selfish spirit, by which people are wholly consumed with their own interests and unwilling to set aside their own ends for the sake of others. Equally opposed to a spirit of love are those who display an excessively grasping and greedy spirit, seizing every opportunity to extract as much as possible from their neighbors in business dealings, charging more for what they do or sell than it is genuinely worth, and pressing unreasonable demands to the limit, with no regard for the real value of what they offer, but essentially wringing out of others everything they can get. Those who behave this way are generally just as selfish when buying from their neighbors, grinding them down to the lowest possible prices and being very reluctant to pay what something is actually worth. Such a spirit and practice stand in direct opposition to a Christian spirit and are sharply condemned by the great law of love: that we do to others as we would have them do to us. 2. As an exhortation to freely do good to others. Since this is a Christian duty, a virtue fitting the gospel, and something a Christian spirit will naturally produce in us, let us seek, as we have opportunity, to do good to the souls and bodies of others, striving to be a blessing to them both in this life and in eternity. To that end, let us be willing to do, to give, and to endure hardship so that we may do good alike to friends and enemies, to the evil and the good, to the grateful and the ungrateful. Let our goodwill and generosity be universal, constant, freely given, habitual, and proportionate to our opportunities and ability, for this is essential to true piety and required by the commands of God. Several things must be considered here:
First, what a remarkable honor it is to be made an instrument of good in the world. When we fill our lives with doing good, God honors us by making us a blessing to others, much like the honor He gave Abraham when He said, "I will bless thee, and make thy name great; and thou shalt be a blessing" (Gen 12:2). Even natural human instinct recognizes this as a great honor. This is why the rulers of the ancient East adopted the title of "benefactors," meaning "doers of good," considering it the most honorable title they could claim (Luke 22:25). It was also common practice in pagan societies that when someone had spent their life doing great good, the people among whom they had lived would count them as gods after their death, building temples in their honor and worshiping them there. To the degree that God makes people instruments of good to others, He makes them like the great heavenly bodies: the sun, the moon, and the stars, which bless the world by pouring down their light. He makes them like the angels, who are ministering spirits sent out for the benefit of others. Indeed, He makes them like Himself, the great fountain of all good, who forever pours His blessings down on humanity.
Second, freely doing good to others is simply doing to them as we would have them do to us. If others genuinely care about us, show us great kindness, stand ready to help when we're in need, and for that purpose are willing to act, give, sacrifice, and carry our burdens alongside us, feeling our pain in times of hardship with warmth and generosity, we deeply admire that kind of spirit and conduct. We don't just admire it either; we praise it openly, and perhaps even look for opportunities to speak well of such people, never thinking for a moment that they've gone beyond what's expected of them, but rather that they're acting exactly as they should. Let us remember, then, that if this quality is so admirable and praiseworthy in others when we are the ones who benefit from it, we should offer the same to them and to everyone around us. What we genuinely admire in others, we should embody in our own lives.
Third, consider how kind God and Christ have been to us, and how much good we have received from them. Their kindness in the things of this world has been immense. God's mercies are new to us every morning and fresh every evening, as ceaseless as our very existence. And beyond that, God has bestowed even greater gifts for our spiritual and eternal good. He has given us something worth more than all the kingdoms of the earth combined. He has given His only-begotten and deeply beloved Son, the greatest gift He could possibly offer. And Christ not only acted on our behalf but suffered enormously, giving Himself to die for us, all freely, without reluctance, and without any expectation of reward. "Though he was rich" with all the riches of the universe, "yet for your sakes he became poor, that ye through his poverty might be rich" (2 Cor 8:9). Consider also what God has done for those of us who have been converted and brought home to Christ: delivering us from sin, justifying and sanctifying us, making us kings and priests before God, and giving us a claim "to an inheritance that is incorruptible, and undefiled, and that fadeth not away" (1 Pet 1:4). And He did all of this while we were not good but evil and ungrateful, deserving nothing but wrath.
Fourth, consider the great rewards promised to those who freely do good to others. God has promised that to "the merciful he will shew himself merciful" (Ps 18:25), and there is scarcely any duty in all of Scripture that carries as many promises of reward as this one, whether for this life or the life to come. For this life, our Savior declares, "It is more blessed to give than to receive" (Acts 20:35). The person who gives generously receives a greater blessing through the giving than the recipient receives through the gift. What we spend in doing good to others is not lost, as though thrown into the ocean. It is rather, as Solomon tells us, like the seed that farmers in the East scatter on flooded waters, which sinks to the bottom, takes root, springs up, and is found again in an abundant harvest after many days (Eccl 11:1). What is given in this way is loaned to the Lord (Prov 19:17), and what we lend Him, He will repay. And He will not merely repay it but will greatly multiply it, for if we give, it is declared that it will be "given to us again, good measure, pressed down, shaken together, and running over" (Luke 6:38). This is, in fact, the very path to increase, for it is written, "There is that scattereth, and yet increaseth; and there is that withholdeth more than is meet, but it tendeth to poverty" (Prov 11:24), and again, "The liberal deviseth liberal things; and by liberal things shall he stand" (Isa 32:8). Even what unregenerate people give in this way, God often seems to reward with significant earthly blessings. His own declaration is that "he that giveth unto the poor shall not lack" (Prov 28:27), and that promise is not restricted to the saints. Our observation of God's providence shows that people's gifts to the poor are rewarded by God almost as reliably as the seed they sow in the field. It is well within God's power to restore to us, and more than restore, everything we give for the good of others. It is precisely this kind of giving that Paul describes to the Corinthians when he says that "he which soweth bountifully shall reap also bountifully," adding that "God loveth a cheerful giver" and that He "is able to make all grace abound toward them," meaning He can cause all their gifts to return to them in abundance (2 Cor 9:6-8). Many people give little thought to how much their prosperity depends on God's providence. And yet, even in this world, "it is the blessing of God that maketh rich" (Prov 10:22), and of the one who considers the poor it is written that "the Lord will deliver him in time of trouble" (Ps 41:1). And if we give in the manner and spirit of genuine Christian charity, we will lay up treasure in heaven and receive at last the rewards of eternity. This is the kind of treasure that does not fail, which Christ speaks of (Luke 12:33), and about which He declares that, though the poor we help cannot repay us, "we shall be recompensed at the resurrection of the just" (Luke 14:13-14). This, then, is the wisest way to store up wealth, whether for this life or for eternity. It is the best way to provide for ourselves and the best way to provide for those who come after us, for of the good man who shows kindness and lends generously, it is written that "his horn shall be exalted with honour," that "his seed shall be mighty upon earth," and that "wealth and riches shall be in his house, and his righteousness endureth for ever" (Ps 112). And when Christ comes in judgment and all people are gathered before Him, to those who were truly kind and generous, in the genuine spirit of Christian love, toward the suffering and the poor, He will say: "Come, ye blessed of my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world: for I was an hungered, and ye gave me meat; I was thirsty, and ye gave me drink: I was a stranger, and ye took me in: naked, and ye clothed me: I was sick, and ye visited me: I was in prison, and ye came unto me. . . . Verily I say unto you, Inasmuch as ye have done it unto one of the least of these my brethren, ye have done it unto me" (Matt 25:34-36, 40).
CHAPTER 6
LECTURE 6. LOVE IS INCOMPATIBLE WITH ENVY
"Charity envieth not." (1 Cor 13:4)
We have already examined how Christian charity, or divine love, responds to the wrongs we receive from others: it "suffers long." We have also seen how it responds to the needs of others: it "is kind." Now we turn to what this same charity produces in us when we consider the good that others possess, and the good that we ourselves possess. When it comes to the good that belongs to others, the apostle tells us that the nature and tendency of charity, or true Christian love, is to feel no envy toward them for whatever good they enjoy: "Charity envieth not." The plain teaching of these words is this: THAT CHARITY, OR A TRULY CHRISTIAN SPIRIT, IS THE VERY OPPOSITE OF AN ENVIOUS SPIRIT.
In exploring this idea, I will address three questions: I. What is the nature of an envious spirit? II. In what ways is a Christian spirit the opposite of such a spirit? And III. What are the reasons and evidence for this teaching?
I. The nature of envy.
Envy can be defined as a spirit of dissatisfaction with, and opposition to, the prosperity and happiness of others when compared with our own. What the envious person resents is the relative superiority of another's honor, prosperity, or happiness over what he himself possesses. This spirit is called envy in particular when we dislike and resist another's honor or prosperity because it is generally greater than our own, or because that person enjoys some honor or advantage that we do not. Men have a natural drive to be at the top, and that drive is directly frustrated when they see others rise above them. It is from this spirit that people resent the prosperity of others, because they feel it makes those who have it superior to themselves in some way. From this same disposition, a person may also resent another's being equal to him in honor or happiness, or in sharing the same sources of enjoyment that he has. As people commonly are, they can barely tolerate a rival any better than they can tolerate a superior, because they want to stand alone in their prominence and advancement. This spirit is called envy in Scripture. Moses speaks of Joshua envying on his behalf when Eldad and Medad were granted the same privilege of prophecy as Moses himself, saying, "Are you jealous for my sake? I wish that all the Lord's people were prophets and that the Lord would put His Spirit on them!" (Num 11:29). And Joseph's brothers, we are told, "envied him" when they heard his dream, which implied that his parents and brothers would one day bow before him and that he would hold power over them (Gen 37:11). From such a spirit, people are not only unwilling for others to surpass them or equal them, but even to come close to them, because the desire to stand out in prosperity and honor is satisfied in direct proportion to how high one rises and how far below everyone else remains, so that the gap is clear and visible to all. This disposition can operate either toward prosperity that others might yet obtain, or toward what they have already achieved. In the latter form, which is the more common, envy shows itself in two ways: first, in relation to another's prosperity, and second, in relation to the person who enjoys it.
1. Envy shows itself in an uneasiness and dissatisfaction with the prosperity of others. Rather than rejoicing in another's good fortune, the envious person is troubled by it. It grates on his spirit to see others rise to such heights of honor and advancement. Hearing that someone has gained a particular advantage, honor, or promotion brings him no comfort; on the contrary, it brings him real distress. He is very much in the spirit of Haman, who, despite "the glory of his riches, and the multitude of his children, and all the things wherein the king had promoted him," could still say, "Yet all this means nothing to me as long as I see Mordecai the Jew sitting at the king's gate" (Esth 5:13). From this spirit, the envious person stands ready to take pleasure in anything that diminishes another's honor or comfort. He is glad to see others brought low, and will even scheme to reduce their standing, just as Haman schemed to humble and destroy Mordecai. Often, like Haman, he will express his resentment not only through plotting but through active efforts of one kind or another to bring others down, and he will eagerly seize the first opportunity to do so. It is also from this disposition that the mere sight of another's prosperity often drives the envious person to speak against them and slander them, even when he barely knows them. Resenting the prominence they have achieved, he hopes that by speaking ill of them he can somewhat diminish their reputation and lower them in the eyes of others.
2. This leads to a second point: the envious person's opposition to another's prosperity will also show itself in a personal dislike of those who prosper. Seeing how others flourish and what honors they attain, the envious person comes to dislike and even hate them on account of that very honor and prosperity. He nurses an ill spirit toward them for no other reason than that they are doing well. He grows bitter toward them simply because they are prominent in name or fortune. Haman, we are told, "was full of indignation against Mordecai" because he saw him at the king's gate and because Mordecai "did not stand up or show any sign of respect for him" (Esth 5:9). Joseph's brothers "hated him and could not speak a kind word to him" because their father loved him, and when he dreamed a dream that implied their inferiority, "they hated him all the more" (Gen 37:4-5). The envious generally treat another's prosperity and rise to honor as though it were a personal injury done to them. Sometimes this settles into a deep hatred, leading, as in the case of Joseph's brothers, to acts of the greatest cruelty and wickedness (Gen 37:19-28). But this is enough on the nature of envy. I turn now to show:
II. How a Christian spirit stands in direct opposition to envy.
1. A Christian spirit refuses to allow envy any expression or exercise. A person who is genuinely guided by Christian principles in the course of his life, though he may find envy lurking in his heart alongside other corrupt impulses, will abhor that spirit as unworthy of him as a Christian and contrary to the nature, will, and character of God. He recognizes it as a deeply ugly and hateful disposition, and he sees that ugliness not only in others but equally in himself. Therefore, whenever he notices its stirrings rising within him on any occasion or toward any person, so far as he is truly governed by a Christian spirit, he will be alarmed by it, will fight against it, and will not permit it to take hold for even a moment. He will not allow it to break out in words or actions; he will grieve over whatever he sees of its movements in his own heart, will work to put that hateful disposition to death within him, and will do everything in his power to act against it in his outward conduct.
2. A Christian spirit not only opposes the outward expressions of envy, but it works to uproot envy's very principle from the heart. To the degree that a Christian spirit takes hold in a person, it doesn't merely restrain envious behavior on the surface; it works to subdue the underlying disposition itself. In direct proportion to the strength of that spirit, a person will find that the impulse to resent another's prosperity simply fades away, and more than that, the ill-will that envy breeds toward those who prosper will fade with it. A Christian spirit inclines us toward genuine contentment with our own circumstances, with the place God has assigned us among others, and with a quiet, settled satisfaction regarding the stations and possessions that God, in His wise and gracious providence, has distributed to us and to those around us. Whether our position is as exalted as that of the angels or as humble as that of the beggar at the rich man's gate (Luke 16:20), we will be equally at peace with it as the post God has placed us in, and we will carry ourselves with equal dignity if we are faithfully serving Him there. Like the apostle, we will learn, if we have a genuine Christian spirit, "in whatever state I am, to be content" (Phil 4:11). But, 3. A Christian spirit not only refuses to permit the expression of envy and works to uproot it from the heart, but it actually disposes us to rejoice in the prosperity of others. It inclines us toward a cheerful, habitual obedience to the apostle's instruction that we "rejoice with those who rejoice, and weep with those who weep" (Rom 12:15), meaning that we enter into our neighbor's condition with the same feeling we would have if it were our own. A spirit of genuine benevolence and goodwill drives out the poisonous spirit of envy and makes it possible to find real happiness in seeing others flourish. I turn now, as I proposed, to demonstrate, III. The reason and evidence for the doctrine we have stated; that is, to show that it is indeed the case, and why it is the case, that a Christian spirit stands in direct opposition to a spirit of envy. This will become clear when we consider three things: first, how strongly a spirit and practice contrary to envy is pressed upon us in the precepts Christ has given; second, how powerfully the history and doctrines of the gospel reinforce those precepts; and third, how naturally a spirit of Christian love will incline us to submit to the authority of those precepts and respond to the motives behind them. And, 1. A spirit and practice entirely contrary to envy is strongly insisted upon in the precepts of Christ. The New Testament is filled with commands to goodwill toward others, and with instructions in meekness, humility, and generosity, all of which stand against a spirit of envy. Beyond these, we also find many direct warnings against envy itself. The apostle urges us to "walk properly, as in the day, not in strife and envying" (Rom 13:13); and again, he rebukes the Corinthians as still being carnal, precisely because envying persisted among them (1 Cor 3:3); and again, he expresses his fear that when he visits he will find among them envyings, coupled, as envy so often is, with "wrath, strife, slander, gossip, arrogance, and disorder" (2 Cor 12:20); and again, envy is listed among the vile works of the flesh, alongside "murders, drunkenness, and carousing" (Gal 5:21); and again, it is condemned as a mark of deep wickedness (1 Tim 6:4); and again, it is named as one of the shameful sins that Christians lived in before their conversion, but from which they have now been redeemed, and which they should therefore confess and abandon (Titus 3:3). In the same vein, the apostle James describes envy as deeply contrary to Christianity, as bound up with every kind of evil, and as earthly, unspiritual, and demonic (Jas 3:14, 16); and he warns us against it, saying, "Do not grumble against one another, brothers, so that you may not be judged; behold, the Judge is standing at the door" (Jas 5:9); and, to cite just one more instance, the apostle Peter warns us against all envy, connecting it with various other evils and identifying it as something that stunts our growth in the things of God (1 Pet 2:1-2). The New Testament is, in short, saturated with precepts that call us to the very opposite of an envious spirit. And these precepts, 2. Are powerfully reinforced by the doctrines and history of the gospel. When we examine the Christian scheme of doctrine, we find that it presses hard against every form of envy. In all its dimensions and teachings, Christian doctrine is fundamentally at odds with an envious spirit. What it teaches us about God is utterly contrary to envy, for we learn there how far God was from begrudging us the most extraordinary honor and blessing, and how He withheld nothing as too costly to do for us or too great and good to give us. He did not begrudge us His only-begotten and beloved Son, who was dearer to Him than all else; nor has He begrudged us the highest honor and blessedness in and through Him. The doctrines of the gospel also show us how far Christ was from begrudging us anything He could do or give. He did not begrudge us a life poured out in labor and suffering, or His own precious blood shed for us on the cross; nor will He begrudge us a throne of glory with Him in heaven, where we will live and reign with Him forever. The Christian scheme of doctrine further teaches us that Christ came into the world to deliver us from the power of Satan's envy toward us, for the devil, in his wretched spite, envied humanity the happiness it first enjoyed and could not bear to see us in our blessed state in Eden. He therefore exerted himself to the utmost to bring about our ruin, and he succeeded. And the gospel also teaches that Christ came into the world to destroy the works of the devil, to rescue us from the misery that his envy brought upon us, and to purify our natures from every trace of that same spirit, so that we might be made fit for heaven.
When we consider not just the teachings of the gospel but also its history, we find that it powerfully reinforces the commands against envy. This is especially true of the life of Christ and the example He set for us. How far removed He was from any spirit of envy! How content He remained in the humble and difficult circumstances He voluntarily accepted for our sake! And how completely He avoided envying those who possessed worldly wealth and status, or longing for their condition! He chose instead to remain in His own lowly state, and when the crowds, overwhelmed with admiration for His teaching and miracles, once stood ready to make Him a king, He refused the honor they intended to bestow on Him, slipped away from them, and withdrew alone to a mountain (John 6:15). When John the Baptist was so widely honored by the people as a great prophet, and all of Judea and Jerusalem went out to hear him and be baptized by him, Christ felt no envy toward him. Instead, He went out to be baptized by John in the Jordan, even though He was John's Lord and Master, and John himself testified that he was the one who needed to be baptized by Christ. And far from begrudging His disciples any honors or privileges as though they were too great for them, He told them plainly and promised them that after His death and ascension they would do greater works than He had done while He remained with them (John 14:12). As the Acts of the Apostles records, everything He foretold came to pass within a short time. And 3. The true spirit of Christian love will incline us to submit to the authority of these commands and to be moved by the reasons behind them. The spirit of love does this directly, through its own immediate tendency, and indirectly, by teaching and leading us toward humility.
First, Christian love disposes us to heed the commands that forbid envy, and to embrace the gospel's arguments against it, by its own immediate tendency. The nature of charity, or Christian love toward others, stands in direct opposition to envy, because love does not begrudge but rejoices in the good of those it cherishes. Surely love for our neighbor does not incline us to resent his prosperity or feel miserable at his good fortune. Love for God also carries a natural tendency to move us toward obedience, since the genuine, consistent fruit of loving God is doing what He commands. This means it will incline us toward obedience in those commands where He forbids envy just as much as in any others, and perhaps even more so, because love takes special delight in obeying commands that themselves require love. In the same way, love for God will move us to follow His example: He has not begrudged us our many blessings but has rejoiced in our enjoyment of them. It will also move us to imitate Christ, who did not begrudge His own life for our sake, and to follow the pattern He set throughout His earthly life. Second, a spirit of Christian love works toward the same end indirectly, by inclining us toward humility. Pride is the deep root and primary source of envy. It is because of pride that people burn with the desire to stand out and to be superior to everyone else in honor and prosperity, and it is pride that makes them so restless and dissatisfied when they see others rising above them. But a spirit of love tends to cut pride down and cultivate humility in the heart. Love for God works toward this because it involves a genuine sense of His infinite excellence, which naturally produces a sense of our own comparative smallness and unworthiness. And love for others tends toward humble conduct among people, because it moves us to recognize the genuine qualities in others, to acknowledge that the honors given to them are deserved, and to regard them as better than ourselves and therefore more worthy of distinction. I will not dwell further on this point here, since a future lecture will give me a fuller opportunity to show how Christian love tends toward humility. Turning, then, to the application of this subject, I offer the following observation.
1. This should lead us to examine ourselves honestly, asking whether we are in any degree living under the influence of an envious spirit. Let us examine our past conduct and look back over how we have behaved among others. Many of us have been part of human society for a long time, living alongside others, dealing with them in countless ways, and connected to them across many situations, both in public and private life. We have watched others prosper, and perhaps prosper more than we have. They have had more of the world's goods, greater wealth, more ease, and far more comfortable and honorable circumstances than we have known. Some who we once considered our equals, or even our inferiors, we may have watched climb steadily in wealth and honor while we were left behind, until they now occupy a position far above our own. It may be that we have witnessed such changes and been called to endure such trials through much of our lives. And we have certainly seen, again and again, others enjoying an abundance of everything the world values while we have gone comparatively without. Now let us honestly ask how these things have affected us: how have our hearts responded, and how have we actually behaved in these circumstances? Has there not been a great deal of unease, dissatisfaction, and inner discomfort, along with a quiet desire to see the prosperous brought low? Have we not felt a flicker of satisfaction when we heard something to their disadvantage? In the gloomy predictions we have voiced about them, have we not really been expressing our wishes? And in word or deed, have we not been ready to do something that might in some way diminish their prosperity or reputation? Have we ever nursed a bitter or unkind attitude toward someone simply because of his success, or been inclined on that account to look at him with suspicion, to oppose him in public matters, or to side with those against him out of nothing more than envy? As we look back, do we not see that in these and many similar ways we have repeatedly given in to an envious spirit, and that our hearts have at times burned with it toward others?
Turning from the past to the present, what do you find when you honestly search your own heart? Do you carry an old grudge against this or that person you see sitting beside you week after week in the house of God, and from time to time at the Lord's table? Doesn't the prosperity of certain people irritate you? Does it make your life feel diminished that they have risen higher than you? Would it secretly comfort you to see them brought low, so that their losses and misfortunes became a source of quiet satisfaction? And doesn't that same spirit lead you to think ill of such people, or to speak of them with contempt, coldness, or harshness to those around you? Those who enjoy greater prosperity than others should also ask themselves whether they harbor a spirit of resistance toward the relative happiness of those beneath them. Isn't there a tendency in you to take pride in standing above others, and a desire that they should not rise further, lest they draw level with you or surpass you? And from that same root, aren't you willing to see them pulled down, even to help pull them down as far as you can, for fear that one day they might get the better of you? Doesn't all of this reveal that you are very much in the grip of an envious spirit?
But perhaps you're tempted to justify yourself here, refusing to call this feeling envy and reaching instead for some other name, some other excuse that makes your envious spirit seem reasonable. Some people are quick to say of others that they don't deserve the honor and prosperity they've received, that many of their neighbors who remain beneath them are far more qualified and worthy of such advancement. But I ask you: where in the world is the person who envies another's honor or prosperity and yet doesn't also think or say that the other person doesn't deserve what they have? Did Joseph's brothers consider him worthy of their father's special love? Did Haman think Mordecai deserved the honor the king gave him? Or did the Jews think the Gentiles worthy of the privileges extended to them under the gospel, when they were so consumed with envy over it, as we read in Acts (13:45; 17:5)? It is almost universally the case that when others are promoted to positions of honor, or come into remarkable prosperity in any way, there are always people ready to seize the moment to catalog their faults, proclaim their unworthiness, and dig up every possible piece of dirt on them. Yet the real issue isn't that these people have faults, because those same faults would often go unnoticed if the person remained obscure. The real issue is that they are prospering. Those who talk so loudly about their faults are simply envious of their prosperity, and that envy is what drives the criticism. I would urge anyone who believes they are justified in opposing others on the grounds that those others don't deserve their prosperity to ask themselves honestly which troubles them more: their neighbor's faults, or their neighbor's success. If it's truly the faults that bother you, then you would be grieved by them whether the person was prospering or not. And if you were genuinely grieved by someone's faults, you would be very slow to speak of them to anyone except the person themselves, and even then only with a spirit of genuine Christian compassion and friendship. But perhaps you say that they make poor use of their prosperity and honor, that it has gone to their heads, that they can't handle it or don't know how to manage it, that they've become insufferable and contemptuous, impossible to deal with in their current state, and that it would be best for everyone if they were brought down a few notches. You tell yourself this would humble them, that the best thing for their own good is to see them returned to the place where they belong, the place that suits them. But here I urge you to examine yourself carefully: do you truly grieve over the harm their prosperity is doing to them? Do you mourn it for their sake, out of genuine love for them? Do your lamentations come from pity, or from envy? If you dislike their prosperity because it isn't good for them and is actually hurting them, then you will grieve for their suffering, not at their success. You will sincerely love them, and out of that love you will be genuinely sorry for the damage their prosperous condition is doing to them, feeling real compassion that the disadvantages of their situation so far outweigh its benefits. But is that honestly what you feel? Don't deceive yourself. Is it their suffering that grieves you, or simply the fact that they are prospering? Is your grief for them, because their prosperity is harming them, or is it for yourself, because their prosperity isn't yours? And here, too, let everyone ask whether they sometimes envy others for their spiritual prosperity. Recall the spirit of Cain toward Abel, of the seed of the serpent toward the seed of the woman, of Ishmael toward Isaac, of the Jews toward Christ, of the elder brother toward the prodigal son. Take care that you don't nurture that same spirit within yourself. Instead, rejoice in the good fortune of others as freely and fully as if it were your own.
2. The subject also exhorts us to reject and put away everything that resembles an envious spirit. Envy is so contrary to the Christian spirit, so evil in itself, and so harmful to others, that it should be rejected by everyone, and especially by those who claim to follow Christ. Many people cherish the hope that they have been given a new spirit, the very spirit of Christ. Let it be evident to all, then, that this is truly your spirit, by practicing the kind of love that does not envy. As the apostle James writes, "Who is wise and understanding among you? Let them show it by their good life, by deeds done in the humility that comes from wisdom. But if you harbor bitter envy and selfish ambition in your hearts, do not boast about it or deny the truth. Such wisdom does not come down from heaven but is earthly, unspiritual, and demonic. For where you have envy and selfish ambition, there you find disorder and every evil practice" (Jas 3:13-16). Envy is the precise opposite of the spirit of heaven, where all rejoice in one another's happiness. It is, in fact, the very spirit of hell itself: a deeply hateful disposition that feeds on the ruin and misery of others. For this reason, some have compared envious people to caterpillars, which take the greatest delight in devouring the most flourishing trees and plants. And as envy is hateful in itself, it is equally miserable for the person who harbors it. Just as it reflects the character of the devil, it also reflects the torment of hell. Solomon captures this vividly: "A peaceful heart gives life to the body, but envy rots the bones" (Prov 14:30). Envy is like a spreading cancer, consuming its host from within, corrupt and destructive. It is also the most foolish form of self-harm, because the envious person suffers needlessly, troubled only by the prosperity of others, even when that prosperity causes no real harm and takes nothing away from their own blessings. They cannot enjoy what they have simply because others are enjoying what they have. Let the sheer foolishness, the moral ugliness, and the disgrace of such a spirit drive us to reject it completely, to resist every excuse it offers, and to pursue instead the spirit of Christian love, that excellent quality of divine charity which leads us always to rejoice in the well-being of others and fills our own hearts with genuine happiness. This love "is from God" (1 John 4:7), and whoever lives in it "lives in God, and God in them" (1 John 4:16).
CHAPTER 7
LECTURE 7. THE SPIRIT OF LOVE IS A HUMBLE SPIRIT
"Charity vaunteth not itself, is not puffed up, doth not behave itself unseemly." (1 Cor 13:4-5)
Having already explored the nature and direction of charity, or Christian love, in two specific areas, the apostle now turns to a third. He has shown how love responds to injury and how it responds to the good fortune of others: it "suffers long and is kind," and it "envieth not." Now he shows how love responds to whatever we ourselves may be or possess. Charity is not proud. It does not boast, does not become arrogant, and does not conduct itself in ways that are unbecoming. Just as love keeps us from envying what others have, it also keeps us from glorying in what we have. Paul has just declared that charity runs contrary to a spirit of envy, and now he declares that it runs equally contrary to the spirit that most provokes envy in others, the spirit of self-promotion and pride in one's own success. When someone rises to prosperity or prominence and others see him puffed up about it, boasting openly, that attitude tends to stir envy and make those around him restless and resentful. But when a person enjoys the same prosperity and advancement without boasting or behaving badly on account of it, others find it far easier to accept his elevated position and to be genuinely content that he holds it. As noted earlier, people who envy others are quick to justify themselves by pointing to the other person's pride, arguing that he doesn't handle his good fortune well and is arrogant about it. But the apostle shows how Christian love tends to make everyone behave appropriately to their circumstances, whatever those circumstances may be: if they are below others, love keeps them from envy; if they are above others, love keeps them from pride and self-congratulation.
In this passage, we can observe that a spirit of Christian love is presented as the opposite of proud behavior, and that two degrees of such behavior are described. The higher degree is expressed by a man "vaunting himself," meaning he carries himself in a way that makes it obvious he takes pride in what he has or who he is. The lower degree is expressed by his "behaving himself unseemly," meaning he fails to conduct himself with appropriate dignity in his prosperity, but acts in a way that reveals he believes his good fortune places him above others. The spirit of charity, or love, is presented as opposed not only to proud behavior, but to a proud spirit, or pride in the heart itself, for charity "is not puffed up." The teaching we draw from these words, then, is this: THAT THE SPIRIT OF CHARITY, OR CHRISTIAN LOVE, IS AN HUMBLE SPIRIT.
In addressing this doctrine, I want to cover two things: first, what humility is, and second, how a Christian spirit, or the spirit of charity, is an humble spirit.
I. What humility is.
Humility can be defined as a settled disposition of mind and heart that reflects our comparative unworthiness and lowliness before God. It is a genuine awareness of our own smallness in His sight, along with the inclination to live in a way that reflects that awareness. Humility has several components: it involves the intellect, in the way we think about and understand ourselves; the will; the sense or estimate we hold of ourselves; and the inclination to behave in a way consistent with that estimate. The first element of humility is:
1. A sense of our own comparative smallness. I say comparative smallness because humility is a virtue suited to beings who are, in many respects, genuinely glorious and excellent. The saints and angels in heaven, for instance, excel in humility, and humility is entirely fitting for them, even though they are pure, spotless, and glorious beings, perfect in holiness and remarkable in mind and strength. Yet for all their glory, they remain comparatively small before God, and they know it. Scripture says that God "humbles Himself to behold the things that are in heaven" (Ps 113:6). Likewise, the man Christ Jesus, the most excellent and glorious of all created beings, is meek and lowly in heart and surpasses all others in humility. This is one of Christ's excellencies, rooted in the fact that He is not only God but also man, and as a man He was humble. Humility is not, and cannot be, an attribute of the divine nature itself. God's nature is infinitely opposed to pride, and yet humility cannot properly be ascribed to Him. If it could, that would imply imperfection, which is impossible in God. He who is infinite in excellence and glory, and infinitely above all things, has no comparative smallness to speak of, nothing to be aware of in that regard, and therefore cannot be humble in this sense. But humility is an excellence suited to every created intelligent being, because all such beings are infinitely small before God, and most of them are in some way lesser than at least some of their fellow creatures. Humility means living out the apostle's instruction: "Do not think of yourself more highly than you ought, but think of yourself with sober judgment, according to the measure" not only of faith but of every gift "God has distributed to each of you" (Rom 12:3). As a virtue in human beings, humility involves a sense of one's comparative smallness in two directions: in relation to God, and in relation to fellow creatures. And first, humility consists primarily and most essentially in a sense of our smallness before God, that is, an awareness of the infinite distance between God and ourselves. We are small, insignificant creatures, worms of the dust, and we should feel ourselves to be nothing, even less than nothing, before the majesty of heaven and earth. Abraham expressed exactly this kind of awareness when he said, "I have taken it upon myself to speak to the Lord, though I am nothing but dust and ashes" (Gen 18:27).
There is no genuine humility without some measure of this spirit. However keenly we may feel our insignificance compared to other people, we are not truly humble unless we also grasp our nothingness before God. Some people think poorly of themselves in relation to others because of their modest circumstances, or because of a melancholy and despondent nature, or for some other reason entirely, while remaining completely unaware of the infinite distance between themselves and God. They may readily consider themselves humble, yet they possess no true humility at all. What matters most for us to understand about ourselves is what we are in comparison with God, our Creator, the one in whom we live and move and have our being, who is infinitely perfect in every way. If we remain ignorant of our smallness before Him, then the most essential and indispensable element of true humility is simply missing. But where this is genuinely felt, something else naturally follows: secondly, a sense of our own insignificance compared to many of our fellow creatures. For a person is not only small in comparison with God; he is also very small compared to the multitudes of beings who occupy a higher rank in the universe, and most people are small compared to many of their fellow human beings as well. When this sense of comparative smallness grows out of a genuine recognition of how small we are as God sees us, it takes on the character of true humility. The person who has a right understanding of himself before God will likely have his eyes open to see himself clearly in every other respect too. Seeing truly where one stands in relation to the first and highest of all beings tends greatly to help a person understand his place among all other creatures. And the one who does not rightly know the first and greatest of all beings, who is the fountain and source of everything else that exists, cannot truly know anything else with clarity. But to the degree that someone has come to know God, he is prepared for and drawn toward the knowledge of all other things, including himself in relation to others and his place among them.
All of this would apply to humanity considered in an unfallen state, and it would have been true of our race had our first parents never sinned and drawn their descendants into corruption with them. But humility in fallen human beings carries an even deeper sense of unworthiness, both before God and before other people. Our natural smallness consists in the fact that we are infinitely below God in every natural perfection, while He stands infinitely above us in greatness, power, wisdom, and majesty. A truly humble person recognizes how narrow the range of his own knowledge is, how vast his ignorance remains, and how limited his understanding is when set beside the understanding of God. He is aware of his weakness, of how little strength he actually possesses, and of how little he is capable of accomplishing on his own. He recognizes his natural distance from God, his dependence on Him, and the inadequacy of his own power and wisdom. He understands that it is by God's power that he is sustained and provided for, that he needs God's wisdom to direct his path, and that he needs God's strength to do what he should. He is conscious of his subjection to God, and he grasps that God's greatness is properly expressed in His authority as the sovereign Lord and King over all things. Such a person is genuinely willing to live under that authority, feeling that it is entirely fitting for him to submit to the divine will and yield in everything to God's rule. This kind of comparative smallness existed in humanity even before the fall. Even then, we were infinitely small and insignificant in relation to God. But our natural smallness has grown far greater since the fall, because the moral ruin of our nature has seriously damaged our natural faculties, even if it has not destroyed them entirely.
A truly humble person, since the fall, is also aware of his moral lowliness and corruption. This consists in his sinfulness. His natural lowliness is his smallness as a creature; his moral lowliness is his vileness and filthiness as a sinner. Unfallen man was infinitely distant from God in his natural qualities and attributes; fallen man is infinitely distant from Him also as a sinner, and therefore as something corrupt. A truly humble person is, to some degree, aware of his comparative lowliness in this sense: he sees how deeply polluted he is before an infinitely holy God, in whose sight even the heavens are not clean. He sees how pure God is, and how filthy and abominable he himself is before Him. Isaiah had exactly this sense of his own comparative lowliness when he saw God's glory and cried out, "Woe is me! for I am undone; because I am a man of unclean lips, and I dwell in the midst of a people of unclean lips: for mine eyes have seen the King, the Lord of hosts" (Isa 6:5). A humble awareness of our lowliness in this respect involves self-abhorrence, the kind that drove Job to exclaim, "I have heard of thee by the hearing of the ear; but now mine eye seeth thee: wherefore I abhor myself, and repent in dust and ashes" (Job 42:5-6). It also involves the kind of contrition and brokenness of heart that David describes when he says, "The sacrifices of God are a broken spirit; a broken and a contrite heart, O God, thou wilt not despise" (Ps 51:17), and the kind that Isaiah had in mind when he declared, "Thus saith the high and lofty One that inhabiteth eternity, whose name is Holy; I dwell in the high and holy place, with him also that is of a contrite and humble spirit, to revive the spirit of the humble, and to revive the heart of the contrite ones" (Isa 57:15). Both the awareness of our own smallness and the awareness of our moral corruption before God are captured in that poverty of spirit the Savior speaks of when He says, "Blessed are the poor in spirit: for theirs is the kingdom of heaven" (Matt 5:3).
To develop this sense of our own smallness and unworthiness that humility requires, we need more than just knowledge of God's greatness, though that is certainly essential to any honest self-understanding. We also need a genuine sense of His excellence and beauty. Demons and the damned perceive a great deal of God's power, wisdom, and sovereignty. God makes them aware of it through what they witness in His dealings with creation and what they experience in their own suffering. However reluctant they may be to acknowledge it, God compels them to recognize how far above them He is, and they will feel that reality even more acutely at and after the final judgment. Yet they have no humility, and they never will, because even though they see and feel God's greatness, they perceive nothing of His loveliness. Without that perception, true humility is impossible, since humility requires that a creature feel its distance from God not only in terms of His power, but also in terms of His beauty and goodness. The angels and redeemed souls in heaven perceive both: not only how much greater God is than they are, but how much more lovely He is as well. So even though they carry none of the absolute corruption that fallen human beings bear, they are still, when measured against God, described in terms like these: "The heavens are not clean in his sight" and "his angels he charged with folly" (Job 15:15; 4:18). From this sense of their comparative smallness, people come to feel how unworthy they are of God's mercy or gracious attention. Jacob expressed exactly this when he said, "I am not worthy of the least of all the mercies, and of all the truth which thou hast shewed unto thy servant" (Gen 32:10), and David when he exclaimed, "Who am I, O Lord God? and what is my house, that thou hast brought me hitherto?" (2 Sam 7:18). This is the posture of everyone who is truly humble before God. But humility is not only a matter of perceiving our comparative smallness; it also implies:
2. A disposition toward conduct that matches that perception. Without this, there is no genuine humility. If it were somehow possible for the mind to be enlightened to see its own smallness while the will and disposition of the soul refused to align with that understanding and actively resisted it, there would be no humility at all. As noted above, demons and the damned do perceive something of their comparative insignificance before God in certain respects. They know that God is infinitely above them in power, knowledge, and majesty. Yet because they neither know nor feel His loveliness and excellence, their wills and dispositions refuse to conform to what their lowly condition actually calls for, and so they have no humility whatsoever, but are filled with pride. Without attempting to catalogue every aspect of behavior that a proper sense of our smallness and unworthiness would call for (since that would encompass the whole of our duty toward both God and neighbor), I want to highlight several things worth noting, both in our conduct toward God and in our conduct toward others.
First, consider some things in our behavior toward God to which humility will incline us. As the first of these, humility moves a person to acknowledge his smallness and unworthiness before God openly and wholeheartedly. He sees how fitting and right it is to do this, and he does it willingly, even gladly. He freely confesses his own nothingness and corruption, acknowledges himself unworthy of any mercy, and recognizes that he deserves nothing but misery. It is the posture of the humble soul to lie low before God, to bow in the dust in His presence. Humility also inclines a person to distrust himself and to depend on God alone. The proud man, who holds a high opinion of his own wisdom, strength, or righteousness, is self-reliant. But the humble are not inclined to trust in themselves; they are skeptical of their own adequacy, and their natural disposition is to rely on God, to cast themselves on Him with genuine delight as their refuge, their righteousness, and their strength. The humble person is further inclined to refuse all credit for whatever good he has or does, and to give that credit entirely to God. If there is anything good in him, or any good accomplished through him, he has no desire to boast of it before God; instead, he attributes everything to God and echoes the words of the Psalmist: "Not unto us, O Lord, not unto us, but unto thy name give glory, for thy mercy and thy truth's sake" (Ps 115:1). It is also the disposition of the humble person to submit himself entirely to God. His heart does not resist full and unconditional submission to the divine will; it inclines toward it. He is disposed to obey God's commands and laws, because he sees it as right and good that one who is so infinitely inferior to God should live in such submission, and that it is an honor properly belonging to God to reign over him and give him direction. He is equally disposed to accept God's providence and daily ordering of his life, submitting cheerfully to whatever God appoints for him. Even when God ordains affliction, hardship, or lowly circumstances as his portion in this world, he does not complain; feeling his own smallness and unworthiness, he recognizes that difficult and painful circumstances are what he deserves, and that his situation is better than he has earned. And however dark God's dealings may appear, with the kind of faith we so often see in those who are most mature in grace, he is ready to say with Job: "Though he slay me, yet will I trust in him" (Job 13:15).
