A Christian Directory 2. Governing Heart and LifeRichard Baxter
N.B. The following text was freely provided by Updated Works. Their updated books and audios are superb in every way.
"Some of the most important ideas in history are locked away in old books that modern readers struggle to understand. Archaic language, unfamiliar phrasing, and outdated conventions create unnecessary barriers to timeless wisdom.
"Updated Works exists to change that. We take significant older texts and translate them into clear, contemporary English while faithfully preserving the author's original meaning and voice. Our goal is simple: make important books readable again.
"Archaic spelling, obsolete words, and tangled sentence structure are rendered into clear, contemporary English--always preserving the author's meaning, voice, and line of argument. We modernize the language, never the message."Please visit their website to purchase select hardcopy books and audio books: Updated Works.
Publisher’s Introduction
A Christian Directory is Richard Baxter’s attempt to answer, in one book, the question a minister is asked all day long: what should I actually do? Published in 1673, it is a sum of practical theology and cases of conscience, written by a man who had spent twenty years being consulted. This volume continues Christian Ethics, the part of that work treating a person’s private duties. It completes Baxter’s account of the three sins he judged most ruinous to a soul, pride, covetousness, and the flesh-pleasing he called the master sin, and then turns to the ordinary government of a life: the redeeming of time, the government of the thoughts, the passions, the senses, and the tongue, and last a Christian’s labor, recreations, and apparel. Here Baxter descends from principle to case, and the cases are domestic ones. The result is a manual rather than a treatise.
CHAPTER 1
DIRECTIONS AGAINST PRIDE AND FOR HUMILITY
Pride, being widely regarded as the great sin of the devil by which he fell, is in name and general reputation infamous and odious to almost everyone. Yet its nature is so little understood, and the sin so seldom recognized by most people, that it is commonly cherished even while it is commonly condemned. Therefore the chief directions for conquering pride are those that expose it fully. For when pride is seen it is shamed, and to shame it is to destroy it. On this subject, read the preface to my book Self-Denial, and chapters 41 through 51.
Direction 1. Understand the nature of pride rightly, so that you neither ignorantly cling to it nor oppose your duty by mistaking it for pride. Here I will explain: I. What pride is, what commandment it violates, and what humility, its opposite, consists in. II. Some appearances that resemble pride, which may cause people to be judged proud for what is not pride at all. III. The counterfeits of humility, which may cause a proud person to appear humble to himself or others.
I. Pride is an excessive self-exaltation, a lifting of oneself above the state or degree God has appointed. The Greek word for it carries the sense of appearing to oneself, and desiring to appear to others, as greater than one actually is or greater than others of one’s standing. Pride is a branch of selfishness; it contains within it the man-pleasing described earlier, and it produces hypocrisy, being indeed that hypocrisy’s root and life. It consists in the following acts or parts.
1. A will to be higher or greater than God would have us be.
2. An overvaluing of ourselves, esteeming ourselves greater, wiser, or better than we truly are.
3. A desire that others should think of us, speak of us, and treat us as greater, wiser, or better than we are.
4. An effort or striving to rise above our appointed place, or to be overvalued by others.
5. An outward display of our inordinate self-esteem in speech or action.
Each of these is an act of pride. The first three are its inward acts in the mind and will; the last two are its external acts.
As love of God and love of neighbor are the comprehensive duties of the Decalogue, expressed most fully in the first and last commandments but extending throughout all the rest, so selfishness and pride (which is a principal part of selfishness) are the opposing sins, forbidden chiefly in the first and last commandments as contrary to the love of God and neighbor, but also contrary to all the rest. They are sins against the very relationship in which God and other people stand to us, not merely against a particular rule. They are against the very constitution of God’s kingdom, not only against its administration. Pride is treason and idolatry against God, a seizing of some portion of his own prerogative. And in the body of humanity it is a monstrous swelling, a single member rising above and therefore against the rest: against superiors (and so against the fifth commandment) or against equals (and so against the remaining commandments).
Humility is the opposite of pride, and therefore consists in these things.
1. A contentedness with the degree and state God has assigned us.
2. Modest thoughts of ourselves, esteeming ourselves no greater, wiser, or better than we truly are.
3. A willingness and genuine desire that others should not think of us, speak of us, or treat us as greater, wiser, or better than we are; that they should give us no more honor, praise, or affection than is our due, since anything beyond that is only a deception, and an injury to both sides.
4. Avoiding all inordinate and ambitious striving, and contentedly fulfilling our assigned duties, including the humblest tasks belonging to our own station.
5. Avoiding all pretense or display of greatness, wisdom, or goodness we do not possess, and fitting our speech, dress, provision, furnishings, and entire bearing and conduct to the modest measure of our abilities, our place, and our actual worth.
This is the very nature of humility. Its more particular signs I will set out later.
II. Pride residing in the heart is often misjudged by others who see only outward appearances, and sometimes by the person himself who does not understand its nature. The inward qualities that are mistaken for pride but are not pride include the following.
1. When a person in authority has a spirit fitted to his position and work, this is not pride but virtue.
2. When natural strength and vigor of spirit drives out timidity, especially when faith, fixing its gaze on God, drives out all inordinate deference to human opinion and all fear of what people can do, this is not pride but Christian magnanimity and courage. Its opposite is not humility but weakness, faint-heartedness, and cowardice.
3. When a wise person recognizes the degree to which he is wise and the degree to which others are ignorant or mistaken; when he is aware of his knowledge, takes delight in it through love of truth, and is thankful to God for revealing it and for blessing his studies so far, all this is a mercy and a duty, not pride. Truth is in itself admirable and delightful. One who knows must necessarily know that he knows, just as one who sees perceives by the very act of seeing that he sees. If it were wrong to know that I know, it would be wrong to know anything at all. But some knowledge is both necessary and unavoidable; what is good must be valued; and we must be thankful for it. Humility does not require a wise person to regard his knowledge as equal to a fool’s, any more than a healthy person must regard himself as sick.
4. When a wise person values the useful knowledge God has given him above all worldly glory and vanity, which is indeed of lower worth, this is not pride but a right estimation of things. Tauler distinguishes two kinds of humility here: one that is clear-sighted but not warm, exercised more by reason than by love; and another that is both clear-sighted and warm, exercised more by love than by reason, though not without reason. For humility, like the other virtues, is a work of the will: we come to know the virtues by reason, but it is by love that they become sweet to us.
5. When a wise person desires that others would share his convictions for their own good and for the spreading of truth, this is not pride but charity and love of truth. Otherwise preachers would be the proudest of all people, and Paul would have done wrong in laboring so hard for conversions and saying to Agrippa, "I would to God, that not only thou, but also all that hear me this day, were both almost and altogether such as I am, except these bonds" (Acts 26:29).
6. When an innocent person is conscious of his innocence, and a holy person is conscious of his holiness, assured of his standing in grace, rejoices in it, and is thankful for it, this is not pride but an excellent privilege and duty. If angels rejoice over the conversion of a sinner, the sinner himself has good reason to rejoice. And if it is a sin to be ungrateful for our daily bread, it is far more so to be ungrateful for grace and the hope of glory.
7. When we value our good name and the honor that is genuinely our due, as we value other outward common mercies, not for their own sake but insofar as they honor God, or tend to the good of others, or advance truth and piety; when we desire no more than is truly our due and do not overvalue honor as something we cannot do without, but submit it to God’s will as something we can live without, this is not pride but a right estimation of the thing.
The outward appearances that others frequently mistake for signs and fruits of pride include the following.
1. When a magistrate or other governor maintains the dignity belonging to his office, which is necessary for effective government, and lives according to his station. When rulers, masters, and parents keep that appropriate distance from their subjects, servants, students, and children that is fitting and necessary for those people’s good, this is usually misjudged as pride.
2. When a sinner becomes convinced of the necessity of holiness in a time and place where it is rare, and where infidelity, profaneness, and ungodliness are the common path, the necessary distinctiveness of that person in giving himself to the will of God is commonly laid at his charge as pride. As if he were proud because he cannot be content to be damned in company with the majority; or to despise salvation because most despise it; or to forsake God when most forsake him; or to serve the devil when most men do.
If you will not swear, drink to excess, gamble, and spend your time, even the Lord’s Day, in vanity and sensuality, as if you were afraid of being saved and as if it were your business to work out your damnation, the world will call you proud and singular, and "think it strange that you run not with them to excess of riot, speaking evil of you" (1 Pet 4:4). Plutarch, in his tract How a Man May Praise Himself Without Incurring Blame, holds that a man who is blamed and who suffers reproach for well-doing may justly speak in his own praise. You will soon hear them say: "What, will you be wiser than the whole town? What a saint! What a precise holy man!" When Lot was grieved at the filthiness of Sodom, they scorned him as a proud interferer: "This one fellow came in to sojourn, and he will needs be a judge" (Gen 19:9).
And what did the world think of Noah, who walked with God in such conspicuous distinctiveness when the world was drowned in, and destroyed for, its wickedness? When David "humbled his soul with fasting," they turned it to "his reproach" (Ps 69:10). Especially when any of Christ’s servants press toward the highest degrees of holiness, they will certainly be regarded as proud hypocrites.
And yet no one accuses that child or servant of pride who surpasses all the rest in pleasing their superiors and doing their work. Nor do people take a sick man to be proud if he is more careful than others about recovering his health. But the person who strives most for heaven, most carefully avoids sin and hell, is most earnest in his religion, and most diligent to please God, this person will be counted proud.
3. Anyone who refuses to forsake God, betray the truth, or wound his conscience by willful sin, who acts as Daniel and the three confessors did (Dan 6 and 3), and answers as they answered, will be counted proud. But it is no pride to prefer God before men, or to fear damnation more than imprisonment or death. The army of martyrs did not in pride prefer their own judgment over the superiors who condemned them; they did it in obedience to God and truth, when that truth was revealed to babes but hidden from the wise, the prudent, the great, and the noble of the world.
4. When those who are faithful to the honor of Christ’s sovereignty dare not approve of papal usurpations against his laws, over his church, and over the consciences of his subjects, the Popish usurpers will call them proud and despisers of government, as if a usurper of royal power should call us proud for refusing to consent to his usurpation, or call us traitors for not being traitors as he is himself.
5. When a man who feels the weight of God’s affairs and the salvation of souls is zealous and diligent to teach others, and when he is a minister, is fervent and laborious in his ministry, he is called proud, as one who insists that everyone must hold his views. Yet compassion for souls, readiness to teach, and preaching urgently in season and out of season are duties that God requires of him. And what is the ministry for, if not to change men’s minds and bring them into full obedience to the truth?
6. If a man understands a point of divinity better than most others, or holds a truth not currently fashionable or commonly received, he will be counted proud for presuming to be so singular and for appearing wiser than those who think they are wiser than he. But humility does not teach us to err for company’s sake, or to stop growing in wisdom once we reach the common level, or to abandon truth that others have not grasped, or to refrain from teaching it merely because it is not already known. If some of the pastors in Abyssinia, Syria, Armenia, Russia, Greece, Italy, or Spain were as well-informed as ministers in England, that would be no evidence of their pride.
7. If a man who understands something contrary to another’s view cannot abandon his position and think or speak as that other would have him, especially if he contradicts him in argument, the other will take it as pride and an overvaluation of one’s own understanding, a stubbornness toward one’s own opinions. Erroneous men who are themselves proudly eager to win others to their views will call you proud for not yielding to their pride. They believe the evidence on their side is so clear that, if you were not proud, you could not help but agree with them. Bias, in the words Diogenes Laertius records, advised the opposite temper: if you set out to do anything, go at it slowly, but hold firmly to what you have chosen.
8. Some humble men are by nature warm and earnest in their manner of speaking, and their natural heat and eagerness are frequently mistaken for pride, until closer acquaintance with their humble lives corrects the error. It is written of Bishop Hooper the martyr that "those that visited him once condemned him of over-austerity; they that came to him twice only suspected him of the same; those that conversed with him constantly not only acquitted him of all harshness, but commended him for sweetness of manners. So that his ill-nature consisted in other men’s little acquaintance with him." Thomas Fuller, Church History, book 7, page 402, and Godwin on the Bishops of Gloucester. The same is true of very many worthy men. Eunapius, praising the humility of Chrysanthius, grants that he was nonetheless rather persistent and did not easily give up an opinion.
9. If we zealously contend for the faith or the peace of the church against heretical or divisive persons and their dangerous ways, they will call us proud, though God commands it of us (Jude 3), especially if we "avoid them" and "bid them not God speed" (Titus 3:10 2 John 10).
10. When a man of understanding exposes another’s ignorance and speaks words of pity about him, even when this is no more than truth and charity require, it will be taken as the language of supercilious pride.
11. That plain dealing in rebuke which God commands, especially from his ministers, toward high and low alike, and which the prophets and servants of God have practiced, will be misread as arrogance and pride (Amos 7:12–13 2 Chr 25:16 Acts 23:4). As if it were pride to be faithful to God, to pity souls, to seek to save them, and to tell them in time of what conscience will speak more closely and terribly when it is too late!
12. Self-idolizing Papists charge their inferiors with pride if they so much as modestly exercise a judgment of discretion in matters bearing on their salvation, if they refuse to believe implicitly as their superiors believe, if they dare to examine or test what is said, if they refuse to swallow everything without any reflection, or if they hold up the commands of God against unlawful human commands. This is as if God were content to suspend his laws whenever human commands contradict them, or as if humility required us to please and obey men at the cost of our salvation. Augustine rightly argues: "When you lie for the sake of humility, if you were not a sinner before you lied, you make yourself by lying what you sought to avoid" (On the Words of the Apostle).
The Papists think we should not trouble ourselves to inquire into such matters but should entrust our souls to them; that the Scriptures are not for lay people to read but that all must rely wholly on the clergy. If a layman inquires into their doctrine or commands, they say to him as David’s brother said to him: "With whom hast thou left the sheep in the wilderness? I know thy pride, and the naughtiness of thy heart" (1 Sam 17:28).
13. If a zealous, humble preacher of the Gospel, one who preaches not himself but Christ, is highly esteemed and honored for his work’s sake, and is crowded after and greatly followed by those who are built up by his ministry, it is common for the envious and the enemies of godliness to say that he is proud and preaches in order to draw disciples to himself and be admired. They judge others’ hearts by their own. They seem not to know that Christ and his most excellent servants have been eagerly followed without thereby being lifted up or justly charged with pride, just as the sun is not to blame for being seen and admired by all the world, nor fire and water, earth and air, food and rest, for being valued by all.
Little do such critics know how deep a renewed sense of their own unworthiness is worked in the hearts of the most applauded preachers by the very occasion of men’s esteem and praise, and how much those preachers desire that no one should overvalue them and turn the eye from the doctrine to the person. How often they cry out with the laborious apostle, "Who is sufficient for these things?" How often they are tempted to abandon everything through fear and a sense of their own unfitness, while envious, dull men fearlessly deliver a dry discourse and think themselves wronged because they are not commended and followed as much as others. Such critics call it pride that the common sense of all the faithful, together with love of the truth and concern for their salvation, leads people to prefer the means best suited to their edification and salvation.
14. If a humble Christian, after much temptation and a holy life, has arrived at well-grounded assurance of his salvation and is thankful to God for sanctifying him and numbering him among his little flock, while the world lies in wickedness, he will be taken for proud by ungodly men who cannot bear to hear beforehand of the difference that God’s judgment will declare between the righteous and the wicked. As if it were pride to be happy, or pride to be thankful.
15. If a man who is falsely accused or slandered modestly denies the charge and uses the lawful means he owes to his own vindication, he will be accused of pride for contradicting proud accusers and refusing to bear false witness against himself, even when the dishonor of religion and the hindrance of men’s salvation are the consequences of his own dishonor going unchallenged.
16. Many poor people mistake their superiors for proud if those superiors do not dress in nearly the same fashion and value as themselves, even when the superior’s dress is sober and fitting to their rank.
17. Some people have a more blunt or careless manner, ill-suited to elaborate courtesy. Others are so absorbed in serious studies and duties that they have neither time nor inclination to attend to the expectations of those who prize formal compliments. Such people are usually charged with pride by those who feel slighted. Callimachus records of Attila that his gait and bearing were so affected and studied that he earned the reputation of an extremely arrogant spirit from that alone (Callimachus, Experie. de Attila, page 341).
18. Some people have a quiet temperament and are accused of pride because they do not speak to others as often as those others expect.
19. Some are naturally slow to become familiar until they have gained real acquaintance; they are so far from boldness that they cannot readily address strangers or even their own inferiors, and so they are commonly misjudged as proud.
20. Some have acquired awkward habits in their speech or gestures that hasty judges read as arising from pride, though it is not so. Through all these appearances, the humble are judged by many to be proud. Eunapius notes of Chrysanthius that his keeping away from the company of great men and nobles was not to be attributed to arrogance or disdain; it should rather be seen as a kind of rusticity and simplicity in a man who did not know what power he held, and so he spoke with them in an ordinary, unaffected way.
III. There are also many counterfeits of humility, by which the proud are taken to be humble.
1. Accusing themselves and bewailing their vileness out of sheer terror of conscience, as Judas did, or under the compulsion of affliction, as Pharaoh did, or in the face of death.
2. The habitual confessing of those sins in prayer or conversation that the best Christians are accustomed to confess, where the very act of confessing is considered more an honor than a disgrace.
3. A religious observance of those commandments and traditions of men of which the apostle speaks, things that have a "shew of wisdom in will-worship, and humility, and neglecting of the body, not in any honour to the satisfying of the flesh" (Col 2:18–23).
4. Holding doctrines that theoretically do most to abase humanity, while never being truly humbled in the heart.
5. A discreet restraint of boasting, combined with a carefully managed self-deprecation calculated to earn a reputation for modesty and humility.
6. An affected condescension and familiarity with others, even those of the lower sort, so that even the poorest receive smiles and courtesy, yet this may be nothing but the humility of Absalom (2 Sam 15:3–6), the fruit of pride, designed to win the commendation of the world.
7. Choosing to associate with inferiors in order to hold sway and always be the greatest person in the room, like Dionysius the tyrant, who, after being dethroned, became a schoolmaster so that he might still domineer, though only over boys.
8. A compelled plainness in dress, provisions, and conduct, when poverty forces a man to speak and live as though he were humble; yet if he had wealth and honor, he would live as extravagantly as the proudest of all. How quiet is the bear when it is chained? And how little does a dog or fox require when it can get no more?
9. An affected plainness in dress while pride runs out by some other channel. A man who is offensively proud of his supposed wisdom, learning, holiness, birth, or reputation may in his very pride consider himself above the womanish and childish form of pride shown in fine clothes and such other little toys.
10. Condemning and speaking against the pride of others while overlooking his own, perhaps because another’s pride overshadows him, just as the covetous resent others who are covetous, since those others are the greatest obstacle to their own gain; as dogs fight over the bone that both desire. Many more counterfeits of humility can be gathered from what was said above about the appearances of pride, to which humility is contrary.
Direction 2. Observe the movements and manifestations of pride toward God and man, so that it may not, like the devil, prevail by remaining unseen. Because this is the chief part of the present work, I will here set out distinctly the signs and movements of pride in its several workings against God and man.
Signs of the Worst Part of Pride against God
Sign 1. Self-idolizing pride causes men to glory in their supposed greatness at the very moment when the greatness of God should reveal their contemptible smallness, and to magnify themselves when they should magnify their Maker. It makes the strong man glory in his strength, the rich man in his wealth, the conqueror in his victories, and princes, rulers, and lords of the earth in their dominions, dignities, and power to help or harm others (Jer 9:23–24 Ps 49:6 2 Chr 25:19), speaking as Nebuchadnezzar did: "Is not this great Babylon that I have built, for the house of the kingdom, by the might of my power, for the honour of my majesty?" (Dan 4:30).
How hard it is to be great and truly humble, and not to swell and be lifted up in heart as one rises in power! God abhors this as unfitting in creatures who are worms and dust, and as an injury to his honor. He will make such men know that power, riches, and strength are his, and that "the Most High doth rule in the kingdom of men, and giveth it to whomsoever he will" (Dan 4:32).
Sign 2. Pride causes men to set up their supposed worth and goodness above or against the Lord, making themselves their supreme end. Some have lately presumed to teach that God cannot and ought not to be man’s end, that man alone is his own end, as if we were made only for ourselves and not for our Creator. Pride makes a man so important in his own estimation that he lives entirely for himself, as if the world stood or fell with him. If he is well, all is well. If he must die, he takes it as though the world were ending. He values God only as he values food, health, or pleasure, as a means to his own felicity, never preferring God before himself, never making God the chief object of his final aim.
He loves himself far more than he loves God. Man has so completely fallen away from God toward himself that he feels this disposition as strongly as if it were his original nature, and therefore warranted, and as if it were impossible to aim higher.
Paul Scaliger puts it this way: as the light of the moon does not appear in the presence of the sun, so by the same reasoning the second does not appear in the presence of the first, nor our own merit in the presence of the merit of Christ.
God is to be man’s end, even though we can add nothing to him. The highest love presupposes no lack in the one loved, but an excellency of glory, wisdom, and goodness to which all our faculties offer themselves in admiration, love, and praise. This love is directed not only to the delight that flows from these things, nor only that our persons may thereby be happy, but chiefly so that God may receive what is his due, and his will may be pleased and fulfilled, because his excellencies deserve all this from men and angels.
When we love a man of wonderful learning, wisdom, meekness, charity, holiness, and goodness, it is not chiefly for our own sake that we love him, that we may receive something from him. We feel his excellency commanding our love even if we were certain we should never receive anything from him. Nor is the delight of loving him our chief end; that delight is a consequence, or a lesser part of our end, for we feel that we love him before we even think of the delight.
The admiration, love, and praise of God as our ultimate end have no end beyond their proper object: they are themselves the final act, man’s perfection. Loveliness draws love as a magnet. If you ask an angel why it loves God, it will say: because he is infinitely lovable. And though in such movements nature secretly aims at its own perfection and happiness, and lawfully draws itself into this final motion, yet the union being between such infinitely unequal parties, how little do the glorified spirits regard themselves in comparison to the blessed, glorious God! See what I said on this above, Chapter 3, Directions 11 and 15. To be supremely loved and to be the ultimate end come to the same thing, and beyond doubt God is to be supremely loved; though Hesychius Illustris reports that Aristotle declared the one end to be the exercise of virtue in a holy and complete life.
Sign 3. Pride makes men more eager to be loved and admired themselves than to love God or to see God loved by others. They want the eyes and hearts of all people fixed on them, as if they were the sun, to be admired and loved by everyone who sees them.
Sign 4. Pride causes men to depend on themselves, to scheme inordinately for their own advantage, and to trust in themselves, as if they lived by their own wit, power, and industry rather than by God’s favor and providence.
Sign 5. Pride makes men return to themselves the thanks that are due to God for the mercies they have received. They thank God only as a formality, but seriously attribute everything to their own care, skill, industry, or power. They sacrifice to their own net and say, "Our hand, our planning, our power, our good management did all this."
Diogenes Laertius, in his life of Thales, tells how the oracle of Delphi awarded the golden tripod to the wisest person; it was sent to Thales, who passed it on to another, until at last it came to Solon, who returned it to the oracle, saying that no one is wiser than God. So we should all return to God the praise and glory of everything that is credited to us.
Sign 6. Pride sets up the wisdom of a foolish man against the infinite wisdom of God. It leads men to presume to judge their Judge and to pass verdict on his laws before they have understood them, quarreling with everything that does not suit their own notions and asking, "How improbable is this or that? How can these things be?" The man who cannot undo a puzzle of linked wire rings, or unriddle a riddle until it is taught him, though it seems obvious once explained, will challenge the truth of the Word of God concerning its highest and most unsearchable mysteries. Proud men imagine they could improve on God’s Word, and that they could have ordered things better in the world, in the church, and for themselves and their friends, than God’s providence has done.
Sign 7. Pride makes men rank their own love and mercy above the love and mercy of God. Augustine mentions a group of heretics he calls Misericordes, "the merciful ones," and Origen was led by this very tendency into his errors. When such men contemplate hell-fire, the great number of the miserable, and the fewness of the saved, they consult their ignorant compassion and conclude that this falls below the love and mercy they themselves possess; they would not treat even an enemy this way, and so they censure Holy Scripture. Pride strongly inclines them toward unbelief, while they forget the narrowness and darkness of their own souls, how unfit they are to censure God, how many truths may lie beyond their sight that would fully satisfy them if they knew them, and how swiftly God will show them what justifies his Word and all his works, and convicts them of the folly and arrogance of their unbelief and censures.
Sign 8. Pride makes men claim to be more just than God, to think they could govern the world more justly, and to censure God’s threatenings, the sufferings of the righteous, and the prosperity of the wicked as such injustices that they are inclined toward atheism. Just so, James and John presumed to be more just than Christ and called for fire on those who rejected the Gospel; and the prodigal’s elder brother resented his father’s leniency.
Sign 9. Pride makes men disregard the authority and commands of God, despise his messengers, and choose to be ruled by their own notions, lusts, and interests, while the humble tremble at his Word and readily obey it (Isa 57:15 Neh 9:16 Neh 9:29 Isa 9:9).
Sign 10. A proud man in power will expect his own will to be obeyed before the will of God, and will expect God’s subjects to displease their Master rather than displease him. He regards it as a crime for a man to inquire first what God would have him do, or to plead conscience and the commands of the God of heaven against obeying his own unjust commands. If he offers promotion, as Balak did to Balaam, he expects it to attract more than God’s offer of eternal life. If he threatens, as Nebuchadnezzar threatened the three witnesses, he expects to be feared more than God who threatens damnation, and he is angry if he is not.
Sign 11. A proud man is more offended by anyone who questions his authority, speaks dismissively of his power, resists his will, or crosses his interest, than by anyone who sins against the authority, will, and interest of God. He is far more zealous for his own honor than for God’s, more grieved by his own dishonor, more hostile to his own enemies than to God’s, and he will trample on the interests of God and souls when it seems necessary to serve his own honor or revenge. He takes far more pleasure and delight in his own applause, honor, and greatness than in the glory of God or the fulfilling of his will.
Sign 12. Proud men would gladly steal from God himself the honor due to his most excellent works. If they are rulers, they are more eager that the people credit the order and peace of society to them than to God. If they are preachers, they would claim more than their due share of the honor for men’s conversion and growth. If they are pastors, they would encroach on Christ’s own part in the government of his church. If they are generous to the poor and do good works, they want more praise than is fitting for a steward or messenger who merely delivers another’s gifts. If they are physicians, they want the real credit for the cure and leave God only an empty compliment, like the atheistical physician who rebuked and struck his patient for thanking God for his recovery, saying, "It was I who cured you; why do you thank God for it?" As Bias said, in the words recorded by Diogenes Laertius: "Whatever good you do, refer it to God."
Sign 13. A proud man gives more to his own honor than to God. His wealth is more at the command of his pride than of God. He gives more when others can see or know about it than he would give in secret. He is more generous with gifts that maintain his reputation for liberality than he is toward those who are truly in need. His chief motive is not the good done but the honor he expects to gain by it. He would rather be sparing in works of the greatest secret charity than in dress, a dignified appearance, the entertainment of friends, or anything done for show and for himself.
Sign 14. A proud man wants others to be as dependent on him as possible. He would like the estates, lives, and welfare of all others to lie in his hand, so that many would fear him, love him, and thank him, and so that many would be indebted to him as the god or great benefactor of the world. He is not satisfied that good is done and needs are supplied unless he himself does it, so that the praise may be his. If he spares an enemy, it is only to make that enemy beholden to him and to be said to have given him his life. He wants to be regarded as the sun is to the world, something mankind cannot do without.
Sign 15. A proud man is very patient when men credit him with more than he knows he deserves, even at the injury of God. He readily forgives those who value and love him beyond what is due, though they sin in doing so. He is seldom offended when anyone praises him too highly, honors or reverences him excessively, sets him too high, ascribes too much power to him, or obeys him ahead of God himself. He cannot have too much love, honor, praise, or thanks.
A humble soul, by contrast, speaks as Psalm 115:1: "Not unto us, O Lord, not unto us, but unto thy name give the glory." And like the angel to John when he would have worshipped him: "See thou do it not, for I am thy fellow servant." They know that God will not give "his glory to another" (Isa 42:8), and that "in his temple every one speaketh of his glory" (Ps 29:9). But of themselves they say, "I am a worm and no man; I am less than the least of all thy mercies; less than the least of all saints; the chiefest of sinners. How unfit am I for so much love, and praise, and honour!"
Sign 16. A proud man wants his reason to be the rule for all the world, or at least for all who are under his influence. If laws or canons were to be made, he would want to make them. He would have everyone take his counsel as an oracle. He would have all the world hold his opinion, and he values more those who esteem him, agree with him, and yield to everything he says and does, than those who most earnestly seek to conform their minds to the Word of God and differ from him in their understanding of any part of it. He prefers those who consult him and take his word over those who consult the Word of God, even though he cannot deny that infallibility and governance of the world are God’s prerogative alone.
Sign 17. A proud man also desires the reputation of God’s immutability, as well as his infallibility. When he has once put forward an error, he will stand by it; when he has once opposed the truth, he will continue to resist it, all to avoid the disgrace of being thought changeable or previously mistaken. His pride keeps him from repenting of any fault or error that he can find even the flimsiest excuse to cover. If he has wronged God and harmed the church, he will do as much again and worse to make it seem right, justifying it by cruelty or violence. If he has once wronged you, he will wrong you further rather than appear to have erred; if he has slandered you, he will destroy you if he can, in order to justify the slander rather than seem so inconsistent as to retract it.
Sign 18. A proud man desires a share in God’s omniscience, and is eager to know beyond what God has revealed, when his pride runs in the direction of intellectual inquiry. This was the sin of our first parents, who desired to be like God in knowledge. This has filled the world with proud contentions and the church with divisions, as proud intellects heretically make unrevealed things the material for their display, their impositions, their censures, and their furious disputes. Humble souls, by contrast, occupy themselves with studying and practicing what has been revealed, and keep within the bounds God has set, knowing that God best understands what measure of knowledge is fitting for them, and that knowledge is to be desired and sought only insofar as it serves our enjoyment of God and the good that truth reveals to us. Otherwise, knowledge may become our sorrow, and truth the instrument of our torment, as it does for the miserable souls in hell.
Sign 19. A proud man is discontented with his station, especially if it is low. He would be higher in power, honor, and wealth; indeed, no height satisfies him but he would go one step higher still. If he had a kingdom, he would want another; if he had the dominions of the Turkish or Tartarian emperor, he would want to enlarge them and to have still more, and would not rest until he possessed the whole world. People do not feel this while they are in humble circumstances, they think, If I only had this much, or that much, I would be content. But this is their ignorance of the insatiable pride that dwells in them.
Look at the greatest emperors on earth: they are always seeking to be greater. Every man by nature would be a pope, a universal monarch of the world; and every such pope would hold both swords, and have princes and peoples entirely at his will, and even when he has no desire to do harm, he would want the power to harm, so that all the world might hold their estates, liberties, and lives by his clemency and gift, and he might be as God to other men. And if he attained all this, pride would not stop until it had driven him to seize every prerogative of God, to dethrone God of his Godhead and majesty, and take his place.
Sign 20. A proud man earnestly desires God’s independence. Though necessity may make him stoop, he would gladly be beholden to no one, not merely because good judgment tells him to preserve his liberty and avoid becoming unnecessarily the servant of men or obligated to serve them in evil ways (for even the humblest person would prefer such independence), but because he would be so great and exalted as to scorn leaning on anyone else. So you see how pride is that great idolatry that sets man up in the place of God.
Signs of the Next Degrees of Pride, as against God
Sign 1. A proud heart is brought only with great difficulty to see the greatness of its sins, to know its own emptiness of grace, to be convinced of its unpardoned and miserable state, or to acknowledge the justice of God should he condemn it to everlasting torments. Concerning others it may readily confess all of this, but hardly concerning itself. Its own unbelief and aversion from God and holiness appear to it a small and tolerable fault; its own pride, lust, worldliness, and sensuality do not seem bad enough to deserve damnation, let alone the smallest sin it commits. Although people may say by habit that God would be just in condemning them, they do not believe it in their hearts.
The most persuasive preacher will have great difficulty bringing a proud man sincerely to confess that he is an enemy to God, a child of wrath, under the guilt of all his sins, and certainly condemned unless he is converted. He will confess that he is a sinner, or anything else that the most godly must also confess, or that does not mark him out as being in a damnable and unregenerate state, but to make an ungodly man know that he is ungodly, an impenitent man know that he is impenitent, and an unsanctified man know that he is unsanctified, is exceedingly hard, because pride has dominion in them. "Are we blind also?" the proud and unteachable Pharisees asked Christ (John 9:40).
Sign 2. A proud heart so greatly overvalues everything that is in itself that every ordinary grace or duty appears to it to constitute a state of godliness. Its common knowledge seems to it to be saving illumination. Every slight sorrow for sin, or wish that things had gone differently once the sweetness of sin has been spent, passes with it for true repentance. Its listless lip-service passes for acceptable prayer; its outward form of religion seems to it to be the life of godliness. It mistakes its own presumption for true faith, its false expectation for Christian hope, its carnal security and dull stupidity for spiritual peace of conscience, and its reckless gambling of the soul on self-deception for a genuine trusting of the soul to God.
If people refrain only from those sins their flesh can do without, sins unnecessary to their ease, provision, or comfort, or even sins the flesh itself tells them to avoid because those sins would damage their reputation, they take this for true obedience to God. Because they would rather have heaven than hell when they must leave the earth whether they will or not, they think themselves heavenly-minded, that they lay up treasure there and take it as their portion. Because conscience sometimes troubles them for their sin, they think they are renewing sincere repentance; and because they daily ask for pardon, they think all is forgiven. Their forced submission to God’s hand they take for patience, and a "Lord, have mercy on us, forgive us, and save us" they take for a true preparation for death. So pride deceives sinners by making them believe they have what they do not have, do what they do not do, and are something when they are nothing, and by multiplying and magnifying the little common good that is in them.
Sign 3. A proud heart has very little sense of the necessity of a Savior who dies for its sins, satisfies God’s justice, and reconciles it to God. Notionally it is sick of sin, and notionally it thinks it needs a physician, but at the heart it practically feels little of its disease, and therefore sets little value on Christ. It does not feel what would thoroughly acquaint it with the reasons for that blessed work of our redemption, and so it is in truth a stranger to the mystery and an infidel at heart, and would turn apostate if the trial were severe enough.
Such a person has never felt himself a condemned man, under the curse and wrath of God, liable to hell. He has therefore never lain in tears with Mary at his Savior’s feet, never wept over his bleeding Lord, never said feelingly with Paul, "He came to save sinners, of whom I am chief," nor "esteemed all things as loss and dung for the knowledge of Christ, that he might be found in him" (Phil 3:7–8). He is a Christian only in the way a Turk is a Mahometan, because it is the religion of the king and of the country in which he was raised.
Sign 4. A proud heart does not perceive its own need for so great a change as the new birth, or for the Holy Ghost to give it a new nature and plant the image of God upon it. Such a person may notice some failings in the soul, but thinks there is no need to break the heart over them, no need to pull everything down and build hope afresh. Amending the heart, he thinks, is enough; there is no need to make it and all things new. He takes the new creature to be nothing more than baptism, or some patching up of the former state with corrections of the grosser faults. He will confess that without Christ and grace we can do nothing, yet he thinks of this grace as an ordinary kind of assistance. The humble soul, by contrast, is so emptied of self, and so aware of its own deadness and insufficiency for good, that it magnifies grace and is deeply thankful for it as for a new and spiritual life.
Sign 5. A proud heart has so little experiential sense of the great accusations Scripture brings against the corrupted heart of man that it is easily drawn into any heresy that denies them, concerning original sin and misery, our need of a Savior, the desperate wickedness of the heart, and man’s inability and aversion toward good. Humble people, by contrast, are better acquainted with the sin within them, which bears witness to all these truths.
Sign 6. The proud have no sense of the need and reason for all the diligence God requires: mortifying the flesh, subduing corruptions, watching the heart, and walking with God in holiness of life. Such a person asks, what need is there for all this effort? Not feeling the need of it, he concludes it is more trouble than necessary. The humble soul, however, is aware of what is within him that makes it necessary and vindicates the strictest ways of God. The wealthy think they have no need to labor; but labor is the poor man’s life and livelihood, miss a day’s work and he feels the lack of it the next.
Sign 7. Proud men have little sense of the need for frequent and fervent prayer to God. Begging is the poor man’s trade; the humble soul perceives that need. He finds as constant a need of God as of air, or bread, or life itself. He knows that the exercise of desire and faith, and the expression by prayer of dependence upon God, is the appointed way to receive supply. The proud are self-satisfied, and think this earnest, frequent praying is nothing but hypocritical and needless work. They cannot make a trade of begging, and so they are sent away empty.
Sign 8. A proud man greatly undervalues all mercies and is ungrateful for them, especially for spiritual mercy. He receives it as a matter of custom, as though it were his due, and gives God thanks in the same customary way. Though he may rejoice in bodily prosperity, he is a stranger to holy thankfulness to God, and thinks diminutively of mercy. Indeed, he is discontented and murmurs if God does not give him as much as he desires. The humble, by contrast, confess themselves unworthy of the least (Gen 32:10). Hezekiah’s self-exaltation and ingratitude are found together (2 Chr 32:24–26). A poor man is deeply thankful for a penny or a crust of bread that the rich would reject as an indignity.
Sign 9. Proud men are always impatient in their afflictions. If they have some stubbornness or numbness, still they lack Christian patience. They take affliction as though God were treating them harshly or doing them wrong. The humble know that they deserve far worse, and that whatever mercy remains to them is more than they deserve. They therefore say with the humbled church, "I will bear the indignation of the LORD, because I have sinned against him" (Mic 7:9). "It is because his compassions fail not, that we are not consumed" (Lam 3:22).
Sign 10. Proud men are fearless of temptations and confident in their strength and the goodness of their hearts. They dare to live among snares, in pomp and pleasure, feasting deliciously every day, among plays, gaming, and lascivious company and society, and fear no harm. Their pride makes them blind to their danger and of the tinder and gunpowder in their own natures, ready for every spark of temptation to catch fire in. The humble are always suspicious of themselves; they know their danger and avoid the snare. "A wise man feareth and departeth from evil: but the fool rageth, and is confident" (Prov 14:16). "A prudent man foreseeth the evil, and hideth himself: but the simple pass on, and are punished" (Prov 22:3).
Sign 11. Pride makes men murmur at the work of God, however well it is done, if they did not do it themselves; and sometimes, by contending for the honor of doing it, they destroy the work altogether. If they are officers of Christ, they look more at the power than at the obligation, more at the dignity than at the duty, and more at what the people owe to them than at what they owe to God and to the people. They are like dogs that snarl at any other dog that would share their place or enter their house. They do not say with Moses, "Would all the LORD‘s people were prophets." Indeed, the peace and unity of church and state are often sacrificed to this accursed pride.
Sign 12. Pride makes men ashamed of the service of God whenever the world disgraces it; and where pride holds dominion, they will deny or forsake Christ and holiness rather than forfeit their honor with men. If they come to Jesus at all, they come as Nicodemus did, by night. They are ashamed to own a reproached truth, a scorned cause, or a servant of Christ. If men will but mock them with the nicknames or slanders hatched in hell, they will do as others do and neglect their duty. A sneer will more effectively stop them from praying in their families before God than the lions’ den could stop Daniel, or the fiery furnace the three confessors.
This is especially true of those who hold honor and greatness in the world. God must be merciful to them while they bow down in the house of Rimmon. As the rich man, when he heard Christ’s terms, "was very sorrowful, for he was very rich" (Luke 18:23), so these, because their honors and dignities are so great, think them too precious to let go for the sake of Christ. If they had only as much as the obscure common person to lay down, they could forsake it, but they cannot forsake so fair a portion, nor endure the reproach of so honored a name.
Yet what contemptible things these are to a humble soul! He marvels at what dreaming worldlings find in the doting thoughts and idle breath of fools, which men call honor, that they should prefer it before the honor of God and their own real honor; when Christ has told them that "whosoever shall be ashamed of him and his words, in an adulterous and sinful generation, of him also shall the Son of man be ashamed, when he cometh in the glory of his Father with his holy angels" (Mark 8:38). I now turn to the signs of pride as shown in particular duties.
The Signs of Pride in and about Religious Duties
Sign 1. A proud person is most concerned with that part of duty which is visible to others and tends to raise his standing in their esteem. He therefore attends more to the outward form than to the inward heart, more to the words than to the spirit. If he is a preacher, he takes great pains to shape his sermon in whatever form best displays his abilities to the particular audience he wants to impress. If he lives where wit is valued above grace, or clever verbal play above solid, clear, judicious, and substantial discourse, he bends himself to the humor of his hearers and acts his part like a stage-player, for applause. If he lives where earnest, searching exhortations are more in demand, he labors to put an affected fervor into his style, enough to persuade hearers that he believes what he says, to seem what he is not, and to appear to feel what he does not feel.
All the while, however, he gives little attention to his own heart, and takes small pains to fill it with reverence for God, a right estimation of his truth, and genuine compassion for men’s souls, to truly believe and feel what he would merely seem to believe and feel. In prayer and conversation alike, his chief study is to speak in whatever way will best win applause; and he is rarely clever enough to hide this design from discerning people who know him. They can usually perceive that he is only the image of a preacher or a Christian, forcing himself by affectation into what he is not genuinely serious about. He is sounding brass, a tinkling cymbal, a bladder full of wind, a skin full of words, wise and devout in public on the stage, but at home and among his companions in ordinary life, he is at best common, if not unclean.
He is the wonder of fools and the pity of the wise. An oracle at first meeting to those who do not know him, and a cause for sorrow to those who have seen him at home and without his mask. He is like the proud gentlewoman who spends a great part of the morning grooming and adorning herself whenever she is to be seen in public, but at home is entirely plain. And because the proud are generally hypocrites, they are usually secret haters of the most earnest and discerning Christians, for such Christians are sharper-sighted than others in seeing through the cloak of their hypocrisy. The exception comes when those discerning Christians, out of charity, restrain themselves from expressing their fears and suspicions, which may reconcile the hypocrite to them.
Sign 2. Proud men readily take on any public duty that may magnify them or display their abilities, and think themselves more worthy of preference and employment than they actually are. They are eager to speak in preaching, praying, or ordinary conversation; a little knowledge makes them think themselves fit to be preachers. The humble, by contrast, say with Moses, "Who am I, that I should go unto Pharaoh? … I am not eloquent, but slow of speech. O, my Lord, send, I pray thee, by the hand of him whom thou wilt send" (Exod 3:11 Exod 4:10 Exod 4:13); or with Isaiah, "Wo is me, for I am undone, because I am a man of unclean lips" (Isa 6:5); or with Paul, "Who is sufficient for these things?" (2 Cor 2:16). How many a sermon has pride both studied and preached! How many a prayer has it formed! And how well are such prayers likely to be heard by God! As Hermolaus Barbarus said, a man who believes himself learned cannot help being unlearned.
As Augustine observes (On Catechizing the Uninstructed, ch. 9), those who appear to excel others in the art of speaking must be diligently urged, clothed in Christian humility, to learn not to despise those whose faults of character they recognize as greater than their faults of words.
Sign 3. The proud are unwilling to be overshadowed by the greater abilities of others. They are content for weaker men to pray or preach alongside them, men who will not eclipse them but rather set off their own parts, so that they may have the pre-eminence, as a dwarf makes another seem a well-built man. They are less troubled that God and the Gospel are dishonored by the infirmities, insufficiency, and faults of others than that their own glory is obscured by worthier men, even when God is honored and his work promoted. Against this temper Lord Bacon cites Pliny, in Essay 54: in commending another you do yourself right, for the man you commend is either your inferior or your superior; if he is your inferior and deserves commendation, then you deserve much more; if he is your superior and does not deserve it, then you deserve much less.
The humbled person, by contrast, wishes from the bottom of his heart that all the Lord’s people were prophets, that all men could preach, pray, discourse, and live far better than he does himself (though he would also wish to be as good as they). He is glad when he hears someone speak more judiciously, powerfully, and convincingly than he, rejoicing that God’s work is done, whoever does it, for he loves wisdom, holiness, truth, and duty not merely because they are his own, but for their own sake, for God, and for the souls of others.
A proud man envies both the gifts, the work, and the honor of others; he is like the devil, chafing at God’s gifts. The better and wiser any person is, the more he envies him. He is an enemy to the fruits of God’s goodness, as though he would have God be less good and generous to the world, or to anyone except himself and those who serve his party and interest and honor his gifts. His eye is evil because God is good. If others are better spoken of than himself, as more learned, able, wise, or holy, it kindles a secret hatred in his heart, unless they are people whose honor is also his honor or contributes to it.
The holy, humble soul, however, is sorry that he lacks what others have, yet glad that others have what he lacks. He loves God’s gifts wherever he sees them, yes, even in one who hates him. He would not have the world shut up in perpetual night merely because he may not be the sun; he would rather have others receive from another what he cannot give them, and is glad they have a sun, even if it is not he. Though some preached Christ out of envy, strife, and contention, and not sincerely, intending to add afflictions to Paul’s bonds, yet Paul rejoiced, and would rejoice, that Christ was preached (Phil 1:15–18).
Sign 4. When the proud man is praying or preaching, his eye is fixed mainly on the hearers; from them his work draws its energy, and from them he draws chiefly the fire and motives of his zeal. He is thinking primarily of how he appears to them, and all the while fishing for their love, approval, and applause; where he cannot have it, the fire of his zeal goes out. The humble person, though he does look to men in a subordinate way, and genuinely desires to do everything for their edification, does not seek to be loved by them so much as to exercise love upon them; nor does he seek honor and esteem from them so much as to convert and save them. It is God he chiefly regards and looks to; from God he draws his most powerful motives; and it is God’s approval he expects. His eye and heart rest on the hearers, yet rest more upon God. He would feed the sheep, but his deeper desire is to please the Lord who owns them.
Sign 5. A proud man, after performing his duty, is more concerned with how he was received by men, what they think or say of him, than with whether God and conscience give him their approval. He has his informants to tell him whether he is honored or dishonored. This is the return from prayer that he looks for; this is the fruit of preaching he seeks to reap. But these things count for little to a serious, humble soul: he has God to please, his work to do, and sets little store by human judgment.
Sign 6. A proud man is more troubled when he perceives he is undervalued and misses the honor he sought than when his preaching fails to benefit souls or his prayers fail to prevail for their spiritual good. Every man is most troubled by missing whatever is his true end. To do good and receive good is the end of the sincere, and he looks after this, rejoices when he obtains it, and grieves when he misses it.
To appear good, wise, and able is the proud man’s end: if the people honor him, it puffs him up with gladness as though he were a fortunate man; if they slight or despise him, he is cast down, or thrown into turbulent passion, and falls to hating or quarreling with those who deny him the honor he expects, as though they had done him a grievous wrong. He is like a physician who lacks both the skill and care to cure his patients, yet hates and rails at them because they prefer a more able doctor, and will not die to protect his honor or magnify his skill for killing their friends. The proud man’s honor is his life and his idol.
Clement of Alexandria (Stromata, bk. 1, ch. 4) says that for a faithful Christian who teaches, a single hearer is enough.
Sign 7. The proud man’s heart is not inclined toward humbling duties, penitent confessions, lamentations for sin, earnest prayer for grace and pardon, but toward formal observances and lip-service, or the Pharisee’s self-congratulation: "I thank thee that I am not as other men, nor as this Publican." This is not to say that the humblest have no great cause to bless God for spiritual mercies and his distinguishing grace; but the proud thank God for what they do not in fact have, for sanctification when they are unsanctified, for justification when they are unjustified, for the assured hope of glory when they are certain to be damned if they are not changed by renewing grace, and for being made heirs of heaven while they remain heirs of hell. For this reason the proud are the least afraid of coming to the sacrament of the body and blood of Christ without right or preparation. They rush in with bold presumption, while the humble soul trembles at the threshold, often more fearful to enter than it ought to be.
Sign 8. Proud persons are, of all others, the most impatient of church discipline, and the least capable of living under the government of Christ. If they sin, they can scarcely endure the gentlest admonition; but if reproved sharply and pointedly, that they may be sound in the faith, their impatience reveals how much it stings. If you proceed to more public reproof and admonition, calling them to an open confession of their sin before those they have wronged, or before the congregation, to ask forgiveness and earnestly seek the prayers of the church, you will then see the full power of pride against the ordinance and commands of God. How scornfully they spurn such reproof and exhortation! How obstinately they refuse to submit to duties that are beyond question! How reluctantly they are brought to confess even notorious sins, or even to acknowledge that it is their duty to confess them, though they would readily believe it is another person’s duty, and would readily urge another to do what they themselves refuse.
The remedy Christ has prescribed seems so loathsome to them that they hate the person who brings it, and will die and be damned before they will take it, and will perhaps turn on that person and tear him apart in every way they can, unless restrained by civil authority. But if you proceed to exclude them from visible communion with the church for their obstinate impenitence in heinous sin, you will see yet more plainly how contrary pride is to the church order and government ordained by Christ. How bitterly they hate those who subject them to such necessary disgrace! How they storm and rage, and turn their fury against the church, as though Christ’s remedy were the greatest injury in the world! Their character may be read in the second Psalm. Therefore Christ calls men to come as "little children" into his school (Matt 18:3), for otherwise they will be unteachable and incorrigible.
Sign 9. A proud man has a heretical disposition even while crying out against heretics. He tends to focus most on matters of dispute and contention in religion, obscure prophecies, God’s decrees, controversies that trouble the church more than edify it, circumstances, ceremonies, forms, externals, orders, and words. And in his opinions on these matters he must be somebody.
Sign 10. A proud man is unsatisfied with his standing in communion with the church of Christ, and is either ambitiously striving for dominion over it or inclined toward separation from it. Such men think themselves too good to stand on equal ground with their brethren: if they may be teachers or rulers, they can approve the church’s constitution; but otherwise it is too low for them to have communion with. They must belong to some more refined or elevated society. It is not enough for them to come out and be separate from the infidel and idolatrous world; they must also come out and be separate from the churches of Christ, which consist of people who make a credible profession of faith and godliness.
They think it insufficient merely to avoid sin themselves, to have no fellowship with the works of darkness but rebuke them, or to separate from people only as those people separate from Christ. Instead, they will separate from their brethren even in their duty, odiously exaggerate every imperfection, fill the church with clamor and contention, and shatter it into factions through schism, not for any true reformation or for building up the body (for how can division build it up?), but to show the world that they consider themselves more holy than the church.
In just this way, Christ himself was quarreled with as unholy by the Pharisees for eating with publicans and sinners, and his disciples for not washing before meals, for failing to observe the traditions of the elders, and for rubbing out grain to eat on the Sabbath. Those who will not be strict in their conformity to Christ will be excessively righteous, stricter than Christ would have them be, wherever pride commands it. They will join the stricter party and adopt stricter opinions, and form opinions and parties that are stricter than God’s commands, running into errors and schisms so that they may stand apart from the general communion of the church, and belong to a group smaller than Christ’s own little flock.
Signs of Pride in Everyday Dealings
Sign 1. Pride causes subjects to be too quick in censuring the actions of their governors, too impatient of what they suffer under them, and prone to murmur and rebel. It makes those in inferior positions think themselves competent judges of commands and actions whose reasons they have never heard and are not equipped to assess, unless they sat on the council themselves.
It makes them forget all the benefits of government and attend only to its burdens and hardships, saying as Korah said: "Ye take too much upon you, seeing all the congregation are holy every one of them, and the Lord is among them: wherefore then lift ye up yourselves above the congregation of the Lord? Is it a small thing that thou hast brought us up out of a land that floweth with milk and honey, to kill us in the wilderness, except thou make thyself altogether a prince over us? Wilt thou put out the eyes of these men?" (Num 16:3 and 16:13–14) Proud men are impatient, magnify their grievances, and are convinced that reason and justice are on their side.
Sign 2. A proud man is more disposed to command than to obey, and cannot serve God contentedly in a humble and lowly station. He is never a good subject, servant, or child, for subordination feels like slavery to him. He thinks it a disgrace to be governed by another. He has a reason of his own that continually contradicts the reason of his rulers, and a will of his own that must be satisfied and cannot bend to authority. He is always ready to step out of his rank and court suffering through disorder, so that he may taste the sweetness of present liberty, much as a horse or cattle might break loose to be free, only to starve in winter when snow has stripped away the grass.
The humble, by contrast, know that it is far easier to obey than to govern; that the valleys are the most fertile ground; that it is the cedars and the mountain trees that are blown down, not the shrubs; that a low condition affords not only more safety, but more leisure and quiet for communion with God; and that it is a mercy when others may be employed in keeping the walls and watching the house, while he may follow his own work in quietness and peace. He therefore willingly renders honor and tribute to those to whom they are due.
Sign 3. If a proud man is a ruler, he is prone to be lifted up in mind and to despise his inferiors, as though they were less than men or he were more than one. He is prone to disdain the counsel of the wise, to scorn admonition from the ministers of Christ, to hate every Micaiah who does not prophesy good concerning him, to value none but flatterers, to discourage faithful dealings, and to refuse to hear of his own faults. He is prone to fall out with the power of godliness and the Gospel of Christ, viewing them as crossing his interests, and to forget his own subjection to God and the danger his subjects face. He is more eager to be obeyed by his inferiors than himself to obey his absolute Lord. He expects his own commands to be obeyed even when God commands the contrary, and is more offended by neglect of his own laws and honor than by contempt for the honor and laws of God.
Sign 4. Whenever any position of office, honor, or advancement becomes vacant, a proud man assumes he is the best qualified for it. If he seeks it and another is preferred as more deserving, he counts it an injury. Even if those who passed him over and chose another did so with the greatest judgment, impartiality, and regard for the common good, without any regard for personal connections or self-interest, this will not satisfy the proud man, who knows no principle but selfishness. He will bear a grudge against men for the most righteous and necessary act. How many ignorant and impious men have we known who were displeased at not being thought worthy to teach in the church, or because a people who knew the worth of their souls had the wisdom and conscience to prefer a worthier candidate? How many worthless men in corporations and elsewhere have been offended at not being chosen to govern! So unreasonable a thing is pride.
Sign 5. A proud man, looking at the work of his superiors, thinks he could do it better himself if he had the opportunity. Not one in a hundred but thinks he could rule better than the king, judge better than the judge, and perhaps preach better than the preacher, unless his ignorance is so obvious that he cannot quite maintain the conviction. Absalom was certain he would do the people better justice than his father David, if only he were king. If all the affairs of church and commonwealth were in his hands, he is fully confident they would be well ordered, every fault corrected, and what a happy world it should be!
Sign 6. A proud man tends to overvalue his own knowledge and to be largely unacquainted with his own ignorance. He is far more aware of what he knows than of how much he lacks that he ought to know. He thinks himself qualified to contradict the ablest divine when he has scarcely knowledge enough to save his own soul (1 Tim 3:6 1 Tim 6:4). If he has acquired enough of a smattering to talk confidently about matters he does not understand, he thinks himself best suited for the teacher’s chair. This fills him with a combative confidence; he believes himself able to dispute with any man, and invariably awards himself the victory.
If it is a woman who has gathered a few recipes, she thinks herself fit to practice medicine and ventures the lives of her dearest friends on her ignorant skill, when seven more years of study would be needed merely to show such beginners how little they know and how much is utterly unknown to them, and seven years beyond that to give them an encouraging taste of real knowledge. Yet pride, by its own authority, makes them doctors in divinity and medicine without all that labor; and as they obtained their credentials, so they practice, in the dark. To spare themselves the trouble of such long study, they can calmly spare, and gravely deride, the very knowledge they cannot obtain on cheaper terms.
No wonder, when it is the nature of pride and ignorance to give birth to and increase each other. It would be remarkable to find an ignorant person who is humble, someone who does not know how great an abundance of excellent truths still lies unknown to them, nor what difficulties lie in every controversy they have never examined. Many studious, learned, and holy divines would travel many thousands of miles, if that would serve, to be thoroughly resolved on many doubts in the mysteries of providence, the decrees, redemption, grace, free will, and others like these, and this after twenty or forty years of study. Yet one can find a boy or a woman in the street who can confidently settle them all in a few words, pity the ignorance or error of such divines, shake their heads at their blindness, and say, "God has revealed these things to babes!"
Perhaps their confidence goes further and takes those who dissent from them for such heretical, erroneous, intolerable persons that they look on them as heathens and publicans, and either, with the Papists, reproach and persecute them, or, with the lesser sects, divide from them as from men who do not receive the truth. So pride makes as many churches as there are different opinions. Lord Bacon observed that a cunning flatterer always follows the arch-flatterer, which is a man’s own self, and upholds him most in whatever he already thinks best of in himself; while an impudent flatterer will credit him by main force with the very thing he knows himself to be most defective in.
Sign 7. Pride makes people remarkably partial in judging their own virtues and vices compared to other people’s. The humble are busy complaining of their weaknesses and sinfulness, and have great difficulty believing they are anything at all, or discerning the sincerity of their own grace; they think their prayers are hardly prayers, and their duties so poor that God will not regard them. The proud, by contrast, think well of everything they do and are little troubled by their greater failings. They easily spot another person’s faults, but justify in themselves the very same or worse. Their own outbursts of temper, their own overreaching and unjust dealings, their own ill words are smoothed over as harmless trifles, while the same things in others are magnified into intolerable crimes. A man may be judged by them unfit for human society for less than what they themselves cannot bear to be reproved for, and will hardly be convinced that it is any fault at all. So blind is pride about itself.
Sign 8. Pride makes people hear their teachers as judges when they ought to hear them as learners and disciples of Christ. They come not to be taught what they do not know, but to pass judgment on what they hear, and they do so as confidently as if their teachers needed only their correction to teach rightly. I grant that no poison is to be received into the soul on the authority of any man, and that we must "prove all things, and hold fast that which is good." Yet even this must be learned; and the pastor’s office is appointed by Christ as necessary to your good. Scholars who are forever quarreling with their teachers, readier to instruct their masters than to learn from them, boldly contradicting what they have never understood, are too proud to become wise. Humility and reason together teach people to learn with a sense of their ignorance and their need of a teacher.
Sign 9. A proud man is always hard to please, because his expectations of others are too high. He looks for so much deference and respect, and to be humored and honored by everyone, that it is nearly impossible for anyone who has much to do with him, and who has any other work to attend to, to satisfy him. Whoever would please him must either have little to do with him and come seldom in his way, or else must master the art of man-pleasing, compliment, and flattery, study it until he could take a degree in it, and make it his trade and occupation as nurses tend the sick or quiet children. Some look, word, or action will daily fall wrong, and some gesture of respect or courtesy will always be found wanting.
Just as godly, humble men rightly reckon their own sins the heavier for the greatness and excellency of the God they have offended, so the proud man foolishly magnifies every small injury done to him, every word spoken against him, and every supposed neglect or slight, by the high estimation he holds of himself as the person against whom it was committed.
Sign 10. The proud are eager for precedence among others: to be greeted first, to be taken into the favor of great persons, and to be placed in the seat of honor, at table, at church, and everywhere else, and to take the better side. He resents those set above him and preferred before him, unless they are very greatly his superiors. And if he has wit enough to avoid the disgrace of openly contending for such trifles and exposing the childishness of his pride, he still retains the displeasure in his heart. The humble, meanwhile, readily yield precedence to others and take the lower place.
Sign 11. A proud man expects that all the good he does will be remembered, and that others will keep a register of his good works, taking notice of his learning, worth, and virtues. Just as his own memory is strongest in this area above all others, he expects other people’s to be the same. It is as though, being inwardly aware of how unfit he is for God’s esteem, he counts as lost whatever men do not observe and applaud. As his own eye is fixed upon himself, he expects the eyes of others to be fixed there too, eager to admire his good qualities and blind to his weaknesses and faults.
Hesychius Illustris tells the contrary story of Arcesilaus. In sharing what he had and in doing kindnesses he was readier and easier than can well be said, and utterly averse to catching any little glory from a benefit, which he would rather have kept hidden. Visiting Ctesibius in his sickness and seeing that he was in want, he secretly slipped a purse of money under his pillow; and when Ctesibius found it, he said, "This is one of Arcesilaus’s tricks."
Sign 12. No one stands higher in a proud man’s estimation than those who admire him. Whatever else they may be, he loves best those who esteem him most highly; he can make light of their faults and forgive them readily. Let them be drunkards, whoremongers, swearers, or otherwise ungodly, the proud man loves them in proportion to the honor they show him. If you would have his favor, let him hear that you have praised him behind his back and ranked him above all other men.
But if the holiest servant of God thinks modestly of him and speaks of him only as he is, especially if he suspects they slight him or work against his interest and reputation, no wisdom or holiness of theirs will reconcile him to them, were they as wise and good as Peter or Paul. It means nothing to him that they honor God, if he thinks they do not honor him. He will not acknowledge their goodness at all, but will take everything for hypocrisy if it does not serve his interest or honor. The reason is simply that he is an idol to himself.
Sign 13. A proud man is prone to domineer with insolence whenever he gains an advantage and finds himself on higher ground. He speaks like Pilate to those in his power: "Knowest thou not that I have power to crucify thee, and power to release thee?", forgetting that they "have no power at all against any, but what is given them from above." Victories and successes lift up fools, making them look great and forget themselves, as though their shadows were longer than before. Servants raised up on horseback will speak disdainfully of princes on foot. David says, "The proud have had me in derision."
When proud men obtain positions of power, they cannot carry it quietly but are puffed up and intoxicated, as if they were not the same men they were before. They treat their inferiors worse, if those inferiors do not humor them, than Balaam treated his donkey; and when they have made their inferiors speak, their insolence cannot bear it. The humble man, by contrast, remembers how fully he stands equal with the lowest, and deals gently even with his own servants, "remembering that he also hath a master in heaven" (Eph 6:9).
Sign 14. A proud man is impatient of contradiction. Right or wrong, you must agree with him or at least not oppose him. This is why men of pride think a man’s life is barely a sufficient price for the wrong done when another presumes to call them liars. I grant that children, servants, and other subordinates should not be irreverent or presumptuous in unnecessarily contradicting their superiors, but should give place in silence when they cannot assent to what is said. Yet impatience even of sober and reasonable contradiction, even from a subordinate or a servant, is no mark of a humble mind.
Sign 15. Wherever a proud man lives, he is turbulent and impatient unless he has his own way. If he holds public office, he will set a whole kingdom on fire if things do not go as he wishes. Among the sins that mark the last and perilous times, Paul numbers these: being "Lovers of their own selves, boasters, proud, traitors, heady, highminded" (2 Tim 3:2–4). If such men have a hand in church affairs, they must have their will and their way, or they will cast everything into confusion, hinder the Gospel, and turn the churches upside down. In towns and corporations they are headstrong and turbulent until they get what they want. In families there will be no peace unless everything goes their way. They cannot yield to another’s judgment.
Sign 16. Proud men are passionate and quarrelsome; they cannot endure injuries or harsh words. A humble man, by contrast, "giveth place to wrath" and "avengeth not himself," nor "resisteth evil," but is meek and patient, "forbearing and forgiving," and so heaps coals of fire on his enemy’s head. "Only by pride cometh contention" (Prov 13:10). "He that is of a proud heart stirreth up strife" (Prov 28:25). What is their rage, their scorn, their railing, and their efforts to vilify those who have offended them, but the foam and overflow of their pride? "Proud, haughty scorner is his name, that dealeth in proud wrath" (Prov 21:24).
Sign 17. A proud man is either an open or a secret boaster. If he is too ashamed to display his pride by open boasting, he learns the skill of presenting himself and making his excellencies known in a subtler and more polished way. His own praise will not appear to be the purpose of his speech; it will seem to come in incidentally, as though he had thought of something else, or as though it were necessary for some other end and something he was unavoidably drawn into against his will. Or he will appear to be concealing it, but only behind a transparent veil, as a proud woman hides her beauty. Or he will mention some of his faults alongside his virtues, yet only such faults as he regards as no disgrace, like the beauty spots a proud woman wears to make her better features stand out more.
But one way or another, whether by open display or subtle suggestion, his work is to make known everything that reflects well on him, ensuring that his goodness, wisdom, and greatness are neither unknown nor overlooked, because he must have the approval of others, which is the hypocrite’s reward. To be unknown is to him like being buried.
"Proud" and "boasters" are joined together (Rom 1:30 2 Tim 3:2). Theudas the deceiver "boasted himself to be somebody" (Acts 5:36). "Simon Magus gave out that himself was some great one, and the people all gave heed to him from the least to the greatest, saying, This man is the great power of God" (Acts 8:9–10). "Such love the praise of men more than the praise of God" (John 12:43).
The humble person, by contrast, has learned a different language, not affected, but from the felt conviction of the heart, to cry out: "I am vile; I am unworthy to be called a child; my sins are more than the hairs of my head." He hates the vanity of those who, by untimely or excessive praise, try to stir him up to pride and so make him truly base by proclaiming him excellent. Far more does he abhor praising himself, having learned: "Let another man praise thee and not thine own mouth; a stranger, and not thine own lips" (Prov 27:2). He praises himself by works, not by words (Prov 31:31).
Sign 18. A proud man loves honorable names and titles, as the Pharisees loved to be called "Rabbi." And yet he may have enough cleverness to pretend that he values such titles only to promote his service for the common good, and not because he is so weak as to care for empty names, or else that they were pressed on him by someone else’s kindness, without his seeking them and against his will.
Sign 19. Pride tickles the hearts of fools with pleasure and satisfaction when they hear themselves applauded, see themselves admired by the people, learn that they have gained a great reputation in the world, or find themselves surrounded by followers who cry up their name. Herod loved to hear in response to his oration, "It is the voice of a god and not of a man" (Acts 12:22). It is a feast to the proud man to hear that people abroad speak highly of him, or to see that those around him reverence, love, and idolize him.
This is how the church has been filled with busy sect-masters, even among those who seemed most forward in religion, a development Paul sadly foretold to the Ephesians. Pride has in every age thrust two kinds of troublemakers upon the church under the name of pastors: devouring wolves and dividing sect-masters. "For I know this, that after my departure, shall grievous wolves enter in among you, not sparing the flock. Also of your ownselves shall men arise, speaking perverse things, to draw away disciples after them" (Acts 20:29–30). See also (Rom 16:16–17).
Sign 20. Pride makes men censorious and uncharitable. They diminish other men’s virtues and good works, and suspect their sincerity without grounds. Very little is needed for them to think or call a man a hypocrite. In their eyes, very few people, even those who genuinely are, are honest, sincere, godly, humble, faithful, capable, or worthy. A slight rumor or conjecture seems sufficient to condemn or defame another. They are quick to see the speck in a brother’s eye.
Their pride and imagination can conjure a thousand heretics, schismatics, hypocrites, and ungodly persons who never were any such thing except in the court of their presumption. Especially when they count someone an adversary, they can cast that person in the most odious shape and make him into whatever the devil desires. The humble, by contrast, are charitable toward others, being conscious of much weakness in themselves, which makes them need the tenderness of others. They judge the best until they know the worst, and they would rather err on the side of charity than of censure. They do not pass judgment on others until they have both evidence to prove the fault and a clear reason to involve themselves in it, having learned (Matt 7:1–4): "Judge not that ye be not judged."
Sign 21. Pride causes men to hate reproof. The proud are quick to find faults in others, but they do not welcome a plain reprover of themselves. Though reproof is a duty God himself commands (Lev 19:17), as an expression of love and the opposite of hatred, it will turn a proud man into your enemy. "A scorner loveth not one that reproveth him; neither will he go unto the wise" (Prov 15:12). "He that reproveth a scorner, getteth himself shame; and he that rebuketh a wicked man, getteth himself a blot. Reprove not a scorner, lest he hate thee: rebuke a wise man, and he will love thee" (Prov 9:7–8).
Reproof galls the proud man’s heart; he takes it as an injury and bears a grudge against the reprover as if he were an enemy. If he respected or honored you before, you have lost him or angered him the moment you have pointed out his faults. If he enjoys hearing a preacher deal plainly with others, he will hate that same preacher when the plain dealing is turned on him. Herod imprisoned John for telling him of his sin, and eventually gave away his head, though before that he had reverenced John and heard him gladly. The proud can easily endure being evil and doing evil; what they cannot endure is hearing of it. It is as if a man with leprosy loved the disease itself and yet hated the person who told him he had it or offered to cure him.
This pride is what has made people so unprofitable to one another, having driven faithful reproof and admonition almost out of the world, because proud people will not bear it. This is why others more often hear of a man’s faults than the man hears of them himself, and why backbiting has become so common, proud sinners drive away reprovers by their impatience and resentment. Husbands and wives, and even servants with their masters, are so out of patience with just reproof that they can barely endure it. Only a person extraordinarily skilled at smoothing every word and making a rebuke sound more like a compliment or flattery than a correction will escape their indignation.
Sign 22. When a proud man is justly rebuked, he immediately sets about denying or minimizing his fault, showing you that he cares more for his reputation than for his honesty. It is a hard thing to bring him to full and frank confession, to thank you for your care and faithfulness, and to resolve on greater watchfulness going forward. The humble soul, by contrast, is readier to believe that he is in the wrong than that he is innocent, and will say more against himself than you would say, if you are truthful.
This one sign alone can tell you how widely pride reigns in the world. How few are they, among the many who receive a just and necessary reproof, who are genuinely thankful for it? Notice what the first word they speak in response to you tends to be: either a denial, or an excuse, or a counter-charge of something they think you are guilty of, or a passionate and proud dismissal, telling you to mind your own business.
Sign 23. Pride makes people talkative, more eager to speak than to hear, and more eager to teach than to be taught, because such people think highly of their own understanding and suppose that others need their instruction more than they need anyone else’s. Humility is no enemy to charitable communication or to zealous effort for the conversion and edification of souls. But a teaching and talking disposition where there is no need, beyond the measure of one’s calling and abilities, when one has more need to learn oneself, that is the fruit of pride.
It shows itself when you pay less attention to what another says to you than you expect him to pay to what you say to him; when your speech is not so much by way of inquiry, as befits a learner, but in the pronouncements and dictates of a teacher; when you are so full of your own thoughts and so dismissive of what others say that you cannot patiently wait in silence until they finish, but rudely interrupt them and cut in yourself, which amounts to saying, "Hold your tongue and let me speak, for I am wiser and worthier"; when you strive to have the most words and to be always speaking, as horses in a race strive to run first.
This is pride puffing you up and moving your tongue as a leaf is shaken by the wind. It fills your sails and makes you like bagpipes, loudest when full of wind and pressed. "A fool is full of words" (Eccl 10:14). "In the multitude of words there wanteth not sin: but he that refraineth his lips is wise" (Prov 10:19).
Among the marks of humility noted by Benedict in his Rule is this: to speak few words, even reasonable ones, and not with a loud voice; to maintain silence until questioned. These things must always be understood, however, consistently with love of truth and care for souls.
Sign 24. Pride makes people excessively reluctant to be indebted to others, so that some will starve or perish before they will stoop to ask for help or be obliged to show gratitude, especially toward those with whom they have any quarrel. They mistake this for manly gallantry, a noble refusal to be base. I grant that, as Paul says to servants, if we can be free, we should prefer it; and that no one should unnecessarily make himself another’s debtor. Ministers in particular should avoid every temptation toward dependence on men: they should neither attach themselves to the powerful, lest they be tempted to unfaithful silence or flattery, nor needlessly live on the charity of their congregations, lest their ministry be hindered.
So Paul worked with his own hands wherever he judged that being a financial burden to the churches would obstruct his work or give his adversaries occasion to reproach him, and he would "rather die than any should make this his glorying void" (1 Cor 9:15). Innocence and independence, as Mr. Bolton used to say, steel a minister’s face and help him be bold and faithful. As Camerarius replied when invited to court: "Let no man be another’s, who can be his own."
Yet man is a social creature, made to be helpful to one another. We are like the wheels of a watch: none can do its work alone without the cooperation of the rest. A proud man who would live wholly on himself and scorns all obligation would break himself off from the place God has set him in, separate from human society, and make himself either a world to himself or a god over others. God has purposely caused all the members to need one another, so that none might be despised, and so that all might continually exercise love in giving and humility in receiving one another’s help.
Sign 25. Pride makes people desperately eager to equal their superiors and surpass their equals in clothing, fine dwellings, provisions, entertainments, and every outward appearance that might make them seem significant in the world, for pride is excessively concerned with the eye of man. A fitting regard for decency is proper, so long as we do not attach to it more weight than it deserves. But pride always strives to keep up with the highest, craves more refinement than is necessary, and makes a far greater matter of decency than the thing warrants.
The old Gloss on Matthew makes humility threefold: necessary, to submit to a greater and not prefer oneself to an equal; abundant, to submit to an equal and not prefer oneself to a lesser; perfect, to submit to a lesser. Anselm counts seven degrees of it: in opinion, to know oneself contemptible and not to grieve at it; in showing it, to confess this, to persuade others of it, and to bear patiently having it said; in the will, to endure being treated contemptibly and to love that very thing.
I do not share the temperament of those who censure every man whose hair is not their cut, whose clothes are not their fashion, or who has been raised in a manner of greater gentility and ceremony than themselves. Yet the eagerness to imitate fashion-followers, the ambition to carry oneself above one’s rank, the preference for the company of superiors over inferiors, and the desire to live like those a step above us rather than those a step below, these are signs of pride as legible as the robes of a judge or doctor are signs of their office and degree. Humility has learned this lesson: "Mind not high things; but condescend to men of low estate: be not wise in your own eyes" (Rom 12:16).
As for the ridiculous, effeminate fashions and mannerisms of some men, and the spots and paintings, and nakedness, and other outlandish fashions of some women, and the many hours wasted daily in dressing and adorning themselves for the sight of others, these are the marks of so foolish, and more than childish, a species of pride that I will not trouble myself or the reader to reprove them at length. Manly pride is itself ashamed of such vanities. Let those who defend these practices satisfy their admirers by proving them lawful, when they have no wiser work to do.
And when they have done that, let them go on to prove that it is lawful for a sober person to wear the irons they put on men in Bedlam, and that the chains worn in Newgate are no sign of a prisoner, and that it is lawful for an honest woman to wear a harlot’s dress. If the proud have no more judgment than to wear the badges of their childishness or disorder, and display their shame to all they meet, and make themselves as ridiculous as men who lay aside their breeches to wear side-coats again like children, I will leave them to themselves without any further contradiction here.
Sign 26. Proud persons feel ashamed and distressed if any necessity forces them to appear in clothing, provisions, or manner below what others of their station display, which reveals that they regard decency not as a duty but as an ornament of their pride. Otherwise they would be at peace when Providence makes such outward display no longer their obligation. They are less ashamed of sin and the neglect of God and their own salvation than they are to be seen in plain or worn attire. Even beggars and servants show here that they can be as proud as lords.
A great many of them seldom go to church, and give as their reason: "I had no suitable clothes," as if they would neglect their souls, their God, and their greatest duty rather than come in the clothes they wear for common work. Does Christ appoint you a meeting, where through his ministers he may instruct you for salvation and you may ask and receive pardon for your sins, and will you disappoint him and refuse to come for want of finer clothes? Surely you do not imagine these are the wedding garments he requires you to bring? You would beg if you were naked or in rags; and will you not come to beg of God because you have no better clothes? Do you value your reputation in clothing above the means of your salvation?
How little such wretches value God and his mercy now, they who will shortly on their deathbeds cry for mercy without any such concern for clothing. Naked they come into the world, and naked they must go out; yet they will turn their backs on the worship of God for want of clothes. They are not ashamed or afraid to be ungodly and forsake their duty, but they are ashamed of torn or poor attire. "What," they say, "shall we make ourselves ridiculous?", when their pride and ungodliness are the cause of a thousandfold more shame. We read of thousands, even among the poor, who crowded after Christ to hear him; but of none who stayed at home for want of clothes, when in all likelihood they had no better than yours.
Sign 27. When a proud man has been wronged, he demands great submission before he will forgive: you must lie down at his feet, make a very full confession, and behave with great humility, especially if the law is in his hands. He is prone to revenge and cruel in it. But if he has wronged others, he can hardly be brought to confess it, and even less to humble himself for reconciliation and ask their forgiveness. A humble person, by contrast, is ready to yield his rights for peace, forgives easily, and stoops easily to ask forgiveness.
Sign 28. Lastly, pride makes men desire inordinately to have an honorable memorial of their names preserved after death, at least among those who rise to any hope of such remembrance. Pride has erected many a monument; written many a book to that end; performed many works that were materially good, yet made bad by so base an intention. It has built hospitals, almshouses, and schoolhouses, and given many a pound to charitable uses in pretension, but to proud and selfish uses in intention.
This is not to say that anyone should needlessly suspect another’s motives, or tarnish the deserved honor of good works, which it is ordinarily lawful to regard. But we should suspect our own hearts and guard against so horrible a sin, which would turn the most excellent gifts and works into poison or corruption. Consider how serious it is for a man to be laying proud designs when he is turning to dust and about to appear before his Judge, indeed, to set up monuments to his pride over his rotting flesh and bones, and to show by that effort that he died in so great a sin without repentance, seeking to keep as much of it alive as possible after he is dead and gone.
When such wicked ends threaten to intrude into necessary and excellent works, an honest heart must abhor and cast them out, beg forgiveness, and yet not on that account forsake the work itself, nor refuse the comfort of more sincere desires and intentions. But those good works that are principally done as a service to pride, to leave a name on earth, sink the hypocrite into hell. When Anaxagoras saw the tomb of Mausolus, he said, according to Laertius, "A costly monument, and stones that are the image of wealth turned to rubble" (Laertius, Lives, Book 2, section 10).
I have spent considerable time showing you the signs of pride, because the discovery is a great part of the cure. Not every proud person displays all these signs, since not everyone faces the same temptations or occasions to reveal them; but everyone shows some, and many show most. And whoever has any one of them has a sign of pride.
I say again: for all this, our reputation, insofar as it serves the honor of God, our religion, and our neighbors’ good, must be carefully preserved by every just means, and by necessary defenses vindicated against those who slander us, even while we quietly bear whatever infamy or slander God sees fit to try us with.
Direction 3. Having understood the nature and the signs or effects of pride, consider next the dreadful consequences and tendency of it, both as it leads to further sin and to misery. I shall briefly open this in some particulars.
1. In the present moment, pride is the heart of the old man, the root and life of all corruption, and of dreadful significance if it is predominant. If any man’s "heart be lifted up, the LORD will have no pleasure in him, or it is not upright in him" (Hab 2:4). I would rather have my soul in the condition of an obscure humble Christian, noticed by few or none but God, and content to approve himself to God alone, than in the condition of the highest and most eminent person in church or state who lives for the observation and praise of men.
Æneas Sylvius, writing of the boasting of the monk Capistrinus, observed: he had overcome the pomps of the world, trampled avarice, subdued lust, but he could not despise glory. No one is so holy that he is not captured by the sweetness of glory. Eminent men find it easier to despise kingdoms than glory. Among all vices, pride is always first and always last: for every sin is committed when it draws near, and is let go when it withdraws (Innocent, On the Contempt of the World, Book 2, ch. 31).
God does not judge men by their great abilities, their profession, or their name. He justifies the humbled soul who is ashamed to lift his face to heaven, who thinks himself unworthy to speak to God or to have communion with his church or to come among his servants, but who stands far off, strikes his breast, and says in true repentance: "God be merciful to me, a sinner" (Luke 18:13). Pride is like a plague-mark on the soul.
2. There is scarcely a sin imaginable that is not spawned in the bowels of pride. To instance some few, beyond all those expressed in the signs above:
1.) It makes men hypocrites, causing them to appear what they are not, for the praise of men.
2.) It makes men liars. Most of the lies told in the world are told to avoid some disgrace or shame, or to make others think highly of them. When a sin has been committed against God or against superiors, instead of humble confession, pride covers it with a lie.
3.) It causes covetousness, so that men may have provision for their pride.
4.) It makes men flatterers, timeservers, and man-pleasers, so that they may win the good esteem of others.
5.) It drives men into profaneness and riot, to do as others do and avoid the shame of being reproached and scorned as singular and precise.
6.) It can draw men away from any duty to God that their company opposes. They dare not pray, or speak a serious word about God, for fear of a sneer from a scorner’s mouth.
7.) It is so contentious a sin that it makes men firebrands in every society where they live. There is no quiet living with such men longer than they can have their own say, will, and way. They must hold sway and must not be crossed. And when all is said, there is no pleasing them: the missing of a word, a look, or a compliment will catch on their hearts like a spark on gunpowder.
8.) It tears church and state apart. Where was there ever a civil war raised, or a kingdom endangered or ruined, or a church divided, oppressed, or persecuted, without pride as the great and evident cause?
9.) It devours the mercies and good creatures of God and sacrifices them to the devil. It is a costly sin. Consider how much it consumes in clothes, buildings, attendance, entertainments, and unnecessary things.
10.) It is an odious thief and squanderer of precious time. How many hours that should be better employed, and must one day be accounted for, are thrown away upon the works of pride just described? This is especially true of the needless compliments and visits of gallants, and the dressings of some vain and lightheaded women, who spend almost half the day in such preparations and can scarcely find an hour in the morning for prayer, meditation, or reading the Scriptures, because they cannot be ready in time. They forget all the while how they disgrace their wretched bodies by advertising that they are so unkempt and misshapen that they cannot be made sweet, clean, and seemly without so much labor and fuss.
11.) It is odiously unjust. A proud man makes nothing of falsehood, slander, deceit, or cruelty, if such things seem necessary to his greatness, honor, advancement, or ambitious ends. He does not care whom he wrongs or betrays, so long as he rises to his desired height or keeps his greatness. Never trust a proud man beyond what his own interest bids you trust him.
12.) Pride is the pander of whoredom and uncleanness. It is an incentive to lust in themselves, and it draws proud persons to adorn and present themselves in the most enticing manner, as tends to provoke the lust of others. They eagerly wish to be thought attractive, so that others may admire them and be taken with their appearance. If they thought no one would see them, they would spare their ornaments. And if plain decency were all they sought, they would spare their fashionable superfluities and curiosities. Even those who would not commit open fornication with anyone still wish to be thought beautiful and desirable, and do what tends to corrupt the minds of foolish onlookers. These, and indeed almost all sins, are the natural offspring of pride.
3. As for the misery that pride brings on themselves and others:
1.) The greatest misery is that proud people forsake God and are in danger of being forsaken by him, for God abhors the proud and regards them as from a distance. So far as you are proud, you are hated by him and have no acceptance or communion with him. Pride is the highway to utter apostasy. It blinds the mind, makes people confident in their own conceits, ready to venture on any new opinion, and ready to quarrel with the word of God before they understand it. When anything seems hard to them, they immediately suspect the truth of the matter, when they ought to suspect their own dark and ill-furnished minds.
Take note of the proud people in any town or congregation; when any infection of heresy or infidelity enters that place, these are the ones who will catch it soonest. Look at those who have turned from truth or godliness, and see whether they were not proud and superficial in religion beforehand. But God gives grace, and more grace, to the humble; he dwells with them and delights in them.
2.) A proud man is a tormentor of himself. He sets his mind on the opinions of others, desiring more of their esteem than he can attain, and finding that esteem unsatisfying vanity even when he has obtained it. He lives under fruitless and vexing desires, suffering frequent disappointments. Nearly everything he sees, almost every word he hears, and every compliment omitted can disturb his peace, break his sleep, and throw him into a fever of passion or thoughts of revenge. The wind that swells him runs up and down and disquiets him in every part. Who would want such a fire in his breast, one that will not let him be at rest?
Vainglorious men are the scorn of the wise, the wonder of fools, the idols of flatterers, and the slaves of their own pride. Lord Bacon, Essay 54.
3.) Pride brings sufferings, and then makes them seem intolerable. It makes the sinner torment his mind by struggling against his afflictions and impatiently magnifying them far more than the suffering itself would ever do.
4. Pride is a deep-rooted and self-preserving sin, and therefore harder to kill and root out than other sins. It hinders the discovery of itself. It drives away the light. It hates reproof. It will not allow the sinner to see his own pride when it is pointed out to him, nor to confess it if he does see it, nor to be humbled for it if he does confess it, nor to loathe himself and forsake it, even though conviction and terror may seem to humble him. Even while he hears all the signs of pride described, he will not recognize them in himself. When he feels his hatred of reproof and knows that this is a sign of pride in others, yet he will not acknowledge it in himself.
If you try to cure him of this or any other fault, you will find you are handling a wasp or an adder; yet even while he spits the venom of pride against his reprover, he does not perceive that he is proud. That venom is his very nature, and so he neither feels it nor finds it troublesome.
Even if the whole town or congregation were to mark him as notoriously proud, he himself, who should know himself best, will not see it. It is a wonder to observe how this sin retains its strength in people who have long labored for their souls and who appear in every other respect to be the most serious and mortified Christians. Yet let them be touched in their interests or reputation, or feel slighted, or see another preferred over them while they are passed by, and they boil with envy, malice, or discontent, showing that the heart of sin, which is selfishness and pride, is still alive, unbroken, and too strong. This is especially so where a person’s natural temperament is not gentle and mild but more passionate; then pride has more oil and fuel to kindle it into these visible flames. The person who has truly conquered pride is a Christian indeed.
5. Pride is the defense not only of itself but of every other sin in the heart and life. It hates reproof and keeps away the remedy; it hides sin, minimizes it, excuses it, and thinks well of what ought to be hated.
6. Pride hinders every means and duty from doing you good, and often corrupts them and turns them into sin. Sometimes it keeps people from the duty itself; sometimes it keeps them from receiving any benefit from it. It makes people think they are so sound and well that they have little need of all this medicine, or even of their daily, necessary food. They think all this is more effort than is needed: why all this preaching, praying, reading, holy conversation, meditation, and heavenly-mindedness? One person is ashamed of it, another thinks he does not need it, another considers himself above it.
They ask where they are commanded to pray with their family, to pray so often, to hear so often, to read any book besides the Holy Scriptures, and so on. They feel no obligation from general commands, to "pray without ceasing," and "always," and "not faint," nor be "weary of well-doing," to "redeem the time," and "do all to edification," and be "fervent in spirit, serving the Lord," because they feel neither the need nor the sweetness that would help them see that frequency is good or necessary for them.
Consider two men to whom a physician says "eat often": one has a strong appetite and the other has none. The hungry man will take "often" to mean at least three times a day, while the man with no appetite will think once a day is "often." Healthy men do not ordinarily ask how you can prove they are bound to eat two or three times a day. Feeling the need and benefit, they are satisfied with the allowance without a command, and will rather ask how you can prove they may not do it, for they feel their own reason pressing them toward it unless God restrains them.
So it is with a humble soul regarding the means of his growth and salvation: he feels the need for preaching, prayer, holy observance of the Lord’s day, and family duties. He feels the need and benefit of frequent engagement with those duties, is glad of leave to draw near to God, and feels the bond of love constraining him.
By contrast, the proud are full and unfeeling, and would easily be content with little in religion if the laws of God or man did not compel them, doing no more than they absolutely must. Indeed, some in recent times have been lifted by pride above all ordinances, that is, above obedience to God in the use of his appointed means, though not above the need of those means, nor above the plagues prepared for the proud and disobedient. Humility guards people from many such destructive opinions.
Direction 4. To conquer pride, it is necessary that you recognize it is truly present in you, that it is the root sin and the very poison of your heart, and that you set yourself watchfully to observe its movements, making it a principal part of your religion and the work of your life to overcome it, and to walk in humility before God and man. If you do not see it as your sin, you will leave it alone and trouble yourself little about it. Pride lives on in people who appear religious because they do not perceive it, or think they harbor only a small degree of it that is not dangerous.
They fail to see it in themselves because they do not observe its operations and appearances: the life in the root must be seen in the branches, the leaves, and the fruit. If you saw more evil in pride than in many more obviously disgraceful sins, and set yourself as earnestly and diligently to conquer it as you do to cast out sins that would cause others to judge you utterly ungodly, no doubt the work would go forward more fruitfully, and you would see more excellent fruit of your labor in mortification than most Christians ever see.
Direction 5. Be much engaged in humbling exercises, but take care not to mistake their true nature or to run into extremes. I have already explained the true nature of humility. Many Christians are tempted by Satan to think that humility consists far more than it does in intense grief, tears, and bodily exercises, lengthy and frequent fastings, confessions, penances, and the like. In this way Satan diverts them from genuine efforts toward true humiliation by keeping them occupied all their days striving for tears or performing external exercises.
What you should strive for, above all, is such a sight of your sinfulness and nothingness as will teach you to esteem Christ highly, to loathe yourself, to take yourself as the vile and sinful creature you truly are, a sight that will make you humbly beg for mercy, stoop to any means to obtain it, and make you patient under God’s rebukes and chastisements and under the contempts and injuries of others. This is the humility you must labor for. External exercises of humiliation must still be used in support of this aim: especially studying the holy law of God, searching your own heart, confessing sin, moderate and timely fasting, and mortifying the flesh. Indeed, the exercises of humiliation are most fitting for those who are most prone to pride. The teaching of those who disparage true humiliation proceeds from pride and is designed to foster pride in others. A humble soul cannot receive such teaching, and is in fact more inclined to run into the opposite excess.
Direction 6. There is no more powerful means to take down pride than to look seriously to God, to set yourself before his eyes, and to consider how he loves the humble and abhors the proud. One sight of God through living faith would teach you with whom you have to do, and make you abhor yourself as vile. A glowworm cannot be seen in sunlight, though it glitters in the dark. Even a glimpse of the majesty of God would make you cry out with Isaiah, "Woe is me, for I am undone, a man of unclean lips," etc.; and with the Israelites desire that Moses, and not God, might speak to you, lest you die. (Isa 6:5) People are proud because they do not know God and do not look to him, but only to fellow sinners, with whom they feel free to compare themselves.
Remember also that God is, as it were, committed against the proud, both in the holiness of his nature and in his honor: for a proud man sets himself up against God, and is an idol that God will either bring down by grace or cast into the fire of destruction. If such a person appears before God among others in days and outward exercises of humiliation, you may judge how welcome an object of divine abhorrence will be. God’s regard is not for all who are clothed in sackcloth, but for the humble soul, the self-abhorring person who judges himself unworthy to come among the people of God, or even to be a doorkeeper in his house, or to eat the crumbs of the children’s bread.
These humble souls are those who submit themselves to one another and think no act of love or service too lowly to perform for the least believer; who in charitable meekness instruct those who oppose them, and bear contradiction and contempt from men; who patiently endure injuries from both enemies and friends, and heartily forgive and love them; who receive the sharpest and plainest rebukes with gentleness and gratitude; who think the lowest place in others’ esteem and affection the most fitting for them; who are far more concerned with how they love others than with how others love them, and more concerned with discharging their own duties than with whether others fulfill their duties toward them.
These are they who will take less evidence to think well of another’s heart or actions than of their own; who reprove themselves more often and more sharply than others reprove them; who are readier to pass judgment on themselves than on others, or than most others are to judge them; who hold a low opinion of their own understanding, abilities, and deeds, and are therefore readier to learn than to teach, and to listen than to speak; who prize every bit and drop of mercy, and above all prize Christ, and grace, and glory. These are the humble whom God accepts, and this is the fast he requires. These are the ones who pray effectively and whose prayers can save a land. These alone truly feel what sin is, when others do not feel it, or remain proud even in the midst of their most extensive confessions and tears. These alone heartily acknowledge that they deserve God’s severest judgments, and justify God when he afflicts them.
Others rather wonder at the greatness and duration of judgments, and argue with God as though he were dealing harshly and unkindly with them, and tell him what a good people he is afflicting. These humble souls alone understand the sinfulness of their very acts of humiliation and prayer, through the weakness of what good is in them and the mixture of much evil, while the proud marvel that God does not hear them at the first word. These alone wait patiently for God’s answer and accept mercy in his own time and measure; while the proud are short-winded, and if God does not come just when they expected, they hasten ahead like Saul, or murmur at his providence, and say it is in vain to serve the Lord, and begin to think of abandoning him and seeking some better course.
Those proud ones who joined in outward acts of humiliation while lifting up their hearts even as they cast down their bodies are the very ones who have turned God’s heart so much against us, leading him to break us in pieces, because he found so many proud people among us whom he counts his enemies.
We have had people humbling themselves in our assemblies who were wise in their own eyes: despising, scorning, and reviling their teachers; criticizing those who did not share their opinions or serve their interests; overly eager for the honor and respect of men; unable to endure being disregarded or thought little of; unable to bear an injury or a harsh word without anger, if not revenge; unable to seek peace or defer to others, or bear plain-dealing in reproof, or forgive a wrong without great submission; full of high expectations from others, and loving best those who esteemed them most; counting it beneath them to take the lowest places or do the humblest services for others’ good; yes, even quarreling with God, his Word, and his providences, and valuing no mercies but those that exalted themselves or pleased their flesh (which proved in the end to be judgments).
And yet, while they thus excommunicated themselves from the face of God by pride and made themselves objects of his abhorrence, they separated from the holiest assemblies and servants of God in the land as though such assemblies were unworthy of their communion unless they first adopted their opinions or joined their sect. We think too little of how great a part this pride has played in our desolations. God has been scattering the proud of every kind in the imaginations of their own hearts.
Direction 7. Look to a humbled Christ to humble you. Can you be proud while you believe that your Savior was clothed with flesh, lived in lowliness, made himself of no reputation, was despised and scorned and spat upon by sinners, and was shamefully treated and nailed as a criminal to a cross? The very incarnation of Christ is a condescension and humiliation enough to confound both men and angels, surpassing all belief except what God himself produces by his supernatural testimony and Spirit. Can pride look a crucified Christ in the face, or stand before him?
Did God take upon himself the form of a servant, and must you domineer and insist on the highest place? Had not Christ a place to lay his head, and must you have your adorned and well-furnished rooms? Must you show yourself off in the most extravagant fashion, in place of your Savior’s seamless coat? He prays for his murderers, and must you take revenge for a word or a petty wrong? He is patiently spat upon and struck, and are you, through proud impatience, ready to spit upon or strike others? Surely he who "condemned sin in the flesh" condemned no sin more than pride.
Direction 8. Look to the examples of the most eminent saints, and you will see that they were all most eminent in humility. The apostles, before the Holy Ghost descended upon them, contended over which of them should be the greatest, which Christ permitted so that he might rebuke it most sharply, and leave his warning to all his ministers and disciples to the end of the world: that whoever would be greatest must be the servant of all, and that they must by conversion become as little children, or never enter the kingdom of God.
But afterward, in what humility did those apostles labor, and live, and suffer in the world? Paul "made himself a servant unto all, that he might gain the more, though he was free from all men" (1 Cor 9:19). They submitted themselves to every injury and affront from men; to be counted the plagues and troublers of the world; to be the scorn and offscouring of all things, and a spectacle to angels and to men. Are you better than they? If you are, you are more humble, and not more proud.
Direction 9. Look to the holy angels who condescend to minister for mankind; think of the blessed souls with God, how far they are from pride; and remember, if you ever come to heaven, how far you yourself will be from pride there. A sight such as Isaiah had would take down pride: "I saw the Lord sitting upon a throne, high and lifted up, and his train filled the temple. Above it stood the seraphims: each one had six wings: with two he covered his face, and with two he covered his feet, and with two he did fly" (signifying humility, purity, and obedience). "And one cried unto another, and said, Holy, Holy, Holy is the Lord of Hosts: his glory is the fulness of the whole earth." (Isa 6:1–3) So in Revelation 4:8–10: "The elders fall down, and cast down their crowns before him that sitteth on the throne." Look up to heaven and you will abhor your pride.
Direction 10. Look upon the great imperfection of your graces and duties. Should a man be proud who has so little of the Spirit and image of Jesus Christ? Who believes so feebly, fears God so little, and loves him so poorly? Who can so poorly trust in him, rest upon his Word and love, delight in him, or in his holy laws and service? One would think that the pitiable weakness of any single one of these graces ought to bring down pride and humble you in your own eyes.
Is he a Christian who does not even abhor himself when he perceives how little he loves his God, and how little all his meditations on the love and blood of Christ, on the infinite goodness of God, and on the heavenly glory manage to kindle the fire and warm his heart? Can we observe the darkness of our minds, our ignorance of God, our alienation from the life to come, and the woeful weakness of our faith, and not be humbled to a loathing of ourselves?
Can we help but abhor hearts that can love a friend, can love the toys and vanities of this life, yet love their God no more than this? That take so little pleasure in his name, his praise, his Word, and his service, when they can find pleasure in the comforts of the flesh? Can we help but loathe hearts that are so averse to God, so reluctant to think of him, so reluctant to pray to him, so weary of prayer, holy meditation, or any duty, yet so eager for the business and recreations of the flesh?
Can we feel how coldly and unbelievingly we pray, how ignorantly or carnally we speak, how confusedly and vainly we think, how slothfully we work, and how unprofitably we live, and yet be proud, and not be covered with shame? For a serious Christian to feel how little of God, of Christ, of heaven is upon his heart, and how little appears in any eminent holiness, fruitfulness, and heavenliness of life, is so humbling a consideration that we have much difficulty owning ourselves at all, and not lying down as utterly desolate.
Should a soul admit a single thought of pride who has so little grace as to be uncertain whether he has any at all in sincerity? Who cannot with assurance call God Father, or plead his interest in Christ or in the promises? Who does not know, if he were to die this hour, whether he would go to heaven or hell? Should he be proud who is so unready to die, so unassured of the pardon of sin, so unwilling to appear before the Lord? If one painful limb will make you groan and walk dejectedly, even when all the rest feel no pain, a soul that has this universal weakness, a weakness that is both sinful and dangerous, has cause to be continually humbled to the dust.
Direction 11. Look upon your great and manifold sins, which dwell in your heart and have been committed throughout your life, and there you will find cause for great humiliation. If your body were full of toads and serpents, and you could see or feel them crawling within you, would you then be proud? Yet so many sins are ten thousand times worse, and should make you far viler in your own estimation. If you were possessed by devils and knew it, would you be proud? Yet devils possessing your body are not so harmful to you as sin in your soul. The sight of a sin should take down your pride more than the sight of a devil.
Should that man be proud who has lived as you have lived, and sinned as you have sinned, from childhood until now? Who has wasted so much time, abused so much mercy, neglected so many means, omitted so many duties to God and man, been guilty of so many sinful thoughts, so many false or foolish words, and has broken all the laws of God? Should he not be deeply humbled who still has so much ignorance, error, unbelief, hypocrisy, sensuality, worldliness, hardheartedness, carelessness, uncharitableness, lust, envy, malice, impatience, and selfishness as remains in you?
Should not your very pride itself be a cause for great humiliation, that so odious a sin should still so greatly prevail? Look in this way at your leprous, defiled soul, and turn your very pride against itself. Know yourself, and you cannot be proud. See the Treatise of Self-Ignorance.
Direction 12. Look also to the desert of all your sins, even to hell itself, and see whether that will bring you low. Though pride came from hell as its efficient cause, yet hell, as its object, may furnish a remedy against it. Think on the worm that never dies, and the fire that shall never be quenched, and consider whether pride befits a soul that has deserved these things. Will you be proud on the road to your damnation? You might as well be proud of your chains and the rope when you are walking to the gallows.
Think whether the miserable souls in hell are now concerned with neat and fashionable attire, or seeking dominion, honor, or advancement, or contending over who shall be greatest, or striving for the highest places, or setting themselves out for the admiration and applause of men, or quarreling with others for slighting or dishonoring them. Do you think there is any place or occasion there for such works of pride, when God abases them?
Direction 13. Look to the day of judgment, when all proud thoughts and looks shall be brought low, and to the endless misery threatened to the proud. Think of that world in which your souls must before long appear before the great and holy God, whose presence will abase the proudest sinner. When the tyrants, the gallants, and the wantons of the earth must with trembling and amazement give up their accounts to the most righteous Judge of all the world, where then are their lofty looks and language? Where are their glory, their finery, their proud and imperious domineering, and their scornful contempt for the humble, lowly ones of Christ?
Would you then recognize that this is the same man who lately could scarcely be seen or spoken to? Who looked so imposing and swaggered in his wealth and honor? Is this the one who could not endure a slight, a contemptuous dismissal, an honest rebuke? Who must have honor and precedence in wit, greatness, and command? Is this the man who thought himself perfect and without sin, or that his sins were so trifling as not to require the humiliation, renewal, and holy diligence of the saints?
Is this the woman who spent half the day adorning herself, her house, and her furnishings for the view of others, and who must always be dressed in the newest or finest fashion? Who was accustomed to walk with an affected pace, a wandering eye, and a wanton bearing, as though she were too good to tread upon the earth? How entirely the case will be altered with such as these! Can you believe and consider that you must be judged by God, and yet be proud?
Direction 14. Look to the devils themselves who tempt you to be proud, and see what pride has brought them to; and remember that a proud man bears the image of the devil, and that pride is the devil’s peculiar sin. He who envies your happiness knows by bitter experience the road to misery, and therefore tempts you to be proud so that you may come, by the same way, to the same end he himself has come to. "The angels which kept not their first estate, but left their own habitation, are reserved in everlasting chains under darkness, to the judgment of the great day" (Jude 6).
Direction 15. Look well upon yourself, both body and soul, and consider whether you are a person fitted for pride. God has purposely clothed your immortal soul in the plain attire of corruptible flesh, and placed it in so poor and ruinous a dwelling, that it might be kept from pride. Indeed, he made this frail and corruptible body a constitutive part of our very persons, so that in knowing it we may know ourselves.
Some men keep a dead man’s skull in their study or chamber as a remedy against pride. But God has bound us yet more closely to mortality: death dwells in our own bodies. We might well marvel that so noble a soul should be lodged in so mean a body, made of earth and destined to return to it. A stone is durable and clean, but my flesh is corruptible and must turn to loathsome filth and rottenness. A marble pillar will stand firm and beautiful from age to age, but I must perish and decay in darkness.
The seats we sit on, the pillars we lean against, the stones we tread upon will remain when we are turned to dust. The house I build may stand when I am rotting in the grave. A tree will live when the man who planted it is dead. Our bodies are made of no better material than those of the brutes; our substance is in continual flux and waste, losing something every day, and if it were not continually repaired and patched up by daily air and nourishment, it would soon be spent and our oil consumed.
If you were chained to a dead body that you had to carry about with you, it would not be so fit a thing to humble you as being joined this closely to so vile a body of your own. We carry a dunghill continually within us.
Ausonius tells in an epigram how King Agathocles ate from earthenware and would often load his sideboard with common Samian clay, setting coarse dishes among jewelled vessels and mingling wealth and poverty together; and when he was asked why, he answered, "I who am king of Sicily am the son of a potter." Hold fortune reverently, Ausonius adds, whoever you are who has risen suddenly to wealth from a lowly place.
How slight a thing is the greatest, the strongest, and the most handsome of you all! What is that flesh you so much pamper but a skin full of corruption, a bag of filth, of phlegm and bile and such waste? If fastidious women could see the phlegm in their heads and bowels, the bile around their liver, the worms and waste in their other parts, they would nearly sicken at the sight. The swine or any other beast has as clean an interior. What difference does it make if this filth is covered with fairer skin or clearer color than your neighbor’s? When sickness alters and consumes you, where is what you called beauty? If a leprosy or smallpox deforms it, if a fever, consumption, or dropsy wastes it, or the stone or gout seizes you, you will feel or see what ought to shame your pride.
Should such a creature be proud, one who cannot, even if he is a Herod, keep the worms from eating him alive? who in a flux cannot retain his own excrements? who cannot easily endure the aching of a tooth? If you are fit for pride, then forbid diseases to touch your flesh or stain your beauty; refuse to be sick or weak or pained; do not let worms and corruption be your guests. But if you are so poor a thing that you cannot prevent any of these, then know yourself, and be ashamed of pride.
In sickness you will become a burden to others, needing their help to feed you, dress you, turn you, and keep you clean. And when all is done, you must die, and be laid in darkness in a grave, rotting night and day until your flesh has turned to earth. Grass withers when it is cut down, yet it is sweet; a felled tree will rot in time, but not with such a loathsome stench as we give off. Those who saw what the late wars so often showed, fields strewn with the carcasses of men, heaped among the rubble of ditches around besieged towns and castles, would think such loathsome lumps of flesh should never have been proud.
Once death strips the body of its soul, even your closest friends will quickly tire of the remainder and be glad to remove it from sight and smell. Go to the churchyard and look on the dust and bones scattered there, and ask yourself whether those who must come to this have any reason to be proud. See whether the dust of the rich, the strong, or the beautiful bears any mark of distinction, whether those bones contend there for supremacy and dominion. For this reason, the desire for ornate monuments on men’s graves is among the most odious forms of pride, shamed by its immediate neighborhood to rottenness and dust. As our serious poet Herbert says,
"When the hair grows sweet with pride and lust, The powder doth forget the dust."
And though your soul is far nobler than your body, consider how ignorant, weak, and disordered it is even here. How full of false ideas are human minds! How little do people know of what they might know, or think with confidence that they know! How dark we are about all the works of God, and about his Word, and still more about himself! The greatest scholars are strongly tempted toward skepticism, and the ignorant who this year are so confident as to hold all who differ from them in contempt may well change their judgments and recant themselves the very next year.
And are our hearts and lives in any better condition than our understandings? While we are imprisoned in the flesh, while its interests are our interests, and its appetites and passions have such great power to corrupt, seduce, and disturb the soul, we have every reason for humility. Know yourself, and pride will die.
Direction 16. If you have anything to be proud of, remember what it is, and that it is not your own, but given or lent to you by that God who hates pride above all things.
1. Are you tempted to be proud of riches? Remember that they are in themselves but dross, which will leave you at the grave as poor as anyone. As for their usefulness, they are only your Master’s talents; and the more you have, the greater will be your accounting. Very few rich men escape the snare and come to heaven; your charge and danger, therefore, should humble you rather and make you fear greatly. Read James 5:1–4 and Luke 12:19–20.
2. Is it greatness, dominion, human applause, or honor that you are proud of? Remember that this too is in itself a dream, it makes you neither actually better nor safer than other men. You stand on higher ground, where you receive more of the storms and dangers than others, and you will be leveled with the lowest in your fall. As for the use of your power and greatness, it exists for God, not for yourself; and your reckoning will be so great, in proportion to the trust placed in you, as would terrify a thoughtful believer who could foresee it.
3. Is it youthful strength that you are proud of? How little can it do for you in what you most need! And how soon will it turn to weakness! How many are cut off "in youth, and their life is among the unclean," as Elihu says (Job 36:14). "Their bones are full of the sins of their youth, which shall lie down with them in the dust" (Job 20:11).
4. Is it beauty that you are proud of? I have already told you what sickness and death will do to it. "When God rebuketh man for sin, he makes his beauty to consume as a moth: surely every man is vanity" (Ps 39:11). And if your beauty could last, how little good would it do you? Only fools look at the skin of a rational creature when they wish to discern worth. A fool, and a slave of lust and Satan, may be beautiful. A sepulchre may be gilded while holding rottenness within. Would you choose the finest purse or the fullest? Who but a child or a fool values a book by the fineness of its cover or the gilding of its leaves, rather than the worth of the matter within? Absalom was beautiful, and what good did it do him? "Favour is deceitful, and beauty is vain; but a woman that feareth the LORD, she shall be praised" (Prov 31:30). Read also (Ps 49:12–14).
5. If it is fine clothes and gaudy ornaments that you are proud of, the sin is so foolish, worse than childish, that it needs no further refutation than this: it defeats itself, making you a scorn and a laughingstock to others when your intention was to be more admired. An ass or a post may be dressed in attire as fine and costly as yours. And shortly you shall exchange it for a winding-sheet.
6. Is it your birth, your ancestors, and your powerful connections that you are proud of? Personal merit is incomparably more excellent than any relationship to the most meritorious parents, much more than a connection to their empty titles. Cain was the son of Adam, the father of all mankind; Ham was the son of Noah; Esau was the son of Isaac; Absalom was the son of David, yet a godly son of a wicked father is more honorable than any of them. Your ancestors are but of the common stock of sinful Adam. Your great friends may yet become your enemies. And the greatest of them can do very little for you if God is not your friend.
7. Is it your learning, wisdom, or ability in speech and action that you are proud of? Remember that the devils, and many now in hell, have far exceeded you in these things. The wiser you truly are, the humbler you will be, and by your pride you refute your own boast of wisdom. Ahithophel’s wisdom, which could not save him from ruin, is little ground for glorying.
There were men who boasted of their wisdom in the very law of God, yet they were put to shame and dismay, because they rejected the word of the Lord, and what wisdom could remain in them after that? "Thus saith the Lord, Let not the wise man glory in his wisdom, nor let the mighty man glory in his might, let not the rich man glory in his riches: but let him that glorieth glory in this, that he understandeth and knoweth me, that I am the LORD, which exercise lovingkindness, judgment, and righteousness, in the earth: for in these do I delight, saith the LORD." (Jer 9:23–24) Those of whom Paul speaks were not unlearned: "Where is the wise? where is the scribe? where is the disputer of this world? Hath not God made foolish the wisdom of this world?" (1 Cor 1:20)
8. Is it success in wars or great undertakings that you are proud of? By whose strength did you accomplish it? And how unhappy is a success that hinders your success in the work of salvation? How many who were lifted up in the pride of their victories have been brought back down to shame?
9. Is it the applause of men, who proclaim your excellence, that you are proud of? How poor a portion is the breath of man, and how changeable are those who applaud you! Perhaps the very next day they will turn their tune and reproach you just as loudly. Will you be proud of praise when it is the devil’s whistle, used deliberately to lure you into this deadly snare and destroy you? It is a danger to be feared, for it destroys many; but it is no true benefit to rejoice in, still less to be proud of, since few are the better for it. Titles and applause add nothing to real worth and virtue; they only inflate many with a fatal swelling.
10. Is it your grace and goodness, or your eminence in religion, that you are proud of? This is most absurd. Dominant pride is a sure sign that you have no saving grace at all, so you are proud of what you do not have. And if you do have grace, then to the degree that you are proud of it you abuse it, contradict it, and destroy it, for pride is to grace what plague or consumption is to health. It is novices, those with the least grace and knowledge, who are most liable to be puffed up with pride, and thereby to fall into the condemnation of the devil (1 Tim 3:6), that is, into a like punishment for a like sin. When a pot boils over, what was inside is lost in the fire. Do not rise too high in your estimation of your own grace, lest you rise to the loss of it. "Be not highminded, but fear." (Rom 11:20) "When you think you stand, take heed lest you fall." (1 Cor 10:12)
Direction 17. Look to the nature and tendency of every grace, ordinance, and duty, and use them diligently; for they all work toward the destruction of pride. Knowledge discerns the folly and destructive course of pride, and furnishes abundant material for humiliation. Faith is the casting off of our pride and the coming to Christ with empty, hungry souls for mercy and supply. Faith shows us the most powerful sight in the world for humbling a soul: a crucified Christ, a most holy God, a glorified company of humble souls, and a dreadful judgment and damnation awaiting the proud. The same could be shown of every grace and duty, but to do so at length would be tedious.
Direction 18. Look to the humbling judgments of God upon yourselves and others, and turn them all against your pride. You would surely think it an unseemly and ill-timed thing for those in calamity to be proud. Are you not often complaining of something, upon your consciences, your bodies, your estates, your reputations, your relationships or friends? And will you still be proud while you complain? If the judgments already fallen on you have not humbled you, and if God loves you and intends to save you, you may expect to feel more; the load will be increased until it makes you stoop.
What miserable, obstinate sinners, who can groan with sickness and yet be proud! Who murmur under want and yet be proud! Who are daily crossed by one thing or another and yet be proud! Yes, and tormented with fears of God’s displeasure, and yet be proud! Have not all the wars, bloodshed, and ruin that have befallen these kingdoms been enough to bring down pride? We have seen many humbling sights and felt many humbling stripes, and yet we are not humbled. We have seen houses robbed, towns burned, the countryside pillaged, the blood of many thousands shed, and their bodies scattered across the fields, and yet we are not humbled.
If we were proud of our riches, they have been taken from us. If proud of our buildings, they have been turned to rubble. If proud of our government, and the fame and glory of our country, we have seen how our sins pulled down our government, dishonored our rulers, and turned our glory into shame, and yet we are not humbled. If you lived in a house infected with plague, and had buried your father and mother, brothers and sisters, with only a very few survivors left waiting for their own turn, and if even those few were not humbled, would you not think them blind and sottish persons? Do you still look high, contend for pre-eminence, seek honor, envy others, desire to dominate, insist on having your own will and way, and dress yourselves in the finest clothes?
Must you have sharper stripes before you will be humbled? Must greater wrongs, violence, losses, fears, and reproaches be the means? Why will you choose so painful a remedy by rejecting the easier one? If it must come to that, the judgment will shortly draw yet nearer to you. It will either strip you of what remains, or cover you with shame, or lay you in pain upon your bed, where your head shall ache, your heart be sick, your body weary, and you shall gasp for breath.
Will you then be proud, and contend for honor, when you expect at any hour that your proud and guilty soul will be turned out of your body to appear before the holy God? When the bell is ready to toll for you, your winding-sheet to be fetched out, your coffin prepared, and the bier brought to carry you to your grave and leave you in the dark with worms and rottenness, will you then be proud? Where then are your high looks, your lofty minds, your splendid ornaments and honors? Will you then be climbing into higher rooms, or seeking revenge on those who dimmed your glory? As David says of princes, and all the sons of men: "His breath goeth forth, he returneth to his earth; in that very day his thoughts perish." (Ps 146:3–4)
Direction 19. Look at the ruinous effects of pride around you in the world, and that will help you see its ugliness and destructive nature. Do you not see how it sets the whole world on fire? How it starts wars, ruins kingdoms, draws out men’s blood, and fills the world with malice, hatred, cruelty, injustice, treasons, and rebellions, destroying mercy, truth, and honesty, and all that remains of God’s image in the mind of man? What is the source of all the confusion and calamity, all the censoriousness, revilings, and cruelties we have seen, felt, or heard of, but pride?
What is it that has trampled on the interests of Christ and his Gospel throughout the world, but pride? What else has burned his martyrs, made havoc of his servants, distracted and divided his church with schisms, raised up so many sect-masters and sects, nearly all of them set against one another, but this cursed, unmortified pride? Anyone who has seen what pride has done in England in this age, and still cannot discern its hatefulness and destructiveness, is strangely blind.
Every proud man is a plague and burden to the place where he lives. If he rises high, he becomes a Nabal, a man can hardly speak to him; he thinks all beneath him exist only to serve his will and honor, as lower creatures exist to serve man. If he is in a lower position, he scorns the honor and authority of his superiors, thinks they claim too much, and considers it beneath him to obey.
If a proud person is rich, he expects the poor to bow before him as before a golden image. If he is poor, he envies the rich and cannot bear the condition God has placed him in. If he is learned, he thinks himself an oracle; if unlearned, he despises the knowledge he lacks and scorns to be taught. Whatever his state, he is like a salamander living in fire, he troubles house, town, and country wherever his power matches his ambition. He is an unpolished stone that will never lie flat in any building; he is by nature an enemy to quietness and peace.
Direction 20. Consider carefully how God has designed the humbling of all whom he will save, in the whole arrangement of our redemption. He could have saved mankind by keeping us in our original innocence, had he chosen. Though he does not cause sin, he knows why he permits it. He judged it insufficient that humanity should have only the thought of creation to humble us, being taken from the dust and made of nothing. He will also have us feel our moral nothingness and sinfulness. He will have us indebted to our Redeemer and Sanctifier for our new life and salvation as fully as we are indebted to our Creator for our natural life.
We are permitted first to undo ourselves, to fall under condemnation, to become children of death and near to hell, before we are ransomed and delivered, so that we may take to ourselves the shame of our misery and ascribe all our hope and recovery to God. No flesh shall be justified by the works of the law, or by a righteousness of our own making, but only by the satisfaction and merits of our Redeemer, so that all boasting may be excluded, that no flesh might glory before God, and that humanity might be humbled while our Redeemer receives the praise to all eternity. God therefore prepares people for faith and pardon through humbling works, and compels sinners to condemn themselves before he will justify them.
Direction 21. Read the character Christ himself gives of his true disciples, and you will see what great self-denial and humility he requires of all. In your first conversion you must become as little children (Matt 18:3). Rather than contending for superiority and greatness, you must be ambitious to be servants of all (Matt 23:11 Matt 20:27). You must learn from him to be meek and lowly in heart (Matt 11:28–29), and to stoop to wash your brothers’ feet (John 13:5 and 13:14). Instead of revenge or contentious insistence on your rights, you must rather yield to those who command you unjustly, turn the other cheek to the one who strikes you, let go the rest to the one who has wrongfully taken from you, bless those who curse you, and pray for those who hurt and persecute and despitefully use you (Matt 5:39–40 and 5:44). These are the followers of Christ.
Direction 22. Remember how pride contradicts itself by exposing you to the hatred or contempt of all. All people abhor in others the very pride they cherish in themselves. A humble person is well thought of by all who know him; a proud person becomes the object of common reproach. The rich disdain him, the poor envy him, all hate him, and many ridicule him. That is his reward.
Direction 23. Keep in mind the dismal end toward which pride tends. It threatens apostasy. If God forsakes anyone among you, or if any of you forsakes God, his truth, and your conscience, and is made like Lot’s wife, a monument of divine vengeance as a warning to others, it will be the proud and self-conceited person. Pride makes all the mercies of God, your duties and gifts, and even your graces in themselves, its food and fuel. It is a sign that you are near some dreadful fall or heavy judgment, for God has given this warning: (Luke 14:11 Luke 1:51 Prov 15:25 Prov 16:5 Isa 2:11–12). An Ahab is safer when he humbles himself; a Hezekiah is falling when he is lifted up. The proudest are the most hardened sinners, scorning reproof, and are therefore ordinarily forsaken by both God and men, and left to their self-delusion until they perish.
Direction 24. Converse with humbled and afflicted persons, not with proud and secure worldlings. Spend time in the "house of mourning," where you may see "the end of all the living, and be made better by laying it to heart;" and do not let your "hearts be in the house of mirth" (Eccl 7:2–4). Do not delight in conversing with "men that be in honour, and understand not, but are like the beasts that perish; for though they think of perpetuating their houses, and call their lands after their own names," yet they "abide not in" their "honour:" and "this their way is their folly," though "yet their posterity approve their sayings" (Ps 49:20 and 49:12–14). Converse with penitent and humbled souls who have seen the ugliness of sin and the wickedness and deceitfulness of the heart, and who can tell you from their own experience what cause for humiliation still lies before you. With these you are most safe.
I have dwelt at length against pride, seeing how prevalent it is in the world and how destructive its effects are upon souls and families, church and state, and because it is not recognized and resisted as it ought to be. I earnestly desire that God would dwell in your hearts and that peace would prevail in your communities; that you would stand firm in the hour of temptation from either prosperity or adversity; and that affliction would be borne with ease. None of this will come without humility. I am reluctant to see us remain unhumbled under the mighty hand of God, even when his judgments call us to lay our mouths in the dust. The storms have been long upon us; the cedars have fallen, it is the low shrubs and bending willows that are now most likely to survive.
I am reluctant to see the marks of coming wrath upon your souls or upon the land. I am reluctant to see any of you left unhumbled of sin through pride, or ashamed to own a despised godliness, or to see those who have appeared religious prove seditious, contentious, or apostate.
Therefore I earnestly urge you: in a particular way, take heed of pride. Be small in your own estimation. Do not praise one another at the wrong moment. Do not take offense at plain reproof. Attend to your duties, and leave your reputation to the will of God. Rebuke pride in your children; accustom them to plain clothing and humble tasks; do not foster in them what is most natural at present and most ruinous. God dwells with the humble, and will take the humble to dwell with him (Isa 57:15 Job 22:29). "Put on humbleness of mind, meekness, longsuffering, forbearing one another" (Col 3:12–13). "Be clothed with humility: serve the Lord with all humility of mind, and he will exalt you in due time" (Acts 20:19 1 Pet 5:6–7).
CHAPTER 2
DIRECTIONS AGAINST COVETOUSNESS, OR LOVE OF RICHES, AND AGAINST WORLDLY CARES
I shall say little on this subject here, because I have already written a treatise on it, called "The Crucifying of the World by the Cross of Christ," in which I have given many directions, in the preface and in the treatise itself, against this sin.
Direction 1. Understand thoroughly the nature and malignity of this sin: both what it is and why it is so great and dangerous. I will show you: 1. What love of riches is lawful; 2. What is unlawful, and in what covetousness or worldliness consists; 3. In what way its malignity or greatness lies; 4. Its signs; 5. What counterfeits of the contrary virtue conceal this sin from the eyes of worldlings; 6. What false appearances of covetousness cause many to be suspected of it unjustly.
1. Not all love of the creature, the world, or riches is sinful.
1.) The works of God are all good as such, and all goodness is worthy of love. As they relate to God, bearing the imprint of his power, wisdom, and goodness, we must love them for his sake.
2.) All the impressions of God’s attributes appearing in his works make them like a mirror in which, at this distance, we must see the Creator. Their sweetness is a drop from him, by which his goodness and love are tasted. In this way, all things were made to lead us up to God, to help our minds commune with him, and to kindle the love of God in our hearts, as a love-token from our dearest friend. Loved as means of communion with God, they are a duty and not a sin.
3.) They are naturally the means of sustaining our bodies, preserving life, health, and energy. As such, our sensitive nature loves them as every animal loves food. This love in itself is not moral; it is neither virtue nor vice, until it is either directed in obedience to reason, in which case it is good, or in disobedience to reason, in which case it is evil.
4.) Created things are necessary means to support our bodies while we carry out the service we owe God in the world, and so they must be loved as means to his service, though we cannot properly say that riches are ordinarily necessary in this way.
5.) Created things are necessary to sustain our bodies on our journey to heaven, while we are preparing for eternity, and so they must be loved as remote aids to our salvation. In these last two respects we call them in our prayers "our daily bread."
6.) Riches may enable us to relieve our needy brethren and to promote good works for church or state. They may be loved on that account as well: we may love whatever we may rightly give thanks for, since we should give thanks only for what is good.
2. Worldliness, or sinful love of riches, is a different matter.
1.) It is sinful when riches are loved, desired, and pursued more for the flesh than for God or our salvation, as the substance and means of worldly prosperity, so that the flesh may lack nothing to please and satisfy it. Or so that pride may have enough to sustain itself by gratifying others, living at a certain rate, and displaying a splendor that shows one’s greatness or extends one’s dominion over others.
2.) It is sinful when we therefore desire riches in the proportion we judge most suitable to these carnal ends, and are not content with our daily bread and that measure which may sustain us as travelers to heaven and tend most toward the security of our souls and the service of God.
The sinful love of riches is principally discerned by its end: when riches are loved for pride or the pleasure of the flesh, as the substance of a worldly, temporal happiness, and not principally for God, his service and servants, and our salvation. Loved as sensualists love them, they ought rather to be hated.
Worldliness is either predominant, a certain sign of spiritual death, or mortified and subdued to a degree consistent with some saving grace.
Predominant worldliness, as found in the ungodly, occurs when people who have no living belief in everlasting happiness, and have not laid up their treasure and hopes in heaven, take the pleasure and prosperity of this life as the highest felicity in their estimation and dearest to their hearts. They therefore love the riches of the world, or full material provision, as the substance and means of their temporal happiness.
Worldliness in a mortified person is different. He has laid up his treasure in heaven, practically values his everlasting hopes above all fleshly pleasure and prosperity, seeks first the kingdom of God and his righteousness, and uses his property principally for God and his salvation. Yet he retains some remnants of inordinate desire for fleshly prosperity and pleasure, and some inordinate desire for riches to that end. These he hates, mourns over, resists, and so far subdues that they do not become predominant against the interests of God and his salvation. Even so, this is a great sin, though it is forgiven.
3. The malignity or greatness of this sin consists in the following points, especially when it is predominant.
1.) The love of the world or of riches is a sin of deliberation, not of mere rashness or sudden passion. Worldlings plan and contrive to reach their ends.
2.) It is a sin of interest, love, and choice, set up against our highest interest. It means establishing a false ultimate end and pursuing it, not merely a sin of error in the means, or a pursuing of the right end in a mistaken way.
3.) It is idolatry, a practical denial and dethroning of God in the heart, setting up his creatures in his place, to the degree that it prevails. The worldling gives to the creature that love and trust which belong to God alone. He delights in it instead of God, seeks and holds it as his happiness instead of God. Accordingly, so far as any man loves the world, the love of the Father is not in him, and the friendship of the world is enmity to God.
4.) It is contempt of heaven, when heaven must be neglected and a miserable world preferred to it.
5.) It shows that unbelief prevails in the heart, to the same degree that worldliness prevails. If people truly and practically believed in the heavenly glory and its promise, they would be carried above these present things.
6.) It degrades the human soul, treating it like a brute creature, when it is set chiefly upon serving the flesh and upon temporal happiness while neglecting its eternal well-being and interests.
7.) It perverts the very direction of a person’s entire life, which is spent pursuing a wrong end, not merely perverting a single faculty or act. It is a habitual sin of the settled disposition and course of mind and life, not merely a particular act.
8.) It perverts God’s created gifts to ends and uses directly contrary to the purpose for which they were made and given. It turns God’s own gifts against him, corrupting the very blessings by which he should be served and honored, and destroys our souls with the very mercies given to help and benefit them.
This is the true character of this heinous sin. In a word, it is the forsaking of God, the turning of the heart away from him, and the alienating of one’s life from his service, toward this present world and the service of the flesh. Fornication, drunkenness, murder, swearing, perjury, lying, stealing, and the like are very heinous sins. But a single act of any of these, committed rashly under the force of passion or temptation, does not speak such a deep and habitual turning of the heart away from God as it does to say that a man is covetous or a worldling.
4. The signs of covetousness are these.
1.) Not preferring God and our everlasting happiness over fleshly prosperity and pleasure, but valuing and loving fleshly prosperity beyond its true worth.
2.) Esteeming and loving the creatures of God as provision for the flesh rather than as aids to the service of God.
3.) Desiring more than is necessary or useful to further us in our duty.
4.) An inordinate eagerness in our desires after earthly things.
5.) Distrust, anxious cares, and endless scheming about the future.
6.) Discontent, distress, and complaining at a poor condition, when we have no more than our daily bread.
7.) When the world occupies our thoughts inordinately, when our thoughts run more easily toward worldly things than toward better things; when thoughts of worldly plenty are more pleasant and sweet to us than thoughts of Christ, grace, and heaven; and when thoughts of need and poverty are more bitter and painful to us than thoughts of sin and God’s displeasure.
8.) When our speech flows more freely and pleasantly about worldly prosperity than about the things of God and our souls.
9.) When the world holds sway in our families and social life, crowding out all serious effort in the service of God and in care for our own souls and others’, or at least cutting religious duties short, pushing them aside, and causing us to hurry through them carelessly.
10.) When we are excessively cast down and impatient under losses, hardships, and injuries from others in worldly matters.
11.) When worldly matters seem sufficient to draw us into contentions and to break peace, when we will pursue our rights through lawsuits even though greater harm is likely to follow to a brother’s soul, or greater injury to the cause of religion and the honor of God, than our right is worth.
12.) When in trouble and distress we draw our comfort more from thoughts of our worldly provisions or hopes of supply than from trust in God and hope of heaven.
13.) When we are more thankful to God or to other people for outward riches or any provision for the flesh than for helps and hopes directed toward salvation, more grateful for wealth than for a powerful ministry, good books, or timely instruction for the soul.
14.) When we are quiet and satisfied if only we prosper and have plenty in the world, even though the soul remains miserable, unsanctified, and unpardoned.
15.) When we are more concerned to secure a worldly portion for our children and friends than a heavenly one, and rejoice more in their bodily prosperity than their spiritual flourishing, and are more troubled by their poverty than by their ungodliness or sin.
16.) When we can see a brother in need and shut up our compassion, or part with nothing beyond mere superfluities for his relief, when we cannot spare what merely improves our own comfort in order to preserve his very existence, or when we give unwillingly or sparingly.
17.) When we venture on sinful means for gain: lying, overreaching, deceiving, flattering, acting against our consciences, or transgressing the commands of God.
18.) When we are too eager to receive liberality from others, expecting everyone we deal with to sell to us cheaper than they can afford, without regard for their loss or need as long as we gain, and never satisfied however generously they treat others if they do not treat us the same. Cicero warned that two things drive all men to crime, extravagance and greed; that morals are corrupted and depraved by the admiration of riches; and that nothing is so sacred that money cannot violate it, nothing so well fortified that money cannot storm it. When Alexander sent Phocion a hundred talents, Phocion asked why he sent to him rather than to all the other Athenians, and was told it was because Alexander took him for the only honest man in Athens. Phocion sent the money back, asking leave to be honest still.
19.) When we overreach in the world for riches, taking too much upon ourselves, striving for advancement, flattering the powerful, and envying anyone promoted before us or receiving what we expected.
20.) When we hold our money more tightly than our innocence, and cannot part with it when Christ requires it, but will stretch our consciences and sin against him, or abandon his cause, to preserve our property, or will not use it in the service of his church or our country when we are called to do so.
21.) When the riches we possess are used only to pamper our flesh and make superfluous provision for our posterity, and nothing but some negligible scraps are given to God and his servants, nor used to advance us in his service or in laying up a treasure in heaven.
These are the marks of a worldly, covetous wretch.
5. The counterfeits of liberality, or the false signs by which a worldling deceives himself into thinking he is free from covetousness, are the following.
1.) One person thinks he is not covetous because he is under necessity to seek more. He is either in debt, or so poor he can barely live, and the poor generally suppose that only the rich are worldlings and covetous. But a person may love riches while lacking them just as much as one who possesses them. If you must labor in your calling, that creates no necessity for loving the world, for caring with disordered anxiety, or for being discontented with your circumstances. Impatience under your needs reveals a love of the world and the flesh every bit as clearly as the extravagance of those who already possess it.
2.) Another thinks he is not a worldling because he desires only necessities, food, clothing, and basic provision for himself and his family, and is not after riches or great things. But if your heart is more set on obtaining these modest necessities than on preparing for death and securing the heavenly treasure, you are miserable worldlings still. It was one of Chilo’s sayings that as the touchstone tries gold, so gold tries men’s minds, whether they are good or bad.
The poor man who sets his heart more on a poor and miserable life than on heaven is more inexcusable than the man who sets his heart more on lands and honors than on heaven, though both are slaves of the world and have as yet no treasure in heaven.
Moreover, those who are now so covetous for a little more would, upon getting it, be equally covetous for still a little more. Next would come better clothing and better food; then the house would need repair; then the land would need enlarging; then something more would be needed for the children, and there would never be an end. You think otherwise now, but your hearts deceive you: you do not know them. If you doubt this, judge by the experience of others who were as confident as you that a certain sum would satisfy them, yet when they had it, still wanted more.
This very plea, "I only need a little more," is the common pretense of nearly all the covetous. Lords and princes think themselves in as much necessity as you think yourselves: as they have more, they have more to do with it, and are typically still as much in need as the poor. The question is not how much you desire, but to what use, to what end, and in what order.
3.) Another thinks he is not covetous because he covets nothing that belongs to his neighbor; he imagines that covetousness consists only in desiring what belongs to another. But if you love the world and worldly plenty in a disordered way and crave more, you are covetous worldlings even if you wish it from no other person. The worldly mind and the love of wealth are the sin at the root; the various ways of getting it are only the branches.
4.) Another thinks he is no worldling because he uses no unlawful means to grow rich, only the lawful labor of his calling. The same answer applies. The love of wealth for the satisfaction of the flesh is itself unlawful, whatever the means. And besides, is it not also an unlawful means of getting when you neglect God, neglect your soul, neglect the poor, and shut out other duties for the sake of the world, as you so often do?
5.) Another thinks he is no worldling because he is contented with what he has and craves nothing more, what he has being, as it happens, a full provision for his fleshly desires. But if you over-love the world and delight more in it than in God, you are a worldling even if you desire nothing further. Christ describes as a miserable, worldly fool the one who says, "Soul, take thy ease, eat, drink, and be merry, thou hast much goods laid up for many years" (Luke 12:19–20). To over-love what you have is worldliness just as much as to desire more.
6.) Another thinks he is no worldling because he gives God thanks for what he has and asks for it in prayer. But if you are a lover of the world and make provision for the desires of the flesh, it only aggravates your sin to ask God to serve your fleshly lusts and to thank him for satisfying your sinful desires. Such prayers and thanksgivings are profane and carnal; they are service rendered to your flesh, not to God. It is as if a drunkard or a glutton should beg God to supply his greedy appetite and thank him when it is satisfied; or as if a fornicator should pray God to be a pander to his lusts and thank him for it; or as if a wanton gallant should make fine clothes and gallantry the subject of his prayer and thanksgiving.
7.) Another thinks he is no worldling because he has some thoughts of heaven, and is unwilling to be damned once he can no longer hold the world; and because he prays often, perhaps fasts like the Pharisee twice a week, gives alms regularly, pays tithes, and wrongs no one. But the Pharisees were covetous for all that (Luke 16:14). The question is not whether you think of heaven and do something toward it, but whether it is heaven or earth that you seek first and make the end toward which everything else is ordered. Every worldling knows he must die, and therefore desires heaven at last as a reserve rather than hell. But where are you laying up your treasure, and where are you placing all your happiness and hope? Where is your heart, on earth or in heaven? (Col 3:1–3 Matt 6:20, 21)
The question is not whether you give the occasional alms to quiet your conscience and part with as much as the flesh can spare, as a pig will stop eating once it is full, but whether everything you have is devoted to the will of God, made subject to his service and the saving of your soul, and could be forsaken rather than Christ forsaken.
8.) Another thinks he is not covetous because he is only providing for his children, after all, "he that provideth not for his own, is worse than an infidel." But that text speaks only of providing necessaries for our families and kindred rather than casting them on the church to be maintained. If you so overvalue the world that you think it your children’s happiness to be rich, you are worldly and covetous, both for yourself and for them. The richest and greatest men make provision precisely for their children, so that their posterity may be great and wealthy after them. This makes them more worldly, not less, because they are covetous on behalf of generations yet to come, even after their own death.
9.) Another thinks he is no worldling because he can speak as harshly of covetous men as anyone. But many a person reviles others as covetous while being covetous himself. Indeed, covetous men are most prone to accuse others of covetousness, of selling too dear, buying too cheaply, or giving too little, because they want to get more for themselves. Many preachers, by their reading and learning, may deliver a forceful sermon against worldliness and yet go to hell at last as worldlings themselves. Words are cheap.
10.) Another thinks he is not covetous because he intends to leave much to charitable uses when he dies. I grant that such giving is good, and I wish more would do it. But the flesh itself can spare what it is forced to leave behind when it goes down into the grave. If they could carry their riches with them and enjoy them after death, they would do so without question. To leave what you can no longer keep is no great virtue. The glutton, the drunkard, the whoremonger, and the proud must all abandon their pleasures at the grave. The real question is: do you serve God or the flesh with your riches while you have them? Do you use them to help or to hinder your salvation? Do not deceive yourselves, for God is not mocked.
6. Yet many are falsely accused of covetousness on grounds such as these.
1.) Because they possess much and are rich: the poor tend to take the rich for worldlings. But God does not give to all alike. He puts ten talents into one servant’s hands and only one into another’s; and from those to whom much is entrusted, more will be required. To be entrusted with more than others is no sin, unless that trust is betrayed.
2.) Others are accused as covetous because they do not satisfy the covetous desires of those they deal with, or fail to meet expectations, or do not give where giving would be not a duty but a sin. The buyer calls the seller covetous; the seller calls the buyer covetous, because neither meets the other’s desires. An idle beggar will accuse you of uncharitableness because you will not maintain him in sinful idleness. The proud expect you to help sustain their pride. Drunkards, rioters, and gamblers expect their parents to fund their sin. No one who has anything will escape the charge of covetousness so long as there is another person in the world who covets what he has. Selfishness recognizes no rule but its own desire.
3.) Others are judged covetous because they do not give what they simply do not have. Those who do not know another’s true circumstances will form their own estimate of it; and if that person’s fine appearance or manner, or common reputation, leads people to think him richer than he is, he will be thought covetous because his generosity does not match their expectations.
4.) Others are thought covetous because they are diligent in their callings, thrifty, and careful not to waste anything. But all of this is their duty. Were they lords or princes, idleness and wastefulness would be their sin. God would have all able people labor in their respective callings; and Christ himself, after feeding many thousands by miracle, said, "Gather up the fragments that remain, that nothing be lost." The real question is how they use what they work so hard for and save so carefully. If they use it for God and for charitable purposes, no one takes a more fitting course. The best servant of God is the one who will labor hard and spend sparingly, so as to be the more able to do good.
5.) Others are thought covetous because, to avoid hypocrisy, they give in secret and keep their works of charity from others’ knowledge. These shall have their reward from God; and his wrath shall be the reward of those who presume to censure them.
6.) Others are thought covetous because they lawfully and peaceably seek their legal rights, and will not let the unjust and covetous wrong them at will. It is true that we must sometimes let go of our rights when recovering them would do others more harm than the recovery would do us good. But the laws are not made in vain; nor should we encourage covetousness, theft, and deceit by allowing people to do as they please; nor should we be careless of the talents our Master has entrusted to us; we must not let everyone take them from us to serve their own desires.
Direction 2. Seriously consider your everlasting state, and how much greater matters than riches demand your attention. By faith, look on the endless joy you may have with God, and the endless misery that worldlings must undergo in hell.
There is no true cure for an earthly mind except by showing it the far greater matters it ought to mind, by acquainting it more fully with its own true concerns, with the greater miseries than poverty or need that we must escape, and with the greater good than worldly plenty that we must seek. It is lack of faith that makes men worldlings. They do not see what is in another world. They recite their creed but do not truly believe in the day of judgment, the resurrection of the body, and the life everlasting. There is not one of them who, if he had a single sight of heaven and hell, would not think more lightly of the world than he ever did before, and would not turn his covetous anxiety and toil into a swift and earnest care for his salvation.
If a person heard the joyful praises of the saints and the woeful laments of the damned for even one hour, he would ever after think that he had greater matters to attend to than scraping together a heap of wealth. Remember, you have another world to live in, a far longer life to prepare for, and you must dwell in heaven or hell forever. This is true whether you believe it or not. You have no time but this in which to make all your preparation; and as you believe, live, and labor now, so it will go with you for all eternity. These are matters worthy of your care.
Can you find it worthwhile to make such a stir here in the dust, to care and labor for a thing of nothing, while you have such things as these to care for, and a work of such transcendent consequence to do? Can a person who understands what heaven and hell are find room for needless things, or time for so much unnecessary work?
Providing for your salvation is a work God has made far more your own responsibility than providing for the flesh. When he speaks of your body, he says, "Take no thought for your life, what you shall eat or drink, nor for your body, what you shall put on: for your Father knoweth that ye have need of all these things" (Matt 6:25, 32); "Be careful for nothing" (Phil 4:6); "Cast all your care upon him, for he careth for you" (1 Pet 5:7).
But when he speaks of your salvation, he commands you to "work it out with fear and trembling" (Phil 2:12), to "give diligence to make your calling and election sure" (2 Pet 1:10), to "strive to enter in at the strait gate" (Matt 7:13; Luke 13:24), and to "Labour not for the meat that perisheth, but for that which endureth to everlasting life" (John 6:27), that is, to "Seek first the kingdom of God and his righteousness, and all these things shall be added to you" (Matt 6:33). Socrates said that the man who needs least is nearest to the gods.
Look up to heaven and remember that there is your home and there are your hopes, or else you are forever undone. It is for that you must care and labor. Believe sincerely that you must dwell forever in heaven or hell according to the preparation you make here; consider this as befits a rational person; and then try to remain a worldling and covetous if you can. Riches will seem dust and chaff to you if you truly believe and consider your everlasting state.
Write on the doors of your shop and your room: "I must be in heaven or hell forever", or, "This is the time on which my endless life depends", and every time you read it, your covetousness should feel a blow to its heart. O blinded mortals, who love like worms to dwell in earth! If only God would give you an eye of faith to foresee your end and where you must dwell for all eternity, what a change it would make upon your earthly minds!
