Christian Directory 1. Walking with God

Richard Baxter

N.B. The following text was freely provided by Updated Works. Their updated books and audios are superb in every way.

"Some of the most important ideas in history are locked away in old books that modern readers struggle to understand. Archaic language, unfamiliar phrasing, and outdated conventions create unnecessary barriers to timeless wisdom.
"Updated Works exists to change that. We take significant older texts and translate them into clear, contemporary English while faithfully preserving the author's original meaning and voice. Our goal is simple: make important books readable again.
"Archaic spelling, obsolete words, and tangled sentence structure are rendered into clear, contemporary English--always preserving the author's meaning, voice, and line of argument. We modernize the language, never the message."

Please visit their website to purchase select hardcopy books and audio books: Updated Works.

 

Publisher’s Introduction

A Christian Directory is Richard Baxter’s attempt to answer, in one book, the question a minister is asked all day long: what should I actually do? Published in 1673, it is a sum of practical theology and cases of conscience, not a treatise on doctrine but a manual for living, written by a man who had spent twenty years being consulted. This volume contains the first part, Christian Ethics, which treats a person’s private duties: how an unconverted sinner may come to grace, how a young Christian may be established, and how anyone may walk with God in a life of faith and holiness. Baxter writes as a casuist. He divides, he numbers, he anticipates the objection, and he answers it, and that structure carries the argument as much as the prose does.

 

The Introduction

The eternal God made humanity as an intellectual and free agent, capable of understanding and choosing good, refusing evil, knowing, loving, and serving the Creator, and by adhering to him through this life of trial, attaining the blessed sight and enjoyment of his glory in the life to come. God has not failed to furnish us with whatever is necessary for these ends to be successfully pursued. When we lost our moral capacity to please him, and so to enjoy him, he restored it through the wonderful work of redemption. In Christ he has reconciled the world to himself, and has granted a general act of pardon contained in the covenant of grace, of which nothing but a person’s own obstinate and final unwillingness can deprive them.

To secure our consent to this gracious covenant, God has "committed" to his ministers the "word of reconciliation," commanding us "to beseech men, as in the stead of Christ, and as though God himself did beseech them by us, to be reconciled unto God" (2 Cor 5:18–20). We are to show people first their sin and misery, then proclaim and offer the true remedy, and make known that all things are now ready, and by pleading their duty, their necessity, and their benefit, to compel them to come in Matthew 22:4 Luke 14:17, 23.

Yet so great is the blindness and stubbornness of humanity that most refuse consent. Deceived by the pleasures, profits, and honors of the present world, they make their alleged necessities and business the substance of their excuses, and the unreasonable grounds of their refusal, negligence, and delay, until death surprises them and the door is shut. Then they knock and cry for mercy and admittance when it is too late (Matt 25:10–12).

Against this willful negligence and presumption, which is the principal cause of the damnation of the ungodly world, I have already written many books. But because there are many who sincerely profess themselves willing, not only to be saved, but to be Christ’s disciples, to learn from him, to imitate him, to be conformed to him, and to do the will of God if they could but know it, I have determined, by God’s assistance, to write this book for their use. My aim is to give them from God’s Word those plain Directions suited to the several duties of their lives, to guide them safely in their walk with God to life eternal.

Do not expect here extensive and earnest exhortations, that work I have already done. I now address those who say they have been made willing and desire help against their ignorance, so that skill and will may together advance their salvation. I will labor to speak as plainly as possible, since I write especially for the ignorant; yet I must also be adequately precise in the Directions, lest such readers lose the benefit through misunderstanding. I must address many cases, because I write for families, where not all are in the same condition, and the same persons are not always the same. If I were not brief in the particulars, I would be too long in the whole, and tediousness might deprive some readers of the benefit.

In families, some are (too commonly) ungodly, in a carnal, unrenewed state, and some are godly, in a state of grace. These may be considered as Christians simply, with respect to God, or in their relations to others. These relations are either ecclesiastical, civil, or domestic.

Cicero preserved Socrates’ account of the same twofold state: there are two ways, he held, and a twofold course for souls departing from the body. For those who have defiled themselves with human vices and given themselves wholly to their lusts there is a devious road, shut off from the council of the gods; but for those who have kept themselves whole and chaste, who have had the least contact with the body and have always called themselves away from it, and who in human bodies have imitated the life of the gods, there lies open an easy return to those from whom they set out (Tusculan Disputations, book 1). It can go well with no wicked man, he wrote elsewhere (Paradoxa 1).

If mind, faith, virtue, and concord are found in the human race, he asked, from where could these flow down to earth except from above? Since counsel, reason, and prudence are in us, the gods must have these same things in greater measure, and must not only have them but use them in the greatest and best of matters (On the Nature of the Gods, book 2). And if it is punishment and the fear of penalty, rather than baseness itself, that deters a man from an injurious and criminal life, then no one is unjust and the wicked are merely to be counted incautious; if we are moved to be good men not by what is honorable in itself but by some advantage and profit, we are cunning, not good. For what will that man do in the dark who fears nothing but a witness and a judge? (On the Laws, book 1).

As it makes no difference whether no one is healthy or no one can be healthy, so Cicero could not see what difference it makes whether no one is wise or no one can be (On the Laws, book 3). Yet he was afraid to speak openly what he knew of the unity of the eternal God, the maker of all: to find him who is, as it were, the parent of this universe is difficult, he wrote, and when you have found him, to declare him to the crowd is forbidden (On the Universe).

Accordingly, my intended method is: 1. To direct ungodly, carnal minds how to attain a state of grace. 2. To direct those who already have saving grace how to use it, both in the contemplative and active parts of their lives; in their duties of religion, both private and public; in their duties toward others, both in their ecclesiastical, civil, and family relations. And along the way, to direct those who have grace how to discern it and take comfort in it, and to direct them how to grow in grace and persevere to the end.

If any reader should be discouraged by the number of duties and directions set before them, I ask them to consider two things.

1. It is God, and not I, who imposes all these duties on you. Who will question his wisdom, goodness, or authority to make laws for us and for all the world?

2. Every duty and direction is a mercy to you, and therefore should be a cause not of grief but of gratitude. They are like the commands of parents to their children when they say, "Eat your food, wear your clothes, go to bed, do not eat poison, do not wallow in the mud, do not cut your fingers, take care near fire and water." To remove any such law or duty would be to deprive you of an excellent mercy.

You would not cut off or cast away any member of your body, any vein, sinew, or artery, on the grounds that their number makes them troublesome, since reducing that number would kill or cripple you. A student is not offended that he has many books in his library; nor a tradesman that he has an abundance of tools; nor the wealthy man at the number of his farms or flocks.

Believe it, reader: if you do not bring a quarrelsome and hostile spirit, you will find that God has not burdened but blessed you with his holy precepts, and that he has not appointed you a single unnecessary or unprofitable duty, only such as tend to your contentment, joy, and happiness. As Acosta observes, God is willing in a manner to suffer a kind of violence, and it is the height of his beneficence that he wills to be knocked at and importuned in order to do good.

O let it be the daily, earnest prayer of both writer and reader, that our hearts prove not false and unwilling to follow the Directions given us, lest we condemn ourselves in the very things we approve. Your practice will now show whether it has been from lack of will or lack of skill, if from this point on you unfaithfully neglect your duty. If you are willing, obey now what is plainly taught you, and demonstrate by your diligence that you are willing.

 

CHAPTER 1

DIRECTIONS TO UNCONVERTED SINNERS FOR THE ATTAINING OF TRUE SAVING GRACE

 

If ungodly, miserable sinners were as few as the devil and their self-love would have them believe, I might omit this part of my work as unnecessary. The whole need not the physician, but the sick. If you go into twenty families and ask them all whether any are in an unsanctified state, unrenewed, unpardoned, and under the wrath and curse of God, you will find few who will not tell you they hope things are better with them than that. Though they are sinners, as all are, they consider themselves repenting, pardoned sinners. Indeed, scarcely one among even the most wicked and notoriously ungodly fails to hope that he is in a penitent and pardoned state. Even those who hate God will say they love him; scorners at godliness will say they are not ungodly, and that it is mere hypocrisy and singularity they mock. It would be well for them if saying so could pass for proof, and if the one who will judge them would take their word.

But God will not be deceived, though foolish men are clever enough to deceive themselves. Wickedness remains wickedness however fair a name it clothes itself in; God will condemn it however plausible its pretenses and excuses. Though the ungodly think to brazen it out in pride and scorn, and expect to be saved by their hypocritical lip-service as readily as the most holy worshippers of the Lord, yet "shall they be like chaff which the wind driveth away: they shall not be able to stand in judgment, nor sinners in the congregation of the righteous." (Ps 1:4–6)

If God knows better than foolish men, then certainly the flock is small to whom the "Father will give the kingdom." (Luke 12:32) "Wide is the gate, and broad is the way that leadeth to destruction, and many there be that go in thereat: because strait is the gate, and narrow is the way which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it" (Matt 7:13–14). When Christ was asked, "Lord, are there few that be saved?" he answered, "Strive to enter in at the strait gate; for many I say unto you, will seek to enter in, and shall not be able." But we need no further information than common experience to tell us whether the greater part of men are holy and heavenly, self-denying, seeking first the kingdom of God and his righteousness, loving God above all, and willing to forsake all they have for the sake of Christ. And undoubtedly none but such are saved, as you may see. (Heb 12:14 Matt 6:20–21 Matt 6:33)

Since the godly are so few and the ungodly so many; since God will accept nothing as holiness that is not truly such; and since it is so terrible a thing for any person with their wits about them to live even one day in an unconverted state, for whoever dies in that state is lost forever, it ought to be our wisdom to be suspicious of ourselves, careful not to be deceived in so grave a matter, and diligent in searching and examining our hearts to see whether they are truly sanctified. To make sure work of our salvation can do no harm, whereas presumption, carelessness, and negligence may betray us to irremediable misery and despair.

I do not here suppose the reader to have any such acquaintance with his own heart, any such care for his salvation, or any such obedient willingness to be taught and governed by Jesus Christ as belongs to those who are truly sanctified, for it is ungodly persons to whom I am now speaking. Yet if I were to suppose them to have no capacity or disposition to make use of the directions I give, I might as well pass them by and spare my labor. I tell you, therefore, reader, what I presuppose in you and expect from you; and I think you will not judge my suppositions and expectations unreasonable.

1. I suppose you to be a human being, and therefore to have reason and natural free will, that is, the natural faculty of choosing and refusing, which ought to keep your appetites in check. I suppose you capable of loving and serving your Creator, and of enjoying him in everlasting life.

2. I suppose you know yourself to be a human being; and therefore that your appetites, or the flesh, ought no more to rule you or go ungoverned by you than a horse should rule its rider or go without a rider’s guidance. I suppose you understand that you were made expressly to love and serve your Maker, and to be happy in his love and glory forever. If you do not know this much, you do not know that you are human, or else you do not know what a human being is.

3. I suppose you to have a natural self-love and a desire for your own preservation and happiness; that you have no desire to be miserable, or to be hated by God, or to be cast out of his favor and presence into hell, there to be tormented with devils everlastingly. I will indeed suppose that you are not indifferent whether you dwell in heaven or hell, in joy or torment, but earnestly wish to be saved and to be happy. Whether you are godly or ungodly, wise or foolish, I will take all this for granted; and I trust that in doing so I do you no wrong.

4. I suppose you to know that you did not make yourself, nor give yourself whatever power or wisdom you possess; and that he who made you and all the world must have existed before all the world, and is therefore eternal, having no beginning, for if there had ever been a moment when nothing existed, nothing would ever have existed, since nothing can produce nothing. I suppose you acknowledge that all the power, wisdom, and goodness of the whole creation combined is less than the power, wisdom, and goodness of the Creator, since nothing can give more than it possesses.

I suppose, then, that you acknowledge there is a God; for to be the eternal, infinite Being, most powerful, most wise, most good, and the first cause of all created being, power, wisdom, and goodness, this, together with the consequent relations to the creature, is to be God. If you deny that there is a God, you must deny that you are human, and that there is any human being or any being at all. We see, Cicero says, that the comforts we use, the light we enjoy, and the very breath we draw are given and imparted to us by him; and it is from his works that we come to know God (Cicero, Pro Roscio Amerino, and Tusculan Disputations, book 1).

5. I suppose you know that God, who gave being to all things, is by the title of creation the absolute Owner and Lord of all. He who made rational creatures with natures fitted to be governed, in view of a further end, is by that same title their supreme Governor, and therefore has his laws commanding duty, promising reward, and threatening punishment; and therefore will judge human beings according to those laws, with justice in his judgments and his rewards and punishments. And he who freely gave the creature its being and all the good it has, and must give it all that it shall ever have, is the Father, the most bountiful Benefactor, to his creatures. Surely I am not asking too much in supposing you to know all this, for all this amounts to no more than that there is a God. He is not God if he is not the Creator, and therefore our Owner, our Ruler, and our Benefactor, our absolute Lord, our most righteous Governor, and our most loving Father.

6. I suppose, therefore, that you are convinced God must be submitted to and obeyed absolutely above all others in the world, and loved above all friends, pleasures, and creatures whatever. To say "He is my Owner" is to say "I must yield myself to him as his own." To say "I acknowledge him as my supreme Governor" is to say "I will be absolutely ruled by him." To say "I take him as my dearest Father and chief Benefactor" is to say "I am obliged to give him my dearest love and highest gratitude." Otherwise you are either jesting, speaking without understanding, or contradicting yourself when you say "He is your God."

7. I suppose you are easily convinced that there is no creature in all the world that can show so full a claim upon you as God, or that has so great an authority to govern you, or that can be so good to you or do so much for you as God can and has done and will do, if you do your part. There is therefore nothing to be preferred before him, or compared with him, in our obedience or love; nor is there anyone who can save us from his justice if we hold out against him.

Cicero writes that there is no nation so savage, and no person so brutal, whose mind has not been touched by some awareness of the gods. "I had rather believe all the fables in the Legend, and the Talmud, and the Alcoran, than that this universal frame is without a mind." Lord Bacon, Essay 16. "A little philosophy inclineth a man’s mind to atheism: but depth in philosophy bringeth men’s minds about to religion." Lord Bacon, Essay 16.

8. God is just in his laws and judgments, faithful enough that he will not deceive mankind, and all-sufficient enough that he has no need to. Governing by mere deceit suits the devil, not God. Since God governs humanity on earth through the hopes and fears of another life, he does not delude people into those hopes and fears. And since he does not use rewards or punishments in this life as his principal means, the wicked prosper here, while the best are persecuted and afflicted, his rewards and punishments must come principally in the life to come.

For if he has no rewards and punishments, he has no judgment; if no judgment, no laws, or else no justice; if no laws and no justice, he is no governor of humanity, or no righteous one; and if he is not our righteous governor, he is not our God, and if he were not our God, we would never have been his creatures, nor had any being at all.

Even the heathens held that the world is governed by the will of the gods, that it is a kind of common city and commonwealth of gods and human beings, and that punishments are prepared in the world below for the impious. Cicero speaks of Jove as the ruler of all things, governing everything by his nod, and, in Ennius’s phrase, "father of gods and of men," a god present and all-powerful; and he adds that anyone who doubts it might as well doubt whether the sun exists (Cicero, De Finibus 3, De Inventione 1, and De Natura Deorum 2, quoting Ennius).

9. Even if God had disclosed nothing about what he intends for us in the life to come, humanity would still be most deeply obligated to obey and love its Maker, because he is our absolute Lord, our highest ruler, and our chief benefactor, all that we are or have comes from him. If we are bound to spend our lives in his service, we can be sure we will not lose by it, not even by the costliest obedience we can offer. God cannot appoint us anything that is in vain, nor can he treat us worse than an honest employer who ensures that a worker is not left out of pocket. Therefore the God for whom we must spend and forsake this life, and all the pleasures that those devoted to the senses enjoy, certainly has something greater to give us in another life.

10. I may take it as established, at the very least, that neither you nor any unbeliever in the world can claim to be certain there is no life after this, a life in which present obedience will be rewarded and disobedience punished. The most an unbeliever has ever been able to say is that he thinks there is no other life. None can deny its possibility, nor with any reason deny its probability. Keep that in mind as we press a little further.

11. Reason and experience both show the brevity and emptiness of all the glory and pleasures of the flesh. They pass so quickly that, even if they were greater than they are, they could be of no considerable value. What is time? It goes in an instant, and when it is gone, everything that passed with it is nothing. The joys and sorrows of so short a life are no great gain or loss in the end.

It follows easily that the bare probability or possibility of an endless happiness should be valued infinitely above such passing vanity, above the greatest things this world can offer. Equally, the probability or possibility of endless misery in hell should engage us with far greater care and diligence to avoid it than we owe to avoiding anything we might hope to escape through sinning, or any suffering this brief life can bring. To fail to see this is to have lost your reason: the mere probability or possibility of a heaven and hell should command our care and diligence far more powerfully than the fading vanities of this fleeting, dreamlike life.

12. We have now reached this point in the clearest light. A religious and holy life is every person’s duty, not only because we owe it to God as our Creator, owner, governor, and benefactor, but also because, as people who love themselves, our own reason commands us to give ten-thousandfold more attention to a probable or possible joy and torment that are endless than to anything small and short-lived. And if a holy life truly is everyone’s duty in view of the life to come, it follows most plainly that such a life to come is real indeed, more than probable or possible, but certain.

For if it is humanity’s duty to order this life by the hopes and fears of another life, then either that other life exists, or God has made it our duty to hope, fear, strive, and labor entirely in vain; and has himself taunted and cheated his creatures, ruled the world by motives of deceit, and made religion and obedience to our Maker a life of folly, delusion, and loss. Anyone who believes that of God scarcely believes him to be God at all. Though I have made this argument in another treatise, I do not think it out of place to repeat it here for your benefit.

13. Supposing you are now convinced that the life to come is real and that human happiness and misery lie there, you must also confess that everything in this life, prosperity or adversity, honor or dishonor, is to be valued and used with reference to that coming life. Nothing is more obvious than that means are to be estimated entirely in terms of their end. Whatever tends toward the happiness of our endless life is good in this life; whatever tends toward our endless harm and deprives us of everlasting good is truly evil in this life. No price or inducement, therefore, should move us to sin against God and forfeit or obstruct our endless happiness.

14. If you have reason, you will agree that God cannot be loved too much, obeyed too exactly, or served too diligently, especially by such reluctant sinners as we are, who have scarcely any inclination to love or worship him at all. No one can be too certain of heaven, pay too high a price for it, or do too much for his salvation, so long as what he does is what God has appointed. Nothing else is so worthy of your time, love, care, and labor. You may need to be restrained in your love, care, and labor for the world, because there you can easily pay too much and do too much. But no one needs restraining in love, care, and labor for God and salvation, which is worth more than we can ever do, and in which even the best of us are inclined to fall short.

15. I also suppose you know that this present life is given to us as a time of trial, to prepare for the life that follows; that as people live here, so they will fare forever; and that time, once gone, cannot be recalled. We should therefore make the best use of it while we have it.

16. You will also readily agree that, since humanity has reason and life for matters of everlasting consequence, our thoughts of those matters should be frequent and serious, and our reason should be brought to bear on them through quiet, sober deliberation.

17. And I take it that, being a person, you are sufficiently acquainted with yourself to know, if you are willing, whether your heart and life answer your convictions, and whether they are more oriented toward heaven or toward earth. You are therefore capable of judging yourself in this matter.

Perhaps you will object that in directing you to be holy I am already assuming you to be holy, since all of the above seems to go a long way toward it. But I see nothing in any of these suppositions that I could not equally suppose to be present in a heathen, I think all of it amounts to no more than supposing you to have the use of your reason in the matters at hand. Speak plainly: is there a single point among all these that you can or dare deny? I think there is not. If heathens and wicked men deny them in their practice, that only shows how sin degrades them, and how, like people asleep or lost in a rush of business, they make no use of the reason they actually possess when their minds are turned away from what matters most.

18. One more thing I think I may suppose in all or most who will read this book: that you also profess to believe in Jesus Christ, and in the Holy Spirit as Sanctifier, and that the Scriptures are the Word of God. If you do so truly, I may hope that my work is in a sense done before it begins. But if your profession is merely a matter of opinion and produces no real effect, God and man may still hold you accountable to the truths you confess.

Having told you what I presuppose about you, I now proceed to the Directions. But I again earnestly entreat and charge you, reader, as you love your soul and would not be condemned for hypocrisy and sloth, do not refuse to put into practice what is here taught you, and so show that, whatever you may claim, you are not genuinely willing to do your own part for your salvation, not even in the most reasonable and necessary things.

Even the light of nature has said much of this. Cicero observed that while nature cast the other living creatures down toward their pasture, it raised the human being alone upright and roused him to the sight of the heavens, as of his kindred and his first home, shaping his face so as to portray in it the character hidden deep within; that unless God frees us from the guardhouse of the body no entrance there can lie open to us; that the minds of the wisest and bravest citizens seem to have passed out of the life of men into the religion and holiness of the gods; and that the soul is implanted in us by God, so that our kinship with the heavenly ones may truly be called a relation, a race, or a stock (Cicero, De Legibus 1, Somnium Scipionis, and Pro Rabirio).

He says too that all things return to the place from which they arose; that he believes the immortal gods scattered souls into human bodies so that there might be those who would care for the earth, and who, contemplating the order of the heavenly things, would imitate it in the measure and constancy of their own lives; and that human beings stand on the earth not as its tenants and inhabitants but as spectators of the higher and heavenly things, a sight that belongs to no other kind of living creature. Nor, he adds, would such a power, taking thought for the human race, beget or nourish a creature that, having drained every labor, should then fall into the everlasting evil of death (Cicero, De Senectute, De Natura Deorum 2, and Tusculan Disputations 1).

Direction 1. ‘If you are truly willing to be sanctified and to become a child of God, do not remain in a state of ignorance; but do your best to come into the light, and to understand the Word of God in the matters of salvation.’

If knowledge were unnecessary, why do we have understanding? And in what way does a person excel a beast? Whoever comes to know himself will know all things in himself: God, in whose image he was made; the world, whose likeness he bears; and all the creatures with which he has something in common (Paulus Scaliger).

If any knowledge at all is necessary, it must certainly be knowledge of the greatest and most necessary things, and nothing is so great and necessary as obeying your Maker and saving your soul. Knowledge is to be valued according to its usefulness. If knowing how to conduct worldly business, to trade and accumulate earthly wealth, to understand the laws, and to maintain your reputation were as important as knowing how to be reconciled to God, to receive pardon and justification, to please your Creator, to prepare in time for death and judgment, and to enter an endless life, then let worldly wisdom have the pre-eminence. But if all earthly things are dreams and shadows, valuable only as they serve us on the way to heaven, then heavenly wisdom is surely the best.

How far is that person from being truly wise who is acquainted with every legal technicality, who is excellent in languages, sciences, and arts, and yet does not know how to live to God, to mortify the flesh, to conquer sin, to deny himself, to give account in judgment for his fleshly life, or to escape damnation! Such a learned person is as far from wisdom as he is from happiness.

Two kinds of people among us quietly live in a state of damning ignorance.

First, a great many poor people who think they may continue in ignorance because they were bred in it, who suppose that because they are not book-learned they need not learn how to be saved, and that because their parents neglected to teach them when they were young, they may neglect themselves ever after and need not learn the things they were made for.

What do you have your life, your time, and your reason for? Do you think it is only to know how to do your worldly business? Or is it to prepare for a better world? It would be better not to know how to eat, drink, speak, walk, or dress yourself, than not to know the will of God and the way to your salvation. Hear what the Holy Spirit says: "But if our gospel be hid, it is hid to them that are lost: in whom the god of this world hath blinded the minds of them which believe not, lest the light of the glorious gospel of Christ, who is the image of God, should shine unto them" (2 Cor 4:3–4).

Darkness is unsafe and full of fear; light is safe and comforting. A person in ignorance can never find his way, nor can he know whether he is on or off the right path, or what enemy or danger is near. The devil is the prince of darkness, and his kingdom is a kingdom of darkness (Eph 6:12 Col 1:13 1 John 2:11 Luke 11:34–35). Grace turns people from darkness to light (Acts 26:18), and causes them to cast off the works of darkness (Rom 13:12), because we are children of light and of the day, not of darkness or of night (1 Thess 5:5). Those who were once darkness are light in the Lord when they are converted, and must walk as children of the light (Eph 5:8).

In the dark the devil and wicked people may deceive you and do almost whatever they please with you. You would not buy your goods in the dark, nor travel or work in the dark, and will you judge the state of your soul in the dark, and do the work of your salvation in the dark? The devil could never draw so many souls to hell if he did not first put out the light, or put out their eyes. People would never follow him in crowds to everlasting torment if they could see clearly and go with open eyes. If people truly understood what they are doing when they sin, and where a carnal life is taking them, they would quickly stop and go no further. All the devils in hell could not draw so many souls there if human ignorance did not give such an advantage to temptation.

The second kind of ignorant person among us is the sensual gentleman or the scholar who has enough education to understand the words and speak somewhat better than the ruder sort, but who has in truth never known the nature, reality, and goodness of the things they speak of. Many of them are as ignorant of the nature of faith, of sanctification, of the working of the Holy Spirit in planting the image of God upon the soul, of the saint’s communion with God, and of the nature of a holy life, as if they had never heard or believed that any such thing exists. Nicodemus is a vivid instance of this: a ruler in Israel, a Pharisee, and yet he did not know what it meant to be born again. And the pride of such people makes their ignorance far harder to cure than other men’s, because it prevents them from recognizing and confessing it.

It is a remarkable and grievous thing to consider how ignorant some people remain, even into old age, under constant and excellent preaching. Some learn neither the words nor the meaning, but hear as though they heard nothing. Some learn the words but grasp the meaning no better than if they had learned only an unknown language; they can repeat their creed and catechism without knowing what they are saying. A respected minister of Helvetia told me that his people attend their sermons very faithfully and yet most of them are grossly ignorant of the very things they most frequently hear. It is almost incredible what ignorance some ministers report finding even in the eldest members of their congregations. Indeed, when I have examined some who professed a strictness in religion above the common sort, I have found some ignorant of the very fundamentals of the Christian faith.

I recall what an ancient bishop of some twelve hundred years ago, Maximus Taurinensis, says in his homilies: that after he had long preached to his people, one evening after a sermon he heard a cry or noise among them, and on listening he found they were shouting to help deliver the moon, which they believed was in labor and needed assistance. This story is also cited by Papirius Massonus, in his life of Pope Hilary, page 67.

Such people react with scorn, as the Pharisees to Christ, saying "Are we blind also?", and are ready to mock those children of the light who are wise to salvation, because those believers differ from these men’s loose or hypocritical opinions in some matters of God’s worship. These men are about as competent to judge such matters as the Pharisees were to judge the doctrine of Christ, as Nicodemus to understand regeneration, or as Simon Magus, Julian, or Porphyry to judge the gifts of the Holy Spirit. These honored but miserable men will bear no contradiction or reproof. Who would dare be so rude, disobedient, or bold as to tell them they are heading away from heaven and are strangers to it, not to say enemies of it, and to presume to turn them from the path to hell, or prevent them from damning themselves and as many others as they can draw along?

Paulus Scaliger says in his Thesaurus that whoever repents of having sinned is nearly innocent, and that the greatest part of purgation is a voluntary repentance of one’s faults. Cicero, in his speech against Vatinius, says that those are more readily pardoned who labor not to persist in a fault but to recall themselves from their error; for to sin is human, but to persist in error is brutish. And Lactantius, at the opening of his Institutes, says there is no sweeter food for the mind than the knowledge of truth.

They think that any serious talk of Christ, grace, and eternal life, anything unlike their own talk in its form, levity, or scorn, is merely the troublesome narrowness of hypocritical, eccentric, half-crazed men. Of the godly they say as the Pharisees said: "Are ye also deceived? Have any of the rulers, or of the Pharisees believed on him? But this people who knoweth not the law are cursed." (John 9:40 John 7:47–49)

Well, whether gentleman or commoner, whoever you are who does not welcome the things of the Spirit but lives in ignorance of the mysteries of salvation, know this: heavenly truth and holiness are works of light and never prosper in the dark. Your best understanding ought to be used for God and your salvation, if for anything at all. It is the devil and his deceits that fear the light. Simply understand well what you are doing, and then try to remain wicked if you can, try to set Christ and holiness at nothing if you dare.

Come out of darkness into the light, and you will see what will make you tremble to live another day ungodly and unconverted. You will see what will make you lament with penitent remorse your long neglect of heaven, and wonder that you could live so long and so far out of your senses, choosing a course of vanity and degradation in the chains of Satan over the joyful liberty of the saints. And though we must not be so impolite as to tell you plainly where you are and what you are doing, you will then call yourselves, with harsher plainness, "exceedingly mad, and foolish, disobedient, deceived, serving divers lusts and pleasures" (Rom 8:5–7, 13), as one man did who had thought himself beforehand as wise and good as any of you. Do not live on in a sleepy state of ignorance, if you ever desire saving grace. (Acts 26:11 Titus 3:3)

Direction 2. ‘Especially, labor first to understand the true nature of a state of sin and a state of grace.’

You are likely to say that all people are sinners, that Christ died for sinners, that you were regenerated in your baptism, and that for the sins you have committed since then you have repented, and so you hope they are forgiven.

But pause a moment and understand the matter carefully as you go, for your salvation is at stake. It is quite true that all are sinners. But it is equally true that some are in a state of sin and some in a state of grace; some are converted sinners and some unconverted; some live in sins incompatible with holiness, which in that sense may be called mortal, while others have only infirmities that are consistent with spiritual life, which in this sense may be called venial. Some hate their sin and long to be perfectly delivered from it; others love it so much that they are loath to leave it. Is there no difference, do you think, between these?

It is equally true that Christ died for sinners, for where else would our hope be? But it is also true that he died to "save his people from their sins," and "to turn them from darkness to light, and from the power of Satan unto God," and "to redeem us from all iniquity, and purify to himself a peculiar people zealous of good works." It is true that "except a man be born again, and converted, and become as a little child," in humility and beginning the world anew, "he cannot enter into the kingdom of heaven." And the very one who died for sinners will at last condemn the workers of iniquity, saying, "Depart from me, ye cursed, into everlasting fire," "I never knew you." (Matt 1:21 Acts 26:18 Titus 2:14 John 3:3, 5 Matt 18:3 Matt 25:41 Matt 7:23)

It is quite true that you were sacramentally regenerated in baptism, that "he that believeth and is baptized shall be saved," and that all who are children of the promise and have that promise sealed to them by baptism are regenerate. The ancient teachers held that baptism places people in a state of grace, that is, all who sincerely renounce the world, the devil, and the flesh, and are sincerely given up to God the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit according to the covenant of grace, and who profess and seal this by their baptism, shall be pardoned and made heirs of life.

But just as it is true that baptism thus saves, it is equally true that it is not the "outward washing only the filth of the flesh" that will suffice, but "the answer of a good conscience towards God." (1 Pet 3:21) And "no man can enter into the kingdom of God, that is not born of the Spirit, as well as of water." (John 3:5) Simon Magus and many another have received the water of baptism who never received the Spirit, but still remained in the "gall of bitterness, and bond of iniquity," and had "no part nor lot in that business, their hearts being not right in the sight of God." (Acts 8:13, 21, 23)

And nothing is more certain than that "if any man have not the Spirit of Christ," notwithstanding his baptism, "he is none of his." (Rom 8:9) And if you do have his Spirit, you "walk not after the flesh, but after the Spirit," and are "not carnally but spiritually minded," and are "alive to God," and as "dead to the world." (Rom 8:1, 5–8, 10, 13, 14) Whether all who have been baptized are such people when they reach adulthood, judge for yourself.

It is also true that if you truly repent, you are forgiven. But it is equally true that genuine repentance is the very conversion of the soul from sin to God, and it does not leave any man in the power of sin. It is not enough for a man, once he has wrung all the pleasure he can from a sin, to wish then that he had not committed it, which is easy enough to wish at that point, while still keeping hold of those sins that remain pleasant and profitable to his flesh. This is like a man who throws away the bottle he has drunk empty but keeps the one that is still full, or like those who sell off their barren cows and buy milking ones in their place. That kind of repentance is a mockery, not a cure for the soul.

If you have true repentance, it has so thoroughly turned your heart from sin that you would not commit it again even if the same temptations were before you; and it has so thoroughly turned your heart toward God and holiness that you would live a holy life all over again, even with the same temptations against it as before. This is the nature of true repentance. Such repentance is indeed never too late to save, but it never comes too soon either.

Mark well, then, I urge you, what a state of sin is, and what a state of holiness is.

The person who is in a state of sin has, habitually and predominantly, a greater love for some pleasures, profits, or honors of this world than he has for God and the glory God has promised. He prefers, seeks, and holds, if he can, his fleshly prosperity in this world over the favor of God and the happiness of the world to come. His heart is turned from God to created things and is set principally on earthly things. In this way his sin is the blindness, madness, faithlessness, and idolatry of his soul, his forsaking of God and his salvation for a thing of nothing. It is to his soul what poison, death, sickness, lameness, and blindness are to his body.

It is the same kind of treatment of God as that of a man who hates his dearest friend or father, prefers the company of a dog or a toad far above his, and obeys his enemy against him. It is like the behavior of a madman toward his physician, seeking to kill the doctor as an enemy because the doctor crosses his appetite or will in order to cure him. Think carefully on this, and then tell me whether this is a state to continue in. This state of sin is something far worse than a single thoughtless act of sin committed by one who otherwise lives an obedient, holy life.

On the other side, a state of holiness is nothing other than the habitual and predominant devotion and dedication of soul, body, life, and all that we have to God: esteeming, loving, serving, and seeking him above all the pleasures and prosperity of the flesh; making his favor and everlasting happiness in heaven our end, Jesus Christ our way, and referring everything in the world to that end, making this the design and purpose of our lives. It is a turning from a deceitful world to God; preferring the Creator over the creature, heaven over earth, eternity over a moment of time, our souls over our corruptible bodies, and the authority and laws of God, the universal Governor of the world, over the word or will of any person, however great.

It is a subjecting of our sensory faculties to our reason, and raising that reason by divine revelation; living by faith and not by sight. In a word, it is a laying up of treasure in heaven, setting our hearts there, living in a heavenly manner, setting our affections on things above and not on things that are on earth, and rejoicing in hope of the glory to come, while those who live only for the senses have nothing but transitory, brutish pleasures in which to rejoice.

This is a state and life of holiness. When we persuade you to be holy, we persuade you to nothing worse than this. When we commend a life of godliness to your choice, this is the life we mean and commend. Can you understand this clearly and still be unwilling? It cannot be. Simply know well what godliness and ungodliness, what grace and sin truly are, and the work is nearly done.

Direction 3. "To know what a life of holiness is, believe the Word of God and those who have experienced it; and do not believe the slanders of the devil and of ungodly men, who have never tried or known the things they reproach."

Reason cannot question the reasonableness of this counsel. Who is wiser than God? Who is more to be believed than he? And who is more likely to know what they speak of than those who speak from their own experience? Nothing is more common among wicked men than to slander and reproach the holy ways and servants of the Lord. No wisdom, no measure of holiness or righteousness will exempt the godly from their malice. Otherwise, Christ himself at least would have been exempted, if not his apostles and other saints, whom his enemies slandered and put to death.

Christ foretold us what to expect from them: "If the world hate you, ye know that it hated me before it hated you. If ye were of the world, the world would love his own: but because ye are not of the world, but I have chosen you out of the world, therefore the world hateth you. Remember the word that I said unto you, The servant is not greater than the Lord. If they have persecuted me, they will also persecute you: if they have kept my sayings, they will keep yours also." (John 15:18–20)

The truth is, wicked men are the seed and children of the devil; they bear his image, obey him, and think, speak, and act as he would have them. The godly are the seed and members of Christ, bearing his image and obeying him. Do you think the devil will tell his children to speak well of the ways or followers of Christ? I must confess that, until I had found it true by experience, I did not fully grasp how bold in lying and how cruel in abusing the servants of Christ his worldly, malicious enemies are.

I had read often of the early enmity placed between the woman’s seed and the serpent’s seed. I had read and marveled that the first man born into the world murdered his brother for worshipping God more acceptably than himself, "because his own works were evil, and his brother’s righteous" (1 John 3:12). I had read the inference: "Marvel not, my brethren, if the world hate you" (1 John 3:13), and yet I did not fully understand how very alike, and how closely related, wicked men and devils are, until the words of Christ, expounded by visible demonstrations, taught it me.

The apostle says (1 John 3:12) that Cain was of that wicked one, that is, the devil. But Christ says it more plainly: "Ye are of your father the devil, and the lusts of your father ye will do: he was a murderer from the beginning, and abode not in the truth, because there is no truth in him: when he speaketh a lie, he speaketh of his own; for he is a liar, and the father of it." John 8:44 Note here that cruel murder and lying are the chief actions of a devil; and that, as the father of these sins, he is the father of the wicked, who are most notoriously given to these two courses against the most innocent servants of the Lamb. How fitting it will be that those who are so alike in disposition and action here should dwell together hereafter, even as the righteous shall dwell with Christ, whose image they bore and whose holy, suffering life they imitated.

I conclude, then, that if you will never turn to God and a holy life until wicked men stop lying about and reproaching them, you may as well say that you will never be reconciled to God until the devil is first reconciled to him; that you will never love Christ until the devil loves him, or tells you to love him; that you will never be a saint until the devil is a saint, or gives you permission; and that you will not be saved until the devil is willing that you be saved.

Direction 4. "That your understanding may be enlightened and your heart renewed, be much and serious in reading the Word of God and those books fitted to people in an unconverted state, and especially in hearing the plain and searching preaching of the Word."

There is a heavenly light, power, and majesty in the Word of God which, in the serious reading or hearing of it, may pierce the heart, prick it open so that corruption may go out and grace come in. "The law of the LORD is perfect, converting the soul: the testimony of the LORD is sure, making wise the simple: the statutes of the LORD are right, rejoicing the heart" (Ps 19:7–8). Moreover, "by them is thy servant warned: and in keeping of them there is great reward" (Ps 19:11).

The eunuch was reading the Scripture when Philip was sent to expound it to him for his conversion (Acts 8). The preaching of Peter pierced many thousands to the heart for their conversion (Acts 2:37). The heart of Lydia was opened to attend to the preaching of Paul (Acts 16:14). "The word of God is quick and powerful, and sharper than any two-edged sword, piercing even to the dividing of soul and spirit" (Heb 4:12). These "weapons are mighty through God, to the pulling down of strong holds; casting down imaginations, and every high thing that exalteth itself against the knowledge of God, and bringing into captivity every thought to the obedience of Christ" (2 Cor 10:4–5).

Have you often read and heard already, and yet find no change in your heart? Read and hear again and again. Ministers must not give over preaching when they have labored without success; why then should you give over hearing or reading? As the farmer labors and looks to God for rain and for the blessing, so must we, and so must you. Look up to God. Remember that it is his Word in which he calls you to repentance, offers you mercy, and deals with you concerning your everlasting happiness. Lament your former negligence and disobedience, beg his blessing on his Word, and you will find it will not be in vain.

The serious reading of books that expound and apply the Scriptures, suited to your condition, may also, by the blessing of God, be effective for your conversion. I have myself written so many to this purpose that I will be briefer on this subject here, and ask you to read them, or some of them, if you have no better at hand: A Call to the Unconverted; A Treatise of Conversion; Now or Never; Directions for a Sound Conversion; A Saint or a Brute; A Treatise of Judgment; A Sermon against Making Light of Christ; A Sermon of Christ’s Dominion; Another of his Sovereignty, etc.

Direction 5. ‘If you would not be without saving grace, let your reason be exercised about the matters of your salvation, with a frequency, sobriety, and seriousness proportionate to the weight of the matter.’

To have reason is common to all people, even the sleepy and distracted. To use reason is common to all whose senses are awake and fit to serve their minds. To use reason in the greatest matters is proper to wise people who know why God made them rational. Unthinking people are all ungodly people, for reason left unused is as bad as no reason at all, and will prove far worse in the day of reckoning.

The truth is this: though sinners are deeply blind and mistaken about the things of God, yet all God’s precepts are so reasonable, and so clearly tend toward our joy and happiness, that if the devil did not win most souls by silencing reason, laying it asleep or drowning its voice with the noise and crowd of worldly business, hell would not have so many sad inhabitants. I scarcely believe that God will condemn any sinner who ever lived in the world and had the use of reason, not even the heathens who had but one talent, without being able to say to them, as in Luke 19:22, "Out of thine own mouth will I judge thee, thou wicked servant: Thou knewest," etc.

To serve God and labor diligently for salvation, preferring it above all worldly things, is so reasonable a course that everyone who repents of the contrary calls it from his heart an impious madness. Reason must be for God, who made it. Reason must be for that which is its proper end and use. Sin, as it resides in the understanding, is nothing but unreasonableness, a blindness and error, a loss and corruption of reason in the matters of God and our salvation. And grace, as it resides in the understanding, does nothing but cure this folly and distraction and make us rational again. It is simply the opening of our eyes and the making of us wise in the greatest matters. It is no more unmanly to love and plead for blindness, madness, and disease, and to hate sight, health, and sound judgment, than it is to love and plead for sin while hating and despising a holy life.

The Word itself stirs reason, and preachers are by reason to expose all sin as unreasonable. The lack of such stirring, through powerful preaching, plain teaching, and personal reflection, is a great cause of the world’s ruin. As for those preachers who lay all the blame on the people’s stupidity or malice, I direct them to a satisfying answer in Acosta the Jesuit (book 4, chapters 2, 3, and 4). Comparatively few souls perish where all the means that should be used by those in authority for their people’s salvation are actually used. If every parish had holy, skilled, and diligent pastors willing to do their part both publicly and privately, great things might be expected.

But Acosta says, in effect: "The chief cause comes back to ministers who are poorly suited to the work. What is our preaching? What is our confidence? We perform no signs; we do not stand out in holiness of life; we do not draw people through generosity; we do not persuade through the power of the Word and the Spirit; we do not obtain results from God through tears and prayers; indeed, we scarcely concern ourselves with these things at all. What complaint, then, do we have? What great accusation can we lay against the people?" An honest confession of the Roman priesthood, and such priests can expect no better outcome. Yet having seen another kind of minister, through God’s mercy, I have seen a corresponding fruit of their labors.

Grant me just this one thing: that you will soberly exercise your reason about these great and weighty questions, Where must I abide forever? What must I do to be saved? What was I created and redeemed for?, and I shall hope that your own understanding, erroneous as it is, will work out something that will promote your good. Withdraw yourself one hour a day from company and other business, and consider your end and life as soberly and seriously as you know the nature and weight of the matter requires, and I am persuaded that your own reason and conscience will call you to repentance and set you, at the very least, on a far better path than you were on before.

When you walk alone, or when you lie awake in the night, remember soberly that God is present, that time is hastening to its end, that judgment is at hand, where you must give account of all your hours, your lusts, passions, and desires, all your thoughts, words, and deeds, and that your endless joy or misery depends wholly and certainly on this brief time. Think soberly on such things for just one hour a day, and see whether it will not recover you to wisdom and godliness. Folly and sin will vanish before the force of deliberate reason as darkness vanishes before the light.

I entreat you now, as in the presence of God and as you will answer for the refusal of so reasonable a request at the day of judgment, to resolve to try this course of sober, serious reflection about your sin, your duty, your danger, your hope, your account, and your everlasting state. Try it at times, especially on the Lord’s Day, and simply mark the result. Notice where such sober reflection points and leads you: whether it is not toward a diligent, holy, heavenly life. If you refuse me even this much, God and your conscience will bear witness that you counted your salvation of little worth, and you may justly be denied it.

Would it not be strange if a person were penitent and godly who had never once thought about the matter with any seriousness? Can so many and so great diseases of the soul be cured before you have once soberly considered that you have them, how great and dangerous they are, and by what remedies they must be healed? Can grace be obtained and exercised while you never so much as think of it? Can the main business of our lives be done without any serious thought, when we think it right to spend so many thoughts on the trivial affairs of this world?

Does the world and the flesh deserve to be remembered all day, all week, all year, and does not God and your salvation deserve to be thought of one hour a day, or one day a week? Judge these things as a person of reason. If you expect that God, who gave you reason to guide your will and a will to command your actions, should carry you to heaven like a stone, saving you against your will or without it, before you ever once soberly thought about it, you may have leisure in hell to lament the folly of such expectations.

Direction 6. ‘Do not allow the devil, through company, pleasure, or worldly business, to divert or hinder you from these serious reflections.’

The devil has only two ways to secure your damnation. The first is to keep you from any sober remembrance of spiritual and eternal things. The second is, if you will think of them, to deceive you into false and erroneous thoughts. To accomplish the first, which is the more common and powerful method, his ordinary tool is diversion: always finding you something else to do, putting other thoughts into your mind and other work into your hand, so that you can never find time for any sober thought of God. Whenever the Spirit of God knocks at your door, you are so taken up with other company or other business that you cannot hear, or will not open to him.

Many a time the Spirit has been ready to teach you, but you were not at leisure to hear and learn. Many a time he has quietly stirred your conscience, checked you in your sin, and called you aside to consider soberly your spiritual and everlasting state, only for the noise of foolish mirth and pleasures, or the commotion of encumbering cares and business, to cause you to stop your ears, put him off, and refuse the motion. And if the grieved Spirit of God departs and leaves you to your beloved mirth and business, and to yourself, it is only just. Then you will perhaps never have a serious, effectual thought of heaven until you have lost it, nor a sober thought of hell until you are in it, unless it be some despairing thought, or some dull and ineffectual one.

Even learning and honest studies may be used as a diversion from more necessary things. As Petrarch writes in his own life: his mind was fitted for every good and wholesome pursuit, especially moral philosophy and poetry, which he himself later neglected as time went on, having found delight in the sacred Scriptures, in which he discovered a hidden sweetness he had once despised, and reserving his literary studies only for ornament.

So then, as you love your soul, do not love your pleasure or business so much that you refuse to attend to the Spirit of God, who comes to offer you greater pleasures and to engage you in far more important work. Set everything aside and listen for a while to what God and conscience have to say to you. They have greater business with you than anyone else you deal with, and better offers to make than any of your old companions. If the devil can keep you occupied, with one pleasure one day, another business the next, and distract you from the work for which you came into this world until time has run out and you have slipped unwittingly into damnation, then he has achieved his aim and won the day, and you are lost forever.

No doubt you set some limits on your foolishness and plan to live this way for only a short while. But when one pleasure fades, the devil will supply a fresh one; and when one pressing business is finished that gave you occasion to plead necessity, another will follow, and then another and another, until you keep imagining you still face some necessity, until time is gone and you see, far too late, how thoroughly you were deceived.

Resolve, therefore, that no company, pleasure, or business will fool you out of your salvation or draw you away from attending to the one thing necessary. If company claims a right to your time, ask whether it is better company than the Spirit of God and your conscience. If pleasure would detain you, ask whether it is a purer and more lasting pleasure than what you may enjoy in heaven by hearkening to grace. If business still pleads necessity, ask whether it is a greater business than preparing your soul and your account for judgment, or of greater necessity than your salvation. If not, do not give it priority. If you are wise, do first what must be done, and set aside what can most easily be spared. What does it profit you to gain the whole world and lose your soul? And even if you dared to claim that your pleasure and business were better than heaven, surely you could sometimes lay them aside and think seriously about your salvation.

Direction 7. If you would be converted and saved, do not be a hostile or resentful enemy to those who seek to convert and save you. Do not be angry with people who tell you of your sin or duty, as though they were wronging or harming you.

God works through instruments. When he intends to convert a Cornelius, he sends a Peter who is willingly heard. When he means to recall and save a sinner, he ordinarily provides some public minister or private friend to be the messenger of searching and convincing truth, fitted to awaken, enlighten, and recover the soul. If God furnishes these instruments with compassion for your souls and a willingness to instruct you, and you choose to treat them as enemies, quarreling irritably with them, contradicting them, perhaps reproaching them, and doing them harm in return for their goodwill, what an inhuman and ungrateful course is this? Will you be angry with people for trying to save you from the fire of hell? Are they seeking any gain or advantage for themselves, or simply trying to help your souls to heaven?

If their efforts served some ambitious design of their own, as the pope and his clergy seek to bring the world under their own jurisdiction, you would have good reason to suspect their motives. But Christ has purposely appointed his greatest church officers to be ministers, that is, servants of all: to rule and save people as volunteers, without coercive power, by bringing his powerful word to bear on their consciences; to beseech and entreat even the poorest of the flock, not as lords over God’s heritage or masters of their faith, but as their servants in Christ and helpers of their joy (1 Pet 5:2–4).

By this arrangement, whenever ministers deliver their message, it is plain that they exercise no dominion and aim at no worldly honor, gain, or advantage for themselves, but only at the conversion and salvation of souls (2 Cor 10:4 2 Cor 5:19–20 2 Cor 1:24 1 Cor 4:1 2 Cor 3:6 2 Cor 11:23 Joel 1:9–13 2 Cor 4:5 Mark 10:44 Matt 20:27 Luke 22:24–26).

Had Christ instead authorized his ministers to exercise authority as the rulers of the Gentiles, to be addressed as gracious lords, and to involve themselves in worldly affairs, their teaching would have been rejected by the greater part of the world. They would always have labored under the grave disadvantage of appearing to seek not the people themselves but their possessions, to preach not for others but for themselves, making a prize of those they addressed. The Jesuits, when they attempt the conversion of the Indians, still find this to be their greatest obstacle: the princes and people assume they use the Gospel as a pretext for subjugating them and their lands to the pope, since they tell the people that submission to the pope is necessary for salvation.

Now, when Christ has appointed a poor, self-denying, entreating ministry, against whom none of these objections can plausibly be raised, to stoop to your feet with the most humble entreaties that you would simply turn to God and live, you have no excuse for your own ungrateful hostility in turning against them, treating them as enemies, and taking offense at their efforts to save you. You know that ministers can hold their positions and livings by smooth, cold, and vague preaching just as well as by more faithful dealing, if not better. You know they gain no worldly advantage by dealing plainly with you. You know they risk their reputation with people like you by doing so, and they cannot be unaware that such honesty is likely to earn them your ill will and indignation.

They are human beings just as you are, and therefore they naturally desire goodwill and kind words from others, and take no pleasure in being scorned or hated. Without question, they overcome much temptation and resistance of the flesh before they can deny themselves enough to pursue your salvation on such terms. And since it is all for your sake, you above all others ought to be their chief encouragers. If others oppose them, you should support them, because they are for you. If I advance with a convoy to relieve a besieged garrison, I expect resistance from the enemy besieging it, but if the besieged themselves shoot at us and treat us as enemies for risking our lives to relieve them, it is time to withdraw and let them take what they get by it.

Perhaps you think the preacher or private admonisher is too blunt with you. But consider that self-love is likely to make you a poor judge of your own case, and therefore far less reliable a judge than they are. Seneca writes that it was as necessary for the Roman people that a Cato should be born as a Scipio: the one waged war with our enemies, the other with our morals (Seneca, Epistles 88). Consider also that God has commanded them to speak plainly, and has warned them that if they fail to do so, the people’s blood will be required at their hands (Isa 58:1 Ezek 18). God knows best what medicine and treatment your condition requires. The matter is of such immense consequence, whether you will spend eternity in heaven or hell, that it is almost impossible for a minister to be too plain or too serious with you.

Your condition is also so stubborn that gentler means have been tried too long without success, and sharper ones must therefore be attempted. Otherwise, why have you not been converted by gentler dealing before now? If you faint or are close to drowning, you will allow bystanders to handle you somewhat more roughly than usual, and will not bring a complaint against them for laying hands on you or disheveling your fine clothes. If your house is on fire, you will permit people to speak in a manner quite different from polished, civil conversation.

Perhaps you think they are presumptuous in judging you to be unconverted when you are not, or in counting you worse and in greater danger than you are, and speaking harder of you than you deserve. But you ought to be the most suspicious of yourself in so weighty a matter, and most afraid of being deceived. A bystander may see more than someone caught up in the game. Certainly one who is awake may see more of you than you can see of yourself while you are asleep.

But suppose it were exactly as you imagine: it is his love that mistakenly attempts your good; he means you no harm; your salvation is what he desires, your damnation what he would prevent. You have every reason to love him and be thankful for his goodwill, not to be angry with him and reproach him for his mistakes. He is nothing like those who bring people before the inquisition and would fine, imprison, banish, burn, hang, or torment you in order to convert and save you.

The worst he does is speak words that, if true, you are deeply concerned to heed, and if mistaken, can do you no harm unless you yourself are the cause. If he speaks in public preaching, he speaks in general descriptions, not by naming you, no more of you than of others in the same condition, and not of you at all if you are not in that condition. If he speaks to you privately, you yourself are the only witness, and so there is no disgrace involved. Never, then, pretend that you are willing to be converted and saved, when in fact you hate those who would promote it, are angry with everyone who tells you of your condition, and could find it in your heart to silence them or do them harm.

Direction 8. "If you are truly willing to be converted, do your best to discover that you are in fact still unconverted and in a lost and miserable state."

Who will work to cure a disease they do not believe they have? Who will try to purge a poison they think they never swallowed, or think is no poison at all? Who will try to climb out of the ditch who does not know they are in it? Who will turn back if they cannot be persuaded they have taken the wrong road? Who will labor to be converted if they think they are converted already? Who will come to Christ as the physician of their soul if they think they are not sick, or are already cured?

The common reason people live and die without the repentance, sanctification, and justification that would save them is that they refuse to believe they lack these things. They are convinced they are already penitent, justified, and sanctified. I have no wish to make any of you think worse of your condition than it actually is; but if you will not know what your condition is, you will not be prepared for recovering grace, nor will you seek the means of your own recovery. You think it so grim a conclusion to find yourselves in a state of condemnation that you are extremely unwilling to know it or acknowledge it.

But please consider just two things. First, either it is true that you are in so miserable a state, or it is not true. If it is not true, the closest examination will only comfort you by showing that you are already sanctified. But if it is true, do you think remaining ignorant of your danger will save you? Will it cure your disease to believe you do not have it? Will thinking well of yourselves without grounds prove that you are actually well? Is it the path to grace to think you have it when you do not? Will it bring you to heaven to think you are headed there when you are on the road to hell? And do you not know that one of the devil’s chief strategies for keeping people from repentance and salvation is to deceive them in precisely this way, to persuade them they are already in a state of grace?

Think soberly about this. If every impenitent, unconverted sinner in the world were certain that they were in a graceless state, from which, if they died in it, there was no hope, do you not think they would quickly look to themselves, come to understand the offers of a Savior far better, and live in continual concern and fear until they found themselves in a safer condition? Bernard, in his work On the Steps of Humility (Step 8), describes how people make excuses for their sins: "If possible, they will say, I did not do it; or else, It was no sin, but lawful; or else, I did not do it often or to any great degree; or else, I meant no harm; or else, I was persuaded by another, and drawn into it by temptation."

If you were certain that you must either become a new creature or be damned, would that not drive you to seek grace far more earnestly than you ever have? The devil knows this well enough. He could scarcely keep you quietly in his snares through a single night; before morning you would be ready to repent, beg for mercy, and resolve on a new life, if only you were sure you were still in a state of condemnation. That is precisely why he does everything he can to hide your sin and danger from your eyes, and to quiet you with the notion that, though you are sinners, you are already penitent, pardoned, and safe.

Now, there can be no harm in knowing the truth. Will you therefore examine yourselves to see whether you are unsanctified or not? You were baptized in the name of the Holy Spirit as your Sanctifier; if you now neglect or mock sanctification, what are you doing but deriding your baptism, or disregarding the very substance and purpose of it? It concerns you far more to know whether sanctification has made you spiritually alive to God than simply to know that you are alive by nature.

And let me offer you this encouragement: we are not calling you to acknowledge that you are unconverted, unpardoned, and miserable as people who have no remedy and must sit down in despair, tormented by foreknowledge of endless pain before the time comes. No, we call you to this knowledge so that you may quickly and gratefully accept Christ, the full remedy, turn to God, and swiftly leave your sin and terror behind, entering a life of safety and peace. We do not want you to continue in the life that tends toward despair and horror; we would have you out of it if it were in our power before tomorrow. That is why we want you to understand what danger you are in, so that you will go no further but turn back at once and seek help. There is no harm, though there may be some present discomfort, in a discovery of danger such as this.

Very well. If you are willing to know what you are, let me help you find out.

1. If you persecute, hate, or mock people for being diligent and serious in God’s service, for being careful not to sin, and for refusing to go along with the crowd in doing evil, or if you do not love such people and would not rather be like them than be the greatest among the ungodly, that is a certain sign you are in a state of spiritual death (Gal 4:29 Acts 26:11 1 Tim 1:13 1 Pet 4:2–5 Ps 15:4 1 John 3:8–15 John 13:35 Ps 84:10).

2. If you love the world most, fix your affections chiefly on things below, and are most concerned with earthly matters, if you do not seek first God’s kingdom and his righteousness, if your heart is not set on heaven and your affections on the things above, and if you do not value your hope of eternal life above all the pleasures and prosperity of this world, that is a certain sign you are merely worldly and ungodly (Matt 6:19–21, 33 Phil 3:18–20 Col 3:1–4 Ps 73:25 1 John 2:15–17 Jas 1:27 Luke 12:20–21 Luke 16:25).

3. If your valuation of, belief in, and hope for everlasting life through Christ is not strong enough to move you to deny yourself and forsake father and mother, your closest friends, your house and land and life and everything you have, for Christ’s sake and for the hope of eternal happiness, then you are no true Christian and are not in a state of saving grace (Luke 14:26, 33 Matt 10:37–39 Matt 13:21–22).

4. If you have not been converted, regenerated, and sanctified by the Spirit of Jesus Christ, the Spirit who makes you spiritual and causes you to set your mind on the things of the Spirit above the things of the flesh, if that Spirit is not in you and you do not walk after it but after the flesh, making provision for the flesh to satisfy its desires and choosing to please the flesh rather than to please God, then it is certain you are in a state of spiritual death (Matt 18:3 John 3:3, 5–6 Heb 12:14 Rom 8:1, 5–13 Rom 13:13–14 Luke 16:19, 25 Luke 12:20–21 Heb 11:25–26 2 Cor 4:16–18 2 Cor 5:7 Rom 8:17–18).

5. If there is any known sin in you that you do not hate, if you do not genuinely prefer to leave it rather than keep it, do not pray and strive and watch against it as far as you can see it in yourself, but instead make excuses for it, plead on its behalf, desire it, and are reluctant to give it up, so that your will is habitually more in favor of it than against it, this is a mark of an impenitent and unrenewed heart (1 John 3:3–4, 6–10, 24 Gal 5:16, 19–25 Rom 7:22, 24 Rom 8:13 Luke 13:3, 5 Matt 5:19–20 2 Tim 2:19 Ps 5:5 Luke 13:27).

6. If you do not love God’s Word as a light that exposes your sin and your duty, but only as general truth, or as something that rebukes other people, if you do not welcome the most searching preaching, have no wish to know how bad you are, and do not come to the light so that your deeds may be made plain, this is a sign that you are not a child of the light but of darkness (John 3:19–21).

7. If the laws of your Creator and Redeemer do not carry the greatest power and authority over you, if the will and Word of God carry no more weight with you than the word or will of any human being, and if God’s threats and promises move you no more than the threats or promises of men, this is a sign that you do not truly take God as your God, but are at heart an atheist and an ungodly person (Luke 19:27 Matt 7:21–23 Matt 7:26 Dan 3:16–18 Dan 6:5 Dan 6:10 Jer 17:5–6 Luke 12:4 Acts 5:29 Ps 14:1).

8. If you have not, in a deliberate covenant or resolution, devoted and given yourself up to God as your Father and your happiness, to Jesus Christ as your only Savior, Lord, and King, and to the Holy Spirit as your Sanctifier, desiring to be made holy by him, longing for your heart and life to be perfectly conformed to God’s will, and wishing to know him, love him, and enjoy him more, then you are empty of godliness and true Christianity. This is the very covenant you made at your baptism, which you call your christening (Matt 28:19–20 2 Cor 8:5 1 Cor 6:17 John 1:10–12 Gal 4:6 Rom 8:14–15).

I have now plainly shown you, and fully proved from the Word of God, by what unmistakable signs an ungodly person may know that he is ungodly, if he is willing to know. Can you not tell, if you are willing, whether the desire and aim of your life is more for this world or for the one to come? Whether heaven or earth is preferred and sought first? Whether your bodily comfort and pleasure, or your soul, is chiefly cared for?

Cicero was inclined to think that if reverence toward the gods is taken away, good faith too, and the fellowship of the human race, and that one most excellent virtue, justice, are taken away with it (Cicero, De Natura Deorum 1).

Can you not know, if you will, whether you love or hate the serious worshippers of God? Whether you would rather be delivered from your sins or keep them? Whether your will is more against those sins or for them? Whether you love a holy life? Whether you would rather be perfect in holiness and obedience to God, or be excused from it and please the flesh? Whether you would rather be someone like Paul, a persecuted saint in poverty and contempt, or someone like Caesar, a persecuting conqueror or king?

Can you not know, if you will, whether you love a searching ministry that tells you the worst and would not deceive you? Can you not know whether you are resolutely devoted and given up to God, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, as your Father and happiness, your Savior and your Sanctifier? And whether the aim, design, and occupation of your life is more for God or for the flesh, for heaven or for earth, which of the two bears sway, and which comes in second and receives only what the other can spare? These things are so close to you, and so observable in your own hearts, that you can come to know them if you are willing. But if you will not, who can help that?

What a foolish objection it is, then, from those ignorant people who, when we tell them these things, ask whether we have ever been to heaven, or ever seen the book of life, and how we can tell who will be saved and who will be damned. If this were about some trivial game, such joking might be more fitting, but to speak so carelessly about the matters of salvation and damnation, and to make a jest of the ruin of souls, is a kind of foolishness that has no excuse.

What if we have never been to heaven, and never seen the book of life? Do you think we have never seen the Scriptures? Wretched sinner, do you not know that Christ came down from heaven to tell us who will come there and who will be shut out? And did he not know what he was saying? Is God the Governor of the world, and has he not given a law by which he governs it? Can I not tell from the law who the Judge will condemn or save? What else is the law for, if not to be the rule of life and the rule of judgment? Read Psalm 1 and Psalm 15, Matthew 5, Matthew 7, and Matthew 25, together with all the passages I have just cited, and see whether God has not told you who will be saved and who will be condemned. See, indeed, whether that is not the very purpose of the Word of God.

Do you think he has written in vain? Some people have loved ignorance and ungodliness so long that the Spirit of grace has withdrawn from them and left them to the dullness of their carnal minds, so that "they have eyes and see not, and ears and hear not, and hearts and understand not." But those who are genuinely willing and diligent to know their sin and their duty, in order to be recovered from them, God will not leave to search in vain, nor hide the remedy from their eyes.

Direction 9. When you have found yourself in a state of sin and death, understand and consider what that state actually is.

You may think it a tolerable condition and linger in it as though you were safe, or delay your repentance as though there were no great urgency, unless you open your eyes, look around you, and see how slippery a place you are standing in. Let me name some aspects of the misery of an unconverted and graceless state, and then judge it as the Word of God directs you.

1. As long as you are unconverted, you must be loathsome and abominable to God. His holy nature is utterly irreconcilable with sin, and would be irreconcilable with sinners too, were it not that he is able to cleanse and purify them. If you truly understood what sin is and what God’s holiness is, you would grasp this far more clearly. Your own aversion to God, and your dislike of the holiness of his laws and his people, might tell you what thoughts he has of you. "He hateth all the workers of iniquity" (Ps 5:5). He regards you as his enemy, and as such he will deal with you if you are not converted. I know that many deeply guilty people, especially those of honor and high standing in the world, would scorn to have that title applied to themselves. But God is not afraid of offending them, nor as protective of their tarnished honor as they are of it themselves, or as they expect the preacher to be.

If those who refuse a king’s government and set up another authority are that king’s enemies, then those who set up the base desires of the flesh, the honor and prosperity of this world, and the will of man, while refusing the government of God their Creator and Redeemer, and refusing the sanctifying work of the Holy Spirit, are the enemies of God, of the Redeemer, and of the Holy Spirit. Read Luke 19:27.

Some find it strange that any person should be called a "hater of God," and I believe you will find it difficult to meet any man who will admit it of himself, until either converting grace or hell compels him to. Indeed, if God himself had not charged people with that sin and called them by that name, we would scarcely have found belief or a patient hearing when we tried to convince the world of it. Simply ask the worst of men to repent of hating God, and observe how they receive it. Yet they may read that name in Scripture (Rom 1:30 Ps 81:15 Luke 19:14).

Did the Jews not hate Christ, when they murdered him? And when they hated all his followers for his sake (Matt 10:22 Mark 13:13)? And does not Christ say that his people will be hated for his sake, not only by the Jews but by "all nations, and all men" (Matt 24:9 Matt 10:22), even by "the world" (John 17:14 John 15:17–19)? And this was a hating of "both Christ and his Father" (John 15:23–24).

But you may say: it is not possible that any person can hate God. I answer: how then did the devils come to hate him? In truth, every ungodly person hates God. No one hates him as good, or as merciful toward them; but they hate him as holy and just, as one who will not allow them the pleasure of sin without damning them, as one committed in justice to cast them into hell if they die without conversion, and as one who has given so pure and exacting a law to govern them, who convicts them of sin, and who calls them to the repentance and holiness that they hate. Why did the world hate Christ himself? He tells you: "The world cannot hate you, but me it hateth, because I testify against it, that the works thereof are evil" (John 7:7). "This is the condemnation, that light is come into the world, and men loved darkness rather than light, because their deeds were evil" (John 3:19).

What is more, it is a marvel of blindness that this God-hating world does not see itself for what it is, a God-hater, when it hates God’s servants to the death, rages against them without mercy, opposes his holy ways and kingdom, and turns the resources of most nations against his people on earth. While the devil wages his war against Christ through the hands of the world, people will acknowledge the devil’s malice against God yet deny their own, as though he used their hands while leaving their hearts untouched.

Poor, wretched creatures! Instead of denying your enmity toward him, lament it, and know that he counts you his enemies and will prove more than a match for you when you have done your worst. Read Psalm 2 and tremble, and submit. This applies above all to persecutors and open enemies, but in their measure also to all who would not have him reign over them. This is precisely why Christ came, to reconcile us to God and God to us, and only those who are sanctified are reconciled to him (Col 1:21 Phil 3:18 1 Cor 15:25 Rom 5:10). "The carnal mind is enmity against God; for it is not subject to the law of God; nor indeed can be" (Rom 8:7). Mark that text well.

2. As long as you remain unsanctified, you are unjustified and unpardoned. The guilt of every sin you have ever committed rests on your account, every sinful thought, word, and deed, the least of which deserves hell, and you yourself must answer for it. What this means, the threatenings of the law will tell you (Acts 26:18 Mark 4:12 Col 1:14). No sin is forgiven to an impenitent, unconverted sinner.

3. Nor is this surprising, since the unconverted have no saving interest in Christ. The pardon and life that God gives are given in and with the Son (Rom 8:9): "God hath given to us eternal life, and this life is in his Son: he that hath the Son, hath life; and he that hath not the Son, hath not life" (1 John 5:10–12). Until we are members of Christ, we have no share in the pardon and salvation he purchased; and ungodly sinners are not his members. Jesus Christ, who is the hope and life of all his own, therefore leaves you exactly as he found you, and that is not the worst of it.

4. It will be far worse for those who impenitently reject the grace of Christ than if they had never heard of a Redeemer. God cannot provide so precious a remedy for sinful, miserable souls and allow it to be despised and rejected without bringing greater punishment upon those who despise it. Was it not enough that you had disobeyed your great Creator? Must you also make light of a most gracious Redeemer who offered you pardon purchased by his blood, if only you would have come to God through him? The very Savior you despised will himself be your Judge, and the grace and mercy you treated so lightly will be the heaviest aggravation of your sin and misery. "How shall you escape, if you neglect so great salvation?" (Heb 2:3). "Of how much sorer punishment (than the despisers of Moses’ law) shall they be thought worthy, who have trodden under foot the Son of God, etc." (Heb 10:29).

5. Even the prayers and sacrifices of the wicked are abominable to God, except those that express genuine turning from wickedness (Prov 15:8 Prov 21:27 Isa 1:13). So terror arises for you from the very thing you expected would be your help.

6. Your ordinary mercies only increase your sin and misery until you return to God. Your unrenewed heart turns everything to sin: "Unto the pure all things are pure: but unto them that are defiled, and unbelieving, is nothing pure: but even their mind and conscience is defiled" (Titus 1:15).

7. While you remain unsanctified, you are powerless and dead to any holy, acceptable work. When you ought to redeem the time, prepare for eternity, examine your spiritual condition, pray, meditate, or do good to others, you have no inclination toward any such spiritual exercises; your mind is set against them (Rom 8:7). Nor is this the pardonable incapacity of those who would do good but cannot; it is the willful incapacity of the wicked, the same as that of devils, who cannot do good because they will not, and will not because they have blind, malicious, and ungodly hearts. This makes their sin all the greater (Titus 1:16).

8. While you have an unsanctified heart, you carry at all times the seed and disposition toward every sin. If you do not commit the worst sins, it is only because some providential restraint keeps the tempter at bay. You deserve no credit for not committing idolatry, blasphemy, theft, murder, or adultery daily, the inclination is in your heart, and will be there whenever temptation and opportunity meet, until you are renewed by sanctifying grace.

9. Until you are sanctified, you are heirs of death and hell (Heb 12:14), living under the curse, already condemned in the court of law even though the final sentence has not yet been pronounced (John 3:18–19 and 3:36). Nothing is more certain than that you would have been damned and lost forever had you died before being renewed by the Holy Spirit, and that this will still be your miserable end if you die unsanctified.

There is one fire of Gehenna in hell, but it does not torment all sinners in one way: each feels as much punishment there as his guilt requires; for as one sun here does not warm all bodies equally, so one fire there burns souls unequally, according to the quality of their crimes (Hugh Etherianus, On the Return of the Soul, ch. 12). Consider, then, what kind of life you have lived until now, and what it means to go on any longer in a condition in which death means certain damnation. Conversion can save you, but unbelief and self-flattery will not rescue you from this endless misery (Heb 2:3 Matt 25:46). "The descent into hell is alike from every side," said Anaxagoras to one who lamented only that he must die in a strange country (Diogenes Laertius, book 2).

10. As long as you remain unsanctified, you are hurrying toward that misery: sin is likely to take deeper root, your heart to grow harder and more hostile to grace, God to be further provoked, and the Spirit further grieved. Every day you draw nearer to your final judgment, when all these things will press upon you with far greater force and clarity (2 Tim 3:1 2 Tim 3:3 2 Pet 2:3).

So I have given you a brief account of the condition of unrenewed souls, only a brief one, because I have treated it more fully elsewhere, in the Treatise of Conversion.

Direction 10. ‘When you have discovered how grave your condition is, consider what there is in sin that could compensate you or make up your loss, anything at all that could justify your delay in converting.’

Surely you will not persist for nothing, if you know it to be nothing, in so dangerous and wretched a situation. And yet you persist for something far worse than nothing, without realizing what you are doing. Sit down sometime and honestly ask yourself: what amends will the world or sin make you for the loss of your God, your soul, and all your hopes, once they are gone beyond recovery? What comfort will it then give you that you were once honored, once wealthy, once ate the finest food, drank from pleasurable cups, enjoyed merry hours, wore fine clothing, and had every such pleasure? Ask whether any of that will dull the horrors of death, turn aside the wrath of God, or reverse the sentence of your condemnation, or whether it will ease a tormented soul in hell.

If it will do none of these things, consider how small, brief, and trivial a gain and pleasure it is that you are buying at so high a price. What can any reasonable person see in it that would make it worth the joys of heaven, or worth enduring everlasting torments? What exactly is it that is supposed to be worth all this? Is it the snare of advancement? Vexing riches? Empty honors? Consuming anxieties? Sensual excess or lust? Brutish pleasures? Or what else are you buying at so astonishing a cost?

How pitiable is the folly of the ungodly! How foolish are sinners, unworthy to see God, and fit for misery! How strangely corrupted is the human heart, that it can sell its Maker, its Redeemer, and its salvation at so low a price!

Direction 11. ‘When you are casting up your account, put into one side of the scales all that sin and the world will do for you, and into the other the comforts both of this life and of the life to come, which you must forfeit for your sins.’

Search the Scriptures and consider how the saints of God are described there. Think what it means to have a purified, cleansed soul; to be free from the slavery of the flesh and its desires; to have the appetites brought under the governance of reason, and reason itself enlightened and corrected by faith; to be alive to God, and disposed and enabled to love and serve him; to have access to him in prayer, with boldness and assurance of being heard; to hold a sealed pardon of all your sins, and a share in Christ, who will answer for them all and justify you; to be a child of God and an heir of heaven; to have peace of conscience and the joyful hope of endless joys.

Think what it means to have communion with the Father, through the Son, by the Spirit, and to have that Spirit dwelling in you and working toward your further holiness and joy; to have communion with the saints, and the help and comfort of all God’s ordinances; to live under his many precious promises, under his protection and provision in his family, and to cast all your care upon him; to delight yourself daily in the remembrance and renewed experience of his love, in your, too limited, knowledge of him and love to him, in the knowledge of his Son, and in the mysteries of the gospel; to have all things work together for your good, and to be able to welcome death with joy, living as if already in heaven in the foresight of your everlasting happiness.

I would have given you here an orderly account of all the privileges of renewed souls, but I have already treated that subject at length in my Treatise of Conversion and Saints’ Rest. This brief taste may help you see what you lose while you remain in an unconverted state.

Direction 12. ‘Having considered the condition you are in, consider also whether it is a condition to remain in for another day.’

If you die unconverted, you are past all hope, for out of hell there is no redemption. You are certain to die before long, and uncertain whether it will be this very night (Luke 12:20). Jo. Benedictus of Paris, in his notes on Luke 12, says that whoever waits for the time of old age to repent is a stranger to faith; and he adds, out of Seneca, that uncertain death overtakes many who go on deferring their lives. You have never laid down to sleep with any assurance that you would rise again; never gone out of doors with assurance of returning; never heard a sermon with assurance of hearing another; never drawn one breath with assurance of drawing the next. A thousand accidents and diseases stand ready to stop your breath and end your time whenever God wills it. And if you die tonight in an unregenerate state, there is no more time, no help, no hope.

Is this, then, a situation a wise person should remain in for a single day, when something can still be done toward recovery? Should you delay another day or hour before falling at the feet of Christ, crying for mercy, returning to God, and resolving upon a better course? May I not say to you, as the angels said to Lot: "Arise, lest thou be consumed: escape for thy life; look not behind thee" (Gen 19:15, 17, 22).

Direction 13. ‘When you are resolved, past all your waverings and delays, give yourself entirely and without reserve to God the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, as your happiness, your Savior, and your Sanctifier, in a wholehearted consent to the covenant of grace.’

This is your Christianity; your betrothal to Christ. It is sacramentally enacted in baptism, but until it is personally owned and heartily renewed by a person who has come to maturity, that person has no reason to count himself among adult believers, or to expect any share in the blessings of the covenant. It is a great pity that this renewal of one’s covenant with God is not treated as a more serious and solemn matter. (I have written toward that end in a Treatise of Confirmation, though so far without effect.) Whatever others do, do it seriously yourself: it is the greatest and most momentous act of your life.

To that end, study carefully the covenant of grace offered to you in the gospel; understand it well. In it, God offers, notwithstanding your sins, to be your reconciled God and Father in Christ, and to receive you as a son and an heir of heaven.

The Son offers to be your Savior: to justify you by his blood and grace, to teach you, and to govern you as your Head, in order to your everlasting happiness. The Holy Spirit offers to be your Sanctifier, Comforter, and Guide, to overcome all the enmity of the devil, the world, and the flesh, in order to the full accomplishment of your salvation. Nothing is required of you for your title to the benefits of this covenant except that you deliberately, sincerely, and entirely consent to it; that you continue in that consent; and that you perform what you consent to perform, and all of this by the help of the grace that will be given you.

See, therefore, that you deliberate carefully over this matter, but without delay. Weigh what you stand to gain or lose. If you find that you are likely to be a loser in the end, and you know of some better way, then take it and boast of it after you have seen the outcome. But if you are past doubt that there is no other way, then resolve upon this one seriously and without hesitation.

Guard against one particular error: do not say, "Why, this is nothing more than what everyone knows, and what I have already done a hundred times, giving myself up in covenant to God the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost." Do you know it, and yet have not done it? Or have you done it with your lips while your heart was not truly in it? If so, lament it as one of your greatest sins that you have dealt so presumptuously with God, and marvel at his mercy that he will still condescend to enter into covenant with one who has so hypocritically profaned his covenant.

If you had ever seriously covenanted and given yourself to God in this way, you would not have gone on neglecting him in an ungodly life, or living afterward for the devil, the world, and the flesh, which were solemnly renounced. The making of this Christian vow and covenant with God in Christ is the act of greatest consequence in your entire life. It is to be done with more judgment, reverence, sincerity, foresight, and firm resolution than anything else you will ever do. If all who make this covenant, even those who do it ignorantly, by fashion, with the lips alone, had done it sincerely, then all who bear the Christian name would be saved. As it is, those who abuse that holy name and covenant will have the deepest place in hell. Write this covenant upon your heart, commit your heart and hand to it with resolution, stand by your consent, and all is yours: conversion is accomplished when this is done.

Direction 14. ‘In immediate fulfillment of your covenant with God, put away your former sinful life. See to it that you sin wilfully no more, and, as far as you are able, avoid the temptations that have deceived you.’

God will never be reconciled to your sins. If he is reconciled to your person, it is as you are justified by Christ and sanctified by the Spirit, he receives you as one who turns in repentance from sin to him. If you wilfully or carelessly continue in your former course of sin, you show that your resolution in the covenant with God was not sincere.

I understand that infirmities and imperfections cannot be shed so easily; they will cling to you even in your best obedience until the day of your perfection comes. But I am speaking of gross and willful sin, the kind you could refrain from if you were but sincerely, however imperfectly, willing.

Have you been a profane swearer or curser, accustomed to taking God’s name in vain, or given to backbiting, slander, lying, or filthy and ribald talk? It is within your power to stop these sins, if only you are willing. Do not say that you fall into them through force of habit before you are aware; for that is a sign that you are not sincerely willing to forsake them. Truly they are deceived who look for the most opposite things at once: the pleasure of idleness and the rewards of virtue (Sallust).

If you were truly penitent, and your will sincerely set against them, you would be more tender and fearful of offending, more firmly resolved against them, more troubled by them, and would abhor them rather than fall into them and say, "I did it before I was aware." You would no more do that than you would spit in your father’s face, curse your mother, slander your dearest friend, or speak treason against the king, and then say it happened through custom before you knew what you were doing. Sin will not be so lightly dismissed by those who have been truly humbled for it and firmly resolved against it.

Have you been a drunkard or a tippler, spending precious hours in an ale-house, chattering over a drink in the company of foolish and tempting sinners? It is within your power, if you are truly willing, to do so no more. If you love and choose such company, such places, such actions and conversation, how can you say you are willing to forsake them, or that your heart has changed? And if you do not love or choose them, how can you commit them, when no one compels you? No one carries you to those places; no one forces you to sin. If you do it, it is because you will do it and love it. If you are in earnest with God, and truly desire to be saved, if you are not content to trade heaven for your cups and company, then away with them at once, without delay.

Have you lived in wantonness, fornication, uncleanness, gluttony, gambling, self-indulgent pastimes, and sensuality, pleasing your flesh while displeasing God? Then bless the patience and mercy of the Lord that you were not cut off and damned for your sin before you came to repentance. And, as you love your soul, delay no longer: make a stand, and go no further, not one step further in the way you know leads to hell. If you know this is the road to your damnation and yet will go on, what pity do you deserve from God or man?

If you have been a covetous worldling, or an ambitious pursuer of honor and advancement, so that your gain, your rise, or your reputation has been the prize you chased, taking the place of God and eternal life, then away now with these known deceits. Do not hunt after vanity and vexation. You already know what you will find when you overtake it and enjoy all it can yield, and how utterly useless it will prove for your comfort or happiness in the end.

Surely, if people were willing, they would be able to restrain themselves from such sins, to make a stand, and to look ahead to prevent their own misery. This is why God pleads with them: "Wash you, make you clean, put away the evil of your doings from before mine eyes; cease to do evil, learn to do well," etc. (Isa 1:16–18).

"Wherefore do ye spend money for that which is not bread? and your labour for that which satisfieth not? Hearken diligently unto me, and eat ye that which is good, and let your soul delight itself in fatness. Incline your ear, and come unto me: hear, and your soul shall live, and I will make an everlasting covenant with you. Seek ye the Lord while he may be found; call ye upon him while he is near. Let the wicked forsake his way, and the unrighteous man his thoughts; and let him return unto the Lord, and he will have mercy upon him, and to our God, for he will abundantly pardon." (Isa 55:2–3, 6–7).

Christ assumes that the foresight of judgment can restrain people from sin when he says, "Sin no more, lest a worse thing come upon thee." (John 5:14; 8:11). Can the presence of other people restrain a fornicator, and can the presence of the judge, or even the prospect of the assizes, restrain a thief? Then shall not the presence of God, together with the foresight of judgment and damnation, restrain you? Remember: impenitent sin and damnation are bound together. If you will bring about the one, God will bring about the other. Choose the one, and you will have no say in whether you receive the other. If you will have the serpent, you shall have the sting.

Direction 15. If you have sincerely given yourself up to God and consented to his covenant, show it by turning the whole direction of your efforts and your way of life completely around, by seeking heaven more fervently and diligently than you ever sought the world or fleshly pleasures.

Holiness does not consist merely in abstaining from a sensual life; it consists principally in living for God. The heart of holiness is inward, and it consists in love of God and of his Word, his ways, his servants, his honor, and his cause in the world, and in the soul’s delight in God, in his Word and ways, in its inclination toward him, its desire after him, its care to please him, and its reluctance to offend him. The outward expression of holiness in our lives consists in the constant, diligent exercise of this inward life, according to the directions of the Word of God.

If you are a believer and have submitted yourself to God as your absolute sovereign, king, and judge, then your work is to obey and please him as a child obeys a father or a servant a master (Mal 1:6). Do you think God will have servants and have nothing for them to do? Would any of you commend or reward a servant for doing nothing, and accept it at the year’s end as a satisfactory account if he said, "I have done no harm"?

God calls you not only to do no harm, but to love and serve him with all your heart, soul, and strength. If you now have a better master than you had before, you ought to do more work than you did before. Will you not serve God more zealously than you served the devil? Will you not labor harder to save your soul than you did to damn it? Will you not be more zealous in good than you were in evil? "What fruit had ye then in those things whereof ye are now ashamed? for the end of those things is death. But now being made free from sin, and become servants to God, ye have your fruit unto holiness, and the end everlasting life." (Rom 6:21–22).

If you are true believers, you have now placed your hopes in heaven, and will therefore apply yourselves to seek it as worldlings apply themselves to seek the world. A sluggish wish, accompanied by half-hearted and lazy endeavors, is no fit seeking of eternal joys. A creeping pace does not suit a person who is on the road to heaven, especially one who traveled faster on the road to hell. This is not running as for your lives. You have every reason to be diligent and make haste: you have great encouragement and help, a glorious end to expect, and the certainty that you will never, in life or in death, have cause to repent of any honest effort. Every step of the way is pure, clean, and delightful, paved with mercies and secured by divine protection. Christ himself is your guide; many have gone this way successfully before you; and the wisest and best people in the world are your companions.

Live, then, as people who have changed their master, their end, their hopes, their road, and their work. Religion does not lull people to sleep, though it is the only way to true rest. It awakens the drowsy soul to higher thoughts, higher hopes, and greater labors than it has ever truly known before. "He that is in Christ, is a new creature; old things are past away, behold, all things are become new." (2 Cor 5:17). You never before sought something that would repay all your cost and effort until now; you never before traveled a road on which you could make haste without one day regretting your haste, until now. How glad you should be that mercy has brought you into the right way after so many wanderings in a sinful life! And your gladness and thankfulness should show itself in cheerful diligence and zeal.

Just as Christ did not raise Lazarus from the dead for him to do nothing or live to little purpose, though Scripture does not give us the history of his subsequent life, so Christ did not raise you from the death of sin to live idly or unprofitably in the world. He who gives you his Spirit as a principle of heavenly life within you expects you to stir up the gift he has given you, and to live according to that heavenly principle.

Direction 16. "Engage yourself in the cheerful, constant use of the means and helps that God has appointed for your confirmation and salvation."

No one can expect to reach the end who refuses to use the means. Of yourselves you can do nothing. God gives his help through the means he has appointed and fitted for your benefit. I will treat the use of these means more fully later; here I only name them so that you may know what you have to do.

1. You must hear or read the Word of God, and other good books that expound and apply it, as I showed you earlier. The newborn Christian inclines toward this just as the newborn child inclines to the breast: "Laying aside all malice, and guile, and hypocrisies, and envies, and all evil speakings, as new-born babes that desire the sincere milk of the word, that ye may grow thereby." (1 Pet 2:1–2) The blessed man’s "delight is in the law of the Lord, and therein doth he meditate day and night." (Ps 1:2–3)

2. Another means is the public worship of God in communion with his church and people. Beyond the benefit of the word preached there, the prayers of the church are effective for its members, and joining with well-ordered assemblies of the saints in praising the Almighty lifts the soul to holy joy. The gatherings of God’s holy worshippers are places of his delight, and they must be places of our delight too. They most closely resemble the celestial company that sounds forth the praises of the glorious Jehovah with purest minds and cheerful voice. "In his temple doth every one speak of his glory." (Ps 29:9) In such a choir, what soul will not be carried away with delight and long to join in the harmony? In such a flame of united desires and praises, what soul so cold and dull that it will not be kindled, and rise to God with more than ordinary ease and eagerness?

3. Another means is private prayer to God. When God would tell Ananias that Paul was converted, he said of him, "Behold, he prayeth." (Acts 9:11) Prayer is the breath of the new creature. The spirit of adoption given to every child of God is a spirit of prayer; it teaches them to cry "Abba, Father," and helps their weaknesses when they do not know what to pray for as they ought; and when words fail, it intercedes for them, as it were, with groans they cannot express. And God knows the meaning of the Spirit in those groans. (Gal 4:6 Rom 8:15 Rom 8:26–27) The first workings of grace appear in desires after grace, driving the soul to fervent prayer, through which more grace is swiftly obtained. "Ask, and ye shall have; seek, and ye shall find; knock, and it shall be opened to you." (Luke 11:9)

4. Another means to be used is confession of sin, not only to God (for even a wicked man may do that, since he knows God is already acquainted with everything, and this adds nothing to his shame; he regards God’s eye so little that he is more ashamed when his sins become known to people), but in three cases confession must also be made to another person.

1.) When you have wronged someone and are therefore obliged to make satisfaction, as when you have robbed, defrauded, slandered, or borne false witness against them.

2.) When you are children or servants under the authority of parents or masters, and they call you to give an account of your actions: you are then bound to give a true account.

3.) When you need the counsel or prayers of others to settle your conscience in peace: in this case you must open your situation to them as far as is necessary for them to help you effectively toward recovery. If they do not know the disease, they will be unfit to apply the remedy. In these cases it is true that "he that covereth his sins shall not prosper: but he that confesseth and forsaketh them, shall have mercy." (Prov 28:13)

5. Another means is the close company and holy conversation of humble, sincere, experienced Christians. The Spirit who dwells and acts in them will kindle the same holy flames in you. Abandon the company of idle, chattering, sensual people who can talk of nothing but their worldly wealth, business, reputations, or appetites; associate instead with those who are walking the road to heaven, if you are resolved to walk it yourself.

What a great difference you will find between these two kinds of companions! The first kind, if you have any thoughts of repentance, will smother them and laugh you out of the use of your reason into their own disordered amusements. If you have any serious thoughts about your salvation, or any inclination to repent and grow wise, they will do much to turn you aside and keep you in the power and snares of Satan until it is too late. If you have any zeal or heavenly-mindedness, they will do too much to quench it and drag your mind back down to earth.

The other kind will speak of things of such great weight and importance, and with such seriousness and reverence, as to raise and quicken your soul; they will give you a taste of the heavenly things they discuss. They will encourage you by their own experiences, direct you by the truth that has directed them, and eagerly share what they have received. They will pray for you and teach you how to pray; they will set the example of holy, humble, obedient lives, and lovingly warn you of your duties and rebuke your sins.

In short, as the carnal mind savors the things of the flesh and is at enmity against God (Rom 8:7–8), the company of such people is a powerful means to infect you with their plague and make you like them, if you have not yet escaped, and all the more to keep you as you are if you have not escaped at all. As those who are spiritual-minded attend to the things of the Spirit, so their conversation tends to make you spiritually-minded as they are. Though there are some useful qualities and gifts in some ungodly people, and some lamentable faults in many who are spiritual, experience will show you so great a difference between them in the main, in heart and life, as will make you all the more ready to believe what the difference between them will be in the life to come.

6. Another means is serious meditation on the life to come and the way that leads to it. Though not everyone can conduct this as methodically as some can, all should become acquainted with it to some measure and at fitting seasons.

7. The last means is to choose a prudent, faithful guide and counselor for your soul, someone to whom you may open matters not fit for everyone to know, and who can advise and resolve questions too difficult for you. The purpose is not to follow blindly after the interests of misguided or ambitious people, nor to commit yourself to his private opinions against Scripture or the church of God; but to have someone who serves your soul as a physician serves your body or a lawyer serves your estate, helping you where they are wiser than you, and where you need their assistance.

Resolve now that instead of idle company and amusements, excessive cares, and sinful pleasures, you will wait on God in the timely use of these means he himself has appointed. You will find that he appointed them not in vain, and that your labor will not be lost.

Direction 17. "So that in all this you may be sincere and not deceived by a hypocritical change, be sure that God is your whole confidence and that all your hopes are placed in heaven; that there is no secret reservation in your heart for the world and the flesh; that you do not divide your heart between God and the things below; and that you do not settle for the religion of a hypocrite, which gives God only what the flesh can spare."

When the devil cannot prevent you from changing and reforming, he will try to deceive you with a superficial change and a half-reformation that does not go to the root, does not recover the heart to God, and does not surrender it entirely to him. If by means of a partial and deceitful change he can persuade you that you are truly renewed and sanctified, and can fix you there so that you go no further, you are as surely his as if you had continued in your grosser sins.

Of all deceptions, this is the most common and dangerous cheat of souls: when people think they can split things between God and the world, securing their fleshly interest in pleasure and prosperity while securing their salvation too, and so they insist on serving both God and mammon.

This is the true character of the self-deceiving hypocrite. He is neither fully persuaded of the certain truth of Scripture and the life to come, nor sufficiently freed from the hold of flesh and world, to take the joys of heaven as his entire portion, to subordinate all his worldly prosperity and hopes to that end, and to part with everything in this life when it is necessary to secure his salvation. He will not therefore release his grip on present things, nor give up his worldly interest for Christ’s sake, as long as he can keep it. He will go no further in religion than is compatible with his bodily welfare, resolving never to be ruined by his godliness, but to preserve himself and his prosperity in the world for as long as he can. He is therefore truly a carnal, worldly-minded man, defined by what is dominant in him.

Yet because he knows he must die, and suspects that for all he knows he may then discover, against his will, that there is another life he must enter, lest the Gospel prove true, he feels he must have some religion. He will therefore take up as much as is consistent with his temporal welfare, hoping to secure both that and heaven in the end. He will be as godly as the dominant interest of the flesh allows him to be.

His first principle is that he will venture his soul rather than be ruined here. His second is that he will be as godly as a worldly, fleshly life will permit. His third is that he will hope for heaven as the destination of such a life. His fourth follows from all three: he will place the greater part of his religion in those things most compatible with worldliness and carnality, things that cost his flesh least, such as belonging to this or that opinion, church, or party (whether Papist, Protestant, or some smaller party); showing zeal for that party; acquiring gifts and abilities that earn him others’ esteem; doing works of charity that do not cost him too much; and refraining from sins that would bring him disgrace or that are simply more costly to commit than to avoid.

His fifth principle is that when a day of trial calls him to choose between God and conscience on one side and the world on the other, he will let go of God and conscience, and risk the pains of hereafter, which he considers uncertain, rather than face certain ruin here. At the very least, he has formed no firm resolution to the contrary that would carry him through such a trial.

His sixth principle is that he will not torment himself or stain his reputation by confessing himself a time-serving worldling who will turn any way to save himself. He will therefore make sure to regard nothing as truth or duty that might prove dangerous; he will supply himself with arguments to show that a thing is not God’s will, or that a sin is no sin at all. He may even invoke conscience and duty in defense of his sin, he will sin, he will say, out of tenderness, piety, and charity to others; and he will accuse those who refuse to comply with him of being the real sinners.

He will first turn every sin his flesh deems necessary, and every duty his flesh finds intolerably costly, into a matter of controversy. Once it is a controversy, and many reputed wise and some reputed good stand on his side, he considers himself on equal footing with the most honest and sincere. He has found a refuge for his conscience and his credit. He refuses to believe himself a hypocrite, and no one else must think him one without being called uncharitable, for then the censure would fall on his whole party. He defends his reputation for piety by saying that though people differ in opinion they must not differ in affection, and must not condemn one another for such differences. That is a perfectly sound principle when rightly applied.

But consider, O hypocrite: why do you differ precisely on those matters where your flesh has an interest, and on no others? Why did this principle never occur to you until your worldly interest required it? How is it that you are always on the side of the self-saving opinion? Why do you consult only those who hold the opinion you want to be true, and not at all, or only partially and half-heartedly, those who oppose it?

Have you ever honestly reckoned what it might cost you to be saved, counted the worst case, and resolved in the strength of grace to go through it all? Have you ever seriously engaged with the self-denying side of religion, or with any duty that would cost you dearly? Does your own conscience not tell you that you never truly believed you would suffer much for your religion, that is, you harbored a secret purpose to avoid it?

Take warning, then, from the mouth of Christ, who has so often and so plainly warned you of this sin and its danger; who has told you how necessary self-denial and a readiness to suffer are in all who are his disciples; and who has shown that the worldly, fleshly principle dominant in the hypocrite is made plain by his self-preserving course. Anyone who will truly be his disciple must take up his cross and follow him in a pattern shaped by his sufferings. We must suffer with him if we will reign with him (Rom 8:17–18).

"He that received the seed into stony places, the same is he that heareth the word, and anon with joy receiveth it, yet hath he not root in himself, but dureth for a while; for when tribulation or persecution ariseth because of the word, by and by he is offended. He also that received seed among the thorns, is he that heareth the word, and the care of this world, and the deceitfulness of riches choke the word, and he becometh unfruitful" (Matt 13:20–22).

If you have not taken heaven as your portion, and are not resolved to release whatever would keep you from it, I must say to your conscience what Christ said to one of your predecessors: "Yet lackest thou one thing" (Luke 18:22), and it is a thing you will find absolutely necessary to your salvation. It is likely, moreover, that some moment of testing even in this life will expose your hypocrisy and make you "go away sorrowful," as he did, for your riches’ sake (Luke 18:23). If godliness with contentment does not seem sufficient gain to you, you will make your gain serve in place of godliness: your gain will sit nearest your heart, hold the place of priority that godliness should hold, choose your religion for you, overrule your conscience, and govern your life.

Take warning also from the apostates and time-serving hypocrites who have looked back, who have, like Demas, forsaken their duty for the world, and who stand erected by divine justice as pillars of salt for your warning and remembrance. If you would make your turning to God a genuine and sure thing, and escape the too-late repentance of the hypocrite, go to the root: resign the world to the will of God; reckon what it may cost you to follow Christ; look for no portion but the favor of God and eternal life; allow no secret reservation in your heart for worldly interest or prosperity; do not think of splitting things between God and the world, or of making your religion accommodate the desires and interest of the flesh. Take God as enough for you, indeed, as everything, or you are not truly taking him as your God at all.

Direction 18. If you would prove true converts, come to God as your Father and supreme good, with desire and delight; embrace Christ as your only Savior with thankfulness and joy; and enter on the way of godliness with pleasure and eagerness, as your greatest privilege and the only path of true profit, honor, and peace. Do not come as those who go against their own will, who would rather do otherwise if they dared, and who regard the service of God as uncongenial and unpleasant.

You are never truly changed until your heart is changed; and the heart is not changed until the will and love are changed. Fear is not the heart of the matter. Fear is ordinarily mixed with unwillingness and aversion, and so runs contrary to what truly constitutes the person. Though fear may accomplish much for you, it will not accomplish enough. Fear is often more vivid than love, even in the best of people, being more intense and urgent; but there is no more genuine acceptance of God in a person than there is will and love toward him. Fear that is merely passive is irrational and disposes us toward irrational things; the fear to be commended is the one that stands with instruction and right reason, and whose proper mark is reverence. Whoever fears God for the sake of Christ and his teaching is subject to him with reverence, while whoever fears God on account of blows and torments seems to have only that passive fear (Didymus of Alexandria, on 1 Peter).

God did not send soldiers, inquisitors, or persecutors to convert the world by working on their fear and driving them into something they took to be harmful to them. He sent poor preachers who had no worldly threats or inducements to move their hearers with, but who had authority from Christ to offer them eternal life, preachers charged with converting the world by setting before them the best and most desirable condition, by showing them where true happiness lies, by demonstrating its certainty and excellence, and by engaging their love, desire, and hope.

God will not be your God against your will, while you regard him as the devil does, that is, as only terrible and harmful to you; while you take his service for slavery; while you would rather be away from him and serve the world and the flesh, if not for fear of damnation. He will be feared as great, holy, and just; but he will also be loved as good, holy, and merciful, as altogether suited to be the happiness and rest of souls. If you do not judge God to be better than the creature, better for you than anything created, and heaven better for you than earth, and holiness better than sin, you are not converted.

But if you do judge him so, then show it by your willingness, eagerness, and delight. Serve him with gladness and cheerfulness of heart, as one who has found the way of life and had no true cause for gladness before now. If you see your servant do all his work with groaning and weeping and lamentation, you will not conclude that he is well pleased with his master or his work. Come to God willingly, with your heart, or you do not come to him at all. You must either make him and his service your delight, or at the very least your desire, recognizing him as the one most truly fitted to be your delight, to the extent that you already enjoy him.

Direction 19. Remember always that conversion is the turning from your carnal self to God, and that it therefore commits you to a lifelong opposition to your own corrupt ideas and desires, mortifying and annihilating them, and bringing them wholly captive to the holy word and will of God.

Do not think that your conversion finishes everything that must be done for your salvation. It is only the beginning of your work, or rather, of your delight and happiness. Conversion enlists you for what must be carried out throughout your entire life. It enters you into the right way, not so that you sit down there, but so that you press on until you reach the desired end. It enters you into Christ’s army, that you may afterward win the crown of life, and the great enemy you are engaged against is yourself. There will still be a law in your members rebelling against the law the Holy Spirit has placed in your mind. Your own ideas and your own will are the great rebels against Christ and the enemies of your sanctification.

It must therefore be your settled, daily work to mortify them and bring them fully over to the mind and will of God, which is their rule and end. If you feel any idea arising in you that is contrary to Scripture and that quarrels with the word of God, suppress it as rebellious. Do not give it room to find fault with your Maker or to dispute impudently with your Governor and Judge. Silence it, and compel it to submit with reverence. If you feel any desire in you contrary to your Creator’s will, if there is something you want or want to do that God opposes and has forbidden, remember that a great part of your work is to flee for help to the Spirit of grace and to destroy all such rebellious desires.

Do not think it enough that you can bear the denial of those desires; destroy the desires themselves at once. If you leave the desires alone, they may in the end seize their prey before you are aware. And even if you were guilty of nothing but the desires themselves, that is no small iniquity: it is the corruption of the heart, the rebellion and adultery of the chief faculty of the soul, which should be kept loyal and pure toward God. The resistance of your will to the will of God is the sum of all the soul’s impiety and evil; the submission and conformity of your will to his is the heart of the new creature and of your righteousness and sanctification. Do not therefore indulge self-conceit or self-will, or any rebellion against the mind and will of God, any more than you would tolerate a dislocated bone, which will give you little ease or use until it is returned to its proper place.

Direction 20. Finally, make certain that you renounce all conceit of self-sufficiency or merit in anything you do, and that you rely wholly on the Lord Jesus Christ as your Head, Life, Savior, and Intercessor with the Father.

Remember that "without him ye can do nothing" (John 15:5). Nor can anything you do be acceptable to God except in him, the beloved Son in whom God is well pleased. Your persons could never have been accepted except in him, and neither can any of your services. All your repenting, even if you had wept your eyes out over sin, would not have satisfied the justice of God or obtained your pardon and justification, without the satisfaction and merit of Christ. Had he not first borne away the sins of the world and reconciled humanity to God so as to secure and offer the pardon and salvation contained in his covenant, there would have been no place for your repentance, faith, prayers, or efforts, as regards any hope of salvation. Your believing would not have saved you, indeed it would have had no justifying object, had he not purchased for you the promise and gift of pardon and salvation for all who believe.

Objection: But perhaps you will say, "If we had loved God without a Saviour, we would have been saved; for God cannot hate and damn those who love him."

Answer: You could not have loved God as God without a Savior. To love him merely as the giver of worldly prosperity, with a love subordinate to the love of sin and your carnal self; to love him as one you imagine so unholy and unjust as to permit you to sin against him and to prefer every vanity over him, this is not to love God, but to love an image of your own imagination. Nor will it in any way secure your salvation. To love him as your God and happiness with a supreme love, you could never have done without a Savior, for two reasons.

1.) On the objective side: God being not your reconciled Father but your enemy, bound in justice to condemn you forever, you could not love him as thus related to you, because he could not appear lovable to you. This is why the damned hate him as their destroyer, as a thief or murderer hates the judge.

2.) On the effective side: your darkened minds and corrupted wills could never have been restored to such soundness as to love God as God without the teaching of Christ and the renewing, sanctifying work of his Spirit. And without a Savior you could never have hoped for this gift of the Holy Spirit. Your supposition itself is therefore groundless.

3.) Conversion is indeed your being grafted into Christ, united to him, and married to him, so that he may be your life, help, and hope. "He is the way, the truth, and the life; no man cometh to the Father, but by him" (John 14:6). "God hath given us eternal life, and this life is in his Son: he that hath the Son, hath life; and he that hath not the Son, hath not life" (1 John 5:11–12). "He is the Vine, and ye are the branches: as the branch cannot bear fruit of itself, except it abide in the Vine, so neither can ye, except ye abide in him: he that abideth not in Christ, is cast forth as a branch, and withered, to be burned" (John 15:4–6).

All your life and help is in him and from him. Without Christ you cannot believe in the Father as one who will show you any saving mercy, you can only believe as the devils do, who believe him just and tremble at his justice. Without Christ you cannot love God or have any living sense of his love. Without Christ you can have no hope of heaven and therefore no effort toward it. Without him you cannot draw near to God in prayer, having no confidence because you have no admittance, acceptance, or hope. Without him, how terrible are the thoughts of death, which in him we see as a conquered thing. When we remember that he was dead and is now alive, the Lord of life, holding the keys of death and hell, with what boldness may we lay down this body and let death undress our souls!

It is only in Christ that we can think with comfort of the world to come, when we remember that he will be our Judge, that in our nature, now glorified, he is at the highest, Lord of all, and that he is "preparing a place for us, and will come again to take us to himself, that where he is, there we may be also" (John 14:3). Without Christ we do not know how to live an hour. We can have neither hope nor peace in anything we have or do. We cannot look with comfort either upward to God or downward to the creation, nor think of our sins, of God, or of the life to come without terror.

Resolve, therefore, that as true converts you are to live wholly upon Jesus Christ, to do everything by his Spirit and strength, and to expect all your acceptance with God on his account. When other people are counted wise for some shallow knowledge of passing things, desire to know nothing but a crucified and glorified Christ. Study him and take him, as your wisdom. When others place their confidence in the flesh, in a show of wisdom, in self-devised worship and humility, following the commandments and teachings of men, seeking to establish their own righteousness, you rejoice in Christ your righteousness. Set continually before your eyes his doctrine and example as your rule. Look always to Jesus, the author and finisher of your faith, who despised all the glory of the world, trampled upon its vanity, submitted himself to a life of suffering, made himself of no reputation, and yet "for the joy that was set before him, endured the cross, despising the shame," and bore the contradiction of sinners against himself.

Live in such a way that you can truly say with Paul: "I am crucified with Christ: nevertheless I live: yet not I, but Christ liveth in me: and the life which I now live in the flesh, I live by the faith of the Son of God, who loved me, and gave himself for me." (Col 2:20–23 Gal 2:20)

Having given you these directions, I most earnestly urge you to read and practice them, so that my labor may not rise up as a witness against you, labor I intend for your conversion and salvation. Consider whether this course is unreasonable, whether this life is unpleasant, whether this is unnecessary. And if it is not, then what is reasonable, necessary, and pleasant, if this is not?

If you encounter any of those confused sinners who would mock you away from Christ and your salvation, saying "this is the way to make men mad," or "this is far more trouble than it needs to be," I will not stop here to expose their brutishness and wickedness, having already done so at length in my books A Saint or a Brute, Now or Never, and the third part of The Saints’ Rest. I will only ask you, as a full defense against all the foolish talk of the enemies of a holy and heavenly life, to take careful note of three things.

1. Mark well the language of the holy Scriptures, and see whether they do not speak directly contrary to these men. Then ask yourself whether God or they are wiser, and whether God or they will be your Judge.

2. Mark whether these men do not change their minds and alter their speech when they come to die. Or consider whether they will not change their minds when death has sent them into that world where none of these deceits remain. And ask yourself whether you should be moved by the words of a man who will shortly change his mind himself, and wish he had never spoken such words. So the Athenians condemned Socrates to death, then lamented what they had done, and raised a bronze statue to his memory.

3. Observe carefully whether their own profession does not condemn them, whether the very thing they hate the godly for is not that the godly are serious in practicing what these malcontents themselves profess as their religion. Are they not then notorious hypocrites?

They profess to believe in God, yet scorn those who diligently seek him. They profess faith in Christ, yet hate those who obey him. They profess to believe in the Holy Spirit as the sanctifier, yet hate and scorn his sanctifying work. They profess to believe in the day of judgment and in the everlasting punishment of the ungodly, yet deride those who endeavor to escape it. They profess to believe that heaven is prepared for the godly, yet scorn those who make it the chief aim of their lives to attain it. They profess to take the holy Scriptures as God’s word and law, yet scorn those who obey it. After each of the ten commandments they pray, "Lord, have mercy upon us, and incline our hearts to keep this law," yet they hate all those who sincerely desire and endeavor to keep them.

Acosta says that whoever would be a pastor to the Indians must resist not only the devil and the flesh but the custom of men, grown powerful through time and numbers, and must set his breast to receive the darts of the envious and the malevolent, who, if they see anything contrary to their profane fashion, cry out "A traitor! A hypocrite! An enemy!" (Acosta, book 4, ch. 15). It seems that among Papists and barbarians the serpent’s seed hisses at the good among their own in just the way it hisses at us.

What shameless hypocrisy is joined to this malice! Mark whether the greatest diligence of the most godly is not justified by the formal profession of the very men who hate and scorn them. The difference between them is this: the godly profess Christianity in earnest, and when they say what they believe, they believe as they say. But the ungodly take up the Christian name out of custom and conformity to company when they are not Christians at all, and by their own mouths they condemn themselves, hating and opposing the serious practice of what they profess to believe. See the proof of the Godhead, that God is the Governor of the world, and that there is another life for man, in the beginning of my Holy Commonwealth, chapters 1, 2, and 3.

CHAPTER 2

THE TEMPTATIONS BY WHICH THE DEVIL HINDERS CONVERSION, WITH THEIR REMEDIES

 

The most holy and righteous Governor of the world has so restrained Satan and all our enemies, and has given us sufficient free will, that no one can be forced to sin against his own will. An act is not sin unless it is voluntary, either positively or by willful omission. All the enemies in hell and earth together cannot make us miserable without our own cooperation, nor can they keep a sinner from true conversion and salvation if he does not keep himself from it. They cannot compel a single sinful thought, word, deed, or omission except by tempting and enticing a person to be willing. All who are without grace are willfully without it. None go to hell except those who choose the way to hell and refuse to be persuaded out of it. None miss heaven except those who set so little value on it as to prefer the world and sin over it, and who refused the holy way that leads there.

Surely a person who naturally loves himself would never take so mad a course unless his reason were lulled to sleep and his understanding terribly deceived. This is the tempter’s work: he does not drag people into sin by force but draws and entices them through temptations. I therefore take it as the next part of my work to lay open these temptations and set out their remedies.

Temptation 1: The devil’s first effort is, in general, to keep the sinner asleep in sin, so that he is like a dead man who makes no use of any of his faculties: eyes that do not see, ears that do not hear, and a heart that neither understands nor feels anything that concerns his peace. Light shining on a sleeping man is useless to him. His work lies undone; his friends, his wealth, his greatest concerns are all forgotten, as if they did not exist. You may say or do whatever you will against him, and he can do nothing in his own defense.

This is the condition the devil labors most to keep the world in, a sleep so deep that their reason, their wills, their fear, their hope, and all their powers are of no use to them. When they hear a preacher, read Scripture or good books, or see the holy examples of the godly, yes, even when they see the grave and know they must shortly lie in one, and know their souls cannot remain here much longer, they still hear, see, and know all this as men asleep: not minding it, as if it concerned them not at all, never once soberly considering and laying it to heart.

Direction 1: For the remedy against this deadly condition:

1. Take heed of drowsy opinions, doctrines, and notions that tend to breed a false sense of security.

2. Do not sit still; be up and active. Stirring tends to shake off drowsiness.

3. Come into the light. Live under a minister who awakens souls, and keep company with people who will not sleep alongside you and who will not easily let you sleep. Agree with them to deal faithfully with you, and promise to receive it thankfully.

4. Meditate often on considerations that rouse the soul. Ask yourself whether a sleeping soul befits someone in your dangerous condition. Can you sleep with such a load of sin on your soul? Can you sleep under the thundering threats of God, under the curse of his law, with so many wounds in your conscience and so many festering sores in your soul? If your body were sick or in the condition of Job, or even if you had nothing worse than a toothache, it would not let you sleep. Is not the guilt of sin a far more grievous thing? If thorns, or toads and snakes, were in your bed, they would keep you awake. How much more odious and dangerous a thing is sin! If your body merely lacks food, drink, or shelter, it breaks your sleep. Is it nothing for your soul to be destitute of Christ and grace?

A condemned man is easily kept awake, and if you are unregenerate, you are already condemned (John 3:18). You sleep in chains, in the captivity of the devil, surrounded by the walking judgments of God, in a life that is always expecting its end, in a boat swiftly carried toward eternity, standing just at the entrance of another world, and that world will be hell if grace does not awaken you. You are about to see the face of God, to see the world of angels or of devils, and to be accompanied by one or the other forever. Is this a place or condition in which to sleep? Is your bed so soft? Is your dwelling so safe? God stands over you, and you sleep? Christ is coming, and death, and judgment (Matt 25:5), and you sleep?

Have you never read of the foolish virgins who slept away their time and knocked and cried in vain when it was too late (Matt 25:5)? You would be wiser to sleep on the pinnacle of a steeple in a storm than to let your soul sleep in so dangerous a condition as yours. The devil is awake, and is rocking your cradle! How busy he is keeping away ministers, or conscience, or anyone who might awaken you! None of your enemies are asleep, and yet you sleep in the thickest of your foes. Is battle a time for sleeping? Is a race a time for sleeping, when heaven or hell must be the outcome?

While the devil keeps you asleep, he can do with you almost whatever he pleases. He knows you have no use of your eyes, your understanding, or your power to resist him. The most learned scholar in his sleep is as ignorant, in practice, as an idiot, and reasons no better than an unlearned man. This is what makes many learned men ungodly, they are asleep in sin. The devil could never have made such a slave of you, to do his work against Christ and your own soul, if you had been awake. You would never have followed his call to the alehouse, the playhouse, the gaming house, and to other sins, had you been in your right mind and fully awake (Prov 7:23–24).

I cannot believe you long to be damned, or hate yourself so much as to have done what you have done, to have lived a godless, graceless, prayerless, and yet merry and careless life, if your eyes had been opened and you had known, and felt, that this was the way to hell. Our very nature will hardly walk toward hell while awake. But it is easy to abuse a person who is sleeping. You have reason, but have you ever roused it to even one hour’s serious consideration of your endless state and present condition?

What a dreadful judgment it is to be given over to the spirit of slumber (Rom 11:8)! Is it not high time now to awake out of sleep (Rom 13:11)? The light has arisen and shines around you. Others who care for their souls are already busily at work. You have already slept away so much precious time. Many a mercy, and perhaps some ministers, have been like candles burned down to give you light while you slept. How often have you already been called? "How long wilt thou sleep, O sluggard?" (Prov 6:9–10)

You still have thundering calls and alarms enough to wake you. God calls, and ministers call! Mercies call, and judgments call! And yet you will not awake? "The voice of the LORD is powerful: full of majesty; breaketh the cedars; shaketh the wilderness," and yet it cannot awaken you? You would not sleep over far smaller matters, not at a meal, not in common conversation, not at the market. But how much greater is the business that should keep you awake! You have an unholy soul to be renewed, an ungodly life to be reformed, an offended God to be reconciled to, and thousands of sins to be forgiven. You have death and judgment to prepare for, heaven to win, and hell to escape. You have many a needful truth to learn and many a holy duty to perform, and yet do you think this is a time to sleep?

Paul, who had far less need than you, watched, prayed, and labored day and night (Acts 20:31 1 Thess 3:10). O that you knew how much better it is to be awake! While you sleep, you lose the benefit of the light and all the mercies that attend you. The sun is no more than a clod of earth to a sleeping man. The world is as no world to him; the beauty of heaven and earth are nothing to him; princes, friends, and all things are forgotten. In the same way, your sleep in sin renders as nothing your health, your patience, your time, your helps, your ministers, your books, and your daily warnings.

What a day you have before you for eternity, if only you had a heart to use it! What a price you hold in your hand (Prov 10:5)! Do not sleep away your day, your harvest time, your tide. "They that sleep, sleep in the night (1 Thess 5:7)." "Awake, and Christ will give thee light (Rom 13:12 Eph 5:14)!" "Awake to righteousness, and sin not (1 Cor 15:34)!"

When you see the light of Christ, what wonder will seize you at the things you now forget! What joy will fill you, and what pity for the sleeping world! But if you insist on sleeping on, know this, sinner: it will not be for long. If you will wake no sooner, death and vengeance will wake you. You will wake when you see the other world, when you see the things you would not believe, and come before your dreadful Judge. "Thy damnation slumbereth not (2 Pet 2:3)." There are no sleeping souls in heaven or hell; all are awake there. And the day that has awakened so many will awaken you. Watch, then, if you love your soul, lest your Lord come suddenly and find you sleeping. What I say to one, I say to all: Watch (Mark 13:34–37).

Temptation 2: If Satan cannot keep the soul in a sleepy, careless forgetfulness, he tries to convince the unregenerate soul that there is no such thing as regenerating grace, that it is a fiction no one has ever experienced. He speaks like Nicodemus: "How can these things be?" (John 3:4). He persuades people that natural conscience is sufficient.

Direction 2: This is easily refuted. Holiness is simply the health and proper order of the soul. It is supernatural only in the way that health is supernatural to someone born a leper. It is nature’s proper condition, its fitting disposition toward the purpose for which it was made. Grace is called supernatural for four reasons: 1. because it is not born in us; 2. because corrupted nature resists it; 3. because its end is the God of nature, who is above nature; and 4. because the means by which it comes, Christ’s incarnation, resurrection, and so on, are themselves supernatural. Yet nature, Scripture, and experience all confirm that humanity is made for another life, and for works that people are utterly unfit for until grace has changed and renewed them, as it does, before your very eyes, in many people. (2 Cor 5:17 Gal 6:15 Gal 4:19 John 3:3 John 3:5 John 3:6 Matt 18:3 1 Pet 1:23)

Temptation 3: The tempter then argues: even if supernatural grace is necessary, perhaps you were born with it. Infants have no sin; Christ says, "Of such is the kingdom of God." Abraham is your father, and indeed, God is your Father (John 8:39 and 8:41). You were born of Christian parents.

Direction 3: For a full proof of original sin in all infants, see my Treatise of the Divine Life, Part 1, Chapters 11 and 12. Grace may indeed be planted in a person early, but it does not come by nature. (Rom 8:9 Rom 8:16 Rom 9:8 Eph 2:3) "Except you be born again, you cannot enter into the kingdom of God" (John 3:3 and 3:5). "If any man be in Christ, he is a new creature: old things are passed away; behold, all things are become new" (2 Cor 5:17). But how empty is it to boast of having been born holy, when you find yourself unholy at present? Show that you now have a holy, heavenly heart and life, and you are happy, whenever that work was done in you.

Temptation 4: But, says the tempter, baptism is the washing of regeneration. You are baptized, and therefore you are regenerated. The ancient teachers held that all sins were washed away in baptism, and that grace was conferred with it.

Direction 4: The ancient teachers, when they spoke of baptism, meant the internal and external acts together: the soul’s surrender to God in covenant, sealed by the outward rite (Matt 28:19 and 28:20). So understood, baptism includes conversion, true repentance, and faith, and all who are baptized in this full sense are pardoned, justified, and holy.

But those who receive only the sacramental ordinance outwardly are not thereby in a state of life. Christ himself says plainly that "except you are born of the Spirit" as well as "water, you cannot enter into the kingdom of heaven" (John 3:5 and 3:6). Peter told Simon Magus, even after he was baptized, that he was "yet in the gall of bitterness, and bond of iniquity" (Acts 8:23). Baptism is not "the putting away the filth of the flesh, but the answer of a good conscience" (1 Pet 3:21). Christ cleanses his church "by the washing of water by the word" (Eph 5:26). But even if you were cleansed in baptism, if you are unclean and unholy at present, can you be saved as you are?

Temptation 5: When this fails, the tempter tries to persuade people that godliness is nothing more than a matter of correct opinion and belief, believing all the articles of the faith, being neither a papist nor a heretic, being of the true religion, and trusting confidently in God’s mercy through Christ. For "he that believeth shall be saved" (Mark 16:16).

Direction 5: To this you must answer: it will not save a man that his religion is true, unless he is true to it. Read James 2 against such a dead faith. Saving faith is the wholehearted reception of Christ as Lord and Savior, the surrendering of the soul to him to be sanctified and governed, as well as pardoned. "Knowledge puffeth up, but charity edifieth." "He that knoweth his master’s will and doth it not, shall be beaten with many stripes" (Luke 12:47). It is a grievous thing that men should expect to be saved by what will in fact condemn them, by holding a right opinion while living a wrong life; by believing their duty instead of doing it; and then presuming that Christ forgives them and that their state is good. Opinion and presumption are not faith.

Temptation 6: But, says the tempter, holiness may be the mark of truly holy persons; yet ordinary, unlearned people may be saved without such elevated things, which are beyond them.

Direction 6: God tells you that "without holiness none shall see him" (Heb 12:14). The unlearned may be saved, but the ungodly cannot (Ps 1:6). Holiness stands to the soul as life to the body: without it a person is dead, though not all enjoy the same degree of spiritual health. Sin is sin, and God hates it in the learned and the unlearned alike. Every soul needs regeneration at the start. And as every living body lives on earth by air and food, so every living soul lives by the same God, and Christ, and heaven, through the same Word and Spirit, and all of this is within the reach of the unlearned.

Temptation 7: But, says the tempter, God is not so unmerciful as to damn all who are not holy. This is merely talk designed to keep people in awe, and should not be believed.

Direction 7: If God’s threatenings are necessary to keep people in awe, then they must be necessary to be executed, for God does not need to rule people by a lie. He knows best to whom he will be merciful, and to what degree. Have you never read Isaiah 27:11: "It is a people of no understanding: therefore he that made them will not have mercy on them, and he that formed them, will shew them no favour"? And (Ps 59:5): "Be not merciful to any wicked transgressors." Is he not just, as well as merciful (Exod 34:6 and 34:7)? You see that people grow sick, suffer, and die, for all that God is merciful. Merciful judges still condemn criminals. Angels became devils through sin, for all that God is merciful, and the devil knows this to his sorrow. "And if God spared not the angels that sinned, but cast them down to hell," will he be unjust for your sake?

Temptation 8: But Christ died for all, and God will not punish both him and you for the same fault.

Direction 8: Christ died for all who have the Gospel in this sense: he procured and sealed for them a free and general pardon of all their sins, on condition that they repent, receive him as their Savior, and thereby bring salvation within their choice. But will this save the ungodly who obstinately refuse? Christ died to sanctify as well as to forgive (Eph 5:27), to "purify to himself a peculiar people, zealous of good works" (Titus 2:14); "to destroy the works of the devil" (1 John 3:8); and to bring all people under his dominion and government (Rom 14:9 Luke 19:27). "If any man have not the Spirit of Christ, the same is none of his" (Rom 8:9).

Temptation 9: No one can be certain of salvation; all must simply hope for the best. Raising doubts in people’s minds about whether they will be saved does not help them, it only bewilders them and drives them toward despair.

Direction 9: Is there so little difference between a child of God and a child of the devil, between the way to heaven and the way to hell, that they cannot be told apart? Has not Christ taught us plainly how to distinguish them (Ps 1 Ps 15 1 John 3)? Has he not commanded us to "give diligence to make our calling and election sure" (2 Pet 1:10)? If all people must hope they will be saved, then most are hoping for what they will never receive, and no hope God has given is a hope that deceives. Should a matter as weighty as our everlasting joy or misery be cast out of our careful attention, and risked so carelessly in the dark, when life and time and everything we have are given to us precisely so we may secure it?

And what harm can it do you to discover the truth of your own condition? If you are indeed unregenerate and unholy, find it out now while there is still time to be recovered. You must despair of being saved without conversion, but that is the very despair that prevents the final, absolute despair. Whereas if you do not discover your condition until time has run out, then hope is gone; and the devil has you in the endless desperation he was always working toward.

Temptation 10: If none of this prevails, the devil will try to carry the day by noise instead of reason. He will keep you in jovial, merry, pleasure-seeking company, people who make their argument through drinks, entertainment, and amusements, who daily mock godliness and speak of the godly with contempt, as a crowd of fanatical hypocrites.

Direction 10: Consider that this is nothing but the rage of fools speaking of what they have never understood. Have they ever tried the way they speak against? Are they to be believed over God himself? Will they not eat their own words in the end? Will their merry lives last forever? Do they die as merrily as they live, and do they deliver on their promises to bring you safely through? Anyone who will be cheated out of his salvation and forsake his God for the ranting scorn of a disordered sinner is worthy to be damned.

Temptation 11: Next, the devil tells people that a godly life is so hard and tedious that if they were to begin it, they could never endure to continue, and that it is therefore pointless to try.

Direction 11: This pretense is compounded of both wickedness and madness. What but a wicked heart could make it so hard a thing to live in the love of God, in holiness, and in the hope and pursuit of eternal life? Why should that not be a sweeter and more pleasant life than drinking, rioting, gambling, and fooling away time in vanity, or even than the full enjoyment of every fleshly delight? Nothing opposes it but a sick, disordered heart that finds distasteful what is, in itself, most delightful.

When grace has changed your heart, it will be easy. Do you not see that others hold on in this life and would not return to what they were for anything in the world? Why should you be any different? God will help you: it is the very work of Christ and the Spirit to help you, and your encouragements are beyond number. The hardness is greatest at the beginning; the longer you continue, the easier it becomes. But even if it were hard, is it not necessary? Is hell easier, and to be preferred over it? And will not heaven repay every cost and every labor? Will you sit down in despair and resolve to let your salvation go, on the basis of such empty, frightening words as these?

Temptation 12: Next, the devil will try to bury people so deeply in worldly cares, hopes, and business that they find no time to think seriously about saving their souls.

Direction 12: This is a snare, and a frequently effective one, yet it is so irrational, and runs so contrary to the warnings and testimonies of all people everywhere, whether at conversion or at death, that anyone who, after all these warnings, still neglects God and his salvation because he has worldly affairs to attend to, is worthy to be handed over to his own choice, and to have no better help or portion in the hour of his need and distress. I have spoken of this sin further in Chapter IV, Part 6.

Temptation 13: To prevent conversion, the devil will do everything he can to keep you from the acquaintance and company of those whose holiness and instruction might convince and strengthen you, and especially from a lively, convicting minister, while drawing you instead toward some cold-hearted minister and society. (Prov 13:20 Prov 28:7 Eph 5:7 Eph 5:11)

Direction 13: Therefore, if it is at all possible, even at some personal loss or inconvenience in the world, live under a searching, heavenly teacher, and in the company of those who are resolved for heaven. A heart that feels no need of such help, and is not strengthened when it has it, is truly dead. If you are ever genuinely on the way to heaven and likely to be converted, it will be in the midst of such helps as these.

Temptation 14: One of Satan’s strongest temptations is making sin intensely pleasant to people, whether through gain, honor, or bodily satisfaction, so that the violence of their sensual appetite and desire is inflamed, and they fall so deeply in love with their sin that they cannot leave it. It is like the thirst of a man burning with fever, who cries for cold drink even though it would kill him: the fury of appetite conquers reason. So we see drunkards, fornicators, and worldlings who are so captivated by their sin that, come what may, they will have it, though they take hell along with it.

Direction 14: Against this temptation I urge you to read what I have written in Chapter IV, Part 7, and Chapter III, Direction 6 and 8. O that poor sinners knew what it is they love so much! Is pleasing the flesh so sweet a thing to you? And are you so indifferent to God and holy things? Are these less worthy of love? Do you foresee what both will amount to at the end? Will your sin seem better than Christ, and grace, and heaven, when you are dying? Do not be so in love with ruinous folly and the pleasures of a beast that you despise the heavenly wisdom and delights.

Temptation 15: Another great temptation is the prosperity of the wicked in this life, combined with the reproach and suffering that usually falls upon the godly. If God were to strike every notorious sinner dead on the spot, or smite him blind, or dumb, or lame, or inflict some immediate judgment, many would fear him and restrain their sin. But when we see that the most ungodly men prosper most, that they are the very ones who persecute the holy, and that sentence against an evil work is not swiftly executed, then "their hearts are set in them to do evil" (Eccl 8:11).

Direction 15: But how brief is the prosperity of the wicked! Read Psalm 73 and 37. Delay is not forgiveness: they are only waiting until the appointed day of reckoning. And will that tempt you to do as they do? How ungratefully sinners treat God! If he were to strike you down and afflict you, that would not please you; and yet when he forbears, you take boldness from it to sin the more. So his patience is turned against him, but the blow will fall all the heavier when it comes.

Do you think those men will always flourish? Will they always swagger and revel? Will they always live in those houses, hold those lands, and be honored and served as they now are? How quickly and how dreadfully will the scene change for them! O if you could see now what faces they will wear, what heavy hearts they will carry, and with what bitter outcries they will at last condemn themselves for all their folly, wishing they had never been deceived by prosperity, but had rather shared the portion of a Lazarus! If you saw that they are only being fattened for slaughter, and in what a dreadful misery their wealth and sport and honors will leave them, you would lament their condition. You would think so great a destruction could not come too soon, and you would have no desire to share their lot.

Temptation 16: Another temptation is their own prosperity. People think that when God prospers them, he cannot be as angry with them as preachers say. It is a very hard thing, in health and comfort, to take sin and its threatened consequences to heart, to have the kind of serious, vivid thoughts about the life to come that adversity, and especially familiarity with death, awakens in people. Prosperity is the greatest temptation to carelessness, to delaying repentance, and to putting off preparation for eternity. Overcome prosperity, and you overcome your greatest snare.

Direction 16: Go into the sanctuary, yes, go into the churchyard, and see the end. Judge by those skulls and bones and dust, if you cannot judge by God’s own warnings, what prosperity amounts to (see my sermon on Proverbs 1:32 at the end of The Vain Religion of the Formal Hypocrite). Judge by the experience of all the world: does it not leave everyone in sorrow at last? Woe to the man who has his portion in this life! O miserable health, and wealth, and honor, that purchase the death and shame and utter ruin of the soul!