And just as humility shapes our behavior toward God, secondly, it shapes our behavior toward other people in ways that match our comparative smallness. I will illustrate this by pointing to the kinds of behavior humility tends to prevent. It tends, first of all, to prevent an ambitious and status-seeking manner of life. The person living under the influence of a humble spirit is content with whatever place among others God has seen fit to assign him. He does not hunger for honor or strive to appear above his neighbors. He lives by the principle behind the prophet's words: "Seekest thou great things for thyself? Seek them not" (Jer 45:5), and the apostle's instruction: "Mind not high things" (Rom 12:16). Humility also tends to prevent a showy or self-promoting manner of life. If the truly humble person has any advantage or blessing of any kind, whether material or spiritual, that others do not share, he will not be eager to put it on display. If he has greater natural abilities than those around him, he will not rush to parade them or take care that others recognize his superiority. If he has had a remarkable spiritual experience, he will not be anxious for people to know about it for the honor it might bring him; nor does he seek to be regarded as an eminent saint or a faithful servant of God, because what others think of him matters very little to him. If he has done something well, or fulfilled some duty at real cost to himself, he does not seek recognition for it, nor does he worry that it might go unnoticed. He is nothing like the Pharisees, who, as it is said, "did all their works to be seen of men" (Matt 23:5). If he has acted sincerely, he is content that the great God who sees what is done in secret has witnessed it and will approve it.
Humility also works against an arrogant and presumptuous manner. A person shaped by a humble spirit doesn't rush to overstep his bounds, and when he's among others, he doesn't carry himself as though he expects or demands a great deal of deference. His behavior doesn't suggest that he considers himself the best in the room, the one who deserves the most attention, or the one whose judgment everyone should seek out and follow. He doesn't act as though everyone should bow and yield to him, as if no one else matters as much as he does. He doesn't adopt an air of self-importance in ordinary conversation, in the conduct of his work, or in the practice of religion. He doesn't reach for authority that isn't his, as though the world were obligated to bend to his will and accommodate his preferences. Instead, he gives genuine respect to the judgments and wishes of others, and his whole manner reflects the truth of what the apostle taught: "Let nothing be done through strife or vain-glory; but in lowliness of mind let each esteem other better than themselves" (Phil 2:3). When he speaks about matters of faith, neither his words nor his bearing suggest that he considers himself among the finest saints in the room. Rather, he carries himself as one who, in the apostle's own words, is "less than the least of all saints" (Eph 3:8).
Humility also tends to prevent scornful behavior. Treating others with scorn and contempt is one of the worst and most offensive expressions of pride. But those who are shaped by a humble spirit are far from behaving this way. They don't look down on people beneath them with a haughty, superior air, as though those people were barely worth their attention or notice. They recognize that the difference between themselves and their fellow human beings is not so vast as to justify that kind of attitude. You won't find them dismissing what others say, mocking what others do, or sitting around retelling someone's words and actions just to get a laugh at their expense. On the contrary, humility moves a person toward a gracious, approachable manner with even the humblest and lowest people, treating those of lesser status with courtesy and warmth. This comes from a genuine awareness of one's own weakness and unworthiness before God, and from the recognition that it is God alone who gives any person an advantage over another. The truly humble will always have the spirit to "condescend to men of low estate" (Rom 12:16). Even those who hold positions of great public trust and honor will, if they are genuinely humble, treat those beneath them with the kind of graciousness described here, rather than carrying themselves with the haughty, scornful air of someone who wants the world to know how important they are.
Humility also tends to prevent willful and stubborn behavior. Those living under the influence of a humble spirit will not insist on their own way, whether in public or private affairs. They won't be rigid and inflexible, demanding that everything unfold according to whatever they happened to propose first. They won't cultivate a disposition that makes things difficult, unsettles others, and ensures that nothing gets done peacefully unless it goes their way. They are not like those Peter describes as presumptuous and self-willed (2 Pet 2:10), always bent on forcing their own agenda, and, when that fails, bent on opposing and irritating everyone around them. Humility, by contrast, inclines people toward a yielding spirit. For the sake of peace, and out of genuine regard for others, the humble person is willing to accommodate many preferences, and to defer to others' judgments wherever doing so doesn't compromise truth or holiness. A truly humble person is unyielding in only one thing: the cause of his Lord and Master, which is the cause of truth and virtue. Here he holds firm, because God and conscience demand it. But in matters of lesser importance, in things that don't touch his core convictions as a follower of Christ, and especially in things that affect only his own private interests, he is inclined to give way. And if he sees that others are being stubborn and unreasonable, he doesn't let that provoke him into matching their stubbornness with his own. Instead, he lives by the principles found in passages like these: "Dearly beloved, avenge not yourselves, but rather give place unto wrath" (Rom 12:19); "Why do ye not rather take wrong? why do ye not rather suffer yourselves to be defrauded?" (1 Cor 6:7); and "If any man will sue thee at the law, and take away thy coat, let him have thy cloak also. And whosoever shall compel thee to go a mile, go with him twain" (Matt 5:40-41).
Humility will also tend to prevent a leveling attitude. Some people are always eager to pull those above them down to their own level, while never being willing to lift those below them up. But a person shaped by genuine humility will avoid both extremes. On the one hand, he will be glad to see others rise as far as their diligence and character deserve; on the other hand, he will be willing to recognize those above him in their proper place, and to give them all the honor that is rightfully theirs. He won't wish for everyone to stand on the same footing, because he understands that gradations in society serve a real purpose: that some should hold higher positions, and be honored and deferred to accordingly. He is therefore content with this divine arrangement, and, in keeping with it, he shapes both his attitude and his conduct according to such commands as these: "Give to everyone what you owe them: if you owe taxes, pay taxes; if revenue, then revenue; if respect, then respect; if honor, then honor" (Rom 13:7); "Remind the people to be subject to rulers and authorities, to be obedient, to be ready to do whatever is good" (Titus 3:1).
Humility also works to prevent a self-justifying attitude. A person living under the influence of a humble spirit, if they have fallen into a fault (as everyone does at some point), or if they have wronged someone or brought dishonor to the Christian name and character, will be willing to own that fault and bear the shame of it. They won't resist being brought to an awareness of what they've done wrong, nor will they resist expressing that awareness through an honest acknowledgment of their error. They will be inwardly humbled by it, and ready to show that humility in the way the apostle describes: "Confess your faults one to another" (Jas 5:16). It is pride that makes people so reluctant to confess a fault when they've committed one, and that causes them to see confession as shameful when it is, in truth, among the highest honors available to them. Humility, by contrast, makes people prompt to do their duty in this regard, and when it operates as it should, it leads them to do so with eagerness and even genuine delight. And when someone offers such a person a Christian word of correction or rebuke for a fault, humility will dispose them to receive it graciously, even gratefully. It is pride that makes people so uncomfortable when a neighbor reproves them, so much so that they often can't bear it at all, responding instead with anger and a sharp bitterness of spirit. Humility, on the other hand, will dispose them not only to tolerate such reproofs, but to value and treasure them as expressions of genuine kindness and friendship. "Let the righteous smite me," says the Psalmist, "it shall be a kindness; and let him reprove me, it shall be an excellent oil, which shall not break my head" (Ps 141:5).
Having established what humility is in its nature, and where it leads us both in spirit and behavior, in our relationship to God and to our fellow human beings, I turn now, as proposed, to the second point: II. That the spirit of charity is a humble spirit. I will develop this in two parts: first, by showing how the spirit of charity, or divine love, implies and tends toward humility; and then by showing how the particular expressions of charity that the gospel draws out of us especially imply and tend toward it. And, 1. A spirit of charity, or divine love, implies and tends to humility.
First, it implies humility. The spirit of charity, or divine love, as we have already seen, is the sum of the Christian spirit, and therefore includes humility as one of its essential qualities. True divine love is humble love, and any love that lacks humility is not truly divine. This becomes clear from two considerations: a genuine sense of God's loveliness is precisely the kind of encounter with God that produces humility, and when God is truly loved, He is loved as an infinitely greater being. To take the first point: a genuine sense of God's loveliness is precisely the kind of encounter with God that produces humility. A sense of God's greatness alone, without any sight of His loveliness, will not accomplish this. It is the discovery of His loveliness that actually brings it about, making the soul truly humble. All grace is worked in the heart through the knowledge of God, through a clear perception of His perfections, and that knowledge is the foundation of every grace. It is the discovery of God as lovely, and not merely lovely but infinitely above us in loveliness, that works humility in the heart. Simply grasping the fact that God is infinitely above us, that there is an infinite distance between Him and us in terms of greatness, will not produce humility on its own. It will do nothing to make the heart humble unless we also recognize that there is an infinite distance between Him and us in His loveliness. This is evident both from the work of the law on the sinner's heart and from the experience of devils and the damned. When the law works on the heart, a person may feel the terrible greatness of God and yet have no humility at all, because they have no sense of His loveliness. All the Spirit's work, and all the work of law and gospel in the heart, is accomplished through conviction. There is a kind of conviction that unregenerate people have concerning God, one that awakens them and makes them feel their danger. It is a conviction of God's terrifying greatness, revealing itself through the demands and warnings of His law. But people can have this conviction, and often do, while remaining entirely without humility, because they have no sense of how far above them God is in loveliness. That is the one missing element, and without it, humility will not come.
And the same truth is evident from the experience of devils and damned spirits. They have a clear sense of God's infinite greatness over them, but they have no humility, because they don't feel how far above them He is in loveliness. As we have already observed, God makes the devils and the lost know and feel that He is above them in greatness and power, and that they are as nothing in His hands; and yet they remain proud, utterly without humility. At the day of judgment and beyond, they will see still more of His greatness. When Christ comes in the clouds of heaven, surrounded by His angels and clothed in the glory of His Father, the wicked will see that He is infinitely above them: the kings, the great rulers, the wealthy commanders, the powerful men of the world. As they behold His terrible majesty, they will hide themselves from His face. The devils, too, will see it, and will tremble far more violently at that moment than they tremble now at the mere thought of it. Both devils and wicked men will be made to know that He is the Lord, and they will know it beyond all doubt. They will know it by what they see and by what they feel when the sentence is executed upon them, that God is truly above them and they are as nothing before Him, as the prophet Ezekiel declared: "According to their deserts will I judge them; and they shall know that I am the Lord" (Ezek 7:27). Yet even though they will see so clearly and so terribly that God is infinitely above them in greatness, they will have no humility. They will see themselves at an infinite distance from God, but their hearts will not yield to that distance or feel what it truly demands. Because they will not see God's loveliness, they will not grasp their infinite distance from Him in that respect, and so they will never be led to humility. Their experience, then, demonstrates that it is a sense of the creature's infinite distance from the Creator in loveliness that produces true humility. This is what produces humility in the angels in heaven and in the saints on earth. And since it is a sense of God's loveliness that works humility in us, we can learn from this that divine love implies humility, for love is simply the heart's disposition toward God as lovely. If the knowledge of God as lovely causes humility, then a regard for God as lovely implies humility. From this love to God arises a Christian love to man; and it follows, therefore, that both love to God and love to man, the union of which is precisely what the apostle calls charity, equally and alike imply humility.
And divine love implies humility for another reason as well: when God is truly loved, He is loved as an infinite superior. True love for God is not love for an equal; everyone who genuinely loves God honors Him as God, that is, as a being infinitely greater and more excellent than all others. It is love directed toward a being who is infinitely perfect in every attribute, the supreme Lord and absolute Sovereign of the universe. But if we love God as one who is infinitely above us, then that love is exercised from the position of infinite inferiors, and it is therefore a humble love. In practicing it, we see ourselves as infinitely small and lowly before God, and our love flows from that recognition.
But loving God in this way means loving Him in humility, with a humble heart. Divine love, then, implies humility. Yet secondly, it also tends toward humility. Humility is not merely a quality embedded in divine love; it is also one of love's effects. Divine love does not only carry humility within its nature, but actively nurtures and produces it, drawing out its expressions as natural consequences and fruits of love. Humility is not simply implied in love, as though it were merely one component among many. It is a fruit, a consistent and reliable product of love, and this happens in two particular ways. First, love inclines the heart toward the kind of spirit and behavior that befits the distance between the soul and the one it loves. It is enmity toward God that makes people so resistant to loving Him and to conducting themselves in ways that honestly acknowledge the vast distance between themselves and Him. When people genuinely love someone, they are willing to honor that person, willing to acknowledge that person's superiority, and willing to recognize how far below them they stand. They are glad to give that person the honor such an acknowledgment requires, especially when the difference in standing is great. The devils understand their distance from God, but they are not at peace with it. The chief of devils sought to be God's equal, even His superior, precisely because he had no love for Him. And in a similar way, this is true of people as long as they remain without divine love. But when love enters the heart, the soul is drawn toward all the humble reverence that rightly reflects the distance between God and us. And so love for other people, flowing out of love for God, likewise disposes us to humility toward them, inclining us to give them all the honor and respect that is genuinely their due.
And so, love toward God naturally leads to an abhorrence of sin against God, and therefore to genuine humility before Him. Whatever we love, we will hate its opposite in equal measure. So, in direct proportion to our love for God, we will feel a corresponding revulsion toward sin against Him. And when we abhor sin against God, we will inevitably abhor ourselves for committing it, and that self-abhorrence will drive us to humble ourselves before Him. Having shown how divine love, which is the very heart of the Christian character, both implies and produces humility, I turn now to the second point: 2. How the gospel tends to draw forth expressions of love that especially imply and produce humility. A Christian spirit and a gospel spirit are one and the same thing. The Christian spirit is whatever the Christian revelation naturally leads us toward, and the Christian revelation is simply the gospel. Now, the particular expressions of love that the gospel draws out of us have a special tendency to produce humility and to embody it, and this is true for several reasons. First, because the gospel leads us to love God as an infinitely condescending God. More than anything else in the world, the gospel displays the extraordinary condescension of God. No other revelation God has ever given of Himself shows such breathtaking condescension as the Christian gospel does. It teaches us how God, who stoops even to notice what happens in heaven and on earth, lowered Himself so far as to take a gracious and tender interest in poor, wretched creatures made of dust, to concern Himself with their salvation, and to go so far as to send His only-begotten Son to die for them, so that they might be forgiven, lifted up, honored, and brought into eternal fellowship with Him, enjoying Him perfectly in heaven forever. The love that the Christian revelation calls us to, then, is love for God precisely as this condescending God, expressed in ways that are fitting toward a God of such infinite condescension. And such love, by its very nature, must be humble love, because no disposition in the creature corresponds more fittingly to condescension in the Creator than humility does. God's condescension is not, strictly speaking, humility, because, as already noted, humility is a virtue that belongs only to beings who occupy a comparatively lowly position. And yet, through His infinite condescension, God reveals a nature that is infinitely removed from and opposed to pride, which is why His condescension is sometimes described in terms of humility. On our part, humility is the most fitting response a creature can offer to God's condescension. His condescension naturally draws humility out of us.
Secondly, The gospel leads us to love Christ as a humble person. Christ is the God-man, uniting both the divine and human natures in one person; and so He possesses not only condescension, which is a divine perfection, but also humility, which is a creaturely excellence. The gospel presents Christ to us as one who is meek and lowly in heart, as the most perfect and complete expression of humility that has ever existed, as one in whom the greatest acts and signs of humility were displayed in His self-abasement. Though He was "in the form of God," He "made himself of no reputation, and took upon him the form of a servant," and "humbled himself, and became obedient unto death, even the death of the cross" (Phil 2:6-8). The gospel leads us to love Christ as this humble person; and therefore, to love Him with the kind of love that is fitting for such a one is itself to exercise a humble love. This is all the more true because the gospel leads us to love Christ not only as a humble person, but as a humble Savior, Lord, and Head. If our Lord and Master is humble, and we love Him as such, then it clearly becomes us, His disciples and servants, to be humble as well. It simply does not befit a servant to be prouder or less lowly than his master. As Christ Himself tells us, "The disciple is not above his master, nor the servant above his lord. It is enough for the disciple that he be as his master, and the servant as his lord" (Matt 10:24-25). He also tells us that His own example of humility was meant for our imitation (John 13:13-16), and He declares again to His disciples: "Ye know that the princes of the Gentiles exercise dominion over them, and they that are great exercise authority upon them. But it shall not be so among you: but whosoever will be great among you, let him be your minister; and whosoever will be chief among you, let him be your servant: even as the Son of man came not to be ministered unto, but to minister, and to give his life a ransom for many" (Matt 20:25-28).
Thirdly, The gospel calls us to love Christ as a crucified Savior. As our Savior and Lord, He endured the deepest shame and was put to the most degrading death imaginable, even though He was the Lord of glory. This reality should kindle humility in His followers and draw them toward a humble love for Him. When God sent His Son into the world to die such a shameful death, He was, in effect, pouring contempt on all the earthly glory that people are so prone to prize. He gave His Son, the Savior and Head of all His chosen people, to appear in circumstances utterly stripped of earthly honor, circumstances marked instead by the greatest earthly shame and disgrace. And Christ, by willingly accepting that humiliation and suffering, not only cast contempt on all worldly glory and greatness, but displayed His humility in the clearest way possible. If we truly see ourselves as followers of the meek, lowly, and crucified Jesus, we will walk humbly before God and man every day of our lives on earth.
Fourthly, the gospel further leads us toward humble expressions of love because it leads us to love Christ as one who was crucified for our sake. The mere fact of Christ's crucifixion is already a powerful argument for the humility of those who follow Him. But His being crucified for our sake is a far stronger argument still. Christ's crucifixion on our behalf is the greatest testimony God has ever given against our sins. It reveals more of God's hatred of sin than any other act or event He has ever directed or permitted. The depth of that hatred is measured by how terribly our sins were punished, and how fully His wrath was poured out against them, even when those sins were imputed to His own Son. This makes the cross the greatest possible inducement to humility, and for two reasons: it is the clearest revelation of the ugliness of what we should be humble about, and it is the strongest argument for embracing the humble spirit the gospel holds out to us. The excellence of Christ and the love of Christ shine more brightly in His willingness to be crucified for us than in any other act He performed. Taken together, these truths draw out humble love from us more powerfully than anything else could. In applying this subject, we may observe:
1. The excellence of a Christian spirit. "The righteous," we are told, "is more excellent than his neighbor" (Prov 12:26). Much of that excellence in the true Christian lies in his meek and lowly spirit, which makes him so like his Savior. The apostle describes this spirit (1 Pet 3:4) as the richest of all ornaments: "the ornament of a meek and quiet spirit, which is in the sight of God of great price."
2. Examine yourself, and see whether you truly have a humble spirit. "His soul which is lifted up is not upright in him," says the prophet (Hab 2:4). The fact that "God resists the proud" (Jas 4:6), or as the original puts it, sets Himself in battle array against him, shows how deeply God abhors a proud spirit. And not every appearance of humility will hold up under the scrutiny of the gospel. There are many imitations of it that fall short of the real thing. Some adopt an affected humility; others have a naturally low-spirited temperament and lack strength of character; others are melancholy or despondent; others, under the pressure of a guilty conscience, seem broken in spirit for a time; others appear deeply humbled during seasons of adversity and affliction, or experience a natural softening of the heart under ordinary exposure to truth; and in others still, there is a counterfeit humility produced by the delusions of Satan. Any of these can be mistaken for the genuine article. Examine yourself, then. Consider the nature of your humility: whether it belongs to one of these shallow categories, or whether it has truly been worked in your heart by the Holy Spirit. Do not rest content until you find that the spirit and conduct the gospel calls humble are genuinely your own.
3. The subject exhorts those who are strangers to the grace of God to seek that grace, so that they may attain this spirit of humility.
If this describes you, then you currently lack the Christian spirit, which is a spirit of grace, and therefore lack humility entirely. Your spirit is a proud one. You may not appear arrogant in your dealings with other people, but you are lifting yourself up against God by refusing to submit your heart and life to Him. In doing this, you are dismissing or defying God's sovereignty and daring to contend with your Maker, even though He issues dreadful warnings to those who do exactly that. You are proudly showing contempt for God's authority by refusing to obey it and continuing to live in disobedience: by refusing to conform to His will, by rejecting the humbling terms of salvation through Christ, and by trusting in your own strength and righteousness rather than the righteousness Christ so freely offers. Consider what kind of spirit this actually is. It is, in a particular sense, the sin of the devil himself. "Not a novice," the apostle writes, "lest, being lifted up with pride, he fall into the condemnation of the devil" (1 Tim 3:6). Consider also how deeply offensive such a spirit is to God, and how terribly He has threatened it. He declares that "every one that is proud in heart is an abomination to the Lord: though hand join in hand, he shall not be unpunished" (Prov 16:5). Again: "These things doth the Lord hate: a proud look" (Prov 6:16). And again: "a man's pride shall bring him low" (Prov 29:23). He tells us that His eyes are on the haughty, that He may bring them down (2 Sam 22:28), and that "the Lord of hosts hath purposed it, to stain the pride of all glory, and to bring into contempt all the honourable of the earth" (Isa 23:9). Consider also how Pharaoh, Korah, Haman, Belshazzar, and Herod were each terribly punished for their pride in heart and conduct. Let their examples warn you to cultivate a humble spirit, to walk humbly with God, and to treat your fellow human beings with genuine humility.
Finally, 4. Let everyone be earnestly urged to pursue a humble spirit and to strive for humility in all their conduct toward God and other people.
Seek a deep and lasting awareness of how small you are before God and before others. Know God truly. Acknowledge your own emptiness and unworthiness before Him. Distrust yourself. Rely on God alone. Refuse all glory except what comes from Him. Give yourself wholeheartedly to His will and His service. Turn away from every impulse toward ambition, self-promotion, arrogance, contempt, stubbornness, self-will, and self-justification. Instead, press toward more and more of the humble spirit that Christ Himself displayed while He walked this earth. Think carefully about all the reasons to pursue such a spirit. Humility is one of the most essential and defining marks of genuine faith. It accompanies every other grace and, in a unique way, purifies Christian feeling. It is the adornment of the soul, the source of some of the deepest and sweetest experiences in the Christian life, the most acceptable offering we can bring to God, and the quality to which He attaches His richest promises. It is the spirit in which He chooses to dwell on earth, and the spirit He will crown with glory in heaven. Pursue it earnestly, then, and nurture it with diligence and prayer. Do this, and God will walk with you here below. When a few more days have passed, He will welcome you into the honors He has prepared for His people at Christ's right hand.
CHAPTER 8
LECTURE 8. THE SPIRIT OF LOVE STANDS AGAINST SELFISHNESS
"Charity . . . seeketh not her own." (1 Cor 13:5)
Having examined the nature of charity in relation to others (showing that it is kind to them and does not envy their blessings), and also in relation to ourselves (showing that it is not proud, either in spirit or in behavior), I now turn to the next quality the apostle identifies: that charity "seeketh not her own." The teaching of these words is straightforward: THE SPIRIT OF CHARITY, OR CHRISTIAN LOVE, IS THE OPPOSITE OF A SELFISH SPIRIT.
The ruin that the fall brought upon the human soul consists largely in the loss of its nobler and more generous instincts, leaving it entirely under the dominion of self-love. Before the fall, as God had created him, man was elevated, dignified, and magnanimous; but afterward he became degraded, base, and self-serving. The moment the fall occurred, the human mind contracted from its original greatness and expansiveness into something remarkably small and narrow, and nowhere was this more evident than in the realm of love. Before, the soul operated under the governance of divine love, a noble principle that enlarged it to encompass all of humanity and their wellbeing. More than that, the soul was not even confined within the boundaries of creation itself; it reached outward in holy love toward the Creator, moving freely across the infinite ocean of goodness, absorbed into it, becoming one with it. But the moment man sinned against God, these noble principles vanished instantly. All that magnificent expansiveness of the human soul was gone. From that point forward, man shrank into a cramped and enclosed space, sealed off within himself, shut away from everything beyond his own interests. Sin, like a powerful astringent, compressed the soul down to the tiny dimensions of selfishness. God was abandoned, fellow human beings were abandoned, and man retreated into himself, governed entirely by narrow and self-serving impulses. Self-love became the absolute master of the soul, while its more noble and spiritual capacities took flight and disappeared. But God, in His mercy toward suffering humanity, undertook the work of redemption, and through the glorious gospel of His Son began drawing the human soul out of its confinement and contraction, restoring it to those noble and divine principles that had animated and governed it from the beginning. He accomplishes this through the cross of Christ, because our union with Christ gives us a share in His nature. Christianity therefore restores a genuine expansiveness, breadth, and generosity to the soul, filling it once again with that divine love or charity described in the text, through which it embraces its fellow human beings and is wholly devoted to and absorbed in the Creator. In this way, charity, which is the very essence of the Christian spirit, participates so fully in the glorious richness of the divine nature that it "seeketh not her own," standing in direct opposition to a selfish spirit. In developing this idea, I will first examine the nature of the selfishness that charity opposes, then explain how charity stands against it, and finally offer some of the evidence that supports this teaching.
I. I want to explore the nature of the selfishness that charity stands against. On this point, I'll begin with what charity is not. 1. Negatively: Charity, or the spirit of Christian love, is not opposed to all self-love. There is nothing un-Christian about a person loving himself, or, to put it another way, loving his own happiness. If Christianity actually worked to destroy a person's love for himself and his own happiness, it would be working to destroy something essential to our humanity. But the very announcement of the gospel as a message of peace on earth and goodwill toward humanity (Luke 2:14) shows that Christianity doesn't undermine our humanity at all; on the contrary, it promotes that spirit to the highest possible degree. A person's love for his own happiness is as natural to him as the capacity to choose; it cannot be eliminated without eliminating the person himself. The saints love their own happiness. Even those who are perfect in happiness, the saints and angels in heaven, love their own happiness; if they didn't, the happiness God has given them would mean nothing to them. After all, no one can enjoy what he doesn't love.
That loving ourselves is not unlawful is also clear from the fact that God's law makes self-love the very standard by which our love for others should be measured. Christ commands, "Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself" (Matt 19:19), which certainly assumes that we may, and indeed must, love ourselves. Notice that it does not say more than yourself, but as yourself. Since we are commanded to love our neighbor second only to God, it follows that we are to love ourselves with a love second only to what we owe to God Himself. This same point is reinforced by the fact that Scripture, from beginning to end, is filled with motivations designed precisely to appeal to the principle of self-love. This includes all the promises and warnings of God's Word, its calls and invitations, its counsel to pursue our own good, and its warnings to guard against ruin. These things can only move us insofar as they engage our hopes or our fears. After all, what would be the point of promising happiness or threatening misery to someone who neither desires the one nor dreads the other? And what sense would it make to counsel such a person to seek the one or avoid the other? It is therefore clear, on the negative side, that charity, or the spirit of Christian love, is not opposed to all self-love. But I want to go further and say something positive.
2. Affirmatively, that the selfishness which charity, or a Christian spirit, opposes is only an excessive self-love. Here, though, a question immediately arises: what exactly makes self-love excessive? This needs to be carefully stated and clearly resolved, because the answer bears directly on many of the doubts and uncertainties that people frequently struggle with. My first answer, then, is this: the excess of self-love does not consist in loving our own happiness too intensely, considered in itself. I don't think it can be said of anyone that their love for their own happiness, taken on its own terms rather than in comparison to other loves, can be too strong, or that it is something capable of being increased or decreased. Self-love in this sense, I would argue, is not a consequence of the fall. It is a necessary feature of every intelligent being's nature, and God has made it the same in all. Saints and sinners alike love happiness, and all share the same unchanging, instinctive drive to desire and pursue it. When a person is converted and sanctified, what changes is not the intensity of their love for happiness, but rather the way that love is ordered: the directions it takes, the things it pursues, and the objects it attaches itself to. Who would claim that the blessed souls in heaven love happiness any less than the miserable spirits in hell? If holiness actually diminished a person's love of happiness, it would diminish their happiness itself, since the less one loves happiness, the less one savors it, and therefore the less happy one actually is.
When God lifts a soul out of misery and into happiness through conversion, He gives that person a joy they never had before, but He doesn't remove their love of happiness in the process. In the same way, when a saint grows in grace, he becomes happier than he was before, but his love of happiness and his capacity to enjoy it don't diminish as his happiness increases, because that would mean increasing his happiness in one direction while undermining it in another. In every case where God makes a miserable soul happy, or a happy soul even happier, He preserves the same love of happiness that was already there. It follows, then, that the saints should have just as strong a love for their own happiness, or love for themselves (which amounts to the same thing), as the wicked do. So if we consider a person's love of self or of their own happiness in absolute terms, it becomes clear that disordered self-love doesn't consist in being too intense, because that intensity is the same in everyone. But I want to note, Secondly, that the disorder of self-love, which is the essence of corrupt selfishness, lies in two things: in being too great by comparison, and in placing our happiness in something that is confined to ourselves alone. First, the degree of self-love can be too great comparatively, making its influence disordered. Although the degree to which people love their own happiness, taken in absolute terms, may be the same in everyone, the proportion that self-love bears to love for others may not be equal across the board. When we compare a person's love of himself with his love for others, we might say he loves himself too much, meaning too much in proportion. And while this may stem from a deficiency of love toward others rather than an excess of love toward himself, self-love still becomes disordered through this imbalance, specifically in the way it governs and directs the person. Even though the principle of self-love, considered on its own, is no stronger than it would be if a proper love for God and neighbor existed alongside it, the greater proportion it holds means its influence over the person grows accordingly, and that influence becomes disordered precisely because the other loves that should restrain and regulate it are weak or absent entirely.
To illustrate this point, consider the case of a servant in a household who was kept in his proper place as long as his master remained strong. His influence over family affairs was not excessive while his master's authority held firm. But if the master later grows weak and loses his strength, and the rest of the household loses its former power as well, the servant's influence can become excessive even without his own strength increasing at all. Simply because the balance has shifted, he may go from being a subject and a servant to becoming the master of the house. This is precisely how self-love becomes disordered. Before the fall, humanity loved itself, or its own happiness, just as intensely as after the fall; but at that time, a higher principle of divine love held the throne and was strong enough to regulate and direct self-love entirely. Since the fall, however, the principle of divine love has lost its strength, or rather has died altogether, so that self-love, continuing at its former intensity with no higher principle to govern it, becomes excessive in its influence, ruling where it should be subject and serving only as a servant. Self-love, then, can become disordered not because it has grown stronger in itself, but because it has grown comparatively stronger relative to everything else. This happens either because love for God and neighbor has grown too weak, as is the case with the saints who still carry significant corruption in this life, or because that love is entirely absent, as is the case with those who have no divine love in their hearts at all. The disorder of self-love, then, is not a matter of its absolute degree but of its comparative influence. In some respects, wicked people don't love themselves enough, not as much as the godly do, because they don't pursue their own genuine welfare and happiness. In this sense, Scripture sometimes speaks of the wicked as hating themselves, even though in another sense they love themselves far too much.
It is further true, in the second place, that self-love, or a person's love of their own happiness, can become disordered by placing that happiness in things that belong only to oneself. In this case, the problem is not so much the intensity of one's self-love as it is the direction in which that love flows. The issue isn't how strongly someone desires their own happiness, but rather where they locate that happiness and how narrowly they confine their love. Some people, though they genuinely love their own happiness, don't place that happiness in goods that belong exclusively to themselves. Instead, they find their happiness in the common good, in what benefits others, or in the good that others enjoy. When self-love flows in this direction, it isn't what we call selfishness; it's actually the opposite. But others, in their love of their own happiness, locate that happiness in goods that are restricted and limited to themselves alone, cutting everyone else out. That is selfishness. This is precisely and most clearly what Scripture means when it condemns self-love. And when we read that charity does not seek her own, we should understand this as her own private good, the good that is limited to herself alone. The phrase "her own" is one of appropriation, and it naturally carries the sense of restriction to oneself. The same idea appears in "all seek their own" (Phil 2:21), which conveys the notion of a confined, self-appropriated good, the kind of good a person holds entirely for himself, sharing it with no one, having drawn such a tight circle around it that others are excluded entirely. The expression in "men will be lovers of their own selves" (2 Tim 3:2) carries the same meaning, for the phrase is as narrow as language allows, restricted to the self alone and excluding everyone else.
A person can love himself as deeply as possible, constantly longing for his own happiness, and yet place that happiness in something so worthy that the very act of pursuing it becomes an expression of profound love for God. Consider, for example, a man whose deepest longing is to enjoy God, to behold His glory, or to live in communion with Him. Or consider someone who finds his greatest happiness in glorifying God, who regards that act of giving glory as the highest conceivable good and longs for it with his whole being. In longing for it, he loves what he has identified as his happiness, because if he didn't love it, he wouldn't long for it at all. And to love one's happiness is, in a real sense, to love oneself. Yet in that same act, he loves God, because he has placed his happiness in God. Nothing more accurately deserves the name of love for any being or thing than placing our happiness in it. By the same logic, a person may place a significant portion of his happiness in the good of others, in his neighbors, for instance, and in seeking their welfare he may simultaneously love himself and his own happiness. Yet this is not selfishness, because it is not a narrow or confined self-love. Rather, his self-love flows outward through a channel wide enough to include others alongside himself. The self he loves is, in a sense, enlarged and multiplied, so that in the very acts by which he loves himself, he loves others as well. This is the Christian spirit, the excellent and noble spirit of the gospel of Jesus Christ. It is the nature of that divine love, or Christian charity, that the text describes. The Christian spirit stands in direct opposition to the selfish spirit rooted in a self-love that reaches only toward confined and limited objects: a man's worldly wealth, the kind of honor that comes from standing higher than his neighbors, his own comfort and ease, or the gratification of his bodily appetites and desires.
Having established what selfishness looks like and why the Christian spirit stands against it, I turn now, as planned, to show II. How the spirit of charity, or Christian love, is contrary to such a spirit. This can be seen in two particulars: that the spirit of charity, or Christian love, leads us to seek not only our own interests but those of others; and that it disposes us, in many cases, to give up or part with our own things for the sake of others. And, 1. The spirit of charity, or love, leads those who possess it to seek not only their own things, but the things of others.
First, such a spirit seeks to please and glorify God. The things that please God and Christ, and that serve the divine glory, are called the things of Christ, in contrast to our own things, as in the words, "All seek their own, not the things which are Jesus Christ's" (Phil 2:21). Christianity requires that we make God and Christ our primary end, and all Christians, to the degree that they actually live as Christians, live so that "for them to live is Christ." Christians are called to live in a way that pleases God and that "proves what is that good and acceptable and perfect will of God" (Rom 12:2). We should be the kind of servants of Christ who seek in all things to please our Master, as the apostle says: "Not with eye-service, as men-pleasers; but as the servants of Christ, doing the will of God from the heart" (Eph 6:6). And so we are required in all things, whether we eat or drink or whatever we do, to do all to the glory of God (1 Cor 10:31). This, surely, is a spirit that stands in direct opposition to self-seeking.
Secondly, those who have the spirit of charity, or Christian love, have a spirit that seeks the good of their fellow human beings. As the apostle commands, "Look not every man on his own things, but every man also on the things of others" (Phil 2:4). We should seek the spiritual good of others; and if we have a genuinely Christian spirit, we will desire and pursue their spiritual welfare and happiness, their salvation from hell, and their ability to glorify and enjoy God forever. That same spirit will also move us to desire and seek the temporal prosperity of others, as the apostle says, "Let no man seek his own, but every man another's wealth" (1 Cor 10:24). We should seek their pleasure in ways that simultaneously serve their lasting good, as the apostle again writes, "Even as I please all men in all things, not seeking mine own profit, but the profit of many, that they may be saved" (1 Cor 10:33); and again, "Let every one of us please his neighbour for his good to edification" (Rom 15:2).
But more specifically, under this heading, I want to highlight that a spirit of charity, or Christian love as it is directed toward our fellow human beings, stands in direct opposition to selfishness, because it is a sympathizing and merciful spirit. It moves people to consider not only their own hardships, but also the burdens and afflictions of others, the difficulties of their circumstances, and to treat the situation of those in need as if it were their own. A selfish person tends to magnify whatever suffering he is experiencing, as though his own deprivations were greater than anyone else's; and when he is not suffering, he is quick to conclude that he has no obligation to share what he has in order to help others. A selfish man is not inclined to notice the needs of those around him; he tends to overlook them, and can barely be persuaded to see or feel them at all. But a person of charitable spirit naturally perceives the afflictions of others, recognizes what makes those afflictions worse, and is filled with genuine concern for them, just as he would be for himself if he were in the same situation. He is also eager to help, finding real joy in meeting the needs of others and easing their difficulties. He delights in obeying the apostle's command: "Put on therefore, as the elect of God, holy and beloved, bowels of mercies, kindness" (Col 3:12). He nurtures the spirit of "wisdom that is from above," which is "full of mercy" (Jas 3:17), and, like the good man the Psalmist describes, he is "merciful," that is, full of mercy (Ps 37:26).
Beyond being compassionate and merciful, the spirit of charity as it is directed toward our fellow human beings stands in direct opposition to selfishness, precisely because it is a generous spirit. It doesn't merely seek the good of those who are suffering; it is ready to give freely to all and eager to promote their well-being whenever the opportunity arises. It never neglects the call to do good and to share with others (Heb 13:16), but instead obeys the exhortation, "As we have opportunity, let us do good to all people" (Gal 6:10). On this point, however, I don't need to go further, since I have already treated it at length in the lecture on "Charity is kind."
And just as the spirit of charity, or Christian love, stands opposed to selfishness in being merciful and generous, it also stands opposed to selfishness in this: it disposes a person to be public-spirited. A person of genuine character is not narrow-minded or self-focused, but is deeply invested in the good of the community to which he belongs, particularly the city or village where he lives, and in the true welfare of the society of which he is a part. God commanded the Jews who had been taken captive to Babylon to seek the good of that city, even though it was not their homeland but only the place of their captivity. His instruction was, "Seek the peace of the city where I have caused you to be carried away captive, and pray to the Lord for it" (Jer 29:7). A person of truly Christian spirit will be earnest about the good of his country and the place where he lives, and will be ready to give himself to its improvement. A man was commended to Christ by the Jews as someone who loved their nation and had built them a synagogue (Luke 7:5), and it is described as something deeply offensive to God that certain people in Israel "were not grieved for the affliction of Joseph" (Amos 6:6). It is recorded to the lasting honor of Esther that she fasted and prayed, and urged others to do the same, for the welfare of her people (Esth 4:16). The apostle Paul expresses the most profound concern for the welfare of his fellow countrymen (Rom 9:1-3). Those who possess the spirit of Christian charity are broader in their concern still, for they care not only about the prosperity of their immediate community, but about the welfare of the Church of God and of all God's people individually. Moses, the man of God, was exactly this kind of person, which is why he interceded so earnestly for God's visible people and declared himself willing to die so that they might be spared (Exod 32:11, 32). Paul was the same, so deeply concerned for the welfare of all, both Jews and Gentiles, that he was willing to become as they were if it meant he might save some of them (1 Cor 9:19-23).