Either faith or sense will be your guide. Nothing but reason sanctified by faith can govern sense. Remember that you are not a beast with no life to live but this one. You have a rational, immortal soul, made by God for higher things, for God himself, to wonder at him, love him, serve him, and enjoy him. If an angel were to dwell for a time in flesh, would he turn an earthworm and forget his higher life of glory? You are like an incarnate angel, and may be equal with the angels when you are freed from this sinful flesh. Beg God for a heavenly light and a heavenly mind; look often into the Word of God, which tells you where you must be forever; and worldliness will vanish away in shame.
Direction 3. Remember how short a time you must keep and enjoy the wealth you have acquired. How quickly you will be stripped of everything. Can you keep it once you have it? Can you make a covenant with death, so that it will not call your soul away? You know already that your time is short, and the world is merely your inn or place of passage, and a narrow grave for your flesh to rot in is all you can keep of your largest possessions, except what you lay up in heaven by spending it in obedience to God.
How short is life! How quickly gone! You are almost dead and gone already. What are a few days or a few years more? Will you make such a great effort for so short a life, and make such careful provision for so short a stay? And how uncertain your time is, as well as short. You cannot say what world you will be in tomorrow. Remember, you must die! You must die! You must quickly die! You do not know how soon. Breathe a few more breaths, and you are gone.
And yet can you be covetous and drown your soul in earthly cares? Do you seriously read your Savior’s warning? Is it not spoken as if to you? "Thou fool, this night thy soul shall be required of thee, then, whose shall those things be which thou hast provided? So is every one that layeth up riches for himself, and is not rich towards God." (Luke 12:20–21) Remember Gehazi, Achan, Judas, Ananias and Sapphira, Demetrius, and Demas. Cicero could not understand what an old man’s covetousness means: can anything be more absurd, he asks, than to seek the more provision for the journey the less of the road that remains?
If you are rich today and in another world tomorrow, would not poverty have served you just as well? Distracted soul! Do you make so great a matter of whether you have much or little for so brief a time, yet take no care at all about where you will be, or what you will have, for all eternity?
Do you say you will cast that care on God? I tell you, he will make you care yourself, and care again, before he will save you. And why can you not cast the care of smaller matters on him, when he commands it? Is it so great a matter whether you are rich or poor, when you are moving so fast into another world where these things have no significance? Tell me: if you were certain you must die tomorrow, or next month, or next year, would you not be more indifferent to whether you are rich or poor, and attend more to greater things?
Then you would share the apostle’s mind: "We look not at the things which are seen, but at the things which are not seen: for the things which are seen are temporal, but the things which are not seen are eternal." Our eye of faith should be so fixed on invisible, eternal things that we hardly have leisure or inclination to regard the things that are visible and temporal. A man going to execution hardly glances at the bustle of streets and shops as he passes by, because these things little concern him in his departing condition. And how little do the wealth and honors of the world concern a soul passing into another world, not knowing whether it may be this very night. Keep your wealth then, or take it with you, if you can.
Direction 4. Labor to feel your greatest needs, which worldly wealth cannot supply. You have sinned against God, and money will not buy your pardon. You have incurred his displeasure, and money will not reconcile him to you. You stand condemned to everlasting misery by the law, and money will not pay your ransom. You are dead in sin, polluted, and held captive by the flesh, and money will sooner increase your bondage than deliver you. Your conscience is ready to tear your heart for your willful folly and contempt of grace, and money will not bribe it into silence. Judas brought back his money and hanged himself, once conscience was merely awakened. Money will not enlighten a blinded mind, nor soften a hard heart, nor humble a proud heart, nor justify a guilty soul. It will not ward off fever or consumption, nor ease the gout, or the stone, or the toothache. It will not hold off ghastly death; you must die, though you owned the whole world.
Look up to God and remember that you are wholly in his hands. Consider whether he will love or favor you for your wealth. Look toward the day of judgment and consider whether money will bring you through it, or whether the rich fare better than the poor.
Direction 5. Be often with those who are sick and dying. Mark what all their riches do for them, what regard they then have for the world, and how the world deals with all in the end. You will see that riches forsake every person in the hour of their greatest necessity and distress, when they would cry out to friends, to wealth, to honor, if they had any hope: "If you will ever help me, let it be now; if you will ever do anything for me, save me from death and from the wrath of God!" But such cries would be wholly in vain. Then, O then! one drop of mercy, one spark of grace, the smallest well-grounded hope of heaven, would be worth more than the empire of Caesar or Alexander.
Is this not true, sinner? Do you not know it to be true? And yet will you cheat and betray your soul? Is not that best now which will be best then? And is not that of little value now which will be so little regarded then? Do you not think men are wiser at that hour than now? Will you pay so much and labor so hard for what will do you so little good, for what you will value so little when you finally have it?
Does not all the world cry out at last about the deceitfulness of riches, the vanity of pleasure and prosperity on earth, and the destructiveness of worldly cares? Does not your conscience tell you that when you come to die, you are likely to feel exactly the same? And yet will you not be warned in time? All the contentment and pleasure of your abundance and prosperity will then be past, and when it is past, it is nothing.
Will you venture on everlasting woe and cast away everlasting joy, for what is today a dream and shadow, and tomorrow, or very shortly, will be nothing? Chilo said that loss is to be chosen rather than shameful gain, for the one is a grief only once, the other always.
The poorest men will stand equal with you at last. And which will be sweeter in the end: honest poverty, or excessively loved wealth? How gladly then would you have been without your wealth, if only you might have been without its sin and guilt! How gladly then would you wish to die the death of the poorest saint! Do you think that poverty or riches are more likely to make a man reluctant to die? Which more commonly troubles the conscience of a dying man? Look to the end, and live as you would wish to die, set most value on that now, and seek that now, which you know you will value most at last, when full experience has made you wise.
Direction 6. Remember that riches make it much harder for a man to be saved, and that love of this world is the most common cause of men’s damnation. This is certainly true, even though poverty has its own temptations and the poor far outnumber the rich. Even the poor may be ruined by their love of the wealth and abundance they never obtain; people may perish for over-loving the world who never once prospered in it. Socrates said that wealth and noble birth have nothing honorable in them, and that every evil springs from them.
If you believe Christ, the point is beyond dispute. He says, "How hardly shall they that have riches enter into the kingdom of God? For it is easier for a camel to go through a needle’s eye, than for a rich man to enter into the kingdom of God. And they that heard it said, Who then can be saved? And he said, The things which are impossible with men, are possible with God." (Luke 18:24–27) "But woe unto you that are rich, for ye have received your consolation: woe unto you that are full, for ye shall hunger." (Luke 6:24–25)
Make plain sense of these and many like texts, and you can gather no less than this from them: riches make the way to heaven far harder, and the salvation of the rich is proportionally more difficult and rare than that of other men. Paul says, "Not many wise men after the flesh, not many mighty, not many noble are called." (1 Cor 1:26) And those who love riches, though they are poor, must remember: "The love of money is the root of all evil." (1 Tim 6:10) And again, "Love not the world, nor the things that are in the world: for if any man love the world, the love of the Father is not in him." (1 John 2:15)
Do you believe that here lies the danger of your soul, and yet can you so love, so choose, and so seek the world? Would you have your salvation made more difficult, doubtful, and humanly impossible? You would rather live where few die young than where most die young; where sickness is rare rather than common. If you were ill, you would choose the physician, the medicines, and the regimen that cure most people, not those from which few recover. If the road were beset with thieves, you would take the route from which most travelers escape, not the one from which few do.
And yet, so long as the flesh is pleased, you will choose the way to heaven from which fewest escape, and the condition of life that makes your salvation hardest and most doubtful. Does your conscience tell you this is wisely done? I know that if God places riches in your hand through your birth or his blessing on your honest labor, you must not throw away your master’s talents merely because he is strict; by holy use of them you may further his service and your salvation. But that is no reason to over-love riches, or to desire and seek so great a danger. Believe Christ with your whole heart, and it will quench your love of riches.
Direction 7. Remember that the more you have, the more you have to give account for. If the day of judgment fills you with dread, you should not make it more dreadful by enlarging your own accounts. If you desired riches only for the service of your Lord, and used them for him, and can honestly report that you laid them out not for needless bodily pleasure or pride, but to equip yourself, your household, and others for his service, and employed them as closely as you could according to his will, then you may expect the reward of good and faithful servants. But if you desired and used them for your own pride and pleasure while you lived, and for the benefit of your posterity or kindred after your death, dropping only insignificant crumbs to God, you will find then that Mammon was an unprofitable master, and that godliness with contentment would have been far greater gain.
Direction 8. Remember what a dear price men pay when they hinder their own salvation and enlarge their danger and their accounts. What a quantity of precious time the lovers of this world waste upon it, time that could have been used to gain wisdom and grace, and to make their calling and election sure. If you had believed that the gain of holy wisdom is as much better than the gaining of gold as Solomon says (Prov 3), you would have spent much of that time laboring to understand the Scriptures and preparing for your endless life.
How many unnecessary thoughts have you squandered on the world, which could better have been directed to your weightier concerns! How many cares, vexations, and disordered passions does it cost men to overload themselves with worldly provision! They are like a foolish traveler who, having a day’s journey ahead, spends the entire day gathering up a load of food, clothing, and money, more than he can carry, for fear of falling short on the way. Or like a foolish runner who has a race to run for his life and spends the very time he should be running in gathering a burden of supposed necessities. As Plutarch observes (On Tranquility of Mind), Alexander wept because he was not lord of the world, while Crates, with nothing but a wallet and a threadbare cloak, spent his whole life in mirth and joy, as though it were a continual holiday.
All the while you have God’s work to do, your soul to attend to, and judgment to prepare for, yet you are tiring and vexing yourselves over unnecessary things, as though your highest ambition were to say, in hell, that you died rich. "Godliness with contentment is great gain: for we brought nothing into this world, and it is certain that we can carry nothing out. And having food and raiment, let us be therewith content: but they that will be rich, fall into temptation and a snare, and into many foolish and hurtful lusts, which drown men in destruction and perdition: for the love of money is the root of all evil, which while some coveted after, they have erred (or been seduced) from the faith, and pierced themselves through with many sorrows." (1 Tim 6:5–10) Piercing sorrows in this life, and damnation in the next, are a very dear price to pay for money.
For Christ himself says, "What shall it profit a man to gain all the world, and lose his own soul? Or what shall a man give in exchange for his soul?" (Mark 8:36–37) That is: what money or price will recover the soul, if a man loses it through the love of gain? "He that is greedy of gain troubleth his own house, but he that hateth gifts shall live." (Prov 15:27) Surely you can see that a godly man, contented with his daily bread, enjoys a far sweeter and quieter life and death than a self-tormenting worldling. "Better is little with the fear of the Lord, than great treasure and trouble therewith." (Prov 15:16)
Direction 9. Look often at the life of Christ on earth, and see how powerfully he condemned worldliness by his example. Did he choose to be a prince or a lord? Did he seek great possessions, lands, money, magnificent buildings, gallant attendants, or lavish provisions? His housing you may read of: "Foxes have holes, and the birds of the air have nests, but the Son of man hath not where to lay his head." (Matt 8:20) His clothing you may read of at his crucifixion, when the soldiers divided it among themselves. As for money, he was reduced to sending Peter to catch a fish to find a coin for their tribute.
If Christ scraped and cared for riches, then you should do so as well. If he counted that the happiest life, you should think so too. But if he despised it, then despise it. If his whole life was directed toward giving you the most perfect example of contempt for all worldly prosperity, then learn from that example, if you take him for your Savior, and if you have any care for yourself. "Though he was rich, yet for our sakes he became poor, that you through his poverty might be rich."
Direction 10. Think on the example of the primitive Christians, the very best of Christ’s servants, and see how it condemns worldliness. Those who by a miracle in Christ’s name could restore limbs to the lame nevertheless said to the beggar, "Silver and gold have we none." Those who had possessions sold them and laid the money at the apostles’ feet; they held all things in common, to show that faith overcomes the world by despising it, by placing it entirely under the rule of charity, and by devoting it wholly to God. Read whether the apostles lived in sumptuous houses with great attendants and worldly plenty and prosperity, and the same holds for all the rest.
Chrysostom notes that his enemies charged him with many crimes, but never with covetousness or wantonness. And so it was with Christ and his enemies.
Direction 11. Remember the ends for which all worldly things were made and given to you, and what a happy advantage you may draw from them, by renouncing them as provision for your lusts, and by devoting yourself and them entirely to God. The use of their sweetness is to draw your souls to taste, by faith, the sweetness of heaven. They are the mirror for souls still clothed in flesh, who are not yet admitted to see spiritual things face to face. As Paul Scaliger observes, in our heavenly country God is the mirror in which the creatures shine, while here on the way the creatures are the mirror in which the Creator is seen.
They are the provision for our bodies, our traveling equipment and aids, our inns and refreshing company along the way. They are some of God’s tokens of love, some of the lesser pieces of his coinage, and they bear his image and superscription. They are drops from the rivers of eternal pleasure, sent to tell the mind through the senses how good and how worthy of love the giver is, and what higher delights await the soul, and to point us toward the better things these foretell.
They are messengers from heaven, bearing witness to our Father’s care and love, calling us to thankfulness, love, and duty, and bearing witness against sin and binding us more firmly to obedience. They are the first volume of the Word of God, the first book man was set to read, in order to become fully acquainted with his Maker. As the Scripture we read and hear is the chariot of the Spirit by which it makes its approach to the soul, so the delights of sight, taste, smell, and hearing were appointed as an ordinary pathway for the swift access of heavenly love and sweetness to the heart, so that upon the first experience of the goodness and sweetness of a created thing, a deep impression of the goodness of God might straightway be conveyed to the soul by a due progression.
The creatures are the letters of God’s book, seen by the outward eye, and their meaning, the love of our great Creator, ought at once to be perceived by the mind. No letter should ever be looked upon except for its meaning; no creature ever seen, tasted, heard, or felt in any delightful quality, without a sense of the love of God. As the touch of the hand upon the strings of a lute produces the melody, so God’s touch upon our hearts through his mercies should at once tune them into love, gratitude, and praise.
They are the tools by which we must do much of our Master’s work. They are means by which we may refresh our brethren, express our love for one another, and show our love to our Lord and Master in the persons of his servants. They are our Master’s capital, which we must trade with, and by improving which no less a reward than that of endless happiness may be attained.
These are the uses for which God gives us outward mercies. Love them in this way, delight in them, use them in this way, and do not hold back; indeed, seek them in this way and be thankful for them. But when creatures have been given for so excellent a purpose, will you debase them all by making them merely the fuel of your lusts and the provisions for your flesh? Will you love and dote on them for these base reasons while utterly neglecting their noblest use? You are just like children who cry for books and can never have enough, but only to play with them because they are fine, and when they are set to learn and read them, they cry just as much because they have no love for it. Or like someone who spends his life and labor obtaining the finest clothes, only to dress his dogs and horses with them, while he himself goes naked and will not wear them.
Even Dionysius the tyrant was generous to philosophers. Diogenes Laertius records in his life of Plato that Dionysius gave Plato above fourscore talents, and much to Aristippus and many more, and that he offered much to many philosophers who refused it. So did Croesus.
Direction 12. Remember that God has promised to provide for you, and that you will lack nothing that is good for you, if you will live above these worldly things and seek first his kingdom and his righteousness. Can you not trust his promise? If you truly believe that he is God, that he is true, and that his particular providence extends to the very numbering of your hairs, you will surely trust him rather than your own foresight and industry. Do you think his provision is not better for you than your own? All your own care cannot keep you alive an hour, nor can it prosper any of your labors, if he is provoked to blast them. And if you are not content with his provision, nor willing to submit to the disposal of his love and wisdom, you offend God and provoke him to leave you to the fruits of your own care and diligence, and then you will find that it would have been far wiser to have trusted God.
Direction 13. Think often on the dreadful importance and effects of the love of riches, or a worldly mind.
Look at the face of this calamitous world and inquire into the causes of all the oppression, robbery, cruelty, and inhumanity that have made men so like devils. Look into the corrupted, torn churches and inquire into the cause of their contentions, divisions, usurpations, malignity, and cruelty against each other. You will find that pride and worldliness are the causes of it all.
1. It is a most certain sign of a state of death and misery wherever it holds the upper hand. It is the departure of the heart from God to creatures. Consider the malice of it as described above. Good men have been overtaken by serious sins, but it is hard to find where Scripture calls any of them covetous. A heart secretly clinging most to this present world and its prosperity is the very killing sin of every hypocrite, indeed, of all ungodly men.
2. Worldliness makes the Word unprofitable, and keeps men from believing, repenting, and returning to God, and from giving serious attention to the everlasting world. What hinders the conversion of sinners so much as the love and cares of earthly things? They cannot serve God and mammon; their treasure and their hearts cannot be chiefly both in heaven and on earth. Those who love this world will not yield to the terms of the gospel; they will not forsake all for a treasure in heaven. In short, as you have heard, the love of money is the root of all evil, and the love of the Father is not in those who love the world.
When men of a proud and worldly mind have by fraud, favor, and simony usurped the pastorship of the churches to suit their own minds and ends, they turn it into a malignant domination; the carnal, worldly part of the church becomes the great enemy and persecutor of the spiritual part; and the fleshly hypocrite, as Cain against Abel, is filled with envy against the serious believer, out of the bitter displeasure of his mind that his own deceitful sacrifice is less regarded.
What covetousness has done to advance the pretended holy catholic church of Rome I will give you now in the words of an abbot and chronicler of their own, the Abbot of Ursperg, in his Chronicle: "Scarcely a bishopric, or any ecclesiastical dignity, or even a parish church, has been left that has not become the matter of a lawsuit, and the case itself brought to Rome, but never with an empty hand."
"Rejoice, our mother Rome, for the floodgates of the treasures of the earth are opened, that rivers and heaps of money may flow to you in great abundance. Be glad over the iniquity of the sons of men, for a price is given you in recompense for such great evils. Be merry over discord, your helper, for it has burst out of the pit of the infernal abyss, that many rewards of money may be heaped up for you. You have what you always thirsted for; sing your song, for you have conquered the world by the wickedness of men and not by your religion. It is not their devotion or a pure conscience that draws men to you, but the committing of manifold crimes and the settling of lawsuits, bought with a price."
Fortunatus Galindas, speaking of Pope Paul V and his love for the Jesuits for helping him to money, says that among such men it counts for far more to be zealous and skilled in getting money than in getting souls. Though they have taken upon themselves the care of souls redeemed by the blood of Christ, they either do not know what a soul is or value a man’s soul no more than a fish’s, having heard, I suppose, some rumor that their office is a kind of fishing. To such men, he says, one would be more welcome who reported that he had found, with Paracelsus, the soul of gold, than the soul of the Elector of Saxony.
John of Salisbury says the same of the monks of his day: the more powerful and the richer men are, the more easily they are discharged by absolution once favor or payment has been received; and, taking other men’s sins upon their own shoulders, they order that whatever those men lament having committed shall be discharged by tunics and dark penitential garments. And if you speak against them, you are called an enemy of religion and an assailant of the truth.
3. It destroys holy meditation and spiritual conversation, turning the thoughts to worldly things. It corrupts prayer and makes it merely a means of serving the flesh, and so makes it offensive to God.
4. It is the great hindrance to necessary preparation for death and judgment, stealing away the heart and time until it is too late.
5. It is the great cause of contentions even among the closest relatives, and the cause of wars and national calamities, and of the woeful divisions and persecutions of the church, when a worldly generation concludes that their worldly interest engages them against self-denying, spiritual principles, practices, and people.
6. It is the great cause of all the injustice, oppression, and cruelty that rages in the world. People would do as they would be done by, were it not for the love of money. It makes men treacherous and false to all their friends and commitments; no vows to God nor obligations to men will hold a lover of the world. The world is his god, and his worldly interest is his word and law.
7. It is the great destroyer of charity and good works. So little is done for God and the poor because the love of the world forbids it.
8. It disorders and profanes families, and betrays the souls of children and servants to the devil. It drives out prayer, the reading of Scripture, good books, and all serious speech about the life to come, because hearts are taken up with the world and have no appetite for anything beyond the provisions of the flesh. Even the Lord’s own day cannot be kept for holy works, nor any duty performed, without the world intruding and diverting the mind.
9. It tempts men to sin against their own knowledge, to forsake the truth, to align themselves with whichever side is rising, and to save their bodies and estates whatever becomes of their souls. It is the very price the devil pays for souls. With this he bought the soul of Judas, who went to the Pharisees with "What will you give me, and I will deliver him to you." With this he attempted Christ himself: "All these will I give thee, if thou wilt fall down and worship me" (Matt 4:9). It is the cause of apostasy and unfaithfulness to God, and it is the price for which sinners sell their God, their conscience, and their salvation.
10. It deprives the soul of holy communion with God and comfort from him, of all foretaste of the life to come, and finally of heaven itself. Because the love of the world keeps out the love of God and heaven, it necessarily keeps out the hopes and comforts that should arise from holy love. It would do much to cure the love of money and of the world if you understood how ruinous a sin it truly is.
Christ’s sheep-mark is plainest on the sheep that are shorn; when the fleece grows long, the mark wears out.
Direction 14. Remember how base a sin covetousness is, and how it dishonors and degrades the human mind. If earth is baser than heaven, and money baser than God, then an earthly mind is baser than a heavenly mind, as the serpent’s feeding on dust is a baser life than that of angels, who spend themselves in wonder at the Most Holy God, in obeying him, and in praising him.
Direction 15. Call yourself to a daily reckoning over how you use everything God has committed to your trust, and test whether you could bear to hear that account read at the judgment. If you made a habit of sitting in daily judgment on yourself, as one who truly believes in the judgment of God, it would make you more careful to use what you have well than to acquire more. It would also quench your thirst for wealth and prosperity, when you reflected that you must give so strict an account of it. The flesh itself will desire wealth less when it finds it may not freely enjoy it.
Victor of Vita writes of Eugenius the bishop that money was never proved to have stayed with him, unless perhaps it was offered at such an hour as when the sun, finishing its daily course, was giving place to the darkness of night. And Plutarch records that Plato compared our life to a game at tables: we may wish for a good throw, but whatever it is, we must play it as well as we can.
Direction 16. When you find your covetousness most fierce and dangerous, resolve to cross it most sharply, and give more to pious or charitable uses than you otherwise would. A man has good reason to flee furthest from the sin he is most in danger of. And actions tend to strengthen their corresponding habits: obeying covetousness increases it, while opposing and displeasing it destroys it. This course will bring your covetousness to despair of ever gaining what it craves, and so it will sit down and abandon the pursuit. It is an open protest against every covetous desire, and an effectual kind of repentance, a wise and honest way of disarming sin and turning its own impulses against itself to its own destruction. Use this course often enough, and covetousness will decide that silence is wisdom.
Direction 17. Above all, take heed that you do not try to reconcile God and mammon, mixing heaven and earth as your happiness, or dream that you may keep heaven as a reserve at the end, after the world has been loved as your best good for as long as you could hold it. Nothing defends worldliness so well as a deceiving hope that you hold it only in a subdued, pardoned degree, and that you are not really a worldling when you are. And nothing sustains that hope so much as telling yourself that heaven must at last be your refuge and full felicity, and therefore you do something for it on the side. But is not the world more loved, more sought, more delighted in, and held more tightly? Does it not have more of your heart, your delight, your desire, and your industry? If you cannot let go of everything for heaven and forsake all this world for a treasure above, you cannot be Christ’s true disciples.
Direction 18. If you would ever overcome the love of the world, your greatest care must be to mortify the flesh, for the world is desired only as provision for the flesh. A mortified person has no need of what is a sensualist’s felicity. Quench your dropsical, feverish thirst, and you will not make such a clamor for drink. Cure the disease that inflames your appetite; that is the safest and least costly way of satisfying it. Then, when you look on other men’s wealth and gallantry, you will be thankful to God that you have no need of those things.
Petrarch says that whoever is rich in virtues lacks nothing, and that the lack of them is what makes men truly wretched and therefore most in need of pity. Socrates, when he looked at the multitude of things for sale in the market, would often say to himself, "How many things there are that I do not need!" And Petrarch asks: Have you lost your money? It is well, if it has not lost you, as it has already lost many of its owners. Be glad that what might have infected you has been taken away, and that you have passed unharmed through the danger.
You will reflect what a trouble, a burden, and an interruption to your better work and comfort it would be to have as much land, as many servants, goods, responsibilities, and people to manage as rich men have, and how much better you can enjoy God and yourself in a quieter, more retired way of life. But more on this in the next part.
If people only knew how much of an ungodly, damnable condition consists in the love of the world; how much it is the enemy of souls; how much of our religion consists in contempt and conquest of it; what it means that they renounced the world in their baptismal covenant; and how many millions the love of the world will damn forever, they would not make such a stir over nothing, spending all their days providing for their perishing flesh. They would not think those happiest who are richest, nor boast of their heart’s desire and bless the covetous whom the Lord abhors (Ps 10:3).
They would not regard it as so small a sin that Christians should not so much as name it (Eph 5:3), save in detestation. For God has determined that the covetous shall not inherit the kingdom of God (1 Cor 6:10; Eph 5:5), and a Christian must not so much as eat with them (1 Cor 5:11). Did Christ speak in vain when he said, "Take heed, and beware of covetousness" (Luke 12:15)? "Woe to him that coveteth an evil covetousness to his house, that he may set his nest on high, that he may be delivered from the power of evil" (Hab 2:9).
What devoted servants the world has, who serve it so diligently, so constantly, and at so steep a price, knowing already that beyond a little transitory, deluding pleasure, it will repay them with nothing but everlasting shame! How wonderful is the deceiving power of such an empty shadow, or rather, how wonderful is the folly of mankind! So many ages have been deceived before us, and almost everyone at death confesses that the world did nothing but deceive them, yet so many still are deceived and take no warning from so vast a world of examples.
I conclude with (Heb 13:5): "Let your conversation be without covetousness; and be content with such things as ye have: for he hath said, I will never leave thee, nor forsake thee."
CHAPTER 3
DIRECTIONS AGAINST THE MASTER SIN, SENSUALITY, FLESH-PLEASING, OR VOLUPTUOUSNESS
I will be briefer here than the subject might otherwise demand, because I have already treated it at length in my Treatise of Self-denial. Before we come to the particular Directions, however, it is necessary to understand the nature and evil of the sin in question. I will therefore address the following: 1. What is meant by "flesh" in this context. 2. What kind of flesh-pleasing is unlawful, and what sensuality consists in. 3. What the malignity of this sin consists in. 4. Answers to some objections. 5. The signs of this sin. 6. The counterfeits of the opposite virtue. 7. And the false signs that lead some to be wrongly accused, whether by themselves or by others.
First. Because you will find in the writings that pass between the Protestants and the Papists that it has become a controversy whether "flesh" in Scripture, where this sin is discussed, means the body itself or the soul insofar as it is unregenerate, I will first briefly settle the question.
When we speak of the unregenerate part of a person, we do not mean that the soul is divided into two parts, one regenerate and the other not. Rather, as a half-blind eye contains both light and darkness in the same organ, so it is with a soul that is regenerate only partially, that is, only in an imperfect degree. By "the unregenerate part" we mean the whole soul considered in relation to what remains unregenerate in it.
The word "flesh" in its primary sense is taken from the bodily part as such, without reference to sin. Beyond that, it refers to the whole body as distinct from the soul. But when Scripture addresses sin and duty, the word is used in three progressively broader senses:
1. Sometimes it refers to the sensitive appetite, not as sinful in itself, but as desiring what God has obliged reason to refuse.
2. More frequently it refers to this same sensitive appetite as disordered and therefore sinful in its own desires.
3. Most frequently it refers to both the disordered sensitive appetite itself and the rational powers insofar as they are corrupted by it, sinfully disposed either to obey it or to follow sensual things inordinately.
Even in this third sense, the name "flesh" is taken primarily from the sensual appetite itself (as diseased), and only secondarily, by extension, from the rational powers.
To understand this, consider the following points.
1.) The appetite itself might, even in a state of innocence, desire a forbidden object. It was not the appetite that was forbidden, but the act of the will in desiring it or the act of taking it. A man in a fever who thirsts for more drink than is lawful has not sinned by the thirst; it is the practical act of willing or the act of drinking that constitutes sin, because those are what God forbids. The thirst itself is not in our power to extinguish. That Adam had an appetite for the forbidden fruit was not his sin; his sin was that his will obeyed his appetite and his mouth ate.
The appetite and sensitive nature are from God, and in the order of nature come before the law. God made us human beings before he gave us laws, and the law does not command us to alter what he made us to be, nor anything else that is naturally beyond our power. The sin belongs to the will and the executive powers, which do evil by obeying an innocent appetite. Because the appetite is necessary and not free, God does not direct his commands and prohibitions to it directly, but to the reason and the free will.
2.) Since the fall, however, the appetite itself has been corrupted and has become disordered, more violent, impetuous, and unruly than it was in innocence, owing to the unhappy disorders that have befallen the body itself. We know from experience that a person who habitually practices wholesome temperance has nothing like the fierce internal struggles between appetite and reason (given good health) that are found in those who are either diseased or accustomed to obeying their appetites. If habit and health can make so great a difference, we have reason to believe that the depravation of nature by the fall did far more.
3.) This disordered appetite is sin by participation, insofar as the appetite may be said to be free by participation, though not in itself, because it is the appetite of a rational, free agent. Sin, in its proper form, resides first in the will; yet the will is not the sole subject of sin (though it is the primary one). Rather, the whole person is the subject of sin insofar as his acts are voluntary. The will commands the other faculties, and those acts are voluntary which the will either commands or fails to restrain when it could and should. Lying is a voluntary sin of the whole person; the tongue shares in the guilt. The will could have prevented the disorder that entered the appetite. If a drunkard or a glutton stirs up a venereous, inordinate appetite in himself, that lust is his sin because he voluntarily provoked it.
4.) Yet those increases of disorder that people stir up in any appetite through their own habitual sins are more aggravated and more dangerous to the soul than the degree of disorder that is simply the fruit of original sin.
5.) This disorderedness of the sensitive appetite, together with the mere absence of rectitude in the mind and will, is sufficient to produce actual sin. If the horses are headstrong, the mere weakness, drowsiness, negligence, or absence of the coachman is enough to contribute to the coach’s overturning. In the same way, even if reason and will had no positive inclinations toward evil or sensual objects, the mere absence of enough light and love of higher things to restrain the sensual appetite leaves that appetite with sufficient positive inclination toward forbidden things to ruin the soul through actual sin.
6.) Yet, though it is a great controversy among theologians, I think that in the rational powers themselves there are positive, habitual, disordered inclinations toward sensual and forbidden things. As a matter of observable fact, the reason of the proud and the covetous does devise and often approve their sin, and the will embraces it. Moreover, these things happen so steadily, in a continuous stream of action from the whole person, that it seems evident that the very faculties which consistently run out in such strong and constant action are themselves the subjects of much of the inclining and positive habit. If this is true of additionally acquired sin, it is likely that it was so in original sin as well.
7.) Though sin is formally seated first in the will, it is materially first in the sensitive appetite, at least this sin of flesh-pleasing or sensuality is. The flesh, or sensitive part, is the first to desire; it becomes sin only insofar as that desiring is voluntary.
8.) All of this together tells us further that the word "flesh" signifies the sensual inclinations of the whole person, but first and principally the corrupted sensual appetite, and the mind and will’s concurrence (whether privative or positive) only secondarily, as they fall in with sense. The appetite: first, forestalls reason; second, resists reason; and third, at last corrupts and entices reason and will to become its servants and suppliers.
That the name "flesh" primarily signifies the sensitive appetite itself is evident in the very origin of the word. Why else would the habits or vices of the rational powers be called "flesh" rather than "spirit" or anything else? If the designation were purely a matter of object, they should equally be called "the world," since the world is their object. A certain rule holds: that faculty is most predominant in a person whose object is made his chief end. Since sensitive pleasures are made the happiness and end of the unsanctified, it follows that the sensitive faculties are predominant; and because those faculties are called "flesh" (by the nearest figure), the mind takes its name from them by extension.
The Scriptures confirm this plainly. I cannot recall a single passage in the Old Testament where there is any real probability that "flesh" refers only to the rational soul as unregenerate.
In Matthew 16:17, "Flesh and blood hath not revealed this unto thee" means: mortal man has not revealed it.
In Matthew 26:41, "The spirit is willing, but the flesh is weak" means: your bodies are weak and resist the willingness of your souls, sinful habits are not what is here called weak.
In John 3:6, "That which is born of the flesh is flesh" means: natural generation can produce only natural humanity, called "flesh" from its visible part, and not the spiritual life, which nature is now without.
In Romans 7:25, "With my flesh I serve the law of sin" means: with my sensitive powers, and my mind insofar as it is held captive to them.
In Romans 8:1 and 8:5, flesh and spirit are frequently contrasted: "They that are of the flesh, mind the things of the flesh, etc." means those in whom the sensitive interest and appetite are predominant. The body is mentioned here as well as the flesh (Rom 8:10, 8:11, and 8:13). The mind is included, but as serving the flesh and its interest.
In Galatians 5:16, 5:17, and 5:19, flesh and spirit are opposed in the same manner.
In 2 Peter 2:18, the lusts of the flesh are mentioned in this same sense. So also in Ephesians 2:3, Romans 7:18, Romans 13:14, 1 Corinthians 5:5, and 1 Peter 2:11, where there is mention of "fleshly lusts, which fight against the spirit," and of "fleshly wisdom, making provision for the flesh."
In Colossians 2:18, there is even the expression "a fleshly mind," which is simply a mind deceived and made subservient to the flesh. In all or most of these passages, therefore, it is the flesh itself, the sensitive interest and appetite, that is the primary referent; and in some, the mind appears only as subservient to it.
It matters greatly that this be rightly understood, or you may be tempted to imitate the Libertines, who think the flesh or sensitive part is capable of no moral good or evil, and who therefore conclude that, all its actions being morally indifferent, we may be unconcerned about them and look only to the higher powers. Others, who think that Scripture by "flesh" means only the rational soul as unregenerate, go on to cherish the flesh itself, pamper it, and feed its unruly lusts, never doing anything to tame the body, while they pray daily that God would destroy the flesh within them, that is, their sinful habits of reason and will. So they cherish the cause, or neglect a chief part of the cure. On the other side, some Papists who look only at the body as their enemy are much taken up with fastings and bodily exercises, while they neglect the mortifying of their carnal minds.
Second. How far flesh-pleasing is a sin I will set out distinctly in the following propositions.
1. The pleasing or displeasing of the sensitive appetite, considered in itself, is neither sin nor duty, neither good nor evil, except as some law of God commands or forbids it, which has not been done absolutely.
2. To please the flesh by forbidden things is undoubtedly a sin; and so is to displease it by forbidden things. Therefore the whole matter is not simply that what pleases the flesh must not be something forbidden.
3. To overvalue the pleasing of the flesh is a sin; and to prefer it above the pleasing of God and the holy preparations for heaven is the state of carnality and ungodliness, and the common cause of the damnation of souls. The delight of the flesh and senses is a natural good, and the natural desire of it in itself is, as noted, neither vice nor virtue. But when this small natural good is preferred over the greater spiritual, moral, or eternal good, this is the sin of the carnal mind, which is threatened with death (Rom 8:1, 5–8, 13).
4. To purchase the pleasing of the flesh at too high a price, such as the loss of time, or with care and trouble beyond its worth, and to be too intent on making provision to please it, shows that it is overvalued and is the sin forbidden in Romans 13:14.
5. When any desire of the flesh is inordinate, immoderate, or irregular in its matter, manner, quantity, quality, or season, it is a sin to satisfy that inordinate desire.
6. When pleasing the flesh too much pampers it, cherishes filthy lusts or any other sin, and is not required on some other account such as doing greater good, it is a sin. But if life requires it, lust must be subdued by other means. As Petrarch writes, if the body is a sufficient instrument for the soul dwelling in it, its strength is enough, for nature made the body to serve the soul, and no one is so enslaved to the body as not to know this. If the body fulfills its proper function, why accuse it or demand more of it? (De remediis, book 2, dialogue 2.) Bodily strength, as Petrarch also says elsewhere, is the strength of a prison (De remediis, book 1, dialogue 5). When Plato saw someone over-pampering his body, he said, "Why do you make your prison so strong?", as recorded by Marsilio Ficino in his Life of Plato.
7. When pleasing the flesh harms it by impairing health, and so makes the body less fit for duty, it is a sin. Nearly all intemperance tends to breed disease; and God commands temperance even for the body’s own good.
8. When unnecessary flesh-pleasing hinders any duty of piety, justice, charity, or self-preservation, whether in thought, affection, word, or deed, it is sinful.
9. If any pleasing of the flesh can be conceived to have no tendency, direct or indirect, to any moral good or evil, it is not the object of a moral choice or refusal. Like the blinking of an eye, which falls outside deliberation, it lies beyond the scope of morality.
10. Every pleasing of the flesh that is capable of being referred to a higher end, and is not so referred and used, is a sin. There is scarcely anything worth choosing, anything a wakeful, attentive person would deliberate over, that should not be referred to a higher end: the glory of God and our salvation, by cheering us to love and thankfulness, or by strengthening and fitting us in some way for some duty.
This is plainly a sin, for these reasons.
1.) Because otherwise flesh-pleasing is made our ultimate end and the flesh an idol, whenever we desire it only for itself when it could be referred to a higher end. Though the sensitive appetite has no intended end of its own, whatever the will desires is desired either as an end or as a means. What is not desired as a means to some higher end is desired as our ultimate end in that very act. But God alone is humanity’s lawful ultimate end.
2.) Because it is against an express command: "whether ye eat, or drink, or whatever ye do, do all to the glory of God" (1 Cor 10:31).
3.) Because otherwise we take God’s creatures in vain and waste them.
4.) Because we lose the benefit to ourselves that the creature or pleasure ought to yield.
5.) Because we silence reason when it should direct, suspend the government of the will, and hand government, for that time, to the flesh and brutish appetite; for that faculty rules whose object is our end.
These reasons clearly prove it a sin to terminate our desires in any act of flesh-pleasing as our end, without looking higher, when the matter falls within moral choice and deliberation.
He is a good Christian who remotely and ultimately refers every created thing to God, and who eats and drinks more to fit himself for God’s service than to please his flesh.
But the creature was appointed for much more than this: for an immediate communication to the heart of the sense of God’s goodness. As a musician who touches only the keys of his harpsichord or organ draws out that sweet, harmonious sound we hear from the strings struck within, so God ordained the order, beauty, and sweetness of the creature to touch the senses with a pleasure that should at once touch the inward sense with an answering delight in God, who gives every creature its life. But where is the Christian who eats and drinks in this way, and who takes pleasure in all his mercies in this way? On the contrary, our hearts are commonly so diverted from God by the creature that whatever delight we find in it we lose out of our delight in God, and even out of our regard and remembrance of him.
11. But the sin here is not simply that the flesh is pleased; it is that the duty of referring pleasure to a higher end is omitted. It is therefore a sin of omission, unless we go further and make better things a mere means to the flesh.
12. The intention of God’s glory or our spiritual good cannot be distinctly and consciously renewed at every particular pleasure we take, every bite we eat, or every thing we use. A sincere habitual intention, well established in the heart at the outset, will serve to govern many particular acts. Just as a traveler fixes his destination at the start of a journey and then proceeds without consciously thinking of it at every step, so the person who has devoted himself to God, and has generally resolved to direct everything to his glory and to the furtherance of duty and salvation, will carry small particulars toward that end by a quiet, unobserved action of the soul, running alongside other actions that alone attract notice.
A person who intends only his health in eating and drinking does not consciously recall health at every bite and sip, yet carries such a habitual care and caution that it unobservedly keeps him on course and helps him fit the means to the end. As the practiced hand of a musician can play a piece on his lute while his mind is on something else, so a resolved Christian can faithfully perform such accustomed acts as eating, drinking, dressing, and working in his calling toward the good ends he resolved on, first by actual intention and still by habitual intention, without a distinct or consciously observed remembrance of that end at every moment.
13. The body must be kept, as far as possible, in the condition best suited to serve the soul, as you keep your horse neither so overfed as to be unruly, nor so underfed as to be unfit for travel. All the health and strength that does not make the body unruly makes it more serviceable. It is not bodily life as such but health and cheerfulness that make the body fit for duty. So much pleasing of the flesh as tends toward its health and cheerfulness is a duty, where it can be accomplished without greater harm on the other side.
A heavy body is but a dull and sluggish servant to the mind, a great impediment to the soul in duty, and a great temptation to many sins, as sickly and melancholy persons, and many dull and phlegmatic people know by sad experience. It is as much a duty to help the body to its proper vigor and fitness for service as it is to tame and subdue it by fasting and sackcloth when it is proud or lustful.
Those who think that fasting on certain days in a formal manner is acceptable to God, even when the state of the body is not helped but rather hurt and hindered by it, as though fasting were required for its own sake, mistakenly offer a sacrifice God does not require. They treat him as an enemy of humanity who desires human pain and grief when that pain tends to no good. A mower with a good scythe will do more in a day than another with a bad one can do in two; every workman knows the benefit of keeping his tools in order; every traveler knows the difference between a fresh horse and a tired one; and those who have experienced both health and sickness know what a help it is, in every work of God, to have a healthy body, cheerful spirits, and a ready willingness to obey the mind.
Yet Petrarch’s observation is true: frail health is an unpleasant companion, but a faithful one; it pinches you frequently, marks the road, and reminds you of your condition. It is the most trustworthy counselor in danger. And as he also notes, sound health has proved dangerous and even deadly to many who would have been safer had they been ill. Nowhere does a sick soul find worse lodging than in a healthy body. And however bad or grievous illness may appear, it is still a welcome evil when it is the remedy for a greater one.
When the sight of fine prospects, beautiful buildings, fields, and landscapes, or the use of walks and gardens, tends to lift the soul toward holy contemplation, to wonder at the Creator, and to think of the glory of the life to come (as Bernard made use of his pleasant walks), such delight is lawful, and perhaps even a duty where it can be had. So when music cheers the mind and prepares it for thanksgiving and praise to God; and when bodily rest, the wearing of your best clothes, and moderate feasting on the Lord’s Day and other days of thanksgiving promote the spiritual service of those days, these things are good and profitable. But for those who are more hindered by fullness, even abstinence on such days is best. The use of the body, then, must be judged according to whether it serves as a means or an expression of the good or evil of the mind.
14. Sometimes the present moment must be the chief consideration, and sometimes the future. When some great sin, imminent judgment, or other reason calls us to a fast, when fasting is necessary for the purposes of that particular day, we must do it even if the body is so weak that it will suffer somewhat afterward, provided the good we may reasonably expect from it that day is greater than the good we are likely to lose afterward. Otherwise, the greater after-loss is to be more carefully avoided.
15. Many things fit us for our main end only indirectly, appearing to have no immediate connection to it, serving merely to supply natural strength, vigor, and readiness, or to prevent impediments. A traveler’s hood and cloak, and the rest of his baggage, seem more like hindrances to his speed; yet they are necessary to protect him from cold and wet, which would otherwise hinder him far more. Indeed, a possible but uncertain danger or impediment, if serious enough, may rightly be prevented at the cost of a certain small impediment. So it is fitting that our bodies be kept in the health and readiness that is ordinarily necessary to our duty; and in eating, drinking, and lawful recreation, we are preparing not only for the duty immediately before us, but for duty that may lie at a considerable distance.
16. Ordinarily it is safest to be more afraid of excess in bodily pleasure than of falling short. We are all ordinarily very prone to excess, and excess is usually the more dangerous of the two. When excess is the damnation of all, or nearly all, who perish, while deficiency is only a trouble and a hindrance but rarely, if ever, the damnation of anyone, it is easy to see on which side we ought to be most fearful, cautious, and watchful.
17. Yet excessive scrupulousness can itself be a greater sin, and a greater hindrance to the work of God, than some small excesses of bodily pleasure committed through ignorance or carelessness. An honest heart that places God before the flesh, and is willing to please him even at the cost of discomfort, may still err in some small particulars or fall into daily mistakes through weakness or inattention. This is far less of a hindrance to the main work of religion than if such a person were to torment his mind daily with scruples about every morsel he eats, whether it is too pleasant or too much, and about every word he speaks and every step he takes, as many poor, tempted, melancholy people do. Such scrupulousness disables them not only from love, praise, and thankfulness, but from any significant service at all.
In sum, every gratification of the senses or the body that is lawful must meet these qualifications:
1.) God’s glory must be the ultimate end.
2.) The matter must be lawful and not forbidden.
3.) It must not therefore hinder duty.
4.) Nor draw us toward sin.
5.) Nor harm our health.
6.) Nor be valued too highly or pursued at too great a cost.
7.) The measure must be moderate.
Where any of these conditions is absent, it is sin. And where the pleasure of the body is habitually the settled preference of heart and life over the pleasing of God, this proves the soul is in captivity to the flesh and in a damnable condition.
Third. I come next to show you the evil and malignity of flesh-pleasing when it is dominant, for if the greatness of this sin were truly known, that knowledge would contribute greatly to the cure.
1. Understand, to begin with, that it is the sin of sins, the end of all sin, and therefore the very essence and animating principle of sin as a whole. Everything evil that wicked people do is ultimately done to please the flesh. Love of bodily pleasure is the cause of all sin. Pride, covetousness, whoredom, wantonness, gluttony, drunkenness, and all the rest are either the immediate works of sensuality and flesh-pleasing, or the more remote service of it, laying in provision for it. All the malicious enmity and opposition to God and godliness arises from the same source: these cross the interests and desires of the flesh. Bodily pleasure is the final cause for which people invent and employ every means that serves it.
Since all other sin is nothing but a means for satisfying our bodily appetites and desires, it follows clearly that flesh-pleasing is the common cause of them all. It stands to every other sin as the spring stands to a watch, or the weight to a clock: it is what gives all the rest their motion. Cure this sin, and you have removed that driving weight and cured all the active sins of the soul, though the sins of omission and deficiency would still remain uncured if nothing more were done, since what makes a clock stand still is not enough to make it run properly. In truth, nothing but the love of pleasing God can genuinely cure the love of pleasing the flesh; and such a cure is the cure of every sin, active and passive, by commission and by omission.
2. Flesh-pleasing is the grand idolatry of the world, and the flesh is the greatest idol ever set up against God. This is why Paul says of sensual worldlings that "their belly is their god" (Phil 3:19), and from that fact they "mind earthly things," "glory in their shame," and are "enemies to the cross of Christ," that is, enemies to suffering for Christ, and to the doctrines and duties that would bring suffering upon them.
Whatever a person takes as his chief good, loves most, trusts in most, and is most eager to please, that is his god. And this is precisely what the flesh is to every sensualist. He "loveth pleasure more than God" (2 Tim 3:2, 4). He "savoureth" or "mindeth" the "things of the flesh," and "liveth" to it, and "walketh after it" (Rom 8:1, 5–8, 13). He "maketh provision for" it "to satisfy its appetite or lusts" (Rom 13:14). He "soweth to the flesh" (Gal 6:8), and fulfils its lust when it "lusteth against the Spirit" (Gal 5:16, 17). And so, while concupiscence or sensuality holds dominion, sin is said to have dominion over such a person, and he is its servant (Rom 6:14, 20). For "to whom men yield themselves servants to obey, his servants they are whom they serve or obey" (Rom 6:16).
The chief form of idolatry does not consist in bowing the knee and praying to another god. Just as loving, pleasing, obeying, trusting, seeking, and delighting in God are the highest parts of his service, which he values above a thousand sacrifices or outward compliments, so loving the flesh, pleasing it, obeying it, trusting in it, seeking its pleasures, and delighting in them are the chief service of the flesh. This service is more truly idolatrous than if one offered a formal sacrifice to it, and so it is the grand idolatry.
The flesh is thus the chief enemy of God: it receives the love and service that are rightly his, and robs him of the hearts of all who are carnal and unsanctified. All the Baals, Jupiters, Apollos, and other idols the world has ever known, taken together, have not received as much of the love and service due to God as the flesh alone receives. If the sensualist idolizes other things, wealth, powerful men, worldly greatness, he does so only insofar as they serve or threaten his bodily comfort; they are but secondary idols. The flesh holds his heart. By the interests of the flesh he judges his condition; by these he judges who his friends are; by these he chooses or refuses his actions; and by these he measures the words and actions of everyone else. He counts everything good that pleases his flesh, and everything bad that crosses his pleasure.
3. The flesh is not only the most common idol, but the most devouring idol in all the world. Other idols that are flattered and served as means to an end receive only a bow, a compliment, or an occasional sacrifice or ceremony. But the flesh receives the heart, the tongue, the body to serve it, the whole of a man’s wealth, the service of friends, the use of wit and every possible effort, in a word, everything. The sensualist loves and serves the flesh as God should be loved and served by his own people, "with all the heart, and soul, and might," and honors it "with their substance, and the firstfruits of their increase." It is served as faithfully as Christ requires of his disciples: men will part with father and mother, brother and sister, their closest friends, and everything that stands against it, for the pleasing of their flesh.
Indeed, Christ required men to give up only transitory earthly things for him, things they must shortly part with whether they will or not. Yet they do ten thousand times more for the flesh than they were ever required to do for Christ. They forsake God for it. They forsake Christ, and heaven, and their own salvation for it. They forsake all the solid comforts of this life and all the joys of the life to come for it. They sell everything they have and lay down the price at its feet, and more than everything they have: they surrender all their hopes of what they might have had to all eternity. They suffer a martyrdom in the flames of hell forever, for their flesh.
All the pains they take are for it. All the wrong they do to others, and all the strife and ruin they cause in the world, is for it. All the time they spend is for it, and had they a thousand more years to live, they would spend them all the same way. If anything seems to be set apart for God, it is only the bones, the crumbs, the leavings of the flesh, or rather, it is nothing at all. God does not truly possess the hours that appear to be his: he receives only a few polished words and compliments, while the flesh holds their hearts even in the midst of their hypocritical worship, even on his holy day. They serve God only as the Indians serve the devil, that he may serve their purposes and do them no harm.
4. How base an idol is the flesh! If all the derision that Elijah and the prophets directed against heathen idolatry was deserved, is not as much deserved by the idolatry of all the sensual? Is it so great a madness to serve an idol of silver, gold, stone, or wood? And what better is it to serve an idol of flesh and blood? A paunch of guts, full of filth and excrements within, whose very skin, the cleanest part, is ashamed to be uncovered?
We may say to the carnal worldling what Elijah said to the Baalists, and more: "Call upon your God in the hour of your distress: cry aloud; perhaps he is asleep, or he is blowing his nose, or vomiting, or purging: certainly he will be shortly rotting in the grave, more loathsome than the dirt or dung upon the earth." And is this a god to sacrifice everything to? To give all our time, and care, and labor, and our very souls? Judge this idolatry as God will make you judge it at last.
5. Consider next how impious and terrible an abasement of the eternal God it is to prefer so vile a thing before him, and whether every ungodly, sensual man is not a constant, practical blasphemer. What do you say by your practice but this: "This dunghill, nasty flesh, is to be preferred before God, more worthy of love, obedience, and service; more deserving of my time; more worthy of my delight"? God will be judge, and will judge in righteousness before long, whether this is not the daily language of your life, however well your tongue has been taught to speak better. Whether this amounts to blasphemy, judge for yourself.
Ask your own heart whether you judge God or the flesh more worthy to be pleased, and which you think it better to please, when cards and dice, eating and drinking, gallantry and idleness, rank and abundance all seem so sweet to you compared with any thought of God, his holy word, and his worship; and when morning and night, and whenever you are alone, your thoughts run freely and pleasurably to these provisions for your flesh, while you can barely force yourself to look up to God for a quarter of an hour, and that only with reluctance.
6. Think also what a contempt of heaven it is to prefer the pleasing of the flesh before it. There are only two ends at which all people aim: the pleasing of the flesh on earth, or the enjoyment of God in heaven, unless someone is deluded enough to think he will have a sensual life hereafter as well as here. These two ends stand in opposition to each other. Whoever sets up one renounces, or as good as renounces, the other. "If ye sow to the flesh, of the flesh ye shall reap corruption: but if ye sow to the spirit, of the spirit ye shall reap everlasting life" (Gal 6:8). Your wealth, honor, sports, pleasures, and appetites are placed on one side of the scales, and all the joys and hopes of eternity on the other. To say you hope to have both is the deceit of unbelief, of one who does not truly believe God. Is heaven not most basely esteemed by those who prefer so base a thing before it?
7. Remember that the pursuit of fleshly pleasure is a great contempt and betrayal of the soul. It is a great contempt of an immortal soul to prefer its corruptible flesh before it, to make its servant become its master, to set flesh riding on horseback while the soul goes on foot. Is the flesh worthy of so much time, cost, care, and effort as the world devotes to it, and is a never-dying soul not worth more? More than contempt, it is a betrayal of the soul: you set up its enemy above it, place its safety in an enemy’s hands, and throw away all its joys and hopes to gratify the flesh.
Might not the soul complain of this cruelty and say, "Must my endless happiness be sold to purchase so brief a pleasure for your flesh? Must I be undone forever and lie in hell, that it may be satisfied for a little while?" But why speak of the soul’s complaint? The soul must in the end complain of itself, for it is its own doing. It has its choice: the flesh can tempt but not compel it; God has placed the chief power and government in its hands. If it will sell its own eternal hopes to pamper what will soon be food for worms, it will meet the consequence accordingly.
You would not think very well of the wit or honesty of a man who sold the inheritance of all his children and all the friends who had entrusted him with it, and then sold their very persons into slavery, all to purchase himself a lavish feast with sports and gallantry for a day. Is he any wiser or better who sells, in effect, the inheritance of his own soul, and betrays it to hell and devils forever, all to purchase the fleshly pleasures of so short a life?
8. Remember what a beastly life it is to be a sensualist. It is the unmaking of yourself as a human being. Sensual pleasures are brutish pleasures; animals enjoy them as much as people do. We have the higher faculty of reason to subdue and govern the beastly part of us. Reason is what makes us human, and it has a nobler kind of happiness to delight in. Do you think a human being is made for no higher purpose than a beast? That you have no more noble an object for your delight than your swine or dog, who enjoy the pleasures of food, lust, play, ease, and instinct just as you do? Wherever sensual pleasures are preferred above the higher pleasures of the soul, that person becomes a beast, or worse, by subjecting reason to the brutish part.
9. Think what an insignificant, pitiful happiness fleshly people choose, how small, how brief, and how sordid. How quickly will the game be over, and the heat of boiling lust be gone! How quickly will the drink pass their throats, and their delicate dishes turn to waste! How brief is the fool’s sport and laughter! How soon will that face become the sign of a body in pain, or a mind grieved and tormenting itself! It is but a few days before all their stately greatness will be leveled, and the most adorned and pampered flesh will have nothing more to show for all the pleasure so dearly bought than a Lazarus, or the most mortified saint. A few days will turn their pleasure into anguish, their revelry into groans, their ostentation into lamentation, and all their glory into shame.
As every passing moment has already ended all the pleasures of their past life, so that those pleasures now are as if they had never been, so the last moment is at hand that will end the little that remains. Then the sinner will confess with groans that he made a miserable choice, and that a more lasting pleasure was within his reach had he been wise. When the skull is turned up by the spade to make room for the next, you may see the hole where all the food and drink once went in, and the grim remnant of that face which once displayed wantonness, pride, and scorn, but you will see no sign of mirth or pleasure.
10. Finally, consider that scarcely any sin in the world is more inexcusable than this one. The flesh-pleaser sees the end of all sensual delight in the faces of the sick, in the corpses carried daily to the earth, and in the graves, bones, and dust of those who once lived as merrily as he does. His own reason can say: all of that is gone with them, as though it had never existed; and so it will shortly be with me. He knows that all the pleasure of his past life is now worthless to him. His warnings are constant, close, and unmistakable, and that is precisely what makes his sin the greater.
Fourth. The sensualist’s first objection is this: "What harm does it do to God, or to anyone else, that I please my flesh? I cannot believe that something so harmless will displease him."
Answer: Considered simply as pleasure, it contains no harm. But consider it as inordinate or immoderate pleasure, as something overloved and preferred before God and your salvation; as something enjoyed more than delight in God; as something stripped of its proper end, loved merely for itself rather than used as a means to higher things; as something that hinders the soul, blocks spiritual pleasure, and obstructs the service of God; and as the brutish gratification of an ungoverned, rebellious appetite that overrules reason and refuses submission to God. Though sin can do God no injury, it can do you immense injury, and it does him wrong.
I believe I have already shown you what harm and poison it contains. It is nothing less than the rebellion of corrupted nature, the inversion of all right order: pulling down God, heaven, and reason; destroying the proper use of every created thing; setting up pleasure of the flesh in their place; and making a brute your god and governor. And you ask what harm there is in this? A child asks the same when he wants a game or a treat; a sick person asks the same when craving what will hurt him. But your father, your physician, and your reason, not your brutish appetite, must be the judge.
Objection 2: But I feel that this appetite is natural to me, and therefore it cannot be sinful.
Answer:
1. The inordinate, violent, unruly appetite is natural to you in no other sense than a leprosy is natural to a leprous generation. Will you love your disease because it is native to you? It is natural in exactly the same way that malice, revenge, disobedience to authority, and abuse of neighbors are natural, yet no one would count you innocent of rebellion or harm simply because those tendencies are natural to you.
2. Even if the appetite is natural, is not reason to govern you equally natural? Is not the subjection of appetite to reason natural? If it is not, you have lost the nature of a human being and been transformed into the nature of a beast. God gave you a higher nature to govern your appetite and your lower nature. Reason cannot extinguish the appetite, but it can rule it and restrain you from fulfilling it in any measure or manner that is unfit.
Objection 3: But the case of Eve shows that the appetite existed in innocence, therefore it cannot be sinful.
Answer: You must not overlook the distinction between: 1. the appetite itself; 2. the violence and unruliness of the appetite; and 3. the actual obeying and gratifying of the appetite. The first, the appetite itself, existed in innocence and is not in itself sinful. But the other two, the violence of it, and the obeying of it, did not exist in innocence, and both are sinful.
Objection 4: But why would God give innocent man an appetite that reason must cross, one that desires what reason must forbid?
Answer: The sensitive nature precedes the rational in the order of natural development, and reason and God’s laws do not abolish sensation as such. You might just as well ask why God made animals that must be restrained and governed by human beings, and therefore desire what their keepers must hold them back from. You are really asking why God made us human beings rather than angels, why he placed our souls in flesh. He owes you no account of his creation. What you can see is that obedience fittingly undergoes some trial through difficulty and resistance before it receives commendation and reward. He gave you a body subject to the soul as a horse is subject to its rider; you should marvel at his wisdom and thank him for reason’s governing power, rather than complain that the horse does not go as well without the rider’s guidance, or that he has not made you able to travel as fast on foot. So much for the sensualist’s objections.
Fifth. The signs of a flesh-pleaser or sensualist are these, which may be gathered from what has already been said.
1. When a man desiring to please his appetite does not refer that desire (actually or habitually) to a higher end, namely, fitting himself for the service of God, but rests content in the delight itself.
2. When he looks more eagerly and industriously after the prosperity of his body than of his soul.
3. When he will not relinquish or forgo his pleasures when God forbids them, or when they injure his soul, or when the needs of his soul call him more urgently elsewhere, but must have his gratification whatever it costs him, and is so set upon it that he cannot deny it to himself.
4. When the pleasures of his flesh exceed his delight in God, in God’s holy Word and ways, and in the prospect of endless joy, and this not only in emotion but in estimation, choice, and pursuit. When he would rather be at a play, a feast, a game, or chasing profitable bargains in the world than live, by faith and love, a holy and heavenly life.
5. When men set their minds to planning and contriving provision for the pleasures of the flesh, and this stands first and sweetest in their thoughts.
6. When they would rather talk, hear, or read of fleshly pleasures than of spiritual and heavenly delights.
7. When they prefer the company of merry sensualists to the communion of the saints, in which they might exercise themselves in the praise of their Maker.
8. When they count that calling, condition, or place best for them to live in where they enjoy the pleasures of the flesh, ease, good fare, and bodily abundance, rather than one that, though it pinches the flesh, provides far better help and provision for the soul.
9. When a man will spend more to please his flesh than to please God.
10. When he will accept no doctrine but Libertinism, and hates mortification as needlessly rigid austerity.
By these and similar signs, sensuality may easily be recognized, indeed, by the whole bent of a person’s life.
Sixth. Many flesh-pleasers flatter themselves with better names, being deceived by means such as these.
1. Because they oppose the doctrine of Libertinism and hold opinions as strict as anyone. But flesh-pleasing can coexist with the doctrine of mortification and the strictest opinions, so long as those opinions are never put into practice.
2. Because they live in no gross or scandalous vice. They do not frequent playhouses, or go unseasonably to alehouses and taverns; they are not drunkards or gamblers, nor do they spend their hours in unnecessary recreations and pastimes; they are no fornicators, nor do they wallow in wealth. But the flesh may be pleased and served in ways that carry no disgrace in the world. May not a man make his ease, his prosperity, or the gratification of his appetite, without any infamous excess, as thoroughly his highest end and practical good as if he pursued it shamefully? Is not many a man a gluttonous flesh-pleaser who makes delight the supreme purpose of all his eating and drinking, and satisfies his appetite without any restraint beyond what health and reputation require, even though he never eats to the point of sickness? Even the flesh itself may forbid a sensualist to be drunk or to eat until he is ill, since sickness and shame are themselves displeasing to the flesh.
Many a man conceals a life of sensuality, not only behind a seeming temperance that no one reproves, but behind a seeming strictness and austerity. Yet conscience could tell them where they have received their good things (Luke 16:25).
3. Some think they are not sensual flesh-pleasers because they live in constant misery, in poverty and want, laboring hard for their daily bread, and so they hope to be like Lazarus, who had his sufferings in this life. But is all this not against your will? Would you not eat as well as the rich, live as idly, and take your pleasures, if you had as much as they? What you would do is what God counts to your charge. It is your will by which you will be judged. A thief does not become an honest man when prison or stocks prevent him from stealing, but only when a changed heart prevents him.
4. Others think they are not flesh-pleasers because their wealth, rank, and social standing entitle them to live well in food and pleasures. The rich man who was "clothed with purple and fine linen, and fared sumptuously every day" (Luke 16:19) lived on his own means, as he supposed, in a manner befitting his station. And the fool who said, "Soul, take thine ease, eat, drink, and be merry" (Luke 12:19), intended only to enjoy what was his own, what God had given him as a blessing on his land and labor.
But no man’s riches entitle him to be voluptuous. The commands to tame and mortify the flesh, not to live according to it, and not to make provision for it to satisfy its lusts, belong as much to the rich as to the poor. Though you are not expected to live in the same style as the poor, you are as fully bound to mortification and self-denial as the poorest person. If you are richer than others, you have more with which to serve God, but not more than others with which to serve the flesh. If poverty prevents someone from having what would better enable their body or mind to serve God, you may go beyond them in that respect and use thankfully the mercies given you. But you must no more be a flesh-pleaser than they.
5. Some deceive themselves by observing a formal fast from time to time, like the fleshly Pharisee who "fasted twice a week" (Luke 18:12), and conclude from this that they are not sensualists. I am not speaking of the Popish fasting on fish and delicacies, which is not even a show of mortification. But even if you truly fast as often as the Pharisees did, and quarrel with Christ’s disciples for not fasting (Matt 9:14, 15), what does that prove? Would not a sensualist do as much if his physician required it for his health? If the general direction of your life is fleshly, the interruption of a formal fast will not acquit you, and it may do nothing more than sharpen your appetite for the next meal.
Seventh. Yet many are wrongly judged by others, if not by themselves, to be sensual, through mistakes such as these.
1. Because they do not live as meanly and sparingly as the poor, who lack things that are necessary or helpful to their duty. But by that reasoning I must not be well simply because other men are sick, or I must not walk briskly because the lame can only hobble. If poor men have bad horses, I may ride the best I can find to dispatch my business and redeem my time, so long as I do not prefer costly and useless display over genuine usefulness.
2. Others are accused of sensuality because the weakness of their bodies requires more careful treatment and diet than healthy men need. Some bodies are less fit for duty when they fast; some are made useless by sickness and infirmity unless managed with great care. To cherish a weak body so as to enable it for God’s service is just as truly a duty as to tame an unruly, lustful body and keep it from offending him.
3. Some melancholy, conscientious persons are constantly accusing themselves out of sheer scrupulosity, questioning nearly everything they eat, drink, wear, or do, whether it is not too much or too pleasant. But what God requires is a cheerful sobriety that neither pampers the body nor disables or hinders it from its duty, not an unprofitable, wrangling scrupulosity.
Direction 1. The first and grand Direction against flesh-pleasing is this: be sure, through a serious and living faith, to see the better things that are with God, and to be wholeheartedly engaged in minding, loving, seeking, and securing them. All the other Directions are subordinate to this one. The soul is a living, active principle and will not lie idle; equally certain is that it will not act except toward some end. The only ends available to us are either temporal or eternal things. There is therefore no true cure for a sensual love of temporal things except to turn the heart to things eternal.
Begin by believing in the certainty, greatness, and eternity of the joys above. Then consider that these joys may more certainly be yours than any worldly riches or pleasures, if only you do not contemptuously reject them. Then recognize that this present life is the time in which you must make sure of them and win them, for it is the very purpose for which you were sent into the world. Then reflect on how fleshly pleasures are the only competitors with everlasting pleasures, that if you ever lose those eternal joys, it will be by overloving these passing things, and that half your work for salvation lies in putting your affections for everything below to death, so that they may be alive to God alone.
Finally, consider how much higher and sweeter pleasures the godly enjoy even in this life than you do, and that you are forfeiting them by preferring these base pleasures. Do you imagine that a true believer does not take a more excellent delight in his anticipation of immortal blessedness with Christ, in the assurance of God’s love, and in communion with him in holy service, than you or any sensualist takes in fleshly pleasures? Sober and serious meditation on these things will turn the mind toward true delight.
Direction 2. Be acquainted with the full range of sensual desires, trace them, and watch them in all their extravagances. Otherwise, while you are stopping one gap, they will be breaking out at many others. I have given many examples in my Treatise of Self-denial. I will briefly set some before you here.
1. Watch your appetites regarding food and drink, both in quantity and quality. Gluttony is a common and unnoticed sin. The flesh enslaves men in no way more completely than through appetite, as is plain in drunkards and gluttons, who can no more abstain than someone burning with fever can stop thirsting.
2. Be on guard against the lust of uncleanness, and against all its degrees and approaches, especially immodest embraces and behavior.
3. Be on guard against ribald and filthy talk, love songs, and such inflaming snares.
4. Be on guard against too much sleep and idleness.
5. Be on guard against taking too much delight in your riches, lands, buildings, and pleasant conveniences.
6. Be on guard lest honor, worldly greatness, or the applause of men become too great a pleasure to you.
7. And lest you come to make it your delight to dwell on such things when you are alone, or to talk idly of them in the company of others.
8. And be on guard lest the success and prosperity of your affairs please you too greatly, as it did the rich fool (Luke 12:20).
9. Do not take up any inordinate pleasure in your children, relatives, or closest friends.
10. Be on guard against delight in vain, unprofitable, and sinful company.
11. Or against delight in finery of clothing, to display yourself to others’ eyes.
12. Be on guard against delight in romances, play-books, invented stories, and useless news, things that corrupt the mind and waste your time.
13. Be on guard against delight in any recreations that are excessive, needless, time-devouring, discomposing to the mind, enticing to further sin, or hindering any duty, above all, hindering our delight in God. Those are miserable souls who can find delight in nothing safer or more profitable than cards, dice, stage-plays, and immodest dancing.
Direction 3. Next to the universal remedy described in the first Direction, see that you have the particular remedies ready to hand that your own specific form of flesh-pleasing most requires. Do not let love of your vanity prejudice you against honest examination, but consider impartially both the disease and the remedy. The particulars will follow shortly.
Direction 4. Remember always that God would give you more pleasure, not less, and that he will give you as much of sensory delight as is truly good for you, provided you receive it in its proper place, in subordination to your heavenly delight. And is not this an increase and multiplication of your pleasure? Are not health, friends, food, and a decent home far sweeter as the fruit of God’s love, as foretastes of everlasting mercies, as helps toward heaven, and as means of spiritual comfort, than they could be in themselves alone? All your mercies come from God. He would take none of them from you, only sanctify them and give you more.
Direction 5. See that reason keeps its authority as the governor of sense and appetite. Whatever the appetite wants, take account of the ends and reasons behind the thing, and what it actually leads to. Do nothing and take nothing merely because sense or appetite desires it, but only because you have good reason to do so, and, with that reason, to gratify the appetite. Otherwise, with reason laid aside, you act no better than animals.
Direction 6. Go to the grave, and there see the end of fleshly pleasure, and what it will do for you at the last. You would think the sight of where all our wealth, mirth, sport, and pleasure must finally be buried would cure the frantic desire for abundance and pleasure.
Direction 7. Finally, remain constantly aware that the flesh is the greatest enemy of your soul, and that pleasing the flesh is the greatest hindrance to your salvation. The devil’s enmity and the world’s enmity are both subordinate to that of the flesh: for the pleasure of the flesh is the end, and the world’s and Satan’s temptations are merely the means of reaching it. Beyond the malignity already described, consider these points:
1. How contrary a life of sensual pleasure is to the blessed example of our Lord, and of his servant Paul and all the apostles. Paul disciplined his body and brought it into subjection, lest, having preached to others, he himself should become a castaway (1 Cor 9:27). All who belong to Christ have crucified the flesh with its affections and lusts (Gal 5:24). This was signified in the ancient manner of baptism, and is still signified by baptism itself, when the person went entirely under the water and then rose out of it, to show that they were dead and buried with Christ (Rom 6:3–4), and rose with him to newness of life. This is called being "baptised into his death," and it seems to be the plain sense of 1 Corinthians 15:29, being "baptised for the dead," that is, baptized as those who are dead, to show that we are dead to the world, must die in the world, but will rise again to the kingdom of Christ, both of grace and glory.
2. Sensuality shows that there is no true belief in the life to come, and proves, so far as it prevails, the absence of all grace.
3. It is a homegrown, perpetual traitor to the soul: a constant tempter and the nurse of all sin; the great withdrawer of the heart from God; and the common cause of apostasy itself. It continually fights against the Spirit (Gal 5:17), and seeks advantage from all our liberties (Gal 5:13; 2 Pet 2:10).
4. It turns all our outward mercies into sin, and strengthens itself against God by means of God’s own benefits.
5. It is the great cause of our afflictions: God will not spare the idol that is set up against him. The flesh rebels, and the flesh shall suffer.
6. And when sensuality has brought affliction, it is most impatient under it and makes affliction seem intolerable. Those who have lived for fleshly pleasure think themselves ruined when affliction strips them of it.
7. Finally, it makes people entirely unfit for death. At death the flesh must be cast into the dust and all its pleasure brought to an end. What a dreadful day it will be for those who had their good things here and their portion in this life, when everything they ever valued and sought is gone, and all the true felicity they brutishly despised is lost forever. If you want to bear joyfully the dissolution and ruin of your flesh at that hour, master and mortify it now. Do not seek the ease and pleasure of a little walking, breathing clay when you should be seeking and foretasting everlasting pleasure. Here lies your danger and your work. Strive more against your own flesh than against all your enemies in earth and hell: if you are saved from this, you are saved from them all. Christ suffered in the flesh, to show you that what your flesh must expect is not pampering but suffering, if you will reign with him.
CHAPTER 4
DIRECTIONS FOR REDEEMING AND MAKING GOOD USE OF TIME
Time is the opportunity given to every person for all the works of life that their Creator expects of them, and on which their endless life depends. Redeeming time, making right use of it, is therefore of the highest importance, and it is fittingly made by the apostle Paul the great mark that distinguishes the wise from fools: "See then that you walk circumspectly; not as fools, but as wise, redeeming the time." (Eph 5:15–16) I will give you specific directions for this duty, but first I will explain the nature of the duty itself, what is meant by time, and what by redeeming it.
Time, in its most common sense, refers generally to the whole space of this present life, which is our opportunity for all the works of life and the measure of them. More strictly, time is used for some special opportunity suited to a particular work, what we call the season, or the fittest time. In both senses, time must be redeemed.
Just as every work has its season that must be taken (Eccl 3:1), so the greatest works assigned to us for God and our souls have special seasons beyond our common time.
1. Some times God has fitted by nature for his service. The time of youth, health, and strength is especially suited to holy work.
2. Some time is made specially fit by God’s own institution, the Lord’s Day above all other days.
3. Some time is made fit by the appointment of those in authority: the hour of public meeting for God’s worship, lecture-days, and the hour for family worship, which every head of a household may appoint for his own household.
4. Some time is made fit by the condition of our bodies: the morning hours are best for most people, the evening for some; and for everyone, the time when the body is freest from pain and disabling weakness.
5. Some time is made fit by the course of our necessary, natural, or civil business: the daytime is fitter than the sleeping hours of night, and that hour is fittest when our other employments will least disturb us.
6. Some time is made fit by a special shower of mercy, public or private: when we live in godly households, among exemplary and helpful company, under lively and excellent means, with faithful pastors, profitable teachers, the best masters or parents, and with faithful friends.
7. Some time is made fit by particular acts of providence: a funeral sermon at the death of someone near us; the presence of an able minister or private Christian whose company we cannot ordinarily have; or a special leisure, as the Ethiopian eunuch had to read the Scripture in his chariot (Acts 8).
8. Some time is made specially fit by the special workings of God’s Spirit upon the heart, when he illuminates, teaches, quickens, softens, humbles, comforts, stirs up, or confirms more than ordinarily. Both time in general and these particular seasons must each be put to good use for their own works. We must take the wind and tide while we can, and strike while the iron is hot.
9. Some time is made fit by the needs of others and the call of God: it is the time to relieve the poor when they ask, or when they are most in need; to help our neighbor when it will do him most good; to visit the sick, the imprisoned, and the afflicted in their hour of need (Matt 25). The godly are thus like trees planted by the riverside, bringing forth fruit in their season (Ps 1:3). So also we must speak in season to the ignorant or ungodly for their conversion, or to the sorrowful for their consolation (Isa 50:4).
10. Our own necessity also makes our seasons: the time of old age and sickness is made by necessity the season of special repentance and preparation for death and judgment.
11. The present time is commonly our season, because of the uncertainty of finding a fitter time, or indeed any time at all. "Withhold not good from them to whom it is due, when it is in the power of thy hand to do it. Say not unto thy neighbour, Go, and come again, and to-morrow I will give; when thou hast it by thee." (Prov 3:27) "Give a portion to seven, and also to eight; for thou knowest not what evil shall be upon the earth." (Eccl 11:2) "Boast not thyself of to-morrow; for thou knowest not what a day may bring forth." (Prov 27:1) "As we have therefore opportunity, let us do good to all men; especially to them who are of the household of faith." (Gal 6:10) These are our special seasons.
To redeem time presupposes five things:
1.) That we know what we are to do with time, what we ought to spend it on, and how great the worth of those things is for which we must redeem it.
2.) That we highly value time in light of this necessary work.
3.) That we feel the weight of our sin and loss in having negligently and willfully squandered as much as we already have.
4.) That we know the particular season of each duty.
5.) That we value all that we must part with in redeeming time less than we value time itself and its proper ends, for otherwise we will not make the exchange.
And as these five things are presupposed, the following are contained in the actual redeeming of time:
1.) To redeem time is to ensure that none of it is cast away in vain, but that every minute is used as a most precious thing and spent entirely in the way of duty.
2.) To be not only doing good, but doing the best and greatest good that we are able and have a calling to do.
3.) To do not only the best things, but to do them in the best manner, to the greatest degree, and to do as much good as we possibly can.
4.) To watch for special opportunities.
5.) To take them immediately when they come, and to make use of them once taken.
6.) To part with everything that is to be parted with, in order to save our time.
7.) To anticipate and prevent impediments, remove whatever weighs us down, and secure all the helps to speed and success in duty.
This is the true redeeming of time.
The ends and purposes for which time must be redeemed are these:
1.) In general, and ultimately, time must be given entirely to God. Not all of it is spent directly upon God in meditating on him or praying to him, yet all of it must be laid out for him, directly or indirectly, either in serving him or in preparing for his service; in mowing, or in sharpening the blade; in traveling, or in resting to be fit for travel. Thus even our time of sleeping, eating, and needful recreation is given to God.
2.) Time must be redeemed especially for works of public benefit, for the church and the state, for the souls of many, especially by magistrates and ministers, who have a special charge and opportunity, and who "must spend and be spent" for the sake of the people, even if rewarded with ingratitude and contempt (2 Cor 12:14–15).
3.) Time must be redeemed for your own soul and your everlasting life: for speedy conversion without delay, if you are yet unconverted; for the killing of every soul-endangering sin, without delay; for the exercise and growth of young and unconfirmed grace; for growth in knowledge; for making your calling and election sure; and for storing up provisions of faith, hope, love, and comfort against the hour of suffering and of death.
4.) Time must be redeemed for the souls of every particular person we have opportunity to do good to, especially for children, servants, and others whom God has committed to our care.
5.) Time must be redeemed for the welfare of our own bodies, that they may be serviceable to our souls.
6.) Lastly, for the bodily welfare of others. This is the order in which those works stand, for which and in which our time must be redeemed.
The price at which time must be redeemed is this:
1.) Above all, by our utmost diligence, that we are always at work, putting forth all our strength, and running as for our lives; and that whatever our hand finds to do, we do it with all our might, remembering that there is no work, nor purpose, nor knowledge, nor wisdom in the grave where we are going. Our sluggish ease is a cheap price to exchange for precious time. To redeem time is not to call back what is past, nor to stop time in its hasty passage, nor to secure a long life on earth; it is to rescue time, as it passes, from being devoured and lost through laziness and sin.
2.) Time must be redeemed from sinful pleasures, sports, and revellings, and from all that is either in itself or incidentally unlawful, from wantonness, licentiousness, and vanity. Both of these are brought together by the apostle: "And that, knowing the time, that now it is high time to awake out of sleep: for now is our salvation nearer than when we believed. The night is far spent, the day is at hand: let us therefore cast off the works of darkness, and let us put on the armour of light. Let us walk honestly, as in the day; not in rioting and drunkenness, not in chambering and wantonness, not in strife and envying. But put ye on the Lord Jesus Christ, and make not provision for the flesh, to fulfil the lusts thereof." (Rom 13:11–14)
3.) Time must be redeemed from things that are indifferent or lawful at another time, when necessary things require it. A man who ought to save lives, or quench a fire in his house, or provide for his family, or do his master’s work cannot excuse his neglect by pleading that he was engaged in something indifferent or lawful. Natural rest and sleep must be given up for time when necessary things require it. Paul preached until midnight, being to depart the next day (Acts 20:7). The lamenting church, calling for prayer, says: "Arise: cry out in the night, in the beginning of the watches pour out thy heart like water before the face of the Lord." (Lam 2:19) The lamp used through the night, as Cleanthes famously did, is the fitting emblem for those whose daylight hours must be spent otherwise.
4.) Time must be redeemed from worldly business and profit when matters of greater weight and benefit require it. Trade, the plow, and gain must stand aside when God calls us, by necessity or otherwise, to greater things. Martha should not even have troubled herself preparing food for Christ and his followers when Christ was offering food for her soul and she should, like Mary, have been sitting at his feet to hear him (Luke 10:42). Worldlings are thus addressed by God: "Ho, every one that thirsteth, come ye to the waters. Wherefore do ye spend your money for that which is not bread? and your labour for that which satisfieth not? Hearken diligently unto me, and eat ye that which is good, and let your soul delight itself in fatness." (Isa 55:1–3)
5.) Time must be redeemed from smaller duties, which in their own season are duties, when those smaller duties stand in the way of a greater duty that ought to take precedence. It is a duty, in its proper time and place, to show respect to neighbors and superiors, to those around us, and to attend to family affairs, but not when we should be at prayer, or when a minister should be preaching or engaged in necessary study. Private prayer, meditation, and visiting the sick are duties, but not when we should be at church or engaged in any greater duty that they would hinder.
Title 1. Contemplative Directions for Redeeming Time
Direction 1. Always keep alive in your heart, through faith and deliberate reflection, a vivid sense of the greatness and absolute necessity of the work that must command your time. Remember who has set you to work, what that work is, on what terms you pursue it, and what its outcome will be.
It is God who calls you to labor. Will you stand still or busy yourself with other things when God expects your duty? Moses had to go to Pharaoh when God told him to go. Jonah had to go to Nineveh when God told him to go. Abraham had to go and offer his son when God told him to go. And will you go after your fleshly pleasures when God commands you to his service?
God has appointed you a work worth every hour and every effort, to know him, serve him, obey him, and seek everlasting life. How diligently should so excellent a work be done, and so blessed and glorious a Master be served! Consider the immeasurable importance of your diligence: you are running the race appointed by your Maker, running for an immortal crown. Heaven is what must now be won or lost. Do you have time to spare in such a race?
You are fighting against the enemies of your salvation. The question now being settled is whether the flesh, the world, and the devil, or you, will win the day. Heaven or hell is the outcome of this warfare, and do you have time to spare in the middle of such a fight, when your very loss of time is no small part of the enemy’s conquest?
Your most wise and all-powerful Creator has been pleased to make this present life the testing-ground and preparation for another, resolving that your eternal condition will correspond entirely to your preparation here. Can you play and loiter away your time when you have such a work before you?
O wretched, senseless souls! Do you truly believe in everlasting life, that your entire life is given to you now in order to decide whether you will be in heaven or hell forever? Do you believe this? I ask again: do you believe this? I urge you to ask your conscience, again and again, whether you truly believe it. Can you believe it and still have time to spare?
Time to play away, to gamble away, to idle and prate away, and yet you believe that this very time is given you to prepare for eternal life, and that salvation or damnation hangs on the race you are now running? Is not such a person a monster of stupidity? If you were asleep or mad, it would be more excusable to be so senseless. But to act this way while awake and in your right mind!
Where are the minds of those men, and of what material are their hardened hearts made, that they can idle and play away that time, that little time, that only time, given them for the everlasting saving of their souls? Truly, if sin had not turned the ungodly part of the world into a bedlam, where it is no wonder to see a man out of his wits, people would run into the streets in astonishment to see such a monster as this, as they do in the country when a madman appears in a place where such sights are rare.
They would call to one another: come and see a man who can trifle and play away his time as he travels toward eternity and stands ready to enter another world! Come and see a man who has only a few days in which to win or lose his soul forever, and is playing them away at cards or dice, or wasting them in doing nothing! Come and see a man who has hours to spare and throws them away on trifles, with heaven and hell before his eyes.
For your soul’s sake, consider and say to yourself: if your fortune in the world depended on how you spent this day or week, if your very life depended on it, so that you would live or die, be rich or poor, healthy or sick, according to how you spent it, would you then waste it in fine dressings, empty compliments, or play? Would you find any of it to spare for pointless trifling? Or would you not rather rise early and be about your business, turn away your games and diverting company, disappoint your idle visitors, and let people see that you are not to be spoken with or at leisure for nothing, choosing to seem disagreeable and stern rather than be ruined?
Would you do this for a passing prosperity or a mortal life, and does eternal life not require far more? Your weighty affairs in the world would resolve you to put aside friends, playmates, sports, and idleness, and should not the work of your salvation do the same?
I would ask for nothing more to silence those distracted time-wasters when they argue for their idle sports and vanities, asking what harm there is in cards and dice, stage-plays, long feasts, empty compliments, and adorned idleness, nothing more than to give them one glimpse of heaven and hell, and make them fully understand what greater business awaits them while they sleep or play.
If I were at this moment arguing the case with an idle lady, or a sensual belly-slave or gamester, and such a person were asking me scornfully what harm is in all this, if someone were to knock at the door and say the king is outside calling for him, he would throw down his game and his dispute at once. Or if the house were on fire, or a child had fallen into the fire or water, or thieves were breaking in, it would make the ladies cast aside the lace or ribbon they were busy with. Or if there were a good bargain or an estate to be gained, they could be up and moving, leaving sport, gambling, and finery behind.
And yet the forerunner of heaven and hell, though one of them is even now at the door, will not move them at all, because heaven is nothing to an unbeliever or an unconsidering, senseless wretch. As heaven is nothing to them when it should move them, so it will be nothing to them when they would enjoy it.
Do not say that recreation must be taken in its season. I acknowledge that necessary sharpening of the tool is no hindrance to the work. But God and your own conscience will soon tell you whether your recreations, feasts, long dressings, and idleness were a necessary refreshment of the body to fit it for the work you were born and live for, or whether they were the pastimes of a pleasure-loving, fleshly brute that lived in these pleasures for the love of pleasure itself.
Truly, when I look upon this one unreasonable sin of time-wasting, it helps me understand why Luke says the prodigal son "came to himself" (Luke 15:17), and why conversion is described as a man being restored to his right mind.
Direction 2. Do not be a stranger to the condition of your own soul, but look inward until you know what state it is in, what it is in danger of, what it lacks, and how far behind you are in your preparations for immortality, and then be an idle time-waster if you can.
Could I but go down with you into that dungeon of a heart and show you by the light of truth what is there, could I but let in one convincing beam from heaven, fully showing you what condition you are in and what you have yet to do with your remaining time, I should have no need to argue you out of your remaining fooleries, nor to tell you to be up and doing for your soul, any more than to tell you to move if a bear were at your back or the house in flames around you.
Alas, our ordinary time-wasters are still unconverted, carnal wretches, and all the while in the power of the devil, who is the chief master of that sport and its greatest gainer. They are utterly strangers to the regenerating, sanctifying work of the Holy Ghost; they remain unjustified, under the guilt of all their sins, and certain to be with devils in hell for ever if they die in that state before conversion. (This is true, sinner, and you will shortly find it so, by grace or by vengeance, though your blind and hardened heart now rises against the mention of it.) Is this a case for a man to sit at cards or dice in, or to sport and swagger in? The Lord have mercy on you, and open your eyes before it is too late; otherwise your conscience will tell you for ever, in a manner far different from mine, that you had need to have made better use of your time, and had greater things to spend it on.
What, for a man in your case, in an unrenewed, unsanctified, unpardoned state, to be casting away that little time on which all his hopes depend, and in which, if ever, he must be recovered and saved! O Lord, have mercy on such senseless souls, and bring them to themselves before it is too late! An enlightened person who understands what that state is, and has escaped it, would not for all the kingdoms of the world be a week or a day in your condition, for fear that death might cut off his hopes and shut him up in hell that very day. He would not dare sleep quietly in your condition a single night, lest death snatch him away to hell, and yet you can sport and play in it, and live securely in a sensual course? O what a thing it is to be blindfolded in misery, and to be led asleep to hell! Who could persuade men, fully awake, to go dancing to hell with their eyes open?
If we were to imagine a Peter or a Paul, or any of the blessed, brought back into the case of one of these unsanctified sinners, and yet knowing what they now know, what would they do? Would they feast, and game, and trifle away their time? Or would they not rather suddenly bewail their former misspent time and all their sins, cry day and night to God for mercy, fly to Christ, and spend all their remaining time in holiness and obedience to God?
Alas, poor sinner, look into your heart and see what you have to do there, work of far greater weight than dressing and playing. I almost tremble to think and write what a case you are in, and what you have to do, while you live as though you had time to spare. If you do not know, I will tell you, and may the Lord make you truly know it.
You have a hardened heart yet to be softened; an unbelieving heart to be brought to a living, powerful belief in the word of God and the unseen world; an unholy heart and life to be made holy, if ever you are to see the face of God. You have a heart full of sins to be mortified and subdued, and an unreformed life to be reformed, and what an abundance of particulars those generals contain! You have a pardon to obtain through Jesus Christ for every sin you have ever committed and every duty you have ever omitted. You have an offended God to be reconciled to, and an estranged soul to come to know him as your Father in Jesus Christ.
What an abundance of Scripture truths you have yet to learn, of which you are ignorant! How many holy duties, prayer, meditation, spiritual conversation with others, and the rest, you have yet to learn, in which you are unskilled, and then to perform once you have learned them! How many works of justice and charity toward the souls and bodies of others you have to do, the needy to relieve as you are able, the sick to visit, the naked to clothe, the sorrowful to comfort, the ignorant to instruct, the ungodly to exhort! What an abundance of duty you have to perform in your relationships, to parents or children, to husband or wife, as master or servant, and the rest! You little know what sufferings you have to prepare for. You have faith, love, repentance, patience, and all God’s graces to obtain, to exercise daily, and to grow in. You have your accounts to prepare, assurance of salvation to obtain, and death and judgment to prepare for.
What does your heart make of all this work? Put it off as lightly as you will, it is God himself who has laid it on you, and it must be done in time, or you will be undone for ever. And yet it is not meant to be your toil but your delight: this is appointed for your chief recreation. Look into Scripture and into your heart, and you will find that all this is to be done. Can you honestly believe that this is not greater business than your gaudy dressings, your idle visits, or your needless sports? Which is more worthy of your time?
Direction 3. Remember how profitable the redeeming of time is, and how exceedingly comforting in the review (Heb 3:13 Heb 10:25 Eph 4:29).
In trade, agriculture, or any profitable enterprise, we say of a man who has grown wealthy that he has made good use of his time. But when heaven, communion with God along the way, a life of holy strength and comfort, and a death full of joy and hope are the gain, how cheerfully should time be redeemed for these ends! If it is pleasant for a man to find himself thriving and prospering in any rising or rewarding work, how much more pleasant it must continually be for us to find, in redeeming time, that the work of God and of our souls is prospering.
Look back now on the time that is past and tell me which part is sweetest to your thoughts. However it may seem now, I can tell you that at death it will be an unspeakable comfort to look back on a well-spent life, to be able to say in humble sincerity: my time was not cast away on worldliness, ambition, idleness, or fleshly vanities and pleasures, but spent in the sincere and laborious service of my God, in making my calling and election sure, and in doing all the good to the souls and bodies of others that I could do in the world; it was entirely devoted to God and his church, and to the good of others and my own soul.
What a joy it is, when going out of the world, to be able to say in our place and measure, with our blessed Lord and pattern: "I have glorified thee on earth: I have finished the work which thou gavest me to do: and now, O Father, glorify me with thyself." (John 17:4–5) Or as Paul: "I am now ready to be offered, and the time of my departure is at hand. I have fought a good fight, I have finished my course, I have kept the faith: henceforth there is laid up for me a crown of righteousness, which the Lord, the righteous Judge shall give." (2 Tim 4:6–8) And again: "For our rejoicing is this, the testimony of our conscience, that in simplicity and godly sincerity, not with fleshly wisdom, we have had our conversation in the world." (2 Cor 1:12)
It is a great comfort in sickness to be able to say with Hezekiah: "Remember now, O Lord, I beseech thee, how I have walked before thee, in truth and with a perfect heart, and have done that which is good in thy sight." (Isa 38:3)
Time well spent is a precious cordial to a soul making its way to its final sentence and drawing up its last and general accounts. Indeed, the review of it will be joyful even in heaven, which is given, though most freely by the covenant as its antecedent ground, yet also as a reward by our most righteous Judge when he comes to sentence men according to that covenant.
Direction 4. Consider, by contrast, how bitter the review of ill-spent time is, and how you will wish you had spent it differently once it is gone. Do you find any comfort now in looking back on your despised hours? I will not insult your intelligence by questioning whether you know you must die. But your sin permits me to ask whether, at your dying hour, you will find any comfort in remembering your pastimes.
Will it please you then to find on your account so many hours spent in doing good to others, so many in prayer, in studying the Scriptures and your own heart, in preparing for death and the life to come, and so many in your calling, managed obediently with eternity in view? Or will you find so many hours lost in idleness, so many in needless sports and games, in hawking and hunting, in courting and wantonness, so many in accumulating and providing for the flesh, and so many in feeding its greedy lusts? Which reckoning does your conscience think would be the more comfortable to you at the last?
I put it to your own conscience: if you were to die tomorrow, how would you spend this present day? Would you spend it in idleness and vain pastimes? Or if you were to die today, where would you wish to be found, and about what exercises? Would you rather death found you in a playhouse, a gaming-house, an alehouse, in your fleshly jollity and pleasure? Or walking in holiness with God and seriously preparing for the life to come?
Perhaps you will say that if you had but a day to live, you would set aside the labors of your calling, and yet that does not prove those labors sinful. But I answer: there is a great difference between an evil and a small, unseasonable good. If death found you in your honest calling, managed in holiness, conscience would not trouble you for it as a sin. And if you rather choose to die in prayer, you are only choosing a greater duty in its season.
But surely you would dread, on a very different account, to be found in your time-wasting pleasures. Conscience, if you have one, would make you fear it as a sin. You will not wish at death that you had never labored in your lawful calling, though you might wish to be found in a more seasonable work. But you will wish, if you understand yourself at all, that you had never lost one minute’s time, and never known those sinful vanities and temptations that caused you to lose it. Spend your time as you would wish to review it.
Direction 5. Go and observe how other men at death value time, and how they wish they had spent it. It is nearly impossible for people in health, especially in prosperity and ease, to imagine how precious time appears to an awakened, dying person. Ask them then whether life is too long and men have time to spare. Ask them then whether idling or working, playing or praying, is the better use of time. Both good and bad, saints and sensualists, then set a very high value on time.
What would an ungodly, unprepared sinner give then for some of the time he had previously treated as worthless? Even the most holy servants of Christ feel keenly, at that hour, how they sinned by losing any of their time. How earnestly they wish they had prized every minute! And those who did the most for God and their souls wish they had done far more. If they could pray their prayers over again, how much more fervently they would plead! How much more good they would do if time and talents were restored!
I knew personally a most holy, grave, and venerable minister, who was so struck by the words of a godly woman who, at her death, cried out repeatedly and with great vehemence, "O call time again! O call time again!" that the weight of it seemed to remain on his heart and show itself in his praying, preaching, and daily life until his own death. Now you have time to cast away on every trifle. But then you will say with David, "Remember how short my time is!" (Ps 89:47). And as "Hagar sat down and wept when her water was spent" (Gen 21:15–16), so you will lament when time is gone or nearly at an end, that you set so little store by it while you had it.
Drowsy sinner! Your heart cannot now conceive how you will value time when you hear the physician say, "You are a dead man," and the minister say, "You must now prepare for another world," and your own heart says, "All my days are gone. I must live on earth no more. All my time for preparation is at an end. Now what is left undone must remain undone forever." O that you had now even the esteem of time that you will have then, or immediately after!
Then it will be: "O pray for me, that God will restore me and give me one more opportunity! O how I would spend my time!" And is it not a most incongruous thing to see the same persons now idling and trifling away their time, perhaps thinking they do no harm, who know that shortly they must cry to God, "O Lord, a little more time to do the great work yet undone; a little more time to make my salvation sure!" May not God then rightly answer: you had time until you knew not what to do with it. You had so much that you had many and many an hour to spare for idleness and vanity, and for what you were not ashamed to call pastime.
Direction 6. Remember also that when judgment comes, God will call you to account for every hour of misspent time and for all the good you should have done in that time but did not. If you must give account for every idle word, then certainly for every idle hour (Matt 12:36). And if we must be judged according to all the talents we have received and the improvement of them required of us, then certainly for so precious a talent as time. How should a person who believes he must give such an account spend his days? He must answer to the most just and holy God, who will judge all people according to their works and cause them all to reap what they have sown. Spend your time as you would be willing to hear of it at the judgment.
Direction 7. Remember how much time you have already lost, and therefore, if you are not impenitent and unfeeling about your loss, let that provoke you to redeem with all the greater diligence the remnant that mercy may still grant you. How much did you lose in childhood, in youth, and in your more mature years? How much in ignorance? How much in negligence? How much in fleshly pleasure and vanity? How much in worldliness and many other sins? If only you knew what a loss even one year, one week, or one day was.
Do you think you have spent your time as you ought, as befits those who have such work to do? If not, do you repent of it, or do you not? If you do not, you have no hope of being forgiven. If you do repent, you will surely not go on doing the same. Who will believe that a man repents of gaming, reveling, or other idle waste of time, who continues in it while he professes to repent? The person who has lost the beginning of the day must go faster toward the end, if he is to complete so great a journey. Can you remember the hours and years you have wasted in the follies of childhood and the vanities of thoughtless youth, and yet still trifle away, not stirred by penitent shame and fear to diligence? Have you not yet thrown away enough of so precious a treasure, that you must also despise the little that remains?
Direction 8. Remember the swift and constant motion of time as it slips neglected past you. What speed it makes, and how it never stops! What was here while you spoke the last word is gone before you can speak the next. Whatever you are doing, saying, or thinking, time is passing on without delay. It does not pause while you sleep. Whether you notice it, mark it, and make use of it or not, it glides away. It does not wait for your convenience. It hastens as fast while you play as while you work, while you sin as when you repent. No monarch is powerful enough to command it to attend his will for even a moment. We have no more Joshuas to stop the sun. Time is above the authority of earthly princes; it will not hear them though they command or beg it to delay its course by the smallest moment. Crowns and kingdoms would be no price to hire it to linger while you draw another breath.
Your lives are not like the garments of the Israelites in the wilderness, which did not wear out, but rather like the provisions of the Gibeonites, worn and wasted while you travel only a little way. And is time so swift, and you so slow? Will you stand still and watch it pass as though you had no use for it, no work to do, and no account to give?
Direction 9. Consider also how irrecoverable time is once it has passed. Take it now, or it is lost forever. All the people on earth, with all their power and all their ingenuity, cannot recall one minute that is gone. All the riches in the world cannot redeem it by reversing even one of those hours or moments you so lavishly threw away for nothing. If you cried and called after it until your heart broke, it would not return. Many thousands have proved this by bitter experience and have cried out too late: "O that we had now that time again which we made so light of!" But not one of them ever obtained their wish. No more will you.
Take it, therefore, while you have it. Time is now as freely given to the poorest beggar as to the greatest prince; it is as much yours as his. Though in your youth and foolishness you spend it as from a full heap, as if time would never have an end, you will find it is not like the widow’s oil or the loaves and fishes, multiplied by miracle. The hour is coming when you will wish you had gathered the fragments and the smallest crumbs, so that nothing of so precious a commodity had been lost, even the little minutes you thought you could neglect without loss. Try whether you can stop the present moment, or recall what has already gone, before you belittle or idle away any more, lest you repent too late.
Direction 10. Think also how very little time you have, and how close you always stand to eternity. Cicero wrote: I take my leave of life as of an inn, not as of a home; for nature has given us a lodging to stay in for a while, not a house to live in. "Is there not an appointed time to man upon earth? Are not his days also like the days of an hireling?" (Job 7:1) "Man that is born of a woman is of few days and full of trouble: he cometh forth like a flower, and is cut down: he fleeth also as a shadow and continueth not." (Job 14:1–2) "Now my days are swifter than a post: they flee away: they see no good: they are passed away as the swift ships, as the eagle that hasteth to the prey." (Job 9:25–26)
What is this brief, hurrying inch of time? How quickly will it all be gone! Look back on all the time that is past: if you have lived sixty or eighty years, what is it now? Does it not seem as yesterday since you were a child? Do not days and nights wheel on swiftly? How short is your stay on earth! How small a span of time will leave you in eternity! What a swift and tiny moment will bring you to the state in which you must remain forever!
Every night is as the death or end of one of the few days allotted to you here. How little a while remains until your mortal sickness, until you must lie under lingering decay and pain, until your vital powers surrender their office, your pulse ceases, and your soul takes its silent, unnoticed flight, leaving your body to be hidden in darkness and carried by your friends to the common earth. How short a time lies between this present moment and the digging of your grave, between your pleasures in the flesh and your sad farewell, when you must say of all your pleasures, "They are gone!"; and between your cares and business for this world and your entrance into another world, where all these vanities count for nothing.
How short is the time between your sin and your account in judgment, between the pleasure and the pain, between the patient holiness of the godly and their full reward of endless joy! Can you spare any part of so short a life? Has God allotted you so little time, and can you spare the devil any of that little? Is it not all barely enough for so great a work as is necessary for a safe and peaceful death? When sloth or pleasure would take their share, remember how little you have in all, how small a stock you draw from, how little remains for the one thing necessary, the securing of eternal life, and how unseasonable it is to be playing away time, so near the entrance into the endless world.
Direction 11. Remember also how uncertain that little time is which you must have. As you know it will be short, so you do not know how short. You have never seen a day or hour in which you could be sure of seeing another. Is it reasonable to idle or throw away a day or hour which, for all you know, may be your last? You think that though you are not certain, you are likely to have more, but nothing hazardous should be admitted into a matter of such weight.
When the longest life is short, and when so frail a body, subject to hundreds of ailments and accidents, along with so sinful a soul, makes it not merely possible but probable that the thread of your life will be cut off well before its natural end, when so many die young for every one who reaches old age, is not the uncertainty of your time a great aggravation of the sin of failing to redeem it?
If you were sure you had but one year to live, it might make you wise enough to see that you had no time to spare. And yet you waste it, not knowing whether you will live another day. Many a person this week is trifling away their time who will be dead the next week, yet who would have spent it better had they merely expected to die the following year.
What if death comes before you have made your necessary preparation? Where are you then? When time is uncertain as well as short, do you not have work of sufficient weight to fill it? If Christ had set you to attend and follow him in the greatest holiness for a thousand years, would you not have gladly done it? And yet can you not hold out for so short a life? Can you not watch with him one hour? Christ himself was moved by the nearness of his death to a swift completion of the works of his life. Should we not be moved likewise?
He sent to prepare his last supper with his disciples in these words: "My time is at hand: I will keep the passover at thy house with my disciples." (Matt 26:18) And in Luke 22:15: "With desire have I desired to eat this passover with you before I suffer." So you too should say, "My time is short; my death is at hand; it therefore concerns me to live in the knowledge and communion of God before I pass from here into his presence," especially since, as Ecclesiastes 9:12 teaches, "man knoweth not his time."
Many thousands would have prepared better had they known when their time would end. "But know this, that if the good man of the house had known in what watch the thief would come, he would have watched, and would not have suffered his house to be broken up: therefore be ye also ready; for in such an hour as ye think not, the Son of man cometh." (Matt 24:43) "Take ye heed, watch and pray; for ye know not when the time is." (Mark 13:33)
Direction 12. Never forget who is kept waiting on you while you are idling or sinning away your time: how the patience and mercy of God are waiting for you, and how the sun and moon and all created things are meanwhile attending upon you. Must God stand by while you go on a little longer abusing and offending him? Must God wait until your cards and dice and pride and worldly, unnecessary cares dismiss you and spare you for his service? Must he wait on the devil and the world and the flesh, taking their leavings and staying until they have finished with you?
Can you be surprised if he makes you pay for this? If he turns away and leaves you to spend your time in as much vanity and idleness as you desire? Must God and all his creatures wait on a careless sinner while he is at his fleshly pleasures? Must life and time be continued to him while he does nothing worthy of his life and time? "The longsuffering of God did wait on the disobedient in the days of Noah." (1 Pet 3:20) But how dearly did they pay for their contempt of that forbearance?
Direction 13. Consider soberly the ends for which God has given you your life and time. God did not make such a creature as man for nothing, and he never gave you an hour of time for nothing. The life and time of animals and plants are given to serve you; but what is yours for? Can you honestly believe that any of your time has been given to you in vain? When you are drowsing it away, idling it, or playing it away, do you sincerely believe you are wisely and honestly fulfilling the ends of your creation, your redemption, and your hourly preservation?
Do you think God is so unwise, or so indifferent to your time and your life, as to give you more than you need? You would blame your tailor if he cut out more cloth than your garment requires, and you would blame your shoemaker if he made your shoes too large; yet do you suppose God is so lavish with time, or so unskilled in his works of providence, as to allot you more time than the work he has appointed for you requires? He who will call you to account for everything has certainly given you nothing in vain. If you can find an hour for which you have nothing to do and must give no account, let that be your hour of leisure. But if you truly knew your need, your danger, your hopes, and your work, you would never dream of having time to spare.
For my own part, I must tell you: if you have time to spare, your situation is very different from mine. It is the daily burden of my mind to see how slowly my work advances and how swiftly my time passes, and how much I am likely to leave undone that I long to complete. The work is great and important, and the life in which it must be done, if it is ever to be done, is short. Even if every day were ten times as long, it would not be too long for the work that is daily before me, not as my immediate duty (for God does not require impossibilities), yet exceedingly desirable to be done.
It is the work that makes time a mercy; time exists for the sake of the work. If the work required of me by the good of the church and of my own soul were done, how gladly I could welcome the ending of my time, and say with Simeon, "Lord, now lettest thou thy servant depart in peace." Remember, then, that God never gave you one minute to spend in vain; even your rest, your ease, and your recreations must be only such, and so much, as fit you for your work, assist it, and do not hinder it. He redeemed and preserves us, that we "might serve him in holiness and righteousness before him all the days of our lives." (Luke 1:74–75)
Direction 14. Remember always that the time of this short, uncertain life is all you will ever have for your preparation for your endless life. When this time is spent, whether well or ill, you will have no more. God will not grant another earthly life to those who have wasted this one. (See my book Now or Never.) There is no returning from the dead to correct what you did wrong here. Whatever good you intend to do must be done now; whatever grace you would gain must be gained now; whatever preparation for eternity you would ever make must be made now. "Behold, now is the accepted time! Behold, now is the day of salvation." (2 Cor 6:2) "Wherefore, as the Holy Ghost saith, To-day if you will hear his voice, harden not your hearts. But exhort one another daily, while it is called to-day, lest any of you be hardened by the deceitfulness of sin." Hebrews 3:7, 13
Have you but one life here to live, and will you lose it, or any part of it? Your time is already measured out; the glass is turned upon you. "And the angel lifted up his hand to heaven, and sware by him that liveth for ever and ever, that time should be no longer." (Rev 10:5–6) Therefore "whatever thy hand findeth to do, do it with thy might: for there is no work, nor device, nor knowledge, nor wisdom in the grave whither thou goest." (Eccl 9:10) What then remains but that, "the time being short, and the fashion of these things passing away," you use the world as if you used it not, and redeem this time for your eternal happiness? (1 Cor 7:29)
Direction 15. Remember always that sin and Satan will waste no time, and so it concerns you to waste none either. "The devil your adversary goeth about like a roaring lion, seeking whom he may devour." (1 Pet 5:8) "Be sober" therefore and "vigilant to resist him." (1 Pet 5:7, 9) If he is busy while you are idle, if he is at work spreading his nets and laying his snares while you are at play and paying him no mind, the outcome is easy to predict.
When your enemy is fighting while you sit still or sleep, it is easy to foretell who will have the victory. The weeds of corruption are continually growing; sin, like a constant spring, keeps running; the world keeps enticing; and the flesh keeps inclining toward its forbidden pleasures. None of these enemies will call a truce or a ceasefire with you, sitting still as long as you sit still. Far from sparing you while you are idle or gratifying the flesh, your very idleness and fleshly indulgence is itself the fruit and evidence of their industry and their success. Waste no time, then, and admit no interruptions to your work, until you can persuade your enemies to do the same.
Direction 16. Consider what a senseless contradiction it is to cherish your life so dearly, yet to throw away your time. What is your time but the duration of your life? You are reluctant to die, reluctant to see your time come to an end, yet you squander it as prodigally as if you were weary of it or longed to be rid of it. Is it only the final hours you are unwilling to lose? Are not the middle portions equally precious, equally to be saved and used well? Or do you merely wish to have time, but not to use it?
No means are good for anything except in advancing the end they serve; a means that does you no good is worthless to you. To possess food or clothing without any use of them is as bad as going without. If you saw a man trembling with fear lest his purse be stolen, yet reaching in himself and throwing away his money, or trading it all for a straw or a feather, what would you think of that man’s judgment? Yet you do the same and worse when you dread death’s ending of your time, while you yourself idle it away and play it away, trading it for a little worldly gain.
But I know how it really is with you: it is for the present pleasure of the flesh, and for the mere sweetness of living, that you value life and are so reluctant to die, not for any higher ends. This is to be brutish, to strip away your humanity, and to degrade your life even while you idolize it. Such are the mad contradictions that sin produces. You make life your ultimate end, desiring to live merely for life itself or for its pleasures, and so you make life stand in place of God and heaven, which should properly be your end. Yet by not directing life toward those higher ends, and using it only for present pleasure, you degrade yourself and your life, as though man differed from a dog or any other brute only in some poor degree of present pleasure.
Direction 17. Consider that in losing time, you lose all the mercies that time contains. Time is full of great and priceless mercies; it is the cabinet that holds the jewels. Throw away the purse and you throw away the money inside it. What might you gain in those precious hours you cast away! What a far richer treasure than money might you win! What a far sweeter pleasure than any game or sport might you enjoy! You could be seeking God for life eternal. You could be exercising and increasing grace. You could be beholding by faith the blessed place and company in which you may dwell forever. All this, and more, you are losing while you are losing time.
You choose as a pleasure what is in truth a heavy curse: "Your strength shall be spent in vain." (Lev 26:20) Why not also take it for a pleasure to throw away your gold or your health? A very little time is worth far more than a great quantity of gold and silver; and it is this more precious commodity that you are casting away.
Direction 18. Think seriously about how Christ, his apostles, and his holiest servants in every age spent their time. They spent it in praying, preaching, spiritual conversation, doing good, and carrying out the duties of their outward callings in service of these things, not in cards, dice, dancing, stage-plays, or indulging the flesh, nor in the pursuit of worldly profit and honor. I read that Christ spent "all night in praying" (Luke 6:12), but nowhere that he spent an hour in playing.
I know you will say that you do not expect to reach their degree of holiness. But remember: a person is not sincere who does not desire to be perfect; a person is graceless who willfully holds onto a cherished sin that he would not rather be delivered from, and who willfully refuses any duty that he would not rather perform as he ought. And you are the more needy, even as Christ, his apostles, and his servants were the more holy. The poor have more need to beg, to work, and to be careful with what they have than the rich. If Christ and his holiest servants were careful with their time and spent it in works of holiness and obedience, do you not have greater need to do the same? Do you not have more need to pray, to learn God’s Word, and to prepare for death than Christ and his apostles had? Are you not further behind, having already lost so much time? Let your needs instruct you.
Direction 19. Do not forget that a time of great demand may come when you will find everything you could have gathered by the most diligent redeeming of time to be too little. If a garrison expects a siege so fierce and prolonged that it will exhaust their provisions, they prepare accordingly so as not to perish by famine. Temptations may grow stronger, and then you will find that you should have been gathering strength now to overcome them, and should have bestirred yourself in the day of getting, so that you might stand firm in the evil day.
Those who now loiter and waste their time, and do not gather knowledge and the strength of grace, are the ones who fall when trial comes. When suffering for righteousness’ sake surrounds you like a siege, when poverty, wrongs, provocations, sickness, and the face of death press in on every side, you will find that all your faith, hope, love, and comfort feel too little. Then you will wish that you had roused yourself now and laid in better provision, and "laid up a good foundation or treasure in store for the time to come" (1 Tim 6:19).
Direction 20. Last, do not forget how time is valued by the damned, whose time and hope are gone forever; and how you yourself will value it if sin carries your soul into that dreadful state. What would those miserable souls now give, if they could, for even one day’s time on the terms of mercy that you now enjoy? Cicero wrote that death is terrible to those for whom all things are extinguished along with their life. Would they sleep it away, or amuse themselves with games and diversions, while God was offering them Christ and grace? Do you suppose they do not set a far higher price on time and mercy than sinners on earth do? Does it not tear their hearts forever to remember how madly they consumed their lives and wasted the only time given them to prepare for salvation?
Do those in hell now think that those who idle and play away their time on earth are wise? No. Their feeling and experience sufficiently refute all that time-wasters now plead for their sottish prodigality. I do not believe you can genuinely believe God’s Word concerning the state of damned souls and at the same time believe that your idle and vain use of time would not rack your conscience and make you rage against yourself, if sin ever brought you there. Then you would see that you had weightier matters on which to have spent your time, and that time deserved far higher esteem and use. O, beseech the Lord to spare you from such a conviction, and to give you a heart to prize your time before it is gone, and to know its worth before you feel the lack of it.
Title 2. Contemplative Directions for Redeeming Opportunity
Opportunity or season is the flower of time. All time is precious, but the season is most precious of all. The present moment is the season for works of present necessity; and all other works have their particular seasons, which must not be allowed to slip. (See the many aggravations of sinful delay in my Directions for Sound Conversion.)
Direction 1. Remember that the great difference between the happy saint and the unhappy world is this: one is wise in time, and the other is wise too late. The godly know when knowledge will do good; the wicked know only when knowledge will torment them. Every person you now see who stands so violently opposed in judgment to the godly will hold the very same opinion shortly, but when it can do them no good. Bear with their contradiction and hostility, for it will last only a very little while.
There is not one furious enemy of holiness who will not confess before long that holiness was best. Do they now despise it as tedious, fanciful hypocrisy? They will soon know it was nothing but the cure of a disordered mind, and the necessary duty owed to God, which both religion and right reason command. Do they now ask of sin, "What harm is in it?" They will soon know that sin is the poison of the soul, worse than any misery or death. They will think more highly of the worth of Christ, of the necessity of all possible diligence for the soul, of the preciousness of time, of the wisdom of the godly, of the excellencies of heaven, and of the Word of God and all holy means, than any of those whom they now reproach for holding such views.
But what good will that do them? No more than it did Adam to know good and evil. No more than it profits a man when he is dead to know what disease killed him. No more than it profits a man to know what is poison after he has taken it and is beyond remedy. The thief will be wise at the gallows; the prodigal spendthrift will be wise when everything is gone. But those who would be safe and happy must be wise in time.
The godly know the worth of heaven before it is lost; the misery of damnation before they feel it; the necessity of a Savior while he is willing to be a Savior to them; the evil of sin before it has undone them; the preciousness of time before it is gone; the worth of mercy while mercy may be had; and the need of praying while praying may prevail. They do not sleep until the door is shut and then knock and cry, "Lord, open to us," as the foolish ones did (Matt 25). They are not like the miserable world, who will not believe until they come where devils believe and tremble, nor repent until torment forces them to repent.
As ever you would escape the dearly bought experience of fools, be wise in time. Do not leave conscience to answer all your cries, laments, and fruitless wishes with the doleful refrain, "Too late! Too late!" Know now by a living faith what wicked men will know by feeling and experience when it is too late, and you will not perish. Live now as the enemies of holiness will wish they had lived when it is too late, and you will be happy. Now God may be found:
"Seek the Lord while he may be found, and call upon him while he is near. Let the wicked forsake his way, and the unrighteous man his thoughts, and let him return unto the Lord, and he will have mercy upon him, and to our God, for he will abundantly pardon." Isaiah 55:6–7
Read the sorrowful lamentation of Christ over Jerusalem (Luke 19:41–42), and then consider what it means to neglect the season of mercy and salvation: "He beheld the city and wept over it, saying, If thou hadst known, even thou, at least in this thy day, the things which belong unto thy peace! But now they are hidden from thine eyes!"
Direction 2. Remember that to neglect the season is to frustrate and destroy the work. When the season is past, the work cannot be done. If you do not sow at sowing time, it will be useless at any other time. If you do not reap and gather in harvest, it is too late in winter to hope for fruit. If you wait until the tide has gone, or fail to catch the wind that serves your course, your voyage may be beyond attempting. Not all work can be done at all times. Christ himself said, "I must work while it is day: the night cometh when no man can work" (John 9:4). Do not say then, "The next day may serve the turn"; the next day has its own work, and you must do both.
Direction 3. Consider that even if the work should not prove impossible, it will still be difficult out of season, when in its season it might be done with ease. How easily can you swim with the tide, sail with the wind, or shape iron while it is still hot? Many a disease that could have been cured if caught in time becomes incurable afterward. You can bend a tender twig and pull up a small plant with ease, but once it has grown into a tree, neither bending nor uprooting it is possible. When you complain of difficulties in religion, ask yourself whether losing the right season, and failing to acquaint yourself with God sooner, is not the very cause.
Direction 4. Consider that work done out of season is not as good or acceptable, even if you could do it. "Every thing is beautiful in its season" (Eccl 3:11). To speak a "word in season to the weary" is the skill of faithful messengers of peace (Isa 50:4). When out of season, good can be turned into evil. Who thanks you for giving medicine, food, or clothing to the dead? Or for pitying the poor when it is too late? In time, all these things may be received with gratitude.
Direction 5. Remember that if you neglect the season, you are left to uncertainties of time, of means, and of grace. Lose this time, and for all you know, you lose everything. Or if you have more time, it may be cursed with barrenness, and fruit may never grow on it again. Preachers may be taken from you; godly company may be taken from you; helps and means may be turned into hindrances, opposition, and strong temptations, and then you will discover what it cost to neglect the season.
Or if all your helps and means continue, how do you know that God will work through his grace, bless them to you, and move your heart? He may determine that if you resist him now, his Spirit will strive with you no more. If while it is called today you harden your heart, he may resolve to leave you to the hardness of Pharaoh, to get himself a name upon you, and use you as vessels of wrath, prepared by your neglect and obstinacy for destruction.
Direction 6. Consider how all creation keeps its proper seasons in the service God has appointed for you. The sun rises and sets at its season, keeping its daily and annual course without missing a minute. So do all the other celestial motions. You have day and night, seedtime and harvest, summer and winter, spring and fall, all exactly in their seasons. "Yea, the stork in the heavens knoweth her appointed time, and the turtle, and the crane, and the swallow observe the time of their coming: but my people know not the judgment of the LORD" (Jer 8:7). Shall only humanity neglect its season?
Direction 7. Consider how carefully you observe the season for your worldly labors, and should you not do so far more in greater things? You will not plow when you should reap, nor do summer’s work in winter. You will not lie in bed all day and go about your business at night. You inquire and learn to recognize the seasons for your benefit and safety in this world: should you not do so far more for a better world? "O ye hypocrites! ye can discern the face of the sky; but can ye not discern the signs of the times?" (Matt 16:3). As at harvest you look for the fruit of your land, so God in season expects fruit from you (Mark 12:2). The godly are "like a tree that is planted by the river’s side, which bringeth forth its fruit in season" (Ps 1:3). Shall worldlings know their season, and shall we not?
Direction 8. Consider how vigilant the wicked are to know and seize their season for doing evil, and how much more vigilant we should be in doing good. Seducers take their opportunity to deceive. The thief and the adulterer take the cover of secrecy and darkness. The ambitious and the covetous watch for their moment of profit and advancement. The malicious wait for their chance at revenge. Have we not more need and more encouragement than any of them? Is it time for the wicked to build their houses and grow great through covetousness and oppression, and not time for you to honor God and provide for your endless life? They "cannot sleep unless they do evil" (Prov 4:16). Can you sleep securely while time passes and your work remains undone?
Direction 9. Remember that the devil watches for the season of temptation in order to destroy you. He succeeds largely by choosing his moment, catching you unarmed, forgetful of God, and resting in careless prosperity, when you are most likely to listen to his temptations. Those same temptations, offered at another time, might not prevail. Will you let your enemy outmaneuver you?
Direction 10. Consider how earnest you are with God in your necessities and distress, not only asking him to relieve and help you, but to do it speedily and in season. You would rather he act before the moment passes than let it slip by. You grow impatient until deliverance comes and can hardly wait for it to ripen. When you are in pain and sickness you cry for swift relief, and are ready to say, "How long, Lord, how long?", and with David, "The time, yea, the set time is come" (Ps 102:13); "Make no longer tarrying, O my God" (Ps 40:17). It would not satisfy you if God said he would ease your pain next year. Why then do you neglect the time of duty and use so many delays with God? He gives you all your mercies in their season. Why then do you not in season give yourself up to his love and service, when you have his promise that you shall "reap in due season if you do not faint"? (Gal 6:9)
CHAPTER 5
PRACTICAL DIRECTIONS FOR REDEEMING TIME
Direction 1. The first point in the art of redeeming time is to attend first, with the greatest care and diligence, to the greatest works of absolute necessity, those which must be done, or else we are undone forever.
First, make sure that the great work of a sound conversion or sanctification has truly been accomplished within you. Secure your saving interest in Christ. Gain assurance of your adoption and peace with God, and of your right to everlasting life. Be able to prove to your own conscience from the Word of God, and from your regenerate, heavenly heart and life, that your soul is justified and safe, and that you could receive the news of death with comfort, whenever it is sent to call you away.
When you have done even this much, you will incur no loss of time that amounts to the loss of your soul or happiness. Much more work still remains, for yourself and for others, yet when this much is soundly done, you have secured the main thing. If you lose the time in which you should have been renewed by the Spirit of Christ, and in which you should have laid up treasure in heaven, you are lost forever.
Be sure, therefore, to look to this first. After that, if you lose the time in which you might have grown wealthy or gained advancement, the loss is bearable, you know the worst of it; you can see the end of it. Even if you lose the time in which you should have grown in holiness and built up others, the loss is grievous, but it will not cost you heaven. So, as Solomon instructs the farmer, "Prepare thy work without, and make it fit for thyself in the field; and afterwards build thine house" (Prov 24:27), I advise you to see first that the necessary work is done. When it is done and done well, you may go quietly and cheerfully about the rest: "Seek first the kingdom of God and his righteousness." What an immense amount is accomplished when this is accomplished!
Direction 2. Learn to understand clearly the relative weight of duties, which is greater and which is less, so that when two seem to demand your time at once, you know which to prefer.
This means knowing not only which duty is greatest in itself and in the abstract, but which is greatest for you, at that season, and with all circumstances considered. A great part of the art of redeeming time consists in this wise discernment and practice: giving precedence to the greater duty.
A person wastes time who earns a penny when he could earn a pound; who visits a neighbor when he should be attending his prince; who weeds his garden when there is a fire burning in his house, even though what he is doing is good in itself. In the same way, one wastes time who prefers the body over the soul, or man before God, or morally indifferent things before necessary ones, or private duties before public ones, or the less edifying before the more edifying, or sacrifice before necessary mercy. The ordering of good works I have explained before, in Chapter III, Direction 10, which you may consult.
Direction 3. Be acquainted with the proper season of every duty, and the duty of each season; and take them in their time.
When duties are rightly ordered, one helps another along. When they are misplaced and disordered, they work against one another, consume your time with distracting difficulties, and leave you lost in confusion. Take morning prayer as an example: if you take the morning hour, or the fittest available hour, you can perform it quietly, undisturbed by your other affairs. But if that season is missed, you will scarcely perform it at all, or perform it almost as poorly as if you had not done it. The same principle holds for matters of conscience, reproof, reading, hearing, meditation, and every other duty.
A wise and practiced Christian should bring his affairs into such order that every ordinary duty has its appointed place, and all are linked like the parts of a chain, each drawing the next along, or like the parts of a clock or other mechanism, which must all work together, each rightly positioned. A workman who has all his tools thrown in a heap spends much of the day searching for the tool he needs rather than using it. The workman who knows where every tool is kept can take it up at once and lose no time. If my books are piled in a heap, I may spend half the day looking for the one I need; but if they are set in order and I know their places, that time is saved. So it is with the right timing of our duties.
Direction 4. Live continually under the government of God; keep conscience tender and active in its proper work; and always be ready to render an account to God and conscience of what you do.
If you live under the government of God, you will constantly be doing his work, keeping his judgment before you, and testing your actions to see whether he approves them, and this will keep you from all time-wasting vanities. If you keep conscience tender, it will promptly check and reprove you for your sin: when you waste even a minute of time, conscience will name the loss. A "seared conscience" is "past feeling" (Eph 4:19 1 Tim 4:2) and will surrender you to "lasciviousness," treating the loss of time as a small matter, or at least will not effectively call you to account for either the sin or the loss.
If you keep conscience active in its office, it will frequently ask you what you are doing and test your works. It will take account of time as it passes and ask how you have spent each day and hour. And as Seneca could say, "He will be the more careful what he does, and how he spends the day, who looks to be called to a reckoning for it every night." This will make the foreseen day of judgment hold you in continual awe, as though you were about to stand before it at any moment, while conscience, in light of that day, is continually pre-judging you. Those who have silenced or dismissed conscience are like schoolboys who bolt the door against their master, intending to spend in play the time they should have spent in learning. The reckoning that comes afterward pays for all.
For the further direction of your consciences, I will set down a few rules for the right spending of your time.
1. Spend it in nothing, as a deliberate moral act, that is not truly, directly, or remotely an act of obedience to some law of God. (I am not speaking of purely natural acts that are no objects of moral choice.)
2. Spend it in nothing that you know must be repented of.
3. Spend it in nothing for which you cannot, or dare not, warrantably ask God’s blessing.
4. Spend it in nothing that you would not be willing to review at the hour of death with an awakened, well-informed mind.
5. Spend it in nothing that you would not be willing to hear of on the day of judgment.
6. Spend it in nothing in which you could not safely and comfortably be found, if death were to surprise you in the act.
7. Spend it in nothing that flesh-pleasing persuades you to, against your conscience, or with a secret unease or doubt of conscience.
8. Spend it in nothing that has no tendency, directly or remotely, toward your ultimate end: the pleasing of God and enjoying him in love forever.
9. Spend it in nothing that tends to do more harm than good, that would do great harm to yourself or others under pretense of accomplishing some small good that could perhaps be better done another way.
10. Lastly, spend it in nothing that is a lesser good when a greater good ought to be done.
Direction 5. Do your best to settle where there are the greatest helps and fewest hindrances to the redeeming of your time. Work harder to fit your home, your circumstances, and your occupation to the great ends of your life and time than to your worldly honor, ease, or wealth.
Live where the trading for the soul is best. Under God’s ordinary blessing, you may gain more in one year in a godly household, in the company of fruitful believers, and under an able and godly minister, than in many years in a barren setting, among the ignorant, the cold-hearted, or the profane, where we must say with David, "I held my peace even from good, while the wicked is before me" (Ps 39:1–2). In such surroundings you must accomplish whatever good you do through heavy opposition, facing great disadvantages and difficulties that will quickly stop hearts as dull and reluctant as ours.
If you prefer worldly gain over your soul in choosing your situation, and plunge yourself into distracting business and company, your time will run in a wrong and unprofitable channel.
Direction 6. Plan ahead with your best skill to prevent obstacles and to carry out your work most effectively. If you leave everything to the moment of action, many hindrances will arise that prudent foresight could have prevented, and you will lose much time to them. In improving the Lord’s Day, for example, if you have not arranged your affairs beforehand so that everything gives way to holy duties, you will meet with so many disturbances and temptations that you will lose much of your time and profit. The same applies to family duties, private duties, meditation, study, and the work of your calling. If you do not anticipate what hindrances are likely to arise so that you can head them off in advance, you must expect to lose much time and suffer much disappointment.
Direction 7. Patiently endure some smaller inconvenience and loss in order to avoid greater loss, and to redeem time for more important duties; and let minor things be resolutely cleared out of your way when they would draw away your time by imperceptible degrees. The devil would cunningly steal by drops what he cannot persuade you to throw away all at once. A person who would never spend recklessly in large amounts may still drain away everything by disregarding small ones. You will find pleas of decency and propriety, civility, good manners, the avoidance of offense and censure, and even apparent necessity, all pressing to draw your precious time away little by little; and if you are easy enough to yield, nearly all of it will be wasted by this temptation.
Consider, for instance, if you are ministers of Christ, whose time must be given to your studies, your pulpits, conference with your people, and visiting and watching over them. Your daily groan is that time is short and work is long, that you are forced to omit so many necessary studies and to pass by so many needy souls for lack of time. Yet if you do not keep a close watch, and will not bear some censure and offense, you will lose even the time you now use well.
Your friends around you will be tempting and telling you: "This friend absolutely must be visited; that friend must be courteously received; you must not dismiss them so quickly; they expect more of your time and company; you are much obliged to them; they will call you uncivil and unsociable. Here is a scholar who has come to make your acquaintance, he will take it ill and misrepresent you to others if you do not give him time for some familiar conversation. He has never been with you before and has never yet taken any of your time." And the next visitor, and the one after that, says exactly the same thing. "Someone called on you, and you must return the visit. There is this journey that simply must be made, and this business and that which simply must be done."
Indeed, one’s own household affairs will steal away all his time if he does not keep a close watch. There will be this servant to speak to, another to hear, family members to attend to, and an abundance of small things to manage, too minor to be named individually, about food and drink and clothing and dressing, house and goods and servants and work, tradesmen and messengers and marketing and payments and livestock and a hundred other things too many to enumerate, each taking a little of your time, and all those little portions added together will amount to all of it.
There is a fitting comparison here: a covetous usurer, in order to purchase a position of honor, agreed for one month to give a penny to everyone who asked him. Word spread quickly through the city, and so many came for their pennies that they took everything he had, and he was forced to relinquish his position of honor because he had nothing left to sustain it. In the same way, an eminent and much-valued minister draws upon himself such a multitude of acquaintances, each expecting a little of his time, that together they leave him almost none for his studies. Not only is his conscience wounded, but his gifts are smothered and his work is starved and poorly done, with the result that his very admirers begin to think as little of him as of others, and all because of their own insistent demands.
It is much the same with our yearly expenditure of money: almost as much goes in small, unnamed, incidental, and unforeseen charges, for which no account can be given in advance, as goes in food, clothing, and the ordinary known expenses. So it will be with your precious time if you are not very careful and resolute. You will find such a press of minor matters, each requiring a little and one beginning where the other ends, that when you review your time after it is gone, you will see that Satan was too cunning for you and cheated you by drawing you into what seemed to be necessities. This is the principal reason why marriage and keeping house are so unsuitable for a pastor of the church who is able to avoid them: they bring upon him just such an abundance of small, unforeseeable diversions.
In this situation a conscientious person, in whatever calling, must be resolute. After he has done his reasonable best to satisfy those who expect something of him and to put aside diversions, if that is not enough, he must disregard them, set them aside, and break free, even if it costs him in his estate, his reputation, or his peace, and even if he is censured as imprudent, uncivil, unsociable, or neglectful of his friends. God must be pleased, whatever displeasure others take. His approval alone must satisfy our minds in place of all other approval. Time must be preserved, whatever else is lost or wasted. The great things must be done, whatever becomes of the lesser, though where both can be done, and the lesser does not hinder the greater nor rob us of time from necessary things, we must take care of both.
Direction 8. Work to keep yourself always well furnished and prepared for every duty that may come your way. Just as a preacher who would not waste his time must come well prepared, so one who would not waste his time in solitude must always be furnished with material for profitable meditation; and one who would redeem his time in company must always be furnished with material for profitable conversation. A person who is full will be ready to pour out to others, and will not fall silent and lose his time for lack of material, skill, or zeal, for in those three things your provision consists. An ignorant, empty person lacks material for thought and speech. An imprudent person lacks the skill to use what he has. A careless, cold, indifferent person lacks the life to set his faculties in motion, the oil and drive to set the wheels of soul and body turning.
Consider in the morning what company you are likely to meet and what duties you are likely to face, and prepare yourself accordingly before you go out, with material and with resolution. Beyond the general preparation of habitual knowledge, charity, and zeal, which is the chief thing, you should also make particular preparation for the duties of each day. A workman who is strong and healthy and has all his tools ready and in order will accomplish more in a day than a sick man, or one who lacks tools, or one who keeps them dull and unfit for use, will accomplish in many.
"The mouth of the righteous speaketh wisdom, and his tongue talketh of judgment," and no wonder, since "the law of his God is in his heart: none of his steps shall slide" (Ps 37:30–31). "Out of the abundance of the heart the mouth speaketh: a good man out of the good treasure of his heart bringeth forth good things" (Matt 12:35). "Every scribe which is instructed to the kingdom of heaven, is like a man that is an householder that bringeth forth out of his treasure things new and old" (Matt 13:52).
Direction 9. Do not promise yourself a long life, but live as those who are always uncertain of another day and who know they must shortly depart from here. The groundless expectation of long life is a very great hindrance to the redeeming of time. People spend freely when they believe their purse is full, but would be careful if they knew they had little left or were likely to come to want. Young and healthy people face the greatest temptation to waste time. They are inclined to think they have plenty of time before them, and that although death is possible soon, it is more likely they will live long. By putting the day of death far from their minds, they lose all the warnings that the nearness of death brings to those who always expect it, and therefore lose the wisdom, zeal, and diligence necessary to redeeming their time.
Pray therefore as the psalmist prays: "So teach us to number our days, that we may apply our hearts unto wisdom" (Ps 90:12). Do not dream of rest and plenty for many years when you have no promise of life until the next morning (Luke 12:19–20). When people perceive that death is at hand and time is nearly ended, almost all of them appear to value time highly and promise to spend it better if only God would give them another chance. Therefore keep yourself continually aware that death is even now at hand and time nearly ended. This will make you continually wiser than death makes most people, and will lead you to redeem your time now, rather than merely resolving, as others do, to redeem it when it is too late.
Direction 10. Sanctify everything you have and do, dedicating it to God, and let Holiness to the Lord be written upon all of it. Whether you eat or drink, let your ultimate aim be his glory. Make all your civil relationships, possessions, and employments holy in this way, directing them to the service and pleasure of God and to the everlasting good of yourself and others, and weaving holy meditation and prayer through them all at fitting times. This is why we are told to "pray continually," and "in all things give thanks" (1 Thess 5:17–18); and "in all things to make known our requests to God, in prayer, supplication, and giving of thanks" (Phil 4:6); and that "all things are sanctified by the word and prayer." This sacred alchemy, which turns our whole way of life, our possessions, and our actions into something holy, is an outstanding part of the art of redeeming time.
Direction 11. Last, learn to recognize the great thieves that rob people of their time and the devil’s methods of enticing them to waste it, and live in continual watchfulness against them. It is a more necessary thrift to be sparing and careful with your time than with your money. It matters more to keep a constant watch against the things that would steal your time than against the thieves who would break into your house or rob you on the road. Those who would tempt you to the loss of time are to be treated as enemies and avoided. I will now name these thieves and time-wasters, so that you may recognize them and save your time and souls from their deceits.
Title 4. The Thieves or Time-Wasters to Be Watchfully Avoided
Thief 1. One of the greatest time-wasting sins is idleness, or sloth. The slothful watch their time pass away and their work left undone, and they can hear of the necessity of redeeming it, and yet they cannot bring themselves to stir. Even when convinced that a duty must be done, they keep delaying and putting it off from day to day, always saying they will do it tomorrow or later. Tomorrow is always the sluggard’s working day; today is his idle day. He spends his time in fruitless wishes: he lies in bed or sits idle and wishes this were labor; he feasts his flesh and wishes this were fasting; he follows his sports and pleasures and wishes this were prayer and a mortified life; he lets his heart run after lust, pride, or covetousness, and wishes this were heavenly-mindedness and laying up treasure above.
So it is that "the soul of the sluggard desireth, and hath nothing: but the soul of the diligent shall be made fat" (Prov 13:4). "The desire of the slothful killeth him; for his hands refuse to labour" (Prov 21:25). Every small opposition or difficulty will turn him aside from duty. "The sluggard will not plow by reason of the cold; therefore shall he beg in harvest, and have nothing" (Prov 20:4). "The slothful man saith, There is a lion without, I shall be slain in the streets" (Prov 22:13). "As the door turneth upon his hinges, so doth the slothful upon his bed. The slothful hideth his hand in his bosom; it grieveth him to bring it again to his mouth." And in the end his sloth corrupts his reason, bribing it to plead the cause of his own negligence: "The sluggard is wiser in his own conceit, than seven men that can render a reason" (Prov 26:14–16).
Time will slide on, duty will be left undone, and your souls will be undone, if impious slothfulness reigns. "The way of the slothful man is as a hedge of thorns: but the way of the righteous is made plain" (Prov 15:19). You will always seem to face so many difficulties that you will never make a successful journey of it. What is more, even when engaged in duty, the slothful person is still losing time. He prays as if he does not pray, and labors as if he does not labor, as if the fruit of holiness passed away as quickly as worldly pleasures. He moves as slowly as a snail, covers little ground, accomplishes little work, resists opposition so feebly, that it amounts to almost nothing, barely more than sitting still and doing nothing at all.
It is a sad thing that people should not only lose their time in sinful pleasures, but also lose it in reading, hearing, and praying, by doing everything in a heartless drowsiness. "He also that is slothful in his work is brother to him that is a great waster" (Prov 18:9). If he begins in the Spirit and for a short burst seems earnest, he flags and tires and ends in the flesh. "The slothful roasteth not that which he took in hunting; but the substance of a diligent man is precious" (Prov 12:27). If he sees and confesses a vice, he has no heart to rise against it, resolutely resist it, and use the means by which it must be overcome.
"I went by the field of the slothful, and by the vineyard of the man void of understanding; and, lo, it was all grown over with thorns, and nettles had covered the face thereof, and the stone wall thereof was broken down. Then I saw, and considered it well: I looked upon it, and received instruction. Yet a little sleep, a little slumber, a little folding of the hands to sleep: so shall thy poverty come as one that travelleth; and thy want as an armed man" (Prov 24:30–34).
Shake off this unmanly sluggishness, then. Remember that you are running for an immortal crown, and therefore lose no time and do not look back, do not turn your eye or lend your ear to any person or thing that would call you back or stop you. Heaven is before you. "We have seen the land, and behold it is very good; and are ye still? be not slothful to go and to enter, and possess the land," as the five Danite spies said to their brethren (Judg 18:9). Abhor a sluggish habit of mind; go cheerfully about what you have to do, and do it diligently and with your might.
Even in your lawful, worldly business, sloth is a time-wasting sin. If you are servants or laborers you rob your masters and those who hired you, who hired you to work, not to be idle. Whatever your station, you rob God of your service, yourself of your precious time, and of all you might accomplish within it. It is the lazy in their callings who say they can find no time for holy duties. Apply yourself to your business through the rest of the day and you will be better able to redeem some time for prayer and reading Scripture. Work hard on weekdays and you will be better able to spend the Lord’s Day entirely for your soul. Idle people, whether servants or others, fall behind in their work and then claim they have no time to pray or read Scripture. Sloth robs multitudes of a great part of their lives.
"Slothfulness casteth into a deep sleep: and an idle soul shall suffer hunger" (Prov 19:15). You cannot say, "No man hath hired you," when you are asked, "Why stand you idle?" (Matt 20:3, 6). Notice how sharply Paul rebukes idleness in 2 Thessalonians 3, determining that "they that will not work should not eat," and that such people should be avoided as unfit for Christian society. In 1 Timothy 5:13 he sharply rebukes certain women who "learn to be idle, wandering about from house to house." And in Romans 12:11: "Not slothful in business, but fervent in spirit serving the Lord." A diligent, hardworking person is continually redeeming time while doing good; a slothful person is always losing it.
Thief 2. The second thief or time-waster is excessive sleep. Necessity cures most of the poor of this temptation, but many of the wealthy are guilty of it. If you ask what constitutes excess, I answer: all sleep beyond what is genuinely needed for health and work. What is truly necessary for these I do not reprove. The infirm may therefore sleep more than the healthy, and the old more than the young. Those who find that an hour’s additional sleep will not hinder but actually further their work, because without it they would be too unfit to function, may use it as a means to making better use of their time afterward.
But when sluggish people spend hours in bed that neither their health nor their labors require, merely out of a swinish love of sleep; when they will have no work or calling that does not give way to their sleepy disease; and when they think they may sleep longer than necessary because they are rich and can afford it and have no pressing business to call them up, these people imagine they may consume precious time and sin more and harm their souls more simply because God has given them more than others. It is as though a servant were to argue he may sleep more than others because he receives higher wages.
If these drowsy wretches knew what work they have to do for God, for their poor souls, and for those around them, it would quickly rouse and stir them. If they knew how earnestly they will one day wish they had all those hours to spend again, they would spend them better now than in drowsiness. If they knew what a dreadful account it will be, when they must answer for all their time, to say that they spent so many hours every week or every morning in excess of sleep, they would be roused from their sty and find a better use for their time, one whose memory will be far sweeter when time is ended and can be no more.
Thief 3. The next thief, or time-waster, is inordinate adornment of the body. The poor may thank God that they are largely free from this temptation and can dress quickly and go about their work. But many ladies and gallants are so guilty of this vice that I marvel at the patience of their consciences. Terence asked long ago, in his Self-Tormentor, "Do you know the ways of women? While they are getting ready, while they are adorning themselves, a year goes by." O poor neglected, undressed souls! O filthy consciences, never cleansed from your pollutions by the Spirit or blood of Christ! Have you no better use for your precious hours than washing, pinning, dressing, curling, patching, and powdering until ten or eleven o’clock in the morning, by which time honest laborers have already done half their day’s work?