Was not the man who soon cried out in vain for a drop of water to cool his tongue (Luke 16) in as prosperous a condition as you? There is none of you so senseless as not to know that you must die. And must you die, certainly die, yet let that day go so unprepared for? Shall present prosperity make you forget it, and live as though you must remain here forever? Do you make so much of what is now, and so little of what is coming, so that when it arrives it strikes you with the full force others feel, yet while it is only approaching you give it no thought at all?

O man, what is a brief and hurrying inch of time? How quickly it is gone! You are departing from here in haste, and nearly gone already. God gives you the mercy of a few days or years of health to make all your preparation for eternity, and does his mercy become the occasion of your ruin? Do you turn it so entirely against the ends for which it was given? Will you gorge yourself on mercy and destroy your soul with it? You have senses to perceive what now is, but you have reason to foresee what will be. Will you play at harvest time and forget the winter?

Temptation 17: Another great temptation that hinders conversion is the example and counsel of powerful, ungodly people. When landlords and men of power are sensual and hostile to a holy life, speaking of it with contempt, their subordinates are easily drawn to echo them, led by the deference they instinctively pay to worldly wealth and rank. The same effect follows when men with a reputation for learning and wisdom hold the opposite view, and especially when subtle enemies raise objections against godliness that the sinner cannot immediately answer.

Direction 17: On this I spoke at the close of the first part of this chapter. No man is as great or as wise as God. Look in his Word and see whether it agrees with what the powerful say. The mightiest who provoke him can no more escape his vengeance than the poorest beggars can. Consider what he made of a Pharaoh, and how Pharaoh’s own hard-heartedness and impenitence became the occasion of God’s glory. He can send worms to devour an arrogant Herod at the very moment the crowd is hailing him as a god.

Where are the Caesars and Alexanders of the world now? The rulers and Pharisees did not believe in Christ (John 7:48). Will you therefore refuse to believe in him? The governor of the country condemned him to death, will you therefore condemn him? "The kings of the earth set themselves, and the rulers take counsel together, against the Lord and his anointed, saying, Let us break their bands asunder, and cast away their cords from us" (Ps 2:2–3). Will you therefore join in the conspiracy, when "he that sitteth in the heavens shall laugh; the Lord shall have them in derision," and "he will break them with an iron rod, and dash them in pieces like a potter’s vessel," unless they "be wise, and kiss the Son, and serve the Lord with fear, before his wrath be kindled, and they perish" (Ps 2:4, 9–12)?

If your landlord or the great ones of this world are to be your god, honored and obeyed before God and against him, then trust to them, call on them in the hour of your distress, and accept whatever salvation they can give you. Do not presume to instruct God in whom to choose or to whom to reveal his mysteries. He does not always choose the learned scholar or the powerful man. Christ himself says, "I thank thee, O Father, Lord of heaven and earth, because thou hast hid these things from the wise and prudent, and hast revealed them unto babes: even so, Father, for so it seemed good in thy sight" (Matt 11:25–26).

If this does not satisfy you, follow the great ones and share their end. If they are greater and wiser than God, let them be your gods. Read Mr. Bolton’s Assize Sermon on 1 Corinthians 1:26–28: "You see your calling, how that not many wise men after the flesh, not many mighty, not many noble are called: but God hath chosen the foolish things of the world, to confound the wise; and God hath chosen the weak things of the world to confound the things that are mighty; and base things of the world, and things which are despised, hath God chosen, and things which are not, to bring to naught things that are" (1 Cor 1:26). The honor, greatness, and wisdom God bestows on the poorest saints surpasses anything the world can give. Those who live for the world will soon find their portion bitter. In your baptism you renounced the world with its pomp and vanity, will you now deify what you then defied?

Temptation 18: Another temptation is to draw the sinner into such an entrenched habit of sin, and such a long neglect of the means of recovery, that his heart becomes utterly hardened.

Direction 18: Against this, read below, Chapter 4, Part 2, on hardness of heart.

Temptation 19: Another temptation is to delay repentance, intending to attend to it later.

Direction 19: On this I urge you to read the many reasons I have given to shame and awaken those who delay, in my book Directions for a Sound Conversion.

Temptation 20: The worst of all is the temptation to flat unbelief, disbelieving Scripture and the life to come.

Direction 20: Against this, read here Chapter 3, Direction 1; Chapter 4, Part 1; and my Treatise against Infidelity.

Temptation 21: If sinners will nonetheless seek after grace, the devil will do everything he can to deceive them with counterfeits, to make them mistake a merely apparent, half-conversion for a genuine saving change.

Direction 21: On this, read my Directions for Sound Conversion, and The Formal Hypocrite, and The Saints’ Rest, Part 3, Chapter 10.

Temptation 22: If he cannot make them flat infidels, he will tempt them to question and dispute the plain sense of every Scripture text used to convict them, and every doctrine that presses hardest on their guilty consciences, the necessity of regeneration, the fewness of those who are saved, the difficulty of salvation, the torments of hell, the necessity of mortification, and the sinfulness of particular sins. They will lend an ear to any caviler who speaks up for a sin or against any part of godliness, and with these objections they willfully deceive themselves.

Direction 22: But if men are determined to side with the devil, to close their eyes and quibble against everything God says to prevent their ruin, to remain ignorant because they will not know, what remedy remains? Who can save people against their own wills? "This is the condemnation, that light is come into the world, and men love darkness rather than light, because their deeds are evil. He that doth evil hateth the light, neither cometh to the light, lest his deeds should be reproved" (John 3:19–20). In Scripture, "some things are hard to be understood, which they that are unlearned and unstable, wrest to their own destruction" (2 Pet 3:16). On particular cases, read the close of my Treatise of Conversion.

Temptation 23: Beyond all this, the devil will do his worst to make sinners heretics, fashioning for them some doctrine of licentiousness fitted to their lusts. It is hard to go on being wicked in the open light, with conscience kicking back, too painful to be long endured. So the devil constructs a religion that pleases them and does their sins no harm: either a religion assembled from loose opinions, like those of the Familists, Ranters, Libertines, and Antinomians (and too much of the Jesuits as well), or one built from petty formalities, much outward ceremony, theatrical performance, and empty compliment, as much of the Popish devotion is.

Very little is needed to draw a carnal heart into a carnal doctrine; it is far easier to acquire a new religion than a new heart. Then the devil assures them that they are on the right road and will therefore be saved. A great part of the world rests confident because it belongs to a particular sect or party, which its leaders declare to be the true church and the true way.

Direction 23: But remember: whatever law you make for yourselves, God will judge you by his own. Forging the king’s coin is no way to pay a debt, it only adds treason to your existing ruin. What is necessary for salvation is a new and holy heart and life, not a new creed or a new church or sect. Being a member of the soundest church on earth will never save you if you yourself are unsound within it, no better than the dust on the temple floor, waiting to be swept out. Still less will it save you to construct your own rule, simply because God’s rule seems too strict.

Temptation 24: Another device of the tempter is to lead men to rest in mere conviction instead of genuine conversion. When they have learned that regeneration and the Spirit of Christ are necessary to salvation, they become as settled and satisfied as if knowing this were the same as actually possessing it. Just as some suppose they have reached perfection when they have only embraced the opinion that perfection is attainable in this life, so great numbers suppose they have sanctification and forgiveness because they now see that these things must be had, and that without sanctification there is no salvation. In this way, knowledge of grace and duty passes for the possession of grace and duty itself; their intellectual judgment about a thing substitutes for actually having it; and instead of truly possessing grace, they force themselves into believing they already do.

Direction 24: But remember: God will not be mocked. He knows the difference between a convinced head and a holy heart. Believing yourself rich does not make you rich. Believing yourself well, or knowing the remedy, is not enough to make you well. You may dream that you eat, and yet wake up hungry. All the land and wealth you see around you is not yours merely because you see it. To know that you ought to be holy makes your remaining unholy inexcusable. Ahab was not spared by believing he would return from battle in peace. Self-flattery in a matter so weighty is the greatest possible folly. "If ye know these things, happy are ye if ye do them" (John 13:17).

Temptation 25: Another great temptation is the devil’s hiding from people the intrinsic evil and ugliness of sin. "What harm," says the drunkard, the adulterer, and the sensual pleasure-seeker, "is there in all this, that preachers make such a fuss about? What hurt does it do to God or man? that they would have us believe we must be damned for it, that Christ died for it, and that the Holy Spirit must mortify it?" So the Jews asked: "Wherefore hath God pronounced all this great evil against us? or what is our iniquity? or what is our sin, that we have committed?" (Jer 16:10). The person who does not know God does not know what sin against God truly is, especially when love of sin and delight in it blinds them.

Direction 25: Against this, I urge you to weigh the forty intrinsic evils of sin that I have listed in Chapter III, Direction 8, along with their aggravations. If the devil can once persuade you that sin is harmless, then all faith, all religion, all honesty, and your very souls are lost. For then all of God’s laws and government must be fictions; there is no work for Christ as Savior or for the Spirit as Sanctifier to do; all ordinances and means become troublesome vanities; and godliness and obedience deserve to be banished from the earth as needless troublers of mankind. Then this poison might safely be taken and made your food. But how insane a notion this is! How swiftly God will make even the proudest person understand what harm it was to refuse the government of their Maker and set up instead the rule of a beastly appetite and a misguided will, and that sin is bad, if hell is bad.

Temptation 26: The devil also tempts people to think that, though they sin, their good works compensate for their bad ones, and so they pray and perform certain outward acts of Pharisaical devotion, to make amends to God for what they do wrong.

Direction 26: Against this, consider that however many good works you might have, they are all merely your duty and make no satisfaction for your sin. What good works can a wicked soul do that God will accept, works done without the heart? Your heart must first be cleansed, and yourself devoted and sanctified to God; for an evil tree will bring forth evil fruit: first make the tree good, and the fruit will be good. The love of God, hatred of sin, and a holy and heavenly life are the good works God chiefly calls for, along with faith, repentance, and conversion as the way to these. Will God accept your lip-labor, or the leaving of some portion of your goods as alms, while the world and fleshly pleasure hold your heart? In truth, you do no work that is genuinely good. The outward matter may be good, but you poison it with corrupt motives and ends. "The carnal mind is not subject to the law of God, nor indeed can be; but is enmity against God." (Rom 8:7)

Temptation 27: Some are tempted to think that God will not condemn them because they are poor and afflicted in this life and have their sufferings here, and that a God who condemns the rich for not showing mercy to the poor will himself show them mercy.

Direction 27: Has he not already shown you mercy? And is it not his mercy that you despise and refuse, namely, Christ, his Spirit, and holy communion with God? Must God show you the mercy of glory without first giving you the mercy of grace? That is a contradiction. It is strange that the very people who cannot be persuaded to accept mercy and let it save them are the ones saying that God will be merciful and save them.

As for your poverty and suffering, it is against your will, and you cannot deny it. Will God save anyone for what they endure against their will? You would have riches, honor, pleasure, and all the good things of this life just as much as anyone else, if you could manage it. You love the world as much as others do, if you could get more of it. To be carnal and worldly for so poor a share of earthly goods, and to love the world even while you suffer in it, makes you more inexcusable than the rich. The devils have suffered more than you, as have many thousands of souls in hell, and yet they are no closer to salvation for it. If you are poor in the world but rich in faith and holiness, then you may well expect salvation (Jas 2:5). But if your sufferings make you no more holy, they only deepen your guilt.

Temptation 28: The devil also blinds sinners by keeping them ignorant of the true nature and power of holiness of heart and life. They have no experience of it, and the devil will not let them see and judge it from Scripture, where it can be seen without any mixture of its counterfeits. Instead, he points them only to professors of holiness, commonly the weakest and worst of them, and to the worst in them, showing them the failures of hypocrites and the falls of weaker Christians, and then telling them, "This is what their godliness and religion amounts to; they are all the same."

Direction 28: It is easy to see how these people deceive and condemn themselves. This reasoning is like arguing that a beast is wiser than a man because some men get drunk, or lose their temper, or lose their mind. Drunkenness and fits of passion, which are the enemies of reason, bring no disgrace to reason itself, only to themselves. Indeed they would be no disgrace at all if reason, which they obstruct, were not honorable. Likewise, no person’s sins bring any disgrace to holiness, which condemns those sins, nor would the sins be bad in themselves if holiness, which they oppose, were not good. There is no disgrace to daylight or the sun in the existence of night and darkness; nor would darkness be bad if light were not good. Will you refuse health because some people are sick? Will you choose to be dead because the living have their infirmities? The devil’s reasoning is more foolish than this.

Holiness is absolutely necessary for salvation. If many who do far more than you are as bad as the devil would persuade you, what does that say about your own condition, who have not nearly as much as they? If those who make it their greatest care to please God and be saved are the very hypocrites the devil claims, then your own case is hopeless, for you fall far short of them. If so, you must do more than they, not less, if you are to be saved. Otherwise, out of your own mouth you will be condemned.

Temptation 29: Another device of the tempter is to drive people to a reckless venture with their souls. Whatever may come of it, they will take their chances rather than live so strict a life.

Direction 29: But consider what you are doing and who will bear the loss of it, and how quickly it may be too late to undo your gamble. What should drive you to so mad a resolution? Is sin so good? Is hell so easy? Is your soul so worthless? Is heaven such a trifle? Is God so hard a master? Is his work so grievous and his way so bad? Does he require anything unreasonable of you? Has God set you so terrible a task that it is better to risk damnation than to perform it? You cannot believe this if you truly believe him to be God. Come closer and think on it more deliberately, and you will find that you might better flee from your food, your friends, and your very life than flee from your God and from a holy life, when the only place you run to is sin and hell.

Temptation 30: Another great temptation is making people believe that their sins are merely the common infirmities that the best Christians share. They cannot deny they have their faults, but are not all people sinners? They hope their sins are not the reigning, unpardonable kind.

Direction 30: But how vast is the difference between a converted and an unconverted sinner, between the failings of a child and the contempt of a rebel, between a sinner who has no gross or mortal sin and who hates, mourns over, and strives against his infirmities, and a sinner who loves his sin, is reluctant to give it up, makes light of it, and does not love a holy life. God will one day make that difference plain to you, when you see that some sinners are justified and saved, and others are condemned.

Temptations to Take Mortal Sins for Infirmities

 

Temptation 1: One subordinate temptation is this: the devil persuades people that their sin is only an infirmity because it remains in the heart and does not appear in outward deeds. They mistake restraint for sanctification.

Direction 1: But the life and reign of sin is precisely in the heart, that is its garrison and throne. Sin’s power consists in the dominance of your lusts within, overriding reason and will. Every outward sin is merely an act of obedience to the reigning sin within, a tribute paid to that inner king. It is for the inner sin that provision is made (Rom 13:14), and on it everything is spent (Jas 4:3). Original sin may be reigning sin, just as a king may be born to the throne. Sin certainly reigns until the soul is converted and born again.

Temptation 2: The devil tells people their sin is only an infirmity because it is not open, gross, or disgraceful. It is hard, they feel, to believe they are in danger of hell for sins counted small.

Direction 2: But do you think it is no mortal, heinous sin to be empty of the love of God and holiness? To love the flesh and the world above him? To value earth more than heaven and to work harder for it? However they present themselves outwardly, these are the great and mortal sins.

Sin is no less dangerous for lying hidden in the heart. The root and the heart are usually unseen. Some kings, as in China, Persia, and elsewhere, keep out of public view for the honor of their majesty, yet are the spring of all government, while officers execute the acts of state. When you see a man walk or work, you know that something within is the cause of everything. If sin appeared outwardly as it is inwardly, it would lose much of its power and majesty, ministers, friends, and every good person would cast a stone at it, but its secrecy is its peace. Even the devil prevails by keeping out of sight; if he were seen, he would be less obeyed.

So it is with the reigning sins of the heart. Pride and covetousness may be reigning sins, though they never show themselves in any notorious or disgraceful course of life. David’s hiding his sin, or Rachel her idol, made neither of them any better. It is a mercy to some people that God permits them to fall into some open, scandalous sin that may humble them, people who would not have been humbled or convicted by heart-sins alone (Jer 4:14 Hos 7:6–7). An oven is hottest when it is stopped up.

Temptation 3: Satan tells people their sins are neither unpardoned nor reigning, because they are common in the world. "If all who are as bad as I am must be condemned," they say, "God help a great number."

Direction 3: But do you not know that reigning sin is far more common than saving holiness? The gate is wide, and the way is broad that leads to destruction, and many go in by it. Salvation is as rare as holiness, and damnation as common as reigning sin where it is not cured. This sign, then, testifies against you rather than for you.

Temptation 4: The tempter says: these sins are not reigning sins because you see good people commit the same ones. You play the same games they do; you do only what you see them do, and they are pardoned.

Direction 4: You must judge the person by his works, not the works by the person, and there is more to examine than the bare outward act. A good person and a bad one may play the same game, but not with the same end, nor with the same love of sport, nor as frequently or as long, to the loss of time. Many drops may wear a stone; many stripes with small twigs may draw blood. Many ordinary people gathered in a senate may together have as much power as kings. In the same way, many small sins set all together may plainly constitute a carnal life. The power of a sin matters more than its outward appearance. A poor man placed in a magistrate’s seat is still a ruler. A sin that is small in outward form, and one that better people also commit, may still be a sin of power and rule in you, and may combine with other, greater sins.

Temptation 5: The tempter says: these are merely sins of omission, and therefore not reigning sins.

Direction 5: Sins of omission are always accompanied by some positive, sensual attachment to the creature, which diverts the soul and causes the omission. Omission is therefore no small part of reigning sin. The failure to employ reason and will for God and for the mastering of sensuality is a large part of what ungodliness in a person consists in. Denying God your heart and life is no small sin. God made you to do good, not merely to do no harm, otherwise a stone or a corpse would be as good a Christian as you, since they do less harm. If sin has a veto over your religion, whether God shall be worshipped and obeyed or not, then sin is your king. It can show its power just as well by commanding you not to pray, not to reflect, and not to read, as by commanding you to be drunk or to swear.

The wicked are described precisely by omissions: those who "will not seek after God: God is not in all his thoughts" (Ps 10:4); those who "know not God, and call not on his name" (Jer 10:25); those who have "no truth, or mercy, or knowledge of God" (Hos 4:1); those who "feed not, clothe not, visit not" Christ in his members (Matt 25); and those who hide their talents (Matt 25). Indeed, if God does not have your heart, the creature does, and so omission and commission go together in your reigning sin.

Temptation 6: The tempter says: these cannot be reigning sins because they are sins of ignorance, or at least you cannot be certain they are sins at all.

Direction 6: Do you truly not know that it is a sin to love the world more than God? To love fleshly pleasure more than God’s service? To love riches more than grace and holiness? To do more for the body than for the soul, and more for earth than for heaven? Are you really uncertain whether these are sins? And do you not feel that they are your sins? You cannot claim ignorance here.

But what causes your ignorance? Is it that you earnestly want to know and cannot? Do you read, hear, study, inquire, and pray for knowledge, yet still cannot find it? Or is it not rather that you do not want to know, that you think it not worth the trouble to find out, or that you love your sin? And will willful ignorance of that kind excuse you? No; it makes your sin the greater. It shows sin’s greater dominion that it can use you as the Philistines used Samson: put out your eyes, make a drudge of you, conquer your reason, and make you believe that evil is good and good is evil. When sin has mastered your understanding, it has taken the principal fortress of your soul. A man who has been fully reconciled to his enemy is one who has come to regard him as a friend.

Do you not know that God should have your heart, that heaven should have your deepest care and diligence, and that you should make the Word of God your rule, your delight, and your meditation day and night? If you do not know these things, it is because you do not want to know them, and it is a miserable condition to be given over to a darkened mind. Take heed, or you will at last commit the most horrific sins without knowing them to be sins. There are already such people: they mock at godliness, persecute Christians and ministers of Christ, and do not know they are doing wrong, they think they are doing God a service (John 16:2).

If a man makes himself drunk and then kills, steals, and abuses his neighbors, and says he did not know he was doing wrong, that will not excuse him. This is your situation. You are drunk with the love of fleshly pleasure and worldly things; these carry you so far that you have neither heart nor time to study the Scriptures, to hear and think about what God says to you, and then you claim you did not know.

Temptation 7: The tempter says: it cannot be a mortal, reigning sin, because it is not committed with the whole heart and not without some struggle and resistance. Do you not feel the Spirit striving against the flesh? That is the experience of the regenerate (Gal 5:17). The good you do not do, you would do; and the evil you do, you would not do, so it is no longer you who does it, but sin dwelling in you (Rom 7:20–23). In a sensual, unregenerate person there is only one party, nothing but flesh; but you feel the combat between flesh and Spirit within you.

Direction 7: This snare is so subtle and dangerous that you need clear eyes to escape it. Understand, therefore, the following points.

1. As for the two Scripture texts the tempter abuses, they say nothing at all about mortal, reigning sin. They speak of the unwilling infirmities of those who had already subdued all such sin, who walked not after the flesh but after the Spirit, whose wills were habitually set toward good, and who longed to be perfect, to have been guilty of no idle thought or word, no imperfection in their holiest service, but to have lived up fully to what the law requires. They could not achieve this because the flesh continually threw obstacles before the will in its performance. But this has nothing to do with the case of someone who lives in gross sin and an ungodly life, who has strivings and convictions and ineffectual wishes to be better and to turn, yet never actually turns. That is simply sinning against conscience and resisting the Spirit who would convert you; and it makes you worthy of many stripes, as one who rebels against the importunities of grace.

Sin may be resisted without ever being conquered; it may still reign despite some opposition. Not everyone who resists a king deposes him from his throne. It is a dangerous deception to think that every good desire that contradicts sin thereby conquers it and is a sign of saving grace. The desire must be for a state of godliness, and it must be an effectual desire.

Power comes in degrees: a ruler may have limited power and still be a ruler. As the evil spirits that possessed men’s bodies were a legion in one person and only one in another, yet both were possessed, so it is here. Grace is not without resistance even in a holy soul; there are remnants of corruption in the will itself resisting the good, yet it does not follow that grace does not rule. So it is with sin in the unregenerate. No one in this life is as good as they will be in heaven, nor as bad as they will be in hell; therefore no one is entirely without moral good. And even the smallest good will resist evil to some degree, as light resists darkness.

This can be seen in the following cases:

1.) In the unregenerate there remains a residue of natural knowledge and conscience, some awareness of God and his will disclosed in his works. God has not left himself without witness (Acts 14:17 Acts 17:27 Rom 1:19–20 Rom 2:7–9). This natural light and law governed the heathens and, in its measure, resists sin and assists the conscience.

2.) When supernatural revelation in Scripture is added to the light and law of nature, so that ungodly people possess the same law as the best believers, it may accomplish more.

3.) Moreover, an ungodly person may live under a most powerful preacher who will never leave them alone in their sins, stirring up much fear and many good resolutions, almost persuading them to be true Christians, and producing not merely some ineffectual wishing and striving against sin, but leading them to do many things in response to the preaching, as Herod did after John, and even to escape the common pollutions of the world (2 Pet 2:20).

4.) A sharp affliction added to all the rest may make such a person appear to others to be a true penitent. When he is stopped in his course of sin, as Balaam was stopped by the angel with a drawn sword, and sees that he cannot go on without risking his life, and that God keeps meeting him with some cross and hedging up his way with thorns (for God shows such mercy even to some of the ungodly), this may produce not only resistance to sin but some measure of reformation. When the Babylonians were planted in Samaria they did not fear God, and he sent lions among them; then they feared him and set up some form of worship performed by a low sort of priests: "they feared the LORD, and served their own gods," thinking it safest to please all (2 Kgs 17:25 and 17:32–33). Affliction makes bad people most resemble the good.

5.) Good education and good company can accomplish a great deal. They may give a person much knowledge and make him a professor of strict religion, a constant companion of those who fear sin and avoid it, so that he must go far in that direction, as Joash did throughout the days of Jehoiada (2 Chr 24:2). Just as plants and fruits change character with the soil they are transplanted into, and as the climate makes some people blackmoors and others white, so education and association exercise so great a power on the mind that they come closest to grace and are often the means by which grace comes.

6.) God also gives to many people, inwardly, some grace of the Spirit that is not peculiar to the saved but is common or preparatory only. This may produce much resistance against sin without mortifying it. A person living under nothing more than the convictions Judas had when he hanged himself would certainly have strivings and internal combat against sin, even without being sanctified.

7.) Indeed, the power of one sin may resist another: covetousness may make strong resistance against sensuality and the pride of life, and pride may resist all sin that would bring disgrace.

Temptation 8: The tempter says: "Your sin is not unpardoned, because you are sorry and repent of it whenever you have committed it, and all sin that is repented of is pardoned."

Direction 8: All the causes listed above that may produce some resistance to sin in the ungodly may equally produce some sorrow and repentance in them. There is repenting and sorrow for sin even in hell. All people repent and are sorry in the end; but few repent in a way that brings pardon and salvation. When a sinner has extracted all the sweetness that sin can yield, and sees that it is gone and only the sting remains, it is no wonder he repents.

I think there is scarcely a drunkard, a whoremonger, or a glutton (who is not a flat infidel) who does not repent of past sin, simply because he has had everything out of it that it could give and nothing lovely remains. Yet he goes on still, which shows that his repentance was unsound. True repentance is a thorough change of heart and life, a turning from sin to a holy life, accompanied by such sorrow for what is past that it would prevent you from doing it again if you faced the same choice. If you truly repent, you would not act so again even under all the same temptations.

Temptation 9: The tempter says: "It is but one sin, and the rest of your life is good and blameless; and God judges by the greater part of a life, whether the evil or the good predominates."

Direction 9: If a man is a murderer or a traitor, will you excuse him because the rest of his life is good and he is charged with only one sin? One kind of poison can kill a man; one stab to the heart is fatal even if every other part of the body is sound. You can be overcome by one dish; one leak can sink a ship. "Whosoever shall keep the whole law, and yet offend in one point, is guilty of all" (Jas 2:10). See also (Ezek 18:10–11).

It is true that God judges by the bent of your heart and the main direction and effort of your life. But can you honestly say that the bent of your heart and the main effort of your life are for God, for heaven, and for holiness? If they were, you would be regenerate; and that state would not allow you to live in any one beloved, chosen, willful sin. The bent of a man’s heart and life may be sinful, earthly, and fleshly even if it runs in only one channel of gross sinning, just as a man may be covetous though he follows only one trade, a whoremonger though he has but one whore, an idolater though he has only one idol.

If you loved God more, you would let go of your sin; and if you love any one sin more than God, then the whole bent of your heart and life is wicked, for it is not set upon God and heaven, and therefore it is ungodly.

Temptation 10: The tempter says: "Your sin is not reigning and unpardoned, because you believe in Jesus Christ, and all who believe are pardoned and justified from all their sin."

Direction 10: Whoever savingly believes in Christ receives him entirely as both Savior and Governor, and surrenders himself to be saved, sanctified, and ruled by him. Trusting your physician implies that you take his medicines and follow his advice, that is what your trust consists in; you do not expect to be cured while disobeying him, through bare trusting alone. So it is with faith and trust in Christ: it is a belief that he will save all those who are ruled by him in the way that leads to salvation. "He is the author of eternal salvation unto all them that obey him" (Heb 5:9).

If you believe in Christ, you believe Christ; and if you believe Christ, you believe "that except a man be converted, and born again, he cannot enter into the kingdom of heaven" (John 3:3 John 3:5 Matt 18:3); and that he who is "in Christ, is a new creature; old things are passed away, and all things are become new" (2 Cor 5:17); and that "without holiness no man shall see the Lord" (Heb 12:14); and that no fornicator, the effeminate, thieves, the covetous, drunkards, revilers, extortioners, murderers, liars "shall inherit the kingdom of God" (1 Cor 6:9–10 Eph 5:4–6 Rev 21:27).

If you believe Christ, you must believe that you cannot be saved unless you are converted. It is the devil, not Christ, who tells you that you may be pardoned and saved in an unholy, unregenerate state. It is grievous that people should believe the devil and call this believing in Christ, and expect to be saved for so believing, as if false faith and presumption pleased God. Christ will not save people for believing a lie and trusting the father of lies above him; nor will he save all who are confident they will be saved. If you think you have any part in Christ, remember: "If any man have not the Spirit of Christ, he is none of his" (Rom 8:9).

See more on temptations in Chapter 3, Direction 9.

CHAPTER 3

DIRECTION 1: LET SOLID CONVICTION, NOT NOVELTY OR REPUTATION, DRAW YOU

 

Before I come to the common directions for the exercise of grace and walking with God, which cover the common duties of Christianity, I will lay down some preliminary instructions suited to those who have only recently entered into religion. I presuppose what I have said in my book of directions for those still under the work of conversion, written to prevent their going astray through a false or superficial change. I have since written a book on this subject, to which I refer the reader for fuller direction.

Direction 1. Take heed lest it be the novelty or reputation of truth and godliness that draws you, rather than a solid grasp of their excellence and necessity, lest, when the novelty and reputation are gone, your religion wither and die away.

Christ said of John and the Jews, "He was a burning and a shining light, and ye were willing for a season to rejoice in his light" (John 5:35). Everyone is most moved by things that seem new and strange. It is not only a childish weakness to be pleased with new clothes and new toys; even serious, thoughtful people find new things the most compelling, and familiarity dulls delight. Our homes, possessions, and honors please us most at the start, and every condition of life affects us most at its beginning. If human nature were not so drawn to novelty, publishing news-books would not have remained so profitable a trade for so long, unless the content had been truer and more worthwhile. This is why change is so welcome to the world, though it ordinarily costs people dearly.

No wonder, then, that religion is more appealing when it arrives with this advantage. When people first hear the doctrine of godliness and the news of another world opened and applied by a powerful preacher, it is no surprise that things of such great moment should affect them for a time. Those who received the seed of God’s Word into stony ground "forthwith sprung up, and they anon with joy received it" (Matt 13:5, 20), but it quickly withered for lack of root. This kind of hearer can no more delight indefinitely in one preacher, one profession, or one way, than a glutton can in one dish or an adulterer in one partner; for the pleasure they take even in the highest truths is merely sensual or natural, and all such pleasure must be fed with novelty and a changing variety of objects.

The Athenians were curious about Paul’s teaching as a novelty, though they afterward rejected it as seeming incredible to them: "May we know what this new doctrine whereof thou speakest, is? for thou bringest certain strange things to our ears: we would know therefore, what these things mean. (For all the Athenians and strangers which were there, spent their time in nothing else, but either to tell, or to hear some new thing)" (Acts 17:19–21).

To this kind of professor, the greatest truths go out of fashion, and they grow weary of them as dull and ordinary things. They must have some new light or new form of religion that has lately come into vogue. Their souls grow tired of the manna that once seemed like angels’ food. Old things seem low to them, and new things seem high; to take up some novelty in religion is, in their view, to advance toward maturity. Too many of these people eventually so far outgrow their old clothing that the old Christ and the old Gospel are left behind altogether.

The light of the Gospel is communicated more quickly than its heat. Since this first element is more agreeable to such people, it is readily received, and religion seems best to them at the start. At first they have only the light of knowledge; then they enjoy the warmth of a new and prospering profession. Some time must pass before the heat begins to burn them, and when it does, they have had enough, and cast religion away as hastily as they picked it up.

If preachers would only lighten and shoot no thunderbolts, even a Herod would hear them gladly and do many things they said. But when his Herodias is touched, he cannot bear it. If preachers would address only people’s imaginations or understanding, and not press too sharply on their hearts, their lives, and their worldly interests, the world would hear them as it hears stage-players, or at least as lectures in philosophy or medicine. A sermon that contains nothing but vague, toothless notions in handsome language seldom causes offense or persecution. It is rare that such preaching is disliked by worldly hearers, or that the preacher’s person is hated for it. "It is a pleasant thing for the eyes to behold the sun" (Eccl 11:7), but not to be scorched by its heat.

Christ himself, when promised and still at a distance, was greatly desired by the Jews; but when he came, they could not bear him, his doctrine and life so thoroughly contradicted their expectations. "The Lord whom ye seek, shall suddenly come to his temple, even the Messenger of the Covenant whom ye delight in: behold, he shall come, saith the Lord of Hosts. But who may abide the day of his coming? and who shall stand when he appeareth? for he is like a refiner’s fire, and like fuller’s soap" (Mal 3:1–3). Many who come to Christ for the first time, by profession, little expect that he will cast them into the fire, refine them, purge away their dross, and cast them anew into the mold of the Gospel (Rom 6:17).

Many will play awhile in the light who will not endure to be melted by the fire. When the preacher reaches this point, he is deemed harsh and intolerable, and loses all the praise he had previously earned; the pleasing novelty of religion is over for them. The Gospel is sent to accomplish such work in the soul and in life as these tender persons will not endure. It must bring every thought captive to Christ, put to death every lust and pleasure that opposes his will, and implant a new and heavenly life in the soul. It must fill people with deep and living apprehensions of the great things of eternity. Wavering, dull opinions will never raise and carry the soul forward in the vigorous, constant, victorious action that salvation requires.

When the Gospel comes to the heart to do this great, prevailing work, these people grow impatient of the searching and the pain, and quickly have done with it. They are like children who love a book for the gilding and fineness of its cover, and pick it up as readily as anyone, but only to play with, not to learn; they grow weary of it when it comes to that.

At first many come to Christ with wonder and insist on being his servants, drawn by something in it that seems attractive, until they learn that the Son of Man does not enjoy even the shelter the birds and foxes have, and that his doctrine and way stand in direct opposition to their worldly and fleshly interests; and then they are gone. They welcomed Christ as a courtesy, supposing he would please them or at least not greatly contradict them. When they find they have received a guest who will rule them rather than be ruled by them, who will not let them take their pleasures or enjoy their riches, but hold them to a life they cannot endure, even undoing them in the world, he is no longer a welcome guest. Had Christ been received as Christ, and truth and godliness deliberately embraced for their clearly discerned excellence and necessity, the deep rooting this produces would have prevented such apostasy and cured such hypocrisy.

But, alas, poor ministers find by sad experience that not all who flock to hear them, fill the crowd, "for a season rejoice in their light," and magnify and defend them, prove to be true saints. The blossom has its beauty and sweetness, but not everything that blossoms or appears in bud comes to perfect fruit. Some will be blasted, some blown down; some nipped by frost, some eaten by worms; some fall quickly, and some hang on until the strongest gales cast them down.

Some are deceived and corrupted by false teachers; some are made unfruitful and turned aside by worldly cares and the deceitfulness of riches. In some, the lusts had deeper root than the Word; in others, friends had greater hold on them than Christ, and so they forsake him to satisfy those friends’ demands. Some are corrupted by the hope of advancement or the favor of others. Some are frightened away from Christ by threats and frowns, and choose to risk damnation rather than face persecution. Some are so worldly-wise that they can find reason to cool their zeal, can save both soul and body, as they see it, and can prove to themselves that what other men call sin is actually their duty, if only the outcome answers their expectations. And some simply grow weary of truth and duty as dull and common things, having no supply of variety to keep alive the pleasures of novelty.

Do not misread what I have said, as if every affection that novelty heightens and familiarity dulls were a sign of hypocrisy. I know that something in human nature, present even in the best, inclines us to be far more powerfully moved by things when they first appear to us than when they have long been known and used. Scarcely one person in a thousand is not more delighted by the light of a truth when it first dawns on them than when it has become familiar; and scarcely one is not more affected by a powerful preacher at first than after sitting under him for years.

The same sermon that transported them at first hearing would move them far less if heard a hundred times. The same books that deeply affected us at the first or second reading affect us less after twenty readings. The same words of prayer that move us greatly when seldom used do less to stir our affections when spoken every day of the year. At our first conversion we feel more passionate sorrow for sin and more intense love toward the godly than we can maintain afterward. All of this is true of the learned and the unlearned, the sound and the unsound alike, though not equally. Even heaven itself is spoken of by Christ as though it shares something of this, when he says that "joy shall be in heaven over one sinner that repenteth, more than over ninety and nine just persons, that need no repentance" (Luke 15:7, 10).

I know also that it is the duty of ministers to take notice of this disposition in their hearers, and not to dull them by always offering the same things, but to profit them through pleasant and profitable variety, not by preaching another Christ or a new gospel. It is the same God, the same Christ, the same Spirit, the same Scripture, the same heaven, the same church, the same faith and hope and repentance and obedience that we must preach as long as we live. Though hearers say they have heard it a hundred times, let them hear it still, bring them no new creed.

If they hear so often of God and Christ and heaven that by faith and love and final possession they attain those things as their end, they have heard well. Yet there is a welcome variety in subordinate particulars, in words, methods, and well-timed applications, that is necessary to faithful ministry and to the growth of the flock. A physician uses the same dispensary and the same medicines, yet he must employ great variety in his compounds, his timing, and his manner of administration.

For all that, though even the best are most powerfully moved by what seems new, and are dulled by the long and frequent use of the same expressions, they are never weary of the substance of their religion to the point of desiring a change. And though they are not so passionately affected by the same sermons and books, or by the thought and mention of the same great matters of religion, as they were at first, yet their judgments embrace and esteem those matters more firmly and solidly, their wills adhere to them more resolutely, and their lives practice them better than before. Those who take up religion merely for the sake of novelty, by contrast, will lay it down when it ceases to be new, and must either exchange it for something newer or have no religion at all. (As Seneca observed, the outcomes of mad hatred and mad love are nearly the same, De Beneficiis, book 6, ch. 25.)

Those people are equally unsound who are religious only because their upbringing, their friends, the law, the judgment of their rulers, or the custom of their country has made it necessary for their reputation. Such people are hypocrites from the very outset, and continuance in so carnal a religiousness cannot save them. I know that law, custom, education, and friends, when they side with godliness, are a great advantage to it, by providing helps and removing obstacles that would weigh heavily on carnal minds. But truth is not truly your own until you receive it on its own proper evidence; your faith is not divine faith until you believe what you believe because God who reveals it is true; you are not children of God until you love him for himself; and you are not truly religious until the truth and goodness of religion itself is the chief thing that makes you religious.

Much is revealed about a person’s sincerity when they are not only religious among the religious but also among the profane, the enemies, the scorners, and the persecutors of religion; when someone does not pray only in a praying household but among the prayerless and those who mock fervent, constant prayer; when someone is heavenly among the earthly, temperate among the intemperate and riotous, and holds the truth among those who reproach it and hold the contrary. A sincere person is not carried along merely by the current of company or outward advantage in their religion, nor does he avoid sin simply for want of temptation, but is religious even against the stream, and remains innocent when cast, against his will, into temptation; is godly where godliness is counted singularity, hypocrisy, faction, eccentricity, disobedience, or heresy; and will sooner let go his reputation for honesty than honesty itself.

CHAPTER 4

DIRECTION 2: ON UNITING SOUND JUDGMENT, ZEAL, AND HOLY PRACTICE

 

"Take heed of being religious only in opinion, without zeal and holy practice; or only in zealous affection, without a sound, well-grounded judgment. See that judgment, zeal, and practice are united."

On the first part of this advice, against a merely opinion-based religion, I have already spoken in my "Directions for a Sound Conversion." Changing your opinions is an easier matter than changing the heart and life. Holding to the truth will save no one without a love and practice of the truth. This is the point St. James makes when he speaks at such length about the worthlessness of a dead, ineffectual belief, one that does not work through love and does not move the soul to practice and obedience.

To believe that there is a God while you neglect and disobey him is unlikely to please him. To believe that there is a heaven while you neglect it and prefer the world before it will never bring you there. To believe your duty and not perform it, to believe that sin is evil and yet to live in it, is to sin with aggravation, without excuse, and not the way to be accepted or justified before God. To hold the same beliefs as holy men, without the same hearts and conduct, will never bring you to the same happiness. "He that knoweth his master’s will, and doth it not, shall be" so far from being accepted for it that he shall be "beaten with many stripes." To believe that holiness and obedience is the best way will never save the disobedient and unholy.

And yet if sound judgment is not your guide, even the most zealous affections will only drive you forward recklessly, making you run fast though completely off the road, like horses that have thrown the coachman and riders. To travel at full speed when you are entirely off course is only to lose your time through great effort and to prepare yourself for yet more labor.

As P. Scaliger says, knowledge that is severed from justice deserves to be called cunning rather than wisdom.

The Jews who persecuted Christ and his apostles had, by Paul’s own testimony, "a zeal of God, but not according to knowledge" (Rom 10:2). Paul says of the deceivers and troublers of the Galatians, whom he even wished cut off, that they "zealously affect" them, "but not well" (Gal 4:17). And of himself, while he was persecuting Christians to prison and death, he says: "I was zealous towards God as ye are all this day" (Acts 22:3–4).

Was not the Papist St. Dominic, who stirred up persecution against Christians in France and Savoy to the murdering of many thousands of them, a very zealous man? Are not the butchers of the Inquisition zealous men? Were not the authors of the third Canon of the General Council at the Lateran, under Pope Innocent III, very zealous men, those who decreed that the Pope should depose temporal lords, give away their dominions, and absolve their subjects if those lords would not exterminate the godly who were called heretics? Were not the Papists’ Gunpowder Plot conspirators zealous men? Has not misdirected zeal in more recent times caused many to rise up against their lawful governors, and many to persecute the church of God, stripping the people of their faithful pastors without any compassion for their souls?

Christ says of such zealots: "The time cometh, when whosoever killeth you will think he doth God service" (John 16:2), that is, offers a service acceptable to God. Paul therefore says, "It is good to be zealously affected always in a good thing" (Gal 4:18), showing that zeal is indeed good, provided that sound judgment guides it.

Your first question must always be: Am I on the right road? Your second: Am I moving forward at a fitting pace? It is grievous to observe what odious actions have been committed in every age of the world through the impulse of misdirected zeal. What a disgrace an imprudent zealot is to his own profession: making himself ridiculous in the eyes of adversaries, he brings his profession itself into contempt and leads the ungodly to conclude that religious people are nothing but a company of carried-away, brain-sick zealots, and by this means they are hardened to their own destruction.

Consider also that the imprudence of well-meaning men has sometimes done as much harm to the church as outright persecution by enemies. For example: when Constantine, son of Constans, was emperor, some officious men attempted to prove from the orthodox doctrine of the Trinity that his two brothers, Tiberius and Heraclius, ought to reign alongside him, arguing that if we believe in the Trinity, we should crown three, which cost the chief of them his life by hanging. (Abbas Urspergensis, edited by Melanchthon, page 162.)

How many things does unguarded passion provoke well-meaning people to do that will afterward become their shame and sorrow.

Labor therefore for knowledge and soundness of understanding, so that you may distinguish truth from falsehood and good from evil, that you may walk with confidence while walking safely, and not bring shame upon your profession by furiously pursuing what you must afterward confess was an error, or by drawing others into what you would afterward wish you had never known yourselves. And yet see that all your knowledge bears its full effect upon your heart and life: receive every truth as an instrument God uses to reveal himself to you, to draw your heart toward him, and to conform you to his holy will.

CHAPTER 5

DIRECTION 3: LEARN THE TRUE METHOD OF DIVINITY AND THE CATECHISM

 

‘Work to understand the true method of divinity, and to see truths in their proper degrees and order, taking neither the last for the first, nor the lesser for the greater. See that you are well grounded in the catechism; do not refuse to learn a sound and full catechism, and keep it in memory throughout your life.’

Method, or right order, greatly aids understanding, memory, and practice. Truths depend on one another: the smaller branches spring from the larger, and those from the trunk and root. Some duties are merely means to other duties, or serve them, and must be measured accordingly. If you do not understand which duty is the chief, you cannot properly refer the others to it. When two things that are each materially good come together and both cannot be done, the greater must take precedence, and the lesser is not a duty at all in that moment, but a sin if preferred over the greater. This is why one of the most common difficulties in cases of conscience is knowing which duty is greater and deserves priority. On this very ground, Christ healed on the sabbath day, and defended his disciples for rubbing ears of corn, and cited David’s eating the showbread, telling his hearers that "the sabbath was made for man, and not man for the sabbath," and that "God will have mercy, and not sacrifice."

Divinity is a carefully and well-composed structure. It is not enough to have all the parts of a watch or clock; every part must be in its proper place, or the mechanism will not run or serve its end. So too it is not enough to know the various parts of divinity or duty, you must know them in their true order and place. Without this, you may be thrown into confusion before you realize it, and led into many dangerous errors by mistaking the order of various truths.

You may likewise be misguided into serious sins by mistaking the degrees and order of duties: for instance, when duties of piety and charity appear to compete; when you think the commands of men contradict the commands of God; when the substance of a duty and its circumstances or modes seem to conflict; or when a means appears to cancel itself by working against its own end. In cases such as these, and many more like them, it is difficult to convey how great a trap ignorance of the method and rank of duties may become.

Objection: If that is so, how can any person avoid being confounded in religion, given that so few teachers observe any method at all, few agree on method, and none has published a scheme or method so exact and clear as to win common approval even among divines themselves? What then can ordinary Christians do?

Answer: Divinity is like a tree with one trunk, from which a few large arms or boughs grow, and from those a thousand smaller branches, or like the veins, nerves, and arteries in the body, which begin with one or a few main trunks, divide into more, those into more still, until they multiply into more than can easily be seen or counted. Now it is easy for anyone to begin at the chief trunk, discern the first divisions and the next, even without grasping the number and order of every outermost and smallest branch. The Stoics said that the virtues are so linked to one another that whoever has one has them all, as Diogenes Laertius reports in his life of Zeno.

So it is in divinity. It is not very hard to begin at the unity of the eternal God as the head, see there a Trinity of persons, primary attributes, and relations, and then rise to the principal attributes and works of God in those relations, to the relations of humanity to God, to the great duties arising from those relations, to discern God’s covenants and chief laws, the duty of humanity in obedience to them, and God’s judgment in executing his sanctions.

Many particular truths may remain unknown, and yet one who begins and proceeds rightly does know, in an orderly fashion, as much as one knows, and is on the right path toward knowing more. The great mercy of God has laid so strong a necessity on us to know those few points that are readily known, and so much less need on us to know the many small particulars, that an ordinary Christian who understands the catechism well, or the creed, the Lord’s Prayer, and the Ten Commandments, may live uprightly, holily, and comfortably, and find daily work and consolation in the use of these.

A sound and well-composed catechism, studied carefully and kept in memory, would provide a solid measure of knowledge for ordinary Christians. It would make them firm and orderly in their understanding, and in their approach to smaller points, and would prevent a great deal of the error and disorder that many are thrown into by poor teaching, to their own grief and the church’s. Indeed, one might wish that some teachers of recent times had learned so much themselves, and learned it in good order. Acosta held that two catechisms are needed: one brief and compendious, to be learned by heart, holding the sum of all that is necessary to a Christian’s faith and conduct; the other fuller, where the same matters are set out more amply and clearly and confirmed more copiously, so that the first serves the learners and the second the teachers themselves.

CHAPTER 6

DIRECTION 4: BEGIN WITH SUBSTANTIALS, NOT CONTROVERSIES

 

‘Begin not too early with controversies in religion: and, when you come to them, let them have but their due proportion of your time and zeal: but live daily upon these certain, great substantials, which all Christians are agreed in.’

1. Do not plunge into controversies too soon. There are several reasons for this.

1.) It will harm you greatly by drawing your soul away from greater and more necessary things. You will gain more growth in holiness, and spend your time more pleasingly to God, by drinking more deeply of the substantials of religion and working them into your heart and life.

2.) It will corrupt your mind. Instead of producing humility, charity, holiness, and heavenly-mindedness, it will feed your pride, kindle faction and a divisive zeal, quench your charity, and fill you with a wrangling, contentious spirit, and you will end up making a religion out of these sins and pitiful disorders.

3.) It is also the way to deceive and corrupt your judgment, making you erroneous or heretical, to your own ruin and the disturbance of the church. For the odds are heavily against you: either you will err immediately, or you will acquire such an itch after notions and opinions that it will lead you into error in the end. You are not yet mature enough to judge these things, because your mind has not yet been prepared by the truths that must be received first. When you undertake work you are not capable of doing, no wonder if it is done badly and must all be undone again, or made worse.

Perhaps you will say that you must not take your religion on trust, but must "prove all things, and hold fast that which is good."

Answer: Your religion must not be taken on trust, but many controverted, lesser opinions must be taken on trust until you are capable of examining them on their proper evidence. Until you can reach them yourself, you must take them on trust or not receive them at all. Although you must believe everything necessary to salvation by a divine faith, many subordinate truths must first be received by a human faith, or not received at all until you are more capable of them. Indeed, a human faith is necessarily subordinate to divine faith even in the substance of religion, and the officers of Christ are to be trusted in their office as helpers of your faith.

Let me add this: while you are young and ignorant, you are not fit even for controversies about the fundamentals of religion themselves. You may believe that there is a God long before you are fit to hear an atheist argue that there is no God. You may believe that Scripture is the Word of God, that Christ is the Savior, and that the soul is immortal, long before you are fit to manage or study the controversies surrounding those claims. For there is nothing so false or bad that a clever and unscrupulous wit cannot put a plausible gloss on it, and your raw, unfurnished understanding will scarcely be able to see through the pretense or escape the deception.

When you cannot answer the arguments of seducers, you will find that they leave a residue of doubt in your mind, because you do not know how plain their answers are to wiser people. And though you must prove all things, you must do it in due order and as you are able, waiting until your furnished mind is capable of the examination. If you insist on reading before you know your letters, or presume to judge Greek and Hebrew authors before you can read English, you will only become ridiculous in the attempt.

2. When you do come to smaller controverted points, let them have only their due proportion of your time and zeal. For the generality of private Christians, that proportion will be no more than one hour in many days. By the time you have thoroughly learned the more necessary duties, you will find there is little time left for lesser controversies. Those who are consumed by opinions and spend most of their time studying and talking about such points are stealing that time from greater matters, and therefore from God and from themselves. Better work goes undone in the meantime. Those who pour their chief zeal into these controversies divert it from more necessary things, and turn the natural warmth of devotion into a fever.

3. The essential, necessary truths of your religion must imprint the image of God upon your heart. They must dwell there continually; you must live on them as your bread, drink, and daily food. All other points must be studied in service of these. All lesser duties must be used as exercises of love for God and neighbor, and of a humble, heavenly mind.

The articles of the creed and the points of the catechism are ever-flowing fountains, providing you with material for the continual exercise of grace. They are both plentiful and solid nourishment for the soul. To know God as Creator, Redeemer, and Sanctifier; to know the laws and covenant of God, his judgment, and his rewards and punishments; to know the parts and method of the Lord’s Prayer, which must be the daily exercise of our desires and love, this is the wisdom of a Christian, and in these things he must be continually exercised.

You may say that the apostle writes, "Leaving the principles of the doctrine of Christ, let us go on to perfection, not laying again the foundation of repentance from dead works," etc. (Heb 6:1)

Answer: By "leaving" he does not mean setting aside their practice, as men who have finished with them and moved past them. He means either setting aside discourse about them at that moment, or presupposing that they have already been taught. He does not lay the foundation again, but neither does he tear it up.

2.) By "principles" he means the first points to be taught, learned, and practiced, and indeed, regeneration and baptism are not to be repeated. But the essentials of religion that I am speaking of contain much more; above all, living in the love of God, which Paul calls "the more excellent way" (1 Cor 12 and 13).

3.) "Going on to perfection" is not achieved by ceasing to believe and love God, but by a more distinct knowledge of the mysteries of salvation, perfecting our faith, love, and obedience.

The points that opinion-driven people call higher, and consider the chief matter of their growth and advancement in understanding, are usually nothing more than smaller, less necessary truths, if not simply uncertain and doubtful questions (1 Tim 1:4, 1 Tim 4:4, 2 Tim 2:23, Titus 3:9), compared with (John 17:3, Rom 13:8–10, 1 Cor 13, 1 John 3, 1 Cor 1:23, 1 Cor 15:1–3, 1 Cor 2:2, Gal 6:14, Jas 2, Jas 3:1).

CHAPTER 7

DIRECTION 5: BE THANKFUL FOR CONVERSION BUT DO NOT OVERESTIMATE YOUR EARLY GROWTH

 

"Be very thankful for the great mercy of your conversion; but do not overvalue your first degrees of knowledge or holiness. Remember that you are still in infancy, and must expect growth and ripeness to come as the fruit of time and diligence."

You have great reason to be more glad and thankful for the least measure of true grace than if you had been made rulers of the earth, since grace is of a far more excellent nature and entitles you to more than all the kingdoms of the world. See my sermon called "Right Rejoicing," on Christ’s words, "Rejoice not that the spirits are subject unto you; but rather rejoice, because your names are written in heaven" (Luke 10:20). Christ warrants you to rejoice, even when enemies envy you and resent both your victory and your triumph. If there is "joy in heaven in the presence of the angels" at your conversion, you yourself have every reason to be glad. If the prodigal’s father will have the best robe and ring brought forth, the fatted calf killed, and music at the feast, that they may eat and be merry (Luke 15:23), the prodigal son himself has the greatest share of all in that joy, whatever his brother may say.

But take care not to mistake the measure of your early gifts for something greater than it is. Diogenes Laertius tells of Cleanthes that when he was once reproached for being timid, he answered, "That is the very reason I go so little wrong."

Grace imitates nature by beginning, ordinarily, with small degrees and growing toward maturity through gradual progress. We are not born again into a state of full manhood as Adam was created. Though the texts that compare the kingdom of God to a grain of mustard seed and to a little leaven (Matt 13:31 and 13:33) apply chiefly to the small beginnings and great increase of the church in the world, they are also true of grace, or the kingdom of Christ, in the soul. Our first stature is only to be "new-born babes desiring the sincere milk of the word, that we may grow thereby" (1 Pet 2:2). Note that the new birth produces only babes, and that growth comes by degrees, through feeding on the Word. The Word is received by the heart as seed into the ground (Matt 13), and seed does not ordinarily bring forth blade and ripe fruit in a single day.

Yet I do not deny that some people, as Paul was, may have more grace at their first conversion than many others have at their full growth. God is free in giving his own gifts, and may give more or less as he pleases. But even for Paul, that greater measure was still his smallest measure, and he himself remained capable of increase to the very end. Such a large measure at first is as rare as Paul’s full growth in later life, and is scarcely to be expected today.

Even if God should grant someone a great measure of holiness at conversion, as he sometimes may, their measure of gifts is never large at first unless those gifts had been acquired or received before conversion. If grace finds a person of great natural ability and understanding, attained before conversion through study and other means, it is no surprise that when those abilities are sanctified, that person is capable in knowledge from the first day; for the knowledge was already there, though without a heart to use it rightly. But if grace finds a person ignorant, unlearned, and of limited ability, that person must not expect to be suddenly raised to great understanding and high degrees of knowledge through grace alone. Such knowledge is not now given by sudden infusion, as extraordinary gifts were in the primitive church.

You need no better proof of this than experience, which silences any who would dispute it. Look around you and observe whether those who are knowledgeable obtained it by infusion, in a moment, or whether they obtained it by diligent study, by slow degrees, though I know God blesses some people’s studies more than others. Name one person who ever arrived at great understanding except through means, labor, and slow degrees; or who knows any truth in nature or divinity that he did not read, hear, or study for as the result of what he read or heard. Even the person most proud of his knowledge must confess he came to it in exactly this way.

Question: But you will ask: "What, then, is the illumination of the Spirit, the enlightening of the mind that Scripture attributes to the Holy Spirit? Does not the understanding need the Spirit for light, just as the heart and will need him for life?"

Answer: Yes, without question, and it is a great and wonderful mercy. Here is what it consists in.

1. The Holy Spirit, by immediate inspiration, revealed to the apostles the doctrine of Christ and caused them infallibly to write the Scriptures. But this is not the ordinary mode of illumination now.

2. The Holy Spirit assists us in hearing, reading, and studying the Scriptures, so that through diligence we may arrive at a true understanding of them, but he does not give us that understanding apart from hearing, reading, or study. "Faith cometh by hearing" (Rom 10:17). He blesses the use of means to us, but does not bless us in the neglect of means.

3. The Holy Spirit opens the eyes and heart of a sinner who has heard and notionally understood the substance of the Gospel, so that what was known only in the mind, notionally and without effect, is now known piercingly, effectually, and practically. The knowledge of the same truth is now made powerful, as if it were of a different kind altogether. This is the Spirit’s sanctifying of the mind and his chief work of saving illumination: not by causing us to know anything of God, Christ, or heaven apart from means, but by opening the heart so that, through means, it may take in that knowledge deeply, knowledge that others hold only in dead opinion, and by making our knowledge clear, quick, and powerful enough to affect the heart and govern the life.

4. The Holy Spirit sanctifies all the notional knowledge a person possessed before their conversion. All their learning and natural abilities are now made subservient to Christ, directed to the right end, and turned into their proper channel.

5. The Holy Spirit, by sanctifying the heart, fills it with such love toward God, heaven, holiness, and truth as is a wonderful help in the pursuit of further knowledge. Experience shows how great an advantage it is to knowledge to have a constant love, delight, and desire toward the thing one wishes to understand.

In all these ways the Spirit is the enlightener of believers.

Failing to observe this direction will have serious effects. I will name them so you can see the necessity of avoiding them.

1. If you imagine that you are already people of great understanding, ability, and holiness, while you are young beginners and no more than newborn babes, you are entering the snare and condemnation of the devil, the odious sin of pride; indeed, a pride in those spiritual gifts that are most contrary to pride; and, worse, a pride in what you do not actually possess, which is the most foolish pride of all. Mark Paul’s words when he forbids placing a young beginner in religion into the ministry: "Not a novice, lest being lifted up with pride, he fall into the condemnation of the devil" (1 Tim 3:6). Why are young beginners more exposed to this danger than other Christians? One might suppose their infancy would make them conscious of their own weakness. But Paul knew what he was saying.

It is so for three reasons.

1.) Partly because the suddenness of their change, coming out of darkness into a light they had never seen before, astonishes and carries them away, making them feel they are almost in heaven and that there is not much more to be attained. This is like a beggar who has been given a hundred pounds and, never having seen a hundredth of that sum before, imagines he has as much money as the king.

2.) Partly because they do not yet have enough knowledge to know how many things they are still ignorant of. Petrarch said that whoever has a raw and conceited pupil is sailing against the wind and up the stream, nourishing a serpent, cultivating poison, and training an enemy. Such beginners have never heard of the difficulties in Scripture, the knots in school divinity, or the hard cases of conscience; whereas seven years of painstaking study will tell them of many hundreds of difficulties they never saw, and forty or fifty years of study beyond that will clothe them with shame and humility at the sense of their lamentable darkness.

3.) And partly because the devil applies himself with the greatest industry to laying this net for young converts, it being the path by which he has the greatest hope of success.

2. Your hasty presumption about your own goodness and ability will make you overconfident in your own strength, and so you will venture into dangerous temptations, which is the road to ruin. You will think yourself too well-informed to fear the company of Papists, or any heretics or deceivers, or to worry about reading their books or attending their worship. You may escape harm; but you may not, and God may leave you to your own devices "to shew you all that was in your hearts," as is said of Hezekiah (2 Chr 32:31, 25, 26).

3. Overvaluing your first grace will also make you dangerously secure at the very time your soul needs holy seriousness and care "to work out your salvation with fear and trembling" (Phil 2:12), and "to serve God acceptably, with reverence and godly fear, as knowing that he is a consuming fire" (Heb 12:28, 29). Such security is the forerunner of a fall.

4. It will lead you to neglect the steady labor and patience required for growth in knowledge and grace, since you already think yourself sufficiently advanced. You will end up worse than those who are always learning but never arrive at mature knowledge, because you will judge yourself fit to be a teacher when you still need to be taught things you refuse to submit to learning. As the text says, "When for the time ye ought to have been teachers, you will have need to be catechised, or taught again which be the first principles of the oracles of God, as having need of milk, and not of strong meat." Note how the Holy Spirit makes time and practice necessary to the kind of growth that qualifies one to teach. For it adds, "But strong meat belongeth to them that are of full age; those who by reason of use have their senses exercised to discern both good and evil" (Heb 5:12–14). Note carefully how wisdom and strength are to be expected, not assumed from the start.

5. This over-hasty presumption of your own ability will tempt you to rush into controversies and disputes for which you are not ready, and so divert you from the studies that are actually necessary and appropriate to your stage.

6. It will make you overconfident of all your own opinions and rigid in all your own notions, too much like the one described in Proverbs 14:16: "The fool rageth and is confident." I have heard, more times than I can count, a man who did not understand what he was saying, and could scarcely speak sense, argue for his opinion with such assurance that he scorned or pitied the wisest person who disagreed, while his ignorance, frantic confidence, and anger made him a genuine object of pity to people of ordinary understanding. There is a kind of madness in this condition that will not leave you enough judgment to recognize that you are afflicted by it.

7. It will also make you harshly judgmental of others. This ignorant pride will lead you to mistake other people’s genuine knowledge for ignorance, if they do not share your particular opinions; and to mistake other people’s true grace for none at all, if they are not of your mind and your party. No one is more ready than such a person to dismiss those who are far wiser and better than themselves, those they may have no real acquaintance with, as being merely moral, civil people, or as being mistaken and deluded. It is a very ugly thing to hear an ignorant, self-satisfied person speak of those who are a hundred times wiser and much better than himself with a commanding air of proud pity or contempt, as if he were the wise one, not knowing what he says.

8. It will make you rebellious against your governors and teachers, and entirely unteachable, despising those whose place it is to instruct and guide you. You will think yourselves wiser than your teachers while you are still in the lowest class. It is to such people that James speaks in James 3:1: "My brethren, be not many masters (or teachers), knowing that ye shall receive the greater condemnation." That whole chapter, well worth your careful study, addresses exactly this condition.

9. In this way it will draw you into heretical opinions, for which there is no more fertile soil than pride taking hold of half-formed, young beginners in religion.

10. And so it will make you troublers of the church, contending without peace for things you do not truly understand.

11. It also tends toward hypocrisy, causing you to give thanks for what you never truly possessed, puffed up with a knowledge that is not sufficient to keep you humble, and lacking the love that would build up both yourself and others (1 Cor 8:1).

12. It tends to deceive you in the matter of assurance of salvation, leading you to mistake your own inflated self-esteem for true assurance, which is not ordinarily to be expected until grace has come to much greater strength.

13. Last, it tends to corrupt your understanding of the very nature of Christianity itself, as you judge it in others according to your own overvalued standard. If you truly knew Christianity as it appears in the heart and practice of the sober, wise, humble, loving, peaceable, self-denying, heaven-focused believer, you would see that it carries a far higher glory than anything you are currently displaying.

I have laid out all these harmful effects of overvaluing your beginnings in religion so that, as you love your souls, you may avoid them. It is a matter of the greatest importance for your safety and perseverance that, while you are infants in grace, you know yourself to be such, so that you may keep your proper place, learn first the lessons that must be learned first, "walk humbly with your God, and obey those that are over you in the Lord," wait on the Spirit through the use of appointed means, and not gladden the tempter by corrupting all that you have received and imitating his fall from a state of hope (Heb 13:7, 17 1 Thess 1:5 1 Thess 5:12).

CHAPTER 8

DIRECTION 6: DO NOT BE DISCOURAGED BY DIFFICULTIES AND OPPOSITION WHEN YOU BEGIN TO WALK WITH GOD

 

"Be not discouraged at the difficulties and oppositions which will rise up before you, when you begin resolvedly to walk with God."

Just as discouragement keeps multitudes away from religion altogether, it is also a powerful temptation that turns many young beginners back, making them, like the Israelites in the wilderness, ready to wish themselves in Egypt again. Three kinds of discouragement rise up before them. 1. Some arise from the nature of the work itself. 2. Some come from God’s trials. 3. Some come from the malice of the devil and his instruments, or from all three together.

1. It is only to be expected that infants and weaklings will find even a small burden heavy and an easy journey wearying. Young beginners are ordinarily at a loss and confused in every trade, art, or science.

Young scholars face a far harder task before they are well established than afterward. Learning is astonishingly hard and unpleasant at first; but once a student is well grounded, the knowledge of one thing helps unlock another, and progress comes with ease. So a young convert who was raised in ignorance, never accustomed to hearing prayer, or heavenly discourse, or to joining with those who practiced such things, will find it strange and hard at first. Those who were used to seeking pleasure, indulging the desires of the flesh, and perhaps to swearing, filthy talk, idle chatter, or lying, will find real difficulty at first in breaking those habits and living a mortified, holy life. Yet grace will accomplish it and prevail. Especially in the areas of knowledge and ability to express yourself, do not be too hasty in your expectations. Wait patiently, making faithful and diligent use of the means, and what once discouraged you with its difficulties will afterward become easy and delightful.

2. God himself intends that his servants and their graces should be tried and exercised by difficulties. He never intended the reward for sitting still, nor the crown of victory without a fight, nor a fight without an enemy and opposition. Even innocent Adam was not ready for his state of confirmation and reward until he had been tried by temptation. It is for this reason that the martyrs bear the most glorious crown, having undergone the greatest trial. Shall we presume to murmur at the method of God?

3. Satan, having liberty to tempt and try us, will quickly raise up storms and waves the moment we set sail, storms that make young beginners fear they will never live to reach the harbor. He will show you the greatness of your former sins, to persuade you they will never be pardoned. He will show you the strength of your passions and corruptions, to make you think they will never be overcome. He will show you the greatness of the opposition and suffering you are likely to face, to make you think you will never persevere.

He will do his worst to meet you with poverty, losses, setbacks, injuries, vexations, persecutions, and cruelties, yes, and unkindness from your dearest friends, as he did with Job, to make you think ill of God or of his service. If he can, he will turn those of your own household into your enemies. He will stir up your father, mother, husband, wife, brother, sister, or children against you, to persuade or persecute you away from Christ. This is why Christ tells us that if we do not hate all these, that is, if we cannot forsake them and treat them as men treat what they hate, when they would turn us from him, we cannot be his disciples (Luke 14:26; Matt 10). If you have once enlisted against Satan in the army of Christ, and resolved to be saved whatever it costs you, expect the worst the devil can do against you. Read Hebrews 11.

Yet consider how little cause you have to be discouraged, even if earth and hell should do their worst, from these few considerations.

1.) God is on your side. He holds all your enemies in his hand and can rebuke or destroy them in a moment. What is the fury of dust or devils against the Lord Almighty? "If God be for us, who can be against us?" (Rom 8:31). Read that chapter often. On the day you entered into covenant with God and he with you, you entered the most impregnable rock and fortress, housing yourself in a stronghold where you may, with due modesty, defy all the adverse powers of earth or hell. If God cannot save you, he is not God. And if he will not save you, he must break his covenant. He may indeed resolve to save you not from affliction and persecution, but in and by it. But in all such sufferings you will "be more than conquerors, through Christ that loveth you" (Rom 8:37), meaning it is far more excellent and desirable to conquer by patience in suffering for Christ than to conquer persecutors in the field by force of arms.

Reflect on the triumphant confidence of the saints in their God: "God is our refuge and strength, a very present help in trouble: therefore will not we fear, though the earth be removed, and though the mountains be carried into the midst of the sea." (Ps 46:1–3). When his "enemies were many" and "wrested his words daily," and "fought against him, and all their thoughts were against him," yet he said, "What time I am afraid, I will trust in thee. In God I will praise his word; in God I have put my trust: I will not fear what flesh can do unto me." (Ps 56:1–5).

Remember Christ’s charge: "Be not afraid of them that kill the body, and after that have no more that they can do. But I will forewarn you whom ye shall fear: fear him, which after he hath killed, hath power to cast into hell; yea, I say unto you, Fear him." (Luke 12:4–5). If all the world were on your side you might still have cause to fear; but to have God on your side is infinitely more.

2.) Jesus Christ is the Captain of your salvation (Heb 2:10), and has himself gone before you along this very road and has conquered on your behalf. He is now committed to making you a conqueror. Will you not go forward where Christ leads the way? He was himself perfected through suffering, and he will ensure that suffering does not destroy you. Can you draw back when you see his footsteps and his blood?

3.) You are not to conquer in your own strength, but by the Spirit of God and the power of a grace that is sufficient for you, a strength that appears most fully in our weakness (2 Cor 12:9). And you "can do all things through Christ that strengtheneth" you (Phil 4:13). "Be of good cheer, he hath overcome the world." (John 16:33).

4.) All who are in heaven have traveled this same road and have overcome oppositions and difficulties just like these. They were tempted, troubled, scorned, and opposed just as you are, and yet they now triumph in glory. "These are they that come out of great tribulation, and have washed their robes, and made them white in the blood of the Lamb. Therefore are they before the throne of God, and serve him day and night in his temple: and he that sitteth on the throne, shall dwell among them." (Rev 7:14–15). And all who ever come to heaven at the age of accountability are likely to come by this same way. Does not the company encourage you? Does not the success of those who have overcome before you encourage you? Will you have the end while refusing the way?

5.) Consider how much greater difficulties ungodly men go through on their way to hell. They face stronger enemies than you do: the devil and wicked men are your enemies, but God himself is theirs, and still they press on. Men threaten you with nothing worse than death, to discourage you; God threatens ungodly men with damnation, to discourage them, and still they are not discouraged. Will you be more afraid of man than sinners are of God? More afraid of death or scorn than they are of hell?

6.) Moreover, if discouragement causes you to turn from the way of godliness, you will be throwing your soul upon far greater evils. You will be running into hell for fear of burning; choosing everlasting death to escape a temporal death or something less. You will be choosing God as your enemy in order to escape the enmity of man. Consider how wise a course that is, especially when, if your ways please God, he can "make your enemies be at peace with you," when he sees it for your good (Prov 16:7). If you must fear, fear him who can damn the soul.

7.) Finally, remember the abundance of mercies you have to sweeten your present life and make your burden light. You have all that is truly good for you in this life, and the promise of everlasting joy: "for godliness is profitable to all things" (1 Tim 4:8). Think of the mercies in your body, your circumstances, your friends, your reputation, and above all your soul. Think of the promises and past experiences that refresh you, the freedom of access to God, a Christ to rejoice in, a heaven to rejoice in, and shall a stony or muddy road discourage you more than all these comfort you?

The sum of it all is this: your work will grow easier and sweeter as your skill and strength increase. Your enemies are as grasshoppers before you. The power of the Almighty is pledged, by love and by promise, to help you. Do you claim to trust in God, and yet will you fear the face of man? "I gave my back to the smiters, and my cheeks to them that plucked off the hair: I hid not my face from shame and spitting. For the Lord God will help me; therefore shall I not be confounded: therefore have I set my face like a flint, and I know that I shall not be ashamed. He is near that justifieth me; who will contend with me? let us stand together: who is mine adversary? let him come near to me. Behold, the Lord God will help me; who is he that shall condemn me? lo, they all shall wax old as a garment; the moth shall eat them up." (Isa 50:6–9).

"Hearken unto me, ye that know righteousness, the people in whose heart is my law; fear ye not the reproach of men, neither be afraid of their revilings. For the moth shall eat them up like a garment, and the worm shall eat them like wool: but my righteousness shall be for ever, and my salvation from generation to generation." (Isa 51:7–8). No soldier of Christ should turn back for fear of scorn or of anything that man can do against him.

And consider whether heaven ought to be more easily reached. The things you are striving for are of unspeakable glory. They are unworthily despised if any earthly thing is thought too precious to part with for their sake, or any labor, difficulty, or suffering too great to endure in order to obtain them.

CHAPTER 9

DIRECTION 7: LIVE UNDER A JUDICIOUS AND POWERFUL MINISTER AND USE HIS PRIVATE COUNSEL

 

‘If it is in your power, live under a judicious, faithful, serious, searching, and powerful minister; diligently attend his public teaching, and make use of his private counsel for more particular direction and application, for settling and managing the affairs of your souls, just as you take the advice of physicians for your health, of lawyers for your estates, and of tutors for your studies.’

I give this direction only to those who may enjoy so great a mercy if they choose. Some live where no such minister is to be found. Some are children, servants, or wives who are bound and cannot move their households or enjoy such liberty, because others will not permit it. Some are too poor to remove their dwelling for such advantages. And some are so useful where they are that they may be bound to remain under a very weak minister in order to do good to others where they have the best opportunity. But whoever can be free and possess so great a mercy, let him accept it thankfully, even at some cost. As Christ said in another case, "Every man cannot receive the saying; but he that can receive it, let him."

Filesacus urges that it is most useful for people to know that meanings are to be preferred to words as the soul is preferred to the body, so that they ought to prefer hearing truer sermons rather than more eloquent ones, just as they ought to prefer wiser friends rather than better-looking ones. Let them know too, he adds, that no voice reaches the ears of God except the affection of the soul; for then they will not mock if they happen to notice some prelates and ministers calling upon God with barbarisms and solecisms, or not understanding the words they pronounce and dividing them confusedly. Juvenal said that many have come to regret the vain and barren professor’s chair. Bucholtzer wrote that he was the harder on the Italian Ciceronians because they speak only words and not things, and their rhetoric is for the most part a gloss without a text, a nut without a kernel, a cloud without rain: the feathers are better than the bird itself.

Take care that prejudice, or any other corruption, does not take possession of your minds; for then everything you hear will be distasteful or unprofitable to you. Great must be the eloquence, Seneca said, that pleases the unwilling.

There is an enormous difference between a weak, unskilled, inexperienced, dead-hearted, and formal teacher and one such as is described in this Direction. Some who are themselves senseless or indifferent in such matters would persuade you to be so as well, to look first, when choosing where to settle, at bodily conveniences, and to be content with whatever teacher you happen to find. They will tell you that the work of grace depends not on the preacher’s gifts but on the gift and blessing of the Spirit of God. The Formalists and the Enthusiasts agree on this point, though from different principles.

Yet although God can render the fittest means fruitless, and can work without means or through means least suited to the end, his ordinary way is to work by means, for the soul as well as for the body, and most effectively by the most apt means. I am sure it is the duty of every teacher to preach in the manner best fitted to his people’s edification, and not to do God’s work carelessly and inaptly simply because God can bless the least fit means. Equally, it is the people’s duty to attend upon the best they can obtain, even though God could just as well work through the weakest or through none at all.

That pretense will not excuse those who hold God’s ordinances in contempt and stay home on every slight occasion, attending no ministry at all. Nor will it excuse those who refuse the help most suited to their edification and settle for a worse when they might have a better. We must not neglect duty on a presumptuous expectation of miraculous or extraordinary works. When we can have nothing better, we may hope for greater benefit even from the weakest minister; but not when the choice comes from our own presumptuous and irreligious hearts.

God could make Daniel and his companions thrive better on pulse than others who feasted at the king’s table; and rather than sin against God, we must cast ourselves on him for unusual supplies, or leave everything to his will. But few would therefore be persuaded, without cause, to live on pulse when they might have better. And one would think this truth would face no contradiction, especially from those who tend to minimize the Spirit’s operations on the soul and to recognize no grace except what consists in a fitting arrangement of means and circumstances. When their doctrine places all a man’s hope of salvation on this very fitness of means and circumstances, how can they then teach men to undervalue or neglect the fittest means and willfully cast their souls upon the most unfit? But ungodliness first decides what to speak against, and only then decides what to say; it will contradict God’s word even when it contradicts its own, and will oppose holiness even by self-contradiction.

The spiritual taste and experience of the godly, however, is a powerful protection against such deluding arguments. It is harder for the most subtle and authoritative sophist to persuade someone who has tasted sugar that it is bitter or that wormwood is sweet, than to persuade one who has never tasted either. And it is hard to convince a healthy man that it is best for him to eat only once a week, or to live on grass or snow. I have no doubt that those to whom I now speak have sufficient experience and perception of the benefit of a judicious and lively ministry, compared to an ignorant, cold, and lifeless one, that no words will make them indifferent on this point.

Have you not found that the ministry of one kind enlightens, warms, quickens, comforts, and strengthens you far more than the other? I am sure I have the common sense and experience of the faithful on my side in this, and that alone is enough, against whatever can be said against it. Even those newly born in Christ have in their new natures a desire, not for senseless or malicious chatter, but for the rational, sincere milk, that they may grow by it and offer to God a rational service (Rom 12:1).

It must take a very proud and dull heart to be so unaware of its own weakness, sinfulness, and need as to suppose that the weakest and dullest minister will serve well enough, that such a person is able to maintain life, vigor, watchfulness, and fruitfulness with any small, ordinary help. I cannot help but fear that such people do not know what the power and efficacy of the Word upon heart and conscience means; nor what it is to live a life of faith and holiness, to watch the heart, and to walk with God.

If they knew these things, they could not fail to find how much difficulty lies in them, and how much backwardness and incompetence they themselves bring to them, and this would make them feel the necessity of the greatest helps. They could not help feeling the difference between a clear and quickening sermon and an ignorant, lifeless discourse spoken as if the man were talking in his sleep, or speaking of something he never understood and had no experience of.

How readily do even the best believers grow cold if they are not kept warm by a powerful ministry! How readily do they lose their hatred of sin, their tenderness of conscience, their fervency in prayer, their zeal and fullness in edifying discourse, and those delights and powers of heavenly meditation they once possessed! How readily does faith waver when it is not powerfully supported by those who are helpers of our faith! How hard it is to maintain the warmth of love, the confidence of hope, and the full resolution of obedience without the help of a powerful ministry! Indeed, how difficult it is to do even our own part in any tolerable measure, even when we have the clearest and liveliest helps that are ordinarily available!

Can anyone who is not blind and proud imagine they are so holy and strong that they are above the need of such assistance, that the feeblest breath is enough to kindle the fire of holy love and zeal and keep them in the fear and obedience of God? We live under a languishing weakness and must be nourished with the best or we will soon decay. We are cripples who cannot walk or stand without our crutches. There must be some savor of the Spirit in the one who would make us spiritual; some savor of faith and love in the one who would kindle faith and love in us. He must speak clearly and convincingly to be understood and to prevail with people such as we are. He must speak with feeling to make us feel, and speak seriously if he would be taken seriously and make us serious.

Ministers are not set up only for public preaching but also for private counsel suited to your particular needs. Just as physicians do not merely issue you general instructions on diet and treatment but are present in your sickness to direct the specific application of remedies, and just as lawyers assist you in your particular cases, freeing your estates from encumbrances and protecting or rescuing them from contentious people, so you should choose some able minister to serve as your regular counselor in the things of God. Let him be someone who is humble, faithful, experienced, and skilled, and who has the leisure, ability, and willingness to assist you.

Acosta notes it as a great hindrance to the Indians’ conversion that their teachers move on for better livings and do not remain until they are well acquainted with the people, and that the bishops are of the same temper. He writes that this great ruin of souls cannot be sufficiently lamented, and that no priest of Christ will accomplish anything notable for the salvation of the Indians without an intimate knowledge of both the people and their circumstances. Many, he observes, think they have fully discharged their duty by repeatedly reciting the Lord’s Prayer, the Creed, the angelic salutation, and the precepts of the Decalogue in Spanish to the Indians, baptizing their infants, burying their dead, marrying their young, and performing the sacred rite on feast days, and their consciences are not troubled (would that they were not so seared) that the sheep of the Lord are scattered abroad.

Just as infants in a household cannot help themselves and need the constant assistance of others, and God therefore plants in parents a special love for their children, making them diligent and patient in caring for them, so it is in the family of Christ. The great majority of Christians are young or weak in understanding and in grace. It will be a long time before you are past the need of others’ help, if indeed you ever are in this life. If you do not feel this weakness and need in yourself, it is only the greater for that.

God will have no one be self-sufficient: we all have need of one another, so that we may be useful to one another, and God may use us as his messengers and instruments for conveying his mercies to each other, and that even self-love may draw us toward community and mutual care. Our souls must receive their share of mercy through this way of communication just as our bodies do. Therefore, as the poor above all others should not be opposed to charity and the sharing of goods, since they need it most, so young Christians who are weak and inexperienced should above all others be most eager for help, especially from an able and faithful guide.

Be sure, however, that you deal sincerely and do not cheat yourselves by deceiving your counselor and hiding the true state of your case. To do this with your lawyer is the way to lose your suit; to do it with your physician is the way to lose your life; and to do it with your pastor and soul-counselor is the way to lose your soul. Let the judgment of your pastor or judicious friend concerning the state of your soul carry real weight with you, even though it is not infallible. How far such a person is to be trusted I will open to you later, together with other duties belonging to this relationship; for now I proceed only to general advice.

CHAPTER 10

DIRECTION 8: ON CHARITY, UNITY, AND SCHISM AMONG BELIEVERS

 

"Keep right understanding of the excellence of charity and unity among believers, and do not hastily receive anything that works against them. In particular, guard against attaching yourself so strongly to any sect or party, whether on grounds of their authority, their numbers, their soundness, or their holiness, that you withdraw your special love and rightful communion from other Christians, or redirect your zeal toward the interests of your party while neglecting the common interest of the church. Instead, love a Christian as a Christian, and work for the unity and welfare of all." (Against uncharitableness and schism, see more in Part II, chapter 23.)

Read often, and carefully consider the meaning and reasoning behind the many urgent passages of Scripture that call all Christians to unity and love. These include (John 11:52, John 17:11, John 17:21–23, 1 Cor 3:10, 1 Cor 3:17, and 1 Cor 12 throughout, 2 Cor 13:11, 1 Thess 5:12–13, Phil 2:1–3, 1 Pet 3:8, Rom 16:17, 1 Cor 1:10, 1 Cor 3:3, 1 Cor 11:18, John 13:35, Rom 12:9–10, Rom 13:10, Gal 5:6, Gal 5:13, Gal 5:22, Col 1:4, 1 Thess 4:9, 1 John 3:14, 1 John 3:23, 1 John 4:7, 1 John 4:11, 1 John 4:16, 1 John 4:19–21).

If the very life of godliness did not depend greatly on unity and love, such words would never have been spoken about it as you find in those passages. Love is to the soul what natural warmth is to the body: whatever destroys it destroys life, and therefore cannot be for our good. Be certain that any opinion, course, or movement that tends to diminish your love for your brothers and sisters tends toward death, and far more so when, under the pretense of zeal, it moves you to hate and harm them.

To divide the body is to kill it or to maim it: dividing the essential, necessary parts is killing it; cutting off any integral part is maiming it. The former can never be an act of friendship, it is the worst thing an enemy can do. The latter is never an act of friendship except when cutting off a member that might otherwise be spared is absolutely necessary to save the whole person from the worse division between soul and body. By this standard, judge what kind of friends those who cause division are to the church, and how well they are accepted of God.

Whoever truly loves any Christian must love all who appear to him as Christians. When malice prevents someone from recognizing genuine Christianity in the credible profession of another, this is just as contrary to Christian love as hating someone you know to be a true Christian. Unwarranted censoriousness, not constrained by just evidence, is as contrary to love as hatred itself.

There is a union and communion with Christians as such. This consists in sharing one God, one Head, one Spirit, one faith, one baptismal covenant, one rule of holy living, and in loving and praying for all, and doing good to as many as we can. This is a union and communion of mind, which we must hold with the universal church throughout the world.

There is also a bodily, local union and communion, which consists in joining in body as well as in mind with particular congregations. Since we cannot hold this simultaneously with all congregations, nor with more than one at a time, we are not bound to hold it with any congregation that drives us away unless we would sin. As a settled matter, we must hold bodily communion with the church to which we are regularly joined and with which we live. On appropriate occasions, we must hold it with all others where we have a call and opportunity, who worship God according to his Word in substance and do not compel us to sin in conforming to them.

It is not schism to lament the sins of any church, or of all the churches in the world, the universal church on earth consists of sinners. It is not schism to refuse to share in any sin of even the purest church in the world: obedience to God is not schism. It is not schism that you do not join bodily with congregations where you do not live and have no particular call to join; nor that you choose the purest and most edifying society rather than one less pure and profitable to you, all else being equal, when you are free to choose; nor that you do not hold bodily communion with a church that will not permit you to do so without sinning against God; nor that you do not join the purest church when you are called to remain with one less pure.

But it is worse than schism to separate from the universal church. To separate from its faith is apostasy and infidelity. To separate from it in one or a few essential articles while professing to hold to Christ the Head is heresy. To separate from it in spirit, by refusing holiness and refusing to love those who are truly holy, is a damning ungodliness and wickedness. To differ from it by any error of judgment or conduct against the law of God is sin. To so magnify any one church or party as to deny due love and communion to the rest is schism. To confine the whole church to your party and deny all or any of the rest to be Christians and parts of the universal church is schism through a dangerous breach of charity, and this is the principal schism I am here warning you to avoid.

It is also schism to unjustly condemn any particular church as no church at all; and it is schism to withdraw your bodily communion from a church you were bound to maintain that communion with, on the false assumption that it is no church, or that communion with it is unlawful. And it is schism to make divisions or parties within a church, even if you do not formally separate from it. With this I have briefly set out what schism is.

1. One pretense for schism is usurped authority, the claim by some one church to command others who owe it no obedience. In this way, pride, which is the spirit of hell, crept into the church of Christ, stirred up usurpations of lordship and dominion, and fueled contention for superiority, causing the most dangerous schisms by which the church has ever been afflicted.

The bishop of Rome, advantaged by the seat and constitution of that empire, claimed to govern the entire Christian world and condemned all churches unwilling to be his subjects. In doing so, he made himself the head of a sect and of the most destructive schism that ever tore the church of Christ. The bishop of Constantinople, and far too many others, followed the same method in lesser degree, exalting themselves above their brothers, imposing laws on them, and then condemning and persecuting those who would not obey. Having imposed their usurped authority and laws on other churches, they arranged things so that all who refused to acknowledge their tyrannical usurpation were branded schismatics and sectarians, when in truth those who would not be schismatics and sectarians with them were the ones so accused.

The deception lies in this: they confuse the church’s unity with their own pretended authority, and identify schism with refusal of submission to themselves. If you will not accept them as your lords, they cry out that you are dividing from the church, as though we could hold communion with no churches except those whose bishops we obey. Communion with other churches is maintained by faith, charity, and agreement in necessary things, without subjection to them. Just as we may hold all rightful communion with the churches in Armenia, Arabia, and Russia without being subject to their bishops, so we may hold such communion with any church of which we are not members. Division and schism are contrary to unity and concord, not to usurped government, though disobedience to the pastors God has genuinely set over us is a sin, and dividing from them is schism.

Both the Pope and all lesser usurpers would do well first to show their commission from God to be our rulers, before calling it schism to refuse their government. Had they not made better use of fire and sword than of Scripture and argument, the world would not have laughed them to scorn upon hearing them say: "All are schismatics who will not be our subjects; our dominion and will shall be necessary to the unity of the church." The universal church is indeed one, united under one Head and Governor, but that Head is Jesus Christ alone, and not any usurping vicar or Vice-Christ. The bishops of particular churches are his officers, but he has appointed no vicar to his own office as the universal Head. Above all sects, beware of this pernicious sect, which cites its own usurped authority as the ground of its schism, and has no means of advancing its cause except by calling all who refuse to be its sectarian subjects schismatics themselves.

2. Another pretext for schism is the size of the party. This is one of the Papists’ arguments, as if dividing the church of Christ were lawful, provided they can claim the larger number. They say, "We are the majority, and therefore you should yield to us." (Others make the same argument wherever the sword has forced the majority into submission.) But our answer is this: however many they are, they are still too few to constitute the universal church. The universal church, comprising all true professing Christians, is far larger than their communion. Papists are not a third part, perhaps not even a fourth, of the whole church. Papists are a corrupted sect of Christians. I am opposed to dividing the body of Christ into any sect, and I refuse to belong to that sect or divided party, however large it may be.

3. Another pretext for schism is the supposed soundness or orthodoxy of a party. Almost every sect claims to be wiser and more doctrinally sound than the rest of the Christian world, including those who most plainly contradict Scripture (as Papists do in their communion in one kind and their unintelligible worship), and who have no better reason for their beliefs and practices than that others have held and done the same before them.

But, first, the loudest claimants to orthodoxy are not necessarily the most orthodox. Second, even if they were more orthodox in some respects, I can value them for their excellence without withdrawing proper respect from the rest of the church. Third, the whole church is orthodox in all the essentials of Christianity, otherwise its members would not be Christians at all, and I must love all Christians with the special love owed to the members of Christ, while also giving appropriate additional esteem to those who are somewhat wiser or more faithful than others.

4. The fourth pretext for schism is the holiness of the party a person adheres to. But holiness can only account for a difference of degree in our esteem and love for some Christians over others. If a group genuinely is more holy, I should love them more and strive to be as holy as they are, but that gives me no right to unjustly withhold communion or due respect from other, less holy Christians, nor to cleave to the holier group as a sect or divided party. For the holiest people are also the most charitable, most opposed to divisions among Christians, and most tender of their unity and peace.

The substance of this Direction is as follows:

1. Value Christian love and unity highly.

2. Love those most who are most holy, and seek their company for your own growth in godliness. Where you have a choice, maintain your local personal communion with the soundest, purest, and best-qualified church.

3. Do not hastily adopt the odd opinions of a divided party; and if you do hold such an opinion, do not place more weight on it than the evidence warrants.

4. Acknowledge the best as best, but do not acknowledge any group as a separated sect, and do not adopt their divisive cause as your own.

5. Do not confine your special love to a party, especially not on the basis of shared opinions, but extend it to all the members of Christ.

6. Do not refuse local communion, when occasion calls for it, to any church that holds the substance of true worship and does not compel you to sin.

7. Love them as true Christians and true churches, even when they drive you from their communion.

It is a most dangerous thing for a young convert to be drawn into a sect. Before you are aware of it, a sect will possess you with a feverish, sinful zeal for its opinions and interests; it will make you bold in bitter attacks and judgments against those who differ from it; it will corrupt your participation in the church and fill even your prayers with partiality and human passion; it will secretly bring malice into your mind and speech under the name of zeal. In a word, it is a hidden but deadly enemy to Christian love and peace.

Let those who are wiser, more orthodox, and more godly than others show it in the way the Holy Spirit directs: "Who is a wise man and endued with knowledge among you? let him shew out of a good conversation his works with meekness of wisdom. But if ye have bitter envying (or zeal) and strife in your hearts, glory not, and lie not against the truth. This wisdom descendeth not from above, but is earthly, sensual, devilish. For where envying and strife is, there is confusion (or tumult), and every evil work. But the wisdom that is from above, is first pure, then peaceable, gentle, and easy to be entreated, full of mercy and good fruits, without partiality (or wrangling), and without hypocrisy. And the fruit of righteousness is sown in peace of them that make peace." (Jas 3:13–18)

CHAPTER 11

DIRECTION 9: DO NOT LET PERSECUTION DRIVE YOU INTO PASSION OR SIN

 

‘Take heed lest any persecution or wrong from others provoke you to any unwarrantable passions and practices, and deprive you of the charity, meekness, and innocency of a Christian; or make you go beyond your bounds in censuring, reviling, or resisting your rulers, who are the officers of God.’

Persecution and wrongs are called temptations in Scripture because they try you, to see whether you will hold your integrity. As many fall in such trials through the fear of men and love of the world and its prosperity, so when you seem most firmly resolved against any sinful compliance, a snare is laid for you on the other side, to draw you into passions and practices that are unwarrantable.

Those tainted with pride, uncharitableness, and schism will itch to persecute those who do not conform to their way, and yet, while doing so, they will cry out loudest against pride, uncharitableness, and schism in others. This has been, is, and will be all too common in the world. You might think that those who claim to act entirely for order and unity would be the last to cause division. But never expect to see this generally remedied, no matter how much you say or do: you must resolve not only to flee from church-division yourselves, but also to endure the persecutions and wrongs of proud or zealous church-dividers.

It is great weakness to think such treatment strange. Do you not know that enmity was placed, from the beginning, between the woman’s seed and the serpent’s seed? Do you think the name or dead profession of Christianity extinguishes that enmity in the serpent’s seed? Do you expect to find more kindness from proud, ungodly Christians than Abel could have expected from his brother Cain? Do you not know that the Pharisees, through their zeal for preeminence, their traditions and ceremonies, and their expectation of worldly power from the Messiah, were more zealous enemies of Christ than the heathens were? And that the carnal members of the church are often the greatest persecutors of the spiritual members? "As then he that was born after the flesh, did persecute him that was born after the Spirit, even so it is now" (Gal 4:29) (and will be). It is enough for you that you shall receive the inheritance, when the sons of the bondwoman are cast out.

It is your treating the ordinary condition of the godly as something strange that leaves you so disturbed and passionate when you suffer. And reason goes down when passion rises. It is by overwhelming reason with passion and discontent that "oppression maketh" some "wise men mad" (Eccl 7:7), for passion is a brief, imperfect madness. In your passion you will think you are doing well when you are doing ill; and you will not perceive the force of reason, however plain and full it stands against you.

Remember, therefore, that the devil’s chief motive in persecuting you is not to harm your body, but to tempt your soul into impatience and sin. And if it can be said of you as of Job, "In all this Job sinned not" (Job 1:22), you have won the victory, and are "more than conquerors" (Rom 8:37–39).

Does it seem strange to you that "few rich men are saved," when Christ tells you it is "so hard" as to be "impossible with men" (Luke 18:27)? Or is it strange that rich men should ordinarily be the rulers of the earth? Or that the wicked should harm the godly, and that the world should hate those who are "chosen out of the world"? None of this should seem strange. Expect it as the common lot of the faithful, and you will be far better prepared for it.

See to it, therefore, that you "resist not evil" (Matt 5:39) by any vengeful or irregular violence. "Let every soul be subject to the higher powers, and not resist lest they receive damnation" (Rom 13:1–3). Imitate your Lord, who "when he was reviled, reviled not again; when he suffered he threatened not, but committed all to him that judgeth righteously; leaving us an ensample, that we should follow his steps" (1 Pet 2:21, 23).

An angry zeal against those who cross and harm us is so easily kindled and so hard to suppress that it becomes clear there is more of corrupted nature in it than of God. We are very ready to think we may "call for fire from heaven" upon the enemies of the Gospel, but "you know not what manner of spirit ye are then of" (Luke 9:55). Christ says to you: "Love your enemies, bless them that curse you, do good to them that hate you, and pray for them that despitefully use you, and persecute you; that ye may be the children of your Father which is in heaven" (Matt 5:44–45). You will find no such prohibition against patiently bearing wrong from anyone.

Take heed of entertaining secret wishes for harm to your adversaries, or of returning reproachful words against them. Take heed of injuring yourself through passion or sin merely because others injure you through slanders or persecutions. Keep to the path of your duty, and leave your name and your life to God. Be diligent to preserve your innocency; in your patience possess your souls; and God will ensure that no harm from enemies reaches you except what he will cause to work for your good. Read Psalm 37: "Commit thy way unto the Lord; trust also in him; and he shall bring it to pass. And he shall bring forth thy righteousness as the light, and thy judgment as the noon-day. Rest in the Lord, and wait patiently for him: fret not thyself because of him who prospereth in his way, because of the man who bringeth wicked devices to pass. Cease from anger, and forsake wrath: fret not thyself in anywise to do evil." (Ps 37:5–8)

CHAPTER 12

DIRECTION 10: WHEN REPENTING OF ONE EXTREME, GUARD AGAINST THE OPPOSITE

 

"When you are repenting of, or avoiding any extreme, do it not without sufficient fear and caution of the contrary extreme."

In your esteem and love of God as your ultimate end, you need not fear going too far, nor anywhere else where impediment, reluctance, or weakness tells you that you can never do too much. But sin lies on both sides of the rule and the right way, and nothing is more common than turning from one sin to another under the name of duty or amendment.

This is especially common in matters of opinion. Some will first believe that God is nothing but mercy, and afterward take notice of nothing but his justice. First they believe that almost all are saved, and afterward that almost none are. First they think every profession of faith is credible, and next that none is credible without some greater proof. First they hold that Christ satisfied for none who will not be saved, and next that he died for all alike. First they say that none now share in the Holy Spirit; and next, that all saints have the Spirit, not only to illuminate and sanctify them by writing the Word upon their hearts, but also to inspire them with new revelations in place of Scripture.

First they think that everything the Papists hold or do must be avoided; and afterward, that no reformation was needed at all. Now they are for legal bondage, and shortly after for libertinism. Today they allow religious liberty to none who do not agree with them in every detail; tomorrow they allow it to everyone. This year all things are lawful to them; the next year nothing is lawful, and they scruple everything they say or do. At one time they are entirely for worship of mere show and ceremony; at another time they oppose even the setting of basic circumstances of order and decency by human authority. At one time they speak of nothing but free grace; at another, of nothing but free will. At one time they favor discipline stricter than the rule requires; at another time, no discipline at all. First timorous compliance with evil; and afterward, contemptuous defiance of all government. Many more such examples could be given.

The remedy for this disease is to proceed deliberately, receiving nothing and doing nothing rashly or without careful thought in religion. When you have discovered your first error, you will be driven by fear of it straight into the contrary error. You must look all around you, attending as carefully to the error you may fall into on the other side as to the one you have already committed. Consult with wise and experienced people. Take note of the unhappy fate of those who have fallen on both sides, and do not wait to learn the danger by painful experience. True moderation is the only safe way, though negligence and lukewarmness are odious even when dressed in that name.

CHAPTER 13

DIRECTION 11: HOLD YOUR FIRST OPINIONS ON DISPUTED POINTS MODESTLY

 

‘Do not let your first opinions about the controverted difficulties in religion, where Scripture is not very plain, be too peremptory, confident, or fixed. Hold them modestly, with a due suspicion of your unripe understanding, and with room for further information, supposing it possible or probable that, upon better instruction, evidence, and maturity, you may in such things change your mind.’

I know that the factious, who take up their religion on the credit of their party, are against this Direction. They think you must first find the right church and then hold whatever that church holds, and therefore never change your mind about anything you receive in that way. I know also that some libertines and half-believers would corrupt this Direction by extending it to the plainest and most necessary truths, persuading you to hold Christianity itself as nothing more than an uncertain, probable opinion.

But as God’s foundation stands sure, so we must be surely built upon it. Whoever does not believe the essentials of Christianity as a certain, necessary revelation of God is not a Christian but an infidel. And whoever does not believe all that he understands in the Word of God believes nothing on the credit of that Word. Sincere believers do have weakness of faith; they must lament the remnants of unbelief and cry, "Lord increase our faith: help thou our unbelief." But the person who approves of his own doubting, who wants it to remain so, and who thinks the revelation is uncertain and warrants no firmer belief, I would scarcely call such a person a Christian. Christianity must be received as a divine, infallible revelation.

Controverted matters of lesser necessity, however, cannot be determined peremptorily by the ignorant or by young beginners without falling into either hypocrisy or a merely human faith passing under the name of a divine one. I am far from weakening your divine belief in all you can understand in Scripture, and implicitly in everything else in general. I am far from diminishing the credit of any truth of God. But the reasons for this Direction are these:

1. When it is certain that you have only a dark and uncertain grasp of any point, to think it clear and certain is simply to deceive yourself through pride. To denounce all uncertainty as scepticism, while you cannot actually lay that uncertainty aside, is only to revile your own infirmity and the common infirmity of mankind, and to suppose foolishly that any person can be as wise and certain whenever he wishes as he ought to be. Reason and experience both show that a young, poorly furnished understanding is not likely to see the evidence of difficult points as clearly as it may upon closer approach and better advantage.

2. If your conclusions are peremptory out of mere self-conceit, you may for all you know be in error, and you are then simply confident in that error. Consider how far you may go in misleading others, censuring those who disagree, and then in the end come back and confess that you were mistaken all along.

3. For a person to be confident that he knows what he does not know is simply the way to keep himself ignorant and to shut the door against all means of further information. When an opinion is fixed by prejudice and conceit, the light has no ready entrance.

4. To be so groundlessly confident so early is not only to accept your teacher’s word in place of faith and knowledge of your own; it is also to cut off all diligence to know more. You may then lay aside your studies and simply learn what those men hold whose judgments constitute your religion, too popish and easy a way to be safe.

5. If you must never change your first opinions, how will you grow in understanding? Will you be no wiser in old age than in childhood, no wiser after long study and experience than before? Both nature and grace tend toward increase.

Even if you were utterly peremptory in your opinions, you could not truly resolve to hold them to the end. Light is powerful and may change you whether you will or not; you cannot know what light you have never yet seen. But prejudice will cause you to resist the light and make it harder for you to understand.

I say this out of much experience and observation. Our first, unripe apprehensions of things will certainly change greatly if we are studious and grow in understanding. Study the controversies about grace and free will, or other such difficult points, when you are young, and the odds are that maturity will afterward make them look quite different to you. For my own part, my judgment has been altered from many of my youthful, confident apprehensions. Where it holds the same conclusion, it rejects as worthless much of the reasoning in which it once rested. And where I keep to the same conclusions and arguments, my apprehension of them is not the same, I see more satisfying light in many things that I once accepted merely on trust. Had I resolved to hold to all my first opinions, I would have had to abandon most of my studies, would have lost much truth I have since discovered, would not have made truly my own what I merely held, and would have resolved to live and die a child.

The sum of it is this: hold fast to the substance of religion and to every clear and certain truth you see in its own evidence. Respect your teachers, especially the universal church, or the generality of wise and godly people, and do not be hasty to take up any private opinion, least of all to contradict the opinion of your governors and teachers in small and controverted matters. In such matters, however, receive their opinions with only a human faith until you have something more. Hold them with the expectation that time and study are very likely to alter your apprehensions, and with a genuine willingness to study impartially and welcome the truth, not to remain sitting exactly where you were born.

CHAPTER 14

DIRECTION 12: ON CONTROVERSIES, DIVISIONS, AND THE DUTY OF THE YOUNG CHRISTIAN

 

If controversies occasion any divisions where you live, be sure to attend first to the interests of common truth and the common good, and to the exercise of charity. Do not become a passionate partisan in the division, or a critic of the peaceable, or of your teachers when they will not override their own understanding simply to earn your approval as orthodox or zealous men. Instead, suspect your own unformed understanding, keep your opinions to yourself until you are clear and certain, and align yourself with the moderate and the peacemakers rather than with the contenders and dividers.

You may be quite certain that division tends toward the ruin of the church, the hindrance of the Gospel, and the injury of the common interests of religion. The Stoics, as Diogenes Laertius reports in his life of Zeno, held that one should quarrel with none of the foolish, since all fools are mad. You know it is strongly condemned throughout Scripture. You can see that it typically feeds and inflames pride, uncharitableness, and passion, and that the devil is most pleased with it, since he gains most by it. On the other side, you cannot easily be certain which party is in the right. And even if you were certain, you could not be sure the matter is worth the cost of the contention. Or if it is worth that cost, you must consider whether the truth is not more likely to gain by being managed in a peaceful way, one that stirs up no contention and does not provoke other people against it, as the way of controversy does.

Whatever it may prove, you both can and should recognize that young Christians who lack the learning, the resources, the time, and the experience to see controversies through are very unfit to make themselves partisans in them. They are still more unfit to be the hottest leaders of such parties and to spur on their teachers, who know more than they do. Even if the work were fit for someone else who knows the ground he stands on and can foresee where things will end, it is certainly not yet fit for you. Therefore, forbear until you are more fit.

I know that those who would draw you into such contentious zeal will tell you that their cause is the cause of God, and that if you are not zealous in it you desert and betray him. They will say that the counsel recommending moderation and peace is nothing but the counsel of flesh and blood, and that your lukewarmness and carnal compliance with error are marks of a hypocrite. They will insist that the cause of God is to be pursued with the greatest zeal and self-denial. All of this is true, provided you are certain it truly is the cause of God, that the greater works of God are not being neglected under such pretexts, and that your zeal for faith, charity, and unity is far greater than your zeal for your opinions.

But from long experience I must tell you this: among the zealous contenders in the world who cry up "the cause of God and Truth," very few understand what they are talking about. Some cry up the cause of God when what they champion is the product of a proud and ignorant mind, and something a judicious person would be ashamed of. Some are recklessly zealous before they have the capacity or the time for any sound judgment. Some are led astray by a person or party that has captivated their minds.

Some are carried away by passion and discontent. Many of the ambitious and worldly are blinded by their self-interest. Many in sheer pride think highly of an opinion in which they are somewhat singular, and which they can call their own with a certain pride, either because they invented it, or because they believe they understand something ordinary people do not. And a great many, after long experience, confess that what they had called the cause of God was in fact their own erroneous cause.

When this is the state of things, when one cries "Here is Christ" and another cries "There is Christ"; when one says "This is the cause of God" and another says "No, that is it," no one who has any care for his conscience, or for the honor of God and his profession, will leap before looking where he will land, or run after everyone who whistles him on with the name or pretense of truth and a good cause.

It is a sad thing to spend many years together in censuring, opposing, and abusing those who disagree with you, seducing others, misemploying your zeal and abilities and time, poisoning all your prayers and conversations, and then at last to see what mischief you have done through lack of knowledge, and to confess with Paul that you were, in ignorance, mad in opposing the very truth and servants of God, though you acted in a zeal for God.

Would it not be far better to wait until you have tested the ground, and so prevent so many years of grievous sin, than to escape only by a painful repentance and leave behind you the rotting, poisonous fruit of your mistake? And it is worse still if you never repent at all. Your own soul and your brethren’s souls are not to be ventured so lightly on dangerous and untried paths. It will not make amends to the truth or the church to say at last, "I thought I was doing well."

Let those who are more mature and who better understand the cause go to the wars of disputing, contending, censuring, and siding with a sect. Wars are not for children. Suspend your judgment until you can form it soundly and with certainty. Serve God in charity, quietness, and peace. The odds are that you will live to see the very contenders who tried to lead you into their wars come off with such losses as will teach them to approve your peaceful course, or teach you to bless God that he kept you in your place and duty.

In all this, I do not deny that every truth of God is to be valued at a very high rate, and that anyone who maintains a studied neutrality when faith or godliness is the matter in question, or does so purely for worldly ends, to protect his stake by playing both sides, is a false-hearted hypocrite, at heart of no religion at all.

But I also tell you this: not everything that an Antinomian-Libertine, an Autonomian-Papist, or another passionate party calls a matter of faith or godliness actually is one. We must avoid contempt for the smallest truth, but we must far more carefully avoid the most serious sins we may commit in defending an error. And some truths must be kept silent for a time, though never denied, when contending for them is ill-timed and tends to harm the church.

If you were teachers in the church, you would be obliged not to teach your students things that would hurt them, even if what you taught them were true. If you were physicians, you would be wrong to force-feed or over-medicate your patients to their injury. Your power and duty are directed toward building up, not tearing down. The good of the patient is the end of your medicine.

Not every truth is to be spoken, nor every good to be done, by every person, or at every time. Those who act otherwise, and dismiss this as a merely worldly principle, are calling folly and sin by the names of zeal and duty, setting the house on fire to cook an egg, and like the Pharisees, preferring the outward observance of the Sabbath over a brother’s life or health. Take heed of what you do when God’s honor, human souls, and the church’s peace are all at stake in it.

Let me share my own observation. As far as my judgment has been able to reach, the men who have stood for pacification and moderation have been the most judicious, and those who best understood the matter at issue, in most controversies I have heard debated among good Christians. Those who furiously censured them as lukewarm or corrupted have been men of least judgment and most passion, pride, and grievous error in the very points under question.

I will tell you more from my observation, of which these times have given us far too much evidence. Profane and nominal enemies on one side, and ignorant, self-conceited quarrelers on the other, who imagine they are champions for the truth while they are venting their passions and foolish opinions, these are the two thieves between whom the church has suffered from its beginning to this day. The first are the persecutors; the others are the dividers and disturbers of the church.

Consuming zeal is apt at last to burn up those who own it. Whatever men say or do against others in their intemperate violence, they teach others at last to say and do against them, when the opportunity comes.

Victor of Vita records how the orthodox taught the Arians to use severity against them, in the edict of King Huneric. Huneric’s complaint is that the law which the Christian emperors long ago issued against them and other heretics, for the honor of the catholic church, the orthodox had not blushed to bring forward against him and his own.

"It is proved to be a mark of triumphal and royal majesty," the edict runs, "to turn evil counsels back upon their authors; for whoever devises anything depraved, let him charge to himself what he incurs. Let the priests of the homoousion hold no assemblies, nor claim for themselves any of the mysteries, which they rather pollute. Let them have no license to ordain." And this, Victor observes, was shown by the very contents of the laws the orthodox had induced the emperors to make: that no church should stand open except to the prelates of their own persuasion, that no others should be allowed to hold meetings or conduct assemblies, and that they should have no churches, either in the cities or in the least places.

Mark what the Holy Spirit says in this case: "But foolish and unlearned questions avoid, knowing that they do gender strifes. And the servant of the Lord must not strive; but be gentle unto all men" (2 Tim 2:23–24). "Do all things without murmurings and disputings: that ye may be blameless and harmless, the sons of God, without rebuke in the midst of a crooked and perverse generation, among whom ye shine, as lights in the world" (Phil 2:14–15).

"If any man teach otherwise, and consent not to wholesome words, even the words of our Lord Jesus Christ, and to the doctrine which is according to godliness; he is proud, knowing nothing, but doting about questions and strifes of words, whereof cometh envy, strife, railings, evil-surmisings, perverse disputings of men of corrupt minds" (1 Tim 6:3–5). "Neither give heed to fables and endless genealogies, which minister questions, rather than godly edifying, which is in faith: now the end of the commandment is charity, out of a pure heart, and a good conscience, and faith unfeigned" (1 Tim 1:4–5).

Yet I must make this declaration: if any false-hearted, worldly hypocrite who has resolved to stay on the safe side, and to count as lawful whatever seems necessary to his safety or advancement, should take any encouragement from what I have said here to corrupt his conscience, sell his soul, and then call all those who will not be equally false to God "furious zealots," let that man know I have given him no cover for so odious a sin. Nor will he find any cover for it at the bar of God, though he may deceive his own conscience and brazen it out through his worldly advantages before men.

CHAPTER 15

DIRECTION 13: TRUE GODLINESS IS THE BEST LIFE ON EARTH

 

‘Know that true godliness is the best life upon earth, and the only way to perfect happiness. Always regard and treat it as the best, therefore; and with great diligence resist those temptations which would make it seem to you a confounding, grievous, or unpleasant thing.’

Everything in a holy life combines to make it the most delectable life on earth, for a rational, purified mind that is not captive to the flesh and does not feed on empty or corrupting things. Its object is the eternal God himself: infallible Truth, the only fully satisfying good, condescending and appearing to us in the mysterious yet fitting glass of a Mediator who redeems, reconciles, teaches, governs, sanctifies, justifies, and glorifies all who are his own. Its end is the pleasing and glorifying of our Maker, Redeemer, and Sanctifier, together with our own everlasting happiness and that of others. Its rule is the infallible revelation of God, delivered to the church by his Prophets, his Son, and his Apostles, contained in the Holy Scriptures, and sealed by the miracles and operations of the Holy Spirit who inspired them.

The work of godliness is a life lived to God and a preparing for everlasting life, by foreseeing, foretasting, seeking, and rejoicing in the endless happiness we shall have with God; and by walking after the Spirit while avoiding the filthiness, delusions, and vexations of the world and the flesh. Human nature is not capable of a more noble, profitable, or delectable life than that to which God has called us through his Son. If we rightly understood it, we would pursue it with continual eagerness and delight. Take care, therefore, to conceive of godliness as it truly is, not as it is misrepresented by the devil and the ungodly. Read what I have written on this in my A Saint or a Brute.

As long as a person conceives of religion as it truly is, the sweetest and most delectable life, he will follow it willingly and wholeheartedly, and will despise the temptations and diversions of fleshly gain and pleasure. He will be sincere, drawn neither merely by others nor by outward advantages, nor frightened into it by fearfulness alone, but loving religion for itself and for its excellent ends. He will then be cheerful in all its duties and far more likely to persevere to the end. We cannot expect the heart and will to be for God and godliness any more than the understanding practically perceives them as good. Indeed, we must always perceive in them a surpassing goodness above all that a worldly life offers, otherwise the apparent goodness of created things will divert us and carry our minds away.

Even in the brute animals we can see how powerfully perception governs action. When your horse is headed home or toward his pasture, how freely he goes through thick and thin. But when he goes unwillingly, his travel is slow and labored, and you have great difficulty urging him forward. It will be the same with you on your way to heaven.

It is therefore the devil’s chief design to hide from you the goodness and pleasantness of religion, and to make it appear a terrible or tedious life. By this means he keeps men from it; and by this same means he continually works to draw you back, to frustrate your good beginnings and your hopes. If he can misrepresent religion to your understanding, he will quickly alienate your will, corrupt your life, turn you back to the world in search of pleasure elsewhere, and reduce you to a heartless lip-service, just enough to keep alive some false hope of being saved.

The means Satan uses to these ends are such as these:

1. He will do his worst to overwhelm you with apparent doubts and difficulties, to bring you to confusion and make religion seem a bewildering rather than a satisfying thing. This is one of his most dangerous assaults upon the weak and upon young beginners. He uses difficulties and disordered passions to throw you into confusion and rob you of a steady, cheerful pursuit of salvation.

When you read the Scriptures, he will press upon your mind an abundance of difficulties in everything you read or hear. He will show you seeming contradictions and tell you that you will never be able to understand these things. He will cast in thoughts of unbelief and blasphemy, and cause you, if he can, to turn them over in your mind.

If you do not cast them out with abhorrence but instead argue with the devil, he hopes to prove too strong for inexperienced and ill-equipped soldiers such as you are. If you do reject them and refuse to dispute with him, he will sometimes tell you that your cause must be weak, otherwise you would not be afraid to consider everything that can be said against it, and by this he gains the advantage of drawing you toward unbelief. Even if you escape this, he will at least trouble and terrify you with the hideousness of his temptations and make you think you are forsaken of God because such blasphemous thoughts have so often entered your mind. In this way he tempts you to blasphemy at one moment and then frightens and torments you with the very thought of those temptations at another.

In the study of other good books as well, he will tempt you to fix upon everything that seems difficult and to confound and perplex yourself there. In your meditations he will seek to make everything tend only toward confusion and overwhelm, keeping hard or frightening things constantly before your eyes, or breaking and scattering your thoughts so that you cannot gather them into any order, make anything of them, or drive them to any desirable conclusion.

In your prayers he would reduce you to confusion through fears, or through doubtful and distracting thoughts about God, your sins, the matter or manner of your duty, or whether your prayers will be heard. In your self-examination he will seek to leave you more in darkness than when you began, and to make you afraid of looking inward or dealing honestly with yourself, like a man afraid to sleep in his own house because he imagines it haunted by apparitions. In this way the devil would make all your religion resemble the unwinding of a tangled skein of yarn or silk, so that you throw it aside in weariness and despair.

Your remedy against this dangerous temptation is to remember that you are still young in knowledge, and that ignorance, like darkness, naturally produces doubts, difficulties, and fears, all of which will vanish as your understanding grows. You must therefore wait with patience until a riper knowledge equips you for satisfaction. In the meantime, take care to occupy your heart most with the great, foundational, necessary, plain, and certain truths on which your salvation rests, the truths that are fitted to your present condition and strength. If you insist on gnawing bones when you should be taking milk, and cannot wait until you are past your spiritual childhood, it is no wonder if you find them hard, if they stick in your throat or break your teeth.

See to it that you live upon God in Christ, that you love and practice what you know, and that you dwell on the excellence of what has already been revealed to you. You already know what end you must seek and where your happiness lies; what Christ has done to prepare it for you; and how you must be justified, sanctified, and walk with God. You have God, Christ, and heaven to think on, and all the mercies of the Gospel to delight in, will you lay these aside as common matters, or overlook them, and perplex yourself over every difficulty along the way? Make clean work before you as you go: live in joyful acknowledgment of the mercies you have received and in the practice of the things you know, and the difficulties will vanish as you press on.

2. Another of Satan’s devices is to confound you with the clamor of sectarians and the diversity of opinions in religion. The Popish sect tells you that if you would be saved you must belong to their church; others say you must belong to theirs. When you find that the sects are many and their arguments are more than you can readily answer, you will be in danger either of being taken in by some of their errors or of being entirely bewildered among them all, unable to determine which church and religion to choose.

But here consider that there is only one universal church of Christians in the world, of which Christ is the sole king and head, and of which every Christian is a member. You were sacramentally admitted into this catholic church by baptism, and spiritually by being "born of the Spirit." You have all the promises of the Gospel: that if you believe in Christ you shall be saved; that all the living members of this church are loved by Christ as members of his body; and that he who is the Savior of his body will present them unspotted to the Father (Eph 5:23–27). "And by one Spirit we are all baptized or entered into this one body" (1 Cor 12:12–13). If, then, you have faith and love and the Spirit, you are certainly a Christian, a member of Christ, and a member of this universal church. If there were any other church besides the parts of this one, then this church would not be universal, and Christ would have to have two bodies.

You are not saved for being a member of the church of Rome, or Corinth, or Ephesus, or Philippi, or Thessalonica, or any other such church, but for being a member of the universal church, the body of Christ: that is, for being a Christian. Just as you are a subject of the king and a member of the kingdom whatever local corporation you belong to, sometimes one, sometimes another, so you are a subject of Christ whatever particular church you are part of. For a body is no church at all if its members are not Christians and subjects of Christ.

For one sect to say "Ours is the true church," and another to reply "No, ours is," is as absurd as disputing whether the hall, the kitchen, the parlor, or the coal-house is your house, with one person insisting it is this room and another insisting it is that, when any child can tell them that the best of these is only a part, and the house contains them all.

As for the Papists, who claim to be the whole and deny that all others are Christians or can be saved unless they are subjects of the Pope of Rome: this is so irrational, so antichristian a fiction and usurpation, and so odious, cruel, and groundless a condemnation of the far greater part of the body of Christ, that it deserves detestation more than debate. If such a threat could frighten the world out of its senses, no doubt other bishops would use it as well, and declare all who refuse their authority to be damned. If you wish to see the folly and mischief of Popery on this and other points, I refer you to my Treatise of the Catholic Church, my Key for Catholics, my Safe Religion, my Disputations against Johnson, and my Winding-Sheet for Popery.

3. Another temptation that confounds you in your religion is the filling of your mind with practical scrupulosity, so that you cannot proceed without doubting at every step whether you are going right. When you ought to be cheerfully serving your Master, you do nothing but disquiet your mind with scruples about whether this or that is right or wrong. The remedy here is not to cast away all care of pleasing God, or all fear of sinning, or to debauch your conscience, but to render a cheerful and quiet obedience to God as far as you know his will, to maintain an upright willingness and effort to understand it better, and to receive with thankfulness the Gospel pardon for your failings and infirmities.

Be faithful in your obedience, but live continually upon Christ; and never imagine reaching a level of obedience that would place you above the need of his merits and a daily pardon for your sins. Do the best you can to know the will of God and to do it. But when you know the essentials of religion and obey sincerely, let no remaining gaps rob you of the comfort of so great a mercy as proves your right to eternal life.

In your pursuit of further knowledge and obedience, let your care be of a kind that promotes your growth and advances you toward your end, not a care that hinders your joy and gratitude for what you have already received. Whatever destroys your joy and thankfulness, and only perplexes you without helping you forward, is mere harmful scrupulosity and should be set aside. When you are right in the main, thank God for it, and pursue further only so far as it helps you onward, not so far as it hinders you. If you send a servant on your errand, you would far rather he pressed on as best he could than that he stood debating at every step which foot to set forward first. Scruples that hinder you do not please God.

4. Another way that confounds you in your religion is when you are driven to overdoing by inventions of your own. When a sincere soul is most eager to please God, the devil will turn religious and set that soul upon some task of voluntary humility or will-worship, as the apostle speaks of Colossians 2:18, 20–23, or upon some ensnaring and unnecessary vows and resolutions, or upon Popish works of imagined supererogation, which is what Solomon calls being "righteous over-much" (Eccl 7:16). In this way many people have made duties for themselves that God never made for them, and treated as sin what God never forbade.

The Popish religion is largely built up of such commandments of men’s own devising and traditions of men. As though Christ had not already given us enough work, people press eagerly to make much more for themselves. And some who should be teaching them the laws of Christ think their office is worthless unless they also prescribe laws of their own and introduce new principles of religion. Indeed, some of the bitterest enemies to strict observance of God’s laws, as though such observance were tedious and unnecessary, nevertheless insist on loading people with an abundance of their own needless precepts. Religion is thus made both wearisome and uncertain, and a door is opened for men to enlarge it and increase the burden at their pleasure. Popery is in fact well fitted to delude and quiet sleeping consciences, and to torment awakened consciences with uncertainties.

There is also something in corrupted human nature that inclines a person toward certain additions and voluntary acts of his own devising, as offerings he imagines most acceptable to God. This is why many sincere Christians rashly entangle their consciences with vows about circumstances and unnecessary things, to give a certain amount, to observe certain days or hours in fasting and prayer, to refrain from something that is in itself lawful, along with many other things of this kind. A change of providence may afterwards make it their duty to do precisely what they vowed to leave undone, or may disable them from performing their vow; and then these snares become fetters on their perplexed consciences, sometimes for the rest of their lives.

Indeed, some Autonomians teach the people that indifferent things are the fittest subject of a vow, to live unmarried, to possess nothing, to live in solitude, and the like. Now it is true that all lawful things, once vowed, must be performed. But a thing is unfit to be vowed unless it is first profitable and best, for ourselves or others. And what is truly best is not indifferent, since every person has a duty to choose what is best. Vows are meant to bind us to the performance of what God has already bound us to by his laws; they are our expression of consent and settled resolution, a self-obligation to obey his will. They are not a means of creating new religious duties for ourselves that would never otherwise have been duties at all.

To escape these snares, you must take care not to corrupt your religion by burdens and mixtures of your own devising. You are called to obey God’s laws, not to make laws for yourself. You may be certain that his laws are just and good; your own may be bad and foolish. When you obey him, you may look for your reward and encouragement from him; but when you will obey only yourself, you must reward yourself. You may find it enough to keep his laws without devising more work for yourself, or fabricating duties he never commanded, or sins he never forbade.

Do not be rash in making vows. Restrict them to necessary duties, and include proper exceptions when they concern changeable circumstances. If you are already entangled by such vows, consult the most judicious, able, and impartial advisors you can find, so that you may come free without a wound. Your counselors need great judgment and integrity, and you will need great submission and self-denial in yourself, to be brought safely out of such a snare. Avoid sin whatever you do, for sinning is not the road to your deliverance. And from this point forward, be wiser: lay no more snares for yourself, do not encumber yourself with your own inventions, but cheerfully obey what God commands, he who has wisdom and authority sufficient to give you perfect laws. Christ’s "yoke is easy" and his "burden light" (Matt 11:30), "and his commandments are not grievous" (1 John 5:3). But if your own mixtures and self-devised snares are grievous to you, blame not God, but yourself for making them.

5. Another of Satan’s strategies to make religion burdensome and grievous is overwhelming you with fear and sorrow. He does this partly by persuading you that religion consists in an excess of sorrow, and so causing you to spend your time striving to trouble and grieve yourselves unprofitably, as though that were the course most acceptable to God. He does it partly also by exploiting a timid, passionate temperament, turning every thought of God or serious act of religion into torment by raising overwhelming fears, for "fear hath torment" (1 John 4:18). In some feminine, weak, and melancholy persons, this temptation has such a grip through the body that even the holiest soul can do little to resist it. Though there may be a sincere love to God, his ways, and his people in such a person, fear plays the tyrant so thoroughly that they are conscious of almost nothing else. It is no wonder that religion is grievous and unpleasant to them.

Yet it is you yourselves who are the cause of this, and you bring the source of your grievance with you. God has commanded you a far sweeter work. He calls you to a life of love, joy, and cheerful progress toward eternal joy, and no more fear or grief than is necessary to separate you from sin and lead you to value and use the remedy he provides. The Gospel sets before you such rich matter for joy and peace that these would become the very character and temper of your souls, if you received them as they are offered.

Religious fears, when they are excessive and harmful, are themselves sinful and contrary to religion, and must be resisted like any other harmful passion. Grow better acquainted with Christ and his promises, and you will find in him enough to pacify the soul and give you confidence and holy boldness in your approach to God (Heb 4:16 Eph 3:12 Heb 10:19). The Spirit he gives is not the spirit of bondage but the spirit of adoption, of love, and of confidence (Rom 8:15 Heb 2:15).

6. Another thing that makes religion seem grievous is retaining unmortified, sensual desires. If you keep your lusts alive, they will war against the Gospel, and all the works of the Spirit will war against them. Every duty will be unpleasant to you to the degree that you remain carnal, because it runs against your carnal inclinations and desires. Put away your beloved sickness, therefore, and both your food and your physician will be far less grievous to you. Mortify the flesh, and you will find the things of the Spirit far less distasteful. "For the carnal mind is enmity against God: for it is not subject to his law, nor can be" (Rom 8:7–8).

7. Another cause of confusion and weariness is the mixture of your actual sins, dealing unfaithfully with God, and wounding your conscience by renewed guilt, especially through sins committed against knowledge and deliberate consideration. If you keep the bone out of joint and the wound unhealed, it is no wonder you are reluctant to work or move. But it is your sin and folly that ought to be grievous to you, not that which is contrary to sin and would remove the cause of all your troubles. Decisively forsake your willful sinning, and return home through "repentance toward God, and faith toward our Lord Jesus Christ" (Acts 20:21). Then you will find that when the thorn is removed, your pain ceases, and that the cause of your trouble lay not in God or religion, but in your sin.

8. Finally, to make religion unpleasant to you, the tempter would keep the substance of the Gospel unknown to you, or unnoticed by you. He would hide the wonderful love of God revealed in our Redeemer, together with all the riches of saving grace, the great deliverance and privileges of believers, and the certain hope of eternal life. He would have the kingdom of God, which consists in righteousness, peace, and joy in the Holy Spirit, represented to you as consisting in errors only, or in trifles, in shadows and shows, and bodily exercises that profit little (1 Tim 4:8).

If you would ever know the pleasures of faith and holiness, you must labor above all things to know God as he is revealed in his infinite love in the Mediator, and to read the Gospel as God’s act of pardon, and the New Testament as the covenant of Christ in which he gives you eternal life. In every duty, draw near to God as a reconciled Father, the object of your everlasting love and joy. Know and use religion as it truly is, without mistaking or corrupting it, and it will not appear to you as a grievous, tedious, or confounding thing.

CHAPTER 16

DIRECTION 14: MORTIFY FLESHLY DESIRES AND WATCH AGAINST TEMPTATION

 

"Be very diligent in mortifying the desires and pleasures of the flesh. Keep a continual watch upon your senses, appetite, and lusts. Do not place yourselves in temptations, occasions, or opportunities for sinning, remembering that your salvation depends on your success."

The lusts of the flesh and the pleasures of the world are the common enemies of God and of souls, and the damnation of those souls that perish. No group is more exposed to temptations of this kind than those in the flower of their youth and strength. When all the senses are vigorous and lust and appetite are at full force, how great is the danger, and how great must your diligence be if you are to escape!

The appetite and lust of the weak and sick are as weakened and sick as they themselves are, and so pose no great temptation or danger to them. Sensory desire and pleasure diminish as natural strength and vigor diminish. Such people have far less need of watchfulness, and where nature has already subdued the flesh, grace has that much less to do. It takes little grace to keep the aged and infirm from fornication, uncleanness, excessive sport, and carnal mirth; gluttony and drunkenness too are sins to which youth is far more liable. This is especially true of those who are not only young and strong, but who have by their constitution and temperament a particular inclination toward some of these sins, lust, or idle sport, or foolish mirth. Such people need a great deal of diligence, resolution, and watchfulness to preserve themselves.

Lust is not like a corrupt opinion, which surprises us through a failure of reason and vanishes as soon as truth appears. It is a brutish inclination which, though reason must subdue and govern it, the most perfect reason will not uproot. It will continue to dwell within you. Since it is constantly present, it will be stirring whenever objects are presented to sense or imagination as allurements. It is like a torrent or a headstrong horse: it must be checked from the start, and is barely restrained once it breaks loose and gains its head.

If you have been raised in temperance and modesty, where there are no great temptations to gluttony, drinking, sports, or wantonness, you may for a time think that your nature has little or none of this concupiscence, and so go about unguarded. But when you come where baits of lust abound, where women, plays, feasts, and drunkards are the devil’s snares, tinder, and bellows to inflame your lusts, you may find to your sorrow that you needed watchfulness all along, and that not everything is mortified which is merely asleep or quiet within you. A man who walks with a candle among gunpowder or near thatch should never be careless, because he is in continual danger. In the same way, you who are young and naturally possess eager appetites and lusts should remember that you carry fire and gunpowder within you always, and are never out of danger while you have such an enemy to watch.