Especially will the spirit of Christian love move those who serve in public roles, such as ministers, magistrates, and other public officials, to pursue the common good. It will move magistrates to govern like fathers of a household, bringing to their public duties the same care and concern that a father brings to his family. It will make them alert to public dangers and eager to use their authority for the benefit of those they serve, rather than being driven by self-interest in how they govern. They will not seek primarily to enrich themselves, to build their own reputations, or to advance at the expense of others, as corrupt rulers so often do, but will strive genuinely for the welfare of all who fall under their authority. The same spirit will move ministers away from squeezing as much as they can from their congregations for personal gain, and toward seeking the good of the flock that the great Shepherd has placed in their care: feeding them, watching over them, leading them to good pastures, and defending them from those who would destroy them. And so, whatever position of honor or influence we occupy, we should demonstrate through it a genuine concern for the public good, so that the world is better for our having lived in it, and so that when we are gone, it may be said of us what was so nobly said of David, that we "served our generation by the will of God" (Acts 13:36). But, 2. The spirit of charity, or love, also moves us, in many cases, to give up what is ours for the sake of others. It moves us to set aside our own private, temporal interests, freely and completely, for the sake of God's honor and the advancement of Christ's kingdom. This was the spirit of the apostle Paul when he declared, "I am ready not to be bound only, but also to die at Jerusalem for the name of the Lord Jesus" (Acts 21:13). The same spirit will also move us to give up our private interests for the good of our neighbors. It will make us ready on every occasion to help them, willing to accept a lesser good for ourselves in order to secure a greater good for them. The situation may even arise, as Scripture says, where "we ought to lay down our lives for the brethren" (1 John 3:16). But I will not linger on this point now, as I will likely have occasion to address it more fully under another part of this discussion. I turn, then, as proposed, III. To consider some of the evidence that supports the doctrine already stated. The truth of the doctrine, that the spirit of charity, or Christian love, stands in direct opposition to a selfish spirit, will become clear when we examine the nature of love in general, the distinctive nature of Christian or divine love, and the nature of Christian love toward God and toward others in particular. And, 1. The nature of love in general. Genuine, sincere love is by its very nature expansive; it reaches outward and takes up the interests of others. This is true of natural affection and ordinary human friendship. Wherever real affection or friendship exists, the parties involved do not pursue only their own interests but take up and seek the interests of one another. They look not only to their own concerns, but to the concerns of those they love. Selfishness is a principle that shrinks the heart and closes it in on itself, while love opens the heart and extends it toward others. Through love, a person's sense of self expands so that those who are loved become, in a real sense, part of that person, so that when their interests are advanced, he feels his own are advanced, and when theirs are harmed, he feels his own are harmed as well. This becomes even clearer when we consider, 2. The distinctive nature of Christian or divine love. It is especially true of charity, or Christian love, that it rises above the selfish principle. While all genuine love for others seeks the good of those who are loved, every other kind of love, apart from this, is rooted in some sense in self-love. This is true of the natural affection parents feel for their children, and of the love that relatives have for one another. Setting aside the impulses of instinct, self-love is the driving force behind it. People love those who belong to them, those closely connected to them, those whose honor and interest are bound up with their own, precisely because they love themselves. The same is true of the closest friendships among people: self-love is the spring from which they flow. Sometimes natural gratitude for kindnesses received moves people, through self-love, toward a similar regard for those who have shown them favor or advanced their interests. And sometimes people are drawn into friendship with others because they see in them qualities that promise some personal advantage. If they find that others are inclined to show them respect and honor, love of their own reputation will draw them toward such people. If they find others to be generous toward them, love of their own benefit will incline them to friendship on that basis. If they discover a strong agreement in temperament and manner, self-love may draw them into companionship for the enjoyment of that harmony, or because seeing their own ways reflected in another amounts to a kind of approval of themselves. There are many other ways in which self-love serves as the source of the love and friendship that arises among people in the natural order. Most of the love that exists in the world grows from this root, and for that reason it never rises above nature. Nature cannot transcend self-love; everything people do traces back, in one way or another, to this same source.
Divine love, or the charity spoken of in the text, stands above self-love precisely because it is supernatural, reaching beyond everything that belongs to our natural condition. It is not a branch that grows from the root of self-love, the way natural affection does, or worldly friendships, or the ordinary love people have for one another. Self-love is the offspring of natural principles, but divine love is the offspring of supernatural ones. It belongs to a higher and nobler order than anything that grows naturally in the soil of the human heart. It is a plant transplanted into the soul from the garden of heaven by the holy and blessed Spirit of God, and so its life is rooted in God, not in self. This is why no other love rises so far above the selfish principle as Christian love does. No other love is so free and so genuinely disinterested, so oriented toward loving God for His own sake, and toward loving people not because of their connection to us, but because of their connection to God: as His children, as creatures of His power, or as those under the influence of His Spirit. Divine love, or charity, is therefore more opposed to a selfish spirit than any other love in the world. Natural love may, in certain respects, work against selfishness, since it can and often does move people toward great generosity toward those they care about. Yet in other respects it remains aligned with a selfish spirit, because when you trace it back to its source, it grows from the same root: the principle of self-love. But divine love has its source where its root is, in Jesus Christ, and so it does not belong to this world but to a higher one, and it tends back toward where it came from. Because it does not spring from self, it does not tend toward self either. It delights in the honor and glory of God for His own sake, not merely for the sake of self, and it seeks and delights in the good of others for their sake and for God's sake. That divine love is indeed a principle far above and contrary to a selfish spirit is made even clearer by this: it extends even to enemies. Its very nature is to reach out toward the ungrateful and the wicked, toward those who harm and hate us, which runs directly counter to every selfish instinct and is entirely beyond what nature produces. It is less like human nature and more like God's.
That Christian love, or charity, is contrary to a selfish spirit is further evident 3. From the particular nature of this love toward God and toward other people. And first, from the nature of this love toward God. When we consider what Scripture tells us about what it means to love God, we find that those who truly love Him love Him in a way that leads them to devote themselves entirely to Him and His service. This is what we are taught in the summary of the Ten Commandments: "You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind, and with all your strength" (Mark 12:30). These words describe what genuine love for God looks like, and they teach us that those who love Him rightly give themselves over to Him completely. They devote everything: all their heart, all their soul, all their mind, all their strength, every faculty and capacity they possess. A person who gives all of this to God holds nothing back. He makes no reservation, no private exception, but surrenders himself wholly and entirely. And all who truly love God have a spirit inclined to do exactly this. This reveals just how far a principle of genuine love for God rises above the selfish principle. If self is wholly devoted to God, then something above self has overcome it, something superior that takes hold of self and offers it up to God. A selfish principle never devotes itself to another; its very nature is to devote everything else to itself. Those who truly love God love Him as God, as the supreme good, whereas selfishness by its nature sets self up in the place of God and makes an idol of it. Whatever a person regards as supreme, that is what he devotes everything to. Those who idolize self devote everything to self, but those who love God as God devote everything to Him.
That Christian love, or charity, stands in direct opposition to a selfish spirit becomes even clearer when we consider what the Scriptures teach us, secondly, about the nature of this love toward others. The Bible offers two chief and especially striking descriptions of what it means to love our neighbors with genuine grace, and each one deserves careful attention.
The first of these is the command to love our neighbor as ourselves. We find it in the Old Testament: "Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself" (Lev 19:18), and Christ cites it in Matt 22:39 as the summary of every duty contained in the second table of the law. This command stands in direct opposition to selfishness, because love is not the kind of thing that locks the heart in on itself. It draws the heart outward, toward others, in the same way and with the same energy that it naturally moves toward the self. Love disposes us to see our neighbors as, in a real sense, one with us; it moves us not only to consider our own circumstances and interests, but to weigh the needs of others with the same seriousness we bring to our own. It means attending not only to our own desires, but to the desires of those around us, and treating them as we ourselves would want to be treated.
The second remarkable way Scripture describes Christian charity, showing how completely opposed it is to selfishness, is this: we are to love others as Christ has loved us. "A new commandment," Jesus says, "I give unto you, That ye love one another; as I have loved you, that ye also love one another" (John 13:34). It is called a new commandment to distinguish it from the older one found in Lev 19:18: "Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself." This doesn't mean the duty of love itself was new, since the same kind of love was required under the Old Testament as is required now. Rather, it is called new because the rule and motivation attached to it, the ones we are now especially meant to keep in view in this age of the gospel, are new. The rule and motivation that stood at the center of the old commandment was our love for ourselves: we were to love our neighbor as ourselves. But the rule and motivation now placed before us, in this age of the gospel and in light of Christ's extraordinary love, is Christ's love for us: we are to love our neighbor as Christ has loved us. John 15:12 reinforces this, where Christ calls it his commandment, saying with unmistakable emphasis, "This is my commandment, That ye love one another, as I have loved you." The command to love one another as we love ourselves belongs to Moses; the command to love one another as Christ has loved us belongs to God our Savior. In its essential substance, it is the same commandment given long ago, but now it is illuminated by the love of Jesus Christ and strengthened by an enforcement that goes beyond anything Moses attached to it. This standard of loving others as Christ has loved us therefore shows us our duty and obligation toward our neighbors more clearly, and to a greater degree, than Moses' formulation ever did.
But to return from this digression, let us consider how Christ's description of Christian love reveals it as the direct opposite of selfishness. We can see this clearly by examining how Christ expressed His love for us, and how powerfully His example challenges every selfish impulse. This becomes evident in four things:
First, Christ set His love on those who were His enemies. The people He loved showed no love toward Him whatsoever; in fact, they were filled with active hostility and hatred toward Him. As Paul writes, "God demonstrates His own love for us in this: while we were still sinners" (Rom 5:8), and a few verses later, while we were still "enemies," "Christ died for us" (Rom 5:10).
Second, Christ's love for us was so profound that He was willing, in certain respects, to regard us as Himself. Through His love, if we will only receive it, He has so completely joined Himself to us and united His heart with ours that He speaks of us and treats us as though we were part of Himself. His chosen people were, from all eternity, as precious to Him as the apple of His eye. He identified with them so fully that He treated their concerns as His own concerns and their interests as His own interests. He even took their guilt upon Himself through a gracious act of substitution, so that it could be reckoned as His own. Through that divine imputation, they are treated as innocent while He suffers in their place. His love has worked to unite them to Himself so completely that they become, in a sense, members of His own body, His flesh and His bones, as He Himself seems to suggest in Matt 25:40, when He declares, "Whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers and sisters of mine, you did for me."
Third, Christ's love for us was such that He, in a very real sense, spent Himself entirely on our behalf. His love didn't stop at warm feelings or modest effort. Though we were His enemies, He loved us enough to deny Himself completely, to take on the most demanding labors, and to endure the most severe suffering imaginable. He surrendered His ease, His comfort, His interests, His honor, and His wealth. He became poor, rejected, and despised, with nowhere to rest His head, and He did all of this for us. And beyond even that, He shed His own blood for us, offering Himself as a sacrifice to divine justice so that we might be forgiven, accepted, and saved. Fourth, Christ loved us this way with no expectation of ever being repaid. He had no need of anything we could offer Him, and He knew perfectly well that we would never be able to repay His kindness, or even come close. He knew we were poor, miserable, empty-handed outcasts who could receive from Him but give nothing back. He knew we had no currency, no price to offer, and that He would have to give us everything we needed freely, or we would go without it forever. Given all of this, shouldn't we be as far from a selfish spirit as possible, and utterly opposed to it, if we love one another in the same way, or if we carry toward others the same spirit of love that Christ carried toward us? If this is truly our spirit, our love for others won't depend on whether they love us in return. We will do what Christ did for us: love people even when they are enemies. We won't only look out for our own interests; we will be so genuinely united to others in our hearts that we will treat their concerns as our own. We will seek to be invested in their good, just as Christ was invested in ours, and we will be ready to give up our own things, in many cases, for the sake of others, just as Christ did for us. And we will do all of this without expecting anything back, just as Christ did such extraordinary things for us without any expectation of return. If this is the spirit we live by, we won't be driven by selfishness. We will be genuinely unselfish in our convictions, our hearts, and our lives.
In applying this subject, the great practical use I want to make of it is to discourage everyone from a selfish spirit and way of life, and to urge everyone to seek the spirit and live the life that stands in direct opposition to it. Seek to have your heart devoted to God and His glory through divine love, and to love your neighbor as yourself, or rather as Christ has loved you. Don't pursue only your own interests, but give genuine attention to the interests of others as well. To stir you toward this, consider three things in addition to the motivations already presented:
First, you are not your own. Just as you did not make yourself, you were not made for yourself. You are neither the author nor the purpose of your own existence. Nor do you sustain yourself, provide for yourself, or depend on yourself. There is another who made you, who preserves you, who provides for you, and on whom you are entirely dependent: and He has made you for Himself, and for the good of your fellow human beings, not merely for yourself. He has set before you higher and nobler ends than self-interest: the welfare of your fellow men, the health of society, and the advancement of His kingdom. For these you should labor and live, not only in this life, but with eternity in view.
And if you are Christians, as many of you claim to be, then in a very real sense "you are not your own; for you were bought with a price," namely "the precious blood of Christ" (1 Cor 6:19-20; 1 Pet 1:19). The apostle uses this as a direct argument against self-seeking: "Therefore glorify God in your body, and in your spirit, which are God's." By nature you were in a miserable, lost condition, a captive in the hands of divine justice and a wretched slave to sin and Satan. Christ has redeemed you, and so you belong to Him by purchase. By the most just title imaginable, you are His and not your own. You must not, therefore, go on treating yourself as if you were your own property, pursuing only your own interests and pleasures, or even making them your primary concern; to do so would be to rob Christ. And just as you are not your own, nothing you possess is truly yours either. Your physical and mental abilities, your material possessions, your time, your talents, your influence, your comforts: none of these belong to you. You have no right to use them as though you owned them outright, which is exactly what you will do if you imagine they exist solely for your private benefit rather than for the honor of Christ and the good of your fellow human beings.
Consider, Second, how your very profession as a Christian unites you to Christ and to your fellow Christians. Christ and all Christians are so bound together that they form a single body, with Christ as the head and Christians as the members. "We, being many," the apostle writes, "are one body in Christ, and every one members one of another" (Rom 12:5); and again, "By one Spirit are we all baptized into one body, whether we be Jews or Gentiles, whether we be bond or free" (1 Cor 12:13). How deeply out of place it is, then, for Christians to be self-centered and concerned only with their own private interests. In the physical body, the hand readily serves the head, and every member readily serves the others. Does the hand act only for its own benefit? Is it not constantly at work for the other parts of the body just as much as for itself? Day after day, isn't everything the hand does directed toward the common good of the whole body? The same can be said of the eye, the teeth, and the feet: none of them work for themselves alone or for their own narrow welfare, but for the shared comfort and health of the entire body. And if the head is dishonored, don't all the members immediately spring into action to remove that dishonor and restore dignity to the head? And if any member is wounded, weakened, or in pain, don't all the other members at once rally around it? The eyes scan for help, the ears listen for a physician's instructions, the feet carry the body to where relief can be found, and the hands apply whatever remedy is available. This is exactly how the body of Christ should function. All its members should be helpers and sources of comfort to one another, promoting their mutual welfare and happiness, and the glory of Christ their head.
Consider once more, Third, that in seeking the glory of God and the good of your fellow human beings, you take the surest possible path to having God seek your interests and promote your welfare. If you devote yourself to God, offering up all your own interests to Him as a sacrifice, you will not be throwing yourself away. Though you may appear to neglect yourself, to deny yourself, to set self aside in imitating the divine generosity, God will take care of you. He will ensure that your interests are provided for and your welfare secured. You will not lose anything by the sacrifices you have made for Him. To His glory be it said, He will not remain in your debt; He will repay you a hundredfold even in this life, to say nothing of the eternal rewards He will bestow on you hereafter. His own words are: "Every one that hath forsaken houses, or brethren, or sisters, or father, or mother, or wife, or children, or lands, for my name's sake, shall receive an hundred-fold" (with another Gospel writer adding "in this present time"), "and shall inherit everlasting life" (Matt 19:29). The spirit of this promise extends to every sacrifice made for Christ, or for our fellow human beings for His sake. Christ uses a specific number to convey the greatness of the reward in this life, but when it comes to the reward that awaits us hereafter, no number suffices. He simply says they will receive everlasting life, because that reward so far exceeds every cost and act of self-denial anyone could ever undertake for Christ's sake that no figure could begin to capture it.
If you are selfish, and make yourself and your own private interests your idol, God will leave you to yourself and let you promote your own interests as best you can. But if you stop grasping for your own advantage and instead seek the things of Jesus Christ and the good of those around you, then God will take your interests and happiness as His own responsibility, and He is infinitely more capable of providing for and advancing them than you ever could be. The resources of the entire universe move at His command, and He can easily direct them all toward your welfare. So, refusing to seek your own in the selfish sense is actually the surest way to seek your own in a far better sense. It is the most direct path you can take toward securing your highest happiness. When you are called not to be selfish, you are not being asked, as has already been noted, to stop loving or pursuing your own happiness; you are only being asked not to make your narrow, private interests your primary concern. But if you place your happiness in God, in glorifying Him and serving Him through doing good, then by that path above all others you will advance your wealth, your honor, and your joy in this life, and you will obtain in the life to come a crown of unfading glory and pleasures forevermore at God's right hand. If you grasp in a spirit of selfishness to claim everything as your own, you will lose everything, and be driven from this world at last, naked and desolate, into everlasting poverty and contempt. But if you seek not your own, but the things of Christ and the good of your fellow human beings, then God Himself will be yours, and Christ yours, and the Holy Spirit yours, and all things yours. Yes, "all things" will be yours: "whether Paul, or Apollos, or Cephas, or the world, or life, or death, or things present, or things to come; all are yours; and ye are Christ's; and Christ is God's" (1 Cor 3:21-22).
Let these things, then, move us all to be less selfish than we are, and to pursue more of that contrary and excellent spirit. Selfishness is native to us; in fact, all the corruption of our nature is rooted in it. But given what we know of Christianity, and how numerous and powerful its motivating truths are, we should be far less selfish than we are, and far less inclined to pursue our own interests to the exclusion of everything else. How much of this evil spirit there is in us, and how little of that excellent, noble, outward-reaching spirit that has just been set before us! Whatever the cause may be, whether it comes from holding too narrow a view of Christianity, from not having truly learned from Christ as we should, or from habits of selfishness inherited from those who came before us, let us strive to overcome it. In doing so, we will grow in the grace of an unselfish spirit, and through that growth, glorify God and do good to others.
CHAPTER 9
LECTURE 9. THE SPIRIT OF LOVE IS THE OPPOSITE OF AN ANGRY SPIRIT
"Charity... is not easily provoked." (1 Cor 13:5)
Having declared that charity stands opposed to the two great cardinal vices of pride and selfishness, those deep and ever-flowing fountains of sin in the human heart, the apostle now moves on to show that it is also contrary to two things that commonly grow out of pride and selfishness: an angry spirit and a censorious spirit. I want to turn your attention to the first of these, namely that charity "is not easily provoked." The doctrine before us is this: THE SPIRIT OF CHARITY, OR CHRISTIAN LOVE, IS THE OPPOSITE OF AN ANGRY OR WRATHFUL SPIRIT OR DISPOSITION.
In addressing this doctrine, I will first examine what this angry spirit or temper actually consists of, and then explain why a Christian spirit stands in opposition to it.
1. What is the angry or wrathful spirit that charity, or a Christian spirit, opposes?
Not every form of anger is contrary to Christianity. Eph 4:26 says, "Be angry, and do not sin," which implies that anger without sin is possible, and that in certain situations a person can be angry without offending God. The short answer, then, is that a Christian spirit, or the spirit of charity, stands opposed to all anger that is undue and unsuitable. But anger can be undue or unsuitable in four distinct ways: in its nature, its occasion, its end, and its measure. 1. Anger may be undue and unsuitable in respect to its nature. Anger can be defined as an earnest, and more or less forceful, opposition of spirit against some real or perceived evil, or in response to a fault or offense committed by another person. All anger involves the mind pushing back against real or perceived evil, but not every such response qualifies as anger in the proper sense. There is, for instance, an opposition of the judgment that is not anger at all, because anger is not the resistance of cool, detached reasoning; it is the resistance of the spirit itself, meaning a person's disposition or heart. Even so, not every opposition of the spirit against evil can be called anger either. There is a kind of opposition directed at natural evil, the suffering we endure, as in grief and sorrow, and that is something quite different from anger. Anger, by contrast, is directed at moral evil: real or perceived wrongdoing on the part of agents who act voluntarily, or who are at least understood to be acting by their own will, and whose actions are considered their fault. Yet even here, not every opposition of spirit against moral fault rises to the level of anger, because a person can dislike something without the spirit being stirred or provoked. That kind of dislike is an opposition of the will and the judgment, not necessarily of the feelings, and for anger to exist, the feelings must be moved. In all genuine anger there is earnestness, an opposition of feeling, and an inner agitation of the spirit. Anger is one of the passions or affections of the soul, though when it is described as an affection, it is, for the most part, to be understood as an evil one.
Such being the general nature of anger, we can now examine what makes anger improper or unsuitable. This is the case with any anger that contains ill-will or a desire for revenge. Some have defined anger as simply a desire for revenge, but this cannot be an accurate definition of anger in general, because if it were, every form of anger would imply ill-will and a wish to see others harmed. Yet there is clearly such a thing as anger that is entirely consistent with good-will. A father, for instance, may be angry with his child: he may feel within himself a deep earnestness and an inward resistance to his child's bad behavior, and his spirit may be genuinely stirred in opposition to that behavior and to the child who persists in it. And yet, at the very same time, he may have no ill-will toward the child whatsoever. On the contrary, he may hold a genuine and tender good-will toward the child, and rather than wishing any harm upon him, he may desire his true welfare more deeply than anything else. His anger, in that case, is nothing more than his opposition to what he believes will ultimately hurt the child. This shows that anger, in its essential nature, consists not in a desire for revenge but in the spirit's resistance to evil.
If anger were inherently rooted in ill-will and a desire for revenge, then no form of anger could ever be justified, because we are never permitted to harbor ill-will toward others. We are required by Christ to wish well to everyone and to pray for their prosperity, including our enemies and those who mistreat and persecute us (Matt 5:44). The apostle's rule is equally clear: "Bless them which persecute you: bless, and curse not" (Rom 12:14). In other words, we are to wish good and pray for good toward others, and never to wish them harm. By the same logic, all personal revenge is forbidden, with the sole exception of the punishment that public justice administers to wrongdoers. In that case, those carrying out the sentence act not on their own behalf, but on God's. The rule is stated plainly: "You shall not take vengeance or bear a grudge against the sons of your own people, but you shall love your neighbor as yourself: I am the Lord" (Lev 19:18). The apostle echoes this: "Beloved, never avenge yourselves, but leave it to the wrath of God, for it is written, 'Vengeance is mine, I will repay, says the Lord'" (Rom 12:19). Any anger that carries ill-will or a craving for revenge is therefore something Christianity directly opposes and forbids under the most serious warnings. Sometimes when Scripture speaks of anger, it refers specifically to this worst form, the kind that implies ill-will and the desire for revenge, and in that sense all anger is condemned. We see this in "Let all bitterness, and wrath, and anger, and clamor, and evil speaking, be put away from you, with all malice" (Eph 4:31), and again in "But now you must put them all away: anger, wrath, malice, slander, and obscene talk from your mouth" (Col 3:8). Anger of this kind is sinful by its very nature. And so, 2. Anger may be unsuitable and unchristian with respect to its occasion. Such unsuitableness arises when anger has no just cause behind it. Christ addresses this directly when He says, "Whoever is angry with his brother without a cause shall be in danger of the judgment" (Matt 5:22). This can happen in three ways:
First, when the source of anger is something that is not the other person's fault at all. This happens more often than we might expect. Many people are so proud and irritable by nature that they grow angry at anything that inconveniences them, opposes them, or simply fails to go their way, regardless of whether anyone is actually to blame. Sometimes people direct their anger at others for things that stem not from any wrongdoing, but from simple, unavoidable ignorance or from genuine inability. They are angry that someone didn't do better, when the only real explanation is that the circumstances made any other outcome impossible. And often enough, people grow angry at others not merely for something that isn't a fault, but for something that is genuinely good and deserving of praise. This is always what's happening when people grow angry at God and chafe against His providence and the way He orders their lives. To be fretful and impatient, to grumble against God's dealings with us, is an especially wicked form of anger. And yet this is precisely what happens, again and again, in this fallen world. It was the sin the Israelites fell into so repeatedly, the very thing for which so many of them were destroyed in the wilderness. It was also what Jonah, though a good man, was guilty of when he grew angry with God without cause, angry over the very thing for which he should have praised God: His great mercy toward the Ninevites. Often, too, people find their spirits worn down by a constant, low-grade irritation when things go against them, when they encounter setbacks, disappointments, and complications in their affairs. They won't admit that God is the one they're really chafing against, and they don't even seem to recognize it themselves. But there is no other honest way to read such fretfulness. Whatever they may claim, it is ultimately directed at the Author of providence, at the God who orders these unwelcome events. It is, at its core, a murmuring and fretting against Him.
And it's quite common for people to grow angry with others simply for doing what is right, or merely fulfilling their obligations. No other cause in human history has generated more bitterness, fierce hostility, and malice among people than the simple act of doing good. History records no cruelties comparable to those inflicted on God's people because of their religious convictions and practice. Consider how deeply the scribes and Pharisees resented Christ for doing His Father's will in everything He said and did while on earth. When people grow angry with others, or with civil or church authorities, for taking appropriate action against their errors or sins, they are angry at those authorities for doing exactly what they should. The same is true when people resent their neighbors or fellow church members for bearing honest witness against them, or for seeking accountability when the situation demands it. Often, people grow angry not only when others do what is right, but even when others act out of genuine friendship toward them, as when someone administers a well-intentioned Christian rebuke for a fault they've observed. The Psalmist said he would welcome such correction as a kindness: "Let the righteous smite me, it shall be a kindness" (Ps 141:5); but those who respond with anger are foolishly and sinfully treating a gift as an offense. In all these cases, our anger is unwarranted and unreasonable because its occasion involves no actual fault on the part of the person we're angry with. And so, Second, anger is unsuitable and unchristian in its occasion when people are angry over small and trivial matters, and when, even if some blame exists, the fault is so minor that it simply doesn't merit the energy of our indignation. God does not call us to keep our spirits in a constant state of opposition and agitation unless the occasion is genuinely significant. A person who grows angry at every small fault he notices in others is certainly not the kind of person described in the text. Of someone provoked by every petty, trifling thing, it simply cannot be said that he is "not easily provoked." Some people are so irritable and fretful by temperament that any small thing throws them off, including things in others, whether in the home, in society, or in business, that are no greater faults than they themselves commit every single day. Those who insist on being angry at every fault they see in others will guarantee themselves a life of constant irritation, and their minds will never find peace; for we cannot expect to go through this world without continually seeing faults in others, just as there are continually faults in ourselves. This is precisely why Christians are directed to be "slow to speak, slow to wrath" (Jas 1:19), and why Scripture says that "he that is soon angry dealeth foolishly." The person who carefully guards his own spirit will not be frequently or easily provoked. He wisely keeps his mind calm and clear, and does not allow it to be stirred to anger except on extraordinary occasions that genuinely call for it. And again, Third, anger may be unsuitable and unchristian in its occasion when our spirits are stirred at the faults of others chiefly because those faults affect us personally, rather than because they are offenses against God. We should never be angry except at sin, and sin should always be what we are opposing when we are angry. When our spirits are moved to oppose this evil, it should be as sin, or primarily as an offense against God. If there is no sin and no fault, we have no cause for anger; and if there is a fault or sin, then it is infinitely more serious as an offense against God than as an offense against us, and therefore it demands our strongest opposition on that ground. People sin in their anger when that anger is self-centered, because we are not to act as though we belong to ourselves or exist merely for our own sake, since we belong to God and not to ourselves. When a fault is committed that wrongs both God and other people, those people should be primarily concerned, and their spirits primarily moved, by the fact that it is against God; for they should care more about God's honor than about their own temporal interests. All anger, with respect to its occasion, is either a virtue or a vice, for there is no neutral middle ground that is neither good nor bad; but there is no virtue or goodness in opposing sin unless it is opposed as sin. Virtuous anger is, in one form, the very thing called zeal. Our anger should resemble Christ's anger. He bore the greatest personal injuries with the gentleness of a lamb, and we never read of His being angry except in God's cause, against sin as sin. This should be true of us as well. And just as anger may be unsuitable and unchristian in these three ways with respect to its occasion or cause, so, 3. it may be undue and sinful with respect to its end, and this in two particulars.
When we are angry without any clear purpose in mind, we fall into the first form of sinful anger. In this mode, anger is rash and unconsidered, allowed to rise and persist without any guiding thought or motive. Reason plays no part in it; the passions run ahead of reason, and anger flares up before we have even paused to ask whether it will benefit ourselves or anyone else. Anger of this kind is not the anger of rational human beings but the blind fury of animals, a kind of brute passion rather than the response of a thinking creature. Every faculty of the human soul should be governed by reason, which is the highest capacity we possess, and every other principle within us should be directed by reason toward its proper end. When our anger bypasses reason entirely, it is unchristian and sinful. The same is true, second, when we allow ourselves to be angry for the wrong ends. Even when reason tells us that our anger serves neither God's glory nor our own genuine good, and that it will likely cause harm to ourselves or others, we may still indulge it because we are chasing the satisfaction of our own pride, the expansion of our influence, or some advantage over others. We use anger as a tool to reach these self-serving ends, and in doing so we feed a sinful spirit.
Finally, 4. Anger may be unsuitable and unchristian with respect to its measure. This applies in two ways: the degree of anger and its duration. First, when it is excessive in degree. Anger can far exceed what a situation actually calls for. It often grows so intense that people lose control of themselves entirely, their passions so violent that, in the moment, they neither know what they are doing nor seem capable of directing their feelings or behavior. Sometimes a person's passions rise so high that they are, in effect, drunk on them, their reason gone, acting as though beside themselves. But the intensity of anger should always be proportional to its purpose, and it should never be allowed to rise beyond what is needed to achieve the legitimate ends that reason has identified. Anger also exceeds its proper bounds, and becomes sinful, second, when it goes on too long. Prolonged anger is a serious sin. The wise man not only commands, "Be not hasty in thy spirit to be angry," but adds that "anger resteth in the bosom of fools" (Eccl 7:9). The apostle likewise says, "Be ye angry, and sin not: let not the sun go down upon your wrath" (Eph 4:26). When anger is allowed to linger, it quickly curdles into malice, because evil spreads far faster than good. A person who holds onto anger toward someone else will soon find that anger turning into hatred. We see this plainly in those who nurse a grudge week after week, month after month, year after year. In the end, they genuinely hate the very people against whom they have stored up that anger, whether they admit it or not. This is a grievous sin before God, and every person should take the greatest care not to let anger take up long residence in their heart.
Having shown what that angry and wrathful spirit looks like, the one to which charity and a Christian spirit stand opposed, I turn now, as planned, to show II. How charity, or a Christian spirit, is contrary to it. I will do this by showing, first, that charity and love, which together form the heart of the Christian spirit, are directly and inherently opposed to sinful anger; and, secondly, that the fruits of charity mentioned in the surrounding passage are all equally opposed to it. And, 1. Christian charity, or love, is directly and inherently contrary to all undue anger. Christian love opposes anger that is unjust by nature, anger that tends toward revenge and therefore implies ill-will, because the very nature of love is good-will. Love works to keep people from growing angry without just cause, and it certainly won't incline anyone to flare up over minor faults. Love is slow to anger and will not give way to it over trivial matters, much less when there is no real cause for anger at all. It is a malignant and evil spirit, not a loving one, that drives people to anger without cause. Love for God also works against the tendency to resent others' faults primarily because we ourselves have been offended or hurt by them; instead, it inclines us to see those faults chiefly as offenses against God. When love is genuinely at work, it holds the passions of anger in check, keeping them under the authority of reason and the spirit of love, so that they don't grow excessive in their intensity or drag on too long. And not only is charity, or Christian love, directly and inherently contrary to all undue anger, but, 2. All the fruits of this charity mentioned in the surrounding passage are also contrary to it. I will mention only two of these fruits, letting them stand for all the rest: namely, those virtues that oppose pride and selfishness. First, love, or charity, is contrary to all undue and sinful anger because, in its fruits, it is contrary to pride. Pride is one of the chief causes of undue anger. It is because people are proud and think highly of themselves that they become vengeful, quick to take offense, and prone to turning small slights into major grievances. They even treat genuine virtues as vices when they feel their honor has been touched or their will has been crossed. And it is pride that makes people so unreasonable and rash in their anger, driving it to such intensity, sustaining it for so long, and often hardening it into habitual malice. But as we have already seen, love, or Christian charity, is utterly opposed to pride. And so, Secondly, love, or charity, is contrary to all sinful anger because, in its fruits, it is contrary to selfishness. It is because people are selfish and pursue their own interests that they become malicious and vengeful toward anyone who opposes or interferes with what they want. If people were not primarily chasing their own private, selfish interests, but instead sought the glory of God and the common good, their spirit would be far more stirred up in God's cause than in their own; and they would not be prone to hasty, rash, careless, excessive, and long-lasting wrath against those who had wronged or provoked them. Instead, they would largely set themselves aside for God's sake, out of their zeal for the honor of Christ. The goal they pursued would not be making themselves great or getting their own way, but the glory of God and the good of their fellow human beings. And love, as we have seen, is opposed to all selfishness.
In applying this subject, let us use it 1. In the way of self-examination. Our own consciences, if honestly searched and seriously questioned, can tell us best whether we are, or have been, people of the angry and wrathful spirit described above: whether we are frequently angry, whether we nurse ill-will, or whether we allow anger to linger. Have we not often been angry? And if so, isn't there good reason to think that anger was excessive, without just cause, and therefore sinful? God does not call Christians into His kingdom so that they can freely indulge their irritability, keeping their minds constantly stirred up and unsettled by anger. And hasn't most of the anger you have harbored been chiefly, if not entirely, on your own behalf? People often claim they are driven by zeal for religion, for duty, and for the honor of God, when in reality it is only their own private interests that are at stake. It is striking how eager people are to appear zealous for God and righteousness precisely in those cases where their own honor, will, or interests have been touched, and how readily they use that appearance as cover for harming others or complaining about them. What a sharp contrast this is to their behavior in other situations, where God's honor is equally or far more seriously wounded, yet their own interests are not directly involved. In those latter cases, there is no such display of zeal or intensity of spirit, no eagerness to rebuke or complain or grow angry; instead, there is often a readiness to make excuses, to leave correction to others, and to remain cold and reluctant when it comes to anything resembling opposition to the sin.
Ask yourself, even further: what good has your anger actually accomplished, and what were you hoping to achieve through it? Have you even stopped to consider these questions? There has been a great deal of anger and bitterness surrounding public events in this town, and many of you have been present at those events. That anger has shown itself in your behavior, and I fear it has taken up residence in your hearts. Examine yourselves honestly on this point, and ask what kind of anger it has truly been. Has most of it, if not all of it, been exactly the kind of wrongful, unchristian anger we have been discussing? Has it not carried the character of ill-will, malice, and bitterness of heart, an anger rooted in pride and self-interest, because your personal stake, your opinion, or your faction was threatened? Has your anger come anywhere close to that Christian zeal which leaves charity intact, keeps the feelings clear, and produces neither unkindness nor a desire for revenge? And what about how long you have held onto your anger? Has the sun not gone down more than once on your wrath, while God and your neighbor both knew it was still there? More than that, has it not gone down again and again, month after month, year after year, while winter's cold never chilled the heat of your resentment and summer's warmth never softened you toward kindness? Are there not some here today who are sitting before God with anger stored up in their hearts, still burning? Or if that anger is temporarily hidden from other people's eyes, is it not like an old wound that never fully healed, so that the slightest touch brings the pain rushing back, or like a fire smoldering beneath a pile of autumn leaves, needing only the smallest breeze to burst into open flame? And what has your spirit been like within your own families? Families are the most closely bound of all human societies, and their members share the nearest relationships and the strongest obligations to peace, harmony, and love. And yet how have you actually behaved at home? How many times have you been irritable, angry, impatient, petty, and unkind toward those whom God has placed in such great dependence on you, those who are so easily made happy or miserable by what you do and say, by your kindness or your coldness? What kind of anger have you allowed yourself in the home? Has it not often been unreasonable and sinful, not only in its character but in its causes, directed at people who were not actually at fault, or over mistakes that were minor or unintentional, or in situations where you yourself were partly to blame? And even when there may have been genuine cause for anger, has your resentment not lingered, driving you to sullenness or harshness that your own conscience condemned? And have you not also been angry with the neighbors who live alongside you, the people you deal with every day, allowing yourself to flare up at them over trivial matters and small offenses? On all these points, we must examine ourselves honestly, understand what kind of spirit we actually possess, and recognize where we fall short of the spirit of Christ.
2. The subject dissuades from, and warns against, all undue and sinful anger.
The human heart is deeply prone to undue and sinful anger, being naturally full of pride and self-interest. We also live in a world that constantly provides occasions to stir up this corruption within us, which means we cannot hope to live as Christians should in this area without constant watchfulness and prayer. We should not only guard against angry outbursts, but actively fight against the underlying disposition toward anger, seeking earnestly to have it put to death in our hearts through the growth of divine love and humility in our souls. Several considerations can help us toward that end.
First, reflect often on your own failures, through which you have given both God and other people reason to be displeased with you. Throughout your entire life, you have fallen short of what God requires, and have therefore justly incurred His fearful wrath. You constantly need to pray that God will not be angry with you, but will show you mercy instead. Your failures toward other people have also been numerous, and have frequently given them reason to be angry with you. Your faults may be just as serious as theirs, and that thought should lead you to spend less time fuming over the specks in their eyes and more time removing the planks from your own. Very often, the people who are quickest to be angry with others and who nurse their grievances most intensely are equally guilty, or even more so, of the very same faults. Those who are most easily offended when others speak ill of them are frequently the ones who speak most ill of others, and who in their anger resort to insults and abuse. When others provoke us, then, instead of lashing out, let our first impulse be to turn inward, to reflect on ourselves, and to ask honestly whether we have not been guilty of the very same things that are making us angry, or perhaps of something worse. Keeping our own failures and errors in mind is one of the most effective ways to guard against undue anger toward others.
Second, consider how undue anger destroys the peace of the person who gives in to it. It troubles the soul that harbors it the way a storm troubles the ocean. Such anger is incompatible with genuine contentment, true peace, or any real sense of self-respect. People with an angry and wrathful temperament, whose minds are perpetually in a state of agitation, lead some of the most miserable lives imaginable. A simple concern for our own wellbeing should therefore motivate us to avoid all undue and sinful anger.
Third, consider how much such a spirit disqualifies a person for the duties of religion. All undue anger makes us unfit for devout reflection and the active practice of faith. It drives the soul far from that calm and excellent state of spirit in which we most fully enjoy communion with God, and in which truth and the means of grace are most beneficial to us. This is precisely why God commands us not to approach His altar while we are at odds with others, but to "first be reconciled to your brother, and then come and offer your gift" (Matt 5:24). It is also why the apostle writes, "I desire then that in every place the men should pray, lifting holy hands without anger or quarreling" (1 Tim 2:8).
Fourth, consider that the Bible describes angry people as unfit for human society. God's explicit instruction is: "Make no friendship with a man given to anger, nor go with a wrathful man, lest you learn his ways and entangle yourself in a snare" (Prov 22:24-25). Such a person is a plague on society, someone who disturbs and unsettles it and throws everything into disorder. "A man of wrath stirs up strife, and one given to anger causes much transgression" (Prov 29:22). Everyone around him is made uncomfortable; his example is harmful, and his conduct is condemned by both God and other people. Let these considerations carry weight with all of us, and lead us to turn away from an angry spirit and temperament, cultivating instead the spirit of gentleness, kindness, and love, which is nothing less than the spirit of heaven.