While you are in health, would not six o’clock in the morning be a far fitter hour to be dressed, so that you might draw near to the most holy God in prayer, read his Word, and set your own souls and your households in order for the duties of the day ahead?
I do not say you must dress no more neatly than laboring people, or spend no more time on it than they do. What I say is this: for your souls and in your callings you are as bound by God to diligence as they are. You have no more time to spare than they have. You should spend as little of it on personal adornment as you possibly can, and understand that any loss is your own. The abundance of precious hours that pride consumes will lie heavy on your consciences one day. Then you will confess, I say you will confess, with aching hearts, that the duties you owed to God and to others, and the care of your souls and your households, should have been preferred above appearing neat and elegant before men.
If you have merely a journey to make, you can rise earlier and be dressed sooner. But for the good of your souls and the redeeming of your precious time, you cannot manage it. O that God would show you what greater work those precious hours were meant to accomplish, and how it will cut your hearts to think of them at last! If you were lying hopelessly sick with a wasting illness, you would likely be cured of this proud disease and spend far less time adorning flesh that is hastening toward the grave and decay. Cannot you now see how time and life are consuming away, and what cause you have, with all possible care and diligence, to use them better before they are gone?
I know that those who are so much worse than childish as to squander so many hours making themselves fine for the admiration of others, and who feel no shame in displaying their sin publicly, will rarely be at a loss for words to excuse their fault and argue it lawful, whether those words make sense or not. But conscience itself will answer all, when time is gone, and will make you wish you had been wiser.
You do not know, ladies and gallants, how precious a thing time is. You have little sense of what a price you yourselves will set upon it at the last. You scarcely consider what you have to do with it. You do not see how swiftly it hastens, nor how near you stand to vast eternity. You have little idea how the time you now despise will one day look an awakened conscience in the face, or what it means to be found unready to die. I know you do not take these things to heart; for if you did, you could not, I say, you could not, so lightly cast your time away.
If everything you say were true, that your rank and honor truly require those precious morning hours to be spent in this way, I confess I would pity you more than galley-slaves, and I would count myself blessed to escape such rank and honor, and make haste into the company of the poor, thinking them happy that they may spend their time better.
But in truth your excuses are frivolous and false, and show only that pride has prevailed in captivating your reason to its own service. For we know lords and ladies as great as any among you, though, alas, too few, who can rise and dress quickly, spend their early hours in prayer and adorning their souls, and come forth in plain and unassuming attire. So far from being ridiculed or thought less of by anyone whose judgment deserves respect, they are rightly regarded as an honor to their order. And if it were not that a few such persons kept up the honor of your rank, I will not say how little it would deserve honor in point of morality.
Thief 4. Another time-wasting thief is unnecessary pomp and elaborateness in retinue, attendance, house, furnishings, provisions, and entertainments, together with excess of compliment and ceremony, and servitude to the tastes and expectations of those who waste time. Petrarch, writing of his own life, said that nothing displeased him more than pomp, not only because it is evil and contrary to humility, but because it is burdensome and hostile to peace. I gather these things together to avoid needless length, since they are all wheels of the same engine.
Here again I must forestall the objections of the guilty by making clear that I do not reprove in the rich everything I would reprove in the poor. I do not intend to level them or judge them by the same measure. The rich are not so fortunate as to be as free as the poor, either from the temptation or from what seems to be a necessity and obligation. Let others pity the poor; I will pity the rich, who appear to be bound by harder necessities than the poor, namely, this apparent necessity of wasting their precious time in compliment, elaborateness, and display, while the fortunate poor may spend theirs in the honest labors of their callings, in which they are at once useful to the commonwealth, able to maintain themselves, and free to meditate or converse on holy things.
Yet I must still say that the rich will give an account of their time, and will pay dearly for what unnecessary excesses devour. Instead of envying the style and elaborateness of others, and seeking to equal or surpass them to avoid criticism, they should reduce and bring down all customs of excess. They should show their high regard for time and their detestation of time-wasting elaborateness. They should imitate the most sober, grave, and holy, and be a pattern to others of employing time in needful, great, and manly things, I say manly; for this vice is so childish that men of gravity and weight abhor it, and men of vanity who are guilty of it usually lay it all on the women, as if they were ashamed of it themselves, or as if it were beneath them.
What abundance of precious time is spent in unnecessary pomp of attendance and provision! What abundance, under the pretense of cleanliness and neatness, is spent in pointless elaborateness about rooms, furnishings, and accommodations, matters of pure pride, vainglory, and ostentation, covered with the respectable name of decency! What abundance is wasted in entertainments, unnecessary visits, compliments, ceremony, and servitude to the tastes of vain, time-wasting people! I am not speaking for filth, uncleanness, or unseemliness. I am not speaking for a cynical churlishness or unsociableness. When conscience is awakened and you come to yourselves, and approaching death makes you better acquainted with the worth of time, you will see a mean between these two extremes, and you will wish you had most feared the time-wasting, prodigal extreme.
I think you should freely allow me to say that although Martha had a better excuse than you, being cumbered about many things for the entertainment of such a guest as Christ himself, with all his followers, who asked for no elaborate provision, yet Mary is more approved by Christ, who neglected all this in order to redeem the time for the good of her soul, sitting at his feet to hear his word. She chose the better part, which shall not be taken from her. Remember, I pray, that one thing is necessary.
I hope I may be permitted to say that if God, your souls, prayer, the reading of Scripture, and the profitable labors of an honest calling are all, or any of them, neglected by you or your servants while you are making a room presentable, washing out some small spot, straightening a wrinkle, or occupied with feminine trifling and proud elaborateness, this is preferring dust over gold, the least things over the greatest. To say that decency is commendable is no excuse for neglecting God, your souls, your family, or leaving undone any greater work that you or your servants might have been doing in that time, I mean any work that is greater, all things considered.
O that you and your households would but live as those who see how fast death approaches, how fast time passes, what you have to do, and what your unready souls still lack! That is all I ask of you. And I assure you, it would save you many a precious hour, cut short your works of elaborate display, and deliver you from your slavery to pride and to the esteem of vain time-wasters.
Thief 5. Another time-wasting sin is needless and drawn-out feasting, gluttony, and tippling. Since these belong to the same family, I treat them together. I am not speaking against moderate, timely, and charitable feasts. But in this luxurious and sensual age, how commonly do men sit two hours at a feast, and spend two more before and after in attendance, without turning any of that time to pious or profitable conversation. The rich will ordinarily spend an hour at a single meal, when every meal is itself a feast, living as their predecessor in Luke 16, faring sumptuously every day. Happy are the poor, who are also free from this temptation.
You spend less time each day in approaching God in prayer, reading his Word, examining the affairs of your conscience, and preparing for death, than you spend in stuffing your guts at a single meal. Petrarch, again writing of his own life, said that what people call banquets had always displeased him, since they are revellings hostile to modesty and to good morals, and that he judged it both burdensome and useless to invite and to be invited. And in taverns and alehouses, how much time is wasted among the pots by rich and poor alike. Remember, while you are eating and drinking, what a corruptible body you are feeding and serving, and how quickly those mouths will be filled with dust. A soul speeding so fast toward eternity should find no time to spare for vanity. You have important enough work to do that, if performed, would afford you a sweeter and a longer feast.
Thief 6. Another time-wasting sin is idle talk. What an abundance of precious time this consumes. Listen to most men’s conversation when they sit, work, or travel together, and you will find little of it better than silence, and if not better, then worse. Those who are empty to the point of silence on anything good are so full of vanity that they can find and sustain a discourse about nothing for hours and days together, and that, as they imagine, with such richness and elegance as deserves acceptance if not applause.
I have often marveled at some wordy preachers, how little substance they can handsomely spread across an hour. But one would marvel more to hear people fill up not an hour but a great part of their day and their lives, without any preparation, without any holy or substantial subject, with words that, if you wrote them all down and reviewed them, would sum to nothing. How self-approvingly and pleasantly they can talk at length of nothing, for a great part of their lives.
I have heard many of them marvel at a poor, unlearned Christian who can pray extemporaneously for many hours together in very good order and well-composed words. But are those talkers not far more remarkable, speaking very handsomely of nothing ten times as long, with greater fluency and without repetitions, entirely off the cuff, when they have none of that variety of great and commanding subjects to give matter to their speech? When time must be reviewed, the consumption of so much of it in idle talk will prove to have been no such venial sin as empty, careless sinners now imagine.
Thief 7. Another thief that by the means already described would steal your time is vain and sinful company. A spiritual physician who goes to such company to cure it, or a holy person who is resolute to bear down vain discourse, may indeed put the time to good use when cast upon it or called to it. But to dwell among such people, to choose them as your close companions, or to stay among them without cause or merely for pleasure, will inevitably waste a great deal of your time. If you would do good, they will hinder you. If you speak of good, they will divert you, or reproach you, or wrangle and cavil with you, or stop your mouths some other way. By a stream of vain discourse, they will either carry you along with them or fill your ears and interrupt the very thoughts by which you hoped to profit yourself, when they will not permit you to be profitable to others.
Thief 8. Another notorious time-wasting thief is needless and inordinate sports and games, which the offenders themselves commonly brand with the infamous name of pastimes, and disguise under the deceptive title of recreations. Such are cards and dice, stage-plays, dancings, revellings, and excess in even the most lawful sports, especially hunting, hawking, and bowling. Whether all of these are lawful or unlawful in themselves is not the present question. But I am certain that the precious hours they consume might have been used to save many thousands of souls, who for want of that time are now undone past recovery.
Setting aside malicious enemies of godliness, I scarcely know a more wretched and pitiable sort of people on earth than those fleshly persons who, through love of sensual pleasure, waste many hours day after day in plays, gaming, and voluptuous courses, while their miserable souls remain dead in sin, enslaved to their fleshly lusts, unreconciled to God, finding no delight in him or in his service, and unable to make a recreation of any heavenly work. How it will torment these unhappy souls to think that they played away those hours in which they might have been pleasing God, preventing misery, and laying up treasure in heaven, that they sold that precious time, for a little fleshly sport, in which they should have been working out their salvation and making their calling and election sure. Diogenes Laertius records of Solon that he forbade Thespis to perform or to teach tragedies, calling them a useless kind of lying. But I have more to say on this shortly.
Thief 9. Another time-wasting thief is excess of worldly cares and business. These do not merely stain the soul deeply in a short time and then recede, as some more disgraced sins do. They dwell upon the mind, hold possession of it, and shut out what is good. They take up the greatest part of the lives of those who are guilty of them. The world is first in their thoughts in the morning, last at night, and present almost all the day.
The world will not allow them to entertain any sober, fixed thoughts of the world to come, nor to do the work to which all other works should give way. It devours almost all the time that God and their souls should have. It will not permit them to pray, read, meditate, or converse about holy things. Even when they appear to be praying or hearing the Word of God, the world occupies their thoughts. As it is written: "They come unto thee as the people cometh; and they sit before thee as my people, and they hear thy words, but they will not do them: for with their mouth they shew much love; but their heart goeth after their covetousness." (Ezek 33:31) In most families there is almost no talk and nothing done but all for the world. These too will one day discover that they had greater work for their precious time, work that should always have taken precedence over the world.
Thief 10. Another time-waster is vain, ungoverned, and sinful thoughts. When men are wearied with vain works and sports, they continue unwearied in vain thoughts. When they lack company for vain discourse and games, they can waste the time alone in idle, lustful, ambitious, or covetous thoughts. In the night while they lie awake, and as they travel along the road, yes, even while they appear to be serving God, they will be wasting time in useless thoughts. This therefore devours a greater share of precious time than any of the former thieves.
When time must be reckoned for, what an abundance will be found on men’s accounts as spent in idle and sinful thoughts. Watch this thief. Remember that though you may think a vain thought is only a small sin, time is not a small or contemptible commodity to be thrown away on so slight a thing as idle thoughts. To treat so choice a treasure with such contempt is itself no small sin. And the work you have to do in the time you thus waste is no small work. A daily course of idle thoughts wastes so great a measure of time that this alone makes the sin more serious than many offenses of greater outward infamy. But more on this in the next part.
Thief 11. Another dangerous time-wasting sin is the reading of vain books, playbooks, romances, and feigned histories, as well as unprofitable studies undertaken merely for vainglory or to please a carnal and curious mind. I have spoken about this in my book on Self-denial. I will not address here how pernicious this vice is in corrupting the imagination and affections, breeding a diseased appetite, and killing your taste for necessary things. But consider, before you spend another hour on such books, whether you could comfortably give an account of it to God, and how precious is the time you are wasting on such childish toys.
You think reading such things is lawful; but is it lawful to lose your precious time? You say your minor studies are desirable and praiseworthy; but neglecting far greater things is not praiseworthy. I discourage no one from laboring to know all that God has in any way revealed to be known. But I say, as Seneca said: "We are ignorant of necessary things because we learn superfluous and unnecessary things." Art is long and life is short; the person who does not have time for everything should secure the greatest matters first, and if anything must remain unknown, let it be what the love of God, our own salvation and that of others, and the public good least require and can best spare.
It is a pitiful thing to see a person waste his time in minute criticism or in mastering the less essential sciences and arts, while he remains a slave to pride or worldliness, has an unrenewed soul, and has not yet learned the mysteries necessary to his own salvation. Those studies are praiseworthy in their proper season, but the fanatic studies of those who would pry into unrevealed things, and the lascivious employment of those who read love-books, playbooks, and vain stories, will one day appear to have been a most unwise use of time for those who had so much better and more urgent work to do with it. I think few of those who argue for such reading would want to be found with such books in their hands at death, or will then find any pleasure in remembering them.
Thief 12. But the master-thief that robs people of their time is an unsanctified, ungodly heart, for this loses time whatever men are doing, because such a person never truly aims at the glory of God. Having neither a right principle nor a right end, his whole course runs toward hell; and whatever he does, he is not working out his salvation. He is therefore always losing his time, as far as his own soul is concerned, however God may use the time and gifts of some such people as a mercy to others. A new and holy heart, with a heavenly intention and design for life, is therefore the great necessity for all who would savingly redeem their time.
Title 5. On Whom the Duty of Redeeming Time Is Principally Incumbent
Though redeeming time is a duty of supreme importance and necessity for all, the following groups of people have special obligations to it.
Sort 1. Those who are in the youth and vigor of their days. Your nature is not so deeply corrupted as in those long hardened in sin; your hearts are not so callous; sin is not so deeply rooted and confirmed in you; Satan has not triumphed over you in so many victories; you are not yet plunged as deep as others into worldly entanglements and cares; your understanding, memory, and strength are in their prime and have not yet failed you.
Who should move fastest and work hardest but those who have the greatest strength? You may now gain more by diligence in a single day than you may gain in many days hereafter. How few people become good scholars or wise persons who do not begin learning until they are old? "Fly youthful lusts" therefore (2 Tim 2:22), and "Remember your Creator in the days of your youth" (Eccl 12:1). "If you be now trained up in the way you should go, you will not depart from it when you are old" (Prov 22:6).
O that you could know what an unspeakable advantage, benefit, and comfort it is to come to a mature age furnished with that wisdom, holiness, and knowledge of God which ought to have been attained in your youth, and what a misery it is to be then learning what you should have been practicing for many years before, to be only beginning to live when you must make an end. How much worse to be cast to hell if death finds you unprepared in your youth, or to be abandoned by God to a hardened old age! Happy are those who, like Timothy and Obadiah, learn the Scriptures and fear God in their childhood and from their youth.
Sort 2. Necessity makes it a special duty for the weak, the sick, and the aged to redeem their time. If those who are certain to have only a little time will not make much of it, if those who know they are near the end of their journey and ready to give account will trifle it away, they are more inexcusable than anyone else. Even a thief or murderer will pray and speak good words when going out of the world. Well may it be said to you, as Paul says in Romans 13:11–12: "Now is it high time to awake out of sleep," when your salvation or damnation is so near! It is high time for the person who must so shortly appear before the most holy God, and be dealt with forever as he has lived here, to look to himself, prepare his soul, and lose no time.
Sort 3. It is specially incumbent on those who have already loitered and misspent much time to redeem what remains. If conscience tells you that you wasted your youth in ignorance and vanity, and much of your adult years in negligence and worldliness, it is a double crime if you now fail to redeem diligently what is left. The proper concern for your salvation demands it, unless you are willing to be damned. Integrity and duty to God demand it, unless you will defy him and resolve to abuse and despise him to the utmost, spending every remaining hour against him. The nature of true repentance demands it, unless you will know nothing but the repentance of the damned, beginning to mourn the misspending of your time only when it is gone and all is too late.
Sort 4. It is specially the duty of those who are short of time through poverty, service, or restraint to redeem what they have. If poor people who must labor all day will not redeem the Lord’s Day and the few hours allotted to them, they will have no time at all for spiritual things. Servants who are not masters of their own time and are held closely to their work must be very diligent in redeeming those few hours that are allowed them for higher things.
Sort 5. Those who enjoy any special helps, whether public or private, must be especially careful to make the most of them and redeem the time. Do you live under a convincing and powerful ministry? Make the most of it and redeem the time, for you do not know how soon those ministers may be taken from you, or you from them. Do you live with godly relations, parents, husband, wife, masters in a godly family, or with godly fellow-servants, friends, or neighbors? Redeem the time; gain something from them every day; you do not know how short this season will be. Do you have books and leisure? Redeem the time; this also may not last long. Would not Joshua have been inexcusably negligent if he had loitered when God made the sun stand still while he pursued his enemies? Do not loiter while the sun of mercy, patience, means, and helps all attends you.
Sort 6. Those must especially redeem the time who are ignorant, or graceless, or weak in grace, who have strong corruptions and little or no assurance of salvation, who are unready to die and have all or most of their work still to do. If these persons loiter, they are doubly to blame. Surely the time past of your lives may suffice to have loitered and done evil (1 Pet 4:3). Has not the devil already had too much? Will you "stand all the day idle" (Matt 20:6)? Look within and see what you have yet to do, how much stands between you and a safe and comfortable death. "Sow to yourselves in righteousness, reap in mercy; break up your fallow ground: for it is time to seek the LORD, till he come and rain righteousness upon you" (Hos 10:12).
Sort 7. Those who hold any office, or have any special opportunity to do public good, must especially redeem the time, above all, magistrates and ministers of Christ. Your life will not be long; your office will not be long. Stir yourselves against sin and Satan, and for Christ and holiness, while you still can: God gives you only a season. Let Obadiah hide and feed the prophets when he is called to do so and while he may, so that God may hide him; let him not think to put off duty and save himself for a better time.
Mordecai said to Esther, "Think not with thyself that thou shalt escape in the king’s house more than all the Jews: for if thou altogether holdest thy peace at this time, then shall their enlargement and deliverance arise from another place, but thou and thy father’s house shall be destroyed: and who knoweth whether thou art come to the kingdom for such a time as this" (Esth 4:13–14). Are you ministers? Preach the Gospel while you may; redeem the time. Every season is your season: so great a work, and the worth of souls, commands you to do it "in season and out of season" (2 Tim 4:2). A man charged with saving others from drowning, or with putting out a fire in the city, is more inexcusable than anyone if he fails to redeem the time by his greatest diligence and speed.
Sort 8. Finally, those who have been recovered from sickness or rescued from danger are under a double obligation, of special mercy received and of special promises made. They promised God, in the hour of sickness or distress, that if he would spare them and try them once more, they would amend their lives, live more holy, spend their time more carefully and diligently for their souls, and show all around them the truth of their repentance by the greatness of their change and an exemplary life. It is a most dangerous and terrible thing to return to security, sloth, and sin, and to break such promises to God. People who do so are often given over to dreadful hardness of heart or despair, for God will not be mocked with hollow words.
I have opened this great duty of redeeming time at such length because it is of unspeakable importance. My soul is continually astonished that the sluggish world can so carelessly and unrepentantly go on wasting precious time, so near eternity and in so needy and dangerous a condition. Though I thank God that I have not wholly lost my time, and have long lived with a sense of how hateful that sin is, I am still amazed at myself that such overwhelming motives do not compel me to make continual haste and to press on with all my might in a matter of everlasting consequence.
CHAPTER 6
DIRECTIONS FOR THE GOVERNMENT OF THE THOUGHTS
In my "Treatise of Walking with God" I showed how much God regards man’s thoughts, and how much man himself should regard them, what powerful agents and instruments they are for great good or great evil. I will take that as established and not repeat it here, but will direct you in governing your thoughts. The work has three parts, each requiring its own directions: 1. Avoiding evil thoughts. 2. Exercising good thoughts. 3. Improving good thoughts so that they become effectual.
Title 1. Directions against Evil and Idle Thoughts
Direction 1. Know which thoughts are evil, and keep so vivid a sense of their loathsome character in your mind that you will always meet them with abhorrence. Evil thoughts include the following: 1. All thoughts against the being, attributes, relations, honor, or works of God, atheistic and blasphemous thoughts, idolatrous and unbelieving thoughts; all thoughts that tend toward disobedience or opposition to God’s will or Word; all thoughts that savor of unthankfulness, or lack of love toward God, or of discontent, distrust, or lack of the fear of God, or that tend toward any of these. Also sinful, selfish, covetous, and proud schemes: making a mere trade of the ministry for financial gain; seeking only to out-talk others; prying into things unrevealed and forbidden; disordered curiosity and hasty confidence in your own opinions about God’s decrees, obscure prophecies, portents, or providence, all of which belong to the pride of understanding already discussed above.
All thoughts against any particular word, truth, or precept of God, or against any particular duty; against any part of the worship and ordinances of God; thoughts tending toward irreverent neglect of the name or holy day of God; all impious thoughts against public, family, or private duty, or that would hinder or spoil any duty.
All thoughts of dishonor, contempt, neglect, or disobedience toward the authority of those set over us by God, whether magistrates, pastors, parents, masters, or any other superiors.
All thoughts of pride, self-exalting ambition, and self-seeking covetousness; voluptuous and sensual thoughts, proceeding from or tending toward the corrupt and disordered pleasures of the flesh; thoughts that are unjust and tend to the harm and wrong of others; envious, malicious, reproachful, injurious, contemptuous, watchful, and revengeful thoughts; lustful, wanton, and filthy thoughts; drunken, gluttonous, and fleshly thoughts; disordered, anxious, fearful, vexatious, and discomposing thoughts; presumptuous and falsely confident thoughts, despairing and dejecting thoughts; slothful, delaying, negligent, and discouraging thoughts; uncharitable, cruel, false, censorious, unmerciful, and idle, unprofitable thoughts. Hate all of these as the devil’s offspring.
Direction 2. Do not fail to realize how much duty or sin lies in the thoughts, nor how dangerous a course of evil thoughts is for your soul, both in what it reveals and in what it leads to. Thoughts reveal what a person is just as much as words or actions do: "For as he thinketh in his heart, so is he" (Prov 23:7). A person is called good or evil by the good or evil treasure of the heart, even if others know it only by its fruits. Consider the vile and numerous sins committed in men’s thoughts alone; the precious time lost in idle and other sinful thinking; the good that is hindered in both heart and life as a result. Having spoken of this in the treatise already mentioned, I now proceed.
Direction 3. Above all, be sure to cleanse the fountain and destroy the sinful inclinations of the heart from which your evil thoughts proceed. It is useless to try to stop the streams if you leave the source untouched; and even if you could dam the streams, the heart itself would remain loathsome in God’s sight.
Are your thoughts wholly upon the world, coveting, anxious, grieving for what you lack, or pleasing yourself with what you have or hope to have? Then bring down your inflated estimate of the world; cast it beneath your feet and out of your heart, and count everything, as Paul did, as loss and rubbish for the sake of the excellent knowledge of God in Christ. Until the world is dead in you, your worldly thoughts will not be dead. Remove this weight and everything stops; crucify the world, and its breath and pulse will cease.
If your thoughts run on advancement, honor, disgrace, or contempt, if you are pleased by your own prominence or applause, mortify your pride and beg God for a humble, self-denying, contrite heart. Until pride is dead, it will never leave you at rest; it will stir up swarms of self-exalting and yet self-tormenting thoughts, making you hateful in God’s eyes.
If your thoughts keep running to what you will eat or drink, or how to please your appetite and senses, mortify the flesh and subdue its desires, bring your appetite into full obedience to reason, and cultivate the habit of temperance. Otherwise your thoughts will always return to your belly and throat, obeying the ruling power within; for a violent passion and desire moves the thoughts so forcibly that reason and will can hardly govern them.
If your thoughts are wanton and filthy, you must cleanse that unclean and lustful heart, and have Christ cast out the unclean spirit, so that you become chaste within, before you will be able to keep out unchaste thoughts. If your thoughts are confused and vain, you must first obtain a well-furnished and well-ordered mind and heart before you can cure the malady of your thoughts.
Direction 4. Keep sufficient distance from those tempting objects that are the fuel and incentive of your evil thoughts. Can you expect a drunkard to govern his thoughts while he is in the alehouse or tavern with the drink in front of him? Or the glutton to rule his thoughts while the tempting dish is before him? Or the lustful person to keep his thoughts chaste in the presence of the object of his desire? Or the wrathful person to rule his thoughts in the middle of contentious and heated words? Or the proud person to rule his thoughts in the midst of honor and applause? Take away this fuel; flee from this infectious air if you want to be safe.
Direction 5. At least make a covenant with your senses and hold them in obedience, if you want obedient thoughts. Everyone knows by experience how powerfully the senses drive the thoughts. Job says, "I made a covenant with my eyes; why then should I think upon a maid?" (Job 31:1). Notice how the covenant with his eyes is made the means of ruling his thoughts. Pray with David, "Turn away my eyes from beholding vanity" (Ps 119:37). Keep a guard on your eyes, ears, taste, and touch if you want to keep a guard on your thoughts. Do not let anything enter through these outer gates that you do not wish to go further. Do not open the door to what you would not have come in.
Direction 6. Remember how close kin a thought is to the deed, and how naturally it tends toward it. Let Christ himself tell you: "But I say unto you that whosoever is angry with his brother without a cause, shall be in danger of the judgment. I say unto you that whosoever looketh on a woman to lust after her, hath committed adultery with her already in his heart" (Matt 5:22, 28). A malicious thought and a malicious deed spring from the same source and share the same nature; only the deed is the full-grown serpent that can sting another, while the thought is the younger serpent that carries the same venom but still only within itself. A lustful thought flows from the same defiled spring as actual filthiness; the thought is merely the passage to the action, the same sin in its infancy, moving toward maturity.
Direction 7. Keep out, or quickly cast out, all disordered passions, for passions press upon the thoughts with violence and carry them away by force. If anger, grief, fear, carnal love, or sensual pleasure is admitted, it will command your thoughts to run after its objects. When you rebuke your thoughts and call them back, they will not hear you until you remove them from the crowd and noise of passion. Just as no government operates well in a kingdom torn by civil war, and violent storms keep sailors from governing the ship and saving themselves, so passion is too turbulent a region for the thoughts to be well governed. Until your soul is brought to a calm condition, your thoughts will be in tumult, driven wherever the tempest sends them. Until these inward wars are ended, your thoughts will run loose and share in the rebellion.
Direction 8. Keep your souls in a constant and careful obedience to God. Observe his law; be continually aware that you are under his government, and held in awe by his authority. Man does not judge your thoughts: if you are subject only to man, your thoughts will go ungoverned. But the heart is the first object of God’s government, and what he chiefly regards. His laws extend to all your thoughts; therefore, if you know what obedience to God means, you must know what the obedience of your thoughts to him means, for whoever obeys God as God will obey him in every matter, and will obey him as the governor and judge of thoughts.
The powerful, searching word of Christ is a "discerner of the thoughts and intentions of the heart, and as a two-edged sword is sharp and quick," and will "pierce" and "cut" as deep as the very "soul and spirit" (Heb 4:12–13). "It casteth down every imagination and bringeth into captivity every thought to the obedience of Christ" (2 Cor 10:5). Therefore David says to God, "Search me O God, and know my heart, try me and know my thoughts; and see if there be any wicked way in me, and lead me in the way everlasting" (Ps 139:23–24).
You will also find God’s laws and reproofs extending to the thoughts. "Their thoughts are thoughts of iniquity" (Isa 59:7). The fool’s heart-atheism is rebuked (Ps 14:1). He reproves a rebellious people for "walking in a way that is not good, after their own thoughts" (Isa 65:2). See how Christ opens the heart (Matt 15:19). He charges them to "beware that there be not a thought in their wicked hearts" against the mercy they must show to the poor (Deut 15:9).
He exposes the "inward thought" of the worldling, "that their houses shall continue for ever" (Ps 49:11). He says, "The thought of foolishness is sin" (Prov 24:9). The old world was condemned because the "imaginations of their hearts were only evil continually" (Gen 6:5). And when God calls a sinner to conversion he says, "Let the wicked forsake his way, and the unrighteous man his thoughts, and let him return unto the Lord, and he will have mercy upon him" (Isa 55:6–7). You see, then, that if you are subject to God, your thoughts must be obedient.
Direction 9. Remember God’s continual presence; that all your thoughts are in his sight. He sees every filthy thought, every covetous, proud, and ambitious thought, every uncharitable and malicious thought. If you are not atheists, the remembrance that God beholds them will do something to check and control your thoughts. "He understandeth" your "thoughts afar off" (Ps 139:2). "Doth not he that pondereth the heart consider it?" (Prov 24:12). "Wherefore think ye evil in your hearts?" says Christ (Matt 9:4).
Direction 10. Consider seriously what a watch you would keep over your thoughts if they were written on your foreheads, or visible to all who see you, or even open to some person you hold in respect. How ashamed you would be for others to see your filthy thoughts, your malicious thoughts, your covetous and deceitful thoughts! And is not the eye of God ten thousand times more to be respected and regarded? If you are more restrained by the eye of man than by the eye of God, and if the eye of man does more to hold you back, have you not made man your god?
Direction 11. Keep your conscience tender, so that it is not unconcerned or insensible to the smallest sin. A tender conscience fears evil or idle thoughts, and will ache in the penitent review of them. But a seared conscience feels nothing except the most grievous, crying sins. A tender conscience obeys the precept: "If thou hast done foolishly in lifting up thyself, or if thou hast thought evil, lay thy hand upon thy mouth" (Prov 30:32).
Direction 12. Cast out vain and sinful thoughts at the outset, before they settle themselves and make a dwelling of your heart. They are more easily and safely resisted at the door. Your heart will give them root and grow familiar with them if you let them linger. Besides that, prolonged toleration reveals greater sin, because there is less resistance and more consent. If the will were truly against them, it would not let them remain so long.
Their continuance also tends toward your ruin. It is like poison lingering in your body, or fire spreading in your thatch, or a spy inside an army: as long as they stay they are working toward greater mischief. If these flies remain long they will breed and multiply; they will make their nests and rear their young, and you will quickly have a swarm of sins.
Direction 13. Take heed lest any practical error corrupt your understanding, or lest you be engaged in some ill design, for these will command your thoughts into a course of sinful service to their ends. One who errs and believes his sin is his virtue or duty will indulge thoughts of it without restraint; indeed, he will drive his mind toward such thinking, and steal from the authority and Word of God the motives and incentives for his sin. As false prophets speak against God in the name of God, and against his Word under the pretended authority of his Word, so an erring mind will draw its arguments from God and from Scripture in support of thoughts that are against both God and Scripture.
If evil thoughts are so difficult to keep out even when we invoke the authority of God and his Word against them and do our utmost to resist them, how much more will they prevail when you invoke the authority of God and the sacred Scriptures for them, and count it your duty to kindle and promote them?
For instance, all the sinful thoughts by which the Roman clergy have contrived to support their kingdom of darkness in the world and continue their tyranny in the church are merely the products of their error, which tells them that this is pleasing to God and profitable to the church. All the bloody thoughts of persecutors against the church and the holy ways of Christ have been nourished by this same kind of error. "The time cometh that whoever killeth you, will think that he doth God service; and these things they will do unto you, because they have not known the Father nor me" (John 16:2–3). All of Paul’s bloody schemes and actions against the church arose from this: "I verily thought with myself that I ought to do many things contrary to the name of Jesus of Nazareth: which thing I also did" (Acts 26:9).
All the scornful and reproachful thoughts and words of many of the ungodly against a holy life come from the same source: "They think it strange that you run not with them to excess of riot, speaking evil of you" (1 Pet 4:4). The empty babbling of hypocrites, who cheat their souls with idle lip-work instead of spiritual service from the heart, the sacrifice of fools, who offer God some outward thing while denying him their hearts and holy obedience, proceeds from the delusion that "they think to be heard for their much babbling" (Matt 6:7), while "they consider not that they do evil" (Eccl 5:1).
All the self-flattery and presumption of the ungodly, and consequently their ungodly lives, arise greatly from erroneous thoughts: "He that thinketh he is something when he is nothing, deceiveth himself" (Gal 6:3). Come into the light, then, and leave your darkness behind, for sinful thoughts are like hobgoblins and hags that flee from the light, and like worms and serpents that creep into holes and crawl and breed in the dark.
Direction 14. Remember what an exposure of thoughts there will be when you come into the light, either here by conviction, or at the last at the day of judgment. Then you will be ashamed to see what filth and vanity you entertained, and with what dross and rubbish you stuffed your minds. When the light comes in, what an abundance of things you will see in the dungeon of your heart, to your astonishment, that you now take no notice of at all.
Remember that all your hidden thoughts must one day be brought into the open light. Do not say this is impossible because they are so numerous: for God, who sees them all at once and causes his sun to illuminate many millions at once, can make you see them all at once, distinctly, and see the shame and filthiness of every one of them.
Direction 15. When you find that thoughts of sin and vanity continue to pursue you despite everything you can do, you must not on that account plunge your soul into such anxious fear and trouble that it discourages and distracts your mind. Instead, wait on God through the twofold path of cure: delight in him and obedience to him.
It is the tempter’s method to keep sinners utterly careless about their thoughts, and insensible of any sin in them, for as long as he can. When that strategy fails him, he will work to make a humbled, obedient soul so acutely aware of the sin in its thoughts, and so preoccupied with them, that he throws that soul into confusion, melancholy, discouragement, and despair, at which point the person will have no command of his thoughts at all. They will be just as ungoverned in a different direction, feeding continually on terror.
The real aim of this temptation is to distract and confound you. The tempter’s pretence runs contrary to his aim: by driving you with terrors to think of nothing else but what you have been thinking, and making your own thoughts the chief subject of your thoughts, he confounds you, renders you unfit for any good, and leaves you unable to govern your thoughts at all. But if you give your chief attention to the excellencies of God and godliness, and take the course that tends to make religion pleasant to you, while at the same time maintaining a reverent obedience to God, that combination of delight and obedience will prove the most effective remedy.
Direction 16. Therefore, surrender your heart to Christ in love and duty, consecrate your thoughts entirely to his service, and keep them continually exercised on him or in his work; and this will most effectively cure them of vanity and sin.
As Marcus Eremita observes, just as fire cannot last in water, neither can a shameful thought last in one who loves God; for everyone who loves God also loves labor, and labor freely undertaken is by nature the enemy of self-indulgent pleasure.
If you have a friend whom you love entirely, you will not feed swine in the room prepared to receive him. You will not leave it filthy and unclean, nor open it to every dirty, unsuitable companion to intrude at will and disturb your friend. In the same way, love and delight will lead you readily and calmly to keep the heart clean, shut out vain and filthy thoughts, and say:
"This room is for a better guest. Nothing shall enter here that my Lord abhors. Is he willing so wonderfully to condescend as to take up so mean a habitation, and shall I crowd him or offend him by letting in his noisome enemies?
"Will he dwell in my heart, and shall I allow thoughts of pride, lust, or malice to dwell with him or enter in? Are these fit companions for the Spirit of Grace? Do I delight to grieve him? I know that the moment they come in, he will either resist them until he drives them out again, or he will withdraw himself. Shall I drive away so dear a friend for the love of a filthy, destructive enemy? Or do I delight in war? Would I have a continual combat in my heart? Shall I put the Spirit of Christ to fight for his own habitation against such an ignoble foe?"
There is in truth no genuine cure for sinful, vain, and unprofitable thoughts except by the contrary: by calling the thoughts back to their proper work and finding them more profitable employment. This is accomplished by consecrating the heart and all its thoughts entirely to the love and service of him who, through the wonders of his love and the extraordinary design of his purchase and merits, has so richly deserved them. Let Christ come in; hand him the key, and pray him to keep your heart as his own. He will cast the buyers and sellers out of his temple and will not allow his house of prayer to become a den of thieves. But if you receive Christ with reservations, and maintain your designs for the world and the flesh, do not be surprised if Christ will not share those quarters with them, but leaves everything to those guests whom you would not leave for him.
CHAPTER 7
DIRECTIONS TO FURNISH THE MIND WITH GOOD THOUGHTS
To have the mind well furnished with material for holy and profitable thoughts is necessary for all who have the use of reason, though not equally so for all. Here I will present only such materials as are necessary to a holy life and for daily use in our walk with God, setting aside what is proper to pastors, magistrates, or other special callings, though I may give some general directions for students at the end of this. See the Directions for Prayer, Hearing, Reading, and the Sacrament, Part 2.
Direction 1. Understand well your own interest and great concerns; be firmly settled as to what you live for, what your true happiness is, and what your end is, and this will command your thoughts to serve it. The end is what all means are chosen and used for. A person’s estimation directs his intention and designs, and his intention and designs command his thoughts. Your end will certainly claim the first and chief thoughts, the most serious, practical, and effective ones, though some stray thoughts may wander another way.
As the miller ensures he keeps enough water to grind his grain, though he may let what he considers excess run by; as you gather all your corn and fruit for yourselves at harvest, though you may leave scattered gleanings for anyone who cares to pick them up, so whatever a person takes as his ultimate end and true happiness will claim the main store and stream of his thinking, though he may scatter a few thoughts on other things when he judges it causes no harm to his main purpose.
As a traveler’s face is ordinarily turned toward his destination, though he may glance behind or to either side when he thinks it will not slow him, so our main end will, on the whole, carry our thoughts forward. Therefore, unholy souls who in practice know no higher end than the prosperity and pleasure of the flesh, the wealth and honor of the world, cannot possibly exercise any holy governance over their thoughts. Their minds and consciences are defiled, and their thoughts made as carnal as their end. There is no way to cure their vicious, wicked thoughts and order them acceptably to God, except by curing their worldly, carnal minds and causing them to change their designs and ends. And this must come by understanding their true interest. Simply know what is most necessary and best for you, and it will change your hearts and save your souls.
Know this, and your thoughts will never lack material to work on, nor will they be left to wander far. This is why the expectation of death and the thought of standing shortly before judgment tend to supply the mind with wiser and more useful thoughts more effectively than the most learned book or ordinary means can. Whatever best tells a person what he has to do, best tells him what he has to think on. The approach of death and the appearance of eternity best tells a dull and fleshly sinner what he has to do: it tells him plainly that he must immediately search his heart and life and judge himself as one going to the final judgment; that it is high time to seek the remedy for his sin and misery. Therefore it commands his thoughts in that direction.
Ask any lawyer, physician, or tradesman what commands his thoughts, and you will find that his interest, his ends, and his work command them. Know what it means to have an immortal soul that must live in joy or woe forever; know how near you always stand to the irreversible and determining sentence; know that this short and uncertain time, and no more, is all you have for preparation. Then it is easy to predict which way your thoughts will go. A man who knows his house is on fire will be thinking how to quench it; a man who knows he is falling into a fatal illness will be thinking how to cure it. There is no better way to have your thoughts both furnished and rightly directed than to know your true interest and right end.
Direction 2. Know God rightly, and behold him through the eye of an effective faith, and you will never lack material for holy thoughts. His greatness and continual presence with you may command your thoughts, overawe them, and keep them from masterless wandering. His wisdom will find them continual employment in the various, excellent, and delightful subjects of his natural and supernatural revelation, but nowhere so richly as in himself.
In God you may find material for your thoughts and affections that is most high and excellent, delighting the mind with a continual sweetness and offering ever fresh delights, though you meditate on him for a thousand years or to all eternity. You might sooner say that the ocean has not water enough for you to swim in, or that the earth has not room enough for you to walk on, than that there is not enough in God for your longest meditations and most delighting, satisfying thoughts. The blessed angels and saints in heaven will find enough in God alone to employ their minds to all eternity.
What horrid darkness and atheism still remains in our hearts, that we should lack material for our thoughts to keep them from feeding on air and filth, or lack material for delight to keep our minds from begging it at the creature’s door or hungering for the husks that feed the swine, when we have the infinite God, omnipotent, omniscient, most good and bountiful, our life and hope and happiness, to think on with delight!
Direction 3. If you have but an eye of faith to see the things of the unseen world as revealed in the sacred Word, you cannot lack material to employ your thoughts. Scripture is the mirror in which you may see the other world.
There you may see the Ancient of Days, the Eternal Majesty shining in his glory for the joy of holy and glorified spirits. There you may see human nature raised above angels, enjoying the highest glory next to the uncreated Majesty; Christ reigning as king over all the world, with all the angels of God obeying, honoring, and worshipping him. You may see him sending his angels on gracious errands to the lowest members of his body, the little ones of his flock on earth. You may see him interceding for all his saints, securing their peace and welcome with the Father, and preparing for their reception when they pass into those mansions, welcoming them one by one as they depart this life.
There you may see the glorious celestial society attending, admiring, extolling, and worshipping the Great Creator, the Gracious Redeemer, and the Eternal Spirit with unceasing, glorious, and harmonious praise. You may see them burning in the delightful flames of holy love, drawn out by the vision of the face of God and by the streams of love he continually pours out upon them. You may see the drawing power of uncreated love, and the blissful union of the holy spirits drawn to him, united to God through Christ and feasting everlastingly on him. You may see the raptures of joy and the unspeakable pleasures which all those blessed spirits have in that transporting sight, love, and praise.
You may see the ecstasies of joy that possess the souls of those newly passed from the body, escaped from the sins and miseries of this world, who find there such sudden and ravishing welcome, unspeakably beyond all their former expectations, imaginings, or belief. You may see with what wonder, what pity, what loathing and detestation those holy and glorified souls look down upon earth, upon the negligence, contempt, sensuality, and profaneness of the dreaming and distracted world. You may see there what you shall be forever if you are among the holy ones of Christ: where you will dwell, what you will do, and what you will enjoy. All this you may so know through sound believing as to be carried toward it as sincerely as if your eyes had seen it (Heb 11:1; 2 Cor 5:7).
And yet, can your thoughts be idle, or carnal, or worldly and sinful for lack of work? Are your meditations dry and barren for want of material? Does the fire of love or other holy affections die out for lack of fuel? Are heaven and eternity not spacious enough for your minds to range in? Is not such a world as that sufficient for you to study, with fresh and delightful variety of discoveries from day to day, or that which is even more delightful than variety? Would you have more material, or higher and more excellent material, or sweeter and more pleasant material, or material which more closely concerns yourselves?
Obtain that faith by which all who shall be saved live, the faith that makes absent things as operative, to some degree, as if they were present; that makes what will be as if it now were; that makes the unseen as if it were now open to your eyes, and then your thoughts will lack neither material to work on nor an animating impulse to set them in motion.
If this were not enough, I might tell you what faith can also see in hell, which is not unworthy of your serious thoughts. (See my treatise on Hebrews 11:1, called The Life of Faith.) What work is there! What dreadful complaints and lamentations! What self-torment, and what a sense of God’s displeasure, and for what? But I will pass this by entirely, so that you may see there is delightful work enough for your thoughts, and that I set you no unpleasant task.
Direction 4. Get the love of God well kindled in your heart, and it will find employment, the highest and sweetest employment, for your thoughts. You yourselves can judge whether love does not, for the most part, govern your thoughts, assigning them their work and directing them when, and how long, to dwell on something. See how a lustful lover is carried away after a beloved, frail piece of flesh: his thoughts run after it so easily and so constantly that he needs no spur. Notice the current that love creates, how it feeds and quickens the imagination and lifts an ordinary fancy into a poetical and passionate strain. What abundance of material can a lover find, in the narrow compass of a dirty corpse, for his thoughts to work on night and day! Will not the love of God, then, much more fill and feast your thoughts? How easily does the love of money find material for the worldling’s thoughts year after year! It is easy to think of anything you love.
What a happy fountain of meditation is a rooted, predominant love of God! Love him strongly, and you cannot forget him. You will then see him in everything you encounter and hear him in everyone who speaks to you. If you lose sight of him, or have offended him, you will think of him with grief; if you taste his love, you will think of him with delight; if you have but hope, you will think of him with desire; and your mind will be taken up in seeking him, and in understanding and using the means by which you may come to enjoy him.
Love is resourceful, abundant, lively, active, and resolute. It is courageous, patient, and extraordinarily industrious; it delights to encounter difficulties, to exert itself in labors, and to show itself in sufferings that give it advantage to appear. Love therefore makes the mind it governs exceedingly busy and finds the thoughts a world of work. If God is not in all the thoughts of the ungodly, it is because he is not in the ungodly person’s heart (Ps 10:4). God may be "nigh their mouths," but he is "far from their reins" (Jer 12:2). Do those people believe themselves, or do they expect any wise person to believe them, when they say they love God above all, yet neither think of him nor love to think of him, while they are untiring in thinking of their wealth, their honors, and the pleasures of their flesh? "Consider this, ye that forget God, lest he tear you in pieces, and there be none to deliver you" (Ps 50:22).
Direction 5. Soundly understand the wonderful mystery of man’s redemption, come to know Jesus Christ, and you will never lack employment for your thoughts. "In him are hid all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge" (Col 2:3). "He is the power of God, and the wisdom of God" (1 Cor 1:24). If the study of Aristotle, Plato, Plotinus, and their numerous followers and commentators can occupy the thoughts of those who would understand the works of God, or be accounted good philosophers, for many years, or a great part of their lives, what work then may a Christian find for his thoughts in Jesus Christ, "who of God is made unto us wisdom, and righteousness, and sanctification, and redemption" (1 Cor 1:30)? "For it pleased the Father that in him should all fulness dwell" (Col 1:19). Therefore in him there is fullness of matter for our meditations.
As Paul "determined to know nothing," meaning, to make a display of no other knowledge, "but Christ crucified" (1 Cor 2:2), so even if your thoughts had nothing to work upon for many years but Christ crucified, they need not stand still a moment for want of fitting and delightful matter. The mystery of the incarnation alone may find you work to search and admire for ages. But if from there you proceed to the world of wonderful matter in his doctrine, miracles, example, sufferings, temptations, victories, resurrection, and ascension, and in his kingly, prophetical, and priestly offices, and in all the benefits he has purchased for his flock, what full and pleasant work is here for the daily thoughts of a believer!
The soul may dwell here in continual delight, until it can say with Paul, "I am crucified with Christ, nevertheless I live; yet not I, but Christ liveth in me: and the life which I now live in the flesh, I live by the faith of the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me" (Gal 2:20). Therefore daily "bow your knees to the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, of whom the whole family in heaven and earth is named, that he would grant you according to the riches of his glory, to be strengthened with might by his Spirit in the inner man; that Christ may dwell in your hearts by faith; that ye being rooted and grounded in love, may be able to comprehend with all saints, what is the breadth, and length, and depth, and height, and to know the love of Christ which passeth knowledge, that ye might be filled with all the fulness of God" (Eph 3:14–20).
Direction 6. Search the holy Scriptures, acquaint yourselves thoroughly with the oracles of God, which are able to make you wise for salvation, and you will find abundant matter for your thoughts. If you cannot find work enough for your minds among all those heights and depths, those excellencies and difficulties, it is because you have never truly understood them or never set your hearts to search them.
What mysterious doctrines, how sublime and heavenly, are there for you to meditate on as long as you live. What a perfect law: a system of precepts most spiritual and pure! What terrible threats against offenders are there to supply your meditations. What wonderful histories of love and mercy! What holy examples! What a treasury of precious promises, on which rests our hope of eternal life! What full and free expressions of grace! What a joyful act of pardon and amnesty for penitent, believing sinners! In a word, the title-deed of our inheritance and the law by which we must be governed and judged are set before us for our daily meditation.
David, who had far less of Scripture than we do, said, "O how I love thy law: it is my meditation all the day" (Ps 119:97). God said to Joshua, "This book of the law shall not depart out of thy mouth, but thou shalt meditate therein day and night, that thou mayest observe to do according to all that is written therein" (Josh 1:8). And Moses commanded the Israelites that "these words should be in their hearts," that they should "teach them diligently to their children, and talk of them when they sat in their houses, and when they walked by the way, and when they lay down, and when they rose up," and should "write them on the posts of their houses, and on their gates" (Deut 6:7), so that they might be sure to remember them.
Direction 7. Know yourself well as the work of God, and in yourself you will find abundant matter for meditation. There you have God’s natural image to meditate on and admire: the noble faculties of understanding, free will, and executive power. If you are not unregenerate, you also have his moral or spiritual image to meditate on, your holy wisdom, will, and power; your holy light, love, and power, with readiness for holy practice, all united in a single holy life. And you have his relative image to meditate on: your being, first, the lord and owner; second, the ruler; and third, the benefactor of the inferior creatures, and their end. (See my book The Mischiefs of Self-Ignorance.) What a world of mysteries you carry continually within that small compass!
What abundance of wonders are in your body, which is fearfully and wonderfully made, and still greater wonders in your soul. You are yourself the clearest mirror in which God is to be seen under heaven, as both a human being and a saint. You are therefore the most worthy object for your own meditations, after the holy Word which is your rule, and the holy church which is but a gathering of many such. What a shame it is that nearly all people live and die such strangers to themselves, utterly unacquainted with the innumerable excellencies and mysteries God has placed within them, while they let their thoughts run out upon vanities and trifles, and then complain of their barrenness and want of material to feed their better meditations.
Direction 8. Do not remain a stranger to the many sins, failings, and weaknesses of your soul, and you will never lack material for meditation. Though these thoughts are not the sweetest, your own folly has made them necessary. If you are dangerously sick, or even painfully sore, you can hardly forget it. If poverty presses on you with grinding want, your thoughts are consumed by care and trouble day and night. If someone wrongs you, you find it easy to dwell on that. Yet you have so often wronged your God and Savior, so unkindly cheapened his mercy, so ungratefully made light of saving grace, so presumptuously and carelessly exposed yourself to his wrath, and still you find yourself short of material for meditation?
You have all the sins of your youth and ignorance to reflect on, and all the sins of rashness and sensuality, of negligence and sloth, of worldliness and self-seeking, ambition and pride, your passions and your omissions, your sinful thoughts and words, and yet you claim to be starved of matter? Do you not carry about you such a body of death, so much selfishness, pride, worldliness, and carnality; so much ignorance, unbelief, aversion to God, and reluctance toward everything spiritual and holy; so much passion and readiness to sin, and yet find nothing sufficient to think on?
Look over the sins of your whole life. See them in all their aggravations: committed against knowledge, against means and helps, against mercies and judgments, against your own vows and promises; in prosperity and under affliction; in secret and in company; in your general and particular calling, in all your relationships, every place, time, and condition you have lived in. Consider your sins directly against God, and your injuries and neglects of your neighbor; sins against holy duties, and sins committed in the performance of holy duties, in prayer, hearing, reading, the sacraments, meditation, conversation, reproofs given and received; your careless preparations for death and judgment; your soul’s distance from God and heaven. Is there not work enough here for your meditations?
If you think not, it is because your heart has never felt the bitterness of sin, nor been truly acquainted with repentance. The time is yet to come when light must show you what sin is, what you are, what you have done, how full your heart is of the serpent’s brood, and that your sin must find you out. Do you not know that your sins are as the sand on the shore, or as the hairs of your head for number? That every sin carries deadly poison in it, and a malignant enmity against God and holiness, and yet these are not enough to keep your thoughts from idleness?
Judge by the language of true penitents whether this is so. "Wash me throughly from my wickedness, and cleanse me from my sin: for I acknowledge my transgressions, and my sin is ever before me." (Ps 51:2–3) "For innumerable evils have compassed me about: mine iniquities have taken hold upon me, so that I am not able to look up: they are more than the hairs of my head: therefore my heart faileth me." (Ps 40:12) "I thought on my ways, and turned my feet unto thy testimonies." (Ps 119:59)
True repentance is described in this way: "Then shall ye remember your own evil ways, and your doings that were not good, and shall loathe yourselves in your own sight, for your own iniquities, and for your abominations." (Ezek 36:31) Indeed, God’s forgiving and forgetting your sins must not lead you to forget them yourself. "I will establish to thee an everlasting covenant; then shalt thou remember thy ways and be ashamed. And I will establish my covenant with thee; that thou mayest be confounded, and never open thy mouth any more, because of thy shame, when I am pacified towards thee for all that thou hast done, saith the Lord God of hosts." (Ezek 16:60–63)
Thus evil may be made the object and occasion of good: it is good to meditate on evil in order to hate it and avoid it. Keep acquaintance with conscience, read through its records, and it will supply your thoughts with humbling material.
Direction 9. Do not remain ignorant of Satan’s methods, subtleties, and diligence in tempting your soul to ruin, and you will find material enough to keep your thoughts from idleness. He is continually scheming to deceive and destroy you. Does it not concern you to think how to defeat him, escape his snares, and save yourself? If the hare does not run as fast as the hound, it will die for it.
If only your eyes were opened to see the snares laid for you, in your own nature, in your temperament and passions, in your interests and relationships, in your friends and acquaintances and ordinary company; in your business dealings and possessions, your house, goods, lands, livestock, tenants, and servants, and everyone you trade with or have dealings with; in your clothing and recreations; in your food, drink, sleep, and ease; in prosperity and adversity; in people’s good or poor opinion of you; in their praise and their blame; in their kindnesses and their wrongs; in their favor and their falling out; in their pleasing or displeasing you; in your very thinking and speaking, and in everything you have to do with. If you could but see all these temptations, and see also where they tend and what they would bring you to, you would find material enough to cure the idleness and wandering of your thoughts.
Direction 10. The world and every creature in it, which you see every day and which reveals to you the great Creator, ought to be enough to keep your thoughts from idleness. If sun, moon, and stars; if heaven and earth with all they contain, are not enough to engage your thoughts, then your idleness has some excuse. You will say, of course, that it is upon some of these things that you do employ your thoughts, but do you not first destroy and kill what you are meditating on, and make nonsense of it? Do you not first separate the creature from God, who is its life, glory, purpose, and meaning? You strip the soul from it and contemplate only the corpse, or you view the creature as mere food for your sensual appetite, as the kite thinks of birds and chicks only to devour them and satisfy its greed. In this way you can think about all God’s works, as long as they serve your flesh.
But the world is God’s book, which he set man at first to read. Every creature is a letter, syllable, word, or sentence, more or less, declaring the name and will of God. There you may behold his wonderful almightiness, his unsearchable wisdom, his immeasurable goodness, mercy, and compassion, and his singular regard for the children of men. The ungodly, proud, and carnal-minded may toy with and study the shape, elegance, and order of the letters, syllables, and words without understanding the sense and purpose. But those who come with holy and illuminated minds to trace the footsteps of the great, wise, and bountiful Creator will find not only material to occupy their thoughts, but material to profit and delight them. The things that are seen may carry them up into sacred wonder, reverence, love, and praise of the glorious unseen Maker of all. Thus to the sanctified, all things will be sanctified, and the study of common things will become divine and holy.
Direction 11. Do not remain ignorant of, or indifferent to, the wonders of providence in God’s governance of the world, and you will find an abundance of material for your thoughts. The dreadfulness of judgments, the delightfulness of mercies, the mystery of all God’s dealings, will be matter for daily searching and wonder. Consider the remarkable preservation of the church, a people hated by all the world, how so small a flock of lambs is kept safe among so many ravenous wolves. Consider God’s sharp afflictions of his own offending people; his severe and consuming judgments sometimes executed upon the wicked, when he intends to set up here and there a monument of his justice as a warning to presumptuous sinners.
Go see how the wicked are deceived by pleasures that befool them, and how the prosperity of fools destroys them; see how they flourish today like a green bay tree, or like the flower of the field, and then go into their sanctuary and see their end: how tomorrow they are cut down and withered, and the place that knew them knows them no more. See how God delights to abase the proud, and to "scatter them in the imagination of their hearts; to put down the mighty from their seats, and to exalt them of low degree; to fill the hungry with good things; and to send the rich empty away." (Luke 1:51–53)
"How great are his signs: and how mighty are his wonders? His kingdom is an everlasting kingdom." (Dan 4:3) "He ruleth in the kingdom of men, and giveth it to whomsoever he will." (Dan 4:32) "For wisdom and might are his; and he changeth the times and the seasons: he removeth kings, and setteth up kings: he giveth wisdom unto the wise, and knowledge to them that know understanding. He revealeth the deep and secret things: he knoweth what is in darkness, and the light dwelleth with him." (Dan 2:20–22) "The Lord is known by the judgment which he executeth; the wicked is snared in the work of his own hand." (Ps 9:16)
Mark also how the upright are daily afflicted, how the feet of violence trample upon them, and yet how they rejoice and hold fast to the very God who afflicts them, how they pity and pray for their miserable persecutors and oppressors, and how "all things do work together for their good." (Rom 8:28) "Wonderful are all the works of God, sought out of them that have pleasure therein." (Ps 111:2) The histories of former ages, and careful observation of the present, will reveal to you a world of material for your thoughts.
Direction 12. Understand all the features and beauty of God’s image upon a holy soul, the excellence and use of every grace, and the harmony of them all, and you will have an abundance of profitable material for your thoughts. Know the nature of every grace, its place and order, its function, use, and exercise, and the means, motives, opposites, dangers, and safeguards belonging to it. Know it as God’s image, and see and love your Maker, Redeemer, and Regenerator in it. Know how God loves it, how useful it is for serving and honoring him in the world, and how deformed and vile a soul is that lacks it.
Know well what faith is; what wisdom and prudence are; what repentance, humility, and mortification are; what hope, fear, desire, obedience, meekness, temperance, sobriety, chastity, contentment, justice, and self-denial are. Know especially the nature and power of love, to God, to his servants, to neighbors, and to enemies. Know what holy resignation and devotedness to God are, and what watchfulness, diligence, zeal, courage, perseverance, patience, submission, and peace are. Know the worth, use, helps, and hindrances of all these, and then your thoughts will not be idle.
Direction 13. If you are not a stranger to the Spirit of Grace, nor a neglecter of his daily movements, persuasions, and operations on your heart, then attending to and making use of them will keep your thoughts from rusty idleness and a wandering course. It is no small thing daily to entertain so noble a guest, to observe daily the offers and movements of so great a benefactor, to receive daily the gifts of so bountiful a Lord, to accept daily his necessary help, and to obey daily the saving commands of so great and gracious a God.
If you knew how insufficient you are without him, to will or to act, to perform or even to think or purpose any good, and that all your sufficiency comes from him, and if you knew that the great skill and diligence required of all who would sail successfully to the desired land of rest is to know the winds of the Spirit’s help, to set all your sails toward the right use of them, and to stir yourself while such favorable winds continue, you would find greater work for your thoughts than wandering.
Direction 14. Be neither ignorant nor neglectful of that pattern and course of holy duty to God and to others in which your whole life should be spent, and you cannot lack material to occupy your thoughts. Your pulse, your breath, and your natural bodily functions continue whether you think of them or not, but holy, moral movement does not, for it must be rational and voluntary. You have all the powers of soul and body to exercise either upon God or for God. You must know him, fear him, love him, obey him, trust him, worship him, pray to him, praise him, give thanks to him, mourn over your sins, hear his Word, and reverently use his name and his day. Is not learning how to do all this, and practicing it in season and in earnest, enough to keep your thoughts from idleness? A serious Christian finds abundant work for his thoughts in any single one of these, in how to pray rightly, or to hear rightly, or to receive the sacrament of Christ’s body and blood rightly.
But beyond all this, how much duty do you have to perform toward magistrates, pastors, parents, masters, and other superiors; toward subjects, people, children, servants, and other inferiors; toward every neighbor, for his soul, his body, his estate, and his reputation; and to do to all as you would be done by. And beyond all that, how much do you have to do directly for yourself, for your soul, your body, your family, and your estate, against your ignorance, unbelief, pride, selfishness, sensuality, worldliness, passion, sloth, intemperance, cowardice, lust, and uncharitableness? Is there not here material for your thoughts?
Direction 15. Do not overlook that life full of particular mercies which God has bestowed on you, and you will find pleasant and profitable material for your thoughts. To spare myself the labor of repeating them, look back to Chapter 3, Direction 14. Think of the mercy that brought you into the world and chose your parents, your place, and your condition; that brought you up and bore with you patiently through all your sins and closely warned you of every danger; that afflicted you in due season and delivered you in due season, and heard your prayers in many a distress; that has kept even the worst of you from death and hell, and has regenerated, justified, adopted, and sanctified those whom he has prepared for eternal life.
How many sins he has forgiven! How many he has in part subdued! How many helps he has granted you, and how well suited to your need! From how many enemies he has saved you! How often he has delighted you through his Word and grace! What comforts you have had in his servants and ordinances, in your relationships and callings! His mercies are innumerable, and yet do your meditations lack material? If I were merely to recite David’s words from many of his psalms of thanksgiving, you would see that mercy gave his thoughts abundant employment.
Direction 16. Foresee the exact and righteous judgment you will shortly undergo, and it will go far toward finding employment for your thoughts. A person who must give an account to God of all that he has done, both good and evil, and who does not know how soon that account will be called for (for all he knows, before tomorrow), ought surely to find something better than vanity to think on.
Is it nothing to be ready for so great a day? To have your justification secure? Your accounts settled? Your conscience cleansed and quieted on solid grounds? To know what answer to give for yourself against the accuser? To be clear and certain that you are indeed regenerate, that you have a part in Christ, that you are washed in his blood, reconciled to God, and will not prove to be a hypocrite or self-deceiver in that testing day, when the sentence will finally decide whether you are saved or damned, and determine whether you go to heaven or hell forever, and you have so short and uncertain a time for preparation?
Will this not supply your thoughts with material? If you were on your way to a trial for your life or your entire estate, you would count that sufficient to occupy your thoughts along the road. How much more, then, this final and dreadful judgment!
Direction 17. If all this will not serve, it is no surprise if God calls your thoughts home through sharp afflictions, and surely the task of making proper use of them, and of seeking their removal, ought to find some employment for your thoughts. It is time then to search and examine your ways and turn again to the Lord (Lam 3:40). Find the Achan who troubles your peace; understand the voice of the rod, what God is angry at, and what he is calling you to consider. Discover what root bears these bitter fruits, and how afflictions may be sanctified to make you conformable to Christ and partakers of his holiness (Heb 12:10).
Beyond the exercise of holy patience and submission, there is a great deal of work to be done in sufferings: to exercise faith, to honor God and the good cause of your suffering, to humble yourself for the sinful cause of it, and to gain the spiritual benefit. If you will not meditate on the duty, you will meditate on the pain whether you choose to or not, and you will say as in Lamentations 3:17–20: "I forgat prosperity: and I said, My strength and my hope is perished from the Lord: remembering mine affliction and my misery, the wormwood and the gall: my soul hath them still in remembrance, and is humbled in me."
Do not force God to remind you by this spur, or drive your meditations by so sharp a means. "Therefore did he consume their days in vanity, and their years in trouble: when he slew them, then they sought him, and they returned and inquired early after God: and they remembered that God was their rock, and the high God their Redeemer" (Ps 78:33–35).
Direction 18. Be diligent in your calling, spend no time in idleness, and perform your work with a holy mind, to the glory of God and in obedience to his commands, and your thoughts will have less leisure and freedom for vanity or idleness. Bodily employment occupies the thoughts: those who have much to do have much to think about, for they must do it prudently, skillfully, and carefully if they are to do it successfully, and so they must think how to do it. The urgency and necessity of business will almost compel the thoughts and carry them forward and give them work, though some employments do this more than others.
Let no one think these thoughts are bad or worthless because they concern worldly things, for if the labor itself is not bad or worthless, then neither are the thoughts that are necessary to performing the work well. Nor should any worldling take comfort here and say, "My thoughts are taken up with my calling," for his calling itself has been perverted by him and made a carnal work for carnal ends, when it should be sanctified.
For the thoughts about your labor to be good, two things are required.
1. Your labor itself must be good, performed in obedience to God, for the good of others, and to his glory.
2. Your labor and your thoughts must keep their proper bounds: higher things must still be preferred, sought, and thought on first. Your labors should occupy your thoughts only as much as is needed to perform them well, but better things must be thought on in those labors that leave room for the mind to range.
Diligence in your calling is nevertheless a very great help for keeping out sinful thoughts and supplying you with thoughts that, in their proper place, are good.
Direction 19. You have all God’s spiritual helps and holy ordinances to feed your meditations and quicken them, and you should use them whenever your mind grows dull or barren. When your mind is empty and you cannot draw up plentiful matter for holy thoughts, reading a well-chosen book, or talking with a mature and experienced Christian, will supply that matter, as will hearing a profitable sermon. Sometimes prayer will do more than meditation alone.
Weak-headed persons, of small knowledge and shallow memory, must draw the material for their meditations more frequently from reading and conversation than others need to. Because they can hold only a little at a time, they must go to these sources more often, as someone who carries water in a spoon or small dish must go to the well more often than someone who carries a larger vessel. Those who have a broad storehouse of knowledge can carry their meditation material with them at all times; those with very little knowledge and memory must have their meditations fed by others, as infants are fed by the spoon. For such people, a little and often is the best approach, both for reading and hearing, and for holy thought itself.
What great mercy it is that weak Christians have such an abundance of helps, that when their minds are empty, they have books and friends who are not empty, from whom they may draw help as they need it. And their hearts are not empty of the love of God, which moves them to do more than their natural capacity enables them to do.
Direction 20. If all these means do not sufficiently supply your meditations, look out across the world and consider what a multitude of miserable souls call for your compassion and your daily prayers on their behalf. Think on the many nations lying in the darkness of idolatry and unbelief. Fewer than one sixth of the world’s people are Christians of any kind. The other five parts are heathens, Mahometans, and a small number of Jews. Of this sixth part, only a small portion has been reformed from popery and the corruptions that Eastern and Southern Christians are also too much defiled with. And within the Reformed churches, how common are profaneness and worldliness, and how few are acquainted with the power of true godliness!
What numbers of ignorant and ungodly persons there are, who hate the power and practice of the very religion they profess and hope to be saved by, as though they expected to be saved for hating, persecuting, and disobeying it. Among those who appear more serious and obedient, how many are hypocrites? How many are possessed by pride and self-conceit, which break out into disorder, contention, and uncharitableness, factions, and divisions in the church? How many Christians are ignorant, passionate, weak, unprofitable, and too many of them scandalous! How few are judicious, prudent, heavenly-minded, charitable, peaceable, humble, meek, diligent, and fruitful, and who have given themselves wholly to being good and doing good?
And of these few, how few are there who are not burdened under heavy afflictions from God, or cruel persecutions from ungodly men? What tyranny is exercised by the Turk from without, and the Pope from within, upon the sincerest followers of Christ! Set all this together, and consider whether your compassionate thoughts and your prayers need ever go without fuel or matter to sustain them from day to day.
CHAPTER 8
DIRECTIONS FOR MAKING GOOD THOUGHTS EFFECTUAL: OR, GENERAL DIRECTIONS FOR MEDITATION
Some of these directions are preparatory; others concern the work of meditation itself.
Direction 1. Make sure that reason maintains its authority in commanding and governing your thoughts, and that they are not left masterless to be carried wherever fancy, passion, and outward objects please to take them. Diseased, melancholy, and disturbed persons have almost no power over their own thoughts. They cannot direct them to what they would have them dwell on, nor call them away from whatever they have run out after. Their thoughts are like an unruly horse with a weak rider, or one that has thrown the rider entirely, like a masterless dog that will not come or go at your command. Our thoughts, by contrast, ought to be under the direction of reason and the command of the will, to start or stop the moment they are bid.
Consider how a student governs his thoughts throughout the day: he can appoint what they will meditate on, in what order, and for how long. A lawyer, a physician, and workers in every trade do the same regarding their craft. A Christian ought to do likewise regarding the matters of his soul. All rules of direction are of little use to those whose reason has lost its power to govern their thoughts.
If I say to a deeply melancholy man, "Order your thoughts in such and such a way," he will tell me that he cannot, his thoughts are not in his power. For any price you could offer, he is not able to stop thinking of what disturbs him, or to direct his thoughts where you would have them go; he thinks only as his disease and trouble drive him. What good do precepts do to such a person? Grace, doctrine, and exhortation all work through reason and the commanding will.
If a holy person could manage his heart-raising practical meditations as steadily, regularly, and readily as a carnal, covetous preacher manages his thoughts when studying the same subjects for carnal ends, to profit from them or to win applause, how well our work would go! Is it not grievous to think that carnal ends should accomplish so much more than spiritual ones, even in the same subject matter?
Direction 2. Carefully avoid the disease of melancholy, for it dethrones reason and disables it from ruling the thoughts. Full distraction disables entirely; melancholy disables only in part, in proportion to how far it has taken hold, and therefore still leaves some room for counsel.
Direction 3. Guard against sloth and negligence of the will, by which reason’s directions go unexecuted for lack of resolution and command, so that every temptation carries the thoughts away. A lazy coachman lets the horses go wherever they like, because he will not trouble himself to restrain them, and so breaks his neck to save his effort.
If, when you feel unclean or worldly thoughts invading your mind, you will not rouse your will, rise against them, and firmly command them out, you will be like a lazy man who lies in bed watching thieves rob his house and lets everything go rather than get up and resist, a sign that he has no great treasure to lose, or he would stir for it. And if you see your duty and know what your thoughts should be doing, but will not resolutely call them to their work, you will be like a sluggard who lets all his servants lie in bed simply because he will not speak to wake them.
Daily experience shows that a person’s thoughts are substantially in the power of the will and can be made to obey it. If money, honor, or the love of knowledge can cause a wicked preacher to command his own thoughts to good things, as described above, then you can command yours to the same things, if you will only exercise your authority over them with equal resolution.
Direction 4. Do not let your thoughts get used to taking their liberty and going ungoverned; for use will make them headstrong and unresponsive to the voice of reason, and will make reason itself careless and slack. Habit and custom have great power over the mind. Where we are used to walking, the path is plain; where there is no such use, there is no path at all. Where water is used to running, there is a channel. It is hard to govern those who are accustomed to being ungoverned.
If habit does so much with the tongue, as we see in those who by custom curse, swear, and speak foolishly, and in others who by the same custom speak soberly and reverently; in some who by practice can speak well in conversation, preaching, or prayer for many hours together, while others who never practice it can do almost nothing in that way, why should habit not prevail just as powerfully over the thoughts?
Direction 5. Take care lest the senses and appetites grow too strong and master reason; for if they do, they will at once dispossess reason of the government of the thoughts, and will themselves brutishly usurp that power. When a rebellious army deposes a king, they not only throw off subjection themselves, but dissolve the government over all other subjects as well, and typically seize power for themselves.
If you have become a servant to your fleshly appetites and senses, your thoughts will have other work to do and another direction to run when you call them to holy and necessary things, especially when enticing objects are close at hand. You might as reasonably expect a clod of earth to rise like fire, or a swine to take delight in temperance, as expect a glutton, a drunkard, or a fornicator to delight in holy contemplation. Reason and the flesh cannot both be the governors.
Direction 6. Keep passions under control, so that they do not depose reason from the government of your thoughts. Passions cause evil thoughts, as I noted earlier, and they equally hinder good ones. Four passions are particular enemies to meditation: 1. Anger. 2. Distressing grief. 3. Unsettling fear. 4. But above all, excessive pleasure in any worldly or fleshly thing. Who can suppose the mind is fit for holy contemplation when it blazes with wrath, is pulled apart by grief and anxiety, trembles with fear, or is drunk with pleasure? Grief and fear are the most harmless of the four; yet all four hinder reason from governing the thoughts.
Direction 7. Evil habits are another great hindrance to reason’s command over the thoughts; therefore labor diligently for the cure of this disease. Though habits do not compel absolutely, they incline powerfully. When every good thought must make its way against a strong and settled inclination, reason will grow weary of driving the soul, and you can expect very little progress.
Direction 8. Urgent and pressing business nearly forces the thoughts into its service; therefore, as much as you can, avoid such urgencies when you want to be free for meditation. At the times when you want your thoughts entirely and freely given to God, let them have as little that would divert them as possible.
Direction 9. Crowds and bad company are no friends to meditation; therefore seek the quiet of solitude when you would accomplish much in this work. Just as studying in a crowd is difficult, and secret prayer before a multitude is out of place, except for short, spontaneous prayers, so too is that setting unfit for holy meditation. A mind fixed on God and on spiritual things needs all possible freedom and peace to retire into itself, withdraw from foreign concerns, and give itself seriously to its greater work.
Direction 10. Above all, guard against sinful interests and designs; for these are the stronghold of Satan, and must be overthrown before any holy thoughts can take root. A man set on schemes of advancement or the accumulation of wealth has something else entirely occupying him, and no room for the sober thoughts of eternal things that would undermine his carnal design.
Direction 11. Now that the impediments to reason’s authority have been removed in the ways described, distinguish between your occasional thoughts and your settled, ordinary course of thought. Just as your hands have their regular daily work that you expect and prepare for each day, so let your thoughts know where their proper channel lies and what their daily task is; and let holy prudence assign them proportionate time and subjects. Consider what life the man leads who has no known routine of labor, but only responds to whatever work happens to fall to him by chance: his work will inevitably be uncertain, scattered, unprofitable, and cheerless, barely work at all. The person who has no settled employment for his thoughts will get little service from them.
First, consider how much of the day is ordinarily spent in common business; then consider whether that business requires your thoughts as well as your hands, or whether it leaves your thoughts at liberty. A lawyer, a physician, a merchant, and most tradesmen must engage their thoughts fully to do their work well, and these must be all the more eager for a free and suitable hour for meditation, precisely because their thoughts are otherwise occupied for the rest of the day.
But a weaver, a tailor, certain other tradesmen, and day laborers can do their work well and still have their thoughts free for better things through a great part of the day. These must contrive a regular way of employing their thoughts when their work does not require them, and for them no other time for meditation is necessary. Those whose business fully occupies their thoughts must content themselves with short, occasional meditations woven into their work; they cannot then find time for more solemn meditation, which differs from the occasional kind as a set prayer differs from a brief, spontaneous one, or as a sermon differs from a passing brief remark.
Those who have more time for their thoughts should beforehand carefully consider how much of it is best spent in meditation for the increase of knowledge, how much for the exercise of holy affections, on what subjects, and in what order, and so come to know their ordinary work.
Direction 12. Place yourself under the urgency of necessity and the power of those motives that should most effectively engage your thoughts. In the example already given, what is it that enables even a wicked preacher to study divine things in an orderly way year after year? It is simply that he remains under the power of his carnal motives, profit, honor, and a degree of pleasure. If you will place yourself habitually and consistently under the sense and power of your far greater motives, always perceiving how much is at stake for yourself, for others, and for the honor of God, this will be a constant counterweight and spring that, once properly wound up, keeps the wheels in steady motion.
Direction 13. Make the service of your Master and the saving of yourself and others your daily business in the world, following it as your ordinary calling, and it will carry your thoughts along with it. Whoever serves God only incidentally, with occasional service, will think of him and his work only incidentally, with occasional thoughts. A close and diligent course of holy living is the best support for a constant and profitable course of holy thinking.
Direction 14. The chief point of skill and holy wisdom, both here and in other religious duties, is to take the course that tends to make religion pleasant and to draw your soul to delight in God, and to guard against whatever would make all of this grievous to you. It is easy and sweet to think of what you take pleasure in. But if Satan can make everything irksome and unpleasant to you, your thoughts will flee it as you flee a carcass, stopping your nose and hurrying away. The Psalmist says in Psalm 104:34, "My meditation of him shall be sweet; I will be glad in the LORD."
Directions about the Work Itself
Direction 1. Just as you must never be without a holy store of material, so you must prudently choose your particular subject. As the choice of a fitting text is half of a good sermon, so the choice of the most fitting subject is much of a good meditation, and this requires genuine acquaintance both with the truth and with yourself.
Direction 2. To that end, you must know what subjects are most excellent in themselves for meditation, and know them in their proper order of rank. The first and highest is the most blessed God himself, and the glorious person of our Redeemer, and the New Jerusalem, the heaven of glory where he is revealed to his saints. Then comes the blessed company that enjoys him there, and the holy vision, love, and joy by which he is enjoyed. Next is the wonderful work of man’s redemption, the covenant of grace, the sanctifying work of the Holy Ghost, and all the graces that constitute God’s image on the soul.
After that comes the state and privileges of the church, which is the body of Christ, for whom all this is accomplished and prepared. Then comes the work of the Gospel, by which this church is gathered, built up, and saved. Then the matter of our own salvation, our state of grace and the way to life. Then the salvation of others. Then the common public good in temporal respects. Then our personal bodily welfare. Then the bodily welfare of our neighbors. And last, those things that bear only a remote relation to all the above.
This is the order of worth and desirability, and it tells you what should hold the highest place in your thoughts and prayers.
Direction 3. You must also know what subject is most timely for your thoughts at any given moment, and refuse even a good thing when it is out of season. A good thing, used at the wrong time, may do harm. The tempter may introduce a good meditation precisely to divert you from a greater good, or to interrupt a duty already in hand, putting in some good thought to turn you from something better, or inserting it in the middle of a sermon or prayer.
Or, if he sees that you are not in a fit state for meditation, or that you have no leisure for it without neglecting your more proper work, he will drive you on regardless, so that by the outcome he may discourage and wound you, making the duty unprofitable and grievous and leaving you more averse to it afterward. Untimely duty may be no duty at all, but a sin covered over with a material good, just as the Pharisees’ sabbath-rest was when mercy called them to set it aside.
Direction 4. Carefully examine and settle the end and purpose of your meditation before you begin, and then labor to fit the meditation to that specific end. The end is first in the intention; from love of the end the means are chosen and used. If you aim to increase knowledge, you must meditate on the evidence for truth and on the matter to be known, in a convincing, demonstrative way. If you aim to increase or exercise divine faith, you must meditate on God’s revealed word, both its content and the evidence of its credibility.
If you want to stir the fear of God, you have his greatness and terribleness, his justice and his warnings to meditate on. If you want to stir love for God, you have his goodness, his mercy, Christ, and his promises to meditate on. If you are preparing for death and judgment, you have your heart to examine, your life to repent of, your graces to discover and revive and exercise, the diseases of your soul to feel, and the remedies to apply. So whenever you intend to make anything of a set meditation, first determine the end, and from it determine the means.
Direction 5. Clarify the truth of things in your mind as far as you can before you labor hard to work them on your affections, lest you afterwards discover that you only misinformed yourself and spent all your effort in vain, printing deluding images on your mind and leading your affections to bow before them. Many have done exactly this by embracing errors, pouring out their zeal upon them for years together, making those errors the ground of hatred, contention, and bitter censure of opposing brethren, forming parties, divisions, and disturbances in the church on their account, only to discover after so many years of zealous sinning that the whole thing was like Michal’s image: a man of straw instead of David, and all that filthy commotion raised in a dream.
Direction 6. Labor next to perceive the weight of everything you think on, whether good or evil. To that end, make sure that God and eternity are brought into every meditation, and that all things are judged in their relation to God and to your eternal state, for only this gives you a true estimate and sense of good and evil. Life, soul, and power will be missing from even your most excellent meditations insofar as God is absent from them and they lack a divine character.
When you meditate on any scriptural truth, think of it as a beam from the Eternal Light, dictated by the Holy Ghost to lead people through obedience to blessedness. Look on it with reverence as a letter or message sent from heaven, a matter of great importance to your soul. When you meditate on any grace, think of it as a part of God’s image, planted and animated by the Holy Ghost to advance the soul into communion with God and prepare it for him.
When you meditate on any duty, remember who commands it, whom you are chiefly to regard in your obedience, and what the end of obeying or disobeying will be. When you meditate on any sin, remember that it is the defacing or deprivation of God’s image, the rebel that rises against him in all his attributes to depose him from the government of the soul and of the world, and foresee the end to which it tends. Bring God in, if you would feel life and power in all that you meditate on.
Direction 7. Let your ordinary meditations be on the great and necessary things, and think less frequently on matters of lesser necessity. Meditation is only a means to a further end: it is to work some good upon the soul. Therefore use those subjects that are most powerful and fitted to work that good. Great truths will do great work upon the heart. They are also generally the surest, the least disputed. There is more weight, substance, and power to benefit the soul in one article of the Creed, or one petition of the Lord’s Prayer, or one commandment of the Decalogue, than in a great quantity of the controverted opinions that have troubled people in every age, just as one purse of gold will buy more than a large heap of farthings.
Meditating on great and weighty truths makes great and weighty Christians. Meditating inordinately on minor and disputed opinions makes superficial, opinionated, and contentious professors. Lesser things may have their time and place, but it must be little time and the last place, except when God makes some lesser thing the matter of our lawful calling and employment (as all the common affairs of the world are lesser things). In that case, they may claim a larger share of our time, though they must still hold the lowest place in our estimation and in our hearts.
Direction 8. Whenever you are called to meditate on any smaller truth or matter, do not take it as though it were cut off from the greater truths, but always view it as connected to them, growing from them and receiving its life and beauty from them. In this way you will preserve the life and importance of the greatest matters in your heart, and will not let lesser things wither into deceptions or idols. We are to climb upward, not descend; we begin at the trunk of the tree and pass up to the few great boughs, and from there to the many smaller branches, which, being hard to distinguish, count, and remember, are not all strong enough to bear our weight, and are fitted more to be observed than to be stood upon.
But if you treat those smaller branches as though they had no connection to the greater ones, and cut them off, they lose their life, beauty, and fruitfulness. If all the controversies in the church had been managed with due honor for holiness, charity, unity, peace, and the greater truths, and if all the circumstantials of religion had been ordered with a saving proviso, due regard, and proper subordination to the power and spirituality of holy worship, the Christian world would have had far more life, strength, and fruitfulness, and far less empty ceremony, hollow religion, frivolous compliment, and hypocrisy.
Direction 9. Let the purpose and order of your meditations be: first, to settle your judgment; second, to resolve and settle your will; third, to reform and improve your life; and only fourth, after all these, to raise your holy passions and lively feeling, which must have no more than their proper room and place. Where some of these are already accomplished, you may assume them and move on to what remains to be done.
If you already know what is sin and what is duty but fail to do it, your meditation should not aim at informing you of what you already know, but first at seriously considering the truth you know and setting it powerfully before you, and then at bringing your will to a fixed resolution of obedience. But if the truth in question bears chiefly on the will and affections, as when you are drawing your heart toward love of God by meditating on his attractive excellencies, then most of your effort must be directed there. On this see Chapter 3, Direction 11.
Direction 10. Turn your reflections often into soliloquies, methodically and earnestly preaching to your own heart on the subject, as you would preach to others if their souls depended on it. This will keep you orderly, prevent your mind from rambling and wandering, and supply you with continual material, for method is a wonderful aid to invention, memory, and delight. It will also bring things most quickly to bear on your affections: earnest pleading of convincing reasons with your own heart is a powerful way to make the fire burn and to kindle desire, fear, love, hatred, repentance, shame, sorrow, joy, resolution, or any other good effect.
Convictions, self-reproach, expostulations, rebukes, and self-persuasion can be very powerful, whereas a dull bare train of thought is like dull preaching with no lively application: it stirs the hearers little. Learn deliberately from the liveliest books you read and the best and most fervent preachers you hear how to preach to your own heart; use this method in an orderly way, and you will find it a most powerful way of meditating.
Direction 11. Turn your meditations often into brief, fervent prayers and addresses to God, for this will keep you reverent, serious, and alert, and will make everything more powerful, because more divine. When you meditate on sin, turn at times to God with penitent lamentation, saying: "Lord, what a wretch and rebel was I, to entertain such an enemy of yours in my heart, and for nothing, to offend you and violate your laws! O pardon me, O cleanse me, O strengthen me! Conquer and cast out this hateful enemy of you and of me."
So also when you are seeking to stir up or exercise any grace, send up a fervent request to God to show his love and power upon your dead and sluggish heart, and to be the principal agent in a work that is so much his own. Prayer is a most holy duty, in which the soul comes so near to God that if there is any holy seriousness in the heart, it will be stirred up by it; even a dull and wandering mind bears some reverence toward God, and therefore brings him into everything.
On this see the fourth part of my Saints’ Rest more fully.
Direction 12. Let every meditation be undertaken with a humble sense of your own insufficiency, and with believing dependence on your Head and Savior to guide and quicken you by his Holy Spirit, and to cover the infirmities of your holiest thoughts. Whatever good is written upon our hearts must be "written by the Spirit of the living God," and this "trust we must have through Christ to Godward: not that we are sufficient of ourselves to think any thing as of ourselves: but our sufficiency is of God" (2 Cor 3:3–5). How heavily everything will go, or rather how certainly we will labor in vain and abandon it all, if Christ casts us off and leaves us to ourselves! Do not think that your life and strength are rooted in yourselves: go to him by renewed acts of faith, through whom alone you can be quickened.
Direction 13. Do not let your holy thoughts be so infrequent that you remain a stranger to the matter of your meditations, nor so brief that they are gone before you have made anything of them. An occasional passing thought will not acquaint the soul with God or bring it to a settled habit and temper of holiness. What you think on frequently and seriously, as both your work and your delight, becomes the nourishment and very nature of your soul, as the air we breathe daily and the food we live on daily become part of our bodies. You will find that as practice breeds skill and strength, so it produces such acquaintance and familiarity as greatly advances both the fruit and the comfort of the work. Those who only cast an occasional glance at God and holiness lose so quickly the little they gain that it makes no great change in them.
Direction 14. Yet do not overdo it in terms of intensity or length; carry on the work sincerely according to the capacity of your mind and body, lest by going beyond your strength you strain your brain, disorder your mind, and render yourself unable to do anything at all. Although we cannot value and love God too highly, it is possible to think of him with too much intensity or for too long at a stretch, because this may exceed what the spirits and brain can bear. Once they are overstrained, if they do not break like a lute-string screwed too tight, they will be like a leg that is out of joint: it can cause pain but cannot bear weight.
While the soul rides on so lame or slow a horse as the body is, it must not go the pace it desires but only the pace the body can sustain, otherwise it may quickly be thrown, like a rider on an exhausted horse. It is not the horse that sets off with fierce heat and violent speed that will travel best; you must set a pace you are able to maintain. You little know how wretched and distressed a state you will be in, or how great an advantage the tempter gains, if once he tires you through overdoing.
Direction 15. Do not choose, unnecessarily or as a regular habit, the bitterest or most unpleasant subjects for meditation, lest you make it grow into a burden; but dwell most on the sweet and delightful thoughts of the infinite love of God revealed through Christ, the eternal glory purchased by him, and the wonderful helps and mercies along the way. As it is the Gospel which Christ’s ministers must preach to others, so it is the Gospel which in your meditations you must preach most to yourself. Love and pleasure are what you must chiefly labor to stir up, and you must do so by contemplating what is lovely and blessed, the proper objects of love and pleasure.
Thoughts of terror, wrath, and misery are not suited to stir up love and delight, though for the unconverted, dull, secure, presumptuous, or sensual sinner such thoughts are very necessary to awaken him and prepare him for the thoughts of love and peace. The principal part of this art is to keep off loathing and aversion, and to keep up readiness and delight.
Direction 16. When you are in company, share the fruit of your private meditations in holy, edifying conversation. Do not gather for yourself alone, but so that you may share with others. The "good scribe instructed to the kingdom of God" must "bring forth out of his treasure things new and old." What is good is what does good. God is communicative by nature, and the best people most resemble him.
Moreover, a fluent discourse is sometimes a great instructor even to ourselves, bringing things into our minds with a clarity that long meditation alone would not have produced. One thought leads in another; in a warm conversation the spirits are stirred, and the understanding and memory are engaged in close attention, so that in the very act of speaking we sometimes encounter a sudden appearance of some truth we had never noticed before, and find that no small addition to our knowledge comes in this way. Just as some find that vocal prayer stirs them more and keeps the mind from wandering better than silent mental prayer does, so free discourse is simply a vocal form of meditation. And whose thoughts are not more prone to disorder, wandering, and interruption than his speech?
Direction 17. Obey everything that God reveals to you in your meditations, and turn it all into faithful practice; do not make thinking the end of thinking. Otherwise you will do just as the ungodly and disobedient do in their prayers, those who offer to God the "sacrifice of fools, and consider not that they do evil" (Eccl 5:1–2). Away with the sin, and do the duty, upon which you have thought.
Direction 18. Do not suppose that the same measure of contemplation and striving with your own affections is required of everyone; an obedient, active life may be just as acceptable to God, when he calls people to it, as a more contemplative life. This leads me necessarily to give some directions about the difference between these two ways.
Title 4. The Difference between a Contemplative Life and an Obedient, Active Life, with Directions Concerning Them
This task is best performed by answering the questions that here require a solution.
Question 1: What is a contemplative life? And what is an active, obedient life?
Answer: Every active Christian is bound to some degree of contemplation, and all contemplative persons are bound to obedience to God and to as much action as their abilities and opportunities allow. Yet some are called much more to the one, and some to the other, and we name the life by what is most prominent and chief. We call it a contemplative life when a person’s condition and calling allows and requires him to make the exercises of his mind on sublime and holy things, and the stirring of his heart with them, his principal business, occupying most of his time.
We call it an active, obedient life when a person’s condition and calling requires him to spend the chief part of his time in some external labor or vocation tending to the good of himself and others. Craftsmen, tradesmen, farmers, laborers, physicians, lawyers, pastors and preachers of the Gospel, soldiers, and magistrates all live an active life, which should be a life of obedience to God, though among these, some have far more time for contemplation than others. There are also a few who are called to neither of these, but to a passive and obedient life: a life in which their obedient bearing of the cross, patient suffering, and submission to the chastening or testing will of God is the most prominent and principal service they can render him, above both contemplation and action.
Question 2: Must every person do his best to cast off all worldly and external labor and retire to a contemplative life as the most excellent?
Answer: No. No one should do so without a special necessity or calling. There are general commands upon all who are able: that we live to the benefit of others, prefer the common good, do good to all people as we have opportunity, love our neighbors as ourselves, and do as we would be done by, all of which calls us to much action. We are also required to labor before we eat. For a person to cast off unnecessarily all the service of his life in which he might be profitable to others is to bury or hide his master’s talents, to neglect charity, and to sin greatly against the law of love. As we have bodies, they must have their work, just as our souls do.
Question 3: Is a contemplative life then lawful for anyone, and for whom?
Answer: It is lawful, and even a duty, and a great mercy for some, to live almost wholly, or indeed entirely, in contemplation, prayer, and such holy exercises. This holds in the following cases:
1.) When age has disabled a person from being serviceable to others through an active life, and when he has already spent his days and strength doing all the good he could; being now disabled, he has special reason to use the remainder of his declining years in more than ordinary preparation for death and in holy communion with God.
2.) When we are disabled by sickness.
3.) When imprisonment restrains us from an active life or from benefiting others.
4.) When persecution forces Christians to retire into solitudes and remote places in order to preserve themselves for better times and places; or when sound judgment tells them that their prayers in solitude may do more good than their martyrdom at that time would be likely to do.
5.) When a student is preparing himself for the ministry or another active life, for which a contemplative life is the preparation.
6.) When poverty, war, or the fury of enemies disables a person from all public engagement and drives him into solitude by unavoidable necessity.
7.) When the number of those fit for action is already sufficient, and the person’s own gifts are so limited, and his usefulness in an active life consequently so small, that, all things considered, holy and impartial judgment tells him that the good he could do for others through an active life is unlikely to outweigh the loss to himself, together with the good his very example of a holy and heavenly life might do, along with the occasional counsel, instruction, and guidance he might offer to those who come to him for advice, drawn by the reputation of his holy life.
In this case, it is lawful to give oneself to a contemplative life, for whatever makes most for one’s own good and for the good of others is beyond doubt both lawful and a duty. "Anna departed not from the temple, but served God with fasting and prayer night and day" (Luke 2:36–37; see Dr. Hammond on this passage, and on 1 Timothy 5 and Titus 2). Whether the meaning is that she strictly kept the appointed hours of prayer in the temple and the fasting twice a week, or frequently, or whether she took up residence in the houses of some of the temple officers and devoted herself to its service, it is plain that either way she did something besides praying and fasting.
So too the widows under the Gospel, who were also to "continue in prayer and supplication night and day" (1 Tim 5:5) and yet were employed in the service of the church, overseeing the younger women and teaching them sobriety (Titus 2:4), which is an active life. But however Anna’s practice is interpreted, if what I have granted here would satisfy the monastics, we would not quarrel with them.
Question 4: How far are those living an active life to use contemplation?
Answer: With very great variation, according to five differences:
1.) According to the difference of their callings in the world and the offices in which they are ordinarily to serve God.
2.) According to the difference of their abilities and fitness for contemplation or for action.
3.) According to the difference of their particular opportunities.
4.) According to the difference of the necessities of others that may require their help.
5.) According to the difference of their own need for action or contemplation. I will determine these more particularly in certain rules.
1. Every Christian must use as much contemplation as is necessary for loving God above all things, for worshipping him in spirit and in truth, for maintaining a heavenly mind and manner of life, for due preparation for death and judgment, and for referring all his common works to the glory and pleasure of God, so that "Holiness to the Lord" may be written upon everything, and all that he has may be sanctified, or devoted together with himself to God.
2. The calling of a minister of the Gospel is so perfectly blended of contemplation and action, though action gives it its name, as being the end and chief purpose, that a minister must excel in both. Without excellence in contemplation, he will not be fit to stand so much nearer to God than the people do, to sanctify God when drawing near him, and to glorify him before all the people; nor will he be fit to open the heavenly mysteries and work upon the people’s hearts what has never been worked upon his own. And without excellence in an active life, he will betray the people’s souls, and will never sustain that painful diligence, preaching in season and out of season, publicly and from house to house, day and night with tears, which Paul commands of them in Acts 20 and in the Epistles to Timothy.
3. The work of a magistrate, a lawyer, a physician, and such like, lies chiefly in doing good within their several callings, and that work must not be neglected for contemplation. Yet all these, and all others, must give God’s service and holy thoughts their proper place at the beginning, middle, and end of all their actions. Magistrates must read and meditate day and night in the Word of God (Josh 1:8). So too the Eunuch and Cornelius (Acts 8 and 10), and others.
4. Some persons in the same calling, whose callings press less urgently upon them, whether by their own necessities or those of others, and who may therefore have more unoccupied time, should gladly use that time for the good of their souls through contemplation and other holy duties. Others who face greater necessities, urgencies, and obligations, or who cannot be spared from serving others (such as physicians, lawyers, and the like), must give less time to contemplation and prefer the greater good.
5. Public necessity or service may in some cases be so great as to set aside all private duty, both prayer and contemplation (except for short, unspoken prayers), for days at a time. In war, necessity often forbids any set or solemn holy service for many days together, even on the Lord’s Day. A physician may sometimes be so tied to close attendance on patients that no time remains for set prayer. A preacher may sometimes be so occupied with preaching, exhorting, and resolving people’s weighty doubts that he has scarcely any time for private duties for days together, though such happy hindrances are rare. In these cases, to perform the lesser duty while neglecting the greater is a sin.
6. Servants, who are not masters of their own time, must be faithful in using it for their master’s service, and must not take for holy duty any part of the time they are meant to be working. They should rather draw on their rest time, so far as they are able, and weave meditations into their labors when possible, redeeming the time that is allowed them all the more diligently, since their opportunities are so rare and brief.
7. The Lord’s Day (excepting works of necessity), and such other intervals as do not hinder other work, as when traveling, working, or lying awake at night, are every person’s own time. That time is not to be given over to another’s service, but reserved and used for the service of God and the good of the soul in holy duties.
8. Some persons cannot bear much contemplation, especially those who tend toward melancholy or have weak heads. Such people must serve God all the more through other duties they are capable of, and must not exhaust and distract themselves by striving to do what they cannot sustain. Others, however, feel no ill effect from it at all, as I can say from my own experience. My physical weakness and declining spirits incline me rather toward mental dullness, and I find that the most stimulating, serious studies and contemplations, in the greatest solitude, are so far from harming me, whether in health, cheerfulness, or serenity of mind, that they seem instead a help to all. Those who can bear long solitude and contemplation in this way ought to be the more exercised in it, except when greater duties must take precedence. But for those prone to melancholy it is to be avoided as harmful.
9. For the same persons, their own condition may at one time call most for contemplation and at another time for action; and so what is a duty at one time may be no duty at another.
10. A merely sinful backwardness is not to be indulged. A disability caused by disease, such as comes from melancholy, weakness of the head, or decay of memory, must be endured with patience and not too severely blamed, since Christ himself excused worse in his disciples, saying, "The spirit is willing, but the flesh is weak." But a sinful backwardness in cases of absolute necessity is not to be endured at all; it must be striven against with all your power, whatever it costs you. To bring yourself to so much serious consideration as is necessary for repentance, unfeigned faith, and a godly life, this must be done, whatever follows, even if the devil persuades you that it will make you melancholy or mad. For without it, you are in a far worse condition than madness.
11. The most desirable life, for those who have a choice, is one that joins contemplation and action together, affording convenient leisure for the highest and most serious contemplation, and using that contemplation to prepare one for the most weighty and profitable action. Such is the life of a faithful minister of Christ; and therefore no class of people on earth is more obligated to thankfulness than they.
12. Servants, poor people, sick people, and others who are called away from much contemplation and employed in a life of obedient action, or even of suffering, by the providence of God and not by their own sinful choice, these must understand that their labor and patience is the way of their acceptable attendance upon God in the use of most of their time.
It would be madness to hope that God will accept labor instead of true faith, repentance, and a godly life, for these must go together and do not hinder one another. But instead of such further contemplations as are not necessary to the existence of a godly life, a true Christian may believe that his obedient labors and sufferings will be accepted.
If you set one servant to cast up an account and another to sweep your chimney or gutters, you will not accept the former and reject the latter because of the difference of their work. You will rather think that the one who yielded without grudging to the most menial service has most deserved your approval. And it is surely an additional mark of acceptable obedience when we readily and willingly serve God in the lowest and most ordinary work.
The person is too refined to serve God who says, "I will serve you in the magistracy or ministry, but not at the plow or cart, or any such drudgery." And if you are simply in God’s way, he can make your very obedience a state of greater holiness and greater safety than if you had spent all that time in the study of holy things, as many ungodly ministers do throughout their lives, and are never the better for it. It is not the quality of the work, but God’s blessing, that makes it do you good.
Nor is he most beloved of God who has turned over the greatest number of good thoughts in his mind or the greatest number of good words on his lips, not even he who has stirred up the strongest emotions in these areas, but rather he who loves God and heaven best, hates sin most, and whose will is most firmly set toward holiness of life. A person who goes about his labor in obedience to God may have as much comfort as another who is meditating or praying. But neither labor nor prayer is a source of comfort to an ungodly, carnal heart.
Petrarch, speaking of his intimacy and esteem with kings and princes, adds: "Yet I fled from many of those whom I loved greatly, so deeply was the love of liberty implanted in me; anyone whose very name seemed contrary to liberty, or opposed to it, I shunned with all diligence." So he writes in his own Life.
Indeed, if decay of memory or natural ability takes you off from both action and contemplation, you may have as much acceptance and solid comfort in a patient bearing of the cross, and an obedient, cheerful submission to the holy will of God.
CHAPTER 9
DIRECTIONS TO THE MELANCHOLY ABOUT THEIR THOUGHTS
It is a common and easy thing for some weak-minded persons to plunge themselves into melancholy by overstretching their thoughts and feelings. The condition of such people is so deeply pitiable that I think it necessary to give them particular directions of their own. I do this the more readily because I see some persons who are unacquainted with the nature of melancholy and other diseases grievously abusing the name of God, and bringing the profession of religion into contempt, by attributing all the effects and utterances of such melancholy persons to some great and notable operations of the Spirit of God, and then drawing conclusions about God’s methods of working on the soul and about the nature of the legal workings of the spirit of bondage. (Similarly, others have published accounts of the prophecies, possessions, and dispossessions of hysterical women, as I have read especially in the writings of the Friars.)
I do not call those persons melancholy who are rationally sorrowful for sin, keenly aware of their misery, and earnestly concerned about their recovery and salvation, even with as great a seriousness as their faculties can bear, as long as their reason is sound and the imagination, fantasy, or thinking faculty is not disordered or diseased. By melancholy I mean this diseased disorder, injury, or error of the imagination, and consequently of the understanding. It may be recognized by the following signs, though not all of them are present in every melancholy person.
1. They are commonly excessively fearful, without cause, or far beyond what cause there is. Everything they hear or see tends to increase their fears, especially when fear was the original cause, as it ordinarily is.
2. Their imagination errs most in magnifying their sin, or their dangers, or their unhappiness. Every ordinary weakness they are ready to speak of with alarm, as a heinous sin; every possible danger they take for probable, and every probable one for certain; every little danger for a great one, and every calamity for utter ruin. Diogenes Laertius reports in his life of Zeno that the Stoics held that a wise man never loses soundness of mind, yet may sometimes fall into absurd imaginings through an excess of black bile, or through a derangement that comes not from any deviation of reason but from a weakness of nature. There is more on this below, in Part 3, against Despair.
3. They are perpetually given to excessive sadness, some weeping without knowing why, and some believing it ought to be so. If they were to smile or speak cheerfully, their conscience would reproach them as if they had done wrong.
4. They place most of their religion in sorrowing and bodily austerities.
5. They are continual self-accusers, turning everything they hear, read, see, or think into a charge against themselves, quarreling with themselves over everything they do, as a contentious person quarrels with others.
6. They are constantly convinced that God has forsaken them, and they are prone to despair. They are like a person lost in a wilderness, abandoned by all friends and comforts, forlorn and desolate. Their constant thought is, "I am undone, undone, undone!"
7. They are always convinced that the day of grace is past and that it is now too late to repent or find mercy. Tell them of the terms of the Gospel and its offer of free pardon to every penitent believer, and they cry out, "Too late, too late, my day is past!", not considering that every soul who truly repents in this life is certainly forgiven.
8. They are often tempted to draw despairing conclusions from the doctrine of predestination. They think that if God has reprobated them or has not elected them, nothing they or anyone else can do will save them. They then strongly convince themselves that they are not elected, and therefore that they are beyond help or hope, not knowing that God elects no one simply and separately to be saved, but conjointly to believe, repent, and be saved, and so to both the end and the means together. All who will repent and choose Christ and a holy life are elected to salvation, because they are elected to the means and condition of salvation, which they shall enjoy if they persevere. To repent is the best way to prove that I am elected to repent.
9. They never hear or read of any miserable example without thinking it describes their own case. If they hear of Cain, or of Pharaoh given over to hardness of heart, or merely read that some are vessels of wrath fitted for destruction, or that some have eyes and see not, ears and hear not, hearts and understand not, they think: "All this is said of me" or "This is exactly my case." If they hear of any terrible judgment of God upon someone, they think the same will happen to them. If someone dies suddenly, or a house burns down, or someone loses their mind, or dies in despair, they think it will be so with them. Reading Spira’s case causes or increases melancholy in many, for the ignorant author described a plain melancholy, brought on by the distress of sinning against conscience, as if it were the damnable despair of a sound understanding.
10. And yet they think that no one has ever been in their condition. I have had a great number of people with me within the span of a few weeks who were almost exactly in the same case, and yet every one of them said that no one had ever been as they were.
11. They are utterly unable to rejoice in anything. They cannot grasp, believe, or dwell on anything comforting. They read all the threatenings of the Word with sharp feeling and ready application, but they read the promises over and over without taking notice of them, as if they had not read them, or else they say, "These do not belong to me. The greater the mercy of God and the riches of grace, the more miserable am I who have no share in them." They are like a person in constant pain or sickness who cannot rejoice because the feeling of the pain forbids it. They look at husband, wife, friends, children, house, and goods with no comfort, as one would who is about to be executed for a crime.
12. Their consciences are quick to accuse them of sin and to press any form of dejection as a duty, but they are dead to all duties that tend toward consolation, such as thanksgiving for mercies, the praise of God, meditating on his love and grace and Christ and his promises. Press them as hard as you will on these things, and they feel no duty in them, nor make any conscience of them, but think such duties are for others and unsuitable for themselves.
13. They always say that they cannot believe, and therefore think they cannot be saved. This is mostly because they mistake the nature of faith, taking it to be a belief that they themselves are forgiven, in favor with God, and will be saved. Because they cannot believe this, and their disease will not allow them to believe it, they conclude they are not believers at all. But saving faith is nothing more than such a belief that the Gospel is true and that Christ is the Savior to be trusted with our souls, as causes the will to consent that he be ours and we be his, and so to subscribe to the covenant of grace. Yet even while they so consent, even while they would give the world to be sure that Christ is theirs and to be perfectly holy, they still think they do not believe, because they cannot believe that he will forgive or save them.
14. They are perpetually displeased and discontented with themselves, just as a fretful, contrary person is apt to be with others. Picture someone who is hard to please, who finds fault with everything he sees or hears, who is offended by everyone who crosses his path, and who suspects everyone he sees whispering, and just so is a melancholy person toward himself: suspicious, displeased, and finding fault with everything.
15. They are greatly drawn to solitude and are mostly weary of company.
16. They are given over to fixed brooding and long, purposeless rumination. Deep musing and thinking are their chief occupation and much of their disease.
17. They are much averse to the labors of their callings, and given to idleness, either lying in bed or sitting alone in unprofitable thought.
18. Their thoughts are mostly turned inward on themselves, like millstones grinding on themselves when there is no grain. One thought breeds another. Their thoughts are occupied with their own thoughts: having been thinking in a disordered way, they then think about what they have been thinking on. They do not much meditate on God (except on his wrath), nor on heaven, nor on Christ, nor on the state of the church, nor on anything outside themselves. All their thoughts are contracted and turned inward. Self-tormenting is the sum of their thoughts and their lives.
19. Their thoughts are all tangled together like knotted yarn or silk, or like a person in a maze or a wilderness who has lost his way in the dark. He is groping about and can make little of anything, but grows more and more bewildered and entangled, full of doubts and difficulties from which he cannot find his way out.
20. He is endless in his scruples, afraid of sinning in every word he speaks, every thought he thinks, every glance, every meal he eats, every piece of clothing he wears. If he tries to correct these things, he at once begins to have scruples about the corrections themselves. He dares neither travel nor stay at home, neither speak nor be silent, but has scruples about everything, as if he were made entirely of self-tormenting doubts.
21. From this it follows that he is greatly addicted to superstition, making many laws for himself that God never made, ensnaring himself with needless vows and resolutions and harmful austerities: touch not, taste not, handle not. He places much of his religion in such outward, self-imposed duties: spending so many hours in this or that act of devotion, wearing only certain clothes and refusing finer ones, giving up all food that pleases the appetite, and much of the like. A great deal of the perfection of Popish devotion proceeded from melancholy, though their government came from pride and covetousness.
22. They have lost the power to govern their thoughts by reason. If you convince them that they should cast out their self-tormenting and unprofitable thoughts and turn their minds to other subjects, or simply rest their minds, they are not able to do it. They seem to be under a kind of compulsion. They cannot drive out their troublesome thoughts; they cannot redirect their minds; they cannot think of love and mercy; they can think of nothing but what they are already thinking, no more than a person with a toothache can stop thinking of the pain.
23. They usually develop from this point an inability to engage in any private prayer or meditation. Their thoughts are thrown at once into confusion when they try to pray or meditate, scattering in a hundred directions with no ability to stay fixed on anything, for this is the very heart of their disease: a disordered, confused imagination, with a weakened reason unable to govern it. At times terror drives them from prayer altogether: they dare not hope, and therefore dare not pray. They usually dare not receive the Lord’s Supper, which is where their fear is greatest of all; and if they do receive it, they are cast down with terror, fearing they have brought damnation on themselves by receiving unworthily.
24. From this they grow into a deep aversion to all holy duty. Fear and despair make them go to prayer, hearing, and reading as a bear goes to the stake. They then conclude they are haters of God and godliness, imputing the effects of their disease to their souls, when at the same time, those among them who are truly godly would rather be freed from all their sins and made perfectly holy than possess all the riches and honor in the world.
25. They are usually so consumed with busy and earnest thoughts, which, being all tangled together, only struggle against each other and contradict one another, that they feel exactly as if something is speaking within them, and as if all their own violent thoughts were the promptings and impulses of some other being. They therefore tend to attribute all their fantasies either to some extraordinary working of the devil or to some extraordinary movement of the Spirit of God. They commonly express themselves in words like these: "It was laid upon my heart, or it was said to me, that I must do this or that: and then it was said I must not do this or that: and I was told I must act in such and such a way." They think that their own imagination is something speaking within them and saying to them everything they are thinking.
26. When melancholy grows strong, they are almost constantly troubled with hideous, blasphemous temptations against God, or Christ, or the Scripture, and against the immortality of the soul. This comes partly from their own fears, which cause them to think most, against their will, of exactly what they are most afraid of thinking, just as the vital spirits and blood tend toward the part that is injured. The very pain of their fears draws their thoughts toward what they fear. Just as a person who is too eager to sleep and afraid of lying awake is sure to remain awake, because his fears and desires keep him so, so the fears and desires of melancholy persons work against themselves.
Beyond this, the malice of the devil plainly intervenes and takes advantage of this disease to tempt and torment them, displaying his hatred of God, Christ, Scripture, and of the persons themselves. Just as he can far more easily tempt a choleric person to anger, a phlegmatic and fleshly person to sloth, and a sanguine or hot-tempered person to lust and wantonness, so also he tempts a melancholy person to thoughts of blasphemy, unbelief, and despair.
They often feel a violent urgency, as if something within them were pressing them to speak some blasphemous or senseless word, and they can have no rest unless they yield, in this case and others like it, to what they are urged toward. Some are driven to yield in order to be quiet; and when they have done so, they are then tempted to utter despair because they have committed so great a sin. And when the devil has gained this advantage over them, he keeps setting it before them.
27. From this they are further tempted to think they have committed the sin against the Holy Ghost, not understanding what that sin actually is, but fearing it is theirs because it is a fearful sin. At the very least they believe they will not be forgiven, not considering that a temptation is one thing and a sin another, and that no one has less cause to fear condemnation for sin than the person who is least willing to commit it and most hates it. And no one can be less willing of any sin than these poor souls are of the hideous, blasphemous thoughts they complain of.
28. From this, some of them go on to believe they are possessed by devils. If it enters their imagination how possessed persons were accustomed to act, the sheer force of imagination will make them imitate it, so that I have known persons who would swear, curse, and blaspheme, and mimic an alien inner voice, themselves believing that it was the devil within them doing all of this. But those who go this far are only a few.
29. Some of them, when they are near madness, genuinely believe they hear voices, see lights and apparitions, that the curtains are drawn back around them, or that something approaches them and speaks to them, when all of this is nothing but the error of a disordered brain and a sick imagination.
30. Many of them grow weary of their lives through the unrelenting, agonizing perplexities of their minds, and yet are afraid of dying. Some resolutely starve themselves. Some are strongly tempted to murder themselves, and they are haunted by the temptation so relentlessly that wherever they go, they feel as if something within them were urging them on and saying, "Do it, do it", so that many poor souls yield and take their own lives.
31. Many of them are restlessly tormented by fears of poverty and need, of misery coming upon their families, of imprisonment or banishment, and of being murdered. Every person they see whispering they imagine is plotting to take their life.
32. Some of them lay a law upon themselves that they will not speak, and so live for long periods in determined silence.
33. All of them are inflexible and stubborn in their own convictions, and are scarcely persuaded out of them, however irrational those convictions may be.
34. Few of them are helped in any lasting way by reason, argument, or counsel. If it seems to satisfy, quiet, and cheer them for the moment, the next day they are just as bad again, it being the nature of their disease to think as they do think, and their thoughts are not cured while the disease itself remains uncured.
35. Yet throughout all this disorder, few of them will believe they are melancholy. They cannot bear to be told so, insisting that it is only the rational sense of their unhappiness and the forsaking and heavy wrath of God. They are therefore scarcely persuaded to take any medicine or to use any means for the cure of their bodies, saying they are well in body and being firmly convinced that it is only their souls that are in distress.
This is the miserable condition of these poor people, and it is greatly to be pitied, not despised by anyone. I have said nothing here that I have not often seen and known. Let no one look down on such people, for people of every kind fall into this misery: learned and unlearned, high and low, good and bad, yes, even some who have lived in the greatest jollity and sensuality, when God has made them feel their folly.
The causes of it are as follows.
1. Most commonly, some worldly loss, hardship, grief, or anxiety that made too deep an impression on them.
2. Sometimes, extreme fear arising from some common occasion of danger.
3. Sometimes, excessive and unrelenting study or thought that strains and overtaxes the imagination.
4. Sometimes, excessive fears, or constant, intense, and consuming thoughts and anxieties about the danger of the soul.
5. The chief predisposing factors, which are in truth the principal cause, are a weak mind and reason joined with strong passion. These are found most often in women and in those for whom such a constitution is natural.
6. In some cases, the condition is brought on by some heinous sin, the sight of which they cannot bear once conscience is awakened.
When this disease has advanced very far, directions given to the persons themselves are of no use, because they no longer have the reason and freedom of will to follow them. In such cases it is their friends and attendants who must receive the directions. But because in most cases, and especially at the outset, some power of reason remains, I give the following directions for the use of those who can still benefit from them.
Direction 1. See that no error in religion is the cause of your distress: especially, understand the covenant of grace and the riches of mercy revealed in Christ. Among other things, it will help you to understand the following truths.
1.) That our thoughts about the infinite goodness of God should bear proportion with our thoughts about his infinite power and wisdom.
2.) That the mercy of God has provided for all mankind so sufficient a Savior that no sinner will perish for lack of a sufficient satisfaction made for his sins by Christ, nor is it made the condition of any person’s salvation or pardon that he satisfy for his own sins.
3.) That Christ has in his Gospel Covenant, which is an act of oblivion, made over himself, with pardon and salvation, to all who will penitently and believingly accept the offer. And that none who hear the Gospel perish except those who finally and obstinately refuse Christ and life.
4.) That whoever so far believes the truth of the Gospel as to consent to the covenant of grace, accepting God the Father as his Lord and reconciled Father, Christ as his Savior, and the Holy Ghost as his Sanctifier, has true, saving faith and a right to the blessings of that covenant.
5.) That the day of grace extends so far across a person’s lifetime that whoever truly repents and consents to the covenant of grace before death is certainly pardoned and in a state of life; and that it is every person’s duty to do so, that pardon may be theirs.
6.) That Satan’s temptations are not our sins, only our yielding to them is.
7.) That the effects of natural sickness or bodily disease are not, in themselves, sins.
8.) That those sins are, in their own nature, the least serious and the least likely to condemn us, which we are most unwilling to commit and have no love or liking for.
9.) That no sin will condemn us which we hate more than love, and which we would rather leave and be delivered from than keep: for this is true repentance.
10.) That a person is truly sanctified who would rather be perfect in holiness of heart and life, in loving God and living by faith, than to have the greatest pleasures, riches, or honors of the world, taking into account also the means by which both are attained.
11.) That whoever has this grace and desire may know that he is elect; and that making our calling sure by consenting to the holy covenant is the same as making our election sure.
12.) That what is a weighty duty for others may be no duty at all for someone who is made unable by bodily disorder, such as fever, frenzy, or melancholy, to perform it.
Direction 2. Guard against worldly cares, sorrows, and discontents. Do not set so much store by earthly things that they are able to unsettle you, but learn to cast your cares on God. There is less peace to be had in an affliction that comes upon you by such carnal and sinful means. It is far safer to be troubled with cares for heaven than for earth.
Direction 3. Meditation is no duty at all for a melancholy person, except for a few who are able to bear a diverting meditation, which must concern something as far removed as possible from whatever is troubling them, or except for brief meditations no longer than a short, darting prayer. Set and serious meditation will only confuse you, disturb you, and make you less able to perform your other duties. If a man has a broken leg, he must not walk on it until it has healed, lest the whole body suffer. Your thinking faculty, or your imagination, is the broken and pained part; you must therefore not exercise it upon the things that trouble you.
Perhaps you will say that this is to be profane, to forget God and your soul, and to let the tempter have his way. My answer is no. It is only to refrain from what you cannot do at present, so that by doing other things that you can do, you may in time return to doing this. It is only to stop attempting what will only make you less capable of every other duty. For the present you may conduct the affairs of your soul by holy reason. I am not urging you away from repenting or believing, but from set, prolonged, and deep meditations, which will only harm you.
Direction 4. Do not spend too long in any private duty that you find you are unable to bear. Prayer itself, when you are unable, must be performed only as you can. Short confessions and brief requests to God must serve in place of longer private prayers when you cannot do more. If bodily sickness may excuse a person for being brief when nature cannot sustain more, the same is true here, in the sickness of the brain and spirits. God has appointed no means to do you harm.
Direction 5. Where you find yourself unable to perform a private duty, do not struggle too violently against yourself; instead, go at the pace you are able to go quietly. Straining beyond your strength does not enable you, it vexes you, makes duty burdensome, and increases your disease, leaving you more disabled than before. It is like an ox that pulls uneasily, or a horse that frets until it quickly tires. Preserve your willingness for duty, and avoid whatever makes it painful to you. Just as for a sick stomach it is not eating much but digesting well that promotes health, and little must be eaten when much cannot be digested, so it is here with your meditations and private prayers.
Direction 6. Give most attention to those duties you are best able to bear, for most people this will be prayer, and for others, hearing the Word or godly conversation. As a sick person whose stomach rejects other foods must eat what he is able to eat, so also God has provided a variety of means, so that one may do the work when another cannot. Do not misunderstand me. In cases of absolute necessity, I say again, you must strive to do what is required whatever the cost. If you are reluctant to believe, to repent, to love God and your neighbor, to live soberly, righteously, and godly, or to pray at all, here you must press forward and not excuse yourself by any reluctance, for these things must be done, or you are lost.
But a person who cannot read may be saved without reading; a person in prison or sick may be saved without hearing the Word and without the church communion of saints; and so a person disabled by melancholy may be saved through shorter thoughts and short, darting prayers, without set and lengthy meditations and private prayers, and the other duties he is capable of will supply the lack of these. Just as nature has provided two eyes, two ears, two nostrils, two kidneys, and two lungs, so that when one is obstructed or fails the other may supply its lack for a time, so it is here.
Direction 7. Avoid all unnecessary solitude, and be as much as possible in honest, cheerful company. You need others and are not sufficient for yourselves; and God will use and honor others as his hands to deliver his blessings to us. For those who are fit for it, solitude is an excellent season for meditation and for communion with God and with one’s own heart. But for you it is a season of temptation and danger. If Satan tempted Christ himself when he had him fasting and alone in a wilderness, how much more will he seize this as his opportunity against you. Solitude is the season for brooding and anxious thought, and these are precisely what you must flee, if you are not to be deprived of everything.
Direction 8. When blasphemous or disturbing thoughts intrude, or fruitless musings begin, meet them at once and use the authority of reason that remains to you, casting them out and commanding them to leave. If you have not lost it, reason and will have command over thoughts just as they do over the tongue, or the hands, or the feet. You would be ashamed to run wildly about or to strike out with your hands and say, "I cannot help it," or to let your tongue run all day and say, "I cannot stop it." In the same way, you should be ashamed to let your thoughts wander at random or dwell on harmful things and say, "I cannot help it."
Are you doing the best you can to help it? Can you not bid those thoughts be gone? Can you not turn your mind to something else? Can you not rouse yourself and shake them off? Some people, by splashing a little cold water on their faces, or asking someone else to do it, can rouse themselves from melancholy musings as if from sleep. Or can you not leave the room and set yourself to some work that will divert you? You could do more than you do, if you were willing, and if you understood how much this is your duty.
Direction 9. When you do think of holy things, fix your mind on the best of them, on God, and grace, and Christ, and heaven; or on your brethren, or the church. Carry all your meditation outward; and be sure you do not brood over yourselves, spending your thoughts upon your own thoughts. Just as we need to call the thoughts of careless sinners inward, turning them from the creature and from sin back upon themselves, so we need to call the thoughts of self-tormenting, melancholy persons outward, for their very disease is this constant grinding upon themselves.
Remember that it is a far higher, nobler, and sweeter work to think of God, and Christ, and heaven, than to think of such worms as we ourselves are. When we rise up to God, we rise to love, and light, and liberty; but when we look down into ourselves, we look into a dungeon, a prison, a wilderness, a place of darkness, horror, filthiness, misery, and confusion. Therefore, though such inward thoughts are necessary so far as repentance and proper watchfulness cannot be maintained without them, they are grievous, ignoble, and barren compared with our thoughts of God.
When you are brooding over your own heart to discover whether the love of God is there, it would be wiser to be thinking of God’s infinite loveliness, for that will cause the love, whether it was there before or not. So instead of searching your heart to know whether it is set on heaven, lift your thoughts to heaven and dwell on its glory; that will draw your heart there and give you, and show you, the very thing you were searching for. The time you spend digging and troubling yourself to find out whether such desires are already there would be far better spent planting holy desires in the garden of your heart.
We are such dark and confused creatures that the sight of ourselves is enough to raise loathing and horror in our minds and make them melancholy. But in God and glory there is nothing to discourage our thoughts, only everything to delight them, if Satan does not misrepresent him to us.
Direction 10. Do not overlook the miracle of love that God has shown us in the wonderful incarnation, office, life, death, resurrection, ascension, and reign of our Redeemer; but steep your thoughts most in these wonders of mercy, which God has set before us as the chief matter of our meditation. It only stands to reason that you should devote many thoughts to Christ and grace for every one you devote to your sin and misery. God requires you to see your sin and misery, but only so far as that sight magnifies the remedy and moves you to accept it. Never think of sin and hell alone, but always as the path leading to thoughts of Christ and grace.
This is the duty even of the worst among us. Are your sins ever before you? Why is pardoning grace in Christ not before you also? Is hell open before you? Why is the Redeemer not before you as well? Do you say it is because sin and hell are yours, but Christ and holiness and heaven are not yours? Then I answer: it is so only because you will have it so. If you would not have it so, it need not be so. God has set life before you first, and not death alone. He has placed Christ, and holiness, and heaven in his end of the balance; and the devil places the pleasures of sin for a season in the other end.
What you genuinely and unreservedly choose is yours, for God has given you the choice. Nothing is more certain than this: God has so far made over Christ and life to all who hear the Gospel that nothing but a final and obstinate refusal can condemn them. Christ and life are brought to the will and choice of all, though not all have the will to accept and choose him. And if you would not have Christ, and life, and holiness, what would you rather have? And why do you complain?
Direction 11. Think and speak as much of the mercy you have received as of the sin you have committed; and as much of the mercy that is offered you as of what you still lack. You would not dare say that the mercy you have received is no more worthy to be remembered and spoken of than all your sins. Shall God do so much for you and yet be overlooked, minimized, and made nothing of, as if his mercies were a bare bone or a barren wilderness, yielding no nourishment for your thoughts? Do not be guilty of so great an ingratitude. Thoughts of love and mercy breed love and sweetness in the soul, while thoughts of sin and wrath breed only aversion, terror, bitterness, and perplexity, and drive the heart away from God.
Direction 12. Commit yourself daily to spending as great a portion of your prayer time in confessing mercy received as in confessing sin committed, and in praising God as in lamenting your own miseries. You cannot deny that this is your duty, if you understand your duty: thanksgiving and praise are greater duties than confessing sin and misery. Resolve, then, that they shall have the larger share of your time.
If you will do this much, which you can do if you will, it will in time take away the bitterness of spirit you now carry. The frequent mention of sweeter things will sweeten your mind and alter its disposition and habit, just as a change of diet alters the constitution of the body. I urge you to resolve on this and try it. If you cannot mention mercy as thankfully as you would, or speak of God’s excellencies as reverently and with as much praise as you would, yet do what you can and mention them as best you are able. You can govern your time, deciding what shall have the greatest share in prayer, even if you cannot govern your affections. You will find the benefit very great if you will do even this much.
Direction 13. Do not overvalue the emotional part of duty; understand that judgment, will, and practice, a high esteem of God and holiness, a resolved choice, and a sincere endeavor, are the life of grace and duty, while passionate feelings are lower and uncertain things. You do not know what you are doing when you lay so much weight on the emotional part of religion, or when you strive so hard for deep and transporting experiences. These are not the great things, nor the essentials of holiness. Too much of this feeling may unhinge you. God knows how much you are able to bear.
Passionate feelings depend greatly on natural temperament. Some persons are more sensitive than others; a small thing cuts deep with some. The wisest and most substantial persons are usually the least passionate, while the weakest can scarcely moderate their passions at all. God is not an object of the senses, and is therefore more fittingly apprehended by the understanding and will than by the passions. The holiest soul is not the one most deeply affected with grief, fear, joy, and other transporting passions, but the one most inclined toward God, most resolved for him, and most conformed to his will, though it would be best if even holy passions could be raised at the will’s command, in whatever measure best fits us for duty.
I have known many who complained of lacking deeper feeling, when in fact, had their feeling, as they called their passion, been greater, it might have undone them. I would rather be the Christian who loathes himself for sin, resolves against it, and forsakes it, though he cannot weep for it, than one who can weep today and sin again tomorrow, whose sinful passions are stirred as quickly as his better ones.
Direction 14. Do not make too great a matter of your own thoughts; and do not pay them too much attention. If Satan casts troubling thoughts into your mind and you cannot drive them out, set little store by them and take as little notice of them as possible.
Making a great matter of every thought that enters your mind will only keep those thoughts there longer. What we are most sensitive to, we think about most; what we regard least, we remember least. If you want never to be rid of such thoughts, the surest way is to keep noting them and magnifying their importance. These troublesome thoughts are like a nagging quarreler: if you pay attention to them and answer them, they will never leave you alone; but if you let them talk and take no notice of them, they will grow weary and give up. The devil’s design is to vex and disquiet you. If he sees that you will not be vexed and disquieted, he will give up trying.
No doubt you will say, "Should I be so ungodly as to make light of such sinful thoughts?" I answer: do not make so light of them as to be indifferent about what thoughts occupy your mind, nor so as to treat the smallest sin as no sin at all. But do make light of them in this sense, do not treat them as greater or more dangerous sins than they actually are, and do not fix particular, distinct attention on them or disquiet yourself about them. If you do, you will have no room in your thoughts for Christ, for heaven, and for those things that ought to fill your mind. The devil will rejoice to see you spending all your time thinking over your own thoughts, or rather, his temptations, and that he can keep you busy all day listening to whatever he says, meditating on his suggestions instead of on the works of God.
None of God’s servants are without irregularities and sins of thought, which they must daily seek forgiveness for and then rejoice to remember that they have a sufficient Savior and remedy, and that sin shall only occasion the magnifying of grace. But if they were to observe every unworthy thought with excessive anxiety, it would become a snare that pulled them away from almost all their more important duties. Would you be pleased with a servant who stopped to fuss and trouble himself over every ordinary imperfection in his work, instead of pressing on and getting it done?
Direction 15. Remember that it is no sin to be tempted, but only to yield to the temptation; and that Christ himself was carried about and tempted blasphemously by the devil, even to fall down and worship him, and yet he turned those temptations into an occasion for the glory of his victory.
Do not take the devil’s sin for your own. Are your temptations more horrid and odious than Christ’s were? What if the devil had carried you to the pinnacle of the temple, as he did Christ? Would you not have thought that God had forsaken you and given you over to Satan’s power?
But you will say that you yield to the temptation, and Christ did not. I answer: can it be expected that sinful humanity should bear a temptation as innocently as Christ did? Satan found nothing in Christ to work with; but in us he finds a sinful nature. Wax receives an impression where marble will not. Yet it is not every sinful taint that amounts to a consent to the sin toward which we are tempted.
Direction 16. Consider how far you are from loving, delighting in, or being reluctant to leave these sinful thoughts; and remember that no sin condemns unless it is so loved and delighted in that you would rather keep it than be rid of it.
Would you not eagerly be delivered from all these horrid thoughts and sins? Could you not willingly live in disgrace, poverty, or banishment, if only you might be free from sin? If so, why do you doubt your pardon? Can you have any surer sign of repentance, or that your sin is not a reigning, unpardoned sin, than that it is not loved and desired by you? The less the will, the less the sin; the more the will, the more the sin. The covetous man loves his money; the fornicator loves his lust; the proud man loves his honor; the drunkard loves his drink; the glutton loves to satisfy his appetite, and they love these things so much that they will not leave them. But do you love your disturbing, confused, or blasphemous thoughts? Are you not so weary of them as to be weary of life itself because of them? Would you not be glad and thankful never to be troubled with them again? And yet you doubt your pardon?
Direction 17. Do not blame your soul for the effects of your disease any more deeply than there is real cause.
It is true that in a remote sense, a person who in a state of mental disturbance thinks or speaks amiss may be said to be at fault, insofar as his own prior sin contributed to his disease. But directly and in itself, the involuntary effects of sickness are not sin. Melancholy is a disease of the spirits and the imagination, even when you feel no bodily sickness; and it is as natural for a melancholy person to be driven and tormented by doubts, fears, despairing thoughts, and blasphemous temptations, as it is for a feverish man to talk incoherently when his understanding fails, or to crave drink when his fever inflames a violent thirst. How much would you hold a man in a fever responsible for such a thirst, or for such thoughts and cravings? If you had in your dreams the hideous thoughts that visit you when you are awake, would you account them unpardonable sins, or rather unavoidable infirmities? Your disease makes them, for you, very nearly what dreams are.
Direction 18. Be sure to keep yourself constantly occupied, as far as your strength allows, in the diligent labors of a lawful calling, and waste none of your precious time in idleness.
Idleness is the tide that floats the tempter in. When you are idle, you invite the devil to come and vex you. You then have nothing but time to listen to him and to turn over in your mind everything he puts there, and then to go over all those thoughts again. When you have nothing else to do, the devil will find you such work. You must sit still and brood; your thoughts will stir in the mud of your own disorders, as children splash in the dirt.
And idleness is itself a sin that God will not favor. He has commanded you to "labour six days, and in the sweat of your brows to eat your bread; and he that will not labour is unworthy to eat." Remember that time is precious and passes swiftly, and that God has given you none of it in vain. So, just as you are troubled for other sins, let your conscience feel the weight of this sin also, and do not waste a quarter of an hour in idle, unprofitable musing. It is a just judgment from God when he makes your sin your punishment, and your own idle thoughts become your daily torment because you will not rouse yourself and attend to your lawful business.
Nor will pleas of prayer or other devotion excuse your idleness, for idleness is against the law of God. Above all the directions I have given you, I urge you most earnestly to obey this one. I have known despairing, melancholy persons cured by setting themselves resolutely and diligently to their callings, and by changing their air and company, and taking rides abroad. If you will sit brooding in a corner, sinning against God by idleness and loss of time and adding to your own miseries, rather than rouse yourself and attend to your business, your calamity is deserved. Do not say you have little or nothing to do: God has made it the duty of all people, however wealthy, to labor in such employment as suits their station and strength.
Direction 19. Simply observe how much the devil gains by keeping you in sad, despondent thoughts, and you will easily see that what is so profitable and pleasing to the devil cannot be your duty, nor what is best for you.
By keeping you in these self-tormenting doubts and fears, Satan robs God of the thanks and praise you owe him for all his mercies. You cast aside those highest duties as though they did not belong to you. You give God no honor for his most miraculous mercy in our redemption; you do not study, relish, wonder at, or magnify the riches of grace in Jesus Christ. You hold poor, low thoughts of the infinite love of God and are unfit to perceive or judge it rightly, like a choleric stomach, which puts continual bitterness in the mouth and prevents any sweetness being tasted in food.
This despondency also unfits you for the love of God and inclines you rather to hate him or flee from him as an enemy, while the devil represents him to you as one who hates you. It wastes your time. It strips away all your willingness to perform duty and all delight in duty, and makes all God’s service a burden and a vexation. It runs directly contrary to the spirit of adoption and to the whole nature of evangelical worship and obedience. And will you, under the pretense of being more humbled, sorrowful, and sensitive, thus gratify Satan and wrong both God and yourselves?
Direction 20. Do not trust your own judgment in your melancholy condition, whether about the state of your soul or about the right choice and ordering of your thoughts and conduct, but commit yourself to the judgment and direction of some experienced, faithful guide. You are no fit judge of your own condition, nor of your duty, in so dark and disordered a state. Consider your own mind: either it is functioning rightly or it is not. If it is functioning rightly, why do you complain of all those disturbances, confusions, and inability to meditate and pray? If it is not functioning rightly, why are you so self-assured as to think yourself capable of judging your own case with so disordered a mind?
One of the worst features of melancholy is that those afflicted by it are typically most confident in their own opinions and most rigid in their own conclusions precisely when their minds are sickest and their understanding weakest. They are headstrong, unruly, and impossible to persuade, as if they were proud of those poor understandings, and believed that no one else could know their case as well as they do.
They say: "You do not know my case." But consider, am I not more likely to understand your case, having seen scores of people in exactly that condition, than you are, who have never known anyone in it but yourself? A bystander may understand the situation of a man who is dreaming better than the dreamer can know his own. You say others do not feel what you feel. True; nor does the physician feel what a man in a fever, or a fit, or a mental breakdown feels. Yet from what you report, and from what he observes, he understands your disease, its nature and its cure, far better than you who are suffering it.
Therefore, as a wise man who falls ill will entrust himself, under God, to his physician’s direction and his friends’ help, rather than arguing against their counsel or stubbornly refusing it because their advice runs contrary to his own feelings, so, if you are wise, you will entrust yourself to a fit spiritual director. Do not dismiss his judgment either about your condition or about your duty.
You believe you are lost and beyond hope. Listen instead to one who is now better placed to judge. Do not set your weakened mind too willfully against him. Do you think he is so foolish as to be mistaken? Should not humility lead you rather to think that of yourself? Accept his guidance about what to think on, about the manner and length of your private devotions, and about all the difficulties on which you need counsel.
Let me ask you one question: do you know anyone wiser than yourself, and better fitted to judge your condition and advise you? If you say no, how proud you are of so impaired a mind! If you say yes, then believe that person, trust him, and resolve to follow his direction. And I would ask further: did you once hold a different opinion of yourself? If so, were you not at that time in a sounder state and better able to judge, and therefore more likely to have been right than you are now?
Direction 21. My last counsel is this: seek the cure of your disease, commit yourself to the care of a physician, and obey him. Do not do as most melancholy persons do, refusing to believe that medicine can help them on the grounds that it is their soul alone that is afflicted. The trouble lies in the spirits, imagination, and passions, which are diseased, and the soul is then like an eye looking through colored glass, believing that everything has the color of the glass. I have seen many people cured by medicine. Until the body is healed, the mind will scarcely ever be healed either, and the clearest reasoning will be entirely in vain.
CHAPTER 10
DIRECTIONS FOR YOUNG STUDENTS ON THE MOST PROFITABLE ORDERING OF THEIR STUDIES
Direction 1. Let your first and most serious study be to make sure that you are regenerate and sanctified by the Holy Ghost, justified by faith in Christ, that you love God above all as your reconciled Father, and that you therefore have a right to the heavenly inheritance.
1.) You are closest to yourselves, and your everlasting happiness is your most immediate and your highest concern. What will it profit you to know everything in the world and lose your own soul? To know as much as devils do, and be forever miserable with them?
2.) It is a most grievous thing to spend all day at work in Satan’s chains, to sit studying God and the holy Scriptures while you remain in the power of the devil, with hearts that are at enmity toward the holiness of that God and that Scripture you are studying. If you first do not study your own deliverance, your course of study is fundamentally disordered. If you could see your condition and your chains, the trembling that would follow would overturn your studies entirely.
3.) Until you are renewed, you study in the dark, without the inward sight and sense by which the life, spirit, and substance of everything you study must be known. All that Scripture says about the darkness of a sinful state, the illumination of the Spirit, the wonderful light of regenerate souls, the natural man’s incapacity to receive the things of the Spirit, and the carnal mind that is enmity against God and cannot be subject to his law, all these passages are not insignificant; they are most weighty truths from the Spirit of Truth. You have only a light that will show you the shell and the dead letter, but not the soul and life-giving sense of any practical, holy truth. Just as the eye recognizes food that has never been tasted, or as a mere grammarian or logician reads a law book or medical book and gathers nothing from it that would save a person’s fortune or life, so you will proceed through all your studies.
4.) You are likely to have poor results in your studies when the devil is your master, one who hates both you and the holy things you are studying. He will blind you, corrupt your judgment, fill your minds with false notions, inject distracting and sensual thoughts into you, and ensure that your own souls are never the better for any of it.
5.) You will lack the true end of all right study and will set up wrong ends in its place. Therefore, whatever the subject of your studies, you will be off course and will know nothing rightly, because you do not know it as a means to the true end. (But more on this shortly.)
Direction 2. When you have first laid this foundation and possess the true principle and end of all right study, be sure you aim at this end in everything, namely, the everlasting sight and love of God, the promotion of his glory, and the pleasing of his holy will. Never engage in any study detached from this end; treat every study as a means toward it and as animated by it.
Every step in a journey that is not directed toward the journey’s end is a waste of time and effort. All that you have to consider or do in the world concerns either the end or the means to it, and all creatures and actions can have no other moral goodness than to serve as means to God, your ultimate end. You can see, then, that whenever you leave God out as the end of your studies, you are either sinning or wasting your effort, for in those studies there can be no moral good, though they may contribute to your knowledge of natural good and evil.
When you think you have grown wise and learned, capable of disputing and discoursing on many things that bring you renown, while your wills refuse to submit to "the wholesome words of our Lord Jesus Christ, and the doctrine which is according to godliness," you are in fact proud, "knowing nothing, but doting about questions and strifes of words, whereof cometh envy, strife, railing, evil surmisings, perverse disputings of men of corrupt minds, supposing that gain is godliness: from such turn away." (1 Tim 6:3–5) As all knowledge comes from God, so any knowledge that does not lead back to God is not knowledge but delusion.
Direction 3. See to it, then, that you choose all your studies according to their tendency toward God as your end. Use them always as means, estimate your knowledge by this end, and judge yourselves to know no more in truth than you know of God and for God. So let practical divinity be the soul of all your studies.
Since life is too short to master everything we wish to know, secure the chief things first and prefer those studies that bear most directly on your end. Do not spend your time on things that serve no part of that end, and do not spend your first and best hours on things unnecessary to it. What ennobles the subject matter of your studies is its nearness to God as the end. All true knowledge leads to God, but not all of it equally; the knowledge nearest to him is the best. Cicero could say of himself that he did not take up philosophy all at once, that from his earliest years he spent no ordinary labor and care upon that study, and that when he seemed least to be philosophizing he was philosophizing most.
Direction 4. Remember that the chief part of your growth in knowledge is not in learning many smaller things of little necessity. It consists rather in growing downward into a clearer insight into the foundations of the Christian faith and taking deeper root than you had at your first believing; then in growing upward into a greater knowledge of God, greater love of him, and greater heavenly-mindedness; and then in growing outward into greater skill, readiness, and ability to serve him in the world.
Know as much as you are able of God’s works, of languages, and of the customs of the world. But always remember that to know God in Christ better is the growth you must pursue daily. When you know most, you will still have far greater need to know better the great things you already know than to learn more things you have never known. The roots of faith can always grow deeper, and the branches and fruits of love can always grow greater and sweeter. As long as you live, you can know better the reasons for your religion, though not better reasons, and you can know better how to use your knowledge. Whatever you learn, let it be so that you may be led further into knowing God more, loving him more, or serving him better.
Direction 5. With fear and detestation, watch and resolve against all carnal and worldly ends. Do not let your hearts be captured by fleshly interest, nor grow to esteem the pleasures, profits, or honors of this world, nor come to relish any fleshly comfort as highly pleasant and desirable. Instead, take God and the hope of glory as your satisfying portion. Follow Christ as cross-bearers, denying yourselves, dead to the world, and resolved and prepared to forsake all for his sake.
These are words you can easily repeat. But they are things so difficult to learn that many of the most learned and respected men perish because they never came to know them better. (I will never count someone wisely learned who has not learned to escape damnation.) Christ’s cross must be learned before your alphabet. To impose the cross on others is quickly done, but to learn to bear it is the difficulty. To lay the cross on others is to follow Pilate; to bear it when it is laid on us is to follow Christ.