And if you once allow the fire to kindle, what devastation may it cause before you are aware! "Every man is tempted when he is drawn away of his own lust, and enticed. Then when lust hath conceived, it bringeth forth sin: and sin, when it is finished, bringeth forth death." (Jas 1:14–15) The fish, when it is caught nibbling at the bait, has no idea that it is swallowing the hook that will land it on the bank in a moment. When you are gazing at the cup, or staring at alluring beauty, or wantonly dallying and pleasing your senses with unsafe things, you little know how far beyond your intentions you may be drawn, how deep the wound may prove, how great the pain, or how long and difficult the cure.

As you love your souls, heed Paul’s counsel: "Flee youthful lusts." (2 Tim 2:22) Keep a full distance. Do not go near the bait. If you take a wound in your conscience through any willful, heinous sin, what a state you will be in! How listless in private duty! Afraid of God, who should be your joy; stripped of the comforts of his presence and all the pleasure of his ways! How miserably you will be tormented between the tyranny of your own concupiscence, the sting of sin, the grip of conscience, and the terrors of the Lord! How much of the life of faith, love, and heavenly zeal will be quenched in a moment! I will speak more on this later. For now I say only, to all young converts who care for their salvation: "Mortify the flesh," and "always watch, and avoid temptations."

CHAPTER 17

DIRECTION 15: CHOOSE YOUR TEACHERS AND YOUR COMPANIONS WITH CARE

 

"Be exceedingly careful not only about which teachers you entrust with the guidance of your souls, but also about the company you keep. Make sure they are not people who would corrupt your minds with error, or your hearts with vice, profaneness, lukewarmness, or a feverish, factious zeal. Instead, choose, as far as possible, judicious, holy, heavenly, humble, blameless, self-denying persons to be your ordinary companions and close friends, and above all in your nearest relationships."

The choice of teachers is a matter of very great importance for your salvation. In this, God’s free grace makes a marked difference among people. Poor heathens and unbelievers have none who know more than what the book of nature teaches, if even that much. In the various nations of Christendom, people generally have no choice but to receive whichever teachers the civil magistrate imposes or the current of national custom commends. It would be remarkable if pure truth and holiness were favored by either of those forces. But when and where his mercy is pleased to act, God sends wise and holy teachers, full of compassion and diligence to seek the saving of souls, so that none but the hostile and obstinate are left without their help.

Ambitious, proud, covetous, licentious, and ungodly men are not to be chosen as your teachers, when you have a choice. In a nation where true religion enjoys public credit and the support of the magistrate, or the approval of the majority, some graceless men may join with better ones in preaching and defending sound doctrine and holy living, and may even serve the church usefully, especially in expounding and arguing for the truth. Even so, more experienced and spiritual teachers are far more desirable. Those who speak most movingly are those who feel what they say; and those best fitted to bring others to faith and love are those who themselves believe and love God and holiness. Those who have life will speak with more vitality than the dead.

In most parts of the world, the ungodliness of graceless teachers makes them enemies to the truth, which is a truth according to godliness. Their natures are at war with the life and power of the doctrine they are supposed to preach. They will do their worst to corrupt civil rulers and win them over to their own mind; and if they can secure the power of the sword, they typically become the cruelest persecutors of the sincere. This is notorious among the Papists, where the lures of power, honor, and wealth have so corrupted the body of their clergy that they conspire together to uphold a worldly government and religion. In plain contradiction of sense, reason, the witness of antiquity, the judgment of the church, and the Holy Scriptures, they hold the ignorant and sensual captive to their tyranny and false worship, and use seduced rulers and multitudes to persecute those who refuse to follow them into sin and ruin. Beware of proud and worldly guides.

Yet not everyone who professes piety and zeal is to be heard or received as a teacher. Look rather for the following marks.

1. Those who ordinarily preach the substantial truths on which all Christians are agreed.

2. Those who make it the aim of their preaching to lift your souls to the love of God and to a holy, heavenly life, and who are zealous against acknowledged sins.

3. Those who do not contradict essential truths by errors of their own, nor undermine the doctrine of godliness by wicked or malicious applications of it.

4. Those who are not pursuing ambitious or tyrannical designs of their own, but deny themselves and sincerely aim at your salvation.

5. Those who are not overly eager to win you over to some singular opinion of their own, for Paul predicted to the Ephesians, "of your own selves shall men arise, speaking perverse things, to draw away disciples after them" (Acts 20:30).

6. Those who are judicious in their zeal, and zealous with judgment.

7. Those who have genuine experience in the things of God, and are not young beginners or novices in religion.

8. Those who show respect for the judgments of the generality of wise and godly people and are careful about the unity of the church, not those who would draw you into a sect or party, to the contempt of other Christians, not even into a party that happens to enjoy the favor of rulers and the people.

9. Those who are gentle, peaceable, and charitable, not those who burn with hellish malice against their brethren, nor with an ungodly or cruel, consuming zeal.

10. Those who do not live sensually and wickedly in contradiction to what they preach, but show by their lives that they believe what they say and feel the power of the truths they proclaim.

Your familiar companions have as great an advantage to help or hinder your salvation as your teachers do. As José de Acosta observes, the society of good men is a great safeguard of virtue: a companion rouses us by example, refreshes us by conversation, instructs us by counsel, helps us by his prayers, and restrains us by his authority, all of which are wanting to solitude. It matters far less who you encounter along the road, or travel with, or do business with, than who you make your intimate and familiar friends. Such friends have both the advantage of their hold on your affections and the advantage of their closeness and familiarity; and if they also possess greater abilities than you, they may be powerful instruments for your good or your harm.

If you have a close friend who will defend you from error, help you resist temptation, lovingly reprove your sin, and speak feelingly of God and the life to come, drawing on the inward power of faith and holy experience, the benefit of such a friend may surpass that of the most learned or eminent person in the world. How sweetly their words will carry the Spirit from which they come! How deeply they may pierce a careless heart! How powerfully may they kindle love and zeal toward God and his commandments! How seasonably may they expose a temptation, prevent your fall, correct an error, and restore your soul! How faithfully will they watch over you! How profitably will they stir and urge you on, pray fervently with you when you are cold, and remind you of the truth, the duty, and the mercy you have forgotten! It is a very great mercy to have a judicious, solid, and faithful companion on the way to heaven.

But if your ears are filled daily with worthless talk and folly, with ribaldry or idle stories, with oaths and curses, with furious words, or with scorn and ridicule aimed at the godly, or with the sophistry of deceivers, is it likely this will leave a wholesome or pleasant impression on your minds? Is it likely the effects will not show themselves in lean or corrupted hearts and lives, just as the effects of foul or unhealthy air and food show themselves in diseased bodies? Anyone who prefers such company is ungodly; anyone who needlessly throws himself into it, confident he will take no harm, is proud and presumptuous; and anyone who will not carefully avoid it is careless of his own soul.

Few who keep such company for long escape without some serious loss, except those who, like Lot in Sodom, grieve over the sin and misery around them; or those who, like Christ among tax collectors and sinners, engage with holy zeal and diligence to convert and save them; or those who have no liberty to do otherwise and must endure what they have no power to avoid.

Diogenes Laertius reports of Zeno that the Stoics held friendship able to subsist only among the good, whom a likeness of pursuits commends to one another. They said that friendship is itself a kind of partnership in all things necessary to life, in which we use our friends as we use ourselves; that a friend is to be chosen for his own sake; that a multitude of friends is among the things worth desiring; and that among the wicked friendship cannot hold.

Among other dangers, you face no small risk from those who are eager to draw you over to some party or unsound opinion. That they sincerely believe they are right, that they act out of love, that they regard it as necessary to your salvation, and that truth and godliness are what they profess, all of this only makes the danger greater if what they propose is not truth and godliness in reality. And none are in more danger than those who are ungrounded and inexperienced, yet so confident in their own wisdom that they are sure they can tell truth from error when they hear it, and are not afraid of being deceived, nor much suspicious of their own understanding. But this has been addressed earlier.

There is a similar danger from the familiar company of the lukewarm or the profane. At first you may be troubled by their sinful or tasteless talk and may resist the infection; but before you know it, your graces may be so chilled and dampened that your decline becomes visible to others. First you will hear them with less offense; then you will grow indifferent to what company you keep; then you will laugh at their sin and folly; then you will begin to speak as they do; then you will grow cold and pray less often, neglecting other holy duties; and if God does not intervene, your judgment will at last grow dim, and you will come to think all of this acceptable.

But of all bad company, the nearest is the worst. If you bring such people into your household or into your closest conjugal relationship, you throw water on the fire. You imprison yourself in fetters that will chafe and wound you, if they do not stop you altogether; you choose a life of constant, close, and heavy temptation. Whereas the society of those who are wise, gracious, and fitted to your condition could greatly advance your grace, comfort, and salvation. To have a constant companion with whom to open your heart, join in prayer and edifying conversation, who will faithfully help you against your sins yet bear patiently with your frailties, this is a mercy that worldly people neither deserve nor value.

CHAPTER 18

DIRECTION 16: CHOOSE YOUR BOOKS CAREFULLY

 

Make a careful choice of the books you read. Let the Holy Scriptures always hold the first place, and after them, the solid, lively, heavenly treatises that best expound and apply the Scriptures. After those, read credible histories, especially of the church, and works on lesser sciences and arts. But beware of the poison found in the writings of false teachers, which would corrupt your understanding; and of idle romances, plays, and false stories, which may bewitch your imagination and corrupt your heart.

Just as the Spirit of God appears more excellently in the Holy Scriptures than in any other book, so the Scriptures have more power and fitness to convey the Spirit and make us spiritual, by imprinting themselves on our hearts. Because there is more of God in Scripture, it will acquaint us more with God, bring us nearer to him, and make the reader more reverent, serious, and devout. Let Scripture be first and foremost in your hearts and hands, and let other books serve it. The efforts of the devil and the Papists to keep it from you show that it is most necessary and desirable for you.

When they tell you that all heretics appeal to Scripture, they are only telling you that Scripture is the common rule and law of Christians, which everyone therefore feels compelled to invoke, just as all lawyers and quarrelers appeal to the laws of the land, however bad their cause, without those laws being on that account concealed or set aside. They are also telling you that, in their concealment and dishonoring of Scripture, they are worse than any of those heretics.

When they tell you that Scripture is misunderstood, abused, and twisted to support error, they might as well argue that the sun should be hidden because the dim-sighted stumble and murderers commit crimes by its light; that the earth should be overturned because it bears evildoers; that roads should be closed because people travel them to do evil; and that food should be banned because it nourishes men’s diseases. When they can show you a law or rule, whether made by pope or council, that no corrupt person can misunderstand, break, abuse, or misapply, then listen to them, and prefer that law as one that makes judgment unnecessary.

The writings of divines are nothing other than the Gospel preached to the eye, just as the voice preaches it to the ear. Vocal preaching has the advantage in moving the affections and in being adapted to the state of the congregations that hear it, the milk comes warmest from the breast that way. But books have the advantage in many other respects.

You may read an able preacher when you have only a mediocre one to hear. Every congregation cannot hear the most learned or powerful preachers, but every individual may read the books of the most powerful and learned. Preachers may be silenced or banished when books remain at hand. Books may be kept at less expense than preachers. We may choose books that treat the very subject we wish to study, whereas we cannot choose what subject the preacher will address. Books are available every day and hour, while sermons come seldom and at set times. If a sermon is forgotten, it is gone; but a book may be read again and again until we remember it, and if we forget, we may return to it at our pleasure and leisure.

Good books are therefore a very great mercy to the world. The Holy Spirit chose the way of writing to preserve his doctrine and laws for the church, knowing how easy and reliable a means it is of keeping them safe across all generations, compared with mere oral tradition, which might have generated as many controversies about the very terms as there are memories and persons serving as preservers and reporters.

Books, when well chosen, are domestic, present, constant, judicious, pertinent, and even powerful sermons, always of very great use to your salvation. They are especially valuable when vocal preaching is absent, and when preachers are ignorant, ungodly, or dull, or when they are persecuted and forbidden to preach.

You need a judicious teacher at hand to direct you in which books to use and which to refuse. Among good books, some are very good, sound and lively. Some are good but moderate, weak, and somewhat dull. And some are very good in part but contain mixtures of error, or incautious and injudicious expressions more likely to puzzle than edify the inexperienced. I am reluctant to name books of these latter sorts, of which a great many have appeared recently. But to the young beginner in religion, I may boldly recommend, after a sound catechism: Mr. Rutherford’s Letters; Mr. Robert Bolton’s Works; Mr. Perkins’s Works; Mr. Whateley’s Works; Mr. Ball On Faith; Dr. Preston’s Works; Dr. Sibbs’s Works; Mr. Hildersham’s Works; Mr. Pink’s Sermons; Mr. Jos. Rogers’s Works; Mr. Rich. Allen’s Works; Mr. Gurnall’s Works; Mr. Swinnock’s Works; Mr. Jos. Simonds’s Works.

To ground you against Popery: Dr. Challoner’s Codex Credo Eccles. Cathol.; Dr. Field On the Church; Dr. White’s Way to the Church with the Defense; Bishop Usher’s Answer to the Jesuit; and Chillingworth, with Drelincourt’s Summary. For sound principles about redemption and related matters: Mr. Truman’s Great Propitiation and his work On Natural and Moral Impotency; Mr. William Fenner On Wilful Impenitency; Mr. Hotchkis On Forgiveness of Sin. I pass over many other excellent works to avoid naming too many.

For a very learned and able reader, capable of evaluating everything he reads, there is no great danger in reading the books of those who would lead others astray, it only reveals how thin and flimsy a cover is thrown over a bad cause. But young soldiers, unaccustomed to such warfare, are unsettled by a single sophistical argument, by a terrifying threat of damnation to dissenters (which any censorious sect can deploy), by every confident and triumphant boast, or by anything with a fair pretense of truth or godliness. Inexperienced persons can answer almost no deceiver they encounter; and when they cannot answer, they think they must yield, as if the fault lay not in themselves but in the cause, and as if Christ had no wiser followers or abler defenders of his truth than they. Do not handle poison, then, until you better know how to use it and can do so with less danger, especially while you have no need to do so.

As for plays, romances, and idle tales, I have already shown in my Book of Self-Denial how harmful they are, especially to the young, and to shallow, empty, idle minds that do not know what a person is or what they have to do in the world. They are powerful bait of the devil, designed to keep more necessary things out of the mind and better books out of the hands, and to poison the mind all the more dangerously because they are read with such delight and pleasure. They fill sensual minds with idle vapors and intoxicating fancies that divert attention from the serious consideration of salvation. And, no small loss, they rob people of an abundance of precious time given them for far more important business, time they will wish again and again at the last that they had spent more wisely.

I know that frivolous people will say these things are innocent and may even teach men much good, reasoning like a man who must visit a brothel to learn to hate impurity, or who would go out with robbers to learn to hate theft. But I will ask them plainly, as in the presence of God:

1. Whether they could not spend that time better?

2. Whether better books and practices would not build them up more?

3. Whether the greatest lovers of romances and plays are also the greatest lovers of the Word of God and of a holy life?

4. Whether they find in themselves that the love of these vanities increases their love for the Word of God, kills their sin, and prepares them for the life to come, or exactly the opposite?

I urge people not to argue against their own experience and reason, not to reason themselves into damnable impenitence, and not to make fools of their souls with a few silly words that any person free from sensuality can see are mere deceit and falsehood. If this is not enough, they will shortly be convinced and answered in another manner.

CHAPTER 19

DIRECTION 17: DO NOT RECEIVE LIBERTINISM AS THOUGH IT WERE THE GOSPEL

 

Take heed that you do not receive a doctrine of libertinism as though it came from the Gospel. Do not conceive of Christ as an encourager of sin, nor pretend that free grace justifies your carnal security or spiritual sloth. To do so is to set up another gospel and another Christ, or rather, to advance the devil’s doctrine and works against Christ and the true Gospel, and to turn the grace of God into licentiousness.

Because the devil knows you will not receive his doctrine under his own name, his usual method is to propose and preach it in the name of Christ, whom he knows you reverence. If Satan did not conceal his own name and hand in every temptation, it would ruin his design; and the more excellent and splendid his pretense, the more powerful the temptation becomes. Cicero judged that if any man had such strength of mind and such a bent toward virtue and self-restraint that he refused every pleasure and ran the whole course of his life so, delighting in no rest, no relaxation, none of the pursuits of his equals, no games and no banquets, and counting nothing in life worth seeking unless it were joined with praise and honor, such a man he took to be furnished and adorned with certain divine goods.

Those who gave heed to seducing spirits and doctrines of devils no doubt thought well of those spirits and doctrines, especially when they appeared strict (for the devil has his own forms of strictness), "forbidding to marry, and abstinence from meats which God hath created to be received with thanksgiving" (1 Tim 4:1, 3). Yet the devil’s strictnesses are always intended to make men loose. He makes people strict after the manner of the Pharisees, in traditions and empty ceremonies, in building the tombs of the prophets and garnishing the sepulchres of the righteous, so that they may hate and murder the living saints who worship God in spirit and in truth. Licentiousness is the devil’s proper doctrine, and all his strictness serves to promote it. To receive such principles is destructive; to attribute them to Christ and the Gospel is blasphemous.

The Libertines, Antinomians, and Autonomians of this age have furnished far too many examples. The Libertine says: "The heart is the man; therefore you may deny the truth with your tongue, attend false worship (such as the Mass), and need not suffer merely to avoid speaking a word, subscribing to an untruth, or performing some small act. So long as you keep your heart toward God and mean well, or maintain an honest mental reservation, or were compelled by others, rather than suffer, you may say, subscribe, or swear anything that you can privately put a lawful sense upon in your own mind, and comply with any outward actions or customs to avoid offence and preserve yourself."

The Antinomians tell you that the moral law is abrogated, and that the Gospel is no law. (If there is no law, there is no governor or government, no duty, no sin, no judgment, no punishment, no reward.) They say that the elect are justified before they are born, before they repent, or before they believe; that their sin is pardoned before it is committed; that God regarded them as having suffered and fulfilled all the law in Christ, as though they themselves had done it in him; that we are justified by faith alone in our consciences; that justifying faith is simply believing that we are justified; that every person must believe he is pardoned in order to be pardoned in his conscience, and that this is to be done by a divine act of faith, and that this is the meaning of the article "I believe the forgiveness of sins," that is, that my sins are forgiven, and that all who believe this are forgiven.

They further say: that it is legal and sinful to work or do anything for salvation; that sin once pardoned need not be confessed or lamented, or at least that we need not ask pardon for sin daily, nor repeatedly for any one sin; that God’s corrections are no punishments, and yet no other punishment is threatened to believers for their sins, and consequently that Christ has not procured pardon for any sin committed after believing, but has simply prevented all necessity of pardon, so that believers must not ask pardon nor do anything to obtain it; that fear of hell must play no part in our obedience or restraint from sin. Some add that a person who cannot repent or believe should take comfort that Christ repented and believed for him, which is a plain contradiction. Many such doctrines of licentiousness have been brought forth by those who abuse the grace of God.

The sect that imitates the father of pride by aspiring to be free from God’s government and to be law-givers and rulers over themselves and all others, which I therefore call the Autonomians, are licentious and still worse. They contend equally against Christ’s government and for their own. They fill the world with wars and bloodshed, oppression, and cruelty, and fill the ears of God with the cries of martyrs and the oppressed, all so that the spiritual and holy discipline of Christ may be suppressed, seriousness in religion made hateful or banished from the earth, and that they themselves may be regarded as the center, pillars, and law-givers of the church. They seek to teach the consciences of all people to abandon every scruple or fear of offending God in comparison with offending them, to submit absolutely to their authority, and never to hesitate at any feared disobedience to Christ.

They scorn and persecute strict obedience to God’s laws, and treat those who fear his judgments as men frightened out of their senses. They regard exact obedience to him (which, alas, who can render, even doing their best?) as nothing but hypocrisy or excessive scrupulosity. But to question their dominion, or to break the laws they have imposed on the world, even on kings and states, without any legitimate authority, must be counted heresy, schism, or rebellion like that of Korah and his company. This Luciferian spirit of the proud Autonomians has filled the Christian world with bloodshed and has been the greatest cause of earthly miseries, and especially of hindering and persecuting the Gospel and establishing a Pharisaical religion in the world. It has fought against the Gospel and soaked in blood the countries of France, Savoy, Rhaetia, Bohemia, the Low Countries, Switzerland, Poland, Hungary, Germany, and many more, making it plainly evident how much of the satanic nature they possess, and how precisely they fulfill his will.

Natural corruption, moreover, contains within it the seeds of all these damnable heresies. Nothing is more natural to fallen humanity than to shake off the government of God, to become a law-giver to oneself and to as many others as one can, and to turn the grace of God into licentiousness. The profane, who never heard these things from any heretic but themselves, frame for themselves a creed along these lines: "God is merciful, and therefore we need not fear his threatenings, for he will be better than his word. It belongs to him to save us, not to us, and therefore we may cast our souls upon his care though we ourselves care nothing for them. If he has predestined us to salvation, we shall be saved; if not, we shall not be saved regardless of what we do or how well we live. Christ died for sinners, and therefore, though we are sinners, he will save us. God is stronger than the devil, and therefore the devil will not have the most."

They add: "Whatever pleases the flesh and does God no harm can never be so serious a matter, or offend him so greatly, as to bring about our damnation. Why all this effort to be saved, or such urgency to turn to God, when anyone who at last repents, cries God mercy, and believes that Christ died for him, shall be saved? Christ is the Saviour of the world and his grace is very great and free; and therefore God forbid that none should be saved but those few who live strict and holy lives and make so much exertion for heaven. No one can know who will be saved and who will not."

They continue: "Therefore the wisest course is to do nobody any harm, live cheerfully, trust God with our souls, and put our salvation on the venture. Nobody is saved by their own works or deservings; and therefore our lives may serve the purpose as well as if they were more strict and holy." This is the creed of the ungodly, and by it you may see how natural it is for them to abuse the Gospel, to plead God’s grace in order to quiet and strengthen themselves in sin, and to embolden themselves on Christ as a reason to disobey him.

But this is simply to set Christ against himself, to pit his merits and mercies against his government and Spirit; to set his death against the ends of his death; to set our Savior against our own salvation; to run from God and rebel against him because Christ died to recover us to God and to give us repentance that leads to life. It is to sin because he died to save his people from their sins (Matt 1:21), "and to purify a peculiar people to himself, zealous of good works" (Titus 2:14). "He that committeth sin is of the devil; for the devil sinneth from the beginning. For this purpose the Son of God was manifested, that he might destroy the works of the devil" (1 John 3:8 John 8:44).

CHAPTER 20

DIRECTION 18: WATCH AGAINST THE DECAY AND CORRUPTION OF GRACE

 

"Watch diligently, both against the more discernible decays of grace, and against its degenerating into some carnal affection, or something counterfeit and of another kind. And do the same for religious duties."

We are no sooner warmed by the celestial flame than natural corruption begins drawing us toward coldness, like hot water that loses its heat by degrees unless the fire is kept burning beneath it. Who does not feel that as soon as the heart has gained a little warmth in a sermon, a prayer, or holy meditation, the moment it is over the heart inclines toward its former earthly temper? A little carelessness in duty, in thought, or in worldly business, and we quickly grow cold and dull again. Be watchful, therefore, against declining too far. Return often to the means that preserve you from decline: when faintness tells you that your stomach is empty of its last nourishment, supply it with more, lest your strength fail. You are rowing against the current of fleshly interest and inclination; do not rest too long at the oars, or you will drift downstream faster by your ease than you can climb back by your labor.

The degenerating of grace is a form of backsliding that is very common and far too little observed. It happens when good affections do not directly cool but instead turn into carnal affections that resemble them while being of an entirely different kind, as if, instead of dying, a man’s body received the soul of a beast in place of his rational human soul. Consider the following cases:

1.) Have you believed in God and in Jesus Christ and loved them accordingly? You may appear to do so still, just as much as before, while your corrupted mind has received some false representation of them. In that case, what you believe and love is in fact something else entirely.

2.) Have you been fervent in prayer? You may remain fervent. If Satan can corrupt your prayers by corrupting your judgment or affections, persuading you that what opposes God is actually God’s cause, that what God commands is against him, and that the most faithful members of the church are its troublers, he has only to turn your prayers against God’s cause and people through your mistake, and you may pray against them as fervently as you please. The same holds for preaching, conversation, and zeal: corrupt them once and turn them against God, and Satan will gladly join you in zealous and frequent preaching, disputing, and conferring.

3.) Have you confidence in Christ and his promise for your salvation? Take care that it does not turn into carnal security, a persuasion of your good standing before God resting on poor grounds, or on no grounds you can clearly name.

4.) Have you the hope of glory? Take care that it does not degenerate into a reckless venturing of your soul, a mere setting aside of fear and of honest self-suspicion.

5.) Have you a love for those who fear the Lord? Watch your heart, lest that love degenerate into something carnal or partial. Many unwary young people of different sexes have begun by loving each other with an honest, chaste, and godly love; but through imprudent over-familiarity, before they were aware of it, that love turned fleshly, and became their snare, drawing them further into sin and trouble.

Many who honored those who feared the Lord have gradually slipped into honoring only those among them who were prominent in wealth and worldly standing, or esteemed for their abilities and positions, while giving little honor to the humble, poor, and obscure Christians who were at least as godly as the rest. They forgot that "the things that are highly esteemed among men are abomination in the sight of God" (Luke 16:15), and that God values people not by their rank and dignity in the world but by their grace and holiness of life.

Many who at first seemed to love all Christians as Christians, as far as anything of Christ appeared in them, have fallen first into some faction, then into over-admiring their own party, then into making light of others as good as themselves, censuring them as unsound, and finally withdrawing their special love and confining it to their own circle, all while believing they loved the godly as much as ever, when in truth that love had degenerated into a partisan attachment.

6.) Are you zealous for God, for truth, for holiness, and against the sins and errors of others? Take care that you do not lose this zeal while thinking it is growing in you. Nothing is more apt to degenerate than zeal. In how many thousands has it turned from an innocent, charitable, peaceable, tractable, healing, profitable, and heavenly zeal into a partial zeal for some party or private opinions, and then into a fierce, censorious, uncharitable, scandalous, turbulent, disobedient, disorderly, and destructive zeal, ready to call down fire from heaven and to kindle contention, confusion, and every evil work. Read carefully (Jas 3).

7.) So also, if you are meek or patient, take care lest that meekness degenerate into insensibility or contempt for those who make you suffer. To be patient is not merely to be unfeeling toward affliction, but to bear the full sense of it by the power of faith, as overruled by things of far greater weight.

How readily people corrupt and debase every duty of religion is plainly visible across the vast majority of the Christian world. Throughout both the Eastern and the Western churches, among the Papists, the Greeks, the Armenians, the Abyssinians, and too many others, though the essentials of religion are retained through God’s mercy, how greatly the face of religion has been altered from what it was in the days of the apostles!

The ancient simplicity of doctrine has been turned into an abundance of new and private opinions, introduced as necessary articles of religion, and how many of them are false. Christians, too proud to accept the ancient measure of Christianity, can no longer agree among themselves what a Christian is and who is to be counted one. They therefore deny each other the name of Christian, destroy their charity toward one another, divide the church, and make themselves a mockery to the unbelieving world through their divisions. In this way the primitive unity, charity, and peace has been partly destroyed and partly replaced by the unity, charity, and peace of separate sects among themselves.

The primitive simplicity of government and discipline has been turned, among most, into a coercive, secular government exercised to exalt one man above others, to serve his will and desires, to make him the rule of other men’s lives, and to suppress the power and spirituality of religion in the world. The primitive simplicity of worship has been turned into such a parade of ceremony and such a burden of formalities and bodily exercises that, if one of the apostolic Christians were to appear among them, he would scarcely think this was the same occupation the church once engaged in, or scarcely recognize religion in such an outlandish dress.

The beautiful and glorious face of Christianity has been so spotted and defiled that it is hidden from the unbelieving world, who laugh at it as irrational or take it to be no different from their own religions. The principal obstacle to converting heathens, Mahometans, and other unbelievers is the corruption and deformity of the churches nearest to them, or that should be the instruments of their conversion.

The most promising path to the conversion of those nations is the genuine reformation of the churches, both East and West. Were they restored to the ancient spirituality, rationality, and simplicity of doctrine, discipline, and worship, and were they living in charity, humility, and holiness, as those whose hearts and conduct are oriented toward heaven, with all worldly glory and honor under their feet, they would appear so illustrious and appealing even to heathens and unbelievers that many would flock into the church of Christ, desiring to be what these Christians are. Their light would so shine before those people that they would see their good works, glorify their heavenly Father, and embrace their faith.

The most common way in which all religious duties degenerate is into dead formality, a lifeless image of religion. If the devil can strip away the spirituality and life from your duties, he will happily allow you to appear very devout, to make great show with outward actions, words, and beads; and you will have zeal enough for a dead religion, or for the corpse of worship, to convince yourself it is alive. By every means take care against turning the worship of God into mere lip-service.

The most common cause of this is a carnality of mind (fleshly people will think best of the most fleshly religion); another is sloth in duty, which makes you settle for the easiest part. It is the work of a saint, and a diligent saint, to keep the soul itself both regularly and vigorously engaged with God. But to repeat certain words by rote and to raise hands and eyes is easy. Hypocrites who know inwardly that they are empty of the life and spirituality of worship try to make everything up with this formality, quieting their consciences and deceiving their souls with a handsome image. I have spoken of this more fully in a book called The Vain Religion of the Formal Hypocrite.

Yet do not run to the opposite extreme by concluding that the body must not worship God as well as the soul, or that the decent and edifying ordering of the outward circumstances of religion and the right structuring of worship is needless or sinful, or that a form of prayer is unlawful, either in itself or when imposed. Rather, let the soul and body of religion go together, and let the adjustable outward elements be used as what they are, adjustable, while the life of holiness is kept constantly alive.

CHAPTER 21

DIRECTION 19: DO NOT PROMISE YOURSELF LONG LIFE OR WORLDLY PROSPERITY

 

‘Do not promise yourselves long life, or prosperity and great matters in the world, lest it entangle your hearts with transitory things, engage you in ambitious or covetous designs, steal away your hearts from God, and destroy all your serious apprehensions of eternity.’

Our own experience, and the changes that the approach of death produces in most people, plainly show that expecting a swift departure and reckoning on a short life greatly helps us in all our preparation and in all the work of holiness throughout our lives. Go to a man lying on his deathbed, or a prisoner condemned to die tomorrow, and try him with talk of riches, honors, temptations to lust, drunkenness, or excess, he will think you are mad, or at least very much out of place, to bring such things before him. If he has only ordinary reason, you will find that he dismisses such temptations far more easily than many religious people do in their prosperity and health.

How earnest we become in repenting, reviewing our past lives, settling our accounts, and asking what we must do to be saved, when we see that death is truly at hand, that time is ending, and that we must go! Every sentence of Scripture then has life and power in it; every word of exhortation is welcome; every reproof of our negligence and sin is well received; every thought of sin, or Christ, or grace, or eternity, cuts to the heart. Time then seems precious. Ask that man whether time is better spent in cards, dice, plays, feasting, needless recreations, and idleness, or in prayer, holy discussion, reading and meditating on the Word of God and the life to come, and the holy use of our lawful labors. How easily he will be satisfied of the truth, and will himself refute the objections of pleasure-seeking time-wasters! His judgment will then settle more readily on the right answer than learning or argument could have achieved before.

In short, the expectation of the soul’s swift approach into the presence of the eternal God, and of our entering into an unchangeable, endless life of joy or torment, carries so much power to awaken every faculty of the soul, that if anything will make us serious, this will, in every thought, every word, and every duty. It is therefore a great mercy of God that this life, which is already short, should also be uncertain, and that frequent dangers and sicknesses call us to look about ourselves and be ready for our departure. As a rule, the sick who expect death are the most thoughtful. It is therefore a major part of the duty of those in youth and health to consider their frailty, the shortness and uncertainty of their lives, and always to live as those who wait for the coming of their Lord.

We have every reason to do so: we are certain the end will come soon; we have many perils and weaknesses to warn us; we are never sure of another hour; and time is so swift, so quickly gone, so unrecoverable, and counts for nothing once it has passed. Common reason requires such people to live in a constant readiness to die.

Cicero asked what there is in a man’s life that can be called long. Grant the longest span, he said; look for the age of the king of the Tartessians, for there was, as he had read, one Arganthonius at Gades who reigned eighty years and lived a hundred and twenty. Yet nothing seems long to him, he observed, in which there is an end; when that end comes, all that went before has simply flowed away, and only what has been gained through virtue and right action remains. Hours, days, months, and years pass on; past time never returns, and what is to come cannot be known. (Cicero, On Old Age, ch. 69.)

But if youth or health once leads you to reckon on a long life, to push the day of your departure far off as though it were nowhere near, this will do much to deceive and dull even the best, to strip every truth of its power, to drain the life from every good thought and duty, until everything dwindles into habit and empty form. You will scarcely keep the faculties of the soul awake unless you continue to think of death and judgment as near at hand. The absolute certainty of your greatest change, and of everlasting joy or misery, will not keep our dull hearts awake unless we regard it as near, not merely as certain.

This is plain from the common difference found in all people between their thoughts of death when they are well, and their thoughts when they see that they must die at once. Those who in health could think and speak of death with laughter, or with careless lightness and no stirring of soul, are at the point of death often so utterly changed that it is as though they had never before heard they were mortal. This plainly shows that to live in the house of mirth is more dangerous than to live in the house of mourning, and that the expectation of a long life is a serious enemy to the workings of grace and the safety of the soul.

Such an expectation is also one of the greatest reinforcements of temptation to luxury, ambition, worldliness, and almost every sin. When people think they have many years ahead in which to repent, they are inclined to transgress more boldly. When they think they have many years yet to live, they are tempted to pass time in idleness, to dawdle in their race, to trifle in all their work, and to overvalue all the pleasures, honors, and shadows of happiness that are found here below. The man who holds his house or land as a permanent possession, or as an inheritance, will set far more store by it and spend far more on it than if he expected to leave it the very next year. To a man who thinks of living many years, the favor of the great, the building up of his estate, name, and family, and the comforts and satisfactions of his flesh will seem weightier matters, and self-denial will become very hard work.

For this reason, though health is a wonderfully great mercy in that it equips a person for duty when the heart is set on using it for that end, it is also, by its natural tendency, a very great danger and snare to the heart itself, turning it from the path of duty. The life best for the soul is the one that least endangers it by being too agreeable to the body, the life in which the flesh has the smallest foothold from which to press its claims against the Spirit.

This is not to say that a larger share of goods must be refused; it should be received and used for God when he entrusts it to us, for when he sets us the hardest work, we may expect his greatest help. But to dwell, as it were, in tents, in constant unsettledness, in a moveable condition, having little and needing little, never finding anything in created things that tempts you to say, "Soul, take your rest," this is, for most people, the safest life, and the one that gives the freest advantages for heaven.

Take heed, therefore, as you love your souls, of falling into the snare of worldly hopes, of laying plans for advancement and riches, and of pleasing yourselves in the pursuit of these things. To do so is to take the readiest road to ruin: to idolatrous worldliness, to apostasy of heart from God, to opening a door to every sin that seems necessary for your worldly ends, to shameful hypocrisy as a cover for all of this, and to quieting your guilty consciences with something that merely resembles religion.

When you begin to speak with the worldly security of the man in Luke 12:18–19, "I will pull down my barns, and build greater; and there will I bestow all my fruits and my goods. And I will say to my soul, Soul, thou hast much goods laid up for many years; take thine ease, eat, drink, and be merry," you are then making fools of yourselves, and near to being called away, as fools, by death, (Luke 12:20–21). And when, with no sense of the uncertainty of your lives, you speak as those in James 4:13–14, "To-day, or to-morrow we will go into such a city, and continue there a year, and buy, and sell, and get gain; whereas you know not what shall be on the morrow," you forget what your lives are: "a vapour, appearing a little while, and then vanishing away" (Jas 4:14). "Boast not thyself therefore of to-morrow; for thou knowest not what a day may bring forth." (Prov 27:1)

CHAPTER 22

DIRECTION 20: LET YOUR RELIGION BE WHOLLY DIVINE, HOLINESS TO THE LORD

 

"See that your religion be purely divine, animated entirely by God as the beginning, the way, and the end. Let there be written first upon your soul, and then upon all that you have and do, ‘HOLINESS TO THE LORD.’ Do not corrupt everything with an inordinate, hypocritical respect for man."

To be holy is to be devoted to God, set apart for him, his will, and his purposes, so that your heart and life are no longer common and unclean. To be godly is to live toward God: to believe from the heart that he is truly God, "that he is the rewarder of them that diligently seek him" (Heb 11:6), that he is our all-sufficient God, "our shield and exceeding great reward" (Gen 15:1; 17:1), and that "of him, and through him, and to him are all things" (Rom 11:36), so that all glory may be given to him forever.

Even Plato reasoned in this way about good and evil: that the end of life is to become like God; that virtue is indeed sufficient for living well and blessedly, but that it needs instruments, namely the goods of the body, such as strength, health, and soundness of the senses, and outward goods as well, such as wealth, noble birth, and reputation; and yet that if these are lacking, the wise man will be blessed nonetheless. He held also that the gods perceive and care for human affairs, and that spirits exist. And in his dialogues he judged justice to be a divine law, the more powerfully to persuade people to act justly, lest after death the wicked should pay the penalty. So Diogenes Laertius reports.

As God is infinitely above all creatures, living on him and toward him must necessarily raise us above the highest merely sensual life. This is why true religion stands transcendently above all sciences and arts. The measure of God that is in you and upon you is the measure by which you exceed what any worldly achievement could raise you to. God should be the first, the last, and the whole of what occupies a believer’s mind, mouth, and life.

God must be the chief object of your religion: your understanding and will must be exercised upon him. When you awake, you should still be with him (Ps 139:18). Your thoughts of him should be sweet, and you should be glad in him. Creatures, placed under him, may be the frequent but secondary object of your religion, yet always only as referred back to him. God must be the author of your religion: he must institute it if you expect him to accept and reward it. God must be its rule, as he reveals his will in his Word. God must be its ultimate end, in that it is directed toward pleasing and glorifying him.

God must be the constant motive and reason behind all you do. You must be able honestly to draw your reason from heaven and say, "I do this because it is his will; I do it to please, glorify, and enjoy him." God must be taken as the sovereign Judge of your religion, of yourself, and of all your actions. You must look wholly to his judgment and approval, and avoid whatever he condemns.

Can you take God as your Owner, your Sovereign, your Savior, your sufficient Protector, your Portion, your all? If not, you cannot be godly or be saved. If his authority does not carry more weight with you than the authority of the greatest person on earth, you are atheistical hypocrites and not truly religious, whatever you claim. If "HOLINESS TO THE LORD" is written on you and on everything that is yours, then you are devoted to him as his own peculiar people.

If your name is marked on your sheep, your plate, or your clothes, and someone takes them, you say, "Those are mine, do you not see my mark on them?" Slavery to the flesh, the world, and the devil is the mark written on the ungodly, on the foreheads of the profane and on the hearts of hypocrites. Satan, the world, and the flesh claim their service accordingly. If you are consecrated to God and bear his name and mark, then tell everyone who would lay claim to you that you are his, and that you are resolved to live to him, love him, trust him, and stand or fall to him alone. Let God be the very life, the animating sense, and the final end of all you do.

When man begins to occupy too much of your regard, when you set too great a store by his favor and esteem, or look too much to him in your profession and practice; when his approval comforts you too much, and his displeasure or criticism troubles you too much; when your fear, love, care, and obedience are too heavily taken up with man, you are, to that degree, withdrawing from God. You are becoming a servant of men, a friend of the world, turning back to bondage, and forsaking your Rock and Portion and your true excellence. The soul of religion is departing from you; it is dying and returning to the dust.

If man once gains precedence over God, if he is preferred above him in your heart and life, feared, trusted, and obeyed before him, then you are dead to God and alive to the world. Having taken men as your gods, you must settle for such a salvation as they can give you. If your alms and prayers are done to be seen of men, to win their good opinion and praise, then make the most of what you get, for your Judge has already told you: "Verily, you have your reward." (Matt 6:1–5)

This is not to say that man is absolutely to be despised or ignored. Not at all. Under God, your superiors must be obeyed; you must wrong no one and do good to all as far as lies in you. You must avoid giving offense, set a good example, and, under God, have enough regard for others to "become all things to all men, for their salvation." But once you elevate others beyond their proper rank, turn yourself into an excessive dependence on them, and make too much of their opinions or words about you, you are losing your godliness and your divine orientation, and turning them into man-pleasing and hypocrisy.

When man stands in competition with God for your first and chief regard, whether in opposition to him, or alongside him as a coordinate rather than a subordinate concern, he is to be numbered among the things to be forsaken. Even good people, whom you must love and honor, and whose fellowship and help you must greatly value, may yet become the object of your sin and your snare. Your honoring of them and love toward them must not entice you to crave honor from them in return, nor lead you to set too much store by their approval. If you do, you will find that while you are too much occupied with man, you are losing God and corrupting your religion at its very heart.

You may also find yourself among those who, however holy they appear, harbor serious errors in matters of religion, errors that tend toward much sin, and who are somewhat censorious toward those who differ from them. In that case, retaining their esteem and avoiding their censure may become one of the greatest temptations of your life. And you will discover that pleasing men is a very demanding yet entirely unprofitable work.

Love Christ as he appears in any of his servants. Follow them as they follow Christ. Value their approval insofar as it agrees with Christ’s. But above all, make sure you are able to live on the favor of God alone, to be at peace in his acceptance even when men despise you; to be satisfied so long as God is satisfied, even when men are displeased with you; and to rejoice in his justification even when men condemn you with the most odious slanders and the greatest infamy, and cast out your name as that of an evildoer. Cicero pressed the same on a heathen’s grounds: if you would look on high, he says, and keep in view that seat and eternal home, you must not give yourself over to the talk of the crowd, nor rest the hope of your affairs on human rewards; virtue herself, by her own attractions, ought to draw you to true honor. Always look, he adds, upon those things that are heavenly, and despise the things that are human.

See that God is enough for you, or else you do not truly take him as God. Enough without man; enough against man. So that you can say, "If God be for us, who can be against us? Who is he that condemneth? It is God that justifieth." (Rom 8:31, 33–34) "Do I seek to please men? For if I yet pleased men, I should not be a servant of Christ." (Gal 1:10)

"Thus saith the Lord; Cursed be the man that trusteth in man, and maketh flesh his arm, and whose heart departeth from the Lord. For he shall be like the heath in the desert, and shall not see when good cometh. Blessed is the man that trusteth in the Lord, and whose hope the Lord is. For he shall be as a tree planted by the waters, and that spreadeth out her roots by the river, and shall not see when heat cometh, but her leaf shall be green; and shall not be careful in the year of drought, neither shall cease from yielding fruit." (Jer 17:5–8) "Cease ye from man, whose breath is in his nostrils: for wherein is he to be accounted of?" (Isa 2:22)

Having given you these Directions, I must tell you in closing that they are like food that does not nourish you by sitting on the table, or like medicine that does not cure you by remaining in the bottle. They must be taken and digested, or you will find none of the benefit. Simply reading them will not serve the great purposes for which they are given, the safe progress and confirmation of those who are new to religion. They require humility to perceive your need of them, and genuine effort to learn, absorb, and practice them.

Those who are too slothful to make that effort must bear the sad consequences of their negligence. There is not one of all these Directions, as to its substance, that can be spared. Study them, understand them, and keep them in mind as things that must actually be done. If either a numbness toward your own need, or a notion that the Spirit will do it all without any diligence of your own, leads you to set these aside with nothing more than a vague approval, the consequences may be far worse than you can now foresee.

Though I assume you have some beginnings of grace, I must tell you that it will be a comparatively wretched kind of life to be erroneous, and a scandal to the church, or to be full of doubts and fears and unruly passions, burdensome to others and to yourselves. Indeed, you have good reason to question your own sincerity if you do not desire to grow in grace and are not willing to use the means necessary to that growth. No one is sincere who does not desire to be perfect; and no one sincerely desires what they are unwilling to pursue at the cost and labor it requires.

I urge you therefore, as you love the happiness of prudent, mature, and settled Christians, and would escape the misery of those grievous spiritual diseases that would turn your lives into weakness, uselessness, and pain, seriously study these Directions. Get them into your minds, your memories, and your hearts. Let the faithful practice of them be your greatest care and the steady occupation of your lives.

CHAPTER 23

GRAND DIRECTION 1: UNDERSTAND THE NATURE AND GROUNDS OF FAITH AND GODLINESS

 

‘Labor to understand well the nature, grounds, reason, and order of faith and godliness: and to believe upon such grounds, so well understood, as will not suffer you to stagger, or entertain a contrary belief.’

Ignorance, and persuasions that are ungrounded or ill-grounded in matters of religion, cause vast numbers of people to delude themselves with the empty name and dead profession of a faith and religion they have never truly possessed. I recognize that many true believers have comparatively low degrees of knowledge, and that there may be much love and holiness where knowledge is very limited in its scope. I recognize too that there is a knowledge that puffs up while charity builds up, and that among those with narrower knowledge there may be the firmest faith and adherence to truth, the kind that holds in the time of trial. Yet I must tell you plainly: the religion you profess is not truly your own religion if you do not know what it is, and do not at least in part know the true grounds and reasons why you should hold it.

If you have only learned to recite a creed or repeat the words of Christian doctrine without genuinely understanding their meaning, or if you have no better reasons for professing the Christian faith than the custom of your country, the command of rulers, the opinion of your teachers, or the example of your parents, friends, or neighbors, you are not Christians in reality. You hold a human belief or opinion that is objectively true, but subjectively, within yourselves, you have no true divine faith. I grant that a true believer may mistakenly rely on some insufficient or even erroneous reasons to prove certain fundamental truths; but that same person also has other, sounder reasons for receiving those truths, and his faith is sound because of those sound, infallible principles, even though some unsound reasons are mixed in. The true believer builds on the rock and gives deep rootage to the holy seed (Matt 7:24 Matt 13:5–8).

Some misguided people may tell you that faith and reason are such enemies that they exclude each other with respect to the same object, and that the less reason you have for the truth of what you believe, the stronger and more praiseworthy your faith is. But when it comes to the test, you will find that faith is not an unreasonable thing. God requires you to believe no more than you have sufficient reason to warrant and sustain. Your faith can be no greater than your grasp of the reasons why you should believe, and God both presupposes reason when he infuses faith and employs reason in the exercise of faith. Those who believe without knowing why, or who know no sufficient reason to warrant their belief, are taking a fancy, an opinion, or a dream for faith.

I know that many sincere Christians are unable to argue for their religion or give others a satisfying account of the reasons for their faith and hope; yet they do have a true grasp of some solid reasons within themselves. They are not Christians for no reason they can name. Though their knowledge may be small in the number of propositions they know, it always extends to everything essential to Christianity and godliness, and they do not believe they know not what. Their knowledge is greater in depth and in its value and operation than the knowledge of the most learned ungodly person in the world.

Though I cannot here digress or dwell long enough to lay out fully the nature, grounds, reason, and method of faith and godliness that I am urging you to understand, I will first set before you a few propositions that will be useful as you inquire into these things, and then open them briefly.

1. A life of godliness is our living toward God as God, being absolutely devoted to him.

2. A life of faith is a living upon the unseen, everlasting happiness purchased for us by Christ, together with everything necessary to it, and freely given us by God.

3. The contrary life of sense and unbelief is a life in which sense or flesh prevails, and the person lives for this present world, for lack of such believing apprehensions of a better world as would lift the soul toward it and conquer the fleshly inclination toward present things.

4. Though humanity in innocence, needing no Redeemer, might have lived to God without faith in a Redeemer, fallen humanity is not only unable to redeem itself but also unable to live to God without the grace of the Redeemer. It was necessary not only that Christ satisfy God’s justice on our behalf, so that God may pardon and save us without any wrong to his holiness, wisdom, or government, but also that he be our teacher by his doctrine and his life, that he reveal from heaven the Father’s will, that in him we may see the wonderful, condescending love and goodness of a reconciled God and Father, that he effectually illumine, sanctify, and quicken us by the working of his Word and Spirit, and that he protect, govern, justify, and glorify us. He is the Head of restored humanity, as Adam was the root of fallen humanity and as fallen spirits had their head. We must therefore live wholly upon him as the Mediator between God and humanity, and the only Savior by merit and by power.

5. Faith is a knowledge received through certain credible testimony or revelation from God, by means that are supernatural or extraordinary.

6. The knowledge of things revealed by nature, such as knowing a cause by its effect, comes before the knowledge or belief of things revealed supernaturally.

7. It is a matter of natural revelation that there is a God; that he is infinite in his immensity and eternity, in his power, wisdom, and goodness; that he is the first cause and ultimate end of all things; that he is the preserver and sovereign disposer of all things, the supreme governor of the rational world, the great benefactor of all humanity, and the special favorer and rewarder of those who truly love him, seek him, and obey him. It is equally a matter of natural revelation that the soul of humanity is immortal, that there is a life of reward or punishment to come, and that this present life is only preparatory to that one; that humanity is bound to love God its Maker and serve him with all its heart and might, and to believe that such labor is not in vain; and that we must do our best to know God’s will in order to do it. This, and much more, belongs to natural revelation and is within reach even of unbelievers.

Diogenes Laertius says of the Magi that they gave themselves to the worship of the gods, rejecting carved signs and statues, and above all rejecting the opinion of those who say that some gods are male and some female. He says also that these same Magi held, and Theopompus with them, that men would live again and become immortal; and he reports the like of many other sects. It is a most irrational thing to doubt the being of the unseen worlds, and of the more excellent inhabitants of them, when we consider that this low and little part of God’s creation is so full of inhabitants. If a microscope will show your very eyes a thousand visible creatures that you could never see without it, nor know that they had any being at all, will you not allow the pure intellectual sight to go much further beyond your microscope?

8. There is a remarkable harmony and correspondence between natural and supernatural divinity: the natural leads toward the supernatural, and the supernatural falls in precisely where the natural ends, falls short, or is defective, which greatly aids us in believing supernatural divinity.

Thales’ sayings, as Diogenes Laertius reports them, run in this vein: the most beautiful thing is the world, for God made it; the greatest is space, for it contains all things; the swiftest is mind, for it runs through all things; the strongest is necessity, for it overcomes all; the wisest is time, for it discovers all things. Asked which was made first, night or day, he answered, night, by one day. Asked whether a man doing evil could escape the notice of the gods, he said, not even thinking of it. Asked what is difficult, he said, to know oneself; and what is easy, to give advice to another. Asked what is sweetest, he said, to obtain what you desire; and what God is, he said, that which has neither beginning nor end.

Moreover, just as the law of nature was exactly fitted to humanity in its natural, innocent state, so the law and way of grace in Christ is admirably and exactly fitted to the state of fallen humanity for its recovery and salvation. The experience that humanity has of its sin and misery can therefore greatly prepare it to perceive and believe this most fitting Gospel, this doctrine of recovery. And though the Gospel cannot be called "natural" in the sense of being fitted to innocent nature, or as if it were revealed by ordinary natural means, yet it may be called natural in the sense that it is exactly suited to the restoration of fallen, miserable nature, just as Lazarus’s restored soul, though supernaturally restored, was the most natural companion of his body, or as bread, milk, or wine, even if it were to fall from heaven, would in itself be the most natural food for humanity.

9. The same truths in divinity that are revealed naturally to all people are revealed again supernaturally in the Gospel. They may therefore rightly be both the object of natural knowledge and the object of faith.

10. When the malicious tempter casts doubt on the existence of God or on other points of natural certainty, he so thoroughly discredits his own suggestions that this discrediting can greatly help us reject his temptations when he also moves us to doubt the truth of the Gospel.

11. Many necessary accompaniments to the objects of divine faith are themselves the matter of human faith. (More on this shortly.)

12. Christ as Mediator is the way, the chief means, to God, coming to restore humanity to its Maker. Faith in Christ is therefore the means by which we are brought to the love of God, though in experience the two are intertwined.

13. Knowledge and faith are the eye of the new creature; love is in the heart. There is no more spiritual wisdom than there is faith, and no more spiritual life, acceptable qualification, or loveliness than there is love for God.

14. All truths in divinity are revealed for the sake of a holy life. Both faith and love are the principles and springs of practice.

15. Practice gives a believing soul such experience as may greatly confirm it in the belief of those supernatural revelations that it had previously received without that aid.

16. The eternal enjoyment of God in glory is the end of all religion, and it must therefore be closest to our heart and most constantly before our eyes. It must objectively animate our whole religion and move us in every duty.

17. Pleasing God is likewise our end, and both, enjoying him and pleasing him, are attainable in some small foretastes even in this life. The effort of our souls and lives must therefore be to exercise love and obedience through faith, for in this way God is pleased and enjoyed.

18. Everything in religion is fitted to the good of humanity and to nothing that harms it. God does not require us to honor him by anything that would make us miserable, but only by embracing and magnifying his love and grace.

19. Yet it is by his own revelation that we must judge what is ultimately for our good or our harm. We may not suppose that our shallow and fallible reason is sufficient to discern without his Word what is best or worst for us. Nor can we rationally argue from any present temporal adversity or bitter experience of the means, "This is the worst thing for me, and therefore it cannot come from the goodness of God." In such cases we must reason the other way: "This is from the goodness and love of God, and therefore it is for the best."

20. The chief obstacle to all religion and to our salvation, hindering our believing, loving, and obeying alike, is the disordered, sensual inclination toward carnal self and toward present transitory things, craftily set before us by the tempter to ensnare us and to divert and steal our hearts away from God and the life to come. Understanding these propositions will greatly help you discern the nature and the reason of religion.

CHAPTER 24

GRAND DIRECTION 2: USE CHRIST AS THE MEANS OF ACCESS TO GOD

"Diligently labor in that part of the life of faith which consists in the constant use of Christ as the means of the soul’s access to God, acceptance with him, and comfort from him: and think not of coming to the Father except by him."

To talk and boast of Christ is easy, and to use him merely to increase our carnal security and boldness in sinning is easier still. But to live in the daily use of Christ for those purposes of his office for which we are to make use of him, this demands far greater skill and diligence than many self-satisfied professors realize. What Christ himself has done, or will do, for our salvation is not directly what we are now considering; rather, it is what use he requires us to make of him in the life of faith. He has told us that his flesh is meat indeed and his blood is drink indeed, and that unless we eat his flesh and drink his blood we have no life in us. Here is our use of Christ, expressed as eating and drinking his flesh and blood, which is by faith.

Jerome writes to Celantia that the whole of righteousness, and this commandment of God, is the common benefit of mankind: "O the wonderful mercy of the Lord! O the unspeakable kindness of God! He promises us a reward if we love one another, that is, if we render to one another the things we each in turn need; and yet we, in a proud and ungrateful spirit, hold back from the will of him whose very command is itself a benefit." I have written more of this in my Reasons of the Christian Religion.

The general parts of the work of redemption Christ has himself performed for us, without asking our consent or imposing on us any condition without which he would not act. Just as the sun illuminates and warms the earth whether the earth wills it or not, and as the rain falls on the grass without asking whether it consents or will be thankful, so Christ, without our consent or knowledge, took our nature, fulfilled the law, satisfied the offended Lawgiver, merited grace, conquered Satan, death, and hell, and became the glorified Lord of all.

Paul Scaliger holds that the incarnation was necessary for the very union between creature and Creator: as in the Godhead there is one essence and three persons, so in Christ there is one person and three essences, deity, soul, and flesh; Christ is begotten according to the nature of his divinity, created according to his soul, and made according to his flesh; and the union in Christ is threefold, of the deity to the soul, of the deity to the flesh, and of the soul to the flesh. Christ alone, he adds, and that according to both natures, is called the Head of the church.

But for the exercise of his graces in us, our advancement to communion with God, and our living in the strength and joys of faith, he is himself the object of our duty, namely of that faith which we must daily and diligently exercise upon him. In this respect, Christ will profit us no further than we make use of him by faith. It is not a forgotten Christ who objectively comforts or encourages the soul, but a Christ believed in and skillfully and faithfully used to that end.

It is in an objective sense (and chiefly so) that Christ is called our wisdom (1 Cor 1:30). The knowledge of him and of the mysteries of grace in him is the Christian or divine philosophy, wisdom set against the vain philosophy of which the learned heathen boasted. This is why Paul determined to know nothing but Christ crucified: that is, to display no other knowledge, to glory in nothing but the cross of Christ, and to preach Christ as though he knew nothing else (1 Cor 1:23 1 Cor 2:2 Gal 6:14). And it is in this same objective sense that Christ is said to dwell in our hearts by faith (Eph 3:17). Faith keeps him ever upon the heart through continual contemplation, application, and use, just as a friend is said to dwell in our hearts when we continually love and think of him.

Christ himself teaches us to distinguish between faith in God as God and faith in himself as Mediator: "Let not your heart be troubled: ye believe in God," or, believe ye in God? "believe also in me" (John 14:1). These two, placed together, are the sufficient cure of a troubled heart. It is not faith in God as God but faith in Christ as Mediator that I am now to speak of, and not as it resides in the understanding, but as it operates on the heart and in the life. This is no small part of the life of faith by which the just are said to live. Every true Christian must be able to say in his measure with Paul: "I am crucified with Christ: nevertheless I live; yet not I, but Christ liveth in me: and the life which I now live in the flesh, I live by the faith of the Son of God, who loved me, and gave himself for me" (Gal 2:20).

The pure Godhead is the beginning and end of all. But Christ is "the image of the invisible God, the first-born of every creature; and by him all things were created that are in heaven and that are in earth, visible and invisible, whether they be thrones or dominions, or principalities or powers, all things were created by him and for him: and he is before all things, and by him all things do consist. And he is the head of the body, the church; who is the beginning, the first-born from the dead; that in all things he might have the pre-eminence" (Col 1:16–19).

"In him it is that we who were sometime afar off are made nigh, even by his blood. For he is our peace, who hath reconciled both Jew and Gentile unto God in one body by the cross, having slain the enmity thereby: and came and preached peace to them that were afar off, and to them that were nigh. For through him we both have an access by one Spirit unto the Father: so that now we are no more strangers and foreigners, but fellow-citizens with the saints, and of the household of God" (Eph 2:13–18). "In him" it is "that we have boldness and access with confidence through faith in him" (Eph 3:12); "he is the way, the truth, and the life: and no man cometh to the Father, but by him" (John 14:6).

It is "by the blood of Jesus that we have boldness," and liberty, "to enter into the holiest: by a new and living way which he hath consecrated for us through the vail, that is to say, his flesh." Because "we have so great a Priest over the house of God, we may draw near, with a true heart, in full assurance of faith" (Heb 10:19–22). "By him it is that we have access by faith into this grace wherein we stand, and boast in hope of the glory of God" (Rom 5:1–2). We must therefore have all our communion with God through him.

Acosta observes that by apostolic and ancient tradition no one is baptized in the church of Christ until he has first been asked whether he believes in God the Father, and in Jesus Christ the Son of God, and in the Holy Spirit, and has answered that he firmly believes; so that however slow of understanding a man may be, if he has any judgment at all, and is so questioned and so answers, he is required to believe just that much expressly. Implicitly and by consequence he believes not only these articles but whatever the Scriptures set forth, though he is not questioned about all of them, since it is by no means necessary that he know every one of them expressly.

Supposing what I have already said on this subject in my "Directions for a Sound Conversion," Direction 5, which I hope the reader will consult, I shall here briefly name the uses we must make of Christ by faith in order to maintain our holy converse with God. But I must say plainly: this is a doctrine that requires a prepared heart, one that has life within to enable it to relish holy truth and to incline it toward diligence, delight, and constancy in practice. A numb reader will find little savor in it, and a sluggish reader who lets it die as soon as it has touched his ears or imagination will fall far short of both the practice and the pleasure of this life. He must have faith, and must live by faith; and he must have the heart and nature of a child if he is to take pleasure in loving, reverent, and obedient converse with a father.

Eulogius, archbishop of Toledo and martyr, says in his Memorial of the Saints that faith is truly the root and foundation of all the virtues: it helps those who contend, crowns those who conquer, and rewards some with a heavenly gift where signs are lacking; for nothing is denied to sincere faith, since God requires of us nothing but faith, which he loves, which he requires, and to which he promises and grants all things. Acosta adds that since faith apart from works is dead, it is by then no longer faith at all. And Luther, as Dr. Boys reports him, says that the Christian religion begins not at the highest but at the lowest: with Christ incarnate, teaching, dying.

1. The great obstacle that blocks the soul seeking to draw near to God is the darkness of ignorance and unbelief. When the soul does not know God, or does not know how capable humanity is of enjoying him, or how much God cares for the human heart; when it does not know by what way God must be sought and found; or when it doubts the certainty of the word that declares duty and grounds human hope, any of these things will suppress the soul’s ascending desires, clip its wings, and break the heart of its holy longing after God, by killing or weakening all hope of success.

Make use of Jesus Christ here, then, the great revealer of God and his will to a blind world, and the great confirmer of the divine authority of his word. Life and immortality are brought more fully to light by the Gospel than ever they were by any other means. Moses and the prophets brought their doctrine with sufficient evidence of its credibility; but Christ has brought both a fuller revelation and fuller evidence to support belief. An inspired prophet who proves his inspiration is a credible messenger. But when God himself comes down into flesh, converses with humanity, teaches us the knowledge of God and the way to life, discloses the mysteries of the world to come, and seals his testimony with unquestionable proofs, who would refuse to learn from such a teacher? Who would withhold belief from such a messenger, except those who are absurd and unreasonable?

Remember, then, when ignorance or unbelief would hinder your access to God, that you have the ablest teacher and surest witness in all the world to acquaint you with him. If God had sent an angel from heaven to tell you what he is, what he requires of you, and what he will do for you, would that not be very welcome? But he has done far more: he has sent his Son. The Deity itself has appeared in flesh. He who has seen God, he who is God, has come among humanity to acquaint us with God. His testimony is more certain and credible than any angel’s. It was the love of God, says Ambrose on Paul’s closing benediction (2 Cor 13:14), that sent us a Savior, by whose grace we are saved; and that we may possess this grace, the communication of the Spirit brings it about.

"God who at sundry times, and in divers manners, spake in times past to the fathers by the prophets, hath in these last days spoken to us by his Son" (Heb 1:1–3). "No man hath seen God at any time; the only begotten Son, who is in the bosom of the Father, he hath declared him" (John 1:18). We have "neither heard the voice of God, nor seen his shape" (John 5:37). "No man hath seen the Father, save he which is of God; he hath seen the Father" (John 6:46). "No man knoweth the Father save the Son, and he to whomsoever the Son will reveal him." (Matt 11:27)

What more could we desire, short of the direct sight of the glory of God, than to have him revealed to us by a messenger from heaven, and such a messenger as has himself seen the Father and is himself God? Plato and Plotinus may describe God according to their dim conjectures. Something of him we may discern by observing his works. But Christ has declared what he saw and what he knew, beyond all possibility of mistake. And lest even his own testimony should seem questionable, he confirmed it by a life of miracles, by rising from the dead himself, by ascending visibly into heaven, and by the Holy Ghost and the miraculous gifts he gave to the messengers of his Gospel. His resurrection from the dead alone would have been enough to make unbelief utterly without excuse.

2. Another great obstacle to the soul in its approach to God is that God’s infinite distance makes it impossible for us to form right conceptions of him. We say with Elihu, "Behold, God is great, and we know him not." (Job 36:26) It is indeed impossible for mortal humanity to have any adequate apprehension of his essence. But in his Son he has come down to us and shown himself in the clearest mirror that has ever revealed him. Think of him, then, as he appeared in our flesh, as he showed himself in his holiness and goodness to the world. You may form positive thoughts of Jesus Christ. Though you should not think that the Godhead itself was flesh, you may think of it as it appeared in flesh. It can settle the understanding to conceive of God as incarnate, and to recognize that we cannot yet "know him as he is" or form any adequate conception of him, while finding in what is revealed a delight that sustains us until we reach something more.

3. The soul’s approach to God is also hindered when that infinite distance tempts us to think that God will not regard or take notice of such contemptible creatures as we are, that he is too exalted for our converse or our pleasure. In this case the soul has no better remedy than to look to Christ, and to see how the Father has regarded us, has set his heart upon us, and has sent his Son to seek and save us. What astonishing, overwhelming condescension of eternal love! Believe that God assumed flesh to make himself familiar with humanity, and you can never again question whether he regards us or will hold communion with us.

4. Comfortable access to God is further hindered when we are overwhelmed by the glory of his infinite majesty. Just as the eye cannot gaze directly at the sun without some cover, so the soul is afraid of God’s majesty, and is overcome by it when it should instead be delighted in him. Against this there is no better remedy than to behold God appearing to us in his Son, where his majesty is veiled, and where he approaches us familiarly in our own nature, inviting us to come to him with holy confidence and reverent boldness.

Christ did not appear in a terrifying form. Women dared to converse with him; beggars, cripples, and the diseased dared to ask his help; sinners dared to eat with him. The proud despised him, but the lowly were never driven away by him. He took upon himself "the form of a servant" and made himself of no reputation, so that he might freely converse with the most obscure and lowly. Though we must not debase the Godhead by imagining it is still humbled in glory as it was on earth in the flesh of Christ, yet that condescension is an unspeakable encouragement to a soul that was once frightened from God to come now with boldness.

5. When the guilt of sin frightens us away from God and we think he will not accept such great offenders as we have been, Christ is our remedy. He has paid our debt, borne our punishment, and by his blood procured and sealed our pardon. Shall pardoned sins drive us from him who pardoned them? He has justified us by his righteousness. The curse and condemnation are indeed terrible; but he has taken them away and given us a full discharge.

Ambrose cries out, "O Lord Jesus, you grieve not for your own wounds but for mine!" And Augustine says that we used immortality badly, and so died; Christ used mortality well, that we might live.

6. The weakness and infirmity of our souls in the duties of worship are also a frequent discouragement in our approach to the most holy and jealous God. To find in ourselves so little knowledge of God, so little love toward him, such cold desires, such wandering and distracted thoughts, such dull requests, it is hard to hold lively and thankful confidence that God accepts such defective, faltering meditations and prayers. We are inclined to think that he will abhor both them and us, that he can take no pleasure in them, and that it might be just as well not to pray at all.

Faith has full relief in Christ here, and can draw two things from him to encourage the fearful soul.

1.) Our acceptance with the Father is through the merits of his Son. Christ is worthy, even though we are unworthy. If we bring only the worthiness of faith, repentance, and sincere desire, Christ brings the worthiness of perfect holiness and obedience for us. We do not go to the Father in our own names, but in his; and whatever we ask the Father in the name of Christ according to his will, he will give us. (John 16:23 John 14:13 John 15:16)

2.) All the infirmities of our souls and our acts of worship are forgiven through Christ. He has undertaken to answer for them all and to justify us from all such accusations. By faith you may, as it were, hear Christ speaking these words for your encouragement: "Come boldly, poor sinner, into my Father’s presence. Do not fear the guilt of your sins or the imperfection of your prayers. As long as you truly repent of them, desire to be delivered from them, and trust in me, I am your worthiness. My righteousness is perfect and without spot. I have taken all your faults and failings upon me. I have undertaken to answer for all the imperfections of your holy acts. Sincerity is your endowment; perfection is mine. Trust me to fulfill the trust I have undertaken."

7. Sometimes the soul that would draw near to God is overwhelmed with grief and terror, so that the sense of sin, danger, and misery nearly drives it to distraction and casts it into an agony. It cries out with David: "My soul refused to be comforted: I remembered God and was troubled: I complained, and my spirit was overwhelmed. Thou holdest mine eyes waking: I am so troubled that I cannot speak." (Ps 77:2–4) Such a soul feels as though God is thrusting it away and has utterly forsaken it.

In this case, faith must look to Christ and remember that he was in an agony when he prayed, a far greater agony than any we have known, so great that he sweated drops of blood, and yet in that agony he prayed all the more earnestly. (Luke 22:44) He himself once cried out from the cross, "My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?", and yet he was the Father’s beloved, and is now at his right hand in glory. He endured all this so that we would not be forsaken. He has removed the enmity; he has reconciled us to God. Through grief he passed into joy, and he will wipe away his servants’ tears and cause their griefs to end in joy.

8. Sometimes the soul that would draw near to God is battered by a storm of hideous temptations and confused by a swarm of disordered, tangled thoughts. Satan assaults it with temptations to despair, with horrid blasphemous thoughts, and with temptations to entangle, interrupt, corrupt, or pervert the very act of worship it is engaged in, so that the soul is discouraged, overwhelmed, and broken by the inward assaults, troubles, and distractions it suffers.

In this case, faith has a Savior perfectly fitted to bring relief. It can look to him who "was tempted in all points like as we are, without sin," and who is now such a High Priest as can be touched with the feeling of our infirmities, and therefore "we may come boldly to the throne of grace, that we may obtain mercy and find grace to help in time of need." "In all things it behoved him to be made like unto his brethren, that he might be a merciful and faithful High Priest, in things pertaining to God, to make reconciliation for the sins of the people: for he himself having suffered, being tempted, he is able to succour them that are tempted." (Heb 4:14–16 Heb 2:17–18)

He submitted not only to be tempted by Satan, but to be tempted in a wilderness where he had no one to comfort him, and to be tempted toward the most horrid blasphemy and wickedness, even to fall down and worship the devil himself. He allowed the tempter to carry him violently to the pinnacle of the temple. (Matt 4) What would we think of ourselves if we were treated so? Would we not conclude that God had utterly forsaken us? He also submitted to be tempted by human beings: by the abuse and contempt of his enemies, by the desertion of his followers, by the carnal counsel of Peter urging him to avoid the death he was appointed to suffer. Yet he who made every temptation serve the triumph of his patience and conquering power will also give the victory of his grace to the weakest soul.

9. The greatest draw toward God, the thing most capable of making the thought of him pleasant, would be a firm belief that he dearly loves us, that he is reconciled to us, that he counts us his children and takes pleasure in us, that he has resolved to glorify us forever with his Son, and that our dearest friend in the world does not love us a thousandth part as much as he does. All of this is clearly set before the eye of faith in Christ. It is all procured for believers by him, and all given to believers in him. In him God is reconciled to us. He is our Father; he dwells among us, in us, and walks in us, and is our God. (2 Cor 6:16–18) Light and warmth are not more abundant in the sun than love is in Jesus Christ. To look on Christ and not perceive the love of God is like looking at the sun and refusing to acknowledge its light.

Therefore, whenever you find your heart averse to God and finding no pleasure in him, look then to Jesus, and consider in him the immeasurable love of God, that you may be able to comprehend with all the saints "what is the breadth, and length, and depth, and height; and to know the love of Christ, which passeth knowledge, that you may be filled with all the fulness of God." (Eph 3:18–19) Love and goodness are to the will what delicious sweetness is to the senses. Draw near, then, and taste the feast of love that God has prepared and offered through his Son. Do you not see or feel the love of God? Come near, and look upon God incarnate; upon a crucified Christ; upon the covenant sealed in his blood; upon all the benefits of his redemption; upon all the privileges of the saints; upon the glory purchased, possessed, and promised by him. Put your hand into his wounded side, and be not faithless, but believing, and you will cry out, "My Lord, and my God."

10. So also, when the soul longs to feel within itself the flame of love toward God, it is the beholding of Christ by faith that strikes the spark and is the effective means of kindling that love. This is the true approach to God, and the true communion and fellowship with him: as far as we love him, so far do we draw near to him, and so far do we have true communion with him. What would a believer’s soul not give to burn in love to God whenever, in prayer, meditation, or conversation, his name and attributes are mentioned or remembered!

For this, there is no more powerful means than to look believingly on Christ, in whom such glorious love appears as will draw out the love of all who perceive it by a living faith. Behold the love God has shown through his Son, and you cannot but love him who is the source of that surpassing love. In the law, God displays his frowning wrath, and therefore it produces "the spirit of bondage unto fear." But in Christ, God appears to us not only as one who loves us, but as love itself, and therefore as supremely lovely to us, giving us the spirit of adoption, the spirit of filial love, by which we run and cry to him as our Father.

11. The soul’s actual dullness and inability to engage in prayer, meditation, and all holy fellowship with the blessed God is the great obstacle to walking with him, and against this, all our relief is in Christ. He is filled with the Spirit in order to communicate it to his members. He can rouse us when we are sluggish; he can give us faith when we are unbelieving; he can give us boldness when we are discouraged; he can pour out upon us the Spirit of supplication, who will help our infirmities when we do not know what to pray for as we ought. Beg of him, then, the spirit of prayer. Look to his example, who prayed with strong cries and tears, continued all night in prayer, and told a parable to this very end: that we should always pray and not lose heart. Call to him, and he who is with the Father will extend the hand of his Spirit to you, quicken your desires, and lift you up.

12. Sometimes the soul listens to temptations of unbelief, questioning whether God even hears our prayers or whether there is as much to be gained by prayer as we are told. In such a case, faith must look to Christ, who has not only commanded prayer and encouraged it by his own example, but has also given us abundant promises of acceptance with God and of the granting of our desires. Returning to those promises will move us to draw near to God.

13. Sometimes the present sense of our own vileness, we who are but dust and contemptible worms, discourages us and weakens our expectation from God. Against this, what a wonderful relief it is to the soul to think of our union with Christ, and of the dignity and glory of our Head! Can God despise the members of his Son? Can he trample on those who are, as it were, his own flesh and bone? Will he cut off, forsake, or cast away even the weakest parts of his body?

14. Sometimes the guilt of renewed failures or spiritual decline brings back distrust and makes us shrink back. We are like a child in its mother’s arms who panics when its own grip loosens, as if its safety depended on holding her rather than on her holding it. Weak performance in duty leads to weak expectation of success. In this case, what an excellent remedy faith finds in looking to the perpetual intercession of Christ. If he is praying for us in heaven, should we not be bold to pray and expect an answer? Remember that he is not weak when we are weak, and that his praying for us is to our benefit. We now have an unchanging priest "who is able to save them to the uttermost," that is, perpetually, "that come (sincerely) to God by him, seeing he ever liveth to make intercession for them" (Heb 7:24–25). If you heard Christ pray for you, would it not encourage you to pray, and persuade you that God would not reject you? Without doubt it would.

15. Sometimes weaker Christians, who lack the gifts of memory or fluency in speech, are inclined to think that ministers and more capable people are accepted by God, but that he places little value on such as themselves. It is a great encouragement to the soul to remember that Jesus our great High Priest makes all his children priests to God. They are "a chosen generation, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, a peculiar people; that they should shew forth the praises of him that hath called them out of darkness into his marvellous light: an holy priesthood, to offer up spiritual sacrifices, acceptable to God by Jesus Christ" (1 Pet 2:5, 9). Even their "broken hearts and contrite spirits" are a sacrifice that God will not despise. He understands the meaning of the Spirit’s groaning (Rom 8:26–27).

16. The strength of the corruptions that trouble the soul, wrestling with it too often and prevailing too much, greatly discourages us from approaching the God who hates all workers of iniquity. Here faith may find relief in Christ, not only as the one who pardons us, but as the one who has himself conquered the devil and the world, and who bids us take heart because he has conquered, possesses all authority in heaven and on earth, and can grant us victorious grace in the season and measure he sees as most fitting. We can do all things through Christ who strengthens us. Go to him then by faith and prayer, and you will find that his grace is sufficient for you.

17. Thoughts of God are less delightful to the soul because death and the grave stand in the way, and we must pass through them before we can enjoy him. It is unpleasant to our nature to contemplate the separation of soul and body, and to think that our flesh must decay in darkness. But against this, faith finds wonderful relief in Jesus Christ: "Forasmuch as we were partakers of flesh and blood, he also himself likewise took part of the same; that through death he might destroy him that had the power of death, that is, the devil; and deliver them who through fear of death were all their lifetime subject to bondage" (Heb 2:14–15).

What an encouragement it is to faith to observe that Christ himself once died, that he rose from the dead, and that he reigns with the Father, death being unable to hold him. Having conquered what seemed to conquer him, death no longer has dominion over him; instead, he holds the keys of death and hell. We may now receive death as a disarmed enemy and say, "O death, where is thy sting? O grave, where is thy victory?" Indeed, death has been sanctified by Christ to become our friend, an entrance into our Master’s joy, since it is better for us to depart and be with Christ (Phil 1:23). Therefore death has become our gain (Phil 1:21).

What abundance of strength and sweetness faith may draw from Christ’s promise: "If any man serve me, let him follow me; and where I am, there shall also my servant be" (John 12:26). As he was dead but now lives forever, so he has promised that "because he liveth, therefore shall we live also" (John 14:19). I have already written two treatises on death and need not press further here.

18. The terror of the day of judgment, and of our particular sentence at death, makes thoughts of God less welcome and pleasant. Here, what a relief it is for faith to grasp that Jesus Christ himself will be our Judge. Will he condemn the members of his own body? Should we fear to be judged by our dearest friend, by the very one who has already justified us at the price of his own blood?

19. The soul’s very unfamiliarity with the unseen world, with its inhabitants and its occupations, greatly restrains its desires and its joyful approach to God. Had we seen the world in which God is to be enjoyed, thoughts of it would be more familiar and sweet. But faith can look to Christ and say, "My Head is there. He sees it on my behalf. He knows what he possesses, prepares, and promises to me, and I will rest quietly in his acquaintance with it."

20. Even the Godhead itself is so infinitely above us that in itself it is inaccessible, and the thought of approaching the incomprehensible Majesty is enough to overwhelm us. But the soul is emboldened by the thought of our glorified nature in Christ, and by the truth that even in heaven God will condescend to us everlastingly through the Mediator. The mediation of redemption and acquisition will be ended, and in that sense Christ will deliver up the kingdom to the Father, yet a mediation of enjoyment appears to continue.

Christ said to his Father, "I will that they also, whom thou hast given me, be with me where I am; that they may behold my glory" (John 17:24). We shall "rejoice" when "the marriage of the Lamb is come" (Rev 19:7). "They are blessed that are called to his marriage supper" (Rev 19:9). "The Lord God Almighty and the Lamb are the temple and the light of the new Jerusalem" (Rev 21:22–23). Heaven would not be so familiar, nor so sweet to my thoughts, if our glorified Lord were not there, he in whose love and glory we must live forever.

O Christian! If you would walk with God in comfortable communion with him, study and practice this life of faith, making daily use of Christ and building on him, who is our life, our hope, and our all.

CHAPTER 25

GRAND DIRECTION 3: BELIEVE IN THE HOLY GHOST AND LET HIM DWELL AND WORK IN YOU

 

‘Understand well what it is to believe in the Holy Ghost: see that he dwell and work in you as the life of your soul, that you do not resist or quench the Spirit, but thankfully obey him.’

Each person in the Trinity is believed in by Christians in such a way that, in baptism, they enter distinctly into covenant with each, accepting the mercies of, and performing the duties toward, each person distinctly. Bernard said that to investigate the mystery is rashness, to believe it is piety, and to know it is life. Just as taking God for your God is more than believing that God exists, and taking Christ for your Savior is more than merely believing he is the Messiah, so to believe in the Holy Ghost is to receive him as Christ’s agent or advocate with our souls, our guide, sanctifier, and comforter, and not only to believe that he is the third person of the Trinity. This, therefore, is a supremely practical article of our faith.

If blasphemy against the Holy Ghost is the unpardonable sin, then every sin against the Holy Ghost carries a special aggravation by reason of its object. And if the sin against the Holy Ghost is the greatest sin, then our duty toward the Holy Ghost is certainly not among our smallest duties. The doctrine of the Holy Spirit, our duty toward him and our sin against him, deserves not the least or last place in teaching, learning, and the most serious consideration.

Two kinds of people sin most dangerously against, or abuse, the Holy Ghost. The first are the profane, who through custom and upbringing can say "I believe in the Holy Ghost" and confess that "he sanctifies them and all the elect people of God," yet hate or resist every sanctifying work and motion of the Holy Ghost. They hate all who are sanctified by him, make them objects of scorn, and deride the very name of sanctification, or at least the reality of it. Johannes Combis summed the matter up: God is the efficient cause in creation, the restoring cause in redemption, and the perfecting cause in sanctification.

The second sort are the enthusiasts, or genuine fanatics, who extol and plead for the Spirit against the Spirit, covering their greatest sins against the Holy Ghost by crying up a pretended claim to the Holy Ghost. Carion records in his Chronicle that the Manichaeans rejected the prophetic and apostolic scriptures and wrote a new Gospel; to appear superior to ordinary people and to seem half-divine, they feigned ecstatic raptures, suddenly throwing themselves to the ground in crowds and lying speechless as though stunned, then rising as if returning from the cave of Trophonius and weeping, prophesying at length, precisely as the Anabaptists did recently in the Münster rebellion. Although in some cases the pretense was transparent, it is certain that in others the frenzy was genuinely sent by devils.

They plead the Spirit in themselves against the Spirit in their brethren, indeed, against almost the whole church. They plead the authority of the Spirit in them against the authority of the Spirit in the Holy Scriptures, against particular truths of Scripture, against several great and necessary duties that the Spirit has required in the word, and against the Spirit in their most judicious, godly, and faithful teachers. But can it be the Spirit that speaks against the Spirit? Is the Spirit of God divided against itself? Are we not "all baptized by one Spirit," one, not diverse or contrary, "into one body" (1 Cor 12:12–13)?

Yet "it is no marvel" for Satan to be "transformed into an angel of light, or his ministers into the ministers of Christ and of righteousness, whose end shall be according to their works" (2 Cor 11:13–15). The Spirit himself has therefore commanded us to "believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they be of God; because many false prophets are gone out into the world" (1 John 4:1). "Yea, the Spirit speaketh expressly, that in the latter times some shall depart from the faith, giving heed to seducing spirits, and doctrines of devils" (1 Tim 4:1). Take heed, therefore, that you neither mistake nor abuse the Holy Spirit.

First. The doctrine concerning the Holy Ghost, to be believed, is briefly this:

1. The Holy Ghost, as given since the ascension of Christ, is his agent on earth, or his advocate with humanity (called by him the Paraclete). In place of his bodily presence, which he granted for a brief season to a few, Christ, having ascended, sends the Holy Spirit as something better for them: his agent continually until the end, with all and in all who believe (John 16:7–8).

2. This Holy Ghost, so sent, infallibly inspired the holy apostles and evangelists, first to preach and then to write the doctrine of Christ, contained as he dictated it in the Holy Scriptures, perfectly imprinting the holy image of God in them (John 15:26 John 16:13 Gal 3:1–4 Heb 2:3–4).

3. The same Spirit, working through them, sealed this holy doctrine and the testimony of these holy men by many miracles and extraordinary gifts, through which they convincingly won over the unbelieving world and planted the churches.

4. The same Spirit, having first given through the apostles a law or canon to the universal church, constituting its offices, the duties of those offices, and the manner of entrance into them, qualifies and disposes men for the ordinary, settled work of ministry (which is to explain and apply the aforesaid Scriptures), and directs those who ordain and choose them, provided those persons are not failing in their own part. In this way he appoints pastors to the church (Eph 3:2–4, 8, 13).

5. The same Spirit assists ministers so sent, in their faithful use of the appointed means, to teach and apply the Holy Scriptures according to the needs of the people, the weight of the matter, and the majesty of the word of God.

6. The same Spirit, by this word, whether heard or read, renews and sanctifies the souls of the elect: illuminating their minds; opening and quickening their hearts; prevailing upon, changing, and resolving their wills; thereby writing God’s word and imprinting his image by that word upon their hearts; making it powerful enough to conquer and cast out their strongest, sweetest, and most deeply cherished sins; and bringing them to the saving knowledge, love, and obedience of God in Jesus Christ (Acts 26:18 John 14:16, 26).

7. The same Holy Spirit assists the sanctified in the exercise of this grace, increasing it by blessing and concurring with the means appointed by him to that end. He helps them use those means, perform their duties, conquer temptations, oppositions, and difficulties, and so confirms and preserves them to the end.

8. The same Spirit helps believers, in the exercise of grace, to feel it and discern its sincerity in themselves, in the measure appropriate to them and in the seasons fittest for them.

9. The same Spirit helps them thereby to conclude that they are justified and reconciled to God, and have a right to all the benefits of his covenant.

10. He also actually helps them to rejoice in perceiving this conclusion. For although reason can do something on its own in these acts, yet man is so averse to all that is holy, and the difficulties and hindrances in the way are so many, that the effective performance of these acts requires the help of the Spirit of God.

By this enumeration of the Spirit’s operations, you may see many errors exposed and many common questions answered.

1. You may see the blindness of those who pit the Spirit within them against Scripture, against the ministry, or against the use of God’s appointed means, when the same Spirit first dictated the Scripture and makes it the instrument to illuminate and sanctify our souls. God’s image exists in three ways:

1.) Primarily, in Jesus Christ his Son.

2.) Derivatively, by his Spirit, imprinted perfectly in the Holy Scriptures.

3.) And by the Scripture, or the holy doctrine of it, instrumentally impressed on the soul.

So the image of God in Christ is the cause of his image in his holy word or doctrine, and his image in his word is the cause of his image on the heart. A king may bear his image, first naturally in his son who resembles his father; second expressively in his laws, which set out his wisdom, clemency, and justice; and third effectively in his subjects and servants, who are by those laws brought into conformity with his mind. As a man may first engrave his coat of arms on his seal and then by that seal stamp it on wax, though it is perfectly engraved on the seal, it may be imperfectly printed on the wax, so God’s image is naturally perfect in his Son, perfectly expressed on the seal of his holy doctrine and laws, but imperfectly reproduced in his subjects, according to their varying degrees of reception.

It is easy, then, to see the error of those who tell people that the light or Spirit within them is their rule, and a perfect rule at that, and that this is true of all people everywhere. God’s Word and experience flatly contradict this, telling us that unbelievers and enemies of God, and all the ungodly, are in darkness and not in the light; and that all who do not speak according to the Word, the law and the testimony, have "no light in them," and therefore no perfect light to serve as their rule (Isa 8:20). The ministry is sent to bring people from darkness to light; therefore they did not already have sufficient light within them (Acts 26:17–18).

"Woe to them that put darkness for light, and light for darkness" (Isa 5:20), telling the children of darkness and the haters of the light that they have a perfect light and rule within them, when God says "they have no light in them" (1 John 1:4–8). "He that saith he is in the light, and hateth his brother, is in darkness even till now" (1 John 2:9–11). The light within a wicked person is "darkness" and "blindness," and therefore cannot be his rule.

Even the light that is in godly people is knowledge of the rule, not the rule itself, and God never calls it so. Our rule is perfect; our knowledge is imperfect. Paul himself says, "We know in part: but when that which is perfect is come, then that which is in part, shall be done away: now we see through a glass darkly" (1 Cor 13:9–10, 12). "The Gospel is hid to them that are lost," being "blinded by satan" (2 Cor 4:3–4).

There is a wonderful and unsearchable concurrence of the Spirit, his appointed means, and the human will in the generation of the new creature and in all the exercises of grace, just as there is a concurrence of male and female in natural generation, and of soil, sun, rain, the gardener’s labor, and the seed’s vital force in producing plants with their flowers and fruit.

It would be as foolish to say it is not the male but the female, or not the female but the male, that generates; or to say it is not the soil but the sun, or not the sun but the rain, or not the rain but the seed’s vital force, that produces plants with flowers and fruit. Equally foolish is it to say it is not the Spirit but the word and means, or not the word and means but the Spirit, or not the reason, will, and effort of humanity but the Spirit. If we lack the wisdom to assign to each cause its proper share in the effect, that is no reason to separate what God has joined, or to deny the reality of a cause simply because we cannot comprehend its manner and influence. To do so is to choose to be made fools by pride rather than to confess that God is wiser than we are.

2. You may also see here how the Spirit assures and comforts believers, and how plainly they err who think the Spirit comforts or assures us of our salvation without using its evidencing grace. The ten operations just enumerated are the whole of what the Spirit does in this work. To expect his comforts without any measure of discerning his graces, which alone can rationally prove our right to the blessings of the promise, is to expect him to comfort a rational creature not as a rational creature, but to cause joy in the dark without the person knowing why; and to make no use of faith for our comfort. For faith rests understandingly on the promise and expects its fulfillment for those to whom it is made, and not for others.

There is, of course, a general encouragement and comfort that all people, even the worst, may draw from the universal conditional promise; and much reduction of our fears and troubles may be drawn from probabilities and uncertain hopes regarding our own sincerity and interest in the promise. But to expect any other assurance or comfort from the Spirit without evidence is simply to expect immediate revelations or inspirations to do the work that the Word of promise and faith should do.

The soul’s consent to the covenant of grace, and its trusting acceptance of Christ as he is offered, is justifying, saving faith. Every person has an object in the promise and offer of the Gospel for this act, and may therefore rationally perform it, though not all have hearts willing to do so. This may rightly be called the faith of adherence, and is itself our evidence, from which we must conclude that we are true believers. The discerning of this evidence, called by some "the reflex act of faith," is not properly an act of faith at all, since it is not believing something about another but the act of conscience knowing what is within ourselves. The discerning and concluding that we are the children of God draws on both faith and conscientious knowledge, which supplied the premises for that conclusion.

3. You may also see from this how we are said to be "sealed" by the Spirit: as a person’s seal marks what is sealed as belonging to him, so the "Spirit of holiness in us" is God’s seal upon us, signifying that we are his. Everyone who "hath the Spirit" is sealed by possessing it, and this is their evidence; if they discern it, they may know they are thus sealed. (Eph 1:13 Rom 8:9 Eph 4:30 2 Tim 2:19)

4. You may also see from this what the "earnest and firstfruits of the Spirit" means: the Spirit is given to us by God as the earnest, or down-payment, of the glory he will give us. To whomever he gives the spirit of faith, love, and holiness, he gives the seed of eternal life and an inclination toward it, and this is his pledge of it. (2 Cor 1:22)

5. You may also see from this how the Spirit witnesses that we are the children of God. The word "witness" here means primarily evidence: if anyone questions our adoption, the witness or evidence we must produce to prove it is the "Spirit of Jesus sanctifying us" and dwelling in us. This is the chief part, at least, of the meaning of Romans 8:16. It is also true that the same Spirit witnesses in other ways:

1.) Showing us the grace he has given us;

2.) And by showing us the truth of the promise made to all believers;

3.) And by helping us to conclude from those promises with boldness that we are the children of God;

4.) And by helping us to rejoice in that conclusion. (Rom 8:16)

Second. I have spent considerable time, though still too little, acquainting you with the office of the Holy Ghost, taking for granted your belief that he is the third person in the Trinity. I have done so because this is a matter of the greatest importance, neglected by many who profess it, and because there are so many dangerous errors in the world concerning it. Your great care now must be: 1. to find this Spirit in you as the animating principle of your life and action; and 2. to obey it and follow its movements as it leads you into communion with God. Of the first I spoke in the first chapter. For the second, observe the following Directions.

Direction 1. "Be sure you do not mistake the Spirit of God and its movements, nor receive in their place the movements of Satan, of your passions, of pride, or of fleshly wisdom." It is easy to think you are obeying the Spirit when you are actually obeying Satan and your own corruptions against the Spirit. The Spirit of God is known by these fruits:

1. The Spirit of God is for heavenly wisdom, and neither for foolishness nor treacherous craftiness (Ps 19:7 Ps 94:8 Jer 4:22 1 Cor 2:4–7).

2. The Spirit of God is a spirit of love, delighting to do good; its doctrine and movements are for love and tend toward good, abhorring both selfishness and harm to others (Gal 5:21–22).

3. He is a spirit of concord, always for the unity of all believers, abhorring both divisions among the saints and carnal compromises and alliances with the wicked (1 Cor 12 Eph 4:3–6, 13 1 Cor 1:10 1 Cor 3:3 Rom 6:17–18).

4. He is a spirit of humility and self-denial, making ourselves, our knowledge, our gifts, and our worth appear very small in our own eyes, abhorring pride, ambition, self-exaltation, and boasting, as well as the actual degrading of ourselves through worldliness or other sin (Matt 18:3 Eph 4:2). No one, said Cicero, was ever a great man without some divine inspiration.

5. He is a spirit of meekness, patience, and forbearance, abhorring numbness of soul, disordered passion, boisterousness, tumult, envy, contention, reviling, and revenge (Matt 11:28–29 Eph 4:2 Jas 3 1 Pet 2:20–23 Gal 5:20 Rom 12:18–20 Eph 4:31 Col 3:8).

6. He is a spirit of zeal for God, resolving people against known sin and for known truth and duty; abhorring a furious and destructive zeal, and equally abhorring indifference in God’s cause and a yielding compliance with whatever is against it (Gal 4:18 Num 25:11, 13 Titus 2:14 Jas 3:15, 17 Luke 9:55 Rev 3:16).

7. He is a spirit of mortification, crucifying the flesh and continually contending against it, and causing people to live above all the glory, riches, and pleasures of the world; abhorring both carnal licentiousness and sensuality, and also the destroying and disabling of the body under the pretense of true mortification (Rom 8:1, 13 Gal 5:17 Rom 13:13–14 1 Cor 9:27 2 Pet 2:19 Col 2:18, 21, 23).

8. The Spirit of Christ does not contradict the doctrine of Christ in the holy Scriptures, but moves us to conform to it exactly (Isa 8:20). This is the sure rule by which to test the claims and movements of any spirit; for we are certain that the Spirit of Christ is the author of that Word, and we are certain he is not contrary to himself.

9. The movements of the Spirit all tend toward our good, and are neither trivial, pointless, nor ultimately harmful. They all work toward the perfecting of sanctification and obedience, and toward our salvation. Therefore unprofitable trifles, or despair, or harmful distractions and disturbances of mind that drive us from God, unfit us for duty, and hinder salvation, are not the movements of the Spirit of God (2 Tim 1:7 Rom 8:15 Isa 11:2 Gal 5:22 Zech 12:10 1 Pet 4:14 2 Cor 3:6).

10. Finally, the Spirit of God subjects all things to God, lifts the heart toward him, makes us spiritual and God-oriented, and is always for God’s glory (1 John 4:5–6 1 Cor 6:11, 17, 20 Eph 2:18, 22 Phil 3:3, 19–20 1 Pet 1:2 1 Pet 4:6).

Examine the texts cited here and you will find that by all these fruits the Spirit of God is distinguished from every seducing spirit and from the fancies or passions of self-conceited people.

Direction 2. "Do not quench the Spirit, either by willful sin or by neglecting the help he offers." The Spirit is like the spring driving all your spiritual motions, like the wind in your sails: you can do nothing without him. Therefore, respect and heed his help, pray for it, obey it, and do not neglect it. When you are certain it is truly the Spirit of God knocking at the door, do not behave as though you do not hear him.

1. Obey him promptly. Delay is an immediate, ungrateful refusal, a kind of outright denial.

2. Obey him fully. A half-obedience is disobedience. Do not put him off with Ananias and Sapphira’s gift, offering only half of what he requires from you.

3. Obey him consistently, not sometimes heeding him and more often neglecting him, but attending to him in a steady, learning, obedient course of life.

Direction 3. "Do not neglect those means which the Spirit has appointed for receiving his help, the very means he uses in all his holy operations." If you wish to meet him, attend him in his own way and do not expect him in byways where he does not go. Pray, meditate, hear the Word, read, and do your best, and then expect his blessing. Your plowing and sowing will not produce a plentiful harvest without sun, rain, and God’s blessing, yet those will not produce it either unless you plow and sow. God has not appointed a course of means in nature or in moral life for nothing, and he will not ordinarily meet you in any other way.

Direction 4. "Do the most when the Spirit helps you most." Do not neglect the extraordinary measures of his assistance. If he helps you in an extraordinary way during prayer or meditation, make the most of that help and do not break off as quickly as you would at other times, unless necessity requires it. This does not mean you should omit duty until you feel his help, for he ordinarily comes with help in the performance of duty, not in its neglect. But do not tire yourself with labored length when the life and energy are absent.

Direction 5. "Do not be ungrateful for the assistance he has given you." Do not deny his grace or attribute it to nature. Remember it, to encourage your expectations of future help. Ungratefulness and neglect are the surest way to be denied further assistance.

Question: "But how shall I know when my spiritual movement comes from the means, or from my own reason and effort, and when it comes from the Spirit of God?"

Answer: This is like asking how you can know whether your harvest comes from the earth, or the sun, or the rain, or God, or from your own labor. Here is the answer: they are all concurrent causes. If the effect is present, they all concur. If the effect is absent, one or more of them is absent. It is foolish to ask which one is the cause when the effect cannot be produced without the concurrence of them all. It would be reasonable to ask which cause failed when the effect fails, but the question as posed makes no sense. This makes the folly of atheists all the more inexcusable: they conclude that God or the Spirit is not the cause simply because they can identify reason and means at work in the effect. But your reason, conscience, and means would all fall short of the effect if the Spirit did not put life into them all.

Objection: "But I am greatly troubled and confused by continual doubts about every movement in my mind, whether it is from the Spirit of God or not."

Answer: The greater fault lies either in your ignorance or in Satan’s malice in causing your distress. In a word, you have sufficient direction to resolve those doubts and end that trouble. Ask yourself: is what you are being moved toward good, evil, or morally indifferent? That question must be resolved from the Word of God, which is the rule of duty. If what you are moved toward is good in its matter, manner, and circumstances, it is from the Spirit of God, whether by his common or special operation. If it is evil or merely indifferent, you cannot attribute it to the Spirit.

Remember that the Spirit does not come to create new duties for you that Scripture never established, he does not bring an additional law. He comes to move and assist you in what was already your duty. (He may supply the matter of an action, while Scripture supplies the obligation through its general command.) If you do not know what your duty is and what it is not, the remedy is a better understanding of Scripture. Interpret Scripture well, and you will find it easy to interpret the movements of the Spirit. If any new duty is pressed upon you that Scripture does not command, treat such a movement as not coming from God, unless it were a case of extraordinary, confirmed revelation.

CHAPTER 26

GRAND DIRECTION 4: ATTAIN A TRUE, ORDERLY, AND PRACTICAL KNOWLEDGE OF GOD

 

‘Let it be your chiefest study to attain to a true, orderly, and practical knowledge of God, in his several attributes and relations; and to find a due impression from each of them upon your hearts, and a distinct, effectual improvement of them in your lives.’

Because I have written more fully on this subject in another treatise, Of the Knowledge of God, and Converse with Him, I will only briefly touch on it here, not wishing to repeat what is delivered there. Let me briefly remind you of these few things:

1. The true knowledge of God is the sum of godliness, the end of all our other knowledge, and the end of all that we have or do as Christians. As Christ is a teacher who came from God, so he came to call and lead us to God, otherwise he would not have come as a Savior. It is from God that we fell by sin, and to God that we must be restored by grace. To save us is to restore us to our perfection and happiness, and that is to restore us to God.

2. The true knowledge of God is powerful and effectual upon the heart and life. Every attribute and relation of God is to be known in such a way as to make its proper impression on us. The measure of this saving knowledge is to be judged not so much by the breadth or number of truths about God that we know, as by the clarity, intensity, and holy effects of that knowledge upon the heart.

3. This is what makes both ourselves and all our duties holy, when God’s image is thus imprinted on us and we are made like him by the new birth, as children to their father. By this knowledge, both our hearts and lives are made godly, being disposed toward God, devoted to him, and employed for him; he being our life, our light, and our love.

Diogenes Laertius, in his life of Zeno, reports what the Stoics held of God: that God is a living being, immortal, rational, perfect, and blessed, utterly removed from all evil, administering by his providence the world and all things in it; and yet that the lineaments of human form are not in him. He is besides the maker of this immense work, and the Father of all; and he is called by many names according to his several properties. They say also that there are certain spirits in whom there is compassion for men, overseers of human affairs; and heroes too, the souls of the wise released from their bodies.

Laertius continues that the Stoics call good men divine, because they have God, as it were, within themselves, while the evil man is impious and without God, which is taken two ways, either that he is said to be contrary to God, or that he despises God, though this does not fit every bad man. The wise, they say, are pious and religious, and all of them skilled in the divine law; piety is the knowledge of the worship of God. They will accordingly offer sacrifices to the gods and keep themselves pure, since they abhor the sins committed against the gods; and those who are holy and just in divine things will be dear and acceptable to them. (Diogenes Laertius, book vii, section 147.)

4. This is the sum of God’s covenant with man: "I will be thy God, and thou shalt be my people." The other parts of the covenant, that Christ is our Savior and the Holy Spirit our Sanctifier, are both subordinate to this end, since there is now no coming to God except as reconciled in Christ our Mediator, and by the teaching and drawing of the Holy Spirit. For God to be our God is for him to be our absolute Owner, our most righteous Governor, and our most bountiful Benefactor and Father, having created, redeemed, and regenerated us, all in accordance with his most blessed nature, properties, and perfections.

5. What is required is not merely a loose and inconstant effect of your particular thoughts of God, such as fearing him when you happen to remember his greatness and justice. Rather, it must be a settled habit or holy disposition within you, each attribute having made its established image upon you, and that habit or image serving as a constant principle of holy, spiritual action. A habitual reverence, belief, trust, love, and so on, should be, as it were, your very nature.

6. The knowledge of God in his perfections should not provoke us to desire his own properties and perfections for ourselves, for an aspiring desire to be gods would be the greatest pride and wickedness. We must desire only these two things:

1.) To be as like God, in all his communicable excellencies, as is fitting to our created state and capacity.

2.) To have as near and full communion with him as we can attain and enjoy.

7. The will of God, his goodness, and his holiness are presented to us more directly as the rule of our conformity than his power and his knowledge. His law is therefore the most immediate expression of his will, and our duty and goodness consist in our conformity to that law, being holy as he is holy.

Since I cannot dwell on every particular, I will give you a brief, incomplete outline of what you must know of God.

God is to be known by us:

I. As in Himself.

First. In his Being, that he exists: 1. One and indivisible, in Three Persons: 1. the Father, 2. the Son, 3. the Holy Spirit. 2. Immense and incomprehensible. 3. Eternal: 1. Necessary, 2. Independent, 3. Immutable.

Second. In his Nature, what he is: A Spirit, 1. Simple and uncompounded; 2. Impassible, incorruptible, immortal; 3. Invisible, intangible, and so on; and Life itself, 1. Power, 2. Understanding, 3. Will.

Third. In his Perfections, what he is like: 1. Omnipotent, 2. Omniscient, 3. Most Good; 1. Most Great, 2. Most Wise, 3. Most Holy and Happy; 1. Being himself, 2. Knowing himself, 3. Loving and enjoying himself.

II. As Related to his Creatures.

First. The Efficient Cause of all things, (Rom 11:36) "of him": 1. Creator and Sustainer; 1. Our Owner or Lord, most absolute, free, and irresistible; 1. Our Life, Strength, and Safety; 1. Perfecting our natures in heavenly life.

Second. The Directing Cause, "through him": 2. Redeemer and Savior; 2. Our Ruler or King, by legislation, judgment, and execution; absolute, perfect, true, holy, just, merciful, patient, and awesome; 2. Our Light and Wisdom; 2. Whom we shall behold in glorious light.

Third. The Final Cause, "to him" are all things; to him be glory forever, Amen: 3. Regenerator and Sanctifier; 3. Our Benefactor and Father, most loving, most bountiful, most worthy of love, patient, merciful, and constant; both as the cause and as the object; 3. Our Love and Joy, and so our End, Rest, and Happiness hereafter; 3. Whom we shall please and love, and be pleased in and loved by; in whom we shall rejoice, whom we shall praise, and so enjoy perfectly and perpetually.

See these matters practically opened and applied in the First Part of my Divine Life. A fuller explanation of the attributes, suited to more capacious readers, is reserved for another treatise.

For the right application of the knowledge of all these attributes of God, I refer you to the treatise mentioned above. The acts you are to exercise toward God are these:

1. The clearest knowledge you can attain to.

2. The firmest belief.

3. The highest estimation.

4. The greatest admiration.

5. The heartiest and sweetest love and delight in him.

6. The strongest desire.

7. A filial awe, reverence, and fear.

8. The boldest, quieting trust and confidence in him.

9. The most steadfast waiting, dependence, hope, and expectation.

10. The most absolute self-resignation to him.

11. The fullest and quietest submission to his disposals.

12. The humblest and most complete subjection to his governing authority and will, and the most exact obedience to his laws.

13. The boldest courage and fortitude in his cause, and owning him before the world amid the greatest sufferings.

14. The greatest thankfulness for his mercies.

15. The most faithful use of his talents, his appointed means, and the trust he has committed to us.

16. A reverent and holy use of his name and word, together with a reverence of his secrets, refraining from intruding upon or meddling with them.

17. A wise and careful observance of his providences, public and private, neither neglecting them nor misinterpreting them, neither running ahead of them nor striving discontentedly against them.

18. A discerning, loving, and honoring of his image in his children, despite their infirmities and faults, without any friendship toward those faults, and without over-magnifying or imitating them in any evil.

19. A reverent, serious, spiritual adoration and worship in public and private, with soul and body, in the use of all his holy ordinances, and especially in the joyful celebration of his praise for all his perfections and mercies.

20. The highest delight and fullest contentment and comfort in God that we can attain, especially a delight in knowing him, obeying and pleasing him, worshipping and praising him, loving him and being beloved by him through Jesus Christ; and in the hope of the perfecting of all these in our everlasting enjoyment of him in heavenly glory.

Of this speaking and thinking of God as he is, Bias said, in Laertius, "Speak of the gods as they are." Lord Bacon says the same of the plainness of the evidence, in his sixteenth Essay: "God never wrought miracle to convince Atheism, because his ordinary works convince it." And Cicero, in the first book of his Tusculan Disputations: "Nor indeed can God himself, as he is understood by us, be understood in any other way than as a mind unfettered and free, separated from all mortal admixture, perceiving and moving all things, and itself endowed with everlasting motion."

All these are the acts of piety toward God. I set them together here for easier observation and memory, though some of them will need to be more fully opened and treated in their own right.

CHAPTER 27

GRAND DIRECTION 5: REMEMBER THAT GOD IS YOUR OWNER, AND RESIGN YOURSELF ABSOLUTELY TO HIM

 

‘Remember that God is your Lord, or Owner: and see that you make an absolute resignation of yourselves, and all that you have, to him as his own; and use yourselves and all accordingly: trust him with his own, and rest in his disposals.’

On this subject I have already spoken in my Sermon of Christ’s Dominion and in my Directions for a Sound Conversion, and so I can only touch on it here. It is easy to know and say in theory that God is our Owner and that we are not our own; but if the habitual, practical knowledge of this were equally easy or common, the happy effects of it would be the sanctification and reformation of the world. I will first explain what this duty is and how it is to be performed, and then what fruits and benefits it will produce, and what should move us to it.

First. The duty consists in these acts.

1. Consider the grounds of God’s ownership of you.

1.) By making you out of nothing and preserving you.

2.) By redeeming you through purchase.

3.) By regenerating you and renewing you for himself.

The first is the ground of his common natural ownership of you and of all things. The second is the ground of his common, gracious ownership of you and all people, as those purchased by Christ (Rom 14:9, John 13:3). The third is the ground of his special, gracious ownership of you and of all his sanctified people, who are specially his own. Understand and acknowledge the full dominion God holds over you, and how absolutely and entirely you are his.

2. Let it give you great pleasure to think that you are wholly his, for it is far better for your safety, honor, and happiness than to belong to yourself or to anyone else.

3. Since God requires in his covenant of grace that he have his right by your consent and not by compulsion, you must thankfully accept his offer and with hearty, full consent of the will resign yourselves to him as his own, as his creatures, his ransomed ones, and his regenerate children, by a covenant never to be broken.

4. You must carefully watch against the claims and reserves of carnal self-interest, lest while confessing that you are God’s and not your own, you should secretly retain possession of yourselves against him, or resume possession of what you surrendered.

5. You must conduct yourselves ever after as belonging to God and not to yourselves.

Cicero urged the same conviction upon a commonwealth in his Laws: let it be settled in the minds of the citizens from the very beginning that the gods are the lords and rulers of all things; that whatever is done is done by their authority and will; that they deserve the best of the human race; that they observe what each person is, what he does, what guilt he takes upon himself, and with what mind and what piety he practices religion; and that they keep account of the godly and the ungodly.

Second. In using yourselves as wholly God’s, both your further duty and your benefits consist.

1. When God’s ownership is recognized and consented to, it will make you aware of how obligated you are to employ all your powers of soul and body in his service, and to see that nothing should be withheld from him, no creature having any coordinate claim to a single thought of your hearts, a glance of your affection, a word from your mouths, or a minute of your time. The sense of God’s ownership must lead you to keep constant accounts between God and you, and to call yourselves to frequent reckoning: whether God has his own, whether you are defrauding him, whether it is his work you are doing, and whether it is for him that you think, speak, and live. All that you have will be used as his, just as you yourselves are, for no one can possess any good thing more truly than he possesses himself.

2. Recognized ownership deepens affection toward the owner. As we love our own children, so children love their own fathers. Even our dogs love their own masters more than a stranger’s. When we can say with Thomas, "My Lord, and my God," it will certainly be the voice of love. God’s common ownership of us as his created and ransomed ones obliges us to love him with all our hearts; but the knowledge of his particular ownership through regeneration will move our love still more powerfully.

3. God’s ownership, once perceived, helps to assure us of his love and care for us, and helps us to trust him in every danger, thereby freeing us from disordered fear, anxiety, and self-concern. Even Cicero, in his book On Divination, could argue that the gods exist, that the world is administered by their providence, and that they take thought for human affairs, not only for all people collectively but for individuals as well. The apostle proves Christ’s love for his church from his ownership: "No man ever yet hated his own flesh" (Eph 5:29). God is not unconcerned with what is his own. Just as we care for our livestock, preserving and providing for them more than they do for themselves, because they are more ours than their own, so God is more concerned with the welfare of his children than they are themselves, they being more his than their own.

Why are we afraid of the wrath and cruelty of men? Will God be careless and negligent of his own? Why are we overly anxious and distrustful of his providence? Will he not take care of his own and make provision for them? "God, even our own God shall bless us" (Ps 67:6). God’s stake in his church, his cause, and his servants is an argument we may urge before him in prayer and with which we may greatly encourage our confidence.

"For my name’s sake will I defer mine anger, and for my praise will I refrain for thee, that I cut thee not off. For mine own sake, even for mine own sake, will I do it: for how should my name be polluted? and I will not give my glory to another" (Isa 48:9 and 48:11). "But now, thus saith the Lord that created thee, O Jacob, and he that formed thee, O Israel; Fear not: for I have redeemed thee; I have called thee by thy name; thou art mine. When thou passest through the waters, I will be with thee, etc." (Isa 43:1–2 1 Chr 17:21–22). If God should disregard our interest, he will not disregard his own.

God’s ownership of us, once recognized, so greatly aggravates our sin against him that it should powerfully restrain us from sin, and should further our humiliation and recovery when we have fallen. "Ye shall be holy unto me: for I the Lord am holy, and have severed you from other people, that ye should be mine" (Lev 20:26). "I sware unto thee, and entered into a covenant with thee, and thou becamest mine, saith the Lord" (Ezek 16:8), said when God is pressing home the weight of Jerusalem’s sin. "Ye are not your own: for ye are bought with a price: therefore glorify God in your body, and in your spirit, which are God’s" (1 Cor 6:19–20). Justice requires that everyone receive what is his own.

5. Reflecting that we are God’s own should silence all murmuring and complaint against his providence. Does he afflict you? Are you not his own? Does he take your life? Are you not his own? As ruler, he will show you reason enough in your sins; but as your absolute Lord and owner, he need not offer any other reason than that he may do with his own as he pleases.

It is impossible that he can do any wrong to what is absolutely his own. If he denies you health, wealth, or friends, or takes them from you, he denies or takes from you nothing but his own. Indeed, as governor and father he has secured for the faithful the promise of eternal life; but even apart from that, as their owner he would not have wronged them if he had made the most innocent soul as miserable as it could possibly be. Do you labor, beat, and kill your livestock because they are your own, and by an imperfect ownership at that? Then can you presume to complain against God for afflicting his own, when their own consciences tell them they have deserved it, and far more?

That you may not mistake a hypocritical profession for a genuine resignation of yourselves to God entirely, observe the following.

1. A person is not truly resigned to God if he thinks any service he is capable of performing is too much for God.

2. Nor is he resigned who thinks any cost he is called to bear is too great for God.

3. Nor he who thinks anything is gained, of his time, wealth, pleasure, or anything else, that he saves or steals from God; for all is lost that God does not have.

4. Nor he who must be the disposer of himself, his condition, and his affairs, and who requires God to accommodate his providence to his carnal interests and will, or else he cannot bear it or think well of it.

5. Remember that all that is spent in sin and devoted to God’s enemies is used against him, not as his own.

6. He who hides his talent or does not use it at all cannot be said to use it for God. Both idleness and diverting God’s gifts to other ends are a robbery of what is his own.

Third. To help you in this work of self-resignation, often consider the following.

1. If you were your own, you would be utterly miserable. You could not support, preserve, or provide for yourselves, who would save you in the hour of temptation or distress? If you are humbled Christians, you already know how much your own insufficiency amounts to; you feel yourselves a daily burden to yourselves, and have had more than enough of yourselves by now. You beg God, above all other enemies, to save you from yourselves, and you count being forsaken by God and given up to yourself the worst of all judgments.

2. Remember that no one in the world has sufficient power, wisdom, and goodness to take full care and charge of you but God; no one else can save you, sanctify you, or keep you alive for a single hour. It is therefore your happiness and honor that you are his.

3. His right over you is absolute, and no one else has any claim on you. No one else created you, redeemed you, or regenerated you.

4. He will employ you only in safe and honorable service, and toward no lesser end than your endless happiness.

5. Whatever you withhold from him or steal away from him, you give to the devil, the world, and the flesh. And do they deserve it more?

6. You are his own by title whether you consent or not, and he will accomplish his will upon you. Your consent and resignation are necessary for your own good, to ease you of your cares and to secure you from present and eternal misery.

CHAPTER 28

GRAND DIRECTION 6: SUBMIT YOURSELF ABSOLUTELY TO GOD AS YOUR SOVEREIGN KING

 

"Remember that God is your sovereign King, to rule and judge you, and that your rectitude and happiness lie in obeying and pleasing him. Labor, therefore, to bring your soul and body into the most complete subjection to him, and make it your delight and chief work to obey his will sincerely and exactly."

Having resigned yourselves absolutely to God as your owner, you must next submit yourselves absolutely to God as your governor and king. How much of our religion consists in this you may see from the nature of the matter itself, from the design of God’s law and Word, from the doctrine and example of Jesus Christ, from the description of the last judgment, and from the common consent of all the world. When Aristippus was once asked what philosophers had that was exceptional, he answered: "If all laws were abolished, we would live the same way." Though love is the highest work of a human being, it is so far from releasing us from subjection and obedience that it compels us to both, most powerfully and most sweetly, and love itself must be judged by these effects.

"If ye love me, keep my commandments. He that hath my commandments, and keepeth them, he it is that loveth me. If any man love me, he will keep my words: and my Father will love him, and we will come unto him, and make our abode with him. He that loveth me not keepeth not my sayings" (John 14:15, 14:21, and 14:23–24). "If ye keep my commandments, ye shall abide in my love; even as I have kept my Father’s commandments, and abide in his love. Ye are my friends, if ye do whatsoever I command you" (John 15:10 and 15:14). "If ye know these things, happy are ye if ye do them" (John 13:17). "For this is the love of God, that we keep his commandments, and his commandments are not grievous" (1 John 5:3).

"He that saith, I know him, and keepeth not his commandment, is a liar, and the truth is not in him. But whoso keepeth his word, in him verily is the love of God perfected: hereby know we that we are in him.

"He that saith he abideth in him, ought himself also to walk, even as he walked. If ye know that he is righteous, ye know that every one that doth righteousness is born of him" (1 John 2:4).

"Whosoever abideth in him, sinneth not: whosoever sinneth, hath not seen him, neither known him. Little children, let no man deceive you: he that doth righteousness is righteous, even as he is righteous. He that committeth sin, is of the devil; for the devil sinneth from the beginning. For this purpose the Son of God was manifested, that he might destroy the works of the devil. Whosoever is born of God doth not commit sin; for his seed remaineth in him: and he cannot sin, because he is born of God. In this the children of God are manifest, and the children of the devil: whosoever doth not righteousness is not of God. And whatsoever we ask, we receive of him, because we keep his commandments, and do those things that are pleasing in his sight" (1 John 3:6–10 and 3:22). "Blessed are they that do his commandments, that they may have right to the tree of life, and may enter in through the gates into the city" (Rev 22:14).

I set these scriptural testimonies together so that the full stream of divine authority might carry you to a living sense of the necessity of obedience.

I will first explain what this full subjection is, and then direct you in how to attain it.

First. Just as in God there is first his relation to us as King, and then his actual government of us by his laws and judgment, so in us there is first our relation as subjects to God, and then our actual obedience. We are subjects by divine obligation before we consent, just as rebels are subjects, but our consent and self-commitment are necessary for voluntary obedience and acceptance with God. Subjection is our standing obligation to obey. This subjection and habit of obedience is right and full under the following conditions:

1. When our sense of God’s authority over us is practical, not merely notional.

2. When it is deep-rooted and fixed, having become second nature to us, as a traveler’s fixed intention of his destination carries him forward to the very last step, or as a child’s subjection to parents or a servant’s to a master is the habitual principle governing his daily life.

3. When it is lively and ready to move the soul toward obedience.

4. When it is constant, keeping the soul in continual attention to the will of God.

5. When it has universal respect for all his commandments.

6. When it is resolute, powerful, and victorious against temptations to disobedience.

7. When it is supreme, recognizing God as our sovereign King, owning no authority against him, and acknowledging no authority except what is subordinate to him.

8. When it is voluntary, pleasant, cheerful, and a delight to obey him to the utmost of our power.

Second. To bring the soul to this full subjection and obedience to God is both difficult and yet entirely reasonable, necessary, and supremely good. No degree of diligence spent in attaining it can be thought excessive. The directions I will give are of two kinds: some are intended to form the mind into an obedient disposition, and some are intended to advance the practice of obedience in particular acts.

Direction 1. "Remember the unquestionable and complete title that God holds to govern you and all the world." A living sense of this will humble the soul, help to subject it to him, and silence all rebellious impulses. Should not God rule the creatures he has made? Should not Christ rule the souls he has purchased? Should not the Holy Ghost rule the souls he has regenerated and quickened?

Direction 2. "Remember that God is perfectly fitted to govern you and all the world." You could wish for nothing reasonable in a governor that is not found in him. He has perfect wisdom to know what is best; perfect goodness, and so he is supremely attentive to his subjects’ good and will place no evil in his laws; and he is almighty, to protect his subjects and enforce his laws.

He is perfectly just, and so can do no wrong, all his laws and judgments are equitable and impartial. He is infinitely perfect and self-sufficient, and has never needed a lie, a deception, or an unrighteous means to govern the world, nor has he needed to oppress his subjects to accomplish his ends. He is our very end, our interest, and our happiness, and so has no interest opposed to our good that would lead him to destroy the innocent. He is our dearest Friend and Father, who loves us more than we love ourselves. We have every reason, therefore, to trust him confidently and to obey him cheerfully and gladly, as one who governs us for our own felicity.

Direction 3. "Remember how unable and unfit you are to govern yourselves." You are so blind and ignorant, so distorted by a corrupted will, your passions so turbulent, the temptations of sense and appetite so relentless and powerful, and your ability to protect and reward yourselves so small, that you ought to fear nothing in this world more than being given up "to your own heart’s lusts, to walk in your own (seducing) counsels" (Ps 81:11–12). The brutish appetite and sensual drive have gained such dominion over the reason of carnal, unrenewed people that for such persons to be governed by themselves is like a man being governed by a swine, or a rider being ruled by his horse.

Direction 4. "Remember how greatly God values his royal prerogatives and how seriously he regards human obedience." The whole tenor of Scripture declares this. His precepts, his promises, his warnings, his urgent exhortations, his sharp reproofs, the sending of his Son and Spirit, the example of Christ and all the saints, the reward prepared for the obedient, and the punishment for the disobedient, all of these cry out that God is far from indifferent about whether you keep his laws. Recognizing how much God weighs a thing will teach you to give it weight as well.

Direction 5. "Consider carefully the excellence of full obedience, and the present benefits it brings to yourselves and to others." Our complete submission and obedience to God is to the world and to the soul what health is to the body. When all the humors maintain their proper balance, proportion, and place, and every part of the body is situated and used according to its natural purpose, then all is at ease within us: our food is pleasant, our sleep is sweet, our labor is light, and our vitality makes life a joy.

We become useful in our station and helpful to those around us who are sick and weak. So it is with the soul that is fully obedient. God gives such a person a foretaste of the final reward; he finds that obedience is its own reward, and that doing good is genuinely pleasant. God acknowledges him, and conscience speaks peace and comfort to him. His mercies become sweet, his burdens and duties grow easy, and he has readier access to God than others do. Indeed, the world will find that there is no path to right order, unity, peace, and happiness except through full submission and obedience to God.

Direction 6. "Remember the sorrowful effects of disobedience, even now, both in the soul and in the world." When we rebel against God, it brings confusion, ruin, and death to the soul and to the world. When we disobey him, the soul falls into disorder and sickness, and we will groan under it. Until our bones are set back in joint, we shall have no ease. God will be displeased and hide his face. Conscience will be restless. The soul will lose its peace and joy. Former mercies will grow less sweet; former rest will turn to weariness; duty will feel burdensome and heavy. Who would willingly embrace such a condition?

Direction 7. "Consider that when God does not govern you, you are ruled by the flesh, the world, and the devil." What right or fitness they have to govern you, what their work amounts to, and what their final reward is, these you should be able to see plainly enough. "If ye live after the flesh, ye shall die" (Rom 8:13). "And if ye sow to the flesh, of the flesh ye shall reap corruption" (Gal 6:8). In the hour of temptation, if you would only stop to think, "I am now about to disobey God and to obey the flesh, the world, or the devil, preferring their will above his," the thought ought to strike you with horror.

Direction 8. "Turn your eye upon the rebellious nations of the earth and upon the condition of the most malicious and ungodly people; and consider that such madness and misery as you see in them is what every willful disobedience to God tends toward, and partakes of in its measure." To see a brutish drunkard in his vomit, to hear a raging madman curse and swear, or a malicious wretch blaspheme and mock a holy life, to hear how foolishly such people speak against God and to see how viciously they hate his servants, one would think this should be enough to turn the stomach against all sin forever. Consider what beasts, or rather incarnate devils, many of the ungodly have become. Consider what confusion and inhumanity fill those nations that do not know God. One would think that seeing sin in its full dominion and ripeness should make even its smallest degree seem repulsive.

Direction 9. "Mark what obedience is expected among human beings, what influence government has on the condition and affairs of the world, and what the world would be without it." Surely this will make you think honorably and gladly of the government of God. What would a nation be without government, but a company of thieves and lawless murderers, or like pike fish in a pond, first consuming the smaller fish and then devouring one another, the greater preying upon the less? Bears and wolves would live more peaceably together than ungoverned human beings, except for those few who are truly subject to the government of God. Government secures every person in his own property, holds lust and madness in check, and maintains peace and order in the world. What would a family be without government? Children and servants are kept by it in their proper roles and work. Consider, then, how necessary and excellent is the universal government of God.

Direction 10. "Think carefully on the endless rewards and punishments by which God will both secure obedience to his laws and vindicate the honor of his government against the disobedient." So that the world may see that he gives sufficient incentives for all that he requires, he will reward the obedient with everlasting blessedness and punish rebels with endless misery. You cannot say he asks you to work for nothing.

Though you can give him nothing but what is already his, and therefore can merit nothing from him in the strict sense of exchange; yet as a Governor and Father he will make so vast a difference between the obedient and the rebellious that one will be welcomed into everlasting joy with "Well done, good and faithful servant," and the other condemned to "everlasting punishments" (Matt 25). Is there not enough in heaven, in a life of endless joy with God, to make obedience lovely to you and sin loathsome? Is there not enough in hell to deter you from disobedience and drive you to God? God will rule, whether you consent or not. Choose to be obedient, or he will punish you without asking your consent.

The Directions for more immediately stirring up your obedience and confirming your full submission are these:

Direction 1. "Keep the face of your soul fixed on God, in a sense of his greatness, his continual presence, and his particular providence." This will hold you in a posture of obedience. You will readily perceive that so great a God cannot be disobeyed without grave iniquity and guilt; that a God who is continually with you must be continually regarded; and that a God who observes and attends to the very thoughts and words of every person deserves to be exactly attended to and observed by every person. This will help you understand the tempter’s aim when you recognize that every temptation is an urging of you to offend, for nothing, so great a God, one who is watching precisely what you do at that very moment.

Direction 2. "Always remember where you are going: that you are preparing for everlasting rest and joy, that you must pass through the righteous judgment of the Lord, and that Christ is your guide and governor, appointed to bring you safely home as the Captain of your salvation, and that sin is a rejection of his help and of your own happiness." Do not think of God as ruling you like a tyrant, to your harm and ruin, exploiting you for his own advantage or binding you with needless laws that have nothing to do with your good and safety. Think of him instead as one who is conducting you to eternal life, who would now guide you by his counsel and afterward bring you into his glory.

Think of him as leading you to the world of light and life and love and joy, where there are rivers of pleasure and fullness of delight forever, that you may see his face and experience his love among a world of blessed spirits, rather than weeping and gnashing your teeth with the impenitent and ungodly.

Is not such a government as this truly desirable? It is simply like the care of a physician who works to save his patient’s life, or like your own government of your children, which is necessary for those who cannot yet feed or direct themselves, or like a pilot guiding a ship that is carrying you toward a kingdom. If the sailors obey him, they can safely reach the desired port; but if they disobey him, they are all wrecked and lost. Should such a government as this seem grievous to you? Should it not rather be most welcome, and obeyed with the utmost care?

Direction 3. "Continually consider what dangers, difficulties, and enemies you must pass through on the way to that rest, and that all your safety depends on the guidance and assistance of your Captain." This will bring even self-love to demand your strict obedience. You must pass through the army of your enemies, and will you disobey the Captain of your salvation here? Would you have him leave you to yourselves?

Your disease is mortal, and none but Jesus Christ can cure it; if he does not cure it, you are lost forever. No pain of gout or stone is comparable to your everlasting pain, and yet will you not be obedient to your physician?

When a temptation comes, think to yourself: "Suppose there were a narrow bridge over the deepest gulf or river, and all my friends and all my happiness lay on the far side, and I must cross it whether I will or not. If Christ were to take me by the hand and lead me over, would I be tempted to refuse his help or let go of his hand? And if he should threaten to release me and leave me to myself, should I not tremble and cry out as Peter did, ‘Lord, save me’, or as the disciples, ‘Save, Master, we perish’?" (Matt 14:30) Should I not hold fast to him and obey him most carefully, as he leads me to eternal life, that I may escape the gulf of endless misery?

Direction 4. "Continually remember how flawed, blind, reluctant, self-deceiving, and weak you are, and therefore how much you need the greatest watchfulness, lest you disobey your pilot and lose your guide before you are even aware of it."

What a heart we have to watch over! A lazy heart that loiters or sits down when it should be following our Lord. A foolish heart that lets him go while we play with every distraction along the way. A cowardly heart that steals away or draws back in danger when it should be following our Captain. A treacherous heart that slips out of our grasp and deceives us just when we thought we held it most securely. A near-sighted heart that, even while following Christ our guide, can barely be kept from missing the bridge and falling into the gulf of misery. Think carefully on these things, and you will obey your governor.

Direction 5. "Do not forget the fruits of your former obedience and disobedience," if you wish to remain in an obedient frame of heart.

Remember that obedience has always been sweetest afterward, and that you have never yet found cause to repent or be ashamed of it. Remember that the fruit of sin was bitter, and that when your eyes were opened and you saw your shame, you would gladly have fled from the face of God, and that what sin appeared to be in the committing looked like an entirely different thing once it was done. Remember what groans and heartache it has cost you, what fears of the wrath of God it brought upon you, how long it was before your broken bones were healed, and what it cost both Christ and you.

This will make the very name and first approach of sin cast you into a preventing fear.