CHAPTER 10
LECTURE 10. THE SPIRIT OF LOVE IS THE OPPOSITE OF A JUDGMENTAL SPIRIT
"Charity . . . thinketh no evil" (1 Cor 13:5)
Having examined how charity, or Christian love, stands opposed not only to pride and selfishness but also to the ordinary fruits of those evil dispositions, namely an angry spirit and a censorious spirit, and having already addressed the former, I turn now to the latter. On this point, the apostle declares that charity "thinketh no evil." The doctrine these words set forth is straightforward: THE SPIRIT OF CHARITY, OR CHRISTIAN LOVE, IS THE OPPOSITE OF A CENSORIOUS SPIRIT. Put another way, genuine Christian love runs directly counter to any disposition to think or judge uncharitably of others.
Charity, in one of its common uses, refers to a disposition to think the best of others that the circumstances will allow. As I have shown before, however, this is not the scriptural meaning of the word charity, but only one way it is expressed, or one of its many rich fruits. Charity is far larger in scope than this. It signifies, as we have already seen, the same thing as Christian or divine love, and is therefore identical to the Christian spirit itself. Consistent with this understanding, we find the spirit of charitable judgment mentioned here among many other good fruits of charity, and expressed, as the other fruits of charity are throughout this passage, negatively, by denying its opposite: censoriousness, or a disposition to judge and condemn others without charity. In addressing this point, I will first explain the nature of censoriousness and what it consists of, and then identify several ways in which it proves contrary to a Christian spirit. I will address, first, the nature of censoriousness, or what a censorious spirit and a disposition to judge others uncharitably actually consist of. It consists in a disposition to think evil of others, or to judge them harshly, with respect to three things: their spiritual state, their character, and their actions. And, 1. A censorious spirit shows itself in an eagerness to judge others' spiritual state harshly. It often appears as a tendency to assume the worst about those around us, whether they are people of the world or professing Christians. With regard to the latter group, it frequently leads people to pass judgment on those who profess religion and to condemn them as hypocrites. Here, though, extremes must be avoided. Some people are very quick to conclude from small observations that someone is a godly person, while others are just as quick, from equally small observations, to declare with certainty that someone has not the slightest degree of grace in their heart and is a complete stranger to living, experienced faith. Yet all such certainty in a matter of this kind appears to be without any warrant from the Word of God. God seems to have reserved the definitive judgment of a person's spiritual state for Himself, keeping it in His own hands as the great and only searcher of the hearts of His children.
Persons are guilty of censoriousness in condemning others when they do so based on things that provide no real evidence of a bad spiritual condition. This includes condemning others as hypocrites because of how God's providence has dealt with them, as Job's three friends condemned him on account of his severe and unusual suffering. The same applies when people condemn others for failings that are no greater than what God's own children commonly experience, and which may be no greater, or even less serious, than their own failings, despite thinking well of themselves as Christians. People are also censorious when they condemn others as unconverted and carnal simply because those others hold different opinions on non-essential points, or when they judge someone's spiritual condition poorly without making reasonable allowances for natural temperament, upbringing, lack of education, or other particular disadvantages under which that person labors. They are equally censorious when they dismiss everyone as irreligious and unconverted because those people's spiritual experiences don't match their own in every detail, setting themselves and their own experience up as the standard for everyone else. Such people fail to appreciate the vast variety and freedom the Spirit of God exercises in His saving work on human hearts, and how mysterious and inscrutable His ways often are, especially in the great work of making people new creatures in Christ Jesus. In all these ways, people act not only censoriously but unreasonably, refusing to recognize as Christians anyone whose experience differs from their own, much as if they refused to recognize as human anyone who didn't share their exact height, physical strength, temperament, or facial features. Moving on, 2. A censorious spirit also shows itself in a readiness to think poorly of others' qualities. It appears as a tendency to overlook good qualities in others, or to assume those qualities are absent when they are not, or to minimize them; to exaggerate bad qualities beyond what is fair; or to attribute faults to people that they simply don't have. Some people are quick to accuse others of ignorance, foolishness, or other contemptible traits when those accusations are entirely undeserved. Some seem inclined to form a low and dismissive opinion of others and to present them that way to their friends and associates, when a charitable disposition would find many good things in those same people, enough to balance or outweigh the bad, and would honestly acknowledge them as people worthy of respect. Others go further and attribute morally serious faults to people who are free from them, or accuse people of such faults to a degree far beyond what they deserve. Some, for instance, are so prejudiced against certain neighbors that they see them as far more proud, selfish, spiteful, or malicious than they actually are. A deep-seated prejudice leads them to assume the worst across the board, crediting those people with every bad quality and none of the good. To the censorious person, a neighbor may appear thoroughly proud, covetous, selfish, or otherwise corrupt, while others who know the same person see many good qualities and perhaps find reasonable explanations for the qualities that fall short. The censorious see only what is wrong and speak only what is unfair and disparaging about others' character. And, 3. A censorious spirit also shows itself in a readiness to judge others' actions harshly. By actions, I mean all the external voluntary acts of a person, whether in words or deeds. A censorious spirit in judging others' actions reveals itself in two ways:
First, judging others as guilty of wrongdoing without any evidence that actually compels such a judgment. A suspicious spirit that leads people to be jealous of others, ready to assume they are guilty of evil things when there is no evidence whatsoever, is an uncharitable spirit and contrary to Christianity. Some people are very quick to pass judgment on others regarding things they assume happen out of their sight. They readily believe that a person commits this or that evil deed in secret, away from the eyes of others, or that they have said or done certain things among their close associates, and that they deliberately conceal these things from anyone outside their circle. These are the people guilty of the "evil surmisings" the apostle names and condemns, which he connects with "envy, strife, and railings" (1 Tim 6:4). Very often, people also show an uncharitable and judgmental spirit toward others by being quick to pick up and spread damaging reports about them. Simply hearing a rumor about someone, in a world as careless and dishonest as this one, is far from sufficient grounds to conclude that the person is actually guilty of what is being reported. The devil, who is called "the god of this world," is described as "a liar, and the father of it," and too many of his children, sadly, take after him in their willingness to speak falsehoods. And yet it is extremely common for people to pass judgment on others on no better basis than having heard that somebody said this or that, with no evidence at all that what was said is true. When they hear that someone has done or said something, they seem to accept it immediately as fact, without any further inquiry, even though nothing is more unreliable or more likely to be false than the murmurs and whispers of common gossip. Some people are so eager to seize on a bad report that it seems to genuinely please them to hear evil of others. Their spirit seems to hunger for it; it is, in a sense, food for their depraved hearts, and they feed on it the way carrion birds feed on rotting flesh. They take it in easily and greedily as truth, without examination, showing how completely unlike they are in character and conduct to the person the Psalmist describes as dwelling in God's tabernacle and abiding on His holy hill, of whom he declares that "he taketh not up a reproach against his neighbour" (Ps 15:1-3). They show instead that they are far more like "the wicked doer" who "giveth heed to false lips," and like "the liar" who "giveth ear to a naughty tongue" (Prov 17:4). A judgmental spirit in thinking evil of others also reveals itself, Second, in a tendency to put the worst possible interpretation on their actions. The judgmental are not only prone to conclude that others are guilty of wrongdoing without sufficient evidence; they are also inclined to read the worst into people's actions even when those actions admit just as easily, and often more naturally, of a charitable interpretation. Very often, the real motive and purpose behind an action is hidden, known only to the person who performed it; and yet people are commonly very quick to pass judgment on the act itself, without any consideration of that inner motive. This kind of censoriousness and uncharitable judging is as common as any other, if not more so. It is very common, for instance, for people who are prejudiced against someone to put a sinister interpretation on that person's words or actions even when those words or actions appear genuinely good, as though everything were performed in hypocrisy. This is especially true in public life and public affairs. If anything is said or done by someone that appears to show concern for the common good, or for a neighbor's welfare, or for the honor of God, or for the cause of religion, there will always be those ready to declare that it is all hypocrisy, that the real aim is nothing more than self-promotion and personal advancement, and that the person is simply flattering and deceiving others while nursing some hidden, self-serving agenda all along.
But here a question arises: where exactly does the evil of judging others poorly lie, given that not all negative judgments are unlawful? And where should the lines be drawn? My first answer is this: there are certain people who are specifically appointed to serve as judges, both in civil society and in the church. These individuals are called to evaluate those who properly fall under their authority, rendering impartial verdicts on whether someone's conduct is good or bad, approving what is right and condemning what is wrong, all according to the evidence, the nature of the act in question, and whether that act conforms to or violates the law that serves as their guiding standard.
Second, individual people, in their private judgments of others, are not required to set aside reason in order to think well of everyone. That would be plainly unreasonable, because Christian charity is not built on the wreckage of reason; there is, in fact, a deep harmony between reason and charity. We are not forbidden, therefore, from forming judgments about people when there is plain and clear evidence that they deserve to be charged with wrongdoing. We are not at fault when we judge those to be wicked and spiritually lost who give flagrant proof of it through a consistent pattern of evil behavior. "Some men's sins," the apostle says, "are open beforehand, going before to judgment; and some men they follow after" (1 Tim 5:24). That is, some people's sins testify so plainly against them that they stand condemned as wicked in the eyes of the world, even before the final day of judgment arrives to expose every secret of the heart. In the same way, some people's actions reveal the evil of their intentions so clearly that judging their motives as corrupt is not the same as presuming to read the secrets of the heart. It is clear, then, that not every judgment we make about another person's spiritual condition, character, or conduct is an act of uncharitable censoriousness. The real evil of that kind of judging, the kind that constitutes censoriousness, lies in two things:
The first form this takes is judging others negatively when the evidence doesn't require it, or thinking poorly of them when the situation actually allows for a charitable interpretation. It happens when everything in their favor gets ignored while everything against them gets amplified and given far more weight than it deserves. The same failure occurs when people are hasty and rash in judging and condemning others, even though both wisdom and charity require them to withhold judgment until they know more about the situation and all the relevant circumstances are clear. People often reveal a great deal of uncharitableness and rashness by freely criticizing others before they've even heard what those people have to say in their own defense. This is precisely why Scripture says, "He that answereth a matter before he heareth it, is folly and shame unto him" (Prov 18:13).
The second mark of a censorious spirit is a kind of pleasure taken in judging others harshly. People can, of course, form negative judgments about others based on clear and compelling evidence, and still feel genuine grief at being forced to that conclusion, much like a loving parent who hears undeniable proof of a child's serious wrongdoing. But far too often, people pass judgment in a way that reveals they are actually enjoying it. They are quick to judge, they act on the flimsiest evidence, and they push their conclusions to the harshest possible extreme, all of which shows that their heart is in it and that they take a certain satisfaction in thinking the worst of others. This same pleasure in harsh judgment also shows itself in how eagerly such people share their opinions, speaking ill of others just as readily as they think ill of them. It may come out as mockery or contempt, as bitterness or malice, or as barely concealed delight in another person's failures and faults. By contrast, when someone is genuinely reluctant to think badly of another, they will be careful and restrained in doing so. They will go no further than the evidence requires, they will assume the best that the situation allows, and they will put the most charitable possible interpretation on what others say and do. When they are forced, against their own wishes, to form a negative opinion of someone, they will feel no desire to broadcast it. They will be slow to mention it to anyone, and will do so only when a genuine sense of duty leaves them no other choice.
Having laid out the nature of a censorious spirit, I turn now, as proposed, to the second point.
1. It is contrary to love for our neighbor, and this is clear from three considerations.
First, we see that people are very reluctant to think badly of themselves. They are quick to think well of their own qualities, and equally quick to assume the best about their own spiritual condition. If they notice anything in themselves that resembles genuine grace, they are extremely prone to conclude that their condition is good. They are ready to think well of their own words and actions, and very slow to judge themselves harshly in any of these areas. The reason is simple: they love themselves deeply. And so, if they loved their neighbors as themselves, that same love would naturally produce the same tendency toward others.
Second, we see that people are very reluctant to think badly of those they love. We see this clearly in how people treat their close friends, and in how parents regard their children. They are quick to think well of them and to assume the best about their qualities, whether natural or moral. They are far more resistant than others to accepting negative reports about them, and slow to believe what is said against them. They lean toward putting the most charitable interpretation on everything those people do. And the reason, again, is simply that they love them.
Third, we can also see that hatred and ill-will toward others almost always go hand in hand with a censorious spirit. When people fall out with one another, and anger and prejudice take hold, and ill-will sets in, there is always a readiness to assume the worst about each other: an instinct to think poorly of each other's qualities, and to imagine all manner of faults, some of them quite serious. Each person tends to grow suspicious of what the other might be doing when out of sight, and is quick to listen to negative reports about him, ready to believe every word, and inclined to put the worst possible interpretation on everything he says or does. Very often, there is also a readiness to question the other person's spiritual condition and to write him off as someone without grace. What is true in personal conflicts between two individuals tends to be equally true when two larger groups are at odds. All of this makes plain that a censorious spirit grows out of a failure to love one's neighbor with genuine Christian love, and from giving free rein to the opposite spirit. I will add only one more point: 2. A censorious spirit reveals a proud spirit. The context makes clear that this is directly opposed to the spirit of charity, or Christian love. A readiness to judge and condemn others betrays a proud disposition, as though the person doing the judging considered himself free from the very faults he is so eager to pin on others, and therefore felt entitled to be both harsh and relentless in charging them with those faults. This is exactly what the Savior implies in the seventh chapter of Matthew: "Judge not, that ye be not judged. And why do you see the speck in your brother's eye, but fail to notice the plank in your own eye? Or how can you say to your brother, 'Let me take the speck out of your eye,' when there is a plank in your own eye? You hypocrite!" The same truth is embedded in the apostle's words: "Therefore you have no excuse, O man, whoever you are, when you judge another; for in passing judgment on him you condemn yourself, because you, the judge, are doing the very same things" (Rom 2:1). If people were genuinely humble about their own failings, they would not be so eager or so pleased to judge others, because the verdict they pass on others would inevitably fall on themselves as well. The same kinds of corruption exist in every human heart, and if those who are most zealous in condemning others would simply look inward and honestly examine their own hearts and lives, they would generally find in themselves the same tendencies and behaviors they are so quick to judge in others, or at least something equally deserving of censure. A disposition to judge and condemn also reveals a conceited and arrogant character. It has the look of someone placing himself above his peers, as though he were fit to be the lord and judge of his fellow servants, with their standing determined by his verdict. This seems to be precisely what the apostle means: "He who speaks evil of his brother and judges his brother speaks evil of the law and judges the law; but if you judge the law, you are not a doer of the law but a judge" (Jas 4:11). In other words, when you judge someone, you are not acting as a fellow servant under the same law, but as the lawgiver himself, the judge whose role it is to pronounce sentence. That is why the very next verse adds: "There is one lawgiver, who is able to save and to destroy. Who are you to judge another?" The same point appears in Rom 14:4: "Who are you to pass judgment on the servant of another? It is before his own master that he stands or falls." God alone is the rightful judge, and a proper sense of His sovereignty and authority should restrain us from ever daring to judge or condemn our fellow human beings.
In applying this subject, I offer the following observations.
1. It sternly reproves those who commonly take it upon themselves to speak evil of others. If merely thinking evil of others deserves such strong condemnation, then those who not only think evil but openly speak it, backbiting their neighbors with their tongues, deserve even stronger censure. Speaking evil of others behind their backs consists largely in criticizing them, or in voicing uncharitable thoughts and judgments about their character and conduct. For this reason, speaking evil of others and judging others are sometimes treated as the same thing in Scripture, as in the passage just quoted from the apostle James. How frequently does Scripture condemn backbiting and evil-speaking! The Psalmist declares of the wicked, "Thou givest thy mouth to evil, and thy tongue frameth deceit. Thou sittest and speakest against thy brother; thou slanderest thine own mother's son" (Ps 50:19-20). The apostle writes to Titus, "Put them in mind... to speak evil of no man, to be no brawlers, but gentle, shewing all meekness unto all men" (Titus 3:1-2); and again, "Wherefore, laying aside all malice, and all guile, and hypocrisies, and envies, and all evil-speakings" (1 Pet 2:1). It is also listed as part of the character of every citizen of Zion, of everyone who shall stand on God's holy hill, that he "backbiteth not with his tongue" (Ps 15:3). Ask yourself, then, whether you have not been frequently guilty of this; whether you have not often criticized others and voiced harsh judgments about them, especially those with whom you have had some conflict, or who belong to a different camp than your own. And is this not a habit you still indulge, to one degree or another, day after day? If so, consider how deeply it contradicts the spirit of Christianity and the solemn profession you may have made as a Christian, and take this as a firm call to abandon it entirely and at once.
2. The subject warns everyone against a censorious spirit, whether expressed in thought or speech, as a matter of being worthy of the name Christian. Beyond what has already been said, let two or three additional considerations be weighed. First, how often, when the full truth finally comes out, do things turn out far better than we were initially prepared to believe? Scripture offers many examples of this. When the tribes of Reuben, Gad, and the half-tribe of Manasseh built an altar beside the Jordan, the rest of Israel heard about it and immediately concluded that these tribes had turned away from God, rashly resolving to go to war against them. But when the truth came to light, it turned out that the altar had been built for an entirely worthy purpose: the worship of God, as recorded in Josh 22. Eli assumed Hannah was drunk when she came to the temple, but when the truth emerged, he understood that she was overwhelmed with grief, praying and pouring out her soul before God (1 Sam 1:12-16). David concluded from Ziba's report that Mephibosheth had shown a rebellious and treasonous spirit against the crown, and he acted on that harsh judgment to Mephibosheth's great harm; yet when the truth finally surfaced, he saw the situation was entirely different. Elijah judged the state of Israel so harshly that he believed no one remained a true worshiper of God except himself; but when God told him the truth, it emerged that seven thousand had never bowed the knee to Baal. And how often do we find the same pattern today? How frequently, on closer examination, have we discovered that others were far better than what we had heard, or than what we had been quick to assume? There are always two sides to every story, and it is generally wise, safe, and charitable to lean toward the better interpretation. Yet there is probably no area in which people go more consistently wrong than in presuming the worst is true, and in forming and voicing judgments about others and their actions before all the facts are known.
Second, How little reason we have to pass judgment on others regarding their spiritual condition, their qualities, or their actions that don't concern us. Our primary concern should be with ourselves. It matters infinitely that we stand in a right relationship with God, that we possess sound character and godly principles, and that we conduct ourselves well, acting from right motives and toward right ends. How things stand with others is, by comparison, a minor matter. And there is little need for our condemnation of them, even if it were deserved, which we can never be certain of. The matter rests in God's hands, and He is infinitely better suited to handle it than we are. A day has been appointed for His verdict. So when we presume to judge others, we don't merely take on work that isn't ours; we do it ahead of schedule. "Therefore," says the apostle, "judge nothing before the time, until the Lord come, who both will bring to light the hidden things of darkness, and will make manifest the counsels of the hearts; and then shall every man have praise of God" (1 Cor 4:5).
Third, God has warned that if we are found harshly judging and condemning others, we will be condemned ourselves. "Judge not," He says, "that ye be not judged; for with what judgment ye judge, ye shall be judged." And again, the apostle asks, "And thinkest thou this, O man, that judgest them which do such things, and doest the same, that thou shalt escape the judgment of God?" (Rom 2:3). These are sobering warnings from the lips of the very Being who will serve as our judge on the final day, whose acquittal we need beyond all measure, and whose sentence of condemnation would be unspeakably terrible for those who ultimately fall under it forever. Therefore, precisely because we do not want to receive condemnation from Him, let us not measure it out to others.
CHAPTER 11
LECTURE 11. ALL TRUE GRACE IN THE HEART LEADS TO HOLY PRACTICE IN LIFE
"Charity . . . rejoiceth not in iniquity, but rejoiceth in the truth." (1 Cor 13:6)
Having described, in the two preceding verses, many of the good fruits of charity and shown how it shapes excellent behavior across a wide range of particulars, the apostle now gathers all of these tendencies together into a single summary statement about active conduct: "It rejoiceth not in iniquity, but rejoiceth in the truth." It is as if he were saying, "I have pointed to many excellent things that charity tends toward, and shown how it stands opposed to many evils. But there is no need to keep multiplying examples, because, in a word, charity is contrary to everything evil in life and practice, and inclines toward everything good. It rejoiceth not in iniquity, but rejoiceth in the truth."
By "iniquity," the apostle seems to mean everything sinful in life and practice, and by "the truth," everything good in life, or all that is included in Christian and holy conduct. The word truth is, in fact, used in a variety of ways throughout the Bible. Sometimes it refers to the true doctrines of religion; sometimes to the knowledge of those doctrines; sometimes to honesty or faithfulness; and sometimes it signifies all virtue and holiness together, encompassing both the knowledge and reception of the great truths of Scripture and the conformity of one's life and conduct to those truths. It is in this last sense that the apostle John uses the word when he writes, "I rejoiced greatly when the brethren came and testified of the truth that is in thee, even as thou walkest in the truth" (3 John 3). Taking the word in this sense and drawing out the broader principle, the text gives us the following doctrine: ALL TRUE CHRISTIAN GRACE IN THE HEART TENDS TO HOLY PRACTICE IN THE LIFE.
Negatively, the apostle declares that charity is opposed to all wickedness and evil conduct; and positively, that it tends toward all righteousness and holy practice. Since this principle can be generalized, and since charity has already been shown to be the sum of all true and saving grace, the doctrine stated here seems clearly contained in the words of the text: that all true Christian grace tends to holy practice. If anyone holds the notion that grace is something placed in the heart only to remain confined and dormant there, with no governing influence over a person's active life, or if they suppose that the change grace produces, though it genuinely improves the heart itself, has no corresponding tendency to improve outward conduct, they are seriously mistaken. To show why this is so, I will proceed in two ways: first, by offering several arguments in favor of the doctrine as stated; and second, by demonstrating its truth with respect to particular graces.
1. I will offer some arguments in support of the doctrine that all true grace in the heart tends to holy practice in the life.
And, 1. Holy practice is the aim of that eternal election which is the first ground of the bestowment of all true grace. Holy practice is not the ground or reason for election, as the Arminians suppose when they imagine that God elects people to everlasting life based on His foreknowledge of their good works. Rather, holy practice is the aim and end of election. God does not elect people because He foresees that they will be holy; He elects them so that He may make them holy, and so that they will be holy. In election, then, God ordained that people should walk in good works, as the apostle says: "For we are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus unto good works, which God hath before ordained that we should walk in them" (Eph 2:10). Again, the elect are said to be chosen for this very purpose: "He hath chosen us in him before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy, and without blame before him in love" (Eph 1:4). And Christ tells His disciples: "I have chosen you, and ordained you, that ye should go and bring forth fruit, and that your fruit should remain" (John 15:16). Now, God's eternal election is the first ground on which saving grace is bestowed. Some people have saving grace and others do not, because some were chosen by God from eternity and others were not. Since holy practice is the scope and aim of the very thing that grounds the bestowment of grace, it follows that holy practice is also the natural tendency of grace itself. To deny this would be to say that God uses a particular means to reach an end that the means is not fitted to achieve and has no tendency toward. It is further true that,
2. Redemption, by which grace is purchased, serves the same end. The redemption accomplished by Christ is the next ground on which grace is bestowed on all who possess it. Through His merits, through the great things He did and suffered in the world, Christ purchased grace and holiness for His own people: "For their sakes," He says, "I sanctify myself, that they also might be sanctified through the truth" (John 17:19). Christ redeemed the elect and purchased grace for them so that they might walk in holy practice. He reconciled them to God through His death, to save them from wicked works, so that they might be holy and blameless in their lives, as the apostle says: "And you, that were sometime alienated, and enemies in your mind by wicked works, yet now hath he reconciled in the body of his flesh through death, to present you holy, and unblameable, and unreproveable in his sight" (Col 1:21-22). When the angel appeared to Joseph, he told him that the child born of Mary would be called Jesus, meaning Savior, because He would save His people from their sins (Matt 1:21). Holiness of life is declared to be the end of redemption when it is said of Christ that He "gave himself for us, that he might redeem us from all iniquity, and purify unto himself a peculiar people, zealous of good works" (Titus 2:14). We are also told that Christ "died for all, that they which live should not henceforth live unto themselves, but unto him which died for them and rose again" (2 Cor 5:15). And to this same end, He is said to have offered Himself through the eternal Spirit, without spot, to God, so that His blood might purge our conscience from dead works to serve the living God (Heb 9:14).
The most striking example of redemptive love in all of Old Testament history was the deliverance of the children of Israel from Egypt. Yet holy living was the very goal God had in mind through that redemption, as He made clear repeatedly to Pharaoh, saying through Moses and Aaron, "Let my people go, that they may serve me." The New Testament echoes this same purpose in its account of Christ's redemption: "Blessed be the Lord God of Israel; for he hath visited and redeemed his people, ... to perform the mercy promised to our fathers, and to remember his holy covenant, the oath which he sware to our father Abraham, that he would grant unto us, that we, being delivered out of the hand of our enemies, might serve him without fear, in holiness and righteousness before him, all the days of our life" (Luke 1:68-75). All of this makes it unmistakably clear that the purpose of redemption is our holiness. A third point follows naturally from this.
3. That effectual calling, or that saving conversion in which grace begins in the soul, serves this same end. God, through His Spirit and by means of His truth, calls, awakens, convicts, converts, and draws into the exercise of grace all those whom He makes willing in the day of His power, so that they might live out that grace in holy practice. "We are his workmanship," the apostle writes, "created in Christ Jesus unto good works, which God hath before ordained that we should walk in them" (Eph 2:10). Paul also reminds the Thessalonian believers that God had not called them to impurity, but to holiness (1 Thess 4:7). And again: "As he which hath called you is holy, so be ye holy in all manner of conversation" (1 Pet 1:15). A fourth point is equally true.
4. Spiritual knowledge and understanding, which accompany all genuine grace in the heart, naturally lead toward holy practice. A true knowledge of God and divine things is, by its very nature, practical knowledge. Many wicked people have attained considerable measures of purely speculative religious knowledge. A person may be vastly learned, and that learning may consist largely of theology, Scripture, and the things of religion; he may reason with great sophistication about the attributes of God and the doctrines of Christianity, and yet his knowledge falls short of being saving knowledge precisely because it remains speculative rather than practical. The person who has a genuine, saving acquaintance with divine things sees the beauty of holiness and of all the paths that lead toward it, because he sees the beauty and excellence of God Himself, which consist in His holiness. For the same reason, he sees the ugliness of sin and of every path that leads toward it. And if a person truly grasps how ugly the ways of sin are, that understanding will naturally move him to avoid them; just as seeing the loveliness of the ways of holiness will naturally incline him to walk in them.
He who truly knows God sees that God is worthy of obedience. Pharaoh didn't see why he should obey God, because he didn't know who God was, and so he said, "Who is the Lord, that I should obey his voice? I know not the Lord, neither will I let Israel go" (Exod 5:2). The Psalmist identifies this same ignorance as the reason wicked men practice iniquity and conduct themselves so wickedly: they have no spiritual knowledge. "Have all the workers of iniquity no knowledge? who eat up my people as they eat bread, and call not upon the Lord" (Ps 14:4). And when God wanted to describe what true knowledge of Himself looks like for the people of Israel, He defined it by its fruit, namely, that it leads to holy practice: "He judged the cause of the poor and needy; then it was well with him. Was not this to know me? saith the Lord" (Jer 22:16). The apostle John confirms this same truth, telling us that keeping Christ's commands is an unmistakable sign of genuinely knowing Him, and he brands as a blatant hypocrite and liar anyone who claims to know Christ while refusing to keep His commandments (1 John 2:3-4). If a man possesses spiritual knowledge and understanding, it naturally produces in him an excellent spirit. "A man of understanding is of an excellent spirit" (Prov 17:27). And that excellent spirit will inevitably express itself in a corresponding way of life. The same truth appears, also, in a fifth consideration.
5. From the more immediate consideration of the principle of grace itself, from which it will be seen that the tendency of all Christian grace is to practice. And here, First, it appears that all true Christian grace tends to practice, because the faculty which is the immediate seat of it is the faculty of the will, which is the faculty that commands all a man's actions and practice. The immediate seat of grace is in the will or disposition. This shows that all true grace tends to practice, because there is not a single act a man performs that can properly be called part of his practice except insofar as it flows from the will. When we speak of a man's practice, we have in mind those things he does as a free and voluntary agent, or, what amounts to the same thing, those things he does by an act of his will. The whole of a man's practice is therefore directed by the faculty of the will. All the executive powers of the man, whether of body or mind, are subject to the will by the design of Him who made us and who is the great author of our being. The will is the source of practice in precisely the same way that the head of a spring is the source of the stream that flows from it. If, therefore, a principle of true grace is seated in this faculty, it must necessarily tend to practice, just as surely as water flowing at the source will flow in the stream.
Second, It is the definition of grace, that it is a principle of holy action. Grace is, by definition, a principle of holiness, a holy principle residing in the heart. But the word "principle" is inherently relational: it must be a principle of something. So if grace is a principle, what is it a principle of, if not action? Principles and actions are correlates that necessarily point toward each other. Consider what we mean by a principle of life: we mean a principle that expresses itself through living action. When we speak of a principle of understanding, we mean a principle from which acts of understanding flow. When we speak of a principle of sin, we mean a principle from which sinful acts flow. In the same way, when we speak of a principle of grace, we mean a principle from which gracious acts flow. A principle of grace relates to practice in exactly the way a root relates to the plant it sustains. If there is a root, it is the root of something; either of something that already grows from it, or of something it is working to bring forth. It is absurd to speak of a root that is the root of nothing, and it is equally absurd to speak of a principle of grace that produces no grace in practice.
Third, one more distinguishing mark of what is real and substantial, as opposed to what is merely a shadow or appearance, is that it actually produces results. A shadow or picture of a man, no matter how detailed or skillfully drawn, no matter how vivid the likeness, and no matter how strong or imposing the man it depicts, accomplishes nothing. It brings nothing about, because it isn't real; it's only an image. The substance, the reality, is something else entirely: it works, it acts, it produces effects. The same principle holds true for what lives in the human heart. That which is only an appearance or imitation of grace, however much it resembles the real thing, is ultimately ineffective, because it lacks reality and substance. But what is genuine and substantial does produce results; it actually changes something in the way a person lives. In other words, it expresses itself in practice. And this leads naturally to the fourth point: the nature of a principle of grace is to be a principle of life, a vital and animating force. Scripture teaches this everywhere. Natural men, those who have no principle of grace in the heart, are described as dead, while those who have grace are described as alive, as possessing the principle of life within them. And it is the very nature of a living principle to be a principle of action and movement. A dead man does nothing; he neither acts, nor moves, nor brings anything about. But in living persons, life shows itself through a continuous course of daily action. They move, they walk, they work, and they fill their days with the fruits of that life.
Fifth, true Christian grace is not merely a principle of life, but an extraordinarily powerful one. This is why Scripture speaks of "the power of godliness" (2 Tim 3:5), and teaches that within grace there operates a divine power, the very power that raised Christ from the dead. And the more powerful any principle is, the more effectively it produces the actions and the way of life toward which it naturally tends.
Having established, in general terms, that all true grace in the heart tends toward holy practice in daily life, I move on to the second point proposed: showing the same truth with respect to particular Christian graces. Here I observe that this holds true, first, with respect to a true and saving faith in the Lord Jesus Christ. This is one of the clearest distinctions between saving faith and merely common faith. True faith is a faith that works; false faith is barren and produces nothing. This is why the apostle describes saving faith as "faith that worketh by love" (Gal 5:6). And James puts it plainly: "A man may say, Thou hast faith, and I have works: shew me thy faith without thy works, and I will shew thee my faith by my works" (Jas 2:18). But let me be more specific.
First, the conviction of the understanding and judgment that is implied in saving faith tends toward holy practice. The person who has true faith is convinced of the reality and certainty of the great things of religion, and whoever is genuinely convinced of these things will be shaped by them; they will govern his actions and his conduct. When people are told of great things that, if true, concern them deeply, and they don't believe what they're told, they won't be much moved by it, and they won't change their behavior on account of what they've heard. But if they truly believe what they are told and regard it as certain, it will influence how they act; in light of it, they will change their conduct and behave very differently from how they would have if they had heard nothing at all. We see this pattern play out in every area of life where something appears genuinely real and important to a person. If a man hears significant news that directly concerns him, and we see no change whatsoever in how he lives, we immediately conclude that he doesn't actually accept it as true, because we know human nature well enough to understand that people govern their actions by what they genuinely believe and are convinced of. And so, when people are truly convinced of the truth of what the gospel tells them about an eternal world and the everlasting salvation Christ has purchased for all who will receive it, that conviction will shape their practice. They will order their lives according to such a belief and will act in ways that tend toward obtaining this eternal salvation. If people are convinced of the certain truth of the gospel's promises, which promise eternal riches, honors, and pleasures, and if they genuinely believe these to be immeasurably more valuable than all the riches, honors, and pleasures this world can offer, they will, for the sake of those eternal things, forsake the things of the world and, if necessary, sell everything and follow Christ. If they are fully persuaded that Christ will indeed bestow all these things on His people, and if all of this appears real to them, it will bear directly on how they live, moving them to order their lives accordingly. Their practice will follow their convictions. Human nature simply won't allow it to be otherwise. If one man promises another that if he parts with one pound he will receive a thousand in return, and if that man is fully convinced the promise is genuine, he will readily give up the lesser amount in confident expectation of receiving the greater. In the same way, the person who is convinced of Christ's sufficiency to deliver him from all evil and bring him into possession of all the good he needs will be shaped in his practice by the promise that offers him all of this. Such a person, while he holds that conviction, will not be afraid to trust Christ even in circumstances where doing so might seem to expose him to hardship, because he is convinced that Christ is able to deliver him. And he will not be afraid to give up other means of securing earthly happiness, because he is convinced that Christ alone is sufficient to provide all the happiness he truly needs.
Second, the act of the will present in saving faith also tends toward holy practice. The person who, by an act of his will, truly accepts Christ as Savior accepts Him as a Savior from sin itself, not merely as a Savior from sin's punishment. But it is impossible for anyone to sincerely receive Christ as a Savior from sin and from sinful ways without having willed, and genuinely aiming, in both heart and life, to turn from every sinful path. For the person who has not willed that sin and he should part cannot have willed to receive Christ as the Savior who would part them. And so, the person who receives Christ through living faith also embraces Him as Lord and King, to rule over and reign within him, and not merely as a priest to make atonement on his behalf. But to choose Christ and embrace Him as King is the same as yielding in submission to His law and in obedience to His authority and commands, and the person who does this lives a life of holy practice.
Third, all genuine trust in God, the kind implied in saving faith, tends toward holy practice. This is precisely where true trust differs from every counterfeit version. Trusting God through negligence is what Scripture calls tempting God, and trusting Him through sin is what Scripture calls presumption, something His Word threatens with terrible consequences. But the person who truly and rightly trusts in God does so through diligence and holiness, which is simply another way of saying through holy practice. The very nature of trusting someone else means resting in a settled confidence in that person's sufficiency and faithfulness, to the point where you are ready to act on that confidence. Those who never act on their persuasion of another's sufficiency and faithfulness aren't really venturing anything. They don't begin any action or course of action from a place of genuine confidence, so they risk nothing, and therefore can't be said to truly trust at all. The person who genuinely trusts another actually stakes something on that trust. And so it is with those who truly trust in God. They rest in the full conviction that God is sufficient and faithful, and they move forward in that conviction, following God and, when necessary, enduring hardship and difficulty for His sake, because He has promised they will not lose by doing so. Their confidence is strong enough that they can and do act on His promise, while those who are unwilling to take that risk reveal by their hesitation that they don't actually trust Him. Those who possess the full trust in God that living faith implies will not be afraid to entrust their material resources to Him. Consider how this works with human relationships: if someone we fully trust asks to borrow something and promises to repay us a hundredfold, we don't hesitate to lend it. In the same way, those who feel genuine confidence in God are not afraid to lend to the Lord. And if we truly trust in God, we will not be afraid to give our labor, our effort, our endurance, and our suffering for His sake, since He has so abundantly promised to reward these things with something that will infinitely outweigh every loss, difficulty, or sorrow we encounter in the path of duty. If our faith is saving faith, it will lead us to actually venture on God in this way, resting in full confidence in His character and His promises. And just as faith, in itself and in everything it implies, tends toward holy practice, the same is true of 2. all genuine love for God. Love is an active principle, and we see this consistently in the affairs of everyday life. Love for other people always shapes how we act and what we do. The whole of humanity is kept in motion, day after day and year after year, largely by one form of love or another. The person who loves money is driven in his conduct by that love, kept in constant pursuit of wealth by it. The person who loves honor is governed in his behavior by that love, with his actions throughout life shaped by his desire for it. And how relentlessly do those who love worldly pleasures pursue them in practice! The same holds true for the person who genuinely loves God: that love shapes his conduct. He continually seeks after God throughout the course of his life, seeking His grace, His acceptance, and His glory.
Reason teaches us that a person's actions are the most reliable test of their love. If someone claims to be a devoted friend, reason tells us that the truest evidence of that friendship lies in what they actually do, not merely in what they say. A genuine friend will be willing, when the moment demands it, to set aside their own interests and accept personal cost for the sake of someone they care about. No matter how warmly a person professes their affection, a wise observer won't take that profession at face value without seeing it confirmed in behavior. Unless someone has proven themselves through consistent, faithful action, ready to both do and suffer on another's behalf, their words carry little weight. That kind of demonstrated loyalty will always be more convincing than the grandest declarations or even the most solemn oaths made without it. The same principle applies to our relationship with God. When we observe someone who consistently exerts themselves in God's service, reason tells us that this conduct offers far more credible evidence of love for God than any claim about feelings stirring in the heart. Likewise, when we see someone whose life genuinely reflects the pattern and spirit of Christ, someone who actively labors for Christ's honor and the growth of His kingdom in the world, reason tells us that this person gives stronger proof of sincere and deep love for the Savior than someone who simply announces their devotion and recounts the moments when their heart felt moved, while at the same time dragging their feet when asked to do anything significant for Christ, finding excuses whenever active effort or self-denial is required.
There are several ways that genuine love for God expresses itself, and all of them lead to holy action. One is through holding God in the highest esteem; we naturally show our regard for whatever we love, and that regard shapes how we behave. Another way of expressing love for God is in choosing Him above everything else. If we sincerely choose Him above all other things, then when the moment of testing arrives, we will actually leave those other things behind. When life places God and our reputation, or God and our wealth, or God and our comfort, before us at the same time, so that we must hold to one and release the other, then a genuine love for God will show itself in practice: we will hold to Him and let the rest go. A third expression of love for God is found in our longing for Him, and this too leads to action. Whoever truly yearns for God will be moved to seek Him actively, approaching it with the same focused energy that people bring to pursuing something they want and believe they can have. Yet another expression of love for God is found in delighting in Him, in finding real satisfaction and happiness in Him; and this, too, shapes how we live. Whoever sincerely delights in God more than in anything else, and finds his contentment in God, will not abandon God for other things. His conduct itself becomes the evidence that God is enough for him. This principle holds in every case: if we have genuinely enjoyed something and then walk away from it for something else, that departure proves we were never fully satisfied with it and never truly prized it above all else. In every one of these expressions, what we feel and what we choose will eventually show up in what we do.