If you become corrupted by love of honor, riches, and advancement, and come to the study of divinity with a fleshly, worldly mind and end, you will serve Satan while appearing to seek God. You will damn your souls among the very doctrines and means of salvation, going to God for materials to bind you faster to the devil, and stealing a nail from divinity to fasten your ear to his door. You have no idea how tightly Judas’s gain will grip and torment an awakened conscience, how the rust will testify against you and eat your flesh like fire.
Direction 6. Digest all that you know, and turn it into holy habits. Look for the same effect on yourselves first that you would expect in others if you were preaching to them. Remember that knowing is not the end of knowing; it is like eating to the body, where health, strength, and service are the end.
Paul Scaliger says that the first rudiment of contemplative wisdom is to meditate, to learn thoroughly, and to unlearn mere talking. Every truth of God is his candle set up for you to work by: it is food that exists for life and action. Knowledge that ends in mere knowing is wasted. Filling your head and your commonplace book is not the whole of your task. You must fortify, quicken, and inflame your hearts. Good habits are the best provision for a preacher. The habits of the mind are better than the best library. But if the habits of heavenly love and a living heart do not concur, the heart and life of a preacher and scholar are still lacking, for all your knowledge. Study Paul’s words: "Knowledge puffeth up, but charity edifieth" (1 Cor 8:1). If he had said that knowledge edifies others while charity saves ourselves, that would have been unremarkable, but even with respect to edification, charity takes precedence.
Direction 7. See that you excel the unlearned as much in holiness as you do in knowledge: otherwise you persuade them that your knowledge is a useless, worthless thing, and you will be judged as unprofitable servants.
Every degree of knowledge is meant to produce a further degree of holiness: ten talents must be improved to ten more. Those who know and do not act are beaten with many stripes. The devil’s scholars look on the godly unlearned with hatred and disdain, preach to their discouragement and disgrace, and strive to set true godliness in the stocks and keep it there. But Christ’s ministers love holiness wherever they see it, and are ashamed to think that the unlearned might be more holy than they. They strive to surpass the unlearned as much in the use and ends of knowledge as in knowledge itself, and with Augustine they lament that while the unlearned take heaven by violence, the learned are thrust out into hell, having thought it their part to know and teach, while other men were left to practise.
Direction 8. Do not cast away a moment of your precious time in idleness or trivialities, but follow your work diligently and with all your might.
By this I do not mean that you should overwork and break down your mind and body, nor that you should neglect such sober exercise as is most necessary to your health, for a sick body is a poor companion for a student, and a disordered mind still worse. Time-wasters love pleasure or idleness more than knowledge and holiness, and wisdom does not fall into idle, sluggish, dreaming souls. If you do not think your work worth your most diligent and concentrated study, you must settle for idle ignorance and go abroad with swelling titles and empty minds, as a deceiver and a scourge of the church.
Direction 9. Keep up a delight in all your studies, and do not carry them on in unwilling weariness. Where there is no notable error in matter or method, gratify your delight by pursuing what pleases you most, even at some smaller inconvenience, because otherwise your weariness may bring much greater harm.
I recognize that a delight in sin and vanity is not to be indulged, and that force must be applied to a reluctant mind in cases of necessity and weight. But when it is merely a matter of varying subjects and choosing pleasing studies that are nonetheless profitable, even if some other study might, strictly speaking, be better, something may reasonably be yielded to delight. Above all, the heart must be brought to delight in holy things. When that happens, time will be well spent, the memory will be strengthened, much will be accomplished, and you will persevere. Such daily labor, being itself a greater pleasure, will also preserve the mind from temptations to needless recreation and from the deadly plague of youthful lusts.
Direction 10. Have a judicious person draw up for you the headings of a threefold commonplace book: one part for definitions, axioms, and necessary doctrines; another for what is useful for ornament and oratory; and a third for references, serving as a general index to all the books in each field you read, for memory cannot hold everything.
Students ordinarily lack the judgment to form their own commonplace books until they are seasoned in study and have read most of the authors they wish to remember. The young must therefore have a wise guide here. And even when the books are formed, a lack of judgment will tend to fill them with less necessary things and produce an ill-chosen selection of material, unless care is taken and an instructor consulted.
Direction 11. Highly esteem sound method in divinity and in all your studies, and work to acquire an accurate scheme or skeleton in which you may see every part in its proper place at once. But remember that if your scheme is not sound it will become a snare; and one error in your scheme or method will tend to introduce a great many more.
It is a poor and pitiful form of knowledge to know many loose fragments and broken members of truth without knowing the whole, or the place and relation each part has to the rest. To know letters but not syllables, syllables but not words, words but not sentences, or sentences but not the scope of the discourse, all of these are unprofitable forms of knowledge. No one truly knows a subject who has not analyzed it thoroughly and carries a sound method of it in the mind. Yet among the many schemes now available, I dare not single out any one as most to be esteemed or as entirely free from error.
Direction 12. Keep the primitive, fundamental truths always in view, and see every other truth you learn as springing from them and receiving life and nourishment from them. Maintain a clear distinction in your mind between truths of differing degrees, both of necessity and of certainty, always reducing the less necessary to the more necessary, and the less certain to the more certain, and never the reverse.
Read Vincentius Lirinensis carefully.
If God had made all points of faith and scriptural revelation equally necessary, our baptism would not have mentioned only belief in the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost; nor would the ancient creed or the ten commandments ever have appeared. And if all points were equally evident, plain, and certain to us, we would not find some so much more contested than others. As Scripture itself says, "Some things" are "hard to be understood," but not "all things" (2 Pet 3:16). To claim that any truth is more necessary than it is tends toward uncharitableness and contention; to say that any truth is less necessary than it is tends toward neglect of it and to the danger of souls. To present any point as more plain and certain than it actually is reveals only pride and ignorance. But to elevate uncertain and unnecessary points into the substance of religion, and to reduce what is certain or necessary to serve them, that is the method of turbulent heretics.
Direction 13. Take nothing as universally necessary in religion that was not so regarded in the days of the apostles and the primitive church.
Take as the safest road to heaven the way the apostles walked, for they are certainly there. Value apostolic purity, simplicity, charity, and unity. Do not follow those who, by being wise and pious to excess, corrupt our sacred pattern with their additions and fill the church with uncharitableness and strife.
Were it not so plainly evident that dominion and riches pass for religion among them, and gain for godliness, and honor and money in place of argument, it would be a most stupendous wonder that so many learned men among Christians work so vehemently and implacably to hinder the peace and unity of the church, as do those in the church of Rome. The thing that would unite almost the entire Christian world is both easy and reasonable: require no more as necessary to our union than what was made necessary in the days of the apostles, and press nothing as necessary to salvation that the apostles and the primitive church were saved without. This easy and reasonable standard, against which no one has anything of genuine weight to urge, would end all the ruinous divisions among Christians.
Direction 14. Be eager to know all that God would have you know, and be content to be ignorant of all that God would have you ignorant of. Do not pry into unrevealed things, and still less make them the subject of uncharitable strife.
Great numbers of contentious volumes between the Dominicans and the Jesuits, and many others besides, are stuffed with bold inquiries, wranglings, and confident verdicts about unsearchable mysteries, mysteries utterly unknown to those who debate them at such length and never revealed in the Word or the works of God. Keep a reverent distance from hidden mysteries. Do not speak of the divine influx, or of the priority, posteriority, dependence, or reason of God’s decrees, as freely as you would speak of your ordinary affairs. Come with great reverence when God calls you to search into the high and holy truths he has revealed, but do not pretend to know what cannot be known. You will only expose your ignorance and arrogance, and you will know no more for having doted on such questions however long.
Direction 15. Avoid both extremes: those who study no further than to know what others have written and held before them, and those who pay little regard to the discoveries of others. Learn from your teachers and authors everything they can teach you, but make it your own, see things in their proper evidence, and build on their discoveries with your utmost diligence, abhorring any proud desire for singularity or for appearing wiser than you are.
Most students, through sloth, look no further for knowledge than to their books; their learning consists merely in knowing what others have written, said, or held before them. Where the slightest departure from the judgment of the party that is uppermost or most esteemed tends to endanger a man’s reputation or advancement, men think it dangerous to appear to know more than is commonly known, and therefore think it needless to study for it. Men are reluctant to take great pains to know what would ruin them to be known, while ignorance of it does them no harm, which is why opposed truth finds so few champions or students among the Papists, or among any who persecute or reproach it.
Others, perceiving this extreme, run into the contrary. Under pretense of the loveliness of truth and the need for liberty of judgment, they think the edifying way is first to demolish everything others have built before them, and to pay little regard to the judgment of their predecessors. They think they must take nothing on trust from others but must begin everything from the very ground themselves. Their pride typically makes them so dismissive of the most approved authors that they have not the patience to read them until they thoroughly understand them; they reject what is received before they understand it, merely because it was the received way. While they claim that nothing must be taken on trust, they immediately take on trust that very opinion, and with it the other opinions of the novelists who teach them this. Believing what such teachers say in disgrace of others, they also believe what those teachers hold in opposition to those they have disgraced.
It is easy to see what a sorry condition mankind would be in if every person had to fabricate all their knowledge themselves, and if posterity were never the better for the discoveries of their ancestors, if the greatest labors of the wisest men and their highest attainments were to profit no one but themselves.
Why use a teacher at all, if one must do everything oneself? If they neither believe their tutors nor take anything on trust, it seems they must already know every truth before they will learn it. And what difference is there between believing a tutor and believing an author? Is not that more credible which, upon long experience, is approved by many nations and ages, than what is recommended by only one or a few? These students should have invented their own alphabet and grammar rather than taking the common ones on trust. It is easier to add to other men’s inventions than to begin and carry everything forward alone. By their course of study the world would never grow wiser; every age and person would still be beginning, and none would advance beyond their rudiments.
Direction 16. Be sure to choose fitting teachers and companions for your studies and your life, people who will assist you in the holy practice of what you know, as well as in your knowledge itself. And shun as a plague the familiarity: 1. Of sensual, idle, brutish persons. 2. Of carnal, ambitious ones who know no higher end than preferment and applause. 3. Of proud, heretical, contentious wits whose wisdom and religion amount to nothing but censuring, reproaching, and vilifying those who are wiser and better than themselves.
Bad company is the common ruin of youth. Their own sensuality is easily stirred by the temptations of the sensual; their consciences are overborne by the example of other men’s voluptuous lives. It emboldens them to sin when they see others sin before them, just as cowards in an army are drawn to run into the face of death by seeing others do it, and to avoid the reproach of cowardice. The noise of mirth and ranting language are the drums and trumpets of the devil, by which their ears are kept from hearing the cries of the wounded and dying, and the lamentations of those who have found the error of that way.
There is in corrupted nature so strong an inclination toward worldly prosperity and vain-glory that men quickly take the bait, especially when the devil offers it through a fitting instrument, which will not deter them as it would if he had offered it himself. It is a pleasant thing to flesh and blood to be rich, great, and generally applauded; and a grievous thing to be poor, despised, and afflicted. Plato, as Diogenes Laertius reports him, held that sound deliberation comes from those who are learned and experienced in many affairs.
Young people who are raw and unsettled, and who lack well-furnished understanding and experience, give a great advantage to heretics and deceivers, who continually sweep away many such people wherever they come and find opportunity. Children are "easily tost up and down, and carried to and fro with every wind of doctrine, by the cunning sleight and subtlety of them that lie in wait to deceive." Deceivers have their methods, and methods are the common instruments of deceit, not easily detected by the inexperienced.
By contrast, the benefit of wise, steady, sober, peaceable, meek, humble, holy, and heavenly companions is exceedingly great, especially for youth. Such companions will lead them in safe paths, continually preserving them, promoting the most necessary parts of knowledge, and quickening them to holy practice, which is the end of all.
Direction 17. In all your studies be wary of both extremes, and distinguish clearly which they are, so that you do not run into one while avoiding the other. Be especially careful not to mistake things that are co-ordinate or subordinate for opposites, and do not throw away every truth you cannot immediately place rightly within the framework or see fitting agreeably with the rest. A deeper insight into true method, attained by very few, may reconcile you to what now offends you. What God has joined together, be sure never to put asunder, even if you cannot yet find the proper place of each part.
Cicero observed that where men’s opinions are so various and so much at odds with one another, it may well happen that none of them is true, though it certainly cannot happen that more than one of them is true.
There is scarcely any error more common among students than supposing truths to be inconsistent which in fact necessarily depend on each other, and casting away a truth as error because they cannot reconcile it with some other truth. Nothing causes this so much as the lack of a sound method. The person who has no adequate method, or who after much laborious effort has fallen upon a false method or upon one that is out of joint at any one significant point, will deal in this way with many certain truths. It is like an ignorant person trying to reassemble all the scattered parts of a clock or watch: misplace one piece, and you will be unable to place all the rest rightly; then, finding that a piece does not fit where you think it must go, you cast it aside, conclude it is not the right piece, and begin searching for or making something else to fill that place. False method rejects many a truth.
Apart from loving God, and other acts of the higher faculties directed toward their ultimate end and highest object, there is scarcely anything in human life that does not have its extremes. Where those extremes are not discerned, they are seldom well avoided. Narrowly-sighted persons are typically fearful of only one extreme and see danger on only one side; and so they are easily carried, by avoiding that one danger, straight into the contrary.
I think it will be useful to give several particular cautions by way of instance, so that you do not imitate those who put asunder what God has joined together, and do not cast away a truth whenever you are puzzled about where rightly to place it in your method.
Instance 1. First and second causes are conjoined in their operations and must not be separated. If the manner of their influx, concurrence, or cooperation is obscure and unsearchable to you, do not deny that it exists simply because you cannot see how it works. The honor of the first and second cause is likewise joined, proportioned to their several interests in the effects. Do not suppose that all honor given to the second cause is taken away from the first; that would show a failure to understand their order. Once you understand it, you will see that the second cause acts in dependence on and subordination to the first, possessing no power except what the first communicates; so too it receives no honor except from the first.
It is no less honor for the first cause to operate mediately through the second than to operate immediately by itself. There is no less of the power, wisdom, or goodness of God in an effect produced through means and second causes than in one he produces directly without them.
It is his goodness to communicate to his creatures the power of doing good and the dignity of working and causing under him, yet he loses nothing by communicating, and has no less himself by giving to his creatures. For if all honor given to the creature were injuriously taken from God, then God would never have made the world or made a saint; the worst creatures would least dishonor him; he would not shine through the sun but only by himself; and he would never glorify saint or angel. On the contrary, it is God’s honor to work by fitting means, and all their honor is truly his, just as all the praise of a clock or watch belongs to the workman. And though God does not do everything without means and second causes, he is never the further from the effect: by immediacy of power and of person he is himself as near to every effect as if he used no means at all.
Instance 2. God’s special providence and his being the first universal cause are conjoined with the culpability of sinners, and no one should separate them. Those who cannot see exactly how they are conjoined may be certain nevertheless that they are. It is no dishonor to an engineer that he can make a watch that runs longer than he keeps his finger moving it. Nor is it a dishonor to our Creator that he can make a creature capable of morally determining itself to an action as commanded or forbidden, without the predetermination of its Maker, though not without that universal concurrence which is necessary to action as action.
If Adam was naturally incapable of this, then the law that threatened death was really demanding that he overcome God or do what was naturally impossible, and that would be the nature of his sin. Hardly anyone dares to say that God cannot make a free, self-determining agent. And if he can make such an agent, it can easily be shown that he has done so; and the force of the opposing argument then disappears.
Instance 3. God’s omniscience and his dominion, government, and decrees are conjoined with the liberty and sin of man; yet many put these asunder, as if God must be either ignorant or the author of sin. As if he made one person poor by decreeing to make another rich. As if he cannot be a perfect governor unless he secures his subjects’ perfect obedience to his laws. As if all fault for breaking the law must be laid upon the maker of the law. As if God’s moral will, his will concerning what is owed and due, fails of its proper effect unless man fulfils it in the event. And as if any creature could comprehend the mode of the Creator’s knowledge.
Instance 4. Many would separate nature and grace, which God, the author of both, has conjoined. Grace presupposes nature, sows all its seed in nature’s garden, and stirs up and corrects all nature’s powers; yet these people speak as if nature had been annihilated, or as if grace came to annihilate it rather than to heal it. As if the leprosy and disease of nature were nature itself. As if natural good had been as thoroughly lost as moral good. As if a man were not a man until grace made him one.
Instance 5. Many separate the natural power of a sinner from his moral inability, and his natural freedom of will from his moral bondage, treating them as mutually exclusive when in fact they coexist. As if a natural faculty could not remain alongside an evil disposition, or natural power alongside a habitual unwillingness to exercise it rightly. And as if a sinner were no longer a man.
Instance 6. Many separate general and special grace and redemption as incompatible, when they are conjoined: the general grace is the proper means by which the ends of special grace are accomplished, and it is always presupposed. As if God could not give more to some while giving something to all. Or as if he gave nothing to all simply because he gives more to some. As if he could not deal equally and without distinction with all as a legislator, and righteously with all as a judge, unless he also dealt equally and without distinction with all as a benefactor in the free distribution of his gifts. As if he were obliged to make every worm and beast a man, every man a king, every king an angel, every clod a star, and every star a sun.
Instance 7. Many separate the glory of God and man’s salvation, God and man, in assigning the ultimate end of humanity. As if a moral intention could not embrace both. As if the end of a lover were not union in mutual love. As if love to God could not be forever the final act and God himself the final object. And as if, in this magnetic union of the two parties, it were impossible for one party to be infinitely greater than the other, so that while both may be called an end, only one is the absolutely ultimate end.
Instance 8. Indeed, many would separate God from God, by separating God from heaven and saying that for the love of God we must be content to be shut out of heaven, when our heaven is the perfect love of God. They say in effect that for the love of God we must be content to be shut out from the love of God.
Instance 9. In the same way the common people separate the mercy and the justice of God, as if God did not know better than man to whom his mercy should extend. As if God were not merciful unless he abandons righteous government, unless he lets the whole world spit in his face and blaspheme him and lets all his enemies go unpunished.
Instance 10. In the same way many separate threats and promises, fear and love, a perfect law and a pardoning gospel. As if a person who is human, and therefore has both fear and love by nature, must not use both in the service of God and his salvation. As if the lawgiver may not frame his laws to work upon both. As if hell may not be feared and heaven loved at once.
Instance 11. In the same way hypocrites mentally separate their seeming holiness and devotion to God from their duties of justice and charity toward other people. As if they could serve God acceptably while wilfully disobeying him. Or as if they could love him whom they have never seen, yet not love his image in his works and his children whom they see daily. As if they could hate and persecute Christ in his little ones, or at least neglect him there, and yet sincerely love him in himself.
Instance 12. In the same way Scripture and tradition, divine faith and human faith, are commonly set in opposition by many people. Because the Papists have assigned tradition a wrong place, many discard it entirely because it does not fit that place. Yet human tradition and ministerial transmission are necessary to make known and deliver God’s revelation to us. A tradition that serves Scripture is no disparagement to Scripture, though a tradition that claims to supplement it is. A man must be believed as a man, even though not as God; and the person who refuses to believe a man as a man will hardly know what he has to believe from God.
Instance 13. Many people separate the sufficiency of the law and rule from the usefulness of an officer, minister, and judge to execute it, as if the law must be imperfect unless it needs no execution and no judge to execute it, or as if a judge’s execution were a supplement or addition to the law itself. The question of who shall judge does not imply that the law is insufficient; promulgation and execution are already assumed by it.
Instance 14. Many also separate the necessity of a public judge from the lawfulness and necessity of private judgment and discernment in every rational subject, as if God and man governed only brutes, or as if one could obey a law without judging it to be a law that requires obedience, and without understanding its meaning and what it commands. As if fools and madmen were the only subjects. As if learning from Christ as his disciples, meditating day and night in his law, and searching his Word for wisdom were acts of disobedience to him as king. It is not possible for subjects to obey without a private judgment of discernment. Nor is there any contradiction between my judging what the king’s law is, and his judging whether I am punishable for disobeying it. Nor does judging ourselves contradict our being judged by God.
Instance 15. Many separate the operation of the Word and Spirit from the minister and Christ, as if the Spirit did not ordinarily work through the Word, and as if Christ did not preach to us through his ministers and ambassadors. As if people could despise his messengers without being counted despisers of himself, or could throw away the dish and keep the milk.
Instance 16. Many separate the special love owed to saints from the common love owed to human beings as such, as if one cannot love a saint without also being free to hate an enemy, despise all others, and deny them the love that answers to their natural goodness.
Instance 17. Many separate universal or catholic union and communion from particular communion. Some recognize no communion except the universal; others recognize none except the particular. Some say that if one does not hold local, particular communion with a group, indeed, if one does not join them in every mode of worship, one has separated from them in catholic communion. As if one could be personally present in ten thousand congregations at once, or else be reckoned to have separated from them all. Or as if, by differing from all other people in face or complexion, one were therefore separated from all mankind. One may be absent from many thousands of churches and still honor them as true churches of Christ and hold catholic communion with them in faith, hope, and love, even if one dare not join them personally in worship because of some sinful condition they impose. Nor does holding a catholic faith and love toward all Christians in the world remove the obligation to be a member of some ordered, worshipping congregation.
Instance 18. Many separate outward and inward worship, some thinking that whatever the body performs is contrary to true spirituality, others that spirituality is mere fancy and opposed to outward form. As if the heart and the knee may not fittingly bow together, or as if decency of order cannot concur with Spirit and truth.
Instance 19. Many separate faith and obedience, separating Paul’s justification by faith apart from the works of the law from James’s justification by works and not by faith only, and from Christ’s justification by our words (Matt 12:37). In doing so they also separate free grace and justification from any necessary condition, and from the rewardableness of obedience (which the ancients called merit). This matter is treated at length elsewhere.
Instance 20. Many separate prudence from zeal, meekness from resolution, the wisdom of the serpent from the innocency of the dove, yielding to no sin, and yet yielding in things lawful; maintaining Christian liberty, and yet becoming all things to all people, if by any means we may save some. These instances are enough; I will add no more.
Direction 18. Guard against falling into factions and parties in religion, whether the party is great or small, high or low, honored or despised, and beware of being infected with a factious, censorious, uncharitable, and destructive zeal, for these are deeply contrary to the interest, will, and Spirit of Christ. Therefore, among all your reading, thoroughly absorb the doctrine of charity and peace, and read widely in reconciling and moderating authors: such as Dury, Hall, Davenant, Crocius, Bergius, Martinius, Amyraldus, Dallæus, Testardus, Calixtus, Hottonus, Junius, Paræus, and Burroughs in their Irenicons, their works written for reconciliation.
Reading such books extinguishes the consuming flame of that infernal, envious zeal described in James 3, and kindles charity, meekness, mellowness, and moderation in the heart. It heals those bloodshot eyes that cannot discern truth until they are cured. It advances knowledge and promotes what is more truly edifying, keeping knowledge from making us conceited. Experience will confirm over time that, among ancients and moderns, Greeks and Latins, Papists and Protestants, Lutherans and Calvinists, Remonstrants and Contra-remonstrants, Prelatists, Presbyterians, Independents, and the rest, the moderators are generally not only the best and most charitable but also the wisest and most judicious people.
Direction 19. With all your reading, keep joining to it the reading of the Scriptures and of the most holy and practical divines, not fantastical, enthusiastic counterfeits, or Paracelsian divines, but those who lead you up by the solid doctrine of faith and love to true devotion, heavenly-mindedness, and godly living.
This must be your bread and drink, your daily and substantial food. Without it you may soon be filled with air that cannot nourish you, and prove in the end as sounding brass and a tinkling cymbal. These works breed strength, peace, and joy; they help you in your communion with God and your hope of heaven, and so advance the end of all your studies. There is more life and sweetness in them than in things more remote from God and heaven.
Direction 20. Finally, do all as dying people: do not promise yourselves a long life, lest it tempt you to waste your time on what is least necessary and to idle it away, or lest you lose the quickening benefit that the sight of death and eternity would give you in all your studies.
The nearer you understand yourself to be to death and heaven, the greater help you have toward mortification and heavenly-mindedness. This will make you serious, sustain right intentions, keep out wrong ones, and powerfully arm you against temptations, so that, having studied to save others, you may not yourself be cast away, nor be cheated by the devil with the shell, the leaves, and the flowers, while you go without the saving fruit.
I have spoken at greater length on this subject of governing the thoughts because it is so great and excellent a part of human work: God regards the heart so deeply, the Spirit of Christ and the spirit of Satan strive so intensely for it, grace is so thoroughly engaged about it, and our happiness or misery, joy or sorrow, is greatly advanced by our thoughts. I would have said more, but much has already been said in the third chapter and in my Treatise of the Divine Life. For a method and directions for particular meditations, I have given them at length in the fourth part of the Saints’ Rest, from which they may easily be taken and applied to other subjects, as they are there applied to heaven. It is easy to write and read directions; but I fear that slothfulness, given the difficulty of practice, will render my directions fruitless for most. Yet if any profit by them, my labor is not lost.
CHAPTER 11
DIRECTIONS FOR THE GOVERNMENT OF THE PASSIONS
The passions are to be considered in two ways.
1. As they are in themselves, and as the sin in them concerns God and ourselves only: this is what I address here.
2. As they are a wrong to others, and a breach of the commandments requiring love and duty toward our neighbor: this I will address later.
Passions are not sinful in themselves, for God has given them to us for his service, and every one of them may be sanctified and used for him. But they are sinful 1. when they are misguided and fixed on wrong objects; 2. when they darken reason, delude the mind, shut out truth, and lead into error; 3. when they rebel against the government of the will, trouble it, hinder it in choosing or pursuing the good, or drive it violently to follow their brutish inclination; 4. when they are ill-timed; 5. or immoderate and excessive in degree; 6. or too prolonged; 7. and when they tend to evil effects, to unseemly speech or action, or to wronging another.
Passions are holy when they are devoted to God and exercised upon him or for him. They are good when 1. they have right objects; 2. they are guided by reason; 3. they are obedient to a well-guided will; 4. they quicken and rouse reason and will to do their duty; 5. they tend to good effects, stirring all the other powers to their work; 6. and they do not exceed in degree so as to disturb the brain or body.
Title 1. Directions against All Sinful Passions in General
Direction 1. Do not rely on any present act of resistance, without the proper habitual mortification of the passions and the fortification of the soul against them. Look first to the holy constitution of your mind and life; then sinful passions will fall away like scabs from a healthy body when the blood has been purified.
No wonder an unholy soul is a slave to passion when the body inclines toward it. Such a person is under the power of selfishness, carnality, and worldliness, and outside the government of Christ and his Spirit; they lack the life of grace by which the corruptions of nature are cured and subdued. The way for such a person to master passion is not to strive by natural, selfish principles and reasoning, which are partial, weak, and insufficient. They must look first to the main thing, and seek earnestly and without delay for a new and sanctified heart, obtaining God’s image, his Spirit, and his renewing, quickening grace. This is the only truly effective conqueror of nature.
A dull and gentle temperament may seem, without this, to have conquered what never much assailed it (for such persons are tried in some other way). But no one truly conquers Satan except by the Spirit of Christ. And if you were free from passion but not free from an unholy, carnal, worldly heart, you would perish at last, however calm you appeared on earth.
Begin therefore at the foundation. See that the body of sin is mortified, that the whole tree bearing these bitter fruits is uprooted, and that the holy, victorious new nature is within you. Then you will resist sin with light and life, whereas others still resist it as if half asleep.
Direction 2. More particularly, let your souls always be held by the fear of God. Live as in his household, under his eye and government, so that his authority may be more powerful than temptations, and your holy fellowship with him may make him more regarded by you than men or any creature. Then this sun will put out the lesser lights, and the thunder of his voice will drown out the whispers that would provoke you and the buzzing of those wasps that make you so impatient. God would make the creature nothing in your sight, and then it would do nothing to disturb you or draw you into sin.
Direction 3. Dwell in the delightful love of God, and in the sweet contemplation of his love in Christ; turn his tender mercies over in your thoughts; let your fellowship be with the holy ones in heaven, and your work be thanksgiving and praise to God. This will form in your souls such a sweetness, mellowness, and stability as will resist sinful passion the way heat resists cold.
Direction 4. Keep your conscience continually tender, and it will check the first appearance of sinful passions, and will feel the pain of the sin more sharply than your passionate nature feels the pain of the provocation. A seared conscience and a hardened, insensible heart are to every sin what a man fast asleep is to thieves: they may enter and do what they will, so long as they do not wake him. But a tender conscience is always awake.
Direction 5. Labor after wisdom, strength of reason, and a solid judgment, for passion is nourished by folly. Children are easily knocked down, and leaves are easily shaken by every little wind, while grown men hold their course and rocks and mountains are not moved. Women, children, the elderly, the weak, and the sick are usually the most passionate. If a wise man happens to have a passionate nature, he possesses something that can do much to control it; whereas folly is a weathercock at the wind’s command.
Direction 6. See that the will is confirmed and resolute, and it will quickly command passion down. People can do much against passion if they will. Nature has placed the will on the throne of the soul. It is the sinful connivance and negligence of the will that is the guilty cause of all rebellion, just as the connivance of commanding officers is the common cause of mutiny in an army. The will either consents to passion or is negligent in its office of forbidding and repressing passion’s rage.
When I say, "you can do it if you will," you may think this is not true, because you are willing and yet passion does not yield to your will’s command. But I do not mean that any kind of willingness will serve: a sluggish wish will not do it. If the will were resolute, without any compliance, connivance, or negligence in its proper office, no sinful passion could remain. For passion is no further sinful than it is voluntary, either through the will’s compliance or through its omission and neglect. Therefore, direct most of your effort toward waking and confirming the will, and it will command passion down.
Direction 7. Labor after holy fortitude, courage, and magnanimity. Great minds are above all the troubles, cravings, and agitations that arise over small things. A poor, base, childish mind is never at rest longer than it is rocked to sleep or flattered.
Direction 8. Above all, see that you are not lacking in self-denial, and that worldliness and fleshly-mindedness are thoroughly mortified, for sinful passion is the very breath and pulse of a selfish, fleshly, worldly mind. Dogs do not fight over a bone more naturally than such people snarl and quarrel, or fall into some disordered passion, over their selfish, carnal interests. Covetousness will not let the mind be at rest. It is as natural for a selfish man to be under the power of sinful passions as for a man with a fever to shake, or for one who is melancholic to be full of fear. Fleshly people carry with them a constant ravenous appetite and feverish thirst for some pleasure-seeking trifle or other.
Direction 9. Keep a court of justice in your soul, call yourself to account daily, and let no passion escape without the censure it deserves. If reason and conscience thus exercise and maintain their authority, and passion is soundly rebuked every day, it will wither like a plant that is cropped as fast as it puts out new growth.
Direction 10. Deliberate and look to the end: examine whether your passion is tending toward something you will be able to approve when it has passed. Looking to the end shames all sinful passions. They are blind, moved only by things present; they cannot bear to look at what is coming, or to be examined as to where they are heading and where they will end up.
Direction 11. Keep a continual awareness of the danger and ugliness of sinful passions, by recognizing how full they are of the seeds of many other sins. See their evil in their effects. Notice what passion does in others and in yourself: what a multitude of evil thoughts, words, and deeds flow from sinful passions.
Direction 12. Observe the immediate, troubling effects of passion and the disorders of your soul, and so turn the fruit of passions against themselves. Mark how they unsettle you, disturb your reason, make your mind like muddied water, breed a diseased restlessness within you, unfit you for your work, and break your peace, so that you can neither know, nor use, nor enjoy yourself.
Direction 13. Let death look your passions frequently in the face. Death has a mortifying power: it reveals the vanity of created things and pulls down those passions that creature-interest and self-deception have raised. It stirs reason back to life and restores it to its proper authority, silencing the rebellion of the senses. A man who knows he must die tomorrow would far more easily repel today’s temptation to lust, covetousness, drunkenness, or revenge than he could at any other time. One clear look into eternity will powerfully rebuke all carnal passions.
Direction 14. Remember always that God is present. Will you behave passionately before him, when even the presence of your prince would calm you? Shall God and his holy angels see you cast aside your reason and conduct yourself like a madman?
Direction 15. Keep ready some fitting Scripture to rebuke your passions, so that you may say to temptation, as Christ said to Satan, "Thus it is written." Address it in the name and Word of God: bare words alone will not charm these evil spirits, but divine authority will curb them. For this "Word is quick and powerful, a discerner of the thoughts" (Heb 4:12). It is "mighty through God, to the pulling down of strong holds, casting down imaginations, and every high thing that exalteth itself against the knowledge of God, and bringeth into captivity every thought to the obedience of Christ" (2 Cor 10:4–5).
Direction 16. Set Christ continually before you as your pattern, who calls you to learn of him to be meek and lowly: who did not desire the wealth or glory of the world; who loved his own who were in the world, but did not love the things of the world; who was never lifted up in pride nor sinfully cast down in despair; who never despised or envied any man, nor ever feared man; who was never over-merry or over-sad; who, being reviled, reviled not again, but was silent as a lamb before its shearers.
Direction 17. Keep as far from all occasions of your passions as other duties will allow, and arrange your affairs so as to oppose temptation as much as possible. Do not run into temptation if you wish to be delivered from evil. A willing and prudent person can accomplish much simply by ordering his affairs well. Both God and Satan work through means, so take those means seriously.
Direction 18. Take due care of your body, so that no physical disorder is allowed to persist and produce disorder in the soul. Passions depend greatly on the condition of the body, and much of their cure, where it is possible, lies in the body’s correction.
Direction 19. Turn all your passions into the right channel, making them holy by directing them toward God and the greatest things. This is the true cure; merely restraining them is only a temporary remedy, like deadening pain with a dose of opium. Cure the fear of man by the fear of God; cure love of the creature by the love of God; cure anxiety for the body by care for the soul; cure earthly and fleshly desires and delights by spiritual desires and delights; and cure worldly sorrow by profitable, godly sorrow.
Direction 20. Control the effects of your passions and deny them what they seek; in time this will destroy their cause. Deny yourself the things that carnal love and desire pursue; refuse the actions that carnal mirth or anger would provoke you to, and the fire will go out for lack of fuel. (More on this will follow in the particulars.)
Title 2. Directions against Sinful Love of Creatures
Love is the master passion of the soul because it has the highest object, goodness itself, which is the proper object of the will. Simple love is nothing but approval, which is nothing but the simple willing of good; and it is a passionate willing or approval that we call the passion of love. I showed earlier when this love is good and when it is sinful. Yet because half the cure here lies in conviction, and it is so difficult to make any lover recognize sinfulness in his love, I will first help you examine your love so as to expose its sinfulness, after first naming the objects of it. As Paul Scaliger says, love alone makes a person good or evil.
Any creature that seems good to us may possibly become the object of sinful love: honor, greatness, authority, praise, money, houses, lands, cattle, food, drink, sleep, clothing, sports, friends, relations, and even life itself. As for lustful love, I shall address that shortly.
Helps for Detecting Sinful Love
Direction 1. Make God’s interest and his Word the standard by which you judge all your affections. Whatever works against the love of God, diminishes or hinders it, or does not directly or indirectly tend to further it, is certainly a sinful love, as is everything contrary to his Word. The love of God is our ultimate act directed toward our ultimate end; therefore whatever does not tend toward it is a sin against that very end, and so against our nature and the right use of our faculties.
Direction 2. Whatever creature is loved ultimately for its own sake, and not for a higher end, for God, his service, his honor, his relation to that creature, or his excellence appearing in it, is loved sinfully. To love anything ultimately for itself is to make it our God.
Direction 3. Suspect all love for creatures that is very strong and violent, easily kindled, and hard to moderate or quiet. Even if you think you love some person or thing for a spiritual end or excellence, suspect it if it comes so easily and burns so intensely. What is truly and purely spiritual runs against corrupted nature and flows from grace, which is weak in us; we find no such readiness to love God, Scripture, prayer, and holiness, and our affections toward these are not so violent. It is well if all the fuel and effort we can muster will keep them alive. If the love blazes fiercely, it is two to one that the flesh and the devil have added some fuel or gunpowder of their own.
Direction 4. Suspect all love in which selfishness and bodily interest have a hand. Is it some physical pleasure and delight that you love so intensely? Or is it a good book or some other help for your soul? We are far more prone to excess and sin in carnal, fleshly-mindedness than in loving what is good for our souls; we should therefore be far more suspicious in that direction. If the love is intense and set on the body, it is ten to one that there is sin in it.
Direction 5. Suspect all love for creatures that your reason cannot account for or justify. If you love one place or person far more than others, and cannot say why except that you cannot help it, this is much to be suspected. Though God may sometimes kindle a hidden love between friends through an inexpressible unity or likeness of minds, a love beyond what reason can fully explain, this is rare. Usually fancy, foolishness, or carnality is the cause. Such love, at any rate, calls for more suspicion and scrutiny than love that reason can clearly account for.
Direction 6. Suspect all fervent love for any creature that forms hastily before sufficient trial; for as a rule both persons and things present their best side first and appear better at the start than they prove to be. This is not to deny that a moderate love may arise at the first sign of genuine excellence, especially spiritual excellence, but it should remain open to the possibility of being deceived and of finding more fault on fuller acquaintance than at first appeared.
Have you lived under the same roof as those you so much admire? Have you seen them tested in their daily dealings? Have you watched them tried by troubles, losses, injury, adversity, prosperity, or the offer of advancement and worldly plenty? You would scarcely believe what lies hidden and unrevealed in the hearts of many who have excellent gifts, until trial brings it to light.
Direction 7. Test your affections in prayer before God: whether they are such as you dare boldly ask God to increase, continue, and bless; and whether they are such as conscience raises no quarrel against. If they cannot bear this test, be more suspicious and search more carefully. The name and presence of God in prayer does much to dispel the deceptions of carnal reasoning. Those who are cast by melancholy into sickly fears and excessive scruples, however, are not able to use this method of trial.
Direction 8. Consult with wise, impartial persons, and open your case to them without deceit, before your affections have gone so far as to blind you or leave you beyond help. In this case, if in any case, the judgment of an impartial and faithful observer is usually to be preferred over your own. We are too close to ourselves, and judgment will be bribed and biased even in the best and wisest persons.
Direction 9. Yet do not abandon everything because you find much excess or carnality in your affections, for there is frequently a mixture of both good and evil in the cause of love and in the love itself. When you have removed everything that was selfish, carnal, or mistaken in its cause, the carnal and violent love will cease, but not all love. There will and must remain a moderate, rational, and holy love, proportioned to the creature’s worth and directed ultimately to God. Once that separation is made, this part must be preserved.
Direction 10. Mere natural appetite is in itself neither morally good nor evil: but as it is well placed and ordered it is good, and as unruled or ill-ruled it is evil.
Helps to Mortify Sinful Love
Direction 1. The greatest of all means to cast out sinful love is to keep the soul in the love of God (Jude 1:21), wholly taken up in admiring him, serving him, praising him, and rejoicing in him. On this see Chapter III, Direction 11.
Those who are taken up in the love and service of one person are not easily drawn to be much taken with any other. As Lord Bacon observes in his tenth essay, nuptial love makes mankind, friendly love perfects it (much more, divine love), but wanton love corrupts and debases it.
But it is not only by diversion, nor only by filling and employing all our love, that the love of God cures sinful love. Beyond these things there is also a majesty in his objective presence that awes the soul and commands all other things to keep their distance. There is an unspeakable splendor and excellence in him that obscures and makes everything else seem as nothing, though those other things may be closer and more clearly seen and known. And there is a heavenly sweetness in his love which, once tasted, leaves the soul with no appetite for passing and inferior good.
It is as when one who has conversed with wise and learned men no longer marvels at the wit of fools, or when one who has been employed in governing a kingdom or in the highest studies is no longer in love with children’s games and playing in the dirt.
Direction 2. The next help is to see that the creature does not deceive you, and therefore that you are not rash and hasty, but wait until you come nearer to it and see it stripped of borrowed or affected ornaments. See it not only in the dress it wears in public, which often covers great deformities, but in its plain and homely state. Bring it to the light; and if possible, see it also when it has endured the fire, which removes the paint and strips away the dress.
Bias, in Diogenes Laertius, held that we should love as though we would one day hate, since most people are bad. Cicero, in his Laelius, judges that maxim plainly unworthy of a wise man, and would rather have us choose friends we shall never be ashamed of having chosen.
Most of your inordinate love to creatures arises from mistake and rashness. The devil dresses them up and paints them so that you fall in love with them; or else he shows you only the outward face of some apparent good and hides the emptiness or rottenness within. Come closer, therefore, and wait longer, and so spare yourself shame and disappointment.
Is it not a shame to see you doting on some place, office, or thing one year, only to be weary of it before the next? Or to see two persons impatiently fond of each other until they are married, and then living in strife, weary of each other? How few persons or things have been too violently loved that were first sufficiently tried?
Direction 3. The next great help is to destroy self-love in its carnal and disordered form, for this is the parent, life, and root of all other sinful love whatever. Why does the worldling overlove his wealth, the proud man his greatness and reputation, the sensualist his pleasures, but because they first overlove that flesh and self of which all these things are merely the provision? Why does a divisive sectary overvalue and overlove every party and faction that shares his opinion, but because he first overvalues and overloves himself?
Why do you love above their worth those who think highly of you, take your side, praise you behind your back, or do you a good turn, but because you first overlove yourselves? Why does lustful love inflame you, or the love of food, drink, sport, and finery carry you into such a gulf of sin, but that you first overlove your fleshly pleasure? What ensnares you in fondness to any person, but that you believe they love you or are suited to some carnal end of yours? See to it, then, that you mortify the flesh.
Direction 4. Always remember how jealous God is of your love, and how greatly he is wronged when any creature encroaches on his right.
1.) You are his own by creation. Did he give you love to spend on others while denying it to himself?
2.) He daily and hourly sustains you; he gives you every breath, every meal, and every mercy you live upon. Will you love the creature with the portion of love that belongs to him?
3.) How dearly has he purchased your love in your redemption?
4.) He has adopted you and brought you into the closest possible relation to himself, that you may love him.
5.) He has pardoned all your sins and saved you from hell, if you are truly his, that you may love him.
6.) He has promised you eternal glory with himself, that you may love him.
7.) His excellence best deserves your love.
8.) His creatures have nothing except from him, and were purposely sent to draw your love toward him rather than toward themselves.
And yet after all this, shall they encroach upon his portion? If you say that what you give the creature is not God’s part but the creature’s own, I tell you that all the love you give a creature beyond its due, you take from God. But if your love to the creature does not exceed its worth, is directed ultimately to God, and makes you love him not less but more, that is not what I am speaking against or urging you to mortify.
Direction 5. Look on the worst of the creature together with the best, and foresee what it will be when it withers, and what it will appear to you at last. I have applied this against worldliness before, in Chapter IV, Part VI, and I will afterward apply it to lustful love. Bring your beloved creature to the grave and see it as it will appear at last, and much of the folly of your love will vanish.
Direction 6. Understand well the most it will ever do for you, and how short a time you must enjoy it, and do not flatter yourselves with hopes of a longer possession than you have reason to expect. If people would consider for how short a time they must possess what they dote upon, it would somewhat cool their misplaced affections.
Direction 7. Remember that too much love brings the present trouble of too much care, and the future trouble of too much grief when you must part with what you love. Nothing produces more care and grief than disordered love. You know beforehand that you must part with it. Will you now cling to it so tightly that the parting tears your flesh and heart? Remember that you brought all of that on yourselves.
Direction 8. Remember that you provoke God to deprive you of what you overlove, or to allow it to become unlovely to you. Many a man’s horse that he overloved has broken his neck. Many a man’s child that he overloved has died early, or lived to become his scourge and sorrow. And many a husband or wife who was overloved has been quickly taken away, or proved a thorn, or a continual source of grief and misery.
Direction 9. If no other means remain, prudently and moderately make the creature you are fond of bitter to yourself, which may be done in many ways, according to its nature. This can be done by using it more seldom or more sparingly, or by using it more for benefit than for delight, or by mixing in some mortifying and humbling exercises, or by mixing in some acts of self-denial and turning your attention more to the good of others, and so on.
Direction 10. In applying all these directions, a great deal of difference must be made between a carnal, self-indulgent heart that is drawn away from sensual love only with difficulty, and a mortified, melancholy, or over-scrupulous person who is running into the opposite extreme, afraid of every bite of food, of everything they own, wear, or use, and sometimes of their very children and relations, ready to overlook their mercies or neglect their duties, suspecting that everything is loved too much.
It is a very hard thing to write or preach to one of these parties without the other misapplying it and making ill use of it. Everything we can write or say is too little to mortify the fleshly person’s affections; and yet, however cautiously we speak, the troubled soul will turn it to bitterness and increase their distress. What we say for the peace and settling of that soul, though it prove too little and insufficient for them, will be quite sufficient to harden the misapplying sensualist in the sinful affections and liberties he indulges. It is therefore best in such difficult and weighty cases to have a wise, experienced, and faithful guide to help with the application.
CHAPTER 12
DIRECTIONS AGAINST SINFUL DESIRES AND DISCONTENT
I will say little here on this subject, because I have already treated it at length in my book Self-denial, in Crucifying the World, and earlier in this work in Chapter IV, Parts VI and VII, against worldliness and flesh-pleasing, and in the preceding directions against sinful love, which is the root cause.
How sinful desires may be recognized can be gathered from what was said about sinful love.
1. When you desire what is forbidden you.
2. Or when you desire something that will do you no good, under the mistaken belief that it is better or more necessary than it really is.
3. Or when you desire it too eagerly, you must have it, or you become impatient and discontented, unable to rest quietly under God’s ordering of your affairs, and instead you murmur against his providence and your lot.
4. Or when you desire it too hastily, unable to wait for God’s time.
5. Or too greedily as to measure, unsatisfied with God’s allowance and insisting on more than he sees fit to give you.
6. Or especially when your desires are disordered, preferring lesser things to greater, desiring bodily and passing things more than the mercies for your soul that will be everlasting.
7. When you desire anything ultimately and purely for the flesh, without referring it to God, that is a sin. Even your daily bread and all your comforts must be desired only as fodder for a horse that he may better finish his journey, that is, as provision for your body, fitting it for the better and more cheerful service of your soul and of God.
8. Still more when your desires are for wicked ends, as to serve your lust, pride, covetousness, or revenge, they are wicked desires. (Read Mr. Burrough’s excellent treatise The Jewel of Contentment, and that excellent tract of a heathen, Plutarch’s On Tranquillity of Mind.)
9. And when they are injurious to others.
Direction 1. Be well acquainted with your own condition, and consider what you most need; then you will find that you have so much grace and mercy to desire for your soul, without which you are lost forever, and that you have a Christ to desire, and an endless life with God to desire, that all your thirst for the things of this world will be quenched. If anything will make you wiser, this will: when you see that you have greater things to attend to. A man in immediate danger of his life will not worry about pins or trinkets; the prospect of a lordship or a kingdom cures the craving for small things; a man who needs a physician for dropsy or consumption will hardly long for children’s toys. And surely a man who is heading toward heaven or hell ought to have something greater than worldly things to long for.
What a vain and foolish thing a carnal mind is: it has pardon, and grace, and Christ, and heaven, and God to think about, and urgently, before it is too late, yet it forgets them all, or does not value them, and instead eagerly craves some little, negligible trifle. It is as if a man were saying, "I must taste that dish before I die; I must have that house, or that child, or that friend, before I pass into another world." Study what need your distressed soul has of a Christ, and of peace with God, and of preparation for eternity; what need your darkened mind has of more knowledge; what need your dead and carnal heart has of more life, tenderness, and love toward God, and communion with him. Feel these needs as you have cause to, and the eagerness of your carnal desires will be gone.
Thaulerus presses the same point in his Flores (pp. 79, 80). A man should keep his mind unpainted by any images; for if he wants to be pure in heart and free of all images, he must possess nothing at all with love, and must cling to no one by a deliberate affection of singular intimacy, nor let anyone cling to him. Every intimacy or company not entered into purely for the love of God infects and unsettles the mind with all sorts of images, since it takes its rise not from God but from the flesh.
Whoever wants to grow into a spiritual and godly man must renounce the carnal life entirely, cling to God alone in love, and possess him particularly in his inner self. Once he has him, all multiplicity, all images, and all disordered love toward creatures are driven powerfully out of him; for when God is inwardly possessed through love, a man is at once set free from every image. God is a spirit, and no one can properly express or portray his image.
Direction 2. Remember how much your carnal desires aggravate the weakness of your spiritual desires, and make the sin more odious and inexcusable. Are you so eager for a husband, a wife, a child, for wealth, for advancement, or such things, while you are so cold and indifferent in your desire for God, grace, and glory? Your desires for those spiritual things are not so intense. They do not make you so insistent and restless; they do not fill your thoughts day and night; they do not drive you to such contrivance and effort. You can live as quietly without more grace, or assurance of salvation, or communion with God, as if you were entirely indifferent about them, but you must have what you desire in the world, or there is no peace in you.
Do you consider what a horrible contempt of God, of grace, and of heaven this reveals? You are either regenerate or unregenerate. If you are regenerate, then all your instruction, and all your experience of the worth of spiritual things and the vanity of temporal ones, makes it a grievous sin to be so eager now for things you have so often called vanity, while remaining so cold toward God whose goodness you have experienced so greatly. Do you still not know the difference between the creature and the Creator? Do you still not understand your necessities and your true interest, what you live on and must trust for your everlasting blessedness?
If you are unregenerate, as all are who love anything more than God, what madness it is for someone condemned by law to endless torments, who will quickly be there unless regenerated and justified by Christ, to be thirsting so eagerly for this or that earthly thing or person, when he should be rousing himself with all his might to save his soul from endless misery. How incongruous these desires are, whether you are among the good or the bad.
Direction 3. Let every sinful desire humble you for the worldliness and carnality it reveals to be still unmortified in you; and turn your desires toward mortifying that flesh and concupiscence which is the cause. If you did not still love the world and the things that are in the world, you would not be so eager for them. If you were not too carnal, and did not set your mind too much on the things of the flesh, you would not be so earnest for them as you are. It should grieve your hearts to consider what worldliness and carnality this shows still to be lodged there. That you should prize the creature so highly as to be unable to bear the lack of it, is this renouncing the world and the flesh?
What you need is not the thing you so ardently desire, but a better heart: one that knows the vanity of the creature, is dead to the world, and can bear the lack or loss of anything in it. You need a fuller mortification of the flesh. Mortifying it, not satisfying it, is your work.
Direction 4. Ask your hearts seriously whether God in Christ is enough for them or not. If they say no, they renounce him and all their hope of heaven, for no man takes God as his God who does not take him as his portion and as sufficient for him. If they say yes, then you have enough to silence your fleshly desires, since your own hearts confess that they have enough in God. Should a soul that has a filial interest in God, and an inheritance in eternal life, be eager for earthly comforts and conveniences for the flesh? If God is not enough for you, you will never have enough. Turn to him more fully, and know him better, if you would have a satisfied mind.
Direction 5. Remember that every sinful desire is a rebellion of your will against the will of God; that it is his will which must govern and dispose of all; that your will must be conformed to his; yes, that you must take pleasure and rest in the will of God. Reason the case out with your hearts and say: "Who governs the world? Who is to rule me and order my affairs, God or I? Whose will is to lead, and whose to follow? Whose will is better guided, God’s or mine? Either it is his will that I shall have what I desire, or it is not. If it is his will, I need not be so eager, for I shall have it in his time and way. If it is not his will, is it fitting for me to murmur and strive against him?"
Remember that your discontents and carnal desires are so many accusations brought against God, as if you were saying: "You have not dealt well, or wisely, or mercifully with me. I must have things better. I will not submit to your will and government. I must have it as I will, and take the disposal of myself into my own hands."
Direction 6. Observe how your eager desires are condemned by yourselves in your daily prayers, or else they make your prayers themselves condemnable. If you pray that the will of God may be done, why do your wills rebel against it, and your desires contradict your prayers? And if you ask no more than your daily bread, why do you thirst for more? But if you pray as you desire, "Lord, let my will be done, and my selfish, carnal desire be fulfilled, for I must have this or that," what an abominable prayer that is. Desire as you must pray.
Direction 7. Remember what covenant you have made with God: that you renounced the world and the flesh, and took him for your Lord, and King, and Father, and yielded up yourselves as his own, as his subject and as his child, to be disposed of, ruled, and provided for by him. This covenant is essential not only to your Christianity, but to your taking him for your God at all. Do you repent of it? Will you break it and forfeit all the benefits of the covenant? If you insist on having disposal of yourselves, you discharge God of his covenant and fatherly care for you, and then what will become of you, if he so forsakes you?
Direction 8. Consider how unfit you are to be the choosers of your own condition. You cannot foresee what that person, or thing, or place will prove to be for you, which you so eagerly desire; for all you know, it may be your undoing, or the greatest misery that ever befell you. Many a person has cried with Rachel, "Give me children or else I die," (Gen 30:1) and has then died by the wickedness and unkindness of those very children. Many a person has been violent in their desire for a husband or a wife, who afterwards broke their heart or proved a greater affliction than any enemy they had in the world. Many a person has been eager for riches, prosperity, and advancement, only to be ensnared by them to the damnation of their soul. Many a person has been earnest for some office, dignity, or place of trust, which only increased their sin and misery.
It is flesh and self that eagerly desires things against the will of God, and nothing is so blind and partial as self and flesh. You would not think your child a competent judge of what is best for him; you make your own understanding, not his desires, the rule by which you deal with him and determine his welfare. Are you more fit to choose for yourselves in relation to God than your child is in relation to you? Either you take God for your Father, or you do not. If you do not, do not call him Father, and do not hope for mercy and salvation from him. If you do, is he not wise and good enough to dispose of you, to determine what is best for you, and to choose for you?
Direction 9. Remember that one of the greatest plagues on this side of hell is to be given up to our own desires, and that by your eagerness and discontents you provoke God to give you up in just this way. "So I gave them up to their own heart’s lust, and they walked in their own counsels: O that my people had hearkened to me!" (Ps 81:12) "Wherefore God also gave them up to uncleanness, through the lusts of their own hearts." (Rom 1:24, 26) "For this cause God gave them up to vile affections." "And even as they did not like to retain God in their knowledge, God gave them over to a reprobate mind, to do those things which are not convenient." (Rom 1:28)
God may give you what you so eagerly desire just as he gave "Israel a king, even in his anger." (Hos 13:10, 11) Or as he gave the Israelites "their own desire, even flesh which he rained upon them as dust, and feathered fowls as the sand of the sea, they were not estranged from their lusts: but while their meat was yet in their mouths, the wrath of God came upon them, and slew the fattest of them." (Ps 78:27, 29–31) "They lusted exceedingly in the wilderness, and tempted God in the desert, and he gave them their request, but sent leanness into their souls." (Ps 106:14, 15)
God may say, ‘Follow your own lust; if you are so eager, take what you desire, take that person, that thing, that dignity you are so earnest for; but take my curse and vengeance with it. Never let it do you good, but let it be a snare and torment to you: "Let a fire come out of the bramble and devour you" (Judg 9:15).’
Direction 10. Be on your guard, lest concupiscence and partiality entice you to justify your sinful desires and take them to be lawful. (2 Thess 2:10–12) For if you do so, you will not repent of them, you will not confess them to God, nor beg pardon for them, nor beg help against them, nor use the means to extinguish them; instead you will cherish them, and be angry with all who oppose them, and love those tempters best who encourage them. How dangerous a condition is this?
And yet nothing is more common among sinners than to be blinded by their own affections and to think they have sufficient reason to desire what they do desire. Affection makes them remarkably clever and determined in deceiving themselves. It sets them to studying every argument that can be made in defense of their enemy, and casting a deceitful gloss over their cause. Test your desires carefully, as directed before.
Question 1: Is the thing you desire something God has commanded you to desire, or promised in his Word to give you, such as grace, Christ, and heaven? If so, desire it freely.
Question 2: But if not, why are you so eager for it, when at most you should have only a submissive, conditional desire after it?
Question 3: Worse still, is it not something you are forbidden to desire? If so, dare you excuse it?
Direction 11. Remember that concupiscence, or sinful desire, is the beginning of all sins of commission, and leads directly to the act. Theft, adultery, murder, fraud, contention, and all such mischiefs begin in inordinate desires. "Every one is tempted, when he is drawn away of his own lust and enticed: then when lust hath conceived, it bringeth forth sin; and sin when it is finished bringeth forth death." (Jas 1:14, 15) By ‘lust’ he means any fleshly desire or will. Therefore when the apostle forbids "gluttony and drunkenness, chambering and wantonness, strife and envying," he strikes at the root of all in this one word: "make no provision for the flesh to satisfy its lusts," that is, its wills. (Rom 13:13–14)
Direction 12. Strip away the deceiving mask, and see what you so eagerly desire as it truly is. What will it be to you at the last? It is now in its spring or summer, but see it in fall and winter. It is now in its youth, but see it withered to skin and bone in its decrepit age. It is now in its clean and fine adornments, but see it in its uncleanness and its plain dress. Cure your self-deceit, and your desire is cured.
Direction 13. Do not promise yourselves long life, but live as dying men, with your grave and burial shroud always before your eyes; and it will cure your thirst after the creature when you feel how short a time you must enjoy it, and especially how near you stand to eternity. This is the apostle’s method: "But this I say, brethren, the time is short: it remaineth, that both they that have wives be as though they had none; and they that weep, as though they wept not; and they that rejoice, as though they rejoiced not; and they that buy, as though they possessed not; and they that use the world, as not abusing it (or as if they used it not): for the fashion of this world passeth away." (1 Cor 7:29–31) You will desire as if you desired not, when you clearly perceive how quickly the thing desired will pass away.
Direction 14. In all your desires, remember the account as well as the thing desired. Think not only of what is now within reach, but of what account you must render to God for it: "For to whom men give or commit much, of them they require the more." (Luke 12:48 Matt 25) Will you thirst after more power, more honor, more wealth, when you remember that you will have the more to give account of? Have you not already enough to answer for, unless you had hearts to use it better?
Direction 15. Keep all your mercies to their holy use; do not let the flesh consume them or gain anything from them through disordered appetite. This will powerfully extinguish disordered desire itself. We are in little danger of being too eager after spiritual and holy things for God’s glory. Resolve, therefore, that everything you have shall be sanctified to God and used for him, not at all to satisfy any disordered craving of the flesh, and the flesh will give up its pleading when it finds it gains nothing by it.
You are able to do a great deal in this way if you are willing. If you cannot immediately suppress the desire, you can immediately resolve to deny the flesh the thing desired (as David refused to drink the water even though he longed for it, 2 Sam 23:15, 17), and you can deny it the more of what you already possess. If you cannot stop being thirsty, you can stop yourself from drinking. If you cannot stop feeling hungry, you can stop yourself from eating whatever is forbidden or unfit. Eve may have felt appetite for the forbidden fruit, yet she could have commanded her hands and teeth and left it alone.
If you cannot otherwise cool your desire for extravagant clothing, wear something plainer than you otherwise would, deliberately to rebuke and check that desire. If you cannot otherwise quench covetous desires, give all the more to the poor in order to cross that desire. You cannot say the outward act is beyond your power, if only you are willing.
Direction 16. When your desires grow too eager, recall the mercies you have already received and currently possess. Has God done so much for you, and are you still clamoring for more, even for things that are unnecessary, when you ought to be giving thanks for what you have? This ungrateful greediness is an ugly sin. Think of what you already have for soul and body, possessions and friends. Will all this not quiet you, even this together with Christ and heaven, unless some further lust or fancy is satisfied, and unless God indulges your sick desires?
Direction 17. Understand how little it would satisfy you even if God gave you everything you now eagerly desire. When you had it, it would not settle you or live up to your expectations. You imagine it would make you happy and be extraordinarily sweet, but it deceives you. You are promising yourself something you cannot define, and therefore desiring something you cannot define. It would be to you like a feast dreamed in sleep, which leaves you hungry in the morning.
Direction 18. Remember always that the greatest harm a created thing can do you is to be loved and desired too much, and it is never so dangerous to you as when it appears most desirable. If you kept this in mind, you would be thrown into the greatest fear and caution the moment anything earthly was presented to you as very pleasing and attractive.
Direction 19. Consider that your desires do nothing but make into a burden and a misery those needs which would otherwise be no burden at all. Thirst makes the lack of drink a torment that is no pain or trouble to another person. The lustful person is ready to die for love of some desired companion whom nobody else cares for, and nobody else is the worse for lacking. A proud, ambitious Haman thinks himself ruined if he is not honored, and is tormented at being reduced to the ordinary condition of a farmer, while many thousands of honest, contented men live cheerfully and peacefully in an equally humble condition. It is men’s own desires, not their real needs, that torment them.
Direction 20. Remember that when all is said and done, if God loves you he will be the one to choose, and he will not grant your sick desires but will correct you for them until they are cured. If a child cries for a knife, or for unwholesome food, or for anything that would harm him, you will quiet him with the rod if he does not stop. And it is a sign that some rod of God is near you when you are sick with longing for this or that and will not be quiet and content unless your fancy and craving are indulged.
Title 4. Directions against Sinful Mirth and Pleasure
Mirth is sinful in the following cases.
1. When people rejoice in what is evil: for instance, in harm done to others, in someone’s sin, in the suffering of God’s servants, in the affliction of the church, or in the success and prosperity of the enemies of Christ or of any evil cause. This is one of the greatest sins in the world and one of the clearest marks of wickedness, when wickedness itself is what they rejoice in. Laertius reports in his life of Zeno that the Stoics called the wise severe, because they neither speak for the sake of pleasure themselves nor accept what others say for the sake of pleasure; and that others are called severe in the sense in which a harsh wine is called severe, the kind used for medicine rather than for drinking.
2. When mirth is ill-timed or directed at an unsuitable object: for instance, being merry in the time and place of mourning; feasting when we ought to fast; or when an unsanctified, miserable soul, still in the power of sin and Satan and near to hell, is absorbed in mirth.
3. Mirth is sinful when it tends toward the committing of sin or is conducted through sin: as making merry with lies and fables, with tempting, unnecessary, time-wasting dances, plays, or recreations; with the slander or abuse of others; or with drunkenness, gluttony, or excess.
4. Mirth is sinful when it hinders duty and renders the soul unfit for the exercise of whatever grace its condition most requires. This is the case when it obstructs a sinner’s conviction and humiliation, resists the Spirit of God, drowns the calls of grace and the voice of conscience so they cannot be heard, banishes all sober reflection on matters we should most consider, and will not permit men to think steadily and soberly about God, themselves, their sin and danger, death and judgment, and the life to come. Such mirth makes the soul more unfit to receive reproof, to profit from a sermon, or to call upon God.
This intoxicating mirth that shuts out reason, silences conscience, laughs at God, jokes at damnation, stupefies the mind, and maddens men in the very matters where they should most display their wisdom, this mirth is the devil’s sport, the sinner’s misery, and the wise person’s pity. Of this Solomon speaks: "I said of laughter it is mad, and of mirth, what doth it?" (Eccl 2:2) "As a madman who casteth firebrands, arrows, and death, so is the man that deceiveth his neighbour, and saith, Am I not in sport?" (Prov 26:18–19) "It is a sport to a fool to do mischief." (Prov 10:23)
5. But mirth is most hideously odious when it is blasphemous and profane: when incarnate devils make themselves merry by jesting and mocking at Scripture, at the judgments of God, or at the duties of religion, or by uttering horrid oaths and cursed speech against the servants of the Lord.
Direction 1. First, make sure you are a person fit for mirth, and that you are not a miserable slave of Satan in an unregenerate, unholy, and unjustified state. "Delight is not seemly for a fool." (Prov 19:10) You would hardly think innocent games and sports fitting for a condemned criminal who must die tomorrow. An unregenerate, unholy person is certain to be damned whenever he dies; and if he does not believe this, he must deny that God or the Gospel is true. He is not certain to live another hour, and he is certain he will die before long. Now, if you have not thrown your reason away, tell me whether your reason can justify the mirth of such a person.
Do you ask, "What harm is there in being merry?" None at all for one who has cause to be merry and who rejoices in the Lord. But for a man to be merry on the road to hell, and so close to it; for a man to be merry before his soul is sanctified and his sin pardoned, or before he has sought these things with all his heart, this is harm, if folly and unbelief and contempt of God and his dreadful justice are any harm.
Hear the calls of God; abhor your sins; set your heart on heaven and holiness, and then God and conscience will allow you to be merry. Obtain a renewed heart and life, obtain the pardon of your sins, a title to heaven, and a readiness to die, and then your mirth will be reasonable and wise. Petrarch observed in his Dialogues (Book 2, Dialogue 119) that if anyone ought to weep at death, he was wrong to have laughed in life, seeing that death always loomed overhead, and that weeping, not far separated from that laughter, would inevitably follow it. Then your mirth will be honorable and warranted, as fitting as the joy of the lame man who was healed and went with Peter and John into the temple "walking, and leaping, and praising God." (Acts 3:8)
But it is a most pitiful sight to see an ungodly, unregenerate sinner laugh and sport and play and live merrily, as though he had no idea what evil is near him. It would draw tears from the eyes of a believer who knows him and thinks of where he is likely to dwell for ever. I recall a credible account of a man who lived not far from me, who in his profaneness was accustomed to wish that he could see the devil, and to whom at last the devil appeared in all his terror. At times the devil smiled at him; and the man used to say that he never seemed so ugly and terrible as when he smiled. The man was so frightened by it that he turned to a reformed life. So too, though a servant of the devil is never attractive, he never appears so ghastly as when he is most merry in his misery.
Direction 2. Yet do not destroy your nature through excessive grief, under the pretense that you have no right to be merry. For, 1. The very discovery of your misery places you in fairer hopes of mercy. 2. Many of God’s children live long without assurance of their justification, and yet should not therefore cast away all joy. 3. Even the unsanctified must maintain so much ease and quietness of mind as is necessary to preserve their natures, so that their lives may continue and they may wait on God until they obtain his grace. They above all people have reason to value their lives, lest they die and be lost before they are recovered. Therefore, just as they must not starve themselves by refusing food and drink, so their sorrows must not be such as may destroy their bodies (of which more shortly).
Direction 3. First settle the peace of your souls on solid grounds, and obtain such evidences of your special interest in Christ and heaven as will reasonably warrant you to rejoice. Then make it the work of your lives to rejoice and delight yourselves in God, and treat this as the chief part of grace and godliness, not as a small or optional matter. In that way, let all lawful and natural mirth be taken in, animated and sanctified by this holy delight and joy. Know that this natural, sanctified mirth is not only lawful, but a duty exceedingly fitting and becoming for a thankful believer on his way to everlasting joy.
This is the true method of rejoicing. Although, as I said, so much quietness may be maintained by the unregenerate as is needful to sustain life and health, and although the Gospel wherever it comes is tidings of great joy to those who hear it, yet no one can live a truly comfortable and merry life except in this method. Any mirth beyond what either sustains nature or meets mercy in one’s return to God will justly be charged with madness, and makes its possessor a more pitiful sight.
See my sermon preached at Paul’s, called "Right Rejoicing," and the earlier discussion in Chapter 3, Direction 13.
The first thing to be done, then, is to lay the groundwork of true mirth. This is accomplished by unfeigned repentance and turning to God through faith in Christ, becoming new creatures, a sanctified, peculiar people, and being justified and adopted as children of God. After that, by discerning upon sober examination the evidences and witness of all this in ourselves, so that we may know we have passed from death to life.
Although there are varying degrees both of grace and of the ability to discern it, some having but little holiness, others having little discernment of it in themselves, yet the least degree may afford much genuine comfort to the soul, though not so much as greater degrees of grace and clearer discernment may do.
With that foundation laid, our next endeavor must be to build upon it a settled peace of conscience and quietness of soul. Until we can attain joy, it is a great mercy to have peace and to be free from the accusations, fears, and griefs that belong to the unjustified. Peace, moreover, must be the more ordinary condition of soul to be expected in our frail state, rather than much joy.
Third, with peace thus settled, we must endeavor to rise up daily into joy, as our great duty and our great happiness on earth. The Scriptures frequently and earnestly command that we "Rejoice in the Lord always" and "Shout for joy, all that are upright in heart" (Ps 33:1 Phil 3:1 Phil 4:4 Deut 12:12 Deut 12:18 Deut 27:7). In this way, the one who "proveth his own work" may have "rejoicing in himself" (Gal 6:4), even in the "testimony of his conscience," of his own "simplicity and godly sincerity" (2 Cor 1:12). All believers should maintain and stir up this joy in themselves.
Fourth, alongside this rejoicing in God, our lawful and natural mirth must be taken in as something subordinate and sanctified. That is, we must advance our holy joy by means of natural mirth and cheerfulness, and through the comforts of our bodies in God’s lower mercies, promote the service and comfort of our souls. This is the proper place for such mirth to enter, and this is the true method of rejoicing.
Direction 4. Mark carefully the usefulness and tendency of all your mirth. If it is useful for fitting you to do your duty, and you intend it for that end, even if you do not always consciously observe that intention at the time, and if it tends to do you good or help you do good without greater harm or danger, then cherish and promote it. But if it tends to carry you away from God toward some creature, to unfit your soul for the duties of your station, and to draw you into sin, then avoid it as something harmful. Always keep in mind that the necessary support of nature must not be avoided by the good or the bad alike. A Christian who has any acquaintance with himself and with the work of holy watchfulness can discern the character of his mirth by its tendency and effects, and can tell whether it does him good or harm.
Direction 5. Be careful that the flesh does not defile your mirth by dropping in obscene or ribald talk, or by stirring up fleshly lust and sin. This will happen quickly if not carefully watched; holy mirth and cheerfulness is very apt to degenerate suddenly into sinful mirth.
Direction 6. Consider what your mirth is likely to prove to others as well as to yourselves. If it is likely to stir up sin in others or to offend them, you must be the more careful to avoid it in their presence, or manage it with greater caution. If it is needful to cheer up the drooping minds of those you are with, or to remove their prejudice against a holy life, you must give the more place to it. For mirth is good or bad according to whether it tends toward good or toward bad.
Direction 7. Never leave reason or godliness out of any of your mirth. Reject the mirth that makes a man a fool, or that plays the fool. Guard against that ungodliness which makes a man merriest when he is furthest from God, like the horse or ox that leaps and plays for gladness when it is unyoked and freed from its labor. Something of God and heaven should appear to be woven into all our mirth, to sweeten and sanctify it.
Direction 8. Watch your tongues in all your mirth, for they are very apt to take sinful liberties then. Mirth is to the tongue what holidays and play days are to idle scholars, who are glad of them as a time when they think they have liberty to gamble, fight, and behave badly.
Direction 9. If a word breaks out from yourself or your companions in mirth that wrongs others, whether as backbiting, evil speaking, jeering, scorning, or defaming, even of an enemy, rebuke it and cast it out as dirt or filth that has fallen into your dish or cup.
Direction 10. If profaneness intrudes, and someone makes merry with jesting at Scripture, religion, or slanders and scorns of godly persons, with a tendency to make religion hateful or contemptible: if they are people you may speak to, rebuke them with reverent seriousness that strikes them with fear. If they are not, show your abhorrence of it by turning your back and leaving the place and company of such devilish enemies of God. Do not be a silent or seemingly consenting witness to such hateful mirth against your Maker.
Direction 11. If the mirth of others in your company grows tasteless, frothy, foolish, wanton, impious, or otherwise corrupt, drop in some holy salt to season it, something serious and divine to check and repress it. For example, remind them of God’s presence, or recite such a text as Ephesians 5:3–4: "But fornication and all uncleanness or covetousness, let it not be once named amongst you as becometh saints; neither filthiness, nor foolish talking, nor jesting; which are not convenient: but rather giving of thanks."
Direction 12. If mirth grows immoderate and excessive and carries you away from God and duty by its sheer carnal pleasure, keep always at hand these considerations to repress it.
1.) Remember that God is present, and levity is not fitting in his sight.
2.) Remember that death and judgment are at hand, when all this levity will be turned to seriousness.
3.) Remember that your souls are still under a great deal of sin, need, and danger, and you have a great deal of serious work to do.
4.) Look at Jesus Christ, and remember the example he gave you on earth, whether he laughed, played, jested, or taught you immoderate or carnal mirth, and whether you are living as disciples of a crucified Christ.
5.) Think of the ordinary way to heaven as Scripture describes it: through many tribulations, afflictions, fastings, temptations, humiliations, sufferings, and mortifications. Consider whether a wanton, jesting, playful life resembles that path.
6.) Think of the course taken by the ancient and excellent Christians, who went to heaven through labor, vigils, fasting, poverty, and cruel persecutions, not through carnal mirth and sport.
7.) Think of the many pitiable objects of sorrow now abroad in the world: the millions of heathens and Mahometans and other strangers and enemies to Christ; the obstinate Jews; the papal tyranny and usurpation; the divided state of all the churches; and the profaneness, persecution, uncharitableness, contentions, mutual reproaches, and revilings that make havoc for the devil among the members of Christ.
CHAPTER 13
DIRECTIONS AGAINST SINFUL HOPES
Hope is nothing but a desirous expectation. The directions given before against sinful love and desire may therefore serve against sinful hopes as well, except for the expecting part, that is, the expectation rather than the desire.
Hope is sinful in four ways: first, when it is placed ultimately upon a forbidden object, for example, hoping for some evil to yourself while mistaking it for good; hoping for felicity in the creature, or for more from it than it can give; hoping for harm to others, for the ruin of your enemies, for the hindrance of the Gospel, or for injury to the church of Christ. Second, when you hope for a good thing by evil means, hoping to please God or reach heaven by persecuting his servants, or by ignorance, superstition, schism, heresy, or any sin. Third, hoping without grounds for what God never promised. Fourth, hoping deceitfully for what God has declared he will never give. All these are sinful hopes. The last two I will not dwell on here, having treated them at length in many other writings.
Lord Bacon, in his Essay of Lies, asks: "Doth any man doubt that if there were taken out of men’s minds, vain opinions, flattering hopes, false valuations, imaginations, etc. but it would leave the minds of a number of men, poor shrunken things, full of melancholy and indisposition, and uncomfortable to themselves?"
Direction 1. Hope for nothing from God against faith or without faith, that is, for nothing he has said he will not give, nor for anything he has not promised to give or given you reason to expect. To hope for what God has told us he will not give, or for what his holiness and justice make it impossible for him to give, is to hope that God will prove a liar, or unholy, or unjust, which is a wicked and blasphemous form of hope. Such are the hopes of countless ignorant and ungodly people who hope to be saved without regeneration, without true holiness of heart or life, and who hope to be saved in willful impenitence or beloved sins.
They hope God forgives sins they do not hate and will not forsake. They hope that reciting some words of prayer, or performing what they call a good work, will save them, even without the Spirit of Christ. Or they hope to be saved while remaining unsanctified, because they are not as bad as some others and do not live in any notorious, disgraceful sin. All these believe the devil, who tells them that an unholy person may be saved, and they believe the Gospel to be false when it says, "without holiness none shall see the Lord" (Heb 12:14).
They hope that God will prove unholy, unjust, and false in order to save them, and yet they call this hoping in God. Hope for what God has promised, and do so freely; but do not hope for what he has said he will not do, and has indeed declared cannot be. (John 3:3, 5)
Direction 2. When you hope for any evil toward others or toward yourself, remember how monstrous a thing it is to make evil the object of your hope, and how such hopes are nothing but your hastening toward chosen misery, contradicting themselves. For you hope for it as though it were good. To be greedy for evil on the assumption that it is good shows the folly of one who will not test the objects of his hopes. It is like a sick man who longs and hopes for something that will kill him if he takes it. So sinners hope for the poisoned bait.
Direction 3. Understand how much of the root of worldliness consists in your worldly hopes. Poor worldlings have little in their possession to delight in, yet they sustain themselves on the hope of more. Many a covetous or ambitious wretch, who never reaches what he desires, still lives on the hope of it. It is hope that sets men to work and keeps them laboring in the service of the world, the flesh, and the devil, just as divine hope sets men to work and keeps them laboring for heaven, for their souls, and for Jesus Christ. And many a hypocrite who sacrifices much for his religion still reveals his rottenness by clinging to worldly hopes, and going no further in religion than will leave those hopes intact.
Direction 4. Has not the world deceived everyone who has hoped in it to this day? Consider what has become of those people and their hopes. What has the world done for them, and where has it left them? Will you place your hope in that which has already deceived so many generations?
Direction 5. Remember that your worldly hopes are a sin so fully condemned by natural reason that you are left utterly without excuse. You know with certainty that you must die. You know how vain the world will be to you then, and how little it can do for you, and yet you are still hoping for more of it.
Direction 6. Consider that the world declares its own vanity in the very hopes of worldlings. It is forever drawing them forward by hope and never giving them satisfaction or contentment. Nearly all the pleasure in a worldling’s life consists in his hopes. The very thing he hopes for does not prove as sweet in possession as it was in his hopes. A life of hoping, and still hoping, for what he will never attain, that is the worldling’s life.
Direction 7. Turn your souls to those blessed hopes of life eternal, which have been sent to you from heaven by Jesus Christ, set before you in the holy Scriptures, and proclaimed to you by the messengers of grace. Does God offer you sure, well-grounded hopes of living forever in his joy and glory? And do you neglect them, lying instead in hope of a felicity in the world that cannot be attained, and that would give no true contentment even if attained? This is more foolish than to exhaust and impoverish yourself in hope of finding the philosopher’s stone while refusing a kingdom that is freely offered.
Title 6. Directions against Sinful Hatred, Aversion, or Backwardness toward God
The hatred of God and backwardness toward his service, which is the chief part of this sin, is to be cured by the directions in the first chapter, in the same way that a state of wickedness is cured. More will be said later regarding the worship of God, and Chapter III, Direction 11 also contains the cure. Here I add only a few directions addressed to a God-hating generation.
Direction 1. The first thing you must do is recognize that this is your sin. For you are confident that you love God above all, while in fact you hate him above all, even above the devil. You will readily confess that such hatred is horrid wickedness wherever it is found, and well deserves damnation. Be careful that your own confession does not judge you.
Remember, then, that we are not speaking about the bare name. I know that God’s name is most honored and the devil’s name is most hated. Nor is it everything in God that is hated. No one hates his mercy and goodness as such, nor is it everything in the devil that is loved: no one loves his hatred of mankind or his cruelty in tormenting people. But the holiness of God, which is what people must receive the image of and be conformed to, is hated by the unholy. And the devil’s unholiness, along with his friendship toward human sin and sensuality, is loved by the sensual and unholy. This hatred of God, and love of the devil, one would think you might easily perceive.
1. In that you would rather God were not so just and holy, you would rather he had never commanded you to be holy, but left you to live as your flesh would have you. You would rather God were indifferent to your sins and gave you leave to follow your lusts. That is the kind of God you want. But a God who will damn you unless you are holy, and unless you hate your sins and forsake them, is a God you do not like and cannot abide; you truly hate him.
2. For that reason you will not believe that God is such a holy, sin-hating God: because you would not have him be so. So you hate his very nature while believing that you love him, and you love only an idol fashioned from your own unholy imagination. As Tertullian says in the first chapter of his Apology, they would rather not know, because they already hate. "These things hast thou done, and I kept silence: thou thoughtest that I was altogether such a one as thyself: but I will reprove thee, and set them in order before thy eyes: now consider this ye that forget God, lest I tear you in pieces, and there be none to deliver." (Ps 50:21, 22)
3. You do not love the holiness of the Word of God, which bears his image. You do not love its strict and holy passages (John 3:3, 5; Luke 14:26, 33; Matt 18:3; Rom 8:13; Col 3:1–4; 2 Cor 5:17), and many more. You would rather have had a Scripture that left your ambition, covetousness, lust, and appetite at liberty, one that said nothing about the absolute necessity of holiness, and nothing against the ungodly.
4. You do not love the holiest ministers and servants of Christ, those who preach his holy Word most powerfully, or who obey it most carefully, seriously, and zealously. Your hearts rise against them when they bring in the light that shows your deeds and you to be evil (John 3:19–20). They are an eyesore to you. Your hearts do not rise nearly so much against whoremongers, swearers, liars, drunkards, atheists, or infidels as they do against these servants of God. What kind of people on the face of the earth are so hated by the ungodly in all nations and of every rank, treated so cruelly, and pursued so relentlessly, as the holiest servants of the Lord?
5. You do not love to call upon God in serious, fervent, spiritual prayer, praise, and thanksgiving. You grow weary of it quickly. You would rather be at a play, or gaming, or a feast. Your hearts rise against holy worship as a tedious, irksome thing.
6. You do not love holy, edifying discourse about God and heavenly things. Your hearts rise against it, and you hate and scorn it, as though all serious talk of God were mere hypocrisy, and God were to be banished from our conversation.
7. You cannot bear the serious, frequent thought of God in private. You would rather fill your minds with thoughts of your horses, hawks, fine clothing, honor, advancement, sports, entertainments, or worldly business and labor, so that not one hour in a thousand, or ten thousand, has ever been spent in serious, delightful thoughts of God, his holy truths, his works, or his kingdom.
8. You do not love the blessed day of judgment, when Christ will come with his holy angels to judge the world, to justify his accused and abused servants, to be "glorified in his saints, and admired in all them that do believe" (2 Thess 1:8–11). After all this, can you still be so blind as not to see that you are haters of God?
Direction 2. Know God better, and you cannot hate him; know especially the beauty and glorious excellence of that holiness and justice which you hate. Should the sun be darkened or disgraced because diseased eyes cannot endure its light? Must kings and judges all be corrupt, or change their laws and let every person do as they please, simply because criminals and licentious men would prefer it so?
Direction 3. Know God and holiness as they relate to you yourself, and you will recognize that they are not merely the best good for you, as the sun is to the world and as life and health are to your body, but your only good and happiness; and then you cannot help but love them. Your prejudice and false conceptions of God and holiness are the source of your hatred.
Direction 4. Cast away your cursed unbelief. If you do not believe what Scripture says about God and humanity, about the soul’s immortality, and the life to come, you will hate everything holy as a deceit and a needless troubler of the world. But once you truly believe the Word of God and the life everlasting, you will have a different heart.
Direction 5. Away with your beastly, blinding sensuality. While you are a slave to your flesh, your lusts, and your appetites, while that interest reigns in you, you cannot help but hate the holiness that opposes it, and hate the God who forbids it and tells you he will judge and damn you for it if you do not forsake it. This is the true cause of hatred toward God and godliness in the world.
God’s laws condemn the very life and pleasures of the fleshly person. Godliness is irreconcilable with concupiscence and the carnal interest. Lay aside your fleshly mind and interest, or, as surely as you are a human being, you will be judged and damned as an enemy to God.
Do you not feel that this is the cause of your enmity, that God sets you on unpleasing (holy) courses, will not let you gratify your flesh, but frightens you with the threats of hell? Salvian, in the fourth book of his work addressed to the Catholic Church, observed that nearly every word of God finds its own enemies, and that there are as many kinds of opponents as there are kinds of commandments: the greedy man is enraged if the Lord commands generosity, the spendthrift curses if he demands frugality, and the wicked call sacred speech their enemy. Jerome, commenting on Galatians 5, likewise observed, "I am not your enemy, but you are the enemy of truth."
"For to be carnally minded is death; but to be spiritually minded is life and peace: because the carnal mind is enmity against God: for it is not subject to the law of God, neither indeed can be: so then they that are in the flesh cannot please God. If ye live after the flesh ye shall die." (Rom 8:6–8, 13) "It is hard for thee to kick against the pricks." (Acts 9:5) "Woe to him that striveth with his Maker." (Isa 45:9) See also (Luke 19:27).
Direction 6. Draw near and accustom your soul to serious thoughts of God, for it is unfamiliarity that makes you more averse to him. We take less pleasure in the company of strangers than of close acquaintances. Reconciliation must be made by drawing nearer, not by keeping at a distance.
Direction 7. Study well the wonderful love and mercy God has shown to your soul in the redemption accomplished by Jesus Christ, in the covenant of grace, in all the patience he has exercised toward you, and in all his offers of mercy and salvation, entreating you to turn and live. Can you reflect on what God has done for you throughout your life, how patiently and mercifully he has dealt with you, and yet hate him, or hold your heart against him?
Direction 8. Do not judge God or holiness by the faults of any who have appeared holy. No more than you would censure the sun because thieves rob by its light, or because some people are nearly blind. God hates sin in them and in you, wherever he finds it. Judge God and holiness by his proper nature and true effects, and by the holy Scripture, not by the crimes of sinners whom he condemns, who, had they been more holy, would have offended less.
Direction 9. Come among the godly, try a holy life for a time, and do not judge it or those who practice it by the reports of the devil and wicked men. Malice will speak ill of God himself and of his holiest servants. Could anything worse be said than was said of Christ himself and his apostles? The devil was not ashamed to slander Job to God’s own face, claiming that a little trial of his flesh would turn him from his godliness. But those who draw near and put the ways and servants of God to the test find that the devil slandered them.
Direction 10. Remember your fast-approaching end, and how dreadful it will be to be found and judged among the malignant enemies of holiness. "And if the righteous be scarcely saved, where then shall the ungodly and the sinner appear?" (1 Pet 4:18) Then what would you give to be one of those holy ones whom you now hate, and to be judged as one who lived in that holiness your malignant heart could not endure? Then you will wish that you had lived and died as the righteous, that your latter end might have been like theirs.
CHAPTER 14
DIRECTIONS AGAINST SINFUL WRATH OR ANGER
As anger concerns the love of our neighbor, I will address it there; as it concerns the soul itself, I address it here. Anger is the rising of the heart in passionate displeasure against a perceived evil that would thwart or deprive us of some desired good. God gave us anger for good, to stir us to vigorous resistance of whatever, within us or outside us, opposes his glory, our salvation, or the real good of ourselves or our neighbors.
Anger is good when it is directed to that appointed end, in the right manner and measure. It is sinful, however, in the following cases:
1. When it rises against God or against something good, as though that thing were evil to us, as wicked men are angry at those who would convert and save them, who tell them of their sins, and who hinder them from their desires.
2. When it disturbs reason and prevents us from judging things rightly. Bias, as Diogenes Laertius reports him, said that two things above all are opposed to good counsel: anger and haste.
3. When it casts us into unseemly conduct, or causes or disposes us toward sinful words or actions, when it inclines us to wrong another by word or deed, and to do as we would not wish to be done by.
4. When it is mistaken and without just cause.
5. When it is greater in measure than the cause allows.
6. When it unfits us for our duty to God or to other people.
7. When it tends to diminish love and brotherly kindness, and to hinder any good we ought to do for others, and far more when it breeds malice, revenge, contention, and quarrelsomeness in communities, or oppression of those beneath us, or dishonoring of those above us. Read Seneca’s On Anger, and be ashamed to come short of a heathen.
8. When it lingers too long and does not cease when its lawful work is done.
9. When it is selfish and carnal, stirred up for the sake of some carnal interest and used merely as a means to a selfish, carnal, sinful end. Such is the anger that rises only because someone has crossed your pride, your profit, your amusements, or any other fleshly desire.
In all these forms, anger is sinful.
Meditative Directions against Sinful Anger
Direction 1. Remember that immoderate anger is an injury to humanity and a rebellion against the rule of reason. It acts without reason and against reason. In a human being, all passions ought to be subject to reason. The suppression and dethroning of reason is the misery of madness and the crime of drunkenness. Sinful anger is a brief madness or drunkenness. Remember that you are a human being, and refuse to subject yourself to a brutish fury.
Direction 2. Sinful anger is also against the government of God, for God governs the rational powers first, and the lower faculties through them. If you destroy the king’s officers and judges, you oppose the king’s government. Is a person in a passion, having silenced his own reason, fit to obey the commands of God?
Direction 3. Sinful passion is a pain and a sickness of the mind. Would you love or cherish your own disease or pain?
Do you not feel yourself in pain and disordered while it is upon you? I do not think you would take all the world in exchange for living continually in that state. If you were perpetually so, what good would you be for anything? What could you enjoy? What contentment would your life give you? If a long-lasting pain is so terrible, a short one is no more lovely. Do not willfully keep so troublesome a sickness in your mind.
Direction 4. Observe also what an enemy anger is to the body itself. It inflames the blood, stirs up diseases, and produces such bitter displeasure in the mind that it tends to drain the strength of nature. It has driven many into acute illnesses and many into chronic ones, which have proved fatal. And how uncomfortable a kind of death that is!
Direction 5. Observe how unlovely and displeasing anger makes you to those who see you. It deforms the face and removes the attractive sweetness that appears in a calm and loving temper. If you were always so, would anyone love you? Would they not go out of your way, if not lay hands on you, as they do with something wild or mad? You would hardly wish to have your portrait painted in your fury, before the scowling wrinkles and inflamed color have faded and left your face its natural attractiveness. Do not love what makes you so unlovely to everyone else.
Direction 6. You should love anger the less because it is a harmful passion, and an enemy to love and to the good of others. You are never angry without being inclined to hurt those who angered you, if not all others who stand in your way. It puts harmful thoughts into your mind and harmful words into your mouth, and it inclines you to strike or to do some mischief. No one loves a creature that hurts. Avoid so destructive a passion.
Direction 7. What is more, observe where anger tends: if it were not stopped, it would move toward the very ruin of your brother, and end in his blood and your own damnation. Anger has murdered or destroyed many thousands. It has caused wars and filled the world with blood and cruelty. Should your heart give such a fury welcome?
Direction 8. Consider how much other sin immoderate anger inclines people to. The great crime of drunkenness is that a man who has lost self-government becomes liable through it to any wickedness, and the same is true of immoderate anger. How many oaths and curses does it produce every day? How many rash and sinful actions?
What villainy has anger not committed? It has slandered, abused, reproached, falsely accused, and injured many thousands. It has murdered, and ruined families, cities, and states. It has made parents kill their children, and children dishonor their parents. It has made kings oppress and murder their subjects, and subjects rebel and murder kings. What a world of sin is committed by sinful anger throughout all the world! It would be endless to give you instances. Even David was once drawn by anger to plan the murder of Nabal’s whole family. Its effects ought to make it odious to us. Seneca writes in On Anger that it is the mark of true greatness not to feel that one has been struck: the person who does not grow angry stands unshaken by the injury, while the person who does grow angry has already been moved.
Direction 9. Anger is worse still in that it does not allow a man to sin alone, but stirs up others to do the same. Wrath kindles wrath, as fire kindles fire. The odds are high that when you are angry you will make others angry, or discontented, or troubled by your words and deeds, and once that has happened, you have no power to moderate them. You do not know what sin it may draw them into. Anger is the devil’s bellows, kindling the corruptions of others and setting hearts, families, and kingdoms in flame.
Direction 10. Observe how anger unfits you for any holy duty, for prayer, meditation, or any communion with God. A gracious soul should be very reluctant about anything that makes it unfit to speak to God or to be employed in his worship. If you were to approach prayer or other worship in your maddened passion, might not God say, as the king of Gath said of David, "Have I need of madmen?" Indeed, anger unfits the whole family, or church, or society it enters for the worship of God. Is a household fit for prayer when wrath has muddied and disturbed their minds? And beyond the household, it divides Christians and churches, and causes confusion and every evil work.
Direction 11. Anger is a great dishonor to the grace of God when a servant of his shows the world that grace is of so little force and effectiveness, that it cannot govern a raging passion, nor even keep a Christian sober; that it fills the soul with no more patience, no more fear of God, no more self-government. Do not wrong God this way by dishonoring his grace and Spirit.
Direction 12. Anger is a sin against conscience, one that almost everyone repents of and disowns when they come to themselves again, and it is nothing more than a preparation for later sorrow. What we know in advance we must repent of afterward should be prevented and avoided by those who do not choose shame and sorrow for themselves.
Objection 1: "But," you will say, "I am by nature hasty and choleric, and I cannot help it."
Answer: A choleric nature may strongly incline you toward anger, but it cannot compel you to sin. Reason and will can still command and master passion, if they do their work. And when you know your disease and your danger, you must watch all the more carefully.
Objection 2: But the provocation was so great that it would have angered anyone, who could help it?
Answer: It is your weakness that makes you think any provocation can be great enough to discharge a person’s reason and license breaking the laws of God. What you call so great would have been small or nothing to a prepared mind. You should rather say, "God’s majesty and dreadfulness are so great that I dared not offend him for any provocation." Has not God given you far greater cause to obey than any person can give you to sin?
Objection 3: But anger comes on so suddenly that I have no time for deliberation to prevent it.
Answer: Do you not still have reason? And should it not be as ready to rule as passion is to rebel? Stop passion at the very first stirring, and take time for deliberation.
Objection 4: But it is brief, and I am sorry for it when it is over.
Answer: If it is evil, even the briefest instance is a sin to be avoided. And when you know beforehand that you must be sorry afterwards, why will you breed your own sorrow?
Objection 5: But there is no one who will not be angry sometimes, not even the best of you.
Answer: A sin is never the better for being widely committed. And yet, if you live where grace is not a stranger, you may see many people who will not be angry easily, frequently, or furiously, and who do not disgrace themselves in anger by verbal abuse, cursing, swearing, or foul language, or doing wrong to anyone.
Objection 6: Does not the apostle say, "Be angry and sin not: let not the sun go down upon your wrath" (Eph 4:26)? My wrath is gone before the sun sets, so I have not sinned.
Answer: The apostle never said that anger is only sinful when it lasts past sunset. Rather, entertain no sinful anger at all; but if you do, quench it quickly and do not continue in it. Do not be angry without cause, or beyond cause; and when you are angry, do not sin by uncharitableness or by any evil words or deeds, nor remain in even the most justified displeasure, but hasten to be reconciled and to forgive.
These reasons, taken to heart, may govern your anger.
Practical Directions against Sinful Anger
Direction 1. The principal help against sinful anger lies in rightly forming the habits of the soul: live as under the government of God, with a constant sense of his authority upon your heart, in the sense of that mercy which has forgiven you and still bears with you, under the power of his healing and assisting grace, and in the life of charity toward God and man. Such a heart is continuously fortified and carries its own defenses within it, just as a wrathful person carries his own kindling within him. There lies the main cause of wrath or of meekness.
Direction 2. Keep a humbled soul that does not overvalue itself; for humility is patient and does not magnify injuries, whereas a proud person takes everything said or done against him as heinous or intolerable. The one who thinks meanly of himself thinks meanly of everything said or done against him. The one who magnifies himself magnifies his provocations. Pride is a profoundly impatient sin; there is no pleasing a proud person without a great deal of tact, care, and diligence. You must approach them as you would approach straw or gunpowder with a candle: "Only by pride cometh contention" (Prov 13:10). "He that is of a proud heart stirreth up strife" (Prov 28:25). "Proud and haughty scorner is his name, who dealeth in proud wrath" (Prov 21:24). "Let the lying lips be put to silence, which speak grievous things proudly and contemptuously against the righteous" (Ps 31:18). Humility, meekness, and patience live and die together.
Direction 3. Guard against a worldly, covetous mind; for such a mind sets such store by earthly things that every loss, cross, or injury will be able to disquiet it and inflame its passion. Neither neighbor, nor child, nor servant can please a covetous person: every small trespass or check to his gain cuts him deeply and makes him impatient.
Direction 4. Stop your passion in its beginning, before it goes too far. It is easiest to moderate at first. Watch against the first stirrings of wrath and promptly command it down. Reason and will can do much if you will use them according to their power. A spark is more easily quenched than a flame, and this serpent is most easily crushed in the spawn.
Direction 5. Command your tongue, your hand, and your face, even if you cannot immediately command your passion. By doing so you will avoid the greatest part of the sin, and the passion itself will quickly be smothered for lack of an outlet. You cannot claim it is not within your power to hold your tongue or your hands if you choose. Do not only avoid the swearing and cursing that mark the profane: also avoid many words until you are more fit to use them, and avoid arguing back, quarrelling, and bitter, insulting, cutting speeches that tend to stir up the anger of others. Use instead mild and gentle speech that breathes love and tends to cool the heat that has been kindled. "A soft answer turneth away wrath: but grievous words stir up anger" (Prov 15:1). What soothes and appeases another will also greatly help to appease yourself.
Direction 6. At the very least, hold yourself quiet until reason has been heard and you have had time to deliberate. Do not act so hastily that you have not considered what you are saying or doing. A little delay will abate the fury and give reason time to do its work. "By long forbearing is a prince persuaded, and a soft answer breaketh the bone" (Prov 25:15). Patience will soften another’s wrath; and if you exercise it only long enough to pause until reason is awake, it will soften your own. The person who cannot stop himself long enough to reflect is driven by fury, not by reason.
Direction 7. If you cannot more easily quiet or restrain yourself, leave the place and the company. Then you will not be heated by contentious words, nor will you further provoke others by your contending. When you are alone the fire will die down. "Go away from the presence of a foolish man, when thou perceivest not in him the lips of knowledge" (Prov 14:7). You would not stand still and stir in a wasp’s nest after you have enraged them.
Direction 8. As a general rule, avoid extended talk, disputes, or dealings with angry people as far as you can without neglecting your duty; and avoid all other occasions and temptations to the sin. A person in danger of a fever must avoid what kindles it. Do not go among the infected if you fear the plague; do not stand in the sun if you are already too hot. Keep as far as you can from whatever most provokes you. Tauler counsels that when anyone argues stubbornly, you should grant him that his cause is just and give way to his obstinacy by keeping silent; in that way you will both remain quiet and undisturbed.
Direction 9. When you are alone, do not dwell in thought on injuries or on provoking things; do not let your mind feed on them. If you do, you will become your own devil and tempt yourself when no one else is tempting you, making your solitude as inflaming as any company, angering yourself by your own imaginations.
Direction 10. Keep vivid before your mind the exemplary meekness and patience of Jesus Christ, who calls you to learn to be "meek and lowly" (Matt 11:29); "who being reviled, reviled not again, when he suffered he threatened not; leaving us an example that we should follow his steps" (1 Pet 2:21, 23); and who has pronounced a special blessing on the meek, that "they shall inherit the earth" (Matt 5:5).
Direction 11. Live as in God’s presence; and when your passions grow bold, repress them with the reverent name of God, reminding them that God and his holy angels see you.
Direction 12. Look at others in their passion and observe how unlovely they make themselves, frowning faces, flaming eyes, threatening and devouring looks, and hurtful impulses, and ask yourself whether these are the patterns you most wish to follow.
Direction 13. Without any delay, confess the sin to those standing by, if easier means will not repress it. Take the shame on yourself promptly, shame the sin, and honor God.
This course is within your power if you are willing to take it, and it will be an excellent and effective remedy. Say to those with whom you are angry: "I find a sinful anger kindling in me; I am beginning to forget God’s presence and my duty, and I am tempted to speak provoking words to you, which I know God has forbidden me to do." Such an immediate disclosure of your temptation will break its force, and such a swift confession will stop the fire from spreading further. It will put your own honor at stake, your reputation for good sense and honesty, both of which will suffer if you go on in the sin immediately after confessing it. I know that prudence is required here, so that you do not make yourself ridiculous or harden others in their sinful provocations. But used with prudence and due caution, this is an excellent remedy, and you can apply it if you are not unwilling.
Direction 14. If you have let your passion break out and offend or wrong anyone, by word or deed, freely and promptly confess it to them, ask their forgiveness, and warn them to take heed of the same sin from your example.
This will do much to clear your conscience, to preserve your brother, to repair the harm done, and to strengthen your resolve against the sin in the future. If you are too proud to do this, then say no more about being unable: the problem is not that you cannot, but that you will not. A good heart will not regard this as too costly a remedy for any sin.
Direction 15. Go immediately, in whatever manner the place allows, to prayer, asking God for pardon and grace against the sin.
Sin cannot endure prayer and God’s presence. Tell him how readily your impatient heart kindles into sinful wrath, ask him earnestly to help you by his sufficient grace, and engage Christ in the cause, who is your head and advocate. Then your soul will grow obedient and calm. Just as Paul, when afflicted with a thorn in the flesh, prayed three times, as Christ did in his agony, so you must pray and pray again and again, until you find God’s grace sufficient for you (2 Cor 12:7–9).
Direction 16. Covenant with some faithful friend who is present with you to watch over you and rebuke your passions as soon as they begin to appear. Promise to receive that rebuke thankfully and without resentment.
And keep that promise, so that you do not discourage your friend from continuing. Either you are genuinely weary of your sin and willing to be rid of it, willing, that is, to do what you can against it, or you are not. If you are, you can do this much if you choose. If you are not, do not pretend to repent or to be willing to be delivered from your sin on any lawful terms, when in truth you are not.
Remember always that the harmful effects of this sin make it no trifling matter. "Be not hasty in thy spirit to be angry: for anger resteth in the bosom of fools" (Eccl 7:9). "He that is slow to anger is better than the mighty: and he that ruleth his spirit, than he that taketh a city" (Prov 16:32). "A wrathful man stirreth up strife; but he that is slow to anger appeaseth strife" (Prov 15:18). "The discretion of a man deferreth his anger, and it is his glory to pass over a transgression" (Prov 19:11).
CHAPTER 15
DIRECTIONS AGAINST SINFUL FEAR
The chief of my advice concerning this sin I have already given, in Chapter III, Direction XII. I will add something further here. Fear is a necessary passion in human nature, planted there to restrain us from sin, to drive us toward duty, and to prevent misery. The objects of fear are God, devils, men, lesser creatures, or ourselves. God must be feared as he is God, as he is great, holy, just, and true; as our Lord, King, Judge, and Father, and the fear of him is the beginning of wisdom. Devils must be feared only as subordinate to God, as executioners of his wrath; and so must men, beasts, fire, water, and other creatures be feared, and in no other way. We must discern and fear a danger well enough to avoid it. We are less inclined to fear ourselves, because we know that we love ourselves. Yet there is no creature we have greater cause to fear than our own folly, weakness, and willfulness in sin.
Fear is sinful in the following cases:
1. When it proceeds from unbelief or distrust of God.
2. When it ascribes more to the creature than is its due, as when we fear devils or men as great, or bad, or as our enemies, without due regard to their dependence on the will of God; when we fear a chained creature as if it were unchained.
3. When we fear God through mistake or error, fearing in him what is not in him or what is not to be feared, as when we fear that he will break his promise; that he will condemn those who keep his covenant; that he will not forgive the penitent who hate their sin; that he will despise the contrite; that he will not hear the prayers of the humble, faithful soul; that he will fail and forsake them; that he will not cause all things to work together for their good; that he will forsake his church; that Christ will not come again; that our bodies will not be raised; that there is no life of glory for the just, or no immortality of souls. All such fears as these are sinful.
4. When fear is so extreme in degree that it distracts us, hinders faith and prayer, and makes us melancholy, or when it hinders love, praise, thanks, and necessary joy, and tends not to drive us to God and to the use of means to avoid the danger, but rather to drive us from God, kill our hope, and leave us in despair.
Directions against Sinful Fear of God
Direction 1. Know God in his goodness, mercifulness, and truth, and it will banish sinful fear of him. Such fears proceed from ignorance or unbelief of these attributes, or from failing to consider and apply them to the situation at hand. "They that know thy name, will put their trust in thee."
Direction 2. Know God in Jesus Christ the Mediator, and come to God through him. Then you may have "access with boldness and confidence" (Eph 3:12). We have "boldness to enter into the holiest by his blood, by the new and living way which he hath consecrated for us, through the veil, that is to say, his flesh. And having an high priest over the house of God, let us draw near with a true heart in full assurance of faith" (Heb 10:19–22). The sight of Christ by faith should banish immoderate fear. "Be of good cheer, it is I, be not afraid" (Matt 14:27).
Direction 3. Understand the tenor of the Gospel and the freeness of the covenant of grace. There you will find abundant encouragement against everything that inordinate fear feeds on.
Direction 4. Engage as much as possible in love and praise; for love drives out tormenting fear. There is no fear in love (1 John 4:18).
Direction 5. Remember God’s particular mercies to you personally. They will persuade you that he will treat you kindly, since you have already found that he has done so. When Manoah said, "We shall surely die, because we have seen God," his wife answered, "If the LORD were pleased to kill us, he would not have received an offering at our hands, neither would he have shewed us all these things" (Judg 13:22–23).
Direction 6. Work to clarify your title to the promises and your particular interest in Christ. Otherwise doubt on that point will keep feeding and justifying your fears.
Direction 7. Consider what a horrible injury it is to God to think of him as you would think of the devil, as an enemy to humble, willing souls, a destroyer of those who seek him, and an adversary to those who diligently come to him. He is in truth the lover and rewarder of such souls. To think of God as evil, and to fear him on such false grounds, is a grave wrong against him.
Direction 8. Observe the sinfulness of your fear in its effects: how it drives you from God, hinders faith, love, and thankfulness, and discourages you from prayer, the sacraments, and every duty. It must therefore be pleasing to the devil and displeasing to God, and there is no way to plead for or justify it.
Direction 9. Notice how you contradict God’s own efforts in his Word and through his ministers. Do you find God driving people away from him, frightening off souls that would gladly be his? On the contrary, he prepares the way himself, reconciles the world to himself in Christ, and then sends his ambassadors in his name and stead to beseech people to be reconciled to God, to declare that all things are ready, and to compel them to come in (2 Cor 5:19; Luke 14:17; Matt 22:8).
Direction 10. Consider how you wrong others and keep them from coming home to God. When they see you terrified in the path of piety, they will flee from it as if enemies or robbers were lying in wait. If you walk fearfully, others will suspect there is quicksand. If you tremble when you enter the ship with Christ, others will conclude he is an unfaithful pilot or the vessel is leaking. Your fear discourages them.
Direction 11. Remember how you leave yourself without any comfort when you inordinately fear the one who alone can comfort you against all your other fears. If you fear your remedy, what will cure the fear of your disease? If you fear your food, what will cure your fear of hunger? If you fear the one who is most good and faithful, the friend of every upright soul, what will ease you of your fear of the wicked and the enemies of holy souls? If you fear your Father, who will comfort you against your foes? You throw away all peace when you make God your terror.
Direction 12. Yet take care, lest under this pretense you cast away the necessary fear of God, the kind proper to people in your condition, which drives them out of sin and false security to Christ, and which the truth of his warnings requires. A senseless presumption and contempt of God is a far more dangerous sin.
Directions against Sinful Fear of the Devil
Direction 1. Remember that the devil is chained and entirely subject to the will and command of God. He could not touch Job, nor an ox, nor an ass of his, until he had permission from God. He cannot appear to you or harm you unless God permits it.
Direction 2. Work therefore to secure the love of God, and then you are safe. You then have God, his love, and his promise always to set against the devil.
Direction 3. Remember that Christ has conquered the devil, in his temptations, on the cross, through his resurrection and ascension. He "destroyed through death him that had the power of death, even the devil, that he might deliver them who through fear of death were all their lifetime subject to bondage" (Heb 2:14–15). The prince of this world is conquered and cast out by Christ. Will you then fear a conquered foe?
Direction 4. Remember that you are already delivered from the devil’s power and dominion, if you have been renewed by the Spirit of God. Let those who are still under his power be afraid of him, not the free and redeemed ones of Christ. On the day he converted you, God delivered you from a calamity a thousandfold greater than any sight of the devil would be; and having been saved from the devil’s greatest malice, you should not overfear what is lesser.
Direction 5. Remember what an injury it is to God, and to Christ who conquered the devil, to fear the devil while God is your Protector, except insofar as he is the instrument of God’s displeasure. To fear the devil in any other sense is as much as to say: I am afraid the devil may prove too strong for God, or that God cannot deliver me from him.
Direction 6. Remember how you honor the devil by fearing him, and how you please him by that very honor. Will you not be horrified to honor and please such an enemy of God and of yourself? This is precisely what the devil wants, to be feared in the place of God. He glories in it as part of his dominion. Just as tyrants rejoice to see men fear them as those who can destroy them at will, so the devil triumphs in your fears as his own honor. When God rebukes the idolatry of the Israelites, it is because they feared their idols of wood and stone. To fear them showed that they took them for their gods.
Direction 7. Consider that it is foolishness to be immoderately afraid of something that has never happened to you and almost never happens to anyone, that is, any terrible appearance of the devil. You have never seen him, and you will hear of only very few in any age who have done so, apart from witches. This fear is therefore irrational, the danger being utterly improbable.
Direction 8. Consider that if the devil should appear to you, even carrying you to the top of a mountain, or the pinnacle of the temple, and speaking to you with blasphemous temptations, it would be no more than what your Lord himself submitted to, who was still the dearly beloved of the Father (Matt 4). One sin is more terrible than this.
Direction 9. Remember that if God should permit the devil to appear to you, it might turn to your very great advantage, by killing all your unbelief and doubts about angels, spirits, and the unseen world. It would make plain to you that there is indeed an unhappy race of spirits who envy mankind and seek their ruin. It would therefore more fully convince you of the evil of sin, the danger of souls, the need of godliness, and the truth of Christianity.
It is likely this is one reason the devil appears so little in the world, not only because it is contrary to God’s ordinary governance, who wills us to live by faith and not by sight, but also because the devil knows how much it would do to destroy his own kingdom by destroying unbelief, atheism, and spiritual carelessness, and awakening men to faith, fear, and godliness. The fowler or the angler must not come into sight, lest he spoil his game by frightening it away.
Direction 10. If it is only the spiritual temptations and harassments of Satan that you fear, remember that you have more cause to fear yourselves. He can only tempt you; and if you do not do more against yourselves than all the devils in hell can do to you, you will never perish.
If you are willing to accept and yield to Christ, you need not fear Satan or yourselves to excess. You are to begin and finish your warfare in the name and strength of Christ, under his command and protection. The Spirit that is in us is greater and stronger than the spirit that is in the world and that troubles us (1 John 4:4). "The Father that giveth us to Christ is greater than all, and none can pluck us out of his hands" (John 10:29). And "the God of peace will tread down Satan under our feet" (Rom 16:20). If it were in Satan’s power he would harass us daily, and we would never have escaped as far as we have; our daily experience tells us that we have a Protector.
Directions against the Sinful Fear of Men and Suffering at Their Hands
Direction 1. Ground your soul and your hopes on Christ; lay up your treasure in heaven; do not be a worldling who lives in hope of happiness in earthly things. Then you will be so far above the fear of men that you will know your treasure is beyond their reach and your foundation and fortress are safe from their assaults.
It is a base, hypocritical, worldly heart that makes you immoderately afraid of men. Are you afraid they will storm and plunder heaven? Or that they will cast you into hell? Or turn God against you? Or bribe or overawe your Judge? No, these are none of your fears. You are not even afraid that they might keep one of your prayers from prevailing with God, or that prison walls and chains might shut out God and his Spirit from you and force you from your communion with him. You are not afraid that they will forcibly rob you of one degree of grace, or heavenly-mindedness, or hope of the life to come.
If your fear is that they might hinder you from these things by tempting or frightening you into sin, which is the only harm they can do to your soul, then that very concern should make you cast away the fear of their hurting your body, since that bodily harm is their very means of tempting you to harm your soul. No, what you truly fear is their hurting your flesh, diminishing your property, depriving you of your liberty or worldly comforts, or taking your life. Does this not reveal how much your heart is still set on earth? How much unmortified worldliness and self-indulgence still lives within you? How much your heart is still false to God and heaven?
How that discovery should humble you, to find that you are still so little dead to the things of the world, and that the cross of Christ has so little crucified them to you; that your fleshly interest is still so powerful, and the interest of Christ and heaven so weak; that God does not seem enough for you, and you cannot take heaven alone as your portion, but are so afraid of losing earth. Search at once into the depths of this corruption in your heart. Lament your worldliness and hypocrisy, work it out, set your heart and hopes above, be content with God and heaven alone, and then this inordinate fear of men will have nothing left to feed on.
Petrarch puts the same thing in verse: all who are yours, O Christ, overcome their torments by bearing them; what they cannot remove, they are able to endure. For such as these, to have lost life is to enjoy it, and to have suffered is to have conquered. And he adds that an appeal to the eternal tribunal of the righteous Judge always lies open, for that Judge is accustomed to overturn what has been wrongly decided.
Direction 2. Set God against man: his wisdom against their scheming, his love and mercy against their malice and cruelty, his power against their weakness, his truth and omniscience and righteousness against their slanders and lies, his promises against their threats. If after all this you are still immoderately afraid of man, you must confess that to that degree you do not believe in God. If God is not wise enough, good enough, just enough, and powerful enough to save you as far as it is best for you to be saved, then he is not God. Away with atheism, and then fear not man.
Direction 3. Remember what manner of creature this man is that you are afraid of. He is a bubble raised up by Providence to be tossed about the world, so that God may honor himself through him or upon him. He is the mere product of his Maker’s will. His breath is in his nostrils. He is hastening to the dust, and on that day his worldly hopes and thoughts perish with him. He is a worm that God can in one moment tread into the earth and into hell. He is a dream, a shadow, a dry leaf or a wisp of chaff blown about the world for a time (Job 13:25; Ps 1:5–6; Ps 68:2; Ps 73:20; Job 20:8). He is, even at the height of his pride and fury, just about to drop into the grave. That same man, or all those men you now fear, will most certainly one day lie rotting in the dust and hidden in darkness, lest their ugly sight and stench become an offense to the living.
Where are all the proud ones who made such a commotion in the world not long ago? In one age they look great, boast of their power, rebel and usurp authority, are mad to be mighty rulers in the world, and persecute the ministers and people of the Lord, and in the next age, or the same, they are viler than the dirt. Their bodies are buried, or their bones scattered abroad, made a horror and a wonder to those who behold them. And is this a creature to be feared above God, or against God?
Victor of Utica says that Augustine himself died of fear when Genseric was besieging Hippo: that river of eloquence which had once run so abundantly through all the fields of the church was dried up by fear itself.
"Hearken to me, ye that know righteousness, the people in whose heart is my law; fear ye not the reproach of men, neither be ye afraid of their revilings. For the moth shall eat them up like a garment, and the worm shall eat them like wool: but my righteousness shall be for ever, and my salvation from generation to generation." (Isa 51:7) "Cease ye from man whose breath is in his nostrils, for wherein is he to be accounted of?" (Isa 2:22) "Put not your trust in princes, nor in the son of man, in whom there is no help: his breath goeth forth, he returneth to his earth; in that very day his thoughts perish." (Ps 146:3–4)
When Herod was magnified as a god, he could not save himself from being devoured alive by worms. When Pharaoh was in his pride and glory, he could not save his people from frogs and flies and lice. God said to Sennacherib: "The virgin, the daughter of Zion hath despised thee, and laughed thee to scorn, and hath shaken her head at thee; whom hast thou reproached and blasphemed, and against whom hast thou exalted thy voice and lifted thine eyes on high?" O what a worm is man that you are so afraid of him!
Direction 4. Remember that human beings, like devils, are chained and dependent on God. They have no power except what he gives them, and can do nothing without his permission. And if God wills that it be done, he has promised that it will work for your good (Rom 8:28). Are you afraid, then, that God might do you good through them? If you saw a knife or lancet only in an enemy’s hand, you might fear it. But if you see it in the hand of a surgeon or a father, nature may flinch a little, yet reason forbids you to make much of it or to fear it beyond measure.
What if God permits Joseph’s brothers to bind him and sell him to the Amalekites, and his master’s wife to have him imprisoned? Is God not to be trusted through all of this to turn it to Joseph’s good? What if he permits Shimei to curse David, or the king to cast Daniel into the lions’ den, or the three confessors into the fiery furnace? Do you believe your Father’s will governs all things, and yet are you afraid of man? When Pilate boasted that he had power either to release or to crucify him, our Lord answered: "Thou couldst have no power at all against me, except it were given thee from above" (John 19:11).
Paul the Deacon records a parallel instance of this faith: when the Emperor Julian ordered Valentinian either to sacrifice to idols or to leave the army, Valentinian voluntarily withdrew. The man who had lost his commission for the name of Christ received, not long after, the empire in place of his persecutor.
I know you will say that you fear men only as God’s instruments, and that if you were certain of his favor and not first afraid of his wrath, you would not fear the wrath of men.
Answer: This very reply reveals how much harm is done by disobedience, by nursing your fears of God’s displeasure, and by hindering your own assurance of his love, since this becomes the cause, or at least the pretext, for so many further sins.
But if you truly fear men only as the instruments of God’s displeasure, consider these questions:
1. Why did you not fear God’s displeasure more before, when no danger from men was in view? God is never short of instruments to execute his wrath or his will.
2. Why do you not fear the sin that displeases him more than you fear the instruments, since those instruments could do you no harm apart from sin?
3. Why do you not fear them more as tempters than as afflicters? And why, in consequence, do you not fear their flatteries, enticements, and preferments, and your own prosperity, more than adversity, when prosperity draws you further into sin?
4. Why do you not fear hell more than anything man can do to you, since God threatens hell far more severely than any human penalty?
5. Why do you not turn chiefly to God for deliverance, but instead study how to pacify man? Why, with greater fear and care and diligence and compliance, do you approach the very people you are afraid of, if it is truly God you fear more than them? Repent and make your peace with God through Christ, and then be at rest. If it is God you fear, your first business is not with the creature but with God.
6. If you fear men only as God’s instruments, why does that fear not drive you to flee more cautiously from further guilt? Why does it instead lead you to stretch your conscience as far as you dare, and to venture as far as you dare upon God’s displeasure in order to escape man’s? Are these signs that you fear them only as instruments of God’s displeasure, or do you see how deceitful your heart is?
Men are indeed to be feared, but only in full subordination to God:
1.) As his officers, commanding us to obey him.
2.) As his executioners, punishing us for disobeying him.
3.) But not as Satan’s instruments, with God’s permission, afflicting us for obeying him, or punishing us without desert.
"For rulers are not a terror to good works, but to the evil. Wilt thou then not be afraid of the power? do that which is good, and thou shalt have praise of the same: for he is the minister of God to thee for good. But if thou do that which is evil, be afraid; for he beareth not the sword in vain: for he is the minister of God, a revenger to execute wrath upon him that doth evil." (Rom 13:3–4) The fuller exposition of this is in 1 Peter 3:10–17:
"For he that will love life, and see good days, let him refrain his tongue from evil, and his lips that they speak no guile: let him eschew evil, and do good; let him seek peace and ensue it. For the eyes of the Lord are over the righteous, and his ears are open to their prayers: but the face of the Lord is against them that do evil.
"And who is he that will harm you, if ye be followers of that which is good? But and if ye suffer for righteousness’ sake, happy are ye: and be not afraid of their terror, neither be troubled; but sanctify the Lord God in your hearts: and be ready always to give an answer to every man that asketh you a reason of the hope that is in you with meekness and fear. Having a good conscience, that whereas they speak evil of you, as of evil-doers, they may be ashamed that falsely accuse your good conversation in Christ. For it is better if the will of God be so, that ye suffer for well-doing than for evil-doing." See also (1 Pet 4:13–15).
When Socrates’ wife, lamenting him, said, "You will die unjustly," he answered, according to Diogenes Laertius, "Would you prefer I died justly?"
Direction 5. Either you fear suffering from men as guilty or as innocent, for evil-doing, or for well-doing, or for nothing at all.
If it is as one who is guilty and suffering for evil-doing, then turn your fears in the right direction: fear God and his wrath against sin, and his threats of a punishment far greater than men can inflict. Acknowledge the justice of what both God and man bring upon you.
But if it is as one who is innocent or suffering for well-doing, remember that Christ commands you to rejoice exceedingly, and remember that martyrs receive the most glorious crown. Will you be excessively afraid of your highest honor, gain, and joy? Believe what Christ has said, and you cannot be greatly afraid of suffering for him.
"Blessed are they which are persecuted for righteousness’ sake; for theirs is the kingdom of heaven. Blessed are ye, when men shall revile you, and persecute you, and shall say all manner of evil against you falsely for my sake. Rejoice and be exceeding glad, for great is your reward in heaven: for so persecuted they the prophets which were before you." (Matt 5:10–12)
Will you fear the very path of blessedness and exceeding joy?
Victor of Utica records that the seven brothers who suffered in Africa under Hunneric walked to their execution with such confidence that they might have been going to a banquet, singing, "Glory to God in the highest," and saying, "This is our day of vows, and more festive than any other solemn day. Behold, now is the acceptable time; behold, now is the day of salvation, when for the faith of the Lord our God we bear the punishment prepared for us, so that we may not lose the garment of the faith we have received." And the people cried aloud, "Do not fear, people of God, and do not dread the threats and terrors of present troubles, but let us die for Christ, as he himself died, redeeming us by his precious and saving blood."
Bucholtzer observes five boastings in Paul: he glories in weakness, in the cross of Christ, in a good conscience, in his afflictions, and in the hope of eternal life.
"Beware of men, for they will deliver ye up to the councils, and they will scourge you in their synagogues, and ye shall be brought before governors and kings for my sake, for a testimony against them. But take no thought, etc." (Matt 10:17–19)
You are permitted to beware of them, but not to be overtaken by fear or anxious thought about the matter.
"And ye shall be hated of all men for my name’s sake; but he that endureth to the end shall be saved. But when they persecute you in this city, fly to another." (Matt 10:22–23)
Flee, but do not fear them with any excessive fear.
"He that findeth his life shall lose it, and he that loseth his life for my sake shall find it." (Matt 10:39)
"Verily I say unto you, there is no man hath left house, or parents, or brethren, or wife, or children, for the kingdom of God’s sake, who shall not receive manifold more in this present time, and in the world to come, life everlasting." (Luke 18:29–30)
Can you believe all this and yet be so afraid of your own happiness? How much secret unbelief is exposed by our immoderate fears!
"Beloved, think it not strange concerning the fiery trial, which is to try you, as though some strange thing happened to you: but rejoice, inasmuch as ye are partakers of Christ’s sufferings; that when his glory shall be revealed, ye may be glad also with exceeding joy. If ye be reproached for the name of Christ, happy are ye; for the spirit of glory and of God resteth upon you: on their part he is evil spoken of, but on your part he is glorified. But let none of you suffer as an evil doer, yet if any man suffer as a Christian, let him glorify God on that behalf, wherefore let them that suffer according to the will of God, commit the keeping of their souls to him in well doing as unto a faithful Creator." (1 Pet 4:12–16, 19)
There is scarcely any point on which God has been pleased to be more full in the Holy Scriptures than the encouragement of his suffering servants against the fear of men, assuring them that their sufferings are the ground of their profit and exceeding joy, and therefore not of excessive fear.
Direction 6. Experience teaches us that people have never had such great joy on earth as when suffering for the cause of Christ, nor such great honor as when dishonored by others for his sake. How joyfully did the early Christians go to martyrdom, many of them grieved that they could not attain it. What comfort have Christ’s confessors found, beyond anything they had known before? And how honored now are the names and memories of those martyrs who died under the slanders, scorn, and cruelty of their persecutors. Even the Papists, who bloodily create more martyrs, nonetheless honor the names of the ancient martyrs by keeping festivals for them and venerating their shrines and relics. For God ordains it so, for the honor of his holy sufferers, that the very generation that persecutes the living saints will honor the dead, those who murder the saints they find alive will honor those whom their forefathers murdered.
As Bucholtzer says, idolatry has struck such deep roots in the world that it cannot be torn out; therefore the best course is to confess the faith and endure. Victor of Utica records that Genseric commanded that when Masculinus came to die, if he showed fear, he should be executed, so that he would die in shame; but if he stood firm, they should spare him, lest he win the glory of a noble martyrdom. His boldness thus saved his life. And though the envious enemy refused to make him a martyr, he could not strip him of his honor as a confessor.
"Woe unto you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! because ye build the tombs of the prophets, and garnish the sepulchres of the righteous: and say, if we had been in the days of our fathers, we would not have been partakers with them of the blood of the prophets (Matt 23:29–31)." Comfort and honor attend the pain and shame of the cross. "They departed from the presence of the council, rejoicing that they were counted worthy to suffer shame for his name (Acts 5:41)." "Paul and Silas sang praises to God at midnight in the prison and stocks (Acts 16:25)," when their backs were raw from the lash. It is recorded of certain Christians imprisoned by Julian that, as the Emperor passed by, they could not refrain from singing in his hearing, "Let God arise, and his enemies shall be scattered."
Direction 7. Love the holy image of God upon your souls more deeply, and you will welcome the great aids to holiness that suffering provides. Who does not find that adversity is safer and more profitable to the soul than prosperity, especially that adversity which Christ is pledged to bless to his servants, being endured for his sake? "We glory in tribulation also; knowing that tribulation worketh patience, and patience experience, and experience hope, and hope maketh not ashamed (Rom 5:3–5)." "God chasteneth us for our profit that we may be partakers of his holiness: now no chastisement for the present seemeth to be joyous, but grievous; nevertheless, afterward it yieldeth the peaceable fruit of righteousness unto them that are exercised thereby (Heb 12:10–11)." Moses "esteemed the very reproach of Christ greater riches than the treasures of Egypt: and therefore rather chose to suffer affliction with the people of God, than to enjoy the pleasures of sin for a season (Heb 11:25–26)."
It is but "now for a season, and if need be, that we are in heaviness through manifold temptations, that the trial of our faith being much more precious than of gold that perisheth, might be found unto praise, and honor, and glory at the appearing of Jesus Christ (1 Pet 1:6–7)." Who, knowing himself, does not feel the need of some affliction, to awaken him from drowsiness, quicken him from dullness, refine him from his dross, wean him from the world, help him mortify the flesh, and save him from the deceits of sin?
Direction 8. Remember that suffering is the ordinary road to heaven. Love heaven more, and your sufferings will feel lighter and your fear of them will diminish. When Anacharsis was asked which ship was the safest, he answered, according to Diogenes Laertius, the one that has come into harbor.
Christ has determined that "if any one come to him, and hate not his father, and mother, and wife, and children, and brethren, and sisters, yea, and his own life also, he cannot be his disciple: and whoever doth not bear his cross and follow him, cannot be his disciple: and whoever he be of you that forsaketh not all that he hath, he cannot be his disciple (Luke 14:26–33)." "In the world we shall have tribulation, but peace in him (John 16:33)." "Through much tribulation we must enter into the kingdom of God (Acts 14:22)." "If so be that we suffer with him that we may be also glorified with him. For I reckon that the sufferings of this present time are not worthy to be compared to the glory that shall be revealed in us (Rom 8:17–18)."
"Therefore we both labor and suffer reproach, because we trust in the living God (1 Tim 4:10)." In preaching the Gospel, Paul says he "suffered as an evil doer even unto bonds, but the word of God is not bound (2 Tim 2:9)." "I suffer these things," he says, "nevertheless I am not ashamed; for I know whom I have believed, and am persuaded that he is able to keep that which I have committed to him against that day (2 Tim 1:12)." "Yea, and all that will live godly in Christ Jesus shall suffer persecution (2 Tim 3:12)."
Our patience in suffering is a joy to our fellow believers, and so suffering is not something to be feared overmuch. "So that we ourselves glory in you in the churches of God, for your patience and faith in all your persecutions and tribulations that ye endure: a manifest token of the righteous judgment of God, that ye may be counted worthy of the kingdom of God, for which ye also suffer (2 Thess 1:4–5)." As Paulus Scaliger says, it is the mark of a philosophic mind to pluck from an enemy’s hatred something it may turn to its own good.
Therefore take God’s own conclusion: "Fear none of those things which thou shalt suffer: behold, the devil shall cast some of you into prison, that ye may be tried: and ye shall have tribulation ten days: be thou faithful unto death, and I will give thee a crown of life (Rev 2:10)." "And in nothing terrified by your adversaries, which is to them an evident token of perdition, but to you of salvation, and that of God: for to you it is given in the behalf of Christ, not only to believe on him, but also to suffer for his sake (Phil 1:28–30)." And shall we fear so great a gift?
Direction 9. Remember how small and brief the suffering will be, and how great and everlasting the glorious reward. It is but a little while before the pain and shame will all be past; but the glory will never pass. What is Stephen the worse now for his stones, or John the Baptist for being beheaded, or Paul for the bonds and afflictions that met him everywhere, or any holy martyr for the torment and death they endured? How completely the case is altered for them, now that God has wiped away all tears from their eyes! Are we so tender that we cannot bear a grief that lasts only for a night, when we know that joy will come in the morning?
"For this cause we faint not; but though our outward man perish, yet the inward man is renewed day by day. For our light affliction, which is but for a moment, worketh for us a far more exceeding and eternal weight of glory; while we look not at the things which are seen, but at the things which are not seen: for the things which are seen are temporal; but the things which are not seen are eternal (2 Cor 4:16–18)." "Cast not away therefore your confidence, which hath great recompence of reward. For ye have need of patience, that, after ye have done the will of God, ye might receive the promise. For yet a little while, and he that shall come, will come, and will not tarry. Now the just shall live by faith: but if any man draw back, my soul shall have no pleasure in him (Heb 10:35–38)."
Direction 10. When you have been delivered from the power of the devil himself, what reason have you to fear his instruments? Can they do more than he can? If Goliath the champion and the general have been overcome, the common soldiers are not likely to overcome us.
Direction 11. Are you better than your Lord? Look to him and be strengthened. "The disciple is not above his master, nor the servant above his lord. It is enough for the disciple that he be as his master, and the servant as his lord. If they have called the master of the house Beelzebub, how much more shall they call them of his household (Matt 10:24)." "Let us run with patience the race that is set before us, looking to Jesus the author and finisher of our faith, who for the joy that was set before him, endured the cross, despising the shame, and is set down at the right hand of the throne of God: for consider him that endured such contradiction of sinners against himself, lest ye be wearied, and faint in your minds (Heb 12:1–3)."
Direction 12. Be of good cheer: our Lord has overcome the world (John 16:33). Should we then be inordinately afraid of a conquered world? He overcame it by suffering, to show us that through suffering we shall overcome it. He triumphed over principalities and powers, greater than any mortal, "on the cross (Col 2:15)." Therefore "all power in heaven and earth is given to him (Matt 28:18)," and he is "Lord both of the dead and living (Rom 14:9)," and "is made head over all things to the church (Eph 1:21–22)." So, though "for his sake we be killed all the day long, and counted as sheep to the slaughter, yet in all these things we are more than conquerors, through him that loved us," that is, we win a nobler victory than if we had conquered them by the sword.
Direction 13. Think how small your suffering is compared to what your sin deserved, and to what your Lord has freely saved you from. Should someone resent a bloodletting done for their health, when they deserved to lose their life? Can you remember that hell was your due, and yet make much of anything that a fellow human being can do to you?
Direction 14. Remember that to sin through fear of suffering is to leap into hell in order to escape a little pain on earth. Are you afraid of men? Be more afraid of God. Is God not more terrible? "It is a fearful thing to fall into his hands: for he is a consuming fire (Heb 10:31; Heb 12:29)." Hear your Lord: "And I say to you my friends, be not afraid of them that kill the body and after that have no more that they can do: but I will forewarn you whom you shall fear: fear him which after he hath killed, hath power to cast into hell: yea, I say unto you, fear him." (Luke 12:4–5) If their fire is hot, remember that hell is hotter, and that God is both the best friend and the most dreadful enemy.
Direction 15. Remember that even here, from God himself, you will suffer at least as much if you escape suffering from men by sinning. If you sin to escape death, you will die anyway, and how quickly! How much more joyful it is to die for Christ than, a little while later, to unwillingly part with the very life you refused to give up for your Lord. And what anguish will gnaw at your guilty conscience, both in life and at death? Even in this life, then, fear would drive you into greater misery than the thing you feared.
Direction 16. Think of the dangerous effects of your immoderate fear. It is the path, as it was for Peter, to denying your Lord; indeed, it is the path to apostasy and to any wickedness that men may drive you toward by terror. If you were living where the Turk now tyrannizes over Christians, and you failed to overcome your fear, he could overcome your fidelity and make you turn from Jesus Christ. As Hincmar of Rheims wrote: one who holds back the truth for fear of punishment is a traitor to the truth. And that is the sin the apostle describes so terribly: "If we sin wilfully," that is, wilfully renounce our Lord, "after the acknowledgment of the truth, there remaineth no more sacrifice for sin, but a fearful looking for of judgment, and fire which shall devour the adversary." (Heb 10:26–27)
How many have been drawn by the fear of men to wound their consciences, neglect their duties, comply with sin, forsake the truth, dishonor God, and ruin their souls. Often in this life they end as poor Spira did, who by sinning through fear of man cast himself into a melancholy and self-destroying despair. Your fear is a more dangerous enemy to you than those you fear. "The fear of man bringeth a snare: but whoso putteth his trust in the Lord shall be safe. Many seek the ruler’s favor, but every man’s judgment cometh of the Lord." (Prov 29:25–26) Fear is given to preserve you; do not use it to destroy you.
Direction 17. Believe and remember God’s special providence, extending to every hair of your head, and the guard of angels he has set over you. "Are not two sparrows sold for a farthing? and one of them shall not fall on the ground without your Father: but the very hairs of your head are numbered: fear ye not therefore, ye are of more value than many sparrows." (Matt 10:29–30) If only this were truly believed and weighed! "The angel of the Lord encampeth round about them that fear him, and delivereth them."
Direction 18. Think what vile dishonor it does to God when his creature, mere breathing dirt, is feared more than he is. It is as if God were less able to help or harm you than a human being, and as though he were neither able nor willing to secure you, so that no one who suffers for his cause will ever be a loser by him. "And of whom hast thou been afraid or feared, that thou hast lied, and hast not remembered me, nor laid it to thy heart: have I not held my peace even of old, and thou fearest me not?" (Isa 57:11)
How did Daniel and the three confessors honor God? By fearing him more than the king and the flaming furnace, saying: "We are not careful to answer thee in this matter: if it be so our God whom we serve is able to deliver us from the burning fiery furnace; and he will deliver us out of thy hand, O king: but if not, be it known unto thee, O king, that we will not serve thy gods, etc." (Dan 3:16–18) Daniel would not stop praying three times a day openly in his house, for fear of the king or of the lions. "Moses forsook Egypt, not fearing the wrath of the king; for he endured as seeing him that is invisible." (Heb 11:27) "So that we may boldly say, The Lord is my helper, and I will not fear what man shall do unto me." (Heb 13:6)
Direction 19. Remember the dangers you have already been saved from, especially from sin and hell. Is an uncircumcised Philistine more invincible than the lion and the bear?
Direction 20. Remember the great approaching day of judgment, where great and small will stand equal before God, where God will right all who were wronged by men, and be the full and final avenger of his children. He has promised that, though "he bear long," he will "avenge them speedily." (Luke 18:7–8) Can you believe in that day and yet think it will not come soon enough to vindicate you fully and finally, and make reparation for all your wrongs? Can you not wait until Christ comes to judge the living and the dead? You will then be reluctant to be found among those who, like Saul, hurried to sacrifice because they could not wait for Samuel, whose souls "drew back, because they could not live by faith."
Petrarch presses the same point: it is as much better to be justly condemned than unjustly acquitted as an unpunished crime is worse than a punished one. In the one case justice is joined to the penalty, and a great good is set against a great evil; in the other there is the crime and its impunity together, and he does not know whether the impunity is not worse than the crime itself.
"Fear them not therefore; for there is nothing covered that shall not be revealed, and hid that shall not be known." (Matt 10:26) "Seeing it is a righteous thing with God to recompense tribulation to them that trouble you; and to you who are troubled rest with us, when the Lord Jesus shall be revealed from heaven with his mighty angels, in flaming fire taking vengeance, etc. When he shall come to be glorified in his saints, and admired in all them that believe." (2 Thess 1:6–10)
Direction 21. Remember that the fearful and unbelieving shall be shut out of heaven (Rev 21:8); that is, those who fear men more than God, and cannot trust him with their lives, but will rather risk his wrath through sin than endure the wrath of men.
Direction 22. Turn your fear of the instruments of the devil into pity and compassion for men in such lamentable misery. Pray for them, as Christ and Stephen did. Foresee now the misery that is close upon them. When you begin to be afraid of them, suppose that the day of judgment were this very moment, and consider how they will tremble at the bar of God, as conscience sometimes already makes some of them do at the hearing or thought of it, as Felix trembled before Paul. See them as those on the verge of being sentenced to the fire prepared for the devil and his angels, as in Matthew 25. Can you fear someone who stands on the brink of such endless misery, someone you should mourn and pity, as the ancient martyrs were accustomed to do? "What shall the end" of the persecutors be, "and where shall the ungodly sinners appear, if judgment begin at the house of God, and the righteous be saved with so much ado?" (1 Pet 4:17)
Concerning the fear of death, I have already written at length in my Treatise of Self-denial, in the Saints’ Rest, in The Last Enemy Death, and in The Believer’s Last Work. I therefore pass over that subject here.
See further at Part III, chapter 29, title 3, and chapter 30.
CHAPTER 16
DIRECTIONS AGAINST SINFUL GRIEF AND TROUBLE
Sorrow is planted in human nature to make us capable of government, by making us capable of punishment, so that we might be kept from sin by the fear or felt sense of what nature has made its penalty. The beginnings of pain are meant to help prevent the sin that would bring greater pain, to drive the wounded soul toward its remedy, and by sympathy to share in the misery of others.
Sorrow or grief, considered in itself, is neither morally good nor morally evil. It is a natural passion, evil in the sense that it hurts the one who experiences it, but good in that it is a fitting and serviceable means toward the universal and higher ends of government for which the Creator and Universal King has planted it in human nature. The same may be said of every capacity for pain and natural suffering.
Mere sorrow, considered simply in itself, is something God neither commands nor takes pleasure in. Sorrow for natural or penal harm is in itself no duty, but a necessary reaction. God does not command it; he threatens it. There is therefore no moral good in sorrow as such. God does not command or plead with people to feel when they are hurt, or to mourn under their torment; he will make them do it whether they are willing or not. Humble souls must therefore take care not to think they earn merit or please God merely by sorrowing for their sufferings.
Yet sorrow for misery may incidentally become a duty and a moral good in four ways. First, by the principle from which it proceeds, as when it is caused by belief in God’s threatenings, or when it flows from love to God. Second, for the matter’s sake, when it is the absence of God, his favor, his Spirit, and his image that one laments (which thus reflects some love to God), and not merely fleshly or sensory suffering. Third, in respect of its end, when we sorrow with the intent of driving our hearts to Christ our Savior, of valuing mercy and grace, and of being recovered to God. Fourth, in respect of its effect, when those foregoing ends actually become its fruits.
Sorrow for sin is a duty and a moral good. First, formally considered in itself: to be sorrowful for offending God and violating his law essentially contains within it a will to please God and obey his law. Second, it must also be made good by a right principle, that is, by faith and love. Third, by a right end, that it carry us from sin to God. Fourth, by a right guide and matter, that it be genuine sin, and not some mistaken, merely apparent sin, that we sorrow over.
Yet sorrow for sin, materially speaking, may be made sinful. First, by a wrong end and motive, when we mourn not for sin as sin, but because one sin hinders another, or because sin spoiled some wicked design. Second, by its effect, when it only sinks a person into despair or torment without at all separating him from the sin. Third, when it flows not at all from love to God or any desire to please him, but only from an unwillingness to be damned, so that sin is lamented only as a means of damnation. Such sorrow, though neither positively good nor positively evil, is evil in a privative sense. Even sorrow that profits nothing may testify to a just affection. Diogenes Laertius records that when Solon was rebuked for mourning his son with the words "You accomplish nothing," he answered, "That is precisely why I weep, because I accomplish nothing" (Diogenes Laertius, Lives of the Eminent Philosophers, book 1, section 63).
But it is the passion of grief in its excess that I must now address. Grief is in excess in the following ways:
1. When we grieve for something we ought not to grieve for at all, either for some good, or for something indifferent that is neither good nor bad. Both of these arise from an error of the mind.
2. When we grieve too much for something we may lawfully grieve for to some degree, that is, for our own afflictions and penal sufferings.
3. When we grieve too much for things we are bound to grieve for to some degree, namely:
1.) For our sin.
2.) For our loss of the favor of God, or of his grace and Spirit.
3.) For other men’s sin and suffering.
4.) For the sufferings of the church and the calamities of the world.
5.) For God’s dishonor.
That very old book of Hermes called Pastor (The Shepherd) shows strikingly how much grief and heaviness are enemies to Christianity and to the Spirit of God.
Though it is not easy to have too much sorrow for sin when we measure it by our estimate of the evil (we can hardly take sin for a worse evil than it is, and grieve for it accordingly), yet it is often all too easy to have too much sorrow for sin, or for any other evil, in the sheer intensity of the passion. Sorrow for sin becomes excessive in these ways:
1. When it distracts the mind, overturns reason, and renders us unfit for the ends that sorrow was meant to serve.
2. When it so shrouds and clothes the soul in grief that it makes us unable to see and consider God’s promises, to relish or believe mercy, to acknowledge benefits, to own the grace we have received or be thankful for it, to feel the love of God, to love him in return, to praise him, to think of him, or to call upon him; when it drives the soul from God, weakens it for duty, teaches it to deny mercy, and sinks it toward despair. All such sorrow is excessive and sinful, as is any sorrow that does more harm than good to the soul; for sorrow is not good in itself, but only as it does good or points toward something good.