A beast that has once fallen into a pit or quicksand will hardly be driven into the same place again. A fish once struck and escaped from the hook will fear and flee from it the next time. A bird that has once escaped the snare or the talons of the hawk is afterward afraid at the mere sight or sound of such a thing. Remember where you fell, what it cost you, and what it might have cost you, and you will obey more carefully from that point on.

Direction 6. "Remember that this is your day of trial, and what depends upon your careful obedience."

God will not crown untried servants. Satan is purposely permitted to tempt you in order to test whether you will be faithful to God or not. All the hope his malice has of destroying you forever lies in his hope of making you disobedient to God. These considerations should awaken you to the most watchful and diligent obedience. If you were told beforehand that a thief had undertaken to rob you and would use every cunning and effort to do it, you would watch far more carefully than at other times. If you were running a race for your life, you would not go at your ordinary pace. God tells you plainly that he will try your obedience through temptation, and that as you stand or fall, so you will fare forever, and will not this keep you watchful and obedient?

Direction 7. "Avoid those tempting and deluding objects that are constantly enticing your hearts away from obedience, and avoid that distracting crowd and noise of company or worldly business that drowns out the voice of God’s commands."

If God calls you into a life of great temptation, he can bring you safely through them all. But if you rush into such a life willfully, you may quickly discover your own inability to resist. It is dangerous to be under strong and importunate temptations, lest the current bear you down, and especially dangerous to remain under them for a long time, lest you grow weary of resisting.

Those who are solicited for long too often yield at last. It is hard always to be in a clear, ready, and resolute frame of mind. Few people have their wits fully at hand, much less their graces, ready for use at any moment. If the thief comes while you have dropped off to sleep, you may be robbed before you can wake.

The constant pull of temptation often wears down the habit of obedience and gradually diminishes our hatred of sin and our holy resolutions by slow, imperceptible degrees, long before we yield to committing any outward act. A mind that is to be kept in full subjection to God must not be so absorbed in a crowd of distracting company or business that it has no time to consider the motives of its obedience. Withdrawing the fuel in this way may put out the fire entirely.

Direction 8. "If you are unavoidably cast into strong temptation, take alarm; put on the whole armor of God, and rouse your soul to watchfulness and resolution, remembering that you are now among your enemies and must resist as for your life."

See every temptation for exactly what it is, something coming from the devil and tending toward your own damnation by enticing your heart away from its subjection to God. Suppose you saw the devil himself, working through his instruments, offering you the bait of advancement, honor, riches, bodily lusts, recreation, or delightful food and drink, to tempt you to excess. Suppose you heard him say to you plainly: "Take this in exchange for your salvation. Sell your God, your soul, and your everlasting hopes for this. Commit this sin, so that you may fall under the judgment of God and be tormented in hell with me forever. Do this to please your flesh, that you may displease your God and grieve your Savior. I cannot drag you to hell except by dragging you to sin. I cannot make you sin against your will, nor undo you except by your own consent and action, so I beg you, consent and do it yourself, and keep me company in torment." That is the naked meaning of every temptation.

Now suppose you saw and heard all this openly, with what revulsion would you then reject it? With what horror would you flee from even the most enticing bait? If a robber tried to lure you off your path and away from your companions with flattering words, so that you might fall into the hands of his associates, and you knew his full meaning and design beforehand, would you follow him? Watch, then, and stand firm, since you know beforehand the devil’s design and what he intends in every temptation.

Direction 9. "Be most suspicious, fearful, and watchful about that which your flesh most desires or finds the greatest pleasure in."

This does not mean you should deny your bodies all delight in the mercies of God. If the body has none, the mind will have the less. Mercy must be distinguished from punishment and must be valued and relished as mercy. The mere natural pleasure of the senses is in itself no moral good or evil. A holy enjoyment of lawful pleasure is a daily duty; inordinate pleasure is a sin. All pleasure is inordinate that tends more to corrupt the soul, by enticing it to sin and turning it from God, than to fit and dispose it for God and his service and to preserve it from sinning.

But always remember: it is not sorrow but delight that draws the soul away from God, and it is the interest of the flesh that sets itself up against him. Many have sinned in sorrow and discontent, but no one has ever sinned for the sake of sorrow and discontent. Discontent and sorrow are not chosen and loved for themselves; they are the effects of love for some pleasure or comfort that has been denied or taken away. Therefore, though not all bodily pleasures are sin, yet since nothing but the pleasures of the flesh and the carnal mind is the sinner’s ultimate aim and the devil’s chief bait, and since this alone causes people’s ruin, you have strong reason to be most afraid of whatever is most pleasing to your flesh and to the mind as it is corrupt and carnal.

Escape the delusions of fleshly pleasure, and you escape damnation. You have far more cause to fear prosperity than adversity, riches than poverty, honor than obscurity and contempt, human praise and applause than slander and reproach, advancement and greatness than a low and humble condition, rich and delicious food than plain and simple fare, costly and elaborate clothing than modest and cheap dress.

Let those who have handed over their reason to the service of their fleshly desires, and placed the crown and scepter in the hands of their appetites, think otherwise. No wonder that those who have sold the birthright of their intellects to their senses, for a mess of pottage, for a prostitute, for a high place, for domineering power over others, or for a belly full of pleasant food and drink, should deride all this and think it a melancholy notion better suited to a hermit or recluse than to people living and working in society. As heaven is the portion of earnest believers and mortified saints alone, so it belongs to them alone to understand the teaching and example of their Savior, and to know practically what it means to deny themselves, to forsake all they have, to take up their cross and follow Christ, and by the Spirit to mortify the deeds of the body (Luke 14:26–29 Luke 14:33 Rom 8:5–7 Rom 8:13 Col 3:1–4).

Such people know that millions part with God for pleasures, but none for griefs, and that hell will be filled with those who preferred wealth, honor, sports, gluttony, drink, and filthy lusts over the holiness and happiness of believers. But no one will be damned for preferring poverty, disgrace, abstinence, hunger, thirst, and chastity over those things. It must be something that appears good which can entice people away from the chief good. Apparent evil makes a poor bait for the devil’s hook. People will not displease God merely to displease themselves, nor choose present sorrow in place of everlasting joy. But for "the pleasures of sin for a season" many will despise pleasures that are endless.

Direction 10. "Meet every impulse toward disobedience with an army of holy graces, with wisdom, fear, hatred, and resolution, with love to God, with zeal and courage, and quench every spark that falls upon your heart before it breaks into a flame." When sin is small and in its infancy, it is weak and easily resisted: it has not yet turned the mind away from God, nor quenched grace or disabled it from doing its work. But when sin has grown strong, grace grows weak, and we lack its help, and lack the sense of God’s presence, his attributes, and his truths to rebuke the sin. Do not wait until your heart has drifted out of earshot and wandered from God beyond the reach of his calls. The habit of obedience will be dangerously weakened if you do not resist the acts of sin quickly.

Direction 11. "Work toward the clearest possible understanding of God’s will, so that uncertainty about your duty does not make you falter in obedience, and uncertainty about what constitutes sin does not weaken your hatred of it, undermine your resistance, or tempt you to risk committing it." When a person is certain what his duty is, that certainty is a great protection against every temptation pulling him away from it. When he is certain that something is sinful, resistance becomes easier. It is therefore the devil’s strategy to deceive the understanding, to make people believe that duty is not duty and sin is not sin, after which it is no wonder that duty is neglected and sin committed. To that end, he raises up one false prophet or another to say to Ahab, "Go, and prosper," or to say, "There is no harm in this": to argue in favor of sin and against duty.

It is almost incredible how much ground the devil gains the moment he has made something a matter of controversy. Every hypocrite then has a cloak for his sin and a dose of opium for his conscience, being able to say: "It is a controversy; some hold one view and some another: you hold that opinion and I hold this." The situation is worse when there are wise and learned persons on both sides; worse still when there are religious people on both sides; worse yet when the numbers appear equal; and worst of all when the majority vote favors the error, as error and sin commonly do in the world. If Ahab has four hundred lying, flattering prophets against one Micaiah, he will think he may hate, reproach, and persecute that one man without any scruple of conscience.

If it is made a controversy whether bread is bread and wine is wine when we see and taste them, some will think they may venture to subscribe or swear that they hold the negative, if their reputation, livelihood, or life depends on it, all the more readily if they can add, "It is the judgment of the Church." If it is once made a controversy whether perjury is a sin, whether a materially lawful vow is binding, whether equivocation is permissible, whether lying with a mental reservation for the sake of truth is lawful, or whether the greatest evil may be done or the falsest thing said with a true and good intent, almost all the hypocrites in the country will take the sinful side whenever their fleshly interest requires it, and will think themselves wronged if they are called hypocrites, liars, or perjurers, so long as the matter remains a point of controversy among learned men.

If it is once made a controversy whether an excommunicated king becomes a private person whom it is lawful to kill, and whether the pope may absolve the subjects of temporal rulers from their allegiance notwithstanding all their oaths, and if learned men such as Suarez, Bellarmine, Perron, and others (to say nothing of Santarellus, Mariana, and the like) argue for it, you will find a Clement, a Ravilliac, a Fawkes, and a ready abundance of instruments willing to strike the blow. When many hold that something may or must be done, some will be found too ready to do it, especially when an approved General Council (Lateran under Innocent III, canon 3) supports such papal absolution. We have seen at home how many will be emboldened to pull down government, to sit in judgment on their king and condemn him, and to destroy their brethren, if only they can say that certain men regard it as lawful.

If it were but once made a controversy whether drunkenness, sexual immorality, swearing, stealing, or any other villainy is a sin, such things would be committed more commonly and with far less regret of conscience. Even good people will be inclined to think that modesty requires them to be less censorious toward those who commit these things, since in controverted cases one must suspect one’s own judgment and allow something to the judgment of those who dissent. And so all the rules of love, peace, and moderation that are genuinely required in controversies over minor and difficult points, the devil applies to the defense of the most odious sins, if only he can once secure some learned, wise, or religious advocates for them. From tenderness toward the persons involved, we slide easily into an indulgent tenderness in judging the sin itself; and by these means even good people are dangerously weakened in their resistance to it and made ready to commit it.

Direction 12. "Take care lest the devil cast you either into the sleep of carnal security, or into such doubts, fears, and perplexing scruples as make holy obedience seem to you an impossible or a tiresome thing." When you are asleep in carelessness, he can use you as he pleases. If obedience becomes grievous and unwelcome to you, your heart will resist it, and you will go no further than a tired horse goes without the spur. You are already half conquered, because you have lost the love and pleasure of obedience; and you remain in constant danger that difficulties will wear you out completely and that weariness will make you yield in the end. The means by which the tempter accomplishes this will be addressed later, and I therefore omit the subject here.

By the faithful practice of these directions, obedience may become, as it were, your second nature, a familiar, easy, and delightful thing, like a cheerful servant or child who waits for your commands and is glad to be put to work. Your full submission of your will to God will be the health, ease, and quietness of your will: you will find that you are never truly well or at peace except when you are obedient and pleasing to your Creator’s will. "Your delight will be in the law of the Lord" (Ps 1:2). It will be sweeter than honey to you, and better than thousands of gold and silver, and this not for any incidental benefit, but because it is the "law of God," "a light unto your feet," and an infallible guide in all your duty.

You will say with David: "I will delight myself in thy statutes; I will not forget thy word. Thy testimonies are my delight and my counsellors. Make me to go in the path of thy commandments, for therein do I delight" (Ps 119:16, 119:24, 119:35, 119:47, 119:70, 119:77, and 119:174). And: "I delight to do thy will, O my God; yea, thy law is within my heart" (Ps 40:8). And: "Blessed is the man that feareth the Lord; that delighteth greatly in his commandments" (Ps 112:1).

CHAPTER 29

GRAND DIRECTION 7: CONTINUE AS THE COVENANTED SCHOLARS OF CHRIST, YOUR PROPHET AND TEACHER

 

‘Continue as the covenanted scholars of Christ, the Prophet and Teacher of his church, to learn of him, by his Spirit, word, and ministers, the further knowledge of God, and the things that tend to your salvation; and this with an honest, willing mind; in faith, humility, and diligence; in obedience, patience, and peace.’

Although I spoke earlier of our coming to God by Jesus Christ as the way to the Father, it is fitting that we speak distinctly of our relation and duty to him as our teacher, our captain, and our master, as well as of our drawing on him as Mediator immediately to God. The necessity of believers, and the office and work of Christ himself, show how much of our religion consists in learning from him as his disciples. "A prophet shall the Lord your God raise up unto you of your brethren, like unto me, him shall you hear" (Acts 7:37). This was the voice that came out of the cloud on the holy mount: "This is my beloved Son in whom I am well pleased, hear ye him" (Matt 17:5). Hence the title of disciples is commonly given to believers.

There is a twofold teaching that Christ has sent his ministers to perform, both mentioned in their commission (Matt 28:19–20). The first is to "teach the nations," making disciples of them by drawing them into the school of Christ, which encompasses the teaching of faith and repentance, and whatever is necessary for their first admission and for their submitting themselves to Christ as their established and infallible Guide. The second is teaching them further to know more of God, "and to observe all things whatsoever he commanded them." It is this second kind of teaching we now address, and I will add some sub-directions for your help.

Directions for Learning of Christ, as our Teacher

 

Direction 1. "Remember who it is that is your teacher: that he is the Son of God, who knows his Father’s will, and is the most faithful, infallible Pastor of the church." There is neither ignorance, nor negligence, nor ambition, nor deceit in him that would cause him to conceal the mind of God. There is nothing we need to know that he is not both able and willing to make known to us.

Direction 2. "Remember what he teaches you, and to what end." He does not teach you how to sin and be damned, as the devil, the world, and the flesh would teach you; nor how to satisfy your lusts, or to know, or do, or attain the trifles of the world. He teaches you how to be renewed to the image of God, how to do his will and please him, how to be justified at his bar, how to escape everlasting fire, and how to attain everlasting joy. Consider this well, and you will gladly learn from such a teacher.

Direction 3. "Let the book which he himself has given by his Spirit be the rule and principal matter of your learning." The Holy Scriptures are of divine inspiration. We must be judged by them and ruled by them, and therefore we must principally learn them. The books and teachings of men are only means for learning this infallible word.

Direction 4. "Remember that, as it is Christ’s work to teach, it is yours to hear, and read, and study, and pray, and practice what you hear." Do your part, then, if you expect the benefit. You have not come into the school of Christ to be idle. Knowledge does not drop into the mouth of the sleeping dreamer. Dig for it as for silver, and search for it in the Scriptures as for a hidden treasure. Meditate on them day and night. Leave it to miserable fools to despise the wisdom of the Most High.

Direction 5. "Fix your eye on Christ himself as your pattern and study, with earnest desire to follow his holy example and to be made conformable to him." Not to imitate him in the works proper to him as God or as Mediator, but in his holiness, which he has set before his disciples for their imitation.

He knew how powerful a perfect example would be where perfect doctrine alone would be less regarded. Example brings doctrine nearer to our eye and heart; it makes it more tangible, and tells us with more powerful force, "such you must be, and thus you must do." The eye makes an easier and deeper impression on the imagination and mind than the ear does.

Therefore Christ’s example should be much preached and much studied. It will be a very great help to keep always before our minds the image of the holy life of Christ, so that we are affected as though we always saw him performing the holy actions he once performed. Paul calls the Galatians "foolish" and "bewitched," that "obeyed not the truth, when Christ had been set forth as crucified among them, evidently before their eyes" (Gal 3:1).

Papists think that images serve well for this purpose; but the records of Scripture, and the living images of Christ in those whom they persecute and kill, are far more useful. How much more powerful example is than doctrine alone you may perceive from the enemies of Christ, who can bear his holy doctrine when they cannot bear his holy servants who practice that doctrine before their eyes. And what most stirs up their enmity has the advantage of exciting the believer’s piety.

Let the image of Christ, in all his holy examples, be always vividly written on your minds.

1. Let the great ones of the world remember that their Lord was not born of those who held rule or lived in worldly pomp and dignity, but of persons who lived in modest circumstances (though of the royal line): how he was born not in a palace but a stable, and laid in a manger, without the attendance or comfort of the wealthy.

2. Remember how he submitted himself to his reputed father and his mother, to teach all children submission and obedience (Luke 2:51).

3. Remember how he condescended to labor at a trade and a humble occupation in the world; to teach us that our bodies, as well as our minds, must express their obedience and have their ordinary employment; to teach men to labor and live by a calling; and to comfort poor laborers with the assurance that God accepts them in the humblest work, and that Christ himself lived so before them, choosing their kind of life rather than the life of princes and nobles who live in pomp, ease, and pleasure.

4. Remember how he did not refuse to submit to all the ordinances of God, to fulfill all righteousness, and to be initiated into the solemn administration of his office by the baptism of John, which God approved by sending down the Holy Spirit upon him, to teach us all to expect his Spirit in the use of his ordinances (Matt 3:15–17).

5. Remember how he voluntarily began his work with an encounter with the tempter in the wilderness, during his fasting; and suffered the tempter to proceed until he moved him toward the most odious sin, even to worship the devil himself. This teaches us that God loves tried servants and expects that we not be turned from him by temptations, especially those who enter upon a public ministry, who must be tried men who have overcome the tempter. It also comforts tempted Christians, who may remember that their Savior himself was most blasphemously tempted to sins as odious as any they have faced; and that to be greatly tempted without consenting or yielding to sin is so far from being a sin in itself that it is the greatest honor of our obedience; and that the devil, who molests and haunts us with his temptations, is a conquered enemy whom our Lord in person has overcome.

6. Remember how earnestly and constantly he preached, not stories, or jingles, or subtle controversies, but repentance, and faith, and self-denial, and obedience. So great was his love for souls that when he had hearers, he preached not only in the temple and synagogues, but on mountains, in a boat, and in any other convenient place; and no fury of the rulers or Pharisees could silence him until his hour had come, for he had his Father’s commission. Even to particular persons he graciously opened by conversation the mysteries of salvation (John 3 and 4), to teach us to love and attend to the plain and powerful preaching of the Gospel, and not to abandon any necessary means for the honor of God and the saving of souls because of the hostility or opposition of malicious men, but to "work while it is day, seeing the night is coming when none can work" (John 9:4).

7. Remember how compassionate he was toward people’s bodies as well as their souls, going about with tireless diligence, doing good: healing the blind, the lame, the deaf, the sick, and the demon-possessed. All his miracles were acts of charity to help, and none were done to harm, so that he was, in his very life and movement, love and mercy made visible. This teaches us to know God in his love and mercy; to abound in love and mercy toward our neighbors; to hate every spirit of harm, persecution, and uncharitableness; to give ourselves to doing good; and to show compassion to people’s bodies as well as to their souls, according to our ability.

8. Remember how his zeal and love endured the reproach and resisted the opposition even of his friends, who went to seize him as though he had lost his mind (Mark 3:20–21). He told Peter, "Get thee behind me, Satan: thou art an offence unto me: for thou savourest not the things that be of God, but those that be of men" (Matt 16:22–23), when Peter, out of a carnal love and worldly wisdom, rebuked him for resolving to lay down his life, saying, "Be it far from thee, Lord: this shall not be unto thee." This teaches us to expect that carnal love and worldly reasoning in our nearest friends will rise up against us in the work of God, discouraging us from both duty and suffering. All such influence must be shaken off and recognized as the instrument of Satan, whenever it tempts us to be unfaithful to our calling, or to spare ourselves by sinfully avoiding the sufferings God calls us to bear.

9. Remember how throughout his life he despised worldly wealth and chose a life of poverty, keeping company with the lowliest people, possessing no grand houses, no large retinue, no wide estates, and no great fortune. He lived in open contempt of all the wealth, splendor, and worldly greatness around him, to teach us how little these little things deserve to be esteemed, that they are no part of a saint’s true treasure and portion, and what folly it is to be captivated by snares and distractions that make the way to heaven as narrow as a needle’s eye.

10. Observe how little he cared for human honor and applause, how "he made himself of no reputation, and took upon him the form of a servant" (Phil 2:7), refusing to "be made a king" (John 6:15) or to have a kingdom of this world. Though he told malicious blasphemers how gravely they sinned by dishonoring him, he did not seek worldly honor for himself. This teaches us how little the opinions or words of ignorant people contribute to our happiness or deserve to be reckoned with, and calls us to turn our eyes from the impenitent censures of flesh and blood to the judgment of our Almighty Sovereign, before whom we stand or fall.

11. Remember how little he provided for bodily comfort, and how he never once tasted any immoderate or sinful pleasure. How far he was from a life of self-indulgence and sensuality! Though his refusal to observe the formal fasts of the Pharisees led them to slander him as a "gluttonous man" and "a winebibber" (Matt 11:19), just as sober Christians were called "flesh-eaters" by those who thought eating meat unlawful, yet he was so far from the guilt of any such sin that not even the desire for it was in his heart.

You will never find in the Gospels that Christ spent half his morning dressing himself, choosing to shorten his time for prayer rather than appear insufficiently adorned, as our hollow, vain, preening young men do. Nor will you ever read that he wasted time in idle visits, card games, dice, reading romances, or attending theatrical performances. The example our Lord left for his disciples was of an entirely different order.

12. Mark also how far Christ was from any idle, indecent, or foolish speech, and how holy and profitable all his words were. This teaches us likewise to speak as those who speak the very words of God, words that build up, that administer grace to those who hear, and that keep our tongues free from all profane, indecent, and worthless talk.

13. Remember that pride and anger are condemned by your pattern. Christ himself says, "Learn of me; for I am meek and lowly in heart: and ye shall find rest unto your souls" (Matt 11:28–29). He declares, therefore, that unless people "be converted, and become as little children, they shall not enter into the kingdom of heaven" (Matt 18:3). Behold the Lamb of God, and be ashamed of your fierce and predatory nature.

14. Remember that Christ your Lord and pattern humbled himself to the lowest act of love, even washing his disciples’ feet, not to teach you to wash a few poor men’s feet as a ceremony once a year while spending the rest of the year persecuting and murdering the servants of Christ, as the Roman Vice-Christ does; but to teach us that since he who is their Lord and Master washed his disciples’ feet, we also ought to stoop just as low in any act of love for one another (John 13:14).

15. Remember also that Christ your pattern spent whole nights in prayer to God, so devoted was he to this holy attendance upon God (Luke 6:12), to teach us to "pray always, and not to faint" (Luke 18:1). And we must not be like the godless, who have no love for any earnest or serious approach to God, and who make those who do practice such prayer the objects of their cruelty or scorn. And if the word rendered "prayer" in that verse should instead mean an oratory, a place of prayer, it still implies that he continued there for prayer.

16. Remember also that Christ opposed the Pharisees’ outward, hypocritical, and ceremonious worship, consisting in lip-service, affected repetitions, and much empty babbling; their "touch not, taste not, handle not," and their vain worship of God according to human tradition, teaching the commandments of men as though they were doctrines of God. He taught us a sincere, spiritual worship: not to "draw nigh" to God "with" our "mouth, and honour him with" our "lips" while our "heart is far from him," but to "worship" God, "who is a Spirit," "in spirit and in truth" (John 4:23–24 Matt 15:6–9 Matt 23).

17. Christ was a sharp reprover of hypocritical, blind, ceremonious, and malicious Pharisees, and he warned his disciples to beware of their leaven. When they were offended at him, he said, "Every plant, which my heavenly Father hath not planted, shall be rooted up. Let them alone: they be blind leaders of the blind" (Matt 15:12–14). This teaches us to beware of self-appointed, haughty, domineering, formal hypocrites and false teachers, and to discern the difference between true shepherds and wolves.

18. Though Christ appears to carefully avoid endorsing the Roman claim of authority over the Jews, he nevertheless pays the tribute himself rather than give offense (Matt 17:25–27), and he tells them to "render therefore unto Caesar the things which are Caesar’s; and unto God the things that are God’s" (Matt 22:21). The Pharisees brought their dispute to him hypocritically, asking whether it was lawful to give tribute to Caesar or not, taking it as already settled that Caesar was a usurper over them. Christ gave them no answer that would either entrap himself, encourage usurpation, or sanction their rebellion, teaching us all the more to pay tribute willingly to our lawful government and to avoid all sedition and provocation.

19. Yet for all this, he is accused, condemned, and executed among criminals, as one aspiring to be "King of the Jews," with the judge told he was "not Caesar’s friend" if he released him. This teaches us to expect that even the most innocent Christians will be accused as enemies of worldly rulers, that misled governors will be stirred up against them by the malicious slanders of their adversaries, and that in this unrighteous world we will be condemned for the very crimes of which we are most innocent, crimes we most abhor and have most fully borne witness against.

20. The furious and enraged mob mocked him with words and deeds, a purple robe, a reed for a scepter, a crown of thorns, and the contemptuous title "King of the Jews." They spat in his face, struck him, and then jeered at him. Through it all, "being reviled, he reviled not again; when he suffered, he threatened not; but committed himself to him that judgeth righteously" (1 Pet 2:21–23). This teaches us to expect the rage of the ignorant mob as well as of misguided rulers, and to be made the object of scorn by the worst of people, bearing it all without impatience, retaliating words, or threats, quieting ourselves in the certain expectation of the righteous judgment that we and they alike must soon face.

21. When Christ is brought before Pilate and urged to speak in his own defense, he remains silent. This teaches us to expect to be questioned at the judgment seat of human authority, and not to be overly anxious about clearing our names from even the most hateful slanders, for the judgment that will fully vindicate us is certain and near.

22. When Christ is in his agony, his disciples fail him; when he is judged and crucified, they "forsook him and fled" (Matt 26:56). This teaches us not to place too much confidence in even the best of people, not to expect much from them in times of trial, but to find our comfort in God alone when our nearest friends abandon us.

23. On the cross he endured the torment and disgrace of death for us, praying for his murderers, "leaving us an example that we should follow his steps" (1 Pet 2:21), teaching us that not even life itself is too dear to surrender in obedience to God and for the love of Christ and one another (1 John 3:16), and that we should forgive and pray for those who persecute us.

24. Through all this suffering at human hands, he also bore so much of the fruit of our sin upon his soul that he cried out, "My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?" This teaches us that if we ever fall into such spiritual calamity that we feel God himself has forsaken us, we should remember for our comfort that the Son of God himself cried out before us, "My God, why hast thou forsaken me?", and that in this too we may expect a trial in which we seem forsaken by God, since our Savior endured the same before us.

I will draw no more instances from his example, so as not to be tedious. Let believers now turn their eyes here. If you love your Lord, you should love to imitate him and be glad to find yourself on the road he has already traveled. If he lived a worldly and sensual life, then do the same; if he was an enemy of preaching, prayer, and holy living, then be so too. But if he lived in the deepest contempt of all worldly wealth, honor, and pleasure, in a life of holy obedience to his Father, wholly devoted to the kingdom of heaven, seeking the salvation of others’ souls, and patiently bearing persecution, mockery, slander, and death, then take up your cross and follow him joyfully toward the crown that awaits.

Direction 6. "If you will learn of Christ, you must learn from his ministers, whom he has appointed to be the teachers of his church." He deliberately equipped them, inclines them, and sends them to instruct you, not to exercise dominion over your faith, but to be your spiritual fathers and "the ministers by whom you believe, as God shall give" ability and success "to every one" as he pleases, "to plant and water," while "God giveth the increase, to open men’s eyes, and turn them from darkness to light," and to be "labourers together with God, whose husbandry and building you are," and to be "helpers of your joy" (2 Cor 1:24 Acts 26:17–18 1 Cor 3:5 1 Cor 4:15).

Since Christ has appointed them under himself to be the ordinary teachers of his church, the one who "heareth them," when they speak his message, "heareth him," and the one "that despiseth them despiseth him" (Luke 10:16). Anyone who says, "I will hear Christ but not you," is in effect saying to Christ himself, "I will not hear you or learn from you, unless you dismiss your assistants and teach me directly yourself."

Direction 7. "Attend also to the secret teachers of his Spirit and your own conscience, not as though they make any new law or duty for you, or can replace Scripture and ministers, but as bringing that truth into your heart and practice which Scripture and ministers have first brought to your eyes and ears."

If you do not understand how the office of Scripture and ministers differs from the office of the Spirit and conscience, you will end up as confused as the sectaries of our time, who separate what God has joined together and argue against Scripture and ministers under the pretense of exalting the Spirit or the inner light. Just as food must be taken into the stomach and pass through an initial stage of digestion before further digestion can occur, so Scripture and ministers must bring truth to your eyes and ears before the Spirit and conscience can carry it into your heart and practice. But truth lies dead and ineffectual in your mind or imagination if you do not attend to the secret teachings of the Spirit and conscience, which would carry it further.

As Christ is the principal outward teacher and ministers are subordinate to him, so the Spirit is the principal inward teacher and conscience is subordinate to the Spirit, being stirred up and informed by it. Those who learn only from Scripture and ministers, through reading or hearing, may become learned and capable people, even if they pay no attention to the sanctifying work of the Spirit or to their consciences. But only those who attend first to Scripture and ministers, and then to the Spirit of God and to their consciences, have an inward, sanctifying, saving knowledge, and these are the ones who are said to be taught of God. Therefore, listen first with your ears to what Christ has spoken to you outwardly, and then listen daily and diligently with your hearts to what the Spirit and conscience say within. For it is their office to preach inwardly to your hearts everything you have already received.

Direction 8. "Since the ordinary present ministry has the sole task of expounding and applying the doctrine of Christ already recorded in Scripture, believe no one who contradicts that recorded doctrine, whatever reason, authority, or special revelation he may claim." "To the law and to the testimony: if they speak not according to these, it is because there is no light in them" (Isa 8:20). No argument can genuinely be reason that is set against the reason of the Creator and God of reason. Authority claimed against the supreme authority of God is no authority at all: God never granted authority to anyone to act against himself, to deceive souls, to set aside the law of Christ, to give men warrant to sin against him, or to add anything to his law or doctrine. The apostles had their "power only to edification, but not to destruction" (2 Cor 10:8 2 Cor 13:10).

There is no revelation from God that contradicts his own revelation already delivered as his perfect law and rule to the church, and therefore none that supplements it. If "an apostle or an angel from heaven," whether possible or impossible, "shall evangelize to us besides what is evangelized" and we "have received," he must be held "accursed" (Gal 1:6–8).

Direction 9. "Do not come to learn of Christ with self-conceit, pride, or confidence in your own prejudices and errors, but as little children, with humble, teachable, and receptive minds." Christ is no teacher for those who already consider themselves sufficiently wise, except first to teach them to "become fools" in their own estimation, because they truly are, "that they may be wise" (1 Cor 3:18). Those who are filled with false opinions and have resolved never to be persuaded otherwise are unfit to be students in the school of Christ. "He resisteth the proud, but giveth more grace unto the humble" (1 Pet 5:5).

People who think highly of their own understanding, who believe they can easily distinguish truth from falsehood the moment they hear it, and who come not to learn but to judge what they hear or read, as though they were competent to assess everything, are more suited to the school of the prince of pride and the father of lies than to the school of Christ. "Except conversion" make men "as little children," who come not to carp and cavil but to learn, they are not "meet for the kingdom of Christ" (Matt 18:3 John 3:3–5). Recognize how blind and ignorant you are, how slow to learn, and humbly ask the Heavenly Teacher to accept and illuminate you. Surrender your understanding entirely to be shaped by him, and offer your heart as the tablet on which his Spirit will write his law, believing his doctrine simply on the ground of his infallible truthfulness and resolving to obey it. This is to be a disciple of Christ in truth, and one who shall truly be taught of God.

Direction 10. "Come to the school of Christ with honest, willing hearts that love the truth and genuinely desire to know it so that they may obey it, not with false and biased hearts that secretly resist the understanding from receiving the truth, because they do not love it, since it runs against their fleshly inclinations and interests." The word received into "honest hearts" was the seed that brought forth fruit abundantly (Matt 13:23). When the heart says sincerely, "Speak, Lord, for thy servant heareth; teach me to know and do thy will," God will not leave such a learner in the dark.

Most of the damnable ignorance and error in the world arises from a corrupt heart that recognizes that God’s truth is against its fleshly interests and desires, and therefore refuses to obey it, and refuses to believe it, lest that belief torment the person for their disobedience. A will secretly poisoned by love of the world, or of any sinful desires and pleasures, is the most powerful obstacle to receiving the truth.

Direction 11. "Learn with quietness and peace in the school of Christ; do not create divisions or meddle with others’ lessons and concerns, but attend to your own." Silence, quietness, and minding your own business is the path to spiritual growth. The turbulent arguers who quarrel with others and practice religion contentiously, in envy and strife, are more likely to be corrected or expelled than to be edified. Read James 3.

Direction 12. "Remember that the school of Christ has a rod; therefore learn with fear and reverence" (Heb 12:28–29 Phil 2:12). Christ will sharply rebuke his own if they grow negligent and give offense; and if he were to cast you out and forsake you, you would be ruined forever. "See," therefore, "that ye refuse not him that speaketh: for if they escaped not, who refused him that spake on earth, much more shall not we escape, if we refuse him that speaketh from heaven" (Heb 12:25). "For how shall we escape, if we neglect so great salvation, which at first began to be spoken by the Lord, and was confirmed to us by them that heard him: God also bearing them witness both with signs and wonders, and divers miracles, and gifts of the Holy Ghost, according to his own will" (Heb 2:3–4). "Serve the Lord therefore with fear, and rejoice with trembling: kiss the Son, lest he be angry, and you perish, in the kindling of his wrath" (Ps 2:11–12).

CHAPTER 30

GRAND DIRECTION 8: REMEMBER YOUR RELATION TO CHRIST AS PHYSICIAN AND TO THE HOLY SPIRIT AS SANCTIFIER

 

‘Remember that you are related to Christ as the Physician of your souls, and to the Holy Spirit as your Sanctifier. Make it therefore your serious study to be cured by Christ, and cleansed by his Spirit, of all the sinful diseases and defilements of your hearts and lives.’

Although I spoke earlier of believing in the Holy Spirit and using his help for access to God and fellowship with him, I deferred a full treatment of the cleansing and mortifying dimension of his work of sanctification until now. I will treat it here as the same work as Christ’s curing work, Christ being related to us as the physician of our souls, and our submission to his rule toward our cure being itself part of our obedience to him. What I write here against sin in general will serve a twofold purpose. The first is to help us against the inward corruptions of our hearts and toward the outward obedience of our lives, thereby advancing the work of sanctification and preventing our sinning. The second is to help us to repentance and humiliation, both habitual and actual, for the sins that remain in us and for those we have already committed at any time.

The general Directions for this curing and cleansing of the soul from sin are contained, for the most part, in what has already been said, and many particular Directions may also be drawn from the sixth Direction preceding. I will now add two general Directions, followed by many more particular ones.

The two General Directions are these.

1. Know what corruptions the soul of man is naturally defiled with. This includes knowledge of the faculties that are the seat of these corruptions, and knowledge of the corruptions that have tainted and perverted each faculty.

2. Know what sin is in its nature, its intrinsic evil, as well as in its effects.

1. The parts or faculties to be cleansed and cured are both the superior and the inferior.

1.) The Understanding, though it was not first in the sin, must be first in the cure. Everything done upon the lower faculties must be done by the governing power of the will, and everything done upon the will, in the order of human nature, must be done through the understanding. The understanding, however, has its own diseases, which must be known and cured. Its general malady is ignorance, not merely the absence of actual knowledge, but an unwillingness or indisposition of the understanding to receive the truth.

A person may lack certain actual knowledge without any disease of the mind causing that lack: for instance, when the object is absent and out of reach, when no sufficient revelation of it has been given, when the mind is wholly occupied with something else, or when a person shuts out the thoughts of such an object or refuses the evidence, which last is an act of the will. Just as a person who is not blind may still fail to see a particular object, so it is with the understanding.

a) In the case where the object is beyond the natural reach of sight.

b) Or where it is night and there is no external light.

c) Or where a person is wholly absorbed in observing other things.

d) Or where a person wilfully closes or turns away their eyes.

It is a difficult question to resolve how far, and in what sense, the diseases of the understanding may be called sin, since the understanding is not a free but a necessitated faculty, and where there is no liberty there can be no sin. To clarify this, consider the following points.

1.) It is not this or that faculty, taken alone, that is the full and proper subject of sin, but the man. The full character of sin is made up of the vice of both faculties, understanding and will, taken together. It is more proper to say "the man sinned" than "the intellect sinned" or "the will sinned," speaking of either faculty exclusively.

2.) Free choice belongs to the man, not to his will alone, though it belongs principally to the will.

3.) Although the will alone is free in itself originally, the intellect is free by participation, insofar as it is directed by the will or depends upon it for the exercise of its acts.

4.) Accordingly, although the understanding, primitively and in itself, is not the primary subject of morality, of moral virtues, or of moral vices, those belonging immediately and primarily to the will, yet its virtues and vices are moralized by participation and become graces or sins, praiseworthy and rewardable or blameworthy and punishable, insofar as they are commanded by the will or depend upon it.

Consider, then, the acts, habits, and dispositions of the understanding.

1.) Some acts, and the privation of them, are necessary, natural, original, and unalterable. These carry no morality and are neither virtues nor sins. For example, knowing unwillingly, as the devils do, or believing when assent cannot be resisted even if one would resist it, is no moral virtue at all, but only a natural condition.

a) To be ignorant of what is no object of knowledge, or what is naturally beyond our knowledge, such as the essence of God, is no sin at all.

b) Nor is it a sin to be ignorant of what has never been revealed, when no fault of ours hindered that revelation.

c) Nor is it a sin to lack the present, actual knowledge or consideration of a particular point at the very moment when our thoughts are lawfully diverted by more pressing matters, or suspended as in sleep.

d) But to be ignorant wilfully is a sin, participatively in the intellect and originally in the will.

e) And to be ignorant for want of revelation when we ourselves have hindered that revelation or are the deserving cause of our own lack is our sin. For though that ignorance is immediately necessary under the circumstances, it is originally and remotely free and voluntary.

So also regarding the habits and disposition of the intellect: it is no sin to lack those capacities that the human understanding in its original and entire nature never possessed, such as knowing without an object, knowing an unrevealed or too distant object, or actually knowing all knowable things at once. But there are defects and ill dispositions that have been sinfully contracted. Though these are now immediately natural and necessary, they are participatively sinful because they were originally and remotely voluntary and free. As Horace says, the greatest part of mankind is tossed by this same disease.

The most common instance of this is the natural person’s incapacity or indisposition to know the things of the Spirit when the Word reveals them. This does not lie in the absence of a natural faculty for such knowledge, but rather: 1. radically in the will; 2. and from there in contrary, false apprehensions with which the intellect is already occupied, apprehensions that resist the truth and may rightly be called the intellect’s blindness or incapacity to receive it; and 3. in the mind’s deep unfamiliarity with those spiritual things it has had no acquaintance with.

Note here the following three points.

1.) The will may be guilty of the understanding’s ignorance in two ways: either by a positive aversion that forbids or diverts it from beholding the evidence of truth, or by the absence and withholding of that direction or excitation which is necessary for the understanding to exercise its acts. This second way is the most common form of sin in the understanding. That which proceeds from the will’s neglect of its proper office, or from its suspension of its act, may truly be called voluntary, even when there is no outright act of opposition or refusal.

2.) The will can do far more to cause disease in the understanding than it can do to cure it. A person can put out another’s eyes but cannot restore them.

3.) Even so, God has so ordered things in his gracious dispensation of the Redeemer’s grace that certain means are appointed for a person to use toward obtaining that grace and achieving their own recovery. Thus, though grace does not cure the understanding of its original, natural weakness, it does cure it of the contracted weakness that was voluntary in its origin but became necessary once contracted. And as the will had a hand in causing this condition, so it must have a hand, through the voluntary use of the appointed means, in the cure of it. This much establishes how the understanding is implicated in sin.

Although no actual knowledge is so immediate as to bypass the mediation of sense and imagination, yet, presupposing these, knowledge is distinguished into immediate and mediate. Immediate knowledge is when the being, quality, or the truth of a proposition is known directly in itself by its proper evidence. Mediate knowledge is when the being of a thing or the truth of a proposition is known by means of some other intervening thing or proposition whose evidence supplies the light by which we discern it.

The understanding is far more satisfied when it can see things and truths immediately, in their proper evidence. When it cannot, it welcomes any means that helps it.

The further we go in a chain of means, knowing one thing by another, that by another, and so on, the less satisfied the understanding becomes, since it perceives a growing possibility of mistake, and increasing difficulty in avoiding mistake when so many intermediate steps are involved.

When the evidence of one thing, in its own nature, reveals another to us, this is knowing by pure reasoning or argument.

When the means by which we know one thing is the credibility of another person’s testimony, someone who knows it directly, this is called, in a special sense, belief. Belief is strong or weak, certain or uncertain, according to how certain and how clearly apprehended the evidence of the reporter’s credibility is.

In both cases, the understanding’s fault is either a complete absence of the act or the disposition toward it, or else a lack of rectitude in the act. When it should know by the thing’s proper evidence, the absence of the act is called ignorance or nescience, and the absence of rectitude is called error, these differing as not seeing differs from seeing falsely. When it should know by testimony, the absence of the act is simple unbelief, or not-believing; and the absence of rectitude is either disbelief, when one concludes the reporter is mistaken, or misbelief, when one accepts a testimony that ought not to be believed.

From all this you can see that the diseases of the mind to be cured are: 1. Mere ignorance. 2. Error, taking truth for falsehood and falsehood for truth. 3. Unbelief. 4. Disbelief. And 5. Misbelief.

Yet since goodness is the chief concern in any object, the understanding’s primary office is discerning the truth about good and evil. Its failure to value God, glory, and grace rightly, and its mistaken overvaluing of bodily pleasure, worldly prosperity, wealth, and honor, is the mind’s principal disease.

2. The diseases of the will lie in its inclinations and in its acts.

1.) A disordered inclination toward satisfying bodily appetite and imagination, and toward all carnal attractions and temporal things that feed it, with correspondingly disordered acts of desire.

2.) An irrational aversion to God, grace, and spiritual good, with a corresponding refusal, an act of the will against them. These disorders exist in the will for the following reasons.

1.) The will has become greatly subject to the sensitive appetite. It has debased itself and, through sinful acts, contracted a sensual inclination; in a corrupted soul, the flesh holds the ruling position.

2.) The intellect, being also corrupted, frequently misleads the will by overvaluing transient things.

3.) The will has been stripped, in its corrupted state, of the power of divine love, that is, of any inclination toward God and holy things, which should have overridden the pull of carnal objects.

4.) The understanding is largely without the light that should draw both faculties higher.

5.) The rage of the corrupted appetite continually seduces the will. For a correct understanding of this, our greatest malady, note the following:

a) The will never desires evil as evil, but as something carnal or apparently good.

b) Nor does it hate good as good, but as an apparent evil, because God and grace seem to the corrupted soul to be its enemies, harming it by blocking the carnal pleasure it now prefers.

c) Even while loving evil for the pleasure it gives the flesh, a person retains, simply as a human being, some natural aversion to that same evil insofar as they perceive it as evil. And while hating God and holiness as obstacles to carnal pleasure, they naturally love them insofar as they perceive them as good. So there is some love of God and good, and some hatred of evil, even in the ungodly, for as long as a person remains human, there is a natural inclination toward good as good, and against evil as evil.

d) But the perception of sensory good is strongest in such a person, and the perception of spiritual good is weakest. The will, receiving a stronger impression from the carnal appetite and carnal mind than from the faint perception of spiritual good, is therefore more drawn to what is in fact worst. Carnal things have gained the ruling, commanding interest in the soul.

e) Note also that sin receives its character as moral evil first in the will, not in the intellect or the sensitive appetite, for something is not sin until it is, positively or privatively, immediately or mediately, voluntary. Yet the first stirrings toward sin arise not in the will but in the sensitive appetite, where, at that initial stage, they are not formally sin.

f) Note that neither intellect, object, appetite, nor sense naturally compels the will to sin; the will remains the first in sin and guilt.

It is a matter of great difficulty to understand how sin first entered the innocent soul, and it is a matter of great importance, because an error here carries dangerous consequences. Two groups of thinkers seem to me to make God so much the necessitating cause of Adam’s first sin, and of all sin, that on their account it would have been as naturally impossible for Adam to have refrained from it as to have conquered God.

1.) Those who assert the Dominican doctrine of an immediate, physical, pre-determining pre-motion, a motion which no created power can resist.

2.) Those who hold that the will is necessitated by the intellect in all its acts (and therefore in all its omissions), that the intellect is necessitated by objects, as it doubtless is, except where its acts are "under the command of the will," and that all these objects are caused and disposed of by God.

Since it is certain that God is not the cause of sin, this certainty decides the question against both of these views.

At present it seems to me that sin entered by the following steps.

1. Sense perceives the forbidden thing.

2. The appetite desires it.

3. The imagination dwells further on its desirability.

4. The intellect conceives of it, accurately, as good, by simple apprehension.

5. The will accordingly wills it by simple complacency or volition. Up to this point there was no sin.

6. But here the will clung to it too strongly and took excessive pleasure in it, when it had the power to do otherwise, and here sin began.

7. From this point the thoughts should have been called away.

8. The intellect should have turned to God and his commands, and moved from simple apprehension to the act of comparison, concluding, "The favor of God is better, and his will should govern." It omitted all these acts because the will omitted to command them, and indeed hindered them.

9. And so the intellect was next guilty of a refusal to forbid or restrain, and the will likewise.

10. Next came positive deception in the intellect and consent to sin in the will; and so, being "finished, brought forth death."

If you object that the will’s first sinful adherence at step six could not occur unless the intellect first directed it to do so, I deny this. The will is the first principle in human action with respect to exercise, though the intellect is first with respect to specification. The will could therefore suspend its exercise and its prompting of the mind.

In all of this I proceed on common principles, but I leave the following questions to further inquiry.

1.) How far the sensitive appetite may move the locomotive faculty without the will’s command, as long as the will does not forbid it, and whether reason has been given to humanity as a rider is given to a horse: not to enable motion but to govern it, so that just as a horse can move if the rider does not restrain it, the sensitive appetite can produce the actions of eating, drinking, thinking, and speaking sensually if reason falls dormant or simply fails to hinder it.

2.) Whether in the first sin, and ordinarily, the sensitive appetite, imagination, and passion are the active movers, and the rational powers are first guilty only in failing to exercise the restraining governance they were capable of exercising.

3.) Whether sin is not, ordinarily, a brutish motion, or a voluntary self-degradation, in which the rational powers are at first guilty only of omission and failure to restrain, but are afterward drawn over to actively serve the sensitive appetite.

4.) Whether the will, which is the first principle of the act with respect to exercise, was not the first in the omission, the intellect having already declared, "This must be considered further," while the will failed to command that further consideration when it both could and should have done so.

However, if it is too difficult for us to trace our own souls through all their movements, it is certain that the will of man is the primary subject of moral good and evil. Uncertainties must not lead us to deny what is certain.

The reader who understands the importance and consequences of these points will, I am sure, pardon me for inserting these difficult and disputed questions. I deliberately avoid such questions where I judge them unnecessary for defending or clarifying the plainer, common truths. As for others, I must bear their censure.

The degree of sinfulness in the will lies in a stiffness and obstinacy, a tenacious clinging to deceitful, temporal good combined with an eager pursuit of it, and a stubborn aversion to spiritual good insofar as it conflicts with that temporal, fleshly good. This is the will’s disease.

3. The sinfulness of the memory lies in its retention of evil and harmful or forbidden things, and its looseness and neglect of better, spiritual, and necessary things. If this were only because present things naturally make a deeper impression on the imagination while absent and unseen things are at a disadvantage, it would be a natural, innocent infirmity. Or if, in sickness, age, or weakness, all kinds of memory decayed equally, the same conclusion might hold. But it is plain that even when the Bible lies open before our eyes, preaching sounds in our ears, and unseen things hold the advantage of their infinite greatness, excellence, and concern for us, our memories remain like walls of stone to anything spiritual, and like walls of wax on which anything secular or evil may be inscribed at will.

Note also that the fault of the memory is sinful only insofar as it is voluntary. It is the will in which sin resides as on its throne. Because people love carnal things and do not love spiritual things, they attend to, understand, and remember the one and not the other. The memory, then, is capable of sin only as it is governed and shaped by the will.

4. The sinfulness of the imagination consists in its readiness to dwell on evil and on common, earthly things, and its inability to think of anything holy and good. When we force ourselves to holy thoughts, they are disordered, confused, and poorly managed, accompanied by great aversion. Here too, voluntariness is the life of the sin.

5. The sin of the affections or passions consists in this: they are too easily and violently moved by the sensitive interest and appetite, and are habitually prone to such carnal, disordered impulses, running ahead of the understanding and will in some cases, and soliciting and urging them toward evil, while resisting and disobeying the commands of reason and the will. At the same time they are dull and reluctant toward spiritually good things and toward carrying out the right dictates of the mind and will. Cicero said as much of defilement: it is not taken away by a sprinkling of water, nor by the passing of a number of days.

6. The sin of the sensitive appetite consists in the disordered intensity and excess with which it pursues its object, leading it to disobey the commands of reason and to become the great instigator of rebellion in the soul, violently urging the mind and will to consent to its desires. In terms of its material basis, this depends greatly on the constitution of the body. But formally, it too is sinful only insofar as it is voluntary, whether positively or privatively, mediately or immediately. Simply having an appetite for the proper object of appetite is no sin; but having a diseased, disordered, and ungovernable appetite is a sin, not primarily in itself considered, but as it is voluntary: as it is the appetite of a rational, free agent who has thus disordered the structure of its own nature.

7. The sin of the exterior parts, tongue, hand, eyes, feet, and so on, exists only in act and not in habit, or at least the habits in them are weak and subject to the will. It consists in the execution of the sinful desires of the flesh and the commands of the will. These parts are not the primary subjects of guilt; the will is, since it either positively directs them toward evil or fails to restrain them when it ought. They are therefore guilty only participatively and secondarily, as the other governed faculties are.

An action is not good or evil merely as it is the act of the tongue or hand, but as it is the tongue or hand of a rational, free agent, either conforming to or departing from the law. If a madman were to speak blasphemy, kill, or steal, it would be sinful only to the extent that he had voluntarily contracted the disposition that caused it while he still had the use of reason. If a man’s hand were seized and forced by another to do harm entirely against his will, the sin belongs to the one who compelled him, not to the involuntary instrument.

Yet no force fully excuses us from guilt when it leaves the act to our rational choice. The man who says, "Take this oath or I will kill you or torment you," applies force as a temptation that can be resisted, but he does not compel the person to swear. He leaves it to that person’s choice whether to swear, to die, or to be tormented, and one both may and ought to choose death rather than the smallest sin. The will may be tempted, but it cannot be constrained.

Direction 2: "Labor clearly to understand the evil of sin, both intrinsically in itself and in its aggravations and effects." Once you have located sin and understood what it consists in, go on to find out its malice and odiousness. I have heard some Christians complain that they read a great deal showing them the evil of sin in its effects, but find little that shows them its evil in itself sufficiently. If you do not see the evil of sin in itself, not only in its effects, it will tempt you to think God unjust in punishing it so severely, and it will keep you from the principal part of true repentance and mortification, which lies in hating sin as sin. I will therefore show you what the intrinsic malice of sin consists in.

1. Sin is, formally, the violation of the perfect, holy, and righteous law of God.

2. It is a denial or contempt of the authority and governing power of God, as if we said, "You shall not be our Governor in this."

3. It is a usurping of sovereign power to ourselves: for when we refuse God’s government we set ourselves up in his place, making gods of ourselves, as if we were self-sufficient, independent, and had a right to rule ourselves.

4. It is a denying or contempt of the wisdom of God, as if he had unwisely given us a law unfit to govern us.

5. It is a setting up of our own folly in place of God’s wisdom, and preferring it above him, as if we were better able to know how to govern ourselves and what is fittest and best for us to do than God is.

6. It is a contempt of the goodness of God as the maker of the law, as if he had not done what is best, but something that may be corrected or contradicted, and as if there were something in the law to be avoided. Plutarch’s tract entitled "That Vice Is Sufficient to Make a Man Wretched" is worth reading on this. And Paulus Scaliger observes that if we are moved to be good men not by what is honorable in itself but by some usefulness or profit, we are shrewd rather than good; if virtue is sought for its returns and not for its own nature, virtue will be empty, and empty virtue is rightly called wickedness.

7. It is a preferring of our own worthlessness above God’s goodness, as if we would act better, or choose better what to do.

8. It is a contempt or denial of the holiness and purity of God, which sets him against sin as light is set against darkness.

9. It is a violation of God’s ownership and dominion, robbing him of the use and service of what is absolutely and entirely his own.

10. It is a claiming of ownership over ourselves, as if we were our own and might do with ourselves as we please.

11. It is a contempt of the gracious promises of God by which he drew us toward and bound us to obedience.

12. It is a contempt of the dreadful warnings of God by which he would have restrained us from evil.

13. It is a contempt or denial of the dreadful day of judgment, on which an account must be given of that sin.

14. It is a denial of God’s truthfulness, giving him the lie, as if he were not to be believed in his predictions, promises, and threats.

15. It is a contempt of all the present mercies, innumerable and great, by which God obliges and encourages us to obey.

16. It is a contempt of our own afflictions and God’s chastisements of us, by which he would drive us away from our sins.

17. It is a contempt of all the examples of his mercies toward the obedient, and of his terrible judgments on the disobedient, both men and devils, by which he warned us not to sin.

18. It is a contempt of the person, office, sufferings, and grace of Jesus Christ, who came to save us from our sins and to destroy the works of the devil; it runs contrary to his shed blood, his authority, and his healing work.

19. It is a contradicting, fighting against, and, in that very act, prevailing against the sanctifying office and work of the Holy Ghost, who moves us against sin and toward obedience.

20. It is a contempt of holiness, and a defacing, to that degree, of the image of God upon the soul, or an outright rejection of it. It is a vilifying of all those graces that stand opposed to the sin committed.

21. It is a pleasing of the devil, the enemy of God and of us, and an obeying of him in preference to God.

22. It is the fault of a rational creature, who was given reason precisely so that he might do better.

23. It is all willingly done and chosen by a free agent who could not be compelled to it. As Martin of Braga writes: every sin is voluntary, take away the excuse, for no one sins unwillingly. He adds further: it matters nothing in what spirit you do what is itself vicious, because acts are what can be seen, while the mind remains hidden.

24. It is a robbing of God of the honor and pleasure he should have received in our obedience, and of the glory we should have brought him before the world.

25. It is a contempt of the omnipresence and omniscience of God, when we will sin against him before his face, while he stands over us and sees everything we do.

26. It is a contempt of the greatness and almightiness of God, in that we dare to sin against one who is so great and so able to take vengeance on us.

27. It is a wrong done to the mercifulness of God, when we leave the way of mercy and compel him to employ the way of justice and severity, he who takes no delight in the death of sinners, but desires rather that they obey, repent, and live.

28. It is a contempt of the attractive love of God, who should be the soul’s end, felicity, and pleasure. It treats all that love and goodness of God as insufficient to draw or hold the heart to him, to satisfy us, or to make us happy, as though he were not fit to be our delight. And it reveals the absence of love to God, for if we loved him rightly we would willingly obey him.

29. It is a setting up of the sordid creature before the Creator, and of refuse before heaven, as if the creature were more worthy of our love and choice, and more suited to be our delight, and as if the pleasure of sin were better for us than the glory of heaven.

30. In all of this it becomes clear that sin is, in its degree, a practical atheism, a dethroning of God, or a denial that he is God, and a practical idolatry, setting up ourselves and other creatures in his place.

31. It is a contempt of all the means of grace, which are all appointed to bring us to obedience and to keep or call us back from our sins: prayer, sacraments, and the rest.

32. It is a contempt of the love and labors of the ministers of Christ; a disobeying of them, a grieving of them, and a frustrating of their hopes and of the lifelong work they have devoted to us.

33. It is a degrading of reason, the soul’s governing faculty, and a setting up of the flesh or the lower faculties in its place, like putting dogs in charge of men, or giving the horse rule over the rider.

34. It is a blinding of reason, a misuse of the soul’s noblest faculties, and a frustrating of them from the purpose and ends for which they were made. In this way sin is the disorder, monstrosity, sickness, or death of the soul. As Plutarch observes: sick bodies only suffer harm, but sick souls both suffer harm and do harm.

35. It is, in its measure, the image of the devil upon the soul, who is the father of sin, and therefore the most hideous deformity the soul can bear; and this in the very place where the Holy Ghost should dwell, and where the image and delight of God should be found.

36. It is the moral destruction not only of the soul, but of the whole creation, insofar as created things are appointed as means to bring or keep us to God. For a means, as a means, is destroyed when it is not used toward its end. A ship is useless if it carries no one. A watch, as such, is useless when it is not used to show the hour of the day. All the world, as the book that should teach us the will of God, is cast aside when that use is cast aside. More than that: sin turns the creature against God, when it should have been used for him.

37. It is a contradicting of our own confessions and professions, a wronging of our consciences, and a violation of our covenants and self-imposed obligations to God.

38. It is a preferring of time over eternity, and a valuing of things of a passing, transitory nature and a moment’s pleasure above that which will never have an end.

39. It is a making of a breach in the harmony and order of the world. Just as the dislocation or deformity of a single member troubles and deforms the whole body, because the comeliness and welfare of the whole consists in the comeliness, proportion, and welfare of all its parts, and just as the dislocation or breaking of one part in a watch or clock works against the use of the whole mechanism, so every person, being a part of the kingdom of God, makes by sin a breach in the order of the whole. Sin also sets a harmful example to other members, makes the sinner unserviceable to the body, dishonors the whole body with the stain of rebellion, lets in judgment upon the world, kindles a consuming fire in the place where the sinner lives, and renders him cruel and injurious to others.

40. Sin is not only a preferring of the body before the soul; it is also an act of mercilessness, or cruelty, against ourselves, both soul and body, and so runs contrary to the true use of the inextinguishable principle of self-love. It wounds and abuses the soul, defiles the body in this life, and casts both soul and body under the wrath of God and into the flames of hell hereafter, or at the very least ventures them recklessly onto the road of endless damnation and despair, all while treating those insufferable torments with contempt. All these elements of malignity and poison are intrinsic to sin, found in its very nature.

With the common aggravations of sin having been treated by many writers, and being easily gathered from what has already been said about its nature, I will name only a few of them briefly.

1. The infinite perfection of God in all those blessed attributes and relations that sin is set against is the greatest aggravation of sin.

2. The inconceivable glory of heaven, which is despised, is a great aggravation of sin.

3. So is the greatness of the torments of hell, which sinners despise and venture upon.

4. So is the great opposition that God has mounted against sin, having said and done so much against it, and having declared that there is nothing else in the world he immediately hates.

5. The clarity of evidence against sin, and the utter emptiness of anything that can be said for it, is also a great aggravation.

6. So is the fullness, fitness, and power of all the means, in created things, in providences, and in the Scriptures, that are granted to the world against sin.

7. So is the experience and warning of all ages: the repentance of the converted, and the near-universal disowning of sin when people come to die. It is astonishing that more than five thousand years of the world’s experience have not taught humanity more effectively to avoid so deadly and destructive a thing.

8. The nearness of sin to us is also an aggravation. It is not a distant evil but one lodged in our inward parts, in our very hearts. We are so strictly bound to love ourselves that it greatly aggravates our guilt to do ourselves so great a mischief.

9. The constant indwelling of sin is a great aggravation: it is ever with us, lying down and rising up, at home and abroad. We are never free from it.

10. That sin should poison all our common mercies and corrupt all our duties is an aggravation. But we will take up some of these points again shortly.

The special aggravations of the sins of God’s own children are these. See also the Assembly’s Larger Catechism on the aggravations of sin.

1.) They sin against a closer relationship than others do, against that God who is their Father by new birth, which is more heinous than if a stranger committed the same offense.

2.) They are Christ’s own members, and it is deeply unnatural for his members to rebel against him or to wrong him.

3.) They sin against more excellent workings of the Spirit than others experience, and against a principle of life dwelling within them.

4.) They sin against the distinguishing grace that appeared in their conversion. God took them out of a world of sinners whom he passed by, though he could just as easily have sanctified them. Should they so quickly repay him in this way?

5.) They sin against the pardon and justification they have already received. God so recently forgave all their former debts, so many, so great, and so heinous, freely to them, when the cost to Christ was so immense. Should they so soon forget, or so poorly repay, so great a mercy?

6.) They sin against a more solemn covenant than other people have entered, namely the covenant they made with God at their conversion.

7.) They sin against all the heart-breaking sorrow and humbling grief they experienced at their conversion and since. They have known more of the evil of sin than others have, through the painful experience of its sting.

8.) They sin against greater knowledge than other people possess. They have known more of what sin is, what Christ is, and what the will of God is than others have; and therefore they deserve to be beaten with many stripes.

9.) They have confessed sin more often than others, spoken of it with revulsion as the vilest of things, and aggravated it before God and man.

10.) Their many prayers against sin, and all their labor in hearing, reading, receiving the sacraments, and using other means, aggravate it further.

11.) They make a greater profession of strict obedience, and so they sin against their own profession.

12.) They have renewed their promises of obedience to God, in prayer, at the sacraments, and at other times, far more than others have.

13.) They have had more experience than others of the goodness of obedience, and of the comforts and benefits that accompany it in the favor of God and in communion with him.

14.) Their sins are aggravated by every reproof and exhortation they have addressed to others, telling them how unreasonable and wicked it is to provoke the Lord.

15.) They sin under greater hopes of glory than others do, and they provoke that very God with whom they hope to live forever.

16.) The high titles of love and praise that God gives them in his Word aggravate their sin. He calls them his treasure, his peculiar people, his jewels, the apple of his eye, his sons and daughters, a holy people, priests to God; he boasts of them as a people more excellent than their neighbors, and after all this they sin against him.

17.) They have had access to God in prayer, the answer of prayers, and many a deliverance and mercy in this life that others have not known, which aggravates their sins both as despising these gifts and as binding them to God more than others are bound.

18.) They dishonor God more than anyone else by their sins. His honor rests not so much on the actions of the ungodly as on those who are nearest to him.

19.) They harden the wicked more than the same sins committed by others would do. They cause the wicked to blaspheme and to reproach the godly on their account, saying, "These are your religious men! Now you see what their strictness amounts to." They hinder the conversion and salvation of others; they grieve the godly and wrong the church and the cause of God far more than the sins of others do.

20.) Finally, they please the devil more than the sins of other people do. How eager he was to make Job sin! And how he would have boasted against God, against grace, and against God’s servants, had he succeeded, when he had boasted so much already on the false presumption of success, as though he could make the godly forsake God and become as bad as others, if only he were given leave to tempt them.

Now I will offer some particular directions, in addition to those already given, to help you think of sin as it truly is, so that you may hate it. Your cleansing and cure consist in this: to the degree that you hate sin, it is mortified and you are cured of it. Having dissected sin so that you may see its hatefulness, I will now direct you to use this knowledge for your cure.

Direction 1: "Labor to know God, to be affected by his attributes, and always to live as in his sight." No one can know sin perfectly, because no one can know God perfectly. You can know what sin is only to the degree that you know what God is, the one against whom you sin. The formal evil of sin is relational: it consists in being set against the will and attributes of God. The godly have some knowledge of sin’s malignity because they have some knowledge of the God who is wronged by it. The wicked have no practical, prevailing knowledge of sin’s malignity because they have no such knowledge of God.

Those who fear God will fear sinning; those whose hearts are bold and irreverent toward God will be bold with sin in heart and life alike. The atheist who thinks there is no God thinks there is no sin against him. Nothing in the world will tell us so plainly and powerfully of the evil of sin as knowledge of the greatness, wisdom, goodness, holiness, authority, justice, and truth of God. A sense of his presence, therefore, will revive our sense of sin’s malignity.

Direction 2: "Consider carefully the office, the bloodshed, and the holy life of Christ." His office is to atone for sin and to destroy it. His blood was shed for it; his life condemned it. Love Christ, and you will hate what caused his death. Love him, and you will love to be made like him and hate whatever is contrary to him. These two great lights will reveal the vileness of darkness.

Direction 3: "Think carefully both about how holy the office and work of the Holy Spirit is, and about how great a mercy it is to us." Shall God himself, the heavenly light, come down into a sinful heart to illuminate and purify it, and yet shall I cling to my darkness and defilement in resistance to such wonderful mercy? Not every sin against the Holy Spirit is the unpardonable blasphemy, yet all sin is aggravated by this.

Direction 4: "Know and consider the wonderful love and mercy of God, and reflect on what he has done for you; and you will hate sin and be ashamed of it." It is an aggravation that makes sin odious even to ordinary reason and gratitude, that we should offend a God of infinite goodness who has filled our lives with mercy. You will grieve if you have wronged a dear friend: his love and kindness will come to mind and make you angry with your own unkindness. Here, look over the catalogue of God’s mercies to you, for soul and body. And here observe that Satan, by hiding the love of God from you and tempting you under the guise of humility to deny his greatest and most particular mercies, is also seeking to destroy your repentance and humiliation, by hiding the greatest aggravation of your sin.

Direction 5: "Think about what the soul of man is made for and ought to be used for, to love, obey, and glorify our Maker, and then you will see what sin is, which disables and perverts it." How excellent, exalted, and holy a work we are created and called to! Should we defile the temple of God, and serve the devil in filthiness and folly, where we ought to welcome, serve, and magnify our Creator?

Direction 6: "Think carefully about what pure and sweet delights a holy soul may enjoy from God in his holy service, and then you will see what sin is, which robs it of those delights and prefers fleshly lusts above them." How happily might we perform every duty! How fruitfully might we serve our Lord! What delight we should find in his love and acceptance, and in the foresight of everlasting blessedness, were it not for sin, which drags the soul down from the doors of heaven to wallow with swine in a beloved dunghill.

Direction 7: "Reflect on what kind of life you must live forever if you live in heaven, and what life the holy ones there are living now; and then consider whether sin, which is so contrary to that life, is not a vile and hateful thing." Either you desire to live in heaven or you do not. If not, I am not speaking to you. If you do, you know that there is no sinning there, no worldly mind, no pride, no passion, no fleshly lust or pleasures. If you could but see and hear for one hour how those blessed spirits are wholly taken up in loving and magnifying the glorious God in purity and holiness, and how utterly removed they are from sin, it would make you loathe sin ever after, and make sinners appear to you like men in Bedlam wallowing in their filth. Consider especially that you hope yourselves to live forever like those holy spirits, and therefore sin ill befits you.

Direction 8: "Look to the state and torment of the damned, and think carefully about the difference between angels and devils, and you may understand what sin truly is." Angels are pure; devils are polluted. Holiness and sin make the difference between them. Sin dwells in hell, and holiness in heaven. Remember that every temptation comes from the devil, to make you like himself, just as every holy impulse comes from Christ, to make you like himself. Remember, when you sin, that you are learning from and imitating the devil, and are in that measure becoming like him. The end of it all is that you may share his pains. If hell-fire is not good, then sin is not good. (John 8:44)

Direction 9: "Always look on sin as one who is on the point of death, and consider how all people judge of it at the last." What do those in heaven say of it? What do those in hell say of it? What do dying people say of it? What do converted souls and awakened consciences say of it? Is sin then pursued with delight and fearlessness as it is now? Is it then applauded? Will any of them speak well of it? No, all the world speaks evil of sin in general even now, while men still love and commit particular acts of it. Will you sin when you are dying?

Direction 10: "Always look on sin and judgment together." Remember that you must answer for it before God, before angels, and before all the world; and that sight will help you to know sin for what it is.

Direction 11: "Look even now upon sickness, poverty, shame, despair, death, and rottenness in the grave, and it may help you a little to understand what sin is." These are things within your sight and feeling; you need no special faith to perceive them. By such effects you may gain some knowledge of the cause.

Direction 12: "Look upon some truly holy persons on earth, and then upon the mad, profane, and malicious world; the contrast will tell you in part what sin is." Is there not something genuinely admirable in a holy, blameless person who lives in love to God and neighbor, and in the joyful hope of eternal life? Is not a beastly drunkard or fornicator, a raging swearer, a malicious persecutor, a very deformed and loathsome creature? Is not the mad, confused, ignorant, ungodly condition of the world a pitiable sight? What then must the sin be in which all of this consists?

Though the main part of the cure lies in turning the will to hate sin, and is accomplished by this exposure of its malignity, I will add a few further Directions concerning the practical side, on the assumption that what has already been said has had its proper effect.

Direction 1: "When you have identified your disease and danger, give yourself over to Christ as the Savior and Physician of souls, and to the Holy Spirit as your Sanctifier, remembering that he is both sufficient and willing to accomplish the work he has undertaken." It is not you who are to be the saviors and sanctifiers of yourselves, except insofar as you work under Christ. He who has undertaken this work takes it as his glory to complete it.

Direction 2: "You must, however, be willing and obedient in applying the remedies Christ prescribes, and in following his directions toward your cure." You must not be tender, squeamish, or fussy, saying that this remedy is too bitter or that one too sharp. Trust his love, his skill, and his care, and take what he prescribes without further complaint. Do not say it is grievous and you cannot bear it, for he commands nothing that is not safe, wholesome, and necessary. And if you cannot take the remedy, you must ask yourself whether you can bear your sickness, your death, and the fire of hell. Are humiliation, confession, restitution, mortification, and holy diligence worse than hell?

Direction 3: "Take care not to side with sin, and do not wrangle or fight against your Physician, or against those who would do you good." Making excuses for sin, pleading for it, minimizing it, resisting the Spirit and conscience, quarreling with ministers and godly friends, and hating reproof, none of these are the path to healing and sanctification.

Direction 4: "See in each of your particular sins that same malignity which you can readily see and acknowledge in sin in general." It is a gross self-deception to speak at length about the evil of sin in the abstract while seeing none of that evil in your own pride, worldliness, anger, peevishness, malice, uncharitableness, lying, backbiting, slander, or in sinning against your conscience for worldly gain or safety. What a contradiction it is for a man to magnify the evil of sin in prayer, and then justify or excuse it when he is reproved for it, or for a popish priest to enter his office sinfully by subscribing or swearing to the Tridentine Confession, and then preach zealously against sin in general, as though he had never committed so grave a crime. This is like a man who speaks against treason and the king’s enemies, yet because the traitors are his friends and kinsmen, protects them, hides them, and takes their side.

Direction 5: "Keep as far as possible from those temptations that feed and strengthen the sins you wish to overcome." Lay siege to your sins and starve them out by cutting off the food and fuel that sustains them.

Direction 6: "Live in the exercise of those graces and duties that are contrary to the sins you are most in danger of." Grace and duty are opposed to sin; they kill it and heal us of it, as fire drives out cold, or health drives out sickness.

Direction 7: "Do not listen to weakening unbelief and distrust, and do not cast away the comforts of God, which are your strength and medicine." It is not a frightened, dejected, despairing frame of mind that is best fitted to resist sin; it is the encouraging sense of God’s love and the grateful awareness of grace already received, combined with a watchful, cautious fear.

Direction 8: "Always be suspicious of carnal self-love, and guard against it." Self-love is the stronghold and fortress of sin, its common defender, ever ready to draw you into sin and to justify it. We are naturally inclined to be partial in our own case, as the story of Judah with Tamar and of David when Nathan rebuked him in a parable make plain. Our own passions, our own pride, our own harsh judgments, our own backbiting and injurious dealings, our own neglects of duty, all these seem small, excusable, even justifiable to us, though we would readily see the fault in another person, especially an enemy. And yet we should know ourselves best, and since we should love ourselves most, we should hate our own sins most.

Direction 9: "Give your first and greatest effort to killing sin at the root, to cleansing the heart, which is the fountain, since it is from the heart that the evils of life flow out." Identify the chief root-sins, and direct your greatest care and effort to mortifying them. They are principally these that follow: 1. Ignorance. 2. Unbelief. 3. Thoughtlessness. 4. Selfishness and Pride. 5. Fleshly indulgence, the appetite for brutal pleasures, lust, or fantasy. 6. Senseless hardness of heart and spiritual sleep in sin.

Direction 10: "Count the world and all its pleasures, wealth, and honors as no better than they truly are, and then Satan will find no bait with which to catch you." Esteem all things as rubbish with Paul, and no one will sin and sell his soul for what he counts as rubbish.

Direction 11: "Keep a heavenly mind and way of life, and your soul will always be in the light and, as it were, in the sight of God, taken up with those concerns and delights that make the baits of sin tasteless to you."

Direction 12: "Let Christian watchfulness be your daily practice, and cherish a preserving, though not a paralyzing or discouraging, fear."

Direction 13: "Guard against the first approaches and beginnings of sin. How great a fire a little spark can kindle! And if you fall, rise quickly through genuine repentance, whatever it may cost you."

Direction 14: "Make God’s Word your only rule, and labor diligently to understand it."

Direction 15: "In doubtful cases, do not lightly depart from the unanimous judgment of the great majority of the wisest and most godly people across all ages."

Direction 16: "In doubtful cases, do not act with passion or haste, but proceed deliberately, and examine things carefully before you commit to them."

Direction 17: "Understand your own bodily constitution, and which sin it most inclines you toward; consider also which sins your calling or your company lay you most open to, so that your watchfulness may be strictest exactly there. (I will speak of all this more fully under the next Grand Direction.)"

Direction 18: "Keep to a life of holy order, such as God has appointed you to walk in, for there is no protection for stragglers who break rank and forsake the order God has commanded." This order rests chiefly on these points:

1.) Keep yourself in union with the universal church. Separate from Christ’s body on no pretense whatever. With the church as regenerate, hold spiritual communion in faith, love, and holiness; with the church as gathered and visible, hold outward communion in profession and worship.

2.) If you are not a teacher, live under your particular faithful pastors as an obedient disciple of Christ.

3.) Let the most godly people be your closest companions, wherever possible.

4.) Be diligent in an outward calling.

Direction 19: "Turn all of God’s providences, whether of prosperity or adversity, against your sins." If he gives you health and wealth, remember that he thereby lays an obligation on you to obedience, and calls for special service from you. If he afflicts you, remember that it is sin he is offended by and searching out; receive his affliction therefore as his medicine, and see to it that you do not hinder its work but help it on, so that it may purge away your sin.

Direction 20: "Wait patiently on Christ until he has completed the cure, which will not be until this life of trial is finished." Persevere in attending to his Spirit and his means, for he will come in due season and will not delay. "Then shall we know, if we follow on to know the Lord: his going forth is prepared as the morning, and he shall come unto us as the rain, as the latter and former rain unto the earth." (Hos 6:3) Though you have often said, "There is no healing" (Jer 14:19), he will heal your backslidings and love you freely (Hos 14:4). "Unto you that fear his name shall the Sun of Righteousness arise with healing in his wings" (Mal 4:2); "and blessed are all they that wait for him" (Isa 30:18).

With this I have given such Directions as may help toward humiliation under sin, hatred of it, and deliverance from it.

CHAPTER 31

GRAND DIRECTION 9: WAGE A VIGILANT WAR AGAINST THE FLESH, THE WORLD, AND THE DEVIL

 

‘Spend all your days in a skillful, vigilant, resolute, and valiant war against the flesh, the world, and the devil, as those who have covenanted to follow Christ, the Captain of your Salvation.’

The flesh is the end of temptation, for all temptation aims at pleasing it, and therefore the flesh is the greatest enemy. The world is the matter of temptation, and the devil is its first mover and efficient cause. These three are the trinity of enemies to Christ and to us, which we renounce in baptism and must constantly resist. Of the world and the flesh I shall speak in chapter iv. Here I shall open the devil’s methods. First, I will prepare your understanding by setting out some foundational truths.

1. It is presupposed that there is a devil. Whoever does not believe this only proves it to others by showing how grossly the devil can make a fool of him. Apparitions, witchcrafts, and temptations are full proof of it to the senses, quite apart from what Scripture says.

2. It is presupposed that the devil is the deadly enemy of Christ and of us. He was once an angel who fell from his first estate through sin, and a multitude of evil spirits fell with him. His envy against mankind was probably all the greater because he knew we were made to succeed him and his followers in their state of glory, for Christ says that we shall "be equal with the angels." He showed his enmity toward humanity in our innocence, and by his temptation caused our fall and misery.

Yet after the fall, God placed a natural enmity in humanity against devils as a merciful protection against temptation: just as human nature universally recoils from serpents, so the soul recoils from and dreads the diabolical nature. Because of this, wherever the devil is recognized in a temptation, that temptation is frustrated, until the enmity in our nature is overcome by his deceits. This is a protection our nature now has against temptation that it apparently lacked before the fall, since before the fall we did not know the devil’s malice against us.

There is a natural enmity to the devil himself placed in all the natural seed of the woman; but the moral enmity against his sinful temptations and works is placed only in the spiritual seed by the Holy Ghost (apart from whatever remnants persist in the light of nature). I will be brief on all of this and the next point, having treated them more fully in my Treatise against Infidelity, Part III.

The devil’s names reveal what he is. In the Old Testament he is called:

1. The ‘Serpent,’ (Gen 3);

2. The Hebrew word translated ‘devils’ in Leviticus 17:7 and Isaiah 13:21 means ‘hairy,’ as satyrs are described, and sometimes ‘he-goats,’ because he often appeared in such forms;

3. ‘Satan,’ (Zech 3:1);

4. ‘An evil Spirit,’ (1 Sam 18:10);

5. ‘A lying Spirit,’ (1 Kgs 22:22), for "he is a liar, and the father of lies," (John 8:44);

6. His offspring is called ‘A Spirit of uncleanness,’ (Zech 13:2);

7. He (or his spawn) is called ‘A Spirit of fornication,’ (Hos 4:12), meaning idolatry;

8. ‘A perverse Spirit, causing staggering and giddiness as in a drunken man,’ (Isa 19:14).

In the New Testament:

1. He is sometimes called simply ‘A Spirit,’ (Mark 9:20, 26; Luke 9:39; Luke 10:20);

2. Sometimes Pneumata Akatharta, ‘unclean Spirits,’ (Luke 6:18), as contrary to the Holy Spirit, both by their nature and their effects;

3. Daimonion, ‘Demons,’ a word used in a good sense by heathen writers but not in Scripture, because they worshipped devils under that name (with the possible exception of Acts 17:18; 1 Timothy 4:1); and Daimon, with respect to their knowledge, and, as some think, to the knowledge promised to Adam in the temptation, see Pool’s Synopsis Criticorum on Leviticus 17; in these latter passages the word ‘Spirit’ signifies the evil disposition that Satan as tempter produces, and by it he is recognized as the source;

4. Peirazon, ‘The Tempter,’ (Matt 4);

5. ‘Satan,’ (Matt 4; 1 Pet 5:8);

6. Echthros, ‘An Enemy,’ (Matt 13:28, 39);

7. ‘The strong man armed,’ (Matt 12);

8. ‘Angels’, (1 Cor 6:3; 2 Pet 2:4), ‘Angels which kept not their first state,’ (Jude 6);

9. ‘A Spirit of divination,’ (Acts 16:16);

10. ‘A roaring lion,’ (1 Pet 5:8);

11. ‘A murderer,’ (John 8:44);

12. ‘Belial,’ (2 Cor 6:15);

13. ‘Beelzebub,’ (Matt 12), the ‘god of flies’;

14. ‘The prince of this world,’ (John 12:31), from his power over wicked men;

15. ‘The god of this world,’ (2 Cor 4:4), because the world obeys him;

16. ‘The prince of the power of the air,’ (Eph 2:2);

17. ‘The ruler of the darkness of this world,’ and ‘Principalities and powers,’ (Eph 6:12);

18. ‘The father of the wicked,’ (John 8:44);

19. ‘The dragon, and the old serpent,’ (Rev 12);

20. Diabolos, ‘the calumniator’ or ‘false accuser,’ frequently;

21. Ho Poneros, ‘the evil one,’ (Matt 13:19);

22. ‘An evil spirit,’ (Acts 19:15);

23. Apolluon, ‘the destroyer,’ and ‘Abaddon,’ the ‘king of the locusts,’ and ‘angel of the bottomless pit,’ (Rev 9:11), unless that passage speaks of Antichrist.

3. The devil is too strong an enemy for fallen, sinful humanity to deal with unaided. If he conquered us in innocence, what may he not do now? He is dangerous: (1.) by the greatness of his subtlety; (2.) by the greatness of his power; (3.) by the greatness of his malice; and from these, (4.) by his constant diligence, watching while we sleep, (Matt 13:25), and "seeking night and day to devour," (1 Pet 5:8; Rev 12:4).

4. Therefore Christ has engaged himself in our cause and has become the "Captain of our salvation," (Heb 2:10). The world is formed into two armies that stand in continual war: the devil is the prince and general of one, and his angels and wicked men are his army; Christ is the King and general of the other, and his angels (Heb 2:14) and saints are his army. Between these two armies the greatest conflicts in the world are fought.

5. This war is carried on, on both sides, both within us and without us, by inward solicitations and by outward means fitted to them.

6. Both Christ and Satan work through officers, instruments, and means. Christ has his ministers to preach his Gospel and pull down the kingdom of Satan. Satan has his ministers to preach licentiousness and lies, and to resist the Gospel and kingdom of Christ, (1 Cor 3:5; 1 Cor 4:1; 2 Cor 2:15; Acts 13:8–10). Christ has his church, and the devil has his synagogue. Christ’s soldiers each fight for him against the devil in their respective places. The devil’s soldiers each fight against Christ in their respective places. Both generals are unseen by mortal eyes, and the unseen power belongs to each of them, but their agents are visible. The soldiers fight not only against the opposing generals but against one another, though it is all, or chiefly, for the generals’ sake. It is Christ whom the wicked persecute in his servants, (Acts 9:4); and it is the devil whom the godly hate and resist in the wicked.

Yet there are several striking differences.

1. The devil’s servants do what they do not out of love for him, but out of love for their own flesh; Christ’s servants act out of love for him as well as for themselves.

2. The devil’s army is deceived into taking up arms, not knowing what they are doing; Christ does everything in the open light and will have no servants except those who deliberately commit to him knowing the worst.

3. The devil’s servants do not know that he is their general; all of Christ’s followers know their Lord.

4. The devil’s followers disown their master and their work, they will not acknowledge that they are fighting against Christ and his kingdom even as they do it; but Christ’s followers own their Captain, his cause, and his work, for he is not a master to be ashamed of.

7. Both Christ and Satan work persuasively, by moral means, and neither by constraint or force. Christ does not force men against their wills to do good, and Satan cannot force them to do evil; all the effort on both sides is to make men willing. The victor is the one who wins and keeps our own consent.

8. Their ends are contrary, and so their ways are also contrary. The devil’s end is to draw humanity to sin and damnation and to dishonor God; Christ’s end is to draw humanity from sin to holiness and salvation and to honor God. But Christ makes his end known, while Satan conceals his end from his followers.

9. There is something within both the good and the wicked that the opposing side can work upon: we are, in a sense, divided within ourselves, with something in us on both sides. The wicked retain an honorable acknowledgment of God and of their greatest obligations to him; a hatred of the devil; love of themselves; a desire to be happy and an unwillingness to be miserable; and a conscience that approves of more good than they actually do and condemns much of their transgression. This gives the ministers of Christ something to work with in persuasion, and these people have a reason capable of knowing more.

Christ’s soldiers, on the other hand, retain a fleshly appetite and the remnants of ignorance and error in their minds, of earthliness and carnality and aversion to God in their wills, along with a closeness to this world and much unfamiliarity with the world to come. Here Satan finds far too much material to work upon through his temptations.

10. But it is the predominant part within us, and the overall direction of our lives, that shows which army we belong to. We must therefore give up our names and hearts to Christ, enlist under his command against the devil, and fight to the death if we are to be saved. The fight is not against the bare name of the devil, for even his own soldiers will spit at his name and hang a witch who makes a contract with him, but against his cause and work, which means fighting against the world and the flesh and for the glory of God.

In opening up this holy war for you, I will, First, show what we must do on the offensive, and Second, what on the defensive. Under the defensive I will show: I. What the tempter aims at as his end. II. What matter and ground he works upon. III. What reinforcements and assistance he has. IV. What kind of officers and instruments he uses. V. What his methods and actual temptations are, 1. To actual sin; 2. Against our duty to God.

First. Our offensive arms are to be used:

1. Against the power of sin within us, and all its advantages and supports, for while Satan rules and possesses us inwardly, we will never successfully oppose him outwardly.

2. Against sin in others, as far as we have opportunity.

3. Against the credit and honor of sin in the world. As the devil’s servants work to bring light and holiness into disgrace, so Christ’s servants must cast disgrace and shame upon sin and darkness.

4. Against all the reasonings of sinners, and their subtle sophistries by which they would deceive.

5. Against the passions and violent lusts that are the causes of men’s other sins.

6. Against the strongholds and supports of sin, such as false teachers, profane revilers, ignorance, and deceit. Only take care not to step out of our proper ranks and places on this pretext, pulling down the powers of the world through rebellion, for "the weapons of our warfare are not carnal."

Second. Regarding our defense:

I. The ends the tempter pursues, which must be understood, are these.

1. In general, his aim is at our utter ruin and damnation, and to lead us here to dishonor God as much as possible. But his particular aim is to strengthen the great heart-sins, which are the most deadly and are the root, life, and source of all the rest. These are especially:

1.) Ignorance, which is the friend and cloak of all the rest.

2.) Error, which will justify them.

3.) Unbelief, which keeps away everything that should oppose them.

4.) Atheism, profaneness, and unholiness, which are open defiance of God and all his armies.

5.) Presumption, which emboldens the sinner and conceals the danger.

6.) Hardness of heart, which fortifies the sinner against all the forces of grace.

7.) Hypocrisy, which makes its practitioners serve Satan as spies and informants within the army of Christ.

8.) Disaffection toward God, his ways, and his servants, which is the devil’s own colors.

9.) Ingratitude, which tends to make sinners unreconcilable and unrecoverable.

10.) Pride, which commands many regiments of lesser sins.

11.) Worldliness, or love of money and wealth, which keeps Satan’s armies in pay.

12.) Sensuality, voluptuousness, and flesh-pleasing, which is the great commander of all the rest, for selfishness is the devil’s lieutenant-general, consisting chiefly in these last three, but especially in pride and sensuality.

Some think it is outward sins that bring all the danger; but these twelve heart-sins are the twelve gates of the infernal city, which Satan prizes above all the rest.

II. The matter and grounds of his temptations are these.

1. The devil first works upon the outward senses, and through them upon the sensitive appetite. He shows the cup to the drunkard’s eye; he dangles the bait of filthy lust before the fornicator; he displays the riches and pomp of the world to the covetous and the proud. The glutton tastes the sweetness of the dish he loves. Stage-plays, enticing sports, proud attire, sumptuous buildings, and all such sensual things are the baits by which the devil angles for souls. So Eve first saw the fruit, then tasted, then ate. So Noah, Lot, and David sinned. So Achan says, "I saw (the garments, silver, and gold) I coveted them, and I took them" (Josh 7:21). The senses are the door of sin.

2. The tempter next works on the imagination, and prints upon it the most attractive image of his bait that he possibly can, engaging the sinner to dwell on it and turn it over and over in his mind, just as God commands us to meditate on his precepts.

3. Next, through the imagination, he works upon the passions and affections. Inflamed by the imagination, these violently press the will and reason, working according to the nature of the passion, whether fear or hope, sorrow or joy, love or hatred, desire or aversion. Yet none is more dangerous in his hands than delight, love, and desire for sensual things.

4. From there he moves to infect the will, working through the simple perception of the understanding, making it cling inordinately to temporal good and neglect its proper function of directing the understanding to meditate on preserving objects and to draw the thoughts away from forbidden things. The will neglects to govern the thoughts and passions as it is its office and natural power to do.

5. And so he corrupts the understanding itself, first causing it to neglect its duty, then leading it to embrace deceit and approve of evil. The servant is thus placed in charge, and the governing powers become its instruments. Reason is blinded by sensuality and passion, becomes their servant, and pleads their cause.

From all this, three things are clear.

1.) Satan’s first bait is ordinarily some good perceived by the senses or merely imagined, set against true spiritual good.

2.) His first assault on reason and will is to tempt them into a sluggish neglect and neutrality, to omit that restraint of sense, thought, and passion that was their proper duty.

3.) And lastly, he tempts them into actual compliance and the commission of the sin. In this process: first, the bait he uses on the understanding is always "some appearance of truth," his craft is to color falsehood and make it seem like truth, for this is how the mind is deceived. For a sinner to plead his mistake as an excuse, saying "I thought it was otherwise; I thought it was no sin, or no duty," is to confess rather than excuse. It amounts to saying, "My understanding sinned along with my will, and was deceived and overcome by the tempter." Second, the bait he uses with the will is always some apparent good: self-love and the love of good is the principle he corrupts and makes his working ground, just as God also uses it in drawing us toward good.

III. The reinforcements and chief resources of the devil are these.

1. He does what he can to make an ill-tempered body serve his side, for as sin originally brought bodily disorders, so those disorders greatly support the very sin that caused them. A choleric temperament greatly assists him in drawing people to passion, malice, murder, cruelty, and revenge. A temperament that is sanguine and bilious helps him draw people to lust, filthiness, levity, wantonness, and time-wasting pleasures. A sanguine temperament mixed with phlegm greatly helps him make people dull, heedless, and insensible to the great concerns of the soul. A phlegmatic temperament helps him draw people to drowsy sluggishness, an idle and slothful life, and so to dishonest means to maintain it, and to reluctance toward every good work. A healthful temperament greatly helps him draw people to gluttony, drunkenness, lust, ambition, covetousness, and neglect of eternal life. A sickly temperament helps him tempt people to peevishness and impatience. And a melancholy temperament assists him in all the temptations just mentioned.

2. He uses his greatest skill to secure the strongest fleshly interests for his side, so that sinning becomes a matter of great pleasure, advancement, honor, and applause, or great material gain, while refusing to sin, or choosing to be holy and obedient to God, becomes a matter of great suffering, disgrace, and loss. Since fleshly interest is the common currency of all his temptations, his main business is to magnify it as much as possible.

3. He makes very great use of the common customs of the country in which people live. This carries away thousands and millions at once. When the common vote and custom favor sin and oppose Christ and holiness, individuals think themselves excused on the grounds that they are no wiser or better than everyone around them. They feel considerably safer sinning in so large a crowd and doing only what most people do. Anyone who contradicts them appears at a great disadvantage in their eyes, since he must oppose an army of adversaries and seems to think himself wiser than so many.

4. He is also exceptionally industrious in securing education for his side. He knows how readily people retain the shape into which they were first molded. If he gains first possession, through actual as well as original sin, he is not easily dislodged. When education conspires with common custom, it delivers most of the people and kingdoms of the earth into his hands.

5. He is also industrious in securing the approved doctrine of the teachers of the people. If he can once establish something as a revelation or command of God, he quickly conquers conscience by it and removes all resistance. He never wages war against God more successfully than when he carries the name of God in his colors and fights against him in his own name. Mahometans, Jews, Papists, and all heretics are the trophies and monuments of his victories by this method. Mischief is never so widely revered, nor does it proceed so successfully, as when it is made into a religion.

When the devil can charge people to do his work in the name of God, under pain of damnation, he has obtained the most powerful weapons he can ever wield. His ordinary bait is some fleshly pleasure; but he reaches the highest extreme when he presumes to offer everlasting pleasures. He tempted Christ with all the kingdoms and glory of the world; but he tempts many millions of souls with the offer of the kingdom of heaven itself, holding it out as bait to those he is laboring to keep from it, in order to draw them away from it and into the way to hell.

6. He is exceedingly diligent in securing the wealth and prosperity of the world for his side, so that he may appear not to flatter his servants with empty promises, but to reward them with real, visible prosperity. He then persuades the sinner that it is Christ who is the deceiver, promising a kingdom that none of his followers has ever seen and that he will not deliver, while he himself does not deceive, but makes good on his promises in this life, without delay. His followers see with their own eyes the things he promises, and they hold them in their hands, with no room for uncertainty about being deceived.

7. He is exceedingly industrious in securing common fame and reputation for his side, so that he can keep his cause in good standing and keep the cause of Christ and holiness in disgrace. He knows how extremely prone people are to go in the way that brings honor and praise from most people, and how reluctant they are to walk the path that is hated and spoken against by the majority.

8. He is very diligent in securing the sword and government of kingdoms, states, countries, cities, and corporations for his side. He knows that the ignorant and common people are extremely prone to adopt the religion of those who have power to help or harm them, and to follow the stronger side. He also knows that the will and example of the ruler acts as the first plate or stamp from which all the rest are printed. He therefore does his worst to place the greatest power in the most ungodly hands. If the emperor is a Turk, most of the common people will quickly become Turks; if their king is a Papist, most of them are likely to become Papists. Look at the present condition of the Heathen, Infidel, Mahometan, Papal, and profane parts of the world, and at the history of every age past, and you will see with grief and astonishment how much the devil has gained by this strategy.

9. He is also very eager to secure our companions and those in our immediate society, people who are near to us and have frequent opportunities to help or harm us. From long and wide experience he knows how powerfully they draw others along, and how often they succeed.

10. He is also very industrious in securing our friends who have authority over us and the greatest hold on us. When he has won them, he has already taken our outer defenses.

11. Finally, he sometimes desires to secure the name and appearance of virtue and piety for his side, so that those doing his work may carry a winning manner, a venerable reputation, and the cloak of virtue, all in the service of advancing the destruction of piety itself.

IV. By what has been said, you can now understand what kinds of officers and instruments the tempter employs.

1. He commonly uses people who are themselves first deceived and corrupted, as fitting instruments to deceive and corrupt others. They carry out his work with confidence and force; the employment comes naturally to them, they are so well suited to it. They are willing to bring others around to their view, and to have company along their path. A drunkard is fit to make a drunkard; a fornicator to entice another into that sin; a gambler to make a gambler; a wanton waster of time to draw another into vain amusements; an ambitious or proud person is fit to kindle that fire in others; a swearer is best suited to make a swearer; and so on with many other sins.

2. The devil usually chooses instruments who have no great tenderness of conscience, no great fear of sinning, and no great concern about ruining souls. He wants no such cowards in his army as God-fearing people would be for his purposes. He needs men who will venture into hell themselves and fear little for the loss of their own souls, and who are therefore not overly tender about destroying others. Butchers and soldiers must not be chosen from too gentle or loving a stock; such people are not suited to carry his work through.

3. He usually chooses instruments most deeply committed to his cause, those whose advancement, honor, gain, and carnal interest drive them as instinct drives a dog, wolf, fox, or other predatory creature; who regard it as a loss, a danger, or a personal injury if others are not hindered in doing good, or are not brought down to their own level.

So Demetrius and the craftsmen who made their living from the trade were the most fitting advocates for Diana’s cause and the most fitting men to stir up the crowd against the apostles (Acts 19:24, 38, 39). The Jews were the most fitting instruments to persecute Christ, since they feared that if they "let him alone, all men would believe on him, and the Romans would come and take away both their place and nation; and that it was expedient for them that one man die for the people, and that the whole nation perish not" (John 11:48, 50). Pilate was the most fitting instrument to condemn him, fearing that otherwise he would be regarded as no friend of Caesar’s. And Pharaoh was the most fitting instrument to persecute the Israelites, standing to lose so much by their departure.

4. When he can, he chooses instruments who are close to us and nearest to us, who have the opportunity to speak to us frequently when others have no chance to help us. The fire nearest to wood or thatch is more likely to set it alight than fire at a distance. Nearness and opportunity are very great advantages.

5. When possible, he chooses instruments with the greatest abilities to serve him. One person of sharp wit, learning, and eloquence, one who can dispute nimbly and make almost any cause seem sound when defending it, or flawed when attacking it, can do more service for the devil than a hundred who lack those gifts.

6. When possible, he chooses the rulers of the world as his instruments, those who can command others and threaten them with imprisonment, banishment, confiscation, or death if they refuse to sin, as the king of Babylon did to the three witnesses and to Daniel (Dan 3 and 6), and as persecutors have done in every age against the holy seed. For the devil knows that, though not with a Job, yet with a carnal person, "skin for skin, and all that a man hath will he give for his life." Those who hold power over life, liberty, and property therefore have carnal people by a handle that will govern them.

7. He makes the rich his instruments: those who, holding the wealth of the world, are able to reward and hire evildoers, and to oppress those who refuse to please them. Landlords and wealthy men can do the devil more service than many of the poor, they are the Judases who carry the bag. Just as an ox follows the one who carries the hay, a horse the one who carries the feed, a dog the one who feeds it, and a crow goes where the carrion lies, so carnal people follow and obey the one who holds the purse.

8. When he can, the devil makes those his instruments whom he sees we most admire and respect, people we consider wisest and most fit to be our advisers. We will accept from them what we would be suspicious of coming from others.

9. He will enlist our own relatives and those who hold our hearts most deeply to serve as his instruments. A husband, a wife, or a Delilah can do more than anyone else; so can a close friend whom we dearly love. When all their claim upon our affections is pressed into the devil’s service, it can accomplish a great deal. This is why we see that husbands and wives who love each other deeply almost always settle into the same religion, opinion, or way of life, even when they differed from each other when they first married.

10. As often as he can, the devil makes the multitude his instrument, so that the crowd and its noise carry people along, make them bold, and take away their fear of punishment.

11. He is very eager to make the ambassadors of Christ his captives, and to hire them to speak against their Master’s cause, so that in Christ’s name they deceive the trusting flock, "speaking perverse things to draw away disciples after them" (Acts 20:30). Sometimes this works through a pretense of Christ’s authority and commission, leading poor people to believe that refusing to hear and obey these ministers in their errors is to be a disobedient rejecter of Christ, and this is how the Romish party carry it. Sometimes it works through talent and plausible, persuasive speech; and sometimes through sheer fervor, which frightens people into error. By these two means most heretics prevail. No one serves Satan so effectively as a false or corrupt minister of Christ.

12. He is exceedingly eager to make parents themselves his instruments for their children’s sin and ruin, and how often he succeeds. He knows that parents have their children in hand during the most pliable and impressionable years of life, and that they possess almost every advantage at once. They hold the purse and control their children’s portion; they command the interest of love, reverence, and esteem; they are constantly present and can solicit their children repeatedly; they hold the rod and can compel obedience. Many thousands are in hell through the agency of their own parents, those who are first such cruel destroyers of their own children’s souls become monsters to the souls of others as well. If the devil can get parents to be cursers, swearers, gamblers, drunkards, worldly-minded, proud, or scornful mockers of a holy life, what a snare this becomes for their poor children.

V. In Satan’s method, the next thing to consider is how he labors to drive off all the forces of Christ that should resist him and destroy his work, how he works to frustrate their efforts and fortify his own position. Among many means he uses, these are the most notable:

1. He does what he can to weaken even natural reason, so that people become dull and incapable of receiving good. It is grievous to observe how hard it is to make some people either understand or care. A brutish kind of upbringing contributes greatly to this, as does long habit in sensual ways, both can effectively reduce people to the level of brutes.

2. He does what he can to prevent parents and masters from doing their part in instructing and admonishing children and servants, and from dealing wisely and earnestly with them for their salvation. Either he will keep parents and masters ignorant and incapable, or he will make them wicked and unwilling, perhaps even driving them to oppose their children in everything good, or he will make them like Eli: slack, negligent, indifferent, formal, cold, and dull, and so keep them from saving their children’s or servants’ souls.

3. He does everything in his power to keep the sinner in security, presumption, and insensibility, effectively asleep in sin. To that end, he works to keep the sinner quiet and in the dark, away from any light or noise that might awaken him, so that he may live as though there were no God, no Christ, no heaven, no soul, nothing worth attending to. His chief concern is to keep the sinner from ever reflecting seriously. He therefore keeps the sinner constantly in company, amusement, or business, and will not allow him to be often alone or to retire into a sober conference with his own conscience or serious thought about the life to come.

4. He does his best to keep searching, lively ministers out of the area or out of a given place altogether, and to silence them where any such exist, keeping the sinner under some ignorant or spiritually dead minister who lacks in himself the faith, repentance, life, love, holiness, and zeal he ought to be a means of producing in others. And the devil will go to the utmost lengths to draw such a man into leading others into sin.

5. He does his worst to make ministers weak and to disgrace Christ’s cause by their bungling and unskillful handling of it, so that no one stands up against sin except unlearned or half-witted men who can scarcely speak sense, and who provoke contempt or laughter in their hearers.

6. He does his worst to make ministers scandalous, so that when they speak to people about their sin and duty, people will assume such ministers do not mean what they say, do not themselves believe it, or regard it as no great matter, as something said merely for custom, reputation, or pay. And so the people, seeing the wicked lives of the preachers, are emboldened to disobey their doctrine, to imitate them, and to live without repentance.

7. He labors to heap reproaches and slanders upon the most able ministers, slanders that thousands will hear who never hear the truth spoken in those ministers’ defense. By making them odious, he ensures that people receive no more good from their preaching than they would from a Turk or a Jew, unless the truth itself prevails by its own force. To this end especially, he does everything he can to stoke continual divisions in the church. While every party is engaged against the others, the interests of their several causes lead them to think it necessary to make their chief opponents seem odious or contemptible to the people, so that those opponents cannot harm their cause or faction. In this way they disable the ablest ministers from serving Christ and saving souls, by the same means they use to protect themselves from those ministers’ influence.

8. He does what he can to keep the most holy ministers under persecution, so that they become like a wounded deer that the rest of the herd shuns, or like a dog set upon by all the others, or so that people fear to hear them, lest they suffer alongside them, or will come to them only as Nicodemus came to Christ, by night.

9. Or if any ministers or godly persons do warn the sinner, the devil will do what he can to ensure they are so few in number compared to those of the contrary mind that he can whisper to the sinner: "Do you think these few self-conceited fellows are wiser than such-and-such, and all the country? Shall none be saved but such a small, precise group?", "Do any of the Rulers or of the Pharisees believe in him? But this people that knoweth not the law are cursed" (John 7:48, 49). That is, as Dr. Hammond notes, "This illiterate multitude are apt to be seduced, but the teachers are wiser."

10. The devil does his worst to create some falling-out, difference of interest, or difference of opinion between the preacher or counselor and the sinner, so that the sinner will regard the preacher as an enemy. Experience will easily convince you how unlikely people are to receive advice from someone they see as an adversary.

11. He works to ensure that powerful preaching is rare and that wicked cavillers contradict it so frequently that the sermon is forgotten, or its impressions erased, before the sinner can hear another to confirm them and drive the point home, so that the fire goes out before the next opportunity arrives.

12. He labors to keep good books out of the sinner’s hands, or to keep the sinner from reading them, lest he fare as the eunuch in Acts 8 who was reading Scripture as he rode in his chariot on the way. In place of such books, the devil puts romances, plays, and trifling or mocking, contradictory writings into the sinner’s hands.

13. He does what he can to prevent the sinner from any close acquaintance with truly godly people, so that the sinner knows them only through the portrait that ignorant or malicious slanderers and scorners paint of them, and knows religion itself only by hearsay, never seeing it lived out in holy, diligent believers. A holy Christian is a living image of God, a powerful convincer and teacher of the ungodly; the closer people draw to such a person, the greater excellence they will see and the greater effect they will feel. In the devil’s army, by contrast, most must not be seen in open light, and even the hypocrite must be viewed like a painting, only by a side-light, never directly.

14. Whatever means are used, the devil labors to frustrate them:

1.) By sluggish heedlessness and disregard.

2.) By prejudice and false opinions that take prior possession of the mind.

3.) By diversions of many kinds.

4.) By prior commitments to a contrary interest and way, so that Christ comes too late for them.

5.) By worldly prosperity and pleasures.

6.) By bad company.

7.) By troubling and frightening the sinner whenever he begins to form any purpose of conversion, giving him ease and contentment while he remains in sin, but raising storms and terrors in his soul the moment he turns toward repentance.

The Methods of Christ against the Tempter

 

Before proceeding to Satan’s particular temptations, I will set out the contrary methods Christ uses in leading his army and opposing Satan.

I. Christ’s ultimate ends are the glory and pleasure of his Father and himself, the saving of his church, and the destruction of the devil’s kingdom; and subordinately, the purifying of his own people and the calling home of all who are ordained to eternal life.

More particularly, he looks chiefly at the heart, intending to plant there: 1. Holy knowledge. 2. Faith. 3. Godliness, or holy devotedness to God and love to him above all. 4. Thankfulness. 5. Obedience. 6. Humility. 7. Heavenly-mindedness. 8. Love to others. 9. Self-denial, mortification, and contentment. 10. Patience. And in all these: 1. Sincerity; 2. Tenderness of heart; 3. Zeal, holy strength, and resolution. Together with these, he aims to make us actively serviceable and diligent in our Master’s work, for our own salvation and the salvation of others.

II. Christ’s order in working is direct, not reversed as the devil’s is. He first reveals saving truth to the understanding and moves the will by showing the goodness of the things revealed. These then engage the thoughts, the passions, the senses, and the whole body, bringing the lower faculties into obedience and gradually casting out the images that had deceived and taken possession of them.

The matter Christ presents to the soul is:

1. Certain truth from the Father of lights, set against the prince and kingdom of darkness, ignorance, error, and deceit.

2. Spiritual and everlasting good, God himself, to be seen, loved, and enjoyed forever, set against the tempter’s temporal, bodily, and illusory good. Christ’s kingdom and work advance by light: he promotes all useful knowledge, and therefore promotes clear and convincing preaching, the reading of Scripture in a known tongue, meditating on it day and night, and the daily mutual exhortation of believers, all of which Satan opposes.

III. The means by which Christ works against Satan include the following.

1.) Sometimes he makes use of the body’s very constitution as a preparation; and being Lord of all, he grants a temperament that will best serve the soul, sober, deliberate, meek, quiet, and patient in disposition. But sometimes he honors his grace by the conquest of sins that even bodily constitution would entertain and cherish.

2.) Sometimes by his providence he removes the occasion of temptations so that they will not be too strong for weak souls; but sometimes his grace turns them all to advantage, and leaves them in place for the magnifying of its repeated victories.

3.) Sometimes he gives his cause the majority among the people, so that it becomes a mark of shameful singularity not to be a professed Christian; and sometimes, though very rarely, the same is true of the life of godliness and the practice of Christianity. But ordinarily, in most parts of the world, custom and the multitude are against him, and his grace is honored by prevailing against these forces of Satan.

4.) He makes his ministers his principal instruments, qualifying, disposing, and calling them to his work, helping them in it, and prospering it in their hands.

5.) He makes it the duty of every Christian to play his part in carrying on the work, and furnishes each with love, compassion, knowledge, and zeal in their respective measure.

6.) He lays a very strict charge on parents to devote their children, together with themselves, to God, encouraging them with the promise that he will accept and bless them; and he commands parents to teach their children the word of God with the greatest diligence, and to bring them up in the nurture and fear of God.

7.) He gives princes and magistrates their power to promote his kingdom, protect his servants, encourage the good, suppress iniquity, and advance obedience to his laws, though in most of the world they turn his enemies, and he carries on his work without them and against their cruel, persecuting opposition.

8.) His light exposes the nakedness of the devil’s cause, and among the children of light it is odious and a common shame. As "wisdom is justified of her children," so the judgment of holy men condemning sin does much to keep sin in check in the world.

9.) His providence ordinarily places the sinner he intends to benefit within the fellowship of his holy church and the familiar company and acquaintance of the godly, who can help him through instruction, affection, and example.

10.) His providence fits all circumstances to the sinner’s good, and is especially effective through well-timed, rousing afflictions. These are the means he ordinarily uses; but the powerful inward operations of his Spirit give efficacy to them all.

Temptations to Particular Sins, with Directions for Preservation and Remedy

 

In Chapter 1, Part 2, I examined the temptations that hinder sinners from conversion to God. I now proceed to those that draw people into particular sins. Satan’s art is exercised here in two ways: 1. In fitting his baits to particular uses; and 2. In applying them accordingly.

Temptation 1. The devil fits his temptations to the sinner’s age. The same bait does not suit everyone. Children he tempts to excessive playfulness, lying, disobedience, unwillingness to learn the things that belong to their salvation, and insensibility to the great concerns of their souls. He tempts youth to wantonness, rudeness, gluttony, unruliness, and foolish thoughtlessness. At the onset of manhood he tempts to lust, sensuality, and luxury; or, if these do not take hold, to schemes of worldliness and ambition. The aged he tempts to covetousness, immovability in their errors, unteachableness, and obstinacy in their ignorance and sin. Thus every age has its own snare.

Direction 1. The remedy against this is:

1.) To be distinctly acquainted with the temptations of your own age, and to watch against them with special heedfulness and fear.

2.) To know the special duties and advantages of your own age, and to turn your thoughts fully toward them. Scripture has various precepts for various ages; study the part that belongs to you. The young have more time to learn their duty and fewer cares and responsibilities to divert them, let them therefore give themselves fully to learning in obedience. Those in middle age have the greatest vigor of body and mind, and should therefore do their Master’s work with the greatest vigor, activity, and zeal. The aged should possess the most judgment, experience, and familiarity with death and heaven, and should therefore teach the younger both by word and by holy example.

Temptation 2. The tempter also fits his temptations to people’s different bodily temperaments. The hot-blooded and strong he tempts to lust. The melancholy and fearful he tempts to discouragement, continual self-torment, and fear of men and devils. Those with strong appetites he tempts to gluttony and drunkenness. Children, women, and the weak-minded he tempts to vanity in dress and trivial social performance. Masculine, wicked unbelievers he tempts to pride of honor, ability, and grandeur, and to an ambitious pursuit of power and greatness. The meek and gentle he tempts to yield too readily to the persuasions and will of erring and tempting persons; and those who are more rigid, to a stubborn resistance of all who would do them good.

He found it most fitting to tempt Saul to malice; David, by surprise, to lust; Absalom to ambition; Peter to cowardice, and afterward to compromise and dissimulation to avoid offending the weak; Luther to rashness; Melanchthon to timidity; Karlstadt to instability; Flacius Illyricus to immoderate zeal; Osiander to self-conceit, if historians have given them their due. One shoe does not fit every foot.

Direction 2. Keep your strictest watch over the sins that match your own temperament; far greater diligence and resolution are needed here than against other sins. Withdraw the fuel, and strive against the bodily disorders themselves. Fasting and labor will do much against lust, which idleness and excess continually feed; and so each remaining disorder has its own remedies. Know also what good your temperament gives you a special advantage for, and turn it fully toward that purpose, keeping it constantly employed there.

Temptation 3. The tempter suits his temptations to your circumstances, whether poverty or riches. The poor he tempts to grumble and grow impatient under their hardships, to distress themselves further with grief and anxiety, and to imagine that their sufferings may save them without holiness, or that necessary labor for their bodies may excuse them from much attending to the concerns of their souls. He also tempts them either to resent and hate the rich out of envy, or to flatter the rich for gain. The rich he tempts to an idle, time-wasting, sensual, fleshly, brutish life, to excess in sleep, food, drink, entertainment, clothing, costly pride, empty conversation, social calls, and compliments; to love the wealth and honors of the world and live in continual gratification of the flesh; to dine luxuriously every day and waste their time without a steady calling; and to be unmerciful to the poor and tyrannical toward those beneath them (Prov 30:8–9 Luke 16).

Direction 3. Here also, observe attentively where your danger lies, and keep a continual watch there. Let the poor remember that if they are not rich in grace, the fault is their own; and if they are, they possess the greatest riches, have learned contentment in every condition, and have great cause to thank God for thus helping them against the love and pleasures of the world. Let the rich remember that they have no less to do than the poor, for more has been committed to their trust, and they may not for that reason indulge the disordered desires of the flesh any the more. Rather, they have more to do, more dangers to fear and watch against, as they have more of their Master’s talents to employ and give account for at the last.

Temptation 4. The devil suits his temptations to men’s daily work and calling. If the work is humble, he tempts them to be ashamed of it through pride; if it is elevated, to be proud of it. If it is hard, he tempts them to grow weary and unfaithful in it, or to let it consume all their time and thought. If it deals with worldly things, he tempts them to be infected by it with a worldly spirit. If they labor for themselves, he tempts them to overreach; if for others, he tempts them to deceitful, negligent, and slothful unfaithfulness.

If they are ministers, he tempts them to be idle, unfaithful, and insensible to the weight of truth, the value of souls, and the shortness of time, so that their failure becomes the ruin or loss of many. If they are rulers, the devil uses his utmost skill to make them adopt an interest contrary to the interest of truth and holiness, to plant in their minds some quarrel against Christ, and to persuade them that his cause is against their own and that his servants are their enemies.

Direction 4. Make sure your work is lawful and that God has called you to it; then receive it as the service he himself assigns you, do it as under his eye and accountable to his judgment, in obedience to his will. Do not think so much about whether it is hard or easy, humble or elevated, as about whether you are faithful in it. If it is sanctified to you by your directing everything toward pleasing God, remember that he loves and rewards the servant who stoops to the lowest task at his command as much as the one employed in the highest. Do all for God, walk in holiness with him, keep out selfishness, the poison of every calling, observe the particular dangers of your position, and keep a constant watch against them.

Temptation 5. The devil suits his temptations to our various relationships. Parents he tempts to be cold and careless about the great work of giving their children a wise and holy upbringing. Children he tempts to be disobedient, ungrateful, devoid of natural affection, and disrespectful toward their parents. Husbands he tempts to be unloving, unkind, and impatient with their wives’ weaknesses; and wives to be irritable, self-willed, proud, loud, passionate, and disobedient. Masters he tempts to use their servants merely as beasts for their own profit, with no care for their servants’ salvation or God’s service; and servants he tempts to be carnal, untrustworthy, dishonest, lazy, and concerned only for appearances, more intent on concealing a fault than on not committing it.

Ministers and magistrates he tempts to seek their own interests, neglect their charge, and pursue their own ends instead of the common good, or to mistake what the common good actually is and what means lead to it. Subjects and citizens he tempts to dishonor and murmur against their governors, to judge them unjustly, to disobey and rebel against them, or else to honor, fear, and serve them more than God, and in defiance of God.

Direction 5. Learn well the duties and dangers of your own relationships, and remember that a great part of your work is to be faithful and excellent within them. Think less about what others owe you than about what you owe to God and to them. Masters, ministers, and magistrates must first study and carefully practice their own duties; yet they must also ensure that those under them do theirs, because that is part of their office. But they must be more eager that God be served first, and more concerned to secure obedience to him, than to be honored or obeyed themselves.

Children, servants, and subjects must be absorbed in doing their own proper work well, remembering that their good or harm depends far more on that than on how their superiors treat or use them. As it is your own body, not your superior’s, that your soul animates, nourishes, and directs, and of which you have the constant sense and responsibility; so it is your own duty, not your superior’s, that you have to perform and to answer for, and therefore most to think about and attend to.

Temptation 6. The tempter also suits his temptations to our opportunities and prospects of rising or thriving in the world. He sees which path leads to our advancement, and there he lays his snares, shaped to fit our designs and ambitions, making some sinful omission or commission appear necessary to success. Either Balaam must prophesy against the people of God, or God will keep him from honor by keeping him from sin. Once Judas is set on "What will you give me?" the devil will show him the way to gain, for that way is indispensable to such sinful ends.

Direction 6. Take care, therefore, not to overvalue the world or to be captivated by its honor, pleasure, or prosperity. Take care lest the love of earthly things draw you into eager desires and schemes to become great or wealthy. For once your heart has set itself on such a design, you have wandered from God: the heart is lost, and everything else will follow as occasion demands. Take to heart these Scriptures: "Labour not to be rich. He that maketh haste to be rich shall not be innocent. He that hasteth to be rich hath an evil eye. But they that will be rich fall into temptations and a snare, and into many foolish and hurtful lusts, which drown men in destruction and perdition: for the love of money is the root of all evil; but godliness with contentment is great gain. Seek not great matters for yourselves" (Prov 23:4 Prov 28:20–22 Phil 4:9 Jer 45:5).

Be dead to the world. Fear the rising way more than the falling. Love most that condition which fits you for communion with God or makes you the most useful servant to him; and hate most that which most hinders you from these and would most enslave you to the world.

Temptation 7. The tempter shapes his temptations to suit our company. If those around us hold any error or sin, or are engaged in any worldly enterprise, he will turn them into snares for us, giving us no rest until we are caught. If they do not love us, he will make them a constant source of provocation, setting all their wrongs before us and stirring us toward uncharitableness and revenge. If they do love us, he will try to make their affection the entry point for their errors and evil ways, drawing us to follow their example. He finds something in every circle of company to make it the material of some temptation.

Direction 7. Keep your closest company with God. Let faith make Christ and the angels your most regarded and attended company, so that their mind and presence may affect you more than the mind and presence of mortal people. Never look at any person’s mind, will, or actions without reference to God who governs all things, to the rule by which all conduct should be measured, and to the judgment that will expose and reward each as it truly is. Never see a person without seeing God behind them; see every person only as a creature dependent on the will of the Maker. Then, when someone sins, you will grieve over it rather than imitate it; and when someone would draw you with them into sin and ruin, you will resist, and Christ says, "hate" (Luke 14:26), rather than be seduced.

Had Adam attended more to God than to Eve, he would not have been seduced by his own helper. You will then regard the proud, the worldly, and the sensual as Solomon regarded the sluggard’s vineyard: "I saw and considered it well, I looked on it, and received instruction" (Prov 24:30–32). No one longs for the plague or leprosy simply because it is a friend’s disease.

Temptation 8. The tempter also takes advantage of what other people think of you, say about you, or do to you, and through every such occasion he works to ensnare you in some sin. If they think poorly of you or speak slightingly of you, he tempts you to hate them, or to love them less, or to speak contemptuously of them in return. If they applaud you, he tempts you to pride. If they wrong you, he tempts you to revenge.

If they enrich you or act as your benefactors, he would make their generosity the price of some sin, making you pay for it with your salvation. If they scorn you for your religion, he would make you ashamed of Christ and his cause. If they admire you, he would draw you toward hypocrisy. If they threaten you, he would lead you into sin through fear, as he led Peter. If they treat you roughly, he tempts you to anger and to pay them back in kind, and even to grow disgusted with religion itself, if people who profess it oppose you or seem to do you wrong. In this way every person is a danger to his neighbor.

Direction 8. In every person, discern what belongs to God, and draw help from that; and discern what belongs to Satan, sin, and self, and guard against that. Look on every person as at once a helper and a tempter, and be always ready to draw out their help and resist their temptation. Remember, too, that the person is only the instrument: it is Satan who tempts you, and God who tries you, through that instrument. As David said of Shimei, "The Lord hath bidden him" (2 Sam 16:10), that is, Shimei is only God’s rod to correct me for my sin, just as my own son has been. As Satan was the instrument in trying Job, not by God’s causing the sin, but by his permitting it, so look to God and to Satan in these encounters more than to the people themselves.

Temptation 9. His temptations are also fitted to opinions and thoughts we have already received. If you have let in so much as one lustful or malicious thought, he can make great use of that seed to draw in more, as a little leaven leavens the whole lump. He can roll it over and over in the mind, and do much to hatch it into a multitude of sins. If you have been touched by any false opinion, or by a prejudice against your teacher, your ruler, or your neighbor, he can cultivate it to great growth, drawing conclusions from it, and further conclusions from those, and driving them all into practice, until observers say with astonishment, "Behold, how great a matter a little fire kindleth."

Direction 9. Take care what thoughts you first admit into your mind, and above all, never cherish or approve a thought without careful trial and examination. If a thought proves corrupt, sweep your imagination and memory clean of it before it takes up permanent lodging and has time to breed. Fill the space instead with contrary thoughts and useful truth, and cherish these daily so that they grow and multiply. Then your heart will be like a well-ordered and well-populated kingdom, able to hold its ground against all enemies.

Temptation 10. He also shapes his temptations to your natural and acquired abilities. If you are weak, he will either discourage you or, which is more common and more dangerous, make you think better of your abilities than they deserve, so that you fancy you know much when you know almost nothing. He will make you wise in your own eyes, ready to receive an error and then confident in it; unable to distinguish between things that differ; swept into false zeal and false ways by the plausible appearances of truth; and then zealous to draw others into the same deception. He will also make you a dishonor to truth and godliness by your weakness and poor handling of good causes, handing those causes over to the adversary through sheer incompetence.

If you are of stronger mind and greater gifts, the tempter will lead you to despise the weak, to mistake common intellectual gifts for saving grace, to undervalue holiness and humility while overvaluing learning and sharpness. Most dangerously, he will tempt you to grow contemptuous of the simplicity of Christianity and of the Scriptures in their style and method, and to take offense at the cross of Christ. People of this kind are generally in greater danger of unbelief, heresy, pride, and insolent domination over the flock of Christ than ordinary Christians of more modest gifts.

Direction 10. Work diligently to know yourself well. If you are weak, know your weakness so that you may be humble and cautious, and seek strength and help beyond yourself. If you are comparatively strong, remember how weak the strongest still are, and how little the wisest actually know. Study carefully the ends and proper use of knowledge, so that all you know may be digested into love and holiness. Use what you know with the awareness that you will have much to give account for.

Temptation 11. The tempter will also draw advantage against you from your past life and actions. If you have wandered from the way to heaven, he will harden you by force of habit, making you think it such a disgrace or burden to turn back that you may as well press on and take your chances. If you have done something outwardly good while your heart and manner of life remain carnal and worldly, he will use that small good to quiet you in your sinful and miserable condition. If a good person has erred or done wrong, the tempter will engage their sense of honor in the error, making them study to defend or excuse it rather than bear the shame, tempting them, as he tempted David, to cover one sin with another. Once he gets hold of one link, he will draw the whole chain of sin along with it.

Direction 11. Take care, therefore, in what you do, and look ahead to the end. Do not let the devil get so much as a foothold; examine a course before you enter it. But if you have already gone wrong, come out of it, thoroughly and promptly, whatever the cost, for be sure the cost of going on will be far greater. If he would make a snare of the good you have done, remember that this is to turn it into the greatest evil of all; and that good must be consistent and whole to make you acceptable before God and to save you. Heart and life must both be good, and good to the very end.

Temptation 12. Finally, he shapes his temptations to the season. He will strike at the exact moment when an evil thought is most likely to take hold, when the winds and tide serve his purpose. What would be abhorred at one time will be entertained at another, when a person’s wits and heart are at their weakest. In times of affliction, he will draw you to deny Christ as Peter did, or to secure yourself by sinful means. In times of prosperity, he will tempt you to carelessness, worldliness, and forgetfulness of the night and winter that are coming. The timing of his temptations is his great advantage.

Direction 12. Live as one in God’s presence, and you will live as though already in eternity, and will see clearly that time, along with all its pleasures, advantages, dangers, and sufferings, is, in itself, of little ultimate weight. Keep your eye fixed on judgment and eternity, where every error of time will be corrected, every inequality leveled, and every passing sorrow and joy dissolved. When you do this, no argument drawn from the frowns or flatteries of the age will carry any force with you. Stay constantly employed for God, armed and watchful, so that Satan may never find you ready to take the bait.

The Tempter’s Method in Applying His Prepared Baits

 

Temptation 1. The devil’s first work is to present the tempting bait in all its alluring and deceptive attractiveness, making it appear as true as possible to the understanding, and as good and desirable as possible to the will. He says everything that can be said for an evil cause, fashioning his image of truth and goodness as beautifully as he can. Sin will be sweetened; its pleasure will be its power (Heb 11:25). Sin will pay its wages on the spot (2 Pet 2:15).

He will commend it with extravagant praise: "What a fine thing it is to be rich and to satisfy the flesh continually, to have power, honor, pleasure, sport, and everything you want! Who would refuse such a condition if it were available?" "All this I will give you" was the temptation he thought fit to assault even Christ himself with. He will also distort the record of the past, telling you that those who followed his way prospered (Jer 44:17); and for the future, he will promise that you will gain by it, as he did with Eve, and that you will have peace even while indulging your flesh in sin (Deut 29:19).

Direction 1. When faced with this, first ask what God says about what Satan is commending. The praise and proposals of an enemy are to be suspected; God is far more to be trusted. Second, consider not only whether a thing is good, but how long it will remain good, what it will prove to be at the end, and how you will judge it at the parting. Consider also what it tends toward, whether toward good or evil, and whether it is the greatest good you are capable of. You will then see that if there were no good, or appearance of good, in it, it could do no harm to a rational agent and would not be fit material for a temptation at all. You will also see that it is temporal good held up to rob you of eternal good, and to entice you into the greatest evil and misery.

Does the devil show you the world and say, "All this I will give you"? Look to Christ, who shows you the glory of the world to come, along with everything truly good for you in this world, and says, far more truthfully, "All this I will give you." The world and hell sit on one side of the scales; pardon, holiness, and heaven sit on the other. Which will you choose? If the devil has more to give you and to bid for you than Christ, then let him take you.

Temptation 2. The tempter works to keep God, Christ, and heaven out of sight, so that they cannot dim the brilliance of his bait. He conceals from the person’s mind those powerful counter-arguments by which the temptation could easily be repelled, arguments well known, certain, and abundantly supported by Scripture, so that when temptation comes, not one of them is ready to hand, and they count for nothing. He accomplishes this through unbelief and thoughtlessness.

Direction 2. Live by faith. See to it that God the Father, the Redeemer, and the Holy Spirit dwell within you and fill your heart; place all your hopes on heaven; and make these your very life and chief concern. Then you will always have at hand the means to repel the tempter. A heart filled with God and Christ, dwelling habitually in heaven, is always fortified and ready to meet every temptation with revulsion.

Keep your soul as constantly and vividly aware of the evil of sin, the danger of sinning, the presence and authority and holiness of God, the wrong sin does to him, the harm it does to yourself and others, and what it cost Jesus Christ, as you are aware of the danger of fire, water, and poison. Then the tempter will not succeed.

Temptation 3. The devil takes great care to keep himself hidden so that he is not seen in the temptation. As the angler hides behind a bush and the fowler conceals himself from the birds, who would otherwise take fright and flee, so the devil uses all his skill to hide himself from the sinner’s perception, so that the deluded soul will little suspect how near the devil is, or how large a part he is playing in the business.

If the ambitious or covetous worldling saw the devil offering the bait and heard him say, "All this I will give you," he would be far less eager to take it. If the devil appeared openly to the fornicator and brought him his partner in sin and encouraged him to his filthiness, it would cool his lust. If he appeared to the drunkard and handed him the cup, the drunkard would have little appetite for it. If the proud and the malicious saw the devil at their backs, rejoicing in their sin and driving them on, it might frighten them halfway back to their senses.

So the devil’s great effort is to persuade people that it is not he who is making the proposal, it is some friend, some neighbor, some gentleman, some minister, some wise man; it is not the devil, until the fish is caught and the bird is in the net. Then the true author of it all appears openly to destroy them and carry them away, without any further concealment.

Direction 3. Look closely at the tendency and manner of a temptation, and you can identify its author. Who else is so consistently against God and against your everlasting happiness? Who else so abuses your reason as to make you prefer temporal things over eternal ones, and the brutish pleasures of corruptible flesh over the interests of an immortal soul? Who else so directly contradicts the entire Word of God? Read God’s warnings, and he will tell you plainly who it is.

Receive every temptation, therefore, whoever delivers it, as though you saw the devil standing beside the messenger, making the proposal himself, and heard him personally urging you to sin. Imagine you saw him escorting you to the brothel, the playhouse, or the alehouse, presiding over the entertainment like a master of ceremonies. How would you receive that? Would you still be angry at the faithful preacher who tries to stop you? Would you take the devil’s side? No, by nature you already fear him and feel enmity toward him. Use that instinct for your own protection. Nothing that comes from him can be good for you. He will show you a far uglier face than you have ever yet seen, when you have done his work and are where he wanted you all along. Know with whom you are dealing.

Temptation 4. The tempter is equally careful to hide from people the true nature and tendency of the temptation itself, so that they do not recognize they are being tempted at all, but see nothing before them except the desirable bait. The angler hides not only himself from the fish, but also his rod, line, and hook as much as he can; the fowler covers his nets, so that the fish and the bird either do not see the snare or do not understand what it is and what it is set for.

In the same way, when the bait of pleasure, honor, or wealth is presented by the devil to the fornicator, the gambler, the proud, or the covetous, they do not see what the devil is doing at that moment or what game he is playing for their souls. They do not perceive the chain connecting pleasure to sin, sin to God’s warning, that warning to judgment, and judgment to everlasting punishment. When Judas was bargaining with the Pharisees, he did not know that the devil was inside him, driving the deal forward.