3. All true and saving repentance tends to holy practice. In the original New Testament Greek, the word we typically translate as "repentance" means a change of the mind. A person is said to repent of sin when their thinking about it fundamentally shifts: what they once valued and approved of, they now reject and dislike. But such a change of mind must, by its very nature, produce a corresponding change in behavior. We see this pattern play out consistently in every other area of life. If someone has long been devoted to a particular pursuit or way of living, and then genuinely changes their mind about it, they will change their habits as well. They will step away from that pursuit and turn toward something else. Sorrow for sin is one essential element of saving repentance, and if that sorrow is genuine and thorough, it will naturally lead to forsaking sin in practice. This holds true across the board. If someone has spent years living in a particular pattern of behavior, and then becomes convinced of its foolishness and sinfulness, and is truly grieved by it, the natural and necessary result will be that they avoid it going forward. If they simply continue as before, no one will believe their sorrow was sincere. 4. All true humility tends to holy practice. Humility is a virtue the Bible commends and insists on repeatedly, and it is frequently held up as one of the marks that distinguishes genuine Christian experience from its counterfeit. This grace, when it truly takes root in the heart, has a direct tendency to shape holy behavior in daily life. A humble heart produces humble conduct. The person who is genuinely aware of their own smallness, their nothingness, and their profound unworthiness will naturally carry themselves accordingly, both before God and before other people. Someone who was once dominated by pride in their conduct, but whose heart has since been changed to one of genuine humility, will necessarily show a corresponding change in their behavior. They will no longer carry themselves with the arrogance, contempt, and ambition that once defined them: no longer straining to appear superior to others, no longer quick to condemn, no longer resentful or furious toward anyone who seems to threaten their earthly standing. That kind of proud behavior, before the change, flowed directly from a proud heart. So if that pride has now been deeply mortified and driven out of the soul, replaced by genuine humility, then the behavior must change as well. Humility of heart is just as powerful a force toward action as pride of heart ever was. If pride is mortified and humility takes its place, the proud conduct that pride once produced will proportionally fade, and the humble conduct that is humility's natural fruit will become evident.
True Christian humility of heart also tends to make people resigned to the will of God, leading them to be patient and submissive under the afflictions He sends, filled with deep reverence toward the Deity, and disposed to treat divine things with the highest respect. It also leads to a meek bearing toward others, making us willing to condescend to those beneath us, respectful toward those above us, and toward everyone gentle, peaceful, easy to approach, not self-willed, not envious, but content with our own condition, calm and quiet in spirit, not quick to resent injuries, but ready to forgive. These are surely marks of holy practice. And so, again, 5. All true fear of God tends to holy practice. The primary meaning of the fear of God in Scripture is a holy concern, a deep dread of offending God by sinning against Him. If a person truly fears offending God and habitually dreads the thought of sinning against Him, this will surely lead him to avoid sin. What people are genuinely afraid of, they will avoid. If a man claims to fear and dread a poisonous serpent, yet takes no care to stay away from it and boldly keeps close to it, who will believe him? Fearing God and carefully obeying all His commandments are joined together as naturally flowing from one another, as in "If you will not observe to do all the words of this law that are written in this book, that you may fear this glorious and fearful name, the Lord your God" (Deut 28:58). Joseph gives his fear of God as the reason for his righteous and merciful conduct toward his brothers, as we see in Gen 42:18. Prov 8:13 tells us that "the fear of the Lord is to hate evil." Job gives his fear of God's judgment as the reason he avoided sin: "destruction from God was a terror to him" (Job 31:23). And God Himself, when He speaks of Job as turning away from evil, points to Job's fear of God as the very ground and reason for it (Job 1:8). In any person at all, the fear of God will lead its possessor to avoid sin and pursue holiness in exact proportion to how fully it reigns in the heart. Again, 6. The spirit of thankfulness and praise tends to holy practice. Sincere thankfulness to God leads us to give back in proportion to the benefits we have received. We regard this as a sure sign of genuine gratitude even among people. If someone does his neighbor a remarkable kindness and the neighbor is truly grateful, he will be ready, when the opportunity comes, to return the favor. And though we cannot repay God's kindness by doing anything that benefits Him directly, a spirit of thankfulness will dispose us to do what we can: whatever is pleasing and acceptable to Him, or whatever may advance His glory. Consider a man who takes pity on another in desperate distress or mortal danger, and who, moved by that pity, exerts himself greatly for the other's defense and rescue, enduring great hardship and suffering in the process, and who by these means actually delivers him. If the one rescued then expresses great thankfulness toward his deliverer, yet in his actual conduct opposes, dishonors, and contemns him, doing him serious injury, no one would place much weight on all his professions of gratitude. Genuine thankfulness simply does not behave that way toward a benefactor. In the same way, no one can be truly thankful to God for the dying love of Christ, and for God's infinite mercy and love toward him personally, and yet lead a wicked life. If his gratitude is sincere, it will lead him to be holy. The same is true, again, 7. Of a Christian detachment from the world, and of heavenly-mindedness, that they tend to holy practice. I speak of these two together because they are largely the same thing, stated negatively and positively. To lack detachment from the world is simply to be worldly-minded; and, on the other hand, to be truly detached from the world in the Christian sense is to be not worldly, but heavenly-minded. This grace, like all the others mentioned, tends to holy practice. If the heart is drawn away from the world, it will tend to draw our pursuits away from the world as well; and if the heart is set on heavenly things, which are not of this world, it will tend to lead us to pursue what is heavenly. A person whose heart is genuinely loose from the world will not, in practice, clutch the world tightly as though desperately unwilling to part with any of it. If a man describes an experience in which he felt his heart weaned from the world, so that the world seemed like nothing and vanity to him, yet in practice appears just as driven after worldly things as ever, and far more earnest in pursuing them than in pursuing heavenly things such as growth in grace, in the knowledge of God, and in duty, then his profession carries very little weight against the evidence of his conduct. And if his behavior shows that he values earthly treasure above heavenly treasure, and if, once he has gained the world or some portion of it, he hugs it close and proves deeply reluctant to part with even a little of it for pious and charitable purposes, though God promises him a thousandfold more in heaven in return, he gives not the slightest evidence of being weaned from the world or of preferring heavenly things to earthly ones. Judged by his practice, there is sobering reason to believe his profession is empty. The same is true, also, 8. Of the spirit of Christian love to others, that this also tends to holy practice. If love for others is sincere, it will express itself in acts of love. A love that appears only in words and not in deeds is hypocritical, not sincere; but love that is genuine will show itself in action, as the apostle says: "My little children, let us not love in word, neither in tongue, but in deed and in truth. And hereby we know that we are of the truth, and shall assure our hearts before him" (1 John 3:18-19). No love for fellow believers that fails to show itself in deeds of love will profit anyone. "If a brother or sister be naked, and destitute of daily food, and one of you say unto them, Depart in peace, be ye warmed and filled; notwithstanding ye give them not those things which are needful to the body, what doth it profit?" (Jas 2:15-16).
Experience shows that those who genuinely love others are ready both to act and to sacrifice on their behalf. We readily believe that parents love their own children, because this love is natural and nearly universal. Yet as unthinkable as it is that a father would not love his child, consider a father who sees his child suffering and won't inconvenience himself to help, or who fails to treat his children with ordinary consideration and kindness, going day after day as though he were completely indifferent to their wellbeing. We would struggle to believe that any trace of a father's love lived in his heart. Love for our children will naturally move us toward loving actions for our children. In the same way, love for our neighbor will move us toward every kind of good practice toward our neighbor. The apostle makes exactly this point when, after summarizing the several commandments of the second table of the law, he writes, "And if there be any other commandment, it is briefly comprehended in this saying, namely, Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself," and then adds, "Love worketh no ill to his neighbour: therefore love is the fulfilling of the law" (Rom 13:9-10). One final observation remains: 9. To a true and gracious hope, that this also tends to holy practice. A false hope moves in exactly the opposite direction. It tends toward moral looseness, encouraging people in their sinful desires and lusts, flattering and emboldening them even while they walk in the way of evil. But a true hope, far from hardening people in sin or making them careless about their duty, stirs them up toward holiness of life, awakens them to their obligations, and makes them more careful to avoid sin and more diligent in serving God. "Every man that hath this hope in him purifieth himself, even as he is pure" (1 John 3:3). A gracious hope carries this tendency by virtue of the nature of the happiness it anticipates, which is a holy happiness; the more a person seeks and hopes for it, the more he is quickened and enlivened in his disposition toward holiness. It also carries this tendency through its relationship to the one from whom that happiness is hoped for: it hopes for it from God, as the fruit of His undeserved and infinite mercy, and so every motive of gratitude engages and stirs the heart to seek what is pleasing to Him. It carries the same tendency as well through its regard for the means by which it hopes to obtain this happiness, since a true hope looks forward to happiness in no other way than the way of the gospel, which is through a holy Savior, by cleaving to Him and following Him. And finally, it carries this same tendency through the influence of what is the immediate source of all gracious hope, namely faith in Christ. Such faith always works, and works through love, purifying the heart and bringing forth holy fruit in the life.
We have now seen, through both general arguments and a survey of specific examples covering all the principal Christian virtues, that genuine grace in the heart naturally tends toward holy practice in daily life. This is as certain as the way a plant's root drives its growth, or the way light naturally shines, or the way the principle of life expresses itself in everything a living person does.
Turning now to the practical implications of this subject: 1. We can see one central reason why Christian practice and good works are so consistently emphasized throughout Scripture as evidence of genuine grace. Christ gave us the rule that we are to judge people by their fruits (Matt 7:16-20), and He insists with particular force that the person who keeps His commandments is the one who truly loves Him (John 14:21). He further declares that the person who loves Him will keep them, while the person who does not love Him will not (John 14:23-24). This helps us understand why the apostle Paul pressed this point so hard, warning his readers that anyone who claimed to belong to the kingdom of God while ignoring His commandments was either a hypocrite or deceiving themselves. His words are direct: "For this you know, that no sexually immoral person, nor impure person, nor covetous man, who is an idolater, has any inheritance in the kingdom of Christ and of God. Let no one deceive you with empty words, for because of these things the wrath of God comes upon the sons of disobedience" (Eph 5:5-6). "Do you not know that the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: neither the sexually immoral, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor men who practice homosexuality, nor thieves, nor the greedy, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God" (1 Cor 6:9-10). "Those who belong to Christ Jesus have crucified the flesh with its passions and desires" (Gal 5:24). "If you live according to the flesh you will die" (Rom 8:13). All of this also explains why the apostle James returns to the same theme repeatedly in passages you will know well, and why the apostle John dwells on it more than almost any other subject. The reason is that God intends for this truth to be deeply fixed in every mind: good works are the only reliable evidence that genuine grace truly lives in the soul. It is by our practice that God evaluates us here on earth, and it is by our practice that He will judge us all on the final day.
2. In view of this subject, let all examine themselves, whether their grace is real and sincere. Let everyone ask honestly and prayerfully whether their spiritual graces actually shape how they live, and whether those graces show up day after day in their behavior and choices. Even some genuinely godly people may be tempted to say that if they judge themselves by their conduct, they have no choice but to condemn themselves, because they fail so often and so consistently, and wander so far from the right path, that they can barely believe they are children of God at all. To those people I want to say this: you may examine your practice and find that you fall short every single day, that you frequently lose your way, and yet still have no real grounds in that practice to condemn yourself. When we talk about a life of Christian practice, and when Scripture describes a course of life as Christian, the point is not that such a life is perfect or sinless. On the contrary, a Christian's life may be marked by many serious and persistent imperfections and still be a genuinely holy life, a truly Christian life. It may be exactly the kind of life that clearly, even unmistakably, shows that the grace a person possesses is the kind that naturally tends toward holy living. The fruit may be solid evidence of the health of the tree, and the works may be clear evidence of the faith behind them. And if you're looking for even more guidance on this, then whatever your imperfections and failures may be, examine yourself to see whether you find the following signs that your grace is of the kind that tends toward holy practice.
First, does your supposed grace actually influence you enough to make the things you've failed at in holy practice feel loathsome, grievous, and humbling? Does it shape your mind in such a way that your past sinful behavior becomes hateful to you? Has it led you to mourn before God for those failures? And does it make the things in your conduct that, since your supposed conversion, have fallen short of Christian practice feel genuinely repugnant to you? Is it the great burden of your life that your practice isn't better? Does it truly grieve you that you have fallen, or continue to fall, into sin? Are you ready, following the example of holy Job, to abhor yourself for it and repent in dust and ashes? And like Paul, do you lament your wretchedness and pray to be delivered from sin as you would pray to be freed from a body of death?
Second, do you carry with you, as a constant habit, a deep dread of sin? Do you not only mourn and humble yourself for sins already committed, but also dread sin going forward? And do you dread it because it is evil in itself, harmful to your own soul, and offensive to God? Do you dread it as a terrible enemy that has wounded you repeatedly, something you've suffered under so deeply that you want nothing more to do with it? Do you stand watch against it the way a person keeps guard against something they genuinely fear, with the kind of dread that led Joseph to say, "How can I do this great wickedness, and sin against God?" (Gen 39:9).
Third, Are you genuinely aware of the beauty and pleasantness of holy living? Do you see the beauty of holiness, and the loveliness of God's ways? The text tells us that "charity rejoiceth in the truth," and the truly godly person is characterized by the fact that "he rejoiceth and worketh righteousness," which is simply another way of saying that he takes joy in doing what is right. And how often does the Psalmist speak of God's law as his deepest delight, and of his love for the divine commandments!
Fourth, Do you find that you particularly value and delight in those practices that can rightly be called distinctively Christian, as opposed to mere worldly morality? By Christian practices, I mean those implied in a meek, humble, prayerful, self-denying, self-renouncing, and heavenly way of living. Some of the ancient pagans were remarkable for many of the moral virtues and wrote brilliantly about them, including justice, generosity, and courage; but they fell far short of the Christian poverty of spirit and lowliness of mind. They sought their own glory and took great pride in their outward virtues, and they seemed to know nothing of the kind of life the gospel requires: a life of self-emptying, poverty of spirit, self-distrust, self-renunciation, and prayerful dependence on God. They were strangers to meekness, and they neither practiced nor even imagined that forgiving and loving one's enemies could be a virtue. These are distinctively Christian virtues, Christian in the fullest and most elevated sense, and it is about these that I am asking: do you hold them in special esteem, for your Savior's sake, and because they are filled with His spirit? If your spirit is genuinely and fundamentally different from that of the mere moralist or the pagan philosopher, you will have a deep and particular love for those virtues that belong most essentially to the gospel.
Fifth, Do you hunger and thirst after a holy life? Do you long to be conformed to God, to have your daily conduct grow more spiritual, more glorifying to God, and more worthy of a Christian? Is this what you love, pray for, long for, and live for? Christ Himself identifies this as a mark of true believers: that they "hunger and thirst after righteousness" (Matt 5:6). Does that description fit you?
Sixth, Do you make holiness your primary pursuit, seeking to live as God would have you live in every area of life? It's not enough to say you make some effort toward holiness; the question is whether you make it your chief concern. Does it weigh on your mind with real seriousness? A true and faithful Christian doesn't treat holy living as a side matter. It is his central preoccupation. Just as a soldier's business is to fight, a Christian's business is to be like Christ, to be holy as He is holy. Christian practice is the great work he is engaged in, just as running the race was the great work of the runner. Is that true of you? And is it your deep aim and desire to keep all of God's commandments, neglecting none that you know? "Then," says the Psalmist, "I shall not be ashamed, when I have respect unto all thy commandments" (Ps 119:6). Is it your sincere, consistent, and prayerful goal to be faithful in every known duty? And finally, Seventh, Do you earnestly desire to know everything that God requires of you? And do you want to know it so that you can do it? Like the patriarch Job, can you pray to the Almighty, "That which I see not, teach thou me" (Job 34:32), adding, as he added to the great Searcher of hearts, "If I have done iniquity, I will do no more"?
If you can honestly meet these tests, then you have evidence that your grace is the kind that leads to holy practice and growth in it. And though you may fall, through God's mercy you will rise again. He who has begun a good work in you will carry it through until the day of Jesus Christ. Though you may at times grow faint, if you keep pressing forward you will be carried from strength to strength, kept by the power of God through faith unto salvation.
CHAPTER 12
LECTURE 12. LOVE SEEKS THE GOOD OF OTHERS
"Charity . . . beareth all things." (1 Cor 13:7)
Having declared in the previous verses those fruits of charity that consist in doing, the apostle now turns to those that have reference to suffering. Here he declares that charity, or the spirit of Christian love, tends to dispose people and make them willing to undergo all sufferings for Christ's sake and in the way of duty. This, I believe, is the meaning of the expression "beareth all things." Some, I know, would read these words as referring only to the patient bearing of injuries from other people. But it seems to me they are better understood in the sense I have given here, as referring to suffering in the cause of Christ and religion, and for the following reasons:
First, as for bearing injuries from others, the apostle had already addressed that earlier, when he said that "charity suffereth long," and again when he declared that it "is not easily provoked," meaning that it tends to resist the passion of anger. There is no reason, then, to suppose he would repeat himself so needlessly by mentioning the same thing a third time.
Second, the apostle appears to have finished cataloguing the more active expressions of charity, having summed them all up in the previous verse: "rejoiceth not in iniquity, but rejoiceth in the truth." He had been working through the various ways charity shapes our conduct toward our neighbors, and having gathered all of that into that single expression, he now seems to turn toward qualities of a different kind, rather than simply restating the same ideas in new words.
Third, the apostle Paul frequently cites suffering in the cause of Christ as a fruit of Christian love, which makes it unlikely that he would leave out such a significant fruit here, in a passage where he is deliberately enumerating all the important fruits of love and charity. He returns to this theme repeatedly elsewhere. In 2 Cor 5:14, for instance, after describing what he had endured for Christ's sake (conduct that led others to accuse him of madness), he explains his motivation by saying that the love of Christ compelled him. Again, in Rom 5:3, 5, he gives as his reason for glorying in suffering the fact that the love of God had been poured into his heart by the Holy Spirit. And once more, he declares that neither tribulation, nor distress, nor persecution, nor famine, nor nakedness, nor peril, nor sword could ever separate him from the love of Christ (Rom 8:35). Given that suffering for Christ's sake is such a prominent fruit of charity, and given how often Paul returns to it elsewhere, it seems highly unlikely that he would pass over it here, in a passage explicitly devoted to tracing out charity's many fruits.
Fourth, The closing words, "believeth all things, hopeth all things, endureth all things," together signal that the apostle has finished addressing those expressions of charity that relate primarily to our fellow human beings, as will become clearer when we examine these phrases more fully. The doctrine I draw from this text, then, is this: THAT CHARITY, OR A TRULY CHRISTIAN SPIRIT, WILL MAKE US WILLING, FOR CHRIST'S SAKE, TO UNDERGO ALL SUFFERINGS TO WHICH WE MAY BE EXPOSED IN THE WAY OF DUTY.
In developing this doctrine, I will first explain it briefly, and then offer reasons and evidence for its truth.
I. I would explain the doctrine. In doing so, I remark, 1. That it implies that those who have the true spirit of charity, or Christian love, are willing not only to do, but also to suffer, for Christ. Hypocrites may, and often do, make a great show of religion in their professions and words that cost nothing, and in actions that involve no real difficulty or suffering. But they don't have a suffering spirit, or a spirit that inclines them to willingly endure hardship for Christ's sake. When they took up religion, it was never with any thought of suffering, nor with any expectation of being harmed by it in their worldly interests. They embraced Christ, to whatever extent they did, only to serve their own purposes. Everything they do in religious life flows from a self-serving spirit, and is generally very much in their own interest, just as it was with the Pharisees of old. They are therefore far from the spirit that is willing to meet suffering, whether in their persons or their interests. But those who are truly Christians have a spirit to suffer for Christ; they are willing to follow Him on the very condition He Himself laid down: "Whoever does not bear his cross and come after me cannot be my disciple" (Luke 14:27). And not only are they willing to suffer for Christ, but, 2. It is also implied in our doctrine that they have the spirit to undergo all the sufferings to which their duty to Christ may expose them. Here, First, they are willing to undergo all sufferings of all kinds that lie in the path of duty. They have the spirit of willingness to suffer in their reputation; to endure reproach and contempt for Christ's sake; and to place the honor of Christ above their own. With the apostle they can say, "Therefore I take pleasure in infirmities, in reproaches, in necessities, in persecutions, in distresses, for Christ's sake" (2 Cor 12:10). They have a spirit to endure the hatred and ill-will of others, as Christ foretold when He said, "You will be hated by all men for my name's sake" (Matt 10:22). They have a spirit to suffer losses in their outward possessions, as the apostle says: "Indeed, I count everything as loss because of the surpassing worth of knowing Christ Jesus my Lord, for whose sake I have suffered the loss of all things" (Phil 3:8). They have the spirit to suffer in their ease and comfort, to endure hardships and exhaustion: like Paul, to prove themselves faithful "in much patience, in afflictions, in necessities, in distresses, in stripes, in imprisonments, in tumults, in labors, in watchings, in fastings" (2 Cor 6:4-5). They have the spirit to suffer bodily pain, like those who were tortured and refused to accept deliverance, and those who endured cruel mockings and floggings, bonds and imprisonment (Heb 11:35-36). They have a spirit to suffer even death itself: "Whoever finds his life will lose it, and whoever loses his life for my sake will find it" (Matt 10:39). These, and all other conceivable sufferings in kind, they are willing to undergo for Christ's sake and in the path of duty. And so, Second, they are willing to undergo all sufferings of all degrees that lie in the path of duty. They are like pure gold that will bear the trial of the hottest furnace. They have the heart to forsake everything and follow Christ, and to comparatively "hate" even "father and mother, and wife and children, and brothers and sisters, yes, and their own life also," for His sake (Luke 14:26). They have the spirit to suffer the greatest degrees of reproach and contempt, to endure not only mockings but cruel mockings, and to bear not only loss but the loss of all things. They have the spirit to suffer death, and not only death, but the most cruel and agonizing forms of it, such as "being stoned, being sawn in two, being killed with the sword, wandering about in sheepskins and goatskins, destitute, afflicted, and tormented" (Heb 11:37). The fiercest and most severe sufferings in degree they are willing to undergo for Christ. I proceed, then, to II. Give some reason or proof of the doctrine. That those who have a truly gracious spirit are willing to undergo all sufferings they may face in the path of duty will become clear from the following considerations:
1. If we lack this spirit, it is evidence that we have never given ourselves unreservedly to Christ. To be a Christian, a follower of Christ, we must give ourselves to Him completely: wholly His, only His, and His forever. This is why Scripture so often compares a believer's commitment to Christ to a bride giving herself in marriage to her husband. God says to His people, "I will betroth thee unto me for ever; yea, I will betroth thee unto me in righteousness, and in judgment, and in loving-kindness, and in mercies" (Hos 2:19). And just as a bride gives herself to her husband to be his, and his alone, true believers are not their own. They have been bought with a price, and they freely acknowledge the full claim Christ has on them, offering themselves to Him as a living sacrifice, willingly and completely devoted. Those who lack the spirit to endure all things for Christ reveal, by that very lack, that they have not given themselves to Him without reservation, because they are holding back in precisely those moments of suffering they are unwilling to bear for His sake. In those moments, they want to be excused from standing for Christ and His glory, preferring instead that His cause be set aside for their own comfort or advantage. But making such exceptions is fundamentally incompatible with a genuine devotion to God. It resembles nothing so much as Ananias and Sapphira, who gave only a portion while secretly keeping back part of what they claimed to offer to the Lord. To give ourselves wholly to Christ means surrendering our temporal interests to Him entirely. And the person who has truly surrendered those interests is ready to suffer any worldly loss for His sake. If God is genuinely loved, He is loved as God, which means loving Him as the highest good. And the person who loves God as the highest good is prepared to let every other good yield to that one, which is simply another way of saying he is willing to suffer all things for the sake of that good.
2. They who are truly Christian fear God so deeply that His displeasure is far more terrible to them than any earthly suffering or affliction. When Christ was preparing His disciples for the persecutions they would face on His account, He told them: "Be not afraid of them that kill the body, and after that have no more that they can do; but I will forewarn you whom ye shall fear: him, which after he hath killed, hath power to cast into hell; yea, I say unto you, fear him" (Luke 12:4-5). The prophet echoes this same truth: "Sanctify the Lord of hosts himself; and let him be your fear, and let him be your dread" (Isa 8:13). Those who are genuinely Christian see and know this God in all His greatness and terribleness. They understand that His displeasure and wrath are far more dreadful than any temporal suffering they might encounter in the course of their duty, more dreadful than the rage and cruelty of men, and more dreadful than the worst torments human hands can inflict. Because of this, they carry within them the resolve to endure whatever suffering may come rather than abandon God and sin against the One who holds the power to pour out eternal wrath upon them.
3. True Christians have a faith that lets them see something far greater than any suffering they could ever endure for the cause of Christ. They see an excellence in God and in Christ, whom they have chosen as their portion, that far outweighs every possible suffering. They also see the glory God has promised to those who suffer for His sake: that "far more exceeding and eternal weight of glory" that their sufferings for Christ actually produce, and against which even the heaviest sorrows and most enduring trials are nothing more than "light affliction, which is but for a moment" (2 Cor 4:17). Moses' faith is offered as the reason he was willing to suffer alongside the people of God and to endure reproach for Christ's sake, because through that faith he saw something far better than the throne and riches of Egypt waiting for him in heaven (Heb 11:24-26).
4. If we are not willing to embrace religion despite all its difficulties, we will be overwhelmed with shame in the end. Christ teaches this explicitly. His words are: "For which of you, intending to build a tower, does not first sit down and count the cost, to see whether he has enough to finish it? Otherwise, after he has laid the foundation and cannot complete it, everyone who sees it will mock him, saying, 'This man began to build and was not able to finish.' Or what king, going to war against another king, does not first sit down and consider whether he can meet with ten thousand the one coming against him with twenty thousand? Or else, while the other is still far away, he sends a delegation and asks for terms of peace. So likewise, whoever among you does not give up all that he has cannot be my disciple" (Luke 14:28-33). The sufferings that come with living faithfully are among the difficulties that attend religion. They are part of the cost of being a Christian. Anyone who is unwilling to pay that cost has never truly accepted the terms of religion. He is like the man who wishes his house were built but refuses to pay what building it requires, and so, in effect, never builds it at all. Whoever does not receive the gospel along with all its difficulties has not received it as it was actually offered to him. Whoever does not receive Christ with His cross as well as His crown has not truly received Him at all. It is true that Christ invites us to come to Him for rest, and to come and buy wine and milk without cost; but He also invites us to take up the cross daily and follow Him. If we come only to accept the first invitation, we have not genuinely accepted the gospel's offer, because both come together: the rest and the yoke, the cross and the crown. It means nothing that, in accepting only the easy part, we accept what God never actually offered on its own. Those who receive only the comfortable side of Christianity, and not the demanding side, are at best almost Christians. Those who are fully Christian receive the whole of Christianity, and they will be accepted and honored rather than cast out in shame on the last day.
5. Without this spirit which the text implies, we cannot be said to forsake all for Christ.; If there is any kind or degree of temporal suffering that we lack the spirit to endure for Christ, then there is something we have not truly forsaken for Him. For example, if we are unwilling to suffer reproach for Christ, then we are unwilling to forsake honor for Him. Likewise, if we are unwilling to suffer poverty, pain, and death for His sake, then we are unwilling to forsake wealth, comfort, and life for Him. But Christ teaches us plainly and repeatedly that we must be willing to forsake everything we have for Him when duty demands it, or we cannot be His disciples (Luke 14:26ff.).
6. Without this spirit, we cannot be said to deny ourselves in the sense in which the Scriptures require us to do it. The Scriptures are clear that self-denial is absolutely necessary for anyone who wants to be a disciple of Christ. "Then said Jesus unto his disciples, If any man will come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow me; for whosoever will save his life shall lose it; and whosoever will lose his life for my sake, shall find it" (Matt 16:24-25). These words, as Christ uses them, amount to a complete renunciation of oneself. The person who actually lives by them conducts his life as though he has disowned himself for Christ's sake. He willingly accepts hardship and suffering as if his own comfort and well-being were simply not his concern. Just as the sons of Levi were said not to acknowledge their own relatives and friends when they put them to the sword for the sin of making the golden calf, Christians are said to deny themselves when they crucify the flesh and endure great suffering for Christ, showing no special mercy toward themselves. Those who act against Christ's will and compromise His glory simply to avoid suffering are, in fact, denying Christ rather than denying themselves. Those who won't confess Christ before persecutors are effectively denying Him before men, and they fall among those of whom Christ says He will deny them before His Father in heaven (Matt 10:33). The apostle makes the same point when he writes, "If we suffer, we shall also reign with him; if we deny him, he also will deny us" (2 Tim 2:12).
7. It is the character of all the true followers of Christ, that they follow him in all things. "These are they," says the beloved disciple, referring to those gathered around the throne of God, "these are they which follow the Lamb wherever he goes" (Rev 14:4). Those who are willing to follow Christ only in prosperity but not in adversity, or only through certain sufferings but not all of them, cannot truly be said to follow him wherever he goes. We read of a man who said to Christ during his earthly ministry, "Master, I will follow you wherever you go," and that Christ replied, "Foxes have holes, and birds of the air have nests, but the Son of Man has nowhere to lay his head" (Matt 8:19-20). By this, Christ was signaling to the man that following him wherever he went would mean following him through great difficulty and suffering. True followers of Christ share the same spirit toward him that Ittai the Gittite showed toward David: not merely clinging to him in his days of prosperity, but remaining loyal even in his darkest adversity, even when David himself tried to release Ittai from the obligation of going with him. Ittai said, "As the Lord lives, and as my lord the king lives, wherever my lord the king may be, whether in death or in life, there also will your servant be" (2 Sam 15:21). This is precisely the spirit that true Christians carry toward Christ, the spiritual David.
8. It is the character of true Christians that they overcome the world. "Whatsoever is born of God overcometh the world" (1 John 5:4). To overcome the world means overcoming both its flatteries and its threats, its sufferings and its difficulties. These are the weapons the world uses to conquer us, and if there is any one of them we lack the courage to face for Christ's sake, then by that weapon the world will bring us into subjection and claim its victory. But Christ gives His servants victory over the world in all its forms. They are conquerors, and more than conquerors, through Him who loved them. And finally, 9. The sufferings that come in the path of duty are often called, in Scripture, temptations or trials, because through them God tests the sincerity of our character as Christians. By placing such sufferings in our path, God tests whether we have the spirit to endure them, proving our sincerity through suffering just as gold is proved by fire, to determine whether it is pure or not. Just as fire distinguishes pure gold from every baser metal and every imitation, so by observing whether we are willing to endure trials and sufferings for Christ's sake, God sees whether we are truly His people, or whether we will abandon Him and His service the moment difficulty or danger appears. This seems to be the very point the apostle Peter makes when he writes: "Though now for a season, if need be, ye are in heaviness through manifold temptations; that the trial of your faith, being much more precious than of gold that perisheth, though it be tried with fire, might be found unto praise, and honour, and glory, at the appearing of Jesus Christ" (1 Pet 1:6-7). And again: "Beloved, think it not strange concerning the fiery trial which is to try you, as though some strange thing happened unto you; but rejoice, inasmuch as ye are partakers of Christ's sufferings, that when his glory shall be revealed, ye may be glad also with exceeding joy" (1 Pet 4:12-13). And so God declares through His prophet: "I will bring the third part through the fire, and will refine them as silver is refined, and will try them as gold is tried: they shall call on my name, and I will hear them; I will say, It is my people; and they shall say, The Lord is my God" (Zech 13:9).
In applying this subject, let it 1. Lead those who consider themselves Christians to examine whether they have the spirit to endure all suffering for Christ's sake. Every person should examine themselves carefully on this point, since Scripture attaches such great importance to a suffering spirit. You may never have faced the extreme trials that many others have endured, but God's providence has given you enough experience to reveal what your spirit truly is, and whether you are disposed to suffer, to give up your own comfort, ease, and self-interest, rather than abandon Christ. It is God's customary way, in His providence, to test all who profess religion, and especially those living in times of trial, by placing difficulties in their path that reveal the true character of their spirit, and whether it is a spirit of self-renunciation or not. Christians who face persecution often find that if they will hold fast to Christ and remain faithful to Him, they must pay a price: suffering in their reputation, losing the goodwill of others, forfeiting their ease and comfort, enduring many hardships, or facing financial difficulty in their work. They must do things they find deeply unpleasant, even frightening. When such trials have come to you, have you found within yourself the spirit to bear whatever comes rather than be unfaithful in any way to your Lord and Redeemer? You have all the more reason to examine yourselves on this point, because you cannot know whether, before you die, you may face the kind of persecution other Christians have endured. Every true Christian carries the spirit of a martyr. If you lack a suffering spirit in the smaller trials God has already sent your way, what will happen if He calls you to face bitter persecution, such as the saints of old were sometimes required to endure? If you cannot bear trials in small things, how can you possess the charity that bears all things? As the prophet says in another context, "If you have run with foot soldiers and they have worn you out, how will you compete with horses? If you stumble in a peaceful land, what will you do in the thickets by the Jordan?" (Jer 12:5). 2. Our subject also calls all who profess religion to cultivate a willing spirit, ready for Christ's sake to endure whatever suffering duty may require. Consider here, first, how Scripture describes the happiness of those who have the spirit to suffer and who actually do suffer for Christ. "Blessed," says Christ, "are those who are persecuted for righteousness' sake, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven. Blessed are you when people revile you and persecute you and utter all kinds of evil against you falsely on my account. Rejoice and be glad, for your reward in heaven is great" (Matt 5:10-12). And again, "Blessed are you who are hungry now, for you will be filled."
"Blessed are you who weep now, for you will laugh. Blessed are you when people hate you, when they exclude you and insult you and reject your name as evil because of the Son of Man. Rejoice in that day and leap for joy, because your reward is great in heaven" (Luke 6:21-23). And again: "It has been granted to you on behalf of Christ not only to believe in him, but also to suffer for him" (Phil 1:29). And again: "Blessed is the one who perseveres under trial because, having stood the test, that person will receive the crown of life that the Lord has promised to those who love him" (Jas 1:12). And again: "But even if you should suffer for what is right, you are blessed" (1 Pet 3:14). The New Testament is filled with expressions like these, all of which are meant to encourage us as we walk the path of suffering for Christ. Consider also, Second, what glorious rewards God has promised to give, in the life to come, to those who willingly suffer for Christ. Scripture says they will receive a "crown of life," and Christ promises that anyone who gives up houses, brothers, sisters, father, mother, wife, children, or fields for his name's sake will receive a hundredfold in return and will inherit eternal life (Matt 19:29). We are also told that those who suffer for Christ's sake will be counted worthy of the kingdom of God (2 Thess 1:5); that it is a trustworthy saying that if we suffer with Christ, we will also reign with him (2 Tim 2:11-12); and that if we share in his sufferings, we will also share in his glory (Rom 8:17). And we have the most glorious promises of all made to those who overcome and win the victory over the world.
"To him that overcomes," says Christ, "I will give to eat of the tree of life, which is in the midst of the paradise of God," and "he shall not be hurt by the second death;" and "to him I will give to eat of the hidden manna;" and "to him I will give power over the nations;" and "I will give him the morning star;" and "he shall be clothed in white raiment, and I will not blot out his name from the book of life, but I will confess his name before my Father and before his angels;" and "him I will make a pillar in the temple of my God, and he shall go no more out, and I will write upon him my new name;" and "to him that overcomes I will grant to sit with me on my throne, even as I also overcame and am seated with my Father on his throne" (Rev 2:7, 11, 17, 26-28; 3:5, 12, 21). Promises this rich and abundant should surely make us willing to endure any suffering for the sake of Christ, who will so gloriously reward us for all of it. Consider once more, Third, How the Scriptures abound with blessed examples of those who have suffered for Christ's sake. The Psalmist, speaking of the reproach and blasphemy he had suffered from his enemies, says, "All this has come upon us, yet we have not forgotten you, nor have we dealt falsely with your covenant" (Ps 44:17-18); and again, "The proud have held me in great contempt, yet I have not turned from your law. Many are my persecutors and my enemies, yet I do not turn from your testimonies. Princes have persecuted me without cause, but my heart stands in awe of your word" (Ps 119:51, 157, 161). The prophet Jeremiah spoke boldly for God even when threatened with death for doing so (Jer 26:11, 15). Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego refused to bow down and worship the golden image the king of Babylon had erected, even knowing they would be thrown into the fiery furnace (Dan 3). And Daniel himself continued faithfully praying to his God, even expecting to be thrown into the den of lions as a result (Dan 6). But time would fail me to recount the stories of apostles, prophets, martyrs, saints, and Christ himself, all of whom remained faithful through praise and slander alike, through suffering and trial, counting their lives as nothing so long as they could be faithful to the end. "Therefore, since we are surrounded by so great a cloud of witnesses, let us lay aside every weight and the sin that so easily entangles us, and let us run with endurance the race set before us, looking to Jesus, the founder and perfecter of our faith, who for the joy set before him endured the cross, despising its shame, and is now seated at the right hand of the throne of God" (Heb 12:1-2). "Fear none of the things you are about to suffer. Be faithful unto death, and I will give you the crown of life."
CHAPTER 13
LECTURE 13. LOVE BEARS, BELIEVES, HOPES, AND ENDURES ALL THINGS
"Charity . . . believeth all things, hopeth all things." (1 Cor 13:7)
These words are commonly understood to mean that charity inclines us to believe the best and hope the best about our neighbors in every situation. But I don't think that's what the apostle is saying here. His point, rather, is that charity is a grace that nurtures and strengthens the exercise of all other graces, particularly faith and hope. By mentioning the graces of believing and hoping, the apostle shows how charity actively promotes their exercise. My reasons for reading the text this way are as follows:
First, the apostle had just finished describing how charity leads us to think the best of our neighbors, saying that it "thinketh no evil" (1 Cor 13:5). There's no good reason to think he would simply repeat that same idea here in different words.
Second, it seems clear that the apostle had already finished his discussion of charity's fruits toward our neighbors when he summed them all up by saying that it "rejoiceth not in iniquity, but rejoiceth in the truth" (1 Cor 13:6), meaning that charity works against all evil behavior and promotes all good behavior. Given that, we should expect this next verse to introduce a different kind of fruit altogether, specifically charity's power to strengthen the graces of faith and hope, which are among the most essential graces of the gospel.
Third, we find that the apostle mentions the three graces of faith, hope, and charity together more than once in this chapter. It's reasonable to assume that each time he does so, he means the same three graces. In the final verse of the chapter, these three are mentioned and compared side by side; and there, by "faith" and "hope," the apostle clearly does not mean thinking well of our neighbors or expecting the best from them. He means those great gospel graces whose primary and immediate object is God and Christ. So when, earlier in the chapter, he mentions the same three graces as he does in that final verse, why would we not conclude that he means the same three things in both places? After all, it is the same chapter, the same discourse, and the same unfolding argument. Fourth, this reading fits the overall aim of the apostle throughout the chapter, which is to show how charity relates to the other graces, and particularly to faith and hope. That is what he is driving at in everything he says. When he reaches his conclusion in the final verse and declares that, of faith, hope, and charity, the greatest is the last, he seems to be circling back to what he said in the text itself: that charity "believeth all things, and hopeth all things." His point is that charity is greater than the other two because it has the most powerful influence in producing them, and it is the grace by which faith and hope are nourished and sustained in the soul.
For these reasons, the doctrine I draw from this text is as follows: THAT THE GRACES OF CHRISTIANITY ARE ALL CONNECTED TOGETHER, AND MUTUALLY DEPENDENT ON EACH OTHER.
That is, they are all linked together, united one to another and within one another, like the links of a chain; each one hangs on the next, from one end of the chain to the other, so that if a single link breaks, everything falls to the ground and the whole becomes useless. In unfolding this idea, I will, first, briefly explain how the graces of Christianity are all connected, and then offer some reasons why this is so. And I will begin by: I. Briefly explaining the manner in which the graces of Christianity are connected. This can be shown in three ways.