Direction 1. Keep your hearts as true and close to God as possible, and make sure of his love, so that you may know you do not have an unregenerate and miserable soul to mourn over, and then all other grief becomes more curable and more tolerable. Once you can say that God is on your side, that Christ, the Spirit, and heaven are yours, you possess the greatest restorative against excessive grief that this world affords.
If you ask how this may be done, I answer that it is explained in its proper place. No wonder sorrow overwhelms a soul that lies in the chains of sin under the curse of God, as soon as an awakened conscience begins to feel its condition. Such a soul is most miserable when it feels the least sorrow, since some hope remains that sorrow may drive it home to Christ. If you have been a secure, unhumbled, carnal wretch, and God is now beginning to humble you by showing you your sin and misery, take care, as you value your soul, not to drive away necessary, healing sorrow and repentance on the pretext of avoiding melancholy or excessive grief. Your pain tends toward your hope of cure.
Direction 2. Do not reopen the wounds of conscience by renewed, willful, gross sin. Sin brings sorrow, especially if you have any living grace to feel it, just as falls and broken bones bring pain. Obey carefully if you would have peace.
Direction 3. Become well acquainted with the general grounds of hope in the mercy of God, the office and death of Christ, and the free and universal offer of pardon, grace, and life in the New Covenant. A great deal of grief dwells in many humbled souls through ignorance of these general grounds of comfort, and it would vanish if these were rightly known.
Direction 4. Understand well the true nature and use of godly sorrow, that it is only a means to higher grace, that it may exceed its proper measure, and that it is not something to stop at or to suppose we can never have too much of. Desire it only in its place and for its proper ends.
Direction 5. Understand well the nature and excellence of those higher graces toward which sorrow is meant to lead: love, thankfulness, delight in God, and fruitful obedience. When you grasp this, you will be drawn after these graces; you will learn to hate the sorrow that hinders them and to cherish only that sorrow which leads you up toward them, valuing it solely as a means to those ends.
Direction 6. Manage all your affairs, and especially those of your souls, with prudent foresight, and do not look only at things as they appear at close range. Pittacus held that prudence consists in foreseeing troubles before they arrive so as to prevent them, while courage consists in bearing them with composure when they do arrive, as recorded by Diogenes Laertius (Lives of the Eminent Philosophers, book 1, section 78). Do not judge by sense alone, but by reason; for sense cannot foresee, and pleases itself in the present with what must turn bitter in the end.
This is the common path by which carnal delight leads to overwhelming sorrow. The person who would avoid tomorrow’s pain and sickness from excess must not please his appetite against reason today. Poison racks and kills no less for tasting sweet. You must know in advance how what you take will work and what its effects will be, not only how it tastes, if you would escape the pain. The drunkard does not think of his vomiting, poverty, shame, or sickness, and so he brings them on himself.
There is no sorrow so intolerable as that of a guilty soul passing in terror before the judgment seat of God, and from there into everlasting pain. Foresee this sorrow in your most pleasant sin, and remember that when you are tempted to sin you are tempted to sorrow, and then you may prevent it. In all your particular actions, apply a foreseeing judgment: ask what the end is likely to be before you begin. Most of our sorrows come from the lack of this, and express themselves in the cry, "Had I known, or had I thought of this, I would have prevented it."
Do nothing that you can foresee must be repented of, for repentance is sorrowful, and the weightier the case the deeper the sorrow. How easy and comfortable a life and death people might have if they would not buy a little forbidden, poisonous pleasure at the price of future pain and sorrow, and if they did not foolishly and over-tenderly refuse those holy, necessary, and medicinal sorrows by which their greater, overwhelming, and ruinous sorrows might have been prevented.
Direction 7. Always look at your remedy when you look at your misery, and when you find any dangerous sin or troubling sign in yourself, immediately consider what your duty is in order to your recovery and escape.
When people of irritable or disordered nature are rebuked for any sin, it is common for them to resist the reproof with excuses for as long as they can. When they can resist no longer, they fall into despairing lamentations: if they are truly so bad, what hope is there for them? Yet all the while they never actually set themselves against the sin, cast it off, and return to obedience so that their comfort might return. They will do anything rather than amend.
God convicts them of sin so that they may forsake it, yet they can be brought to anything sooner than to that. Convince them of their pride, malice, worldliness, disobedience, sloth, or anger, and they will sooner sink into sorrow and despair than they will resolve on genuine reformation. This is exactly what the devil desires: he can allow you grief and desperation, but not amendment.
But is this best for you? Or is it pleasing to God? Do not deny your sin, but see at the same time that there is enough in Christ for your pardon and deliverance. He has appointed you means for your present recovery and is ready to help you. Ask what your duty is for your cure, and set upon it without delay.
Direction 8. Remember your causes of joy as well as your cause of sorrow, so that each may receive its due, and your joy and sorrow may both be suited to their occasions. To this end you must labor for the most exact acquaintance with your own condition that you can possibly attain.
If you are still ungodly, your sorrow must outweigh your joy; otherwise it will be irrational joy, harmful to your soul, and will increase your future sorrow. You must not, however, overlook the real grounds for comfort that God’s patience, and the offered Savior, and the offer of pardon, grace, and life in him afford you. If you are truly godly, you must mourn for sin, weakness, deficiency, and the crosses and afflictions of yourself and others, yet never so as to forget the invaluable mercies you have already received: your part in Christ and in eternal life, your beginnings of grace, and your reconciliation with God. These call for, and indeed command, great rejoicing. Remember that no humiliation excuses you from observing and acknowledging all these mercies.
Direction 9. Read through all the scriptural commands that make it your duty to rejoice in the Lord, and to rejoice exceedingly; and make as much conscience of them as of any other command of God.
The same God who commands you to hear, to pray, and to repent commands you to rejoice (Ps 33:1, Phil 3:1, Phil 4:4, Rom 5:2, Phil 3:3, 1 Thess 5:16, 1 Pet 1:6–8, 1 Pet 4:13, Heb 3:6, 2 Cor 6:10, Rom 12:12, Ps 32:11, Ps 132:9–16, Rom 14:17, Ps 5:11).
Direction 10. Do not foster your own excessive sorrows by thinking them a duty, nor suspect lawful mirth and joy as though they were sinful or unbecoming.
If you take your sin for your duty and argue in its defense, and take your duty for your sin and argue against it, you are far from the path of amendment and recovery. Yet it is common for an afflicted, weak, and impatient soul to fall into a liking for its inordinate sorrows, though not a love of them, to justify them, and to think it a continuing duty to mourn. If these sorrows were truly of God, our natures would resist them more readily; and if our comfort were not more pleasing to God, our natures would not draw back from it as they do.
Direction 11. Love no creature too much, and do not let it grow too sweet and pleasant to you; otherwise you are preparing sorrow for yourself from that creature. Love it less, and you will sorrow less.
All your grief over losses and disappointments, in goods, estate, children, friends, reputation, liberty, health, and life, comes from loving these things too much. Value them only as they deserve, and you will bear the loss of them without being overwhelmed. The person who makes them an idol or the ground of his happiness will grieve their absence or loss as one utterly undone, incapable of living without them. But the person who has placed his happiness and hope in God, and values the world only insofar as it serves his ultimate end, will grieve over the lack of it only so far as he misses it for that end. "The love of money, and coveting after it, doth pierce men through with many sorrows" (1 Tim 6:10). Notice what your heart is too much set upon, too greatly pleased by, or hoping for, and draw it back quickly, if you love your peace.
Direction 12. Learn to be pleased and satisfied in the will of God. Trust your heavenly Father, who knows what you need.
It is some measure of rebellion or resistance in our wills against the will of God that causes our inordinate griefs and trouble. Because we cannot bring our wills to conform to his, nor make our reason bow to his wisdom, nor think well of his providence unless he will bend it to our opinions, interests, and lusts, therefore, so far as we are carnal, we are commonly displeased and aggrieved at his ways. If we could have had our own way concerning our estate, our reputation, our children, our friends, our health, or our life, we would not have been troubled at the time. But because it is God’s way that is taken and God’s will that is done, not ours, we are grieved and discontented, as though his way and will were worse than ours, and as though God had lacked his foolish children as counselors, or as though they could have chosen better for themselves!
Direction 13. Afflict yourselves no further than God or others afflict you: and remember, if you already think you have too much against your will, how foolish and self-contradicting it is to willingly heap a great deal more upon yourselves.
Martin of Braga writes: bear willingly what is necessary, for pain is overcome by patience; and if you can, admit no sadness at all; but if you cannot, at least do not display it.
Is it slander or reproach that others afflict you with? Let it be so; that does not touch the heart. Is it poverty, reversal, or loss that God afflicts you with? Let it be so; that does not touch the heart either. Is it the loss of children or friends, or pain and sickness? I grant these are severe, yet even they do not by themselves reach the heart. If they do reach there, that is your own doing; and though some moderate grief there is fitting, if it is immoderate, that is your own sinful doing.
It is you who grieve and make the heart ache. God and others did no more than make the flesh ache. If others hurt your body, will you therefore torment your mind? Will you pierce your own heart because someone has touched your name or your goods? If so, remember which part of your sorrow is of their making and which is of your own. Can you for shame go and beg God or others to ease the grief that you yourself are causing and willfully sustaining, even while you pray against it? Why lament what you yourself cause and choose? It is a shame to be willfully your own tormentor.
Direction 14. Abhor everything that tends to weaken the authority and governance of reason, that is, all feebleness and cowardice of mind, and a melancholic, irritable, or passionate disposition, and labor to keep reason in authority, and to keep all your passions subject to your will; which must be accomplished by Christian faith and fortitude.
If you have reached that childish or disordered state in which you grieve and say, "I cannot help it; I know it is sinful and excessive, but I cannot choose otherwise," then if you speak truly, you are beyond the reach of counsel, advice, or comfort. You are not to be preached to or talked to or written for. We do not write directions to teach people how to touch the stars, or to explain the roughness and irregularities of the moon, or the dark parts of Saturn, or to govern the celestial spheres, or to drive the chariot of the sun. If it has become a natural impossibility for you, doctrine can offer no remedy. But if the impossibility is only moral, rooted in the weakness of reason and a failure of consideration, then doctrine, deliberate thought, and resolution may yet overcome it. You can do more than you think you can, if you are willing; on this see Mr. Fenner’s book on Wilful Impenitency.
How did you come to lose command of your passions? Did not God make you a rational creature, with understanding and will to govern all the passions? How have you come to lose the ruling power of reason and will? You would consider it a slur to be told you have lost the use of your reason; and is it not one of reason’s chief functions to govern the passions and all the other subordinate powers of the soul?
You say you cannot help grieving! But if someone could give you the thing you lack or desire, then you could help it: you could rejoice, if someone could restore that child, that friend, that estate you have lost. But God, and Christ, and heaven, it seems, are not enough to cure you: if you must have only them, you cannot help but grieve! What kind of hearts have you, then, that are so affected? Should not such hearts rather be grieved over? God will at some point make you see that you had more power than you used.
Direction 15. Observe the harmful effects of excessive sorrow, so that you may feel the full force of your reasons to avoid it. While you do not know what harm it does, you will be all the more slack in resisting it. I will briefly name some of its unhappy fruits.
1. It is a continual pain and sickness of the mind. (You know this by experience.)
2. It destroys bodily health and life. For "worldly sorrow worketh death" (2 Cor 7:10). "A merry heart doth good like a medicine: but a broken spirit drieth the bones" (Prov 17:22).
3. It robs the soul of its taste for God’s mercies, causing us to undervalue them and, consequently, to be ungrateful for them and to make no use of them.
4. It destroys the sense of God’s love and gravely unfits the soul to love him, and for that one effect alone it should be detested by us.
5. It destroys the joy of the Holy Ghost and makes us incapable of obeying God’s command to "rejoice continually."
6. It works against a heavenly mind and walk, and cuts us off from all foretastes of the everlasting joys. Even Anaxagoras the philosopher, when asked whether he had no care for his country, pointed his finger toward heaven and answered that his care for his country was very great indeed (Diogenes Laertius, Lives of the Eminent Philosophers, book 2, section 7).
7. It unfits us for the excellent work of praise. Who can ascend in the praises of God while grief oppresses and holds the soul captive?
8. It destroys the sweetness of all God’s ordinances: hearing, reading, prayer, the sacraments. We may force ourselves to use them, but we shall find no delight in them.
9. It hinders the exercise of faith, and stirs up distrust and sinful doubts and fears within us.
10. It produces sinful discontents and murmuring against God and man.
11. It makes us impatient, irritable, contrary, quick-tempered, and hard to please.
12. It weakens the soul for everything good and destroys its fortitude and strength, for it is the "joy of the Lord that is our strength" (Neh 8:10).
13. It hinders us in the duties of our callings. Who can fulfill them as they ought to be fulfilled, weighed down by a disquieted mind?
14. It makes us a grief and burden to our friends, and robs them of the comfort they should receive through us.
15. It makes us unprofitable to others and prevents us from doing the good we might do. When we should be instructing, exhorting, and praying for poor sinners, or attending to the concerns of the church of God, we are entirely consumed at home with our own afflictions.
16. It makes us a stumbling block and scandal to the ungodly, and hinders their conversion, while the devil places us before the church doors to keep the ungodly from a holy life, as people set scarecrows in their fields and gardens to frighten away birds.
17. It dishonors religion by making people believe that it is a melancholy, vexing, self-tormenting way of life.
18. It obscures the glory of the Gospel and crosses the work of Christ, his Spirit, and his ministers, who all come with a message of great joy to all nations and proclaim glad tidings to the worst of sinners, and far more so to the sons of God and heirs of life.
19. It misrepresents God himself. Our lives, when we who profess to fear and seek him live in such immoderate grief and distress, preach hideous doctrine about God: that he is a hard and cruel master whom none can please, even through a Mediator under a covenant of grace; that we are worse off for having served him than before; that he delights in our grief and misery and is against our peace and joy; and that there is no joy or pleasure in his service.
20. And it gives far too much pleasure to the devil, who is glad to torment us here if he may not do so in hell, and is especially pleased to make us our own tormentors when he is himself restrained, so that he can boast and say, "Though I may not vex you, I will persuade you to vex yourself."
These are the fruits of sinful sorrow.
Direction 16. Govern your thoughts, and do not allow them to dwell and feed on the objects that cause your grief. No wonder your wound is always smarting when you are always rubbing it in your thoughts. I spoke of this more fully just above.
CHAPTER 17
DIRECTIONS AGAINST SINFUL DESPAIR (AND DOUBTING)
Despair is the contrary of hope. There is a despair that is a duty, a despair that is a sin, and a despair that is morally indifferent, being merely natural rather than moral. Despair is a duty when it is contrary to the sinful hope described earlier, that is,
1. When we despair of anything that God has told us will never come to pass, for we are bound to believe his word: for example, that the whole world will be saved or converted, or that our bodies will not die and perish, and many such things.
2. It is a duty to despair of ever reaching a good end by means or on terms that God has told us it will never be reached by. So it is a great duty for an unregenerate person to despair of ever being saved without regeneration, conversion, and holiness, and to despair of ever being pardoned or saved if he lives after the flesh, does not have the Spirit of Christ, does not repent sincerely of his sin, is not a new creature, and does not crucify the flesh with its affections and lusts. Such despair is one of the first things necessary for a sinner’s conversion, because the false hope of being pardoned and saved without regeneration is the very obstacle that must be removed. See more on the cure of doubting in Part II, Chapter XXV.
Despair is a sin when it runs contrary to any hope that God commands, provided it is not merely a negative despair (a bare not-hoping, which in sleep and at other times may be innocent), but a positive despair that concludes against hope. This occurs in three cases:
1. Particular despair of the benefit of some particular promise, as if Israel had despaired of deliverance from Egypt, or Abraham of a son.
2. General despair of the fulfillment of some general promise, as if we despaired of the resurrection or of Christ’s kingdom in glory.
3. When by misapplication we despair of that pardon and salvation for ourselves which we nonetheless believe will be given to others.
Indeed, despair is sometimes sinful even when it is not contrary to any promise or commanded hope. If God has not revealed his will one way or the other, it is no duty to expect the thing, and yet it is a sin to conclude positively that it will not occur, for then we say more than we know or than God has revealed. If hope means the comfort that arises from perceiving a mere possibility, then it is a duty to hope for what is merely possible. But if hope means confident expectation, then both such hope and the contrary despair would be sin. We may refrain from hoping, but we may not actively despair. Possibilities must be treated as no more than possibilities, and yet they must still be treated as possibilities.
Someone who despairs only of a common mercy he should not despair of commits a sin of the lesser sort, so far as the matter itself is concerned. Someone who despairs of a great mercy for others, even where it has not been promised, commits a greater sin in respect of the matter (for instance, despairing of the conversion of a wayward child, or of the continuance of the Gospel in a kingdom). But one who despairs of his own pardon and salvation sins most dangerously of all in respect of the matter.
Despairing of pardon and salvation because one despairs of the truth of the Gospel or of the sufficiency of Christ is damnable, and a certain mark of a wretched infidel if it is dominant. Judas perished not merely through despair; he had no repentance that renewed his soul, nor any love for God and holiness. But to believe the whole Gospel to be true, to desire Christ and life as the greatest good, and yet to despair through too low an opinion of oneself or through some other mistake, this is a sin of infirmity, consistent with the presence of grace, unless the despair becomes so total and prevailing that the sinner settles into casting off a godly life and giving himself over to wickedness. Scripture says little about this humble kind of despair and nowhere threatens it as it threatens infidelity.
The most common despair, like that of Spira, which arises immediately from an invincible and dominant melancholy (though it was first occasioned by sin) is no more sinful or dangerous than the despair or ravings of a madman or someone in a delirious fever. It is the too-humble despair, arising from personal misapplication and particular mistakes, that I shall address here.
Direction 1. Take care not to be ignorant of, or to misunderstand, the three great general grounds of faith and hope:
1.) The infinite goodness of God and his immeasurable love and mercy.
2.) The relation of Christ’s office to all people, and the sufficiency of his ransom and sacrifice for all.
3.) The universality of the promise, the act of pardon, the deed of gift of free forgiveness and salvation to all, on condition of penitent belief and acceptance, which is procured and given by Christ and contained in the Gospel.
If you err in your understanding of any one of these, failing to believe or grasp them, or failing to consider and apply them, no wonder you are left under continual doubting and vulnerable to despair.
Direction 2. Understand well the true nature of the condition of this universal promise: how much it consists in the will or acceptance of Christ and life as offered by the Gospel, or in our heartfelt consent to the baptismal covenant, that God be our God and Father, our Savior and Sanctifier. Understand that in God’s account the will is the person: the one who is truly willing to receive Christ to the ends of his office is a true believer and has a share in Christ. And the one who heartily consents to the covenant of grace has right to all its benefits.
This is true faith; this is the condition of pardon; and on these terms Christ and life are given. This is the infallible evidence of a state of grace. If you do not know this, but instead look for something else as necessary, something separable from this, no wonder you are perplexed and inclined to despair.
Direction 3. Understand the extent of this pardoning covenant as to the sins it forgives: it contains the forgiveness of all sin without exception for those who fulfill its condition, that is, for those who consent. So no sin is directly excepted except non-performance of the condition; but consequently, all sin is excepted and none at all is forgiven to those who do not perform the condition.
Every conditional grant expressly excepts non-performance of the condition simply by making it the condition. To say, "All sin is forgiven to those who believe and repent, and to no others," plainly implies that unbelief and unrepentance are not forgiven while they continue, nor is any other sin forgiven to such persons. But to penitent believers and consenters, all sin is pardoned. This is why the ancient writers said that all sin is washed away in baptism, assuming the person baptized is a fit subject who has the condition of the covenant that baptism seals and delivers to him.
Direction 4. Do not misunderstand the excepted sin against the Holy Ghost, which is nothing other than an aggravated non-performance and refusal of the covenant’s condition, specifically, when infidels are so obstinate in their infidelity that they will sooner attribute the miracles of the Holy Ghost to the devil than be convinced by them that Christ is the true Messiah and Savior.
This is the true nature of the sin against the Holy Ghost, on which I have written in the third part of my Treatise of Infidelity. Therefore, no one commits the sin against the Holy Ghost who confesses that Jesus is the Christ and Savior; or who confesses that the miracles done by Christ and his apostles were done by the Holy Ghost; or who confesses the Gospel to be true; or who does not justify his sin and infidelity. The person who commits this sin must be a professed infidel who resists miracles he himself acknowledges.
And yet many despair because they fear they have committed this sin, people who never understood what it is and have no reason to imagine it is theirs except bare fear and some blasphemous temptations they themselves abhor. The truth is that in their troubled condition, if any other sin had been spoken of with equal severity, they would have thought that sin was theirs too.
Though the distress of some calls for a fuller treatment of this sin, I have already written a treatise on it and must not be tedious here by repeating what is said there.
Direction 5. Understand the time to which the Gospel’s condition extends, namely, to the end of our earthly life. The day of this grace has no shorter end. The Gospel does not say that whoever believes this year or next shall be saved; it says, without any time limit short of death, that whoever believes shall be saved. To doubt whether true repentance and faith will be accepted at any point before death is simply to be ignorant of the Gospel, or to doubt whether the Gospel is true. When a despairing soul says, "Even if I did repent, it is too late, the day of grace is past," that soul is either contradicting the Gospel covenant itself or speaking without understanding. God has never turned away a soul that truly repented and believed before death.
Objection 1: But do not some divines say that some men’s day of grace ends sooner, that God has forsaken them, and that it is too late because they did not come in time?
Answer: Those who understand what they are saying must mean only this: the phrase "day of grace" carries several senses.
1.) Properly speaking, the day of grace is the time in which, according to the tenor of the Gospel, God will pardon and accept those who repent. In this sense, the time of a person’s life is the time of grace: whenever a sinner repents and is converted, he is pardoned.
2.) Sometimes "day of grace" means the time during which the means of grace are continued to a nation or a person. In this sense it is true that the day of grace passes more quickly for some nations than others: God sometimes removes the preachers of his Gospel from a people that rejects them, and so ceases to offer them his grace through preaching. But in this sense a person can easily tell whether his day of grace is past, that is, whether Bibles, books, Christians, and preachers have all been taken from him. No person in his right mind can think that his day of grace has passed while Christ is being offered to him, while a Bible exists, or while a preacher or fellow Christian is near him. (And yet even if all those were gone, the person who receives Christ before they are gone is safe.)
3.) Sometimes "day of grace" means the certain time we can count as our own. In that sense only the present moment is our time of grace, because we cannot be certain in advance of another moment. Yet when the next moment arrives, it is just as much a time of grace as the previous one was.
4.) Sometimes "day of grace" means the time in which God actually works and gives grace, that is, simply the day of our conversion. In this sense to have the day of grace past is a happiness and a comfort: the day in which we were converted is past.
5.) Sometimes "day of grace" means the time in which God moves the hearts of the impenitent more strongly toward conversion than he has before. This is what divines mean when they speak of the day of grace passing for some people before death: though such persons never have a day of effectual grace, their impulses toward conversion were stronger at some earlier point than they will be afterward, and they were closer to conversion then than they will be once they drift further from it.
This is true, and it is all that can rightly be meant. But what does any of it say to a soul who is willing to come to God and who ignorantly questions whether he will be accepted because the day of grace has passed?
Objection 2: But Christ says, "If thou hadst known in this thy day" (Luke 19:42).
Answer: That was the day of the offers of grace through preaching. We freely grant that nations have only their season of enjoying the Gospel, and that they may cut it short by sinning it away.
Objection 3: But it is said of Esau that "afterward, when he would have inherited the blessing, he was rejected: for he found no place of repentance, though he sought it carefully with tears" (Heb 12:17). It seems, then, that repentance in this life may come too late.
Answer: It is true that Esau’s opportunity for the blessing was gone the moment Isaac had given it to Jacob. When Esau had sold his birthright, it was too late to reclaim it, because the right had been transferred to his brother; neither repentance nor crying nor tears could recover the right he had sold or recall the words Isaac had spoken. But this does not prove that our day of grace does not continue until death, or that any person who repents before death will be rejected as Esau was. The apostle neither says nor means any such thing.
The meaning of the passage is only this: Take heed lest any among you be so profane as to treat the blessings of the Gospel, Christ himself and eternal life, as lightly as Esau treated his birthright, trading them away for a base lust or a passing thing, as Esau valued a morsel of meat above his birthright. Let such people be sure that the time will come (the time Christ speaks of, when the door is shut and the Lord has returned) when they will bitterly repent it. Then, as it was with Esau when the blessing was gone, so it will be with them when their blessing is gone, repentance, crying, and tears will be too late, for the Gospel has its justice and its terrors as well as the law. That is the whole meaning of the text; there is no suggestion that our day of grace is as brief as Esau’s hope of the blessing was.
Objection 4: But Saul had only his time, and when he lost it he was forsaken by God.
Answer: Saul’s sin provoked God to reject him from being king of Israel and to appoint another in his place. But had Saul truly repented, he would have been saved after that, even though he would not have been restored to the throne. It is true that just as God withdrew from him the spirit of government, so many people, before death, by the greatness of their sins cause God to forsake them to the extent of withholding the impulses, convictions, fears, and disturbances about sin that they once experienced, giving them over to "a reprobate mind," to commit "all uncleanness with greediness," and to glory in it as being "past feeling" (Rom 1:28 Eph 4:18–19). If this is truly your condition, you would not want to be better; you would not want to be recovered; you would think sin best for you and hate all who would reform you.
Objection 5: "Behold, now is the accepted time; behold, now is the day of salvation" (2 Cor 6:2). And also, "To-day if ye will hear his voice, harden not your hearts, lest any of you be hardened by the deceitfulness of sin" (Heb 3:7 and 3:12–13).
Answer: These passages say no more than that the present time is the best, indeed the only certain, time, and that we cannot be sure the day of salvation will continue, because death may cut us off. Yet beyond that, sin itself is hardening: the longer we sin, the more hardened we become. God may indeed withhold the movements of his Spirit and leave us to ourselves and to the hardness of our own hearts. He does this with thousands of wicked persons who are left in impenitence and hatred of the truth. But most certainly, if those persons repented they could be saved; the very reason they lack Christ and life is still and only that they will not consent.
Direction 6. Understand by what help and strength the obedience the Gospel requires must be performed, not by your own strength alone, but by the help of grace and the strength of Christ. If he has but made you willing, he will help you to perform the rest. Under this covenant you are not called to be your own savior and sanctifier; you are called to consent that Christ be your Savior and the Holy Ghost your Sanctifier. You might well despair if you were left entirely to what you are utterly unable to do. Though you must "work out your own salvation with fear and trembling, it is he that worketh in you to will and to do of his good pleasure" (Phil 2:13).
Direction 7. Understand clearly the difference between mortal sins and infirmities, so that you do not take every sin as a mark of death or gracelessness, but can distinguish between sins that should lead you to conclude you are unjustified and sins that call only for particular humiliation, being sins that even justified persons commit.
We accept no sin as venial in the Popish sense, that is, as something that is not properly a sin or does not deserve death under the law of works. Yet the distinction between mortal and venial sin is very necessary: that is, the distinction between sins that show a person to be in a state of death, or unjustified, and sins that are consistent with a state of grace and justification, between sins the Gospel does not pardon and sins it does pardon, which is to say all sins that stand alongside true repentance.
Some sins are such that everyone who repents of them forsakes them completely and ceases to commit them. There are also lesser sins which those who repent of them genuinely hate, yet frequently repeat: such as our shortfalls in the degree of repentance itself, faith, love, trust, fear, and obedience; vain thoughts and words; certain sinful passions; omissions of many duties of thought, affection, word, or deed toward God or others; moments of time that slip away; prayer and other duties performed with sinful coldness or carelessness; and the like. Such sins are properly called infirmities and venial because they are consistent with life and are forgiven. Discerning the difference between these two kinds of sin is of great use for the peace of our consciences: one kind requires conversion into a new state, while the other requires only particular repentance, and where the latter sins are unknown they are forgiven without particular repentance, because our general repentance is virtually, though not actually, particular with respect to them.
One kind gives grounds to judge ourselves ungodly; the other kind calls only for a child’s humble grief before God. Anyone can see the great need to discern this difference. Yet to distinguish them correctly in doctrine is a matter requiring very careful judgment, and to discern them accurately in one’s own particular case is even more so.
The way to do it is to know first what the condition of the new covenant is and what is absolutely necessary to salvation or justification. Every sin that is inconsistent with that condition is mortal; all the rest, being consistent with it, are venial or mere infirmities. Taken as meaning sins that are pardonable and may coexist with true grace, a venial sin may be found materially in an unsanctified person where it is not pardoned, for example, a wandering thought or a moment of passion is a sin of the kind that in a godly person is consistent with true grace. But taken as meaning a sin that is pardoned, or pardonable without regeneration or conversion from a state of death into a state of life, venial sin belongs to no unregenerate, unjustified person; it belongs only to the infirmities of the saints. That is the sense in which I speak of it here.
In brief: a sin that actually coexists with habitual repentance, with genuine hatred of that sin to the degree that you would rather be free of it than commit or retain it, and with an unfeigned consent to the covenant, that God be your Father, Savior, and Sanctifier, and with love of God above all else, is no more than an infirmity or venial sin. But to know from the nature of each particular sin which sins fall into this category would require an entire volume to direct you.
Direction 8. Understand how necessary a faithful minister of Christ is, in such cases of danger and difficulty, to guide your conscience. Open your case honestly to such a minister, and place as much confidence in their judgment of your spiritual state as their office, abilities, and faithfulness warrant. Do not set your own timid, darkened, and perplexed judgment above theirs in cases where they are better qualified to judge.
Such a guide is necessary both because Christ himself appointed the pastoral office and because of the gravity, danger, and difficulty of your situation. Do you not feel your own insufficiency, your need of help? A soul tempted to despair can surely feel it readily enough. If you do not, you are either very proud or blindly self-satisfied.
You may also readily understand that Christ, who appointed ministers to their office, requires that they be both used and trusted within it, as far as reason allows. And even apart from any formal office, ability and faithfulness by themselves deserve and demand a corresponding credit. Why else do you trust physicians, lawyers, and craftsmen in their respective professions and arts, according to their known skill and integrity? No human being is to be believed as infallible, as God is; but a human being is to be believed as a human being. If you will use and trust your spiritual guide only as far as you use and trust your physician or lawyer, you will discover great benefit, provided you choose your guide well.
Direction 9. When you have sinned, remember how certain, sufficient, and ready the remedy before you is, namely, Jesus Christ and the covenant of grace. Remember also that God’s design in redemption is not to save anyone as though they were innocent, so that no one may boast, but to save those who were first plunged in sin and misery, and to recover them as from the very gates of hell, so that love and mercy might be magnified in everyone who is saved, and grace might abound all the more where sin has abounded (Rom 5:15 and 5:20).
This is not a license for anyone to "continue in sin because grace hath abounded: God forbid" (Rom 6:1). Rather, it means that we should magnify the grace and mercy that has surpassed our sins, and turn even the memory of our worst sins into wonder at that great and extraordinary mercy. To magnify mercy when you see the greatness of your sin, and to love much because much is forgiven, this pleases God and fulfills the very design and end of our redemption. But to magnify your sin, to diminish mercy, and to say that your sin is too great to be forgiven, this pleases the devil and works against God’s design in our redemption.
Is your disease so great that no ordinary remedy could cure it? Then it is all the more fitting that Christ should honor his office upon it, and that God should honor his love and mercy in it. Simply "come to him that you may have life," and you will find that no past magnitude of sin will cause him to refuse you, and no infirmities you are willing to be rid of will cause him to disown you or cast you out. The prodigal is not so much as upbraided with his sins, but finds himself, before he is aware of it, in his father’s arms, clothed with the best robes, the ring, and shoes, and joyfully entertained with a feast. Remember: there is enough in Christ and in the promise to pardon and heal every sin you are willing to forsake.
Direction 10. Take care not to be so blind or proud in your humility as to think that you could be more willing to be a servant of Christ than he is to be your Savior, or more willing to have grace than God is to give it to you, or more willing to come home to Christ than he is to receive and welcome you.
Either you are willing or unwilling to have Christ and grace, to be sanctified and freed from sin. If you are willing, Christ and his grace shall certainly be yours. If you would have pardon without holiness, that cannot be, and there is no promise of it. But if you desire Christ as your Savior and King, and his Spirit as your sanctifier, and if you would rather be perfect in love and holiness than to possess all the riches of the world, then you are in sincerity what you desire to be in perfection. Understand that God counts you to be what you truly desire to be. The great work of grace lies in the renewing of the will. If the will is sound, the person is sound.
I do not mean the defeated, ineffectual half-wish of the wicked, who wish they could be free from pride, sensuality, gluttony, drunkenness, lust, and covetousness without surrendering any of their cherished honor, wealth, or pleasure. When they think of sin as the road to hell, they dislike it and wish they were rid of it; but when they think of it as gratifying their fleshly desires, they love it more and will not leave it, because that is the prevailing disposition of their will. So Judas was unwilling to betray his Lord insofar as it was the betrayal of the innocent and the road to hell, but he was more willing insofar as it brought him his thirty pieces of silver. So Herod was unwilling to kill John the Baptist insofar as it was the murder of a prophet, but his willingness was stronger insofar as it pleased the girl and rid him of a troublesome reprover.
But if your willingness to have Christ and perfect holiness is greater than your unwillingness, greater than your desire to keep your sin and enjoy the honor, wealth, and pleasures of the world, then you have an unmistakable sign of uprightness, and a love for grace and longing after it that nothing but grace itself can produce.
And if you are thus willing, it is a serious wrong to Christ to doubt his willingness. Consider:
1.) He is a greater lover of holiness than you are, and therefore cannot fall behind you in willing your holiness.
2.) He is more merciful toward you than you are toward yourself; his love and mercy surpass your measure.
3.) He has already begun with you and fully demonstrated his willingness first. He died to provide you a complete remedy. He drew up the covenant; he expressed his own consent in it and now entreats yours. He is first in consenting and is the one who seeks the union. No sinner in the world has ever approached him first. No one was ever willing of the match before he was. His general offer of mercy and the covenant tendered to all shows his willingness before they can show theirs by accepting. No one has ever surpassed him in willingness or been more willing than he.
Receive this, sinner, as God’s infallible truth: if the union between Christ and you breaks down and you are lost, it will not be through his refusal but through yours. It cannot break any other way, not by the craft or force of all the devils in hell, except either because Christ is unwilling or because you are unwilling; and on Christ’s part it shall never break. Therefore, if you are willing, the match is made, and the only danger is that your own heart may draw back. If you are not willing, why do you complain of lacking what you will not have? If you are willing, the covenant stands, for Christ is more willing, and was willing first.
Direction 11. Write out those sentences that contain the sense and substance of the Gospel, and read them often. Write them on your very chamber walls, and keep them before your eyes. Then consider whether they agree with the words of the one who tempts you to despair. Here are some that I transcribe for you:
"God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life. This is the condemnation that light is come into the world, and men loved darkness rather than light, because their deeds were evil. He that believeth on the Son of God hath the witness in himself: he that believeth not God hath made him a liar, because he believeth not the record that God gave of his Son: and this is the record, that God hath given to us eternal life, and this life is in his Son: he that hath the Son hath life; and he that hath not the Son of God hath not life." (John 3:16 John 3:19 1 John 5:10–12)
"He came unto his own, but his own received him not: but to as many as received him, to them gave he power to become the sons of God, to them that believe on his name. Let him that is athirst come; and whosoever will, let him take the water of life freely. And ye will not come unto me, that ye may have life. All that the Father giveth me, shall come to me, and him that cometh to me I will in no wise cast out. If any man thirst, let him come to me and drink. Come, for all things are now ready." (John 1:11–12 Rev 22:17 John 5:40 John 6:37 John 7:37 Luke 14:17)
And read often (Luke 15).
Direction 12. Distinguish between sin that is seen and felt, and sin that reigns unto death. Do not be so confused as to think your sin is greatest, or your condition worst, when your sight and feeling of it are most acute. To see and feel your sin and misery is at least the ordinary preparation for recovery. To be dead is to be past feeling. Those who are most forsaken of God are most content with their present condition: they love their sin most, hate holiness and all who would reform them, and, when they have the power, will persecute such people as enemies.
Direction 13. Do not think that the troublesome strivings and temptations that wear you down are the worst possible condition, or a sign that sin is winning. They are rather a sign that God has not yet forsaken you, since he still bears witness in you against sin and continues to follow you with his warnings. Paul says, "For the flesh lusteth against the Spirit, and the Spirit against the flesh: and these are contrary the one to the other; so that ye cannot do the things that ye would" (Gal 5:17). Read Romans 7:14 to the end of that chapter.
Direction 14. Understand the difference between weak grace and no grace, so that you do not take every lack of grace as a sign of total gracelessness. When you have laid out a long catalogue of weaknesses in your complaints, consider whether there is not still a true desire to be better, and some degree of life present alongside all of these.
Direction 15. Think well of the excellence of even the smallest degree of special grace: it is a seed of glory, the beginning of eternal life, the divine nature and the image of God, and of greater worth than all the learning, wealth, and honor in the world. Do not be ungrateful for so great a mercy simply because you do not have more.
Direction 16. Make it a matter of conscience to observe the grace and mercy you have received, just as you observe the wants that remain and the sins you have committed. Give as much thankful attention to mercy, mentioning it to others and before God in prayer, as you give humble attention to sin. Think of mercy as often as you think of sin. This is your plain duty. If you will not do it, your willful unthankfulness for what you have received may rightly leave you in distress, without the comfort of it.
Direction 17. Let your thoughts of God’s goodness bear some proportion to your thoughts of his knowledge and his power. Then you will not be so ready to entertain false suspicions of it, or to think of him as a hater of mankind, like the devil, or to flee from him who is the infinite, most attractive good.
Direction 18. Record the particular kindnesses by which God has testified his particular love to you, so that they may stand as near and constant witnesses of his mercy and readiness to do you good, against your excessive fearfulness and despair.
Direction 19. Consider how few people in the world are as well-placed for mercy as you are. Do not look only at those who are better than yourself. Reflect that five parts of the world are open infidels and heathens; and of the sixth part that are Christians, how few have been reformed from popish and barbarous ignorance and superstition; and among Protestants, how small is the number of those who are less in love with sin than you. I know that many wicked people abuse this comparison to breed presumption. But I also know that a Christian may and must use it against despair, and must not think of God and the Redeemer as one who would save so few that they amount to almost none at all.
Direction 20. Remember that God commands faith and hope, and forbids unbelief and despair, and that despair is therefore your sin. Will you sin still more, having already sinned so much? What if you see no other reason to hope and no other reason not to despair except God’s command? Is that not enough? I charge you in the name of God: obey him and do not despair. Do not sin willfully against him in this way. Hope is your duty; dare you argue against duty? Despair is your sin; will you justify it?
Consider, too, what great comfort lies in this: if there were no hope of your salvation, God would never have made it your duty to hope, nor would he have forbidden you to despair. He does not command the devils or the damned to hope as he commands you; he does not forbid them to despair as he forbids you. There is a reason for this. He would have dealt with you as he deals with them if your condition were as hopeless as theirs. (Ps 146:5 Ps 31:24 Rom 8:24 Rom 15:4 Rom 15:13 Col 1:23 1 Thess 5:8 Heb 3:6 Heb 6:11 Heb 6:18 Heb 6:19 Titus 1:2)
Direction 21. If God forbids you to despair, it is certainly the devil who commands it. Will you knowingly obey the devil? What if the devil openly urged you to despair with his own mouth, would you not recognize that what such an enemy draws you toward must be evil? This thought should give you great comfort: the fact that it is the devil who persuades you to despair proves that you ought not to despair, and that proves your case is not desperate but hopeful.
Direction 22. Consider where despair leads. To despair is to give up all hope of your salvation, and when you have no hope you will use no means. For why would anyone seek what they have no hope of finding? When that weight is removed, all the wheels stop turning. The devil’s intention has two parts: the first is, do not hear, or read, or pray, or seek advice, or speak any more about it with godly people, for there is no hope. The second part is either to destroy yourself, or to sin boldly and take the pleasure of sin while you can, for there is no hope of anything better.
Do you think that either of these comes from God, or is for your good? What is the meaning of it all but to cast away your soul? While you have hope, you will seek and use some means; but to cast away hope is to cast away everything. Have you so far lost all care for yourself as to be the one who brings about such a deed?
Direction 23. Think what a wrong you do to the Father, the Savior, and the Sanctifier of souls when you think so poorly and despairingly of his grace, as though it were not able to prevail against your sin, and when you obscure the glory of his redemption, and believe the devil in his slandering, diminishing, and dishonoring of that in God which God wills to have most glorified by sinners.
Direction 24. Consider: can you name a single person in all the world who ever perished or was rejected, who was willing in this life to be saved and sanctified by Christ, and who preferred Christ and perfect holiness over the treasures or pleasures of the world? Name even one such person if you can. You cannot. Will you then fear what has never happened to anyone, or think that Christ will begin with you?
Direction 25. Rise and act. Resolve, in defiance of the devil, that you will wait on God in the use of means, cast yourself on Christ, and that if you perish you will perish there. Do this, and you will never perish. You cannot do worse than despair and give up everything; you cannot please the devil more, displease God more, or wrong Christ and the Spirit more. You can be certain that you lose nothing by trusting your soul to Christ, hoping in him, and patiently using his means. Do but this, and hope will save you where Satan by despair would damn you.
Direction 26. Understand the time and order in which Christ gives his grace and saves his people from their sins: he does not do it all at once, but by degrees, and he takes the whole span of this present life to accomplish it. However skilled your physician is, he will not finish the cure until your life is finished. The next life is the state of absolute perfection; all things are imperfect here. Do not therefore despair of all that you have not yet attained. Your sin may be further mortified, and your grace further strengthened. If it is accomplished before you come to judgment, it is well for you. Do your part in daily diligence: plant and water, and he will give the increase. Read more on this in the earlier section, Part II, against Melancholy.
CHAPTER 18
DIRECTIONS FOR THE GOVERNMENT OF THE SENSES
Part I. General Directions for the Government of the Senses (by a Life of Faith)
The most wise and gracious God, having constituted us of soul and body, so that our nobler part might have a companion and instrument suited to the lower place through which it passes on its way to a nobler state, has appointed our senses not only to sustain life and manage our lower actions and convey his lesser mercies, but also to serve as the common passage to the imagination and so to the mind, rendering service to our rational powers and aiding our worship of our Maker and our communion with him in his higher gifts. To these ends all our senses should be used, since they are capable of being sanctified and made serviceable to God.
But sin entered through the senses, and through sin they are now corrupted along with the body, grown disordered, violent, and unruly in their appetite. The rational powers, having lost and forsaken God, their proper end and highest object, have sold or enslaved themselves to the sensitive appetite in order to serve its ends. So the sensitive appetite has become the ruling faculty in the unsanctified, and the senses the common entrance of sin and the instruments of Satan. Although the work of grace operates primarily in the rational powers, it works secondarily in the lower powers as well, sanctifying them and bringing them under the government of a renewed mind and will, and so restoring them to their proper use.
I cannot say that grace immediately alters the senses themselves, but it does so mediately, by altering the mind, and through the mind the will, and through the will the imagination, and through the imagination the sensitive appetite, and through the appetite the sense itself in its exercise. We see that temperance and chastity not only restrain the appetite but actually reduce the rage and violence it previously had, not the natural appetite, but the sensitive appetite insofar as it is sinful.
The sanctifying and governing of the senses and their appetite has two parts: first, guarding them against the entrance of sin; and second, using them as the entrance of good into the soul. This second part is so high a work that too few are skilled in it, and few can perform even the first well.
Direction 1. The principal part of the work concerns the superior faculties, securing a well-informed judgment and a holy, confirmed will, not the sense itself. Reason is dethroned by sin, and the will is left unguided and unguarded to the assaults of sensual violence. Reason must be restored before the senses will be well governed, for what else is to serve as their immediate governor? It is no sin in brutes to live by sense, because they have no reason to govern it. In humanity the senses are governed more or less as reason is more or less restored. When reason is cleared only in temporal matters (as in worldly-wise people), the senses will be mastered and ruled for temporal ends, as far as those ends require. But where reason is sanctified, the senses are governed for the ends of sanctification, in proportion to the measure of grace.
Direction 2. Only the high, eternal things of God and our salvation, objectively settled in the mind and will, made as it were natural to them, and established as our ruling end and interest, are sufficient for a true and holy government of the senses. Lower things may muzzle the senses and make people appear temperate and sober to the degree that honor, wealth, health, and life require it. But this is merely stopping one gap while most of the hedge lies open, enlisting the senses to serve the flesh, the world, and the devil in a composed and less conspicuous way, rather than as filthily and furiously as others do.
Direction 3. The main practical part of this government is taking special care that no good perceived by the senses is made the ultimate end of desire, nor sought for its own sake, nor rested in, nor delighted in excessively; but seeing to it that the soul, having first fixed habitually on its proper higher end and happiness, directs all the actions of every sense (as far as they fall under deliberation and choice) to serve those holy ends, even if only remotely. The sense is not sanctified unless it is used toward a holy end, and its object is not sanctified to us unless it is made serviceable to higher objects. A merely negative restraint of the senses for common ends has no better quality than the ends for which it is exercised. When eyes, ears, taste, and feeling are all taught by reason to serve God for his glory and our salvation, then, and never before then, they are well governed.
Direction 4. To this end, the constant exercise of a lively belief in the Word of God and the unseen things of the other world must be the first and principal means by which reason governs every sense, both in restraining it and in rightly employing it. Living by sight and living by faith are therefore opposed in Scripture: "we walk by faith, not by sight" (2 Cor 5:7), that is, sight and sense are not our principal guiding faculty but are subservient to faith, and the objects of sight are not the things we principally or ultimately seek or value, but the objects of faith. As it is expressed just before that text, "While we look not at the things which are seen, but at the things which are not seen: for the things which are seen are temporal, but the things which are not seen are eternal" (2 Cor 4:18). Therefore faith is described as the "substance of things hoped for" and the "evidence of things not seen" (Heb 11:1).
Believing serves a Christian in place of seeing, because he knows by God’s testimony that the things believed are true, though they are unseen. And consider that the objects of sense are mere trifles compared to the great and astonishing objects of faith. If faith is lively, it must prevail and overrule the senses, because its objects utterly eclipse and reduce to nothing the transitory objects of sense. The apostle John says: "Whatsoever is born of God overcometh the world: and this is the victory that overcometh the world, even our faith" (1 John 5:4). Moses, "by seeing him that is invisible," overcame his desire for Egypt’s treasures and the "fear of the wrath of the king, having respect to the recompence of reward" (Heb 11:26–27). Stephen easily endured his cruel death when "he saw heaven opened, and Christ standing at the right hand of God" (Acts 7:56).
I dare appeal even to the most sensual person, the one who says, "I am not able to deny my appetite or rule my senses," whether he would not be able to do so if he could see at the same moment what is taking place in the other world. If he saw heaven and hell, the glorified and the damned, and saw the majesty of that God who commands him to abstain, would he not be able to leave alone the cup, the dish, the harlot, the sport, which now have such power over him?
I would give no thanks to the most beastly sensualist among you for living as temperately, in outward act, as the strictest saint alive, if only he could see the worlds that departed souls now see. It is not possible that such a sight would fail to overpower his sensual desires, yes, and call his very senses to serve him in seeking what he must do to be saved. Therefore, if believing the unseen world stands in place of seeing it with our eyes, it is certain that the means to overcome sensuality is faith, and that lively belief must govern our senses.
Direction 5. The more this belief in God and glory kindles love toward them, the more effective it will be in governing the senses. The common proverb says, "Where the love is, there is the eye." How readily attention follows the heart! Love will not alter the sense itself, but it commands the use of all the senses. It will not sharpen a dim, failing sight; but it will direct what that sight looks upon. Just as a stronger love for one dish, one pastime, or one company draws you away from another you love more faintly, so the love of God, heaven, and holiness will draw you out of captivity to all sensual things.
Direction 6. It must be carefully considered how powerful and dangerous the things we perceive by sense are, and how high and difficult a work it is, in our depraved and earthly state, to live by faith on things unseen and to govern and rise above the senses, so that the soul may be roused to sufficient fear and watchfulness, and may flee to Christ for help toward faith.
It is no small thing for a person in the flesh to live above the flesh. The soul’s way of receiving and operating here is so much through the senses that it easily grows too familiar with the things it perceives and becomes a stranger to things it has never seen. It is a great work to lead a person in the flesh to deny the pleasures he sees, tastes, and feels, for pleasures he has only heard of, and heard of as pleasures not to be enjoyed until after death, in a world that sense has no acquaintance with. What a glory it is to faith that it can accomplish such a work! How hard it is for a weak believer! And the strongest believers find it work enough.
Consider this, that it may rouse you to undertake this work with the care its greatness demands. You are called to live by faith, above a life of sight and sense, and your happiness or misery depends on it.
Direction 7. Sense must not only be kept off the throne, but excluded from any share in governance. We must take care never to admit it to our counsels, never to negotiate with it or hear it plead its case. Sense must gain nothing by striving, importunity, or violence, but must be governed absolutely, as a horse is governed by its rider.
If governance is ever divided between sense and reason, your life will be half bestial. Where reason does not rule, faith and grace do not rule either, for faith relates to reason as sight relates to the eye. There are no human beings who entirely set aside reason and are governed by sense alone, unless they are idiots or madmen. But sense should have no share of governance whatsoever. Where sense holds the chief power, the devil is the unseen governor there.
You cannot excuse yourself here by any plea of necessity or constraint. Though sense is both violent and enticing, God has made reason and will the absolute governors under him. For all its rebellion and violence, sense cannot depose them or force even one sin upon them. It accomplishes all its mischief by securing their consent. This happens in two ways: sometimes by flooding the imagination and passions so deeply with pleasurable and alluring objects that the higher faculties are drawn into agreement; and sometimes by wearing down the resisting mind and will until they ease their opposition, relax the reins, and by a sinful withdrawal of restraint allow sense to take its course.
A headstrong horse is not so easily managed as one with a tender mouth that has been well ridden. And so, though the rider has the power to rule him, he will sometimes, for his own ease, loose the reins. A horse that has been allowed his will whenever he strains against the rider, because the rider is slothful or unskilled, will strain every time he is crossed, and so will become the master.
So too with ill-bred children who have always been given whatever they cry for: they will certainly cry before they will accept being denied. It is the same with our sensitive appetite. If you habitually satisfy it when it grows eager or insistent, you will be mastered by that eagerness and insistence. If you make a habit of paying it too much regard, delaying your commands until sense has been heard and consulted, the odds are two to one that it will prevail, or at the very least it will be a great trouble to you, proving a traitor within your own breast and keeping you in continual danger through its temptations. Therefore never loose the reins. Keep sense under constant governance, if you value either your safety or your peace.
Direction 8. You can tell whether sense or faith and reason holds chief authority by identifying which of their objects you treat as your highest end, what you count your greatest good, what you love and delight in and pursue accordingly. If the objects of sense are treated as your best and highest end, then sense certainly holds the governing power. But if the objects of faith and reason, God himself and eternal life, are treated as your best and highest end, then faith and reason are the ruling power.
Even if you employ the greatest understanding and policy in pursuit of sensual things, riches, honor, worldly greatness, or bodily pleasures, this does not prove that reason is governing. It proves all the more strongly that sense has conquered, that reason has been captured and degraded by sense, and that reason crouches beneath it as a willing slave. And the greater your learning, wit, and ability, and the nobler your upbringing, the greater the victory and dominion of sense, that it can subdue and press into its service faculties so noble.
Direction 9. Though sense must be thus absolutely ruled, its proper powers must neither be disabled, suppressed, nor denied.
You must keep your horse strong and fit for his work, though not headstrong and unruly. You must not prevent him from using his strength, even though you do not grant him the rule. Nor would you deny that he may be physically stronger than the rider, even while the rider holds the governing authority. The horse possesses more of what might be called natural power, though the authority of rule belongs to the rider. So it is here.
1.) No one should destroy his bodily sense. The keenest sense is the best servant to the soul, provided it is not headstrong and too impetuous. The body must be disciplined to the point of being "kept under and brought into subjection," but not disabled from its service to the soul (1 Cor 9:27).
2.) Nor must we forbid or abstain from the exercise of the senses in their proper subordinate role to the exercise of the interior senses (Heb 5:14). It is indeed a smaller loss to part with a right hand or a right eye than to lose salvation; but this does not prove that we are driven to such an extreme as to be forced to choose between them, unless persecution puts us to it.
3.) Nor must we deny the reliability of sensitive perception when it keeps its proper place. The Papists do exactly this when they insist that it is necessary to salvation to believe that the sight, taste, smell, and touch of every person in the world who receives the sacrament are certainly deceived, that what they perceive as bread and wine is not bread and wine at all. If all the senses of all sound and rational people are certainly deceived in this, we have no way of knowing when they are not deceived, and no certainty of faith or knowledge is possible.
If someone replies that the Church tells us sense is deceived in this case, and only in this case, the answer is this: unless it is first granted that sense, rightly employed, yields certain apprehension, there can be no certainty that any church exists, that any man exists, that there is a world, or that the Church ever said anything, or that any of its members said anything. And if sense is that fallible, the Church itself may be deceived, since it arrives at all its knowledge by means of sense.
To deny faith is the property of an infidel. To deny reason is to deny humanity, and is fittest for a madman or a beast (if reason could be denied by one who had no reason). But to deny the reliability of sense itself, the united senses of all sound people, concerning the proper objects of those senses, reveals that ambition can construct a religion that brings mankind below the beasts, reducing him to something like a mushroom, so that Rome may have subjects capable of submitting to her governance, and all this under the pretense of honoring faith and saving souls. It makes God the destroyer of nature under the guise of perfecting it, and the deceiver of nature under the guise of building it up.
Direction 10. Sense must not be made the judge of matters that lie above it, the proper objects of faith and reason, nor must we argue negatively from our senses in such cases, which God in nature never submitted to their jurisdiction.
We cannot say there is no God, no heaven, no hell, no angels, no souls of men, simply because we do not see them. We cannot say, "I do not see the antipodes, nor other kingdoms of the world, and therefore no such place exists." By the same token, we say, as well as the Papists, that sense is no judge of whether the spiritual body of Christ is present in the sacrament, any more than it can judge whether an angel is present here. But sense combined with reason is the judge of whether bread and wine are present, or else human understanding can judge of nothing.
Christ would have had Thomas believe without seeing and touching, and he pronounces blessed those who neither see nor touch him yet believe. But he never blesses anyone for believing contrary to the sight, touch, and taste of all those in the world who have sound senses and sound minds.
The Papist appeal to the Virgin’s conception of Christ proves nothing against this position, for it does not belong to sense to judge whether a virgin may conceive. Nor will any rational person’s reason conclude that the Creator, who in making the world out of nothing was the sole cause, cannot supply the place of a partial secondary cause in generation. Rome might more plausibly argue, with Aristotle, against creation itself, that "out of nothing, nothing comes." But it is beyond question that the reliability of sense is not at all implicated in this question; and it is sufficiently demonstrated by Christians that God can create without any pre-existing matter.
Reason can see much further than sense, aided by the data of sense; and further still, aided by divine revelation received through faith. To argue negatively against the conclusions of reason or divine revelation, on the mere ground that sense does not perceive what they affirm, is to reduce a human being to a beast. We must not be so irrational or impious as to say there is nothing beyond what we have seen, felt, tasted, and so on. If we readily believe other travelers who have seen distant lands that there are other parts of the world, we have every reason to believe the sealed testimony of God himself that there are such higher worlds and powers as he has declared. In both cases our use of sense is the same: in the one, we hear or read the human report of countries we have never visited; in the other, we hear or read God’s own revelation by the same faculties of sense.
If they will make the question whether the senses may be deceived, I answer: we do not doubt that they may, through distance from the object, or through disorders in the sense, or through some mismatch in the sense itself or in the medium through which it perceives. But if the sense itself, and all the means, and the objects have their natural soundness, aptitude, and disposition, it is a contradiction to say that it is deceived. That is to say it is not the sense we are supposing it to be. If God deceives it in that way, he makes it another thing altogether: it is no longer the same, and will not admit the same definition.
However that may be, it is perfectly evident that since the senses are the first entrance and inlet of knowledge, the first certainty must lie there, and is presupposed by every certain judgment of the intellect. If the senses err, all subsequent certainty that rests upon their certainty is destroyed; and an error in the first reception, like an error in the first digestion, is not corrected by the second. If God should leave everyone under a fallibility of sense, he would leave no certainty in the world. I ask those who know the definition of a lie to consider whether this is not to make God out to lie in the very frame of nature, and to rule the world by constant lies, when it is impossible for God to lie.
And even if this blasphemy were granted them, it would still be a man’s duty to judge by such senses as he has about the objects of sense. For if God has made them fallible, we cannot make them better, nor can we create in ourselves a reason that does not presuppose the judgment of sense, or that can supply the sense’s ordinary, natural defects. So the Roman faith of transubstantiation, in denying the reality of the bread and the wine, does not merely unman the world; it brings man lower than a beast, makes sense to be no sense, hands the world over to be governed by natural deceits and lies, and banishes all certainty of faith and reason from the earth.
And after all this, with such extraordinary enmity to charity as makes man more like the devil than could easily be believed, they sentence to hell everyone who does not believe it. They decree that such people be burned first here on earth; that temporal lords who favor them, or who will not drive them out of their lands, be deposed from their dominions; and that their subjects be absolved from their allegiance and their dominions given to others. You may read all this in the third canon of the Lateran General Council under Innocent III.
Direction 11. Never look at any object of sense through sense alone, and do not stop there. Let reason begin where sense ends, and always perceive by faith or reason the part that is invisible, just as you perceive by sense the part that is visible. From what is seen, rise toward what is unseen. If God had given us eyes, ears, taste, and touch but no mind, we would rightly exercise no faculty but what we had. Yet he who gave us the higher faculty surely requires that we use it as well as the lower.
And remember that these faculties are not simply parallel: the sensitive is subordinate to the intellectual. What the created thing reveals through sense to the intellect therefore points to something to which the objects of sense are themselves subordinate. If you stop at the things you perceive and do not look through to the principle that animates them, the power that orders and rules them, and the end for which they were made and must be used, you are playing the beast. You see nothing but a dead carcass without a soul, a useless, meaningless thing. You know nothing to any real purpose, not even the creature itself, while you remain ignorant of its use and meaning and cut it off from its life, its guide, and its end.
Direction 12. First, always look upon everything you perceive by sense as the product of the will of the invisible God, depending on him more completely than sunlight depends on the sun; never see or taste any creature in separation from God. Do you want to know what a plant is while ignoring the earth that bears and nourishes it? Do you want to know what a fish is while remaining ignorant that it lives in water? Do you want to know what a branch or fruit is while not knowing it grows on the tree?
The nature of things cannot be known apart from knowing their causes and their proper relations. Knowing incoherent scraps and fragments is as good as no knowledge at all. To know a hand as though it were no part of the body, or to know an eye or nose without knowing a head, or a body without knowing its life or soul, is not to know it at all, you have made it into something else. The difference between a wise person and a fool is that the wise person looks comprehensively to things as they stand together, takes all in at once, and leaves out nothing useful to his end; the fool sees one thing and overlooks another that is necessary to the true knowledge or use of what he sees.
See God as the cause and life of everything you see. As a carcass is a ghastly sight without the soul, and quickly corrupts and stinks once separated, so the creature without God is an unlovely sight, and quickly corrupts and becomes a snare or a nuisance to you. God is the beauty of all that is beautiful, the strength of all that is strong, the glory of the sun and all that is glorious, the wisdom of all that is wise, and the goodness of all that is good, being the sole original and total cause of all. You play the brute when you see the creature and overlook its Maker, from whom it derives whatever it is. Will you study the sundial and overlook the sun? Remember that the purpose of every creature is to show you God, and so the purpose of every sense is to advance the knowledge of him.
Direction 13. See God as the Conductor, Orderer, and Disposer of all creatures according to their natures, whether they act necessarily or freely, and never watch any of the motions or events of the world without observing God’s interest and overruling hand in them. Sense reaches only to effects and events; reason and faith can see the First Cause and Disposer of all. Again: if you look only at the particles of things by sense and do not see God setting all together and doing his work through those who never dream of it, you see only the separate gears and components of a clock, knowing nothing of the one who made and keeps it, who applies the weight and winds it up to serve his ends. Joseph could say, "God sent me hither," when his brethren sold him into Egypt; and David recognized his Father’s rod in Shimei’s curse.
Direction 14. See God as the End of every creature; observe how all things are ordered for his service; and be sure you do not stop at any creature without referring it to a higher end. Otherwise, as I have said before, you will be like a child or an illiterate person who opens a book and marvels at the printer’s craftsmanship and the neat arrangement of the letters, but never attends to or understands the subject, the meaning, or the purpose. Or like someone who looks at a fine portrait and gives no thought either to the one who painted it or to the one it represents. Or like someone who gazes at an inn sign and praises the workmanship but does not understand that it is placed there to direct him to food and lodging within.
This folly and sin is all the greater because it is the very end of God in all his works of creation and providence to reveal himself by them to the rational world. Must God display his power, wisdom, and goodness so wonderfully in the frame of creation, and in his daily general and particular providence, and shall man, who daily sees all this, overlook the intended use and end, making all this glorious work as nothing, or as lost to him? Sense knows no end but its own delight and the natural contentment that the objects of sense afford the sensitive creature. But reason must take up the work where sense ends its course, and carry all home to him who is the end of all. "For of him, and through him, and to him, are all things, to whom be glory for ever. Amen." (Rom 11:36)
Direction 15. Besides the general use and ultimate end of every creature, work toward a clear acquaintance with the particular use and nearer end of everything you have to do with, the way each thing serves your ultimate end, and suppose you always saw that special use written as a title upon each creature.
Suppose upon your Bible were written: "The Word of the living God, to acquaint me with himself and his will, that I may please, glorify, and enjoy him for ever." Upon your godly friend suppose you saw written: "A servant of God who bears his image, appointed to accompany and assist me in his service unto life everlasting." Upon your food suppose you saw written: "The provisions of my Father, sent me as from my Saviour’s hands, not to gratify my sensuality and serve my disordered desires, but to refresh and strengthen my body for his service in my passage to everlasting life." So upon your clothes, your servants, your goods, your cattle, your houses, and everything you have, inscribe their proper use and end.
Direction 16. Know both the final and the immediate danger of everything you have to do with, and suppose you always saw them written upon every thing you see. The final danger is hell; the immediate danger in general is sin, but you must discern what particular sin each creature will be made a temptation to by the devil and the flesh.
Suppose you saw written upon money and riches: "The bait of covetousness and all evil, to pierce me through with many sorrows and then to damn me." Suppose you saw written upon grand buildings, estates, honors, and rank: "The great price the devil would give for souls, baits to tempt men to the immoderate love of fleshly pleasures, and to draw their hearts from God and heaven to their damnation." Suppose you saw written upon beauty and upon tempting actions and dress: "The bait of lust, by which the devil corrupts the minds of men to their damnation." Suppose you saw written on the playhouse door: "The stage of the mountebank of hell, who here cheats men of their precious time and entices them to vanity, luxury, and damnation, under pretence of instructing them by a nearer and more pleasant way than preachers do." The same I say of gambling, recreations, and company: see the particular snare in all.
Direction 17. To this end, be well acquainted with your own particular inclinations and disorders, so that you may know which creature is likely to prove most dangerous to you and there keep the strictest watch. If you are prone to pride, keep furthest from the baits of pride and watch most carefully against them. If you are prone to covetousness, watch most against the baits of covetousness. If you are inclined to lust, stay away from the sight of alluring objects. Knowledge of your temperament and your disease must direct you both in your diet and your remedy.
Direction 18. Live in a constant course of obedience, and suppose you saw the law of God written upon everything you see. When you look on any tempting beauty, suppose you saw written on the forehead: "Thou shalt not lust. Whoremongers and adulterers God will judge. They shall not enter into the kingdom of God." See upon the forbidden dish or cup the prohibition of God: "Thou shalt not eat or drink this." See upon money and riches this written: "Thou shalt not covet." See upon the face of all the world: "Love not the world, nor the things that are in the world: if any man love the world, the love of the Father is not in him." So see the will of God upon all things.
Direction 19. Do not make the objects of sense more tempting and dangerous to yourselves than they need be; take special care, as far as in you lies, to order everything so that you may have as much of the benefit and as little of the snare of the creature as possible. Would you not be gluttonous pleasers of your appetite? Then do not choose too full a table, nor overly pleasant and tempting drinks or dishes, though do choose what is most useful to your health. Would you not overvalue the world, your present house, lands, or station? Then do not be your own instruments in gilding and sweetening your bait. If you put in the sugar, the devil and the flesh will put in the poison. Will you make everything as pleasant and lovely as you can, while you believe that loving them too much is the greatest danger to your salvation? Will you be your own greatest tempters, and then ask God not to lead you into temptation?
Direction 20. Do not let the tempting object come too near your senses, for nearness inflames the sensitive appetite and creates opportunity for sin. Do not come too close to the fire if you would not be burned, yet use prudence in keeping the fire’s usefulness for warmth, while still avoiding the burning. Distance from the snares of pride, lust, passion, and other sins is a well-proven remedy; nearness is their strength.
Direction 21. Accustom your souls to frequent and familiar exercise about their invisible objects, just as your senses are exercised about theirs. As you are daily and hourly seeing, tasting, and hearing the creature, do not be only rarely engaged in the humble adoration of him who appears to you in them. Otherwise, familiarity will make the creature so close to you, and disuse will make God so strange, that by degrees you will lose his acquaintance, become like carnal and sensual men, live wholly by sense, and forget the holy exercise of the life of faith.
Direction 22. Do not lose your humble sense of the corruption of your hearts, how readily they, like tinder, take fire from every temptation, and never grow reckless and confident in yourselves. Holy fear is necessary to watchfulness, and watchfulness is necessary to your escape and safety. Peter’s self-confidence led him to deny his Lord. Had Noah, Lot, and David been more afraid of the sin, they would likely have escaped it. It is part of the character of the beastly heretics that Jude denounces, that they were "spots in their feasts of charity, when they feasted with the church, feeding themselves without fear." When the knowledge and sense of your weakness and sinful inclination are gone, fear is gone, and when fear is gone, safety is gone, and your fall is near.
CHAPTER 19
PARTICULAR DIRECTIONS FOR THE GOVERNMENT OF THE EYES
Direction 1. Know the uses that your sight is given you for. These are: 1. To see the works of God, so that through them your mind may see God himself. 2. To read the Word of God, so that in it you may perceive his mind. 3. To see the servants of God whom you must love, and the poor whom you must relieve or pity, and all the visible objects of your duty; to conduct your body in the discharge of its office in all the matters of the world; and in particular, often to look up toward heaven, the place where your blessed Lord is glorified, and from which he shall come to take you to his glory.
Direction 2. Remember the sins the eye is most in danger of, so that you may be watchful and escape.
1. You must guard against a proud, lofty, and scornful eye, which looks on yourself with admiration and delight, as the peacock is said to do on his tail, and on others as beneath you with slighting and disdain.
2. You must guard against a lustful, wanton eye, which secretly draws your heart toward a befooling piece of dirty flesh, and steals from beauty and ornaments a spark to kindle that fire which prepares for everlasting fire.
3. Guard against a greedy, covetous eye, which, like Achan and Gehazi, looks on the bait to tempt you to unlawful love and desire, and so brings you, through their sin, to their ruin.
4. Guard against a luxurious, gluttonous, and drunken eye, which lingers on the forbidden fruit, the tempting dish, and the delicious cup, until it has provoked the appetite of that greedy worm which must be pleased, though at the cost of your damnation.
5. Guard against a gazing, wandering eye, which, like a vagrant, has no home, no work, and no master, but roams about seeking death and finding matter for temptation. "Wisdom is before him that hath understanding; but the eyes of a fool are in the ends of the earth" (Prov 17:24).
6. Guard against an envious eye, which looks with dislike and discontent at the prosperity of others, especially those who stand in the way of your own interest (see Dr. Hammond on Matthew 6). "Is thine eye evil because I am good?" (Matt 20:15). It is the envious eye that in Scripture is called by the name of an evil eye. It is an eye that would rather see evil than good befall another, as in Deuteronomy 15:9: "Lest thine eye be evil against thy poor brother," etc. It is an eye that grudges another anything that is ours (Prov 23:6; Prov 28:22; Mark 7:22).
7. Guard against a passionate, cruel eye that kindles the hurting or reviling fire in your breast, or is kindled by it, one that draws matter of rage or malice from everything in another that displeases you.
8. Guard against a self-conceited and censorious eye, which looks on all the actions of another with quarreling, undervaluing, censure, or reproach.
9. Guard against a fond and fanciful eye that falls too deeply in love with houses, friend, child, goods, or whatever else pleases it.
10. Guard against a sleepy, sluggish eye that is closed to good, and would rather sleep than watch, read, pray, and labor.
11. Abhor a malignant eye, which looks with hatred on a godly man, on the holy assemblies and communion of saints, and on holy actions, one that can hardly see a man of exemplary zeal and holiness without the heart rising against him, and wishing all such were expelled or cut off from the earth. This is the heart that bears the image of the devil in his most vivid colors, since he is the father of such, as Christ calls him (John 8:44).
12. Abhor a hypocritical eye, which is lifted up to heaven when the heart is fixed on earth, on lusts, on honors, on sports or pleasure, or plotting mischief against the just. Know the evil and danger of all these diseases of the eye.
Direction 3. Remember that the eye, being the noblest and yet the most dangerous sense, must have the strictest watch. Sight is frequently used in Scripture to represent all the senses, and living by sight is the opposite of living or walking by faith: "We walk by faith, not by sight" (2 Cor 5:7). A sensual life is called a "walking in the ways of our heart and in the sight of the eyes" (Eccl 11:9). An ungoverned eye reveals the power of ungoverned senses. A great abundance of good or evil enters through these doors; everything lies open if you do not guard them.
Direction 4. Remember that your sin or duty, and equally your sorrow or joy, depend greatly on the government of your eyes, and the eye’s present pleasure is the common path to later sorrow. What a flood of grief did David let into his heart by one unlawful look!
Direction 5. Remember that your eye is much of your honor or dishonor, because it is the index of your mind. In the eye you see what is nearest the mind itself, the most immediate expression of the invisible soul. How easily a wandering eye, a wanton eye, a proud eye, a luxurious eye, a malicious eye, a passionate eye betrays the treasure of sin that lies in the heart! Your soul lies more open to the view of others in your eye than in any other part; your very reputation, therefore, should make you keep watch.
Direction 6. Remember that your eye is of all the senses most subject to the will, and therefore there is the more duty or sin in it, for voluntariness is what makes an act moral, whether in good or evil. Your will cannot so easily command your feeling, tasting, hearing, or smelling as it can your sight; it can open or shut the eye so readily, in a moment, that you have all the less excuse if the eye is not governed, for all its faults will be shown to be that much more deliberate.
Ham was cursed for not turning away his eyes from his father’s shame, and Shem and Japhet were blessed for doing so. The righteous man is described thus: "He that stoppeth his ears from hearing of blood, and shutteth his eyes from seeing evil; he shall dwell on high" (Isa 33:15), etc. Men’s idols, which they are commanded to cast away, are called "the abomination of their eyes" (Ezek 20:7). Covetousness is called "the lust of the eyes" (1 John 2:16). Of the unclean it is said that they have "eyes full of adultery" (2 Pet 2:14). And as sin, so punishment is placed on the eye: "The eyes of the lofty shall be humbled" (Isa 5:15). Indeed, the whole bodies of the daughters of Zion are threatened with dishonor, nakedness, scabs, stench, and shame, because they walked with "wanton eyes, haughtily, and mincing as they go," etc. (Isa 3:16).
Direction 7. Therefore let believing reason and a holy, resolved, fixed will keep a continual law upon your eyes, and let them be used as under a constant government. This is what Job calls "making a covenant with them" (Job 31:1). Do not leave them at liberty, as though a look contained nothing of duty or sin, or as though you might look on whatever you wished. Will you go to foolish, tempting plays, gaze on vain and alluring objects, and think there is no harm in any of this? Do you think your eye cannot sin as well as your tongue? Undoubtedly much sin is both committed by it and enters in through it. Stay away from the bait, therefore, or command your eye to turn away.
Direction 8. Remember how much easier and safer it is to stop sin here at the gates and outworks, than to drive it out again once it has entered. If a tempting sight has tainted even your imagination or memory, as such sights will almost unavoidably do, it has there spawned material for a swarm of vain and sinful thoughts. It is nearly impossible to rule the thoughts without ruling the eye; the passions are at once contaminated, and the citadel of the heart is taken before you are aware. You little know, when a lustful or covetous look begins the game, to what a sorrowful end it leads. Many a horrid adultery, murder, robbery, and wickedness has begun with nothing more than a look; a look has begun what has brought many thousands to the gallows and many millions to hell.
Direction 9. Keep both eye and mind employed in continual duty, and do not let them be idle and free to wander upon vanity. Idleness and neglect of spiritual and bodily duty are what begin and nurse much sensuality. Let your spiritual work and your lawful bodily labors occupy your time and thoughts, commanding and keeping your senses in their proper services.
Direction 10. Beg daily of God the preserving assistance of his grace and providence. Ask for his inward grace to confirm you and assist you in your resolutions and watchfulness, and for his providence and gracious ordering of you and of surrounding objects, to keep temptations from before your eyes. While others will go out of their way to gaze on vain or tempting shows, or to admire like children the vanities of the playful and pompous world, go instead to God with David’s prayer: "Turn away mine eyes from beholding vanity; and quicken me in thy way" (Ps 119:37). Imitate him also in this: "Mine eyes prevent the night watches, that I might meditate on thy word" (Ps 119:148). And make every look a passage to your mind, to carry it up to God, and pray: "Open thou mine eyes, that I may behold wondrous things out of thy law" (Ps 119:18). Observe these directions alongside the general ones already given.
CHAPTER 20
DIRECTIONS FOR THE GOVERNMENT OF THE EAR
Direction 1. Employ your ears in the duties they were made for, and to that end understand those duties. They are as follows:
1. To be the organ by which we receive such communications from others as are necessary for our dealings in the world and for the duties of our various relationships and callings.
2. To hear the Word of God delivered publicly by his appointed teachers of the church.
3. To hear the counsel of those who privately advise us for our good, and the reproofs of those who tell us of our sin and danger.
4. To hear the praises of God set forth by his church in public, and by particular servants in private.
5. To hear from our ancestors and from those learned in history what was done in the times before us.
6. To hear the complaints and petitions of the poor, the needy, and the distressed, so that we may show them compassion and work toward their relief.
7. To be the passage by which grief and hatred enter our hearts through the sinful words we hear unwillingly.
Direction 2. Know which are the sins of the ear, so that you may avoid them. They are as follows:
1. A careless ear, which hears the Word of God and the private exhortations of his servants as if it heard them not.
2. A sottish, sleepy ear, which hears the Word of God as nothing more than a confused sound, and neither understands nor feels what it hears.
3. A scornful ear, which despises the message of God, and the reproofs and counsel of men, and disdains to be reproved or taught.
4. An obstinate, stubborn ear, which pays no regard to advice, or will not yield.
5. A profane and impious ear, which loves to hear oaths, curses, and profane and blasphemous expressions.
6. A carnal ear, which loves to hear of fleshly things but takes no pleasure in words that carry the flavor of holiness.
7. An airy, hypocritical ear, which loves the music and melody more than the sense and the soul’s spiritual elevation toward God; which prizes the cadence, composition, and tone above the substance of preaching, prayer, and other such duties; and which serves God with the ear while the heart remains far from him.
8. A fastidious ear, which loses all appetite for the most profitable sermons, prayers, or discourses if they are not exactly ordered and expressed; which slights or forfeits the offered benefit for some imperfection in the manner of the offer, or in the instrument; which throws away all the gold because a piece or two has caught a little rust; and which perhaps quarrels with the style of the sacred Scriptures as not exact or fine enough for its expectations.
9. An itching ear, which runs after novelties and heaps up teachers for itself, and likes something extraordinary better than the things that are necessary.
10. A selfish ear, which loves to hear everything that confirms its own conceits, which loves to be flattered and smoothed over by others, and which can endure nothing that crosses its opinions.
11. A proud ear, which loves its own applause, is much pleased with its own praises, and hates all who speak of it with mean, undervaluing words.
12. A peevish, impatient ear, which is nettled by almost everything it hears; which can endure nothing but silken words, oiled and sugared and fitted by flattery or the lowest submission to its perverse mind; and which is so hard to please that only those who have graduated in the art of pleasing can manage it.
13. A bold, presumptuous ear, which will hear false teachers and deceivers out of a proud conceit and confidence in its own ability to discern what is true and what is false.
14. An ungodly ear, which can easily hear the reproach of holiness, and scorns the servants and ways of Christ.
15. A neutral, indifferent ear, which hears either good or evil without much love or hatred, but with a dull and cold indifference.
16. A dissembling, time-serving ear, which can compliantly hear one side speak for holiness and the other speak against it, and suit itself to whatever company and conversation it meets with.
17. An uncharitable ear, which willingly hears the censures, backbitings, slanders, and revilings used against others, even against the best.
18. An unnatural ear, which can easily and willingly hear the dishonor of parents or other near relations, if some carnal interest has but engaged it against their honor.
19. A rebellious, disobedient ear, which does not heed the just commands of magistrates, parents, masters, and other governors, but listens with greater pleasure to the words of seditious persons who dishonor them.
20. A filthy, unclean, and adulterous ear, which loves to hear filthy, ribald speeches, love-songs, romances, lascivious plays, and the talk of wanton lust and dalliance.
21. A self-provoking ear, which listens after everything that others say against it, which may kindle hatred, dislike, or passion within it.
22. A busy, meddling ear, which loves to hear of other men’s faults, or of matters that do not concern it, and to listen to twattlers, carry-tales, and make-bates, and to have to do with evil reports.
23. A timorous, cowardly, unbelieving ear, which trembles at every threat from man, even in a cause that is God’s own and that he has promised to vindicate.
24. An idle ear, which can listen to idle, time-wasting talk, and so makes the sins of twattlers your own.
In all these ways, and more, you are in danger of sinning by the ear, of becoming partakers in the sins of all whose sinful words you hear, and of turning into sin the very words of God and of his servants that were spoken for your good.
Direction 3. Know when hearing evil, and not hearing good, is your sin. That is:
1. When it is not out of any imposed necessity but of your own voluntary choice; when you might avoid it on lawful terms without a greater hurt, and will not.
2. When you do not hate the evil you are compelled to hear, and do not love the good that necessity keeps you from hearing; but your heart complies with your necessities.
3. When you do not show as much disowning and dislike of the evil you hear as you might without an inconvenience greater than the benefit; but instead make it your own by sinful silence or compliance.
4. When you are presumptuous and fearless of your danger.
Direction 4. Know where the danger of such sinful hearing lies.
1. In displeasing God, who does not love to hear his children listening to those who are abusing him, nor to see them playing too boldly about fire or water, nor to touch any stinking or defiling thing, but calls to them, "Come out from among them, and be ye separate, saith the Lord, and touch not the unclean thing, and I will receive you" (2 Cor 6:16–18).
2. It is dangerous to your imagination and memory, which quickly receive hurtful impressions from what you hear. Even if you hear provoking words against your will, it is hard to escape taking in some hurtful impression from them; and if you hear lascivious, filthy words against your will, much more if you hear them willingly, it is two to one that they leave thoughts in your mind that may breed further sin. It is dangerous to your passions and affections, lest they catch fire before you are aware. It is dangerous to your understanding, lest it be perverted and seduced, and to your will, lest it be turned toward evil and turned away from good. And how quickly all of this is done.
3. It is dangerous to the speaker, lest your voluntary hearing encourage him in his sin and hinder his repentance.
4. And it is dishonorable to God and to godliness.
Direction 5. Do your best to live in such company as will let you hear what is good and edifying, and to escape the company whose conversation is hurtful and corrupt. Do not run yourselves into this temptation. Be sure you have a call to be there, and let your call be discerned by these:
1. By your office or place: whether any duty of your office or relationship binds you to be there.
2. By your ends: whether you are there as a physician to do them good, as Christ went among sinners, or to do the work of your proper calling; or whether you are there out of a carnal, man-pleasing, or time-serving spirit.
3. By the measure of your ability to attain those ends.
4. By the measure of your danger of receiving the infection.
5. By the quality of your company, and the probability of good or evil in the outcome.
Direction 6. When you are called into ill company, go armed with both defensive and offensive weapons, foreseeing what danger or duty you are likely to be cast upon. Foresee what discourse you are likely to hear, and prepare yourselves accordingly. Let your first preparation be to preserve yourselves from the hurt, and your next to confute the evil and convict the sinful speaker, or at least to preserve the endangered hearers, if you have both the ability and the opportunity.
If you are to hear a seducing, heretical teacher, one kind of preparation is to be made. If you are to hear a beastly, filthy talker, another kind is to be made. If you are to hear a cunning pharisee, or a malignant enemy of godliness, reproach, cavil, or wrangle against the Scriptures or the ways of God, yet another kind is to be made. And if you are to hear only the senseless scorns, or the railings and bawlings, of ignorant, profane, and sensual sots, still another kind is to be made. To give you particular directions for your preparation against every such danger would make my work too tedious. But remember how much depends on your own preparation or unpreparedness.
Direction 7. Do not sinfully fail to supply good discourse yourselves, if you would not be ensnared by the bad discourse of others. Your own good discourse may forestall, divert, shame, or disappoint their evil discourse. Turn the stream another way, and do it wisely, so that you do not expose yourselves and your cause to scorn and laughter. Do it with such zeal as the cause requires, so that you are not borne down by their greater zeal in evil. And where it is unfit for you to speak, let your countenance or your departure signify your dislike and sorrow.
Direction 8. Take special pains to mortify those sins which the unavoidable discourse of your company most tempts you to, so that where the devil does most to hurt you, you may there do most in your own defense.
Does the talk you hear tend most toward heresy, seduction, or turning you from the truth? Study all the more to be established in the truth: read more books in its defense, and hear more of what wise and godly men say against the error you are tempted to. Does your company tempt you to profaneness, or to dislike of a holy life? Apply yourselves all the more to God, give yourselves up to holiness, and let your study and practice be such as tend to keep your souls in relish with holiness and in hatred of sin. Is it pride that their applauding discourse tempts you to? Study all the more the doctrine of humiliation. Do they incite you to lust, or to drunkenness, gluttony, sinful recreations, or excess? Labor all the harder at the work of mortification, and keep the strictest guard where they assault you.
Direction 9. Do not be unacquainted with the particular weaknesses and dangers of your own hearts, or with any of your sinful inclinations. When you know where the wall is weakest, you can make the best defense there. A wanton word will set a wanton heart on fire, which a sober mind hears with pity as a bedlam kind of speech. A peevish, passionate heart is instantly disturbed and kindled by words that a well-composed soul scarcely notices.
Direction 10. Hear every sinful word as dictated by the devil, and suppose you saw him all the while at the speaker’s elbow, putting each word into his mouth and telling him what to say. For it is as truly the devil who suggests them all as if you saw him. Suppose you saw him behind the railer, hissing him on as boys do dogs in a fight, and bidding him call you this and that. Suppose you saw him at the malignant’s ear, bidding him revile a holy life and speak evil of the ways and servants of the Lord. Suppose you saw him behind the wanton, bidding him use such ribald talk, or on the stage suggesting it to the actors, or at the ear of those who would stir you to passion, telling them what to say against you. This supposition is a just one, and holding it before you would do much to preserve you.
Direction 11. Suppose you heard the outcome attached to the end of every speech. When you hear someone tempting you to lust, suppose he said, "Come, let us take our pleasures awhile, and be damned for ever." So also with every word that tempts you to any other sin: if the tempter puts in the sin, you put in God’s wrath and hell. Do not separate what God has joined together, but along with the serpent, see the sting.
Direction 12. Watch for the point at which the infection first seizes on you, and immediately take an antidote to expel it, if you love your souls. The signs of infection are these:
1. Your zeal abates, and you grow more indifferent to what you hear.
2. Next, you feel some little inclination toward it.
3. Next, you venture a little upon imitating it.
4. And lastly, you come to full consent, and so to ruin.
If you feel even a slackening of your dislike and hatred, or any filth or tincture left on your thoughts and imagination, go immediately and shake it off. Bewail it to God in true repentance, wash your souls in the blood of Christ, cast up the poison by holy resolutions, and sweat out the remnant by the fervent exercises of love and holiness.
CHAPTER 21
DIRECTIONS FOR GOVERNING THE TASTE AND APPETITE
Title 1. Directions against Gluttony
Most of what needs to be said about the nature and evil of this sin has already been covered in Chapter 4, Part 7, on flesh-pleasing. But something more particular must be said: 1. to show what gluttony is and what it is not; 2. to show its causes; 3. to show its odiousness; and 4. to set out the more particular helps and means against it.
I. Gluttony is a voluntary excess in eating, for the gratification of appetite or some other carnal end. The Israelites’ behavior in Numbers 11, loathing manna because they demanded variety, was a sin of gulosity or gluttony, driven more by appetite than by health. Note here, first, the matter, and second, the end or effect of this excess.
1.) The excess is sometimes one of quantity, when more is eaten than is fitting.
2.) Or it may be an excess in delicious quality, when more regard is paid to delight and sweetness than is fitting.
3.) Or it may be an excess in frequency and ordinary unseasonableness of eating, when men eat too often or sit at table too long.
4.) It may be an excess in costliness, when men feed themselves at too high a rate.
5.) Or it may be an excess of curiosity in the dressing, saucing, and ordering of everything.
Second, gluttony is usually pursued for some carnal end. Whether it could properly be called gluttony if a man supposed himself bound at a sacrifice or thanksgiving to eat excessively, and so made the service of God his end, that we need not inquire (though I see no reason why it may not bear that name). Such a case is rare, and it is undoubtedly a sin; and it is gluttony when it is done to please others who press you importunately. But common gluttony is when eating is done to please the appetite with a pleasure that neither helps health nor duty, but ordinarily hurts both body and soul, the body being harmed by the excess, and the soul by the disordered pleasure.
Even fruitful land, says Plutarch, does not enrich if it costs too much to cultivate. So it is here.
Indeed, it is a kind of gluttony and excess when men will not fast or abstain when they are required to do so from something they might otherwise use moderately and without blame. If a man does not ordinarily eat excessively or luxuriously, yet if he will not abstain from his temperate diet, either at a public fast, or when suppressing the body’s desires demands it, or when his physician would restrict his diet for his health and his condition would be worsened by what he eats, this is disordered eating and excess for that person at that time. Or if the delight the appetite takes in a particular food that is harmful to the body prevails over reason and health so that a person will not forgo it, that is a degree of gulosity or gluttony, even if in quantity and quality the food is in itself quite ordinary.
From this you may see several things:
1.) It is not the same quantity that constitutes excess in one person as in another. A laboring man may eat somewhat more than one who does not labor, and a strong and healthy body more than the weak and sick. Excess in quantity must be reckoned with respect to that particular person at that particular time, when he eats more than profits his health or his duty, in order to please his appetite.
2.) The frequency of eating must likewise be considered with the person’s circumstances. One person may rationally eat a little and often for health’s sake, while another eats more often than is profitable to health out of self-indulgence. "Woe to thee O land, when thy king is a child, and thy princes eat in the morning. Blessed art thou O land, when thy king is the son of nobles, and thy princes eat in due season, for strength and not for drunkenness." (Eccl 10:16–17)
3.) In the matter of costliness, the same measure cannot be set for a prince and a ploughman: what is luxurious excess in one may be temperance and frugality in another. Yet unprofitable expenditure, which all things considered would do more good directed elsewhere, is excess in anyone.
4.) In curiosity of diet, likewise, a difference must be allowed. The naturally healthy man need not be so particular as the sick; and the ploughman need not be so particular as rank and expectation somewhat require the noble and the rich to be.
5.) As for length of time at table, though needlessly prolonging a meal is a sin in anyone, the poor man is not obliged to spend as much time this way as the rich may do.
6.) Not every delight in food or gratification of appetite is a sin, Isaac’s pleasant meat is an instance (Gen 27:7). Only that delight which men make their end, not referring it to any higher end, is sinful: when the pleasure itself does not tend to health, or to alertness in duty, nor is used with that aim, but merely to please the flesh and invite excess.
7.) It is not necessary that we measure the profitableness of quantity or quality by immediate and present benefits alone, but sometimes by more remote ones. So merciful is God that he allows us what is truly for our good and forbids only what harms us, or at the very least does us no good.
8.) Not every sin in eating is gluttony, but only those described here.
II. The causes of gluttony are these:
1.) The chief cause is a disordered appetite joined with a fleshly mind and will set upon flesh-pleasing as its happiness. "They that are after the flesh do mind the things of the flesh" (Rom 8:6–7). This gulosity, which Clement of Alexandria calls the "Throat devil," is the primary cause. Cicero observed that no one can truly praise temperance who places the highest good in pleasure, for temperance is the enemy of sensual craving. Aristotle writes that the temperate person is one who takes pleasure in denying fleshly pleasures, while the intemperate person is distressed at being unable to have them (Nicomachean Ethics 2.3).
2.) The next cause is the want of strong reason, faith, and a spiritual appetite and mind, which ought to call the glutton away and engage him with higher pleasures, pleasures more suited to his dignity as a human being, and in which his true happiness consists. "They that are after the Spirit do mind the things of the Spirit." Reason alone can do something to lift a man above the happiness of a beast, as the philosophers’ attacks on the Epicureans show. But faith and love, which feast the soul on sweeter delights, must achieve the cure.
3.) Gluttony is greatly increased by habit. When the appetite is regularly satisfied, it becomes more demanding and ungovernable, whereas a habit of temperance makes it manageable and renders excess not a pleasure but a burden. I recall from my own experience that when I first adopted the regimen described by Cornaro and Lessius, which I followed for a time for particular reasons, it seemed somewhat difficult for two or three days; but within a week it became a pleasure, and neither a different kind of food nor a larger quantity was desirable. I think nearly all who confine themselves to one dish in a small quantity find that more is a discomfort rather than a temptation, so powerful is habit, at least in those who are not engaged in very heavy labor.
4.) Idleness and want of diligence in a calling is a great cause of luxury and gluttony. Though labor produces a healthy appetite, it cures a beastly, sensual mind. An idle person has leisure to think of his guts, what to eat and what to drink, and to be longing after this and that; whereas a man wholly occupied in lawful business, especially the kind that engages the mind as well as the body, has no room for such thoughts. The man closely occupied in his studies or other calling has something else to think about besides his appetite.
5.) Another incentive to gluttony is the pride of rich men who, to be counted generous housekeepers and to live in a manner befitting their grandeur, make their houses shops of sin, no better than alehouses. They make their tables a snare to themselves and others through excess, variety, deliciousness, costliness, and elaborateness of fare. They count it an honor that a man may drink to excess in their cellars whenever he pleases, and that their tables offer such provision for gluttony as puts everyone seated at them to the test of their temperance, whether a temptation so near and so studiously prepared can lead them to break the bounds God has set them.
Diogenes Laertius records several sayings of Socrates on this. He said that those who paid a great price for early summer fruit plainly did not expect to live long. When he had invited rich men to supper and Xanthippe was ashamed of the modest fare, he told her, "Be of good cheer: if they are modest and frugal they will not scorn our table; and if they are intemperate, we need take no care about them." And he used to say that other men live in order to eat, while he eats in order to live.
It is a lamentable thing when those who have authority over others and influence over common people think their honor rests upon their sin, indeed upon a constant course of sinning, and think it a dishonor to live in wholesome temperance and to see that those around them do likewise. All of this springs either from overvaluing the esteem and talk of fleshly epicures and being unable to bear the censure of a swine, or from being of the same mind themselves, those who "glory in their shame" (Phil 3:18–19).
6.) Another incentive is the custom of urging and pressing others to eat more and more, as though this were a necessary act of friendship. People have grown so uncharitable and suspicious that they think they are not welcome unless they are pressed to eat; and those who invite them feel they must do this to avoid the suspicion of such a sordid mind.
I do not deny that it is right to urge people to do what is genuinely good for them: if we see that modesty leads someone to eat less than is healthy, we may encourage them to eat more. But as things stand, with no real regard for what is best for others, people consider it a necessary courtesy to press guests to eat more and more until they flatly refuse. Yet among the closest friends, almost no one will warn another against excess, advise him to stop when he has had enough, or point out how easy it is to overstep our limits and how much more naturally we tend to exceed than to fall short. Custom and compliment are thus preferred over temperance and honest care for one another.
You will say, "What will people think of us if we do not urge them to eat, still more, if we actually ask them to eat no more?"
Answer:
1. Put your duty above what others think of you. Put virtue before the opinions or words of men.
2. Even so, if you act wisely, the wise and good will think all the better of you. You can easily let them see that you do it not out of sordid sparing but out of genuine care for temperance and for them, if you speak only when there is real need, whether to eat more or less; if your remarks begin with a general commendation of temperance and are applied to the person only when you see they need help in applying it.
3. It is undeniable that healthy people are far more prone to excess in eating than to deficiency, and that our nature is very strongly inclined to luxury and gluttony, as much as to almost any other sin. It is equally certain that it is a beastly, breeding, odious sin. If this is so, is it not clear that we ought to do a great deal more to help one another resist such excess than to provoke one another toward it? Were it not that we give far more weight to people’s favor, preferences, and opinions than to God and the good of their souls, the question would be quickly settled.
7.) Another cause of gluttony is that rich men are not acquainted with the true use of riches, nor do they think of the account they must one day render to God for all they have. They think their riches are their own, to be used as they please, or that riches have been given them as abundant provision for their bodily comfort, which they may spend on themselves in satisfying their own desires, as long as they drop some crumbs or scraps to the poor.
They think they may be saved by the very path on which the rich man in Luke 16 was damned, the man who wanted to warn his five brothers not to come to that place of torment, yet is himself no warning to those who follow his example. They are clothed in purple and fine linen or silk, and feast splendidly every day, and take their good things in this life, and perhaps imagine they earn credit by giving the scraps to Lazarus, as that rich man probably did also.
But God will one day make them understand that even the richest were only his stewards, who should have distributed his provisions more wisely and improved his talents more faithfully, and that nothing in all their wealth was given them for harmful or unprofitable indulgence of their appetites, nor were they granted any greater allowance for luxury than the poor. If they understood the true use of riches, it would reform them.
Petrarch observed how far this runs in the great: the arts that were once liberal have turned mechanical, and the very men who used to be commanders in war, philosophers, rulers of cities and fathers of their country have become hunters and fowlers; and, so that you may see no hope of recovery is left, what belongs to Gluttony, or beyond doubt to vanity, is now put to the credit of nobility.
8.) Another cause of gluttony is people’s lack of acquaintance with those rational and spiritual exercises in which the benefits of abstinence show themselves most clearly. Even a person engaged in serious, demanding study of any worthy subject finds that temperance brings great clarity and mental freshness, while fullness and excess bring a cloudy heaviness to the mind and dullness to the powers of thought. And a person accustomed to holy contemplation, meditation, reading, prayer, self-examination, or any spiritual exercise above the common level easily discovers a very great difference: how abstinence helps, and how luxury and fullness hinder such work.
These epicures, however, have no acquaintance with any such holy or serious pursuits, nor any desire for them, and are therefore unacquainted with the sweetness and benefit of abstinence. Having no experience of its benefits, they cannot value it. They have nothing to do when they rise from the table but a little talk about worldly business, or pleasantries with company, or sport to empty their paunches for the next meal and sharpen their appetites lest their appetite for luxury should diminish, as the Israelites worshipped the golden calf, and as the heathens worshipped their god Bacchus: "They sat down to eat and drink, and rose up to play." (1 Cor 10:7) Their diet is suited to their work: idle or worldly lives and gluttony agree with one another. But if they were accustomed to better work, they would find the necessity of a better diet.
9.) Another great cause of gluttony is men’s beastly ignorance of what is hurtful or helpful to their very health; of this I have said more in my book Self-Denial. They make their appetites the rule for the quantity and quality of their food, and they think nature instructs them to do so because it gives them such an appetite, and because appetite is the right measure for a beast. But in proving themselves beasts, they take a beast’s measure as their own, as if their natures were not rational but only sensory, or as if nature had not given them reason to govern the senses as a superior faculty.
They seem not to know that God gives the brutes a more limited appetite because they have no reason to restrain it; that he does not set before them the tempting variety of delicacies available to men; or that he gives them a digestion suited to their appetites, while he has made man the rational governor of those animals that are for his special service and apt to exceed. And if his swine, his horses, and his cattle were all left to their own appetites, they would live but a short time. Plutarch’s precepts of health speak to this.
If unrestricted procreation, which is lawful in brutes, is not lawful for mankind, why should people not acknowledge the same holds for appetite? Men have such love of life and fear of death that if they truly knew how much their gluttony hastens their death, that knowledge would do more to restrain most of them than even the fear of eternal death does. But they judge their digestion by how they feel at the moment: if they do not feel sick to their stomachs, or on the verge of vomiting, or if no immediate pain corrects them, they conclude that their gluttony has not harmed them and that they have eaten no more than was good for them. More on this will follow in the Directions.
10.) Another great cause of gluttony is that it has become common custom, and because it goes largely unrecognized, it carries no disgrace, unless men eat till they spew or reach some extraordinary measure. As a result, every man looks at the measure he sees others using and concludes that it is moderation and is right for him. In reality, however, ignorance of basic health and physiology has made gluttony nearly as common as eating itself, among all who are not held back by poverty or sickness. And so every man becomes an example of evil to his neighbor, and each encourages the other in the sin. If gluttony were held in as much disgrace as whoredom, indeed, even as much disgrace as drunkenness, and were as easily observed and as widely noticed, it would contribute greatly to a general reformation.
III. The Greatness of the Sin of Gluttony
To understand the greatness of a sin is the main part of its cure for all who believe there is a God. I will therefore set out next the nature, effects, and accompanying features of gluttony that make it great, and that ought therefore to make it odious to all.
1. Luxury and gluttony are sins utterly contrary to the love of God; they are a form of idolatry, since they claim the heart that God should have. Gluttons are rightly called belly-gods and god-bellies, because the love, care, delight, service, and diligence that belong to God are given instead to the belly and the throat. The glutton loves the pleasure of his appetite more than the pleasure of God. His dishes delight him more than any holy exercise. His thoughts turn more often and more sweetly to his belly than to God or godliness. He labors more to satisfy himself in food and drink than to secure his salvation, justification, and sanctification.
Scripture gives them this name: "whose end is destruction, whose god is their belly, who glory in their shame, who mind earthly things," being enemies to the cross of Christ, that is, to bearing the cross for Christ, to crucifying the flesh, and to the mortifying and suffering elements of religion. (Phil 3:19)
The belly is so devouring an idol that it swallows up more through intemperance and excess than all other idols in the world combined. And remember that the very life of this sin lies in the appetite and the heart. When a man’s heart is set upon his belly, though outward necessity may force him to eat poorly, he is a glutton in heart. When you make a great matter of what you shall eat and drink for the sake of pleasure; when you count it a great loss or hardship to eat plainly and are troubled by it; when your thoughts and conversation run on your belly; and when you lack the indifference between coarse and pleasant food (provided it is wholesome) that all temperate persons possess, that is the heart of gluttony, and is the heart’s forsaking of God and making the appetite its god.
2. Gluttony is self-murder. Though it does not kill suddenly, it kills surely, like the dropsy, which kills as it fills, by degrees. Many of the wisest physicians believe that of those who survive childhood, scarcely one in twenty, or even one in a hundred, dies without gluttony or excess in eating and drinking being a principal cause, though not always the most immediate one. It is thought to kill a hundred to one of all who die at a mature age.
It is a common saying that gluttony kills more than the sword. Seneca observed that whatever birds fly, whatever fish swim, whatever beasts roam, is buried in our bellies; one may well ask why we die so suddenly, since we live on death. Jerome records that he had read of men afflicted with arthritis and gout who were cured when poverty, brought on by the confiscation of their estates, forced them to a plain diet.
Gluttony does not allow its victims to die easily or quickly but torments them first with manifold diseases throughout their lives. You eat more than nature can perfectly digest, and because you do not immediately feel sick, you think it does you no harm, whereas it is altering and corrupting the constitution of the blood and humors by degrees, rendering them crude, unnatural, and unfit for the proper nourishment of the body. The nourishing mass is turned into a burdensome, waste-laden mixture, overloaded with saline or tartarous matter, consisting more of phlegmatic slime or excess serum than of that sweet, nourishing milk of nature, quickened with those spirits and well-proportioned heat, which should make it fit to be the oil of life.
As a result, the body’s candle either sparkles away with salt, or runs down because there is a thief in it, or goes out because the oil has turned to water, or quickly wastes and gutters through the inconsistent softness of its oil. Hence one part is tainted with corruption and another consumed for want of fit nourishment; and the vessels, secretly obstructed by the coarseness or other unfitness of the blood to run its circuit and perform its offices, are the cause of a multitude of pitiable diseases: disorders of the brain, stupor and coma, lethargy, deep unconsciousness, and apoplexy; palsy, convulsion, epilepsy, vertigo, catarrh, headache, and often frenzy and madness, all arising from what gluttony and excess do to the blood and humors.
Asthma usually, and consumption, pleurisy, and pneumonia, and spitting of blood often come from the same source. Even fainting spells, palpitations of the heart, and swooning, which men typically attribute to weakness, usually arise either from nature being oppressed by these secret excrements or putrefying blood, or from a weakness contracted when the blood, vitiated by excess, becomes unfit to nourish the body.
Loathing of food and loss of appetite commonly stem from the crudities and disorders caused by excess. Even the very canine appetite that would still have more is caused by a corruption in the humors thus contracted. Stomach pains, vomiting, cholera, hiccoughs, inflammations, thirsts, these usually trace to this cause.
Wind colic, intestinal obstruction, looseness and fluxes, straining at stool, and ulcers; worms and other troubles in those regions, are usually from the same source. Obstructions of the liver, jaundice, inflammation, abscesses and ulcers, hardening of the liver, and dropsy commonly come from the same source. So too, usually, are inflammations, pains, obstructions, and hardening of the spleen. The stone, kidney torments, stoppage of urine, and ulcers of the kidneys and bladder commonly arise from here as well. Scurvy and most of the fevers in the world, which bring such multitudes to the grave, commonly come from this cause. Even those fevers immediately caused by cold, disorders of the air, or infection are often principally caused by long excess, which corrupts the humors and prepares them for the disease. Gout, hysterical conditions, diseases of the eyes, and ailments of other external parts likewise commonly flow from here. We may rightly say that gluttony enriches landlords, fills the churchyards, and hurries multitudes prematurely to their end.
Chrysostom says that the difference between famine and excess is that famine kills people sooner and ends their pain, while excess putrefies and consumes them through long and painful sicknesses (in Hebr. Hom. 29).
Perhaps you will say that even the most temperate people have diseases. To this, experience teaches me to answer that children are commonly permitted to be voracious and gluttonous, whether in quantity or in quality, eating raw fruit and unwholesome things, so that by the time gluttony has bred the disease or laid in the matter, all the temperance one can afterward exercise is barely enough to keep it in check for the rest of life. On the other hand, many who have been brought to the doors of death by excess have afterward been preserved to a reasonable age by abstinence, and many have been entirely freed from their diseases. Read Cornaro’s treatise of himself, and Lessius, and Sir William Vaughan, and others, though I urge no one, without necessity, to their extreme strictness. Judge now what a murderer gluttony is, and what an enemy to mankind.
3. Gluttony is also a deadly enemy to the mind and to all the noble exercises of reason, whether religious, civil, or intellectual. Basil says, "As smoke drives away bees from their hive, so gluttony expels all spiritual gifts and excellent endowments of mind." (de Jejun.) It unfits men for any close and serious study, and so tends to nourish ignorance and keep men fools. It greatly unfits men for hearing God’s Word, or for reading, praying, meditating, or any holy work, and makes them more inclined to sleep; or it dulls and disorders them so thoroughly that they have no life or readiness for their duty. A clear head, unclouded by drowsy vapors, will accomplish more and gain more in an hour than a full-bellied beast will in many. Gluttony is therefore as much an enemy to all religious and earnest study as drunkenness is to a garrison, where the drunken soldiers are disabled from resisting the enemy.
4. Gluttony is also an enemy to diligence in every honest trade and calling, for it dulls the body as well as the mind. It makes men heavy, drowsy, and slothful, so that they go about their work as though carrying a coat of lead and wearing fetters. They have no energy or alertness, and are fitter to sleep or play than to work. Basil says: "A ship heavily laden is unfit to sail; so is a full belly for any duty."
5. Gluttony is the immediate symptom of a carnal mind and of the damnable sin of flesh-pleasing described above. A carnal mind is the very sum of iniquity and the proper name of an unregenerate state: "It is enmity against God, and neither is nor can be subject to his law", so that they who are thus "in the flesh cannot please God: and they that walk after the flesh shall die." (Rom 8:6–8 and 8:13) The filthiest sins of lechers, and misers, and thieves all aim at pleasing the flesh, and who serves the flesh more thoroughly than the glutton?
6. Gluttony breeds and feeds every other lust. As the saying goes, without food and wine, sexual desire grows cold. Gluttony pampers the flesh to make it a ready sacrifice for lust. Just as dunging the ground makes it fruitful, especially in weeds, so gluttony fills the mind with the weeds and vermin of filthy thoughts, desires, words, and deeds. As Jerome observes, wantonness is always joined to excess.
7. Gluttony is a base and beastly sin. For a man to place his happiness in the pleasure of a swine, and to make his reason serve his throat, or sink into his guts, as if he were but a hogshead to be filled and emptied, or a sink for liquor to run through into the channel; as if he were made only to carry food from the table to the dunghill, how base a kind of life is this? Indeed, many beasts will not eat and drink to excess as the gluttonous epicure will. As Seneca puts it, those who obey their belly are counted among the animals, not among men.
8. Gluttony is a prodigal consumer and destroyer of God’s creatures. What does a man deserve, asks Chrysostom in his twenty-ninth homily on Hebrews, who would take food and drink and cast it away into the channel? And what of the man who would go to great trouble and expense to procure the finest delicacies he could get, only to throw them away? The glutton does worse than that. It would be better, all things considered, to throw his excesses into the sink or the ditch, for then they would at least not first harm his body. Are the creatures of God worth so little? Were they given to you to be put to a use worse than simple waste? Would you have your own children treat their provisions this way?
9. Gluttony is a supremely ungrateful sin. It takes God’s mercies and spews them, as it were, in his face. It carries his provisions over to his enemy, to the strengthening of fleshly lusts, and turns them all against him. You could not have had a single bite except through his liberality and blessing. Will you use those gifts to provoke and dishonor him?
10. Gluttony turns your own mercies, wealth, and food into a snare and leads you to deadly ruin. You please your throat and poison your soul. As Seneca says, a well-governed appetite is a great part of freedom. It would be a thousand times better for you to have lived on scraps and in the poorest manner than to have turned your plenty into damnable sin. "When thou shalt have eaten and be full, then beware lest thou forget the LORD" (Deut 6:11–12). "Feed me with food convenient for me, lest I be full and deny thee, and say, Who is the LORD?" (Prov 30:9). "So they did eat and were filled, for he gave them their own desire; they were not estranged from their lust" (Ps 78:29–30).
11. Gluttony is a great waster of time. Consider how much time is spent earning the money laid out to please the throat; then by servants in preparing for it; then in long sittings at table and feasting; and no small time in taking medicines to counteract the effects, or to ease or cure the diseases it causes, besides all the time lost in lingering sickness, or cut short by untimely death. In this way men live to eat, and eat only to frustrate and shorten life.
12. It is a thief that robs you of your estate and devours what was given you for better uses, for which you must one day give account to God. It is a costly sin, and it consumes more than would serve many worthier purposes. What a great portion of the wealth of most kingdoms is spent on luxury and excess?
13. It is a sin that does great harm to the common good. Rulers and commonwealths have good reason to hate and restrain it as an enemy of their safety. Men lack the money to meet the public costs necessary to the defense of the land because they have consumed it on their guts. Armies and navies go unpaid, fortifications are neglected, and everything that tends toward a people’s glory is opposed as working against personal interest, because nothing is ever enough for the throat. No great works can be done for the honor of the nation or the public benefit. No schools or almshouses are built and endowed, no colleges erected, no hospitals founded, nor any excellent work undertaken, because the guts devour it all. If it were known how much of a nation’s treasure is thrown down the sink by epicures of every rank, this sin would be held in far greater contempt.
14. Gluttony and excess are greatly aggravated by the need of the poor. What an incongruity it is that one who claims to be a member of Christ’s body should be feasting luxuriously every day, overflowing with abused superfluities, while another starves and wastes away in a cottage or begs at the door. That some families should do worse than cast their delicacies to the dogs, while thousands at that very moment are on the edge of famine and are reduced to such unwholesome food that it kills them as surely as luxury kills the epicure! Do these men believe that they will be judged according to how they fed the poor? Or do they take themselves to be members of the same body as those whose sufferings they feel so little (1 Cor 12:26)?
Perhaps you will say, "I do relieve many of the poor." But are there not more yet to be relieved? As long as any remain in distress, your luxury is all the more sinful. "If there be a poor man of one of thy brethren in thy land, thou shalt not harden thy heart, nor shut thy hand against thy poor brother, but thou shalt open thy hand wide unto him," etc. (Deut 15:7). And how often are the poor oppressed precisely to satisfy luxurious appetites. Great numbers must endure hard bargains and hard usage, must toil like horses, and can scarcely get bread for their families, so that all may be brought in to belly-god landlords, who consume the fruit of other men’s labor on their devouring flesh.
When a friend of Socrates complained to him about how expensive everything was, wine costs so much, honey so much, purple so much, Socrates led him to the meal-hall and said, "Look, you can buy here half a sextary of good meal for a halfpenny" (which, boiled in water, was his own food), "God be thanked, the market is very cheap." Then he took him to an oil shop where a measure was sold for two brass dodkins. Then he led him to a broker’s shop where a man could buy a suit of clothes for ten drachms. "You see," said he, "that the pennyworths are reasonable, and things good cheap throughout the city." (Plutarch, On the Tranquility of the Mind, page 153.)
15. This sin is all the more serious in light of the common calamities of the church and the servants of Christ throughout the world. One part of the church is oppressed by the Turk, another by the Pope; many countries are laid waste by the cruelty of armies and persecuted by proud and impious enemies. Is it fitting, then, for others to be wallowing in sensuality and gluttony? "Woe to them that are at ease in Zion, ye that put far away the evil day, and cause the seat of violence to come near, that lie upon beds of ivory, and stretch themselves upon their couches, and eat the lambs out of the flock, and the calves out of the midst of the stall, that chaunt to the sound of the viol, that drink wine in bowls, and anoint themselves with the chief ointments, but they are not grieved for the affliction of Joseph" (Amos 6:1 and 6:3–6).
It is a time calling for deep humiliation. Are you now given over to fleshly luxury? Read Isaiah 22:12–14: "And in that day did the Lord God of Hosts call to weeping and to mourning, and to baldness, and to girding with sackcloth; and behold, joy and gladness, slaying oxen and killing sheep, eating flesh and drinking wine, let us eat and drink for to-morrow we shall die: Surely this iniquity shall not be purged from you till ye die, saith the Lord of hosts."
16. Luxury is a sin most unfitting for men in such great misery, and at odds with the real condition of the glutton himself. If you had a true view of your sin and misery, of death and judgment, and of the dreadful God whom you offend, you would see that fasting, prayer, and tears suit your condition far better than gorging your devouring flesh. Consider: a man unpardoned, unsanctified, in the power of Satan, ready to be damned if he dies in this state, for that is what must be said of a glutton, and yet this man takes his fleshly pleasure! A Dives faring sumptuously every day, who must shortly beg for a drop of water to cool his tongue, is as foolish as a condemned thief who feasts before going to the gallows, and far more so. For you could yet prevent your misery, and a different posture altogether would serve that end. "Fasting" and "crying mightily to God" befit your condition far better (Jonah 3:8; Joel 1:14; Joel 2:15).
17. Gluttony is a greater sin in proportion to how much will and delight you take in committing it. All else being equal, the most voluntary and most beloved sin is the greatest, and few sins are more pleasant and more beloved than this one.
18. Those sins are worst that are least repented of. But gluttony is so far from being truly repented of by the luxurious epicure that he loves it, seeks after it, contrives how to commit it, and buys it at the cost of much of his estate.
19. It is a greater sin because it is so frequently committed. Men live in it as their daily practice and delight; they live for it and make it the end of other sins. It is not a sin they fall into seldom, it is nearly as habitual as eating and drinking itself. Having turned themselves into beasts, they live as beasts continually.
20. Last, it is a spreading sin, and has therefore become common, the sin of entire countries, of rich and poor alike. Both love their bellies, though they do not have equal provision for them. So far from taking warning from one another, they encourage one another; and the sin is scarcely noticed in one out of a hundred who daily live in it. Almost no one reproves it or helps another against it, unless by impoverishing each other, but most encourage it by persuasion and example, though some do so far more than others. By now you can see that this is no rare or trivial sin.
You can also see why it is no wonder that none of the commandments expressly names this sin, not only because it is a sin directly against ourselves, but because it is against nearly every commandment. And do not suppose that either wealth or poverty excuses it, when even princes are restricted from so much as eating at the wrong hour (Eccl 10:16). If gluttony was among the great sins for which Sodom was burned with fire, consider whether England stands in no danger because of it. Read, O England, and know yourself and tremble (Ezek 16:49): "Behold this was the iniquity of thy sister Sodom; pride, fulness of bread, and abundance of idleness, was in her and in her daughters, neither did she strengthen the hand of the poor and needy."
IV. The Directions or Helps Against It
Direction 1. Mortify the flesh, following the Directions in Chapter 4, Part 7. Subdue its inclinations and desires, and learn to esteem and use it only as a servant. Consider what a pitiful price a little gluttonous pleasure of the throat is for a man to sell his God and his salvation. As Plato observed, God is the temperate man’s law, and pleasure is the intemperate man’s. Learn to be indifferent whether your food pleases your appetite or not, and make no great matter of it. Remember always what an odious, swinish, and damning sin it is for a man’s heart to be set upon his belly. "All that are Christ’s have crucified the flesh with its affections and lusts" (Gal 5:24).
Direction 2. Live faithfully to God and upon spiritual, lasting delights. Then you will measure your eating and drinking by how they serve that higher end. No inferior thing can be used rightly until you have first settled your true end and are using that thing as a means toward it, and can judge how far it actually is such a means.
Direction 3. See all your food as provided and given to you by God, beg it and the blessing of it at his hand, and it will greatly restrain you from using it against him. It is a wretch indeed who takes his food as from his Father’s hand and throws it in his face, though perhaps a petulant child might do the same to a fellow-servant. The person who thinks he owes his plenty chiefly to himself will say as the fool: "Soul take thy ease, eat, drink, and be merry, thou hast enough laid up for many years" (Luke 12:19–20). But the person who sees that it is God’s hand reaching it to him will use it more reverently.
It is a grievous aggravation of the gluttony of this age that people play the hypocrite in it, first asking God’s blessing on their food as a matter of custom, and then sitting down to sin against him with it. Such are the prayers of hypocritical sensualists. But a serious recognition of God as the giver would teach you to do everything, whether you eat or drink, to the glory of him from whom it comes.
Direction 4. See by faith the blood of Christ as the purchasing cause of all you have. Then surely you will hold his blood in enough reverence not to cast the fruit of it into the sink of sensuality, or worse than throw it on the dunghill. What, must Christ be a sacrifice to God, and die to recover for you the mercies you had forfeited, only for you to cast them to the dogs and please a sinful appetite with them? Did he die to purchase you provisions for your lusts and to serve the flesh?
Direction 5. Do not forget how the first sin entered the world, by eating the forbidden fruit. And let the slain creatures whose lives are taken for your food remind you of that sin which brought the burden on them for your sakes. Every piece of flesh you see should appear to carry this warning: "Sin not as your first parents sinned by pleasing their appetite; for our death, and your devouring the flesh of your fellow-creatures, is the fruit of that sin, and warns you to be temperate. Do not revel to excess in your fellow-creatures’ lives."
Direction 6. Keep an obedient, tender conscience, not scrupulously troubling yourself over every bite you eat, as melancholy persons do, but letting conscience check your appetite, remind you of God’s commands, and teach you to fear all sensual excess. It is a graceless, disobedient, and senseless heart that makes men so boldly obey their appetite. When the fear of God is absent from the heart, no wonder they "feed" and "feast themselves without fear." Either they make little of sin in general, or at least of this sin in particular. It is usually the same persons who do not fear to waste their time in idleness, sport, or vanity, and who live in worldliness or fleshly lusts, who also live in gluttony to feed all the rest.
The belly is a brute that does not trouble itself much with reason. Where conscience is asleep and seared, reason and Scripture do little to move a sensual belly-god. Anything at all will serve as a reason to declare it lawful and to answer every argument made against it.
There is no use arguing with a man who is asleep, especially if his guts and appetite are wide awake. You might almost as well bring reason and Scripture to keep a swine from overeating, or persuade a hungry dog away from a bone, as to pull a glutton from pleasing his throat once he has grown blockish and has mastered his conscience through unbelief, or stilled it with a stupefying opiate. His taste then serves in place of reason, and against reason. He says, "I feel it do me good," meaning he feels that it pleases his appetite, just as a swine feels its food does it good when it is on the verge of bursting, and this he takes as an answer to everything that can be said against it.
He can then sacrifice his time and treasure to his belly and mock the abstinence and temperance of sober men as needless self-affliction, fit only for the weak and sickly. If the steady fear and obedience of God do not rule the soul, the appetite will be unruled; and if a tender conscience is not on guard at the door, the throat will stand open to whatever the appetite demands. One sight of heaven or hell, to awaken their reason and sleeping consciences, would be the best remedy to convince them of the odiousness and danger of this sin.
Direction 7. Understand clearly what is most conducive to your health, and let that ordinarily govern the measure of your diet in quantity, quality, and timing. Surely your own nature, if you are still truly human, can have nothing to say against this standard, and therefore nothing against the rest of the directions that presuppose it. Nature has given you reason as well as appetite, and reason tells you that your health deserves more regard than your appetite. Diogenes Laertius reports that Socrates lived so sparingly and temperately that though the plague ravaged Athens again and again, he alone was never sick.
Surely you will not say that God is too strict with you, or would subject you to too harsh a diet, when he ordinarily allows you to choose, where you may do so lawfully, whatever is best for your own health, and forbids you nothing but what harms you. What heathen or infidel who is neither mad nor swinish would not accept this standard and this freedom, no less than Christians? Indeed, even if you did not believe in a life to come, you would think it poor judgment to shorten the life you now have. God would only keep you from harming yourselves through excess, as you would keep your children or your swine. Though he has a further end in view, and so must you, namely, that a healthy body may serve a holy soul in your Master’s work, it is the health of your bodies that is to be your nearest and most immediate end and measure.
It is a very great oversight in the education of the young that they are not taught early the basic and necessary rules about diet, what tends toward health and life, and what toward sickness, pain, and death. It would be neither unprofitable nor unnecessary for rulers to ensure that all their subjects had some such common and needful rules in familiar reach (for example, in the books that children first learn to read, alongside the precepts of moral duty). Men do not love death or sickness; all men love their health and life. Therefore even those who do not fear God would be greatly restrained from excess by the fear of sickness and death. Consider what an advantage this would be to the commonwealth: the treasure it would save, besides the lives, health, and strength of so many citizens. The point Petrarch makes is sound: thinking on death’s end is useful against all vices, and especially so against this one.
It is certain that most people have no real knowledge of what measure is best for them; the common rule they go by is appetite. They think they have eaten enough when they have eaten as long as they wished, and not before. If they could eat more with appetite and not be sick afterward, they never think themselves guilty of gluttony or excess.
First. You must know, then, that appetite is not to be your rule or measure, whether for quantity, quality, or timing. As Seneca puts it, temperance commands the pleasures: it refuses and drives away some, orders others, and directs all toward a sound measure, never pursuing them for their own sake. He also writes that the best measure of desire is not how much you want but how much you ought to take.
1.) Appetite is irrational, and reason is your ruling faculty, if you are in fact a rational being.
2.) Appetite depends on the condition of the body, its humors and diseases, not merely on the body’s actual need for food. A man with dropsy is most thirsty when he has least reason to drink; in a malignant fever, a draught of cold drink might well be fatal, yet appetite craves it nonetheless. Stomachs burdened with acid humors commonly have a strong appetite even when digestion is very weak, and most such people could eat with appetite twice what they ought to eat. Conversely, some people desire less than is necessary to sustain them and must be urged to eat against their appetite.
3.) Most healthy people in the world have an appetite for far more than their bodies can well digest, and would kill themselves if they indulged it. God never gave man his appetite to serve as the measure of his eating and drinking, but to make grateful what reason directs him to take.
4.) Man’s appetite is no longer as sound and orderly as it was before the Fall; it has grown more rebellious, unruly, and diseased along with the body. It is therefore far less fit to serve as our measure now than it was then.
5.) You can see this even in swine and in many greedy children, who would promptly destroy themselves if the reason of others did not restrain them.
6.) Poison itself may be as pleasant to the appetite as wholesome food; dangerous foods may taste as agreeable as the most nourishing. Appetite is plainly unfit to be the measure of a human being.
Yet this much is also true: when reason has no objection, appetite does indicate what the body takes to be most agreeable to itself. Appetite therefore has something to be said for it, all else being equal, because it shows what the stomach is likeliest to receive and digest best, and so gives reason some help in discerning when the body is prepared for food.
Second. It is equally certain that how you feel at the moment, ease or discomfort, is no reliable guide to judging your digestion or your right measure. Some delicate and relaxed stomachs do feel sick or troubled when they are overloaded, but with most people this is not so. Short of truly swinish excess, they feel no immediate harm from lesser excess; the damage is that imperfect digestion corrupts the humors and gradually prepares the ground for sickness. One person feels the consequence a month later in some diseased discharge; another feels it a year later; another not for many years, until it has ripened into an incurable disease. (Diseases bred through such long preparation are ordinarily far more incurable than those arising from sudden accidents in a cleaner body.)
To say "I feel no harm from it, therefore it is no excess" is the saying of an idiot who has no foreseeing reason, who refuses to resist an enemy while he is garrisoning and arming himself, and acts only when the blows fall. It is like someone who walks into a plague-house and says, "I feel no harm," but within days or weeks he will feel it. The early stage of consumption is no less harm because the sufferer does not yet feel it. Living like a beast will in the end make men judge like beasts, and brutify their brains as well as their bellies.
Third. It is likewise certain that common custom and received opinion are no reliable rule, indeed, they are a mistaken rule. Judging by appetite has brought people ordinarily to mistake excess for temperance. All three, then, appetite, present feeling, and common custom, are false measures.
If I were now to offer you specific rules for judging the right measure, physicians would think I had overstepped my calling; some might take offense at an effort that tends so much to reduce their income, and those who serve the greedy worm would be still more offended. I will therefore offer only these general observations.
1.) Nature is satisfied with a little, but appetite is never satisfied until it has overwhelmed nature. As Seneca writes, the stomach is content with little, if you give it what you owe it and not what you are able.
2.) It is the perfection of digestion and the quality of the nourishment that contributes more to health than mere quantity.
3.) Nature will more easily manage twice the quantity of light and digestible nourishment than half as much of gross and heavy food. (Those who prescribe exactly twelve ounces a day without distinguishing between foods that differ so greatly are greatly mistaken.)
4.) A healthy, strong body requires more than the weak and sickly.
5.) Middle-aged persons require more than the elderly or children. As Socrates said, the virtue of the young is "nothing to excess."
6.) Hard laborers must eat more than those who labor easily, and these more than the idle, the studious, or any who move about very little.
7.) A body with close pores that releases little through sweat or perspiration must take in less, especially of moisture, than other bodies.
8.) So must a cold and phlegmatic constitution.
9.) So must a stomach that corrupts its food and expels it through periodic bilious discharges.
10.) Food that troubles the stomach during digestion is either too much or of bad quality, unless the person is very weak and sickly.
11.) So too is food that makes you dull for study or heavy and unfit for labor, unless some disease is the primary cause.
12.) A body already filled with undigested matter through excess should take in less than another, so that nature has time to digest and clear it.
13.) Everyone should work to understand the constitution of their own body, know which diseases they are most prone to, and seek the judgment of a physician or some skilled person to give directions suited to their particular constitution and ailments.
14.) Hard laborers err more in quality than in quantity, partly through poverty, partly through ignorance, partly through appetite, when they refuse what is more wholesome (such as plain bread and beer) because it pleases them less.
15.) If I may venture a conjecture: very hard laborers ordinarily exceed in quantity by about a quarter; shopkeepers and persons in easier trades ordinarily exceed by about a third; indulgent gentlemen and their household servants who do no hard labor usually exceed by about half again as much (though I always except those who are extraordinarily temperate, whether through physical weakness or through wisdom). The same gentlemen usually exceed still more in variety, cost, elaborateness, and the time spent at table than they do in quantity, so that they are gluttons of the first order. The children of those who do not govern their appetites, but let them eat and drink as much and as often as they desire, typically exceed by more than half again and lay the foundation for the diseases and miseries of their entire lives. All of this is close to the truth, though the belly refuses to hear it. As Seneca says, the stomach does not listen to precepts.
Once you have grown wise enough about what measure, timing, and quality best suit your health, do not go beyond it for any pressing of appetite or of friends; for everything beyond it is gluttony and sensuality in its degree.
Direction 8. If you can lawfully avoid it, do not make your table a snare of temptation to yourselves or others. I know that a greedy appetite will turn even a table with bare necessities into a snare for itself; but do not needlessly become devils, or tempters to yourselves or others.
1. On quality: do not cultivate deliciousness too much. Except for weak or disordered stomachs, the best food is that which leaves in the mouth neither a troubling nausea nor an eager craving for more on account of taste, but something like bread, which leaves the palate in calm moderation. The elaborate invention of new and delicious dishes purely to please the appetite is gluttony inviting greater gluttony: excess in quality leading to excess in quantity.
If you will not take this counsel, at least set out a basin and a feather or a provang after the meal for your guests to vomit it back up again, so that you may show some mercy to their bodies, if you will show none to their souls.
Objection: But I shall be thought niggardly or sordid, and reproached behind my back, if my table is fitted to the temperate and abstemious.
Answer: This is pride pleading on behalf of gluttony. Rather than be criticized by belly-gods, or by ignorant, fleshly people, you will sin against God and prepare a feast as a sacrifice to Bacchus or Venus. The ancient Christians were thrown to beasts because they would not cast a pinch of frankincense onto an idol’s altar, and will you feed so many idol-bellies so lavishly just to avoid their censure? Did I not tell you that gulosity is an irrational vice? Good and temperate persons will speak well of you for it: and do you care more for the judgment of belly-gods?
Erasmus records that when a sensualist pressed Cato to admit him among his close companions, Cato answered, "I cannot live with one whose palate is wiser than his brain."
Objection: But I do not mean riotous or luxurious persons, I have none such at my table. Yet even good and sober people will speak against me.
Answer: I told you that some degree of gluttony has become a common sin, and many are tainted with it through custom who are otherwise good and sober. But should they therefore be left as incurable? Or should they drag everyone else down to their level? Must we all commit a sin simply because some sober people have grown accustomed to it? You endure their censures over differences in religion and other matters, why not here as well? The deluded Quakers may stand as a witness against you: running to the opposite extreme, they bear the deepest censures of all the world without flinching. Can you not, for the sake of honest temperance and sobriety, bear the censures of some untempered or guilty persons who think otherwise? Certainly, when they plead for excess and the baits of sensuality, they are not acting as temperate persons.
2. On variety also: do not needlessly make your table a snare. Have no greater variety than the weakness of stomachs or the diversity of appetites truly requires. Unnecessary variety and pleasantness of food are the devil’s great instruments for drawing people into gluttony, and I would not wish any good person to serve as his cook or caterer. When the very brutish appetite itself begins to say of one dish, "I have had enough," another dish comes to tempt it to more excess, and another after that. In all of this I have the concurrent judgment of physicians, who condemn fullness and variety as the great enemies of health and the nurseries of disease. Is not the concurrent judgment of physicians more reliable on matters of health than your private opinions or appetites? When sickness genuinely requires variety, however, it is necessary.
3. Do not sit too long at the table. Besides the sin of wasting time, prolonged sitting only coaxes you to take a little more and then a little more still. A person who would be temperate if seated for a quarter of an hour, which is ordinarily enough, will exceed when tempted by half an hour, which is sufficient for the entertainment of guests. Much more so when you must sit out a full hour, which is by any honest measure too long. Though greedy eating is never good, sober and moderate feeding can satisfy nature in a short time.
4. See that your provisions are not more costly than necessary. I know that some difference must be allowed for different persons and occasions, yet see that no cost is spent unnecessarily; and let sober reason, not pride or gluttony, judge what is necessary. We commonly call the man in Luke 16 "the rich glutton," the man who "fared sumptuously every day." It is not said that he ate more than other men, only that he fared sumptuously. You will never be able to answer to God with any peace for spending on the belly what might have done far more good another way. It is a horrid sin to pour out such stores of wealth needlessly on eating, as is commonly done. The cheapest diet, all else being equal, must be preferred.
The old custom in country households was not amiss: the story of the rich man and Lazarus was painted on the walls above the dining table.
Objection: But the scandal of covetousness must be avoided as well as gluttony. People will say that all this sparing is done from a miserable, worldly spirit.
Answer:
1. That censure is easier to bear than the displeasure of God.
2. No scandal must be avoided by sinning; that is a scandal taken, not given.
3. To temperate persons, your excess is far more scandalous.
4. I will teach you a remedy for this in the next Direction.
Objection: But what if I set variety and plenty on my table? May not men choose whether they eat too much? Do you think men are swine, who do not know when they have had enough?
Answer: Yes, we see by certain experience that most men do not know when they have had enough, and they exceed when they think they do not. Not one in many is more prone to fall short than to exceed; and those who sin by excess vastly outnumber those who sin by defect.
Is sin so small a matter to you that you will lay snares before men and then say, "They may take heed"? Men may also choose whether to go into a whore-house, and yet the Pope hardly deals honestly by licensing them at Rome, still less is it right to prepare and invite men there. Will you excuse the devil for tempting Eve with the forbidden fruit, on the ground that she could choose whether to touch it? What business does that which is purposely cooked to tempt the appetite, fitted to draw men to gulosity and excess, and in no way needful, have on your table? "Woe to him that layeth a stumblingblock before the blind." "Let no man put a stumblingblock in his brother’s way." It is the wicked person’s curse: "Let their table be made a snare, and a trap, and a stumblingblock." And it was Balaam’s sin that he taught Balak to tempt Israel, or lay a stumblingblock before them.
Direction 9. Resolve to spend what you would have wasted on such superfluities on the poor, or some other charitable use, so that it does not become a sacrifice to the belly. Let the greatest and most pressing uses be served first. It is no time to be gorging your appetites and wallowing in excess when any, indeed, so many, around you lack even clothing and bread. If you direct to the poor everything you save from feeding your own excess and that of your guests, no one can say your sparing comes from covetous niggardliness, and that reproach is removed.
The cost of one feast will buy bread for a great many poor people. It is no great credit to give the poor your leavings once your belly has first been glutted with as much as appetite desired: that costs you nothing. A swine will leave to another what it cannot eat. But if you are willing to restrain your flesh a little, deny yourselves, and live more sparingly and frugally so that you may have more to give to the poor, that is truly commendable.
Direction 10. Do not over-persuade anyone to eat when there is no need; rather, help one another resist running into excess, through timely conversation about the sinfulness of gluttony and the excellence of abstinence, and through friendly watchfulness and mutual warning. Satan, the flesh, and its unavoidable baits are temptation enough: we need not add more through misguided kindness.
Direction 11. When you feel your appetites raging against reason and conscience, check them and resolve that they shall not be satisfied. Irresolution keeps the temptation alive. If you would simply resolve, you would find peace. But when the devil finds you yielding, wavering, or undecided, he will never give you rest. "When thou sittest to eat with a ruler, consider diligently what is before thee, and put a knife to thy throat if thou be a man given to appetite: be not desirous of his dainties, for they are deceitful meat" (Prov 23:1–3).
The phrase translated "if thou be a man given to appetite," rendered in agreement with the Septuagint and the Arabic, is translated by Montanus, the Vulgate Latin, and the Chaldee Paraphrase as "if thou have the power of thy own soul, or be master of thy soul," that is, show yourself master of yourself by abstinence. Instead of "Put a knife to thy throat," meaning threaten yourself into abstinence, the Syriac and various expositors translate it as "Thou dost, or lest thou dost put a knife to thy throat," that is, you are as bad as cutting your own throat, or destroying yourself, when you feed yourself gluttonously. Maintain resolution and the rule of reason.
Direction 12. Remember what your body is, and what it will shortly become, and how loathsome and vile it will be in the dust. Then consider how far such a body deserves to be pampered, and at what cost. Jerome writes that one who desires Christ and feeds on that bread has little concern for making costly food into dung. Do not pay too dear for a feast for worms. Look into the grave and see what becomes of all your pleasant food and drink, all your elaborate and costly fare. You may see skulls cast up, and the gaping hollow of that mouth which devoured so many delicious morsels, yet none of the pleasure remains now.
What wonderful folly it is, that people can so easily, so eagerly, so obstinately waste their estates, neglect their souls, displease their God, and in effect sell their hopes of heaven for so small and sordid a delight as the pleasing of a body that must shortly come to so vile an end! Was it worth such care, toil, and cost, worth casting away your salvation, to pamper for a little while a body that must shortly be such a loathsome carcass? One sight of a skull or a grave ought to make you see gluttony and luxury for the madness they are. Seneca writes that nothing will serve your temperance so well as frequent meditation on the brevity and uncertainty of life, and that whatever you do, you should keep death in view.
"It is better to go to the house of mourning, than to the house of feasting: for that is the end of all men, and the living will lay it to heart" (Eccl 7:2). David says of the wicked, "Let me not eat of their dainties," but "let the righteous smite me and reprove me" (Ps 141:4–5). So dangerous a thing is feasting even among friends, where it is in itself lawful, that Job thought it a season calling for fear and sacrifice. "And his sons went and feasted in their houses every one his day, and sent and called for their three sisters to eat and to drink with them. But Job sacrificed for them, saying, It may be my sons have sinned, and cursed," that is, thought provokingly, unreverently, unholily, or contemptuously of, "God in their hearts. Thus did Job continually" (Job 1:4–5). A funeral is a safer place for you than a feast.
Direction 13. Go sometimes into the houses of the poor, and see what provision they live on, and how little time they spend at meals. Then ask yourself whether their diet or yours does more to mortify fleshly lusts, and whether theirs will not taste as sweet as yours in the end. Ask whether mere wealth should make so great a difference in eating and drinking between them and you. I know that where people lack what is necessary for their health, you may rightly exceed them and be thankful. But not so as to forget their needs, nor so as to turn your plenty into excess. The very sight, now and then, of a poor man’s diet and way of life would do you good: seeing affects us more than merely hearing.
Direction 14. Look at the ancient Christians, those models of abstinence, and consider whether their lives resembled yours. They were much given to fasting and self-denial, and strangers to gluttony and excess. They were more inclined to excessive abstinence than to excessive eating; great numbers of them lived in wildernesses or cells, subsisting on roots or on bread and water. It was the formal, hypocritical imitation of these men that gave rise to the swarms of friars in the world today. Will you commend their holiness and abstinence, and yet be so far from any serious imitation of them that you directly oppose them by living in gluttony and excess?
I have now exposed the odiousness of this sin and shown you, if you are willing, how best to avoid it. If all this is not enough, if there is "any profane person among you like Esau, who for one morsel of meat sold his birthright" (Heb 12:16), who will sell his soul for the pleasure of his throat, let him know that God has another kind of remedy for such a person. He may cast you into poverty, where you are a glutton only in desire but have nothing to satisfy it. He may soon cast you into those diseases that will make you loathe your pleasant food and wish you had the poor man’s fare and appetite, and make you say of all the baits of your sensuality, "I have no pleasure in them" (Eccl 12:1).
The case will be very different when all your wealth, friends, and greatness cannot keep your pampered carcass from corruption, nor procure your soul a comfort equal to a drop of water to cool your tongue in the flames of God’s displeasure. Then all the comfort you can draw from God or conscience will be only this sad reminder: "Remember that thou in thy lifetime receivedst thy good things, and likewise Lazarus evil things: but now he is comforted, and thou art tormented" (Luke 16:25). "Go to now ye rich men; weep and howl for your miseries that shall come upon you, Ye have lived in pleasure on the earth, and been wanton; ye have nourished your hearts as in a day of slaughter: ye have condemned and killed the just, etc." (Jas 5:1 and 5:5). "Wo to you that are full, for ye shall hunger" (Luke 6:25).
Yet after all this, remember not to run into the contrary extreme. Do not place more religion in outward abstinence and fasting than you ought. Know your own condition, and how far either fasting or eating is truly a help or hindrance to you in those greater ends they are meant to serve, and act accordingly. Seneca observes that philosophy requires temperance, not self-punishment. A failing body must be carefully supported; an unruly body must be carefully subdued. The same remedies do not serve contrary constitutions and diseases.
To suppose that abstaining from flesh while glutting yourself with fish and other foods is acceptable to God, or that merely abstaining for certain hours of the week and then indulging your appetite the rest of the time is meritorious, or that abstinence from food proves you holy without abstinence from sin, all of this is self-deceiving error. Nor should you raise a great many perplexing scruples about everything you eat or drink, to no benefit but only to your own torment. Instead, in cheerful temperance, preserve your health and subdue concupiscence.
CHAPTER 22
DIRECTIONS AGAINST DRUNKENNESS AND ALL EXCESS OF DRINK
I. Most of what I said against gluttony applies equally to excess of drink, so I need not repeat it all. Drunkenness, in its broadest sense, extends to both the desire and the effect. Someone is a drunkard, in God’s sight, by reputation, if he would drink too much were he able, and is restrained not by his own will but only by necessity.
Drunkenness in its effect or act is sometimes taken more broadly and sometimes more strictly. Broadly understood, it means all drinking to excess in order to please the appetite. Two things together make up the crime: 1. love of the drink, or the pleasing of the appetite, which we call gulosity; and 2. excess in drinking, which may be excess in quantity or in quality.
Drunkenness strictly understood means drinking until reason has suffered some impairment. This admits of many degrees. Anyone who has in the slightest degree disturbed his reason, and disabled or hindered it from its proper function, is drunk to that degree. Anyone who has overthrown reason entirely, or rendered it wholly useless, is stark drunk, drunk in the fullest degree.
All excess of drink is sinful gulosity or sensuality, of the same nature as gluttony, and falls under every reproof and direction I gave in that connection. In some people who can sit through a long drinking session and bear much liquor without intoxication, the sin may be greater than in others who are surprised into drunkenness by a smaller quantity before they are aware of it. Yet, all else being equal, the overthrow of the understanding makes the sin far greater, for it contains all the evil of the lesser degrees and adds more. Drunkenness of this kind is a voluptuous excess in drink that corrupts reason. Gulosity is its general nature; excess is its matter; the corruption of reason is its distinctive form.
It is excess of drinking when you drink more than sound reason judges will tend, directly or indirectly, to fit your body for its proper duty, without producing greater harm. Sometimes the immediate benefit matters most, for instance, if a person has some pressing duty of great importance to perform at once. The immediate benefit consists in two things: 1. relieving a troublesome thirst or pain that would hinder you from doing your duty; and 2. supplying such refreshment and alertness to the spirits as makes them fitter instruments for the operations of mind and body. A measure that does one or both of these things without greater harm is not excessive.