Direction 4. Be wise and suspicious: blindness or recklessness will lead you into the snare. Be wise enough to recognize where every thing presented to your thoughts is tending, and to perceive danger when it is there. Be suspicious and cautious: test things sufficiently, act only on sure grounds, and avoid the very appearance of evil. When it is hell you fear, do not draw near. Do not play like the fly around the candle. Salvation is necessary; but advancement, wealth, liberty, reputation, or even life itself are not necessary to you. Prove all things. Do not flatter yourselves into snares by foolish hopes, or by judging things as the flesh would have them be rather than as they truly are. If no danger appears, lift every covering and search carefully lest one be hidden. The devil has his gunpowder-plots and mines that may blow you up before you are aware. Not only lawfulness and indifference, but the appearance of great good is the pretense for the greatest evil.

Temptation 5. The tempter also takes care to bring the tempting object near enough, or to draw the sinner near enough to it. The net must come to the fish, or the fish to the net; a distant fire will not ignite the wood. The devil’s chief confidence lies in the bodily appetite, which is strongest at close range. If he gets the drunkard into the alehouse and sets the cup before him, he has half conquered him already, and if the man is still reluctant, someone will drink a health or press the cup into his hand.

The thief, like Achan, will see the bait, and the sight will stir a covetous desire. The glutton will have tempting dishes set before him, at a table loaded with such variety of delicious food that it becomes his snare; had he been given only the poor man’s plain food, with nothing in it fit to tempt him, he might easily have escaped. The fornicator will have his alluring object brought near and presented in a tempting manner, for at a sufficient distance there would have been little danger. The ambitious person will have advancement offered, or placed so nearly within reach that a little effort would attain it. The fearful coward will be threatened with the loss of estate or life, and will hear the report of Satan’s cannons, guns, and drums. Peter is half conquered when he is drawn among questioning company in the high priest’s hall. So it was with David, so with Lot, and so ordinarily sinners are drawn into the snare.

Direction 5. If you would preserve your innocency and your souls, flee as far from tempting objects as you can, as far, I say, as you can without distrusting God through the neglect of a certain duty. A wife or servant who is bound cannot flee; nor must we leave a certain duty undone because of an uncertain danger that may otherwise be avoided. But keep your distance from temptation as far as you possibly can. When your souls are at stake, the safest course is the best. Do not plead the lawfulness of what you do when it is a temptation to something unlawful. You say it is lawful to wear such fine ornaments and dress yourself with every care, but is it lawful to be proud or lustful, or to consume your time unprofitably? If not, do not tempt yourself or others toward it.

Stay away from the place where the snare is laid. Consider the end before you meddle with the beginning. Why should I eat what I know I cannot digest without casting it up again? Why should I taste what I must not eat? Why should I desire to have before me, and to gaze on, what I must not taste? Come not near if you would not be taken. What are you doing in the alehouse with a cup before you, if you would not be drawn to excess? If you are prone to excess in eating, do not make your own table your temptation. Flee from temptation as you would flee from hell or from the devil himself.

If you are inclined to lust, do not look upon its bait, or come nowhere near it. Solomon says:

"Remove thy way far from her, and come not nigh the door of her house; for her end is bitter as wormwood, sharp as a two-edged sword: her feet go down to death, her steps take hold on hell. Her house inclineth to death and her paths unto the dead: none that go to her return again, neither take they hold of the paths of life. Her house is the way to hell, going down to the chambers of death.

"Whoso is simple let him turn in hither: and as for him that wanteth understanding, she saith to him, Stolen waters are sweet, and bread eaten in secret is pleasant. But he knoweth not that the dead are there; and that her guests are in the depths of hell. Lust not after her beauty in thy heart, neither let her take thee with her eyelids. Can a man take fire in his bosom and his clothes not be burnt?" (Prov 5:8 Prov 4:5 Prov 2:18–19 Prov 7:27 Prov 9:16 Prov 9:18 Prov 6:25 Prov 6:27–28)

Remember that you pray daily, "Lead us not into temptation." If you will run into it yourselves, are not your prayers hypocritical and an abuse of God? If you would be saved from sin, you must be saved in God’s way, and that is by fleeing temptations, not by drawing near, gazing on forbidden objects, and tempting yourselves. Just as God’s holy means must be used by all who would come to holiness and heaven, so the devil’s means must be avoided by those who would escape sin and hell.

2. But if you cannot remove yourself far enough from the snare, then double your fear, your watchfulness, and your resolution. Flee with Joseph from the sin, even if you cannot leave the house entirely. How carefully should every step be placed, when we know that we walk among snares! Rule your senses if you cannot remove the bait. Make Job’s covenant with your eyes, that you will not look on what would allure. Set a constant watch over every sense.

Temptation 6. The next great work of the tempter is to give us the fairest opportunities to sin, to remove all impediments, and to hold out encouraging prospects and invitations. He will show the thief how to steal, the covetous man how to thrive by deceit and overreaching, the ambitious man how to rise, and the fornicator how to obtain his desire and sin without discovery, and then he tells them how easy it is: no one sees you; you may do it without fear or shame. It is the devil’s great care to clear away everything that would alarm or hinder sinners, so that they have every inducement and no obstacle. He is therefore very eager that public impediments be removed, especially the godly magistrate and minister, and that the common disgrace of sinning be lifted, and if possible turned against religion, or directed against those who are sin’s greatest adversaries.

Direction 6. It is therefore a principal part of your wisdom and watchfulness to avoid opportunities for sinning, and to place as many impediments as possible in your own path. There is a most foolish and sinful disposition in some who think it admirable to have the power to do harm, even while claiming they abhor doing it. One who says he hates oppression yet would have the power to oppress, to hold all men at his will and mercy, thinks that a fine thing. In the same way, those who would not be gluttonous still want a tempting table always before them, presuming that their own will is a sufficient safeguard against the sin.

Those who would not be ensnared by lust still desire to appear as lovely and desirable as possible, and to command the affections of others, and to have opportunity offered them, so that they may sin if they choose. But is your will so well established, so mortified and unchangeable, that it can be trusted that far? What a foolish sinner, who knows yourself so little and observes your danger so poorly, who does not perceive that this very desire to have the power to do evil reveals a degree of that evil already in your heart, and that you are not yet as far from it as you must be to be safe.

Arrange your life, if you are wise and love yourself, so that sinning is made as difficult as possible. Make it impossible, if that can be done. Power is for the act, do not desire the ability to sin if you would not sin. Not that the natural power to do good should be destroyed because it is also a power to do evil, but cast as many obstacles in the path of your sinning as you can, until sinning becomes a moral impossibility. Desire the strictest laws and rulers. Seek to live in the sight of others, and arrange your affairs so that you can have no hope of secrecy. Arrange things so that sinning would bring you utter shame and loss. If you are tempted to fornication, never be alone with the person who is your snare. If you are tempted to deceive and rob those who trust you, avoid taking on that trust, or if you have already done so, make restitution and confess, so that shame may preserve you.

Temptation 7. The tempter urgently draws our thoughts and imagination to dwell on the tempting object: the lustful person lingers over the objects of his lust; the ambitious man turns over visions of the honor he craves; the covetous man broods on wealth, property, or a profitable deal; and the malicious man rehearses every real or imagined wrong that feeds his malice.

Direction 7. Keep a continual watch over your thoughts. Remember that this is the common entrance of the greatest sins, and if they go no further, the Searcher of hearts will still judge you for the adultery, murder, and other sins committed in the heart. Above all, keep your thoughts so occupied with better things that sin never finds them empty and waiting.

Temptation 8. The tempter also works hard to keep the final outcome hidden from the sinner’s view, persuading him that there is no danger, and that things will be just as fine in the end as they are now. The tempter cannot endure any mention of death or judgment, unless he can first fortify the sinner with some presumptuous confidence that his sins are already pardoned and his condition is secure. He will either convince the sinner that there is no real danger to the soul, or simply prevent him from thinking about that danger at all.

The tempter is reluctant to let a sinner look into a grave, or visit a house of mourning, and see where all the living end up, lest the sinner take it to heart and realize what worldly pleasure, wealth, and greatness actually amount to, by seeing where they leave those who pursue them. If anyone speaks of death, judgment, or the life to come, the devil stirs up scorn, weariness, or hostility toward such conversation. If a sinner begins to consider privately what will become of him after death, the devil will either lure him away or agitate him, and will never let him rest until he has driven off every thought that might lead to his salvation. The tempter cannot bear it when, seeing the pomp and pleasure of the world, you pause to ask: How long will this last? And what will it come to in the end?

Direction 8. Go to the Holy Scriptures and see what they declare about the final outcome of godliness and sin. God knows far better than the devil, and is infinitely more worthy of belief. In the Word of God you can see what becomes of saints and sinners, the godly and the ungodly, at last, what they will think and say when they look back on how they lived, what Christ will say to them, how he will judge them, and what their eternal reward will be. This is the infallible forecast, where you may foresee your endless state. In this mirror, constantly look ahead to the end. Never judge anything by present taste alone. Ask not only how it tastes, but how it works and what its effects will be. Remember that God’s law has inseparably joined holiness and heaven, and unrepented sin and hell, and since these cannot in reality be separated, never separate them from each other in your thinking. Without this, you will never truly understand either Christ or Satan.

When Christ says, "Wilt thou deny thyself, and take up the cross, and follow me," his meaning is: Shall I heal your carnal, worldly heart and life, and bring you by grace to the sight of God in endless glory? You will never understand what prayer, obedience, and holy living mean, unless you see their end, heaven, joined to them.

When the devil says to the glutton, "eat also of this pleasant dish," and to the drunkard, "take another cup," and to the fornicator, "take your pleasure in the dark," and to the pleasure-seeker, "go to the playhouse or the gaming-house; come, play at cards or dice," his real meaning is: "Come, venture into sin, disregard God’s warnings, reject his word, his Spirit, and his grace, so that I may have your company among the damned, in the fire that shall never be quenched." That is the true meaning of every temptation. Open your ears, then, and whenever the devil or any sinner tempts you to sin, hear it as though they said, "I beg you, leap into the flames of hell."

Temptation 9. If the tempter cannot quickly draw someone into the sin itself, he will at least try to weaken their resolve against it, moving them to deliberate, to listen to what can be said for it, and to enter into a dispute with Satan or one of his instruments. He tells them that a truth which will not endure examination must be false, and that we must "prove all things." But while the sinner deliberates and disputes, the venom is working its way into his veins, sense is quietly undermining and betraying him, bribing his reason and seducing his will. It is exactly like an enemy who engages a garrison in negotiations so that, during the talks, he may send in spies, discover their weaknesses, and corrupt the soldiers. So does the devil with the sinner.

Direction 9. Remember that it is Christ, not Satan, whom you are to hear. Truth is strong and can bear examination before any competent judge; but you are weak, and not as capable a judge as you may imagine. Ignorant, unskilled, and unsettled persons are easily deceived, however clear the matter may be. If the question seems untried by you, it has not gone untried by all the godly, nor is it unknown to him who gave us the Holy Scriptures.

If it genuinely needs to be questioned and debated, seek the help of able and godly teachers or friends, and hear what they have to say, matters of endless life or death are not to be risked carelessly. But if it is something beyond dispute, in which you have already been convinced and settled, reject the tempter outright, and tell him you owe him no such service as to debate whether you should care for your salvation. Otherwise there will be no end to it, until you are betrayed and ruined. Innocent Eve was deceived the moment the matter came to a dispute. Do not be like Balaam, who tempted God and refused to be satisfied with the answer he was given.

Temptation 10. The tempter also overcomes a great many by making them presumptuously confident in their own strength, saying: You are not so weak that you cannot withstand a temptation greater than this. Can you not gaze on beauty, or go among vain and tempting company, and still choose whether to sin? Only a child has so little self-command. Can your table, your cup, your house, your lands not give you pleasure and delight without your falling into excessive love of them and turning them into sin?

Direction 10. Know your own weakness. You carry within you a treacherous enemy always ready to open the back door to the devil. Remember that the flesh is on the tempter’s side, and how much it can do with you before you are even aware. Remember what an unstable creature you are, how many good resolutions in the past have come to nothing, and how often you have fallen to temptations just as slight. Remember that without the Spirit of Christ you can do nothing and cannot withstand any assault of Satan, and that Christ gives his Spirit and help in his own way, not to those who tempt him to abandon them by deliberately thrusting themselves into temptation.

Shall any mortal presume upon his own strength, after the falls of Adam, Noah, Lot, David, Solomon, Hezekiah, Josiah, and Peter? After the ruin of so many professing Christians as our own eyes have witnessed? "All these things happened unto them for ensamples, and they are written for our admonition, on whom the ends of the world are come. Wherefore let him that thinketh he standeth, take heed lest he fall." (1 Cor 10:11–12)

Temptation 11. It is a great and often successful strategy of the devil to draw people into sin by first showing them an effective remedy: the abundant mercy of God, the sufficient satisfaction made by Christ, the full and free and universal promise, all of which are enough to cleanse the soul of any sin. Therefore, the tempter argues, you need not be afraid.

Direction 11. But God is just as well as merciful, and there are "vessels of wrath" as well as vessels of mercy. Judge how God will exercise his mercy, and to whom, by his own Word, for he knows better than you do to whom, and how far, to show mercy. Is the tempter himself saved, for all that God is merciful? And the Gospel assigns far severer punishment than the law does to those who abuse grace. Christ is the most dreadful Judge to the wicked, just as he is the tenderest Savior to his own.

There is enough in his grace to save the penitent, but if you will sin on the presumption that grace will save you, you have little reason to think you are penitent, or ever will be, without a very merciful change wrought upon you. How many can you name who were ever converted and forgiven while living willfully in sin precisely because the remedy was sufficient? No doubt some such have been recalled from that path, but this is no ground for hope. It is a terrible thing to sin deliberately and willfully on the strength of God’s mercy and the sufficiency of Christ’s death. No one but the penitent convert is saved by Christ, and deliberate sinning on that ground is the very opposite of penitence and conversion. Christ does not act like a mountebank, who wounds a man to show the crowd how quickly his remedy can cure him, or makes a man swallow poison to demonstrate the power of his antidote. Christ heals the diseases he finds in believers, he does not cause them.

Temptation 12. The tempter also tells the sinner that the remedy is certain, easy, and within his own power: he need only repent, and all sin will be pardoned.

Direction 12. Consider the following replies.

1.) Is repentance truly in your power? If so, your sin is all the greater, since you sin on when you should be repenting. If it is easy, how inexcusable are you for refusing to do it and pressing on in sin?

2.) Repentance is the gift of God (2 Tim 2:25–26), and is God likely to grant it to those who willfully presume upon it and abuse him in expectation of receiving it?

3.) Easy as repentance is said to be, only a small number of those who continue in sin ever truly repent and are forgiven, compared with the multitudes who go on and perish.

4.) Even the easiest repentance is so bitter that it is far easier simply to avoid the sin in the first place. It is better not to wound yourself at all than to rely on the best remedy, even if you were certain of obtaining it.

5.) Repentance driven only by fear of death and hell, with no genuine love for God and holiness, is nothing but the repentance of the damned, and it never obtains pardon. The devil has exactly that kind of repentance, and that kind of faith, and neither will save him.

Temptation 13. Satan also emboldens the sinner by pointing to the many who sinned as badly or worse and yet repented and fared well: he cites Noah, Lot, David, Peter, the thief on the cross, Paul the persecutor, and even Manasseh.

Direction 13. Ask yourself honestly whether any of those persons sinned as they did because others before them had escaped. And weigh the millions who never repented and stand condemned against the few who did repent. If repentance is better than sin, why do you choose to sin? If sin is better than repentance, why do you plan to repent at all? Is it not base ingratitude to offend God willfully simply because he has pardoned many offenders and is ready to forgive the penitent?

Should any reasonable person deliberately manufacture occasions for his own repentance, doing what he knows he will one day wish with grief he had never done? If some people have survived being cast into the sea, or falling from great heights, or swallowing poison, or suffering dangerous wounds, does that give you reason to put yourself in the same danger in the hope of being saved?

Temptation 14. The tempter persuades the sinner that God cannot regard sin as any great matter, since a man’s thoughts, words, or deeds are of little moment when man himself is so poor a creature, and whatever a man does, it does no harm to God. So there is no need to make so much of it.

Direction 14. If God regards us so highly as to make us, sustain us continually, become our Governor, give us his law, judge us, and reward his servants with nothing less than heaven, then it is plain he regards us enough to take notice of whether we obey or break his laws. A person who cares enough about a clock or watch to make it and wind it up does care whether it keeps good time or not.

What sort of God do these people imagine, one who does not care what men do? On that reasoning, he would not care if men beat you, robbed you, or killed you, since none of that harms him. And a king could say, if someone murders your family: why should I punish him? He did not hurt me. But justice exists to maintain order in the world, not merely to protect the ruler from personal injury. God may be wronged even though he cannot be harmed. And he will hold you to account, both for harm done to others and for harm done to yourself.

Temptation 15. The tempter labors to minimize the sin and make it appear trivial: if every little sin must be made such a great matter, you will never have any peace.

Direction 15. Keep these things in mind.

1.) Deadly poison lies in the very nature of sin, however small the sin may appear, just as there is poison in a serpent however small it is. The least sin is worse than the greatest pain any person has ever endured. Would you choose it and call it little? The least sin is odious to God, had its share in the death of Christ, and will damn you if it is not pardoned. Should such a thing be made light of? Many sins counted small carry grave aggravations when they are committed knowingly, deliberately, and willfully. To love a small sin is itself a great sin, especially to love it so well that the memory of God’s will and love, of Christ, of heaven and hell, is not enough to resolve you against it.

2.) Beyond that, a small sin is the common road to greater ones. "When lust hath conceived it brings forth sin, and sin when it is finished brings forth death" (Jas 1:14–15). "Behold how great a matter a little fire kindleth" (Jas 3:5). The terrible sins of David and Peter had small beginnings. Fatal sicknesses appear trivial at the start. Thousands upon thousands have sinned their way to hell having begun with what is considered a small matter.

Temptation 16. The devil also draws the sinner forward by promising that he will sin only once, or perhaps a very few times, and then stop: he tells the thief or the fornicator that if they will do it just this once, they will be at peace.

Direction 16. Consider two things.

1.) One stab to the heart may prove incurable. God may deny you the time or the grace to repent.

2.) It is easier to resist the first time than the second, for one sin prepares the heart for another. If you cannot refuse the first temptation, how will you refuse the next? When you have lost your strength, grieved your helper, and strengthened your enemy and your snare, do you expect to resist better when you are wounded than you can now while you are whole?

Temptation 17. Once the devil has prevailed the first time, he turns that very fact into an argument for a second: he tells the thief, the drunkard, the fornicator that it is only the same thing already done once; and if once may be pardoned, twice may be pardoned; and if twice, why not three times, and so on.

Direction 17. This is what comes of letting the devil get a foot in the door. A spark is easier to quench than a flame. Yet remember that the longer you wait, the worse your condition: the more often you sin, the greater the abuse of the Spirit of God, the deeper the contempt of grace, the heavier the wrong to Christ, the harder the repentance, and sharper too when it finally comes, because the wound is deeper. Repent quickly, therefore, and go no further, unless you wish the devil’s next argument to be that it is now too late.

Temptation 18. The tempter uses the greater sins of others to persuade men to venture upon lesser ones. You hear other men curse, swear, and rail, and do you hesitate over idle talk? How many in the world are enemies of Christ and persecute his ministers and servants, and do you make so great a matter of missing a sermon, a prayer, or some other holy duty?

Direction 18. As there are degrees of sin, so there are degrees of punishment. Will you settle for the easiest place in hell rather than heaven? However small the matter of the sin may be, your willfulness in committing it, against your conscience, against mercies received, against warnings given, may make it very great in your particular case. Do the great sinners appear so happy to you that you would be as much like them as you dare?

Temptation 19. He also emboldens the sinner by pointing to how common the sin is and how many commit it or worse, as though its prevalence made it less wicked or less dangerous.

Direction 19. Remember that the more examples you have to serve as warnings, the more inexcusable your fall becomes. It was not the great number of angels who fell that kept them from becoming devils and being condemned for their sin: God will execute justice on many just as readily as on one. The greater the number sinning, the greater the sin, and the punishment will not be reduced on that account.

Apply it to yourself: would you accept as a valid reason for someone to abuse you, beat you, or rob you the fact that many others had done so before? You would surely say rather that you had already been wronged enough, and that he should not add to your injuries. If, after many had already spat in Christ’s face or struck him, someone had added one more spit or one more blow, as though he had not suffered enough already, would you not reckon that person the worst and most cruel of them all? If you do as the many do, you will fare as the many fare.

Temptation 20. "It is a dangerous temptation when the devil proposes some very good end and makes sin appear to be the most fitting, or even the necessary, means to accomplish it. When he blinds people into thinking that sin is necessary for their own salvation, or for others’ salvation, or for the welfare of the church, or for the progress of the Gospel, or for pleasing God, then sin is committed without regret and continued without repentance. This is the reason heresy, will-worship, and superstition persist: "Having a show of wisdom in will-worship, and humility, and neglecting the body" (Col 2:18, 21–23). Much of the world’s wickedness against God is done in the name of God; much of the murder and persecution carried out by Papists has been done in the name of the church and of truth."

Direction 20. Remember that God needs no sinful means to accomplish his ends. He will not be indebted to the devil to do his work; he would not have forbidden something if he had wanted you to do it. He is never so constrained that he cannot find rightful means enough to carry out his purposes.

A great part of the wisdom on which our salvation depends lies in choosing and using right means once we are committed to a right end. It is a serious offense against God to attach his name to sin and make it appear necessary to his ends and honor. Good ends do not justify evil actions. What sin is so odious that some good end has not been claimed for it? Even Christ was put to death as a criminal for ostensibly good ends, to vindicate God’s honor from blasphemy, to protect Caesar from injury, and to spare the nation from calamity. His disciples were killed so that God might be served by removing dangerous troublers of the world. (John 16:2 Acts 24:5 Acts 17:6)

Temptation 21. "He would lead us to presume on the fact that we are God’s children, that special saving grace cannot be wholly lost, and that since we once found grace in ourselves, we may venture boldly as people who are safe."

Direction 21. Many thousands will be damned who once believed they possessed true saving grace. It is a difficult controversy among learned and godly men whether those in a state of saving grace can fall from it and perish; but it is beyond controversy that those who live and die impenitently in willful sin will perish. To appeal to the possession of true grace as an encouragement to sin is so contrary to the nature and purpose of grace that it should make you question whether your grace is real at all. You can be no more certain that you have true grace than you are certain that you hate all known sin and desire to be free from it.

Christ himself teaches you how to answer such a dreadful temptation: "If thou be the Son of God, cast thyself down: for it is written, He shall give his angels charge over thee", and his reply: "Thou shalt not tempt the Lord thy God." (Matt 4:6–7) Sonship, divine promises, and the possession of true grace are entirely the wrong grounds for drawing you toward sin; and when sin is committed on such grounds, those very gifts become grievous aggravations of it.

Temptation 22. "The devil most dangerously imitates the Holy Spirit and comes in the form of an angel of light. He will champion knowledge in the Gnostics; unity and church government in the Papists; mortification in the Friars; free grace and tenderness toward the consciences of fellow believers in the Libertines; peace and mutual forbearance in the Socinians; zeal, self-denial, fearlessness of men, and claims to special revelation and spirituality in the Quakers. He will pose as an opponent of heresy, schism, error, disobedience, and hypocrisy, in those who hate and persecute true holiness and reformation; and when he chooses to seem religious, he will be superstitious and appear to outdo Christ himself."

Direction 22. Stay close to Christ, so that you may know his voice from the voice of strangers. Cultivate holy wisdom to test the spirits and to discern between things that differ. Let the whole framework of truth and godliness be established in your mind and heart, so that you can perceive when something would breach any part of it. The devil never promotes any good except in service of some evil. Therefore, examine where a thing tends, not only what it is, but what use he wants you to make of it. Love no evil because of any good claimed for it; and do not dislike or reject any good because others have put it to evil use. Whatever doctrine is brought to you, test it by these rules:

1. Accept no doctrine that is against the certain nature, attributes, and honor of God.

2. Nor any that is against the light or law of nature.

3. Nor any that is against Scripture.

4. Nor any that is against holiness of heart and life.

5. Nor any that is against charity and justice toward others.

6. Nor any, in matters to be ordered by human authority, that is against proper order, or against government and the peace of church and state.

7. Nor any that is against the true unity, peace, and fellowship of the saints.

8. Nor any that is certainly inconsistent with great and well-established truths.

By these tests, try the spirits, whether they are of God.

Temptation 23. "The tempter commonly draws people toward one extreme under the pretense of helping them avoid another, making them so afraid of the danger on one side that they take no heed of the danger on the other."

Direction 23. Understand all your dangers. Study the full scope of God’s commands and keep watch on every side. You must also know in which duties you are in danger of extremes, and in which you are not.

In those acts of the soul that are purely rational with respect to your ultimate end, knowing God, loving him, being willing and resolved to please him, you cannot do too much. Emotions, however, can potentially go too far even in relation to God, especially fear and grief, which may become more than nature can bear without distraction, death, or inability to fulfill duty. Few people are actually guilty of this. Toward created things, the emotions can far more easily exceed proper bounds; and in external actions toward God or other people there can certainly be excess. But it is especially in matters of judgment that it is easy to slide from one extreme into another.

2. In every duty you perform, every sin you avoid, and every truth you receive, you must know what the contrary extreme to that duty, sin, or truth is, and keep it in view. Without this kind of vigilance you will reel from side to side like a drunk man and never walk uprightly with God. You will swing from extravagance to greed, from cruel persecution to licentiousness, or from licentiousness back to persecuting cruelty, from hypocritical formalism to hypocritical pretended spirituality, or from enthusiasm and faction to dead formalism. I have addressed this at length in Chapter 5, Part 2, "Directions to Students."

Temptation 24. "On the contrary, the tempter will often plead moderation and prudence against a holy life and careful, zealous obedience to God. He would have you believe that being so diligent in duty and scrupulously afraid of sin is running into an extreme, being ‘righteous overmuch’, and that it makes religion a vexing, distracting thing, more trouble than it is worth."

Direction 24. I have answered this so often that I will say only this: God cannot be loved too much, nor heaven valued too highly, nor too diligently sought and obeyed; nor can sin and hell be too carefully avoided. No person need fear doing too much when he may be certain that, even after doing his very best, he will have done too little. Listen to what people say about this on their deathbeds.

Temptation 25. "The tempter would persuade us that one sin is necessary in order to avoid another, that of two evils you must choose the lesser, as though there were no other way. So James and John, acting from sinful and uncharitable zeal, desired to call down fire to punish sin (Luke 9:54); Peter chose to fight sinfully against the sinful Jews (Matt 26:52). So the tempter bids people lie in order to avoid some dishonor to God and religion, or persecute others to preserve the unity of the church and keep out sin, or commit a lesser sin themselves in order to escape a greater."

Direction 25. This is to abuse God, as though he had made necessary what he forbids, and had not provided sufficient lawful means for resisting every sin. It is to do willfully the very thing you claim to be unwilling to do, that is, to sin. Of two evils, avoid both; and be certain that you consent to neither.

Temptation 26. "He pleads Christian liberty to entice people to sin, especially sensuality. Has not Christ purchased your liberty to enjoy the created world? All things are yours. No one but the godly has a true right to them."

Direction 26. Christ never purchased us the freedom to abuse created things as a poison against ourselves, to hinder mortification, strengthen our enemy and our snare, and steal our hearts away from God. The liberty Christ has purchased is liberty from sin, not liberty to sin.

Temptation 27. "The tempter urges the necessity of wife, children, estate, life, and so forth. Necessity makes it lawful."

Direction 27. There is no necessity of sinning. Whoever thinks it more necessary to save his life or provide for wife and children than to obey his Lord cannot be Christ’s disciple. God must be trusted with these things.

Temptation 28. "But," says the tempter, "lust, love of honor, ease, and pleasure are natural to you, therefore they are no sin."

Direction 28. Nature is corrupted and sinful. It is equally natural to you to be rational, to govern your senses and appetites by reason, and not to act on every desire of lust or appetite, otherwise a man is no better than a beast.

Temptation 29. "But authority commands it: it is your parent’s or master’s will, and you must obey."

Direction 29. All authority derives from God, and therefore no authority stands against him or above him. Parents and masters must be obeyed in everything lawful, but not in sin. They cannot save you or themselves from the wrath of God.

Temptation 30. "But," says the tempter, "you have promised or vowed to do it, and are not free to refuse."

Direction 30. A vow of something lawful must be kept; but if you vow to sin, it is a further sin to carry it out, and to wrong God or your neighbor because you have vowed to do so does not make the wrong less wrong.

Temptation 31. "But the matter is disputed, and many learned and godly people think it is no sin."

Direction 31. That is all the more reason to be fearful and cautious. The case is evidently obscure, the snare is subtle, and you may be sure that learned and godly people on one side or the other are already deceived before you. Remember that God is your king and judge, and he will not accept as an excuse for sin that learned or good people did it or defended it. Consult not with flesh and blood, but with God.

Temptation 32. "But will you be singular, and be pointed at and mocked by everyone?"

Direction 32. In doctrine, I will not be singular from the Holy Catholic Church of God; in worship, I will not in singularity or schism separate from the communion of saints. But in doctrine I will indeed be singular from infidels and heretics, and in holy living I will be singular from the ungodly, the profane, and the sensual, lest, by doing as they do to avoid their scorn, I come to the same end as they do.

Temptation 33. "But you are weak, and you cannot help it until God gives you the grace to do otherwise."

Direction 33. That is precisely why I must not be willful, negligent, or rash, doing evil I could forbear, and resisting and refusing the grace, help, and mercy without which I can do nothing.

Temptation 34. "But you repent and ask God’s forgiveness through Christ every night for the sins of the day."

Direction 34. Repenting is a sorrowful turning of the heart from sin to God; you have not repented if you do not turn. To mock God with such hypocritical praying and repenting is itself a serious sin. Would you call it repentance if a man who spits in your face and strikes you every day were to ask your forgiveness at night, all while intending to do the same again, because he asked forgiveness?

Temptation 35. "But every man sins daily; you are only doing what the best people in the world do."

Direction 35. No truly justified Christian has any sin that he does not hate more than love, would not gladly be rid of, and does not strive against through holy means. No justified believer has a cherished sin he would rather keep than leave.

Temptation 36. "But those who appear strict and godly are hypocrites, secretly as bad as you."

Direction 36. This is exactly what we would expect from the devil, the accuser of those sanctified and justified by Christ, the father of malice and lies, charging on others what he himself admits is secret and cannot prove. So he said of Job that if Job’s estate and body were touched he would abandon his godliness; but the devil was found a liar. However that may be, I know for certain that I must be holy or I shall not see God, and if "I live after the flesh I shall die"; the misery of other people will be no comfort to me. (Heb 12:14 Rom 8:9, 13)

Temptation 37. "But if you will not sin, at least come near it, do what is lawful."

Direction 37. We must indeed not rush into the contrary extreme under the pretense of fleeing far enough from sin. But if you are keeping clear of other sins, you cannot be too far from any one of them. To be near sin is to be near God’s wrath and near what tends toward hellfire; and drawing near it is the common way of falling into it. The person who could wish he might do it is already infected at the heart. Keep a tender conscience and a constant sense of the danger of sinning.

Temptation 38. Sin gains a dangerous respectability in two ways:

1.) First, by giving it fair names, calling luxury and gluttony "keeping a good house and a good table"; calling drunken company "sharing a cup with a friend"; calling lust and filthiness "love"; calling worldliness "thrift and good economy"; calling idleness and wasted time "a gentleman’s leisure"; calling slothfulness "not being too worldly"; calling time-wasting pastimes "recreation"; calling pride "decency and good appearance"; calling proud revenge "honor and gallantry"; calling Romish cruelty, persecution, and the ravaging of the church "maintaining order, obedience, and unity"; calling disobedience to lawful authority "not fearing man"; and calling church divisions "strictness and zeal."

2.) Second, and especially powerfully, when a sin does not carry disgrace among the stricter sort of people, it greatly prepares others to commit it. Breaking the Lord’s Day is treated this way in many Reformed churches abroad. At home, spiritual pride, censoriousness, backbiting, disobedience, and church divisions are not held in nearly the disgrace among many who profess strictness that they deserve, nowhere near the disgrace attached to swearing and the like.

Direction 38. Remember that whatever the name or disguise, God judges righteously according to the truth. Names may deceive us, but they will not deceive our Judge. Sin remains in disgrace with God, whatever reputation it holds among men. Remember too that the more attractive the paint and covering are, the greater the danger, and the more watchful and cautious we ought to be. Our rule is not imperfect man, but the perfect law of God. The great success of this temptation should itself deter us from entertaining it. What immeasurable mischief it has done in the world!

Temptation 39. Sometimes the devil tempts people to some serious sin so that, if he cannot prevail in that, he may at least draw them into a lesser one. It is like a dishonest trader who asks twice the price of his goods so that, by appearing to come down greatly, he can make you willing to pay too much. One who wants a little must ask for a great deal. He will tempt you to drunkenness, and if he draws you only to tippling or wasting time, he has gained something. If he tempts you to fornication and succeeds in drawing you only to filthy thoughts or immodest, lascivious talk or actions, he has accomplished much of what he intended. If he tempts you to some terrible cruelty and you yield only to some lesser degree of it, or to unjust or uncharitable judgments of others, you think you have conquered, when it is he who has conquered.

Direction 39. Remember that the least degree of sin is still sin, and that "death is the wages of it." Do not think you have escaped well if your heart has taken any of the infection, or if you have been wounded at all, even if it could have been worse. If the tempter had tempted you to nothing more than a lustful, malicious, or proud thought or word, you would understand that his prevailing is his conquering. Recognize the same when he gains this much by brazenly asking for more.

Temptation 40. Sometimes the tempter makes us so fearful and watchful against one sin, or so occupied with one danger, that we become careless about another and lie open to his attack there. It is like a fencer who appears to aim entirely at one spot so that he may strike you elsewhere while you are guarding it, or like an enemy who raises all the alarm at one end of a city, drawing the people there while he storms another place. So Satan makes some people so afraid of worldliness that they do not watch against idleness; or so fearful of hard-heartedness, deadness, and hypocrisy that they do not watch against passion, neglect of their callings, or despondency; or so afraid of sinning or of being deceived about their salvation that they do not fear the absence of love, joy, and thankfulness for all the mercy they have received, nor the neglect of holy praise to God.

Direction 40. Remember that obedience must be entire and universal, and so Satan’s temptation is likewise directed against every part of your obedience. Your watchfulness must extend to all of it if you are to escape. Your excessive fear of any one particular failing would be cured if you spread that concern across all the rest.

Temptation 41. Sometimes, by the suddenness of a temptation, he catches people off guard before they are aware of what is happening.

Direction 41. Never be without your armor or off your watch, especially against sudden thoughts, sudden passions, or rash words, which are typically committed for lack of deliberation.

Temptation 42. Sometimes he works through intense vehemence, especially when he enlists passion on his side, so that reason is overwhelmed and the sinner says, "I could not help it."

Direction 42. Remember that the very wild unruliness of your passion is itself a sin; that no one can compel you to sin; and that reason must deliberate and govern your actions, otherwise every murder and act of wickedness could claim the excuse of urgent passion.

Temptation 43. Sometimes he uses the violence of other people: they threaten men in order to frighten them into sin.

Direction 43. But are not God and his threatenings more to be feared? People may threaten imprisonment, death, or ruin, yet God threatens everlasting misery. And can he not defend you from everything men threaten, if that is what is best for you? Consider the portion of the fearful: (Rev 21:8).

Temptation 44. Sometimes the variety of temptations distracts people so that they cannot attend to all of them at once.

Direction 44. Remember that one unguarded quarter of a city may lose the whole in a general assault.

Temptation 45. Sometimes he pauses, to make you feel secure, lay down your arms, and then he catches you off guard.

Direction 45. Be alert to Satan’s ambushes and beware of false security. Distinguish between a ceasefire and a victory. You have not conquered simply because you have rest and quiet from temptation. Until the sin is genuinely hated and the contrary grace or duty is being practiced, you have not overcome at all. Even when that is achieved, do not trust the devil or the flesh, and do not imagine the war will end before your life does, one assault begins where the last left off. Use every pause only to prepare for the next encounter.

Temptation 46. He will tempt you to mistake striving for overcoming, to suppose that because you pray and make some resistance, sin is conquered; and that because your desires are good, all is well.

Direction 46. Not all who fight overcome. "If a man strive for masteries, yet is he not crowned, except he strive lawfully" (2 Tim 2:5). "Many will seek to enter and shall not be able" (Luke 13:24).

Temptation 47. He pursues the sinner with constant importunity until he wears him down and makes him yield.

Direction 47. Consider the following.

1.) Remember that Christ is as persistent in seeking to save you as the devil can be in seeking to destroy you, which, then, should prevail?

2.) Be equally constant in resistance: be as frequent in prayer and other strengthening means. Do as Paul (2 Cor 12:7–8) did, who prayed three times (as Christ did in his agony), when the thorn in the flesh was not removed.

3.) Do not encourage the tempter by giving him any hope: a faint refusal is an invitation to try again. Give him a prompt and firm denial and deprive him of hope, if you would shorten the temptation.

Temptation 48. Last, the devil would plunge the sinner into despair, persuading him that it is now too late.

Direction 48. Recognize his design: it is simply to remove the hope that sets the soul’s wheels turning. In everything he is against God and against you, in other sins he attacks God’s authority; in this one he attacks God’s love and mercy. Read the Gospel and you will find that Christ’s death is sufficient, that the promise is universal, full, and free, that the day of grace extends as far as the day of death, that no one who truly desires it will be refused it, and that the same God who forbids your presumption also forbids your despair.

Temptations to Draw Us Away from Duty

 

Temptation 1. The greatest temptation against duty is persuading people that something is not a duty at all. We have seen this in our own day, when almost every duty has been abandoned on the strength of this kind of error. One person says that the holy observance of the Lord’s Day is not commanded by God in Scripture. Another asks what Scripture warrant there is for family prayer, singing psalms, baptizing infants, praying before and after sermons, or for offices, ordination, tithes, church buildings, and so on. Another says that church government and discipline are not of divine institution. Another says that baptism and the Lord’s Supper were for that age only. And so, instead of performing their duties, people simply abolish them.

Direction 1. Read and fear (Matt 5:19): "Whosoever shall break one of these least commandments, and shall teach men so, he shall be called the least in the kingdom of heaven; but whosoever shall do and teach them, the same shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven." Denying duty is too easy a way of evading obedience to serve any real purpose. Denying the laws that bind you to public obligations will not free you from them, deny them as you will, you may still be compelled to comply. God will make it more costly for you if he must enforce duty from you. Must he take you to law over it? He will quickly show you the law and prove that it was your duty. Bring your doubts to capable and learned men, and you will hear more evidence than you currently know; but if pride and a corrupt heart blind you, you must bear the punishment.

Temptation 2. The tempter says: such duties belong to weaker believers, but not to you. You must not remain forever under ordinances, in the lower class. Every day should be a Sabbath to you, every meal a sacrament, every place a church, you must live above ordinances in Christ.

Direction 2. We must certainly live free from the Mosaic ordinances (Col 2:18–21), but not above Christ’s ordinances, unless you intend to live above obedience and above Christ’s government. Has not Christ appointed the ministry and the helps of the church "till we all come to a perfect man" (Eph 4:13), and promised to "be with them to the end of the world" (Matt 28:20)? It is a foolish pride that leads you to suppose you have no need of the means Christ himself has instituted.

Temptation 3. But you are too unworthy to pray or to receive the sacrament; these things are not for dogs.

Direction 3. Those who are unworthy are the willfully impenitent who refuse grace. The willing soul who earnestly desires to be what God would have him be has an accepted worthiness in Christ.

Temptation 4. But while you are in doubt, you do not act in faith, and therefore to you it is sin.

Direction 4. But is it not a greater sin to leave the duty undone? Will doubting about every duty excuse you from all of them? That would be a very convenient path to freedom from every obligation, simply doubt whether you should believe in God, or in Christ, or love him, or live a godly life, and apparently you would be excused. But if you doubted whether you should feed your child and then let it starve, you would deserve to be treated as a murderer. If you doubt a duty, it remains your duty, and your first obligation is to resolve your doubts. It is indifferent things, matters left to your own choice, that must not be done with a doubtful conscience: it was of such things that Paul spoke.

Temptation 5. The devil always places something in the way that appears urgent, in order to crowd out duty.

Direction 5. God has not assigned you work and then denied you the time to do it. Is all your time genuinely spent in better things? Is it not your carnal mind that makes carnal things seem most urgent? Christ says, "One thing is needful" (Luke 10:42). "Seek first the kingdom of God and his righteousness, and all these things shall be added to you" (Matt 6:33). If you had the love and delight in holiness that you ought to have, you would find time for it. An unwelcome guest is put off with any excuse.

Others, as pressed for time as you, find time for duty because they are willing. Set your affairs in order, let everything keep its proper place, and you will have time for every duty.

Temptation 6. But you are so incapable and unskilled at prayer and learning that it is as well never to attempt it.

Direction 6. Apply yourself to learn, and observe those who have skill; then do what you can. You must learn by practice, an unskilled attempt at duty is better than none. Wordless groans often come from the Spirit of God, and God understands and accepts them (Rom 8:26–27).

Temptation 7. But it will be so hard and take so long to learn that you will never get past it.

Direction 7. Willingness and diligence carry the promise of God’s help. Remember, this is something that must be done. When your own neglect and sin have made it hard, will you offer that as an excuse to God and your own soul? If you had neglected to teach a child to speak or walk while young, should that child therefore never learn? Will you despair and give up all hope on that pretense? Or do you expect to be saved without prayer and other holy duty? Both of these responses are foolish. Sick people must eat even when they have no appetite, otherwise they cannot live.

Temptation 8. But you find yourself no better for duty, and even worse for it.

Direction 8. Satan will do everything he can to make things go worse for you after duty than before. He tries to discourage you by blocking your sense of progress, so that you conclude it is all pointless. Many preachers, having fished long and caught nothing, grow cold and dispirited, ready to sit down and say with Jeremiah, "I will not make mention of him, nor speak any more in his name" (Jer 20:9). The same pattern appears in prayer, the sacrament, reproof, and the rest, the devil makes great use of the question, "What good has it done you?" But patience and perseverance win the crown.

The beginning is seldom the time to perceive results. A carpenter works long before a house is raised; nature does not produce the plant or bring forth new life on the first day. Your lifetime is your working time. Do your part, and God will not fail on his. It is his part to give success, do you dare accuse him or doubt him?

There is more of the answer to prayer to be believed than to be felt. If God has promised to hear, he does hear, and we must believe it whether we feel it or not. Prayers are often answered long before the thing we prayed for arrives, we pray for heaven, but we will not be there until death. If Moses’s message to Pharaoh seemed lost ten times over, it was not lost for all that. What work would ever have been done if it were abandoned at the first sign of failure? Be glad that you have time to plow and sow, to do your part, and trust God to give fruit at last.

Temptation 9. But the tempter says: things have gone worse for you in the world since you set yourself to read, pray, and live obediently. You have been poorer and more despised than ever before: "You are a derision daily, every one mocketh you" (Jer 20:8). This is what you get from it.

Direction 9. Anyone who never reckoned that being a holy Christian might cost more than this did not begin well. If God in heaven is not enough to be your portion, never serve him, go and find something better if you can. A person who cannot lose the world cannot use it rightly. If you would rather be at the devil’s provision and disposal than at God’s, you are welcome to whatever you get from that choice. And if you think your very soul is worse off, remember: we are not at our worst when we are most troubled. Medicine makes a patient sick when it is working properly.

Temptation 10. Satan fills many people with an abundance of scruples about every duty, so that they come to it as sick people come to food, in a peevish, quarrelsome frame of mind. This is wrong with it, that is wrong with it; something is always amiss and they cannot get it down. The minister has this fault in praying or preaching; this circumstance is wrong; the others joining in worship have some defect, and all of this is designed to turn them away from everything.

Direction 10. But do you improve matters by casting off everything, or by running into greater evils? Is not their imperfect prayer and communion better than your idle neglect of all duty, or your unjustifiable separation? It is the mark of an upright heart to be most watchful over oneself and most critical of one’s own conduct; it is the mark of a hypocrite to be most quarrelsome about the manner of other people’s worship, and to be easily driven from the worship of God and the fellowship of the saints by any available pretext.

Temptation 11. The devil will set one duty against another, reading against hearing, praying against preaching, private worship against public, outward worship against inward, mercy against justice, piety against charity, and he always labors to drive out the greater.

Direction 11. The work of God forms a harmonious and well-composed whole. Leave out a part and you damage the whole, and undermine your benefit from everything else. Place each duty in its proper order, and each part helps rather than hinders the others. Let each duty plead for the rest, but set none aside.

Temptation 12. The most common and most damaging temptation is the removal of appetite for holy duties by deadening the sense of one’s own need. When the soul is drowsy and feels no need of prayer, reading, hearing, or meditation, when it thinks itself tolerably well without such things, or when it grows sick of them and is troubled to perform them, so that every duty is like eating to an upset stomach, then it is easy to be tempted to neglect or omit many a duty. A small thing is enough to push it aside when people feel no need of it.

Direction 12. Keep a lively sense of your needs. Remind yourself constantly that time is short, death is near, and you are far less ready than you ought to be. Stay acquainted with your own heart and life, and every day will show you your necessities, which are greatest when they are least felt.

Temptation 13. The tempter gains much by attributing the results of holy means to your own effort, or to chance, or to something else entirely, and by making you overlook the actual benefit you have received, benefit that would greatly encourage you. When you are delivered from sickness or danger after prayer, he tells you that you might have recovered just the same without ever praying. Was it not the physician’s skill and care, and the excellent medicine? And if you prosper in some business, was it not through your own planning and diligence?

Direction 13. This habit of separating God from his means, when God is working precisely through those means, is the error of practical atheism. When God answers your prayer in sickness or danger, he shows it by directing the physician, or you yourself, to the right treatment and by blessing that treatment. He is just as truly the cause, and prayer just as truly the first means, as if he had worked your deliverance by a miracle. Do not many people use the same physician, the same medicine, and the same diligence, and yet come to grief? Careful attention to the answers of prayer would go a long way toward correcting this error. All our industry must say with Peter and John, "Why look ye so earnestly on us, as if by our own power or holiness we had done this?", when God is glorifying his grace and honoring his appointed means (Acts 3:12).

Temptation 14. Finally, the devil sets up something else in opposition to holy duty in order to make it appear unnecessary. In some people he raises up their good desires and says: God knows your heart without any outward expression of it, you can have just as good a heart at home as at church. In others he substitutes superstitious inventions of human devising for God’s own institutions. In others he pleads the Spirit against external duty, saying: the Spirit is everything; the flesh profits nothing. In some he even sets Christ himself against Christ’s own ordinances, saying: it is not these but Christ who profits you.

Direction 14. This is self-contradictory madness, setting Christ against Christ, and the Spirit against the ordinances of the Spirit. Was it not Christ and the Spirit who appointed them? Does Christ not know best the way in which he will give his grace? Can you nourish the soul and its life while killing the body? Can you have the water yet disregard the spring or cistern, and cut off the pipes that must convey it? It is astonishing that Satan could make people so irrational, as this reasoning has shown us many are in our own day. To set up superstition, or to plead a good heart, against God’s appointed worship is to accuse the one who appointed it of not knowing what he was doing, and to imagine that we are wiser than he, and to display a good heart by disobedience, pride, and contempt for God and his mercies.

Temptations That Aim to Frustrate Holy Duties and Make Them Ineffectual

 

The devil is extremely diligent in this work for three reasons:

1. That he may drive the soul to despair, leading it to say: I have used all the means and they have been in vain, there is no hope.

2. To double the sinner’s misery by turning the very remedy into a disease.

3. To display his malice against Christ, and to say: I have turned your own appointed means to your dishonor.

Consider, therefore, how greatly we are concerned to perform the work of God effectively. Means well used lead to more grace, to communion with God, and to salvation; but when ill used, they dishonor and provoke him, and destroy ourselves, like children who cut their fingers with a knife they should have used to cut their food.

Temptation 1. Duty is frustrated by false ends:

1. Trying to move God to tolerate one’s sin, when duty’s proper purpose is to destroy sin.

2. Trying to make satisfaction to God for sin, which is Christ’s work alone.

3. Trying to merit grace, when the imperfection of our performance merits wrath.

4. Trying to prosper in the world and escape affliction (Jas 4:3), which is merely serving the flesh and expecting God to serve it too.

5. Trying to quiet conscience while continuing in a course of sin, adding sin upon sin by offering the sacrifice of fools.

6. Trying to win human approval, and indeed they have their reward (Matt 6:5).

7. Trying to secure salvation only when the world and sin can no longer be kept, which amounts to hoping the Gospel may be proved false and God proved unjust.

Direction 1. First, ensure the heart is honest, and that God, heaven, and holiness are what you most desire, otherwise everything you do will lack right ends.

Temptation 2. When ignorance or error causes people to take God for what he is not, thinking of him blasphemously, as if he resembled them, approved of their sins, or had no love for holiness, they frustrate all their worship of him.

Direction 2. Study God in his Son, in his Word, in his saints, and in his works. Know him as described earlier (Chapter 3, Direction 4), and take care that your wicked, corrupted heart or willful forgetting of him does not blind your understanding.

Temptation 3. Coming to God in yourself and outside of Christ, using his name only out of habit rather than in faith and confidence, frustrates duty.

Direction 3. Know clearly your sin, your vileness, and what you deserve, together with the justice and holiness of God. Then you will see that unless Christ reconciles and justifies you by his blood, sanctifies and helps you by his Spirit, makes you a child of God, and intercedes for you, there is no access to God and no standing in his presence.

Temptation 4. The tempter would have you pray hypocritically, with the tongue only and not the heart, offering God a few customary words, seeming to pray as one dismisses the poor with empty words (Jas 2), whether in a form of words not understood, not truly considered, or not felt; or in grosser hypocrisy still, praying for the holiness one does not actually want and against the sin one is unwilling to leave.

Direction 4. Fear the holy, jealous, heart-searching God who hates hypocrisy, who must be worshiped sincerely in spirit and truth, and who demands to be held holy by all who draw near him (Lev 10:3). He says that those who "draw nigh him with the lips, when the heart is far from him" "worship him in vain" (Matt 15:8–9). See God by faith as present with you, know yourself, and this will awaken you to seriousness (Heb 4:13 Hos 8:12–13).

Temptation 5. The tempter would destroy faith and hope, making you doubt whether you will gain anything through duty.

Direction 5. But consider:

1. Why would God command duty and promise blessing if he did not mean to perform it?

2. Remember God’s infiniteness, omnipresence, and all-sufficiency. He is as truly with you as you are where you stand; he upholds you; he shows by his mercies that he regards you, and by his care for lesser things. If he regards you, he regards your duties. It is no greater thing for him to hear your prayers than if you were the only creature he had to hear. Believe, then, and hope, and wait upon him.

Temptation 6. Sometimes the tempter will promise you more through holy duty than God himself promises, making you expect deliverance from every enemy, from want and sickness, and a speedier deliverance of your soul than God has ever promised, all in order to make you cast everything aside as worthless and conclude that God has failed you when your expectations go unmet.

Direction 6. God will fulfill everything he has promised, but not everything the devil and you yourself promise. Look to what God promises in his Word. That is sufficient. Make his promises, and nothing beyond them, the goal of your duties.

Temptation 7. The tempter commonly draws you away from the heart and life of duty by placing too much weight on the outward form, the mere performance of the act, the giving of alms, the hearing of sermons, the saying of words, the polished expression and orderly manner. All of these are good in their place when animated by spirit, life, and seriousness.

Direction 7. Look first and most to the soul in duty, and to the soul of duty itself. A picture of food does not nourish; a picture of fire does not warm. God does not want dead formality in place of spiritual worship. We ourselves pay no attention to words except insofar as they express the heart. Let the outward form have only its due.

Temptation 8. The tempter leads you to rest in a forced, affected, counterfeit fervor, stirred up by the desire to impress others.

Direction 8. Look chiefly to God and to holy motives, and less to people, so that all your fire is holy, drawn from heaven.

Temptation 9. The tempter would keep you in a lazy, sluggish coldness, reading, hearing, and praying as if half asleep, as if you were not really doing it at all.

Direction 9. Rouse yourselves with an awareness of God’s presence and the immense importance of what you are doing, and refuse to yield to sloth.

Temptation 10. The tempter would have you bring a divided, distracted heart to duty, a heart that is half occupied with worldly business.

Direction 10. Remember that God is jealous, that your business with him is great, and that much depends on it. Call your heart back, and do not let it remain elsewhere. All the powers of your soul are barely enough for such work (Ezek 33:31).

Temptation 11. Ignorance, unskilfulness, and unfamiliarity with duty are a serious obstacle for most people.

Direction 11. Learn through study joined with practice; do not grow weary, and difficulties will be overcome.

Temptation 12. Putting duty out of its proper place and neglecting the fittest season for it often leads to its being done carelessly.

Direction 12. Redeem time and dispatch other business, so that idleness does not rob you of the leisure needed for duty. Do all things in order.

Temptation 13. Neglecting one duty is the tempter’s snare for ruining another. If he keeps you from reading, you will not understand well what you hear. If he keeps you from meditating, you will not digest what you hear or read. If he keeps you from hearing, you will lack both material and vitality for prayer, meditation, and conversation. If he keeps you from godly company, you will be hindered in all these things and in their practice as well. Not one duty can be omitted without your being weakened in all the rest.

Direction 13. Observe how each duty helps the others, and take them all together, each in its proper place.

Temptation 14. Sometimes the tempter calls you away to another duty, interjecting untimely urgings toward something that is good in its proper season. He interrupts prayer by drawing you into meditation; he sets seeming truth against love, peace, and concord.

Direction 14. Always discern which duties are greatest and which season belongs to each, and do all in order.

Temptation 15. The tempter ruins duty by causing you to perform it only as a duty and not also as a means for the good of your own soul, or only as a means and not also as a duty. If you do it only as a duty, you will not be stirred by the ends and benefits, nor carried forward by hope, nor will you shape your performance toward its goal, nor be as fervent and vigorous as a lively sense of your own good would make you. If you do it only as a means and not as a duty, you will give up or grow faint when you lack or doubt the outcome, whereas a sense of both together would make you both vigorous and constant.

Direction 15. Keep yourself under a sense of God’s authority, so that you feel bound to obey him whatever the outcome, and resolve to wait on him in an obedient way. At the same time, admire his wisdom in fitting all duties to your benefit, commanding you nothing that is not for your own good, or the good of others, or his own honor. Mark the reason and purpose of each duty, and your own deep need of it.

Temptation 16. The tempter hinders you in duty as well as from duty, by setting you to quarrel with the minister, the words, the company, the manner, or the circumstances, so that these things divert your thoughts from the substance of duty, or distract your mind with groundless scruples.

Direction 16. Pray and labor for a clear judgment and an upright, self-examining, humble heart, one that dwells most within itself, looks most to the spiritual substance of duty, and does not crave singularity.

Temptation 17. The tempter ruins duty through your inconstancy: you read or pray so seldom that you have lost the benefit of one duty before you come to the next, and you grow cold in the intervals between.

Direction 17. Remember that this is not a diversion but your calling, and it stands in the same relation to your soul as eating does to your body.

Temptation 18. Sometimes Satan corrupts duty through people’s private passions, interests, and opinions, leading them in preaching and praying to vent their own conceits and resentments, to attack those who differ from or offend them, and so to profane the name and work of God, or to seek proudly the praise of other people.

Direction 18. Remember that God is most jealous in his worship and hates hypocritical profaneness above all other profaneness. Search your hearts and put your passions to death, especially selfishness, remembering that it is a poisonous and insinuating sin that will easily conceal itself under a cloak of zeal.

Temptation 19. A false-hearted, half-committed spirit is among the most accursed corrupters of holy duty: when the soul is not wholly given up to God, but takes up duty from some common motive, because it is respectable, or to please a friend, intending to try it for a while and leave it off if it proves unappealing.

Direction 19. Fear God, you hypocrite, and stop wavering between two opinions. If the Lord is God, obey and serve him with all your heart. But if the devil and the flesh are better masters, follow them and let him go.

Temptation 20. Last, the tempter greatly hinders holy duty through wandering thoughts, melancholy perplexities, and a storm of temptations that torment and distract some Christians until they cry out, "I cannot pray, I cannot meditate," growing weary of duty and even of life itself.

Direction 20. This reveals the malice of the tempter and your own weakness; but if you would rather be delivered from it, it does not hinder your acceptance with God. For fuller treatment of this, read what I have written in Chapter 5, Part 2, at length, especially in my Directions to the Melancholy.

I have been forced to treat many things briefly here that deserved fuller handling. I must now omit the account of those temptations by which Satan keeps people in sin once he has drawn them into it; 2. those by which he causes decline in grace and outright apostasy; and 3. those by which he brings distress upon true believers, for otherwise this Direction would swell into a treatise of its own, and most readers will already think it too long, even though the brevity I have used throughout, in order to avoid prolixity, does the subject a real injustice. Familiarity with temptations is essential to overcoming them.

CHAPTER 32

GRAND DIRECTION 10: LAY OUT YOUR LIFE IN DOING GOD SERVICE AND ALL THE GOOD YOU CAN

 

‘Your lives must be laid out in doing God service, and doing all the good you can, in works of piety, justice, and charity, with prudence, fidelity, industry, zeal, and delight; remembering that you are engaged to God, as servants to their Lord and master; and are entrusted with his talents, and must give account of how you have improved them.’

The next relation between Christ and us that we must consider, subordinate to that of King and subjects, is this relation of Master and servants. Though Christ says to the apostles, "Henceforth I call you not servants, but friends" (John 15:15), the meaning is not that he does not call them servants at all, but that they are more than mere servants: they are admitted to such knowledge of his counsels as his friends enjoy. For he immediately, in verse 20, bids them "Remember that the servant is not greater than the lord." And in John 13:13: "Ye call me Master and Lord; and ye say well, for so I am." And in Matthew 23:8: "One is your Master, Christ; and all ye are brethren," repeated in verse 10. The apostles likewise called themselves the "servants of Jesus Christ" (Rom 1:1 1 Cor 4:1 Phil 1:1), and "of God" (Titus 1:1).

He is called our Master, and we his servants, because he is our Ruler with full and absolute ownership. He does not give us laws to obey while we go about our own business, but gives us his work to do, together with laws governing how we are to do it rightly. It is service conducted under his eye and in dependence on him for our daily provision, as servants depend on their lord. God has work for us to do in the world, and he will require its performance. God bids his sons, "Go work to day in my vineyard" (Matt 21:28), and expects that they do it (Matt 21:31). His "servants" are as "husbandmen," to whom "he entrusteth his vineyard, that he may receive the fruit" (Matt 21:33–34, 21:41, and 21:43).

"Faithful servants" shall be "made rulers over his household" (Matt 24:45–46). Christ delivers to his servants his talents to improve, and will require an account of that improvement at his coming (Matt 25:14). Good works, in the proper and comprehensive sense, are all actions, internal and external, that are morally good. In the narrower sense, they are works that are not only formally good as acts of obedience in general, but also materially good in the way that a servant’s work benefits his master, or benefits others whose welfare the master regards. Because the doctrine of good works is disputed in our time, I will first set it out briefly, and then give the Directions.

1. Nothing is more certain than that God does not need the service of any creature, and that he receives no addition to his perfection or happiness from it. It follows that, on the terms of commutative justice, which gives one thing in exchange for another, as in buying and selling, no creature is capable of meriting anything at his hands.

2. It is certain that on the terms of the law of works, which required perfect obedience as the condition of life, no sinner can perform any work so good as to merit, by distributive or governing justice, anything at God’s hands.

3. It is certain that Christ has so fulfilled the law of works as to merit for us.

4. The redeemed are not without a master; they still have a Lord, who now holds a double right to govern them. This governor gives them a law, and this law requires them to do good works to the full extent of their ability. It binds as obligingly as the law of works did, though not as terribly. By this law of Christ we must be judged, and to be judged is nothing other than to be justified or condemned. Such works are therefore rewardable according to the distributive justice of the law of grace, by which we are judged.

When the ancient fathers, without opposition, spoke of good works as meritorious with God, they meant no more than that these are works which the righteous Judge of the world will reward according to the law of grace by which he judges us. Once this doctrine is agreed upon as certain truth, the only remaining dispute with them is whether the word merit was used properly or improperly. I have shown at length in my Confession that both Scripture and common usage support the fathers’ use of the word.

5. Christ is so far from redeeming us from any necessity of good works that he died in order to restore us to a capacity and ability to perform them, and has made us new for that very end. "He gave himself for us, that he might redeem us from all iniquity, and purify to himself a peculiar people, zealous of good works" (Titus 2:14). "For we are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus to good works, which God hath before ordained that we should walk in them" (Eph 2:10).

6. Good works set in opposition to Christ, his satisfaction, merit, righteousness, mercy, or free grace in the matter of justification or salvation are not good works at all, but proud self-confidence and sin. Good works, however, kept in their proper subordination to God’s mercy and Christ’s merits and grace, are both necessary and rewardable.

7. Though God needs none of our works, that which is materially good pleases him, insofar as it tends to his glory and to our own and others’ benefit, in which he delights.

8. God glorifies himself in the world by communicating his goodness and excellencies to the creature. In heaven, where this communication is fullest, he is most glorified. The praise given to the creature who receives everything from God is therefore God’s own praise. It is no dishonor to God that his creature is honored by being good and being recognized as good. Were it otherwise, God would never have created anything, for fear of detracting from himself; or he would have made creatures bad, lest their goodness should dishonor him; and he would be most pleased with the wicked and least pleased with the best, as those who dishonor him most. But even madness recoils from such notions.

9. Therefore, as an act of mercy to us and for his own glory, just as in the beginning he made all things very good, he will make the new creature according to his image, which is holy and just and good, and will employ us in good works. It is our honor, our gain, and our happiness to be so employed by him. Just as he will not communicate light to the world without the sun, whose glory detracts nothing from his own honor, so he will not perform good works in the world solely and immediately by himself, but through his servants. Doing good must be their calling and their daily occupation, what they are made for, as the sun is made to give light and heat to lesser things. "Let your light so shine before men, that they may see your good works, and glorify your Father which is in heaven" (Matt 5:16). Christ was far from the opinion of those who think that good works attributed to good men are dishonoring to God.

As Scaliger says, a good man is one who does good to whomever he can and harms no one. And Acosta writes that the minister of the Gospel should not think it beneath him to visit the sick, to refresh them with some gift, to feed the hungry with at least common bread, to clothe the naked, to rescue the poor man who has no helper from the slanders and power of the rich, to appeal to the prince or magistrate on behalf of the afflicted, to build up a household by his counsel, to stand diligently and kindly by the dying, and to settle lawsuits and quarrels. (Acosta, bk. iv, ch. 18.)

10. The person most obligated to God is the one most exercised in good works. The more we do, the more we receive from him; and our very doing is itself our receiving, for it is he who "giveth us both to will and to do," by his operation in us (Phil 2:13), even "he, without whom we can do nothing" (John 15:5).

11. The obligation to good works, that is, to works of piety, justice, and charity, is essential to us as servants of the Lord. We are practical atheists if we do not perform works of piety toward God. We are rebels against God, enemies to ourselves, and unfit for human society if we do not do what is good for ourselves and for others when we have the ability and opportunity. This is the fruit God expects from us; and if we bear it not, he will cut us down and cast us into the fire.

12. Though causing no harm will never suffice without doing good, the same works are not required of all, nor to the same degree, but according to every person’s talent and opportunities (Matt 25:14–15).

13. God looks not only, nor even primarily, at the outward act, but far more at the heart of the one who performs it; not at the length of time served, but at the sincerity and diligence of his servants. He is so just that he will not withhold the reward promised to those who have borne the burden and heat of the day; yet he is so gracious and generous that he will give as much to those whom he finds equally willing and diligent, who would have done more had they had the opportunity (Matt 20:12–15). All of this makes plain what our doctrine concerning good works actually is, and how little those Papists are to be believed who tell their uninformed followers that we regard good works as useless and unnecessary.

Directions for Faithful Serving of Christ, and Doing Good

 

Direction 1. Make certain that you possess inwardly the holiness, justice, and charity that are the necessary foundations of good works. "A good tree will bring forth good fruit, and an evil tree evil fruit: make the tree good, and the fruit good: a good man out of the good treasure of his heart bringeth forth good things: and an evil man out of the evil treasure of his heart bringeth forth evil things." As evil works proceed from the heart (Matt 15:19–20), so must good works (Matt 7:16–20).

Can the dead perform the works of the living? Can the unholy do works of holiness, or the unrighteous works of justice, or the uncharitable works of charity? Will someone who hates Christ’s members on earth do good to them? Will he not rather imprison them than visit them in prison, and strip them of all they have rather than feed and clothe them? And even if a person does something outwardly good from pride or some other sinful motive, God does not accept it, he regards every sacrifice offered without the heart as carrion.

Direction 2. Do not content yourself with doing occasional good on the side, or only when pressed into it. Study to do good and make it the central occupation of your life. Given how many obligations and how great encouragements you have, do whatever you do with all your might. If you want to know whether you are a servant of Christ or a servant of the flesh, the question must be: which of these commands the main care and diligence of your life? Just as every carnal act does not prove you a servant of the flesh, no single good action proves you a servant of Christ.

Direction 3. Before undertaking any work, consider whether you can honestly say it is service to God and will be accepted by him. Ensure that it is done:

1.) To his glory, or to please him.

2.) In obedience to his command.

Purely natural actions that have no moral character, things that are neither good nor evil and so fall outside the scope of morality, are not our present concern, since they do not involve rational or obediential choice: the blinking of an eye, which foot you step forward first, or the choice of this or that food, drink, tool, company, or action when all options are genuinely equal and the matter calls for no rational or obediential decision. But every act done deliberately and rationally as a matter of choice must be made morally good by doing it, first, to a right end, and second, according to the rule. "Whether we eat, or drink, or whatsoever we do," that is, whatever involves rational choice, "must be done by us to the glory of God" (1 Cor 10:31).

Not all works tend equally to his glory; some do so more immediately and directly, others more remotely; but all must ultimately have that end. Even servants laboring at hard physical work must "do it as to the Lord, and not (only, or ultimately) to men, not with eye-service as men-pleasers, but as the servants of Christ," from whom their greatest reward or punishment will come (Eph 6:5–8 Col 3:22–25). All the comforts of food, rest, recreation, and pleasure that we enjoy should be aimed at fitting us for our Master’s work, or at strengthening, cheering, and helping us in it. Deliberately do nothing that falls under the government of reason except as God’s service in the world, what you can truly say he has set you to do.

Direction 4. Do not set the duties of piety, justice, and charity against one another as though they were enemies. Receive them as inseparable, just as God has made them. Do not imagine you can offer God a sacrifice purchased by injury, bribery, fraud, oppression, or any uncharitable act. And do not claim the benefit of others, or the safety of societies and kingdoms, as a justification for impiety toward the Lord. Some think they earn credit by remedying the harms they themselves have caused. But as Seneca says, it is wickedness to push someone under so that you may pull him out, to overthrow him so that you may raise him up, to shut him in so that you may let him go. The ending of an injury is no benefit, and it was never a merit to take away what the one who took it away had himself inflicted. (Seneca, On Benefits, bk. vi, ch. 26.)

Direction 5. Familiarize yourself with all the talents you receive from God, and with the uses to which they ought to be put. Keep a faithful account of what you have received and what goods of your Master have been placed in your hands. Make it a central part of your study to understand what every thing in your hand is good for in your Master’s service, and how he would have you employ it.

Direction 6. Keep an account of your expenditures, at least of all your most significant talents, and bring yourself daily or frequently to a reckoning of what good you have done or attempted. Every day is given to you for some good work; keep account of every day, in conscience, not on paper. Every mercy must be put to some good use; call yourself to account for every mercy, and ask what you have done with it in your Master’s service. Do not suppose that hours, minutes, and small mercies may pass without entering the reckoning. A servant who thinks he may do as he pleases with small sums, laying out only the larger amounts for his master’s use and keeping the smaller for himself, will prove unfaithful and fall short in his accounts. Sums smaller than pounds must still be reckoned.

Direction 7. Take special care that the common thief, your carnal self, whether in your own person or in your attachments to family, does not rob God of what he rightfully expects and devour what he requires. It is not without reason that God calls for the first fruits: "Honour the LORD with thy substance, and with the first fruits of all thine increase: so shall thy barns be filled with plenty, and thy presses shall burst out with new wine" (Prov 3:9–10); and the same claim of the first fruits runs through the law and the prophets (Exod 23:16 Exod 23:19 Exod 34:22 Exod 34:26 Lev 2:12 Lev 2:14 Neh 10:35 Ezek 20:40 Ezek 44:30 Ezek 48:14). If carnal self were served first, its devouring greed would leave God nothing. Though godliness with contentment is great gain if one has but food and clothing, where people have many hundreds or thousands a year, if it all pours into that gulf there will barely be enough for themselves and their children.

Indeed, whoever begins with God has the promise of his abundant provision; but whoever must first serve the flesh falls into such a consuming thirst for more that everything merely feeds it. The devil engineers for such people an endless array of needs and uses for all they have, so that they end up with no more to spare than far poorer people, able to give God nothing but the leavings of the flesh, whatever it can do without, which is commonly next to nothing. Though in particular holy uses first-fruits and fixed portions satisfied the requirement, God must in truth have all, and the flesh, in any disordered or ultimate sense, must have none. Every penny spent on ourselves, our children, and our friends must be spent as by God’s own appointment, in order to serve and please him. Watch carefully, or this thievish, carnal self will leave God nothing.

Direction 8. Prefer greater duties over lesser ones, all else being equal, and work hard to discern which is the greater and which should take precedence. This does not mean that any genuine duty is to be neglected; but what we call a duty in this sense is something materially good and appropriate in its proper season. When that thing cannot be done without omitting something greater, it is formally no duty at all at that moment. For a minister to be praying with his family or comforting one afflicted soul when he ought to be preaching publicly is to do something that is a duty in its proper season, but at that moment is his sin. It is an unfaithful servant who is busy with some small task when he should be saving an animal from drowning, rescuing the house from fire, or doing the greater part of his work.

Direction 9. Prudence is absolutely necessary for doing good, so that you can discern good from evil, judge the right season, measure, and manner, and determine which among competing duties must take precedence. Labor diligently to acquire wisdom; and if you lack it yourself, be sure to draw on those who possess it, asking their counsel in every important and difficult case.

Zeal without judgment has not only entangled souls in many serious sins, but has ruined churches and kingdoms, while under the pretense of surpassing others in doing good it has made people the greatest instruments of evil. There is hardly a sin so great and odious that ignorant zeal will not lead people to commit it as though it were a good work. Christ told his apostles that those who killed them would think they were doing God service. And Paul testified of the murderous, persecuting Jews "that they had a zeal of God, but not according to knowledge." The Papists’ murders of Christians under the name of heretics have written it before the world, in the blood of many hundreds of thousands, what ignorant and carnal zeal will do in the name of good, and what sacrifice it will offer up to God.

Lord Bacon stated the qualification well. Christ said, "Sell all and give to the poor, and follow me"; but sell not all, unless you follow me, that is, unless you have a calling in which you may do as much good with little means as with great. (Bacon, Essays, 13.)

Direction 10. In doing good, prefer the souls of men over their bodies, all else being equal. To convert a sinner from the error of his way is to save a soul from death and to cover a multitude of sins (Jas 5:20). This is a greater work than giving a man an alms. Just as cruelty to souls is the most heinous cruelty, as persecutors and soul-betraying pastors will one day know to their irreversible sorrow, so mercy to souls is the greatest mercy.

Yet sometimes mercy to the body must take precedence in a given moment, for everything is excellent in its proper season. If a man is drowning or starving, you must not delay relieving his body while you preach to him for his conversion; relieve him first, and then instruct him when the moment allows. The greatest duty does not always come first in time: sometimes a lesser work is a necessary preparation for a greater one, and sometimes a physical benefit may tend more to the good of souls than some spiritual work may. I say again, therefore, that prudence and an honest heart are worth more than many directions: they look not only at the immediate benefit of an action but at its furthest tendency and remote effects.

Direction 11. In doing good, prefer the good of the many, especially the good of the church or commonwealth, over the good of one or a few, all else being equal. Many are worth more than one; many will honor God and serve him more than one; and so both piety and charity require it. Yet this must also be understood with the qualification "all else being equal," for it is possible that some cases of exception may arise. Paul’s is a striking example: he could have wished himself accursed from Christ for the sake of the Jews, judging God’s honor more engaged in their salvation than in his own standing alone. As Clement of Alexandria observes, it is absurd for one person to live sumptuously while many go hungry; how much more glorious it is to do good to many than to dwell magnificently, and how much wiser to spend on people than on stones and gold. (Clement of Alexandria, The Instructor, bk. ii.)

Direction 12. Prefer a lasting good that extends to posterity over a brief and transitory one. Just as building an almshouse is a greater work than giving a single alms, and establishing a school greater than teaching one scholar, so promoting the settlement of the Gospel and a faithful ministry is the greatest of all, as it tends to the good of many, indeed, to their everlasting good. This is the advantage of good books over a passing speech: they provide a more enduring help and benefit.

Look ahead with judicious foresight. Just as you must not do a present good for one person that brings greater harm to many, so you must not do a present good for one or many that is likely to produce a greater and more lasting harm. Such blind reformers have treated the church as ignorant physicians treat their patients, giving them a little immediate ease while casting them into greater misery, seeming to cure them with a dose of opium or the Jesuit’s powder, when in fact they are bringing them into a worse condition than the one they pretended to cure. When will the poor church at last have wiser and more far-sighted helpers!

Direction 13. Let everything you do for the good of the churches tend surely toward holiness and peace, and do nothing under the name of a good work that is hostile to either of these. Holiness and peace are to the church what life and health are to the body; the increase of the church’s welfare is nothing other than the increase of these.

Whatever they claim, trust no one who says they seek the good and welfare of the church if they do not seek the promotion of holiness and peace. If they hinder the powerful preaching of the Gospel and the means that tend to the saving of souls; if they hinder the serious and spiritual worship of God and the unity and peace of all the faithful; if they divide the faithful into sects and parties, or harass all who differ from them and will not flatter their opinions, count all such persons as benefactors to the church in the way that a wolf is to the flock, a plague to the city, a fever to the body, or a fire in the thatch to a house.

"The wisdom from above is first pure, then peaceable, gentle," and so on. "But if ye have bitter envying, and strife in your hearts, glory not, and lie not against the truth: this wisdom descendeth not from above, but is earthly, sensual, devilish; for where envying and strife is, there is confusion and every evil work." (Jas 3:14–18)

Direction 14. If you would do the good that God accepts, do what he requires. Do not apply the name of good works to your sins or to unnecessary things of your own invention, and do not think that any good may be accomplished by forbidden means. No one knows so well as God himself what pleases him. Our ways may seem right in our own eyes, and worldly wisdom may think it has devised the fittest means to honor God, when he may abominate it and say, "Who required this at your hand?" If we will do good by sinning, we must do it in defiance of God, who is set against our sins and against us. God does not need our lie for his glory.

If Papists expect to find at the last day that their foolish ceremonies, superstitions, and will-worship, their "touch not, taste not, handle not," are reckoned to them as good works; or if Jesuits or Enthusiasts expect to find their perjury, treasons, rebellions, or conspiracies counted among good works; or if persecuting the preachers and faithful professors of godliness is to be accounted a good work, how pitifully will they find their expectations disappointed!

Direction 15. Keep to the work of your own place and calling, and do not take other men’s work upon yourself without a call, under any pretense of doing good. Magistrates must do good in the place and work of magistrates; ministers in the place and work of ministers; private persons in their private place and work. One man must not step into another’s place, take his work out of his hands, and say, "I can do it better." Even if you could do it better, the disorder would cause more harm than you would do good by the improvement.

One judge must not step into another’s court and bench and say he will pass more righteous judgment. You must not go into another man’s school and say you can teach his scholars better; nor into another’s charge or pulpit and say you can preach better. A servant may not rule the master on the grounds that he could do it best, no more than you may take another man’s wife, house, lands, or goods because you could use them better than he. Do the good to which you are called.

Direction 16. Where God has prescribed a particular good work or way of service for you, you must prefer that over another work that may be greater in itself. This qualifies and limits Direction 8. The reason is that God knows best what is pleasing to him, and "obedience is better than sacrifice." You must not neglect the necessary maintenance of wife and children under pretense of performing a work of piety or greater good, because God has prescribed this order of duty: begin at home, though not stop there. Another minister may have a larger or more needy congregation, but you must first do good in your own and not step without a call into his charge. If God has called you to serve him in a humble and ordinary employment, he will accept you more readily in that work than if you undertook the work of another man’s place, however much you imagined you were doing him greater service.

Direction 17. Do not lose your resolutions or opportunities for doing good through unnecessary delays. "Withhold not good from them to whom it is due, when it is in the power of thine hand to do it. Say not unto thy neighbour, Go, and come again, and to-morrow I will give; when thou hast it by thee" (Prov 3:27–28). "Boast not thyself of to-morrow; for thou knowest not what a day may bring forth" (Prov 27:1). The odds are that delay will cost you your opportunity and raise unexpected distractions or difficulties that will frustrate your intent and ruin the work. Take your moment if you mean to serve: a good deed is beautiful in its season.

Direction 18. Yet present necessity may make a lesser work your duty when the greater work can more safely wait. For instance, saving a person’s life in sickness or danger takes priority when you may afterward have time to seek the saving of his soul. Not only works of mercy may in this way be preferred over religious observance, but even the ordinary necessities of daily life: rising, dressing, and attending to other business may properly come before prayer when prayer can be performed afterward as well or better, and would in fact be hindered if these things were not done first.

Direction 19. Although, all else being equal, the duties of the first table are to be preferred over those of the second, yet the greater duties of the second table must be preferred before the lesser duties of the first. The love of God is a greater duty than the love of man, and the two must never be separated, yet we must prefer saving a person’s life or extinguishing a fire in town over a prayer, a sacrament, or the observance of a Sabbath. David ate the showbread, and the disciples of Christ rubbed out grain on the Sabbath day, because preserving life was a greater duty than observing a Sabbath or a positive, ceremonial law. Christ commands the Pharisees, "Go, learn what this meaneth, I will have mercy, and not sacrifice": the blood of our brothers is no acceptable means of pleasing God, maintaining piety, or advancing anyone’s opinions in religion.

Direction 20. Choose that employment or calling, so far as the choice is yours, in which you may be most serviceable to God. Do not choose for wealth or worldly honor, but for the greatest opportunity to do good and the best prospect of escaping sin.

Question: But what if in one calling I am most serviceable to the church yet face the most temptations to sin, while in another I face the fewest temptations but am least serviceable to the church, which is the ordinary difference between those in public stations and those in solitude? Which should I choose?

Answer:

1. Either you are already committed to a calling or you are not. If you are, you will need stronger reasons to leave it than would have been sufficient to keep you from choosing it at the outset.

2. Either the temptations to sin are such as good people ordinarily overcome, or they are extraordinarily severe. You may more justifiably avoid those great temptations you are unlikely to conquer than small or ordinary ones.

3. Either you are well equipped against these temptations or you are not. If not, you must be more cautious about approaching them; but if you are, you may trust God more boldly to carry you through.

4. Either the temptations are to ordinary human frailties in the manner of performing duty, or they are temptations to more dangerous sin. The former does not warrant you to avoid doing good in order to escape them as readily as the latter does.

5. The service you are called to, presumed to be great and necessary for someone to perform, is either such that others will do it as well or better if you withdraw, or it is not. If the church or common good suffers no harm from your refusal, you may more freely attend to your own preservation. But if the necessities of the church or state, the lack of fitter instruments, or any evident call of God singles you out for that service, you must obey God whatever the difficulties and temptations may be: no temptation can compel you to sin, and the God who calls you can easily preserve you. But take care what you thrust yourself into unbidden.

Question: But may I change my calling for the service of the church, when the apostle commands every man to abide in the calling in which he was called? (1 Cor 7:20)

Answer: The apostle requires only that people make no unlawful change, such as forsaking a wife or husband, nor treat an unnecessary change as though it were obligatory, as in the case of circumcision. Yet in the very next words he says, "Art thou called being a servant? care not for it; but if thou mayst be made free, use it rather." He commands every man to abide with God in the station to which he was called, but he does not forbid changing that station when there is a genuine call to do so. (1 Cor 7:24)

He speaks more of relationships, single persons and married, servants and free, than of trades or offices; and yet no one doubts that a single person may marry, that a marriage may in some cases be dissolved, and that a servant may become free. No one should take up or change a calling without sufficient cause, but when sufficient cause is present, refusing to change is itself a sin. The apostles changed their callings when they became apostles, as did multitudes of the church’s pastors in every age. God nowhere forbids people to change their employment for the better upon a sufficient cause or call.

Direction 21. Above all, make sure you do not live without a calling, that is, without some settled course of employment in which you may best be serviceable to God. Disability is an unavoidable impediment. Otherwise, no one must live idly or content themselves with doing a few small tasks as a recreation or a sideline. Every person who is able must be steadily and regularly employed in work that is serviceable to God and the common good.

Question: But will not wealth excuse us?

Answer: Wealth may excuse you from certain lowly kinds of work by enabling you to serve in higher ways, but it no more excuses you from service and work of one kind or another than it does the poorest person, unless you think God requires least from those to whom he has given most.

Question: Will not age excuse us?

Answer: Yes, insofar as age genuinely disables you, but no further.

Objection: But I have been turned out of my calling.

Answer: You have not been turned out of the service of God. He calls you to that service, or to another.

Question: But may I not cast off worldly concerns so that I may give all my attention to my salvation?

Answer: You may cast off all such excess of worldly care or business as unnecessarily hinders you in spiritual things. But you may not abandon all bodily employment and productive labor through which you could serve the common good. Every member of the church or commonwealth must employ their abilities to the fullest for the good of the church and commonwealth: public service is God’s greatest service. To neglect this and say "I will pray and meditate" is like a servant refusing your most important work and confining himself to some lesser, easier task.

God has commanded us in some way to labor for our daily bread and not to live as drones on the sweat of others. Innocent Adam was placed in the garden of Eden to tend it; and fallen man must "eat his bread in the sweat of his brow" (Gen 3:19); and he that "will not work must be forbidden to eat" (2 Thess 3:6, 10, 12). Beyond that, work is necessary for our own sake: our bodies grow diseased with idleness, and when the body fails the soul suffers with it. A person living in the body needs work for the body as well as for the soul. The person who does nothing but pray and meditate will likely be disabled before long, through sickness or melancholy, from doing either, unless his body is unusually strong.

Direction 22. Be a vigilant redeemer of your time, and make it a matter of conscience for every hour and minute not to lose it, but to spend it in the best and most serviceable manner you can. I will speak to this more fully later, and so will add nothing more here.

Direction 23. Watchfully and resolutely avoid the entanglements and distracting occasions by which the tempter will continually try to waste your time and hinder you from your work. Know what is the principal service you are called to, and avoid whatever pulls you away from it. Magistrates, ministers, and all who carry great public responsibilities must be especially vigilant here. If you are not wise and watchful, the tempter will draw you, before you realize it, into such a multitude of distracting cares and businesses that all seem like duties, yet leave you nearly useless in the world. There will always be this or that small thing that must be done, this or that friend who must be visited or spoken to, this or that courtesy that must be performed, so that trifles end up keeping you from all work of real consequence.

I grant that friends must not be neglected, nor all civilities refused. But our greatest duties carry the greatest necessity, and everything else must yield to them in their proper season. To avoid giving offense to friends, avoid the places and occasions where such interruptions arise. And where that cannot be done, whatever others may think of you, do not neglect your most necessary work. Otherwise it will rest with men and Satan whether you are of any service to God at all.

Direction 24. Seriously ask yourselves how you would wish, at the hour of death and the day of judgment, that you had used all your wit, time, and wealth, and resolve to use them that way now. This is an excellent guide and motive both for doing good and for avoiding the condemnation that will fall on unprofitable servants. Ask yourself: will it comfort me more at death or judgment to recall that I spent this hour in amusement or idleness, or that I spent it doing good to myself and others? How will I then wish I had laid out my estate, and every part of it? Reason itself condemns the person who will not now choose the course that, seeing the outcome of that day, he knows he will wish he had chosen.

Direction 25. Understand how much you owe to God, and not he to you, in that he condescends to employ you in doing any good; understand that doing good is the very path of your own receiving; and know the excellence of your work and its end, so that you may do it all with love and pleasure. It is unfamiliarity with our Master, and with the nature and tendency of our work, that makes it seem tedious and unpleasant to us. We will never do it well when we do it unwillingly, as though merely compelled. God loves a cheerful servant, one who loves his master and his work. It is the devil’s chief strategy to make our duty appear grievous, unprofitable, and wearisome; for even a small obstacle will stop the person who goes forward reluctantly and in continual pain.

Direction 26. Expect your reward from God alone, and expect ingratitude and ill-treatment from many people, or do not be surprised when it comes. If you are servants of God and not of men, look for your recompense from the one you serve. You are not truly serving God if his reward alone does not satisfy you and you must also have the approval of men. "Verily you have your reward" (Matt 6:2), if like the hypocrite you labor for human approval.

Expect, especially if you are ministers or others laboring directly for the good of souls, that many will become your enemies for telling them the truth. Even if you were as godly as Paul and as tireless in seeking people’s salvation, the more you love, the less many will love you in return. Those for whom he could have wished himself cut off from Christ did hate and persecute him as though he were the most cursed of wretches. They called him a pestilent fellow, a mover of sedition, one who turned the world upside down; and wherever he went, "bonds and imprisonment did attend him" (Acts 20:23), slander, abuse, flogging, the stocks, and vows against his life, all the thanks and return he received from those for whose salvation he spared no effort, but spent himself utterly.

If you cannot do good on such terms as these, for people who will repay you in this way, and be content to await your reward in heaven, you are not fit to follow Christ, who was treated worse than all this by those to whom he showed more love than any of his servants can show. "Take up your cross, and do good to the unthankful, and bless them that curse you, and love them that hate you, and pray for them that despitefully use you and persecute you, if you will be the children of God" (Matt 5).

Direction 27. Do not make your own judgment or conscience the law, or the maker of your duty. Conscience is only the discerner of God’s law, of the duty he has made for you, and of your own obedience or disobedience to him. A dangerous error has become far too common: the idea that a person is bound to do everything his conscience tells him is the will of God, and that every man must obey his conscience as though it were the lawgiver of the world. In truth, it is not ourselves but God who is our lawgiver. Conscience is not appointed or authorized to create duties for us that God has not created. Its office is only to discern God’s law and call us to observe it. An erring conscience is not to be obeyed; it is to be better informed and brought to a truer performance of its proper office.

In working out this Direction, I will answer several cases concerning doubt.

Question 1: "What if I doubt whether a thing is a duty and a good work, or not? Must I do it while I am in doubt? And what if I am uncertain whether it is a duty or a sin?"

Answer:

1. In all cases involving an erring or doubting conscience, do not forget to distinguish between the existence of a duty and the knowledge of a duty. The first question is: Is this my duty? The next is: How may I discern that it is? God gives the duty its existence through his law; conscience is only meant to recognize and apply it. God does not change his law and our duty every time our opinions about it change. The obligation of the law remains constant, even when our consciences misread it.

Therefore, if God commands a duty and your opinion is that he does not command it, or even that he forbids it, making it no duty or even a sin, it does not follow that God truly does not command it simply because you think so. If it did, your thinking could never be an error; indeed, error would be impossible if a thing became true merely because you believed it to be true. God commands you to love him, to worship him, to provide for your children, to obey lawful authority, and much more. Do you imagine you will be discharged from all these duties, free to be profane, sensual, resistant to authority, or neglectful of your children, simply because you are blind enough to think that God wills it so?

2. Your error is itself a sin. Do you suppose that one sin can authorize another? Can sin discharge you from your duty and annul the law?

3. You are a subject of God, not a king unto yourself. You must obey his laws, not make new ones.

Question 2: "But is it not every person’s duty to obey his conscience?"

Answer: No. It is no one’s duty to obey a conscience that is in error and contradicts the command of God. Conscience is only a discerner of God’s command; it is not to be obeyed strictly as a commander. It is to be followed in a broader sense, that is, followed wherever it truly discerns God’s command. Our duty is to set aside our error, seek its correction, and press on until we attain it, not to obey the error.

Question 3: "But is it not a sin for a person to act against his conscience?"

Answer: Yes, not because conscience has any authority to make laws for you, but because in doing so you are, in effect, acting against God. You are bound to obey God in all things; and when you believe God has commanded you something, yet you will not do it, you are disobeying formally, even if not materially. The matter of obedience is the thing commanded; the form of obedience is doing that thing because it is commanded, that is, because the authority of the commander moves you to act. When you reject what you believe God has commanded, even if he did not in fact command it, you are rejecting God’s authority.

Question 4: "Since the form of obedience is what makes it obedience, giving it its character in a way that matter alone cannot, and since no sin can be committed except against God’s authority (which is the formal cause of obedience), is it not my duty to follow my conscience?"

Answer:

1. All the necessary causes must be present together to constitute obedience, though the absence of any one of them makes for sin. To be called obedient, you must have both matter and form, because the true form is found only in the right matter: you must do the thing commanded, because of the authority of the one who commands it. Even if acting out of an erroneous conscience could be called obedience in some formal sense, it is not acceptable obedience, for God requires not merely obedience of some kind, but obedience in the very thing he commands.

2. Moreover, as long as your error is sinful, you are deficient in the form of obedience as well as in its matter, even when you intend obedience in the particular act. Formal disobedience is not only the willful, positive rejection of the commander’s authority; it is any privation of due submission to it, any failure to let his authority move you to your duty as it ought. This formal disobedience is present in an erroneous conscience: for if God’s authority had moved you as it should, to diligent inquiry, to the use of all appointed means, and to the avoidance of all causes of error, you would never have erred about your duty. And if the error were entirely involuntary and blameless, the thing you did not know could not have been your particular duty in the first place.

Question 5: "But if it is a sin to act against my conscience, must I not avoid that sin by obeying my conscience? Would you have me sin?"

Answer: You must avoid the sin by changing your judgment, not by obeying it, for to obey an erroneous conscience is only to avoid one sin by committing another. An erring judgment can be neither obeyed nor disobeyed without sin: it can make you sin, though it cannot create your duty; it ensnares, though it does not oblige. If you follow it, you break God’s law by doing what he forbids; if you forsake it and act against it, you reject God’s authority by doing what you believe he forbids. There is no path to innocence except by first coming to know your duty and then doing it. Suppose you tell your servant to weed your corn, and he misunderstands you, firmly believing you told him to pull up the corn instead of the weeds. What should he do? Should he follow his judgment, or act against it? Neither, he should change it, and then follow it; and to that end, he should inquire further until he is better informed. Nothing else will serve.

Question 6: "Since no one who errs knows or thinks that he is erring, for that would be a contradiction, how can I set aside an opinion I take to be the truth, or strive against it?"

Answer: It is your sin that you take a falsehood to be a truth. God has appointed means for the cure of blindness and error just as he has for other sins, otherwise the world would be in a desperate condition. Come into the light with proper self-suspicion and impartiality; diligently use all of God’s appointed means; and avoid the causes of deceit and error. The light of truth will at once show you what is true and show you that you previously erred. In the meantime, sin remains sin even when you take it to be a duty or no sin at all.

Question 7: "But since the servant who knows his master’s will and does not do it will be beaten with many stripes, and the one who did not know it with few (Luke 12:47–48), is it not my chief duty to avoid the many stripes by avoiding sin against my conscience or knowledge?"

Answer:

1. Your duty is to avoid both kinds of failure; and if both were not sinful, they would not both be punished with stripes.

2. Your conscience is not your knowledge when you err, it is your ignorance. Conscience, considered as a faculty of knowing, may be called conscience even when it errs, just as reason is still reason as a faculty when we reason wrongly. And an erring act of conscience may be called conscience so far as any genuine knowledge is present in it, just as a person is said to see when he misjudges colors, or to reason when he argues badly. But in so far as it errs, it is no conscience in act at all, for conscience is knowledge, not ignorance. You sin against your knowledge when you sin against a well-informed conscience; you sin in ignorance when you sin against an erring one.

3. If the question is not what your duty is but which sin is smaller, then it is true that, all else being equal, it is a greater sin to act against your judgment than to follow it. But other inequalities in the matter and circumstances may be exceptions to this rule.

Question 8: "But it is not possible for anyone to know all their duty at once, or to avoid all error about it. Knowledge takes time. All people are ignorant in many things. Should I not then, in the meantime, follow my conscience?"

Answer:

1. Your ignorance is either culpable or not culpable. If it is not culpable, then the thing you are ignorant of is not your duty. If it is culpable, which is the case being considered, then just as you brought yourself into that difficulty of knowing, so it will remain your sin until it is cured; and one sin does not warrant another. Throughout that time you are under a double command: one to seek knowledge and use the means of it, and the other to do the thing commanded. However long you remain in error, you remain in sin, and you are not under any obligation to follow your error, you are under obligation to first come to know the truth, and then to do your contrary duty.

2. As long as you keep yourself in a state of sinning, you must call it sin for what it is, and not call it duty. It is not your duty to choose a lesser sin over a greater; it is your duty to refuse and avoid both the lesser and the greater. And if you say you cannot, remember that your inability is itself your sin, your impotency is sinful. That said, it is true that you are most obliged to avoid the greatest sin; and so all that remains in resolving such cases is to determine which of two sins is the greater.

Question 9: "What if there is a great duty I cannot perform without committing a small sin? Or a very great good I cannot accomplish except by an unlawful means, such as saving many lives by telling a lie?"

Answer:

1. When you cannot do a thing without willful sin, it is not your duty, however great that thing may be. To deliberately choose a sin in order to perform some service to God or do some good to others is to run before you are called, to make work for yourself that God never made for you, to offer sin as a sacrifice to God, and to do evil so that good may come, abusing God and rejecting his government under the pretense of serving him. "The sacrifice of the wicked is an abomination to the Lord: how much more when he bringeth it with a wicked mind?" (Prov 21:27 Prov 15:8). "He that turneth away his ear from hearing the law, even his prayer shall be abomination." (Prov 28:9). "Be more ready to hear, than to offer the sacrifice of fools: for they consider not that they do evil." (Eccl 5:1).

2. If you would do good by sinning, you must do good in opposition to God, and how easily can he disappoint you and turn it into evil! What must be accomplished by sin is not truly good. The final good is never promoted by sin; and all lesser good is to be evaluated by its tendency toward the ultimate end. You think something is good when it is not, because you judge by the immediate feeling of the flesh and do not foresee how it stands in relation to the everlasting good.

Question 10: "Since I am already certain that I cannot preach, or hear, or pray, or perform any good action without sin, must I not, by this rule, refrain from all of them?"

Answer: No, because the infirmities that accompany your performance of duty, which you would avoid but cannot, are not made the condition of your action; they are its diseases, not its substance. They are not chosen or approved. The duty remains your duty despite those infirmities, and may still be accepted by God, for you cannot serve God perfectly until you are perfect yourself, and to abandon his service altogether is a far greater sin than to perform it imperfectly. You can serve him without willful, chosen sin, if not in one way then in another. The imperfection of your service is repented of even as it is committed; but an approved, chosen sin is not.

When a man deliberately commits a sin against God, even one he has often committed before in pardonable weakness, he turns it into a presumptuous and heinous offense. If he does it for worldly gain or safety, he sells his obedience to God for trifles. If he does it in the name of serving God, he blasphemes God, declaring him to be evil, a lover of sin, or too weak to accomplish his ends by lawful means. It is most dangerous to hand over to the devil, under any pretext whatever, a pledge that we will sin.

Question 11: "What if I am certain that the duty is great, but uncertain whether the thing attached to it is a sin? Must I omit a certain duty for an uncertain sin? Or forgo a great and certain good for fear of a small and uncertain evil?"

Answer:

1. The question of what a thing is must come before the question of how it appears. Either what you call uncertain really is a sin, or it is not. If it is not a sin, you are bound both to search until you know that, and not to neglect your duty on its account. But if it really is a sin, then your uncertainty about it is itself a sin, and what God requires is that you forsake both.

2. Your question contains a contradiction: you cannot be certain that something is your duty at all unless you are equally certain that the conditions or means involved are lawful. Consider an ordinary hearer in Spain or Italy who says, "I am certain that I must obey my teachers, but I am uncertain whether their doctrines of the mass, purgatory, and the rest contain any falsehood or sin, therefore I must not omit certain obedience for an uncertain sin." Or a priest among them who says, "I am certain that preaching God’s word is a duty, but I am not certain that the Tridentine articles I must swear or subscribe are sinful or false, therefore I must not leave a great and certain duty for an uncertain sin." The answer to both is plain.

1.) It is their sin that they are uncertain about the sinfulness of things God has forbidden. God commands them first to search the Scriptures and correct that error. He gave his law before their doubts arose, and he will not change it because they doubt.

2.) They contradict themselves through a mistake. They have no more certainty that they ought to obey their teachers in these particulars than they have that the things taught or commanded are not against God’s law. They are certain they must obey in all things not forbidden by God and within the proper reach of that authority, and equally certain that it is unlawful to obey any authority against God’s law, and that God must be obeyed before man. But whether they must obey in this particular case, they cannot be certain so long as they are uncertain whether God forbids it. The priest must be just as uncertain whether preaching God’s word is any duty of his at all as he is uncertain about the lawfulness of the Tridentine oath or subscription, unless he can preach without taking them.

If a private citizen says, "I am certain that governing a kingdom well is a great and good work and duty, but I am uncertain whether deposing the king when he governs badly and setting myself up in his place is a sin, therefore the certain good must outweigh the uncertain evil," I give the same answer.

1.) It is your sin to be uncertain whether rebellion is a sin. God requires you to lay aside that sinful judgment rather than use it as a lever to commit more sin.

2.) You are sure that governing well is a good work, but you should be equally sure that governing well is not your duty or a good work for you to do, given that you are a private person and a subject, never called to perform another’s office. A private man may say, "I am sure that preaching is a good work, but I am not sure whether a private, unordained man may lawfully set himself apart to do it." Yet he can be no more certain that preaching is his duty than he is that he is called to it.

Question 12: "Very well, suppose my ignorance is my sin, and suppose I am equally uncertain both of the duty and of the sin attached to it. Yet if I have done everything I am able and remain unresolved, and after my most diligent inquiry am as uncertain as before, what should I do?"

Answer:

1. If by some former sin you had forfeited God’s assistance so that he leaves you in your blindness, this does not alter his law or your obligations, which remain the same: to learn, understand, and obey.

2. But if you are truly willing to understand, truly willing to obey, and truly using the means he has appointed, you have no reason to suppose he will abandon you. He undoubtedly appoints no means in vain. If you do not reach sufficient resolution to guide your duty, it is either because your heart is not honest in the inquiry, biased, or unwilling to know the truth and act on it, or because you are not using the right appointed means for resolution, but through partiality or laziness are neglecting them.

Question 13: "Suppose still that my ignorance is my sin. Which is the greater sin, to neglect the good work, or to venture on the feared evil attached to it? I am not aware of any unfaithfulness in myself, but only of the human frailty that keeps me from certainty. And no one is so perfect as to have no culpable ignorance, or to be certain in every point of duty. Therefore I must with greatest caution avoid the greatest sin, when I am beyond hope of avoiding all. On one side, a common rule says I must do nothing against conscience, not even a doubting conscience, though I need not always do everything conscience commands: ‘for he that doubteth is condemned if he eat: for whatsoever is not of faith is sin.’ On the other side, if every duty that conscience doubts about is omitted, I may be kept from almost every duty."

Answer: The heart is so deceitful that you have great cause to watch lest human frailty be made a pretense for an error whose real cause is a corrupted, biased, partial mind, or willful laziness. Diligent study, inquiry, and prayer, with a sincere desire to know the truth, may succeed at least in bringing so much satisfaction that your mind is kept in quietness and peace, you find comfort along the way, and you are preserved from every sin incompatible with your safety and acceptance with God.

Yet it is true that human frailty will produce, even in the best people, uncertainties in some particular cases. And though God does not make it our duty to choose the lesser of two sins, he calls us to refuse both, he does make it our duty to avoid the greater sin more diligently than the lesser. Cases also arise so suddenly that no inquiry can be made. A Christian should therefore know which sins are greatest and most to be avoided.

With that in mind, I set down the following rules, premising this: where the circumstances that make sins greater or lesser must be compared, they are often so numerous and varied that no rules laid down in advance will cover every case, any more than law books or medical books can handle every case without a present, experienced, and judicious counselor. Present prudence and sincerity must do the most.

Rule 1. In things altogether indifferent, nothing must be done that conscience doubts, because in that case there is a possibility or fear of sinning on one side but none on the other, and venturing on a feared sin is then a certain sin. This presupposes, however, that the thing really is indifferent in all its circumstances, and that nothing has arisen to strip away that indifferency.

Rule 2. If a thing is truly unlawful and I believe it to be lawful, but with some doubt, yet I am clear that refraining from it is no sin, then the sin lies only in doing it, because everything is clear and safe on the side of abstaining.

Rule 3. Many sins are always sinful, in all persons and in all circumstances, and no one can doubt this without gross unfaithfulness or negligence. Here there is no room for doubting whether we must do some good that cannot be achieved without that sin, for it is certain that no such supposed good can be a duty. Examples include: committing idolatry, blaspheming God, denying Christ, denying the Scriptures, hating, reproaching, or opposing a holy life, committing perjury, approving or justifying the sins of others, and similar acts. Nothing can be a duty if it cannot be done without willfully yielding to, or committing, these or any other known sin.

Rule 4. Some duties are so great, clear, and universal that only a profligate or graceless conscience, or one deeply poisoned by sin, could deliberately call them into doubt. These duties, therefore, do not fall within the case under consideration.

Rule 5. If moral evil is compared only with natural good, or moral good with natural evil, there is no room for doubt: the least sin contains more evil than the prosperity or lives of millions of people contain good (considered simply as natural good), and the least duty to God contains more good than the deaths of millions of people (as such) contain evil. The good of duty and the evil of sin are enlarged by their relation to God, while the other goods and evils are diminished because they are good or evil only to people and with respect to them.

Rule 6. Where I am equally uncertain about a duty I might omit and about a sin I might commit, it is a greater sin to risk committing a grave positive sin (should it prove sinful) than to risk omitting a lesser duty (should it prove a duty). Conversely, it is worse to risk omitting a great duty than to risk committing a small positive sin.

For example: suppose my own house, or my neighbor’s, is on fire, and I am in doubt whether I may take another man’s water to quench it without his permission. Or suppose my own life, or my child’s, or my neighbor’s is in danger from starvation, and I doubt whether I may take another person’s apples, pears, ears of corn, or bread without consent in order to save that life. The thing is already made lawful or unlawful by God’s law, whether or not I can determine which, but given unavoidable uncertainty, if I am equally doubtful on both sides, it is a far greater sin (if sin it be) to fail to save the house or life than to take another person’s water or food, when that person has plenty (if that taking proves sinful).

Suppose a king and nobles are aboard a ship that will be seized and everyone killed by pirates, unless I say they are different persons. If I were equally in doubt whether to lie or not, though sin has more evil than all our lives have good, still, a sinful failure to save all their lives is a greater sin than a sinful telling of such a lie. Suppose I doubt whether I may lawfully save an ox, an ass, or a human life by working on the Sabbath; or suppose David had been in doubt whether he might eat the consecrated showbread out of necessity: it is plain that the sinful neglect of a human life is worse than the sinful violation of the Sabbath or the sinful use of the consecrated bread.

If I am equally in doubt whether I may use a ceremony or a disorderly, defective form of prayer, and whether I should preach the Gospel to save souls where there are not enough others to do it, it is plain that sinfully using a ceremony or a disorderly form of prayer is, all else being equal, a lesser sin than sinfully neglecting to preach the Gospel and to save souls.

On the other side: suppose I lived in Italy and could not obtain leave to preach the Gospel there without subscribing to the Tridentine confession, or to the third canon of the Lateran Council under Innocent III. The first requires men to swear to transubstantiation and to interpret Scripture only according to the unanimous consent of the fathers, who in fact never unanimously consented to any exposition of the greater part of Scripture at all. The second decrees the pope’s power to depose temporal lords and release their subjects from allegiance.

On one side, I doubt whether by subscribing I become guilty of justifying idolatry, perjury, and rebellion, and of making myself guilty of the perjury of many thousands of others. On the other side, I doubt whether I may disobey my superiors who require this subscription, or may refrain from preaching when there are others available to preach it, when my worth is not so great that my removal and replacement would be a serious loss, when God does not need me specifically but has instruments at his command, and when I do not know how soon he may restore my liberty or how I might serve him in another country or through suffering at home. In such a case, a sinful justification of perjury or rebellion across whole nations is a far greater sin than a sinful omission of my preaching, for whoever justifies perjury destroys the bonds of all societies and sets subjects loose against their rulers.

Or if I, as a minister, am forbidden to preach where there is urgent need unless I commit some sin, and I doubt on one side whether I should disobey my superiors, and on the other whether I should abandon my calling and neglect the souls of sinners: it is a lesser sin, all else being equal, to disobey a man sinfully than to disobey God sinfully and be cruel to souls unto their perdition.

Or if I have made a vow and sworn to throw away a penny or a shilling, and I doubt on one side whether I am bound to keep it as a vow, and on the other whether keeping it is itself a sin because throwing away any of my talents is a sin, in that case, the sinful discarding of a penny or a shilling is not as great a sin as sinful perjury.

If Daniel and the three witnesses had been equally in doubt whether to obey the king or to pray to God (Dan 6), and whether to refuse to bow to his idol (Dan 3), a sinful omission of prayer as commanded and a sinful bowing to the idol would have been a greater sin than a sinful disobedience of the king’s command in such a case, had they been mistaken.

Rule 7. If I cannot discern whether the duty I might omit or the sin I might commit is the greater in substance or in other respects, then that which my doubting conscience most strongly suspects to be sinful, on its most impartial deliberation, will be the greater sin for me. If other things are equal, sinning against more or less conviction or doubt must create an inequality. For instance, if I could not discern whether subscribing to the Tridentine confession, refraining from preaching, or preaching though prohibited were the greater sin (were all three sinful), but I most strongly suspect sinfulness in the subscription, less strongly in refraining from preaching in such a case, and least of all in preaching though prohibited, then subscribing sinfully is the greatest sin, refraining sinfully from exercising my office is the next, and preaching without warrant is the least.

Rule 8. If I can perceive no difference in the degree of evil between the omission and the commission, nor any difference in the degree of my suspicion or doubt, then the greater sin is the one I had greater help and evidence to have known, and yet did not.

Rule 9. If both greater material evil and greater suspicion or evidence of sinfulness are on the same side, then that is certainly the greater sin.

Rule 10. If the greater material evil falls on one side and the greater suspicion or evidence of sinfulness falls on the other, then the former (if it is indeed sinful) will be the greater sin in itself and considered materially; but the latter will be the greater act of disobedience to God in a formal sense. The comparison, however, will be very difficult to make. Suppose I swear to God that I will throw away a shilling, or that I will refrain from praying for an entire week. I take perjury to be a greater sin in itself than throwing away a shilling or omitting prayer for a week. Yet when I ask whether that oath should be kept, I have stronger suspicion that it should not be kept, because no oath may serve as the bond of the least iniquity. If failing to keep it proves to be a sin, then by breaking the oath I commit the greater sin in itself; but by keeping it, if it ought not to be kept, I display the greater disobedience.

Rule 11. If on one side there is a doubtful sin and on the other only a single sin, this creates an inequality in the case. Suppose that in my father’s household there are heretics and drunkards, and I swear that in my proper place and calling I will endeavor to remove them. My mother approves the vow; my father opposes it and releases me from it on the grounds that I took it without his advice. On one side, I doubt whether I am bound, or even free, to act against my father’s will. On the other side, I equally doubt whether I am not guilty of perjury and disobedience to my mother if I do not act, and whether I am not disobeying God, who had already made it my duty, before I ever vowed it, to endeavor that very thing in my place and calling.

Rule 12. There is a great difference between omitting the substance of a duty altogether and merely delaying it, or adjusting its time, place, or manner. What justifies or excuses shortening my prayer, or praying only once a day, or praying at noon rather than in the morning, or some deficiency in method, fervor, or expression, does not justify or excuse denying, renouncing, or long abandoning prayer altogether. Likewise, what might excuse an apostle for not preaching in the temple or synagogues, or for lacking the emperor’s or the high priest’s permission, or for not remaining in one city or country, would not excuse him if he had renounced his calling, or had entirely and in every time, place, and manner ceased his work out of fear of men.

Rule 13. If the duty to be omitted and the sin to be committed seem equal in gravity, and doubt is equal on both sides, it is commonly held safer to avoid the commission more carefully than the omission. Many reasons are given for this.

Rule 14. There is usually much greater ground for fear and suspicion, all else being equal, regarding sins to be committed than regarding duties to be omitted, when the commission of some act is made a necessary condition for performing the duty. This is so, first, because that is precisely where the fear begins: I can be certain that a good work is no duty to me if the act that is its necessary condition is itself sinful. Therefore, to the degree that I suspect the act to be sinful, I must equally suspect that the duty is no duty to me at that time. I cannot be rationally more convinced that the duty is my duty than I am convinced that its necessary condition is not sinful. Even if performing the act would save the lives of every person in the country, I could only regard it as my duty to the extent that I regard the necessary act as no sin, since it is beyond controversy that we must not sin in order to accomplish any good whatsoever.

Second, because the sin is always a sin, while few duties are duties at all times; and the sin is a sin for every person, while the duty may belong to another person and not to me.

For instance: the Emperor Charles V imposed the Interim on Germany. Some pastors complied; others refused and were driven out. Those who complied pleaded the good of the churches and the prevention of their utter ruin; yet they acknowledged that if what was imposed were sinful, it could not be their duty to comply for any good whatever, but only to seek the church’s good as best they could without complying.

Those who were driven out argued that to the extent they were confident the Interim was sinful, they must be equally confident that nothing requiring it could be their duty; that God knows best what is good for his church, and its good cannot be accomplished through sin and God’s displeasure; and that they were not thereby abandoning their ministry, they were only forfeiting the ruler’s license, for they resolved to preach wherever they could until imprisoned, and God can use their imprisonment or death as well as their preaching. While others who judged the Interim lawful filled their places, the churches were not entirely without pastors; and if God saw fit, he could restore fuller liberties in time. To serve God in the meantime, as all pastors did for three hundred years after Christ without the civil magistrate’s license, was not to abandon their office.

Another instance: the zealous Papists, in the reign of Henry III of France, believed it necessary to enter the League and make war against the king, because religion was in danger, and its preservation is an unquestionable duty. The learned and moderate lawyers who opposed them replied that, since there was no question that the king held total sovereignty over them, they were certain that resisting the higher powers was a sin, and therefore no preservation of religion that required such a certain sin could be a duty or lawful for them. Sin is not the means by which religion or the commonwealth is saved.

Rule 15. When something is not sinful and prohibited simply in itself, but only because of some accidental or consequential evil to which it tends, a greater accidental or consequential good may outweigh that evil and make the act not sinful but a duty. It is often exceedingly difficult to discern whether a thing is simply and absolutely forbidden, or only forbidden by reason of circumstance and thus in an alterable way, and to judge which circumstance carries greater weight. So many considerations must be taken into account here, and so much of a person’s life and peace depends on this question, that it deserves a treatise of its own. I will therefore go no further with it here, for fear that an inadequate treatment would be worse than none at all in a matter where error is so easy and so dangerous.

Rule 16. As for the danger to the sinner himself, there is a great difference between an error or sin arising from human frailty when the service of God, true obedience, and the common good are sincerely intended, and an error or sin arising from insincerity and laziness when self-interest is the hidden spring of the error and worldly advantage the real end, however much God and his service are claimed as the motive. The surrounding circumstances will usually reveal something of this to others.

For instance: two magistrates and two ministers each submit to some disputed imposition, and all claim that the glory of God and his service is what moves them to comply. One of the magistrates afterward faithfully serves God with his authority, demonstrating by this that he was sincere. The other does no good in his office and reveals his hypocrisy. One of the ministers preaches with zeal and labors privately as one who thirsts for the saving of souls; the other preaches formally, coldly, and half-heartedly, never converts a soul, and neglects the very work he claimed was his purpose.

CHAPTER 33

GRAND DIRECTION 11: LOVE GOD AS YOUR FATHER AND HIGHEST GOOD

 

Let this truth be most deeply engraved on your heart: God is infinitely good and worthy of love, your great Benefactor and Father in Christ, the end of all that you are and have, and the everlasting rest and happiness of your soul. See to it, therefore, that your inflamed heart is entirely and absolutely offered up to him through the mediation of his Son, to love him, to trust him, to delight in him, to give him thanks, to glorify him, and through faith to long for the heavenly glory where all this will be done perfectly and forever. We begin, then, with Love.

In the first Direction I urged you to lay a good foundation in faith and knowledge. In the second, I directed you how to live upon Christ. In the third, how to believe practically in the Holy Ghost. In the fourth, I directed you to an orderly and practical knowledge of the attributes of God. In the fifth, how to know God practically in his first grand relation, as your owner. In the sixth, how to know him practically in his second grand relation, as your king and governor, and in subordination to that governing relation. In the seventh, I directed you in your relation as disciples to Christ your teacher. In the eighth, in your relation as patients to Christ your physician and to the Holy Ghost as your sanctifier. In the ninth, in your relation as soldiers to Christ the captain of your salvation. In the tenth, in your relation as servants to Christ your master.

Now that those subordinate relations (belonging to the second grand relation) are treated, I proceed to direct you in your third grand relation to God, as your Benefactor, Father, and Felicity. Because there are several great duties under this heading, I begin with Love and will address the rest in turn.

Directions for Loving God as Our Father and Felicity

 

Here I will first offer these general preparatives, and then give directions for the actual exercise of holy love. 1. You must understand the nature of love to God. 2. You must understand the differences of this love. 3. You must understand the reasons for it. 4. You must understand its contraries. 5. You must understand its counterfeits.

First. On the nature of love to God, observe the following:

1. Love to God is not love directed toward a particular good, but toward the infinite, universal Good. A creature is a particular good, and our love toward it is a particular, limited love, confined as to a single point. God is the universal good, and our love to him is not limited by its object, but only by the narrowness and imperfection of our own faculties.

Suppose you had several candles in a room, along with diamonds and other bright objects: you love each of these with a particular love, for their brilliance and usefulness, and you can more easily notice and feel the movement of that confined love. But light itself, as light, you love with a more universal love, a love that is greater, yet not as readily felt. (This is not the logical notion of a universal that exists only in particular instances, but the natural, transcendent, infinite Good that exists eternally and appears by his own will in certain created things.) Just as love of an infinite light would differ from love of a candle, and love of an infinite heat from love of a fire, and love of infinite wisdom itself from love of a wise man, and love of infinite goodness itself from love of a good man, so does love of God differ from love of any particular created good.

2. Our love to God is not ordinarily as passionate as our love to creatures, because the nearness and tangibility of creatures promotes that kind of felt response. God, by contrast, is not seen or felt or heard, but believed by faith and known by reason. Moreover, the limitations of a creature create resistances, obstacles, and difficulties that occasion a turbulent, intense passion of love; the infiniteness of God offers no such occasion. Our love to creatures is like a stream running in a channel too narrow for it, where banks and obstructions make it rush forward with a roaring force. Our love to God is like that same stream gliding into the ocean, where it is quietly absorbed.

Therefore, love to God must be perceived chiefly not in violent passions, but in a high esteem of him, in the will’s firm adherence to him, and in its effects (to be mentioned shortly).

Yet when passionate love is added to these, it may be most excellent, both in what it signifies and in what it produces.

Some philosophers hold that God cannot be loved with a passionate love at all, since he is a pure, immaterial being and therefore cannot be the object of a material act or motion such as our passions are, and that whatever is so loved is merely an idol of the imagination. But two things may be said in reply.

1.) If they mean that his pure essence, in itself, is not the immediate object of passion, the same could be said of the will itself: for a person in the flesh can have no act of the will toward God except as God is apprehended by the intellect. And if by "idol" they mean the image of God in the mind, gathered from the appearances of God in his creatures, then in the flesh we have no other knowledge of him at all. Here we know him but darkly, as in a riddle and as in a glass, and have no direct, proper conception of his essence. The rational powers themselves, therefore, know and will God’s essence only as it is represented to us in a glass.

2.) And in the same way we may also love him passionately: it is God in his objective being, as apprehended by the intellect, that we both will and passionately love. The movement of the soul in the flesh may, through the instrumentality of the bodily spirits, raise passions toward an immaterial object, which is called the object of those passions not primarily as passions of a rational agent, but rather as it is first apprehended by the higher powers of intellect and will, and only then by the passions. A person may delight in God, for how else is God our felicity? yet we know of no delight that is not a passion. A person may love his own soul with passionate love, though the soul is immaterial. When I passionately love my friend, it is his immaterial soul, his wisdom, and his holiness that I chiefly love.

3. Grace does not cause a believer to love God only for his excellencies and perfections in himself, nor only for his love and benefits to us, but for both together: as he is good and does good, especially to us, in the greatest things.

4. Our first special love to God is properly and rationally raised by belief in his goodness in himself and in his common love and mercy to sinners, manifested in the giving of his Son for the world, in granting humanity the conditional promise of pardon and salvation, and in offering us Christ and eternal life. This common love and mercy is extended to us as it is to others. Our first special love to God is not to be grounded in the belief or persuasion of his special, particular, electing, redeeming, or saving love toward us above others who have the same invitations and offers. It is the knowledge of common love and mercy, not yet of special love and mercy already possessed, that is appointed to be the motive of our first special love to God. (Yet within that first love there is already an apprehension that God is our only possible felicity, and that he will give us a special interest in his favor if we return to him through faith in Christ.)

Several reasons support this:

1.) Every person is bound to love God with a special love, but not every person is specially loved by him. No one is bound to love God as one who specially loves them unless they are in fact so beloved, for otherwise they would be obligated to believe a falsehood and to love what is not real, and grace would be founded on error and deceit. The object must exist before the act. God’s special love must exist before its revelation; as revealed, it must come before our belief of it; as believed, it must come before our loving him on that basis.

2.) The first saving faith is inseparably joined with special love. Christ is believed in and embraced as the way or means to God as the end, otherwise it is not true faith. The willing of the end (which is love) precedes, in the order of nature, the choice and use of the means as such. If we must love God as one who specially loves us in our very first act of love, then we must believe him as such in our very first act of faith, and if so, it must be a revealed truth to us.

But it is not revealed to the elect themselves before their faith and first love; for if it were, the revelation would have to be either ordinary or extraordinary. If ordinary, it would come either directly from Scripture or from evidences within ourselves that Scripture identifies as marks of God’s special love. But neither of these applies: Scripture promises salvation not to named persons but to described persons, and there is no evidence of God’s special love before a person’s faith, repentance, and first love to God. And extraordinary revelation by inspiration or angel is not the ordinary means by which faith is produced, for faith is the belief of God speaking to us through his written word.

Where there is no object of love, there can be no love; where there is no revelation of it to the understanding, there is no object for the will; and until a person first believes and loves God, he has no revelation that God specially loves him. Search as long as you will, you will find no other basis.

3.) If the wicked were condemned for failing to love a false or merely imaginary object, this would quiet their consciences in hell once they had detected the deceit and seen the natural impossibility and contradiction involved.

4.) The first love to God is more a love of desire than of possession, and it is therefore sufficient to raise it that we see the possibility of being forever happy in God and enjoying his special love, even though we do not yet know that we possess that love. The nature of the matter itself proclaims it most rational and fitting that we love the Infinite Good, who has done so much through the death of his Son to remove the obstacles to our salvation, who is so far reconciled to the world in that death as to send a message of reconciliation entreating us to accept Christ, pardon, and salvation freely offered, and who is himself the offered happiness of the soul. Anyone who dares say that this is not objectively sufficient to engage the soul in special love is a blind undervaluer of wonderful mercy.

5.) The first special grace brings no new object for faith or love, but produces a new act upon the object that was already revealed.

5. Our love to God is greatly increased and strengthened afterward by assurance or settled persuasion of his particular, special love to us. All Christians should therefore highly value such assurance, as the appointed means of advancing them to greater love toward God.

6. As we know God here through the mirror of his Son, his Word, and his creatures, so we most keenly love him here as his goodness appears in his works, his graces, his Word, and his Son.

7. The closer we come to perfection, the more we shall love God for himself and for his infinite natural goodness and perfections, not setting aside the consideration of his goodness toward us, but regarding him above all for his own sake, being drawn to him beyond ourselves.

Second. Though love in its own nature is always the same, being nothing but the rational appetite for good, or the will’s inclination toward good as apprehended by the understanding; the first movement of the will toward good, arising either from that natural inclination toward good which is the nature of the will and the very weight of the soul, or from healing grace that repairs what sin has broken in nature, yet love differs according to the condition of the one who loves and the way love is expressed in action.

1.) Either the lover is in hopeful pursuit of the beloved, and then it is desiring, seeking love.

2.) Or the lover is, or seems to be, denied, bereft, and deprived of the beloved, in whole or in part, and then it is mourning, lamenting love.

3.) Or the lover enjoys the beloved, and then it is enjoying, delighting love.

These three states map onto three conditions:

1.) The ordinary love that grace produces on earth is a predominance of seeking, desiring love, encouraged by some small foretastes of enjoying, delighting love, and largely accompanied by mourning, lamenting love.

2.) The condition of deserted, dark, declining, relapsing, and melancholy, tempted Christians is a predominance of mourning, lamenting love, sustained by some measure of seeking, desiring love, but lacking enjoying, delighting love.

3.) The condition of the glorified is the perfection of enjoying, delighting love alone. All the rest is ordered to bring us to this.

Third. The reasons why love to God is so great, so exalted, and so necessary, and why it is esteemed above other graces, are these:

1.) Love is the movement of the soul toward its end, and the end is more excellent than all the means that lead to it.

2.) The love, or will, or heart is the man himself; where the heart and love are, there the man is. To love God as God, to offer him the heart, is the fullest surrender of the whole person to him. God never truly has what is his until we love him. Love is the supreme, vital, significant movement of the soul: as the heart, or will, or love is, so you may rightly call the man.

Tauler writes that it is nobler and more excellent to exercise love in God than to exercise the virtues for God’s sake; that love is the shortest way to God, the way by which we come to him most swiftly; and that without love no virtue has any supernatural savor for a person, since love is the form of all the virtues. Through this exercise of love, he adds, a person comes to such a loathing of himself that he not only despises himself but bears being despised by others with an even mind, and even rejoices in their contempt.

3.) The love of God is the perfection and highest development of all the soul’s faculties, and the end toward which all other graces tend, grow, and in which they complete their operations.

4.) The love of God is the animating spirit of moral excellence in all other graces, not their form exactly, but that in which their acceptability to God consists. Without love, they are to God as a lifeless corpse is to us. To prove any action sincere and acceptable to God is to prove that it comes from a willing, loving mind; without that proof, no other proof will ever suffice.

5.) Love is the commander of the soul. God therefore knows that if he has our hearts he has everything, for all else is at love’s command. It is, as it were, the very nature of the will, which is the commanding faculty, and its object is the ultimate end, which is the commanding object. Love sets the mind to thinking, the tongue to speaking, the hands to working, the feet to moving, and every faculty obeys its command.

6.) The obedience that love commands shares in love’s own nature: it is a ready, cheerful, willing obedience, acceptable to God and pleasant to ourselves.

7.) Love is a pure, chaste, and cleansing grace that powerfully casts out all attachment to created things from the soul. The love of God quenches all carnal and sinful love, and most effectively lifts the soul to such high delights that it comes to despise and forget the trifles it once admired.

8.) The love of God is the true acknowledgment and honoring of him as good. That blessed attribute, his Goodness, is denied and despised by those who do not love him. The light of the sun would not be valued, honored, or used by the world if there were no eyes to see it; and the goodness of God is to those who do not love him as light to those who have no eyes. If God had intended his goodness to remain unknown and neglected, he would never have made rational creatures. Only those who truly love him give him the glory of his goodness.

9.) Love, in its attainment, is the enjoying and delighting grace, the very contentment and felicity of the soul, both because it makes us capable of receiving the most delightful communications of God’s love to us, and because it is the soul’s delightful union with its most amiable and fulfilling object.

10.) Love is the everlasting grace, and the work we shall be doing in heaven forever. These are the reasons for love’s pre-eminence.

Augustine (Tractate 9 on John), after showing that among human beings loving a beautiful person does not make the lover beautiful, says: "Our soul is made ugly by iniquity; by loving God it is made beautiful. What kind of love is it that makes the lover beautiful? God is always Father: he loved us when we were ugly, so that out of the ugly he might make the beautiful. We shall be beautiful by loving him who is beautiful. As love grows in you, so grows your beauty; for love itself is the beauty of the soul."

Fourth. The love of creatures has its contraries at both extremes, in excess and in defect. But the love of God has no contrary in excess, for Infinite Goodness cannot possibly be loved too much (unless perhaps the emotion might in some cases be raised to a degree that disturbs or distracts the mind). The odious vices contrary to the love of God are:

1.) Privative: not loving him.

2.) Positive: hating him.

3.) Opposite: loving creatures in his place.

All three meet in every unsanctified soul. That all such souls are void of the true love of God and taken up with creature love is beyond doubt. Whether they are all haters of God may seem more open to question, but it is equally certain.

In most people, hatred of God does not break out into open opposition, persecution, or blasphemy as it does with some given over to desperate wickedness; nor do such people think that they hate him. Yet aversion of the will is hatred of God, and if people did not have a deep aversion to him they would not forsake him and refuse to be converted, despite every argument of love that might be used to draw them. Displeasure, refusal, and aversion are hatred.

If you think it impossible that people can hate God, whom they confess to be infinitely good, consider these points for a true understanding of this hatred.

1.) It is not as good that they hate him.

2.) It is not God simply and absolutely in himself that they hate, and so it is not everything in God that they hate.

3.) It is not the name of God that they hate.

4.) What they hate is, first, God as he seems unsuitable to them and unfit for their delight and love, a seeming produced by their carnal inclination toward things of a different nature, the sinful corruption of their appetites, and the blindness and error of their minds.

5.) They hate God as he stands against their carnal desires: his holy nature opposes their unholiness, he hates their sin, and his laws forbid them the very things they most love and delight in. They hate God as a madman hates his keeper and physician and takes them for enemies, or as a hungry dog hates the one who keeps it from the meat it craves or would snatch from its mouth.

6.) They hate God as one who, by his holiness, justice, and truth, is bound to condemn them for their sin, and so, as a consequence of their sin, is their enemy who will destroy them unless they forsake it. When their wills are enslaved to their sins and they cannot bear to be forbidden them, and yet see that God will damn them in hell-fire if they do not cast those sins away, this fills them with displeasure against God as holy and just.

7.) From there they consequently hate him in his other attributes: his omniscience, because he always sees them; his omnipresence, because he is always with them; his omnipotence, because he is irresistible and able to punish them; his very mercy as shown to others, when they can have no share in it; and even his immutability, eternity, and very being, as he will continue to be the avenger of their wickedness. So the wicked in despair wish there were no God; and in prosperity they wish he were not their Governor and Judge, or that he were unholy and unjust and would let them do as they please without accountability or punishment.

In this way God is hated by the wicked in proportion to the measure of their wickedness, their carnal interest, and the desires he opposes. Two things are worth noting here:

1.) The hatred of God begins with the sensual love of temporal things that he forbids.

2.) The great and powerful among the wicked, and those with the strongest carnal desires, are rightly the greatest haters of God, having the greatest opposing interest and being most in love with the things he prohibits and will condemn.

Fifth. The counterfeit of love to God is something that resembles true love and yet is consistent with its prevailing absence, and thus produces self-deceiving hypocrisy.

1.) One counterfeit occurs when a person loves only those aspects of God they believe do not oppose their lusts and carnal interests, such as his mercy and readiness to forgive, and then concludes they truly love God, while in fact hating his holiness and other attributes.