1. All the graces of Christianity always go together. They go together in such a way that where one is present, all are present, and where one is missing, all are missing. Where there is faith, there is also love, hope, and humility. Where there is love, there is trust. Where there is holy trust in God, there is love for God. And where there is genuine hope, there is also a holy fear of God: "The Lord taketh pleasure in them that fear him, in those that hope in his mercy" (Ps 147:11). Where there is love for God, there is also a gracious love for others, and where there is a Christian love for others, there is love for God. This is why the apostle John can, in one breath, point to love for fellow believers as evidence of love for God, saying, "If a man say, I love God, and hateth his brother, he is a liar" (1 John 4:20), and then turn around and point to love for God as evidence of love for fellow believers, saying, "By this we know that we love the children of God, when we love God and keep his commandments" (1 John 5:2).
2. The graces of Christianity depend on one another. They are not merely connected in the sense that they always appear together; they are mutually dependent, so that none can truly exist without the others. To deny one is, in effect, to deny another, and ultimately to deny all of them, just as denying a cause is to deny its effect, or denying an effect is to deny its cause. Faith promotes love, and love is the most vital ingredient in a living faith. Love depends on faith, because a being cannot be truly loved, especially loved above all others, unless that being is first recognized as real. And love, in turn, deepens and strengthens faith, because we are far more inclined to believe, trust, and rely on those we love than on those we don't. Faith also gives birth to hope, because faith sees and trusts in God's ability to give blessings and in His faithfulness to His promises, that He will do what He has said. All genuine hope rests on faith, and hope in turn draws out fresh acts of faith. Love also tends toward hope, because the spirit of love is the spirit of a child, and the more a person feels that childlike spirit toward God, the more natural it becomes to look to God and go to Him as a Father. This childlike spirit drives out the spirit of bondage and fear, and gives the Spirit of adoption, which is the spirit of confidence and hope: "Ye have not received the spirit of bondage again to fear; but ye have received the Spirit of adoption, whereby we cry, Abba, Father" (Rom 8:15). And John adds, "There is no fear in love, but perfect love casteth out fear" (1 John 4:18). Equally, a true and genuine hope powerfully promotes love. When a believer has the clearest sense of hope in God's favor and in the eternal blessings that flow from it, that hope draws out the exercise of love, and often does exactly that, as Paul writes: "Tribulation worketh patience; and patience, experience; and experience, hope; and hope maketh not ashamed: because the love of God is shed abroad in our hearts" (Rom 5:3-5).
Faith also promotes humility, because the more completely a person depends on God's sufficiency, the lower his sense of his own will become. And humility, in turn, promotes faith, because the more clearly a person recognizes his own insufficiency, the more his heart will be drawn to trust in God alone and to rest entirely on Christ. Love promotes humility as well, because the more the heart is captivated by God's beauty, the more it will recoil from itself, ashamed of its own ugliness and corruption. And humility promotes love, because the more deeply a person feels his own unworthiness, the more he will marvel at God's goodness toward him, and the more his heart will be drawn out in love toward God for His glorious grace. Love also leads to repentance, because the person who truly repents of sin does so precisely because that sin was committed against someone he loves. And repentance leads to humility, because no one can be genuinely sorry for sin, and honestly self-condemned because of it, without being humbled in heart over it. In the same way, repentance, faith, and love all tend toward thankfulness. The person who trusts Christ by faith for salvation will be grateful to Him for that salvation. The person who loves God will be inclined to acknowledge His kindness with a thankful heart. And the person who repents of his sins will be moved to thank God wholeheartedly for the grace that is sufficient to deliver him from both their guilt and their power. A genuine love for God naturally tends toward love for the people who bear His image, and a spirit of love and peace toward others nurtures a spirit of love toward God, just as love for a portrait nurtures love for the person it depicts. One could go on to show how all the graces depend on one another by tracing many other connections. Humility strengthens every other grace, and every other grace strengthens humility. Faith promotes every other grace, and every other grace in turn sustains and deepens faith. The same holds true for every grace the gospel produces.
3. The different graces of Christianity are, in some respects, implied one in another. They are not only mutually connected and dependent, each one strengthening the others, but in certain respects each grace carries the others within its very nature. For several of them, this is especially true: one grace is essential to another, belonging to its core definition. Humility, for instance, is implied in the nature of genuine faith to such a degree that it forms part of faith's essence. True faith must be humble faith; true trust must be humble trust. In the same way, humility belongs to the nature and essence of many other genuine graces. Christian love must be humble love; submission must be humble submission; repentance must be humble repentance; thankfulness must be humble thankfulness; and reverence must be humble reverence.
Love is therefore implied in genuine faith. It is an ingredient in faith, belonging to its very essence, and functioning as its animating principle, its active and operative nature. Just as the soul is what makes a human being active and alive, love is what makes faith active and alive; for the apostle Paul tells us that "faith worketh by love" (Gal 5:6), and the apostle James tells us that faith without its working nature is dead, just as the body is dead without the spirit (Jas 2:26). By the same token, love implies faith, because it is essential to genuine Christian love that it be a believing love. In this way, saving repentance and faith are bound up in each other. They are both one and the same conversion of the soul from sin to God through Christ. When the soul turns from sin to God through Christ, that turning is called repentance insofar as it concerns what is being left behind, namely sin; and it is called faith insofar as it concerns the destination toward which the soul turns and the mediation by which it arrives there. But it is the same movement of the soul, just as when a person flees from darkness into the light, it is a single act and a single motion, even if it can be described in different ways depending on whether you are looking at the darkness being fled or the light being entered: in the first case, we call it turning away; in the second, we call it receiving or embracing.
True thankfulness implies love, because genuine thankfulness is simply love toward God expressed in response to His goodness to us. A true, childlike fear of God also contains love within it, since childlike fear differs fundamentally from slavish fear, which contains no love at all. All three graces of love, humility, and repentance are bound up together in the gracious, childlike submission to God's will. In the same way, being free from worldly attachment and keeping one's mind fixed on heaven consists primarily in the three graces of faith, hope, and love. A Christian's love for other people is, in a sense, an indirect love for Christ; and the justice and truthfulness toward others that qualify as genuinely Christian virtues carry love within them as an essential component. Love and humility together form the substance of meekness toward others. And it is love for God, combined with faith and humility, that makes up Christian patience and contentment with our circumstances and with whatever God's providence brings our way. All of this shows that the graces of Christianity are linked together in a chain, each one connected to and dependent on the others. I turn now, as I proposed, to the second point.
II. To give some reasons why they are connected and dependent in this way.
1. They all come from the same source. All the graces of Christianity flow from the same Spirit, as the apostle says: "There are diversities of gifts, but the same Spirit; diversities of operations, but it is the same God which worketh all in all" (1 Cor 12:4, 6). Every Christian grace flows from the same Spirit of Christ, sent into the heart and dwelling there as a holy, powerful, and divine nature. The graces are therefore simply different expressions of that one divine nature at work within us, much as sunlight may be reflected in many different ways while remaining, at its source, the same light. Grace in the soul is the Holy Spirit acting within the soul, communicating His own holy nature to it. Think of water flowing from a single fountain: it is all one and the same substance, simply channeled through different streams. Those streams must share the same nature because they all come from the same source, and the differences among the graces, including the different names we give them, are largely a matter of the different objects they are directed toward and the different ways they are exercised, rather than any deep difference in their essential nature.
2. They are all produced in the same work of the Spirit, namely, conversion. There is not one conversion that produces faith, another that produces love for God, another for humility, another for repentance, and yet another for love toward others. All of these are produced by one and the same work of the Spirit, as the result of one and the same transformation of the heart. This confirms that all the graces are united and bound together, since they are all contained within that single new nature given to us in regeneration. The parallel with physical birth is instructive: in the generation of the body, all the faculties are given at once. The senses of sight, hearing, touch, taste, and smell, along with the capacities for movement, breathing, and everything else, are all given at the same time. They are all one human nature and one human life, even though that life expresses itself in many different modes and forms.
3. They all share the same root and foundation, namely, the knowledge of God's excellence. The same perception of God's greatness gives rise to faith, love, repentance, and every other grace. A single glimpse of that excellence is enough to produce all of them, because it reveals the ground and reason for every holy disposition and every holy response toward God. Those who truly know God's nature will love Him, trust Him, and have a spirit of submission, service, and obedience toward Him. "They that know thy name will put their trust in thee" (Ps 9:10). "Whosoever sinneth hath not seen him, neither known him" (1 John 3:6). "Every one that loveth is born of God, and knoweth God" (1 John 4:7).
4. They all have the same rule, namely, the law of God. This is another reason they must be linked together. Since all the graces are oriented toward the same rule, they all tend to uphold the whole of that rule and to bring the heart and life into conformity with it. Whoever has a genuine regard for one of God's commands will have a genuine regard for all of them, because they are all established by the same authority and are together an expression of God's single holy nature. "Whosoever shall keep the whole law, and yet offend in one point, he is guilty of all; for he that said, Do not commit adultery, said also, Do not kill. Now if thou commit no adultery, yet if thou kill, thou art become a transgressor of the law" (Jas 2:10-11).
5. All the Christian graces share the same end, namely, God. He is their end because they all tend toward Him. Just as they all rise from the same source, stand on the same foundation, grow from the same root, and are governed by the same rule (the law of God), they are all directed toward the same end: God, His glory, and our happiness in Him. This shows that they must be closely related and deeply interconnected. And one more point follows naturally from this: 6. All the Christian graces are equally connected to one and the same grace, namely, charity, or divine love, as the sum of them all. As we have already seen, charity, or love, is the sum of all true Christian graces, however many names we give them. And however different their expressions or the ways they show themselves, a careful examination reveals that they all resolve into one thing. Love, or charity, is the fulfillment of all of them; they are simply variations, different branches, different relationships, and different modes of expression of the same underlying reality. One grace effectively contains all the others, just as a single principle of life encompasses all its expressions. It is no wonder, then, that these graces always appear together and that each one depends on and implies all the rest.
In applying this subject, 1. It may help us understand in what sense old things are said to pass away, and all things become new, in conversion. This is precisely what the apostle teaches. "If any man be in Christ, he is a new creature: old things are passed away; behold, all things are become new" (2 Cor 5:17). The doctrine of our text, along with everything we have examined under it, helps clarify how this works. We learn that all the graces of Christianity are imparted at once in conversion, because they are all bound together: when one is given, all are given, never just a single one in isolation. The moment a person is truly converted, he possesses not one or two but all holy principles and every gracious disposition. These may be feeble, like the faculties of a newborn child, but they are genuinely present, and they will gradually flow outward in every form of holy feeling and behavior toward both God and man. In every true convert there are as many graces as there were in Jesus Christ Himself, which is exactly what the evangelist John means when he writes, "The Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us (and we beheld his glory, the glory as of the only-begotten of the Father), full of grace and truth; and of his fulness have all we received, and grace for grace" (John 1:14, 16). This could not be otherwise, for all true converts are renewed in Christ's image, as the apostle declares: "And have put on the new man, which is renewed in knowledge, after the image of him that created him" (Col 3:10). No image or portrait is genuine if it is missing parts or features. A true likeness has something corresponding to every part of the original. The copy answers to the original throughout, in all its parts and features, even if some are faint and none is rendered perfectly, just as grace answers to grace. Grace in the soul is a reflection of Christ's glory, as 2 Cor 3:18 makes clear. It reflects His glory the way a mirror reflects a man's face, part corresponding to part.
Just as a newborn infant has all the parts of a complete human being, even though those parts are still undeveloped, so it is with the new birth. Nothing is missing; the infant has just as many limbs and organs as a fully grown adult. This is why what God produces in regeneration is called "the new man," not merely new eyes, new ears, or new hands, but a whole new person, possessing every human faculty. In the same way, all the graces of the Christian life are new. Every one of them belongs to the person after conversion, and none of them belonged to that person before. Because something like a new man, complete with all these qualities, is born in conversion, Christians are said to be sanctified wholly, in soul, body, and spirit (1 Thess 5:23). Old things pass away, and everything becomes new, because as the new man is put on, the old man is put off, and the person becomes, in a real sense, entirely new.
When all these graces are alive in the new person, it follows that all corruptions are put to death, because every corruption has a corresponding grace that opposes it, and when that grace is given, it mortifies the corruption it stands against. Faith works against unbelief; love works against enmity; humility works against pride; meekness works against the desire for revenge; thankfulness works against an ungrateful spirit; and so on. As each grace takes its place in the heart, the opposing corruption gives way, just as darkness vanishes from a room the moment a light is brought in. This is how old things pass away. All old things pass away to some degree, though none pass away completely in this life, and so all things become new, though also imperfectly. This shows that conversion, whenever and wherever it occurs, is a profound work and a profound change. Grace may still be far from perfect, yet the person who once had no corruption put to death and now has all of them checked, who once had not a single grace and now has every grace, has clearly undergone a tremendous transformation. Such a person can rightly be called a new creature, or, as the original language puts it, a new creation in Christ Jesus.
2. From this same principle, those who hope they have grace in their hearts can test one grace by examining another, since all the graces grow together. If someone believes they have faith and therefore believes they have come to Christ, they should ask whether that faith was accompanied by repentance; whether they came to Christ with a broken heart, genuinely aware of their own unworthiness and corruption through sin; or whether they came instead in a presumptuous, self-righteous spirit, drawing confidence from their own supposed goodness. They should test their faith by asking whether it was accompanied by humility; whether they trusted in Christ in a lowly, humble manner, genuinely delighting to set aside their own claims and give all the glory of their salvation to Him. In the same way, they should test their faith by their love; and if their faith carries only light but no warmth, it does not carry the true light. Nor is it genuine faith if it does not express itself through love.
In the same way, people should examine their love by their faith. If they seem to have an affectionate love toward God and Christ, they should ask whether that love is accompanied by a real, deep conviction of the reality of Christ, of the truth of the gospel that reveals Him, and of the settled certainty that He is the Son of God: the only, glorious, and all-sufficient Savior. Here lies one of the great differences between false affections and true ones. False affections are not accompanied by this kind of conviction; they do not come with any genuine perception of the truth and reality of divine things. For that reason, such affections are very little to be trusted. They are much like the feelings we might have toward a character we are reading about in a novel, someone we know all along to be entirely fictional. Affections that are not rooted in conviction will never carry people very far in their duties, nor will they move people to any significant degree, whether in action or in suffering.
People should also examine what appears to be the grace of hope within themselves. They should ask whether their hope is accompanied by faith, whether it grows out of faith in Jesus Christ, and whether it rests on trust in His worthiness alone. Is their hope built on that rock, or is it actually grounded in a high opinion of something they consider good in themselves? They should examine how their hope works in practice, what influence it has on their lives, and whether it is accompanied by humility. A true hope leads its possessor to recognize his own unworthiness, and in light of his sins, to reflect on himself with shame and a broken heart. It lies in the dust before God, and the comfort it produces is a lowly, humble joy and peace. A false hope, by contrast, tends to fill its possessor with an inflated sense of himself, his spiritual experiences, and his own achievements. We should also ask whether our hope is accompanied by a spirit of obedience, self-denial, and freedom from attachment to the world. A true hope comes with these other graces, bound up with it and dependent on it, while a false hope stands without them. It does not draw the heart toward obedience; it flatters and hardens the heart in disobedience. It does not put sinful appetites to death or loosen the world's grip on us. Instead, it indulges sinful desires and passions, embraces them, and leaves people perfectly comfortable while living in them.
People should also examine their detachment from the world by asking whether it is accompanied by a genuine love that draws their hearts away from worldly things toward those spiritual and heavenly realities that true divine love carries the soul toward, more powerfully than any earthly attraction. They should not simply ask whether they have something that looks like real love; they should hear Christ putting to them the same question He put to Peter: "Simon, son of Jonas, do you love me more than these?" This is precisely where genuine detachment from the world differs from a counterfeit version. False detachment does not arise from love for God and heavenly things. It comes instead from fear, a troubled conscience, or perhaps some external hardship that forces a person's attention away from the world for a time, toward something they feel compelled to acknowledge is better, even though it holds no real sweetness for them. Such people are not drawn away from the world so much as driven, beaten, or torn from it, and their hearts would cling to it just as tightly as ever if only they could enjoy it without those terrors and afflictions. Those who have a genuine detachment from the world, on the other hand, are not bound to worldly things even when those things appear at their most appealing, because their hearts have been drawn away by love for something far greater. They are so captivated by God and by spiritual realities that their affections simply cannot take hold of the things of the world.
In the same way, people should test their love for God by examining their love for God's people, and test their love for fellow Christians by examining their love for God. False grace is like a flawed or misshapen portrait in which some essential feature is missing. There may be, for instance, an apparent warmth toward God while genuine Christian compassion toward other people is entirely absent. Or if someone seems kind, just, generous, and good-hearted toward others, there may be a corresponding failure in their relationship with God. This is precisely why God complained of Ephraim that "he is a cake not turned" (Hos 7:8), meaning that his goodness was lopsided and inconsistent: good in one area and deficient in another, like a cake left unturned on the griddle, burnt on one side and raw on the other, and useless either way. We should take great care to avoid such a character, and instead strive to let each grace we possess confirm the genuineness of all our other graces, so that we may be well-proportioned Christians, growing in the unity of the faith and in the knowledge of the Son of God, toward full maturity, toward the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ.
CHAPTER 14
LECTURE 14. TRUE GRACE CANNOT BE OVERTHROWN BY OPPOSITION
"Charity . . . endureth all things." (1 Cor 13:7)
In these words, and in the earlier statements that "charity suffereth long" and that it "beareth all things," the apostle is generally understood to be making essentially the same point three times over, as though all three expressions were synonymous and simply restated the same idea in different words.
But this idea almost certainly stems from a misunderstanding of what the author meant. If we look carefully at these various expressions and the way they are used, we find that each one points to a distinct fruit of charity. Two of them have already been examined: that "charity suffereth long" and that it "beareth all things." The first was shown to refer to bearing injuries received from other people, and the second to the spirit that moves us to endure whatever suffering we may be called to face for Christ's sake, rather than abandon Him or our duty. The expression we are now considering, that charity "endureth all things," means something different from either of those. It describes the lasting and enduring nature of charity itself, the principle of true grace in the soul, and declares that it will not fail. It will continue and hold firm regardless of whatever opposition it encounters or whatever forces are brought against it. The two phrases "beareth all things" and "endureth all things," as they appear in our English translation and as they are commonly understood, do carry much the same meaning. But the original expression, translated literally, would read "charity remains under all things," meaning that it still stands, still holds constant and persevering, beneath every form of opposition that may come against it. Whatever assaults are launched against it, charity does not collapse or give way. It holds its ground, presses forward, and sustains itself with constancy, perseverance, and patience through everything.
According to the explanation already given of the four expressions in this verse, "beareth," "believeth," "hopeth," and "endureth all things," the apostle's meaning comes through clearly, naturally, and in full agreement with the surrounding context. He is working to demonstrate the universal benefit of charity, or the spirit of Christian love. To show how it represents the sum of all good within the human heart, he first shows how it shapes all good behavior toward others, summing up that point by saying that charity "rejoiceth not in iniquity, but rejoiceth in the truth." He then goes further, declaring that charity not only inclines us toward doing and suffering in the cause of Christ, but that it carries within itself a spirit of endurance, so that it "beareth all things." It does this by nurturing the two graces of faith and hope, which are most fully exercised precisely in times of suffering for Christ's sake. Such sufferings are the proving ground of our faith, and what sustains the Christian through them is the hope of a far greater and eternal weight of glory awaiting the faithful in the end. Charity cultivates this faith and hope, and as the fruit of both, it endures all things, perseveres, holds firm, and cannot be conquered by any opposition brought against it. For faith overcomes the world, and hope in God enables the Christian to triumph always in Christ Jesus.
The doctrine I draw from this text, then, is this: THAT CHARITY, OR TRUE CHRISTIAN GRACE, CANNOT BE OVERTHROWN BY ANYTHING THAT OPPOSES IT.
In addressing this doctrine, I want to do three things: first, acknowledge the reality that many forces actively oppose the grace at work in a Christian's heart; second, affirm the great truth that this grace cannot be destroyed; and third, explain why it cannot be shaken, but holds firm against every assault.
I. There are many things that powerfully oppose the grace within the Christian's heart. This holy principle has countless enemies watching and warring against it. The child of God is surrounded on every side. He is a pilgrim and a stranger passing through hostile territory, exposed to attack at any moment. Thousands of devils, cunning, intelligent, relentless, and mighty, are bitter enemies of the grace within the Christian's heart, and they do everything in their power to destroy it. The world, too, is an enemy of this grace, filled as it is with people and circumstances that resist it, along with every form of allurement and temptation designed to lure or drive us away from the path of faithfulness. But the Christian faces not only enemies from without; he carries multitudes of enemies within his own chest, from which he cannot escape. Evil thoughts and sinful impulses cling to him, and the corruptions that still hold their ground in his heart are grace's worst enemies, possessing the greatest advantage in their warfare against it. These enemies are not merely numerous; they are extraordinarily strong, fierce in their hostility, implacable, uncompromising, and deadly, seeking nothing less than the complete ruin and overthrow of grace. They are tireless in their opposition, which is why the Christian, for as long as he remains in this world, is described as living in a state of warfare. His calling is that of a soldier, and he is frequently spoken of as a soldier of the cross, one whose great duty is to fight courageously the good fight of faith.
Many are the powerful and violent assaults that the enemies of grace launch against it. They are not only constantly besieging it, but often they storm it like a city they intend to take by force. They are always lurking, always watching for any opening, and sometimes they rise up in terrible fury and press their attack with relentless urgency. Sometimes one enemy strikes, sometimes another, and sometimes all of them together, moving as one, battering grace from every side and rushing in like a flood, ready to overwhelm it and swallow it whole. Sometimes grace, caught in the most violent opposition its enemies can muster, fighting against their combined cunning and strength, resembles a spark of fire surrounded by swelling waves and raging billows that look as though they will swallow it up and snuff it out in an instant. Or it is like a flake of snow falling into a burning volcano; or better still, like a precious gold jewel sitting in the heart of a fiery furnace, where the raging heat is enough to consume anything except pure gold, which by its very nature cannot be destroyed by fire.
It is with grace in the heart of a Christian much as it is with the church of God in the world. It is God's outpost, and it is small, and countless enemies press hard against it. The powers of earth and hell are marshaled to destroy it if they can, and they often rise with such violence and such overwhelming force that, judging only by appearances, one would expect it to be overrun and annihilated at any moment. Consider the children of Israel in Egypt, against whom Pharaoh and the Egyptians combined all their cunning and power in a determined effort to wipe them out as a people. Consider David in the wilderness, hunted like a partridge on the mountains, driven from one desert or cave to another by those who sought his life, and more than once chased into a foreign land. Consider the Christian church under the pagan and antichristian persecutions, when the whole world, as it were, united its strength and ingenuity to erase it from the earth, destroying thousands and millions with savage cruelty through the bloodiest persecutions imaginable, without regard for sex or age. But, II. All the opposition that is or can be made against true grace in the heart cannot overthrow it. The enemies of grace may, in many respects, gain significant advantages against it. They may oppress it severely and reduce it to such straits that it appears to stand at the very edge of total ruin. And yet it will live. The destruction that seemed imminent will be turned aside. Though the roaring lion sometimes advances with open mouth and no refuge appears to be at hand, the lamb will still escape and reach safety. Even if grace finds itself in the very paw of the lion or the bear, it will be rescued rather than devoured. And even if it seems to have been swallowed whole, as Jonah was by the whale, it will be brought up again and live. In this respect, grace in the heart is like the ark on the waters: however terrible the storm, however vast the flood that swallows everything else, it will not swallow that. However high the waters rise, the ark will be kept above them, and though the mighty waves may crest above the peaks of the highest mountains, they cannot rise above this ark; it will float on in safety. Or consider grace as it was with the ship in which Christ was sailing when a great storm arose and the waves ran so high that the vessel seemed about to go under at any moment. It did not sink, though the water was breaking over it, because Christ was in it.
Grace in the heart is like the children of Israel in Egypt, at the Red Sea, and in the wilderness. No matter how fiercely Pharaoh tried to destroy them, they continued to grow and thrive. When he finally pursued them with his entire army, chariots and cavalry included, and they found themselves trapped against the Red Sea with no apparent way out, standing on what seemed like the very edge of destruction, they still escaped. They were not handed over as prey to their enemies. They were preserved even as they passed through the sea itself: the waters parted before them, and once they had crossed safely, the waters rolled back and swallowed their pursuers whole. They were then sustained for years in a barren wilderness full of pits, drought, and venomous serpents. Just as the gates of hell can never prevail against the church of Christ, so too they can never prevail against the grace that lives in the heart of a Christian. The seed remains, and no one can uproot it. The fire stays alive even in the midst of rushing floodwaters, and though it often burns low, looking as though it is nearly spent with no visible flame and only a thin thread of smoke rising, that smoldering wick will not be snuffed out.
Grace will not only survive, but will ultimately triumph. It may endure long seasons of fierce conflict, suffering setbacks and being pressed down again and again, yet it will live. And not merely live: it will prosper, prevail, and triumph in the end, with every enemy brought low beneath its feet. Consider David in the wilderness. For a long time he lived in desperate, hunted circumstances, pursued by powerful enemies, repeatedly brought to the very edge of destruction, where a single step seemed to separate him from death. Yet through all of it he was preserved, and at last he was raised to the throne of Israel, wearing the royal crown in prosperity and glory. Grace works the same way. It cannot be overthrown. Every depression it suffers only prepares the ground for its eventual exaltation. Where grace truly exists in the heart, no enemy can destroy it and no opposition can crush it. It endures everything, weathers every shock, and stands firm against every adversary. Two reasons explain why this is so.
1. True grace has far more in its nature that drives it toward perseverance than false grace ever does. False grace is a superficial thing, consisting in outward appearances or shallow emotions, never touching the nature beneath. True grace, by contrast, reaches all the way to the bottom of the heart. It consists in a new nature, and that is precisely why it lasts. Where there is nothing but counterfeit grace, sin remains unmortified. Whatever wounds appear to be inflicted on it are only surface wounds that never reach its life or weaken its hold. Sin is left in full strength in the soul, so it's no surprise that it eventually prevails and sweeps everything before it. True grace, however, genuinely mortifies sin in the heart. It strikes at sin's vitals and delivers a wound that is mortal, driving the blow to the very core. From the moment grace first enters the soul, it begins a conflict with sin that never ceases, which is why it holds its ground and finally prevails over its enemy. Counterfeit grace never dislodges sin from its ruling position in the soul and never breaks its reigning power there, so it's no wonder that counterfeit grace cannot sustain itself. True grace, by its very nature, is incompatible with sin's dominion. As it enters the heart, it drives sin from the throne and takes that throne for itself, which is precisely why it is far more likely to hold that seat and, in the end, to prevail over sin entirely.
Counterfeit grace, though it may stir the emotions, is not grounded in any genuine conviction of the soul. True grace, by contrast, begins with real and thorough conviction, and because it rests on that foundation, it has a far greater tendency toward perseverance. Counterfeit grace is not diligent in prayer, but true grace is prayerful, and through prayer it lays hold of divine strength to sustain it, eventually becoming divine in character itself, so that the very life of God is, as it were, imparted to it. Counterfeit grace is indifferent about whether it perseveres to the end, but true grace naturally produces earnest desires for perseverance and leads to deep longings for it. It also makes people aware of the dangers surrounding them, and tends to stir them toward watchfulness, care, and diligence in persevering, as well as toward looking to God for help and trusting Him to preserve them from the many enemies that stand against it. And 2. God will uphold true grace, once He has planted it in the heart, against all opposition. He will never allow it to be destroyed by whatever force may be brought against it. Though true grace has far more within it that tends toward perseverance than counterfeit grace does, nothing in the nature of grace itself, considered apart from God's purpose to sustain it, would be sufficient to guarantee its continuation or to keep it from final defeat. We are kept from falling not by the inherent power of grace itself, but, as the apostle Peter tells us, "by the power of God through faith" (1 Pet 1:5). The principle of holiness in the hearts of our first parents, where it had no corruption to contend with, was still overthrown; and we should expect far more readily that the seed of grace in the hearts of fallen people, surrounded by so much corruption and exposed to such active and relentless opposition, would likewise be overthrown, were it not for God's sustaining hand. He has undertaken to defend that grace from all its enemies and to bring it to final victory, and therefore it will never be destroyed. Here I will briefly show how it is evident that God will uphold true grace and not allow it to be overthrown, and then offer some reasons why He will not allow it.
First, let me show how it is clear that God will uphold true grace in the heart. In a word, the evidence comes from His promise. God has explicitly and repeatedly promised that true grace will never be destroyed. This is promised in the declaration about the righteous man: "though he fall, he shall not be utterly cast down; for the Lord upholdeth him with his hand" (Ps 37:24). It is promised again in the words, "I will make an everlasting covenant with them, that I will not turn away from them to do them good; but I will put my fear in their hearts, that they shall not depart from me" (Jer 32:40). And again in Christ's own words, that "it is not the will of your Father which is in heaven, that one of these little ones should perish" (Matt 18:14). In keeping with these declarations, Christ promised that grace would be in the soul "as a well of water, springing up into everlasting life" (John 4:14). He also said, "This is the Father's will which hath sent me, that of all which he hath given me I should lose nothing, but should raise it up again at the last day" (John 6:39). Elsewhere we are told that Christ's sheep "shall never perish, neither shall any man pluck them out of his hand" (John 10:27); that those God "did foreknow, them he also called; and whom he called, them he also justified; and whom he justified, them he also glorified;" and that nothing "shall separate" Christians "from the love of Christ" (Rom 8:29-30, 35). We are told further that "he which hath begun a good work" in us "will perform it until the day of Jesus Christ" (Phil 1:6); that Christ "shall confirm" his people "unto the end, that they may be blameless in the day of our Lord Jesus Christ" (1 Cor 1:8); and that "he is able to keep them from falling, and to present them faultless before the presence of his glory with exceeding joy" (Jude 24). Many other similar promises could be cited, all of them declaring that God will sustain grace in every heart where He has once planted it, and that He will keep to the end all who place their trust in Him.
Second, let me briefly outline some reasons why God will uphold the principle of grace and keep it from being destroyed. To begin with, if the redemption Christ provided did not secure our perseverance through every form of opposition, it would not be a complete redemption. Christ died to redeem us from the evil we were subject to under the law and to bring us to glory. But if He brought us no further than the state we were in at first, leaving us just as liable to fall as before, then His entire work of redemption could be rendered void and come to nothing. Before the fall, man was left to the freedom of his own will, and he fell from his steadfastness, losing his grace at a time when he was comparatively strong and not yet exposed to the enemies that now surround him. What hope could fallen man have in his present condition, with such imperfect grace and surrounded by powerful enemies on every side, if his perseverance depended on himself alone? He would utterly fall and perish, and a redemption that failed to secure him against that outcome would be a deeply inadequate redemption.
In the second place, the covenant of grace was introduced to supply what was missing in the first covenant, and a sure foundation for perseverance was the main thing it lacked. The first covenant had no defect on God's part; in that respect it was perfectly holy, just, wise, and complete. But experience proved that on our part it fell short, and something more was needed to make it effective for our salvation. What was needed was a secure basis for our perseverance. Under the first covenant, the only ground we had was the freedom of our own will, and that proved to be unreliable. So God made another covenant. Because the first was liable to fail, a more enduring one was established in its place, one that could not fail, and which is therefore called "an everlasting covenant." The things that could be shaken are removed, to make way for those that cannot be shaken. The first covenant had a head and guarantor who was capable of failing, namely the father of our race. Therefore God has provided, as the head and guarantor of the new covenant, one who cannot fail: Christ Himself, with whom, as the head and representative of all His people, the new covenant is made, ordered in all things and sure.
In the third place, it is not fitting that in a covenant of mercy and saving grace, the reward of life should be suspended on human perseverance, as though it depended on the strength and steadfastness of a person's own will. It is a covenant of works, not a covenant of grace, that ties eternal life to what a person can produce through their own strength to keep from falling. If everything flows from free and sovereign grace, then free grace has taken the matter fully in hand, to complete and finish it, rather than leaving it to people themselves and the power of their own wills, as it was under the first covenant. Since divine grace has begun the work, it will finish it, and therefore we will be kept to the end.
In the fourth place, our second surety has already persevered and accomplished what our first surety failed to do, and therefore we will surely persevere as well. Adam, our first surety, did not persevere, and so all fell with him. Had he persevered, all would have stood with him and never fallen. But our second surety has already persevered, and therefore all who have him as their surety will persevere with him. When Adam fell, he was condemned, and all his posterity was condemned and fell with him. Had he stood firm, he would have been justified, partaken of the tree of life, and been confirmed in a state of life, and all his posterity would have been confirmed along with him. By the same logic, now that Christ, the second Adam, has stood firm and persevered, has been justified and confirmed in life, all who are in Christ and represented by Him are likewise accepted, justified, and confirmed in Him. The fact that He, as the covenant head of His people, has fulfilled the terms of that covenant makes it certain that they will persevere.
In the fifth place, the believer is already fully justified, and thus entitled, through the promise of mercy, to eternal life. Therefore, God will not allow him to fail and fall short of it. Justification is the actual acquittal of the sinner: a complete release from guilt, freedom from condemnation, deliverance from hell, and full acceptance into a title to eternal life. All of this is plainly incompatible with the notion that deliverance from hell and the attainment of eternal life remain suspended on an uncertain perseverance.
In the sixth place, Scripture teaches us that the believer's grace and spiritual life are a participation in Christ's resurrection life, which is immortal and unfading. The apostle makes this plain when he writes, "You hath he quickened together with him," that is, with Christ (Col 2:13); and again, "But God, who is rich in mercy, for his great love wherewith he loved us, even when we were dead in sins, hath quickened us together with Christ; and hath raised us up together, and made us sit together in heavenly places in Christ Jesus" (Eph 2:4-6); and again, "I live; yet not I, but Christ liveth in me" (Gal 2:20). These passages show that the believer's spiritual life cannot fail, for Christ declares, "I am he that liveth, and was dead; and behold, I am alive for evermore" (Rev 1:18), and the apostle affirms, "Knowing that Christ, being raised from the dead, dieth no more; death hath no more dominion over him" (Rom 6:9). Our spiritual life is His life, just as truly as the life of a branch is the life of the tree, and therefore it cannot but endure.
In the seventh place, grace is what God has planted in the heart against fierce opposition, and He will therefore certainly sustain it there against every continued and combined effort to uproot it. The enemies of God and the soul exerted their full strength to prevent grace from ever taking root in the heart that now possesses it. Yet God displayed His all-conquering and glorious power by establishing it there in spite of them all. He will not, in the end, allow Himself to be overcome by their efforts to expel what His mighty power so triumphantly brought in. From all of this, it is clear that God will uphold the principle of grace in the Christian's heart so that it will never be overthrown or extinguished.
In applying this subject, 1. We may learn one reason why the devil so fiercely opposes the conversion of sinners. It is because once they are converted, they are converted forever, placed permanently beyond his reach, never to be overthrown or destroyed. Even if falling from grace were possible, the devil would still oppose our receiving it; but he opposes it all the more intensely now, knowing that once we possess grace, he can never dislodge it, and that we are, by that very possession, lost to him forever, beyond the reach of his destroying power. This helps explain the violent opposition that people experience when they are under conviction and seeking conversion, the relentless and overwhelming temptations the adversary hurls at them. He is always active, throwing himself furiously into the effort to destroy such people, piling obstacles in their path if he can, trying to hinder the saving work of the Holy Spirit and prevent their conversion. He labors with everything he has to extinguish conviction of sin, and if possible to lead those who feel it back into carelessness and habitual transgression. Sometimes he flatters; at other times he discourages. He works to tangle and confuse their minds, stirs up every corrupt impulse within them, plants blasphemous thoughts, and drives them toward bitterness against God. Through countless subtle temptations, he tries to convince them that seeking salvation is pointless. He tempts them through the doctrine of God's decrees, or through their own sense of weakness and helplessness, or by insisting that everything they do is sin, or by persuading them that their day of grace has already passed, or by terrifying them with the thought that they have committed the unpardonable sin. Or perhaps he tells them that their struggle is unnecessary and that there is plenty of time later; or, if he can manage it, he deceives them with false hope, flattering them into thinking they are safe while they remain outside of Christ. Through these and countless other strategies, Satan works to block the conversion of men and women, because he knows the truth of the doctrine we have been examining: that once grace is planted in the soul, he can never uproot it, and that the gates of hell cannot prevail against it.
2. We may also see from this subject that those whose apparent grace fails and collapses may conclude they never had any true grace at all. Grace that resembles the morning cloud and the early dew, which vanish without a trace, is not true grace. When people seem for a time to be awakened and alarmed, gaining some sense of their sinfulness and corruption, and then appear to be moved by God's mercy and to find comfort in Him, yet afterward, once the novelty has worn off, their impressions fade and disappear without producing any lasting change in heart or life, that is a clear sign they never possessed true grace. Nothing in such a case corresponds to the apostle's declaration that "if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation" (2 Cor 5:17). If a person, after an apparent conversion, turns away from God, Christ, and spiritual things, and the heart drifts back toward vanity and the world, and the known duties of religion are neglected, and the person returns to sinful patterns, gratifying selfish and sensual appetites and living a carnal, careless life, then everything that seemed promising about their conversion was an illusion. It is like the blossoms that appear on trees in spring or early summer, so many of which simply drop off and never produce fruit. The outcome proves that all these apparent signs of grace were only appearances, and that those who trusted in them were tragically deceived. Grace that does not hold out and persevere is not real grace.
3. This subject also provides rich grounds for joy and comfort to all who have solid evidence that they truly possess grace in their hearts. Those in this condition hold an priceless treasure, worth more than all the jewels, precious stones, crowns, and costly riches in the universe. And they may take great comfort in knowing they will never lose this treasure, that the One who gave it will keep it safe for them, and that having brought them into a state of profound blessing, He will sustain them in it. His mighty power, by which He is able to bring all things into submission, stands on their side and is pledged for their protection, so that none of their enemies will be able to destroy them. They may rejoice that they have a strong city, one to which God has appointed salvation as its walls and defenses. And whatever bitterness their enemies show toward them, however cunning and violent their attacks may be, they can still stand secure on the high rock where God has placed them, look their foes in the face without fear, and glory in the Most High as their sure refuge and defense. The everlasting arms are beneath them. The Lord, who rides across the heavens, is their help. He will bring all their enemies into submission under His feet, so that they may well rejoice in the Lord and take joy in the rock of their salvation.
4. Finally, this subject also provides powerful encouragement to believers as they carry on the warfare against the enemies of their souls. Nothing puts a soldier at a greater disadvantage than going into battle without any hope of winning, with the expectation of defeat already settled in his mind. Hope, in the one case, is half the victory; despair, in the other, all but guarantees defeat. Despair drains and weakens, while hope works alongside a soldier's strength and multiplies it. You who have solid evidence of grace in your hearts have, then, everything you could need to press forward with confidence. The Captain of your salvation will lead you to victory in the end. He who is able to sustain you has promised that you will overcome, and His promise will never fail. Resting on that promise, be faithful to your part, and before long the song of victory will be yours, and the crown of victory He will place, with His own hands, upon your head.