I say without greater harm because if anyone were to prefer a moment of present ease and alertness over his health and life in dropsy or fever, that would be excess. Likewise, if anyone habitually drinks more than nature will properly digest, causing impaired digestion, and consequently accumulated phlegm and corrupted humors that breed many diseases, that is excess of drinking, even if he feels ease and cheerfulness in the moment. This is the common condition of most habitual drinkers or tipplers who are not stark drunkards: they feel present relief from thirst and perhaps a little lift of spirits, and so they conclude their measure is not excessive, when in fact it tends toward digestive disorder, disease, and the ruin of their health and life.
Therefore, except in some great and extraordinary case of necessity, it is not so much the present effects as the foreseeable future effects that should guide you in knowing your proper measure. Reason can foresee what appetite cannot. Future effects are usually great and lasting; present effects may be small and brief. Anyone who does what tends to harm his health merely to ease or please a thirsty appetite in the moment sins against reason and acts like a beast. You ought to know your own body and the conditions of your health well enough to judge first whether enduring the thirst, or drinking to quench it, is more likely to hurt your health and hinder your duty.
As for the present alertness that strong drink brings to some people, you must foresee that you are not purchasing it at too high a price, a longer dullness or incapacity afterward. Take care also not to mistake a false, counterfeit cheerfulness, consisting in mere sensual pleasure, for that genuine serenity and proper alertness of spirits that fits you for your duty. This is another common, and willful, self-deception among sensualists: they persuade themselves that a cup of wine or strong drink gives them a truly helpful alertness, when in fact it only produces a sensual delight that more hinders and corrupts the mind than genuinely advances it in its duty. Such artificial pleasure differs from true alertness as paint differs from beauty, or as a fever differs from the body’s natural warmth.
You see, then, that intemperance in drinking takes two forms: 1. habitual excessive drinking; and 2. drunkenness in its various degrees. These intemperate drinkers come in several kinds.
1. Those who, when they have overheated themselves, or are feverish, or suffer from some ordinary diseased thirst, will please their appetites even at the cost of their health, who would rather risk their lives than endure thirst. Though in fevers, dropsies, or coughs drink may be their greatest enemy, they are such beastly servants to their appetites that drink they will, whatever the cost. Though physicians forbid them and friends plead with them, appetite has so fully mastered reason in them that they act more like brutes than rational men.
These are of two kinds. One kind retains the nominal soundness of reason, though they have lost all its strength and power through lack of a firm will: they confess they ought to abstain, but say they cannot, acknowledging they have so little command of themselves. The other kind have surrendered even their reason to the service of their appetites: they will not believe, until a cough, gout, dropsy, or the like forces the belief upon them, that their measure of drinking is too much or that it will harm them; they say instead that it would harm them more to go without it. Some do this through genuine ignorance; others have been made willingly ignorant by their appetites.
2. Another sort of habitual drinkers, much worse than the first, have no great diseased thirst to excuse their gulosity. They call it thirst whenever their appetite craves a drink, and they habitually satisfy such appetite and drink almost whenever the throat desires it, saying it is only to quench their thirst, and never charge themselves with intemperance. These may be distinguished from the first sort by the quality of what they drink. The first sort craves cold small beer to quench a real thirst, the same thirst that reason tells them to endure if other means will not relieve it. The second sort drinks wine, or strong drink, or some drink with a pleasing flavor, to gratify the appetite they call their thirst. Among these luxurious tipplers, next to stark drunkards, there are also several degrees, some less guilty and some more.
1.) The lowest degree are those who will not ordinarily drink except at meals, but at meals they drink more than nature requires or health profits.
2.) The second degree are those who habitually drink between meals whenever their appetite moves them, hindering digestion, increasing sluggishness and catarrhs, gradually corrupting their humors, and generating many diseases, all without true necessity, without the approval of sound reason, or of any wise physician. Yet they only tipple at home, where you may find a pot at their elbow at all hours.
3.) The third degree includes many poor men who have no drink at home, but when they come to a gentleman’s house, a feast, or perhaps an alehouse, they pour in to excess, though not to outright drunkenness, and think no harm is done because it happens rarely, and they drink such weak drink the rest of the year that they persuade themselves such occasional excess is medicinal and beneficial to their health.
4.) Another rank of habitual drinkers are those who, though they do not frequent alehouses or taverns, yet readily take every health-toast or pledging cup offered them, never reaching drunkenness, and habitually drink many unnecessary cups in a day in order to pledge, as they call it, those who drink to them; and custom and compliment are all their excuse. Gildas wrote that not only worldly men but also the flock of the Lord and its very pastors, who should have been examples to all the people, fell into this condition: very many were sodden and stupefied with drunkenness as though soaked in wine, and were torn by the swelling of animosities, the strife of quarrels, the rapacious claws of envy, and an inability to judge rightly between good and evil (Epistle of Gildas, Josselin’s edition, 1568, pp. 18–19).
5.) Another degree are the habitual alehouse haunters, who love to sit there for many hours a day with a pot before them, tippling and drinking one to another. And whenever they have a bargain to strike or a friend to meet, the alehouse or tavern must be the place, where drinking is part of the business.
6.) The highest degree are those who are not easily made stark drunk, and who therefore think themselves less guilty, while they sit at it, make others drunk, and are strong enough to hold more than others can. They have the drunkard’s appetite, the drunkard’s measure, and the drunkard’s pleasure, though not his giddiness or loss of wit.
3. Among those who are truly drunk, there are also many degrees and kinds. Some are overcome by less drink and some by more. Some experience only a slight diseased levity and talkativeness beyond what they had before; some have distempered eyes and stammering tongues; some go further to unsteady, reeling heads, stumbling feet, and unfitness for their callings; some proceed to sick and vomiting stomachs or a stupefied heaviness; and some proceed to stark madness, quarreling, railing, bawling, hooting, ranting, roaring, talking nonsense, or doing mischief. The furious sort are like mad dogs that must be tied, and the sottish, prating, and spewing sort are commonly the derision of boys in the streets.
II. Having described what tippling and drunkenness are, I will briefly describe their causes, briefly, because most of them can be gathered from what was said about the causes of gluttony.
1. The first and chief causes are three, acting together: a beastly, raging appetite or greed; a weakness of reason and resolution to govern it; and a lack of faith to strengthen reason and of holiness to strengthen resolution. These are the root cause of all.
2. Another cause is the tipplers’ failure to recognize that their excess is genuinely harmful or dangerous to their health. They remain ignorant of this for several reasons.
One is that they were raised among ignorant people and never taught to know what is good or bad for their own bodies, except by the common talk of mistaken ordinary people.
Another is that appetite so overpowers their very reason that they can persuade themselves to believe what they would prefer not to be true.
Another is that, being of healthy bodies, they feel no harm at present, presume they will feel none later, and observe that some abstemious people are weaker than they, not perceiving that those persons did not become abstemious until a chronic disease had already taken hold of them.
And so they do with their bodies exactly what wicked men do with their souls: they judge everything by present feeling and lack the wisdom to bring foreseen consequences into their deliberations. What lies far ahead they count as nothing, or as an uncertain near-nothing. As heaven and hell do not move ungodly men because they seem distant, so while these people feel themselves in health they are not moved by the threat of sickness. The cup is in their hands, and they will not set it down for fear of something unknown that will befall them at some unknown time. As the thief who was told he would answer for it at the day of judgment replied that he would take the other cow too if he must wait that long unpunished, so these belly-gods reason that they will take the other cup if punishment is deferred so far off. And because the temporal punishment of their greed is not swiftly executed, the hearts of men are fully set to please their appetites.
3. Another cause of tippling and drunkenness is a wicked heart that loves the company of wicked men, and the foolish talk and cards and dice by which they are entertained. One sin draws down another. It is a delight to prate over a pot, or rant and game, and drive away every thought that carries any flavor of sound reason, the fear of God, or the care of their salvation.
Gregory set up wakes, church-ales, and holiday meetings in England as a policy for winning the heathens. His direction was that those who were accustomed to kill many oxen in sacrifice to demons should have some solemnity changed for them in this matter also: on the day of a church’s dedication, or on the birthdays of the martyrs, they should make themselves booths of tree branches around those same churches that had been converted out of heathen shrines, and keep the festival with religious feasting; and they should no longer sacrifice animals to the devil, but kill animals for their own eating to the praise of God, and give thanks to the giver of all for their plenty (Registrum, book 10, epistle 71). But do Christians need this as the heathens did, when we see the sad effects of such riotings? See Acosta, De Procuranda Indorum Salute, book 3, chapter 34.
Many of them will say it is not for love of the drink but of the company that they frequent the alehouse, an excuse that makes their sin far worse and reveals how deeply wicked they are. To love the company of wicked men, to delight in their lewd, idle, and foolish talk, and to game and sport away your time with them in addition to your tippling, this reveals a wicked, fleshly heart far worse than if you loved the drink alone. The company you love best reflects your own character. Even if you were no tippler or drunkard, it is a certain mark of an ungodly person to prefer ungodly company over the company of wise and godly people who could build you up in the fear of God.
4. Another cause of tippling is idleness, having no constant employment in their callings to occupy them. Some make it their chief excuse that they drink to pass the time. Blind wretches, who stand so near eternity and can find no better use for their hours. I spoke to these earlier, in Chapter 5, Part 1.
5. Another cause is the wicked neglect of their duties to their own families. They make no effort to love their own relations and teach them the fear of God, nor to pursue their proper business, and so they take no pleasure in being at home. The company of wife, children, and servants is no delight to them; they must go to an alehouse or tavern for company more suited to their tastes. Thus one sin draws on another.
6. Another cause is the miserable state of their own consciences at home. They have brought themselves into so dreadful a condition that they dare not be much alone, dare not soberly consider their own state, dare not seriously look toward the world to come. They flee from themselves and seek a place to hide from their consciences, forgetting that sin will find them out. They run to an alehouse as Saul ran to his music, to drink away melancholy, to drown the voice of a guilty, self-accusing mind, and to drive away every thought of God, heaven, sin, hell, death, and judgment, until it is too late. They seem resolved to be damned, and therefore resolved not to think of their misery or of the remedy. Yet though they dare venture upon hell itself, these sots dare not venture upon the serious thought of it.
Either there is a hell, or there is not. If there is none, why would you be afraid to think of it? If there is a hell, as you will discover if you continue only a little longer, will not the feeling be more intolerable than the thought of it? And is not thinking of it beforehand a necessary and inexpensive way to prevent the experience of it? How much wiser to retire to some private place and look ahead to eternity, to hear first what your conscience has to say about your past life, your sin and misery, and then what God has to say about the remedy. You will one day find that this was a more necessary work than anything you had at the alehouse, and that you had greater business with God and conscience than with your idle companions.
7. Another cause is the custom of pledging those who drink to you, and of drinking healths, by which the laws of the devil and the alehouse impose measures of excess upon men and make it their supposed duty to disregard their duty to God. It is a lamentable thing to be the compliant slaves of men and the stubborn rebels against God. Plutarch mentions one who, being invited to a feast, stopped when he learned that men were compelled to drink after the meal, and asked whether they were compelled to eat as well, sensing that his stomach was in danger. It seems to be nothing but custom that makes it appear less ridiculous or offensive to constrain men to drinking than to eating.
8. Another great cause of excess is the devil’s method of drawing people on by degrees. He does not tempt them directly to get drunk, but to drink one more cup, then another, and another, so that the worst he seems to ask is just a little more. In this way, as Solomon says of the fornicator, they yield to the flatterer and go on as the "ox to the slaughter, and as the fool to the correction of the stocks, till a dart strike through his liver, as a bird hasteth to the snare, and knoweth not that it is for his life." (Prov 7:21–23)
III. The greatness of this sin appears in what was said earlier about gluttony, but more especially in the following particulars.
1. Consider what a degrading master you serve, being a slave to your own throat. What a beastly thing this is, and worse than beastly, since few beasts but a swine can be induced to drink more than is good for them. How feeble is the reason of a man who cannot govern his own throat!
2. Consider how you waste the creatures God gave for useful service, not for self-indulgence and luxury. The earth will testify against you that it brought forth its fruit for better purposes than to be squandered on your sin. Your servants and animals that labored to produce it will likewise testify against you. You offer God’s creation as a sacrifice to the devil, for drunkenness and tippling is the devil’s service. It would be less foolish to do as Diogenes did: when given a large cup of wine, he threw it under the table so it could do him no harm. You make yourself like caterpillars, foxes, and wolves, destroying creatures that live to do mischief and consume what should nourish mankind, and are therefore hunted down as unfit to live. You are to the commonwealth what mice are to a granary, or weeds to a cornfield. It is a great part of the work of faithful magistrates to weed out such as you.
3. You rob the poor, consuming on your throat what should sustain them. If you have anything to spare, you will find far more comfort at the last in having given it to the needy than in knowing that a greedy throat devoured it. In this the miser is far better than the drunkard and the self-indulgent: he gathers, while they scatter. The commonwealth bears a double or triple burden in people like you. Just as the same pasture that keeps many sheep will keep only one horse, the same country that maintains many temperate persons can maintain only a few gluttons and drunkards.
The worldly man makes provision cheaper by acquiring and saving; but the drunkard and glutton make it dearer by wasting. The miser who scrapes together for himself often gathers for one who will pity the poor when he is dead; but the drunkard and the riotous devour everything while they are alive.
The one is like a hog that is good for something at last, even if his feeding yields no profit while he lives; the other is like devouring vermin, leaving nothing to pay for what they consumed. The one is like the pike among fishes, who pays when he is dead for what he devoured alive; but the other is like a drain or gutter, repaying you with nothing but stench and filth for all that is poured into it.
4. You bring poverty and ruin upon yourself. Beyond the value you waste, God ordinarily joins with the prodigal through his judgments and scatters as fast as the prodigal does. "He that loveth pleasure shall be a poor man: he that loveth wine and oil shall not be rich" (Prov 21:17). "There is that scattereth and yet increaseth" (Prov 11:24), but this is not the outcome of your kind of scattering. "Hear thou my son and be wise, and guide thy heart in the way. Be not amongst wine-bibbers, amongst riotous eaters of flesh: for the drunkard and the glutton shall come to poverty, and drowsiness shall clothe a man with rags." (Prov 23:19–21)
Diogenes, when begging of a prodigal, asked a pound from him when he asked only a penny from the next man, because, he said, I may often receive from others, but God knows whether I shall ever get anything more from this man. (Laërtius, Life of Diogenes.)
5. You are an enemy to your own family. You grieve your friends. You impoverish your children and rob those you are bound to provide for. You fill your house with discontent and quarreling, and drive out all peace and the fear of God. A discontented or brawling wife, and ragged, dissolute, untaught children, are often signs that a drunkard or riotous person is the head of that household.
6. You are a grievous waster of your precious time, which is far worse than wasting your property. If only you knew, as you will one day know, what those hours are worth that you waste over your drinks, and how much more important work you had to spend them on! How many thousands in hell are now wishing in vain that they had back the hours they spent in the alehouse and senselessly threw away with companions in sin, hours they might have spent in prayer and repentance. Is the hourglass running for you, and death hastening toward you to end all your time and lay you where you must dwell forever, and yet you sit tippling and prating your time away, as if this were all you had to do with it? What a wonder of sottishness and stupidity is the hardened sinner, living so far beneath his own reason! The senseless neglect of your soul’s interests and weightier concerns is in fact the greater part of your sin, more than the drunkenness itself.
7. What a low price you set upon your Savior and your salvation, when you will not so much as forgo a cup of drink for them! The smallness of the thing reveals the smallness of your love to God and the smallness of your regard for his Word and your own soul. Is it loving God as God, when you love a cup of drink more? Are you not ashamed of your hypocrisy, when you say you love God above all, yet love him not as well as your wine and ale? Surely one who does not love him above ale does not love him above all.
Your choices reveal what you love best, far more reliably than your tongue does. It is the dish a man greedily eats that he loves, not the one he praises but will not touch. God tests men’s love for him by their keeping his commandments. It was the aggravation of the first sin that they would not deny so small a thing as the forbidden fruit in obedience to God, and so it is with yours, that you will not leave a forbidden cup for him.
O miserable wretch! Do you not know that you cannot be Christ’s disciple unless you forsake all for him, and hate even your own life in comparison with him, and would rather die than forsake him? Are you likely to lay down your life for him when you will not leave a cup of drink for him? Can you burn at a stake for him when you cannot leave an alehouse, or vain company, or excess for him? What a sentence of condemnation you pass upon yourself! Will you sell your God and your soul for so small a thing as a cup of drink? Do not deceive yourself by saying, "I hope I do not," when you know that God has declared in his Word that "drunkards shall not inherit the kingdom of God" (1 Cor 6:10). Indeed, God has commanded those who would come to heaven to have no fellowship with you even on earth, "no, not so much as to eat" with you (1 Cor 5:11).
Read what Christ himself says: "But if that evil servant shall say in his heart, My lord delayeth his coming, and shall begin to smite his fellow-servants, and to eat and to drink with the drunken, the lord of that servant shall come in a day when he looketh not for him, and in an hour that he is not aware of, and shall cut him asunder, and appoint him his portion with the hypocrites: there shall be weeping and gnashing of teeth." Matthew 24:48–51
Read also (Deut 29:19–20): if when you "hearest the words of God’s curse, thou bless thyself in thy heart, saying, I shall have peace, though I walk in the imagination of my heart, to add drunkenness to thirst: the Lord will not spare that man, but then the anger of the Lord, and his jealousy shall smoke against him, and all the curses that are written in this book shall lie upon him, and the Lord shall blot out his name from under heaven, and the Lord shall separate him to evil." You see here how God will spice your cups.
8. You are the shame of human nature. You represent man in the likeness of a beast, or worse than a beast, as if he were made only to serve as a barrel or a drain. Look at a drunkard fouling himself and spewing, reeling and bawling, and ask whether he is not uglier than a brute. You are a shame to your own reason, when you show the world that reason cannot so much as shut your mouth or prevail with you in so small a matter. Do not wrong reason so far as to call yourself rational, and do not wrong mankind so far as to call yourself a man. When the drunken Emperor Bonosus was hanged, someone said of him: "It is a barrel and not a man."
You are also a shame to your family. It is said that Cicero’s son proved a drunkard, the very son to whom Cicero had addressed his book On Duties, and this became a reproach upon the father himself.
9. You destroy that reason which is the glory of your nature and the natural part of God’s image upon your mind. If you were to deface the king’s coat of arms in a public place and put the image of a dog in its stead, would that not be a treasonous contempt? How much worse, then, to do this to God? To mangle and deform your body would be a lesser offense in this respect, because it is not your body but your soul that is made after the image of God. Has God given you reason for such high and excellent ends, and will you dull it and drown it in obedience to your throat?
Your reason is worth more than your house, your land, or your money, yet you would not throw those away so carelessly. Had God made you an idiot, or mad and lunatic, your condition would deserve pity; but to make yourself mad, to despise your own manhood, deserves punishment. Basil put it plainly: "Involuntary madness deserves compassion, but voluntary madness deserves the sharpest whips." "Judgments are prepared for scorners, and stripes for the fool’s back" (Prov 19:29), above all for the voluntary fool. One who willfully makes himself a beast or a madman ought to be treated by others as a beast or a madman, whether he will or not.
10. You make yourself unfit for anything that is good. How unfit you are to read, hear, or meditate on the Word of God; how unfit to pray; how unfit to receive the holy sacrament. What a dreadful thing it is to picture a drunken man speaking to God in prayer. Concerning drunken priests, I am reluctant to speak at length, but I urge such persons to read Isaiah 52:12 and Isaiah 28:7, Micah 2:11, 1 Timothy 3:3, 1 Timothy 3:8, Isaiah 56:11, Isaiah 56:12, Leviticus 10:9, Jeremiah 35, Ezekiel 44:21, Matthew 24:49, 1 Thessalonians 5:7, Galatians 5:21.
Your best condition until you are sober is to be asleep, for then you do the least harm. You are made incapable of doing good, and equally incapable of receiving good from others; you are not even open to reproof or counsel. Anyone who offered to speak to you for the good of your soul would only dishonor the name and Word of God; it would be casting pearls before swine.
A story is told of a drunkard whom someone rebuked, saying, "Are you not ashamed to be in this state?" He replied, "Are you not ashamed to speak to a man who is drunk?" It is indeed a shame to the person who would cure you by reason, when you have thrown your reason away.
If you have taken only a cheerful cup and imagine yourself the fitter for your duty, and even if you perform it well outwardly, the principle is still false and base, and you deserve blame for casting your work upon so great a hazard. Sophocles said of an orator who wrote well when half drunk: "Though he did it well, he did it ignorantly and by chance." For your unsteadiness weakens your judgment, and whatever good you do is done by accident, as a passionate man may happen to speak well, but it is improbable and uncertain, and no credit to him that it did not turn out worse.
You also dispose yourself to almost every sin. Drunkenness breaks every one of the commandments by disposing men to break them all. It disables them above all in the duties of the first commandment, to know God, to believe, to trust, and to love him. It renders men wholly unfit for the holy worship required by the second commandment, as I have shown. God, who hates the guilt of former sin in his worshippers, hates present wickedness still more: "The sacrifice of the wicked is abomination: how much more when he bringeth it with a wicked mind." (Prov 21:27) Idolatry, wantonness, and excess in eating and drinking habitually encourage one another (1 Cor 10:7). Sacrifices of mirth, gluttony, and drunkenness are fit offerings for idols and devils, but not for God.
It is therefore commonly observed that it is the drunkards and riotous people in every town who are the great enemies of Gospel preaching, of all holy exercises, and of all who fear God and refuse to join their madness. When there is a sacrifice to be offered to Bacchus, any merry gathering where drinking, feasting, dancing, and carousing are the sport, that is where the ministers and servants of Christ are slandered, scorned, and reviled. (Acosta, speaking of drunkenness, remarks that it is the settled and consistent judgment of many that the Indians are taught the Christian religion in vain so long as this ruinous custom is kept up by the idle connivance of our own people: De Procuranda Indorum Salute, book 3, chapter 22.) That is where hellish reproaches of godliness, like the devil’s cannons, are fired without restraint, though by God’s mercy they carry more powder than shot and do little real damage.
That is where the devil sits as president in his council, plotting what to do against the people and ways of Christ. And though it is drunken, sottish counsel, it suits his business perfectly well, for the thunderbolt he has to cast is a brutish one, and the work he has to do is senseless and furious, and no other instruments will serve his purpose.
He has a scheme to blow up the reputation and honor of serious godliness; but whoever sets fire to his fuse must also blow himself up. No one is so fit for this work as a drunkard or a sensual sot. Few others will venture to cast their own souls into the fire of hell in order to blow a little foul breath into the faces of the godly. Few others would set their own houses on fire merely to trouble God’s servants with the smoke. Their very work is like that of those in Daniel 3, to cast the servants of Christ into the flames that must devour those who cast them, and that can scarcely singe a thread of the garments or a hair of the head of those for whom the fire was prepared (see Acosta, De Procuranda Indorum Salute, book 3, chapters 21–22). And who would do this, knowing what he was doing and in his right mind? Must a man not first be made drunk before he will do it?
Drunkenness also disposes you to swearing, blasphemy, perjury, and speaking contemptuously and irreverently of God, and to treating Scripture with profane mockery, and so "fools make a mock of sin." You are fit for none of the holy exercises of the Lord’s Day. That is the day you choose to defile with your filthy sin, the day on which God sends out his gracious invitations and the devil his wicked incitements; in which God gives most of his grace and the devil infects most with sin; in which God is best served by his sincere ones and the devil is most served by his impious ones.
You also dispose yourself to sin against your rulers. When you are drunk you have no command of tongue or action. How many in drunkenness have reproached and abused father and mother, spoken treason against their king, or reviled magistrates and superiors, and perhaps attempted and done mischief as well as spoken it? If you are in a position of authority, how unfit you are to judge or govern. Is it not right for any subject to appeal from you, as the woman appealed from Philip when he was drunk, to Philip when he was sober? You will be far more likely to abuse your inferiors than to govern them well.
Drunkenness also destroys civility, justice, and charity. It inflames the mind with anger and rage; it teaches the tongue to curse, rail, and slander; it makes you faithless and incapable of keeping any secret, and ready to betray your closest friend, being master of neither your mind, your tongue, nor your actions. Drunkenness has driven men to commit many thousands of murders. It has caused many to kill themselves and their closest relatives. Many have drowned by falling into water, or broken their necks falling from horses, or died suddenly from the body’s own suffocation. It draws men into idleness and pulls them away from their lawful calling. It produces a multitude of thieves by breeding poverty and emboldening men to villainy. It is a principal cause of lust and filthiness, and the great maintainer of whoredoms.
Drunkenness also takes away all the shame, fear, and wit that should restrain men from this or any other sin. What sin is there that a drunken man may not commit? He deserves no thanks for holding back from the greatest wickedness. Cities and kingdoms have been betrayed by drunkenness, and many a drunken garrison has let in the enemy. No confidence can be placed in a drunken man, and there is no mischief he is safe from.
Gluttons, drunkards, and lustful sensualists are prepared for atheism, infidelity, and any impious notion, for their wits are buried in the dunghill of their guts and drowned in the excess moisture of their brains: where the eye is dry, the understanding is clear. The vapors and fumes of their boiling lusts so intoxicate and cloud their brains that they have little use of their reason except to contrive the service of their guts and their lusts. Acosta reports that he himself saw two men come half-overcome with wine out of a tavern and kill each other with one and the same sword over the value of scarcely a penny, the blade being twice wrenched out of the stricken body in the fury of striking the other, so that in a moment both fell down lifeless (De Procuranda Indorum Salute, book 3, chapter 21).
12. Finally, you do not sin alone but tempt others with you toward perdition. It is the great crime of Jeroboam that he made Israel to sin. The judgment of God condemns those who not only do wickedness "but have pleasure in them that do it." Is this not your case? Are you not Satan’s instrument to tempt others with you, to waste their time, neglect their souls, and abuse God and his creatures? Some of you even glory in your shame, boasting that you have drunk down your companions and carried the day, the honor of a sponge or a tub, which can absorb or hold liquor just as well as you. What is such a man worthy of, who would transform himself and others into such monsters of iniquity?
IV. Now let us hear the drunkard’s excuses, for even drunkenness will claim the cover of reason, and men will not make themselves mad without some argument to justify it.
Objection 1: The tippler says, "I take no more than does me good. You allow a man to eat as much as does him good, why not to drink as much? No one is better placed to judge this than I, for I am sure I feel it do me good."
Answer: What good do you mean? Does it fit you for holy thoughts, words, or deeds? Does it help you to live well or prepare you to die well? Can you honestly claim it benefits your body’s health? You cannot say so without the charge of foolishness or self-conceit, when all the wisest physicians in the world hold the contrary. No, it does what gluttony does: it pleases you in the drinking, but it fills your body with impurities and phlegm and prepares it for many deadly sicknesses. It makes your body like ground after a flood, covered with foul slime; or like fen-land drowned in water, bearing no fruit; or like soil soaked by too much rain, dissolved to mud and fit for nothing.
It makes you like a leaking ship that must be pumped and emptied or it will sink. Without vomits and purges to empty you, you will quickly drown or suffocate your own life. As Basil says, "A drunkard is like a ship in a tempest, when all the cargo is thrown overboard to lighten it lest it sink." Physicians must pump you out, or you will drown, and even that will not serve if you keep filling again, for intemperance makes most diseases incurable. A historian tells of two physicians who disagreed in their prognosis about a patient: one abandoned him as incurable, the other undertook him as certainly curable; but when the second came to prescribe, he required so strict an abstinence as the patient would not undergo, and so they agreed in the end, one judging him incurable because intemperate, the other curable if he would be temperate.
You who feel the drink doing you good have little idea how the devil has a design in it, not only to have your soul, but to have it quickly, so that the crumbling walls of your body may not hold it long. I must tell you that you have reason to value a good physician for more than your life, and are more indebted to him than most, for he may help keep your soul out of hell a little longer, "if God will give thee repentance," that you "mayest escape out of the snare of the devil, who taketh thee captive at his will" (2 Tim 2:25–26).
Aelian writes of King Antigonus that, having great respect for Zeno the philosopher, he once met him while drunk and, embracing him, urged him to ask whatever he wished, binding himself with many oaths to grant it. Zeno thanked him, and the request he made was that the king go home and vomit, telling him that he needed to be relieved of his drink far more than he himself needed any gift.
The truth is, the good you feel the drink doing you is nothing more than the present pleasing of your appetite and the tickling of your imagination by its exhilarating fumes. The glutton, the whoremonger, and every sensual wretch will say the same, that he feels it doing him good. God preserve all sober men from such a good. The gambler feels the sport doing him good too, but perhaps he is quickly made a beggar by it. It is reason and faith, not your appetite or your present feeling, that must tell you what does you good, and how much.
Objection 2: But I have heard some physicians say it is wholesome to be drunk sometimes.
Answer: None but some sot who had first drunk away his own understanding could say such a thing. I have known physicians who were drunkards themselves and were ready to plead for their own vice; but they quickly killed themselves, and all their skill could not save their lives from the consequences of their own brutishness, just as the knowledge and doctrine of a wicked preacher will not save his soul if he lives contrary to what he professes. And even if the vomiting of a drunkard did him some good among all the harm, are there not easier, safer, and more lawful means enough to achieve the same benefit without the harm? A man who knows no better remedy than this is a brute, not a physician. Your conscience tells you this is nothing but a false excuse.
Objection 3: But I wrong no one in my drinking; the harm is my own.
Answer: It is no credit to you if you wrong nobody. Read over the aggravations set out above and then justify yourself in this if you can. You seem to think nothing of wronging God by disobedience. But suppose the harm were no one’s but your own, do you hate yourself? Is your own harm nothing to you? Do you make nothing of damning your own soul? Whom will you love if you hate yourself? It is the specific aggravation of this sin, as of fornication (1 Cor 6:18), that it is against your own body, and far more so as it is against your own soul.
Objection 4: But I was only merry; I was not drunk.
Answer: It would be well for you if God would accept your labels and definitions, and count no one a sinner who does not count himself one. There are several degrees of drunkenness short of the highest. And even if your reason was not disturbed, mere excess in drinking, tippling, and greediness of appetite will prove a greater sin than you suppose.
Objection 5: But I drink only a little; my head is weak and a little overturns it.
Answer: If you knew that beforehand, you are the more without excuse for not avoiding the measure you know you cannot bear. If you knew that less poison would kill you than it would another man, you would be the more afraid of it, not the less.
Objection 6: But I have a thirst on me, and I take no more than will quench it.
Answer: The whoremonger says the same, that he has a lust on him and takes no more than will quench it. And the malicious man who beats you or ruins you may say he has a passion on him and takes no more revenge than satisfies it. But if you add drunkenness to thirst, read your doom again (Deut 29:19). If it is a natural, moderate thirst, moderation will satisfy it. If it is a diseased thirst, as in a fever or dropsy, a physician must direct your cure, and weak drink is fitter for a thirst than strong.
But if it is the thirst of a drunkard’s raging appetite, long accustomed to being pleased and loath to be denied, you had better quench it on better and cheaper terms than displeasing God and damning your soul, lest you find it far more tormenting in the flames of hell to want a drop of water for your tongue than it would ever have been to bridle a beastly appetite. Lest you then cry out as Lysimachus did when thirst forced him to surrender to the Scythians for a little drink: "For how short a pleasure did I lose so great a felicity!" Take heed lest you reason your souls into impenitence.
Pliny observes that the habit of drinking increases the craving for it; and Acosta adds that to try to settle drunkenness by drinking is like trying to put out a fire by heaping on fuel, for what is granted to nature’s own appetite is moderate, but a vicious craving beyond nature is never filled.
Question 1: Is it not lawful to drink when we are thirsty, and know of no harm that it is likely to do us, since thirst tells us what the stomach needs?
Answer: A beast may act on that principle, having no higher faculty to guide it. A man may factor in his thirst as one consideration for reason to weigh in judging the right quantity and time, but no more than that. A man must never drink merely to please his appetite, whether against reason or without it. No man should so subordinate his reason to sense as to take appetite for his principal guide; nor should he be so brutish as to know what helps or hurts him only by present feeling.
Sometimes true reason will tell a man that thirst signals a genuine need for drink, and then he may take it. But often, and commonly with blockish people, satisfying a thirst will harm their health, and they are too foolish to know it: either because they are ignorant of such things, or because appetite makes them unwilling to believe it until they feel the damage, or because they judge only by immediate effects. A man may kill himself by drinking cold drink while overheated, or during certain fevers, a dropsy, a cough, a wasting condition, and so on. Excess quietly corrupts the blood and stores up the seeds of many diseases, which are incurable before the sot will believe that drinking when he was thirsty did him any harm.
If drink will truly do no harm, you may drink when thirsty, because it will then do good. But if it will quench natural heat, hinder digestion, and breed diseases through ill timing, bad quality, or excess, neither your thirst nor your sottish ignorance of the harm will excuse the sin, or prevent the coughs, kidney stones, gout, colic, swellings, palsies, agues, fevers, or death that will follow.
Question 2: Is it not lawful to drink a health sometimes, when refusal would give offense, or to be uncovered while others drink it?
Answer: Distinguish between: 1. drinking moderately as need requires, and drinking immoderately when there is no need; and 2. the foreseeable effects, whether a thing is done ordinarily, when it will cause harm, or extraordinarily, when it will prevent a greater harm. With those distinctions made, I conclude as follows.
1. It is unlawful to drink more than is good for your health at the provocation of other men.
2. It is unlawful to do what tempts and encourages others to drink too much. The custom of pledging healths does precisely that, especially when refusing is treated as an offense.
3. Therefore the ordinary pledging or drinking of such healths is unlawful, because it is the scandalous hardening of others in their sin to their ruin.
4. But if we fall in among such furious beasts as would stab a man who refused to drink a health, it is lawful to do so in order to save one’s life, just as it is lawful to hand over one’s purse to a robber, because drinking that cup is not something simply evil in itself, only evil by circumstance, and a weightier circumstance may outweigh it.
5. Therefore any other circumstance besides saving your life, which genuinely outweighs the harmful one, may make compliance lawful: as, for instance, where in some cases and companies the offense caused by refusal would do far more harm than yielding would, such as where a malignant company would use it to impugn one’s loyalty to the king.
6. Christian prudence, therefore, not carnal compliance, must be the present judge in each case, by weighing the good and evil effects against each other.
7. To be uncovered when others make the honor of the king or of superiors the ground for it is a ceremony that may, on the same reasoning, be complied with.
8. When we are extraordinarily pressed into any such ceremony to avoid a greater evil, it is fitting to add words, where we are free to do so, that may prevent scandal or prevent those present from being hardened in sin.
9. And it is a duty to avoid the company that will put us in such difficult situations, as far as our calling permits.
V. Because it is the drunkard’s heart and will that needs persuading more than his understanding needs directing, I will, before the directions, attempt his fuller conviction. If he will only read and consider soberly (if he is ever sober) the following questions, and not leave them until he has answered them to the satisfaction of his own conscience:
Question 1: Do you know that you are a man, and what a man is? Do you know that reason is what distinguishes him from a beast, which is governed by appetite and has no reason? If you do know this, let your reason do its proper work. Do not drown it, and do not set the beast above it.
Question 2: Do you believe there is a God who governs the world, or not? If not, tell me how you came to be a man, and how your tongue and palate came to taste your drink and food any more than your finger does. Look at your finger and at your tongue: you can see no reason why one should taste and not the other. If you live in the midst of a world which God has made and daily governs, and yet do not believe he exists, you are already in a state far worse than drunkenness or madness, and it is no wonder you are a drunkard.
But if you do believe there is a God, hear further, you stupid beast, and tremble! Is he the Governor of heaven and earth, yet not worthy to govern you? Is all the world at his disposal, yet he is not worthy to direct your throat and appetite? Are crowns, kingdoms, heaven, and hell at his disposal, yet he is not worthy to be master of your cup and your company? Will you say to him by your practice: go rule the sun and moon and all the world, except my appetite and my cup?
Question 3: Do you truly believe that God is present with you, and sees and hears everything done and said among you? If not, you do not believe he is God, for one who is absent, unknowing, and not infinite, omnipresent, and omniscient is not God. And if God is not present, you are not present either, for what else upholds you and maintains your life, your breath, and your being? But if you do believe that God is present, do you dare to drink on, and dare to waste your time before him, prating over a pot with your companions?
Question 4: Tell me, do you believe that Holy Scripture is true? If not, no wonder you are a drunkard. Acosta counts it a great reproach to Christians that Inga, a barbarian king given over to idols, held his subject peoples back from drunkenness, while our own people, whose corrupt manners ought rather to have been reformed, have made such increase in it (De Procuranda Indorum Salute, book 3, chapter 21).
But if you do believe Scripture, then remember: it is true that "drunkards shall not inherit the kingdom of God" (1 Cor 6:10). And mark what else Scripture says. "Woe to the crown of pride, to the drunkards of Ephraim" (Isa 28:1). "Woe to him that giveth his neighbour drink, that puttest thy bottle to him and makest him drunk also" (Hab 2:15).
"Woe to them that rise up early in the morning that they may follow strong drink, that continue till night till wine inflame them: and the harp, and the viol, and the tabret, and the pipe, and wine, are in their feasts, but they regard not the work of the LORD, nor consider the operation of his hands" (Isa 5:11–12). "Woe unto them that are mighty to drink wine, and men of strength to mingle strong drink" (Isa 5:22). "It is not for kings to drink wine, nor for princes strong drink; lest they drink and forget the law, and pervert the judgment of any of the afflicted: give strong drink to him that is ready to perish, and wine to those that be of heavy hearts" (Prov 31:4–6).
"Take heed to yourselves, lest at any time your hearts be overcharged with surfeiting, and drunkenness, and cares of this life, and so that day come upon you unawares" (Luke 21:34; see also Amos 6:6). "Not in gluttony and drunkenness, not in chambering and wantonness, not in strife and envying; but put ye on the Lord Jesus Christ, and make no provision for the flesh to satisfy the lusts thereof" (Rom 13:13–14).
"Wine is a mocker; strong drink is raging; and whosoever is deceived thereby is not wise" (Prov 20:1).
"Who hath woe? who hath sorrow? who hath contentions? who hath babbling? who hath wounds without cause? who hath redness of eyes? They that tarry long at the wine, they that go to seek mixed wine. Look not thou upon the wine when it is red, when it giveth his colour in the cup, when it moveth itself aright: at the last it biteth like a serpent, and stingeth like an adder. Thine eyes shall behold strange women, and thine heart shall utter perverse things: yea, thou shalt be as he that lieth down in the midst of the sea, or as he that lieth upon the top of a mast" (Prov 23:29–32). "Whoredom and wine, and new wine take away the heart" (Hos 4:11). "Awake, ye drunkards, and weep and howl, all ye drinkers of wine" (Joel 1:5). If you truly believe the Word of God, why do not such passages make you tremble?
Question 5: Consider into how dangerous a situation you place yourself when you are drunk or keep company with drunkards. How many other sins does it expose you to? How great is your peril of some immediate judgment from God? Even the biblical examples that you might think encouraging should make you tremble.
Noah was drunk only once, yet that single lapse is recorded to his shame as a warning to others. Lot fell into a horrid crime through the temptation of drunkenness. David made Uriah drunk in order to conceal his own sin (2 Sam 11:13). Amnon, David’s son, was murdered by his brother Absalom’s command, in God’s just retribution, when "his heart was merry with wine" (2 Sam 13:28). Nabal was struck dead by God after his drunken feast (1 Sam 25:36–38). King Elah was murdered while drinking himself drunk (1 Kgs 16:9). And in the midst of Belshazzar’s carousing, the terrible hand appeared writing upon the wall to signal the loss of his kingdom, and that very night he was slain.
You see that God does not spare even kings, who one might suppose would be allowed more liberty in pleasure. Will he spare you? "It is not for kings to drink wine, nor for princes strong drink" (Prov 31:4–5), and is it then fitting for you? Mark the dreadful fruit of it even among the greatest: "They make the king glad with their wickedness, and the princes with their lies: they are all adulterers as an oven heated … In the day of our king the princes have made him sick with bottles of wine: he stretched out his hand with scorners" (Hos 7:3–5). Whether great or small, both soul and body are thrown by tippling and drunkenness into greater danger than a man at sea in a raging tempest. You place yourself in the path of God’s vengeance, and you are not likely to escape it for long.
Question 6: Have you ever measured your sin by that remarkable punishment God commanded against incorrigible gluttons and drunkards? "If a man have a stubborn and rebellious son, which will not obey the voice of his father, or the voice of his mother, and that, when they have chastened him, will not hearken to them: then shall his father and his mother lay hold on him, and bring him out unto the elders of his city, and to the gate of his place; and they shall say unto the elders of his city, This our son is stubborn and rebellious, he will not obey our voice; he is a glutton and a drunkard. And all the men of the city shall stone him with stones, that he die: so shalt thou put away evil from among you; and all Israel shall hear, and fear." (Deut 21:18–21)
Gluttony and drunkenness are clearly heinous crimes, when a man’s own father and mother were obligated to bring him before the magistrate to be put to death if he would not be reformed by their correction. Notice also that youth is no excuse for it here, though today it is widely thought excusable in the young.
Question 7: Do you think your drink too good to give up at God’s command? Or do you think God begrudges you its sweetness? Or do you rather understand that he forbids it for your good, so that you may escape its harm? And tell me plainly: do you love God more than your drink and pleasure, or do you not? If you do not, your own conscience, if it is not entirely seared, must tell you that there is no hope of salvation in that state. If you say that you do love God more, will God or any wise person believe you, when you will not be governed by him so far as to leave so small a thing for his sake? "For this is the love of God, that we keep his commandments: and his commandments are not grievous." (1 John 5:3) So also (2 John 6).
Question 8: Do you remember that your carcass must lie rotting in the grave, and how loathsome a thing it must soon become? Can you make so great a matter of presently satisfying so vile a body, and manure the earth at so dear a cost?
Question 9: Would you have all your friends and children do as you do? If so, what would become of your household? It would be a mad world if everyone were a drunkard. Would you have your wife be a drunkard? If she were, you could scarcely be confident of her chastity. Would you have your servants be drunkards? They might set your house on fire; they would do you little work, or do it so poorly it were better left undone. Your house would be bedlam if everyone were drunk, and far worse than bedlam, for at least in bedlam there are some sane men to govern and restrain the mad ones.
But if you dislike it in your wife, children, and servants, why do you continue in it yourself? Are you not closest to yourself? Do you love others better than yourself? Would you rather have your own soul damned than theirs? Or can you endure it more easily in yourself? I have sometimes observed drunkards who are very severe against the same sin in their children, and very eager to have them sober. The reason is not hard to find: their children’s sobriety costs them nothing, and requires no denial of their own appetite, whereas their own sobriety would.
Question 10: Would you want your physician drunk when he should be curing your sickness? Your lawyer drunk when he should be pleading your cause? The judge drunk when he should be deciding it? If not, why will you be drunk when you should be serving God and attending to the business of your soul? If you would not have your servant idling at an alehouse when he should be doing your work, will you sit there potting and prating yourself, when you have a thousand times more important work to do for your everlasting happiness?
Question 11: If someone were to lame or spoil your beast and make him unfit for your service, would you be pleased with it? And will you make yourself unfit for the service of God, as though your own work were of less concern than your beast’s?
Question 12: Would it please you if your servants poured all that drink into the gutter? If not, I have already shown you that it should displease you more to pour it into your own belly, for you will find at last that it harms you far more.
Question 13: What taste does your pleasant liquor have the next day? Is it any sweeter then than wholesome abstinence would have been? All the delight vanishes instantly. Nothing remains but the slime in your gut and the ulcer in your conscience, which cannot be cured by all your wealth, nor long deadened by all your pleasure. Can you set much store by so brief a delight? All those sweet and merry cups are now no sweeter than if they had been wormwood; and all the rest will quickly come to the same end and the same taste.
As Plato said of his modest supper compared to a rich man’s feast, "Yours seems better tonight, but mine will be better tomorrow." So your conscience tells you that temperance and holy obedience will be better tomorrow, and better throughout eternity, even though gluttony and drunkenness seem better now.
Question 14: Do you consider how dearly you are paying for hell, and that you are buying damnation at a harder price than salvation would have cost you? What shame it costs you! What sickness it is likely to cost you! What painful vomitings, or worse, do you endure! How much it costs you in property and money! And is hell worth all this trouble?
Question 15: Do you not think in your heart that sober, temperate, godly men live a quieter and more comfortable life than you do, as well as a more honest and safer one?
The person who needs least from created things is the happiest, not the one who has most. Socrates said it belongs to God alone to need nothing; but those who came closest to God in this were the happiest of men.
If you do think the godly man happier, why will you not imitate him? The choice is as open to you as it was to him. If you think he is not happier, consider this: as he has none of your forbidden cups, so he has none of your thirst or craving for them. Abstinence is far sweeter to him. He has none of your sour belchings or vomitings, none of your shame or danger, no reckoning to pay. He has none of your pangs of conscience and terrors under the guilt of such a sin. He lives in the love of God and the anticipation of heaven, while you are in the alehouse.
Do you not think in your conscience that, for a heart fitted and sanctified to it, living in the love of God is a sweeter thing than living in the love of your sensuality? Dare you say, whatever you may think, that God, and heaven, and holiness are not as lovely and worthy of delight as a cup of wine or ale? Surely you dare not say so.
If for no other reason than the different prospect of death and eternity for them compared to you, I judge your life in the midst of all its pleasures incomparably more wretched than theirs. They look at death as the time of hope, the day of their deliverance, as an innocent or pardoned man looks toward the assizes. But you look on death with terror, as the end of all your mirth, as the guilty criminal thinks of the assizes, or else with numbness and presumption, which is worse still. They look to eternity as their endless, unspeakable happiness; you scarcely dare think seriously of it except through the deadening comfort of unbelief or false hopes. You dare not look steadily beyond death except through the devil’s deceiving spectacles.
I tell you plainly: a sober, godly man would not live your merry life, as you count it merry, for a single day, not for all your wealth or any worldly gain. He would rather lie in jail or sit in the stocks during that time than drink and swagger with you. Keep your merriment to yourself, for no wise or good person will share it with you. If you were their enemy, they would not wish you so much misery as you choose for yourself.
There is a story of a confessor who, hearing many confess the sin of drunkenness, resolved to try for himself what pleasure it held. Having vomited and slept it off, the next drunkard who came to him in confession was assigned, as his penance, to be drunk again, with the confessor’s comment that he could devise no sharper punishment.
Question 16: Does your very pride not cure your drunkenness? Pride is so natural and deep-rooted a sin that, if you have not overcome your sensuality, you have certainly not overcome your pride. Is your reputation worth so little to you? Will you, for a cup of drink, become the talk of the country, the scorn of the town, the sport and laughing-stock of boys, and the pity of sober people? If you are a great man among them and they dare not say it to your face, so that you never hear what they say of you, in private they take free liberties with your name and speak of you as of a filthy beast.
Do you imagine that sober men honor you? Whatever honor your position may accidentally command is a separate matter; but you take a course that prevents anyone from honoring you for your worth, and you do your worst to bring your rank and place into contempt. It is said that in Spain a drunkard is not allowed to serve as a witness against any man, and surely he is not a credible person. Regard your reputation, if you care nothing for your soul. "They that are drunken, are drunken in the night" (1 Thess 5:7).
Question 17: Do you not love the very body you so lavishly pamper? If you do, why will you drown it and choke it up with phlegm and filth? Ask physicians whether drunkenness is wholesome. Notice how few drunkards live to old age: "a gouty Ennius" is a proverbial saying. The sickness lasts longer than the sweetness of your cup. If you do not fear hell, fear the consumption, the gout, or the dropsy.
Question 18: Why should you not take more pleasure in the company of your family, and in the company of people who fear God, who worship him in sincerity, and who will do their best to help save you? Can you give any reason why such company should not be more pleasant to you than your drinking companions? And why should it not be more pleasant to speak of the way to heaven, the pardon of sin, the love of Christ, and eternal happiness, than to prate a deal of idle nonsense in an alehouse? There is no reason for it but your filthy mind, which is suited to vanity and sin and unsuited to everything that is wise and holy.
Question 19: What if you were to die in a drunken fit? Would you not yourself consider your case desperate or dangerous? It may well be so; for all you know, it has been the case of many a person. But even if it were not, to die a drunkard is as certain a damnation as to die in the very act of drunkenness. If the guilt of the sin rests on you, it does not matter when it was committed, whether recently or long ago: unpardoned sin is certain damnation, and it is certainly unpardoned until it is truly repented of, and it is not repented of if it is not forsaken. Think, then, how you will look back on these days, and what thoughts you will have then of your cups and your companions.
Question 20: Are you willing to part with your sin, or are you not? Speak, are you willing? If you are not willing, bear witness against yourself that you do not repent of it and that you are not forgiven for it, and therefore that you are at present a slave of the devil. If you die in that state, you are as surely damned as you are now alive. Bear witness that you were not kept from grace, and consequently from heaven, against your will, but by your willful refusal of it; and that it was not because you could not be saved that you go to hell, but because you would not. Surely even now you cannot deny any of this, if you confess that you are not willing to amend. Take your will in sin, if God’s will, which offered you mercy and commanded you to accept it, must be violated; but be assured that God will have his will in punishing you.
But you will likely say that you are willing to amend and leave your sin, but you cannot do it because the flesh is frail, company is tempting, and God has not given you grace: willing you are, but unable. Wait a moment. God will not let you carry it off and smooth over your wickedness with a lie. Your real meaning, if you spoke plainly, is not that you are presently and heartily willing to forsake your sin, but only that you would be willing if drink and the devil did not tempt you. So you will be willing to love God and be saved when nothing tempts you to the contrary! Would you thank your wife for such a willingness to forsake adultery when no one tempts her to it? Or your servant for such willingness to do your work when he has nothing to tempt him to idleness or neglect? Judge by this what thanks you deserve from God for such willingness.
Do not trifle with God or mock your conscience. Speak plainly to the question: are you willing to give up your drinking company and tippling from this day forward, or are you not? Take care what you say. If you say "No," God may say "No" to all your cries for mercy in the day of your misery and distress. But if you still say you are willing but unable, I will prove you are lying.
Question 1: Tell me, then: what force is used to make you sin against your will? Were you carried to the alehouse, or did you go yourself? Were you gagged and drenched? Was the drink poured down your throat by violence, or did you take the cup and pour it down yourself? Who was the man that held open your mouth and poured it in? Indeed, if it had been so, it would not have been your sin, for where there is no will, there is no sin. Or did they set a sword or pistol to your breast and force you to it? Even if they had, that would not have proved you unwilling; it would only mean they forced you to be willing, and their force is no excuse, for God threatened hell, and you should have feared that most.
Question 2: Did you love the drink, or loathe it while you were drinking? Did you love it against your will, when love and willingness are one and the same thing?
Question 3: Will you wait until you are carried to drink next time, and until it is forcibly poured down your throat with a funnel? If not, confess that it is your own will.
Question 4: Could you not hold back if the judge or the king were standing beside you? And can you not hold back when God stands by? If you will, you can.
Question 5: Could you not hold back if you were certain to be put to death for it, if the law hanged all drunkards and the hangman were at your back? Surely you could. Can you not hold back by an act of will, then, when God has made it worse than hanging, and when death is on its way to fetch you to execution?
Question 6: Could you not hold back in sickness, if your physician required it and told you that drinking would kill you? I have no doubt you could. If you could not, you are very unworthy to live, a person who cannot deny himself a cup of drink to save his own life. And you are equally unworthy to be saved if you will not do for your soul what you would do for your present life.
Question 7: Could you not hold back if it were to save the life of your wife, or child, or friend, or neighbor? If you knew that refusing your forbidden cup would save the life of any one of them, could you not, indeed, would you not, do it? If not, you tell the world what kind of husband, father, friend, and neighbor you are: one who would not refuse a cup of drink to save a friend or neighbor’s life.
I would think you an unworthy friend if you would not do that much at a friend’s request, even if no such necessity were attached to it. If this is really so, I will never take a drunkard for my friend, for he would not refuse a cup of drink for my sake, not even to save my life. If you say, "God forbid, I would do far more than that," then why did you say you could not hold back? Notice how your own tongue reproves your falsehood. And can you not do for your own soul what you could do for the life, or at the request, of a friend or neighbor?
Question 8: Could you not hold back if it were to gain a lordship or a kingdom? Or to save your own property, if it were all in danger and only this would save it? I have no doubt you could. Why then do you say you cannot?
Question 9: If you were certain you were to die tomorrow, would you be drunk tonight? Or if you were sure to die within a week or a month, would you be drunk before then? I do not believe you would; fear would shut your mouth that long. You see, then, that you can hold back if you were only willing and awakened out of your stupidity and folly.
Question 10: What if you were sure there was an ounce of arsenic or some other poison in the cup? Could you not hold back then? Yes, without question. It is plain, therefore, that you speak falsely when you say you cannot. And is not God’s wrath and curse in your cup far worse than poison?
Question 11: What if you saw the devil standing beside you, offering you the cup and urging you to drink it? Could you not hold back then? Yes, without question. And is he not just as certainly there tempting you as if you saw him? Well, the matter is proved against you to your own conscience: if you will hold back, you can.
Question 12: But if you truly cannot hold back, consider whether you can better bear the pains of hell. God is not jesting with you in his threatenings. If your thirst is harder to bear than hell, then choose whatever is easiest to you, but remember hereafter that you had your choice.
Now, are you willing to let go of your sin? For I am sure you are able, to the extent that you are willing. I will take your case as it is: you have some half-hearted, ineffectual willingness, a lazy wish that cannot conquer temptation; you are sometimes in a slightly better frame of mind than at other times; you love your sin and would not leave it if you could freely choose, yet you do not love hell, and so you have some thought of parting with your cups against your will, out of fear of punishment. These wishes and half-formed purposes will never save you.
What is required is a renewed nature, one that loves God and hates the sin, to make you capable of salvation. But in the meantime it is still necessary that you hold back from your sin, even if only through fear, since you cannot otherwise expect the Holy Ghost to renew your nature. I will therefore give you practical directions for holding back from your sin as surely and as easily as possible, on the condition that you are willing; and the performance of these directions will itself help to promote your willingness.
Practical Directions against Tippling and Drunkenness
Direction 1. Write over your bed and your chamber door, where you may read it every morning before you go out, some text of Holy Scripture suited to serve as your daily reminder, such as 1 Corinthians 6:10: "Drunkards shall not inherit the kingdom of God," and (Rom 8:13): "If ye live after the flesh, ye shall die: but if by the Spirit you mortify the deeds of the body, you shall live." Read it before you leave the house.
Direction 2. Also fall on your knees before God and earnestly beg him to keep you that day from temptations, from bad company, and from all your fleshly desires and excess, and above all, that he would renew your nature and give you a true hatred of the sin.
Direction 3. Keep yourself in the constant employment of your calling. Do not spend a quarter of an hour in idleness; allow your thoughts no leisure to dwell on drink and pleasure, and give your body no opportunity to pursue them. God has commanded everyone to labor six days and eat their bread in the sweat of their brow, and has forbidden idleness and negligence in one’s calling. Avoiding idleness will help you greatly.
Direction 4. Do not count on long life. Think how quickly death will come, and that for all you know you may die that very day, and how dreadful it would be to be found among tipplers, or to die before you are truly converted. Think of this before you leave the house. Think of it on your way to the alehouse. Look on the cup and the grave together: the dust of those bones will be wholesome spice to you. Remember, when you see the wine or ale, how unlike it is to the black and loathsome fluid your blood and humors will become when you are dead. Remember that the hand that takes the cup must shortly be scattered bones and dust; that the mouth that drinks from it must shortly be an ugly hole; that the palate, stomach, and brain that take pleasure in it must shortly be a stinking puddle. The graves of drunkards are the field and garden of the devil, where corpses are sown to rise at the resurrection as fuel for hell.
Direction 5. When you are tempted toward the alehouse, call up your reason. Remember that there is a God who sees you and will judge you, that you have an endless life of joy or torment shortly to possess, that you have already sinned in this way too long, that without sound repentance your case is desperate, and that you are far from true repentance while you continue in sin. Ask yourself: Have I not sinned long enough already? Have I not abused God’s mercy long enough? Shall I make my case beyond remedy and throw away all hope? Does not God stand by, seeing and hearing everything? Am I not stepping through death into an endless world? Think on these things, and use your reason, if you are a man, and have reason to use.
Direction 6. Practice daily repentance for what is past, and this will guard you for the time to come. Confess your former sin to God with sorrow, and beg his forgiveness with tears and earnest prayer. If you make light of everything that is past, you are prepared to commit more. As you go about your work, think how grievously you have sinned, against your own knowledge and conscience, in the sight of God, against all his mercies, and how stubbornly you have continued, how ungratefully you have rejected mercy, neglected Christ, and refused grace. Think what would have become of you had you died in that condition, and how much you owe to God’s patience in not cutting you off and casting you into hell, and that he has provided and offered you a Savior and is still willing to pardon and receive you through his Son, if you will but resolutely return and live in faith and holiness.
These penitent thoughts and exercises will mortify your sin and bring you healing. Fast and humble yourself for what you have already done, as the holy apostle says: "Forasmuch as Christ hath suffered for us in the flesh, arm yourselves likewise with the same mind: for he that hath suffered in the flesh hath ceased from sin; that he no longer should live the rest of his time in the flesh to the lusts of men, but to the will of God. For the time past of our life may suffice us to have wrought the will of the Gentiles, when we walked in lasciviousness, lusts, excess of wine, revellings, banquetings, abominable idolatries; wherein they think it strange that you run not with them to the same excess of riot, speaking evil of you: who shall give account to him that is ready to judge the quick and the dead." (1 Pet 4:1–5)
Direction 7. Keep away from the place and the company: "be not partakers with them. Have no fellowship with the unfruitful works of darkness, but rather reprove them." (Eph 5:7, 11) You cannot deny that you are able to do this if you will. Can you not stay at home and keep away from them? If you truly want to escape, do not run into the snare.
Direction 8. Stop at the first cup; do not let yourself be drawn on little by little. As the sluggard says, "yet a little more sleep," so the drunkard says, "yet a little more drink: I will take just one more cup." Know your proper measure, so that you can recognize excess. For an ordinary, healthy person who does not labor and sweat heavily, a quart a day is enough; for cold and phlegmatic persons it is too much. The old rule ran: "The first cup is for thirst, the second for mirth, the third for sensual pleasure, the fourth for madness." Those of you who have been drinking too much for a long time should drink less than other people, not the same. Your souls require it for penitence and prevention; your bodies require it, to remedy the accumulated damage already done.
Direction 9. Avoid the ceremonies drunkards use to tempt others: drinking healths, urging others to pledge them, or pressing them to drink more. Plutarch records that when Agesilaus was made master of a feast and was to set its rules for drinking, his law was: "If there is wine enough, give every man what he asks for; if there is not enough, divide it equally." By this means no one was tempted or urged to drink, and the intemperate were ashamed to ask for more than others. As among witches, so among drunkards, the devil has his own laws and ceremonies, and it is dangerous to practice them.
Direction 10. Go to your sinful companions in their own houses, and tell them plainly and seriously that you repent of what you have already done, that you are ashamed to remember it, and that you now see there is a righteous God, a day of judgment, and an endless punishment to be reckoned with. Tell them you are resolved you will be voluntarily mad no more; that you will not sell your soul and your Savior for a merry cup. Beseech them, for the sake of Christ and of their souls, to join you in repentance and reformation, but let them know that if they will not, you have come to take your leave of them, and are resolved you will no longer be their companion in sin, lest you become their companion in hell.
If you are truly willing to repent and be saved, do this at once and plainly, and do not flinch at their displeasure or contempt. If you will not do it, say you will not, and say nothing more about being unable. Say plainly: "I will keep my sin and be damned," for that is what it amounts to.
Direction 11. When a cup of excess is offered to you, picture these words written on it: "Sin and hell." Picture the devil offering it and urging you to drink. Picture Christ bleeding on the cross and calling out to you: "O drink not that which cost so dear a price as my blood!" Press this image firmly into your mind, and it is not unreasonable. Sin truly is in that cup; hell follows close on sin; it is the devil who is driving you on; and it is Christ, unseen, who would turn you back.
Direction 12. Imagine that the cup offered to you contains deadly poison, and then ask yourself: would I drink it if there were poison in it? If not, why drink it when sin is in it and hell is near? The image is not empty. It is recorded of Cyrus that when Astyages noticed at a feast that he drank no wine, and asked his reason, Cyrus answered that he feared there was poison in the cup, for he had observed that some of those who drank from it lost their speech or understanding, others vomited, and so he was afraid it would poison him. Whatever one thinks of that, the cup is certainly poison to the soul.
Direction 13. Look soberly at a drunken man, and consider whether that is a desirable state for a wise man to put himself into. Observe how repulsive he appears, heavy eyes, a slobbering mouth reeking of drink or vomit, staggering, falling, spewing, bawling, talking like a madman, pitied by the wise, hooted at by boys, and reeling on headlong toward hell. Then look at a wise and sober man: see how composed and dignified are his face and bearing, how sound his words, how orderly his conduct, how calm his mind, envied by the wicked, but respected by all who are fair-minded. Then consider which of the two it is better to resemble. Basil says, "Drunkenness makes men sleep like the dead and wake like the sleeping." It turns a man into a useless, foul, filthy, harmful, and devouring beast.
Direction 14. If none of this is sufficient, and you are willing to be helped, there is a cheap restraint at hand, a remedy that works against drunkenness and excess. Resolve that after every cup of excess you will drink a cup of wormwood juice, or of carduus, or centaury, or germander: at the very least as soon as you come home and recover your senses, make this your penance. Keep to it for even a little while, and your appetite will sooner choose to go without the drink than endure the penance. Do not hesitate. If your reason is not strong enough for a manly cure, drench yourself like a beast and use such a cure as you are capable of; in time it may bring you to the point where a better cure is within reach. A bitter draught is a very cheap remedy for preventing a sin.
Direction 15. If none of this serves, there is yet another remedy, if only you are willing. Confess that you are unfit to govern yourself, and put yourself under the governance of someone else, your wife, your parents, or a friend. This requires the following steps:
1. Engage your wife or friend to watch over you, and not to allow you to go to the alehouse or to drink beyond what is good for your health.
2. Hand over your purse to them and keep no money yourself.
3. Drink nothing at home except what they give you, and leave it to them to judge what measure is best for you.
4. When you are tempted to go to the alehouse, tell your wife or friend so that they may watch over you, just as you would call for help if thieves were robbing you.
5. Allow your wife or friend to instruct the ale-sellers not to serve you; and go yourself, when you are in your right mind, and charge them yourself to give you none, telling them that you are not yourself, or in your right senses, when you ask for it.
If these measures seem too hard to you now, and you will sin on and risk the wrath and curse of God and hell rather than use them, then remember hereafter that you were damned because you chose to be, that you chose the road to hell to avoid these inconveniences, and take what you get by it. But do not say you could not help it, for you certainly can do this if you will. You lock your door against thieves: lock your mouth too against a far more dangerous thief, one who would rob you of your reason and your salvation. Basil says, "If a master does no more than cuff or beat his servants, they will flee from the blows, and will you not flee from the drink that would shatter your mind and understanding?"
Direction 16. But the saving remedy is this: study the love of God in Christ, the riches of grace, and the eternal glory promised to holy souls, until you have fallen in love with God, with heaven, and with holiness, and have found a sweeter pleasure than your excess, and then you will need no more directions.
Read Ephesians 5:18.
CHAPTER 23
DIRECTIONS AGAINST FORNICATION AND FILTHY LUSTS
Title 1. Directions against Fornication and All Uncleanness
Although adultery and fornication, considered as sins against another person, are forbidden in the seventh commandment and should be treated there, they are also sins against our own bodies, bodies that should be members of Christ and temples of the Holy Ghost, as 1 Corinthians 6:15–19. For that reason they are treated here among the sins of the senses. I choose to address them here also because what I said in the two preceding titles against gluttony and drunkenness applies equally to this sin. Nearly all the same arguments, searching questions, and directions will serve if you simply substitute the name of this sin. Since the reader does not love needless repetition, I am glad of this means to avoid naming so odious and filthy a sin more often than necessary, though something particular to it must still be said. I will therefore: 1. show the greatness of the sin; and 2. give directions for the cure.
I. The Greatness of the Sin of Fornication
No sin is so odious that love for it, and frequent practice of it, will not go far toward reconciling even the judgment to it, leading a person either to think it lawful, or tolerable and venial; to think it no sin at all, or only a small sin, easily forgiven. With some brutish persons this happens even in the case of this sin.
1. It is reason enough against any sin that it is forbidden by the most wise, infallible, and universal King of all the world. Your Maker’s will is enough to condemn it, and will be enough to condemn those who remain its servants. He has said:
"Thou shalt not commit adultery. Be not deceived, neither fornicators, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor effeminate, nor abusers of themselves with mankind, shall inherit the kingdom of God. Know ye not that your bodies are the members of Christ? Shall I then take the members of Christ, and make them the members of an harlot? God forbid. What! know ye not that he which is joined to an harlot is one body: for two (saith he) shall be one flesh: but he that is joined to the Lord is one spirit. Flee fornication: every sin that a man doth is without the body: but he that committeth fornication sinneth against his own body. What! know ye not that your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost which is in you?" (1 Cor 6:9–10 and 6:15–19)
(Note that Paul does not address these last words to fornicators themselves, for their bodies are not temples of the Holy Ghost; he addresses them to those who in those times were being tempted by filthy heretics to regard fornication as no great sin.)
"But fornication, and all uncleanness, and covetousness, let it not be once named among you, as becometh saints: neither filthiness, nor foolish talking, nor jesting. For this ye know, that no whoremonger, nor unclean person, nor covetous man who is an idolater, hath any inheritance in the kingdom of God. Let no man deceive you with vain words; for because of these things cometh the wrath of God upon the children of disobedience: be not ye therefore partakers with them." (Eph 5:3–6)
"Now the works of the flesh are manifest, which are adultery, fornication, uncleanness, lasciviousness, … of the which I tell you before, as I have also told you in time past, that they which do such things shall not inherit the kingdom of God." (Gal 5:19)
"For this is the will of God, even your sanctification, that ye should abstain from fornication: that every one of you should know how to possess his vessel in sanctification and honour, not in the lust of concupiscence, as the Gentiles which know not God." (1 Thess 4:3) See also (Col 3:5–6).
"Marriage is honourable, and the bed undefiled: but whoremongers and adulterers God will judge." (Heb 13:4)
"The abominable, and whoremongers, shall have their part in the lake which burneth with fire and brimstone." (Rev 21:8)
"For without are dogs, and sorcerers, and whoremongers, and murderers." (Rev 22:15)
"Even as Sodom and Gomorrah and the cities about them in like manner, giving themselves over to fornication, and going after strange flesh, are set for an example, suffering the vengeance of eternal fire." (Jude 7)
I will add no more, lest I become tedious.
2. Beyond Scripture, God has planted in human nature a special sense of shame and modesty to restrain this sin. Those who commit it violate the law of nature and sin against a witness and accuser that dwells within them. Scarcely any of them ever commits it boldly, calmly, and without fear until they have first hardened their hearts, seared their consciences, and overcome the light of nature by frequent and willful sinning.
Nature covers the obscene parts of the body and teaches human beings to blush at any mention of what exceeds the bounds of modesty. Do not say this is mere custom. Human nature, corrupted as it is, is not so fastidious, nor is the villainy of the world so rare and restrained, that it would not long since have swept away every restraint on this sin above most others, if it could have done so, and if God had not inscribed the law condemning it very deeply in nature, in characters that are nearly indelible. So it is that despite the horrid wickedness of the earth, and though mankind is almost universally inclined to lust, there are nevertheless universal laws and customs restraining it. Except among a very few savages and cannibals living like beasts, there is no nation on earth where filthiness is not a shame and modesty does not lay some rebuke upon uncleanness.
You need look no further for a law against this sin; your own nature is a law against it. The better a person is, the more he abhors the lusts of uncleanness. So it is that among saints, as the apostle says, it is "not to be named," that is, not without need and detestation, "for it is a shame even to speak of those things that are done of them in secret." And when drunkenness had uncovered the shame of Noah, his son Ham was cursed for gazing upon it, while the other sons were blessed for their modest and reverent covering of him.
Boniface (also known as Winfrid) wrote of Ethelbald, the fornicating English Mercian king, that the English were a disgrace both to Christians and heathens, who said that the English nation, rejecting the customs of other peoples, was wallowing in lust and adultery in the manner of neighing horses and braying asses, foully corrupting and confounding everything (Epistle of Boniface 10, to Perefrid). Salvagus, Bishop of Sarzana, having been sent by Pope Paul V to visit the churches of Styria, Carinthia, and Carniola, found on completing his visitation that out of all the priests in those three provinces only six were free from concubinage, even though a great part of them had come out of Jesuit training (Giraldi, Apology for the Venetian Senate, page 165). Roman law under the Twelve Tables required that an adulterer caught in the act be put to death.
3. That God has not written this law into human nature without very great cause is evident, though our implicit trust in and submission to him should satisfy us even if we did not know the particular reasons. Much of the cause, however, is plain to common observation. Had God not restrained lust by laws, lust would have made the female sex the most contemptible and miserable of creatures, treated worse than dogs.
First, rape and violence would deflower them, since they are too weak to resist. And even if that were restrained, men’s lust would remain unsatisfied; most men would grow weary of the same woman they had abused and take another. At the very least, when a woman grew old they would choose a younger one, and so aged women would be the most wretched creatures on earth. Beyond this, lust craves variety and grows weary of the same object; quarrels between men and women, illness that makes them less pleasing, age, and other misfortunes would expose women almost universally to utter misery. Men would be the lawmakers, and so they would make no laws for women’s relief beyond what served their own lusts and ends. Half the world would have been ruined had it not been for the laws of matrimony and such other laws as restrain men’s lusts.
4. There would also be a confused mixture in procreation, and no man would rightly know which children were his own, which is worse than not knowing which lands or houses belong to him.
5. Natural affection would accordingly be diminished or extinguished: not only the love of husband and wife, but the love between fathers and children would be undermined.
6. The proper education of children would consequently be hindered or utterly overthrown. The mothers who should first care for them would be disabled and turned away so that fresh harlots could be received, women who would hate the offspring of their predecessors. In this way the world, all societies, and all civil order would be ruined, and men would be made worse than brutes, whom nature has either instructed better or else supplied otherwise.
Learning, religion, and civility would be virtually extinguished, as we observe they are among those few savage cannibals living under no restraint, for how much all these depend upon education, experience shows plainly. In short, this confusion in procreation would produce such confusion in men’s hearts, families, and all societies, by corrupting and destroying the natural affections and the education that depends on them, that it would be the greatest plague imaginable to mankind and would make the world so base and beastly that the destruction of the human race from the earth would seem far more desirable. Judge, then, whether God should have left men’s lusts unrestrained.
Objection: But (you will say) there might have been some moderate restraint to a certain number, as it is with the Mahometans, without so much strictness as Christ requires.
Answer: That this strictness is necessary and is an excellence in God’s law appears from the following reasons.
1.) The greatness of the harm that would otherwise follow. To be remiss in preventing such confusion in the world would be to act as an enemy to it.
2.) Human nature is so violently inclined to break over every boundary that if the hedge were not tight, there would be no sufficient restraint; people would quickly push through any small gap.
3.) The wiser and better any nation or persons are, even among the heathens, the more fully they agree with the strictness of God’s laws.
4.) Even the cleanest sort of brutes are taught by nature to be equally strict in their mating. Though it is otherwise with purely land-dwelling beasts and birds, the aerial creatures go in pairs. Those called the fowls of the heavens, that fly in the air, are commonly taught this chastity by nature, as if God would not allow lust to come near heaven.
5.) The families of the Mahometans who have more than one wife display the harm of it in the effects: in the hatred and disagreement among those wives, and in the great slavery women are kept in, made like slaves so that they may be kept quiet. When women are thus enslaved, women who have so great a part in the education of children, through which all virtue and civility are maintained in the world, this cannot but tend to the debasing and brutalizing of mankind.
7. Children are the most precious of all our treasure, and so the strictest laws are necessary to secure their good education and welfare. If it is treason to debase or counterfeit the king’s coin, and if men are hanged for robbing you of your goods or money, and the laws securing your estates are not thought too strict, then how much more is it necessary that the laws be strict against the corrupting of mankind, against the debasement of your own image in your children, and against everything that tends to the extirpation of all virtue and the ruin of all societies and souls.
8. God wills that there be a holy seed in the world to bear his image of holiness, and for this purpose he wills that all the means be fitted to that end. Brutish, promiscuous generation tends to produce a brutish offspring. And though the word preached is the means of sanctifying those who remain unsanctified from their youth, yet holy marriage, holy dedication of children to God, and holy education of them are the prior means, which God would not have neglected or corrupted, and to which he promises his blessing. This is shown in 1 Corinthians 7:14 and Malachi 2:15: "Did not he make one? Yet had he the residue of the Spirit. And wherefore one? That he might seek a godly seed. Therefore take heed to your spirit, and let none deal treacherously against the wife of his youth: for the LORD hateth putting away."
9. Moreover, lust corrupts the mind of the person himself, if it is not very greatly restrained and moderated. It turns the mind away from the only truly excellent pleasure by the force of its brutish kind of pleasure. It carries away the thoughts, disorders the passions, and corrupts the imagination, and thereby easily corrupts the intellect and heart. Pleasure is so much the proper end of humanity, which by nature we desire, that the chief thing in the world that makes a person good and happy is to engage the heart in pleasures that are genuinely good and make people happy. And the chief thing that makes a person bad and miserable is to engage them in pleasures that make people bad and end in misery.
The principal way to know yourself or others, what you truly are, is to know what your pleasures are, or at least what you choose and desire for pleasure. If the body rules the soul, you are brutish and will be destroyed. If the soul rules the body, you live according to true human nature and the purpose of your creation. If bodily pleasures are your predominant pleasures, to which you are most addicted, then the body rules the soul and you will perish as traitors to God who debase his image and turn man into a beast (Rom 8:13).
Solomon’s wives turned away his heart after other gods (1 Kgs 11:4). The wisdom of Solomon could not protect him from the power of lust and the deceit of women (1 Pet 2:10).
If the pleasures of the soul are your most predominant pleasures, to which you are most addicted, even if you attain as yet but little of them, then the soul rules the body and you live as true human beings. This cannot come about until faith shows the soul those higher pleasures in God and everlasting glory, which lift it above all fleshly pleasures.
From all this taken together, you can easily see that the devil’s way to corrupt and damn people is to keep them from faith, so that they have no heavenly, spiritual pleasure, and to strengthen sensuality and give them their fill of fleshly pleasures, imprisoning their minds so that they can rise no higher. And the way to sanctify and save people is to help them by faith to heavenly pleasure, and to check and keep under that fleshly pleasure that would drag their minds down. By this you can understand what the doctrine of mortification, taming the body, and abstaining from the pleasures of the flesh means, and you can now see what personal harm lust does to the soul.
10. Your own experience and conscience will tell you that if lust is not very greatly moderated, it unfits you for every holy duty. You become unfit to meditate on God, to pray to him, or to receive his word or sacrament. This is why nature teaches those who handle holy things to be more continent than others, which Scripture also confirms (1 Sam 21:4–5). Such sensual things and sacred things do not sit well together in close proximity.
11. From all this you see sufficient cause why God should make stricter laws to bridle lust than fleshly, lustful persons would prefer. And when those laws are broken by the unclean, it is a sin that conscience, until it is thoroughly debauched, deeply accuses the guilty of, and bears a very clear testimony against. Consider the unrest, the horror, the despair that I have known many persons to experience even for the sin of self-pollution, who never proceeded to fornication! And how many adulterers and fornicators have we known who lived and died in despair, and some of whom hanged themselves! Conscience will condemn this sin with a heavy condemnation, until custom or unbelief have utterly seared it. As Chrysostom says: the adulterer, even before damnation, is already most miserable.
12. It is also very noteworthy that once men have mastered conscience on this point and reconciled it to the sin of fornication, it is a hundred to one that they are utterly hardened in all abomination and barely make conscience of any other villainy whatsoever; these are the "hurtful lusts which drown men in destruction and perdition" (1 Tim 6:9). If fornication once counts for nothing, or next to nothing, with them, then usually all other sin is reckoned the same: given an equal temptation, lying, swearing, perjury, and theft, yes, and murder and treason, would seem small too. I have never known any such person who was not willing and ready for any villainy the devil set him upon. If I know such a man, I would no more trust him than I would trust a man who lacks nothing but opportunity and motive to commit any heinous sin you can name.
I confess I have known some of the former sort, those who committed this sin under horror and despair, who retained some good in other respects and were recovered. But of this latter sort, those who have reconciled their consciences to fornication, I have never known one who was recovered, or who retained anything of conscience or honesty, beyond as much outward show of it as their pride and worldly interest required of them. They were malignant enemies of goodness in others, and lived according to the unclean spirit that possessed them. Thales, when an adulterer asked him whether he should make a vow against his sin, answered: "Adultery is as bad as perjury: if you dare be an adulterer, you dare forswear yourself" (Diogenes Laertius, book 1, section 36). Herod dared behead John, having dared to be incestuous.
These are terrible words in Proverbs 2:18–19: "For her house inclineth unto death, and her paths unto the dead: none that go unto her return again, neither take they hold on the paths of life." Old age keeps them from the actual practice of filthiness and lust, and so may hell, for there is no fornication there, but they retain their debauched, seared consciences.
13. This sin is greater because it is never committed alone; the devil takes people in pairs. Lust inflames lust, and fuel gathered together makes the fiercest flame. You are guilty of your wretched companion’s sin as well as your own.
14. Finally, the miserable effects of this sin, and the punishments that have attended it in this life, declare how God regards it. It has ruined persons, families, and kingdoms. God has borne his testimony against it through many signal judgments, which nearly all histories record (Judg 19 and 20). The tribe of Benjamin was nearly cut off on account of an adultery or rape. See also (Num 25:8, Gen 12:17, 2 Sam 12:10, Luke 3:19, 1 Cor 5:1, John 8:2). As there is scarcely any sin that the New Testament condemns more frequently and more severely, as may be seen in Paul’s epistles, in 2 Peter 2, in Jude, and elsewhere, so there are few that God’s providence more frequently pursues with shame and misery on earth.
In latter ages, God added one accompanying plague not known before, commonly called the lues venerea, the venereal disease, so that many of the most brutish offenders go about stamped with a mark of God’s vengeance, a foretaste and warning of a heavier one to come. And none of them all, unless by deep repentance they are made new creatures, leave anything but an infamous name and memory when they die, if their sin was publicly known. However great, gallant, victorious, successful, open-handed, flattered, or applauded they were in life, God so orders things that truth ordinarily prevails with the historians who write of them after their death; and among all sober people their names rot and stink, as their bodies do. "The memory of the just is blessed, but the name of the wicked shall rot."
So much for the greatness of the sin. Boniface, Archbishop of Mainz, writing to Ethilbald, an English king who was a fornicator (Epistle 19), says:
"Fornication is a reproach not only among Christians but among Pagans. For in old Saxony, if a virgin had thus stained her father’s house, or a married woman had broken the marriage covenant by committing adultery, they sometimes force her to hang herself with her own hand, and over her ashes when she is burnt they hang the fornicator.
"Sometimes they gather a band of women, lead her about scourging her with rods, cut off her clothes at the girdle, and with small knives cut and prick all her body, sending her from village to village thus bloody and mangled with small wounds; and so more and more women, stirred by zeal for chastity, meet her and scourge her again, until they leave her either dead or barely alive, that others may fear adultery and licentiousness. And the Wineds, who are the filthiest and worst sort of men, keep the love of matrimony with such great zeal that a wife will refuse to live when her husband dies."
After some rebukes directed at the fornicating king, Boniface adds further accounts:
"Ceolred, your Highness’ predecessor, as those who were present testify, was splendidly banqueting with his earls when the evil spirit that had drawn him to violate God’s law suddenly distracted him in the midst of his sin; so that without repentance or confession, raging mad and talking with the devil and abominating God’s priests, he departed this life, without doubt to the torments of hell.
"And Osred, king of Deira and Bernicia, was carried by a spirit of licentiousness into fornication and the defiling of sacred virgins in the monasteries, until by a vile and shameful death he lost his glorious kingdom together with his youthful and dissolute life. Therefore, my dearest son, take heed of the ditch into which you have seen others fall before you."
How great were the sufferings imposed on priests, monks, and nuns who had committed fornication, several years of imprisonment and scourging, may be seen in the same collection, in an edict of Carloman issued with the advice of a council of bishops.
In Epistle 85, page 87, Boniface writes to Lullo that he was compelled to permit a priest who had long ago committed fornication to officiate, baptize, and pray, because there was no other man to be had in all the country, and he judged it better to risk that one man’s soul than to let all the people perish, and he asks Lullo’s counsel on the matter. All of this shows how heinous the sin of fornication was then judged to be.
Objection: "But," say the filthy ones, "did not David commit adultery? Did not God permit the Jews to have many wives? How many did Solomon have? So this cannot be as great a sin as you claim." Every filthiness will plead for itself for a season.
Answer: David did sin, but does that make the sin any smaller? It is easier to abstain from it than to endure the tears and sorrows David bore for his sin. Beyond the bitterness of his soul, his son Absalom rebelled and drove him from his kingdom, and his own wives were publicly defiled, and yet God left it as a perpetual blot on his name. Solomon’s sin was so great that it nearly ruined both him and his kingdom. Though his experience led him to write against this sin more fully than any other author in the Old Testament, it remains a controversy among divines whether he was ever recovered and saved; and ten of the twelve tribes were for this reason taken from his line and given to Jeroboam. Is this any encouragement to imitate him?
Christ tells you, in the matter of divorce, that God permitted, not approved, but endured, some such sins among the Jews because of the "hardness of their hearts"; but from the beginning it was not so, for one man and one woman were joined in the original institution. The special reason why plurality was tolerated among the Jews was to increase the population of the nation more fully: they were the only people in covenant with God, few in number among surrounding enemies, and separated from the other peoples of the earth; their strength, safety, and glory depended greatly on their increased numbers, and so some degree of irregularity was tolerated for the sake of multiplication, but it was never absolutely approved. Even so, fornication was punished severely, and adultery with death. (Mark 10:5)
II. The Directions against Fornication
Direction 1. If you would avoid uncleanness, avoid the things that dispose you to it: such as gluttony, fullness of diet, pampering the flesh, idleness, and other things treated under the next title, on subduing lust. Reducing the filthy desires is the surest way to prevent the filthy act, and this can be done if you are willing.
Direction 2. Avoid present temptations. Do not go where the snare lies except when necessity requires it. Abhor the devil’s bellows that blow up the fire of lust, such as enticing apparel, filthy talk, and filthy sights, of which more will be said under the next title.
Direction 3. Carefully avoid all opportunity of sinning.
"Come not near the door of her house," says Solomon (Prov 5:8). Avoid the company of the person you are in danger from. Do not go where she is, this you can do if you are willing; no one will force you there. If you go out looking for a thief, no wonder if you are robbed. If you carry fire to put into the thatch, no wonder if your house burns. The devil will play the tempter quite enough without your help. That is his part, leave it to him. Your part is to watch against him; and he will give you work enough. If you watch as narrowly and constantly as you can, you may barely escape. As you love your soul, avoid all opportunities of sinning: make it impossible for yourself. Much of your safety lies precisely here.
Never be alone in private company with someone you are in danger from, be with them either not at all, or only in the sight of others. Especially, do not contrive such opportunities as being together at night, in the dark, or on the Lord’s Day when others are at church, one of the devil’s chosen seasons for such work, or any opportunity that combines leisure and secrecy; for opportunity itself is a powerful temptation. Just as the way to make a thief is to set money in his path, or to trust him so that he can easily rob you without being discovered, so the way to make yourself unclean is to secure an opportunity to sin with little probability of impediment or detection.
The chief point in all watchfulness is to keep far enough away. Touch pitch and you will be defiled. "Whosoever toucheth her shall not be innocent (Prov 6:29)." "Can a man take fire in his bosom, and his clothes not be burnt? Can one go upon hot coals, and his feet not be burnt? So he that goeth in to his neighbour’s wife (Prov 6:27–28)." Do not bring the fire and the gunpowder too close together. If you cannot keep your distance, or cannot refrain from the presence of the bait, you are not likely to refrain from the sin.
Direction 4. Stand in awe of your own conscience. Mark what it says now, for it will shortly speak in a far more terrible manner. Hear it willingly, for it is dreadful to hear it when you can no longer resist. Deal with conscience while there is still time, for you do not know what a fearful tormentor it can become. I have no doubt that it has already given you sharp pangs for your very lust, even before that lust ever came to practice. Yet the sorest of those pangs now are merely like a cat playing with a mouse before delivering the killing bite.
Does no one see you? Conscience sees you. You are a wretch indeed if you do not stand in greater awe of conscience than of any man. As Chrysostom says, suppose no one knows the crime but the man himself and the woman with whom he committed it, how will he bear the rebukes of conscience, when he carries about with him so sharp and bitter an accuser? No man can outrun himself, and no man can avoid the sentence of this court within him. It is a tribunal that cannot be corrupted with money or perverted by flattery, for it is divine, placed in the soul by God himself. The less the adulterer feels it now, the more quickly he hastens to the ruin of his soul.
Do you not feel a sentence passed within you? A terrible sentence, declaring the wrath of a revenging God? Bless God that it is not yet an irreversible sentence, but sue out your pardon quickly, before it reaches that point. Do you not feel that you are afraid and ashamed to pray, or to approach God? Much more afraid to think of dying and appearing before him? If your sin makes you want to flee from him now, if only you knew how, can you look him in the face at the last? Can you hope to stand with comfort at his bar? Are you fit to live in heaven with him, when you have made yourself unfit to pray to him?
Even lawful procreation, as I said before, blushes to come too near to holy exercises. So Plutarch asks in his Roman Questions (Question 65) why the bridegroom was to have no light when he first came to bed to his bride, and answers: perhaps this was instituted to show how sinful and damnable all unlawful company of man and woman together is, since even what is lawful and permitted is not without some blemish and note of shame.
Chrysostom makes the same point: "On the day when you have given yourself lawfully to having children, though that is no crime, you dare not pray," and then adds: "If rising from an undefiled bed you are afraid to come to prayer, when you rise from the devil’s bed, why do you dare to call upon the dreadful name of God?" Conscience is a better friend to you than you imagine when it would reclaim you from your sin, and it will be a sharper enemy than you can now imagine if you will not obey it.
Direction 5. Suppose you saw written on the door of the house or chamber where you enter to sin: "Whoremongers and adulterers God will judge" (Heb 13:4). Write that, or similar words, upon your chamber door, or at least upon your heart. Keep your eye upon the terrible threatenings of the dreadful God. Do you dare to sin when vengeance is at your back? Will not the thought of hell-fire quench the fire of lust, or restrain you from your presumptuous sin? Can you not say with Joseph, "How shall I do this great wickedness, and sin against God?" (Gen 39:9)
It is written of a chaste woman that, being tempted by a fornicator, she asked him first to hold his finger in the fire. When he refused, she answered: "Why then should I burn in hell to satisfy you?" So ask yourself: can I more easily overcome the flames of hell than the flames of lust?
Direction 6. Remember that God stands by. If he were not there, you could not be there, for in him you live and move and have your being. He who made the eye must see; and he who made both light and darkness sees as well in the dark as in the light. If you imagine he is absent or ignorant, you do not believe he is God, for an absent and ignorant God is no God at all.
And do you dare, I say, do you dare, to commit such a villainy while God beholds you? The very thing you would be ashamed to have a child witness; the very thing you would not do if a man stood nearby. Do you think your locks and the secrecy of darkness have darkened or shut out God? Do you not know that he sees not only within your curtains, but within your heart? What a hardened heart is yours, that in the sight of God, your maker and your judge, you dare to do such wickedness.
Ask your conscience: would I do this if I were to die tomorrow and go to God? Would I do this if I saw God, or even an angel, in the room? If not, should you do it when God is as surely there as if you saw him? Remember that he is a holy God who hates uncleanness, and that "our God is a consuming fire." (Heb 12:29)
Direction 7. Suppose, throughout the whole act, that you saw the devil opening the door for you, bringing in your companion, driving on the match, and persuading you to the sin. What if he appeared openly to play his part, as surely as he now plays it unseen? Would not your lust be cooled? Would not the very devil cure the disease he has stirred up in you? Why, then, do you obey him now, when he is just as certainly the instigator as if you saw him?
Have you so little reason that seeing and not seeing makes so great a difference to you? If you were blind, would you play the fornicator before a whole company simply because you could not see them, when you know they are there? If you know anything, you know God is there; and you can feel by the temptation itself that Satan is in it. Will you not be ruled by the law unless you see the king? Will you not fear the infection of the plague unless you can see it? Use your reason for your soul as you would use it for your body. Act as you would act if you saw the devil tempting you and Christ forbidding you.
Direction 8. If you are unmarried, marry, if easier remedies will not serve. "It is better to marry than burn." (1 Cor 7:9) Marriage is God’s ordinance, appointed partly for this very end. "Marriage is honourable and the bed undefiled." (Heb 13:4) It is a likeness of Christ’s union with his church, and is sanctified to believers. (Eph 5 1 Cor 7)
Marriage may perhaps bring you great worldly troubles if you are not ready for that state, as is the case with apprentices. In that case, keep clear of your sin by some easier means. But if no easier means will do, the lawful remedy must be used even if it costs you dearly in the world. It is better for your body to be undone than your soul, if it must be one or the other. If you are already married, you are a monster and not a man if this remedy does not prevail with you, though even then the other directions may still serve you.
Direction 9. If lesser means do not prevail, open your case to some able and faithful friend, engage them to watch over you, and tell them when the temptation most endangers you. This will shame you away from the sin and lay further obligations on you to keep away from it. If you tell your friend, "Now I am tempted to this sin, now I am moving toward it," he will quickly stop you. Break your secrecy and you lose your opportunity.
You can do this if you are willing. If your conscience ever prevails so far as to bring you to a resolution against your sin, or even to a willingness to escape it, then act while conscience is awake. Go tell your friend. Tell him who your wicked companion is. Let him know all your haunts, so that he may the better know how to help you.
Do you say this will shame you? It will shame you before the one who comes to know it, but that is precisely the benefit of it, and the reason I advise it. Shame can help to save your soul. If you go on, the sin will both shame and damn you; and a shame greater than this is a gentle remedy for so foul and dangerous a disease.
Direction 10. If all this still will not serve, tell it to many, tell it to the whole town if need be, rather than go uncured. The public shame will then do far more. Confess it to your pastor, and ask him openly to seek the prayers of the congregation for your pardon and recovery. Begin thus to seek the benefit of church discipline yourself; so far should you be from fleeing it and spurning it, as the desperate and hardened do.
If you say this is a hard lesson, remember that the suffering of hell is harder. Do not say that I wrong you by putting you upon scandal and open shame. It is you who have put yourself upon it, by making it necessary and refusing all easier remedies. I put you on it only on the supposition that you will not be cured more easily, much as Christ speaks of "cutting off a right hand" or "plucking out a right eye, lest all the body be cast into hell." That is not the first remedy he commands; he would have you avoid the need of it. But he tells you it is better to do so than worse, and that this suffering is easy in comparison to hell.
So I advise you likewise: if you love your good name, keep clear of your sin by a cheaper means. But if you will not, then take this way rather than damn your soul. If the shame of the whole town were upon you, and boys hooted after you in the streets, if that would drive you from your sin, how easy a suffering would it be compared to what awaits you otherwise? Concealment is Satan’s great advantage. It would be far harder for you to persist in this sin if only it were brought to light.
Title 2. Directions against Inward, Filthy Lusts
Direction 1. Because for most people the body’s constitution plays a large part in this sin, your first care must be about the body, to bring it into a temper less inclined to lust. The chief remedy here is fasting and much abstinence. This is the more bearable because it is generally people strong enough to endure it who face this temptation. If your temptation is not strong, less abstinence from food and drink may suffice, for I would prescribe no stronger medicine than the disease requires. But if the temptation is violent and lesser means will not prevail, it is better that your body be somewhat weakened than that your soul be corrupted and ruined. In that case, observe the following:
1.) Eat no breakfasts or suppers; take one meal a day, with no more than a bite or two of bread and a sip or two of water in the morning, and even then not too full a dinner, and nothing at night.
2.) Drink no wine or strong drink, but water if the stomach can bear it without sickness, and in some constitutions that run hot, water is actually healthier than beer.
3.) Eat no hot spices, or strong, heating, or wind-producing foods; eat lettuce and other cooling herbs.
4.) If necessary, be bled often, or take purges that copiously evacuate fluid rather than merely irritating the body.
5.) Bathe often in cold water. But consult a physician so that all of this is done safely.
If you think this course too costly a cure and would rather coddle your flesh and your lust, then you are not the persons I am directing here; I speak only to those who are willing to be cured and to use the necessary means. If you have not reached that point, your conscience needs a far sharper awakening. Christ himself says that when the bridegroom was taken from his disciples they would "fast" (Mark 2:19–20). Even the tireless Paul was "in fasting often" (2 Cor 6:5 2 Cor 11:27), and "kept under his body and brought it into subjection, lest by any means when he had preached to others, himself should be a castaway" (1 Cor 9:27). The ancient Christians who lived in solitude and ate nothing but bread and water, or fare meaner than bread, did not think this cure too costly. Even smaller necessities than this led them into "fasting" (1 Cor 7:5). This unclean devil will scarcely be cast out except by "prayer and fasting" (Mark 9:29).
You must understand that fullness naturally feeds lust as fuel feeds fire. Fullness of bread prepared the Sodomites for their filthy lusts. It is no more surprising that a stiff paunch has a lustful fury than that water flows into pipes when the cistern is full; it is no more strange than seeing a dunghill bear weeds or a carcass swarm with maggots.
Plutarch tells of a Spartan who, when asked why Lycurgus made no law against adultery, answered, "There are no adulterers among us." "But what if there were?" said the other. "Then he must pay an ox large enough to stand on this side of the river Taygetus and drink from the river Eurotas," said the Spartan. "That is impossible," said the other. The Spartan’s reply was: "And how can there be an adulterer at Sparta, where riches, delights, and foreign adornment are a disgrace, and where modesty, self-restraint, and due obedience to magistrates are honoured and praised?"
If wealthy men count it their privilege to feast freely and satisfy their appetites, they must count it their privilege also to feed their lust. But God gives no one abundance for such purposes. A man’s having much is no more an excuse for eating and drinking heavily than it would be an excuse for his cook to put far more salt into his meat than into a poor man’s, simply because more salt was available, as Zeno’s comparison in Diogenes Laërtius illustrates (Lives, Book 6).
Whoever sees the filthy and ruinous effects of that gluttony which wealthy men count their honor and happiness will never envy them that miserable felicity. He will say rather as Antisthenes said, "Let it befall the children of my enemies to live in delights," though that curse is too heavy for a Christian to lay on any enemy.
For himself, the Christian must remember that he is the servant of a holy God, has holy work to do, and holy sacrifices to offer, and therefore must not pamper his flesh as though he were fattening a sacrifice for Venus. As 1 Thessalonians 4:3–4 says: "This is the will of God, even your sanctification, that you abstain from fornication, that every one of you should know how to possess his vessel in sanctification and honour, not in the lust of concupiscence as the Gentiles that know not God."
When Antigonus asked a philosopher whether he should go to a merry feast to which he had been invited, the philosopher answered, "You are the son of a king." That answer is sufficient. So against every temptation to self-indulgence, it is answer enough for a Christian to say: "I am the son of the most holy God." If you are invited to feasts where pressure or allurement is likely to make you exceed your bounds, do not go, or leave when you see the bait being laid. Epaminondas, finding excess at a feast he had attended, left when he saw it, saying, "I thought you were sacrificing, not reveling." Say likewise: "I came to dine, not to be wanton or self-indulgent, to support my body for duty, not to pamper it for lust."
Plutarch marvels at the folly of those who dread the charms of witches lest they be harmed, yet do not fear but love the charms of rich dishes, which harm a thousand where witches harm one. Withdraw the fuel of excess, and the fire of lust will go out of itself, or at least this enemy must be besieged and starved out when it cannot be conquered by storm.
Direction 2. Guard against idleness, and be wholly taken up in the diligent work of your lawful calling when you are not engaged in the more immediate service of God. David in his idleness caught those sparks of lust from which his troubled military life had kept him safe. Idleness is the soil, the cultivation, and the opportunity of lust. The idle person goes to school with the devil, setting aside every other employment so that the devil has time to instruct him, negotiate with him, and solicit him to evil. Why be surprised that such a person dwells on lustful objects, or that he gives himself to feasting and drinking, to chambering and wantonness? He has nothing else to do.
The laborious, diligent person, by contrast, has a body that is subdued and hardened against effeminate softness, and a mind that is occupied with better things. Leave your body and mind no leisure to dwell on tempting, filthy objects or to go looking for them. As Ovid writes, "Take away idleness, and Cupid’s bow is broken," and again, "Love reigns in an empty heart"; and Diogenes called love "the business of the idle."
Jerome says: "Be always doing some work, so that the devil may always find you busy." Do not for the ease of your flesh relax your labors and indulge it. Rise early, go late to bed, and put yourself under a necessity of diligence throughout the day. Take on and commit to as much business as you are able to carry through, so that even if you wished to indulge the flesh you would not be able to. For if you are not kept under the press of necessity, lust will use idleness in its service, and the flesh will lie down the moment it feels no spur. This is why the rich and idle are more lustful and corrupt than the poor laboring people. The same bed that invites sloth invites lust.
Listen to a heathen and do not refuse to imitate him. Seneca says: "No day passes me in idleness. Part of the night I reserve for study. I do not purposely set myself to sleep, but yield to it when it overcomes me; and when my eyes are wearied with watching and are falling shut, I hold them to their work. I had rather it went ill with me than delicately or tenderly. If you are delicate or tender, the mind little by little becomes effeminate and dissolves into the likeness of the idleness and sloth in which it lies. I sleep very little and take only a short nap; it is enough for me to have ceased from waking. Sometimes I know that I slept; sometimes I merely suspect it."
Aristotle says, "Nature made nothing to be idle." Plato calls idleness "the plague of mortals."
If you are resolved to serve and please your flesh, then do not ask advice against your lust, for self-indulgence is part of the pleasure, and no wonder if you refuse this medicine as too bitter and the remedy as too costly. But if you are resolved to be cured and to be saved, do not shrink from the effort: give yourself wholly to your business, and lust will die for want of food.
Direction 3. If you would be free from lust, keep far enough from the tempting object. If possible, do not live in the same house with any person by whom you feel yourself endangered. If that is not possible, avoid their company, especially in private. Abhor all lascivious and immodest actions. Do you allow yourself the liberty of wanton dalliance and lustful embracements, and yet expect to be free from lust? Will you thrust your hand into the fire when you are afraid of being burned?
Either you have power over your own heart, or you do not. If you do, why do you not quench your lust? If you do not, why do you cast it upon greater temptations, and place it further beyond your control? Flee from a tempting object for your safety as you would flee from an enemy for your life. These loving enemies are more dangerous than hating ones: they get hold of the key to our hearts and come in and steal our treasure with our consent, or at least without resistance, whereas an open enemy is suspected and shut out.
Direction 4. Command your eyes, and as Job did, make a covenant with them, so that you may not dwell on tempting objects (Job 31:1). Shut these windows and you preserve your heart. Do not gaze upon any alluring object. A look has kindled the fire of lust in many a heart, and that fire has ended in the fire of hell. It is easier to stop lust at these outward doors than to drive it out once it has infected the heart. If you cannot manage even this, how can you manage anything more? An ungoverned eye fetches fire to burn the very soul that should have governed it.
Plutarch, in his work On Curiosity, praises Cyrus for refusing to look upon Panthea, and he rebukes those who cast a wanton eye at women passing by in coaches, who look out of windows to get a full view of them, and yet think they are committing no fault, letting a curious eye and a wandering mind slide and run wherever they will.
Direction 5. Do not linger in the pleasant snares of lust when you feel even the least beginnings of it; quickly throw water on the first discerned spark before it breaks into a flame. Ovid, the amorous poet, in his Remedies of Love teaches this same lesson, and if delay is ever dangerous, it is here. He writes: "While it is permitted and only mild stirrings touch the heart, if you repent, halt your foot at the first threshold. Crush the seeds of sudden disease while they are new, and let your horse, just beginning to run, be reined in; for delay gives strength. While love is new, let us rather fight against it at the start: a fresh flame is put out by a little scattered water. But in the meantime the silent flame creeps through the inward parts, and a poisonous tree drives its roots deeper."
Delay will produce such entanglements with sin that you will get free only at a far dearer cost. If food is indigestible, it is best not to look at it; the next best is not to touch or taste it; but once it has gone down, it will cost you sickness and pain to bring it up again, and if you do not, it will destroy you.
Direction 6. Abhor lascivious and immodest speech. Such words come from either vain or filthy hearts and betray the absence of the fear of God; and they tend to make the hearer like the speaker. If your ears grow merely patient and tolerant of such talk, you have already lost much of your innocence. Christians must abhor any mention of such filthy sins except in a manner that leads hearers to abhor them.
Do not be deceived: "evil words corrupt good manners" (1 Cor 15:33). "Let no corrupt communication proceed out of your mouth, but that which is good to the use of edifying, that it may minister grace to the hearers, and grieve not the Holy Spirit of God." Corrupt communication is rotten, stinking communication, and none but dogs and crows love carrion. But "fornication, and all uncleanness, and inordinate lust or luxury, let it not once be named among you, as becometh saints; neither filthiness, nor foolish talking, nor jesting," and so on.
Direction 7. Abhor the practice of covering filthy lust with handsome names to make it more acceptable. The discourse of those who dress up an ugly lust in fine language is more dangerous than that of those who speak of it in nasty language. Among the brutish party, lust goes by the names of love, having a mistress, courting, and the like. But as one writer quoted in Stobæus said, lust commonly called love is already doubled, and doubled love is stark madness. If filthiness will walk abroad, let it go as filthiness and appear for what it is.
Direction 8. Avoid reading romances and love stories. These are the library of Venus, or the devil’s books of the lustful art, designed to cover filthiness with clean names, bewitch the fantasies of fools with fine words, and lead men to conceive of the ready road to hell under the images of excellence, beauty, love, and gallantry. By representing strong and amorous passions, they stir up the same passions in the reader.
Just as one who insists on reading a conjuring-book is well enough served if devils come about his ears, so with those who insist on reading such romances and other books of the burning art: God may justly allow an unclean devil to possess them, and let them catch the fever of lust, which may not only burn up the heart but produce that ruinous delirium in the brain that is its ordinary symptom.
Direction 9. Avoid all wanton stage-plays and dancings, which either conceal the ugliness of lust or produce temptations to it. (See Petrarch, On Spectacles, Dialogue 30.) As God has his preachers, holy assemblies, and exercises for the communion of saints and the stirring up of love and holiness, so these are Satan’s instruments, assemblies, and exercises for the communion of sinners and the stirring up of lust and filthiness. Those who willingly go to the devil’s church deserve to be filled with his principles and numbered among his disciples. The early Christians were very strict against attending these spectacles, shows and plays, especially for anyone in the clergy.
Direction 10. Avoid all tempting, unnecessary ornaments or attire, and avoid regarding or gazing upon them on others. It is a forward, impudent, lustful desire to appear comely and attractive that is the common cause of this excess. The folly, or lust, or both, of fashionists and gaudy gallants is so visible to everyone in their affected dress that pride never more thoroughly defeats itself than in such public displays of disgraceful folly or lust. Lysander forbade his daughters to wear the showy attire that Dionysius sent them, lest, as he put it, "being conspicuous in luxury, they should appear the more deformed."
Those who profess to be enemies of lust, yet take care whenever they appear in public to present themselves in the most adorned manner, doing everything a harlot can do to make themselves a snare to fools, put even charitable observers to the hard question of whether it is their tongues or their backs that are the liar. As Jerome says: "You deserve hell, even if no one is the worse for you; for you brought the poison, even if there had been no one to drink it."
Let your apparel be suited not only to your rank but to your disease. If you are inclined to lust, dress more plainly yourself, and do not gaze upon the ornaments of others. It is foolishness indeed to be enamored of a tailor’s work, yet it is so common that it is frequently the clothing rather than the person that first attracts, and plain garments would have prevented the deceit. As Ovid writes in his Remedies of Love: "We are carried away by adornment; gems and gold cover everything; the woman herself is the smallest part of herself."
Direction 11. Think of your tempting object as it is within, and as it will shortly appear without. How common it is for what is called beauty to be the portion of a fool, for a fair skin to cover a silly, childish, peevish mind, and a soul enslaved to the devil. As Solomon says, "As a jewel of gold in a swine’s snout, so is a fair woman without discretion" (Prov 11:22). And will you lust after such an adorned thing?
Think also what a dunghill of filth is covered by those ornaments, filth that would turn your stomach if you could see within. Think what that face would look like covered with pox, and what it will look like when sickness or age has consumed or wrinkled it. Think what that admired carcass will be after a few days in the grave; you would have little desire for it then. And how quickly that time will come.
There is nothing truly lovable in the creature but the image of God: the wisdom, holiness, and righteousness of the soul. Love that, then, if you would love with wisdom, purity, and safety; for the love of purity is itself pure and safe.
Direction 12. Think about your own death, and how quickly you are hastening to another world. Is a lustful heart a fitting state for one who is about to die, to stand before God, and to enter that world where nothing but what is pure and holy has any place?
Direction 13. Consider carefully the tendency and fruits of lust, so that it may always appear in your mind as ugly and terrible as it truly is.
1.) Think what a shame it is to the soul that it cannot better govern the body, and that it is so defiled by its own lusts.
2.) Think what an unfit companion lust is to lodge in the same heart with Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit. Shall a member of Christ be so polluted? Shall the temple of the Holy Ghost be turned into a swine-sty? Is lust fit to dwell alongside the love of God? Will you entertain your Lord with such odious company? What an unkindness and injury this is to God, that when he who dwells in the highest heavens condescends to take up a dwelling in your heart, you should bring these toads and snakes into the same room with him. Take heed, lest he take it unkindly and depart. He has said he will dwell with the humble and contrite heart; but where has he said, "I will dwell in a lustful heart"?
3.) Think how lust makes you unfit for prayer or any holy approach to God, and what shame, fear, and deadness it casts upon your spirit.
4.) Think also how lust tends toward worse things. Lust leads toward actual filthiness, and that toward hell. Do not cherish the eggs if you want none of the brood. It is an easy step from a lustful heart to a defiled body, and a shorter step from there to everlasting horror than you imagine. As James says, "Every man is tempted when he is drawn aside of his own lust and enticed; then when lust hath conceived, it bringeth forth sin, and sin when it is finished bringeth forth death" (Jas 1:14–15). "If ye sow to the flesh, of the flesh ye shall reap corruption" (Gal 6:8). Remember that lust is the spawn of sin, and sin is the road to hell.
Direction 14. Be sure to keep up a holy, constant government over your thoughts. Do not let them go after tempting, filthy, or sensual things. As soon as a thought of lust enters your mind, abhor it and cast it out. A great part of both your cure and your safety depends on governing your thoughts. Those who let their thoughts run without restraint and feed on filthiness are already fornicators in the heart; they are hatching the cockatrice eggs. No wonder that from thoughts they proceed to deeds.
Consider how much uncleanness is committed in thought alone, uncleanness people are little ashamed of because it is unseen by others. If the thoughts of many were laid open, what wantonness and lust would appear in those adorned sepulchres, even in the time of holy worship. Once the unclean spirit takes possession of such thoughts, how hard it is to cast him out; such a person can scarcely look a comely person in the face without some vicious thought.
If Jerome confessed that even in his wilderness his thoughts were wandering among the ladies of Rome, what should we think of those who deliberately feed such filthy fantasies? Do not say you cannot rule your thoughts. You can do much if you will, and more than you do. If money and honor can make an ungodly preacher command his thoughts to holy things through years of studying divinity, you can see that your thoughts are far more within your power than you claim. But I have spoken of this before.
Direction 15. If other means do not serve, open your case to some friend, and shame yourself before him, as I advised under the previous title. Confession, shame, and counsel will all help.
Direction 16. Above all, go to Christ for help, beg for his Spirit, and surrender your heart to better things. If your heart were truly taken up with God, with heaven, and with the holy life that leads there, things so great, so holy, so sweet, and of such vital concern to you, they would leave little room for lust within you, and would make you abhor it as contrary to everything that holds your heart. There is no cure for carnal love like the love of God, and no cure for fleshly lusts like a spiritual, renewed, and heavenly mind. You would then tell Satan that God has taken up all the room, and that your narrow heart is too small even for him alone, so that there is no room left for lust or the thoughts that serve it.
A true conversion that turns the heart to God does turn it from this and other sins, though some sparks may remain unextinguished. It was once observed that many people turned from other sects to the Epicureans, but none ever turned from the Epicureans to any other sect. The reason was that human nature is inclined toward sensuality in all people, and when that inclination is confirmed by habit and teaching, philosophy is too weak to master it. But Christ calls and saves epicures, and publicans, and harlots, and has cleansed many such by his grace, grace that teaches men to "deny ungodliness and worldly lusts, and to live soberly, righteously, and godly in the world."
Philostratus tells of a sudden change in one Isaeus, who turned from luxury to extraordinary temperance, so that when someone asked him, "Is that not a handsome woman?" he answered, "My eyes’ diseases are cured." When asked which dish was most pleasing, he said, "I have done regarding such things." And when they marveled at his change, he told them the reason: he had found that he was only gathering fruit from the garden of Tantalus. They are "deceitful lusts" (Eph 4:22), and Satan himself will mock you forever if he can deceive you by them. As Alexander, having taken Darius with all his gallantry, his sumptuous houses and furniture, reproached him with the words, "Was this to rule?", so Satan would one day show you your lusts and say, "Was this to be a Christian and seek salvation?"
CHAPTER 24
DIRECTIONS AGAINST SINFUL EXCESS OF SLEEP AND SINFUL DREAMS
Part VI. Directions against Sinful Excess of Sleep
Of this subject, something has already been said in Chapter V, Part 1, and more will follow in the Directions against Idleness. I will therefore say little here. 1. I will show when sleep is excessive. 2. I will explain what makes it sinful. 3. I will say what to do to cure it.
First. Sleep is given to us for the necessary rest of our animal functions and of the labor or motion of the outward parts, by quieting the senses and shutting them down, so that the natural and vital operations may be less disturbed. Sleep is necessary: 1. for rest, and 2. for digestion. Weariness and poor digestion are therefore the chief indicators of how much sleep we need.
Sleep is sinfully excessive: 1. when it is voluntarily more than our health requires, and 2. when it is untimely, taken at forbidden hours.
Not every feeling of weariness or sleepiness makes sleep lawful or necessary. Some weariness is produced by laziness, some by disease, and some by chronic causes that keep a person almost always tired. Nor is poor digestion always cured by sleep: sometimes it results from overeating and must be remedied another way, and many diseases cause it that require other treatment. No one should indulge in excess on these pretexts.
Nor should a present pleasure in sleeping, or reluctance to wake, be the judge of what is needed. Sluggards may believe that extra sleep does them good and that early rising harms them, but the good is nothing more than present ease, and the harm is nothing more than a brief trouble to the head, eyes, and lazy flesh at the moment of rising. Reason and experience must determine what measure of sleep best serves your health, and that measure must not be exceeded. For some, five hours is enough; for ordinary healthy persons, six hours is enough; for many weak or sickly persons, seven hours may be needed. For the sick, I do not here prescribe directions.
2. Sleep is also excessive at a particular time when it is ill-timed. This happens in two ways:
1.) When some necessary business demands immediate action and we are asleep.
2.) When we should be hearing a sermon or praying, whether in public or private, and we are asleep instead.
In short, sleep is ill-timed whenever it displaces a greater duty we ought then to perform. So it was when the disciples slept while Christ was in his agony: "Could ye not watch with me one hour? watch and pray that ye enter not into temptation." (Matt 26:40–41)
It is foolishness and an abuse of God and ourselves to imagine that broken sleep pleases God in itself, or that rising at midnight to pray is more acceptable to him than praying at another hour. Such midnight rising is ordinarily sinful for these reasons:
1. Because it rests on the mistaken belief that God accepts it better than daytime prayer.
2. Because time is wasted in dressing and undressing.
3. Because cold in winter harms the health, so that more time is lost by shortening one’s life than is gained by the extra hour of prayer.
4. And because one is ordinarily more drowsy and less fit for prayer at that hour.
It is appropriate to rise in the night for prayer on some extraordinary occasion, such as to pray with or for a dying person, or when an unusual fervor and fitness prepares the soul for it, and when one can remain awake and does not lose time returning to bed. But ordinarily the best way is the one that most redeems time: determine exactly how much sleep your health requires, take it without interruption if possible, then rise and go about your duties. Those who cannot sleep at night must redeem that time as good judgment directs.
The sinfulness of excessive sleep lies chiefly in its voluntariness: the more voluntary, the more sinful. In a lethargy or stupor it is no sin at all; and when prolonged wakefulness, bodily weakness, or disorder makes it nearly unavoidable, the sin is smaller. For that reason, when his disciples were overcome with drowsiness after long watching, Christ partly excused them, saying, "The spirit is willing, but the flesh is weak" (Matt 26:41).
But when excessive sleep arises from flesh-pleasing sloth, or from indifference to whatever holy exercise is at hand, it is a serious sin. And even if you are not conscious of choosing to sleep at that very moment, even if you say, "I would gladly stay awake if I could," if the excess is voluntary in its causes, the sin is still yours. You would now stay awake, but you would not give up the pampering and overfeeding of the body that caused the drowsiness; you would not deny the flesh its ease in order to avoid it.
Second. The sinfulness of excess of sleep consists in these particulars.
1. It is a sinful waste of every minute consumed in it. Bernard observed that no part of our life is so utterly lost as what is assigned to sleep. This is a very serious matter to anyone who feels the preciousness of time. When we consider how short our lives are and how great our work is, we should see how grave a sin it is to throw away any of this little time in needless sleep.
Yet many people spend a great deal of it in just this way. Nearly half their whole lives is spent in bed by many drones who suppose they may sleep as much as they like because they are wealthy and have no pressing material need to rise and labor. I do not recall ever being so nearly tempted to complain at God’s natural ordering of human life as on account of our being required to spend so much of our short time in sleep; nor was I ever so tempted to complain of my own weakness as on this very point, that it robbed me of precious time that might otherwise have been spent in profitable work. The preciousness of time makes excessive sleep a great sin, measured by the degree of the excess.
2. Excessive sleep is a neglect of all our powers and faculties, which ought all that time to be at work. Reason lies idle and buried. All your wisdom and knowledge are of no use to you: as Plato observed, quoted in Diogenes Laertius, a sleeping man is of no account to anyone. All the learning of the greatest scholar counts for no more while he sleeps than if he were illiterate; all the prudence of the wisest man, than if he were a fool. All the strength and health of the strongest serve no better than if he were sick; the skill of the greatest craftsman counts for nothing, as if he had never learned his trade; none of your limbs or senses serve any better than if you were lame, blind, deaf, or senseless.
I leave it to any person’s consideration whether, if drunkenness is so odious a sin because it voluntarily deprives a man of the use of his reason and faculties, it must not also be a great sin to do the same by excessive, voluntary, habitual sleep. No man, I think, is drunk as often as the sluggard is dead in sleep. Sluggards wholly kill their reason, while most drunkards only maim it or make it sick. Sluggards bury their wits and faculties in sleep, commonly ten times as long in a year as the worst drunkards do. Has God given you reason, faculties, and strength only to bury them for so considerable a part of your lives?
3. Excess of sleep is guilty of every omission of duty that should have been performed during that time: every holy thought, word, and deed that should have been exercised; every duty of your calling; every prayer that should have been prayed; every chapter that should have been read; and all the good you should have received yourself or done for others, wife, husband, children, parents, servants, neighbors.
Omissions are one half, and the greater half, of the sins of the world. God will condemn the wicked at last for their omissions: for not feeding the poor, not clothing them, not visiting them. He requires the improvement of every talent he entrusts to us. His terrible sentence is: "Thou wicked and slothful servant, etc. Cast ye the unprofitable servant into outer darkness; there shall be weeping and gnashing of teeth." (Matt 25:26, 30)
What then shall we think of the willful omission, not of one duty but of all duty whatever; not now and then but constantly, for an hour, or two, or three, once in every twenty-four hours? During all that time, no love of God, no desire toward him, no good of any kind is exercised.
Question: Can the love of sleep alone be the mortal, reigning sin in any one? The reason for the doubt is that mortal sin is a sin of mistaken ultimate interest, that is, a sin that holds a person’s highest love and is set above God. Sleep or ease seems too small a thing for that role; it appears to be mere neglect or slackness in duty, not something a person would actually choose as their happiness.
Answer: The sin that stands opposed to the love of God as a person’s ultimate end and happiness is flesh-pleasing in general, or carnal self-love. A person guilty of this can hardly be imagined to exercise sensual desire only through sloth and sleep. Certainly such a person wants the greatest available fleshly pleasure more than the lesser; therefore, in terms of habit or inclination, he is just as much given to covetousness, gluttony, ambition, or other forms of sensuality. If those greater pleasures are within reach, he will actually desire them more than sleep. There is no unregenerate sensualist who has genuinely mortified covetousness, luxury, and pride, and yet remains captivated only by sleep or sloth; the same grace that truly mortifies the greater would also mortify the lesser.
It is possible, however, that a beggar or someone similarly situated, having no other sensual pleasure in view or in hope, may exercise his sensuality chiefly through idleness. Not that he would not rather have riches and honor than his beggarly ease; but those desires have no material to work on, and so they lie dormant because he has no hope of attaining such things.
The summary is this: 1. Carnal self-love is the great opposite of the love of God. 2. This self-love works toward carnal pleasure, and most powerfully toward the greatest pleasures. 3. Habitually, therefore, the love of riches, honor, and voluptuousness is stronger than the love of ease. 4. Actually, the love of ease may be the strongest desire in some persons. 5. But if those persons were equally capable of higher fleshly pleasures, they would actually love those more. 6. What proves a sensual, unsanctified state of soul is not the occasional omission of particular duties through love of ease, but the setting of ease above a holy life in the main, as when people love their ease so much that they will not make it the chief of their desires and employments to "seek the kingdom of God and his righteousness." (Matt 6:33)
Overcoming excessive sleep is easy, if you are thoroughly willing.
Direction 1. The first thing to be done is to correct that sluggish, phlegmatic bodily temperament that inclines you to sleep. This is chiefly accomplished by the kind of abstinence and temperate diet for which directions were given earlier. A full belly is fit for nothing but sleep or lust. Reduce your diet to what is genuinely necessary for your health, and do not eat more simply to please your appetite. When you have eaten too much, let fasting be your remedy.
Direction 2. Work hard in your calling, so that your sleep may be sweet while you are in it, otherwise you will lie in bed on the pretense of necessity, claiming you cannot sleep well when you are there. You will then say you must make up sleep in the morning because you did not sleep at night. But make sure that idleness is not the cause. Tire your bodies in your daily labors: "for the sleep of the labouring man is sweet." (Eccl 5:12)
Direction 3. Make sure you have a calling that will fill all the time that God’s direct service does not require, one that even presses you toward diligence. Otherwise you will lie in bed saying you have time to spare or nothing to do. You can rise when you have a journey ahead of you or a pressing necessity to attend to; keep yourself under some steady pressure of necessary work, at the very least.
Direction 4. Take pleasure in your calling and in the service of God. Even sluggards can rise for what they greatly enjoy, for a merry gathering, a feast, a game, a good bargain, or anything that delights them. If you genuinely delighted in your calling, in reading Scripture, in prayer, and in doing good, you could not lie contentedly in bed, but would long to be up and active, as children long for play. The wicked can rise early to do wickedness, because their hearts are set on it; they can drink, steal, fornicate, or plot their ambitious and covetous schemes when they ought to be sleeping. If your heart were set as much on good as theirs is on evil, would you not be just as wakeful and just as ready to rise?
Direction 5. Remember the great importance of the work of your souls, which always lies before you, and let the weight of that work rouse you. Will you lie idling in bed when you are so far behind in knowledge, grace, and assurance of salvation, when there is so much of Scripture and other books to read and understand? Have you no grace to beg for a needy soul? Is not prayer better work than excess of sleep? Important affairs in the world can make you rise; why should greater ones not do the same?
Direction 6. Remember that you must give an account in judgment for your time. What comfort will it give you to say that you slept away so many morning hours? And what comfort will it bring at death, when time is gone, to look back on so much cast away in sleep?
Direction 7. Remember that God sees you and is calling you to your work. If you understood his Word and his providence rightly, you would hear him saying, as the mariners said to Jonah, "What meanest thou, O sleeper? Arise, call upon thy God." (Jonah 1:6) Will you lie sleeping beyond measure when God stands over you and calls you to rise? If the king, or any great person or friend, were to knock at your door, you would get up at once to receive them. Yet God would speak with you through his Word, or hear you speak to him in prayer, and will you lie still and despise his call?
Direction 8. Remember how many are attending you while you sleep. If it is summer, the sun has risen before you, having traveled thousands of miles while you slept; it has given a day’s light to the other half of the world since you lay down, and has come again to light you to your work. Will you let it shine in vain? All the creatures are ready in their places to serve you, and you are still asleep?
Direction 9. Consider whether you would allow your servants to do the same. They must be up and at work, or you will be displeased and tell them they are no servants for you and that you did not hire them to sleep. Yet do you not owe God more service than they owe you? Did God hire you to sleep? Is it any more lawful for you than for them to sleep one minute beyond what your health requires? Not a minute. If you are more sickly than they, that is another matter, but be sure that overeating and idleness are not the cause. Your wealth is no excuse: will you be more idle than your servants because you receive more? Will you do less service because you receive more pay? Or is it your special privilege to be so wretched as to waste the time that poorer people save?
Direction 10. Remember that your morning hours are the finest part of the entire day for holy exercise or earnest employment of the mind. The mind is fresh and clear, and there is less interruption from worldly business; once others are up and about, interruptions will multiply. Those who have tried it can attest by experience that the morning hours are the best time for prayer and study, and that early rising is a large part of the art of redeeming time.
Direction 11. Remember how many are putting you to shame by their diligence while you are sleeping away your time. How many holy persons are then in secret prayer, wrestling fervently with God for their salvation, or reading and meditating on his Word? What do they gain while you sleep? The blessed man delights in the law of the Lord and meditates on it day and night, while you love your ease and sleep day and night. Will not all these be witnesses against you? So will the diligent in their callings; so will the worldly and the wicked who rise early to pursue their sins. How many thousands are hard at work while you are sleeping? Do you not have work to do as well as they?
Direction 12. Remember that sensuality, the pursuit of fleshly pleasure, is the great condemning sin that turns the heart from God. If it is odious in a drunkard or a fornicator, why is it not equally odious in you? Mortify the flesh, and learn to deny it its disordered desires, and your sin is very nearly cured.
Direction 13. Once you are genuinely willing, the practical part is easy: simply arrange for someone to wake you, and a little cold water will wash away your drowsiness once you have consented to rise.
Part VII. Directions against Sinful Dreams
Dreams are neither good nor sinful simply in themselves, because they are not rational or voluntary, nor within our power. But they are often made sinful by some other voluntary act; they may be sinful by participation and by consequence. The acts that make them sinful are either those that go before or those that follow after.
1. The antecedent causes are any sinful act that disorders the body, any sin that inclines the imagination and mind toward such dreams, or the omission of whatever was necessary to prevent them.
2. The causes that afterward make them sinful in their object are the bad uses people make of them: taking their dreams to be divine revelations and trusting them, or being frightened by them as ominous or prophetic, and making them the ground of their actions, so deceiving themselves by the phantasms of their own brains.
Direction 1. Avoid, as far as you can, those bodily disorders that cause sinful dreams, and especially a full diet. A full stomach causes troublesome dreams and lustful dreams, and it has its ill effects by night and by day.
Direction 2. Work at curing those sinful disorders of the mind that cause sinful dreams. Curing a worldly mind is the best way to cure worldly, covetous dreams; curing a lustful heart is the best way to cure lustful dreams; and so with the rest. Cleanse the fountain, and the waters will be sweeter both by day and by night.
Direction 3. Do not let your thoughts, your tongue, or your actions run sinfully in the day upon what you would not dream sinfully of in the night. Common experience tells us that our dreams tend to follow the thoughts, words, and deeds that went before them. If you think most frequently and affectionately of what is good, you will dream of what is good. If you think of lustful, filthy objects, or speak of them, or meddle with them, you will dream of them; and so with covetous and ambitious dreams. Those who make no conscience of sinning while awake are not likely to scruple much at sinning in their sleep. Gregory, in his Morals, observes that holier thoughts are followed by gentler and more delightful dreams.
Direction 4. Commend yourselves to God in prayer before you take your rest, and ask him to set a guard on your imagination when you cannot guard it yourself. Cast the cure upon him, and flee to him for help by faith and prayer, in the awareness of your own insufficiency.
Direction 5. Let the last thoughts you have before sleep be holy, and yet quieting and consoling. Dreams tend to follow our last thoughts. If you go to sleep with worldliness or vanity in your minds, you cannot expect to be wiser or better asleep than you were awake. But if you close the day’s thoughts with God, and sleep finds them on some holy subject, it is likely to use them as it finds them.
Yet if the thoughts you end with are distrustful, unbelieving, and fearful, your dreams may take on the same disorder; frightening and often sinful dreams follow sinful doubts and fears. But if you sweeten your last thoughts with the love of Christ, the remembrance of your past mercies, the prospect of eternal joys, or a confident casting of yourselves upon some promise, it will make for quiet sleep and wholesome dreams. And if you should die before morning, would it not be most desirable that your last thoughts were holy ones?
Direction 6. When you find some corruption appearing in your dreams, use them to renew your repentance and to stir up your efforts to mortify that corruption. A corruption may be discerned in dreams: 1. when the dreams that reveal it are frequent; 2. when they are earnest and violent; 3. when they are pleasing and delightful to your imagination. Not that any certain knowledge can be drawn from them, but only a conjecture, added to other signs.
So if you frequently, earnestly, and delightfully dream of promotions and honors, or of the favor of great men, suspect ambition, and take greater pains to detect and mortify it. If your dreams are of riches, gain, and money, suspect a covetous mind. If they are of revenge, or of harm to someone you dislike, suspect some malice, and mortify it quickly. And do the same if they are of lust, or feasting, or drinking, or empty amusements, sports, and games.
Direction 7. Lay no more weight on your dreams than there is just cause for.
1. When you have searched and find no such sin prevailing in you as your dreams seem to suggest, do not conclude that you have more than your waking evidence discovers. Do not set your sleeping signs above your waking signs and your waking self-examination.
2. When you are conscious that you indulge no corruption that would occasion such a dream, do not suppose the dream faulty in itself, and do not lay the blame of your bodily temperament, or of causes unknown to you, upon your soul with too heavy and unjust a charge.
3. Abhor the presumptuous folly of those who make predictions from their dreams, measure their expectations by them, and cast themselves into hopes or fears by them. Diogenes said, "What folly is it to be careless of your waking thoughts and actions, and inquisitive about your dreams? A man’s happiness or misery lies upon what he does when he is awake, and not upon what he suffers in his sleep."
CHAPTER 25
DIRECTIONS FOR THE GOVERNMENT OF THE TONGUE
Title 1. The General Directions
Direction 1. Understand in general how important and consequential it is that the tongue be well governed and used. Those who think words are trivial will use them carelessly. The notion that words carry little weight (as some say of thoughts, that they are free) leads people to use their tongues as if these too were free, saying, "Our lips are our own: who is Lord over us?" (Ps 12:4)
1. The tongue of man is his glory: through the power of expression it gives him, he excels the animals. It is a wonderful work of God that a person’s tongue can articulate such a vast number of distinct words. God has not given man so admirable a faculty for vanity and sin. The more noble and excellent it is, the more carefully it must be regarded, and the greater is the fault of those who abuse it. Hilary compares such persons to a bad barber who cuts a man’s face and so disfigures him, when his proper work was to make him neater and more presentable. So it is the office of the tongue to serve excellently for the good of others and to be the glory of mankind; the shame of its faults is therefore all the more inexcusable.
2. The tongue is made to be the index and expression of the mind. If the mind is worth regarding, so is the tongue; and if the mind is not worth regarding, neither is the man. Our Lord tells us that the tree is known by its fruit: an evil tree brings forth evil fruit, and "out of the abundance of the heart the mouth speaketh." Aristotle says that such as a man is, such are his speeches, his works, and his life. By vain or sinful words, therefore, you reveal to others the vanity and corruption of your minds. The tongue is the mind’s index; as Aristippus answered when asked how the wise man differs from the fool: "Send them both naked to strangers and you will find out," as reported by Diogenes Laertius, Lives of the Philosophers, Book 2, section 73.
3. Men’s works depend greatly on their words; so if their deeds are worth regarding, their words are worth regarding. Deeds are stirred up and caused by speech. Daily experience reveals the power of words. A speech has saved a kingdom, and a speech has lost a kingdom. Great actions depend on them, and even greater consequences follow from them.
4. If the people we speak to are worth regarding, our words are worth regarding, for words are powerful instruments of their good or their harm. God uses words through his ministers for the conversion and salvation of men; Satan uses them through his ministers for their ruin and damnation. How many thousands of souls are hurt every day by the words of others, some deceived, some puffed up, some hardened in sin, some provoked to sinful passions! And how many thousands are every day built up by words, instructed, admonished, quickened, or comforted. Paul says, "The weapons of our warfare are mighty through God." And Pythagoras could say that tongues cut deeper than swords, because they reach even to the soul. Tongue-sins and tongue-duties are therefore great matters.
5. Our tongues are the instruments of our Creator’s praise, given us expressly to "speak good of his name" and to "declare his works with rejoicing" (Ps 66:2 Ps 96:2 Ps 135:3 Ps 148:13 Ps 29:2). It is no small part of the service God expects from man, nor a small part of the purpose of our creation. The use of all our highest faculties, gifts, and graces is expressed through the tongue; our wisdom and knowledge, our love and holiness, are largely lost to the honor of God and the good of others if they are not expressed. The tongue is the lantern or window of the soul, through which it looks outward and shines upon others. The sin or duty of so noble an instrument must not be treated lightly by anyone who values the honor of our Maker.
6. Our words also reflect and react upon our own hearts. As they come from our hearts, so they return to them, as we observe daily in prayer and conversation. For our own good or harm, therefore, words must not be made light of.
7. God’s law and judgment will best teach you what regard you owe to words. Christ tells you that "by your words you shall be justified, and by your words you shall be condemned" (Matt 12:37). Words of blasphemy against the Holy Ghost constitute the unpardonable sin (Matt 12:31). When Charyllus was asked why Lycurgus made so few laws, he replied that those who use few words need few laws, as Plutarch records in his Apophthegms.
"If any man offend not in word, the same is a perfect man, and able to bridle the whole body" (Jas 3:2). "The tongue is a fire; a world of iniquity: so is the tongue amongst our members, that it defileth the whole body, and setteth on fire the course of nature, and it is set on fire of hell" (Jas 3:6). "If any man among you seem to be religious, and bridleth not his tongue, but deceiveth his own heart, this man’s religion is vain" (Jas 1:26). "For he that will love life and see good days, let him refrain his tongue from evil, and his lips that they speak no guile" (1 Pet 3:10). "But I say unto you, that every idle word that men shall speak, they shall give account thereof in the day of judgment" (Matt 12:36).
The third commandment tells us that "God will not hold him guiltless that taketh his name in vain." And "speaking the truth in his heart, and not backbiting with the tongue" is the mark of him who shall abide in "God’s tabernacle, and dwell in his holy hill." The very work of heaven is said to be the perpetual praising of God (Rev 4:8, 11). Consider now how God judges your words.
8. Some sense of this may also be drawn from the judgment of the world. Do you not care what men say to you and about you? Do you not care what language your children, servants, or neighbors give you? Are not words against the king treasonable and punishable with death, as well as deeds? "The wheel of affairs," or the course of nature, "is set on fire by words" (Jas 3:6). I may conclude, then, with Solomon: "Death and life are in the power of the tongue" (Prov 18:21); and "Whoso keepeth his mouth and his tongue, keepeth his soul from trouble" (Prov 21:23).
Direction 2. Understand well and remember the particular duties of the tongue. Merely restraining it from evil is not enough. Those duties are these:
1.) To glorify God by magnifying his name, to speak of the praises of his attributes and works.
2.) To sing psalms of praise to him, and delight our souls in the sweet remembrance of his excellencies.
3.) To give him thanks for mercies already received, and to declare to others what he has done for our souls and bodies, for his church, and for the world.
4.) To pray to him for what we need, and to pray for our brethren, for the church, and for the conversion of his enemies and ours.
5.) To appeal to him and swear by his name when we are lawfully called to do so.
6.) To make necessary covenants and vows to him, and to make open profession of our belief, submission, and obedience before men.
7.) To preach his Word, or to declare it in conversation; to teach those committed to our care; and to build up the ignorant and those in error as opportunity allows.
8.) To defend the Word of God by conversation or debate, and to refute the false teaching of deceivers.
9.) To exhort men to their particular duties, to reprove their particular sins, and to endeavor to do them good as we are able.
10.) To confess our own sins to God and to man as occasion requires.
11.) To seek the counsel and help of others for our souls; to inquire after the will of God and the way of salvation.
12.) To praise what is good in others, and to speak well of all people, superiors, equals, and inferiors, wherever there is just ground and cause to do so.
13.) To bear witness to the truth when we are called to it.
14.) To defend the cause of the just and innocent, to vindicate them against false accusers, and to excuse those causes and persons that deserve to be excused.
15.) To communicate and convey to others the same good impressions and affections of mind that God has worked in us, and not merely the bare truths we have received.
16.) And finally, to serve as instruments of common conversation: expressing our mutual affections and regards, transacting all our worldly affairs, and advancing learning, arts, crafts, and the like.
These are the uses and duties of the tongue. Plato, as reported by Diogenes Laertius in his Lives, divides right speaking into four elements: first, what one ought to say; second, how much to say; third, to whom; and fourth, when it is fitting to speak. One ought to say what is useful both to the speaker and the hearer, neither too much nor too little. When speaking to older persons who have sinned, one should use language appropriate to their age; when speaking to younger persons, one should speak with greater authority.
Direction 3. Understand and remember the sins of the tongue that are to be avoided. These are very many, and many of them very great. The most notable are as follows.
1. (Setting aside the sins of omission, which are easy to identify once the duties have been named), among the sins of commission, the first and greatest is blasphemy, the reproaching of God. To speak contemptuously of God, to vilify or dishonor him by denying his perfections, or to debase him by false titles, doctrines, images, or likenesses, such as comparing him to humanity in any of our imperfections, is blasphemy. Such was the speech of Rabshakeh when he threatened Hezekiah; and such is the speech of infidels and heretics who deny God’s omnipresence, omniscience, governance, justice, particular providence, or goodness, or who affirm any evil of him, as that he is the author of sin, or false to his word, or that he governs the world by mere deception, or anything of that kind.
2. Another sin of the tongue is false doctrine, teaching things that are false and dangerous as though they came from God. If someone falsely claims to have received a doctrine by divine inspiration, vision, or revelation, he is a false prophet. But if he merely asserts falsely that a certain doctrine is contained in Scripture or delivered by tradition to the church, he is a false teacher, a sin greater or lesser depending on the aggravating circumstances discussed below.
3. Another sin of the tongue is indirectly opposing godliness: misapplying true doctrine, attacking godly persons for the sake of their godliness, and picking at particular truths and duties of religion; or indirectly opposing truth or duty under the pretense of objecting only to some disputed mode or imperfection in the person who speaks or practices it; defending positions and practices that would subvert or undermine religion; and working quietly to make all serious godliness appear unnecessary. Many who seem orthodox are in fact impious and malicious opponents of the very truth they notionally hold and publicly profess, opposing it in its application.
4. Another great sin of the tongue is profanely deriding serious godliness, mocking, jesting at, and scorning godly persons as such, or scorning some real or supposed imperfection of theirs on account of their piety, so as to make them hateful, and through them to make piety hateful. When a person speaks in such a way that the drift and tendency of the speech is to draw others to dislike truth or holiness, when mockery of a particular opinion, practice, or manner tends toward contempt for religion as seriously practiced, this is the sin. It includes mocking a Gospel preacher for his expressions, imperfections, or for the truth itself, with the aim of bringing him and his doctrine into contempt; or ridiculing the prayers and religious speech of devout persons, to the injury of religion.
5. Another great sin of the tongue is unjustly silencing Christ’s ministers, forbidding them to preach his Gospel or speak in his name, or standing against them, contradicting, resisting, and hindering them in preaching the truth: what Gamaliel calls "fight against God" (Acts 5:39). This is precisely what was done to the apostles: "When they had called the apostles and beaten them, they commanded that they should not speak in the name of Jesus, and let them go" (verse 40).
So too in Acts 4:18–19: "They called them and commanded them not to speak at all, nor teach in the name of Jesus: but Peter and John answered and said unto them, Whether it be right in the sight of God, to hearken unto you more than unto God, judge ye; for we cannot but speak the things which we have seen and heard." As Paul writes, "Who both killed the Lord Jesus, and their own prophets, and have persecuted us; and they please not God and are contrary to all men. Forbidding us to speak to the Gentiles that they might be saved, to fill up their sins always: for the wrath is come upon them to the uttermost" (1 Thess 2:15). As Dr. Hammond paraphrases it, this was generally the ground of the quarrel against the apostles, that despite the prohibition, they continued to preach to the Gentiles.
6. Another sin of the tongue is profane swearing, whether by God or by creatures; and also all light and irreverent use of the name and attributes of God, of which more will be said below.
7. Far more heinous still is perjury, swearing falsely. It is an appeal to God, the author and defender of truth, to bear witness to an untruth and to judge the offender; it is in effect a craving of God’s vengeance upon oneself.
8. Lying is also a great and common sin of the tongue, of which more will be said shortly.
9. Another sin of the tongue is hypocritical dissembling, which is worse than simple lying. This is when a person’s tongue does not agree with his heart, when he speaks good words in prayer to God or in conversation with others in order to conceal evil intentions or affections, and to appear to his hearers as better than he is.
10. Another is ostentation and proud boasting, whether of a person’s wit and learning, greatness, riches, honor, strength, beauty, gifts, piety, or anything else that pride fastens upon. As Pittacus said (cited in Diogenes Laertius, Book 1, section 78): do not announce what you mean to do, for if you cannot do it, you will be laughed at.
The faithful "do make their boast in God" (Ps 34:2 Ps 44:8), and in "the cross of Christ," by which "they are crucified to the world" (Gal 6:14). But the covetous "boast themselves in the multitude of their riches" (Ps 49:6), and "the workers of iniquity boast themselves against the righteous, and the proud do triumph and speak hard things" (Ps 94:2–4). Even against the Lord they boast, in boasting against his people (Ezek 35:13). So far as pride prevails in a person, he is apt to "boast himself to be somebody" (Acts 5:36), openly, as the more foolish do, or cunningly behind plausible pretenses, as the more clever proud ones do.
11. Another sin of the tongue is speaking of common things when holy things should be preferred, on the Lord’s Day, at the time of public worship, or when the company, occasion, or opportunity calls for holy speech. Worldlings talk, like Saul, of their donkeys when they should be talking of a kingdom (1 Sam 9 and 10). To speak about your calling and common affairs is lawful when done moderately and in season; but when your talk runs entirely on worldly things and vanity, never comes to an end, and leaves you with hardly any other talk, and even on God’s Day you will "speak your own words" (Isa 58:13), this is profane and sinful.
12. Another common sin of the tongue is tempting and persuading others to sin, enticing them to gluttony, drunkenness, licentiousness, fornication, or any other crime, being those who "not only do the same, but have pleasure in them that do them" (Rom 1:32). This is to serve as an instrument of the devil and to do his work directly in the world. The same applies to unjustly excusing, minimizing, or defending the sins of others, or commanding, alluring, frightening, or encouraging them into sin.
13. Another is a carnal manner of handling the sacred things of God, treating them with lightness, with unsuitable verbal showiness, or in a ludicrous and trifling way, especially on the part of Gospel preachers themselves, rather than with a style that is grave and serious, befitting the weight and majesty of the truth.