2.) Another counterfeit is to love God under a fundamental misapprehension: imagining he shares the sinner’s outlook and will overlook ungodliness without condemnation. This is not love of God at all but love of something contrary to God. If people’s fantasies paint God as a friend to sin, an enemy to holiness, and false in his threatenings, and they love that imagined being, then so far from truly loving God they are committing an odious blasphemy against him.

3.) Another counterfeit is to love God only for his temporal mercies, because he preserves and sustains us, while resisting him whenever he offers spiritual gifts.

4.) Another counterfeit is to mistake intellectual approval in the mind, or honor paid with the lips and the knee, for true love. In a word, any love of God that does not regard him as God truly is, that is not supreme, and that is subordinate to love of the creature, is merely counterfeit.

Sixth. The directions for exercising love to God are as follows.

Direction 1: Consider carefully that love for our Creator, Redeemer, and Regenerator is the very end for which we were created, redeemed, and regenerated, and how right it is that God should obtain the end of such excellent works. By neglecting or opposing this love of God, which is that end, we in effect neglect or oppose the works of creation, redemption, and regeneration themselves.

Let us press these works of God upon our own hearts and say: "O sluggish soul! Have you forgotten the purpose for which you were created, and for which you were endued with rational faculties? Do you regret being a human being, and refuse the proper work of one? What is an instrument good for, apart from its intended end and use? God made the sun to shine, and it shines; he made the earth to support us and bear fruit, and it does so; he made you to love him, and will you refuse and disobey? How noble and excellent is your calling compared to theirs! Is the fruit of the earth, the labor of your beast, or the service of any lower creature as sweet and honorable a work as yours, to know and love your bountiful, glorious Creator? How happy is your lot compared to theirs! And yet will you abandon your place and descend to more ignoble objects, as though you would rather have been some base, mean animal?"

"If you would not rather be a beast than a human being, why do you choose the love and pleasures of a beast and refuse the love and pleasures of a human? Is creation, and the image of God in a rational, free soul, something to be despised for nothing? What is the sun good for if it yields no light or heat? And what are you good for beyond the beasts that perish, if you neither know nor love your Creator?"

"If God offered to strip your humanity and turn you into a horse or dog, you would think he was thrusting you into misery, and yet you can voluntarily and willfully strip your own humanity and take it as your ease and pleasure. If death came this night to dissolve your nature, it would not please you, and yet you can daily destroy your nature in its use and end and not lament it!"

"It would have been better never to have been a human being, never to have had a heart or love within me, than to spend that love on anything other than the holy love of my Creator. It is true that I have a body made to eat and drink and sleep, but all of this exists only to serve my soul in the love of him who gives me everything. Life is not for food, drink, or play; these exist for life, and life for the higher ends of life."

Look to your Redeemer, drowsy soul, and ask for what end he redeemed you. Was it that you might wander a few years about the earth and sleep and sport in the flesh? Or was it to crucify you to the world and raise you up to the love of God? He came down from heaven, from love itself, being full of love, to reveal the loveliness of God, to reconcile you to him, to remove the enmity, and by love to teach you the art of love. His love constrained him to offer himself as a sacrifice for sin, so that you might become a priest to God yourself, offering the sacrifice of an inflamed heart in love and praise. Will you then disappoint your Redeemer, and deprive yourself of the benefits of his love? The means exists for the end; you might as well say you want no redemption as say you will not love the Lord.

And ask yourself, O drowsy soul, for what purpose you were regenerated and sanctified by the Spirit. Was it not that you might know and love the Lord? What is the Spirit of adoption given to believers but a Spirit of prevailing love to God? (Gal 4:6) You could have loved vanity and doted on your fleshly friends and pleasures without the Spirit of God; the Spirit did not come for those things but to destroy them, and to kindle a nobler, heavenly fire in your breast.

Examine, search, and test yourself: has the Spirit truly sanctified you or not? Do you not know that "if any man have not the Spirit of Christ, the same is none of his"? (2 Cor 13:5 Rom 8:9) And if Christ and his Spirit dwell in you, your love is dead to earthly vanity and awakened and raised toward the most holy God. Live then in the Spirit, if you have the Spirit; to walk in the Spirit is to walk in love. Has the regenerating Spirit given you a new principle of love for this very purpose, done so much to stir it up, and fanned the coals so often, and will your carnality or sluggishness yet extinguish it? As you would not renounce or despise your creation, your redemption, and your regeneration, do not despise or neglect the love of your Creator, Redeemer, and Regenerator, which is the end of them all.

Direction 2: Think of the perfect fitness of God to be the only object of your supreme love, and of how natural and necessary it should appear to do a work so agreeable to right reason and uncorrupted nature. Turn away in revulsion from every temptation that would make God seem unsuitable to you.

"O sluggish and unnatural soul! Should not an object so admirably suited to you draw you? Should not such compelling goodness attract you? Should not perfect loveliness win you wholly to itself? Simply know yourself and know God, and then try to hold back your love if you can! Where should a fish live but in the water? Where should birds fly but in the air? God is your very element; you die and sink down into brutishness if you forsake him or are taken from him."

"What should delight the sense of smell but fragrance? What should satisfy appetite but fitting food? What should delight the eye but light and what it reveals? What should delight the ear but harmony? And what should delight the soul but God? If you know yourself, you know that the nature of your mind inclines toward knowledge, rising from effects to causes, and from lower and lesser matters to the highest and greatest. And if you know God, you know that he is the cause of all things, the maker, preserver, and orderer of all, the being of all beings, the most great, most wise, most good, and most blessed, so that to know him is to know all things, and to know the most excellent, independent, and glorious being, who will leave no darkness or unsatisfied desire in your soul. Is he not then most fitting for your mind?"

"If you know yourself, you know that your will, free as it is, has a natural and necessary inclination toward goodness. You cannot love evil as evil, nor can you help but love what you perceive as good, and especially the chief good, when rightly perceived. And if you know God, you know that he is infinitely good in himself, the source of all the good in the world, the giver of all the good you have received, and the only fitting and adequate good to satisfy your desires for all time to come. And yet shall it be so hard to love, in keeping with your truest nature, so perfect, full, and fitting a good, Goodness and Love himself, who has already begun to love you?"

"Are any of the creatures you love as suitable to you? Are they good and only good, perfectly good, unchangeably and eternally good? Are they the spring of comfort and the satisfying happiness of your soul? Have you found them to be so, or do you expect to find them best at last? Foolish soul! Can you love the uneven, defective, troublesome creature, because in some one small, inferior use it seems fitting to you, and yet not love him who is everything that rational love could possibly desire?"

"True, the creature is near to you and God is infinitely above you, yet he is nearer to you than any creature. And though he dwells in glory far above you, you are passing to him in his glory and will soon be there. The sun is distant from you, yet it communicates its light and heat to you and is more fitted to you than the candle that is closer. True, God is most holy and you are too earthly and unclean, but is he not all the more suited to purify you and make you holy?"

"If you are poor, you would rather have the company and favor of the rich who can relieve you than of beggars who can only lament with you. If you are unlearned and ignorant, you want the company of the wise and learned who can teach you, not of those as ignorant as yourself. Who is more suited to your desires than he who possesses all that you could wisely desire and is willing and ready to satisfy you to the full? Who is more suited to your love than he who loves you most, has done most for you, must do all that will ever be done for you, and is himself most lovely in his infinite perfections?"

"O poor, diseased, fallen soul! Had sin not corrupted and disordered and perverted you, you would have found God as suited to your love as food to your hunger, drink to your thirst, and rest to your weariness, as the earth and water and air and sun are to those who inhabit the world. How far have you fallen! How long have you wandered from your God, that you now draw back from him as from a stranger, and look away from him as from an unsuitable good!"

Direction 3: Never imagine God to be far away from you; think of him instead as always near you and with you, in whose present love and goodness you subsist. Nearness of objects excites the faculties: we hear no sound, smell no odor, taste no sweetness, and see no color when the source is too distant. The mind, being limited in its activity, neglects or cannot reach things that are too far away; it requires some nearness to its object just as the senses do. This is especially true when it comes to stirring the affections and moving us to action. A distant danger does not raise such fear, a distant misery does not cause such grief, and a distant benefit does not bring such pleasure as those that are close at hand. Death affects us far more deeply when it seems near than when we think we have many years yet to live.

In the same way, carnal minds are so submerged in the flesh and so captive to the senses that they take little notice of what they cannot see, and therefore think of God as absent because they cannot see him. They think of him as confined to heaven, the way we think of a friend who is on the other side of the world, who, even if not entirely forgotten, is too distant for us to converse with in any delightful way.

"Remember always, O my soul, that none is so near you as your God. Even Seneca could say of good people that ‘God is with us, and in us.’ Nature taught the heathens that ‘in him we live, and move, and have our being.’ Your friend may be absent, but God is never absent from you: he is with you when, as far as other people are concerned, you are alone. The sun can illuminate only one part of the earth at a time and must leave the rest in darkness. But God is with you night and day, and for the soul that enjoys him there is no night."

"Your life, your health, your love, and your joy are not nearer to you than your God: he is now before you, around you, within you, moving you toward good, restraining you from evil, marking and accepting all that is well, disliking and opposing all that is ill. The light of the sun does not more certainly fill a room and surround you than God does with his goodness. He is as much at leisure to observe you, to converse with you, to hear and help you, as if you were his only creature, just as the sun can illuminate every bird and insect as fully as if it shone on nothing else."

"Open the eye of faith and reason, and behold your God! Do not forget him, or through unbelief deny him, and then say, ‘he is not here.’ Do not say that the sun does not shine because you have shut your eyes. O, do not quench your love to God by pretending he is out of reach and occupied with other things! Do not turn to lesser delights by imagining he has turned you over to them. Love him not as an absent friend, but as the friend who is always in your sight, in your heart, and at your very center, the fuel that lies closest to the flames of love."

Direction 4: All other graces must do their part in supporting love, must be exercised in service to it, and must aim, directly or indirectly, at promoting it. Fear and watchfulness must keep away the sin that would extinguish love, and guard you from the guilt that would drive the soul from God. Repentance and mortification must clear away the diverting and deceiving objects that would steal your love from God. Faith must show you God as present in all his blessed attributes and perfections. Hope must depend on him for closer access and the promised joy. Prudence must choose the fittest seasons, means, and aids for our special approaches to him, and teach us how to avoid hindrances.

Obedience must keep us in a fit condition for communion with him. A mind that is let loose to wander after vanity for the rest of the day is not ready, in an hour of prayer or meditation, to be caught up in the love of God. Walking in a fitness for that love must be the work of the day and of our lives, even if we are not always in its immediate and lively exercise.

To sin deliberately for one hour and then be taken up with the love of God the next is as unlikely as abusing your parents in one hour and finding the pleasure of their love in the next, or falling and breaking a bone in one hour and then running and working as freely as before in the next.

We must also ensure that all other graces are exercised in their proper subordination to love, and that none degenerates into a harmful extreme that hinders this, which is their true end. When you set yourself to repent and mourn for sin, it must be from love and for love, so that by an earnest grieving over the injuries you have done to a gracious God, you may be cleansed from the filth that displeases him, and being reconciled to him in Christ, may be fit to return to the exercises and delights of love.

When you fear God, let it be with a filial fear that comes from love and serves only to preserve or restore love. Avoid as sinful that slavish fear which tends toward hatred and would make you flee from God. Love casts out this tormenting fear and frees the soul from the spirit of bondage.

The devil tempts those prone to melancholy to live before God as though they were constantly among bears or lions about to devour them, for he knows how great an enemy such fear is to love. Satan would never promote such fears if they came from God and tended to our good. You have never found him advancing your love or delight in God! But he cares nothing for how deeply he plunges you into distracting terrors. If he can, he will frighten you out of your love, out of your comforts, and out of your sanity. A dull and sluggish sinner he keeps from fear, lest it should wake him from his sin; but a poor, melancholy, penitent soul he would keep under perpetual terror. Such persons find fear so easy that they may take this very ease as evidence that the fear is sinful and disordered, for gracious works do not come so easily.

Resist also all humiliation and grief that do not, directly or indirectly, tend to support your love. A religion that leads only to grief, terminates in grief, and goes no further has far too much in it of the enemy’s malice to be of God. No tears are desirable except those that tend to clear the eyes from the filth of sin so that they may see the loveliness of God more clearly.

Direction 5: Regard your lack of love to God, together with the turning of that love toward created things, as the very heart of the old man, your most comprehensive and odious sin. See it as the life of all your particular sins, and hate it above all the rest. This is the very death and greatest deformity of the soul: the absence of God’s image and Spirit, and in a real sense of God himself.

"I never loathe my heart so much as when I observe how little it loves the Lord. It seems to me that all the sins I have ever committed are not so loathsome to me as this want of love to God. And it is this that is the poison and malignity of every particular sin. I never hate myself so fully as when I observe how little of God is within me, and how far my heart is estranged from him. I never so fully approve of the justice of God, should he condemn me and thrust me forever from his presence, as when I observe how far I have thrust him from my heart."

"If there were any sin that did not proceed from a want of love to God, I could more easily pardon it to myself, knowing that God would more easily pardon it. But not to love the God of love, the fountain of love, the joy of souls, this is a sin unfit to be pardoned to anyone until it is repented of and at least partly cured."

"Christ will forgive it to none who cling to it; and when it becomes incurable, it is the defining sin of hell, the mark of devils and the damned. If God will not give me a heart to love him, I wish I had never had a heart at all. If he gives me this, he gives me everything."

"Happy are the poor, the despised, and the persecuted who can but live in the love of God. O miserable are those emperors, kings, and lords who are strangers to this heavenly love and love their lusts above their Maker! If I might but live in the fervent love of God, what does it matter in what country, what cottage, or what prison I live? If I do not live in the love of God, my homeland would be worse than exile; a palace would be a prison; a crown would be a wretched comfort to one who has thrown away his true comfort and is heading toward everlasting shame and sorrow."

Were we but rightly sensible of the worth of love, and of the vileness and malignity that are in the want of it, we could not remain at rest in our daily neglect of it; it would drive us to seek it and to stir it up.

Direction 6: Use the principle of self-love to promote the love of God, by considering what he has done for you and what he is and would be to you. I do not mean carnal, disordered self-love, which is the greatest enemy of the love of God; I mean that rational love of happiness and self-preservation which God implanted in innocent Adam and has planted in human nature as necessary to his governance. This natural, innocent self-love is the remaining principle in the human heart upon which God himself presupposes in all his laws and exhortations, and which he turns to advantage in his works and Word, for the conversion of the wicked and for persuading his own servants to obedience.

This is the common principle we share with all the wicked of the world: that all people should desire and seek to be happy, and should choose and do what is best for themselves. Without this, it would be pointless for ministers to preach, since we would have no common ground in them to sow our seed and to work upon. If self-love is informed and guided by understanding, it will compel you to love God and show you that nothing deserves to be loved so much. Everyone who is a man must love himself, we do not need to persuade him of this. And everyone who loves himself will love what he judges to be best for himself. Every wise person must know that whatever good they have ever had, or can have, came from God. Why do people love lust, or wealth, or honor, except because they believe these things are good for them? Would they not love God, if they practically knew that he is the best of all things for them, better than everything else combined?

"Unnatural, ungrateful heart! Can you love yourself and not love him who gave you yourself and gives you all things? Nature teaches all people to love their most devoted and necessary friends. Do we deserve any reward for loving those who love us, when even tax collectors do the same? Are you not also obligated to love those who hate, curse, and persecute you? What reward, then, is due to your unnatural ingratitude, that you cannot love your greatest friend? All the friends who were ever kind to you and did you good were merely his messengers delivering what he sent you. Can you love the bearer and not the giver?"

"He made you a human being and not a beast. He placed your life within his visible church, not among deceived unbelievers or miserable heathens who have never heard, except in mockery, of the Redeemer’s name. He brought you into a land of light, in a Reformed church where knowledge and holiness have as great an advantage as anywhere in all the world, not among deceived, ignorant Papists, where ambition would have been your governor, pride and tyranny would have made your laws, and a formal, ceremonial imitation of piety would have been your religion. He gave you parents who raised you in his fear, not parents who were profane and ignorant and would have restrained and persecuted you from a holy life."

"He spoke to your conscience early in childhood and kept you from the gross sins you would otherwise have committed. He bore with the folly and frailties of your youth. He gave you, at the right times, the books, teachers, companions, and aids most suited to you, and blessed them to your further awakening and instruction, while he passed by others and left them in their sins. He taught you to pray and heard your prayers. He turned all your fears and groans to your spiritual good. He pardoned all your grievous sins; and since that time, how much has he endured and forgiven!"

"He gave you necessary and timely discipline and brought you up in the school of affliction, yet moderated it so that it would not disable or discourage you, only correct you, and keep you from complacency, waywardness, dullness, and contempt of holy things, and so ruin every temptation toward ambition, worldliness, and fleshly lust. By threats of great calamities and death, he has repeatedly awakened you to cry to heaven; and by equally frequent and remarkable deliverances, he has answered your prayers and encouraged you to keep waiting upon him. He has given you the earnest prayers of many hundreds of his faithful servants, and has heard them on your behalf in many a distress. He has preserved you in an astonishing way through manifold dangers."

"He has not made you among the poorest of people, where poverty might tempt you to bitterness, nor set you on the pinnacle of worldly honor, where dizziness might have been your ruin, and where temptations to pride, lust, luxury, and hostility to a holy life are so violent that few escape. He has not launched you onto a sea of cares, worldly entanglements, and burdensome business, but has fed you with what is fitting and given you leisure to walk with God. He has not chained you to an unprofitable calling or used you as those who live like their animals, eating, drinking, sleeping, and playing, living merely to live, but has called you to the noblest and sweetest work, making your daily occupation what others were glad only to taste as recreation and refreshment."

"He has allowed you to converse with books and with the best and wisest people, and to spend your days drinking in delightful knowledge, not for your pleasure alone, but for your use; not for yourself only, but for many others. How many sweet and precious truths has he allowed you to feed on all day long, while others are pulled away and usually glimpse them only from a distance! How many precious hours has he granted in his holy assemblies and in his honorable and most pleasant work! How often have his day, his holy and uncorrupted ordinances, the fellowship of his saints, the naming of his name and kingdom, the pleading of his cause with sinners, and the celebrating of his praise been my delight!"

"How many hundreds that he has sent have lacked the abundant encouragement I have had! When he saw the disease of my despondent mind, he did not test me by withholding success, nor, as with Jonah, let me follow my own inclination and run ahead of his work, but drew me on with continual encouragements and strewed the entire way with mercies."

"His mercies to me in the souls of others have been so great that I will acknowledge them in private rather than record them here, where I must limit myself to those ordinary mercies of believers that lie along the common road to heaven. And how endless it would be to name them all! All the good that friends and enemies have done me! All the wise and gracious arrangements of his providence in every condition and change of life, change of times, and every place to which he brought me! His mercies renewed each day! His support through all my weakness and decline; his plentiful supplies; his gracious help; his daily forgiveness; and the glorious hope of a blessed immortality which his Son has purchased and his covenant and Spirit have sealed to me! The mercies contained in one Christ, one Holy Spirit, one Holy Scripture, and in the blessed God himself!"

"These things I have laid before you, ungrateful heart, to shame you for your want of love to God. And I leave them on record as a witness for God against your ingratitude, to cover you with shame if you deny your love to such a God. Every one of all these mercies, and countless more, will rise up against you and shame you before God and all the world as a monster of unkindness, if you do not love him who has treated you thus."

Consider also what God is for your future good, not only what he has been until now, how all-sufficient, how powerful, merciful, and good. But more on this shortly.

Direction 7: Use the vanity and vexation of the creature, together with all your disappointments, injuries, and afflictions, to promote your love to God. This works through a double advantage: First, by recognizing that there is nothing worthy of diverting your love or robbing God of it, unless you are willing to love your own trouble and distress. Second, that love to God is the very comfort by which you must be sustained under the injuries and troubles you meet with in the world; to neglect it, therefore, is simply to surrender yourself to misery.

"Is it for nothing, O my soul, that God has turned the world loose against you? That devils rage against you; wicked people reproach and slander you and seek your ruin; friends prove insufficient and like broken reeds? It would have been just as easy for God to have prospered you in the world, suited all things to your own desires, and strewed your way with the flowers of worldly comfort and delight. But he knew your tendency to ruin yourself with earthly loves and how easily your heart is drawn away from your God. He has therefore wisely and mercifully ordered things so that your temptations shall not be too strong, and no creature shall appear to you in an overly attractive, tempting form. He has allowed them to become your enemies, and will you love an enemy better than your God?"

"What! An envious and malicious world! A world of cares, griefs, and pains, a weary, restless, empty world! How deep and piercing are its injuries! How shallow and deceitful is its friendship! How real are its sorrows! What hollow shows and dreams are its delights! How constant are its cares and labors! How seldom and brief are its flattering smiles! Its comforts are overshadowed by the certain expectation of sorrows to follow; its sorrows are deepened by the expectation of more. In the midst of its flatteries, I hear something within me saying, ‘You must die; this is but the road to rottenness and dust.’ I see a shroud and a grave always before me; I foresee how I must lie in pain and groaning, and then become a loathsome corpse. And is this a world to be more delighted in than God?"

"What have I left for my support and solace, in the midst of all this vanity and vexation, but to look to him who is the all-sufficient, sure, and never-failing good? I must love him, or I have nothing to love but enmity or deceit. And is this the worst of God’s design in permitting and causing my pains and disappointments here, that it is simply to drive my foolish heart back to himself, so that I may have the solid delight and happiness of his love? Then let his blessed will be done!"

"Come home, my soul, my wandering, tired, grieved soul! Love where your love will not be lost. Love him who will not reject you or deceive you, nor repay you as the world does, with injuries and abuse. Do not despair of welcome, though the world denies it you. The peaceable region is above. In the world you will have trouble, so that in Christ you may have peace. Retire to the harbor if you would be free from storms. God will receive you when the world casts you off, if you heartily cast off the world for him. What a solace it is to the soul to be driven clearly from the world to God, and there to be engaged in that sacred love which will accompany us into the world of love."

Direction 8: Labor for the truest and fullest conceptions of the goodness and excellencies of God, which constitute his loveliness; and reject all misrepresentations of him as unlovely.

What is perceived as unlovely cannot be loved; and what is perceived as evil is perceived as unlovely. It is therefore the grand design of Satan to conceal God’s goodness and misrepresent him as evil, not by denying that God is good in himself, for he has no hope of being believed in that, but by persuading people that God is not good to them, or by making them forget or overlook his goodness. Not by persuading them that God is evil in himself, but that he is evil toward them, by restraining them from their beloved sins, by hating them as sinners, and by resolving to damn them if they persist impenitently. This, which is actually part of God’s goodness, Satan makes them believe is evil, by drawing them into a course and interest that he knows God is set against, and luring them under the strokes of his justice.

Satan also tempts believers themselves toward poor, diminished, unworthy thoughts of God’s goodness and mercy, keeping them in constant apprehension of his wrath and terror. If he can make them believe that God is their enemy, and cause them to think of him only as a consuming fire, how little are they likely to love him? If Christians understood how much of the devil’s malice against God and against them is exercised in this one work, making God appear unlovely to humanity, they would more carefully guard against such misrepresentations and flee from them with greater horror.

This does not mean that we must first, by the counsel of arrogant reason and self-love, as some do, draw up a false description of goodness and loveliness in our own minds and make that the measure by which we judge God’s nature, attributes, and decrees; nor must we take his goodness to consist only in his conformity to our opinions, wills, and interests. Rather, we must draw from the Word and works of God that true description of his goodness which he has given of himself, and expunge from our thinking whatever is contrary to it. Think of God’s goodness in proportion with his other attributes.

Raymond Lull counsels the one who prays: in your prayer, love God more than yourself and more than all else; do this and you are just and prudent, settled in love and holiness, and that settled habit is your friend in prayer. When you pray concerning your sins, hold fast to the justice of God by loving it, not by hating it. For if you hate it, the mercy of God cannot be your friend, and your habit becomes cruel and estranged from hope and love, and your loving is perverted into hating, in which hating you would be fixed forever.

"O my soul, how unevenly you have thought of God! You readily believe that his power is omnipotence and his knowledge is omniscience; but of his goodness, how narrow and poor are your conceptions, as if it were nothing beside his power and knowledge. How often you have been struck with wonder at the thought of his greatness, and how rarely moved by the apprehension of his goodness! You gratify the one who would have you believe and tremble, as he does himself, rather than him who would have you believe and love."

"How often you have allowed the malicious enemy to accuse God to you, to make you believe he is a hater of humanity and hateful to humanity, or a hater of you in particular, that he might make you hate God in return! How often you have let him draw a false portrait of your dearest Lord in your thoughts and display him to you in that unlovely shape! How often your conceptions have dishonored and blasphemed his love and goodness, even while you seemed to magnify his knowledge and his power!"

"Think of him now as love itself, as more full of goodness than the sea is full of water, or the sun of light! Love freely and boldly, without the interruptions of suspicion and fear, in the one place where you can be certain you can never love enough. If all the love of men and angels were united in a single flame, they could never love too much, or come anywhere near the measure of the glorious goodness they love. Cast yourself boldly into this ocean of delights. Though the narrowness of your own capacity confines you, yet since there are no bounds in the object of your love, do not let false and unbelieving thoughts confine you further."

"O that I were all eye, to see the glorious loveliness of my God! O that I were all love, that I might be filled with his goodness! O that all the passions of my soul were turned into this holy passion! O that all my fears, and cares, and sorrows were turned into love, and that all the thoughts that crowd confusedly in upon me and disturb me were turned into this one unceasing thought of the infinite goodness of my God! O that all my tears and groanings, yes, and all my other mirth and pleasures, were turned into the melodious songs of love, and that the pulse, the voice, and the activity of love were the whole motion of my soul! Surely in heaven it will be so, though it cannot be expected here."

Direction 9: The great means of promoting love to God is duly to behold him in his appearances to humanity, in the ways of Nature, Grace, and Glory. First, therefore, learn to understand and make good use of his appearances in Nature, to see the Creator in all his works, and through the knowledge and love of those works to be raised to the knowledge and love of him.

Although sin has so disabled us from making proper use of God’s appearances in nature that grace must first restore us before we can do it effectively and acceptably, yet objectively nature remains the same in substance and affords us much help toward the knowledge and love of God. The person who does not know God in the world, and by means of it, does not truly know the world at all.

Some observe that the greatest students of nature are not usually the most advanced in grace, and that philosophers and physicians are seldom great admirers of piety. But this is to judge the wise by the foolish, and to lay the ignorance and impiety of some on the shoulders of others who abhor it. Without question, the person who does not see and admire the Creator in his works is no philosopher but a fool.

If a man devoted himself entirely to knowing the shape and form of letters, copying them elegantly, or cutting them in brass and stone, or printing them, without understanding their meaning or use, it would be no wonder if he remained ignorant of the arts and sciences those letters, properly understood, would teach him. Such a man might be called an engraver, a scrivener, or a printer, but not a scholar. And no more can the atheist be called a philosopher or a learned man, when he denies the most wise and almighty Author while beholding his works, since the nature and name of God is so plainly engraved upon them all.

A great part of a Christian’s daily work is to see and admire God in his works and to use them as steps by which to ascend to God himself. "The works of the Lord are great, sought out of all them that have pleasure therein. His work is honourable and glorious; and his righteousness endureth for ever. He hath made his wonderful works to be remembered." (Ps 111:2–4) "I meditate on all thy works; I muse on the works of thy hands." (Ps 143:5) "I will meditate also of all thy work, and talk of thy doings." (Ps 77:12) "For thou, Lord, hast made me glad through thy work. I will triumph in the works of thy hands. A brutish man knoweth not; neither doth a fool understand this." (Ps 92:4–6)

As the praising of God’s works, so the observing of God in his works is much of the occupation of a holy soul. "Great is the Lord, and greatly to be praised; and his greatness is unsearchable. One generation shall praise thy works to another, and shall declare thy mighty acts. I will speak of the glorious honour of thy Majesty, and of thy wondrous works. And men shall speak of the might of thy terrible acts; and I will declare thy greatness. They shall abundantly utter the memory of thy great goodness, and shall sing of thy righteousness. All thy works shall praise thee, O Lord; and thy saints shall bless thee. The Lord is righteous in all his ways, and holy in all his works." (Ps 145:3–7, 10, 17)

"That which might be known of God is manifest in them; for God hath shewn it unto them. For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made; even his eternal power and Godhead: so that they are without excuse." (Rom 1:19–20)

If we move through the world as believers and rational creatures ought, we should as often as David repeat these words: "O that men would praise the Lord for his goodness, and for his wondrous works to the children of men! And let them sacrifice the sacrifices of thanksgiving, and declare his works with rejoicing. They that go down to the sea in ships, that do business in great waters; these see the works of the Lord, and his wonders in the deep." (Ps 107:21–24)

But this subject is better suited to a full volume, natural philosophy treated theologically, than to so brief a treatment. What an excellent book the visible world is for the daily study of a holy soul! Light is no more visible to the eye in the sun than the goodness of God is visible, in the sun and in every creature, to the mind. If I do not love God when all the world reveals his loveliness and every creature testifies that he is good, what a blind and wicked heart I have!

O what wonderful wisdom, goodness, and power appear in everything we see, in every tree, plant, and flower; in every bird, beast, and fish; in every worm, fly, and creeping thing; in every part of the body of man or beast, and far more in the admirable composition of the whole; in the sun, moon, stars, and meteors; in lightning and thunder, air and winds, rain and waters, heat and cold, fire and earth; and especially in the composed frame of all things, so far as we can see them set together, in the admirable order and cooperation of all things, in their times and seasons, and the wonderful usefulness of all for humanity.

How glorious is the power, wisdom, and goodness of God in the whole frame of nature! Every creature silently speaks his praise and declares him to humanity, whose office it is, as the world’s high-priest, to stand between the creatures and the great Creator and expressly offer him the praise of all.

"When I consider thy heavens, the work of thy fingers, the moon and the stars, which thou hast ordained; what is man, that thou art mindful of him? and the son of man, that thou visitest him? For thou hast made him a little lower than the angels, and hast crowned him with glory and honour. Thou madest him to have dominion over the works of thy hands; thou hast put down all things under his feet. O Lord, our Lord, how excellent is thy name in all the earth!" (Ps 8:3–6, 9) "O that men would praise the Lord for his goodness, and declare his wondrous works to the children of men! The earth is full of the goodness of the Lord." Psalm 33:5 Read Psalm 65 as well. Thus love God as he appears in the works of nature.

Direction 10: Study to know God as he appears more clearly to sinners in his goodness in the works of grace, especially in his Son, his covenant, and his saints, and there love him in admiring wonder at his love. Here love has turned our sin and unworthiness, our necessities and miseries, the law and justice, and the flames of hell into an occasion for its own fullest display. The abundance of sin and misery has glorified abounding grace: grace that draws sons for God from among the willing slaves of the devil, that brings children of light out of darkness and living souls out of death, that rescues heirs of heaven from the gates of hell and brings us as from the gallows to the throne.

1. A believing view of the nature, undertaking, love, obedience, doctrine, example, sufferings, intercession, and kingdom of Jesus Christ cannot but set the believer’s heart ablaze with a corresponding degree of love toward God. To look on Christ and not love God is to have eyes and not see, to overlook God while appearing to look at him. Christ is the most vivid image of infinite goodness, the messenger of the most unsearchable and astonishing love, and the purchaser of the most invaluable benefits ever revealed to humanity.

Our greatest love must be kindled by the greatest revelations and expressions of God’s love. "Greater love hath no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends" (John 15:13), that is, no dearer or clearer way exists for a person to express love to friends. Yet that love is all the more overwhelming when it goes as far for enemies: "But God commendeth his love toward us, in that while we were yet sinners Christ died for us. And if, when we were enemies we were reconciled to God by the death of his Son, much more, being reconciled, we shall be saved by his life." (Rom 5:8–10)

Steep that stiff and hardened heart in the blood of Christ, then, and it will melt. Come near, as Thomas did, and through the passage of his wounds draw near to his heart; it will change your cold and ungrateful heart into the very nature of love. Christ is the greatest teacher of love the world has ever had, he taught it not only by his words but by his blood, by his life, and by his death. If you cannot learn it from him, you can never learn it. Love is the strongest commander of love and the most effective argument to draw us into it, and no one has ever loved at the measure and cost that Christ has loved. To stand by such a fire is the way for a frozen heart to melt and the coldest affections to grow warm. A living faith that continually holds Christ, the mirror of infinite love and goodness, before our faces is the greatest lesson in the art of love.

2. Behold God also in his covenant of grace, which he has made in Christ. There you may see mercies so certain, so great and wonderful, freely given to a world of sinners and to you among them, as will supply abundant matter for love and thankfulness to feed on throughout your life. There you may see how reluctant God is that sinners should perish, how he delights in mercy, and how great and unspeakable that mercy is. There you may see an act of pardon and full forgiveness granted, on the reasonable condition of believing and penitent acceptance, to all mankind. Sins committed over many years together, willful, grievous, aggravated sins, you may see pardoned by a mercy yet more surpassing; enemies of God reconciled to him, condemned rebels saved from hell, brought into his family, and made his children. What an image of the goodness of God shines out in the whole tenor of his word and covenant! Holiness and mercy make up its entire substance, they appear in every line.

The precepts, which seem too strict to sinners, are simply the perfect rules of holiness and love for the health and happiness of humanity. What loveliness did David find in the law itself, and so should we, if we read it with his eyes and heart. It was sweeter to him than honey; he prized it above gold; he cried out, "O how I love thy law! it is my meditation all the day." (Ps 119:97 and 119:127) If the law is so lovely, must not the Lawgiver be far more lovely still, since his goodness appears to us through it? "Good and upright is the Lord; therefore will he teach sinners in the way." (Ps 25:8) "I will delight myself in thy commandments, which I have loved: my hands also will I lift up to thy commandments, which I have loved; and I will meditate on thy statutes." (Ps 119:47–48) How much more joyfully, then, should I love and meditate on the blessed Author of this holy law!

How can anyone read the history of love, the astonishing design of grace in Christ, the mystery that angels eagerly desire to look into, the promises of life to lost and miserable sinners, and not feel the power of love transforming them? "Behold, with what love the Father hath loved us, that we should be called the sons of God." (1 John 3:1) How does God pour out his love on our hearts, except by opening to us in his Word the superabundance of it, and by his Spirit opening our hearts to receive it?

When a poor sinner who has felt the weight of sin and the wrath of God hears with feeling what mercy is offered in the covenant of grace, hears Christ’s messengers tell him from God that all things are now ready, that he is invited to the heavenly feast, even urged and pressed to come in, what melting love must this work in that sinner’s heart! When we see the grant of eternal life sealed to us by the blood of Christ, and a pardoning, justifying covenant so freely made and so surely confirmed by the very God we had so greatly offended, what an incentive to love is here!

When I speak of the covenant I include also the sacraments, which are its accompanying confirming seals and the solemn investiture of the believer with its benefits. In these God is pleased to condescend to the most intimate communion with his church, so that love and thankfulness might lack no aid. There the love of God in Christ applies itself most closely to particular sinners; and what was not sweet to us when it lay on the table becomes sweet when it reaches our mouths. How many hearts has this moved! How many have felt stirrings of love they had not felt before, when they saw Christ crucified before their eyes and heard the minister, in his name and at his command, bid them "Take," and "Eat," and "Drink," commanding them not to refuse their Savior but to receive him and the benefits of his blood as their own, assuring them of his willingness and readiness to forgive and save them.

3. Behold also the loveliness of God in his holy people, who bear his image and are raised up by his love and mercy. If you are truly Christians, you are taught of God to love his servants, to see excellence in the saints on earth, and to make them the people of your delight. (Ps 16:2–3 1 Thess 4:9) And this must make you all the more aware of the surpassing loveliness of the most holy God who made them holy. How often have the fervent, heavenly prayers of lively believers stirred affections in me that I had not felt before! How often have I been warmed by their heavenly discourse!

How admirable is that holy, heavenly disposition and way of life that appears in them, their faith, their love, their trust in God, their cheerful obedience, their hatred of sin, their desire for the good of all, their meekness and patience. How far these qualities raise them above the ignorant, sensual, proud, and ungodly world! How good, then, is that God who makes people good! And how small is the goodness of the best of us compared to his immeasurable goodness! Whenever your fellowship with holy people stirs up your love toward them, rise from that immediately to the God of saints, and turn it all toward him who gives all things, to them and to you.

The privileges and great advancement of the saints, no less than their excellence, should reveal to you the goodness of the God who advances them. Every time you see a saint, however poor or obscure in the world, you see a living monument of the Lord’s abundant kindness. You see a child of God, a member of Christ, an heir of heaven. You see one whose sins are all forgiven, who has been snatched as a brand from the fire, delivered from the power of Satan, and transferred into the kingdom of Christ. You see one for whom Christ has conquered the powers of hell, one freed from the bondage of the flesh, one who has been taken from being the devil’s slave and made a priest to offer up the sacrifices of praise to God.

You see one who has the Spirit of God within him, one who has daily access to heaven and audience with God, one who is dearly beloved by him in Christ. You see in mortal flesh a companion of angels, one who shares the divine nature, who will shortly be above the stars in glory, who will be with Christ and will love and magnify God forever. Is not the loveliness of God plainly apparent in such mercy bestowed on sinful humanity? Should we not begin even now to admire him in his saints and glorify him among his people, he who will come with thousands of his angels to be glorified and admired in them at the last? (2 Thess 1:10)

Consider the abundant deliverances, preservations, provisions, and encouragements that all his servants receive from God. Who has ever truly seen the righteous forsaken, even when they believed themselves forsaken? "For the Lord loveth judgment, and forsaketh not his saints; they are preserved for ever. The law of his God is in his heart; none of his steps shall slide. Mark the perfect man, and behold the upright; for the end of that man is peace." (Ps 37:25, 28, 31, 37) "Precious in the sight of the Lord is the death of his saints." (Ps 116:15) "Ye that love the Lord, hate evil: he preserveth the souls of his saints; he delivereth them out of the hand of the wicked. Light is sown for the righteous, and gladness for the upright in heart." (Ps 97:10–11) "O love the Lord, all his saints! for the Lord preserveth the faithful, and plentifully rewardeth the proud doer." (Ps 31:23)

Direction 11: Do not insist so much on your desire for direct vision that you undervalue the lower apprehensions of faith. Love God by way of faith, as preparation for the love of full intuition.

We are far too prone to crave direct sight, and to regard nothing as capable of truly moving us unless the senses perceive it. Even when we have the surest evidence of unseen realities, we are hardly satisfied unless we can see or feel. This hinders our love for God: we think of him as though he were not, and treat the apprehensions of faith as if they were uncertain, little better than a dream.

It also becomes the ground of dangerous temptations toward unbelief itself. When we account our knowledge of God gained through faith, along with the love and communion exercised thereby, as nothing, we are next tempted to think that no true knowledge of God and communion with him can be attained at all. After long searching and striving, and finding we can reach no further, we are tempted to conclude that the human soul was made, like the beasts, only for present things, incapable of the higher realities revealed in the Gospel, and that if there were indeed a life to come, and humanity were made to enjoy God, we should be drawing nearer to him than we are, and knowing him more fully, and loving him better.

But consider: is it nothing, presumptuous soul, to see God in a glass, in preparation for a nearer sight? Is it nothing to have the heavenly Jerusalem described and promised to you, unless you see and possess it now? Will you travel nowhere unless you can see every step of the road? Would you have no difference between earth and heaven? What more can heaven give you than immediate intuition? Would you have no life of trial in the obedience of faith before the life of fruition and reward? Can you think that a life of sight and sense is a fitting trial to show who is ready for the life of reward?

Ungrateful soul, compare your condition with that of the animals. Is it nothing that you know your Maker through the works of his creation and providence, through the revelations of grace, and through the belief in promised immortality, unless you immediately see him in his glory? Your fellow-creatures do not know him at all. Compare yourself now with yourself in the days of your ignorance and worldliness. Did you then have any such knowledge of God as you now undervalue? Any such communion with him as you now count as nearly nothing? When the light first shone in your eyes and you first experienced the knowledge of God, you thought it something, and you rejoiced in the light. If you could then have suddenly reached as much as you have now attained, would you have called it nothing? Would it not have seemed a greater treasure than knowing both the Indies as your own?

Do not be ungrateful for the little you have received, when God might have left you in that darkness in which the greatest part of the world lies, leaving you to desire no higher knowledge than what feeds your fancy, pride, and lust. Are you so far sunk in flesh and sense as to take intellectual apprehensions for dreams unless sense sees and feels? Will you count your own soul as nothing because it cannot be seen or felt? Must subjects refuse to honor and obey their king unless they have visited his court and seen his face?

Desire the fullest and closest sight; the purest and strongest love; and freely desire the life in which all this will be had. But beware of being too hasty with God, and ungrateful for the mercies of the way. Understand better the difference between your journey and your home, and know what is fitting for travelers to expect. Humbly submit to an obedient waiting in a life of faith, and make much of the testament of Christ until you come of age to possess the inheritance. You must live, and love, and run, and fight, and conquer, and suffer by faith, if you are ever to come to see and to possess the crown.

Direction 12: A powerful means to kindle love for God in a believer is to foresee by faith the glory of heaven, and what God will be there to his saints forever.

Julian of Toledo’s Prognosticon is worth reading here. Didymus of Alexandria, writing on the first epistle of Peter against the millenarians, argues that if this inheritance is kept in heaven for the faithful, then those who think to receive it in an earthly Jerusalem, and suppose they will hold the rewards of delight as their own property for a thousand years, put forward something trifling and lukewarm. Such people should be asked how they can maintain bodily delights, when this inheritance is said to be incapable of corruption or of fading.

To behold God in his glory in this way is the proper use of grace. Though our present knowledge of him by faith falls far short of what we there expect, it is the same God and the same glory that we now believe and shall one day more openly behold. Therefore, just as that love will inconceivably surpass the highest love attainable here, so the forethought of it surpasses all other arguments and means for affecting us now, and will raise us as high as any means can raise us.

The greatest things and the deepest interests of our souls being located there will greatly raise us to the love of God, if anything will. To foresee how near him we shall soon be; what glorious proof we shall have of his goodwill; how our souls will be ravished everlastingly with his love, to think what hearts the blessed have who see his glory and live with Christ, how full of love they are, and what a delight it is to them to love in this way, all this must affect the heart of a believer.

Lift up your head, poor drowsy sinner! Look up to heaven and think where you must live forever. Think what the holy ones of God are doing now. Do they love God, or do they not? Must that not then be your life and occupation forever? How can you hold back from loving him now, when he is bringing you to such a world of love? You would love more the one who gave you guaranteed possession of a kingdom you had never seen than the one who gave you only some trifle in your hand. And do not let the distance seem too great to move you: the time until you are there is as nothing. You do not know but that you may be there this very night.

There you will see the Maker of the worlds and know the mysteries of his wondrous works. There you will see your blessed Lord, and feel the love you have read of in the Gospel, and enjoy its fruits forever. There you will see him who suffered for you and rose again, whom angels see and worship in his glory. You will see there a more glorious sight than those saw who watched him heal the blind, the lame, and the sick, and raise the dead; more than those saw at his transfiguration; more than those who saw him on the cross or after his resurrection; more than Stephen saw when he was stoned; more than Paul saw at his conversion, yes, more perhaps than Paul saw when he was caught up in his rapture into the third heavens.

Who can think believingly on the life we must shortly live there, the glory we must see, the love we must receive, and the love we must exercise, and not feel the fire begin to flame, and the glass through which we now see the Lord become a burning-glass to our affections? Christ and heaven are the books we must be often reading, the mirrors in which we must daily gaze, if we are ever to become good students and practitioners in the art of holy love.

Direction 13: Exercise your souls so frequently and diligently in this way of love that the method becomes familiar to you, the means and motives always ready to hand, so that you can fall into the way quickly, as one well acquainted with it, and are not distracted and lost in vague generalities, not knowing where to fix your thoughts.

I know that methods alone will never raise the dead or cause a worldly, insensible heart to love the Lord. But I also know that many sincere hearts, in whom the Spirit of love already dwells, have great need to be warned against quenching the Spirit, and great need to be directed in how to stir up the grace they have been given. Many live a duller, more distracted, and more uncomfortable life than they would if they did not lack skill and diligence in this.

The soul is most reluctant toward this highest work, and therefore has the greater need of help. Even the best have need enough that it is well if everything together is sufficient to maintain loving and grateful thoughts of God in their minds. When every trade, art, and discipline requires diligence, practice, and experience, and everyone is a novice at first, can we reasonably expect to attain any high degree of love through brief, shallow, and infrequent thoughts?

Direction 14: Yet let not weak-headed or melancholy persons set themselves on those methods or lengths of meditation which their heads cannot bear, lest the tempter gain advantage over them and diminish their love by making religion seem a torment; but let such take up with shorter, more straightforward meditations, and exercise their love in an active, obedient way of living.

The best medicine is the one fitted to the patient’s strength and condition, and the best shoe is the one that fits the foot, not the largest or the finest. It is a great scheme of Satan to make all duties grievous and burdensome, casting us into continual pain, fear, and trouble, and so destroying our delight in God and consequently our love. Therefore, do not mistake fleshly unwillingness and mental laziness for genuine disability, but do not ruin everything by grasping at more than you can bear. Take on as much as you are able, and increase your work if God increases your strength. If a melancholy person breaks his mind with immoderate, ill-timed striving, he will only disable himself for everything.

Direction 15: Keep clear, and hold fast the evidences of your sincerity, so that you may perceive your share in the love of God and resist the temptations that would conceal his love from you and lead you to doubt or deny it. Satan has not achieved his goal when he has troubled you and robbed you of peace and comfort; what he is seeking to do is far worse.

His malice is directed more against God than against you, and more against God and you in this matter of love than in any other grace or duty. He knows that God values love above all; he knows that if he can kill your love, he kills your soul. He knows how natural it is for people to love those who love them and hate those who hate them, however excellent those persons may be in themselves. Therefore, if he can drive you to despair, to believe that God hates you and is resolved to damn you, he will not abandon hope of drawing you to hate God. Or if he can merely bring you to fear that God does not love you, he expects to diminish your love accordingly.

I know that a truly gracious soul maintains its love even when it loses its assurance, mourning and longing and seeking in love when it cannot triumph and rejoice in love. Yet some impression of former apprehensions of God’s love remains on the heart, and such souls place themselves at a severe disadvantage in the exercise of love, making it a work of extraordinary difficulty. How powerfully love is kindled when we can see God’s surest tokens of love in our hearts, look to the promises and say, "They are all mine," think of heaven as something that will certainly be our own, and say with Thomas, "My Lord, and my God," and with Paul, that "The life which I live in the flesh, I live by the faith of the Son of God, that loved me, and gave himself for me." Denying our own grace may look like humility, but it tends to extinguish love and gratitude.

Question: "But," you may say, "I must avoid self-delusion and Pharisaical pride on the other side. And few reach assurance; how then can we maintain the love of God?"

Answer: Although I have not yet come to the point of testing and discerning grace, I will give you this much help along the way, because it bears so directly on the exercise of love.

1.) If you do not have a love that enjoys and delights, try whether you have a love that desires and seeks. Love shows itself just as truly in desiring and seeking good as in delighting in it. Poor men show their love of the world by desiring and pursuing it as much as rich men do by delighting in it. What is it that you most desire and seek?

2.) Or if this desire is so faint that you can scarcely discern it, do you not find a mourning and lamenting love? You show that you loved your money by grieving when you lose it, and that you loved your friend by sorrowing at his death, just as much as by delighting in him while he lived. If you sincerely lament it as your greatest misfortune and loss when you think that God has cast you off, that you are empty of grace, and that you cannot serve and honor him as you wish, this shows you are not empty of love.

3.) If you do not feel that you love him, do you feel that you long to love him, and that you love the very act of loving him? If so, it is a sign that you do love him, when you desire not merely the evidence of salvation within you, but love itself, and love to love God. Would you not rather have a heart to love him perfectly than to possess all the riches in the world? Would you not rather live in the love of God, if you could attain it, than in any earthly pleasure? If so, be sure he has your heart. The will is the love and the heart; if God has your will, he has your heart and your love.

4.) What else has your heart, if he does not have it? Is there anything you prefer and pursue before him, anything you would rather have than him? Can you be content without him, and let him go in exchange for any earthly pleasure? If not, it is a sign he has your heart. You love him savingly if you value nothing else above him.

5.) Do you love his holy image in his Word? Do you delight in and meditate on his law? Is it written on your heart? Do you pray, "Incline my heart unto thy testimonies"? If you love God’s image in his Word, its wisdom and holiness, you love God. (Ps 1:2 Ps 40:8 Ps 119:36)

6.) Do you love his image in his children? If you love them for their heavenly wisdom and holiness, you love God in that measure. One who loves a candle for its light loves the light itself and the sun; one who loves the wise and holy for their wisdom and holiness loves wisdom and holiness themselves. Because his Word and his saints lie closer to our sense and perception than God himself does, we ordinarily feel our love for them more keenly than our love for God, yet it is God, in his Word and servants, whom we love. (1 John 3:14 Ps 15:4)

Though for want of assurance you do not feel the delights of love, do you not have a heart that would delight in it more than in all the riches of the world, if only you could obtain assurance of your interest in God? Would nothing comfort you more than being sure he loves you, and being able to love and obey him perfectly? If so, it is not for want of love that you do not delight in him, but for want of assurance.

If God has your heart, whether in a delighting love, or a seeking and desiring love, or a lamenting and mourning love, he will not despise or reject it. "He is nigh to them that be of a broken heart"; "A broken and contrite heart is his sacrifice, which he will not despise." The "good Lord will have mercy on every one that prepareth their hearts to seek him, though they do it not according to the preparation of the sanctuary." (Ps 34:18 Ps 51:17) By these evidences you may discern the sincerity of love even in small degrees, and so you may make love the occasion of more love, by discerning the goodness of God that is manifested to you even in the least measure.

2. But suppose you cannot yet attain assurance: do not neglect to draw on that goodness and mercy of God which he reveals to you in the condition you are in. Love him as Infinite Goodness deserves to be loved, he who "so loved the world as to give his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life." (John 3:16) Love him as the most blessed and merciful God who made you and all things, who has offered the world a universal pardon on condition of penitent acceptance, who offers everlasting life, all of it purchased by the blood of Christ.

Love him as one who offers you reconciliation and entreats you to be saved, as one who takes no pleasure in the death of the wicked but rather that they turn and live, as one who would have all people be saved and come to the knowledge of the truth, though he will save none but the penitent who acknowledge that truth. And when you love him sincerely on these grounds, you will gain the evidence of his special love toward you.

Direction 16: Use your sense of natural and human love to raise yourself toward the love of God. When you see or feel the love a parent has for children, a husband for a wife, a wife for a husband, or faithful friends for one another, reflect in this way:

"What love do I owe to God! How insignificant is the loveliness of a child, a wife, a friend, the best of creatures, compared to the loveliness of God! Can you, unworthy soul, love a drop of goodness in your friend and yet fail to love the ocean of goodness in your God? Is a spark in a creature more worthy of love than the fire that kindled it? You can love your friend for all his faults, his ignorance, his passions, his many imperfections, and yet you cannot love your God, who has none of these, and nothing in him to discourage or cool your love?"

"You love your friend, and rightly so, because he loves you and deals kindly with you. But how much greater is the love of God! Did any friend ever love you as he has loved you? Did any friend ever do for you what he has done? He gave you your very existence, your daily safety, and all the mercies of your life. He gave you his Son, his Spirit, and his grace. He pardoned your sins, received you into his favor, adopted you as his child, and made you an heir of heaven. He will glorify you with the angels in the presence of his own glory!"

"How should such a friend be loved, and how far above all earthly friends! Their love and friendship is only a token and messenger of his love. Because he loves you, he sends you kindness and mercy through your friend. When that human kindness fails or can do you no good, his kindness will continue and comfort you forever. Love them, then, as the messengers of his love, but love him in them, love them for him, and love him far more."

Direction 17: Think often about how delightful your life would be if you could live in the love of God; for the pleasure of that prospect will stir desire, and desire will turn you toward God, until you find that you do love him. The love of a friend has its own sweetness, and when we love someone we feel such pleasure in that love that we love to love them. How much more pleasant, then, would it be to love your God!

"What a blessed and joyful life it would be, if I could love him as much as I desire to love him! How freely I could leave the ambitious, the covetous, and the sensual to their foolish, deluding, degrading loves! How easily I could spare all earthly pleasures! How close I would come to the life of the angels! To love God as I would love him would fill me with constant pleasure and be the sweetest feast a soul can know. How readily it would quench all carnal love! How far it would lift me above these passing things, how much I would think lightly of them, and pity the wretched souls who know no better and have their portion only in this life!"

"How readily I would obey, and how pleasant obedience would be! How sweet all my meditations, when every thought is full of love! How sweet all my prayers, when a constraining love brought me to God and animated every word! How sweet the sacraments, when my ascending, flaming love would meet that wonderful, descending love that comes from heaven to call me there, and in the living bread and spiritual wine is the nourishment and strength of my soul! How sweet all my speech, when love governed it and every word was full of love!"

"How quiet my conscience would be, if it never had occasion to accuse me, to my shame and confusion, of being lacking in love to the blessed God! If I could love God with the powerful love that his love and goodness deserve, I would no longer question my sincerity or doubt his love for me. How freely I would acknowledge his grace, and how heartily I would thank him for my justification, sanctification, and adoption, which now I can barely mention without doubt and fear!"

"How it would lift my soul to his praise and make it my delight to speak well of his name! What a purifying fire love would be in my heart, burning up my corruptions, enduring nothing contrary to the will and honor of my Lord, and hating every impulse that tends toward displeasing him. It would fill my soul with so much of heaven that I would long to be there, and death, now so terrible, would be welcome."

"Instead of these retreating, shrinking fears, I would desire to depart and to be with Christ, as being by far the best of all. How easily I would bear any burden of reproach, loss, or want, if I thus loved God and were assured of his love! How light the cross would be! How honorable and joyful it would seem to be imprisoned, reviled, spat upon, and struck for the sake of Christ! How desirable even the flames of martyrdom would appear, as testimony of my love to him who loved me at a far greater cost than I can love him!"

"Lord, is there no more of this blessed life of love to be attained here on earth? When all the world declares your goodness; when your Son has come down to make known your love in so full and wonderful a way; when your Word has opened a window into heaven where we may see your glory from afar, shall our hearts remain cold clods and ice? O, have pity on this ungrateful, unnatural soul, this dead, insensible, indifferent soul! Teach me by your Spirit the art of love. Love me not only so as to convince me that I have abundant cause to love you above all things, but love me so as to compel me to it, by the magnetic, attractive power of your goodness and the irresistible working of your almighty love."

Direction 18: In meditating on all these incentives to love, preach them earnestly to your own heart, and plead with it through soliloquy, until you feel the fire begin to burn. Do not merely think about the reasons for love, dispute it out with your conscience, and by earnest, pressing reasoning with your heart, work to move it. There is far more moving force in this kind of earnest self-address than in bare mental reflection that never forms itself into words.

Imitate the most powerful preacher you have ever heard. Just as he pleads the case with his hearers and presses truth and duty on them through reason and urgent appeal, do the same in private with yourself. There is more in this than most Christians realize or practice. It is a great part of a Christian’s skill and duty to be a good preacher to himself. This is a lawful and profitable form of preaching. No one can question your calling, deny you a license, or silence you here, except yourself. Two or three sermons a week from others is a fair portion; but two or three such addresses a day from yourself is ordinarily too little. For this reason I have added Soliloquies to many of these Directions for Love, to show you how, through such pleadings with yourself, to move your heart and kindle love.

O that these Directions might bear this happy fruit in you who are now reading or hearing them, that you would offer up your heart to Jesus Christ our great High Priest, to be presented as an acceptable sacrifice to God. Or if it does not yet flame with love as you desire, give it up to the Holy Spirit to increase the flame. You little know how much God values a heart. He calls to you himself: "My son, give me thy heart" (Prov 23:26). Without it, he cares nothing for anything else you can give him. He cares nothing for your fairest words without it; nothing for your loudest prayers without it; nothing for your costliest gifts or offerings, if he does not have your heart.

"If thou give all thy goods to feed the poor, and give thy body to be burned, and have not love, it will profit thee nothing. If thou speak with the tongue of men and angels, and hast not love, thou art but as sounding brass, or a tinkling cymbal. If thou canst prophesy, and preach to admiration, and understand all mysteries and knowledge, and hast faith to do miracles, and have not love, thou art nothing" (1 Cor 13:1–3). Without love you have only a shadow, lacking the very substance and life of all the rest.

Come then, and make an agreement with God. Resolve now to offer him your heart. He asks you for nothing you do not have. He is not seeking your riches and lands, otherwise the poor might say with Peter, "silver and gold have I none." Give him what you have, and it is enough. He knows it is a polluted, sinful heart; but give it to him, and he will make it clean. He knows it is an unkind heart that has held out too long; but give it to him still, and he will pardon and accept it. He knows it is an unworthy heart; but give it to him, and he will be its worth.

Only see that you give it entirely and without reservation. He will not negotiate with the devil or the world for a divided heart. A half-heart, a hollow heart, one merely lent to him until fleshly interest or necessity calls it back, he will not accept. Only resign it to him, and consent that your heart be his, entirely and absolutely his, and he will take it and use it as his own. It is already his by right; let it be so also by your consent.

If God does not have your heart, who will? Will the world? Pride? Fleshly lust? Did they make your heart, or did they purchase it? Will they serve you better in the hour of your greatest need? Do they offer more for your heart than God will give you? He will give you his Son, and his Spirit, and his image, and the forgiveness of all your sins. If any gain, honor, or pleasure could win your heart, he offers it. If heaven itself can purchase it, he will not fail you on the price. Do the world and sin have a greater price to offer?

And what do you suppose God will do with your heart, that you are so reluctant to give it to him? Will he blind it, deceive it, corrupt it, abuse it, and at last torment it, as Satan will do? No. He will further illuminate it, and cleanse it, and make it alive (Ps 51:10 Eph 2:1 Jer 24:7). He will make it new, and heal it, and save it (Ezek 36:26 2 Cor 5:17). He will raise it and honor it with the highest relations, employments, and delights. For Christ has said, "If any man serve me, let him follow me; and where I am, there shall also my servant be. If any man serve me, him will my Father honour" (John 12:26). He will love your heart, govern it, and comfort it; the heart delivered to him will be kept near to his own. "For the Father himself loveth you," says Christ, "because you have loved me" (John 16:27).

But if you do not deliver your heart to him, it will feed on the poison of seductive vanity, which will grip and tear it once it has taken hold. It will be like a house inhabited only by dogs, flies, worms, and snakes. It will be like someone lost in a wilderness at night, wearing himself out in searching for the way home, and the longer he wanders, the worse his plight. Despair and restlessness will be his companions forever.

Let me once more, in the name of God, appeal to your heart. I will not use his commands or threatenings just now, though these, as supporting arguments, must eventually be brought in, because love must be drawn by attractive reasons and is not kindled by mere authority or fear. If there is not love and goodness enough in God to deserve the highest affections of every rational creature, then let him go, and give your heart to someone better.

Hear how God pleads his own cause with an ungrateful people: "Hear O ye mountains the Lord’s controversy. O my people what have I done unto thee? and wherein have I wearied thee? testify against me." (Mic 6:2–3). What is there in him to turn your heart away? Let malice say its worst, without outright shamelessness, against him. What has he ever done that deserves your coldness and neglect? What would you need, to win a heart, that is not found in him? For which of his mercies or excellencies do you despise and abuse him? What do you lack that he cannot, indeed, will not, give you? Does not your tongue speak honorably of his goodness, while your heart contradicts it and denies everything?

What have you found that will prove better for you? Is it sin or God that must be your glory, rest, and joy, unless you choose to be a brand of restlessness and misery forever? What do you say, sinner? Shall God, or the world and fleshly pleasures, have your heart? Are you not yet convinced which best deserves it, and which will treat it best? Can you be a loser by giving it to him? Will he make it worse, and sin make it better? Will you ever have cause to repent of giving your heart to God, as you have cause to repent of giving it to the world and sin?

I tell you plainly: if God does not have your heart, it would be better for you to have no heart at all. I would a thousand times rather have the heart of a dog, or the lowliest creature, than the heart of a man who follows his fleshly lusts and is not sincerely surrendered to God through Christ.

If I have not prevailed with your hearts for God by all I have said, your own consciences will yet bear witness that I showed you God’s title, his love, and his goodness, and said what ought to have prevailed. And you will find before long who will have the worst of it. But if you resolve and give your hearts to God now, he will welcome them, sanctify them, and save them. This happy day and work will be the joy of angels, my joy, and above all, your own everlasting joy.

CHAPTER 34

GRAND DIRECTION 12: TRUST GOD WITH YOUR SOUL AND BODY

 

‘Trust God with that soul and body which you have delivered up and dedicated to him; and quiet your mind in his love and faithfulness, whatever may appear to you, or befall you in the world.’

I will briefly show you: 1. What is the nature of this trust in God. 2. What are its contraries. 3. What are its counterfeits. 4. What is its usefulness. And then 5. I will give you some directions on how to attain and exercise it.

1. To trust in God is, upon the apprehension of his all-sufficiency, goodness, and faithfulness, to quiet our hearts in the expectation of safety or benefits from him that we desire, rejecting the cares, fears, and griefs that would otherwise disquiet us, if we had not the refuge of these hopes. It involves crediting the Word or nature of God, judging it to be a sufficient ground of our security and expectation; and then security and expectation built upon that ground make up the rest of what trust is. We look for the benefit, find a settled contentment and quietness of mind in the ground discovered, and cease all other cares and fears that would otherwise disturb us. Aquinas and other scholastics often call trust "a confirmed hope." Of the nature of affiance and faith I have written more fully in my disputation with Dr. Barlow on saving faith. Peucer, in his ten years’ imprisonment, put the whole of it into a couplet: by faith alone cleave constantly to God alone; by him alone you will be delivered from all evils.

There is a twofold trust in God. One is for that which God has not promised to do, yet we find sufficient reason, from his very nature and relations to us, to expect: this may be more or less certain and strong, depending on how clearly we can discern God’s will from his nature.

The other is when we have not only God’s nature but his promise to trust upon: and this gives us certainty, if we rightly understand his promise. Under this latter kind I may also place trust in God for particular benefits when we have only a general promise, which does not make the particulars known and certain to us. For example, the promise that all things shall work together for our good gives us only a probability of health, outward protection, or deliverance, because we cannot know with certainty how far these things are for our good. Everything that is promised is sure; but whether this or that particular thing is good for us must be known by other means.

Yet those general promises that contain their particulars as surely as the promise itself make every particular benefit as certain by promise as the general: for example, the promise of the pardon of all our sins assures us of the pardon of every individual sin. Where there is a promise, we trust God’s faithfulness as well as his nature; where there is none, we trust his nature alone, as a child quietly trusts his parents, without any explicit promise, that they will not kill, torment, or forsake him.

But because we are prone to draw false conclusions about God’s will from his nature alone, he has given us such clear expressions of it in his Word as to raise us above mere uncertain probabilities, providing faith with sufficient ground, given his known properties, for our governance and peace. It is certain that any reading of God’s will that contradicts his Word is the error of the reader.

In what I have said in this Direction, I want you chiefly to observe three things: 1. That God’s nature and love are the sufficient, general security of the soul. 2. That his promise is the sufficient, particular security. 3. That our sincere self-dedication to him is our sufficient evidence of our share in his love and covenant, which may warrant our special trust and expectations.

2. The contraries to trust in God are these:

1.) Privative: not trusting him, not seeing just grounds of security in his love and promise; not crediting what is seen; not laying aside disquietness and distrustful cares and fears.

2.) Positive distrust: supposing that God’s all-sufficiency, goodness, and promises are not sufficient grounds of our expectation and security, and on that account disquieting our minds with sinful fears, griefs, cares, and schemes to secure ourselves some other way. This has various degrees: in some it is predominant; in others, not.

3.) Opposite or adverse: when we trust ourselves, or friends, or wealth, or something else instead of God, either against him, without him, or in coordination with him.

3. The counterfeits of this trust are these:

1.) When we in fact trust in our own ingenuity, power, resourcefulness, friends, or in some means or creature alone, or in coordination with God, but pretend and suppose that we do so only in subordination to him, and that our primary trust is in him alone. This is exposed by testing whether we can trust God alone when he gives us a promise but no obvious means.

2.) Pretending to trust God alone by neglecting the means he has appointed us to use, and the duties he has made the condition of his promises. This trust is nothing but a self-deceiving cover for sin and laziness.

3.) Pretending to trust God in the use of self-devised, sinful means, when he has promised a blessing to no such means, but has threatened them with a curse.

4.) Thinking we trust God when it is in fact a false revelation from the devil, or some delusion of deceivers, or some dream, fancy, or proud notion of our own minds that we are actually believing and grounding our trust upon, as those do who are deluded by false prophets and false teachers, and by the fantastical fancies of their corrupted imaginations.

5.) When people in presumption and carnal security rashly venture their souls in the darkness of uncertainty, as well as in the neglect of a holy life, casting away all sense of their miserable condition, together with all the necessary fear and care that tended toward their recovery, and persuade themselves that they are in no great danger, or that concern will do no good, and call all this trusting God with their salvation.

6.) Pretending to trust God for what is contrary to his nature: such as that he will love the wicked with approval, or receive them into heaven.

7.) Pretending to trust God for what is contrary to his Word: such as that he will save the unregenerate and unholy, so that not believing him is itself taken for believing in him and trusting him.

8.) Pretending to believe and trust him for what neither his nature nor his Word has ever declared to be his will, in matters he has kept secret or never revealed. This includes what some call a particular faith: believing in prayer that some specific thing, never promised, will be granted because we ask it, or because we feel a strong persuasion that it will be so.

Question: ‘But is not such a particular faith and trust divine and solid?’

Answer: To expect any particular mercy that God’s nature, Word, or works tell us he will give is sound and warranted. To expect a particular thing made known through inspiration, prophecy, or genuine extraordinary revelation is likewise warranted, since this constitutes a Word from God. But all other belief and expectation is mere self-promising and self-deception. Wise people will not easily take themselves for prophets, nor take anything for an inspiration or divine extraordinary revelation that does not bring with it the testimony of compelling evidence.

4. There are three great uses and benefits of this trust in God that highly commend it to us and make it necessary.

1.) It is necessary to our acknowledging and honoring God. It is a heartfelt, practical confession of his power, wisdom, goodness, and truth, for where any one of these is lacking, there is no rational ground for trust. The greater the danger or assault against us, the more God is acknowledged and honored by our trust; for then we declare that no creature or impediment can thwart his will, that his power surpasses all power, his wisdom surpasses all wisdom, and his goodness and faithfulness are constant and invincible. Distrust, by contrast, is a denial of God in some of his attributes, or a suspicion cast against him.

2.) It is necessary for our own sake, for the quiet, peace, and comfort of our minds, which otherwise will be left inevitably to continual disquietness and pain through tormenting fears, griefs, and cares, unless numbness or self-deception should ease them.

3.) It is necessary to prevent the errors and sinful failures of our lives. For if we do not trust in God, we will spend all our thoughts and labors on sinful means; we will be idolatrously trusting in creatures; we will be scheming for ourselves through lies or any unlawful method, and lose ourselves in the very act of saving ourselves, as if apart from God, or without him.

4.) This explains why trust in God is so frequently and earnestly commanded throughout Scripture, and why such blessings are promised to it, as though it were the very sum of godliness and religion. "Cursed be the man that trusteth in man, and maketh flesh his arm, and whose heart departeth from the Lord. Blessed is the man that trusteth in the Lord, and whose hope the Lord is" (Jer 17:5, 7). "Whoso trusteth in the Lord, happy is he" (Prov 16:20). "Blessed are all they that put their trust in him" (Ps 2:12). "O taste and see that the Lord is good: blessed is the man that trusteth in him" (Ps 34:8 Ps 84:12). In addition, all mercies are promised to those who trust in God (Ps 34:22 Ps 37:3, 5, 40 Ps 91:2, 4 Ps 125:1 Isa 50:10). Faith in Christ is itself called trust (Matt 12:21 Eph 1:12, 13); and idolaters and worldlings are described precisely by their trusting in idols and wealth (Ps 115:8 Ps 135:18 Amos 6:1 Mark 10:24 Prov 11:28 Prov 28:26).

Directions for a Quieting and Comforting Trust in God

 

Direction 1: Let your soul retain the deepest impression of God’s almightiness, wisdom, goodness, and faithfulness, and of the certainty with which all persons, things, and events are under his power, understanding how utterly impotent the whole world is to resist him, and that nothing can harm you except by his consent.

The primary means of a confirmed confidence in God is to know him, and to know that everything we might fear is nothing and can do nothing except by his command, movement, or permission. I am not afraid of a bird or a worm because I know it is too weak for me: and if I rightly understood how much all creatures are weaker still before God, and how fully sufficient God is to deliver me, that trust would quiet me. "Fear thou not; for I am with thee; be not dismayed; for I am thy God: I will strengthen thee; yea, I will help thee; yea, I will uphold thee" (Isa 41:10). "They that know thy name will put their trust in thee" (Ps 9:10). "Hearken unto me ye that know righteousness, the people in whose heart is my law; fear ye not the reproach of men, neither be afraid of their revilings: for the moth shall eat them up like a garment, and the worm shall eat them like wool" (Isa 51:8).

Direction 2: Work toward a sound and clear understanding of God’s promises, so that you may know precisely how far he calls you to trust him.

To suppose he promises what he does not is not to trust him but to deceive yourself; and to suppose he does not promise what he truly does is to throw away the very ground of trust.

Direction 3: Do not yield to the tempter, who would either entice you into terrifying guilt and so blot your evidences of grace, or else hide those evidences from you and keep you in doubt and suspicion of God’s love.

Almost everything a distrustful soul can say to justify its distrust amounts to this: I am not sure the promises are mine. Remember always that a heart dedicated to God, or consenting to his covenant, is your fullest evidence; and do not allow that evidence to be hidden or blotted. Willful sin and guilt breeds fear, and will interrupt your trust and peace until it is forsaken.

Direction 4: Keep in mind all the grounds of confidence and quietness God has given you in his Son, his covenant, his Spirit, his sacraments, and your own and others’ manifold experiences, setting them all before your eyes together.

Will he not give you "all things with him" who has "given you his Son"? Is not Christ a sufficient advocate and encourager? Are not his covenant, promise, and oath sufficient security? "Wherein God, willing more abundantly to shew to the heirs of promise the immutability of his counsel, confirmed it by an oath; that by two immutable things in which it was impossible for God to lie, we might have a strong consolation" (Heb 6:17, 18). And is not the heavenly seal and earnest of his Spirit sufficient to confirm us? (2 Cor 1:22 2 Cor 5:5 Eph 1:13, 14 Eph 4:30). Have you tried God so often, and still cannot trust him? Our frequent experiences, though the least of all these supports of trust, are very powerful because they are near to us and almost satisfy the senses themselves, when all our bones cry, "Lord, who is like unto thee, who deliverest the poor!" (Ps 35:10).

Direction 5: Consider the greatness of the sin of distrust: how it denies God in his attributes, and ordinarily supposes the creature to stand above him.

In distrust you either doubt or deny his power to help you, or his wisdom, as though it were deficient in forming his promises or finding the means of your deliverance, or his goodness and love, as if he would deceive you, and so his truth and faithfulness in his promises. If you fear a man, however great, when God calls you to trust him for your help, what are you saying but that this man is more powerful than God, or that God cannot deliver you from his hands? If it is poverty, sickness, or death you fear, what are you saying in your heart but that God either does not know what is best for you as well as you know it yourself, or else is not powerful or gracious enough to give it, nor faithful enough to keep his promise? "He that believeth not, makes God a liar" (1 John 5:10, 11).

Direction 6: Remember that trusting God, as it were, obliges him, while distrusting him greatly dishonors him, especially when something else is trusted in his place.

If someone trusts you on the strength of your own encouragement, you feel yourself obliged to be reliable and not to fail that honest trust; but if he does not trust you, or trusts another instead, you turn him over to those he has trusted. God may rightly say to you: Let those help you whom you have trusted, you did not trust in me, and so I do not fail your trust when I forsake you.

Direction 7: Remember that you must trust in God, or trust in nothing.

Nothing is more certain, or more frequently proved by experience, than that everything else is utterly insufficient to be our help. Shall we choose a broken reed that we already know will both deceive and pierce us? How dire is the condition of the person who has no surer foundation for trust than creatures? The greatest of them are unable; and the best of them are untrustworthy and deceitful. How sad your case will be if God turns you over to these for help in the hour of your extremity!

Then you will see that "it is better to trust in the Lord, than to put any confidence in princes" (Ps 118:8, 9). "The righteous also shall see, and fear, and laugh at him: Lo, this is the man that hath made not God his strength; but trusted in the abundance of his riches, and strengthened himself in his wickedness" (Ps 52:6, 7). "But they that trust in the Lord shall be as mount Zion, that cannot be removed, but abideth for ever" (Ps 125:1). Creatures will certainly disappoint your trust; God never will.

Direction 8: Believe and keep in mind the particular providence of God, who regards the fall of a sparrow to the ground and has numbered the very hairs of your head (Matt 10:30).

Can you distrust the one who is so precisely attentive to your smallest concerns, who is always present and watching over you? You need not fear his absence, inattention, forgetfulness, or insufficiency. If he numbers your hairs, does he not also number your groans and prayers and tears? How then does he wipe away your tears and keep them all as in his bottle? (Ps 56:8 Rev 7:17).

Direction 9: Compare God with your dearest and most faithful friend, and then consider how boldly you could trust that friend if your life or welfare were wholly in his hand, and how much more boldly you should trust in God, who is wiser, kinder, more merciful, and more reliable than any mortal can be.

When you are in need, in prison, in sickness and pain, or expecting death, reason this way: if my life, health, or liberty were absolutely in the power of my surest friend, how quietly could I wait, and how confidently could I cast away fear, even without any promise about what he would do, because I know he would do nothing but what is for my good. Is not God then to be trusted far more? A friend would ease my pain, supply my wants, or save my life in a case where God will not; but that is not because God is less kind, but because he is wiser and better understands what tends to my harm or good. My friend would pull off the plaster as soon as I cry out at the pain; but God will wait until it has completed its cure. God is surely more to be trusted for my true and final good, even if my friend is readier to give me ease. All friends may fail; but God never fails.

Direction 10: Use your natural love of quietness, and your natural weariness of tormenting cares, fears, and sorrows, to move you to cast yourself on God and find rest in trusting him.

God has purposely made you and everything else insufficient, unsatisfying, and vexing, so that you might be driven to rest on him alone, since nothing else affords you rest. Cares, fears, and inward turmoil are thorns and briars that human nature cannot love or be content with, and you can be sure there is no way to be delivered from them except by trusting in God. Will you then choose torment when so sure and inexpensive a path to ease lies open before you? Who can bear to have fears gnaw at him and cares feed daily on his heart, when he could safely be freed from them? A festering, aching mind is a greater calamity than any merely bodily distress. And if you are thrown back on your own resources, or committed to the care of any creature, you can never rationally find peace.

For your own ease and comfort, therefore, turn to God and cast all your care and burden on him, who cares for you and knows perfectly what you need (1 Pet 5:7; Matt 6:32). Read often Matthew 6 from verse 24.

How sweet an ease and quietness belongs to the mind that can confidently trust in God! How quiet that person is from the storms of trouble and the sickness of mind that distress others: "Thou wilt keep him in perfect peace, whose mind is stayed on thee: because he trusteth in thee. Trust ye in the Lord for ever, for in the Lord Jehovah is everlasting strength" (Isa 26:3, 4). "He shall not be afraid of evil tidings; his heart is fixed, trusting in the Lord; his heart is established; he shall not be afraid" (Ps 112:7, 8).

"Oh how great is thy goodness, which thou hast laid up for them that fear thee; which thou hast wrought, for them that trust in thee, before the sons of men. Thou shalt hide them in the secret of thy presence from the pride of man; thou shalt keep them secretly in a pavilion from the strife of tongues. Be of good courage, and he shall strengthen your heart, all ye that hope in the Lord" (Ps 31:19, 20). "What time I am afraid, I will trust in thee. In God I will praise his word; in God have I put my trust: I will not fear what flesh can do unto me" (Ps 56:3, 4). How easy and sweet a life this is!

Direction 11: Remember that distrust is a fertile, multiplying sin, and will carry you into all iniquity and misery if you allow it to prevail.

Distrusting God is nothing less than the beginning of a life of error, sin, and woe. It immediately sets us on an idolatrous confidence in human strength, on sinful expedients, and on stretching of conscience. It corrupts our judgment and makes everything seem lawful that seems necessary for our safety and welfare, and makes everything seem necessary without which we think we cannot secure it. All sinful compromises, trimming, people-pleasing, and the persuading ourselves that sinful means are no sin, all of this flows from distrust of God.

Direction 12: Do not allow distrustful thoughts and reasonings to dwell in your mind; cast them out and command them to be gone.

Thoughts are the instruments through which good and evil operate in the human mind; neither can act except through thought, and the will has more command over thoughts than it has immediately over the passions themselves. If you cannot trust God as quietly as you wish, and cannot suppress every fearful apprehension, at least keep out, or cast out, the thoughts that feed your sin, and turn your mind to something else.

When thoughts no longer drive it, your distrustful fears and cares will fade. What are your cares but the churning of your thoughts, continually feeding on difficulties and trouble, and wearing themselves out searching for help? Cast away the thoughts, and the cares are gone. You can do much in this if you will, though it is difficult. "Take no thought for your life, what ye shall eat, or what ye shall drink, nor yet for your bodies, what ye shall put on. Which of you, by taking thought, can add one cubit to his stature? And why take ye thought for raiment?" (Matt 6:25, 27, 28)

Direction 13: When commands will not prevail, rebuke and challenge your unbelieving heart, and reason it out of its distrustful cares, fears, and sorrows.

Say to it, as David often did: "Why art thou cast down, O my soul? and why art thou so disquieted within me? Trust in God, for I shall yet give him thanks, who is the health of my countenance, and my God." (Ps 42; 43)

O foolish soul! Have you still not learned to know your God better? Does he sustain the heavens and the earth and the whole creation, and yet you cannot rely on him? Is he not wise enough to be trusted with the ordering and directing of your life? Is he not good and gracious enough to be trusted with your life, estate, reputation, and welfare? Is he not great and powerful enough to be trusted against the greatest danger, difficulty, or opposition that could ever befall you? Is he not faithful enough to be trusted, whatever improbabilities may rise before you?

Where did the person ever live, and what was his name, who trusted God in vain, or was ever failed or deceived by him? Are not his Son, his Spirit, his covenant, and his oath sufficient pledges of his love for your security? How often has he fulfilled his promises to you, heard your cries, and helped and saved you in your distress? How often has he refuted your unbelief and put your distrustful fears and cares to shame, and then you resolved to trust him better in the next trial. Shall all his wonders of mercy now be forgotten? Shall all your confessions, thanksgivings, and promises now be repented of, contradicted, and abandoned by renewed distrust and unbelief?

Is he not the same God who has so repeatedly and abundantly shown mercy to you? Is he not the same God who has saved all who trusted in him, wrought such wonders for his servants in the earth, and brought so many safely to heaven? "Our fathers trusted in him; they trusted, and he delivered them; they cried to him, and were delivered; they trusted in him, and were not confounded." (Ps 22:4, 5) And is he not sufficient for you, he who is sufficient for all the world? Who ever came off badly by trusting him? Or who has prospered by trusting in themselves or in any other, apart from him or against him?

Unworthy soul! Will you atheistically deny the sufficiency, truthfulness, or goodness of your God? Shall your distrust deny him or slander him? Will you idolatrously set a worm above him? Is there more power in man, or in anything else, to hurt and ruin you, than there is in God to save you? Whom will you trust, if you will not trust God? Do you dare suppose that anything else deserves your confidence more? You would be at ease and confident if your dearest friend held your life and welfare in his hands, and are you troubled now that it is in the hands of God? Is he sufficient to be our endless happiness in heaven, yet not worthy of your confidence on earth? Can you trust him to raise your body from the dust, but not to restore your condition, your reputation, or your troubled mind?

Either take him as your rock and your hope, or never claim to take him as your God. If you do not trust in him, you must despair or trust against him, and whom will you then trust to save you from him? Even if you had no more encouragement to trust him than this, that he has commanded you to trust him, you could be sure he would never deceive you. Lament, therefore, your disquiet and self-tormenting fears. Lament your unjust distrust of your most dear Almighty Father. Do not choose torment when the harbor of his love lies open to receive you.

If men or devils are against you, say as those believers said: "We are not careful to answer thee in this matter; our God whom we serve is able to deliver us." (Dan 3:16, 17) Go on, as Daniel did, praying to your God, and trust him with the lions’ jaws. "Commit thy way unto the Lord; trust in him, and he shall bring it to pass." (Ps 37:5) "Some trust in chariots, and some in horses, but I will remember the name of the Lord our God." (Ps 20:7) "Trust in him, for he is thy hope and shield." (Ps 115:9, 10, 11)

Direction 14: Do not take the suggestions of the tempter, or the words of your own distrustful heart, for the voice of God, or as any reason to abandon your confidence in him.

Some people take every malicious suggestion of the devil as a legitimate cause for their anxiety and fear, as if it were the Spirit of God producing all the terrors and disturbances in them that are actually produced by God’s and their enemy. They fear when Satan prompts them, thinking it is the Spirit of God; and they dare not trust God when he commands them to, for fear that it might instead be the will of Satan. Others are so powerfully affected by their own notions and fancies that they treat everything their heart or imagination says as if God himself had said it, and so one fear becomes the reason for another.

Your heart is not so wise or so good that you should take its every word as the word of God. Your "flesh and thy heart" may "fail thee," while God, who is "the rock of thy heart and thy portion," never will (Ps 73:26). Your heart may say, "I have no grace, no help, no hope," when God has never said so (Ps 77:7, 8, 9, 10). Your heart may say, "I am a reprobate, forsaken by God; he will not hear me; the time of grace is past," when God has never said so.

Your heart may say, "I am undone; I can find no comfort in any friend, no evidence of grace within me, no comfort in God, in Christ, or in the promises; my life is nothing but a burden to me; I cannot pray, I cannot believe, I cannot answer Satan’s objections, I can struggle no longer against my fears, I cannot bear my wounded conscience." All of this is the failing of the heart, but it proves nothing about any failing of God, whose grace is sufficient for you, and whose strength is manifested in your weakness. The heart has a thousand sayings and conceits that God utterly contradicts.

Direction 15: When you cannot exercise a trust of assurance, exercise the trust of general faith and hope, and the quiet submission of yourself to the holy will of God.

The common reason given for distrust is: "I do not know that I am a child of God," and "it is fitting for the ungodly to fear his wrath." Yet just as the Gospel is tidings of great joy to every people among whom it comes, so it is a word of hope and trust. Trust God at least as far as infinite goodness deserves to be trusted, he who will condemn none but those who finally and obstinately refuse his saving grace.

And with Aaron (Lev 10:3), hold your peace when God is glorifying himself through his corrections. Remember that the will of God is never mistaken; that it is the beginning and end of all things (Rev 4:11 Rom 11:36); that it never wills anything but good; and that it is the center and goal of all our wills. There is no rest or quietness for our wills except in the will of God. His will is always for the good of those who truly desire to be conformed to it, through obedience to his commands and submission to his ordering of their lives. Say therefore, with your Savior, "Father, if it be thy will, let this cup pass from me; but not as I will, but as thou wilt." Nothing is gained by struggling against the will of God, nor anything lost by a quiet submission to it. And if you love his will and desire to obey and please it, trust in it, for it will surely save you.

CHAPTER 35

GRAND DIRECTION 13: LABOR SO THAT GOD AND HOLINESS MAY BE YOUR CHIEF DELIGHT

Directions for Delighting Ourselves in God

 

Direction 1. Rightly understand what delight in God you must seek and exercise. It is not a merely sensory delight, which is exercised on objects of sense or imagination and is common to animals and humans alike. Nor is it the delight of the immediate vision of God that the blessed enjoy in heaven. Nor is it an enthusiastic delight, consisting in irrational raptures and joys for which no rational account can be given. Nor is it a delight incompatible with sorrow and fear when those are duties. I have said more about enthusiastic impressions in my Directions for the Cure of Church Divisions, in the defense of that work, and in other books.

Rather, it is the solid, rational satisfaction of the soul in God and holiness, arising from a true perception of what in him is rightly and justly delightful to us. In its estimation of its object, and in its inward satisfaction and gladness, though not necessarily in passionate joy or high feeling, it must exceed our delight in temporal pleasures. And it must be the goal to which all our humiliations and other lower duties finally lead.

Direction 2. Understand how much of this holy delight may reasonably be hoped for on earth. Too many Christians feel far more fear and sorrow in their religion than delight. Yet every true Christian does esteem God as more truly worthy of delight than anything else, worthy to be enjoyed, if only he could be. The carnal person, by contrast, finds fleshly things more fitting objects of delight. And though most Christians never rise very high in their delight in God, he has appointed means through which, if faithfully used, we might reach much greater heights. We may well expect at least this much:

1.) Enough to make our lives incomparably more quiet, contented, and pleasant than the lives of the greatest and happiest worldly people.

2.) Enough to make our thoughts of God and the life to come ready, welcome, and pleasant thoughts to us.

3.) Enough to prevail greatly against our disordered griefs and fears, our reluctance in duty, and our weariness in it, enough to make religion an ordinary pleasure.

4.) Enough to take away our craving for unnecessary recreations and unlawful pleasures of the flesh.

5.) Enough to sweeten all our mercies with a spiritual savor and relish.

6.) Enough to make some sufferings joyful, and the rest more bearable.

7.) Enough to make the thought of death less terrifying, and to make us desire to be with Christ.

Direction 3. Understand what there is in God and holiness that is fit to be the soul’s delight.

1.) Behold him in the infinite perfections of his being: his omnipotence, omniscience, and goodness; his holiness, eternity, and immutability. Just as the eye delights in an excellent painting, a well-made building, or a fine landscape, not because these things belong to you, but because they are a delightful object to the eye, so let your mind delight in God considered in himself, as the only object of the highest delight.

2.) Delight also in his relational attributes, by which his goodness toward his creatures is expressed: his all-sufficiency, his faithfulness and truth, his benevolence, his mercy and compassion, his patience toward sinners, and his justice toward all.

3.) Delight in him as his glory appears in his wonderful works of creation and daily providence.

4.) Delight in him as he is related to you, as your God and Father, and as the sole source of all your interest, hope, and happiness.

5.) Delight in him as his excellencies shine forth in his blessed Son.

6.) Delight in him as his excellencies appear in the wisdom and goodness of his Word, in all the precepts and promises of the Gospel (Ps 119:162 Jer 15:16).

7.) Delight in his image, even though it is but imperfectly stamped on your soul, and also in his holy servants (Gal 2:20 1 Cor 15:10).

8.) Delight in the consideration of the glory he receives from all his creatures, and in the universal fulfillment of his will. As the prosperity and happiness of a dear friend delights you, as the success of an excellent enterprise does, as the praise of excellent things and persons does, and as you take a special pleasure in the triumph of truth and in the flourishing order, unity, peace, and prosperity of kingdoms, and most of all of the church, far more than in your own personal success (unless you are selfish, petty, and narrow-minded): so much more should you delight in the glory and happiness of God.

9.) Delight in the safety you have in his favor and protection, and in the treasury you have in his all-sufficiency and love for your continual supply in every need and deliverance in every danger, and in the ground of quiet confidence and contentment that his presence offers to fearful souls.

10.) Delight in the particular expressions of his common mercies to the world, his special mercies to his saints, and his personal mercies to you from your birth to this moment, to your soul, your body, your friends, your reputation, your possessions, and all your affairs in every sphere of life.

11.) Delight in the privilege you have of speaking to him and of him, of hearing from him, of adoring and worshipping him, of singing and publishing his praise, and in the communion your soul may have with him through Christ, on his holy days and at all times, in his sacraments, and throughout your whole life. Say with Solomon, "And will God indeed dwell on earth? Will he dwell and walk with sinful men? When the heaven of heavens cannot contain him." (1 Kgs 8:27) "Let those that seek him rejoice and be glad in him." (Ps 40:16) Let us be glad to go to the house of the Lord and join his holy assemblies in worship. "The streams" of his grace "make glad the city of God, the holy tabernacles of the Most High: God is in the midst of her; she shall not be moved." (Ps 46:4)

12.) Delight above all in the anticipation and hope of the glory you shall see and enjoy forever.

I do no more than name all these points to aid your memory, because they have already been treated fully in the Directions for love.

Direction 4. Understand how much these holy delights please God, and how strongly he is committed to his people’s joy. Many Christians are hindered in their joy by the thought that it is against God’s will for people such as themselves to rejoice so greatly, or at least by failing to perceive how clearly he has commanded it, what a great duty it is, and how much it pleases him. Consider the following:

1.) It is not without reason that human nature is made capable of higher and more expansive delights than a merely animal, sensual nature is, that in this we are made only a little lower than angels.

2.) Nor is it without reason that God has made delight and satisfaction the most powerful and commanding affection, the end to which all the other passions openly minister and tend, and the most natural and inseparable affection of the soul, since there is no one who does not desire delight.

3.) Nor has God provided and offered such an abundance of most excellent objects for our delight, above all himself, in his attributes, love, mercy, Son, Spirit, and kingdom, in vain. Animals were not made to know or enjoy these things.

4.) Nor has he given us in vain such excellent, fitting, and varied helps and lower preparations that draw us toward delight in him, helps both for body and mind, to further our delight in God.

5.) Nor is it in vain that he makes us more directly capable of this through his Spirit, through the humbling, mortifying, cleansing, illuminating, and quickening work of grace. The kingdom of heaven consists in righteousness, peace, and joy in the Holy Spirit; and the Spirit has undertaken to be the Comforter of believers, sent upon no low or needless errand.

6.) Nor did Christ purchase his people’s joy in vain by the price of his grievous sufferings and sorrows. Having borne our griefs and been made a man of sorrows, he suffered so that we who have not seen him might rejoice in believing with joy unspeakable and full of glory.

7.) Nor is it in vain that he has filled his Word with such matter for delight and comfort, in the most glad tidings that could ever come to mankind, and in promises so free, so full, and so sure.

8.) Nor has he multiplied his commands to rejoice and delight in him in vain, again and again commanding us to rejoice, and always to rejoice.

9.) Nor is it insignificant that he has forbidden those worldly anxieties, fears, and griefs that would consume his people’s joy, nor that he has so clearly shown them the way to joy, and rebukes them when they do not walk in it.

10.) He fills their lives with mercies and material for delight, through his guidance, support, provision, and ordering of all things, and all this while they are yet in the way of trial and in the valley of tears.

11.) How tender he is toward their sufferings and sorrows, not afflicting willingly, nor taking pleasure in the grief of the children of men.

12.) He does not take away their delight and comfort until they cast it away themselves, through sinning, self-tormenting, or neglecting the pleasures he has set before them.

13.) He never fails to meet them with his delights when they walk in the way he has prescribed for that end, except when a brief interruption of present pleasure tends to their greater joy in the end.

14.) In their greatest need, when they and all other supports fail, he often gives them the greatest joys.

15.) He takes their delights and sorrows as if they were his own. In all their afflictions he is afflicted, and he delights in their welfare and rejoices over them to do them good. Can you not see your Father’s will in all of this?

16.) If you cannot yet see it, lift up your eyes and look ahead to the eternal delights he has prepared for you, when you shall enter into your Master’s joy, and then judge whether God is for your delight.

Direction 5. Take special notice of the reasons why God commands you to delight in him, and consequently how much of religion consists in these delights.

1. You dishonor and demean him if you do not judge him supremely worthy of your delight.

2. If you do not delight in God, your thoughts of him will be rare, or else unwelcome and unpleasant when they do come.

3. And your speech of him will be rare, or forced and hollow. Everyone knows how readily our thoughts and tongues follow our delight. Whatever we most delight in, house, land, books, friends, or particular activities, we need no compulsion to bring our minds there. The worldly man thinks on his wealth and business; the proud man on his rank and honor; the sensual man on his lusts, entertainments, food, and drink, all because those things are their delight. So must the Christian think on God, on his hopes, and on holy business, as his delight. "To rejoice in God is the highest thing on earth," Bucholtzer.

4. If you have no delight in God and holy things, it will keep you from the holy duties in which you should have communion with him. This is why so many neglect both public and private worship, they find no delight in it, whereas those who do delight in it are eager to seize every opportunity.

5. The absence of delight in God will corrupt your judgment and lead you to think that a little is enough, that serious diligence is needless fastidiousness, and that performing a quarter of your duty is excessive. A man who has no delight in God and godliness is easily persuaded that infrequent, cold, formal, and lifeless preaching and praying will do, that any lip-service is acceptable to God, and that anything more is needless trouble. From there he is drawn to reproach those who surpass him, in order to quiet his own conscience and preserve his reputation, and at last to become a wretched, malicious scoffer, hater, and persecutor of the sincere and holy worshippers of God. "Behold, the word of the Lord is a reproach to them: they have no delight in it: therefore I am full of the fury of the Lord." (Jer 6:10)

6. If you do not delight in it, whatever you do will be done without heart, with reluctance and weariness, like an ox that pulls unwillingly in the yoke and is glad when unyoked, or a horse that moves only as long as it feels the spur; whereas delight would produce eagerness and endurance.

7. The absence of delight makes people prone to quarrel with the Word, and every weakness in the minister offends them, like sick stomachs that always find something wrong with their food.

8. It greatly inclines people toward carnal and forbidden pleasures, because they have not tasted the higher and more excellent delights. Taverns, alehouses, plays, and whores, cards, dice, and excessive recreation must be sought out for them, just as Saul sought a witch and a musician in place of God. The most effective answer to all the shallow reasoning of the pleasure-seeking, when they argue for the lawfulness of their unnecessary, foolish, time-wasting diversions, would be to help them attain a heavenly nature and hearts that delight more in God. "There are three conditions of virtue: the removal of temptation, the multiplication of good actions, and delight in what is good," P. Scaliger. This better pleasure would do more to confute and banish their sinful pleasures than twelve months of disputing and preaching can do, so long as they remain strangers to the soul’s delight in God. Then they would say to their companions, "O come and taste those high delights which we have found in God!"

9. The absence of delight in God and holiness leaves the soul exposed to sorrows as prey. Every affliction that strikes it may do its worst and land its full blow on the naked, unguarded heart, for the pleasures of created things will prove a poor defense.

10. The absence of delight in God and holiness is the road to apostasy itself. Few people will persist in a way they find no delight in, when all other delights must be forsaken for it.

The caged hypocrite, confined to a stricter life than he himself desires, is loathsome to God even while he appears to serve him, for the body without the will is nothing but a corpse in God’s eyes. If you would rather not serve God, you do not truly serve him even while you seem to do so. If you would rather live in sin, you do in effect live in sin while you merely refrain from the outward act, because in God’s reckoning the heart, the will, is the man; and what a man habitually chooses to be, that is what he truly is. And yet this hypocrite is always looking for a gap to escape his cage and abandon the unloved outward form of religion, like a beast driven down a road he is reluctant to travel, always turning aside at every opening. All these harms follow from the absence of delight in God.

On the contrary, the benefits that follow from our delight in God, beyond the sweetness of it, are beyond telling. Those that are the direct opposites of the harms just described I leave to your own reflection.

1.) Delight in God will prove that you know him, love him, and are prepared for his kingdom; for all who truly delight in him shall enjoy him.

2.) Prosperity, the mere addition of earthly things, will not easily corrupt or carry you away.

3.) Adversity, the withdrawal of earthly delights, will not deeply grieve or easily discourage you.

4.) You will receive more profit from a single sermon, a good book, or a godly conversation that you delight in, than others who find no delight in them will receive from many.

5.) All your service will be sweet to yourself and acceptable to God. If you delight in him, he certainly delights in you. (Ps 147:11 Ps 149:4 1 Chr 29:17)

6.) You carry a continual feast within you, which can sweeten all the crosses of your life and afford you greater joy than your sorrow even in your saddest hour.

7.) When you delight in God, your delight in created things will be sanctified to you and rightly ordered in its proper place, whereas in others the same delight is idolatrous or corrupt.

These, with many more, are the benefits of delight in God.

Direction 6. Consider how perfectly suited God and holiness are to be the object of your delight, and guard against every temptation that would represent him as unsuitable to you.

1.) He is most perfect and blessed in himself.

2.) He is full of all that you could ever need.

3.) He holds the whole world under his command for your relief.

4.) He is nearer to you in presence and in relation than anything else in the world.

5.) He has fitted everything in religion to your delight, in content, variety, and benefit.

6.) He will be a certain, constant, and durable delight to you when all others fail.

Your soul came from him, and so it naturally should tend back to him. It is from him and for him, and therefore must rest in him or have no rest at all. We delight in the house where we were born, in our native country, in our parents, every creature inclines toward its own origin. So should the soul incline toward its Creator.

Direction 7. Do not corrupt your minds and appetites with contrary delights.

Do not give yourself over to fleshly pleasures. Taste nothing that is forbidden. Sorrow itself is not so much an enemy to spiritual delights as sensual and sinful pleasures are. O leave your beastly and your childish pleasures, and come and feast your souls on God. Away with the delights of lust, pride, greed, vain entertainment, gluttony, and drunkenness, if you would ever have solid and lasting joy. Do not think of joining both together.

Consider seriously: can anything but the disease and wickedness of your own heart make a play, a feast, or drunken and wanton company more pleasant to you than God? What kind of heart thinks it a toil to meditate on God and heaven, yet a pleasure to dwell on the baits of pride and greed? What kind of heart regards sensuality, wantonness, and vanity as the pleasures of a household that must not be expelled, while counting godliness, heavenly conversation, and spiritual exercises as the gloom and burden of a household that must not be admitted, lest it ruin the merriment? What kind of heart calls it an intolerable slavery to love God, holiness, and heaven, yet a delight to love a whore, or excess of food, drink, or sport? You could say nothing more disgraceful of a man short of calling him a devil.

It would not be so vile for a child to delight more in a dog than in his parents, or a husband to delight more in the ugliest harlot than in his wife, as it is for a man to delight more in fleshly vanities than in God. Will you go on lapping up filth when you ought to be refreshing your souls in angelic pleasures and tasting beforehand the delights of heaven? How justly will God drive such wretched people from his everlasting presence, people who so abhor his ways and himself! Can they blame him for withholding the things they hate, or count so little, as to prefer a lust over them? If they were not haters of God and holiness, they would never be so averse even to the delights they were made to share with him.

Direction 8. Guard against a melancholy habit of body, for people sunk in melancholy can scarcely delight in anything, and therefore not in God. Delight is as difficult for them as it is for a limb in pain to find pleasure, or for a sick stomach to take any enjoyment in food it loathes. They can think of God only with trouble, fear, horror, and despair, never with delight.

Direction 9. Guard against an impatient, peevish, self-tormenting mind that can bear no hardship, and against overvaluing earthly things, which breeds impatience when they are lacking. Do not make too much of bodily pain or pleasure. Otherwise your minds will be pulled into constant attendance on the flesh, consumed by unrelenting desires, anxieties, fears, griefs, or pleasures, and will never be free to find rest in God.

The soul that would know pure and elevated delights must withdraw itself from the concerns of the flesh, and look on your body as though it were someone else’s, whose pain and pleasure you may, to some degree, choose not to dwell on. When Paul was caught up into the third heaven and saw things too deep for words, he was so released from the prison of sense that he did not know whether he was in the body or out of it.

As separated souls, who behold the face of God and the Redeemer, leave their bodies to be buried and to rot in the dark and feel none of this as any interruption to their joy, so faith can imitate something of that death to the world, that neglect of the flesh, and that elevating withdrawal of the mind toward things above. If, in this close union of soul and body, you cannot leave the body to rejoice or suffer alone, at least remember that the body is no more than a servant to the soul; do not let its pain or pleasure dominate and override the soul’s higher operations. A courageous, believing soul, though it cannot diminish the pain at all, nor reconcile the flesh to its affliction, can still, in spite of the pain, do far more for its own delight than onlookers would believe.

Some women, and weak-spirited, emotional men, especially in sickness, are so irritable and impatient that their daily occupation is to disturb and torment themselves. One can hardly speak to them or look at them without giving offense. And since the world is full of occasions for provocation, such people are unlikely to know much quietness. It is hard to imagine that those who keep their minds in a perpetual, raw, festering state, incapable of any delight at all, never ceasing from self-torment, will ever delight in God.

Direction 10. Only a life of faith will be a life of holy, heavenly delight; therefore exercise yourselves in believing contemplations of the things unseen. It must not be the occasional glance of the soul’s eye toward God, or the rare greeting you might give a stranger, but a walking with him and a frequent turning of the soul toward him, that will bring you the delight believers find in communion with him.

Direction 11. Above all, let faith go frequently to heaven for fresh matter of delight, and often consider what God will be to you there forever, and with what full and everlasting delight he will satisfy your souls. As heaven is the place of our complete delight, so the foresight and foretaste of it is the highest delight attainable on earth. A soul that is a stranger to the foresight of heaven will be equally a stranger to the true delights of faith.

Direction 12. It is a great advantage to holy delight to spend much time in the more delightful parts of worship, in thanksgiving and praise, and in a worthy observance of the sacrament of the body and blood of Christ. Of these I have spoken in the preceding Directions.

Direction 13. A skilled, experienced pastor who is able to open the treasury of the Gospel, and to guide his flock both publicly and privately in self-examination and the heavenly exercises of faith, is a great help to Christians’ spiritual delight. The experience of believers confirms this: how often do those who came to the assembly or to their pastors in great distress, almost in despair, go away refreshed and revived (Job 33:23 2 Cor 1:3–4)? It is the office and joy of the ministers of Christ to be "helpers of his people’s faith and joy" (2 Cor 1:24 Phil 1:4 Phil 1:25 1 Thess 2:20).

Direction 14. Make use of all the prosperity and lawful pleasure God gives you in outward things, to increase and advance your delight in God. Though fallen nature is more prone to abuse prosperity and earthly pleasures than almost any other condition, and nearly all the devil’s poison is delivered in sweet or gilded enticements, the original, natural purpose of prosperity, health, plenty, honor, and peace is to lift the mind toward God and give us a foretaste of his spiritual delights.

The intention is that the body’s nearness might be an advantage to the soul, and that God, who in this life is seen only as in a mirror, and who communicates his comforts through appointed means, might use the enjoyment of the senses to draw us toward himself and to convey his love and pleasure to us. The moment the eye, or ear, or taste perceives the delight of its proper object, the holy soul should at once take the signal and be carried upward into delightful thoughts of him who gives us all these pleasures.

Without question, to the extent that we can turn delight in friends, food, health, home, and the comforts of the body into a means of advancing our delight in God, or of removing those melancholy fears and sorrows that would hinder this spiritual delight, it is not only lawful but our duty to use them, with the moderation that serves that end.

Direction 15. Make use of affliction as a great advantage for your purest and most unmixed delight in God. The servants of Christ have generally never known more of the joy of the Holy Spirit than in their greatest sufferings, especially when those sufferings are for his sake. The soul never retreats so readily and delightfully to God as when it has no one else who will receive it or from whom it can draw any comfort. God comforts us most when he has brought us to see that no one else can or will relieve us.

When all friends have forsaken us but one, that one is sweeter to us than ever before. When all of a house is burned down except one room, that room is more pleasant to us than it was before. One who has lost an eye will value the remaining one more than before. In prosperity our delight in God is too often corrupted by a mixture of sensual pleasure; but all that remains when created things are stripped away is purely divine.

Direction 16. Work through self-examination, conducted carefully and under the guidance of a capable spiritual guide, to settle your souls in a well-grounded assurance of your personal interest in God and heaven; and then do not allow Satan, by his persistent importunity, to revive your doubts or disturb your peace. An orderly, well-guided, diligent self-examination can quickly do much to show you your true condition. If you are convinced that genuine grace is in you, do not let fears and suspicions pass for reason and drive you to deny what you cannot deny without contradicting your own conscience.

You do not see Satan’s design in all this: his business is, by making you fear you have no interest in God, to destroy your delight in him and in his service, and after that, to lead you through weariness to forsake him entirely, and either to despair or to turn to sensual pleasures. Foresee and forestall these designs of Satan, and do not allow him at his pleasure to raise fresh storms of fears and troubles, or to draw you to deny your Father’s mercies or to suspect his proven love.

Direction 17. Do not dampen your delights by willful sin. If you grieve your Comforter, he will grieve you, or leave you to grieve yourselves. In exact proportion as any known sin is harbored, delight in God will certainly decay.

Direction 18. Use your observation of wicked men’s sensual pleasures to stir your own soul to delight in God. Ask yourself: shall hawking, hunting, pride, filthiness, cards, dice, plays, sports, excess, idleness, foolish talk, and worldly honors be so delightful to these deluded sinners, and shall not my God and Savior, his love and promises, and the hope of heaven be far more delightful to me? Is there any comparison between the substance of my delights and theirs?

Direction 19. Work to overcome those fears of death that would damp your joy in the foresight of everlasting joy. As nothing feeds holy delight more than anticipating heaven, so there is scarcely anything that more hinders our delight in those anticipations than the fear of death standing in the way. See what I have written against this fear in my Treatise of Self-denial, Saints’ Rest, Treatise of Death, as the Last Enemy, and Last Work of a Believer.

Direction 20. Do not set any other religious duty against your delight in God and holiness; rather, use them all in their proper role as means subordinate to that delight. Penitent sorrow is only a purge to expel those corruptions that prevent you from tasting your spiritual delights. Use it therefore as medicine, only when needed, only for that purpose, and do not make it your ordinary food. Delight in God is the health of your souls: do not say you have no time to be healthy because you must take medicine, or that you take medicine against health or in place of health, but for your health. So too, take up no sorrow against your delight in God or instead of it, but for it, and only so much as promotes it. See the Directions for love given earlier.

By now you can see that holy delight, joined to love, is the chief part of our religion, and that those who locate religion in anything else are mistaken. How inexcusable, then, are all those who are ungodly enemies or neglecters of a holy life. If it had been a life of grief and toil, they would have had some excuse; but to flee from pleasure, and refuse delight, and such delight as this, is inexcusable. Know this, sinners: God is not calling you to forsake delight, but to receive it, to exchange your delight in sin and vanity for delight in him. You cannot honestly say this is not the better exchange. You cannot keep your houses and lands forever, nor your lusts and excesses forever; but you may have God forever. And if you hope to live with him forever, have you truly no delight in him?

People deal with Christ as the Papists deal with the Reformed churches: because we reject their ceremonies and formal observances, they charge us with abolishing all religion. So too, because we would call people away from their brutish pleasures, they say we would leave them no pleasure at all, for the epicure thinks that when his luxury, lust, and sport are gone, everything is gone. Call a sluggard from his bed, or a glutton from his table, to receive a kingdom, and he will complain, if he looks only at what is taken from him and not at what is offered in its place. When earthly pleasures end in misery, who will not wish they had chosen the holy, enduring delights instead?

CHAPTER 36

GRAND DIRECTION 14: LET THANKFULNESS BE THE TEMPERAMENT OF YOUR SOUL

 

"Let thankfulness to God your Creator, Redeemer, and Regenerator be the very temperament of your soul, faithfully expressed by your tongue and life."

Though our thankfulness is no benefit to God, he is pleased with it as something fitting to our condition and as evidence of the sincerity and honesty of the heart. An ungrateful person merely consumes mercies and buries them, without the sense or honesty to recognize and acknowledge the hand that gives them. The thankful person, by contrast, looks beyond himself and returns everything he can to the one from whom all blessings flow.

True thankfulness to God is distinguished from its counterfeit by these marks:

1. True thankfulness, having a fair estimate of mercies by comparison, prizes spiritual and everlasting mercies above those that are merely physical and temporary. Worldly thankfulness, on the other hand, chiefly values worldly mercies, even if it can mouth the admission that spiritual ones are greater.

2. True thankfulness draws the soul toward spiritual rejoicing in God and toward a desire for more of his spiritual mercies. Worldly thankfulness is only a delight in the prosperity of the flesh, or in the mind’s delusion and false security, inclining people toward empty, carnal merriment and toward a craving for more such fleshly pleasure, abundance, or comfort, much as a well-fed animal will frisk and play and show that it is content with its condition, or, if it has ease, simply wishes not to be disturbed.

3. True thankfulness kindles in the heart a love for the giver above the gift, or at least a love for God above our worldly prosperity and pleasure, and draws the heart ever closer to God through all his mercies. Worldly thankfulness, by contrast, springs from self-love or love of bodily prosperity; it is moved by that love and serves it, and it loves God and thanks him only so far as he gratifies the flesh. A child’s thankfulness makes us love our Father more than his gift and makes us long to be with him. A dog loves you and is grateful to you, but only for feeding it; it loves you in subordination to its appetite and its bones.

4. True thankfulness inclines us to obey and please the one who obliges us by his benefits. Worldly thankfulness puts God off with the hypocritical, flattering thanks of the lips, then spends the mercy on pleasing the flesh and makes it nothing more than fuel for lust and sin.

5. True thankfulness to God is necessarily total, just as his mercies are boundless. The saving of our souls from hell, the promise of eternal life, and the gift of our very existence and everything we have together oblige us to be wholly and absolutely his, one who is so transcendent a benefactor, and move the truly grateful person to devote and surrender himself and all he has to God in response to so great an obligation. Worldly thankfulness falls short of this complete and total dedication; it leaves the sinner in the power of self-love, devoting himself in reality to himself, using everything he is and has to please his worldly mind, and giving God only the tithe or leftovers of the flesh, only so much as it can spare, lest he stop the flow of divine kindness and rob the flesh of its prosperity and comforts.

Directions for Thankfulness to God, Our Benefactor

 

Direction 1. "Understand thoroughly how great this duty is by its very nature, and especially how the entire design and tenor of the Gospel, and the whole manner of our salvation through a Redeemer, calls it forth as the very character of the soul and of every duty."

A creature who belongs entirely to his Creator, is sustained every moment by him, fed and maintained daily by his bounty, and placed in a capacity for eternal life is surely bound to ceaseless gratitude. Among human beings, ingratitude is rightly considered an unnatural and monstrous vice that forfeits the benefits of friendship and society. "Unthankful" people are listed alongside the "unholy" and similar characters as part of the dreadful figures who would appear in the last times (2 Tim 3:2), figures we have lived to see, answering that full description exactly.

But the design of God in the work of redemption is deliberately laid to produce the highest possible thankfulness in humanity. The Covenant of Grace contains such abundant and wonderful mercies as should compel the souls of people to gratitude, or leave them utterly without excuse.

It is a great truth deserving careful consideration that gratitude is the general duty of the Gospel, the duty that contains and animates all the rest, being essential to everything properly evangelical. A law, as a law, requires obedience as the general duty, and this obedience is to be exercised and expressed in every particular duty the law enjoins. The covenant with the Jews was called "the Law" because its regulating character was most prominent; obedience was therefore the thing that law most eminently required, though the measure of mercy they received also bound them to thankfulness.

But the Gospel, or New Covenant, is most prominently a record of mercy and a tender and promise of the most matchless benefits ever heard by human ears. The gift of mercy is therefore the dominant element of the Gospel or New Covenant. And though God remains our Governor, and the New Covenant also has its precepts and is a law, that is in a manner the subordinate element. What obedience is to a law, the formal answer to its obligation, thankfulness is to a benefit. So while we are called to as exact obedience as ever, it is now only a thankful obedience to which we are called.

Just as law and promises are joined together in the New Covenant, so obedience and thankfulness must be joined in our hearts and lives: one rendered to God as our Ruler, the other to him as our Benefactor, and both animating every act of heart and life. We must repent of sin, but it must be a thankful repenting, as befits those who have received a free pardon of all their sins procured by the blood of Christ and offered in the Gospel. Remove that gratitude, and it is no longer evangelical repentance. And what is saving faith in Christ but assent to the truth of the Gospel together with a thankful acceptance of the good it offers, Christ himself as our Savior, with all the benefits of his redemption?

The love to God required in the Gospel is the thankful love of his redeemed people. And love to our very enemies, the forgiving of wrongs, all love for one another, and all the works of charity required there are exercises of gratitude, all to be done on this basis: because Christ has loved us and forgiven us, that we might show our thankful love to him. Preaching, prayer, sacraments, public praise, the communion of saints, and obedience are all to be animated by gratitude; they are no further evangelically performed than thankfulness is the very life and character of them all.

The obscure and inadequate treatment of this truth by preachers gave the Antinomians occasion to run to the opposite extreme and to diminish too much God’s law and our obedience. But if we eclipse the doctrine of evangelical gratitude, we do as badly or worse than they. Obedience to our Ruler and thankfulness to our Benefactor, joined and working together as the head and heart in the natural body, make a true Christian. Understand this well, and it will greatly incline your heart toward thankfulness.

Direction 2. "Keep the greatness of God’s manifold mercies continually before your eyes."

Thankfulness is produced by a right appreciation of the greatness of mercies. If you do not recognize them as mercies, or do not see that they are mercies to you, or do not believe what is said and promised in the Gospel, or if you forget them, fail to think on them, or make light of them through the corruption of your mind, you cannot be thankful for them. I have already spoken of mercy in connection with kindling love, so I will now only set out the following, to be kept always in your memory:

1. The love of God in giving us a Redeemer, and the love of Christ in giving his life for us, and in all the aspects of our redemption.

2. The covenant of grace, the pardon of all our sins, the justification of our persons, our adoption, and our title to eternal life.

3. The fitness of the means appointed for calling us to Christ; the gracious and wise workings of Providence to that end; the gifts and compassion of our teachers; the care of parents; and the help and example of the servants of Christ.

4. The effectiveness of all these means: God’s giving us to will and to do, his opening of our hearts, his giving us repentance unto life, and the Spirit of Christ to mortify our sins, purify our nature, and dwell within us.

5. Our standing in his church, under the care of faithful pastors; the liberty, comfort, and frequent benefit of his Word and sacraments, and the public communion of his saints.

6. The fellowship of those who fear the Lord, their faithful admonitions, rebukes, and encouragements, and the kindness they have shown us for body and for soul.

7. The mercies of our family relationships, our homes, our estates, and the notable turns and events of our lives.

8. The many times our souls have been preserved and delivered: from errors and deceivers, from terror and distress, from dangerous temptations, and from many a soul-wounding sin; and that we are not abandoned to the errors and desires of our own hearts, or given up to seared consciences as those forsaken by God.

9. The many deliverances of our bodies from enemies, injuries, hardships, sicknesses, and death.

10. The mercies of adversity, in wholesome and necessary chastisements or honorable sufferings for his sake, and in the support and comfort given under them all.

11. The communion our souls have had with God in the course of our private and public duties, in prayer, the sacraments, and meditation.

12. The use he has made of us for the good of others, so that our time has not been wholly wasted and we have not lived merely as burdens to the world.

13. The mercies of all our friends and his servants, which were as much our own; and our share in the mercies and public welfare of his church, which are greater than our personal mercies.

14. His patience and forbearance with us under our constant unprofitableness and provocations, and his renewed mercies in spite of our misuse of them; our perseverance until now.

15. Our hope of everlasting rest and glory when this sinful life is ended.

Dwell on these mercies in your fuller meditations, and they will surely compel you to cry out: "Bless the Lord, O my soul: and all that is within me, bless his holy name. Bless the Lord, O my soul, and forget not all his benefits; who forgiveth all thine iniquities; who healeth all thy diseases; who redeemeth thy life from destruction; who crowneth thee with loving-kindness and tender mercies." (Ps 103:1–4)

"Enter into his gates with thanksgiving, and into his courts with praise; be thankful unto him, and bless his name. For the Lord is good; his mercy is everlasting; and his truth endureth to all generations." (Ps 100:4–5)

"The Lord is merciful and gracious, slow to anger, and plenteous in mercy. For as the heaven is high above the earth, so great is his mercy toward them that fear him." (Ps 103:8, 11)

"O give thanks unto the Lord; for he is good; for his mercy endureth for ever." (Ps 136:1)

"O give thanks unto the Lord; call upon his name; make known his deeds among the people. Sing unto him, sing psalms unto him; talk ye of all his wondrous works. Glory ye in his holy name: let the heart of them rejoice that seek him." (Ps 105:1–3)

Direction 3. "Be well acquainted with the greatness of your sins, and feel them as the very thing that makes God’s mercies to you so remarkable." This is the main reason God humbles those he will save: not to drive them to despair of mercy, nor because he takes pleasure in their sorrow for its own sake, but to work their hearts toward a proper esteem of saving mercy, a genuine desire for it, and a readiness to receive it thankfully, retain it carefully, and use it faithfully. An unhumbled soul sets little store by Christ, by grace, by glory; it has no appetite for spiritual mercy and cannot be thankful for what it feels no great need of. True humiliation restores that appetite and teaches us to value mercy for what it really is.

Think, then, what sin is, as I opened in Direction 8, and think of your many, aggravated sins; then consider how great those mercies are that are bestowed on so great and unworthy sinners. Mercy will then melt your humbled hearts when you confess that you are "unworthy to be called sons" (Luke 15), and that you are "unworthy to look up to heaven" (Luke 18:13), and that you are "not worthy of the least of all the mercies of God." (Gen 32:10) The humbled soul is the thankful soul, and it is therefore so greatly valued by the Lord.

Direction 4. "Understand what misery you were delivered from, and measure the greatness of the mercy by the greatness of the punishment you had deserved." Misery, no less than sin, must reveal to us the greatness of God’s mercies. This has already been opened in Chapter 1, Direction 9.

Direction 5. "Suppose you saw the damned souls, or suppose you had spent one day in hell yourself, then consider how thankful you would have been for Christ and mercy." You were condemned to it by the law of God; had death brought you to execution, you would have been there. Then mercy would have been more deeply prized. If a preacher were sent to those miserable souls to offer them pardon and eternal life on the very terms on which it is offered to us, do you think they would treat it as lightly as we do?

Direction 6. "Do not neglect to keep the evidences of your title to those special mercies clear, the mercies for which you should be most thankful, and do not listen when Satan tempts you to think they are not yours, so that he might cause you to withhold from God the thanks he expects." I have already spoken on this in the Directions for Love.

Direction 7. "Think often about those personal mercies God has shown you from your youth until now, by which he has displayed his care for you and his particular kindness to you." Though the common mercies shared by all of God’s servants are the greatest, since every other Christian shares them, personal favors peculiar to ourselves tend to move us most, being near to our understanding and expressing a care and love directed specifically at us. Christians should therefore take note of God’s dealings with them, and write down the great and notable mercies of their lives, something not unfit for others to read as well.

Direction 8. "Compare your share of mercies with that of the rest of the people in the world, and you will find that not one in many thousands has received what you have." So small a part of the world are Christians; of those, so few are orthodox, reformed Christians; of those, so few are seriously and devoutly godly; and of those, so few escape perplexities, errors, scandals, or severe afflictions and distress, that the few who are in none of these straits have cause for wonderful thankfulness to God. Indeed, even the most afflicted Christians in the world have cause for it. Suppose God had divided his mercies equally among all people, health, wealth, honor, grace, the Gospel, and so on, how little of it would have come to your share compared with what you now possess? How many have less wealth or honor than you? How many thousands have less of the Gospel and of grace? Your thankfulness, then, ought proportionally to be extraordinary.

Direction 9. "Compare the mercies you lack with those you possess, and observe how much greater your receivings are than your sufferings." You enjoy many plentiful meals for every one day of scarcity or real hunger; many days of health for every one day of sickness. If one part of your life goes ill, more parts do not; if one trouble befalls you, you are spared many others that could have come upon you, and that you deserve.

Direction 10. "Consider how you would value your mercies if you were deprived of them." Their loss is usually the most effective teacher of their worth. Think how you would value Christ and hope if you were in despair; how you would value earthly mercies if you were in hell; how you would value the mercies of England if you lived among bloody inquisitors and persecutors, or among wicked, cruel Heathens or Mahometans, or among brutish, savage Americans. Think how good sleep would seem if you could not sleep for pain; how good your food, drink, clothing, home, livelihood, and friends would all seem if they were taken from you; what a mercy health would seem if you were under some tormenting sickness; what a mercy time would seem if death were near and time were running out; and what a mercy even your least sincere desires, or smallest measure of grace, would appear in comparison with those who hate, despise, and persecute holiness. These thoughts, followed through honestly, may shame you into thankfulness.

Direction 11. "Keep heaven always before your eyes, and think continually of the endless joy you will have with Christ." That is the mercy of all mercies. Whoever does not have that in hope to be thankful for will never be truly thankful for anything; but whoever has heaven in promise has at all times reason for the highest, most joyful thanks, whatever worldly thing they lack, even if they were certain never again to find comfort in any creature on earth. The person who will not be thankful for heaven is truly unthankful; but heaven is a mercy that, once our title to it is discerned, will press us toward thankfulness. The more believing and heavenly the mind is, the more thankful it becomes.

Direction 12. "See earthly and present mercies in connection with heaven, which is their final end, and as sweetened by our relationship with the God who gives them." If you leave out God and overlook him, you leave out all the life and sweetness that should cause your thankfulness. A dead body has neither the beauty nor the usefulness of a living person. You drain your mercies of meaning when you separate them from God and heaven; their beauty, sweetness, and excellence vanish, and how can you be thankful for husks and shells when you foolishly neglect the kernel? Receive every gift as from your Father’s hands. Remember that he feeds, clothes, and protects you as his child; it is to "Our Father which is in heaven" that we must go every day for our "daily bread." Taste his love in every gift, and you will find it sweet.

Remember where all his mercies are leading and where they will leave you, in the bosom of eternal love. Think to yourself: how good this is, with the love of God! This, together with heaven, is more than enough for me. Plain food, plain clothing, plain treatment in the world, hard work, and a poor dwelling, with heaven to follow, is mercy beyond all human estimation or conceiving. Nothing can be small that is a token of God’s love and leads to eternal glory. Its connection to heaven is the life and glory of every mercy.

Direction 13. "Think often about what a great mercy it is that thankfulness for mercy has been made so large a part of your duty." Is there any sweeter occupation in the world than to be always thinking about something as sweet as the mercies of God, and to be recounting them with glad and thankful hearts? Is this not sweeter work than abusing mercy, squandering it on fleshly lusts, sinning it away, and turning it against yourself? Is it not even sweeter than groaning under sin and misery? If God had fixed your thoughts as firmly on grieving and heartbreaking objects as he has, by his commands, on reviving and delightful ones, you might well have thought religion a melancholy life.

But when sorrow is required only as a preparation for delight, and cheerful thanksgiving is made the life and sum of your religion, who but a monster would find it burdensome to live in thankfulness to our great Benefactor? To reflect on the sweetness of this calling will do much to draw us toward it and make it feel natural.

Direction 14. "Make it a matter of conscience ordinarily to give God’s mercies as much room in your thoughts and prayers as you give to your sins, needs, and troubles." On a day of humiliation, after a notable fall into sin, or in some special season of distress, I grant that sin and danger may rightly take the greater share. But ordinarily, mercy should occupy more time in our remembrance and confession than our sins do.

Let the reasons for this first convince you that it is your duty; and once convinced, hold yourself to its performance. If you cannot be as thankful as you desire, at least spend as much time confessing God’s mercy to you as you spend confessing your sins and presenting your needs. Thanksgiving is an effective way of petitioning for more: it shows that the soul is not drowned in self-concern, but wishes to return the fruit of all God’s mercies back to him. Even if you cannot think on mercy as thankfully as you would, see to it that mercy receives its due proportion of your thoughts.

This practice of allowing mercy its rightful time in our thoughts and prayers would gradually work the soul toward greater thankfulness. By contrast, when people habitually spend ten or twenty words in confession and petition for every one word of thanksgiving, and give ten thoughts to sins, needs, and troubles for every one thought of mercies, they starve thankfulness and drive it out entirely. You can govern your words and thoughts if you choose; resolve, therefore, to perform this duty.

Direction 15. "Guard against a proud, covetous, fleshly, or discontented mind, for all of these are enemies of thankfulness." A proud heart thinks itself most deserving of more and thinks little of everything it has received. A covetous heart is always craving more and never returning the fruit of what it has already been given. A fleshly mind is an insatiable gulf for bodily mercies, like a greedy dog gaping for another bone as soon as it has devoured one, sacrificing everything to its belly, which is its god. A discontented mind is always murmuring and never satisfied, always finding something to quarrel with, and taking far more notice of the refusal of its unjust desires than of the granting of many undeserved mercies. Thankfulness cannot thrive where these vices flourish.

Direction 16. "Avoid as much as possible a melancholy and excessively fearful temperament, for such a temperament will not allow you to see or savor your greatest mercies, nor to rejoice or be thankful for anything you have, but constantly represents everything to you in a terrible or lamentable shape." The grace of thankfulness may exist habitually even in a timid, melancholy mind, as is evident from how highly such people value mercy: how glad and thankful they would be if they were assured that God’s love is toward them! But it is nearly impossible for them, in ordinary life, to exercise thankfulness, because they cannot bring themselves to believe anything good or comforting about their own condition. It is as natural for them to go on fearing, despairing, complaining, and tormenting themselves as it is for fretful children to cry or for sick men to groan. Do not therefore indulge this miserable condition, but resist it by every proper remedy.

Direction 17. "Guard against unthankful doctrines, those that teach you to deny or undervalue mercy." Such doctrines include three in particular.

1.) The doctrine of the Pelagians (whom Prosper called "the Ungrateful") who denied that faith and special grace are any special gift of God, and who teach that Peter owes God no more than Judas does for the distinguishing grace that set them apart.

2.) The doctrine that denies general grace, which is presupposed by special grace, and tells the world that Christ died only for the elect and that all the mercy of the Gospel is confined to them alone. This teaching tells everyone to withhold thanks to God for Christ and every Gospel mercy until they know they are elect and justified, and would instruct the wicked, both on earth and in hell, that they ought not to charge themselves with sinning against any Gospel mercy, or with rejecting a Christ who died for them.

3.) All doctrine that makes God the physical, efficient predeterminer of every act of the creature considered in every circumstance, and so teaches that saving grace is no more, and no differently caused by God, than sin and every natural act is, so that whatever thanks we owe him for keeping us from sin amounts to no more than thanks for not irresistibly premoving us to it. Such doctrines cut the veins of thankfulness; and since they are not doctrines consistent with godliness, the life of grace and the spiritual sense of believers stand against them.

Direction 18. "Do not put God off with verbal thanks, but give him yourself and all you have." Thankfulness leads the soul to ask, "What shall I render unto the Lord for all his benefits towards me?" (Ps 116:12). And no less than yourself and all you have is what you must render: you must give God not only your tithes and the offering of Cain, but yourself entirely as his servant, and everything you possess placed at his command to be used as he would have you use it. A thankful soul devotes itself to God, this is the "living, acceptable sacrifice" (Rom 12:1).

It considers how to serve him and how to do good with all his mercies. Thankfulness is a powerful spring of obedience, and makes people long to be fruitful and useful, glad of every opportunity to serve God. So law and Gospel, obedience and gratitude work together. A thankful obedience and an obedient thankfulness are a Christian’s life. "Offer unto God thanksgiving; and pay thy vows to the Most High: and call upon me in the day of trouble, and I will deliver thee, and thou shalt glorify me. Whoso offereth praise glorifieth me; and to him that ordereth his conversation aright, I will shew the salvation of God" (Ps 50:14–15, 23).

I earnestly ask you who read these lines: be so faithful to God, so candid and honest, so genuinely a friend to the comfort of your own soul, and so true a lover of a joyful life, that you will set yourself from this time forward to a more conscientious performance of this noble work. Steep your thoughts in the abundant mercies of your God, and express them more fully in all your speech to God and to others.

Say with David: "O Lord, truly I am thy servant; thou hast loosed my bonds. I will offer to thee the sacrifice of thanksgiving, and will call upon the name of the Lord" (Ps 116:16–17). "I will extol thee, O Lord, for thou hast lifted me up, and hast not made my foes to rejoice over me. O Lord my God, I cried unto thee, and thou hast healed me. O Lord, thou hast brought up my soul from the grave; thou hast kept me alive, that I should not go down to the pit. Sing unto the Lord, O ye saints of his, and give thanks at the remembrance of his holiness. Thou hast put off my sackcloth, and girded me with gladness; to the end that my glory may sing praise to thee, and not be silent. O Lord my God, I will give thanks to thee for ever" (Ps 30:1–4, 11–12).