CHAPTER 15
LECTURE 15. THE HOLY SPIRIT WILL FOREVER BE GIVEN TO THE SAINTS IN THE GRACE OF DIVINE LOVE
"Charity never faileth: but whether there be prophecies, they shall fail; whether there be tongues, they shall cease; whether there be knowledge, it shall vanish away." (1 Cor 13:8)
Throughout the surrounding passage, the apostle's central aim is to demonstrate the superiority of charity over all the other graces of the Spirit. In this chapter, he establishes its excellence on three grounds: first, by showing that it is the most essential quality of all, and that every other gift amounts to nothing without it; second, by showing that all good dispositions and conduct flow from it; and third, by showing that it is the most enduring of all gifts, and will remain when the church of God has reached its most perfect state and the other gifts of the Spirit have passed away. Within the text itself, two things deserve our attention:
First, that one defining quality of charity, through which its excellence is displayed, is that it never ends: "Charity never faileth." This follows naturally from the closing words of the preceding verse, where the apostle declares that "charity endureth all things." There he affirms the durability of charity as it appears in its ability to withstand every form of opposition the world can throw against it. Now he goes further, declaring that charity not only endures to the end of time, but throughout eternity as well: "Charity never faileth." When every temporal thing has collapsed and disappeared, charity will still remain, and will remain forever. We may also observe in the text, Second, that in this respect charity is distinguished from all the other gifts of the Spirit, such as prophecy, the gift of tongues, and the gift of knowledge. "Whether there be prophecies, they shall fail; whether there be tongues, they shall cease; whether there be knowledge, it shall vanish away;" but "charity never faileth." The knowledge spoken of here is not spiritual and divine knowledge in general, because there will certainly be such knowledge in heaven, just as there is on earth, and in far greater measure than anything we experience now, as the apostle explicitly states in the verses that follow. The knowledge Christians have of God, of Christ, of spiritual realities, and indeed all their knowledge in the ordinary sense of that word, will not vanish away but will be gloriously expanded and perfected in heaven, which is a world of light no less than of love. Rather, the knowledge the apostle says will vanish away refers to a specific miraculous gift that existed in the church of God during that era. The apostle, as we have seen, is comparing charity with the miraculous gifts of the Spirit: those extraordinary endowments that were common in the early church, among them the gift of prophecy and the gift of tongues, meaning the ability to speak in languages that had never been learned. Both of these gifts are mentioned in the text, and the apostle says they will fail and cease. A third gift was the gift of knowledge, or the word of knowledge, as it is called in the eighth verse of the previous chapter, where it is described in a way that makes clear it was distinct both from the speculative knowledge gained through reason and study, and from the spiritual or divine knowledge that comes through the saving work of the Holy Spirit in the soul. It was a particular gift of the Spirit given to certain individuals, enabling them through direct inspiration to understand mysteries, including the mysterious prophecies and types found in Scripture, which the apostle refers to in the second verse of this chapter: "Though I have the gift of prophecy, and understand all mysteries, and all knowledge," and so on. It is this miraculous gift that the apostle says will vanish away, along with the other miraculous gifts he mentions, such as prophecy and the gift of tongues. All of these were extraordinary endowments granted for a season, for the purpose of introducing and establishing Christianity in the world, and once that purpose was accomplished, they were all to fail and cease. But charity was never to cease. In this way the apostle plainly teaches the doctrine of the text: THAT THE GREAT FRUIT OF THE SPIRIT THROUGH WHICH THE HOLY SPIRIT WILL BE COMMUNICATED TO THE CHURCH OF CHRIST, NOT MERELY FOR A SEASON BUT EVERLASTINGLY, IS CHARITY, OR DIVINE LOVE.
To better understand the meaning and truth of this doctrine, I want to address it through four propositions: first, the Spirit of Christ will be given everlastingly to His Church and people, to influence and dwell within them; second, there are other fruits of the Spirit besides divine love, through which the Spirit of God is communicated to His Church; third, these other fruits are only temporary, and either have already ceased or will cease at some point; fourth, charity, or divine love, is that great and inexhaustible fruit of the Spirit in which His everlasting influence and indwelling in the saints, and in His Church, will be made known.
1. The Spirit of Christ is given everlastingly to His Church and people, to influence and dwell in them. The Holy Spirit is the great purchase, the supreme gift Christ secured for His people. The sum and substance of all the good things promised for this life and the life to come, everything purchased on behalf of the Church, is the Holy Spirit. He is not only the great purchase but also the great promise, the central thing God and Christ pledged to the Church. As the apostle Peter declared on the day of Pentecost: "This Jesus, being by the right hand of God exalted, and having received of the Father the promise of the Holy Ghost, he hath shed forth this, which ye now see and hear" (Acts 2:32-33). This great purchase and promise of Christ is to be given to His Church forever. Christ has promised that His Church will endure, and He stated plainly that the gates of hell will not prevail against it. To ensure that the Church is preserved, He has given His Holy Spirit to every true member of it, and has promised that this Spirit will remain forever. His own words are these: "And I will pray the Father, and he shall give you another Comforter, that he may abide with you for ever; even the Spirit of truth; whom the world cannot receive, because it seeth him not, neither knoweth him: but ye know him; for he dwelleth with you, and shall be in you" (John 14:16-17).
Man, in his original state in Eden, possessed the Holy Spirit, but lost Him through disobedience. Yet a way has been provided for the Spirit to be restored, and now He is given a second time, never again to depart from the saints. The Spirit of God is given to His own people in such a way that He becomes truly theirs. He was, in fact, given to our first parents in their state of innocence and dwelt with them, but not in the same sense in which He is given to and dwells in those who believe in Christ. Adam and Eve had no firm right or secure claim to the Spirit, and He was not given to them finally and forever, as He is to believers in Christ. If He had been, they never would have lost Him. But the Spirit of Christ is not merely communicated to those who are converted; He is secured to them by a sure covenant, so that He becomes genuinely their own. Christ has become theirs, and therefore His fullness is theirs, and therefore His Spirit is theirs: their purchased, promised, and certain possession. But, II. There are other fruits of the Spirit besides the one that consists essentially in charity, or divine love, through which the Spirit of God is communicated to His church. For example, 1. The Spirit of God has been communicated to His church through extraordinary gifts, such as the gift of miracles, the gift of inspiration, and so on. The Spirit of God appears to have been communicated to the church through such gifts, formerly to the prophets under the Old Testament, and to the apostles, evangelists, and prophets, and to the majority of the early ministers of the gospel, and also to great numbers of ordinary Christians under the New Testament. They received gifts such as the gift of prophecy, the gift of tongues, the gift called the gift of knowledge, and others mentioned in the surrounding passage and in the preceding chapter. And beyond these, 2. There are the common and ordinary gifts of the Spirit of God. These, in every age, have been given in varying degrees to many unconverted people, in the form of ordinary conviction of sin, common illumination, and general religious feeling. Though these contain nothing of the nature of divine love or true saving grace, they are still fruits of the Spirit in the sense that they result from His influence on human hearts. As for faith and hope, if there is no divine love present alongside them, there can be no more of the Spirit of God in them than what is common to unregenerate people. The apostle makes this clear in this very chapter when he says, "Though I have all faith, so that I could remove mountains, and have not charity, I am nothing." All saving faith and hope have love woven into them as an essential ingredient; take that ingredient away, and what remains is a body without life. It is nothing saving, but at best only a common fruit of the Spirit. But, III. All these other fruits of the Spirit are temporary, and either have already ceased or will cease at some point. The miraculous gifts of prophecy, tongues, and the like are of only temporary use and cannot be carried into heaven. They were given as extraordinary means of grace that God was pleased, for a time, to grant to His church in the world. But when the saints who once enjoyed these gifts entered heaven, such means of grace ceased, because they were no longer needed. There is no occasion for any means of grace in heaven, whether ordinary (such as the regular, common means of God's house) or extraordinary (such as the gifts of tongues, knowledge, and prophecy). None of these means of grace need to continue in heaven, because there the entire purpose of all such means has already been fully achieved in the perfect sanctification and happiness of God's people. In Ephesians 4, the apostle speaks of the various means of grace and says they are given "for the perfecting of the saints, for the work of the ministry, for the edifying of the body of Christ; till we all come in the unity of the faith, and of the knowledge of the Son of God, unto a perfect man." But once that has come to pass, once the saints are perfected and have already reached the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ, there will be no further need for any of these means, whether ordinary or extraordinary. In this respect, it is much like the crops of a field, which require cultivation, rain, and sunshine until they are ripe and brought in, and then need them no more.
These miraculous gifts of the Spirit were temporary not only for the individuals who received them, but also for the church of God as a whole. They were never meant to continue throughout every age of the church's history. Rather, they were present from the beginning of the world until the canon of Scripture was complete, though even during that long period they came and went with considerable gaps. Before the sacred canon began (that is, before the book of Job and the five books of Moses were written), these gifts served a specific purpose: God's people received His word through direct, ongoing revelation given to prominent figures who functioned as spiritual fathers within the community of God. That revelation was then passed down to others through oral tradition. During this early period, it was entirely common for the Spirit of God to communicate through dreams and visions, as several passages in Job make clear. Extraordinary gifts of the Spirit existed even before the flood. God revealed Himself directly and miraculously to Adam and Eve, and then to Abel and to Enoch, who, we are told, had the gift of prophecy (Jude 14). Noah likewise received direct revelation and warned the ancient world on God's behalf; and Christ, speaking through Noah by His Spirit, "went and preached to the spirits now in prison, who were once disobedient, when God's patience waited in the days while the ark was being prepared" (1 Pet 3:19-20). Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob were all favored with direct revelation; Joseph received extraordinary gifts of the Spirit; and so did Job and his friends. After this period, the extraordinary gifts appear to have gone silent until the time of Moses, after which they continued through an unbroken succession of prophets, though again with occasional interruptions, all the way to Malachi. Following that, there was a long silence of several hundred years, until the dawn of the gospel age, when the Spirit began once more to move in extraordinary ways, as seen in Anna, Simeon, Zechariah, Elizabeth, Mary, Joseph, and John the Baptist.
These communications of the Spirit were given to prepare the way for the One who possesses the Spirit without measure: the great prophet of God, through whom the Spirit is given to all other prophets. During His earthly ministry, His disciples received a measure of the Spirit's miraculous gifts, enabling them to teach and perform miracles. But after the resurrection and ascension, the most full and remarkable outpouring of the Spirit in miraculous gifts that had ever occurred began on the day of Pentecost, after Christ had risen and ascended to heaven. As a result, these extraordinary gifts were not limited to a few exceptional individuals; they became common throughout the church and continued so for the entire lifetime of the apostles, until the death of the last of them, the apostle John, which occurred around a hundred years after the birth of Christ. That first century of the Christian era was, in every sense, the age of miracles. But shortly after that period, once the canon of Scripture was completed when John wrote the book of Revelation not long before his death, these miraculous gifts were no longer continued in the church. A complete, written revelation of the mind and will of God had now been established, in which God had fully recorded a permanent and all-sufficient rule for His church in every age. With the Jewish church and nation having been overthrown, and the Christian church and its final arrangement now firmly established, the miraculous gifts of the Spirit were no longer needed, and so they ceased. Though they had been present in the church for so many generations, God caused them to end because there was no further occasion for them. And so the words of the text were fulfilled: "Whether there be prophecies, they shall fail; whether there be tongues, they shall cease; whether there be knowledge, it shall vanish away" (1 Cor 13:8). There now appears to be a permanent end to all such fruits of the Spirit, and we have no reason to expect their return. As for those fruits of the Spirit that are common, such as conviction, illumination, and belief, which are shared by both the godly and the ungodly, these are given in every age of the church throughout the world. Yet even these will cease for each individual at death, and for the church considered as a whole, they will come to an end after the day of judgment. I turn, then, to demonstrate the fourth point I proposed:
4. Charity, or divine love, is that great fruit of the Spirit that never fails, and in which His continued and everlasting influence and indwelling in His church will be seen and made known. We have seen that the Spirit of Christ is given to the church of Christ forever, given so that He may dwell in His saints permanently, in influences that will never fail. Therefore, however many fruits of the Spirit may be temporary and reach a point where they end, there must be some way in which the Spirit's influence, and some fruit of that influence, is unfailing and eternal. Charity, or divine love, is that fruit, and it is in communicating, nourishing, and exercising this love that His unfailing and eternal influences are made visible. This is a fruit of the Spirit that never fails or ceases in the church of Christ, whether we consider it with respect to its individual members or regard it as a collective body.
1. We may consider the church of Christ with respect to its individual members. Here it becomes clear that charity, or Christian love, is an unfailing fruit of the Spirit. Every true member of Christ's invisible church possesses this fruit of the Spirit in the heart. Divine love is planted there, dwells there, and reigns there as an everlasting fruit of the Spirit, one that never fails. It never fails in this world, but persists through every trial and opposition, for the apostle tells us that nothing "shall be able to separate us from the love of God which is in Christ Jesus our Lord" (Rom 8:38-39). Nor does it cease when the saints come to die. When the apostles and others of their generation died and went to heaven, they left all their miraculous gifts behind with their bodies. But they did not leave behind the love that was in their hearts; they carried it with them to heaven, where it was gloriously perfected. Though when wicked men die, those who had received the common influences of the Spirit, their gifts will eternally cease, death never overthrows Christian love, that great fruit of the Spirit, in any who truly possess it. Those who have it may and will leave behind many other fruits of the Spirit they held in common with wicked men. And though they will leave behind all that was merely common in their faith and hope, all that did not belong to this divine and holy love, yet this love they will not leave behind. It will go with them into eternity, be perfected there, and live and reign with perfect and glorious dominion in their souls forever.
2. We may also consider the church of Christ collectively, as a body. Here again it becomes clear that charity, or Christian love, will never fail. Though other fruits of the Spirit fail within it, this one never will. In earlier times, when the miraculous gifts of the Spirit were interrupted in the church and seasons arose in which no prophet or inspired person appeared with such gifts, there was still never any total interruption of this excellent fruit and influence of the Spirit. Miraculous gifts were suspended through the long period stretching from Malachi to near the birth of Christ, yet throughout all that time, the Spirit's influence in sustaining divine love within the church was never withdrawn. Just as God always maintained a church of saints in the world from the first establishment of the church after the fall, so this influence and fruit of His Spirit never failed within it. And when, after the completion of the scriptural canon, the miraculous gifts of the Spirit finally appeared to have ceased in the church, the Spirit's influence in producing divine love in the hearts of His saints did not cease. It has been sustained through every age from that time to this, and so it will continue to the end of the world. At the end of the world, when the church of Christ is settled in its final, most complete, and eternal state, and all common gifts such as convictions and illuminations, along with all miraculous gifts, have come to an eternal end, divine love will not fail. It will be brought to its most glorious perfection in every individual member of the redeemed church above. Then, in every heart, the love that now seems like a mere spark will be kindled into a bright and glowing flame. Every redeemed soul will be, as it were, ablaze with divine and holy love, and will remain and grow in this glorious perfection and blessedness throughout all eternity.
I will offer just one reason why the doctrine presented here is true. The great reason why other fruits of the Spirit eventually fail while love endures is this: love is the ultimate purpose behind all the other fruits and gifts of the Spirit. The principle of divine love in the heart, its expression in daily conduct, and the happiness that flows from it, these are the ultimate goal toward which all the Spirit's other fruits point. Charity, or divine love, is the destination; all inspiration and miraculous gifts that have ever existed in the world are simply the road leading there. They were only means of grace, while charity or divine love is grace itself, and not merely that, but the very sum of all grace. Revelation and miracles were never given for any purpose other than to promote holiness and build up Christ's kingdom in human hearts. Christian love, however, is the sum of all holiness, and its growth is nothing less than the growth of Christ's kingdom in the soul. The extraordinary fruits of the Spirit were given to reveal and confirm the word and will of God, so that people, by believing, might be shaped by that will. They were valuable and good only insofar as they served that purpose. When that purpose was achieved, when the canon of Scripture, that great and powerful instrument of grace, was completed, and the ordinances of the New Testament were fully established, the extraordinary gifts ceased. They were no longer needed. Miraculous gifts, being a means to a further end, are only as good as their usefulness in reaching that end. But divine love is that end, and therefore it remains when the means to it are gone. The end is not merely a good thing; it is the highest kind of good in itself, and so it endures forever. The same logic applies to the common gifts of the Spirit given in every age, such as illumination, conviction, and the like. These gifts have no inherent goodness of their own. They are only as good as their tendency to promote the grace and holiness that find their root and their fullest expression in divine love. When that purpose is finally and completely fulfilled, these common gifts will come to a permanent end, while divine love, the goal toward which they all pointed, will remain for eternity.
1. That there seems to be no reason to think, as some have thought, that the extraordinary gifts of the Spirit will be restored to the church in the future glorious era of her latter-day prosperity and blessing. Many theologians have held the view that when the latter-day glory of the church, as described in Scripture, finally arrives, there will once again be prophets and people endowed with the gifts of tongues and miracle-working, just as in the apostolic age. Some people alive today appear to hold the same view.
But based on what the apostle says in the text and its surrounding context, Scripture gives us no real reason to expect anything of the sort. Yes, the Bible speaks of that coming era as more glorious than any before it, and as a time when the Spirit of God will be poured out in greater measure than ever. All of that may well be true, and yet no extraordinary gifts need be given to the church at all. When the Spirit of God is poured out for the purpose of producing and deepening divine love, He is poured out in a far more excellent way than when He manifests Himself through miraculous gifts. The apostle teaches this explicitly in the closing section of the preceding chapter, where, after listing many miraculous gifts, he urges Christians to desire the best of them, but then adds: "And yet I will show you a more excellent way" (1 Cor 12:31), by which he means seeking the Spirit's work of producing love in the heart. Surely, when Scripture describes the church's future glorious state as something supremely excellent, it gives us no grounds to conclude that the Spirit will be poured out then in any way other than the most excellent way. And without question, the most excellent way of the Spirit belongs to the most excellent state of the church.
The fact that the church's future state will be far more perfect than anything seen before actually argues against the return of miraculous gifts, not in favor of it. The apostle himself, in this passage and the verses surrounding it, speaks of these extraordinary gifts fading and disappearing precisely to make room for something better: a richer, more mature fruit of the Spirit. Read the text alongside the two verses that follow it, and the logic becomes clear. The reason prophecy and tongues fail while love remains is that the imperfect yields to the perfect, and the lesser gives way to the greater. And the greater, the apostle tells us, is charity, or love. Prophecy and miracles are actually signs of the church's immaturity, not its maturity. God designed them as a kind of scaffolding, or to use a gentler image, as a leading string for a child learning to walk, suited to the church in its infancy rather than in its full growth. The apostle seems to treat them in exactly this way. When the Christian church was newly born after Christ's ascension, it was in its infancy, and miracles were needed to establish it. But once it was established and the canon of Scripture was complete, those gifts ceased. According to the apostle's own reasoning, that cessation reveals their imperfection and shows how far inferior they are to the fruit of the Holy Spirit expressed in divine love. Why, then, should we expect them to return precisely when the church reaches its most perfect state? The apostle seems to class all these miraculous gifts among "childish things" when set beside the nobler fruit of Christian love. They belong to the church's childhood, while holy love is what we should expect to flourish in its mature and fully grown condition. And considered in themselves, these gifts are childish by comparison with that holy love which will overflow in the church when it finally reaches its perfect stature in Christ Jesus.
The glorious future state of the church provides no argument for the continuation of miraculous spiritual gifts in that era. After all, that future state will not surpass the glory of heaven itself, and the apostle makes clear that in the heavenly state all such gifts will cease, leaving only the Spirit's work of producing divine love. Nor does it appear that miraculous gifts will even be necessary to bring about that future glory, since God is fully capable of accomplishing it without them. If the Spirit is poured out in His gracious work of converting souls and kindling divine love in them to whatever measure He chooses, that will be more than sufficient, without new revelations or miracles, to produce every effect needed to usher in the glorious age we are describing. We can see this confirmed by the little we have already witnessed in the recent outpouring of the Spirit in this and the neighboring towns. If we lacked a sufficient rule to guide us, and the ordinary work of the Spirit together with the Word of God were not enough, then there might be some case for restoring miracles. But there is no need whatsoever for new Scriptures or any additions to those we already have, since they are in themselves a perfect and complete rule for our faith and practice. And since there is no need for a new canon of Scripture, there is equally no need for those miraculous gifts whose primary purpose was either to confirm the Scriptures or to compensate for their absence before the inspiring Spirit had given them.
2. The subject we have been considering should make us extremely cautious about giving any credence to what appears to be a new revelation, or to any claim of an extraordinary gift of the Spirit. Sometimes a person receives what feels like a direct impression on their mind, something they believe has been immediately revealed to them about their own future or the future of someone close to them. Or perhaps they believe something previously hidden has been disclosed to them, something that would have remained a secret without this supposed revelation. In other cases, someone may think they have been shown the spiritual condition of another person, or of their own soul, through some means other than the scriptural signs and evidences of grace at work in the heart. Sometimes people believe they have received direct guidance from heaven to take a specific course of action, through impressions made immediately on their minds rather than through Scripture or reason pointing them toward their duty. And sometimes they imagine that God has revealed the future to them through a dream. But all of these experiences, if they were genuinely from God's Spirit, would belong to the category of those extraordinary spiritual gifts which the apostle says have ceased and passed away. Since those gifts have long since ended, there is no reason to suppose God will restore them. And if these experiences are not from God's Spirit, they are nothing more than serious delusions.
3. This subject also teaches us how deeply we should value those influences and fruits of the Spirit that serve as genuine evidence of true grace in the soul, all of which are summed up in charity, or divine love. This is precisely the apostle's purpose in the text and its surrounding context: to teach us to value this charity, or love, by showing that it never fails, even though all the miraculous gifts of the Spirit do fail and come to an end. This grace is the most excellent fruit of the Spirit, and without it even the most extraordinary and miraculous gifts amount to nothing. Love is the great end toward which those gifts are merely the means, and the end is, of course, more excellent than any means used to reach it. Let us therefore earnestly seek this blessed fruit of the Spirit, and let us seek it in abundance. May the love of God be poured out more and more in our hearts, and may we love the Lord Jesus Christ in sincerity, and love one another as Christ has loved us.
In this way, we will possess the richest of all treasures and the highest of all graces. Because we carry within us a love that is immortal by nature, we will have the surest evidence that our immortality will be blessed, and that our hope of eternal life is the kind of hope that will never disappoint us. Love nurtured in the soul here on earth will be both a foretaste of and a preparation for that world which is entirely a world of love, where the Spirit of love reigns and blesses forever.
CHAPTER 16
LECTURE 16. HEAVEN IS A WORLD OF LOVE
"Charity never faileth: but whether there be prophecies, they shall fail; whether there be tongues, they shall cease; whether there be knowledge, it shall vanish away. For we know in part, and we prophesy in part. But when that which is perfect is come, then that which is in part shall be done away." (1 Cor 13:8-10)
From the first of these verses, I have already drawn the teaching that the great fruit of the Spirit in which the Holy Spirit will be communicated to the church of Christ, not merely for a season but everlastingly, is charity, or divine love. I now want to consider that same verse alongside the two that follow it, and from all three verses I will make two observations.
First, that one of the great excellencies of charity is that it will remain when every other fruit of the Spirit has passed away. And Second, that this will happen in the perfect state of the church, when that which is partial has been done away with and that which is perfect has finally come.
There is a twofold imperfect and, correspondingly, a twofold perfect state of the Christian church. In its earliest stage, before it had taken firm root in the world, before it had settled into its New Testament form, and before the canon of Scripture was complete, the church existed in an imperfect state: a kind of childhood, compared to what it would become in its later and more mature ages, when it would reach something like full growth and comparative earthly perfection. And then again, even that comparatively mature church of Christ, for as long as it remains in its militant state on earth (that is, until the very end of time), will still be in an imperfect and, in a sense, childlike condition, compared to what it will be in its heavenly state, where it will at last reach something like true adulthood and perfection.
Corresponding to these two stages, there is also a twofold ending of the miraculous gifts of the Spirit described here. The first ending came at the close of the church's infant age, when the canon of Scripture was completed and those gifts were no longer needed. By that point, the church was meant to have put away childish things and grown into maturity before the end of the world, with the Spirit of God most gloriously poured out and expressed in that love or charity which is His greatest and most enduring fruit. The second ending will come when all the common fruits of the Spirit cease: for individual believers at death, and for the whole church at the end of the world. Yet charity will remain in heaven, where the Spirit of God will be poured out and expressed in perfect love in every heart, forever.
The apostle, in this passage, seems to have both of these states of the church in view, but especially the latter. For though the church's glorious state in its final age on earth will be perfect compared to what came before, it is the church's state in heaven that best fits the apostle's words when he says, "When that which is perfect is come," and so on, and, "Now we see through a glass darkly, but then face to face; now I know in part, but then shall I know even as also I am known." The doctrine I draw from this text, then, is that HEAVEN IS A WORLD OF CHARITY OR LOVE.
In this passage, the apostle describes the church in its perfected, heavenly state, a condition in which the Holy Spirit will be given more fully and abundantly than He is now on earth. The way He will be given, when poured out so completely, will be through that great fruit of the Spirit: holy and divine love, filling the hearts of every blessed inhabitant of that world. The heavenly state of the church is therefore distinguished from its earthly state in a specific way. It is the state God has designed especially for this kind of communication of His Holy Spirit, the state in which the Spirit will be given perfectly, whereas in our present condition He is given with great imperfection. It is also a state in which this holy love, this charity, will be, in a sense, the only gift or fruit of the Spirit that remains, because it is the most perfect and glorious of all. When love is brought to its full perfection, every other gift God was accustomed to bestowing on His church on earth becomes unnecessary. To better understand how heaven is a world of holy love, I will consider, first, the great cause and fountain of love that exists in heaven; second, the objects of love it contains; third, the subjects of that love; fourth, its principle, or the nature of love itself; fifth, the remarkable circumstances in which love is there exercised, expressed, and enjoyed; and sixth, the happy effects and fruits of all this. And, I. The cause and fountain of love in heaven: Here I want to note that the God of love Himself dwells in heaven. Heaven is the palace, the throne room, of the high and holy One who is love, and who is both the cause and the source of all holy love. Considered in terms of His essence, God is everywhere; He fills both heaven and earth. Yet Scripture speaks of Him as being more especially present in certain places than in others. He was said in former times to dwell in the land of Israel above all other lands, in Jerusalem above all other cities of that land, in the temple above all other buildings in the city, in the holy of holies above all other rooms of the temple, and on the mercy seat over the ark of the covenant above all other places in the holy of holies. But heaven is His dwelling place above all other places in the universe, and every one of those earlier locations where He was said to dwell were simply types pointing forward to this. Heaven is the part of creation that God built for this very purpose: to be the place of His glorious presence, His eternal home. Here He will dwell and make Himself gloriously known, forever.
This is what makes heaven a world of love: God is the fountain of love, just as the sun is the fountain of light. The glorious presence of God in heaven fills it with love, just as the sun, positioned at the center of the visible sky on a clear day, floods the world with light. The apostle tells us that "God is love" (1 John 4:8), and because He is an infinite being, it follows that He is an infinite fountain of love. Because He is an all-sufficient being, it follows that He is a full, overflowing, and inexhaustible fountain of love. And because He is an unchangeable and eternal being, He is an unchangeable and eternal fountain of love.
There, in heaven itself, dwells the God from whom every stream of holy love proceeds, including every drop that has ever existed. There dwells God the Father, God the Son, and God the Spirit, united as one in love that is infinitely dear, incomprehensible, mutual, and eternal. There dwells God the Father, who is the father of mercies and therefore the father of love, who loved the world so deeply that He gave His only-begotten Son to die for it. There dwells Christ, the Lamb of God, the prince of peace and of love, who loved the world so completely that He shed His blood and poured out His soul unto death for humanity. There dwells the great Mediator, through whom all divine love is expressed toward humanity, through whom the fruits of that love were purchased and are communicated, and through whom love is imparted to the hearts of all God's people. There dwells Christ in both His natures, human and divine, seated on the same throne as the Father. And there dwells the Holy Spirit, the Spirit of divine love, in whom the very essence of God flows out and is breathed forth in love, and through whose immediate influence all holy love is poured into the hearts of every saint on earth and in heaven. There, in heaven, this infinite fountain of love, this eternal Three in One, stands open without any obstacle to hinder access to it, flowing forever without interruption. There this glorious God is revealed and shines forth in full glory, radiating beams of love. And there this glorious fountain flows forever in streams, indeed in rivers of love and delight, rivers that swell into an ocean of love in which the souls of the redeemed may bathe with the sweetest enjoyment, their hearts flooded and overwhelmed with love. I would also consider heaven with regard to:
II. To the OBJECTS of love that it contains. And here I would observe three things:
1. There are none but lovely objects in heaven. No offensive, unlovely, or corrupted person or thing can be found there. Nothing in heaven is wicked or unholy. "There shall in no wise enter into it anything that defileth, neither whatsoever worketh abomination" (Rev 21:27). Nothing there is marred by any natural or moral defect; instead, everything is beautiful to behold, admirable, and excellent in its own right. The God who dwells there and reveals Himself in glory is infinitely lovely, gloriously lovely as a heavenly Father, as a divine Redeemer, and as a holy Sanctifier.
Every person belonging to the blessed society of heaven is lovely. The Father of the family is lovely, and so are all His children; the head of the body is lovely, and so are all its members. Among the angels, there is not one who is unlovely, for they are all holy. No evil angels are permitted to trouble heaven as they trouble this world; they are kept at an eternal distance by the great gulf that separates them from that glorious world of love. And among the entire company of the saints, there are no unlovely persons either. There are no false professors or hypocrites there, no one who claims to be a saint while harboring an unchristian or hateful spirit, as happens so often in this world. There is no one whose gold has not been purified of its dross, no one who is not lovely both in themselves and to others. There is not a single object there to cause offense, or to stir up any feeling of hatred or dislike. Every object there will draw forth love, and nothing else, forever.
Not only will every object in heaven be lovely, but 2. They will be perfectly lovely. Many things in this world are lovely in a general sense, yet not entirely free from their opposite. There are spots on the sun, and similarly, many admirable and deeply lovable people still have qualities that are disagreeable or off-putting. In good people, some flaw of temperament, character, or conduct often mars what would otherwise seem most beautiful; and even the very best of people remain imperfect while on earth. But heaven is different. No pollution, deformity, or unpleasant flaw of any kind will be found in any person or thing there. Every soul will be perfectly pure and perfectly lovely. That blessed world will be perfectly bright, without a trace of darkness; perfectly fair, without a single blemish; perfectly clear, without a cloud in sight. No moral or natural defect will ever enter there. Nothing sinful, weak, or foolish will be seen; nothing coarse or displeasing in nature or appearance, nothing that could offend even the most refined taste or the most sensitive eye. No string will vibrate out of tune to introduce a jarring note into heaven's harmony, and no voice will strike a discord in the anthems of saints and angels.
The great God who reveals Himself so fully there is perfect with an absolute and infinite perfection. The Son of God, who is the radiance of the Father's glory, appears there in the fullness of His glory, free from the outward humility He wore during His time in this world. The Holy Spirit will be poured out there with perfect richness and sweetness, like a pure river of the water of life, clear as crystal, flowing from the throne of God and of the Lamb. Every member of that holy and blessed society will be entirely free from sin, imperfection, weakness, foolishness, or any blemish of any kind. The whole church, ransomed and purified, will be presented to Christ as a bride clothed in fine linen, clean and white, without spot or wrinkle or anything of the sort. Wherever the inhabitants of that blessed world turn their eyes, they will see nothing but dignity, beauty, and glory. The most impressive cities on earth, however magnificent their buildings, still have their foundations in the dust; their streets are dirty and defiled, made to be walked on and worn down. But the very streets of this heavenly city are of pure gold, like transparent glass; its foundations are of precious stones, and its gates are pearls. And all of these are only faint symbols of the purity and perfection of those who dwell within. In heaven, 3. Shall be all those objects that the saints have set their hearts upon, and which they have loved above all things while in this world. There they will find the things that appeared most beautiful to them while they lived on earth: the things that satisfied their deepest judgments, captured their affections, and drew their souls away from even the most cherished and pleasant earthly objects. There they will find the things that were their delight in this life, on which they loved to meditate, and with the sweet contemplation of which their minds were so often occupied. There, too, they will find the things they chose as their true portion, things so precious to them that they were willing to endure the severest suffering for their sake, and to leave behind father and mother, family and friends, spouse and children, and even life itself. All who were truly great and good, all who were pure and holy and excellent from this world, and perhaps from every corner of the universe, are constantly moving toward heaven. As rivers move toward the ocean, so all of these are flowing toward that great ocean of infinite purity and joy. The passage of time only carries them forward into its blessedness, and carries us there as well, if we are holy, to be united with them at last. Every precious soul that death tears roughly from us here is a glorious jewel shining forever there; every Christian friend who goes before us out of this world is a ransomed spirit waiting to welcome us in heaven. There will be the child we lost too soon below, found again above through grace; there the Christian father and mother, the wife and child and friend, with whom we will renew the holy fellowship of the saints, interrupted by death here but taken up again in the upper sanctuary, never to end. There we will keep company with the patriarchs, the fathers, and the saints of the Old and New Testaments, those of whom the world was not worthy, people we knew on earth only through faith. And there, above all, we will enjoy and dwell with God the Father, whom we have loved with all our hearts on earth; with Jesus Christ, our beloved Savior, who has always been to us the chief among ten thousands and altogether lovely; and with the Holy Spirit, our Sanctifier, Guide, and Comforter. There we will be filled with all the fullness of the Godhead forever.
And with those being the objects of love in heaven, I turn, III. To its subjects; these are the hearts in which love dwells. In every heart in heaven, love dwells and reigns. The heart of God is love's original home and source. Divine love exists in Him not as something He receives from another, but as something native to His very being. Love is in God the way light is in the sun: the sun doesn't shine by reflected light, as the moon and planets do, but by its own light, as the great fountain of all light. And from God, love flows out toward all the inhabitants of heaven. It flows out, first of all, necessarily and infinitely, toward His only-begotten Son, poured forth without reservation toward an object who is Himself infinite and therefore fully adequate to receive a love that is also infinite. This infinite love is infinitely exercised toward Him. Not only does the fountain send forth streams toward this object; the very fountain itself goes out toward Him entirely and without remainder. And the Son of God is not only the infinite object of love, but also its infinite subject. He is not only the beloved of the Father; He loves the Father infinitely in return. The infinite, essential love of God is, as it were, an infinite and eternal mutual energy of holiness between the Father and the Son: a pure and holy act by which the Deity becomes, in a sense, one infinite and unchangeable movement of love proceeding from both the Father and the Son. This divine love has its seat within the Deity itself, as it is exercised within God toward Himself.
But this love isn't confined to those expressions alone. It flows out in countless streams toward all the created inhabitants of heaven, toward every saint and angel there. The love of God the Father flows toward Christ the head, and through Him to all the members who were beloved in Him before the foundation of the world, and in whom the Father's love was expressed in time through His death and suffering, as it is now fully revealed in heaven. The saints and angels are secondary recipients of this holy love, not as those in whom it originates, the way light originates in the sun, but as planets that shine only by reflected light. And the light of their love is reflected back, first and foremost, to its great source. Since God has given the saints and angels this love, their love is directed chiefly toward God as its fountain, which is entirely fitting. They all love God with a supreme love. There is no enemy of God in heaven; all love Him as their Father, as His children. They are united with one mind, pouring out their whole souls in love toward God their eternal Father, toward Jesus Christ their common Redeemer, their head, and their friend.
Christ loves all His saints in heaven. His love flows out to His whole church there, and to every individual member of it. They all, with one heart and one soul, unite in love to their common Redeemer. Every heart is joined to this holy and spiritual husband, and all rejoice in Him, while the angels join them in their love. The angels and saints all love one another as well. Every member of the glorious society of heaven is sincerely united with the rest. There is not a single secret or open enemy among them. Not one heart there is without love, and not one inhabitant who is not beloved by all the others. And since all are lovely, all perceive each other's loveliness with full satisfaction and delight. Every soul reaches out in love to every other, and among all the blessed inhabitants, love is mutual, complete, and eternal. I turn now to speak, as proposed, IV. Of the principle of love in heaven. By this I mean the love itself that fills and blesses the heavenly world, which can be considered both in its nature and its degree.
1. As to its nature. In its nature, this love is entirely holy and divine. Most of the love found in this world is corrupt at its core. But the love that exists in heaven is not carnal; it is spiritual. It does not arise from corrupt principles or selfish motives, nor is it aimed at low or degrading ends. In contrast to all of that, it is a pure flame, directed by holy motives and seeking nothing that conflicts with God's glory or the happiness of the universe. The saints in heaven love God for His own sake, and they love one another for God's sake, for the relationship they share with Him, and for the image of God that rests on them. All their love is pure and holy.
2. As to its degree. In degree, this love is perfect. The love that dwells in the heart of God is perfect with an absolutely infinite and divine perfection. The love of angels and saints toward God and Christ is perfect in its kind, with the kind of perfection appropriate to their nature. It is perfect in that it is sinless, and perfect in that it fully matches the capacity of their nature. So the text says that "when that which is perfect is come, that which is in part shall be done away" (1 Cor 13:10). Their love will have no trace of any opposing principle, with no pride or selfishness to interrupt it or hold it back. Their hearts will be full of love. What existed in the heart on earth as a mustard seed will become a great tree in heaven. The soul that in this world carried only a small spark of divine love will, in heaven, be transformed into a bright and ardent flame, like the sun shining at its fullest brilliance, without a single spot upon it.
In heaven, no enmity will remain, no distaste, no coldness, no deadness of heart toward God and Christ. Not even the faintest trace of envy will exist toward angels or other beings who surpass us in glory, nor will there be any contempt or dismissiveness toward those of lesser standing. Those who occupy a lower station in glory than others lose nothing of their own happiness by seeing others elevated above them. On the contrary, every member of that blessed society rejoices in the happiness of the rest, because the love of goodwill is perfect in all of them. Each person holds not merely a sincere but a completely perfect goodwill toward every other. Sincere and strong love finds deep gratification and delight in the prosperity of the one it loves, and when that love is perfect, the greater the beloved's prosperity, the more the lover is pleased and satisfied. The prosperity of the beloved is, in a sense, the food that love feeds on, so the greater that prosperity, the more richly love is nourished. Just as the love of delight rejoices in beholding another's beauty or excellence, the love of goodwill rejoices in beholding another's flourishing. The superior prosperity of those who stand higher in glory, then, is far from diminishing the love felt toward them. It actually deepens and enriches that love, becoming part of it.
There is, without question, an inconceivably pure, sweet, and fervent love among the saints in glory. That love is proportional to the perfection and loveliness of its objects, and so it will naturally produce delight when the saints see that the happiness and glory of others corresponds to how lovely those others are, and therefore to how deeply they are loved. Those who stand highest in glory are those who stand highest in holiness, and for that reason they are the most beloved by all the saints, since every saint loves most deeply those who are most holy. All the saints will therefore rejoice that the holiest among them are also the most blessed. Nor will any saint grieve to see those above them in holiness and likeness to God receiving greater love than themselves, for every saint will receive as much love as they desire and as many expressions of that love as they can bear. All will be fully satisfied, and where there is perfect satisfaction, there is simply no ground for envy. There will also be no temptation to envy those in higher glory on the grounds that such persons are lifted up with pride, because there will be no pride in heaven at all. We should not imagine that those who are holier and happier than others will carry themselves with any air of superiority, for those who surpass others in holiness will surpass them equally in humility. The saints who stand highest in glory will be the lowest in spirit, since their deeper humility is itself part of their deeper holiness. Though all the saints will be perfectly free from pride, some will possess greater degrees of divine knowledge than others, and larger capacities to perceive the divine perfections. Precisely because of this, they will see more clearly their own comparative smallness and insignificance before God, and will therefore be the most lowly and self-abased of all.
And beyond this, those who occupy a lower place in glory will have no reason to envy those above them. The highest among them will not only be more deeply loved by those below, precisely because of their greater holiness, but they will also possess a greater capacity for love itself, and so will love those beneath them more abundantly than they could if their own elevation were less. Those who stand highest in glory will have the greatest capacity of all; and because their knowledge is greatest, they will see most clearly the beauty of God, and consequently their hearts will overflow with love, both for God and for the saints. For this very reason, those who are lower in glory will not envy those above them: they will be the most beloved by the very ones who stand highest. And the superior in glory will be far from looking down on those beneath them. On the contrary, they will love them most abundantly, with a depth of love proportioned to their greater knowledge and happiness. The higher anyone rises in glory, the more they resemble Christ in this regard, so that the love flowing downward from the higher to the lower will actually exceed the love that flows between equals. And what removes all remaining doubt that seeing others' greater happiness could somehow diminish the happiness of those in a lower place is simply this: the superior happiness of the higher consists precisely in their greater humility, their greater love for those below them, and their greater love for God and Christ, surpassing whatever the lower possess in themselves. Such will be the sweet and perfect harmony among the saints in heaven, and such the perfect love reigning in every heart toward every other, without limit, without impurity, without interruption. No envy, no malice, no revenge, no contempt, no selfishness will ever find a foothold there. All such impulses will be kept as far away as sin is from holiness, and as hell is from heaven.