14. Another is an imprudent, rash, and careless handling of holy things, speaking of them so ignorantly, unskillfully, disorderly, or passionately as to dishonor them and frustrate the desired effect. Didymus of Alexandria, commenting on James 3 on bridling the tongue, notes that what he says there is not to be taken as referring merely to grammatical or verbal blunders, the things some call solecisms and barbarisms.
15. Another sin of the tongue is reviling or dishonoring superiors, when children speak disrespectfully and dishonorably to or about their parents; when subjects speak so of their governors; or servants of their masters, whether to their faces or behind their backs (2 Pet 2:10). "They are not afraid to speak evil of dignities" (Jude 1:8).
16. Another is the imperious contempt of inferiors, domineering over them, provoking and discouraging them. "Fathers, provoke not your children to wrath" (Eph 6:4).
17. Another sin of the tongue is idle talk and a multitude of useless words, a babbling loquacity, a habit of speech that tends to no edification and serves no good purpose for mind, body, or practical affairs.
18. Another sin is foolish talk, or jesting in levity and folly, which tends to fill the minds of hearers with the same disposition of levity and folly as the speaker’s. "Foolish talking and jesting are things not convenient" (Eph 5:4). Honest mirth is lawful, and it is best when it is most sanctified, springing from a holy principle, bearing on a holy matter, or directed to a holy end: "as rejoicing in the Lord always" (Phil 4:4); "if any be merry let him sing psalms" (Jas 5:13). But such light and frothy jesting as is merely the outlet of habitual levity in idle words is not allowable.
The most odious abuse of tongue and reason belongs to those who counterfeit idiots or fools, using their wit to disguise their jests with a pretense of foolishness in order to make them more ridiculous, and who make it their very profession to be the jesters of great men. They make a trade of heinous sin.
19. Another sin is "filthy speaking" (Eph 5:4), obscene and ribald talk, which the apostle calls "corrupt or rotten communication" (Eph 4:29): when wanton, filthy minds make sport for themselves with wanton, filthy speeches. This is the devil’s preparation for whoredom and all abominable uncleanness. Once the tongue has been taught to treat such filthy sins as entertainment, and the ear has learned to take pleasure in it or to be indifferent to it, only a small step remains to actual filthiness.
20. Another sin of the tongue is cursing, when men wish some mischief on others without cause or warrant.
Even if you speak only in anger or in jest, and do not genuinely desire the harm you name, it is still a sin of the tongue, just as it is sinful to speak blasphemy or treason in anger or in jest. The tongue must be governed as well as the heart. If you do truly desire the harm you wish on others, it is so much the worse. But worst of all is when passionate, factious men turn their very prayers into cursings, calling for fire from heaven and praying for other people’s destruction or injury, and citing Scripture examples for it, as though they may do without warrant what others did in other circumstances with warrant.
21. Slandering is another sin of the tongue: when out of malice and ill will men speak evil of others falsely, to make them odious or to do them harm; or when, through uncharitable credulity, they too readily believe a false report and repeat it to others; or when, through rashness and an unruly tongue, they spread a report before they have tested it, obtained proper proof, or received any warrantable call to mention it.
22. Another sin is backbiting, venting damaging reports about people behind their backs without any warrant. Whether the matter is true or false, as long as you do not know it to be true, or knowing it to be true, spread it only to diminish the person’s reputation, or at least without sufficient cause, it is a sin against God and a wrong to other people.
23. Another sin is rash censuring, when you speak evil of another that rests on nothing more than an uncharitable surmise; when you treat as probable what is only possible, or as certain what is only probable against another. As Jerome notes against Helvidius: many mistake talkativeness for eloquence and think that speaking evil of everyone is a mark of a good conscience.
24. Another sin is railing, reviling, or speaking passionate and provoking words that tend to diminish charity, break peace, stir up discord, and provoke a return of railing from others, all contrary to the love, patience, meekness, and gentleness that become those who are holy.
25. Another sin is cheating, deceiving, and overreaching words: when men use their tongues to defraud their neighbors in bargaining for their own gain.
26. Another sin of the tongue is false witness-bearing and false accusing, a sin that cries to God for vengeance, since he is the justifier of the innocent.
27. Another sin of the tongue is passing an unrighteous sentence in judgment: when rulers absolve the guilty or condemn the just, and call evil good and good evil, and say to the righteous, "Thou art wicked." (Prov 24:24)
28. Another sin of the tongue is flattery, which is all the more serious the more harmful it is. It is most harmful in two ways.
1.) When it tends to deceive people in the greatest matters, even the state of their souls. The flattery of a preacher who deceives people in the name of Christ is the most pernicious flattery of all: to make the unregenerate believe they are regenerate; the ungodly believe they are godly; the unjustified believe they are justified; and the children of Satan believe they may be saved without conversion, making a worldling, a swearer, a glutton, a drunkard, a fornicator, a formal hypocrite, or a hater of holiness believe that such a person may reach heaven without the sanctifying, renewing work of the Holy Ghost.
This is the most eminent service the tongue of any man can render the devil, short of openly opposing religion altogether. As the devil more commonly flatters men into hell than frightens them there, so do his ministers and instruments. All doctrines of libertinism and looseness, which warrant men to do evil and neglect a holy life, are in this respect a more dangerous form of flattery than that which consists only in misapplication.
Carnal friends also flatter a sinner into presumption and false hope when they see him convinced of his sin and misery, saying: "Do not trouble yourself; God is merciful, and you have lived well, been a good neighbor, and done nobody harm, and if such as you are not saved, God help a great many." So when a convicted sinner is striving to escape the devil’s snares, the servants of Satan rock him back to sleep again with false and flattering speeches.
2.) Flattery is also deeply harmful when it tends to injure many people, as when rulers are deceived and perverted by it to the destruction of the people and themselves. As Bias said (cited in Diogenes Laertius, Book 1, section 88): do not praise an unworthy man for the sake of his wealth.
"A lying tongue hateth those that are afflicted by it, and a flattering mouth worketh ruin." (Prov 26:28) See also (1 Thess 2:5, Ezek 12:24, Ps 12:2–3).
29. Another sin is jeering, mocking, deriding, or scorning others, whether for bodily or mental infirmities, for their virtues, out of envy and malice, out of pride, or from a settled habit of scornful speech. "Scorners delight in scorning," especially when sinners scorn the reproofs and counsels of the godly and cast them back with contempt. For "he that reproveth a scorner getteth himself a blot," and "a scorner loveth not one that reproveth." (Prov 1:22) See also (Ps 22:7, Ps 44:13, Ps 79:4, Prov 9:7–8, Prov 15:12).
30. Another tongue-sin is idolatry or false worship: the praise of idols, praying to them, or composing songs, speeches, or arguments on their behalf, as well as the false worship of the true God. These are among the sins of the tongue to be avoided. It is no wonder there are so many, for the "tongue is a world of iniquity" (Jas 3:6).
Direction 4. When you have understood the duties and sins of the tongue and their gravity, the next thing you must attend to most carefully is this: keep in your heart everything that ought to be on your tongue, and keep your heart clean from everything that your tongue must be kept clean from. The main work must be done on the heart. For "out of the abundance of the heart the mouth speaketh."
1.) The tongue will be effectively governed in no other way. If the heart is set on the world, the tongue will most commonly follow it there. You may force the tongue a little against the heart’s inclination, but it will yield only very inconsistently. The moment you ever so slightly loosen the reins, it is gone. If the heart is proud, the tongue will speak proudly. If the heart is lustful, vain, or malicious, the words will ordinarily be so too.
2.) Or if you can force the tongue to go against the heart, the result is only hypocritical reformation. A vain, proud, worldly, lustful, malicious, or ungodly heart will condemn you, even if the tongue was forced to speak humbly, chastely, patiently, or piously. Seneca’s rule holds here: speak what you think, and think what you speak. And as Pittacus said, the tongue can utter nothing trustworthy while a double mind sits deep in the heart. So too with Bias: when an ungodly man asked him what piety was, he gave no answer at all; and when the man pressed him for the reason of his silence, he said, "I am silent because you are asking about matters that are none of your concern."
Therefore, if you would overcome the vanity, worldliness, licentiousness, or any other corruption in your speech, first set yourself to overcome the same corruption in your heart, and to revive and activate the contrary graces. If you would use your tongue to honor God and build up others, wind up the spring of those holy affections that must serve as water to the mill. The tongue’s purpose is to express the mind; holy speech is the expression of a holy mind. Do you expect to express what you do not have? Will you make a duty out of a lie?
If you would speak of Christ or heaven with seriousness, see that your heart is seriously set upon Christ and heaven. When you enter any company where you should speak for God and for the hearers’ good, endeavor beforehand to get a deep impression on your heart of those attributes or truths of God you wish to express, and to revive in yourself the sense of what you would make others feel. Stir up within you the love of God, the love of holiness and truth, and love for the souls of those you speak to, and you will be like a conduit that flows as soon as the tap is turned, because it is always full.
Direction 5. Work for a real understanding of the matters you will have to speak about. Ignorance leaves you with nothing to say, or furnishes you only with chaff and vanity, so that it would be better to say nothing at all. Knowledge and wisdom are continual storehouses of good and profitable talk, like "the scribe instructed to the kingdom of heaven, that bringeth out of his treasure things new and old" (Matt 13:52). When a person understands the matter he is speaking about, he is equipped to address it intelligibly and to defend it against those who dispute it.
"The mouth of the righteous speaketh wisdom, and his tongue talketh of judgment: the law of his God is in his heart; none of his steps shall slide." (Ps 37:30–31) "The mouth of the just bringeth forth wisdom: but the froward tongue shall be cut out: the lips of the righteous know what is acceptable: but the mouth of the wicked speaketh frowardness." (Prov 10:31–32) Wise people are never at a loss for wise speech; but the mouth of fools betrays their folly. "The tongue of the wise useth knowledge aright; but the mouth of fools poureth out foolishness." (Prov 15:2) "In the mouth of the foolish is a rod of pride; but the lips of the wise shall preserve them." (Prov 14:3) "A fool’s lips enter into contention, and his mouth calleth for strokes. A fool’s mouth is his destruction, and his lips are the snare of his soul." (Prov 18:6–7)
You may object that being told to get wisdom is easy to say but not easily or quickly done. That is quite true, and it is equally true that the tongue is not easily well used or governed, for no one can express wisdom they do not have, except by rote. Therefore you must follow Solomon’s counsel in Proverbs 2:1–6: "My son, if thou wilt receive my words, and hide my commandments with thee; so that thou incline thine ear to wisdom, and apply thine heart to understanding; yea, if thou criest after knowledge, and liftest up thy voice for understanding; if thou seekest her as silver, and searchest for her as for hid treasures; then shalt thou understand the fear of the Lord, and find the knowledge of God: for the Lord giveth wisdom, etc."
Direction 6. In the meantime, learn to be silent until you have learned to speak. Do not let your tongue run ahead of your understanding. Do not speak about what you do not know well, unless as a learner seeking instruction. Of the two extremes, err on the side of speaking too little rather than too much. (Jas 1:19) "Slow to speak, slow to wrath." Those who insist on talking about things they do not understand either speak evil of those things when they are good (Jude 10), or speak ill of them regardless. A person who cannot hold his tongue cannot speak well. "There is a time to keep silence, and a time to speak." (Eccl 3:7) "There is a time so evil, that the prudent should keep silence." (Amos 5:13)
At such a time, as Seneca says, the best course is to be quiet, to say little to others, and to reflect much within yourself. You have two ears and one tongue, hear twice and speak once. We repent of speaking far more often than of staying silent. Few words are quickly answered for. Being careful and sparing in speech not only avoids a great deal of contention, danger, and regret, but also earns you a reputation for wisdom.
Plutarch rightly says that those who speak few words need but few laws. When someone said to a Cynic who was much given to silence, "If you are a wise man, you act foolishly; if you are a fool, you act wisely," he replied, "A fool cannot hold his tongue," and the one who cannot hold his tongue cannot hold his peace. Pythagoras’s counsel on this agrees with Christ’s: either be silent, or say something better than silence. It was a wise answer the man gave when asked whom covetous landlords hated most, and whom covetous lawyers hated most: to the first he replied, "Those who eat little and work hard," for such people live long, and their leases do not soon expire; to the second, "Those who speak little and love much," for such people seldom make any work for lawyers.
Two things are required regarding the content of your speech: it must be something needful to say, and something you actually understand. Until both conditions are met, be silent.
Direction 7. Guard against hasty rashness in your speech, and practice deliberation, especially in important or uncertain matters. Bias warned that speaking hastily is a sign of madness. Think before you speak. It is better to try your words before you speak them than after; a preventive test is better than a repentant one. If both are neglected, God will put your words to the test at far greater cost to you. I recognize that in matters thoroughly understood, a wise person can speak without further premeditation beyond immediately drawing on the knowledge being expressed. But whenever there is risk of misunderstanding, or an inability to speak fittingly and safely without forethought, hasty speech without deliberation, especially in weighty matters, must be avoided. "Seest thou a man that is hasty in his words? there is more hope of a fool than of him." (Prov 29:20)
Take particular care when speaking to God in prayer, in the name of God, or as from God in preaching or exhortation, or when addressing the holy things of God in any conversation. "Keep thy foot when thou goest to the house of God, and be more ready to hear than to offer the sacrifice of fools: for they consider not that they do evil." (Eccl 5:1) That is: watch yourself in public worship, and be more inclined to learn from God and to obey him, recognizing your own ignorance and submission to his will, than to offer him your sacrifice as though he stood in need of you while you neglect or reject his commands.
"Be not rash with thy mouth, and let not thy heart be hasty to utter any thing before God: for God is in heaven, and thou upon earth; therefore let thy words be few. For a dream cometh through multitude of business, and a fool’s voice is known by multitude of words." (Eccl 5:2–3) That is: come to God as an obedient learner and receiver, not as a giver; be readier to hear what he commands you than to pour out many words before him, as though he would accept and hear you for your babbling. If talkativeness and an eagerness to speak many undigested words is a mark of folly among people, how much more so when you are speaking to God who is in heaven?
Direction 8. Maintain holy government over all your passions, as said before, and especially test with suspicion every word that any passion urges you to utter. Passion is so apt to blind the judgment that even holy passions must be managed carefully, and treated with the same caution you would use carrying fire among straw or other combustible material. As "grievous words stir up anger" (Prov 15:1), so anger causes grievous words. "Be not hasty in thy spirit to be angry; for anger resteth in the bosom of fools." (Eccl 7:9)
Governing the tongue when you are in any passion, whether love, fear, grief, or anger, is like steering a ship in a storm, or managing a horse that is fierce and heated. "The fool rageth and is confident: he that is soon angry dealeth foolishly." (Prov 14:16–17) "It is better to dwell in the wilderness than with a contentious, angry woman." (Prov 21:19) "An angry man stirreth up strife, and a furious man aboundeth in transgression." (Prov 29:22) There is no ruling the tongue if you cannot rule the passions. Therefore this is sound counsel: "Make no friendship with an angry man, and with a furious man thou shalt not go; lest thou learn his way, and get a snare to thy soul." (Prov 22:24)
Direction 9. Foresee your opportunities for profitable conversation, and your temptations to evil speech. We are seldom thoroughly prepared for sudden, unexpected occasions. Before you go out, consider what company you are likely to encounter, what good you may be called to do, and what evil you are most likely to be tempted toward. Give particular attention to the regular, recurring duties and temptations of your daily company and conversation.
Direction 10. Besides your general preparations already mentioned, prepare specifically for those duties and those temptations. Always carry with you some particular safeguards against those sins of speech you are most in danger of, and some particular provisions and helps toward those duties of speech you may be called to. A surgeon carries with him the instruments and medicines he is most likely to need among the patients he serves. A traveler carries those necessities he cannot do without on the road.
If you must converse with angry men, come furnished with patience and firm resolutions to "give place to wrath." (Rom 12:19) If you must converse with ignorant and ungodly men, come furnished with powerful, convincing reasons to humble them and change their minds. If you must go among those who cavil at or scorn holiness, come equipped with well-considered arguments in defense of what they are most likely to attack, so that you may shame and silence such opponents. This must be done by "the sword of the Spirit, which is the word of God." (Eph 6:17) Therefore be thoroughly acquainted with Scripture, and with particular plain texts for each particular use, for by them "the man of God is complete, throughly furnished to every good work." (2 Tim 3:17)
Direction 11. Continually walk as in the presence of God, under his government and law, and as those who are moving toward judgment. Whatever you say, ask yourself: 1. Whether it is fit for God to hear. 2. Whether it agrees with his holy law. 3. Whether it is speech you would want brought up on the day of judgment. If something is unfit for the hearing of a grave and godly person, will you say it before God? Will you speak wantonly, filthily, foolishly, or maliciously, when God forbids it, when he is present and hears every word, and when you must certainly give account to him for all? (Ps 139:4)
Direction 12. Pray every morning to God for preservation from the sins of speech you are liable to that day. Commit the keeping of your tongue to him, not as though this discharged you of your own responsibility, but so as to seek and trust his grace. Pray as David prayed: "Set a watch, O Lord, before my mouth; keep the door of my lips; incline not my heart to any evil thing," and that "the words of your mouth and the meditations of your heart, may be acceptable to him." (Ps 141:3–4 Ps 19:14)
Direction 13. Make it part of your continual work to watch your tongue. Carelessness and negligence will not serve in so difficult a task. James tells you that taming and ruling the tongue is harder than taming wild beasts, birds, and serpents; it is like the guiding of a horse by the bridle, or a ship driven by fierce winds. He says that "the tongue is an unruly evil," and that "he that offendeth not in word is a perfect man, and able also to bridle the whole body." (Jas 3) So make it your study and constant occupation to watch the tongue at all times.
Direction 14. Call your tongue to a daily account. Ask yourself what evil you have spoken, and what good you have left undone each day. Be humbled before God in penitent confession of the sin you discover, and renew your resolution toward a stricter watch going forward. If a servant is at fault every day and never hears of it, he will regard the fault as nothing and take little care to amend. You will even remind your ox of his fault with a prick or a stroke when he strays from the furrow, and your horse of his fault with a spur or a rod. Do you think that if you let yourself, your very tongue, be at fault every day and never call it to account, it will ever be reformed and not grow careless and settled in the sin?
Your first care must be to prevent the sin and perform the duty, saying as David did: "I said, I will take heed to my ways, that I offend not with my tongue: I will keep my mouth with a bridle while the wicked is before me: I was dumb with silence, I held my peace." (Ps 39:1–3) "My tongue shall speak of thy righteousness and of thy praise all the day long." (Ps 35:28) "My tongue shall speak of thy word." (Ps 71:24 Ps 119:172) "My tongue is as the pen of a ready writer." (Ps 45:1) But your next care must be to repent of the faults you have committed, to judge yourself for them, and to reform, remembering that "there is not a word in your tongues, but is altogether known to God." (Ps 139:4)
Direction 15. Make use of a faithful monitor and reprover. Through habit and self-partiality we are prone to overlook the faults of our own speech. A friend is extraordinarily useful here. Ask a trusted friend to watch over you in this matter, amend what he points out, and do not be so foolish as to take the side of your fault against your friend.
CHAPTER 26
SPECIAL DIRECTIONS AGAINST PROFANE SWEARING AND USING GOD’S NAME IRREVERENTLY AND IN VAIN
First. To swear is to affirm or deny something with an appeal to some other thing or person as a witness to the truth or an avenger of falsehood, a witness or judge who cannot be produced in a human court. An affirmation or negation is the substance of an oath; the particular invocation is its form. Not every appeal or attestation constitutes an oath (Deut 6:13 Deut 10:20).
To appeal from a partial or incredible witness to one who is credible and can be produced in court is not an oath. To appeal from an incompetent judge or inferior court to a competent judge or higher court is not swearing. To say "I take the king for my witness" or "I appeal to the king" is not to swear by the king. But to say "I take God to witness" or "I appeal to God as the judge of the truth of what I say" is to swear by God.
To appeal to God as a righteous Judge against the injustice or cruelty of men, however, without reference to his attesting or judging any specific affirmation or negation of our own, is not swearing by him, because the substance of an oath is absent. An oath is an appeal to some supernatural or higher and more dreadful power than that of the court or person before whom we swear, made to render our testimony more credible when other evidence of certainty or credibility is lacking. A lawful legal testimony or appeal, then, is not swearing.
Swearing is either just and lawful, or sinful and abusive. For an oath to be just and lawful, five conditions are necessary.
1. It must be God alone whom we ultimately swear by, since no witness and avenging judge above human courts can be appealed to except God. To swear by any creature in the proper sense in which God is sworn by is therefore to idolize it and to ascribe to it the attributes of God (Isa 48:1 Jer 4:2). (More on this below.)
2. The matter of the oath must be true in the case of assertory or negative oaths; and in the case of promissory oaths, the matter must be (1) honest and lawful, and (2) possible. If any one of these conditions is absent, the oath is unlawful.
3. There must be an honest end, for the end is a principal ingredient in all moral good and evil.
4. The oath must be taken on a sufficient occasion and with honest motives, not unnecessarily or without just reason.
5. The manner and circumstances must be lawful.
The word "oath" is equivocal. It is sometimes used for what is formally an oath, as just described, and sometimes for what is merely the matter and expressive form without any real intention of swearing. Alternatively, an oath may refer either to the complete human act, comprising both the words that signify and the purpose they signify, or to the outward sign, that is, the words alone. (Just as "prayer" sometimes signifies the bare form of words and sometimes the words together with the desire they express; and as "sacrament" is sometimes taken for the external signs only and sometimes for the signs along with the mutual covenanting and actions they signify.) This raises a question.
Question: Is it swearing when ignorant and careless people use the words or form of an oath out of mere habit, with no understanding of what an oath is and no thought or intention of appealing to God or to the creature by which they swear? The difficulty is that what they do seems to be only the matter or external part of an oath, and it is the form that specifies and names it. Someone who ignorantly spoke the words of an oath in Latin or Greek while not understanding the language and intending no such thing would not thereby swear.
Answer:
1. In the fullest and most proper sense of the word, it is before God no oath at all if there is no intent to confirm one’s speech by an appeal to God or to that by which one swears. A playful washing with the words of baptism is no more a true baptism than a corpse is a man. (And here what the Papists say is true: that the intention of the baptizer is necessary to the being of baptism, that is, it is necessary, before God, to the being of sacramental administration in the baptizer himself that he truly intend to baptize; it is necessary, before God, to the being of baptism in the person baptized that the person himself, if of age, or those who have authority to dedicate him to God if he is an infant, truly intend it; and it is necessary to the being of the external ordinance before the church that both the baptizer and the baptized profess or appear to intend it.)
2. But if you use words that are the ordinary form of an oath in a language you understand, in such a way that hearers may reasonably suppose you understand it, then before men it is an oath in this narrower sense of the word. It will be binding on you, and can be pleaded against you in any court of justice by those to whom you swear it. Indeed, God himself regards you as thereby obligated to them. If it is a profane and causeless swearing, men must call it an oath, for they cannot see the heart, just as they must take as baptized the person who professes to intend it. Before men it is indeed an oath; and God himself will account you a sinner who has used the external form of an oath, something that, before men, is an oath, to the dishonor of his name and to the scandal of others.
It will not excuse you to say you did not know it was an oath, or did not know the nature of an oath, or used it rashly without considering what it was. You were bound to know and to reflect; you should have done so and could have done so had you chosen. But if the words were ones you could not have known to be the form or expression of an oath, and the hearers could perceive that you meant something altogether different, then you are excusable, provided you had just cause to use them.
Second. As to the case of swearing by creatures, and how far it is sinful: the answer runs parallel to the case of worshipping images, or worshipping by means of images. One who worships an image or any creature as God, terminating his worship ultimately in the creature itself, commits direct and full idolatry; and the sin is all the greater the baser the thing he idolizes (Deut 10:20 Isa 45:23 Isa 65:16 Jer 4:2).
But if he makes the image or creature merely his medium of that worship which ought to be offered to God directly, and which terminates ultimately in God, it is not gross idolatry, though it is a false and forbidden way of worshipping the true God. If, however, the creature is made the medium of the worship God would have offered to him through a medium, then it is lawful so to use or worship it, as when we honor and admire God as revealed in his works, or when we give to parents and rulers, as his officers, that worship or honor which is ultimately directed to God.
The same principle applies to swearing, for swearing is a part of the worship of God. One who swears by any creature as a god, or as the avenger of those who by falsehood escape human judgment, commits idolatry in doing so, as Julian did when he swore by the sun, which he praised in his orations and worshipped as God (Amos 8:14 Hos 4:15 Zeph 1:5 Jer 12:16 Isa 19:18). But one who swears by a creature in such a way as to intend God ultimately as the witness and avenger, yet names only the creature, or names it in a way that carries an appearance of idolatry, or tends to draw the mind away from God, or obscures his honor scandalously, or proceeds in any other forbidden manner, swears by the true God in intention but in a sinful manner.
One who swears directly by God (on a just occasion) and also by or with reference to a creature, naming the creature in clear and inoffensive subordination to God, is excusable. So we customarily lay our hands on the Bible and swear, "So help me God, and the contents of this book." On great occasions, many good men have similarly written to clear themselves of some slander: "I call God, and angels, and men to witness." Many who name creatures intend rather a curse than a swearing by the creature, as in: "If it be not so, let God destroy me by this fire, or this water," and so on.
Question: Is it lawful to lay hands on the book and kiss it in swearing, as is done in England?
Answer: To take an oath as imposed in England, with laying the hand on the Bible and kissing it, is not unlawful.
1. Proved: What God does not forbid is lawful before God. But taking an oath in this way is not forbidden by God, therefore it is lawful. The minor premise will be established sufficiently by disproving all alleged grounds for a prohibition. The major premise needs no proof.
2. If it were forbidden, it would be either: 1. as an act in worship that is not commanded, and so will-worship; 2. as a significant ceremony in worship that is not commanded; or 3. as an uncommanded significant ceremony that contains in itself some forbidden matter or manner. But it is not forbidden on any of these grounds, therefore it is not forbidden at all.
1.) It is not forbidden as an uncommanded act in worship. If it were, the inference would run from the one instance to all, and every act in worship not specifically commanded would be unlawful, which is false. For:
a) The acts used in swearing in Genesis 24:2, Genesis 14:22, and Revelation 10:5 were not commanded yet were lawful, as will be shown shortly.
b) God has not commanded what tune to use when singing a psalm, how to divide the Bible into chapters and verses, whether to use a written or a printed Bible, what words, what method, what particular text to choose, what translation to use, or many similar things.
2.) It is not forbidden as an uncommanded significant ceremony. If it were, then all such ceremonies would be forbidden, which is not true.
a) Abraham’s swearing by lifting up the hand, and the angel’s doing the same (Rev 10), and Abraham’s servant’s swearing by putting his hand under the thigh, were significant ceremonies. Anyone who says they were commanded must prove it. The contrary may reasonably be assumed: first, because no such law is recorded in Scripture, and given the completeness of God’s laws, what does not appear there does not exist there; second, because, as Paraeus and other commentators note, these are described as customary rites and therefore do not depend on any particular precept given to Abraham alone as a prophet; third, because more than one kind of swearing rite is mentioned, lifting up the hand, and putting it under the thigh.
b) Almost all Christians regard some uncommanded significant ceremony in swearing as lawful. The ceremony Paraeus mentions in the same place, as used in the Palatinate, is one such: raising three fingers of the right hand while calling upon the Holy Trinity as avenger. The English Annotations observe that the customs of different countries vary greatly on this point, yet most agree in adding some outward attestation of action or gesture to words when taking an oath, so that it may be better remembered and more seriously regarded than bare words of affirmation, promise, or imprecation. And Josephus, cited by Grotius, tells us it was then the Jewish custom to swear by the ceremony of placing the hand under the thigh, whether as a token of subjection, or because that was the place of the sword, the instrument of revenge, as Grotius and others suppose, or in expectation of the promised seed, as the Fathers thought. The case of Joseph’s adjuration confirms this practice. See Pererius on Genesis 14 and 24.
c) An action of another part of the body is no more forbidden to express the mind than an action of the tongue. God never said that minds may be expressed in sacred or civil matters only through the tongue. A change of countenance can express it, a frown or a pleasant look ("The face is the index of the mind"). Paul lifted up his hand to the Jews when he wanted to speak for himself. Christ acted as though he would go further (Luke 24). Words are not natural signs; in their particulars they are invented and arbitrary, even though the capacity to speak such invented and learned words is natural. If it is lawful to use significant words not commanded in worship, it is lawful to use significant actions, under due regulation.
All the ancient churches, without a single dissenting voice that I have ever read, used many such significant actions. Augustine in his letter to Januarius laments sorrowfully that in his day these had grown to an oppressive number, yet he never speaks against the practice itself. To stand at the creed is a significant expression of consent, which not only all other churches but the old non-conformists never questioned, nor as far as I can learn do the present ones. Whether to sit, stand, or kneel at the singing of psalms is left to liberty. To remove one’s hat is a significant ceremony or act in worship that is not commanded in itself, nor was it used in former times with the same signification it now carries. In countries where covering the head signifies reverence, it is better to remain covered than to go bare.
In one country custom makes standing up the sign of reverence; in another, sitting with the head bowed; in another, kneeling; in another, prostration, and each may accordingly be used in God’s service. When covenants between God and the people are renewed, consent may lawfully be expressed by standing up, or by holding up the hand (by which votes on sacred matters were customarily given), or by subscribing, or by voice. God has commanded us to express consent, reverence, and the like, but has left the word, gesture, or signifying act to our liberty. Anyone who asserts that God has left no means of expressing our minds in sacred matters except words, and has bound us to words alone, must prove that claim, which he would have to prove against Scripture, against nature, and against the judgment and custom of all Christ’s churches and of the world.
3.) If laying the hand on the book and kissing it were unlawful for some special matter or manner more forbidden than in other significant acts, it would be for one of the reasons you have named. I will now answer them.
Objection: It savors of Romish superstition.
Answer:
1. It does not at all, prove it if you can.
2. Superstition consists in imagining things to be pleasing or displeasing to God when they are not, and acting or refraining accordingly. Whatever the etymology of the word, whether "worship of those who have survived" or "beyond what is established," it is certain that common usage among heathens (as Plutarch discusses at length) and among Christians fixed its meaning as an erroneous, undue fear of God: thinking this or that was displeasing or pleasing to him, to be done or avoided, when in fact it was merely the notion of a frightened and mistaken mind. To say that God is displeased with this manner of signifying the mind, when that cannot be shown to be so or proved, is itself superstition. This is not an isolated instance of Satan introducing superstition under the pretense of avoiding superstition.
3. The meaning of the law is to be judged by the law itself, and by the clear doctrine and declared position of those who made the law and of the nation, which here explicitly renounces any superstitious use of the ceremony. I confess I was more afraid that the Papists had taken too much away from Scripture than that they had given it too much honor. And they themselves profess that they do not swear by a creature. See Pererius on Genesis 24:2.
Objection: But Paraeus, commenting on Genesis 24:2, says: "It is not without superstition when an oath is taken with fingers placed upon a crucifix or a copy of the Gospels, as is done in Popery."
Answer:
1. The very same act that is superstitious in Popery, because of the superstitious conceptions and ends attached to it there, is not superstitious in others who have no such conceptions or ends.
2. It is nothing new to be quick in accusing one’s adversaries; but Paraeus adds not a syllable of proof, and had he done so, it would either not have touched us at all, or would have been invalid.
Objection: Some good men have had scruples about it.
Answer:
1. Ten thousand to one good men have had no such scruple.
2. Such men are not our gods or our law.
3. The Quakers and the old Anabaptists, and they cite Origen, had scruples about, and indeed condemned, all swearing or all imposed oaths. If we avoid as sin everything that some good men have scrupled, we shall make superstition a great part of our religion. And if, on the same grounds, we practice as duty everything that some good men have taken for duty, we shall quite outpace the Papists. Anyone who reads Bede, Boniface, and a multitude of such pious writers will soon see that godly or fanatical religious persons, their dreams, visions, strict opinions, confident assertions, credulous acceptance of one another’s testimony, and the hope of using such things against Pagans and Jews for the sake of Christianity, together brought in nearly all the legends and superstitions of the Papists.
Objection 2: Our common-law commissions, which give authority to examine persons, direct that it be done "upon their oaths, faithfully to be administered by the holy Gospels of God"; and in the form used in ecclesiastical courts the words are "duly and lawfully sworn at the holy Gospels of God." Do not these forms imply that in their original use persons either swore by the Evangelists or were at least at fault in that mode of swearing? And our common law calls it a corporal oath, from the touching of the book.
Answer:
1. To understand the sense of our present law, it is not necessary to know what meaning its first users had in mind. The law is not now the law of the king who first made it (a king who no longer governs has no law), but the law of the king who now reigns and gives it its sense.
2. To justify our obedience to a law, it is not necessary to prove that every phrase in that law is perfectly expressed.
3. But examine it carefully, and consider whether it may in fact be fitting and praiseworthy.
1. There are three things joined together in the oaths in question: 1. An assertory testimony or a promise. 2. An oath. 3. An imprecation. The assertory testimony is the first thing intended; the oath and imprecation serve only as means to make that testimony or promise valid.
2. The published doctrine of England, set out in the Thirty-Nine Articles, the book of ordination, and similar documents, is that the Holy Scriptures contain all things necessary to salvation, as God’s law and rule for our faith and life. All our duty to God is commanded there; all the promises on which we hope are there contained; all the punishments which the perjured or any sinner must feel and should fear are there threatened.
3. The laying on of the hand and the kissing of the book is an action directly related to the imprecation, and not to the oath except by consequence, since the imprecation is subservient to the oath as the oath is to the assertion. The plain paraphrase of the whole ceremony, then, is this: "I believe that God, the Ruler of all the world, is the Judge of secrets beyond human judgment, the Searcher of hearts, and the hater and avenger of perjury, according to this his holy Word by which he governs us. To this God I appeal as to the truth of my testimony, consenting to forfeit all the benefit of his promises to the just, and to bear all the punishment here threatened to the perjured, if I lie."
And what could be more fitting:
1. To affirm the Protestant doctrine that Scripture is God’s perfect word, that the evil to be feared and the good to be hoped for are all contained there and constitute the fulfilling of that word?
2. And to place the Word in its proper subordination to God? Our ordinary form of swearing reflects this: "So help you God, and the contents of this book." Whether you call this "swearing upon or by the Gospel," or call it "a corporal oath" or a spiritual oath, is a matter only of naming, and says nothing about the thing as truly described. In the Latin of those forms, sacramentum signifies the oath itself, and ad sancta evangelia, "at the holy Gospels," is a fitting phrase. Or if super sacramenta is taken to mean "upon the sacraments," referring to the two sacraments of the Gospel, it can mean no more than: "As one who, by receiving the sacrament, professes to believe this Gospel to be true, I renounce its benefits if I lie," and in this sense it has been the custom of some to receive the sacrament when they intended to swear solemnly.
Objection 3: Some seem to object against kissing the book, as appearing to give too much honor to it, or to place some adoration upon it; and because the ceremony of kissing is held to be of later date than laying on the hand.
Answer: The ceremony signifies that I love and approve the Gospel, and place the hope of my salvation in it. The published doctrine of the kingdom, already cited, serves as a full exposition of what we ascribe to it. But just as some scrupulous brethren in Scotland gratify the Papists by rejecting the oath of supremacy, which is the most formidable barrier against Popery, even while decrying Popery itself, so others gratify the Papists by suggesting that we give too much to the Bible and adore it, when the very heart of England’s Protestantism is its rightful ascription to the Holy Scriptures of their sufficiency in all things necessary to salvation. So Satan continues to undo by overdoing.
Objection 4: Laying on the hand and kissing the book seem to be of the same nature as the cross in baptism and other significant ceremonies. An oath is part of the worship of God, and therefore it should not be taken with such ceremonies, or doing so will appear to justify the others.
Answer:
1. Significant words, gestures, or actions are not evil simply because they are significant, unless brutishness is a virtue. Nor are they evil merely because someone calls them "ceremonies," else that name might be applied to anything by an adversary to strip us of our liberty. I cannot judge any ceremony by that general label alone, until it is identified in particular.
2. On the cross in baptism, see my Disputations of Church Government on ceremonies, written long ago. There are several plain differences between the cases.
1.) The cross is an image used in God’s worship, not a permanent but a transient image, and used as an image of the cross of Christ, though only drawn in water or oil. God has more specifically forbidden images in his worship than he has forbidden a professing significant word, gesture, or action that is not an image and not used as one.
2.) The cross appears to function as a third sacrament of the covenant of grace, used as a symbol of Christianity and a dedicating sign, as the canon calls it, by which before the church a solemn self-obligation is made, as it were sacramentally, to renounce the devil, the world, and the flesh, and to fight manfully under Christ’s banner as his faithful servants and soldiers to life’s end, implying trust and hope in Christ crucified for the benefits of his death.
Even if it falls short of being a complete third sacrament, it possesses so much of what is proper to a sacrament, resembling the military oath (the sacramentum militare, from which the word "sacrament" entered the church), that for my part I dare not use it. I do not presume to censure those who do, nor do I condemn every other use of the cross, which the ancient writers used abundantly as sudden, individual, professing signs far below this solemn covenanting use.
Just as a king would rightly take offense if a subject presumed to create another badge of an order, after the king has already made the star the badge of the Knights of the Garter, even though many a significant gesture or act may be used without offense, so I fear Christ would not take it well if I presumed to make or use another symbol or mark of Christianity, especially one carrying so much of a covenanting, sacramental character. But what does any of this have to do with things or gestures significant of no such kind? You can see, then, the difference between these cases.
But if you were able to prove the cross as harmless as the swearing ceremony, I would be for the cross and not against laying the hand on the book and kissing it.
1.) I do not form my judgment on particular cases simply to align with my preconceived opinions about things I have placed in the same category, nor do I make the interests of my former conclusions the measure of my later judgments.
2.) Nor do I think it any great honor to be strict in my opinions, when it is a dishonor to be superstitious, to add to God’s law by claiming he forbids what he does not, or to affect singularity by refusing lawful things with a "touch not, taste not, handle not" (Col 2:21). I do not judge a person to be wisest, best, or holiest who holds the narrowest and strictest opinions, but who holds the rightest; not the one who makes the most things into sins, but the one who commits least actual sin; not the one who makes the most laws for himself and others, but the one who best obeys God’s laws.
Question 1: May a person who himself has scruples about swearing in this way, but is commissioned to administer oaths, give such an oath to another who has no such scruples?
Answer:
1. If the thing is, as has been proved, lawful, his personal scruple will not make him innocent in neglecting the duties of his office.
2. If the substance of the oath were lawful but only the mode or ceremony were sinful as suspected, then:
1.) If the commissioner must himself specifically command that mode, it would be unlawful for him to do so.
2.) But if he simply commands and administers the oath as an oath, leaving the mode without his approbation or command to the taker and to the law, he may give the oath on those terms. Christians in every age have regarded it as lawful to make covenants even with infidels and idolaters, and to accept a Turk’s oath by Mahomet, when what they demand is the oath itself and the mode is the taker’s own, which they would rather be without and give no approval of. If a king may thus demand an infidel’s or idolater’s oath, as God himself demands men’s duty even knowing they will sin in performing it, then much more may one do so in the case of a doubtful ceremony which he neither authored nor approves. But I hold the ceremony in question to be lawful, fitting, and praiseworthy.
Third. On the matter of taking God’s name in vain, which for brevity I treat together with swearing, this is done in one of two ways: 1. in the grossest and most heinous manner; or 2. in a lesser manner.
1.) The grossest form of taking God’s name in vain is perjury, calling him as a witness to a lie. Among the Jews, "vanity" and "a lie" were words frequently used interchangeably.
2.) The lesser form of taking God’s name in vain is using it lightly, irreverently, contemptuously, jestingly, or without just cause. Even in these cases there is profaneness and very great sin, which is aggravated in proportion to the degree of contempt or profanation. It is a grave sin to make an irreverent byword of "O Lord," or "O God," or "O Jesus," or "God help us," or "Lord have mercy on us," or "God send this or that," in common talk, or to take God’s name in vain in any such way. But to use it in jeers and mockery at religion, or to make playbooks and stage-plays full of such profane and contemptuous jibes, is one of the greatest villainies a human tongue can commit against its Maker. (More on this below.) See Dr. Hammond’s Practical Catechism on the third Commandment.
Direction 1. To avoid all this profaneness in swearing and taking the name of God in vain, the first Direction must be this general one: use all the Directions given in Chapter 1 for a wicked man’s attaining true conversion, and take careful note of how powerful an evidence this sin is of a graceless, ungodly, and miserable soul. For it is assumed to be a habitual or frequent sin, and therefore indicates that no effective principle in the heart opposes it; and therefore that sin holds the principal place in the will; and therefore that it remains unrepented of by any saving, renewing repentance. If you had any true grace, it would teach you to fear and honor God more. To make light of God is, in a predominant degree, incompatible with godliness, for the two are directly contrary.
Direction 2. Bring your heart to a genuine sense of the intrinsic evil of your sin. It would never be so easily and habitually committed if you did not regard it as small. To help you see it rightly, consider the following aggravations. Fitzherbert writes (Book 1, ch. 23, page 17): "I cannot but lament that so great an impiety as blasphemy, being so common, goes unpunished, whereas in other countries even the least blasphemies are severely punished; insomuch that in Spain I have known a man set in the market-place for the greater part of a day gaping with a gag in his mouth, merely for swearing ‘By the life of God.’"
1. Consider who that God is whom you abuse. Is he not the great and terrible Majesty who made the world, upholds it, and governs it by his will? The governor and judge of all the earth, infinitely surpassing the sun in glory? A God most holy, who is to be named with holiness? And will you make a byword of his dreadful name? Will you profanely swear by his holy name, and use the name of your God as you would scarcely use the name of your father or your king? Will you toss it about irreverently and contemptuously like a football? (Job 5:21–22 Job 42:5–6 Job 38:2–3) Do you know no more difference between God and man? Know God, and you will sooner tremble at his name than abuse it so carelessly.
2. Consider who you are, that you venture to profane the holy name of God. Are you not his creature and his subject, bound to honor him? Are you not a worm, unable to resist him? Can he not tread you into hell, or ruin you and take vengeance on you with a word, or less? He need only say, "Thus I will have it," to execute his vengeance on the greatest of his enemies. If he wills it, it will be done. And are you then a fit person to despise this God and abuse his name? Is it not an astonishing act of condescension that he permits such worms as we are to pray to him, to praise and worship him, and that he accepts it at our hands? And yet you venture to slight and despise him?
I have often heard the same impious tongue reproach the prayers of the godly as too bold and familiar with God, arguing against long or frequent praying on the ground that man must not be so bold with God, and persuading others that God does not accept it, while that very tongue was freely swearing by his name and using it lightly in common talk. Indeed, God’s servants must guard against rude and irreverent boldness even in prayer. How much more, then, is the boldness of profaning God’s holy name to be condemned? If they must take care how they use it in prayer and praise, how dare you abuse it in oaths, curses, and empty speech?
3. Do you not sometimes pray by that very name which you profanely swear by? If not, you seem utterly to renounce God, and you are a miserable wretch indeed. But if you do pray, what a hypocrite you show yourself to be in all your prayers, professing reverence for the name of God while you toss it about carelessly and swear and curse by it the moment you rise from your knees. It is part of Bishop Hall’s character of the hypocrite that he bows to the name of Jesus, swears by the name of God, and prays to God in church, but forgets him or swears by him the rest of the week. Does not your conscience sting you for this hypocrisy when, in your prayers, you are reminded of your abuse of God?
4. Consider, man, what use you will have for that holy name in your hour of distress, the very name you now abuse. When sickness and death come, you will cry, "Lord, Lord!" Then the name of God will be called on with far more reverence. And do you dare make a football of it now? Do you not fear that on your deathbed, when you are calling upon God, it will be your terror to remember: "This is the name I was accustomed to swear by and take in vain"?
5. Remember that millions of glorious angels are magnifying that great and holy name which you are profaning and taking in vain. Do you not wonder that some of them do not become the executioners of God’s vengeance against you, and that the earth does not open and swallow you up? Shall a worm on earth be tossing about that holy name, or swearing by it profanely, while a whole world of glorious angels is magnifying it?
6. Consider that you are more impious than those who profane things consecrated to God. Was Belshazzar punished with the loss of kingdom and life for carousing with the vessels of the sanctuary? Would you not call it profane for someone to make a stable of the church, or to feed his swine from the communion cup? Then know that the name of God himself carries a higher degree of holiness than any place or utensil of his worship, and therefore that to abuse his name is a greater profaneness than to abuse any of these. Does not your tongue then convict you of hypocrisy, when you would cry out against anyone who so profaned the church, the font, the communion cup, or the table, while you yourself habitually profane the very holy name of God and use it as a common word?
7. Consider how poorly you repay God for giving you the gift of a tongue and speech. He gave you this noble faculty to honor him, and is this your thanks? To use it to dishonor him by swearing and taking his name in vain?
8. Your infectious breath corrupts others. It tends to bring God into common contempt among his own creatures when they hear his name spoken of contemptuously.
9. You forget how tender and jealous God has shown himself to be of the honor of his holy name, what terrible threats he has pronounced against those who profane it, and what judgments he has executed upon them. (Ps 29:2 Ps 66:2 Ps 68:4 Ps 34:3 Ps 96:2 Isa 9:6 Isa 12:4 Isa 41:25 Jer 34:16 Ezek 36:22–23 1 Kgs 8:16 1 Kgs 8:18–19 1 Kgs 8:29 1 Kgs 9:3 1 Kgs 9:7 2 Sam 7:13 Deut 14:23 Ps 145:1–2 Isa 26:8 Isa 26:13 Ps 86:9 Ps 86:12 Ps 135:13 Song 1:3 John 12:28)
"Ye shall not swear by my name falsely: neither shalt thou profane the name of thy God: I am the Lord" (Lev 19:12; see also Lev 18:21). Of the priests it is said, "They shall be holy unto their God, and not profane the name of their God" (Lev 21:6 Lev 22:2 Lev 22:31–32). "Therefore shall ye keep my commandments, and do them: I am the Lord: neither shall ye profane my holy name, but I will be hallowed among the children of Israel: I am the Lord which hallow you."
"If thou wilt not observe to do all the words of this law that are written in this book, that thou mayest fear this glorious and fearful name, The Lord thy God, then the Lord will make thy plagues wonderful, and the plagues of thy seed; great plagues and of long continuance; and sore sicknesses and of long continuance" (Deut 28:58–59).
Worshipping God and trusting in him is called "a walking in his name, and calling upon his name" (Mic 4:5 Ps 99:6). The place of his public worship is called "the place where he putteth or recordeth his name" (Exod 20:24 Deut 12:5 Deut 12:11 Deut 12:21). "They shall sanctify my name, and sanctify the Holy One of Jacob, and shall fear the God of Israel" (Isa 29:23). "For how should my name be polluted? and I will not give my glory to another" (Isa 48:11).
God told Moses, and Moses told Aaron when his two sons were slain, "I will be sanctified in them that come nigh unto me, and before all the people I will be glorified" (Lev 10:3). "A man that in striving with another blasphemed and cursed, was stoned to death" (Lev 24:10 and 24:14). And in the third commandment it is terrible enough that God says, "The Lord will not hold him guiltless that taketh his name in vain."
10. Do you not regularly say the Lord’s Prayer, asking, "Hallowed be thy name" (Matt 6:9)? And will you then profane the very name you pray may be hallowed? Is it hallowing God’s name to swear by it, or to use it carelessly and vainly in everyday talk? Will God endure such hypocrisy, or take any account of such hypocritical prayers?
11. Your habitual swearing is also an uncharitable accusation of those who hear you, as though they were so unbelieving that they would not take a man’s word without an oath, and so profane that they take pleasure in the profanation of God’s name, which is in fact a grief to every honest hearer.
12. You also accuse yourself as a person who is suspected of lying and cannot be trusted: among honest people, a word is credible without an oath. If you were taken for an honest man, your bare word would be believed. By swearing, you tell everyone who hears you that you assume your word alone is not believed. And if that is so, why do you need to announce it so openly?
13. By swearing, you further confirm that suspicion as justified, and show that you genuinely are not to be trusted. Swearing, far from making your words more credible, does the very reverse. For anyone who has so little conscience and fear of God as to swear profanely can hardly be thought to make any conscience of a lie. It is the same God who is offended by both. A swearer gives you every reason to suspect him for a liar.
14. Both swearing and taking God’s name in vain are all the greater sins because the temptation to them is so weak. They commonly bring no honor, but shame. They bring none of the sensual pleasure that gluttony, drunkenness, and uncleanness offer. They are usually committed without any profit to draw a person toward them. You do not gain the worth of a penny by your sin, so it is hard to find what drives you to it, unless it is to show God that you do not fear him, and unless you mean to defy him and do what you know will offend him out of sheer contempt. One would think that even a small measure of grace would suffice to cure so fruitless a sin; its persistence, therefore, is a mark of gracelessness.
15. How terribly you draw God’s vengeance down upon yourself! Cursing yourself is a petition for vengeance; profane swearing is a profane, contemptuous appeal to God’s judgment. Do you dare, even in the midst of your sins, to appeal to the judgment of God? Do you fear it so little? To that judgment you shall indeed go, and you will soon have more than enough of it, and discover what it was for stubble to appeal to the "consuming fire" (Heb 12:29).
Direction 3. Remember God’s presence, keep his fear upon your heart, remember the judgment to which you are hastening, maintain a tender conscience, and keep watch over your tongue, and you will easily escape so gross a sin. Would you dare abuse God’s name before his face?
Direction 4. Write over your door or above your bed, where you may read it often, the third commandment, or some of these solemn passages of Scripture: "I say unto you swear not at all: neither by heaven, nor by the earth, nor by thy head, but let thy communication be yea, yea, nay, nay: for whatsoever is more than these, cometh of evil" (Matt 5:34–37). "Above all things, my brethren, swear not, neither by the heavens, neither by the earth, nor any other oath; but let your yea, be yea, and your nay, nay; lest ye fall into condemnation" (Jas 5:12) (or hypocrisy, as Dr. Hammond thinks it should be read). "Every one that sweareth shall be cut off" (Zech 5:3). "Because of swearing the land mourneth" (Jer 23:10 Hos 4:2). Think carefully on such texts as these.
Direction 5. Love God and honor him as God, and you will not be able to despise and abuse his name in this way. You will naturally respect and honor the name of the person you love, revere, and honor. It is atheism and a lack of love for God that makes you profane his name so freely.
Direction 6. After every such offense, impose on yourself a voluntary fine or penalty sufficient to sharpen your attention and memory. If no one enforces the law against you (which sets the penalty at twelve pence per oath), lay a heavier one on yourself and give it to the poor. You are not obliged to act as a judge over yourself, but you may rightly use such a measure as a remedy, since it has a rational fitness for curing the habit.
CHAPTER 27
SPECIAL DIRECTIONS AGAINST LYING AND DISSEMBLING
To understand what lying is, we must first understand what truth is and what speech is for. Truth can be considered in three ways: 1. as it exists in the things known and spoken of; 2. as it exists in the mind’s conception or knowledge; 3. as it exists in the expressions of the tongue.
1. Truth in things known is simply their reality, that they actually are what their names mean or what the mind takes them to be. This is what is called both physical and metaphysical truth (see Aquinas, On Truth).
2. Truth in the mind’s conception or knowledge is nothing other than the agreement or conformity of knowledge to the thing known. To conceive of something truly is to conceive of it as it actually is. Mistake or error is the opposite of this truth.
3. Truth as it exists in expressions involves a twofold relation.
1.) The primary relation is of our words or writings to the matter expressed. Truth of speech in this sense is simply the agreement of our words to the things they express, when we speak of them as they are.
2.) The secondary relation of our words is to the mind of the speaker, because the natural use of the tongue is to express the mind as well as the matter. In this sense, truth of speech is the agreement of our words to our own thoughts or judgments.
Truth as the agreement of thoughts or words to the matter may be called logical truth. This is merely the common element of moral or ethical truth, and it can be found partly in a clock, a watch, a weathervane, or a sailor’s chart. The agreement of our words to our minds is the more proper and specific element of moral truth. Its form as a moral virtue is its agreement to the law of the God of truth.
And since the object of a relation enters its definition, our words have regard to the mind of the hearer or reader as their proper object, their purpose being to acquaint that person: 1. with the matter expressed; and 2. with our own minds concerning it. It is therefore necessary to the logical truth of speech that it be capable of rightly informing the hearer, and to its ethical truth that the speaker genuinely intend to inform rather than to deceive. (This presupposes that we are speaking to another person.)
You can see, then, that moral truth requires all of the following:
1. The words must agree with the matter expressed, so far as we are obliged to know that matter.
2. The words must agree with the speaker’s own mind or judgment.
3. The expressions must be capable of informing the hearer of both the truths above.
4. We must genuinely intend by them to inform the hearer of the truth, insofar as we assert it.
5. The speech must be agreeable to the law of God, which is the rule of duty and the revealer of sin.
In some statements the truth of words as agreeing to the matter and as agreeing to the mind are one and the same, namely, when our own conception or judgment of a thing is all that we assert. When we say, "I think, or I believe, or I judge that such a thing is so," it is not at all necessary to the truth of my words that the thing actually be as I think it is (for I do not assert that it is so), but only that I genuinely think as I say I think. Yet the agreement of our words to our minds is always and without exception necessary to all moral truth.
We are not bound to disclose everything that is true, for then no one could keep a secret, much less to every person who asks us. We are therefore not bound to try to correct every person’s error in every matter, because we are not bound to speak to every person at all. If I am not obligated to disclose the truth at all, or my mind at all, then I am not obligated to disclose all of the truth, or everything in my mind, not even to those to whom I am obligated to disclose part of both.
If I find someone in an ignorance or error that I am not bound to correct, indeed, one it might be sinful to correct, as it would be to reveal the king’s military secrets to his enemies, I may and must shape my speech to that person, even on those matters, in such a way that he does not learn what he ought not to know, whether about the matter or about my own mind. I may remain silent, or speak obscurely, or use words that he does not understand through his own limitations, or that I know his weakness will cause him to misunderstand. But I must not speak any falsehood to him.
There is also a great difference between speaking in a way that fails to cure the hearer’s prior ignorance or error, and speaking in a way that leads him into some new error. The former may be done in many cases where the latter may not. There is likewise a great difference between speaking words that in common usage tend to inform hearers of the truth, even if I happen to know that through some weakness of their own they will misunderstand them and be misled, and speaking words that in common usage carry a meaning other than the one I intend by them. In the first case, the hearer is sometimes his own deceiver, not the speaker, when the speaker is not bound to reveal more. In the second case, the speaker is the deceiver.
There is also a great difference between speaking to someone to whom I am duty-bound to reveal the truth and speaking to someone to whom I am not so bound, indeed, from whom my duty to God and to my king or country obliges me to conceal it. From these principles and distinctions you may understand what a lie is, and may resolve the ordinary doubts that are commonly raised about speaking truth or falsehood.
Question 1: Am I bound to speak the truth to every person who asks me?
Answer: You are not bound to speak at all in every case to every person who asks. And one who is silent does not speak the truth.
Question 2: Am I bound to speak the truth to every person I do answer?
Answer: Your answer may sometimes amount to nothing more than a refusal to answer or to reveal what is being asked of you.
Question 3: Am I bound to speak all the truth whenever I speak part of it?
Answer: No. It is God’s Word that must tell you when and how much you must reveal to others. If you go only as far as God allows, it does not follow that you must go further (Matt 26:63; Mark 14:61; Mark 15:5; Luke 23:9; John 19:9; Jer 38:26, 27). A soldier captured by the enemy may tell the truth when asked about things that will do no harm to his king and country, but he must conceal the rest, which would give the enemy an advantage against them.
Question 4: Is it always a sin to speak a logical falsehood, that is, to speak in a way that does not agree with the thing I am speaking about?
Answer: Not always. You may sometimes believe something untrue without sin, because you are to believe things according to their evidence and appearance. If the mistake was unavoidably caused by a false appearance or evidence and was through no fault of yours, then the error is not your fault either. But your expressions must then claim no more certainty than you actually have, nor show more confidence than the evidence warrants. When you say that such a thing is so, the meaning must be understood as: I am persuaded it is so. If you say you are certain of something when you are not, you sin.
Question 5: Is it always a sin to speak falsely or contrary to the matter when I know it to be false, that is, is it always a sin to speak contrary to my own judgment or mind?
Answer: Yes. God has forbidden it, and on great and weighty grounds, as you will hear presently.
Question 6: Is it a sin when I speak neither a known untruth nor contrary to my opinion, nor with any intent to deceive?
Answer: Yes; it is often a sin even when none of those elements are present. If it is your duty to know what you are saying, to deliberate before you speak, to acquaint yourself with the truth or falsehood you are ignorant of, and to take care not to deceive another through negligence, and yet you neglect all these duties and through culpable ignorance and carelessness deceive both yourself and others, then this is a sin just as much as if you had deceived them knowingly.
Question 7: But though it be a sin, it remains doubtful whether it is a lie.
Answer: This is merely a dispute about a name, not about the thing itself. As long as we agree that it is a sin against God and must be avoided, it matters little whether you call it a lie or give it some other name. That said, I think it should be called a lie. I know that most who define lying follow Cicero and say that a lie is a falsehood spoken with a purpose to deceive; yet I think that where the will is culpably negligent in failing to avoid deception, an untruth so carelessly uttered deserves the name of a lie.
Question 8: Must my words, to be free from falsehood, always be true in the proper, literal sense?
Answer: No. Augustine’s judgment on this point is clearly right: "What is said figuratively is not a lie," that is, not a lie under that name. To speak ironically, by metonymy, by metaphor, and so on, is not therefore to lie. Since the truth of words lies in their fitness to express the thing and the speaker’s mind in a way suited to the understanding of the hearers, words that express this, whether properly or figuratively, are true words. But if figurative language is used contrary to the hearers’ sense and the common understanding of the words, with a purpose to deceive, then it is a lie, even if you appeal to a figure of speech to justify it.
Question 9: Must my words be used in the common sense, or in the hearer’s sense?
Answer: Without question, so far as you intend to inform the hearer, you must speak to him in his own sense. If he has a particular sense of some word that differs from the common sense, and you know this, you must speak in his particular sense. But if the matter is one you are bound to conceal from him, the question becomes much harder. Some hold it an untruth and sinful to use words toward him that you know he will interpret to his own error. Others think you are not required to accommodate his particular usage and speak in his dialect contrary to common sense, and that it is not your fault if he misunderstands you, even though you foresee it, where it will neither profit him to understand you nor are you obliged to make him understand you, but rather the contrary. The next question will open this further.
Question 10: Is it lawful by speech to deceive another, even to intend it, provided what you say is true?
Answer: It is not a sin in all cases to contribute toward another person’s error or mistake.
1. There are many cases in which it is no sin for a person to be mistaken, and no harm to him either. To contribute toward something that is neither sin nor harm is not itself a sin. Indeed, there are some cases in which an error, though not as such, may reflect a duty: for example, thinking charitably and well of a hypocrite as long as he appears sincere. If by charitable reports I contribute to someone’s mistaken good opinion of such a person, this seems to be my duty. For just as the hearer is bound to believe the best while it is probable, so I am bound to report the best while it is probable.
2. There are many cases in which a person’s ignorance or error may be a very great benefit to him. His life or estate may depend on it. I may know that if he understood such and such a thing, he would use that knowledge to his own ruin.
William Ames, in his Cases of Conscience (book 5, chapter 53), notes that it is sometimes lawful, without violating truth, to utter words from which we know the hearers will probably draw a false conclusion. This is not lying or bearing false witness, but only giving another an occasion to err, not to commit sin, but rather to avoid it. See also (Luke 24:28; John 7:8, 10).
3. There are many cases in which a person’s innocent error is necessary to the safety of others or of the commonwealth.
4. It is lawful in such cases to deceive people by actions, as an enemy may be deceived by military stratagems, or a traitor by signs he will misread. And true words that we know in advance he will mistake, through no fault of ours but his own, seem even less questionable than actions, which by their nature tend toward deception.
5. God himself has written and spoken words that he foreknew wicked men would misunderstand and thereby deceive themselves; and he has done works and given mercies that he knew they would turn into a snare against themselves. His dominion or prerogative cannot be invoked to excuse this if it were unholy. In this sense, of permitting and occasioning, it is said, "And if the prophet be deceived, I the Lord have deceived that prophet" (Ezek 14:9).
Yet we must not follow Plato in thinking it lawful to lie to an enemy in order to deceive him.
1.) All deceit that is against charity or justice is sinful.
2.) All deceit performed by means of a lie is sinful. As Augustine says, there are some lies spoken for another’s safety or benefit, not in malice but in benignity, as the midwives lied to Pharaoh. These lies are not commended in themselves, but for the charitable intent in them. Those who lie in this way will deserve, that is, be on the way, to be at last delivered from all lying. There is also lying in jest, which does not truly deceive, because the person spoken to knows it is in jest. Neither of these sorts is faultless; but the fault is not great. A perfect man must not lie to save his life. But it is lawful to remain silent about the truth, though not to speak falsely. (On the Psalms.)
In his Enchiridion, Augustine adds: "It does not seem absurd to me that every lie is a sin; but it makes a great difference with what mind, and in what matters, a man lies."
Some think a physician may lie to persuade his patient to take a medicine and save his life. He may lawfully deceive him by concealing a medicine, or by true but obscure speech that he expects will be misunderstood, but not by outright falsehood.
Question 11: In what does the proper vice of lying consist? Is it in deceiving another? In speaking falsely? Or in speaking contrary to one’s own thoughts?
Answer: It is an aggravation of a lie that it is an injurious deceit. But the malignity of the sin does not consist merely in deceiving another person’s mind. As has been said, it may be a great benefit to many people to be deceived: a patient’s life may be saved when his physician finds it necessary, for his taking a medicine, to employ some deception, since without it the patient will refuse. Children and weak-headed people must similarly be handled. Such charitable deception, as such, cannot be a sin.
Therefore the general nature of a lie does not consist solely in the purpose of deceiving, but in speaking falsely and contrary to the mind. Otherwise it would follow either that all deception is sin, or that all lying and false speaking is lawful wherever the deception of another is charitable or lawful, neither of which can be granted.
Yet not every untruth is a lie. Some of the scholastics distinguish between lying (as going against one’s own mind) and saying a falsehood, as if telling a falsehood were not always lying, because it is not always contrary to the mind. But by falsehood in that sense they mean nothing more than a factual untruth.
My conclusion, then, is this: a lie is the voluntary asserting of a falsehood. The more it tends toward injury of another, the more it is aggravated; but injuriousness and lying are two different things. When I say a falsehood, I mean something apt to deceive the hearer. It is therefore necessary to the being of a lie that it be deceitful, though the explicit purpose of deceiving is found only in the more flagrant sorts of lies. A thing is called false precisely from its power of deceiving: it would not be false if it were not deceitful, or apt to deceive. An inapt or figurative expression that carries a right sense as used by both speaker and hearer is no falsehood. In one language a double negative affirms; in another a double negative is a more emphatic form of denial; yet neither speaker ought to be charged by the other with speaking an untruth.
By asserting I mean any expression that makes the falsehood the speaker’s own, as distinct from historical narration. It is not lying to repeat a lie when one is merely reporting what another person said. By voluntary I mean not only what is done knowingly, with actual will, deliberate choice, or consent, but also what is done through the fault of the will and is properly imputed to it.
It is of great importance to observe, in regard to every sin, that while we truly say all sin is voluntary and extends no further than the will, "voluntary" here does not mean only what is actually and explicitly willed. It includes everything the will is guilty of. Augustine rightly says that "the tongue is not made guilty except by a guilty mind." But we must understand that the mind and will are guilty of forbidden omissions as well as actions. It is therefore a lie, a voluntary untruth, when the mind and will fail to restrain the tongue as they ought.
1. When a person errs or remains ignorant through wilful sloth or negligence, and so speaks falsely while believing it true: this is a culpable falsehood, and so a lie, because he could have avoided it and did not. This is the condition of most false teachers and heretics. Similarly, if someone lets his tongue race ahead of his judgment through passion, habit, or carelessness, speaking falsely because he never stops to consider or heed what he is saying, that too is a culpable untruth and a lie, and it is voluntary, because the will should have prevented it and did not, even though there was no purpose to deceive.
There are therefore two degrees of lying. 1. The grossest is speaking a known falsehood with a purpose to deceive. 2. The other is speaking falsely through culpable ignorance, error, or thoughtlessness.
Direction 1. Be well informed of the evil of the sin of lying. The common cause of lying is that people think there is no great harm in it unless someone is seriously wronged. But God does not forbid it only because it wrongs others. It has all the following evil in it.
1. Lying perverts the noble faculties of humanity, turning them entirely contrary to their natural purpose. God gave us a tongue to express our minds and reveal the truth; lying monstrously turns it to obstruct both mind and truth, and indeed to vent the contrary of both. Just as drunkenness is the evil of corrupting so noble a faculty as reason into a kind of voluntary madness, so lying corrupts, perverts, and deforms both mind and tongue, and by that confusion destroys God’s work and creature as to its proper use. Augustine, in the Enchiridion, puts it this way: words were instituted not so that people might deceive one another by them, but so that each person might bring his thoughts to the knowledge of another. To use words for deception rather than for the purpose for which they were instituted is, therefore, sin.
2. Lying is the enemy and destroyer of truth, and truth is something divine, of unspeakable excellence and usefulness. Truth is God’s instrument by which he makes humanity wise, good, and happy. Were he not to make strict laws for the preservation of so excellent a thing, he would fail to secure the happiness of the world.
Consider the analogy: to secure men’s lives it is not enough to make a law that says you shall not kill without just cause, though that is all the law intends to prevent, because if every man were left to judge for himself, passion and self-interest would always seem to him just cause. The law must therefore say, "You shall not kill at all without the magistrate’s judgment." Similarly, even if the law against lying intended no more than protecting people from the injuries of error and deceit, it would not have been sufficient to say merely, "You shall not injure men by lying," for men would then judge the injury by their own interests and passions. Still more necessary is a stricter law when truth itself is what God intends to secure, alongside the interests of men.
In the eyes of Christians, heathens, and all mankind who have not forfeited their humanity, truth displays a singular beauty and excellence. Aristotle said that "the nature of man is made for truth." Cicero said that "what is true, simple, and sincere is most suited to the nature of man." Veracity and virtue were always regarded as the inseparable perfections of humanity.
Pythagoras said that to love truth and do good were the two things that made humanity most like God, and therefore his two most excellent gifts. Plato said that truth was the best rhetoric and sweetest oration. Epictetus said that truth is immortal and eternal, the most precious of all things, better than friendship because it is less liable to blind affection. Jamblichus said that as light naturally and constantly accompanies the sun, so truth accompanies God and all who follow him. Epaminondas is praised for refusing to lie even in jest. Pomponius Atticus was so great a hater of lies that all his friends were eager to entrust their affairs to him and use him as their counsellor.
No one who does not know the excellence of truth knows what humanity’s understanding and tongue were made for. Every lie is evil and to be avoided, as Aristotle teaches (Ethics, book 4). See also (Ps 5:7; Prov 6:17, 19; Prov 12:22; Prov 19:5, 9; Prov 21:18; Rev 21:27; Rev 22:15; John 8:44; Col 3:9).
Let only a Pilate ask as a stranger "what is truth?" (John 18:38), as Pharaoh asked "who is the Lord?" For "this end Christ himself came into the world to bear witness to the truth, and every one that is of the truth will hear him." (John 18:37) "He is the truth," (John 14:6) and "full of grace and truth." (John 1:14) "Grace and truth came by him." (John 1:17)
His Spirit is given to "guide his servants into the truth," (John 16:13) and to "sanctify them by the truth," (John 17:19) that "knowing the truth, it might make them free." (John 8:32) "The fruit of the Spirit is in all truth." (Eph 5:9) His ministers can "do nothing against the truth, but for the truth." (2 Cor 13:8) "Truth" is the "girdle" that must "gird our loins." (Eph 6:14) The "church" is the "pillar and ground of truth." (1 Tim 3:15) The faithful are "they that believe and know the truth." (1 Tim 4:3) "Speaking the truth in love" is the way of the church’s growth and edification. (Eph 4:15)
"Repentance" is given to men "to the acknowledging of the truth, that they may escape out of the power of the devil." (2 Tim 2:25–26) The dullards are those "never able to come to the knowledge of the truth." (2 Tim 3:7) "They are men of perverse minds that resist the truth." (2 Tim 3:8) "They that receive not the truth in the love of it cannot be saved." (2 Thess 2:10) All they "are damned that believe not the truth." (2 Thess 2:12–13)
You see then what truth is in the judgment of God and all the sober world. A lie, which stands contrary to truth as darkness to light, must be equally odious as truth is lovely. No wonder, then, that it is absolutely forbidden by God.
3. This may be seen more easily by noting that other faults of the tongue, idle talk, swearing, and the like, are forbidden not only because they harm others, but because of the evil intrinsic to the acts themselves. All the more reason, then, that this should hold for lying.
4. Lying is a vice that makes us most unlike God.
He is called the "God of truth," (Ps 31:5; Deut 32:4) all his "ways" are "mercy and truth," (Ps 25:10) his "judgment is according to truth," (Rom 2:2) "it is impossible for God to lie," (Heb 6:18; Titus 1:2) and his word is the "word of truth." (Ps 119:43; Col 1:5; 2 Tim 2:15; Jas 1:18; 2 Cor 6:7) And who shall "dwell in his tabernacle," but those who "speak the truth in their hearts"? (Ps 15:2)
The soul’s disconformity to God is its greatest deformity, especially in those very things in which it was made to be conformed to him. From this it is plain that lying is a deeply odious sin. This becomes still clearer when you consider what the world’s condition would be if God could lie and were not of undoubted truth: we should then be certain of nothing, and could have no sure knowledge by his word, no sure direction and guidance by his precepts, and no sure consolation in any of his promises. Whatever makes us most unlike the true and holy God must therefore be odious.
5. Lying bears the image and character of the devil, and liars are his children in a distinctive sense. Christ tells us that the devil "abode not in the truth, for there is no truth in him: when he speaketh a lie he speaketh of his own: for he is a liar, and the father of it" (John 8:44). The proud, the malicious, and the liars are in a special sense the children of the devil, for Scripture makes these three in a special manner the devil’s own sins, as when the spirit says, "I will be a lying spirit in the mouths of all his prophets" (1 Kgs 22:22–23; 2 Chr 18:21–22).
Surely, then, there is an intrinsic evil and odiousness in a lie. It was Satan who filled the hearts of Ananias and Sapphira to lie to the Holy Ghost (Acts 5:3). To change the "truth of God into a lie," and "to make God a liar," are therefore the most odious sins (Rom 1:25; 1 John 5:10), because they are a feigning God to be like the devil. Should we then make ourselves like the devil by the same vice? If you have no love for the devil’s sin and image, have no love for a lie.
6. Lying destroys human society and brings the most pernicious confusion into the affairs of mankind. Without truth, men cannot buy, sell, trade, or live together. It would be enough to destroy rational society if people had no tongues at all; but to have false tongues is far worse. Silence simply fails to open the mind; lying pretends to open it while misrepresenting it entirely.
You may say that your lies do no such great harm; yet since this destruction is the very nature and tendency of lying as such, it is both just and merciful for the righteous God to prohibit all lying by the strictest laws. Just as the whole nature of serpents is so contrary to the nature of man that we hate and kill them even when they have never harmed us, because it is in their nature to harm us, so God has justly and mercifully condemned all lying, because its nature tends toward the desolation and ruin of the world. If any indulgence were given to it, all iniquity and injustice would at once, like a flood, overwhelm us.
One of the Roman Twelve Tables stipulated that anyone convicted of bearing false testimony should be cast from the Tarpeian Rock.
7. Lying tends directly toward perjury itself. The same God forbids them both; and when a heart is hardened in the one, it is only a step further to the other. Even Cicero could observe that one who is accustomed to lying will easily become a perjurer. A seared conscience that tolerates the one will easily be brought to bear the other.
8. The liar displays a moral inconsistency that condemns himself: he condemns the sin in others while justifying it in himself, since no man wishes others to lie to him. As Augustine says, "I have known many that would deceive, but never any that would be deceived." If lying is good, why should not others lie to you? If it is bad, why will you lie to others? Is your tongue under a different law from theirs? Do you approve of it in your children and servants? If not, it should seem far worse to you in yourself, since you are most responsible for your own actions.
Augustine further observes that men both deceive and are deceived, yet are more wretched when they deceive through lying than when they are deceived by believing a lie. The rational nature recoils so strongly from falsehood, and shuns error as far as it can, that even those who love to deceive have no wish to be deceived themselves (Enchiridion, c. 17).
9. Judge what lying is by your own desire and expectation to be believed. Do you not want people to believe you, whether you speak truth or not? You plainly do: the liar defeats his own purpose the moment he is known to lie and goes unbelieved. But is it a reasonable desire or expectation to be believed when you speak a lie? If you wish to be believed, speak what is worthy of belief.
10. Lying makes you permanently incredible, and so useless and dangerous to others. A person who will lie leaves others perpetually uncertain whether he ever speaks the truth, since there is no better evidence of his truthfulness than his credibility, and that is gone. As Aristotle says, "A liar gets this by lying, that nobody will believe him when he speaks the truth." How is anyone to know that a person speaks truth today who lied yesterday, unless open repentance has restored his credibility? Truth defends itself and vindicates the one who holds to it in the end; but falsehood cannot be defended, and will shame those who champion it.
Petrarch puts it well: "As truth is immortal, so a fiction and lie endureth not long: dissembled matters are quickly opened: as the hair that is combed and set with great diligence is ruffled with a little blast of wind: and the paint that is laid on the face with a deal of labour, is washed off with a little sweat: the craftiest lie cannot stand before the truth; but is transparent to him that nearly looketh into it; every thing that is covered is soon uncovered: shadows pass away; and the native colour of things remaineth: it is a great labour to keep hidden long. No man can live long under water: he must needs come forth, and shew the face which he concealed." (De Vita Solitaria, Book 1.) And at the last, God at the day of judgment will lay open all.
Direction 2. If you would avoid lying, take heed of guilt. Cicero observed that for those who often do wrong, lying is the readiest resource. An unclean body needs a covering and is most ashamed to be seen. Guilt causes lying, and lying deepens the guilt. When people have done what they fear or are ashamed to have known, they feel compelled to deploy their ingenuity to keep it secret. But cleverness and craft are a poor substitute for honesty: such patches only widen the tear. Since the corrupted heart of man will work in this way and reach for deceitful shifts, prevent the cause and occasion of your lying. Do not commit the fault that requires a lie. Avoiding the fault is far better than hiding it, even if you could hide it perfectly, which, in fact, you cannot, since truth commonly comes to light.
The best way in the world to avoid lying is to be innocent, and to do nothing that fears the light: truth and honesty do not blush or wish to hide. Children and servants are particularly prone to this fault: when folly, wantonness, appetite, slothfulness, or carelessness has made them faulty, they immediately devise a lie to cover it, which is to go to the devil and ask him to defend his own works. But wise, obedient, careful, diligent, and conscientious children and servants have no need of such wretched stratagems.
Direction 3. Fear God more than man, if you would not be liars. Excessive fear of man is a common cause of lying. It makes children so ready to lie to escape punishment, and most people who are exposed to harm from others are in danger of lying to avoid their displeasure. But why do you not fear God more, whose displeasure is immeasurably more terrible? Your parents or master will be angry and threaten to correct you; but God threatens to damn you, and his wrath is a consuming fire. No human displeasure can reach your soul or extend to eternity. Will you run into hell to escape punishment on earth? Remember, whenever you are tempted to escape some danger by a lie, that you are running into a thousandfold greater danger, and that no harm you escape by lying can possibly be half as great as the harm that lying brings. It is as foolish as curing a toothache by cutting off the head.
The defender of truth must be one who, when he thinks rightly, does not fear to speak, nor blush to do so (Ambrose). As Montaigne’s Essays observe: liars are bold against God and cowards against men.
Direction 4. Bring down your pride and excessive regard for the opinions of men, if you would not be liars. Pride makes men so hungry for reputation, and so impatient of others’ poor opinion of them, that all their honest efforts are not enough to secure the standing they crave, and so lying must make up the difference. Shame is so unbearable a suffering to the proud that they make lies the habitual cover of their nakedness.
A man who lacks wealth but has pride will embellish his estate with a lie. A man who lacks eminence of parentage and birth, if he is proud, will make himself a gentleman by a lie. A man who is a nobody at home, if proud, will make himself a person of consequence among strangers by a lie. A man who lacks learning, degrees, or anything else he would take pride in, will try by a lie to supply the deficiency, just as wanton women by the actual lie of painting would make themselves beautiful, out of a proud desire to be esteemed.
Most of all, the man who has committed some shameful crime, if he is proud, will rather venture on a lie than endure the shame. But if your pride is cured, your temptation to lie becomes negligible: you will be so unconcerned about honor and reputation that you will not risk your soul and God’s displeasure for it. This is not to say anyone should be shameless or entirely indifferent to reputation; but no one should overvalue it, prefer it above their soul, or seek it by unlawful means. Avoid shame by doing well, and do so freely, only be sure you have a higher motive than shame alone.
Seneca says, "There are more that abstain from sin through shame, than through virtue or a good will." It is well when virtue is so highly regarded, and vice so deeply discredited, that those without the virtue would gladly have the name, and those who will not abandon the vice would at least escape the shame. It is well that there are human motives to restrain those who care nothing for divine ones. Yet as human motives produce no saving virtues, so wicked and devilish means are far from preventing any pernicious harm; they are, in fact, the surest means of bringing it on.
Avoid both the extremes that Petrarch mentions: just as many have been found who feigned themselves good, so some have been found who feigned themselves bad, doing so to escape either the pestilent breath of human favor or the hated burden of worldly goods, as is recorded of Ambrose. And Seneca asks how like friendship flattery is: it does not merely imitate friendship but outdoes it, making itself welcome by the very act with which it wounds.
Direction 5. Avoid ambition and unnecessary human dependence if you would avoid lying. The ambitious surrender themselves to other people, and so flattery becomes their trade. How much lying is woven into flattery requires no explanation. Truth is seldom chosen as the instrument of flattery; on the contrary, it commonly leads to hatred. As Ambrose says: "Those who preach truth freely and without flattery, and reprove the deeds of a wicked life, find no favor with men." And as Jerome says on Galatians 4, enmity always pursues truth.
Hatred is the shadow of truth, as envy is the shadow of happiness. When Aristippus was asked why Dionysius spoke so harshly against him, he answered, "for the same reason that all other men do," implying that it was no wonder a tyrant could not endure truth and plain dealing, when this is the condition of almost all humanity. People are so guilty that everyone except flatterers seems to press too hard on their wounds.
This is much of the misery of great men: few or none deal honestly with them, and they are flattered into ruin. Seneca says: "One thing rich men lack when they have everything else, someone to speak the truth. For if you become the dependent or client of prosperous or powerful men, you must give up either the truth or their friendship." Cicero adds that a man whose ears are so closed to truth that he cannot bear to hear it from a friend is past all hope of recovery. Athenaeus observes that nobody loves a flatterer who has grown grey at the trade, and that the very stuff of flattery goes stale with time; and Seneca warns that when a bad man speaks you fair you should recognize him for the snare he is, since flattering speech carries its own poison.
Jerome thought that this was why Christ had no house to lay his head in: he would flatter nobody, and so nobody in the city would take him in. And worst of all, where flattery reigns it is taken for a duty and the neglect of it for a vice. As Jerome writes to Celantia: "and, which is most grievous, because it goes for humility and kindness, it comes to pass that he who cannot flatter is taken to be envious or proud."
Yet the flatterer will in the end be hated even by the person whose ears his false praises once pleased. Deceit and lies satisfy the flattered person only for a time, until he feels the bitterness of the effects, and the fruit shows him it was only a sugared form of enmity. Flattery always reveals itself at last to be, as Augustine calls it, a "pernicious sweetness." Augustine also says, in his exposition of Psalm 59: "There are two kinds of persecutors: the opposer and the flatterer, but the tongue of the flatterer does more harm than the hand of the persecutor."
Do not think that any person’s greatness or favor will excuse you or keep you safe in your lies, for the God who avenges them is greater than the greatest. As Augustine writes: "Whoever thinks that there is any kind of lie that is no sin deceives himself shamefully, while imagining himself an honest deceiver of others." "Be not the servants of men," if you would be truthful. (1 Cor 7:23)
Direction 6. Do not love covetousness, if you would not be a liar. A lie appears to the covetous man as an easy means to secure his profit, strike a good bargain, or pass off damaged goods for more than they are worth. As Seneca says in Hippolytus: "Impious greed for gain and headlong anger shatter all covenants." The person who loves money more than God and conscience will, for money’s sake, displease God and conscience, by this sin or any other. (Prov 21:6)
Direction 7. Learn to trust God, if you would not be a liar. Lying is the practice of the person who believes he must fend for himself by his own schemes. Even Abraham’s and Isaac’s evasion in calling their wives their sisters, and David’s feigning madness, sprang from some distrust in God: they would not have thought it necessary to shift for their lives in that way if they had fully committed their lives to God. Gehazi’s covetousness and his lying both arose from a lack of confidence in God. If a man were truly confident of God’s protection, convinced that he is better served by leaving all things to God’s choice than to his own, what use could he imagine for lying, or for any sinful contrivance? (Jer 7:4, 8)
Direction 8. Do not be too quick to believe bad reports, if you would not be a liar. Malice is so reckless and unconscionable a sin, and the tongues of men are so habitually careless, that if you readily believe evil reports, you are readily believing the devil, and making yourself his servant in spreading malicious lies. You may think: "Because many say it, and say it confidently, I may lawfully believe and report it." But this is only to think that the number of liars, and their malice and impudence, warrant you to follow them, because they are so bad.
Will you bark and bite because dogs do so? If a man is stung by an adder, you should help cure him, not desire to sting him yourself. Selfish, self-seeking, malicious, partial, and factious persons are so commonly liars, and so impudent in their lies, that you must, if you would not be a liar yourself, take care before repeating anything they say. Cicero observed that he was not accustomed to make rash assertions about others, because it is dangerous, given the hidden motives and complex natures of human beings. These spiders will weave a web out of thin air or out of their own bowels. (Prov 17:4; Hos 7:3; Nah 3:1)
Direction 9. Do not be rash in saying things before you have examined them. Consider what you are saying, and know before you speak. Is it not shameful, when you have spoken falsely, to fall back on saying, "I thought it was true"? But why will you speak on mere thought, rather than waiting until you better understand the matter? If the case truly demanded haste, you should have said no more than, "I think it is so." "Prove all things," and then "hold that which is good," and assert only what is true. Cicero says: "Nothing is more unseemly than temerity, nor is anything so unworthy of the gravity and constancy of a wise man as either to hold a falsehood, or confidently to defend what has not been sufficiently examined and established." He says the same elsewhere: "Temerity is conspicuous when a false or unknown thing is affirmed; and nothing is more disgraceful than for assertion and approval to outrun knowledge."
Direction 10. Foresee what is likely to trap you in a lie, so that you may prevent it. Do not let occasion and temptation overtake you unprepared. Foresight will make a temptation easy to overcome that, coming upon you unawares, would be too strong for you.
Direction 11. Cultivate a tender conscience, and walk as in the sight and hearing of God, as one who is approaching his judgment. A seared conscience will venture upon lies or anything else; but the fear of God is the soul’s preservative. What makes men lie, but thinking they deal only with other men? They suppose that by a lie they can deceive a fellow human being and conceal the truth. But if they remembered that they have most to do with God, that he is always present and cannot be deceived, that his judgment will bring all hidden things to light and expose all their lies before the whole world, they would not hire a torn and filthy cloak at so dear a price, for so short a time. No wonder men are liars who neither fear God nor believe in the day of judgment. (Acts 5:4; Isa 59:13; Ezek 13:9, 19)
Direction 12. To save others from lying as well as yourselves, be sure to watch against it in your children, and wisely help them to see the evil of it. For children are very prone to lying; and unwise correction frightens them into lies to save themselves, just as indulgence and connivance encourage them in it. Make them often read such texts as these.
"Ye shall not steal, nor deal falsely, nor lie one to another" (Lev 19:11); "He that speaketh the truth from his heart, etc." (Ps 15:2); "He said, surely they are my people; children that will not lie; so he was their Saviour" (Isa 63:8); "The devil is a liar and the father of it" (John 8:44); "There shall in no wise enter into it any thing that defileth … or maketh a lie" (Rev 21:27); "For without are dogs … and whosoever loveth and maketh a lie" (Rev 22:15); "The mouth of him that speaketh lies shall be stopped" (Ps 63:11); "He that speaketh lies shall not tarry in my sight" (Ps 101:7).
"A false witness shall not be unpunished, and he that speaketh lies shall not escape (shall perish)" (Prov 19:5, 9); "If a ruler hearken to lies, all his servants are wicked" (Prov 29:12; see also Ps 31:18; Ps 52:3); "I hate and abhor lying, but thy law do I love" (Ps 119:163); "A righteous man hateth lying" (Prov 13:5); "Wherefore putting away lying, speak every man truth with his neighbour, for we are members one of another" (Eph 4:25).
The meaning of that last text is: a man would not lie to deceive his own bodily members; no more should we lie to deceive one another. In a word, where love of God and neighbor prevails, truth prevails; but where self-love, partiality, and carnal self-interest prevail, lying becomes a household servant and is thought a necessary means to those ends.
Because lying is so common, so grave a sin, and cases about it arise daily, I shall now address some of those cases distinctly, even though I believe what has already been said contains material enough to answer them, in order to help those who cannot readily apply general answers to their particular situations.
Question 1: Is frequent, known lying a certain sign of a graceless state, that is, a mortal sin, proving the sinner to be in a state of damnation?
Answer: The difficulty of this case concerns lying no more than it concerns any other sin of equal malignity. I must therefore refer you to those places where I have explained the difference between mortal, reigning sins and mere infirmities. For now, take this brief resolution.
1. It is extremely difficult to determine exactly how many acts of a grave sin may coexist with a present state of grace, that is, a covenant right to heaven.
2. The only sin that can coexist with a state of spiritual life is sin that coexists with a habitual, predominant love of God and holiness; no other kind can.
3. A person who seldom or never commits such outward crimes, and yet does not love God, heaven, and holiness above all the pleasures and interests of the flesh, is in a state of spiritual death.
4. It is certain that love for God and holiness is not predominant in someone whose carnal interest and lust ordinarily has more power, in the general drift and tenor of his life, to draw him to the willful commission of known sin than that love has to keep him from it. For we are servants of whatever we obey, whether it be sin leading to death or obedience leading to righteousness.
5. Therefore the way to know whether sin is mortified or mortal is: (1) by feeling the true bent of the will, whether we love or hate the sin; (2) by observing the true bent and tenor of our lives, whether God’s interest in us or the contrary is predominant when we are composed and tempted to such sins.
6. Anyone who sins in this way as often as he supposes saving grace will permit will never have assurance of his sincerity, or the peace and comfort of a sound believer, until he repents and leads a better life.
7. A person who, even in sin, retains the spirit of adoption, the image of God, or habitual divine love, also retains habitual and virtual repentance for that very sin before he actually repents, because he has that habitual hatred of it which will produce actual repentance when he is composed to act according to his predominant habits.
8. In the meantime, the state of such a sinner is neither to be unregenerate, carnal, and unholy as he was before conversion (and so to forfeit all his right to life), nor yet to have as full a right as if he had not sinned. Rather, a bar is placed against his claim, which must be removed before his right is complete and ripe for present possession.
9. There are some sins in which all people continue while they live, such as deficiency in the degrees of faith, hope, love, and so on; vain thoughts, words, disorder, unruly passions, and the like. These sins are not entirely involuntary; otherwise they would not be sins at all. Indeed, the evil prevails in the will against the good to the extent of committing those sins, though not to the extent of corrupting the overall bent of heart or life.
10. There are some sins of which no one on earth actually repents: namely, those they do not know to be sins; those they have entirely forgotten; and the faults they are guilty of at the very moment of dying.
11. In these cases, virtual, implicit, or habitual repentance is sufficient to prevent damnation. Likewise, a will to have lived perfectly suffices in the case of continued imperfections.
12. Things work on the will not as they are in themselves, but as they are perceived by the understanding. Whatever is perceived to be either of doubtful evil, or only a small sin of little danger, will be resisted far less and committed far more often than sins clearly perceived to be grave. Therefore, wherever any kind of lie is perceived in this way, as of small or doubtful evil, it will be committed the more frequently.
13. If this perception is wrong and arises from the predominance of a carnal or ungodly heart, which will not allow the understanding to do its proper work or to recognize as evil what the person is unwilling to abandon, then both the judgment and the lie are mortal sins, not mortified and pardoned ones.
14. But if this misperception of the understanding arises from natural weakness, or unavoidable lack of better instruction, or only from the fault of a vicious inclination that is nevertheless not predominant but is the remnant of a vice already mortified in the main, then neither the error nor the frequent lying is a mortal sin, but a mortified one. For instance, if false teachers (such as the Jesuits) should persuade a justified person that an officious lie that hurts no one is only a venial sin or no sin at all, it is possible for such a person to commit it frequently, though he does not err altogether innocently.
15. Although it is true that all good Christians should not indulge even the smallest sin, and that true grace will make a person willing to forsake even the least, yet certain experience tells us that some constant sinning (of the kinds named above) does coexist with grace in all who possess it on earth. Consequently, lesser sins, such as vain thoughts and unruly passions, are not resisted as strenuously as greater ones, and are therefore more readily indulged and favored; otherwise they would not be committed. No godly person rises up with as great and constant watchfulness against an idle thought or word, or a disordered prayer, as he does against a heinous sin.
Anyone who wants all such cases resolved in a single word, without being required to test the case by all these distinctions, must go to another casuist, or rather to a deceiver instead of a resolver, for I cannot otherwise resolve him.
Question 2: Is it not contrary to the light of nature to allow a parent, a king, oneself, or one’s country to be destroyed rather than to save them by a harmless lie?
Answer: No. Because:
1. Particular good must yield to the common good. And if once a lie may pass as lawful in cases where it appears to produce good, it will overthrow human communication and debauch human nature and the world.
2. If one evil may be made a means to good, the same logic will justify other evils as means to good, and so will confound good and evil, leaving a vicious person free to regard as good whatever he thinks will produce good. A lie that is simply evil, being against the law of God, against the order of nature, against the proper use of human faculties, and against the interests and social intercourse of mankind, is not to be called harmless.
3. The error of those who raise these objections consists mainly in thinking that nothing is further harmful and morally evil than what causes bodily harm to some person. But in fact that is evil which is against the universal rule of right, against the will of God, and against the nature and perfection of the one who acts, all the more so when it also tends to harm other people’s souls by setting them an example of sinning.
4. And though there may sometimes be some human likelihood of such a thing, there is no certainty that a lie will ever so fall out as to save the life of a king, a parent, or yourself. God can open the eyes of the very enemy you thought to blind by a lie, and cause him to know the whole truth, and so take the life you imagined you had thus saved.
5. And there are lawful means enough to save your life when it is truly best that it be saved. Obey God and trust him with your life; he can save it without a lie if that is best, and if it is not best, it should not be desired.
6. If people did not overvalue life through error, they would not think a lie necessary to preserve it. When it is not necessary to live, it is not necessary to lie for life. But one sin brings on another: when carnal men overvalue life itself and prize it above enjoying God in the glory of heaven, they must then overvalue any means that seems necessary to preserve it. (Job 13:7–10; Prov 13:17; Rom 6:15; Rom 3:7–9; Ps 5:7; Hos 4:2; John 8:44; Rev 21:27; Rev 22:15; Col 3:9; 1 John 2:21)
7. Yet as to the degree of evil in the sin, I readily grant, with Augustine (Enchiridion), that "It matters greatly with what intention and about what matters a person lies; for the one who lies with intent to help does not sin in the same way as the one who lies with intent to harm; and the one who sends a traveler astray by a lie does not do as much harm as the one who corrupts the way of life by a deceiving falsehood."
Objection: Are not the midwives rewarded by God for saving the Israelitish children by a lie?
Answer: I need not follow Augustine in saying "the deed was rewarded and the lie pardoned," because no lie is actually found in the midwives’ conduct. Who can doubt that God could strengthen the Israelitish women to deliver without the midwives? And who can doubt that once the midwives had made the king’s murderous command known, the women would delay sending for them until, with each other’s help, the children were secured, which is still attributed to the midwives because they confederated in this and delayed to that end? There is dissembling and the concealing of part of the truth here, but no lie that can be proved.
Objection: But Hebrews 11:31 and James 2:25 say that Rahab was justified by faith and works when she saved the spies by a lie.
Answer: It is uncertain whether her words were a lie or only an equivocation, or whether they were not in fact true of some other men who had been her guests. But suppose them to be a lie, as seems most likely: Scripture no more justifies her lie than it justifies her having been a harlot. What she is commended for is her faith in the God of Israel, whose works she acknowledged, together with her saving of the spies at the risk of her own life. And it is no wonder if such a woman in Jericho had not yet learned the sinfulness of such a lie.
Objection: But at least it could be no mortal sin, because Hebrews 11:31 and James 2:25 say she was justified.
Answer: It was no mortal sin in her, that is, a sin which proves one to be in a state of spiritual death, because it lacked the specific evils that make a sin mortal. But a lie told knowingly, out of a lack of that predominant authority and love of God in the soul which should habitually prevail against contrary motives, is a mortal sin in an ungodly person. It is a pernicious falsehood and a delusion of souls when teachers lead poor sinners to think that what makes a sin venial rather than mortal is merely the smallness of the outward act or the outward harm alone.
Question 3: Is deception by action lawful, when it amounts to a practical lie? And how are we to interpret Christ’s acting as though he would have gone farther (Luke 24:28), or David’s feigning himself mad, or common stratagems in war, or doing things purposely to deceive another?
Answer:
1. I have already shown that not all deceiving of another is a sin; some may even be a duty. A physician may deceive a patient to get a medicine down and save his life, provided he does not do it by a lie.
2. Christ’s seeming to go farther was nothing other than a lawful concealment or disguising of his purpose, in order to draw out their earnest request. Not all dissimulation is evil, though lying always is. The same can be said of lawful stratagems as such.
3. David’s case was not sinful simply as dissimulation to deceive his enemies for the sake of escape. Whether it also involved sinful distrust of God, or a dissimulation carried out by too unmanly a means, I cannot determine without knowing more of the circumstances.
Question 4: Is it lawful to tempt a child or servant to lie merely to test them?
Answer: It is not lawful to do so without sufficient cause, nor ever to do anything that invites them to lie or lends any approval to the sin, as Satan and wicked people do when they tempt others to sin by commending it or minimizing it. But to place an occasion before them purely to test them, such as leaving money, wine, or other things in their way, in order to know whether they are thieves or given to drink, so as to know better how to cure them; and similarly to test their honesty, is not unlawful, for these reasons:
1.) The sin is virtually committed when there is the will to commit it, even if there is no temptation or opportunity.
2.) We do nothing that either commends the sin or persuades toward it; we are not any true physical or moral cause of it, but only an occasion.
3.) God himself, who is more opposed to sin than any creature, does by way of trial administer such occasions of sin to viciously disposed people as he knows they will take; and his common mercies are such occasions.
4.) God has nowhere forbidden this to us. We may not do evil that good may come of it; but we may do good even when we know that evil will result from it through people’s own vice.
5.) It may be a necessary means to the cure of a sin that cannot be known until it is brought to light in this way.
Question 5: Is all equivocation unlawful?
Answer: There is an equivocating that is really lying: when we abandon the usual or proper sense of a word and use it in an alien, unusual sense that we know will not be understood, and do so in order to deceive those whom we are bound not to deceive.
But there is also a use of equivocal words that is lawful and necessary, for human language has few words that do not carry more than one meaning, in these cases:
1.) When our equivocal sense is well understood by the hearers, and we use it not to deceive them but because common usage has made such words fitting; all metaphors are equivocal, and yet may rightly be used.
2.) When the equivocal sense is the most usual or obvious one, and if it is not understood, that is due to the hearer’s own fault or exceptional dullness.
3.) When a robber, a usurping tyrant, or any cruel enemy who has no authority to do so seeks to ensnare my life by questions, I may lawfully answer in words purposely intended to deceive him or leave him ignorant of my meaning, provided those words are not lies or false in their ordinary usage.
4.) To such a person I may also answer ambiguously when it is apparent that it is an ambiguous answer, and that I am making clear by doing so that I will answer him no more particularly or plainly, but will conceal the rest.
Question 6: Is all mental reservation unlawful?
Answer: This requires no different answer from the one above. If the words actually spoken are a lie, no mental reservation will make them justifiable as truth. But if the expressed words are in themselves true, then mental reservation may be lawful, when it amounts to no more than concealing part of the truth in a case where we are not bound to reveal it.
But for both of these cases I must refer the reader to what I have said about vows in Part III, Chapter V, Title 2, without which my meaning here will not be clear.
Question 7: May children, servants, or subjects who are in danger use words that tend to hide their faults?
Answer:
1. When they are bound not to hide the fault, they may not. This obligation arises when either due obedience, or the greater good that would follow, requires them to disclose it.
2. When they are not bound to disclose it, they may hide it by just means, but not by lies or any other evil. I will say no more here about which cases allow a fault to be concealed by just means.
Question 8: May I say something I believe to be true but am not certain of?
Answer: If you have a proper occasion to speak, you may say that you think it is true; but you may not state flatly that it is so.
Question 9: May I believe and repeat what I hear reported of another, as news, conversation, or character, when the report comes from godly, credible persons, or from many sources?
Answer:
1. The main question is whether you have a proper occasion to speak at all, which is addressed at length later, in Part IV.
2. You must not believe and repeat evil reports of another as readily as you would good ones.
3. You must not believe ill of another any further than the evidence compels you to. You may, however, believe it in proportion to the degree of evidence or credibility, and make use of the report for reasonable caution or for good ends, but not to defame another on uncertain grounds or without a proper occasion.
4. The sin of receiving and spreading false reports of others on hearsay is now so common among those who profess sobriety and religion, that everyone should guard against it in all company, as they would guard against the plague in a time of infection. Since it is now so notorious that false news and slander are widespread, neither the words of good men nor common reputation will justify you, or excuse you, in believing or reporting evil of another, unless you are able to show it is your duty to do so. All Christians should join in lamenting and reproving this common, uncharitable sin.
CHAPTER 28
SPECIAL DIRECTIONS AGAINST IDLE TALK AND BABBLING
Direction 1. Understand well what idle talk is. Many take that to be vain which is not, and many do not take that to be vain which is. I will therefore explain this before going any further.
The judgment of infidels and impious men deserves little weight here.
1. Some of them think prayer is but vain words, because God already knows our wants and hearts (Job 22:2–3), and our service profits him nothing, as if he had told us to "seek him in vain" (Isa 45:19). These I have refuted elsewhere.
2. Others think frequent preaching vain, and say of Paul what the infidels said, "What will this babbler say?" (Acts 17:18); and they say with Pharaoh, "Let them not regard vain words" (Exod 5:9). But God says, "Set your hearts to all the words which I testify among you, for it is not a vain thing for you, because it is your life" (Deut 32:46–47).
3. Some carnal wretches call vain whatever in God’s service is spiritual, or beyond their understanding, or above the reach of a fleshly mind.
4. Some call vain whatever is long in preaching, discussion, writing, or prayer. Yet Christ spoke no vain words when he "prayed all night" (Luke 6:12). We are not commanded to pray in vain when we are told to "pray continually, instantly, and importunately" (1 Thess 5:17 Acts 6:4 Luke 18:1–2). Paul did not speak idly when he preached until midnight (Acts 20). Godliness is not vain, for it "is profitable to all things" (1 Tim 4:8). It is true that the wicked may make our preaching vain for their own salvation, but the word of God does not return empty. The oblations of the disobedient are vain (Isa 1:13), and "the prayer of the wicked is abominable to the Lord, but the prayer of the upright is his delight" (Prov 15:8).
5. Some think all preaching vain that covers what they already know, whereas they most need to hear those very things, lest they condemn themselves by sinning against their own knowledge (2 Pet 1:12–13 Rom 14:22).
6. Some think it vain if the same things are often preached on or repeated, though they have never received and obeyed them; or if the same words are often repeated in prayer, though the repetition comes not from emptiness or affectation but from fervency (Mark 14:39 Ps 136 Ps 119).
7. Unbelievers think our boasting in God is vain (2 Kgs 18:20 Isa 49:4–5).
8. Some malicious adversaries charge it on ministers as preaching in vain whenever the hearers are not converted (Heb 4:2 Gal 5:2 Gal 3:4 Gal 4:11 Isa 53:1).
On the other side, many who are godly are mistaken in thinking:
1. That all talk is vain which is not of absolute necessity to some great use and end (1 Kgs 18:27 Prov 29:9).
2. That all mirth and pleasant talk is vain. Yet the Holy Ghost says, "A merry heart doth good like a medicine, but a broken spirit drieth the bones" (Prov 17:22), and "A merry heart maketh a cheerful countenance; but by sorrow of the heart the spirit is broken" (Prov 15:13). King Abimelech saw Isaac sporting with Rebekah his wife (Gen 26:8), laughing, as the Hebrew has it, or playing, as the Chaldee, Samaritan, and Septuagint read it, or jesting, as the Syriac, Arabic, and Latin Vulgate render it.
Observe these qualifications, and your mirth and playful talk will not be idle.
1.) Let it be such, and so much, as is useful to maintain that cheerfulness of mind and liveliness of spirit which benefits your health and duty. If bodily recreations are lawful, then recreations of the tongue are lawful when they are fitted to that same end.
2.) Let your speech be savory, seasoned with salt, and not corrupt and rotten communication. Do not jest with filthiness or sin.
3.) Let it be harmless to others. Do not make yourselves merry with the sins or miseries of other men. Do not jest to their wrong.
4.) Let it be well timed, not when another frame of mind is more fitting, nor when graver and weightier talk should take its place.
5.) Let it be moderate and not excessive, neither wasting time for nothing, nor tending to habituate the speakers or hearers to levity, nor drawing them away from the things that should come first.
6.) See that all your mirth and speech is sanctified by a holy end, that your intent in it all is to whet your spirits and cheer and fit yourselves for the service of God, as you do in eating and drinking and everything else.
7.) Mix in, with careful reverence, some serious things, so that the end and use are not forgotten, and your mirth is not altogether as empty and fruitless as that of the unsanctified. Playful, pleasant, recreational talk is not vain, but lawful on these conditions.
8.) Remember always that the most holy and profitable talk must be the most pleasant to us. We must not, through weariness of it, turn aside to carnal mirth as though that were more desirable; we may turn only to natural, honest mirth as a necessary companion to refresh the spirits (Jas 5:13).
Idle or vain words, then, are such as are unprofitable and tend to do no good. As Gregory defines it in his Moralia, an idle word is one that lacks the purpose of just necessity or of pious benefit. I pass over here those idle words which are also worse than vain, mentioned earlier among the sins of the tongue. Idle words are of two kinds.
1.) Those that are simply such, tending to no good at all. These are always idle, and therefore always sinful.
2.) Those that are comparatively such, words about some small or inconsiderable good, spoken when you should be speaking of greater things. These are sometimes lawful in themselves, that is, when greater matters are not to be talked of. In its season it is lawful to speak about the saving of a penny, or a thread, or a pin; but out of season, when greater matters are in hand, this is merely idle, sinful talk.
There is also a great deal of difference between an occasional idle word and the babbling, prating custom by which idle speech becomes the daily practice of some loose-tongued persons, so that the greater part of the words of all their lives are merely vain.
The particular kinds of idle talk are scarcely to be numbered. Some of them are these.
1. When the tongue is like a vagrant beggar or a masterless dog that is never in the way and never out of the way, left to talk at random about any unprofitable matter that comes before it. Such people never lack matter to talk of. Everything they see or hear is the subject of their chat, and one word begets occasion and matter for another, without end.
2. Another sort of idle talk is the vain discourse, by word or writing, of some learned men who bestow an excessive multitude of words on some small, irrelevant thing, not to edify, but to show off their cleverness. Seneca rebukes this at length.
3. Another sort of idle talk is vain and immoderate disputing about the smaller circumstances of religion, or frequent talk about such unedifying things while greater matters should be discussed. "But avoid foolish questions, and genealogies, and contentions, and strivings about the law, for they are unprofitable and vain" (Titus 3:9).
"Now the end of the commandment is charity, out of a pure heart, and of a good conscience, and of faith unfeigned: from which some having swerved, have turned aside unto vain jangling, desiring to be teachers of the law, understanding neither what they say, nor whereof they affirm" (1 Tim 1:5–7). "O Timothy, keep that which is committed to thy trust, avoiding profane and vain babblings, and opposition of sciences falsely so called; which some professing, have erred concerning the faith" (1 Tim 6:20–21). "But shun profane and vain babblings; for they will increase unto more ungodliness" (2 Tim 2:16). "There are many unruly and vain talkers," and so on, in Titus 1:10–11.
4. Another sort of idle talk is the using of a needless multitude of words even about what is good and necessary in itself, but might better be opened more briefly. As Hugo said, there is a time when nothing should be spoken, and a time when something should be spoken, but never a time when everything should be spoken (Job 35:16).
Even in preaching or praying, words may be vain, and they are so when they are not suited to the matter and the hearers. Note that the same words which are necessary to one sort of hearer are vain to another. Ministers must therefore take heed to suit their manner of speech to their hearers, and hearers must take heed not to censure rashly as vain what is merely unnecessary for them or for such as they. There may be many ignorant persons present whom the preacher knows better than the critic does. The ignorant lose what is concisely uttered. They must have it at large, in many words, and often repeated, or else they do not understand it, or do not remember what they do understand.
But a real excess of words even about holy things must be avoided. "Be not rash with thy mouth, and let not thine heart be hasty to utter any thing before God: for God is in heaven, and thou upon earth; therefore let thy words be few: for a dream cometh through the multitude of business, and a fool’s voice is known by the multitude of words" (Eccl 5:2–3). The Spartans, as Erasmus records, banished an orator for saying that he could speak all day on any subject.
Two causes of idle words in prayer must be avoided.
1.) Emptiness and rashness.
2.) Affectation, which takes two forms.
a) An affectation of words, as if you should be heard for saying so many words over and over. So the Papists in their Jesus Psalter say over the name "Jesu" nine times together, and those nine times fifteen times over, besides all their repetitions of it in the petitions between; and so likewise in the titles of the blessed Virgin in her Litany. Hypocrites in all ages and religions have the same trifling way of devotion, as Christ shows of the very heathen who used this way: "But when ye pray, use not vain repetitions, as the heathen do: for they think that they shall be heard for their much speaking. Be ye not therefore like unto them" (Matt 6:7–8).
b) There is also an affectation of length that causes idle words in prayer, when men think it is to the honor of their abilities to spend so much time and speak so long together, or when their superstitious consciences in secret prayer tie them to hold on so long that they have neither matter nor affection to fill up the time. It is no wonder if that time is filled up with words that are far too guilty of vanity.
5. Another kind of idle talk is that which is purposely contrived to humour idle fancies, to entertain vicious minds, and to pass away men’s precious time. Such are the abundance of love-books, romances, plays and playbooks, volumes of vanity and hours full of studied vanity, and worse. Such too is much of the talk of feigned fools and jesters: vices which I can hardly express to be as odious as I find them.
6. Another sort is a custom of inordinate jesting. This vein or disposition is so strong in some that when they have a mind to vent a jest they cannot hold it in; out it must come, whatever it costs, however frivolous and vain it may be (Eph 5:4).
7. Another sort is foolish talk, which has not sense enough to make it edifying (Eph 5:4). And among idle talkers, how much of it is foolish! How weary it makes a man to hear the talk of many babblers! How insipid it is, how sottish, like the talk of a madman, or a drunken man, or a man in his sleep. It is far pleasanter to hear a bird chirp, or even a swine grunt, than to hear much of their talk (Prov 10:14 Prov 12:11 Prov 28:19 1 Pet 2:15 Prov 15:2 Prov 15:14).
Direction 2. Understand also the aggravations of idle words, which of them are the greatest sins, so that those may be most carefully avoided. Though all idle words are sins, not all are equally sinful. The worst are such as these that follow.
1. When idle words are frequent, multiplied, and made a person’s common talk and custom. This is the case of some men, but of a great many loquacious women, whose natural disposition inclines them to it. One who has but little intelligence, and much self-conceit, and much passion, will have a torrent of words for a drop of sense. Megabyzus, a great Persian lord, was told by Apelles that while he was silent they reverenced him for his gold and rich attire, but when he talked of what he did not understand, the boys in the shop laughed at him (Plutarch, On Tranquillity of Mind, page 154).
If they meet with anyone patient and idle enough to give them a hearing, they will sit a whole hour with you, yes, many hours, to tell you first how the affairs go between them and their husbands, or children, or servants; and then they talk of their cattle, house, or land; and then they tell you the news, and enter on a long discourse of other men’s matters, which they neither understand nor have anything to do with. Next they talk of the weather, and then of the market, what is cheap and what is dear.
Then they tell you what this body said to them and what the other body said; and then they tell you a story of the old times, and how the world is changed, and how much better the former times were than these. Then they tell you what wrong such a one did them, and what he said of them, and how bad this or that man is, and what they said or did amiss, and what the report of the country is of such and such. Then they tell you what clothes such a one wears, and how fine and gallant such a one is, and who keeps a good house, and who is niggardly and sparing.
Then they tell you what food was served at such and such a table or feast; and if they are at dinner, they have something to say about every dish and every sort of food or drink. News especially takes up much of their talk (Ezek 33:30).
And it is well if in all this the preacher’s sermon, or his prayer, or his life is not brought in to fill up the empty places of the talk; and it may be that the King and his council, and his laws, and his doings will be defiled by these parrots’ irreverent prattling, as well as lesser things and persons. As Theophrastus says, "He that would not fall into a fever, let him run from them with all the haste he can." I would sooner say it threatens the scurvy, if weariness is as sure a symptom of it as they say.
A man who has nothing to do in this world, nor anything to do for the world to come; who has no use for his time, or mind, or tongue, or hands, but wakes as he sleeps and lives as he must lie when he is dead; who has neither master, work, nor wages, but thinks he was made to see leaves wag and hear flies buzz: let him choose such a companion, and let him sit and hear such people chat. For my part, I can more easily endure to have them call me morose, or proud, or uncivil, or anything else; indeed I would rather be digging, or ploughing, or clearing ditches than endure the tediousness of their talk.
Sidonius Apollinaris, in his description of King Theodoric, says that at his feasts the greatest weight lay in the words, since there either nothing was told, or only serious things.
Theophrastus also observed that it is hard to hold out with those who cannot distinguish times of leisure from times of business.
Dionysius sent a man to be put to death for finding fault with his poetry, but called him back to try him once more; and the man rose up in the middle of the recitation, saying, "Come, let me go to the gibbet," choosing to die rather than be so wearied. I am not so impatient, but I would be glad if I could sleep well while I am tied to such company. If I had one to send to school who was sick of the talking evil, the disease of talking, I would gladly give the schoolmaster a double fee, as Isocrates required: one part for teaching him to hold his tongue, and the other for teaching him to speak. I would think many such men and women half cured if they were half as weary of speaking as I am of hearing them.
As Horace says, everything superfluous runs out of a mind already full.
Anyone who lets such chattering swallows build in his chimney may expect his pottage to taste of their dung. Even where they have some learning and goodness to season their talk, their too much loquacity will turn one’s stomach against it, and the surfeit may make some queasy stomachs turn even from more wholesome food. Pompey grew so weary of Cicero’s talkativeness that he wished Cicero had been on Caesar’s side, for then, he said, Cicero would have feared him, whereas now his familiarity wearied him.
2. It is an aggravation of the sin of loquacity and idle talk when it is done in a proud self-conceit of your own cleverness, with an ill-mannered contempt of others. This is the case of a great many who have not the manners or the patience to stay until another man has finished his speech. They think others so long that their eagerness will not hold until the end comes. Yes, many self-styled learned men and disputants have this disease: without any shame, or respect to order, or care for their own reputation, they are in such haste to answer and talk themselves that they cut off the speech of others in the middle, as if to say, Hold your tongue, and let me speak, for I am wiser. Their excuse is that the other is so long that they will forget half of it before the end comes.
But in disputation, or about great matters, it is usually much more to the advantage of the truth and of the hearers to speak all that must be considered together, in one continued speech. The parts of truth have such a dependence one upon another, like the members of a body or the wheels of a watch, that they are not understood in isolation, half the sense of each part referring back to the others. To deliver it in such cases by fragments, with chopped words and frequent interruptions of one another, is to chat or to contend, and not to open the truth with the clearness and gravity it requires.
Those, then, who accuse others of speaking too long in order to excuse their own uncivil interruptions may take their answer from Augustine: "Let it not be counted much speaking when necessary things are said, however great the number or length of words in which they are said." The huge volumes of Augustine, Chrysostom, Suarez, Calvin, yes, of Tostatus himself, are seldom accused of idle words. If you allot each an equal share of time, a composed discourse is fitter for the purpose and spares time better than interrupting arguments and exchange of words. And if your memory cannot hold all that is said, either take notes, or ask for some repetition, or answer the part you do remember.
3. Idle talk is worst when it is about holy things and tends to profane them, when men irreverently babble about the Scriptures or the controversies of religion, or when men with fluent tongues aim at the increase of some faction, the propagating of some error, or the showing off of their own abilities. Jerome says, writing to Nepotianus, "To roll words around and win the admiration of an unlearned crowd is the mark of uneducated men; nothing is so easy as to deceive the common, unlearned people with a voluble tongue, for whatever it does not understand it admires the more." Profane loquacity is the worst kind of loquacity.
4. Idle words are the greater sin when they are magnified and justified, and taken to be lawful, if not something excellent. So it is with some unhappy scholars who spend whole days and months on trivial, unnecessary studies, while Christ, the wisdom of God, the true subject of divine philosophy, is neglected. Anyone who hears some of their supposed critical curiosities would say with Paul, "The Lord knoweth the thoughts of the wise, that they are vain" (1 Cor 3:20). And if he compares their lives with their studies, perhaps he will remember, "They became vain in their imaginations, their foolish hearts were darkened, and professing themselves wise, they became fools" (Rom 1:21–22).
5. Idle words are an aggravated sin when they are studied and pompously set forth at great labor and cost, as a matter to be gloried in, as in plays and romances, which are worse than tobacco houses where men sell smoke. The pleasure, the love, the labor, the cost, the time, the deceit, the temptation, and the impenitence are great aggravations of this sin.
Direction 3. Understand and consider the mischief of the sin of babbling and idle talk. The common cause of it is that men take it to be so small a sin that they think there is no danger in it, and so they fear it no more than a scratched finger.
1. Besides the general evil mentioned in Title 1, Direction 1, consider that much idle talk is a multitude of sins. Though one idle word were ever so small a sin, yet when it comes to hundreds and thousands, and is your daily, hourly custom, all set together cannot be small. Many thousand pence are more than one shilling or one pound. Your frequent custom of idle talk may amount to a greater sinfulness than Noah’s one drunkenness, or David’s one adultery, or Peter’s one denying of Christ. If a swearer should swear as often, or a liar lie as often, or a thief steal as often, as many women (and men too) speak idly, what monsters we should take them for!
2. Idle talk shuts out all the good and edifying speech that should have been used in that time (Col 3:16 Col 3:17 Eph 4:29 Ps 108:1). We have many greater uses for our tongues. You have your business to talk of, and your God, and your souls, and your duties, and your sins, and the life to come. How many great and necessary things there are! Will you shut out all this edifying speech by your idle chat? Will you hinder others as well as yourselves?
3. Idle talk is a sinful consumer of time. You have greater business to spend your hours on. If you saw what a world you are ready to go to, and how near you are to it, you would judge for yourselves that you had greater business than idle chat to spend your time on. Do you know what you lose in losing all those hours?
4. Idle talk corrupts the hearers’ minds, and tends to make them light, and vain, and empty, just as good discourse tends to make them good. Why do you talk to others at all, except to communicate your sense and affections to them by your words? And though many take it for a little sin, I am sure that it is no little hurt that it does. If men were not used to being entertained with so much vain discourse, they would not know how to keep better things from their minds or mouths; nor would their thoughts be so habituated to vanity; nor would they make such returns of idle words. One vain discourse begets another, and it is a multiplying and very infectious sin.
5. As your tongues are misemployed, so your wits and minds are dishonored by vain talk. Even good words grow contemptible when they are too cheap and common. A fiddler at the door passes only for a rogue, though music and musicians are honored; and who ever took a talkative babbler for a wise man? A lover of talk is seldom a lover of learning, and much less a lover of wisdom. As Demosthenes said to a prater, "If you knew more, you would say less."
Those who talk much seldom pass for men of action and worth; those who say much usually do little. Women, and children, and old folk are commonly the greatest talkers (I may add, mad folk). Livy notes that soldiers who prate and brag much seldom fight well, and Erasmus notes that children who quickly learn to speak are long in learning to walk. It is not the barking dog that bites. Let it be the honor of a parrot to speak much, but of a man to speak wisely.
The mobility of their tongues, an honor they share with an aspen leaf, is the whole honor of those who can say a little in a great many words. But to say much in few words is the character of the wise, except when the quality of the hearers forbids it; and those who are briefest in speaking, if the hearers can bear it, shall be accounted the best speakers (Eccl 5:3 Eccl 5:7 Eccl 10:12 Eccl 10:13 Eccl 10:14 Ps 37:30 Prov 17:27 Prov 17:28 Prov 10:20 Prov 12:18 Prov 10:19 Prov 18:4 Prov 18:5 Prov 18:6 Prov 21:23).
I am not of the mind of the man who said that he often repented of speaking but never repented of silence. Yet except in the case of ministers, few men have so much cause to repent of silence as of speech. Not how much, but how well, must be the Christian’s care. As one said of philosophy, I may say much more truly of religion, that though an orator’s excellence appears only in speaking, the philosopher’s, and the Christian’s, appears as much in silence.
6. Where there is much idle talk, there will be much sinful talk. "In the multitude of words there wants not sin: but he that refraineth his lips is wise" (Prov 10:19). There are lies, or backbitings, or meddling with other folks’ matters, or scurrilous jests, if not many such sins, that go along with a course of idle talk. Idle talk is the vehicle in which the devil administers his most poisonous doses. Lipsius says that it is given to praters to speak ill as well as to speak much.
7. Vain words hinder your own edification. Who knows whether, if you held your tongue, someone else might speak more wisely and do you good (Prov 23:8–9)?
8. You weary your hearers (unless they are strangely patient) when you mean to please them; otherwise you might as well talk it all by yourself. It is scarcely good manners for them, unless you are much their inferiors, to tell you that they are weary of hearing you and to beg you to hold your tongue; but you little know how often they think so. I judge others by myself. I flee from a talkative person as from a bed that has fleas or lice; I would shut my doors against them as I stop my windows against the wind and cold in winter. How glad I am when they have finished, and gladder when they are gone! Do not make yourselves a burden to your company or your friends by the troublesome noise of a tongue that never tires.
9. Many words are the common causes of contention. Some word or other will fall that offends those who hear it, or else will be carried to those who are absent and made the occasion of resentments, retellings, brawls, or lawsuits. There is no keeping quietness, peace, and love among talkative prattlers, at least not for long.
10. Are you not aware what pride and impudence lie in it when you think yourselves the worthiest to speak? It is as if you should say, "You are all children to me: hold your tongues, and hear me speak!" If you had Christian humility and modesty, you would in honor prefer others before yourselves. You would think yourselves the unworthiest to speak (unless the contrary were very evident), and would rather desire to hear and learn. When Heraclitus was asked why he alone was silent in the company, he answered, "That you may talk." So when you talk beyond your abilities, it is as if you told the company, "I talk so that all of you may be silent."
11. It is a voluntary sin, and not repented of. You may easily refrain from it if you will, yet you willfully continue in it; and therefore impenitence is your danger.
12. Lastly, consider how unprofitable a sin it is, and how little there is to tempt you to commit it. What do you get by it? Will you daily sin against God for nothing?
Direction 4. If you would not be idle talkers, see that your hearts are taken up with something that is good, and that your tongues are acquainted with and accustomed to their proper work and duty. (Isa 32:4–6 Matt 12:34 Matt 12:36 2 Cor 4:13 John 3:11 1 John 4:5 Prov 16:23 Ps 40:5 Song 7:9)
An empty head and heart are the causes of empty, frothy, vain discourse. Conscience may tell you, when your tongues run upon vanity, that at that time there is no sense of sin or duty, no sense of the presence of God upon your hearts, no holy love, no zeal for God, but that you are asleep to God and to all that is good. In that sleep you ramble and talk idly of anything that comes into your mind. You also fail to make conscience of speaking what is good; if you did, it would keep out vanity and evil.
Remember what abundance of greater matters you have to talk of. You have the evil of sin, the multitude and subtlety of temptations and the way of resisting them; your faults to lament; your evidences of grace to inquire after; your mercies to open thankfully; the greatness and goodness and all the attributes of God to praise. You have all the works of God to admire, all the creatures in the world to contemplate, and all God’s admirable providences and government to observe.
You have the mystery of redemption; the person, office, life, miracles, sufferings, glory, intercession, and reign of Christ; all the secret sanctifying operations of the Holy Ghost; all the ordinances of God and all the means of grace; all our duties to God and to one another; and all the holy Scripture. Besides these there are death and judgment, and heaven and hell, and the concerns of the church of God, and the case of the persons you speak to, who may need your instruction, exhortation, admonition, reproof, or comfort. Is there not work enough here to employ your tongues and keep them from idle talk?
Make conscience of the duties commanded. "Let no corrupt communication proceed out of your mouth, but that which is good to the use of edifying, and may minister grace to the hearers, and grieve not the holy Spirit of God." (Eph 4:29) "Be not drunk with wine wherein is excess, but be filled with the Spirit, speaking to yourselves in psalms, and hymns, and spiritual songs, singing and making melody in your hearts to the Lord, giving thanks always for all things unto God and the Father, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ." (Eph 5:18–19) "If any man speak, let him speak as the oracles of God." (1 Pet 4:11)
Sinful omission of good discourse is the cause of sinful commission of vanity, especially when the heart itself is vain, for as a man is, so is he apt to speak. "They are of the world, therefore speak they of the world." (1 John 4:5) "For the vile person will speak villany, and his heart will work iniquity, to practise hypocrisy, and to utter error against the Lord." (Isa 32:6)
Direction 5. Walk always with God as in his presence, and in the awe of his laws and judgment, that conscience may be kept awake and tender. (Jer 8:6 Prov 6:22 Ps 77:12 Ps 105 Ps 114 Ps 119:11)
You will be restrained from vain talk if you perceive that God is hearing you, and if you remember that your tongue is under a law, and that "for every idle word men shall give account in the day of judgment" (Matt 12:36–37), and that by your "words you shall be justified or condemned." If the law of God were in your hearts (Ps 40:8) and hidden there (Ps 119:11), your heart would be fixed (Ps 57:7). His word would then be the rejoicing of your heart (Ps 119:111), and your tongues would be talking of judgment (Ps 37:30).
A tender conscience will smart more at an idle word than a seared, senseless conscience smarts at an oath, or a lie, or a slander. For "the fear of God is clean" (Ps 19:9), and by it "men depart from evil" (Prov 16:6). "Be thou therefore in the fear of the Lord all the day long." (Prov 23:17)
Direction 6. Avoid idleness, if you would avoid idle talk. (1 Tim 5:13 1 Pet 4:15) The drones of the commonwealth, who have nothing else to do but visit, and pay compliments, and prate of other men’s matters, and who can find time to sit whole hours together on no business, are the ones most guilty of idle chat. Idle gentlemen, and beggars, and idle gossiping women, and old men who are void of the fear of God, and children who have no business to do, are the ones who can sit talking away their time to as little purpose as if they had been asleep the whole while. All idle persons swarm with the vermin of idle thoughts and words.
Direction 7. If you would avoid idle talk, avoid idle, talkative companions; or if you cannot avoid them, do not answer them, but let them talk alone, unless it is to rebuke them or turn them to more profitable talk. To refuse to answer a chatterer is itself a rebuke to him. When you hear vanity, it will incline you to speak vanity; and these ungodly persons "speak every one vanity to his neighbour," as if their tongues were so their own that no lord might control them (Ps 12:1–4). The philosopher could say, "What you would not hear, do not speak; and what you would not speak, do not hear." Most are like parrots, which will oftenest speak the words they oftenest hear. How hard it is to avoid idle talk among idle talkers! One vain word draws on another, and there is no end.
Direction 8. Avoid vain works, if you would avoid vain words. A man who engages himself in vain employment loses all the words he uses about that employment; they are vain with it. What a life, then, do those live who have an unlawful calling? When their very business and trade is sin, everything connected with it, including the words spoken about it, must be sin, and so all their lives are one continued sin. I would rather be the basest drudge than one of these men. Stage-players especially should think of this. And those who spend whole hours, yes, half days, if not nights, in gaming and vain or sinful sports: what an abundance of idle words they use about them! Every cast of the dice and every card they play has an idle word with it, so that a sober man would be weary and ashamed to hear them.
Direction 9. Do not plunge yourselves into an excess of worldly business, as some do who undertake more without necessity than they can discharge. Such persons necessitate a variety of thoughts and words; and all that is spent in serving them in those vain employments is vain, though the work, for the matter of it, is not.
Direction 10. Do not let a vicious mind make that seem necessary or convenient which is vain. Carnal hearts that are acquainted with no better things think nothing vain that pleases their sensual inclinations or that their carnal interest requires. A man-pleaser thinks civility obliges him to keep up his unnecessary visits and compliments, and to answer idle talkers rather than sit silent by them or contradict them; and so it becomes a point of good manners to break the law of God. Just as such a man thinks it uncivil not to pledge every drinker in his healths, so he thinks it uncivil not to answer every prattler in his talk.
Direction 11. Take heed of a proud, self-conceited mind that thinks too well of your own discourse. Get but humility, and you will rather choose to hear than to speak. But when all your fancies and irrelevancies seem excellent matters to you, you are restless until you are delivered of them, and then all must reverence and silently attend your pride and folly, or be taken as neglecters of you for disregarding it. (Prov 3:7 Prov 26:12 1 Cor 3:18)
Direction 12. Avoid passion and passionate companions. Passion is talkative, and will not be checked, but resists the restraint of reason and multiplies words that are worse than vain. (Prov 14:17 Prov 15:18 Eccl 7:8–9)
Direction 13. Take heed of an inordinate, jesting vein. It habituates the mind to foolish levity, and knows no bounds, and breeds idle words as thick as putrefied flesh breeds vermin; and it is the greater sin because it is ordinary, and attended with a certain pleasure and pride, and glorying in vanity, and sinful levity and folly. (Eccl 2:2 Eccl 7:6 Eph 5:4)
Direction 14. Understand particularly what service you have to do for God or for men in every company you come into, and so fit your words to the present duty and company. (Prov 22:17 Prov 12:18 Prov 13:20 Prov 15:2 Prov 15:7 Prov 15:31) Words that are vain and out of place in one company are necessary or fitting in another. If you are to converse with the ignorant and ungodly, turn your discourse into a compassionate way of instruction or exhortation. If with men wiser and better than yourselves, inquire and learn of them, and draw from them what may edify you.
Direction 15. Do not affect an unnecessary fineness of speech, but take those for the fittest words which are suited to the matter, and to your heart, and to your hearers. Otherwise you will be no better than a clever trifler, which is what one writer called the man who wrote a great book on a little matter. Your speech will be studied and affected in its vanity, and you will glory in that as elegant which is your shame. Hypocritical words that do not come from the heart are dead and corrupt, and are only the image of true speech, lacking that truth and meaning of the mind which give speech its life. Words are like laws, which are valued by their authority, matter, and end more than by their ornament and elegance; or like money, which is valued by its authority, metal, and weight, and not by the fineness of its sculpture, imagery, or design. All that is counterfeit, however finely wrought, is vain.
Direction 16. Suppose you had written down the idle words of a day, your own or any other prattler’s, and read them over all at night. Would you not be ashamed of such a volume of vanity and confusion? What a book it would be, that one should thus write from the mouth of idle talkers! What a shame it would be to human nature! It would tempt some to question whether man is a reasonable creature, or whether all men are so, at least in practice. Remember, then, that all is recorded by God and conscience, and all this jumble of vanity must be reviewed and answered for.
The rest of what is necessary for direction against idle words you may find in Chapter 5, Part 2, in the Government of the Thoughts, and in my book Self-Denial. In a word (for I must not commit the fault I am reproving), do not account a course of idle talk a small sin. Never allow so loose and slippery a member as your tongue to go unguarded; and never speak anything of which you dare not say, as in Psalm 19:14, "Let the words of my mouth, and the meditations of my heart, be now and always acceptable in thy sight, O Lord, my strength and my Redeemer."
But especially above others, these persons should watch against vain words.
1. Preachers, who are doubly sanctified persons, and whose tongues, being consecrated to God, must not be sacrilegiously turned to vanity, which is worse than the sacrilegious misuse of the places, or utensils, or revenues of the church. Hate it therefore more than these.
2. Older people, whose words should be grave and wise, and full of instruction to suppress the levity of youth. Childhood and youth are vanity, but age should not be so. (1 Tim 4:12 Job 12:12 Eccl 11:10)
3. Parents and masters, who should be examples of gravity and steadiness to their families, and who by their reproofs and corrections should repress such faults in those under them.
4. Those who are better qualified than others, with knowledge and fluency, to use their tongues to edification. Vain speech is a double sin in them.
5. Those who are noted as persons of holiness and religion, for it is supposed that they pray and speak much against idle talk, and therefore must not themselves be guilty of it. "If any man among you seem to be religious, and bridleth not his tongue, but deceiveth his own heart, this man’s religion is vain." (Jas 1:26; see my sermon on that text.)
6. Those who are ignorant, and greatly need the edifying speech of others.
7. Those who live among wise and holy persons by whom they may be much edified.
8. Those who are among tattlers, where they know they have more need to watch their tongues than their purses among cut-purses.
9. Those (women especially) who are naturally addicted to overmuch talk, and who should therefore be the more watchful, as knowing their disease and its danger.
10. Both empty and angry persons, who carry a continual temptation about them. All these should be specially watchful against idle talk.
And for the time: first, especially when they are among those who may receive most hurt by it; and second, when you are going to holy duty, or have newly come from it.
CHAPTER 29
SPECIAL DIRECTIONS AGAINST FILTHY, RIBALD, SCURRILOUS TALK
Direction 1. The chief direction against this filthy sin is general: get out of a graceless state, and get a heart that fears God, and then you will not dare to be guilty of such impudence. God is not so despised by those who fear him.
Direction 2. Do not neglect your holy communion with God in his worship, especially in private. Do not be a stranger to him, or seldom in his presence. Then you will not dare to pollute those lips that are accustomed to speak seriously to God. What, talk of lust and filthiness with the same tongue that spoke but a moment ago to the most holy God? God’s name and presence will awe you, cleanse you, and show you that his temple must not be so defiled, that he has not called you to uncleanness but to holiness, and that a filthy tongue is unfit for the holy praise of God. But when the rest of your life is nothing but serving the devil and the flesh, it is no wonder that ribaldry seems a fitting language for you.
Direction 3. Cleanse your heart of vanity and filthiness, and your tongue will be the cleaner for it. It is a vain or unchaste heart that makes an unchaste tongue.
Direction 4. Remember what a shame it is to open and proclaim the filthiness of your heart that you might otherwise have kept hidden. Christ tells us how to interpret your words: "out of the abundance of thy heart, thy mouth speaketh" (Luke 6:45). And what need is there to tell people that it is the rutting season with you, and that lust and filthiness are the inhabitants of your mind? If you are not so far past all shame as to commit fornication in the open street, why will you talk of it there?
Direction 5. Remember that filthy talk is only the approach to filthy acts. It is merely breaking the shell of modesty so that you may eat the kernel of the vomiting nut. This is where such talk tends, whether you intend it or not. Can you be offended with someone who believes you do in secret the villainy you talk of openly, or who takes you to be preparing yourself for a whore? If the deed is bad, making a jest of it cannot be good.
Direction 6. Remember that you bid defiance to godliness and honesty. "Corrupt communication grieveth the Spirit of God" (Eph 4:29–30 Eph 5:4). Can you expect the Holy Ghost to dwell and work in so filthy a room, and with such filthy company? Do you dare go to prayer, or read the Scripture, or speak of any holy thing with lips that talk of filthy ribaldry? Do you find yourself fit to go to prayer after such discourse? Or do you not rather leave everyone who hears you to conclude that you renounce God and godliness, and never practise any serious worship of God at all?
And if you do pretend to worship him with that filthy tongue, what can you expect in answer to your prayers but a vengeance worse than Nadab and Abihu’s (Lev 10:1–3)? "Shall sweet water and bitter come from the same fountain?" (Jas 3:11) Do you bless God and talk filthily with the same tongue, and think he will not be avenged on your hypocrisy?
Direction 7. Consider how you bid defiance to common civility. You do what civil heathens would be ashamed of, as if you had a design to reduce England to the customs of cannibals and savages in America, who go naked and are past shame.
Direction 8. Observe what service you do the devil in corrupting others, as if he had hired you to be a tutor in his academy, or one of his preachers, to draw the minds of your hearers away from modesty and prepare them for the brothel. Above all, people can hardly have more dangerous wildfire cast into their imaginations than by hearing rotten, filthy talk. And will you be one of Venus’s priests?
Direction 9. Remember how little need there is of your efforts. Are not lust and filthiness so natural, and the minds of all unsanctified and uncleansed people so prone to them, that they need no tutor, no instigator, no pander to their lusts? This fire is easily kindled; the bellows of your scurrility are needless to make such gunpowder burn.
Direction 10. Immediately lament before God and man the filthiness your tongue has been guilty of, and wash both heart and tongue in the blood of Christ. Flee the company and society of the obscene as you would flee a pest-house or any infectious, pestilential air. And if you hear such rotten talk, either reprove it or leave, and let them see plainly that you hate it and fear God.
Objection: But the filthy mouth says: "I mean no harm; may we not jest and be merry?"
Answer: What, have you nothing to jest with but dung and filth and sin and the defilement of souls and the offending of God? Would you be unclean before the king, or throw dung in men’s faces, and say, "I mean no harm; I am only in jest"?
Objection: But he says: "Those who are so demure are as bad in secret, and worse than we are."
Answer: What, is a chaste tongue a sign of an unchaste life? Then you might just as fairly take a meek and quiet tongue to be a sign of an angry man, or a lying tongue to be a sign of a truthful one. Would the king accept that excuse from you if you talked treason openly and said, "Those who do not are yet as bad in secret as I am"? I am sure he would not take that for an excuse.
CHAPTER 30
DIRECTIONS AGAINST PROFANELY DERIDING, SCORNING, OR OPPOSING GODLINESS
To forestall the scorner’s replies and excuses, I must tell you several things here.
1. By godliness I mean nothing other than entire devotedness to God and living for him, the doctrine and practice that agree with holy Scripture. I mean no fancies of mistaken men, no private opinions of any sect, but the practice of Christianity itself.
2. And yet I must tell you that it is the common practice of these scorners to fasten more on the concrete than the abstract, on the person rather than the bare doctrine, and to oppose godly persons as such, while still claiming they do not oppose godliness. There are several reasons for this.
1.) Because they dare be bolder with the person than with the rule and doctrine of God himself. If they scorned the Bible, or godliness directly as such, they would be scorning God himself so openly that the world would cry shame on them and conscience would trouble them. But godliness as it appears in a neighbor, a preacher, or a particular man seems to them something they can treat with less reverence, and they tell themselves that what they are doing is against the person, not the thing.
2.) In men they always have something else to cite as the grounds of their scorn. Godliness in men is hidden, invisible, impossible to prove as to its sincerity, and unclear as to its exercise. If a scorner says of a godly man, "He is not godly but a hypocrite," there is no perfect justification against such a slander available in this world; only the probable evidence of profession and a godly life can be brought. But godliness as it stands in Scripture lies open to the view of everyone, and cannot be denied there except by denying the Scriptures themselves.
3.) Godliness as contained in the rule of holy Scripture is perfect, without any blemish that could give a scorner a pretext. But godliness in men is very imperfect, mixed with sins and faults that the world can often discern and that godly people themselves are most ready to confess. So in them a scorner can find some plausible pretext. When he derides professors of godliness as all being hypocrites, he will not point to their virtues but to their faults, to Noah’s drunkenness, Lot’s incest, David’s adultery and murder, Peter’s denial of Christ. Yet all the while the dart is aimed at piety itself, and the conclusion he draws is not to drive men away from drunkenness, adultery, or any particular sin, but from serious godliness itself.
4.) Godliness as contained in the rule is to these men a more unnoticed, dormant thing, and does not trouble them as much. They can shut their Bibles, or treat it as nothing more than a few good words. But godliness as it exists in godly teachers and neighbors is more visible to them, more active, more troublesome, and therefore more hated. In a dead letter, or in a dead saint who no longer disturbs them, they can commend it; but in the living they are provoked by it. The nearer it is to them, the more they are enraged against it. The Word is the seed of godliness, and it offends them least until it springs up and bears the fruit that condemns their wicked lives.
3. Just as opposers and scorners usually strike at godliness through the person and his faults, so they commonly strike at the particular parts of God’s worship through some mode, circumstance, or imperfection in men’s performance. It is not preaching or praying they scorn, if you believe them, but this or that manner or imperfection in preaching and praying. But the entire drift of this is not to help anyone do it better; it is to make those most serious in doing it at all appear odious, and thereby to persuade people that it is a needless thing.
Diogenes Laertius tells how Socrates, carried away by the very vehemence of his delivery, would often fling his fingers about while he spoke, so that most people laughed at him and held him in contempt; yet he bore it all with an even mind.
4. Note also that what offends these men most is not the outward form or lifeless part of religion, but the life, zeal, and diligence of the godly. So even where there is no difference in profession about any doctrine or ceremony, they still hate and scorn the godly for doing seriously what they themselves only hypocritically profess.
5. Lastly, note that this is not a quarrel of one sect, party, or church against another over differing opinions. It is something found within all parties, wherever any trace of serious religion exists. Even among the papists there are some spiritual, serious, holy persons who are derided and opposed by the profane within their own church. Among the heathens, Seneca and others record that strictness in moral virtue was made an object of scorn by the crude and sensual sort of men. The quarrel itself is simply the one taken up from the beginning between the woman’s seed and the serpent’s seed; yet in every country where church differences produce contention, this serpentine enmity creeps in with serpentine subtlety, exploits those differences, and takes up the nicknames or sharper weapons that differing Christians forge against one another, in order to strike at the heart of Christianity itself.
Gildas describes the same thing in his own day: if any one of them seemed milder and somewhat nearer the truth, all men’s hatred and weapons were hurled at him without respect, as though he were the subverter of Britain; and everything that displeased them and pleased God was weighed at best in an equal balance, if what displeased them was not in fact the more welcome.
Cyprian writes to Antonian concerning Cornelius: "That certain dishonorable and malicious things are put about concerning him, do not wonder at; for you know that this is always the devil’s work, to tear God’s servants with lying and to defame a glorious name with false opinions, so that those who shine with the light of their own conscience may be soiled by other men’s rumors." And Tertullian says of such scorn, "We too once laughed at these things."
Direction 1. For the cure of those already infected with so heinous a sin, the chief direction is to understand the greatness of that sin and its miserable consequences, as follows.
1. Consider what it is that you are deriding. Do you know against what you open your mouth?
1.) You deride or oppose men for loving God with all their heart, soul, and strength. Do you not acknowledge that this is the duty of every living person, and that whoever does not love God above all is not worthy to be called a Christian? You cannot deny this. And yet will you oppose it? Do not deny what this is; for this is the very thing you oppose, men’s loving God, or showing their love to him. If you loved him as much as they do, you would seek and serve him as diligently as they. Surely you know this yourself: if you loved God with all your heart, soul, and strength, you would seek, serve, and obey him with all your heart, soul, and strength.