"I will praise the name of God with a song, and magnify him with thanksgiving. This also shall please the Lord better than an ox" (Ps 69:30–31). "It is a good thing to give thanks unto the Lord, and to sing praises unto thy name, O Most High; to shew forth thy loving-kindness in the morning, and thy faithfulness every night" (Ps 92:1–2). "At midnight will I rise to give thanks unto thee, because of thy righteous judgments" (Ps 119:62). "Surely the righteous shall give thanks unto thy name; the upright shall dwell in thy presence" (Ps 140:13).

Remember that you are commanded "in every thing to give thanks" (1 Thess 5:18). Be sparing in your thankfulness to God only when God is sparing in his mercy to you, not when the devil, a forgetful heart, an unbelieving heart, or a discontented heart would hide his greatest mercies from your sight. It is entirely just for God to give over to sadness of heart and to cheerless, self-tormenting melancholy the person who, despite the greatness and abundance of God’s mercies, cannot be persuaded to make frequent and glad returns of thanks.

CHAPTER 37

GRAND DIRECTION 15: GLORIFY GOD WITH HEART, TONGUE, AND LIFE

 

"Let your very heart be set to glorify God, your Creator, Redeemer, and Sanctifier, both with the esteem of your mind, the praises of your mouth, and the holiness of your life."

Glorifying God is the end of humanity and of all creation, and so it must be the highest duty of our lives, deserving careful and distinct consideration. "Whether ye eat or drink, or whatsoever ye do, do all to the glory of God" (1 Cor 10:31). "That God in all things might be glorified through Jesus Christ, to whom be praise and dominion for ever and ever. Amen" (1 Pet 4:11). I will therefore first explain what it means to glorify God, and then give directions for how to do it.

To glorify God is not to add anything to his essential perfections, his felicity, or his real glory. The phrase "the glory of God" is used in several senses.

1. Sometimes it signifies the essential, transcendent excellencies of God considered in himself (Rom 6:4; Ps 19:2).

2. Sometimes it signifies the glory that angels and saints behold in heaven. What this is, a soul in the flesh cannot formally conceive or comprehend. It does not seem to be the very essence of God, since that essence is everywhere, whereas this glory is not, or if anyone thinks his essence is this glory, present equally everywhere, and that the creature’s capacity is the only difference between heaven and earth, that view seems refuted by the fact that the glory of heaven will be seen by the glorified body itself, which is not thought to be capable of seeing the essence of God. Whether that glory is the essence of God, or some immediate emanation from his excellency, as beams and light sent forth by the sun, or a created glory for the happiness of his servants, we will know when, with the blessed, we enjoy it.

3. Sometimes it is used for the manifestation of God’s perfections in his creatures, whether in nature or in free agents, as discerned by human beings, and for his honor in the estimation of humanity (John 11:4, 40 1 Cor 11:7 2 Cor 4:15 Phil 1:11; 2:11 Isa 35:2; 40:5). In this sense, to glorify God means: first, objectively, to represent his excellencies or glory; second, mentally, to conceive of them; and third, verbally, to declare them.

I will therefore direct you distinctly on three fronts: first, how to glorify God in your minds; second, by your tongues; and third, by your lives.

Directions for Glorifying God with the Heart

 

Direction 1. "Reject all blasphemous representations and thoughts of God. Do not think of him as limited, unbalanced, diminished, or in any bodily form. Do not attempt to comprehend him, but rather bow before him in reverent wonder." Conceive of him as incomprehensible and infinite. If Satan tempts you to think meanly of anything in God, or to think highly of one of his perfections while thinking poorly of another, reject such temptations. Think of his power, knowledge, and goodness equally, as the infinite perfections of God.

Direction 2. "Behold his glory in the glory of his works of nature and of grace, and see him in all things as the soul, the glory, and the all of the whole creation." What a power is that which made and preserves the entire world! What a wisdom is that which fitted together the universal frame of heaven and earth and keeps all things in their order! How good is he who made all things good, and gave to creatures all their goodness, both natural and spiritual, through creation and renewing grace! "The heavens declare the glory of God, and the firmament sheweth his handy-work" (Ps 19:1). "His glory covered the heavens, and the earth was full of his praise" (Hab 3:3). "The voice of the Lord is upon the waters; the God of glory thundereth" (Ps 29:3; 145).

Direction 3. "Behold him in the person, miracles, resurrection, dominion, and glory of his blessed Son," who is "the brightness of his glory, and the express image of his person; upholding all things by the word of his power, and having by himself purged our sins, sat down at the right-hand of the Majesty on high, being made better than the angels" (Heb 1:3–4). "By him" it is that "glory is given to God in the church" (Eph 3:21). "God hath highly exalted him, and given him a name which is above every name; that at the name of Jesus every knee should bow, of things in heaven, and things in earth, and things under the earth; and that every tongue should confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father" (Phil 2:9–11).

Pray, therefore, that the "God of our Lord Jesus Christ, the Father of glory, may give unto you the spirit of wisdom and revelation in the acknowledgment of him: the eyes of your understanding being enlightened; that ye may know what is the hope of his calling, and what the riches of the glory of his inheritance in the saints, and what is the exceeding greatness of his power to usward who believe, according to the working of his mighty power, which he wrought in Christ, when he raised him from the dead, and set him at his right hand in the celestials, far above all principality, and power, and might, and dominion, and every name that is named, not only in this world, but also in that which is to come; and hath put all things under his feet, and gave him to be Head over all things to the church" (Eph 1:17). "The Father hath glorified his name in his Son" (John 12:28; 13:31, 32; 14:13; 17:1).

Direction 4. "Behold God as the end of the whole creation, and set him as the end of all the actions of your life." You do not honor him as God if you do not practically esteem him as your ultimate end, that is, the pleasing of his will and the honoring of him in the world. If anything else becomes your chief end, you are honoring it above him and making a god of it.

Direction 5. "Answer each of his blessed attributes with the affections that fit them (as I have directed in my Treatise of the Knowledge of God, and here briefly in Direction 4), and answer his relations to us with the duties those relations require" (subjection, love, and so on), as I have set out in the foregoing Directions. We glorify him in our hearts when the image of his attributes is received there.

Direction 6. "Behold him by faith as always present with you." When you do, every attribute will affect you more deeply, and you will not admit dishonoring thoughts of him. Pray to him as though you saw him, and you will speak to him with reverence. Speak of him as though you saw him, and you will not dare to take his name in vain, nor speak of God with a common state of mind, nor in a common manner, as though speaking of common things. "By faith Moses forsook Egypt, not fearing the wrath of the king; for he endured, as seeing Him that is invisible" (Heb 11:27). God is despised by those who imagine they are behind his back.

Direction 7. "Think of him as in heaven, where he is revealed in glory to the blessed and magnified by their high, everlasting praise." Nothing helps us so much to glorify God in our minds as beholding him by faith where he is glorious. Even reading through the description of the glory of the New Jerusalem (Rev 21; 22) will greatly stir a believing mind with a sense of the gloriousness of God. Suppose, as Stephen did, that we saw heaven opened, the Ancient of Days, the great Jehovah, gloriously illuminating the city of God; Jesus in glory at his right hand; and the innumerable company of glorified spirits before his throne, praising and magnifying him with the highest wonder and most joyful acclamation that creatures are capable of, would this not lift us to something of the same wonder? The soul that by faith dwells most above is the one that most glorifies God, as being nearest to his glory.

Direction 8. "Foresee by faith the coming of Christ and the day of universal judgment, when Christ shall come in flaming fire with thousands of his holy angels, to be glorified in his saints, and admired in all them that do believe" (2 Thess 1:10).

Direction 9. "Reject all doctrines that blaspheme or dishonor the name of God, and would obscure the glory of his Majesty." I give you this rule for your own preservation, not in imitation of uncharitable troublemakers and dividers of the church, who exercise pride and a domineering spirit by condemning all those whose opinions they can maliciously attach a blasphemous consequence to, even when that consequence exists only in their own imagination, or is not acknowledged but actually hated by those upon whom they fasten it. Be content to detest false doctrines without detesting the persons you imagine guilty of them, who profess to believe the contrary truth just as firmly as you yourself do.

Direction 10. "Take heed of sinking into flesh and earth, and being diverted by things sensible from the daily contemplation of the glory of God." If your belly becomes your god, and you set your mind on earthly things, and pursue the honors, profits, or pleasures of the world when your citizenship is in heaven, you will be glorying in your shame when you should be admiring the glory of your Maker (Phil 3:18–20), and you will have so much to do on earth that you will find no leisure, because you have no heart, to look up seriously to God.

Directions for Glorifying God with Our Tongues in His Praises

 

Direction 1. "Conceive of this duty of praising God according to its surpassing excellence, as being the highest service that the tongue of men or angels can perform." To bless, praise, or magnify God is not to make him greater, better, or happier than he is; it is to declare and extol his greatness, goodness, and blessedness. To inflame your hearts for this excellent work, I will show you how great and necessary, how high and acceptable a work it truly is.

1. It is giving God his chief due, speaking of him as he is. A Christian is one who says and does what is unwelcome to the devil, and who adorns the glory of God, the author of his life and salvation (Bucholtzer). And when we have said the highest things we can, how far we still fall short of expressing his glorious perfections! What praise does that Almightiness deserve which creates and sustains all the world, governs all the sons of men, and is able to do whatever he wills! "Great is the Lord, and greatly to be praised; and his greatness is unsearchable. One generation shall praise his works to another and declare his mighty acts: I will speak of the glorious honour of thy Majesty, and of thy wondrous works; and men shall speak of the might of thy terrible acts, and I will declare thy greatness" (Ps 145:3–5).

What praise does that knowledge deserve which extends to all things that are, were, or ever shall be, and that wisdom which orders all the world! He knows every thought of man and all the secrets of the heart (Ps 44:21 Ps 94:11). "Known unto God are all his works, from the beginning of the world" (Acts 15:18). "His understanding is infinite" (Ps 147:5).

What praise does that goodness and mercy deserve which is spread throughout all the world, and is the life, hope, and happiness of men and angels! "His mercy is great unto the heavens, and his truth unto the clouds" (Ps 57:10). "O how great is his goodness to them that fear him" (Ps 31:19)! And therefore how great should be his praise! "Who can utter the mighty acts of the Lord, and who can shew forth all his praise" (Ps 106:2)? "For great is the glory of the Lord" (Ps 138:5)!

2. Praising God is the end of all his wondrous works, and especially the end for which man was made, so that all things might praise him objectively, and men and angels might praise him in estimation and expression. His glorious excellence was to be visible in his works and admired and extolled by the rational creature; for this, all things were created and are continued; for this, we have understanding and speech; this is the fruit God expects from all his works. Deny him this, and you are guilty of frustrating the whole creation as much as lies in you. You would have the sun shine in vain, the heavens and earth stand in vain, and man and all things live in vain, if God were not to have the praise and glory of his works.

Therefore sun, moon, stars, and firmament are called upon to praise the Lord (Ps 148:2–4), as they are the matter for which he must be praised by us. "O praise him therefore for his mighty acts: praise him according to his excellent greatness" (Ps 150:2). "O that men would praise the Lord for his goodness, and declare his wondrous works for the children of men" (Ps 107:8)!

Yes, it is the very end of Christ’s redemption of the world and his saving of his elect, that God might have, in the church, on earth, and in heaven, the "praise and glory of his grace" (Eph 1:6, 12, 14). "By him therefore let us offer the sacrifice of praise to God continually, that is, the fruit of our lips, giving thanks to his name" (Heb 13:15). "And let the redeemed of the Lord say, that his mercy endureth for ever" (Ps 107:2). For this, all his saints "are a chosen generation, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, a peculiar people, that they should shew forth the praises of him that hath called them out of darkness into his marvellous light."

3. The praise of God is the highest and noblest work in itself.

1.) It has the highest object, the glorious excellencies of God himself. Thanksgiving is somewhat lower, as it has more respect to ourselves and the benefits we have received; but praise is directed immediately at the perfections of God himself.

2.) It is the work most immediately oriented toward God as our end. And as the end, considered as such, is better than all the means taken together, so the final duties that concern the end are greater than all the intermediate duties.

3.) It is the work of the most excellent of God’s creatures, the holy angels. They proclaimed the coming of Christ in praise: "Glory to God in the highest: on earth peace: good will towards men" (Luke 2:13–14 Ps 103:20 Ps 148:2). And since we are to be equal to the angels, it must be in equally praising God, otherwise our equality will not extend to equality of glory.

4.) It is the work of heaven, the place and state of all perfection; and that is best and highest which is nearest heaven. There "they rest not day nor night, saying, Holy, Holy, Holy, Lord God Almighty, which was, and is, and is to come." "Thou art worthy O Lord to receive glory, and honour, and power, for thou hast created all things, and for thy pleasure they are and were created." "A voice came out of the throne, saying, Praise our God, all ye his servants, and ye that fear him, both small and great. And I heard as it were the voice of a great multitude, and as the voice of many waters, and as the voice of mighty thunderings, saying, Alleluiah: for the Lord God omnipotent reigneth. Let us be glad and rejoice, and give honour unto him: for the marriage of the Lamb is come, and his wife hath made herself ready" (Rev 4:8, 10 Rev 19:5–6).

4. It is entirely fitting, and greatly concerns us, to learn and practice the very work we must perform in heaven forever, which is to love and joyfully praise the Lord. Earth is but the place of our apprenticeship for heaven. The preparatory works of mortifying repentance must be done in their proper place, but only as servants to this work, which we must do forever, when we shall sing the "new song" before "the Lamb, Thou art worthy," "For thou wast slain, and hast redeemed us to God by thy blood, out of every kindred, and tongue, and people, and nation, and hast made us kings and priests unto our God" (Rev 5:9–10).

Therefore the primitive church of believers is described as most like heaven: "with great joy they were continually in the temple, praising and blessing God" (Luke 24:53). "O praise the Lord therefore in the congregation of the saints: let Israel rejoice in him that made him: let the children of Zion be joyful in their king. Let the saints be joyful in glory: let the high praises of God be in their mouths" (Ps 149:1–2, 5–6).

5. Even though we are still diseased sinners, in the midst of our warfare, among enemies, dangers, and troubles, praise is seasonable and fitting to our condition here, it is the greatest part of our duty, to which everything else must be subordinate. Do not pretend that praise is unsuitable to you because you are sinners, and that humiliation alone befits your state. The design of your redemption, the nature of the Gospel, and your own condition all bind you to praise.

Are they not bound to praise the Lord who have been brought so near to him for that very end? who have been reconciled to him? to whom he has given and forgiven so much? who have so many great and precious promises? who are the temples of the Holy Spirit, who dwells in them and sanctifies them to God? who have a Christ interceding for them in the highest heaven? who are always safe in the arms of Christ? who are guarded by angels, while devils and enemies are forbidden to touch them beyond what their Father sees as necessary for their good? who have the Lord as their God? who have his saints as companions and helpers? who have so many ordinances to help their souls and so many creatures and comforts for their bodies? who live continually on the abundance of his love? who have received so much and are still receiving?

Should we not bless him every day with praise, who blesses us every day with benefits? Should we not praise the bridge we cross over, the friend we have tried so often? Let us resolve with the Psalmist: "Every day will I bless thee: I will praise thy name for ever and ever" (Ps 145:2). "Because thy loving kindness is better than life, my lips shall praise thee: thus will I bless thee while I live: I will lift up my hands in thy name" (Ps 63:3–4). Are they not bound to praise him on earth who shall reign with Christ forever in heaven? (Rom 8:17, 33 Rev 1:5–6 Col 1:12 1 Pet 1:4)

6. The praises of God exercise our highest graces. Praise is the very breath of love, joy, and gratitude; it tends to raise us above ourselves and make our hearts burn within us as the glorious name of God is magnified. It has the most pure, spiritual, and elevating effect upon the soul, and so tends most powerfully to make us holier by increasing those graces.

7. To be much employed in the praise of God tends greatly to vanquish all harmful doubts, fears, and sorrows. Joy and praise promote each other. This happens in six ways.

1.) By keeping the soul near to God and within the warmth of his love and goodness. (Ps 140:13)

2.) By the exercise of love and joy, which are the heartening, reviving, strengthening graces. (Ps 94:19 Ps 116:1)

3.) By dispersing distrustful and vexing thoughts, and turning the mind to sweeter things. (Ps 104:34)

4.) By holding off the tempter, who is usually least able to pursue us with his harassment when we are highest in the praises of our God.

5.) By bringing the evidences of our sincerity into the light, while the chief graces are in active exercise. (2 Cor 3:18)

6.) By way of reward from God, who loves the praises of even his humblest servants.

On this point I would commend an experiment to uncomfortable and troubled souls who have not found comfort by long searching within themselves for evidences of grace. Exercise yourselves much in the praises of God. This is a duty you have no excuse to avoid. Against thanksgiving for his grace, you may plead that you do not know whether you have received his grace; but to praise him for the excellency of his perfections, his power, wisdom, goodness, mercy, and truth, is the duty of every person in the world. While you are doing this, you will feel your graces stir, and feel a comfort from the face of God that you are unlikely to find by any other means.

Evidences are exceedingly useful for our ordinary settled peace and comfort, but it is often a long time before we can discern them with confidence; and even when we do discern them, the soul is not always moved to any strong sense of comfort and delight; and we quickly lose sight of evidences unless we are very wise and careful.

But a life of praise brings comfort to the soul as standing in sunshine brings light and warmth, or as labor warms the body, or as the sight and company of our dearest friend, or the hearing of good news, rejoices the heart, without any great reasoning or arguing the matter. This is the way to have comfort by direct experience: to be much engaged in the heartfelt praises of the Lord. When we come to heaven we shall have our joy by immediate vision and the delightful exercise of love and praise. If you would taste those heavenly joys on earth, you must imitate heaven as closely as you possibly can; and this is your nearest imitation of that work.

8. To live a life of praising God will make religion sweet and easy, take away its wearisomeness, and make the work of God a pleasure. Those who set themselves only to works of humiliation and leave out these soul-delighting exercises put themselves in great danger by making religion appear to them a grievous and unwelcome life. This makes people reluctant toward every duty, causing them to perform it halfheartedly, easily yielding to temptations of omission and neglect, and in the end perhaps falling away through weariness. The soul that is daily employed in the high and holy praises of its God, by contrast, is continually drawn forward by encouraging experience and does everything with a willing, ready mind.

9. No duty is more pleasing to God than the cheerful praises of his servants. He loves your prayers, tears, and groans, but your praises far more. And what pleases God most must be most pleasing to his servants, for to please him is their end, "whether present or absent," to "be accepted of him" (2 Cor 5:9). Praise is therefore a duty that both fulfills our final aim and delights the one who performs it.

10. To be much employed in the praises of God will acquaint the world with the nature of true religion, remove prejudice, refute dishonorable accusations against it, and recover the honor of Christ, his holy ways, and his servants. Many people are averse to a holy life because they imagine it consists of nothing but melancholy fears or anxious scruples. But who can open his mouth against the joyful praises of our Maker? I have heard and read of several enemies and would-be murderers who broke in upon Christians intending to kill them or carry them away, but finding them on their knees in prayer, and respecting the work so much that they stayed and listened until they had finished, they also came to respect the persons, departed, and did not dare touch those heavenly worshippers of God.

This life of praise is a continual pleasure to the soul, entirely contrary to a melancholy life. It refreshes the spirits and is healthful to the body, which is consumed by cares, fears, and sorrows. It is the way that yields the "mirth which doth good like a medicine," and the "continual feast" (Prov 17:22 Prov 15:15). The apostle accordingly says, "Is any merry, let him sing psalms" (Jas 5:13). One cannot better employ one’s cheerfulness than in singing praises to God. This keeps the soul continually reaching upward, desiring to be ever nearer to God so as to have more of these delights; and in this way it overcomes the sense of persecution and affliction, and the fear of death, serving as an excellent restorative and companion in the greatest sufferings.

Was it not a remarkable thing to witness the joy of Paul and Silas when, in prison and in stocks, their backs raw from scourging, they sang at midnight the praises of the Lord (Acts 16:25), so that all the doors were opened and all the prisoners’ bonds were loosed, those very prisoners having been their audience, so great was God’s acceptance of their work? May we do that honor and right to true religion as to show the world its nature and value by living in the cheerful praises of our God, and not teach the world to blaspheme it by our failures.

I have said so much about the excellence and benefits of this work because one of your best aids in performing it is to understand the reasons for it and to see how much of your religion, duty, and comfort consists in it. Forgetting this is the common reason it is so boldly and routinely neglected, or performed carelessly.

Direction 2. "Keeping the heart in wonder and glorifying of God, in the manner the foregoing Directions describe, is the chief help toward rightly praising him with our lips." For out of the heart’s abundance the mouth will speak; and if the heart does not bear its part, no praise is melodious to God.

Direction 3. "Read much in those Scriptures that speak of the praises of God, especially the Psalms; and fill your memory with a store of those holy expressions of God’s excellencies that he himself has taught you in his Word." None knows the things of God but the Spirit of God, who teaches us in Scripture to speak divinely of divine things. No other language so well befits the work of praise. God, who knows himself best, teaches us best how to know and praise him. Every Christian should have a treasury of these sacred materials in memory, so as to be able at all times, in conversation and in worship, to speak of God in the words of God.

Direction 4. "Be much engaged in singing psalms of praise, with the most heart-lifting cheerfulness and melody, especially in holy assemblies." The melody and the joining together of many serious and holy souls tends greatly to elevate the heart. Where it is done intelligibly and reverently, as part of a rational, spiritual, and serious worship, the use of musical instruments need not be questioned or refused, any more than the tunes or melody of the voice itself.

Direction 5. "Remember to give the praises of God their proper proportion in all your prayers." Do not shut praise out, forget it, or cut it short with two or three words at the close. The Lord’s Prayer begins and ends with praise, and its first three petitions are for the glorifying of God’s name, the coming of his kingdom, and the doing of his will, by which he is glorified, all of this before we ask anything directly for ourselves. Practice will help you greatly in the praise of God.

Direction 6. "Spend the Lord’s Day especially in praises and thanksgivings for the work of our redemption and its benefits." God himself has set this day apart for that holy work. If you ordinarily spend it in other religious duties that do not serve this end, you are not spending it as God requires. The thankful, praiseful commemoration of the work of human redemption is the day’s special work. The celebration of the sacrament of the body and blood of Christ, which is for this reason called the Eucharist, was part of these acts of praise, and was observed every Lord’s Day by the primitive church. It is not only a holy day set apart for God’s worship in general, but for this eucharistic worship in particular above all the rest, as a day of praise and thanksgiving to God. All Christians should ordinarily use it in this way.

Direction 7. "Let your holy conversation with others be largely about the glorious excellencies, works, and mercies of the Lord, by way of praise and wonder." This is truly to speak for edification, and as the "oracles of God" (Eph 4:29), "That God in all things may be glorified" (1 Pet 4:11). "In his temple doth every one speak of his glory" (Ps 29:9). "My tongue shall speak of thy righteousness, and of thy praises all the day long" (Ps 35:28). "And men shall speak of the might of thy terrible acts. They shall speak of the glory of thy kingdom, and talk of thy power: to make known to the sons of men his mighty acts, and the glorious majesty of his kingdom. My mouth shall speak of the praises of the Lord, and let all flesh bless his holy name for ever and ever" (Ps 145:6, 11, 21). "Talk ye of all his wondrous works: glory ye in his holy name" (Ps 105:2–3).

Direction 8. "Do not speak of God in a light, irreverent, or casual manner, as though you were talking about ordinary things; but speak with all possible seriousness, gravity, and reverence, as if you saw the majesty of the Lord." Common speech and holy speech are opposites. Only that is holy which is set apart from common use for God. You speak profanely, however holy the subject matter may be, when you speak of God with the same careless levity you use for everyday things. Such speech dishonors God and harms hearers more than silence would, because it breeds contempt of God in them and teaches them to imitate you in shallow thoughts and words about the Almighty. By contrast, one who speaks reverently of God, as in his presence, will often impress hearers with more reverence for his majesty in a few words than an irreverent preacher conveys through the most polished sermons delivered in a casual or affected tone.

Whenever you speak of God, let your hearers perceive that your heart is possessed with his fear and love, and that you place more distance between God and man than between a king and the smallest worm. Likewise, when you speak of death or judgment, of heaven or hell, of holiness or sin, or of anything closely related to God, do so with the gravity and seriousness the subject demands.

Direction 9. "Do not speak of God or holy things so clumsily and foolishly that you tempt hearers to turn it into an occasion for scorn or laughter." In particular, understand how your abilities match the company you are in. Among the more ignorant, somewhat weak discourse may be tolerable and profitable, for they are most moved by what is said in their own idiom and manner. But among judicious or critical hearers, unskilled persons must be very sparing with their words, lest they cause harm while meaning to do good and make religion appear ridiculous.

We may rightly rejoice in the scorn we endure for Christ, and in scorn directed at his holy laws or the substance of our duty. But when people are mocked for speaking ridiculously and foolishly about holy things, they have little ground for comfort in any of that beyond their honest intentions; indeed, they should be humbled for having brought dishonor on the name of godliness. The tragedy is that few ignorant and weak persons have enough knowledge and humility to recognize their own ignorance and weakness. They suppose they are speaking as wisely as anyone, and are offended if their words are not treated with respect accordingly. Just as a minister should study and work to gain skill and ability to preach, because preaching is his work, so every Christian should study for the skill to speak with wisdom and fitting expression about holy things, because this is his work. Unsuitable words and conduct in a minister breed contempt rather than edification; the same is true in conversation.

Direction 10. "Whenever God’s holy name or word is blasphemed, used in levity or jest, or a holy life is mocked, or God is openly abused or dishonored, be ready to reprove it with gravity where you can; and where you cannot, at least make your detestation of it clearly known." Among those to whom you may speak freely, lay open the greatness of their sin. Or if you are unable to engage in lengthy or careful discourse, at least tell them what has been said: "Thou shalt not take the name of the Lord thy God in vain; for the Lord will not hold him guiltless that taketh his name in vain." Where speaking is unsuitable, as with some superiors, or is likely to do more harm than good, let your leaving the room, or your expression, or better still your tears, show your disapproval.

Directions for Glorifying God in Our Lives

 

Direction 1. "Our lives glorify God when they are such that his excellencies most appear in them, that is, when they are most divine and holy; when they are so ordered that the world can see that God is our chief concern, and that Holiness to the Lord is written upon all our faculties and affairs." As much of God as appears in our lives, so much are they truly worthy of reverence and raised above the level of fleshly, worldly lives. It is utterly shameful for a philosopher to teach otherwise than he lives (Paulus Scaliger). God alone is the real glory of every person and thing, and of every word and action of our lives. The natural conscience of the world, which, despite its tendency toward practical atheism, is compelled to acknowledge and reverence a Deity, will be compelled (even when it hates and persecutes) to reverence the appearance of God in his holy people.

Let it therefore appear:

1.) That God’s authority commands you above all the powers of the earth, and against all the power of fleshly lusts.

2.) That it is God’s glory and interest that you live for and pursue as your chief aim in the world, not your own carnal interest and glory, and that it is his work you are doing, not your own, and his cause, not your own, that you are engaged in. What we tell people about the kingdom of heaven and about contempt for present things, they either do not grasp or are not easily persuaded of, when our words are overthrown by our deeds (Acosta, book 4, ch. 18).

3.) That it is his word and law that serves as your rule.

4.) That the example of his Son is your pattern.

5.) That your hearts and lives are moved and directed in the world by motives drawn from the rewards he has promised and the punishments he has threatened in the world to come.

6.) That it is a supernatural and powerful principle, sent from God into your hearts, even the Holy Spirit, by which you are inclined and moved in the course of your lives.

7.) That your daily dealings are with God, and that other people and creatures are comparatively nothing to you, but are made to stand aside while God is preferred, honored, and served by you, so that all your business in the world is with him or for him.

Direction 2. "The more of heaven that appears in your lives, the more your lives glorify God." Worldly and carnal people are inwardly aware that their glory is a fading glory, their pleasure but a passing dream, and that all their honor and wealth will shortly leave them in the dust. Even against their own sensuality, they are therefore compelled to bear some reverence toward the life to come. And though they do not have the heart to deny themselves the pleasures and profits of the world, to spend their days preparing for eternity, and to lay up treasure in heaven, they are convinced that those who do so are the best and wisest of people. They could wish they might die the death of the righteous, and that their last end might be like his.

As heaven exceeds earth even in the respectful acknowledgment of the world, though not in their practical esteem or deliberate choice, so heavenly Christians receive a respectful acknowledgment from the world (when malice does not conceal their heavenliness through slanders), even though the world will not be heavenly themselves. Let it appear in your lives that you genuinely seek a higher happiness than this world offers, that you truly look to live with Christ, and that as honor, wealth, and pleasure direct the lives of the ungodly, so the hope of heaven directs yours. Let it appear that this is your design and business in the world, that your hearts and conduct are set on things above, and that whatever you do or suffer is for this end and no lower one. This is a life by which God is glorified.

Direction 3. "It glorifies God by displaying the excellence of faith when we hold the riches and honors of the world in contempt, live above the worldling’s life, and account as despicable what he accounts his happiness and loses his soul for." Just as adults despise children’s toys, a believer must regard the transitory vanities of this world as so insignificant that they are not worth attending to, except insofar as they are the material of duty to God, or relate to him or to the life to come. As Paul says, "We look not at the things which are seen," they are not worth observing, "but at the things which are not seen: for the things which are seen are temporal, but the things which are not seen are eternal" (2 Cor 4:18).

The world lies beneath a believer’s feet while his eye is fixed on the celestial world. He travels through it toward his home, and he is thankful if the road is fair and he has his daily bread; but it is not his home, and he makes no great matter of whether his treatment in it is kind or unkind, or whether his lodging is well-furnished or not. He is nearly indifferent whether, for so short a time, he is rich or poor, in a high or low condition, except insofar as it bears on his Master’s service.

Let people see that you have a higher birth than they do, higher hopes, and higher hearts, by setting little store by what others count their greatest happiness. When professing Christians are as worldly and ambitious as everyone else, and make as much of their gain, wealth, and honor, they show only that they are covering the base and sordid spirit of worldlings with the mask of the Christian name, deceiving themselves, bringing the faith into scorn, and dishonoring the holy name they claim.

Direction 4. "It greatly honors God when his servants can quietly and fearlessly trust in him in the face of every danger and threat that devils or men cast before them, and can joyfully suffer pain or death in obedience to his commands, relying on his promise of everlasting happiness." This shows that we truly believe "there is a God," and that "he is the rewarder of them that diligently seek him" (Heb 11:6); that he is true and just and his promises are to be trusted; that he is able to fulfill them despite all the malice of his enemies; and that the threats and frowns of sinful mortals are contemptible to one who fears God. "So that men shall say, Verily there is a reward for the righteous: verily there is a God that judgeth in the earth" (Ps 58:11), and who at last will judge the world in righteousness.

Paul gloried in the Thessalonians "for their faith and patience in all their persecutions and tribulations which they endured; as a manifest token of the righteous judgment of God, that they might be accounted worthy of the kingdom of God, for which they suffered: seeing it is a righteous thing with God to recompense tribulation to them that trouble us, and rest with his saints to those that are troubled" (2 Thess 1:4–7). "If ye be reproached for the name of Christ, happy are ye; for the Spirit of glory, and of God, resteth upon you; on their part he is evil spoken of, but on your part he is glorified" (1 Pet 4:14). "If any man suffer as a Christian, let him not be ashamed; but let him glorify God on this behalf" (1 Pet 4:16).

When confidence in God and assurance of the "great reward in heaven" (Matt 5:11–12) cause a believer to say undauntedly, as the three witnesses said, "We are not careful, O king, to answer thee in this matter: the God whom we serve is able to deliver us" (Dan 3:16–17), when by faith we can go through the trial of mockings and scourgings, bonds and imprisonment, destitution and affliction, and even torture, refusing deliverance on sinful terms, God is glorified by believers.

"Lift up your voices," O afflicted saints, "and sing, for the majesty of the Lord. Glorify ye the Lord in the fires, even the name of the Lord God of Israel in the isles of the sea" (Isa 24:14–15). Sing his praise with Paul and Silas even with your feet in the stocks. If God calls for your lives, remember that "you are not your own: you are bought with a price: therefore glorify God in your bodies and spirits which are his" (1 Cor 6:20). Rejoice if you "bear in your bodies the marks of the Lord Jesus" (Gal 6:17), and if you "always bear about in the body the dying of the Lord Jesus, that the life also of Jesus might be manifested in your bodies" (2 Cor 4:10). And "with all boldness" see that "Christ be magnified in your bodies, whether it be by life or death" (Phil 1:20). The person who thinks Christ is not to be trusted even unto death dishonors and reproaches Christ and faith itself.

Direction 5. "It greatly honors God when the hope of everlasting joy causes believers to live with far more genuine gladness than even the most prosperous worldlings." Not the worldling’s kind of doting mirth, expressed in vain sports, foolish talking, and unseemly jests, but the constant cheerfulness and gladness that befits heirs of glory. Let it appear to the world that you truly hope to live with Christ and to be equal with the angels. Does a dejected face, and a mournful, troubled, complaining life, express such hopes? Or does it rather tell people that your hopes are small, that God is a hard Master, and his service grievous? Do not dishonor him by excessive dejection; do not frighten and discourage sinners away from the pleasant service of the Lord.

Direction 6. "When Christians live in readiness to die, and can rejoice at the approach of death, and love and long for the day of judgment, when Christ shall vindicate them from the world’s slanders and pronounce them heirs of eternal joy, this is to the glory of God and of our profession." When death, which is the king of fears to others, appears disarmed and conquered to believers; when judgment, which is the terror of others, is their desire, this displays a triumphant faith and proves that godliness is not in vain. It must be something above nature that can make a man "desire to depart and be with Christ, as best of all," and "to be absent from the body and present with the Lord," and "to comfort one another" with the mention of the glorious coming of their Lord, and the day when he shall judge the world in righteousness (Phil 1:21 2 Cor 5:8 1 Thess 4:18 2 Thess 1:10).

Direction 7. "The humility, meekness, and patience of Christians greatly honor God and their holy faith; just as pride, passion, and impatience dishonor him." Let people see that the Spirit of God overthrows the devilish sin of pride and makes you like your Master, who humbled himself to take on our flesh, to submit to "the death of the cross," and to endure the contradiction and reproach of foolish sinners, who "made himself of no reputation," "endured the shame" of being derided, spat upon, and crucified (Phil 2:7–9 Heb 12:2), and stooped to wash the feet of his disciples. Boldness, self-assertion, insisting on your terms, and standing on your honor in the world, these do not honor God.

When you are as little children, as nothing in your own eyes, and seek not the honor that comes from people, but say, "Not to us, O Lord, not to us, but to thy name be the glory" (Ps 115:1); when you are content that your own honor decrease and be trodden into the dust so that his may increase and his name be magnified, this is the glorifying of God. Similarly, when you show the world that you are above the feeble passions of ordinary people, not insensible, but able to "be angry and sin not," to "give place to wrath," not to resist and "avenge yourselves" (Rom 12:19), and to be "meek and lowly in heart" (Matt 11:29), this honors him.

It will be clear that you possess the wisdom "from above" if you are "first pure, then peaceable, gentle, easy to be entreated, full of mercy and good fruits, without partiality, and hypocrisy" (Jas 3:17). "But if you have bitter envying and strife in your hearts, glory not, and lie not against the truth" as if this were the wisdom from above that glorifies God, for this "wisdom descendeth not from above, but is earthly, sensual, and devilish" (Jas 3:14–15). "A meek and quiet spirit is of great price in the sight of God" (1 Pet 3:4), an adornment commended to women by Scripture, and one that is attractive in everyone’s eyes.

Direction 8. "It honors God and your profession when you abound in love and in good works, loving the godly with a special love, but all people with enough love to make you earnestly desire their welfare; loving your enemies, bearing wrongs patiently, studying to do good to all and harm to none."

To abound in love is to be like God, who is Love itself (1 John 4:7, 11), and it shows that God dwells in us (1 John 4:12). "All men may know that we are Christ’s disciples, if we love one another" (John 13:35). This is the "new" and the "great commandment; the fulfilling of the law" (Rom 13:10 John 15:12, 17 John 13:34). You will be known as "children of your heavenly Father, if you love your enemies, and bless them that curse you, and pray for them that hate and persecute you, and despitefully use you" (Matt 5:44).

Do all the good you possibly can, if you would be like him who does good to the evil and whose mercies are over all his works. Show the world that you "are his workmanship, created to good works in Christ Jesus, which he hath ordained for you to walk in" (Eph 2:10). "Herein is your Father glorified, that ye bring forth much fruit" (John 15:8). "Let your light so shine before men, that they may see your good works, and glorify your Father which is in heaven" (Matt 5:16). "Honour God with thy substance, and with the first fruits of all thy increase" (Prov 3:9). "And those that honour him he will honour" (1 Sam 2:30), while barren, worldly hypocrites who honor God only with their lips and flattering words will be treated as those who genuinely dishonor him.

Direction 9. "The unity, concord, and peace of Christians glorify God and their profession; their divisions, contentions, and malicious persecutions of one another heinously dishonor him."

People respect a faith and practice when they see its adherents unanimously agree in it. The same people will despise both it and its adherents when they see them at each other’s throats, and hear a babel of confusion, one saying "This is the way," another saying "No, that is it"; one saying "Here is the true church and worship," another saying "No, it is there." This does not mean that one person or a few may fashion a shoe to fit their own foot and then declare, "All who will not dishonor God by discord must wear this shoe, think as I think and say as I say, or you are schismatics."

Rather, we must all agree in believing and obeying God, and "walking by the same rule so far as we have attained" (Phil 3:15–16). "The strong must bear the infirmities of the weak, and not please themselves; but every one of us please his neighbour for good to edification; and be likeminded one towards another, according to Christ Jesus, that we may with one mind, and one mouth glorify God: receiving one another, as Christ also received us to the glory of God" (Rom 15:1–2, 5–7).

Direction 10. "Justice, both in exchange and in distribution, both private and public, in dealings, in government, and in judgment, honors God and our profession in the eyes of all. We must do no wrong, but do to all people as we would have them do to us (Matt 7:12), so that no one defrauds or takes advantage of his brother in any matter; for the Lord is the avenger of all such things" (1 Thess 4:6).

A person’s word must be their bond. We must not lie to one another, nor equivocate or deal subtly and deceitfully, but in plainness and singleness of heart, and in simplicity and godly sincerity, conduct ourselves in the world. Those who perjure themselves and break their covenants, dissolving the bonds of human society and taking the name of God in vain, will find by his vengeance that he does not hold them guiltless.

Direction 11. "It greatly glorifies God to worship him rationally and purely, in spirit and in truth, in accordance with the glory of his wisdom and goodness. It dishonors him to be worshipped ignorantly and carnally, with hollow formulas and irrational mimicry, as though he were less wise than serious, grave, and thoughtful people."

Those who worship God have great cause to take heed how they conduct themselves, lest they meet with the fate of Nadab and Abihu, and God declare by his judgments "that he will be sanctified in all them that come nigh him, and before all the people he will be glorified" (Lev 10:1–3). The second commandment is enforced by God’s jealousy concerning his worship. Ignorant, rude, or unseemly words, or unbecoming gestures that tend to raise contempt in hearers, or levity of speech that makes people laugh, are abominable in a preacher of the Gospel. So too is it abominable to pray irrationally, incoherently, and confusedly, with vain repetitions and empty redundancies, as though men thought they would be heard for babbling through so many words, with not even the appearance of a well-composed, serious, rational, and reverent address of a fervent soul to God.

To worship God after the manner of the Papists, with images, Agnus Deis, crucifixes, crossings, spittle, oil, candles, holy water, kissing the pax, counting beads, praying to the Virgin Mary and to other saints, repeating the name of Jesus nine times in a breath and certain sentences a set number of times, praying to God in an unknown tongue and saying to him they know not what, adoring the consecrated bread as no longer bread but the very flesh of Christ himself, choosing a patron saint whose name they will invoke, fasting by feasting on fish instead of flesh, saying so many masses a day and offering sacrifice for the living and the dead, praying for souls in purgatory, purchasing indulgences for their release from purgatory from the pope, carrying the supposed bones or other relics of their saints, the pope’s occasional canonizing of new saints, claims of miracles to deceive the people, pilgrimages to images, shrines, or relics, and offerings before images, together with a multitude of other such devotional practices, most heinously dishonors God.

As the apostle truly says, such things make unbelievers say "They are mad" (1 Cor 14:23), and that they are "children in understanding, and not men" (1 Cor 14:20).

Indeed, this appears to be one of the greatest obstacles to the conversion of the heathen and Mahometan world, and the chief means of confirming them in their unbelief and making them hate and scorn Christianity, that the Romish, and the Eastern, and Southern churches, within their sight, worship God so dishonorably, as if God were like a small child who must be pleased with pretty toys brought home from the fair. If, by contrast, the unreformed churches of the East, West, and South were reformed; if they had a learned, devout, capable ministry that clearly preached and seriously applied the word of God, and worshipped God with understanding, gravity, reverence, and genuine spirituality, and lived a holy, heavenly, self-denying life, this would be the way to spread Christianity and win the unbelieving world to Christ.

Direction 12. "If you would glorify God in your lives, you must rise above a selfish, private, and narrow mind, and be chiefly intent on the public good and the spreading of the Gospel throughout the world."

A selfish, private, and narrow soul brings little honor to the cause of God. It is always occupied with itself, or imprisoned in a corner and in the dark, captive to the interests of some sect or party, unable to see how things stand in the world. Its desires, prayers, and efforts reach no further than it can see or travel. But a larger soul surveys the whole earth and longs to know how it goes with the cause and servants of the Lord, how the Gospel gains ground among unbelieving nations, and such a soul is moved by the state of the church a thousand miles away almost as if it were next door, knowing itself to be a member of the whole body of Christ and not merely of a sect.

Such people pray for "the hallowing of God’s name," the "coming of his kingdom," and the "doing of his will throughout the earth, as it is in heaven," before they come to their own needs, at least in the order of their esteem and desire. The prosperity of themselves, their party, or their country does not satisfy them while the church abroad is in distress.

They live as people who know that God’s honor is more bound up in the welfare of the whole than in the success of any one party against the rest. They pray that the Gospel may have free course and be glorified abroad as it is among them, and that its preachers may be "delivered from unreasonable and wicked men" (2 Thess 3:1–2). The silencing of ministers and the suppression of the interests of Christ and souls are the most grievous news to them. Therefore they "pray for kings, and all in authority," not for any worldly ends, but "that we may lead a quiet and peaceable life in all godliness and honesty" (1 Tim 2:1–3). In this way God must be glorified by our lives.

CHAPTER 38

GRAND DIRECTION 16: LET YOUR LIFE ON EARTH BE A CONVERSATION IN HEAVEN

 

‘Let your life on earth be a conversation in heaven, by the constant work of faith and love: even such a faith as maketh things future as now present, and the unseen world as if it were continually open to your sight: and such a love as makes you long to see the glorious face of God, and the glory of your dear Redeemer, and to be taken up with blessed spirits in his perfect, endless love and praise.’

My treatise The Life of Faith, and the fourth part of The Saints’ Rest, were written wholly or mostly to this purpose. I must refer the reader to them and say no more on this Direction.

CHAPTER 39

GRAND DIRECTION 17: DENY YOURSELF, THAT THE SOUL MAY BE DELIVERED FROM ITS ENEMIES

 

‘As the soul must be carried up to God and devoted to him according to all the foregoing Directions, so must it be delivered from carnal selfishness, or flesh-pleasing, which is the great enemy to God and godliness in the world, and from the three great branches of this idolatry: the love of sensual pleasures, the love of worldly wealth, and the proud desire and love of worldly honor and esteem. The mortifying of these must occupy much of the labor of your lives.’

On this subject I have written so much in a Treatise of Self-denial and in another called The Crucifying of the World by the Cross of Christ that I shall now pass over all of it here, reserving what is seasonable for the more particular Directions in the Fourth Part, when I come to speak of selfishness as it is opposed to the love of others.

I have now given you the General Grand Directions, which contain the very being and life of godliness and Christianity, together with the particular sub-directions necessary for carrying them out. You must understand that your life, strength, and comfort depend chiefly on these, and so does your success in resisting all your particular sins. If you do not first obey these General Directions, the more particular ones that follow will be almost useless to you, like branches cut off from the trunk of a tree, stripped of their support and life. On the assumption, however, that you will maintain these vital parts of your religion, I shall proceed to direct you: first in certain particulars most closely subordinate to the duties already mentioned, and then in the more remote branches.

CHAPTER 40

APPENDIX: THE TRUE DOCTRINE OF LOVE TO GOD, TO HOLINESS, TO OURSELVES, AND TO OTHERS

 

I do not pass over this subject as a small matter, and I ask the reader not to pass it over either. I take the love of God, kindled by faith in Christ and accompanied by the full denial of our carnal selves, to be the sum of all religion. Yet because I would not do so great a duty an injustice by treating it too briefly, I urge the reader who studies for practice and needs such help to work through the books I have already mentioned, Self-Denial and Crucifying the World.

These questions principally belong to the theoretical domain, and so to another treatise in preparation called Methodus Theologiae. Yet because they are also practical, and bear greatly on the more practical directions in this work, and because understanding them rightly may help the reader resolve a multitude of cases of conscience, the individual discussion of which would swell this already large volume too much, I will set them out here in brief propositions. These propositions will shed light on one another, and I trust they contain much of the true nature of love, which is the mystery of the Christian religion.

The questions addressed are these: What self-love is lawful, and what sinful? Must God be loved above our own happiness, and if so, how? Can loving our own happiness more than God be consistent with a state of saving grace? Is there a middle state between sensuality and the divine nature, in which we love God more for our own sake than for his own? Is loving God for our own sake the state of a believer as one who is under the promise of the New Covenant? Are the Spirit and sanctification promised to believers the love of God for himself, that is, the divine nature promised to the one who chooses Christ and God through him out of self-love for personal happiness? How does God work upon and presuppose the principle of self-love in man’s conversion? These and many similar questions the following propositions address, so as to avoid the tedium of debating each one separately.

1. The formal act of love is complacency, expressed by the term "it pleases," which Augustine so often calls Delectation.

2. Benevolence, or desiring the good of those we love, is only a secondary act of love, or an effect of the primary, formal act. To wish someone well is not, strictly speaking, to love him formally; rather, we wish him well because we love him, and so love comes first in order.

3. The definition of love as "to wish someone well, so that it may go well with him" is therefore inept, being derived only from an effect of love, not from its essence.

4. Love is either merely sensitive and passionate, the perceptible act and passion of the sensitive and imaginative appetite, or it is rational, which is the act of the rational appetite or will. Sensitive love is called sensitive in two respects: first, because it follows the apprehension of the senses or imagination, loving what they present as good; and second, because it is exercised passionately and feelingly through the sensitive appetite. Rational love is called rational: first, because it is the love of what reason presents as good; and second, because it is the complacency of a will that is a higher faculty than the sensitive appetite.

5. Sensitive love often exists without rational love (always so in animals), but rational love is never entirely without sensitive love, at least in this life, whether because the sensitive and rational are faculties of the same soul, or because they are so closely connected that one cannot move or act without the other.

6. Yet one is predominant in some persons and the other in others.

7. Love is the complacency of the appetite in apprehended good. Good is the formal object of love. Sensitive love is the complacency of the sensitive appetite in sensible good, that is, in what sense and imagination present as good. Rational love is the complacency of the rational appetite in what reason presents as good; and this is the same thing as primary volition.

8. Good is not only a person’s own happiness and the means toward it, what may be called "good to me," whether as profitable, pleasant, or honorable (as some suppose who have, in thinking so, diminished their own humanity). There is also extrinsic good: that which is good in itself, in others, or for others, and which is nonetheless the natural object of human love, so far as human nature remains sound. The learning, wisdom, justice, charity, and all other perfections of a person at the other end of the world, whom I have never seen and never expect to see or receive any benefit from, are yet worthy of love to every person who has not lost their full humanity. So too is the good of posterity, of nations, of kingdoms, of the church, of the world, apprehended as future when we are dead and gone, and even if we were to be annihilated, desirable to us, and therefore worthy of our love, even though it could be no benefit to us at all.

9. Self-love is either sensitive or rational. Sensitive self-love as such is necessary and not free; it has been purposely implanted by the most wise and blessed Creator in both human beings and animals as a principle useful for preserving the world, for engaging creatures in the use of the means of their own preservation and thereby bringing them to their proper end, and for giving them those fears and hopes that make them capable of moral government.

10. The rational or higher appetite also has a natural inclination toward self-preservation, self-perfection, and happiness; but this inclination is ordered, and orderable, to higher ends.

11. The rational powers cannot nullify the sensitive ones, nor directly or entirely prevent their action. But they may and must indirectly restrain those actions, by avoiding objects and temptations, by turning the thoughts to higher things, and so on, and may govern the effects by directing the power of movement.

12. Sensitive self-love contains within it: first, a love of life, and with it a love of individual self-existence; second, a love of all the sensitive pleasures of life; and third, consequently, a love of the means of life and pleasure.

13. In sensitive self-love, therefore, the self, that is, life, is both the material and the formal object: we love ourselves simply because we are ourselves; we love this individual person and recoil from annihilation or dissolution.

14. Although the will and the higher faculties are naturally inclined to love ourselves and our own happiness, they exercise this inclination with a certain freedom. The act of simple complacency or volition toward our own being and happiness may be free and yet necessary; but the comparative act, by which, comparing several goods, we choose one and refuse another, may be free in a way that is not necessary. That is, a person may will their own annihilation rather than some greater evil, not as something good in itself and therefore willed for its own sake, but as a means to a greater good; and so a person may resist annihilation less strongly than a greater evil.

15. Similarly, a tolerable pain may on the same account be willed, or less resisted, and so consented to in order to avoid a greater evil. But intolerable pain cannot possibly be willed, consented to, or left unresisted, because it removes the exercise of reason and free will. What counts as intolerable I do not determine here, since it is variously measurable according to the strength of the person enduring it.

16. The soul as an intellectual being, through its rational appetite, also has a natural inclination to intellectual operations, to knowing and loving, and to intellectual objects as such, and to intellectual perfections within itself. Yet although it necessarily (though freely) loves those acts and perfections as long as it has being, it does not necessarily love every such object, nor does it necessarily choose the continuation of its own being; rather, in some cases as described above, it can yield or consent to annihilation as a lesser evil.

17. The rational soul, not being from itself nor existing for itself alone or chiefly, is naturally inclined not only to love itself and what is for itself, but also to love extrinsic good, as was noted above. Accordingly, it ought to love most what is best. The argumentative principle holds: if something is good and that goodness is the formal reason for loving it, the principle extends to all that is good and to every degree of goodness. If we must love anything or anyone because it is good, then we should love all that is good, and love most what is best, if we perceive it as such.

18. Although I must love greater, simple, extrinsic good above myself with a love that is purely rational, this cannot ordinarily be done with a more intense sensitive and passionate love.

19. I am not always obligated to do the most good to the person I love more than others and ought so to love, nor to the person to whom I must wish the most good. This is because there are other particular laws that regulate my actions, distinct from the law that governs my affections, laws that place children, family members, households, and neighbors under my especial charge and care, even though at times others must be more loved.

20. The good that is the object of love is not a mere universal or general notion, but is always some particular or singular being, whether in real existence or in cognition. There is nothing in the nature of things that is "good" in a purely general sense, detached from natural existence, moral perfection, pleasure, profit, honor, and the like, and not instantiated in some singular subject or conceived as such. Likewise, there is no such thing as love without some singular object. (As Rada and other Scotists have made plain.)

21. All good is either God, or a creature, or a creature’s act or work.

22. God is Good infinitely, eternally, primitively, independently, immutably, and communicatively, of whom, and by whom, and to whom are all things: the first efficient beginning, the directing and ultimate cause of all created good, making and directing all things for himself.

23. It is therefore the duty of every rational creature to love God completely, without exception or restriction, with all power, mind, and will, not only in degree above ourselves and all the world, but also as God, with a love in kind that transcends the love of every creature.

24. All the goodness of the creature formally consists in its threefold relation to God:

1.) In the impressions God has left upon it as its first efficient cause or creator, in that it is his image, the effect and demonstration of his perfections, namely his infinite power, wisdom, and goodness.

2.) In its conformity to his directions and governing laws, and so in its order and obedience.

3.) In its fitness for and tendency toward God as its final cause, toward the demonstration of his glory and the satisfaction of his will.

25. All created good is therefore derivative, dependent, contingent, finite, and secondary, from God, by God, and to God, receiving its form and measure from its relation to him.

26. Yet insofar as created good may be subordinately from man, as the principle of his own actions, and by man, as a subordinate ruler of himself or others, and to man, as a subordinate end, there is accordingly a subordinate kind of goodness denominated from these relations to the creature who is himself good in a subordinate sense.

27. But all this subordinate goodness, good from us, good through us, good to us, is only analogically good, and is dependent on the primary goodness described above. Taken in due subordination to that primary goodness it is something real; taken against it, it is nothing, that is, not properly good at all.

28. The best and most excellent creatures, in the goodness described above as relating to God, are most to be loved, each according to the degree of their goodness, more than according to their goodness in relation to ourselves.

29. But since their goodness is formally their relation to God, it follows that they are loved primarily only for his sake. Consequently, God’s image or glory in them is loved first, and so the true love of any creature is but a secondary form of the love of God.

30. The best being next to God is the universe or whole creation, and therefore next to him it is most to be loved by us.

31. Next in loveliness is the whole celestial society, Christ, angels, and saints.

32. Next, when we come to distinguish among them, is Christ’s own created and glorified nature in the person of the Mediator, because God’s glory or image rests most fully upon him.

33. Next in loveliness is the whole angelic society, or the orders of intellectual spirits above man.

34. Next are the spirits of the just made perfect, or the triumphant church of saints in heaven.

35. Next is all this lower world.

36. Next is the church in the world, or the church militant on earth.

37. Next are the particular kingdoms and societies of the world, and likewise the particular churches, according to their various degrees.

38. Below societies and multitudes come those individual persons who are best in the three respects described above, whether ourselves or others. In this way, by the nature of their objects, our rational love should be differentiated in degree, and what is best should be loved most.

39. The image of God in man that calls forth our love consists, as has often been said, of three parts:

1.) Our natural image of God, or the image of his three essential properties as such: our vital active power, our intellect, and our will.

2.) Our moral image, or the image of those same properties in their perfections: our holiness, that is, our holy life or spiritual vitality and active power; our holy light or wisdom; our holy will or love.

3.) Our relative image of God, or the image of his supereminence, dominion, and majesty, which belongs:

a) In common to all men with respect to the lower creatures, in that we are their owners, governors, end, and benefactors;

b) Eminently to rulers of men, parents, and princes, who are analogically sub-owners, sub-rulers, and sub-benefactors to those beneath them, in various degrees.

From this it can be discerned what it is we are to love in man, and with what variety of kinds and degrees of love, as the kinds and degrees of loveliness in the objects differ.

40. Even the sun, the moon, and the whole frame of nature, inanimate things and animals, must be loved in proportion to one another and to man, as the impressions of the divine perfections appear more or less gloriously in them, and as they are fitted for God as the ultimate end.

41. As God is in this life seen only dimly and as in a glass, so he is proportionally to be loved, for our love cannot exceed our knowledge.

42. Yet it does not follow that we must love him only as he appears in his works, which demonstrate him as effects demonstrate their cause. For both by those works, refined by reason, and by his Word, we know that he exists prior to and above his works, and is so distinct from them as to transcend, comprehend, and sustain them all by a continual causality. He must therefore be loved accordingly.

43. Our love to God is greatly hindered when we overlook all the intermediate excellencies between him and us, excellencies, such as those listed above, that are far better and therefore more lovely than ourselves.

44. The love of the universe, as bearing the liveliest image or impression of its cause, is an eminent secondary love of God and a great aid to our primary or immediate love of him. Could we take in the glorious excellency of the universal creation, in its matter, form, parts, order, and uses, we would see so glorious an image of God as would beyond all telling advance the work of love.

45. Whether the Glory of God in Heaven, which will forever make blessed those who behold and possess it, is the Divine Essence itself (which is everywhere), or a created glory purposely placed there for the happiness of holy spirits, and what that glory is, these are questions best resolved by those who will behold and possess it.

46. Yet if it were no more than the universal, existing frame of nature containing all God’s creatures, beheld in a single act of vision in the nature, order, and use of all its parts, it would be an inconceivable joy to the beholders, being an inconceivable and glorious demonstration of the Deity.

47. It is lawful and a necessary duty to labor, by means of the excellencies we now know and of the comparisons to which heaven is likened in Scripture, to imprint on our imaginations such an image of the glory of the heavenly society, Christ, angels, saints, and the heavenly place and state, as will assist our intellectual grasp of the spiritual excellencies that transcend imagination. Neglecting to love God as foreseen in the demonstration of heavenly glory greatly hinders our love of him considered immediately in himself.

48. The Lord Jesus Christ, in his glorified created nature, is crowned with the highest excellency of any particular creature, so that he might be the Mediator of our love to God, and that in him, seen by faith, we might behold the glory of the Deity. And as in heaven we shall have spiritual, glorified bodies as well as souls, so the glorified created nature of Christ will be an objective glory fitted, at least for our bodies, to behold for their own glory, just as the Divine nature, as it pleases God to reveal it in glory, will be the fitting object for the soul.

49. The exercise of our love upon God as he now appears to the glorified in the glorious created nature of Christ, beheld by us through faith, is a great part of our present exercise of divine love. We extinguish our love to God by beholding so little, through faith, our glorified Mediator.

50. We owe greater love to angels than to men, because they are better, nearer to God, more like him, and more fully demonstrate his glory; and they in fact love us better and do more for us than we can do for one another. Neglecting our due love and gratitude to angels, forgetting our relation to them and what we receive by them and our communion with them, and living as though we had little to do with them, all this is a culpable overlooking of God as he appears in his most noble creatures, a neglect of our love to God in them, and a great hindrance to the higher and more immediate love of him. We should therefore by faith and love maintain a daily fellowship with angels as part of our heavenly way of life, and accustom ourselves to love God in them, though not to pray to them or give them divine worship. (Phil 3:20–21 Heb 12:22)

51. We must love the glorified saints more than the inhabitants of this lower world, because they are far better, more like God, nearer to him, and more fully reveal his holiness and glory. Our neglect of conversing with them by faith, and of loving them above ourselves and earthly things, is a neglect of our love to God in them and a hindrance of our more immediate love. A loving fellowship with them by faith would greatly help our higher love to God.

52. Our neglect of love to the church on earth, and to the kingdoms and public societies of mankind, is a sinful neglect of our love to God in them, and a hindrance of our higher love to him. The true exercise of such public love would greatly advance that higher love.

53. If those heathens who laid down their lives for their countries had done so neither for fame, nor merely from valuing their country’s temporal good above their own lives, but from a genuine recognition of the worth of the many over the one and of God’s greater interest in them, they would have done a most noble and holy work.

54. Our clinging first to our carnal selves and then to our carnal interests and friends, while neglecting to love the highest excellencies in God’s servants and failing to love people in proportion to the measure of God’s image in them and their relation to him, is a great neglect of our love to God in them and a hindrance of our higher, more immediate love. Accustoming ourselves to love people as God appears in them would greatly promote that higher love. In this way we should love the best of people above ourselves.

55. Loving ourselves in a merely sensual way, preferring our present life and earthly pleasures over our higher spiritual happiness in heaven, and neglecting to love holiness, to seek it for ourselves, and then to love God in ourselves, is a neglect and hindrance of the love of God.

56. Humanity has not lost as much of the knowledge and love of God as he appears in his greatness, wisdom, and natural goodness in the frame of creation, as the Author of the creatures’ natural goodness, as it has lost the knowledge and love of his holiness as the Holy Ruler, Sanctifier, and End of souls.

57. The sensitive faculty and its interests remain dominant in a carnal or sensual person; his reason is voluntarily enslaved to his senses, so that even the intellectual appetite, contrary to its original and sound nature, chiefly loves the life of sensation and pleasure.

58. It is therefore exceedingly hard, in this depraved state of nature, to love God or anything more than ourselves, because we love more by sense than by reason, and reason is weak and serves the interest of sense.

59. Yet the same person who is predominantly sensual may still know that he has a rational, immortal soul; that knowledge and right moral order are his soul’s proper happiness; and that it is the knowledge, love, and delight in God, the highest good, that can make him perpetually happy. Insofar as these things are perceived as means to his own happiness, he may have some kind of love or inclination toward them all.

60. What every carnal person ultimately wants is an everlasting, perfect, sensual pleasure. He conceives the perfection of his soul as consisting chiefly in this kind of happiness, and even the knowledge and love of God, which he takes to be part of his happiness, is apprehended mainly as a speculative gratification of the imagination, in the way carnal people now desire knowledge generally. Even if he has a truer notion of God and holiness as things to be loved for themselves, loved ultimately above sensual pleasure and self, this remains an ineffective, half-dreaming knowledge that produces nothing more than a correspondingly idle wish. It does not prevail against the stronger love of sensuality and imaginary pleasure, nor against disordered self-love. The heaven the carnal person hopes for is, at bottom, a sensual heaven dressed in spiritual language.

61. Such a carnal person may love God as a means to this dreamed-of happiness, knowing that it cannot be had without him and tasting bodily comforts from him in this life. He may love holiness insofar as it removes its opposite calamities and is, as he believes, crowned with such a reward. But given the choice, he would rather have that reward without holiness.

62. He may also love and desire Christ as a means, as he conceives it, to such an end. He may engage in much religious duty toward that end and may refrain from sins that would jeopardize his hoped-for happiness. He may even endure much in order to avoid endless suffering.

63. Since nature necessarily loves self and self-happiness, both God and the devil make great use of this natural weight, this necessitating principle, for their respective ends. The devil says: you love pleasure, so take it and make provision for it. God says: you love happiness and fear misery; I and my love are the true happiness, and clinging to sensual pleasure deprives you of something far better, marks the beginning of your misery, and will bring you to something worse.

64. God commands nothing of humanity that is not for our own good, and forbids nothing that is not, directly or indirectly, to our harm. He therefore enlists self-love on his side in every act of our obedience.

65. Yet our own good is not the highest, nor the sum total, of the good God intends and we must intend. It is subordinate to the greater good already described.

66. Just as a carnal person may hold merely theoretical, ineffectual convictions that God and his love are his spiritual happiness, better than sensual happiness, and even that God is his ultimate end above his own happiness itself, so the sanctification of a person consists in bringing those convictions to be truly effectual and practical, renewing and governing the mind, will, and life.

67. Whether this is accomplished by first knowing God as the beginning and end above ourselves and then knowing, effectively, that he is humanity’s true happiness; or whether self-love is first stirred to love him as our own happiness and we are then carried upward to love him for himself as our highest end, it all amounts to the same thing when the work is done. We cannot prove that God binds himself always to either method exclusively. But experience tells us that the latter is the usual way, and that as nature does, so grace begins with the smallest seed and grows upward toward perfection. Self-love, the desire for endless happiness, and the fear of endless misery are the first notable effects or changes in a repenting soul.

68. The state of sin lies both in humanity’s fall from God to self and in the mistaking of our own true happiness, preferring, even for ourselves, a sensible good over a spiritual one and the creature over the Creator. We must therefore be set right in both respects.

69. The hypocrite’s ineffectual love for God and holiness is revealed in this: just as he loves deceased saints, their images, and holy days because they make no demands of him, so he loves, in opinion, and least resists, in practice, the saints in heaven, and a holiness far removed from him, and God conceived as one who is in heaven to glorify people. But he practically hates, though he would never profess it, the God who would make him holy, deprive him of his sinful pleasures, or condemn him for them. He can more readily admire holiness in his pastor, neighbor, or child than in himself.

70. Sincerity therefore consists greatly in the love of holiness in oneself, not for self alone, however, but as carrying self and all things to God.

71. Just as sunbeams reach the eye without obstruction, and by them our sight rises and extends, without obstruction, to the sun itself, so God’s communicated goodness and glorious revelation extend through and by all intermediate means to our understandings and our wills; and our knowledge and love ascend and extend through all, and by all again, to God. It would be unnatural for an eye illuminated by the sun to see only itself, or to see only the intermediate creatures and not the light and sun by which it sees, and indeed, it least sees itself. So it is unnatural for the soul to understand and love only itself, which it little understands and should love with self-denial, and to love only the creatures, without loving God, by whom we know and love the creature at all.

72. It is possible to love God, holiness, and heaven as a preferred state and means of escaping pain and attaining sensual happiness. But to love God as the true happiness of the rational nature and as our spiritual rest, and yet to love him only or chiefly for ourselves rather than for himself as our highest end, involves a contradiction. The same applies to holiness when loved only for ourselves. The proof is clear: it is essential to God not only to be better than ourselves and every creature, but to be the ultimate end of all things, toward which all things should tend in all their perfections. And it is essential to holiness to be the soul’s devotion of itself to God as God, not merely to God as our happiness. To love God only or chiefly for ourselves is therefore to make him a mere means to our happiness rather than our chief end; it is to make ourselves more excellent and so more worthy of love than God, that is, to make ourselves gods.

73. Much of the controversy between the Epicureans and the sober philosophers turns on this same point, as can be seen in Cicero and others. The sober philosophers held that virtue was to be loved for its own sake more than for the pleasure it brings, because if pleasure as such were better than virtue as such, then all sensual pleasure would be better than virtue. The Epicureans replied that the chief good was not pleasure in general but the pleasure of virtue, as Torquatus’s words in Cicero show.

Now, if it had first been established that a person’s self is the proper ultimate personal end, what the philosophers call the finis cui, the end for whom, then it would be a difficult question whether the Epicureans were not right about the finis cujus, the real end of pursuit, which on that assumption would be merely a means to the personal end. But since it is most certain that no person is to be his own personal end, but rather that God is that end, and after him the universe and the societies of the world as described earlier, it follows easily that the sober philosophers were right: no person’s pleasure is the ultimate end, the finis cujus. This is so because no one’s pleasure is either such a demonstration of the divine perfection as virtue is in itself, nor does it so much advance the common good of societies and of humanity, and through that, the pleasing and glorifying of God. By this line of argument Cicero could easily have made his case against the Epicureans.

74. Although no one truly loves God as God who does not love him as better than themselves, and therefore does not love him more, as the absolutely ultimate end, and although no one truly desires holiness who does not desire to be devoted absolutely to God before and above themselves, it is nonetheless very common to hold a false and incomplete notion of God and holiness, conceiving of them merely as human happiness, and while not explicitly denying it, simply omitting the essential attribute of divine supremacy.

It is even more common to acknowledge all this about God and holiness in theory, as was described earlier, yet in practice to take from God and holiness no more than the recognition that they are better for us than temporal pleasures. Some go further and embrace them as better than any sensual delight, even perpetual sensual delight, and so make the perfection of humanity’s highest faculties their practical ultimate end. They desire and love God and holiness, imperfectly and falsely understood, for themselves and their own happiness, rather than directing themselves, their happiness, and their holiness ultimately toward God. This shows that although such people have to some degree overcome sensual desire and the pull of the flesh, they have not sufficiently overcome self-centeredness, nor have they truly known and loved God as God, or the good as the good.

75. Yet it is not a sin to love God for ourselves and for our own happiness, provided we do not make him a mere means to that happiness as our absolutely ultimate end. For as God truly is: 1. the efficient cause of all our good; 2. the directing cause that leads us to it; and 3. the end in which our happiness truly consists, he is rightly to be loved on all these grounds.

76. If God were not to be loved in this way for our own sake, subordinately, under him, then gratitude would not be a Christian duty.

77. Our love for God is a love of friendship, a desire for a kind of union, communion, and adherence. Yet it is not like friendship between creatures, where there is some measure of equality; it is the love between those who are utterly unequal, the one infinitely below the other, and absolutely subject and subordinate to him.

78. Therefore, although in a love of friendship the union of both parties, and consequently the shared interest of both, not of one alone, constitutes the ultimate end of both, in this case it must obtain with complete disproportion. We are obliged to know God as infinitely better than ourselves and therefore to love him incomparably more, even though that love will always be proportioned to the capacities of the one loving.

79. The purest movement of love, then, proceeds as follows: first, to receive the divine gifts with gratitude, and to love God as the one who communicates all that we and all things are, have, and shall receive; and in doing so, to see his perfect goodness in himself and to love him as God for that goodness. In this there is nothing but the final act, which is our love, and the final object, which is the infinite good. The act belongs to humanity (though it comes from God), but nothing is to be joined with God as the absolutely final object, for that would be to set something alongside God as God.

80. And though it is entirely true that this act may itself become the object of another act, as Amesius says, "By universal human consent we say, ‘I will to will’", so we may and must say, "I love to love God." The very exercise of my own love is my delight, and in that sense my happiness in its essential nature, being a resting in the highest objective good. And this same love is my holiness, and so both it and I are pleasing to God. Yet all these are consequences of the proper understanding of the final act, and they lead back to it in a circle.

We must love our happiness and holiness, which consist in our love of God, but as things that relate to God subordinately: God is first glorified through them, and then finally pleased by them. And so from his will, which we delight to please, we ascend to his total, perfect being, to which we adhere through perfect love. In brief: our ultimate end of acquisition, and God’s own, so far as he may be said to have an end, is the pleasing of the divine will through his glorification. And our ultimate end of rest, objectively, is the infinite goodness of the divine will and nature.

81. There is therefore a proper place for the question, "Must I love God or myself more?", and it has a clear answer. But there is no place for the question, "Must I love God or myself?" because God never permits us to separate them (though there is a degree of just self-reproach and even self-hatred in deep repentance). Nor is there any place for the question, "Must I seek God’s glory and pleasure, or my own happiness?", for I must always seek both, though not with equal regard. Indeed, I may be said to seek both with the same diligence, because by the same effort and the same act by which I seek one, I seek the other. I cannot possibly do anything for one that does not equally advance the other, provided I act rightly, placing God before myself in my inward estimation, love, and intention.

82. Although it is essential to divine love, and consequently to true holiness, to love God for himself and as better than ourselves, for otherwise we do not love him as God, as has been shown, this is rarely and with great difficulty perceived in its early stages, even by the person who truly has it.

The reason is that love of self is more passionate, stirring up in us a range of subordinate emotions: fear of punishment, desire for happiness, grief over harm and misery, and so on. God, by contrast, being immaterial and invisible, is not in any way an object of the senses, but only of reason and will, and therefore not directly of sensitive or emotional love. Indirectly, however, while the soul is united to the body, its activity even upon immaterial objects does move the lower, sensitive faculties and the bodily spirits. Moreover, God is in need of nothing that we could desire on his behalf, and he suffers nothing that we could grieve over for his sake, though we must grieve for having injured him and for being displeasing to his will.

83. I cannot affirm, nor do I believe, however attractive the opinion may seem before it is examined, that the gospel faith which carries the promise of justification and of the Spirit is nothing more than believing in Christ as the means of our happiness through redemption and salvation, arising from self-love alone and directed to no higher end than that happiness. Such a view cannot be right, because Christ is not believed in as Christ unless he is received as a reconciler who brings us home to God. And we do not receive him as bringing us to God as God unless he is bringing us to God as the beginning and end of all things, and as infinitely more worthy of love than ourselves. The repentance for not having loved God accordingly, above ourselves, must accompany our first justifying faith.

Therefore, although we are learners before we are lovers, and intellectual assent comes before the will’s consent, yet our assent that God is God and better than ourselves must accompany our assent that Christ is the Mediator who saves us by bringing us to him. And our assent that this is salvation, namely, to love God above ourselves and as better than ourselves, must likewise accompany it. Our consent to all these particulars must therefore be present together in saving faith.

84. Therefore, whoever accepts Christ out of self-love as the means to their own happiness, if they truly understand what happiness is, accepts him as the means of being brought to love God perfectly, as God, above themselves, and to be perfectly pleasing to his will.

85. Yet it is plain that almost all of God’s preparatory grace consists in stirring and developing the natural principle of self-love in human beings, and in showing them that if they act as those who truly love themselves, they must become Christians, must forsake sin and the disordered love of their own senses, and must be holy, loving God both for his essential goodness and for his goodness as communicated to them. To do otherwise is to act as one who hates himself and is, in effect, seeking his own damnation. If we could only bring people to put genuine self-love to rational use, they would become Christians, and so become holy.

86. Because this is a weighty, though delicate, point, one I have touched on more generally in considering whether faith in Christ, or love to God as our end, comes first, and because it is in fact the chief reason I have prefaced these propositions with the others, I will venture a little further and state more precisely how much love to God is present in our first justifying faith, and how much is not.

I will also address how far the state of such a believer is a middle state between mere preparation or common grace on the one side, and proper sanctification or possession of the Holy Spirit on the other, and consequently, how far the calling that gives us first faith and repentance differs from sanctification. I do this the more willingly because my less mature thoughts and writings once defended Mr. Pemble, who identified these two things against the prevailing opinion of our divines. I am convinced that all the following acts concerning the point at issue are present in every true believer at their first faith, even if the believer does not distinctly recognize them.

1.) The sinner has an intellectual awareness that there is a God, for an atheist is not a believer, and therefore that this God is the first and the last, the highest of all beings, the Maker, Owner, Ruler, and Benefactor of the world, the rightful end of all created actions, and one who is to be loved and pleased above ourselves. For all of this is simply what it means to believe that there is a God.

2.) He is convinced that his own chief happiness lies not in temporal or bodily pleasure, but in perfectly knowing, loving, and pleasing this God above himself. If he does not know what true salvation and happiness are, he cannot desire or accept them.

3.) He knows that until now he has lived without this love and without this happiness.

4.) He desires to be happy and to escape everlasting misery.

5.) He repents, that is, he is sorry that all this time he has not loved God as God, nor sought his happiness there.

6.) He is willing and desirous that, from this point forward, he should love God as God, above himself, and please him before himself: that is, he desires to have a heart disposed to do so.

7.) He finds that he cannot do this by himself, nor with his old, carnal, and unprepared heart.

8.) He believes that Christ, through his teaching and Spirit, is the appointed Savior to bring him to that love.

9.) He gladly consents that Christ shall be such a Savior to him, not merely justifying him from guilt and delivering him from felt punishment, but also bringing him to the perfect love of God.

10.) He would rather Christ bring him to this through sanctification than enjoy all the pleasures of sin for a season, or even a perpetual sensory happiness without this perfect love to God and pleasing of him.

11.) Since God has been declared to him in Jesus Christ as a God of love who forgives sin and conditionally grants pardon and life even to his enemies, God is thereby more easily loved with gratitude on our own behalf. Beyond that, the goodness of God’s own nature in himself is here suggested and made known, with some quiet delight arising in the soul. Surely he is good who is so merciful, so ready to do good, and in a manner so wonderful as is revealed in Christ.

12.) So just as baptism, which is nothing other than explicit justifying faith, or its expression in covenanting with God, is our dedication by vow to all three Persons, to God the Father as well as to the Son and Holy Spirit, so faith itself is such a dedication of the heart.

13.) In this, I dedicate myself to God as God, to be glorified and pleased in my justification, sanctification, and glorification, that is, in my reception of the fruits of his love, and in my loving him above all as God; or, to put it another way, to be pleased in me and I in him for ever.

14.) Throughout all of this, the understanding acknowledges God to be God, by assent, and to be loved above myself; and the will desires to love him in that way. But the direct object of the will here is its own future disposition and act. It does not say, "I already love God as God, above myself," but only, "I would so love him, and I desire to be so changed as to dispose me to love him so; I acknowledge that I ought to love him so, and that I do love him for his mercies to myself and others."

Nor can it be said that a desire to love God, willing to will, willing to love, is itself direct love to God. This is because having God as the object of my will is not the same thing as having my own act of willing or loving as its object; and because a person may, for other ends, such as mere fear of hell, will to will or love something which he does not yet actually will or love for its own sake.

15.) In this matter above all others, it is clear that every conviction of the understanding does not correspondingly determine the will. In this new convert, the understanding says plainly, "God is to be loved as God, above myself," but the will says, "I cannot do it, though I would. I am so captivated by self-love, and so empty of true love for God, that I can say no more than this: for my own sake I wish to love God for his own sake. I love my own happiness so deeply that I love God as my happiness; I love him under the conception of God, the perfect good who is infinitely better than myself; and I desire a heart to love him more than myself. But I cannot say that I yet do so, or that I love most the one whom I acknowledge to be best and to deserve to be loved as such."

16.) Yet in all this, there is not only a seed of divine love to God as God, but the foundation of it laid, and some obscure, secret beginning of it forming in the soul. For when the understanding confesses God to be supremely worthy of love, and the will desires that happiness which consists in loving him above myself, and experience tells me that he is good to me, and therefore good in himself, it is difficult to conceive that all of this does not involve some kind of hidden love to God as better than myself.

87. Note, throughout all of this, that it is one thing to love God under the conception of the infinite good who is better than myself and all things, and another thing for the will to love him more as that conception properly requires.

88. The reason these are so often separated is that beyond a passing intellectual grasp, what is needed for the will to reach its proper determination is a clear and deep understanding, a rightly ordered disposition of the will, and the awakening of its active power.

89. Moreover, not every slight act of willing or velleity will overcome the opposition of desire and competing acts of will; nor is every act of will strong enough to govern the life and prevail against what opposes it.

90. Therefore, I conclude that in our first believing in Christ, even to the point of justification, although reason tells us that he is more worthy of love than ourselves, and we desire to love him as such in the future, and have an obscure, weak beginning of love to God as God or as so conceived, yet three things remain true.

1.) The strength of sensory self-love makes our love to ourselves more intensely passionate.

2.) Reason, at least in its degree of attention, is too absorbed in grasping our own self-interest and too slack in grasping the loveliness of God as God. So even our rational love is still greater toward ourselves, even though, at the level of our conceptions, God has the preeminence.

3.) Throughout this whole affair of our baptismal covenanting, consent, and Christian profession, our love to our own happiness as such is more powerful and effective in moving the soul and securing our resolution for a new life than is our love to God for his own sake and as God.

91. This is why fear plays such a large role in our first change: everything that such fear accomplishes, it accomplishes as moved by self-love, I mean the fear of suffering and damnation. Yet experience tells us that conversion commonly begins in fear. And though where self-love and fear exist alone, without love of God as good in and for himself, there is no true grace; yet I hold that there is genuine initial grace in those weak Christians who have more fear and self-love in their passionate and powerful part than love to God, provided they do not have a greater love to sin or to anything that stands in competition with God.

92. Therefore, the person who has a disordered self-love inclining him toward created things, a love stronger in him than love to God, is without grace, because it will turn his heart and life away from God. But the person who has only a necessary self-love, even a love for his own spiritual and eternal happiness, operating by strong desire and fear, joined with a weaker degree of love to God as good in himself, I think such a person has grace and may be saved. For here there is only an unequal motion toward the same end, not a competition between opposing ends.

93. If anyone dislikes this conclusion, I only ask them to remember that there are apparent dangers on both sides. On one side, it is dangerous to say that a person is in a state of grace and salvation who does not love God as God, that is, more than himself. On the other side, the experience of most Christians in the world shows that at their first believing, if not long afterward, they loved God more for their own sake than for his own, and loved themselves more than God, even while knowing that God was greater and more worthy of love; and that the fear of misery and the desire of their own salvation were more effective and prevailing with them than love of God for himself.

I fear that very few reach this higher love in so full a degree as to be clear and certain of it. And if we make a requirement for salvation out of something that few even of the best Christians find in themselves, we either condemn nearly all professing Christians or at least leave them in uncertainty and terror. Since God’s interest speaks so loudly on one hand and human experience on the other, we need to proceed with the greatest precision.

94. By this point we can see that, just as Christ is the way to the Father and the Savior who recovers fallen humanity from itself back to God, so faith in Christ as such is a mediate and medicinal grace and work. Faith is but the bellows of love. Our first believing in Christ, though it is the regenerating work that generates love, is a middle state between the unregenerate and the regenerate, not a third state specifically distinct from both, but as the beginning (the initial stage) of the latter; or as the embryo, the state of conception in the womb, stands somewhere between being and not yet being a man. Faith contains love in the process of its formation.

95. Just as love of ourselves most powerfully, though not solely, moves us to receive Christ as our Savior, so while we are by this means united to him, we receive a double assistance or influence from him for the production of a purer love of God. The first is objective, consisting in all the divine demonstrations of God’s love: his incarnation, life, death, and resurrection; his teaching, example, and intercession; and all his benefits given to us in our pardon, adoption, and the promises of future glory. The second is in the secret operations of the Holy Spirit, whom he gives us to work together with these means and make them all effectual.

96. The true state of sanctification, as distinct from mere calling and faith, consists in this pure love of God and holiness, love directed more toward God for himself and his infinite goodness than toward ourselves and our own felicity.

97. Therefore, when we are promised the Spirit to be given to us if we believe in Christ, and sanctification is promised together with justification on the condition of faith, this is part of the meaning of that promise: that if we truly receive Christ as our Savior to bring us to the love of God, even though at present we are most moved by love of ourselves to accept him, he will, by his Word, works, and Spirit, bring us to that love, initially here and perfectly in heaven. That is, he will bring us to be fully pleased in God for his own perfect goodness, and so to be fully pleasing to him. And in this way, apart from extraordinary gifts given to a few, the Spirit of holiness and love, who is the Spirit of adoption, is promised by covenant to all believers.

98. Accordingly, this promise is fulfilled in the following way: in the first moment we have a relative right to Christ as our head and the sender of the Spirit, and to the Holy Spirit himself as our Sanctifier by undertaking, according to the terms of the covenant. But this does not always produce a perceptible or effectual love of God above ourselves at the outset; rather, it comes by degrees as we pursue the work of faith in practice.

99. It is especially worth noting that the doctrinal and objective means of love that Christ employs, and his internal spiritual influence, work together. His way is not to work on us by his Spirit alone without those objects, nor by the objects without the Spirit, nor by both separately as though producing distinct effects; but by both working together for the same effect. The Spirit’s influence causes us effectively to make use of the objects and reasons of our love, as the hand that uses the seal and the seal itself together make one impression.

100. Just as Christ began to win our love toward God by stirring our self-love and multiplying and revealing God’s mercies to us personally, so he largely continues to increase that love by the same means. For as each day adds fresh experience of the greatness of God’s love to us, we thereby gain a certain taste that God is love and good in himself; and so by degrees we learn to love him more for himself, and to move our notional esteem of his essential goodness into something practical.

101. Although faith itself is not worked in us without the Holy Spirit, and is not, if sincere, a common gift, yet this operation of the Spirit drawing us to Christ by arguments and means fitted to the work of believing is distinct from the consequent covenant-right to Christ and the Spirit that is given to believers, and from the Spirit of adoption as recovering us, as described above, to the love of God.

102. In this last sense it is that the Holy Spirit is said to dwell in believers, and to be the new name, the pledge, the earnest, the first-fruits of eternal life, the witness of our right to Christ and life, and Christ’s agent and witness in us to maintain his cause and interest.

103. Consider the analogy of a man who, through sickness, has lost his appetite for food. He is told that a certain physician will cure him if he will take a particular medicinal food that the physician prescribes. At first he takes it without appetite for the food or medicine in itself, purely out of love for his health. But afterward he is brought to love it for itself in two ways: first, because he has now tasted the sweetness of what he previously only saw from a distance; and second, because his health and appetite have been restored. So it is with the soul and the love of God procured through believing: when we have tasted through the persuasion of self-love, that very taste and recovery cause us to love God for himself.

104. When the soul has risen to this habitual, predominant love of God and holiness as such, loving them for their own goodness, above one’s own felicity as such, though always in conjunction with it and as one’s own true felicity, then the law is written in the heart, and this love is the effective fulfillment of all the law. It is of such persons that it is said the law is not made; that is, to the degree that they love the good for itself, they need not be driven to it by threats or promises of external things, which work only through self-love and fear. This is not to say that divine authority need not accompany love in producing obedience, especially while love remains imperfect; but rather that love is the highest principle, making the good commanded by God become natural to us.

105. I believe that it is this Spirit of adoption and love which is called "the divine nature" in us, because it inclines us to love God and holiness for themselves, in the same way that nature is inclined to self-love, to food, and to other necessities. This does not mean that the specific essential nature, that is, the substance or form of the soul, is changed, or that a man is deified and becomes a god who was before a man. Rather, the human soul or nature is elevated and more fully perfected, as a sick man is perfected by health, or a blind man by sight, by the Spirit of God habitually inclining it toward God himself, as he is and for himself. (This is all that the publisher of Sir H. Vane’s notions of the two covenants and two natures can soundly mean, and seems to be groping toward.)

106. From all of this you can see that, just as the love of God has a double form of self-love to contend with, so it deals with each differently.

1.) Sensual, disordered self-love it destroys, both the inordinate love of sensual pleasure and the inordinate love of self and life.

2.) Lawful and just self-love it increases and improves for our further good, but subordinates it to the highest and purest love of God.

107. From this you can gather what a confirmed Christian is: one in whom the pure love of God as God, and of all things for God, is predominant and more powerful than, not only vicious love of self, but also, the good, lawful, and necessary love of oneself.

108. Though Christians must study themselves and maintain a care for their own salvation, they must far more diligently study God, his greatness, wisdom, and goodness as they shine in his works and Word, in his Son, and as they will be seen in heavenly glory. In this knowledge of God and Christ is eternal life. Nothing tends more to the holy advancement and perfection of the soul than to keep continually sound apprehensions of the divine nature, attributes, and glorious appearances in his works, apprehensions that rest upon the soul so that they become a constant course of contemplation, the settled habit and constitution of the mind, and the constant guide of heart and life.

109. To attain this would be a taste of heaven on earth. Our wills would follow the will of God and rest in it, and recoil from all resistance. All our duty would be both quickened and sweetened by love. Self-interest would be unable either to seduce us into sin or to torment us with griefs, cares, fears, or discontents. We would so fully entrust soul and body to the will and love of God that we would find more comfort in knowing that both are in his hands than if they were absolutely at our own disposal.

With God as our all, the constant, settled, and satisfying object of our love, our souls would be constantly fixed and satisfied. We would live in such experience of the sanctifying grace of Christ as would most powerfully conquer our unbelief, and in such foretastes of heaven as would make life sweet, death welcome, and heaven unspeakably desirable to us. But the mere love of personal goodness as our own perfection would not accomplish all of this in us.

110. The soul troubled by doubts about whether it loves God as God, or only as a means to its own happiness in subordination to self-love, must resolve those doubts in the following way.

If you truly believe that God is God, that is, the efficient, directing, and final cause; the just end of every rational agent; the Infinite Good, who is above all to be loved, in comparison with whom you are vile, contemptible, and as nothing, if you feel yourself as loathsome because of sin; if you would not accept an everlasting sensual pleasure alone, without holiness, even if you could have it; if you would not accept any perfection of your intellectual nature merely as such and for your own sake, without pleasing and glorifying God in it; if you practically perceive that everything is therefore, and to that extent, good and lovable as God shines in it as its cause, or as it conduces to glorifying him and pleasing his will.

If, accordingly, you love most that person in whom you perceive most of God and who is most serviceable to him, though of no benefit to yourself; if you love the welfare of the church, the nation, the world, and of the heavenly society, saints, angels, and Christ, as the divine nature, interest, image, and impression makes each lovely in their several degrees; if you would rather be annihilated, were the choice put to you, than that saints, angels, kingdoms, and church should be annihilated; if your heart has devoted itself, and all that you have, to God as his own, to be used in his utmost service; if your chief desire and endeavor in the world is to please his blessed will, and in that will and in the contemplation of his infinite perfections you seek your rest.

If you desire your own everlasting happiness in no other form than as consisting in the perfect sight of God’s glory, in your perfect love of him, and in being pleasing and beloved to him, resting more in the infinite loveliness of God himself than in the happiness that will follow to you, though that too must be desired; if you now deny your own glory for his glory; if your chief desire and endeavor is to love him more and more; if you love yourself best when you love him most; if, in a word, nothing takes up your care more than how to love God more; and if nothing in the whole world, yourself or others, appears more lovable to your sober, practical judgment and will than the infinite goodness of God as such.

If all of this is so, you have not only attained sincerity (which is not now the question), but this divine nature and this high, confirmed holiness. And this remains true even though you never cease to desire your own salvation, which is simply to desire more of this very love, and even though your nature retains a sensitive, self-centered desire for life and pleasure that has been brought into subjection to this divine love.

If anyone is offended that so many propositions are required to open the case, and says that they only confuse people’s minds rather than inform them, I answer:

1. The matter is elevated, and I could not ascend by a shorter ladder. Nor do I have the faculty of climbing it by leaps, stepping immediately from the lowest to the highest point. If anyone can make the case plainer in fewer words and with less effort, I will thankfully receive his work as a great benefit when I see it.

2. Either all these particulars are genuinely distinct and genuinely relevant to the matter in question, or they are not. If they are not, it is not the mere number of them that will prove this, but the naming of those particulars that are either unjustly or unnecessarily distinguished or included. And if the complaint is only that the same things are repeated, I will be glad if all these words, and more, would make such weighty matters clear. I confess that even after all of this I need more light, and I am myself almost stalled by the difficulties.

But if the particulars cannot be shown to be false or needless, and the reader is only overwhelmed by the number, I would ask him to be patient with others who are more diligent and more capable of knowledge. Let him understand that if his difficulties drive him to impatience and accusation rather than to diligent inquiry, I count him not only among the slothful who despise knowledge, but therefore also among its enemies, just as I count those who neglect, despise, and accuse piety among piety’s enemies.

Before I conclude, however, I must answer some objections.

Objection 1: Some will say, "Does not every man love God above himself and all others, when he knows God to be better and therefore more lovable? For there is some act of the will that corresponds to this understanding."

Answer: You must understand that the carnal mind is first captured by carnal self-interest and sensuality. Therefore, the most practical and powerful perceptions of goodness and loveliness in every such person fasten upon life and pleasure, or sensual prosperity. Because the senses have here engaged both mind and will, the contrary conclusions, that God is best, are merely superficial and ineffectual, like dreams. Although they produce some answering effects in the will, these are only feeble wishes, which are overwhelmed by far stronger desires pulling in the opposite direction.

So though God is loved as one notionally conceived to be best and most worthy of love, he is not loved best or most in practice. Indeed, though the understanding ordinarily says that God is best, best for me, and most to be loved, when it comes to actual choice, a hidden perception speaks more powerfully: "Here and now, this sensible pleasure is better for me and more to be chosen." Why else is it chosen? Unless you say that the motion is chiefly from sensual appetite, and that the force of that appetite suspends all effective opposition from the intellect and so governs the faculty of action itself. But whether the intellect is actively complicit or merely omissive in this, the sin reaches the same height of evil.

Whatever the mechanism, it is plain that while such men say God is most to be loved, they do not love him most, since they will not leave a lust or a known sin for his love, and their lives display not such love but the contrary.

Objection 2: "But do not all men practically love God best when they love wisdom, honesty, and goodness in all people, even in strangers who will never benefit them? And what is God but wisdom, goodness, and greatness themselves?"

Answer: They first make idols of themselves and their sensual pleasures, and then they love such wisdom, goodness, and greatness as suits their selfish, sensual desires and interests. What they love is not the supreme good standing above them and to be preferred over them, but goodness as it serves their fleshly desires and ends. For this reason, they do not love holiness. And though they love goodness even in those who will never benefit them, that is only because such goodness belongs to the same kind as the goodness found in those closer to them who may benefit them, and is thus agreeable to their minds and interests.

We do grant that the human mind retains certain principles of virtue and some traces and witnesses of a divine nature. But though these work up to a general approval of good and dislike of evil, and in particular cases where goodness does not conflict with their desires, they never rise to preferring the best things in practice over those desires. God is not loved best, nor loved as God, if he is not loved more than fleshly lust.

Objection 3: "It seems that most or all people love God practically best. For there are few if any who would not rather be annihilated than have no God or no world at all. Does this not show they love God more than themselves?"

Answer:

1.) They know that if there were no God and no world, they could not be themselves either, and so would also be annihilated.

2.) But suppose they would rather be annihilated than continue in prosperity alone, without a God, if that were possible, that preference is only for the world’s sake, because the world cannot be what it is without a God. This proves only that they are human enough to love the whole world more than themselves. If the world could somehow be what it is without a God, I scarcely believe they would choose annihilation rather than accept a Godless existence.

3.) But suppose they would choose annihilation over a Godless world. Even so, many sensual people love their lusts or pleasures more than their very being. They would rather be annihilated forever if they could spend their lives in pleasure, than live forever without those pleasures. They say a short life with pleasure is better than a long one without it. And when they profess to believe in the life to come and the danger of sinning, they still will not leave their sinful pleasures to save their souls. Therefore, a person who would rather be annihilated than live without God may yet love his lusts more than God, even if he does not love his lusts more than his existence.

4.) Moreover, I cannot say that everyone who loves God, under a false conception or image of him, more than himself will therefore be saved, any more than a disordered lover is saved by loving his mistress more than himself. God is not loved as God unless he is loved as infinitely great, wise, and good, which includes his holiness, and also as the Owner, holy Governor, and final End of humanity. If someone loves God under the notion that God favors him and will indulge his sins, or if he loves God only for his greatness and as the source of all natural, sensible good, but does not love him as holy or as a holy and just Governor and End, then it is not truly God that this person loves. Or he loves him only in a partial sense, and not as God.

Objection 4: "But suppose I loved God above all as he is simply great, wise, and good in producing all natural and sensible good, without the notion of holiness or hatred of sin. Would not that love itself be holy and saving?"

Answer: Your love would be no holier or better than your conception of its object. If you do not conceive of God as holy and pure, you cannot love him with a pure and holy love. If you conceive of him only as the cause of sun and moon, light and heat, life and health, food and drink, you will love him with the same kind of love you have for those things. Such love would not separate you from any sin as such, but would be fully consistent with a sensual heart and life. Not everything in God is what corrupted human nature hates or is in conflict with. But if you do not love him more than your lusts and pleasures, and do not love him as your most holy Governor and End, you do not love him as God, or you love him only in a partial sense. If, however, you love him in a holy way, you love him as holy.

Objection 5: "God himself loves the substance or person more than the holiness, for he continues the persons of both humans and devils even when he permits holiness to perish in them or does not grant it."

Answer: We must distinguish between existence and event on one side, and moral goodness on the other; and likewise between God’s mere willing of an outcome and his delight in good as good. God does not will that a reasonable soul exist in a stone or a piece of straw, yet it does not follow that he loves a stone better than reason in a human being. God wills to make his creatures various in degrees of goodness and regards such diversity as good, without requiring every creature to be of the highest kind.

Yet the goodness of things remains various: one has more excellence than another. The good of the whole may require that each part not be best in itself, while still being best in its proper relation to the beauty of the whole. A peg is not better than a post, yet it serves the building better in its own place; a finger is not better than a head, yet it serves the body better in its place than another head would. The head must therefore be comparatively more valued than the finger, and the finger may be cut off to save the life when the head must not be.

In the same way, God can see fit to permit both humans and devils to fall into misery, and permit thieves to be hanged, and use this for the beauty of the whole, while still loving a righteous person more than a thief, and a good person more than an evil one.

Either you speak of goodness or holiness that exists or of goodness that does not exist. In a devil there is substance, which is good in its natural kind and is so far loved by God. But there is no holiness in a devil, and what does not exist is not an object of love. If you mean existing holiness in a saint, then it is false that God loves the person of a devil more than the holiness of a saint. Nor does God’s equally willing the existence of both prove that he loves them equally, for he does not will them to be equal in goodness, though he equally wills their existence. And by love we mean delight, not mere willing of existence.

Otherwise your argument would be as strong as this: what God brings to pass rather than some other thing, he wills and loves more than that other thing; but God brings to pass people’s sickness, pain, death, and damnation, and not the holiness, ease, or salvation of those persons; therefore he loves their pain, death, and damnation more than their holiness, and therefore we should love pain, death, and damnation more than holiness, and devils or miserable people should love their misery more than holiness. God shows what he loves often by commanding it, even when he does not effect it. He loves holiness both as it is known to him and as it exists in his creatures, in each case as his own image.

Objection: "But at least it will follow that in the case of some particular persons, such as the devils, God loves their substance more than their holiness. For what he wills, he loves; but he wills their substance without their holiness; therefore he loves their substance without their holiness."

Answer: This is already answered above. Moreover:

1.) God willed that holiness should be the duty of all people and devils, even though he did not will absolutely and irresistibly to produce it in them.

2.) The word "without" can mean either exclusion or mere non-inclusion. God does not will the person excluding holiness, for he does not exclude holiness by will or by act. He simply wills the person without including holiness in any absolute act of will. In that sense, God loves the person without the holiness; but not as much as he would love that person were he holy.

Objection: "But you suggest that it is best for the beauty of the universe that there be sin, unholiness, and damnation; and God loves what is good for the universe, indeed, that is a higher good than personal good, since the universe as a whole is a nobler subject and therefore more to be loved, both by us and by God."

Answer:

1.) I know Augustine is often cited as saying that "it is good that evil occurs." But sin and punishment must be distinguished. It is true of punishment, presupposing sin, that it is good and fitting in respect to public ends, even though it is harmful to the person suffering. God wills punishment as good, and so we ought not only to endure it with patience but to accept it as right, insofar as it demonstrates God’s justice and holiness and is genuinely good, though not insofar as it is our harm. But sin, or privative unholiness, is not good in itself, nor good for the universe. It is not a true saying that "it is good that there be sin." Sin is not willed by God, though he does not suppress it by any absolute and effective act of rejection, as has been explained at length elsewhere. Sin is not good for the universe, nor any part of the creature’s beauty. God neither wills it, causes it, nor loves it.

Objection: "At least he has no great love for holiness in those persons to whom he never gives it; otherwise he would work it in them."

Answer: He cannot love as existent what does not exist. Nor does he will to give holiness to them beyond commanding it and providing all necessary means and persuasions toward it. But consider: if God makes only one sun, would you say he has no great love for a sun because he makes no more? If he makes no more worlds, does that prove he has no great love for a world? He loves the world, the sun, and likewise the saints, whom he has made. But he does not love suns, worlds, or saints to the degree of making as many as foolish minds would prescribe to him. Our question is what being God loves, and what we should most love as being best and most like him, not what he ought to bring into existence that does not yet exist.

Objection 6: "Holiness is only an accident, and the person is the substance, which is better than the accident. Dr. Twiss, on such grounds, opposes the saying of Arminius that God loves justice more than just men, because it is for justice’s sake that he loves them."

Answer: Aristotle and Porphyry have not made so clear to us the nature of those things or modes which they call accidents that we should place great weight on their classifications here. Another thinker might say that goodness itself is merely an accident, or a mode, as most would say, and that the substance is therefore better than goodness itself. Would that be sound reasoning? We must distinguish between the physical goodness of being, the soul considered both as a substance and as a formal essence, and the perfective, modal, qualitative, or gradual goodness. The latter always presupposes the former. Where there is holiness, there is the substance with its physical goodness and also the perfective, moral goodness; but where there is no holiness, there is only a substance deprived of its moral and modal goodness. Is not both better than one alone? Is not a complete being better than an incomplete one?

As for Arminius’s saying: he cannot mean that God loves righteousness together with a subject more than a subject without righteousness, for there is no such thing as righteousness without a subject to love, even if the mind can form an abstract, distinct conception of it. If the question is simply whether God loves the same man more as a man or more as a saint, I answer that he has a love suited to each kind. He has such a satisfaction in the substance of a serpent, a man, or a devil as is fitting to their being, that is, as they bear the natural impressions of his creative perfections, yet this is a love consistent with their pain, death, and misery. But he has such a satisfaction in the actual holiness, love, and obedience of men and angels that he regards the person who possesses these qualities as fit for his service, his glory, and everlasting happiness, and delights in that person as being qualified for it.

God’s love must therefore be distinguished by its object. So there is a love of nature and a love of the moral perfections of nature: the first is by which he loves a man because he is a man, and similarly all other creatures; the second is by which he loves a good man because he is good and holy. And if it comforts you that God loves your existence apart from your perfections or virtue, let that comfort you in pain, and death, and hell, that he sustains your being without your well-being or happiness.

Objection 7: "All goodness or holiness is someone’s goodness or holiness, just as health belongs to a person. And since it is the person’s welfare and perfection, it is given for the person’s sake. Therefore the person, as the one for whom it is given, the final recipient, is better than the thing given, and thus more worthy of love."

Answer: That all goodness is someone’s goodness proves only that someone is the subject or being that is good, not that to exist is better than to be good, as such. And although the person is in one sense the recipient for whom goodness is given, and thus goodness is good to him, both he and his goodness exist for a higher end: the pleasing of God through the demonstration of his goodness. What most demonstrates God’s goodness is therefore best.

Moreover, there is no subject or substance without its accidents or modes; and a person who is not good and holy is bad and unholy. The real question, then, is whether a person who is bad and unholy is more worthy of love than a person who is good and holy, possessing both physical and moral goodness. And even granting that the category of "accident" makes action seem subordinate to the person, it must also be said that the person and his faculties exist for action, the person being the substance in its perfect mode, and that action is directed toward ends higher than the person’s mere existence or happiness.

Objection 8: "Love is nothing but benevolence, willing good to someone so that they may fare well. But who would not wish good to God, that is, that he be blessed as he is? How then can holiness itself be loved, rather than the person loved for his holiness? For we cannot wish holiness well; we can only wish that it remain what it is."

Answer:

1.) The definition is false, as has been shown, and as the very example proves, for on that definition a person could not be said to love learning, virtue, or any quality, but only to love the person who lacks or possesses it. Love is properly a satisfaction or delight in its object; benevolence is either its effect or its antecedent.

2.) The unholy do not in fact wish good to God, for they would all dethrone him from his Godhead. They would not have him be a hater of their sin, nor their holy and righteous Governor and Judge.

Objection 9: "It is better to be a man, even a sinful and miserable man in hell, than not to exist at all. Otherwise God would never have ordained, caused, or permitted it."

Answer: It is better, with respect to the highest ends, God’s glory and universal order, to be a punished man than to be nothing at all, when God wills it so; because punishment, in relation to those highest ends, is genuinely good, even though it is not best for the wretched sinner himself. But the same cannot be said of sin. It is indeed better, with respect to those highest ends, for a man to exist though sinful, while God continues humanity, than for him not to exist; for sin in itself contains no good, and therefore God neither causes it nor wills it, even though he permits it. But although a sinful man is better than no man at all with respect to God’s ends, it does not follow that merely existing as a man is better than existing as a good man.

Objection 10: "If that which most glorifies God is best and most worthy of love, then it is more worthy of love to be a sinner suffering torment in hell and thereby glorifying his justice than not to exist at all, or to be a brute creature."

Answer: Neither of those alternatives is what is offered to your love and choice, what is offered is to be holy. Not every good is a proper object of election. The good that exists in hell is not the sin but the punishment, for sin as much as it is able robs God of his glory, while punishment repairs it. Love the punishment if you will, and do not hold back, so long as you love holiness still more, for holiness would honor God more excellently and please him more fully.

Objection 11: "If I must love to be like God, I must love to be great, and I must love the greatest as most like him."

Answer: You must love to be like him in those perfections of which you are capable, and in ways suited to the ends of your proper nature. Therefore you should desire to be like him in your own measure, in such power and greatness as are fitting to the nature and ends of a rational soul. Not in such strength as he gives a horse, or such magnitude as he gives a mountain, for those are not ways of being most like him. Rather, you should seek to be like him in the vital activity and power of an intellectual, free agent: to be powerful and great in love to God and in all his service, in all good works, and in being profitable to the world; to be lively and ready in all obedience, strong to endure suffering, and to conquer sin and every temptation, in a word, to be great and powerful in wisdom and true goodness. In this way seek, even in power, to be like God within your own capacities.

Objection 12: "God himself does not love men only for their goodness, nor does he love best what is best. He loves his elect while they are still enemies and ungodly. He told Israel he loved them because he would love them, not because they were better than other nations. And in the womb he loved Jacob more than Esau, when Jacob was no better than Esau."

Answer: Two distinctions must be made: 1. between God’s complacency and his benevolence; 2. between the good that is presently in a person and the good that is foreseen in them together with a present capacity for it.

1. God had a greater benevolence toward Jacob than toward Esau, and toward the Israelites than toward other nations that were perhaps not much worse. It is not on account of our goodness that God decrees to make us good, or to give us a greater portion of those mercies which he gives not as Ruler but as absolute owner and free benefactor. With this love of benevolence he loves us even when we are his enemies, that is, he purposes to make us good. Yet this benevolence is a secondary love and fruit of complacency, joined to the free and unequal distribution of what is his own.

2. As for complacency, which is love in the first and strictest sense, God loves the wicked, even the elect among them, only insofar as they are good and lovely: that is, (1) as they have the natural goodness of rational creatures; (2) as they are capable of all the future service they will render him and the glory they will bring him; and (3) as his infinite wisdom knows it fitting to choose them for that service. Or if the benevolence of election does precede his first complacency in them above others, coming before his foresight that they will serve and love him more, still this proper love called complacency never extends beyond the worth of the thing loved.

Objection: "Does God love us with complacency in Christ beyond the good that is actually in us?"

Answer: Not beyond our real and relative good, as we are in ourselves by his grace, and as we are in Christ related to him, both of which demonstrate the divine perfections and ensure that we will love, glorify, and please him forever.

So much for the opening of the true nature of love to God, to ourselves, and to others; of man’s ultimate end; and of the nature of holiness and goodness, and those mysteries of religion that are bound up in these points.

CHAPTER 41

DIRECTIONS AGAINST UNBELIEF

 

The positive directions covering the essential duties of godliness and Christianity have already given you guidance against the corresponding sins. In the first Grand Direction you receive help against direct unbelief. In the second, you receive directions against unbelief understood as the failure to use and apply Christ according to your various needs. In the third, you receive directions against all resistance or neglect of the Holy Ghost, these three coming first because in practice we must come through the Son and the Spirit to the saving knowledge and love of the Father.

In the fourth, you receive directions against atheism, idolatry, and ungodliness. In the fifth, you receive directions against self-idolizing, self-dependence, and the unholiness of alienating yourself from God. In the sixth, you are directed against rebellion and disobedience toward God. In the seventh, you receive directions against unteachableness, ignorance, and error. In the eighth, you receive directions against impenitence, unhumbleness, impurity, unreformedness, and all sin in general as sin. In the ninth, you are directed against security, unwatchfulness, yielding to temptations, and in general against all danger to the soul.

Of the sin against the Holy Ghost I have written a special treatise in my Unreasonableness of Infidelity; and since the writing of this I have published the same at greater length in my Reasons of the Christian Religion and in my Life of Faith. Of presumption and false hope, enough is said in the Saints’ Rest, and here under temptation, hope, and the other heads that follow.

In the tenth, you are directed against barrenness, unprofitableness, sloth, and uncharitableness, and against mistakes in matters of duty or good works. In the eleventh, you are directed against all averseness, disaffection, or cold indifference of heart toward God. In the twelfth, you are directed against distrust, and sinful cares, fears, and sorrows. In the thirteenth, you are directed against an overly sorrowful or dispirited service of God, serving him merely from fear, or under compulsion, without delight. In the fourteenth, you are directed against unthankfulness. In the fifteenth, you are directed against all unholy or dishonorable thoughts of God, against all injurious speech about him, and against all barrenness of tongue and of life, and against scandal. In the books referred to in the sixteenth and seventeenth directions, you are directed against selfishness, self-esteem, self-love, self-conceit, self-will, self-seeking, and against all worldliness and fleshly-mindedness in thought and life. Yet, so that no necessary help against such serious sins should be lacking, I will add some further particular directions against those sins that were not fully treated before.

Part I. Directions against Unbelief

 

I know that most troubled Christians, when they complain of the sin of unbelief, mean by it their failure to believe that they are sincere believers, personally justified, and certain to be saved. I also know that some divines have affirmed that the sense of the article of the creed, "I believe the remission of sins," is "I believe my sins are actually forgiven." But the truth is this: to believe that I am elect, or justified, or that my sins are forgiven, or that I am a sincere believer, is not to believe any Word of God at all. No Word of God says any of these things, nor anything equivalent, nor anything from which they can be directly gathered.

The conclusion is a rational inference, and one of the premises that produces it must be found in myself by reflection, internal sense, and self-knowledge. Scripture says only, "He that truly believeth is justified, and shall be saved." But it is conscience, not belief in Scripture, that must say, "I do sincerely believe." The conclusion, that I am justified and shall be saved, is therefore a rational inference drawn from what I find in Scripture and in myself taken together, and it can be no firmer or surer than the weaker of its two premises.

Now certainty is of two kinds: objective, residing in the thing itself, or subjective, residing in my apprehension of it. As to objective certainty, all truths are equally true; but all truths are not equally discernible, since there is more occasion for doubt about some things that are less evident than about others that are more evident. God’s promise of justification to believers is therefore more certain, that is, it has fuller and surer evidence by which it can be discerned, than the truth of my sincere believing. "That I sincerely believe" is the weaker of the two premises, and the conclusion follows it in its weakness; it therefore cannot be an article of faith. As to subjective certainty, that varies according to each person’s apprehension. The premises, considered as evidence or in their capacity to assure us, are the cause of the conclusion as something knowable. The premises, as actually apprehended, are the cause of the conclusion as actually known.

Some raise a serious question: whether a person can possibly be more certain that he believes than he is that the thing believed is true, since an act cannot extend further than its object, and to be sure that I believe is simply to be sure that I take the thing believed to be true. I will, however, grant the contrary: a person may possibly be more certain that he believes than he is that the thing believed is true. This is because my believing is not always a full subjective certainty that the thing is true, but rather a believing that it is true.

And although you may be fully certain that all God’s Word is true, you may nevertheless believe that this particular writing is his Word with some mixture of doubt. The question then becomes simply this: whether you may not know with certainty, without doubting, that you believe the Word of God to be true, even though that belief carries some degree of doubt within it, and it seems that you may. But then a further question arises: whether you can be more certain of the saving sincerity of your faith than you are that God’s Word is true. That ordinary people doubt the first as much as they doubt the second I take to be an established fact of experience.

Yet grant that with some it may be otherwise, because a person believes sincerely who so far trusts the Word of God as to stake his life and soul upon it and to forsake all in obedience to it, and that I do so may perhaps be known with less doubting than I yet have about the truth of the Word so believed. Even so, all that follows is this: that among those who doubt their justification and salvation, some of their doubt arises more from doubting God’s Word than from doubting whether they sincerely, though doubtingly, believe it; while the doubt of others about whether they are justified and will be saved arises far more from doubting their own sincere belief than from doubting the truth of Scripture. The great majority of Christians seem to themselves to belong to this latter group. Clearly, although a person of clear understanding can scarcely believe without knowing that he believes, he may believe sincerely without knowing that he believes sincerely.

Even so, the knowledge of our own justification is simply the effect and outcome of our belief in the Word of God together with our knowledge that we do sincerely believe it, these two jointly are its parents and causes, and it can be no stronger than the weaker of those two parents. The effect is not the cause: the combined effect of faith and knowledge is not faith itself. To believe that you believe, or that you are justified, is not the same as believing the Word of God. Yet because faith is one of the parents of that conclusion, some call it by the name of faith, when they should more precisely call it an effect of faith as one of its causes. And our doubts about our own salvation may rightly be said to arise from unbelief, because unbelief is one of their causes, and the most sinful one.

That the article of the remission of sins is to be believed with application to ourselves is certain, but not with the application of assurance, persuasion, or belief that we are already pardoned. Rather, it is applied through an accepting reception of an offered pardon, and through consent to the covenant that makes that pardon ours. We believe that Christ has purchased remission of sins and has made a conditional grant of it in his Gospel to all, that is, to all who will repent and believe in him, or receive him as their Savior, or become penitent Christians. We consent to do so, and to accept pardon on those terms. And we believe that all who thus consent are actually pardoned.

From all this you can see that those troubled Christians who do not doubt the truth of God’s Word, but only doubt their own sincerity, and consequently their justification and salvation, are mistaken when they complain that they have no faith or cannot believe. To doubt whether my own heart is sincere is no act of unbelief at all; it is ignorance of myself, not any degree of unbelief, for God’s Word nowhere says that I am sincere, and therefore I may doubt this without doubting God’s Word in the least. Every troubled Christian should understand that their unbelief is no greater than their actual doubting of the truth of God’s Word. Even that despair which contains none of this doubting contains no unbelief in it, if any such despair exists.

I thought it necessary to explain what unbelief is before giving directions against it. And though the mere doubting of one’s own sincerity is no unbelief at all, real unbelief of the very truth of Holy Scripture is so common and dangerous a sin, and some degree of it lies hidden even in the best, that I think nothing advances the work of grace so much as destroying it. The weakness of our faith in the truth of Scripture, and what remains of our unbelief of it, is the principal cause of all the languishing of our love, obedience, and every other grace; to strengthen faith is to strengthen all. What I have written more fully in my Saints’ Rest, Part 2, and my Treatise against Infidelity, I here take as assumed.

Direction 1: Consider carefully how much of religion nature itself teaches, and reason, without supernatural revelation, must acknowledge: that there is another life for which humanity was made, that we are obliged to the fullest love and obedience to God, and the rest laid down in the Introduction. Then observe how fittingly the doctrine of Christ comes in to help where nature is at a loss, how exactly it aligns with natural truths, how clearly it explains them, how fully it contains as much of them as is necessary to salvation, how suitable and proper a means it is to reach those ends, and what great testimony the doctrines of nature and grace give to each other.

I must say plainly that the nature and the remarkable difference between the godly and the ungodly, and their conduct in the world, are to my eyes perpetual and visible evidences of the truth of Holy Scripture.

1. That there should be so universal and relentless a hatred of the godly among common, unregenerate people in all ages and nations, when these people deserve well of their neighbors and do them no wrong, is visible proof of Adam’s fall and of the need for a Savior and a Sanctifier.

2. That all who are seriously Christian should be so far renewed and recovered from the common corruption, as their heavenly minds, their lives, and their remarkable difference from other people show, is visible proof that Christianity is of God.

3. That God so plainly shows a particular, special providence in converting and confirming souls by distinguishing grace, and works upon the soul as the sanctified themselves feel, shows that the work is truly his.

4. That God so plainly answers many of his servants’ prayers through special providences proves that he owns them and his promises.

5. That God ordinarily allows his servants in all times and places to suffer so much for his love and service at the hands of the world and the flesh shows that there is a future judgment with rewards and punishments. For otherwise our highest duty would be our greatest loss, and how then could his government of humanity be just?

6. That the renewed nature, which makes people better and is therefore of God, looks entirely toward the life to come, leads us toward it, and lives upon it, shows that such a life exists. If it did not, this renewal would be a delusion, and goodness itself would be a deception.

7. It is undeniable that in fact the world is not governed without the hopes and fears of another life: nearly all heathen nations believe in it, and by their very practice of worshipping their dead heroes as gods they show that they believed the soul survives death. Even the wicked in general are restrained by those hopes and fears within themselves. And it is equally clear that it is not possible for the world to be governed in a manner suited to humanity’s rational nature without those hopes and fears; without them, people would be worse than beasts and every villainy would become the common practice of the world, as every person may feel within himself what he would likely become and do without such restraint. Since no doctrine or way of life compares to Christianity in its tendency toward the life to come, all these are visible and standing evidences, greatly supported by common sense and reason, ever apparent to all, leaving unbelief without excuse and always at hand to strengthen our faith and resist temptation to disbelief.

8. If the world had not had a beginning as Scripture teaches, then first, we would have found monuments of antiquity more than six thousand years old; second, arts and sciences would have advanced much further, and printing, gunpowder, and the like would not have been so recently invented; third, so much of America and other parts of the world would not still be uninhabited, uncultivated, or undiscovered. Of atheism I have spoken in the Introduction; and nature so clearly reveals a God that I regard it as almost needless to say much of it to thoughtful people.

Direction 2: Consider that since humanity’s end lies in the life to come, and since God is the righteous and merciful Governor of humanity in order to that end, it must follow that God will give sufficient means to know his will toward that end, and that the clearest and fullest such means must most powerfully display God’s governance and mercy.

Direction 3: Consider what full and painful experience the world has of its corruption and great depravity, that the natural tendency of reason is toward those high and excellent things which corruption and brutishness nearly extinguish or drive out in most people, and that the dominance of the lower faculties over right reason is so lamentable and universal, to the confusion of the world, as to tell us plainly that this is not the state in which God first made us, and that sin has surely marred and disordered his work. The wickedness of the world is a great confirmation of Scripture.

Direction 4: Consider how exactly the doctrine of the Gospel and the covenant of grace are fitted to the fallen state of humanity, just as the law of works was fitted to humanity’s state of innocence, so that the Gospel may be called the law of fallen nature, as suited to it, though not as revealed by it, as the law of works was the law of unfallen nature.

Direction 5: Compare the many prophecies of Christ with their fulfillment in his person, such as the prophecy of Moses cited by Stephen (Acts 7:37), and those of Isaiah 53 and Daniel 9:24–26, and others. And consider that the Jews, who are the bitterest enemies of Christians, nevertheless acknowledge and preserve those prophecies and the entire Old Testament, which gives such full testimony to the New.

Direction 6: Consider what a remarkable suitableness there is in the doctrine of Christ to the taste of a serious, heavenly mind, and how all that is spiritual and truly good in us closes with it and embraces it from a natural affinity of natures, as the eye does with light, and the stomach with its proper food. Every good person reading Holy Scripture feels something within, all that is good, bearing witness to it. Only our worse part quarrels with it and rebels against it.

Direction 7: Consider how all the first churches were planted through the effect of those miracles recorded in Scripture, and that the apostles and thousands of others saw the miracles of Christ; that the churches saw the miracles of the apostles and heard them speak in languages they had never learned, and had the same extraordinary gifts communicated to themselves. These gifts, being openly and frequently displayed, convinced unbelievers and were openly appealed to by the apostles to silence opponents and confirm believers. Had all these been fabrications, those who were said to be their own eyewitnesses and agents would have scorned both the arguments and the faith those arguments supported. The very existence of the churches was therefore testimony to the facts themselves. And what greater testimony to God’s endorsement and approval can there be than Christ’s resurrection and all these miracles?

Direction 8: Consider that not one of all the heretics or apostates ever contradicted the matters of fact, nor has anyone left behind any kind of refutation of them, and this not for lack of malice, encouragement, or opportunity to do so.

Direction 9: Consider that not one of the thousands who asserted these miracles is ever mentioned in any historical record as having repented of doing so, whether in health or at the hour of death. Yet it would have been so heinous a villainy to have deceived the world in so great a cause that the consciences of dying men, especially men who placed all their hopes in the life to come, must surely have given way to repentance, had the story been a fabrication.

Direction 10: Consider that the witnesses of all these miracles, and all the churches that believed them, were taught both by their own doctrine and by experience to forsake everything they had in the world, to be reproached, hated, and persecuted by all people, to live as lambs among wolves in daily expectation of death, and all this for the hope of the blessedness promised them by a crucified and risen Christ. No worldly motive, therefore, could have moved them to deceive, or willingly to be deceived.

Direction 11: Consider how utterly impossible it is, even in itself, that so many people should conspire together to deceive the world, for nothing, and at the cost of their own ruin and death, that they should all agree so unanimously in the same narratives and doctrines, and that not one of them should ever confess the deceit and disgrace the rest. When everything is carefully weighed, this proves not merely a moral impossibility but a natural one, especially given the character and distance of the witnesses: there were thousands scattered across several countries who had never seen one another’s faces, much less could have entered into a confederacy to deceive the world.

Direction 12: Consider the reliable way by which the doctrine and writings of the apostles and other gospel messengers have been handed down to us, with no real possibility of material alteration. The Holy Scriptures were not entrusted only to private individuals or to the Christians of a single country, who might have agreed on corruptions and changes. Rather, it was the appointed duty of the ordinary ministers to read, expound, and apply them. Every congregation had one or more such ministers, and the people received the Scriptures as the law of God, the standard by which they must live and be judged, their charter for heaven. It was therefore impossible for one minister to corrupt the Scripture text without the rest, together with the people, quickly reproving him; and equally impossible for the Christians of one nation to impose alterations upon all other Christians throughout the world without extensive deliberation and open resistance, of which history records nothing.

Direction 13: Acquaint yourself as fully as you can with the history of the church, so that you may know how the Gospel has been planted, propagated, assaulted, and preserved to this day. This will satisfy you far more than vague and uncertain talk from others.

Direction 14: Ask yourself whether God, as the wise and merciful Governor of the world, would allow the most honest and obedient of his subjects on earth to be deceived in a matter of such importance, deceived by means of doctrines and miracles presented as proceeding from himself, and which none but God (or one specially empowered by God) is able to perform, without either disowning those miracles or giving the world sufficient means to detect the fraud. He certainly has no need of deceit to govern us.

If you object that God permits Mahometanism, I answer:

1. The main, positive doctrine of the Mahometans, the worship of the one God against idolatry, is true. And the subsidiary inventions of their self-styled prophet are not commended to the world on the strength of attesting miracles at all, but on the bare assertion of revelations, without any credible seal or divine attestation, and forced upon the world by the power of the sword. God, who is supreme truth and goodness, cannot deceive his own offspring, the human race (Marsilio Ficino, On the Christian Religion, ch. 1).

2. God has given the world sufficient protection against these inventions in the absence of any real proof for them, and in the evident foolishness of the writings and the claims themselves. Honesty and diligence will therefore easily expose them.

Direction 15: Observe the supernatural effects of the Gospel upon the souls of believers, how it plants in a person the image of the holy God, powerfully bringing both the senses and the strongest interests of the flesh into subjection to the will of God, making people wise and good, and setting them apart from all others in a remarkable way. Then judge whether this is not God’s seal upon his Gospel, bearing his own image first upon itself, which he uses and honors as the instrument for imprinting that image upon us. Piety, said Cicero, is the foundation of all the virtues.

Direction 16: Mark well the certain emptiness of all other religions that prevail on the earth. Idolatry and Mahometanism, which openly bear the marks of their own shame, have between them divided almost all the rest of the world; for pure Deism has barely any established following, and Judaism holds no considerable inheritance, and both Deism and Judaism are sensibly refuted by human corruption, human need, and what humanity deserves.

Direction 17: Mark the great difference between the Christian part of the world, those who receive Christianity seriously and sincerely, and all the rest. Xenophon reports Cyrus as saying that if all his household were endowed with piety toward God, they would do less evil to one another and to him. Those farthest from Christianity are farthest from piety, honesty, civility, or any praiseworthy quality of character or conduct. Most of them live in a brutish and ungodly way, and the rest are only a little better; ignorance and brutishness cannot be the perfection of a human being.

Indeed, even among professed Christians, the multitudes who hold only the name while hating the nature and practice of it are like swine or wolves, and some of the worst are near kin to devils. Whereas all who receive Christianity practically into their hearts and lives are heavenly and holy; in the same measure as they receive it, their sins are mortified, they are devoted to God, filled with justice, charity, and patience toward others, and lifted above this world, holding in contempt what the rest make their happiness and delight. So that if that which does good is itself good, then the goodness of the Christian faith is apparent to all who have any honest acquaintance with it, along with reason and impartiality to judge.

Direction 18: Ask yourself what you would have been had you not been a Christian. Yes, what would now follow if you were to fall away from the Christian faith? Would you not regard the life to come as doubtful? Would you not resolve to take your pleasure in the world, to gratify the flesh, to neglect your soul, and to venture upon almost any vice that seemed useful to your worldly ends? Christianity has cleansed and sanctified you, if indeed you are sanctified. And if, which God forbid, you were to forsake Christianity, you would most likely quickly show the difference by a dirty, fleshly, and worldly life. Cicero doubted whether, if reverence toward the gods were once taken away, trust and the fellowship of the human race, together with justice, the most excellent of all the virtues, would not be taken away with it.

Direction 19: When you see the evidence for divine revelation and authority, that is enough to silence your doubts and objections about particular words or circumstances. You know that God is true and infallible; and you know that you are ignorant creatures utterly at a loss whenever there is no one at hand to open every difficulty for you, just as all arts and sciences appear full of difficulties and contradictions to ignorant and inexperienced beginners.

Direction 20: Throughout your study, make consistent allowance for the difficulties that necessarily arise from translation, the ambiguity of all human language, the change and variety of words and customs over time, differences of place and circumstance, and especially your own unfamiliarity with all these things, so that your own weaknesses, ignorance, and errors in reasoning are not attributed to the truth itself.

Direction 21: Understand the proper purpose of Holy Scripture, and in that light how far it is divine, so that you are not tempted toward unbelief by expecting from it what was never intended, and then finding those groundless expectations disappointed.

It is not divine in its terms, style, arrangement, and such incidental and circumstantial matters, as though every degree of exactness that God could put into a book might be looked for there. Nor is it intended as a system of physics, logic, or any of the subordinate sciences or arts. It is, rather, an infallible revelation of the will of God for the governance of the church and the guiding of people to eternal life; and it is arranged and worded so as to share in such human limitations as in no way impair its truth or its power, but rather make it better suited to the generality of people, whose weakness calls for such a style and manner of treatment.

Just as a child of God has a body from parents, which is yet from God, but so from God as to share the parents’ frailties, or rather as Adam had a body from God but from earth, and accordingly frail, yet a soul more immediately from God and therefore purer and more divine, so Scripture has its style, language, and method from God in such a way that nothing in it is unsuitable to its ends; but not from God in such a way as if God had displayed in it his own most perfect wisdom to the utmost, with no trace of human limitation. The truth and goodness, which are the soul of Scripture, are more immediately from God. The style and method of the human authors may vary, but the same soul animates every part.

It is no dishonor to the Holy Scriptures if Cicero is preferred for purity of style, expression, and oratory in other common uses. But Scripture is certainly to be preferred for its proper use, just as the best style for an act of parliament is nearly the worst for an oration. Means are ordered to their ends.

Direction 22: Consider how much assistance apparitions, witchcraft, and other tangible evidence of spirits conversing with humanity give to faith. I have treated these matters in the treatises mentioned earlier, and so I pass over them here.

Direction 23: Consider what advantage faith may gain by observing the nature and tendency of the soul, its hopes and fears of a life to come, and the superior, glorious worlds that are certainly inhabited by nobler beings. Anyone who sees every corner of earth, sea, and air teeming with life, and then reflects on how small the earth is compared with all the great and glorious spheres above it, will hardly imagine that those spheres are all empty of inhabitants, or that there is no room in them for souls. See my book A Saint or a Brute.

Direction 24: The ministry of angels, of which particular providences give us strong probability, lends real support to the doctrine that we shall live with angels, and that we shall ascend to closer familiarity with those who now condescend to such great service on our behalf.

Direction 25: The universal, relentless, and implacable hatred that corrupted humanity bears toward the holy doctrine, ways, and servants of Christ, the open war waged against him in every kingdom, and the secret war sustained in every heart, along with the character of every temptation, their violence and constancy across all ages and against all persons, all arrayed against Christ, heaven, and holiness, plainly declares that the Christian doctrine and life do tend toward our salvation. That is precisely why the devil opposes them so maliciously and incessantly. In this way his very temptations give the tempted soul a great advantage against the tempter, for the enemy of our souls does not make such fierce opposition for nothing.

That such a devil exists, opposing Christ and tempting us, is proved not only by visible apparitions and witchcraft, but by the all-too-real temptations which, by their matter and manner, plainly reveal their origin. This is especially clear when the whole world is formed into two hostile armies, one fighting under Christ, the other under the devil, as it has been from Cain and Abel to this day.

Direction 26: The prophecies of Christ himself concerning the destruction of Jerusalem, the gathering of his church, and the cruel treatment it would suffer throughout the world give great assistance to faith, when we see them all so precisely fulfilled.

Direction 27: Examine whether it is not concern for temporal things that is assaulting your belief, and do not approach so great a mystery with a biased, sensual mind. Worldliness, pride, and sensuality are deadly enemies of faith; where they prevail they show their enmity and blind the mind. If the soul is sunk in mud and filth, it cannot see the things of God.