Let us now consider the fifth point: the excellent circumstances in which love will be exercised, expressed, and enjoyed in heaven.
1. Love in heaven is always mutual. It is always met with a fitting return of love, a return proportioned to what was given. This is precisely what love seeks; and the more deeply someone is loved, the more their own love is desired and treasured in return. In heaven, this longing to be loved will never go unsatisfied. No inhabitant of that blessed world will ever be troubled by the thought that they are overlooked by those they love, or that their love has not been fully and warmly returned.
As the saints will love God with an inconceivable intensity of heart, and to the fullest extent of their capacity, so they will know that He has loved them from all eternity, that He loves them still, and that He will continue to love them forever. God will then reveal Himself to them in glorious fullness, and they will understand that all the happiness and glory they possess are the fruits of His love. With that same ardor and passion, the saints will love the Lord Jesus Christ; their love will be received and welcomed; and they will know that He loved them with a faithful love, even a love that carried Him to death. They will then grasp, more deeply than they ever could in this life, what an extraordinary act of love it was for Christ to lay down His life for them. Christ will open to their sight the great fountain of love that has always resided in His heart for them, revealing depths they had never before perceived. In this way, the love of the saints toward God and Christ is shown to be fully returned, and that declaration is brought to its completion: "I love them that love me." And though God's love for them cannot strictly be called a response, since He loved them first, that very fact will only deepen their joy, their wonder, and their love for Him all the more.
The love that the saints have for one another will always be mutual and reciprocal, though we shouldn't assume that everyone will be equally beloved in every respect. Even on earth, some saints are more beloved by God than others. The angel told Daniel that he was "a man greatly beloved" (Dan 9:23); Luke is called "the beloved physician" (Col 4:14); and John is described as "the disciple whom Jesus loved" (John 20:2). So it follows that those who have been most distinguished in faithfulness and holiness, and who stand highest in glory, are most beloved by Christ in heaven. And those saints who are most beloved by Christ, who are nearest to Him in glory, are also most beloved by all the other saints. We can reasonably conclude, then, that saints like the apostle Paul and the apostle John are more beloved by the saints in heaven than saints of lower rank. They are more beloved even by those of lesser standing than by those on equal footing with themselves. Yet there are fitting returns of love in these cases, because those who are most beloved by all the other saints are also the ones whose hearts are fullest of love toward others. The heart of Christ, the great Head of all the saints, is fuller of love than the heart of any saint could ever be. He loves all the saints far more than any of them love one another. But the more deeply any saint is loved by Him, the more that saint resembles Him in this very way: the fuller that saint's heart is of love.
2. The joy of heavenly love will never be interrupted or dampened by jealousy. Those who love in heaven will have no doubt about one another's love. They won't fear that declarations of affection are insincere; instead, they will be perfectly certain of the depth and genuineness of each other's feelings, as clearly as if every chest had a window through which the heart could be seen. There will be no flattery in heaven, no pretense of any kind. Perfect sincerity will reign throughout and in everyone. Each person will be exactly who they appear to be, and will truly possess all the love they seem to have. It won't be like this world, where comparatively few things are what they appear to be, and where professions of love are often made carelessly and without real meaning. In heaven, every expression of love will come from the deepest part of the heart, and everything that is declared will be genuinely and completely felt.
The saints will know with certainty that God loves them, and they will never doubt the depth of that love. Nor will they question the love of their fellow inhabitants of heaven. There will be no jealousy over whether others' affections will hold, no suspicion that someone's love has cooled, no fear that a rival has drawn another's heart away. They won't wonder whether something in themselves has become disagreeable to others, or worry that inconstancy, whether in their own hearts or in someone else's, might quietly erode what they share. There will be no anxiety that any love directed toward them might one day diminish. Inconstancy and unfaithfulness simply will not exist in heaven; those forces that so often fracture friendships in this life will have no place in that blessed community. The saints will have no fear that God's love will ever cool toward them, or that Christ will cease to hold them with the same tenderness and affection He has always shown. And they will feel no jealousy toward one another, knowing instead that by divine grace the love they share will never decay, never shift, and never end.
3. There shall be nothing within themselves to clog or hinder the saints in heaven in the exercises and expressions of love. In this world, the saints find much that holds them back in this regard. They carry a profound heaviness within them. They move through life burdened by a heavy, earth-bound body, a mass of flesh and blood that is simply not suited to serve as the instrument of a soul burning with intense divine love. Instead, the body proves to be a constant weight on the spirit, so that the saints cannot express their love for God as they wish, and cannot be as active and alive in that love as they long to be. Often they desperately want to soar, but they are held down as if by a dead weight fastened to their wings. They want to rise up and blaze like a flame of fire, but they find themselves hampered and chained, unable to follow where their love would lead them. Love moves them to break out in praise, but their tongues won't cooperate; they lack the words to express the intensity of their souls, and cannot arrange their speech because of the darkness surrounding them (Job 37:19). And often, for lack of any adequate expression, they are left with nothing but groans too deep for words (Rom 8:26).
In heaven, none of these hindrances will exist. There will be no sluggishness or spiritual inertia, no corruption of the heart fighting against divine love and blocking its expression. No earthly body will weigh down the heavenly flame with its heaviness. The saints in heaven will have no difficulty expressing all their love. Their souls, burning with holy love, will not be like a fire trapped and smothered, but like a flame fully uncovered and free. Their spirits, carried on the wings of love, will feel no weight pulling against their flight. There will be no lack of strength or energy, and no shortage of words with which to praise the One they adore. Nothing will prevent them from communing with God, praising Him, and serving Him exactly as their love moves them to do. Love naturally longs to express itself, and in heaven the love of the saints will be completely free to do so, whether directed toward God or toward His created beings.
4. In heaven, love will be expressed with perfect decency and wisdom. Many people in this world are sincere in their hearts and genuinely possess true love for God and their neighbors, yet they lack the wisdom to guide how and when they express it. Their intentions, and therefore their words, are good, but they are often poorly timed or handled without enough care, accompanied by a kind of indiscretion that greatly obscures the beauty of grace in the eyes of others. But in heaven, the loveliness and excellence of their love will not be dimmed by any such failure. There will be no indecent, unwise, or discordant words or actions; no foolish sentimentality; no unnecessary meddling; no base or sinful impulses of passion; and nothing like emotion clouding or distorting reason, or running ahead of it or against it. Instead, wisdom and discretion will be just as perfect in the saints as love itself is, and every expression of their love will be marked by the most beautiful, complete, and fitting decency and care.
5. There will be nothing in heaven's external conditions to keep its inhabitants apart or to prevent them from fully enjoying one another's love. No wall of separation will divide the saints from each other, nor will distance of any kind prevent them from experiencing the complete fullness of one another's love, for they will all dwell together as one family in their heavenly Father's house. There will be no lack of genuine acquaintance to block the deepest possible intimacy, and far less will there be any misunderstanding between them, or any misreading of what others say or do. No division will arise from differences in temperament, manner, circumstance, opinion, interest, feeling, or loyalty. Instead, all will be united in the same purpose, all equally bound to the same Savior, and all engaged in the same great work of serving and glorifying the same God.
6. In heaven, all will be united in the closest and most cherished relationships. Love always reaches toward nearness with the one it loves, and in heaven everyone will be intimately bound to one another. All will be closely related to God, the supreme object of their love, for they will all be His children. All will be closely related to Christ, for He will be the head of the entire society and the husband of the whole Church of saints, who together will constitute His bride. And all will be related to one another as brothers and sisters, for there will be only one society, or rather one family, with every member belonging to the household of God. And beyond even this:
7. In heaven, all will have a true claim and ownership in one another. Love longs to possess the beloved as its own, and divine love rejoices in saying, "My beloved is mine, and I am his." In heaven, the saints will not merely be related to one another; they will genuinely belong to each other. The saints will be God's. He brings them home to Himself in glory as that portion of creation He has chosen as His own treasured possession. And in turn, God will be theirs, given over to them through an everlasting covenant established in this world, and in heaven they will at last be in full and permanent possession of Him as their inheritance. So too the saints will be Christ's, for He purchased them at great cost; and He will be theirs, for the One who gave Himself for them will have given Himself to them. In the bonds of mutual and eternal love, Christ and His saints will have given themselves entirely to each other. And just as God and Christ will belong to the saints, so the angels will be their angels, as is suggested in "their angels always see the face of my Father" (Matt 18:10). The saints will also belong to one another, for the apostle speaks of the believers in his day as first giving themselves to the Lord and then to one another by the will of God (2 Cor 8:5). If this is true on earth, it will be fulfilled far more perfectly in heaven.
8. In heaven, they will enjoy one another's love in perfect and uninterrupted prosperity. What so often diminishes the pleasure of earthly relationships is that even people who genuinely love one another may live in poverty, or face serious hardships and painful trials, which cause them to grieve both for themselves and for each other. Love and friendship do lighten the load in some ways, of course, but in other ways they actually make it heavier, because those who love each other become, through that very love, sharers in each other's suffering. Each person must carry not only his own burdens, but also the weight of his beloved friends' pain. In heaven, however, there will be no adversity to cause such grief, and nothing will disturb or trouble those heavenly friends in the enjoyment of one another's company. Instead, they will share in each other's love amid the greatest prosperity, surrounded by glorious riches and comfort, clothed in the highest honor and dignity, reigning together in the heavenly kingdom: inheriting all things, seated on thrones, each wearing a crown of life, made kings and priests unto God forever.
While on earth, Christ and His disciples walked together through affliction and trial, sustaining one another with a fierce and devoted love even under the weight of great suffering. Now, in heaven, they share that same love in immortal glory, with every trace of sorrow and sighing gone forever. Both Christ and His saints knew grief deeply in this world, though Christ bore the greatest portion of it, being uniquely "a man of sorrows." But in heaven they sit together in heavenly places where grief will never again find a foothold. In the same way, all the saints will enjoy one another's love in a glory and prosperity so vast that the wealth and thrones of the greatest earthly rulers look, by comparison, like squalid poverty. Because they love one another, each saint has not only his own blessedness to rejoice in, but also the blessedness of every other saint. Love makes them genuine participants in each other's glory. Indeed, the love each saint bears toward every other is so complete that the glory he sees another enjoying becomes, in a real sense, his own. He rejoices so fully in their exaltation that it is, in some meaningful way, as though he were experiencing that glory himself.
9. In heaven, everything will work together to deepen their love and enrich their enjoyment of one another.; Nothing there will tempt anyone toward dislike or hatred. There will be no busybodies, no malicious rivals spreading distortions, stirring up misunderstandings, or circulating damaging rumors. Every person and every thing will conspire to nurture love and its fullest expression. Heaven itself, as a place of dwelling, is a garden of delights, a paradise perfectly suited in every way to be a home for heavenly love: a place where its inhabitants enjoy rich fellowship and the complete, unhindered pleasure of one another's company. No one there is withdrawn or held at a distance. The petty social distinctions of this world draw no dividing lines in heaven's community; instead, everyone meets as equals, united in holiness and the love that holiness produces.
Everything in heaven visibly reflects the beauty and loveliness of God and Christ, radiating the brightness and sweetness of divine love. The very light that fills that world is the light of love, for it is the shining glory of the Lamb of God, that most wonderful expression of lamb-like meekness and love that illuminates the heavenly Jerusalem. "The city had no need of the sun, neither of the moon, to shine in it; for the glory of God did lighten it, and the Lamb is the light thereof" (Rev 21:23). The glory surrounding the One who reigns in heaven is so radiant and sweet that it is compared to "a rainbow round about the throne, in sight like unto an emerald" (Rev 4:3), and the rainbow is, of course, the image used throughout the Old Testament as the fitting sign of God's love and grace expressed in His covenant. The light of the New Jerusalem, which is the light of God's glory, is described as being like a jasper stone, clear as crystal (Rev 21:11), signifying the greatest preciousness and beauty; and as for its duration, we are told there is no night there, only an endless and glorious day. This suggests, once more, that:
10. The inhabitants of heaven will know that they will be kept forever in the perfect enjoyment of each other's love. They will know that God and Christ will be with them forever as their God and portion, that His love will be sustained and fully expressed without end, and that all their beloved fellow saints will live with them in glory forever, keeping in their hearts the same love they now possess. They will know, too, that they themselves will live forever to love God and love the saints, and to enjoy that love in all its fullness and sweetness for eternity. They will have no fear that this happiness will end, that its fullness will diminish, that they will ever grow weary of its expressions and exercises, or that they will tire of its enjoyments, or that the beloved objects of their love will ever grow old or disagreeable, causing their love to fade at last. All in heaven will flourish in immortal youth and freshness. Age will never diminish anyone's beauty or vitality there; and love will abide in every heart like a living spring perpetually welling up in the soul, or like a flame that never dies. The holy pleasure of this love will be like a river flowing forever clear and full, growing deeper with every passing moment. The heavenly paradise of love will be kept in a perpetual spring, without autumn or winter, where no frost will blight, no leaves will wither and fall, but where every plant will remain in perpetual freshness, bloom, fragrance, and beauty, always growing, always blossoming, always bearing fruit. The leaf of the righteous will not wither (Ps 1:3). And in the middle of the streets of heaven, on either side of the river, grows the tree of life, bearing twelve kinds of fruit and yielding its fruit every month (Rev 22:2). Everything in the heavenly world will contribute to the joy of the saints, and every joy of heaven will be eternal. No night will ever settle its darkness upon the brightness of their everlasting day.
Having examined many of the blessed circumstances in which love in heaven is exercised, expressed, and enjoyed, I turn now, as proposed, to the final point: VI. Of the blessed effects and fruits of this love, as exercised and enjoyed in these circumstances. Among the many blessed fruits of this love, I will mention only two at this time.
1. The most excellent and perfect behaviour of all the inhabitants of heaven toward God and each other. Charity, or divine love, is the sum of all good principles, and therefore the source from which all admirable and excellent actions flow. Since this love in heaven will be perfect, completely excluding every sin rooted in enmity toward God and fellow creatures, its fruit will be a perfectly holy manner of life toward all. Life in heaven, then, will be entirely free from even the slightest sinful failure or error. No one will ever fall short or stray from the path of holiness in any degree. Every feeling and every action will be perfect in itself and in all its particulars. Every aspect of their conduct will be holy and divine in its substance, its form, its spirit, and its purpose.
We don't know the specific details of how the saints in heaven will spend their time, but we know in general that they are occupied with praising and serving God. They will do this perfectly, moved by the kind of love we have been examining. We also have good reason to believe that they serve one another's happiness in some way, under God's direction, since Scripture portrays them as united in a single community. That community, it seems, can only exist for the purpose of mutual service and shared joy. They serve one another in this way through conduct that is excellent and genuinely beautiful, as a natural expression of their perfect love for each other. And even if they are not confined to that community, but are sometimes sent on missions of duty or mercy to distant worlds, or employed, as some have suggested, as ministering spirits to those still living in this world, they are still guided by love in everything they do. Their conduct in all circumstances is pleasing to God and therefore contributes to their own happiness and the happiness of others. The second fruit of love, as it operates in those circumstances, is:
2. Perfect tranquility and joy in heaven. Charity, that is, holy and humble Christian love, is a principle of remarkable power to bring an inexpressible quietness and tranquility to the soul. It drives out every disturbance, gently settles the spirit, and fills the inner life with a divine calm that is sweet and deeply happy. In the soul where divine love reigns and moves with vitality, nothing can stir up a storm or even gather threatening clouds on the horizon.
There are many principles that run contrary to love, and they make this world feel like a storm-tossed sea. Selfishness, envy, revenge, jealousy, and all their kindred passions keep life on earth in a state of constant turmoil, turning it into a scene of confusion and uproar where no genuine rest can be found except by renouncing this world and fixing one's eyes on another. But what rest there is in that other world, which the God of peace and love fills with His own gracious presence, and in which the Lamb of God lives and reigns, flooding it with the brightest and sweetest rays of His love. There, nothing disturbs or offends; every being and every object is surrounded by perfect beauty and sweetness. The saints will find everything they have ever loved and be fully satisfied. There is no enemy and no enmity, only perfect love in every heart toward every being. Perfect harmony reigns among all who dwell there: no one envies another, and every soul rejoices in the happiness of every other. All their love is humble and holy, perfectly Christlike, without the slightest trace of carnality or impurity. Love there is always mutual and fully returned. There is no hypocrisy or pretense, only perfect simplicity and sincerity. There is no treachery, no faithlessness, no inconstancy, no jealousy of any kind. Nothing clogs or hinders the expression of love, no imprudence or indecency mars the giving of it, and no foolishness or poor judgment taints any word or deed. No walls of separation exist there, no misunderstanding or awkward distance, but full acquaintance and perfect intimacy among all. No divisions arise from differing opinions or competing interests; instead, all who belong to that glorious and loving society are bound together in the closest and most divine fellowship, each belonging to every other, and all enjoying one another in perfect prosperity, abundance, and honor, without sickness, grief, persecution, or sorrow, without any enemy to threaten them or any meddler to stir up jealousy and misunderstanding or disturb the perfect, holy, and blessed peace that reigns in heaven. And all of this unfolds in the garden of God, in the paradise of love, where everything is saturated with love, where everything conspires to promote and kindle it, to sustain its flame, and nothing ever interrupts it. An all-wise God has fitted every part of that place for love's full enjoyment, under the greatest possible advantages, forever. And there, too, the beauty of the beloved will never fade, love will never grow weary or decay, and the soul will rejoice in love more and more, without end.
What tranquility will fill such a world as this! Who can fully express the richness and blessedness of that peace? What a calm it will be: sweet, holy, and full of joy. What a haven of rest to enter after passing through the storms and tempests of this world, where pride, selfishness, envy, malice, scorn, contempt, contention, and vice roll like waves on a restless ocean, always churning and often crashing with violence and fury. What a Canaan of rest to arrive at after journeying through this barren and howling wilderness, full of snares, pitfalls, and poisonous serpents, where no rest could be found.
And what joy will rise up in the hearts of the saints after they have completed their wearisome pilgrimage, to be brought at last to such a paradise as this! Here is joy that is truly unspeakable and full of glory: humble, holy, enrapturing, and perfect in its divine character. Love is always a sweet principle, and divine love most of all. Even on earth, it is a spring of sweetness; but in heaven it will become a stream, then a river, then an ocean. All will stand around the God of glory, who is the great fountain of love, opening their very souls, as it were, to receive the outpourings of love that flow from His fullness, just as flowers on the earth open their petals on bright and joyous spring days to receive the sun's light and warmth, flourishing in beauty and fragrance beneath his cheering rays.
Every saint in heaven is like a flower in God's garden, and holy love is the fragrance they all send forth, filling the bowers of that paradise above. Every soul there is like a note in a great concert of delightful music, harmonizing sweetly with every other note, all of them blending together in the most rapturous strains of praise to God and the Lamb forever. Each helps the others, to the fullest extent possible, to express the love of the whole society toward its glorious Father and Head, and to pour love back into the great fountain of love from which they are all supplied and filled with love, blessedness, and glory. And so they will love, and reign in love, and in that godlike joy which is love's blessed fruit, a joy such as eye has not seen, nor ear heard, nor has it ever entered into the heart of man in this world to conceive. And thus, in the full sunlight of the throne, enraptured with joys that are forever increasing and yet forever full, they will live and reign with God and Christ forever and ever.
In applying this subject, I want to note the following. 1. If heaven is the kind of world that has been described, then we can understand why contention and strife tend to darken our sense of our own fitness to possess it. Experience confirms this effect. When malice and ill-will take hold among God's people, as they sometimes do through the lingering corruption of the human heart, and those people fall into a contentious spirit or become caught up in some conflict, whether public or private, their spirits filling with opposition toward their neighbors over whatever the matter may be, their former evidence of heaven seems to grow dim or fade away entirely. They find themselves in darkness about their spiritual condition, no longer able to find the comfortable and satisfying hope they once enjoyed.
And so, when converted persons fall into troubled patterns within their families, the result is commonly, if not universally, that they live without much of a genuine sense of heavenly things, or any lively hope of heaven. They don't enjoy the spiritual calm and sweetness that those who live in love and peace experience. They lack the help from God, the communion with Him, and that close connection with heaven in prayer that others have. The apostle seems to speak of family conflict as having precisely this effect. His words are: "Likewise, ye husbands, dwell with them" (your wives) "according to knowledge, giving honour unto the wife, as unto the weaker vessel; and as being heirs together of the grace of life, that your prayers be not hindered" (1 Pet 3:7). Here he suggests that discord in families tends to hinder Christians in their prayers. And what Christian who has made this painful experiment has not felt it as a source of sorrow, and does not bear witness in his own experience to the truth of what the apostle is saying?
Why contention produces this effect, hindering spiritual exercises, comforts, and hopes while destroying our sense of the heavenly, can be understood through the doctrine we have already examined. Because heaven is a world of love, it follows that when we exercise the least love and are most dominated by a contrary spirit, we have the least of heaven and are farthest from it in the orientation of our minds. We have the least exercise of what constitutes conformity to heaven, preparation for it, and movement toward it. Necessarily, then, we have the least evidence of our claim to heaven and are farthest from the comfort that such evidence provides. From this subject we may also see, 2. How happy those are who have a rightful claim to heaven. There are people living on this earth to whom the happiness of the heavenly world belongs as fully, indeed far more fully, than any person's earthly estate belongs to himself. They have a share and interest in this world of love, and hold a genuine right and title to it, for they are among those of whom it is written: "Blessed are they that do his commandments, that they may have right to the tree of life, and may enter in through the gates into the city" (Rev 22:14). Without question, such people are among us right now. And how happy they are, holding as they do a claim to such a world as heaven! Surely they are the most blessed people on earth, and the fullness of their blessedness exceeds what any language can describe or any words express. But here some may be inclined to ask: "No doubt those who have a title to such a blessed world, and are soon to enter into the eternal possession of its joys, are happy indeed. But who are these people? How can they be recognized, and by what marks can they be distinguished?" In answer to that question, I would point to three things that belong to their character:
First, They are those who have had the very same love that reigns in heaven planted as a seed within their hearts, in this life, through the work of regeneration. They are not those whose hearts contain nothing beyond natural instincts, or whatever they inherited from their first birth, for "that which is born of the flesh is flesh." Rather, they are those who have experienced the new birth, who have been born of the Spirit. A glorious work of the Spirit of God has been accomplished in their hearts, renewing them by bringing down from heaven, as it were, some of that light and some of that holy, pure flame that fills that world of love, and giving it a home within them. Their hearts are the soil in which this heavenly seed has been sown, where it takes root and grows. And so they are transformed: once earthly in their inclinations, they have become heavenly. The love of the world has been put to death in them, and the love of God has been planted in its place. Their hearts are drawn toward God and Christ, and for their sake overflow toward the saints in humble, spiritual love. "Being born again, not of corruptible seed, but of incorruptible" (1 Pet 1:23); "who were born, not of blood, nor of the will of the flesh, nor of the will of man, but of God" (John 1:13).
Second, they are those who have freely chosen the happiness that flows from practicing and enjoying the kind of love that exists in heaven, placing it above every other conceivable form of happiness. They understand enough of it to recognize that it is the highest good, and they don't simply concede this point because rational arguments have persuaded them. They know it from the little they have already tasted of it. This is the happiness of love, the beginning of a life defined by love that is holy, humble, divine, and heavenly: love for God, love for Christ, love for fellow believers for God's and Christ's sake, and the enjoyment of the fruits of God's love through holy communion with God, with Christ, and with godly people. This is what they genuinely hunger for. Their renewed nature is such that this kind of happiness fits their disposition, their desires, and their deepest longings more fully than anything else, not merely more than what they currently possess, but more than anything they can even imagine possessing. The world offers nothing comparable. They have chosen this above everything else, and they have chosen it freely. Their souls reach toward it more than toward anything else, and their hearts pursue it with greater eagerness. Crucially, they haven't chosen it simply because they've encountered suffering, or because their circumstances are so difficult that they've given up expecting much from the world. They chose it because their hearts were so captivated by this good that they embraced it for its own sake, placing it above all worldly goods, even if they could have had those goods in abundance and enjoyed them indefinitely.
Third, Those who have genuine love within them are people who, in heart and life, in principle and practice, are actively striving after holiness. Holy love makes them long for it. It is a principle that thirsts after growth. It exists in imperfection and in a kind of spiritual infancy in this world, and it desires to grow. It has much to struggle against. In the human heart, there are many opposing principles and influences, and love struggles toward greater unity, more freedom, more open expression, and better fruit. The great strife of the new man is directed toward holiness. His heart strives after it because he has a stake in heaven, and so he wrestles with the sin that would keep him from it. He is filled with ardent desires, longings, and strivings to be holy. And his hands struggle just as his heart does. He strives in his practice. His life is one of sincere and earnest effort to be universally and increasingly holy. He feels that he is nowhere near holy enough, not even close; and he desires to draw nearer to perfection, to be more like those who are already in heaven. This is one reason he longs to be there: so that he may be perfectly holy. And the great principle driving him to strive this way is love. It is not fear alone, but love for God, love for Christ, and love for holiness itself. Love is a holy fire burning within him, and like any flame that is partly contained, it will struggle for freedom. That struggle is the struggle for holiness.
3. What has been said on this subject should awaken and alarm those who remain unrepentant. First, by reminding them of their misery: they have no portion or right in this world of love. You have heard what has been said of heaven, what kind of glory and blessedness exists there, and how happy the saints and angels are in that world of perfect love.
But consider that none of this belongs to you. When you hear of such things, you hear of something in which you have no share. No one like you, a wicked hater of God and Christ, someone living under the power of a spirit of hostility toward everything good, will ever enter there. People like you never belong to the faithful Israel of God and will never enter their heavenly rest. What Peter said to Simon applies to you: "Thou hast neither part nor lot in this matter, for thy heart is not right in the sight of God" (Acts 8:21). So does what Nehemiah said to Sanballat and his associates: "You have no portion, nor right, nor memorial, in Jerusalem" (Neh 2:20). If a soul like yours were admitted into heaven, that world of love, how repulsive it would be to those blessed spirits whose souls burn like a flame of love! It would shatter that loving and blessed community and throw everything into disorder. Heaven would cease to be heaven if such souls were admitted there. It would transform from a world of love into a world of hatred, pride, envy, malice, and revenge, just like this present world. But this will never happen, and the only alternative is that people like you will be shut out with "dogs, and sorcerers, and whoremongers, and murderers, and idolaters, and whosoever loveth and maketh a lie" (Rev 22:15), that is, with everything vile, unclean, and unholy. This subject is well suited to awaken and alarm the unrepentant, secondly, by showing them that they are in danger of hell, which is a world of hatred. There are three worlds. One is this present world, which is an intermediate world, a world in which good and evil are so thoroughly mixed together that this mixture itself is a sure sign the world cannot continue forever. Another is heaven, a world of love, entirely without hatred.
And the other is hell: a world of hatred, where love is entirely absent, and the world to which all who remain in a Christless state truly belong. This is the world where God displays His displeasure and wrath, just as He displays His love in heaven. Everything in hell is hateful. There is not a single object there that is not repulsive and detestable, horrifying and loathsome. Nothing in that place is beautiful or lovely, nothing pure, holy, or pleasant. Everything is abominable and odious. The only beings there are devils and damned spirits who have become like them. Hell is, in a sense, a vast den of poisonous, hissing serpents: the ancient serpent who is the devil and Satan, together with his entire hateful brood.
In that dark world, there are none but those whom God hates with a perfect and everlasting hatred. He extends no love and no mercy to a single soul there, but pours out upon them horrors without any mixture of relief. Everything in the universe that is hateful will be gathered into hell, as into a vast receptacle made for precisely that purpose, so that the universe God has made may be cleansed of its filth by casting it all into this great sink of wickedness and misery. It is a world made expressly for the expression of God's wrath. He created hell for this purpose, and He has no other use for it than to testify forever to His hatred of sin and sinners, where no token of love or mercy exists. Nothing there reflects anything but divine indignation and wrath. Every object declares that wrath. It is a world entirely submerged beneath a flood of wrath, like a deluge of liquid fire, so that it is rightly called a lake of fire and brimstone, and the second death.
There is no one in hell who was not, in life, a hater of God, and it is that hatred which brought His wrath down upon them. In hell, that hatred never ends. No love for God will ever be felt there. Every soul in that place hates Him perfectly, completely, and without restraint, blaspheming and raging against Him even while gnawing their tongues in agony. And though they are united in their opposition to God, there is no fellowship or solidarity among them. They agree on nothing except hatred, and the expression of it. They hate God, Christ, the angels, and the saints in heaven; but they also hate each other, like a pit of serpents and vipers, spitting venom not only at God but at one another, biting and stinging and tormenting each other without end.
The devils in hell will hate the damned souls there. They hated them in this world, which is precisely why they pursued their destruction with such cunning and relentless temptation. They thirsted for those souls because they despised them. They longed to get them in their power so they could torment them. They stalked them the way a roaring lion stalks its prey. And the moment those souls were separated from their bodies, the devils fell upon them like hellhounds, burning with eagerness to inflict pain. Now that they have them in their grip, they will spend eternity tormenting them with every ounce of cruelty and strength that devils possess, tearing at these poor damned souls without pause or mercy. And the damned will not only be hated and tormented by devils; they will show no love or pity toward one another either. They will be to each other what devils are to them, tormenting one another to the fullest extent of their power, like burning brands in a fire, each one feeding the flames that consume the rest.
In hell, every principle opposed to love will reign and rage without restraint, with no moderating grace to hold any of it in check. There will be unbounded pride, malice, envy, revenge, and conflict in full fury, without end and without peace. The miserable inhabitants will tear at and devour one another, while also standing as enemies to God, to Christ, and to every holy being. Those who shared a kind of carnal friendship in their wickedness on earth will find no trace of fellowship there. What will exist between them is perfect, unrelenting, and undisguised hatred. Just as they once encouraged each other's sins, they will now intensify each other's suffering. On earth they were instruments of each other's ruin, stoking the fires of each other's lusts; in hell they will stoke the fires of each other's torments forever. They destroyed one another through sinning, through bad examples and poisonous conversation, and now they will be just as consumed with tormenting each other as they once were with tempting and corrupting each other.
And there, their hatred, envy, and every evil passion will become a torment to themselves. God and Christ, whom they will hate most intensely, and toward whom their souls will burn as full of hatred as a furnace is full of fire, will remain infinitely beyond their reach, dwelling in boundless blessedness and glory that nothing they do can diminish. Their bitter envy of the saints and angels in heaven will accomplish nothing except to deepen their own anguish, since they can neither approach nor harm those they despise. No pity will come to them from any quarter, for hell is regarded only with revulsion, never with compassion. And so they will be left to spend their eternity together.
Now consider carefully, all of you who are outside of Christ: you who have never been born again, never experienced the blessed renewal of your hearts by the Holy Spirit planting divine love within you, never been led to choose holy love as your greatest and sweetest good, and never spent your life striving after holiness. Consider your danger, and what lies ahead of you. This is the world to which you are condemned, the world to which you belong under the sentence of the law, the world where every day and every hour you risk having your eternal home fixed forever. This is the world you will soon enter, if you do not repent, instead of entering that blessed world of love you have just heard described. Consider, oh, consider, that this is truly your situation. These are not cleverly invented fables. They are the great and terrible realities of God's Word, things that in a short while you will know with everlasting certainty are true. How, then, can you rest in the state you are in? How can you go about so carelessly from day to day, so heedless and negligent of your precious, immortal souls? Take these things seriously, and be wise for yourself before it is too late, before your feet stumble on the dark mountains and you fall into the world of wrath and hatred, where there is weeping and wailing and gnashing of teeth, where spiteful malice and rage against God, against Christ, and against one another reign forever, and where horror and anguish of spirit never end. Flee to the stronghold while you are still prisoners of hope, before the door of hope is shut, before the agonies of the second death begin their work, and your eternal doom is sealed.
4. Let the reality of heaven, as we have described it, move us all to pursue it earnestly. If heaven is truly such a blessed place, then let it be our chosen homeland, the inheritance we look for and actively seek. Let us turn our lives in that direction and press on toward claiming it. It is not impossible for us to obtain this glorious world. It is being offered to us. As magnificent and blessed as it is, God stands ready to grant us an inheritance there, if only we desire it, choose it, and seek it with genuine effort. God gives us the freedom to choose. We may have our inheritance wherever we set our hearts, and we can obtain heaven if we will simply pursue it through patient, faithful perseverance in doing good. In a sense, all of us have been placed here in this world as if in a vast wilderness, with different countries surrounding it and various roads leading to each one, and we are left to decide which direction we will take. If we sincerely choose heaven and set our hearts fully on that blessed Canaan, that land of love, and if we embrace and love the path that leads there, we may walk that path; and if we keep walking it, it will bring us to heaven at last.
Let everything we have heard about the land of love stir us to turn our faces toward it and set our course in that direction. Isn't what we've heard about the happiness of that country, and the countless delights it holds, enough to make us thirst for it? Shouldn't it drive us, with the greatest earnestness and unwavering resolve, to press toward it and spend our entire lives traveling the road that leads there? What joyful news it is to hear of a world of perfect peace and holy love, and to know that it is not only possible but fully within our reach to arrive there and spend eternity in its joys. Isn't what we have heard of that blessed world enough to make us weary of this one: a world of pride, malice, and endless conflict; a world of confusion; a wilderness of hissing serpents; a stormy ocean where there is no rest, where everyone lives for themselves, where selfishness reigns, where all are striving to lift themselves up with no regard for what becomes of others, where everyone grasps after worldly gain as the great prize of desire and competition, and where people are constantly harassing, slandering, insulting, and otherwise wounding one another. This is a world full of injustice, oppression, and cruelty; a world riddled with treachery, falsehood, fickleness, hypocrisy, suffering, and death; a world where trust in other people is scarce, where even the best of men carry serious flaws that make them difficult to love and hard to be around, and where sorrow, guilt, and sin appear in every conceivable form.
Truly, this is an evil world, and it will likely remain so. It is pointless to expect anything different: this will always be a world of sin, of pride and hostility and conflict, and therefore a world without rest. And though times may improve in certain seasons, these realities will persist in the world to some degree as long as it endures. Who, then, would be satisfied with making this world his home? What person, thinking clearly and carefully, would devote himself to accumulating wealth here, rather than letting the world go to whoever wants it, and instead pouring all his heart and strength into laying up treasure in heaven and pressing on toward that world of love? What does it profit us to hoard great possessions in this life? How can the thought of having our portion here bring us any satisfaction, when we are offered a share in something as glorious as heaven, and especially when choosing our portion here means that once this world has passed away, we will spend eternity in hell, that world of hatred and the unending wrath of God, where only devils and the damned reside?
We all naturally long for rest and peace, and if we truly want to find it, we should set our sights on that world of peace and love we have been considering, where a sweet and blessed rest awaits God's people. If we secure our place in that world, then when we are finished with this one, we will leave behind all our cares, troubles, exhaustion, confusion, and conflict forever. We will rest from the storms raging around us now, and from every burden and struggle, in the paradise of God. If you are poor, and feel looked down on by your neighbors and overlooked by the people around you, don't let it consume you. Don't set your heart on the friendship of this world; seek heaven instead, where contempt doesn't exist, where no one is despised, and where every person is deeply honored and cherished by all. If you feel you have been wronged and mistreated by others, don't dwell on it. Don't let bitterness take root; instead, fix your heart on heaven, that world of love, and press on toward that better country where everything is kindness and holy affection. On the question of how to seek heaven, consider this first direction: don't let your heart chase after the things of this world as though they were your greatest good. Don't indulge yourself in earthly possessions as though they could satisfy your soul. That is the opposite of seeking heaven; it is walking in the direction directly away from the world of love. If you want to seek heaven, your affections must be pulled away from worldly pleasures. You must not give yourself over to sensuality, materialism, or the pursuit of worldly enjoyment and status. You must not fill your thoughts and time with accumulating the dust of the earth. You must put to death the desire for empty recognition, and instead become poor in spirit and humble in heart.
Second, In your meditations and spiritual disciplines, you must actively engage with heavenly persons, realities, and joys. You cannot consistently seek heaven without directing your thoughts there. Turn the current of your thoughts and affections toward that world of love, toward the God of love who dwells there, and toward the saints and angels at Christ's right hand. Let your mind dwell on the objects and enjoyments of that world of love. Commune deeply with God and Christ in prayer, and think often of all that heaven contains: the friends who are there, the praise and worship offered there, and everything that will constitute the blessedness of that world of love. "Let your conversation be in heaven."
Third, Be willing to press through every difficulty on the way to heaven. The path lies open before you, and you may walk it if you choose, but it is a path that climbs steadily upward, filled with obstacles and hardships. That glorious city of light and love stands, as it were, on the summit of a high mountain, and there is no road to it except by steep and demanding steps. Yet however difficult the ascent, and however full of trials the journey, it is worth enduring all of it for the sake of arriving and dwelling in such a glorious city at last. Be willing, then, to take on the labor, face the hardship, and push through the difficulty. What does any of it amount to, compared with the sweet rest waiting at the end of your journey? Be willing to resist the natural pull of flesh and blood, which always draws downward, and press onward and upward toward the prize. With every step, the climbing will grow a little easier, and the higher you ascend, the more you will be encouraged by the glorious prospect ahead and by a closer view of that heavenly city where, before long, you will rest forever.
Fourth, keep your eyes fixed on Jesus throughout your journey, for He has gone to heaven as your forerunner. Look to Him. Behold His glory there, and let that vision stir in you a deeper longing to arrive. Look to Him as your example, and consider how He went before you to heaven through patient perseverance in doing good and patient endurance of great suffering. Look to Him as your mediator, and trust in the atonement He has made, entering into the holiest place in the heavenly temple. Look to Him as your intercessor, who pleads for you before the throne of God without ceasing. Look to Him as your strength, trusting that by His Spirit He will enable you to press forward and overcome every obstacle along the way. Trust in His promises of heaven to those who love and follow Him, promises He confirmed by entering heaven Himself as the head, representative, and Savior of His people. And, Fifth, if you want to be on the road to the world of love, then live a life of love: love toward God, and love toward others. All of us hope to share in that world of love one day, and so we should nurture a spirit of love and live a life of holy love here on earth. This is how you become like the inhabitants of heaven, who are now forever confirmed in love. Only in this way can you share in their excellence and beauty, and share, too, in their happiness, rest, and joy. By living in love in this world, you may also be like them in sweet and holy peace, and so enjoy, even here on earth, a foretaste of heavenly pleasures and delights. In this way, too, you may gain a sense of the glory of heavenly things: of God, of Christ, of holiness itself. Your heart, opened and prepared by holy love toward God and by a spirit of peace and love toward others, will grow sensitive to the excellence and sweetness of everything that heaven holds. The windows of heaven will, in a sense, be thrown open, and its glorious light will pour into your soul. You will find in this the evidence of your readiness for that blessed world, and the assurance that you are genuinely on the path toward it. And being made fit, through grace, for the inheritance of the saints in light, when a few more days have passed, you will be with them in their blessedness forever. Happy, three times happy, are those who are found faithful to the end and then welcomed into the joy of their Lord. There "they shall hunger no more, neither thirst any more; neither shall the sun light on them, nor any heat. For the Lamb which is in the midst of the throne shall feed them, and lead them to living fountains of waters, and God shall wipe away all tears from their eyes" (Rev 7:16-17).