If the godly do more than this, deride them and spare not. If they love God and serve him with more than all their heart, soul, and strength, then call them righteous overmuch. If you know anyone who loves God or serves him more than he deserves, blame and oppose that person and spare not. You know that whatever you love most, you are yourself diligent in seeking and keeping in mind. You labor for money because you love it; and they labor in seeking and serving God because they love him. Is there any work fit for anyone but a devil, to oppose or scorn men for loving God, or for showing their love to him?
2.) You deride men for delighting in what is most delightful: for delighting in high and heavenly knowledge, in a holy state of soul and life, in the law of God and meditating on it day and night, in holy prayer and the praises of their Maker, in the anticipation and mention of eternal joys, and in making their calling and election sure.
What is it but the exercise of these holy desires and delights that you deride? And would you not be as serious in religion and holiness as they, if you possessed as much of these delights as they do? Can you sit over your drinking pots, follow your games and sports, or talk of vanity for many hours together because you delight in them, and yet deride those who pray or hear God’s Word expounded for many hours because it is their delight? O poor souls! How quickly and how terribly will God make plain to you whether their delights or yours were the more rational and just, and whether their work or yours was the more fit to be derided!
3.) You scorn people for paying only what they owe to the God who created and redeemed them. Are they not his own? Did he not give them all their faculties and powers? Are not all their abilities and possessions his? What do they have that they did not receive from him? Is it just or honest to mock people for offering to pay their debts and give God what is his? If you know anyone who gives him more than he owes, mock that superstitious, over-righteous man by all means. But if people should not be mocked for paying their debts to you, do not mock them for paying their debt to God and giving him what belongs to him. As we must give to Caesar what is Caesar’s, so we must give to God what is God’s.
4.) You mock servants for diligently obeying their highest master, and for diligently doing the greatest, best, and most necessary work in all the world. Is this a good example for your own servants? Surely if a man should be mocked for serving God, he should be mocked far more for serving such a master as you. Do you know where we might find a better master to serve, with better encouragement than God gives? He has made us his stewards, entrusted us with his goods, and you scorn us for being faithful in our stewardship? You mock his subjects for obeying the king of all the world. Is that a good example to the king’s subjects? Should it be a matter of scorn to obey the king? Or do you think God’s authority is less, or that obedience to him is less commendable?
5.) Moreover, you mock people for doing only a part of their duty and discharging only a fraction of their debt. The holiest person you mock for doing too much is in fact doing less than he ought. You know that even the best of men love God and serve him less than he deserves, and that the most conscientious fall short of perfectly keeping his laws. Will you then scorn people for doing as much as they do, when they themselves know, and you admit, that they do too little? Even if they did all, they would have done only their duty (Luke 17:10).
6.) You scorn people because they will not set themselves, their own wit and will, against their Maker. God has commanded them to "give all diligence to make their calling and election sure" (2 Pet 1:10), and to "strive to enter in at the strait gate" (Matt 7:13), and "day and night to meditate in his law" (Ps 1:2), and to love him with all their heart and might, and to "pray continually" (1 Thess 5:17). And you mock people for obeying these commands! What would you have us do? Should we tell God we are wiser than he? That he shall not have his will but we will have our own? That we know a better way than he has appointed? That he is mistaken and would deceive us by his laws? Would you have people be voluntarily mad, and openly profess themselves rebels against God?
7.) You scorn people because they trust him who is truth and goodness itself. We cannot imagine that he would deceive us by his word, or that any law he makes for us is not good, or that any duty he requires of us will ultimately harm us or leave us as losers. We therefore resolve to obey him as carefully as we can, confident that goodness itself will not abuse us and truth itself will not deceive us. Is this a matter for scorn? Should not children trust their father?
Malignity so blinds the understanding that it leads people to blame every evil that befalls them on the very thing that is the only way to happiness. Whenever the heathen Romans suffered setbacks, they blamed the Christians. So Paul the Deacon records in Book 3, when Radagasus the Goth invaded Roman territory: a vast terror seized Rome; everyone declared that they were suffering these things because the rites of the great gods had been neglected; loud complaints spread everywhere about restoring and celebrating the old sacrifices; across virtually the whole city, blasphemies were heaped on the name of Christ as though it were some plague; and the Romans hired two heathen generals against Radagasus, and so on.
8.) You mock people for not sinning against their own certain knowledge and experience. They know that a holy life is best, even if you do not. They know its reasonableness; they know its sweetness; they know its necessity. Chrysostom says that those who run or compete in the public games, besides the prize they hope for, greatly increase their strength and health by preparing their bodies for it; so too, besides the hope of heaven, it is no small comfort and advantage along the way that Christians gain by their holy lives.
Must they renounce their own understanding? Must they be ignorant because you are ignorant, and put out their eyes because you are blind? Is it a crime for people to be wiser than you, especially in the things of God and their own salvation? They have tried what a holy life is; you have not. They have experienced what a life of faith and obedience is. Must they renounce their own experience? Must those who have tasted honey say it is bitter, because you, who have never tasted it, say so? Alas, what unreasonable men we have to deal with!
9.) You oppose and scorn people for loving themselves, yes, for loving their souls and caring for their soul’s health and welfare. How can a man truly love himself and not love his soul, which is himself? How can a man love his soul and not prefer it over the low concerns of his flesh? How can he not take the greatest care of its greatest and everlasting happiness? Can a man truly love himself and yet damn himself, or waste the little time in which he must, if ever, work out his salvation? You would not scorn someone who was careful of your children, or even of your cattle; you love them and are careful of them yourself. Should not then the man who loves his soul be careful of it? To love ourselves is natural to us as men. And how shall a man love his neighbor who does not love himself?
10.) You scorn people because they love heaven above earth and desire to live forever with God and all the holy hosts of heaven. What is it that these people do so diligently, but seek to be saved? What do they do but "seek first the kingdom of God, and his righteousness," and "labour for the meat" that does not perish (John 6:27), and lay up their "treasure in heaven" (Matt 6:20), and set their "hearts there" (Matt 6:21), and "seek the things that are above, and have their conversation in heaven" (Col 3:1–3, Phil 3:19–20)? If seeking heaven is so contemptible a matter, you evidently never think of coming to heaven yourself, unless you expect to arrive there by scorning those who seek it.
11.) You mock people because they are unwilling to be damned, and unwilling to do what they know would damn them, and unwilling to neglect what is necessary to escape hell. They believe God’s threatenings, and therefore think no effort too great to escape his wrath. They hold that a holy life is both a necessary and an easy way to avoid everlasting torment. If you think otherwise, keep your opinion until grace or hell makes you wiser, and meanwhile mock the man who will not play with his own damnation or leap into hell as recklessly as you do.
12.) You mock people because they will not be their own voluntary destroyers. Was it not enough to betray them to others, or to murder any of your neighbors yourself? Must you also wish them to destroy themselves with their own hands, and mock them if they refuse? O cruel monster, to wish a man to lie in the fire of hell for evermore, and to go there willingly of his own accord! That is ten thousand times worse than wishing him to cut his own throat.
Perhaps you say, "God forbid! I desire no such thing." But do you know what you are doing? Does not the man tempt another toward the gallows who tempts him to murder and steal? The righteous God has unchangeably determined in his law that "without holiness none shall see God, and that Christ shall come in flaming fire to render vengeance to them that obey not his Gospel, and that all they shall be damned that obey not the truth, but have pleasure in unrighteousness" (Heb 12:14, 2 Thess 1:8–10, 2 Thess 2:12). God has resolved that hell shall be the wages of ungodliness. When you urge people to be ungodly, are you not urging them to damn themselves? If you believe there is any hell at all, tell me, what else could a man possibly do to murder his soul and damn himself, except be ungodly? If that way does not do it, nothing else poses any danger.
Tell me: does the devil deserve to be called a murderer of souls? If not, it seems you will openly take the devil’s part. But if he does deserve that name, then let the reason of all the world judge whether that man does not deserve it far more, who will do more against himself than the devil ever did or can do. The devil can only tempt; but you would have men actually do the thing he tempts them to, actually sin, and neglect a holy life. And which is the worse, the one who does the evil, or the one who only persuades him to it? If the devil is called "Our adversary that like a roaring lion goeth about night and day seeking whom he may devour" (1 Pet 5:8), what should that man be called who does far more against himself than all the devils in hell do against him? Surely he is a devourer and destroyer of himself.
Tell me, you distracted scorner: is the devil’s work good or bad, do you think? If it is good, take your share of it, and boast of it when you see the end. If it is bad, to deceive souls and entice them into sin and hell, why would you have men do worse to themselves? The one who sins does worse than the one who tempts. Tell me, what way does the devil take to hurt men and damn their souls, except by drawing them into sin? He has no other way in the world to undo anyone but by tempting him to the very thing you tempt men to: to sin against God and neglect a holy life. So it is plain that you scorn and oppose men because they will not be worse than devils to themselves.
13.) Moreover, you oppose men for not forsaking God. What is it to forsake God, but to refuse to love, honor, and obey him as God? He has told us himself that "He that cometh to God must believe that God is, and that he is the rewarder of them that diligently seek him." And is it not this diligent seeking of him that you mock? It is plain, then, that you would scorn men away from God and have them forsake him as you have done.
14.) You scorn men for not being hypocrites, because they will be in good earnest what you only hypocritically call yourself. You call yourself a Christian; and what is it but for being serious Christians that you mock them? You profess to believe in God; and what is it but for obeying and serving God that you mock them? You profess to believe the Scripture is the Word of God; and what is it but for following the holy Scriptures that you mock them? You say you believe in the communion of saints, yet you mock those who hold that communion in practice. You say you believe that Christ shall judge the world, yet you scorn those who are serious about preparing for his judgment. You pray that God’s name may be hallowed, his kingdom come, and his will be done on earth as it is in heaven, yet you mock those who hallow his name, live as subjects of his kingdom, and strive to do his will.
O wretched hypocrite! And yet that tongue of yours pretends it is their hypocrisy for which you hate and mock them, when in truth you do it because they are not the same blind and senseless hypocrites as yourself. Can there be grosser hypocrisy in the world than to hate and scorn the serious practice of your own profession, and the diligent living by what your own tongue professes to believe?
If you say it is for doing too much and being too strict, I answer: if it is not the will of God that they do these things, I would seek to change them as well as you, though I would not deride them. But if it is the will of God, then tell me: do they do more than those who are in heaven? Do they live more strictly than the saints in heaven? If they do, then oppose them and spare not. If not, why do you pray that God’s will may be done on earth as it is in heaven?
15.) You mock men for doing the very thing they were made for, the purpose for which they have reason and will and all their faculties. Take them off this, and they are good for nothing. A beast is good to serve man, and plants to feed him; but what is man good for, or what was he made for, if not to serve his Maker? And do you scorn him for the very thing he came into the world to do? You might as well hate a knife for cutting, or a scythe for mowing, or a clock for telling the hour of the day, when that is precisely what each was made for.
16.) You mock men for being saved by Christ and for imitating his example. What did Christ come into the world for, but to destroy the works of the devil, and to save "his people from their sins," and "to redeem us from all iniquity, and purify to himself a peculiar people, zealous of good works"? (Matt 1:21, Titus 2:14) Christ, to the astonishment of men and angels, came down into flesh, lived among men, gave them his holy doctrine and example, and suffered death for them, all to bring men to zealous purity. And do you dare make a scorn of it after all this? What is that but to scorn your Savior, scorn all the work of redemption, tread underfoot the Son of God, and despise his blood, his life, and his precepts?
17.) You scorn men for being renewed and sanctified by the Holy Ghost. What is the work of the Holy Ghost upon us, but to sanctify us? And what is it to sanctify us, but to cleanse us from sin and cause us entirely to devote our souls and lives to God? Do you believe in the Holy Ghost or not? If you do, that is to believe in him as the sanctifier of God’s elect. And what did you take sanctification to be, but this purity and holiness of heart and life? And yet you dare to mock it?
18.) You mock men for imitating those ancient saints whose names you yourself seem to honor, and in whose honor you keep holy days. You profess to honor the names of Peter, Paul, Stephen, and John; of Augustine, Jerome, Chrysostom, and other such saints of God, yet you will make a scorn of those who strive to imitate them. Search and see: if any of these men, after their conversion, lived in luxury, card-playing, dicing, and profaneness, if any of them were against a holy life, against much praying, hearing, and reading the Scriptures, meditating, and exact obedience to God, then let the shame be mine, not yours. Let the scorn fall on whoever is most unlike them.
19.) You mock men for repenting of their former sin, and for accepting that mercy which Christ has purchased, which God has offered, and which he has sent his messengers to entreat them to accept. Can they repent of their former ungodliness without turning from it and amending their lives? If you knew what they know, you would repent yourself rather than mock men for repenting. If you knew the gift of God, you would beg it and gladly accept it yourself, rather than mock those who do accept it.
20.) You scorn men for keeping the covenant which you yourself made with God in your baptism. At the same time you speak against the Anabaptists who will not have their children baptized, and yet you mock those who keep the very covenant they made in baptism. What a monster of contradictions is an ungodly hypocrite! Did you not in baptism renounce the flesh, the world, and the devil, and give yourself up in covenant to God the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost? And do you not yet know what you did, that you scorn those who perform it? What is it to be given up to God in baptism, but to take him for your God, your Savior and Sanctifier, whom you must love, seek, and obey in holiness with all your heart, soul, and might? He is a covenant-breaker indeed who hates the keeping of it.
I have been showing you thus far what it is that you oppose and mock. I will now go further and show you what you are doing, by setting out the aggravations of your sin and its true significance.
2. Consider that in all of this you are an open enemy to God and an open soldier for the devil. What more could you do against God, do your worst, than make a scorn of all his work and servants? He does not fear your power or rage; you cannot hurt him. How many millions of such worms as you can he tread into hell, or destroy in a moment? It is in his servants and his service that he is honored or opposed here, and that mortals show their love or hatred toward him. And how could you devise, if you wished to do your very worst, to serve the devil more notoriously than by opposing and deriding the service of God? If such persons are not Satan’s servants, he has none.
3. Consider what a terrible badge of misery you carry about you. You bear the mark of Satan, death, and hell on your forehead, as it were. If there were any doubt whether a swearer, a drunkard, or a fornicator might be in a state of grace, it is beyond all doubt that a scorner of godliness is not. It would be strange indeed for a man who derides holiness to be holy himself. There is scarcely any kind of person in the world more certainly in a state of damnation than you are.
It is unclear to us what God will do with infidels and heathens who never had the means of salvation, but what he will do with all the unbelieving and ungodly who have had those means we know beyond doubt, and still more what he will do with those who are not only void of holiness but deride it. I do not deny that if you are converted you may yet be saved. O that God would "give thee repentance to the acknowledging of the truth," that you might escape out of the devil’s snares, who leads you captive at his will. It is written of Basil that by his prayers he caused the devil to give back a writing by which a wretched man had sold his soul to him, that he might enjoy his master’s daughter, and that the man repented and was delivered. If you may be so recovered, it will be a happy day for you.
But until then, it is as sure as the Scripture is sure that you are a miserable creature, and an undone man if you die in the condition you are now in. O, with what fear ought you to rise and lie down, if you had your wits about you, lest you should die before you are converted.
Victor of Vita records that Cyril, the Arian bishop, persuaded King Hunneric that he could not hold a peaceful and long-lasting reign unless he destroyed the name of the innocent; yet by God’s judgment, not many days afterward, the king was cut off by a most shameful death and expired swarming with worms.
4. To scorn holiness is to defy grace, as though you renounced God’s mercy. You do your worst to drive away all hope and make your case incurable and desperate. For if you are ever saved, it must be by this very grace and holy life that you deride. Is scorning grace the way to obtain it? And is it likely that the Holy Ghost will come and dwell in a man who scorns his sanctifying works?
5. To scorn godliness is to dare God to give up his patience and execute his vengeance on you at once. Can you wonder if he should make you a monument of his justice and set you up as a warning to all others? Who is fitter for this than the scornful opposers of his grace and service? Do not hasten vengeance, man; it will come soon enough. Will a worm defy the God of heaven?
6. How little do you understand of all that you oppose? Have you ever tried a holy life? If you had, you would not speak against it. If you have not, are you not ashamed to speak evil of what you do not understand? It is a thing no one can thoroughly know without experience. Try it for a while, and then speak your mind.
7. Have you ever considered how many judgments stand against you, and whom you contradict and scorn?
1.) If you scorn serious godliness, preaching, hearing, reading, praying, meditating, and strict avoiding of sin, you contradict God himself, for no one in all the world is so holy or so much for holiness as he. Ultimately, therefore, it is God himself whom all your malice is against: God the Father, the Redeemer, and the Sanctifier.
2.) You set yourself against all the evidence of Scripture.
3.) You set yourself against all the works of God, for all of them conspire to call the world to holiness and strict obedience to God.
4.) You contradict all the prophets and apostles, all the ancient fathers of the church, all the martyrs and saints of God who ever were in the world, all the learned and faithful ministers and pastors of the church who are or have been, all the godly throughout the world, and all who ever had experience of a holy life. What are you, that you should scorn all these? Are you wiser than all the ministers and godly persons in the world? Than all the apostles and holy martyrs of Christ who ever were? Yes, than God himself?
8. Have you ever noticed how unlike the speech of Christ and his apostles was to yours? Did they deride men for being too diligent in pleasing God and saving their souls? Read the following passages and judge: (Matt 5:8, Matt 5:11, Matt 5:20, Matt 6:33, Matt 6:21, Matt 7:13–14, 1 Pet 4:18, 2 Pet 3:11, 2 Pet 1:10, Heb 11:6, Matt 5, Rom 8:1, Rom 8:5–9, Rom 8:13, Phil 3:18–19, Heb 12:28–29).
9. Do you not yourself do as much for the world as those you oppose do for heaven? Are you offended that they preach and pray so long? Are you not longer about your worldly business? Are not gallants longer at a feast, a visit, or games and recreations? Are you offended that they talk so much of heaven? Do you not talk more of earth? And which of these, in your own conscience, do you think better deserves to be sought and talked of? Which will prove better at the last? And whose labor will be more worthy of derision?
10. What would you gain if you had your will, and praying, preaching, and holiness were as thoroughly banished from the world as you would have them? If men to please you should displease God and cast away their souls forever, would it do you good for the earth to be so like hell? Godly men already grieve to think how little holiness there is in the world. There is scarcely a sadder thought that has ever come into my heart than to survey all the nations of the earth and consider how ignorance and ungodliness abound, and how few there are who are truly holy. What an inhuman creature is the one who would have them fewer still, and who would scorn out of the world the little wisdom and piety that is left.
And would it be any pleasure to you in hell to have men accompany you there to humor you? No, it would be your everlasting torment to see so many there undone forever by hearkening to your wicked counsel. Do not say that you are not so cruel, and that it is not their damnation you desire: no more is it your own that you desire; but it is all one as to the effect, if you desire the way to it. You might as well give one man poison and mock another for eating and drinking, and still say, "It is not your death that I desire." But die they must, if they are ruled by you.
11. Would he not be a cruel man who refused to do as much for the saving of his neighbor’s soul as that which you deride others for doing in the saving of their own? If you were sick, should I refuse to pray for your life? Or if I knew that some means or pains might save another’s soul, should I think any of it too much? If not, it seems I may be allowed to do as much for myself as charity bids me do for another.
12. Is it a season to mock at holiness, when at this very moment there are so many millions of souls in heaven who all came there by the way of holiness, and so many millions of souls in hell who all came there for lack of holiness? While you are prating against it, they are crying out in despair at the folly of their neglecting it. Would one of the souls in heaven regard your mocks if he were to live on earth again? Or would one of the souls in hell be mocked into going there, if they were but tried with another life? If you saw at this hour what unholy souls in hell are suffering and what holy souls in heaven enjoy, would you ever mock again at holiness? For shame, consider what you are doing, and see by faith the things that mortal eyes behold not.
13. What if men should yield to your derisions and forsake a holy life to please you? Would you undertake to justify them, or be answerable for them before that God who required holiness and will condemn all the unholy? Would you bring them off and save them from damnation? Alas, poor soul, how unable will you be to save yourself. And will you take them for wise men if they displease the Lord and go to hell to humor such a one as you?
14. You would not yourself be mocked out of your house, or land, or right, nor from your food, or drink, or rest. Would you cast these away if another should merely mock you for using them? I think you would not. And would you have wise men be mocked out of their salvation?
15. You would not think it reasonable that your children or servants should be derided for loving or obeying you, or your very horse dispraised for serving you. And do they owe you more than we all owe God?
16. God highly honors them and dearly loves them for that very thing that you hate and deride them for. "He that hath my commandments and keepeth them, he it is that loveth me: and he that loveth me shall be loved of my Father: and I will love him, and will manifest myself to him" (John 16:27, John 14:21). "The righteous Lord loveth righteousness: his countenance doth behold the upright" (Ps 11:7). "The Lord loveth the righteous" (Ps 146:8). "For ye are the temple of the living God: as God hath said, I will dwell in them, and walk in them; and I will be their God, and they shall be my people. Wherefore come out from among them, and be ye separate, saith the Lord, and touch not the unclean thing; and I will receive you, and will be a Father unto you, and ye shall be my sons and daughters, saith the Lord Almighty" (2 Cor 6:16–18).
And do you dare scorn the sons and daughters of the Almighty, for the very thing for which he has promised to receive them and to be a Father to them? How contrary to God you are! "A book of remembrance was written for them that feared the Lord, and thought upon his name: and they shall be mine saith the Lord of Hosts, in that day when I make up my jewels: and I will spare them as a man spareth his own son that serveth him" (Mal 3:16–18). And do you dare scorn God’s jewels, those who are thus precious to him? "For them that honour me I will honour, and they that despise me shall be lightly esteemed" (1 Sam 2:30). And will you be one of his despisers, opposing in others the very thing for which God himself has promised to honor them?
17. To hate and scorn at holiness is to hate and scorn at God’s own image, and the clearest image of God that is under heaven: that very copy of the holy life of Christ which by the Spirit of God is drawn upon the heart, and of which Christ came down from heaven to give us the first draft. He who scorns this image of God scorns the Holy Ghost who made it, and scorns Christ who gave us the first pattern, and scorns God himself whose image it is. Chrysostom says, "God is loved and hated in his servants, as a king is honoured or despised in his image." And he who dares scorn God, and scorn Jesus Christ, and scorn the Holy Ghost in the image of God upon his children should never have the face to expect to be saved by the God he scorns.
18. You are the shame of human nature, and you make man so like a devil that it is hard to prove the devils can do much worse than you. Martin of Braga asks in his book on morals, "What is most hostile to man?" and answers, "Man." Can there be a greater sin than for a creature to scorn and deride the image and laws of his Creator, and to hate and oppose, or persecute, men for obeying him, and seeking to please him, and to save their souls? What could you do worse if you set yourself to be as bad as you could be? What a shame it is to your understanding to be so blind, and to your heart to be so wicked. It would not be half so great a shame to scorn the sun for shining, or the earth for bearing fruit; for though these are God’s creatures, they do not bear the image of his holiness as his children do.
When he will condemn men at last it will be upon this account: "Verily I say unto you, inasmuch as you did it not (or did it) to one of the least of these (my brethren) ye did it not (or did it) unto me" (Matt 25:40 and 25:45). O, how astonishing that the nature of man can ever come to this: to hate, and oppose, and scorn the image and obedience of his Maker, and to make a mock of the holiness of God!
It is a great question whether the very tempting of men to such sins as these is not the devil’s greatest sin; and, other things being equal, to commit such a sin is worse than to tempt you to commit it. And for a man who has a Savior offered him thus to scorn his Savior’s grace and mock his servants must needs be far worse than for the devil to do it, who has no Savior, no pardon offered, and no hope, but is shut up under endless desperation. It is here as with a child: it is worse for him to curse or scorn his father than for an enemy to do it. Think and tremble, how near this deriding or opposing of the work of the Holy Ghost comes to the unpardonable blasphemy against him.
19. What villainy may not be expected from you, who can commit such a sin as this? May not your neighbor look for any mischief that your carnal interest shall lead you to do against him? Is it any wrong to you to think that you are a thief, a murderer, a whoremonger, a deceiver, unless it be for want of a temptation to commit them? Or that you would be a traitor against your king and country, or perfidious to your truest friend, if you were tempted to it? And this when you scorn men for obeying God himself!
Will that man stop short at any wickedness he is equally tempted to, who dares scorn his Maker, the Redeemer, and the Sanctifier, and spit contempt upon holiness itself, the image of his Judge? For my part, if ever I trust you or any such man as you with life or liberty, or with the worth of a groat, it shall be my interest and not your honesty and conscience that I trust. I will trust you little further than I would trust the devil himself who governs you.
20. Lastly, consider what you will think of yourself for this at death and judgment. Read carefully in Jude 14–15 and Psalm 1. Will it comfort you, when you are going to be judged of God, to think that you are now going into the presence of that God whom you used to scorn? When you see Christ come with thousands of his holy angels to judge the world, will it comfort you to think, "This is he whose holy life, and precepts, and servants I mocked or persecuted on earth; now I must be judged by him that I derided"? O dreadful case, for a scorner or persecutor of godliness to go and be judged by that holy God whose ways he scorned and persecuted!
If you say it was not Christ but a man that you derided, see Matthew 25:40, Matthew 25:45, Luke 19:27, and Acts 9:4: "Saul, Saul, why persecutest thou me?" If you scorn a child for that in which he resembles, imitates, or obeys his father, you will find in the day of judgment, to your woe, that it was the Father himself who was the utmost and principal object of your scorn. Then I had rather be the vilest toad than such a man. Will you then stand to what you said? Will you then maintain your slanders and reproach? Will you then condemn or scorn the godly, when you see them justified at Christ’s right hand, or glorified with him in heaven?
No. As Malachi 3:18 says, when God makes up his jewels, "Then shall ye return and discern between the righteous and the wicked, between him that serveth God and him that serveth him not." Then how gladly would you eat all the words of reproach and scorn that ever you uttered against a saint, and wish that you had never spoken them. I tell you, it is an unseemly thing for the same man now to scorn at godliness who will so speedily tremble before the righteous God in the remembrance of it.
I have thought these discoveries of the horridness of this sin to be the best directions against it, for as it is a sin that you gain nothing by, so it is a sin that you may easily leave if you are willing. But for those who are yet only in the way to it, or in danger of it, I shall add these further directions to keep them from so desperate a wickedness.
Direction 1. Avoid the company of those distracted men who dare revile the servants and ways of God. There is that in your corrupted natures which will incline you to imitate the most horrid blasphemies if you often hear them. We have seen it in our days, that in imitation of others men have been drawn to sins not to be named: to drink healths to the devil, to make "God damn me" an ordinary byword. Do not, therefore, be companions of them.
Direction 2. Take heed of sinning yourself into blindness of mind and hardness of heart. Do not forsake God, lest you be forsaken by him. It is men forsaken of God who ordinarily come to this desperate degree of sin.
Indeed, the Book of Homilies, describing them, says: "The third sort he calleth scorners, that is, a sort of men whose hearts are so stuffed with malice, that they are not contented to dwell in sin, and to lead their lives in all kinds of wickedness; but also they do contemn and scorn in others, all godliness, true religion, all honesty and virtue. Of the two first sorts of men, I will not say but they may take repentance, and be converted unto God: of the third sort, I think I may without danger of God’s judgment pronounce, that never any yet were converted unto God by repentance, but continued still in their abominable wickedness, heaping up to themselves damnation against the day of God’s inevitable judgment." (Homily 10, Part 2, cited before in my Now or Never, page 125.) Though I take this to be too severe, it is the judgment of the Church of England, and terrible to scorners who profess their assent to it.
Direction 3. Take heed of scorning at the very circumstances or modes of worship which you dislike. Such scorns come so near to the worship itself that the minds of the hearers may easily be drawn from them to dishonor the substance for the sake of the derided mode or circumstance; and it plainly savors of a bold profaneness which grave and sober Christians abhor. In the case of idolatry, or where the very substance of the worship is impious and forbidden, I do not deny that Elias may sometimes, and with wariness, be imitated, who derided Baal’s priests. But to do this upon smaller differences in the manner or circumstances of worship is the way to teach men to turn all religion into matter of derision and contempt.
If you see about the king some circumstance of clothing, ornament, or attendance of his followers which you dislike or judge ridiculous, and you look toward him with a scornful laughter, it will not excuse you to say, "I laughed not at the king, but at such or such a thing about him," for his presence should have restrained you from that which seems to be a deriding of him. So here. I know you will say, "It is not at God’s worship, but at such words or gestures of the minister that I scorn." But take heed of dallying with holy things. Do not play so near the consuming fire. Do not give others occasion to deride the thing itself by your deriding the circumstances, though they were unapt.
Have we not seen, while factious Christians raise jests, and nicknames, and scorns against each other, how the profane and common enemies of religion take them up and turn them against all serious godliness, to the trouble of others and their own damnation? And we have had experience in these contentious times that it is the sectaries and the profane who are apt to use these scoffs and scorns against the things and persons that they dislike, and that sober, peaceable, judicious men of all sides abhor it.
How unsavory and profane have all sober men thought it, when they heard some young and hot-brained persons mocking at the Common Prayer by the name of "Pottage," and at the surplice by the name of "the whore of Babylon’s smock." And from there the same spirit led them as proudly and bitterly to deride at ministers, universities, learning, temples, tithes, and all the appurtenances of worship: yes, at the Lord’s day, and singing psalms, and preaching, and almost all the duties of religion. For when once men will pretend to strive for God with the spirit and weapons of Satan, and the world, and the flesh, there is no stop till they come to the bottom of impiety, and do Satan’s work in Satan’s way.
And so on the other side, while some have too reproachfully scorned such as Precisians or Puritans, who differed from them about the form of church government and ceremonies, the rabble of the profane soon gained advantage from it, and turned these words into so common and bitter reproaches of the godly, sober, peaceable people of the land that Mr. Robert Bolton says: "I am persuaded there was never poor persecuted word, since malice against God first seized on the damned angels, and the graces of heaven dwelt in the heart of man, that passed through the mouths of all sorts of unregenerate men, with more distastefulness and gnashing of teeth, than the name of Puritan doth at this day: which, notwithstanding as it is now commonly meant, and ordinarily proceeds from the spleen and spirit of profaneness and good fellowship, is an honourable nickname, that I may so speak, of Christianity and grace." (Discourse of Happiness, page 193.)
Nicknames themselves are the great engines of the devil, and are to be avoided. It went well with the church when Christ’s disciples put no other name on one another but Christians, though their enemies scornfully called them Nazarenes, and a sect, and a heresy. More is cited out of Bolton, and out of Bishop Downam, Bishop Abbot, and others, in my Formal Hypocrite, pages 210, 212, and following.
Direction 4. Be very fearful of making the persons of the godly contemptible, though for their real faults, lest the ungodly easily step from there to the contempt of godliness itself. For it is easy to observe how commonly ordinary people judge the doctrine and the religion by the person that professes it. If a Papist or a Sectary lives a holy life, take heed of making a scorn of their persons, notwithstanding that you take the rise of your derision from their mistakes; for even a mistaking saint is dearly beloved and honored of God. Wherever holiness is, it is the greatest, most resplendent, and predominant thing in him that has it, and therefore puts a greater honor on him than any mistake or infirmity can dishonor him.
As the person of a king must not be dishonored by a reproachful mention of his infirmities, lest it reflect upon his office, so neither must the person of a holy man, lest it reflect on his religion. Not that any man’s person should credit or secure his faults, nor that we should judge of the faults or manners by the men, instead of judging of the men by their manners; but you must judge of them by that which is predominant, and so blame their faults as to preserve the honor of their virtues and religion, and of their persons for their virtues’ sake. So blame the falls of Noah, and Lot, and David, and Peter, as may make the sin more odious, but not so as may make their persons contemptible, lest their religion be the next thing despised.
Mark here the difference between the mentioning of good men’s falls by the godly and by the ungodly. The godly mention them to make sin appear a thing more to be feared and watched against, and holiness to appear more excellent and necessary; but the ungodly mention them, and read them in Scripture, to make themselves believe that sin is not so bad and dangerous a thing as preachers tell them, and that holiness differs but little from a fleshly life.
Pliny says that as pearls, though they lie in the bottom of the sea, are yet much nearer kin to heaven, as their splendor and excellency shows, so a godly and generous soul has more dependence on heaven, from which it comes, than on earth, where it abides. A good saying for a heathen.
Direction 5. Do not judge God’s servants merely by report, without some considerable acquaintance with them. I cannot remember one out of the whole multitude of the enemies, scorners, and persecutors of godliness, great or small, high or low, who ever had the happiness of being well acquainted with the godly by any familiarity, or by observing the private passages of their lives; usually they are such as know them only by report, or by sight, or by slight acquaintance. And if they did but live with them in the same houses, or were of their familiarity, it were the likeliest way to change their minds and speeches, unless their acquaintance were only with some of the more ignorant, passionate, or distempered sort of Christians.
Direction 6. Take heed of uncharitableness and malice against any, but especially against the servants of Christ. For this blinds the judgment, and maddens men with a venomous kind of passion, and will make them scorn and rage against the most holy servants of the Lord. The least true love to a Christian, as a Christian, would do much to the cure of all this sin.
Direction 7. Take heed of being engaged in a sect or faction, and take heed of the carnal zeal of schism, and of the spirit of faction, which ordinarily makes men think it lawful, if not necessary, to scorn the persons that seem against them, that so they may disable them from hindering the interest of their cause or party. Thus Papists, and thus the factious ones of every party, think that their revilings are but the necessary disarming of the enemies of God (for such all must seem that differ from them), and a stripping of them of that honor by which they might do hurt. Thus good is pretended for the most odious evil, and God is set up against that love which is the fulfilling of his law, and made the patron of the scorners of his children. But surely he scorns the scorners (Prov 3:34).
Direction 8. Take heed of error and unbelief. For if the understanding be once deluded, and take religion itself to be but a deceit or fancy, and godliness to be but conceit and hypocrisy, no wonder if it be made a scorn by such. And such scorners will justify themselves in it, and think they do no harm: so great a plague is a blinded mind.
I have said less against this devilish sin than the nature of it requires, because I have already said so much, especially in three treatises: The Vain Religion of the Formal Hypocrite, that called Now or Never, and A Saint or a Brute.
I conclude with these earnest requests to the godly.
1. Give men no occasion of scorn by your imprudence, scandal, selfishness, or passion, as you tender the honor of God and men’s salvation. As Chrysostom says, "As he that beareth the king’s standard in fight had need to be well guarded, so he that carrieth the name and profession of God and godliness." Diogenes Laertius tells how Socrates, when he had been kicked by someone, said to those who marveled at his forbearance, "What if an ass had kicked me? Would I have summoned it to court?"
2. Do not be discouraged by scorners. What they inflict is easy compared with what Christ suffered for you, and with what the scorners themselves must suffer.
CHAPTER 31
DIRECTIONS ABOUT OUR LABOR AND CALLINGS
Title 1. Directions for the Right Choice of Our Calling and Ordinary Labor
I have already spoken of Christian works and the duty of our callings in Chapter III, Grand Direction 10, and now I need only add these few directions for rightly choosing your calling. I will say more about the use of them later.
Direction 1. Understand how necessary a life of labor is, and the reasons for that necessity.
Question 1: Is labor necessary for all? Or, if not for all, for whom?
Answer: It is necessary as a duty for all who are able to perform it; but it is not necessary for those who are unable, such as infants, sick persons, those who are mentally incapacitated, prisoners, anyone unavoidably restrained or hindered by others, or people disabled by age or by anything that makes labor naturally impossible.
Question 2: What kind of labor is necessary?
Answer: Some labor that employs the faculties of both soul and body, and is profitable, as far as possible, to others and to ourselves. But the same kind of labor is not required of everyone.
In some labors the mind is more engaged than the body, as in the labors of a magistrate, minister, physician, lawyer, and the like, though some in these callings also bear considerable bodily labor.
The labor of some is almost entirely of the mind:
1. Students of divinity, philosophy, law, medicine, and so on, who are only preparing themselves for a calling.
2. Some ministers, or other godly persons, who by the wickedness of the place or times in which they live may for a season be prevented from appearing among others and laboring for any except by the mind, being imprisoned, driven into solitude, or otherwise made incapable.
3. Men who have some extraordinary necessity for a time to be alone with God and their own souls, such as men near death who need to set aside all other labors to prepare themselves. Though even those near death should ordinarily labor for the good of others to the last, and in doing so they both profit and prepare themselves.
The labor of some others is more of the body than the mind, as with most tradesmen and day-laborers.
And the labor of some is equally of body and mind, as with some hardworking ministers and physicians, scribes, and craftsmen of more skilled professions, such as watchmakers, printers, and builders. Some of these callings suit one person, and some suit another (1 Cor 9:6 2 Cor 6:1 1 Cor 16:10 2 Tim 2:15).
Question 3: May not religion excuse men from all labor other than prayer and contemplation?
Answer: Religion is our obligation to obey God. God binds us to do all the good we can to others. Some men who have the ability, opportunity, and a call may be excused by religion from worldly labors, ministers, for example, but not from such spiritual labors for others as they are able to perform. See Chapter VI, Title 4, above, and my Treatise of Divine Life, Part III.
The person who, under the pretense of religion, withdraws from society, refrains from doing good to others, and lives only for himself and his own soul, makes religion a pretense against charity and the works of charity, which are a great part of religion itself. For "pure religion and undefiled before God and the Father is this, to visit the fatherless and widows in their affliction, and to keep himself unspotted from the world" (Jas 1:27). Even when sickness, imprisonment, or persecution prevents us from doing any more for others, we must pray for them. But while we can do more, we must.
Question 4: Will not riches excuse a person from laboring in a calling?
Answer: No, they rather bind him to it all the more. For the one who has received most from God should do the most work for him. Though the rich have no outward need to drive them, they have exactly the same necessity to obey God and do good to others as any poor person does.
Question 5: Why is labor thus necessary for all who are able?
Answer:
1. God has strictly commanded it for all, and his command is reason enough. "For even when we were with you, this we commanded you, that if any would not work, neither should he eat. For we hear that there are some which walk among you disorderly, working not at all, but are busy-bodies. Now them that are such, we command and exhort by our Lord Jesus Christ, that with quietness they work and eat their own bread" (2 Thess 3:10–12). "We beseech you brethren, that ye study to be quiet, and to do your own business, and work with your hands as we commanded you, that ye may walk honestly (or decently) towards them that are without, and that ye may have lack of nothing" (1 Thess 4:11). "In the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat bread, till thou return unto the ground" (Gen 3:19). And in the Fourth Commandment: "Six days shalt thou labour." See also (Eph 4:28 and Prov 31:31).
2. By nature, action is the end of all our powers, and a power would be worthless apart from its exercise. The ability to understand, to read, to write, to walk, and so on would count for little if it did not exist for the sake of doing those very things.
3. It is for action that God sustains us and our abilities. Work is the moral as well as the natural end of power; what is commanded is the act performed through the power.
4. It is by action that God is most served and honored, not so much by our being able to do good as by our actually doing it. Who would keep a servant capable of work who refuses to work? Will his mere ability satisfy what you require of him?
5. The public welfare, the good of the many, is to be valued above our own. Every person is therefore bound to do all the good he can to others, and especially for the church and the commonwealth. This is not accomplished by idleness but by labor. As bees labor to replenish their hive, so man, being a social creature, must labor for the good of the society to which he belongs, a society in which his own good is contained as one part.
6. Labor is necessary for the preservation of the faculties of the mind.
1.) The labor of the mind is necessary for this, because unused abilities decay, as iron not used will corrode with rust. Idleness makes people foolish and dull, and ruins what little ability they have.
2.) The exercise of the body is ordinarily necessary as well, because of the mind’s dependence on the body and its functioning according to the body’s condition and state: the mind is greatly helped or hindered by the body.
7. Labor is needful for our health and life. The body itself will quickly fall into deadly diseases without it, except in a very few persons of extraordinary soundness. Next to abstinence, labor is the chief preserver of health. It stirs up the natural heat and vital spirits that perform the chief functions for human life; it is the proper bellows for this vital fire; it aids all of nature’s digestive processes; it breaks down what is too thick; it purifies what is beginning to corrupt; it clears obstructions; it keeps the mass of blood and other nourishing fluids in their proper condition, fit for motion, circulation, and nutrition; it assists them all in discharging their natural functions; it helps the parts draw each its proper nutriment, and promotes every process of fermentation and assimilation by which nature sustains the body’s ever-consuming substance.
Socrates was strongly devoted to physical exercise as necessary for the health of both body and mind (Laertius). Plutarch, drawing on Plato, says that soul and body should be exercised equally together, driven on like two horses in a carriage, neither outpacing the other (Precepts of Health).
Labor excels art in preparing, altering, and expelling all waste matter, which, if retained, would be the cause of countless diseases, and it powerfully resists every enemy of health. In short, for the prevention of most diseases that afflict humanity, it is incomparably superior to the help of the most skilled physicians and the best medicines in the world. Consequently it benefits the soul itself, which makes cheerful use of a cheerful and well-regulated body, but uses a languid, sickly body as a rider uses a tired horse, or as one uses a sick or lazy servant, a blunted knife, or a clock that is out of order.
I say all this about bodily labor, which is necessary for the body and consequently for the mind. For want of it, multitudes grow melancholy, multitudes become sluggish and good for nothing, multitudes cherish filthy lusts, and millions every year return to the earth before their time. For lack of bodily labor, a multitude of idle gentry, wealthy people, and slothful young people heap up in the secret recesses of the body a dunghill of undigested, waste matter, corrupt all the fluids that should be the fuel and oil of life, and die by thousands of untimely deaths, of fevers, palsies, convulsions, apoplexies, dropsies, consumptions, gout, and more, more miserably than if thieves had murdered them on the highway, because it is their own doing: by their sloth they kill themselves.
For want of bodily exercise and labor interspersed, many scholars and sedentary persons fill themselves with diseases, hasten their death, and groundlessly blame their hard studies for what was caused by their bodily sloth. The hardest studies will do little harm to most men, if they but maintain all the humors in their proper balance by means of well-placed bodily labor. Instead, by a sluggish walk now and then in place of genuine labor and exertion, they cheat themselves.
If the world truly understood the benefit of temperance and labor for maintaining health and life, and the harm of excess in eating and drinking and of idleness, the love of health and life would accomplish what God’s authority alone will not.
8. Labor and diligence keep the mind on a lawful occupation, and so drive out many dangerous temptations. They keep thoughts from vanity and sin, restrain vain words, and preserve the soul from many sins that idleness and sloth encourage. Labor helps even uneducated people to restrain their thoughts and words from sin more effectively than the greatest knowledge and diligent watchfulness can do in an idle kind of life.
9. Diligent labor mortifies the flesh, holds its self-indulgent impulses in check, and subdues the pride, lust, and brute sensuality that an idle life fosters.
10. Last, labor is God’s appointed means for obtaining our daily bread. It is a more genuine honor to earn one’s bread than to receive it as a gift from friends or parents, and to a well-informed mind it is also more satisfying. We can best believe that our food and provisions come to us in mercy, and that they will be blessed to us, when we obtain them in God’s appointed way, for he has said, "If any man will not work, neither should he eat."
Direction 2. As labor is thus necessary, understand how needful a settled calling is for the right performance of your labors. A calling is a steady, ordinary course of labor. It is very needful for the following reasons.
1.) Without a calling, a man’s labors are only occasional and inconsistent, so more time is spent in idleness than in work.
2.) A man is most skilled in what he is accustomed to doing.
3.) He will be best supplied with the tools and materials it requires.
4.) He therefore does it better than he could do another kind of work, and so wrongs no one, and more fully achieves the ends of his labor.
5.) He does it more easily, whereas a man who is unaccustomed, unskilled, and ill-equipped toils greatly to accomplish little.
6.) He will carry out his work in an orderly way, while another lives in continual confusion, his business having no fixed time or place, one part of it undercutting another.
Some settled calling or trade of life is therefore best for every person.
Question 1: May a man not have a calling that consists of occasional, uncertain work?
Answer: A man who can have nothing better may do so, provided the works are consistent and within his ability, as a footman may run various errands and a day-laborer may do many kinds of work. But great variety will be a serious inconvenience to him.
Question 2: May a man hold several trades or callings at once?
Answer: Yes, without question, if it serves the common good or his own, injures no one else, and the callings are not so incompatible that one makes him unfaithful in the other. In that case, God does not forbid it.
I answered the question whether a man may change his calling earlier, in Chapter III, Direction 10.
Direction 3. Do not think that a calling can be lawful when the work of it is sinful, nor that you, your labor, or your gain in an unlawful calling will be blessed. An unlawful act is bad enough; an unlawful calling is a life of sin. To make sin a man’s trade, his work, and his livelihood is a most dreadful and ruinous way to live, as with mercenary soldiers who will fight against legitimate authority, right, and innocence for their pay, and murder men for half a crown a day; and those who live by cheating, stealing, oppression, or prostitution, or by sheltering and profiting from such persons; or who live off the sin of drunkards, gamesters, or other sensual vices that they knowingly and willingly sustain.
Direction 4. Do not suppose that because an act is lawful, it is therefore lawful to make a calling of it. It is lawful to jest at the right time and in due measure, but not lawful to be a jester as one’s trade in life. Even if it should prove lawful in some cases to perform a comedy or tragedy, it does not follow that it is lawful to be a stage-player by profession. If a game at cards or dice may be lawful in some cases, it does not follow that it is lawful to be a gamester by trade. The same may be said of many other things.
Direction 5. It is not enough that the work of your calling be lawful, nor even that it be necessary; you must also take special care that it be safe, and not seriously dangerous to your soul. The calling of a vintner or ale-seller is lawful and useful, yet it is so very dangerous that, unless the place or circumstances are exceptional, a man who loves his soul should be reluctant to enter it if he can find a safer way to earn his bread. Sober people bring so little profit, and so much of the gain depends on men’s sin, that it is a constant temptation to those in that trade to become promoters of it. A frail man who can barely keep his footing on solid ground should be reluctant, for a little money, to walk continually on ice and to hazard his soul in a life of such temptations, for the odds are greatly against him.
Direction 6. The first and foremost consideration in choosing a trade or calling, whether for yourself or your children, must be the service of God and the public good. Therefore, all else being equal, the calling that most promotes the public good is to be preferred.
The callings most useful to the public good are those of magistrates, pastors and teachers of the church, schoolmasters, physicians, lawyers, and farmers (ploughmen, graziers, and shepherds). Next to these are mariners, clothiers, booksellers, tailors, and others employed in things most necessary to mankind. Some callings are concerned with matters of so little use, such as tobacco-sellers, lace-sellers, feather-makers, periwig-makers, and many more, that a person who can choose better should be reluctant to take one up, even if such a calling may in itself be lawful. It is a deep satisfaction to an honest mind to spend one’s life doing the greatest good one can; and it is a kind of imprisonment and constant misery to be bound to spend one’s life doing almost no good to others at all, even if one should grow rich in the process.
Direction 7. When two callings contribute equally to the public good, and one of them offers greater wealth while the other is more beneficial to your soul, the latter must be preferred. After the public good, the soul’s advantage must guide your choice. Suppose, for example, that a lawyer were as profitable to the public good as a minister, and that the law is the path to far greater wealth and honor, the sacred calling is still far more desirable for the benefit of your soul. For it is an immense help to be engaged by one’s calling to have the word and doctrine of Christ continually before you, in your mind and on your lips, while others must be content to take it up only now and then, when their hearts have been cooled by the frequent and prolonged demands of their worldly business. In this way, our calling and work becomes, to an honest heart, a continual source of refreshment, preservation, and edifying support for grace.
Similarly, a schoolmaster’s calling is usually poorly paid and very demanding, requiring close and constant attention, yet it is of such great use to the common good and allows the mind so much opportunity to grow in worthy learning, that it is fitter to be chosen and embraced by a well-balanced mind than richer and more honored employments. There is something deeply satisfying about spending the entire day doing so much good.
Direction 8. If at all possible, choose a calling that exercises the body without overwhelming you with cares and labor that strip you of all leisure for the holy and noble pursuits of the mind, and that likewise exercises your mind while still allowing some exercise for the body.
1.) A calling that consumes body and mind so completely as to allow neither mingled thoughts of higher things nor any suitable pause for them is a constant snare and prison to the soul. This is the condition of many who plunge themselves into more and greater business than they can otherwise manage, yet are content to be thus perpetually cut off in their minds from God and heaven, all for the sake of gaining more of the world. Many poor laborers, clothiers, tailors, and others like them, can work with their hands while meditating or conversing about heavenly things without any hindrance to their work, whereas many men in wealthier callings have scarcely room for a single thought or word about God or heaven throughout the day.
2.) On the other hand, if the body does not also have its labor alongside the mind, it will ruin your health, and both body and mind will grow useless.
Direction 9. It is lawful and fitting to seek the profit of your calling, but only in the third place, that is, after the public good, and after your personal good of soul and bodily health. When Scripture says, "Labour not to be rich" (Prov 23:4), the meaning is that you must not make riches your chief end: wealth pursued for fleshly ends must not be your ultimate aim. But riches may be sought in subordination to higher things, that is, you may work in whatever manner tends most to your success and lawful gain, since you are bound to put all your master’s talents to use. Your end, however, must be that you are better equipped to serve God, and that you may do more good with what you have.
If God shows you a way to gain more lawfully than another way, without harm to your soul or to anyone else, and you refuse it in favor of the less profitable way, you cross one of the ends of your calling. You refuse to be God’s steward, refusing to accept his gifts and use them for him when he requires it. You may work to be rich for God, but not for the flesh and sin.
Direction 10. It is not enough to consider which calling and labor is most desirable; you must also consider what you or your children are most fitted for, both in mind and body. A calling that is a blessing to one person may be another’s misery and ruin. A weak body cannot bear labors that require strength, and a dull, heavy mind cannot do work that requires sound judgment and quickness of wit.
It has been a calamity for the church, and the undoing of many ministers themselves, that well-meaning parents, out of love for the sacred work of God, have placed their unfit children in ministry. Many self-conceited persons are also quick to thrust themselves into that holy office on the strength of some slight smattering of knowledge and a poor measure of gifts, overvalued by those who do not understand what so great a work requires.
Be certain you look first at the natural quickness of understanding in your children or yourselves, and then at their grace and piety. Let no one be devoted to the ministry who does not naturally have a sharp understanding and a freedom of expression, otherwise you set him to live by the ruin of souls, the wrong of the church, and the corruption of God’s work, and you make him an enemy to the best of his flock when they value him only as he deserves. And let none be so foolish as to become a preacher of faith, love, and holiness he has never possessed himself.
Even for the calling of physician, no one should be chosen who lacks unusual aptitude, sagacity, and natural quickness of apprehension, otherwise he makes a trade of killing men, for that calling requires a quick and strong power of reasoning that no study can supply where natural acuteness and aptitude are absent. In all callings, then, you must consider not only the will of the child or parents, but their natural fitness of body and mind. As Petrarch writes (Dialogues, Dialogue 41, Book 2): all who now are, or ever were, renowned for character or learning cannot kindle a single mind unless some sparks are already within the soul, which, stirred and helped by the teacher’s breath, can catch the noble tinder of instruction.
Direction 11. Choose no calling, especially one of public consequence, without the advice of judicious, faithful persons already in that calling. They are best able to judge within their own profession. Never resolve on the sacred ministry without the counsel of able ministers; resolve not to become a physician except by the counsel of physicians; and so with the rest. A great many people ignorantly fancy themselves sufficient when they are utterly insufficient, and so live out their days as a wrong and burden to others, in sin and misery to themselves.
Direction 12. If you are called to the poorest and most laborious calling, do not carnally murmur at it because it is wearisome to the flesh, nor imagine that God accepts your work and you any less for it. Follow it cheerfully, and make it your pleasure and joy that you are still in your heavenly Master’s service, even about the lowest things, that he who knows what is best for you has chosen this for your good, and that he tries and values your obedience all the more by how lowly the work you stoop to at his command. But be sure you do it all in obedience to God and not merely out of your own necessity. Every servant must serve the Lord in serving their masters, and from God expect their chief reward (Col 3:22–24 Eph 6:6–7).
Title 2. Directions against Idleness and Sloth
Here I must show you what idleness and sloth are and what their signs are, and then give you directions for conquering them. Sloth means chiefly the indisposition of the mind and body; idleness means the actual neglect or omission of our duties. Sloth is an aversion to labor through a carnal love of ease or indulgence of the flesh. This aversion to labor is sinful when it is a voluntary backwardness to labor that is our duty. Sloth shows itself in two ways:
1. By keeping us from our duty, causing us to delay or omit it.
2. By making us do it slowly and only halfway.
Both of these effects are called idleness, which is the omission or negligent performance of our duties through a flesh-pleasing backwardness to labor.
From this you may see what sloth and idleness are not:
1. It is not slothful or sinfully idle to omit labor you are unable to perform, as when the sick, the aged, and the weak are averse to labor through the power of an irresistible disease or weakness, or when nature is already wearied by as much labor as it can bear.
2. Nor is it sloth when reason allows and requires you to cease your usual labor for the sake of your health, or for some other sufficient cause.
3. Nor when you are unwillingly restrained and hindered by others, as by imprisonment or denial of opportunity: for example, when a magistrate forcibly prevents a preacher, physician, or lawyer from doing what he otherwise should do.
4. If a mistake or sinful error alone keeps a man from his labor, that is a sin, but not this sin of sloth. So also if any sensual vice or pleasure other than love of ease draws him away.
5. If the aversion is only to labor that is no duty to him, it is merely a natural and not a vicious sloth.
Voluntary aversion to the labor of our duty, through indulgence of fleshly ease, is the sinful sloth or laziness I am speaking of.
Sloth and idleness so described are a sin in all persons, but a far greater sin in some than in others. You may know what sloth is most sinful by the following marks:
1. The more sloth is seated in the mind itself, and the less it is seated in the body, the greater the sin. The mind is the nobler part and the immediate seat of sin.
2. The smaller the bodily disorders or temptations that seduce the mind, the greater the sin, for this shows the mind to be the more deeply corrupted and tainted with sloth. One who is under an irresistible bodily indisposition sins not at all (unless he voluntarily brought that condition on himself). But if the body’s indisposition to labor is great yet not irresistible, it is a sin to yield to it, though a smaller sin, all else being equal, as the bodily disease is greater. One who has some scurvy-like weariness or phlegmatic heaviness sins if he does not strive against it as much as he can and as reason requires; not every bodily indisposition excuses a man from all labor so long as he is able to labor in spite of that disease. But if the disease is severe, so that resisting his weariness costs him great effort, his sin is the less.
It was one of Solon’s laws that whoever pursues idleness shall be liable to prosecution by any who wish to accuse him (Diogenes Laertius, Book 1, Section 55, page 34). And of Cleanthes, when asked why he would draw water, it is recorded: "Do I draw water only? Why should I not also dig, and water, and do everything for philosophy’s sake?" (Ibid., Book 7, Section 169, page 473).
The man who has a sound and able body, free of any disease that might indispose him, sins most of all if he is slothful, for he shows the most corrupted mind.
3. The most sinfully slothful person is the most voluntarily slothful, one who strives least against sloth, who loves it most and would not leave it, who is least troubled by it, least repents and mourns over it, and contrives to accommodate his sloth.
4. Sloth is, all else being equal, the worst when it most prevails to the omission or negligent performance of duty. Sloth that only indisposes us but is so far conquered by resistance as not to keep us from duty, or not much or often, is the smaller sin.
5. That sloth is most sinful, all else being equal, which is against the greatest duties. To be backward to the most holy duties, such as praying, hearing, or reading the Word of God, or to duties of public consequence, is a greater sin than to be lazily backward to common, toilsome work.
6. That is the most sinful sloth and idleness which is committed against the greatest motives to labor and diligence. In one respect, a poor man’s sloth is more sinful than a rich man’s, because he is under the pressure of necessity. In another respect, the rich man’s sloth is worst, because he buries the greatest talents and is idle when he receives the greatest wages. A man with many children sins more than another by his idleness, because he wrongs all those he must provide for. A magistrate or pastor of a church sins incomparably more than common people if they are slothful, because they betray the souls of men and sin against the good of many.
Just as it is a greater sin to be lazy about quenching a fire in a city than about some common, trivial business, so it is a far greater sin to be slothful in working out our salvation and making our calling and election sure, when God, and Christ, and heaven, and hell are the motives rousing us to duty, and when the time in which all our work for eternity must be done is so short, than to be slothful when only bodily wants or benefits are the motives we resist.
Yet God’s will is resisted in all such cases, for he forbids us to be "slothful in business." (Rom 12:11)
Sloth is something easily recognized. Its signs are as follows:
1. When the very thought of labor is troublesome and unpleasant, and ease seems sweet.
2. When duty is omitted and left undone because of it.
3. When only the easy part of a duty is chosen, and the harder part is cast aside.
4. When the judgment refuses to believe that a demanding duty is a duty at all.
5. When whatever you do is done unwillingly, with a constant weariness of mind, and there is no eagerness or pleasure in your work.
6. When you accomplish in much time no more than you could do in less, if you had a willing and ready mind.
7. When the reluctant mind shifts duty off with excuses, finds something else to do, or at least delays it.
8. When you choose a condition of greater ease and lesser labor over a more demanding condition that is in other respects better for you, as when a servant would rather live in an ungodly household where there is more ease and plenty, than in a place of greatest advantage for the soul where there is more labor and scarcity.
9. When small obstacles discourage or stop you. "The slothful saith, there is a lion in the way." (Prov 22:13) "His way is an hedge of thorns." (Prov 15:19) "He will not plough by reason of cold." (Prov 20:4)
10. When you make a great matter of a little business, it cannot be done without such preparation and elaborate effort, which reveals a slothful mind. Even "putting his hand to his mouth" and "pulling it out of his bosom" is a business with the sluggard: that is, he makes a great matter of a small one. (Prov 26:15 Prov 19:24)
11. Finally, the fruits of slothfulness typically expose it, in soul, body, and property, for it corrupts, impoverishes, and ruins all. The weeds in his field or garden, the vices of his soul, the sins of his life, the duties omitted or sleepily performed, the disorders of his family or charge, and usually his poverty, all betray him. (Prov 24:30 Prov 12:24 Prov 12:27)
How little have some men, ministers included, to show for all the good they might have done throughout their lives? The work they have done convicts them of idleness.
From all this it is easy to see the shameless folly of the Quakers and certain ignorant country people who rail against magistrates and ministers for living idly, on the grounds that they do not plow or thresh or ply some mechanical trade. As if the labor of their highest calling were no labor at all, but mere idleness! Such is the arrogance of men who condemn what they do not understand. Had they tried it, they would have found that the work of a faithful minister is further from idleness than a thresher’s work is. Does not Christ and the Holy Ghost repeatedly call ministers "labourers, fellow-labourers with Christ, and workmen," and their work "a labour"? (Luke 10:7 1 Cor 3:9 1 Tim 5:17 1 Tim 5:18 2 Tim 2:15 Matt 10:10 1 Cor 3:13–15 1 Cor 9:1 Eph 4:12 Phil 2:30)
From this you may also see:
1. That though all who are able must labor, there is great variety of labors, and all men are not to do the same work. Magistrates, pastors, lawyers, and physicians must labor diligently, but they are not all bound to plow and thresh and perform the most servile labors of those beneath them.
2. That every man must labor in the works of his own calling, "and do his own business," taking as his best employment that to which God calls him, and not presuming to step out of his place and take up the work of other men’s callings. (1 Thess 4:11 2 Thess 3:11)
3. That a man who is paid for his labor by another, such as lawyers, physicians, schoolmasters, and servants, robs those who pay him whenever he withholds through idleness any part of what he is paid to deliver.
Direction 1. The first remedy against sloth is to become well acquainted with the greatness of the sin. No wonder it is committed by those who think it small. I will therefore set out what sloth is.
1. God himself ranks it among heinous sins. "Pride, fulness of bread, and abundance of idleness," which is the very character of the debauched part of the gentry, is identified as Sodom’s sin, the city consumed by fire from heaven. (Ezek 16:49) The Thessalonians were also forbidden to keep company with those who lived disorderly and did not work. (1 Thess 5:12–13 Prov 18:9 Prov 21:25 2 Thess 3:11 Prov 12:24 Prov 19:15 Eccl 10:18)
2. Idleness is a temporary destruction, as to their use, of all the faculties of mind and body that ought to be exercised. It is contrary to nature, for nature made our faculties for use. The idle person buries himself alive. If it is a sin to hide God’s lesser talents, what is it to bury ourselves and all our powers? If it is a sad thing to see a dead man, because he is of no use to the world, is it not a matter of pity and shame to see someone voluntarily dead, one who makes himself useless by his sloth? Should not the churchyard be the dwelling of the slothful, so that he may be nearest in place to those he is already nearest to in condition?
3. Idleness and sloth consume all the mercies of God. You are the barren ground where he sows his seed and none comes up. You return him nothing but a crop of thorns and briars, and such ground is "nigh to cursing," the final curse, "whose end is to be burnt." (Heb 6:8) Does God daily feed, clothe, keep, protect, support, teach, and warn you, all for nothing? Is idleness the work for which he has employed you? Will you charge your Maker with such great imprudence, and your Redeemer with still greater, as if he created and redeemed you to do nothing, or something as bad or worse than nothing? He calls to you: "Why stand you idle?" (Matt 20:3 and 20:6) And the sentence such persons shall receive is terrible: "Thou wicked and slothful servant; cast the unprofitable servant into outer darkness, etc." (Matt 25:26)
4. Idleness is a robbing of God, who is the Lord of us and of all our faculties, and to whom all our service is due. You rob him of the honor and service you might have rendered by your diligence.
5. It is also a robbing of yourselves of all the good, to soul or body, that industry and labor might have gained you. The slothful man lies wishing until he perishes. (Prov 10:26 Prov 18:9 Prov 11:25)
6. It is a robbing of the commonwealth, and of all those to whom your labors or their fruit were due. You are a burden to the commonwealth, like drones in the hive. (Col 3:22)
7. Slothfulness is a great consumer of time, as was shown in Chapter V. You lose not only all the time in which duty is omitted, but much of the time in which you do perform it, since you make no progress and work as if you were not working at all. The person who travels only one mile an hour loses his time just as surely as one who travels two miles in one hour and then sits still for the next. How vast an amount of their lives do idle persons squander! When time is gone, they will better understand the greatness of their sin and loss, though they now make light of it.
8. Idleness is not a single sin but a continuous course of sinning. An idle person is sinning for as long as he is idle, and for some that is a great portion of their lives. It is all the greater a sin because the duration shows that it has not been effectually repented of.
9. Idleness is a destroyer of grace, gifts, and natural abilities, which will rust for want of use. "The slothful is brother to the great waster." (Prov 18:9) Weeds will grow up and choke the fruit.
10. Idleness and sloth are a fruit of flesh-pleasing, and so spring from the most destructive of vices. It is merely to please the flesh that one person is drunk, another gluttonous, another a fornicator, another covetous, and your idleness and sloth is simply the same flesh pleased in another way, which is forbidden equally with the rest. "And if ye live after the flesh ye shall die." (Rom 8:13)
11. Idleness strengthens the flesh against the Spirit by indulging its ease and sloth, making it not only unruly and unfit for service, but dominant and insistent in pursuing its own desires.
12. Idleness is the mother and nurse of many serious sins.
1.) It feeds lust and draws people into fornication, which hard labor would have done much to prevent.
2.) It provides the occasion for foolish sports, vanity, wantonness, and excess of riot, with all the harm that typically follows.
3.) It provides the occasion for idle talk and meddling in other people’s affairs. Paul therefore reproves the idle as busybodies, those who concern themselves with matters that do not belong to them, as twattlers and tale-carriers. (2 Thess 3:11 1 Tim 5:13 1 Thess 4:11) Those who do not do what they should will always be doing what they should not.
4.) It provides the occasion for gluttony, drunkenness, gaming, and all other sensuality.
5.) It even provides the occasion for seditions and rebellions, just as in armies it is the time for mutinies.
13. Idleness is the season of temptation: it is Satan’s seed-time. It is then that he finds the opportunity to tempt people to malice, revenge, and every other villainy that is committed.
14. Idleness is "a disorderly walking," a departure from the way God has appointed us to earn our bread and receive his blessings. (2 Thess 3:10–11)
The extended description of a virtuous woman in Proverbs 31:10 to the end is well worth the study of the slothful: "She seeketh wool, and flax, and worketh willingly with her hands. She is like the merchant’s ships; she bringeth her food from afar. She riseth also while it is yet night, and giveth meat to her household, and a portion to her maidens. She considereth a field and buyeth it: with the fruit of her hands she planteth a vineyard. She girdeth her loins with strength, and strengtheneth her arms. She perceiveth that her merchandize is good: her candle goeth not out by night. She layeth her hands to the spindle, and her hands hold the distaff. She stretcheth out her hand to the poor, yea, she reacheth forth her hand to the needy. She is not afraid of the snow for her household: for all her household are clothed with scarlet. She looketh well to the ways of her household, and eateth not the bread of idleness."
See also (Ps 128:2): "Thou shalt eat the labour of thy hands." (Prov 14:23 Prov 13:11)
I urge our ladies and gentlewomen, who may regard this pattern as beneath them, to remember that it was not a ploughman but a king, and the greatest king Israel ever had, who gave this counsel as received from his mother, and who concludes in verses 30–31: "Favour is deceitful, and beauty is vain: but a woman that feareth the Lord, she shall be praised. Give her of the fruit of her hands; and let her own works praise her in the gates."
But if our gallants could have no food or clothing except what was the fruit of their own hands, it would make a sorry change in their dress and diet! And if their own works must be the basis of their praise, instead of the names of their ancestors, coats of arms, estates, and titles, it would make an equally sorry change in their honors!
Cleanthes, the Stoic philosopher, once brought his earnings into the middle of his companions and said that Cleanthes could support another Cleanthes if he wished. When he was examined in court about how he lived, the gardener he worked for and the woman who baked his food were the witnesses who acquitted him, for they could testify to his hard labor. Hard labor and hard fare fitted him for hard study. (Diogenes Laertius, Book 7, section 170, page 473.)
15. Idleness commonly brings poverty, which is a just and merciful chastisement from God intended to cure the sin. Yet those who fall into poverty through idleness can have little comfort in their want, nor can they expect others to pity them as they would pity the diligent. Indeed, many who are brought to poverty by idleness are then driven by poverty into murmuring and stealing, ruining soul and body, family and reputation alike.
16. Idleness is a murderer of the body. Gluttony and idleness kill more people before their time than almost anything else: no two sins more consistently carry this curse with them.
17. Idleness makes you the shame of creation. Do you not see how all the world is in motion? The sun runs its course for you, the waters flow, the ground brings forth its produce, your cattle labor for you. The most excellent things are the most active, and the most inactive things are the most base, dead, and worthless. Scripture sends the slothful to the ant to learn the lesson of labor (Prov 6:6). Shall the ant, the bee, and every creature stand as witnesses against you to condemn your sloth?
18. Last, idleness disables you from doing good to others. You should "work with your own hands, that you may have to give to him that needeth" (Eph 4:28). And even if you give out of your surplus, at no cost to your own labor, it brings you far less honor and comfort than if you had been purposefully thrifty and industrious in order to do good. The person who pleases his flesh with ease and abundance and then gives his leftovers (however large) to the poor will never have the same comfort and evidence of God’s acceptance and grace as the person who does not pamper his flesh with abundance, but gives to the poor what he has earned by his diligence, what he has withheld from his own disordered desires.
Direction 2. Those persons must be extraordinarily watchful against the sin of idleness whose constitution, unfortunate upbringing, condition of life, or company most strongly tempts them to it. Some people face comparatively little temptation to this sin; others need a great deal of care and resolution to escape it.
1. Those most prone to this sin are those with a phlegmatic constitution, dullness of spirits, or other bodily indisposition that feeds it. Such persons should strive all the more against it, and not yield to any sloth they are able to resist. Though their bodies are like a dull or tired horse, they must use the rod and spur all the more. People of this heavy temperament also tend to sleep more than others, yet they can still resist it and rise early if they choose, even though they have a greater sluggishness than others to overcome.
In the same way, though they are less inclined to labor than more active persons, if they do their best they can accomplish as much as their bodily strength allows. They should strive all the more to do this, unless they have a disease that labor would worsen, because habit does much to increase or decrease their bodily sluggishness, and labor is the most effective means of curing that fleshly torpor which makes them unfit for their work. As Diogenes Laertius records, when Plato saw a man playing dice he rebuked him; and when the man replied, "Why do you rebuke me over so small a matter?" Plato answered, "But habit is no small matter." (Diogenes Laertius, Life of Plato.)
2. Those who have been unhappily raised in idleness have great cause to repent of the sinful life that is past, and to be doubly diligent in overcoming this sin. If their parents have been enemies to them in this way, they should not continue to be enemies to themselves. Though it is commonly the characteristic besetting sin of the children of the rich and proud, who are most unfortunate in their upbringing compared to children of wise, humble, and industrious parents, their own understanding and willingness, by the help of grace, may overcome it.
If your parents had trained you to live by stealing, could you not leave it when you came to know that God forbids it? In the same way, though they bred you in idleness and did their part to ruin you in soul and body, making your soul a sty for sin and your body a vessel of disease, yet if you will do your part you may be recovered, at least in your soul. Custom can conquer the fruits of custom. You cannot do worse than to go on and spend the rest of your life in sin.
If you had been stillborn or killed in infancy, you would have lain idle in the common earth without sin. But to teach a living soul to be idle, to train up the living into conformity with the dead (save only that they eat, and spend, and sin, and carry their ornaments on their backs, while the dead bear theirs as a lasting monument), was great cruelty and treachery on the part of your parents. Yet you must not therefore be equally cruel and treacherous toward yourself.
Callimachus, in his account of Attila, reports that when certain performers came before Attila to display the agility of their bodies in their exercises, he was offended to see such able, active bodies no better employed, and ordered them to be trained in archery and other military skills. When they could not do it, he ordered that they were to have no food but what they took by hunting at a great distance, and drilled them in this way until they became excellent soldiers.
3. Those who abound in wealth and have no need to labor for bodily provision should be especially watchful against this sin. Necessity is a constant spur to the poor, except those who live by begging, who form the second rank of idle persons in the land, but the rich and proud are under a continual temptation to live idly. They need not rise early to labor for their bread; they need not work hard for food or clothing; they have no cries of hungry children to rouse them; they have plenty for themselves and their families without labor, and so they think they may take their ease.
It is a sad state for poor souls when the commands of God count for nothing with them, and cannot move them to diligence as much as poverty or need could, and when God’s service seems to them unworthy of their labor compared with their own. It may be that God will bring you to the necessity of laboring for your daily bread, if you so poorly requite him for your plenty. But it is better that your idleness be cured by grace than by necessity: for when you labor only for your own supply, your own supply is your reward; but when you labor in true obedience to God, it is God who will reward you (Col 3:23–24).
I think with great love and honor of the industrious lives of certain lords and ladies I know, who hate idleness and vanity and spend their time in diligent labors suited to their station.
But it is a matter of deep shame and sorrow to consider the lives of far too many of our gallants. If they were to take a true account of their lives, as God will make them wish they had done when he calls them to account, how many hours, do you think, would be found spent in any honest labor or diligent work worthy of a Christian or a member of the commonwealth, compared with all the rest of their time spent in bed, in dressing, in ornaments, in idle talk, in playing, in eating, in idle wanderings and visits, and in doing nothing, or something far worse?
Erasmus writes in the Colloquies that unless a man is a skilled gambler, an inveterate card-player, a shameless whoremonger, a vigorous drinker, a reckless spendthrift, a debtor and forger of debts, and adorned besides with the French pox, scarcely anyone will believe him a gentleman. See more of this in Chapter V, and read Luke 16 and James 5.
How much of the day does idleness consume, compared with any profitable work! May God make such people know in time how dreadful a thing it is to imitate Sodom, which was punished with the vengeance of eternal fire, rather than to imitate Christ. As for idle beggars, they do not read books, and so I will not write for them; they are in this happier than the idle gentry, in that the law compels them to work and does not leave them to themselves.
4. Those who live in idle company have special reason to fear this sin: such company will entangle you in idleness and greatly hinder you from conscientious diligence.
5. Those servants who live in great men’s houses and are kept more for show and display than for service, having little to do, should especially guard against the sin of idleness. Many such servants count it their happiness to live idly and regard that service as best where they have the least work. But have you nothing to do for yourselves, for soul or body? If you have leisure from your master’s service, you should use it thankfully in God’s service and your own.
Direction 3. Settle yourself in a lawful calling, which will keep you under the necessity of regular and orderly employment. Just as we cannot so easily bring our minds to close attention upon God on weekdays, when common business diverts us, as we can on the Lord’s Day, which is set apart for that purpose and in which we have his appointed ordinances to assist us, so a man who has no established course of labor cannot avoid idleness as well as one who has his regular hours and routine of work to keep him at it. It is a dangerous life to live without a calling.
Direction 4. Take heed of excess in food, drink, and sleep, for these drown the senses, dull the spirits, and load you with a burden of flesh and ill humors, making the body greatly unfit for diligent, useful labor. A full belly and a drowsy brain are unfit for work. It will seem labor enough for such a person merely to carry the load of flesh and phlegm he has accumulated. A pampered body is more disposed to lust and wantonness than to work.
Direction 5. A resolute, manly spirit is an effective remedy against sloth. Resolve, and it will be done. Do not give way to a slothful disposition. Be up and doing: you can do it if you will only resolve. To this end, never let God’s quickening motives, mentioned above, depart from your mind. Think what a sin and shame it is to waste your time; to live like the dead; to bury a rational soul in flesh; to be a slave to so base a thing as sloth; to neglect all God’s work while he sustains and maintains you and looks on; to live in sloth with such miserable souls, so near to judgment and eternity. Such thoughts, well pressed home, will make you stir when a drowsy soul is making an idle body.
Direction 6. Take pleasure in your work, and you will not be slothful in it. Your very horse goes heavily where he goes unwillingly, and goes freely toward where he would be. Your work is either good or bad: if it is bad, avoid it; if it is good, why should you not take pleasure in it? It ought to be pleasant to do good.
Direction 7. To this end, be sure to do all your work as something God requires of you and has promised to reward, and believe in his acceptance of your least labors when they are done in obedience to his will. Is it not a delightful thing to serve so great and good a master, and to do what God accepts and promises to reward? God’s interest in your lowest, hardest, and most servile labor makes it honorable and ought to make it sweet.
Direction 8. Do not let your imagination run after sensual and vain delights, for these will make you weary of your calling. No wonder that foolish young people are idle when their minds are set on sport; and no wonder that sensual gentlemen live idly when they glut themselves with corrupting pleasures. The idleness of such sensualists is more inexcusable than other men’s, because it is not labor itself they object to, but only such labor as is honest and profitable. They can spend more effort in play, dancing, running, hunting, or any vanity than their work would require. The cause is the folly and sickness of their minds, not any disability of their bodies. Those who are busiest in evil are most slothful toward good.
Direction 9. Mortify the flesh and keep it in obedient submission to the soul, and you will not be captivated by sloth. Idleness is simply one way of pleasing the flesh: the man who is a sensual slave to his flesh will please it in whatever way it most desires, one man in fornication, another in ambition, another in ease. But the man who has overcome and mortified the flesh has mastered this appetite along with the rest of its desires.
Direction 10. Keep always in mind that time is short, death makes haste, judgment will be just, and all must be judged according to what they have done in the body; that your souls are precious, heaven is glorious, hell is terrible, the work to be done is varied and great, and hindrances are many; and that it is not idleness but labor that brings comfort when you review your time. This will powerfully expel your sloth.
Direction 11. Call yourself daily or frequently to account for how you spend your time, what work you do, and how you do it. Do not let a single hour or moment pass for which you cannot give your conscience a just account.
Direction 12. Lastly, watch against the slothfulness of those under your charge as carefully as against your own. Some people of rank and standing are diligent themselves and invest their time in the service of God, their king and country, and the good of their souls and families, and I wish there were more such. But if meanwhile their wives, children, and many of their servants spend most of the day and year in idleness, and if those people of rank are guilty of it through failing to make a thorough effort at reform, their burden will prove far greater at the last than they imagined.
In short: although it is the diligence of a believing saint, not that of a covetous worldling, that tends toward the soul’s salvation, and diligence in evil only hastens a man to hell, yet sloth in itself so powerfully feeds vice and so mortally opposes all that is good, and idleness is so broad a course of sin, that every bit of your understanding, resolution, and authority should be brought to bear in curing it in yourself and in others.
Title 3. Directions against Sloth and Laziness in Spiritual Things; and for Zeal and Diligence
Zeal in spiritual things stands opposed to sloth, coldness, and slackness; diligence stands opposed to idleness. Zeal is the fervor or earnestness of the soul. Its primary seat is in the will and affections, stirred by the judgment, and from there it shows itself in practice. It is not a distinct grace or affection in itself, but the vigor and liveliness of every grace and their fervent exercise.
Direction 1. Be sure you understand the nature and use of zeal and diligence, and do not mistake a carnal, degenerate form of zeal for that which is spiritual and genuine.
1. There is a zeal and activity that is merely natural, being the effect of an active physical temperament.
2. There is an affected, hypocritical zeal about things that are good, when people speak and make an outward show as though they were truly zealous, when in fact they are not.
3. There is a selfish zeal: when a proud and self-centered person is fervent about anything that concerns himself, his own opinions, his own honor, his own property, or his friends or interests, anything that is his own.
4. There is a partial, factious zeal: when error, pride, or worldliness has drawn people into a party, and they believe it is their duty or interest to side with the sect or faction they have chosen, they will be zealous for all the opinions and ways of their adopted party.
5. There is a superstitious, childish, carnal zeal for small, morally indifferent, and trivial things, like that of the Pharisees (and all such hypocrites) for their washings, fastings, and other ceremonial observances.
6. There is an envious, malicious zeal against those who hold precedence, who cross your desires, who eclipse your honor in the world, or who contradict you in your opinions and ways, the kind described at large in James 3.
7. There is an irritable, contentious, wrangling zeal that attacks every person who does not conform exactly to your own notions.
8. There is a malignant zeal against the cause and servants of the Lord, which drives people to persecute them. Take care that you do not mistake any of these, or anything like them, for holy zeal.
If you were to make such a mistake, the following evils would follow.
1. Sinful zeal makes people doubly sinful: just as holy zeal is the fervor of grace, so sinful zeal is the intensification and fervor of sin.
2. It honors sin and Satan, as though sin were worthy work and Satan a master worthy of fervent, diligent service.
3. It is the most effective and violent way of sinning, enabling people to do great evil in little time and making them more harmful to others than ordinary sinners are.
4. It blinds the judgment, causing people to take truth for falsehood and good for evil, and disabling reason from doing its proper work.
5. It is the most violent resister of all God’s means; it teaches people to rage against the truth that would convince them, stopping their ears and turning their hearts from counsel that would do them good.
6. It is the most furious and bloody persecutor of the saints and the church of Jesus Christ. It once made Paul exceeding mad against them, and made him "shut them up in prison, and punish them in the synagogues, and compel them to blaspheme, and persecute them even unto strange cities, and vote for their death" (Acts 26:10–11). So it was that "concerning zeal he persecuted the church" (Phil 3:6).
7. It is the turbulent disquieter of all societies, a destroyer of love, a breeder and fomenter of contention, and an enemy to order, peace, and quietness.
8. It greatly dishonors God by presuming to put his name on sin and error, and to attach his authority to all the wickedness it does. Such zealous sinners commit their sin as though in the name of God, fighting against him in ignorance by his own, pretended or abused, authority.
9. It is an impenitent way of sinning. The zealous sinner justifies his sin, pleads reason or Scripture for it, and thinks he is doing well, even that he is serving God, when he is murdering God’s servants (John 16:2).
10. It is a multiplying sin, making people extremely eager to bring all others into the same sinful mind with them: the zealous sinner draws as many into his sin as he can.
Now, even if the misdirected zeal is merely for small and useless things, or for minor controversies or opinions in religion, these evils still follow.
1. It reveals a mind that is grievously unacquainted with the tenor of the Gospel, the mind of Christ, and the practice of the great and substantial things of faith.
2. It destroys charity and peace, and breeds a habit of censuring and abusing others.
3. It brings holy zeal into disrepute in a secondary way, causing the profane to conclude that all zeal is nothing better than the foolish passion of deceived people.
4. It disables those who have it from doing genuine good. Even when they are zealous for holy truth and duty, people will suppose their zeal is of the same character as their erroneous zeal, and so will disregard them.
The marks of holy zeal are these.
1. It is guided by right judgment. It is a zeal for truth and goodness, not for falsehood and evil.
2. It is for God and his church and cause, not merely for ourselves. It is consistent with meekness, self-denial, and patience regarding our own interests, and it causes us to prefer the interest of God above our own (Num 12:3 Exod 32:19 Gal 4:12 Acts 13:9 Acts 13:12).
3. It is always more careful of substance than of circumstance. It prefers great things to small things; it does not contend for minor controversies at the cost of greater truths. It extends to every known truth and duty, but in due proportion, burning hottest in the greatest matters and coolest in the least. It makes people zealous for good works rather than for their disputed opinions.
4. Holy zeal is always charitable. It is not cruel and bloody, nor disposed to harm (Luke 9:55); rather, it is tender and merciful, burning with a desire to win and save souls rather than to hurt bodies (1 Cor 13). Zeal against the sin is joined with love and pity for the sinner (2 Cor 12:21).
5. Yet it excludes that foolish pity which cherishes the sin itself (Rev 2:2, 1 Kgs 15:13).
6. True zeal is tender of the church’s unity and peace. It is not a dividing and tearing zeal; it is first "pure, and then peaceable, gentle, and easy to be intreated, full of mercy and good fruits" (Jas 3:17).
7. True zeal is impartial, and burns just as hot against our own sins, and the sins of our children and other close relations, as against the sins of others.
8. True zeal respects all of God’s commandments. It is not fervent for one and contemptuous of another. It aims at perfection and does not set desire at any lower degree. It makes a person long to be like God, holy as he is holy. It consists principally in the fervor of our love to God, whereas false zeal consists principally in censorious wrangling against other people’s actions or opinions. True zeal works first toward the good, and then rises up against whatever hinders that good.
9. It makes a person diligent in holy duty to God and active in all his work; it does not lie merely in heated thoughts, rigid opinions, or heated speech.
10. It is not a sudden flash but a constant resolution of the soul, like the body’s natural warmth rather than a fever (though the felt intensity varies), and so it matures and strengthens, whereas false zeal only torments and consumes.
Direction 2. When you have become acquainted with the nature of true zeal, consider next its excellency and singular benefits, so that you may come to love and honor it in your heart. To that end, consider the following commendations of it.
1. Zeal, being nothing other than the fervency and vigor of every grace, carries in itself all the beauty and excellency of that grace, and in the highest degree. If love to God is excellent, then zealous, fervent love is most excellent.
2. Holy objects are so great and excellent, so transcendent and of unspeakable consequence, that we cannot be sincere in our estimation and pursuit of them without zeal. When it comes to riches or honors, a cool desire and a dull pursuit might well suffice; but in matters of God, and Christ, and heaven, such cold desires and efforts amount to contempt. To love God without zeal is not to love him at all, because it is not loving him as God. To seek heaven without zeal and diligence is not to seek it, but to despise it. To pray for salvation without any zeal is mere hypocritical babbling rather than true prayer. No desire for Christ, holiness, and heaven is saving unless it places them above all the treasures and pleasures of the world, and whatever does so must have some zeal in it. Thus some degree of zeal is essential to every grace, just as life and warmth are essential to a man.
3. The integrity and honesty of the heart before God consists greatly in zeal. The person who is truly loyal to a friend is zealous on his behalf, not indifferent and cold. To do God’s service with zeal is to do it willingly, heartily, and wholly. To do it without zeal is to do it half-heartedly, leaving out the very life and substance of the duty, for it is the heart that God requires first.
4. Zeal is much of the strength of duty and makes it most likely to achieve its end. The prayer of the faithful that is effectual must be "fervent" (Jas 5:16). Zeal must make us importunate seekers who will take no denial if we are to succeed (Luke 18:1–8). "The kingdom of heaven suffereth violence, and the violent take it by force." We must "strive to enter in at the strait gate, for many shall seek to enter and not be able." Not everyone who strives is crowned, nor does every runner win the prize, only the one who runs so as to prevail.
No wonder we are commanded to love God with all our heart, soul, and might, which is a zealous love; for this is what overcomes all other love and constrains us to dutiful obedience. Experience confirms that it is the zealous and diligent preacher who does good, while the cold and negligent accomplish little. So it is in all other duties: the diligent hand makes rich, and God blesses those who serve him heartily with all their might.
5. Zeal and diligence seize the opportunity that sloth and negligence let slip. They rise with the sun and "work while it is day." They "seek the LORD while he may be found, and call upon him while he is near." They recognize the day of their visitation and salvation; they do not delay but take the "accepted time." The slothful, meanwhile, are still delaying and trifling, not heeding God’s voice while it is "called to-day," but hardening their hearts, sleeping with their "lamps unfurnished," and knocking only when the door is already shut. They stand looking at their work instead of doing it. They are never ready when Christ and mercy are to be received. They keep putting off their duty to another time, until time runs out, their work is undone, and they are undone forever.
6. Zeal and diligence are the best improvers of time and mercy. As they do not delay but seize the present moment, so they do not loiter but do their work thoroughly. As a swift traveler goes farther in one day than a sluggish one in many, so a zealous, diligent Christian will do more for God and his soul in a little time than a negligent dullard in all his life.
It is remarkable to consider what Augustine and Chrysostom accomplished among the ancients; what Calvin, Perkins, Whitaker, Reignolds, Chamier, and many other Reformed divines achieved in very little time; and what Suarez, Vasquez, Jansenius, Tostatus, Cajetan, Aquinas, and many other Papists accomplished by diligence. Meanwhile, millions of men who lived longer have left the world as unknown as they entered it, having never attained the knowledge needed to escape the reproach of brutish ignorance, let alone enough to save their souls from hell. Many others who had diligence enough to acquire some praiseworthy abilities never had diligence enough to use them for any great benefit to others or themselves.
Zeal and diligence are the fruitful, well-tended soil where God sows his seed with the best result, returning him a hundredfold for his mercies and giving him at his coming "his own with usury" (Matt 25:27–28). But sloth and negligence are the grave of mercies, where they lie buried until they rise in judgment against those who despised and wasted them. Aristotle and Plato, Galen and Hippocrates, improvers of nature, will condemn those who slothfully neglect and abuse nature and grace. Even their oxen and horses will stand as witnesses against many who never served God with as much diligence as those beasts served them. Indeed, many gallants of great estates never did as much service for the common good in all their lives as their very beasts have done. Their gifts, their years, and all are lost to them.
7. Zeal and diligence are the victorious enemies of sin and Satan. They do not make peace with sin; they are to it as a consuming fire is to thorns and briars. Zeal burns up lust, covetousness, pride, and sensuality. It works among our sins as diligent weeders work in a garden, pulling up the tares and burning them. It does not stand dallying with sin, nor tasting or eyeing the bait, nor arguing with or listening to the tempter. It casts away the temptation with abhorrence, abstains from the very appearance of evil, hates the garment spotted by the flesh, and promptly quenches the sparks of concupiscence. It charges home and so resists the devil that he flees. Sloth and negligence, by contrast, cherish sin and encourage the tempter, inviting him by their cold resistance.
The vineyard of the sluggard is overgrown with nettles. His heart swarms with noisome thoughts and lusts, and he does not resist them but easily tolerates them. If sinful thoughts possess his mind, he does not rise up with zeal against them, he lacks the heart to cast them out or make any effectual resistance. He starves his soul with fruitless wishes, because his hands refuse to labor. Negligence is the nurse of sin.
8. Zeal and diligence bear down all opposition to duty with power and success. The obstacles that stop a sluggard are as nothing before them. A cart moving slowly is easily stopped by a small stone or any obstruction in its way, while one moving swiftly rolls over everything. The lion that stands in the sluggard’s path is no more than a barking puppy in the path of a diligent, zealous Christian. Cold weather does not stop him from plowing. A mere sneer, a mockery, or a mortal man’s threat will dismay and stop a faint-hearted hypocrite, but these things only serve as oil to the fire, inflaming the courage of the zealous all the more. What seems insuperable to the slothful is a small matter to the zealous. He goes through what the slothful calls impossible; and when the slothful sits still saying "I cannot do this or that," the zealous, diligent Christian does it.
9. Zeal and diligence remove the toil and wearisomeness of duty and make it easy. A quick-spirited, diligent servant finds his work a pleasure, while a lazy one does it in pain and weariness. A spirited horse makes a journey pleasant, while a dull one plods through it painfully. In the same way, reading, hearing, and prayer are easy to the zealous soul, while to another they are an unwelcome burden and chore.
10. Zeal is faithful, constant, and courageous, and therefore greatly pleases God. It stands by him through persecution; the fire does not consume it; many waters cannot quench it. But others are false-hearted, and those whose religion is merely cold will easily be drawn or driven from it. They are so indifferent that a little more of the world thrown into the balance will outweigh Christ in their estimation. The hopes and fears of temporal things prevail with them against the hopes and fears of eternal things. No wonder, then, that God disowns such treacherous servants and dismisses them as unworthy of his household.
Direction 3. Let the great motives of holy zeal and diligence be pressed home and printed on your hearts. Read them over often in some quickening books, so that you may remember them and be moved by them. I have given many such rousing, exciting considerations in the third part of my Saints’ Rest, and in my Saint or Brute, Now or Never, and my sermon against Making Light of Christ, so I will be very brief here. See also the Directions for Redeeming Time earlier, in Chapter V.
1. When you grow cold and sluggish, remember how great a master you serve, should anything be done negligently for God? And remember how good a master you serve, one for whom you can never do too much, nor as much as he deserves, and who will never let you be the loser by your service.
2. Remember that he is always present, in your conversations with others, in your prayers, your reading, and all your duties. Will you loiter in his sight? Even a servant who works only when watched will work while his master stands by.
3. One serious thought of the end and consequence of all your work ought to put life into the dullest soul. Say to your sleepy, frozen heart: Is it not heaven I am seeking? Is it not hell I am avoiding? Can I be cold and sluggish about heaven and hell? Will not my eternal condition follow directly from how I now behave? Is this truly the best I can do for my salvation? Is it not God I have to please and honor, and shall I do it carelessly?
4. One thought of the immense greatness of our work ought to make us zealous and diligent. Think how much knowledge we still must gain, how much of every grace we lack, how many means we must use, and how much opposition and how many temptations we must overcome. A humble sense of our souls’ weakness and the greatness of our sins should make us say that, whatever the rich in grace may do, hard labor befits the poor.
5. Remember how short our working time is, and how uncertain. How swiftly it flies away, how soon it will end. All the time we shall ever have to prepare for eternity is now. Shortly there will be no more praying, no more hearing, no more working on earth. To look into the grave, to go to the house of mourning, to consider that this heart has but a little more time to think and this tongue but a little more time to speak, and that all will end in an endless reckoning, should quicken the coldest heart.
6. Remember how many millions have already been ruined by sloth and negligence. How many are in hell lamenting their slothfulness on earth, even while I am hearing, reading, or praying to prevent the same fate, this alone should wake me from my sloth. What if I could see them and hear their cries? Would that not make me serious? What if one of them had time, opportunity, and hope again as I do now, would he be cold and careless?
7. Think how many millions are now in heaven, every one of whom came there by holy zeal and diligence, and are now enjoying the fruit of all their labor and suffering. Think of the blessed end of all their pains and patience, and how far they are from regretting it, this should stir us up to zeal and diligence.
8. Consider what thoughts all the world will have of holy diligence at last. The best will wish they had been better and had done far more for God and their salvation. The worst will wish, too late, that they had been as zealous and diligent as the best. How earnestly they will knock and cry, "Lord, open to us," when it is all in vain, and say to the watchful, diligent souls, "Give us of your oil, for our lamps are gone out" (Matt 25). Think how glad the most ungodly would then be, if they might but have "died the death of the righteous, and their latter end might be as his!" (Num 23:10). What heart-tearing grief will seize upon them forever, to think how madly they lost their souls and sluggishly drifted to hell, sparing themselves the sweet and holy work that would have prevented it. Will not such forethoughts awaken even the most sluggish and stupefied souls, if they will only follow those thoughts through to the end?
9. Remember that you must be zealous and diligent in this, or in nothing, for there is nothing else worthy of your earnestness compared to this. To be ardent and laborious for perishing vanities is a disgrace to your mind; it will prove a disappointment and leave you at last in shame and sorrow. But holy diligence will repay all your pains.
10. Remember also that you have already been slothful and negligent too long. How do you truly repent of your former sloth if you remain just as slothful still? Are you grieved to think how many duties slothfulness has crowded out, how many it has killed and frustrated and reduced to nothing, and how much grace, mercy, and comfort it has already cost you, and how much better your condition would be had you lived in as much holy diligence as the best person you know? And will you still be slothful?
11. Remember that your life, health, mind, and gifts have been given for no other purpose than to use your present duty to prepare for everlasting joy. All of God’s mercies bind you to be diligent. Every ordinance, every help and means of grace, has been given to advance you in the work. Sun and moon and air and earth all attend you with their aid. And will you still be cold and sluggish, and frustrate all these means and mercies?
12. Remember how diligent your enemy is: Satan "goeth about even night and day, like a roaring lion seeking to devour." And will you be less diligent in resisting him?
13. Think what an example of diligence Christ himself has left you, and how laboriously the blessed Paul and all the holy servants of Christ followed their Master’s work. Did they pray and watch and labor as slothfully as you do?
14. Remember how hot and earnest you once were in your sin. And will you now be cold and negligent in your duty, when God has set you in a better way?
15. Observe how eager and diligent worldlings are for the world, pleasure-seekers for their sports and pleasures, proud persons for their greatness and honor, and hostile persons in opposing the Gospel of Christ and their own and other men’s salvation. Look at them, and think what a shame it is to be more cold and slack than they are for God.
16. Observe how an awakening pang of conscience, or the near sight of death, can rouse even the wicked to some degree of serious diligence for a time, so that by their confessions, cries, promises, and changes, while the fit was upon them, they seemed more zealous than many who were sincere. Shall not saving grace do more for you than a fit of fear can do for the ungodly?
17. Remember how serious a matter it is, and what it indicates, to be cold and slothful. If sloth is dominant enough to keep you from a holy life, it is damnable. A spirit of slumber is a most dreadful judgment. But even where it does not so prevail, it still signals, even in a child of God, a great weakness of soul, and foretells some sharp affliction if God intends to restore you by a cure. The decay of natural warmth is a sign of old age and is accompanied by the decay of all the body’s powers, followed by sickness and pain. Just as you will put the rod or spur to your horse when he grows dull and sluggish, expect, when you grow cold and dull, to feel the spur of some affliction to make you stir and mend your pace.
18. Remember that your sloth is sinning against your knowledge, against your experience, and against your own covenants, promises, and profession, and is therefore a greatly aggravated sin. These and similar serious thoughts will do much to stir a slothful soul to zeal and diligence.
Direction 4. Do not drown your hearts in worldly business or delights, for these breed a loathing, an aversion, and a weariness toward holy things. The two are so contrary to each other that the mind cannot be eagerly set on both at once; as it savors the one, it more and more loses its taste for the other. There is no heart left for God when other things have carried it away.
Direction 5. Do everything you can to raise your hearts to the love of God and a delight in holy things, and then you will not be slothful, weary, or negligent. Love and delight are the most excellent remedy against a slow and reluctant performance of duty. Once you know how good it is to walk with God and do his work, you will do it cheerfully.
Direction 6. A hidden root of unbelief is the mortal enemy of zeal and diligence; labor for a well-grounded faith in the word of God and the world to come, and stir that faith into active exercise when your slothful heart needs rousing. When the heart secretly questions, What if there is no life to come? What if the grounds of religion are unsound?, this withers the vigor of all endeavor. It inclines people to serve God only with hypocritical half-measures and mental reservations, and leads them to resolve on no more religion than is compatible with present, fleshly comfort.
Direction 7. Take heed of debauching conscience by venturing on doubtful things, and far more by known and willful sin. Once conscience is trained to comply with sin and is overmastered in one thing, it will perform its duty well in nothing; zeal will quickly be extinguished. Diligence dies when conscience is corrupted or has fallen asleep. (Rom 14:21–22; 1 Cor 5:6; Eph 4:29–30).
Direction 8. Live in a constant expectation of death. Do not foolishly flatter yourself with groundless notions that you will live long. There is great power in the nearness of death to rouse a drowsy soul, and great force in the expectation of long life to make even good people grow more negligent and careless.
Direction 9. Live among warm and serious Christians, especially in your closest friendships. The zeal of one person has very great power to kindle zeal in others, just as fire kindles fire. Serious, wholehearted, diligent Christians are excellent helps toward making us serious and diligent ourselves. One who travels with quick travelers will be willing to keep pace with them, and tired stragglers are drawn forward by the company; whereas one who travels with the slothful will go as slowly as they do. (Prov 22:24–25; Prov 27:17; Heb 3:13; Heb 10:24–25; Rom 15:14).
Direction 10. Lastly, make frequent use of quickening means, and live, if you can attain it, under a quickening, zealous minister. There is life in the Word of God, and when it is opened and applied with liveliness it puts life into the hearers. Read the holy Scriptures, and such lively writings as help you to understand and practice them. Just as going near the fire is our way of curing numbness when we are cold, so reading a portion of a warm and quickening book will do much to warm and quicken a benumbed soul. It is no small help toward rousing us to prayer or meditation and putting life into us before we draw nearer to God in those duties.
I have found it a great help in my own studies and preaching. When working on my own heart would not serve the turn, when I could not wake myself to serious fervency, but everything I did was cold and dull because all within me was cold and dull, I have taken up a book far warmer and more serious than myself, and reading it has recovered my heat; and my warmed heart has then been fitter for my work.
Christians, beware of a cold, dull, and heartless religion, and count no effort too great to cure it. Death is cold, and life is warm; and labor itself is what best excites it.
CHAPTER 32
DIRECTIONS ABOUT SPORTS AND RECREATIONS, AND AGAINST EXCESS AND SIN THEREIN
Direction 1. If you would escape the sin and danger into which men commonly fall through unlawful sporting under the pretense of lawful recreation, you must understand what lawful recreation is and what its proper end and use are. No wonder if you sin when you do not know what you are doing.
There is no doubt that some sport and recreation is lawful, indeed necessary, and therefore a duty for some people. Lawful sport or recreation is the use of some natural thing or action not forbidden to us, for the refreshing of the natural spirits through the imagination and the due exercise of our natural faculties, thereby fitting body and mind for ordinary duty to God. It is, in short, some form of delightful exercise.
1. We do not call unpleasant labor sport or recreation, even though it may be better and more necessary.
2. We do not call every delight sport or recreation: eating and drinking may be delightful, and holy things and duties may be delightful, yet they are not properly sports or recreations. It is the imagination that is chiefly delighted by sports.
All the following conditions are necessary for a sport or recreation to be lawful; the absence of any one of them makes it unlawful.
Qualification 1. The end you truly intend in using it must be to fit yourself for your service to God, that is, either for your calling, for his worship, or for some work of obedience in which you may please and glorify him. "Whether ye eat or drink, or whatever you do, do all to the glory of God." Recreation stands in the same relation to your duty as a mower’s sharpening of his scythe: it exists to make you fit to do your work.
Qualification 2. The person who uses recreation must therefore be one who is heartily devoted to God and his service, who genuinely lives to do his work and to please and glorify him in the world, which none but the godly truly do. No carnal, ungodly person who has no such holy end can use any recreation lawfully, because he does not use it toward a right end. The end is essential to the moral goodness of any action, and an evil end necessarily makes the action evil. "Unto the pure all things are pure (that is, all things not forbidden), but unto them that are defiled and unbelieving is nothing pure, but even their mind and conscience are defiled."
Question: But must all wicked men therefore abstain from recreation?
Answer:
1. Wicked men are those who will not obey God’s law even when they know it, and so they do not inquire what they should do with any sincere purpose of obeying. But if they were willing to obey, what God commands them immediately is to forsake their wickedness and become his servants, and then there would be no room for this question.
2. But if they continue in a sinful, ungodly state, it is pointless to work out how they may amuse themselves without sin. We may still tell them, however, that if a sport is materially lawful, it is not the matter itself that they are bound to forsake, but the sinful end and manner. Until that is reformed they cannot but sin.
Qualification 3. A lawful recreation must be a means fittingly chosen and used toward that end. If it has no capacity to fit us for God’s service in our ordinary callings and duty, it cannot be a lawful recreation for us. Though it may be lawful for another person whom it genuinely helps, it is unlawful for us.
Qualification 4. All recreations are therefore unlawful that are themselves preferred over our callings, or that are used by someone who lives idly, in no calling, and has no ordinary work that creates a need for them. Such means are entirely unfit; they exclude the end instead of advancing it.
Qualification 5. All sports are therefore unlawful that are used only to delight a carnal imagination and have no higher end than to please the sickly mind that loves them.
Qualification 6. All sports are therefore unlawful that genuinely unfit us for the duties of our callings and the service of God, that, weighing benefit and harm together, hinder us as much or more than they help us. This is the case of all voluptuous wantons.
Qualification 7. All sports are unlawful that consume any part of the time we ought to spend on greater works: this includes those that are unseasonable (such as on the Lord’s Day without necessity, or when we should be at prayer or some other duty), and those that take up more time than the purpose of recreation strictly requires, which is all too common.
Qualification 8. If a recreation is profane, making sport of holy things, it is a mockery of God, a villainy unworthy of any of his creatures, and it exposes them to his heaviest vengeance. The children who made sport of calling the prophet "bald head" were slain by bears (2 Kgs 2:23).
Qualification 9. Sports used to the wrong of others are unlawful: for example, players who defame and reproach other men, or hunters and hawkers who trample poor men’s corn and hedges.
Qualification 10. It is sinful to make sport of other men’s sinning, or to act it out ourselves so as to become partakers in it, a failing all too common among comedians and other profane wits.
Qualification 11. Unclean and obscene recreations are unlawful, when filthiness or wantonness is represented without due expression of its odiousness, or is accompanied by obscene words or actions. "But fornication, and all uncleanness or covetousness, let it not be once named among you, as becometh saints; neither filthiness, nor foolish talking, nor jesting" (Eph 5:3).
Qualification 12. Those sports are unlawful that occasion the multiplication of idle words about them and draw players into foolish, needless, unprofitable chatter.
Qualification 13. Those sports are sinful that plainly tend to provoke ourselves or others to sin: to lust, swearing, cursing, railing, fighting, or the like.
Qualification 14. Those are also sinful that are an exercise of covetousness, designed to win other men’s money from them, or that tend to stir up covetousness in those you play with.
Qualification 15. Cruel recreations are also unlawful: taking pleasure in watching duelers, fighters, or any who abuse one another, or any other creatures that needlessly torment each other.
Qualification 16. Excessively costly recreation is also unlawful. Since you are only God’s stewards and must give account to him for all you have, it is sinful to spend it needlessly on sports.
Qualification 17. Unnecessary recreations forbidden by your lawful governors are unlawful. Even if they were previously lawful to you, they are no longer so; for your king, your pastor, your parents, and your masters have authority to govern and restrain you in such matters, and you must obey them.
Qualification 18. Finally, when you have a choice among several recreations, you must choose the most fitting one. If you choose one that is less suitable and profitable when a more suitable one was available, that is your sin, even though what you chose would have been lawful if you had had no other option.
By all this it is easy to judge our common stage-plays, gaming, cards, dice, and various other such sports. If they possess even one of these evil qualities they are sinful, and they are rarely used without very many of them.
1. They are too commonly used by men who never intended to fit themselves for their work and duty by them, indeed by men who do not live at all to please and glorify God, who have no idea what it means to be obediently devoted to his service, and who do not live in any steady, honest labor but make a virtual trade of their recreations, making them the chief occupation of the day.
2. They are sports unfit for the ends of lawful recreation, as will readily appear on impartial examination. Horace long ago remarked what an uproar attends the watching of games and stage performances. It is either your body or your mind that most needs recreation. Either you are a sedentary person or you have a calling of bodily labor. If you are sedentary, a student, a scribe, or someone in a similar occupation, it is your body that most needs exercise and recreation, and labor is better suited to you than sport, or at least some active, vigorous sport.
In that case, to sit at cards, dice, or a stage-play is not to exercise your body but to increase its need of exercise. It does not stir your limbs; it does not warm your blood; it does not help digestion, circulation, or the body’s other functions. It does you far more harm than good even as to your health alone.
But if you are a hard laborer who needs bodily rest and mental recreation, or are lame or sickly and cannot take bodily exercise, then surely a hundred profitable exercises are readily at hand that are far better suited to your condition. You have books you are bound to read, above all the Word of God, and books that profit your soul, and books that increase your knowledge of the world: history, geography, and all the arts and sciences. Should not any one of these be more pleasurable to you than dice, cards, and plays?
3. At least it is plain that these are not the fittest recreations for anyone who intends a lawful end. If you are students or idle gentlemen, would not walking, riding, shooting, or some honest bodily labor that joins pleasure and profit together be a fitter form of exercise? Or if you are laboring people who need only refreshment for your minds, should you not take pleasure in God, in Scripture, in holy conversation, meditation, or good books? Or if you truly need relief from both, have you not profitable history or geography to read?
Have you not herbs, flowers, trees, beasts, birds, and other creatures to observe? Have you not fields, gardens, meadows, or woods to walk in? Have you not your close relations to delight in, your wives, children, friends, or servants? May you not talk with good, wise, and cheerful people about things that are both pleasant and edifying? Has God given you such an abundance of lawful pleasures, and will none of them, nor all of them together, serve your need, without resorting to unlawful ones, or at least unfitting ones, which are therefore unlawful?
All these pleasures are undoubtedly lawful; but cards, dice, and stage-plays are at best very questionable. Among wise and learned and good men, and no small number of these, they are condemned as unlawful. Should someone who fears God and loves his own salvation choose so doubtful a sport when such abundance of clearly lawful ones is available?
Among the epistles of Boniface of Mainz there is a council held under Carloman, king of France, which says in the king’s name that hunting, roaming through the forests with dogs, and the keeping of hawks and falcons are all forbidden to the servants of God. These pursuits are surely better than cards and dice, and yet some priests now indulge in those too freely.
If you are proud or rash enough to reply, "Why should I leave my sport for another man’s opinions and judgment?", let me tell you something that should shame both your reply and yourself, if you can still blush.
1.) It is not some whimsical, odd fanatic that I cite against you, nor a lone divine, but the judgment of the ancient church itself. The fathers and councils condemn Christians, and ministers especially, who attend spectacles, that is, who watch stage-plays, or engage in dicing.
2.) Even the oldest canons of our own Church of England forbid dicing to the clergy, on the grounds that it was regarded as evil or at least disreputable.
3.) Many laws of religious princes likewise condemn these practices.
4.) A great number of the most learned and holy divines condemn them.
5.) Even the most sober and learned among the Papists condemn them.
6.) And you are not ignorant of how great a number of the most religious ministers and people in your own age and place stand against them.
Does the judgment of the ancient church, of councils and fathers, of the most learned Protestants and Papists, and of the most religious people, together with many ancient laws and canons, carry no weight with you in a case like this? Will you cling to something you admit to be unnecessary, against the verdict of so many who account it sinful? Are you and your playfellows wiser and more learned than all of these? Is it not the height of pride for unstudied, empty men to prefer their sensual conceits over such a united stream of weightier and wiser judgments?
Read only Dr. J. Reignolds’s treatise against stage-plays, written against Albericus Gentilis, and you will see what a multitude of witnesses stand against you. And if the judgment of Voetius, Amesius, and other learned men against all lots used in play carries no authority with you, at least consider this: even Mr. Gataker and others who write in defense of their lawfulness in that respect still set out the remaining conditions required to make such lots lawful, conditions that utterly condemn the common use of cards and dice, and still more condemn our gamesters. Every sober divine I have ever read or heard condemns these practices. Are you wiser than all of them?
4. Beyond all this, your own consciences know that you are so far from using these sports to fit you for your callings that you either live idly outside any calling, or you place your sports before your calling. You have no desire for your work, because your mind is so occupied with play. You have no desire for home or family, and you grow weary of your business because your sports have captured your hearts. And you are so far from using recreation to prepare you for any holy duty that it utterly unfits you for it, and corrupts your hearts with a kind of sensual delight that makes them more resistant to everything good, so much so that many of you grow so far gone as to hate and scorn what is good altogether. That is the benefit these pastimes bring you.
5. And you cannot but know what a time-wasting sin this is. Grant that the game were as lawful as could be, is it lawful to spend so many hours on it? As though you had neither souls, nor bodies, nor families, nor estates, nor God, nor death, nor heaven to attend to?
6. Consider also how much profaneness and abuse of others appears in many stage-plays: how much wantonness and amorous folly, how much representation of sin in a manner designed to entice people toward it rather than make it odious, making sport and mockery of sin, and much else of the same kind. Cards and dice are the habitual exercise of covetousness, the occasion of endless idle chatter and foolish babbling over every throw and every card, and often the occasion of cursing, swearing, railing, and hatred toward those who win your money; and they have not infrequently led to fighting and even murder itself. And even your hunting is commonly so costly a recreation that the expense of keeping a pack of hounds would support a poor family now in want, quite apart from the time it also consumes.
One of the Roman laws of the Twelve Tables reads: a prodigal shall be forbidden the management of his own estate.
The case is therefore clear: our gamesters and licentious, sportful gallants are a sort of people who have blinded their minds, seared their consciences, and despise the laws and presence of God. They forget death and judgment, live as if there were no life to come, neglect their miserable souls, and find no delight in the Word or holy worship of God, nor in the anticipation of eternal joys. They therefore seek their pleasure in such foolish sports, and spend those precious hours in these vanities, hours which God knows they urgently need to spend in repenting of their sins, cleansing their souls, and preparing for another world.
If any impenitent gamester or idle time-waster should still reply, "I will not believe that my cards, dice, or plays are unlawful. I use them only to fit me for my duty. Would you have all men live like hermits or anchorites without any pleasure?", I answer only with this reasonable request. Set yourselves as dying men in the presence of God and in sight of eternity, and provide a true answer to the following questions: an answer your own consciences will dare to stand by at the bar of God.
Question 1: Do you not think in your conscience that your Maker and Redeemer, his work and service, your family and calling, and the anticipation of heaven are worthier objects of delight for a sober mind than cards or stage-plays? And what can it be but a vain and sinful mind that makes these toys so pleasant to you, and the thoughts of God and heaven so unpleasant?
Question 2: Does not your conscience tell you that it is not to fit you for your calling or God’s service that you use these sports, but only to delight a carnal imagination? Does not conscience tell you that it is more the pleasure than any benefit to your soul or body that draws you to them? Do you work so hard or study so hard throughout the rest of the day that you need so much recreation to refresh you?
Question 3: Does not your conscience tell you that if your sensual imagination were cured, it would be a more profitable recreation for your body or mind to take some sober bodily exercise confined to its proper limits of time, or to turn to a variety of labor or study, than to sit at these idle games?
Question 4: Do you think that either Christ or his apostles used stage-plays, cards, or dice, or ever encouraged such a cast of mind as is addicted to them? And was not David as wise as you, who took his pleasure in the Word of God and in melodious praise?
Question 5: Does your conscience not tell you that your delight is more in your plays and games than it is in God? And that these sports do nothing to increase your delight in God, but rather unfit and indispose you for it? And yet every "blessed man’s delight is in the law of the LORD, and in it he meditateth day and night." Do you do so?
Question 6: Do you spend as much time in praying, reading the Word of God, and meditating on it as you do in your sports and recreations? Do you not rather shuffle this over, and put God off with a few hypocritical, heartless words, so that you may get back to your sports or something else you love more?
Question 7: Does your conscience not tell you that this precious time could be far better spent in the works God has appointed you to do? And that your sinful soul has need enough to spend it on far greater matters? Does it become someone who has sinned so long, who has so little assurance of pardon and salvation, who is near another world and so unready for it, to sit at cards or hear a stage-play when he should be making ready and getting assurance of his peace with God?
Question 8: Would you want to be found at cards or plays when death comes? If it were this day, would you not far rather be found engaged in some holy work or profitable labor?
Question 9: When you are dying, will it bring you more comfort to look back on the time you spent at cards, plays, and vanity, or on the time you spent serving God and preparing for eternity?
Question 10: Do you dare to pray to God to bless your cards, dice, and plays to the good of your soul or body? Would your conscience not tell you that this would be mockery of God, praying for what you do not truly intend, and what your pleasures are wholly unfit for? And yet no recreation is lawful which you may not lawfully pray for a blessing upon.
Question 11: If you are sure yourselves that you do not sin in your games or sports, are you equally sure your companions do not? That they bring no lust or vanity of mind to stage-plays, no covetousness, no sinful pleasure, no passion at cards or dice? If you say, "We are not bound to keep all other men from sin," I answer: you are bound to do your best toward it; you are bound not to contribute willingly to their sin; and you are bound to give up a thing that is in itself morally neutral and no duty of yours, in order to avoid scandalizing or tempting another.
If Paul would never eat flesh while he lived rather than cause a weak person to offend, should not your sports be subject to at least as great a charity? He says, "It is good neither to eat flesh, nor to drink wine, nor any thing whereby thy weak brother stumbleth, or is offended, or made weak." (Rom 14:21 1 Cor 8:13)
Objection: Then we must give over our meat, drink, clothing, and everything.
Answer: It does not follow that we must forsake our duty to prevent another man’s sin, simply because we must forsake our pleasure in things indifferent. If you truly understood what sin is, and what it means to save or lose a soul, you would not make sport of other men’s sin, nor so casually contribute to their damnation, nor regard your sensual pleasure as a sufficient excuse. In such cases, "we that are strong ought to bear the infirmities of the weak," that is, to feel for them as we would for children in their weakness, "and not to please ourselves" to their hurt. "Let every one of us please his neighbour, for his good to edification," that is, prefer the building up of another’s soul over the pleasure of your bodies. "For even Christ pleased not himself." If Christ lost his life to save men from sin, will you not lose your sport for it?
Question 12: What kind of men are most addicted to your games and plays, and what kind of men avoid and oppose them? Are there not more fornicators, drunkards, swearers, cursers, those who covet other men’s money, and profane neglecters of God and their souls among gamesters and players than among those who are against them? Judge by the fruits.
What I have said to idle gamesters applies proportionally to voluptuous youths who run after wakes, May-games, dancings, and revellings, and who are carried by the love of sports and pleasure away from the love of God, the care of their salvation, the love of holiness, and the love of their callings, and into idleness, riotousness, and disobedience to their superiors. For the cure of this voluptuousness (besides what is said in Chapter IV, Part 9), consider the following.
1. Do you not know that you have higher delights to mind? Are these toys fitting for a noble soul that has holy and heavenly matters to delight in?
2. Do you not feel what a plague the very pleasure is to your affections, how it bewitches and befools you, and makes you fall out of love with holiness and unfit for anything good?
3. Do you know the worth of those precious hours you play away? Have you nothing better to do with them? Look inward to your soul, and forward to eternity, and think more carefully.
4. Is sport what you most need? Do you not far more need Christ, and grace, and pardon, and preparation for death and judgment, and assurance of salvation? Why then are these not your business?
5. Do you not have a God to obey and serve? Does he not always see you? Will he not judge you? Alas, you do not know how soon. Though you are now merry in your youth, and your "heart cheer thee, and thou walk in the ways of thy heart, and the sight of thy eyes, yet know thou that for all these things God will bring thee into judgment." (Eccl 11:9)
6. Observe in Scripture what God judges of your ways. "We ourselves were sometimes foolish, disobedient, deceived, serving divers lusts and pleasures." (Titus 3:3) "Fly youthful lusts: but follow after righteousness, faith, charity, peace with them that call on the Lord out of a pure heart." (2 Tim 2:22) And read also (1 Pet 4:1–4 and 2 Pet 3:3). "Lovers of pleasure more than lovers of God." (2 Tim 3:4)
7. You are only preparing for future sorrow, whether that sorrow comes through repentance or destruction. The greater your pleasure now, the greater will be your grief and shame when you look back on it.
Having spoken this much for the cure of sinful sports, I proceed to direct the more sober in their recreations.
Direction 2. When you understand the true nature and purpose of recreations, work to discover just how much, and what sort of recreation is needful for you in particular. In determining this, you must consider: 1. your bodily strength; 2. your mind; 3. your labors. Once you have settled what and how much is needful and fitting to help you in your duty, allow it its proper time and place as you do your meals, and take care that you do not let it encroach upon your duty.
Direction 3. Ordinarily join profit and pleasure together, so that you lose no time. I do not know one person in a hundred, or in many hundreds, who needs any game at all, since there is such a variety of better exercises at hand to recreate them. It is a sin to idle away any time that we could better improve.
I confess my own nature was as much addicted to playfulness as most men’s, and my judgment allows me as much recreation as is needful for my health and work, and no more. But for all that, I find no need of any game to recreate me. When my mind needs refreshment, I have a variety of refreshing books, friends, and tasks to supply it. When my body needs it, the hardest labor I can bear is my best recreation: walking takes the place of games and sports, being as profitable to my body and more profitable to my mind. If I am alone, I can use that time in meditation; if with others, I can use it in profitable, cheerful conversation.
I do not condemn all sports or games in others, but I find none of them to be the best for myself. When I observe how far the temper and life of Christ and his best servants were from such recreations, I avoid them with all the more suspicion. I see very few people who do not find them distasteful in ministers, even shooting, bowling, and other more healthful games, to say nothing of chess and similar pastimes that do not serve the purpose of recreation at all.
There is therefore something in it about which our very nature has its misgivings. A student who needs chess or cards to please his mind, I suspect, has a carnal and empty mind. If God, and all his books, and all his friends cannot suffice for this, there is some disease that should be cured rather than pleased. And for the body, it is a different kind of exercise that truly benefits it.
Direction 4. Watch against inordinate, sensual delight, even in the most lawful sport. Excess of pleasure in any such vanity corrupts and befools the mind. It puts it out of relish with spiritual things and turns it away from God, and heaven, and duty.
Direction 5. To this end, keep watch over your thoughts and imagination, so that they do not run after sports and pleasures. Otherwise you will be like children who are thinking of their sport, and longing to be at it, when they should be at their books or their business.
Direction 6. Avoid the company of revellers, gamesters, and such time-wasters. Do not come among them, lest you be ensnared. Keep company instead with those who delight themselves in God.
Direction 7. Remember death and judgment, and the necessities of your souls. Such sports usually seem like foolishness to serious men, who say of this mirth, as Solomon did, "it is madness." It is great and serious subjects that make men serious. Death and the world to come, when they are soberly thought on, put the mind quite out of relish with foolish pleasures.
Direction 8. Be painful in your honest callings. Laziness breeds a love of sports; when the slothful flesh must be pleased with ease, it must be further pleased with vanities.
Direction 9. Delight in your relations and family duties and mercies. If you love the company and converse of your parents, children, wives, or kindred as you ought, you will find more pleasure in talking with them about holy things or honest business than in foolish sports. But adulterers who do not love their wives, unnatural parents and children who do not love one another, and ungodly masters of families who do not love their duty, are put to seek their sport abroad.
Direction 10. See to the sanctifying of all your recreations. Having chosen those that are truly suited to your need, do not turn to them before you need them, nor use them beyond your need. Also make sure you lift up your hearts secretly to God for his blessing on them, and mix them throughout, as far as you can, with holy things, holy thoughts or holy speech.
As for music, which is a lawful pleasure, I have known some who thought it profane to use it privately or publicly with a psalm, yet who had no scruple about using it in common mirth, when in fact all our mirth should be sanctified as fully as possible. All things should be done to the glory of God, and Scripture gives us far more warrant for the holy use of music, both public and private, than for any other use of it whatsoever. It is the particular excellence of melody and music that they are recreations which can be more aptly and profitably sanctified by application to holy uses than any other. I would think them of little worth at all if I could not use them for the holy exhilarating or elevating of my soul, or to move it in affection toward God, or to rouse it to duty.
Direction 11. The sickly and the melancholy, who are usually least inclined to sport, have far more need of recreation than others, and may therefore allow it a much larger time than those who are in health and strength. This is because they take it only as medicine to restore them to health, intending to reduce it again once they have recovered.
Direction 12. Be far more severe in regulating yourselves in your recreations than in censuring others for using some sports you dislike. You may not know their case, and reasons, and temptations. But as for the idle, time-wasting, sensual sporter, everyone should look on such a person with pity as a miserable wretch.
CHAPTER 33
DIRECTIONS AGAINST APPAREL, AND AGAINST THE SIN THEREIN COMMITTED
Direction 1. Fitness is the first thing to be respected in your apparel, to make it answer the ends for which it is appointed. The ends of apparel are:
1. To keep the body warm.
2. To keep it from being hurt.
3. To adorn it soberly, so far as befits the common dignity of human nature and the special dignity of your station.
4. To cover those parts which nature has made a matter of shame, and which modesty requires to be hidden.
The fitness of apparel consists in these things:
1. It must be fitted to your body, as your shoe to your foot, your hat to your head, and so on.
2. It must be suited to your sex: men should not wear what is proper to women, nor women what is proper to men.
3. It must be suited to your age, the young and old being generally distinguished by it.
4. It must be suited to your means, and not exceed them.
5. It must be suited to your station or office.
6. It must be suited to its use and purpose: to cover your nakedness so far as health, modesty, or decency requires; to keep you from cold; to protect you from harm in your labor (as the shoe protects the foot and the glove the hand); and for sober ornament, as noted above.
Direction 2. Among the ends and uses of apparel, the greatest is to be preferred; ornament, being the least, must not be set against any of the rest. Those who, for the sake of ornament, (1.) leave uncovered any part that should be covered; or (2.) go so lightly clothed as to harm and endanger their health, as our semi-Evites, or half-naked gallants, do; or (3.) either injure their bodies (as our strait-laced fashionists do), or disable themselves from labor, travel, or proper exercise, through wearing clothes made more for appearance than use, all such people defeat the very ends of clothing.
Direction 3. Do not cultivate singularity in your apparel; that is, an odd and conspicuous difference from all others of your own rank and quality, unless their fashions are evil and intolerable (in pride, immodesty, levity, and the like), in which case your singularity is your duty. An unnecessary affectation of singularity shows:
1. A weakness of judgment.
2. A pride in the very thing you affect.
3. A placing of duty in matters that are morally indifferent.
On the other hand, imitating proud or immodest fashions:
1. Encourages others in sin.
2. Reveals a carnal, proud, or compromising mind that will displease God himself to humor other people and avoid their contempt and low opinion.
Direction 4. Do not fall into sordid filth, slovenliness, or ridiculous, whimsical, squalid fashions under pretense of avoiding pride. For:
1. This betrays great weakness of judgment.
2. It makes your judgment, in the eyes of those who perceive it, more contemptible and less useful to them in other matters.
3. It hardens people in their own excess when they conclude that only eccentricity, folly, or superstition is reproving them.
4. You sin by dishonoring human nature. God has placed a special honor upon humanity and intends that we honor it ourselves; this is why he appointed clothing after the fall. Just as nakedness wrongs God in his creature, so does clothing that is excessively squalid or ridiculous.
Direction 5. Be far more suspicious of pride and excess in apparel, as the more common and dangerous extreme. Human nature is incomparably more prone to this than to the opposite fault, and many hundreds, if not thousands, sin through excess for every one who sins through defect. This manner of sinning is also more dangerous. On this I will show: (1.) how pride in apparel appears, and (2.) what its sinfulness consists in.
1. Pride appears in apparel when the material is too costly.
2. When in fashion you seek to imitate those above your station or rank, and dress so as to appear a higher or wealthier person than you are.
3. When you are excessively fastidious about material, cut, or dress, and make far more of it than you should, as if your appearance were more important than it is, or as if some plainness or unfashionable style were intolerable.
4. When your fastidiousness consumes more time in dressing than so small a matter deserves, while far more important matters are neglected.
5. When you make too great a distinction between your private and your public dress, going plainly when no strangers see you, and being excessively careful when you go out or when strangers visit you. These habits reveal a pride that consists in the desire to appear either richer or more attractive than you are.
Beyond these, there is a pride that makes people want to seem more learned than they are, which shows itself in affecting not only the titles but the dress of the learned; and this carries some aggravations beyond the former.
There is also a pride consisting in the desire to seem more grave and dignified than you are. This is what Christ rebukes in the Pharisees’ fondness for long robes: when you wear dress of more gravity than you actually possess, it is hypocrisy.
And there is a pride consisting in a desire to appear more mortified and holy than you are. To affect those distinguishing garments that signify more of these qualities than you actually have is proud hypocrisy. In this way, vile or threadbare clothing is often the fruit of pride. If a man falls into that kind of pride that desires to be noticed as the most mortified of persons, squalid clothing is as fitting a badge for him as fine dress is for those proud of their appearance, and grave clothing for those proud of their dignity.
Question 1: But can we as easily detect this kind of pride in clothing as the other?
Answer: No, because plain, cheap clothing is commonly worn by people who are genuinely mortified and sober, and necessarily by the poor; and grave clothing is commonly worn by people who are genuinely grave. We are therefore bound to take people to be what their apparel presents them as, unless their pride and hypocrisy are revealed by some evidence other than their dress. When we judge a person vain because they wear vain clothing, or proud of their appearance because they are inordinately careful in displaying it, we are judging according to the primary and proper meaning of their dress. Hypocrisy is invisible to other people. It is by visible signs, according to their proper meaning, that we must judge. When we see people wear vain and showy attire, we may rightly judge them vain and showy; and if we are mistaken, the fault lies with those who gave such a signal. When we see people wear grave or humble clothing, we must judge them grave and humble until the contrary appears.
Question 2: But how else will pride of gravity or mortifiedness make itself known?
Answer: It appears when people boast of these qualities in themselves and are contemptuous in censuring and reproaching those who differ from them; when they talk more about the fashions they avoid than about any faults of their own; when they affect to be singular in dress even from the genuinely grave and humble people of their rank; and especially when they make a public stir about their fashions so as to be noticed, to become eminent, and to be talked about and admired for their mortified manner of dress.
Many sects among the Popish friars agree, or even vow, to wear clothes so different from everyone else in seeming humility and gravity, making that distinctiveness the badge of their order in the eyes of the world, that the boast and affectation is open and acknowledged. Similarly, the Quakers, by the notorious conspicuousness of their difference from other sober persons, by their impudent shouting in streets and churches, and by their railing against the holiest and humblest ministers and people who do not belong to their sect, all this done openly in markets and congregations, make a plain profession, or rather an unmasking, of their pride. But where pride is not openly revealed, we cannot judge it.
Question 3: Is it not lawful for a person who is deformed to hide their deformity by their clothing? And may any person, by clothing, cosmetic spots, or painting, make themselves appear to others as comely and beautiful as possible?
Answer: The person, the means, the ends and reasons, the underlying disposition, and the probable consequences must all be considered to answer this question rightly. It is lawful for some persons, by some means, for good ends and reasons, when no greater evil is likely to follow, to hide their deformities and adorn themselves so as to appear more comely than they are. But for other persons, by evil means, for evil ends and reasons, or when it tends to evil consequences, it is unlawful.
1. A naturally deformed person may do more to conceal that deformity by ornament than a person with no such deformity may do to appear more comely, because the former aspires only to appear somewhat like other people, while the latter aspires to appear excellent above others. A person under authority may also do more in obedience to their governors than one who acts entirely by their own choice.
2. If the means of ornament is modest, decent clothing, not immodest, insolent, luxurious, vain, contrary to nature, or against the law of God or man, it is allowable in that respect. But no cover of deformity by unlawful means is allowed on those grounds.
3. It may be lawful if the end is also lawful: for instance, to obey a governor, or simply to conceal a deformity so as not to reveal it unnecessarily. But it is always sinful when the end is sinful. The sinful ends include:
1.) If the aim is to appear extraordinarily beautiful or comely when you are not, or to be observed and admired by beholders.
2.) If it is to tempt beholders’ minds toward lustful or inappropriate affections.
3.) If it is to deceive someone you wish to marry, for in that case, using such disguise to appear what you are not is the most injurious kind of fraud, far worse than selling a blind or lame horse as a sound one.
4.) If it is to follow the fashions of proud gallants, so as not to be scorned by them as insufficiently neat, all of these are unlawful ends and reasons.
4. The underlying disposition from which the action springs may also make it sinful:
1.) If it proceeds from a lustful, wanton mind.
2.) If it proceeds from an excessive regard for the opinion of those who see you, which is the characteristic mark of pride. Diogenes Laertius records that when Croesus sat in all his ornaments and glory upon his throne, he asked Solon whether he had ever seen a finer spectacle. Solon replied that common cocks, pheasants, and peacocks were clothed with a natural splendor and an incredible beauty far surpassing it.
A person who acts without pride is not particularly anxious about the matter, nor makes much of whether others regard him as comely or not; he therefore spends no great cost or care on appearing comely to them. If such persons are deformed, they know it is God’s work and not their sin, for sin is the true cause of shame, and all God’s works are good, and for our good if we are his children. They know that God uses deformity to keep them humble and to prevent the pride, lust, and wantonness that has undone many others. They will therefore be careful to make good use of it and gain the benefit, rather than hide it and appear more comely than they are.
5. The consequences also contribute greatly to making an action good or bad. Even if a sinful outcome is not your end, if you can foresee that more harm than good is likely to follow, it will be your sin.
1.) If your adornment tends to ensnare beholders in shameless, lustful, and wanton passions, though you say you do not intend it, it is your sin that you did what would probably produce it, and that you did not do your best to avoid it. Though their sin and vanity is the cause, it is nonetheless your sin to be the unnecessary occasion. You must remember that you live among diseased souls. You must not lay a stumbling-block in their way, nor fan the flame of their lust, nor let your ornaments become their snares. You must walk among sinful people as you would carry a candle among straw or gunpowder, or you may see the flame, when it is too late to quench it, that you would not foresee. But a proud, shameless, and lustful mind is so eager to be loved, thought highly of, admired, and desired, that no fear of God, and no consideration of the sin and misery of themselves or others, will restrain it.
2.) It is also sinful to adorn yourself in fashions that will probably encourage pride or vanity in others, or appear to endorse it. When any fashion has become the common badge of the proud and vain people of that time and place, it is sinful to conform to it unnecessarily, because you harden them in their sin and join yourself to them, as one of their company, by a kind of public profession.
When spotted faces (a term earlier ages would not have recognized), or naked breasts, or similar fashions, are ordinarily worn by the vain, and brain-sick, and heart-sick, proud and wanton party, it is a sin to adopt them unnecessarily. For first, you will hinder their repentance. And second, you will forfeit the great benefit the world might gain from their vain attire.
Though it is no credit to those who do not intend it, there is a very great practical benefit that comes to mankind from the sin of such people: that fools should go about in a fool’s coat, and that empty heads and proud and wanton hearts should be so openly exposed in streets and churches, so that sober people may avoid them, and that wise, chaste, and civil people may not be deceived by them in marriage to their ruin.
Just as the different clothing of the different sexes is necessary for chastity and order, so it is of great benefit to a commonwealth that sots, and swaggerers, and phrenetics, and idiots, and the proud, and the wanton and lustful should be openly distinguished from others, as in a time of plague the doors of infected houses are marked with "Lord have mercy on us." The wisest magistrate could not have accomplished this himself by law as effectively as the wretches themselves accomplish it by their own voluntary choice, for if it were not voluntary, it would be no distinguishing badge of what they profess to be.
For honest, civil people to join them, take up their livery, and wear the habit of their order, is to profess themselves to be such as they, and so to encourage and endorse them, or else to blur the distinction between the proud and the humble, the vain and the sober, the wanton and the chaste, and to destroy the benefit of that distinction.
From all this you may see that it is not so much the bare fashion itself that matters, as its meaning and its consequences. The same fashion, when used by sober persons to better meaning and better consequences, may be lawful, whereas otherwise it is unlawful. Therefore those fashions that can hardly ever be supposed to carry a good meaning and good consequences are hardly ever to be supposed lawful.
Note also that any one of the foregoing evils makes a fashion evil; but all the required conditions must be present together to prove your fashion good or lawful.
Question 4: Is it not sometimes lawful to follow the fashions?
Answer: It is always lawful to follow the sober fashions of sober people. But it is not lawful to follow the vain, immodest, and ill-signifying fashions of the riotous, proud, and wanton sort, except in cases of necessity such as David faced when he acted like a madman, or as Paul faced when he declared himself a Pharisee to escape persecution, or to escape from thieves or enemies. Or unless, for a time, it proves as conducive to the good of others as Paul’s circumcising of Timothy, or his becoming all things to all men that he might win some. But to follow ill-signifying fashions unnecessarily, or for carnal ends, to avoid the low opinion or harsh words of carnal persons, or to appear as fine as they, is undoubtedly a sin (Phil 3:10 Rom 12:2 Eph 5:11).
Direction 6. Be sure to avoid excess of costliness in your apparel. Remember that you must answer for all your estates. One day it will prove far more comforting to find in your accounts "So much a year laid out in clothing the naked," than "So much a year in finery or elaborate dress for yourselves or your children." Costly apparel devours what could go far in supplying the necessities of the poor.
Direction 7. Be sure you waste not your precious time in needless fastidiousness about your dress. It is difficult to overstate how great a sin it is, and how dreadful a sign of folly and misery, in those gallants who spend whole hours, indeed most of the morning, dressing and adorning themselves before they appear to others, so that some can scarcely do anything else before dinner. The morning hours best suited for prayer and reading the Word of God are consumed in this way. They spend not a quarter as much time in the serious examination and adorning of their souls, nor in any holy service of God; and so God, family, and soul are all neglected.
Direction 8. Next to the usefulness of your apparel for your bodies and your work, let your rule be to imitate the common fashion of the grave and sober persons of your own rank. Not those who are sober in other things yet still follow the fashions of the proud and vain, but the ordinary fashion of genuinely grave and sober persons. In this way you will avoid both the levity of the proud and any needless singularity.
Direction 9. Regard more the harm that your fashion may do, than the offense or criticism of anyone. When proud persons call you sordid, or not fine enough, and talk of your coarse attire, that is no great disgrace to you and no great hurt. It is a greater disgrace to be thought proud. A desire to be seen as fine signals an empty, childish mind, not only pride, but the pride of a fool, distinct from whatever pride those of mature understanding might have. You should not disgrace yourselves by wearing the badge of pride and folly any more than an honest woman should wear the badge and attire of a whore.
Moreover, plain apparel is no great temptation to yourselves or others to any sin. But proud and elaborate apparel signals and stirs up a lustful or proud disposition in yourselves; it tempts those of the same sex to envy and imitation, and those of the other sex to lust or wantonness. You spread the devil’s nets, even in churches, open streets, and public gatherings, to catch deluded and foolish souls. You should rather serve Christ with your apparel, expressing humility, self-denial, chastity, and sobriety, drawing others to imitate you in good, than to serve the devil, pride, and lust by drawing others to imitate you in evil.
Direction 10. Remember what a body it is that you so carefully and elaborately adorn. The apostle rightly calls it a "vile body" (Phil 3:21). What a silly, loathsome lump of dirt it is! What would the pox, or leprosy, or almost any sickness make it appear to be? What loathsome excrements within are covered by all that finery without! Think what it is made of, what is inside it, and what it will come to, how long it must lie rotting in a dark grave, more loathsome than common dirt, and then turn to common earth. Are purple and silk (Luke 16:19), and a fine dress, becoming to a body that must shortly have nothing but a winding-sheet, and must lie in the grave, while the soul, it is to be feared, lies in hell for this pride (Luke 16:23, 25)? Is all this cost and care becoming for one who knows he is returning to the dust?
Direction 11. Remember that you have sinful souls, that have continual cause for humiliation, and that need far more care and adorning than your bodies. Therefore your apparel should express your humiliation and show that you take more care for the soul. How lowly should that sinner be in his own eyes who knows what he has done against God, what mercy he has sinned against, what a Savior he has slighted, what a Spirit of grace he has resisted, and what a glory he has undervalued and neglected! Whoever knows what he is, what he has done, what he has deserved, and in how dangerous a condition his soul still stands, will necessarily have a soul formed in a humble frame.
Every penitent soul is vile in its own eyes and loathes itself for its inward corruptions and actual sins. One who loathes himself as vile will not be eager to make his sinful, corruptible body appear fine, nor use elaborate ornaments to attract the eyes of vain spectators. How often have I seen proud, vain gallants suddenly cast off their finery and gaudy, gay attire and clothe themselves in plainness and sobriety, the very moment God opened their eyes, humbled their souls for sin, helped them to know themselves better, and brought them home through true repentance, so that within a week they seemed like different persons altogether. And this was wrought by mere humiliation, without any arguments directly against their fashions or proud attire.
It is no wonder that the light of nature led the more serious philosophers to so plain a manner of dress, among them Socrates and Xenocrates, along with nearly all the Stoics and Cynics, and many of the Academics and Pythagoreans.
As old Mr. Dod said when someone asked him to preach against long hair: "Preach to them once Christ and true repentance, and they will cut their hair without our preaching against it." As pride would be seen in proud apparel, so humility will appear in dress suited to it, even when it has no desire to be seen. Mark this from 1 Peter 3:3–6: "Whose adorning let it not be that outward adorning of plaiting the hair, and of wearing of gold, or of putting on of apparel," that is, elaborate dressing or adorning the body beyond plain simplicity of attire, "but let it be the hidden man of the heart, in that which is not corruptible, even the ornament of a meek and quiet spirit, which in the sight of God is of great price. For after this manner," that is, with inward holiness and outward plainness, "in the old time the holy women also, who trusted in God, adorned themselves, being in subjection unto their own husbands."
O that God would print those words upon your hearts! "Yea, all of you be subject one to another, and be clothed with humility: for God resisteth the proud, and giveth grace to the humble" (1 Pet 5:5). Plainness among Christians is a greater honor than fine clothing (Jas 2:2–5). "In like manner also that women adorn themselves in modest apparel with shamefacedness and sobriety, not with broidered hair, or gold, or pearls, or costly array: but (which becometh women professing godliness) with good works" (1 Tim 2:9, 10). I urge those given to finery or elaborate dress to read Isaiah 3 from verse 16 to the end.
Direction 12. Make not too great a matter of your clothing, but treat it with the indifference due to something so secondary. Do not set your hearts upon it, for that is a worse sign than any excess in the clothing itself. "Take no thought wherewith ye shall be clothed: but remember how God clothes the lilies of the field" (Matt 6:28). If you have "food and raiment, be therewith content" (1 Tim 6:8), however plain it may be.
Direction 13. Be not too censorious of others for different fashions of apparel. Be as plain and modest as you can yourself, but do not lay undue stress on the fashions of others. If they are grossly impudent, disown such fashions and seek to reform them; but to carp at everyone who dresses more finely than you, or to condemn them as proud because their fashions differ from yours, may reveal a worse spirit than the fashions you find fault with. I have often observed more pride in such censures than in the fashions being censured.
When your eye is fixed on every fashion that differs from what your background or your rank is accustomed to, and you immediately brand such people as proud or vain, you reveal an arrogant mind that mounts the judgment seat and sentences those who are none of your concern, before they have been heard or their reasons known. Perhaps their fashion was as common among the modest people where they have lived as yours is among those you have kept company with. Custom and common opinion account for much of the meaning carried by fashions in apparel.
I should next have given special directions about the use of your estates, your dwellings, your food and drink, and your honor and reputation. But being reluctant to make this book too long, I refer you to what has already been said against covetousness, pride, and gluttony, and to what is said elsewhere about works of charity and family government. On the proportion of our estates that should be given away, see my Letter to Mr. Gouge.
As for sacred dress, and the different garb, rules, and ways of life, diet, and so on, of those called religious orders among the Papists, both regular and secular, whether and how far these are lawful or sinful, these matters are treated so extensively in the controversies between Protestants and Papists that I pass them by. I will only recall the words of the clergy of Ravenna to Charles the Younger, king of France, found among the letters of Hincmar of Reims: that clergy should be distinguished from the people and from others by their teaching, not their dress; by their conduct, not their garb; by purity of mind, not outward display. For the people are to be taught rather than entertained, and precepts are to be poured into their minds, not a spectacle put before their eyes.