Direction 28: Come with humility and a sense of your ignorance, not with arrogance and self-conceit, as if everything your empty, foolish mind cannot immediately perceive to be right must therefore be wrong. The most notorious apostates I have ever known were, without exception, men of conspicuous pride and self-conceit.

Direction 29: Do not provoke God, by willfully sinning against the light you have already received, to abandon you and give you over to unbelief. "Because men receive not the love of the truth, that they might be saved; for this cause God sends them strong delusions to believe a lie; that they all might be damned who believed not the truth, but had pleasure in unrighteousness" (2 Thess 2:10–12). Obey Christ’s doctrine as far as you know it, and you will come to know more fully that it is of God (John 7:17 John 10:4).

Direction 30: Do not tempt yourself toward unbelief through a false humility that degrades your natural faculties, when what you should be humbled for is your moral corruption. Vilifying the soul, its reason, and its natural will tends toward unbelief, by leading you to think yourself no better than other lower animals, incapable of a life above with God. By contrast, humbling yourself because of the corruption of reason and will tends to show you your need of a physician, and so assists your faith in Christ.

Direction 31: Do not judge so great a matter by sudden impressions, or by the surprise of a temptation, at a moment when you have no leisure to gather all the evidences of faith, lay them together, and take a full and deliberate view of the whole case.

This is a mystery so great that it requires a clear and undistracted mind, freed from prejudice and abstracted from things that divert and deceive, a mind that, even with the best assistance and greatest diligence, must weigh everything together to discern the truth. If, after your best assistance and consideration, you have been convinced of the truth, and you then allow every sudden thought, temptation, or difficulty to seem sufficient to call everything into question again, you are being unfaithful to the truth. That is the way to resist the clearest evidence and never reach a settled conclusion.

It is like answering your adversary in court when your witnesses have all been dismissed or are absent, your evidence is not at hand, and perhaps your counsel is gone too. It is like casting up a long and intricate account which you have worked through carefully over time, and then, when the account-books are not before you, allowing one person to question this item and another to question that, it is not right to answer every particular challenge, or to doubt your own reckoning, until you have as full an opportunity and as much help to work through everything again.

Direction 32: If the task seems too hard for you, go and consult the wisest and most experienced Christians, who can readily answer the difficulties that most perplex and tempt you. Modesty itself will tell you that the advantage of study and experience makes everyone wisest in their own field, and places others above you when you have less of these.

Direction 33: Remember that Christianity is the surest way to secure your eternal hopes, and that the things of this life which lead men to forsake it are such passing trifles that you can be no loser by it. So even if you doubted, you could still be certain it is the safer course.

Direction 34: Do not judge so great a matter during a time of melancholy, when fears and confusion leave you unfit for it. In such a condition, and equally whenever Satan would disturb your settled faith or tempt you to keep reopening resolved questions and discerned truths, abhor his suggestions, refuse to entertain them in your thoughts, and throw them back in the tempter’s face.

Scarcely one person in a multitude who suffers from melancholy is not violently assaulted with temptations to blasphemy and unbelief, at a time when they have only half the use of their reason and no composure of mind to debate such questions with the devil. It is not fitting for them, in that incapacity, to listen to any suggestion drawing them to dispute the foundations of their faith; they should cast such suggestions away with resolute rejection. Nor should any Christian who is soundly settled on the true foundation gratify the devil by disputing with him whenever he provokes us, but rather labor only to strengthen faith and destroy whatever remnants of unbelief remain.

Direction 35: Remember that Christ propagates his religion through his Spirit and his Word together, and himself produces the very faith he commands. For although there is sufficient evidence of credibility in his Word, the blinded minds and corrupt, perverted hearts of people need the healing of his medicinal grace before they will believe effectively and savingly a doctrine so holy, lofty, and heavenly, and one that so thoroughly restrains their lusts. See to it, therefore, that you distrust your corrupted hearts, and earnestly seek the Spirit of Christ.

Direction 36: Labor earnestly for the love of every truth you believe, to feel its renewing power on your heart and its reforming power on your life, and above all to be drawn to the love of God and to a heavenly mind and life. This will be an excellent defense against all temptations to unbelief, for the heart holds the Gospel far more firmly than the head alone.

The seed cast into the earth, if it quickens and takes root, is best preserved; the deeper it is rooted the more surely it remains. But if it dies, it perishes and is gone. When the seed of the holy Word has produced the new creature, it is secure; but when it is retained only in the mind as a dead opinion, every temptation can overturn it.

The serious, practical Christian has a great advantage over all hypocrites and unsanctified persons: love holds on far more firmly than dead belief. Love is the grace that endures forever, and the faith that endures is the faith that works by love. The experienced Christian has felt so much of the power and goodness of the Word that if you confuse his head with subtle arguments against it, his heart and experience will not allow him to let it go. He has tasted it so sweet that he will not believe it to be bitter, even if he cannot answer everything said against it.

If someone tried to persuade you to think ill of your dearest friend or father, love and experience would guard you from that deception far better than reasoning alone would do. The new nature in believers, and their experience of God’s love communicated to their souls through Jesus Christ, are constant witnesses to the Word of God: he that believes has the witness in himself, that is, the Holy Spirit given to him, which is both an objective testimony and an effective one. For this, see my Treatise of Infidelity.

Unsanctified people may more easily be turned to unbelief, for they have never felt the renewing, quickening work of faith, nor have they been brought by it to the love of God and a holy, heavenly mind and life. Those who were never truly Christians at the heart are the soonest turned away from being Christians in opinion and name.

Question: By what reason, evidence, or obligation were the Jews bound to believe the prophets? Since Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel, and others worked no miracles, and there were false prophets in their days, how could anyone know that these men were truly sent by God when they simply claimed it?

Answer: I raise this objection because it is omitted in my book The Reasons of the Christian Religion, to which I refer the reader for all related questions, and because it is one of the hardest questions concerning our faith.

1. Those who hold that every book of Scripture proves itself divine by its own matter, style, and intrinsic properties will say that hearing the prophets then, just as reading them now, made this satisfying evidence discernible. All I can say is that the prophecies do contain such marks as help faith, making it more readily credible that they are from God, but not such as would have given me certainty by themselves, especially when delivered piecemeal at the time.

2. Nor am I satisfied by the answer that those who have the same Spirit can recognize the Spirit’s style in the prophets. First, this would imply that no one without the same Spirit could believe them on solid grounds. Second, the Spirit of sanctification is not sufficient by itself for discerning prophetical inspirations, as both reason and experience fully show. The gift of discerning spirits was not common to all the sanctified (1 Cor 12:10).

3. It is highly significant that God never sent any prophet to establish a law or covenant on which the salvation of the people depended without the attestation of unquestionable miracles. Moses worked numerous open miracles, miracles that exposed and overcame the apparent miracles of his opponents in Egypt, and Christ and his apostles worked still more than Moses. The laws and covenants by which God would rule and judge his people were therefore all confirmed beyond any reasonable exception.

4. It must also be noted that many other prophets worked miracles to confirm their doctrine and to prove that they were sent by God, as did Elijah and Elisha.

5. It must further be noted that there were schools of prophets, communities of them, in those times (1 Sam 10:10 1 Sam 19:20 1 Kgs 20:35 1 Kgs 20:41 1 Kgs 22:13 2 Kgs 2:3 2 Kgs 2:5 2 Kgs 2:7 2 Kgs 2:15 2 Kgs 4:1 2 Kgs 4:38 2 Kgs 5:22 2 Kgs 6:1 2 Kgs 9:1 1 Cor 14:32). These communities educated men in ways suited to receiving prophetical inspiration when God was pleased to grant it. Not that education alone made anyone a prophet, nor that the prophets possessed the active gift of prophecy at all times; but God was pleased to honor men’s diligent obedience by joining his blessing to a fitting formation, and at times of his own choosing to illuminate such men with visions and revelations beyond all others. It is therefore spoken of Amos as something extraordinary that he was made a prophet from being a herdsman.

6. A prophet among the Jews was therefore typically known to be a prophet before the recorded prophecies we now have in Holy Scripture, recognized on several grounds.

1.) The spirits of the prophets, which are subject to the prophets, were judged by those prophets who truly had the Spirit, so the people had the testimony of the established prophets concerning the newer ones.

2.) The LORD‘s own rule for recognizing a true prophet (Deut 18:22), whether the thing he foretells comes to pass, means that it is likely that before any prophet was received into the company of prophets, he had already given the prophetic societies satisfaction by the fulfillment of earlier predictions.

3.) Or such men may have worked miracles beforehand to satisfy the members of the prophetic community of their calling, even though those miracles are not all recorded in Scripture.

4.) Or the other prophets may have received some divine testimony about them through their own visions, revelations, or inspirations. The people were therefore not left to the bare, unverified claims of anyone who simply said he was sent by God.

7. Some prophets gave specific signs to confirm their word, such as Isaiah’s predictions regarding Hezekiah’s danger, remedy, and recovery, and the going back of the shadow on Ahaz’s sundial by ten degrees. There may have been further such signs that we do not know of.

8. Not all prophecies carried equal obligation. The first prophecies of a prophet who brought no miraculous attestation and had not yet spoken anything fulfilled might be a merciful disclosure from God that obliged hearers to a respectful attention, an inquiry into the prophet’s authority, and a patient waiting to see whether the word came to pass, with its fulfillment correspondingly increasing their obligation. Some prophecies foretelling only temporal things, such as captivities or deliverances, might at first, before the prophet had produced divine attestation, be more in the nature of a bare prediction than a binding law; and if men did not believe them, they might not thereby be guilty of any damning sin at all, but only refused a warning of temporal judgment that would have served them had they heeded it.

9. Our obligation now to believe the same scriptural prophecies is greater, however, because we live in the age when most of them have been fulfilled, and the rest are attested by Christ and his apostles, who confirmed their attestation by manifold miracles.

10. When the prophets reproved the known sins of the people and called them to duties the law required, no one could come to harm by obeying such a prophet, since the substance of his message was already found in God’s own law, which had to be obeyed in any case. This is in fact the main content of the recorded prophecies.

11. And anyone who spoke against any part of God’s law, whether natural or revealed, was not to be believed, since God cannot contradict himself (Deut 13 and 18).

12. The prophets themselves, however, were under a different and stronger obligation to believe their own visions and inspirations than any of their hearers were. God’s great extraordinary revelation was like light, which immediately revealed itself and compelled the understanding to recognize it as coming from God. Such were the revelations that came through angelic appearances and visions. Prophets could therefore be bound to things by these revelations, such as wounding themselves, going barefoot, or eating foul food, that their bare word could never have bound their hearers to. This was Abraham’s case in offering Isaac. Yet God never commanded a prophet, or commanded anyone through a prophet, to do something inherently and absolutely evil; only things that were mutable in nature, whose moral quality his sovereign will could alter. Abraham’s case, rightly considered, falls under this principle.

CHAPTER 42

DIRECTIONS AGAINST HARDNESS OF HEART

 

It is necessary that some Christians be better informed about what hardness of heart actually is, especially those who complain of it most. The metaphor is drawn from the hardness of any material on which a craftsman tries to make an impression. It signifies the passive and active resistance of the heart against the Word and works of God: the heart receives no impression from the Word, refuses to obey God’s commands, and after great and powerful means has been brought to bear, remains exactly as it was before, unmoved, unaffected, and disobedient.

Hardness of heart is therefore not a distinct sin by itself, but rather the habitual power of every sin, the deadness, immovability, and obstinacy of the heart in any sin. There are as many ways the heart can be hardened against the Word as there are duties commanded and sins forbidden. It is accordingly a serious mistake, and one that has had very bad consequences for many people, to suppose that hardness of heart consists in nothing but a lack of passionate feeling in matters of the soul, and especially a lack of sorrow and tears.

This mistake has made people overly anxious about tears and grief, while dangerously underestimating far greater instances of their heart’s hardness. Many beginners in religion, absorbed in penitential duties, think that all repentance amounts to nothing more than a change of opinion unless they experience those passionate griefs and tears that are, it is true, fitting for the penitent. As a result they expend more effort trying to move their hearts to sorrow for sin and to force out tears than they do on many far weightier duties. But when God calls them to love him, to praise him, to be thankful for his mercies, to love an enemy, or to forgive a wrong, when he calls them to mortify their earthly-mindedness, carnality, pride, passion, or disobedience, they yield very little to that call, showing far greater hardness of heart there, while hardly noticing or complaining of it.

Consider, then, that the greater the duty is, the worse it is to harden the heart against it; and the greater the sin is, the worse it is to harden the heart in obstinate continuation of it. The greater duties are the love of God and neighbor, together with a mortified and heavenly mind and life; to resist God’s Word commanding these is the great and dangerous form of heart-hardening.

The life of grace consists in three things:

1. Preferring God, heaven, and holiness above all worldly things in the estimation of the mind.

2. Choosing them and resolving for them in the will above all else.

3. Seeking them in the consistent bent and direction of our endeavors.

These three together constitute a state of holiness. Strength of mental capacity, memory, or expression, and likewise passionate affections of sorrow or joy and the tears that accompany them, are all desirable in their proper time, place, and measure, but they are not necessary to salvation or to the life of grace. They follow largely from the constitution of the body: some people have much of them and yet little or no grace, while others lack them and yet have much grace.

The work of repentance consists chiefly in loathing and breaking with ourselves over our sins, forsaking them with abhorrence, and turning to God. The person who can do this without tears is truly penitent; the person who has ever so many tears without this is still impenitent. The hard-hearted sinner is the one who will not be moved to love holiness or let go of sin when God commands it, who, after all exhortations, mercies, and perhaps afflictions, remains exactly the same, as though never admonished, or as though God’s words and dealings had made no impression at all.

Having explained what hardness of heart is, you will see that I have already given directions against it more fully in Chapter III, Direction VI and VIII. I add here a few further directions.

Direction 1: Remember the majesty and presence of that most holy God with whom we have to do. Nothing will more affect and awe the heart, or govern it in matters of religion, than a true knowledge of God. We do not speak carelessly or contemptuously to a king; how much less should we be dull or contemptuous before the God of heaven? This is the God whom angels worship, who sustains the world, who keeps us in life, who is always present and observes everything we think, say, or do, whose commands lie upon us, and with whom we have to do in all things. Augustine’s word bears on it: a man is not blessed merely because he is patient in his misery. Shall we then be hardened against his fear? "Who hath hardened himself against Him, and hath prospered?" (Job 9:4)

Direction 2: Think seriously about the unspeakable greatness and importance of the truths and realities that should move you, and of the duties required of you. An eternity of joy or torment is so astonishing a thing that one would think every thought and every mention of it, or of anything that bears upon it, ought to go to our very hearts, deeply affect us, and command the obedience and service of our souls. It is true that these are unseen things, and therefore less naturally apt to affect us than visible ones; but their immensity should more than compensate for that disadvantage a thousandfold.

If our lives hung on every word we spoke or every step we took, how carefully we would speak and walk! But how much more deeply ought things to affect us when our everlasting life is at stake! One would think that something of such enormous weight as dying and passing into an endless life of pain or pleasure would so seize and absorb the human mind that we would struggle to bring ourselves to attend to the trivial interests of the body at all. How inexcusable is a dull, careless, negligent heart when God looks upon us and heaven or hell lies just before us, when we are so heavily burdened with our sins, surrounded by so many enemies, and in the midst of such great and manifold dangers, yet remain senseless under all of it. This is, to that degree, to be dead. If a person cannot feel the prick of a pin he will feel the stab of a dagger, if he is alive.

Direction 3: Remember how near the time is when stupidity and senseless neglect of God will be banished from the entire world, and what certain and powerful means await you at death and judgment to awaken and pierce the hardest heart. Very few are entirely without feeling at the point of death; none are past feeling after death, whether in heaven or in hell. No one will stand before the Lord on the day of judgment with a sleepy or senseless heart. As Valerius Maximus said of Dionysius, the divine anger moves with slow step toward its vengeance, and compensates for the slowness of the punishment by its severity.

God will restore your feeling through misery if you will throw it away in sin rather than recover it by grace. He can make you a terror to yourself even now (Jer 20:4); he can make conscience speak things in secret to you that you will not be able to forget or dismiss. But if conscience does not awaken you, the approach of death likely will, when you see that God is now in earnest with you, that die you must, and there is no avoiding it. Will you not then begin to ask, Where must I go? What will become of me forever? Will you harden your heart against God and his warnings even then? If you do, the very first moment of your entrance into eternity will cure your dullness forever.

It ought to grieve any heart that is not stone to consider what feelings those stony-hearted sinners will shortly have, when God purposely makes them feel with his wrathful streams of fire and brimstone, when Satan, who now hinders your feeling, will do his utmost to make you feel; and when conscience, the never-dying worm, gnaws at your heart and makes it feel, without relief or any hope of remedy. Think what an awakening day is coming.

Direction 4: Think often of the love of God in Christ, and of the bloody sufferings of your Redeemer, for this has a mighty power to melt the heart. If love, and the love of God, and a love so great and wonderful, will not soften your hardened heart, what will?

Direction 5: Work toward a full understanding of the evil and danger of a hardened heart. It is the death of the soul to the extent it prevails. At its mildest, it resembles the numbness of a paralyzed limb or a cauterized wound.

Note the names Scripture gives it: "the hardening of the heart" (Prov 28:14); "the hardening of the neck" (Prov 29:1), which signifies inflexibility; "the hardening of the face" (Prov 21:29), which signifies shamelessness; "the searing of the conscience" (1 Tim 4:2); "the impenitence of the heart" (Rom 2:5). Sometimes it is called "foolishness" or "stupidity" (Jer 4:22). Sometimes it is called "not caring," or "not laying things to heart, and not regarding" (Isa 42:25; Isa 5:12; Isa 32:9–11).

Sometimes it is described metaphorically by comparisons to lifeless things: "a face harder than a rock" (Jer 5:3); "stony hearts" (Ezek 11:19; Ezek 36:26); "a neck with an iron sinew, and a brow of brass" (Isa 48:4). It is also called "sleep," a "deep slumber," a "spirit of slumber" (Rom 13:11; Rom 11:8; Matt 25:5), and "death" itself (1 Tim 5:6; Eph 2:1, 5; Col 2:13; Jude 12).

Consider also how dreadful this condition is when it predominates, both in what it signals and in what it produces. It is a forerunner of ruin (Prov 28:14). It is a dreadful sign that conversion is far less likely than in others. When people are "alienated from the life of God by their ignorance," and are "past feeling," they are "given up to work uncleanness with greediness" (Eph 4:18–19). God ordinarily calls those he will save before they are past feeling.

Though such persons are not without hope, their hope lies in recovering the very feeling they have lost. A hardened heart, an iron neck, and a brazen forehead are a sadder sign of God’s displeasure than if he had made the heavens like brass and the earth like iron over you, or had sent the severest bodily affliction upon you. When people have eyes and see not, ears and hear not, and hearts but understand not, it is a grim indication that they are very unlikely to be "converted and forgiven" (Mark 4:12; Acts 28:27).

A hardened heart, when it predominates, is garrisoned and fortified by Satan against every means we can bring to bear. None but the Almighty can drive him out and deliver them. Let a husband, wife, parent, or dearest friend beg a hardened sinner to be converted, and he will not hear them. Let the most learned, wise, and holy person alive both preach and plead with him, and he will not turn. At a distance he may admire and honor a great divine or a learned and holy person, especially when that person is dead; but let the best person on earth be the minister of the parish where he lives and entreat him daily to repent, and he will either hate and persecute him, or neglect and disobey him. What minister, however learned, holy, or powerful a preacher, has not had painful experience of this?

The prophet cried out, "Who hath believed our report?" (Isa 53:1). The apostles were compelled to shake the dust from their feet against many who rejected them, and were abused, scorned, and persecuted by those whose souls they would have saved. Indeed, Jesus Christ himself was refused by most of those who heard him, and no minister should dare compare himself with Christ. If our Lord and Master was blasphemed, scorned, and murdered by sinners, what better should his ablest ministers expect? Augustine found drunkenness so widespread in Africa that he proposed calling a council to suppress it; but if a general council of all the learned bishops and pastors in the world were convened, they could not convert a single hardened sinner by all their authority, wisdom, or diligence, without the power of Almighty God. Will those who are hardened against God be converted by mere human effort?

What could we possibly say to reach their hearts, to get inside them and do them good? Shall we tell them of the law and judgments of the Lord, and of his wrath against them? They have heard all this so often that they sleep through it or laugh at it. Shall we speak of death, judgment, and eternity? We might as well speak to posts, or to men asleep, they hear us as though they heard us not. Shall we describe endless joy and endless torment? They do not feel, and therefore they do not fear or heed. They have heard all these things until they are weary of hearing them, and our words seem to them no more than the sound of wind or running water, signifying nothing.

If miracles were worked among them, if a preacher healed the sick and raised the dead, they would marvel, but would not be converted. Christ did these very things and prevailed with only a few (John 11:48, 53). The apostles worked miracles and were still rejected by most (Acts 7:57; Acts 22:22). Even if one of a hardened person’s old companions were sent back from the dead to warn him, it might frighten him, but would not convert him, Christ himself told us so (Luke 16:31). Or if an angel from heaven were to preach to such a person, he would remain hardened, as Balaam and others were. Christ rose from the dead and was rejected even after that. We have no record of the conversion of the soldiers who guarded his tomb, though they were terrified by the sight of the angels; afterward they were hired for a little money to lie and claim that Christ’s disciples had stolen his body.

If rulers with power over their bodies were to press them toward godliness, they would not obey or be persuaded. King Hezekiah’s messengers were only mocked by the people. David and Solomon could not convert their hardened subjects. Punish them, even execute them, and they remain wicked to the last, witness the impenitent thief who died alongside Christ and died blaspheming him. Though God afflict them with one rod after another, they persist in sin and remain unchanged (Ps 78; Hos 7:14; Amos 4:9; Jer 5:3; Isa 1:5). Let death draw near and look them in the face; let them see that they must shortly go to judgment, it will frighten them, but not convert them. They may know and confess that sin is evil, that holiness is best, that death and eternity are close; yet they remain the same, and nothing will win their hearts to God, until grace removes their stony hearts and gives them tender, fleshy hearts (Ezek 36:26).

Direction 6: Take notice of the terrible effects of hard-heartedness in the world. Hard-heartedness fills the world with wickedness and disorder, with wars and bloodshed, and leaves it under the deplorable abandonment and delusion we see across the greater part of the earth. How many kingdoms are left in the blindness of Heathenism and Mahometanism for hardening their hearts against the Lord! How many Christian nations are given over to the grossest deceits of popery, with princes and people alike resisting reformation, because they hardened their hearts against the light of truth! What vice is so odious, even the most degrading filthiness, the bitterest hatred, the fiercest persecution of God’s ways, that men of every rank do not wallow in it securely through the hardness of their hearts?

This is what grieves the godly, exhausts good magistrates, and breaks the hearts of faithful ministers. Having done their best, they are compelled, like Christ himself before them, to grieve over the hardness of people’s hearts. We live among the dead. Our towns and villages are in a sadder state than Egypt when every house had a corpse in it. Even in our churches, it would be well if the dead were only underground; but most of our pews do not lack a dead man who sits as if he listens and kneels as if he prays, while nothing has ever pierced him to the quick.

We have searched for the most penetrating words; we have preached with tears in the most urgent manner; yet we cannot make them feel. We might as well cry out as Baal’s prophets did, "O Baal, hear us!", or lament as the Irish mourn over their dead: "Why wouldst thou die, and leave thy house, and lands, and friends?" In the same way we speak to people about the death of their souls and their willful misery, and they never feel the weight of anything we say. We are left to sound a peal of lamentation and weep over them as over the dead, who are unmoved by our tears. We cast seed into stony ground (Matt 13:5, 20): it lodges in the surface, and it is not within our power to open their hearts and get inside them.

I confess that we ourselves are much to blame for ever having spoken to such miserable souls without more impassioned earnestness and tears, and it is because the stone of the heart is still too much uncured in ourselves, for which God now justly lays many of us aside. Yet we must say that our urgency is such as leaves them without excuse. We speak to them of the greatest matters in all the world; we speak in the name of God; we show them his own Word; we plead with them using the very arguments he has put in our mouths, and yet we speak as to posts and stones, to people past feeling.

What a pitiful sight it was to see Christ standing and weeping over Jerusalem for the hardness of their hearts and the nearness and greatness of their misery, while they themselves were so far from weeping over it that they raged against the life of the very one who pitied them so deeply! We thank God it is not this way with everyone. He has encouraged some of us with the attentive, yielding, obedient hearing of many large congregations. But even among the best, how many hardened sinners are mixed in, and in many places, how greatly they abound!

This is why such odious abominations are committed: such filthiness, lying, perjury, and malicious hatred toward the servants of the Lord; such widespread enmity against God and godliness. If Satan had not first hardened their hearts, he could never have led them to the shameless crimes now openly committed in the land. As Lot’s daughters were forced to make their father drunk before he would commit incest, so the devil first strips people of both reason and feeling before he can drive them to such heinous wickedness, making them laugh at their own destruction and despise most bitterly those who most earnestly would save them. They are not only past feeling; they so hate every awakening ministry, every truth, every means that would restore their feeling, that they seem to go to hell as some condemned criminals go to the gallows, making themselves drunk beforehand, as though their one concern were to keep themselves blindfolded, knowing and feeling nothing of where they are going, until they arrive there.

See what a picture of a hardened people God gives to Ezekiel: "But the house of Israel will not hearken to thee; for they will not hearken to me: for all the house of Israel are impudent and hard hearted" (Ezek 3:7). Only observe what a case it is that they are so insensible of, and you will see what a hard-hearted sinner, past feeling, really is.

1. They are the servants of sin, in its power and corrupted by it, and yet they do not feel it.

2. They have the guilt of many thousand sins upon them, every one they ever committed still unpardoned, and yet they do not feel it.

3. They have the threatenings and curses of God in force against them in his Word, words so terrible that you would think they might frighten them out of their sins or out of their wits; and they profess to believe this Word of God, and yet they do not feel it.

4. They are in the power of the devil, ruled and deceived by him, and taken captive by him at his will (Acts 26:18 2 Tim 2:26).

5. They may be certain that if they die in this condition they will be damned, and they are uncertain whether they will live another day. They are never sure of being one hour longer out of hell, and yet they do not feel it.

6. They know that they must die, that death will make a great change in them, of the greatest and endless consequence, and that this is both sure and near, and they are past all doubt of it; and yet they do not feel it. Petrarch says: You will be struck, you will die, you will feel it; but whether blind or seeing, that lies in your own hand. Wish, then, to die well, which is itself in vain unless you have lived well. Wish it, I say, strive for it, and do what lies in you; leave the rest to him who brought you into this life without your asking, and who, when you are to go out of it, will give you his hand only if he is called and asked. But do not wish never to die.

7. They must shortly appear before the Lord, be judged for everything they have done in the body, and be sentenced to their endless state; and yet they do not feel it.

8. They know that life is short, that they have only a little time to prepare for all this terrible change, and that it will go with them forever as they now prepare; and yet they do not feel it.

9. They hear and read of the case of hardened, wicked people who have gone before them, who resisted grace and lost their time as they now do, and they read or hear what a miserable end such people came to; and yet they do not feel it.

10. They have a world of examples continually before them. They see the filthy lives of many for their warning and the holy lives of others for their imitation, and they see how Christ and Satan strive for souls; and yet they do not feel it.

11. They are always before the eye of God, and do all this to his face. He warns them and calls them to repentance, and yet they do not feel it.

12. They have Christ as it were crucified before their eyes (Gal 3:1). They hear of his sufferings; they may see in him what sin is and what the love of God is; he pleads with them his blood and his sufferings against their obstinate unkindness; and yet they do not feel it.

13. They have everlasting joy and glory offered to them, and heaven so opened to them in God’s promises that they may see it as in a glass (1 Cor 13:12). They profess to believe how deeply the blessed spirits there abhor such wickedness as theirs; and yet they do not feel it.

14. They have the torments of hell opened to them in the Word of God. They read what impenitent souls must suffer to all eternity; they hear some in despair in this life, roaring in the misery of their souls; they hear the joyful thanksgivings of believers that Christ delivers them from those torments; and yet they do not feel it.

15. All the promises of salvation in the Gospel enter an exception against these people, "unless they be converted." The promises are made to the penitent, not to the impenitent. There is justification and life, but not for them. "There is no condemnation to them that are in Christ Jesus, that walk not after the flesh, but after the Spirit" (Rom 8:1). "But he that believeth not, is condemned already" (John 3:18). And those who "after their hardness and impenitent hearts, do treasure up wrath against the day of wrath" shall have "tribulation and anguish" (Rom 2:5–7). Here is comfort for repenting sinners, but none for these, except on condition that they repent. When others are welcomed to Christ’s marriage feast, he says to these, "How came you in hither?" And yet they do not feel it.

16. They constantly carry about in themselves the grim evidence of all this misery. One might think that the ambitious, the covetous, and the pleasure-seeking would see these death-marks on themselves; that the ungodly would feel that God does not have their hearts, especially those who hate the godly, show wolfish cruelty against them, and are the spiritual offspring of Cain. And yet they feel none of it, but live as quietly and talk as pleasantly as if all were well with their souls, and their calling and election were assured. If these souls were not hardened in sin, we would see it in their tears or hear it in their complaints. They would come to the minister after a sermon, as those in Acts 2:37 and Acts 16:30 came, saying, "Sirs, what must we do to be saved?"

Or we would see it in their lives, or hear it reported by others who had observed the change that grace had made. Sermons would stay with them longer, rather than being dismissed at best with a fruitless compliment, "That was a good sermon," and nothing more. Judge now, by this true description, what a hardened sinner is. And let the godly, seeing all this, so lament the remnants of this evil in themselves as to be daily thankful to God that they are not wholly in its power.

Direction 7: Live, if at all possible, under a lively, quickening ministry and in the company of serious, lively Christians. It is true that we ought to be deeply affected by the truths of God however coldly they are delivered. But the question is not what our duty is; it is what our disease is, what our need is, and what the proper remedy is. All people ought to be so holy as to need no exhortations to conversion at all, but shall ministers therefore neglect such exhortations, or those who need them turn away their ears? Hear, if possible, the minister who first feels what he speaks and speaks what he feels in a way most likely to make you feel it too. "Cry aloud; spare not, lift up thy voice like a trumpet, and shew my people their transgressions, and the house of Israel their sins," though such are those "as seek me daily, and delight to know my ways, as a nation that did righteousness, and forsook not the ordinances of their God" (Isa 58:1–2).

God is the chief agent, but he ordinarily works according to the fitness of the instrument. It is a grievous thing to hear a dead minister speaking the living truths of the living God to a dead people. As Christ said, "If the blind lead the blind, both will fall into the ditch." If the dead must raise the dead, and the ungodly enemies of a holy life must bring people to godliness, that would require a power like the one that once used clay and spittle to open the eyes of the blind. There was a proverb in Christ’s day, "Let the dead bury their dead," but not "Let the dead raise the dead." God may honor the bones of the dead prophet by raising a corpse cast into his grave when it touches them. A meeting of a dead minister with a dead people is like a place of graves.

Though it is a pitiable thing to hear a man speak without any life of eternal life, God can still concur in the quickening of a soul. But we have little reason to expect that he will ordinarily convert people so miraculously, bypassing the natural aptitude of the means.

It is thoroughly incongruous for any person in ordinary conversation to speak of things concerning eternal life without great seriousness and reverence. But for a preacher to speak of God, of Christ, of heaven and hell, as coldly and drowsily as if he were persuading his hearers not to believe him, a man who evidently has no regard for himself, is far less tolerable. It is a sad thing to hear a man drag out a dreaming, dull discourse on such overwhelming matters; to speak as though the art of preaching were to teach people to sleep while the names of heaven and hell are in their ears, and to feel nothing while they receive the message of the living God about their everlasting life or death.

If a man runs into the street to report a fire in the town, or a soldier brings an alarm that the enemy is at the gates, but does so in a reading or jesting tone, the hearers will ignore him and conclude that he does not believe it himself. I know that mere noise will not convert a soul. A ranting fervor that hearers can detect is theatrical and affected rather than from a serious heart will harden the audience worst of all. Rude, irreverent clamor is unworthy of an ambassador of Christ. But an ignorant mouthing of a few confused words, or a drowsy recitation of the most urgent truths, is equally unworthy.

Christ did not raise Lazarus by the loudness of his voice; yet where the physical ears are the passage to the mind, the voice and manner ought to be fitting to the matter. Noise without seriousness and substance is like gunpowder without a bullet: it makes a sound, but does no execution. And the weightiest matter without clear explanation and lively application is like a bullet without powder. If you throw cannon balls at the enemy with your hands, they will fall on your own feet sooner than on his.

It is deadness aggravated by hypocrisy when a lifeless preacher pretends to moderation, as though he were afraid of speaking too loudly or too earnestly, lest he should wake the dead whom lightning and thunder will not wake; when he excuses himself by accusing those who are not as drowsy or as dead as he is; and when he would have people believe that seriousness is intemperate rage or madness. If you are cast upon a cold and sleepy minister, consider the matter more than the manner; but do not choose such a one for the cure of hardness and insensibility of heart.

Direction 8: Notice how tender-hearted Christians are moved by sins far less serious than those you treat as a joke, and how deeply those matters touch their hearts that leave yours unmoved. Do you not have as much cause to be stirred as they? Do you not need to take such things to heart as much as they do? If you only knew what a burden it is to them to be haunted by temptations to the unbelief and atheism that prevail so easily with you, though they are far from choosing or delighting in such things!

You would see how involuntary thoughts and frailties make some of them weary of themselves, and how they almost hate their own hearts for believing so little, for loving God so little, and for feeling so distant from God and heaven, when nothing in the world is more precious to them or commands more of their esteem and effort. You would surely think that if such hearts had your sin and misery to feel, they would feel it to their grief indeed, unless the sin itself were deadening the feeling, as it does with you. Let tender-hearted Christians instruct you, and do not allow them to stand as witnesses against you.

Direction 9: Guard against company, examples, and conversation that harden the heart. Hearing people rail and scoff at holiness, curse, swear, and blaspheme the name and truth of God will at first make you tremble. But if you willfully and habitually place yourself in such company, your sensitivity and tenderness will gradually disappear. You will discover a very powerful hardening force in the company you keep, in the conversations you hear, and in the practices you witness, even those you inwardly condemn.

Direction 10: Guard against willful sinning against knowledge, and still more against continuing in such sin without repentance. To sin against knowledge greatly hardens the heart; to commit the same sins again and again hardens it far more. This grieves and drives away the Spirit, and dangerously provokes God to leave a person to themselves.

Direction 11: Guard against approaching the very means appointed to cure a hardened heart as mere routine. If lively preaching, holy living, and fervent prayer from the servants of God become to you nothing more than matters of course, if you go to church and to prayers as you eat and drink, or kneel only out of habit, you will become like the blacksmith’s dog, which sleeps beside the anvil while the hammers are beating and sparks fly around its ears. It is dangerous to grow dull and customary under powerful and lively means of grace.

Direction 12: Spend time often with the sick and in the house of mourning. Read your lesson in the churchyard, and let the grave, the bones, and the dust instruct you. When you see the end of all the living, perhaps you will begin to lay it to heart. Sight can sometimes accomplish what hearing even greater truths cannot. Fear may touch a heart that does not yet have enough tenderness to be melted by love. And ordinarily, the humbling and softening of a hard, impenitent heart begins in fear and ends in love. The work of preparation is almost entirely the work of fear alone. The first work of true conversion begins with a great measure of fear and some measure of love, though so little love that it is scarcely perceived, because fear’s operations are so much more keenly felt. As a Christian grows, love increases, until in the state of perfection perfect love casts out all tormenting fear, though not our reverence or filial fear of God.

Look, then, into the grave, and remember, man, that you must die, you must die, it is beyond all dispute that you must die. And do you know where you must appear when death has done its work? Do you not believe that after death comes judgment? Do you not know that you are now living a life of trial, the outcome of which is endless joy or endless misery? That this life is lived only once? That if you fail now you are ruined forever? That all hope of escaping damnation exists only now, while this life of trial continues? "Now is the accepted time: this is the day of salvation." If hell is to be avoided, it must be avoided now. If you will ever pray, if you will ever be converted, if you will ever be made an heir of heaven, it must be now.

How quickly will patience have done with you, and time be gone, and then it will be too late. Do you not know that all the care, labor, and hope of the devil for your damnation is directed this one way: to find you other work if possible, to fill your thoughts with other things, to keep you asleep with presumptuous hopes, carnal pleasure, mirth, and company, or to quiet you with delays until time is gone and it is too late? Will you let him have his way, and oblige him with your own destruction? Do you think these are not things worth considering? Do they not deserve your most urgent and serious thought? At least use your reason and your love for yourself to awaken, move, and soften your hardened heart.

CHAPTER 43

DIRECTIONS AGAINST HYPOCRISY

 

Hypocrisy is playing the part of a religious person, as an actor on a stage, while not being truly religious. It is seeming in religion to be what you are not, or to do what you do not. It is counterfeiting a piety you do not possess. To counterfeit a state of godliness is a sin belonging only to the unregenerate, who are at present in a state of misery. To counterfeit some particular act of godliness is an odious sin, but one into which even a regenerate person may be tempted. This act of hypocrisy does not make a person a hypocrite; it is the state of hypocrisy that does so. Every hypocrite, therefore, is an ungodly person who appears godly, someone who is not truly a Christian, yet professes to be one.

Abraham Bucholtzer observed that many kiss Christ but few love him: to love is one thing, to kiss another. The Stoics, as Diogenes Laertius records in his account of Zeno, held that the wise are sincere, taking anxious care never to be commended as better than they are by any paint or artifice that hides what is bad in them and makes what is good appear, and cutting away every pretence from their speech. Paul Scaliger said that philosophy is so difficult a thing that even to counterfeit it is a great part of philosophy. One of the Roman laws of the Twelve Tables ran, "Let no ungodly person dare to go about to appease the displeasure of the gods by gifts," that is, he must appease them first by reformation. And Seneca said that a good conscience wishes to come forward and be seen, while wickedness fears the very darkness that covers it.

There are two kinds of hypocrites. Some wish to deceive others but not themselves; they know they are dissemblers. These are commonly called gross hypocrites. Others deceive both themselves and those around them; they do not believe themselves to be hypocrites, but are as confident of their honesty and sincerity as if they were no dissemblers at all. Yet they are just as truly hypocrites as the first kind, because they seem to be religious and sincere when they are not, even though they think they are, and they profess to be true Christians when they are nothing of the kind. These are called close hypocrites, because they do not know themselves to be hypocrites, though they could know it if they were willing. This is the most common sort.

There are also two degrees of hypocrites. Some make only a general profession of Christianity and godliness, the professed religion of the country where they live, and are hypocrites simply because they profess to be what they are not. Others make a greater and extraordinary profession of special strictness in their religion while remaining insincere. These are pre-eminently called hypocrites: such as the Pharisees were among the Jews, and such as many friars, Jesuits, and nuns are among the Papists, who by their separating vows, orders, and habits profess an extraordinary degree of devotion, while they lack the life of godliness altogether.

In all hypocrisy two things are worth noting: first, the thing pretended; second, the pretence, that is, the means of appearing, or the cloak of their deceit.

1. The thing pretended by common hypocrites is to be true Christians, servants of God, and heirs of heaven, though not to be as zealous as those of a higher degree. The thing pretended by eminent hypocrites is to be zealous, eminent Christians, or at least to be sincere in a special manner, while they can see that the common hypocrite is not sincere.

2. The cloak by which they would be thought to be what they are not is, in general, anything that has the appearance of godliness and is apt to make others think them godly. Accordingly there are various sorts of hypocrites, distinguished by the variety of their cloaks and ways of dissimulation, though hypocrisy itself is the same thing in all of them.

Even among the very Mahometans and heathens there arise notable hypocrites who, by pretended revelations and austerity of life, profess themselves, as Mahomet did, to be holy persons having some extraordinary familiarity with God or angels. Among the Papists, beyond the common variety, there are as many sorts of hypocrites as there are self-devised orders. Everywhere the cloak of the common hypocrite is so thin and transparent that it reveals his nakedness to the more discerning; this drives the eminent hypocrite to adopt some more plausible pretence that is not so easily seen through.

For instance, the hypocrisy of common Papists, whose cloak is made up of penances and ceremonies, of reciting Latin phrases, or counting words and beads as prayers, along with all the rest of their religious apparatus (see Chapter III, Grand Direction 15, Direction 11), is so thin a cloak that it will not satisfy some even among themselves. These withdraw into distinct societies and orders, as though the Church and the profession of Christianity were not enough, so that they may be seen as religious, implying that the rest are not. The common ungodly Protestants, for their part, have enough discernment to see through all Popish hypocrisy, and so they take up a cloak better suited to themselves: the name of a Protestant Reformed religion and church, combined with a common profession of Christianity. The name and profession of a Christian and a Protestant, with church attendance and a heartless lip-service in saying their prayers, is the cloak of all ungodly Protestants.

Others, perceiving the thinness of this cloak, think to make themselves a better one. They adopt the strictest opinions in religion, align themselves with what they consider the strictest party, and embrace what they regard as the purest and most spiritual form of worship. The cloak of these people is their opinions, their party, and their manner of worship, while their carnal lives expose their hypocrisy.

Some who can see through all these pretences take up the most excellent cloak of all: an appearance of serious spirituality in religion, combined with due observance of all the outward means and a reformation of life in works of piety, justice, and charity. I say, an appearance of all these, for if they had these things in reality, they would be sincere and would be saved. It is here that the genuine Christian surpasses them all.

From this it is plain that, among us in England, all who are not saints are hypocrites, because all, save here or there a Jew or infidel, profess themselves to be Christians, and every true Christian is a saint. They know that none but saints and godly persons will be saved, and few of them are willing to abandon their hope of heaven; so they must all pretend to be godly. Is it not the most accursed and horrid hypocrisy for a man to claim religion as the only way to his salvation, and confidently call himself a Christian, while he hates and mocks the very power and practice of the religion he professes? On this, see my treatise "Vain Religion of the Formal Hypocrite."

The hypocrite’s aims in his pretences and dissemblings are not all the same. One intends to please parents or friends on whom he depends, who would otherwise be displeased with him and think ill of him. Another intends to please those in authority, when it happens that they favor godliness. Another intends to preserve his reputation among religious people, so that they will not judge him wicked and profane. Another intends to conceal some particular villainy, or to advance some ambitious enterprise. But the most common aim is to quiet and comfort a guilty soul with an image of that holiness it lacks, and to steal some peace for the conscience by means of a lie. Because they will not be truly religious, they take up some show or image of religion, to make themselves as well as others believe that they are religious.

Direction 1: To escape hypocrisy, understand clearly what the life and power of godliness consists in, and how it differs from the lifeless image or empty shell of godliness. The life of godliness is set out in the Seventeen Grand Directions in Chapter III. It consists principally in such a faith in Christ as causes us to love God above all things, to obey him before all others, and to prefer his favor and the hope of heaven over all the pleasures, profits, and honors of the world, and to worship him in spirit and truth, according to the direction of his Word. The images or counterfeits of religion were described above. Beware of any such lifeless image.

When Petrarch, writing of his own life, mentions how others extolled his eloquence, he adds his own low estimate of it: if only he had lived well, he would care little how he had spoken, for it is a windy glory to seek fame from the mere splendor of words. Attend to conscience rather than to fame, says Seneca; fame may often be deceived, but conscience never.

Direction 2: Make your chief study the state of your heart: see that God’s image is planted there, his interest advanced, the pull of the world and the flesh subdued, the love of every sin cast out, and the love of holiness taking its place. Do not content yourself with appearing to do good in outward acts while you are bad within, a stranger to the great internal duties.

The first and great work of a Christian concerns the heart. It is there that God dwells by his Spirit in his saints, and there that sin and Satan reign in the ungodly. The greatest duties and the greatest sins belong to the heart. The heart is the root of all good and evil; the tongue and the life are merely the fruits and expressions of what dwells within.

We must live, said Seneca, as though we lived in open sight, and think as though someone could look into our inmost breast, for someone can. He said also that you may judge our morals by this: you will scarcely find anyone who could live with his door open. It is our conscience, not our pride, that has posted the doorkeepers; we live in such a way that to be suddenly looked upon is to be caught out.

The inward habit of sin is a second nature, and a sinful nature is worse than a sinful act. "Keep your hearts with all diligence: for from thence are the issues of life" (Prov 4:23). Make the tree good and the fruit will be good; but the "viperous generation that are evil, cannot speak good: for out of the abundance of the heart the mouth speaketh" (Matt 12:33–34). Until the Spirit has regenerated the soul, all outward religion is nothing but a dead and pitiful thing. Although there is something God has appointed an unregenerate person to do toward his own conversion, no such preparatory act will prove that the person is justified or reconciled to God until he is converted. To construct a religion out of saying or doing something good while the heart is empty of the Spirit of Christ and sanctifying grace, that is the hypocrite’s religion.

Direction 3: Make your conscience sensitive to sins of thought and desire, and the other affections and passions of the mind, just as much as to sins of tongue or hand. A lustful thought, a malicious thought, a proud, ambitious, or covetous thought, especially when it advances to a wish, a contrivance, or a consent, is a sin all the more dangerous for being so inward and near the heart, as Christ shows in Matthew 5–6. The hypocrite, who cares most about the eye of man, lives as though his thoughts were free from all accountability.

Direction 4: Make your conscience as sensitive to secret sins committed out of the sight of others, and concealed from them, as to open and notorious sins. If he can act in the dark and protect his reputation, the hypocrite is bold; but a sincere believer carries a reverence for conscience, and far more for the all-seeing God.

Direction 5: Be faithful in secret duties that have no witness but God and conscience, duties such as meditation, self-examination, and secret prayer, and do not be religious only in the sight of others.

Direction 6: In all public worship, labor harder with the heart than with the tongue or the knee, and see that your tongue does not outrun your heart and leave it behind. Do not neglect the careful composure of your words and the proper behavior of your body; but take far greater pains to exercise holy desires from a believing, loving, and fervent soul.

Direction 7: Do not place more weight on the externals, modes, circumstances, or ceremonies of worship than is their due, and do not spend more zeal on indifferent or minor things than they deserve. Let the great essentials of religion take precedence and be far preferred over lesser matters. Let the love of God and neighbor be the sum of your obedience, and be sure you understand well what it means: "I will have mercy, and not sacrifice." Remember that the great thing God requires of you is "to do justice, and love mercy, and walk humbly with your God." Do not destroy with your scruples those for whom Christ died. Do not call for fire from heaven upon those who differ from you, and do not think every person in the church intolerable simply because he does not agree with you in every small matter.

A pitiful cure of the Indians’ idolatry is the one the honest Jesuit Acosta prescribes, as the rest of them do: that care must especially be taken to introduce saving rites in place of hurtful ones, and to obliterate ceremonies by ceremonies; that the priests should persuade the novices that holy water, images, rosaries, grains, and torches, and the rest which the church allows and uses, are very fit for them, and should extol these with many praises in their popular sermons, so that instead of the old superstition the people may be accustomed to new and religious signs. This is to quench the fire with oil.

Remember that Christ described the hypocrisy of the Pharisees as consisting in zeal for their own traditions and human inventions, and for the smallest matters of the ceremonial law, combined with neglect of the greatest moral duties and furious cruelty toward sincere, spiritual worshippers of God. "Why do thy disciples transgress the tradition of the elders? for they wash not their hands when they eat bread. Ye hypocrites, well did Esaias prophesy of you, saying, This people draweth nigh unto me with their mouth, and honour me with their lips, but their heart is far from me: but in vain do they worship me, teaching for doctrines the commandments of men" (Matt 15:2, 7–10).

"They bind heavy burdens, which they touch not themselves. All their works they do to be seen of men: they make broad their phylacteries, and enlarge the borders of their garments; and love the uppermost rooms at feasts, and the chief seats in the synagogues, and greetings in public, and to be called Rabbi. But they shut up the kingdom of heaven against men" (Matt 23:4–6, 13–14), and were the greatest enemies to the people’s reception of the Gospel. They "tithed mint, and anise, and cummin, and omitted the great matters of the law, judgment, and mercy, and faith." They "strained at a gnat and swallowed a camel." They showed great veneration for the "dead prophets and saints," yet persecuted and murdered their living successors (Matt 23:23).

From this description you can see which way hypocrisy most ordinarily works: toward a blind and bloody zeal for opinions, traditions, ceremonies, and other small things, trampling down the interest of Christ and his Gospel, neglecting the life and power of godliness, and cruelly persecuting those servants of Christ whom they are bound to love far above any ceremony. I marvel that many Papists do not tremble when they read Christ’s portrait of the Pharisees, but hypocrisy is a hidden sin, and is an enemy to the very light that would expose it.

Direction 8: Make your conscience sensitive to the duties of obedience to those in authority, and of justice and mercy toward others, just as much as to acts of piety toward God. Do not say a long mass in order to devour a widow’s house, or a Christian’s life or reputation. Be as exact in justice and mercy as you are in prayer, and labor as earnestly to surpass common people in the one as in the other. Devote yourself to doing all the good you can for all people, to harming none, and to treating everyone as you would wish to be treated.

Direction 9: Be far more occupied with yourself than with others, more searching in your judgment of yourself than of other people, and more strict in reforming yourself than anyone else. This is the mark of the sincere person. The hypocrite, by contrast, spends little time at home and much time abroad: he is a sharp reproacher of others while being ruinously soft and indulgent toward himself.

Listen to his talk in any company, and you will hear how freely he censures and bitterly reproaches others, how this person and that person (whoever differs from him, has opposed him, or whom he simply dislikes) is thus and so faulty, bad, and hateful. He is just as ready to accuse his adversaries of hypocrisy as if he were not a hypocrite himself, because he can charge them with a heart-sin without any visible means of refuting him. If he called them drunkards, swearers, persecutors, or oppressors, everyone who knew them would know he was lying; but when he speaks of matters hidden from view, he counts his slanders harder to disprove. You hear many a word from him about how bad his adversaries are, but without such hypocritical talk to betray him, he would never tell you how bad he is himself.

It is one of Thales’s sayings, recorded by Diogenes Laertius, that when he was asked how we shall live best and most justly, he answered: if we ourselves do not do what we blame in others. To judge of ourselves as we judge of others is the way of the sincere.

Direction 10: Be impartial, and place yourself before your conscience in the same cases you judge in others. Ask yourself: "How would I judge this behavior in a man I am used to blaming? What would I say of him if my adversary did what I do? Is it not as bad in me as in him? Is not the sin most dangerous to me that lies closest to me? Ought I not to be more watchful over my own faults than over any other man’s? His sin will not cause my damnation, but my own may. Instead of seeing the gnat in his eye, I have far more reason to cast a gnat out of my own than a camel out of his."

Direction 11: Study first to be whatever you genuinely desire to seem. Desire a thousand times more to be godly than to seem so; to be generous than to be thought so; and to be free from every secret or presumptuous sin than to be esteemed such. Velleius Paterculus wrote of Cato that he was a man most like virtue itself, who never did right in order to seem to do it, but because he could not do otherwise, and to whom that alone seemed to have reason in it which had justice in it. When you feel the desire to be regarded as good, let that desire remind you how much more necessary and desirable it is to actually be good. To be godly is to be an heir of heaven, your salvation follows from it. To be esteemed godly profits you very little.

Direction 12: Do not overvalue other people, and place no more weight on their approval, admiration, or opinions of you than those things actually deserve. Hypocrisy consists largely in overvaluing other people and making too great a matter of their thoughts and words. The hypocrite’s religion is divine in name but human in practice: it is human beings he chiefly serves and observes; the world’s contempt is the evil he most carefully avoids; and the world’s high esteem and praise is his reward.

Consider what a feeble creature a person is, and how little their thoughts or words about you matter compared to the love of God. Their thoughts neither make you better nor worse. If those thoughts either lift you up or trouble you, it is your own pride and foolishness at work, and you could choose otherwise. If you have not lost the government of your own heart, shut the door and keep all such things out. Let people’s reproaches go no further than your ears, and what harm will all the world’s lies and slanders do you? And what good, beyond the gratification of a self-indulgent mind, does their applause do you?

Jerome complained that even in his day these things were sought in the churches: the apostolic simplicity and purity of speech abandoned, and the congregation gathering as though to a lecture hall, so that the applause of the bystanders might be stirred up, and a sermon painted over with the falsehood of rhetorical art might walk out in public like some little harlot, seeking the people’s favor rather than teaching the people.

Direction 13: Look upon everyone you deal with as on the verge of death, turning to dust, and passing into that world where their censure or esteem of you will matter to you very little. If you act in front of an infant, you take little account of his presence or opinion. You would take even less account of the dead. If you knew a man were to die tomorrow, even if he were a prince, you would not be greatly troubled to avoid his censure or secure his praise, because his thoughts all perish with him, and it is a small thing what he thinks of you for a single day.

Since all people are hastening to their graves, and you know with certainty that everyone who applauds or censures you will soon be gone, how little should you care about their judgment! Look in the face of the person whose praise you desire or whose criticism you fear, and remember that he is a breathing clod of clay. How many such people now lie in the grave whose opinions you once valued just as much, and this reflection will make you far less anxious about the matter.

Direction 14: At the very least, remember that you yourself are passing out of this world, and should expect at any moment to be called away, knowing with certainty that you will be here only a little while. Is it really so great a matter what strangers think of you as you are passing by? You are quite content that your name, worth, and virtues remain unknown at the inn where you stay only a night, and that they go unrecognized by travelers you meet on the road. The foolish expectation of more time on earth than God has given you any warrant to expect is the very thing that causes us to overvalue human judgment, just as it causes us to overvalue everything else earthly, and it is a great sustainer of every sensual vice.

Direction 15: Apply yourself to mortifying self-love and pride, for hypocrisy is nothing but the outworking of these. Hypocrisy dies to the degree that pride dies, and to the degree that self-denial and humility prevail. Hypocrisy is a proud desire to appear better than you are. Be thoroughly humbled and lowly in your own eyes, and hypocrisy is finished.

Direction 16: Be most suspicious of your own heart in cases where self-interest or strong passions are involved, for in the smoke and confusion of such disorders, your heart will easily deceive you. Interest and passion so blind the mind that you may sincerely believe you are defending the truth and serving God with genuine zeal, when all along you are only defending some error of your own, serving yourself, and fighting against God.

The Pharisees thought they were siding with God’s law and truth against Christ. The pope, his cardinals, and his bishops think, as in charity I must assume, that it is for Christ, for unity, and for truth that they work to bring the world under their own power. And what but self-interest blinds them into such hypocrisy? In the same way, passionate disputants typically deceive themselves, genuinely believing they are zealous for the faith when they are merely contending for their own honor or cherished opinions. Passion hides a great deal of deceit from the person in its grip.

Direction 17: Be most on your guard against hypocrisy in the company of the great, the wise, the learned, and the godly, or whoever else’s favor, opinion, or applause you most value. It is easy for a thorough hypocrite to despise the favor or opinion of the common crowd, the ignorant, or the profane, whose judgment he holds in contempt. It is no great honor or dishonor to be praised or blamed by a child, a fool, or someone who has become contemptible through ignorance or wickedness.

But hypocrisy and pride work hardest to win the esteem of those whose judgment or abilities you most admire. One person admires worldly greatness most, and such a person will play the hypocrite most energetically to flatter and please the powerful people he admires. Another, wiser person admires the judgment of the learned above all, and he will play the hypocrite to win their good opinion, though he can dismiss a thousand ignorant people without a thought, indeed, his very pride will cause him to dismiss them. Yet another, wiser still, is convinced of the excellence of godly people above all the great and learned of the world; and this person is in the greatest danger of pride and hypocrisy in seeking the good opinion of the godly. He can despise the greatest multitude of the ignorant and profane, and his pride will even lead him to count their opposition and contempt as an addition to his glory.

Direction 18: Keep in mind the perfections of the God you worship: that he is a Spirit, and therefore must be worshipped in spirit and in truth; that he is supremely great and awesome, and therefore must be worshipped with seriousness and reverence, not trifled with or served with empty, lifeless lip-service; that he is supremely holy, pure, and jealous, and therefore must be worshipped in purity; and that he is always present with you, and "all things are naked and open to him with whom we have to do." The knowledge of God and the remembrance of his all-seeing presence are the most powerful means against hypocrisy.

Christ himself argues from the nature of God, who is a Spirit, against the hypocritical ceremonialism of the Samaritans and Jews (John 4:23–24). Hypocrites offer to God what they know an ordinarily wise person would scorn if it were offered to him. If a man could see their hearts as God does, would he be pleased with words, compliments, and gestures unaccompanied by any genuine seriousness of mind? Would he be pleased with affected, theatrical performances? Someone who watches a Papist priest emerge in his vestments and lead the people, in a language they do not understand, to worship God through a multitude of ceremonies and droning, repeated, customary words, would think he was watching a stage actor playing a part, not a wise and holy people seriously worshipping the most holy God.

And not only in formal worship, but in private duties, in dealing with others, and in the whole of your life, the remembrance of God’s presence is a powerful rebuke to all hypocrisy. It is more foolish to sin in the sight of God because you can hide it from the world, than to steal or commit adultery in the open marketplace before a crowd while being careful only that dogs and crows do not notice. If the whole world sees you, that is far less than if God sees you in secret. "Be not deceived, God is not mocked" (Gal 6:7).

Direction 19: Remember how much God hates hypocrisy, and what punishment is appointed for hypocrites. They are joined in torment with unbelievers. Just as wicked men’s punishment is aggravated by being condemned to the fire prepared for the devil and his angels, so the punishment of ordinary ungodly persons is aggravated by the fact that their portion shall be with hypocrites and unbelievers. How often do you find the Lamb of God himself thundering his woes against the hypocritical scribes and Pharisees! How often does he press upon his disciples, "Be not as the hypocrites" (Matt 6:2, 5, 16).

No wonder hypocrites are hateful to God: they and their services are lifeless images, bearing nothing but the name and outward shell of Christianity, dressed up with antique forms and human ornaments of wit and ability, as a corpse is more adorned with flowers than the living, needing those ceremonies to compensate for the absence of life that would otherwise keep it wholesome. A carcass is not pleasing to God. The hypocrite also insults God, acting as if God were like the heathen’s idols, with eyes that cannot see, unable to discern the secret deceits of the heart; or as if God were like fools and children, pleased with fair words and trifles. God cannot but hate such abuse.

Direction 20: Come into the light, so that your hearts and lives may be thoroughly known to you. Seek out the most searching and faithful ministry and books, and be thankful for those who rebuke you and deal plainly with you. Darkness is what nourishes deceit; it is the office of light to expose it. Those wretches who perish in their hypocrisy justly do so, for they will not endure the light that would undeceive them. They flee from a plain and powerful ministry, hate plain reproof, and arm themselves with excuses and quibbles to defend their own deceit.

Direction 21: Be very diligent in examining your hearts and all your actions by the Word of God, and frequently call yourself to a strict account. Deceit and guilt cannot endure strict examination. The Word of God is living and powerful, discovering the thoughts and imaginations of the heart. There is no hypocrite who could not be delivered from his own self-deception, if, with the help of an able guide, he would faithfully pursue the work of self-examination without partiality or sloth.

Direction 22: Live continually as one who is about to be judged at the bar of God, where all hypocrisy will be exposed and shamed, and condemned by the all-knowing God.

Tauler draws the picture exactly. Those who are lukewarm, lazy, negligent, vain, superficial, pleasure-seeking, and self-indulgent, who pursue bodily comforts and their own advantage in everything, and wherever possible preserve their reputation and good name, are inwardly stubborn servants of their own will: they are unresigned, far from self-denial, proud, prying, and contrary in all things, even if outwardly they appear well-mannered before everyone. In temptation they are impatient, bitter, provocative, angry, and sullen, troublesome to others, yet clever in words and wit. In prosperity they are excessively elated and jovial; in adversity, excessively troubled and fainthearted. They are rash judges of others; they think it an excellent thing to scrutinize others’ faults with great care, to gossip frequently about others’ failings, and to boast of them. From these and similar works they can most easily be recognized, for by their manners and gestures they betray themselves, as the shrew is known by its own telltale movements.

One thought of appearing before the Lord, and of the day of his impartial judgment, ought to make a person walk in the light and understand that the sun is not eclipsed every time they shut their eyes, nor does night fall because they draw the curtains. What a shame it will be to have all your dissembling laid open before the entire world! "Beware of the leaven of the Pharisee, which is hypocrisy: for there is nothing covered, which shall not be revealed; neither hid, that shall not be known. Therefore whatever ye have spoken in darkness shall be heard in the light; and that which ye have spoken in the ear in closets, shall be proclaimed on the house-tops."

Direction 23: Do not imagine you have escaped hypocrisy simply by changing its outward expression; take care that while avoiding a grosser form you do not fall into a more subtle one. There is no outward manner of worshipping God, and no religious opinion so sound, that a hypocrite cannot make a cloak of it. You may observe an ignorant, ridiculous hypocrite, such as Bishop Hall describes in his character sketch, who can pray facing a pillar while his heart has no idea what his tongue is doing, who babbles over a few words to God while dressing or washing himself and talking in between to those standing nearby, who offers God the sacrifice of a fool without knowing that he does evil, who serves God with trifles and theatrical gestures, and repeats certain words that have never been acquainted with any feeling of the heart, nor scarcely with his understanding.

To avoid his hypocrisy, perhaps you can merrily mock him, making the formal Popish hypocrite the subject of your jokes, while you yourself, with sound understanding, pour out hours of orderly and fitting prayer. But remember that many a hypocrite makes himself a cloak of cloth just as fine as this. Pride has all the more advantage to work on your greater knowledge and better abilities; and hypocrisy is nothing but the offspring of pride. All of this, without a heart entirely devoted to God, is merely a better-dressed corpse, as the wealthy have more elaborate monuments than the poor. There is no outward thing in which a hypocrite may not appear excellent.

Direction 24: Be true to your conscience, listen diligently to all it says, treat with it often, and make it your daily, familiar companion. Hypocrites have little respect for their conscience. They deal with it so often and so boldly that conscience is effectively deposed from its office and silenced, lest it trouble them by preaching those hard sayings they cannot bear, until at last it is seared or bribed into taking the side of sin. Yet ordinarily a hypocrite carries a secret judge within who condemns him. Take great care how you treat your conscience, as you value your peace and happiness. Next to Christ, it must be your best friend or your greatest enemy. However much you smooth it over now, if you wound it, it will ache at last. Poverty, shame, and torment are easier to bear than its wounds.

1.) Mark the very principles and settled judgment of your conscience; and if they have changed, know what changed them.

2.) Listen to all the secret counsel and reproofs of conscience, especially when it speaks often and forcefully. Do not dismiss it without a hearing; learn the reason even for its scruples and doubts.

3.) When conscience is troubled and disquieted, discover what the matter is, and expel whatever rightly disturbs it, whatever the cost. Be sure you go to the bottom and do not leave the root behind.

4.) Open your conscience to some able and trustworthy guide when that is necessary, even if it costs you shame. An overly tender avoidance of such shame is the hypocrite’s own sin and folly. Counsel is safe in matters of such importance.

5.) Prefer conscience over every human authority, however great. None stands above it but God. Conscience is God’s messenger when it is truly conscience. Remember what it says to you, from whom it comes, and for what purpose. Let friends, neighbors, company, business, profit, pleasures, and honor all stand aside while conscience speaks, for it will prove a better friend to you than any of these, if you treat it as a friend. It would have served Judas better than his thirty pieces of silver.

6.) Yet see that conscience is well informed; examine its warrant, for it is not above God and is not without a master or law. What is the use of hiding yourself and avoiding the eyes and ears of other people? A good conscience invites a crowd; a guilty conscience is anxious and troubled even in solitude. If what you do is honorable, let everyone know it; if it is shameful, what does it matter that no one else knows, when you yourself know? How wretched you are if you despise this witness within you. (Seneca, Epistles, 43) (Matt 23:13–15, 23, 25, 27, 29)

7.) Do not converse with conscience only in a crowd, but in secret.

8.) Keep it awake; keep it among awakening means and company. It will fall asleep far more readily in a tavern or a playhouse, or among the foolish and profane, than at a lively sermon, in prayer, or in reverent conversation about God.

If I could but get conscience awakened to do its office, and preach over all that I have said here in secret, it would ferret the hypocrite out of his self-deception. Go, conscience, and search that deceitful heart; speak to it in the name of God. Ask the hypocrite whether conversion ever made him a new creature, and whether his soul and all that he has are entirely devoted to God; whether his hopes and treasure are laid up in heaven and his heart is there; whether he subjects all his worldly interest to the will of God and the good of his soul; whether his greatest work is the care of his heart and the aim to approve himself to God; and whether he makes an impartial and diligent inquiry after the truth, with a desire to receive it at whatever cost.

Tell him that a proud self-flattery may now lead him to justify or minimize his sins, to take his formalities and lip-service and abuse of God for true devotion, and to hate every person who would expose his hypocrisy and seek to convert him by bringing in the light, but a light will shortly appear to his soul that he shall not be able to resist. And then let him stand to his defense if he can; and let him then make it good that he gave himself up in sincerity, simplicity, and self-denial to his God.

Direction 25: Remember that hypocrisy consists largely in doubling, in a divided heart and life. Serve God, therefore, in singleness of heart, in simplicity and integrity, as belonging entirely to him. Do not think of serving God and mammon. A deep reserve kept for the world in the heart, even while a person seems to give himself up in covenant to God, is the defining mark of a hypocrite. Live as those who have one Lord and Master to whom all power bows, one end or goal to which everything else is only a means, one work of absolute necessity to perform, one kingdom to seek first and with the greatest care and diligence to make sure of, those whose hearts and faces are always turned one way, and who are consistent in what they think, say, and do. A double heart and a double tongue are the habits of the hypocrite.

He keeps one heart for the world, for pride, and for lust, a heart that must occasionally seem to be lifted up to beg forgiveness, so that he may sin on in quietness and hope of salvation. You would not guess, watching him count his beads or lift up his hands and eyes in what seems devout prayer, how recently he came from a tavern, a brothel, a lie, or from scorning serious godliness. As Bishop Hall says, he seems to serve at church on holy days the God he neglects at home, and bows at the name of Jesus while swearing profanely by the name of God.

Remember that there is only one God, one heaven for us, one happiness, and one way, and this one thing is of such weight that it calls for the full intention and attention of our souls, is enough to satisfy us, and is enough to call us away from everything that would divert us. A divided heart is a false and self-deceiving heart. Are there two Gods? Is Christ divided? While you grasp at both God and the world, you will certainly lose one, and very likely lose both. To have two Gods, two rules, two heavens is to have no God, no true rule, no heaven, and no happiness at all. Do not halt, therefore, between two opinions: if God is God, obey and love him; if heaven is heaven, make sure it is sought first. But if your belly is your god and the world is your heaven, then serve and seek them, and make the best of them you can.

Direction 26: Guard against all that fleshly cunning and worldly wisdom that runs contrary to the wisdom of the Word of God and would draw you away from the plain open-heartedness that godly sincerity requires. Let what was Paul’s boast be yours, that in simplicity and godly sincerity, not in fleshly wisdom, you have conducted yourself in the world. Christianity does not renounce wisdom or honest self-preservation, but it does make people plain-hearted and hostile to crafty, fraudulent minds.

What is that famous hypocritical religion added on top of Christianity and called Popery, but precisely what Paul feared in his godly jealousy for the Corinthians: "lest as the serpent beguiled Eve by his subtilty, so their minds should be corrupted from the simplicity that is in Christ" (2 Cor 11:3)? To forsake the Christian simplicity of doctrine, discipline, worship, and conduct is the hypocrisy of religion and of life. Equivocation, dishonest evasions, and concealment suit those who have a bad cause, a guilty conscience, or a master they dare not trust, not those who have so good a cause and so good a God as Christians have.

Direction 27: Remember how much of sincerity consists in seriousness, and how much of hypocrisy consists in merely seeming, dreaming, and trifling with the things of God and our salvation. Keep your souls awake, therefore, in a sensible and serious frame. Read through the fifty considerations I have given in the third part of my Saints’ Rest to convince you of the necessity of being serious. See that there is as much substance in your faith as in your creed, and as much reality in your hearts and lives as in your professed belief. Remember that seeming and dreaming will not mortify deep-rooted sins, nor conquer strong and subtle enemies, nor make you acceptable to God, nor save your souls from his avenging justice.

Consider what a mad kind of profaneness it is to jest and trifle about heaven and hell, and to dally with the great and dreadful God. "Seeing all these things shall be dissolved, what manner of persons ought you to be in all holy conversation and godliness?" (2 Pet 3:11) You pray for an obedience matching the pattern of the heavenly society when you say, "Thy will be done on earth as it is in heaven," and will you then be such hypocrites as to pray that you may imitate saints and angels in the purity and obedience of your hearts and lives, and having done so, settle for shows and seemings and the saying of a few words, and a lifeless image of a holiness you never possessed?

And perhaps even deride and persecute in others the very thing you daily pray for? This is a horrible abuse of the all-seeing God. Do you so little believe or fear his justice? When the apostle says, "Be not deceived; God is not mocked" (Gal 6:7), he implies that hypocrites attempt to put a scorn on God with a mock religion, though it will not be God, but themselves, who prove to be mocked in the end.

Lord Bacon, in his essay on superstition, names the causes of it, and they are the causes of hypocrisy too: pleasing and sensual rites and ceremonies; an excess of outward and Pharisaical holiness; too great a reverence for traditions, which must needs load the church; the stratagems of prelates for their own ambition and gain; and the over-favoring of good intentions, which opens the door to novelties and superstitions. Philippus Callimachus Experiens describes Attila in just this way: a devourer of flesh and wine, and yet addicted, even to superstition, to the religion and the beliefs about the gods that he had received from his own nation.

They offer God an empty shell for a sacrifice. A hypocrite differs from a true Christian as a stage fencer differs from a real soldier: he plays his part very formally, with much applause, but you can tell he is not in earnest by his trifling, his formality, and his never killing any of his sins. Would people show so little seriousness of heart and effort about the great and eternal matters of their own professed belief, if they were not hypocrites? Would they hate and scorn others for doing the very thing, or part of the very thing, they themselves pray and profess to do, if they were not hypocrites?

Woe to the world because of hypocrisy! Woe to idle shepherds, and to the nominal, lifeless Christians of whatever party, for God will not be mocked. They are Christians, but with a mock Christianity, while their souls remain strangers to any true esteem and use of Christ. They are believers, but with a mock belief, the kind described in James 2. They believe that God should be loved above all things, yet they do not love him. They believe that holiness is better than all the pleasures of sin, yet they do not choose it, but hate it. They are religious with a vain, outward religion that cannot so much as humble them or bridle their tongues.

They are wise with a mock wisdom, wise enough to prove that all their sins are either lawful or mere venial offenses; wise enough to throw away the medicine that would heal them; wise enough to argue down the physician, to answer the most learned preacher, to escape salvation, to secure themselves a place in hell, and to keep themselves ignorant of it until they arrive there.

They are converted, but with a mock conversion that leaves them as carnal, proud, and worldly as before, born of water but not of the Spirit, remaining sensual still. They repent with a mock repentance: they repent, but they will not leave their sin, nor confess and mourn over it; they hate reproof and excuse their sin. They are honest with a mock honesty, though they swear and curse and rail and slander and backbite and sneer at piety itself, they mean well and have honest hearts. Though they do not receive the Word with deep roots in their hearts, but are abominable and disobedient and unfit for every good work (Luke 8:15 Titus 1:16), they are honest for all that.

They love God above all, though they cannot bear to think or speak of him seriously, though they hate his holiness and justice, his Word, his holy ways and servants, and are those whom Scripture calls "haters of God," though they keep not his commandments and do not live to his glory. They love the servants of God, yet they would not mind if the world were rid of them all; they regard true believers as a company of self-conceited, troublesome people, and as very hypocrites themselves. The poor Christians cruelly treated by them cannot tell whether they are speaking in earnest or in jest when such people profess to love the worshippers of God. They do not love money, or land, or their lusts with any love like that, to be sure.

They always have good desires, but such mock desires as those in James 2:15, where people wished the poor were fed, clothed, and warmed, yet gave them nothing toward it: the good desires of the sluggard who lies in bed and wishes all his work were done. "The desires of the sluggard killeth him, because his hands refuse to labour" (Prov 21:25). They pray, but with mock prayers; you would hardly guess they are speaking to the most holy God for no less than the salvation of their souls, for they bring more seriousness to their games and sports. They pray for grace, yet they cannot bear it; they pray for holiness, yet are resolved they will have none of it; they pray against their sin, yet no persuasion can move them from it.

They want a mock ministry, a mock discipline, a mock church, a mock sacrament, as they make a mock profession and give God only a mock obedience, as I could trace through every particular were it not for the risk of tedium. And all this is because they have only a mock faith: they do not truly believe that God is in earnest with them in his commands, his threatenings, and his foretelling of judgment, just as Lot’s sons-in-law did not. "He seemeth to them as one that mocked" (Gen 19:14), and so they serve him as people who would mock him in return.

O wretched hypocrites! Is this consistent with your holy profession? You call yourselves Christians and profess to believe the doctrine of Christ, is this consistent with Christianity, with your creed, with the ten commandments, with the Lord’s prayer, and with the rest of the Word of God? Had you no one but the holy, jealous God to make a mockery of? Had you nothing less than religion and the matters of salvation and damnation to play with? Do you serve God as though he were a child, or an idol, or a figure of straw, as though he neither knows your hearts nor is pleased with toys and compliments and shows, with saying over certain words or acting a part before him on a stage? Do you know what you offer, and to whom? His power is omnipotence; his glory surpasses the sun’s ten thousandfold; his wisdom is infinite; millions of angels adore him without ceasing; he is your King and Judge; and he abhors hypocrites.

If you were to glimpse even one flash of his glory, or behold the least of his angels, that sight would wake you from your dreaming and trifling, and drive you from your empty formalities into a serious regard for God and your everlasting state. "Offer this now to thy governor; will he be pleased with thee, or accept thy person, saith the LORD of hosts?" (Mal 1:8). If your servants set before you on the table the feathers instead of the fowl, the hair and wool instead of the flesh, and the scales instead of the fish, would you not think they were mocking rather than serving you?

How dearly have some paid, even in this life, for mocking God. Consider the case of Aaron’s sons (Lev 10:1 and 10:3), and of Ananias and Sapphira (Acts 5). If, like the fig tree (Matt 21:19), you offer God nothing but leaves instead of fruit, you are near to being cursed, and your end is to be burned. Have you not read what he says to the church of Laodicea: "I would thou wert cold or hot; because thou art lukewarm, and neither cold nor hot, I will spue thee out of my mouth" (Rev 3:15 and 3:16)? The meaning is plain: be an open infidel, or be a genuine, wholehearted, zealous Christian, but because you call yourself a Christian yet have none of the life or zeal of a Christian, and cover your worldliness and carnality with that holy name, God will cast you away as something vile and loathsome.

It would make a true believer’s heart ache to contemplate the hypocrisy of most who take the name of Christian upon themselves, and how cruelly they are deceiving themselves. What a glory is set before them, and they lose it by their trifling! What a price is placed in their hands! What mercy is offered them, and they forfeit it by their trifling! What danger stands before them, and they walk into it by their trifling! Does not the weight of your salvation forbid this levity? You might as well set the town on fire and make a joke of it as jest your souls into the fire of hell.

Lord Bacon says in the same essay that superstition is the more deformed for its likeness to religion, and that as wholesome meats corrupt into little worms, so good forms and orders corrupt into petty observances.

Then you will find that hell is no jesting matter. If you mock yourselves out of your salvation, where will you be? If you play with time, and means, and mercy until they are gone, you are undone forever. Do not trifle until you are past remedy. Alas, poor dreaming, trifling hypocrites! Time is so swift, life so short, death so certain and so near, God so holy, just, and terrible, heaven so glorious, hell so fierce, and both everlasting, and yet you will not be in earnest about your work? Rise and act, as you are human beings, and as you have any care for what becomes of you forever! "Depart from iniquity," if you will "name the name of Christ" (2 Tim 2:19).

Do not let a deceitful world cheat you for a moment and take the kernel and the heart, while God receives only the empty shell. A mock religion will sustain nothing more than a mock hope, a mock peace, and a mock joy and comfort, until Satan has finished his work and is ready to unmask you and open your eyes. "So are the paths of all that forget God; and the hypocrite’s hope shall perish" (Job 8:13).

"For what is the hope of the hypocrite, though he hath gained, when God taketh away his soul? Will God hear his cry when trouble cometh upon him?" (Job 27:8 and 27:9). "Knowest thou not this of old, that the triumphing of the wicked is short, and the joy of the hypocrite but for a moment? Though his excellency mount up to the heavens, and his head reacheth unto the clouds; yet he shall perish for ever like his own dung: they which have seen him shall say, Where is he?" (Job 20:4, 20:5, 20:6, and 20:7).

Away then with hypocritical formality and trifling, and be serious and sincere for your soul and before your God.

CHAPTER 44

DIRECTIONS AGAINST INORDINATE MAN-PLEASING

Directions Against Inordinate Man-Pleasing: that overvaluing of human favor and censure which is the fruit of pride and a great cause of hypocrisy, or, Directions Against Idolizing Man

 

As in other cases, so here: the sin consists not simply in the heart’s neglect of God, but in preferring some competitor, in allowing some rival object to assert a contrary claim. To obey man before God and against him, to value human favor and approval above God’s approval, and to fear human censure or displeasure more than God’s, this is to idolize man, to set him up in the place of God.

It redirects our chief observance, care, labor, pleasure, and grief into a human, fleshly channel, and makes everything in our hearts and lives merely human that should, by its proper object, be divine. This is so great and dangerous a sin, so deeply shot through with impiety, hypocrisy, and pride, that it deserves a special place among these Directions, and the most vigilant watchfulness to escape it. Martin of Braga’s counsel in On the Conduct of Life is to the point: strive not to please many, but to please those of worth.

As all other creatures, so especially man, must be regarded and valued only in proper subordination and service to God. If man is valued otherwise, he is made God’s enemy, and as such he is to be shunned, and he becomes the chief instrument of ruin to those who overvalue him. Consider what Scripture says of this sin: "Cease ye from man whose breath is in his nostrils: for wherein is he to be accounted of?" (Isa 2:22) "And call no man your Father upon the earth; for one is your Father which is in heaven." (Matt 23:9)

Diogenes Laertius records that Socrates, with great loftiness of mind, despised those who carped at him and reproached him (Lives 2.26).

"And be not ye called Rabbi; for one is your Master, even Christ: but he that is greatest among you shall be your servant." (Matt 23:8) "Cursed be the man that trusteth in man, and maketh flesh his arm." (Jer 17:5) "The Lord is on my side; I will not fear what man can do unto me. It is better to trust in the Lord, than to put confidence in man, yea, in princes." (Ps 118:6, 8, 9) "Let me not accept any man’s person; neither let me give flattering titles unto man: for I know not to give flattering titles; in so doing my Maker would soon take me away." (Job 32:21, 22) "As for me, is my complaint to man?" (Job 21:4)

"Do I seek to please men? for if I yet pleased men, I should not be a servant of Christ." (Gal 1:10) "But with me it is a very small thing to be judged of you, or of man’s judgment." (1 Cor 4:3) "If a man come to me, and hate not his father, and mother, and wife, and children, and brethren, and sisters, yea, and his own life also, he cannot be my disciple." "Blessed are ye when men shall revile you, and persecute you, and shall say all manner of evil against you falsely for my sake." (Matt 5:11) "Rejoice, and be exceeding glad, for great is your reward in heaven." "Not with eye-service, as men-pleasers." (Eph 6:6 Col 3:22) "So we speak, not as pleasing men but God, who trieth our hearts." (1 Thess 2:4) "Having men’s persons in admiration because of advantage." (Jude 16)

This is sufficient to show what Scripture says about inordinate man-pleasing and undue deference to human opinion. I now proceed to direct you on how to escape it.

Direction 1. Understand clearly what the nature of this sin consists in, so that you do not run into the opposite extreme, but know precisely where to direct your resistance. I will therefore first show how far we may and must please men, and how far we may not.

1. Our parents, rulers, and superiors must be honored, obeyed, and pleased in everything they require of us within their several spheres of God-given authority. This must be done not merely as to human authority, but as to the officers of God, for his sake, by his delegation, and never against him, for from him alone they hold all their power. (Rom 13 Exod 20:12 Titus 3:1 1 Pet 2:13 2 Pet 2:10)

2. We must in charity, condescension, and gentleness of manner seek to please all people for the sake of their salvation. We must so earnestly desire the conversion of sinners that we become all things, all lawful things, to all people, in order to win them. We must not stand on our dignity or keep at a distance from them; we must stoop to the lowest, bear the weaknesses of the fragile, and in indifferent matters not pursue our own preference, but rather that course which, by pleasing our weak brother, may build him up.

We must forbear and forgive, give up our rights, and deny ourselves the exercise of Christian liberty, for as long as it takes, if that is necessary for the salvation of our brothers’ souls, by removing the obstacle that prejudice has placed before them. When Chrysippus was asked why he did not train himself along with the crowd, he answered that if he did as most do, he would be no philosopher. And Tacitus observed that flattery carries the foul reproach of servility, while malice wears the false appearance of liberty. Secure conscience first: once it is lost, you will afterward be nothing. We must not seek our own worldly ends, but the benefit of others, and do them every good we can.

3. Just as our neighbor is commanded to love us as himself, we are in turn bound by every lawful means to make ourselves lovable to him, so as to assist and promote that love in him, which is more necessary for his sake than for ours. To help him obey so great a commandment is itself a great duty. Therefore, if his very sin has prejudiced him against us, or led him to take offense at some indifferent thing, we must lawfully remove the cause of that prejudice and dislike as far as we can, though if someone hates us for obeying God, we must not cure his hatred by disobeying God. So far are we from being required to displease people through rudeness and sourness that we are positively bound to gentle, brotherly kindness, and to every manner of conduct that may cure sinful hatred or aversion toward us.

4. We must not be self-conceited, nor prefer a weak and poorly furnished judgment of our own over the greater wisdom of another. In honor we must prefer one another. The ignorant must respect the knowledge and gifts of those who surpass them; they must not be rigid in their own opinions, or wise in their own eyes, or dismissive of another’s reasoning or judgment. Rather, they should be glad to learn from anyone who can teach them, and humbly acknowledge their own insufficiency.

5. Above all, we must respect the judgment of our able, faithful teachers, and not by pride set our weaker judgment against theirs or resist the truth they deliver to us from God. Nor must we treat lightly the censures or admonitions of the lawful pastors of the church. When those censures conform to the Word and judgment of God, they are deeply solemn. As Tertullian says: "If anyone so offends as to be excluded from the communion of prayer, assembly, and all sacred fellowship, it is a judgment that anticipates the great judgment to come." Indeed, even if the officers of Christ should wrong you by their censures, through passion or mistake, while acting within their proper charge on matters belonging to their jurisdiction, you must bear the wrong respectfully and patiently, so as not to dishonor and despise the authority and office, however abused.

6. If sober, godly persons who know us well strongly suspect us to be at fault where we do not see it ourselves, that suspicion should make us more watchful and fearful. If discerning people fear, from observing your temper and course of life, that you are a hypocrite and no sound Christian, this should prompt you to search your own heart with greater seriousness, not to dismiss their judgment. And if discerning people, especially ministers, tell a poor, fearful, doubting Christian that they genuinely believe that person’s spiritual state to be safe, this may be a great support, and must not be treated as nothing, even though it cannot give certainty about one’s condition. This is the extent to which human judgment must be valued.

7. A good reputation among people, that is, the reputation of our integrity, is not to be disregarded as worthless. It is a mercy from God for which we must be thankful, and it is a useful means of serving and honoring God effectively. The more prominent we are, and the more the honor of God and of religion is bound up with our reputation, or the good of souls depends upon it, the more carefully we must guard it. It may sometimes be a duty to defend it through the magistrate’s justice against slander. Preachers especially, whose success in saving their hearers depends greatly on their good name, must not despise it. Jerome, writing to Nepotian, gives the rule: whatever can plausibly be invented about you, forestall it before it is invented. And it was said harshly enough to Acosta that in this matter not only truth but reputation must be studiously sought, so that you may sometimes not in the least regret having played the hypocrite.

8. The insults of the most insolent, and the contempt of enemies, are not to be dismissed lightly, these are sins, and we must grieve over them; nor should we dismiss them, since they may prompt us to more diligent self-examination and careful watchfulness over our ways. This is the full extent to which human judgment deserves our attention.

But there are limits to that regard, which must be kept clearly in mind.

1. We must recognize how frail, mistaken, and inconsistent human beings are, and so must not place too high expectations on them. We should expect that people will misunderstand us, wrong us, and slander us, through ignorance, passion, prejudice, or self-interest. When this happens, we must not treat it as strange or unexpected.

2. We must consider how far the enmity that fallen human nature harbors toward holiness, and the ignorance, prejudice, and passion of the ungodly, will drive people to despise, mock, and slander all who serve God seriously and zealously, and who cross their worldly interests. If for the sake of Christ and righteousness we are made the scorn and refuse of all, counted as troublemakers and movers of sedition, deemed unworthy to live, and have all manner of evil spoken of us falsely, this must not seem strange or unexpected, nor cast us down. We must bear it patiently, and indeed rejoice exceedingly in the hope of our reward in heaven.

3. Considering how much pride and self-conceit remains even in many who have genuine grace, and how many hypocrites are within the church, whose religion consists in opinions and particular modes of worship, we must expect to be reproached and abused by those who differ from us in opinions, forms, or circumstances, and who therefore take us for their adversaries. A great deal of injustice, sometimes in slander or reproach, sometimes in greater violence, must be expected from contentious professors of the same religion as ourselves, especially when their factional interest demands it, or when we bring any truth among them that seems new, contradicts the opinions they hold in honor, or would reform anything that is amiss.

4. No one must be pleased by sin, nor their favor preferred over pleasing God. Human favor, when set against God, is to be despised, and human displeasure counted as nothing. If doing our duty will displease them, let them be displeased; we can only pity them.

5. We must place none of our happiness in human favor or approval, but regard it, as it concerns ourselves, as a matter of no great moment, not worth great effort to obtain, nor great grief to lose. We must not only despise it in comparison with God’s approval and favor, but must value it in itself only as we value other transitory things, estimating it as a means toward some higher end, the service of God and the greater good of ourselves and others. Beyond its usefulness for such ends, it must be nearly indifferent to us what people think or say of us, and the displeasure of all people, when unjust, must be reckoned among our light afflictions.

6. One truth of God, and the least duty, must be preferred over pleasing and winning the favor of all people in the world. Yet, as a means to advancing a greater truth or duty, the favor and pleasing of people may rightly be preferred over stating a lesser truth or doing a lesser good at that moment, because it is then no duty to do it.

7. Our hearts are so naturally selfish and deceitful that when we are very anxious about our reputation, we must watch ourselves carefully lest self be the true aim while God is the pretended one. We must take special care to be sure that it is the honor of God, of religion, and of souls, or some benefit greater than honor itself, that we value our reputation for.

8. Human nature is so prone to go too far in valuing esteem from others that we should fear the error on that side far more than the error of undervaluing it. It is far safer to do too little than too much in vindicating our own reputation, whether through the magistrate’s justice, through argument, or through any contentious means.

9. We must not rest entirely on any person’s judgment about the state of our souls, or take their verdict as infallible, but use their help as an aid to self-knowledge.

10. If ministers, or councils called General, err and contradict the Word of God, we must do our best to discern it, and when we do, we must abandon their error rather than the truth of God. As Calvin, and after him Paraeus on 1 Corinthians 4:3, say: "We must give an account of our doctrine to all who require it, especially to ministers and councils; but when a faithful pastor finds himself overwhelmed by unjust and perverse factions, and that there is no place for equity and truth, he ought to be unconcerned with human esteem, appeal to God, and flee to his tribunal. And if we see ourselves condemned without our cause being pleaded, and sentence passed without our case being heard, let us lift our minds to this greatness of spirit, despising human judgment, and await with boldness the judgment of God." And we should say with Paul, "With me it is a small matter to be judged of you, or of man’s judgment; I have one that judgeth me, even the Lord." (1 Cor 4:3)

11. God must be enough for a gracious soul. We must know that "in his favour is life," and that his lovingkindness is better than life itself. Our care and labor must be that "whether living or dying we may be accepted of him." If we have his approval, that must satisfy us, though the whole world condemn us. Therefore, having faithfully done our duty, we must leave the matter of our reputation to God, who, if our ways please him, can make even our enemies to be at peace with us, or at least powerless against us. As we quietly leave to him what measure of wealth we shall have, so we must leave to him what measure of honor we shall have. It is our duty to love and honor others, not to be loved and honored ourselves.

12. Our Savior’s prophecy must always be believed, that "the world will hate us." His example must always be before our eyes: he submitted to being spat upon, mocked, and struck; he was slandered as a traitor and usurper of the crown; he "made himself of no reputation," "endured the cross," and "despised the shame," leaving us an example "that we should follow his steps, who did no sin, neither was guile found in his mouth; who, when he was reviled, reviled not again; when he suffered, he threatened not, but committed all to him that judgeth righteously." (1 Pet 2:21–22) This is what the Christian must expect, not the good opinion of all, nor the applause and honor of the world.

13. It is not only the approval of the ignorant and ungodly that we must hold at so low a value, but even that of the most learned and godly, so as to bear their censures as an easy burden when God is pleased to try us this way, and to be satisfied in God alone and in the expectation of his final judgment. We must go further than Seneca, who said: "Evil men speak ill of me, but they are evil; I would be moved if it were Cato, or Laelius the wise, or the two Scipios who said these things, but as it is, to displease the wicked is to be praised." We must be prepared to hold even the censure of the good lightly, if God so requires it.

Direction 2. "Remember that winning human favor and pleasing others is one of your snares, which would work against your pleasing God." Guard against its danger as you would guard against any other earthly thing.

Direction 3. "Remember how small a creature a human being is, and that his favor can be no better than himself." The thoughts or words of a mortal are matters of no considerable weight to us.

Direction 4. "Remember that it is the judgment of God alone on which your eternal life or death depends, and how little you are truly concerned in the judgment of any human being."

1.) A soul that has been humbled, one who has felt what it is to have displeased God, what it is to lie under his curse, and what it is to be reconciled to him by the death and intercession of Jesus Christ, is so entirely taken up with seeking God’s favor, and so troubled by any fear of his displeasure, and so delighted in the sense of his love, that it has scarcely any room to attend to so small a matter as human favor or displeasure. God’s favor is enough for such a soul, and so precious, that when it finds it has that, so slight a thing as a person’s favor will scarcely be missed.

2.) God alone is our supreme Judge, and our earthly governors are officers limited by his authority. As for others, if they will usurp his seat and set themselves on the throne of God, firing off censures against things and persons that are no concern of theirs, why should we seem much troubled by it? If a beggar stepped up onto a judge’s bench and there condemned one person and fined another, would you fear him, or laugh at him? "Who are you to judge another man’s servant? To his own master he stands or falls." People may presume to mount the throne of God and judge others according to their own interests and passions, but God will quickly pull them down and teach them to know their place. How much does the common censure of the world resemble the game of boys who play at holding an assize, appointing a judge, staging a trial, and condemning one another in sport? And have we not a far greater Judge to fear?

3.) It is God alone who passes the final sentence, from which there is no appeal to any other. But from human judgment, an appeal lies to God. Human judgment must itself be judged by him, and things will not stand as people now censure them. Many a bad cause is today judged good because of the number or greatness of those who favor it, and many a good cause is condemned. Many a person is treated as a criminal because he obeys God and does his duty. But all these things must be tried again before the one who has pronounced a "woe to them that call evil good and good evil; that put darkness for light and light for darkness" (Isa 5:20). "He that saith to the wicked, thou art righteous, people shall curse him, nations shall abhor him" (Prov 24:24).

It would go very badly for the best servants of Christ if the judgment of the world were to stand, for the world condemns them as fools and hypocrites and whatever else it pleases; by that reckoning, the devil’s judgment would stand too. But the truly wise person is the one whom God will judge to be wise at last, and the truly happy person is the one whom God calls happy.

The erring judgment of a creature is like an ignorant man writing labels on an apothecary’s boxes: if he writes "poison" on some and "antidote" on others when neither description matches the contents, the boxes are not to be valued according to those labels. How different are the names that God and the world assign to things and persons! How few people now approve of what God approves and will justify at the last day! How many will God judge heterodox and wicked who were judged orthodox and worthy of applause by others? And how many will God judge orthodox and sincere who were called heretics and hypocrites by people? God will not ratify every word that angry or contentious disputants speak against his servants. The learning, authority, or other advantages of those who contend may for now overwhelm the arguments and reputations of wiser and more righteous people, but God will restore and vindicate them at last.

The names of Luther, Zwingli, Calvin, and many other excellent servants of the Lord have been made odious in the writings and reports of Papists through shameless lies; but God judges otherwise, with a more righteous judgment. What an abundance of persons and causes will be justified at the great day of God that the world condemned! And how many will be condemned there who were justified by the world! Blessed day, most desirable to the just, most terrible to the wicked and to every hypocrite! How many things that are now crooked will then be set straight! How many innocents and saints will then experience a resurrection of their murdered names, which were buried by the world under a heap of lies, names their enemies never imagined would revive. Fix your eyes on that final judgment of the Lord, and you will take human censures as no more than the shaking of a leaf.

The open daylight of truth does not show the masks, mummeries, and triumphs of the world half so stately and splendid as candlelight does. Lord Bacon, Essay of Truth.

4.) It is God alone who has power to execute his sentence to our happiness or misery: "there is one lawgiver that is able to save and to destroy" (Jas 4:12). If he says to us, "Come ye blessed," we shall be happy though devils and men curse us, for those whom he blesses are blessed indeed. If he condemns to hell, the applause of the world will fetch no one out, nor give any ease. A great name on earth, histories written in one’s praise, or a gilded monument over one’s bones, these are a poor relief to damned souls.

Equally, the barking of the wicked and their scorn on earth are no diminution of the joy or glory of souls shining and triumphant with Christ. It is our Lord who "hath the keys of death and hell" (Rev 1:18). Please him, and you are sure to escape, though the pope and all the wicked of the world should thunder out against you their most dreadful curses. Woe to us if the wicked could execute all their malicious censures, then how many saints would be in hell! But if it is God who justifies us, how little it matters who they are that condemn us, or what their pretenses may be (Rom 8:33).

Direction 5. Remember that the judgment of ungodly people is corrupted and directed by the devil, and that to be overruled by their censures, or to fear them too much, is to be overruled by the devil and to be afraid of his censures of you. Will you honor him so highly? It is he who puts those thoughts into the minds of the ungodly and those reproachful words into their mouths. To prefer the judgment of a person over God’s is odious enough, even before you consider that you are thereby preferring the devil’s judgment.

Direction 6. Consider what a slavery you choose when you make yourselves the servants of every person whose censures you fear and whose approval you pursue. "Ye are bought with a price; be not ye the servants of men" (1 Cor 7:23), that is, do not needlessly put yourselves in chains. What a burden the people-pleaser carries! He has as many masters as he has onlookers. No wonder this pulls people away from the service of God, for the "friendship of the world is enmity to God," and whoever will be "a friend of the world is an enemy to God." No one can serve two masters, God and the world. You know that people will condemn you if you are true to God; if, therefore, you must have human favor, you must take it alone without God’s favor. A people-pleaser cannot be true to God, because he is a servant to the enemies of God’s service, the breath of a person’s mouth will drive him about like chaff, away from any duty and toward any sin.

How servile is the people-pleaser! How many masters he has, and how mean they are! This habit perverts the course of your hearts and lives, and turns everything away from God toward this profitless pursuit. As Seneca writes in On Anger: the proud man will wound you with contempt, the rich man with insult, the petulant man with injury, the envious man with malice, the quarrelsome man with contention, and the vain and lying man with his emptiness. You will not be able to bear being feared by the suspicious, beaten in argument by the stubborn, or disdained by the fastidious.

Direction 7. Remember what a pitiful reward you seek. "Verily," says our Lord of hypocrites and people-pleasers, "they have their reward." A miserable reward indeed, the opinion and breath of mortal men! Instead of God, instead of heaven, this is their reward. Their happiness will be to lie in hell and remember that they were well spoken of on earth, that they were once counted religious, learned, wise, or honorable, and to remember that they preferred this reward over everlasting happiness with Christ. If this is not gain, then all the labor you spend hunting for applause is lost. If this is enough to spend your time for, to neglect your God for, and to lose your soul for, then rejoice in the hypocrite’s reward.

Direction 8. Remember also that honor is something found sooner by an honest contempt of it than by an excessive desire for it and pursuit of it. Honor is a shadow: it retreats from you when you chase it, and follows you as fast as you walk away from it. Whose names are now more honorable on earth than those prophets, apostles, martyrs, preachers, and holy, self-denying Christians who in their own days set the least store by the world’s approval, and were made the scorn or plaything of their age? Those who were satisfied with the approval of their heavenly Father, who saw them "in secret," have been "rewarded by him openly."

Even in the eyes of rational people, it is a far greater honor to live for God above worldly honor than to seek that honor. And to the degree that a person is perceived to desire and pursue honor, he loses it, for he is seen to need it, and people recognize that he is playing a low and pitiful game in his eagerness for their applause. Just as they would despise a man who went about licking up everyone’s spittle, so they will despise the one who lives on their opinions and breath, and will honor far more the one who lives on God.

Direction 9. If nothing else will cure this disease, at least let the impossibility of pleasing people, and the futility of your attempts to do so, be sufficient argument against so fruitless a pursuit. I will now show you how impossible it is, or at least how unreasonable it is to expect success.

1. Remember what a multitude you must please; and when you have pleased some, how many more will remain unpleased, or actively displeased, even after your best effort. We simply cannot attend to all those who observe us and wish to be pleased by us. You are like a person who has only twelve pence in his pocket while a thousand beggars crowd around him, each one offended if he does not receive everything.

If you resolve to give all you have to the poor in order to please God, you may achieve your goal; but if you do it to please people, then when you have satisfied the few you gave to, twice as many will revile or curse you for receiving nothing. The beggar who fares well will call you generous; the beggar who fares poorly will call you stingy and heartless. You will end up with more people to offend and dishonor you than to comfort you with their praise, if that is what your comfort depends on.

As Seneca wrote from Democritus, one person counts as a whole people to me, and the whole people as one person; a few are enough, one is enough, none is enough. Socrates was condemned by a majority of his judges, and they would not allow Plato to speak in his defense. His sentence read that he violated the gods received from ancestral custom, denying they existed, and introduced strange new spiritual beings, so Diogenes Laertius records.

2. Remember that everyone is so self-interested that their expectations will exceed anything you can satisfy. They will not consider your other obligations, your competing duties, or what you do for others; most will expect as much of your time as if you had no one else to care for.

Many times, when I have had an hour or a day to spend, a great number of people each expected that I would spend it with them alone. When I visit one, ten are offended that I am not visiting them at the same hour. When I am talking with one, many more are offended that I am not speaking to all of them at once. Those I do speak with think me courteous, humble, and respectful; those I cannot reach, or can only greet briefly, think me rude and cold. How many have blamed me for not giving them time that God and conscience required me to spend on more urgent work! If you have any office to bestow or benefit to give, one that only one person can receive, everyone considers himself the most deserving. When you have pleased the one who receives it, you have displeased all who did not, and who failed to get what they wanted.

3. You have a great many people to please who are so ignorant, unreasonable, and weak that they take your greatest virtues for faults and cannot tell when you are doing well or ill, and yet no one is bolder in criticism than those who least understand what they are criticizing. As Seneca wrote: what I know, the people do not approve; what the people approve, I do not know. And as Cleobulus observed, ignorance and a flood of words rule most people. Many times, my own sermons and those of others have been openly defamed for things that were never in them, or even for things they directly argued against, simply because they were not understood. A preacher who writes or speaks concisely, without repetition, where every word must be followed to avoid misunderstanding, will frequently be misrepresented.

4. You will also have many factious zealots to please who, being strangers to genuine love of holiness, true Christianity, and unity, are governed entirely by the interests of their opinion or party. These will never be satisfied unless you join their side and conform to their views. If you refuse to take sides against them, and instead try to reconcile and resolve the church’s divisions, they will hate you for not promoting their cause, condemning your conciliatory efforts as a dreaded compromise. As in civil wars, so in church conflicts: those who fan the flames cannot endure the peaceable. If you try to remain neutral, you will be treated as an enemy. No matter how clearly you stand for Christ, for holiness, and for shared truth, it counts for nothing unless you also stand for them and their particular opinions.

Scultetus records an instance of it. When the divines of Heidelberg appointed Pitiscus to write his Irenicon, his very writing for peace, and to persuade the Reformed away from apologies and disputes, gave occasion for renewed agitation among the Saxon and Swedish divines, who told people that they could have no peace with us.

5. Most of the world hates holiness and bears a deep-seated enmity to the image of God, being unrenewed by the Holy Spirit. They will not be satisfied with you unless you sin against your Lord and live as they do, "walking in lasciviousness, lusts, excess of wine, revellings, banquetings, and abominable idolatries, wherein they think it strange that ye run not with them to the same excess of riot, speaking evil of you; who shall give account to him that is ready to judge the quick and the dead" (1 Pet 4:3–5).

You must expect to be seen as Lot among the Sodomites, a meddler who comes among them to set himself up as their judge and to interfere with their ways, if you dare tell them of their sin. You will be called a precise, hypocritical fool (or something far worse) if you refuse to be as bad as they are, or if your very abstinence, even without a word, appears to rebuke their sensuality and contempt of God. Among the reckless you must play the reckless, if you hope to escape their tearing scorn. Can you truly hope to please such people?

6. You will also have satanic God-haters to please, people of seared and hardened consciences, malicious and cruel, satisfied with nothing less than some terrible iniquity, the ruin of your soul, and the dragging of others into ruin with them. Like that monster of Milan who, when he had brought his enemy down, made him blaspheme God with the promise of sparing his life, and then stabbed him, calling it a noble revenge that killed the body and damned the soul at once.

There are such people in the world who so visibly act the devil’s part that they would corrupt your conscience with the most appalling perjuries, treacheries, and impieties, simply to triumph over your ruined soul. It is possible, just possible, that you might satisfy them, if you were willing to damn yourself deliberately. But if you tell them you cannot please them without being dishonest, displeasing God, sinning against your conscience, and risking your salvation, they will laugh at such arguments and expect you to gamble your soul and everything on their opinions, caring as little for God and your soul as they do.

Desperate sinners are reluctant to go to hell alone; it is a torment to them to see others living better than themselves. Those who are cruel to themselves, who have no pity on their own souls and will sell them for a corrupt pleasure, a promotion, or worldly honor, will scarcely have mercy on anyone else’s soul: "his blood be on us, and on our children" (Matt 27:25).

7. You will have rigorous, captious, uncharitable, and unjust people to please, those who "make a man an offender for a word, and lay a snare for him that reproveth in the gate, and turn aside the just for a thing of nought, and watch for iniquity" (Isa 29:20–21). They have none of that charity which covers faults and interprets words and actions generously, and none of that justice which leads people to treat others as they wish to be treated and to judge as they would be judged. Judging without mercy, they are likely to receive judgment without mercy. They are glad whenever they find something to reproach you with; and once they find it, true or false, they will never let it go, but dwell on it as a fly settles on a sore. As Salvian observed, those entrusted by Christ with the duty of speaking face an impossible predicament: they displease God if they stay silent, and people if they speak.

Even for the greatness of your services you may perish through the suspicion and envy of the very powerful people you served, as is proved by the cases of Saul and David, Belisarius, Narses, Bonifacius, the two sons of Huniades (one imprisoned, one slain), and many others like them.

8. You will have passionate people to please, people whose judgment is blinded and who are incapable of being pleased. They are like the sick and the injured, who flinch at every touch; and, as Seneca observes, eventually flinch at the mere suspicion of a touch. How can you please them when displeasure is their chronic condition, lodged at the very center of their hearts?

9. You will find that a censorious spirit is a common vice. Though very few people are competent judges of your actions, not knowing all the circumstances, nearly everyone will venture an opinion. Presumptuous self-confidence is an extremely common failing: a person hears only part of the story and immediately feels qualified to judge, with no awareness of how often that judgment has proved wrong, though daily experience could teach the lesson. Few stand at your side, and no one stands inside your heart; they therefore know neither the circumstances and reasons behind what you do, nor what you would say in your own defense, yet they presume to condemn you when they would have acquitted you had they only heard you speak. It is rare to find even the most sincerely devout people who are genuinely careful and fearful of sinning in this matter of rash, groundless judging, without either the competence or the calling to judge.

10. You live among quarrelsome gossips and tale-carriers who seek to please others by accusing you. Who with ears has not had such pests as these buzzing in them? Only the occasional upright person whose stern expression has consistently driven away backbiting tongues is spared. All of it will be said behind your back, when you have no opportunity to defend yourself. If the person who slanders you is someone the hearers respect, they consider it entirely right to believe the report; and those who are that person’s friends, allies, and fellow partisans will invariably be regarded as trustworthy enough to be believed. Nor is it strange for a learned, gifted, even a godly person to be too ready to pass on an evil report drawn from others’ mouths, after which the listener feels fully justified in believing it and passing it on further.

David himself, by the temptation of a Ziba, was drawn to wrong Mephibosheth the son of his greatly deserving friend (2 Sam 16:3–4). No wonder, then, that Saul would listen to a Doeg, to David’s injury and the priests’ destruction. "The words of a tale-bearer are as wounds" (Prov 18:8). "Where no wood is, the fire goeth out: so where there is no tale-bearer the strife ceaseth" (Prov 26:20). When tale-carriers are perpetually near and you are far away, it is easy for them to sustain the most odious representation of even the most praiseworthy person’s conduct.

11. The imperfection of all people’s understanding and godliness is so great that differences of judgment among the best of them will tend to the injury and belittling of their fellow believers. One person is confident that his way is right; another is equally confident of the opposite. To what extent such differences can grow into strife and injury, anyone living through this age already knows.

Lucilius said that he did not care to have Persius read him; he wanted Laelius Decimus.

We need not reach for the example of Paul and Barnabas, that was a far lighter case, nor for Epiphanius, Jerome, and Chrysostom, nor for the tragedies of contending bishops in both Eastern and Western churches through the ages, each convinced his cause was plain enough to justify whatever he said and did against those who dared to differ. You may well expect some displeasure even from good and learned people, when the churches have suffered such terrible upheavals and bleed to this day from hideous divisions, born of the pride and ignorance that their own revered leaders have never entirely shed.

I may add that you have guilty consciences to please, and the guilty are, as Seneca puts it, like a man with an ulcer, who at first is hurt by every touch and at last even by the suspicion of a touch. Does anything afford safety to a bad conscience? Nothing makes the guilty man secure, Seneca answers, for he thinks that even if he is not caught he still may be caught; he tosses in his sleep, and whenever he speaks of another’s crime he thinks of his own (Epistles 105). The first and greatest punishment of sinners is to have sinned; and these second punishments press hard and follow after: to fear always, to be terrified, and to distrust one’s own safety (Epistles 97).

12. You have people of great inconstancy to please, people who one hour are ready to worship you as gods and the next to stone you or treat you as devils, as they did with Paul, and with Christ himself. What a weathervane is the human mind, and especially the mind of the crowd and the time-server! You may spend your entire life building your reputation on this sand, only to have one gust of wind or one storm knock it down at last, your cost and labor lost.

Serve people as humbly and diligently as you can, and still some accident or some failure to meet their unreasonable expectations may cause everything you ever did to be forgotten, and drive you out of the world with Wolsey’s groan: "If I had served God as faithfully as man, I had been better rewarded, and not forsaken in my distress." How many have fallen by the hands or frowns of those whose favor they had dearly purchased, perhaps at the price of their salvation! If you ever place such trust in a friend that you fail to reckon with the possibility that he may one day prove your enemy, you do not know human nature, and you may learn the lesson at a painful cost. Thrasybulus, writing to Periander, put the principle at its worst: to a tyrant even friends are often objects of suspicion; therefore, if you wish to hold your tyranny in safety and be established in it, remove the leading men of the state, whether they seem friends or enemies (in Diogenes Laertius, Lives 1.100).

13. Every person alive will inevitably be led by God himself into certain duties that are highly liable to misinterpretation, duties that carry an outward appearance of evil in the eyes of those who do not know the full inward reality and circumstances. This is why a great part of historical writing deserves little confidence: the actions of public figures are perceived only by halves by most who record them. Historians write largely by hearsay, or know only the outward appearance of events, not the spirit, the life, and the reality of the matter. People do not choose their own duties; God appoints them through his law and providence, and it pleases him often to test his servants in this way: many of the circumstances behind their actions remain hidden from others, circumstances that would vindicate them if they were known, and so they are counted notorious and scandalous persons simply because those circumstances are not known.

It is the disposition of most people, Galiadus observes in his Arcana Jesuitica, to scrutinize even the smallest errors of others while passing over their good deeds even when these are set in plain view, just as vultures take no notice of living and healthy bodies but track down carrion and corpses by scent, however far off they lie.

How like evil was the Israelites’ taking of the Egyptians’ goods, and how readily it could expose them to censure! So too was Abraham’s attempt to sacrifice his son; David’s eating the showbread and dancing nearly unclothed before the ark; Christ’s eating and drinking with tax collectors and sinners; Paul’s circumcising Timothy and purifying himself in the temple, and countless similar things that arise in every Christian’s life. No wonder that Joseph once thought of putting Mary away, until he learned the evidence of her miraculous conception; and how exposed she was to censure by those who knew nothing of it! How vain, then, is the judgment of human beings! How frequently it is contrary to the truth! With what caution must history be read! And how desirable is the great day of God, when all human censure shall itself be justly judged!

14. The perverseness of many people is so great that they impose contradictions and impossibilities on you, which is simply their way of announcing that they are resolved never to be pleased by you. If John practices fasting, they say "he hath a devil"; if Christ comes "eating and drinking," they say, "behold a gluttonous person, and a wine-bibber, a friend of publicans and sinners" (Matt 11:18–19). If your judgment and practice conform to those in authority, especially if those authorities have undergone a change, you will be judged a mere opportunist and time-server; if they do not conform, you will be judged disobedient, stubborn, and seditious. If you speak warmly and pleasingly, they will call you a flatterer and a hypocrite; if you speak more frankly, even in a necessary case, they will say you are ranting.

If you accept a position of honor, they will say you are ambitious, proud, and worldly; if you refuse it, however modestly, they will say you are discontented and harbor seditious designs. If you do not preach when you are forbidden to, you will be accused of abandoning the calling you undertook and obeying man rather than God; if you do preach, you will be counted disobedient and seditious. If a friend or relative asks you to help him to some position or advantage for which he is not fit, or which would wrong another person, and you grant his request, you will be thought dishonest for favoring him at another’s expense; if you refuse him, you will be called unnatural, unfriendly, and worse than an infidel.

If you give to the poor for as long as you have means, you will be criticized the moment you stop, those who do not know whether you have anything left to give will be displeased when you do not give; and however many years you may have supported people freely, it all counts for nothing the moment you stop, whether because your resources are exhausted or because someone else has become the more pressing object of your charity. If you have been wronged in your estate and you pursue the matter at law, they will call you contentious; if you let your estate go to avoid contention, they will call you a simpleton or a fool.

If you perform works of charity in public, they will call you a hypocrite who does it for applause; if you do it secretly so that no one knows of it, they will call you miserly and say that for all your religious profession you do no good, and others will be censured on the same grounds because of you. If you are pleasant and cheerful, they will censure you as frivolous and vain; if you are more grave and serious, they will say you are melancholy or discontent. In a word, whatever you do, be certain that some will condemn it; whether you act or refrain, speak or stay silent, you will inevitably displease someone and never fully escape the censures of the world.

15. Among people there is such great contrariety of judgments, dispositions, and interests that they will never agree among themselves; and if you please one, you thereby displease the rest. The person you please is the enemy of another, and so by pleasing him you offend his enemy. Sometimes political differences divide kingdoms into parties, and one party will be displeased with you if you side with the other, and both parties will be displeased if you remain neutral or reject them both. Each party believes its cause justifies any accusation it can bring against you, any contemptuous label it can attach to you, and whatever suffering it can inflict on you.

Church differences and sects have existed in every age, and you cannot hold every party’s opinion at once. If you align with one party, you must displease the rest; if you take one side in a disputed question, the other side counts you erroneous. And how far will the supposed interest of a cause and party carry people? One half of the Christian world today condemns the other half as schismatical at the very least, while the other half does the same in return. And can you be Papists, and Protestants, and Greeks, and everything at once? If not, you must displease as many as you please.

What is more, if changeable people shift their position time and again, they will expect you to shift just as quickly and to follow them wherever their contradictory interests lead. One year you must swear to something; the next you must unsay it all. Whatever cause or action they engage in, however wicked, you must approve and endorse it, and declare that everything they do is well done. In a word, you must train your tongue to say or swear anything, sell your innocence, and hire out your conscience entirely to their service, or you cannot please them. Micaiah must say with the rest of the prophets, "Go, and prosper," or he will be hated for not prophesying good of Ahab, but evil (1 Kgs 22:8). And how can you serve all interests at once?

It seems that God’s providence has, as if by design, turned the affairs of the world in such a way as to test and expose people-pleasers and time-servers before the eyes of all. It is therefore plain that if you will please everyone, you must at once both speak and stay silent, confirm contradictions, be in many places at the same time, hold every person’s opinion, and support every person’s way. For my own part, I mean to wait until the world is considerably more agreed among itself before I make it my ambition to please it. If you can reconcile all their opinions, interests, temperaments, and dispositions, and make them all of one mind and will, then you may hope to please them.

16. If you excel in any one virtue or duty, even that will not protect you from the opposite slander, so unreasonable are malicious people. Nothing in the world can secure you from censorious and slanderous tongues. Those who saw Stephen’s face as it had been the face of an angel, and heard him declare that he saw heaven open, yet stoned him to death as a blasphemer (Acts 6:15 Acts 7:55–60). The perfect holiness of Jesus Christ could not protect him from being called a gluttonous person, a wine-bibber, and a friend of publicans and sinners. His extraordinary contempt of worldly dignities and honors, and his submission to Caesar, could not protect him from being slandered and crucified as Caesar’s enemy. The great piety of the early Christians did not excuse them from the common slander that they met together for filthiness in the dark, or from the mob cry of "Away with the ungodly!" because they refused to worship idols.

I have known people who gave everything they ever had to the poor except their food and bare necessities, though it amounted to a considerable sum, and yet were reproached as unmerciful by those who had not received what they expected. Many a person has been defamed by scandalous rumors of unchastity who lived in untainted chastity all their lives. The most eminent saints have been accused of the most horrific crimes, crimes that never entered their minds.

The principal concern to which I have devoted my studies and efforts has been the reconciling, unity, and peace of Christians, and opposition to discord, uncharitableness, turbulence, and division, and yet there have been those whose interest and malice have led them to charge me with the very sin I have spent my days, my zeal, and my study opposing. How often have opposing factions charged me with perfectly contradictory accusations? I can scarcely think of anything I do in the world that some will not be offended by, nor of any duty so clear and great that some will not call it my sin, nor of any self-denial so costly, even at hazard of my life, that has not been called self-seeking or something directly contrary to what it actually was. Instead of serving and pleasing this malicious and unrighteous world, I therefore despise its blind and unjust censures and appeal to the most righteous God.

Diogenes Laertius records that Socrates was the first to discourse on the conduct of life, and the first of the philosophers to die under sentence of condemnation, having before that discoursed much and nobly on the immortality of souls (Lives 2.45).

17. If you desire a reputation for honor after you are dead, consider what power a prevailing faction may have to corrupt the history of your life and present you to posterity as the exact opposite of what you were, and how impossible it is for posterity to know which history is the product of malicious and shameless lies and which is the account of impartial truth. Consider how contrary histories of particular persons and events have been written by people of the same religion, for example, regarding Pope Gregory VII and the emperors who contended with him, and regarding Pope Joan, and many similar cases, where you may read scores of historians on each side. Seneca, in his Consolation to Marcia, says that rumor is the freest judge of princes.

18. Remember that the holiest saints and apostles could never please the world, nor escape its censures, slanders, and cruelties, nor could Jesus Christ himself. Do you think you can, by honest means, please the world better than Christ and all his saints have done? You do not possess the wisdom Christ had for pleasing people and avoiding offense. You do not have the perfect innocence and blamelessness that Christ had. You cannot heal their diseases and infirmities, and do the good for them that Jesus Christ did to please and win them. You cannot convince them and compel their reverence through countless miracles as Jesus Christ did.

Can you even imitate the excellent pattern set for you by the holy, patient, charitable, and tireless apostle Paul (Acts 20; 1 Cor 4; 1 Cor 9; 2 Cor 4; 2 Cor 5; 2 Cor 6; 2 Cor 10; 2 Cor 11; 2 Cor 12)? If you cannot, how can you please those who would not be pleased by such inimitable works of love and power? The more Paul "loved" some of his hearers, "the less he was beloved" (2 Cor 12:15). They treated him "as an enemy for telling them the truth" (Gal 4:16). Though he "became all things to all men," he could "save but some," and please but some (1 Cor 9:22). And what are you, that you should please them better?

19. Godliness, virtue, and honesty themselves will not please the world, and so you cannot hope to please the world by means that are not pleasing to it. Will people be pleased by what they hate, and by actions that they feel accuse and condemn them? And if you become ungodly and vicious to please them, you sell your soul, your conscience, and your God for their approval. God and they are not pleased by the same ways, and which do you think should be pleased first? If you displease him for their favor, you will pay dearly for it.

Plutarch tells how Aristides, having earned the surname of the Just, was hated by the Athenians for it, who decreed his banishment. Every voter had to write down the name of the man he voted against, and a countryman who could not write came to Aristides himself and asked him to write down the name of Aristides. Aristides asked whether he knew the man, and he answered no, but that he would vote against him because his name was the Just. Concealing who he was, Aristides granted the request, wrote his own name on the roll, and handed it back: so easily did he bear being condemned by the world for being just.

20. They are not pleased with God himself, indeed, no one displeases so many people so greatly as he does. Can you do more than God to please them, or deserve their favor more than he does? They are perpetually displeased with his works of providence. One person wants rain when another wants none; one wants the winds to serve his voyage while another wants them in the opposite direction; one party is displeased when another is favored and exalted. Every enemy wants his cause to succeed and the victory to be his; every contender wants everything to go his way. God must, in their view, be ruled by them, must fit himself to the interest of the most unjust, conform to the will of the most vicious, do as they demand, and serve their appetites, or they will not be pleased with him.

His holy nature, his holy Word, and his holy ways displease them even more than his ordinary providence. They are displeased that his Word is so precise and strict, that he commands so holy and disciplined a life, and that he threatens the ungodly with damnation. He must, they feel, alter his laws, make them more lenient, fit them to their fleshly interests and desires, and speak without any demands, before they will be satisfied with him (unless he first changes their minds and hearts). And how do you think they will be pleased with him in the end, when he carries out his threatenings, when he strikes them down, turns their bodies to dust, and brings their guilty souls to torment and despair?

21. How can you please people who cannot even please themselves? Their own desires and choices satisfy them only briefly. Like children, they cry for something and quickly grow tired of it once they have it, it is worthless and thrown aside; they are content neither with it nor without it. They are like sick people who crave every food and drink they think of, and then cannot swallow it when it arrives, because the sickness within them is what causes their dissatisfaction. How many people torment themselves daily by their own passions and folly? Can you truly please people who cannot please themselves?

And how can you please others when you cannot please yourselves? If you fear God and feel the burden of your sins, and are alive enough spiritually to sense your own diseases, I dare say that no one in the world displeases you as much as you displease yourselves. You carry within you, and feel within you, that which troubles you more than all your enemies combined. Your passions and corruptions, your lack of love for God, your remoteness from him and from the life to come, the daily failings of your duties and your lives, these are your daily burden, and they displease you most. If you are not able, wise, and good enough to please yourselves, how can you be able, wise, and good enough to please the world? As your sins are nearest to you, so are your graces; and as you know more of your own evil than others do, so you also know more of your own good. A fire that cannot warm the hearth it lies on will not warm the whole room.

Direction 10. "Remember what a life of unquiet and continual vexation you choose, if you place your peace or happiness in the good will or good word of other people." Abraham Bucholtzer’s rule fits the case: do you wish to be at ease in the world? Then learn to be despised, and to despise.

Having shown you how impossible a task you have undertaken, it must follow that pursuing it will be a life of torment: to invest yourself in such great anxieties and be sure to be disappointed; to make that your goal which you cannot attain; to find that you labor in vain and daily meet with displeasure instead of the favor you expected, this must be a very grievous life. You are like someone who lives on the top of a mountain yet cannot bear to have the wind blow on him, or like someone who lives in a wood yet is frightened by the rustling of a leaf. You dwell among a world of wounded, self-serving, contradictory, changeable, unpleasable minds, and yet you cannot endure their displeasure.

Are you magistrates? The people will grumble at you; and those who are least qualified will be the quickest to criticize you and imagine they could govern far better. When someone asked Socrates whether a certain man had not spoken ill of him, he answered, "No; for those things are not in me." Those who bear the necessary burdens of public safety and defense will say you oppress them; criminals who are punished will say you deal with them without mercy; and those with the most unjust case will say you wronged them if the verdict goes against them. Are you pastors and teachers? You will seem too harsh to one person and too soft to another, indeed, too harsh to the very same person when you reprove or discipline his own faults, even while he criticizes you as too lenient and friendly toward sinners when you deal with others. No sermon you preach is likely to please all your hearers, nor any of your pastoral duties.

Are you lawyers? Clients who lost their case will call you unscrupulous behind your back and say you betrayed them; those who prevailed will call you greedy and complain how much you charged and how little you did. It is no wonder that among ordinary people your profession is a target for reproach. Are you physicians? You will be blamed for the deaths of those who die, and accused of greed for taking money whether the patient lives or dies, this is the common talk of the crowd, except among the few whose cases you handled well.

Are you tradespeople? Most buyers are so self-interested that unless you impoverish yourselves, they will say you deceive them, deal dishonestly, and charge too much. They give little thought to your family’s necessary support, and care nothing whether you live or profit by your trade. If you sell at a loss they will call you very honest; and yet when you are ruined, they will accuse you of imprudence and defrauding your creditors. You must buy dear and sell cheap and live by the loss, or displease. When Alcibiades told Socrates that Xanthippe’s peevishness was not to be borne, he answered that he had grown so accustomed to it that it was like the continual creaking of a pulley in his ears, and that after putting up with Xanthippe he found the rest of humanity easy to endure.

Direction 11. "Remember always that pleasing God is your purpose in this world, and that in pleasing him your soul may find safety, rest, and full contentment, even if the whole world is displeased with you." God is enough for you; his approval and favor are your portion and reward. How sweet and safe is the life of sincere and upright people, who care more to be good than to appear good, and who, knowing that God accepts them, count that enough! Bucholtzer said that this was almost the whole of the refuge and defense he had in his troubles: conversation with God, with true friends, and with mute masters.

What a mercy it is to have an upright heart, one that renounces the world and all within it that competes with God; that takes God as its true God, Lord, Judge, portion, and all; that in temptation remembers the eye of God, and in all its duty is moved and governed by the will and pleasure of its Judge; and that regards the eyes and thoughts of other people no more than it would the presence of a bird or animal, except as piety, justice, or charity require due regard for others in proper subordination to God.

Such a person, when others applaud them as exceptionally holy and good, feels anxious lest the all-knowing God think otherwise than their admirers do; and under all the censures, reproaches, and slanders of others, even when, through temptation, good people treat them unkindly, can live in peace on God’s approval alone, and can rejoice in being justified by his righteous Judge and gracious Redeemer, though the inconsiderable censures of people condemn him. No one is made wretched by another’s verdict, but by his own; and those who are truly blessed in their own conscience cannot be truly made miserable by any false judgment of others. (Salvian, On the Government of God, book 1.)

I cannot see how any other kind of person can live a life of true and solid peace and joy. If God’s approval and favor cannot quiet you, nothing can rationally do so. If pleasing him does not satisfy you, though people, though good people, though all people should be displeased with you, I do not know how or when you will be satisfied. Indeed, if you can rise above the censure of the ungodly but not also of the godly, when God permits them, as he permitted Job’s wife and friends, to be your trial, it will not be enough for a calm, contented, and quiet life. Consider, then:

1. If you seek first to please God and find your satisfaction there, you have only one to please instead of multitudes. As P. Scaliger said, the philosopher’s liberty is troublesome to everyone, and much more the faithful pastor’s. A multitude of masters is harder to please than one.

2. And he is one who requires nothing of you that is unreasonable, either in degree or in kind.

3. And he is one who is perfectly wise and good, and cannot misunderstand your situation or your actions.

4. And he is one who is perfectly holy, and takes no pleasure in iniquity or dishonesty.

5. And he is one who is impartial and perfectly just, and is no respecter of persons.

6. And he is a fully competent Judge, having both the fitness and the authority to judge, and being acquainted with your hearts and with every circumstance and reason behind your actions.

7. And he is one who is perfectly consistent with himself, and does not require contradictory or impossible things of you.

8. And he is one who is constant and unchangeable, not pleased with one thing today and the opposite tomorrow, not favorable to a person one year only to grow weary of them the next.

9. And he is one who is merciful, and does not require you to hurt yourselves to please him; indeed, he is pleased with nothing you do except what tends toward your happiness, and displeased with nothing except what harms you or others, like a father displeased when his children soil or injure themselves.

10. He is gentle, though just, in his judgments of you, judging truly, but not with harsh severity, and never making your actions out to be worse than they are.

11. He is not subject to the passions of people, which blind the mind and lead to injustice.

12. He cannot be moved by tale-bearers, whisperers, or false accusers, nor can he be misled by any false information.

Consider also the benefits of seeking to please God.

1. Pleasing him is your happiness itself, the matter of pure, full, and constant comfort, which you can have continually at hand and which no one can take from you. Attain this and you have reached the true end of human life; nothing can be added to it except its own perfection, which is heaven itself.

2. What an abundance of disappointments and frustrations you will escape, the very things that tear the hearts of those who live to please people, and fill their lives with useless sorrow.

3. It will direct and order your cares, desires, thoughts, and labors toward their right and proper end, and prevent those energies from being squandered on sin and vanity.

4. It will make your life not only divine, but make that divine life sweet and easy, as you set aside human censures that would otherwise create prejudice and difficulty for you. While others glory in wit, wealth, and strength, you will glory in this: that you know the Lord.

5. As God is above humanity, your heart and life are greatly ennobled by directing your regard to God and refusing to give disordered deference to people. This is truly to walk with God.

6. The sum of all graces is contained in this sincere desire to please God and in contentment with what you find you have attained of it. Here faith, humility, love, holy desire, trust, and the fear of God are all concentrated together. You "sanctify the Lord of hosts himself, and make him your fear, and dread, and sanctuary."

7. If human approval is genuinely good for you and worth having, seeking God’s pleasure is the surest way to obtain it, for God holds its disposal. "If a man’s ways please the LORD, he maketh even his enemies to be at peace with him," whether by calming their anger, restraining them from intended harm, or turning what they meant for hurt into your good.

See to it, then, that you live on God’s approval as the thing you chiefly seek and as what is sufficient for you. You may recognize whether you are doing this by these signs.

1.) You will be most careful to understand Scripture, so as to know what pleases and displeases God.

2.) You will take more care in performing every duty to fit it to the pleasing of God than of people.

3.) You will attend to your heart and not only to your outward actions, to your motives, thoughts, and the inward manner and degree of what you do.

4.) You will give as much attention to private duties as to public ones, and to what no one sees as much as to what others see.

5.) You will respect your conscience and deal seriously with it, never dismissing it. When it tells you of God’s displeasure, it will trouble you; when it tells you of his approval, it will comfort you.

6.) Your desire to please people will be charitable, for their genuine good, and ordered toward the pleasing of God; it will not be proud or ambitious for your own honor among them, nor will it come at the cost of displeasing God.

7.) Whether people are pleased or displeased, how they judge you, or what they call you, will seem a small matter, their own private concern, compared with God’s judgment. You do not live on their opinion. You can bear their displeasure, censures, and reproaches, if God is but pleased. These will be your evidences.